WEBVTT

1
00:05:38.060 --> 00:05:59.858
<v Anna Plum>Did you know that everybody can become self-sufficient after 7 years of disability?

2
00:05:59.923 --> 00:06:00.425
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>Tired of waiting?

3
00:06:00.490 --> 00:06:01.672
<v Candace Avalos>Oh yeah, I'm just starting.

4
00:06:01.947 --> 00:06:03.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon.

5
00:06:04.458 --> 00:06:08.302
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm now calling to order the joint work session of the City of Portland and Multnomah County.

6
00:06:09.444 --> 00:06:15.411
<v Jamie Dunphy>The subject of our meeting is our jurisdictions' roles and responsibilities in the homelessness response system.

7
00:06:15.459 --> 00:06:17.384
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to start by turning it over to Chair Vega-Peterson.

8
00:06:19.949 --> 00:06:23.975
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>All right, is it— yes, good afternoon everyone.

9
00:06:24.072 --> 00:06:27.002
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Really appreciate the chance to convene here in City Hall.

10
00:06:27.065 --> 00:06:30.946
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Thanks again for hosting us, President Dunphy and council members.

11
00:06:31.682 --> 00:06:31.975
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

12
00:06:32.057 --> 00:06:41.673
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I think that these joint sessions have proven to be really helpful for us as we are looking at how our 2 jurisdictions work together.

13
00:06:41.737 --> 00:06:45.574
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>They've been really important for us as partners to respond to homelessness in our community.

14
00:06:46.490 --> 00:07:02.629
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>And I think today especially, we're going to be hearing about and discussing our relative work in this area, which is a really crucial thing and also a really well-timed thing as we're both moving into our budget Uh, discussions, um, in the next month for both of our bodies.

15
00:07:03.367 --> 00:07:10.745
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>We all received a preview of the slides from our Homelessness Response System team, so thank you so much for doing that.

16
00:07:11.242 --> 00:07:26.336
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I really am impressed with the level of work that staff did to create informative graphics on roles and responsibilities between the city and the county, and I think that gives us an excellent starting point for our discussions today, as well as the investments from the— that multiple jurisdictions have on our homelessness programs.

17
00:07:27.041 --> 00:07:38.466
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>And I think this is especially important as we ensure that we are not duplicating any services or any systems, which we know is inefficient and it doesn't get us the results that we want to have.

18
00:07:39.059 --> 00:07:51.074
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>We need to keep this front and center as we are developing budgets, especially in the constrained resource environment that we're in, that the state is in, that we know that many of our partners are in as well.

19
00:07:51.795 --> 00:07:55.752
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I'm glad today that also we're going to have a very brief presentation and then we're going to have 90 minutes.

20
00:07:56.122 --> 00:07:57.084
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>For discussion and Q&A.

21
00:07:57.262 --> 00:07:59.877
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>So lots of time for all of us to talk today.

22
00:08:00.151 --> 00:08:03.649
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>So appreciate the chance for these remarks, and I'll turn it back over to you, President Dunphy.

23
00:08:03.730 --> 00:08:04.644
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Madam Chair.

24
00:08:04.934 --> 00:08:08.127
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm also going to turn it over to our Housing Chair, Councilor Avalos.

25
00:08:08.882 --> 00:08:10.165
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Council President.

26
00:08:10.310 --> 00:08:14.771
<v Candace Avalos>I am really excited to dive in today's, uh, dive into today's discussion.

27
00:08:15.365 --> 00:08:21.127
<v Candace Avalos>Um, this is a topic that I've been leading, um, conversations on since I've held the gavel of Homeless List and Housing Committee.

28
00:08:21.930 --> 00:08:22.011
<v Meghan Moyer>Hello.

29
00:08:22.059 --> 00:08:23.613
<v Candace Avalos>So hello, everybody's trickling in.

30
00:08:23.790 --> 00:08:24.769
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

31
00:08:25.153 --> 00:08:30.189
<v Candace Avalos>Over the years, we have seen the city move into areas that have historically been our responsibility.

32
00:08:30.380 --> 00:08:40.467
<v Candace Avalos>And in part, this is because the scale of homeless— the homelessness crisis put pressure on city officials to act, and because our old form of government led to a lack of long-term planning and siloed approach to policy.

33
00:08:40.884 --> 00:08:52.543
<v Candace Avalos>So while that scattered approach wasn't as much of an issue when we had plenty of resources flowing in from Metro and the state and federal resources, recent cuts and funding shortfalls mean that we have to fundamentally realign our priorities.

34
00:08:54.033 --> 00:09:02.322
<v Candace Avalos>The good news is that the work is already underway, and very grateful to all of the folks, especially the folks at this table, at the dais there, who have been leading that.

35
00:09:02.947 --> 00:09:09.423
<v Candace Avalos>So last year I led the Unified Housing Strategy resolution with Council President Dunphy, which council overwhelmingly supported.

36
00:09:09.888 --> 00:09:20.996
<v Candace Avalos>And the UHS is intended to create one comprehensive roadmap for our policies and programs across the homelessness-to-housing continuum, which will also clarify the city's responsibilities in our joint system.

37
00:09:21.605 --> 00:09:24.559
<v Candace Avalos>Now, earlier in January, I facilitated a work session as part Thank you.

38
00:09:24.559 --> 00:09:24.559
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Smith, thank you.

39
00:09:24.559 --> 00:09:31.090
<v Candace Avalos>So we had a public comment session as part of the UHS development where we spoke about where councilors see us leading in the wide world of housing policy.

40
00:09:31.480 --> 00:09:39.019
<v Candace Avalos>Overwhelmingly, councilors agreed that our first priority as a city should be on bricks and sticks, increasing housing production and homeownership.

41
00:09:39.419 --> 00:09:45.909
<v Candace Avalos>And as we see in the presentation graphic that will be posted here shortly, we're involved in a lot more than just housing production.

42
00:09:46.100 --> 00:09:53.764
<v Candace Avalos>We're involved in things like eviction defense and rent assistance, landlord-tenant resources, public space management, outreach, crisis management, and shelters.

43
00:09:53.957 --> 00:09:56.971
<v Candace Avalos>And so that gets to another major area of agreement among councilors.

44
00:09:57.403 --> 00:10:02.245
<v Candace Avalos>Many of my colleagues expressed the desire to move away from the city operating shelters.

45
00:10:02.293 --> 00:10:03.768
<v Candace Avalos>That's what I heard in that work session.

46
00:10:04.360 --> 00:10:14.124
<v Candace Avalos>And the January 15th work session and the many conversations we've had about the unspent housing funds as a council give us a good starting point for today's work session with our counterparts at the county.

47
00:10:14.956 --> 00:10:22.764
<v Candace Avalos>I wanna be clear that while funding shortfalls and major budget gaps at the city and county make today's discussion especially urgent, Councilor Smith.

48
00:10:22.812 --> 00:10:23.004
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Mayor.

49
00:10:23.052 --> 00:10:26.488
<v Candace Avalos>This is a conversation that we always should have been having regardless, right?

50
00:10:26.583 --> 00:10:31.609
<v Candace Avalos>So Portlanders put us here with the expectation that we should be doing better at addressing homelessness.

51
00:10:32.267 --> 00:10:41.110
<v Candace Avalos>And without alignment between our 2 governments, we will never deliver on that promise of a region where every person has a safe place to call home, which I know is all of our goal.

52
00:10:42.073 --> 00:10:48.991
<v Candace Avalos>I don't expect us to reach a place of final agreement by the end of today's work session, but I am grateful for the discussion and how you have structured the dialogue.

53
00:10:49.168 --> 00:10:53.599
<v Candace Avalos>So I hope that we can have some clarity after today that will align our path forward.

54
00:10:53.938 --> 00:10:54.361
<v Candace Avalos>That's all for now.

55
00:10:54.605 --> 00:10:54.865
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

56
00:10:55.157 --> 00:10:55.791
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

57
00:10:56.001 --> 00:11:02.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, I have 3 quick housekeeping things before we get started.

58
00:11:02.138 --> 00:11:07.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>First, to our county colleagues, I'd like to introduce our new city administrator, Raymond Lee.

59
00:11:08.380 --> 00:11:11.263
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is his first attempt— first meeting, joint meeting with you all.

60
00:11:11.363 --> 00:11:12.645
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I wanted to make sure everybody sees him.

61
00:11:12.712 --> 00:11:13.113
<v Jamie Dunphy>He's right there.

62
00:11:14.740 --> 00:11:22.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>So second, because our county colleagues are not in the Zoom meeting, I'm gonna ask folks to raise their hand, just make eye contact with me if you wanna get in the queue.

63
00:11:22.799 --> 00:11:26.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll write you down and I'll call things out so you won't have So you don't have to worry about it twice.

64
00:11:27.633 --> 00:11:34.475
<v Jamie Dunphy>Third, we have a tight 90 minutes for discussion, and that means it's only about 5 minutes per person to talk.

65
00:11:35.104 --> 00:11:44.676
<v Jamie Dunphy>At the very top here, I'm going to really quickly run through the prompt— discussion prompt questions that we sent ahead of time so that you have those in mind as we start the presentation, and then we'll dive in.

66
00:11:45.279 --> 00:11:51.485
<v Jamie Dunphy>The prompt questions were generally, first, does anyone have questions about the roles and responsibilities outlined here?

67
00:11:51.549 --> 00:11:51.615
<v Anna Plum>Yes.

68
00:11:51.806 --> 00:11:54.005
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we will have that opportunity to ask for clarifying questions.

69
00:11:54.970 --> 00:12:02.503
<v Jamie Dunphy>In a post-COVID environment and with one-time ARPA and SHS funding largely expended, what should each of our roles be?

70
00:12:03.610 --> 00:12:13.456
<v Jamie Dunphy>Given the fiscal constraints we both face heading into fiscal year '27, what shifts do you think we need to make in roles, in strategies, and in investments?

71
00:12:14.613 --> 00:12:17.841
<v Jamie Dunphy>What does a more unified, balanced system look like?

72
00:12:18.145 --> 00:12:27.282
<v Jamie Dunphy>And in the context of the recently approved revised HRS action plan and the key performance indicators, what does success look like to you?

73
00:12:27.331 --> 00:12:28.534
<v Jamie Dunphy>So let's keep those in mind.

74
00:12:28.663 --> 00:12:33.703
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll turn it now over to Director Shoney to lead us through a brief presentation.

75
00:12:33.817 --> 00:12:34.458
<v Olivia Clark>Great.

76
00:12:35.100 --> 00:12:36.738
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you, Council President, Chair.

77
00:12:38.216 --> 00:12:41.571
<v Jillian Schoene>For the record, my name is Jillian Shoney, Director of the Homelessness Response System.

78
00:12:42.149 --> 00:12:49.743
<v Jillian Schoene>Our goal here is to keep the presentation short, as was just mentioned, and use the 2 graphics before you to elicit a productive discussion amongst all of you.

79
00:12:51.458 --> 00:12:58.503
<v Jillian Schoene>As you all are well aware, our collective— the contributions to our collective response to homelessness are extensive and expensive.

80
00:12:59.256 --> 00:13:13.246
<v Jillian Schoene>The work requires a lot of coordination and collaboration, not just between the city and the county, but also Metro, the state, the federal government, and of course all of the public employees and the contracted providers that help us carry out this work.

81
00:13:14.096 --> 00:13:31.192
<v Jillian Schoene>We have been in partnership for decades, since 1983 to be exact, as I shared with y'all in the January memo I sent you, our relationship, the roles the city and the county have played, and the associated investments have varied over the years, and that's okay.

82
00:13:31.673 --> 00:13:45.525
<v Jillian Schoene>But the financial challenges and the shifting policy and investment decisions, particularly by the state and federal governments, require us to take a step back, look at the status quo, and use data to inform what will be a new normal.

83
00:13:46.522 --> 00:13:50.929
<v Jillian Schoene>We need to be realistic about what we can do and what we can achieve.

84
00:13:51.794 --> 00:13:54.552
<v Jillian Schoene>I hope that after today, this discussion doesn't end.

85
00:13:54.937 --> 00:14:03.065
<v Jillian Schoene>Please carry this forward in your one-on-one relationships with each other, into your respective budget discussions, and of course, your votes.

86
00:14:04.394 --> 00:14:07.408
<v Jillian Schoene>That said, I bring your attention to the first of 2 slides.

87
00:14:07.745 --> 00:14:18.164
<v Jillian Schoene>The goal of this graphic is to boil down all that the county and the city do in response to homelessness, and generally who leads and/or funds each piece of that work.

88
00:14:18.212 --> 00:14:18.325
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you.

89
00:14:19.139 --> 00:14:25.825
<v Jillian Schoene>I'll hand it off first— oh, let's just say, sorry, I have here with me the leadership of all of those efforts.

90
00:14:26.197 --> 00:14:34.557
<v Jillian Schoene>They will walk you through the graphic at a very high level from left to right to describe the work so that we're all operating with the same baseline information.

91
00:14:35.238 --> 00:14:41.956
<v Jillian Schoene>So I'll first hand it off to Rachel Pearl, Director of the Department of County Human Services, to speak to eviction prevention.

92
00:14:43.669 --> 00:14:44.221
<v Rachel Pearl>Thanks, Jillian.

93
00:14:44.917 --> 00:14:45.678
<v Rachel Pearl>Good afternoon, everyone.

94
00:14:45.986 --> 00:14:46.571
<v Rachel Pearl>My name is Rachel Pearl.

95
00:14:46.619 --> 00:14:46.991
<v Rachel Pearl>I use she/her pronouns.

96
00:14:47.089 --> 00:14:48.288
<v Rachel Pearl>I'm the Interim Director for Department of County Human Services.

97
00:14:51.508 --> 00:14:54.857
<v Rachel Pearl>And yes, I will start because DCHS— what's that?

98
00:14:55.049 --> 00:14:55.932
<v Rachel Pearl>Closer?

99
00:14:56.157 --> 00:14:56.397
<v Rachel Pearl>Okay.

100
00:14:56.572 --> 00:14:58.224
<v Rachel Pearl>I was asking about these mics.

101
00:14:58.321 --> 00:14:58.496
<v Rachel Pearl>Sorry.

102
00:14:58.673 --> 00:15:04.508
<v Rachel Pearl>I was also told I had 2 minutes, so excuse the speed of my conversation here with you.

103
00:15:04.828 --> 00:15:06.351
<v Rachel Pearl>DCHS is— is that better?

104
00:15:06.495 --> 00:15:06.993
<v Rachel Pearl>Can you hear me?

105
00:15:07.153 --> 00:15:07.505
<v Rachel Pearl>Is that working?

106
00:15:07.634 --> 00:15:07.730
<v Rachel Pearl>Okay.

107
00:15:08.596 --> 00:15:11.898
<v Rachel Pearl>DCHS is tasked with the prevention side of the continuum.

108
00:15:12.042 --> 00:15:17.445
<v Rachel Pearl>So essentially we are supporting households who are at imminent risk of becoming homeless.

109
00:15:17.974 --> 00:15:21.548
<v Rachel Pearl>We're also the designated community action agency in Multnomah County.

110
00:15:22.317 --> 00:15:29.326
<v Rachel Pearl>So eviction prevention is our most effective tool that we have to slow the inflow into homelessness.

111
00:15:30.241 --> 00:15:39.351
<v Rachel Pearl>This intervention at the county is particularly for households who have an eviction notice or are currently in a court eviction process.

112
00:15:40.427 --> 00:15:44.645
<v Rachel Pearl>Before the pandemic, eviction prevention did not exist in the county.

113
00:15:45.158 --> 00:15:50.759
<v Rachel Pearl>So obviously ARPA funds allowed us to build a rapid response Councilor Smith.

114
00:15:50.759 --> 00:15:50.759
<v Rachel Pearl>Thank you, Mayor.

115
00:15:50.759 --> 00:15:57.590
<v Rachel Pearl>So we have seen a tremendous response of upwards of $101 million in fiscal year 2022 as a result of that investment.

116
00:15:58.240 --> 00:16:02.659
<v Rachel Pearl>But today we are running out of fuel, essentially, if you will.

117
00:16:02.659 --> 00:16:10.529
<v Rachel Pearl>And the evictions that we're seeing are the highest we've ever seen in the state at the same time as resources are dwindling.

118
00:16:11.059 --> 00:16:17.220
<v Rachel Pearl>So, you know, why did we not need this method prior to the pandemic?

119
00:16:17.220 --> 00:16:22.192
<v Rachel Pearl>Well, obviously things have changed in our community, you know, as a result of rent increases, utility increases, Thank you.

120
00:16:22.240 --> 00:16:33.557
<v Rachel Pearl>So we've seen housing cost increases, food cost increases, income have flatlined, and that has resulted in a pretty serious problem for folks who are trying to keep themselves housed in our community.

121
00:16:34.557 --> 00:16:45.681
<v Rachel Pearl>So we moved from a peak from a budget perspective of over $100 million in ARPA funds primarily down to just $8.9 million for fiscal year 2026.

122
00:16:46.600 --> 00:16:50.937
<v Rachel Pearl>So that was in the height of this, we were able to serve over 3,500 households.

123
00:16:51.029 --> 00:16:58.970
<v Rachel Pearl>But with a lot of wraparound services and supports as well, which is something that we're often asked about is like, what are the additional retention strategies that we employ?

124
00:16:58.970 --> 00:17:03.710
<v Rachel Pearl>When we have only, you know, $8.6 million, we really are just preventing evictions.

125
00:17:04.309 --> 00:17:08.880
<v Rachel Pearl>When we have $100 million, we're able to do a lot more to support households with stability.

126
00:17:09.779 --> 00:17:16.430
<v Rachel Pearl>So as far as a current crisis that we're in, I think you're all well aware that evictions again are at an all-time high.

127
00:17:16.430 --> 00:17:21.089
<v Rachel Pearl>In the month of January, we saw over 2,500 evictions filed in this state.

128
00:17:21.089 --> 00:17:21.269
<v Rachel Pearl>That was the highest number that's ever been filed.

129
00:17:21.269 --> 00:17:21.289
<v Rachel Pearl>Wow.

130
00:17:22.930 --> 00:17:23.730
<v Rachel Pearl>Been recorded.

131
00:17:23.843 --> 00:17:26.361
<v Rachel Pearl>In February, we saw over 2,000 in the state as well.

132
00:17:27.355 --> 00:17:33.640
<v Rachel Pearl>Oftentimes in Multnomah County, we're seeing 40 to 60% of those evictions in the state are in Multnomah County.

133
00:17:33.721 --> 00:17:35.403
<v Rachel Pearl>So the need is significantly high.

134
00:17:35.709 --> 00:17:38.547
<v Rachel Pearl>The system that we have at DCHS is a no-wrong-door system.

135
00:17:39.059 --> 00:17:53.121
<v Rachel Pearl>We are partnering with culturally specific organizations who essentially are supporting households who come in with that eviction notification or in a court process and being able to help and navigate that, them getting able their rent to be able to be paid for them.

136
00:17:53.184 --> 00:17:57.865
<v Rachel Pearl>And we also have an internal county program, Bienestar de la Familia, who also provides that service.

137
00:17:59.036 --> 00:18:03.059
<v Rachel Pearl>We also, we don't just pay rent, we're also funding legal defense as well.

138
00:18:03.429 --> 00:18:14.554
<v Rachel Pearl>So our budget includes legal support through Commons Law and the Metropolitan Public Defenders to ensure that families have representation in the courtroom, which is really important so they can avoid that actual eviction going on their record.

139
00:18:14.826 --> 00:18:17.375
<v Rachel Pearl>We can't avoid evictions without paying back rent though.

140
00:18:17.423 --> 00:18:21.928
<v Rachel Pearl>So that's a really important distinction that we often find people are a little bit confused about.

141
00:18:22.056 --> 00:18:22.888
<v Rachel Pearl>Eviction prevention.

142
00:18:22.970 --> 00:18:26.334
<v Rachel Pearl>Eviction prevention is also our primary strategy for family stability.

143
00:18:26.509 --> 00:18:39.505
<v Rachel Pearl>It's our main tool for targeting and preventing childhood homelessness, which we often don't talk about, but is critically important to the long-term health of our community that we are absolutely prioritizing preventing childhood homelessness, and eviction prevention is critical to that.

144
00:18:40.690 --> 00:18:41.763
<v Rachel Pearl>And rent assistance works.

145
00:18:41.892 --> 00:18:44.007
<v Rachel Pearl>It's been proven effective throughout this country.

146
00:18:44.070 --> 00:18:51.345
<v Rachel Pearl>There's been many studies, but at DCHS, 92% of households receiving rent assistance remain stably housed 12 months after receiving that service.

147
00:18:51.925 --> 00:18:56.739
<v Rachel Pearl>And 85% of households avoid an eviction being on their record entirely.

148
00:18:57.336 --> 00:19:06.210
<v Rachel Pearl>And so until we solve the long-term housing affordability, rent assistance is going to be a critically important tool in our belt of slowing the inflow into homelessness in the county.

149
00:19:06.387 --> 00:19:08.034
<v Rachel Pearl>I'm not sure if I hit the 2 minutes.

150
00:19:08.082 --> 00:19:10.471
<v Rachel Pearl>I'm sure it was more, but that is my overview.

151
00:19:11.214 --> 00:19:11.635
<v Jillian Schoene>Michael.

152
00:19:13.542 --> 00:19:20.740
<v Michael Buonocore>Council President, Chair Vega-Peterson, councilors and commissioners, Michael Bonaccor, interim director of the Portland Housing Bureau.

153
00:19:21.221 --> 00:19:27.390
<v Michael Buonocore>For the record, I am dressed entirely in green today because Jillian insisted upon it, and I'm frankly a little scared of her.

154
00:19:27.535 --> 00:19:28.768
<v Michael Buonocore>That's okay.

155
00:19:29.153 --> 00:19:43.012
<v Michael Buonocore>The first thing I want to call your attention to in the orange box under eviction prevention, which is the city's services, it says rent assistance, which it also says in the county's box.

