WEBVTT

1
00:02:39.177 --> 00:02:40.019
<v Loretta Smith>Keelan, I'm here.

2
00:02:40.390 --> 00:02:41.408
<v Loretta Smith>This is Councilor Smith.

3
00:03:12.995 --> 00:03:14.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you hear us online, Councilor Smith?

4
00:03:16.258 --> 00:03:17.021
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, I am.

5
00:03:17.719 --> 00:03:18.206
<v Olivia Clark>We can hear you.

6
00:03:18.353 --> 00:03:18.612
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

7
00:04:37.029 --> 00:04:37.218
<v Angelita Morillo>Good morning.

8
00:04:37.281 --> 00:04:37.723
<v Keith Wilson>Good morning.

9
00:05:07.745 --> 00:05:14.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>Calling to order the Wednesday— no, Thursday, March 5th work session of the Portland City Council.

10
00:05:17.577 --> 00:05:21.653
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this morning we're going to spend some— hear a presentation from our friends at the Housing Bureau.

11
00:05:21.701 --> 00:05:25.711
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're going to have ample time for discussion about the unspent Housing Bureau dollars.

12
00:05:26.211 --> 00:05:31.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to be turning facilitation of this meeting over to the chair of the Housing and Homelessness Committee, Councilor Avalos.

13
00:05:31.939 --> 00:05:32.196
<v Jamie Dunphy>Take it away.

14
00:05:33.961 --> 00:05:35.353
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much, Council President.

15
00:05:35.434 --> 00:05:36.531
<v Candace Avalos>So good morning, colleagues.

16
00:05:36.579 --> 00:05:37.333
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for being here.

17
00:05:39.052 --> 00:05:51.478
<v Candace Avalos>So we have taken a long winding road to get to this point, but I'd like us to put aside any frustrations with the extended process and focus on the important opportunity in front of us.

18
00:05:52.093 --> 00:05:59.442
<v Candace Avalos>As many of you know, Council recently identified approximately $106 million in housing-related balances that were not previously budgeted for allocation.

19
00:06:00.043 --> 00:06:11.625
<v Candace Avalos>So today's work session is an opportunity for us to step back and ensure that we all share a common understanding understanding of the funding available to us, the constraints attached to those funds, and the range of policy options before council.

20
00:06:12.651 --> 00:06:22.225
<v Candace Avalos>Over the past several months, council has had substantial conversations about housing priorities, including prevention strategies, housing production, and longer-term structural solutions.

21
00:06:22.771 --> 00:06:32.019
<v Candace Avalos>Today is not meant to start those conversations from scratch, but rather to build on that work and provide space for a comprehensive discussion about how these resources might Thank you, Councilor Smith.

22
00:06:32.019 --> 00:06:32.019
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Mayor.

23
00:06:32.019 --> 00:06:32.019
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Smith, you have the floor.

24
00:06:32.019 --> 00:06:32.019
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Mayor.

25
00:06:32.019 --> 00:06:32.019
<v Candace Avalos>I'm pleased to be here today to discuss the proposed 2024-25 housing budget.

26
00:06:32.019 --> 00:06:32.019
<v Candace Avalos>This is a critical document for the city of Portland.

27
00:06:32.019 --> 00:06:34.439
<v Candace Avalos>It outlines the funding priorities and constraints that will be available to support our shared housing goals.

28
00:06:34.439 --> 00:06:41.649
<v Candace Avalos>This session is designed primarily as a working discussion among council, supported by staff to help clarify the technical details.

29
00:06:42.199 --> 00:06:57.279
<v Candace Avalos>And my hope is that by the end of the conversation, we will have a shared understanding of the funding categories and constraints, clarity around areas where councilors may already have alignment, a clearer sense of where additional discussion or policy development may be needed.

30
00:06:57.279 --> 00:07:10.678
<v Candace Avalos>And this is also the time to surface new ideas or priorities if councilors believe there are gaps in the options currently We are going to begin with a staff presentation to ground us in the financial details and then move into 2 structured discussion blocks.

31
00:07:11.175 --> 00:07:17.576
<v Candace Avalos>First, we're gonna focus on clarifying the available options and then on policy priorities and potential allocation approaches.

32
00:07:18.026 --> 00:07:26.271
<v Candace Avalos>So my role today will simply be to help facilitate the conversation, ensure that everyone has the space to contribute, and keep us moving through the agenda.

33
00:07:26.672 --> 00:07:29.576
<v Candace Avalos>And so with that, I'm gonna turn it over to staff for the first part of our presentation.

34
00:07:29.639 --> 00:07:30.264
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator.

35
00:07:30.619 --> 00:07:31.129
<v Candace Avalos>Come on up.

36
00:07:43.009 --> 00:07:44.824
<v Donnie Oliveira>Who's, who's driving?

37
00:07:46.024 --> 00:07:46.769
<v Michael Bonacore>Uh, Priya.

38
00:07:55.401 --> 00:07:57.069
<v Michael Bonacore>Good morning, Council President, councilors.

39
00:07:57.427 --> 00:08:00.115
<v Michael Bonacore>Michael Bonacore, interim, uh, director for the Portland Housing Bureau.

40
00:08:02.548 --> 00:08:10.915
<v Michael Bonacore>I wanna start by saying thank you all for the time that you spent in the small briefings leading up to today.

41
00:08:11.764 --> 00:08:28.821
<v Michael Bonacore>As Donnie said, we used those conversations to sort of hone our presentation, get more clear on what kind of information is gonna be most helpful for you and for the public to, you know, understand this issue as clearly as possible.

42
00:08:30.216 --> 00:08:33.149
<v Michael Bonacore>So as I tee this up, just a few things in that realm.

43
00:08:34.929 --> 00:08:41.577
<v Michael Bonacore>We tuned into terminology that we're using and clarity in how we present information.

44
00:08:41.706 --> 00:08:46.265
<v Michael Bonacore>So you're not going to see references to NOFAs or RFPs.

45
00:08:46.330 --> 00:08:56.991
<v Michael Bonacore>You're going to see the word solicitation, which simply means any number of ways by which resources are made available to the public through competitive processes.

46
00:08:57.490 --> 00:08:58.677
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you.

47
00:08:59.274 --> 00:09:06.278
<v Michael Bonacore>There is one reference to contingency, and it's a very specific— specifically used.

48
00:09:06.841 --> 00:09:12.671
<v Michael Bonacore>But otherwise, we're basically talking about these funds as held for future expenditure.

49
00:09:14.912 --> 00:09:19.392
<v Michael Bonacore>The old deck referred to unrestricted contingency, which caused some confusion.

50
00:09:20.134 --> 00:09:27.908
<v Michael Bonacore>You'll now see funds presented as having committed uses or PHB proposed uses, and I'll point it out when we When we get there.

51
00:09:29.340 --> 00:09:33.674
<v Michael Bonacore>The presentation of funds across multiple years wasn't super helpful in some cases.

52
00:09:33.855 --> 00:09:34.248
<v Michael Bonacore>It was confusing.

53
00:09:35.500 --> 00:09:41.390
<v Michael Bonacore>So we're now using rounded numbers that you can easily track up and down columns and across rows.

54
00:09:41.907 --> 00:09:49.177
<v Michael Bonacore>And then at the end, we'll tie those numbers back to what was presented in CA Lee's memo so it's easy to track between the two.

55
00:09:50.714 --> 00:09:55.374
<v Michael Bonacore>As a reminder, as we said in the briefings, federal grants are excluded from this exercise.

56
00:09:56.038 --> 00:10:05.653
<v Michael Bonacore>Those are driven by approved grant plans and held by the sponsor, usually HUD, and distributed to us on a reimbursement basis, not held as cash on hand.

57
00:10:08.037 --> 00:10:25.499
<v Michael Bonacore>And we weren't sure as we approached those small group briefings what your appetite might be for sort of context setting and information sharing about how PHB manages its funds and makes long-term investment decisions, how our funds are monitored.

58
00:10:26.330 --> 00:10:28.221
<v Michael Bonacore>We heard back that you are interested in learning more.

59
00:10:28.287 --> 00:10:28.384
<v Adrian Delgado>Thank you.

60
00:10:28.615 --> 00:10:29.552
<v Michael Bonacore>More rather than less.

61
00:10:29.907 --> 00:10:33.166
<v Michael Bonacore>And so you'll see that as we now get into the presentation.

62
00:10:33.860 --> 00:10:39.427
<v Michael Bonacore>And with all that said, I appreciate— I know you all are willing to hold your questions to the end.

63
00:10:39.590 --> 00:10:40.543
<v Michael Bonacore>I know you'll have many.

64
00:10:40.818 --> 00:10:45.120
<v Michael Bonacore>I'll be happy to start all the way back from the beginning of the deck if that's what's most helpful to you all.

65
00:10:45.168 --> 00:10:46.510
<v Michael Bonacore>So thank you for that.

66
00:10:47.620 --> 00:10:48.327
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

67
00:10:51.918 --> 00:11:03.304
<v Michael Bonacore>So we'll be going through this presentation in 3 chunks, some background, some information about how we have managed our accrued funds, and Then we'll get into the detail of the subfund balances.

68
00:11:03.659 --> 00:11:04.014
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

69
00:11:07.599 --> 00:11:17.067
<v Michael Bonacore>So these first few slides of background try to get at some of the questions in the vein of where was the money, who can see the money, how is money accounted for.

70
00:11:17.845 --> 00:11:19.399
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

71
00:11:21.648 --> 00:11:27.721
<v Michael Bonacore>So first, let's talk about the ACFR, the Annual Comprehensive Financial Reports.

72
00:11:28.783 --> 00:11:37.163
<v Michael Bonacore>From the city's website, the accounting departments of the City of Portland and Prosper Portland prepare financial statements, also known as annual comprehensive financial reports.

73
00:11:38.000 --> 00:11:43.265
<v Michael Bonacore>An external financial auditor audits these financial statements every year and issues audit opinions.

74
00:11:43.879 --> 00:11:52.272
<v Michael Bonacore>The ending fund balances for the prior fiscal year are displayed in the ACFR, which is presented annually to City Council and is published on the city's public website.

75
00:11:52.720 --> 00:11:53.116
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

76
00:11:55.385 --> 00:12:10.710
<v Michael Bonacore>So All of the Portland Housing Bureau's funds are represented in the ACFER, maddeningly misrepresented as AFKER in the title, so apologies for that.

77
00:12:14.057 --> 00:12:18.614
<v Michael Bonacore>So all of the funds are represented here, including those that were excluded from the forward-looking budget.

78
00:12:19.582 --> 00:12:22.860
<v Michael Bonacore>No funds have been found to be missing or misspent or in the wrong place.

79
00:12:23.785 --> 00:12:36.410
<v Michael Bonacore>However, presenting funding in this way requires translation for council and the public to understand how these ending Fund balances carry over into each new fiscal year budget and what is proposed to be held for future expenditures.

80
00:12:36.539 --> 00:12:43.000
<v Michael Bonacore>In other words, the money's all there, but you can't just look at that and understand how that translates into our budget.

81
00:12:44.350 --> 00:12:52.559
<v Michael Bonacore>And PHB's responsibility is to present that information clearly to Council during the budget process so it has information for its deliberations and decision-making.

82
00:12:52.817 --> 00:13:01.273
<v Michael Bonacore>So said simply, as you've heard me say before, That is not how PHB has ever presented its budget in the past.

83
00:13:01.822 --> 00:13:07.871
<v Michael Bonacore>That is a process that we are going through now in collaboration with CBO and with Jonas.

84
00:13:10.009 --> 00:13:14.297
<v Michael Bonacore>It is a really significant transition process, and it is still underway.

