WEBVTT

1
00:09:06.000 --> 00:09:06.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>Woo!

2
00:09:06.465 --> 00:09:07.779
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, and we are back.

3
00:09:08.807 --> 00:09:18.107
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, friends, to the afternoon work session of the Wednesday the 11th afternoon work session of the Portland City Council.

4
00:09:18.909 --> 00:09:21.845
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're here to convene— oh, everybody got quiet.

5
00:09:21.893 --> 00:09:22.534
<v Jonas Biery>I appreciate that.

6
00:09:24.027 --> 00:09:29.120
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're here to have a conversation about the budget, and we're working down, uh, through a couple of specific service areas today.

7
00:09:29.184 --> 00:09:32.735
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'd like to invite our folks up.

8
00:09:32.799 --> 00:09:34.024
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know who's kicking this off.

9
00:09:34.087 --> 00:09:36.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator, welcome.

10
00:09:38.196 --> 00:09:40.934
<v Raymond C. Lee>Good afternoon.

11
00:09:41.804 --> 00:09:42.754
<v Raymond C. Lee>Good afternoon, councilors.

12
00:09:42.931 --> 00:09:44.508
<v Raymond C. Lee>Uh, just thank you for having me today.

13
00:09:44.701 --> 00:09:46.374
<v Raymond C. Lee>Raymond Lee, City Administrator.

14
00:09:46.952 --> 00:09:53.505
<v Raymond C. Lee>I have our Chief Financial Officer, uh, Jonas Biery, as well with me, as well as DCA Tracy Warren.

15
00:09:54.625 --> 00:10:02.134
<v Raymond C. Lee>And we have bureau and program directors and other finance leads to help answer questions as we go through this presentation.

16
00:10:02.823 --> 00:10:07.894
<v Raymond C. Lee>We'll start with the City Administrator's Office today with the CFO and Portland Solutions.

17
00:10:08.423 --> 00:10:21.306
<v Raymond C. Lee>Then we'll shift into the City Operations service area, which will include an update on the larger realignment projects, and we'll be at a high level as we talk through some of the realignment projects.

18
00:10:21.433 --> 00:10:29.715
<v Raymond C. Lee>Then we'll pass it off to DCA Priory and, and her team to talk through the public works service area.

19
00:10:30.163 --> 00:10:42.424
<v Raymond C. Lee>As a reminder, today's work session is about setting a common baseline understanding of how bureaus and programs operate across funds and revenue streams.

20
00:10:43.163 --> 00:10:53.073
<v Raymond C. Lee>Also, a fairly high-level overview of budgets challenges and opportunities and trade-offs for bureaus and funds as well.

21
00:10:53.683 --> 00:11:04.631
<v Raymond C. Lee>Then our high-level options that the bureaus are bringing forward in response to Mayor Wilson's guidance as it was trying to bring up budget reduction conversations.

22
00:11:05.529 --> 00:11:11.557
<v Raymond C. Lee>But before I start, I want to pass it to Jonas for a quick reminder about next steps and where we're going from here.

23
00:11:12.823 --> 00:11:13.063
<v Jonas Biery>Great.

24
00:11:13.224 --> 00:11:14.634
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you, City Manager Lee.

25
00:11:14.682 --> 00:11:18.577
<v Jonas Biery>Council President, Council, for the record, Jonas Biery, the city's Chief Financial Officer.

26
00:11:19.316 --> 00:11:27.988
<v Jonas Biery>Wanted to first acknowledge that last week we had a work session, the first of these on public safety service area and community economic development.

27
00:11:28.308 --> 00:11:31.643
<v Jonas Biery>There was a great conversation, daylighted a lot of great questions.

28
00:11:32.220 --> 00:11:36.515
<v Jonas Biery>The City Budget Office has assembled answers to those questions.

29
00:11:36.563 --> 00:11:38.006
<v Jonas Biery>And so I think those were just published today.

30
00:11:38.552 --> 00:11:47.240
<v Jonas Biery>And so we'll be doing the same thing with the work session today, collecting those questions, providing responses in writing to all of you as soon as possible next week.

31
00:11:47.849 --> 00:11:54.399
<v Jonas Biery>Also wanted to acknowledge we're working on a similar body of we do have responses related to the Thursday work session on Spring Tao.

32
00:11:54.399 --> 00:11:57.850
<v Jonas Biery>So that is still coming to you hopefully by the end of this week.

33
00:11:58.120 --> 00:12:11.000
<v Jonas Biery>Also wanted to note that after today, there's another budget work session of kind of this initial series scheduled next Thursday on Thursday the 19th.

34
00:12:11.000 --> 00:12:15.759
<v Jonas Biery>Our intent based upon the last work session is that we'll have a little bit of a focused time on public safety.

35
00:12:15.759 --> 00:12:18.059
<v Jonas Biery>There were a number of questions around public safety service area.

36
00:12:18.279 --> 00:12:21.019
<v Jonas Biery>So have some focused time to come back to some of that.

37
00:12:21.019 --> 00:12:21.100
<v Raymond C. Lee>And then probably another—.

38
00:12:21.100 --> 00:12:21.279
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we should have a public comment session.

39
00:12:23.275 --> 00:12:26.806
<v Jonas Biery>Major topic TBD, probably a little bit pending today's discussion.

40
00:12:26.886 --> 00:12:28.201
<v Jonas Biery>I may be able to populate something there.

41
00:12:28.731 --> 00:12:39.274
<v Jonas Biery>Also wanna make a little space next week to have a few minutes to discuss and agree on what the next iteration of work sessions look like as we do that work.

42
00:12:39.643 --> 00:12:47.408
<v Jonas Biery>I think a couple more work sessions scheduled in April, Mayor's proposed on April 21st, and then space held for some work sessions after that.

43
00:12:47.504 --> 00:12:51.178
<v Jonas Biery>And so I wanna have a little conversation to make sure we're on the same page about those next steps.

44
00:12:51.375 --> 00:12:52.857
<v Jonas Biery>In April and May.

45
00:12:53.336 --> 00:12:54.653
<v Jonas Biery>And with that, I'll hand back to City Administrator Lee.

46
00:12:54.753 --> 00:12:54.984
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you.

47
00:12:56.643 --> 00:12:57.341
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you, Jonas.

48
00:12:57.390 --> 00:12:58.985
<v Raymond C. Lee>Can we go to the agenda slide, please?

49
00:13:00.677 --> 00:13:04.323
<v Raymond C. Lee>This is what we're going to cover today in the City Administrative Service area.

50
00:13:04.451 --> 00:13:06.927
<v Raymond C. Lee>We're going to review the current service level budgets.

51
00:13:07.344 --> 00:13:10.773
<v Raymond C. Lee>We'll talk through some high-level cut options and trade-offs.

52
00:13:11.291 --> 00:13:16.600
<v Raymond C. Lee>You'll note that we have a significant focus on Portland Solutions in these slides as well.

53
00:13:16.809 --> 00:13:20.960
<v Raymond C. Lee>This is the most complex piece of the service area budget.

54
00:13:21.489 --> 00:13:22.018
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide.

55
00:13:23.254 --> 00:13:28.162
<v Jamie Dunphy>And but before you start, City Administrator, uh, colleagues, I would like to allow them to get through the presentation.

56
00:13:28.210 --> 00:13:34.980
<v Jamie Dunphy>If there are technical or clarifying questions about the information that is directly in front of you, please feel free to ask, but otherwise let's hold our conversations for the end.

57
00:13:35.221 --> 00:13:37.899
<v Raymond C. Lee>Okay, thank you, Council President.

58
00:13:38.878 --> 00:14:00.360
<v Raymond C. Lee>As you can see, we range from the office to the CFO to Portland Solutions, the bureaus and programs in this service area all have citywide impact and application and are charged with coordinating citywide policies and programming and developing— delivering citywide approaches to things that Portlanders are seeking.

59
00:14:00.857 --> 00:14:15.094
<v Raymond C. Lee>You'll note that the CFO fund is so large because it includes a number of other funds such as the Arts Education and Access Fund, also bond interest and sinking fund as well.

60
00:14:15.980 --> 00:14:19.802
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide.

61
00:14:21.980 --> 00:14:23.244
<v Tracy Warren>Come up.

62
00:14:28.496 --> 00:14:29.032
<v Dan Ryan>And that's it.

63
00:14:29.144 --> 00:14:30.182
<v Raymond C. Lee>All right, that was it.

64
00:14:31.553 --> 00:14:34.366
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

65
00:14:34.447 --> 00:14:38.691
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, does that mean that the city administrator is giving all of his funds back?

66
00:14:38.788 --> 00:14:39.109
<v Jonas Biery>I think so.

67
00:14:42.157 --> 00:14:43.154
<v Raymond C. Lee>I wish it was that simple.

68
00:14:45.549 --> 00:14:47.907
<v Tracy Warren>I apologize, the slides disappeared from the deck.

69
00:14:48.294 --> 00:14:49.182
<v Tracy Warren>Working on it.

70
00:14:51.190 --> 00:14:51.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>We love technology.

71
00:14:54.070 --> 00:14:56.933
<v Sameer Kanal>This is why we shouldn't realign BTS.

72
00:14:57.354 --> 00:15:00.008
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, we shouldn't realign our TIF zone.

73
00:15:03.095 --> 00:15:05.695
<v Tracy Warren>Apologies, it's coming.

74
00:15:39.158 --> 00:15:40.841
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think we're back up and running again.

75
00:15:41.845 --> 00:15:47.714
<v Raymond C. Lee>What you're looking at right now is a zoom in on the portion of the previous slide that represented Portland Solutions.

76
00:15:48.552 --> 00:15:55.730
<v Raymond C. Lee>Portland Solutions is a young department office as it was launched in July of 2024.

77
00:15:56.504 --> 00:16:00.067
<v Raymond C. Lee>This is the most complex and volatile piece of the city administrator's budget.

78
00:16:00.744 --> 00:16:07.903
<v Raymond C. Lee>Due to high interest in that office, throughout the presentation we'll drill down on some items for this budget.

79
00:16:08.789 --> 00:16:09.482
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide.

80
00:16:11.190 --> 00:16:17.052
<v Raymond C. Lee>In developing the concepts, we've had similar challenges and approaches to other service areas.

81
00:16:17.552 --> 00:16:19.711
<v Raymond C. Lee>Challenges are listed on this slide.

82
00:16:20.178 --> 00:16:26.683
<v Raymond C. Lee>Specific to Portland Solutions, many programs have been funded largely by one-time dollars.

83
00:16:28.052 --> 00:16:35.153
<v Raymond C. Lee>Those programs include the City Outreach Team, shelter programming, and the PMO Services.

84
00:16:35.490 --> 00:16:36.443
<v Raymond C. Lee>PMO Services.

85
00:16:37.267 --> 00:16:48.106
<v Raymond C. Lee>That model has required a year-to-year hustle to find and secure funding for continued programming as demand and the need for those services increase.

86
00:16:48.812 --> 00:16:53.335
<v Raymond C. Lee>But I will say we've seen a tremendous amount of impact on our streets today.

87
00:16:54.417 --> 00:16:57.479
<v Raymond C. Lee>As part of the exercise, every program participated.

88
00:16:58.183 --> 00:17:07.786
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are focused on supporting the continued implementation of the new form of government and helping to address some of our most pressing community challenges.

89
00:17:08.699 --> 00:17:20.560
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are limited by our— we are limited by our budgets being largely personnel and are trying to minimize some operational cuts, as is the case across the city.

90
00:17:21.189 --> 00:17:27.775
<v Raymond C. Lee>Cuts have added up year over year to impact some of our service delivery and some of our capacity needs.

91
00:17:28.290 --> 00:17:29.064
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide, please.

92
00:17:34.047 --> 00:17:35.175
<v Raymond C. Lee>Performance management.

93
00:17:35.354 --> 00:17:43.943
<v Raymond C. Lee>Our bureaus and programs work on a wide variety of things, united mostly in that they all have citywide impact and implications.

94
00:17:44.709 --> 00:17:48.464
<v Raymond C. Lee>We collect a variety of metrics, Across the service areas.

95
00:17:49.282 --> 00:17:57.419
<v Raymond C. Lee>Our work is also often measured on long— on long timelines for equity, sustainability, legislative goals.

96
00:17:57.868 --> 00:18:01.383
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are often needing to look over many years to see progress.

97
00:18:01.816 --> 00:18:13.259
<v Raymond C. Lee>For example, OGR consistently has a rating of 75 to 95% on their yearly customer service survey with regard to progress made on legislative priorities.

98
00:18:13.307 --> 00:18:13.515
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

99
00:18:14.413 --> 00:18:26.830
<v Raymond C. Lee>PMO has cleaned 921 blocks representing 44 miles, having disposed of 25 tons of trash on a quarterly basis.

100
00:18:27.648 --> 00:18:42.309
<v Raymond C. Lee>Moving forward, the Performance Office will help the city leaders and staff use data to make better informed decisions, improve service and operations, and build a culture where continuous improvement as part of the everyday work.

101
00:18:42.536 --> 00:18:50.872
<v Raymond C. Lee>And you've heard me talk about this previously, and the mayor previously as well, about us becoming a high-performing organization.

102
00:18:52.230 --> 00:18:52.941
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide, please.

103
00:18:55.115 --> 00:18:56.777
<v Raymond C. Lee>Program expenses by fund.

104
00:18:57.050 --> 00:19:05.757
<v Raymond C. Lee>This slide really focuses on most of our large funds outside the general fund are collected and housed in the CFO divisions.

105
00:19:06.288 --> 00:19:08.936
<v Raymond C. Lee>And have very specific allocations and purposes.

106
00:19:09.695 --> 00:19:16.278
<v Raymond C. Lee>The largest components of the general fund are Portland Solutions and the City Attorney's Office.

107
00:19:16.778 --> 00:19:22.753
<v Raymond C. Lee>Generally, this is where the programmatic expenses in this service area hit the most.

108
00:19:23.542 --> 00:19:30.345
<v Raymond C. Lee>In the next slide, I'll discuss a little about why the general fund visualization is a little misleading.

109
00:19:31.190 --> 00:19:31.775
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide, please.

110
00:19:36.556 --> 00:19:52.092
<v Raymond C. Lee>I note that Civic Life's general fund budget has decreased, uh, by $7.1 million since 2022 and 2023 because of both the realignment of resources to other city bureaus and service areas and ongoing budget reductions.

111
00:19:53.248 --> 00:20:01.482
<v Raymond C. Lee>In addition, we begin first reports of actuals for the city administrator in 2024 and 2025 due to the new form of government.

112
00:20:01.901 --> 00:20:09.834
<v Raymond C. Lee>You'll see here that the CFO's general fund discretionary budget has remained relatively consistent over the past 5 years.

113
00:20:10.749 --> 00:20:19.950
<v Raymond C. Lee>The general fund discretionary overall is noted here as really large due to what is mostly a categorization problem rather than a general fund issue.

114
00:20:20.865 --> 00:20:25.136
<v Raymond C. Lee>This significant increase you see can best be described as unknown funding.

115
00:20:25.458 --> 00:20:35.204
<v Raymond C. Lee>Similar to last spring when Mayor Wilson was knocking on doors to invest in emergency overnight shelter— shelters, which he's doing a lot of fundraising now that I know as well.

116
00:20:36.376 --> 00:20:42.028
<v Raymond C. Lee>For our purposes today, this is what we require to maintain current service levels.

117
00:20:42.623 --> 00:20:49.286
<v Raymond C. Lee>Administrative leaders are having multiple conversations to secure funding prior to the mayor's proposed budget.

118
00:20:49.929 --> 00:20:56.035
<v Raymond C. Lee>In reality, we are asking for fewer general fund discretionary dollars for Portland Solutions.

119
00:20:57.478 --> 00:21:05.730
<v Raymond C. Lee>This reduced ask is strategic to decrease the impact Portland Solutions may have on the general fund.

120
00:21:09.869 --> 00:21:26.532
<v Raymond C. Lee>Looking at FTEs, the slight changes between '25 and '26 adopted budget and the '26-'27 CSL budget reflects positions shifting into the performance office from city operations and BPS.

121
00:21:27.911 --> 00:21:44.111
<v Raymond C. Lee>Staffing levels within the city administrator service area declined between 2022-2023 and FY '26 and '27 due to charter transition, reorganization, and moving positions out of this service area.

122
00:21:45.540 --> 00:21:47.340
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide.

123
00:21:48.770 --> 00:21:51.101
<v Dan Ryan>Real quick, um, technical question.

124
00:21:51.357 --> 00:21:54.233
<v Dan Ryan>Is neighborhood associations under what?

125
00:21:54.715 --> 00:21:56.483
<v Raymond C. Lee>It's under civic life.

126
00:21:57.111 --> 00:21:58.090
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, that's what I thought.

127
00:21:58.250 --> 00:21:58.669
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

128
00:21:59.215 --> 00:21:59.713
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

129
00:22:00.035 --> 00:22:01.144
<v Tracy Warren>Wow.

130
00:22:01.770 --> 00:22:13.182
<v Raymond C. Lee>On slide 10, uh, you'll note that a majority of the program expenses in this area are 3 programs: alternative shelter, Revenue collection and liability.

131
00:22:14.250 --> 00:22:28.333
<v Raymond C. Lee>The jump in program expenses from FY25 and 26 is due to the development of emergency overnight shelter that was paid for almost exclusively through state and Metro SHS dollars.

132
00:22:29.575 --> 00:22:41.457
<v Raymond C. Lee>The liability program anticipates a reduction in expenses in FY26-27 compared to the fiscal year due to projected lower claim payments.

133
00:22:44.313 --> 00:22:44.923
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide.

134
00:22:47.349 --> 00:22:55.776
<v Raymond C. Lee>On Portland Solutions program expenses, we just showed the overall service area, but this will drill down a little deeper into Portland Solutions.

135
00:22:57.434 --> 00:23:02.955
<v Raymond C. Lee>As Portland Solutions was implemented in FY24-25, our lookback begins there.

136
00:23:03.826 --> 00:23:05.974
<v Raymond C. Lee>A few notes to program expenses.

137
00:23:06.808 --> 00:23:17.440
<v Raymond C. Lee>Emergency overnight shelter utilization has seen seasonal EBBs inflow, which has allowed for more accurate expense targets in estimating.

138
00:23:18.498 --> 00:23:27.492
<v Raymond C. Lee>In July of 2025, we pulled our alternative 24/7 shelter contracting back to the city from the county.

139
00:23:28.134 --> 00:23:31.068
<v Raymond C. Lee>That move has realized a significant cost savings.

140
00:23:31.133 --> 00:23:31.229
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

141
00:23:31.815 --> 00:23:34.653
<v Raymond C. Lee>That we are now able to apply to future budgeting.

142
00:23:36.769 --> 00:23:37.375
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide, please.

143
00:23:41.829 --> 00:23:48.692
<v Raymond C. Lee>Core program revenues are not significantly changing over time, with the exception of Portland Solutions.

144
00:23:49.290 --> 00:23:54.635
<v Raymond C. Lee>Revenue generation has involved very different models for Portland Solutions year over year.

145
00:23:55.648 --> 00:24:03.547
<v Raymond C. Lee>That group and the mayor have hustled to find program money each and every year, which has resulted in various revenue models.

146
00:24:04.365 --> 00:24:13.561
<v Raymond C. Lee>I want to call out that the budget gap in this graph is the difference between the current service level and known funding with Portland Solutions.

147
00:24:14.394 --> 00:24:34.409
<v Raymond C. Lee>As I previously mentioned, there are unknown funds that are still in the process of being secured due to diverse funding strategies, other revenue, is a catch-all that includes money such as ARPA funding, state pass-through money, county swaps, interest earnings, and et cetera.

148
00:24:36.059 --> 00:24:36.877
<v Raymond C. Lee>Next slide, please.

149
00:24:39.830 --> 00:24:51.256
<v Raymond C. Lee>There is a current service level gap of $200,000 for the executive programs, including my office, and $600,000 for the Office of the CFO.

150
00:24:51.305 --> 00:24:51.469
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

151
00:24:53.016 --> 00:25:05.171
<v Raymond C. Lee>The factors at play are the same: rising costs, enterprise inefficiencies, inflation, and compound cuts year over year.

152
00:25:06.567 --> 00:25:16.522
<v Raymond C. Lee>The gap includes echoes from last year's cuts as well, in internal and external materials and services, software, temporary staffing as well.

153
00:25:17.487 --> 00:25:25.414
<v Raymond C. Lee>If you have more questions about this, I'm happy to answer more questions about this in the question and answer portion of our presentation.

154
00:25:26.474 --> 00:25:36.169
<v Raymond C. Lee>On slide 14, keeping in mind the revenues we discussed a few slides back, I want to highlight for current service level gaps for Portland Solutions specifically.

155
00:25:37.469 --> 00:25:49.526
<v Raymond C. Lee>In alternative shelters, we have a $35.3 million gap with the end of one-time money for alternative shelter coming from the state, county, and federal government.

156
00:25:50.493 --> 00:25:57.278
<v Raymond C. Lee>In overnight shelter, there is an estimated $19.8 million gap for emergency overnight shelter.

157
00:25:58.104 --> 00:26:03.568
<v Raymond C. Lee>This includes anticipated underspending from this year given to us by the state.

158
00:26:05.767 --> 00:26:12.007
<v Raymond C. Lee>There is a total of $4.2 million gap for the Street Service Coordination Center.

159
00:26:12.087 --> 00:26:12.346
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

160
00:26:12.987 --> 00:26:24.094
<v Raymond C. Lee>Which is a split between a gap for current service level city staff on the city's outreach team and a $1.3 million for contracted outreach services.

161
00:26:25.076 --> 00:26:33.683
<v Raymond C. Lee>Finally, there is a $5.8 million shortfall from the end of one-time funding to maintain current PMO programming.

162
00:26:36.829 --> 00:26:37.482
<v Sameer Kanal>Next slide.

163
00:26:39.766 --> 00:26:50.759
<v Raymond C. Lee>We have explored options for filling the CSL gaps and participated in the 3 to 10% cut exercise as directed by the mayor's office.

164
00:26:51.306 --> 00:26:54.579
<v Raymond C. Lee>We have a range of strategies outlined on this slide.

165
00:26:55.238 --> 00:27:06.905
<v Raymond C. Lee>From the executive programs, we looked at options that significantly reduce spending for priority-setting exercises and facilitation needed to guide leadership planning and decision-making.

166
00:27:07.001 --> 00:27:07.259
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

167
00:27:07.997 --> 00:27:17.762
<v Raymond C. Lee>We've reduced ability to participate in collaboration with peer cities, including regional and national travel to key meetings, conferences, and convenings.

168
00:27:18.773 --> 00:27:31.041
<v Raymond C. Lee>Support and other staff cuts, including potential changes in compliance ability— attorney support is an example of this as well— and rent savings and other EMS cuts.

169
00:27:32.469 --> 00:28:00.820
<v Raymond C. Lee>For the CFO, some of the things we've discussed would result in reduced staff capacity across nearly all divisions, increasing operational and compliance risk, diminished risk management, claims oversight, and foreclosure activity, risk to timely completion of the annual, uh, comprehensive financial report, delays in vendor payments, and risk to financial reporting.

170
00:28:02.051 --> 00:28:10.757
<v Raymond C. Lee>Potential cuts to revenue collection has risks, including receipts of matching funds and funds from other jurisdictions as well.

171
00:28:12.251 --> 00:28:22.136
<v Raymond C. Lee>And as we look at Portland solutions, while we have identified funding needs, work is still underway to secure resources outside of the general fund.

172
00:28:22.801 --> 00:28:25.836
<v Raymond C. Lee>We'll know more by the mayor's proposed budget what that may look like.

173
00:28:26.241 --> 00:28:31.184
<v Raymond C. Lee>But as always, we want to provide you options for your priorities.

174
00:28:32.019 --> 00:28:42.898
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are continuing conversations with internal and external sources of revenue to either realign our fund programming for all work areas.

175
00:28:43.092 --> 00:29:06.980
<v Raymond C. Lee>This includes revenue areas such as state, metro, other jurisdictions, the county IGA, and the Portland Clean Energy Fund, among other it's important to reiterate that funding gaps we have identified are a focus of our efforts to find revenue from other non-general fund resources.

176
00:29:07.736 --> 00:29:14.609
<v Raymond C. Lee>Discussions are ongoing about a long-term funding model for the City of Portland priorities supported by Portland Solutions.

177
00:29:14.898 --> 00:29:21.145
<v Raymond C. Lee>It's simply not sustainable to continue funding Portland Solutions and their programming in our current model.

178
00:29:22.012 --> 00:29:32.546
<v Raymond C. Lee>Not only does it decrease stability for those services, but it eats up our leadership time and capacity because we have to act as entrepreneurs during a very tight budget cycle.

179
00:29:33.588 --> 00:29:38.164
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are already in discussions with you about how to resolve the issues long-term.

180
00:29:38.887 --> 00:29:57.234
<v Raymond C. Lee>If we're not successful in identifying funding solutions for the coming year, we are anticipating reductions concepts, including strategically closing shelters, reducing corridor cleaning efforts, and eliminating city outreach contracting.

181
00:29:58.394 --> 00:30:09.794
<v Raymond C. Lee>Further, while we are attempting to preserve the very small team that implement and oversee these programs, options include FTE reductions to staff.

182
00:30:10.686 --> 00:30:12.278
<v Raymond C. Lee>For us, this is the last resort.

183
00:30:12.928 --> 00:30:18.403
<v Raymond C. Lee>Due to sheer volume of work these teams are facing on a day-to-day basis.

184
00:30:21.137 --> 00:30:23.150
<v Raymond C. Lee>And that concludes the presentation.

185
00:30:23.214 --> 00:31:01.654
<v Raymond C. Lee>One thing I will say in this— going to the next slide as we get to the questions— I will take into account that as we've gone through retreat on Saturday, uh, really taking a closer look at what the council's priorities are As we go through more budget deliberations and conversations as a result— as results of the mayor presenting a proposed budget to City Council, we will be incorporating those concepts and ideas that came out of that retreat into it, which will further help shape how we'll be moving forward in the mayor's proposed budget.

186
00:31:01.974 --> 00:31:03.258
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

187
00:31:03.354 --> 00:31:04.155
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator.

188
00:31:05.319 --> 00:31:06.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, now we move into discussion.

189
00:31:07.457 --> 00:31:08.963
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark, take us along.

190
00:31:10.518 --> 00:31:11.327
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

191
00:31:11.424 --> 00:31:13.499
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, uh, City Administrator.

192
00:31:13.930 --> 00:31:14.768
<v Olivia Clark>Appreciate this.

193
00:31:15.251 --> 00:31:20.298
<v Olivia Clark>It is a very, very high level, so it's hard to get your head around exactly what this means.

194
00:31:21.027 --> 00:31:29.854
<v Olivia Clark>And I assume that we're going to have another chance at a future date to dig in a little bit deeper on these things, so I'll keep, um, my questions pretty high level.

195
00:31:29.917 --> 00:31:40.159
<v Olivia Clark>And just, um, for the record, The color charts, it's hard to distinguish between the blues and figure out which goes to which, but maybe that can be corrected.

196
00:31:40.207 --> 00:31:45.092
<v Olivia Clark>I do have a question on page 8, which is about civic life.

