WEBVTT

1
00:05:15.471 --> 00:05:16.764
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good evening.

2
00:05:17.271 --> 00:05:17.663
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good evening.

3
00:05:17.778 --> 00:05:24.189
<v Jamie Dunphy>Before we officially gavel in, I am turning this over to Councilor Koyama Lane for a pre-gravel celebration.

4
00:05:24.494 --> 00:05:25.312
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

5
00:05:25.536 --> 00:05:26.641
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

6
00:05:26.995 --> 00:05:28.324
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Good evening, everyone.

7
00:05:28.581 --> 00:05:32.846
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you all for being here today as we recognize Minoru Yasui Day.

8
00:05:33.326 --> 00:05:43.201
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you to Mayor Wilson for formally recognizing this day through an official proclamation affirming the importance of remembering this history and carrying forward its lessons.

9
00:05:43.826 --> 00:05:57.786
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's an honor to gather in this space with very special guests, people who are very important to me, to reflect on the life and legacy of Minoru Yasui, And to bravely commit to being the allies today that our families needed during World War II.

10
00:05:58.512 --> 00:06:02.737
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And with that, I will turn things over to our guests, Lynn, June, Peggy, and Kay.

11
00:06:03.834 --> 00:06:04.997
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

12
00:06:05.545 --> 00:06:08.177
<v Olivia Clark>Good evening, President Dunphy and City Council members.

13
00:06:08.774 --> 00:06:26.115
<v Olivia Clark>Min was just 26 years old when he defied the military curfew imposed on people of Japanese ancestry that led to the unjust incarceration of over 120,000 men, women, in children, including my family.

14
00:06:26.709 --> 00:06:29.244
<v Olivia Clark>And he did this to test the constitutionality.

15
00:06:30.238 --> 00:06:37.569
<v Olivia Clark>And his act of defiance 84 years ago was a stand against government overreach and discrimination.

16
00:06:38.019 --> 00:06:41.934
<v Olivia Clark>He knew that no government should have unchecked power.

17
00:06:42.511 --> 00:06:54.757
<v Olivia Clark>He recognized the common struggle of marginalized people and worked tirelessly across ethnic, racial, class, and other elements of diversity, including age and disabilities.

18
00:06:55.189 --> 00:07:04.939
<v Olivia Clark>And for his lifetime of activism, he was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 2015, and he's the only Oregonian to receive this honor.

19
00:07:05.855 --> 00:07:19.442
<v Olivia Clark>In 2016, in an intensely bipartisan year, we worked with the Oregon Legislature and unanimously passed House Bill 4009, designating March 28th Yes.

20
00:07:19.841 --> 00:07:26.939
<v Olivia Clark>—Was the day he defied curfew— as Minoru Yasui Day in Oregon in perpetuity.

21
00:07:28.093 --> 00:07:45.810
<v Olivia Clark>The bill was signed, and we had the March for Justice with over 400 people, ages 103 down to 3 years old, that retraced Min's steps from his office in what was Portland's Japantown to police headquarters where he was arrested and jailed.

22
00:07:46.276 --> 00:07:50.569
<v Olivia Clark>And we continue to hold Min Yasui Day events every year since.

23
00:07:50.697 --> 00:07:59.380
<v Olivia Clark>So we wanted to thank you for your proclamation recognizing Min, but also calling out past and present injustices.

24
00:07:59.812 --> 00:08:20.880
<v Olivia Clark>Now, we must do our part to correct them, because in Min's words, if we believe in America, if we believe in equality and democracy, if we believe in law and justice, then each of us, when we see or believe errors are being made, have an obligation to make every effort to correct them.

25
00:08:20.961 --> 00:08:21.185
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

26
00:08:21.362 --> 00:08:22.379
<v Olivia Clark>Effort to correct them.

27
00:08:23.298 --> 00:08:27.963
<v Olivia Clark>Now, your proclamation calls out the Alien Enemies Act of 1798.

28
00:08:28.545 --> 00:08:35.172
<v Olivia Clark>We must push Congress to repeal it with the passage of the Neighbors Not Enemies Act.

29
00:08:35.916 --> 00:08:43.182
<v Olivia Clark>So every day is a call to action, to speak out when our democracy is threatened and the rule of law broken.

30
00:08:44.006 --> 00:08:44.799
<v Olivia Clark>So what would Min do?

31
00:08:45.559 --> 00:08:47.469
<v Olivia Clark>That's the name of our event this year.

32
00:08:48.302 --> 00:09:14.570
<v Olivia Clark>As we mark the 10th anniversary of Min Yasui Day and the 250th anniversary of our Declaration of Independence, both rooted in democracy and the belief that power belongs to the people, we must unite the power of our voices and actions because what Min says, what is done to the least of the least of us can be done to all of us.

33
00:09:14.682 --> 00:09:18.434
<v Olivia Clark>So this is Min's call to action then and his call to action now.

34
00:09:18.514 --> 00:09:18.754
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

35
00:09:19.241 --> 00:09:21.904
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for letting us share more about Min's legacy.

36
00:09:22.895 --> 00:09:23.432
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Lynn.

37
00:09:23.643 --> 00:09:25.397
<v Keelan McClymont>Would you like to say your full name for the record?

38
00:09:25.527 --> 00:09:25.868
<v Olivia Clark>Sure.

39
00:09:26.630 --> 00:09:28.326
<v Olivia Clark>Lynn Fuchigami Parks.

40
00:09:29.070 --> 00:09:29.474
<v Sameer Kanal>Great.

41
00:09:29.634 --> 00:09:31.153
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Would you like to introduce yourself?

42
00:09:31.895 --> 00:09:34.125
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My name is June Arima Schumann.

43
00:09:36.932 --> 00:09:47.514
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>During 2014 and '15, I served as project administrator for the Minoru Yasui Tribute Committee in Portland.

44
00:09:48.976 --> 00:09:52.116
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It was formed by Holly Yasui and Peggy Nagae.

45
00:09:53.302 --> 00:09:59.921
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The purpose was to nominate Minoru Yasui for the 2015 Presidential Medal of Freedom.

46
00:10:01.169 --> 00:10:08.380
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The committee felt this national recognition for Min Yasui should not be delayed any further.

47
00:10:09.807 --> 00:10:21.980
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The Portland-based Minoru Yasui Tribute Committee involved dedicated lawyers, advocates, and community leaders with active connections to local and national organizations.

48
00:10:22.879 --> 00:10:47.941
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Minoru Yasui Tribute Committee submitted the Presidential Medal of Freedom nomination to President Obama with nearly 90 letters of support, including past and current federal cabinet officials, representatives, senators, governors, from multiple states, local advocacy organizations, and community leaders.

49
00:10:49.625 --> 00:11:02.581
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here are some examples of the important ways local and national organizations supported the recognition for constitutional and racial justice fought for by Minoru Yasui.

50
00:11:04.453 --> 00:11:12.220
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>First, the Oregon ACLU leader obtained a support letter from the National ACLU.

51
00:11:13.869 --> 00:11:24.831
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>He then submitted the local letter referencing the MacNaughton Award granted to Minoru Yasui in Oregon in 1983.

52
00:11:26.905 --> 00:11:45.865
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Secondly, the legislative liaison for Oregon ACLU facilitated the approval of state legislative action to establish March 28th as Minoru Yasui Day, effective 2016.

53
00:11:48.163 --> 00:12:00.556
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Third, the Portland Urban League learned about Minoru Yasui's role in helping to establish Denver, Colorado's Urban League in the 1950s.

54
00:12:01.927 --> 00:12:09.706
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They were among Portland local advocacy organizations to support Minoru Yasui for the Presidential Medal of Freedom.

55
00:12:10.817 --> 00:12:11.682
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

56
00:12:11.778 --> 00:12:30.509
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Fourth, Portland's Coalition of Communities of Color was one of the organizations to learn about how Minoru Yasui had an active role in Denver to establish advocacy organization for Black, Latino, Native, and Asian American communities.

57
00:12:31.342 --> 00:12:45.951
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>His efforts in Denver in the 1950s were in line with Coalition of Communities of Color present day's mission and submitted their letter of support for Minoru Yasui.

58
00:12:47.703 --> 00:12:56.943
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Lastly, I wanted to mention Hood River Middle School students who in 2015 studied what is a hero.

59
00:12:58.299 --> 00:13:07.164
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They learned about Minoru Yasui, who graduated from Hood River High School, and said in their letter of support, Minoru Yasui is a hero.

60
00:13:07.246 --> 00:13:07.378
<v Loretta Guzman>Thank you.

61
00:13:09.614 --> 00:13:11.815
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Because he stood up for what was right.

62
00:13:12.667 --> 00:13:19.143
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>He was a hero because he dedicated his life fighting for what he believed in.

63
00:13:20.660 --> 00:13:22.062
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for my statement.

64
00:13:23.840 --> 00:13:27.841
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Tiffany Koyama Lane, thank you very much for inviting us here.

65
00:13:28.049 --> 00:13:29.856
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you to all the councilors for being here.

66
00:13:30.453 --> 00:13:35.535
<v Olivia Clark>My name is Peggy Nagai, and I have a few words about the Minyasui case.

67
00:13:35.649 --> 00:13:40.616
<v Olivia Clark>I was his lead attorney reopening his case, World War II case in the early '80s.

68
00:13:41.722 --> 00:13:55.017
<v Olivia Clark>Sherrilyn Ifill recently described Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. as a democracy warrior who put his body on the line and spoke truth to power, harnessing a truth force to demand change.

69
00:13:55.995 --> 00:14:11.943
<v Olivia Clark>Likewise, Minoru Yasui, as a lawyer, patriot, and activist, was a democracy lawyer who put his body on the line when he intentionally violated the military curfew imposed upon U.S. citizens of Japanese ancestry.

70
00:14:12.938 --> 00:14:15.123
<v Olivia Clark>By this act, he spoke truth to power.

71
00:14:15.587 --> 00:14:22.106
<v Olivia Clark>The incarceration of persons without due process is a clear violation of the 5th Amendment's command.

72
00:14:22.812 --> 00:14:24.418
<v Olivia Clark>Does this sound familiar?

73
00:14:25.864 --> 00:14:52.440
<v Olivia Clark>While Yasui firmly believed the government was transgressing fundamental rights, he did not know the extent to which government lawyers, both in the War Department and the Department of Justice, lied, suppressed, misrepresented, and falsified a key military report and other government assessments so that they could argue national security mandated incarceration.

74
00:14:53.692 --> 00:14:54.813
<v Olivia Clark>Does this sound familiar?

75
00:14:56.169 --> 00:15:23.259
<v Olivia Clark>The evidence of these lawyers The evidence these lawyers tampered with intentionally misled the Supreme Court about the military assessment of the West Coast and hid the general's racist views of Japanese Americans as an enemy race, calling them animals and saying that no amount of time would make a difference to prove the loyalty or their disloyalty to the US.

76
00:15:23.870 --> 00:15:42.573
<v Olivia Clark>General DeWitt said it would be like separating goats from sheep, language that characterized American citizens of Japanese descent as subhuman and alleviated any moral obligation to treat them as the U.S. citizens that they were.

77
00:15:44.048 --> 00:15:56.698
<v Olivia Clark>Why did these lawyers, against their own ethical rules, withhold exculpatory evidence from verified government sources that the incarceration was not necessary?

78
00:15:57.596 --> 00:16:33.664
<v Olivia Clark>Why is it that the Solicitor General of the United States, the 4th-ranking official in the Department of Justice representing the federal government in all U.S. Supreme Court cases and appointed by the president, refused to disclose credible reports from the Office of Naval Intelligence, the FBI, the Federal Communications Commission, all of which found no evidence of sabotage, and all of which said that it was unnecessary to imprison Japanese Americans.

79
00:16:34.802 --> 00:16:37.399
<v Olivia Clark>We reopened his case in the 1980s.

80
00:16:38.249 --> 00:16:48.458
<v Olivia Clark>I've been asking my— these questions for the last 40-some years, and it's been an exhausting process of wondering, why did this happen?

81
00:16:48.668 --> 00:16:55.874
<v Olivia Clark>Why did lawyers— because I used to practice law— how could we How could we betray our ethical obligations?

82
00:16:57.836 --> 00:17:03.913
<v Olivia Clark>And I have come to— I still don't quite understand it.

83
00:17:04.346 --> 00:17:19.884
<v Olivia Clark>Why did they betray their responsibilities to not serve the public interest, to not act with integrity, to not seek justice, and to ensure a fair process rather than pursuing a conviction at all costs?

84
00:17:19.965 --> 00:17:20.597
<v Olivia Clark>Councilwoman Loretta Smith.

85
00:17:21.672 --> 00:17:23.574
<v Olivia Clark>Why did they not uphold the law?

86
00:17:25.369 --> 00:17:40.730
<v Olivia Clark>I've come to believe that these high-ranking government lawyers and officials did not see, nor did they believe, that the United States is a multiracial, multicultural, inclusive democracy where all people are created equal.

87
00:17:41.665 --> 00:17:54.411
<v Olivia Clark>Rather, I believe they saw it as a white country where they are girded by beliefs like Manifest Destiny, With whiteness at the core of the nation's success, history, politics, and culture.

88
00:17:55.519 --> 00:17:58.441
<v Olivia Clark>That is why history is repeating itself today.

89
00:17:59.387 --> 00:18:12.375
<v Olivia Clark>That is why we have a current-day Supreme Court justice ruling that ICE agents can make arrests based on race, ethnicity, Spanish-speaking proficiency, and type of work.

90
00:18:13.675 --> 00:18:22.669
<v Olivia Clark>Called the Kavanaugh stop, it allows ICE agents to arrest people based on these agents' personal stereotypes and racism.

91
00:18:24.715 --> 00:18:29.067
<v Olivia Clark>And what would Yasui say in the final year of his life?

92
00:18:29.615 --> 00:18:41.347
<v Olivia Clark>He said, this is the United States of America, founded in liberty, dedicated to the proposition that all men— and I included— and women are created equal.

93
00:18:43.402 --> 00:18:52.569
<v Olivia Clark>As an American citizen, as a lawyer, I felt that we owed at least the obligation to tell our government they're wrong.

94
00:18:53.803 --> 00:19:01.701
<v Olivia Clark>That is a sacred duty of every citizen, because what is done to the least of us can be done to all of us.

95
00:19:02.679 --> 00:19:04.713
<v Olivia Clark>I knew we had to protest.

96
00:19:06.123 --> 00:19:15.126
<v Olivia Clark>In honor of Min Yasui, let us fight for the rule of law, fight for our democracy, democracy, fight for the soul of this nation.

97
00:19:15.191 --> 00:19:15.287
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

98
00:19:16.059 --> 00:19:16.382
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

99
00:19:22.509 --> 00:19:22.702
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

100
00:19:23.172 --> 00:19:24.902
<v Eric Zimmerman>Oh, my name is Kay Endle.

101
00:19:25.678 --> 00:19:34.825
<v Eric Zimmerman>I was incarcerated in the Minidoka War Relocation Center, which is located 16 miles northeast of Twin Falls, Idaho.

102
00:19:35.858 --> 00:19:51.623
<v Eric Zimmerman>As a youth, we had a lot of fun because our parents all had jobs working in the camp as cooks, in the mess halls, fire department, police department.

103
00:19:51.672 --> 00:20:03.527
<v Eric Zimmerman>So it was the camp was self-sufficient, and as youngsters, all we did was play all day until school started on September 26th.

104
00:20:04.587 --> 00:20:09.005
<v Eric Zimmerman>That was my ninth birthday, but we didn't celebrate my birthday.

105
00:20:10.226 --> 00:20:15.027
<v Eric Zimmerman>For some reason, nobody knew about it, and we didn't even have a cake.

106
00:20:15.749 --> 00:20:19.699
<v Eric Zimmerman>And Christmas was really nice.

107
00:20:20.003 --> 00:20:32.463
<v Eric Zimmerman>They had toys that were donated by the churches all through the United States, and I got a gift, but I can't remember it, but it was really a nice present.

108
00:20:33.330 --> 00:20:44.726
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in camp, to this day, you— for me, it wasn't that bad, but for the older generation, it was really bad.

109
00:20:45.161 --> 00:20:58.490
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I wish some of them could come here and explain to you what happened, but most of them are either not here anymore or in, in the late '90s.

110
00:20:58.718 --> 00:21:01.826
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm right now 92, so I'm— 92.

111
00:21:02.381 --> 00:21:07.961
<v Eric Zimmerman>One of the younger ones that knew about camp, and we had a lot of fun.

112
00:21:11.583 --> 00:21:15.226
<v Eric Zimmerman>And and what we did was we went out and played.

113
00:21:15.273 --> 00:21:21.515
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then one of the things they had a canal, and they used to swim across the canal.

114
00:21:21.726 --> 00:21:27.718
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the good swimmers went and the swiped some watermelons.

115
00:21:28.021 --> 00:21:32.385
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then we used to look at them while they were eating watermelon.

116
00:21:32.498 --> 00:21:37.423
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then pretty soon they said, come on in and help yourself to the watermelon.

117
00:21:37.487 --> 00:21:41.065
<v Eric Zimmerman>That was really a great present for us.

118
00:21:41.642 --> 00:21:46.632
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that was our— my adventure in camp.

119
00:21:46.936 --> 00:21:50.481
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for the older generation, it was really terrible.

120
00:21:50.803 --> 00:21:53.898
<v Eric Zimmerman>But for us, it was really, really good.

121
00:21:54.253 --> 00:22:00.191
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you so much, all of you, for your powerful words and reflections.

122
00:22:00.304 --> 00:22:02.288
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you to everyone who joined us this evening.

123
00:22:02.920 --> 00:22:13.672
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Let's continue to honor Minyasoui by carrying forward the conviction that at times challenging unjust laws is absolutely necessary in the pursuit of democracy and dignity for all.

124
00:22:13.720 --> 00:22:21.931
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Sometimes I sit at my window here in City Hall and I imagine him, because he walked around downtown telling a police officer, hey, arrest me, arrest me.

125
00:22:22.986 --> 00:22:30.566
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We know that the police officer said, run along home, sonny boy, until he went to the police station and said, you have to arrest me, I'm breaking the curfew on purpose.

126
00:22:31.318 --> 00:22:38.337
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So as we wrap up, I encourage everyone to continue honoring Min's legacy by staying engaged, learning more.

127
00:22:38.547 --> 00:22:44.653
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Please research Congresswoman Ilhan Omar's Neighbors Not Enemies Act, HR 630.

128
00:22:44.780 --> 00:22:52.023
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Please attend the Min Yasui Day celebration right up the street at the Oregon Historical Society hosted by the Minoru Yasui Legacy Project.

129
00:22:52.489 --> 00:23:03.321
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And we have proclamations, to give to you all, to gift to the Japanese American Museum of Oregon, the Minoru Yasui Project, the JACL, and one to you, Mr. Kei Endo.

130
00:23:03.386 --> 00:23:04.645
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for sharing your story with us.

131
00:23:05.023 --> 00:23:06.784
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Let's all remember that never again is now.

132
00:23:18.278 --> 00:23:19.919
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for being here.

133
00:23:20.112 --> 00:23:23.606
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, there's going to be Councilors, there's a request for us to do a quick photo outside.

134
00:23:23.865 --> 00:23:27.442
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, we're gonna do that and try to be back here in, well, as quick as we can get.

135
00:23:27.991 --> 00:23:29.173
<v Jamie Dunphy>We got a full evening tonight.

136
00:23:29.303 --> 00:23:29.933
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That'll be great.

137
00:28:29.801 --> 00:28:31.561
<v Jamie Dunphy>And welcome back, ladies and gentlemen.

138
00:28:31.740 --> 00:28:40.057
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm now gaveling into order this meeting of the Portland City Council on Wednesday— the evening of Wednesday, March 18th.

139
00:28:40.413 --> 00:28:42.246
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can you please call the roll?

140
00:28:43.558 --> 00:28:43.866
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

141
00:28:44.271 --> 00:28:44.531
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

142
00:28:44.872 --> 00:28:47.145
<v Sameer Kanal>Smith.

143
00:28:47.551 --> 00:28:47.925
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

144
00:28:48.364 --> 00:28:49.192
<v Sameer Kanal>Present.

145
00:28:50.151 --> 00:28:50.442
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

146
00:28:50.637 --> 00:28:50.913
<v Steve Novick>Here.

147
00:28:51.353 --> 00:28:51.579
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

148
00:28:52.246 --> 00:28:52.521
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

149
00:28:52.880 --> 00:28:53.535
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

150
00:28:54.748 --> 00:28:55.993
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

151
00:29:05.440 --> 00:29:05.730
<v Keelan McClymont>Here.

152
00:29:06.136 --> 00:29:06.509
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

153
00:29:08.066 --> 00:29:09.994
<v Jamie Dunphy>And can we please read the rules of decorum?

154
00:29:11.630 --> 00:29:11.871
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Good evening.

155
00:29:12.064 --> 00:29:13.301
<v Keelan McClymont>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

156
00:29:13.751 --> 00:29:19.765
<v Sameer Kanal>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

157
00:29:23.402 --> 00:29:26.391
<v Olivia Clark>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

158
00:29:27.057 --> 00:29:30.597
<v Keelan McClymont>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

159
00:29:31.096 --> 00:29:33.087
<v Olivia Clark>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

160
00:29:33.665 --> 00:29:35.400
<v Olivia Clark>The presiding officer preserves order.

161
00:29:35.848 --> 00:29:43.957
<v Sameer Kanal>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

162
00:29:44.535 --> 00:29:46.557
<v Sameer Kanal>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

163
00:29:47.071 --> 00:29:49.384
<v Olivia Clark>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

164
00:29:49.978 --> 00:29:53.156
<v Olivia Clark>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

165
00:29:53.830 --> 00:29:56.608
<v Olivia Clark>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

166
00:29:57.122 --> 00:29:59.221
<v Sameer Kanal>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

167
00:29:59.686 --> 00:30:01.609
<v Sameer Kanal>When testifying, state your name for the record.

168
00:30:01.753 --> 00:30:03.340
<v Olivia Clark>Your address is not necessary.

169
00:30:03.917 --> 00:30:06.626
<v Keelan McClymont>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

170
00:30:07.140 --> 00:30:10.506
<v Sameer Kanal>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

171
00:30:10.826 --> 00:30:11.131
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

172
00:30:12.108 --> 00:30:12.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

173
00:30:13.391 --> 00:30:17.461
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, our first action item today is approval of the agenda.

174
00:30:18.263 --> 00:30:27.685
<v Jamie Dunphy>Item number 4, titled Amend Council Schedule During the '26-'27 Budget Process, has been pulled from consent in part to add an amendment and to add an emergency clause.

175
00:30:28.450 --> 00:30:30.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have many substantive policy items to hear tonight.

176
00:30:31.729 --> 00:30:39.092
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would like to be able to place this at the beginning of the regular agenda so that we can complete it and move on to other business rather than move it to the end, as is normally the case.

177
00:30:40.619 --> 00:30:46.339
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there any objection, or may I have unanimous consent to place item 4 between items 3 and 5?

178
00:30:48.692 --> 00:30:48.965
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know.

179
00:30:51.071 --> 00:30:53.961
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would like to— usually items from consent get pulled to the end.

180
00:30:54.092 --> 00:30:57.807
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to have it read chronologically, if that's okay.

181
00:30:58.051 --> 00:31:00.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there any other requests to amend the agenda?

182
00:31:03.031 --> 00:31:04.749
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

183
00:31:04.814 --> 00:31:06.109
<v Jamie Dunphy>I see that.

184
00:31:06.336 --> 00:31:07.696
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lots of little nods.

185
00:31:08.200 --> 00:31:09.576
<v Jamie Dunphy>The agenda is approved.

186
00:31:09.673 --> 00:31:10.224
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

187
00:31:11.559 --> 00:31:12.923
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call public communications?

188
00:31:15.164 --> 00:31:16.924
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Karen Shirey.

189
00:31:21.671 --> 00:31:22.698
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yep, come on up, Karen.

190
00:31:22.891 --> 00:31:23.243
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

191
00:31:23.436 --> 00:31:27.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please introduce yourself, share your name, your pronouns if you prefer, and you have 3 minutes.

192
00:31:28.076 --> 00:31:29.424
<v Keelan McClymont>Hi, my name is Karen Chire.

193
00:31:30.661 --> 00:31:32.779
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, I am a business owner in District 4.

194
00:31:33.487 --> 00:31:34.707
<v Keelan McClymont>I own Stadium Suprette.

195
00:31:34.835 --> 00:31:36.424
<v Keelan McClymont>I am part of Stadiumhood.

196
00:31:37.179 --> 00:31:42.605
<v Keelan McClymont>You guys have seen me all in various venues here testifying.

197
00:31:42.718 --> 00:31:46.666
<v Keelan McClymont>I also testify for county, and I've been testifying for state legislature.

198
00:31:47.277 --> 00:31:50.903
<v Keelan McClymont>I am advocating for businesses in our area.

199
00:31:51.786 --> 00:31:59.585
<v Keelan McClymont>We've had now 35 businesses close within a 4-block radius of our store by Providence Park in the last 2 years.

200
00:32:00.612 --> 00:32:08.763
<v Keelan McClymont>I am dealing with ongoing crime, and the consensus of a lot of the businesses is that very thing, is crime and safety.

201
00:32:10.079 --> 00:32:16.114
<v Keelan McClymont>I, I don't know what else to do other than continue arresting the people that commit these crimes.

202
00:32:16.241 --> 00:32:30.953
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm up to 26 people as of the Sunday before last that I've had arrested since last April, due in part for me, like, either following the suspect until police can get to my location to arrest the people.

203
00:32:31.578 --> 00:32:38.557
<v Keelan McClymont>Some people I've had to let go just because I couldn't wait any longer due to business and stuff.

204
00:32:38.782 --> 00:32:46.315
<v Keelan McClymont>And And it's just, it's just an ongoing cycle of homelessness and drugs and crime.

205
00:32:46.732 --> 00:32:58.169
<v Keelan McClymont>And with all the monies that we're spending on the homeless and, uh, SNAP benefits and all these things, I just don't understand why it just is continuing, you know.

206
00:32:58.233 --> 00:32:58.298
<v Olivia Clark>Right.

207
00:32:58.394 --> 00:33:02.827
<v Keelan McClymont>And like, what else can we do to mitigate these things, you know?

208
00:33:03.053 --> 00:33:10.534
<v Keelan McClymont>And the reason why our, our our economy is so bad is because we do have these crimes.

209
00:33:10.597 --> 00:33:19.555
<v Keelan McClymont>And so when, when retail outlets have criminal activity or vandalism like I've had, you know, we're going to have to raise our prices.

210
00:33:19.748 --> 00:33:24.354
<v Keelan McClymont>You know, I, I could barely afford the employees that I have working right now.

211
00:33:25.189 --> 00:33:33.086
<v Keelan McClymont>And just because, you know, I have now more employment taxes, I have cost of living, you know, increases.

212
00:33:33.134 --> 00:33:33.358
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Smith.

213
00:33:34.192 --> 00:33:40.877
<v Keelan McClymont>And, um, and so I'm just— I'm pleading with you guys, like, you know, please help in some way.

214
00:33:41.471 --> 00:33:44.340
<v Keelan McClymont>You know, I, I just— I feel like we're the minority.

215
00:33:44.999 --> 00:33:49.214
<v Keelan McClymont>And, you know, I, I didn't necessarily choose to open this store.

216
00:33:49.808 --> 00:33:50.657
<v Keelan McClymont>It wasn't my dream.

217
00:33:50.721 --> 00:33:51.893
<v Keelan McClymont>It was my husband's dream.

218
00:33:52.229 --> 00:34:01.304
<v Keelan McClymont>But I, I helped make it happen, and I'm continuing to make it happen for him while he works construction, just so that we can keep the store open.

219
00:34:01.384 --> 00:34:01.704
<v Keelan McClymont>Mm-hmm.

220
00:34:01.752 --> 00:34:05.314
<v Keelan McClymont>I mean, we literally have to have 2 incomes, right?