156
00:19:43.237 --> 00:19:50.652
<v Michael Buonocore>And that's an unfortunate miss on my part because I think it's worth distinguishing the phrases.

157
00:19:51.105 --> 00:20:05.288
<v Michael Buonocore>And really what we're talking about here is financial assistance associated with eviction legal defense, not ongoing rent assistance or vouchers as folks often conjure when they think of the phrase rent assistance.

158
00:20:05.401 --> 00:20:15.214
<v Michael Buonocore>So I just wanted to flag that as I go into this because I know this is a very energized conversation around sort of role, which role falls in which jurisdiction.

159
00:20:16.923 --> 00:20:19.060
<v Michael Buonocore>And as I said, I'll speak more about it specifically.

160
00:20:19.992 --> 00:20:31.655
<v Michael Buonocore>So first, the Portland Housing Bureau administers an eviction legal defense program through its Renter Services Office, and it provides legal advice and representation for tenants who are facing eviction.

161
00:20:32.653 --> 00:20:43.078
<v Michael Buonocore>In the first 2 quarters of this fiscal year, 235 households maintained their housing as a result of the program, and overall it has served about 4,000 households in total.

162
00:20:43.993 --> 00:20:52.375
<v Michael Buonocore>The eviction legal defense services are provided by Metropolitan Public Defender, Oregon Law Center, and the CLEAR Clinic.

163
00:20:53.146 --> 00:21:02.813
<v Michael Buonocore>In addition to legal services, the eviction legal defense program includes limited rent and other financial assistance intended to avoid eviction or mitigate the harms of eviction.

164
00:21:03.406 --> 00:21:10.999
<v Michael Buonocore>So this can be up to $6,000, and on average, Households receive around $4,500.

165
00:21:12.724 --> 00:21:25.163
<v Michael Buonocore>And so that gives you a sense of sort of the finite stabilization support that is provided as opposed to sort of ongoing payments to subsidize a person's rent.

166
00:21:26.587 --> 00:21:36.683
<v Michael Buonocore>On an annual basis, the budget is about $3.8 million, which consists of about $2.2 million in financial assistance that is contracted with the United Way.

167
00:21:36.877 --> 00:21:48.178
<v Michael Buonocore>So when our contracted legal defense providers are working with a client and determine that, say, a month of back rent is necessary to be paid off, they work with the United Way.

168
00:21:48.275 --> 00:21:54.556
<v Michael Buonocore>So the City of Portland is also not sort of in the business of administering those financial assistance funds.

169
00:21:56.880 --> 00:22:04.855
<v Michael Buonocore>And this— and the financial assistance is tied entirely to the eviction legal defense program and not available to tenants who are not facing eviction.

170
00:22:06.859 --> 00:22:17.786
<v Michael Buonocore>The Renter Services Office administers a host of other support services for landlords and tenants, including mediation services and a hotline for questions about landlord-tenant law.

171
00:22:20.119 --> 00:22:24.250
<v Jillian Schoene>Now we'll move to Outreach and Public Space Management and Safety, and we'll start with Skylar.

172
00:22:24.523 --> 00:22:26.380
<v Skylar Breading>Okay, thank you for having me.

173
00:22:26.443 --> 00:22:28.671
<v Skylar Breading>Skylar Breckernapp, Director of Portland Solutions.

174
00:22:28.768 --> 00:22:31.313
<v Skylar Breading>Chair, Council President, Mayor, City Administrator, appreciate you all being here.

175
00:22:32.906 --> 00:22:39.269
<v Skylar Breading>I forgot to wear green after Jillian told me, so this is the closest thing I had in my office, but we're doing our best.

176
00:22:39.636 --> 00:22:48.193
<v Skylar Breading>I'm going to go over just city outreach and then public space management, and Anna Plum and I are going to kind of go back and forth, as you see a lot of different colored boxes in these 2 sections.

177
00:22:48.241 --> 00:22:56.928
<v Skylar Breading>So city outreach performs traditional street outreach, which includes case management, day center, shelter, and detox and treatment referrals.

178
00:22:57.505 --> 00:23:09.961
<v Skylar Breading>I would say some of their unique roles have to do with overnight shelter outreach opening and closing, so providing that outreach, those services to folks who are entering or leaving the overnight shelter space.

179
00:23:10.268 --> 00:23:24.058
<v Skylar Breading>They also coordinate with the Impact Reduction Program, which we'll go over, at hotspots or large encampments or sites that are flagged by a lot of city employees, the public, in 3 times a week meetings that we have.

180
00:23:24.333 --> 00:23:26.903
<v Skylar Breading>Called the Street Services Coordination Center Coordination Group.

181
00:23:28.438 --> 00:23:42.065
<v Skylar Breading>The outreach also sometimes joins PPB or IRP contractors— sorry, Portland Police Bureau or the Impact Reduction Program contractors at site removals to offer those services.

182
00:23:42.420 --> 00:23:49.558
<v Skylar Breading>They also aid ODOT, the Oregon Department of Transportation, when they also are doing a removal and kind of request those services.

183
00:23:49.690 --> 00:23:50.010
<v Skylar Breading>Services.

184
00:23:50.058 --> 00:23:56.839
<v Skylar Breading>So trying to provide those outreach services to shelter or detox or day center services.

185
00:23:57.338 --> 00:24:00.403
<v Skylar Breading>They also are in charge of our reunification program at the City of Portland.

186
00:24:00.468 --> 00:24:07.018
<v Skylar Breading>So that's connecting folks to community, family, friends outside of the immediate area, that warm handoff program.

187
00:24:08.667 --> 00:24:12.791
<v Skylar Breading>CHAT, which is Community Health Assess and Treat, is under the Portland Fire Bureau.

188
00:24:13.375 --> 00:24:19.737
<v Skylar Breading>Many of you know what they do, but just a quick overview is light medical care, overdose response, reviving patients on the street.

189
00:24:20.218 --> 00:24:23.423
<v Skylar Breading>They administer withdrawal management and connections to shelter and treatment.

190
00:24:23.502 --> 00:24:26.915
<v Skylar Breading>They also coordinate really closely with all of the groups I just mentioned.

191
00:24:26.963 --> 00:24:38.405
<v Skylar Breading>So I think there's a lot of different ways to put these different groups in different boxes, but they really are performing a street-level service to a lot of the same folks that our outreach teams are seeing every day.

192
00:24:39.446 --> 00:24:49.847
<v Skylar Breading>Moving to public space management, that big orange box is going to include the Impact Reduction Program, which receives 100,000 annual camp reports from the community.

193
00:24:50.762 --> 00:25:01.459
<v Skylar Breading>We assess all campsites with the Clean Start Program through Central City Concern, remove camps and also just adjacent kind of trash with the most risk to health and safety.

194
00:25:01.523 --> 00:25:07.481
<v Skylar Breading>So lots of waste, hazardous waste, proximity to houses, schools, businesses, blocking ingress or egress.

195
00:25:07.546 --> 00:25:13.647
<v Skylar Breading>There's a whole point system and matrix that's been established based on several settlement agreements from different lawsuits.

196
00:25:14.836 --> 00:25:17.388
<v Skylar Breading>We also provide day storage through Central City Concern.

197
00:25:17.662 --> 00:25:25.016
<v Skylar Breading>The Glitter Program, which is through Trash for Peace, is a trash pickup program and employment opportunity, as well as the Wash House through Trash for Peace.

198
00:25:25.128 --> 00:25:28.067
<v Skylar Breading>So we partner with them to be able to launder textiles.

199
00:25:28.580 --> 00:25:32.980
<v Skylar Breading>They do that for folks on the street, but they also do it with other service providers, shelters, etc.

200
00:25:34.265 --> 00:25:34.376
<v Skylar Breading>Okay.

201
00:25:34.923 --> 00:25:42.356
<v Skylar Breading>PBOT, so the Portland Bureau of Transportation vehicle inspection team responds to reports of lived-in vehicles.

202
00:25:42.469 --> 00:25:43.690
<v Skylar Breading>That's cars or RVs.

203
00:25:44.316 --> 00:25:48.859
<v Skylar Breading>Our team coordinates with them, so they're in those 3 times a week street service coordination calls.

204
00:25:49.919 --> 00:26:02.170
<v Skylar Breading>Per state law, both camp removals and lived-in vehicles require a 72-hour notice, so they tag different vehicles and they let them know and warn them that that folks will be back to tow.

205
00:26:02.459 --> 00:26:07.228
<v Skylar Breading>They also coordinate with the Impact Reduction Program to clean up the outside of vehicles as needed.

206
00:26:07.276 --> 00:26:14.823
<v Skylar Breading>So if there's a lot of trash or things outside of the lived-in vehicle, they will help with that.

207
00:26:15.545 --> 00:26:20.314
<v Skylar Breading>The vehicle inspection team offers referrals to services, so day centers, overnight shelters.

208
00:26:20.362 --> 00:26:25.146
<v Skylar Breading>Again, they coordinate with those outreach teams, but they can also provide access and referrals to services themselves.

209
00:26:25.903 --> 00:26:31.328
<v Skylar Breading>So that's been something that we've coordinated in the last few years just for the deep need that we were seeing on the street.

210
00:26:32.230 --> 00:26:41.387
<v Skylar Breading>They also coordinate with city outreach and our team to refer RVs when there's space to the North Portland Road shelter, which allows RVs to be on site.

211
00:26:42.930 --> 00:26:50.320
<v Skylar Breading>Portland Police Bureau, 24/7 emergency response, enforces city's camping regulations with outreach and IRP.

212
00:26:50.951 --> 00:26:58.999
<v Skylar Breading>So that's a pretty limited scope, just because of the Neighborhood Response Team officers are— have a lot of things on their plates.

213
00:26:59.047 --> 00:27:12.500
<v Skylar Breading>It's a smaller subset of the Portland Police Bureau, and they coordinate about a couple days a week on various kind of hotspots or recurrent kind of camping areas that we're getting repeated outreach from community or city employees.

214
00:27:14.200 --> 00:27:18.174
<v Skylar Breading>The Behavioral Health Unit is also housed within the Portland Police Bureau.

215
00:27:18.276 --> 00:27:18.856
<v Skylar Breading>It's smaller.

216
00:27:19.405 --> 00:27:29.190
<v Skylar Breading>A lot of folks aren't— don't totally know all the ins and outs of it, but it's a specialized team for behavioral and mental health care on the street, which includes emergency response and service referrals.

217
00:27:29.238 --> 00:27:32.434
<v Skylar Breading>They also have some transitional housing through the service coordination team.

218
00:27:32.951 --> 00:27:35.730
<v Skylar Breading>I like to think of it— it's like a LEAD program in other cities.

219
00:27:35.795 --> 00:27:47.565
<v Skylar Breading>So those folks who have high rates of recidivism, have been in and out of the criminal justice system extensively, they really focus on working with those okay, uh, day centers.

220
00:27:47.661 --> 00:27:47.805
<v Skylar Breading>Yes.

221
00:27:48.221 --> 00:27:58.461
<v Skylar Breading>Um, so we also, um, recently, um, have, under the mayor's plan, um, coordinated with different day centers and, uh, stood up one of our own within the city of Portland.

222
00:27:58.877 --> 00:28:01.473
<v Skylar Breading>Um, so we coordinate and give funding to the JOIN Day Center.

223
00:28:01.538 --> 00:28:15.941
<v Skylar Breading>We were able to expand, um, their center on 82nd, um, and allow them to operate 7 days a week and for more individuals at that we also stood up the Oasis Day Center, which is an outdoor day space that's in Old Town.

224
00:28:16.855 --> 00:28:17.337
<v Skylar Breading>I will stop there.

225
00:28:18.124 --> 00:28:18.878
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Great.

226
00:28:18.942 --> 00:28:19.842
<v Anna Plum>Good afternoon, everyone.

227
00:28:19.906 --> 00:28:20.291
<v Anna Plum>Welcome.

228
00:28:20.869 --> 00:28:21.993
<v Anna Plum>Thank you for having us, not welcome.

229
00:28:22.330 --> 00:28:23.230
<v Anna Plum>My name is Anna Plum.

230
00:28:23.439 --> 00:28:27.421
<v Anna Plum>I use she and her pronouns, and I'm the interim director for Multnomah County's Homeless Services Department.

231
00:28:27.484 --> 00:28:28.368
<v Anna Plum>Nice to see you again.

232
00:28:29.042 --> 00:28:31.884
<v Anna Plum>So the Homeless Services Department does also fund day centers.

233
00:28:31.932 --> 00:28:35.336
<v Anna Plum>This is one of the things we do, we support in partnership with the City of Portland.

234
00:28:36.106 --> 00:28:38.414
<v Anna Plum>So we have day centers that we fund across the county.

235
00:28:39.249 --> 00:28:43.833
<v Anna Plum>We have ramped up some of those during some recent unanticipated revenue we got a few fiscal years ago.

236
00:28:44.137 --> 00:28:51.398
<v Anna Plum>So examples include the Marie Equi Center, which is a day center for our LGBTQIA2S+ folks who are experiencing homelessness.

237
00:28:52.073 --> 00:28:55.439
<v Anna Plum>We do focus our day services where we can on priority populations.

238
00:28:55.759 --> 00:28:59.013
<v Anna Plum>We also have day centers for youth at both Nafi and Outside In.

239
00:28:59.912 --> 00:29:07.028
<v Anna Plum>In some cases at these day centers, we are able to fund case management and housing support that folks can access at those day centers.

240
00:29:07.446 --> 00:29:10.037
<v Anna Plum>In some cases, that's assigned to that day center itself.

241
00:29:10.296 --> 00:29:15.006
<v Anna Plum>In other cases, it's via an in-reach model where folks are visiting that day center to meet people when they're there at the center.

242
00:29:16.690 --> 00:29:17.703
<v Anna Plum>I can transition to our outreach.

243
00:29:17.848 --> 00:29:17.993
<v Anna Plum>Yes.

244
00:29:18.316 --> 00:29:21.599
<v Anna Plum>So I'm going to back up to the top of the visual to talk about county outreach.

245
00:29:22.019 --> 00:29:24.450
<v Anna Plum>Again, this is another place where we partner with the city.

246
00:29:25.829 --> 00:29:31.115
<v Anna Plum>So Multnomah County funds 3 major kinds of outreach and then in-reach, which is similar but different.

247
00:29:31.647 --> 00:29:33.646
<v Anna Plum>So within outreach, we have 3 focuses.

248
00:29:33.743 --> 00:29:37.758
<v Anna Plum>The first the first is survival, so helping folks survive out on the streets.

249
00:29:38.270 --> 00:29:44.540
<v Anna Plum>We also focus on service navigation, helping people get referrals to the services that will help them, and then housing placement-focused outreach.

250
00:29:44.685 --> 00:29:49.785
<v Anna Plum>These are outreach workers who have access to housing assistance and can help people move directly into housing.

251
00:29:50.442 --> 00:29:58.444
<v Anna Plum>As we have experienced more and more resource constraint, we are focusing more on that housing placement-focused outreach to the extent that we can.

252
00:29:59.278 --> 00:30:05.019
<v Anna Plum>We have 8 zones across the county, and our providers are assigned to zones so that we have full coverage across the county.

253
00:30:05.933 --> 00:30:12.769
<v Anna Plum>With the exception that our culturally specific outreach and our health-related outreach, those are not assigned to a zone.

254
00:30:12.834 --> 00:30:14.326
<v Anna Plum>Those go across the whole county.

255
00:30:15.480 --> 00:30:20.615
<v Anna Plum>We have 9 providers, culturally community providers, who are providing outreach in the community right now.

256
00:30:21.402 --> 00:30:29.087
<v Anna Plum>And we also have recently launched a new outreach data collection method that is allowing us to get better information on what our outreach workers are doing and what they're accomplishing.

257
00:30:29.376 --> 00:30:32.121
<v Anna Plum>We're looking at engagements and referrals to services and other data.

258
00:30:32.184 --> 00:30:42.040
<v Anna Plum>So we're doing a better job in-reach is a similar model in that it involves people going to where folks are to help them get services and access housing.

259
00:30:42.491 --> 00:30:44.394
<v Anna Plum>But in-reach means you're going to a place.

260
00:30:44.828 --> 00:30:51.031
<v Anna Plum>So a lot of our in-reach is folks who are going to shelters or day centers where folks are and helping that person start their housing journey there.

261
00:30:51.113 --> 00:30:55.556
<v Anna Plum>So that's another sort of mobile service that we fund at the Homeless Services Department.

262
00:30:56.980 --> 00:30:57.142
<v Jillian Schoene>Shelters.

263
00:30:57.337 --> 00:30:57.500
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

264
00:30:58.069 --> 00:30:59.518
<v Skylar Breading>Thanks, Anna.

265
00:30:59.681 --> 00:31:02.708
<v Skylar Breading>Another part of our coordination and collaboration is our outreach efforts.

266
00:31:03.355 --> 00:31:04.221
<v Skylar Breading>Is the shelter space.

267
00:31:04.349 --> 00:31:09.175
<v Skylar Breading>So I'm going to go over the overnight shelter program, our newest program as of the last year.

268
00:31:09.865 --> 00:31:12.317
<v Skylar Breading>We have over 1,500 adult shelter beds.

269
00:31:13.311 --> 00:31:20.525
<v Skylar Breading>So that's 900, over 900 that are available tonight, and then almost 600 in flexible beds that could be open tomorrow if we need.

270
00:31:21.151 --> 00:31:23.538
<v Skylar Breading>They serve adults, families, and our recovery needs.

271
00:31:23.907 --> 00:31:28.203
<v Skylar Breading>So different kind of aspects that we saw a deep need for on the street.

272
00:31:28.829 --> 00:31:34.288
<v Skylar Breading>These are providing immediate care, so safety off the street, a safe place for someone to sleep tonight.

273
00:31:34.705 --> 00:31:39.859
<v Skylar Breading>Hot off the presses, we've provided over 100,000 nights of safe sleep in the last 11 months.

274
00:31:40.824 --> 00:31:44.452
<v Skylar Breading>We've promoted stability and engagement with services kind of through those efforts.

275
00:31:44.580 --> 00:31:49.943
<v Skylar Breading>We're really excited about further partnership with different services at those sites and with those providers.

276
00:31:50.056 --> 00:31:54.278
<v Skylar Breading>We just brought somebody on to really deepen those relationships and those service connection points.

277
00:31:55.178 --> 00:32:08.907
<v Skylar Breading>For 24/7 shelter, we have 8 sites with 705 different units representing 600 and— or 867 total beds, an additional 550 congregate shelter beds at Bybee Lakes as well.

278
00:32:09.628 --> 00:32:22.509
<v Skylar Breading>So those are providing beds for about 1,000 different individuals every night, providing on-site amenities like laundry, bathrooms, showers, kitchenette services, meals, and on-site wraparound services like case management and housing navigation.

279
00:32:23.343 --> 00:32:27.252
<v Skylar Breading>We also partner deeply with other organizations as well as the county at those different sites.

280
00:32:27.605 --> 00:32:28.406
<v Skylar Breading>I'll pass to Anna.

281
00:32:28.471 --> 00:32:29.031
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Thank you.

282
00:32:29.673 --> 00:32:33.567
<v Anna Plum>So the county homeless services department funds 24/7 shelters.

283
00:32:33.615 --> 00:32:36.019
<v Anna Plum>So our shelters are open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

284
00:32:37.028 --> 00:32:40.731
<v Anna Plum>In this fiscal year, we funded just under 2,600 units of shelter.

285
00:32:40.875 --> 00:32:44.128
<v Anna Plum>That is counting some of the alternative shelter for the city that we partially funded.

286
00:32:44.176 --> 00:32:45.346
<v Anna Plum>So there's a little bit of overlap there.

287
00:32:46.181 --> 00:32:52.734
<v Anna Plum>The bulk of our shelters are in the adult system, about 2,100 adult shelter units funded, and they're 24/7 funded by Multnomah County.

288
00:32:53.434 --> 00:33:03.752
<v Anna Plum>We also fund 185 units of shelter for survivors of domestic and sexual violence, just under 200 for the family system, 85 in the youth system, and then the rest is in that adult system.

289
00:33:04.855 --> 00:33:11.214
<v Anna Plum>In fiscal year 2025, the whole system served over 10,000 unduplicated people in shelter across both systems.

290
00:33:14.740 --> 00:33:18.913
<v Anna Plum>We also have— some of our shelter units are focused on folks who have higher behavioral health needs.

291
00:33:18.978 --> 00:33:20.115
<v Anna Plum>We partner with the health department.

292
00:33:21.012 --> 00:33:29.445
<v Anna Plum>It is funded via SHS, and those are sort of higher-intensity shelter units that are specifically for folks who have a higher behavioral health need to be successful in shelter.

293
00:33:31.262 --> 00:33:31.714
<v Jillian Schoene>Keep going.

294
00:33:31.811 --> 00:33:32.375
<v Jillian Schoene>Housing placement.

295
00:33:32.472 --> 00:33:32.811
<v Anna Plum>Okay.

296
00:33:33.102 --> 00:33:34.473
<v Anna Plum>Now I'm going to talk about housing placement.

297
00:33:34.715 --> 00:33:35.715
<v Anna Plum>Lots of blue boxes here.

298
00:33:35.876 --> 00:33:41.796
<v Anna Plum>So Multnomah County and the Homeless Services Department fund a lot of different housing placement programs, starting with transitional housing.

299
00:33:42.295 --> 00:33:43.792
<v Anna Plum>We do support transitional housing.

300
00:33:44.163 --> 00:33:49.251
<v Anna Plum>That specifically is housing that is short in nature, and typically the person might need to move.

301
00:33:49.332 --> 00:33:54.164
<v Anna Plum>If it's a physical location they cannot that's a difference between some of the rapid rehousing programs.

302
00:33:54.661 --> 00:33:57.561
<v Anna Plum>This is usually paired with a needs-specific set of supports.

