WEBVTT

1
00:07:01.232 --> 00:07:02.961
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Good afternoon.

2
00:07:03.218 --> 00:07:07.928
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I am now calling to order the 4th in a series of work sessions on the upcoming budget process.

3
00:07:09.004 --> 00:07:13.339
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>This is our series of briefings prior to receiving the mayor's proposed budget.

4
00:07:13.901 --> 00:07:18.944
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Today we're going to be hearing about the Public Works Service Area and a discussion about process as well.

5
00:07:20.404 --> 00:07:25.110
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>With that, I believe— oh, I'm introducing— let's see, who am I introducing?

6
00:07:25.526 --> 00:07:25.670
<v 4,410.>No one.

7
00:07:26.120 --> 00:07:29.605
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.

8
00:07:30.182 --> 00:07:32.896
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Thank you, Council President, and good afternoon, councilors.

9
00:07:33.795 --> 00:07:35.012
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And City Administrator Lee.

10
00:07:35.637 --> 00:07:40.557
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>For the record, my name is Priya Dhanapal, and I'm the Deputy City Administrator for Public Works Service Area.

11
00:07:40.958 --> 00:07:45.444
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I'm honored to be here on behalf of the Public Works and to be sharing our important work with all of you.

12
00:07:46.646 --> 00:07:53.839
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I'm joined by my colleagues Jeremy Patton to my right and Claudio Camposano, who are the budget and finance leads for the service area.

13
00:07:54.625 --> 00:08:02.059
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We're also joined by bureau directors and subject matter experts from the Public Works in the audience who are available to provide additional details as necessary.

14
00:08:02.682 --> 00:08:03.380
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

15
00:08:06.851 --> 00:08:10.949
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We'll cover 4 areas at today's presentation at a very high level.

16
00:08:11.384 --> 00:08:15.642
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>First, the budget context and the key pressures impacting public works.

17
00:08:16.206 --> 00:08:20.862
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And second, we will provide an overview of the service area and the scale of what we manage.

18
00:08:21.524 --> 00:08:25.937
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Third, we will go through the service level gaps and what is driving them across each bureau.

19
00:08:26.358 --> 00:08:31.178
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And finally, an overview of the budget reduction scenarios developed within each bureau.

20
00:08:32.244 --> 00:08:38.985
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Today's overview is meant— intended to be focused and high level, and we welcome your questions and feedback as we move through the presentation.

21
00:08:39.808 --> 00:08:40.357
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

22
00:08:43.788 --> 00:08:49.256
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I want to start with an overview of the pressures shaping this year's budget conversation across Public Works.

23
00:08:50.302 --> 00:08:55.202
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And as you listen to today's presentation, you'll hear 3 consistent themes across all 4 bureaus.

24
00:08:56.284 --> 00:09:02.379
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>First, Public Works manages large aging infrastructure systems, and the condition of those systems Thank you.

25
00:09:02.379 --> 00:09:02.379
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Thank you, Mayor.

26
00:09:02.379 --> 00:09:02.379
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.

27
00:09:02.379 --> 00:09:02.440
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>It's a system that spans multiple agencies.

28
00:09:02.440 --> 00:09:05.570
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Today reflects decades of investment decisions.

29
00:09:06.360 --> 00:09:17.120
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Second, these systems require consistent investment to remain safe and reliable, yet the cost of maintaining them is growing faster than the revenues that support them.

30
00:09:17.539 --> 00:09:24.659
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Several funding sources are also declining, which makes it even more challenging to keep pace with system needs and community expectations.

31
00:09:25.779 --> 00:09:32.120
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And third, this creates a structural gap between the service level expectations and the revenue available to support these services.

32
00:09:34.422 --> 00:09:37.692
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>To address that gap, we are generally left with 2 primary paths.

33
00:09:38.323 --> 00:09:46.720
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We can either identify new or expanded revenue sources to support the current service levels, or we can adjust the service levels to match the revenues available.

34
00:09:47.686 --> 00:09:52.158
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that will be the central policy questions before council for the Public Works this budget cycle.

35
00:09:54.023 --> 00:10:01.475
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And as staff develop the reduction scenarios, I ask them to follow 4 principles, which is to protect regulatory compliance and system reliability.

36
00:10:02.312 --> 00:10:13.384
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Preserve council and community priorities where possible, ensure the proposals were realistic and implementable, and be transparent about the impacts of the choices in front of you.

37
00:10:14.541 --> 00:10:23.041
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Our goal today is to give council a clear understanding of the choices, the trade-offs, and the decisions that will shape service delivery going forward.

38
00:10:23.748 --> 00:10:24.375
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

39
00:10:24.631 --> 00:10:27.267
<v Thank you.>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator.

40
00:10:28.745 --> 00:10:32.407
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Before we begin, I want to ground us in what Public Works actually is.

41
00:10:33.725 --> 00:10:45.048
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The Public Works service area delivers core services Portlanders rely on every day, and it is what makes the city function in every neighborhood, in every district, every day.

42
00:10:45.995 --> 00:11:03.950
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>When you spend time in the park or participate in a recreation program, when you turn on the tap and have access to clean, safe drinking water, When you flush and it goes away, and when stormwater is safely managed through the system, protecting homes, streets, and our waterways, or when you travel safely across the city, you're experiencing Public Works.

43
00:11:05.106 --> 00:11:16.787
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Public Works is foundational to what makes Portland a great place to live, work, play, and visit, and to the safety, livability, and the economic vitality of not just our community, but the broader region.

44
00:11:18.484 --> 00:11:21.609
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Our systems are complicated, intricate, and sophisticated.

45
00:11:22.722 --> 00:11:25.433
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And the scale of operating the systems is massive.

46
00:11:26.894 --> 00:11:35.123
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Across the 4 public works bureaus, we manage an annual budget of approximately $4.7 billion, which is about half the city's total budget.

47
00:11:36.197 --> 00:11:41.057
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That supports about 31,000 full-time staff, representing about 40% of the city's workforce.

48
00:11:42.133 --> 00:11:44.346
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We also have about 1,000 seasonal employees.

49
00:11:45.566 --> 00:11:49.030
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That scale reflects the responsibility of what we are delivering every day.

50
00:11:49.110 --> 00:11:49.239
<v 1,000 years.>Thank you.

51
00:11:49.849 --> 00:11:57.225
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Our teams plan, design, build, operate, and maintain the systems that the city depends on 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.

52
00:11:57.948 --> 00:12:06.037
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And together they manage $77 billion in infrastructure assets, which roughly represents 96% of the city's total built assets.

53
00:12:08.864 --> 00:12:13.052
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Our assets include infrastructure systems that are long-lived and last 50 to 100 years.

54
00:12:13.652 --> 00:12:19.150
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And the condition of these assets today is a result of prior funding decisions made over many decades.

55
00:12:19.200 --> 00:12:19.298
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

56
00:12:20.721 --> 00:12:34.542
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>For many years, the investment did not keep pace with what these systems require for maintenance and renewal, and that gap has grown to $14.2 billion in deferred maintenance across the entire service area.

57
00:12:36.500 --> 00:12:39.681
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>When maintenance to a system is delayed, it does not go away.

58
00:12:40.085 --> 00:12:40.908
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>It compounds.

59
00:12:42.087 --> 00:12:44.753
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Systems become more expensive to operate.

60
00:12:45.221 --> 00:12:48.361
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>More expensive to repair, and more vulnerable to failure.

61
00:12:49.628 --> 00:12:52.528
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that brings us back to the framework we previewed earlier.

62
00:12:53.715 --> 00:13:10.941
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Over time, addressing these challenges generally requires 2 pathways: either increasing the investment by identifying new or expanded revenue sources to support these systems, or to accept the increasing system risk and adjust the service levels and the community expectations to match the funding available.

63
00:13:12.004 --> 00:13:22.552
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And because these systems last for generations, the decision made in this budget cycle will shape asset condition, system reliability, and service delivery for decades.

64
00:13:23.153 --> 00:13:23.769
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

65
00:13:28.182 --> 00:13:35.207
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I'm going to spend a little moment on this, a little more time on the slide, because I want to make sure this drives the important point that we're trying to communicate.

66
00:13:36.408 --> 00:13:40.527
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide highlights a few performance measures across the public works bureaus.

67
00:13:41.448 --> 00:13:47.158
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These measures show what the Portlanders experience every day and what it takes to deliver that level of service reliably.

68
00:13:48.940 --> 00:13:50.378
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>On the top left, you see parks.

69
00:13:50.830 --> 00:13:54.644
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>About 96% of Portlanders visited a park in the past year.

70
00:13:55.620 --> 00:13:59.846
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Parks also supports more than 1.3 million recreation program visits.

71
00:14:01.224 --> 00:14:03.686
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Each of those visits depend on something working.

72
00:14:04.225 --> 00:14:09.077
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>A clean restroom, a maintained trail, a staffed program, a safe facility.

73
00:14:10.001 --> 00:14:14.106
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that is what ongoing maintenance, staffing, and operations makes possible every day.

74
00:14:15.700 --> 00:14:16.504
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And then you have transportation.

75
00:14:17.990 --> 00:14:21.639
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>19,000 Miles of streets were swept in the last fiscal year.

76
00:14:22.807 --> 00:14:33.501
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Council support in the '26 budget cycle will allow PBOT to increase its street sweeping and flushing by 46,000 miles per year and has already added leaf service, recruiting 7 new leaf districts.

77
00:14:33.551 --> 00:14:33.664
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

78
00:14:34.844 --> 00:14:41.403
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This improves street conditions and neighborhood cleanliness and also protects the stormwater system by keeping debris out of the drains.

79
00:14:44.028 --> 00:14:48.283
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And in the utility bureaus, our water system— here's a math problem for you all.

80
00:14:49.013 --> 00:14:56.567
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Our water system includes 22,050 miles of pipe, and today we replace about 5 miles per year.

81
00:14:57.342 --> 00:15:01.644
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Does anybody want to take— do the math to tell me how long it would take to replace the water system?

82
00:15:01.708 --> 00:15:02.259
<v 1,000 years.>1,000 Years.

83
00:15:06.813 --> 00:15:12.421
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>22,000— So 2,250 or 2,250 and 5 miles per year.

84
00:15:13.285 --> 00:15:14.615
<v 4,410.>4,410.

85
00:15:15.033 --> 00:15:16.217
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>About 400.

86
00:15:16.650 --> 00:15:18.909
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Yeah, I think, I think we are there.

87
00:15:19.070 --> 00:15:29.996
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So that the math shows that it's going to take about 400 years to replace the full water system, which— and our pipes are designed to last for 50 to 100 years.

88
00:15:30.269 --> 00:15:36.241
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And what that means is that Many pipes will reach the end of the lifespan before they can be replaced.

89
00:15:37.916 --> 00:15:40.288
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that gap doesn't show up all at once.

90
00:15:40.678 --> 00:15:43.004
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>It accumulates quietly over time.

91
00:15:46.452 --> 00:15:52.046
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>BES reinvests just under 1% of the system's asset value every year based on available revenue.

92
00:15:53.063 --> 00:15:57.812
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>At the same time, regulatory requirements and customer expectations remain unchanged.

93
00:15:57.878 --> 00:15:58.232
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

94
00:15:59.375 --> 00:16:04.962
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These systems must meet environmental and public health standards 365 days a year.

95
00:16:05.479 --> 00:16:07.716
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>There is no flexibility in those outcomes.

96
00:16:09.289 --> 00:16:15.408
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Our teams continue to meet those standards while managing aging infrastructure and limited resources.

97
00:16:16.485 --> 00:16:23.580
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And across Public Works, these measures reflect the level of service required to operate critical infrastructure reliably every day.

98
00:16:24.451 --> 00:16:32.000
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And maintaining that level of service requires skilled staff, disciplined maintenance, and sustained investment the systems Portland depends on.

99
00:16:32.683 --> 00:16:33.318
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

100
00:16:37.990 --> 00:16:42.769
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This chart shows program expenses by fund across the Public Works service area.

101
00:16:43.701 --> 00:16:45.645
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>A few key things to notice over here.

102
00:16:46.048 --> 00:16:56.115
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>First, the public work expenses largely reflect the cost of operating and maintaining major infrastructure and managing public programming across water, storm, sewer, transportation, and parks.

103
00:16:57.759 --> 00:17:03.179
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Second, the increase that you see in the last couple of years is primarily in the water fund.

104
00:17:04.821 --> 00:17:15.669
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That increase is significant, but it is driven by a specific capital investment, which is the Bull Run Filtration Project, a federally required investment to protect Portland's drinking water.

105
00:17:16.686 --> 00:17:20.737
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The expenses in the fund is expected to stabilize once that project is complete.

106
00:17:20.903 --> 00:17:21.117
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

107
00:17:22.707 --> 00:17:34.070
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus.

108
00:17:34.887 --> 00:17:38.798
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources.

109
00:17:40.289 --> 00:17:49.954
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day.

110
00:17:50.526 --> 00:17:51.165
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

111
00:17:56.380 --> 00:18:01.602
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area.

112
00:18:02.571 --> 00:18:11.457
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total.

113
00:18:12.345 --> 00:18:19.292
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide.

114
00:18:21.575 --> 00:18:28.375
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources.

115
00:18:29.695 --> 00:18:35.542
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes.

116
00:18:36.364 --> 00:18:40.615
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus.

117
00:18:41.773 --> 00:18:47.450
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.

118
00:18:47.500 --> 00:18:47.682
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

119
00:18:48.326 --> 00:18:48.978
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

120
00:18:52.771 --> 00:18:56.692
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide shows the general fund discretionary support within the public works service area.

121
00:18:58.640 --> 00:19:03.028
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Our utility bureaus, water and BES, do not rely on the general fund.

122
00:19:03.960 --> 00:19:06.917
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These systems are funded through rates paid by customers.

123
00:19:08.279 --> 00:19:12.390
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>For transportation, the general fund makes up less than 1% of the total budget.

124
00:19:12.454 --> 00:19:12.681
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

125
00:19:13.717 --> 00:19:20.208
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that support has declined significantly over time, as you can see in the blue on the chart, and it's now minimal.

126
00:19:22.339 --> 00:19:25.493
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Parks relies on general fund more than the other public works bureaus.

127
00:19:26.093 --> 00:19:31.865
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>About 45% of Parks funding comes from general fund, and that support is also declining over time.

128
00:19:32.878 --> 00:19:37.685
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>As a result, general fund decisions have significant impact in addressing Parks' service level gap.

129
00:19:38.826 --> 00:19:39.438
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

130
00:19:43.166 --> 00:19:47.035
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide shows the full-time equivalent staffing across Public Works service area.

131
00:19:48.143 --> 00:19:56.025
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Over the past 5 years, staffing level across Public Works have remained relatively flat and in some cases have slightly declined.

132
00:19:56.907 --> 00:20:01.722
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>At the same time, service expectations and infrastructure demands continue to increase.

133
00:20:02.750 --> 00:20:09.387
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Public Works includes large, complex, highly regulated systems that require skilled staff to operate, maintain, and repair them.

134
00:20:10.482 --> 00:20:16.830
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And I want to acknowledge the many public works staff who are doing this important work every day and may be watching this live.

135
00:20:17.964 --> 00:20:22.564
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Their work is essential to the health, safety, and daily functioning of the city.

136
00:20:24.939 --> 00:20:32.090
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So the reality is that the needs of our aging system continue to grow, and the workforce responsible for the work has not.

137
00:20:32.959 --> 00:20:35.787
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This creates compounding operational risk over time.

138
00:20:36.998 --> 00:20:43.673
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>At this point, further reductions to the workforce would directly impact the services that the bureaus are able to provide.

139
00:20:44.761 --> 00:20:50.902
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And ultimately, budget decisions determine where our teams focus their efforts and what services can be delivered.

140
00:20:51.853 --> 00:20:52.546
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

141
00:20:56.942 --> 00:21:03.903
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide shows what we are funding across the Public Works service area, focusing on 10 highest program offers.

142
00:21:05.124 --> 00:21:09.523
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The colors on this chart are working a little bit over time, just like Public Works does.

143
00:21:10.743 --> 00:21:21.309
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>As you can see in the chart, the largest expenditures are focused on core infrastructure functions such as water treatment, wastewater capital investment, and transportation construction.

144
00:21:22.402 --> 00:21:26.207
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These are long-lived infrastructure systems that Portland relies on every day.

145
00:21:27.701 --> 00:21:32.962
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And all 3 of those programs operate massive aging, and highly regulated systems.

146
00:21:34.019 --> 00:21:38.490
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And work at that scale requires large capital investments that often span multiple years.

147
00:21:39.724 --> 00:21:45.461
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And there is also a direct correlation to the $14.2 billion maintenance backlog we discussed earlier.

148
00:21:46.358 --> 00:21:52.271
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>When maintenance is deferred, the operating cost tends to go up because systems become more expensive to repair and maintain over time.

149
00:21:53.410 --> 00:21:56.967
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And every dollar of maintenance deferred today costs more to address later.

150
00:21:58.256 --> 00:22:01.942
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That context explains why we are seeing growing pressure on the current service levels.

151
00:22:03.106 --> 00:22:03.721
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

152
00:22:06.759 --> 00:22:15.067
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide highlights the gap between the revenue available and the cost to maintain and operate this— operate our systems at the current level of service.

153
00:22:16.472 --> 00:22:24.219
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Firstly, our current service levels are already lean, which means there's limited capacity to absorb additional cost pressure without consequence.

154
00:22:25.558 --> 00:22:34.564
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Second, many services within Public Works are not discretionary, and many of them are required by regulatory requirements and are tied to public health and safety.

155
00:22:35.781 --> 00:22:38.280
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These are not areas where there's meaningful flexibility.

156
00:22:39.242 --> 00:22:52.204
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>At the same time, costs are rising faster than many of the revenue sources that support the system, and as discussed earlier, most funding is restricted to specific purposes, limiting the ability to shift resources between bureaus to close the gap.

157
00:22:53.263 --> 00:23:02.661
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So taken today, the policy choices available to address these gaps come down to 2 options, the same 2 options: adjusting revenue or adjusting service levels.

158
00:23:03.590 --> 00:23:04.290
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

159
00:23:08.209 --> 00:23:14.136
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide shows the primary levers available to close the budget gaps across the service area.

160
00:23:15.021 --> 00:23:21.375
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The first is operational optimization, and we at Public Works have prioritized efficiencies first.

161
00:23:22.002 --> 00:23:31.328
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And examples include managing vacancies, reducing consulting and professional service contracts, streamlining internal processes, and optimizing procurement of materials and equipment.

162
00:23:33.010 --> 00:23:37.925
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>After those efficiencies are identified, 2 primary levels— levers remain.

163
00:23:38.730 --> 00:23:42.612
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And as I mentioned earlier, those options are service level adjustments or revenue adjustments.

164
00:23:43.597 --> 00:23:52.863
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And service level adjustments involve reducing operating hours, narrowing programs, Deferring preventative maintenance or scaling back planning, regulatory, or capital support work.

165
00:23:54.324 --> 00:24:04.888
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The other path is revenue adjustments, which includes adjusting rates or fees where the tools exist, or identifying new and sustainable funding sources.

166
00:24:06.365 --> 00:24:12.451
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And neither option is easy in a service area which is as visible and as essential as public works.

167
00:24:13.736 --> 00:24:19.468
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And again, please forgive me for being a, being a broken record, but the implications are important to be clear about.

168
00:24:20.335 --> 00:24:29.278
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>When service level changes in public works, the impacts are immediate and noticeable because they affect infrastructure and services people rely on every day.

169
00:24:30.434 --> 00:24:38.977
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And reduced investment also increases long-term risks to the system reliability and leads to higher future costs due to deferred maintenance.

170
00:24:40.247 --> 00:24:49.227
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The revenue adjustments are equally visible, and I want to highlight them for you as well, particularly when affordability is a real concern for residents and businesses.

171
00:24:50.659 --> 00:24:53.374
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Those are the trade-offs in front of you this budget cycle.

172
00:24:54.769 --> 00:24:55.377
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

173
00:24:58.761 --> 00:25:05.815
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide summarizes the drivers and magnitude of each bureau's gap and the policy levers available to council to address them.

174
00:25:07.404 --> 00:25:13.544
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The drivers differ by bureau, but in general, they reflect costs rising faster than existing revenue sources.

175
00:25:14.799 --> 00:25:23.782
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Starting at the top, water and BES are experiencing pressures largely from inflation in operating costs and capital obligations within existing systems.

176
00:25:24.460 --> 00:25:27.037
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And together, the combined gap is about $7 million.

177
00:25:28.646 --> 00:25:35.413
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Because these are utility systems, the primary policy tools available to council are rate adjustments or service level changes.

178
00:25:37.144 --> 00:25:44.250
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Parks is at a similar level at about $7 million, driven primarily by lower earned revenue and higher operating costs.

179
00:25:44.896 --> 00:25:50.375
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And here the primary levers include general fund allocation decisions, revenue options, or service level changes.

180
00:25:51.979 --> 00:26:02.480
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>PBOT faces the largest gap, about $25 million in general transportation revenue, largely due to state funding losses and declining parking revenue.

181
00:26:03.945 --> 00:26:13.921
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>At that level, the policy tool includes new transportation funding sources that are sustainable, parking pricing adjustments, or service level changes that will be very visible.

182
00:26:15.351 --> 00:26:27.252
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>When we step back and look across the service area, after operational efficiencies are pursued, the choices to address these gaps ultimately come down to how we balance the service levels and revenue within each bureau's funding structure.

183
00:26:29.115 --> 00:26:32.613
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And I want to take a moment to acknowledge how difficult these trade-offs are.

184
00:26:33.468 --> 00:26:43.411
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And I also want to reiterate that in a service area responsible for long-lived infrastructure with visible community impacts, infrastructure decisions accumulate over time.

185
00:26:45.355 --> 00:26:53.039
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And the choices that you make now will shape system condition, maintenance backlogs, and service reliability for decades.

186
00:26:54.282 --> 00:27:02.883
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>With that context in mind, the next slides walk through how these trade-offs show up in the different bureaus and the specific issues we're solving for in their budgets.

187
00:27:03.648 --> 00:27:04.349
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

188
00:27:08.028 --> 00:27:11.807
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide shows where the Water Bureau's funding comes from and how it is used.

189
00:27:13.673 --> 00:27:20.477
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>On the left, you see the water system is about $2.2 billion in resources for the fiscal year '27.

190
00:27:22.186 --> 00:27:24.150
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>On the left, you see the source of income as well.

191
00:27:24.615 --> 00:27:28.846
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The most important point is that the vast majority of the water funding comes from utility rates.

192
00:27:28.943 --> 00:27:29.153
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

193
00:27:29.392 --> 00:27:30.642
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That are paid for by customers.

194
00:27:31.394 --> 00:27:40.738
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And additional resources come from bond revenues used to finance capital projects, along with fund balances and internal transfers used to manage the, manage the system's finances.

195
00:27:41.731 --> 00:27:44.311
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>On the right, you see how those funds are used.

196
00:27:45.481 --> 00:27:51.075
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Funding supports day-to-day operations, major capital investments, and debt service for infrastructure projects.

197
00:27:52.068 --> 00:27:59.537
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And a large share of those capital programs is driven by regulatory requirements, including the Bull Run Filtration Project.

198
00:27:59.585 --> 00:27:59.840
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

199
00:28:01.263 --> 00:28:17.201
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The key takeaway for council is that most of these resources are already committed to operating, maintaining, and financing critical infrastructure, which means there's limited flexibility within the system to absorb cost increases without rate adjustments or service impacts.

200
00:28:18.711 --> 00:28:19.386
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

201
00:28:23.730 --> 00:28:33.894
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide outlines 3 scenarios for balancing the Water Bureau's budget Each reflecting a different balance between rate affordability, service levels, and long-term costs.

202
00:28:34.921 --> 00:28:42.214
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Starting on the left, Scenario 1 maintains the current service level, and this is a scenario preservation— a service preservation scenario.

203
00:28:43.000 --> 00:28:51.498
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The cost pressures here are largely driven by cost increases in personnel, chemicals, electricity, basically operating costs, and ongoing infrastructure maintenance.

204
00:28:52.604 --> 00:28:56.884
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This scenario assumes 30-year bond financing for the filtration project.

205
00:28:57.012 --> 00:29:02.183
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That means the project is paid off in 30— like, faster, but annual debt payments are higher.

206
00:29:02.954 --> 00:29:07.549
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>As a result, Scenario 1 requires a 9.8% water rate increase.

207
00:29:09.500 --> 00:29:19.824
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Now, moving to the middle column, Scenario 2 stays within the previously forecasted rate increase of about 8.1%, and this is a rate increase that you saw in the last budget cycle.

208
00:29:21.068 --> 00:29:29.818
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>To achieve that, the bureau will have to implement $1 million in operation reductions which includes internal operational adjustments and reductions in maintenance and services.

209
00:29:31.221 --> 00:29:39.672
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that, for example, that will include internal and administrative changes and streamlining processes and reducing contracted services.

210
00:29:40.416 --> 00:29:43.719
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And in this case, the customers would see little to no change.

211
00:29:46.746 --> 00:29:55.222
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Where the customers would see changes is we will be shifting to paperless billing or adjusting fee structures where feasible with respect to credit card fees.

212
00:29:55.271 --> 00:29:55.384
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

213
00:29:57.211 --> 00:30:04.162
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This scenario may reduce costs but may create changes— challenges for customers who rely on mailed notices or have limited access to digital tools.

214
00:30:05.670 --> 00:30:11.292
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And some reductions begin to affect operational capacity, including facilities management and water quality testing.

215
00:30:12.309 --> 00:30:20.258
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These functions are critical for system reliability and regulatory compliance, so reductions in these areas carry significant high service risk.

216
00:30:21.329 --> 00:30:21.996
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Scenario 2.

217
00:30:22.636 --> 00:30:30.057
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Assumes a 40-year bond financing, which spreads the cost over a longer period and lowers annual debt service payments.

218
00:30:30.866 --> 00:30:36.349
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And this reduces near-term rate pressure but comes with significant long-term cost trade-off.

219
00:30:37.498 --> 00:30:45.507
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Extending the financing from 30 years to 40 years increases total borrowing costs by about $900 million over the life of the bonds.

220
00:30:46.984 --> 00:30:52.586
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So in simple terms, lower rate pressure today equals higher cost over time to customers.

221
00:30:53.773 --> 00:31:00.519
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Scenario 3 on the right reflects a 5% revenue reduction, which lowers the rate increase to about 7%.

222
00:31:01.853 --> 00:31:08.567
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This is a deeper reduction scenario and would require about $3.3 million in operations reductions.

223
00:31:09.643 --> 00:31:24.396
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These reductions would mean less preventative system flushing and maintenance, Less capacity to support billing and customer inquiries, reduced emergency preparedness planning, and fewer resources available for water quality testing and long-term infrastructure resilience.

224
00:31:25.823 --> 00:31:34.941
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These may not be immediately visible at the tap, but they reduce the bureau's ability to respond to emergencies, maintain system reliability, and the plan for future risks.