221
00:34:05.378 --> 00:34:10.016
<v Keelan McClymont>The store and, and his income, just to keep the store afloat, you know.

222
00:34:10.177 --> 00:34:24.253
<v Keelan McClymont>And, and so I, I just, I don't know what else to do other than, like I said, um, I, I feel like we need to bring back Neighborhood Watch, um, to help the police kind of be eyes on the street, you know, know these different locations.

223
00:34:24.702 --> 00:34:32.385
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, if we can bring back Reserve Program maybe to give us a little bit You know, more, more boots on the ground.

224
00:34:32.597 --> 00:34:41.394
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, I don't know, I just, I, I want somebody to reach out to me and see what else we can come up with, um, to help our businesses not have to close.

225
00:34:41.913 --> 00:34:42.608
<v Keelan McClymont>I don't want to close.

226
00:34:43.530 --> 00:34:45.454
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you so much for being here tonight.

227
00:34:47.300 --> 00:34:48.730
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Evan Lewis.

228
00:34:51.519 --> 00:34:51.996
<v Eric Zimmerman>Welcome.

229
00:34:54.481 --> 00:34:54.626
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

230
00:34:55.059 --> 00:35:00.123
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please introduce yourself for the record, pronouns if you prefer, and you have 3 minutes.

231
00:35:00.813 --> 00:35:03.250
<v Evan Lewis>Yes, my name is Evan Lewis, he/him.

232
00:35:04.485 --> 00:35:06.648
<v Evan Lewis>I am the executive director of Third Angle New Music.

233
00:35:07.226 --> 00:35:13.686
<v Evan Lewis>I'm a proud member of 2 local grassroots arts advocacy groups, Portland Arts and Culture for Equity and Portland Arts Leaders.

234
00:35:14.119 --> 00:35:22.230
<v Evan Lewis>And I'm here speaking on behalf of my organization and the 49 other Portland arts organizations who have signed a letter emailed to the council last Monday.

235
00:35:23.014 --> 00:35:34.463
<v Evan Lewis>This cohort of 50 organizations represents groups from across the city that encompass multiple artistic disciplines and budget sizes, from those under $75,000 to those with annual budgets over $15 million.

236
00:35:35.219 --> 00:35:40.599
<v Evan Lewis>This request is in direct response to the recent discovery of $8.5 million of unspent arts tax funds.

237
00:35:41.181 --> 00:35:49.233
<v Evan Lewis>We respectfully request a multi-year structured drawdown of a portion of these reserve funds to stabilize and preserve arts nonprofits across the city over the next several years.

238
00:35:49.990 --> 00:35:55.987
<v Evan Lewis>These funds should serve as a bridge toward a renewed era of increased public investment in Portland's vibrant arts and culture community and creative economy.

239
00:35:56.057 --> 00:35:56.161
<v Evan Lewis>Second.

240
00:35:58.630 --> 00:36:06.000
<v Evan Lewis>We ask that the city distribute during this fiscal year $1.6 million from these funds equally to all 80 general operating support organizations.

241
00:36:06.498 --> 00:36:22.442
<v Evan Lewis>This would mean a one-time fund disbursement of $20,000 to each general operating support organization with an understanding that there will be additional funding from this pool next year and that the pool of eligible organizations will be larger as a result of application requirements that are more equitable and open for all.

242
00:36:23.452 --> 00:36:29.536
<v Evan Lewis>Immediately following this distribution, we request that the city restructure the framework of eligibility for general operating support.

243
00:36:30.177 --> 00:36:46.081
<v Evan Lewis>We request that all arts organizations who apply, particularly those who have had— who have been previously denied access to general operating support funding for a myriad of reasons, many detailed in our letter, including budget size and staffing structure, these organizations be eligible within the next year to apply.

244
00:36:47.190 --> 00:36:51.650
<v Evan Lewis>Our third major request is especially timely with today's release of the city auditor's startling report on the arts tax.

245
00:36:51.731 --> 00:36:52.197
<v Evan Lewis>Thank you, Councilor Dan Ryan.

246
00:36:52.309 --> 00:36:58.413
<v Evan Lewis>The detailed report found many large concerning issues with the arts tax in terms of goals, oversight, and accountability.

247
00:36:58.943 --> 00:37:09.304
<v Evan Lewis>We request urgent action by the Portland City Council to reconsider and remedy the arts tax structure by presenting a new funding framework to put into effect within the next tax year and 2027 funding cycle.

248
00:37:10.090 --> 00:37:14.797
<v Evan Lewis>The report spells out what changes are needed and needed now, and we urge you to act on them immediately.

249
00:37:15.376 --> 00:37:17.496
<v Evan Lewis>Thank you for your time and for supporting arts in our community.

250
00:37:17.559 --> 00:37:17.704
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

251
00:37:18.429 --> 00:37:19.291
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

252
00:37:21.545 --> 00:37:23.740
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Dr. Carmen P. Thompson.

253
00:37:27.329 --> 00:37:27.525
<v Evan Lewis>Welcome.

254
00:37:28.320 --> 00:37:29.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

255
00:37:29.963 --> 00:37:33.652
<v Jamie Dunphy>Introduce yourself for the record, pronouns if you prefer, and you have 3 minutes.

256
00:37:46.690 --> 00:37:50.490
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, my name is Dr. Carmen P. Thompson, and I live in District 2.

257
00:37:51.581 --> 00:38:15.657
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to comment on the discussion of agenda item number 10 in last Wednesday's City Council meeting, in which Councilor Kanal made reference to my written testimony about pages 23 and 24 of the PCEF redline adjustments to the climate investment plan of the Portland Housing Bureau that strikes equity language from the fund in an attempt to comply with Mayor Wilson's flawed I'm sorry.

258
00:38:15.722 --> 00:38:42.757
<v Unidentified speaker>I would like to move that the council adopt an executive order that going forward for the entirety of your tenure forces you to go on the record to state your commitment to diversity, equity, inclusion every time you are asked to affirm or approve changes or removal of diversity and equity inclusion language from the policies or programs of city agencies and bureaus that are seeking to comply with Mayor Wilson's ill-conceived executive order.

259
00:38:43.541 --> 00:39:01.103
<v Unidentified speaker>In other words, his executive order has added an additional layer of responsibility to councilors to confirm or deny their commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion with each attempt by city agencies and bureaus to remove equity language in order to comply with the order.

260
00:39:01.568 --> 00:39:10.317
<v Unidentified speaker>As a result, voters will have a public record for which to evaluate you and to hold you accountable on your position on diversity, equity, and inclusion.

261
00:39:10.380 --> 00:39:10.476
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

262
00:39:11.184 --> 00:39:28.632
<v Unidentified speaker>With regard to pages 23 and 24 of the Portland Housing Bureau's redline adjustments to the climate benefit plan, Councilor Dunphy, I look forward to your promise to add to the council agenda a discussion on the new equity language to replace that which was stricken from pages 23 and 24.

263
00:39:29.163 --> 00:39:36.681
<v Unidentified speaker>You promised to have this discussion in 30 to 45 days, and I and the voters of Portland will be anxiously awaiting this discussion.

264
00:39:36.730 --> 00:39:36.907
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

265
00:39:37.597 --> 00:39:42.068
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilors, the problem with the executive order of Mayor Wilson's are numerous.

266
00:39:42.501 --> 00:39:59.846
<v Unidentified speaker>As a Black woman who is part of the protected classes that this executive order seeks to target, that this executive order targets, my concern is as much about future generations of councilors who will not have the institutional knowledge that you have about the city's prior position on diversity, equity, inclusion.

267
00:40:00.375 --> 00:40:11.148
<v Unidentified speaker>If left as stands, these future councilors will not have to make any commitment to diversity, equity, inclusion in housing that the Portland Housing Bureau has to abide by.

268
00:40:11.740 --> 00:40:24.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Likewise, other city agencies and bureaus will also be without commitments to diversity, equity, inclusion if such language is not put back into agencies, policies, and programs, all of which may take decades to restore.

269
00:40:25.065 --> 00:40:33.259
<v Unidentified speaker>The language of diversity, equity, inclusion was put in place because of decades of exclusion and is endemic of Oregon's white supremacist history.

270
00:40:33.563 --> 00:40:39.309
<v Unidentified speaker>I frankly do not need a disparity study to understand institutionalized white supremacy and anti-Blackness in Portland.

271
00:40:40.289 --> 00:40:50.264
<v Unidentified speaker>It is literally written in our city records, and it remains to be seen this council's role in advancing diversity, equity, inclusion policies that this executive order threatens to roll back.

272
00:40:50.586 --> 00:40:51.021
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

273
00:40:51.746 --> 00:40:53.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>Really good timing.

274
00:40:53.887 --> 00:40:54.193
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

275
00:40:54.932 --> 00:40:56.081
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much for being here.

276
00:40:56.242 --> 00:40:56.615
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

277
00:40:59.014 --> 00:41:00.666
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Jack Dickinson.

278
00:41:07.389 --> 00:41:07.655
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

279
00:41:07.985 --> 00:41:10.753
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please introduce yourself for the record and pronouns, and you have 3 minutes.

280
00:41:13.262 --> 00:41:15.405
<v Jack Dickinson>All right, my name for the record is Jack Dickinson.

281
00:41:15.697 --> 00:41:20.856
<v Jack Dickinson>I'm here today to talk a little bit about the Moda Center renovations, but briefly I wanna comment on some other recent news.

282
00:41:21.461 --> 00:41:28.061
<v Jack Dickinson>The City of Portland should rename Cesar Chavez Boulevard either to Dolores Huerta Boulevard or just back to 39th.

283
00:41:28.822 --> 00:41:37.248
<v Jack Dickinson>We can talk about whether this is an appropriate use of scarce public money, I don't think it is unreasonable to ask our city streets not be named after serial rapists.

284
00:41:37.969 --> 00:41:44.137
<v Jack Dickinson>And in the future, let's be a bit more careful about naming things after men with cult followings, because there's a bit of a pattern here.

285
00:41:44.474 --> 00:41:47.885
<v Jack Dickinson>All right, so now let's talk about the plan to renovate the Moda Center.

286
00:41:48.061 --> 00:41:49.711
<v Jack Dickinson>And I'm just here with a couple concerns that I have.

287
00:41:50.304 --> 00:41:54.679
<v Jack Dickinson>So first, I have a concern that we're really doing this without examining our priors.

288
00:41:55.431 --> 00:42:02.512
<v Jack Dickinson>There's a pervasive assumption in politics that these stadium deals are a boon for the economy, but the research broadly does not support that conclusion.

289
00:42:02.561 --> 00:42:02.688
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

290
00:42:03.427 --> 00:42:18.891
<v Jack Dickinson>To quote a 2023 paper titled The Economics of Stadium Subsidies: A Policy Retrospective, quote, studies consistently demonstrate that sports stadiums have little to no tangible economic impact on host communities, and thus typical public subsidies tend to exceed any meager economic benefits.

291
00:42:20.286 --> 00:42:22.018
<v Jack Dickinson>I think it's okay to abstract this a bit, a little bit.

292
00:42:22.693 --> 00:42:30.969
<v Jack Dickinson>I mean, the basic logic behind stadium deals is kind of the same logic behind trickle-down economics, and I think that's why the logic Thank you.

293
00:42:32.139 --> 00:42:44.289
<v Jack Dickinson>Now, in a press release, the mayor cited $670 million of annual economic activity, and this leads me into my second and more important concern, which is there appears to be nobody representing the interests of the public right now.

294
00:42:45.219 --> 00:42:50.862
<v Jack Dickinson>The figure appears to have come from lobbyists for the Blazers, with whom Mayor Wilson has been privately meeting with for nearly a year.

295
00:42:51.791 --> 00:42:58.043
<v Jack Dickinson>I would have hoped the mayor would have been wise enough to not simply regurgitate lobbyist talking points, But alas, here we are.

296
00:42:59.246 --> 00:43:01.090
<v Jack Dickinson>I feel I need to remind you of a simple fact.

297
00:43:01.875 --> 00:43:03.173
<v Jack Dickinson>You work for the people of Portland.

298
00:43:03.478 --> 00:43:05.177
<v Jack Dickinson>You do not work for the Portland Trail Blazers.

299
00:43:05.577 --> 00:43:10.628
<v Jack Dickinson>By all means, find and exploit the areas where those interests align, but don't assume they're aligned all the time.

300
00:43:11.733 --> 00:43:18.099
<v Jack Dickinson>I think we need you all to be more open about this conversation because talking about these things is part of how we create the leverage.

301
00:43:19.429 --> 00:43:28.269
<v Jack Dickinson>And with the new ownership getting a sweetheart deal from the state, I think they're going to be even less inclined to walk away if we ask for things like partial naming rights or pilots.

302
00:43:29.697 --> 00:43:30.998
<v Jack Dickinson>And clearly there's an element of fear here.

303
00:43:31.079 --> 00:43:34.577
<v Jack Dickinson>Nobody wants to be the elected official that gets blamed for losing the Blazers.

304
00:43:35.092 --> 00:43:35.460
<v Jack Dickinson>I get that.

305
00:43:35.733 --> 00:43:37.034
<v Jack Dickinson>And I don't want the Blazers to leave.

306
00:43:37.739 --> 00:43:47.018
<v Jack Dickinson>But I also think if we're talking about political consequences, you should be fearful of being the elected official who gleefully robs PSF because you refuse to call a billionaire's bluff.

307
00:43:47.996 --> 00:43:50.469
<v Jack Dickinson>Steve, I appreciate how open you have been about this particular topic.

308
00:43:50.532 --> 00:43:50.628
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

309
00:43:52.472 --> 00:43:53.393
<v Jack Dickinson>That's all I have time for today.

310
00:43:53.764 --> 00:44:04.152
<v Jack Dickinson>But since I'm probably never gonna be back here testifying about sports ever again, I just wanna say on the record that if we do end up getting an MLB team, the only acceptable name for it would be the Portland Crows.

311
00:44:04.653 --> 00:44:06.188
<v Jack Dickinson>And I won't accept any other answers for that.

312
00:44:06.300 --> 00:44:07.043
<v Jack Dickinson>So thank you.

313
00:44:08.045 --> 00:44:08.643
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

314
00:44:10.630 --> 00:44:12.536
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Bridge Crane Simka.

315
00:44:23.309 --> 00:44:23.746
<v Steve Novick>Welcome.

316
00:44:23.827 --> 00:44:24.168
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening.

317
00:44:24.313 --> 00:44:24.798
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you all.

318
00:44:25.057 --> 00:44:30.596
<v Unidentified speaker>Madam Vice President, Mr. President Dunphy, I'm Charles Simcoe Bridge Crane Johnson.

319
00:44:30.855 --> 00:44:31.615
<v Unidentified speaker>It's good to be back here.

320
00:44:32.298 --> 00:44:50.469
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe this is the first time I've done this thing since Mr. Novick, the originator somewhat of my name, back when Charlie Hales thought it was his duty as mayor to rush through a police contract before— in the final couple months of his term.

321
00:44:51.802 --> 00:45:18.576
<v Unidentified speaker>And I know, you know, your plates seem already full, but I know that that's an ongoing process to look at how we can successfully negotiate with the Portland Police to not only bring down the not-too-bad crime numbers, but to make sure that everyone of every background in this community feels safe and sees their community represented among the Portland Police Bureau.

322
00:45:22.300 --> 00:45:29.057
<v Unidentified speaker>When I was here a couple weeks ago, you were all involved in a good effort to try and get money.

323
00:45:32.157 --> 00:45:34.170
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's the correct phrasing for it, isn't it?

324
00:45:34.253 --> 00:45:38.246
<v Unidentified speaker>We so often talk about things here about the money part and not the actual results part.

325
00:45:38.327 --> 00:45:38.474
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

326
00:45:39.528 --> 00:45:40.528
<v Unidentified speaker>Trying to get money out.

327
00:45:40.594 --> 00:45:56.989
<v Unidentified speaker>We were arguably quibbling and throwing shade about whether there was going to be $150,000 or $350,000 out to some organizations to help victims of the Trump administration— victims of state terrorism, actually.

328
00:45:58.855 --> 00:46:05.175
<v Unidentified speaker>And fortunately, I know that that issue is crucial to all of you, but especially Thank you.

329
00:46:05.920 --> 00:46:17.447
<v Unidentified speaker>Commissioner Avalos, who I'm sure will be looking at ways to get back to that money and to increase the spend so that people who are— I don't have the phrasing.

330
00:46:17.512 --> 00:46:18.693
<v Unidentified speaker>I didn't keep it on my screen.

331
00:46:18.871 --> 00:46:25.032
<v Unidentified speaker>I think the phrasing we had earlier was war detention centers, concentration camps.

332
00:46:26.409 --> 00:46:39.103
<v Unidentified speaker>The Japanese American people did describe it as incarceration, but of course it was a A separate special system of incarceration like too many of our neighbors find.

333
00:46:39.231 --> 00:46:48.144
<v Unidentified speaker>I do think one thing that sticks with me from that time is that Councilor Morillo was very adamant about facts.

334
00:46:48.208 --> 00:47:10.262
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that actually one way to actually improve public sentiment about going back into either that particular source of money or other funding to make sure that anybody arrested, caught up by ICE in their state-sponsored terrorism has representation is to talk about the numbers that are already suffering.

335
00:47:10.375 --> 00:47:15.440
<v Unidentified speaker>When we had the poem downstairs about the experience and No More Tears, we had names.

336
00:47:15.489 --> 00:47:19.664
<v Unidentified speaker>So, and also that's important for you to scope the problem.

337
00:47:20.891 --> 00:47:29.063
<v Unidentified speaker>The crisis with homelessness is that a few people get housed and many people remain extremely underserved or not served.

338
00:47:29.188 --> 00:47:29.295
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

339
00:47:29.969 --> 00:47:37.568
<v Unidentified speaker>So I look forward to a time soon when we will talk about how many people have been victimized by Trump's state terrorism and how we're going to make sure they get due process.

340
00:47:37.960 --> 00:47:38.396
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

341
00:47:38.945 --> 00:47:39.577
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

342
00:47:43.168 --> 00:47:45.157
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes public communications.

343
00:47:45.577 --> 00:47:45.835
<v Jamie Dunphy>Excellent.

344
00:47:46.483 --> 00:47:47.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you everybody for being here tonight.

345
00:47:49.000 --> 00:47:54.112
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, our next item on this is an update from the city administrator with regard to the federal response.

346
00:47:54.385 --> 00:48:04.231
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're going to get— I will continue to be holding times on our agendas to hear updates about the ongoing federal response and any other emergency response matters at the beginning of council meetings.

347
00:48:04.681 --> 00:48:05.498
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator Lee.

348
00:48:06.251 --> 00:48:07.791
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

349
00:48:07.951 --> 00:48:09.474
<v Sameer Kanal>There's no new updates today.

350
00:48:09.554 --> 00:48:23.996
<v Sameer Kanal>Staff is still working on the permanent policy that we'll be trying to bring forward to council in the summer months, but we will keep you updated as we get new updates on the schedule of the hearing as well.

351
00:48:24.530 --> 00:48:25.163
<v Sameer Kanal>For the land use.

352
00:48:25.211 --> 00:48:29.414
<v Sameer Kanal>So as soon as we get that update, we will make sure council is up to speed on that.

353
00:48:29.722 --> 00:48:30.436
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

354
00:48:32.434 --> 00:48:34.317
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please read item number 4?

355
00:48:37.849 --> 00:48:45.737
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 2026-112, amend council schedule during FY 2026-27 budget process.

356
00:48:46.835 --> 00:48:52.753
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is an item that I filed specifically in response to our, uh, 2026-2027 budget process.

357
00:48:53.719 --> 00:48:59.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>Specifically, it is because we have a number of meetings that we must have and we have to change our calendar.

358
00:48:59.385 --> 00:49:01.695
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have to remove some of the committee structure meetings.

359
00:49:02.916 --> 00:49:18.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I specifically also had it pulled from— well, it was pulled from consent, but I also have an amendment which has been filed to fill out the rest of the legal requirements that we need in order to enable our budget calendar.

360
00:49:18.418 --> 00:49:24.391
<v Jamie Dunphy>It additionally adds an emergency clause to ensure that these changes are enforced by the time that we need them to be.

361
00:49:25.467 --> 00:49:29.387
<v Jamie Dunphy>The amendment is posted online under the item.

362
00:49:29.661 --> 00:49:34.067
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm happy to answer any technical questions if I am able to.

363
00:49:36.137 --> 00:49:41.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that is about as much as I have written here in front of me.

364
00:49:42.413 --> 00:49:44.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

365
00:49:44.759 --> 00:49:45.664
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, Council President.

366
00:49:45.713 --> 00:49:47.023
<v Sameer Kanal>Just a technical question, if I may.

367
00:49:47.168 --> 00:49:47.315
<v Sameer Kanal>Please.

368
00:49:48.059 --> 00:49:55.773
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to the The changes from the April 29th, May 6th, and May 13th.

369
00:49:55.820 --> 00:50:02.121
<v Sameer Kanal>This is not about the amendments, about the underlying, the move from the morning to the afternoon session.

370
00:50:02.429 --> 00:50:03.880
<v Sameer Kanal>Just wanted to understand that a little bit.

371
00:50:04.108 --> 00:50:07.061
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, those—.

372
00:50:07.485 --> 00:50:11.585
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll ask my staff to come up and help me walk through the specifics because there's a lot of moving parts.

373
00:50:12.039 --> 00:50:12.931
<v Jamie Dunphy>Evan, please join us.

374
00:50:13.693 --> 00:50:14.065
<v Evan Hoffer>Greetings.

375
00:50:15.233 --> 00:50:16.385
<v Evan Hoffer>Thank you for the question, Councilor.

376
00:50:16.449 --> 00:50:42.989
<v Evan Hoffer>For the record, my name is Evan Hoffer, Policy Advisor for Council President in the 3 weeks that we have between the mayor's proposed budget document and the initial hearing and our full council budget hearings, we have a number of work sessions that are scheduled in order to hear, to move through our key— wow, words, I apologize— in order to move through program areas and bureaus in a consistent way.

377
00:50:43.615 --> 00:50:45.929
<v Evan Hoffer>In order to allow consistency of that schedule, Councilor Smith.

378
00:50:46.443 --> 00:50:58.568
<v Evan Hoffer>For the public, for our staff, and also that there's a regular cadence of being able to think through potential amendments following those morning hearings, we intended to schedule them all in the mornings.

379
00:50:58.827 --> 00:51:04.592
<v Evan Hoffer>So it's consistent if you're going to a budget work session every morning, Tuesday through Thursday, 3 weeks in a row.

380
00:51:08.099 --> 00:51:08.378
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

381
00:51:08.427 --> 00:51:11.023
<v Sameer Kanal>And can you speak to the choice to include an end time?

382
00:51:12.340 --> 00:51:16.001
<v Sameer Kanal>Most of our other schedules have just a start time for the meetings.

383
00:51:17.791 --> 00:51:18.338
<v Evan Hoffer>Absolutely.

384
00:51:18.936 --> 00:51:25.619
<v Evan Hoffer>That's out of respect primarily to staff for a 5:00 PM end.

385
00:51:25.976 --> 00:51:33.690
<v Evan Hoffer>We are consistently able to hold over those times and we do regularly.

386
00:51:34.914 --> 00:51:42.956
<v Evan Hoffer>However, in the context of an intense period, making sure to manage our time in a way where we're not burning each other out is a value for the office.

387
00:51:45.487 --> 00:51:48.643
<v Sameer Kanal>So how is that going to be interpreted is, I guess, what I'm saying.

388
00:51:48.773 --> 00:51:50.626
<v Sameer Kanal>Those 2 things you just said contradict each other.

389
00:51:50.690 --> 00:51:51.898
<v Sameer Kanal>So I wanna understand our—.

390
00:51:51.898 --> 00:51:52.235
<v Evan Hoffer>Absolutely.

391
00:51:52.688 --> 00:51:53.766
<v Evan Hoffer>I can speak to that clearly.

392
00:51:54.860 --> 00:51:56.438
<v Evan Hoffer>Yes, that is a loose 5:00 PM.

393
00:51:56.501 --> 00:51:58.516
<v Evan Hoffer>That is an intended and not strict 5:00 PM.

394
00:51:58.740 --> 00:51:58.949
<v Sameer Kanal>Got it.

395
00:51:59.143 --> 00:51:59.255
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

396
00:51:59.304 --> 00:51:59.724
<v Evan Hoffer>Thank you.

397
00:52:01.012 --> 00:52:01.898
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

398
00:52:01.978 --> 00:52:02.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

399
00:52:03.813 --> 00:52:04.737
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

400
00:52:05.302 --> 00:52:11.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I understand the value for all of us of having the consistency of budget work sessions in the morning.

401
00:52:11.831 --> 00:52:18.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is also a change for Portlanders who might be coming to testify at council meetings to see a meeting from 2 to 5 PM.

402
00:52:18.271 --> 00:52:21.855
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our council meetings generally are in the morning or these evening sessions.

403
00:52:23.557 --> 00:52:43.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are you willing to work with council operations to make sure that there's clear posting and information going out on email channels, social media, all of the spaces that we have to communicate with Portlanders so that our constituents understand that if they are coming for a council meeting during that time, it is a different time than they are used to being here?

404
00:52:43.385 --> 00:52:43.882
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

405
00:52:43.961 --> 00:53:03.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, it is my intention to use every tool that I have and that is within the city broadly to try to be as transparent with the public about the number of opportunities folks can either speak specifically to the budget or the change specific here about when they expect to be able to come and address us.

406
00:53:03.202 --> 00:53:13.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, I will use every— I'll be working closely with Council Ops, with the clerk, and hopefully all of you as well to boost it on social media and other places.

407
00:53:13.447 --> 00:53:13.847
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

408
00:53:14.023 --> 00:53:21.302
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to make sure that Portlanders know how they can communicate with us, not just about the budget, but through our regular courses of business as well.

409
00:53:21.543 --> 00:53:21.927
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

410
00:53:22.264 --> 00:53:22.648
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

411
00:53:23.547 --> 00:53:26.416
<v Jamie Dunphy>You have my assurance to the maximum ability.

412
00:53:26.463 --> 00:53:33.416
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, First, I would like to move my— the Dunphy 1 amendment, which— and thank you, Councilor Ryan.

413
00:53:34.478 --> 00:53:39.867
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, is there any discussion on the amendment?

414
00:53:41.936 --> 00:53:46.168
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, can we please call the roll on the amendment Dunphy 1?

415
00:53:48.621 --> 00:53:48.637
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

416
00:53:49.813 --> 00:53:50.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absent.

417
00:53:58.938 --> 00:53:58.985
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

418
00:53:59.663 --> 00:53:59.710
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

419
00:54:00.226 --> 00:54:00.275
<v Councilmember Herbold>Aye.

420
00:54:01.838 --> 00:54:01.887
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

421
00:54:02.483 --> 00:54:02.498
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

422
00:54:03.208 --> 00:54:03.257
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

423
00:54:04.416 --> 00:54:04.432
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

424
00:54:05.157 --> 00:54:05.335
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

425
00:54:05.706 --> 00:54:05.755
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

426
00:54:07.724 --> 00:54:07.773
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

427
00:54:08.612 --> 00:54:17.347
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.

428
00:54:17.672 --> 00:54:18.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

429
00:54:19.190 --> 00:54:22.664
<v Jamie Dunphy>And can— is there any further discussion on the now amended underlying ordinance?

430
00:54:26.764 --> 00:54:27.266
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

431
00:54:28.304 --> 00:54:28.628
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

432
00:54:28.710 --> 00:54:32.536
<v Sameer Kanal>Just wanted to ask if you could speak to just a little clarity.

433
00:54:33.251 --> 00:54:37.173
<v Sameer Kanal>It didn't relate to the— it wasn't a technical question before, but you said 3 days in a row.

434
00:54:37.655 --> 00:54:39.728
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm seeing that we have recess sessions.

435
00:54:39.938 --> 00:54:48.706
<v Sameer Kanal>Is it— we're referring to May 18th, 19th, 20th, or are you referring to in April, May, the April 29th, May 6th, and May 13th week?