197
00:31:46.634 --> 00:31:54.406
<v Olivia Clark>Can you— are you at a point where you can share with us what portion of that budget goes to the neighborhood associations?

198
00:31:55.789 --> 00:32:00.845
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know if anybody can answer that, but that will be a question for me and a concern for me.

199
00:32:01.787 --> 00:32:10.248
<v Raymond C. Lee>I would have to go back and look at to see what's the actual component of that actually goes to that service out of Civic Life.

200
00:32:10.327 --> 00:32:13.066
<v Raymond C. Lee>But we can follow up with council with that direct answer.

201
00:32:13.471 --> 00:32:13.748
<v Angelita Morillo>Great.

202
00:32:13.876 --> 00:32:15.111
<v Olivia Clark>I would appreciate that.

203
00:32:15.825 --> 00:32:27.111
<v Olivia Clark>And then on page 15, page 15 on closing the gap.

204
00:32:27.845 --> 00:32:35.233
<v Olivia Clark>Under the CFO column, could you— I don't understand what reduced foreclosure activity and reduced revenue collection mean.

205
00:32:37.259 --> 00:32:49.257
<v Raymond C. Lee>I'll let Jonas come up and speak to that one, but if we were making reductions to that area, those are actual FTEs, people who are actually going out and collecting those dollars that we would be looking at reducing.

206
00:32:49.450 --> 00:32:51.384
<v Raymond C. Lee>But I'll let Jonas go into further detail.

207
00:32:52.339 --> 00:32:52.711
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, thank you.

208
00:32:52.759 --> 00:32:55.711
<v Jonas Biery>And I'll be brief and we can come back with more detail if we need it.

209
00:32:55.759 --> 00:32:57.115
<v Jonas Biery>Councilor, thank you for the question.

210
00:32:59.680 --> 00:33:07.612
<v Jonas Biery>Proposals that exist for those areas would be reducing the staff that do that foreclosure work, kind of the behind-the-scenes processing.

211
00:33:08.060 --> 00:33:22.448
<v Jonas Biery>So we recently, a couple years ago, accelerated that effort per prior council direction to trying to get to 3 or 4 foreclosure actions each year, foreclosure moments when we can actually have those sales processed.

212
00:33:22.496 --> 00:33:27.583
<v Jonas Biery>And so this would reduce our capacity to do that to probably more like once or twice a year.

213
00:33:28.096 --> 00:33:31.369
<v Jonas Biery>And then I think, so I was like, one of your questions, the other was on the revenue side.

214
00:33:31.498 --> 00:33:34.707
<v Jonas Biery>So again, very staff-intensive work.

215
00:33:34.835 --> 00:33:44.141
<v Jonas Biery>And so reducing that capacity would reduce our ability to pursue collections and respond to payers of the city's various taxes that the revenue division collects.

216
00:33:44.478 --> 00:33:55.291
<v Olivia Clark>Well, in response to that, I would just say that when we are looking at cuts like this, if there is a, You know, pennywise, pound foolish, that we're cutting things that actually bring in revenue.

217
00:33:55.421 --> 00:33:58.261
<v Olivia Clark>I think we ought to consider that in all these areas.

218
00:33:58.326 --> 00:34:01.189
<v Olivia Clark>But that, I think that was one that stuck out for me.

219
00:34:03.324 --> 00:34:15.594
<v Olivia Clark>I also think it would be helpful, and not for today, but for the future, when we're talking about cutting shelter services, that we understand what the impact would be on the street should that happen.

220
00:34:16.896 --> 00:34:24.940
<v Olivia Clark>And I know that that's happening, proposed to happen at the county as well, but what are our streets going to look like if we do those kind of cuts?

221
00:34:25.501 --> 00:34:28.161
<v Olivia Clark>So just a couple points there as we think about the future.

222
00:34:28.610 --> 00:34:39.280
<v Olivia Clark>You know, let's not be pennywise and let's think about the impacts of what some of these cuts will be when it comes to the quality of life for Portlanders.

223
00:34:39.425 --> 00:34:41.956
<v Raymond C. Lee>And great question, Councilor, and great comments.

224
00:34:42.005 --> 00:34:56.590
<v Raymond C. Lee>And that's something that we'll be presenting to Council, as we look at making reductions in services that we move forward, one of the columns that you will be looking at is the impact, impact to our citizens or impact internally to the organization.

225
00:34:57.199 --> 00:34:59.340
<v Raymond C. Lee>And some of this is a domino effect for us as well.

226
00:35:00.032 --> 00:35:10.277
<v Raymond C. Lee>As we see other areas hit certain reductions, it's going to have an impact on other areas and their ability to be able to perform the duties that they do on a day-in and day-out basis.

227
00:35:10.621 --> 00:35:18.224
<v Raymond C. Lee>And we'll show those correlations with council when we're talking about overall comprehensive cuts of what that looks like.

228
00:35:19.362 --> 00:35:19.682
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

229
00:35:19.907 --> 00:35:23.018
<v Olivia Clark>I think maybe Amanda has an answer to my other question.

230
00:35:23.853 --> 00:35:24.478
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Yes, thank you.

231
00:35:24.574 --> 00:35:26.226
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Amanda Garcia-Snell for the record.

232
00:35:27.155 --> 00:35:46.525
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So to the money that goes directly to the DCO or to the neighborhood program, to the DCOs, not counting personnel costs, is about $1.8 million, and $1.6 million of that is distributed into nearly even 4 grants based on population.

233
00:35:46.572 --> 00:35:47.744
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So there's a slight difference.

234
00:35:48.083 --> 00:35:54.184
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And then we also provide an extra— the extra amount for neighborhood small grants.

235
00:35:55.532 --> 00:35:56.288
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

236
00:35:56.672 --> 00:35:57.492
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

237
00:35:58.438 --> 00:36:00.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

238
00:36:02.766 --> 00:36:03.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>Further questions?

239
00:36:04.003 --> 00:36:04.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

240
00:36:04.333 --> 00:36:04.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

241
00:36:05.222 --> 00:36:06.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

242
00:36:10.411 --> 00:36:12.581
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Now I'm wondering if I— if my question makes sense.

243
00:36:13.369 --> 00:36:20.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In the current services level gap is— so for under executive programs, is that your office?

244
00:36:20.447 --> 00:36:20.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

245
00:36:21.172 --> 00:36:26.262
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So is the $0.2 million, that gap, what you feel like you need to be fully staffed?

246
00:36:27.052 --> 00:36:27.358
<v Raymond C. Lee>Correct.

247
00:36:27.860 --> 00:36:29.831
<v Raymond C. Lee>Okay, sorry, I might cut my mic off.

248
00:36:29.911 --> 00:36:30.864
<v Raymond C. Lee>That is correct.

249
00:36:31.025 --> 00:36:38.487
<v Raymond C. Lee>Uh, my office is a very small office, uh, really pertaining to, uh, 3 or 4 employees including myself.

250
00:36:39.342 --> 00:36:45.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, and so you have 3 or 4 employees including yourself, and can you remind me how many direct reports you have?

251
00:36:45.927 --> 00:36:46.413
<v Raymond C. Lee>Uh, 14.

252
00:36:47.791 --> 00:36:55.461
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, um, well, we really need you to be successful, and you, you need to be staffed well, and the whole city is I'm just hoping for that.

253
00:36:55.510 --> 00:36:56.539
<v Angelita Morillo>And there's a lot on your shoulders.

254
00:36:56.650 --> 00:37:03.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I support moving things so your office is fully staffed and you're set up for success.

255
00:37:06.128 --> 00:37:06.532
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

256
00:37:06.952 --> 00:37:08.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

257
00:37:08.548 --> 00:37:09.291
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

258
00:37:10.244 --> 00:37:11.469
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

259
00:37:12.461 --> 00:37:13.853
<v Steve Novick>My question, and Mr.

260
00:37:14.159 --> 00:37:31.853
<v Steve Novick>Administrator, I'm not sure you know this off the top of your head, but the cost of the alternative shelters, how much of the cost is sort of the physical infrastructure, the existence of the pods, the showers, the electricity, et cetera, and how much of it is kind of social service, you know, staff providing services?

261
00:37:32.610 --> 00:37:40.199
<v Steve Novick>If you just said, we're gonna give you a key and make sure that the water running and the electricity works, but there won't be anybody there, how much of a cost savings would that be?

262
00:37:42.818 --> 00:37:45.713
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Hi, for the record, Skylar Brackenap, Director of Portland Solutions.

263
00:37:46.052 --> 00:37:53.873
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Councilor, we'll get you the precise numbers, but just kind of ballpark, the majority of that number is gonna be the operations for the 24/7 staff.

264
00:37:54.981 --> 00:37:57.070
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>That are working kind of that site.

265
00:37:57.472 --> 00:38:00.106
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I also just wanna give folks a little bit of context.

266
00:38:00.204 --> 00:38:05.376
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>We've been in kind of development mode basically until right now for a lot of those sites.

267
00:38:05.425 --> 00:38:14.358
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So numbers you see for past years include the true development of utilities on that site, placing pods, paying for that infrastructure.

268
00:38:14.664 --> 00:38:17.797
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Now we're kind of in maintenance mode, which will look different going forward.

269
00:38:17.862 --> 00:38:26.117
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So one thing you'll see in the mayor's proposed budget is gonna be Kind of a decreased level of how much that overall cost is, but I can get you the breakdown.

270
00:38:27.177 --> 00:38:37.150
<v Steve Novick>And again, of those 24/7 staff, how many of them are doing stuff that's sort of essential to the physical operation of the facility as opposed to people who are more of a social service mode?

271
00:38:37.615 --> 00:38:48.135
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Yes, so we have 2 maintenance folks on our shelter services team, so city employees who do basically all of the maintenance, frankly, on all of those sites.

272
00:38:48.876 --> 00:38:50.070
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>They do an amazing job.

273
00:38:50.489 --> 00:38:54.713
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>They'll get assistance occasionally from a contractor, but really it's those 2 individuals.

274
00:38:57.340 --> 00:39:02.063
<v Steve Novick>So the majority of the staff are not in that physical maintenance mode, but in sort of a social service mode?

275
00:39:02.128 --> 00:39:02.530
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Correct.

276
00:39:02.836 --> 00:39:03.175
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

277
00:39:03.400 --> 00:39:04.641
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah.

278
00:39:05.173 --> 00:39:05.931
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

279
00:39:06.463 --> 00:39:06.929
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

280
00:39:07.688 --> 00:39:08.943
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, President Dunphy.

281
00:39:09.443 --> 00:39:14.099
<v Dan Ryan>Appreciated the questions earlier from Councilor Clark about neighborhood associations.

282
00:39:15.889 --> 00:39:16.197
<v Dan Ryan>Could—.

283
00:39:16.376 --> 00:39:22.759
<v Dan Ryan>It's gone from 1.8 is what I heard, and then 1.6 is distributed.

284
00:39:23.619 --> 00:39:34.762
<v Dan Ryan>I'd like to see the comparables going back the last decade so I really understand what— how much support we're providing the infrastructure of that practice in the city.

285
00:39:37.260 --> 00:39:45.088
<v Dan Ryan>2, Second question is How much money do we receive from the SHS funds that Metro administers?

286
00:39:46.929 --> 00:39:48.626
<v Dan Ryan>How much comes directly to the city?

287
00:39:49.693 --> 00:39:52.523
<v Dan Ryan>And then you could— if you can't answer these today, that's fine.

288
00:39:52.621 --> 00:39:59.144
<v Dan Ryan>And then how many— how much comes to us splintered off from the county deciding that they can share money with the city?

289
00:40:00.969 --> 00:40:02.257
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Uh, Councilor, it's a great question.

290
00:40:02.306 --> 00:40:03.239
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Again, Skyler Bruckner-Knapp.

291
00:40:03.481 --> 00:40:15.480
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Um, so we received $15 million this This current fiscal year, so '25-'26, from the Metro SHS tax measure for overnight shelters specifically.

292
00:40:15.561 --> 00:40:26.894
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>We also had some carryover funds from the previous year, and I would have to go back and check exactly on, I think around, let's say $5 million, but I can get you the precise number that went to our alternative shelter program.

293
00:40:28.711 --> 00:40:31.190
<v Dan Ryan>And did the counties also then release money?

294
00:40:31.304 --> 00:40:43.246
<v Dan Ryan>'Cause they received the largest, 'cause that's The way the internal government's decided to do this, do they also share money with us since we're doing so much of the first response services?

295
00:40:44.224 --> 00:40:53.650
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Yeah, Councilor, the county, so that money had to pass through the county, but the county funds that we received from them specifically were actually general fund this fiscal year.

296
00:40:53.699 --> 00:40:57.481
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So not SHS, $10 million in their county general fund.

297
00:40:58.251 --> 00:41:00.173
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, I'll have more follow-ups on that later.

298
00:41:00.286 --> 00:41:00.670
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

299
00:41:01.217 --> 00:41:03.304
<v Dan Ryan>And with cuts in travel, I just want to make a comment.

300
00:41:03.400 --> 00:41:13.918
<v Dan Ryan>I think that it's a really appropriate time to spend more time with those peers in Vancouver, in Beaverton, Hillsboro, Lake Oswego, Gresham.

301
00:41:14.704 --> 00:41:20.983
<v Dan Ryan>I think based on some of the trends I'm seeing, at least in my neighborhood out in District 2, that's where people are moving to.

302
00:41:21.063 --> 00:41:23.873
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm kind of curious what, what they're doing that we could learn from.

303
00:41:24.210 --> 00:41:25.494
<v Dan Ryan>So I think it's a great time to lean local.

304
00:41:25.543 --> 00:41:25.655
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

305
00:41:25.702 --> 00:41:26.217
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Dan Ryan.

306
00:41:28.364 --> 00:41:29.293
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

307
00:41:30.351 --> 00:41:31.905
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have myself in the queue next.

308
00:41:31.969 --> 00:41:33.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have a couple of specific questions.

309
00:41:34.213 --> 00:41:41.184
<v Jamie Dunphy>We started— City Administrator, you sort of mentioned it, but could we get a little bit more granular?

310
00:41:41.889 --> 00:41:42.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your—.

311
00:41:42.306 --> 00:41:52.193
<v Jamie Dunphy>The general fund for your current service level is listed at $280 million roughly, which is an increase of about $56 million over the current year spending.

312
00:41:52.820 --> 00:41:54.163
<v Jamie Dunphy>In order to maintain the current service level.

313
00:41:54.260 --> 00:41:59.224
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could you just be a little more explicit about what the significant driver of those increases are?

314
00:41:59.353 --> 00:42:09.626
<v Raymond C. Lee>I'll have our budget team come up and speak to that question, but a lot of that is increased to just our normal overhead costs that we normally have with the city.

315
00:42:09.996 --> 00:42:15.289
<v Raymond C. Lee>And I believe our budget team can kind of speak to some of the details of that as well.

316
00:42:23.905 --> 00:42:27.806
<v Tracy Warren>Hi, Elizabeth Hilt, Interim Business Operations Division Manager.

317
00:42:28.722 --> 00:42:35.690
<v Tracy Warren>That really big increase in the general fund discretionary is a reclassification of funds that were not general fund.

318
00:42:35.867 --> 00:42:59.121
<v Jamie Dunphy>They were classified as possibly state funds in last year's budget, but now were put as general fund dollars in this budget showing meaning that these were either like one-time dollars or another source of dollars that had been budgeted to the, to the CA's office area, whatever we're calling it, um, and we do not have those.

319
00:42:59.168 --> 00:42:59.875
<v Jamie Dunphy>Those were one-time.

320
00:42:59.938 --> 00:43:00.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>We don't have that.

321
00:43:00.597 --> 00:43:05.505
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if we want to maintain them, we have to backfill with, uh, federal— with general fund.

322
00:43:06.115 --> 00:43:06.981
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I will just caveat.

323
00:43:07.175 --> 00:43:08.505
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So a lot of that is Portland Solutions.

324
00:43:08.603 --> 00:43:09.565
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So sorry, jumping in.

325
00:43:10.463 --> 00:43:16.617
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>But a lot of those funds, yes, were previously from like state or county or metro like we were just talking about.

326
00:43:16.952 --> 00:43:20.590
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>We are in current conversations with those jurisdictions about funding.

327
00:43:20.655 --> 00:43:26.601
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So for the mayor's proposed, it will not look like that general big of a general fund gap, at least for our program.

328
00:43:26.969 --> 00:43:30.398
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>But we can't, we aren't confirmed on some of those yet, so.

329
00:43:31.039 --> 00:43:31.215
<v Olivia Clark>Got it.

330
00:43:31.697 --> 00:43:33.588
<v Ruth Levine>And sorry, Ruth Levine, budget director.

331
00:43:33.635 --> 00:43:34.773
<v Ruth Levine>Sorry to pile on here.

332
00:43:35.543 --> 00:43:45.786
<v Ruth Levine>I just wanted to clarify, we did, when we presented about the current service level at the worksite, session a couple of weeks ago, we flagged this and the city administrator flagged it, but I know it's confusing.

333
00:43:48.494 --> 00:43:59.929
<v Ruth Levine>We basically just didn't— there wasn't a clear way to categorize it one way or another because we can't really assume that it's going to be non-general fund at this point because those decisions haven't been finalized.

334
00:44:00.699 --> 00:44:09.661
<v Ruth Levine>So we put it in as general fund with the kind of asterisk that it's not— the implication is not that we would have to cut general fund to fund that.

335
00:44:09.811 --> 00:44:09.945
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Thank you.

336
00:44:10.148 --> 00:44:17.903
<v Ruth Levine>So it is confusing, particularly on this chart that looks back at the previous 5 years.

337
00:44:18.001 --> 00:44:18.487
<v Ruth Levine>But yeah.

338
00:44:18.730 --> 00:44:18.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>Gotcha.

339
00:44:19.393 --> 00:44:34.601
<v Jamie Dunphy>But this functionally is a policy choice that we are trying to make at this point of do we continue the services we are providing now with different revenue sources, recognizing that funding one means probably cutting another?

340
00:44:34.811 --> 00:44:35.150
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that—.

341
00:44:35.375 --> 00:44:36.052
<v Raymond C. Lee>That is correct.

342
00:44:36.170 --> 00:44:37.068
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

343
00:44:44.530 --> 00:44:49.998
<v Jamie Dunphy>That— sorry, I have a lot of in-the-weeds questions and I'm trying to decide if I want to get that deep into the weeds.

344
00:44:53.849 --> 00:45:18.509
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, um, with regard to the— sorry, I'm interested to know, I mean, like you mentioned, you mentioned on— I don't remember what slide number it was, but, uh, the proposed as right now for the CFO office would result in a reduced— a reduction in revenue collection, which I imagine is primarily just because we have staff and we just simply have to do that.

345
00:45:18.574 --> 00:45:29.166
<v Jamie Dunphy>But is that one of the problems that Councilor Clark was sort of previewing, that we're gonna cut off our nose to spite our face and that we're cutting the people who collect our money, that we are gonna have less money?

346
00:45:30.039 --> 00:45:30.972
<v Raymond C. Lee>And that is an option.

347
00:45:31.021 --> 00:45:33.623
<v Raymond C. Lee>That is not something that we're saying we're moving forward with.

348
00:45:33.976 --> 00:45:51.217
<v Raymond C. Lee>This was an exercise as we went through looking at 3 to 10% reductions, as we've asked all bureaus and programs to do, to go through that exercise and pull forth these type of recommendations of what could be potential options.

349
00:45:51.731 --> 00:46:00.625
<v Raymond C. Lee>Does not mean that we would move in this direction, as we're still going through our own deliberations from the executive and administrative side of it.

350
00:46:00.961 --> 00:46:04.494
<v Raymond C. Lee>To see what will be going forward in the mayor's proposed budget.

351
00:46:04.896 --> 00:46:11.190
<v Raymond C. Lee>These are just all things that we will be taking under consideration in the preparation of producing a balanced budget.

352
00:46:11.864 --> 00:46:21.931
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, to that same end though, um, I— this is maybe not apples and oranges, but I've heard that for every million dollars the IRS spends on tax collectors, they collect $10 million.

353
00:46:23.105 --> 00:46:40.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there something— I mean, honestly, like, if we were to increase If the only budget we increased was yours, specifically towards revenue collection, would that see a net result in collections above and beyond the amount of money we would put into your office?

354
00:46:40.753 --> 00:46:42.244
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, Councilor, it's a great question.

355
00:46:42.356 --> 00:46:51.619
<v Jonas Biery>There is analysis, I don't have it at my fingertips, that sort of estimates at least by at the reduction level for each sort of staff we reduce in that function.

356
00:46:51.972 --> 00:46:54.347
<v Jonas Biery>What's the trade-off in reduced revenue collection?

357
00:46:54.782 --> 00:46:55.713
<v Jonas Biery>It's net negative.

358
00:46:56.547 --> 00:47:00.353
<v Jonas Biery>We do get, Councilor Clark, as you said, penny smart, pound foolish.

359
00:47:00.706 --> 00:47:05.972
<v Jonas Biery>We get that budgetary savings and probably get that revenue reduction as well.

360
00:47:06.920 --> 00:47:11.126
<v Jonas Biery>It's a little trickier going up because there's sort of diminishing returns.

361
00:47:11.463 --> 00:47:17.485
<v Jonas Biery>And so I don't know that we have that analysis, but we'll get back to you on what that analysis is of the sort of reduction scenario.

362
00:47:18.224 --> 00:47:22.880
<v Jonas Biery>You know, and again, as the city administrator said, I can speak for the CFO office.

363
00:47:23.442 --> 00:47:29.239
<v Jonas Biery>We don't have anything that we provide that isn't bare-bones essential services.

364
00:47:29.608 --> 00:47:33.974
<v Jonas Biery>And so there is no reduction scenario that won't have negative impacts.

365
00:47:34.440 --> 00:47:36.898
<v Jonas Biery>And so I'll just state that explicitly and transparently.

366
00:47:37.476 --> 00:47:59.097
<v Jamie Dunphy>To the CA's point, that'll be part of the calculus in deciding what goes forward for council and appreciate council's input on those you know, I think that one thing that I have seen with this transition to the new form of government is that we are finally getting a sane budgeting process that is starting to come away from the siloed bureaus and sanctioned dollars.

367
00:47:59.161 --> 00:48:01.873
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that your office in particular needs more staff.

368
00:48:02.195 --> 00:48:07.666
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just think that if we are going to be able to run this city, we need to be making that a kind of investment.

369
00:48:07.811 --> 00:48:12.144
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I know that that comes with tradeoffs, and I don't understand how to balance those and understand how those things work.

370
00:48:12.646 --> 00:48:18.155
<v Jamie Dunphy>But that is a top priority for me because, as we all acknowledge, we have a revenue problem.

371
00:48:18.300 --> 00:48:25.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>And sometimes it's not just that our revenue-generating sources aren't generating the same amount, it's that it's harder to collect it.

372
00:48:25.998 --> 00:48:28.244
<v Jamie Dunphy>Like, we know how expensive it is to collect the arts tax.

373
00:48:28.949 --> 00:48:30.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you.

374
00:48:31.641 --> 00:48:37.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that I'll put— I will take myself out of the queue for now and I'll turn it over to some colleagues.

375
00:48:37.675 --> 00:48:37.788
<v Ruth Levine>Thank you.

376
00:48:38.652 --> 00:48:39.605
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll turn it over to Councilor Green.

377
00:48:41.570 --> 00:48:42.289
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. President.

378
00:48:43.389 --> 00:48:45.764
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, City Administrator Lee, for the presentation today.

379
00:48:45.927 --> 00:48:46.952
<v Mitch Green>I just have a few questions.

380
00:48:49.130 --> 00:48:50.210
<v Mitch Green>Some are small, some are big.

381
00:48:50.438 --> 00:48:51.599
<v Mitch Green>I'll start with the small ones.

382
00:48:51.809 --> 00:49:04.047
<v Mitch Green>So earlier, I can't remember which slide you said, but you'd made the argument that by pulling back the 24/7 sheltering program inside the City of Portland, we're realizing some savings from that.

383
00:49:04.112 --> 00:49:06.525
<v Mitch Green>Can you say a little bit more about what's driving those savings?

384
00:49:07.414 --> 00:49:08.778
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Yeah, I can speak to that, Councilor.

385
00:49:08.858 --> 00:49:12.648
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So some of those were just different contracts that the county held.

386
00:49:12.697 --> 00:49:20.179
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So for example, food service or trying to get a little more competitive on kind of what contracts we have for services at those sites.

387
00:49:20.757 --> 00:49:22.780
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Some of them are operations contracts as well.

388
00:49:23.150 --> 00:49:31.965
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So just kind of the way everything was being run, we got to— we got the opportunity to drill down kind of on line item budgets for each and every site.

389
00:49:32.699 --> 00:49:38.099
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so it's not a sort of like seams problem between the city and the county.

390
00:49:38.148 --> 00:49:46.771
<v Mitch Green>It's more the city in control, maybe making better, um, or I would say it differently, making decisions that have a lower cost.

391
00:49:46.998 --> 00:49:47.503
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>That is correct.

392
00:49:47.568 --> 00:49:47.940
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Okay, thank you.

393
00:49:48.135 --> 00:49:48.719
<v Mitch Green>That's helpful.

394
00:49:49.492 --> 00:49:55.889
<v Mitch Green>Um, so I guess these are bigger questions.

395
00:49:56.260 --> 00:50:09.708
<v Mitch Green>Um, I guess I'm just broadly concerned about like where the cuts will come from to validate this inclusion of the Portland Solutions budget, particularly into the general fund.

396
00:50:10.418 --> 00:50:26.164
<v Mitch Green>I know, I think we're hearing a conflicting message today, which is that on the one hand, um, we, we need to get to a more stable funding choice if this is a program we want to keep, we want to sustain, uh, so we can stop being entrepreneurs and, you know, With a side hustle.

397
00:50:26.244 --> 00:50:28.458
<v Mitch Green>And I, you know, I think that, that makes sense.

398
00:50:28.521 --> 00:50:32.527
<v Mitch Green>But then we're also being said, well, don't worry about it, it won't be that big because we're going to go get the money.

399
00:50:33.378 --> 00:50:34.989
<v Mitch Green>So that's what I'm hearing.

400
00:50:35.166 --> 00:50:37.211
<v Mitch Green>Um, so that's a— that seems to be a bit in conflict here.

401
00:50:37.275 --> 00:50:49.047
<v Mitch Green>And so I don't really want to budget, um, based upon we might get the money because I think we— that takes on a lot of risk.

402
00:50:49.516 --> 00:50:50.355
<v Mitch Green>Takes on a lot of risk.

403
00:50:50.402 --> 00:50:51.726
<v Mitch Green>And I think everyone understands that.

404
00:50:51.840 --> 00:51:00.601
<v Mitch Green>Um, and so the prudent I think the most fiscally responsible thing to do in a budget is assume the worst-case scenario, which has a large cost driver.

405
00:51:01.338 --> 00:51:11.036
<v Mitch Green>And so as we get into this exercise, we're going to be having to make decisions between whether we want to sustain this level of CSL and Portland Solutions in particular.

406
00:51:12.809 --> 00:51:15.434
<v Mitch Green>I mean, there are other areas that are identified for cuts, but that's the meat of it.