85
00:13:15.508 --> 00:13:35.470
<v Michael Bonacore>Once that change is made, it will be made forever, and you will be able to look at the full picture of our finances in a way that has not Heretofore been available to you and therefore limits your ability to fully understand your decision-making authority in the budget process.

86
00:13:35.937 --> 00:13:36.806
<v Michael Bonacore>So we will fix that.

87
00:13:39.803 --> 00:13:50.748
<v Michael Bonacore>In addition to the ACVOR process, PHB also goes and undergoes an annual audit of its federal HUD grants through the City of Portland's single audit, which is also published on portland.gov.

88
00:13:51.318 --> 00:13:51.807
<v Michael Bonacore>Link is there.

89
00:13:52.039 --> 00:13:58.932
<v Michael Bonacore>And then finally, an external audit of the Portland Housing Bond is required every year until all funds are fully expended.

90
00:13:59.767 --> 00:14:06.788
<v Michael Bonacore>Between these 3 processes, PHB has been audited 14 times since 2020 with zero financial findings.

91
00:14:06.932 --> 00:14:17.208
<v Michael Bonacore>Now, it's also important to say that in this process, you all have asked for a comprehensive audit of the Bureau, and that is not the same as these.

92
00:14:18.302 --> 00:14:25.892
<v Michael Bonacore>I want to acknowledge that difference and that we are committed to going through that process and making those findings available to you all.

93
00:14:27.289 --> 00:14:27.677
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

94
00:14:29.806 --> 00:14:39.643
<v Michael Bonacore>I think we all understand this now, but the public, I think, does not yet fully understand that there is not $106 million to spend.

95
00:14:40.826 --> 00:14:46.690
<v Michael Bonacore>It's important to be honest that the $21 million in unspent Rental Services Office funds Yes.

96
00:14:46.754 --> 00:14:47.769
<v Michael Bonacore>So that is a specific issue.

97
00:14:47.914 --> 00:14:50.075
<v Michael Bonacore>Those funds should have been put out into the community.

98
00:14:50.187 --> 00:14:56.163
<v Michael Bonacore>Those are operating dollars and they should have been deployed, not held and accumulated at that level.

99
00:14:57.673 --> 00:15:02.543
<v Michael Bonacore>The remaining amount in the total of $106 million is largely committed.

100
00:15:03.153 --> 00:15:09.649
<v Michael Bonacore>So they're tied to specific commitments or proposed plans for future housing-related priorities.

101
00:15:10.475 --> 00:15:19.256
<v Michael Bonacore>However, you all have the opportunity to make different choices than what PHB has proposed, and we look forward to having that conversation and potentially trade-offs with you.

102
00:15:20.086 --> 00:15:21.158
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

103
00:15:22.182 --> 00:15:30.528
<v Michael Bonacore>So a bit more background, a lot of which you have seen, but we'll review, especially again for the public's benefit, along with some new information.

104
00:15:31.549 --> 00:15:31.919
<v Eric Zimmerman>Next slide.

105
00:15:35.365 --> 00:15:55.461
<v Michael Bonacore>So as you've heard me say, we typically wait until we have at least $20 million to put out in a solicitation Often it's a larger amount than that, but at least that amount allows us to fund a few projects at a reasonably significant level to do some important work.

106
00:15:56.923 --> 00:16:06.402
<v Michael Bonacore>On the left side of that sunburst, you look at the different sources of funds and see how long on their own it would take for them to accrue to those amounts.

107
00:16:06.964 --> 00:16:17.214
<v Michael Bonacore>And so the way that— The Bureau manages those solicitations is to braid those funds together and get them out at a sort of a regular cadence.

108
00:16:19.058 --> 00:16:28.192
<v Michael Bonacore>And then on the other side of the sunburst is the development process and the disbursement of funds, which typically lasts anywhere from 5 to 7 years.

109
00:16:28.791 --> 00:16:31.298
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

110
00:16:33.740 --> 00:16:49.259
<v Michael Bonacore>Some information we hadn't broken out for you in the past, but the sort of the Value of a solicitation process is that it gives us the opportunity to define what kinds of goals we're trying to achieve with the money that we're putting out into the community.

111
00:16:49.995 --> 00:16:57.354
<v Michael Bonacore>Things like the number of units, bedroom sizes, permanent supportive housing, affordability, populations served, and geographies.

112
00:16:58.412 --> 00:17:04.536
<v Michael Bonacore>It gives us the opportunity to determine whether to release properties along with cash.

113
00:17:05.080 --> 00:17:13.332
<v Michael Bonacore>So there are PHB-controlled sites that we can pair with available funding to sort of increase the impact of those projects.

114
00:17:14.779 --> 00:17:26.055
<v Michael Bonacore>We are on the verge of releasing a production NOFA in which a property in Mount Tabor and a property in Gateway will be made available along with funding.

115
00:17:27.930 --> 00:17:32.602
<v Michael Bonacore>This also gives us the opportunity to articulate funding requirements and restrictions.

116
00:17:33.950 --> 00:17:41.885
<v Michael Bonacore>So things like our own internal policies around maximum subsidy per unit, cost containment priorities, And funding source parameters.

117
00:17:41.933 --> 00:17:50.551
<v Michael Bonacore>So each of those funding types that we looked at, you know, comes with its own sort of sets of requirements and parameters.

118
00:17:50.808 --> 00:17:52.846
<v Michael Bonacore>And parenthetically, you see early investor.

119
00:17:52.991 --> 00:18:05.942
<v Michael Bonacore>Very often we are an early investor, if not the first money in, and that gives us the opportunity to have more ability to define some of these issues such as cost containment that may be important to us.

120
00:18:06.392 --> 00:18:23.199
<v Michael Bonacore>Once a project is farther in the development, cycle, those things are already baked in and there's less leverage for us to sort of get the kinds of impacts that we may sort of have defined earlier on if we were— if it was— if we were early money.

121
00:18:24.181 --> 00:18:32.425
<v Michael Bonacore>And then importantly, these solicitations allow us to conduct outreach and provide information sessions before the solicitations are released.

122
00:18:33.616 --> 00:18:39.300
<v Michael Bonacore>And that gives— makes sure that there's a fair opportunity that folks in the community know this money will be coming available and have—.

123
00:18:39.300 --> 00:18:39.384
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

124
00:18:41.390 --> 00:18:48.018
<v Michael Bonacore>The opportunity to put forward their eligible project— projects for consideration through a public competitive process.

125
00:18:48.869 --> 00:18:49.240
<v Jonas Biery>Next slide.

126
00:18:52.461 --> 00:18:55.876
<v Michael Bonacore>So here's a look back at the last 5 years of housing production.

127
00:18:55.990 --> 00:18:59.878
<v Michael Bonacore>It sort of reinforces the idea that we braid funds.

128
00:18:59.942 --> 00:19:07.884
<v Michael Bonacore>And if you look in each of these years, the combination of funds, types of funds that were put together are different in each of the years.

129
00:19:09.861 --> 00:19:13.178
<v Michael Bonacore>Currently, there are about 40 projects at various development stages.

130
00:19:14.655 --> 00:19:20.424
<v Michael Bonacore>And as we get to— actually, go ahead, next slide.

131
00:19:21.195 --> 00:19:31.933
<v Michael Bonacore>So when you look at this slide, this sort of talks about the process from beginning to end, and PHB staff are engaged in that process throughout the entire lifecycle.

132
00:19:32.063 --> 00:19:37.001
<v Michael Bonacore>So from the beginning where we're defining what the solicitation is and then managing that selection process, Yes.

133
00:19:37.868 --> 00:19:44.067
<v Michael Bonacore>Assessing eligibility and qualifications of the projects to pre-development, construction, and lease-up.

134
00:19:44.211 --> 00:19:54.599
<v Michael Bonacore>There are roles that technical experts in the Bureau play to sort of help guide and support the projects in the development lifecycle.

135
00:19:55.066 --> 00:20:10.407
<v Michael Bonacore>So as we think about how, you know, how we're pacing the release of funds into the community, we're also thinking about how all these projects stack up and the bandwidth of the staff to manage all of them.

136
00:20:11.037 --> 00:20:11.489
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

137
00:20:14.692 --> 00:20:19.592
<v Michael Bonacore>So this is a slight variation on a slide we talked about in the briefings.

138
00:20:19.851 --> 00:20:31.019
<v Michael Bonacore>I had said verbally that if you imagined looking backward from '26-'27, you would see Yeah.

139
00:20:31.164 --> 00:20:35.256
<v Michael Bonacore>You know, bars that are of a significant height.

140
00:20:35.385 --> 00:20:43.468
<v Michael Bonacore>And when you look at them, you see just sort of what a stark contrast these next 5 years will be as funding declines.

141
00:20:43.516 --> 00:20:54.948
<v Michael Bonacore>In particular, you can see sort of the stark decrease of the bonds and the diminishment of TIF.

142
00:20:55.291 --> 00:21:04.835
<v Michael Bonacore>And so as we think about, You know, what the future looks like and understanding too that a forecast is simply a forecast.

143
00:21:04.948 --> 00:21:08.683
<v Michael Bonacore>We don't know if there could be another housing revenue source that becomes available.

144
00:21:09.622 --> 00:21:14.036
<v Michael Bonacore>We don't know if the federal government will step up differently than it has in the last few years.

145
00:21:14.148 --> 00:21:24.085
<v Michael Bonacore>But based on what we know, we're expecting these next few years to be not resource-rich in the way that they have in the last several years for us.

146
00:21:24.683 --> 00:21:25.117
<v Jonas Biery>Next slide.

147
00:21:29.166 --> 00:21:42.311
<v Michael Bonacore>And again, this is just a snapshot of that work over the past 5 years, which has resulted in over half a billion dollars of economic activity and renter support and housing production in the community.

148
00:21:43.454 --> 00:21:43.760
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

149
00:21:46.048 --> 00:22:01.876
<v Michael Bonacore>So now we get back into the presentation of the fund balances and sort of how those are Either committed or what the plans are for their future and how you might want to consider those.

150
00:22:02.200 --> 00:22:02.520
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

151
00:22:05.444 --> 00:22:08.353
<v Michael Bonacore>So this one falls under the inclusionary housing umbrella.

152
00:22:08.498 --> 00:22:13.458
<v Michael Bonacore>And if you look at the 3rd column, you'll see the phrase committed uses.

153
00:22:14.606 --> 00:22:19.769
<v Michael Bonacore>And in the next column, you'll see the phrase PHB planned uses.

154
00:22:19.883 --> 00:22:21.357
<v Michael Bonacore>Hopefully those feel intuitive.

155
00:22:21.911 --> 00:22:23.926
<v Michael Bonacore>In the committed uses column, you'll see—.

156
00:22:23.926 --> 00:22:24.397
<v Jonas Biery>Councilmember Herbold.

157
00:22:25.910 --> 00:22:36.092
<v Michael Bonacore>Specific projects that we have made commitments to or ongoing program operating costs.

158
00:22:37.021 --> 00:22:44.461
<v Michael Bonacore>And then on the planned uses side, you see where we have plans for future solicitations.

159
00:22:45.278 --> 00:22:55.366
<v Michael Bonacore>And those are, you know, policy trade-off conversations for you all to have about whether you do in fact wanna hold those funds for future Solicitations or do something differently.

160
00:22:56.057 --> 00:23:06.942
<v Michael Bonacore>I'll note that while the $6 million contingency is arguably a planned use, Councilor, here's a legit contingency for you.