303
00:33:57.898 --> 00:34:02.465
<v Anna Plum>So examples include our recovery-oriented transitional housing, which is a part of our continuum of care.

304
00:34:02.770 --> 00:34:08.764
<v Anna Plum>And we do have some behavioral health-focused transitional housing or transitional housing for folks who are exiting the justice system.

305
00:34:08.844 --> 00:34:11.826
<v Anna Plum>Those are some examples of some of that transitional housing that we support.

306
00:34:13.251 --> 00:34:15.094
<v Anna Plum>You'll see the box that says navigation support.

307
00:34:15.672 --> 00:34:21.248
<v Anna Plum>When we think specifically about our rapid rehousing and our PSH, a lot of the work is helping that person find that housing.

308
00:34:21.746 --> 00:34:28.815
<v Anna Plum>So that navigation support is some of the case management to meet folks, get to know them, find out what's going to work for them, and help them access that housing placement.

309
00:34:29.360 --> 00:34:33.193
<v Anna Plum>There are 2 really main ways that we help people find housing and stay in that housing.

310
00:34:33.561 --> 00:34:34.876
<v Anna Plum>The first is rapid rehousing.

311
00:34:35.228 --> 00:34:36.896
<v Anna Plum>That is also a shorter-term program.

312
00:34:36.992 --> 00:34:38.547
<v Anna Plum>It's usually up to 2 months.

313
00:34:38.851 --> 00:34:46.898
<v Anna Plum>The difference there is that typically that's someone being put into an apartment that they can stay in after that financial assistance is over, but they are then taking on that rent themselves.

314
00:34:47.027 --> 00:34:51.025
<v Anna Plum>So that's the difference between rapid rehousing and transitional housing at a very high level.

315
00:34:51.090 --> 00:34:52.744
<v Anna Plum>There are other differences that we could get into.

316
00:34:53.514 --> 00:35:05.429
<v Anna Plum>Permanent supportive housing is a longer-term, permanent being the key word, support with high-intensity support services that is meant for folks who would not be able to sustain that housing without that resource.

317
00:35:05.797 --> 00:35:09.458
<v Anna Plum>People need to— it's for folks who are chronically homeless and have a disability.

318
00:35:09.507 --> 00:35:12.284
<v Anna Plum>So there's specific eligibility for our permanent supportive housing program.

319
00:35:12.333 --> 00:35:12.445
<v Anna Plum>Thank you.

320
00:35:13.672 --> 00:35:19.565
<v Anna Plum>In fiscal year 2025, just over 6,000 people left homelessness for housing across all of these programs.

321
00:35:20.387 --> 00:35:28.295
<v Anna Plum>And right now, every month, we are placing hundreds of people into housing every month, and we're supporting thousands in our permanent supportive program of housing programs every month as well.

322
00:35:30.043 --> 00:35:38.748
<v Anna Plum>The end box, the other longer-term housing placement, we do have other programs that are longer-term but may not have that intensive level of support that you would see with permanent supportive housing.

323
00:35:39.266 --> 00:35:43.420
<v Anna Plum>One of them is reunification, is the word that you have probably heard here on the city side.

324
00:35:43.596 --> 00:35:55.527
<v Anna Plum>For a long time, our housing providers have been allowed to use their flexible client assistance programs to help someone move home if that home is not here and they have a stable, safe place to stay that is long-term that is not in our jurisdiction.

325
00:35:55.639 --> 00:36:02.182
<v Anna Plum>So a bus ticket, a plane ticket, that's something we've been able to do for a long time that I know the city is also really focusing on, which is a great efficient way to get people into housing.

326
00:36:02.936 --> 00:36:15.179
<v Anna Plum>We do also have some longer-term subsidies that are pretty much just a rental subsidy and are not paired with that higher case management need for folks who just need that long-term subsidy who will not be able to afford their housing on a long-term basis.

327
00:36:18.956 --> 00:36:19.945
<v Michael Buonocore>Housing development.

328
00:36:20.204 --> 00:36:21.954
<v Michael Buonocore>So here we are at the end of the spectrum.

329
00:36:22.570 --> 00:36:24.501
<v Michael Buonocore>I'll just make a couple of points here in the interest of time.

330
00:36:24.630 --> 00:36:28.574
<v Michael Buonocore>One, in the box you see planning, permitting, middle-income housing.

331
00:36:28.670 --> 00:36:31.641
<v Michael Buonocore>This reflects that while folks thank you.

332
00:36:31.706 --> 00:36:45.958
<v Michael Buonocore>So while folks intuitively think of the Portland Housing Bureau around housing development, it really is a service area function on a number of levels, including the permitting department, Bureau of Planning Services, and Prosper Portland.

333
00:36:47.922 --> 00:36:54.306
<v Michael Buonocore>PHB funds the development and preservation of affordable housing through competitive solicitation processes.

334
00:36:56.842 --> 00:36:57.050
<v Michael Buonocore>Thank you.

335
00:36:57.242 --> 00:37:12.596
<v Michael Buonocore>I think sort of obvious nexus in this conversation is that, for example, in the administration of the Portland Housing Bond and Metro Housing Bond funds, there were requirements around the number of permanent supportive housing units that would be added into new developments.

336
00:37:12.659 --> 00:37:23.628
<v Michael Buonocore>And so we, you know, sort of supported the designation of housing resources that helped contribute to development of new permanent supportive housing units.

337
00:37:26.250 --> 00:37:29.050
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you.

338
00:37:29.050 --> 00:37:30.650
<v Jillian Schoene>Next slide, please.

339
00:37:30.650 --> 00:37:38.559
<v Jillian Schoene>And this will be short and sweet, so pull out those discussion prompts shared by the council president because it's going to be your turn in just a few moments.

340
00:37:39.369 --> 00:37:43.570
<v Jillian Schoene>The second slide takes it one step further and weaves in large investments and how they typically flow.

341
00:37:43.570 --> 00:37:47.840
<v Jillian Schoene>This is actually at the request of council president staff, so kudos to them.

342
00:37:48.210 --> 00:37:50.730
<v Jillian Schoene>Please note, not every dollar is represented here.

343
00:37:50.730 --> 00:37:51.510
<v Jillian Schoene>That would be impossible.

344
00:37:52.150 --> 00:37:57.992
<v Jillian Schoene>And nor should you add these numbers because, again, because we have the council president's staff here, we're going to be able to talk about flow represented here as well.

345
00:37:58.217 --> 00:38:04.050
<v Jillian Schoene>For example, you're going to see some of those state monies right in the county and city amounts.

346
00:38:04.148 --> 00:38:05.637
<v Jillian Schoene>So no addition, please.

347
00:38:06.311 --> 00:38:07.289
<v Jillian Schoene>A few highlights.

348
00:38:08.394 --> 00:38:15.096
<v Jillian Schoene>I want to note that within the amount under the federal government, you— we have very meaningful investments in permanent supportive housing.

349
00:38:15.592 --> 00:38:22.373
<v Jillian Schoene>Generally speaking, most of that does go to community-based providers with following a local rating and ranking process.

350
00:38:22.452 --> 00:38:22.581
<v Michael Buonocore>Thank you.

351
00:38:23.061 --> 00:38:32.092
<v Jillian Schoene>With only a small portion remaining in the county budget, primarily for data systems, planning, and administering the process by which we place people into permanent supportive housing.

352
00:38:33.166 --> 00:38:38.411
<v Jillian Schoene>The future of this funding continues to have a very big question mark over it, as has been mentioned to you before.

353
00:38:38.619 --> 00:38:49.414
<v Jillian Schoene>And all of us just got out of a meeting with HUD, who was here on the ground this morning doing some discussions with communities throughout the country in the context of the direction that they will be going.

354
00:38:49.461 --> 00:38:51.193
<v Jillian Schoene>So please stay tuned for big shifts.

355
00:38:51.291 --> 00:38:51.579
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you.

356
00:38:52.077 --> 00:39:01.407
<v Jillian Schoene>In many millions of dollars that affect hundreds, potentially thousands of lives of people who are already housed here when fiscal '28— fiscal year '28 rolls around.

357
00:39:02.677 --> 00:39:05.550
<v Jillian Schoene>At the state, we typically track 4 buckets of investments.

358
00:39:05.599 --> 00:39:09.356
<v Jillian Schoene>You see those there: shelter, eviction prevention, short- and long-term rent assistance.

359
00:39:09.822 --> 00:39:21.824
<v Jillian Schoene>As you will recall, they made deep cuts, which resulted, just by way of example, in a $28 million cut in the middle of a fiscal year for HSD and a $5 million cut for DCHS and eviction prevention.

360
00:39:23.760 --> 00:39:30.655
<v Jillian Schoene>Jumping to Metro, they play an oversight role and they look to take on issues that really should be addressed at a regional level.

361
00:39:31.775 --> 00:39:37.594
<v Jillian Schoene>I hope to see this work intensifying under the renewed oversight body that they are literally putting in place right now as we speak.

362
00:39:38.500 --> 00:39:47.943
<v Jillian Schoene>A lot of the work that we partner with them on right now relates to the connections between health— the healthcare system and the homelessness response system, both housing and shelter.

363
00:39:48.311 --> 00:39:51.246
<v Jillian Schoene>The data work around that is phenomenal, phenomenal, y'all.

364
00:39:51.391 --> 00:39:54.614
<v Jillian Schoene>It is nationally recognized, and we are really ahead of the game there.

365
00:39:55.608 --> 00:40:09.784
<v Jillian Schoene>Those 3 entities, the feds, the state, and Metro, I label as investment inputs, which is different than the city and the county that both invest local funds and also perform the work, the outputs, in partnership with contracted providers.

366
00:40:10.778 --> 00:40:15.878
<v Jillian Schoene>Beyond that, I'm not going to go through the county and the city any further because we just did that on the previous slide.

367
00:40:15.990 --> 00:40:16.119
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you.

368
00:40:17.018 --> 00:40:27.414
<v Jillian Schoene>But I do want to just highlight the black arrows here that represent the typical flow of funds, with most of the monies coming together and being braided and invested by the county.

369
00:40:28.717 --> 00:40:37.164
<v Jillian Schoene>I think a really good example of how you really do need one entity being on the receiving end of the investments is how we fund permanent supportive housing.

370
00:40:37.679 --> 00:40:46.014
<v Jillian Schoene>We take federal money, we take state money, we layer in some regional and local funds, including some general fund, and we make that program whole.

371
00:40:46.063 --> 00:40:51.521
<v Jillian Schoene>Like, Somebody needs to be putting the pieces of the puzzle together and making things happen.

372
00:40:52.775 --> 00:40:57.208
<v Jillian Schoene>And finally, I will just say the city and the county have a history of exchanging funds.

373
00:40:57.257 --> 00:41:04.469
<v Jillian Schoene>That's why you see the double arrow there, depending on how the partnership is defined and the priorities of any given administration and the elected bodies.

374
00:41:05.706 --> 00:41:11.217
<v Jillian Schoene>With that, I will hand it back to Council President Dunphy and Chair Vega Pedersen for discussion.

375
00:41:11.489 --> 00:41:12.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

376
00:41:12.710 --> 00:41:16.806
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now, colleagues, first to start, if there's anything any technical or clarifying questions for our panel?

377
00:41:17.016 --> 00:41:17.273
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then we—.

378
00:41:17.530 --> 00:41:19.489
<v Jamie Dunphy>Otherwise we can jump into conversations.

379
00:41:19.536 --> 00:41:22.172
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'll remind you all, we've each got about 5 minutes to talk.

380
00:41:22.637 --> 00:41:26.186
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, so, uh, if folks want to raise a hand, let me know.

381
00:41:26.652 --> 00:41:28.259
<v Candace Avalos>Point of information process.

382
00:41:28.693 --> 00:41:30.813
<v Candace Avalos>So there's like different discussion prompts.

383
00:41:30.909 --> 00:41:35.568
<v Candace Avalos>Are you planning on going through each and then we speak, or you want us to use our 5 minutes to answer all of them?

384
00:41:35.664 --> 00:41:39.391
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think let's use our, our 5 minutes to answer, um, however you want to do those.

385
00:41:39.438 --> 00:41:45.472
<v Jamie Dunphy>Those are just the general prompts of kinds of things I'd love to have us all discuss, um, rather than going round by round.

386
00:41:45.552 --> 00:41:46.068
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

387
00:41:46.150 --> 00:41:47.376
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Commissioner Moyer.

388
00:41:48.365 --> 00:41:48.606
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

389
00:41:50.728 --> 00:41:51.275
<v Meghan Moyer>Okay, thank you.

390
00:41:51.820 --> 00:41:56.094
<v Meghan Moyer>Um, as this is very helpful, thank you.

391
00:41:56.400 --> 00:41:59.574
<v Meghan Moyer>Um, as is the financial breakdown of this.

392
00:41:59.784 --> 00:42:25.753
<v Meghan Moyer>Um, I think it's really telling how little help we get both from our federal government and and our state, um, being that this is repeatedly, at least regionally outside of just Multnomah County but also Washington and Clackamas County, consistently one of the most important issues to residents is our collective response to our homeless crisis.

393
00:42:26.507 --> 00:42:35.871
<v Meghan Moyer>Some of the questions that I have and comments I have, um, I already know the answer to, but I think it's important yes.

394
00:42:36.193 --> 00:42:48.061
<v Meghan Moyer>For us to think about, which is some of the changing dynamics and the opportunities that we, um, may or may not have, uh, available to us and where we're at in those processes.

395
00:42:48.190 --> 00:43:04.467
<v Meghan Moyer>One is, um, the governor talks often about homelessness and, uh, behavioral health and, um, as a reason she ran and things that she has focused on.

396
00:43:04.724 --> 00:43:19.846
<v Meghan Moyer>To what degree has the governor helped facilitate Multnomah County or the City of Portland getting Medicaid match for permanent supported housing like many other communities nationwide?

397
00:43:20.393 --> 00:43:24.181
<v Meghan Moyer>Because only the Oregon Health Association can apply for that.

398
00:43:26.465 --> 00:43:36.364
<v Jillian Schoene>I would describe that as an active dialogue that has happened in various iterations over the years, primarily with Multnomah County knocking on the door of the state of Oregon.

399
00:43:37.362 --> 00:43:38.860
<v Jillian Schoene>We've made some progress recently.

400
00:43:39.052 --> 00:43:40.148
<v Jillian Schoene>We got some attention.

401
00:43:40.277 --> 00:43:43.481
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you, Commissioner Moyer, for your leadership on a letter that we sent the state.

402
00:43:43.561 --> 00:43:53.141
<v Jillian Schoene>There is going to be a workgroup set up to get more people enrolled that have severe and persistent mental illness.

403
00:43:53.543 --> 00:43:55.059
<v Jillian Schoene>We hope to get traction on that.

404
00:43:57.307 --> 00:44:05.715
<v Jillian Schoene>But, and in the governor's recent executive order, you saw that she mentioned 2 new pilots related to permanent supportive housing.

405
00:44:06.532 --> 00:44:12.333
<v Jillian Schoene>Um, to my knowledge, unless the chair or somebody else has heard, we're still waiting to hear where those pilots are.

406
00:44:12.414 --> 00:44:15.443
<v Jillian Schoene>Of course, our first question was, one will be in Multnomah County, right?

407
00:44:15.938 --> 00:44:25.376
<v Jillian Schoene>So know that we are constantly knocking on that door to figure out where the opportunities are because, um, we need to solve that problem.

408
00:44:26.483 --> 00:44:31.427
<v Meghan Moyer>Related to, um, Who is experiencing unsheltered homelessness?

409
00:44:31.940 --> 00:44:50.628
<v Meghan Moyer>Uh, little less than a year ago, Health Share embarked on a data match with our, uh, by-names list, which showed some really important information for us in understanding who is on our streets and who is needing to access shelters on a regular basis.

410
00:44:50.996 --> 00:45:07.237
<v Meghan Moyer>Some of the information that came out of that and, um, was presented to City Council and others was that 50% of the individuals who are in our shelters each night, um, have a pre-existing diagnosis of a severe mental illness.

411
00:45:08.152 --> 00:45:22.079
<v Meghan Moyer>Um, we also know that that is a primary driver of people's need for permanent supported housing, and yet Oregon is ranked 50th out of 51 states or territories in behavioral health.

412
00:45:24.085 --> 00:45:39.201
<v Meghan Moyer>Um, what degree has the state of Oregon partnered in making sure that we have the necessary services for people who experience behavioral health issues that contribute to experiencing homelessness?

413
00:45:40.840 --> 00:45:41.210
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Do it again.

414
00:45:41.628 --> 00:45:42.094
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, go ahead.

415
00:45:42.675 --> 00:45:56.070
<v Jillian Schoene>Um, first, uh, thank you for the question, Commissioner, and this is where I will just remind everybody in the public that homelessness housing production is at the top of the list, healthcare generally, and then behavioral health is very close behind.

416
00:45:56.369 --> 00:46:10.469
<v Jillian Schoene>So we have a shelter system, a homelessness response system more generally, acting as a— providing services in place of other broken systems, right?

417
00:46:10.469 --> 00:46:15.989
<v Jillian Schoene>So I would say on permanent supportive housing, I also want to just say it does work.

418
00:46:16.750 --> 00:46:16.929
<v Jillian Schoene>Mm-hmm.

419
00:46:16.929 --> 00:46:27.795
<v Jillian Schoene>I just don't think that we're necessarily there on scale, whether you're talking about permanent supportive housing or other types of the Medicaid piece or just services in general, like 84% of the people who we place in permanent supportive housing are still there 2 years later.

420
00:46:29.141 --> 00:46:36.677
<v Jillian Schoene>We need to keep running down that track hard and fast and to just continue figuring it out, to just do it even better.

421
00:46:37.222 --> 00:46:38.954
<v Jillian Schoene>We're on the right track, but we just need more.

422
00:46:39.403 --> 00:46:39.644
<v Jamie Dunphy>Anna?

423
00:46:40.286 --> 00:46:40.847
<v Anna Plum>Yeah, no, I would agree.

424
00:46:40.927 --> 00:46:53.440
<v Anna Plum>I think we do a lot of things to partner and try to shore up the gaps in our behavioral health system, but we simply cannot we can't do that on our own, and so it's really important that we keep partnering with our health partners, not just within the county, across the community.

425
00:46:53.521 --> 00:47:00.101
<v Anna Plum>That's sort of the goal and the dream of the Homelessness Response System, is to bring those partners to the table so we're working on a holistic problem as a holistic body.

426
00:47:00.902 --> 00:47:19.657
<v Meghan Moyer>Then my last question, acknowledging that we might have service gaps which are outside of homeless response but certainly are contributing to the inflow and some of the challenges people experience in finding and keeping permanent housing.

427
00:47:20.155 --> 00:47:26.186
<v Meghan Moyer>Do you know the amount of money that our— that HealthShare cut in local behavioral health this last year?

428
00:47:28.282 --> 00:47:29.262
<v Meghan Moyer>It's $100 million.

429
00:47:30.596 --> 00:47:49.032
<v Meghan Moyer>Has that positively influenced Medicaid recipients' ability to access necessary behavioral health care, which and I would assume if 50% of our, uh, unsheltered population is experiencing, they need access to on their journey to, to permanency.

430
00:47:49.793 --> 00:47:56.240
<v Meghan Moyer>Are, are we seeing positive outcomes from cutting $100 million of behavioral health services?

431
00:47:59.577 --> 00:47:59.739
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No.

432
00:48:00.239 --> 00:48:01.617
<v Anna Plum>I would say no.

433
00:48:02.425 --> 00:48:03.704
<v Meghan Moyer>I, I would also say no.

434
00:48:03.802 --> 00:48:04.175
<v Rachel Pearl>I didn't—.

435
00:48:04.190 --> 00:48:07.376
<v Jillian Schoene>I'm going I'm going to go on a limb based on the timing when those cuts came down.

436
00:48:07.585 --> 00:48:09.239
<v Jillian Schoene>I'm not sure we've seen the full picture yet.

437
00:48:09.351 --> 00:48:09.625
<v Jillian Schoene>Correct.

438
00:48:09.704 --> 00:48:10.476
<v Jillian Schoene>So more to come.

439
00:48:10.556 --> 00:48:14.938
<v Meghan Moyer>So I bring this up not because I'm in any way trying to beat up on—.

440
00:48:14.938 --> 00:48:16.271
<v Jamie Dunphy>Commissioner, we're at 6 minutes.

441
00:48:16.512 --> 00:48:16.608
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

442
00:48:16.914 --> 00:48:17.876
<v Meghan Moyer>I just want to end.

443
00:48:18.021 --> 00:48:42.076
<v Meghan Moyer>My last comment is homeless services alone cannot resolve our homeless crisis, and we absolutely have to have better support from the state in addressing unmet behavioral health needs, or it will continue to be an upward fight that we do not have the resources to do.

444
00:48:42.188 --> 00:48:44.001
<v Meghan Moyer>They have to be a better partner.

445
00:48:44.835 --> 00:48:45.556
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Commissioner.

446
00:48:45.637 --> 00:48:47.208
<v Jamie Dunphy>Commissioner Bram Edwards.

447
00:48:48.025 --> 00:48:49.693
<v Jamie Dunphy>You all have a lot of last names.

448
00:48:49.967 --> 00:48:50.623
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Thank you.

449
00:48:50.784 --> 00:48:51.938
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I like the 3 letters.

450
00:48:52.597 --> 00:49:01.726
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, so I also had— oh, thank you for, um, I think this is a very useful chart just to, uh, for us to be— as we look at our roles and responsibilities.

451
00:49:02.559 --> 00:49:04.213
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, I just had a question.

452
00:49:04.630 --> 00:49:09.606
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, behavioral health wasn't also under the housing placement, um, it was under the shelter.

453
00:49:09.702 --> 00:49:14.244
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>But, um, I know there's a comment that just says this does not include the regional system of behavioral health.