225
00:31:35.951 --> 00:31:44.798
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So the decision in front of council is how to balance rate affordability, service levels, and the long-term cost of financing critical infrastructure investments.

226
00:31:46.176 --> 00:31:46.873
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

227
00:31:50.106 --> 00:31:54.513
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide shows BES revenue, where that comes from, and how it's used.

228
00:31:54.903 --> 00:31:56.944
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And you'll see many similarities to the Water Bureau.

229
00:31:57.769 --> 00:32:03.163
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Nearly 90% of BES revenue comes from utility rates, which include sanitary sewer and storm services.

230
00:32:04.065 --> 00:32:09.481
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And these rates support day-to-day operations, system maintenance, emergency repair, and major capital investment.

231
00:32:09.548 --> 00:32:09.766
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Thank you.

232
00:32:11.026 --> 00:32:21.807
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>BES also receives non-rate revenues such as piece of funding, and that supports maintenance of green infrastructure and natural assets that help the city meet environmental and watershed health requirements.

233
00:32:22.755 --> 00:32:30.740
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And on the use side, which is on the right, the majority of the spending supports operations and capital investments needed to maintain and upgrade the sewer and stormwater system.

234
00:32:32.057 --> 00:32:40.328
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And because the capital investment needs exceed available resources, BES must focus on the most critical projects, projects first.

235
00:32:41.050 --> 00:32:49.528
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>As a result, the only area with some level of flexibility is operations and maintenance, and reductions there would directly affect core services and regulatory compliance.

236
00:32:50.636 --> 00:32:59.998
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So similar to water, most of the system's funding is already committed to maintaining critical infrastructure, leaving very limited room for reductions without service or compliance impacts.

237
00:33:00.656 --> 00:33:01.346
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

238
00:33:04.814 --> 00:33:08.200
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This outlines the 3 scenarios for balancing the BES budget.

239
00:33:09.019 --> 00:33:16.625
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Similar to the Water Bureau, each scenario has a different balance between rate affordability, service levels, and long-term system performance.

240
00:33:17.268 --> 00:33:20.525
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Starting on the left, Scenario 1 maintains current service levels.

241
00:33:21.519 --> 00:33:26.255
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And similar to the Water Bureau, BES is also experiencing higher operating and maintenance costs.

242
00:33:27.298 --> 00:33:32.719
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Under this scenario, BES maintains current services with a 5.9% rate increase.

243
00:33:34.179 --> 00:33:54.528
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Moving to the middle column, Scenario 2 stays within the previously forecasted rate increase of about 5.15%, and this scenario slows the rate growth through targeted reductions, which means the bureau would have to implement $3.3 million in support functions with about $1.8 million in materials and service reductions.

244
00:33:55.845 --> 00:34:09.641
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And some examples include reduced ability to respond to emergency infrastructure repairs, reducing planning and program coordination capacity, reducing resources for developing codes, rules, and manuals needed to support environmental compliance.

245
00:34:10.829 --> 00:34:17.873
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These reductions begin to slow planning work and reduce the bureau's ability to respond quickly to emerging infrastructure issues.

246
00:34:19.204 --> 00:34:26.690
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Scenario 3 on the right reflects a 5% revenue reduction similar to the Water Bureau, And here it lowers the rate increase to about 3.5%.

247
00:34:27.807 --> 00:34:31.356
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And this scenario requires materially deeper service impacts.

248
00:34:33.606 --> 00:34:40.784
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Over time, these impacts would slow capital delivery and increase operational and operational risk and compliance risk as well.

249
00:34:41.909 --> 00:34:48.391
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And similar to the Water Bureau, the decision for council here is balancing affordability with maintaining service levels and system reliability.

250
00:34:48.518 --> 00:34:48.905
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

251
00:34:49.534 --> 00:34:50.266
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

252
00:34:54.431 --> 00:34:59.750
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>It's important to know the scale of capital investment planned over the next 5 years for water and BES.

253
00:35:00.396 --> 00:35:07.663
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Together, the utilities manage about $52 billion in infrastructure, with nearly $3 billion in planned capital investment over the next 5 years.

254
00:35:08.992 --> 00:35:18.791
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Much of this infrastructure is over 100 years old, so ongoing investment is required to maintain reliability and main— and regulatory requirements.

255
00:35:19.675 --> 00:35:27.864
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The major projects for water and BES include the Bull Run Filtration Project, seismic upgrades, water treatment plant and collection system improvements.

256
00:35:28.425 --> 00:35:36.132
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And these investments are necessary to maintain critical infrastructure and are a major driver of rate pressures we described earlier.

257
00:35:36.775 --> 00:35:37.385
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

258
00:35:37.722 --> 00:35:38.476
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

259
00:35:41.896 --> 00:35:48.626
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide shows the 5-year rate forecast for water and BES under Scenario 1, which is maintaining current service levels.

260
00:35:49.864 --> 00:35:55.277
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And before we go into the details, I want to share a brief framing on utility rates.

261
00:35:56.594 --> 00:36:06.215
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Annual rate adjustments are necessary to keep the pace with inflation, ongoing operations and infrastructure maintenance, as well as the delivery of capital plans.

262
00:36:07.516 --> 00:36:15.603
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Affordability remains a key priority for our utility bureaus, and rate projections are developed to balance system needs with impacts on households.

263
00:36:17.032 --> 00:36:29.780
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Under Scenario 1, which maintains current service levels, the Water Bureau rate, which you see in blue on the top, is about 9.8%, and BSS rates, which you see at the bottom, is about 5.9%.

264
00:36:31.905 --> 00:36:42.135
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>It begins at 5.9%, and combined, that results in an overall utility rate increase of about 7.5% in fiscal year '26-'27, declining slightly in the later years.

265
00:36:43.550 --> 00:36:49.690
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This scenario aligns rates with the cost— actual cost of operating, maintaining, and reinvesting in the systems at the current service levels.

266
00:36:50.838 --> 00:36:51.550
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

267
00:36:53.981 --> 00:37:04.527
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Under Scenario 2, which was developed to stay with the previously forecasted rate levels, the combined rate increase remains under about 6.75% over the 5-year period.

268
00:37:05.597 --> 00:37:17.518
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>You'll see a lower water rate projection under the scenario, and that lower rate is achieved with financing strategies including the long-term bonding, which is a 40-year bonding for the filtration project.

269
00:37:18.849 --> 00:37:26.327
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And while this approach reduces the near-term rate pressure, the cost shifts into the future and increases the overall long-term costs for the customers.

270
00:37:27.244 --> 00:37:27.934
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

271
00:37:30.090 --> 00:37:36.539
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We wanted to show you the Proposed rate projection for the scenarios 1 and 2 side by side for water and BES.

272
00:37:37.396 --> 00:37:42.309
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And as you can see, the combined rates increase for scenario 1 is 7.5% and steps down over time.

273
00:37:42.826 --> 00:37:49.135
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And the combined rate increase for scenario 2 is in the mid-6% over the next 4 years, and that is utilizing the 40-year bond.

274
00:37:52.525 --> 00:37:52.672
<v Unidentified speaker>I—.

275
00:37:52.753 --> 00:37:59.681
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Longer-term bonds also saddles future ratepayers with more debt over time, as we will need to continue to reinvest and replace infrastructure.

276
00:37:59.730 --> 00:38:00.215
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So it's not a one-time thing.

277
00:38:00.262 --> 00:38:03.847
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Reinvestment is important over a long period of time.

278
00:38:04.862 --> 00:38:13.268
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I also want to share that we have robust financial assistance programs in place to support customers who need help managing costs, which I will cover in a moment.

279
00:38:13.896 --> 00:38:14.509
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide.

280
00:38:18.793 --> 00:38:26.228
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The key takeaway in this slide is the difference that customers would see in the monthly bill between Scenario 1 and Scenario 2.

281
00:38:27.163 --> 00:38:39.842
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>For a typical single-family household That difference is about $1.82 per month in fiscal year '26-'27 and roughly $1 to $2 per month in each year of the 5-year forecast.

282
00:38:41.420 --> 00:38:42.081
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

283
00:38:49.409 --> 00:38:55.135
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>A common misconception is that Portland has some of the highest utility rates in the region or even in the country.

284
00:38:56.532 --> 00:39:08.422
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Despite cost pressures, what this slide shows you is Portland Utilities rates remain within the range of comparable national peer cities with similar systems and regulatory requirements.

285
00:39:10.400 --> 00:39:10.923
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

286
00:39:14.096 --> 00:39:22.838
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Access to water and storm and sewer service is essential, and affordability, as I mentioned previously, remains a key priority for both of our utility bureaus.

287
00:39:22.951 --> 00:39:23.047
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

288
00:39:24.028 --> 00:39:31.505
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Last year, about $39 million was dedicated to support financial assistance and affordability programs for customers who need help paying their bills.

289
00:39:32.670 --> 00:39:41.893
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These programs provide bill discounts, payment plans, crisis assistance, and, and support for low-income households and affordable housing providers.

290
00:39:43.452 --> 00:39:49.048
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Some customers have— some customers receive discounts of up to 75% depending on income eligibility.

291
00:39:49.932 --> 00:40:04.134
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And customers can apply online at portland.gov/water/assistance or call a customer service team at 503-823-7770, and staff can walk them through the process.

292
00:40:06.900 --> 00:40:07.505
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

293
00:40:12.594 --> 00:40:17.835
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This chart shows PBOT's overall budget with revenue sources on the left and expenditures on the right.

294
00:40:18.690 --> 00:40:29.836
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Starting in the upper left, the general transportation revenue, or GTR, represents PBOT's most flexible funding source, totaling of about $156 million in ongoing resources.

295
00:40:31.219 --> 00:40:39.344
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>GTR includes state highway fund revenues such as gas taxes, DMV fees, parking revenues, transportation network company fees, and interest earnings.

296
00:40:40.893 --> 00:40:50.802
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And these funds support many of PBOT's core transportation services, including paving, street cleaning, signals and streetlight maintenance, transportation planning, and operational support.

297
00:40:52.630 --> 00:41:01.358
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The bottom portion of the chart represents restricted funding, which totals to about $381 million and makes a majority of PBOT's budget.

298
00:41:02.856 --> 00:41:10.438
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These funds are legally restricted to specific uses such as capital projects by grants, permit-related work, or programs supported by dedicated fees.

299
00:41:11.938 --> 00:41:18.336
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>While these investments support important transportation projects, the funds cannot be redirected to address gaps in other programs.

300
00:41:20.159 --> 00:41:26.934
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The key takeaway is that only a portion of PBOT's budget is flexible, and that is where the bureau's structural funding challenges occur.

301
00:41:28.139 --> 00:41:28.641
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide.

302
00:41:32.461 --> 00:41:37.367
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Early budget guidance asked each bureau to identify scenarios to address potential budget shortfalls.

303
00:41:38.228 --> 00:41:46.882
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And unlike the utility bureaus, these scenarios that you see here are not independent options, but they're cumulative constraints that must be addressed together.

304
00:41:48.358 --> 00:41:55.423
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>For PBOT, the most significant issue is a projected $25 million gap in the general transportation revenue over the 5-year financial plan.

305
00:41:56.708 --> 00:42:06.132
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This gap is driven by higher operating costs and lower than expected revenues, particularly declines in the state highway fund revenues and parking citation.

306
00:42:07.963 --> 00:42:16.056
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Addressing this gap will require a combination of service reductions, program adjustments, and/or new revenue sources.

307
00:42:17.945 --> 00:42:27.563
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>PBOT has limited areas where reductions occur without affecting visible services, so most reductions translate directly into service impacts experienced by the community.

308
00:42:29.001 --> 00:42:39.889
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>At deeper levels of reductions like these, the bureau shifts from maintaining the system to recovery mode where restoring infrastructure condition and service levels become more difficult and more costly over time.

309
00:42:42.092 --> 00:42:46.425
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The second scenario reflects a policy choice around city-controlled revenues.

310
00:42:47.250 --> 00:42:58.365
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>If parking rates and transportation network fees are not indexed to inflation, PBOT would face an additional $3.6 million in reduction in ongoing transportation revenue.

311
00:43:00.465 --> 00:43:07.094
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The 3rd scenario reflects 10% general fund reduction requirement applied across the city for general fund bureaus.

312
00:43:08.329 --> 00:43:15.327
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>PBOT receives about $1.3 million in ongoing general fund support, resulting in a target reduction of roughly $134,000.

313
00:43:16.353 --> 00:43:23.094
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>At that level, the bureau would reduce planning capacity related to climate policy work, which would be absorbed by the bureau internally.

314
00:43:24.282 --> 00:43:25.101
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

315
00:43:25.181 --> 00:43:25.309
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

316
00:43:29.170 --> 00:43:34.362
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide shows the major funding sources for Parks and how those resources are used, similar to the other bureaus.

317
00:43:35.677 --> 00:43:41.702
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Most of our operating budget in Parks is concentrated in the general fund that you see in the top left.

318
00:43:41.911 --> 00:43:51.429
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That includes about $82 million in general fund support, $78 million from the Parks Levy, and about $19 million in earned revenue from programs and fees.

319
00:43:51.476 --> 00:43:51.605
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

320
00:43:52.503 --> 00:43:56.646
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And together, these resources total to about $178 million.

321
00:43:58.106 --> 00:44:09.070
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>However, maintaining these current service levels requires about $185 million, leaving about a $7 million current service level gap that must be addressed through reductions and/or additional revenue.

322
00:44:10.467 --> 00:44:20.847
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The remaining funds here support specific or restricted purposes such as capital projects, tree planting, or self-supporting enterprise programs like golf and the Portland International Raceway.

323
00:44:22.608 --> 00:44:29.644
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The key takeaway is that most of parks operational challenges occur within the general fund and the parks levy portion of the budget.

324
00:44:31.115 --> 00:44:32.980
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide.

325
00:44:34.829 --> 00:44:47.298
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>When council set the parks levy rate last year, you discussed 2 variables that could affect levy's availability— sorry, we discussed 2 variables that could affect the levy's ability to sustain current service levels.

326
00:44:48.114 --> 00:44:52.014
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>One is rising costs and 2, potential general fund reductions.

327
00:44:53.155 --> 00:44:56.992
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>General fund reductions remain a possibility and would directly affect service levels.

328
00:44:57.746 --> 00:45:01.809
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide focuses on cost pressures that are already affecting the base budget.

329
00:45:03.269 --> 00:45:12.132
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The largest drivers are internal service costs and employee health benefits, both of which were significantly higher than what was assumed when the levy was sized.

330
00:45:12.342 --> 00:45:12.903
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Thank you.

331
00:45:13.867 --> 00:45:23.003
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Health costs are expected to stabilize over time, but internal service costs continue to grow at roughly 9% annually and across the city.

332
00:45:23.436 --> 00:45:30.663
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And as a result, projected costs are about $12.2 million higher than what was assumed in the financial plan used to set the levy rate.

333
00:45:31.931 --> 00:45:32.364
<v Thank you.>This is the—.

334
00:45:32.429 --> 00:45:41.405
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This increase is the major reason we are now seeing a cut— a service— this increase is a major reason we are now seeing a current service level gap in the parks budget.

335
00:45:42.065 --> 00:45:42.630
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide.

336
00:45:46.648 --> 00:45:52.143
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This slide shows what happens to Park's financial outlook under current service levels compared to making reductions.

337
00:45:53.389 --> 00:46:04.242
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>On the left, maintaining current service levels results in ongoing operating deficits shown in orange and a significant negative ending balance by the end of the forecast shown in blue.

338
00:46:06.552 --> 00:46:17.275
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>On the right, Implementing about $7 million in ongoing reductions next year largely eliminates those annual deficits and maintains a positive ending balance across the 5-year forecast.

339
00:46:19.168 --> 00:46:27.253
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This does not fully resolve the structural imbalance, but it keeps the bureau financially stable in the near term and allows us to stay in the black through the forecast period.

340
00:46:28.003 --> 00:46:28.652
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

341
00:46:32.213 --> 00:46:42.376
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This is an important slide, and I want to take a moment to walk through how Parks approached identifying potential reductions including the possibility of general fund reductions of up to $8.1 million.

342
00:46:43.822 --> 00:46:52.302
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Given the importance of parks to the community, this work was intentionally structured to be thoughtful, transparent, and grounded in clear principles.

343
00:46:53.460 --> 00:47:04.172
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Parks developed a collaborative and transparent process grounded in the bureau's strategic framework, levy priorities, and community feedback, as well as core operational needs.

344
00:47:05.358 --> 00:47:10.818
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The work was organized into service categories that reflect how Portlanders experience the park system.

345
00:47:11.965 --> 00:47:24.896
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Reduction options that were evaluated were done using clear criteria aligned with the city's core values, with input from advisory bodies including the Parks Board, Parks Levy Oversight Committee, and Urban Forestry Commission.

346
00:47:26.523 --> 00:47:33.463
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>This approach ensures that decisions are not made in isolation, but reflect community priorities and longstanding policy direction.

347
00:47:34.956 --> 00:47:45.764
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And in applying those criteria, similar to the other bureaus in Public Works, Parks looked for operational efficiencies first and then prioritized protecting core services.

348
00:47:46.838 --> 00:47:54.048
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that includes daily park care, keeping community centers open, and maintaining community programming to the extent possible.

349
00:47:54.851 --> 00:47:55.478
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

350
00:47:55.590 --> 00:47:55.719
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

351
00:47:59.311 --> 00:48:06.134
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Using that criteria, the bureau developed nearly 5 dozen potential reduction options across the 3 scenarios that you see on this slide.

352
00:48:08.320 --> 00:48:14.240
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The column 1 shows reduction required to maintain current service level, which has a $7 million gap.

353
00:48:15.659 --> 00:48:19.539
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Columns 2 and 3 represent alternative general fund reduction scenarios.

354
00:48:20.235 --> 00:48:26.539
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So the overall reduction for parks would include column 1, Plus either column 2 or column 3, but not both.

355
00:48:27.932 --> 00:48:40.338
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>While developing the reduction scenarios, we prioritized protecting levy commitments, including daily restroom cleaning, trash pickup, keeping community centers open, and preserving most programming.

356
00:48:41.733 --> 00:48:53.967
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Under the current service level gap and 3% general fund reduction scenarios, the impact primarily focuses— the impacts focus primarily on operational adjustments and reduced capacity, rather than visible closures.

357
00:48:55.108 --> 00:49:07.338
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And examples include slower facility repair timelines, reduced natural area and trail maintenance, returning splash pad operations to earlier schedules, and some adjustments to programming.

358
00:49:09.019 --> 00:49:16.657
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These reductions affect the bureau's operational capacity and system condition, but most residents may not notice immediate changes.

359
00:49:19.543 --> 00:49:23.807
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Under the 10% reduction scenario, the impacts become more visible to the public.

360
00:49:24.898 --> 00:49:35.574
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Residents would begin to see changes in park care, field conditions, and playability, longer repair times, reduced support for community gardeners, and slower emergency tree response.

361
00:49:36.375 --> 00:49:42.434
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>At that level, the Bureau's ability to maintain park assets and respond quickly to issues begin to decline more noticeably.

362
00:49:43.813 --> 00:49:49.809
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Even in this scenario, we made every effort to protect levy commitments and maintain basic park services where possible.

363
00:49:49.873 --> 00:49:50.001
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

364
00:49:52.085 --> 00:49:52.780
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Next slide, please.

365
00:49:54.974 --> 00:50:00.445
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Before we wrap up, I want to highlight the key takeaways across Public Works bureaus.

366
00:50:01.429 --> 00:50:10.940
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We are managing essential systems where costs continue to rise and many services are not discretionary, and funding is both restricted in how it can be used and in some cases declining.

367
00:50:11.971 --> 00:50:24.251
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And after operational efficiencies, the remaining choices ultimately come down to 2 things: like service level adjustments or revenue adjustments, and that those trade-offs present differently across each of our Public Works bureaus.

368
00:50:24.846 --> 00:50:27.541
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>But the underlying challenge across the bureaus is the same.

369
00:50:28.601 --> 00:50:34.764
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>As service level changes, those impacts will be experienced directly by— will be experienced directly by the community.

370
00:50:35.742 --> 00:50:43.300
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Decreased service levels also come with a responsibility to manage expectations with Portlanders in a clear, transparent, and coordinated way.

371
00:50:44.327 --> 00:50:51.715
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Reduced investment also increases long-term risks to system reliability and leads to higher future costs due to deferred maintenance.

372
00:50:52.677 --> 00:51:02.213
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>These are long-term systems, and the decisions made in this budget cycle will shape service reliability, affordability, and asset condition for years to come.

373
00:51:03.496 --> 00:51:07.181
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That concludes our formal presentation, and we welcome your questions and feedback.

374
00:51:08.143 --> 00:51:09.250
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, DCA Dhanapal.

375
00:51:09.585 --> 00:51:12.534
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Colleagues, this is a good time now for open question and answer.

376
00:51:12.775 --> 00:51:13.675
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>We're going to jump to the queue.

377
00:51:14.077 --> 00:51:15.507
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Vice President Clark, lead us off.

378
00:51:16.085 --> 00:51:18.447
<v 1,000 years.>Thank you, Council President.

379
00:51:19.123 --> 00:51:20.472
<v 1,000 years.>Uh, thank you for the presentation.

380
00:51:20.568 --> 00:51:25.775
<v 1,000 years.>Thank you for, um, making it as understandable as possible, breaking it down into pieces.

381
00:51:25.887 --> 00:51:26.804
<v 1,000 years.>I really appreciate that.

382
00:51:27.414 --> 00:51:29.793
<v 1,000 years.>I just have a couple comments and a couple of questions.

383
00:51:30.050 --> 00:51:35.528
<v 1,000 years.>Um, this is a lot to digest, uh, bureau by bureau inside Public Works.

384
00:51:36.010 --> 00:51:38.744
<v 1,000 years.>First, I just want to say I'm really proud of the work Thank you.

385
00:51:38.824 --> 00:51:39.164
<v Thank you.>Thank you, Mayor.

386
00:51:39.211 --> 00:51:40.728
<v 1,000 years.>I appreciate the work that Public Works does.

387
00:51:40.938 --> 00:51:46.456
<v 1,000 years.>I, as the chair of the T&I Committee, really appreciate the working relationship that we have.

388
00:51:47.570 --> 00:51:56.713
<v 1,000 years.>I think next to public safety, Public Works is the most, you know, basic area of city services that everyone depends on and takes for granted.

389
00:51:58.036 --> 00:52:05.188
<v 1,000 years.>So I know we have tremendous challenges ahead of us, and we have lots of liabilities.

390
00:52:06.480 --> 00:52:20.244
<v 1,000 years.>I'm very passionate for my concern about these things, but I did want to just comment that I think for the average person, the maintenance backlog is really difficult to fathom and how we're going to address that.

391
00:52:20.373 --> 00:52:31.199
<v 1,000 years.>And I think my colleagues can understand why I started out my term talking about asset management, that we are so far behind that it's almost depressing.

392
00:52:32.016 --> 00:52:38.922
<v 1,000 years.>How we're going to address our backlog, because we're going to pay for this one way or another, folks.

393
00:52:39.628 --> 00:52:46.021
<v 1,000 years.>And you, you can see that we're paying for it right now when we see water mains busting across the city.

394
00:52:47.416 --> 00:52:53.505
<v 1,000 years.>We have 100-year-old pipes that we've got to address because we're going to address it one way or another.

395
00:52:53.809 --> 00:52:59.083
<v 1,000 years.>And I hope— hopefully we'll get ahead of it to some degree, but I know we're going to Continue to have emergencies.

396
00:52:59.179 --> 00:53:04.380
<v 1,000 years.>And I know I talked to the mayor months ago about a streetlight that had fallen over.

397
00:53:05.518 --> 00:53:11.793
<v 1,000 years.>We risk really being quite liable in the public.

398
00:53:13.143 --> 00:53:19.338
<v 1,000 years.>The incident we had in parks with the hammock between the lights, how much did that cost us?

399
00:53:19.418 --> 00:53:26.849
<v 1,000 years.>I know it was under $1 million, but I can foresee more of those coming if we don't get ahead of our problems.

400
00:53:26.913 --> 00:53:27.056
<v 1,000 years.>Thank you.

401
00:53:27.833 --> 00:53:28.302
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

402
00:53:29.304 --> 00:53:32.199
<v 1,000 years.>I think that's particularly true in parks.

403
00:53:33.326 --> 00:53:38.434
<v 1,000 years.>I can foresee if we don't get ahead of the maintenance problem in parks, we're just going to start closing parks.

404
00:53:38.873 --> 00:53:45.402
<v 1,000 years.>There are so many pathways, bridges that are at the risk of failure right now.

405
00:53:45.934 --> 00:53:49.827
<v 1,000 years.>I don't think we can run around and just start fencing everything off.

406
00:53:51.451 --> 00:53:53.483
<v 1,000 years.>It's of great concern to me.

407
00:53:54.199 --> 00:54:07.028
<v 1,000 years.>I would say, DCA Dhanapal, that on your list of challenges, that I would add one more, and that is our liabilities, that we are going to face liabilities across all of these areas.

408
00:54:09.335 --> 00:54:12.530
<v 1,000 years.>So it's difficult to fathom how we're going to approach this.

409
00:54:12.579 --> 00:54:20.715
<v 1,000 years.>Now, T&I is going to take on the transportation issue as best we can, and we'll be talking more about that when we come back from the spring break.

410
00:54:20.764 --> 00:54:20.896
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

411
00:54:21.280 --> 00:54:21.682
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

412
00:54:21.748 --> 00:54:24.184
<v 1,000 years.>But that's just one slice of public works.

413
00:54:24.313 --> 00:54:31.407
<v 1,000 years.>But we're hoping to at least get ahead of that and address the pothole problem, the maintenance problem that we have all across the city.

414
00:54:32.565 --> 00:54:41.461
<v 1,000 years.>I do have a question, a couple questions on the Water Bureau.

415
00:54:42.170 --> 00:54:49.425
<v 1,000 years.>We have talked about getting an outside independent review of the water filtration plant.

416
00:54:49.603 --> 00:54:50.903
<v 1,000 years.>What's going— can you address where we are with that?

417
00:54:53.822 --> 00:54:55.414
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Absolutely.

418
00:54:55.753 --> 00:55:27.612
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Um, Director Liu is, uh, working on, um, making sure— so we, we have multiple, um, the, the filtration project right now is, um, we have $450 million in, uh, additional, additional cost increases that we have to address, and Director Liu is taking that seriously and wants to make sure that we have an independent financial oversight over the filtration project, not just for the added revenue, but also over the construction project that is ongoing right now.

419
00:55:28.210 --> 00:55:37.485
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And she is hoping to provide an update to the council in an upcoming T&I committee, which will now be the Public Works Committee at a future date.

420
00:55:38.360 --> 00:55:51.096
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We all— we are also hoping to share with this council on some of the additional cost control measures that we will be taking to ensure that To avoid further cost increases to the extent possible.

421
00:55:51.592 --> 00:55:56.994
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And we are looking forward to sharing that with you in the— at a future Public Works Committee.