161
00:23:08.404 --> 00:23:30.123
<v Michael Bonacore>The idea here is that every, pretty much every project that is going through and has recently gone through our development project faces, because of increased interest rates, You know, construction costs gaps that the Housing Bureau sort of negotiates helping to fill, and that ensures their viability to get to the finish line.

162
00:23:30.171 --> 00:23:41.115
<v Michael Bonacore>So there's some jeopardy for actually having those projects make it and having, you know, gaps come up that we wouldn't be able to fill in the absence of that money.

163
00:23:42.695 --> 00:23:43.266
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

164
00:23:45.842 --> 00:23:46.229
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you.

165
00:23:46.309 --> 00:23:53.307
<v Michael Bonacore>So in this table for short-term rental, the 2 types of short-term rental funds, you see only PHB planned uses.

166
00:23:54.180 --> 00:23:58.030
<v Michael Bonacore>There are no specific commitments that have been made with these funds.

167
00:23:58.580 --> 00:24:06.915
<v Michael Bonacore>The intention is to do a preservation solicitation next year with them unless council decides to do something different.

168
00:24:07.159 --> 00:24:21.354
<v Michael Bonacore>And the note here is that given the wind-down of current TIF districts and the lag in revenue from new ones, these 2 funds figure more prominently in our ability to fund preservation and/or new development in the next few years than they have in the years prior.

169
00:24:23.009 --> 00:24:23.444
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

170
00:24:26.346 --> 00:24:29.214
<v Michael Bonacore>So this table is our housing property funds.

171
00:24:30.440 --> 00:24:42.366
<v Michael Bonacore>These represent revenue generated from rents essentially at the properties and are funds that need to go back into for you know, sort of capital needs at the properties.

172
00:24:43.640 --> 00:24:45.338
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

173
00:24:47.476 --> 00:24:54.566
<v Michael Bonacore>Here's a little bit of a ragtag collection of funds, all of which have very prescribed uses for them.

174
00:24:58.451 --> 00:25:02.983
<v Michael Bonacore>And I don't think I need to necessarily talk through each one of them.

175
00:25:03.065 --> 00:25:05.273
<v Michael Bonacore>I think they're labeled pretty clearly.

176
00:25:05.467 --> 00:25:14.417
<v Michael Bonacore>And You know, this isn't a huge amount of money, but they're all in, you know, funds that have very defined uses for them.

177
00:25:15.630 --> 00:25:16.436
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

178
00:25:18.405 --> 00:25:19.326
<v Michael Bonacore>A couple more here.

179
00:25:19.696 --> 00:25:26.276
<v Michael Bonacore>Housing Investment is another fund that will cover staff costs and general fund overhead.

180
00:25:27.111 --> 00:25:33.859
<v Michael Bonacore>This one in particular mitigates the projected decline in program income, including the suspension of SDCs.

181
00:25:34.101 --> 00:25:37.089
<v Michael Bonacore>So with those funds not coming in, As they have been.

182
00:25:37.138 --> 00:25:42.694
<v Michael Bonacore>Now that there's a suspension of SDCs, this becomes sort of an ability to backfill that.

183
00:25:43.583 --> 00:25:52.839
<v Michael Bonacore>And then the risk mitigation pool is designed to reimburse landlords of permanent supportive housing properties for eligible damage claims.

184
00:25:54.079 --> 00:25:54.563
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

185
00:25:56.785 --> 00:25:58.990
<v Michael Bonacore>So this is our last big one.

186
00:25:59.425 --> 00:26:01.084
<v Michael Bonacore>Well, this is our last one, and it's a big one.

187
00:26:01.680 --> 00:26:08.824
<v Michael Bonacore>And these are the TIF So on the left side, you see committed uses.

188
00:26:09.000 --> 00:26:14.839
<v Michael Bonacore>Those are for specific projects and for our home repair program.

189
00:26:15.979 --> 00:26:26.375
<v Michael Bonacore>On the right-hand side, you'll see some of the districts have money that is not currently allocated to specific projects.

190
00:26:26.647 --> 00:26:32.150
<v Michael Bonacore>And so that is typically work that the Bureau does either through solicitations or—.

191
00:26:32.150 --> 00:26:33.048
<v Jonas Biery>Through grants.

192
00:26:33.790 --> 00:26:41.086
<v Michael Bonacore>As primarily through solicitations or as opportunities become sort of made known in those districts.

193
00:26:42.171 --> 00:26:48.786
<v Michael Bonacore>And again, are developed according to action plans that are developed with the community.

194
00:26:51.470 --> 00:26:51.989
<v Dan Ryan>Next slide.

195
00:26:54.977 --> 00:27:08.799
<v Michael Bonacore>So finally, we heard from you all that you wanted to Be able to understand how what we're presenting to you today ties back to the information that you were provided on February 6th from City Administrator Lee.

196
00:27:09.833 --> 00:27:14.221
<v Michael Bonacore>So the 6 tables that I just talked you through total about $93 million.

197
00:27:16.736 --> 00:27:29.516
<v Michael Bonacore>There is an additional $8.9 million of RSO funds under council consideration, plus $1.8 million that were proposed Appropriated in the fall TAO.

198
00:27:30.143 --> 00:27:35.258
<v Michael Bonacore>Just to be super clear, the whole $20.7 million is there and for your decision-making.

199
00:27:37.868 --> 00:27:47.304
<v Michael Bonacore>And then there's another about $6 million that were backed out based on having been budgeted in FY25-26.

200
00:27:48.500 --> 00:27:49.986
<v Michael Bonacore>So if we go to the next slide.

201
00:27:52.161 --> 00:27:57.442
<v Michael Bonacore>So this is the table on page 7 from City Administrator Lee's memo.

202
00:27:57.700 --> 00:27:58.166
<v Donnie Oliveira>If you—.

203
00:27:59.910 --> 00:28:06.500
<v Michael Bonacore>So if you add up the column, the big column of numbers, that totals to $112 million.

204
00:28:06.854 --> 00:28:17.954
<v Michael Bonacore>And if you subtract out the TIF and the Inclusionary Housing Fund line items, as we did on the prior slide, then you get to $106 or $105.9.

205
00:28:22.174 --> 00:28:26.724
<v Michael Bonacore>That, I think, Is the presentation.

206
00:28:27.576 --> 00:28:33.357
<v Michael Bonacore>So we are now happy to take your, take your questions and conversation.

207
00:28:33.647 --> 00:28:35.156
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

208
00:28:36.634 --> 00:28:36.796
<v Candace Avalos>Here we go.

209
00:28:37.920 --> 00:28:38.739
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much.

210
00:28:38.819 --> 00:28:50.979
<v Candace Avalos>So colleagues, what we're going to do now is we're going to enter a period of technical questions, and then after that we'll take a quick break, and then we'll come back and do the facilitated discussion for— with the prompts that you received over email.

211
00:28:52.117 --> 00:28:57.056
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

212
00:28:57.715 --> 00:28:58.987
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you all so much for this presentation.

213
00:29:01.432 --> 00:29:05.586
<v Angelita Morillo>I had a question about the housing beginning fund balances.

214
00:29:07.118 --> 00:29:15.556
<v Angelita Morillo>So on Tuesday, the City Budget Office sent out the beginning fund balance information for all funds in the city to city financial analysts to reconcile.

215
00:29:17.386 --> 00:29:25.912
<v Angelita Morillo>And from that information provided, the total beginning fund balance across all housing funds, general fund not included, is $145 million.

216
00:29:26.592 --> 00:29:32.221
<v Angelita Morillo>We know that $8 million of that has been budgeted, leaving a net beginning fund balance of $137 million.

217
00:29:33.722 --> 00:29:45.227
<v Angelita Morillo>So right now we've been having a discussion of $106 million, and I'm wondering if you can explain the discrepancy there, because we have not been talking about $137 million.

218
00:29:45.307 --> 00:29:46.049
<v Angelita Morillo>We've been talking about $106 million.

219
00:29:46.097 --> 00:29:46.194
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

220
00:29:48.385 --> 00:29:51.163
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you, Councilor, for the question.

221
00:29:51.211 --> 00:29:57.990
<v Jonas Biery>And yeah, this was highlighted, and I'll give a sort of a partial answer that may not be super satisfactory.

222
00:29:58.538 --> 00:30:00.939
<v Jonas Biery>I'm honestly struggling to track those numbers.

223
00:30:01.035 --> 00:30:09.307
<v Jonas Biery>I know I've seen numbers that were kind of provided to your office that track somewhat, but it's a little unclear.

224
00:30:09.453 --> 00:30:12.019
<v Jonas Biery>And so I'm— I can give you a number.

225
00:30:14.198 --> 00:30:21.387
<v Jonas Biery>Hesitant to acknowledge that because I need to frankly do a little more due diligence to understand the source of those numbers.

226
00:30:21.740 --> 00:30:28.128
<v Jonas Biery>I've also looked at the CBO email from Tuesday and I'm not coming up with that same math.

227
00:30:28.241 --> 00:30:31.980
<v Jonas Biery>So I'm not saying it's wrong, I just haven't been able to sort of independently verify that.

228
00:30:33.377 --> 00:30:39.974
<v Jonas Biery>The other thing I'll note is that the ACFER ending fund balance, we're talking about a '24-'25 balance.

229
00:30:40.022 --> 00:30:48.214
<v Jonas Biery>The numbers we've been talking about now are for '26-'27 and there's kind of a, A gap fiscal year in there in which expenditures have been made.

230
00:30:48.731 --> 00:30:51.960
<v Jonas Biery>We know there's at least $8 million of that that was budgeted as reflected in the memo.

231
00:30:52.559 --> 00:31:06.587
<v Jonas Biery>And so we're trying to identify if that delta is a nuance of sort of the accounting accrual for determining that fund balance amount, the ending fund balance in '24-'25.

232
00:31:07.415 --> 00:31:09.884
<v Jonas Biery>Is there something that was budgeted as perhaps a transfer?

233
00:31:09.932 --> 00:31:10.013
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

234
00:31:10.546 --> 00:31:12.680
<v Jonas Biery>That wasn't showing up in the programmatic budget.

235
00:31:13.198 --> 00:31:16.010
<v Jonas Biery>And so we're looking to identify that as well.

236
00:31:16.124 --> 00:31:18.824
<v Jonas Biery>So I just appreciate the additional due diligence.

237
00:31:19.519 --> 00:31:25.287
<v Jonas Biery>We will have it corrected and transparently reported, the reasons for that, in the spring TAO.

238
00:31:25.804 --> 00:31:35.990
<v Jonas Biery>I just want to be really cautious that we're not continuing sort of a legacy over the last few months of providing information that isn't perfectly accurate.

239
00:31:36.071 --> 00:31:36.619
<v Jonas Biery>So I just wanted—.

240
00:31:36.619 --> 00:31:36.700
<v Loretta Smith>That's—.

241
00:31:36.700 --> 00:31:36.828
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

242
00:31:37.383 --> 00:31:39.017
<v Jonas Biery>I just want to be clear about that.

243
00:31:39.615 --> 00:31:41.444
<v Jonas Biery>And I don't mean that facetiously.

244
00:31:41.493 --> 00:31:46.888
<v Jonas Biery>I mean that absolutely honestly, that we're trying to figure out, you know, how does that math work?

245
00:31:47.211 --> 00:31:53.930
<v Jonas Biery>And so we can be really clear about what those numbers are and be really clear for council about the reasons for that delta.

246
00:31:55.445 --> 00:31:56.590
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

247
00:31:56.993 --> 00:32:03.088
<v Angelita Morillo>And I appreciate that you're trying to get us the correct numbers so that we don't have misinformation or misunderstandings going out to the public.

248
00:32:03.877 --> 00:32:07.967
<v Angelita Morillo>I will say my staff first reached out about this at the beginning of February.