454
00:49:15.061 --> 00:49:19.699
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, it seems like that's a missing component, like just a call out for the, uh, for the county.

455
00:49:20.534 --> 00:49:31.798
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>And then the other— when I look at this, it seems comprehensive, but then I look at the reasons for why, why there's inflow, and so much of them relate to money.

456
00:49:33.306 --> 00:49:41.373
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>And I'm trying to see where on this chart we talk about like employment-related services or any sort of income generation.

457
00:49:41.567 --> 00:50:04.561
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I mean, if we're just dealing with the housing but not some of the underlying systems, it seems like there is a place where we would want to look at like how are we supporting individuals in terms of just self-sufficiency or, you know, their portion of what they, they need to do towards their rent or just, you know, life's basics.

458
00:50:04.835 --> 00:50:09.086
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, and, and the city and county may be like, that's not our jobs.

459
00:50:09.425 --> 00:50:18.844
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, but it's— I'm then curious who's paying attention to that because that seems pretty fundamental to the reason of why people are being yes, you're right.

460
00:50:18.893 --> 00:50:27.043
<v Anna Plum>It's not on this slide, but we do— Multnomah County does fund employment programs that are performed by contracted providers.

461
00:50:27.539 --> 00:50:35.465
<v Anna Plum>This year we had somewhere between $5 and $6 million of employment programs in our budget, a variety of low-barrier, higher-barrier income acquisition programs.

462
00:50:36.202 --> 00:50:43.342
<v Anna Plum>I will say that it's— we— I think everyone agrees that employment is a really important path to stability for a lot of folks.

463
00:50:45.106 --> 00:51:00.788
<v Anna Plum>As we're focusing on what we are able to do as a region and what certain groups can do, we're going to have to be really thoughtful about, again, what is the larger community's ability to support some of these programs that are not necessarily a housing placement program, which is historically the role of the Homeless Services Department.

464
00:51:00.835 --> 00:51:04.030
<v Anna Plum>So completely agree, employment programs are super important to our community.

465
00:51:05.090 --> 00:51:06.019
<v Anna Plum>We are funding them now.

466
00:51:06.469 --> 00:51:09.969
<v Anna Plum>We know we're moving into future constraint, and so what that looks like will be something I think we're going to have to figure out.

467
00:51:10.016 --> 00:51:10.144
<v Anna Plum>Thank you.

468
00:51:10.385 --> 00:51:14.056
<v Skylar Breading>And I'll just mention on the city side, Commissioner, that's a great question.

469
00:51:15.291 --> 00:51:27.971
<v Skylar Breading>We see kind of a lot of those programs pop up in kind of that day center box, but also in the 24/7 shelter box as part of the wraparound services and kind of opportunities that are brought on those sites and that resource navigation that happens.

470
00:51:28.356 --> 00:51:34.014
<v Skylar Breading>I would also just say, I think it's not often discussed, but a lot of our contractors are second chance employers.

471
00:51:34.447 --> 00:51:40.681
<v Skylar Breading>So we're really investing pretty heavily, frankly, in I mentioned Clean Start Program, the Glitter Program.

472
00:51:40.730 --> 00:51:46.456
<v Skylar Breading>There's a lot of really great second chance employers that we are employing through the whole system that you see in front of you.

473
00:51:47.358 --> 00:52:07.815
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Yeah, I'd love to have that somehow captured here because whether it's Ground Score or Cultivate Initiatives or PDX St. Love's, if you find that people who have an opportunity for that, if they've been chronically homeless, have an opportunity for some sort of employment or entry-level employment, they have much higher rates ultimately of being housed or getting housed.

474
00:52:09.204 --> 00:52:18.827
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So that'd just be one thing that I would love to see on this larger mix because it seems like it is a key pathway to people having more stability.

475
00:52:20.452 --> 00:52:21.842
<v Rachel Pearl>Commissioner, can I chime in really quick?

476
00:52:22.052 --> 00:52:40.960
<v Rachel Pearl>I just want to say that in, in DCHS, we also have our Aging, Disability, and Veterans Services Division and our Intellectual and Developmental Disability Services Division, which both have long-term case management, which we both provide homeless services and prevention services with long-term case management in those programs that also have employment services connected to that.

477
00:52:41.009 --> 00:52:59.202
<v Rachel Pearl>So it's an important part, I think, of the continuum that we don't call out here, that like DCHS is the safety net services for the county, and there's a lot of specific targeted support to specific populations who are quite vulnerable to becoming homeless and are becoming homeless at faster rates than, than other folks.

478
00:53:01.119 --> 00:53:02.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you, Commissioner.

479
00:53:02.853 --> 00:53:03.467
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

480
00:53:05.184 --> 00:53:06.172
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, President Dunphy.

481
00:53:06.561 --> 00:53:07.614
<v Dan Ryan>Good to see you, Madam Chair.

482
00:53:08.769 --> 00:53:14.164
<v Dan Ryan>Um, you're one of the only people that have been around, uh, as long as I have now, so it's good to, um, have that continuity.

483
00:53:14.260 --> 00:53:16.835
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for your service, and thank you for the panel.

484
00:53:16.996 --> 00:53:22.168
<v Dan Ryan>I want to start by acknowledging I had the pleasure of being at Senator Avel Gordley's service this morning.

485
00:53:22.590 --> 00:53:26.228
<v Dan Ryan>It was good to see you, Mr. Mayor, and Councilor Clark there.

486
00:53:26.329 --> 00:53:27.867
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

487
00:53:28.621 --> 00:53:35.146
<v Dan Ryan>She was a champion in many areas, but she was definitely a bold champion for mental health and behavioral health.

488
00:53:35.275 --> 00:53:39.266
<v Dan Ryan>In fact, it got her into some cahoots with their own party, the Democratic Party.

489
00:53:39.972 --> 00:53:40.949
<v Dan Ryan>And this is a statement.

490
00:53:41.974 --> 00:53:55.023
<v Dan Ryan>In my 5 and a half years in this space, and I appreciate some of the questions earlier, I continue to be baffled by how we don't lift and focus more on behavioral health and mental health.

491
00:53:55.840 --> 00:53:57.123
<v Dan Ryan>And the county is the provider.

492
00:53:57.844 --> 00:54:03.469
<v Dan Ryan>We can blame all the sources all we want, but you are the mental health and behavioral health provider.

493
00:54:04.253 --> 00:54:14.157
<v Dan Ryan>And I just hope that we can keep being more bold and honest about the fact that so many are suffering on our streets even before they were homeless.

494
00:54:15.021 --> 00:54:20.599
<v Dan Ryan>I know way too many people in my life that became homeless was because of behavioral health and addictions.

495
00:54:21.260 --> 00:54:25.358
<v Dan Ryan>They lost their families, they lost their jobs, and they ended up on the streets.

496
00:54:26.199 --> 00:54:29.322
<v Dan Ryan>So I hope that we continue to not stuff that.

497
00:54:29.934 --> 00:54:32.686
<v Dan Ryan>This is a couple quick questions under the what happened.

498
00:54:33.760 --> 00:54:44.353
<v Dan Ryan>So in '21 to '23, you recall this, Chair Vega-Peterson, we really focused on having a promise of providing services for those that were showing improvements.

499
00:54:44.402 --> 00:54:44.452
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

500
00:54:45.358 --> 00:54:47.541
<v Dan Ryan>Showing some agency to live independently.

501
00:54:47.686 --> 00:54:55.056
<v Dan Ryan>They were in our 24-hour shelters with services, which was a pioneer step finally amongst our two jurisdictions.

502
00:54:56.197 --> 00:55:02.844
<v Dan Ryan>We focused on them getting housed after they showed some agency being built and some independence.

503
00:55:03.021 --> 00:55:08.077
<v Dan Ryan>You see some of the incremental gains, oddly enough, in the data right after that commitment.

504
00:55:08.978 --> 00:55:10.005
<v Dan Ryan>What happened to that commitment?

505
00:55:12.733 --> 00:55:14.273
<v Dan Ryan>The commitment to what specifically?

506
00:55:15.059 --> 00:55:30.563
<v Dan Ryan>To prioritizing those that are in services, in 24/7 services particularly, that are showing improvements in terms of building their agency, like for working on their addictions, getting into workforce.

507
00:55:31.108 --> 00:55:34.333
<v Dan Ryan>They were prioritized, and we're showing great— we're showing great results for that.

508
00:55:35.039 --> 00:55:41.871
<v Dan Ryan>What happened to that commitment kind of a rewards program for those that went from chronic homelessness that were showing some hope.

509
00:55:42.271 --> 00:55:43.699
<v Dan Ryan>What happened to that commitment?

510
00:55:43.954 --> 00:55:45.157
<v Dan Ryan>I don't see it in the data.

511
00:55:45.253 --> 00:55:46.840
<v Dan Ryan>It looks like it leveled off.

512
00:55:47.867 --> 00:55:49.565
<v Anna Plum>I don't think any change was made to that commitment.

513
00:55:49.630 --> 00:55:56.490
<v Anna Plum>And I would also say committing to— the county transitioned to 24/7 shelter with services model prior to 2021.

514
00:55:56.539 --> 00:56:02.775
<v Anna Plum>And so that commitment to having people in shelter that lasts 24/7 and that has housing services related to it actually predates that.

515
00:56:03.496 --> 00:56:05.164
<v Anna Plum>And I don't think that commitment has changed.

516
00:56:05.583 --> 00:56:16.923
<v Anna Plum>I think what you— how I might respond to that is we have different models of shelter across the community, and we need to make sure we have the right balance because there are certain models that are easier to have people access services in them.

517
00:56:17.452 --> 00:56:19.409
<v Anna Plum>And I think what I hear you saying is we do have models.

518
00:56:19.474 --> 00:56:29.532
<v Anna Plum>I'll call out a shelter in our community, a program that has a congregate shelter and a motel shelter, and they do move folks from that congregate shelter to the motel shelter when they feel like they might be more ready to go on that housing journey.

519
00:56:29.579 --> 00:56:30.028
<v Anna Plum>And that's not a problem.

520
00:56:30.110 --> 00:56:32.789
<v Anna Plum>It's easier to do that in a motel shelter than in a congregate shelter.

521
00:56:33.110 --> 00:56:38.052
<v Anna Plum>That motel shelter has great outcomes because of that trajectory from folks who are feeling more ready.

522
00:56:38.405 --> 00:56:39.545
<v Anna Plum>So that model exists.

523
00:56:39.914 --> 00:56:43.668
<v Anna Plum>I think that's a model we can zoom in on and recreate across the continuum.

524
00:56:44.023 --> 00:56:54.789
<v Anna Plum>And our ability to do that equitably really depends on having a common agreement about what that looks like, what the best pathways are, and funding that equitably across all of the shelters and not just in little pockets here and there.

525
00:56:55.320 --> 00:56:55.577
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

526
00:56:55.657 --> 00:56:56.893
<v Dan Ryan>The data doesn't indicate that.

527
00:56:56.972 --> 00:56:59.467
<v Dan Ryan>I want to get I'm going to get to my other questions because I'm going to get the hook soon.

528
00:57:00.550 --> 00:57:06.447
<v Dan Ryan>In '23-'24, I sat on a subcommittee focused on the city and the county goal of building more of those shelters.

529
00:57:07.382 --> 00:57:08.387
<v Dan Ryan>And that was a big goal.

530
00:57:08.760 --> 00:57:09.668
<v Dan Ryan>And we locked arms.

531
00:57:09.717 --> 00:57:13.996
<v Dan Ryan>I was on that subcommittee with you, Commissioner Brim Edwards, among a couple others.

532
00:57:14.706 --> 00:57:15.697
<v Dan Ryan>That was just 2 years ago.

533
00:57:16.266 --> 00:57:21.856
<v Dan Ryan>And now I read through media sources that the county— through this, that the county's abandoning this goal.

534
00:57:22.115 --> 00:57:22.164
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

535
00:57:23.456 --> 00:57:25.576
<v Dan Ryan>Looking to close over 1,000 shelter beds.

536
00:57:26.907 --> 00:57:33.007
<v Dan Ryan>How is it that we can go from having a goal just 2 years ago to then abandoning that goal?

537
00:57:33.811 --> 00:57:36.876
<v Dan Ryan>It's these fits and starts that makes it so challenging to build the system.

538
00:57:37.342 --> 00:57:42.655
<v Dan Ryan>Why is the county choosing to cut so many shelter beds in this upcoming budget?

539
00:57:43.137 --> 00:57:46.217
<v Anna Plum>So as the person who led that subcommittee, I will happily respond to that question.

540
00:57:47.005 --> 00:57:53.954
<v Anna Plum>So you're referring to the community sheltering strategy, which was a 2-year goal to add shelter to the community, but that was not the only goal of the community sheltering strategy.

541
00:57:54.452 --> 00:57:59.951
<v Anna Plum>It was also to have more people exit that shelter to housing and to provide more supportive services in those shelters.

542
00:58:00.623 --> 00:58:04.760
<v Anna Plum>To be quite frank, that goal was set when we were in a very, very different funding scenario in the community.

543
00:58:05.833 --> 00:58:18.884
<v Anna Plum>And as we've communicated a few times, the decision to recommend to close some shelters— we do have some closing this year, the rest is all part of our requested budget— really is about making sure we have the right balance across our community between shelter and housing placement.

544
00:58:19.043 --> 00:58:19.780
<v Anna Plum>Thank you.

545
00:58:19.909 --> 00:58:30.326
<v Anna Plum>Succeed in increasing the number of people who are exiting shelter to housing, partially because as the number of beds rise, it gets— that percentage, the denominator gets bigger, the percentage will go down even as we're housing more people.

546
00:58:30.677 --> 00:58:36.190
<v Anna Plum>But partially because we are spending money on shelter that is then therefore not going into housing placement.

547
00:58:36.510 --> 00:58:42.456
<v Anna Plum>In a situation where we had less of a resource constraint, we were able to envision let's add shelter and add housing placement.

548
00:58:42.777 --> 00:58:45.085
<v Anna Plum>Now we're having to make really tough choices between the two.

549
00:58:45.728 --> 00:58:48.695
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, and I'll just end with one last question.

550
00:58:49.389 --> 00:58:52.648
<v Dan Ryan>And I also think we stopped prioritizing those people for housing.

551
00:58:53.630 --> 00:58:56.601
<v Dan Ryan>In outreach, I continue to be confused.

552
00:58:56.648 --> 00:58:58.385
<v Dan Ryan>I'm glad that conversation came up.

553
00:58:58.922 --> 00:59:00.804
<v Dan Ryan>And this is with you, Mr. Mayor and the chair.

554
00:59:00.887 --> 00:59:09.773
<v Dan Ryan>Like when we built yours, the— not yours, the city, the county's shelter systems, they close at 5:30 AM.

555
00:59:10.275 --> 00:59:10.664
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

556
00:59:11.753 --> 00:59:15.972
<v Dan Ryan>Where's the outreach workers to help them get from there to, say, the Blanchet House?

557
00:59:16.605 --> 00:59:25.041
<v Dan Ryan>Where's the outreach workers that we finally got TriMet to take on, which really is doing wonderful work?

558
00:59:25.088 --> 00:59:26.364
<v Dan Ryan>I've been on that for a few years.

559
00:59:26.880 --> 00:59:29.670
<v Dan Ryan>And then I hear they have threats for their outreach money.

560
00:59:29.864 --> 00:59:33.414
<v Dan Ryan>And that's our largest shelter that we have is MAX on the east side.

561
00:59:33.978 --> 00:59:37.786
<v Dan Ryan>I get to this because SHS money could be used for shelters.

562
00:59:37.849 --> 00:59:37.898
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

563
00:59:38.530 --> 00:59:39.958
<v Dan Ryan>It can be used for outreach.

564
00:59:40.456 --> 00:59:43.541
<v Dan Ryan>It can be used for behavioral health and mental health services.

565
00:59:43.974 --> 00:59:52.182
<v Dan Ryan>And I think a lot of Portlanders keep scratching their head on why we don't prioritize such things from the Metro SHS funds that taxpayers are funding.

566
00:59:52.391 --> 00:59:52.728
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

567
00:59:53.677 --> 01:00:00.327
<v Jillian Schoene>And Commissioner, I just want to clarify, you know, Multnomah County does not run the entire regional behavioral system of behavioral health.

568
01:00:00.518 --> 01:00:03.411
<v Jillian Schoene>Multnomah County is just a safety net, largely the uninsured.

569
01:00:04.309 --> 01:00:07.652
<v Jillian Schoene>So we are part of a region that expands out of just the tri-county area.

570
01:00:07.733 --> 01:00:11.380
<v Jillian Schoene>I believe Columbia, and I could be corrected, out to Clatsop counties.

571
01:00:11.445 --> 01:00:16.313
<v Jillian Schoene>That is sort of one of the regions where the state funds the regional system of behavioral health.

572
01:00:16.650 --> 01:00:23.463
<v Jillian Schoene>There have been 533 beds that the state has funded in this, in Multnomah County specifically since 2021.

573
01:00:23.721 --> 01:00:29.489
<v Jillian Schoene>Investments became— started sort of being invested in our community, and it's still not enough.

574
01:00:29.987 --> 01:00:32.813
<v Jillian Schoene>But zero of those beds were inpatient psych.

575
01:00:32.974 --> 01:00:45.871
<v Jillian Schoene>So that is where the need remains right now and where you will see advocacy from our team and Health Share and others coming together around getting more inpatient psych beds, like what you see at Inpatient Prov, those psych beds in Unity.

576
01:00:45.983 --> 01:00:47.172
<v Jillian Schoene>We need more of that here.

577
01:00:47.268 --> 01:00:51.652
<v Jillian Schoene>But Multnomah County does not control that, just to fact-check that for a second.

578
01:00:52.231 --> 01:00:59.572
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you to all the outreach workers that are meeting people where they are, and I really keep absolutely, we agree.

579
01:00:59.909 --> 01:01:00.827
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Thank you, Jillian.

580
01:01:00.940 --> 01:01:01.536
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I appreciate that.

581
01:01:01.664 --> 01:01:10.704
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I mean, I will— Multnomah County is the local mental health authority, and we are legally responsible for people who are uninsured and underinsured.

582
01:01:11.012 --> 01:01:20.516
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>But we have an entire Medicaid system, our CCO system, the healthcare system that is also incredibly responsible for people who are on Medicaid or other insurance.

583
01:01:21.036 --> 01:01:30.974
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>And so that's why I think looking at the systems and those including what the state is responsible for, which Commissioner Moyer has been such an advocate of, is a really important fact check to this.

584
01:01:31.503 --> 01:01:41.230
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I think the other thing that I wanted to say is, you know, one of the reasons we wanted to have this discussion about roles and responsibilities right now is that we are about to go into our budget cycle.

585
01:01:41.277 --> 01:01:43.409
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>So there are decisions that are going to be made about dollars.

586
01:01:44.322 --> 01:01:51.342
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>You know, one of the things that is on here is about that, like the 2 arrows pointing to each other about the exchange of money that thank you.

587
01:01:52.918 --> 01:02:06.617
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Right now, the, the $31.5 million that the— that is in the IGA for the city to give to the county provides funding for 756 shelter units and 218 transitional housing units.

588
01:02:06.731 --> 01:02:19.106
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>So when we think about the dollars that are going into the system and the impact that they have, I think it's important for all of us to understand how those dollars are being used to support it, whether it's city dollars thank you, Chair Vanga Peterson.

589
01:02:19.188 --> 01:02:19.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

590
01:02:20.335 --> 01:02:21.123
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

591
01:02:22.822 --> 01:02:23.648
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

592
01:02:23.713 --> 01:02:26.028
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for being here, everyone, for the presentation.

593
01:02:27.590 --> 01:02:30.746
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I have the different areas we're supposed to speak within.

594
01:02:30.958 --> 01:02:34.780
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So the first one for me is around system, the unified balance system.

595
01:02:35.476 --> 01:02:45.204
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The more that I've learned, the more spaces I've toured, shelters I've visited, I do believe more and more there's no one-size-fits-all solution to homelessness.

596
01:02:45.253 --> 01:02:45.934
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's no one exact way to solve it.

597
01:02:49.599 --> 01:02:55.264
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You know, shelter, or like, we need a wide range of approaches to meet people where they're at, when they're ready.

598
01:02:56.242 --> 01:03:06.079
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also think, you know, that includes preserving programs that we know are demonstrably working, that have good outcomes, the ones that are successfully transitioning folks into housing.

599
01:03:06.126 --> 01:03:07.057
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I heard that mentioned.

600
01:03:07.650 --> 01:03:14.469
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>To zoom in, I, I want to zoom in on an example that I know pretty well in Montavilla, where we have shared constituents.

601
01:03:14.518 --> 01:03:14.726
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

602
01:03:15.112 --> 01:03:15.913
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Beacon Village.

603
01:03:15.976 --> 01:03:28.027
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I remember when it was first created, how intentional that model was, how impressed council was on their focus on dignity, stability, connection, and they've seen real outcomes.

604
01:03:28.076 --> 01:03:29.405
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Their numbers are really good.

605
01:03:30.576 --> 01:03:40.431
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What what you don't see by the numbers too is I've talked to a lot of the people in the neighborhood who were worried about the shelter at first, and now it is a really important part of their neighborhood.

606
01:03:40.494 --> 01:03:40.559
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They say.

607
01:03:40.833 --> 01:03:43.304
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They say that they feel safer because of it.

608
01:03:43.661 --> 01:03:46.762
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They feel like the folks that are there are their neighbors.

609
01:03:46.811 --> 01:03:47.764
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They come back and visit.

610
01:03:48.820 --> 01:03:52.811
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>People that are on the storefronts nearby too say something similar.

611
01:03:54.023 --> 01:04:10.041
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was just talking with Mayor Wilson yesterday about how it is one of the places that has— it's on the chopping block that we, when we're talking about over 1,000 beds being slated to be cut, I'm really concerned about places like this being closed.

612
01:04:11.369 --> 01:04:11.791
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can we—.