436
00:54:49.364 --> 00:54:53.110
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of having the Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday cadence that you mentioned, Evan?

437
00:54:54.733 --> 00:54:54.974
<v Evan Hoffer>Yes.

438
00:54:55.215 --> 00:55:07.557
<v Evan Hoffer>So April 28th, 29th, and 30th are 2 budget work sessions and a joint city-county work session, which based off of the schedules could not be at that same time.

439
00:55:08.554 --> 00:55:16.409
<v Evan Hoffer>Then May 5th through 7th and May 12th through 14th, each of those 3-day blocks all have back-to-back work sessions.

440
00:55:24.898 --> 00:55:30.775
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I just want to understand because I'm, I'm also seeing committee on that time, but I— okay.

441
00:55:31.418 --> 00:55:34.648
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, yeah, thanks.

442
00:55:35.900 --> 00:55:36.688
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

443
00:55:37.507 --> 00:55:44.561
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we will be doing, again, in addition to sharing this information as widely about the rescheduled Council hearings.

444
00:55:44.610 --> 00:55:49.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll also be trying to share as much information about the budget calendar publicly so folks have a better idea.

445
00:55:49.693 --> 00:55:59.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if there are any conflicts, um, additionally, you know, for example, uh, we are trying to work with some of the committee chairs in order to try and accommodate some additional— putting back some additional time.

446
00:55:59.711 --> 00:56:05.023
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, we will try to be as flexible about this, but I want to maximize the amount of time that we get to talk about this budget.

447
00:56:07.632 --> 00:56:08.677
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I appreciate that.

448
00:56:08.980 --> 00:56:12.364
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor, I just want— Council President, I just wanted to make sure I understood it exactly.

449
00:56:12.623 --> 00:56:16.782
<v Sameer Kanal>And I would love an updated version of that calendar just so we can be prepared.

450
00:56:17.306 --> 00:56:20.081
<v Sameer Kanal>But I know it's a lot of work that you're all doing and your team as well.

451
00:56:20.146 --> 00:56:20.389
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

452
00:56:20.873 --> 00:56:26.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are working as hard as we can and we will get it out as quickly as possible, but it'll be hopefully in your inbox very soon.

453
00:56:28.534 --> 00:56:33.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue to discuss, can we please call the roll on the now amended emergency ordinance?

454
00:56:37.905 --> 00:56:37.922
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

455
00:56:39.853 --> 00:56:40.860
<v Keelan McClymont>Miss Absent.

456
00:56:41.007 --> 00:56:41.202
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

457
00:56:41.802 --> 00:56:41.851
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

458
00:56:43.177 --> 00:56:43.355
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

459
00:56:43.853 --> 00:56:43.885
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

460
00:56:46.556 --> 00:56:46.603
<v Robin Miller>Aye.

461
00:56:47.135 --> 00:56:47.168
<v Councilmember Herbold>Aye.

462
00:56:48.969 --> 00:56:49.016
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

463
00:56:49.532 --> 00:56:49.708
<v Councilmember Herbold>Aye.

464
00:56:50.498 --> 00:56:50.547
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

465
00:56:51.951 --> 00:56:52.000
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

466
00:57:01.621 --> 00:57:01.670
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

467
00:57:02.106 --> 00:57:07.211
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance as amended passes with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.

468
00:57:07.824 --> 00:57:08.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

469
00:57:08.871 --> 00:57:10.815
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will get through the budget, I promise.

470
00:57:11.541 --> 00:57:13.092
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please call item number 5?

471
00:57:17.989 --> 00:57:28.489
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 2026-055, amend campaign finance code to maintain enforcement of voter-approved regulations following court Order amend Code Chapter 2.10.

472
00:57:29.807 --> 00:57:32.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

473
00:57:33.119 --> 00:57:34.534
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there any further council discussion?

474
00:57:41.347 --> 00:57:45.085
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

475
00:57:45.583 --> 00:57:45.889
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

476
00:57:46.630 --> 00:57:46.679
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

477
00:57:47.436 --> 00:57:47.824
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

478
00:57:48.081 --> 00:57:48.550
<v Keelan McClymont>Absent.

479
00:57:48.663 --> 00:57:48.889
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

480
00:57:49.791 --> 00:57:49.969
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

481
00:57:50.583 --> 00:57:51.132
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

482
00:57:51.873 --> 00:57:51.922
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

483
00:57:52.030 --> 00:57:52.045
<v Robin Miller>Aye.

484
00:57:52.159 --> 00:57:52.192
<v Evan Lewis>Aye.

485
00:57:52.289 --> 00:57:52.353
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

486
00:57:52.467 --> 00:57:52.483
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

487
00:57:52.856 --> 00:57:52.873
<v Robin Miller>Aye.

488
00:57:52.922 --> 00:57:53.295
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Ryan?

489
00:57:53.425 --> 00:57:53.586
<v Dan Ryan>No.

490
00:57:53.992 --> 00:57:55.518
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Koyama Lane?

491
00:57:55.875 --> 00:57:55.923
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

492
00:57:56.523 --> 00:57:56.929
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

493
00:57:57.481 --> 00:57:57.530
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

494
00:57:59.097 --> 00:57:59.146
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

495
00:58:00.309 --> 00:58:00.650
<v Keelan McClymont>Clerk?

496
00:58:01.038 --> 00:58:01.085
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

497
00:58:01.699 --> 00:58:01.909
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

498
00:58:03.137 --> 00:58:03.315
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

499
00:58:03.882 --> 00:58:04.237
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

500
00:58:05.320 --> 00:58:05.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

501
00:58:06.773 --> 00:58:06.903
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

502
00:58:07.679 --> 00:58:11.637
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with 10 yes votes, 1 no vote, and 1 absent.

503
00:58:12.121 --> 00:58:13.188
<v Jamie Dunphy>Fantastic.

504
00:58:13.818 --> 00:58:14.998
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 6?

505
00:58:18.052 --> 00:58:27.268
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 2026-039, amend Chronic Nuisance Property Code to address human trafficking, gun violence, and administrative challenges.

506
00:58:27.856 --> 00:58:31.402
<v Keelan McClymont>Amend Code Chapter 14B.60.

507
00:58:33.376 --> 00:58:37.664
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome Christopher Hare from Council Operations with a committee staff summary report.

508
00:58:38.539 --> 00:58:39.282
<v Christopher Hare>Yes, thank you.

509
00:58:39.606 --> 00:58:41.594
<v Christopher Hare>Good evening, Council President and councilors.

510
00:58:41.692 --> 00:58:47.376
<v Christopher Hare>For the record, Christopher Hare, Council Operations Policy Analyst, and I serve as staff to the Community and Public Safety Committee.

511
00:58:48.175 --> 00:59:01.027
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance before you, document number 2026-039, was considered in the Community and Public Safety meeting on January 27th, February 10th, and again on February 24th, where it was referred to council with a recommendation it be passed.

512
00:59:02.134 --> 00:59:11.161
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance amends Portland City Code Chapter 14B.60, as shown in Exhibit A, to revise definitions, procedures, and enforcement provisions related to chronic nuisance properties.

513
00:59:11.818 --> 00:59:22.641
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance, through the proposed code changes, removes references assigning administrative responsibility to the chief of police or precinct commander and assigns those responsibilities to the city administrator or their designees throughout the chapter.

514
00:59:23.152 --> 00:59:25.509
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance modifies the definition of a nuisance property.

515
00:59:26.021 --> 00:59:36.998
<v Christopher Hare>Under the proposed language, the property may be considered a nuisance property when 2 or more nuisance activities occur on the property or within 200 feet of it by a person associated with the property during a 90-day period.

516
00:59:37.398 --> 00:59:40.972
<v Christopher Hare>Previously, the threshold was 3 nuisance activities within a 30-day period.

517
00:59:41.565 --> 00:59:46.179
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance adds several activities to the list of nuisance activities, including loitering to solicit prostitutes, Yes.

518
00:59:46.179 --> 00:59:46.559
<v Sameer Kanal>Opposed?

519
00:59:46.559 --> 00:59:46.619
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

520
00:59:46.619 --> 00:59:46.619
<v Keelan McClymont>Motion passes.

521
00:59:46.619 --> 01:00:15.599
<v Christopher Hare>Next item on the agenda is Ordinance 2023-24, Prohibition of Unlawful Prostitution as Defined in Portland City Code Section 14A.40.040, Operation of a Massage Business in Violation of Oregon Revised Statutes 687.021, Possession of a Loaded Firearm in a Public Place as Defined in Portland City Code Section 14A.60.010, Unlawful Prostitution Procurement Activities as Defined in Portland City Code Section 14A.40.050, and Failure of Transient Lodging Operators to Maintain Required Records and Logs as Defined in Portland City Code Section 687.021.

522
01:00:15.599 --> 01:00:15.679
<v Christopher Hare>All those in favor?

523
01:00:18.141 --> 01:00:33.202
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance removes from the list of nuisance activities unlawful operation of sound-producing or reproducing equipment and excessive noise as defined in Portland City Code Section 14A.30.010 and Portland City Code Chapters 18.04 and 18.14.

524
01:00:33.619 --> 01:00:42.255
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance limits the definition of persons associated with a nuisance activity to individuals who entered, patronized, or visited the property associated with the nuisance activity.

525
01:00:42.304 --> 01:00:42.465
<v Candace Avalos>Second.

526
01:00:43.072 --> 01:01:00.036
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance also adds a new section, Portland City Code Section 14B.60.025, that provides an exemption from chronic nuisance designation when the person in charge of the property has timely reported suspected nuisance activities to law enforcement and has engaged in good faith efforts to assist in addressing those activities.

527
01:01:00.637 --> 01:01:03.858
<v Christopher Hare>The section also establishes criteria for qualifying for this exemption.

528
01:01:04.621 --> 01:01:38.599
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance amends procedures under Portland City Code Section 14B.60.030 by increasing the number of police reports required to initiate chronic nuisance proceedings from 1 to 2 and allowing other official documentation to be used to initiate proceedings, extending the time for a property owner to respond to a nuisance— chronic nuisance proceeding from 10 days to 14 days, requiring notices to include a list of possible abatement measures, points of contacts, and a summary of potential next steps or future actions, and reducing the time in which the person in charge of the property and the city must agree on an abatement plan from 60 days to 30 days.

529
01:01:39.260 --> 01:02:15.838
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance also amends provisions in Portland City Code Section 14B.60.040, by adding implementation of abatement measures to the list of remedies a court may order, removing the specified timeframe of 6 months to 1 year for court-ordered closure and securing of a property, and instead allowing closure for a period determined appropriate by the court, increasing the minimum civil penalty from $100 to $1,000 for each day nuisance activity occurs on the property after the city has provided notice of a chronic nuisance proceeding, and removing language allowing a property's general reputation or the reputation of persons residing in or frequenting the property to be used as proof in nuisance proceedings.

530
01:02:16.592 --> 01:02:25.248
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance also makes minor technical and conforming edits throughout the chapter, including updating cross-references and alphabetizing lists for clarity and ease of reference.

531
01:02:26.195 --> 01:02:30.137
<v Christopher Hare>The committee adopted an amendment to the ordinance prior to moving the item to full council.

532
01:02:30.202 --> 01:02:34.755
<v Christopher Hare>The effects of the amendment on the original ordinance are summarized in the committee staff summary posted online.

533
01:02:35.748 --> 01:02:50.474
<v Christopher Hare>The full impact statements on the item include financial and budgetary impacts and analysis, economic and real estate development impacts, community impacts and community 10 individuals provided verbal testimony in committee, and 34 individuals submitted written testimony prior to committee action on February 24th.

534
01:02:51.228 --> 01:03:02.561
<v Christopher Hare>General themes included relationship between human trafficking, prostitution activity, and incidents of violence in Portland, and connections raised between these activities and certain properties, particularly along the 82nd Avenue corridor.

535
01:03:03.188 --> 01:03:10.282
<v Christopher Hare>Community safety concerns, including experiences of parents and students associated with McDaniel High School encountering prostitution-related activities in the surrounding area.

536
01:03:10.329 --> 01:03:10.619
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilmember Herbold.

537
01:03:11.054 --> 01:03:13.610
<v Christopher Hare>And broader impacts on neighborhood safety and community reputation.

538
01:03:14.208 --> 01:03:23.532
<v Christopher Hare>Impacts of nuisance properties and open sexual exploitation on surrounding neighborhoods, businesses, and commercial corridors, and a desire for efforts to improve safety for residents, students, businesses, and commuters.

539
01:03:24.353 --> 01:03:32.224
<v Christopher Hare>Desire of small business owners and community members for additional city tools to support and support to address nuisance activities occurring on or near the properties.

540
01:03:32.661 --> 01:03:40.302
<v Christopher Hare>Partnership between certain hotels that may be implicated by the code changes and community organizations providing shelter, housing assistance, and other services to community members.

541
01:03:40.351 --> 01:03:40.452
<v Christopher Hare>Second.

542
01:03:41.289 --> 01:03:51.554
<v Christopher Hare>Importance of addressing human trafficking and nuisance activity while minimizing unintended consequences for vulnerable communities, including sex workers, victims of trafficking, unhoused individuals, and immigrant communities.

543
01:03:52.326 --> 01:04:00.068
<v Christopher Hare>Concerns about potential displacement of vulnerable populations or sex workers moving into less visible environments that may increase vulnerability to exploitation.

544
01:04:00.583 --> 01:04:09.418
<v Christopher Hare>Concerns regarding profiling, increased police contact with certain communities, and expanded law enforcement authority and potential implications related to due process and surveillance.

545
01:04:09.739 --> 01:04:22.262
<v Christopher Hare>Concerns regarding potential impacts on business owners and property operators in areas with higher levels of nuisance activities, including properties renting rooms to unhoused individuals or property owners not directly involved in the activity.

546
01:04:22.905 --> 01:04:31.416
<v Christopher Hare>Reference to policies used in other cities, including Seattle's Stay Out of Areas of Prostitution and Stay Out of Drug Area approaches in discussion of potential impacts.

547
01:04:31.880 --> 01:04:41.418
<v Christopher Hare>Interest in additional services and resources in areas such as 82nd Avenue corridor to support individuals experiencing trafficking and reduce conditions that contribute to exploitation.

548
01:04:41.916 --> 01:04:47.760
<v Christopher Hare>And finally, interest in increased flexibility and timely action by the city when addressing chronic nuisance properties.

549
01:04:48.418 --> 01:04:49.768
<v Christopher Hare>That concludes the committee staff summary.

550
01:04:49.960 --> 01:04:50.346
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

551
01:04:51.003 --> 01:04:53.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Christopher.

552
01:04:53.331 --> 01:04:55.820
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick, you are both the sponsor and the committee chair.

553
01:04:55.916 --> 01:04:59.514
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also understand there will be some amendments to be discussed, so I turn it over to you.

554
01:04:59.994 --> 01:05:01.648
<v Steve Novick>Thank you very much, Mr. President, and thank you, Christopher.

555
01:05:01.730 --> 01:05:03.527
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Christopher.

556
01:05:03.768 --> 01:05:11.235
<v Steve Novick>I want to begin by thanking the members of the Committee of Public— and the Committee on Public Safety Committee and everyone who's engaged with this legislation over the past few months.

557
01:05:11.780 --> 01:05:20.114
<v Steve Novick>We had 2 sessions on this proposal in the Committee on Public Safety Committee and a brief sort of summary of it in an in-between session.

558
01:05:20.628 --> 01:05:26.969
<v Steve Novick>We've spoken with victim advocates, survivors, motel owners, law enforcement experts, counselors, and others to refine this ordinance.

559
01:05:28.092 --> 01:05:44.813
<v Steve Novick>The fundamental question this ordinance poses is, to what extent do we think property owners have an obligation to make sure that their properties aren't being used as a base for certain sorts of illegal activity, such as human trafficking or drug dealing?

560
01:05:46.030 --> 01:05:59.411
<v Steve Novick>Currently, the code allows the city to initiate a process to have a property declared a chronic nuisance property If there are 3 instances of illegal activity documented by the police within 30 days.

561
01:06:00.309 --> 01:06:04.387
<v Steve Novick>What we've heard from law enforcement is that is too restrictive.

562
01:06:05.061 --> 01:06:13.940
<v Steve Novick>A heck of a lot of bad stuff can happen on their property and property without law enforcement documenting the existence of bad stuff happening within 30 days.

563
01:06:14.679 --> 01:06:18.838
<v Steve Novick>So the heart of this legislation is to extend the timeline.

564
01:06:18.934 --> 01:06:19.094
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

565
01:06:19.657 --> 01:06:26.775
<v Steve Novick>What passed out of committee was 2 instances in 90 days is sufficient to initiate the process.

566
01:06:27.931 --> 01:06:33.811
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney has suggested making that 3 in 90 days, and I'm amenable to that amendment.

567
01:06:35.001 --> 01:06:53.565
<v Steve Novick>What happens when the city initiates the chronic nuisance property process is the city informs the property owner that, or the person in charge of the property, That we've seen this activity and we're asking you to take steps to, to come up with a plan to abate this activity.

568
01:06:54.143 --> 01:06:59.458
<v Steve Novick>And then there's back and forth between the property owner and the city, and hopefully they come up with a plan to abate the activity.

569
01:07:00.286 --> 01:07:10.829
<v Steve Novick>In unusual cases where there's not a agreed-upon plan, then as a last resort, the city can go to court to get the court to order abatement or other activities.

570
01:07:11.679 --> 01:07:13.478
<v Steve Novick>That has very, very rarely happened.

571
01:07:17.021 --> 01:07:28.894
<v Steve Novick>So among the things that this ordinance does in addition to that, though, are to address concerns that people had primarily about— largely not about our proposed amendments, but about the existing law.

572
01:07:29.840 --> 01:07:49.547
<v Steve Novick>For one thing, Taran Patel of the Asian American Hotel Owners Association came to us and said that under current law, if a property owner calls up to report a crime on their property, that instance could be held against them as an instance leading to their being declared a nuisance property.

573
01:07:50.206 --> 01:08:04.005
<v Steve Novick>So we passed an amendment to address that that says that if somebody calls up to report a crime on their own property, that's— as long as they're cooperating and taking steps to make sure that the activity is abated, that's not going to be held against them.

574
01:08:04.744 --> 01:08:12.130
<v Steve Novick>Another thing that we did was we deleted from the Hmm.

575
01:08:12.438 --> 01:08:19.135
<v Steve Novick>As a nod to President Dunphy's reminding us that noise ordinance has been used in nefarious ways in the city.

576
01:08:20.520 --> 01:08:32.554
<v Steve Novick>We have several other amendments today in response to continuing conversations that are in one way or another sort of along the same lines, making sure that this, or that the chronic nuisance law is not abused.

577
01:08:34.038 --> 01:08:52.421
<v Steve Novick>I will say that one of the reasons that we brought this ordinance forward is that we have heard that students at McDaniel High School, which is in District 3, walk through a gauntlet of sex trafficking every day.

578
01:08:53.859 --> 01:09:03.105
<v Steve Novick>And so although this ordinance does not relate solely to sex trafficking or to the area around McDaniel High School, That was one of the motivating forces in our bringing this forward.

579
01:09:05.085 --> 01:09:09.454
<v Steve Novick>Now, it's important to note that this ordinance does not further criminalize sex work or sex workers.

580
01:09:10.051 --> 01:09:13.551
<v Steve Novick>It doesn't change the approach of the Human Trafficking Unit in their engagement with victims.

581
01:09:14.460 --> 01:09:16.980
<v Steve Novick>The police do not arrest victims of sex trafficking.

582
01:09:18.199 --> 01:09:20.759
<v Steve Novick>It doesn't reestablish any kind of prostitution-free zone.

583
01:09:21.471 --> 01:09:26.314
<v Steve Novick>And actually, one of the amendments that I'm bringing forward today would— Christopher talked about how— I think that's a good point.

584
01:09:27.069 --> 01:09:31.886
<v Steve Novick>The committee had added loitering to solicit prostitution as one of the nuisance activities.

585
01:09:32.320 --> 01:09:37.048
<v Steve Novick>We're proposing to delete that because that seems like something that goes after the victims.

586
01:09:37.177 --> 01:09:45.021
<v Steve Novick>So we're going to remove that and— but add some as nuisance activities, some human trafficking crimes listed in state code.

587
01:09:50.530 --> 01:09:53.728
<v Steve Novick>On— we heard a presentation on human trafficking at our January 23rd meeting.

588
01:09:54.351 --> 01:10:17.637
<v Steve Novick>We heard an alarming description of the problem both locally and nationally, including who is trafficked and how, how PPB and victim advocacy groups work to connect victims with resources while focusing arrests on buyers and traffickers, how resource strain requires the type of innovative approaches to reducing human trafficking that this tool represents, and again, how PPB considers this code to be a tool of last resort after outreach and requests to property owners have failed.

589
01:10:18.230 --> 01:10:37.909
<v Steve Novick>I'd like to ask Deputy DA J.R. Ujrafusa, who's here, to come forward and make a very brief statement good evening, Council President, Vice President.

590
01:10:37.909 --> 01:10:39.000
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is J.R. Ujifusa.

591
01:10:39.000 --> 01:10:41.479
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm with the Multnomah County District Attorney's Office.

592
01:10:41.529 --> 01:10:43.880
<v Unidentified speaker>I will try to be as brief as I can and give a little history.

593
01:10:44.289 --> 01:10:53.369
<v Unidentified speaker>As Councilor Novick mentioned, the average age of entry for victims of trafficking is between 13 and 15 years old.

594
01:10:53.369 --> 01:10:53.590
<v Unidentified speaker>The average age of entry is 13 to 15 years old.

595
01:10:54.063 --> 01:11:11.341
<v Unidentified speaker>That is backed up by a recent PSU study which identified over 400 local victims in our community, which they found the average age of seeking services was 15 and a half years old, which means that they were trafficked before seeking services for being a victim of trafficking.

596
01:11:12.335 --> 01:11:14.546
<v Unidentified speaker>These are the most vulnerable victims in our community.

597
01:11:15.461 --> 01:11:32.729
<v Unidentified speaker>There's an overrepresentation of children of color as well as individuals that are from the LGBTQ In the history of Portland, we— in 2007, the city allowed the prostitution-free zone to sunset.

598
01:11:33.756 --> 01:11:48.194
<v Unidentified speaker>In 2008, the street-level prostitution activity, human trafficking activity skyrocketed, skyrocketed until about 2012 when we saw Craigslist and backpage.com allow for the trafficking of human beings to move online.

599
01:11:48.323 --> 01:11:48.435
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

600
01:11:49.975 --> 01:11:56.805
<v Unidentified speaker>The online trafficking culture increased until 2018 when the FBI closed down backpage.com.

601
01:11:57.511 --> 01:12:09.506
<v Unidentified speaker>And what we saw in our community, as well as communities throughout the nation, is that the movement from online went back to the streets, back to motels, back to cars and street corners and sidewalks in our communities.

602
01:12:10.163 --> 01:12:15.167
<v Unidentified speaker>Most of the time, these were communities of color and underrepresented communities and vulnerable communities.

603
01:12:15.215 --> 01:12:15.359
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

604
01:12:16.970 --> 01:12:23.293
<v Unidentified speaker>What has changed though, as Councilor Novick said, is we are trauma-informed, victim-centered.

605
01:12:23.680 --> 01:12:34.805
<v Unidentified speaker>We have moved away from arresting and charging victims of trafficking and focusing on buyers, traffickers, and those who enable the trafficking, especially of children in our community.

606
01:12:36.896 --> 01:12:39.409
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a tool to combat human trafficking.

607
01:12:39.769 --> 01:12:41.873
<v Unidentified speaker>Human trafficking crimes are very dynamic.

608
01:12:43.560 --> 01:12:53.680
<v Unidentified speaker>It is the last resort for those who refuse or have been educated, who we've worked with in other ways to reduce trafficking and are enabling it to happen.

609
01:12:53.680 --> 01:12:58.359
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll be available for questions after if there are any questions from the councilors.

610
01:12:58.939 --> 01:13:00.960
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

611
01:13:00.960 --> 01:13:02.380
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Chair.

612
01:13:05.680 --> 01:13:08.760
<v Steve Novick>Mr. President, I see Councilor— I see that Councilor Kanal has his hand up.

613
01:13:08.760 --> 01:13:10.300
<v Steve Novick>I was just wondering if he's got a question for Deputy City Administrator Donnie Oliveira.

614
01:13:12.078 --> 01:13:13.704
<v Sameer Kanal>No, I had a question for Christopher Hare.

615
01:13:13.884 --> 01:13:14.372
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, okay.

616
01:13:14.583 --> 01:13:16.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>I apologize.

617
01:13:16.472 --> 01:13:17.466
<v Jamie Dunphy>Christopher, could you come back up?

618
01:13:24.340 --> 01:13:32.231
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for the, I think, longest, uh, committee staff summary we've ever had, uh, and appreciate your work on a very dynamic and large-scale conversation.

619
01:13:32.813 --> 01:13:37.770
<v Sameer Kanal>You said the word certain, and I will— it's the second to last bullet on the second Second to last page.

620
01:13:39.056 --> 01:13:48.823
<v Sameer Kanal>Concerns regarding profiling, increased police contact with certain communities, expanded law enforcement authority, and potential implications related to due process or surveillance.

621
01:13:49.292 --> 01:13:52.112
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just ask if you could speak to what the word certain means.

622
01:13:52.306 --> 01:13:54.104
<v Sameer Kanal>Which communities are we talking about?

623
01:13:56.859 --> 01:13:58.599
<v Christopher Hare>Yes, thank you for the question, Councilor.

624
01:13:59.694 --> 01:14:07.493
<v Christopher Hare>I believe that the testimony that centered around that A lot of it was specific to sex workers.

625
01:14:07.604 --> 01:14:18.411
<v Christopher Hare>And then also there was other testimony that was tied into that that had reference to what's going on with the federal government right now and our immigrant refugee community members.

626
01:14:18.667 --> 01:14:24.095
<v Christopher Hare>And so that increased surveillance and how the federal government could abuse that.

627
01:14:24.143 --> 01:14:27.965
<v Christopher Hare>And with that increased law enforcement, that distrust, just how that can affect those communities.

628
01:14:28.880 --> 01:14:29.136
<v Jack Dickinson>Thank you.

629
01:14:29.537 --> 01:14:29.810
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Of course.

630
01:14:31.269 --> 01:14:33.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knoll, and I apologize again about that.

631
01:14:34.234 --> 01:14:39.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick, did you also want to preview your amendments before public testimony?

632
01:14:39.780 --> 01:14:40.198
<v Steve Novick>I did.

633
01:14:40.582 --> 01:14:41.224
<v Keelan McClymont>Please.

634
01:14:41.465 --> 01:14:50.489
<v Steve Novick>And actually, even in your office suggested that we actually try to move the amendment and vote on the amendments before we get to public testimony, but I don't know whether— what your preference is.

635
01:14:50.987 --> 01:15:00.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that that is perfectly reasonable so that the public is testifying on the okay.

636
01:15:00.606 --> 01:15:16.743
<v Steve Novick>So one of the amendments, Novick 3, would be, as I previewed before, to remove from the nuisance activities loitering to solicit prostitution, because we think that that is a statute that appears to be focused on victims rather than traffickers.

637
01:15:18.369 --> 01:15:25.614
<v Steve Novick>And we would remove a reference to prostitution or related offenses as defined in ORS 167.007 through 167.008.

638
01:15:26.789 --> 01:15:27.127
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

639
01:15:27.949 --> 01:15:33.365
<v Steve Novick>But add human trafficking or related offenses as defined in other ORS provisions.

640
01:15:33.978 --> 01:15:37.905
<v Steve Novick>So those will now be designated as potential nuisance activities.

641
01:15:38.661 --> 01:15:40.461
<v Steve Novick>So that's, that's the Novick 3.

642
01:15:42.597 --> 01:16:05.274
<v Steve Novick>Novick 4 would sort of shift back from something that our initial— it relates to the amount of time that a property owner has to come up with a plan to address the nuisance and to negotiate that with the city and to actually abate the nuisance.