422
00:55:57.764 --> 00:55:57.893
<v Thank you.>Great.

423
00:55:57.940 --> 00:56:03.070
<v 1,000 years.>Well, we'll definitely be scheduling that on our agenda after the holiday.

424
00:56:03.760 --> 00:56:14.612
<v 1,000 years.>We'll also be scheduling a discussion of the utility rates and colleagues, and we'll be bringing that forward out of the T&I or new Public Works Committee after the break as well.

425
00:56:14.996 --> 00:56:19.690
<v 1,000 years.>I'm really glad that you included the slide on how we stack up against other comparable cities Thank you.

426
00:56:19.690 --> 00:56:26.920
<v 1,000 years.>I think it's important to compare us to other cities because I often hear that, oh, we're so expensive, oh, we're really out of line, and we're not.

427
00:56:27.269 --> 00:56:32.650
<v 1,000 years.>It seems like we're really in line with most cities our size, and we're right in the middle of the pack.

428
00:56:33.210 --> 00:56:37.280
<v 1,000 years.>And that gives me some solace.

429
00:56:38.769 --> 00:56:41.030
<v 1,000 years.>I think with that, I'll just end there.

430
00:56:41.030 --> 00:56:47.449
<v 1,000 years.>I'll have more questions later, but give other— our committee member, Councilor Green, an opportunity to weigh in here too.

431
00:56:48.134 --> 00:56:49.788
<v 1,000 years.>Thank you so much for the presentation.

432
00:56:49.980 --> 00:56:51.393
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

433
00:56:51.827 --> 00:56:52.275
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Green.

434
00:56:53.335 --> 00:56:54.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mr. President.

435
00:56:54.460 --> 00:56:56.932
<v Unidentified speaker>And are we just in broad, anything goes?

436
00:56:57.206 --> 00:56:57.494
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Anything?

437
00:56:57.606 --> 00:56:58.409
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Well, not anything.

438
00:56:58.795 --> 00:57:00.690
<v Unidentified speaker>As long as it's related to Public Works.

439
00:57:01.043 --> 00:57:12.331
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, uh, thank you so much, uh, Deputy City Attorney Dhanapal and staff for, uh, coming here today, uh, and presenting some really tough data for us to wrestle with right now.

440
00:57:13.407 --> 00:57:17.047
<v Unidentified speaker>I agree with all my comments of the chair for Public Works.

441
00:57:17.512 --> 00:57:21.121
<v Unidentified speaker>It is such a core piece, and it's something that Portlanders experience every day.

442
00:57:21.266 --> 00:57:31.081
<v Unidentified speaker>I just received a direct message on my Instagram account with some pictures from streets in a very poor state of disrepair up in Arlington Heights.

443
00:57:31.144 --> 00:57:41.202
<v Unidentified speaker>And I know that that's in every neighborhood around our city, and that's why it's so important that we pursue this tough conversation that we've— this tough, tough conversation that we've been pursuing.

444
00:57:41.250 --> 00:57:41.699
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>You've got to pay for the streets.

445
00:57:41.746 --> 00:57:41.858
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

446
00:57:41.940 --> 00:57:42.215
<v Unidentified speaker>Stuff.

447
00:57:42.295 --> 00:57:46.664
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think I have some specific questions, but I just— I do want to frame it up.

448
00:57:46.728 --> 00:58:07.717
<v Unidentified speaker>You said something earlier on that I think is so prescient in the slides, which is that when we think about the $14.2 billion in deferred maintenance, that deferred maintenance creates an upward cost pressure bias on operation and maintenance, and it only gets worse and worse and worse until we deal with it.

449
00:58:08.329 --> 00:58:23.833
<v Unidentified speaker>And so whether we're rate basing it all the way right now or we are financing it through long-term bond issuances, we have to think about the generations that follow us and whether we're going to kick the can down the road any further.

450
00:58:23.914 --> 00:58:24.882
<v Unidentified speaker>And we just can't afford to.

451
00:58:25.204 --> 00:58:36.413
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think it's just really, really important to hammer home that just because we don't want to spend the money today, whether that's through borrowing or increasing rates, doesn't mean it doesn't still cost us.

452
00:58:37.177 --> 00:58:40.726
<v Unidentified speaker>So colleagues, that's what we have to kind of keep in mind when we talk about this.

453
00:58:40.807 --> 00:58:45.402
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate the different scenarios for the rates that you're going to present, and I'll get into that in a second.

454
00:58:45.467 --> 00:58:53.608
<v Unidentified speaker>But I do have a specific question on slide 6 and also, I guess, 7, because I was a little bit— I just want to confirm my reading.

455
00:58:54.400 --> 00:58:57.532
<v Unidentified speaker>That's the program expenses by fund and also resources by fund.

456
00:58:59.018 --> 00:59:00.440
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>John, can you go to slide 6, please?

457
00:59:04.315 --> 00:59:05.943
<v Unidentified speaker>Maybe resources by class.

458
00:59:07.458 --> 00:59:10.601
<v Unidentified speaker>But there's this sort of fund transfers piece.

459
00:59:10.681 --> 00:59:16.711
<v Unidentified speaker>I guess it's more relevant to slide 7.

460
00:59:16.842 --> 00:59:21.878
<v Unidentified speaker>What it looks like in the '25-'26, there was a big fund transfer relative to '24-'25.

461
00:59:24.568 --> 00:59:27.784
<v Unidentified speaker>And then it's tapered off a bit in the sort of current service level budget.

462
00:59:29.704 --> 00:59:36.306
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you speak a little bit about what was being transferred from which fund to what looks like the Public Works service area?

463
00:59:37.251 --> 00:59:39.414
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Are you talking about slide 7, Councilor?

464
00:59:39.719 --> 00:59:43.998
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, it's the orange fund transfers category on the bar charts.

465
00:59:44.269 --> 00:59:52.057
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, there's a material increase in fund transfers as the source, as the resource for the service area.

466
00:59:52.762 --> 01:00:00.757
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm just curious And if you don't have that information handy, I can take it by email at a later time.

467
01:00:00.822 --> 01:00:09.657
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Yeah, the fund transfers, it represents the internal movement of resources between funds for financial management and transfers to or from the rate stabilization funds.

468
01:00:09.849 --> 01:00:11.505
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that is what there is.

469
01:00:11.617 --> 01:00:16.373
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And I'm trying to see if our water finance person is able to answer that.

470
01:00:16.501 --> 01:00:16.822
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

471
01:00:19.007 --> 01:00:22.396
<v Unidentified speaker>My intuition was that we're drawing down the rate stabilization fund.

472
01:00:23.043 --> 01:00:25.753
<v Unidentified speaker>In that year and then maybe looking ahead, but I don't know if I'm correct on that.

473
01:00:26.876 --> 01:00:30.900
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, um, so for the record, my name is Cecilia Yuhin with the Water Bureau.

474
01:00:31.461 --> 01:00:36.931
<v Unidentified speaker>A large part of the fund transfers are actually within water and within BES.

475
01:00:37.460 --> 01:00:47.643
<v Unidentified speaker>Within water, we transfer between our operating and construction fund as well as our rate stabilization account, and then for BES similarly.

476
01:00:48.043 --> 01:00:53.206
<v Unidentified speaker>So The bigger and larger our capital program, the bigger the transfer.

477
01:00:53.708 --> 01:00:57.900
<v Unidentified speaker>So the increase that you're seeing there is the increase in our capital program.

478
01:00:58.949 --> 01:01:06.969
<v Unidentified speaker>And that correlates with the slide 6 increases in the— and it's the water filtration system, is that right?

479
01:01:07.018 --> 01:01:07.179
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

480
01:01:07.405 --> 01:01:07.534
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

481
01:01:07.583 --> 01:01:08.971
<v Unidentified speaker>That's what I thought.

482
01:01:09.034 --> 01:01:09.889
<v Unidentified speaker>That's helpful.

483
01:01:12.842 --> 01:01:22.003
<v Unidentified speaker>I think I want to, since you're up here already, I want to talk a little bit about slide— let's see here— the water rates scenarios.

484
01:01:22.920 --> 01:01:29.657
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe that is slide— yeah, slide 15.

485
01:01:33.429 --> 01:01:33.753
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

486
01:01:34.693 --> 01:01:41.405
<v Unidentified speaker>As that's coming up on the screen, I understand the table that's being presented.

487
01:01:41.666 --> 01:01:49.559
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to just say, colleagues, Mr. Mayor, City Administrator, I'm not supportive of Scenario 3 as we kind of get into this.

488
01:01:49.688 --> 01:01:58.090
<v Unidentified speaker>And the reason why is because I know that there's a desire to show ratepayers that we're cutting rates.

489
01:01:58.266 --> 01:02:08.137
<v Unidentified speaker>But as we said earlier, this is going to increase the ongoing operations and maintenance liabilities and our system resiliency liabilities, if I understand this correctly.

490
01:02:08.672 --> 01:02:08.963
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

491
01:02:09.322 --> 01:02:19.461
<v Unidentified speaker>By disinvesting so deeply in our infrastructure program, and then that will continue to sort of yield costs, as it were, down the road.

492
01:02:19.527 --> 01:02:25.469
<v Unidentified speaker>And I just think when you're dealing with a big infrastructure problem like we deal with in the City of Portland, we can't afford to lose any ground.

493
01:02:25.518 --> 01:02:33.478
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think Scenario 3 places us in that dangerous territory for not a lot of meaningful ratepayer— on average ratepayer benefit.

494
01:02:33.864 --> 01:02:37.085
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that a fair way to— I mean, maybe I'm getting a little too political for your comfort, but— No, no, no.

495
01:02:37.282 --> 01:02:39.726
<v Unidentified speaker>That's how I react to that.

496
01:02:39.967 --> 01:02:41.003
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I think that's accurate.

497
01:02:41.085 --> 01:02:54.226
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And Scenario 3 reflects significant cuts to our operations and maintenance over time that will result in increased liabilities and long-term system resilience as well.

498
01:02:54.889 --> 01:02:59.855
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So it'll be both visible short-term and long-term visible impacts on the system.

499
01:03:00.648 --> 01:03:00.971
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

500
01:03:01.295 --> 01:03:12.306
<v Unidentified speaker>And I just— so taking that off the table for me, The decision that me as a councilor in one office of 12 has to think through is, do I support scenario 1 or scenario 2?

501
01:03:13.440 --> 01:03:29.478
<v Unidentified speaker>And the chart that you show later on, which shows the sort of typical representative average monthly bill impact between those 2 scenarios, is about a $2 or $1.82 change for the CSL rate increase.

502
01:03:30.996 --> 01:03:37.702
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it's worth just maybe sharing how I think about the 40-year bond trade-off versus the 30.

503
01:03:37.831 --> 01:03:52.581
<v Unidentified speaker>I, I appreciate that you laid out that it, it costs another $900 million over 40 years in interest, but I think we have to think about that we are providing an asset that are— it's a 100-year asset, right?

504
01:03:52.885 --> 01:04:00.920
<v Unidentified speaker>And, uh, when we built Bull Run and we delivered water to the city of Portland 100 or so odd years ago or more, we financed that too.

505
01:04:01.514 --> 01:04:05.626
<v Unidentified speaker>And it ended up providing the basis for a city to grow into what we have today.

506
01:04:06.268 --> 01:04:16.677
<v Unidentified speaker>And so when I think about adding things onto utility ratepayers' bills, such as a transportation utility fee, a couple dollars means something.

507
01:04:17.175 --> 01:04:31.213
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think I'm going to probably support Scenario 2 largely because I do think it's important to spread that rate pressure over an additional 10 years because we're going to have future ratepayers who are going to help shoulder the bill of the thing that we're building for them today.

508
01:04:32.246 --> 01:04:40.541
<v Unidentified speaker>And one of the nice things about issuing debt, colleagues, in fixed-rate terms is you— it's in some sense an inflation hedge.

509
01:04:40.994 --> 01:04:49.038
<v Unidentified speaker>So you're locking in nominal costs today with a bond issuance that then inflation over time eats away in real terms.

510
01:04:49.135 --> 01:04:51.268
<v Unidentified speaker>So the burden of that debt.

511
01:04:51.590 --> 01:05:02.043
<v Unidentified speaker>And so if we're smart, we do all this other housing policy work and land use policy work that we want to do, we do the economic development work that we want to do, we're going to grow our rate base over time into that 40 years.

512
01:05:02.106 --> 01:05:05.253
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that's how I'm thinking about this.

513
01:05:05.333 --> 01:05:06.586
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm supporting Scenario 2.

514
01:05:06.827 --> 01:05:14.630
<v Unidentified speaker>I would like to know more about what some of these service impacts are that are on there because there's the 40-year issuance and then there's the other things that are cut.

515
01:05:15.735 --> 01:05:22.340
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to make sure we're not hampering our ability to deliver services in a meaningful way to ratepayers and Portlanders alike.

516
01:05:22.422 --> 01:05:25.731
<v Unidentified speaker>But maybe we'll get into that in the broader conversation here.

517
01:05:27.219 --> 01:05:33.251
<v Unidentified speaker>And then finally, do you have a question on the last substantive slide?

518
01:05:33.349 --> 01:05:35.327
<v Unidentified speaker>It's the Parks and Rec budget scenarios.

519
01:05:36.139 --> 01:05:43.972
<v Unidentified speaker>I was having trouble reading, making the connection between the scenarios and the The reduction levels.

520
01:05:45.297 --> 01:06:00.572
<v Unidentified speaker>Scenario 1 is the current service level gap scenario, which has a $7 million reduction, which I expected to be— I guess I'm not reading it correctly because then it goes Scenario 2 is a 3% reduction, but that's $2.4 million, and then Scenario 3 is a $5.7 million reduction.

521
01:06:01.443 --> 01:06:05.898
<v Unidentified speaker>And I expect it to kind of be— go from low to high in that.

522
01:06:05.961 --> 01:06:06.865
<v Unidentified speaker>And what am I missing here?

523
01:06:07.010 --> 01:06:10.447
<v Unidentified speaker>Is it just that the service level gap is maybe more than 10% or More than 3%.

524
01:06:10.735 --> 01:06:11.217
<v Unidentified speaker>And so—.

525
01:06:12.275 --> 01:06:12.802
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Yeah, go ahead.

526
01:06:13.315 --> 01:06:17.498
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, Claudio Campuzano, Finance Property Technology Manager for Public Works Business Services.

527
01:06:17.898 --> 01:06:29.146
<v Unidentified speaker>So the first scenario is merely the current service level gap for all of parks— excuse me, parks operating fund, which is that $185 million fund.

528
01:06:29.260 --> 01:06:31.471
<v Unidentified speaker>So general fund, parks levy, earned revenues.

529
01:06:32.768 --> 01:06:37.159
<v Unidentified speaker>So that is a gap that we need to close in order to match resources with expenditures.

530
01:06:37.576 --> 01:06:39.903
<v Unidentified speaker>The next 2 scenarios layer on top of that.

531
01:06:39.983 --> 01:06:45.105
<v Unidentified speaker>One would be a 3% reduction to general funds, so removing 3% general fund resource.

532
01:06:45.250 --> 01:06:48.155
<v Unidentified speaker>So we get about $81 million of general fund.

533
01:06:48.588 --> 01:06:50.226
<v Unidentified speaker>We would take 3% of that away.

534
01:06:51.237 --> 01:06:53.083
<v Unidentified speaker>These are the reductions associated with that.

535
01:06:53.387 --> 01:06:56.679
<v Unidentified speaker>And then an additional 7% to get to the 10% scenario.

536
01:06:57.016 --> 01:06:58.396
<v Unidentified speaker>That's what that next one is.

537
01:06:58.445 --> 01:07:00.402
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are additive relative to yourself?

538
01:07:00.451 --> 01:07:01.318
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, they accumulate, yes.

539
01:07:01.447 --> 01:07:04.704
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so scenario 2 would be a $9.4 million reduction.

540
01:07:05.378 --> 01:07:08.614
<v Unidentified speaker>Scenario 3 is a 12, 13—.

541
01:07:08.824 --> 01:07:09.336
<v Unidentified speaker>15.1.

542
01:07:09.592 --> 01:07:10.409
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you.

543
01:07:10.811 --> 01:07:11.900
<v Unidentified speaker>Terrible at math.

544
01:07:12.413 --> 01:07:14.817
<v Unidentified speaker>Great at abstract algebra, but terrible at arithmetic.

545
01:07:15.442 --> 01:07:17.141
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, okay, that is helpful.

546
01:07:18.085 --> 01:07:35.927
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I don't want to monopolize too much time up here because I know a lot of my colleagues have some important questions, but I just kind of want to share some comments I've received recently from, uh, Pro-Tech 17, which as we get into As we get into this exercise, like, we're looking at every part of the city for savings.

547
01:07:37.585 --> 01:07:58.342
<v Unidentified speaker>I've heard multiple times from this union that there's a deep concern that we are not doing our due diligence, especially in the public works service area, on cost control on our contracting side, that there is the perception that we've got contractors who come in low on a bid and then their total effective net cost is much higher than we expected.

548
01:07:59.106 --> 01:08:02.012
<v Unidentified speaker>And this might be work that can be done in-house.

549
01:08:02.155 --> 01:08:06.826
<v Unidentified speaker>And I've— Councilor Kanal has talked about this at length about why are we paying others to think for us.

550
01:08:07.628 --> 01:08:11.286
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, we're losing that administrative capacity building opportunity.

551
01:08:11.945 --> 01:08:22.118
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd really like to understand, as we go into this very deep budget cycle, what is the true cost of our contracting out program?

552
01:08:22.953 --> 01:08:25.439
<v Unidentified speaker>What are we saving up front versus what is it costing us over the long run?

553
01:08:25.552 --> 01:08:25.809
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

554
01:08:26.225 --> 01:08:33.338
<v Unidentified speaker>To hire out those sorts of services rather than say kind of invest in our rank and file FTEs here at the city?

555
01:08:33.931 --> 01:08:35.213
<v Unidentified speaker>That's gonna be pretty important for me to know.

556
01:08:35.293 --> 01:08:42.792
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't expect a— if you have a response now, that's great, but also that's a complicated set of questions and I'd like some—.

557
01:08:43.368 --> 01:08:46.668
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Councilor, you're asking a very important question that is also important to me.

558
01:08:47.453 --> 01:08:50.770
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And we can get back to you with the actual number.

559
01:08:51.298 --> 01:08:55.944
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>As a part of, you know, we saw operational optimization as one of the first things that we are gonna look at.

560
01:08:56.844 --> 01:09:00.677
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Not just for this budget cycle, but across the service area moving forward.

561
01:09:01.095 --> 01:09:09.292
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And whether that is, you know, each of the bureau directors, especially in the water BES, where I think you might be hearing the questions from.

562
01:09:09.355 --> 01:09:09.436
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

563
01:09:09.756 --> 01:09:13.944
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We're looking into how we can do some of those work.

564
01:09:14.185 --> 01:09:26.622
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Like, what is, what is, like, you know, evaluating where we are at, how can we be more efficient, and how can we, you know, how can we reduce the spend levels, which includes doing some of the work in-house.

565
01:09:27.009 --> 01:09:31.265
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And with our service area now, we have the infrastructure bureaus all within one house.

566
01:09:31.667 --> 01:09:45.533
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And so there's opportunities in multiple areas for cross-learning from each other and how we can, you know, even if one bureau doesn't have the ability, there's one bureau that is very strong with design or GIS mapping or even construction.

567
01:09:45.645 --> 01:09:48.810
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So there's opportunities to learn from each other and how we can do that in-house.

568
01:09:48.859 --> 01:10:01.837
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And so While we may not have immediate action, it's something that we want to do and it may take a few years, but that is something that we are definitely looking into over the next few years.

569
01:10:02.752 --> 01:10:04.729
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And we can get back to you with the actual contract numbers.

570
01:10:05.082 --> 01:10:06.898
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate that and that's helpful.

571
01:10:06.993 --> 01:10:19.449
<v Unidentified speaker>And I do want to convey that I think I've heard from this union that PBOT does a pretty good job at sharing down to a very Fine-grained level of detail what goes out in contracts.

572
01:10:19.546 --> 01:10:25.515
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think there's just a desire to see that level of detail for transparency purposes in the other parts of Public Works.

573
01:10:25.564 --> 01:10:29.037
<v Unidentified speaker>So I look forward to that interchange with you.

574
01:10:29.118 --> 01:10:32.447
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think, colleagues, I'll leave it at that for now.

575
01:10:33.289 --> 01:10:33.932
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Councilor Green.

576
01:10:34.996 --> 01:10:37.136
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I put myself in the queue because I can.

577
01:10:39.261 --> 01:10:48.631
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>John, you don't have to change the slide, but on slide 15, the water rate-based scenarios that Councilor Green was just talking about, You know, I agree fully with Councilor Green that Scenario 3 feels like a bad option.

578
01:10:48.760 --> 01:10:52.788
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>And the Scenario 2, I mean, the 40-year bond thing kind of scares me.

579
01:10:53.192 --> 01:11:00.788
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>And I think it is really important for this council to be very clear-eyed about that and very explicit that this is not, this is a trade-off.

580
01:11:00.854 --> 01:11:01.693
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>This is a decision.

581
01:11:01.740 --> 01:11:06.096
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>This is an intentional policy decision that also in many ways binds the hands of future councils.

582
01:11:08.029 --> 01:11:09.679
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>But I still think it might be the right option.

583
01:11:10.815 --> 01:11:14.567
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>That is a clear— you know, just wanted to be very explicit about that.

584
01:11:16.260 --> 01:11:27.606
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>On slide number 4, talking about the maintenance backlog, I am wondering if there is an ability to break this backlog down by district, which no one should be surprised hearing me say that.

585
01:11:28.493 --> 01:11:32.114
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>A $6 billion PBOT backlog is, you know, it's no joke.

586
01:11:33.412 --> 01:11:55.127
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>But I also heard specifically, I've received an email from a I think I heard from a PBOT staffer at some point, and I don't remember the exact context, but more or less the bureau calculates maintenance as being more expensive the further from the central city it is, that maintenance costs are calculated as being more expensive in District 1 because of how far the crews have to travel.

587
01:11:55.690 --> 01:11:57.845
<v 4,410.>Mm-hmm.

588
01:11:58.987 --> 01:12:02.444
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Is that reflected in this backlog total, this dollar amount?

589
01:12:02.828 --> 01:12:14.153
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Is it based off of what the pipe costs per square foot or is it also including having to send a team out to 145th and Division as opposed to, you know, 1st and Division?

590
01:12:15.072 --> 01:12:17.539
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We can get back to you on the details of that one.

591
01:12:19.024 --> 01:12:39.175
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>But I do wanna share that this is an important question and we are happy to one, get the, you know, split of the asset deferred maintenance by district as well as making sure that we are, Um, you know, get, get you the details on whether— how much is it going to cost for the away from the central city.

592
01:12:39.789 --> 01:12:57.145
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Uh, one thing that we are doing right now is, uh, our bureaus are working on collecting a summary of all the assets, uh, that we have in each of our bureaus and, um, what is the asset condition, um, and, you know, what is the cost that it's going to take to get it back to good condition.

593
01:12:57.663 --> 01:13:01.564
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that— and we can include District location in it as well.

594
01:13:01.661 --> 01:13:05.096
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So we are happy to— once we collect that information, we're happy to bring it back.

595
01:13:05.546 --> 01:13:07.216
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We are calling it a Phase 1 data collection.

596
01:13:07.649 --> 01:13:13.060
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Phase 2 will be like, you know, a consequence of failure, um, you know, uh, all, all of those things will be in Phase 2.

597
01:13:13.109 --> 01:13:15.805
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>But Phase 1 is where we're doing the primary data collection.

598
01:13:16.224 --> 01:13:20.574
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So we will make sure to include district in those asset data, so we will be able to provide the data for you.

599
01:13:21.201 --> 01:13:21.762
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Fantastic.

600
01:13:21.859 --> 01:13:25.648
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Council President, I'd like to add to that, you know, historically what you Yes.

601
01:13:25.953 --> 01:13:39.765
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>And the statements that you just made as it relates to it costs more to drive out further distances, and that's typically related to the unit cost of a pothole or unit cost of doing that type of repair.

602
01:13:40.247 --> 01:13:51.189
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Some of the things that I think just lean towards the cost of probably East Portland and the cost of it is, is just the age and the condition of the actual asset itself.

603
01:13:51.270 --> 01:13:53.850
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Itself that is really driving that cost.

604
01:13:54.106 --> 01:14:01.161
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>But when you start looking at unit costs, that distance does build into kind of the unit cost of the repair.

605
01:14:01.305 --> 01:14:04.671
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>But looking holistically, it's really the age of that infrastructure.

606
01:14:04.847 --> 01:14:14.563
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I mean, that makes sense, but I'm interested to see how this looks on a map because, for example, downtown Portland has the old— probably some of the oldest water pipes.

607
01:14:15.252 --> 01:14:22.335
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>East Portland probably has the youngest Sewer pipes because we weren't part of the city until the promise of annexation and sewer access.

608
01:14:22.384 --> 01:14:28.795
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>So perhaps our sewer system is in better shape than the rest of the city, but it will cost more to fix it or whatever that is.

609
01:14:29.213 --> 01:14:30.036
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I'm interested to know more.

610
01:14:30.115 --> 01:14:31.856
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I think it's just good, you know, information is good.

611
01:14:33.119 --> 01:14:33.395
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you.

612
01:14:33.846 --> 01:14:40.229
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>On slide 13, there's a statement in there about declining parking revenue.

613
01:14:41.957 --> 01:14:45.354
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Last year, this council raised the Hourly cost for parking.

614
01:14:46.270 --> 01:14:48.003
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Did that lead to lower collections?

615
01:14:48.277 --> 01:14:50.042
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Did we scare people away?

616
01:14:50.926 --> 01:14:54.154
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That is a great question, and we have the perfect person to answer that for you.

617
01:14:54.217 --> 01:14:56.434
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Jeremy Patton will be happy to take the question.

618
01:14:56.931 --> 01:14:57.702
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thanks for the question.

619
01:14:57.751 --> 01:15:00.304
<v Unidentified speaker>Jeremy Patton, the finance lead for the service area.

620
01:15:01.203 --> 01:15:04.992
<v Unidentified speaker>The declining parking revenue that we're talking about in this particular case is the citation revenue.

621
01:15:05.055 --> 01:15:09.198
<v Unidentified speaker>So we had assumed higher citation revenue based on the number of citations we were writing.

622
01:15:09.536 --> 01:15:13.984
<v Unidentified speaker>But that citation revenue has not yet shown up through— it takes a while to make it through the courts.

623
01:15:14.047 --> 01:15:18.752
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we did reduce our forecast to kind of show what we've seen over the last couple of years.

624
01:15:19.667 --> 01:15:21.884
<v Unidentified speaker>The other small piece is when we reduce the hours.

625
01:15:21.996 --> 01:15:24.340
<v Unidentified speaker>So if you remember last year, we talked about extending hours.