613
01:04:12.244 --> 01:04:16.460
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are you able to share what the projected cost savings from closing these beds is?

614
01:04:16.844 --> 01:04:17.393
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is there a number?

615
01:04:19.168 --> 01:04:21.405
<v Anna Plum>Yes, I will look it up and give it to you in just a moment.

616
01:04:21.534 --> 01:04:25.737
<v Anna Plum>I don't have it right off the top of my head, but it's from across the whole spectrum.

617
01:04:25.849 --> 01:04:28.460
<v Anna Plum>It's tens of millions of dollars that we are saving by closing those shelter units.

618
01:04:28.525 --> 01:04:33.253
<v Anna Plum>And I do want to speak to the number because that is an additive number over a period of time.

619
01:04:33.318 --> 01:04:45.260
<v Anna Plum>So in this fiscal year that we are in, Our budget that we adopted this fiscal year included closing 230 units of shelters in 2 programs, one where the lease was ending and one where the building needs to be used for other purposes.

620
01:04:45.773 --> 01:04:55.514
<v Anna Plum>The current— our requested budget for this fiscal year includes closing about 775 units as sort of close to the end of this fiscal year.

621
01:04:56.204 --> 01:04:59.943
<v Anna Plum>Those are primarily in the adult system and some scattered site vouchers.

622
01:05:00.137 --> 01:05:01.628
<v Anna Plum>Not all of those are occupied.

623
01:05:02.063 --> 01:05:04.661
<v Anna Plum>It does envision another program going halfway through next fiscal year.

624
01:05:04.710 --> 01:05:04.855
<v Anna Plum>Thank you.

625
01:05:05.351 --> 01:05:12.373
<v Anna Plum>So the 1,000 that's being quoted is actually including some things that we are already planning to close this fiscal year and some things moving into the next.

626
01:05:12.436 --> 01:05:18.175
<v Anna Plum>So I just wanted to be really clear on what that number actually is because we're using a smaller number when we talk about the impact of this fiscal year.

627
01:05:18.815 --> 01:05:19.056
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay.

628
01:05:19.456 --> 01:05:27.760
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And it's no secret that the county and the city, we have a lot of fiscal constraints that we're looking at as we're doing our next budget.

629
01:05:28.273 --> 01:05:41.277
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I also need to be clear that I am getting so many emails and I'm getting hearing from many of our constituents that are really concerned about cuts like this when hundreds of millions of dollars are going to the Moda Center.

630
01:05:42.286 --> 01:05:48.764
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's really difficult for people to reconcile that level of spending with cuts to, like, small, effective homelessness programs.

631
01:05:49.134 --> 01:06:01.161
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I think a question we need to talk about is how are we prioritizing investments when there are proven community-supported models like Beacon Village— it's a small one— on the chopping block, while much larger expenditures are moving forward.

632
01:06:01.692 --> 01:06:10.293
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I don't know like which pocket, which plate is it general fund money that we're giving, but I— this conversation needs— the public needs to be able to hear.

633
01:06:10.614 --> 01:06:13.952
<v Anna Plum>And to the question on the shelter units, it's around $30 million of reduction.

634
01:06:14.385 --> 01:06:14.835
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>$30 Million.

635
01:06:15.172 --> 01:06:19.088
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And are— is it public yet what the county is, um, giving the Blazers?

636
01:06:19.280 --> 01:06:20.516
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Because I think it's more than that.

637
01:06:21.302 --> 01:06:24.512
<v Anna Plum>I don't know the answer.

638
01:06:24.800 --> 01:06:26.068
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

639
01:06:27.380 --> 01:06:29.061
<v Jamie Dunphy>Anybody else want to get in queue?

640
01:06:29.143 --> 01:06:30.728
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the quietest this body has ever been.

641
01:06:31.909 --> 01:06:41.295
<v Jillian Schoene>Council President, and I'll just layer in there some additional context because like this is what I'm about to name is like part of the shared challenge that we all are in.

642
01:06:42.293 --> 01:06:48.320
<v Jillian Schoene>You had the county homeless services department announce that it needed to take $68 million in cuts.

643
01:06:48.673 --> 01:06:56.550
<v Jillian Schoene>About half of that amount is based on the city's city's current intention of keeping what it normally would send across the river.

644
01:06:58.820 --> 01:07:04.721
<v Jillian Schoene>However, if the city doesn't keep its money, to be fair, you're going to probably be closing shelter.

645
01:07:05.900 --> 01:07:09.539
<v Jillian Schoene>The city shelter system was largely funded by one-time-only monies.

646
01:07:10.460 --> 01:07:18.637
<v Jillian Schoene>Prior Administrator Mike Jordan has been warning about this fiscal cliff for years when the city started down that journey.

647
01:07:19.096 --> 01:07:19.695
<v Jillian Schoene>Here we are.

648
01:07:19.985 --> 01:07:23.177
<v Jillian Schoene>The fiscal cliff is happening on the city side of the equation.

649
01:07:23.467 --> 01:07:24.342
<v Jillian Schoene>ARPA is all gone.

650
01:07:25.380 --> 01:07:35.224
<v Jillian Schoene>SHS, one-time-only monies that the county was legally forced to get out the door on a time— within a year by Metro.

651
01:07:35.739 --> 01:07:36.673
<v Jillian Schoene>Those are all gone.

652
01:07:37.172 --> 01:07:39.186
<v Jillian Schoene>Here we are, a collective fiscal cliff.

653
01:07:39.701 --> 01:07:45.418
<v Jillian Schoene>So let's design the new normal, a unified, balanced system that moves more people into housing.

654
01:07:45.518 --> 01:07:45.802
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you.

655
01:07:46.528 --> 01:07:48.155
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you.

656
01:07:50.150 --> 01:07:50.554
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

657
01:07:52.581 --> 01:07:55.416
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. President.

658
01:07:55.496 --> 01:07:59.525
<v Mitch Green>I'm pulling up my stopwatch because I'm a good boy.

659
01:08:00.885 --> 01:08:07.728
<v Mitch Green>Um, okay, thank you, colleagues, uh, county colleagues.

660
01:08:07.905 --> 01:08:09.873
<v Mitch Green>Um, I just have a couple questions here.

661
01:08:10.117 --> 01:08:15.721
<v Mitch Green>So the color scheme on the continuum orange is the City of Portland, blue is the county.

662
01:08:16.460 --> 01:08:24.113
<v Mitch Green>Is that to indicate just funding source, or is it to indicate who performs a function, or is it some combination of the two?

663
01:08:26.426 --> 01:08:27.542
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Both.

664
01:08:27.818 --> 01:08:32.948
<v Jillian Schoene>Yeah, it's both roles and investments.

665
01:08:33.886 --> 01:08:35.796
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that is helpful.

666
01:08:36.475 --> 01:08:52.435
<v Mitch Green>I think just in the spirit of like trying to get to a sense of, I mean, think there's some problems I think it makes sense for me to have a function area be consolidated under one roof.

667
01:08:53.168 --> 01:08:56.103
<v Mitch Green>And then if we have to blend monies together, we blend monies together.

668
01:08:56.680 --> 01:09:00.060
<v Mitch Green>But having 2 different eviction defense offices is confusing.

669
01:09:01.283 --> 01:09:06.145
<v Mitch Green>There might be a good legacy reason for it, but I think I strongly support eviction defense.

670
01:09:06.193 --> 01:09:06.483
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Dan Ryan.

671
01:09:07.087 --> 01:09:20.087
<v Mitch Green>I think that we need to pair that with actual financial resources to make those tenants whole, get them out of arrears, and then perhaps subsidize them for a time and then connect them with employment services.

672
01:09:20.136 --> 01:09:25.234
<v Mitch Green>But 2 different offices, I'm not sure meets the mark.

673
01:09:27.234 --> 01:09:28.945
<v Mitch Green>I want to talk a little bit about budget.

674
01:09:31.270 --> 01:09:35.734
<v Mitch Green>Jillian, you just reminded us I think it's important to note that we've known about this fiscal cliff for a long time and we are confronting it now.

675
01:09:35.926 --> 01:09:38.760
<v Mitch Green>We're very fortunate to be on the body now that has to deal with that.

676
01:09:41.329 --> 01:10:02.528
<v Mitch Green>The way that I'm thinking about it is I think the City of Portland— I'm not going to speak for the county, but I think if our designation is sticks and bricks, as Councilor Avalos has kind of sort of helped us frame, then my first principle would be the city needs to step in and play the role as the price maker not the price taker in the rental market.

677
01:10:02.591 --> 01:10:10.073
<v Mitch Green>What that means for me is we need to be acquiring properties as part of a social housing portfolio.

678
01:10:10.639 --> 01:10:13.081
<v Mitch Green>If you're not ready to call it that, call it whatever.

679
01:10:13.161 --> 01:10:21.372
<v Mitch Green>But we have properties that are on sale relative to the new construction price of a building.

680
01:10:22.069 --> 01:10:30.112
<v Mitch Green>And if we can go out and acquire those into some level of permanence, Then we have locked in a cost to the City of Portland, which is then a cost to the county.

681
01:10:30.159 --> 01:10:40.164
<v Mitch Green>'Cause so if the county's gonna sort of subsidize rent, provide rent assistance for a long period of time, we do not wanna be downstream.

682
01:10:40.679 --> 01:10:52.305
<v Mitch Green>We do not wanna be at the very bottom of a downstream kind of market-driven process where we have to kind of make up an ever-growing share of subsidy because there's no cost control in our jurisdiction.

683
01:10:53.306 --> 01:10:57.235
<v Mitch Green>And so it's really about setting— being in the driver's seat on cost.

684
01:10:57.396 --> 01:11:04.250
<v Mitch Green>And I know that there's only so much of this you can do and you have to phase it out, but I urge us to think in that direction.

685
01:11:04.524 --> 01:11:07.077
<v Mitch Green>I think some of us are across this dais.

686
01:11:08.805 --> 01:11:26.354
<v Mitch Green>And I would say that I think when folks think about social housing as part of this continuum, the immediate response is, well, you can't put someone who's experiencing a severe behavioral health crisis in kind of just any old building 'cause they're not ready for it or they'll do some damage.

687
01:11:26.418 --> 01:11:33.644
<v Mitch Green>And we can have a debate around that, but not everyone who's experiencing houselessness or is destined for houselessness has an acute condition.

688
01:11:34.729 --> 01:11:46.457
<v Mitch Green>And so we can imagine parsing, finding more places for people to be at a lower cost so that way we can get a handle around this and then pairing them with the appropriate wraparound services that they need.

689
01:11:47.237 --> 01:11:50.962
<v Mitch Green>I think if we look at the— I'm at 3 minutes and 50 seconds.

690
01:11:51.042 --> 01:12:01.078
<v Mitch Green>If we look at the key KPIs, there's that model of, you know, how much do we need to scale in financial resources to reduce, you know, homelessness by some percentage?

691
01:12:01.206 --> 01:12:03.920
<v Mitch Green>And it's— there is no scale efficiency built into that model.

692
01:12:04.193 --> 01:12:08.978
<v Mitch Green>There's no way to realize some sort of efficiency at a system level.

693
01:12:09.170 --> 01:12:11.113
<v Mitch Green>And this, I think, is the way to think about that.

694
01:12:11.193 --> 01:12:12.077
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

695
01:12:12.627 --> 01:12:14.774
<v Mitch Green>I've already talked about consolidated eviction defense.

696
01:12:14.840 --> 01:12:16.953
<v Mitch Green>I think that that's critical.

697
01:12:19.083 --> 01:12:27.122
<v Mitch Green>And finally, we should be having a conversation about capitalizing a larger risk mitigation common pool resource.

698
01:12:27.234 --> 01:12:40.064
<v Mitch Green>There is one, I think the city contributes some money to it, that is really meant to support the kind of insurance risk profile, the actuarial risk profile of PSH providers.

699
01:12:40.738 --> 01:12:46.818
<v Mitch Green>But again, we've got— a lot of our affordable housing stock is filling that space as well.

700
01:12:47.555 --> 01:12:56.137
<v Mitch Green>And so the damage to those units, I think, would be benefited, those providers would be benefited by having access to a risk mitigation common pool.

701
01:12:56.202 --> 01:13:03.131
<v Mitch Green>And so that's one of the things that I think can stretch our resources in this community and we can have a multi-jurisdictional approach to that.

702
01:13:03.197 --> 01:13:04.864
<v Mitch Green>So I'm 5 minutes and 5 seconds.

703
01:13:04.912 --> 01:13:05.024
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

704
01:13:06.068 --> 01:13:15.689
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Councilor Green, just to clarify, we don't have an eviction defense office at the— we provide dollars for eviction defense, but we don't have an office for that.

705
01:13:15.850 --> 01:13:16.685
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's helpful.

706
01:13:16.908 --> 01:13:19.828
<v Mitch Green>That's— I just see it in the chart there as blue, so I wanted to make sure.

707
01:13:20.582 --> 01:13:21.768
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Councilor Green.

708
01:13:21.944 --> 01:13:22.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

709
01:13:22.762 --> 01:13:24.333
<v Rachel Pearl>Unless you want me to say something.

710
01:13:25.007 --> 01:13:27.510
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President and commissioners.

711
01:13:27.573 --> 01:13:29.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's so good to see you today.

712
01:13:31.743 --> 01:13:37.822
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, Jillian, I want to pick up on what you were saying just a minute ago.

713
01:13:38.703 --> 01:13:41.092
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We saw these fiscal cliffs coming.

714
01:13:41.686 --> 01:13:43.145
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We knew this was going to happen.

715
01:13:43.194 --> 01:13:57.581
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm sitting here knowing that the council is going to be debating soon using one-time dollars toward potentially rent assistance, creating another fiscal cliff, by the way, on a service that is another Mm-hmm.

716
01:13:58.543 --> 01:14:10.297
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I feel like we've now spent a year talking about the fact that we have these 2 systems that sit side by side, um, that are not well coordinated.

717
01:14:10.635 --> 01:14:14.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've spent a year doing that since we started the joint meetings.

718
01:14:14.184 --> 01:14:21.488
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A whole lot of people talked about this not together, not in joint meetings, 4 years before that, but we've had a year of joint meetings now.

719
01:14:22.436 --> 01:14:23.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

720
01:14:24.059 --> 01:14:25.873
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have systems that duplicate services.

721
01:14:26.774 --> 01:14:36.154
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I still don't know how much those services are being provided in coordination with each other versus we're doing our thing and you're doing your thing.

722
01:14:37.471 --> 01:14:41.422
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have fiscal cliffs we knew were coming and didn't plan for.

723
01:14:42.853 --> 01:14:57.015
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have not enough resources to support people in our community who desperately need support, and the impacts of that roll into other community members who didn't previously need support and are now needing help with the impacts of that.

724
01:14:59.770 --> 01:15:05.984
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we have a foreseeable mess that may not have been preventable, but at least could have been dealt with more effectively.

725
01:15:07.862 --> 01:15:12.912
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think the question keeps being asked, what do we all as electeds want to do about that?

726
01:15:15.449 --> 01:15:27.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I still have a long list of questions about where services are coordinated, who can perform them most efficiently, who can perform them for the least dollar amount, where we get the most effective impact.

727
01:15:28.448 --> 01:15:46.801
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we look at slides that collect data but don't actually take it apart to tell me where, as a policymaker, I should be investing at the city and where I should be so I guess I'm looking for a staff recommendation, truly.

728
01:15:47.302 --> 01:15:47.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yep.

729
01:15:48.692 --> 01:15:51.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Where the city and the county staff come together.

730
01:15:51.197 --> 01:15:51.359
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yep.

731
01:15:52.231 --> 01:16:21.121
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And say, if we want to operate the most efficient, most effective system that takes our very limited resources, and in the long run, not just today, but 5 years from now, I'll call that the medium run, Has moved the most people into housing, prevented the most possible people from moving into homelessness, and helped us move toward the system that my colleague was talking about just a moment ago, where we actually are better able to control rent prices.

732
01:16:21.170 --> 01:16:22.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So this is less of a problem into the future.

733
01:16:25.229 --> 01:16:35.501
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So there's a lot I could say about what I think the system should look like, and a lot of questions I could ask about where the duplication is the biggest problem and how we can undo that in this budget when we do not.

734
01:16:35.600 --> 01:16:41.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not have enough resources to provide the services that frankly people should be demanding from us.

735
01:16:42.435 --> 01:16:54.408
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, but with only 5 minutes, instead I'm going to ask for that staff recommendation because we can't keep spinning our wheels and we are at the crisis point.

736
01:16:54.712 --> 01:17:06.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are past the crisis point in fact because we are now cutting the funds without having created the long-term system that we should have with those one-time dollars that prevented us from getting to this point.

737
01:17:07.490 --> 01:17:24.798
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I would love it— I don't set these agendas anymore, Council President Chair, you do— but I would love it if at some point we are actually looking at a proposed solution and not just outcomes that aren't meeting the mark and a system that contains an immense amount of duplication.

738
01:17:25.472 --> 01:17:25.842
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

739
01:17:26.356 --> 01:17:26.854
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you.

740
01:17:26.918 --> 01:17:30.100
<v Jillian Schoene>I just need a directive on both sides of the river.

741
01:17:30.519 --> 01:17:30.792
<v Jillian Schoene>Thank you.

742
01:17:31.646 --> 01:17:34.532
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President and Chair, I would love it if we could give that directive.

743
01:17:34.710 --> 01:17:35.064
<v Steve Novick>Heard.

744
01:17:36.320 --> 01:17:36.612
<v Jamie Dunphy>More to come.

745
01:17:37.930 --> 01:17:40.693
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

746
01:17:40.742 --> 01:17:41.783
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

747
01:17:41.863 --> 01:17:42.904
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you guys so much for your presentation.

748
01:17:44.009 --> 01:17:53.881
<v Angelita Morillo>Jillian, I really appreciate everything that you shared, and I think that I appreciate you reasserting that this was an issue that people before us Councilor Smith.

749
01:17:53.994 --> 01:17:54.268
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Mayor.

750
01:17:54.427 --> 01:18:00.578
<v Angelita Morillo>This is a crisis that none of us who are sitting here saw coming and did not account for it, and we have inherited those woes, and it's up to us to deal with it now.

751
01:18:00.706 --> 01:18:06.293
<v Angelita Morillo>But I just want to say, you know, we are all facing a very difficult budget crisis.

752
01:18:07.434 --> 01:18:12.122
<v Angelita Morillo>The federal government not bringing those dollars down to every local jurisdiction is very difficult.

753
01:18:12.266 --> 01:18:19.074
<v Angelita Morillo>And so I just appreciate the work that we're all trying to do here today, and I'm glad to see my colleagues from the county here as well.

754
01:18:20.421 --> 01:18:30.073
<v Angelita Morillo>As far as what I've seen, before COVID the city spent a lot of money, about $20 million, on programs like rapid rehousing, supportive housing, and permanent supportive housing.

755
01:18:31.073 --> 01:18:33.025
<v Angelita Morillo>Currently, that is significantly lower.

756
01:18:33.090 --> 01:18:34.979
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it's around $5 million.

757
01:18:37.061 --> 01:18:48.360
<v Angelita Morillo>We've seen, I think, on the city side, a huge increase in sweeps, putting people into temporary shelters, And a lot less on getting people into long-term housing.

758
01:18:48.859 --> 01:18:53.369
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm curious, maybe Jillian, this is for you directly, how that has impacted your guys' work.

759
01:18:54.237 --> 01:18:59.036
<v Angelita Morillo>And if you could ask the city to focus on something, what would you have us focus on?

760
01:18:59.132 --> 01:19:06.115
<v Angelita Morillo>If this is the right move or the wrong move, no judgments, not trying to throw anyone under the bus, but just genuinely asking what would be the most helpful.

761
01:19:06.533 --> 01:19:16.582
<v Jillian Schoene>I'm not here to throw anybody under the bus either, because I think, you know, prior to COVID, things looked differently and we had that joint partnership.

762
01:19:16.712 --> 01:19:18.173
<v Jillian Schoene>It wasn't perfect yet either.

763
01:19:18.335 --> 01:19:19.684
<v Jillian Schoene>I mean, homelessness is hard, right?

764
01:19:20.262 --> 01:19:21.033
<v Jillian Schoene>And then COVID hit.

765
01:19:22.255 --> 01:19:29.036
<v Jillian Schoene>Things got blurry during COVID new programs came in online because of what was happening out on our streets.

766
01:19:29.100 --> 01:19:31.686
<v Jillian Schoene>I have zero blame around that.

767
01:19:32.474 --> 01:19:38.612
<v Jillian Schoene>But here we are now today, and things need to shift to a new normal.

768
01:19:38.885 --> 01:19:45.054
<v Jillian Schoene>And we now have shared key performance indicators that both elected bodies have used.

769
01:19:45.970 --> 01:19:47.625
<v Jillian Schoene>That is the investment strategy.

770
01:19:48.042 --> 01:19:51.078
<v Jillian Schoene>Those indicators should inform everyone's votes.

771
01:19:51.657 --> 01:19:55.512
<v Jillian Schoene>HSD did use those KPIs to inform their budget.

772
01:19:55.913 --> 01:20:00.829
<v Jillian Schoene>What you see in their requested budget is the more balanced system that we need.

773
01:20:01.377 --> 01:20:12.082
<v Jillian Schoene>Right now, we spend about $150 million on shelter between both of us, and that is equal to the ongoing SHS amount coming to Multnomah County and back out the door.

774
01:20:12.211 --> 01:20:14.694
<v Jillian Schoene>Like, we're spending a lot on shelter.

775
01:20:15.192 --> 01:20:20.192
<v Jillian Schoene>We have to shift our funds to more moving more people out of homelessness.

776
01:20:20.239 --> 01:20:24.533
<v Jillian Schoene>So that's the HSD budget is a requested budget is a great start.

777
01:20:25.046 --> 01:20:37.467
<v Jillian Schoene>I think with a directive, I would bring together the wonderful team at Portland Solutions and HSD, particularly around what does a UNO what is the right mix of shelter?