249
00:32:08.465 --> 00:32:11.492
<v Angelita Morillo>So we are a month out into getting that information.

250
00:32:12.390 --> 00:32:13.114
<v Angelita Morillo>You see how that—.

251
00:32:13.372 --> 00:32:14.112
<v Jonas Biery>I understand.

252
00:32:14.192 --> 00:32:15.288
<v Jonas Biery>And I will also acknowledge that—.

253
00:32:15.288 --> 00:32:16.125
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm not done, sir.

254
00:32:17.976 --> 00:32:24.829
<v Angelita Morillo>These numbers are also published in the ACFR, and the CBO sent those numbers out to the analysts to reconcile.

255
00:32:25.250 --> 00:32:35.566
<v Angelita Morillo>So I'm curious as to why bureaus are being asked to match published beginning fund balances if you don't believe that those are real numbers?

256
00:32:39.905 --> 00:32:40.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

257
00:32:40.613 --> 00:32:42.672
<v Jonas Biery>That's not my suggestion.

258
00:32:43.750 --> 00:32:45.711
<v Jonas Biery>I appreciate your analysts had provided this.

259
00:32:45.840 --> 00:32:49.042
<v Jonas Biery>I appreciate that this is a complex situation that we're all working on.

260
00:32:49.978 --> 00:33:15.849
<v Jonas Biery>Many of us who are doing this work, myself included, were either out of office working on other work, and so it's not We are in a very resource-constrained environment with very, very high expectations, and we're busting our asses trying to get this information accurately to the public in an environment where misinformation is continuing to be shared in the media and otherwise.

261
00:33:16.039 --> 00:33:17.980
<v Jonas Biery>So I appreciate your analysts' work.

262
00:33:17.980 --> 00:33:25.279
<v Jonas Biery>I appreciate the staff at the CBO and in our accounting team who are doing this, and we are working as hard as we can to get those facts out to the public as quickly as possible.

263
00:33:25.279 --> 00:33:25.319
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

264
00:33:31.980 --> 00:33:32.076
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right.

265
00:33:32.663 --> 00:33:35.727
<v Angelita Morillo>But this is the work session where we're supposed to be getting those answers.

266
00:33:37.236 --> 00:33:42.896
<v Angelita Morillo>So we do actually need those answers in this discussion so that we know the dollars that we're working with.

267
00:33:42.961 --> 00:33:57.086
<v Angelita Morillo>Because if there is a difference between $106 million versus $137 million and the number keeps changing, We are dealing with a big issue and council can't talk about it and we can't figure out exactly what is going on.

268
00:33:59.049 --> 00:34:06.804
<v Jonas Biery>Councilor, let me pause that for a second and back up because we do know things that council can decide upon today.

269
00:34:07.357 --> 00:34:08.280
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes, the $21 million.

270
00:34:08.780 --> 00:34:09.105
<v Jonas Biery>Correct.

271
00:34:09.202 --> 00:34:11.675
<v Jonas Biery>We know that the RSO has $20.7 million.

272
00:34:11.789 --> 00:34:17.018
<v Jonas Biery>We've talked about multiple proposals for many weeks about deploying that into the community.

273
00:34:17.722 --> 00:34:25.550
<v Jonas Biery>Director Bonaccor just talked about buckets and if TLDR, And I know there's proposals about realigning that.

274
00:34:26.498 --> 00:34:31.972
<v Jonas Biery>We know that there's other funds, as just described, that have restrictions around them that are much more difficult to redeploy.

275
00:34:32.760 --> 00:34:37.721
<v Jonas Biery>And we know that we have work to do to figure out where that delta, that technical delta lies.

276
00:34:38.331 --> 00:34:40.949
<v Jonas Biery>So I hear you and we're working on it.

277
00:34:41.045 --> 00:34:47.114
<v Jonas Biery>And I also just would acknowledge that that doesn't have to slow down taking action.

278
00:34:47.291 --> 00:34:48.414
<v Jonas Biery>I'm equally as frustrated.

279
00:34:48.463 --> 00:34:48.574
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

280
00:34:48.831 --> 00:34:50.114
<v Jonas Biery>That this is complex.

281
00:34:50.659 --> 00:34:52.088
<v Jonas Biery>It's a multi-year legacy.

282
00:34:52.585 --> 00:35:04.893
<v Jonas Biery>I'm frustrated that we don't have resources to commit the 10 or 12 hours that I and my staff are spending 6 days a week working on all of the city's priorities, that we can't commit all that time to doing just this work.

283
00:35:05.518 --> 00:35:22.806
<v Jonas Biery>I'm frustrated, and I would like to see us be able to start making progress on the things that we can make progress while we're also addressing those other bigger concerns and, and Okay.

284
00:35:23.309 --> 00:35:30.070
<v Angelita Morillo>How often does your office coordinate with the accounting manager to get us accurate numbers?

285
00:35:33.230 --> 00:35:35.052
<v Jonas Biery>I'm not sure I know how to respond to that.

286
00:35:35.117 --> 00:35:39.682
<v Jonas Biery>The city controller reports to me, so that is my office.

287
00:35:40.844 --> 00:35:54.610
<v Jonas Biery>We do, We have some processes in place to have connectivity between what is reflected in the audit, what's reflected in the city's SAP system, and what's used by the bureaus and budget office staff.

288
00:35:56.530 --> 00:35:57.161
<v Jonas Biery>So I'm not sure.

289
00:35:58.344 --> 00:36:02.992
<v Jonas Biery>I mean, that's a multifaceted question.

290
00:36:05.827 --> 00:36:17.543
<v Jonas Biery>There are, meaning there are moments in time where there's specific actions The budget development, for example, the budget manual directs doing that connectivity at the point of doing specific budget actions.

291
00:36:17.833 --> 00:36:23.641
<v Jonas Biery>There are also daily conversations that can occur between staff, between the accounting team and other offices.

292
00:36:24.733 --> 00:36:41.918
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, I just think when we're talking about capacity, the accounting team is being underutilized because if they're going to have those accurate numbers, and I'm not asking gotcha questions, Jonas, like I truly am not trying to, But we are not getting accurate numbers.

293
00:36:43.565 --> 00:36:45.436
<v Angelita Morillo>This feels like it keeps changing.

294
00:36:45.501 --> 00:36:47.860
<v Angelita Morillo>This is the work session for us to discuss it as a body.

295
00:36:48.005 --> 00:36:50.271
<v Angelita Morillo>This is the day that we're all here together to do that.

296
00:36:51.387 --> 00:36:55.335
<v Angelita Morillo>And I don't think I'm asking complicated trick questions.

297
00:36:55.431 --> 00:36:57.112
<v Angelita Morillo>We need those accurate numbers.

298
00:36:57.371 --> 00:36:57.905
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, I understand.

299
00:36:57.954 --> 00:37:01.639
<v Jonas Biery>I just would be cautious about suggesting that the numbers are not accurate.

300
00:37:02.231 --> 00:37:06.873
<v Jonas Biery>I think that the numbers you're receiving are accurate and there's context.

301
00:37:08.244 --> 00:37:14.340
<v Jonas Biery>Around those accurate numbers that we need to do a better job of due diligencing and being able to describe.

302
00:37:14.836 --> 00:37:18.719
<v Jonas Biery>So I want to be really careful in continuing the narrative that there are inaccurate numbers.

303
00:37:19.233 --> 00:37:25.311
<v Jonas Biery>There was certainly an environment where things were not budgeted the way they should have been, and that's why we're here talking about this today.

304
00:37:26.210 --> 00:37:29.596
<v Jonas Biery>That is not the same as producing inaccurate numbers.

305
00:37:29.643 --> 00:37:33.686
<v Jonas Biery>So I just want to be really cautious in continuing that narrative that frankly has continued for a while.

306
00:37:33.751 --> 00:37:34.007
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

307
00:37:34.458 --> 00:37:35.378
<v Jonas Biery>I mean, it's true.

308
00:37:35.619 --> 00:37:45.929
<v Jonas Biery>I mean, it's true that it's an important piece of conversation, but it has also continued to kind of have us stumble over our feet in getting to some resolution on this specific item.

309
00:37:45.976 --> 00:37:46.268
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

310
00:37:46.719 --> 00:37:50.206
<v Angelita Morillo>And, you know, my staff informed you this was something they were looking into.

311
00:37:50.351 --> 00:37:52.835
<v Angelita Morillo>I informed you yesterday that this was something I would ask about.

312
00:37:53.014 --> 00:37:54.505
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm not catching anyone off guard.

313
00:37:54.748 --> 00:37:57.427
<v Angelita Morillo>So let's not pretend I'm doing anything unexpected.

314
00:37:57.492 --> 00:37:57.719
<v Angelita Morillo>Understood.

315
00:37:57.815 --> 00:37:58.855
<v Jonas Biery>Totally understand, Councilor.

316
00:37:58.936 --> 00:38:05.014
<v Jonas Biery>Just appreciate your Your Grace, in recognizing that we just haven't had time to fully vet that.

317
00:38:05.594 --> 00:38:09.494
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes, we've had a month, and this is the work session to clear up the narratives.

318
00:38:09.590 --> 00:38:11.675
<v Angelita Morillo>So we need answers when we ask questions.

319
00:38:11.789 --> 00:38:13.293
<v Angelita Morillo>That is the expectation, frankly.

320
00:38:13.728 --> 00:38:15.409
<v Angelita Morillo>But I'm done with my questions for now.

321
00:38:17.784 --> 00:38:18.496
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor.

322
00:38:18.592 --> 00:38:19.257
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Novick.

323
00:38:19.789 --> 00:38:21.925
<v Steve Novick>Oh, you just got it.

324
00:38:21.974 --> 00:38:22.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, go ahead.

325
00:38:22.394 --> 00:38:22.815
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

326
00:38:24.123 --> 00:38:29.969
<v Steve Novick>So one of my priorities, frankly, is to see how much we can get to the general fund of all of this.

327
00:38:30.762 --> 00:38:40.628
<v Steve Novick>And so I'd appreciate it if you could tell me, for each of the funds you've talked about, what potential might there be to return some money or to, to give some money to the general fund?

328
00:38:43.487 --> 00:38:48.972
<v Michael Bonacore>My good friend Adrian Delgado is in the audience, so I'll ask Adrian to come up and give us some guidance.

329
00:38:55.840 --> 00:38:58.697
<v Loretta Smith>Good morning.

330
00:38:59.146 --> 00:39:00.896
<v Adrian Delgado>Thank you for the question.

331
00:39:01.074 --> 00:39:03.626
<v Adrian Delgado>Adrian Delgado, City Attorney's Office, for the record.

332
00:39:04.478 --> 00:39:10.804
<v Adrian Delgado>So I don't know that I'm going to be able to match up those funds, but I can just go through the memo that—.

333
00:39:10.804 --> 00:39:12.538
<v Sameer Kanal>Adrian, your microphone is not on.

334
00:39:12.650 --> 00:39:13.791
<v Dan Ryan>Hold on just a quick second.

335
00:39:13.871 --> 00:39:15.588
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know if you can turn it on or if we turn that on.

336
00:39:16.744 --> 00:39:17.179
<v Loretta Smith>No.

337
00:39:17.563 --> 00:39:20.005
<v Michael Bonacore>Do you want to take my switch?

338
00:39:23.954 --> 00:39:24.740
<v Adrian Delgado>Oh, now it's on.

339
00:39:25.239 --> 00:39:27.262
<v Adrian Delgado>Well, I'll get your tea.

340
00:39:28.626 --> 00:39:31.853
<v Adrian Delgado>All right, so I'll go through the memo and just identify funds for you.