626
01:15:24.404 --> 01:15:26.412
<v Unidentified speaker>We took those hours back out of our forecast.

627
01:15:27.118 --> 01:15:32.753
<v Unidentified speaker>That led to a little bit— the actual increase in rates, I would say that doesn't lead to a decline in parking revenue.

628
01:15:32.818 --> 01:15:34.809
<v Unidentified speaker>Do we see slightly less people paying?

629
01:15:35.306 --> 01:15:41.588
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, the higher the rate you go, you're going to see less people actually paying, but the actual revenue coming in has not declined on parking districts.

630
01:15:42.055 --> 01:15:42.520
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>That's good.

631
01:15:43.034 --> 01:15:45.797
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>And I'm more for sort of building on that.

632
01:15:45.926 --> 01:15:47.518
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Is there a break-even point?

633
01:15:47.774 --> 01:15:55.775
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Or, I mean, if we are paying our parking enforcement folks to go out and provide citations, do they ultimately pay for themselves?

634
01:15:56.193 --> 01:15:57.479
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Or do they generate revenue?

635
01:15:57.880 --> 01:16:01.189
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Or are we sort of paying for the privilege of having parking tickets?

636
01:16:02.956 --> 01:16:07.002
<v Unidentified speaker>I would say historically they've typically written citations in the amount to pay for themselves.

637
01:16:07.051 --> 01:16:08.287
<v Unidentified speaker>I would say the data has backed that up.

638
01:16:08.496 --> 01:16:11.868
<v Unidentified speaker>Recently, there's just a lack of the payment of those citations.

639
01:16:11.931 --> 01:16:15.271
<v Unidentified speaker>Not that people aren't just necessarily paying, but it just takes a while, so it's harder to do that.

640
01:16:15.720 --> 01:16:20.747
<v Unidentified speaker>I think you have to build in both the citations written, but also just the parking meter revenues collected in general.

641
01:16:20.795 --> 01:16:25.002
<v Unidentified speaker>So if we had zero enforcement, nobody would probably pay at the meters.

642
01:16:25.050 --> 01:16:29.412
<v Unidentified speaker>So when you look at actual parking collections, and citations, they would pay for themselves.

643
01:16:29.461 --> 01:16:30.229
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Okay, gotcha.

644
01:16:30.326 --> 01:16:39.443
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Council President, I'd like to add to that too as well, and I probably experienced this myself as I tested out our parking system with trying to figure out a ticket.

645
01:16:40.243 --> 01:16:47.582
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Um, one thing I've seen from a customer experience standpoint, it's pretty difficult to go on and pay a parking ticket too as well.

646
01:16:48.287 --> 01:16:58.833
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>So we have to figure out that whole process, uh, to make it more, uh, customer-friendly to be able to go on To be able to pay for these type of citations.

647
01:16:59.270 --> 01:17:06.896
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>And also looking at the consequences for not paying a parking ticket is very limited.

648
01:17:07.427 --> 01:17:21.305
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>So there's certain things that we could be looking at and bringing back to the council for consideration as, as we evaluate kind of the parking ticketing process as a whole that I think we could enhance.

649
01:17:21.731 --> 01:17:25.555
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>To make it better for ourselves and for citizens.

650
01:17:25.989 --> 01:17:26.328
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Perfect.

651
01:17:27.114 --> 01:17:27.902
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I totally agree.

652
01:17:27.983 --> 01:17:28.319
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you.

653
01:17:29.829 --> 01:17:30.216
<v Unidentified speaker>I have—.

654
01:17:30.425 --> 01:17:32.144
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I'm sorry, I have 3 more quick questions.

655
01:17:33.560 --> 01:17:49.695
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>The peer city list on slide 23, I was noting— I mean, I think it is helpful for us to have nationwide peer cities in terms of population, but I'm also noticing that we are significantly ahead neighboring cities In terms of our overall rate.

656
01:17:50.685 --> 01:17:55.109
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>And most specifically concerning for me is that Gresham's water rate is so much lower.

657
01:17:55.819 --> 01:17:59.634
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>But am I correct in remembering that Gresham gets water from us?

658
01:18:01.939 --> 01:18:02.810
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Good question, Councilor.

659
01:18:02.891 --> 01:18:04.572
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Gresham used to get water from us.

660
01:18:04.668 --> 01:18:08.644
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>They are no longer a customer, a wholesale customer.

661
01:18:08.740 --> 01:18:10.389
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>They are using their own water supply.

662
01:18:12.079 --> 01:18:12.753
<v Unidentified speaker>And yeah.

663
01:18:12.981 --> 01:18:13.286
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Okay.

664
01:18:13.863 --> 01:18:28.990
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>You know, representing the border with Gresham, I have a lot of worries specifically about, I mean, I worry less about people from District 1 moving to Washington, D.C. than I do them moving across the other side of 165th and turning into Gresham and getting that.

665
01:18:30.432 --> 01:18:32.708
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>So I'm interested broadly.

666
01:18:32.773 --> 01:18:50.060
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I think it is important for us to have some peer-sized cities to recognize, but I am also interested in generally understanding more how we compare across the region, if only because I am also broadly interested in how we compare across the region in terms of all of our metrics, our parks maintenance, our permitting times, all of these things.

667
01:18:50.557 --> 01:18:55.761
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>It'd be great to be better than Nashville, but I'm more concerned about being better than Gresham and Happy Valley.

668
01:18:56.822 --> 01:18:57.784
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Absolutely, Councilor.

669
01:18:58.042 --> 01:19:08.770
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>One thing that I, if I may add, is we are happy to get back to you with the comparison between our peer cities or our cities in our local jurisdiction.

670
01:19:09.525 --> 01:19:18.490
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>But one thing that we want to point out is We have to compare, you know, our water system and the regulatory requirements.

671
01:19:18.971 --> 01:19:26.154
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And, you know, for BES, we have a combined sewer storm, which is not the case in many of the other neighboring jurisdictions.

672
01:19:26.203 --> 01:19:28.302
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So we have to compare apples to apples.

673
01:19:28.367 --> 01:19:35.198
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We are happy to get you the cost from the other cities, but we want to make sure that there's a difference between what their system is and what our system is.

674
01:19:35.246 --> 01:19:37.762
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>You know, don't put too much time into that one in particular.

675
01:19:37.827 --> 01:19:46.783
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>In fact, I think maybe just for the For a future budget presentation, it would be helpful for me as next year's city councilor to know more.

676
01:19:46.927 --> 01:19:50.315
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>But you all have a lot going on, so maybe don't spend a ton of time on that.

677
01:19:51.139 --> 01:19:51.801
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry to jump in.

678
01:19:51.945 --> 01:19:57.305
<v Unidentified speaker>I just wanna clarify that the comparison on the slide is both water sewer and stormwater.

679
01:19:57.740 --> 01:20:08.890
<v Unidentified speaker>The water portion is the lighter blue and it looks like the darker green, what is, what's, more than Gresham, and that is sewer and stormwater.

680
01:20:09.436 --> 01:20:12.582
<v Unidentified speaker>And I suspect that Gresham didn't have to do the CSO.

681
01:20:13.144 --> 01:20:14.105
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Yeah, I suspect not.

682
01:20:14.331 --> 01:20:14.507
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>No.

683
01:20:14.828 --> 01:20:16.850
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Okay, that actually really is very helpful.

684
01:20:16.914 --> 01:20:17.315
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you.

685
01:20:18.262 --> 01:20:30.426
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Um, you know, I'll say broadly, um, on slide 25, there are again some camp— some like items that are things that I'd like to see broken down by district wherever possible.

686
01:20:31.501 --> 01:20:37.101
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Asset maintenance, derelict RV camp, Cleanup, the street sweeping, vegetation, graffiti stuff.

687
01:20:38.712 --> 01:20:46.078
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I'm interested broadly to know, again, I raised a concern last year about street sweeping in District 1.

688
01:20:46.127 --> 01:20:52.484
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>So I will always be really interested to understand where are we spending our money and how are my neighbors in D1 getting access to that.

689
01:20:52.694 --> 01:20:56.175
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>My last question then, I'm just going to just— I'll just put that out there and it's not a question.

690
01:20:56.742 --> 01:21:00.177
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>My last comment is specifically, maybe this is more of a policy I'm sorry.

691
01:21:00.259 --> 01:21:21.966
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I know this is not a policy question, but I'm— with regard to parks and the likelihood that we're going to have to reduce some services or some level of what people are accustomed to, the news this morning was also talking about the North Portland Aquatic Center opening, and that process is getting further along in the design, and we're scoping and all of that.

692
01:21:22.047 --> 01:21:28.076
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>But I'm really worried about that Becoming another— I'm not trying to say anything.

693
01:21:28.140 --> 01:21:29.747
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I see them all staring at me.

694
01:21:29.828 --> 01:21:31.578
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>But are we going to— I know, I know.

695
01:21:32.140 --> 01:21:36.157
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Are we going to build a beautiful aquatic center and then in 2 years cut services to it?

696
01:21:36.960 --> 01:21:40.735
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>And if we are, why would we build it right now?

697
01:21:42.181 --> 01:21:43.676
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That's a really good question.

698
01:21:43.787 --> 01:21:52.896
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I know that there's— we are working on it right now, but the timeline, I'm going to call in Director Szymanski to talk about the timeline and what that would look like.

699
01:21:54.645 --> 01:21:54.900
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Right now?

700
01:21:55.525 --> 01:21:55.671
<v 1,000 years.>Sure.

701
01:21:55.751 --> 01:21:56.006
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>What?

702
01:21:56.551 --> 01:21:59.292
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Yeah, you can go ahead.

703
01:21:59.837 --> 01:22:00.143
<v Unidentified speaker>You wanna begin?

704
01:22:00.430 --> 01:22:00.768
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Timeline?

705
01:22:01.520 --> 01:22:01.778
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Yeah.

706
01:22:01.873 --> 01:22:10.802
<v Unidentified speaker>So just jumping in on the timeline, we currently have in our forecast that it comes online in 2030.

707
01:22:11.220 --> 01:22:19.506
<v Unidentified speaker>And to your question, a little bit about the finances, we have a little bit less than $5 million built in for ongoing major maintenance starting in that year.

708
01:22:19.667 --> 01:22:23.694
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's included in the forecast and is part of what we're trying to balance for right now.

709
01:22:25.027 --> 01:22:27.930
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll add briefly, Sonia Szymanski, Interim Parks Director.

710
01:22:28.076 --> 01:22:28.604
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

711
01:22:29.182 --> 01:22:37.029
<v Unidentified speaker>This is one of the things we are so happy to talk to you about when we come back on the long-range funding strategy conversation.

712
01:22:37.527 --> 01:22:47.587
<v Unidentified speaker>There are a lot of things beyond the horizon of our 5-year forecast that need understanding and discussion and in some cases decision.

713
01:22:47.971 --> 01:22:52.497
<v Unidentified speaker>Including those major pieces of the future operating budget.

714
01:22:53.911 --> 01:22:54.231
<v Unidentified speaker>Brilliant.

715
01:22:54.552 --> 01:22:55.452
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I mean, that's exactly right.

716
01:22:55.500 --> 01:22:59.384
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>So don't worry, D2, I'm not saying anything else.

717
01:22:59.448 --> 01:23:00.105
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>That is the end of it.

718
01:23:00.154 --> 01:23:00.747
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you very much.

719
01:23:00.877 --> 01:23:01.935
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>That's my last comment.

720
01:23:02.400 --> 01:23:03.042
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Novick.

721
01:23:04.488 --> 01:23:05.466
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mr. President.

722
01:23:05.546 --> 01:23:13.010
<v Unidentified speaker>I have to say, I share your fear of Gresham, and I'm afraid I might have taken an action that'll make Gresham even more of a threat.

723
01:23:13.667 --> 01:23:20.836
<v Unidentified speaker>A few years ago, there was an auto dealership there that had a tagline at the end of their radio ad that said, guts, glory, Gresham.

724
01:23:21.734 --> 01:23:28.261
<v Unidentified speaker>And I asked Mayor Stovall last year why they haven't adopted that as their official city slogan, and he said he'd think about it.

725
01:23:28.324 --> 01:23:32.060
<v Unidentified speaker>And then I realized, wait a minute, if they have that slogan, people will just move across to Gresham in droves.

726
01:23:32.238 --> 01:23:35.220
<v Unidentified speaker>So I apologize for that.

727
01:23:35.621 --> 01:23:49.963
<v Unidentified speaker>I have one big sort of existential question, as it were, which is Do we know how much it cost and how much regular citizens were paying when we first built the water system, when we first built the initial sewer system?

728
01:23:51.560 --> 01:23:52.868
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Could you repeat your question, Councilor?

729
01:23:53.193 --> 01:24:07.762
<v Unidentified speaker>I sort of want to know, okay, back when our forefathers initially built a water system, when they initially built a sewer system, my assumption is that that was probably really expensive and like the average Portlander spent like 25% of their income for the next 20 years paying for it.

730
01:24:08.260 --> 01:24:13.171
<v Unidentified speaker>And we could like hold that up as an example of like the investment our predecessors are willing to make.

731
01:24:13.412 --> 01:24:16.381
<v Unidentified speaker>But I might be totally wrong about that, and it also might be impossible to know.

732
01:24:16.783 --> 01:24:20.442
<v Unidentified speaker>But I just, at some point, I'd be interested in sort of an historical retrospective on that.

733
01:24:20.715 --> 01:24:24.838
<v Unidentified speaker>Maybe we can get Shane Cavanaugh to write a big article about the sacrifices people made back then.

734
01:24:25.529 --> 01:24:28.081
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We can definitely look into that and get back to you, Councilor.

735
01:24:28.483 --> 01:24:29.172
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Okay.

736
01:24:29.766 --> 01:24:51.740
<v Unidentified speaker>And on parking revenues, I might have missed you already saying this, but Have, aside from citations, have revenues from the garages and the street meters— I know they declined for a while in the wake of the, of the, uh, um, or during the pandemic, um, but has— have those numbers kept on going down even during the recovery?

737
01:24:52.479 --> 01:24:53.439
<v Unidentified speaker>They haven't kept on going down.

738
01:24:53.488 --> 01:24:56.997
<v Unidentified speaker>They have been going up, but mostly that is due to the rate increases that we're seeing.

739
01:24:57.094 --> 01:24:59.493
<v Unidentified speaker>We're not seeing a ton more of just utilization.

740
01:24:59.590 --> 01:25:02.110
<v Unidentified speaker>I would say it's mostly related to the rates.

741
01:25:02.904 --> 01:25:03.130
<v Unidentified speaker>Ouch.

742
01:25:04.375 --> 01:25:05.311
<v Unidentified speaker>It's better than the pandemic.

743
01:25:05.360 --> 01:25:12.925
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't want to say that it is better than the pandemic, but it is not— and I'd have to look at the data, but I don't think it's quite at that level pre-pandemic as far as utilization.

744
01:25:13.728 --> 01:25:14.018
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

745
01:25:14.099 --> 01:25:19.185
<v Unidentified speaker>And now I wanted to get to— I'm glad this slide is up— the GTR flexible spending in PBOT.

746
01:25:20.618 --> 01:25:24.622
<v Unidentified speaker>Have we— I was surprised when you showed me this last week, Priya.

747
01:25:25.497 --> 01:25:32.061
<v Unidentified speaker>How much of that money goes to street sweeping, graffiti, derelict RV, campsite cleanup?

748
01:25:32.854 --> 01:25:36.409
<v Unidentified speaker>Are those numbers dramatically higher than they were, say, 8 years ago?

749
01:25:39.461 --> 01:25:53.065
<v Unidentified speaker>I would say the street sweeping or not, those street sweeping, if you're comparing dollar to dollar, so the value of the dollar doesn't change with inflation, I would say street sweeping was actually reduced a few years back when we removed neighborhood street So I would say that, that wouldn't show an increase.

750
01:25:53.130 --> 01:25:58.237
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of the newer programs, derelict RV campsite cleanup, those are newer programs that didn't exist in prior years.

751
01:25:59.296 --> 01:26:03.069
<v Unidentified speaker>So, but it's— we've been doing it for years, but if you think a decade ago.

752
01:26:03.247 --> 01:26:03.520
<v Unidentified speaker>But it's true.

753
01:26:03.568 --> 01:26:11.115
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so a decade ago, if we hadn't started doing those things, we might have almost $8 million available for maintenance of the actual streets.

754
01:26:12.319 --> 01:26:12.721
<v Unidentified speaker>That'd be correct.

755
01:26:12.801 --> 01:26:12.881
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Yeah.

756
01:26:12.962 --> 01:26:14.087
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

757
01:26:14.327 --> 01:26:19.743
<v Unidentified speaker>Then I'd like to see at some point a further breakdown of like Project delivery.

758
01:26:20.407 --> 01:26:22.332
<v Unidentified speaker>What kind of projects are those?

759
01:26:22.931 --> 01:26:24.275
<v Unidentified speaker>That's our entire capital program.

760
01:26:24.323 --> 01:26:30.292
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's everything from the planning, design, engineering, and the actual construction for any capital project in PBOT.

761
01:26:30.939 --> 01:26:36.935
<v Unidentified speaker>But aren't a chunk of our capital projects done with other kinds of money rather than GTR?

762
01:26:38.069 --> 01:26:39.572
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, this is the restricted.

763
01:26:39.619 --> 01:26:40.912
<v Unidentified speaker>Are you looking at restricted or the—.

764
01:26:40.912 --> 01:26:42.609
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sorry, I'm looking at GTR flexible.

765
01:26:43.351 --> 01:26:43.512
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

766
01:26:43.675 --> 01:26:44.288
<v Unidentified speaker>That's all I care about.

767
01:26:46.020 --> 01:26:47.996
<v Unidentified speaker>That piece, yeah, most of it is down.

768
01:26:48.043 --> 01:26:49.345
<v Unidentified speaker>You can see below in the restricted.

769
01:26:49.472 --> 01:26:51.336
<v Unidentified speaker>I can get you the details on the specifics.

770
01:26:51.720 --> 01:26:54.242
<v Unidentified speaker>Right, but there is $25 million for project delivery.

771
01:26:54.322 --> 01:27:03.265
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm— I think, to be honest, I think that there's a lot of people who assume that PBOT spends all of its money on bike lanes.

772
01:27:04.164 --> 01:27:08.628
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'd be interested in a breakdown of that project delivery to be able to respond to that.

773
01:27:08.837 --> 01:27:08.997
<v Unidentified speaker>Yep.

774
01:27:09.143 --> 01:27:09.737
<v Unidentified speaker>Happy to get you that.

775
01:27:10.283 --> 01:27:19.050
<v Unidentified speaker>And then for asset maintenance, I think about $25 million of that, $20 to $25 million of that is pavement.

776
01:27:19.612 --> 01:27:26.885
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm curious, I'd like to see a breakdown of that too, and I'm just curious off the top of your heads, I mean, how much of it is maintaining the streetlights?

777
01:27:27.447 --> 01:27:33.131
<v Unidentified speaker>And like, could you give like the, the, the top 4 things other than pavement maintenance that make up that $45 million?

778
01:27:33.420 --> 01:27:34.207
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I can provide that.

779
01:27:34.384 --> 01:27:34.689
<v Thank you.>It's—.

780
01:27:35.090 --> 01:27:35.395
<v Unidentified speaker>We have it.

781
01:27:36.233 --> 01:27:36.329
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Yeah.

782
01:27:36.411 --> 01:27:39.676
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that— do I remember correctly that streetlights themselves are a big chunk of it?

783
01:27:41.244 --> 01:27:42.069
<v Unidentified speaker>Give me 30 seconds.

784
01:27:42.149 --> 01:27:43.685
<v Unidentified speaker>I can probably tell you what most of that is.

785
01:27:43.750 --> 01:27:44.850
<v Unidentified speaker>But streetlights are a big chunk.

786
01:27:44.898 --> 01:27:46.693
<v Unidentified speaker>Paving is gonna be a large chunk of that asset maintenance.

787
01:27:46.742 --> 01:27:50.543
<v Unidentified speaker>But the streetlight signals piece is gonna be another large piece of that as well.

788
01:27:50.770 --> 01:27:50.867
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

789
01:27:51.432 --> 01:27:52.259
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

790
01:27:53.681 --> 01:27:59.601
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, and actually, I would also like to see a breakdown of street sweeping versus graffiti versus vegetation at some point.

791
01:28:00.021 --> 01:28:00.280
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

792
01:28:01.184 --> 01:28:01.490
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

793
01:28:03.287 --> 01:28:04.081
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

794
01:28:04.243 --> 01:28:04.792
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Kanal.

795
01:28:05.295 --> 01:28:06.395
<v 4,410.>Thank you, Council President.

796
01:28:06.444 --> 01:28:07.496
<v 4,410.>Thanks everybody for being here.

797
01:28:07.577 --> 01:28:09.600
<v 4,410.>Appreciate the presentation and all the information.

798
01:28:10.510 --> 01:28:20.145
<v 4,410.>While we're on this slide, I just wanted to note that there's these, these smaller chunks of money that we see here around things like payments for citywide services.

799
01:28:20.210 --> 01:28:27.175
<v 4,410.>And so our internal fund rates, or so our internal IMS rates, are things that we still need to talk about and haven't had a chance to.

800
01:28:27.224 --> 01:28:30.876
<v 4,410.>I'm looking forward to opening up that conversation when we have a Committee of the Whole.

801
01:28:32.560 --> 01:28:34.408
<v 4,410.>I have a bunch of questions.

802
01:28:34.457 --> 01:28:38.253
<v 4,410.>I'll start just slides 6 and 7, which Councilor Green asked about.

803
01:28:38.608 --> 01:28:50.783
<v 4,410.>I just wanted to understand, am I reading this wrong, why the budget slides add up to $2.04 billion, but the revenue sides come up to $4.78 billion across the 2 slides?

804
01:28:50.898 --> 01:28:52.158
<v 4,410.>Should we not be comparing those?

805
01:28:53.645 --> 01:28:54.434
<v Unidentified speaker>You want me to answer that?

806
01:28:56.427 --> 01:28:57.390
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Yes, go ahead.

807
01:28:57.631 --> 01:29:04.712
<v Unidentified speaker>The slides are actually showing 2 different things as far as— so the resources is all of the revenue or resources coming into the funds.

808
01:29:05.259 --> 01:29:09.819
<v Unidentified speaker>On slide 6, program expenses doesn't include some of the other fund-level expenses.

809
01:29:10.990 --> 01:29:13.270
<v 4,410.>Sorry, there was a— Doesn't include what?

810
01:29:13.608 --> 01:29:18.087
<v Unidentified speaker>It doesn't include like fund transfers, contingencies, things like that in the program expenses.

811
01:29:18.201 --> 01:29:20.881
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are just personnel, materials and services, capital outlay.

812
01:29:21.300 --> 01:29:22.542
<v Unidentified speaker>That's the only expenses captured there.

813
01:29:23.574 --> 01:29:25.286
<v 4,410.>Okay, thank you for that.

814
01:29:25.850 --> 01:29:37.006
<v 4,410.>I just wanted to also to build off of Councilor Green, you mentioned this in slide 12, just give you some praise here for thanking, and thank you for putting reduced consulting and professional services in that operational optimization piece.

815
01:29:39.180 --> 01:29:56.319
<v 4,410.>Slide 24, and this also relates I think a little bit to the conversation that We've had in the past, but not today so far, but which is mentioned, I believe, on slide 22, about monthly bills versus quarterly bills.

816
01:29:57.144 --> 01:30:06.823
<v 4,410.>And I understand, just, I think these are some things here, the discount program and the option to go to monthly billing are maybe not the best known options for people.

817
01:30:07.257 --> 01:30:15.032
<v 4,410.>And just wanted to understand a little bit about your plans to help boost awareness and in the case of the discount program utilization.

818
01:30:15.097 --> 01:30:15.163
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

819
01:30:17.662 --> 01:30:29.891
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We can— so we definitely do affordability program information in our— we make sure that we are sharing that information through our social media, through bill inserts, and it is passed on to our community.

820
01:30:30.180 --> 01:30:35.765
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And happy to partner with you councilors if you want to share affordability programs in your newsletters to your districts as well.

821
01:30:36.216 --> 01:30:40.917
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I think this is important for everybody to have, and people who are eligible, we're happy to provide that information.

822
01:30:41.913 --> 01:30:45.176
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And what was your other question about affordability?

823
01:30:45.917 --> 01:30:46.333
<v Unidentified speaker>Just the—.

824
01:30:46.333 --> 01:30:59.237
<v 4,410.>I don't think it's necessarily something we want to increase or decrease the percentage of people who do this, but to make Portlanders more aware of the option to seek a monthly bill versus a quarterly one.

825
01:30:59.493 --> 01:31:01.521
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We can make sure that it's communicated.

826
01:31:01.988 --> 01:31:07.784
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I think we've heard that increasingly from both councilors and some constituents as well.

827
01:31:07.979 --> 01:31:11.212
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So we'll make sure in upcoming bill insert we can include information on that.

828
01:31:12.722 --> 01:31:17.279
<v 4,410.>Yeah, and I'm happy to, I'm sure many colleagues as well, to share it outward as well.

829
01:31:18.824 --> 01:31:38.465
<v 4,410.>On the subject of discounts, I think just another tag for our— my colleagues here that when we talk about the TUF, that talking about how we do the discounts is really important to me here because I think the goal of a discount on the TUF is not necessarily the same as the goal of a discount on the water rates.

830
01:31:39.047 --> 01:31:45.715
<v 4,410.>And just worth kind of seeking into that because we're not— we can't affect behavior the way we can with the water, uh, discounts.

831
01:31:46.597 --> 01:31:48.786
<v 4,410.>Um, just a topic for another time.

832
01:31:49.416 --> 01:31:55.085
<v 4,410.>Um, I mentioned— I'm kind of going back to the same thing, but it's on different slides.

833
01:31:55.149 --> 01:32:05.877
<v 4,410.>So slide 28, you have, uh— I just wanted to understand the internal service fund, uh, Forecasts.

834
01:32:06.536 --> 01:32:09.551
<v 4,410.>That's a pretty significant change in 6 months.

835
01:32:10.305 --> 01:32:12.326
<v 4,410.>I just wanted to understand that a little bit better.

836
01:32:12.373 --> 01:32:16.448
<v 4,410.>You gave kind of a general, like, explanation of what it is, but the why side.

837
01:32:17.137 --> 01:32:18.212
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, no, that's a great question.

838
01:32:18.324 --> 01:32:29.712
<v Unidentified speaker>So historically, the city economist has provided a figure for internal service fund increases, and we've, you know, we as bureaus have used that figure for our forecasts.

839
01:32:30.515 --> 01:32:32.904
<v Unidentified speaker>This year, I think we've seen a big improvement in that.

840
01:32:33.145 --> 01:32:42.546
<v Unidentified speaker>Which is actually working with the internal service funds to identify like what are they forecasting in their rates and what are they planning, what are they expecting to see.

841
01:32:42.949 --> 01:32:51.164
<v Unidentified speaker>So we received that forecast in November and really that was the first time we'd seen that granular service-by-service forecast.