778
01:20:37.547 --> 01:20:42.453
<v Jillian Schoene>Right, because we brought on a new type of shelter during COVID which was the right thing to do.

779
01:20:43.319 --> 01:20:56.033
<v Jillian Schoene>But what is the right mix of shelter, and what is that level of investment that allows us, in the context of the key performance indicators, to actually start curving down, if you will, the number of homeless people in our community?

780
01:20:56.225 --> 01:21:03.809
<v Jillian Schoene>Like, we have the data and we have the key performance indicators that we share to inform those investment decisions and come back with that recommendation to you.

781
01:21:05.100 --> 01:21:09.323
<v Angelita Morillo>So simplify that for folks in the audience who don't know all the key performance indicators.

782
01:21:09.677 --> 01:21:12.547
<v Angelita Morillo>Just plainly say, what would you want the city to be focused on?

783
01:21:14.149 --> 01:21:18.005
<v Jillian Schoene>Being in partnership with Multnomah County to end the homelessness of more individuals.

784
01:21:19.189 --> 01:21:26.737
<v Angelita Morillo>Right, but as far as actual things, like, do you want us to focus on long-term housing, moving people into permanent housing?

785
01:21:29.484 --> 01:21:30.173
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Loretta Smith.

786
01:21:31.296 --> 01:21:35.243
<v Jillian Schoene>I think the city has a couple of roles that the county just does not play.

787
01:21:35.853 --> 01:21:41.885
<v Jillian Schoene>Housing development, high five, y'all, and start sprinting right down that.

788
01:21:42.189 --> 01:21:43.586
<v Jillian Schoene>A lot of great work has happened.

789
01:21:44.212 --> 01:21:46.104
<v Jillian Schoene>Economic development paired with that, right?

790
01:21:46.201 --> 01:21:52.698
<v Jillian Schoene>Y'all, I mean, the county has a tiny bit of funds, but housing development, economic development, like, go for it.

791
01:21:53.453 --> 01:21:57.179
<v Jillian Schoene>I do think all 24/7 shelter should go back to the county.

792
01:21:58.176 --> 01:22:06.661
<v Jillian Schoene>And we have one system with referral, looking at the referral pathways, redoing the referral pathways, and that, that live at the county.

793
01:22:07.259 --> 01:22:10.895
<v Jillian Schoene>Do we keep— I'll say what is not being said yet.

794
01:22:11.202 --> 01:22:19.953
<v Jillian Schoene>Do we keep some overnight-only beds online for public space management?

795
01:22:20.019 --> 01:22:20.131
<v Jillian Schoene>Yes.

796
01:22:21.052 --> 01:22:21.632
<v Jillian Schoene>I think so.

797
01:22:22.970 --> 01:22:33.891
<v Jillian Schoene>For those getting a human to a bed who maybe is resisting 24/7 shelter, maybe keeping, I'm gonna say, 200 to 300 online for that purpose.

798
01:22:35.465 --> 01:22:35.725
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

799
01:22:35.789 --> 01:22:36.260
<v Angelita Morillo>I appreciate you being—.

800
01:22:36.292 --> 01:22:37.556
<v Jillian Schoene>During this transition time period.

801
01:22:38.060 --> 01:22:38.171
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Gotcha.

802
01:22:38.557 --> 01:22:38.798
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

803
01:22:38.846 --> 01:22:40.197
<v Angelita Morillo>See, I love Jillian.

804
01:22:40.261 --> 01:22:41.644
<v Angelita Morillo>She'll answer you honestly and directly.

805
01:22:41.707 --> 01:22:42.479
<v Angelita Morillo>I appreciate that.

806
01:22:43.780 --> 01:22:44.537
<v Angelita Morillo>And I agree with you.

807
01:22:44.585 --> 01:22:47.288
<v Angelita Morillo>I think, you know, when we look at this chart, the part of housing Councilor Smith.

808
01:22:47.337 --> 01:22:52.140
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that housing development falls squarely under the city, and I think that's where we haven't really seen a vision from the city.

809
01:22:52.895 --> 01:23:04.480
<v Angelita Morillo>I think now we have a council that's very committed to doing things like social housing, land banking, revolving loan funds, debt buydowns so that we can create more sustainable rent pricing.

810
01:23:04.545 --> 01:23:07.550
<v Angelita Morillo>And so I'm very committed especially to that part.

811
01:23:07.597 --> 01:23:26.902
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that's where my colleagues— I hope that we will focus on, and I'm really excited about the possibility of us really looking into those long-term solutions so that the county can— I feel like you do so much of that emergency management, really, of the crisis that has been handed to us, also partially by the federal government right now.

812
01:23:26.966 --> 01:23:29.663
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you, I really appreciate that.

813
01:23:29.823 --> 01:23:45.221
<v Angelita Morillo>And I would just urge my colleagues that when we have opportunities to invest these dollars in long-term solutions like social housing, that we need to be taking those and we need to be decidedly committing to it every single step of the way, because if we don't, then we will just fall back on the status quo.

814
01:23:45.270 --> 01:23:46.570
<v Angelita Morillo>So thanks for your time.

815
01:23:47.726 --> 01:23:48.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

816
01:23:48.626 --> 01:23:49.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

817
01:23:50.311 --> 01:23:51.194
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

818
01:23:51.275 --> 01:24:01.118
<v Steve Novick>First of all, Mr. President, Chair Vega Pedersen, I suggest the next meeting like this just be billed as Jillian Unplugged, and we should just let Jillian hold forth.

819
01:24:01.375 --> 01:24:03.688
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I've got a few quick specific questions.

820
01:24:03.800 --> 01:24:05.381
<v Steve Novick>One is, And I doubt we know this.

821
01:24:05.640 --> 01:24:11.685
<v Steve Novick>Do we happen to know what percentage of people who are served eviction notices subsequently become homeless?

822
01:24:15.765 --> 01:24:19.668
<v Rachel Pearl>You want to know the percentage that actually become homeless after being served an eviction notice?

823
01:24:19.748 --> 01:24:19.957
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

824
01:24:20.021 --> 01:24:24.698
<v Rachel Pearl>We don't have the entire— I don't have that data available specifically to you right now.

825
01:24:25.247 --> 01:24:26.262
<v Rachel Pearl>We know there's a lot of layers.

826
01:24:26.311 --> 01:24:31.880
<v Rachel Pearl>So we know that for every eviction that ends up in eviction court, people self-evict, right?

827
01:24:31.927 --> 01:24:34.109
<v Rachel Pearl>So for every one person that ends Mm-hmm.

828
01:24:34.399 --> 01:24:36.645
<v Rachel Pearl>Up in eviction court, 5 self-evict.

829
01:24:36.694 --> 01:24:49.421
<v Rachel Pearl>So that means the number that we see that actually make it to eviction court, which really our resources that we have for eviction prevention at the county would only prevent evictions for 1 month, um, for the entire year, right?

830
01:24:49.485 --> 01:24:51.266
<v Rachel Pearl>If that— if all of those moved forward.

831
01:24:51.315 --> 01:25:02.354
<v Rachel Pearl>The challenge with eviction once it gets to eviction court is there is arrears payments that are due in order to actually prevent that eviction and prevent the eviction from being on their record and the eviction from happening.

832
01:25:02.721 --> 01:25:12.208
<v Rachel Pearl>So we can see what actual data is available to you in terms of the numbers that actually become homeless, but it is a challenging data point to collect accurately.

833
01:25:12.962 --> 01:25:13.122
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

834
01:25:13.827 --> 01:25:25.748
<v Steve Novick>I mean, what I'm getting at obviously is I'd be curious to know, I mean, if we could show that here's the percentage of overall people served eviction notices become homeless, and here's the percentage if they get some sort of assistance, how big the difference is.

835
01:25:26.551 --> 01:25:32.953
<v Steve Novick>Another random question I have is, what is the annual cost per unit of permanent supportive housing?

836
01:25:35.387 --> 01:25:38.237
<v Anna Plum>Are you asking for the rent assistance or just all services?

837
01:25:38.286 --> 01:25:39.451
<v Steve Novick>Like the total public money.

838
01:25:39.613 --> 01:25:44.837
<v Steve Novick>If you have one permanent supportive housing unit, what does that cost in public money per year?

839
01:25:44.935 --> 01:25:48.085
<v Anna Plum>Hold on, I'm Googling it for you right now.

840
01:25:48.246 --> 01:25:50.685
<v Anna Plum>So it depends on the household.

841
01:25:50.734 --> 01:25:57.020
<v Anna Plum>So there's adult, family, So the costs do change depending on that, and we do have an average cost I'm going to pull up for you.

842
01:25:57.069 --> 01:25:57.554
<v Anna Plum>Just one second.

843
01:26:03.010 --> 01:26:09.737
<v Anna Plum>So for an adult doing PSH, the average cost is around $36,000 to $38,000.

844
01:26:11.010 --> 01:26:11.268
<v Mitch Green>A year?

845
01:26:11.364 --> 01:26:11.591
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>A year?

846
01:26:11.735 --> 01:26:11.896
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

847
01:26:12.703 --> 01:26:18.505
<v Steve Novick>And do we have a wild guess as to how many people we think should be in permanent supportive housing right now but aren't?

848
01:26:19.023 --> 01:26:27.534
<v Anna Plum>So Metro did just publish, uh, some— or they're about to publish some numbers on that that I can send to you around the estimates by county, how many folks are in PSH and how many they estimate would need it.

849
01:26:27.600 --> 01:26:29.012
<v Anna Plum>I don't have those memorized, but they do exist.

850
01:26:29.060 --> 01:26:29.622
<v Anna Plum>We can follow up.

851
01:26:29.863 --> 01:26:29.961
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Yeah.

852
01:26:30.345 --> 01:26:42.617
<v Steve Novick>And finally, Mr. Bhattacharjee, I think you touched on this, but in terms of rent assistance, can we say that the city has only provided X kinds of rent assistance, they're different from the Y kinds of rent assistance that the county has provided?

853
01:26:43.099 --> 01:27:01.108
<v Michael Buonocore>Has there been either officially or unofficially I think in terms of the eviction legal defense interventions, I think there's a question of whether we're in parallel with each other.

854
01:27:02.110 --> 01:27:11.868
<v Michael Buonocore>But again, in terms of anything that you— that one might categorize as rent assistance, the only thing the city does is around eviction legal defense.

855
01:27:11.960 --> 01:27:21.710
<v Steve Novick>And is it true that the county does some of that too, but the county also does a lot of other rent assistance stuff?

856
01:27:22.380 --> 01:27:23.819
<v Michael Buonocore>I believe that's true.

857
01:27:24.239 --> 01:27:35.140
<v Rachel Pearl>Yeah, so, and, and DCHS is, because we are the designated community action agency, which is the designated, like, safety net provider for the county, we have eviction prevention.

858
01:27:35.140 --> 01:27:38.880
<v Rachel Pearl>We have also, we are a provider for the Medicaid 1115 waiver.

859
01:27:38.880 --> 01:27:39.020
<v Angelita Morillo>We have a lot of different programs.

860
01:27:39.315 --> 01:27:44.416
<v Rachel Pearl>We do contract out for legal defense and legal support related to evictions as well.

861
01:27:45.202 --> 01:27:46.645
<v Rachel Pearl>So those are— yes, we do.

862
01:27:47.094 --> 01:27:51.904
<v Rachel Pearl>We cover everything related to eviction prevention in DCHS.

863
01:27:52.867 --> 01:27:58.078
<v Steve Novick>And in the past, you've provided some rent assistance that goes beyond eviction prevention, no?

864
01:27:59.042 --> 01:27:59.170
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Yes.

865
01:27:59.715 --> 01:28:05.038
<v Rachel Pearl>So in terms of economic stability programs, we also have a program called Multnomah Stability Initiative.

866
01:28:05.231 --> 01:28:19.605
<v Rachel Pearl>Or MSI that's connected to the Sun Service System, which is largely a— it's a prevention program for households who have a child who's under 18 who are considered potentially at risk for becoming unstable in their housing.

867
01:28:19.670 --> 01:28:21.868
<v Rachel Pearl>And that's long-term case management and support.

868
01:28:22.028 --> 01:28:30.451
<v Rachel Pearl>But then we have eviction prevention, which is for folks who have an eviction notification or are already actively involved in an eviction court process.

869
01:28:30.899 --> 01:28:43.210
<v Steve Novick>And that's where and is that pretty similar— do you run that pretty similar to how the city does eviction prevention paired with some financial assistance?

870
01:28:43.210 --> 01:28:46.569
<v Rachel Pearl>I can't speak to how the city runs their legal support.

871
01:28:46.569 --> 01:28:49.399
<v Rachel Pearl>I don't know what your— the pairing with rent assistance is.

872
01:28:49.630 --> 01:29:18.911
<v Rachel Pearl>But I think we know that one of the things that we can continue to talk about, and I do think it's an area of exploration of like who should do what and is there opportunity for us to streamline if we are having duplication of services, is how do we make sure that we're providing the best I think the constant question around legal support as paired with the amount of dollars we actually have for eviction prevention, we really do need to make sure those are comparable amounts, that we aren't overly investing in legal support because we know that we can't prevent evictions if we don't actually have rental assistance to pair with the legal support.

873
01:29:19.023 --> 01:29:22.314
<v Rachel Pearl>So that is an important conversation that we need to continue to have.

874
01:29:22.363 --> 01:29:25.703
<v Rachel Pearl>And I think there's opportunities for us to partner with the city to streamline that.

875
01:29:26.221 --> 01:29:26.613
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

876
01:29:26.875 --> 01:29:28.867
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

877
01:29:28.932 --> 01:29:29.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>Commissioner Brem Edwards.

878
01:29:31.880 --> 01:29:32.202
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Thank you.

879
01:29:32.541 --> 01:29:50.859
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, so I just want to state one thing for the record, um, that when I joined the County Commission, um, Metro and the broader community was kicking the county because of the $100 million in unanticipated and underspent dollars, and the corrective action plan had us spending it.

880
01:29:50.957 --> 01:29:51.773
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So just Thank you.

881
01:29:51.853 --> 01:30:00.621
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Just for the record, it wasn't— there was a lot of pressure on the county because of the humanitarian crisis on the street to make those investments.

882
01:30:02.300 --> 01:30:04.784
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So it wasn't like people just ignored the fiscal cliff.

883
01:30:04.898 --> 01:30:09.676
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>There was a corrective action plan, and we had a crisis on their streets.

884
01:30:09.902 --> 01:30:15.618
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>And I think the county made both some long-term investments and also some ones that were needed right then.

885
01:30:15.796 --> 01:30:18.944
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Since I have limited time, I want to focus on the KPIs.

886
01:30:19.279 --> 01:30:26.835
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Number 1, which is reducing homelessness over 2 years, and 8, which is within 2 years reduce the share of people who are known to be unsheltered.

887
01:30:31.543 --> 01:30:39.698
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I support a unified city and county strategy on shelter and housing, respecting our roles.

888
01:30:40.610 --> 01:30:46.228
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I'm concerned that we're heading into both of our budgets yes.

889
01:30:46.698 --> 01:31:00.378
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Not with a discussion about the right mix, but about both entities looking at cutting some significant shelter capacity without taking into consideration what the overall impact will be of those cuts.

890
01:31:02.542 --> 01:31:12.576
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>The 675 that's proposed reduced by the county, added on top of the 230 that are coming offline already at the end of this fiscal year, year.

891
01:31:12.721 --> 01:31:20.317
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Just this last week, Sunstone, that is both a city and a county shelter provider, announced shutting its doors on June 30th.

892
01:31:22.359 --> 01:31:24.561
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Are all those individuals exiting to the street?

893
01:31:24.626 --> 01:31:26.346
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>That's, you know, my question.

894
01:31:26.411 --> 01:31:36.775
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I don't think that's a good thing for our community, and I think it certainly doesn't support KPI number 8 with it, you know, of reducing the share of people who are known to be unsheltered.

895
01:31:36.823 --> 01:31:47.170
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Councilor Loretta Smith, So I really hope that we have— we don't just have this quarterly meeting and then go our separate ways in the budget process, but really that we have— we act in a coordinated way.

896
01:31:48.342 --> 01:31:53.380
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I hope we act in a coordinated way to continue to provide adequate shelter capacity.

897
01:31:54.989 --> 01:31:58.860
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I mean, we do need to make investments in other places.

898
01:31:59.055 --> 01:32:03.452
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I will say though, giving someone a safe thank you.

899
01:32:03.613 --> 01:32:19.529
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So providing a safe place to sleep with basic services, access to other services, safety, the ability to get stabilized, to me, that's— has— is a valuable investment of our resources.

900
01:32:21.020 --> 01:32:21.837
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So we need to do that.

901
01:32:22.061 --> 01:32:27.304
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>To me, it's really an and conversation, not an or or instead of.

902
01:32:27.993 --> 01:32:36.131
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I'm hopeful that we can the city and the county don't just be like, hey, we're not gonna invest that anymore, the other side will do that.

903
01:32:36.599 --> 01:32:37.646
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>We really need to be coordinated.

904
01:32:37.743 --> 01:32:46.015
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>We have to have a, for those, if there are shelter beds that are reduced, that we need to have a person-level transition plan.

905
01:32:46.128 --> 01:32:50.136
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So every person from a shelter is not exiting to the street.

906
01:32:50.204 --> 01:32:51.256
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>That's the wrong thing to do.

907
01:32:52.677 --> 01:32:54.502
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So we should be acting in coordination and—.

908
01:32:54.600 --> 01:32:55.903
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Councilor Smith.

909
01:32:57.295 --> 01:33:02.961
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I think while we're doing that, the other piece is really like leaning into the conversation.

910
01:33:03.009 --> 01:33:09.123
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>This is one that the city will lead on housing production, but like, what is the housing— what's the city's housing production goal?

911
01:33:09.717 --> 01:33:11.113
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>How do we fill those vacant units?

912
01:33:11.162 --> 01:33:14.453
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>How does the county support the city in that work?

913
01:33:15.657 --> 01:33:22.319
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Because I think that's what our overall community expects us to do, not to be like, hey, we're keeping our money, Councilor Smith.

914
01:33:22.319 --> 01:33:22.319
<v Candace Avalos>I think it's important that we have a coordinated strategy.

915
01:33:22.319 --> 01:33:29.789
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>We're going to keep our money, they're keeping their money, and we're going to both do the things that we want to do, we want to invest in, but really having a coordinated strategy.

916
01:33:30.560 --> 01:33:41.460
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Because I think that's the only way we're going to actually make progress on these 2 key performance indicators, which I think are both important.

917
01:33:41.510 --> 01:33:48.240
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>And I think how this is phrased here, this says the goal is based on— but the goal is based on budget yes.

918
01:33:48.514 --> 01:33:51.783
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I think the community is going to look at that and say, what does that mean?

919
01:33:52.137 --> 01:33:58.213
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>We expect outcomes and reductions in both homelessness and unsheltered homelessness.

920
01:33:58.650 --> 01:34:01.127
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>And so what are the budget votes that need to happen?

921
01:34:01.239 --> 01:34:06.926
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>What's the coordination and the planning that needs to happen in order to actually see improvements?

922
01:34:07.497 --> 01:34:10.712
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Not in 2 years, but in this upcoming budget year.

923
01:34:12.289 --> 01:34:17.679
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I hope this is maybe a message to leadership that we continue these conversations.

924
01:34:17.779 --> 01:34:25.872
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>These discussions and the coordination, um, because we can't be blaming, um, the other party, um, at the other end of our budget process.

925
01:34:26.385 --> 01:34:28.019
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I think our community expects more.

926
01:34:28.948 --> 01:34:29.525
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Commissioner.

927
01:34:29.590 --> 01:34:39.284
<v Skylar Breading>Council President, if I may just— I know it wasn't a question, but I just, I want to offer maybe a ray of hope for folks, because I think, um, Commissioner, thank you for those, um, for that statement.

928
01:34:39.349 --> 01:34:44.639
<v Skylar Breading>I think we are more coordinated than I think we've ever been, um, so I will I will just offer that.

929
01:34:44.975 --> 01:34:49.824
<v Skylar Breading>I think there is room for improvement and we will keep working on it and we can always coordinate better and more.

930
01:34:50.837 --> 01:34:56.439
<v Skylar Breading>But I just want to state that that's been my reality for the last 4 years and I think I really appreciate the partnership.

931
01:34:57.018 --> 01:34:59.170
<v Skylar Breading>Julie and I talk on the phone literally every single day.

932
01:34:59.426 --> 01:35:01.948
<v Skylar Breading>So I think just want to name that.

933
01:35:02.060 --> 01:35:04.596
<v Skylar Breading>I do think there is room for improvement and we need to keep working better.

934
01:35:04.645 --> 01:35:09.189
<v Skylar Breading>And I think the elected bodies also need to be talking and coordinating in that way, not just the administrative bodies.

935
01:35:10.345 --> 01:35:32.470
<v Skylar Breading>I would also just mention, I think we've definitely been talking about fiscal cliffs for a long time, and I will just offer, I think it's been a conversation between the former city administrator Mike Jordan, the COO at the county Chris Neal, and now the new city administrator Raymond Lee about not swapping money back and forth and coordinating our services.

936
01:35:32.567 --> 01:35:39.135
<v Skylar Breading>So I think both of those things have been really underlined by those conversations that have happened behind closed doors often.

937
01:35:39.247 --> 01:35:44.144
<v Skylar Breading>But I just wanted to name that because I think maybe you all don't ever see that every day.

938
01:35:44.224 --> 01:35:49.844
<v Skylar Breading>And I think those conversations have happened and are happening and that coordination is taking place.

939
01:35:50.164 --> 01:35:57.069
<v Skylar Breading>Again, we have plenty of room to improve, but I think it's gotten a lot better and we're trying really hard.