407
00:51:15.938 --> 00:51:16.706
<v Mitch Green>Mm-hmm.

408
00:51:17.472 --> 00:51:22.275
<v Mitch Green>And are we trading that between Public safety, because that's the other big cost driver that has a big gap right now.

409
00:51:23.028 --> 00:51:26.128
<v Mitch Green>And those are 2 areas that people say don't touch a dime.

410
00:51:26.673 --> 00:51:27.541
<v Mitch Green>So then what gives?

411
00:51:27.686 --> 00:51:39.871
<v Mitch Green>I'm worried about, I'm worried about our insurance and the products that we— I mean, the neighborhood associations are only existing because they can get money from the city for insurance.

412
00:51:40.771 --> 00:51:48.740
<v Mitch Green>And it's going to be all those little areas in the budget, in the general fund, That are outside those 2 big broad buckets that are going to be identified for cuts.

413
00:51:48.806 --> 00:51:50.221
<v Mitch Green>That's the thing I'm really worried about right now.

414
00:51:51.056 --> 00:51:52.730
<v Mitch Green>I'm sure everyone else is too.

415
00:51:53.179 --> 00:51:54.483
<v Mitch Green>So I just needed to name that.

416
00:51:56.918 --> 00:52:01.202
<v Mitch Green>So I have some other questions that might help us answer those kind of questions as you develop this.

417
00:52:01.556 --> 00:52:10.009
<v Mitch Green>I'd be curious to know what the average capacity utilization rate is for our overnight shelters, as well as our alternative shelters.

418
00:52:12.039 --> 00:52:24.041
<v Mitch Green>I would like to know if all of those alternative shelter contracts are Urban Alchemy contracts, and if so, what are we spending per person per year to run those?

419
00:52:25.751 --> 00:52:34.527
<v Mitch Green>Getting that kind of information, and maybe you have it right now, would be, I think, really helpful for this council as we head into our reaction to the mayor's proposed.

420
00:52:35.092 --> 00:52:36.693
<v Mitch Green>I think that's probably all I have.

421
00:52:37.132 --> 00:52:38.157
<v Mitch Green>For questions, so.

422
00:52:38.655 --> 00:52:43.190
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I can give you at least just a few of those pieces, Councilor, but also happy to talk to you separately.

423
00:52:44.201 --> 00:52:55.534
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So the capacity, just quickly, we hover between around 60%, 60 to 70% for overnight shelter depending on weather, what's going on kind of outside.

424
00:52:55.663 --> 00:53:00.182
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So colder, rainier, we tend to see an uptick kind of in overnight shelters, and that's an average.

425
00:53:00.278 --> 00:53:04.431
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So some shelters are quite full every night and some are not as full.

426
00:53:04.574 --> 00:53:06.081
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So that's what we've seen.

427
00:53:06.146 --> 00:53:10.170
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>We track that religiously basically to see kind of What the need is in the community.

428
00:53:10.235 --> 00:53:24.257
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>For alternative, it's over 100%, which is crazy to say, but that means that we have, okay, this is how many pods we have and we have some couples in those pods and we frankly have more couples than we anticipated when we kind of set the capacity numbers at those sites.

429
00:53:24.690 --> 00:53:27.673
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So those are always full is kind of the easiest way to think about that.

430
00:53:28.684 --> 00:53:30.545
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Not all of those sites are run by Urban Alchemy.

431
00:53:30.690 --> 00:53:37.018
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>We have 3 main contractors for our alternative shelter sites, Cultivate Initiatives, Sunstone Way and Urban Alchemy.

432
00:53:37.197 --> 00:53:37.701
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>That's right now.

433
00:53:37.798 --> 00:53:43.271
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>We went through an RFP process recently for folks to apply for those sites as well.

434
00:53:43.592 --> 00:53:46.195
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>And so we can also walk you through that competitive process.

435
00:53:46.726 --> 00:53:49.313
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I can get you the per-person cost or the average.

436
00:53:49.376 --> 00:53:52.739
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>It will depend how quickly folks are moving through those shelters.

437
00:53:52.788 --> 00:53:56.903
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So if that pod turns over 3 or 4 times in a year, it's going to be cheaper, obviously.

438
00:53:57.471 --> 00:53:58.248
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>But I can get you the average.

439
00:54:00.114 --> 00:54:00.788
<v Mitch Green>That would be helpful.

440
00:54:00.853 --> 00:54:24.849
<v Mitch Green>And I just as we go into a decision where we're going to have to say yes or no to renewing this in situ, um, I need to name that I think one of the primary complaints I've heard with, um, the alternative shelters in particular is that we're not seeing the wraparound services from Urban Alchemy as promised, and that we've got a lot of clients who are suffering because of it.

441
00:54:25.460 --> 00:54:28.719
<v Mitch Green>And so getting me comfortable on that's going to be really important.

442
00:54:28.782 --> 00:54:28.894
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

443
00:54:29.538 --> 00:54:33.744
<v Mitch Green>I'm sure there's a lot of information I don't know, so I'm just asking it here.

444
00:54:34.275 --> 00:54:35.014
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Absolutely, Councilor.

445
00:54:35.094 --> 00:54:36.233
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I'm happy to get that for you.

446
00:54:36.699 --> 00:54:44.536
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I'm really proud of the care coordination, the case management that's done there, but we can get you the precise information or we can take you on a tour or have you meet the staff as well.

447
00:54:45.612 --> 00:54:49.788
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>And the larger kind of question that you're asking, thank you for bringing that forward.

448
00:54:49.869 --> 00:54:54.766
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I think it's something that we wrestle with, as the City Administrator said, every single year.

449
00:54:54.847 --> 00:54:58.668
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I feel like a huge part of my job is being a fundraiser, which is not what I signed up for.

450
00:54:58.750 --> 00:54:59.389
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Yeah.

451
00:54:59.485 --> 00:55:10.204
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>And so I think the mayor and I have done our very best every single year, but there needs to be a more sustainable approach if these functions are still gonna proceed.

452
00:55:10.380 --> 00:55:11.902
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I think that's not sustainable.

453
00:55:11.998 --> 00:55:20.699
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>And the city administrator has been very clear that he sees that immediately when he saw kind of how hard we're working to try to make sure this isn't a question for the general fund.

454
00:55:21.291 --> 00:55:26.755
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>We don't want you to have to deal with it that way, but we're gonna have to figure out what it looks like going forward.

455
00:55:26.898 --> 00:55:29.030
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I think I would say, I know it sounds like I'm sorry.

456
00:55:29.077 --> 00:55:35.001
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I don't mean to give conflicting information or direction, but we're going to need time to figure out what that looks like.

457
00:55:35.481 --> 00:55:40.954
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>And I don't think 3 or 4 months are going to be sufficient to figure out what the programs look like going forward.

458
00:55:41.340 --> 00:55:44.501
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>It takes us 3 to 4 months to decommission an alternative shelter site.

459
00:55:45.016 --> 00:55:57.550
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So I need some runway to be able to have those really important conversations of what happens with all the humans, what happens with the staff, where do we want this to sit within the city of Portland if we want it to continue.

460
00:55:58.114 --> 00:56:02.356
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Please give us, that's my plea, a little time to be really thoughtful about it.

461
00:56:02.873 --> 00:56:07.985
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>And that is just one more budget cycle to really figure out what we're doing here and what you want to see going forward.

462
00:56:09.992 --> 00:56:10.282
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Skyler.

463
00:56:10.476 --> 00:56:10.717
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Thanks.

464
00:56:12.010 --> 00:56:12.655
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

465
00:56:12.817 --> 00:56:13.882
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

466
00:56:14.269 --> 00:56:15.545
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

467
00:56:16.199 --> 00:56:22.115
<v Steve Novick>Jonas, I just wanted to return to the Council President's questions about revenue-generating positions.

468
00:56:23.039 --> 00:56:27.309
<v Steve Novick>It seems to me that the bang for the buck depends on what they're collecting.

469
00:56:27.659 --> 00:56:31.900
<v Steve Novick>Like if they're collecting the arts tax at $35 a pop, they're probably not very efficient.

470
00:56:31.900 --> 00:56:37.679
<v Steve Novick>But if you put more people on collecting the business license tax, then maybe it's a fair amount of bang for your buck.

471
00:56:38.260 --> 00:56:47.800
<v Steve Novick>I had an experience when I was asking Thomas Lanham to like recalculate what a different level of CEO pay ratio surcharge tax would collect.

472
00:56:47.800 --> 00:56:53.960
<v Steve Novick>And in the course of answering that question, he went through and found out that there are a bunch of companies that weren't paying that should and picked up several hundred thousand dollars that way.

473
00:56:53.960 --> 00:56:54.039
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So I'm just curious.

474
00:56:54.039 --> 00:56:54.059
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

475
00:56:58.422 --> 00:57:07.498
<v Steve Novick>Not to answer it now, but I think it might be interesting for us to learn what you think the bang for the buck would be, particularly if you had more staff looking at the business license tax in particular.

476
00:57:08.849 --> 00:57:11.130
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, Councilor, great question, and happy to look at that.

477
00:57:11.659 --> 00:57:22.648
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, it is different for different, I'd say, both flavors of revenues that are collected and different points in the cycle, which might be both throughout the year or throughout the economic cycle more broadly.

478
00:57:22.746 --> 00:57:24.630
<v Jonas Biery>So, um, but, but we'll work.

479
00:57:24.677 --> 00:57:30.201
<v Jonas Biery>I think that we have data that sort of breaks out a little bit of where the staff time relative to collections lie.

480
00:57:30.409 --> 00:57:33.831
<v Jonas Biery>And yeah, certainly there's efficiencies in some areas that don't exist in others.

481
00:57:36.724 --> 00:57:37.681
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

482
00:57:37.923 --> 00:57:38.554
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

483
00:57:42.052 --> 00:57:43.023
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks, Council President.

484
00:57:43.445 --> 00:57:46.172
<v Dan Ryan>I'll look where you started with your questions about revenue.

485
00:57:46.545 --> 00:57:54.918
<v Dan Ryan>So I just want to get some technical questions we serve Metro in collections of SHS, and we serve the county.

486
00:57:55.112 --> 00:57:57.467
<v Dan Ryan>We provide them— we're a vendor for them for pre-K-4.

487
00:57:58.869 --> 00:58:07.117
<v Dan Ryan>Can you tell me, are we getting the right rate of fee, if you will, from Metro and the county to provide those services?

488
00:58:09.907 --> 00:58:10.847
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, Councilor, good question.

489
00:58:11.221 --> 00:58:22.672
<v Jonas Biery>That's correct, we do collect those taxes on behalf our regional partners, there's an intergovernment agreement that exists with those entities that identify what the cost recovery is.

490
00:58:22.864 --> 00:58:25.226
<v Jonas Biery>And my understanding is that it is based upon kind of actuals.

491
00:58:25.275 --> 00:58:33.242
<v Jonas Biery>So short answer is yes, I believe we are probably collecting the fair amount, but happy to provide more information about those IGAs.

492
00:58:34.349 --> 00:58:39.650
<v Dan Ryan>I know that some of our performance, like collecting the arts tax, went down once we started taking on new work.

493
00:58:39.860 --> 00:58:45.731
<v Dan Ryan>So there was a— there was some, I think, some collateral loss in terms of taking it on because it's a big lift.

494
00:58:45.891 --> 00:58:48.762
<v Dan Ryan>And shout out to Tom and his team for taking that on.

495
00:58:49.420 --> 00:58:59.976
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I think what I care about when it looks at the alternative shelters is the provider-comparable results from each village, um, because we named 3.

496
00:59:00.762 --> 00:59:09.784
<v Dan Ryan>And so before we speculate, it'd be just good to see that raw objective data, like how many are, in my opinion, how many are saying yes to addiction services?

497
00:59:09.976 --> 00:59:13.190
<v Dan Ryan>I know Urban Alchemy has a much, much higher rate than the other 2.

498
00:59:13.655 --> 00:59:16.500
<v Dan Ryan>Um, how many are going into workforce?

499
00:59:16.661 --> 00:59:18.652
<v Dan Ryan>Again, Urban Alchemy has a much higher rate.

500
00:59:18.958 --> 00:59:28.967
<v Dan Ryan>So I want to see the results that we're getting from those vendor relationships, uh, for our unhoused participants who are trying to help become stable and be on their own someday.

501
00:59:29.454 --> 00:59:29.697
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

502
00:59:31.722 --> 00:59:32.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

503
00:59:32.534 --> 00:59:33.068
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

504
00:59:35.887 --> 00:59:36.291
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

505
00:59:37.175 --> 00:59:55.262
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate a lot of this conversation and I appreciate the focus on Portland Solutions, but I want to start with something outside of Portland Solutions briefly, which is there's a slide in which the City Attorney line disappears in the rightmost column, and I had some questions about that.

506
00:59:55.492 --> 00:59:56.706
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd like to keep one.

507
00:59:58.356 --> 01:00:09.501
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm sure that the goal is not to get rid of the office or anything, and obviously it's charter required, but I'm guessing it's just a different way we're going to start counting it and wanted to get a little clarity on that briefly before I get into the Portland Solutions IBEX.

508
01:00:12.289 --> 01:00:12.853
<v Sameer Kanal>Slide 8.

509
01:00:15.253 --> 01:00:22.103
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, well, loosely looking, Councilor, my assumption is that that's either just a gap in the labeling or a cutoff of the chart, but we'll look into that.

510
01:00:22.150 --> 01:00:26.556
<v Jonas Biery>There's certainly not a reduction to elimination of the City Attorney's Office.

511
01:00:26.771 --> 01:00:27.719
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, it's OGR.

512
01:00:27.766 --> 01:00:28.730
<v Jonas Biery>Just a gap in the presentation.

513
01:00:28.777 --> 01:00:39.016
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, OGR and maybe equity, although, um, the line is so thin on equity, um, that maybe it's hard to tell, which is itself a problem we should be solving.

514
01:00:39.594 --> 01:00:42.932
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so I hope we can solve that issue, uh, as well.

515
01:00:43.527 --> 01:00:55.161
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, getting to Portland Solutions, part of the challenge in assessing your budget is that there are bundles that don't always, um, make a lot of sense from a legislative perspective.

516
01:00:55.320 --> 01:01:07.990
<v Sameer Kanal>I imagine they make much more sense operationally, but we dealt with this in the fall technical adjustment ordinance where impact reduction program combines the clearances of trash and the clearances of people.

517
01:01:09.032 --> 01:01:11.503
<v Sameer Kanal>And those are 2 very different conversations.

518
01:01:11.614 --> 01:01:16.585
<v Sameer Kanal>I imagine if you asked this council who supports clearing trash, it'd be a 12-0 vote.

519
01:01:16.987 --> 01:01:18.719
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't think it's a 12-0 vote on the other side.

520
01:01:19.152 --> 01:01:29.822
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I want to make sure that when we get to the proposed budget, that the bucketing allows for legislative decisions to be made in a way that makes sense to this side, to that side, and to the public.

521
01:01:30.126 --> 01:01:41.262
<v Sameer Kanal>And just wanted to daylight that ahead of time because I have an interest in renewing that conversation because I want to make sure you have the money to clean trash and that that's protected from cuts.

522
01:01:42.047 --> 01:01:43.920
<v Sameer Kanal>You look like you want to say something, so I'll pause here if you want to.

523
01:01:44.097 --> 01:01:44.353
<v Tracy Warren>Sorry.

524
01:01:44.402 --> 01:01:45.619
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>No, thank you, Councilor.

525
01:01:45.668 --> 01:01:46.885
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>That's helpful and we can provide that.

526
01:01:46.949 --> 01:01:52.349
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I think one thing that will continue to be be a difficulty with IRP's budget is they're all internal agreements.

527
01:01:52.460 --> 01:01:58.726
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So all of those processes are things we're doing on behalf of other bureaus and they're bucketed together.

528
01:01:59.063 --> 01:02:06.193
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So I can try to pull apart how much we spend on it, but it's gonna be difficult from a budgeting process to kind of pull that, piece that apart.

529
01:02:06.242 --> 01:02:08.740
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>But we can work with the CBO to figure it out.

530
01:02:09.302 --> 01:02:10.103
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you clarify?

531
01:02:10.248 --> 01:02:13.083
<v Sameer Kanal>I can see how that would make sense for the trash pickup.

532
01:02:13.291 --> 01:02:13.516
<v Sameer Kanal>So—.

533
01:02:14.349 --> 01:02:19.614
<v Sameer Kanal>You have internal agreements Is this for sweeping campsites with other bureaus too?

534
01:02:19.951 --> 01:02:21.219
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Yes, so it's all of it together.

535
01:02:21.268 --> 01:02:29.088
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>So it's bucketed as we provide the assessment, we provide the trash pickup, we provide the removal, we provide the posting, we provide the storage of belongings.

536
01:02:29.425 --> 01:02:31.143
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>That's all together for—.

537
01:02:31.224 --> 01:02:31.898
<v Sameer Kanal>For interagency?

538
01:02:32.010 --> 01:02:32.509
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Exactly.

539
01:02:33.215 --> 01:02:36.748
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that's a little surprising, but I would like to see that.

540
01:02:37.068 --> 01:02:45.269
<v Sameer Kanal>I think part of what, one of the challenges that we have with the overall budget, this has nothing to do with the service area, is that we, We pay each other a lot.

541
01:02:46.063 --> 01:02:48.958
<v Sameer Kanal>We have an $8.5 billion budget with $6.5 billion.

542
01:02:49.070 --> 01:02:49.880
<v Sameer Kanal>Mm-hmm.

543
01:02:50.106 --> 01:02:52.581
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's because of the money moving around.

544
01:02:52.628 --> 01:02:55.972
<v Sameer Kanal>And it creates some weird situations when we're trying to assess it.

545
01:02:56.019 --> 01:03:00.233
<v Sameer Kanal>And I know everybody who's involved in that is trying to move away from that in the long term.

546
01:03:00.298 --> 01:03:04.079
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm not trying to fault anyone, but just wanted to illustrate that.

547
01:03:05.713 --> 01:03:16.699
<v Sameer Kanal>Another conversation is around the decreasing gap in the cost per person in the 2 types of shelter that we bucketed out here.

548
01:03:16.764 --> 01:03:28.074
<v Sameer Kanal>My understanding is that historically there was maybe a $50, $60 a night difference in how much it cost to shelter a person in overnight shelter versus alternative shelter.

549
01:03:28.235 --> 01:03:33.561
<v Sameer Kanal>And now we're looking at maybe a $30, maybe $25 difference.

550
01:03:34.235 --> 01:03:55.858
<v Sameer Kanal>And so looking at maybe that helps justify given that the alternative shelter both has— the last update we got was that it had a higher placement rate out of it into permanent housing, and the fact that it minimizes some of the concerns we have with night-only shelter, namely the where do people go during the day part of it, that that's a conversation we need to have.

551
01:03:55.923 --> 01:04:15.088
<v Sameer Kanal>That not necessarily to eliminate overnight shelter, I'm not arguing for that at all, but in terms of making sure we maintain and potentially as we expand shelter, that that focus goes more towards the alternative side, either in the expansions that were referenced or to existing sites, or if we talk about a new location.

552
01:04:15.554 --> 01:04:24.010
<v Sameer Kanal>I understand finding a parking lot and finding a building as your sort of starting points are different and the setup costs are different, but in terms of ongoing, that might be worth considering.

553
01:04:24.608 --> 01:04:30.284
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to mention that there's not really, I don't know if there's a question in that, but if you wanted to—.

554
01:04:30.284 --> 01:04:32.371
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>We can provide that so that you have that information, yes.

555
01:04:32.985 --> 01:04:33.405
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, great.

556
01:04:34.789 --> 01:04:35.079
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

557
01:04:35.226 --> 01:04:44.086
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I guess off of the bigger picture things, not specific to Portland Solutions, I'm really excited to see the conversation around performance management.

558
01:04:45.117 --> 01:04:52.190
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm really excited to see, and I want to support you having the staffing you need, Administrator Lee, to do the job that we've asked you to do.

559
01:04:53.420 --> 01:05:01.782
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to make sure we talk about span of control so often in the opposite sense, you know, people who have A vertical kind of thing.

560
01:05:02.610 --> 01:05:06.914
<v Sameer Kanal>14 Is a lot as a number of direct reports, and that should be much smaller.

561
01:05:07.369 --> 01:05:08.815
<v Sameer Kanal>I think our goal is 4 to 7 right now.

562
01:05:09.659 --> 01:05:12.811
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's the mayor's guidance, and I agree with that range.

563
01:05:15.728 --> 01:05:17.210
<v Sameer Kanal>So that seems good.

564
01:05:17.355 --> 01:05:42.983
<v Sameer Kanal>I would love, as a part of that, to understand the lines of authority and conversation around who manages because you have DCAs and you also have chief officers and you also have Skyler and Portland Solutions, which is its own thing, and then evidently 4 more that I haven't even accounted for somewhere.

565
01:05:43.436 --> 01:06:07.686
<v Sameer Kanal>But as we— I think that understanding and not siloing off those for disciplines and practices, I should say, so that they are able to have the authority necessary to not only do their job with their verticals, but to ensure that the rest of the enterprise is doing— is behaving equitably, communicating, engaging, and being sustainable.

566
01:06:08.346 --> 01:06:15.543
<v Sameer Kanal>That piece of it, I don't know that the org chart alone can help answer that, but it's the best time to talk about it.

567
01:06:15.592 --> 01:06:16.844
<v Sameer Kanal>So I wanted to mention that.

568
01:06:17.887 --> 01:06:19.909
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think you raise an excellent point.

569
01:06:20.070 --> 01:06:43.858
<v Raymond C. Lee>And I think as we've gone through different iterations of our organizational structure and how do we infuse some of these, what I would consider pillars of our organization— equity, sustainability, engagement— into the fabric of our organization and what we do day in and day out is something that I've, you know, throughout my career I've seen different organizations do it differently.

570
01:06:44.539 --> 01:07:03.382
<v Raymond C. Lee>And we're gonna have to figure out what works uniquely for our organization as we move forward to really have that a part of the culture of the organization where we're just not talking about 'em in terms of positions, but we're talking about 'em in terms of the value and what we stand for, what goes without mention for our organization.

571
01:07:03.510 --> 01:07:09.565
<v Raymond C. Lee>So I think that's gonna be some of the debate that we have as we look at how do we structure this long-term?

572
01:07:10.164 --> 01:07:24.456
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think some of this may have been too just a direct report to me and the time that is allocated to those direct reports to make sure that they have that thought partner as it relates to how do they infuse their operations throughout the organization.

573
01:07:24.827 --> 01:07:30.530
<v Raymond C. Lee>And that's something that we are going to get better at as we evolve as an organization and mature as an organization.

574
01:07:31.297 --> 01:07:31.916
<v Sameer Kanal>Great, thanks.

575
01:07:32.030 --> 01:07:52.367
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think the, the one of the things that is left to get figured out is the diagonal line for those 4 practices in the org chart, how they engage with the people they don't directly manage in the bureaus, and whether or not that those are staff for them embedded versus staff they influence.

576
01:07:53.266 --> 01:08:03.849
<v Sameer Kanal>I tend to lean towards the former as someone who's been on the administrative side because, and I think this is particularly notable in equity and engagement, but I imagine it's the same in the other 2 practices, Thank you.

577
01:08:03.849 --> 01:08:03.849
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a great question.

578
01:08:03.849 --> 01:08:05.150
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's a question that we have to ask of our practices as well.

579
01:08:05.150 --> 01:08:23.520
<v Sameer Kanal>If we're trying to move towards measuring the actual outcome and not just the output, meaning not measuring how many meetings did an equity or engagement officer have— not officer, a staffer— have, but did we have more equitable outcomes that reflected the engagement we heard?

580
01:08:23.550 --> 01:08:27.750
<v Sameer Kanal>The authority has to be a part of that conversation in a way that it hasn't yet.

581
01:08:27.750 --> 01:08:32.779
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to set up not only the 3 we already have, but I know we're about to hire Chief Equity Officer.

582
01:08:32.859 --> 01:08:42.957
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to make sure that they're set up for success and have the authority to do that, both so that the practices do well and so that we're able to track their performance in the new performance office.

583
01:08:43.697 --> 01:08:46.121
<v Sameer Kanal>I have 2 other quick notes.

584
01:08:46.667 --> 01:08:57.568
<v Sameer Kanal>One is, speaking of equity, the cuts in the Office of Equity and Human Rights last year are a high priority for me to reverse some of, and I want to just daylight that on day one.

585
01:08:58.408 --> 01:09:04.082
<v Sameer Kanal>That was one of the things I thought was the worst part of last year's budget.

586
01:09:05.806 --> 01:09:12.067
<v Sameer Kanal>And the other piece relates to the revenue side that's been discussed here.

587
01:09:13.360 --> 01:09:30.622
<v Sameer Kanal>I think if there is a revenue source which costs more or costs close to as much to implement as it does to do, As it raises back, then we should discuss whether or not cost recovery is a goal we can achieve.

588
01:09:30.798 --> 01:09:32.193
<v Sameer Kanal>I know I'm speaking the mayor's language right now.

589
01:09:32.497 --> 01:09:37.756
<v Sameer Kanal>He's talked about this before, but I think that list would be really helpful to frame.

590
01:09:38.894 --> 01:09:48.865
<v Sameer Kanal>And I would love to work with Councilor Novick, as I'm sure many other people have volunteered to over the course of this last year, about that one specific source of revenue, the surcharge.

591
01:09:48.962 --> 01:09:49.137
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

592
01:09:49.493 --> 01:09:52.280
<v Sameer Kanal>And exploring that in the future, but there's been a bunch of others.

593
01:09:52.328 --> 01:09:55.502
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, I think that, that would be really helpful information for us.

594
01:09:55.697 --> 01:09:55.953
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

595
01:09:56.341 --> 01:09:57.226
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

596
01:09:57.469 --> 01:09:58.323
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

597
01:09:58.516 --> 01:09:59.131
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

598
01:10:01.988 --> 01:10:02.422
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

599
01:10:02.859 --> 01:10:04.667
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I'm looking at slide 9.

600
01:10:04.877 --> 01:10:05.926
<v Eric Zimmerman>It talks about FTE.

601
01:10:06.087 --> 01:10:08.332
<v Eric Zimmerman>They're in the city administrator's budget.

602
01:10:08.833 --> 01:10:18.233
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, uh, just, just first off, just to the— this now I think our second one of these— I really appreciate just the, um, consistency between reports, right?

603
01:10:18.296 --> 01:10:27.076
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's really helpful as we start doing a comparison, and we are also talking about the, the size and relativity of one program to the next.

604
01:10:27.220 --> 01:10:30.146
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, um, I've appreciated this approach.

605
01:10:31.167 --> 01:10:46.466
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, that being said, I would second, uh, Councilor Clark's comment, and it might seem trivial, but in a world of decision-making 7 shades of blue is not a decision-making color I can decipher.

606
01:10:46.707 --> 01:10:52.109
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I hope that we can address that moving forward because it does look like we're probably standardizing the whole city.

607
01:10:52.206 --> 01:10:55.234
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if I'm about to spend 4 months deciphering blue, I'm going to go crazy.

608
01:10:55.587 --> 01:11:01.054
<v Eric Zimmerman>But, um, going to that slide, I have a question.