842
01:32:51.609 --> 01:32:55.945
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we incorporated that into our forecast and it was pretty substantial.

843
01:32:56.641 --> 01:33:00.652
<v Unidentified speaker>I will note that a big chunk of it is in the risk IA.

844
01:33:01.729 --> 01:33:07.305
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that that is, and we're looking at 17% increases year over year through the forecast.

845
01:33:07.371 --> 01:33:16.115
<v Unidentified speaker>And we're working with CBO and with risk to try and determine whether there's some opportunity to bend that forecast down a little bit based on some nuance.

846
01:33:16.926 --> 01:33:19.838
<v Unidentified speaker>But really, like, that's the biggest driver.

847
01:33:21.036 --> 01:33:28.353
<v Unidentified speaker>As an example, we saw, we had about $2.5 million in the risk IA 2 years ago, the end of fiscal year '25.

848
01:33:28.435 --> 01:33:28.533
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Yeah.

849
01:33:29.649 --> 01:33:35.421
<v Unidentified speaker>And going into fiscal year '27, it's about $4.5 million, and that rises with that 17% escalator to nearly $10 million.

850
01:33:35.856 --> 01:33:41.847
<v Unidentified speaker>So if we can figure out how to bring that down, that could be some significant savings in the forecast.

851
01:33:42.587 --> 01:33:44.261
<v 4,410.>Great.

852
01:33:46.746 --> 01:33:54.279
<v 4,410.>When you talk about the reduction packages for parks, I think one of the things that— this is the slide that has the— it's 31.

853
01:33:57.030 --> 01:34:02.217
<v 4,410.>The built-in sort of assumption being scenario 1 and then adding in either 2 or 3.

854
01:34:02.747 --> 01:34:11.787
<v 4,410.>I just, I really wanted to kind of focus on that last sentence in the bottom left here of some reductions to recreation and community centers.

855
01:34:13.024 --> 01:34:15.078
<v 4,410.>And first say, let's not do this again.

856
01:34:16.074 --> 01:34:38.895
<v 4,410.>We just spent half of a year, it feels like, talking about reductions to community centers and the idea of, Recreation programs being, I think, a core part of the parks levy, which we just asked people to vote on with at least an implication on the environmental ed side too, that we were not going to be reducing these services if the levy passed.

857
01:34:39.458 --> 01:34:43.153
<v 4,410.>So I just, I want to, let's just stop looking there.

858
01:34:43.682 --> 01:34:55.024
<v 4,410.>There's plenty of other places in a large bureau to look, and I don't want to be in the position of of telling Portlanders, I know we said that, but now, because we made commitments.

859
01:34:55.088 --> 01:35:06.211
<v 4,410.>And I, I just think it's, it's a, yeah, something that we, we can and should avoid, at least in the context of this Scenario 1, talking about what we're going to cut automatically.

860
01:35:06.872 --> 01:35:13.644
<v 4,410.>Um, and I think for those who were at the listening sessions last year, many of us were at more than just our own district.

861
01:35:13.725 --> 01:35:26.958
<v 4,410.>It was the single biggest thing that came And I understand that's partially because it was one of the things that was already floated for a cut last year, but it's partially because of the volume of support that we have for this particular type of service.

862
01:35:28.115 --> 01:35:31.600
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Thank you, Councilor Knoll, and thank you for sharing your concern about the community center.

863
01:35:32.131 --> 01:35:50.827
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>One thing I would like to clarify is it's not just community centers, but across the board in all the programs that you're seeing, it does not completely eliminate A community center, but we're looking at reducing the operating hours or, you know, maybe a day in a week or something like that for certain community centers.

864
01:35:51.261 --> 01:35:52.914
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So, but we are looking into that option.

865
01:35:53.027 --> 01:35:57.332
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We're developing those options as we come through, but we will take your input into consideration.

866
01:35:58.167 --> 01:36:07.208
<v 4,410.>Yeah, I think the question that I would have is, would the average voter have thought that if they approved the parks levy, this wasn't going to happen?

867
01:36:08.229 --> 01:36:09.226
<v 4,410.>And I think there—.

868
01:36:09.355 --> 01:36:09.421
<v Unidentified speaker>It—.

869
01:36:09.774 --> 01:36:13.155
<v 4,410.>What we said in the, in the vote, that's what I'm concerned about here.

870
01:36:13.493 --> 01:36:29.341
<v 4,410.>I understand there's a lot of concern here, and I imagine that because we didn't commit around maintenance in the same way except for the 3-cent piece of it, that that's likely to be the place that's the least protected by this conversation or what the voters knew.

871
01:36:29.828 --> 01:36:33.143
<v 4,410.>But I just wanted to make sure that was in the, in the record here.

872
01:36:33.207 --> 01:36:33.418
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you.

873
01:36:35.190 --> 01:36:42.833
<v 4,410.>And on that subject, I'd love to talk about— we— Councilor Ryan talks a lot about the sponsorship and getting the private dollars into parks.

874
01:36:42.913 --> 01:36:49.466
<v 4,410.>But one thing that also came up, which I also believe Councilor Ryan talked about, was the volunteer programs that we used to have.

875
01:36:49.721 --> 01:36:51.520
<v 4,410.>And I'd love to see updates on that.

876
01:36:51.569 --> 01:36:56.386
<v 4,410.>Councilor Clark had an item on this last year, and I think that might be a place to look.

877
01:36:56.643 --> 01:37:00.622
<v 4,410.>And I can see Director Schavansky nodding, of course, I see you're already looking into it.

878
01:37:00.719 --> 01:37:02.627
<v 4,410.>I'd love to get some updates on that at a later time.

879
01:37:03.364 --> 01:37:10.131
<v 4,410.>So we have some hopefully hope for how to assist with the sort of gaps here.

880
01:37:11.094 --> 01:37:14.895
<v 4,410.>Everything else I have is on kind of the transportation side.

881
01:37:15.311 --> 01:37:36.475
<v 4,410.>I imagine to Council President Dunphy's point about the deferred maintenance backlog by district that some, I don't know if you distinguish between deferred maintenance And the stuff we never built at all and have therefore no— it's not necessarily maintaining something, but it's sort of deferred capital broadly.

882
01:37:36.747 --> 01:37:48.595
<v 4,410.>And I'm not sure if that would be helpful to understand because some of the things that we're talking about needing maintenance in D2, D3, D4 are things that we're talking about needing to build for the first time in D1.

883
01:37:49.014 --> 01:37:50.715
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And what you're saying is absolutely real.

884
01:37:50.859 --> 01:38:01.641
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Like for the Water Bureau, we are significantly investing in the filtration plant that many of our capital needs have been deferred because the resources have been focused on the filtration plant.

885
01:38:01.689 --> 01:38:11.171
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And we can, in addition to the deferred maintenance, we can look into what has been deferred with respect to capital need and we can get back to you as well, district by district.

886
01:38:12.198 --> 01:38:23.622
<v 4,410.>And my guess would— am I correct in saying that that means that the backlogs we're seeing here do not capture the full amount of necessary capital investments?

887
01:38:23.863 --> 01:38:25.070
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>That is my understanding, yeah.

888
01:38:25.619 --> 01:38:27.649
<v 4,410.>Okay, so it is worse than we thought.

889
01:38:27.746 --> 01:38:28.068
<v 4,410.>Great.

890
01:38:28.390 --> 01:38:40.243
<v 4,410.>That's the thing we hear the most in, I think, the City Council, my experience, not from anyone specific, but that there's— it's a bigger problem that we've been left to figure out and that you've been left to figure out as well.

891
01:38:42.015 --> 01:38:51.131
<v 4,410.>I would love to get more on that, and I appreciate the information because I was not aware that BES actually had a larger backlog than PBOT until today, for example.

892
01:38:51.503 --> 01:38:53.854
<v 4,410.>That's— we hear about PBOT, I think, all the time.

893
01:38:55.380 --> 01:39:01.192
<v 4,410.>On the subject of parking enforcement, you said that if we had no enforcement, we'd have nobody paying parking rates.

894
01:39:01.738 --> 01:39:09.077
<v 4,410.>And I would love to understand the conversation around enforcement on double parking for loading vehicles.

895
01:39:10.470 --> 01:39:16.663
<v 4,410.>Every single day I drive in here, I have to change lanes, get around a truck that is double parked illegally.

896
01:39:17.403 --> 01:39:24.145
<v 4,410.>And I don't want to be that guy taking pictures out of my window, but I can start if it's helpful.

897
01:39:24.466 --> 01:39:25.574
<v 4,410.>Over to you.

898
01:39:26.073 --> 01:39:26.168
<v 1,000 years.>Yeah.

899
01:39:26.796 --> 01:39:27.759
<v 4,410.>And okay, thanks.

900
01:39:28.497 --> 01:39:42.108
<v 4,410.>But I would love to understand why there's limited investments in that enforcement and how the amount be raised to the point that it is whatever one step beyond a deterrent is?

901
01:39:43.342 --> 01:39:53.060
<v 4,410.>Because it's, it's something I hear about in downtown, of course, but also out in district as well on all the major roads that people are trying to use to get to the local businesses that they go to.

902
01:39:53.926 --> 01:39:56.957
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Director Williams is here to answer your— respond to your question.

903
01:39:57.037 --> 01:39:57.614
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Thank you so much.

904
01:39:57.838 --> 01:39:58.207
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Good afternoon.

905
01:39:58.256 --> 01:40:01.189
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Millicent Williams, Director of the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

906
01:40:01.703 --> 01:40:03.002
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Thanks for your question, Councilor.

907
01:40:03.386 --> 01:40:16.429
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>I did want to mention several Several years ago, we more than doubled the number of parking enforcement officers that we had providing the service to the city with the goal of creating the opportunity for more people to comply.

908
01:40:17.042 --> 01:40:22.576
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>We felt like if they were actually receiving tickets, there would be the potential for them to actually pay the tickets.

909
01:40:23.479 --> 01:40:28.484
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>And so we have, over the course of the past several years, seen an increase in compliance.

910
01:40:28.582 --> 01:40:29.939
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>So compliance is up 70%.

911
01:40:31.972 --> 01:40:33.007
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>But the—.

912
01:40:33.288 --> 01:40:36.222
<v 4,410.>And that makes sense on the I agree with what you said earlier.

913
01:40:36.302 --> 01:40:39.979
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>And so then the revenue part has to catch up, as Jeremy has mentioned previously.

914
01:40:40.878 --> 01:40:53.837
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>And as the city administrator reflected, there's some opportunities we have to work with Multnomah County and the courts to ensure that the payment system reflects the ease with which we need for people to be able to pay.

915
01:40:54.382 --> 01:41:05.194
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>We also, as has been mentioned, don't have or don't use the levers that are available to us to encourage people to pay their tickets on time or at all.

916
01:41:05.853 --> 01:41:09.411
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>People do not receive double penalties anymore.

917
01:41:09.603 --> 01:41:11.318
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>There used to be a time when we would double tickets.

918
01:41:11.365 --> 01:41:12.344
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>That doesn't happen anymore.

919
01:41:12.649 --> 01:41:17.698
<v 4,410.>And I'm not suggesting being more punitive on the conversation around individual parking tickets.

920
01:41:17.858 --> 01:41:28.502
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>And so then with regard to people double parking in loading zones or non-loading zones, we do have those officers who are out often ticketing.

921
01:41:29.079 --> 01:41:43.470
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>And what we have heard from some businesses at least is that the cost of doing business is to just park the vehicle wherever, even though we have created and extended loading zones for businesses to be able to park in the appropriate places and spaces.

922
01:41:43.918 --> 01:41:45.105
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>It is very challenging.

923
01:41:45.362 --> 01:41:53.929
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>And so it's very difficult for us to essentially ticket our way out of getting people to comply as it currently stands.

924
01:41:54.747 --> 01:42:02.140
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Those who are loading and unloading, if they're in the parking— in the loading zones, or not even in a loading zone, do not have to pay to use the curb.

925
01:42:02.300 --> 01:42:09.740
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>In other jurisdictions, people who are delivering goods and other services actually do have to pay to use the curb.

926
01:42:09.917 --> 01:42:13.012
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>We do not require that here in the city, and that's something that we're also discussing.

927
01:42:13.685 --> 01:42:15.337
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>But that's a big challenge.

928
01:42:15.595 --> 01:42:20.244
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>And because people feel like it's easier to just pay the $80, $100, $200 ticket, Thank you.

929
01:42:20.582 --> 01:42:30.581
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>They will do that instead of waiting for a space to free up, waiting for us to tow a vehicle that's parked in a space that they should not be in so that loading can happen appropriately.

930
01:42:31.416 --> 01:42:51.510
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>But we also have an opportunity to work with companies to ensure that we schedule when they're able to do the deliveries so that everyone's not showing up at Pioneer Courthouse Square or around the mall Yeah, I appreciate that.

931
01:42:51.559 --> 01:42:55.762
<v 4,410.>And I think those are things worth considering is how the loading zones work.

932
01:42:55.859 --> 01:43:04.198
<v 4,410.>I'm mostly interested in the delivery vehicles that are in driving lanes and are stopped in the middle of the road.

933
01:43:04.747 --> 01:43:11.112
<v 4,410.>And I would love to talk about how we can add a zero to the end of the amount every time until it gets that done.

934
01:43:11.194 --> 01:43:11.904
<v 4,410.>I think that's a great idea.

935
01:43:12.256 --> 01:43:17.515
<v 4,410.>I want to incentivize your parking enforcement officers to go after those people.

936
01:43:18.126 --> 01:43:21.878
<v 4,410.>And it is completely unacceptable and it's rampant.

937
01:43:22.038 --> 01:43:22.631
<v Thank you.>We agree.

938
01:43:22.695 --> 01:43:24.028
<v 4,410.>Literally every day I come downtown.

939
01:43:24.283 --> 01:43:26.079
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>And I experience the same thing.

940
01:43:26.144 --> 01:43:38.765
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>And in fact, I've spoken with our parking enforcement leadership and said there are certain points of— there are certain parts of town at certain points in the day Yes.

941
01:43:39.936 --> 01:43:49.337
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>So that a person is not parking in the 5-minute spot, sticking their tail end out, blocking, for example, 4th Avenue on a daily basis.

942
01:43:49.466 --> 01:43:51.935
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>I see that, those types of things happening.

943
01:43:52.288 --> 01:44:00.759
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Again, if there's no trigger, there's nothing that's causing a person to pay that $100, $200, $300 ticket, there's no consequence to them not paying it.

944
01:44:01.431 --> 01:44:04.127
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>That is just an exercise in futility.

945
01:44:04.175 --> 01:44:04.944
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>So we've got to work on that.

946
01:44:05.105 --> 01:44:13.326
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>On the jaws of the enforcement action so that people will feel the need to be in greater compliance as it relates to that.

947
01:44:13.390 --> 01:44:20.582
<v 1,000 years.>Council President, can we— maybe we could just deputize Councilor Kanal to be that officer, that kind of vigilante parking officer.

948
01:44:21.497 --> 01:44:24.564
<v 4,410.>You know, New York does have a sort of vigilante program on it.

949
01:44:24.644 --> 01:44:25.414
<v 4,410.>I know, I know.

950
01:44:25.574 --> 01:44:28.400
<v 4,410.>I don't think they call it that, but yeah.

951
01:44:29.750 --> 01:44:33.423
<v 4,410.>The last thing, and this kind of relates Sorry, 2 last things.

952
01:44:33.761 --> 01:44:48.663
<v 4,410.>One is I'd love to also talk about adjustable parking, kind of event parking style overlays for larger portions of the city, including smart parks and street parking in downtown as well.

953
01:44:49.256 --> 01:45:06.563
<v 4,410.>But the thing I wanted to float here is, and this relates to Council President's comment about the way of looking at everything by district, that it doesn't necessarily I think it's worth noting that it doesn't necessarily make sense to apply every— a 25% rule to everything, that 25% of our problem or 25% of our investment should be in every district.

954
01:45:06.899 --> 01:45:13.442
<v 4,410.>It also has not worked to have no rule whatsoever because all the money goes to D4 for the last 150 years.

955
01:45:14.114 --> 01:45:26.269
<v 4,410.>And so I think it's worth, um, worth having a conversation around a 15 or 20% understanding to give administration a lot of flexibility.

956
01:45:26.332 --> 01:45:26.493
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Thank you.

957
01:45:26.783 --> 01:45:31.246
<v 4,410.>But having some sort of penciling in of what we should expect as a minimum for every district.

958
01:45:31.743 --> 01:45:41.185
<v 4,410.>I'd love to have that conversation, um, because— and it's, it's been a, a— and, and by the way, there are many parts of D4 that are also neglected.

959
01:45:41.618 --> 01:45:42.341
<v 4,410.>I should note that.

960
01:45:42.823 --> 01:45:49.679
<v 4,410.>Uh, so I, I— it just, it so happens that the parts that are not neglected, a lot of them are also in D4.

961
01:45:50.208 --> 01:45:55.274
<v 4,410.>Um, and so for the people out in outer South I definitely understand and have heard a lot of the same stories.

962
01:45:56.278 --> 01:46:15.149
<v 4,410.>But I would love to have some understanding of a flexibility that's council, a council conversation around a flexible framework that has, that can give Portlanders certainty that at least a portion of the investments we're making that are citywide will be in their district.

963
01:46:15.811 --> 01:46:19.256
<v 4,410.>And I don't know if that's 15% for every district and 40% is flexible.

964
01:46:19.337 --> 01:46:19.402
<v 1,000 years.>Yeah.

965
01:46:19.798 --> 01:46:21.686
<v 4,410.>Or something nearly that prescriptive.

966
01:46:21.735 --> 01:46:25.591
<v 4,410.>That's not an actual number, but just illustrative example.

967
01:46:25.996 --> 01:46:30.752
<v 4,410.>But I would love to have that conversation with colleagues going forward and not specific to Public Works alone.

968
01:46:31.461 --> 01:46:31.622
<v 4,410.>Thanks.

969
01:46:32.024 --> 01:46:32.926
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

970
01:46:33.167 --> 01:46:38.934
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Colleagues, I promised staff we would take a quick 10-minute bathroom break halfway through, and we are a little bit past halfway through on this.

971
01:46:40.024 --> 01:46:43.134
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>We may not last until 5, but I was— I shouldn't have said that.

972
01:46:43.198 --> 01:46:43.654
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I'm sorry.

973
01:46:45.496 --> 01:46:51.051
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>To take an 8-minute bathroom break and have us back here at 3:50 to jump back into the queue.

974
01:46:51.774 --> 01:46:52.463
<v Thank you.>Apologies.

975
01:54:26.369 --> 01:54:27.805
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Get back to order, please.

976
01:54:27.871 --> 01:54:39.667
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Ladies and gentlemen, from the old budget office, we're getting back to it.

977
01:54:40.152 --> 01:54:42.479
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I love the amount of fun happening here.

978
01:54:42.657 --> 01:54:43.595
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

979
01:54:46.051 --> 01:54:47.636
<v Thank you.>Thank you, Council President.

980
01:54:49.373 --> 01:54:57.454
<v Thank you.>Um, I want to I'd like to ask a couple of questions about the bond option on slide 15.

981
01:54:59.161 --> 01:55:03.202
<v Thank you.>My colleague said this is a 100-year asset, and I actually would like to ask the question.

982
01:55:04.680 --> 01:55:07.427
<v Thank you.>We're talking about bonding for a water treatment facility.

983
01:55:08.591 --> 01:55:11.194
<v Thank you.>How long do we expect that asset to last?

984
01:55:11.259 --> 01:55:14.087
<v Thank you.>And I guess 2 pieces to that question.

985
01:55:14.152 --> 01:55:23.445
<v Thank you.>How long do we expect it to last total lifespan, and how long do we expect How long do you expect it to last before it needs some sort of major maintenance that we might also bond for?

986
01:55:26.079 --> 01:55:32.279
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The typical lifespan of infrastructure asset like that for the— in a water bureau is about 50 to 100 years.

987
01:55:32.730 --> 01:55:32.956
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

988
01:55:33.520 --> 01:55:43.139
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And that being said, you know, in addition to that new infrastructure, there's going to be ongoing maintenance.

989
01:55:45.127 --> 01:55:53.811
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>A thought is to spread the cost to the future years as much as possible because it's going to be a 50 to 100-year infrastructure.

990
01:55:54.358 --> 01:56:03.590
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>But I also want to highlight that the deferred maintenance and other maintenance, ongoing operations maintenance, is going to also compound over time.

991
01:56:03.911 --> 01:56:13.087
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And so the future generation, in addition to getting to pay for this particular infrastructure, they will have their own aging infrastructure and maintenance to pay for.

992
01:56:13.457 --> 01:56:17.805
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And I don't know if Cecilia, if you have a number on the maintenance.

993
01:56:20.354 --> 01:56:26.011
<v Unidentified speaker>I think the question was on when will more capital maintenance will be coming on with the—.

994
01:56:26.604 --> 01:56:27.103
<v Thank you.>Exactly.

995
01:56:27.184 --> 01:56:45.371
<v Thank you.>And what, what I'm trying to understand is if this is a 50 to 100-year asset, are we looking at the larger maintenance, the capital maintenance that's needed to extend the lifespan, or that's needed to replace major parts at year 30, at year 40, at year 60?

996
01:56:46.444 --> 01:56:57.326
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, I suspect that there will be parts of the filtration plant that will need to be replaced in 20 years, electrical, and then there will be ones that will be much later.

997
01:56:57.677 --> 01:57:12.663
<v Unidentified speaker>So over the next 20, 30, 40 years, there's going to be parts of the treatment plant that will need major maintenance work and replacements, equipment that is put into the plant, those will need to be replaced.

998
01:57:13.707 --> 01:57:14.125
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

999
01:57:14.766 --> 01:57:24.288
<v Thank you.>I'm interested in understanding what the rates would look like if we looked at the reductions in Scenario 2, but a 30-year bond.

1000
01:57:25.091 --> 01:57:55.003
<v Thank you.>And I'm interested in that because The longer we push out our bond payments, the more we are depending on either significant population growth that does not bring with it its own costs, or hoping that we don't have other significant deferred maintenance costs, or assuming that we will double up and be paying for these bonds and the costs of that significant maintenance.

1001
01:57:55.100 --> 01:57:55.715
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Thank you.

1002
01:57:56.104 --> 01:57:59.958
<v Thank you.>I'm not comfortable with any of those scenarios.

1003
01:58:00.412 --> 01:58:17.024
<v Thank you.>I'm not comfortable with the first scenario because while population growth will certainly, as my colleague pointed out, help to spread the cost, it also will come with additional pressures on our system that I have to assume will increase costs.

1004
01:58:17.653 --> 01:58:24.877
<v Thank you.>And I don't want to set us up for a long-term cycle of chasing growth in an unsustainable way.

1005
01:58:26.079 --> 01:58:46.958
<v Thank you.>I do not like the idea of setting ourselves up to be paying off bonds from an asset that we've purchased while we also are looking at the next big investment here and needing to either save or begin bonds for the next big investment on the facility as well and doubling up costs for future generations.

1006
01:58:47.990 --> 01:59:00.037
<v Thank you.>If you're telling me that this is a 50 to 100-year asset, I'm going to assume that maybe an electrical upgrade aside, we can get through 25 to 30 years before we have major maintenance on it.

1007
01:59:01.931 --> 01:59:11.042
<v Thank you.>40 Years starts to push where I worry that you'll be sitting in front of 12 new people, or 4 new people will be sitting in front of 12 new people.

1008
01:59:11.640 --> 01:59:12.422
<v Thank you.>I think that's a fair point.

1009
01:59:13.307 --> 01:59:19.551
<v Thank you.>30, 35 Years from now saying, hey, we need to be planning for something and we still have 10 years left on these old bonds.

1010
01:59:19.728 --> 01:59:33.916
<v Thank you.>So I'd like to see what that interim scenario, that in-between scenario looks like that is a 30-year bond, but with the reductions in scenario 2, I'm hoping that's something that you might be able to share with us when you send follow-up documents.

1011
01:59:34.349 --> 01:59:38.153
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We actually have the information and Cecilia can share that with you right now.

1012
01:59:38.282 --> 01:59:39.354
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Councilor, if that's okay with you.

1013
01:59:39.418 --> 01:59:39.921
<v Thank you.>That would be great.

1014
01:59:40.230 --> 01:59:47.012
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so if we go with the 30-year term bonds, we're pretty much looking at Scenario 1 rates.

1015
01:59:47.574 --> 01:59:56.887
<v Unidentified speaker>The reduction, the $1 million reduction, will be able to allow us to drop year 1, fiscal year '26-'27, from 9.8% to 9.4%.

1016
01:59:57.773 --> 02:00:03.198
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's a 9.4% rate increase for year 1, and then the forecast will be 9.8%.

1017
02:00:04.382 --> 02:00:20.801
<v Thank you.>So it would give us a slight decrease in the increase in year 1, but we would still be looking at the same numbers lowered by just a couple of dollars from that first year out from there.

1018
02:00:22.680 --> 02:00:29.541
<v Thank you.>Why is it that even with the— Well, okay, that's helpful.

1019
02:00:29.605 --> 02:00:29.914
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

1020
02:00:30.132 --> 02:00:31.030
<v Thank you.>I appreciate that.

1021
02:00:33.819 --> 02:00:44.856
<v Thank you.>I'd love to see the exact numbers on what that looks like on the bar charts, the cost to taxpayers when you have that available, or if you have it, if you want to send it along.

1022
02:00:45.684 --> 02:00:50.128
<v Thank you.>It sounds like it's not significantly better though than doing a full Scenario 1.

1023
02:00:50.631 --> 02:00:51.182
<v Unidentified speaker>That's right.

1024
02:00:54.341 --> 02:00:57.639
<v Thank you.>I am also wondering about the Ratepayer Stability Fund.

1025
02:00:58.648 --> 02:01:06.016
<v Thank you.>We talk about having contingencies, having stability funds for hard times.

1026
02:01:07.413 --> 02:01:13.722
<v Thank you.>Are there triggers that you have in code for when we can access those funds?

1027
02:01:14.237 --> 02:01:17.173
<v Thank you.>When do we usually turn to those?

1028
02:01:17.367 --> 02:01:28.235
<v Thank you.>From the historic data that I've seen over the past 8 or 10 years, those reserves are Decent, not huge, and relatively stable.

1029
02:01:28.429 --> 02:01:30.579
<v Thank you.>We haven't drawn on them significantly.

1030
02:01:31.560 --> 02:01:56.501
<v Thank you.>And I am wondering if that is a source we should be looking to, to make our costs look more like Scenario 2 while still having a more responsible bonding timeline, or if there are reasons that we're holding on to those funds or triggers that have not been So we're talking about the rate stabilization funds.

1031
02:01:57.975 --> 02:01:59.546
<v Unidentified speaker>They really serve 2 purposes.

1032
02:02:00.203 --> 02:02:05.060
<v Unidentified speaker>One is to be able to allow us to smooth rates, 9.8, 9.8.