940
01:35:57.149 --> 01:36:10.203
<v Skylar Breading>And I think to your point, Commissioner, When we hear there's a constrained budget and we're going to have to close shelter at the county, our first call is to our county partners to say, how do we help with the humans who are going to leave those shelter beds?

941
01:36:10.622 --> 01:36:11.537
<v Skylar Breading>How are we going to help?

942
01:36:11.600 --> 01:36:14.443
<v Skylar Breading>Because we have overnight shelter, we are working on housing placement.

943
01:36:15.117 --> 01:36:16.145
<v Skylar Breading>How do we help you?

944
01:36:16.643 --> 01:36:17.237
<v Skylar Breading>What do you need?

945
01:36:17.301 --> 01:36:23.819
<v Skylar Breading>And I think those are the conversations that really hearten me of this is a system, this is a city, this is a county, and we're working on this together.

946
01:36:23.884 --> 01:36:25.377
<v Skylar Breading>So sorry for editorializing.

947
01:36:25.426 --> 01:36:32.760
<v Skylar Breading>I just wanted to say yeah, I was—.

948
01:36:32.760 --> 01:36:39.199
<v Anna Plum>I would just add on that, and I was going to jump in and say I think one of the places where we coordinate the best is in the event of a program closure or move.

949
01:36:39.199 --> 01:36:45.760
<v Anna Plum>We work together really, really, really intensively to find places for folks who work with our providers, who work with each other.

950
01:36:45.960 --> 01:36:51.479
<v Anna Plum>Like, that is a place where I think we do a really good job of coordinating to focus on the humans who are, who are in those spaces who need a safe place to be.

951
01:36:51.479 --> 01:36:51.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dan Ryan.

952
01:36:53.122 --> 01:37:12.605
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I really appreciate that, and I have heard that informally, but I think it's really important to make it more public in ways that people can see it, because all we see is, hey, there's 675 shelter beds that are coming offline, and what does that mean to the community, and which ones are being closed?

953
01:37:12.686 --> 01:37:17.970
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>And it's not being explained in a way, or the path ahead being laid out in a way that people can see.

954
01:37:18.019 --> 01:37:18.408
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Councilor Smith.

955
01:37:19.644 --> 01:37:22.640
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Described in a way that the city and county are working together.

956
01:37:22.737 --> 01:37:27.659
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I love that that's happening, but it's not visible.

957
01:37:28.307 --> 01:37:34.203
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>And so making it visible so that people can see that coordination, because you have a lot of people really panicked in the community right now.

958
01:37:35.399 --> 01:37:42.328
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I mean, there's lots of shelter providers, staff who feel like they're going to lose their jobs shortly.

959
01:37:43.460 --> 01:37:57.550
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>You have community members who feel like they're absolutely.

960
01:37:57.550 --> 01:37:58.350
<v Skylar Breading>Thank you.

961
01:37:58.350 --> 01:37:59.810
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Commissioner.

962
01:37:59.810 --> 01:38:00.970
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

963
01:38:01.909 --> 01:38:02.729
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

964
01:38:02.729 --> 01:38:04.149
<v Olivia Clark>Just a couple of quick things.

965
01:38:04.149 --> 01:38:06.510
<v Olivia Clark>I want to reinforce some of the things that have already been said.

966
01:38:07.109 --> 01:38:11.569
<v Olivia Clark>It's been a good dialogue, but I think it's time we move from coordination to consolidation.

967
01:38:11.712 --> 01:38:12.081
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

968
01:38:12.658 --> 01:38:16.578
<v Olivia Clark>And that's something that we're looking at in the change of government here in the city.

969
01:38:17.493 --> 01:38:19.935
<v Olivia Clark>We're moving in that direction in our bureaus as well.

970
01:38:20.063 --> 01:38:23.564
<v Olivia Clark>So I really think we need to continue to discuss consolidation.

971
01:38:24.384 --> 01:38:35.047
<v Olivia Clark>I think if the public, you know, sees this, this complex web of fragmented programs, they're going to scratch their head and wonder about the cost of administration.

972
01:38:36.108 --> 01:38:47.154
<v Olivia Clark>How much money are we spending both To some degree, I think we also need to discuss consolidating of the providers, consolidating.

973
01:38:47.588 --> 01:39:00.417
<v Olivia Clark>And I know I heard you say, Councilor Koyama Lane, that it's not a one-size-fits-all, but I do think that we need to look at some way of saving administrative costs through consolidation.

974
01:39:01.076 --> 01:39:03.180
<v Olivia Clark>And you asked the question about what would be my ideal.

975
01:39:03.228 --> 01:39:03.275
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

976
01:39:03.323 --> 01:39:15.810
<v Olivia Clark>I think that we need to look at simplify this entire system so that there's one place to call, there's one place to get help, there's one way to enter the system, just to make it as easy as possible.

977
01:39:16.260 --> 01:39:20.801
<v Olivia Clark>And I want to also reinforce the idea of the additional psych beds.

978
01:39:20.899 --> 01:39:31.490
<v Olivia Clark>I think you're absolutely right, Jillian, that— and I think that Commissioner Megan Moyer started out with that, that I think we have to have a shared legislative agenda around that.

979
01:39:31.572 --> 01:39:36.836
<v Olivia Clark>The city and the county need to link arms and go to the legislature and ask for those things together.

980
01:39:37.349 --> 01:39:41.394
<v Olivia Clark>You know, I've talked about having an annex of the state hospital up here, but maybe that's not the approach.

981
01:39:41.457 --> 01:39:43.336
<v Olivia Clark>Maybe it's just psych beds somewhere.

982
01:39:44.346 --> 01:39:49.483
<v Olivia Clark>But I'd like to see us more closely coordinate our legislative strategy around that.

983
01:39:49.804 --> 01:39:53.815
<v Olivia Clark>But I would just emphasize, I think we really need to move from coordination to consolidation.

984
01:39:54.842 --> 01:39:56.384
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

985
01:39:57.042 --> 01:39:57.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, morning, Tim.

986
01:39:57.764 --> 01:39:58.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think Councilor Avalos.

987
01:40:00.962 --> 01:40:02.002
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you.

988
01:40:06.260 --> 01:40:12.907
<v Candace Avalos>So, um, I want to start by talking about how I'm thinking of this conversation overall.

989
01:40:13.855 --> 01:40:18.145
<v Candace Avalos>It is important that our understanding of homelessness reflects current conditions.

990
01:40:19.175 --> 01:40:28.140
<v Candace Avalos>While individual factors can lead to— play a big role, whether that's mental illness, substance abuse, there's also domestic violence is a big factor to homelessness.

991
01:40:28.206 --> 01:40:31.689
<v Candace Avalos>Let's not forget there there's actually a long list of them.

992
01:40:32.506 --> 01:40:38.006
<v Candace Avalos>The strongest driver of homelessness today is structural: the cost of rent and the lack of available housing.

993
01:40:38.743 --> 01:40:40.443
<v Candace Avalos>We see this consistently in the data.

994
01:40:40.523 --> 01:40:46.743
<v Candace Avalos>Places with higher housing costs and lower vacancy rates have higher rates of homelessness, regardless of any of those other factors.

995
01:40:47.159 --> 01:40:55.078
<v Candace Avalos>So in other words, the strongest predictor is whether people can afford housing, rent burden relative to income, not whether they have a behavioral health condition.

996
01:40:55.159 --> 01:40:55.967
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

997
01:40:57.698 --> 01:41:03.503
<v Candace Avalos>I think what differs is, you know, mental illness exists in every community, but homelessness does not, right?

998
01:41:03.828 --> 01:41:06.440
<v Candace Avalos>And what differs is whether people have access to housing they can afford.

999
01:41:07.150 --> 01:41:11.309
<v Candace Avalos>Homelessness happens when vulnerable people are in a system where housing is too scarce and too expensive.

1000
01:41:11.859 --> 01:41:15.832
<v Candace Avalos>So that framing matters to me because I think it informs what our role should be as the city.

1001
01:41:16.578 --> 01:41:20.949
<v Candace Avalos>Now, when I look at the Homeless to Housing Continuum, I see that the city's strongest role on the front Councilmember Smith.

1002
01:41:20.949 --> 01:41:20.949
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Mayor.

1003
01:41:20.949 --> 01:41:22.130
<v Candace Avalos>I think that we need to focus on both the front and the back ends.

1004
01:41:22.130 --> 01:41:29.329
<v Candace Avalos>So that to me looks like preventing people from entering homelessness in the first place and ensuring that there is enough housing for people to exit into.

1005
01:41:29.829 --> 01:41:40.250
<v Candace Avalos>That means eviction prevention, rent assistance, housing stabilization on the front end, and housing production, especially permanently affordable social municipal supportive housing on the back end.

1006
01:41:40.510 --> 01:41:43.090
<v Candace Avalos>I don't think that the city should be in the shelter business long term.

1007
01:41:43.090 --> 01:41:56.786
<v Candace Avalos>I think that the county is better positioned to lead on services, outreach, behavioral health, shelter operations, case management, And our job is to make sure fewer people ever need those services in the first place, and that when we do, when the when they do, there's somewhere for them to go.

1008
01:41:57.748 --> 01:41:59.850
<v Candace Avalos>And so that is where I see rental assistance becoming critical.

1009
01:41:59.914 --> 01:42:04.649
<v Candace Avalos>I know this is a growing discussion that I just want to name and put my stake in the ground.

1010
01:42:05.194 --> 01:42:11.917
<v Candace Avalos>If the primary driver of homelessness is the inability to pay rent, then preventing that loss of housing is one of the most effective tools that we have, in my opinion.

1011
01:42:12.511 --> 01:42:15.944
<v Candace Avalos>And so when someone falls behind by a month or two, that's often the tipping point for them.

1012
01:42:16.283 --> 01:42:25.082
<v Candace Avalos>And a relatively small amount of rental assistance can keep a household stable and prevent a much more expensive and traumatic experience that is homelessness.

1013
01:42:25.533 --> 01:42:33.033
<v Candace Avalos>So if we're serious about slowing the inflow, I, I think that we need to invest in the tools that actually do that, and rental assistance is one of the most direct proven ways.

1014
01:42:33.948 --> 01:42:39.038
<v Candace Avalos>In a post-COVID environment, you know, we've been talking about ARPA funds winding down.

1015
01:42:39.552 --> 01:42:54.422
<v Candace Avalos>I think that, you know, as everyone has said, we just have to be real clear about our goals, and the city should be leading where the market will never meet the need— below-market housing, supportive housing, long-term affordability— while also maintaining strong prevention strategies like the rental assistance and eviction defense.

1016
01:42:54.827 --> 01:42:57.836
<v Candace Avalos>And I think the county should continue leading on the service side of the system.

1017
01:42:58.466 --> 01:43:09.641
<v Candace Avalos>Now, given the fiscal constraints that we're heading into, we have to be more intentional, and I think our limited dollars should be concentrated, um, in the prevention of homelessness, building the housing solutions that don't Councilor Smith.

1018
01:43:09.738 --> 01:43:09.948
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Mayor.

1019
01:43:10.029 --> 01:43:12.515
<v Candace Avalos>I think that we need to be very intentional about the services that exist today at a scale that we need.

1020
01:43:12.613 --> 01:43:17.587
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that, you know, as everyone is saying, maybe taking a step back from areas that are better led by other governments, including the county.

1021
01:43:19.328 --> 01:43:24.182
<v Candace Avalos>Now, ultimately what success looks like to me is, you know, what you said, Jillian, right?

1022
01:43:24.247 --> 01:43:26.118
<v Candace Avalos>Fewer people entering homelessness in the first place.

1023
01:43:26.184 --> 01:43:29.185
<v Candace Avalos>I think that has to be the number one success metric for us.

1024
01:43:30.318 --> 01:43:38.048
<v Candace Avalos>And that success will come because we've stabilized them upstream and there's a clear functioning pathway into permanent housing for those who do end up experiencing homelessness.

1025
01:43:38.662 --> 01:43:39.016
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1026
01:43:39.787 --> 01:43:45.215
<v Candace Avalos>And so that requires that both sides of the system are working together, that strong prevention and the supportive housing.

1027
01:43:46.113 --> 01:43:56.197
<v Candace Avalos>I also want to name something that I've been hearing consistently, which is that staff are asking for clearer direction, and at the same time, we as policymakers are often turning back to the staff for that direction.

1028
01:43:56.246 --> 01:43:57.675
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm just like, oh no, we're in this cycle.

1029
01:43:57.770 --> 01:43:59.199
<v Candace Avalos>So let's just call that out real quick.

1030
01:43:59.939 --> 01:44:02.877
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that what that signals is that we just need to be clearer about our roles.

1031
01:44:03.054 --> 01:44:14.694
<v Candace Avalos>And so for the council, you know, I, and I The council and the commission, but for the sake of who I am, council needs to set the vision and the policy direction, and your job, right, is to operationalize that.

1032
01:44:15.112 --> 01:44:23.557
<v Candace Avalos>And so if we're asking the staff to define the vision, then we're going to continue to see, you know, some of the incremental approaches instead of the structural alignment that we need.

1033
01:44:23.622 --> 01:44:31.457
<v Candace Avalos>Because understandably, I think staff get worried about getting ahead of the electeds, but then electeds, you know, we don't always have all of the right information.

1034
01:44:31.506 --> 01:44:35.917
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm just calling that out as a problem that we need to continue to work on solving.

1035
01:44:35.980 --> 01:44:39.573
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that can be solved in lots of ways that I'm happy to lead on in the future.

1036
01:44:40.712 --> 01:44:45.572
<v Candace Avalos>And then I think ultimately, you know, that is a big part of why we've been working on the unified housing strategy.

1037
01:44:45.764 --> 01:44:47.912
<v Candace Avalos>And we're making really good progress on that.

1038
01:44:48.635 --> 01:44:54.296
<v Candace Avalos>All of these folks are in those meetings and helping us to define what our role is on the continuum.

1039
01:44:55.466 --> 01:44:58.930
<v Candace Avalos>Because without that shared framework, we're just going to continue to have these same conversations.

1040
01:44:59.027 --> 01:45:13.747
<v Candace Avalos>So I hope that as we enter in these next couple of months, you know, the new housing committee will get up and going, and the plan is to bring those discussions to the committee, bring those to the whole council, uh, so that hopefully— it sounds like you guys need the vision, and that's what we need to do.

1041
01:45:13.796 --> 01:45:15.064
<v Candace Avalos>So we need to be charged.

1042
01:45:15.128 --> 01:45:26.753
<v Candace Avalos>And I agree that we're kind of in this conundrum, but, um, I would ask that, um, we start figuring out how to give that clear direction to staff, because, um, sometimes we keep expecting it back and forth, and that's clearly not working.

1043
01:45:27.800 --> 01:45:28.859
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1044
01:45:28.859 --> 01:45:30.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, President.

1045
01:45:33.619 --> 01:45:34.819
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>Thank you, Chair.

1046
01:45:34.819 --> 01:45:36.050
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>Uh, just a couple things.

1047
01:45:36.180 --> 01:45:40.600
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>One, I'm one of the only commissioners that— or the only commissioner that has 4 other cities outside of Portland.

1048
01:45:41.020 --> 01:45:49.100
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>Um, so just, uh, yes, coordination, but please, please, please, please invite the folks out in East Multnomah County as far as like the homeless services division.

1049
01:45:49.479 --> 01:45:50.800
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>I think you guys already do that with Jessica.

1050
01:45:51.369 --> 01:45:55.484
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>Um, one of the big— biggest things that one thing that we continue to lean into is just coordination.

1051
01:45:55.613 --> 01:46:08.953
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>Like even for the nighttime shelters specifically, it sounds like we started that process as far as DHS figuring out how can we potentially coordinate services for folks that are in our care, even if it's for 12 hours at night.

1052
01:46:09.902 --> 01:46:16.354
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>And then also I just would like to take it a step further to think through if we collectively can think through how are we using technology.

1053
01:46:16.418 --> 01:46:21.747
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>I know we have Housing Connector and OneApp and other, you know, of businesses here.

1054
01:46:21.939 --> 01:46:28.336
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>How can we fulfill the vacancies and ensure that folks that need wraparound services have those wraparound services here in Multnomah County?

1055
01:46:28.832 --> 01:46:41.640
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>And then we need to do a better job as far as— and I'm repeating some of the things that has been said already— as far as working with our partners at the state level, DHS, and then also OHA, and really build out a system of care that works for our most vulnerable.

1056
01:46:42.395 --> 01:46:48.699
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>Lastly, I appreciate your leadership and then the push and we can figure this out together, and that's what we're doing.

1057
01:46:48.796 --> 01:46:51.318
<v Alisha Jones-Dixon>So thank you, and unfortunately I have to leave.

1058
01:46:51.783 --> 01:46:53.166
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Commissioner Jones-Dixon.

1059
01:46:53.695 --> 01:46:55.045
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1060
01:46:56.121 --> 01:46:57.085
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

1061
01:46:57.792 --> 01:47:06.368
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I want to uplift something I've heard from providers who are possibly going to have to shut down their programming, their shelters.

1062
01:47:06.706 --> 01:47:22.105
<v Anna Plum>Um, has there been conversation about there being an extended ramp-down period from We're in active conversation with our providers around various options for what closures could look like across the community.

1063
01:47:22.395 --> 01:47:25.166
<v Anna Plum>I think the thing to keep in mind is that any extension would cost money.

1064
01:47:27.329 --> 01:47:48.404
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then the other question is around— I started talking to the mayor about this yesterday, but is there a way to think about some of our current vacant affordable housing units and potentially and seeing if we can— if first access, first dibs can be given to those who are losing shelter or those who are coming out of shelter.

1065
01:47:49.002 --> 01:47:49.979
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is that something we can do?

1066
01:47:53.259 --> 01:47:59.162
<v Michael Buonocore>I think we can physically do it.

1067
01:47:59.309 --> 01:48:17.648
<v Michael Buonocore>I think there's a, you know, there are, as we said before, many compounding issues that affordable housing providers are facing and the most the most visible one is literal vacancies, you know, empty apartments that we want to see there be a connection between.

1068
01:48:17.936 --> 01:48:22.194
<v Michael Buonocore>There's a space for someone to have a home and a person who needs it.

1069
01:48:23.095 --> 01:48:33.041
<v Michael Buonocore>What's less visible is referred to as economic vacancy, which is folks who are in apartments and are struggling to pay their rent.

1070
01:48:33.282 --> 01:48:34.005
<v Michael Buonocore>And so— I think that's a good point.

1071
01:48:34.573 --> 01:48:40.252
<v Michael Buonocore>Apartments that look occupied by rent-paying folks, that's not necessarily the case.

1072
01:48:41.667 --> 01:48:52.836
<v Michael Buonocore>So if we are making that connection of someone who is homeless to an empty apartment and they don't have income, we don't really have a solution, right?

1073
01:48:52.884 --> 01:49:00.279
<v Michael Buonocore>We have a physical environment, but no— housing providers simply cannot operate with no revenue coming in.

1074
01:49:00.377 --> 01:49:01.344
<v Michael Buonocore>So there has to be a— Yeah.

1075
01:49:02.899 --> 01:49:11.409
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Which maybe could be continued conversation as we talk about these housing dollars.

1076
01:49:11.479 --> 01:49:12.960
<v Jillian Schoene>Yes.

1077
01:49:12.960 --> 01:49:17.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1078
01:49:17.500 --> 01:49:19.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1079
01:49:19.300 --> 01:49:20.399
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1080
01:49:20.399 --> 01:49:26.579
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to note to the public that's listening that nobody likes any of the kind of cuts that any of us are talking about.

1081
01:49:26.899 --> 01:49:39.479
<v Steve Novick>But I wanted to say that from the city perspective, we are committed to making sure that we are able to when one-time money for housing, homelessness-related stuff expires, the only pot of money we could theoretically use to make that up is the general fund.

1082
01:49:39.550 --> 01:49:44.189
<v Steve Novick>And in the city, the general fund mostly goes to police, fire, and parks.

1083
01:49:44.189 --> 01:49:52.510
<v Steve Novick>So we'll be— what we'll be talking about is cutting police, fire, and parks in order to continue funding shelters or what have you.

1084
01:49:52.510 --> 01:49:55.310
<v Steve Novick>And I'm sure the county has similar constraints.

1085
01:49:55.310 --> 01:49:57.149
<v Steve Novick>I actually just wanted to see if any of the commissioners wanted to weigh in on to that.

1086
01:49:57.149 --> 01:49:57.210
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1087
01:49:57.193 --> 01:50:04.604
<v Steve Novick>Step up and say what general fund programs they have that they'd have to cut further if they were trying to avoid cutting these homeless dollars.

1088
01:50:09.654 --> 01:50:19.882
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Yeah, I mean, I, I think we're in a similar position in that when you look at what general fund dollars fund at the county, as well as similarly at the city, we're talking about public safety investments.

1089
01:50:19.979 --> 01:50:24.378
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>You know, our Multnomah County Sheriff's Office is almost entirely funded by general fund dollars.

1090
01:50:24.662 --> 01:50:30.930
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>We have similar with our District Attorney's Office, but we also have like really incredible programs in DCHS.

1091
01:50:31.076 --> 01:50:47.235
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>A lot of our youth and family services system programs are all funded by general fund dollars, and some of those are the most important upstream investments that we are making, including some that are helping with things like eviction prevention or employment opportunities to help stabilize folks.

1092
01:50:47.511 --> 01:50:50.850
<v Anna Plum>So, I mean, I think we can all say this, that there are no good cuts.

1093
01:50:50.899 --> 01:50:50.948
<v Mitch Green>Right.

1094
01:50:51.100 --> 01:50:51.180
<v Michael Buonocore>Yes.

1095
01:50:51.778 --> 01:51:08.488
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>—That any of us are having to face in these more difficult economic times and looking at the new normal that we're getting to in terms of sources of funding like SHS dollars, as well as the really unstable environment, federal environment that we have dealing with.

1096
01:51:08.537 --> 01:51:16.668
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>So as we're making these decisions, as we're thinking about, well, do you have to— do you want to continue this one-time-only investment?