341
00:39:32.143 --> 00:39:38.181
<v Adrian Delgado>Um, they're not going to necessarily match up to what was presented, but hopefully we can figure that out.

342
00:39:39.304 --> 00:39:49.719
<v Adrian Delgado>All right, so unrestricted general funds, we've got the Local Housing Trust Fund Is an unrestricted general funds.

343
00:39:52.166 --> 00:39:53.753
<v Adrian Delgado>The risk mitigation pool—.

344
00:39:58.494 --> 00:39:59.501
<v Steve Novick>I'm sorry, I should clarify.

345
00:40:00.659 --> 00:40:10.507
<v Steve Novick>What I'm talking about is of funds that aren't already allocated some to the general fund, what could be sort of be shifted to the general fund?

346
00:40:10.623 --> 00:40:20.271
<v Steve Novick>For example, Councilor Smith's proposed amendment has $5.4 million back to the general fund from the short-term rental 2% category.

347
00:40:20.802 --> 00:40:21.882
<v Steve Novick>So that would be a new thing.

348
00:40:22.577 --> 00:40:28.639
<v Steve Novick>So I'm just sort of wondering how many opportunities are there for new things where the general fund gets money?

349
00:40:30.192 --> 00:40:34.581
<v Adrian Delgado>So I can speak on that proposal.

350
00:40:35.242 --> 00:40:43.393
<v Adrian Delgado>The 2%, the short-term rental 2% fund can— it originates from general funds, so it could go back to the general fund.

351
00:40:44.135 --> 00:40:47.829
<v Steve Novick>So does that mean that theoretically all of it, all $8.6 million, could go to the general fund?

352
00:40:51.030 --> 00:40:53.030
<v Adrian Delgado>That's the short-term rental amount, $8.6 million.

353
00:40:54.498 --> 00:40:54.757
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

354
00:40:55.144 --> 00:40:55.532
<v Steve Novick>And actually—.

355
00:40:55.628 --> 00:40:55.726
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

356
00:40:55.952 --> 00:40:56.177
<v Adrian Delgado>Yes.

357
00:40:56.371 --> 00:40:56.614
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

358
00:40:56.759 --> 00:41:08.237
<v Steve Novick>That's the— and I'm sorry, I don't understand these as well as I should, but that's— there's the short-term rental 2% from Smith 1 and short-term rental We're talking about the short-term rental 2%?

359
00:41:08.626 --> 00:41:11.552
<v Adrian Delgado>2% Can go back to the general fund, right?

360
00:41:11.615 --> 00:41:14.670
<v Adrian Delgado>That comes from the transient lodging tax.

361
00:41:14.929 --> 00:41:15.092
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

362
00:41:18.324 --> 00:41:19.923
<v Adrian Delgado>Just consulting my notes.

363
00:41:21.378 --> 00:41:23.949
<v Adrian Delgado>Yeah, so that's a general fund tax that's unrestricted.

364
00:41:25.030 --> 00:41:29.547
<v Adrian Delgado>But short-term rental 0 to 60 nights is a restricted tax.

365
00:41:29.739 --> 00:41:30.528
<v Adrian Delgado>It's a restricted fee.

366
00:41:31.625 --> 00:41:36.525
<v Adrian Delgado>It's restricted for affordable housing and homelessness, so would not be able to go back to the general fund.

367
00:41:37.056 --> 00:41:37.480
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

368
00:41:39.105 --> 00:41:45.306
<v Steve Novick>And then speaking again of those 2 funds, going back to Table 2, I think that—.

369
00:41:46.552 --> 00:41:50.324
<v Michael Bonacore>Could we take the presentation back to Table 2, please?

370
00:41:56.010 --> 00:42:04.829
<v Steve Novick>So it looks like, my understanding is the Bureau was planning to use up all that money through a preservation solicitation.

371
00:42:06.210 --> 00:42:09.295
<v Steve Novick>And can you explain what preservation means?

372
00:42:09.360 --> 00:42:15.052
<v Steve Novick>Does that mean things like doing mortgage buydowns or other things to stabilize the existing pool of affordable housing?

373
00:42:16.199 --> 00:42:31.521
<v Michael Bonacore>No, if you, well, I don't know that that's precluded here, but what we mean by a Preservation solicitation is that we would put a solicitation out for public competition.

374
00:42:31.780 --> 00:42:41.197
<v Michael Bonacore>And what typically happens is affordable housing providers bring significant capital rehab needs to us and we assess those and then make awards.

375
00:42:42.788 --> 00:42:47.474
<v Steve Novick>So that's existing affordable housing providers to address their needs for their existing properties?

376
00:42:47.521 --> 00:42:48.025
<v Michael Bonacore>That's right.

377
00:42:48.219 --> 00:42:48.380
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

378
00:42:48.494 --> 00:42:48.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

379
00:42:48.699 --> 00:42:52.242
<v Steve Novick>Okay, so this is— that's what you'd planned to do with this money?

380
00:42:52.500 --> 00:42:52.628
<v Adrian Delgado>Yes.

381
00:42:52.822 --> 00:42:59.784
<v Steve Novick>And so this is, I mean, this is an example of it's not really new money, it's money that you already had plans for, and that was the plan?

382
00:42:59.945 --> 00:43:00.333
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

383
00:43:01.481 --> 00:43:29.541
<v Steve Novick>So the— I mean, looking at Councilor Smith's proposal, she's got under short-term rental 0 to 60, She's got the Broadway Corridor Project, the Williams and Russell Project, that those are actual— are those things that left to your own devices you wouldn't have done that because you would've had it all in these preservation solicitations for existing affordable housing?

384
00:43:32.021 --> 00:43:38.784
<v Michael Bonacore>I mean, objectively, the councilor's proposal is not what we've presented, so that there are differences there.

385
00:43:39.976 --> 00:43:40.217
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

386
00:43:40.621 --> 00:43:53.081
<v Steve Novick>But theoretically, All of that money could, you know, could be spent as you planned it to help the existing affordable housing providers deal with issues they have in surviving and keeping their units full.

387
00:43:53.371 --> 00:43:53.628
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

388
00:43:54.047 --> 00:43:54.208
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

389
00:43:54.981 --> 00:44:00.213
<v Steve Novick>Another question about those specific projects.

390
00:44:00.391 --> 00:44:08.119
<v Steve Novick>I have heard that the Broadway Corridor Williams and Russell projects, there's some indication there's interest in those projects at the state level.

391
00:44:08.182 --> 00:44:26.054
<v Michael Bonacore>There's no commitment, but there's the possibility that we Well, I can tell you my understanding is that the state is skeptical of a need to invest in our projects because they believe we have $106 million.

392
00:44:28.820 --> 00:44:31.826
<v Steve Novick>Okay, so my information is outdated apparently.

393
00:44:34.677 --> 00:44:34.789
<v Candace Avalos>You—.

394
00:44:34.934 --> 00:44:38.235
<v Steve Novick>We would not necessarily expect the state to step up and pay a share of those projects?

395
00:44:39.617 --> 00:44:46.559
<v Michael Bonacore>We would hope that they would, but I think we're not in the position that we would hope to be in those conversations with them.

396
00:44:46.737 --> 00:44:47.480
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

397
00:44:49.724 --> 00:44:51.969
<v Steve Novick>And another question.

398
00:44:52.161 --> 00:44:57.447
<v Steve Novick>This is not necessarily directly related, but you talked about the maximum subsidy per unit rule.

399
00:44:57.721 --> 00:44:59.521
<v Steve Novick>What is the maximum subsidy per unit rule?

400
00:45:00.918 --> 00:45:18.045
<v Michael Bonacore>Again, that has been an internal policy in the With the housing bonds for new production, there was a max award of $150,000 per unit, and for preservation projects, $100,000.

401
00:45:18.126 --> 00:45:31.023
<v Michael Bonacore>And I can't say that, you know, that there wasn't some wiggle room depending on circumstances, but that's generally what the Bureau has communicated to folks in the solicitations for new production versus preservation.

402
00:45:32.440 --> 00:45:33.217
<v Steve Novick>Okay, thank you.

403
00:45:33.815 --> 00:45:38.907
<v Steve Novick>And let's see, I just want to be sure.

404
00:45:39.085 --> 00:45:52.442
<v Steve Novick>I mean, assuming you've looked at Smith 1, are there any concerns about the legal challenges to any of the ways that Smith 1 would spend the $20.7 million?

405
00:45:55.061 --> 00:45:55.177
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

406
00:45:55.259 --> 00:46:02.545
<v Donnie Oliveira>Oh, Councilor Donnie Oliveira, for the record, I I'll just chime in to say, uh, generally speaking, they're doable.

407
00:46:03.092 --> 00:46:08.476
<v Donnie Oliveira>The details will matter, especially for that second tranche under the short-term rental 0 to 60 night tranche.

408
00:46:09.186 --> 00:46:11.748
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, how we do those, they have to align with existing code.

409
00:46:12.181 --> 00:46:19.335
<v Donnie Oliveira>But, uh, at a high level, yes, there would be ways to fund those projects, again, assuming they meet the standard.

410
00:46:19.563 --> 00:46:20.702
<v Steve Novick>Okay, thank you.

411
00:46:23.960 --> 00:46:25.115
<v Candace Avalos>All right, Councilor Clark.

412
00:46:25.994 --> 00:46:26.925
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

413
00:46:27.905 --> 00:46:40.418
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I really appreciate that we're getting more— excuse me— transparency and clarity regarding a very complex set of, um, buckets, basically, which has led to so much misunderstanding.

414
00:46:40.916 --> 00:46:41.766
<v Olivia Clark>They're really unfortunate.

415
00:46:41.815 --> 00:46:43.806
<v Olivia Clark>So I appreciate getting a better understanding.

416
00:46:44.449 --> 00:46:50.023
<v Olivia Clark>I just have 3 little points to make on the production slide.

417
00:46:50.103 --> 00:46:51.034
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's slide 11.

418
00:46:52.255 --> 00:46:56.914
<v Olivia Clark>It just would be helpful to know the number of units that correspond with these investments.

419
00:46:57.556 --> 00:46:57.958
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Mm-hmm.

420
00:46:58.199 --> 00:47:02.181
<v Olivia Clark>I don't think I've seen that anywhere, but if you could follow up with that, I'd really appreciate it.

421
00:47:02.231 --> 00:47:06.181
<v Olivia Clark>It would help me understand what we're really— what the benefits really are, what we're paying for.

422
00:47:07.338 --> 00:47:16.364
<v Olivia Clark>Secondly, on slide— the following slide, on slide 12, it seems to me that there's a missing slide here at the very end.

423
00:47:17.778 --> 00:47:27.365
<v Olivia Clark>After the loan closeout, it seems like we should have some sort of tracking or follow-up or accountability, or how do we know that we're getting what we paid for?

424
00:47:27.896 --> 00:47:32.423
<v Olivia Clark>Is there a follow-up in our investments in units?

425
00:47:32.954 --> 00:47:36.471
<v Olivia Clark>And I would really like to see what the follow-up is, if there is any.

426
00:47:36.583 --> 00:47:40.775
<v Olivia Clark>Presumably there's some so that we know we're getting what we wanted.

427
00:47:41.786 --> 00:47:55.121
<v Olivia Clark>And then on table 6, I think Looking at slide 21, I have a question on the TIF on the South Park Blocks.

428
00:47:55.768 --> 00:47:57.349
<v Olivia Clark>It says $7 million.

429
00:47:58.010 --> 00:47:59.737
<v Olivia Clark>Can you tell me what that's going for?