609
01:11:01.101 --> 01:11:04.387
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's really in Jonas's shop, and I guess I'm trying to understand.

610
01:11:04.467 --> 01:11:12.537
<v Eric Zimmerman>You've all heard me talk about deep concern about how we are set up with bureaus who have their independent financial and budget staff.

611
01:11:16.444 --> 01:11:23.480
<v Eric Zimmerman>And based upon this, it looks like— and we've always said that like the CFO's office is fairly small.

612
01:11:23.545 --> 01:11:29.167
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can I— help me out here, Jonas, in terms of what am I reading here in terms of FTE who directly work for you?

613
01:11:29.701 --> 01:11:35.421
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are there bureau folks who are represented in this 375 and you have a good half of that?

614
01:11:35.520 --> 01:11:35.993
<v Eric Zimmerman>What, what is this?

615
01:11:36.336 --> 01:11:37.395
<v Eric Zimmerman>Help me decipher this a bit.

616
01:11:37.460 --> 01:11:38.680
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, yeah, good question, Councilor.

617
01:11:38.744 --> 01:11:40.141
<v Jonas Biery>And we can certainly get the detailed data.

618
01:11:40.189 --> 01:11:41.506
<v Jonas Biery>I'm sure folks here might have it handy.

619
01:11:41.570 --> 01:11:49.487
<v Jonas Biery>But, um, so most of those staff, to be clear, while they're within the, the bureau called the Office of the CFO, most of those are in the Revenue Division.

620
01:11:49.760 --> 01:11:51.091
<v Jonas Biery>Um, the vast majority of those.

621
01:11:51.751 --> 01:12:06.086
<v Jonas Biery>Um, the one thing that I'd note that I think is a little wonky that you see going on here in that line is that in '24 prior— well, '24-'25, and for a couple years prior, um, that was the budget and finance service area, which included some folks that later moved to City Ops.

622
01:12:06.134 --> 01:12:14.395
<v Jonas Biery>And so that decline that you see happening in '25-'26, I believe, is just functionally moving those people to other parts of the organization out of that bureau.

623
01:12:14.621 --> 01:12:16.113
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks for the reminder on the revenue.

624
01:12:16.337 --> 01:12:17.235
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's making more sense.

625
01:12:17.283 --> 01:12:35.271
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, so this is also then this $375,000, which is the CSL as it's described here, is representative of time now It's unrelated to, or what could be proposed as part of the central core realignment issues and services, right?

626
01:12:36.139 --> 01:12:38.835
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is, if nothing changed, this is what it is.

627
01:12:38.962 --> 01:12:39.043
<v Raymond C. Lee>Okay.

628
01:12:39.108 --> 01:12:39.524
<v Raymond C. Lee>That's correct.

629
01:12:39.750 --> 01:12:40.167
<v Raymond C. Lee>That's correct.

630
01:12:40.617 --> 01:12:40.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

631
01:12:42.220 --> 01:13:09.023
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I'm a very big proponent of either articulating a dotted line relationship from finances to bureaus in terms of either CFO so, serves bureaus as a customer service agency, or bureau financial and budget staff very clearly understand that the Chief Financial Officer does dictate your work at the bureau level.

632
01:13:09.761 --> 01:13:14.648
<v Eric Zimmerman>Whatever that is, whether it's solid or dotted line, is very important, and it's not part of our culture.

633
01:13:15.181 --> 01:13:15.569
<v Eric Zimmerman>Mm-mm.

634
01:13:16.685 --> 01:13:27.475
<v Eric Zimmerman>The idea that there are some finance teams who think they work for their bureau director and not for the City of Portland is my most concerning thing as as we go into the budget, because I hope that we have self-corrected after last year.

635
01:13:28.243 --> 01:13:55.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if that was the case, if in the central core realignment we were to see perhaps a line— and this may not be your proposal, but if you were to say, I want, you know, 50% of the current people who do that job to actually work for the CFO now, and then I divvy them up as customer service agents out to the bureau to take care of their stuff, would I then see the FTE count in the CFO in this slide?

636
01:13:55.985 --> 01:14:01.365
<v Eric Zimmerman>It would presumably jump significantly because you would take on that as an FTE count at your level.

637
01:14:02.570 --> 01:14:03.470
<v Raymond C. Lee>That is correct.

638
01:14:03.935 --> 01:14:05.203
<v Raymond C. Lee>And what I would say too—.

639
01:14:05.220 --> 01:14:06.136
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not proposing it yet.

640
01:14:06.184 --> 01:14:10.198
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm gonna wait for your proposal, but I'm just trying to make sure I'm reading your data the right way here.

641
01:14:10.279 --> 01:14:10.551
<v Raymond C. Lee>Correct.

642
01:14:11.338 --> 01:14:12.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, sorry I cut you off.

643
01:14:12.688 --> 01:14:19.011
<v Raymond C. Lee>No, I would say one thing I would say in this, I've seen it in multiple organizations that I've worked in, Me too.

644
01:14:19.108 --> 01:14:26.673
<v Raymond C. Lee>As it relates to, you know, the departments or bureaus, for our instance, having some core staff.

645
01:14:26.801 --> 01:14:31.033
<v Raymond C. Lee>I started out my career in departments as the budget person in Dallas.

646
01:14:31.081 --> 01:14:45.779
<v Raymond C. Lee>Those large organizations where pieces are moving every day from a financial standpoint, having some staff there that understands the inner workings of what happens from a budgetary standpoint, a financial standpoint, are critical.

647
01:14:46.292 --> 01:15:04.099
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think what has broken for us in our organization over time is that reporting structure back to the central hub, budget office and CFO of our organization, and not let it stay siloed from the standpoint of ultimately what is the financial decision for the city.

648
01:15:04.195 --> 01:15:18.725
<v Raymond C. Lee>And I think with the new structure of government that we have, having one direct person at the lead of that organization from an administrative standpoint and having those centralized functions from HR, IT, purchasing, budget.

649
01:15:19.144 --> 01:15:25.597
<v Raymond C. Lee>It's going to take a little time for us, but I have no question that we will get there as an organization.

650
01:15:26.032 --> 01:15:32.662
<v Raymond C. Lee>We won't be having these same conversations, you know, 2 years from now or 3 years from now about what's happening.

651
01:15:33.161 --> 01:15:33.273
<v Dan Ryan>Right.

652
01:15:33.658 --> 01:15:34.317
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, thanks.

653
01:15:34.461 --> 01:15:35.569
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate it.

654
01:15:35.664 --> 01:15:45.338
<v Eric Zimmerman>As we go into this, it's just helpful to Um, uh, well, just to have an understanding, make sure I understand the baseline of what we're talking about.

655
01:15:45.403 --> 01:15:47.636
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so, uh, I've appreciated that.

656
01:15:48.038 --> 01:16:00.588
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, um, I, I will just say the— I think if my, my, uh, constituents were here, they would be making me circle the $5.8 shortfall in PIMO.

657
01:16:01.011 --> 01:16:01.367
<v Eric Zimmerman>Noted.

658
01:16:01.756 --> 01:16:06.024
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, so that is a, a deep concern in terms of of that and what they're delivering.

659
01:16:06.136 --> 01:16:07.146
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for the presentation.

660
01:16:07.805 --> 01:16:08.752
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

661
01:16:09.168 --> 01:16:11.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, unfortunately we are about 25 minutes over already.

662
01:16:12.457 --> 01:16:15.073
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have one last, it's not even a question, I'm just gonna put it out there.

663
01:16:16.404 --> 01:16:24.988
<v Jamie Dunphy>This body seems continually interested in understanding the difference between money from your area that goes out to FTE versus money that goes out to contracts.

664
01:16:25.469 --> 01:16:28.918
<v Jamie Dunphy>If we could get further clarification about that, always helpful.

665
01:16:30.185 --> 01:16:33.311
<v Jamie Dunphy>And with that, I'd like to— oh, Councilor Kanal.

666
01:16:33.408 --> 01:16:34.354
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll be very quick.

667
01:16:35.155 --> 01:16:37.703
<v Sameer Kanal>I had a thought triggered by a colleague's comment.

668
01:16:38.121 --> 01:16:45.447
<v Sameer Kanal>I would love to have some information on the long-term planning of how Portland Solutions becomes part of the permanent structure of the city.

669
01:16:45.752 --> 01:16:47.675
<v Sameer Kanal>If it becomes a service area, that's an answer.

670
01:16:47.851 --> 01:16:51.282
<v Sameer Kanal>If it becomes in other existing service areas, that's an answer.

671
01:16:51.363 --> 01:16:55.835
<v Sameer Kanal>But just something that isn't this structure built on our old form of government would be great.

672
01:16:56.171 --> 01:17:00.511
<v Sameer Kanal>PMO in particular is a good place to start on that.

673
01:17:00.592 --> 01:17:09.329
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a little— it's related to but a little different from the other 3, and I want to make sure that it's stable given what we're hearing from the same type of comments that Councilor Zimmerman referenced.

674
01:17:09.377 --> 01:17:09.716
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

675
01:17:11.405 --> 01:17:12.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

676
01:17:12.211 --> 01:17:12.662
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

677
01:17:13.579 --> 01:17:26.923
<v Mitch Green>Just briefly, as we go through these work sessions, and it's not specific to the material today, I just want to level set for the public following along and my colleagues that yes, we're considering an $8.6 billion budget, but I think we need to be thinking about what is the operating expenses of the budget.

678
01:17:27.533 --> 01:17:29.858
<v Mitch Green>That's much less than $8 billion.

679
01:17:30.997 --> 01:17:33.675
<v Mitch Green>It's, I think it's $4.3, somewhere around there.

680
01:17:34.283 --> 01:17:43.488
<v Mitch Green>And so when we think about whether we're spending too much and ignoring the revenue side completely, we need to compare it to our peer cities, and we're right in the middle of the pack.

681
01:17:44.081 --> 01:17:51.360
<v Mitch Green>So I hope we all keep that in mind, that there's only so far you can cut to the bone before you have to have real conversations about revenue strategy.

682
01:17:51.440 --> 01:17:51.537
<v Ruth Levine>Thank you.

683
01:17:55.265 --> 01:17:56.043
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

684
01:17:56.546 --> 01:17:58.574
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, with that, I'd like to move to our next part of our presentation.

685
01:18:03.804 --> 01:18:04.768
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much.

686
01:18:08.109 --> 01:18:08.599
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

687
01:18:10.721 --> 01:18:12.127
<v Tracy Warren>We're just getting our slides up.

688
01:18:24.493 --> 01:18:31.676
<v Jamie Dunphy>And as we are pulling these up, colleagues, again, I will note we are, we are over time already, um, and we have 2 more, uh, presentations ahead of us.

689
01:18:32.430 --> 01:18:37.466
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, the big one, the first being city, the core realignment, and then the second being, uh, public works.

690
01:18:37.643 --> 01:18:39.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>So let's keep it tight.

691
01:18:39.262 --> 01:18:39.551
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

692
01:18:40.930 --> 01:18:41.668
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you, Council.

693
01:18:42.487 --> 01:18:44.251
<v Tracy Warren>For the record, my name is Tracy Warren.

694
01:18:44.314 --> 01:18:46.929
<v Tracy Warren>I'm the Deputy City Administrator for City Operations.

695
01:18:47.521 --> 01:18:55.070
<v Tracy Warren>My understanding was that we had about 10 minutes for this portion, which is a basic overview of city operations, budget, and current service levels.

696
01:18:55.150 --> 01:19:03.756
<v Tracy Warren>I'll do my best to move us through that really quickly so that we can get to the meat of the presentation, which will talk about the core service realignment as the second phase.

697
01:19:05.135 --> 01:19:07.314
<v Tracy Warren>We'll start by reviewing the agenda.

698
01:19:08.436 --> 01:19:22.368
<v Tracy Warren>I appreciate the opportunity to share with you an overview of city operations, our current service level budget by bureau, and then a review of options and trade-offs related to reductions for any service level gaps.

699
01:19:23.680 --> 01:19:24.975
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

700
01:19:27.291 --> 01:19:53.666
<v Tracy Warren>City Operations brings together the city's internal service functions, including human resources, technology, fleet and facilities, budgeting, procurement, grants, security, community customer service with our 311 program, and accountability offices with our IPR, Independent Police Review Board— or Bureau, excuse me— and our Office of Police Accountability.

701
01:19:55.143 --> 01:20:00.890
<v Tracy Warren>These teams provide the operational backbone that allow the rest of the city to deliver services to Portlanders.

702
01:20:01.869 --> 01:20:13.104
<v Tracy Warren>They are a mix of different fund types managed by these programs, from general fund to grants to other funds that are based on cost recovery models.

703
01:20:14.425 --> 01:20:20.128
<v Tracy Warren>And they are responsible for helping to support and manage approximately $1 billion of the city's dollars.

704
01:20:20.814 --> 01:20:21.435
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

705
01:20:24.363 --> 01:20:30.036
<v Tracy Warren>This will be a common theme that you heard from other presentations and just earlier from the city administrator.

706
01:20:30.612 --> 01:20:37.595
<v Tracy Warren>City Operations provides many of the internal services that every bureau relies on to accomplish their mission-critical work.

707
01:20:38.347 --> 01:20:45.762
<v Tracy Warren>Because of that, reductions in these service areas require careful balancing to maintain core internal functions.

708
01:20:46.216 --> 01:20:58.112
<v Tracy Warren>Our approach prioritizes essential services while being transparent about the trade-offs, including potential impacts to service hours and administrative capacity to support the rest of the city.

709
01:20:58.951 --> 01:20:59.645
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

710
01:21:03.127 --> 01:21:06.224
<v Tracy Warren>This slide goes over program expenses by fund.

711
01:21:06.637 --> 01:21:12.125
<v Tracy Warren>This slide shows the city operations fund types and what's driving the cost increases.

712
01:21:12.301 --> 01:21:23.355
<v Tracy Warren>Much of the growth is tied to core operational needs, including fleet and facilities investments, higher health insurance claims, and technology vendor costs increasing.

713
01:21:24.094 --> 01:21:35.356
<v Tracy Warren>A large portion of spending, particularly in fire and police disability and retirement, is also non-discretionary under the city charter and has limited flexibility for reduction.

714
01:21:35.404 --> 01:21:35.533
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

715
01:21:36.579 --> 01:21:52.154
<v Tracy Warren>Which has limited where you'll see an opportunity for us to capture additional savings within the general fund and then our internal service funds as well as other fund sources.

716
01:21:52.283 --> 01:21:52.884
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

717
01:21:55.445 --> 01:21:58.496
<v Tracy Warren>This slide goes over the general fund.

718
01:21:58.835 --> 01:22:12.341
<v Tracy Warren>The overall change you see between physical years is largely driven by a shift in how general fund overhead was allocated in the first year between 2025, and then what we are anticipating in 2026.

719
01:22:13.256 --> 01:22:19.822
<v Tracy Warren>It was allocated— if you look, I think you'll see the biggest difference is in the human resources area.

720
01:22:20.046 --> 01:22:28.778
<v Tracy Warren>One of the things that was done is it was allocated as discretionary revenue, so it reflects differently structurally in accounting.

721
01:22:29.452 --> 01:22:40.858
<v Tracy Warren>Additionally, there was one-time investments that were made for class comp and also carryover is not included in the future year.

722
01:22:42.949 --> 01:22:54.155
<v Tracy Warren>Finally, prior to the Community-Based Police Accountability Board being seated, the Office of Police Accountability preemptively budgeted for an increase in personnel to help stand up that office.

723
01:22:54.413 --> 01:23:00.569
<v Tracy Warren>In the coming weeks, we hope to work with the board to understand how they'd like us to proceed with their budget development for the next fiscal year.

724
01:23:00.618 --> 01:23:01.389
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you, Deputy City Attorney Nancy Thorington.

725
01:23:03.500 --> 01:23:04.139
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

726
01:23:07.789 --> 01:23:11.167
<v Tracy Warren>This slide is related to the full-time equivalents.

727
01:23:11.685 --> 01:23:35.014
<v Tracy Warren>I'll start by saying there's a similar pattern in what you heard the city administrator talk about, which is that there's been a lot of shifting within our organization related to the new form of government, and there's been some moving around of what would be considered city operations with staff going from different parts of the organization into city operations to create the service area.

728
01:23:35.818 --> 01:23:42.425
<v Tracy Warren>This does not include any anticipated increases that we might see as a result of core realignment.

729
01:23:43.050 --> 01:23:45.456
<v Tracy Warren>Those decisions, as you know, have not been made yet.

730
01:23:45.520 --> 01:23:49.422
<v Tracy Warren>We are just in the process of developing concepts and sharing those with you all.

731
01:23:51.250 --> 01:23:51.904
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

732
01:23:58.210 --> 01:24:04.585
<v Tracy Warren>So we've moved into our new form of government, and we've worked to realign to the one-city model approach.

733
01:24:05.050 --> 01:24:06.976
<v Tracy Warren>City operation has been shifting a lot.

734
01:24:07.041 --> 01:24:08.005
<v Tracy Warren>I just went over that.

735
01:24:08.326 --> 01:24:18.313
<v Tracy Warren>This slide includes the 10 of the largest programs within city operations from a funding standpoint that's not related to the FTE alone.

736
01:24:19.243 --> 01:24:22.502
<v Tracy Warren>Overall, City Operations has roughly 50 programs.

737
01:24:23.257 --> 01:24:31.573
<v Tracy Warren>2 of the largest programs, Fire and Police Disability and Retirement and the Health Fund, are pass-through programs.

738
01:24:31.765 --> 01:24:34.881
<v Tracy Warren>So the money is collected and then it's distributed out.

739
01:24:36.005 --> 01:24:38.829
<v Tracy Warren>Additionally, there are several major projects underway.

740
01:24:38.911 --> 01:24:42.635
<v Tracy Warren>The transition of garage operations from Kirby to Cutter.

741
01:24:43.405 --> 01:24:49.319
<v Tracy Warren>This project will include improved workflows, more efficient maintenance operations, and customer service.

742
01:24:50.239 --> 01:25:03.985
<v Tracy Warren>Over the next few budget cycles, the city will need to make decisions to modernize our technology systems related to human resources and financial management as our systems continue to be outdated.

743
01:25:06.470 --> 01:25:06.792
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

744
01:25:11.025 --> 01:25:17.387
<v Tracy Warren>City Operations has a wide mix of revenue sources because it provides services across many areas of city government.

745
01:25:17.436 --> 01:25:22.244
<v Tracy Warren>I think this gets back to a comment that was made earlier from Councilor Kanal.

746
01:25:23.047 --> 01:25:35.314
<v Tracy Warren>Many of our programs operate on a cost recovery model, which means that as services are provided, they are then billed out to the bureaus who are receiving those services across the city.

747
01:25:35.813 --> 01:25:45.029
<v Tracy Warren>Additionally, we have a number of IAs for those services, which is interagency agreements where we are collecting money back for the services that are being provided.

748
01:25:46.212 --> 01:25:52.658
<v Tracy Warren>We also have service fees, taxes, and other funds such as transfers and reimbursements.

749
01:25:53.822 --> 01:26:03.748
<v Tracy Warren>Overall revenues are generally growing at about the rate of inflation, with tax revenue primarily coming from the dedicated FPD&R property tax levy.

750
01:26:05.595 --> 01:26:06.109
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

751
01:26:08.792 --> 01:26:10.849
<v Tracy Warren>This slide talks about the current service level gap.

752
01:26:12.077 --> 01:26:17.350
<v Tracy Warren>Highlighting the gap that we have in security in our PDX 311.

753
01:26:18.087 --> 01:26:24.899
<v Tracy Warren>You'll notice off to the side we also have BHR Communications, the City Budget Office, Grants Management, and Procurement.

754
01:26:26.100 --> 01:26:38.858
<v Tracy Warren>We're not solving for those gaps or providing potential solutions in this portion of the presentation because we are looking to reduce our overall current service level as part of the core service realignment.

755
01:26:39.403 --> 01:26:43.389
<v Tracy Warren>And so we will cover those gaps as part of that process.

756
01:26:45.090 --> 01:27:01.503
<v Tracy Warren>This slide highlights the demand for security, which as you all know, has increased significantly over the last fiscal year, which has driven up costs associated with that because we primarily use contracted services for security.

757
01:27:02.644 --> 01:27:06.889
<v Tracy Warren>We will need to close that gap or we will need to reduce the demand, right?

758
01:27:06.953 --> 01:27:10.243
<v Tracy Warren>So security is one of those things that when you need it, we need to be able to call upon it and make sure that they're available.

759
01:27:10.341 --> 01:27:22.070
<v Tracy Warren>And here's to support us, but that does come at a cost that we will have to figure out how to solve for as we move through the— this fiscal year and next fiscal year.

760
01:27:23.418 --> 01:27:38.233
<v Tracy Warren>PDX 311 is facing cost pressures from personnel increases and inflation, which could lead to reduced capacity and longer wait times for community who utilizes their services to help them navigate the city processes.

761
01:27:38.280 --> 01:27:38.425
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

762
01:27:40.036 --> 01:27:48.222
<v Tracy Warren>Overall, these gaps are largely driven by rising costs, with some addressed through operational adjustments and others through the realignment effort.

763
01:27:49.369 --> 01:27:50.118
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

764
01:27:53.466 --> 01:27:59.296
<v Tracy Warren>This slide offers some solutions that we have been evaluating.

765
01:28:00.207 --> 01:28:03.444
<v Tracy Warren>This is showing the 3 10% concepts.

766
01:28:04.293 --> 01:28:06.842
<v Tracy Warren>It also has a 5% concept.

767
01:28:06.939 --> 01:28:26.921
<v Tracy Warren>I apologize, it's not in the title there, but this includes, you know, $2.5 million for security, $1.5 million for PDX 311, $0.7 million for special appropriations, and then $1.9 million for the Bureau of Fleet and Facilities.

768
01:28:28.546 --> 01:28:29.497
<v Tracy Warren>Security.

769
01:28:29.592 --> 01:28:29.914
<v Tracy Warren>Yes.

770
01:28:30.336 --> 01:28:42.613
<v Tracy Warren>This is related to the demand in services, and so a need to increase either finances to support that or to decrease our needs related to that team.

771
01:28:43.333 --> 01:28:47.309
<v Tracy Warren>The PDX 311 is a reduction in customer service hours.

772
01:28:47.421 --> 01:28:58.545
<v Tracy Warren>What that would look like is that we would have reduced availability for folks to answer the phone for customers depending on the level of reduction that would be taken from that particular group.

773
01:28:59.364 --> 01:29:03.212
<v Tracy Warren>Or 10 would determine the level of reduced hours.

774
01:29:04.474 --> 01:29:19.565
<v Tracy Warren>Special appropriations would mean cuts to many of our grants that are not legally required or restricted for something in particular, which would mean less money for specific groups in the community.

775
01:29:20.631 --> 01:29:27.229
<v Tracy Warren>And then for Bureau of Fleet and Facilities, it would be reducing our footprint within the Portland building.

776
01:29:27.782 --> 01:29:34.393
<v Tracy Warren>We're currently renting the bulk of it, would be reducing our footprint within the Portland building.

777
01:29:34.440 --> 01:29:42.689
<v Tracy Warren>We currently rent space from the Water Bureau, which we pay at a different level for renting that space.

778
01:29:42.769 --> 01:29:50.247
<v Tracy Warren>And so this would be us moving out of that space into other space that is empty within the building and reducing our costs.

779
01:29:51.113 --> 01:30:01.666
<v Tracy Warren>And then some other ad hoc savings related to EMS Contracting dollars as well as reduced security for improved environment at a particular facility.

780
01:30:04.569 --> 01:30:05.296
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

781
01:30:08.587 --> 01:30:09.863
<v Tracy Warren>And so I moved through that pretty quickly.

782
01:30:10.121 --> 01:30:11.502
<v Tracy Warren>Questions related to this?

783
01:30:17.106 --> 01:30:17.543
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

784
01:30:18.094 --> 01:30:20.052
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal, start us off.

785
01:30:20.198 --> 01:30:22.319
<v Sameer Kanal>Go back to— I have questions on slides 7 and 11.

786
01:30:22.368 --> 01:30:23.824
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you go back to slide 7, please?

787
01:30:24.840 --> 01:30:25.996
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for this, by the way.

788
01:30:26.108 --> 01:30:27.199
<v Sameer Kanal>It's super helpful.

789
01:30:28.018 --> 01:30:40.055
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, while you're scrolling, I just want to say express support for continuing the levels of security we have on both sides of that, as well as, uh, 311, uh, who does really great work.

790
01:30:40.617 --> 01:30:54.837
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, on this slide, you, you brought up the, the increase, uh, in OCPA staffing, but I'll notice that the much larger increase is actually from last year to this current year, and it appears that most of that is in City Operations itself.

791
01:30:56.042 --> 01:30:58.610
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to that specifically?

792
01:30:59.413 --> 01:30:59.927
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, it's—.

793
01:31:00.119 --> 01:31:18.744
<v Tracy Warren>It is similar to the conversation that Chief Financial Officer Jonas Biery just had with you all, in that when we shifted folks out of the Budget and Finance service area, many of them landed between City Operations and the City Administrator's Office, which created an increase in staff.

794
01:31:19.342 --> 01:31:20.640
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks.

795
01:31:20.801 --> 01:31:27.496
<v Sameer Kanal>And then switching to slide 11, and I imagine I saw Councilor Clark's reaction at the same place mine was.

796
01:31:28.109 --> 01:31:43.055
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you walk through, I don't think the public necessarily knows how we have to rent space, that you rent space from the Water Bureau, now you're moving somewhere else as opposed to just the city has a building.

797
01:31:44.500 --> 01:31:49.050
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's one thing to say we're renting from a third party, Who owns a building.

798
01:31:49.389 --> 01:31:53.599
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we have the 1900 building we don't own, but we rent space there, right?

799
01:31:53.680 --> 01:31:54.131
<v Sameer Kanal>That's fine.

800
01:31:54.229 --> 01:32:02.503
<v Sameer Kanal>I would love to see that be reduced over time and the city either transition to owning buildings and land or just consolidating the space.

801
01:32:02.569 --> 01:32:04.542
<v Sameer Kanal>We don't necessarily need to spread out so much.

802
01:32:05.238 --> 01:32:13.621
<v Sameer Kanal>But within the Portland Building, which somebody in the city owns, the city owns it, but I imagine if I looked it up, it would say some specific bureau.

803
01:32:13.670 --> 01:32:13.717
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

804
01:32:15.688 --> 01:32:17.948
<v Sameer Kanal>How can you walk through how that's carved up?

805
01:32:18.908 --> 01:32:28.748
<v Sameer Kanal>Just, I think this is an important transparency piece for the public to understand that you might pay double if you rent from the Water Bureau here and you go over there, and that's because we're really helping shore up another bureau's budget.

806
01:32:29.085 --> 01:32:36.377
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is also why Councilor Dunphy, Council President Dunphy's desk might cost $25,000 to move, like 20 feet.

807
01:32:37.563 --> 01:32:38.908
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, happy to.

808
01:32:39.832 --> 01:32:43.833
<v Tracy Warren>Provide a very general response and then follow up with more specifics.

809
01:32:45.966 --> 01:32:52.822
<v Tracy Warren>The general response is that the Portland Building is managed and ran by the Bureau of Fleet and Facilities.