643
01:16:05.819 --> 01:16:16.128
<v Steve Novick>So in our— as we came out of committee, ours said that you had 30 days to respond to the initial— to come up with a plan and 60 days to abate the nuisance.

644
01:16:16.819 --> 01:16:34.858
<v Steve Novick>What Novick 4 would do is say that, first of all, that It would increase the timeline for the property owner to respond to the letter from 10 days to 14 days, and then leave 60 days to negotiate an abatement plan and 90 days to abate the activity itself.

645
01:16:36.960 --> 01:16:44.171
<v Steve Novick>So again, that's extend— Novick 5 would amend the list of abatement measures.

646
01:16:44.430 --> 01:16:59.417
<v Steve Novick>One thing that this proposal does is historically, The police can propose any number of abatement activities to the property owner, but we didn't have sort of a menu listed in code of these are some of the kind of things you might be asked to do.

647
01:17:00.045 --> 01:17:05.524
<v Steve Novick>So borrowing, I think, from Washington, D.C., we've added the list of these are the kind of things you might be asked to do.

648
01:17:06.150 --> 01:17:11.868
<v Steve Novick>And that's primarily intended to give the property owner an opportunity to say, okay, let me look at these.

649
01:17:12.046 --> 01:17:13.306
<v Steve Novick>Maybe we can improve lighting.

650
01:17:13.904 --> 01:17:27.539
<v Steve Novick>Maybe we can— Maybe we can do a better job of controlling entrances and exits to prevent unauthorized access, et cetera, et cetera.

651
01:17:28.265 --> 01:17:40.470
<v Steve Novick>We propose adding to abatement measurage possibilities a list of activities you could do to prevent or reduce illegal activity.

652
01:17:40.551 --> 01:17:41.086
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

653
01:17:41.712 --> 01:17:46.865
<v Steve Novick>This is specifically, you know, to address victims of human trafficking.

654
01:17:48.373 --> 01:17:51.112
<v Steve Novick>Engagement with service providers and advocacy groups.

655
01:17:51.354 --> 01:17:55.381
<v Steve Novick>Work with peer-led groups, including on-property visits, to increase availability of resources.

656
01:17:56.100 --> 01:18:02.715
<v Steve Novick>Post and make available information about resources for victims, including support groups, advocate information, and the National Human Trafficking Hotline.

657
01:18:03.230 --> 01:18:06.313
<v Steve Novick>Have staff training programs to educate employees on identifying victims.

658
01:18:06.417 --> 01:18:06.676
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

659
01:18:07.287 --> 01:18:09.644
<v Steve Novick>So we want to add that to the list of potential abatement activities.

660
01:18:11.970 --> 01:18:29.601
<v Steve Novick>Another thing that we wanted to add to the abatement list is current code says that the court, if the court is going to impose conditions on the property owner, has to consider a variety of factors, one of which is the financial capacity of the property owner to do what the court's asking to do.

661
01:18:31.122 --> 01:18:36.268
<v Steve Novick>That current code does not say that the city needs to consider the same factors in proposing abatement measures.

662
01:18:36.887 --> 01:18:46.233
<v Steve Novick>So it would simply add language saying, in determining what abatement measures should be included in the agreement, the city administrator or the designee should consider the same factors required of the court.

663
01:18:46.636 --> 01:18:55.496
<v Steve Novick>Finally, Novick 6 addresses another issue that actually Councilor Pirtle-Guiney identified in the existing law.

664
01:18:57.086 --> 01:19:07.658
<v Steve Novick>The existing law says that initiating the process to declare a property nuisance property It doesn't say what the police reports have to say.

665
01:19:07.833 --> 01:19:14.810
<v Steve Novick>And Councilor Pirtle-Guiney noted, wait a minute, what if the police report reports an unfounded allegation by a grumpy neighbor with a vendetta?

666
01:19:15.692 --> 01:19:27.815
<v Steve Novick>Now, I don't think that the city has relied on such reports with such allegations in the past, but we thought that it was worth changing the language to say police reports or other official documentation.

667
01:19:27.881 --> 01:19:28.168
<v Steve Novick>That's a good point.

668
01:19:28.682 --> 01:19:37.435
<v Steve Novick>That a police officer has determined that probable cause exists to believe a nuisance activity has occurred, which should eliminate the unfounded allegations of a grumpy neighbor.

669
01:19:38.078 --> 01:19:49.368
<v Steve Novick>So those are my proposed amendments, and I want to turn it over, if I may, to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney to, to talk about her proposed amendments, please.

670
01:19:50.429 --> 01:19:52.934
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Novick, and thank you, Council President.

671
01:19:53.399 --> 01:19:59.743
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I want to start just by thanking Thank you, Councilor Novick and others who've worked on these improvements to the Chronic Nuisance Code.

672
01:20:00.725 --> 01:20:04.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have 2 amendments that I will be offering today.

673
01:20:05.335 --> 01:20:16.103
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is Pirtle-Guiney 1, which I'd like to speak to, but I may not move because the content is also captured in Novick 6, and I prefer the way that Councilor Novick has put it forward.

674
01:20:17.670 --> 01:20:21.726
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I do want to talk about a piece of that because it's a piece, Councilor, that you didn't mention about Novick 6.

675
01:20:21.774 --> 01:20:21.823
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay.

676
01:20:22.126 --> 01:20:38.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I understand that Councilor Novick's underlying ordinance loosens the complaint threshold in 2 ways, by changing the window for complaints and reducing the number of complaints that constitute a chronic nuisance.

677
01:20:39.222 --> 01:20:40.530
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I support the movement of the timeline.

678
01:20:40.595 --> 01:20:46.377
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A nuisance pattern should certainly be measured over the course of months, not the course of a single month.

679
01:20:47.037 --> 01:20:50.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I do worry that if we move the complaint threshold from 3 to 2, that the window for complaints will be too short.

680
01:20:50.238 --> 01:20:50.658
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Novick.

681
01:20:51.262 --> 01:21:00.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We put too low a barrier forward, which could lead to frivolous complaints that, while technically qualify under the code, don't actually establish a pattern of nuisance.

682
01:21:01.445 --> 01:21:12.655
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We heard from the testimony in committee and the overview today that systems like this have been historically applied unfairly and in biased ways, particularly around race in the past.

683
01:21:13.153 --> 01:21:21.831
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think the movement to 2 as opposed to 3 reports gets us in a situation where there is too much risk of that.

684
01:21:22.296 --> 01:21:26.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So Pirtle-Guiney 1 moves us back to that threshold of 3.

685
01:21:26.547 --> 01:21:31.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's also captured in Novick 6, which includes the other language Councilor Novick went over.

686
01:21:31.761 --> 01:21:34.761
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I prefer that, but if that doesn't pass, I'll move Pirtle-Guiney 1.

687
01:21:35.997 --> 01:21:48.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Pirtle-Guiney 3, which unfortunately what's posted online is Pirtle-Guiney 2, and after some additional conversations Today with the sponsor of the measure, we replaced Pirtle-Guiney 2 with Pirtle-Guiney 3.

688
01:21:48.712 --> 01:21:53.956
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, Pirtle-Guiney 3 is in your inboxes, but it came in too late to be posted by the clerk.

689
01:21:54.100 --> 01:21:56.896
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know, Keelan, if we're able to get that up for folks who are watching.

690
01:21:56.962 --> 01:21:57.494
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that possible?

691
01:21:58.479 --> 01:21:58.899
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

692
01:22:00.614 --> 01:22:02.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pirtle-Guiney 3 does 2 small things.

693
01:22:03.591 --> 01:22:16.409
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It clarifies that when the— it clarifies that the response clock for respondents to a concern begins after the property owner has received notice.

694
01:22:17.228 --> 01:22:28.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's important to me that we are providing both true due process to an individual who has a nuisance complaint against them, as well as a true opportunity for response.

695
01:22:29.148 --> 01:22:32.117
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We want to make sure individuals have their full clock to respond.

696
01:22:33.015 --> 01:22:55.538
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Additionally, it provides some clarification and additional language to increase the chances that we actually get that notice to the individual who owns that nuisance property so that they have their full opportunity for response, so that we are doing our due diligence to give them their due process and their opportunity.

697
01:22:56.213 --> 01:23:22.904
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We add language to a paragraph that includes the words and a further paragraph in that section, we are adding language which says if the person in charge is not present at the address where service is attempted, um, but an employee of the person in charge is, service may be made on the employee with the request to provide it to the person in charge.

698
01:23:23.563 --> 01:23:27.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In addition, if the ownership document for the property lists an alternative mailing address, the notice may be made on that address.

699
01:23:27.574 --> 01:23:27.719
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

700
01:23:28.216 --> 01:23:36.662
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are trying to ensure that we meet a person at the address of the nuisance property.

701
01:23:37.466 --> 01:23:52.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If they are not there at any other addresses of properties that we know that they own, if we cannot find them there, that we are mailing it as well so that, again, that owner has the opportunity to respond and engage with the city before we take any actions against them.

702
01:23:52.863 --> 01:23:53.136
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

703
01:23:53.682 --> 01:24:05.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and Council President, I don't know if this is the appropriate time, but if it is, I would be interested in moving, uh, Novick 3, 4, 5, and 6 and Pirtle-Guiney 3.

704
01:24:06.689 --> 01:24:07.555
<v Jamie Dunphy>As a package?

705
01:24:08.840 --> 01:24:10.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, is that what you—.

706
01:24:10.927 --> 01:24:11.167
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

707
01:24:11.666 --> 01:24:15.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, as package, 3, 4, 5, 6, and Pirtle-Guiney 3.

708
01:24:16.097 --> 01:24:16.451
<v Steve Novick>Second.

709
01:24:17.109 --> 01:24:18.779
<v Jamie Dunphy>There we go, colleagues.

710
01:24:19.997 --> 01:24:22.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is a package of amendments before us.

711
01:24:23.154 --> 01:24:25.668
<v Jamie Dunphy>We move to technical or clarifying questions.

712
01:24:26.743 --> 01:24:30.828
<v Jamie Dunphy>First, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, are you— anything first?

713
01:24:31.149 --> 01:24:31.597
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think so.

714
01:24:31.694 --> 01:24:32.063
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, good.

715
01:24:32.110 --> 01:24:32.703
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just want to make sure.

716
01:24:33.792 --> 01:24:34.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

717
01:24:34.162 --> 01:24:35.891
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're moving into technical or clarifying questions.

718
01:24:35.956 --> 01:24:37.333
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

719
01:24:38.600 --> 01:24:38.872
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

720
01:24:39.561 --> 01:24:46.274
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, this is a question for you on the— I was just wondering what the basis was for changing it from 2 to 3.

721
01:24:46.372 --> 01:24:54.828
<v Angelita Morillo>3, Um, or, uh, I, I feel like 2 maybe was also arbitrary in the original code, but I'm just curious if there was any reason for that.

722
01:24:55.520 --> 01:24:55.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

723
01:24:56.064 --> 01:25:04.363
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe the original code was 3, and the amend— the, the ordinance that Councilor Novick brought forward lowered it to 2.

724
01:25:04.570 --> 01:25:09.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what I am asking is that we move it back to the 3 that was in the original code.

725
01:25:10.509 --> 01:25:18.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, 2 in my mind felt like Something happened, your neighbor didn't like it, it happens again, they complain.

726
01:25:19.336 --> 01:25:20.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That may not be a pattern.

727
01:25:20.796 --> 01:25:26.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You might have a cousin who comes over and causes a disruption, and you tell them to go away, and they come over again a month later.

728
01:25:26.975 --> 01:25:27.875
<v Keelan McClymont>Mm-hmm.

729
01:25:28.099 --> 01:25:35.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>By 3, we can start to expect that you are addressing whatever that concern is more realistically.

730
01:25:37.070 --> 01:25:38.322
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That is what is in the code now.

731
01:25:39.172 --> 01:25:47.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't have any reason to believe that that hasn't been working in the letters that I've gotten from constituents about this.

732
01:25:47.265 --> 01:25:49.288
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I haven't heard anybody say raise it above 3.

733
01:25:50.171 --> 01:25:52.467
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So returning to the original was my intent there.

734
01:25:53.222 --> 01:25:54.283
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, that's helpful.

735
01:25:55.551 --> 01:26:01.106
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it feels— some of this, the metrics here feel a little bit arbitrary.

736
01:26:01.171 --> 01:26:21.703
<v Angelita Morillo>And to me, the part that feels arbitrary is the when we're talking about a police report, and I think the amendments improve what's here, but the thing that concerns me about the police report is that instead of it being a completed documented offense, it just is a required report.

737
01:26:22.298 --> 01:26:27.393
<v Angelita Morillo>And so that could be an attempt or conspiracy, or it could just be a written report.

738
01:26:27.440 --> 01:26:34.027
<v Angelita Morillo>That doesn't necessarily mean that they were like found guilty, but maybe I'm reading it wrong.

739
01:26:34.220 --> 01:26:35.746
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't know if you want to speak to that, Councilor Novick.

740
01:26:35.859 --> 01:26:36.677
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm just trying to understand it.

741
01:26:37.578 --> 01:26:44.970
<v Steve Novick>Yes, the reference to a police report is in the existing law, and it does not require that there be like an actual conviction of an offense.

742
01:26:46.779 --> 01:26:50.280
<v Steve Novick>So that's what's in the existing law.

743
01:26:50.909 --> 01:26:57.341
<v Steve Novick>What we are saying in the proposed amendment is that it shouldn't just— we should make sure that it's not just a grumpy neighbor complaining.

744
01:26:58.042 --> 01:27:04.909
<v Steve Novick>That it should be— an officer has made a determination that probable cause exists to believe that an offense has occurred.

745
01:27:05.823 --> 01:27:15.466
<v Steve Novick>And then if this winds up going to court, then the rules there say that the court must find by a preponderance of the evidence that an offense actually has occurred.

746
01:27:15.627 --> 01:27:19.043
<v Steve Novick>So it's sort of the way law enforcement normally works in a way.

747
01:27:20.021 --> 01:27:20.198
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

748
01:27:21.048 --> 01:27:23.503
<v Angelita Morillo>And you've worked a lot with the DA's office.

749
01:27:23.777 --> 01:27:36.842
<v Angelita Morillo>I assume that they are saying that they're going to be taking on these additional well, initially the DA isn't involved.

750
01:27:36.891 --> 01:27:40.916
<v Steve Novick>I mean, initially it's a discussion between the city and the property owner.

751
01:27:42.029 --> 01:27:48.703
<v Steve Novick>There's not a heck of a lot of cases that actually go to court, but I'd like to ask JR to give his thoughts on that question.

752
01:27:50.909 --> 01:27:51.628
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening again.

753
01:27:52.412 --> 01:27:53.181
<v Unidentified speaker>That is correct.

754
01:27:53.377 --> 01:27:54.604
<v Unidentified speaker>This is not something where the DA is involved.

755
01:27:54.936 --> 01:28:00.398
<v Unidentified speaker>The DA's office will be doing the same thing we always do, which is the human trafficking team will be investigating human trafficking.

756
01:28:00.912 --> 01:28:17.516
<v Unidentified speaker>By doing that, if we identify that there are properties or individuals who are enabling that trafficking, then this is an option to start to work with those businesses or property owners to fix that enabling.

757
01:28:17.630 --> 01:28:23.264
<v Unidentified speaker>But this doesn't add anything to the DA's office as far as charges or cases.

758
01:28:23.311 --> 01:28:27.851
<v Unidentified speaker>This would be a civil case that the city would do if it went all the way to the end.

759
01:28:28.304 --> 01:28:35.057
<v Unidentified speaker>The beginning is just a letter saying we've noticed this and we'd like your help and to, to abate this, and here are some suggestions.

760
01:28:39.773 --> 01:28:40.899
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, I will pause for now.

761
01:28:40.979 --> 01:28:41.365
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

762
01:28:42.266 --> 01:28:43.055
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

763
01:28:43.231 --> 01:28:43.842
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Connell.

764
01:28:44.904 --> 01:28:45.050
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

765
01:28:45.097 --> 01:28:49.472
<v Sameer Kanal>I have a technical question first and then one other comment, and it's for Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

766
01:28:50.922 --> 01:28:52.782
<v Sameer Kanal>Just then, this might be 2-part.

767
01:28:52.845 --> 01:29:01.594
<v Sameer Kanal>For Pirtle-Guiney 3, what is the distinction here between the highlighted text and the fullness of the red paragraph at the bottom?

768
01:29:01.722 --> 01:29:06.625
<v Sameer Kanal>Is the red paragraph new, or is that change Councilor Novick's, and then yours is just the yellow highlight?

769
01:29:07.362 --> 01:29:09.284
<v Olivia Clark>So the red paragraph—.

770
01:29:09.814 --> 01:29:21.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize, I, I was trying to differentiate between Pirtle-Guiney 2 and Pirtle-Guiney 3, which is the replacement, since I had assumed folks might have read 2 in advance and then we dropped 3 on you last minute.

771
01:29:21.694 --> 01:29:21.918
<v Sameer Kanal>Got it.

772
01:29:21.966 --> 01:29:27.650
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So the red part that is not crossed off replaces the red part that is crossed off.

773
01:29:27.939 --> 01:29:29.337
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All of that is an amendment.

774
01:29:29.722 --> 01:29:34.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The highlighted portion is just the change from 2 to 3.

775
01:29:35.020 --> 01:29:43.498
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if you previously looked at the amendment I had filed, Pirtle-Guiney 2, you would have seen the red that is not crossed off without the highlighted portion.

776
01:29:44.157 --> 01:29:47.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Highlighted portion is now added in Pirtle-Guiney 3.

777
01:29:48.006 --> 01:29:51.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All of that is the new text and replaces what is crossed off here.

778
01:29:52.046 --> 01:29:52.448
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

779
01:29:53.170 --> 01:29:57.997
<v Sameer Kanal>So my question then is about, I guess, the highlighted portion here.

780
01:29:58.462 --> 01:29:58.525
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

781
01:29:58.605 --> 01:30:06.463
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to note that when you presented this, you— when you combined the 2, you said that the intent was to ensure that the business owner would have the fullness of the time.

782
01:30:07.265 --> 01:30:22.481
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I want to understand how that is how that happens when the clock starts when an employee gets a document, but not when the business owner or manager gets the document, and how there's any guarantee that that information is communicated.

783
01:30:23.252 --> 01:30:25.595
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So Pirtle-Guiney 3 actually does 2 things.

784
01:30:25.644 --> 01:30:33.235
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if you look at the top portion of Pirtle-Guiney 3, under A3, there is a highlighted portion that says of delivery of the notice.

785
01:30:33.284 --> 01:30:39.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So instead of demand that the person in charge respond within 14 days, To the city administrator.

786
01:30:39.551 --> 01:30:43.713
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It now says within 14 days of delivery of the notice to the city administrator.

787
01:30:44.195 --> 01:30:59.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was concerned before that that could be 14 days of printing the notice, and then somebody holds on to it for 3 days, you don't see them, you go again, you try to find them a second time, suddenly there's 5 days left for them to respond.

788
01:30:59.645 --> 01:31:02.217
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So this says 14 days of delivery of the notice.

789
01:31:02.395 --> 01:31:04.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then with the second portion of this amendment, Yes.

790
01:31:05.386 --> 01:31:15.703
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rather than attempting to deliver— actually, rather than delivering the notice to the address of the nuisance property, and if you'd like, you can mail it as well.

791
01:31:16.457 --> 01:31:27.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What we are saying is you attempt to deliver it to the notice of the nuisance property or such other place which is likely to give the person in charge notice of the determination.

792
01:31:27.287 --> 01:31:31.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if there is another address you know for them, to attempt to deliver it in person there.

793
01:31:32.259 --> 01:31:42.010
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you cannot find them at either address, then you can leave it with an employee and mail it to any other additional addresses that you have on file.

794
01:31:42.635 --> 01:31:45.426
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So there is still a hole here.

795
01:31:46.051 --> 01:31:53.813
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is still a hole that if you cannot find this person, you leave it with an employee and they don't pass it along.

796
01:31:54.966 --> 01:31:57.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What I was trying to do here Councilor Smith.

797
01:31:57.132 --> 01:32:31.510
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The reason that we were in favor in adding the second attempt at hand delivery and the requirement that it's then mailed, as opposed to just an attempt, a single attempt at hand delivery and then the option of mailing it, was to say that we need to try every way that we have to reach somebody while also recognizing that using our police time to go to a business 40 times to try to deliver this is probably not a good use of our resources and at a certain point is predictably futile.

798
01:32:32.554 --> 01:32:52.878
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So this is admittedly still leaving a hole there, but my attempt at finding where that balance point might be between every reasonable attempt to close that hole and the point at which we really just are not going to okay, so that opened up—.

799
01:32:52.878 --> 01:32:53.671
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for that clarity.

800
01:32:53.734 --> 01:33:05.127
<v Sameer Kanal>That opened up one thing that we should talk about later, which is I think the way the first one's written implies the notice is being delivered to the city administrator or their designee, and I think that's not your intent from how you just explained it.

801
01:33:05.545 --> 01:33:09.475
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just think it's kind of weird wording, and so I'd love to get some clarity on that.

802
01:33:09.992 --> 01:33:11.261
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the other question I had is—.

803
01:33:11.261 --> 01:33:13.256
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There needs to be 2 commas there to create a clause.

804
01:33:13.578 --> 01:33:14.043
<v Sameer Kanal>Exactly.

805
01:33:14.525 --> 01:33:16.435
<v Sameer Kanal>The other question is, what constitutes an employee?

806
01:33:17.014 --> 01:33:21.077
<v Sameer Kanal>And the reason I ask this is very specific, that these are— many of these properties are family-run.

807
01:33:22.072 --> 01:33:30.068
<v Sameer Kanal>And as someone who had a father who had a small business and worked there, I was an employee, but not everybody is.

808
01:33:30.967 --> 01:33:33.921
<v Sameer Kanal>Are people's spouses who are covering the front desk, those sorts of things?

809
01:33:34.420 --> 01:33:37.341
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to understand what constitutes an employee.

810
01:33:40.760 --> 01:33:49.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, Council President, Councilor Novick, I think we may need to look to how that is defined elsewhere in statute.

811
01:33:49.083 --> 01:33:55.256
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think it's defined in this part of the statute, but I believe there is very likely some legal precedent we could turn to there.

812
01:33:56.493 --> 01:33:59.204
<v Steve Novick>And frankly, Councilor, that was my suggestion.

813
01:33:59.787 --> 01:34:07.988
<v Steve Novick>And what I was thinking of was like whoever's working the front desk, and you're right, Maybe it wouldn't be an employee.

814
01:34:08.621 --> 01:34:21.143
<v Steve Novick>But so I'm open to some other description, maybe to a person present at the— a person working at the property.

815
01:34:22.930 --> 01:34:34.948
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I think part of the challenge here, and we'll talk about this when we get into the actual debate on it, is that these— you'd be looking at someone who is determining whether or not this is a person that constitutes a substitute.

816
01:34:35.814 --> 01:34:42.578
<v Sameer Kanal>And that is more discretion being given, and that heightens all the concerns that we talked about in, in the committee.

817
01:34:42.643 --> 01:34:44.037
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think it's worth exploring.

818
01:34:44.951 --> 01:34:51.411
<v Sameer Kanal>The last thing I wanted to say is I would strenuously object to any consideration and vote on these amendments before the public has had their say.

819
01:34:51.859 --> 01:35:06.654
<v Sameer Kanal>And in fact, due to the sheer magnitude of these amendments, would love to have some discussion after after testimony, but before we get into the amendments on whether or not we should even be doing this here or referring it back to the committee.

820
01:35:07.800 --> 01:35:17.521
<v Sameer Kanal>So, but I, there is no practice that we have had of not hearing from the public before non-sponsor amendments and even many of the sponsor amendments.

821
01:35:18.277 --> 01:35:18.518
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

822
01:35:19.563 --> 01:35:20.318
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

823
01:35:22.390 --> 01:35:24.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the package of amendments has been moved.

824
01:35:24.447 --> 01:35:24.993
<v Jamie Dunphy>I actually agree.

825
01:35:25.090 --> 01:35:26.586
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would, they are on the table.

826
01:35:26.637 --> 01:35:33.742
<v Jamie Dunphy>They're available for the public to respond to, I would like to move to testimony first before we come back for further debate and vote on the amendments.

827
01:35:35.126 --> 01:35:40.252
<v Jamie Dunphy>If that's— any further technical or clarifying questions, colleagues?

828
01:35:42.438 --> 01:35:44.434
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call up any public testimony?

829
01:35:45.501 --> 01:35:47.247
<v Keelan McClymont>We have 12 people signed up tonight.

830
01:35:47.523 --> 01:36:11.996
<v Jamie Dunphy>First up, we have Holly Brown, Kanan Patel, Robin Miller, Chelsea Passon, any of those folks are here or online, you're welcome to come on up as a, as a panel or a group, or whomever's here first gets to go first.

831
01:36:15.568 --> 01:36:15.907
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

832
01:36:15.987 --> 01:36:17.404
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please introduce yourself for the record.

833
01:36:18.225 --> 01:36:20.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Good evening, honored members of this council.

834
01:36:20.078 --> 01:36:21.833
<v Keelan McClymont>My name is Chelsea Passon.

835
01:36:22.091 --> 01:36:23.422
<v Keelan McClymont>My pronouns are she/they.

836
01:36:24.957 --> 01:36:29.960
<v Keelan McClymont>I am a survivor of almost a decade of commercial sexual exploitation and human trafficking.

837
01:36:30.904 --> 01:36:39.402
<v Keelan McClymont>I now serve our community at Safety Compass, a local nonprofit providing confidential advocacy and crisis response to survivors like myself.

838
01:36:40.604 --> 01:36:52.713
<v Keelan McClymont>I have personally spoken with hundreds of survivors and lived experience experts, some of whom are actively engaging in the commercial sex industry and some who were lucky enough to retire from the industry.

839
01:36:54.369 --> 01:36:59.930
<v Keelan McClymont>Overwhelmingly, our stories are ones of violence and oppression, not of empowerment.

840
01:37:01.970 --> 01:37:05.949
<v Keelan McClymont>I would like to take a moment to acknowledge the privilege I have in being able to speak here today.

841
01:37:06.514 --> 01:37:15.260
<v Keelan McClymont>I have the inherent privilege of being a light-skinned person, in having my basic needs met, and in having the choice to offer testimony in front of this council.

842
01:37:16.792 --> 01:37:26.197
<v Keelan McClymont>As we talk about bridging the gap of a law that already exists to become a more effective tool for safety, I invite everyone in this room to consider your own privilege.

843
01:37:28.149 --> 01:37:51.689
<v Keelan McClymont>Now I want you to consider that at this very moment as we speak, there is someone, probably many someones, stuck in a hotel room on 82nd Avenue who is unable to leave or eat or even sleep until they meet their quota for making as much money as they can through the exchange of commercial sex, commercial sex acts.

844
01:37:53.859 --> 01:38:01.375
<v Keelan McClymont>I hope no one else in this room ever has to experience the feeling that comes from the commodification of one's body for another person's pleasure.

845
01:38:02.497 --> 01:38:06.698
<v Keelan McClymont>However, if that is something that resonates, you are not alone, and I offer you my solidarity.

846
01:38:08.449 --> 01:38:20.909
<v Keelan McClymont>The responsibility of managing the safety of the city falls to our leaders, and if a law that was intended to create pathways to safety is ineffective, the responsibility to make adjustments falls upon this council.

847
01:38:22.179 --> 01:38:31.363
<v Keelan McClymont>As you consider what adjusting this law means, I beg you to consider those most marginalized and vulnerable who do not have the privilege to be in this room today.

848
01:38:31.411 --> 01:38:45.845
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilmember I ask this council to please make the tools that interrupt an industry that profits from the commodification and harm of others actually effective and amend Code Chapter 14B-60.

849
01:38:45.957 --> 01:38:53.162
<v Keelan McClymont>In an anti-violence movement that faces so much pushback because of a violent industry's profitability, it is the least that can be done.