430
00:48:02.693 --> 00:48:11.293
<v Michael Bonacore>What we— what our planned uses are on the— in the column is that It's unidentified.

431
00:48:11.342 --> 00:48:18.275
<v Michael Bonacore>So there's $7 million available in the South Park box for acquisition, new construction, or preservation.

432
00:48:20.063 --> 00:48:20.353
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

433
00:48:20.465 --> 00:48:23.186
<v Michael Bonacore>So there's nothing, nothing is committed yet with that.

434
00:48:23.300 --> 00:48:32.451
<v Olivia Clark>I've heard in the rumor mill that that's money that may be going to PSU for their cultural performing arts plan.

435
00:48:33.271 --> 00:48:34.706
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, thanks for the question.

436
00:48:35.512 --> 00:48:38.659
<v Donnie Oliveira>So this is just the PHB allocation of TIF.

437
00:48:39.028 --> 00:48:41.742
<v Donnie Oliveira>So this is focused on that 45% set-aside.

438
00:48:41.998 --> 00:48:44.952
<v Donnie Oliveira>So this would be targeting projects related to housing.

439
00:48:45.451 --> 00:48:52.067
<v Donnie Oliveira>If you're talking about something related to the PSU project, that perhaps could come from the PROSPER allocation of TIF.

440
00:48:52.195 --> 00:48:53.623
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, thank you for the clarification.

441
00:48:53.672 --> 00:48:54.090
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate it.

442
00:48:54.137 --> 00:48:55.358
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for the presentation.

443
00:48:55.405 --> 00:48:55.599
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

444
00:48:55.663 --> 00:48:58.842
<v Michael Bonacore>And Councilor, I can give you a couple of answers to your questions.

445
00:49:01.523 --> 00:49:06.260
<v Michael Bonacore>Units represented on slide 6 total about 3,600 units.

446
00:49:07.463 --> 00:49:09.742
<v Michael Bonacore>That includes new production and preservation.

447
00:49:10.914 --> 00:49:19.695
<v Michael Bonacore>And then when PHB loans funds to projects, they enter into a regulatory agreement with us.

448
00:49:20.130 --> 00:49:26.038
<v Michael Bonacore>So there is a compliance component post-lease-up into operation.

449
00:49:26.807 --> 00:49:29.248
<v Olivia Clark>What is that, like a quarterly report or how?

450
00:49:29.456 --> 00:49:30.387
<v Michael Bonacore>There's an annual report.

451
00:49:31.500 --> 00:49:31.693
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

452
00:49:32.018 --> 00:49:36.271
<v Olivia Clark>And on the $3,600, how does that divide up between new and preservation?

453
00:49:37.666 --> 00:49:38.543
<v Olivia Clark>What's the split?

454
00:49:38.739 --> 00:49:42.945
<v Michael Bonacore>My team hears these questions and they're getting them to me, so I'll come back and answer that for you.

455
00:49:43.027 --> 00:49:43.612
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

456
00:49:43.789 --> 00:49:44.213
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate it.

457
00:49:44.260 --> 00:49:45.202
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

458
00:49:46.670 --> 00:49:46.943
<v Candace Avalos>Absolutely.

459
00:49:47.264 --> 00:49:48.038
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Green.

460
00:49:50.081 --> 00:49:51.014
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

461
00:49:51.931 --> 00:49:54.394
<v Mitch Green>And these are just— we're still in the technical questions phase.

462
00:49:54.507 --> 00:49:54.909
<v Mitch Green>Okay, great.

463
00:49:57.940 --> 00:50:08.505
<v Mitch Green>So my team did— we had that nice presentation with your team that walked us through the big spreadsheet here.

464
00:50:09.983 --> 00:50:21.126
<v Mitch Green>And our takeaway is that there's really only about $55.9 million of money at council's discretion with degrees of discretion.

465
00:50:22.186 --> 00:50:26.817
<v Mitch Green>Of that, $20.7 million is very much at council's discretion.

466
00:50:26.913 --> 00:50:28.626
<v Mitch Green>There's no other planned uses for it.

467
00:50:28.690 --> 00:50:34.443
<v Mitch Green>We can spend it without any trade-off, essentially, except for the trade-offs between the different decisions we might make.

468
00:50:34.684 --> 00:50:34.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>Correct, yes.

469
00:50:35.644 --> 00:51:01.014
<v Mitch Green>So then if you take that number out, you're left with $30.4— and I'm sorry I'm making everyone do math here, but $30.4 million in what I would say is conditional discretion because We already have some planned uses in the Portland Housing Bureau that come from the short-term rental subfunds, which is $19.7 million, and the CET inclusionary housing fund, which is $10.7 million.

470
00:51:01.079 --> 00:51:12.637
<v Mitch Green>And so if we were— we could consider different uses of those funds, but then that would sort of call into question the existing NOFAs and some of the other stuff.

471
00:51:12.717 --> 00:51:15.103
<v Mitch Green>Is that a correct way to characterize that bucket?

472
00:51:15.199 --> 00:51:15.297
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

473
00:51:15.637 --> 00:51:22.092
<v Michael Bonacore>I would say it doesn't jeopardize existing NOFAs, just future planned solicitations.

474
00:51:22.204 --> 00:51:23.280
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for clarifying that.

475
00:51:23.329 --> 00:51:24.534
<v Mitch Green>That's important for folks watching on.

476
00:51:24.677 --> 00:51:33.590
<v Mitch Green>It's just any NOFAs that are in the pipeline that we might want to do as a future thing that those funds would support, we would be saying we're going to go a different direction.

477
00:51:34.152 --> 00:51:34.295
<v Adrian Delgado>Yes.

478
00:51:34.552 --> 00:51:36.255
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

479
00:51:36.880 --> 00:51:40.878
<v Mitch Green>And then there's— you've included a number of the TIF balances.

480
00:51:41.666 --> 00:51:50.362
<v Mitch Green>Just for— I think presumably just for the sake of the full presentation of information, understanding that in those balances, some are very much restricted.

481
00:51:51.599 --> 00:52:02.474
<v Mitch Green>But then there's also some, it looks like in particular the TIF River District, which is a district that no longer exists, which has been rolled in to capitalize the Old Town TIF District.

482
00:52:03.021 --> 00:52:05.411
<v Mitch Green>There's a sum of $4.8 million.

483
00:52:05.523 --> 00:52:05.862
<v Mitch Green>Mm-hmm.

484
00:52:07.876 --> 00:52:12.659
<v Mitch Green>That has, to my knowledge, no project identified.

485
00:52:12.724 --> 00:52:16.096
<v Mitch Green>It's just sort— it's for acquisition, new construction, or preservation.

486
00:52:17.021 --> 00:52:20.206
<v Mitch Green>So, and all that adds up to $55.9 million.

487
00:52:22.257 --> 00:52:34.130
<v Mitch Green>If council were to consider that $4.8 million of the TIF River District, we would have to— we'd be amending an action plan because we would be directing Prosper Portland how to spend that money.

488
00:52:34.179 --> 00:52:34.244
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

489
00:52:34.795 --> 00:52:36.362
<v Mitch Green>Is that, is that a correct way to think about it?

490
00:52:38.262 --> 00:52:43.739
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, Councilor, I— in this particular case, if we're talking about the Housing Bureau money, you're right that we would want to amend.

491
00:52:43.867 --> 00:52:46.407
<v Donnie Oliveira>But in this particular case, that's an older action plan.

492
00:52:46.518 --> 00:52:49.317
<v Donnie Oliveira>But yes, we'd want to maintain the spirit of that action plan.

493
00:52:49.751 --> 00:52:55.998
<v Donnie Oliveira>We'd ask Council to get clear clarifying direction on that if there was a movement away from something not contemplated.

494
00:52:56.739 --> 00:53:10.523
<v Donnie Oliveira>But this would be, again, towards housing dollars and not necessarily ECTAV I think to your question, yes, council could direct the bureau to more discreetly direct those dollars in that TIF district.

495
00:53:10.619 --> 00:53:11.936
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that.

496
00:53:12.755 --> 00:53:17.222
<v Mitch Green>And the way that I think about it is kind of complicated because the River District doesn't exist anymore.

497
00:53:18.072 --> 00:53:21.398
<v Mitch Green>Now it's the Old Town, but the Old Town is sort of over as well.

498
00:53:22.088 --> 00:53:24.418
<v Mitch Green>And so the new thing is the Westside TIF District.

499
00:53:25.141 --> 00:53:34.514
<v Mitch Green>And so any project that's in the Westside TIF District Presumably one could make the argument at this body that that $4.8 million could go to things like maybe say the Broadway Corridor Project.

500
00:53:34.851 --> 00:53:35.155
<v Loretta Smith>Correct.

501
00:53:35.509 --> 00:53:35.652
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

502
00:53:36.599 --> 00:53:38.958
<v Mitch Green>That's helpful for me stacking all this up.

503
00:53:39.021 --> 00:53:45.376
<v Mitch Green>And then colleagues, there's $58.1 million in TIF balances that is extremely restricted.

504
00:53:45.840 --> 00:53:50.188
<v Mitch Green>I would suggest for the sake of our discussion that that's just not on the table.

505
00:53:50.396 --> 00:53:51.889
<v Mitch Green>That's not on the table for us to talk about.

506
00:53:52.001 --> 00:53:52.867
<v Mitch Green>We don't want to muddy the water.

507
00:53:52.916 --> 00:53:53.141
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that fair?

508
00:53:53.367 --> 00:53:53.996
<v Steve Novick>Is that a fair characterization?

509
00:53:55.603 --> 00:53:56.431
<v Mitch Green>Yes, yes, that's fair.

510
00:53:57.047 --> 00:53:57.469
<v Donnie Oliveira>All right, thank you.

511
00:53:57.697 --> 00:54:12.195
<v Mitch Green>Um, I think the last question I have is, um, in the very last slide, on slide 23, um, there is— oh, I'm sorry, it's slide 22, page 22.

512
00:54:12.275 --> 00:54:18.974
<v Mitch Green>It's, um, there's a line item that says $18.9 million RSO-under council consideration.

513
00:54:20.003 --> 00:54:21.527
<v Mitch Green>Plus $1.8 million from FALTOW.

514
00:54:22.266 --> 00:54:23.164
<v Mitch Green>I don't understand that.

515
00:54:23.534 --> 00:54:24.673
<v Mitch Green>Can you please help me understand that?

516
00:54:24.882 --> 00:54:30.965
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, we just wanted to be transparent to show this is that, that $20.7 RSO that you're contemplating.

517
00:54:32.023 --> 00:54:43.722
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, as a reminder, or just for daylighting for the public, in the FALTOW, $1.8 of that was, was moved into the operating budget this year as just a normal function of how the bureaus manage that fund.

518
00:54:43.916 --> 00:54:45.601
<v Donnie Oliveira>Any unspent dollars just rolls over.

519
00:54:45.730 --> 00:54:50.829
<v Donnie Oliveira>So $1.8 million has already been activated, unspent, unplanned, but it's already in their operating budget.

520
00:54:50.989 --> 00:54:59.949
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so the next action council takes on the RSO dollars would remove, remove the $18.9 million into the budget to make it $20.7 million.

521
00:54:59.949 --> 00:55:01.369
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so it's still $20.7 million.

522
00:55:01.369 --> 00:55:02.389
<v Donnie Oliveira>Still $20.7 million.

523
00:55:02.389 --> 00:55:05.809
<v Mitch Green>It's just you're, you're crosswalking it to the fall TAO action.

524
00:55:05.809 --> 00:55:06.090
<v Loretta Smith>Correct.

525
00:55:06.090 --> 00:55:06.610
<v Mitch Green>For us.