810
01:32:54.225 --> 01:33:06.344
<v Tracy Warren>And the Water Bureau, at the time that they did the remodel of the Portland Building, bought a floor, a floor or 2.

811
01:33:06.828 --> 01:33:07.359
<v Tracy Warren>2 floors.

812
01:33:08.261 --> 01:33:17.216
<v Tracy Warren>And they incurred debt services associated with purchasing those specific floors for their bureau.

813
01:33:17.699 --> 01:33:26.859
<v Tracy Warren>And so what that means is that when someone else occupies that space, they need to be able to recover their costs, which also include the debt services.

814
01:33:27.523 --> 01:33:31.418
<v Tracy Warren>And so yes, it's complicated.

815
01:33:31.725 --> 01:33:43.524
<v Tracy Warren>I acknowledge that we have a very complicated system of cost recovery across the city.

816
01:33:44.920 --> 01:33:54.833
<v Tracy Warren>And I have a much more detailed memo on my desk that I plan to send to council that will provide you with more information around the internal service funds.

817
01:33:55.587 --> 01:34:00.849
<v Tracy Warren>And then I would leave you with just a general acknowledgement that I recognize that we need to do something about it.

818
01:34:01.506 --> 01:34:03.402
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, and I want to be clear for anyone listening.

819
01:34:03.514 --> 01:34:09.356
<v Sameer Kanal>I imagine that there's nobody who still works at the city that was involved in setting up this process and the way we do things.

820
01:34:10.271 --> 01:34:12.069
<v Sameer Kanal>But if they are, I don't think they're in this room.

821
01:34:12.134 --> 01:34:15.055
<v Sameer Kanal>So I appreciate the explanation.

822
01:34:15.247 --> 01:34:17.671
<v Sameer Kanal>But that also leads to 2 other questions.

823
01:34:17.976 --> 01:34:34.326
<v Sameer Kanal>Does that mean that before that floor was rented, that part of your water bill would go to paying debt service on a floor of the Portland Building that the Water Bureau bought from Fleet and Facilities after the renovation?

824
01:34:35.868 --> 01:34:37.832
<v Tracy Warren>I would not garner to answer that.

825
01:34:37.962 --> 01:34:45.417
<v Tracy Warren>I would need to get that to you at a later time and confer with our Public Works service area to make sure that that's answered appropriately.

826
01:34:46.737 --> 01:34:47.413
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

827
01:34:48.429 --> 01:35:10.095
<v Sameer Kanal>While you're doing that, just to add one more kind of related question, I would love to know, and I imagine this is I know it's split up among thousands of actual humans that, that work at the city, but I'd love to know the rough estimate of FTE associated with processing the payments between bureaus, because that's an investment we make.

828
01:35:10.560 --> 01:35:16.322
<v Sameer Kanal>You know, 15 minutes to, to pay the invoice between a bureau to another bureau, 15 minutes to, to receive the payment.

829
01:35:16.722 --> 01:35:20.863
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm, I'm guessing that adds up to some number that's— if it's 5 FTE, that's not a big deal.

830
01:35:21.457 --> 01:35:26.072
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, but if it's more, then there may be a better use for those folks' time still within the city.

831
01:35:26.119 --> 01:35:34.131
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not talking about laying anybody off, but you know, I don't think anybody signed up to work at many of these bureaus to do something that different from the mission of the bureau.

832
01:35:34.676 --> 01:35:37.592
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'll leave it there.

833
01:35:37.721 --> 01:35:37.978
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

834
01:35:38.523 --> 01:35:39.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

835
01:35:39.740 --> 01:35:40.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

836
01:35:41.182 --> 01:35:42.032
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor President.

837
01:35:42.127 --> 01:35:52.453
<v Olivia Clark>Just to riff a little bit off of these comments, and thank you very much, I, um, It is a very confusing web of intergovernmental agreements and transfers and reimbursements.

838
01:35:52.518 --> 01:35:56.034
<v Olivia Clark>It's just a very strange web of very creative budgeting.

839
01:35:58.256 --> 01:36:01.090
<v Olivia Clark>And it's almost like a— Portland building sounds like a condominium.

840
01:36:01.717 --> 01:36:21.284
<v Olivia Clark>But I understand that over time we're going to simplify this, that this is really a vestige of the old form of government and that we're moving forward and we will simplify with CA's help, we will simplify this and get to the bottom of the interconnecting web.

841
01:36:21.686 --> 01:36:27.342
<v Olivia Clark>You mentioned that you're going to give us a memo on the ISF, the intergovernmental whatever it's called.

842
01:36:28.418 --> 01:36:36.966
<v Olivia Clark>I had questions about that, but I'm very guilty of assuming that it's ballooning and then, you know, beyond inflation and so forth.

843
01:36:37.015 --> 01:36:41.463
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm really interested in getting your memo to to, to better understand that.

844
01:36:41.528 --> 01:36:43.006
<v Olivia Clark>I, you know, I worked at the state level.

845
01:36:43.390 --> 01:36:48.079
<v Olivia Clark>I saw this, that kind of administrative cost spread out across all the different state agencies.

846
01:36:48.176 --> 01:36:53.682
<v Olivia Clark>I know this is a parallel to that, but I, I'm looking forward to getting your memo and wrapping my head around that.

847
01:36:54.132 --> 01:36:54.743
<v Olivia Clark>But thank you.

848
01:36:55.079 --> 01:36:57.729
<v Tracy Warren>Absolutely, Council President— or excuse me, Vice President.

849
01:36:58.372 --> 01:37:07.037
<v Tracy Warren>And it will be detailed with data related to the inflationary costs and how it has been over the last, I believe, 5 years.

850
01:37:07.296 --> 01:37:07.587
<v Olivia Clark>15.

851
01:37:07.796 --> 01:37:08.248
<v Angelita Morillo>15.

852
01:37:08.846 --> 01:37:09.703
<v Tracy Warren>15 years.

853
01:37:09.961 --> 01:37:10.591
<v Olivia Clark>15 years.

854
01:37:11.172 --> 01:37:14.239
<v Olivia Clark>But I am looking forward to how you're going to untangle this web too.

855
01:37:14.480 --> 01:37:14.963
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

856
01:37:15.945 --> 01:37:16.993
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

857
01:37:17.073 --> 01:37:17.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

858
01:37:19.328 --> 01:37:20.373
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

859
01:37:20.519 --> 01:37:26.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have 3 questions, 2 of which I don't need answers for today, but would appreciate in follow-up.

860
01:37:26.806 --> 01:37:33.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am wondering, looking at these options for closing gaps and the current service level gap that exist.

861
01:37:35.134 --> 01:38:08.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>On the security side, I'm wondering if that is being driven by the building security here or by security in other buildings across the city or by the security team who specifically work with the mayor and councilors and where those costs are coming from so that we can better understand, is this being driven by the need to have more Security at council meetings or other, other city buildings or events that we're having and how we might be able to control that moving forward.

862
01:38:09.106 --> 01:38:15.497
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am also wondering if we can see a breakdown of the types of calls that come into 311.

863
01:38:16.076 --> 01:38:26.411
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is this at this point calls for service because people have concerns with service that they're getting from some of our, our Public-facing bureaus?

864
01:38:26.587 --> 01:38:29.398
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are these calls for referrals for shelter services?

865
01:38:29.591 --> 01:38:31.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are these something completely different?

866
01:38:31.934 --> 01:38:36.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are these calls coming in that are then diverted to counselor offices?

867
01:38:36.287 --> 01:38:39.131
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What is it that we're talking about cutting if we cut hours there?

868
01:38:41.175 --> 01:38:43.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't need answers to either of those today.

869
01:38:43.599 --> 01:39:05.113
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What you might be able to answer today, and perhaps I actually need an answer from somebody else in the room at another time, is if you move forward with the fleet and facilities cut into the space that we are renting from the Water Bureau, does that mean that the Water Bureau is going to have a budget hole greater than what they are currently anticipating?

870
01:39:05.932 --> 01:39:14.266
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And at some point, I would like to understand how the Water Bureau is budgeting or not budgeting for that reality in your budget.

871
01:39:15.568 --> 01:39:19.818
<v Tracy Warren>Absolutely happy to answer that last component and then get back to you on the other 2.

872
01:39:21.014 --> 01:39:32.141
<v Tracy Warren>My understanding is that we've been working with the Water Bureau's finance folks to make sure that they're aware of the concept that we're floating so that they can include it as part of their planning.

873
01:39:33.899 --> 01:39:34.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for taking that step.

874
01:39:35.372 --> 01:39:38.720
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

875
01:39:39.497 --> 01:39:40.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have myself in the queue.

876
01:39:40.791 --> 01:39:41.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>I had 2 quick questions.

877
01:39:44.180 --> 01:39:48.202
<v Jamie Dunphy>One is broadly to the service realignment efforts that are undergoing.

878
01:39:49.869 --> 01:40:07.076
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's not— my understanding is that the service realignment efforts that we're doing are not cost savings, but rather enterprise efficiencies and getting past the operational silos that we've had, but obviously will involve some changes in budget and things like that.

879
01:40:07.286 --> 01:40:15.663
<v Jamie Dunphy>But from the presentation, I'm not really clear how we're envisioning these, those efficiencies, or how service— how it will be guiding service delivery.

880
01:40:16.403 --> 01:40:21.975
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, is there anything you can clarify about— oh, did I— am I jumping ahead?

881
01:40:22.442 --> 01:40:23.662
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh Jesus, never mind.

882
01:40:23.710 --> 01:40:24.930
<v Olivia Clark>It's okay, you're on top of it.

883
01:40:26.216 --> 01:40:27.581
<v Tracy Warren>I got lots of slides.

884
01:40:27.661 --> 01:40:28.399
<v Sameer Kanal>You got lots of slides.

885
01:40:28.463 --> 01:40:30.037
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, never mind.

886
01:40:30.953 --> 01:40:31.372
<v Raymond C. Lee>Um, great.

887
01:40:31.740 --> 01:40:31.885
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I'm—.

888
01:40:32.784 --> 01:40:33.684
<v Jamie Dunphy>I thought I was ahead.

889
01:40:33.765 --> 01:40:34.246
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, never mind.

890
01:40:34.327 --> 01:40:35.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm taking myself out of the queue.

891
01:40:35.113 --> 01:40:35.515
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Novick.

892
01:40:35.676 --> 01:40:36.382
<v Olivia Clark>Sorry.

893
01:40:36.961 --> 01:40:37.538
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, thank you.

894
01:40:37.684 --> 01:40:38.840
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

895
01:40:38.904 --> 01:40:45.779
<v Steve Novick>I just have to say that one of my earliest victories as a lawyer involved justifying the rent the federal government charges itself for its own buildings.

896
01:40:45.956 --> 01:40:55.368
<v Steve Novick>So it might sound like a silly idea, but I'm very emotionally attached to that concept, and I will fight any attempt to get rid of it.

897
01:40:55.753 --> 01:40:56.588
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

898
01:40:56.797 --> 01:41:00.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here's the problem.

899
01:41:02.427 --> 01:41:06.195
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, seeing nobody else in the queue, we can move to the next part of our presentation.

900
01:41:06.324 --> 01:41:07.677
<v Tracy Warren>All right, let's do it.

901
01:41:14.822 --> 01:41:19.738
<v Tracy Warren>I'm going to invite, uh, Chief Engagement Officer Amanda Garcia-Snell up.

902
01:41:36.742 --> 01:41:41.113
<v Tracy Warren>So now we're going to jump into the presentation related to core service realignment.

903
01:41:42.748 --> 01:41:52.045
<v Tracy Warren>I will kick us off by quickly reviewing some project background, walk through budget proposal options for human resources, procurement, and technology.

904
01:41:52.838 --> 01:42:03.752
<v Tracy Warren>And then I'll hand it over to Chief Engagement Officer Amanda Garcia-Snell, who will walk through initial options under consideration for engagement and equity.

905
01:42:04.439 --> 01:42:07.296
<v Tracy Warren>And then we'll do an overview and next steps.

906
01:42:11.199 --> 01:42:23.877
<v Tracy Warren>As you know, the realignment project was launched a little over a year ago with the goal of reorganizing our internal services to better align with our new form of government and live into the one-city model.

907
01:42:24.667 --> 01:42:39.248
<v Tracy Warren>The leaders of these areas were directed to create a new centralized model, work to improve systems and delivery, and to create a proposal that would generate a 20% reduction within the service area across the enterprise.

908
01:42:41.640 --> 01:42:42.447
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

909
01:42:45.064 --> 01:43:03.916
<v Tracy Warren>These 7 core services equate to around 1,000 staff across the city, which is more than 10% Because of the more internal nature of the work, this service can often feel invisible, but are critical to the success of the organization.

910
01:43:05.199 --> 01:43:10.832
<v Tracy Warren>I think of these services as the skeleton and nervous system of all the work the city performs.

911
01:43:13.355 --> 01:43:20.899
<v Tracy Warren>Every part of the enterprise relies on these teams for everything from hiring an employee to contracting for services to managing the city's finances.

912
01:43:21.286 --> 01:43:26.380
<v Tracy Warren>Fixing a laptop, issuing a press release, or engaging our community.

913
01:43:27.770 --> 01:43:28.092
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

914
01:43:31.425 --> 01:43:35.064
<v Tracy Warren>Our current structure was designed to support our old form of government.

915
01:43:36.170 --> 01:43:45.788
<v Tracy Warren>Walking into this project, it was no surprise that the staffing within the central bureaus was not proportionate to the level of service needed by the organization.

916
01:43:47.518 --> 01:43:57.752
<v Tracy Warren>Over the years, our internal services were often not factored into funding proposals for new programs and initiatives, despite being critical to the completion of the work.

917
01:43:59.149 --> 01:44:10.122
<v Tracy Warren>As a result, our customer bureaus were left to figure out how to get their unmet needs met to ensure that they were able to deliver on mission-critical work for the city.

918
01:44:11.277 --> 01:44:16.490
<v Tracy Warren>That resulted in them building their own teams within their bureaus to support their needs.

919
01:44:16.538 --> 01:44:16.715
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thank you.

920
01:44:21.313 --> 01:44:22.030
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

921
01:44:25.500 --> 01:44:37.146
<v Tracy Warren>The realignment process for each core service has been a little different, but they've all had some similar commonalities in the way that they approach the work.

922
01:44:37.323 --> 01:44:53.980
<v Tracy Warren>They started with some initial subgroups and surveying of the people who lead the work, the people who are responsible for delivering the work, and the people who receive the outcomes of the services that are provided.

923
01:44:54.528 --> 01:45:01.934
<v Tracy Warren>And they heard a lot of the similar things related to the services and a drive for demand.

924
01:45:03.867 --> 01:45:08.757
<v Tracy Warren>We took that information and we started to plan what a new model might look like.

925
01:45:09.872 --> 01:45:21.061
<v Tracy Warren>And how we might incorporate ourselves into the new form of government and create a one-city model replicated within our internal services.

926
01:45:21.815 --> 01:45:23.627
<v Tracy Warren>We started to develop proposals.

927
01:45:23.802 --> 01:45:35.488
<v Tracy Warren>We talked about those proposals with city leadership, with— in briefings with council, and with presentations to some of our bureau directors.

928
01:45:36.453 --> 01:45:37.130
<v Tracy Warren>And now here we are.

929
01:45:37.403 --> 01:45:45.588
<v Tracy Warren>We're at council talking about the next steps of the process and giving you all some options as we move into budget development for consideration.

930
01:45:47.109 --> 01:45:48.426
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

931
01:45:50.983 --> 01:45:51.641
<v Tracy Warren>What we learned.

932
01:45:51.979 --> 01:45:53.024
<v Tracy Warren>It's complicated.

933
01:45:53.650 --> 01:46:12.636
<v Tracy Warren>You're talking about moving around a large portion of our workforce, which requires a large amount of planning and thought to ensure that we are not breaking materially critical systems that people rely on to carry out their day-to-day jobs.

934
01:46:13.389 --> 01:46:20.055
<v Tracy Warren>What that meant is that it took a little bit more time than I think was expected.

935
01:46:20.198 --> 01:46:28.498
<v Tracy Warren>It also means that we've discovered areas within the core services that still need more time.

936
01:46:29.742 --> 01:46:34.841
<v Tracy Warren>Or likely a reduced expectation around what's accomplishable.

937
01:46:35.131 --> 01:46:37.858
<v Tracy Warren>One of those, an example, is budget and finance.

938
01:46:38.511 --> 01:46:42.650
<v Tracy Warren>You will not see a proposal in here today related to budget and finance.

939
01:46:42.716 --> 01:46:49.615
<v Tracy Warren>And the reason for that is because they've been incredibly busy with helping to support the budget development process.

940
01:46:50.293 --> 01:46:55.555
<v Tracy Warren>And we need to make sure that they are able to deliver services during this critical time.

941
01:46:55.636 --> 01:46:58.453
<v Tracy Warren>That does not mean that no work is happening related to the core realignment.

942
01:46:58.505 --> 01:46:58.555
<v Tracy Warren>Yes.

943
01:46:59.467 --> 01:47:03.091
<v Tracy Warren>It's just not ready to move forward in this forum yet.

944
01:47:11.130 --> 01:47:21.963
<v Tracy Warren>I'm going to start with talking about human resources, but I want to give a little bit of a framework for how we're going to approach all of the slides today so that you know what to expect.

945
01:47:23.635 --> 01:47:26.657
<v Tracy Warren>We're going to start with an overview of the structure for each of the services.

946
01:47:26.979 --> 01:47:31.055
<v Tracy Warren>We're going to talk about impacts of a 20% reduction.

947
01:47:31.488 --> 01:47:45.868
<v Tracy Warren>We're going to talk about the risks associated with a 20% reduction that we heard from folks, and then we're going to provide you with an alternative reduction plan that mitigates some of the risks but not all of the risks.

948
01:47:46.926 --> 01:47:53.720
<v Tracy Warren>The goal is to keep us moving forward to a realigned stage while also helping to support the cost-saving measures thank you.

949
01:47:53.720 --> 01:47:53.720
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

950
01:47:53.720 --> 01:47:56.439
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate the opportunity to be here today and to share with council members the information that was requested of us.

951
01:47:56.439 --> 01:48:02.460
<v Tracy Warren>Additionally, I'd like to make it clear that this presentation is very high level.

952
01:48:02.460 --> 01:48:09.279
<v Tracy Warren>It does not get into the specifics of individual, individual positions or personnel.

953
01:48:09.279 --> 01:48:31.876
<v Tracy Warren>We still have decisions that need to be made related to that, and once those decisions are made, we want to have the opportunity to talk directly with any persons who are impacted by those changes before broadcasting now I'll start on the Bureau of Human Resources.

954
01:48:32.760 --> 01:48:47.416
<v Tracy Warren>Through this project, we identified approximately 190 staff who perform human resources work across the enterprise, and that we would have roughly a $6.4 million cut target to achieve a 20% reduction.

955
01:48:47.480 --> 01:48:48.157
<v Tracy Warren>Councilmember Herbold.

956
01:48:56.615 --> 01:48:59.243
<v Tracy Warren>Here is a future structure outline.

957
01:48:59.340 --> 01:49:18.005
<v Tracy Warren>You will see this as a common theme throughout all of the different service functions that we have designed in a way that there is a core service function that is mostly driven by governance, compliance, and other activities that have citywide impact.

958
01:49:18.069 --> 01:49:22.395
<v Tracy Warren>We are in fact pushing information out to embedded services in Teams.

959
01:49:23.389 --> 01:49:32.649
<v Tracy Warren>The embedded services in Teams are designed to leverage bureau-specific expertise to meet service area needs in alignment with standards, practices, and processes.

960
01:49:33.644 --> 01:49:39.667
<v Tracy Warren>The activities are housed here, require frequent collaboration with the customer.

961
01:49:41.094 --> 01:49:52.918
<v Tracy Warren>And then lastly, we, we have in different areas, you'll see like a yellow bucket that slightly different between each of the different functions that house something that's unique to that central function.

962
01:49:54.237 --> 01:50:11.809
<v Tracy Warren>One of the things that is common is that even though there are embedded services who will be close to the customers providing them support, they will have central reporting relationships and central accountability for the outcomes and the processes that they engage in.

963
01:50:13.984 --> 01:50:14.604
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

964
01:50:18.750 --> 01:50:22.989
<v Tracy Warren>What you see in front of you is the 20% reduction plan scenario.

965
01:50:23.296 --> 01:50:28.565
<v Tracy Warren>This takes the total footprint from 190 staff today to 153.

966
01:50:29.983 --> 01:50:33.975
<v Tracy Warren>That results in a net 37 FTE reduction.

967
01:50:35.606 --> 01:50:41.788
<v Tracy Warren>When you see the core, that is referring to what is currently the central bureau providing that service.

968
01:50:43.530 --> 01:50:53.913
<v Tracy Warren>City operations are people who are doing those services within the city operations service area, and then so on and so forth by the other service areas.

969
01:50:55.470 --> 01:51:09.253
<v Tracy Warren>What you'll see as a note is that there's technically 63 cuts, but we are reclassing 26 of the positions in this proposal so that we can continue to utilize them in the new model.

970
01:51:09.302 --> 01:51:09.416
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

971
01:51:10.210 --> 01:51:14.654
<v Tracy Warren>But doing slightly different work and classified in a consistent way.

972
01:51:16.609 --> 01:51:23.034
<v Tracy Warren>This reduction scenario would net a $6.4 million savings per year.

973
01:51:27.487 --> 01:51:29.088
<v Tracy Warren>Risk to address.

974
01:51:29.251 --> 01:51:46.938
<v Tracy Warren>So as we introduce the 20% reduction plan to city leadership DCAs, and bureau directors, they highlighted for us areas that they saw could be critical points of failure as we move forward in the process.

975
01:51:47.934 --> 01:51:54.501
<v Tracy Warren>And so we spent a lot of time with them helping to understand ways in which we could mitigate that.

976
01:51:54.581 --> 01:52:11.416
<v Tracy Warren>Were there things that we could do with training, with shifting where we took the cuts, with providing additional tools or support to help make sure that we're moving forward in a way that we could still deliver the services that folks depend on.

977
01:52:13.970 --> 01:52:14.592
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

978
01:52:17.402 --> 01:52:23.605
<v Tracy Warren>We took all of that feedback and we came up with a revised reduction plan that mitigated that risk.

979
01:52:24.167 --> 01:52:35.305
<v Tracy Warren>Some of the key areas specific to human resources that were identified as risks was safety training for bureau-specific work that is performed.

980
01:52:36.320 --> 01:52:45.332
<v Tracy Warren>In our 20% reduction plan, we were down to one trainer who would have to support all citywide trainings related to safety.

981
01:52:46.801 --> 01:52:56.005
<v Tracy Warren>And we would also have a need to figure out a way to track all of that specialized safety training and certification.

982
01:52:56.936 --> 01:52:57.515
<v Tracy Warren>In a system.

983
01:52:57.692 --> 01:53:07.814
<v Tracy Warren>Our current learning management system is not able to track that information, and we are exploring ways that we might be able to improve that in the future.

984
01:53:08.184 --> 01:53:17.980
<v Tracy Warren>But for now, we need to rely on the people who are doing that work to make sure that the folks are trained on the best safety protocols and also are able to track the information.

985
01:53:18.640 --> 01:53:24.822
<v Tracy Warren>Additionally, we also received feedback related to timekeeping and payroll.

986
01:53:24.871 --> 01:53:24.936
<v Tracy Warren>Yes.

987
01:53:26.088 --> 01:53:34.565
<v Tracy Warren>Many of the positions are responsible for doing manual entry for folks who are in the field into the time system.

988
01:53:35.640 --> 01:53:46.317
<v Tracy Warren>Part of, you know, part of the work that the Bureau of Human Resources has been doing is looking at ways that they could improve the timekeeping and payroll system.

989
01:53:47.457 --> 01:53:51.438
<v Tracy Warren>But that takes an investment and more time to map that out and plan.

990
01:53:51.502 --> 01:53:51.679
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

991
01:53:52.256 --> 01:54:00.011
<v Tracy Warren>And in the interim, we need to have the people who are doing that work to ensure that we are able to pay people appropriately.

992
01:54:00.828 --> 01:54:08.649
<v Tracy Warren>If we have errors in timekeeping and payroll, that increases costs, which is the opposite of what we are trying to achieve here.

993
01:54:10.076 --> 01:54:16.662
<v Tracy Warren>So this reduced plan would go from 190 today to 164 FTE in the future.

994
01:54:16.869 --> 01:54:25.737
<v Tracy Warren>It would be a 26% reduction, and you would see about a $4.4 million per year savings.

995
01:54:30.284 --> 01:54:36.631
<v Tracy Warren>This gives a high-level view of the 14% reduction for workforce impacts.

996
01:54:36.761 --> 01:54:40.247
<v Tracy Warren>This talks about managers currently to future.

997
01:54:40.796 --> 01:54:44.396
<v Tracy Warren>You'll see that we will be going from 27 managers to 20 managers.

998
01:54:45.237 --> 01:54:49.055
<v Tracy Warren>Creating a 1 to 8 span of control for the human resources function.

999
01:54:49.904 --> 01:54:58.648
<v Tracy Warren>You will also note that there is a large portion of reductions with the City of Portland Professional Workers Group.

1000
01:54:59.996 --> 01:55:06.396
<v Tracy Warren>That is the largest representation for folks who do this work at the city.

1001
01:55:07.069 --> 01:55:11.208
<v Tracy Warren>And so because this is the largest group, that's where you're seeing the most reductions.

1002
01:55:14.337 --> 01:55:14.971
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

1003
01:55:20.329 --> 01:55:21.403
<v Tracy Warren>Now I'll talk about procurement.

1004
01:55:21.648 --> 01:55:23.583
<v Tracy Warren>Procurement follows a similar flow.

1005
01:55:26.229 --> 01:55:34.345
<v Tracy Warren>Procurement today shows 79 staff across the enterprise and a $2.7 million cut to reach 20%.

1006
01:55:34.412 --> 01:55:34.795
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

1007
01:55:35.475 --> 01:55:36.539
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you, Deputy City Attorney.

1008
01:55:37.829 --> 01:55:39.448
<v Tracy Warren>It's organized in a similar way.

1009
01:55:40.443 --> 01:55:46.697
<v Tracy Warren>One thing I would point out is that you'll notice grants listed as a bucket within procurement.

1010
01:55:47.177 --> 01:55:53.416
<v Tracy Warren>As part of the realignment process, we are looking to combine grants management with the procurement office.

1011
01:55:54.328 --> 01:56:03.997
<v Tracy Warren>They already work very closely together on a lot of items, and it makes sense to have them combined so that there's better flow and efficiency between those 2 groups.

1012
01:56:04.110 --> 01:56:04.367
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

1013
01:56:08.752 --> 01:56:09.537
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

1014
01:56:14.600 --> 01:56:18.069
<v Tracy Warren>This represents a 20% reduction plan scenario.

1015
01:56:18.824 --> 01:56:23.356
<v Tracy Warren>You'll see the staffing from 79 today to a future of 67.

1016
01:56:23.630 --> 01:56:31.206
<v Tracy Warren>That represents 12 FTE reductions with a $2.7 million savings per year.

1017
01:56:31.896 --> 01:56:49.268
<v Tracy Warren>One thing that I will note that I didn't note the first time around, but what you will see for human resources and procurement and then later on in engagement and equity is that most of these groups do not have funding sources outside of FTE.