850
01:38:53.939 --> 01:38:54.184
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

851
01:38:55.110 --> 01:38:56.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here.

852
01:38:58.037 --> 01:38:59.895
<v Keelan McClymont>Robin Miller is joining us online.

853
01:39:00.996 --> 01:39:02.171
<v Steve Novick>Mr. President, I apologize.

854
01:39:02.283 --> 01:39:09.470
<v Steve Novick>Representative Tran is available to testify remotely, and we normally often give electeds a privilege to testify early.

855
01:39:09.551 --> 01:39:13.394
<v Steve Novick>So after the next witness, I would ask that we go to her.

856
01:39:13.570 --> 01:39:17.333
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would be happy to have Representative Tran after Robin finishes hers.

857
01:39:18.155 --> 01:39:19.280
<v Robin Miller>Hi, thank you.

858
01:39:19.360 --> 01:39:20.613
<v Robin Miller>Hi, my name is Robin Miller.

859
01:39:21.047 --> 01:39:29.109
<v Robin Miller>I'm here tonight as a survivor of commercial sexual exploitation or prostitution, and I'm here to speak in support of Portland City Code 14B-1.

860
01:39:29.971 --> 01:39:36.094
<v Robin Miller>This ordinance isn't just necessary, it is lawful, and it is long overdue.

861
01:39:36.655 --> 01:39:39.853
<v Robin Miller>I'm not speaking in theory, I'm speaking from lived experience.

862
01:39:40.414 --> 01:39:43.002
<v Robin Miller>I was bought and sold on 82nd Avenue in Portland.

863
01:39:43.146 --> 01:39:44.784
<v Robin Miller>I was raped on 82nd.

864
01:39:44.833 --> 01:39:45.444
<v Robin Miller>I was beaten.

865
01:39:45.782 --> 01:39:47.676
<v Robin Miller>I lived under constant control and threat.

866
01:39:48.304 --> 01:39:56.176
<v Robin Miller>I was moved up and down 82nd through motels, places where everyone knew what was happening and where no one intervened.

867
01:39:56.225 --> 01:39:56.337
<v Robin Miller>Thank you.

868
01:39:57.043 --> 01:39:59.981
<v Robin Miller>These motels were not just and are not just neutral spaces.

869
01:40:00.158 --> 01:40:03.322
<v Robin Miller>They're hubs of exploitation, and they're places where my life was at risk.

870
01:40:04.091 --> 01:40:10.033
<v Robin Miller>And I'm also an advocate, and I've been serving victims and survivors of trafficking for 12 years, countless.

871
01:40:10.354 --> 01:40:12.233
<v Robin Miller>And I would say the same for them.

872
01:40:13.436 --> 01:40:16.890
<v Robin Miller>So when we talk about nuisance properties, let's be honest about what that means.

873
01:40:17.097 --> 01:40:21.899
<v Robin Miller>We're talking about locations where exploitation is allowed to flourish, where systems fail to interact.

874
01:40:22.155 --> 01:40:26.320
<v Robin Miller>Violence, and that violence is predictable, patterned, and preventable.

875
01:40:27.202 --> 01:40:34.219
<v Robin Miller>I often hear— we keep hearing this argument that it's going to— passing this ordinance will push the sex trade somewhere else, somewhere more dangerous.

876
01:40:34.747 --> 01:40:37.728
<v Robin Miller>And I'm wondering, I can't figure it out, where is this somewhere else?

877
01:40:37.792 --> 01:40:39.250
<v Robin Miller>Where is this more dangerous place?

878
01:40:40.179 --> 01:40:45.865
<v Robin Miller>More dangerous than being trafficked in plain sight in known locations where violence is normalized and profits are protected?

879
01:40:46.523 --> 01:40:52.738
<v Robin Miller>More dangerous than motels where buyers come and go all night, where women are isolated behind closed doors, and where no one is accountable?

880
01:40:54.136 --> 01:40:57.554
<v Robin Miller>The reality is exploitation already happens in dangerous places.

881
01:40:57.987 --> 01:41:04.101
<v Robin Miller>This ordinance does not create danger; it disrupts it—the conditions that allow it to continue to go unchecked.

882
01:41:04.872 --> 01:41:07.184
<v Robin Miller>What this ordinance does is create accountability.

883
01:41:07.537 --> 01:41:13.073
<v Robin Miller>It says that property owners and those connected with the spaces cannot keep ignoring repeated harm.

884
01:41:13.716 --> 01:41:18.225
<v Robin Miller>Gives the city a tool to intervene when patterns of exploitation are clearly established.

885
01:41:18.483 --> 01:41:21.885
<v Robin Miller>Let's be clear: nothing doing nothing is not neutral.

886
01:41:22.800 --> 01:41:26.585
<v Robin Miller>Doing nothing protects the status quo, and the status quo is violence.

887
01:41:28.060 --> 01:41:30.676
<v Robin Miller>One second, you guys.

888
01:41:30.739 --> 01:41:31.333
<v Robin Miller>I'm shaking.

889
01:41:31.510 --> 01:41:32.552
<v Robin Miller>I don't ever shake like this.

890
01:41:33.033 --> 01:41:45.096
<v Robin Miller>This ordinance will not solve everything, but it's a step toward interrupting systems that have allowed people like me to be hurt and the people I serve to be hurt over and over and over again in the same locations with no consequence.

891
01:41:45.561 --> 01:42:02.145
<v Robin Miller>I stood out in front, out above a hotel lobby In the '90s, after a man tried to kill me, I ran from the room without my clothes on and screamed fire fire fire fire because I knew no one would come if I screamed rape or help me.

892
01:42:02.932 --> 01:42:06.708
<v Robin Miller>The owners of the motel or the managers came out and they saw me and they looked at me.

893
01:42:07.431 --> 01:42:08.912
<v Robin Miller>The man left, but they did nothing.

894
01:42:11.636 --> 01:42:11.998
<v Robin Miller>I serve.

895
01:42:12.148 --> 01:42:14.176
<v Robin Miller>I see women and girls coming out of the same motel.

896
01:42:15.478 --> 01:42:27.416
<v Robin Miller>Today when I'm on driving on that street, Portland has, has an opportunity to act, to say that repeated exploitation is not expect— not acceptable and not invisible.

897
01:42:27.578 --> 01:42:28.518
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for your testimony.

898
01:42:30.778 --> 01:42:32.369
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Representative Tran, please go ahead.

899
01:42:33.431 --> 01:42:39.462
<v Steve Novick>Uh, good evening, Council President Dunphy, Council Vice President Clark, and members of the council.

900
01:42:39.864 --> 01:42:54.672
<v Steve Novick>For the record, I am State Representative I represent the students of McDaniel High School and the residents of Sumner, Parkrose, Roseway, and Madison South neighborhoods.

901
01:42:55.332 --> 01:43:05.623
<v Steve Novick>I come here today to stand with human trafficking advocates from across our city who are demanding that we finally stop looking the other way.

902
01:43:06.828 --> 01:43:18.551
<v Steve Novick>This past month, last month— well, this month, the Oregon Senate unanimously passed House Bill 4157 to support trafficking victims, sending it to the governor's desk.

903
01:43:19.001 --> 01:43:28.078
<v Steve Novick>This state-level work is a direct response to the incredible activism of survivors who are now fighting for the freedom of others.

904
01:43:29.024 --> 01:43:40.435
<v Steve Novick>During our committee hearing, a survivor shared a haunting story of being repeatedly assaulted and purchased in full view of the staff at the hotel near McDaniel High School.

905
01:43:41.077 --> 01:43:46.231
<v Steve Novick>This hotel is still in business today on Northeast 82nd Avenue.

906
01:43:46.777 --> 01:43:58.787
<v Steve Novick>We must be better leaders for our children, both for those being trafficked and for those who simply want to walk to school without witnessing human rights violations.

907
01:43:58.884 --> 01:43:59.029
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

908
01:43:59.686 --> 01:44:04.436
<v Steve Novick>The legislation we passed in Salem gives victims a voice in court.

909
01:44:05.158 --> 01:44:12.140
<v Steve Novick>The amendment before you today gives our neighborhoods and students a voice in their own backyard.

910
01:44:13.023 --> 01:44:21.689
<v Steve Novick>To be clear, this nuisance code update is not a magic wand that will solve every facet of human trafficking.

911
01:44:22.251 --> 01:44:23.904
<v Steve Novick>It is a surgical tool.

912
01:44:24.337 --> 01:44:26.149
<v Steve Novick>It is designed to address thank you, Mayor.

913
01:44:26.198 --> 01:44:42.815
<v Steve Novick>This ordinance seeks to address blatant, violent, illicit activity, crimes that often involve minors, by holding property owners accountable for what they allow to happen under their roofs and very close to their property.

914
01:44:43.712 --> 01:44:48.664
<v Steve Novick>I want to directly address the concern regarding equity and potential overreach.

915
01:44:49.322 --> 01:44:51.868
<v Steve Novick>This is not an attack on hotel owners.

916
01:44:52.542 --> 01:44:59.006
<v Steve Novick>Nor is it intended to displace the housing insecure or target consensual sex workers.

917
01:45:00.483 --> 01:45:06.225
<v Steve Novick>I recognize these questions of whether it could be used to target minority-owned businesses.

918
01:45:06.819 --> 01:45:10.315
<v Steve Novick>Every law carries the potential for misuse.

919
01:45:10.748 --> 01:45:22.266
<v Steve Novick>However, the mechanism to prevent overreach is not to vote down focused, vital legislation, as I believe this is this mechanism.

920
01:45:22.764 --> 01:45:24.337
<v Steve Novick>Is you, the council?

921
01:45:24.930 --> 01:45:25.988
<v Steve Novick>It is your staff.

922
01:45:26.085 --> 01:45:26.887
<v Steve Novick>It is the mayor.

923
01:45:26.967 --> 01:45:28.395
<v Steve Novick>It is the police chief.

924
01:45:28.475 --> 01:45:36.337
<v Steve Novick>It is other city leaders like myself, our constituents, and those who might be speaking in opposition today.

925
01:45:36.802 --> 01:45:45.225
<v Steve Novick>It is our collective responsibility to ensure this tool is never used to unfairly target the vulnerable.

926
01:45:45.722 --> 01:45:55.378
<v Steve Novick>We cannot let a hypothetical risk prevent us from taking necessary steps to rescue those being trafficked in our city today.

927
01:45:55.869 --> 01:45:56.377
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

928
01:45:57.246 --> 01:45:58.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Representative.

929
01:46:00.890 --> 01:46:03.293
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, okay, checking to see if Holly Brown is here.

930
01:46:03.988 --> 01:46:05.085
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanan Patel.

931
01:46:06.554 --> 01:46:07.393
<v Keelan McClymont>Adam Skiles.

932
01:46:18.100 --> 01:46:18.309
<v Olivia Clark>Welcome.

933
01:46:19.082 --> 01:46:20.841
<v Councilmember Herbold>Myself, Cannon Patel.

934
01:46:22.502 --> 01:46:25.470
<v Councilmember Herbold>I am one of the business owners on Sandy Boulevard.

935
01:46:25.697 --> 01:46:26.600
<v Councilmember Herbold>I am a motel owner.

936
01:46:27.380 --> 01:46:33.864
<v Councilmember Herbold>So one of the biggest problems we are challenging, challenging as of now is drugs and prostitution.

937
01:46:35.185 --> 01:46:38.136
<v Councilmember Herbold>Sorry, is drugs and prostitution.

938
01:46:38.649 --> 01:46:39.550
<v Councilmember Herbold>Councilmember Herbold.

939
01:46:39.550 --> 01:46:39.550
<v Councilmember Herbold>Thank you, Mayor.

940
01:46:39.550 --> 01:46:39.550
<v Councilmember Herbold>I'm a victim of human trafficking.

941
01:46:39.550 --> 01:46:46.779
<v Councilmember Herbold>I've been reporting to police frequently about the stuff happening in the property or outside the property.

942
01:46:47.109 --> 01:46:50.520
<v Councilmember Herbold>So we really get good help from police.

943
01:46:51.329 --> 01:46:58.399
<v Councilmember Herbold>But when they are arrested, they get back out from the jail, and the cycle is on and on.

944
01:46:58.550 --> 01:47:03.590
<v Councilmember Herbold>So we, we really need help to cut off that cycle.

945
01:47:03.750 --> 01:47:12.515
<v Councilmember Herbold>So when a prostitute Or a drug dealer is arrested, they come back out of the jail and they are still back in this area.

946
01:47:13.012 --> 01:47:15.465
<v Councilmember Herbold>So the crime rate is never going down.

947
01:47:15.657 --> 01:47:18.621
<v Councilmember Herbold>The crime rate is always going up and up.

948
01:47:20.047 --> 01:47:26.537
<v Councilmember Herbold>And as a mom of 2 kids, I never let my kids to walk on the streets on Sandy Boulevard.

949
01:47:27.354 --> 01:47:31.520
<v Councilmember Herbold>I used to take my kids away from Sandy Boulevard or 82nd Avenue.

950
01:47:31.600 --> 01:47:31.872
<v Councilmember Herbold>Thank you.

951
01:47:32.403 --> 01:47:36.242
<v Councilmember Herbold>I'm even scared to walk in the parks on Sandy Boulevard.

952
01:47:36.965 --> 01:47:44.305
<v Councilmember Herbold>One of the incidents happened with me last year was I was walking along with my 6-month child on the Sandy Boulevard.

953
01:47:45.028 --> 01:47:54.055
<v Councilmember Herbold>Some of the people, the homeless people, they use like some knives and guns.

954
01:47:54.713 --> 01:47:57.203
<v Councilmember Herbold>Because I was like, what is the reason of doing that?

955
01:47:57.381 --> 01:48:10.195
<v Councilmember Herbold>And The statement they gave me was, so you called the police on one of our friends who was dealing drugs outside your property, so we are gonna shoot your child.

956
01:48:11.130 --> 01:48:14.752
<v Councilmember Herbold>So I was like yelling, I need help, I need help!

957
01:48:14.817 --> 01:48:19.849
<v Councilmember Herbold>Some of the people gathered around me and they helped me to move around, to move my house.

958
01:48:21.914 --> 01:48:23.641
<v Councilmember Herbold>So it's a big challenge.

959
01:48:24.168 --> 01:48:26.622
<v Councilmember Herbold>We are fighting as small business owners.

960
01:48:26.993 --> 01:48:29.154
<v Councilmember Herbold>We run property along with the families.

961
01:48:29.654 --> 01:48:32.640
<v Councilmember Herbold>I never let my child a lot of time to stay with me.

962
01:48:32.737 --> 01:48:37.841
<v Councilmember Herbold>I used to leave them with my in-laws because it gets harder for us to pay the bills.

963
01:48:40.525 --> 01:48:47.987
<v Councilmember Herbold>My daughter, there was a recently shooting in my property last, yes, last month.

964
01:48:49.377 --> 01:48:53.567
<v Councilmember Herbold>So the questions come here is they are not usually the people staying in our property.

965
01:48:54.847 --> 01:49:01.626
<v Councilmember Herbold>So during nighttime, they come walk in the properties and they does a lot of stuff that is inappropriate.

966
01:49:02.027 --> 01:49:05.600
<v Councilmember Herbold>We are scared to walk outside to pull the people out.

967
01:49:06.305 --> 01:49:11.417
<v Councilmember Herbold>So we, we really need some security on Sandy Boulevard, especially at nighttime.

968
01:49:11.978 --> 01:49:21.078
<v Councilmember Herbold>We are always happy to help Portland Police if they need any tips from us regarding prostitution and drug dealing.

969
01:49:21.143 --> 01:49:21.255
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

970
01:49:21.976 --> 01:49:31.057
<v Councilmember Herbold>Lot of people, like, they comes and whenever we ask them, they are like, we are helping people not in the property but outside the property.

971
01:49:31.203 --> 01:49:43.539
<v Councilmember Herbold>I used to counsel a lot of prostitutes walking on the side, and I feel proud on me that I cleared up one prostitute and I sent her to work as an Amazon.

972
01:49:43.653 --> 01:49:45.353
<v Councilmember Herbold>I paid a lot of stuff for her.

973
01:49:45.721 --> 01:49:46.845
<v Councilmember Herbold>She went to detox.

974
01:49:47.261 --> 01:49:53.564
<v Councilmember Herbold>She got a good lady, she got her kids back, and she owns an apartment on Sandy Boulevard, but she is clean.

975
01:49:53.980 --> 01:49:59.578
<v Councilmember Herbold>She got her daughter back and she's working on Amazon and 2 other jobs.

976
01:50:00.988 --> 01:50:02.801
<v Councilmember Herbold>So I feel proud of myself.

977
01:50:03.042 --> 01:50:08.719
<v Councilmember Herbold>At least I tried to change one of the lives of a prostitute, but I'm still working on that part.

978
01:50:08.911 --> 01:50:10.417
<v Councilmember Herbold>But I really need help.

979
01:50:10.738 --> 01:50:11.974
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here tonight.

980
01:50:12.037 --> 01:50:13.095
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, thank you for your testimony.

981
01:50:13.225 --> 01:50:13.545
<v Councilmember Herbold>Thank you.

982
01:50:15.538 --> 01:50:26.132
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Emmy Koyama, Tommy Jarvis, Loretta Guzman, Zachary Lauritzen, Hannah Lewis.

983
01:50:26.845 --> 01:50:28.125
<v Keelan McClymont>Go ahead and come up to the table.

984
01:50:28.930 --> 01:50:33.354
<v Keelan McClymont>You can state your name for the record and begin your testimony.

985
01:50:37.510 --> 01:50:37.706
<v Olivia Clark>Go ahead.

986
01:50:38.082 --> 01:50:38.198
<v Loretta Guzman>Okay.

987
01:50:38.262 --> 01:50:40.016
<v Loretta Guzman>Hi, my name is Loretta Guzman.

988
01:50:40.065 --> 01:50:43.637
<v Loretta Guzman>I'm a small business owner here in the City of Portland, and I was also raised here.

989
01:50:44.038 --> 01:50:50.426
<v Loretta Guzman>I think, um, when I originally first read this, what was coming before you guys, it was— there was like so much.

990
01:50:50.537 --> 01:50:58.578
<v Loretta Guzman>But I'm glad to hear that, that everybody is like putting input in this, and so it's not just going to fall on the business owners.

991
01:50:58.643 --> 01:51:07.918
<v Loretta Guzman>Because we running businesses, we are held to a higher standard than people, but we also can't control everything that happens out on the streets around our business.

992
01:51:07.966 --> 01:51:08.110
<v Loretta Guzman>Thank you.

993
01:51:08.832 --> 01:51:18.827
<v Loretta Guzman>We try to, but also you guys need to put something in place that works for us because there's like not a lot for help for us when we do call or we do need help.

994
01:51:18.908 --> 01:51:25.324
<v Loretta Guzman>A lot of times we have to go to other sources to get help because our— right now our system is eroding.

995
01:51:25.516 --> 01:51:26.655
<v Loretta Guzman>It's not safe out there.

996
01:51:26.961 --> 01:51:28.003
<v Loretta Guzman>I don't care what you guys say.

997
01:51:28.628 --> 01:51:31.693
<v Loretta Guzman>You know, you guys already know I come here all the time and speak.

998
01:51:32.158 --> 01:51:34.548
<v Loretta Guzman>I speak about, you know, my real life experiences.

999
01:51:34.613 --> 01:51:34.708
<v Loretta Guzman>Thank you.

1000
01:51:35.222 --> 01:51:35.960
<v Loretta Guzman>That I have.

1001
01:51:36.007 --> 01:51:39.471
<v Loretta Guzman>So there's a lot of concern, and our kids are our future.

1002
01:51:39.792 --> 01:51:43.609
<v Loretta Guzman>And I feel like you guys need to take and give, give our kids safety.

1003
01:51:44.106 --> 01:51:45.373
<v Loretta Guzman>Our kids don't have safety.

1004
01:51:46.112 --> 01:51:49.591
<v Loretta Guzman>You know, my net— my little nephew, um, his dad was killed.

1005
01:51:49.961 --> 01:51:51.500
<v Loretta Guzman>He just, he just moved.

1006
01:51:51.564 --> 01:51:57.001
<v Loretta Guzman>His— him and his mom had to move because, you know, she has a lot of trauma from everything that's happened.

1007
01:51:57.096 --> 01:52:03.140
<v Loretta Guzman>And she could have very easily been somebody who fell between the cracks and became a prostitute and became a drug addict.

1008
01:52:03.204 --> 01:52:12.149
<v Loretta Guzman>She could have been out there on 82nd, and I had to do a lot of work to help to get her to where she, you know, was able to get, get a job.

1009
01:52:12.310 --> 01:52:15.123
<v Loretta Guzman>And, you know, and I did a lot of juggling with the kids.

1010
01:52:15.429 --> 01:52:26.657
<v Loretta Guzman>So our kids are our future, and I hope you guys do something really, um, put something in place, but also don't put all the blame and all everything on us as business owners.

1011
01:52:26.706 --> 01:52:26.804
<v Loretta Guzman>Thank you.

1012
01:52:27.510 --> 01:52:29.180
<v Loretta Guzman>It, it's hard for us right now.

1013
01:52:29.243 --> 01:52:31.010
<v Loretta Guzman>You know, everything is raising on us.

1014
01:52:31.492 --> 01:52:36.469
<v Loretta Guzman>A lot of businesses are really struggling, and I don't know, we just need help.

1015
01:52:37.192 --> 01:52:44.947
<v Loretta Guzman>And so I just feel like our system is really eroded, and so I hope we get some real help out here, and you guys will see me more.

1016
01:52:45.155 --> 01:52:46.038
<v Loretta Guzman>Thank you.

1017
01:52:46.664 --> 01:52:47.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for your testimony.

1018
01:52:48.912 --> 01:52:50.341
<v Keelan McClymont>Emmy is joining us online.

1019
01:52:53.503 --> 01:52:54.515
<v Keelan McClymont>Hi, thank you so much.

1020
01:52:54.802 --> 01:53:01.989
<v Keelan McClymont>My name is Emiko Yama, and no relation to Councilor Koyama Lane, but I'm happy about the, you know, yesterday's proclamation earlier.

1021
01:53:02.487 --> 01:53:20.114
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm a survivor who has been on 82nd Avenue many years ago and longtime advocate for survivors, people who live and work on the street, migrant Asian women working in massage parlors, and other people in or adjacent to the sex trade who have not been meaningfully consulted in the process of drafting this legislation.

1022
01:53:20.934 --> 01:53:37.296
<v Keelan McClymont>I oppose the expansion of chronic nuisance property ordinance, especially in the name of preventing and interrupting exploitation and abuse within sex trade, because it displaces people in activities that community considers nuisance rather than addressing underlying social economic conditions that lead to vulnerabilities and abuse.

1023
01:53:37.793 --> 01:53:45.114
<v Keelan McClymont>People engage in sex trade under varying and oscillating combinations of choice, coercion, and circumstances.

1024
01:53:45.148 --> 01:53:46.015
<v Keelan McClymont>Public policies must respect and empower choices.

1025
01:53:46.221 --> 01:53:57.168
<v Keelan McClymont>Fight coercion, and vastly improve circumstances so that everyone in the sex trade, regardless how one entered or how much power they currently exercise, can benefit from greater freedom and safety.

1026
01:53:57.761 --> 01:54:00.086
<v Keelan McClymont>The proposal before you does none of that.

1027
01:54:00.421 --> 01:54:01.704
<v Keelan McClymont>In fact, it does the opposite.

1028
01:54:01.784 --> 01:54:10.310
<v Keelan McClymont>It pushes certain people and activities further underground, displacing, isolating, and endangering people who are already vulnerable to exploitation and abuse.

1029
01:54:11.064 --> 01:54:29.720
<v Keelan McClymont>From the street sweeps to backpage.com shutdown to motel and strip club closures, Last summer, Seattle expanded its chronic nuisance property law and recently received the first batch of public records from its enforcement.

1030
01:54:30.020 --> 01:54:41.020
<v Keelan McClymont>I noticed that in December, Seattle's Chief of Police issued a letter designating a business as chronic nuisance property based in part on the police report generated when someone at the business called 911.

1031
01:54:41.020 --> 01:54:41.060
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1032
01:54:41.060 --> 01:54:52.520
<v Keelan McClymont>I would like to ask the city I don't think it was the intent of Seattle City Council to penalize businesses for saving lives by reporting overdose, but this is a textbook example of unintended consequences.

1033
01:54:53.229 --> 01:55:03.079
<v Keelan McClymont>The Novick 1 amendment comes close to addressing this particular harm but does not actually provide relief because seeking medical emergency assistance in good faith is not included.

1034
01:55:03.630 --> 01:55:07.050
<v Keelan McClymont>Nobody in Seattle foresaw that expanding current nuisance property ordinance to include businesses.

1035
01:55:07.050 --> 01:55:07.090
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilmember Herbold.

1036
01:55:07.202 --> 01:55:14.641
<v Keelan McClymont>Might discourage businesses from calling for medical assistance and possibly cause delay in assistance and increase preventable death.

1037
01:55:15.220 --> 01:55:38.686
<v Keelan McClymont>But here in Portland, we are telling you right now that the likely detrimental consequence of enacting this ordinance on the safety and lives of people in sex trade— please scrap this legislation now and start over with a broader group of stakeholders to enact the policies that respect choice, fight coercion, and radically transform social and economic Thank you very much.

1038
01:55:39.849 --> 01:55:41.609
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you much, so much for your testimony tonight.

1039
01:55:43.270 --> 01:55:44.534
<v Keelan McClymont>Zachary is joining us online.

1040
01:55:46.869 --> 01:55:47.512
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening, everyone.

1041
01:55:47.882 --> 01:55:49.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Zachary Lauritzen at Oregon Walks.

1042
01:55:49.604 --> 01:55:55.238
<v Unidentified speaker>We're a pedestrian advocacy organization, and I'm testifying in support of the changes to the nuisance property code.

1043
01:55:56.163 --> 01:56:07.452
<v Unidentified speaker>In my role at Oregon Walks, I do a lot of organizing along 82nd Avenue, and over the years we've really developed a community vision for 82nd as this transit-rich, as this housing-rich spine of East Portland.

1044
01:56:07.532 --> 01:56:16.164
<v Unidentified speaker>And thanks to the work of advocates for years, of many of your predecessors, and frankly many of you, we're making steady progress towards those goals.

1045
01:56:17.560 --> 01:56:25.295
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, one of the biggest challenges, frankly, is 82nd Avenue's reputation, and that reputation is based in a lot of reality often.

1046
01:56:26.225 --> 01:56:29.997
<v Unidentified speaker>McDaniel students tell me about hearing gunshots shots being a weekly occurrence.

1047
01:56:30.623 --> 01:56:34.204
<v Unidentified speaker>82nd Avenue is known as a place where folks can get drugs of choice.

1048
01:56:35.056 --> 01:56:46.458
<v Unidentified speaker>Parts of 82nd Avenue, especially as mentioned earlier in the northern section by the Grotto, McDaniel, that area is well known as a place to purchase sex, often from people who have been coerced or trafficked into Portland to do so.

1049
01:56:46.538 --> 01:56:47.310
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's the reality.

1050
01:56:48.208 --> 01:56:55.259
<v Unidentified speaker>And philosophically, Oregon Walks, myself personally, we're not big in the enforcement lens of using police to achieve ends.

1051
01:56:56.238 --> 01:57:01.145
<v Unidentified speaker>But this legislation reminds me as a time, as like my time as an educator.

1052
01:57:01.770 --> 01:57:07.768
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of you know that before I was at Oregon Walks for 15 years, I was a coach and a teacher and an administrator in public schools in Oregon.

1053
01:57:08.521 --> 01:57:11.697
<v Unidentified speaker>And in that role, we needed various tools.

1054
01:57:12.354 --> 01:57:26.573
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, you taught appropriate behaviors, you used restorative practices, you intentionally built positive community, but sometimes and this feels a lot the same.

1055
01:57:26.815 --> 01:57:31.591
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, first we want to build a lot of housing on 82nd Avenue, really develop out the transit.