526
00:55:06.610 --> 00:55:07.510
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

527
00:55:07.510 --> 00:55:09.110
<v Mitch Green>I think that concludes my technical questions.

528
00:55:09.210 --> 00:55:10.670
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

529
00:55:10.670 --> 00:55:11.050
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

530
00:55:11.050 --> 00:55:11.710
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor.

531
00:55:11.710 --> 00:55:13.523
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Thank you, Chair Avalos.

532
00:55:14.019 --> 00:55:15.416
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, thank you everyone for being here.

533
00:55:16.297 --> 00:55:19.860
<v Sameer Kanal>So, uh, I'm gonna start with slide 9, please.

534
00:55:20.293 --> 00:55:23.981
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just— I want to understand the timing here a little bit.

535
00:55:24.239 --> 00:55:44.344
<v Sameer Kanal>Is it— is it correct for me to interpret this as saying the first dollar in the door could take 7 to 17 years to result in a physical building that someone could be leasing up, or a preservation effort being completed and then re— I'm seeing the 5 to 7 on one hand, 2 to 10 on the other.

536
00:55:45.791 --> 00:55:49.387
<v Michael Bonacore>Oh, sorry, those should be sort of thought of separately.

537
00:55:49.597 --> 00:56:05.945
<v Michael Bonacore>So on the left side, what that's attempting to illustrate is that if each of those funding sources needed to accrue over time to get to $20 million on its own, that's about how long it would take.

538
00:56:06.762 --> 00:56:13.940
<v Sameer Kanal>Right, so the first dollar could be sitting there waiting for the other dollars to get to $20 million for up to 10 years.

539
00:56:14.115 --> 00:56:24.434
<v Michael Bonacore>I mean, it's sort of, yes, it's sort of a hypothetical because as we said, we braid these funds together and combine them in a way that like they're not really sitting that long.

540
00:56:25.572 --> 00:56:40.335
<v Michael Bonacore>But that helps illustrate, I think, that the act of braiding, which is, you know, adds complexity to the process, is necessary in order to, to like arrive at these larger solicitation amounts.

541
00:56:40.721 --> 00:56:53.384
<v Sameer Kanal>Has anyone done a comparative analysis with other jurisdictions as to that 7 to 17 year figure and if it takes longer here or shorter relative to other cities?

542
00:56:54.298 --> 00:56:58.119
<v Michael Bonacore>I'm not aware of a comparative analysis.

543
00:56:58.777 --> 00:57:11.934
<v Michael Bonacore>I would say very informally, if our jurisdiction were moving at a dramatically faster or slower pace in the context of all the bond activity that has happened, like that would get compared.

544
00:57:12.771 --> 00:57:18.181
<v Michael Bonacore>You know, like we would be hearing that Clackamas County was moving 2 years faster than we were or whatever the case may be.

545
00:57:18.246 --> 00:57:22.963
<v Michael Bonacore>But no, specifically to answer your question, I don't believe there's been a comparative analysis done.

546
00:57:23.398 --> 00:57:23.800
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

547
00:57:25.652 --> 00:57:27.068
<v Sameer Kanal>Going to Table 1.

548
00:57:27.704 --> 00:57:34.094
<v Sameer Kanal>I have 3 questions on these tables, um, and then one question after that.

549
00:57:34.869 --> 00:57:37.768
<v Sameer Kanal>Help me understand the line CET commercial.

550
00:57:38.509 --> 00:57:51.043
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, my understanding is this is a, a tax that is the construction excise tax on construction of commercial buildings, but what are the uses that are allowed to use it?

551
00:57:51.269 --> 00:57:52.548
<v Sameer Kanal>What are we allowed to use that fund on?

552
00:57:56.213 --> 00:57:58.313
<v Adrian Delgado>Hi, I can answer that.

553
00:57:58.666 --> 00:58:03.699
<v Adrian Delgado>Um, so construction excise tax can be used for affordable housing.

554
00:58:04.773 --> 00:58:06.474
<v Adrian Delgado>It is restricted.

555
00:58:06.601 --> 00:58:12.389
<v Adrian Delgado>It's a tax that is restricted at the state level, so it's statutorily restricted.

556
00:58:13.094 --> 00:58:26.728
<v Adrian Delgado>Um, the city, when it adopted the tax, restricted it for 35% to be transferred to Housing Bureau for affordable housing production and preservation of units at or below 60% median family income.

557
00:58:28.489 --> 00:58:35.344
<v Adrian Delgado>The state allows the city to define affordable housing, and that's just the way per ordinance right now and in code that it's restricted.

558
00:58:36.362 --> 00:58:37.925
<v Sameer Kanal>And so this is just the 35%?

559
00:58:38.219 --> 00:58:40.903
<v Sameer Kanal>The other 65% is somewhere outside of the Housing Bureau?

560
00:58:43.179 --> 00:58:51.777
<v Adrian Delgado>15% Goes back to the 4% is the administrative fee retained by permitting for the city.

561
00:58:53.150 --> 00:59:02.411
<v Adrian Delgado>50% Is transferred to Housing Bureau to fund finance-based incentives programs that are related to like development incentives, SDCs.

562
00:59:02.588 --> 00:59:05.197
<v Adrian Delgado>I think the Bureau could speak more on, on that restriction.

563
00:59:06.050 --> 00:59:08.757
<v Sameer Kanal>That adds up to $104,000 though.

564
00:59:09.208 --> 00:59:09.918
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

565
00:59:10.480 --> 00:59:11.668
<v Adrian Delgado>Okay, let's try again.

566
00:59:11.780 --> 00:59:14.414
<v Adrian Delgado>We've got 50, 90.

567
00:59:15.489 --> 00:59:17.112
<v Adrian Delgado>It does add up to $104 million.

568
00:59:17.722 --> 00:59:20.018
<v Adrian Delgado>I will— I'm just going from the memo.

569
00:59:20.068 --> 00:59:22.123
<v Adrian Delgado>I can check with Bureau Engineering.

570
00:59:22.219 --> 00:59:22.331
<v Adrian Delgado>Thanks.

571
00:59:22.396 --> 00:59:27.391
<v Sameer Kanal>But the fact that it's called commercial is the funding stream, the collection side of it.

572
00:59:27.454 --> 00:59:32.481
<v Sameer Kanal>It has nothing to do with what we're allowed to spend it on in the context of this $9.7 million.

573
00:59:32.739 --> 00:59:33.300
<v Adrian Delgado>Correct.

574
00:59:33.382 --> 00:59:34.442
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

575
00:59:35.389 --> 00:59:36.159
<v Sameer Kanal>Slide—.

576
00:59:36.449 --> 00:59:36.931
<v Steve Novick>Table 2.

577
00:59:37.864 --> 00:59:43.027
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanna follow up on Councilor Novick's questions around the STR short-term rental funding.

578
00:59:44.548 --> 01:00:13.329
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanna understand, you're saying the $11.1 million has to remain within the 0 to 60-day first line here has to stay within the restrict— it's much more restricted, whereas the $8.6, does the short-term rental fee have anything to do Given its collection, given the activity that it is collecting money off of, what are the limitations in terms of spending money on tourism promotion?

579
01:00:15.539 --> 01:00:16.492
<v Adrian Delgado>Good question.

580
01:00:18.012 --> 01:00:24.989
<v Adrian Delgado>So it is from the transient lodging tax, and it's an unrestricted tax.

581
01:00:25.103 --> 01:00:26.920
<v Adrian Delgado>So it's just a general fund.

582
01:00:27.586 --> 01:00:29.373
<v Adrian Delgado>It can go back to the general fund for any use.

583
01:00:30.338 --> 01:00:30.985
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the 2%.

584
01:00:32.166 --> 01:00:34.202
<v Adrian Delgado>The 2%, yeah, correct.

585
01:00:35.722 --> 01:00:41.648
<v Adrian Delgado>The city has a resolution where they've restricted the funds and give a specific, like the 2% going to the housing bureau.

586
01:00:41.793 --> 01:00:44.159
<v Adrian Delgado>But as council, you could do something else with that.

587
01:00:44.867 --> 01:00:47.686
<v Adrian Delgado>So the source of the fund itself is general fund.

588
01:00:48.443 --> 01:00:52.643
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the 0 to 60 days, that's restricted in a different way?

589
01:00:53.210 --> 01:00:53.809
<v Adrian Delgado>Correct.

590
01:00:53.956 --> 01:00:54.929
<v Adrian Delgado>That is a fee.

591
01:00:57.068 --> 01:01:04.952
<v Adrian Delgado>And it does have that restriction that you were just mentioning, I believe, where it has to be related to the collection, like the imposition of the fee.

592
01:01:05.900 --> 01:01:10.619
<v Adrian Delgado>And it's restricted for affordable housing and houseless homelessness initiatives.

593
01:01:10.893 --> 01:01:14.152
<v Sameer Kanal>And is it restricted by state law or by city code?

594
01:01:14.907 --> 01:01:20.608
<v Adrian Delgado>It is restricted by city— let's see, it is restricted by city code.

595
01:01:21.972 --> 01:01:35.052
<v Adrian Delgado>But it also has the fee restriction because it's a fee and we wouldn't, even if council decided to extend the code, it's one of the situations where it would still need to be related to the collection, the imposition of the fee.

596
01:01:35.757 --> 01:01:37.876
<v Sameer Kanal>Right, that's exactly why I'm asking about tourism.

597
01:01:37.925 --> 01:01:39.755
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, exactly.

598
01:01:40.043 --> 01:01:40.251
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

599
01:01:41.070 --> 01:01:44.954
<v Sameer Kanal>Table 6, the River District funds as well.

600
01:01:45.387 --> 01:02:01.916
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to clarify, The $5 million that are here for the Broadway Corridor Project, the $2 million for Parcel 4A and the $3 million for Parcel 6, are completely separate, right, from what has been discussed about other uses in the previous council discussions, right?

601
01:02:02.237 --> 01:02:02.349
<v Michael Bonacore>Yes.

602
01:02:03.215 --> 01:02:10.780
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's $5 million that doesn't— that's $5.7 million proposed, which has been proposed, that would be additional to this $5 million?

603
01:02:11.693 --> 01:02:11.885
<v Michael Bonacore>Yes.

604
01:02:12.431 --> 01:02:13.858
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that's helpful to know.

605
01:02:14.659 --> 01:02:25.376
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the The last question, and this might be something that— let me know if this is more than just technical.

606
01:02:25.423 --> 01:02:29.032
<v Sameer Kanal>It's on slide 13, and it's about the forecasted decline in revenue.

607
01:02:29.793 --> 01:02:41.876
<v Sameer Kanal>It appears to me that the 3 big buckets that are being reduced here, the largest reductions are in federal grants, which is a whole other conversation, TIF, which is already authorized, and then bonds.

608
01:02:41.925 --> 01:02:43.447
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to the bonds part of it?

609
01:02:43.972 --> 01:02:48.539
<v Sameer Kanal>And just give a little more insight into how that came to be projected this way.

610
01:02:49.244 --> 01:02:49.467
<v Olivia Clark>Sure.

611
01:02:49.643 --> 01:02:54.996
<v Michael Bonacore>I mean, we're spending down the Portland Housing Bonds and the Metro Bonds.

612
01:02:56.054 --> 01:03:02.927
<v Michael Bonacore>Like, those have all been— there's, I think, $5 million more that's committed to Hollywood Hub from the Portland Housing Bond.

613
01:03:04.001 --> 01:03:10.443
<v Michael Bonacore>And then still some, you see over the next couple of years, still some Metro Housing Bond funds to deploy.

614
01:03:10.780 --> 01:03:14.048
<v Michael Bonacore>But they're both at the end of their—.