1018
01:56:49.364 --> 01:56:56.274
<v Tracy Warren>So when you're talking about making reductions within those programs, it comes at personnel.

1019
01:56:59.454 --> 01:57:00.167
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

1020
01:57:02.707 --> 01:57:08.130
<v Tracy Warren>We heard a lot of concern about cuts to procurement.

1021
01:57:09.488 --> 01:57:23.115
<v Tracy Warren>In a 20% reduction, there would be impacts to support for capital project contracts and administration, which carries hefty liability from a cost and service delivery standpoint, most notably in our public works thank you.

1022
01:57:23.163 --> 01:57:27.869
<v Tracy Warren>So the City of Portland's capital projects are a large service area that makes up the majority of our capital project contracts.

1023
01:57:28.737 --> 01:57:42.051
<v Tracy Warren>They were concerned with continued delays and the ability for them to be able to move their capital projects through the contracting process quickly, which they felt would result in increased costs on the back end.

1024
01:57:42.404 --> 01:57:58.856
<v Tracy Warren>We did our best to mitigate some of that risk, but we're not able to fully mitigate that risk without next slide, please.

1025
01:58:02.279 --> 01:58:13.501
<v Tracy Warren>This 12% reduction plan is a reduced reduction plan that takes into consideration the risks that I just spoke about with Public Works and the capital projects contracting.

1026
01:58:15.778 --> 01:58:21.498
<v Tracy Warren>So this would take 6 FTE net reduction.

1027
01:58:21.546 --> 01:58:30.953
<v Tracy Warren>It would go from 79 today to 73 in the future, and it would allow for a $1.9 million per year savings.

1028
01:58:32.331 --> 01:58:49.115
<v Tracy Warren>One of the other things that it would allow for us to do is be able to phase in moving particular areas within the procurement space to ensure that we have the framework set and ready so that we don't delay services to our customers.

1029
01:58:51.158 --> 01:58:53.368
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

1030
01:58:54.112 --> 01:58:57.177
<v Tracy Warren>This shows the 12% reduction impacts.

1031
01:58:58.770 --> 01:59:06.192
<v Tracy Warren>You will have from 15 managers today to 12 managers in the future, which would give you a 1 to 6 span of control.

1032
01:59:07.318 --> 01:59:14.488
<v Tracy Warren>The majority of the cuts next slide.

1033
01:59:16.671 --> 01:59:18.578
<v Tracy Warren>Now we'll talk about technology services.

1034
01:59:20.020 --> 01:59:34.731
<v Tracy Warren>With approximately 470— 407 staff across the enterprise performing related work, what is unique about technology scenarios is that they have been able to approach this reduction exercise from both a technology perspective and a cost perspective.

1035
01:59:34.862 --> 01:59:35.024
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

1036
01:59:35.661 --> 01:59:48.025
<v Tracy Warren>Reduction in personnel as well as a reduction in non-personnel savings through efficiencies in the way that we utilize technology and our technology footprint.

1037
01:59:48.577 --> 01:59:49.192
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

1038
01:59:53.192 --> 02:00:03.796
<v Tracy Warren>One element of technology services org chart that I would flag for you is that they are keeping some of the groups within customer bureaus.

1039
02:00:04.768 --> 02:00:11.332
<v Tracy Warren>And spending more time to figure out and plan for movement of those groups.

1040
02:00:11.380 --> 02:00:26.015
<v Tracy Warren>And the reason why is because those folks are responsible for highly sensitive systems and programs, and moving them too quickly without making sure that we have a thoughtful plan in place could lead to system failures.

1041
02:00:26.689 --> 02:00:30.076
<v Tracy Warren>An example of that is SCADA, and I had to look this up.

1042
02:00:30.125 --> 02:00:30.349
<v Tracy Warren>What is SCADA?

1043
02:00:31.201 --> 02:00:34.974
<v Tracy Warren>But it's supervisory control and data acquisition.

1044
02:00:35.652 --> 02:00:44.895
<v Tracy Warren>And so what it does is it allows for folks to manage things like the water treatment plant from technology.

1045
02:00:45.960 --> 02:00:57.127
<v Tracy Warren>If we move people who are highly specialized in that area too quickly, there is a risk that there might be a failure in that system, and we don't want that, right?

1046
02:00:57.207 --> 02:01:07.262
<v Tracy Warren>So we want to take our time there and part of this plan is to ensure that we take a phased approach so that we can take our time and reduce any type of critical error.

1047
02:01:09.100 --> 02:01:11.198
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

1048
02:01:14.421 --> 02:01:24.226
<v Tracy Warren>The 20% reduction plan scenario for the Bureau of Technology Services goes from 407 staff today to 355 in the future.

1049
02:01:25.501 --> 02:01:28.967
<v Tracy Warren>You will see a large portion of those cuts being taken from public works.

1050
02:01:29.032 --> 02:01:29.354
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

1051
02:01:32.122 --> 02:01:35.157
<v Tracy Warren>This has been a common theme throughout the presentation.

1052
02:01:35.270 --> 02:01:36.997
<v Tracy Warren>I think it will continue to be a common theme.

1053
02:01:37.061 --> 02:01:45.801
<v Tracy Warren>The reason for that is that they do have the largest group, the Public Works service area does have the largest group of city employees.

1054
02:01:46.621 --> 02:01:53.010
<v Tracy Warren>They also have had the ability to build up their functions to help support where their unmet needs have been.

1055
02:01:55.060 --> 02:01:59.921
<v Tracy Warren>There's a 52 FTE net reduction.

1056
02:02:01.810 --> 02:02:07.045
<v Tracy Warren>Overall, with a 20% reduction plan, there would be $16.2 million savings.

1057
02:02:08.212 --> 02:02:14.220
<v Tracy Warren>53% Of that would be in personnel, and then 47% would be outside of personnel.

1058
02:02:15.470 --> 02:02:16.600
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

1059
02:02:17.215 --> 02:02:25.400
<v Tracy Warren>I'll talk a little bit about the risks that were identified, and then I'll talk to you a little bit more about the non-personnel reductions.

1060
02:02:26.939 --> 02:02:41.051
<v Tracy Warren>So this level of reduction would force technology services to limit its focus to maintenance, security, and critical systems with reduced capacity for advancing new technology to support the city in advancing its work.

1061
02:02:42.076 --> 02:02:49.336
<v Tracy Warren>We would anticipate more downtime for critical patches and upgrades and less capacity for documentation and cross-training.

1062
02:02:50.904 --> 02:02:51.114
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

1063
02:02:51.180 --> 02:02:51.324
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

1064
02:02:54.118 --> 02:02:58.034
<v Tracy Warren>This is a 17% reduction plan scenario.

1065
02:02:58.454 --> 02:03:12.500
<v Tracy Warren>This eliminates less personnel and also takes some of the cost savings that we were anticipating and allows— that is non-personnel— and allows us to space that out over more time.

1066
02:03:13.493 --> 02:03:29.507
<v Tracy Warren>It also allows us to make some reinvestments in technology that will help drive support for the other areas that are realigning, as well as support within technology that's happening within the bureaus.

1067
02:03:30.261 --> 02:03:43.458
<v Tracy Warren>So that would result in 45 FTE net, a $13.6 million per year savings, 47% coming from personnel and 53% coming from other.

1068
02:03:45.465 --> 02:03:46.076
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

1069
02:03:48.744 --> 02:03:54.487
<v Tracy Warren>Now we have an extremely wordy chart that gives you all the details.

1070
02:03:54.534 --> 02:03:59.612
<v Tracy Warren>I'm going to keep it high level to keep us moving so that you all have time to ask questions.

1071
02:04:00.355 --> 02:04:09.328
<v Tracy Warren>But this chart really outlines the different components of the technology non-personnel reductions that we were looking to achieve.

1072
02:04:09.408 --> 02:04:16.354
<v Tracy Warren>And then We highlighted low, medium, high, and very high risk areas.

1073
02:04:16.851 --> 02:04:25.818
<v Tracy Warren>We have already mitigated some of the areas of risk and have removed them from this chart, from the 20% reduction.

1074
02:04:25.865 --> 02:04:59.771
<v Tracy Warren>Some of those include taking our time with some of the technology rationalization projects, which is a project that is moving from, I believe, 6,000-ish applications and softwares that are managed by our technology services group and reducing them so that we are using more common applications and software and tools across the city so that we're not paying for a bunch of different things and we're not maintaining and helping to support a bunch of different things.

1075
02:05:01.814 --> 02:05:11.358
<v Tracy Warren>Additionally, I would draw your attention to the first item, which is low, and that's the savings from technology rationalization achieved today.

1076
02:05:11.599 --> 02:05:18.487
<v Tracy Warren>I'd like to call out that we have already achieved $2.7 million in this fiscal year related to that project.

1077
02:05:18.599 --> 02:05:27.921
<v Tracy Warren>So the team has been working diligently to make sure that they are trying to reach savings as quickly as possible within those areas.

1078
02:05:30.333 --> 02:05:31.118
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

1079
02:05:32.929 --> 02:05:40.810
<v Tracy Warren>This goes into a little bit more description related to the 17% reduction in the mitigation and reinvestment.

1080
02:05:41.149 --> 02:05:54.595
<v Tracy Warren>This really talks about adding back FTE that would be cut in the 20% reduction to help support the change efforts that will be needed across these different areas that we're looking to achieve savings.

1081
02:05:56.309 --> 02:05:59.203
<v Tracy Warren>It would increase information security.

1082
02:05:59.782 --> 02:06:09.739
<v Tracy Warren>It would provide for a citywide Microsoft product owner who would help us to transition to more Microsoft products and help folks be ready for that change.

1083
02:06:10.605 --> 02:06:18.591
<v Tracy Warren>And then we would also add someone who would be supporting citywide ServiceNow, which is a ticketing system.

1084
02:06:18.801 --> 02:06:27.556
<v Tracy Warren>And the goal would be to help us utilize that ticketing system more effectively across next slide.

1085
02:06:30.630 --> 02:06:35.688
<v Tracy Warren>This slide provides an overview of the workforce impacts, again showing a similar view.

1086
02:06:36.186 --> 02:06:41.055
<v Tracy Warren>It's going from 59 managers today to 45 in the future.

1087
02:06:42.113 --> 02:06:53.346
<v Tracy Warren>You would see a net reduction of 10 supervisors, with some of those positions being converted to non-represented or non-supervisory and represented by a union.

1088
02:06:54.970 --> 02:07:02.478
<v Tracy Warren>It would make the span of control for technology services 1 to 8, and it includes 26 vacancies.

1089
02:07:06.957 --> 02:07:13.453
<v Tracy Warren>Now I'm going to turn it over to Amanda Garcia-Snell to walk us through engagement and equity.

1090
02:07:14.979 --> 02:07:15.320
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thanks.

1091
02:07:15.451 --> 02:07:18.067
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So, uh, for the record, Amanda Garcia-Snell.

1092
02:07:18.701 --> 02:07:27.582
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The engagement and equity realignments are under the same directive and are following similar processes as the previous alignments that were just mentioned.

1093
02:07:28.015 --> 02:07:36.148
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>But there are some distinct differences that have created very dynamic elements in the process, and I'll speak to some of those as I move through the slides.

1094
02:07:37.859 --> 02:07:51.625
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So we believe that there are about 64 staff conducting engagement, community engagement across the organization today, costing about $9.3 million which would make the 20% cut target $1.8 million.

1095
02:07:52.521 --> 02:07:53.226
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

1096
02:07:53.996 --> 02:08:01.511
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So one of the first— in the beginning, one of the first challenges we discovered is that there is no shared definition of community engagement.

1097
02:08:01.975 --> 02:08:04.170
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And so we have that now.

1098
02:08:04.618 --> 02:08:23.935
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And in the future state structure, when we say conduct community engagement, it would really be with this connection to pathways to participation that is laid out here in the core services the central team would be Civic Life, and that's where Civic Life would really morph into a strategic engagement team.

1099
02:08:24.529 --> 02:08:40.027
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And then the embedded services would be staff that are still in the service area level, and in some instances in bureaus, to really focus on some of that subject matter expertise related to engagement in those areas.

1100
02:08:41.436 --> 02:08:46.215
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>As with the other alignments, they would still be incorporated into a larger organizational structure.

1101
02:08:47.869 --> 02:08:48.738
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

1102
02:08:50.070 --> 02:09:01.569
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So in the 20% reduction plan scenario, we would likely— that would likely result in a net reduction of 10 FTE, bringing the total staff down to 54.

1103
02:09:02.261 --> 02:09:13.037
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>This distribution of staff across service areas, it really showcases where there are more existing vacancies as well as areas where we believe we can combine some functions.

1104
02:09:14.207 --> 02:09:20.203
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And eliminate or minimize some— it would mean that we would have to eliminate some comprehensive practices.

1105
02:09:21.037 --> 02:09:34.551
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>One of the challenges, and I'll mention this in the risks as well, but we— because there is no community engagement job family, it was very challenging and time-consuming to determine who actually works in engagement across the city.

1106
02:09:35.127 --> 02:09:39.800
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>That was, of course, aggravated by the lack of a definition and common understanding of what that work does.

1107
02:09:42.728 --> 02:09:45.212
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And let's see, just want to make sure that I'm capturing here.

1108
02:09:45.358 --> 02:09:46.390
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Okay, next slide, please.

1109
02:09:47.229 --> 02:10:16.273
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So some of those risks, um, in addition to this job family and just, um, wanting to really make sure that we have, uh, the full, uh, universe of engagement professionals and really, um, wanting to take the time to make sure we understand that additional, uh, risks of that 20% that really came around later as we had many of those conversations is that that would not allow for any capacity to have any employee engagement.

1110
02:10:16.578 --> 02:10:30.509
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And as we continue to go through these ongoing transitions and change management needs, not having anyone to really support employee engagement has created a burden on other areas of staffing, in particular communications.

1111
02:10:31.248 --> 02:10:32.891
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>As they move to address that.

1112
02:10:34.567 --> 02:10:48.958
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Additionally, the 20%, while we would still be able to maintain the legal and regulatory engagement requirements, it doesn't allow for the spaciousness to really look at comprehensive engagement, which impacts equitable engagement.

1113
02:10:50.158 --> 02:10:50.872
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

1114
02:10:52.645 --> 02:11:16.537
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So this proposal of a 14% reduction plan would allow us to have that capacity for internal engagement, but more specifically, meet those minimum requirements as well as continue to grow and strengthen capacity across the organization to provide equitable engagement practices in a shared— with a shared definition and shared understanding of what that means.

1115
02:11:19.246 --> 02:11:20.439
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

1116
02:11:21.698 --> 02:11:23.552
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So, oh, actually, could you go back one?

1117
02:11:23.601 --> 02:11:24.472
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>I forgot to mention one thing.

1118
02:11:24.828 --> 02:11:29.604
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So the distribution, again, this is really based on vacancies.

1119
02:11:29.654 --> 02:11:38.417
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We looked at vacancies first across the organization and then looked at places where we might be able to combine some services but still maintain those functions.

1120
02:11:39.095 --> 02:11:39.851
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Okay, next slide.

1121
02:11:42.194 --> 02:11:54.578
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So in this distribution, there are very— there are not very many supervisor or manager classifications in this larger universe of community engagement professionals across the organization.

1122
02:11:54.658 --> 02:11:58.682
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>They're primarily in the analyst and coordinator classification series.

1123
02:11:59.685 --> 02:12:08.287
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And so we would really look at how to structure that so that we would at least have this 1 to 8 span of control.

1124
02:12:09.949 --> 02:12:10.547
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

1125
02:12:13.170 --> 02:12:27.686
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So with equity, equity, similar challenges as I mentioned with engagement in terms of the delay and being able to really get to this full 20% realization.

1126
02:12:27.818 --> 02:12:27.948
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thank you.

1127
02:12:28.804 --> 02:12:38.162
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Additionally, without the— with a vacant Chief Equity Officer, there's really no one to clearly lead and inform this work across the organization.

1128
02:12:38.595 --> 02:12:49.158
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>That's not to minimize the expertise of staff that participated in this process at different points, but that definitely did create some delays in how we look at this.

1129
02:12:49.271 --> 02:12:56.859
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So we believe there to be 43 staff today, and that would mean the cut target is which costs about $5 million.

1130
02:12:56.907 --> 02:12:59.136
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And so the cut target would be nearly $1 million.

1131
02:13:00.380 --> 02:13:00.832
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide.

1132
02:13:03.466 --> 02:13:18.402
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So this structure is based on a few things, but most recently the city had hired a consultant to really help us determine capacity and core functions and really look at those core foundational services.

1133
02:13:18.498 --> 02:13:25.173
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And so that's what's laid out here, and it would be similar to engagement, but the central team, of course, would be the Office of Equity and Human Rights.

1134
02:13:27.095 --> 02:13:34.729
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And then again, there would be that structural organizational reporting structure that all leads up to that Chief Equity Officer.

1135
02:13:37.237 --> 02:13:37.993
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide.

1136
02:13:40.634 --> 02:13:46.365
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So really, what I'm going to show today is not a 20% reduction scenario.

1137
02:13:46.430 --> 02:13:48.375
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>It's a 16% reduction scenario.

1138
02:13:48.456 --> 02:13:57.649
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And that's just based on if we were to eliminate the existing vacancies across the engagement staff in the organization.

1139
02:13:58.323 --> 02:14:12.362
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Although we could definitely provide that 20% scenario, it would require getting to further down the road in the active process that we have of conversations around what are those true impacts.

1140
02:14:13.164 --> 02:14:24.934
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We believe that we could still meet the minimum requirements, but we would not be able to, to really advance equity in a comprehensive way, which has significant you know, concern to community.

1141
02:14:25.997 --> 02:14:31.551
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And it really would perpetuate that generational lack of access that we see.

1142
02:14:33.247 --> 02:14:33.635
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide.

1143
02:14:35.328 --> 02:14:44.931
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So just looking at the existing vacancies, which there are 7, this is the proposed organizational structure that could occur.

1144
02:14:45.962 --> 02:14:50.244
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The 16% savings would be— would look at about $800,000.

1145
02:14:50.309 --> 02:14:50.567
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thank you.

1146
02:14:53.520 --> 02:14:54.216
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And next slide.

1147
02:14:55.948 --> 02:15:01.453
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And this would be the distribution and still looking at that 1 to 8 span of control.

1148
02:15:04.960 --> 02:15:05.735
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And back to Tracy.

1149
02:15:07.353 --> 02:15:13.742
<v Tracy Warren>So I'll take us home with just 2 more slides and then we'll open it up for questions.

1150
02:15:13.806 --> 02:15:18.148
<v Tracy Warren>This gives a total impact of the lower reduction proposal.

1151
02:15:18.944 --> 02:15:23.681
<v Tracy Warren>So this equates to roughly 98 cuts in FTEs.

1152
02:15:23.779 --> 02:15:30.074
<v Tracy Warren>Some of those are vacant, some of those are filled, and roughly $23.7 million.

1153
02:15:31.150 --> 02:15:40.434
<v Tracy Warren>That does include a current savings for this fiscal year of $2.7 million, and then that does include a mix of funding types.

1154
02:15:40.498 --> 02:15:43.453
<v Tracy Warren>So that is not all a savings to the general fund.

1155
02:15:43.533 --> 02:15:47.454
<v Tracy Warren>Some of these are savings to other funds and rate-driven funds.

1156
02:15:48.659 --> 02:15:50.154
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

1157
02:15:52.018 --> 02:15:56.917
<v Tracy Warren>And then I will end us with ongoing risk and challenges.

1158
02:15:57.998 --> 02:16:01.163
<v Tracy Warren>This project is extremely large.

1159
02:16:01.390 --> 02:16:11.507
<v Tracy Warren>It involves a lot of people, a lot of moving parts, and it will continue to need a lot of dedicated time and support to move it forward.

1160
02:16:11.572 --> 02:16:11.685
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thank you.

1161
02:16:12.796 --> 02:16:32.625
<v Tracy Warren>I've recently communicated with folks who are part of HR, IT, and procurement on a series of engagement and activities that we plan to engage in over the next several months leading up to decisions that will take place in June with council.

1162
02:16:36.167 --> 02:16:41.658
<v Tracy Warren>I appreciate your time today and being able to offer you an update related to the realignment project.

1163
02:16:43.662 --> 02:16:45.458
<v Tracy Warren>And happy to answer any questions.

1164
02:16:46.940 --> 02:16:47.663
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much.

1165
02:16:48.193 --> 02:16:51.346
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, we were also originally scheduled to hear Public Works.

1166
02:16:52.280 --> 02:16:53.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is 4:15.

1167
02:16:53.147 --> 02:16:54.434
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's no chance we're going to hear that.

1168
02:16:55.020 --> 02:17:00.567
<v Jamie Dunphy>So rather than stopping us for a break, I'm going to have us get our council questions and we will end early today.

1169
02:17:01.779 --> 02:17:02.627
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Vice President Clark.

1170
02:17:04.340 --> 02:17:08.015
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President, and thank you for this presentation.

1171
02:17:08.146 --> 02:17:09.388
<v Olivia Clark>I recognize how much Thank you, Mayor.

1172
02:17:09.435 --> 02:17:09.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1173
02:17:09.757 --> 02:17:10.013
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Mayor.

1174
02:17:10.094 --> 02:17:10.656
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate how much work has gone into this.

1175
02:17:11.202 --> 02:17:14.076
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate the individual briefing that I received.

1176
02:17:15.137 --> 02:17:28.415
<v Olivia Clark>I really thank you for providing the context for this, that the one-city model— I, I like that because we are in that transition, that culture change, and kind of unwinding 100 years of practice.

1177
02:17:28.479 --> 02:17:32.092
<v Olivia Clark>So, and we're trying to do it lickety-split.

1178
02:17:32.380 --> 02:17:34.692
<v Olivia Clark>So I appreciate that.

1179
02:17:34.968 --> 02:17:38.197
<v Olivia Clark>I do have a couple of concerns I want to express and questions.

1180
02:17:39.949 --> 02:17:48.899
<v Olivia Clark>Obviously, you know, Public Works is the largest service area and they're taking the brunt of this alignment.

1181
02:17:50.269 --> 02:17:55.037
<v Olivia Clark>And I want to ask you, they're not general fund.

1182
02:17:56.661 --> 02:18:03.207
<v Olivia Clark>And I wondered if— I know this is supposed to be phased, I'm worried that it's not phased enough.

1183
02:18:03.480 --> 02:18:08.013
<v Olivia Clark>I'm worried about the risks, particularly with capital projects and delivery on things.

1184
02:18:08.061 --> 02:18:09.706
<v Olivia Clark>That's of great concern to me.

1185
02:18:11.301 --> 02:18:17.620
<v Olivia Clark>Is there some way that these positions could be— I mean, they're in Public Works, they're not general fund funded.

1186
02:18:18.313 --> 02:18:21.159
<v Olivia Clark>So why are we taking such a hit there?

1187
02:18:21.996 --> 02:18:22.639
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah.

1188
02:18:23.911 --> 02:18:43.490
<v Tracy Warren>Well, so I think what I would share is that we are continuing to engage in conversations with Public Works Public Works around the risk associated with the cuts and talk through alternatives to making sure that they continue to be supported, including are there different ways for us to fund this work.

1189
02:18:45.408 --> 02:18:47.809
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, so this is a work in progress.

1190
02:18:48.486 --> 02:18:49.680
<v Tracy Warren>It is still a work in progress.

1191
02:18:49.727 --> 02:18:51.404
<v Olivia Clark>All right, I appreciate that.

1192
02:18:51.888 --> 02:18:56.215
<v Olivia Clark>I mean, you're over your target, your total target, so I see there's flexibility here.

1193
02:18:59.756 --> 02:19:04.320
<v Olivia Clark>But I'd be really interested in looking at more phases for Public Works.

1194
02:19:04.386 --> 02:19:10.996
<v Olivia Clark>I'm just, like I said, my primary concern is the delivery on capital projects, and, and we don't want to risk that.

1195
02:19:11.641 --> 02:19:16.968
<v Olivia Clark>That's my, that's my biggest worry here, and because they're not general fund funded as well.

1196
02:19:18.609 --> 02:19:21.834
<v Olivia Clark>So I just want to put that stake in the ground that I'm concerned about that.

1197
02:19:21.899 --> 02:19:22.674
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know if you want to make any comments.

1198
02:19:22.738 --> 02:19:23.254
<v Olivia Clark>No, I think that's a fair point.

1199
02:19:25.040 --> 02:19:29.055
<v Raymond C. Lee>I would just say briefly, a portion of Public Works is general fund.

1200
02:19:29.136 --> 02:19:31.030
<v Raymond C. Lee>We do have some park stuff that fits in there.

1201
02:19:31.174 --> 02:19:31.415
<v Raymond C. Lee>Parks.

1202
02:19:31.575 --> 02:19:42.445
<v Raymond C. Lee>Some of it goes to levy, as we'll have further conversations regarding PBOT and how some of those funds are used, as well as it relates to the general fund dollars to support these type of services.

1203
02:19:42.943 --> 02:19:57.782
<v Raymond C. Lee>But 100%, we're on the same page as you are as it relates to we don't want to sacrifice our responsiveness and our ability to produce We're trying to just meet a magic number for us as an organization.

1204
02:19:58.200 --> 02:20:08.387
<v Raymond C. Lee>We want to be an efficient, effective, and economical government, but we also want to be responsive and agile to the change, to the ever-changing environment that we're in as a government entity.

1205
02:20:08.836 --> 02:20:18.668
<v Raymond C. Lee>So that is at the forefront of our minds as we look through kind of these reductions, what makes sense and what does not make sense for this organization to move forward with.

1206
02:20:19.183 --> 02:20:30.361
<v Raymond C. Lee>'Cause we don't wanna cut something so drastically where it's so hard we can't ever recover from those type of cuts because there'll be other demands and other calls for services in the future.

1207
02:20:30.425 --> 02:20:40.191
<v Raymond C. Lee>So we just wanna make sure there's a happy balance there as it relates to the decisions that we're making now and still evaluate it as we go through these other budget years.

1208
02:20:40.625 --> 02:20:46.213
<v Raymond C. Lee>As we have more consolidation, we get more of a rhythm about how we function in this new form of government.

1209
02:20:46.262 --> 02:20:46.567
<v Raymond C. Lee>Mm-hmm.

1210
02:20:46.808 --> 02:21:00.365
<v Raymond C. Lee>That we can kind of look at those type of things to see where can we make additional efficiencies or effective cuts that impact our ability, one, to provide services to the public, but at a better cost to the public as well.

1211
02:21:01.307 --> 02:21:02.588
<v Olivia Clark>Well, I really appreciate that.

1212
02:21:04.984 --> 02:21:06.368
<v Olivia Clark>We're on the same wavelength.

1213
02:21:06.415 --> 02:21:07.028
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate that.

1214
02:21:07.397 --> 02:21:22.273
<v Olivia Clark>But so I can assume that this core alignment presentation that you've made is really at this point somewhat theoretical, that it's— there's a lot more work to go on this, a little deeper dive, particularly in Public Works.

1215
02:21:22.979 --> 02:21:23.461
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Correct.