1033
02:02:05.510 --> 02:02:08.042
<v Unidentified speaker>We are drawing on those funds in some years.

1034
02:02:09.117 --> 02:02:16.954
<v Unidentified speaker>The second purpose is also for us to be able to meet our liquidity metric that the rating agencies are looking at.

1035
02:02:17.854 --> 02:02:24.649
<v Unidentified speaker>And we also maintain a minimum fund balance equal to about 90 days of operating expenses.

1036
02:02:25.099 --> 02:02:33.130
<v Unidentified speaker>So together, it allows us to be able to maintain our credit rating because of the strong cash position that we hold.

1037
02:02:34.094 --> 02:02:49.506
<v Thank you.>So the first part of what you said, that 9.8% over 5 years in Scenario 1, that is already drawing on funds from the Stabilization fund, dollars from the stabilization fund to keep that 9.8 level.

1038
02:02:49.569 --> 02:02:51.862
<v Thank you.>That's not actual true costs that we're seeing?

1039
02:02:52.118 --> 02:02:52.615
<v Unidentified speaker>That's correct.

1040
02:02:53.801 --> 02:02:54.859
<v Thank you.>Okay.

1041
02:02:55.341 --> 02:03:00.759
<v Thank you.>I didn't see that in the initial information, so I apologize.

1042
02:03:01.978 --> 02:03:09.063
<v Thank you.>And is that being drawn on in scenario 2 as well, or are we able to move forward without drawing on those funds in scenario 2?

1043
02:03:11.452 --> 02:03:13.956
<v Unidentified speaker>Likely are drawn a little bit on that as well.

1044
02:03:14.404 --> 02:03:20.697
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, again, you know, in the years where if we didn't use the account, it may require more than 8.5%.

1045
02:03:21.018 --> 02:03:23.970
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're just, you know, using the account to allow us to smooth the rates.

1046
02:03:24.452 --> 02:03:47.676
<v Thank you.>Okay, I have a couple of questions about parks, and I want to start by thanking you for specifically looking to reductions that minimize impact to Portlanders who are using our parks facilities and especially minimizing impacts to things that we promised during the levy conversation.

1047
02:03:48.011 --> 02:03:49.694
<v Thank you.>I appreciate that that's the intent.

1048
02:03:50.112 --> 02:03:52.546
<v Thank you.>I'm a little worried that we don't fully capture that.

1049
02:03:53.381 --> 02:04:08.150
<v Thank you.>And so I'd like to pick up on some of the questioning that my District 2 colleague started and understand more what the reduction in recreation, community centers, and environmental education are more specifically?

1050
02:04:08.712 --> 02:04:16.390
<v Thank you.>Because you said that they are not shutting down a full facility, which I appreciate, that it might be some hours or days reduced.

1051
02:04:17.289 --> 02:04:19.603
<v Thank you.>What are those proposals?

1052
02:04:21.000 --> 02:04:27.279
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We are looking forward to coming back in April and May with more information on what those proposals look like, Councilor.

1053
02:04:27.344 --> 02:04:29.431
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We are still evaluating what that would be.

1054
02:04:29.577 --> 02:04:31.792
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We are still finalizing those— that information.

1055
02:04:32.162 --> 02:04:38.923
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So either in a Public Works Committee or when we come back in April, or we can follow up with more information on that.

1056
02:04:40.354 --> 02:04:49.556
<v Thank you.>I think it's important as we look at any reduced hours that we are taking into account all of the uses in our community centers.

1057
02:04:50.938 --> 02:05:02.155
<v Thank you.>Closing community centers on days when preschool or after-school programs are there has a significant impact beyond just the, the standard recreation programs.

1058
02:05:02.988 --> 02:05:15.568
<v Thank you.>Closing community centers on days when kids are not in school and don't have other places to go has a significant impact beyond what some other days might look like.

1059
02:05:16.466 --> 02:05:31.170
<v Thank you.>So I would encourage you to think about not just what a day might cost, But what the impact might be if we're looking at some certain days, whatever those are.

1060
02:05:33.483 --> 02:05:37.378
<v Thank you.>Environmental education cuts—I'm not sure what is included there.

1061
02:05:38.072 --> 02:05:51.086
<v Thank you.>I know that those programs cover a lot of different things, but when we get specifics, I will be asking very specifically about summer programming, affordable camp options.

1062
02:05:51.198 --> 02:05:51.505
<v Thank you.>I know that.

1063
02:05:51.631 --> 02:05:56.095
<v Thank you.>Some of our camps are not included under environmental education, but some are.

1064
02:05:57.792 --> 02:05:59.490
<v Thank you.>Some are free-for-all options.

1065
02:06:00.122 --> 02:06:17.034
<v Thank you.>The things that make sure that kids have a safe place to go, a meal to eat, that parents have what is one of the only affordable day camp options in our city available to them at the level that is needed.

1066
02:06:18.068 --> 02:06:21.453
<v Thank you.>Those are things that are going to be really important for me to see maintained.

1067
02:06:21.935 --> 02:06:31.885
<v Thank you.>So as you work out the specifics, I hope that those are included in the programming that moves forward, and I'll certainly be asking about them.

1068
02:06:32.768 --> 02:06:34.966
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Thank you for that feedback, Councilor.

1069
02:06:35.416 --> 02:06:37.100
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We will definitely take that into consideration.

1070
02:06:37.404 --> 02:06:51.118
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I do want to mention, if I may, the choices that we are looking at are you know, program adjustments where we can scale back services with our alternate providers or closing lower demand sites.

1071
02:06:51.182 --> 02:06:58.386
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And so we are— I think we are aligned in what you're saying, and we will take that into consideration as we make, make those proposals forward.

1072
02:06:58.920 --> 02:06:58.984
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Yeah.

1073
02:06:59.082 --> 02:06:59.485
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

1074
02:07:00.212 --> 02:07:10.835
<v Thank you.>I also just want to note on slide 29, we're looking at closing the gaps here.

1075
02:07:11.688 --> 02:07:17.225
<v Thank you.>Is that deficit line parks levy or full parks funding?

1076
02:07:19.091 --> 02:07:23.868
<v Unidentified speaker>So that is, that is just the levy, which is that marginal resource on top of the general fund.

1077
02:07:23.917 --> 02:07:23.997
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1078
02:07:24.353 --> 02:07:30.600
<v Thank you.>So I am concerned that in both of these slides we show a deficit in the final year of the levy.

1079
02:07:31.666 --> 02:07:37.600
<v Thank you.>And I'm concerned with that because when we reviewed what happened with the previous levy.

1080
02:07:38.659 --> 02:07:47.128
<v Thank you.>What we discovered was that because we had phased funding, we used less at the beginning in order to afford more at the end.

1081
02:07:47.595 --> 02:08:01.381
<v Thank you.>We set up a situation where we were necessarily going to have to ask voters for a higher levy funding this past year because we ended the levy period spending more than we had available in any given Councilor Smith.

1082
02:08:02.378 --> 02:08:03.956
<v Thank you.>I see that happening again.

1083
02:08:05.097 --> 02:08:08.057
<v Thank you.>I'm very concerned that I see that happening again.

1084
02:08:09.279 --> 02:08:20.497
<v Thank you.>One of the conversations that we had during the process of putting the levy together was that we could not end up in a scenario where we necessarily had to go back to Portlanders and say we need more to do the same.

1085
02:08:22.252 --> 02:08:49.340
<v Thank you.>I would love to end up in a place 5 years from now where we have If we have to go back to Portlanders in 5 years and say, we saw this coming 5 years ago, we need more money to do the same, Portlanders should not say yes to us.

1086
02:08:50.170 --> 02:08:53.130
<v Unidentified speaker>And if Portlanders do not say yes to a levy, we will not be able to do the work that we need to do.

1087
02:08:53.130 --> 02:08:53.170
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1088
02:08:53.533 --> 02:08:59.929
<v Thank you.>We do not have the park system that our families absolutely rely on to have the type of city they want to live in.

1089
02:09:01.085 --> 02:09:27.445
<v Thank you.>So I hope that over the next year, because I know this doesn't change with what we do between now and a budget 2 months from now, we can figure out how to change the projections on levy spending so that that line is either flat and we are using the levy in a consistent way across the 5-year period, or that line starts higher so that it still ends in the positive.

1090
02:09:28.145 --> 02:09:45.467
<v Thank you.>I don't think it's acceptable just a few months after we asked Portlanders to fund a sustainable level of levy to project a parks plan that shows us 5 years from now needing to ask them for even more to do the same thing.

1091
02:09:48.252 --> 02:09:54.515
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think that's a really great point, and it is one of the reasons why we are showing the before and after.

1092
02:09:54.740 --> 02:10:00.667
<v Unidentified speaker>And I just want to acknowledge that as a finance guy, I try to be as conservative as possible in our projections.

1093
02:10:01.020 --> 02:10:07.077
<v Unidentified speaker>And so one thing we don't want to do is overcut in order to meet that, to meet that goal.

1094
02:10:07.992 --> 02:10:17.940
<v Unidentified speaker>And so there is some hope for some upside, but it does give us several years of positive, of no deficit in order to figure out does that upside materialize?

1095
02:10:17.989 --> 02:10:23.412
<v Unidentified speaker>We just talked about potential adjustments to the expense forecast in some of the internal services.

1096
02:10:23.460 --> 02:10:30.996
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's those areas where we wanna make sure that we're not overcutting in advance of other decisions or possible things that might come into the forecast.

1097
02:10:31.043 --> 02:10:40.880
<v Unidentified speaker>But absolutely, we wanna be looking out those 5 years and that's really why we're bringing this to you and we wanna make sure that collectively we're looking at that.

1098
02:10:40.929 --> 02:10:41.043
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Thank you.

1099
02:10:41.492 --> 02:10:42.247
<v Unidentified speaker>Always and all the time.

1100
02:10:42.939 --> 02:10:43.405
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

1101
02:10:43.487 --> 02:10:56.117
<v Thank you.>And I know that the ending fund balance is in a much better place, is in the positive with the $7 million reductions, but the year over year still shows a deficit in that final year, even with the $7 million reduction.

1102
02:10:56.164 --> 02:10:57.865
<v Thank you.>And that's the piece that's concerning to me.

1103
02:11:01.327 --> 02:11:10.815
<v Thank you.>Council President, I think I'm going to end there because I don't want to draw us into 20 more minutes questions, which is what will happen if I start going down the PBOT path.

1104
02:11:10.880 --> 02:11:14.779
<v Thank you.>And I think we have a lot of other work that will happen around our transportation funding.

1105
02:11:15.372 --> 02:11:16.061
<v Thank you.>Thank you very much.

1106
02:11:17.153 --> 02:11:17.795
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Sounds good.

1107
02:11:17.859 --> 02:11:18.115
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you.

1108
02:11:18.886 --> 02:11:22.287
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>There are 6 councilors still in queue, folks.

1109
02:11:22.350 --> 02:11:28.832
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>We also have a brief discussion with the CFO at the end of this to discuss what happens after today.

1110
02:11:29.634 --> 02:11:32.666
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>So I'm hoping we can be a little timely in this.

1111
02:11:33.099 --> 02:11:33.740
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Clark.

1112
02:11:34.302 --> 02:11:35.377
<v 1,000 years.>Thank you, Councilor President.

1113
02:11:35.426 --> 02:11:36.436
<v 1,000 years.>I'll be very brief.

1114
02:11:36.694 --> 02:11:39.631
<v 1,000 years.>Um, I don't have any questions, I just have some more comments.

1115
02:11:40.305 --> 02:11:46.484
<v 1,000 years.>Um, I guess I'm somewhere on the other end of the stick from, uh, my colleagues in District 2.

1116
02:11:47.365 --> 02:11:55.293
<v 1,000 years.>Uh, I'm quite concerned that on slide 31 that we're looking at reducing more of the parks maintenance budget.

1117
02:11:55.807 --> 02:12:01.070
<v 1,000 years.>We are already so underfunded in taking care of the assets that we have.

1118
02:12:01.262 --> 02:12:05.077
<v 1,000 years.>As I said earlier, I think we're risking liability issues.

1119
02:12:05.734 --> 02:12:07.961
<v 1,000 years.>Um, that is of great concern to me.

1120
02:12:08.073 --> 02:12:15.877
<v 1,000 years.>It hasn't been taken into consideration what kind of liabilities we may have, but we're already way underfunding maintenance.

1121
02:12:16.711 --> 02:12:24.930
<v 1,000 years.>Um, so, uh, I was very disappointed to see maintenance, uh, parks maintenance highlighted, uh, on page 31.

1122
02:12:25.315 --> 02:12:29.021
<v 1,000 years.>I'm hoping that There's other ways we can skin this cat.

1123
02:12:30.354 --> 02:12:38.296
<v 1,000 years.>And my second comment is about not so much volunteerism, but entrepreneurial approach to our assets.

1124
02:12:39.501 --> 02:12:44.122
<v 1,000 years.>We have assets that, as the mayor likes to say, they are not sweating.

1125
02:12:44.234 --> 02:12:46.095
<v 1,000 years.>We need to make some of these things sweat.

1126
02:12:46.161 --> 02:12:53.109
<v 1,000 years.>We need to be more creative about the public-private partnerships that we have when it comes to parks and recreation.

1127
02:12:53.527 --> 02:13:00.079
<v 1,000 years.>I was just at the Multnomah Arts Center here recently, and, um, don't worry, I'm not, I'm not going there.

1128
02:13:00.753 --> 02:13:15.917
<v 1,000 years.>Um, but I, I realized that the kitchen— it was a commercial kitchen— if that was updated, they would be able to rent out the, the gymnasium and the other facilities there and actually make money for the arts programs.

1129
02:13:16.350 --> 02:13:19.529
<v 1,000 years.>But I don't understand why that kind of an entrepreneurial Yes.

1130
02:13:19.641 --> 02:13:24.658
<v 1,000 years.>Is not being encouraged more at our facilities.

1131
02:13:24.706 --> 02:13:26.484
<v 1,000 years.>So I just want to put that out there.

1132
02:13:27.654 --> 02:13:28.952
<v 1,000 years.>That's a future issue.

1133
02:13:29.095 --> 02:13:35.939
<v 1,000 years.>But let's not be, as I said the other day in one of the other budget discussions, penny-wise and pound-foolish.

1134
02:13:36.451 --> 02:13:45.729
<v 1,000 years.>There are investments here that we should be making that will pay off, that will prevent us from having liabilities, and really encourage growth and potentially revenue generation.

1135
02:13:48.077 --> 02:13:49.113
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1136
02:13:49.226 --> 02:13:50.166
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Ryan.

1137
02:13:50.911 --> 02:13:52.126
<v Thank you.>Thank you, Council President.

1138
02:13:52.368 --> 02:13:55.948
<v Thank you.>First off, excellent presentation, uh, DCA Dhanapal.

1139
02:13:55.997 --> 02:13:59.952
<v Thank you.>I really appreciate it, you— especially that you got to the scenario planning.

1140
02:14:01.345 --> 02:14:08.005
<v Thank you.>Um, we've talked a lot about trade-offs in the past year, and this year it can no longer be talk.

1141
02:14:08.198 --> 02:14:13.793
<v Thank you.>I mean, we're here, and so it's going to be really hard, it's going to be painful, And it's the action that we have to take this year.

1142
02:14:14.180 --> 02:14:20.359
<v Thank you.>And so by having the scenario planning slides, it brought that reality, and I appreciate that.

1143
02:14:21.561 --> 02:14:34.208
<v Thank you.>And the reason why the reality is probably hitting harder with this presentation than the others is because Portlanders, if you add public safety to this, public works and public safety is our must-haves.

1144
02:14:34.481 --> 02:14:42.770
<v Thank you.>Like, these are the basics that when you compare to your Neighboring cities that you mentioned earlier, Council President.

1145
02:14:42.819 --> 02:14:43.828
<v Thank you.>That's the equation.

1146
02:14:44.485 --> 02:14:50.238
<v Thank you.>It's how much are they paying for their basic services, and then what's their service they're receiving from those.

1147
02:14:51.311 --> 02:14:54.805
<v Thank you.>And when I listen to Portlanders, they are asking those questions.

1148
02:14:56.038 --> 02:14:58.283
<v Thank you.>And so this is tough work.

1149
02:14:59.068 --> 02:15:03.762
<v Thank you.>And I want to acknowledge that I see the public servants that are in Public Works.

1150
02:15:03.810 --> 02:15:03.907
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1151
02:15:05.128 --> 02:15:10.708
<v Thank you.>Like public safety that are engaging and interacting with Portlanders every day.

1152
02:15:11.935 --> 02:15:25.993
<v Thank you.>So I hope that we can prepare, we can protect as much the wisdom on the ground as we look at some of those trade-offs that are going to be painful again, but might be in some of the positions that are between, that are up higher.

1153
02:15:26.984 --> 02:15:29.925
<v Thank you.>And so I've always agreed with your— is it, you call it pillar and pyramid?

1154
02:15:29.972 --> 02:15:30.055
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1155
02:15:30.807 --> 02:15:30.984
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1156
02:15:31.225 --> 02:15:32.926
<v Thank you.>Okay, I'll go with that for right now.

1157
02:15:33.216 --> 02:15:36.475
<v Thank you.>I want to do something with the pyramid, but anyway, I'll go with that.

1158
02:15:37.086 --> 02:15:41.277
<v Thank you.>And I think that this is the kind of presentation that reminds us of that.

1159
02:15:41.903 --> 02:15:47.442
<v Thank you.>I have a few comments to make about, um, we've had a lot of dialogue about the bond rate.

1160
02:15:48.390 --> 02:15:56.720
<v Thank you.>And actually, Jonas, could you come up and give us bold, direct, crisp, uh, Jonas on What is it?

1161
02:15:56.947 --> 02:16:01.694
<v Thank you.>What's really the impacts of 40-year bond compared to 30-year bond, for example?

1162
02:16:02.291 --> 02:16:07.309
<v Thank you.>I think we've all made statements, but I kind of want to hear it from the CFO.

1163
02:16:08.185 --> 02:16:10.422
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you, Councilor, for the question.

1164
02:16:10.471 --> 02:16:17.266
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, Jonas Biery, the city's Chief Financial Officer, anticipated this question may come up at some point today.

1165
02:16:18.462 --> 02:16:19.625
<v Unidentified speaker>Couple things I'll observe.

1166
02:16:20.319 --> 02:16:39.081
<v Unidentified speaker>First is that broadly, You know, particularly over the last couple few years that we've experienced sort of an increase in higher or medium risk kind of decision-making, deferred payments around debt, extending those bond payment schedules, you know, reductions in reserves.

1167
02:16:39.851 --> 02:16:47.924
<v Unidentified speaker>So I really appreciate the question, Councilor, because it does highlight how the collective impacts of those little decisions do start to have demonstrable impacts.

1168
02:16:48.051 --> 02:16:48.261
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1169
02:16:49.046 --> 02:16:53.961
<v Unidentified speaker>And we're certainly seeing indications of that when we have those credit rating discussions right now.

1170
02:16:55.921 --> 02:17:06.996
<v Unidentified speaker>Specific to the kind of 40-year bond question, and this came up I think in another comment around, a couple of comments around kind of intergenerational equity and kicking the can.

1171
02:17:07.752 --> 02:17:15.538
<v Unidentified speaker>There's an important lens to look at, and I think Cecilia kind of got to this earlier as well, but extending the debt payment is literally kicking the can.

1172
02:17:15.587 --> 02:17:15.772
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1173
02:17:16.477 --> 02:17:23.588
<v Unidentified speaker>It's literally extending those payments out to future generations, stacking additional debt onto that.

1174
02:17:23.861 --> 02:17:27.940
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe the strategy is that all debt for that project would go to 40 years.

1175
02:17:28.759 --> 02:17:42.468
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that not only kicks the can down beyond, you know, kind of the foreseeable generation, it also limits our capacity to invest in the future as we stack those debt payments on.

1176
02:17:42.725 --> 02:17:47.117
<v Unidentified speaker>We have less available in future years to invest in the next cycle of asset needs.

1177
02:17:47.165 --> 02:17:49.963
<v Unidentified speaker>So I just wanna observe that, that that's an important trade-off.

1178
02:17:51.120 --> 02:18:00.531
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd also kind of note that having been around here for a while, it wasn't that long ago that we actually shifted from 20-year debt to 25- and 30-year debt.

1179
02:18:01.274 --> 02:18:10.656
<v Unidentified speaker>I was in a different seat and advocating for making that change despite some anxiety around even extending to the 30-year window that we have now.

1180
02:18:11.292 --> 02:18:13.144
<v Unidentified speaker>Also recognizing it's a slippery slope.

1181
02:18:13.225 --> 02:18:14.432
<v Thank you.>When you say not long ago?

1182
02:18:14.737 --> 02:18:16.380
<v Unidentified speaker>A decade or so ago.

1183
02:18:16.590 --> 02:18:18.538
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, maybe 15 years or so.

1184
02:18:19.198 --> 02:18:26.031
<v Unidentified speaker>So I just want to also acknowledge that we only recently extended in the utilities beyond kind of a 20-year timeframe.

1185
02:18:27.620 --> 02:18:37.338
<v Unidentified speaker>And then just lastly, to summarize, I mean, I certainly understand deeply the rate pressure and the need to continue to invest in our infrastructure on a timely basis.

1186
02:18:38.162 --> 02:18:47.295
<v Unidentified speaker>If you're asking me as CFO what my recommendation is with all those trade-offs considered, it is not extending beyond the 30-year timeframe.

1187
02:18:49.139 --> 02:18:49.862
<v Thank you.>That was really helpful.

1188
02:18:50.280 --> 02:18:50.826
<v Thank you.>Thank you, Jonas.

1189
02:18:51.516 --> 02:19:01.100
<v Thank you.>I'm going to shift to the Water Bureau, and I just have to plug one more time how much I appreciate and support the filtration system project.

1190
02:19:01.343 --> 02:19:05.995
<v Thank you.>It's the big— it's like It's bigger than the Big Pipe and it keeps growing.

1191
02:19:06.894 --> 02:19:20.106
<v Thank you.>And what I like about it, and I'll always be an advocate for this part for sure, I see the student graduating from David Douglas, getting a pre-apprenticeship, staying on that project for 10 years and becoming a journey person.

1192
02:19:20.155 --> 02:19:25.190
<v Thank you.>So from a labor standpoint, it's just so— it's a good story and I want to go out of the way.

1193
02:19:25.271 --> 02:19:28.926
<v Thank you.>It's also a Portland story because we have access to fresh water.

1194
02:19:28.975 --> 02:19:31.867
<v Thank you.>That's the envy of like Many around the entire world.

1195
02:19:32.334 --> 02:19:34.493
<v Thank you.>It's like one of our most precious jewels, if you will.

1196
02:19:35.072 --> 02:19:37.778
<v Thank you.>And I don't have to wax on about why everyone knows that's important.

1197
02:19:38.740 --> 02:19:45.707
<v Thank you.>We gotta make it, make certain that it like works and it is that asset that we want for the over a century.

1198
02:19:46.405 --> 02:19:55.948
<v Thank you.>And so I think what I'm missing this past year that I experienced differently 2 years ago, if you will, was more frequent updates on that.

1199
02:19:55.995 --> 02:19:56.043
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Yeah.

1200
02:19:56.802 --> 02:20:05.055
<v Thank you.>And so I think that would be helpful, CA Lee, if we work that into the reports from the city administrator.

1201
02:20:05.760 --> 02:20:07.715
<v Thank you.>They feel like it comes too infrequent.

1202
02:20:08.164 --> 02:20:12.281
<v Thank you.>And I know some of that's because we had stoppage and such, but it's such a big project.

1203
02:20:12.890 --> 02:20:14.765
<v Thank you.>And so thank you for hearing that.

1204
02:20:15.310 --> 02:20:21.929
<v Thank you.>I am rushing to go through stuff because others had gone earlier and I have to be quick.

1205
02:20:21.977 --> 02:20:22.088
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1206
02:20:23.329 --> 02:20:23.527
<v Thank you.>PBOT.

1207
02:20:23.691 --> 02:20:24.942
<v Thank you.>Do I want to say any of that?

1208
02:20:28.943 --> 02:20:37.486
<v Thank you.>PBOT, I feel your pain already just looking at these numbers, and there's not a general fund to help rescue.

1209
02:20:38.542 --> 02:20:41.697
<v Thank you.>And maybe what I'll just say is that I appreciate the work that you're doing.

1210
02:20:42.430 --> 02:20:51.808
<v Thank you.>I also appreciate everyone that's bellyaching to me about when they have— they know construction rates are different than Cost of living rates, but they can only live in the world of cost of living.

1211
02:20:52.470 --> 02:21:00.922
<v Thank you.>And so when rates get— increases get above 3.7 or so, wherever they're at right now, who knows what's going on in Washington, D.C. today that could make them go up even more.

1212
02:21:01.050 --> 02:21:09.400
<v Thank you.>But it's just so important that we're mindful of how many Portlanders are struggling right now with affordability.

1213
02:21:10.566 --> 02:21:12.734
<v Thank you.>And that gets passed down to renters as well, as we know.

1214
02:21:14.255 --> 02:21:15.479
<v Thank you.>And so thank you, Councilor Clark.

1215
02:21:15.528 --> 02:21:18.992
<v Thank you.>You're doing really hard work and it's going to be tough.

1216
02:21:20.083 --> 02:21:24.586
<v Thank you.>And I hope with that we see creative, bold restructuring.

1217
02:21:26.076 --> 02:21:38.888
<v Thank you.>I was disappointed with the last city administrator that was here in the interim and that we didn't go harder on accepting the fact that we have an opportunity to break down the silos.

1218
02:21:38.938 --> 02:21:41.056
<v Thank you.>Remember, that was one of the reasons people voted for the charter.

1219
02:21:41.936 --> 02:21:52.388
<v Thank you.>And so we've focused on the political part of the restructure, but we're waiting for the enterprise of the city to be a part of that new form of government.

1220
02:21:53.656 --> 02:21:54.841
<v Thank you.>And this is the time.

1221
02:21:56.447 --> 02:21:59.373
<v Thank you.>And it's going to be painful, but this is the time.

1222
02:22:00.581 --> 02:22:01.546
<v Thank you.>So I look forward to that.

1223
02:22:01.593 --> 02:22:06.362
<v Thank you.>And I think the PBOT story clearly makes me want to speak to that.

1224
02:22:06.414 --> 02:22:08.157
<v Thank you.>So I'll I'll avoid the details.

1225
02:22:09.459 --> 02:22:20.605
<v Thank you.>On parks, first I want to applaud you, or you are, Sonya Szymanski, Director Szymanski, for hiring someone to focus on philanthropic efforts, for private endeavors, for partnerships.

1226
02:22:22.138 --> 02:22:23.622
<v Thank you.>And we have to keep going harder there.

1227
02:22:24.219 --> 02:22:25.850
<v Thank you.>We've talked about the friends groups.

1228
02:22:26.559 --> 02:22:42.114
<v Thank you.>How do we go from the Bureau of No sometimes when it came to embracing That joy and messiness that is having a lot of volunteers to just embracing it and just having them more and more part of even some of the cleanup.