1097
01:51:17.032 --> 01:51:19.965
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>It's all about the trade-offs, and they're not easy.

1098
01:51:20.462 --> 01:51:39.649
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>And I think that's why this conversation that we're having today and the work that we've been doing about how do we more— how do we best work together in order to fund a system that is effective and efficient and gets us to the goal of connecting people to safer, stable, and permanent places to live is incredibly important.

1099
01:51:40.130 --> 01:51:43.929
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>So thank you for bringing that up and for helping to raise up, like, these are not easy decisions.

1100
01:51:44.041 --> 01:51:44.136
<v Skylar Breading>Thank you.

1101
01:51:44.747 --> 01:51:47.582
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>But they're critical ones that we're all gonna be making in the next several months.

1102
01:51:48.467 --> 01:51:51.252
<v Steve Novick>Finally, just, I'm sorry that Commissioner Jones-Dixon left.

1103
01:51:51.591 --> 01:51:58.533
<v Steve Novick>He mentioned the fact that he represents other cities, and I just wanna state the obvious, which is that it would solve all our problems if Wood Village just stepped up and did their fair share.

1104
01:52:00.042 --> 01:52:00.542
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hear, hear.

1105
01:52:00.608 --> 01:52:02.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1106
01:52:02.805 --> 01:52:04.953
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1107
01:52:05.114 --> 01:52:05.373
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1108
01:52:06.988 --> 01:52:12.847
<v Mitch Green>Just briefly, you know, This is an important conversation 'cause we don't have a lot of money.

1109
01:52:13.283 --> 01:52:17.225
<v Mitch Green>We, in fact, we're at a deficit across our jurisdiction, so we need to figure out how to close.

1110
01:52:18.079 --> 01:52:25.260
<v Mitch Green>So in that kind of a space, I wanna make sure we're not doing things that are pennywise and pound foolish.

1111
01:52:26.640 --> 01:52:36.484
<v Mitch Green>Like for example, the impact reduction program hauls away a lot of personal belongings, trash, what have you.

1112
01:52:37.472 --> 01:52:39.846
<v Mitch Green>And that's what that program does.

1113
01:52:40.024 --> 01:52:55.287
<v Mitch Green>But if we make sure that we adequately fund programs like the glitter program in particular, then I believe that they've got like a sort of a laundry reuse type of like, they sort of divert some of that away from the waste stream to be reused.

1114
01:52:55.707 --> 01:53:02.930
<v Mitch Green>That can cut our costs to the impact reduction program because I think we get the swelling of the volume in the winter months when it's wet.

1115
01:53:03.577 --> 01:53:03.817
<v Mitch Green>Right?

1116
01:53:03.898 --> 01:53:04.891
<v Mitch Green>That's how we measure this stuff.

1117
01:53:04.956 --> 01:53:21.960
<v Mitch Green>So, you know, I think about making sure that we're seeing opportunities to preserve the buckets of money that we have and just make more efficient choices in that while also providing these ancillary benefits for sort of, you know, jobs for those that traditional labor markets cannot provide.

1118
01:53:22.746 --> 01:53:24.622
<v Mitch Green>And so it looks like you want to say something.

1119
01:53:24.686 --> 01:53:26.307
<v Skylar Breading>Yeah, well, Councilor, I just appreciate that.

1120
01:53:26.372 --> 01:53:34.586
<v Skylar Breading>I would just say I think that's exactly why the Impact Reduction Program chose to invest in the wash house to get it up and running and in the glitter program for exactly that reason.

1121
01:53:34.650 --> 01:53:46.587
<v Skylar Breading>Because we see it's frustrating, I think, to us to like keep having to do the same thing when we could actually do something else and fund a program that would divert and reuse kind of those textiles that we're finding on the street.

1122
01:53:46.636 --> 01:53:47.779
<v Skylar Breading>So I just wanted to share that.

1123
01:53:48.563 --> 01:53:49.652
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for acknowledging that.

1124
01:53:49.699 --> 01:53:52.981
<v Mitch Green>That's going to be really important to me to make sure that we see an ongoing commitment there.

1125
01:53:53.112 --> 01:53:59.243
<v Mitch Green>But also, I know that there are more people lined up per day looking for work with that program than they have available.

1126
01:53:59.358 --> 01:54:02.256
<v Mitch Green>And that's and that's a huge opportunity for us.

1127
01:54:02.692 --> 01:54:08.989
<v Mitch Green>We want to provide a job for anyone who wants to work and who has the capacity to do something and give back.

1128
01:54:09.636 --> 01:54:10.993
<v Mitch Green>So thank you.

1129
01:54:11.704 --> 01:54:13.095
<v Skylar Breading>Yeah, we're looking to expand that.

1130
01:54:13.644 --> 01:54:13.822
<v Skylar Breading>Yep.

1131
01:54:14.387 --> 01:54:15.243
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1132
01:54:15.907 --> 01:54:17.490
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to put myself in the queue.

1133
01:54:19.199 --> 01:54:37.244
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, I heard a lot of agreement across this board and a lot of, not, I mean, a lot of agreement across I personally don't quite understand why we have a system where we have 24/7 beds and how those are dramatically more expensive than overnight-only beds plus day centers.

1134
01:54:37.824 --> 01:54:40.868
<v Jamie Dunphy>Feels like it's going to be a wash ultimately.

1135
01:54:43.176 --> 01:54:45.140
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's nothing on this chart that I would like to cut.

1136
01:54:45.510 --> 01:54:47.971
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would like to expand all of these things until we solve the problem.

1137
01:54:48.020 --> 01:54:49.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's obviously not where we're at.

1138
01:54:49.725 --> 01:54:59.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so from my perspective, anywhere that the color is over overlap needs to be the priority of us getting into our own lanes and doubling down on what works and what doesn't.

1139
01:55:02.759 --> 01:55:05.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's a lot of good work happening here across this thing.

1140
01:55:05.435 --> 01:55:12.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I also want to totally acknowledge what, Sky, what you were saying, that the systems are working better together than they ever have.

1141
01:55:12.126 --> 01:55:13.421
<v Jamie Dunphy>And is there room for improvement?

1142
01:55:13.565 --> 01:55:13.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

1143
01:55:13.841 --> 01:55:18.792
<v Jamie Dunphy>Should we probably think about, as Councilor Clark was, or Vice President Clark was saying, yes.

1144
01:55:19.051 --> 01:55:19.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>Some consolidation?

1145
01:55:20.067 --> 01:55:20.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

1146
01:55:20.729 --> 01:55:24.859
<v Jamie Dunphy>Should we— is there work to be done on our contract languages across our 2 bodies?

1147
01:55:24.908 --> 01:55:25.618
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, absolutely.

1148
01:55:26.376 --> 01:55:27.521
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's prioritize some of that.

1149
01:55:27.569 --> 01:55:29.735
<v Jamie Dunphy>But also, we need to double down on what is working.

1150
01:55:29.993 --> 01:55:39.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I am also hearing the call from staff for more input from us and more direction to say this is what comes next.

1151
01:55:39.077 --> 01:55:43.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I look forward to working with all of you towards what that next vision may be.

1152
01:55:44.270 --> 01:55:45.503
<v Jamie Dunphy>With— we have 9 minutes left.

1153
01:55:45.583 --> 01:55:51.338
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to turn it to Commissioner Moyer for our last word, and then I'm going to turn it to the mayor for— oh, and Councilor Avalos, and then the mayor.

1154
01:55:52.317 --> 01:55:54.064
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Commissioner Moyer first.

1155
01:55:54.400 --> 01:56:14.573
<v Meghan Moyer>Yeah, I do think one of the things that we have not talked about, but it is really important because it was very much central in the passing of SHS, is that there was, and when passed, and continues and should continue to be A focus on reducing people who experience chronic homelessness.

1156
01:56:15.006 --> 01:56:26.756
<v Meghan Moyer>And that is an important distinction because people who experience chronic homelessness, it is a more challenging community to successfully permanently house.

1157
01:56:27.207 --> 01:56:34.847
<v Meghan Moyer>We— if we want to house the most number of people for the least amount of money, we would entirely focus not on chronic homelessness.

1158
01:56:34.912 --> 01:56:47.546
<v Meghan Moyer>We would focus on eviction prevention, People who don't have disability, who don't experience significant barriers to being rehoused, would go in, swoop in.

1159
01:56:47.899 --> 01:57:06.538
<v Meghan Moyer>I'm for all of those things, but I am very nervous in some of this conversation that we're not remembering that the intention of that money had a focus on people who experience chronic homelessness, which means they're likely to be experiencing co-occurring challenges.

1160
01:57:06.603 --> 01:57:25.293
<v Meghan Moyer>Councilor Smith, But in my district, and I'm sure other people see this in areas of their district, there is a high concentration of people who experience chronic homelessness who are also experiencing a variety of other issues such as behavioral health or disability on our street.

1161
01:57:25.780 --> 01:57:34.579
<v Meghan Moyer>And I, you know, from my perspective, it's just my perspective, there is also a moral imperative to serve those people even if they cost more.

1162
01:57:34.628 --> 01:57:34.677
<v Meghan Moyer>Yes.

1163
01:57:35.542 --> 01:57:38.926
<v Meghan Moyer>Because our safety net system has crumbled.

1164
01:57:39.391 --> 01:57:42.712
<v Meghan Moyer>And I— that is so beyond this room of individuals.

1165
01:57:42.760 --> 01:57:43.947
<v Meghan Moyer>We didn't create that.

1166
01:57:44.524 --> 01:58:03.899
<v Meghan Moyer>But I don't want us to lose how important it is to struggle with building the right system, even for the people who have the most barriers, and even if they are never fully independent, um, because it is incredibly important to who we are as a community.

1167
01:58:03.962 --> 01:58:04.106
<v Meghan Moyer>Thank you.

1168
01:58:04.493 --> 01:58:06.282
<v Meghan Moyer>That we not leave those people behind.

1169
01:58:06.411 --> 01:58:13.180
<v Meghan Moyer>Not that I think anybody implied that here, but, um, I just wanted to say that because they, they cost more.

1170
01:58:13.600 --> 01:58:13.939
<v Meghan Moyer>They do.

1171
01:58:18.989 --> 01:58:19.699
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

1172
01:58:19.894 --> 01:58:20.685
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Commissioner Moyer.

1173
01:58:21.756 --> 01:58:23.162
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, what's going on?

1174
01:58:24.655 --> 01:58:27.180
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, yeah, wait for the weird sound to go away.

1175
01:58:27.423 --> 01:58:28.645
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, okay.

1176
01:58:28.792 --> 01:58:29.997
<v Jamie Dunphy>Commissioner Avalos or Councilor Avalos.

1177
01:58:30.844 --> 01:58:31.454
<v Candace Avalos>I know it's confusing.

1178
01:58:32.917 --> 01:58:36.805
<v Candace Avalos>I just wanted to first react to what you're saying because I completely agree, Commissioner.

1179
01:58:37.577 --> 01:58:54.127
<v Candace Avalos>And I think my— where my brain is at is I'm concerned about us creating more chronically homeless people by not fixing the problem of not letting people become homeless because too many more people are becoming homeless due to all the factors we talked about.

1180
01:58:54.546 --> 01:58:55.140
<v Candace Avalos>So that's my concern.

1181
01:58:55.189 --> 01:58:55.766
<v Candace Avalos>So I agree with you.

1182
01:58:56.137 --> 01:59:02.269
<v Candace Avalos>There are going to be a group of people that are just always going to be difficult to care for and are going to have unique needs.

1183
01:59:02.317 --> 01:59:06.935
<v Candace Avalos>And we need to create systems that adapt to that because that is ultimately government's job is to address those things, right?

1184
01:59:07.001 --> 01:59:08.724
<v Candace Avalos>We have disability programs.

1185
01:59:08.773 --> 01:59:10.056
<v Candace Avalos>We have all these programs for that reason.

1186
01:59:10.756 --> 01:59:20.735
<v Candace Avalos>And, you know, if we don't stop the amount of people going in, we're just going to create more long-term chronic homeless people that are going to be even more of a strain on the system.

1187
01:59:20.801 --> 01:59:22.235
<v Candace Avalos>So just want to affirm what you're saying.

1188
01:59:22.926 --> 01:59:23.506
<v Candace Avalos>And lift that up.

1189
01:59:23.971 --> 01:59:30.782
<v Candace Avalos>I actually just had a quick question because I was reflecting on what you framed, Council President, and you were like, let's look at the places where there's overlap and pick a lane.

1190
01:59:31.440 --> 01:59:36.259
<v Candace Avalos>And that when I looked back at the diagram, I realized that under housing placement, it's all blue.

1191
01:59:36.822 --> 01:59:40.387
<v Candace Avalos>But I seem to understand that the city is doing housing placement type things.

1192
01:59:40.435 --> 01:59:42.314
<v Candace Avalos>You've got the strike team about like housing placement.

1193
01:59:42.363 --> 01:59:46.283
<v Candace Avalos>So can you explain where— why do we have no orange in this section?

1194
01:59:46.378 --> 01:59:47.375
<v Candace Avalos>Because I feel like I've heard us describe that.

1195
01:59:47.470 --> 01:59:58.394
<v Jillian Schoene>So the housing placement is a yeah, I could have on the final blue box where we reference reunification, which is one example of other long-term housing placements, we, we could have colored that orange.

1196
01:59:58.666 --> 02:00:00.173
<v Jillian Schoene>I'll take responsibility for that.

1197
02:00:00.253 --> 02:00:00.430
<v Jillian Schoene>Yeah.

1198
02:00:00.671 --> 02:00:09.091
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, so then in other words, you're saying out of all of the things under this category, the thing that the city does right now is just that reunification part, but everything else is county?

1199
02:00:10.037 --> 02:00:10.244
<v Skylar Breading>Yes.

1200
02:00:10.518 --> 02:00:12.282
<v Skylar Breading>I think there's a lot of caveats.

1201
02:00:12.362 --> 02:00:17.643
<v Skylar Breading>I would just say in terms of what Councilor Koyama Lane mentioned with kind of some potential housing dollars.

1202
02:00:17.755 --> 02:00:27.149
<v Skylar Breading>We have coordinated with the county in the past almost every year basically on placing folks into housing, but that doesn't mean we own that program, if that makes sense.

1203
02:00:27.229 --> 02:00:31.917
<v Skylar Breading>So I think what Jillian is trying to show with the chart is like who's overseeing that program.

1204
02:00:31.966 --> 02:00:38.854
<v Skylar Breading>That doesn't mean that we don't place folks into housing in coordination, often like directing to the contractors and helping them.

1205
02:00:38.934 --> 02:00:40.746
<v Skylar Breading>Councilor them to place folks in housing.

1206
02:00:40.793 --> 02:00:42.845
<v Skylar Breading>But we don't like own that program, if that makes sense.

1207
02:00:43.198 --> 02:00:44.238
<v Candace Avalos>That's very helpful to know.

1208
02:00:44.479 --> 02:00:46.418
<v Candace Avalos>And then I think is also part of the problem, right?

1209
02:00:46.483 --> 02:00:51.610
<v Candace Avalos>Because it's like those little nuanced details are where we get tripped up, because then it's like, wait, who's on first?

1210
02:00:51.755 --> 02:00:52.268
<v Candace Avalos>Who's doing that?

1211
02:00:52.315 --> 02:00:58.757
<v Candace Avalos>So I, I guess some feedback that I, I love how this is structured, and then maybe let's add a couple more layers of nuance to that.

1212
02:00:58.837 --> 02:01:00.969
<v Candace Avalos>Maybe it's more colors, more charts, I don't know.

1213
02:01:01.305 --> 02:01:09.798
<v Candace Avalos>But I think that would help us because those are the little things that add up and make the councilors and the commissioners feel like they don't know who is on what.

1214
02:01:10.104 --> 02:01:10.670
<v Candace Avalos>Does that make sense?

1215
02:01:11.479 --> 02:01:11.899
<v Candace Avalos>Um, that's all.

1216
02:01:11.979 --> 02:01:12.172
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

1217
02:01:13.108 --> 02:01:14.140
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1218
02:01:14.720 --> 02:01:15.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mayor.

1219
02:01:18.185 --> 02:01:19.185
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Council President.

1220
02:01:19.251 --> 02:01:21.467
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Chair, councilors, commissioners.

1221
02:01:21.564 --> 02:01:23.011
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for this opportunity.

1222
02:01:23.091 --> 02:01:24.890
<v Keith Wilson>Panel, thank you for all the work.

1223
02:01:25.100 --> 02:01:27.639
<v Keith Wilson>You know, we've got a lot of hard work to look at.

1224
02:01:27.686 --> 02:01:29.501
<v Keith Wilson>How are we going to balance the continuum?

1225
02:01:29.568 --> 02:01:31.662
<v Keith Wilson>What are we going to do with the processes we have.

1226
02:01:31.742 --> 02:01:39.777
<v Keith Wilson>There are so many variables that we get to work with, and working together is really going to allow us to really meet the moment.

1227
02:01:41.684 --> 02:01:55.797
<v Keith Wilson>Commissioner Moyer had noted that there's a moral obligation, and I always go back to outcomes, and I also go back to what are we really trying to measure and what are the measurement that is really most important, and I look at lost lives.

1228
02:01:56.533 --> 02:02:04.609
<v Keith Wilson>And in '23 and '24, we lost 800 Portlanders to suffer and die homelessness in Portland, and we had to act.

1229
02:02:05.347 --> 02:02:09.377
<v Keith Wilson>We simply could not continue on, and we all were elected to act.

1230
02:02:10.759 --> 02:02:19.189
<v Keith Wilson>I'm proud to say that my new emergency overnight shelter system has provided over 100,000 nights of safe sleep to vulnerable people who would otherwise be on the streets.

1231
02:02:19.798 --> 02:02:24.864
<v Keith Wilson>2,100 unique individuals operated— pardon me, stayed in those shelters last month.

1232
02:02:26.489 --> 02:02:33.704
<v Keith Wilson>We've helped people out of derelict RVs so they no longer pose a hazard to our roads, our watershed, and our neighborhoods.

1233
02:02:33.769 --> 02:02:41.018
<v Keith Wilson>And encampment counts have dropped across the city, and they've decreased by 70%, 75% in the downtown core.

1234
02:02:41.829 --> 02:02:48.465
<v Keith Wilson>Most importantly, we've accomplished this by offering a helping hand, life-saving resources, and a path off the streets.

1235
02:02:49.488 --> 02:02:52.512
<v Keith Wilson>We've seen the success of our efforts reflected across the city.

1236
02:02:54.180 --> 02:02:57.612
<v Keith Wilson>More businesses are choosing to stay and grow in Portland.

1237
02:02:58.567 --> 02:03:01.627
<v Keith Wilson>We've seen one of the steepest declines in homicides in the nation.

1238
02:03:02.876 --> 02:03:25.533
<v Keith Wilson>And Councilor Koyama Lane, something that would be really dear to your heart, even pedestrian deaths are way down now that we quickly clear high-crash corridors and tents and other as we discuss our performance and priorities, I will ask that we continue to fund a balance of life-saving shelter and shelter to housing options for all Portlanders to succeed in Portland.

1239
02:03:25.743 --> 02:03:26.000
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1240
02:03:27.122 --> 02:03:27.733
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

1241
02:03:28.166 --> 02:03:28.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>Chair Vega-Petersen.

1242
02:03:29.690 --> 02:03:30.750
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Thank you so much.

1243
02:03:30.797 --> 02:03:40.015
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I just want to thank everyone here, um, at the dais for the clarity that you've provided on what you'd like to see, the providing— the, um, priorities you have, and thank you.

1244
02:03:40.064 --> 02:03:42.317
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>And the perspective on our roles and responsibilities.

1245
02:03:44.390 --> 02:03:50.104
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I also wanted to say a huge thank you to this like all-star staff that we have sitting here for providing information, answering questions.

1246
02:03:50.699 --> 02:03:57.895
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>But I think most importantly for the work that you guys do every single day to make sure that the policies and decisions that we make up here get implemented.

1247
02:03:58.445 --> 02:04:04.730
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>That work has the biggest impact on the people that we are serving here in these elected roles.

1248
02:04:05.958 --> 02:04:17.814
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I also want to just say I think it's so important for us as partnering jurisdictions to provide the best support that we can to those who are experiencing homelessness, at risk of experiencing homelessness.

1249
02:04:18.038 --> 02:04:29.573
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>And I just appreciate the opportunities that we have to come together to have these conversations as we're looking at the, the limited budgets that we have to work with and all of the different priorities we have even outside of the homelessness.

1250
02:04:30.006 --> 02:04:35.914
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>I know that this is something we all care deeply about, passionately about, and the constituents that we serve do as well.

1251
02:04:36.573 --> 02:04:41.278
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Our next session is going to be a little more than a month away on Tuesday, April 28th.

1252
02:04:41.326 --> 02:04:47.524
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>So I look forward to continuing our conversation, to convening again and keeping this work going.

1253
02:04:47.604 --> 02:04:48.069
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>So thank you.

1254
02:04:48.229 --> 02:04:49.836
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Thank you, Council President.

1255
02:04:50.301 --> 02:04:50.654
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1256
02:04:51.039 --> 02:04:53.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you to our county colleagues for coming over.

1257
02:04:53.271 --> 02:04:56.787
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you to everybody for the presentation today and all the amazing hard work that is happening.

1258
02:04:57.680 --> 02:04:59.519
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, thank you all for your time today.

1259
02:04:59.601 --> 02:05:00.497
<v Jamie Dunphy>And with that, we are adjourned.

1260
02:05:02.228 --> 02:05:02.881
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>1 Minute.

1261
02:05:03.060 --> 02:05:03.634
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Good job.

1262
02:05:04.025 --> 02:05:05.154
<v Keith Wilson>To the races.

1263
02:05:06.753 --> 02:05:07.591
<v Keith Wilson>Meetings galore.