1216
02:21:23.558 --> 02:21:26.673
<v Raymond C. Lee>And some of the budget conversation is going to help dictate this as well too.

1217
02:21:27.251 --> 02:21:40.575
<v Raymond C. Lee>As we go further into some of the budget conversations and trying to make up our gap, some of this information that you see will be weighed into the decision-making process that will be producing the mayor's proposed budget.

1218
02:21:40.915 --> 02:21:54.556
<v Raymond C. Lee>And as council goes through its deliberations, some of this information may be called back into consideration as we go through those deliberation conversations to make sure that we're producing an overall budget that meets the needs of all Portlanders.

1219
02:21:55.183 --> 02:21:56.376
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate that.

1220
02:21:58.340 --> 02:22:00.672
<v Olivia Clark>Let me just ask one little question here.

1221
02:22:00.884 --> 02:22:03.328
<v Olivia Clark>I should have asked this early on, but I didn't want to interrupt the flow.

1222
02:22:04.733 --> 02:22:06.727
<v Olivia Clark>Under each section you have core.

1223
02:22:07.165 --> 02:22:09.177
<v Olivia Clark>I wasn't sure what core means.

1224
02:22:11.110 --> 02:22:23.752
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, what, what we did is we were— the core is the central function, so it is primarily focused on governance, compliance, best practice.

1225
02:22:24.332 --> 02:22:27.809
<v Tracy Warren>And so I'll use human resources as an example.

1226
02:22:27.875 --> 02:22:46.847
<v Tracy Warren>Currently, the Bureau of Human Resources provides the core service of HR in that it provides benefits, it does the compliance and support for recruitment and training, it does classification, compensation, pay equity, it does employee and labor relations.

1227
02:22:46.897 --> 02:22:49.415
<v Tracy Warren>So those functions would primarily stay the same.

1228
02:22:50.395 --> 02:22:54.856
<v Tracy Warren>I don't know that we've all the way figured out our terminology for the new model.

1229
02:22:54.968 --> 02:23:01.422
<v Tracy Warren>We were really trying to distinguish between great, I appreciate that.

1230
02:23:01.486 --> 02:23:02.209
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

1231
02:23:02.289 --> 02:23:04.102
<v Olivia Clark>I think that's the end of my questions.

1232
02:23:04.457 --> 02:23:05.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1233
02:23:05.564 --> 02:23:06.207
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

1234
02:23:07.490 --> 02:23:08.469
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1235
02:23:08.614 --> 02:23:10.364
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, thank you guys so much for this presentation.

1236
02:23:10.493 --> 02:23:19.259
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, I will say, of all of them, I think this one really made my stomach drop just looking at the numbers, and I think we all, uh, feel that way up here right now.

1237
02:23:20.254 --> 02:23:24.364
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I have a— an easy question to start with.

1238
02:23:24.590 --> 02:23:36.129
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, do you know when council is going to be getting to see the various scenario cuts for different bureaus and if we're going to get to see them before the mayor's budget is put out and give feedback on that?

1239
02:23:37.899 --> 02:23:39.031
<v Raymond C. Lee>You know, that's a great question.

1240
02:23:39.855 --> 02:23:48.540
<v Raymond C. Lee>Let me put some thought to that to see kind of a timing mechanism if we could get that, if it's going to— especially if it's going to be incorporated with the mayor's proposed budget.

1241
02:23:48.604 --> 02:24:02.944
<v Raymond C. Lee>So let me follow back up with you, Council, as it relates to that particular question of a timing perspective, because I know We're on a tight schedule, but I would like to be able to get you some information if we are going that direction to help you have a better sense of what that means and impacts.

1242
02:24:04.149 --> 02:24:10.994
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, that would be really helpful just because then I think we can have more detailed conversations with the mayor during our one-on-ones on, on the budget proposal.

1243
02:24:11.041 --> 02:24:11.782
<v Angelita Morillo>So appreciate that.

1244
02:24:11.992 --> 02:24:12.556
<v Tracy Warren>Most definitely.

1245
02:24:13.684 --> 02:24:21.559
<v Angelita Morillo>Regarding the core realignment work, there was a potential loss of 98 to 125 full-time employees.

1246
02:24:22.227 --> 02:24:31.577
<v Angelita Morillo>And the service risks noted throughout the presentation, this feels a lot more like service reductions to me than a process to streamline efficiency.

1247
02:24:31.754 --> 02:24:34.674
<v Angelita Morillo>So I'm kind of struggling to see the efficiency gains in this.

1248
02:24:35.512 --> 02:24:42.424
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think originally last year we were— when these discussions started, we were told that this was an effort to maximize efficiency.

1249
02:24:43.208 --> 02:24:52.075
<v Angelita Morillo>So can you help me understand what efficiencies you're anticipating in light of all of the risks that we saw outlined absolutely.

1250
02:24:52.138 --> 02:25:14.079
<v Tracy Warren>I think it's, you know, I think what has complicated the conversation is that when we originally started the project to realign, we were really focused on how do we realign our services to better conform to the new form of government, ensuring that we're able to provide services across the enterprise in a consistent and equitable manner.

1251
02:25:16.279 --> 02:25:34.509
<v Tracy Warren>Then we had some financial challenges which layered on top of it a reduction, which really required us to think really hard around what are the basic services that we could provide within each of these functional areas with a reduced footprint.

1252
02:25:34.604 --> 02:25:38.523
<v Tracy Warren>And so that is really what those 20% reductions represent.

1253
02:25:39.005 --> 02:25:41.254
<v Tracy Warren>There will be efficiencies along the way.

1254
02:25:41.399 --> 02:25:42.171
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1255
02:25:42.316 --> 02:25:48.278
<v Tracy Warren>But it will be— it won't be smooth, right?

1256
02:25:48.406 --> 02:26:10.662
<v Tracy Warren>Anytime you are moving a large portion of your organization to shift the way that they do business and deliver services, it's going to be a little bumpy, and you're going to have to have patience and work through those processes together as a unified group to go, How do we work together to make sure this is the best service possible?

1257
02:26:10.790 --> 02:26:39.004
<v Tracy Warren>But you'll see improvements like consistency with the way that we provide leave administration, reduced technology specialized systems, which means that technology over time will have more capacity to be able to support the folks who are using the same system, and they will have more expertise within those systems because they're not thank you.

1258
02:26:39.886 --> 02:26:54.995
<v Tracy Warren>When you talk about procurement, you will see efficiencies because you will have procurement rolling out standards and having control over the accountability and outcomes of the contracts that are happening within bureaus.

1259
02:26:55.092 --> 02:27:07.943
<v Tracy Warren>That also helps us at some point get to a place where we're able to provide you all with more consistent data and information because we will have access okay, thank you.

1260
02:27:08.007 --> 02:27:09.163
<v Angelita Morillo>That's really helpful and clarifying.

1261
02:27:09.210 --> 02:27:10.043
<v Angelita Morillo>Did you want to add something?

1262
02:27:10.397 --> 02:27:17.032
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>I was just going to speak a little bit to like a very concrete example in terms of engagement, and I think a lot of that is around coordination.

1263
02:27:17.129 --> 02:27:34.329
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>There isn't a tremendous amount of coordination between staff doing certain things in community, and so in some instances we are creating an unnecessary burden for community partners because multiple staff from multiple bureaus are developing relationships or have relationships, and we're not necessarily all talking to each other all the time.

1264
02:27:34.378 --> 02:27:50.225
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And so to me, this is a real opportunity to coordinate around those things, not duplicate that, and then be able to grow and expand relationships, strengthen them in other— with other communities that we don't have relationships with now because we're so focused on connecting with the same partners.

1265
02:27:51.850 --> 02:27:52.906
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks for clarifying that.

1266
02:27:53.165 --> 02:27:56.692
<v Angelita Morillo>That helps me just get a clearer picture of what was intended there.

1267
02:27:58.386 --> 02:28:09.265
<v Angelita Morillo>I also firmly believe that the people who are closest to the day-to-day work in the bureaus and all of that tend to know the efficiencies and the things that are needed a lot more than those of us who are higher up, high level.

1268
02:28:09.362 --> 02:28:11.907
<v Angelita Morillo>We don't see all those day-to-day intricacies.

1269
02:28:12.743 --> 02:28:25.576
<v Angelita Morillo>How have staff in each of those areas that are potentially going to be affected, how have they been engaged in this decision-making process to ensure that we don't have unintended consequences?

1270
02:28:27.379 --> 02:28:27.668
<v Olivia Clark>Absolutely.

1271
02:28:28.913 --> 02:28:58.444
<v Tracy Warren>You know, for HR, IT, and procurement, there was some initial engagement where we brought folks together who were doing the work or managing or leading the work into work groups and subgroups where they took particular tasks or processes within each of the functional areas, and they really dove into them and talked about what things were working and not working within those areas.

1272
02:28:58.960 --> 02:29:07.278
<v Tracy Warren>They used that information as part of the model that was developed for the future structure.

1273
02:29:07.440 --> 02:29:15.888
<v Tracy Warren>They took components of the frustrations and the areas that people wanted to see change and said, okay, let's use that information and create this model.

1274
02:29:17.888 --> 02:29:31.106
<v Tracy Warren>Now we're on the second, well, I guess maybe like the third phase of the project where We plan to start having more direct engagement with staff based on the new model that was developed in the reductions that have been planned.

1275
02:29:32.439 --> 02:29:39.279
<v Tracy Warren>There will be a series of monthly town halls related to the realignment overall.

1276
02:29:39.584 --> 02:30:00.417
<v Tracy Warren>There will also be opportunities for each of the functional areas to have independent conversations on a monthly basis to say, What are some areas we can work through as we're thinking about service level agreements that we can both mold our expectations from the delivery and the receiving customer?

1277
02:30:01.126 --> 02:30:33.856
<v Tracy Warren>And then we will also be doing a series of customer forums where we plan to get together with the customer leadership and bureaus and talk through where we're seeing challenges with the realignment and talk through the input that we're getting from staff related to the service level agreements and really work together as a unified leadership team to develop and continue to develop the best service model for our employees to work within.

1278
02:30:35.764 --> 02:30:36.547
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks for that.

1279
02:30:36.661 --> 02:30:41.561
<v Angelita Morillo>And I hope for folks who are watching, listening, they have learned of different new ways to engage thank you.

1280
02:30:41.658 --> 02:30:43.923
<v Angelita Morillo>And hopefully will give us feedback on that moving forward as well.

1281
02:30:45.094 --> 02:30:47.213
<v Angelita Morillo>Last question, because I know we're running out of time.

1282
02:30:48.611 --> 02:30:57.345
<v Angelita Morillo>Using the engagement realignment that we've been discussing, how has that been tailored per each bureau's needs?

1283
02:30:57.394 --> 02:31:02.130
<v Angelita Morillo>Because obviously engagement looks very different for public safety versus transportation, for example.

1284
02:31:03.382 --> 02:31:06.754
<v Angelita Morillo>How has it been tailored to address some of those different needs?

1285
02:31:08.134 --> 02:31:25.549
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So, so far this has involved a lot of conversation with front-level staff as well as mid-level managers and then leadership to really try to understand and unpack as this was concurrent with trying to determine who was actually working in engagement.

1286
02:31:26.479 --> 02:31:30.601
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And so as part of those conversations, we've been talking about, okay, what are those functions?

1287
02:31:30.649 --> 02:31:48.286
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And that's how we developed the— that's what informed the structure slide is, and that information is really around appreciating that engagement is defined, and we now have this definition for engagement around pathways to participating in government decision-making.

1288
02:31:48.638 --> 02:31:52.763
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And we have these ideas around these 3 points of that pathway.

1289
02:31:53.358 --> 02:32:05.568
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Then we started talking about what does that look like for each service area and then bureaus within those to really develop, you know, some, put some I hate this— meat on the bones of a structure.

1290
02:32:05.958 --> 02:32:12.852
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And now we're at the same point where we'll start going back out and saying, okay, here's what we— here's what we think this looks like, and tell us what you think.

1291
02:32:13.852 --> 02:32:14.572
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, thank you.

1292
02:32:14.654 --> 02:32:15.275
<v Angelita Morillo>That's very helpful.

1293
02:32:16.978 --> 02:32:18.601
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I, I think I'll leave it at that.

1294
02:32:18.682 --> 02:32:19.331
<v Angelita Morillo>Appreciate you guys.

1295
02:32:19.379 --> 02:32:19.638
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1296
02:32:20.692 --> 02:32:21.584
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

1297
02:32:21.908 --> 02:32:22.605
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1298
02:32:22.881 --> 02:32:24.520
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor—.

1299
02:32:24.648 --> 02:32:25.152
<v Jamie Dunphy>Council President.

1300
02:32:25.540 --> 02:32:26.779
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thanks everybody for being here.

1301
02:32:27.006 --> 02:32:35.922
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I had a couple I had a couple questions that related to the overarching part of this, and I wanted to start by thanking you.

1302
02:32:35.986 --> 02:32:44.575
<v Sameer Kanal>The what we've learned slide is in strong alignment with what some of us said last year during the budget process, and I'm grateful for that acknowledgement.

1303
02:32:45.362 --> 02:32:54.354
<v Sameer Kanal>And it takes a lot, and I want to make sure that we're helping resolve that because obviously we budgeted expecting these reductions, and now there's going to be some need to fix that.

1304
02:32:54.403 --> 02:32:54.514
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1305
02:32:55.743 --> 02:32:56.984
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1306
02:32:57.483 --> 02:33:03.364
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there an identification when there will be new money?

1307
02:33:04.332 --> 02:33:18.987
<v Sameer Kanal>We talked about the reductions, but outside of those sort of collecting revenues on mostly Jonas's side, I haven't really seen the conversation around where the revenue increases— sorry, where the revenue increases would come from.

1308
02:33:19.538 --> 02:33:26.254
<v Sameer Kanal>So I don't know if there's a I think there's a big picture answer there that is sort of overarching, but I wanted to maybe flag that for later.

1309
02:33:28.559 --> 02:33:34.277
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm mostly deferential to the details of some of the things that you mentioned, DCA Warren.

1310
02:33:34.763 --> 02:33:41.157
<v Sameer Kanal>I have a lot more questions on your side, Amanda, and part of it's not engagement but equity.

1311
02:33:41.656 --> 02:33:48.615
<v Sameer Kanal>So on the engagement side, I imagine that there are several hundred other positions at the city that have at least a small part of their job be engagement also.

1312
02:33:48.665 --> 02:33:48.733
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1313
02:33:48.995 --> 02:33:49.815
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1314
02:33:49.959 --> 02:33:53.798
<v Sameer Kanal>And, you know, I've seen that in my work on the other side.

1315
02:33:54.152 --> 02:34:00.222
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that the job family may be helpful for that, some sort of superimposed classification.

1316
02:34:00.334 --> 02:34:05.731
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm sure you have that, and I'm imagining Tracy knows way more than I do, DCA Warren knows way more than I do about how to do that.

1317
02:34:05.796 --> 02:34:11.015
<v Sameer Kanal>But I just wanted to flag that to help with that assessment in the future.

1318
02:34:11.657 --> 02:34:15.368
<v Sameer Kanal>The definition of engagement is something that council has given direction thank you.

1319
02:34:15.465 --> 02:34:15.737
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mayor.

1320
02:34:15.817 --> 02:34:19.465
<v Sameer Kanal>So I wanted to take a second to mention that it's part of it.

1321
02:34:19.610 --> 02:34:24.397
<v Sameer Kanal>It's in a lot of places, but it's even in the core values and it's in the description for collaboration.

1322
02:34:24.445 --> 02:34:29.362
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just wanted to take a second to read this because I think it really helps center this conversation.

1323
02:34:29.731 --> 02:34:49.859
<v Sameer Kanal>Intentional inclusion, practicing broad outreach and engaging the community to ensure diversity, approaching outreach inclusion from a culture-add growth rather than a culture-fit fixed mindset, create an environment for diverse perspectives, ensure that all voices have value, reach out to bring in with authenticity and kindness, center the voices and experiences of BIPOC staff and staff with disabilities.

1324
02:34:50.371 --> 02:34:52.877
<v Sameer Kanal>Peer support and training is the second part that's more indirect.

1325
02:34:52.941 --> 02:34:54.113
<v Sameer Kanal>The third one is commitment.

1326
02:34:54.852 --> 02:34:59.138
<v Sameer Kanal>Our belief that we are better together promotes collaboration and the co-creation of knowledge.

1327
02:34:59.700 --> 02:35:03.265
<v Sameer Kanal>The nexus of politics and public services connects our workforce and communities.

1328
02:35:03.780 --> 02:35:07.055
<v Sameer Kanal>Civic engagement, receptive collective action empower our employees and residents.

1329
02:35:07.391 --> 02:35:10.792
<v Sameer Kanal>Inclusive outreach and public engagement increase institutional knowledge and awareness.

1330
02:35:11.242 --> 02:35:15.701
<v Sameer Kanal>All behaviors, actions, decisions, and systems reflect a culture of accountability and commitment to the city's core values.

1331
02:35:16.070 --> 02:35:26.049
<v Sameer Kanal>Some of that is cyclical definitions, and I fully acknowledge that, but I think there's some really key principles that undergird that that you see in some other documents that are maybe more dispersed around the city.

1332
02:35:26.161 --> 02:35:31.021
<v Sameer Kanal>And but there's one particular piece in there that I really wanted to highlight, and it's the word co-creation.

1333
02:35:31.213 --> 02:35:40.684
<v Sameer Kanal>And if, if you boil it all down to that, That's when we're doing successful engagement, is when we are a part of it and the community is also a part of it.

1334
02:35:41.985 --> 02:35:43.832
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to make sure that that was centered.

1335
02:35:43.879 --> 02:35:52.373
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't want to see some redefinition because I, I've seen that already a little bit with the combination of the managers with communication.

1336
02:35:52.968 --> 02:35:53.240
<v Sameer Kanal>Mm-hmm.

1337
02:35:53.513 --> 02:36:03.751
<v Sameer Kanal>One of the really key weaknesses of the city's engagement, in my experience, is the connection of engagement with communication, which is one-way outward-facing.

1338
02:36:04.504 --> 02:36:11.879
<v Sameer Kanal>And very important task, very important role, helps set up some of the engagement feedback loops and things like that, but is fundamentally different.

1339
02:36:11.975 --> 02:36:13.209
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to highlight that.

1340
02:36:14.138 --> 02:36:17.954
<v Sameer Kanal>On the flip side, I also really wanted to appreciate your comment about employee engagement.

1341
02:36:18.611 --> 02:36:26.763
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to talk about that maybe in a different form of how we can do it, in particular creating a space for anonymous employee feedback.

1342
02:36:27.441 --> 02:36:36.588
<v Sameer Kanal>I cannot tell you the number of times that different people who are employed at the city have raised a piece of feedback with the caveat of, you didn't hear it from me.

1343
02:36:38.167 --> 02:36:46.648
<v Sameer Kanal>Or more specifically, raise a concern about something on a spectrum that starts much smaller and ends at retaliation.

1344
02:36:47.310 --> 02:36:59.860
<v Sameer Kanal>So I really want to figure out a way that we can do that without Um, and create that space because there are things that the ground floor people know that we're not hearing, and I imagine that the, the leadership on the administrative side is not either.

1345
02:37:00.666 --> 02:37:18.306
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, switching gears to equity, um, I'm really concerned that the presentation labels equity primarily as regulatory compliance, um, especially as the state and federal governments both backslide.

1346
02:37:18.354 --> 02:37:19.885
<v Sameer Kanal>And in light of the mayor's executive order.

1347
02:37:21.692 --> 02:37:27.148
<v Sameer Kanal>I also wanted to note we do actually have a leader in equity in the interim, and she's in the room.

1348
02:37:27.879 --> 02:37:49.009
<v Sameer Kanal>We have an interim director of the Office of Equity and Human Rights, and I wanted to make sure that while we don't have someone, which will probably not be a very long time, that the staff in OEHR, whoever's left, and I know we've been decimating that bureau over and over again, but everybody that's still there is great, and I want to make sure that they're consulted too, all the way up to our interim director.

1349
02:37:50.576 --> 02:37:58.167
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wanted to ask, how much money did the consultant cost that was asked what the core functions of equity were?

1350
02:37:59.361 --> 02:38:04.765
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>I can get the exact figure, but I can tell you what the contract was approved up to.

1351
02:38:05.154 --> 02:38:11.433
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>I don't— we're still receiving invoice, so I don't have the exact figure of what's being spent, but it was up to $25,000.

1352
02:38:13.082 --> 02:38:13.179
<v Ruth Levine>Okay.

1353
02:38:13.957 --> 02:38:14.605
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1354
02:38:14.849 --> 02:38:15.173
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1355
02:38:15.271 --> 02:38:23.836
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we tend to look for— and this has nothing to do with this contract, but in general— well, it might, I guess, but I don't know that for sure.

1356
02:38:23.981 --> 02:38:28.140
<v Sameer Kanal>We tend to look for a new answer from a new contractor often.

1357
02:38:28.577 --> 02:38:36.414
<v Sameer Kanal>And even if one is $25,000, I find that the overreliance on contractors is a big reason why we're in some of the financial situations we're dealing with.

1358
02:38:36.461 --> 02:38:38.192
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's a good thing that we're with today anyway.

1359
02:38:38.657 --> 02:38:40.661
<v Sameer Kanal>So I wanted to make sure I highlighted that.

1360
02:38:40.740 --> 02:38:41.975
<v Sameer Kanal>That's a smaller one than I expected.

1361
02:38:42.022 --> 02:38:43.144
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm very glad to hear it's small.

1362
02:38:44.185 --> 02:39:06.127
<v Sameer Kanal>But I'm really looking forward to having this role defined and for the new equity director role, but also to take the opportunity while I have the floor here to mention that if you had to combine managers of engagement with something else, I would've strongly preferred policy.

1363
02:39:06.334 --> 02:39:14.315
<v Sameer Kanal>I know not everybody else has a policy development role like that, but that would've highlighted community, sorry, co-creation as that core function.

1364
02:39:15.054 --> 02:39:21.363
<v Sameer Kanal>But in the absence of that, equity's probably the other closest thing to combine.

1365
02:39:21.878 --> 02:39:24.833
<v Sameer Kanal>I would prefer to have its own vertical for each service area.

1366
02:39:24.880 --> 02:39:29.263
<v Sameer Kanal>But if you, while we're in a budget crisis, if we need to combine, those two seem to make more sense.

1367
02:39:29.360 --> 02:39:29.521
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1368
02:39:29.828 --> 02:39:35.674
<v Sameer Kanal>To me together than associating engagement with outward one-way functions like communication.

1369
02:39:37.170 --> 02:39:37.603
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thanks.

1370
02:39:39.436 --> 02:39:40.306
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1371
02:39:40.820 --> 02:39:41.512
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1372
02:39:43.716 --> 02:39:44.021
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1373
02:39:44.198 --> 02:39:59.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I think that, you know, in theory, this makes a lot of sense to me as you get ready to move us into that direction in terms of, you know, the idea of having 26 versions of how we do a thing is concerning.

1374
02:39:59.688 --> 02:40:03.415
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think there's nuance, but then there's wholly different systems.

1375
02:40:03.463 --> 02:40:06.370
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I think that this is getting to that.

1376
02:40:06.740 --> 02:40:11.415
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciated the pre-brief that we got.

1377
02:40:12.299 --> 02:40:22.468
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I guess one question really, either for Tracy or for Raymond, is, you know, we're seeing the numbers here and they're in the 12%, the 14%, the 17%.

1378
02:40:23.476 --> 02:40:24.900
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think anybody hit the 20%.

1379
02:40:25.498 --> 02:40:31.406
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I want to ask is, did anybody bring you what you asked for, which was a 20%?

1380
02:40:32.929 --> 02:40:44.684
<v Eric Zimmerman>And is this then the— now that you've dug into it, a back-off of like your recommendation, or was no one able to hit the mark with what the direction was?

1381
02:40:45.927 --> 02:40:52.399
<v Tracy Warren>Everyone brought me— so for human resources, IT, and procurement, everyone brought me 20%.

1382
02:40:53.316 --> 02:40:53.477
<v Tracy Warren>Okay.

1383
02:40:54.183 --> 02:41:06.102
<v Tracy Warren>And then we got a lot of feedback about the risk associated with the 20%, and we went back to the table to bring an alternate recommendation, and that's what the lower amount is.

1384
02:41:07.387 --> 02:41:07.808
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1385
02:41:07.968 --> 02:41:20.592
<v Eric Zimmerman>That, um, that makes this a lot more, um, it gives me more faith in it that there's already been some of that that, uh, additional due diligence.

1386
02:41:20.640 --> 02:41:21.658
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll put it in that category.

1387
02:41:22.418 --> 02:41:24.083
<v Eric Zimmerman>There have been— there's a couple areas.

1388
02:41:24.180 --> 02:41:40.636
<v Eric Zimmerman>I raised it in the pre-brief that I got, and I'll raise it again because there's a new section that was not part of the pre-brief, but, um, one who highlights the fact that their reductions include 26 vacancies, but a statement that was said today, we looked at vacancies first.

1389
02:41:42.952 --> 02:41:54.967
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is that is a red flag for me in a realignment of services because that looks like it was a realignment of where we didn't have to have personnel conversations.

1390
02:41:55.224 --> 02:42:12.903
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so it may be that 26 sitting vacancies are the right place, but when that statement is said and when— I mean, that's a large number to just like, that's our group out of, out of, um, You know, the other proposed reductions.

1391
02:42:14.986 --> 02:42:29.406
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really hope that this reduction is about what are the right services in each of these buckets that need to be delivered in your estimate in a reduced funding package, but how— what do we do and how do we do that?

1392
02:42:29.536 --> 02:42:34.894
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is hard to do if you start with what is not filled today.

1393
02:42:34.959 --> 02:42:35.056
<v Raymond C. Lee>I agree.

1394
02:42:36.352 --> 02:42:36.496
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>It—.

1395
02:42:36.897 --> 02:42:38.435
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I have been through these, right?

1396
02:42:38.740 --> 02:42:57.393
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that there may be times where we have conversations that certain things that are filled with a current city employee, we say that's, that's not in the package moving forward, but we have this vacancy over here in the same family of them, and that, that transfer over is part of the bumping and part of the looking.

1397
02:42:57.825 --> 02:43:15.653
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just want to think about that because I— this was really programmed to us I think the mention was efficiencies, was about, you know, right-sizing different services for the rest of the city because the core function of the city was fairly muted in the old form of government and it really needs to be bolstered.

1398
02:43:16.040 --> 02:43:18.852
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's bringing them from the bureaus into a centralized piece.

1399
02:43:20.878 --> 02:43:25.602
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would just— I give caution to the area where we led with the vacancies already, right?

1400
02:43:25.666 --> 02:43:30.638
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that you have done some due diligence, but the So those are the things that kind of flagged for me.

1401
02:43:32.386 --> 02:43:55.213
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then I always love working with Councilor Clark, but your comments that you've made about maybe being too aggressive in some of the non-general fund bureaus, I would offer another side of that, which is I really hope that the realignment, the core services affects and helps us get the whole city under the correct pyramid and the way we do services.

1402
02:43:55.279 --> 02:43:55.408
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thank you.

1403
02:43:56.264 --> 02:44:06.409
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'd be worried if it was only general fund bureaus have to adhere to our central services model, right?