1229
02:22:42.621 --> 02:22:44.324
<v Thank you.>And I'm going to end with a story yesterday.

1230
02:22:45.670 --> 02:22:48.457
<v Thank you.>I, I won't say their name because I didn't get permission.

1231
02:22:48.584 --> 02:22:53.402
<v Thank you.>I had a conversation with a person from Parks that was doing painting.

1232
02:22:55.163 --> 02:22:57.721
<v Thank you.>They were painting a restroom, so they were doing maintenance work.

1233
02:22:57.820 --> 02:22:58.102
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, that's great.

1234
02:22:58.897 --> 02:23:05.454
<v Thank you.>But I kept asking them questions about, is it different doing this work today than it was 10 years ago?

1235
02:23:06.734 --> 02:23:10.784
<v Thank you.>And they said, yes, there's more damage, there's more repair now.

1236
02:23:12.537 --> 02:23:18.322
<v Thank you.>Some of the same challenges we're having because, of course, abatement work has gone up, graffiti removal has gone up.

1237
02:23:18.402 --> 02:23:19.397
<v Thank you.>Well, that's parks.

1238
02:23:20.475 --> 02:23:25.215
<v Thank you.>All of our assets that are facing the public right-of-way are experiencing more damage.

1239
02:23:25.310 --> 02:23:25.375
<v Unidentified speaker>Right.

1240
02:23:26.078 --> 02:23:27.271
<v Thank you.>That's just a fact.

1241
02:23:28.317 --> 02:23:31.217
<v Thank you.>And it's making our cost drivers go up and expenses go up.

1242
02:23:32.022 --> 02:23:43.584
<v Thank you.>They didn't get into that detail 'cause that's my job at this level, but they're just so enthusiastic about their job and they were so content with making that restroom look better than it has in a long time.

1243
02:23:44.245 --> 02:23:48.617
<v Thank you.>But that job takes longer than it did 10 years ago, and they've worked here for some time.

1244
02:23:51.501 --> 02:23:55.397
<v Thank you.>I am intrigued by how you got to your budget approach.

1245
02:23:55.623 --> 02:23:56.788
<v Thank you.>Like, who was at the table?

1246
02:23:56.836 --> 02:23:59.699
<v Thank you.>Was that predominantly with the Parks Board?

1247
02:23:59.843 --> 02:24:01.902
<v Thank you.>Was it with the friends groups?

1248
02:24:02.421 --> 02:24:09.040
<v Thank you.>Who were the voices at the table that inspired this approach to budget prioritization?

1249
02:24:15.612 --> 02:24:21.897
<v Thank you.>I will say that Your wonderful finance person is very conservative with estimates.

1250
02:24:22.351 --> 02:24:22.837
<v Thank you.>I know this.

1251
02:24:24.323 --> 02:24:24.468
<v Thank you.>Yeah.

1252
02:24:24.709 --> 02:24:25.788
<v Thank you.>Hi, Director Szymanski.

1253
02:24:25.852 --> 02:24:26.513
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, thank you.

1254
02:24:26.576 --> 02:24:27.109
<v Unidentified speaker>Great question.

1255
02:24:27.558 --> 02:24:28.943
<v Unidentified speaker>Sonia Szymanski, Parks Bureau.

1256
02:24:29.878 --> 02:24:35.721
<v Unidentified speaker>We had very little time to develop scenarios for this process.

1257
02:24:36.703 --> 02:24:39.988
<v Unidentified speaker>We worked primarily among our senior management team.

1258
02:24:41.469 --> 02:24:54.076
<v Unidentified speaker>We did not have a lot of opportunity to work with our advisory bodies, of which we have a few, primarily Parks Board, nor has there been time for deep community engagement in this process so far.

1259
02:24:54.993 --> 02:25:01.324
<v Unidentified speaker>We did lean heavily though on prior community engagement, including very recent.

1260
02:25:01.902 --> 02:25:25.235
<v Unidentified speaker>And we really, I think rigorously for the time we had, looked to community needs survey information, Portland Insight survey information, our employee survey, Healthy Parks, Healthy Portland, and what we've heard from you, including in the last budget cycle, to try to align as closely as we could to all of that direction.

1261
02:25:26.613 --> 02:25:27.272
<v Thank you.>That was helpful.

1262
02:25:27.352 --> 02:25:27.736
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

1263
02:25:29.115 --> 02:25:33.029
<v Thank you.>Since the pool came up, thank you, Council President.

1264
02:25:33.301 --> 02:25:36.076
<v Thank you.>I want to remind people why it was selected at that Thank you.

1265
02:25:36.125 --> 02:25:38.985
<v Thank you.>So, Councilor Dan Ryan, can you tell us why we selected that site and why swim literacy really matters?

1266
02:25:39.081 --> 02:25:45.588
<v Thank you.>It was selected at that site because it was by far the highest equity-rated site of the 3 locations.

1267
02:25:46.070 --> 02:25:52.369
<v Thank you.>It was closest to our schools and the schools that have the higher BIPOC populations.

1268
02:25:52.626 --> 02:26:02.298
<v Thank you.>And data suggests very heavily that the ones— people, families who don't have access to pools and therefore have a higher rate of Not knowing how to swim.

1269
02:26:02.345 --> 02:26:02.971
<v Thank you.>Not knowing how to swim.

1270
02:26:03.084 --> 02:26:03.933
<v Thank you.>Let's just call it that.

1271
02:26:04.768 --> 02:26:08.761
<v Thank you.>And so that's what swim literacy is, and it's trying to narrow that gap.

1272
02:26:09.722 --> 02:26:11.775
<v Thank you.>And that site was selected for that.

1273
02:26:12.386 --> 02:26:35.539
<v Thank you.>There's a Schools to Pools program that I hope we can keep engaging with PPS, because in David Douglas School District, one reason they have a much higher swim literacy rate is because the students do a PE class called swimming at their So Portland, working with our school system, can do swimming lessons called PE with their elementary schools.

1274
02:26:36.132 --> 02:26:41.577
<v Thank you.>And that site was centrally located around the entire catchment area for the Roosevelt cluster.

1275
02:26:41.995 --> 02:26:46.138
<v Thank you.>And then you have Dishman that's more centralized to the Jefferson and Summer Grant.

1276
02:26:46.573 --> 02:26:50.235
<v Thank you.>So we have to think of it as a system to improve swim literacy.

1277
02:26:50.893 --> 02:26:53.656
<v Thank you.>And that's one of the main drivers of this goal for that pool.

1278
02:26:53.719 --> 02:26:53.897
<v It's a system that spans multiple agencies.>Thank you.

1279
02:26:54.443 --> 02:27:00.462
<v Thank you.>So I just wanted to bring it back to some of the original intention as we're in the budget aspect of this.

1280
02:27:01.447 --> 02:27:09.195
<v Thank you.>I think it's important to remind our colleagues one reason we're here is because our bread and butter revenue for general fund is way down.

1281
02:27:10.090 --> 02:27:12.631
<v Thank you.>Our business taxes, licenses are flat.

1282
02:27:13.911 --> 02:27:20.899
<v Thank you.>And our property taxes, no matter what your opinion is of this, the commercial buildings downtown's value have gone—.

1283
02:27:20.933 --> 02:27:20.981
<v Unidentified speaker>Down.

1284
02:27:21.352 --> 02:27:22.292
<v Thank you.>Down considerably.

1285
02:27:22.811 --> 02:27:25.860
<v Thank you.>So we have less revenue coming into the city and the county.

1286
02:27:26.443 --> 02:27:27.254
<v Thank you.>That's our reality.

1287
02:27:28.513 --> 02:27:37.716
<v Thank you.>And so we have to keep figuring out how to provide a city that attracts currency so that we can start to see our general fund come up.

1288
02:27:38.602 --> 02:27:47.966
<v Thank you.>And we can't tax our way out of this, but we can, we can continue to provide a place that attracts people that want to live here, invest here.

1289
02:27:48.698 --> 02:27:50.498
<v Thank you.>And shamelessly visit.

1290
02:27:50.789 --> 02:27:56.079
<v Thank you.>Like, thank you to all the people who are here from all the different universities across the country.

1291
02:27:56.175 --> 02:27:59.322
<v Thank you.>We're like having a really good weekend in terms of collecting revenue.

1292
02:28:00.083 --> 02:28:06.138
<v Thank you.>It's one of those moments where you wish you could do a temporary sales tax for restaurants.

1293
02:28:06.316 --> 02:28:07.238
<v Thank you.>It's called the tourist tax.

1294
02:28:07.629 --> 02:28:12.546
<v Thank you.>'Cause I always feel like in the summer and moments like this, we leave so much money on the table compared to other cities.

1295
02:28:13.061 --> 02:28:18.800
<v Thank you.>Okay, that was a colorful thing to say that I'm was not in my— obviously in my text, so I better stop.

1296
02:28:19.299 --> 02:28:20.117
<v Thank you.>It's spring break time.

1297
02:28:20.486 --> 02:28:23.504
<v Thank you.>All right, be bold, be creative, impress us.

1298
02:28:23.841 --> 02:28:24.097
<v Thank you.>Thanks.

1299
02:28:24.739 --> 02:28:25.990
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1300
02:28:26.247 --> 02:28:26.938
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Green.

1301
02:28:28.271 --> 02:28:28.592
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1302
02:28:28.768 --> 02:28:29.570
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll, I'll be brief.

1303
02:28:29.779 --> 02:28:46.077
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I want to weigh back in on the conversation around bonds, and I think I just want to clarify that— I mean, I think if the choice is between not issuing the bonds and paying for A and issuing the bonds for paying for A, always don't issue the bonds.

1304
02:28:46.433 --> 02:28:50.322
<v Unidentified speaker>Like, just pay for A. I mean, that's obviously a better proposition to make.

1305
02:28:50.870 --> 02:28:57.986
<v Unidentified speaker>I think where I get concerned is, are we going to not do other important things because we're making trade-offs with scarce current resources?

1306
02:28:59.653 --> 02:29:12.884
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think in the context of PBOT's revenue challenge, context of just the broad affordability discussion that we're thinking about, We hear over and over and over again that Portlanders are leaving the city because they can't afford to be here anymore.

1307
02:29:13.352 --> 02:29:16.513
<v Unidentified speaker>Utility rates are a big part of that, or at least that's what I hear from my constituents.

1308
02:29:16.995 --> 02:29:28.515
<v Unidentified speaker>And so if we're able to ease that a little bit, to send a signal that we, we do care about giving folks a break right now and they don't leave, that is a boon to our growth.

1309
02:29:30.253 --> 02:29:43.487
<v Unidentified speaker>And the scholarly research in urban regional economics is very clear that when you have a density-focused growth regime, that your cost per unit of delivery of infrastructure declines.

1310
02:29:43.617 --> 02:29:44.836
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's an economy of scale.

1311
02:29:45.447 --> 02:29:51.516
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think I get concerned about growing our way out of it, as Councilor Pirtle-Guiney had raised.

1312
02:29:51.596 --> 02:29:53.442
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, it's a really legitimate concern.

1313
02:29:54.054 --> 02:30:06.978
<v Unidentified speaker>If we don't have a growth regime that sets us up to have dense growth, And we're growing it in a very tepid way, very slow way, and we're just kind of pushing out at the boundaries, then I'm not sure you get that economy of scale.

1314
02:30:07.042 --> 02:30:10.592
<v Unidentified speaker>And you probably do match your costs with your growth, and that's scary.

1315
02:30:10.656 --> 02:30:17.543
<v Unidentified speaker>And if we don't grow at all, if we're just flat, then that debt overhang is— that is the doom loop, frankly.

1316
02:30:17.881 --> 02:30:20.434
<v Unidentified speaker>That is what cities— that's the Detroit example.

1317
02:30:20.531 --> 02:30:23.277
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's what people are really worried about when we think about the debt.

1318
02:30:23.341 --> 02:30:23.485
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1319
02:30:25.477 --> 02:30:32.393
<v Unidentified speaker>So, you know, at the end of the day, if we choose Scenario 1 or Scenario 2, it's probably not going to make a huge difference one way or the other.

1320
02:30:32.489 --> 02:30:49.451
<v Unidentified speaker>I just needed to name that $900 million over 20 years in interest is not as scary as it sounds when you think about— or I should say 40 years— when you think about the opportunity that we have to climb out of this trough we're in, in a very robust growth climate.

1321
02:30:49.504 --> 02:30:49.643
<v Thank you.>Thank you.

1322
02:30:50.194 --> 02:30:52.408
<v Unidentified speaker>Because we've set the right land use policies in place.

1323
02:30:52.925 --> 02:30:54.104
<v Unidentified speaker>That's the opportunity ahead of us.

1324
02:30:54.154 --> 02:30:55.801
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think we're actually trying to go in that direction.

1325
02:30:55.850 --> 02:31:00.602
<v Unidentified speaker>This council may be the most pro-growth council in a long period of time.

1326
02:31:02.639 --> 02:31:10.144
<v Unidentified speaker>I think $2 on an average utility bill is probably not going to send the price signal to make a difference one way or the other.

1327
02:31:10.191 --> 02:31:12.028
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's a really rich conversation to have.

1328
02:31:12.583 --> 02:31:26.110
<v Unidentified speaker>But I think I didn't want to miss the moment to name that People who study this and publish in peer-reviewed journals do find that when we let our cities grow more densely, then our cost per unit of infrastructure delivery declines.

1329
02:31:26.462 --> 02:31:27.395
<v Unidentified speaker>That's what we want to do.

1330
02:31:27.490 --> 02:31:28.968
<v Unidentified speaker>That's, that's where we want to go.

1331
02:31:29.578 --> 02:31:41.592
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think the city of Portland will have a challenge because we have— we've got a pretty low-density city, and we do have the infrastructure deficits in East Portland that will take a long period to catch up.

1332
02:31:41.639 --> 02:31:42.009
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's a good point.

1333
02:31:42.201 --> 02:31:45.567
<v Unidentified speaker>And so even if we were to upzone and grow in East Portland, we're going to have that lag.

1334
02:31:45.631 --> 02:31:47.565
<v Unidentified speaker>And that might be what you're worried about, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1335
02:31:47.983 --> 02:31:48.644
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm worried about it too.

1336
02:31:48.708 --> 02:32:04.118
<v Unidentified speaker>And so, you know, I'll wrap up my rant here by saying that our ability to issue the bonds is going to be a function of creditworthiness, our willingness to raise rates when we have to raise rates, and what our overall asset and liability picture looks like.

1337
02:32:04.199 --> 02:32:07.548
<v Unidentified speaker>And so if we're a growing city, it's not a finite resource.

1338
02:32:07.614 --> 02:32:07.682
<v Unidentified speaker>Right.

1339
02:32:08.861 --> 02:32:11.748
<v Unidentified speaker>Like, that will scale with the size of our city.

1340
02:32:11.814 --> 02:32:14.879
<v Unidentified speaker>So, uh, I'm grateful we can have this conversation.

1341
02:32:14.926 --> 02:32:18.103
<v Unidentified speaker>There's some critical voices up here, so, um, I'm going to leave it at that.

1342
02:32:18.554 --> 02:32:19.676
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1343
02:32:19.836 --> 02:32:20.478
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Novick.

1344
02:32:21.602 --> 02:32:22.501
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mr. President.

1345
02:32:22.950 --> 02:32:34.584
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, on the proposed parks cuts, um, I think that the, the biggest chunks of parks expenses are maintenance of the outdoor parks in particular and operation of the community centers and other places where kids go to play.

1346
02:32:35.995 --> 02:32:36.461
<v Unidentified speaker>Facilities.

1347
02:32:36.622 --> 02:32:47.581
<v Unidentified speaker>And I was wondering if you looked at another cut package that focused more on reducing operations of facilities, or is there some accounting thing where we rely on the levy more for that than general fund?

1348
02:32:50.699 --> 02:33:02.134
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think that some of the reductions that are being considered that Deputy City Administrator Dhanapal spoke about earlier speak to some of those services rather than rather than maintenance.

1349
02:33:02.713 --> 02:33:03.373
<v Unidentified speaker>But I think you're right.

1350
02:33:03.438 --> 02:33:08.738
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are— you've identified the, like, the main costs associated with delivering service in parks.

1351
02:33:09.239 --> 02:33:12.809
<v Unidentified speaker>Director Szymanski, did you want to elaborate on that?

1352
02:33:12.954 --> 02:33:13.730
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I'm just in the wings.

1353
02:33:13.924 --> 02:33:14.489
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1354
02:33:15.379 --> 02:33:22.530
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, because I just— I mean, I think that it might be reasonable to sort of look at 2 approaches.

1355
02:33:22.805 --> 02:33:24.257
<v Unidentified speaker>One, cutting back on maintenance.

1356
02:33:24.338 --> 02:33:25.613
<v Unidentified speaker>2, Cutting back on operations.

1357
02:33:26.159 --> 02:33:28.466
<v Unidentified speaker>And we could see what the what those would look like.

1358
02:33:30.908 --> 02:33:44.097
<v Unidentified speaker>On PBOT, first of all, Director Williams, I'm glad to hear that we've increased the number of parking enforcement officers because it was Bob Dylan who said in Subterranean Homesick Blues, don't follow leaders, watch the parking meters.

1359
02:33:45.760 --> 02:34:01.458
<v Unidentified speaker>I wanted to ask a question that Councilor Kanal and I were talking about earlier today, which is— and I will recite my favorite grim statistic that It would take an additional $40 to $50 million a year to keep our streets of citywide concern in their current mediocre condition.

1360
02:34:02.084 --> 02:34:08.170
<v Unidentified speaker>And what we were wondering is, can you break the streets of citywide concern into kind of like categories?

1361
02:34:08.747 --> 02:34:19.313
<v Unidentified speaker>Like, could we say, here's what it would take to maintain the streets that would be absolutely terrifying to lose, and here's what it would take to maintain the ones who'd be worrying to lose.

1362
02:34:19.409 --> 02:34:25.328
<v Unidentified speaker>Here's the ones who would take the ones with the sound like Break it into streets of citywide terror, streets of citywide worry, and streets of citywide concern.

1363
02:34:25.698 --> 02:34:26.370
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Yes, we can do that.

1364
02:34:27.364 --> 02:34:28.343
<v 4,410.>Thank you.

1365
02:34:28.551 --> 02:34:34.852
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that'd be really useful as we get into the tough conversation and talk about how much goes to maintenance, how much to other things, and what are we maintaining.

1366
02:34:35.846 --> 02:34:36.568
<v Thank you, Mayor. The Portland Metro system is a complex and complex system.>Happy to provide that.

1367
02:34:37.129 --> 02:34:37.531
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1368
02:34:37.787 --> 02:34:39.855
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1369
02:34:39.951 --> 02:34:40.480
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Avalos.

1370
02:34:40.850 --> 02:34:48.610
<v Thank you.>All right, well, um, yeah, I want to start by saying I really appreciate the line of questioning that we've heard today.

1371
02:34:48.915 --> 02:34:54.701
<v Thank you.>I think that, uh, my colleagues have done a strong job at surfacing the trade-offs and the pressures that we're facing.

1372
02:34:54.751 --> 02:35:04.806
<v Thank you.>So instead of repeating all of that, I just wanted to take a step back and add my voice to talk about how I'm thinking about the budget and the values that I'm bringing into it, especially speaking for East Portlanders.

1373
02:35:06.078 --> 02:35:14.287
<v Thank you.>So, um, I think ultimately that this is a reflection of what we believe Portlanders deserve in their daily lives.

1374
02:35:14.484 --> 02:35:20.153
<v Thank you.>These, um, assets, these programs, these are all things that make a city in a lot of ways.

1375
02:35:20.329 --> 02:35:25.716
<v Thank you.>And so what really stood out to me in the presentation is the scale of the challenge, right?

1376
02:35:26.037 --> 02:35:28.073
<v Thank you.>We're managing $77 billion in assets.

1377
02:35:28.522 --> 02:35:30.990
<v Thank you.>We've got a $14.2 billion maintenance backlog.

1378
02:35:31.390 --> 02:35:35.431
<v Thank you.>Our workforce is flat or declining, and costs are rising faster than revenue.

1379
02:35:35.558 --> 02:35:43.718
<v Thank you.>So at the same time, we're being asked to consider reductions that are going to defer more maintenance, reduce service levels, or increase costs on residents through rates and fees.

1380
02:35:44.488 --> 02:35:48.947
<v Thank you.>So to me, this is not just a budget exercise, but a capacity crisis is how I see it.

1381
02:35:49.523 --> 02:35:51.593
<v Thank you.>So I want to be clear about how I'm approaching that.

1382
02:35:52.475 --> 02:35:55.217
<v Thank you.>First, I'll say that maintenance is not optional.

1383
02:35:55.393 --> 02:35:55.873
<v Thank you.>It's safety.

1384
02:35:56.259 --> 02:36:01.791
<v Thank you.>I know you know that, but I think it's important to just elevate that because when we defer maintenance, we're not saving money.

1385
02:36:01.871 --> 02:36:03.522
<v Thank you.>We're just pushing risk forward.

1386
02:36:04.101 --> 02:36:09.296
<v Thank you.>And that shows up as unsafe roads, failing infrastructure, parks that feel neglected or unsafe.

1387
02:36:09.393 --> 02:36:12.264
<v Thank you.>And you know, East Portlanders are feeling All of these things acutely.

1388
02:36:13.083 --> 02:36:18.670
<v Thank you.>And so I want to make sure that we're not balancing the budget in a way that's going to let the city fall apart.

1389
02:36:19.697 --> 02:36:21.977
<v Thank you.>Secondly, parks are not a luxury.

1390
02:36:22.073 --> 02:36:23.438
<v Thank you.>They are essential infrastructure.

1391
02:36:23.998 --> 02:36:26.792
<v Thank you.>And, you know, I fought hard last year for parks funding.

1392
02:36:26.888 --> 02:36:32.442
<v Thank you.>I will continue to do that because in East Portland and across the city, parks are cooling centers in heat waves.

1393
02:36:32.988 --> 02:36:34.898
<v Thank you.>They are safe places for kids and families.

1394
02:36:35.012 --> 02:36:38.367
<v Thank you.>They're one of the few public spaces that people can access without costs.

1395
02:36:38.462 --> 02:36:42.890
<v Thank you.>We know that we need much more third spaces, especially with this economy.

1396
02:36:43.034 --> 02:36:45.698
<v Thank you.>People need more places to go that aren't going to cost them money.

1397
02:36:45.762 --> 02:36:53.495
<v Thank you.>And so what I'm seeing here is this $7 million gap for parks, reduced maintenance, potential service cuts, and that is not a small hit.

1398
02:36:53.783 --> 02:36:57.040
<v Thank you.>I see that as a direct hit to quality of life and public health.

1399
02:36:57.634 --> 02:37:07.709
<v Thank you.>And so I think that if parks are core infrastructure and not something that we cut when times get tough, then I want to see that elevated when we look at this budget about how we're prioritizing those investments.

1400
02:37:07.772 --> 02:37:07.885
<v 1,000 years.>Thank you.

1401
02:37:09.040 --> 02:37:12.156
<v Thank you.>Third, we can't balance this budget on the backs of residents.

1402
02:37:12.701 --> 02:37:14.806
<v Thank you.>I know it's difficult.

1403
02:37:14.886 --> 02:37:21.452
<v Thank you.>I know that we have a revenue crisis, and— but I have to speak up for East Portlanders who are already on the brink.

1404
02:37:22.593 --> 02:37:29.931
<v Thank you.>We are looking at utility rate increases, fee increases, service reductions, and, you know, I understand the reason.

1405
02:37:29.978 --> 02:37:33.302
<v Thank you.>I think that there are ways to go about it that can minimize the harm.

1406
02:37:33.899 --> 02:37:45.417
<v Thank you.>And yet I think just everybody is feeling a pinch, and it's important to just name what that looks like and just be extremely cautious about shifting costs onto residents who are just already struggling to stay afloat.

1407
02:37:45.483 --> 02:37:49.015
<v Thank you.>So that's the one of the value that I'm looking at at this budget.

1408
02:37:51.676 --> 02:37:55.101
<v Thank you.>Fourth, equity has to be real, not theoretical.

1409
02:37:55.555 --> 02:38:04.748
<v Thank you.>And we heard that reduction criteria includes looking at disparate impacts, which I appreciate, but those impacts are not abstract.

1410
02:38:05.198 --> 02:38:08.805
<v Thank you.>They're often geographic, they are visible, and they're predictable.

1411
02:38:09.076 --> 02:38:10.376
<v Thank you.>I think that's the key to me.

1412
02:38:10.968 --> 02:38:18.406
<v Thank you.>And because we already know which neighborhoods have fewer parks, we already know which areas have worse conditions, we already know which communities rely most on public services.

1413
02:38:18.920 --> 02:38:24.578
<v Thank you.>And so we should be able to clearly show who is impacted before decisions are made, not after.

1414
02:38:24.708 --> 02:38:29.155
<v Thank you.>So that's what I want to see as we look at the impacts of these cut scenarios.

1415
02:38:29.573 --> 02:38:33.715
<v Thank you.>I want to see clearly who is being impacted so we can make those judgments based on that.

1416
02:38:34.486 --> 02:38:39.849
<v Thank you.>So as we move forward in this process, the things I'm going to be looking for are, are we protecting core infrastructure?

1417
02:38:40.731 --> 02:38:42.963
<v Thank you.>Are we investing in parks as essential services?

1418
02:38:43.654 --> 02:38:45.950
<v Thank you.>Are we avoiding cost burdens on residents?

1419
02:38:46.513 --> 02:38:50.029
<v Thank you.>And are we being honest about who is impacted by these decisions?

1420
02:38:50.541 --> 02:38:55.479
<v Thank you.>Because at the end of the day, the budget is about whether people experience a city that works for them.

1421
02:38:55.673 --> 02:38:56.795
<v Thank you.>We're the city that works.

1422
02:38:57.100 --> 02:38:59.343
<v Thank you.>I think that people are feeling some kind of way about that.

1423
02:39:00.387 --> 02:39:05.501
<v Thank you.>And I don't want this to be a city that is slowly pulling away from our constituents, the people that we serve.

1424
02:39:05.676 --> 02:39:07.584
<v Thank you.>And I want to make sure we're moving in the right direction.

1425
02:39:07.793 --> 02:39:09.814
<v Thank you.>So I appreciate what you're putting forward.

1426
02:39:09.925 --> 02:39:15.522
<v Thank you.>I know that we're in a difficult budget crunch, but I do think that we have a lot of choices.

1427
02:39:15.618 --> 02:39:16.980
<v Thank you.>I think we can be very creative.

1428
02:39:17.156 --> 02:39:19.129
<v Thank you.>I appreciate the way you guys are starting to show that.

1429
02:39:20.122 --> 02:39:22.704
<v Thank you.>And offer options that give us different paths.

1430
02:39:23.090 --> 02:39:32.966
<v Thank you.>And I'm gonna continue to elevate the particular impact on East Portlanders who desperately need the city's services and are often not receiving them at the rate that the rest of the city is.