1056
01:57:31.639 --> 01:57:35.215
<v Unidentified speaker>We want to have thriving businesses so that we bring positive interactions.

1057
01:57:35.264 --> 01:57:39.886
<v Unidentified speaker>We want to depave and plant trees and make the space more welcoming and humane.

1058
01:57:40.400 --> 01:58:04.404
<v Unidentified speaker>And in the case where we know exactly, for example, where a hotel is being used, as we heard earlier tonight, You know, we need those traditional discipline tools, and I see this legislation as, as tightening and cleaning up the code that refines those tools that we have in that tool belt to address these challenging behaviors that you've heard tonight.

1059
01:58:05.287 --> 01:58:07.452
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate the process over the last few months.

1060
01:58:07.949 --> 01:58:12.744
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate actually hearing the attention to detail tonight to improve this legislation.

1061
01:58:12.824 --> 01:58:13.016
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1062
01:58:13.882 --> 01:58:23.953
<v Unidentified speaker>And I hope that we can heed the call of neighbors on 82nd Avenue, but also around the city in general, to start addressing these nuisance properties and the very real harms that they are causing to our community.

1063
01:58:24.451 --> 01:58:25.076
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1064
01:58:26.310 --> 01:58:27.033
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

1065
01:58:28.154 --> 01:58:30.127
<v Keelan McClymont>Hannah Lewis is joining us online.

1066
01:58:31.345 --> 01:58:31.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Hannah.

1067
01:58:33.046 --> 01:58:33.880
<v Keelan McClymont>Hi, Council.

1068
01:58:34.073 --> 01:58:36.863
<v Unidentified speaker>I had, uh, Hannah Lewis, she/her pronouns.

1069
01:58:37.761 --> 01:58:51.228
<v Unidentified speaker>I had a very well-thought-out testimony for tonight, but I'm going to go rogue because just hearing everybody's comments, the amendments, it's inspired me to share a stream of consciousness with you.

1070
01:58:51.840 --> 01:58:55.582
<v Unidentified speaker>I also want to thank Zachary for the spine of East Portland.

1071
01:58:55.631 --> 01:58:57.389
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to be quoting that going forward.

1072
01:58:59.091 --> 01:59:00.798
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to say thank you to council.

1073
01:59:00.880 --> 01:59:04.863
<v Unidentified speaker>This process has been very well thought out to understand the impact to residents.

1074
01:59:05.760 --> 01:59:09.891
<v Unidentified speaker>Owners, impacted individuals, and our workers on the streets.

1075
01:59:11.380 --> 01:59:15.802
<v Unidentified speaker>Meaningful consultation has occurred through the public testimony process.

1076
01:59:16.965 --> 01:59:25.646
<v Unidentified speaker>This first was brought to us back in January, and I thought we were voting in January, but here we are in March and continuing the discussion.

1077
01:59:28.242 --> 01:59:43.751
<v Unidentified speaker>A point that was brought up earlier was the Change to the number of instances in 90 days, and I'm curious around that because gun violence and trafficking tonight is being referred to as a nuisance, but it's really so much more than that.

1078
01:59:44.649 --> 01:59:56.626
<v Unidentified speaker>So when we have this history of issues happening at a property and then all of a sudden there's gun violence or we confirm trafficking, is that weighted heavier?

1079
01:59:56.675 --> 01:59:56.724
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1080
01:59:57.970 --> 01:59:58.916
<v Unidentified speaker>Just a question I have.

1081
02:00:00.989 --> 02:00:08.967
<v Unidentified speaker>Removing loitering, I think, is a win for those that are consensually out there in the sex work industry.

1082
02:00:10.582 --> 02:00:18.015
<v Unidentified speaker>At every one of our community meetings where the human trafficking unit presents, it's really interesting.

1083
02:00:18.113 --> 02:00:22.354
<v Unidentified speaker>The audience ends up turning their attention more towards the buyers than the women.

1084
02:00:22.884 --> 02:00:26.048
<v Unidentified speaker>So is there an opportunity to call for tougher consequences?

1085
02:00:28.493 --> 02:00:33.215
<v Unidentified speaker>Along the lines of loitering, but maybe it's— it looks more like repeat offenses.

1086
02:00:34.987 --> 02:00:38.346
<v Unidentified speaker>We've also heard from some really great business owners.

1087
02:00:38.863 --> 02:00:41.545
<v Unidentified speaker>Ms. Patel, very impressed to hear from her.

1088
02:00:42.563 --> 02:00:43.658
<v Unidentified speaker>Loretta Guzman as well.

1089
02:00:44.430 --> 02:00:48.779
<v Unidentified speaker>And we see those business owners being listened to tonight.

1090
02:00:50.051 --> 02:00:53.832
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to talk about an experience I've had in the Sumner neighborhood with the Quality Inn.

1091
02:00:53.917 --> 02:00:53.984
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1092
02:00:54.432 --> 02:01:08.529
<v Unidentified speaker>This goes back to delivering notice to a property owner where I personally tried to reach that hotel before I was really plugged into my neighborhood association or city council and how it all works, and it went unanswered.

1093
02:01:08.578 --> 02:01:22.975
<v Unidentified speaker>So is there an opportunity to hold the property owner accountable for being contactable, and how many owners work in their businesses train their staff, know how to support their staff with this nuance.

1094
02:01:23.568 --> 02:01:38.390
<v Unidentified speaker>And then just to add on to Rep Tran's statement, for students it's more than witnessing this, it's more than living among this, it's the fact that they are walking to school and they have a car slowly pull up to them and want to know their price.

1095
02:01:38.935 --> 02:01:41.563
<v Unidentified speaker>How can students respond to that?

1096
02:01:42.380 --> 02:01:45.472
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, just want to say thank you for your time and thank you for this process.

1097
02:01:47.159 --> 02:01:48.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Hannah.

1098
02:01:53.487 --> 02:01:58.740
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, next up, um, well, actually, let me check to see if Tommy Jarvis is here.

1099
02:02:01.186 --> 02:02:06.826
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, our last testifier is Taliana Lindseth, joining us online.

1100
02:02:15.867 --> 02:02:17.014
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, please go ahead.

1101
02:02:18.210 --> 02:02:21.052
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name's Theo.

1102
02:02:21.520 --> 02:02:25.634
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of you guys have seen me— I go by Theo, but some of you guys have seen me in council.

1103
02:02:26.779 --> 02:02:27.800
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, my baby is here.

1104
02:02:29.225 --> 02:02:40.960
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, as someone that has worked as a sex worker in Portland by choice, I'm here to testify the opposition to the ordinance 2026- Um, -039 to amend the chronic nuisance property.

1105
02:02:41.713 --> 02:02:55.797
<v Unidentified speaker>I do want to thank everybody that has been hearing the concerns from the community about making a difference between consensual sex work and prostitution from human trafficking, because they're definitely 2 different things.

1106
02:02:56.230 --> 02:02:59.327
<v Unidentified speaker>Consensual sex work is not the same thing as human trafficking.

1107
02:03:00.626 --> 02:03:03.497
<v Unidentified speaker>Human trafficking is a real and pressing issue in our city.

1108
02:03:03.594 --> 02:03:04.154
<v Unidentified speaker>However, Thank you.

1109
02:03:04.653 --> 02:03:12.319
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here today with concerns for the unintended impacts that this could have on sex workers in Portland.

1110
02:03:13.314 --> 02:03:29.404
<v Unidentified speaker>When you criminalize sex work and any action aiding in sex work, you put our community members at a greater risk, pushing them to the shadows and forcing them to work in unsafe conditions, specifically using lording and soliciting— solicit prostitution.

1111
02:03:29.515 --> 02:03:31.007
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for changing that as well.

1112
02:03:31.055 --> 02:03:31.184
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1113
02:03:32.404 --> 02:03:39.761
<v Unidentified speaker>Prostitution or related offenses, public indecency, unlawful prostitution and procurement activities.

1114
02:03:40.500 --> 02:03:46.426
<v Unidentified speaker>Things like this that I just listed can potentially lead to harming consensual sex workers.

1115
02:03:47.085 --> 02:03:55.277
<v Unidentified speaker>I do, I do not want others who choose to work here to face greater danger as a result of well-intended but harmful policy.

1116
02:03:56.096 --> 02:04:05.822
<v Unidentified speaker>For example, amending policy to include verbiage as prostitution or public indecency dredges up negative ideas around consensual sex work.

1117
02:04:06.609 --> 02:04:18.932
<v Unidentified speaker>I do urge you guys to work with BIPOC-led sex worker organizations within the community to work on decriminalization of sex work, to help separate sex work from sex trafficking.

1118
02:04:19.831 --> 02:04:30.207
<v Unidentified speaker>If you're going to work with— work on things that affect the sex worker community, then you should have consensual sex workers included in the conversation.

1119
02:04:31.046 --> 02:04:43.386
<v Unidentified speaker>If you're voting yes on this, then you should think about working to make consensual sex workers safe as well as decriminalizing sex work and step towards— and step towards working towards that.

1120
02:04:43.722 --> 02:04:54.398
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much for listening to me, and I hope that when you guys vote yes on this, that you guys are thinking about consensual sex workers in the community that can be harmed by specific words.

1121
02:04:55.002 --> 02:04:55.409
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1122
02:04:56.046 --> 02:04:57.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for your testimony tonight.

1123
02:04:58.500 --> 02:04:59.631
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

1124
02:05:00.293 --> 02:05:03.884
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I'm going to give us a 10-minute, uh, bathroom break.

1125
02:05:04.822 --> 02:05:06.034
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will be back here at 8:10.

1126
02:15:00.197 --> 02:15:01.746
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are back.

1127
02:15:01.908 --> 02:15:04.893
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues, for getting back on time.

1128
02:15:05.862 --> 02:15:07.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, we are now moving into council discussion.

1129
02:15:09.722 --> 02:15:10.917
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Avalos.

1130
02:15:12.728 --> 02:15:12.985
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1131
02:15:14.408 --> 02:15:26.087
<v Candace Avalos>Um, yeah, colleagues, I testified on this proposal when it was in committee because I wanted to make make sure that the people most likely to be impacted, particularly members of the sex worker community, were meaningfully included in the conversation.

1132
02:15:26.826 --> 02:15:34.157
<v Candace Avalos>I appreciate that outreach occurred and that amendments were made, but I'm still hearing from community members who remain deeply concerned about the impacts.

1133
02:15:34.220 --> 02:15:39.996
<v Candace Avalos>And so I want to take those concerns seriously and ask a couple of questions to get to the heart of that.

1134
02:15:40.220 --> 02:15:43.975
<v Candace Avalos>So, and I don't know who will answer some of these, I see there's people in the audience.

1135
02:15:44.023 --> 02:15:48.128
<v Candace Avalos>I'm assuming, Councilor Novick, you have like staff that are available to answer technical questions?

1136
02:15:48.193 --> 02:15:48.467
<v Candace Avalos>Yes?

1137
02:15:49.243 --> 02:15:49.436
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1138
02:15:49.728 --> 02:15:50.615
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, sounds good.

1139
02:15:52.199 --> 02:15:54.038
<v Candace Avalos>Um, let's start here.

1140
02:15:54.829 --> 02:16:00.912
<v Candace Avalos>So we have heard that this policy is intended to focus on buyers, not victims.

1141
02:16:01.364 --> 02:16:21.046
<v Candace Avalos>So I was wondering if, um, someone could explain how that distinction is operationalized in practice, especially when enforcement is tied to place-based nuisance Councilor Avalos, thank you for that question.

1142
02:16:21.712 --> 02:16:32.183
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll try to answer as best I can because I think enforcement with chronic nuisance is a little different than enforcement for criminal investigations, but they go hand in hand.

1143
02:16:32.832 --> 02:16:48.686
<v Unidentified speaker>And so as of, I would say, roughly around 2012, law enforcement and prosecutors' offices, especially in the Portland area, in Multnomah County area, decided not to arrest or charge victims of trafficking, any sellers.

1144
02:16:49.522 --> 02:17:11.729
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the focus of investigations, of enforcement, of missions has been specifically towards reducing demand, because we know economics— you reduce demand, you, you reduce trafficking— as well as looking into the people behind the scenes who are forcing individuals, victims, manipulating, controlling them to engage in this work.

1145
02:17:11.825 --> 02:17:14.760
<v Unidentified speaker>And so it's been— we've been focusing on buyers and traffickers.

1146
02:17:15.416 --> 02:17:27.921
<v Unidentified speaker>100% Of victims that are victims in significant trafficking cases, when they are contacted, say, I chose to do this, I don't have a trafficker, I am an independent sex worker.

1147
02:17:28.402 --> 02:17:29.908
<v Unidentified speaker>100% Of those individuals say that.

1148
02:17:29.957 --> 02:17:30.084
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1149
02:17:30.816 --> 02:18:03.861
<v Unidentified speaker>And so although I think theoretically it's easy to say that there's a difference between someone who's a sex worker and someone who's being trafficked, reality is, is that all victims of trafficking are groomed and told and taught to say that they are independent, that there's no one behind the scenes running them, and that the details of trafficking, when you look at the details of the violence, the homicide rates, the horrible things that I hear on a daily basis, That is at the very least a lack of choices, and most likely because someone is forcing them to do that.

1150
02:18:09.441 --> 02:18:09.618
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1151
02:18:09.860 --> 02:18:11.600
<v Candace Avalos>I don't think that answered the question, but I'm going to move on.

1152
02:18:12.034 --> 02:18:19.552
<v Candace Avalos>So my next question is, this ordinance still relies heavily on police reports and probable cause determination.

1153
02:18:19.681 --> 02:18:32.575
<v Candace Avalos>So in communities, particularly in East Portland, where people may be reluctant to engage with law enforcement due to immigration concerns or prior experiences, How are we ensuring that this is not silencing victims or discouraging reporting?

1154
02:18:34.840 --> 02:18:42.608
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, human trafficking is one of those— Councilor Avalos, human trafficking is one of those crimes that very few people come forward on their own.

1155
02:18:42.706 --> 02:18:45.733
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a lot of proactive investigations that go on.

1156
02:18:46.263 --> 02:19:00.658
<v Unidentified speaker>What I will say is probable cause is a standard in which warrants are, you know, in which warrants are used to apply to search homes, the residence probable cause is the standard for officers to use to make arrests, to refer cases to the DA's office.

1157
02:19:00.738 --> 02:19:10.023
<v Unidentified speaker>So probable cause is the standard that I think is available to law enforcement in a day-to-day base, in a daily basis for all sorts of things.

1158
02:19:10.521 --> 02:19:27.420
<v Unidentified speaker>As far as silencing victims, this only focuses on businesses and property owners in which we have are trying to seek ways to reduce crimes on their businesses or related to their businesses.

1159
02:19:27.581 --> 02:19:43.355
<v Unidentified speaker>So I don't believe, in my experience, and I've been doing this since 2008, I don't believe that there is a mechanism here that would silence victims of trafficking because they're worried about what may happen to the business who enabled their trafficking, if that's the question.

1160
02:19:46.506 --> 02:19:50.546
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, uh, let me move on to another one.

1161
02:19:50.593 --> 02:19:58.078
<v Candace Avalos>So I appreciate the amendment to ensure that if a property owner calls to report their own property, that they will not be penalized.

1162
02:19:58.174 --> 02:19:59.729
<v Candace Avalos>I understand the spirit of that amendment.

1163
02:20:00.194 --> 02:20:10.756
<v Candace Avalos>However, I am still wondering, how does this ordinance protect tenants, small business owners, and immigrant-owned businesses from being penalized for activity they might not be aware of or have the ability to control?

1164
02:20:10.805 --> 02:20:12.343
<v Candace Avalos>I heard a little bit of that in the testimony.

1165
02:20:13.001 --> 02:20:37.771
<v Steve Novick>Uh, I'm wondering if you can respond to how this well, first of all, I want to point out that the ordinance amends existing law, and under the chronic nuisance statute exists under existing law, and under existing law, the property owners can be held responsible for authorizing, for allowing illegal activity.

1166
02:20:39.167 --> 02:20:44.573
<v Steve Novick>What this— what the underlying law does is it prohibits the city from and what is that?

1167
02:20:46.217 --> 02:20:56.075
<v Steve Novick>Provide that if illegal activity is going on in a property, then the property owner is asked to take steps to abate that illegal activity.

1168
02:20:57.520 --> 02:21:05.183
<v Steve Novick>The property owner may or may not be aware of the illegal activity, but they're informed that this illegal activity is going on.

1169
02:21:05.505 --> 02:21:07.099
<v Steve Novick>Will you take steps to stop it?

1170
02:21:07.601 --> 02:21:12.386
<v Steve Novick>And then there's a back and forth between the property owner and the city about what those steps might be.

1171
02:21:13.013 --> 02:21:17.716
<v Steve Novick>So the property owner isn't penalized for conduct they weren't aware of.

1172
02:21:17.780 --> 02:21:22.041
<v Steve Novick>They're told, here's conduct that's going on, and will you take steps to address it?

1173
02:21:22.828 --> 02:21:27.297
<v Steve Novick>I also want to note that we're discussing the amendments now, and I—.

1174
02:21:27.585 --> 02:21:27.763
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are we?

1175
02:21:28.228 --> 02:21:32.217
<v Steve Novick>Yes, we're not discussing the underlying measure.

1176
02:21:32.927 --> 02:21:34.529
<v Candace Avalos>So which amendments?

1177
02:21:34.835 --> 02:21:35.143
<v Candace Avalos>All of them?

1178
02:21:35.191 --> 02:21:36.404
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was a package of amendments.

1179
02:21:36.468 --> 02:21:36.613
<v Steve Novick>Right.

1180
02:21:37.131 --> 02:21:38.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>We, we had— there was a move.

1181
02:21:38.511 --> 02:21:40.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>They— yeah, the package of amendments have been moved and seconded.

1182
02:21:40.963 --> 02:21:43.545
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, I still think my questions are relevant, but thank you for letting me know.

1183
02:21:43.930 --> 02:21:44.105
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1184
02:21:44.265 --> 02:22:05.828
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, uh, my last question is, um, what evidence do we have that nuisance property designations— and I am aware that you are amending an existing ordinance, but my concerns are that the amendments are making it worse, not better— so, um, what evidence do we have that nuisance property designations reduce trafficking or exploitation rather than simply moving it elsewhere?

1185
02:22:05.909 --> 02:22:11.373
<v Candace Avalos>And specifically What are the metrics that you're using to determine whether this ordinance is actually improving safety?

1186
02:22:27.545 --> 02:22:31.460
<v Steve Novick>Why we think that there's that these that the nuisance property designation is effective.

1187
02:22:32.138 --> 02:22:36.619
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, but to be clear, just to restate my question, I'm asking what specific metrics.

1188
02:22:36.719 --> 02:22:43.000
<v Candace Avalos>So that's my, my ask.

1189
02:22:43.000 --> 02:22:45.000
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead.

1190
02:22:45.049 --> 02:22:50.930
<v Keelan McClymont>So I hear that you're asking about the future metrics.

1191
02:22:51.319 --> 02:22:54.459
<v Candace Avalos>Well, I guess I'm asking a technical question about how to implement the ordinance.

1192
02:22:54.459 --> 02:22:58.020
<v Candace Avalos>So maybe if you want to share a bit of your experience with— I don't know that you're the right person to answer this.

1193
02:22:58.079 --> 02:23:02.659
<v Candace Avalos>I'm looking for actual metrics that we will use to enforce the, the law.

1194
02:23:02.659 --> 02:23:17.549
<v Steve Novick>Um, so the way that we will enforce the ordinance is I think that the law will be enforced with the city using it to try to get property owners at properties designated product nuisance properties to try to abate the nuisance.

1195
02:23:18.897 --> 02:23:29.620
<v Steve Novick>And I can't promise— whenever we pass laws, we don't generally say we're going to change the law back if we don't have certain specific evidence of certain results within a couple of years.

1196
02:23:29.668 --> 02:23:30.295
<v Steve Novick>So you're not going to change the law?

1197
02:23:31.112 --> 02:23:39.341
<v Steve Novick>We think that this will reduce illegal activity at the properties that are designated as chronic nuisance properties.

1198
02:23:40.736 --> 02:23:47.856
<v Steve Novick>But there's nothing that we— I mean, there's nothing that we do is guaranteed to have a particular result.

1199
02:23:48.578 --> 02:23:51.818
<v Steve Novick>We make our best guess as to what the results might be.

1200
02:23:52.587 --> 02:23:53.519
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I understand that.

1201
02:23:53.630 --> 02:23:57.849
<v Candace Avalos>But I also thought the point of making laws is so that they could produce certain results.

1202
02:23:57.897 --> 02:24:11.150
<v Candace Avalos>And so what I'm asking is, technically, In your belief, what do you believe is changing about this law that you think is going to, with specific metrics, make a difference in human exploitation and not moving it elsewhere?

1203
02:24:11.199 --> 02:24:13.614
<v Candace Avalos>Because that's the concern that we're hearing, that it's going to get pushed away.

1204
02:24:13.694 --> 02:24:18.108
<v Candace Avalos>So how do you— how are you— what is your judgment on how this is going to affect that?

1205
02:24:18.189 --> 02:24:22.368
<v Candace Avalos>And I am looking for specifics because I do think that we can ask for that as we are passing laws.

1206
02:24:23.997 --> 02:24:47.118
<v Steve Novick>I think that if there's fewer places for exploitation to occur, I also note that part of our concern— and again, this ordinance is not just about human trafficking— but part of our concern is the students at McDaniel walking through a gauntlet of sex trafficking, which is partly because of the hotels that have tolerated that periodically.

1207
02:24:47.198 --> 02:24:54.040
<v Steve Novick>It's not all hotels at all times, but if hotels are accepting sex trafficking in their establishments and the hotels are around that area, then that's a problem.

1208
02:24:54.087 --> 02:24:54.184
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1209
02:24:55.384 --> 02:24:59.847
<v Steve Novick>Then you can see more of that activity, and the students will see more of that activity.

1210
02:25:00.300 --> 02:25:17.218
<v Steve Novick>So I am hoping that by holding property owners in that area accountable for sex trafficking on their establishments, you'll wind up with the students walking into Daniel High School dealing with less— not having to walk through a gauntlet of sex trafficking.

1211
02:25:17.573 --> 02:25:17.895
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1212
02:25:18.056 --> 02:25:23.219
<v Candace Avalos>So then what I'm understanding by how you're describing it, you do not expect this to abate it.

1213
02:25:23.299 --> 02:25:29.783
<v Candace Avalos>You just expect it to move because what you said is your concern is people seeing it and that there's a row of hotels.

1214
02:25:30.137 --> 02:25:35.898
<v Candace Avalos>And if this is a place-based ordinance, tell me more about how— like, that's not what I'm—.

1215
02:25:35.898 --> 02:25:37.166
<v Steve Novick>Councilor, that is not what I said.

1216
02:25:37.279 --> 02:25:43.586
<v Steve Novick>What I said first is that I think by reducing the number of places where trafficking can occur, I would hope that reduces trafficking.

1217
02:25:43.859 --> 02:25:43.987
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1218
02:25:44.084 --> 02:25:50.875
<v Steve Novick>I also said that there's an additional issue which we're, which we're concerned about, Which is the children of Daniel High School walking through a gauntlet of sex trafficking.

1219
02:25:51.021 --> 02:25:55.234
<v Candace Avalos>I, yeah, I appreciate that, and I, I— please do not lecture me about the impact.

1220
02:25:55.299 --> 02:25:57.073
<v Candace Avalos>I am aware, I'm aware of that impact.

1221
02:25:57.137 --> 02:26:01.122
<v Candace Avalos>I work with youth about this, so I would appreciate that not being the case.

1222
02:26:01.717 --> 02:26:07.537
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I think both that what I'm hearing though is that it's not a clear one-to-one, and that's what I'm asking.

1223
02:26:07.585 --> 02:26:13.655
<v Candace Avalos>That's— I'm asking for data on is this a one-to-one, and if it is, we don't want it in this area, then that's great.

1224
02:26:13.718 --> 02:26:19.093
<v Candace Avalos>But I didn't hear that that is the impact that it's reduce human trafficking across the city if there's just one place.

1225
02:26:19.157 --> 02:26:30.170
<v Candace Avalos>Particularly, I say that because the DA specifically— or I'm sorry, no, your title, your DA assistant specifically said that when it was moved off of online, it just moved back to the streets.

1226
02:26:30.218 --> 02:26:33.471
<v Candace Avalos>So it was— you didn't abate it, you just— it moved somewhere else.

1227
02:26:33.567 --> 02:26:36.245
<v Candace Avalos>So that— I'm taking your words of how you describe that situation.

1228
02:26:36.292 --> 02:26:37.367
<v Candace Avalos>That's what I'm trying to avoid.

1229
02:26:37.672 --> 02:26:40.700
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm looking to understand how the ordinance is going to avoid that impact.

1230
02:26:40.781 --> 02:26:41.038
<v Unidentified speaker>Sure.

1231
02:26:41.182 --> 02:26:42.480
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to talk about metrics.

1232
02:26:43.346 --> 02:26:43.894
<v Unidentified speaker>In a couple ways.

1233
02:26:44.487 --> 02:26:53.840
<v Unidentified speaker>The way that chronic nuisance works is that the vast majority of businesses don't even get to this point because they send their employees to be trained.

1234
02:26:53.888 --> 02:26:56.556
<v Unidentified speaker>We've been training hotel and motel staff for 10 years.

1235
02:26:56.636 --> 02:26:59.319
<v Unidentified speaker>Most of these businesses say, we want to help, what can we do?

1236
02:26:59.736 --> 02:27:04.976
<v Unidentified speaker>We'll send our employees to be trained, and we want to look for signs so that we can report it and help it and prevent it in our hotel.

1237
02:27:05.441 --> 02:27:17.996
<v Unidentified speaker>This is for the hotels or businesses, whatever it may be, That have refused to do that, refused to meet with the city, refused to work with investigators and detectives to identify victims of trafficking.

1238
02:27:18.206 --> 02:27:28.093
<v Unidentified speaker>And very— at the very end, this is a last-ditch effort to say we need your help to prevent trafficking of youth and minors and individuals in your hotel.

1239
02:27:28.575 --> 02:27:39.938
<v Unidentified speaker>As far as metrics, if I can prevent 2 young people in Portland from being trafficked and their trafficker to be held accountable so that they don't recruit other young people, I think that metric is well worth—.

1240
02:27:39.970 --> 02:27:40.147
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1241
02:27:41.254 --> 02:27:49.542
<v Unidentified speaker>Creating and amending this city code to protect those youth in our community, because they are not youth from other countries, they're not youth from other states.

1242
02:27:49.929 --> 02:27:55.679
<v Unidentified speaker>They're youth that you live next to, that go to school with your children, that go to church with you, and other things.

1243
02:27:55.951 --> 02:27:57.895
<v Unidentified speaker>That metric, I think, is enough.

1244
02:27:58.424 --> 02:28:18.671
<v Unidentified speaker>And the fact of the matter is, is because trafficking, trafficking is so prolific, and we've seen that there's over 10,000 attempts to purchase another human being a week, it would be very difficult for us to say that that metric has been met other than to say we are protecting and helping vulnerable— the most vulnerable in our community not be trafficked.

1245
02:28:19.296 --> 02:28:21.797
<v Unidentified speaker>And when I said it moved from one place to another, absolutely.

1246
02:28:22.102 --> 02:28:24.314
<v Unidentified speaker>I didn't say increased or stayed the same.

1247
02:28:24.746 --> 02:28:30.870
<v Unidentified speaker>I was just saying about the general movement of what we see was from street level to online to back to the street.

1248
02:28:31.014 --> 02:28:34.829
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm not saying that the same numbers happened in each movement.

1249
02:28:34.941 --> 02:28:40.023
<v Unidentified speaker>All I was saying is that that's what we've seen in historical look at trafficking in the city.

1250
02:28:40.377 --> 02:28:42.573
<v Candace Avalos>But have you seen a reduction then as a result of that?