1404
02:44:06.459 --> 02:44:20.334
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that even our enterprise funds and those who have others, you know, the way we do HR, the way we do procurement and IT, I actually like that we're applying it across the board, even if it's phased, but applying it across the board.

1405
02:44:20.432 --> 02:44:21.159
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a good point.

1406
02:44:21.423 --> 02:44:30.188
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that the entire organization— one, I think that helps us be better because it sets a cultural tone.

1407
02:44:31.190 --> 02:44:43.907
<v Eric Zimmerman>So just a kind of a competing idea with Councilor Clark there, because I'd be— I wouldn't be supportive if the budget package this year only had this type of realignment in general fund-funded bureaus.

1408
02:44:44.425 --> 02:44:45.720
<v Eric Zimmerman>That wouldn't have my support.

1409
02:44:46.207 --> 02:44:49.605
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Zimmerman, can I just say that I don't disagree with you.

1410
02:44:49.976 --> 02:44:56.549
<v Olivia Clark>I just think we need to go a little bit slower in Public Works when it comes to those big capital projects.

1411
02:44:57.282 --> 02:45:10.932
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, you know, maybe in the procurement piece, but if we're talking about— if we look at what we're talking about here in terms of the types of services, I will also remind folks that the city had 2 years to do this, right?

1412
02:45:11.496 --> 02:45:17.529
<v Eric Zimmerman>The city reorganized itself even before we all took office, and largely this was not happening.

1413
02:45:18.189 --> 02:45:21.799
<v Eric Zimmerman>And largely in the first year of our time here, a lot of this was not happening.

1414
02:45:22.493 --> 02:45:26.486
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think the ultimate time for this to have occurred would have been last July.

1415
02:45:27.263 --> 02:45:29.203
<v Eric Zimmerman>So we are catching up in that.

1416
02:45:30.255 --> 02:45:38.781
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then the last piece that I want to share, and I think, Tracy, you and I have had some chats about this, I do see this as a— it's going to be a very, very hard transition.

1417
02:45:38.829 --> 02:45:38.895
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1418
02:45:39.253 --> 02:46:04.806
<v Eric Zimmerman>In the in the short term, and in the long term, I look at this as being a way where you know you are a professional of this of this brand of service, and you for some time you are reporting and providing that service to you know public works, and maybe that means parks for these few years, and then you look and you compete for an opportunity to do the same thing, or your boss thinks hey we need some help over because.

1419
02:46:04.930 --> 02:46:06.772
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because maybe PBOT needs your expertise.

1420
02:46:07.444 --> 02:46:18.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>That more well-roundedness is actually, for me, the markings of a really, really healthy organization because we have players who can be successful in multiple places.

1421
02:46:18.903 --> 02:46:20.698
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm really looking forward to that.

1422
02:46:20.825 --> 02:46:22.123
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think you are setting this up.

1423
02:46:22.203 --> 02:46:23.038
<v Eric Zimmerman>I see where you're moving.

1424
02:46:24.094 --> 02:46:26.434
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for the thorough presentation to the both of you.

1425
02:46:26.979 --> 02:46:29.254
<v Eric Zimmerman>None of this will be hard or easy decisions.

1426
02:46:29.398 --> 02:46:30.361
<v Eric Zimmerman>All of this is going to be hard.

1427
02:46:30.457 --> 02:46:31.120
<v Eric Zimmerman>So Thank you.

1428
02:46:32.143 --> 02:46:33.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1429
02:46:33.264 --> 02:46:33.947
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1430
02:46:34.093 --> 02:46:35.653
<v Raymond C. Lee>One quick thing I'd like to share.

1431
02:46:35.782 --> 02:46:44.230
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think in the beginning of this process, this was a kind of a target-based process, uh, of hitting a certain mark.

1432
02:46:44.953 --> 02:46:57.971
<v Raymond C. Lee>And I think as we move forward, as you said, through your first priority-setting meeting this weekend, we're going to really start moving towards priority-based kind of decision-making, uh, as it relates to target-based decision-making.

1433
02:46:58.907 --> 02:47:10.397
<v Raymond C. Lee>And this is going to help us wrap our mind around these type of decisions that we're making and what is the strategy behind why we're making the decisions that we're making instead of just trying to hit a target.

1434
02:47:10.654 --> 02:47:13.513
<v Raymond C. Lee>But what are we ultimately trying to achieve as an organization?

1435
02:47:14.013 --> 02:47:16.567
<v Raymond C. Lee>And does this help us achieve that as an organization?

1436
02:47:17.066 --> 02:47:21.790
<v Raymond C. Lee>And that's where we're flipping the business model towards as an organization.

1437
02:47:22.224 --> 02:47:34.784
<v Raymond C. Lee>And that's going to cause us to be more intentional about the decisions that we're making, and it's more transparent to our employee base on why certain decisions are being made as an organization.

1438
02:47:37.900 --> 02:47:38.468
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, sir.

1439
02:47:38.956 --> 02:47:39.751
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1440
02:47:40.513 --> 02:47:41.536
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1441
02:47:43.032 --> 02:48:15.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I feel like I've moved from a budget work session into something very different than a budget work session with this presentation, and I I'm noting that because I appreciated, Tracy, the way that you laid out at the beginning that this is about bringing our core services back into the center, that we had set out probably once upon a time to do that, and then those core services weren't invested in, so other bureaus started to duplicate services.

1442
02:48:16.126 --> 02:48:16.961
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's not Councilor Smith.

1443
02:48:17.236 --> 02:48:21.921
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is not the creation of anyone in this room, presumably.

1444
02:48:22.001 --> 02:48:26.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's certainly not the creation of anybody sitting behind you both wearing blue shirts.

1445
02:48:29.823 --> 02:48:42.350
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if we want to have a more unified Portland city government, if we want to be more predictable in how we do things both to our own employees and thank you.

1446
02:48:42.445 --> 02:48:44.838
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And to the public, it's something we have to change.

1447
02:48:45.898 --> 02:49:06.226
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it is not lost on me that every single change, every single position we're talking about, is a person who is doing a job presumably very well to have gotten through our hiring process and made it through many rounds of slimming down our city government that we have already gone through.

1448
02:49:08.952 --> 02:49:20.058
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it's hard as we talk about this realignment and budget cuts at the same time, where I think we are starting to conflate 2 really important things.

1449
02:49:20.171 --> 02:49:29.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How do we move services back to the core, and how do we figure out what our budget looks like moving forward?

1450
02:49:29.849 --> 02:49:33.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know it is hard for a lot of people as we conflate those 2 things.

1451
02:49:33.295 --> 02:49:33.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a great point.

1452
02:49:35.163 --> 02:49:44.668
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To believe that we up here, and probably some of the leaders on the administrative side, value the work.

1453
02:49:44.894 --> 02:49:56.050
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just, I want to note that because we do value the work and we are trying to do 2 things at once here that are different but are coming to a head because of where we sit in this budget environment.

1454
02:49:56.694 --> 02:49:57.838
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's important to note.

1455
02:49:58.112 --> 02:50:03.788
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, To that end, I actually have a question, a budget question.

1456
02:50:07.478 --> 02:50:20.037
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As one of my colleagues pointed out, only one of our core service areas is proposing a 20% reduction target, which is what had originally been proposed through this exercise.

1457
02:50:21.450 --> 02:50:33.457
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do the numbers that we have looked at around what CSL is, what the cost are for next year and what reductions are necessary given our current projections for revenue.

1458
02:50:33.763 --> 02:50:36.685
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess I should say reductions or raised revenue are necessary.

1459
02:50:37.397 --> 02:50:47.861
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do those numbers include the 20% targets, or do they include the proposals that you have brought to us today that range between, I think, 15% and 20%?

1460
02:50:49.829 --> 02:50:50.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess 12% and 20%.

1461
02:50:52.191 --> 02:50:57.150
<v Tracy Warren>So I think I understand what you're asking, but you may have to redirect me if I'm off.

1462
02:50:58.065 --> 02:51:06.217
<v Tracy Warren>So the realignment cuts are separate from the current service level gaps.

1463
02:51:06.859 --> 02:51:15.347
<v Tracy Warren>However, when we were realigning, we took into consideration the current service level gaps for the areas that are realigning.

1464
02:51:16.102 --> 02:51:19.055
<v Tracy Warren>And so it's not additive on top of it.

1465
02:51:19.459 --> 02:51:20.411
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Opposite question.

1466
02:51:20.670 --> 02:51:21.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1467
02:51:23.172 --> 02:51:45.818
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In the budget gap that we have seen, did that take into account seeing a 20% reduction in these core services, or did that take into account seeing between a 12% and 20% reduction as we're seeing here, or did that take into account some other number that is different from both of those?

1468
02:51:47.529 --> 02:51:48.715
<v Ruth Levine>Yeah, Ruth Levine, Budget Director.

1469
02:51:48.763 --> 02:51:50.542
<v Ruth Levine>Sorry to jump in.

1470
02:51:50.591 --> 02:51:51.792
<v Ruth Levine>I think the answer is 10%.

1471
02:51:51.856 --> 02:52:07.615
<v Ruth Levine>So the 10% reduction, you'll recall last year in the '25-'26 development process, the then City Administrator Jordan set out the 20% target but said we're going to aim for 10% in the first year.

1472
02:52:08.129 --> 02:52:18.384
<v Ruth Levine>That 10% was taken ongoing, which would have meant like adding another 10% target starting in '26-'27 to get to the total of 20.

1473
02:52:19.780 --> 02:52:24.742
<v Ruth Levine>We haven't— we've only assumed that first 10% so far in the current service level.

1474
02:52:24.837 --> 02:52:26.443
<v Ruth Levine>So the—.

1475
02:52:27.567 --> 02:52:27.777
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can—.

1476
02:52:28.531 --> 02:52:32.191
<v Ruth Levine>Yeah, so the second 10% sort of becomes irrelevant at this point.

1477
02:52:32.239 --> 02:52:57.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So as we think about this as part of a budget conversation, Assuming that realignment actually leads to reductions and to reductions at the levels that you've presented today, and assuming that those phase in over the course of another year, we are— I'm going to use the word safe in terms of what we've built into the budget.

1478
02:52:57.870 --> 02:53:04.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're not going to have additional cuts that we need to take because we budgeted for 20% at the beginning of the year.

1479
02:53:06.300 --> 02:53:06.852
<v Ruth Levine>That's correct.

1480
02:53:07.191 --> 02:53:24.094
<v Ruth Levine>And remember, those numbers that were on the slides today are citywide numbers, so they work out a little bit differently at the— there's a lot of complex math we're trying to do at the fund level specific to where positions are moving and where those fund sources are coming from.

1481
02:53:26.253 --> 02:53:33.891
<v Ruth Levine>So I think at this level that's presented here, we would be pretty close to the 10% assumption in the general fund.

1482
02:53:33.945 --> 02:53:33.998
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

1483
02:53:34.522 --> 02:53:36.014
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1484
02:53:36.064 --> 02:53:36.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's really helpful.

1485
02:53:37.556 --> 02:53:47.988
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I said this felt less like a budget presentation and more like a programmatic conversation, and so I do have 2 questions on that side also, um, or comments, I guess.

1486
02:53:48.309 --> 02:54:00.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, the first is that one of my colleagues cautioned us against being, um, penny-wise and pound-foolish looking at the timekeeping thank you.

1487
02:54:01.736 --> 02:54:12.061
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also want to make sure that we are not being pennywise and pound foolish by cutting so low that we then need to contract for work that we could have had our employees doing.

1488
02:54:14.191 --> 02:54:27.252
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want us to be as efficient as possible, and I want us to be as efficient as possible using city employees who know our book of business and have been doing this work and are well paid.

1489
02:54:27.828 --> 02:54:45.162
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if we get to a point where you are saying in order to make these cuts, one of the risks is that we will have to contract for something to make up for it, I want to make sure that we know that before you make those cuts so that we can ask you to do something different.

1490
02:54:46.045 --> 02:55:10.452
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I also want to note we had a disagreement between 2 of my colleagues, or and if this is really about providing services in a more unified and effective way and not just about finding another place to cut budgets, then we need to be doing this across all of our service areas and all of our fund types.

1491
02:55:11.365 --> 02:55:15.629
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we also need to be moving to the core across all of our core service types.

1492
02:55:15.951 --> 02:55:17.978
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I noted as we were going through this that we have a lot of work to do.

1493
02:55:18.027 --> 02:55:18.316
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1494
02:55:18.653 --> 02:55:30.691
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That in most of the core service areas, most of the cuts were in, um, in the other service areas, not in what you labeled as core.

1495
02:55:31.550 --> 02:55:43.805
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But in one or two, and I think outreach was one of them, or engagement rather, was one of them, but I think there might have been another as well, proportionally there were very few cuts outside of core.

1496
02:55:43.853 --> 02:55:43.934
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1497
02:55:44.836 --> 02:55:46.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Compared to cuts within core.

1498
02:55:46.299 --> 02:55:58.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that feels backwards to me if what we really want to do is say we have experts in these services who don't need to be experts in the program areas because they work with the program people.

1499
02:56:00.595 --> 02:56:02.334
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's be moving everything toward the core.

1500
02:56:02.449 --> 02:56:07.227
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's not make exceptions there if that's really what we're trying to do and this is more than just a budget exercise.

1501
02:56:08.239 --> 02:56:10.483
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I hope you keep those things in mind as we move forward.

1502
02:56:10.548 --> 02:56:10.662
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Thank you.

1503
02:56:11.700 --> 02:56:14.111
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1504
02:56:14.676 --> 02:56:15.502
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm next.

1505
02:56:15.889 --> 02:56:19.593
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have one request and one question.

1506
02:56:19.691 --> 02:56:23.326
<v Jamie Dunphy>My question specifically is a very budget-related question with regard to IT.

1507
02:56:24.313 --> 02:56:36.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>There was a line item in there that said, and I'm sort of summarizing, that there were about $2.5 million in savings for reducing duplicative technologies and better contract negotiation.

1508
02:56:37.384 --> 02:56:40.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>But that it was labeled as high risk.

1509
02:56:42.291 --> 02:56:48.627
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could you tell me why that would be a high-risk thing to get rid of duplicative technology or contract negotiation?

1510
02:56:49.468 --> 02:56:51.698
<v Tracy Warren>I think I'll call it— oh, and there she is.

1511
02:56:54.819 --> 02:56:55.698
<v Tracy Warren>Hello, Council President.

1512
02:56:55.745 --> 02:56:56.608
<v Tracy Warren>Hello, councilors.

1513
02:56:57.048 --> 02:56:57.909
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you for the question.

1514
02:56:58.022 --> 02:56:58.852
<v Tracy Warren>Elise Rosenberg.

1515
02:56:58.902 --> 02:57:00.917
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I'm the Director of the Bureau of Technology Services.

1516
02:57:02.031 --> 02:57:06.404
<v Tracy Warren>So I think you're referring to the very words Spreadsheet slide.

1517
02:57:07.147 --> 02:57:18.475
<v Tracy Warren>And so you're correct that we basically made an estimate based on our experience what we could be doing to manage our technology portfolio differently.

1518
02:57:18.555 --> 02:57:23.968
<v Tracy Warren>So get rid of systems that create— that have duplicative functions.

1519
02:57:24.066 --> 02:57:34.297
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>What we found as we've started working with Bureau partners is that many of these folks have developed very complicated workflows and integrations.

1520
02:57:34.363 --> 02:57:34.465
<v Tracy Warren>Right.

1521
02:57:34.852 --> 02:57:36.719
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>Associated with some of those systems.

1522
02:57:37.266 --> 02:57:43.220
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>And so undoing that without breaking the workflow in the business is gonna take a little bit longer.

1523
02:57:44.030 --> 02:57:59.859
<v Tracy Warren>And so what we've done is backed off a little bit in the 17% scenario so that we can phase that in with some more time and take some more care for those things that have workflows across city bureaus or across systems so that we don't break them.

1524
02:57:59.954 --> 02:58:00.084
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

1525
02:58:01.326 --> 02:58:01.459
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

1526
02:58:01.623 --> 02:58:02.647
<v Jamie Dunphy>That makes some sense to me.

1527
02:58:04.319 --> 02:58:13.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>The city historically moves pretty slowly on technology things broadly, and we've built, you know, some heavy systems around antiquated technology.

1528
02:58:14.549 --> 02:58:16.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>I hope we move with some urgency to modernize that.

1529
02:58:17.787 --> 02:58:19.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>But that makes some sense as to why it would be risky.

1530
02:58:23.100 --> 02:58:27.037
<v Jamie Dunphy>More broadly, my next question— just in the effort of being timely, I'll just be a little more broad.

1531
02:58:27.386 --> 02:58:38.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm having a hard time tracking when there is a proposal, and maybe this is more broadly for all the presentations, but when we're saying that there are cuts, reclassifications, and vacancies, I'm having a hard time sort of following where the ball is.

1532
02:58:39.022 --> 02:58:50.587
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there a way we could break that out a little bit more, especially if there are, not for the sake of just knowing, but if there are decision-making points where this body has to actually weigh in, can we break that out a little bit more granularly?

1533
02:58:52.226 --> 02:58:52.459
<v Olivia Clark>Absolutely.

1534
02:58:53.754 --> 02:58:54.046
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

1535
02:58:54.239 --> 02:58:56.346
<v Jamie Dunphy>That will be my only questions for now.

1536
02:58:56.427 --> 02:58:57.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1537
02:58:58.615 --> 02:58:59.604
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1538
02:59:00.299 --> 02:59:04.572
<v Steve Novick>Thank you so much for this presentation, and thanks for the previous preview that we got.

1539
02:59:06.496 --> 02:59:13.443
<v Steve Novick>I will say that to me, this is an example of what to me is kind of a truism, which is that government is rarely as inefficient as we think.

1540
02:59:14.015 --> 02:59:25.031
<v Steve Novick>And the old form of government led to some duplication, inefficiencies, et cetera, but it's not like it was so much It means there was $100 million lying around to be picked up, and I think people need to recognize that.

1541
02:59:25.769 --> 02:59:32.537
<v Steve Novick>I also just want to take this opportunity to make some big sweeping requests of the city administrator and the mayor.

1542
02:59:33.146 --> 02:59:47.518
<v Steve Novick>Administrator Lee, I just want to reiterate what I told you privately a few days ago, and following up on what Councilor Murillo asked about scenarios, the earlier you can get us a variety of different cut scenarios for the bureaus for us to start thinking about, the better.

1543
02:59:48.145 --> 03:00:00.257
<v Steve Novick>And I think we're better off with multiple scenarios based on different assumptions and philosophies for each bureau than just like one cut package, because with any one cut package, a lot of people's reaction is going to be, that's a Washington Monument strategy.

1544
03:00:00.611 --> 03:00:03.856
<v Steve Novick>And if you see several different versions, people are less likely to have that reaction.

1545
03:00:04.548 --> 03:00:14.676
<v Steve Novick>And Mayor, I need to ask you, last year my experience with you was up until pretty much the day you issued your budget, every conversation I had about you with the budget you explained something you weren't going to cut.

1546
03:00:15.226 --> 03:00:19.840
<v Steve Novick>At some point, I went to Michael Jordan and said, when is the man going to acknowledge he's actually going to cut some things?

1547
03:00:20.809 --> 03:00:35.358
<v Steve Novick>So I'm asking you, at least privately and also publicly, to start laying out the actual cuts you're thinking about early so that we can have, you know, thoughtful, rational responses to them rather than knee-jerk responses when you issue your actual budget.

1548
03:00:37.010 --> 03:00:38.045
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, happy to do that.

1549
03:00:38.093 --> 03:00:42.913
<v Sameer Kanal>And you and I are going to be meeting in my office on a frequent basis, and I'll be sharing those challenges.

1550
03:00:44.549 --> 03:00:45.296
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1551
03:00:45.522 --> 03:00:46.397
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal, take us home.

1552
03:00:47.286 --> 03:01:04.885
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, that last piece is really interesting, and I think, not to put Administrator Lee on the spot, but that's one of the reasons why I was really hoping to have some of those cuts not necessarily laid out as formal or final, but the way that it was floated last February was actually very helpful, I think.

1553
03:01:05.272 --> 03:01:10.031
<v Sameer Kanal>For putting some things into the, into the ether and helping, uh, get some feedback on it earlier.

1554
03:01:10.783 --> 03:01:19.324
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I wanted to start by, uh, saying I, I agree with Councilor Zimmerman's note about vacancies not necessarily aligning with where the, the highest or lowest priority needs are.

1555
03:01:19.868 --> 03:01:26.438
<v Sameer Kanal>I also appreciate Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's point about the filled positions and, and the part about combining, uh, realignment and budget cuts.

1556
03:01:26.582 --> 03:01:36.713
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I wanted to, uh, note that my experience with realignment was very different, and it was also during a different period of time in terms of the city's overall budget situation.

1557
03:01:36.762 --> 03:01:41.753
<v Sameer Kanal>And I know our city budget office knows about this quite a bit because she's part of it.

1558
03:01:41.800 --> 03:01:50.097
<v Sameer Kanal>But when we, when we realigned into what is now the public safety service area, the— there, it was attrition-based.

1559
03:01:50.564 --> 03:02:02.709
<v Sameer Kanal>We were moving people together, and separately we were looking at budget cycles, and there wasn't a need to cut overall around the city, but it helped with a difficult change management process.

1560
03:02:04.105 --> 03:02:15.540
<v Sameer Kanal>And it aligned as well with some of the concepts that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney brought up with relation to how backwards it feels to be cutting the core part when we're talking about aligning.

1561
03:02:16.148 --> 03:02:21.793
<v Sameer Kanal>And I mean, it doesn't sound like you're moving into the— moving positions into the core and then eliminating them in these scenarios.

1562
03:02:21.842 --> 03:02:24.247
<v Sameer Kanal>It sounds like they're actually positions that are already in the core.

1563
03:02:24.985 --> 03:02:37.322
<v Tracy Warren>So just just for clarity, the structure is to identify that there will be teams embedded and that there will be teams that are within what we've called the core bureau.

1564
03:02:37.386 --> 03:02:41.059
<v Tracy Warren>But it's just— it's basically the bureau that is providing.

1565
03:02:41.269 --> 03:02:49.146
<v Tracy Warren>Some of the work is to bring people who are currently doing work in bureaus into the core to continue to deliver services.

1566
03:02:49.193 --> 03:02:56.700
<v Tracy Warren>Some is to have them embedded, but all will report centrally and be a part of one team within those different bureaus.

1567
03:02:57.599 --> 03:03:11.583
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I guess what I'm trying to say, when we have public safety present here, especially to anybody on the Enterprise Services side, those are all now DCA's office employees, but they are under Enterprise Services.

1568
03:03:12.272 --> 03:03:15.111
<v Sameer Kanal>They all used to be in police or fire or BOEC or PBEM.

1569
03:03:15.254 --> 03:03:23.472
<v Sameer Kanal>And as those changes happen, I mean, there's people who've been in one of those bureaus since before 2000, the year starting in 1.

1570
03:03:24.147 --> 03:03:38.114
<v Sameer Kanal>And there was a, I think, a positive impact on change management, which was still difficult and imperfect, associated with really separating out the function of doing the budget conversation and the realignment.

1571
03:03:38.244 --> 03:03:40.138
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to flag that.

1572
03:03:41.342 --> 03:03:47.844
<v Sameer Kanal>The other piece that I wanted to bring up, Is there's a slide in here about internal engagement.

1573
03:03:48.022 --> 03:03:54.637
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a 5-step process of what you've been going on, and I think the last step is us right now having this conversation.

1574
03:03:55.376 --> 03:03:59.438
<v Sameer Kanal>It's slide 6.

1575
03:03:59.968 --> 03:04:00.690
<v Skyler Bruckner-Knapp>I know what you're talking about.

1576
03:04:00.771 --> 03:04:04.816
<v Sameer Kanal>Data and analysis, strategic planning, internal engagement, proposal, and council.

1577
03:04:05.667 --> 03:04:07.242
<v Sameer Kanal>And we're obviously number 5.

1578
03:04:08.140 --> 03:04:19.314
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you, I think it would be fair to assume based on who's in the room, but I'm going to guess that— actually, I'm not going to guess.

1579
03:04:19.361 --> 03:04:19.989
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just going to ask.

1580
03:04:20.310 --> 03:04:22.146
<v Sameer Kanal>What was the nature of the internal engagement?

1581
03:04:22.579 --> 03:04:24.880
<v Sameer Kanal>Did it include the particular labor partners?

1582
03:04:24.944 --> 03:04:26.424
<v Sameer Kanal>Did it include the particular managers?

1583
03:04:28.183 --> 03:04:28.682
<v Sameer Kanal>How did that work?

1584
03:04:29.373 --> 03:04:29.630
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah.

1585
03:04:29.727 --> 03:04:34.908
<v Tracy Warren>So there was some early-on engagement before we got to the data and analysis phase.

1586
03:04:35.532 --> 03:04:39.210
<v Tracy Warren>That was where we first started introducing the project.

1587
03:04:39.692 --> 03:04:45.329
<v Tracy Warren>And basically what it included was work groups and subgroups for HR, IT, procurement.

1588
03:04:45.956 --> 03:04:50.164
<v Tracy Warren>I'm not sure, I think budget and finance was on a little bit of a separate track.

1589
03:04:51.175 --> 03:04:56.507
<v Tracy Warren>And what they did is they had folks come together as representatives of that work.

1590
03:04:56.587 --> 03:05:01.759
<v Tracy Warren>So not every single person who does that work was included, but there was representatives of the work.

1591
03:05:02.834 --> 03:05:06.817
<v Tracy Warren>Based on the functional tasks that they were considering.

1592
03:05:06.995 --> 03:05:11.282
<v Tracy Warren>They got together, they worked through a series of workgroup conversations.

1593
03:05:11.828 --> 03:05:16.985
<v Tracy Warren>That information was taken into consideration as the design was developed.

1594
03:05:17.772 --> 03:05:19.602
<v Tracy Warren>There was a lot of data analysis.

1595
03:05:19.780 --> 03:05:21.530
<v Tracy Warren>The design was developed with that.

1596
03:05:22.012 --> 03:05:42.240
<v Tracy Warren>Now we're getting to, okay, now that we know what it looks like and we actually have something that we can share with employees to get their feedback related to what service level agreements might look like and how we might organize this work into the new model, we're going to start engaging more.

1597
03:05:43.015 --> 03:05:53.202
<v Tracy Warren>But really, there wasn't a lot in between those initial work groups and getting here that had direct employee feedback who's doing the work.

1598
03:05:53.364 --> 03:05:58.825
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm sorry, we are at 5:01 and we are about to lose We're going to recess the quorum because, uh, councilors need to catch a bus.

1599
03:05:59.036 --> 03:06:01.531
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we can follow up with additional questions.

1600
03:06:01.871 --> 03:06:02.907
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, council is co-creation.

1601
03:06:03.541 --> 03:06:03.688
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thanks.

1602
03:06:03.786 --> 03:06:04.094
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1603
03:06:04.256 --> 03:06:05.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

1604
03:06:05.557 --> 03:06:06.403
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are at time.

1605
03:06:06.710 --> 03:06:07.783
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are adjourned.

1606
03:06:07.914 --> 03:06:09.198
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you everybody for being here today.