1431
02:39:33.415 --> 02:39:33.993
<v Thank you.>Thank you for your time.

1432
02:39:34.793 --> 02:39:35.644
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1433
02:39:36.461 --> 02:39:38.370
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I have myself in the queue, colleagues.

1434
02:39:39.587 --> 02:39:47.509
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>DCA Dhanapal, I had a follow-up question about the filtration project and specifically the oversight and some of the cost controls you have put— you're putting in place.

1435
02:39:48.182 --> 02:39:52.908
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>You'd mentioned an independent financial oversight committee is something that the Bureau is working on setting up.

1436
02:39:53.469 --> 02:39:57.282
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Are there other accountability or cost control measures the Bureau is working on?

1437
02:39:57.956 --> 02:39:58.452
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Absolutely.

1438
02:39:58.740 --> 02:40:00.888
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>I'm gonna call Director Lu to talk to that one.

1439
02:40:01.400 --> 02:40:10.213
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>The Bureau is looking forward to implement several steps to ensure for the accountability and cost control measures, and Director Lu here is here to talk about it.

1440
02:40:11.479 --> 02:40:13.033
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much, DC, Dhanapal.

1441
02:40:13.082 --> 02:40:14.027
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, Councilors.

1442
02:40:14.379 --> 02:40:15.212
<v Unidentified speaker>My name's Ting Lu.

1443
02:40:15.629 --> 02:40:17.684
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland Public Utilities Director.

1444
02:40:18.390 --> 02:40:25.230
<v Unidentified speaker>So I want to commit everyone that the transparency and accountability is a top priority for us for the filtration project.

1445
02:40:25.617 --> 02:40:37.242
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm currently working with the project staff to evaluating existing measures that we have put in place, and also will soon share a plan for additional independent financial oversight to you all.

1446
02:40:37.963 --> 02:40:42.395
<v Unidentified speaker>Regarding the existing measures I have put in place for the last a couple months.

1447
02:40:43.118 --> 02:40:45.654
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to share there are 3 perspectives.

1448
02:40:45.846 --> 02:40:53.375
<v Unidentified speaker>One is from a contractor perspective, 'cause they are the ones day-to-day going out to the field and doing the construction project.

1449
02:40:53.791 --> 02:41:08.864
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's where I have been requesting a supply chain audit and also a potential price volatility mitigation strategy from contractors because of a lot of equipment and the systems that could potentially go additional price going up.

1450
02:41:08.929 --> 02:41:09.024
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Thank you.

1451
02:41:09.425 --> 02:41:14.944
<v Unidentified speaker>So we have been requesting that information, making sure to avoid the cost increase as much as possible.

1452
02:41:15.843 --> 02:41:44.384
<v Unidentified speaker>From an internal perspective, I have also refreshed the governance model for the filtration project and having the direct oversight of the project design delivery team reporting to the chief engineer versus previously the program manager to having that technical disciplined approach We have also enhanced internal reporting on project spending, schedule risk, and key milestones, and reporting on a monthly basis.

1453
02:41:45.299 --> 02:41:52.951
<v Unidentified speaker>There is also enhanced project management practices to ensure there is clear timelines and cost tracking moving forward too.

1454
02:41:53.626 --> 02:41:56.577
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's the internal measures I have put in place.

1455
02:41:57.027 --> 02:42:12.808
<v Unidentified speaker>For external communication perspective, I have also directed the team to having a new place for Water Bureau's filtration project, which include additional information on the budgeting, spending milestone progress, and financial projections.

1456
02:42:13.280 --> 02:42:25.346
<v Unidentified speaker>So I envision this will be a work in progress, but happy to share with you all the first, the public-facing website, and getting all of your feedback as we continue moving forward to increase transparency.

1457
02:42:27.240 --> 02:42:28.001
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you very much.

1458
02:42:30.974 --> 02:42:31.729
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>That's my only question.

1459
02:42:31.778 --> 02:42:34.481
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Kanal.

1460
02:42:36.269 --> 02:42:37.507
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Okay, legacy hand from Councilor Kanal.

1461
02:42:37.557 --> 02:42:38.103
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Ryan.

1462
02:42:38.538 --> 02:42:43.443
<v Thank you.>Oh yeah, real quick, uh, Deputy City Attorney Dhanapal, where— what's the status on One Water?

1463
02:42:44.448 --> 02:42:45.451
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Thank you, that's a great question.

1464
02:42:46.889 --> 02:42:52.465
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Um, we are— Public Works has been focused on One Water and unified CIP moving forward, and we've made progress on the One Water.

1465
02:42:53.039 --> 02:43:08.175
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Um, Director Liu, the utilities director who's been in place for about a couple of months, is working together with the leadership teams of both Water and BES and is looking forward to put together a draft integration organizational chart for the leadership team.

1466
02:43:08.577 --> 02:43:12.325
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And we will be coming to the Public Works Committee to share that update as well.

1467
02:43:13.439 --> 02:43:22.122
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>We are looking for, you know, one thing I want to reiterate is when we look at integration, one of the first things we look for is cost efficiencies.

1468
02:43:22.235 --> 02:43:32.851
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And in the One Water space, It's going to take a few years to realize those cost efficiencies, but there are so many, so many important benefits that we would have other than cost, non-cost benefits.

1469
02:43:32.898 --> 02:43:42.737
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>For example, water and PES are trying to solve for their, you know, have similar challenges, rate increases, aging infrastructure, affordability programs.

1470
02:43:42.834 --> 02:43:48.154
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And they're, instead of solving for it separately, they're looking to work together to solve for those challenges together.

1471
02:43:48.458 --> 02:43:53.365
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And the teams have already working on multiple of these initiatives together, especially on the affordability front.

1472
02:43:53.766 --> 02:43:57.200
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>So we are making slow but sure progress on it.

1473
02:43:58.164 --> 02:44:11.500
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Both water and BES are utilities that are heavily regulated, so you want to make sure that any changes that we make in the organizational structure doesn't impact what we deliver or to any of the programs, whether it's capital or operational service that we provide.

1474
02:44:11.548 --> 02:44:14.612
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>And so we are definitely making forward momentum.

1475
02:44:14.870 --> 02:44:19.430
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>In the upcoming few months, we will be coming to the Public Works All right, thank you.

1476
02:44:19.525 --> 02:44:20.136
<v Thank you.>I appreciate that.

1477
02:44:20.217 --> 02:44:25.485
<v Thank you.>I just— I'll just say I think the average person in the public would assume they're already merged because it's all in one bill.

1478
02:44:26.031 --> 02:44:27.058
<v Thank you.>So yeah, thanks.

1479
02:44:27.203 --> 02:44:28.150
<v Third, outside of that major capital investment, inflation in labor, materials, and the cost of internal services is impacting all of us across the city, including our public works bureaus. As a result, operating costs are rising faster than many of our revenue sources. So what this chart really shows is that the public works spending growth is driven by the cost of operating, maintaining, and modernizing the infrastructure that Portland depends on every day. Next slide, please. This slide provides an overview of revenue sources that support the Public Works Service Area. The stacked bars show total revenues for each fiscal year shown on the y-axis, and the colors represent the different funding sources that make up the total. I'm happy to go into the details of each funding source, but in the interest of time, I can skip to the key messages of the Next slide. The key takeaways from this slide are Public Works has a complicated revenue structure made up of multiple funding sources. And the second important point is most of these funds are restricted to specific purposes. As a result, there's limited flexibility to move these resources across systems or bureaus. In practice, what that means is that the funding available in one area cannot be used to solve gaps in another area.>Thank you for your question.

1480
02:44:28.842 --> 02:44:31.042
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Okay, and that brings us to the end of questions.

1481
02:44:31.396 --> 02:44:33.645
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you all for your presentation today.

1482
02:44:34.914 --> 02:44:37.097
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Um, you all may go.

1483
02:44:37.243 --> 02:44:37.515
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you.

1484
02:44:37.579 --> 02:44:41.096
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Next, I'm going to invite, uh, CFO Jonas Biery up.

1485
02:44:41.273 --> 02:44:46.253
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>We are going to, uh, discuss about What is coming next, what the process is beyond today.

1486
02:44:46.817 --> 02:44:50.273
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>You may have noticed quite a number of holds on your calendars in the coming weeks, friends.

1487
02:44:50.548 --> 02:44:51.985
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>We're going to spend a lot of time in this room together.

1488
02:44:59.979 --> 02:45:00.206
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

1489
02:45:00.625 --> 02:45:02.638
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Council President.

1490
02:45:02.782 --> 02:45:05.810
<v Unidentified speaker>Again, for the record, Jonas Biery, City's Chief Financial Officer.

1491
02:45:08.003 --> 02:45:10.575
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think— oh yeah, we've got a presentation pulling up.

1492
02:45:10.673 --> 02:45:13.665
<v Unidentified speaker>Just a few brief slides to help Kind of visualize what's happening.

1493
02:45:15.879 --> 02:45:19.712
<v Unidentified speaker>City Budget Office Director Ruth Levine had to leave kind of unexpectedly, so I'm pitch hitting here.

1494
02:45:20.325 --> 02:45:23.369
<v Unidentified speaker>Owen and CBO staff are here to help out if needed.

1495
02:45:24.332 --> 02:45:31.527
<v Unidentified speaker>What we wanted to do is just take a few minutes to daylight the calendar of kind of upcoming public meetings that are related to the city budget.

1496
02:45:32.159 --> 02:45:37.759
<v Unidentified speaker>These will include moments for additional information sharing, for Q&A, particularly with service areas and bureaus.

1497
02:45:37.808 --> 02:45:37.906
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1498
02:45:38.377 --> 02:45:39.968
<v Unidentified speaker>And space for Council dialogue.

1499
02:45:40.707 --> 02:45:52.773
<v Unidentified speaker>I just wanna reiterate my appreciation for Council's input and feedback as we're kind of learning together and trying new pathways to make adequate space to support Council decision-making related to the annual budget.

1500
02:45:53.496 --> 02:45:57.209
<v Unidentified speaker>So just to walk through the items here.

1501
02:45:58.189 --> 02:46:24.605
<v Unidentified speaker>So just noting the first, third, and fourth items, The work session on April 1st, the— I'm sorry, the 1st, 2nd, and 4th items, the work session on April 1st, the council meeting on April 8th, and then the council meeting on April 15th are related to the spring TAO, Technical Adjustment Ordinance, which is the current year, fiscal year '25-'26 adjustment.

1502
02:46:24.654 --> 02:46:26.291
<v Unidentified speaker>So we've included those here.

1503
02:46:26.806 --> 02:46:29.326
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are a little bit of a separate but simultaneous track.

1504
02:46:30.255 --> 02:46:36.867
<v Unidentified speaker>Our next formal conversation related to next year's budget, the '26-'27 budget, will be on April 8th.

1505
02:46:37.510 --> 02:46:41.799
<v Unidentified speaker>So the 3rd item there, April 8th in the afternoon.

1506
02:46:42.972 --> 02:47:02.195
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we anticipate that to be an update from the city economist about the general fund forecast, kind of updates on general financial condition in the context of that forecast, and then lots of space for councilors to share input and suggestions for the fiscal '26-'27 mayor's proposed budget.

1507
02:47:03.641 --> 02:47:19.861
<v Unidentified speaker>The next major step in the budget process is that we expect the big old package of the full detail in the mayor's proposed budget will be published Monday, April 20th, which will then be followed by a budget hearing on Tuesday, April 21st.

1508
02:47:20.440 --> 02:47:29.380
<v Unidentified speaker>State budget law requires That the mayor present a balanced proposed budget to City Council and to the public, and that meeting will fulfill that requirement.

1509
02:47:30.199 --> 02:47:37.806
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to pause, kind of divert for a quick second, and just make a couple of notes about budget committee and public testimony.

1510
02:47:38.319 --> 02:47:45.829
<v Unidentified speaker>So you'll see in the way this is presented, and we've heard dialogue at council conversation before about convening as the budget committee.

1511
02:47:46.343 --> 02:47:48.782
<v Unidentified speaker>And so just take this moment to sort of—.

1512
02:47:48.782 --> 02:47:48.879
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1513
02:47:49.056 --> 02:48:03.034
<v Unidentified speaker>Clarify, there's under state budget law, the capital B Budget Committee, capital B, capital C Budget Committee, is required to meet to do 2 things: to receive the proposed budget and approve the budget that ultimately goes to TSCC.

1514
02:48:03.355 --> 02:48:04.880
<v Unidentified speaker>And we'll talk about TSCC in a second.

1515
02:48:05.586 --> 02:48:11.604
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, the capital B, capital C Budget Committee is not required to do anything more than that.

1516
02:48:11.765 --> 02:48:15.522
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are the requirements of, of that capital, um, capital letter Budget Committee.

1517
02:48:16.181 --> 02:48:23.476
<v Unidentified speaker>But work sessions between the proposed and approved can still be thought of as sort of, let's say, lowercase budget committee meetings.

1518
02:48:23.523 --> 02:48:27.413
<v Unidentified speaker>So you'll see reference to budget committee in the context of those work sessions.

1519
02:48:27.926 --> 02:48:35.575
<v Unidentified speaker>Just wanna be clear with that technical reality that when you actually say words and convene as the Budget Committee, it's those 2 moments.

1520
02:48:36.379 --> 02:48:39.304
<v Unidentified speaker>So hopefully that's more clear and not confusing.

1521
02:48:39.480 --> 02:48:40.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1522
02:48:42.145 --> 02:48:49.635
<v Unidentified speaker>And then once the approved budget is sent to the TSCC, then you're just back to being a normal council from there on out.

1523
02:48:50.629 --> 02:49:05.191
<v Unidentified speaker>And then regarding public testimony, the 2 moments, at least related to the '26-'27 budget, the 2 moments that public testimony is required are for the mayor's proposed hearing on April 21st and then the approved budget hearing the week of May 18th.

1524
02:49:05.238 --> 02:49:06.248
<v Unidentified speaker>We'll talk about that in a second.

1525
02:49:06.345 --> 02:49:09.323
<v Unidentified speaker>And then of course any regular council meetings per usual.

1526
02:49:11.510 --> 02:49:18.757
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, the last item on this first page is— oh, sorry, if we can move to the next slide please.

1527
02:49:18.806 --> 02:49:19.079
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry.

1528
02:49:19.337 --> 02:49:21.770
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so then the next item here also on April 21st.

1529
02:49:22.092 --> 02:49:24.959
<v Unidentified speaker>So April 21st will be the mayor's proposed hearing.

1530
02:49:25.379 --> 02:49:30.460
<v Unidentified speaker>There's sort of an adjacent moment on April 21st related to the budget for Prosper Portland.

1531
02:49:30.772 --> 02:49:32.004
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1532
02:49:32.632 --> 02:49:36.721
<v Unidentified speaker>Sits as Prosper's budget committee, but not as its board, obviously.

1533
02:49:37.255 --> 02:49:41.891
<v Unidentified speaker>So Council's role as it relates to Prosper's budget is kind of twofold.

1534
02:49:42.566 --> 02:49:52.837
<v Unidentified speaker>One is Council is a funder to the extent there's any appropriated general fund that goes to Council via the city budget.

1535
02:49:53.032 --> 02:49:58.364
<v Unidentified speaker>Council adopts, approves and adopts that budget that then sends those resources to Prosper.

1536
02:50:00.018 --> 02:50:05.650
<v Unidentified speaker>And City Council serves as the budget committee to amend and approve the PROSPER budget.

1537
02:50:06.005 --> 02:50:14.408
<v Unidentified speaker>The PROSPER board then adopts that agency budget and has the legal authority to adopt the recommendations of Council as the budget committee.

1538
02:50:16.860 --> 02:50:28.363
<v Unidentified speaker>The next kind of series of things, and I don't intend to go through these all in detail, but kind of the next series of, I think there's 8 work Sessions are kind of the next deep dive.

1539
02:50:28.413 --> 02:50:36.613
<v Unidentified speaker>So kind of what is in the mayor's proposed and more opportunity for council to have additional due diligence and dialogue about that.

1540
02:50:38.424 --> 02:50:46.208
<v Unidentified speaker>We do recommend that the first session, the April 29th session, focus on generally the topics here.

1541
02:50:46.336 --> 02:51:09.148
<v Unidentified speaker>We're kind of more of the central service type functions so that we can get maybe a little bit of Insight and clarity into that so that we can start building the general fund overhead and doing some of the work behind the scenes that will flow through kind of all those rates that flow through the other bureaus and sort of impacts the budget math that will ultimately help us define those trade-offs.

1542
02:51:09.292 --> 02:51:12.202
<v Unidentified speaker>So we would recommend that that session come at the front end.

1543
02:51:12.701 --> 02:51:17.039
<v Unidentified speaker>And then after that, there's some flexibility around how we structure those.

1544
02:51:17.958 --> 02:51:22.368
<v Unidentified speaker>It's certainly likely that things will adjust as we get through it and identify Areas of interest.

1545
02:51:22.864 --> 02:51:36.511
<v Unidentified speaker>We've tried to kind of recommend here a flow of topics that we think kind of generally matches our understanding of expectations, but obviously expect some adjustment there and happy to accommodate those adjustments.

1546
02:51:37.281 --> 02:51:48.924
<v Unidentified speaker>The one note I would make is having upfront clarity about sort of the timelines and plans and expectations is immensely helpful to kind of the humans who are doing the work to prepare for these dates.

1547
02:51:49.472 --> 02:52:00.057
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think to the extent that we can have a little insight, foresight into what those topic areas will be, I think results in better information for council and for the public to the extent that's possible.

1548
02:52:02.450 --> 02:52:04.227
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's see, next slide please.

1549
02:52:04.325 --> 02:52:15.000
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm happy to come back to any of the details here, but so a series of work sessions and then the last couple lines here, the week of May 18th will be the approved Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1550
02:52:15.000 --> 02:52:17.979
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have the approved budget hearing.

1551
02:52:17.979 --> 02:52:19.959
<v Unidentified speaker>And a few notes about this.

1552
02:52:19.959 --> 02:52:22.940
<v Unidentified speaker>The approved hearing will be a bit different, I think, than it was last year.

1553
02:52:22.940 --> 02:52:25.299
<v Unidentified speaker>Hopefully it'll certainly feel different, I hope.

1554
02:52:25.299 --> 02:52:39.659
<v Unidentified speaker>Our understanding is that Council President aims to begin the hearing on Monday, May 18th, and please update me if this is incorrect, Council President, but begin the hearing on Monday and then carry it over potentially over the next couple of days as needed.

1555
02:52:40.186 --> 02:52:47.599
<v Unidentified speaker>With the intent of hopefully avoiding, you know, very, very late evenings and exceptionally long hours on any one given day.

1556
02:52:48.128 --> 02:52:50.181
<v Unidentified speaker>But that's, I think, the intent around that.

1557
02:52:51.673 --> 02:53:02.918
<v Unidentified speaker>During that hearing, and we'll probably have more opportunity to talk about this, again, just as a reminder to folks and to the public, but during that hearing, there's sort of a list of steps that'll be required under state budget law for council to do.

1558
02:53:03.224 --> 02:53:05.934
<v Unidentified speaker>City Budget Office will help navigate that.

1559
02:53:06.610 --> 02:53:12.262
<v Unidentified speaker>The key pieces of that will be to discuss amendments to the proposed budget and to take public testimony.

1560
02:53:13.161 --> 02:53:26.712
<v Unidentified speaker>In addition to that amendment conversation, which I'm sure will be streamlined and efficient— pause to let that sink in— in addition to that, 3 key things will need to occur before that hearing ends.

1561
02:53:27.307 --> 02:53:37.870
<v Unidentified speaker>Council will approve the city's budget to send to TSCC, will approve the for budget, to also send to TSCC, and then we'll vote on the utility rate ordinance as regular City Council.

1562
02:53:38.000 --> 02:53:39.798
<v Unidentified speaker>But that'll be a simultaneous action.

1563
02:53:40.536 --> 02:53:45.175
<v Unidentified speaker>We've got kind of a— next slide, please.

1564
02:53:45.272 --> 02:53:47.135
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think this is the last sequence here.

1565
02:53:48.418 --> 02:53:54.567
<v Unidentified speaker>We've got kind of a— yeah, so you can see the continued continuation of the budget hearing to the extent needed through May 20th.

1566
02:53:55.307 --> 02:53:57.683
<v Unidentified speaker>And then we've got a placeholder work session on June 3rd.

1567
02:53:57.974 --> 02:54:04.978
<v Unidentified speaker>If we need space for— to continue dialogue between the approved budget and the budget adoption in June, at least have a moment there.

1568
02:54:06.100 --> 02:54:13.992
<v Unidentified speaker>You've all been through now one round of TSCC, the Tax Supervising and Conservation Commission, sometimes affectionately called Tax Soup.

1569
02:54:14.862 --> 02:54:22.495
<v Unidentified speaker>So that is a required hearing with public members, the commissioners of that body to fulfill the public participation requirements under state budget law.

1570
02:54:23.203 --> 02:54:25.744
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that's actually a hearing of that commission.

1571
02:54:25.796 --> 02:54:25.849
<v Thank you.>Okay.

1572
02:54:26.365 --> 02:54:28.480
<v Unidentified speaker>Of which City Council also participates.

1573
02:54:29.411 --> 02:54:31.558
<v Unidentified speaker>And that date is firmly scheduled.

1574
02:54:32.135 --> 02:54:37.968
<v Unidentified speaker>And then that all culminates obviously in adoption, first reading on June 10th and a vote on June 17th.

1575
02:54:38.319 --> 02:54:52.004
<v Unidentified speaker>Lastly, we just noted is, as it was the case last year and every year, it is critical that we meet that final date and have a balanced city budget so that we can achieve the technical implementation over the last couple weeks of the— of the year.

1576
02:54:52.663 --> 02:54:59.695
<v Unidentified speaker>Month of June and ensure we have uninterrupted city operations on July 1st when fiscal '26-'27 begins.

1577
02:55:01.156 --> 02:55:04.208
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, and happy to, in the last few minutes, take questions or move on.

1578
02:55:04.368 --> 02:55:04.593
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1579
02:55:04.786 --> 02:55:05.042
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you.

1580
02:55:05.106 --> 02:55:12.750
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>And Jonas, I just want to add on to that, that colleagues, you should anticipate a memo coming from me with detailed information about this, including all these dates.

1581
02:55:12.909 --> 02:55:15.126
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Yeah, you know, I hope no one was furiously taking notes.

1582
02:55:15.207 --> 02:55:26.415
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>We will share this with all the times and all the Topics, including some additional work that we've been doing with the budget office around amendments, how we're going to track them, how we're going to prioritize them, how we're going to group them.

1583
02:55:27.260 --> 02:56:02.680
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>I will preview for you that I would like to be able to work individually with you to figure out what your priorities are, but also there will be an opportunity for you to demonstrate interest in other people's amendments so that we're not going in blind and assuming that everything only has one And additionally, there'll be some additional parameters around budget notes, making sure that we are using those tools to their absolute maximum rather than what might be better.

1584
02:56:02.727 --> 02:56:05.822
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>So I'm going to open it to some questions from our colleagues.

1585
02:56:06.095 --> 02:56:07.190
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Ryan.

1586
02:56:07.865 --> 02:56:09.362
<v Thank you.>Yeah, thank you so much, Jonas.

1587
02:56:09.476 --> 02:56:11.310
<v Thank you.>Mine is actually a plug for parks.

1588
02:56:11.471 --> 02:56:12.703
<v Thank you.>Next week is Spring break.

1589
02:56:12.849 --> 02:56:20.064
<v Thank you.>And so many of us have the opportunity to go away and some of us just have that luxury of never worrying about food.

1590
02:56:20.497 --> 02:56:31.762
<v Thank you.>But I love that parks always make sure that they target our students during spring break and you'll be having free lunch delivery services or no, they come and take it out, right?

1591
02:56:32.372 --> 02:56:33.962
<v Thank you.>At several parks next week, correct?

1592
02:56:34.879 --> 02:56:35.040
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1593
02:56:35.103 --> 02:56:37.658
<v Thank you.>All right, so make sure that all of you publicize that.

1594
02:56:37.933 --> 02:56:45.780
<v Thank you.>It's a really important service that Parks does every spring break, and I'm delighted that we have enough funds to make sure that this is happening in 2026.

1595
02:56:46.087 --> 02:56:47.105
<v Thank you.>Thank you, Sonia, and your team.

1596
02:56:47.784 --> 02:56:48.495
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1597
02:56:48.674 --> 02:56:49.222
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Kanal.

1598
02:56:50.531 --> 02:56:53.343
<v 4,410.>Yeah, I, I didn't have a— can you go back a couple slides?

1599
02:56:53.925 --> 02:56:54.558
<v 4,410.>2 Slides.

1600
02:56:58.620 --> 02:56:59.754
<v 4,410.>Uh, actually, sorry, one forward.

1601
02:57:01.458 --> 02:57:10.110
<v 4,410.>I just wanted to ask if it's possible to, to get Either not through creation of a new thing, but to separate Portland Solutions and revenue generation.

1602
02:57:10.688 --> 02:57:17.897
<v 4,410.>Those are both incredibly big conversations, and I think we're going to run out of time on either of them if they have 3 hours each.

1603
02:57:19.198 --> 02:57:32.040
<v 4,410.>And I think putting them together, I think Portland Solutions is probably the expenditure side that gets the most conversation from the most of us at this point, and revenue generation Obviously it's its own thing that, that may have it.

1604
02:57:32.137 --> 02:57:42.618
<v 4,410.>So just wanted to, to, as you're working through this and as you go from near final to final, just wanted to, to put that plug in there because I think it'll, it'll end up, uh, running out of time pretty, pretty quickly otherwise.

1605
02:57:43.782 --> 02:57:44.024
<v 4,410.>Thanks.

1606
02:57:44.591 --> 02:57:45.075
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you very much.

1607
02:57:45.140 --> 02:57:45.819
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Councilor Kanal.

1608
02:57:47.436 --> 02:57:49.656
<v Thank you.>I, I am, I am curious why they're together.

1609
02:57:49.948 --> 02:57:52.932
<v Thank you.>So do, do either of you want to speak to that?

1610
02:57:53.353 --> 02:57:59.192
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor, I'll just note I think they're together just under the anticip— that we just have to Puzzle the pieces together.

1611
02:57:59.451 --> 02:58:06.380
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that was a date that was available that we thought there could be space for 2 topics, not because there's any necessary— necessarily any relation.

1612
02:58:06.638 --> 02:58:06.719
<v Thank you.>Yep.

1613
02:58:06.930 --> 02:58:07.627
<v Thank you.>Thank you so much.

1614
02:58:07.772 --> 02:58:08.291
<v Thank you.>Yeah, perfect.

1615
02:58:08.372 --> 02:58:12.286
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>All right, with that, I am going to adjourn this work session.

1616
02:58:12.886 --> 02:58:13.520
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>Thank you very much.

1617
02:58:13.811 --> 02:58:14.720
<v I'm going to be just turning it over directly to DCA Dhanapal and staff.>4:54.