1251
02:28:42.845 --> 02:28:44.977
<v Candace Avalos>Are you saying that it's just moving from—.

1252
02:28:45.170 --> 02:28:46.532
<v Unidentified speaker>Absolutely, we've seen a reduction there.

1253
02:28:46.805 --> 02:28:48.761
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, well, I appreciate the value statements.

1254
02:28:48.808 --> 02:28:52.816
<v Candace Avalos>Again, I'm looking for facts, I'm looking for metrics, so that's what I'm trying to seek out.

1255
02:28:52.880 --> 02:28:53.970
<v Candace Avalos>I agree with the values.

1256
02:28:54.066 --> 02:28:58.299
<v Candace Avalos>I obviously care a lot about this, especially as a survivor of sexual abuse.

1257
02:28:58.412 --> 02:29:00.738
<v Candace Avalos>So this is very personal to me too.

1258
02:29:00.834 --> 02:29:16.033
<v Candace Avalos>So I would appreciate having a little bit of deference for the fact that I'm coming from my own lived experience and that there are people in my community that are experiencing the results of exploitation by further pushing this into the shadows, and especially immigrant communities.

1259
02:29:16.949 --> 02:29:27.444
<v Candace Avalos>And so, and that's what I heard from the immigrant communities that I talked to in a workshop, that they are concerned that women are being pushed into trafficking Or they're being pushed into sex work because ICE is stealing their permits.

1260
02:29:27.941 --> 02:29:28.615
<v Candace Avalos>They have no way to work.

1261
02:29:29.146 --> 02:29:36.575
<v Candace Avalos>And so for them, it's the choice between working with— working for sex or feeding their family and keeping a roof over their head.

1262
02:29:37.329 --> 02:29:42.947
<v Candace Avalos>And so I think it's important that we're naming these as the real impacts and the people that are being affected by that.

1263
02:29:43.332 --> 02:29:45.209
<v Candace Avalos>And this is not some ideological thing.

1264
02:29:45.272 --> 02:29:48.514
<v Candace Avalos>This is a real impact that I'm seeing in the district, and I think it's important we voice that.

1265
02:29:48.724 --> 02:29:50.568
<v Candace Avalos>I'll say that for now, and thank you.

1266
02:29:50.648 --> 02:29:51.338
<v Candace Avalos>I'll yield the rest of my time.

1267
02:29:51.677 --> 02:29:51.870
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1268
02:29:52.338 --> 02:30:00.534
<v Steve Novick>Mr. President, I'd like Chelsea to have an opportunity to weigh in on her views of whether this would simply push sex work into the shadows.

1269
02:30:00.631 --> 02:30:04.721
<v Candace Avalos>I would appreciate that, but I think I've asked my questions, and I— if I have more, I will ask them.

1270
02:30:04.818 --> 02:30:10.566
<v Candace Avalos>I thank you for your, for your, your perspective, but I think I'm done with my questioning, and I'm not asking for further.

1271
02:30:10.760 --> 02:30:11.131
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1272
02:30:13.447 --> 02:30:14.757
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to move us forward.

1273
02:30:15.388 --> 02:30:15.631
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1274
02:30:16.296 --> 02:30:16.683
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1275
02:30:17.185 --> 02:30:17.558
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1276
02:30:21.291 --> 02:30:21.645
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you, Mr.

1277
02:30:21.709 --> 02:30:22.350
<v Mitch Green>President.

1278
02:30:22.815 --> 02:30:24.754
<v Mitch Green>Thank you to everyone who testified today.

1279
02:30:25.459 --> 02:30:31.070
<v Mitch Green>I also read through the volume of written testimony as well, so I want to thank folks for submitting that.

1280
02:30:31.792 --> 02:30:35.816
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to speak just to the amendments on the floor as a package.

1281
02:30:36.522 --> 02:30:43.431
<v Mitch Green>I think in general, I think these amendments are an improvement on the piece that came out of the committee.

1282
02:30:43.511 --> 02:30:43.735
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1283
02:30:45.147 --> 02:30:53.477
<v Mitch Green>I don't know if I can support the underlying, but I'm going to save my comments on why or where I'm at on that until we get past this vote.

1284
02:30:53.525 --> 02:30:59.350
<v Mitch Green>But I, but I do appreciate the— appreciate the— I want to call out specifically, I appreciate the amendment.

1285
02:30:59.397 --> 02:31:11.201
<v Mitch Green>I think it's Novick 3 maybe that, that struck the explicit reference to solicitation of prostitution and just replaces it with the human trafficking citations that are out there.

1286
02:31:11.281 --> 02:31:11.459
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1287
02:31:12.281 --> 02:31:14.697
<v Mitch Green>I forget exactly which one that is, but it's part of this package.

1288
02:31:15.550 --> 02:31:16.469
<v Mitch Green>That was a big one for me.

1289
02:31:17.259 --> 02:31:18.967
<v Mitch Green>So thanks for being responsive to that.

1290
02:31:20.350 --> 02:31:31.483
<v Mitch Green>I think there are some other— there's some other cleanup stuff that I think I heard that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney also laid on the table that was helpful relative to what came out of committee.

1291
02:31:31.531 --> 02:31:42.906
<v Mitch Green>So I'm going to support the amendment package, but I've got more to say on the underlying Thank you, Councilor Green.

1292
02:31:43.261 --> 02:31:43.871
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knell.

1293
02:31:46.460 --> 02:31:47.408
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1294
02:31:48.075 --> 02:32:11.905
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, first, I wanted to thank my colleagues on the Community and Public Safety Committee for a thoughtful conversation, not just in the conversation around this, uh, agenda item, but Councilor Novick led on holding presentations about human trafficking and raising the attention of the committee, the council, and the broader community, uh, to the issues that we're talking about here, including the particular nexus, not just on 82nd, but the particular points around what the police and the DA's office refer to as the blade here.

1295
02:32:12.308 --> 02:32:21.506
<v Sameer Kanal>I also want to thank the testifiers, in particular those who do important work on this subject, Safety Compass, DA's office, but also Rep. Tran, who led the way on House Bill 4157, which I support.

1296
02:32:21.990 --> 02:32:24.507
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to start by saying I share the concerns and the assessment here.

1297
02:32:24.992 --> 02:32:30.156
<v Sameer Kanal>I had the privilege of going to an event with Councilor Novick, and I think several other councilors or staff were there too, at McDaniel High School.

1298
02:32:30.219 --> 02:32:30.269
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1299
02:32:31.168 --> 02:32:36.793
<v Sameer Kanal>It was an hour and 7 minutes in before the first mention of hotels or motels in talking about the problem.

1300
02:32:37.551 --> 02:32:46.751
<v Sameer Kanal>And it was in 2 responses to the question, what are some misconceptions around the situation around McDaniel, where one person said they felt hotels were a big part of the problem and the next person said they felt they were not.

1301
02:32:47.340 --> 02:32:49.768
<v Sameer Kanal>Hotels were mentioned one other time in passing with no commentary.

1302
02:32:49.897 --> 02:32:51.709
<v Sameer Kanal>And this crowd was parents and one student.

1303
02:32:52.245 --> 02:32:53.700
<v Sameer Kanal>No representatives from hotels were there.

1304
02:32:55.842 --> 02:33:00.364
<v Sameer Kanal>They talked about what one of our testifiers talked about in testimony the experience of their children in their communities.

1305
02:33:00.477 --> 02:33:05.156
<v Sameer Kanal>They talked about the desire to have a police response, and that includes the county not engaging in catch and release.

1306
02:33:06.085 --> 02:33:10.380
<v Sameer Kanal>And they talked about the need to do more and have more conversations with hotel and motel owners.

1307
02:33:11.054 --> 02:33:16.709
<v Sameer Kanal>That hasn't happened yet, but we're still talking about running them out of business, which is the only really predictable outcome of this legislation.

1308
02:33:17.703 --> 02:33:20.683
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to be clear: I don't assume bad intent from anyone who supports this.

1309
02:33:20.747 --> 02:33:22.638
<v Sameer Kanal>I think Councilor Novick and his team are trying to do the right thing.

1310
02:33:23.298 --> 02:33:26.655
<v Sameer Kanal>I do not think their goal is to do anything other than what they say, which is ending human trafficking.

1311
02:33:27.088 --> 02:33:39.620
<v Sameer Kanal>But I have to say, and this is underlying my vote on every amendment, that one of the most dangerous things a person with decision-making can do, a decision-making authority can do, is to recognize a real problem and say just we have to do something.

1312
02:33:40.085 --> 02:33:43.924
<v Sameer Kanal>Because when you say we have to do something, you're really opening the door to doing anything.

1313
02:33:44.520 --> 02:33:52.469
<v Sameer Kanal>And while I agree with the testifier who said that doing nothing is not neutral, we have a responsibility to find a solution that addresses the problem instead of blaming another group of people.

1314
02:33:53.015 --> 02:34:06.181
<v Sameer Kanal>What has been done here is taking an accurate assessment of the problem and going and finding a scapegoat— business owners along 82nd beyond the one that we all know about— and proposing creating new policy to bail out the people who should be keeping us safe from their responsibility to do so.

1315
02:34:06.904 --> 02:34:39.090
<v Sameer Kanal>The sponsor noted that the fundamental question this ordinance poses is to what extent do we think property owners have an obligation to make sure their properties aren't being used as a base for certain sorts of illegal activity In my interpretation, the fundamental question of this ordinance is whether or not the responsibility for addressing an observable, geographically limited pattern of a particular type of crime, which is to say human trafficking along 82nd and the area there is, resides with the police, or whether or not we should allow the outsourcing of that responsibility to private business owners.

1316
02:34:39.799 --> 02:34:41.659
<v Sameer Kanal>And there are ancillary questions as well to this.

1317
02:34:41.659 --> 02:34:42.260
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll name 2.

1318
02:34:42.260 --> 02:34:44.033
<v Sameer Kanal>One is, is the city's response to human trafficking how does this affect other businesses?

1319
02:34:44.370 --> 02:34:45.477
<v Sameer Kanal>How would it affect yours?

1320
02:34:45.911 --> 02:34:49.441
<v Sameer Kanal>At what point does something within 200 feet of your business become your fault?

1321
02:34:49.842 --> 02:35:00.541
<v Sameer Kanal>Would we consider the stadium superette a chronic nuisance property because they're surrounded by some significant criminal activity, and perhaps some of those people have purchased something in the past from the superette?

1322
02:35:01.072 --> 02:35:03.109
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll note that that's in the original code.

1323
02:35:03.156 --> 02:35:05.434
<v Sameer Kanal>That's not part of Councilor Novick's proposal here.

1324
02:35:05.724 --> 02:35:08.514
<v Sameer Kanal>This idea that you are responsible for something within 200 feet of your business.

1325
02:35:08.675 --> 02:35:12.965
<v Sameer Kanal>Feet of your, of your business if someone's purchased something from your property?

1326
02:35:13.591 --> 02:35:20.467
<v Sameer Kanal>And secondly, why have we not implemented council guidance to move overtime dollars to the police's human trafficking unit?

1327
02:35:20.900 --> 02:35:36.112
<v Sameer Kanal>The commanding sergeant of that unit has said in years past there was overtime available for human trafficking and said that there are no hours available for them now, despite a council-approved budget note saying to move overtime away from protest response and community presence to a suite of community needs, including human trafficking.

1328
02:35:36.563 --> 02:35:46.040
<v Sameer Kanal>And PPB data showing that they presented in our committee that the overtime spending on protest response and community presence did go down, but that overtime spending on those community needs did not go up.

1329
02:35:46.940 --> 02:35:49.879
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not opposing this legislation without offering an alternative.

1330
02:35:49.959 --> 02:36:03.806
<v Sameer Kanal>I would think we should do a 2-part alternative, which is to first get PPB to follow the budget guidance approved by the City Council and give the Human Trafficking Unit the resources we said to, and for the DA's office to commit in public to stopping catch and release, which we've heard from some of the business owners here.

1331
02:36:03.854 --> 02:36:06.295
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilmember for the kinds of abuses that we're talking about.

1332
02:36:06.744 --> 02:36:18.477
<v Sameer Kanal>And let me also say that I support using existing law, criminal law, yes, but also other legal structures like eminent domain to address the specific nuisance property that is at the center of what we're all talking about here.

1333
02:36:18.735 --> 02:36:27.403
<v Sameer Kanal>I understand that this law will target all hotels and motels, but the examples people are giving, many of them focus on a single property near McDaniel High School.

1334
02:36:27.468 --> 02:36:31.704
<v Sameer Kanal>We don't need to name them, but everyone knows the state of the property and the state of public safety in that area.

1335
02:36:32.587 --> 02:36:37.578
<v Sameer Kanal>Why do we need to put other hotel and motel owners out of business when we know where a lot of this is centered?

1336
02:36:37.899 --> 02:36:41.719
<v Sameer Kanal>Why can't we use the existing code about the state of that one property?

1337
02:36:42.699 --> 02:36:47.851
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that we have to talk about this because that is what's in the community impact statement.

1338
02:36:48.557 --> 02:36:55.040
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's also in the statement of, I think by reducing the number of places where trafficking can occur, I would hope that reduces trafficking.

1339
02:36:55.394 --> 02:36:56.998
<v Sameer Kanal>We know what the impact will be.

1340
02:36:57.078 --> 02:37:11.915
<v Sameer Kanal>This is designed to go and put the impact on a whole host of businesses as opposed to the small subset, which everybody agrees it's a small subset, who are doing the particular types of activity we're talking about.

1341
02:37:13.215 --> 02:37:23.346
<v Sameer Kanal>So with that, I'm going to make a motion because of the importance and because my comments were about the underlying and because of the volume of the amendments that have been proposed here and the time it is now.

1342
02:37:23.814 --> 02:37:30.594
<v Sameer Kanal>To postpone this item, the entire item, to a time certain, which is the next meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee.

1343
02:37:34.353 --> 02:37:36.661
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal has made a motion.

1344
02:37:36.838 --> 02:37:39.693
<v Jamie Dunphy>I— is this a debatable motion?

1345
02:37:40.766 --> 02:37:42.004
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, it also needs a second.

1346
02:37:42.150 --> 02:37:42.329
<v Angelita Morillo>Second.

1347
02:37:42.655 --> 02:37:45.828
<v Angelita Morillo>Sorry, for clarity, you want to refer this back to the Public Safety Committee?

1348
02:37:49.734 --> 02:37:51.087
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm looking to our attorneys.

1349
02:37:51.154 --> 02:37:51.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Point of information.

1350
02:37:54.150 --> 02:38:08.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With the way our committees are structured, can we refer to a time certain at a committee, or do we need to vote to send it to committee as a separate action?

1351
02:38:08.469 --> 02:38:10.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am not trying to be pedantic here.

1352
02:38:10.209 --> 02:38:13.809
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am trying to make sure that we know what our rules are and are following them.

1353
02:38:15.037 --> 02:38:17.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is a good clarification.

1354
02:38:18.444 --> 02:38:19.575
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know.

1355
02:38:20.760 --> 02:38:21.422
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll need to look.

1356
02:38:21.519 --> 02:38:31.650
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So it's the 2 questions, voting to time certain and whether that's debatable, and the voting on dissent committee.

1357
02:38:31.747 --> 02:38:38.763
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, should a referral back to a committee be to a time certain, or is it simply— is it a simple motion to refer back?

1358
02:38:38.912 --> 02:38:40.070
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd like to— oh, sorry, go ahead.

1359
02:38:40.888 --> 02:38:46.894
<v Sameer Kanal>I can amend the motion because I think this is a correct— I think it's a motion to refer to the committee.

1360
02:38:47.263 --> 02:38:47.664
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1361
02:38:48.033 --> 02:38:48.548
<v Sameer Kanal>And yeah.

1362
02:38:48.949 --> 02:38:49.110
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1363
02:38:49.334 --> 02:38:55.324
<v Sameer Kanal>With the intention of it not being referred with an indefinite never come back to it, but with the intention of it being discussed.

1364
02:38:56.158 --> 02:38:56.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1365
02:38:56.399 --> 02:39:01.265
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the motion and a second is to refer the item back to committee.

1366
02:39:01.619 --> 02:39:05.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are in a motion as well on amendments.

1367
02:39:05.457 --> 02:39:06.806
<v Sameer Kanal>Motion to refer takes precedence.

1368
02:39:06.917 --> 02:39:07.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's a motion to refer.

1369
02:39:07.560 --> 02:39:07.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1370
02:39:07.834 --> 02:39:08.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1371
02:39:08.345 --> 02:39:10.334
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're learning lots about Robert's Rules.

1372
02:39:11.070 --> 02:39:12.095
<v Keelan McClymont>Who was the second?

1373
02:39:12.208 --> 02:39:12.640
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm sorry.

1374
02:39:13.234 --> 02:39:14.933
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Avalos was the second.

1375
02:39:16.215 --> 02:39:18.345
<v Steve Novick>And is this a debatable motion?

1376
02:39:18.779 --> 02:39:19.899
<v Keelan McClymont>It is debatable.

1377
02:39:19.980 --> 02:39:22.448
<v Keelan McClymont>The motion to refer to a committee is debatable.

1378
02:39:22.545 --> 02:39:27.593
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, so we have a motion and a second that is debatable to refer this back to committee.

1379
02:39:27.656 --> 02:39:38.823
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is going to take precedence, so we are now in debate of the motion to Refer.

1380
02:39:38.951 --> 02:39:40.307
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick, do you want to—.

1381
02:39:41.049 --> 02:39:41.404
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1382
02:39:42.518 --> 02:39:51.384
<v Steve Novick>This proposed ordinance already passed out of committee, and I have yet to hear anybody objecting to any of the specific amendments that have been offered here today.

1383
02:39:51.479 --> 02:39:54.380
<v Steve Novick>I've heard a lot of argument about the underlying measure.

1384
02:39:54.944 --> 02:40:13.226
<v Steve Novick>So I don't see what the point would be of sending this back to a committee And when— I don't see any argument that there's any reason for the amendments that we're proposing, which I haven't heard anybody opposing, to be rediscussed by the committee.

1385
02:40:15.418 --> 02:40:16.644
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1386
02:40:18.498 --> 02:40:20.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Marie, are you to the motion?

1387
02:40:21.602 --> 02:40:21.994
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

1388
02:40:22.645 --> 02:40:26.418
<v Angelita Morillo>First, I want to say thank you to the folks that came and testified both at committee and here.

1389
02:40:26.566 --> 02:40:27.298
<v Angelita Morillo>I think this is a very important issue.

1390
02:40:28.289 --> 02:40:35.689
<v Angelita Morillo>A very important issue for our entire city and painful for many people in our community for a lot of different reasons.

1391
02:40:36.079 --> 02:40:38.627
<v Angelita Morillo>So I just want to honor the work that's being done here.

1392
02:40:40.012 --> 02:40:44.101
<v Angelita Morillo>And I— it did come out of committee.

1393
02:40:44.844 --> 02:40:47.818
<v Angelita Morillo>I do think it needs to go back to committee for a few reasons.

1394
02:40:48.959 --> 02:40:53.032
<v Angelita Morillo>For one thing, I think that the amendments, some of them are certainly improvements.

1395
02:40:53.164 --> 02:40:58.452
<v Angelita Morillo>I think the removal of language around sex work and changing it to human trafficking is really critical.

1396
02:41:00.319 --> 02:41:16.250
<v Angelita Morillo>But there are simply too many changes to the actual— the amendments that are proposed make it slightly better for me, but not good enough for me to feel comfortable with them because there are a lot of changes that need to be made.

1397
02:41:16.747 --> 02:41:18.629
<v Angelita Morillo>Like, for one thing, I think—.

1398
02:41:18.629 --> 02:41:19.278
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Smith.

1399
02:41:20.709 --> 02:41:32.373
<v Angelita Morillo>At its crux, the police report thing I think needs to be changed to actual evidence and not just an officer's arbitrary perspective on writing up a report.

1400
02:41:32.920 --> 02:41:41.563
<v Angelita Morillo>There— all of the amendments are slightly better than what is being proposed, but I don't think that they actually make things better in the long run.

1401
02:41:41.835 --> 02:41:46.206
<v Angelita Morillo>And the— even the discussion about changing it from 2 to 3 and back to 2, I think, is a little bit of a stretch.

1402
02:41:46.254 --> 02:41:46.478
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Smith.

1403
02:41:48.177 --> 02:41:52.648
<v Angelita Morillo>It's very clear that there's no real metric for why we are making these decisions.

1404
02:41:53.066 --> 02:41:54.620
<v Angelita Morillo>It feels very vibes-based.

1405
02:41:55.308 --> 02:42:09.475
<v Angelita Morillo>And the majority of what we have seen as far as data collected from the ACLU is that chronic nuisance ordinances actually reduce public safety because they can incentivize landlords to repress crime reporting and evict victims.

1406
02:42:10.147 --> 02:42:11.445
<v Angelita Morillo>That is what we often see.

1407
02:42:11.495 --> 02:42:11.879
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Herbold.

1408
02:42:12.301 --> 02:42:17.025
<v Angelita Morillo>So I don't feel comfortable with this as is.

1409
02:42:17.686 --> 02:42:24.725
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think that this is a very complicated policy that just requires a bit more discussion in committee.

1410
02:42:25.395 --> 02:42:27.175
<v Angelita Morillo>We had some time for discussion.

1411
02:42:27.760 --> 02:42:34.731
<v Angelita Morillo>It was— I raised some concerns in committee and then it was quickly— we quickly moved on from them before they were fully addressed.

1412
02:42:35.521 --> 02:42:36.021
<v Angelita Morillo>And now we're here.

1413
02:42:36.712 --> 02:42:37.847
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's fine.

1414
02:42:38.595 --> 02:42:39.213
<v Angelita Morillo>That happens sometimes.

1415
02:42:39.263 --> 02:42:39.458
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Smith.

1416
02:42:40.244 --> 02:42:46.620
<v Angelita Morillo>But I think with the amount of feedback that we've gotten from community members, I am concerned about it.

1417
02:42:47.230 --> 02:42:56.949
<v Angelita Morillo>The town hall that was also held talking about this policy, Councilor Kanal brought up that there were no hotel owners there present.

1418
02:42:57.655 --> 02:43:02.940
<v Angelita Morillo>I would also point out that there were no sex workers present there to talk about the impacts of this.

1419
02:43:03.679 --> 02:43:05.300
<v Angelita Morillo>And so— Councilor Smith.

1420
02:43:06.361 --> 02:43:11.031
<v Angelita Morillo>I just don't feel comfortable with this as is, and I think it does need, uh, further research and discussion.

1421
02:43:12.438 --> 02:43:13.391
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

1422
02:43:14.055 --> 02:43:15.299
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, to the motion?

1423
02:43:16.969 --> 02:43:20.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was in the queue for a different motion, but if you don't mind, I'd like to speak to this one.

1424
02:43:20.222 --> 02:43:20.352
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please.

1425
02:43:20.529 --> 02:43:21.608
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Council President.

1426
02:43:22.541 --> 02:43:45.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I am generally a fan of taking more time in committees, but what I have heard tonight are concerns with not even the language in the underlying ordinance, but the language in the current law, which is some— in some areas is being changed and some is not.

1427
02:43:46.924 --> 02:43:57.873
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am hearing a lot of concern with the extent of the amendments, but what I see are a few amendments that don't change the direction of the underlying ordinance.

1428
02:44:04.065 --> 02:44:09.198
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perhaps not all of them, but many, and folks saying that it is making it better.

1429
02:44:11.204 --> 02:44:23.407
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am hearing a lot of opposition to, at a minimum, the underlying language, the original language in code right now, and perhaps to the ordinance before us.

1430
02:44:24.521 --> 02:44:26.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I'm not hearing an interest in making it better.

1431
02:44:26.600 --> 02:44:27.181
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a fair point.

1432
02:44:28.308 --> 02:44:34.791
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Changing this policy, perhaps an interest in other changes to the current code, but not this policy.

1433
02:44:35.852 --> 02:44:42.769
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, so I'm not sure why we're sending this back to committee other than to delay.

1434
02:44:43.329 --> 02:44:52.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm, I'm trying to listen for interest in digging in on this, um, and I'm not hearing that.

1435
02:44:52.638 --> 02:45:14.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I would that we vote on whether these amendments move us in the right direction or not, and that when this comes back up, presumably in a week, because I believe this is a first reading of a non-emergency ordinance, that we give an up or down vote on whether this is a change to the current code that exists that we like or not.

1436
02:45:17.772 --> 02:45:32.912
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I'm not sure why we're sending it back to committee if if there's not a real interest in addressing the language to move us toward something that makes our current code better in a way that's different from what we have before us.

1437
02:45:37.299 --> 02:45:38.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1438
02:45:38.603 --> 02:45:39.281
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1439
02:45:39.974 --> 02:45:40.908
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

1440
02:45:44.518 --> 02:45:48.252
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do feel that these amendments are moving things Thank you.

1441
02:45:48.333 --> 02:46:00.318
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that the amendment is moving things in a bit of a better direction, and I'm trying to separate that from the underlying, also from the idea that maybe some more work needs to be done on this.

1442
02:46:01.240 --> 02:46:26.929
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My thoughts around more work being done on this connect to— and Councilor Novick, you can let me know if this is addressed in any of the amendments, but there is written testimony from Multnomah County Health Department's Public Health Division where they are so they say they're supportive with changes, and they ask for an inclusion of a requirement for annual public reporting on the ordinance's implementation over a 3-year period.

1443
02:46:28.453 --> 02:46:33.290
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, is that already addressed in any of the amendments?

1444
02:46:33.531 --> 02:46:35.094
<v Steve Novick>It isn't.

1445
02:46:35.144 --> 02:46:36.030
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It isn't.

1446
02:46:37.120 --> 02:46:40.404
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, so I am, I am interested in, in that.

1447
02:46:40.612 --> 02:46:54.822
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then the other one that stood out to me was the one from the Northwest Regional Director for the Asian American Hotel Owners that one's more about engagement, which is important.

1448
02:46:54.918 --> 02:47:05.787
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This Multnomah County Health Department Public Health Division one is one that I think deserves some more, I think, some more conversation.

1449
02:47:05.835 --> 02:47:09.390
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that could be an important amendment to add.

1450
02:47:09.617 --> 02:47:10.989
<v Steve Novick>Can I ask you to restate that again?

1451
02:47:12.270 --> 02:47:14.514
<v Steve Novick>Remind me what the Health Department said.

1452
02:47:14.564 --> 02:47:27.954
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Said to ensure the ordinance's effectiveness and to guard against potential abuse or unfair use, we respectfully recommend the inclusion of a requirement for annual public reporting on the ordinance's implementation over a 3-year period.

1453
02:47:28.019 --> 02:47:43.465
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This transparent reporting mechanism will monitor implementation and enforcement practices and increase accountability and transparency, allowing the public and policymakers to track the ordinance's impact, monitor for unintended outcomes, assess its equity, and make data-driven adjustments as needed.

1454
02:47:43.641 --> 02:47:46.820
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I do believe this is very important.

1455
02:47:46.916 --> 02:47:49.067
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Everyone who's come to testify, thank you so much.

1456
02:47:49.181 --> 02:47:56.838
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do think it's— we want to make sure that we do this right, and this seems like something to consider.

1457
02:47:57.031 --> 02:48:03.663
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so I could be supportive of spending a little bit more time and being able to work on these amendments.

1458
02:48:03.710 --> 02:48:05.829
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm seeing like last-minute amendments come in.

1459
02:48:06.343 --> 02:48:08.447
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know there's mixed feelings about that.

1460
02:48:09.394 --> 02:48:14.435
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do support making sure we're getting to as best of a place as possible and doing it well.

1461
02:48:15.656 --> 02:48:20.809
<v Steve Novick>I'd actually bet that— I think that is an interesting potential amendment.

1462
02:48:21.355 --> 02:48:33.270
<v Steve Novick>And given the time, I actually would be okay with continuing this to the next council meeting, and we could see if we can work on that amendment and drop it into the package.

1463
02:48:37.747 --> 02:48:40.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>If this item is continued, I will schedule it with urgency.

1464
02:48:41.036 --> 02:48:41.421
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1465
02:48:42.319 --> 02:48:43.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1466
02:48:43.602 --> 02:48:44.165
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1467
02:48:44.308 --> 02:48:44.502
<v Dan Ryan>Sure.

1468
02:48:44.870 --> 02:48:46.009
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

1469
02:48:47.277 --> 02:48:56.421
<v Dan Ryan>Well, you know, it must be council after dark because we always have these moments, um, when you think something's moving along and then some surprises come at you.

1470
02:48:56.902 --> 02:49:00.736
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I'm not in support of putting this back to the committee.

1471
02:49:00.927 --> 02:49:03.694
<v Dan Ryan>I am good with it going back back to the council.

1472
02:49:03.858 --> 02:49:06.593
<v Dan Ryan>So I hope that it stays in the lane of the council.

1473
02:49:07.700 --> 02:49:09.306
<v Dan Ryan>I really just want to say a couple things.

1474
02:49:09.418 --> 02:49:12.631
<v Dan Ryan>I really appreciate Councilor Novick's solid and comprehensive work.

1475
02:49:13.500 --> 02:49:23.534
<v Dan Ryan>You connected with— you connected the dots with those closest to this issue, um, providing safety for those who understand sex trafficking system.

1476
02:49:23.631 --> 02:49:24.259
<v Dan Ryan>It's very complex.

1477
02:49:25.719 --> 02:49:31.638
<v Dan Ryan>Victims, family members, DA's office, hotels, schools, neighbors, police.

1478
02:49:32.091 --> 02:49:33.398
<v Dan Ryan>And thank you all for being here.

1479
02:49:33.625 --> 02:49:35.289
<v Dan Ryan>Many of you are still here in the audience.

1480
02:49:36.691 --> 02:49:41.186
<v Dan Ryan>I also really want to take a moment, like we all have, to thank you all for the test— those who testified.

1481
02:49:41.688 --> 02:49:43.127
<v Dan Ryan>It was outstanding testimony.

1482
02:49:43.385 --> 02:49:47.970
<v Dan Ryan>You're brave, you're courageous, and you're also fighting for those who don't have a voice.

1483
02:49:49.435 --> 02:49:52.891
<v Dan Ryan>How many times do we have to hear the average age of mostly young women?

1484
02:49:52.957 --> 02:49:54.636
<v Dan Ryan>There's also men, there's also boys.

1485
02:49:55.925 --> 02:49:57.298
<v Dan Ryan>That often gets dismissed.

1486
02:49:58.492 --> 02:50:01.849
<v Dan Ryan>Girls and boys who are on the street that don't have anyone advocating for them.

1487
02:50:04.790 --> 02:50:09.181
<v Dan Ryan>Your lived experiences, your advocacy for children and youth inspired me.

1488
02:50:09.343 --> 02:50:10.716
<v Dan Ryan>It really did capture my heart.

1489
02:50:12.319 --> 02:50:16.395
<v Dan Ryan>I'm confused about some of the pushback that's currently happening.

1490
02:50:17.074 --> 02:50:19.192
<v Dan Ryan>I feel like we got off topic a few times.

1491
02:50:19.743 --> 02:50:33.110
<v Dan Ryan>I want to ask if it's okay when We hear things like the DA does catch and release, like maybe the DA could come back up and explain that as opposed to having that just tossed out there because they're thoughtfully remaining with us in the room.

1492
02:50:34.281 --> 02:50:36.993
<v Dan Ryan>Anyway, I want to end by saying these are really thoughtful amendments.

1493
02:50:37.265 --> 02:50:39.608
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Pertigini and Novick.

1494
02:50:39.672 --> 02:50:46.700
<v Dan Ryan>You could tell you really worked well together to make these even more thoughtful and improve this legislation, which everyone seems to agree they have.

1495
02:50:47.212 --> 02:50:49.844
<v Dan Ryan>So I look forward to supporting those when we ever get to vote on them.

1496
02:50:49.893 --> 02:50:50.004
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

1497
02:50:50.730 --> 02:51:01.967
<v Dan Ryan>And I, I would like to hear a response from the DA on that statement because it was a very heavy statement, and I think it's important for transparency in government to allow that.

1498
02:51:02.129 --> 02:51:06.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, I will definitely do that, but we're going to get through this discussion of the motion first.

1499
02:51:09.691 --> 02:51:10.481
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, sorry, Councilor.

1500
02:51:10.740 --> 02:51:12.939
<v Dan Ryan>It's okay, as long as we have transparency.

1501
02:51:13.067 --> 02:51:13.487
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

1502
02:51:13.972 --> 02:51:14.586
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1503
02:51:15.775 --> 02:51:19.173
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so first, I repeated a statement from testimony.

1504
02:51:19.236 --> 02:51:20.840
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to just be very clear about that.

1505
02:51:21.239 --> 02:51:24.750
<v Sameer Kanal>But it's also something that I've heard from many, many of the people who've weighed in on this.

1506
02:51:24.845 --> 02:51:34.798
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wish that people had paid attention to the testimony in committee, where I think some of the folks may have given up on our willingness to listen on this after it got referred out.

1507
02:51:35.887 --> 02:51:38.644
<v Sameer Kanal>But, you know, it's— that testimony still exists.

1508
02:51:38.708 --> 02:51:47.297
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm grateful that Councilor Koyama Lane referred to the I want to stress that I do not think that all the amendments are improvements.

1509
02:51:47.361 --> 02:51:48.194
<v Sameer Kanal>I think a couple of them are.

1510
02:51:49.524 --> 02:51:52.906
<v Sameer Kanal>I will, if this fails, I will be dividing out the amendment package.

1511
02:51:52.969 --> 02:52:06.111
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's a rewrite of most of the legislation, and it doesn't make sense to do that here after the ordinance that we referred out was not the same as what it would be if these amendments all passed, right?

1512
02:52:06.334 --> 02:52:12.537
<v Sameer Kanal>The committee referred out something that is very different from what will be heard in the later parts of this consideration because of the amendments that were made.

1513
02:52:12.601 --> 02:52:12.938
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Smith.

1514
02:52:15.100 --> 02:52:18.649
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's not exactly fair.

1515
02:52:18.649 --> 02:52:23.469
<v Sameer Kanal>But it's also broadly that in committee is where you can do the changing of direction.

1516
02:52:23.969 --> 02:52:25.729
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's the better place to do it.

1517
02:52:25.729 --> 02:52:28.610
<v Sameer Kanal>I was asked by Councilor Novick if I wanted to put up amendments to it.

1518
02:52:28.610 --> 02:52:29.270
<v Sameer Kanal>I drafted one.

1519
02:52:29.270 --> 02:52:34.219
<v Sameer Kanal>I pre-filed it to get rid of the 200-foot requirement because I think it's ludicrous to have guilt by association.

1520
02:52:35.049 --> 02:52:40.069
<v Sameer Kanal>And again, that's not in the ordinance or the amendments today.

1521
02:52:40.069 --> 02:52:42.850
<v Sameer Kanal>It's in the original code that is being altered in the first place.

1522
02:52:42.850 --> 02:52:43.480
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick, place.

1523
02:52:43.978 --> 02:53:20.965
<v Sameer Kanal>But fundamentally, the purpose of this is to help make a law that is not currently being used, which is why I'm not focused on changing it— help take a law that's not currently being used and provide as much discretion as possible to try and use it to go after business owners, not traffickers, business owners, for things that might happen 199 feet away from their and, you know, when we have someone who comes up and testifies about it, and then they're accosted after they testify in opposition, that's a problem, right?

1524
02:53:21.685 --> 02:53:22.630
<v Sameer Kanal>For being a business owner.

1525
02:53:22.968 --> 02:53:30.963
<v Sameer Kanal>And I have a colleague who asked my motivation, who's also talked about how one of the most marginalized groups in Portland is business owners.

1526
02:53:31.798 --> 02:53:33.368
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's a fair point to raise.

1527
02:53:33.479 --> 02:53:33.689
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it is.

1528
02:53:34.250 --> 02:53:34.329
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1529
02:53:34.665 --> 02:53:42.742
<v Sameer Kanal>And so if, if there's going to be a change in direction, I, I don't think it's fair for me to say I'm going to offer this small amendment and then it's a total change in direction.

1530
02:53:43.415 --> 02:53:44.681
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's why I haven't done that.

1531
02:53:44.761 --> 02:53:49.454
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think it's fair to say if we want to have a change in direction, we should go back to committee and do it.

1532
02:53:49.744 --> 02:53:52.307
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's, that's my underlying interest here.

1533
02:53:52.628 --> 02:53:54.022
<v Sameer Kanal>I can debate the individual ones.

1534
02:53:54.069 --> 02:53:55.703
<v Sameer Kanal>If this motion fails, I'm happy to do that.

1535
02:53:55.752 --> 02:54:00.013
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll be— I'll just divide them and, and go one by one because some of them are very good.

1536
02:54:00.063 --> 02:54:03.577
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I particularly, I tend to support more of the ones I like the ones from Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1537
02:54:04.317 --> 02:54:08.905
<v Sameer Kanal>I also like a significant part of Novick 5, but there's other ones in here that I think are pretty problematic.

1538
02:54:10.602 --> 02:54:35.167
<v Sameer Kanal>And we've had this conversation before, and I was hoping to have a conversation on the underlying before amendments were limiting what we could talk about, because we— not knowing the direction the council helps— knowing the direction the council would help me understand whether we're trying— what the purpose is of amending something to make it better when it's just not good in your— in my personal opinion.

1539
02:54:35.537 --> 02:54:37.254
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's, that's what I was trying to get to.

1540
02:54:37.317 --> 02:54:40.174
<v Sameer Kanal>But because the amendment was allowed to be moved before, we've been stuck in this.

1541
02:54:40.862 --> 02:54:43.510
<v Sameer Kanal>So anyway, that's the, that's the rationale here.

1542
02:54:43.735 --> 02:54:45.789
<v Sameer Kanal>I would love to have consideration of it.

1543
02:54:45.836 --> 02:54:51.724
<v Sameer Kanal>If I wanted to kill this just completely off and say this isn't a real thing, it's not important, I wouldn't be proposing to refer it back to committee.

1544
02:54:51.772 --> 02:54:54.130
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd be proposing to postpone it indefinitely.

1545
02:54:54.579 --> 02:55:04.936
<v Sameer Kanal>But because I do think there is merit to talking about this actual problem and addressing it in a way that addresses it, um, and doesn't go after a different situation.

1546
02:55:05.147 --> 02:55:14.688
<v Sameer Kanal>Because I do think there are plenty of tools that— and I'd love to ask when the ADA comes up, what other tools exist when there is a single property that is the nexus of so much of this?

1547
02:55:14.880 --> 02:55:15.943
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll just put that into the ether.

1548
02:55:16.072 --> 02:55:18.070
<v Sameer Kanal>But that's my rationale for the motion.

1549
02:55:20.340 --> 02:55:21.022
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1550
02:55:21.121 --> 02:55:21.921
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1551
02:55:22.203 --> 02:55:22.786
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

1552
02:55:23.301 --> 02:55:31.324
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, I'm sorry, briefly, colleagues, I will remind you there is still another item after this, and if we do not start the item by 9 o'clock, we must move that to the next agenda.

1553
02:55:32.351 --> 02:55:33.619
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that's in 10 minutes.

1554
02:55:33.666 --> 02:55:35.736
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we are probably gonna be moving it to the next agenda.

1555
02:55:36.378 --> 02:55:36.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Maria.

1556
02:55:37.405 --> 02:55:37.822
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1557
02:55:39.185 --> 02:56:03.824
<v Angelita Morillo>I just wanna say I have had to make the very tough choice of sending an ordinance back to committee when I was very certain, like fairly certain that based on the discussion at the dais that I had the vote but my algorithmic price-fixing ordinance, I realized that day that there was a legal issue that made the policy not as strong as it should have been to serve Portlanders.

1558
02:56:04.487 --> 02:56:11.614
<v Angelita Morillo>And even though it could have been an easy win that day, I made the choice to refer my policy back to committee for the good of the public.

1559
02:56:12.199 --> 02:56:13.706
<v Angelita Morillo>So it wasn't a cheap win.

1560
02:56:15.665 --> 02:56:19.559
<v Angelita Morillo>It did eventually pass, but I had to send it back to committee to fix the things that were wrong.

1561
02:56:19.610 --> 02:56:19.904
<v Olivia Clark>Councilmember Herbold.

1562
02:56:20.510 --> 02:56:23.647
<v Angelita Morillo>And then it did come back to council and it passed, and I think it will do good.

1563
02:56:25.120 --> 02:56:37.840
<v Angelita Morillo>So when I say that I think this needs more discussion, I don't say that lightly, and I don't say that as someone who— I've worked on a policy for months that I'm profoundly passionate about and had to make that tough choice.

1564
02:56:39.532 --> 02:56:47.313
<v Angelita Morillo>I think the issue here is that I don't just have issues with the amendments and not just with the but with the whole underlying code.

1565
02:56:47.361 --> 02:56:48.248
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that's correct.

1566
02:56:48.718 --> 02:56:53.351
<v Angelita Morillo>But if we're going to revisit the law, then we should do it thoroughly and we should do it right.

1567
02:56:54.020 --> 02:57:06.781
<v Angelita Morillo>It doesn't make sense for us to piecemeal this and to not do it, to not address all of the impacts that this could have on communities of color, on businesses that are not actually causing harm directly.

1568
02:57:08.396 --> 02:57:11.844
<v Angelita Morillo>And this is exactly what we're talking about here.

1569
02:57:11.958 --> 02:57:13.318
<v Angelita Morillo>This is the purpose of committee.

1570
02:57:13.554 --> 02:57:13.602
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

1571
02:57:13.943 --> 02:57:18.977
<v Angelita Morillo>Which is to make sure that we are fleshing out those conversations and addressing them.

1572
02:57:21.739 --> 02:57:32.332
<v Angelita Morillo>There are a lot of people that we have heard from, mostly in written testimony and to our offices, who are also experts on human trafficking, who have studied this issue extensively.

1573
02:57:33.934 --> 02:57:45.208
<v Angelita Morillo>And the committee, we discussed some of these things, but there were also, frankly, a lot of amendments that came out after committee, which means that we didn't have time to process them.

1574
02:57:45.850 --> 02:57:46.363
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's okay.

1575
02:57:46.507 --> 02:57:49.429
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm totally someone who has brought amendments last minute as well.

1576
02:57:49.942 --> 02:57:57.373
<v Angelita Morillo>But when you have about 6 amendments to process to code for code change, that is, uh, that is a very substantial, I would say.

1577
02:57:57.823 --> 02:58:06.023
<v Angelita Morillo>And I have been chided before and told that if I'm making substantial changes to a policy, that it needs to go back to committee to be processed.

1578
02:58:06.585 --> 02:58:13.039
<v Angelita Morillo>So So what I'm hearing is, frankly, a lot of vibes-based policymaking around the 3 versus 2.

1579
02:58:13.990 --> 02:58:18.219
<v Angelita Morillo>There is no evidentiary basis for some of these adjustments that we're making.

1580
02:58:18.752 --> 02:58:28.602
<v Angelita Morillo>We don't have analysis of these chronic nuisance cases that show what the right numbers are and why we are making those adjustments, other than we think it might have this impact, maybe.

1581
02:58:30.113 --> 02:58:31.449
<v Angelita Morillo>This is a good policy.

1582
02:58:31.576 --> 02:58:34.602
<v Angelita Morillo>It is an important policy, and it deserves Councilor Smith.

1583
02:58:34.665 --> 02:58:35.019
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Mayor.

1584
02:58:35.579 --> 02:58:37.569
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that this deserves due diligence.

1585
02:58:37.843 --> 02:58:45.832
<v Angelita Morillo>And so, again, I say this truly as someone who understands the position that it is to send a policy that you care about, that you've worked on really hard, back to committee.

1586
02:58:46.826 --> 02:58:50.549
<v Angelita Morillo>But I think that that is the right choice because there's just too much to process with this policy.

1587
02:58:50.596 --> 02:58:53.435
<v Angelita Morillo>There's too much drafting, and the amendments don't cut it either.

1588
02:58:53.725 --> 02:58:56.244
<v Angelita Morillo>But if it does come to that, I agree with Councilor Kanal.

1589
02:58:56.452 --> 02:58:59.725
<v Angelita Morillo>I would also approve to divide the question on each amendment.

1590
02:59:02.264 --> 02:59:06.478
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

1591
02:59:08.200 --> 02:59:08.783
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1592
02:59:10.083 --> 02:59:12.518
<v Steve Novick>First of all, thank you, Mr. President.

1593
02:59:13.549 --> 02:59:15.397
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Knoll and Councilor Murillo were on the committee.

1594
02:59:15.911 --> 02:59:25.888
<v Steve Novick>I do not recall them saying that they had a list of amendments they'd want to make, except Councilor Knoll had one to amend the underlying ordinance to eliminate the within 200 feet and have it just be on the property.

1595
02:59:26.668 --> 02:59:30.870
<v Steve Novick>So it was not like they offered a bunch of amendments that were voted down.

1596
02:59:30.997 --> 02:59:34.735
<v Steve Novick>So I don't see why they think that we would benefit from further discussion in committee.

1597
02:59:35.376 --> 02:59:38.519
<v Steve Novick>As the amendments we're talking about today, they're pretty straightforward.

1598
02:59:39.144 --> 02:59:40.442
<v Steve Novick>They're not hard to understand.

1599
02:59:41.726 --> 02:59:45.140
<v Steve Novick>One of them is instead of 2 and 90 days, 3 and 90 days.

1600
02:59:45.879 --> 02:59:48.493
<v Steve Novick>That softens the proposal a bit.

1601
02:59:49.486 --> 02:59:53.752
<v Steve Novick>The others are instead— Councilor Pirtle-Guiney is proposing that okay.

1602
02:59:53.816 --> 03:00:06.656
<v Steve Novick>Whereas the current law says that you can serve the person in charge by first-class mail, she wants there to be personal delivery to the property.

1603
03:00:07.217 --> 03:00:09.828
<v Steve Novick>That is not a very complex proposal.

1604
03:00:10.342 --> 03:00:23.230
<v Steve Novick>The other— another proposal is currently under the existing law, you can base the determination of whether something is a nuisance property is based on a police report.

1605
03:00:23.951 --> 03:00:31.264
<v Steve Novick>And Councilor Pirtle-Guiney and I decided that a police report— it should be that it should specify what the police report might say.

1606
03:00:31.890 --> 03:00:36.043
<v Steve Novick>This is not like— we don't have a whole bunch of like big, long, complicated things.

1607
03:00:37.263 --> 03:00:38.290
<v Steve Novick>They're pretty simple things.

1608
03:00:38.722 --> 03:00:41.529
<v Steve Novick>And I do think that my colleagues do simply want to delay.

1609
03:00:42.811 --> 03:00:46.581
<v Steve Novick>I don't think they see any reason to think that sending this back to committee would make any difference.

1610
03:00:46.661 --> 03:00:46.869
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1611
03:00:47.222 --> 03:00:48.283
<v Steve Novick>They don't like the underlying law.

1612
03:00:48.750 --> 03:00:49.730
<v Steve Novick>They don't like the proposal.

1613
03:00:50.036 --> 03:00:50.985
<v Steve Novick>That's not going to change.

1614
03:00:53.493 --> 03:00:54.313
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1615
03:00:55.309 --> 03:00:55.713
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

1616
03:00:57.040 --> 03:01:05.185
<v Candace Avalos>I think what we're saying is that there is plenty of written testimony, testimony from community, emails we are all receiving from constituents, our own experiences.

1617
03:01:05.462 --> 03:01:08.118
<v Candace Avalos>That is what we were saying is the reason it needs to go back to committee.

1618
03:01:09.295 --> 03:01:11.411
<v Candace Avalos>So, uh, there's your answer.

1619
03:01:14.440 --> 03:01:15.301
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1620
03:01:17.531 --> 03:01:32.103
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, uh, Keelan, can we please call a roll on the motion to refer back to committee?

1621
03:01:32.313 --> 03:01:37.915
<v Jamie Dunphy>So yes, a yes vote is to send the, uh, item back to committee.

1622
03:01:39.770 --> 03:01:40.060
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1623
03:01:40.805 --> 03:01:40.967
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1624
03:01:41.694 --> 03:01:42.164
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1625
03:01:42.745 --> 03:01:43.425
<v Keelan McClymont>Absent.

1626
03:01:44.137 --> 03:01:44.541
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1627
03:01:44.864 --> 03:01:45.011
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1628
03:01:46.370 --> 03:01:46.611
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1629
03:01:48.425 --> 03:01:48.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

1630
03:01:50.046 --> 03:01:50.256
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1631
03:01:50.612 --> 03:01:50.759
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1632
03:01:52.069 --> 03:01:52.604
<v Olivia Clark>Koyama Lane?

1633
03:01:52.960 --> 03:01:53.188
<v Mitch Green>No.

1634
03:01:54.629 --> 03:01:55.371
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

1635
03:01:55.775 --> 03:01:55.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1636
03:01:56.680 --> 03:01:57.019
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1637
03:01:58.117 --> 03:01:58.278
<v Steve Novick>No.

1638
03:01:58.601 --> 03:01:59.424
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1639
03:01:59.811 --> 03:01:59.974
<v Olivia Clark>No.

1640
03:02:00.781 --> 03:02:01.022
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1641
03:02:02.799 --> 03:02:02.977
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1642
03:02:11.180 --> 03:02:12.227
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Zimmerman.

1643
03:02:13.549 --> 03:02:15.240
<v Steve Novick>He's gone.

1644
03:02:15.483 --> 03:02:16.255
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't see him online.

1645
03:02:16.674 --> 03:02:17.561
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, absent.

1646
03:02:17.657 --> 03:02:18.045
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1647
03:02:22.899 --> 03:02:22.996
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

1648
03:02:23.318 --> 03:02:29.434
<v Keelan McClymont>The motion to refer the item back to committee fails with 4 yes votes, 6 no votes, and 2 absent.

1649
03:02:31.638 --> 03:02:33.404
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

1650
03:02:33.966 --> 03:02:45.573
<v Sameer Kanal>I move to divide the question of the amendment package into all of its subsidiary parts, and I will probably make a motion to divide some of them further, but I'm happy to defer to whatever order Councilors Novick and Pirtle-Guiney would like to go in.

1651
03:02:46.631 --> 03:02:46.808
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1652
03:02:47.370 --> 03:02:47.644
<v Sameer Kanal>Either one.

1653
03:02:48.254 --> 03:02:53.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, before we move on, I did promise the ADA if he would be able to answer that specific question.

1654
03:02:54.417 --> 03:02:54.818
<v Unidentified speaker>I know it's late.

1655
03:02:54.915 --> 03:02:55.574
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll be very quick.

1656
03:02:55.782 --> 03:02:58.141
<v Unidentified speaker>I was surprised— Councilor Ryan, thank you for bringing that up.

1657
03:02:58.207 --> 03:03:00.502
<v Unidentified speaker>I was very surprised by that reference yes.

1658
03:03:01.015 --> 03:03:05.737
<v Unidentified speaker>There is no one other, uh, more concerned about that than the District Attorney's Office.

1659
03:03:06.316 --> 03:03:16.754
<v Unidentified speaker>The District Attorney's Office every day in justice, in the judicial courts, requests individuals be held, requests bail be made, and file preventative detention hearings to hold people.

1660
03:03:17.316 --> 03:03:24.800
<v Unidentified speaker>The catch and release issues, uh, are squarely upon the funding of the jail and the jail beds open from the county.

1661
03:03:25.105 --> 03:03:33.186
<v Unidentified speaker>They are squarely upon the challenges for the defense attorney issues that are going on in the courts, and they're on the judicial decisions made in RECOG.

1662
03:03:33.282 --> 03:03:36.183
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you for allowing me to speak on that behalf.

1663
03:03:36.504 --> 03:03:37.770
<v Unidentified speaker>I also want to— there was one other question.

1664
03:03:37.834 --> 03:03:38.476
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll be very quick.

1665
03:03:38.796 --> 03:03:40.318
<v Unidentified speaker>This is not regarding one hotel.

1666
03:03:40.799 --> 03:03:42.097
<v Unidentified speaker>This is not regarding one motel.

1667
03:03:42.257 --> 03:03:44.132
<v Unidentified speaker>This is not regarding one specific part of the business.

1668
03:03:44.261 --> 03:03:50.078
<v Unidentified speaker>Part of the reason chronic nuisance works is because there are all these motels and other businesses that are doing the right thing.

1669
03:03:50.575 --> 03:03:55.944
<v Unidentified speaker>The vast majority are saying, we don't want this, we want to report this, we're spending money and resources to make sure this doesn't happen.

1670
03:03:56.024 --> 03:03:56.184
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1671
03:03:56.600 --> 03:04:01.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1672
03:04:01.190 --> 03:04:02.489
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1673
03:04:02.489 --> 03:04:05.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, I'm sorry, the motion to divide.

1674
03:04:06.129 --> 03:04:06.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, there we go.

1675
03:04:06.569 --> 03:04:08.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1676
03:04:09.129 --> 03:04:11.209
<v Steve Novick>I didn't want to— wasn't going to speak to the motion to divide.

1677
03:04:11.209 --> 03:04:23.629
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to say that given that it's 9 o'clock and Councilor Koyama Lane and I have already agreed that we're going to work on an additional amendment, that means that we're not going to set to vote on these amendments and then send this to second reading next week.

1678
03:04:24.200 --> 03:04:28.182
<v Steve Novick>So I think it makes more sense for us to recess and take this up at the beginning of the next meeting.

1679
03:04:30.132 --> 03:04:31.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>I agree.

1680
03:04:33.030 --> 03:04:41.453
<v Jamie Dunphy>It being 9 o'clock right now, we are not able to read the last item.

1681
03:04:42.051 --> 03:04:45.362
<v Jamie Dunphy>So these two— uh, it's too late.

1682
03:04:46.010 --> 03:04:47.156
<v Jamie Dunphy>These two items will be continued.

1683
03:04:48.315 --> 03:04:52.082
<v Jamie Dunphy>And, uh, We are out of time, so I— please.

1684
03:04:52.500 --> 03:04:53.977
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, they will be continued to—.

1685
03:04:56.212 --> 03:04:58.415
<v Sameer Kanal>Before you— yeah, before you adjourn the meeting.

1686
03:04:58.528 --> 03:05:02.708
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, yeah, you can suspend the rules with 9 votes if you want to do the grant thing.

1687
03:05:06.193 --> 03:05:07.398
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, uh, that's in the ordinance.

1688
03:05:07.913 --> 03:05:09.343
<v Jamie Dunphy>How do we move out of the item we're on?

1689
03:05:09.617 --> 03:05:11.673
<v Sameer Kanal>We— well, you, you just passed it to second.

1690
03:05:11.850 --> 03:05:12.911
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, just pass it on to—.

1691
03:05:13.086 --> 03:05:17.148
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the item is continued to the next So I will—.

1692
03:05:17.599 --> 03:05:18.658
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, it's suspending.

1693
03:05:19.028 --> 03:05:20.825
<v Sameer Kanal>So I will move to suspend the rules to allow for—.

1694
03:05:20.825 --> 03:05:21.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan is—.

1695
03:05:21.596 --> 03:05:24.985
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm sorry, staff was just released.

1696
03:05:25.226 --> 03:05:25.467
<v Jamie Dunphy>There you go.

1697
03:05:25.627 --> 03:05:26.013
<v Keelan McClymont>That item.

1698
03:05:26.494 --> 03:05:26.879
<v Candace Avalos>Good try.

1699
03:05:28.341 --> 03:05:29.191
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will get to it next time.

1700
03:05:30.027 --> 03:05:34.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, with that, these items will be continued and we are adjourned.

1701
03:05:43.558 --> 03:05:44.318
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh-huh.

1702
03:05:45.256 --> 03:05:48.023
<v Sameer Kanal>Whoops.

1703
03:05:50.772 --> 03:05:52.617
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, she didn't seem terribly cool.