615
01:03:14.661 --> 01:03:16.755
<v Sameer Kanal>And there's nothing new expected is I guess the question.

616
01:03:16.867 --> 01:03:17.818
<v Michael Bonacore>Yes, that's right.

617
01:03:18.396 --> 01:03:18.541
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

618
01:03:18.945 --> 01:03:19.186
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah.

619
01:03:19.750 --> 01:03:21.007
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

620
01:03:22.960 --> 01:03:23.284
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

621
01:03:23.380 --> 01:03:24.478
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Smith.

622
01:03:25.784 --> 01:03:27.842
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam Chair.

623
01:03:31.329 --> 01:03:34.394
<v Loretta Smith>Michael, you talked about the ACRA earlier.

624
01:03:36.422 --> 01:03:45.708
<v Loretta Smith>The $106 million in funds, were those funds reported to Moss Adams or Baker Tilly?

625
01:03:45.820 --> 01:03:46.675
<v Loretta Smith>That's their new name.

626
01:03:47.014 --> 01:03:47.871
<v Loretta Smith>That's our auditor.

627
01:03:49.132 --> 01:03:50.472
<v Loretta Smith>Did they know about those funds?

628
01:03:50.893 --> 01:03:52.039
<v Loretta Smith>Were those put in our audit?

629
01:03:53.927 --> 01:03:54.945
<v Jonas Biery>Councilor, yeah, good question.

630
01:03:56.027 --> 01:03:56.461
<v Jonas Biery>They were.

631
01:03:56.672 --> 01:03:58.755
<v Jonas Biery>I mean, we're talking different fiscal years, right?

632
01:03:58.802 --> 01:04:03.644
<v Jonas Biery>So we're talking future budgeted balance versus historical audit.

633
01:04:03.744 --> 01:04:11.606
<v Jonas Biery>But yes, the audit reflects Those full amounts that track to what the future fiscal year budget requires.

634
01:04:11.686 --> 01:04:15.572
<v Loretta Smith>The $106 million, you reported it to the auditor.

635
01:04:16.023 --> 01:04:25.081
<v Loretta Smith>So there's no modifications that need to be made on that audit that we received in '25-'26?

636
01:04:25.257 --> 01:04:26.269
<v Jonas Biery>Yes, that's our understanding.

637
01:04:26.623 --> 01:04:31.248
<v Loretta Smith>And so were those funds also reported when we got our credit rating?

638
01:04:31.762 --> 01:04:31.875
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

639
01:04:31.987 --> 01:04:32.420
<v Loretta Smith>We had that.

640
01:04:32.483 --> 01:04:42.952
<v Loretta Smith>So, so basically everybody that needed to know about it except the people who authorize it were informed.

641
01:04:43.449 --> 01:04:48.081
<v Loretta Smith>And I agree with you that they weren't lost, they were just hidden from us.

642
01:04:49.460 --> 01:04:53.563
<v Loretta Smith>But you shared it with everyone else, correct?

643
01:04:54.349 --> 01:04:59.943
<v Jonas Biery>Uh, yes, including council who also sees the backwards-looking financial audit when it's completed.

644
01:05:00.152 --> 01:05:07.036
<v Loretta Smith>No, no, no, I'm talking about in the authorization of the new budget for '26, for '25-'26.

645
01:05:07.518 --> 01:05:11.469
<v Loretta Smith>When we were supposed to see those dollars, we were not made aware of them.

646
01:05:11.534 --> 01:05:13.349
<v Loretta Smith>They were not put in our authorization.

647
01:05:13.717 --> 01:05:13.878
<v Jonas Biery>Yes.

648
01:05:13.927 --> 01:05:17.204
<v Loretta Smith>But yet, and still, you shared them with the auditor.

649
01:05:18.264 --> 01:05:20.623
<v Jonas Biery>Um, let me be clear.

650
01:05:20.688 --> 01:05:23.016
<v Jonas Biery>So the auditor looks at the prior year.

651
01:05:23.355 --> 01:05:23.547
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

652
01:05:23.596 --> 01:05:29.329
<v Jonas Biery>So the information the auditor is looking at is the prior year, which is not the budget that looks at the upcoming year.

653
01:05:29.766 --> 01:05:45.998
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so let me back up because Moss Adams and Baker Tilly, that's their new name, they look to see if the numbers are within $1 million from each year, and if there are, there has to be some, some sure-up of the budget.

654
01:05:46.452 --> 01:05:59.605
<v Loretta Smith>But what I'm asking you, and I'm trying to get to the point, did they see the full authorization as we presented it when we voted on it in May, in June?

655
01:06:00.759 --> 01:06:01.817
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I'm asking you.

656
01:06:02.105 --> 01:06:08.996
<v Jonas Biery>So the information that the auditor would have had, would have seen, is what the same information that was publicly presented in the budget.

657
01:06:09.076 --> 01:06:11.320
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so they didn't see it just like we didn't see it.

658
01:06:12.137 --> 01:06:13.146
<v Loretta Smith>And so that's a problem.

659
01:06:14.460 --> 01:06:15.070
<v Loretta Smith>That's a problem.

660
01:06:15.117 --> 01:06:19.027
<v Loretta Smith>The auditor didn't see the full authorization, and that's what I'm asking you.

661
01:06:19.652 --> 01:06:27.335
<v Loretta Smith>Um, question, Michael, Thank you, uh, Councilor Novick, for going over my $40 million.

662
01:06:27.590 --> 01:06:38.692
<v Loretta Smith>And I went over that with, with Ruth prior to this to ask if the ideas that we had in our Smith 1, if they could be used without code changes.

663
01:06:38.820 --> 01:06:48.780
<v Loretta Smith>And she said yes to the $20.7, yes to the $8.6, and yes to the $11.1, that those uses were accurate.

664
01:06:48.909 --> 01:06:49.021
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

665
01:06:49.489 --> 01:07:00.289
<v Loretta Smith>But the reality is we can't begin to plan for a NOFA that's happening in the future if you're the only ones who know about the money.

666
01:07:02.547 --> 01:07:14.204
<v Loretta Smith>And we didn't know about the money, so, so to suggest that you had plans for it and it was going to be in a future NOFA, those plans don't exist because those funds were not authorized.

667
01:07:14.797 --> 01:07:16.193
<v Loretta Smith>And so no one knows about it but you.

668
01:07:16.762 --> 01:07:19.215
<v Loretta Smith>So it was hidden from the council and the mayor.

669
01:07:20.039 --> 01:07:23.693
<v Loretta Smith>It was hidden from our auditors who didn't know about it.

670
01:07:24.179 --> 01:07:30.802
<v Loretta Smith>And so now when we go back for this year, our auditors are going to have to look at it and our audit is going to be wrong.

671
01:07:32.775 --> 01:07:39.351
<v Loretta Smith>You may have a different way of doing things prior to this new council, but Oregon budget law hasn't changed.

672
01:07:40.161 --> 01:07:40.289
<v Adrian Delgado>Yes.

673
01:07:40.547 --> 01:07:58.949
<v Loretta Smith>You are supposed to— when you said to me a few weeks ago that yes, you knew you were supposed to report it to us, yes, your staff knew they were supposed to support it for, you know, report it to us, and yes, it was over a multi-year, um, uh, surplus.

674
01:07:59.655 --> 01:08:09.710
<v Loretta Smith>So for me to come up with all these magical plans and say that you were going to do this and do that You are hiding that from us, and that is a lie, sir.

675
01:08:10.764 --> 01:08:14.829
<v Loretta Smith>That is a lie that I don't like because we have to know about all monies.

676
01:08:15.375 --> 01:08:22.122
<v Loretta Smith>Now, I came in on the tail end of Councilor Morillo, and she is absolutely right.

677
01:08:22.845 --> 01:08:24.430
<v Loretta Smith>There are some things that you all know about.

678
01:08:24.479 --> 01:08:28.198
<v Loretta Smith>I'm going to ask you this question, and I'm going to ask it very slowly and clearly.

679
01:08:29.708 --> 01:08:41.667
<v Loretta Smith>Is there any other monies in these pots that you have not told us about that we should know about above the $106 million?

680
01:08:44.710 --> 01:08:45.050
<v Loretta Smith>Michael?

681
01:08:46.878 --> 01:08:51.289
<v Michael Bonacore>What we presented today is all of the unbudgeted fund balances that I'm aware of.

682
01:08:51.610 --> 01:08:52.462
<v Loretta Smith>That you're aware of?

683
01:08:52.591 --> 01:08:52.864
<v Candace Avalos>Mm-hmm.

684
01:08:53.539 --> 01:08:58.537
<v Loretta Smith>So I know that Ruth is aware of maybe possibly $137 million.

685
01:09:00.324 --> 01:09:04.637
<v Loretta Smith>And that she's been working with Morillo's office to kind of reconcile that.

686
01:09:04.735 --> 01:09:06.260
<v Loretta Smith>So you don't know about that money?

687
01:09:07.954 --> 01:09:08.051
<v Adrian Delgado>No.

688
01:09:08.394 --> 01:09:09.761
<v Loretta Smith>Do you know about it, Jonas?

689
01:09:10.038 --> 01:09:12.938
<v Jonas Biery>So, councilors, I think you caught the tail end of the conversation.

690
01:09:13.710 --> 01:09:20.292
<v Jonas Biery>There's, I think, some gaps in information about the $137,000.

691
01:09:20.453 --> 01:09:30.661
<v Jonas Biery>For example, that's, I think, reflective of last year's audit, what's in the ACFR, which is also different from what will be projected in the budget.

692
01:09:30.708 --> 01:09:33.226
<v Jonas Biery>So it's kind of mixing a couple of things.

693
01:09:33.323 --> 01:09:34.604
<v Jonas Biery>So I'll say it another way.

694
01:09:35.037 --> 01:09:40.938
<v Jonas Biery>If it were 100, that's a comparison of ending year to ending year, and that math works.

695
01:09:41.500 --> 01:09:42.045
<v Jonas Biery>That's accurate.

696
01:09:42.782 --> 01:09:43.456
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

697
01:09:44.161 --> 01:09:48.554
<v Jonas Biery>That does not include, for example, amounts that were budgeted in the current year.

698
01:09:49.194 --> 01:09:50.413
<v Jonas Biery>And so let's take that out.

699
01:09:50.990 --> 01:09:56.279
<v Jonas Biery>It does not include what I believe is a large payment for Related to the housing bond.

700
01:09:56.505 --> 01:09:57.930
<v Jonas Biery>And so that number gets smaller.

701
01:09:58.268 --> 01:10:05.000
<v Jonas Biery>There are some deltas in individual amounts that are around that million-ish that we're looking into to understand.

702
01:10:05.064 --> 01:10:10.176
<v Jonas Biery>Is that a nuance of the way that the accounting rules around the ACFR are developed?

703
01:10:10.947 --> 01:10:11.363
<v Jonas Biery>Or is it—.

704
01:10:11.652 --> 01:10:13.703
<v Loretta Smith>Whether it's cash or accrual.

705
01:10:14.199 --> 01:10:14.569
<v Jonas Biery>Correct.

706
01:10:15.177 --> 01:10:17.118
<v Jonas Biery>And so we're still doing that work.

707
01:10:17.198 --> 01:10:22.037
<v Jonas Biery>It's not— I wish it was as simple as just asking a question and turning a switch and spitting out an answer.

708
01:10:23.033 --> 01:10:30.332
<v Jonas Biery>But I just, it's particularly challenging to talk about in this environment when we don't actually know the reason why.

709
01:10:30.398 --> 01:10:31.423
<v Loretta Smith>But you know there's something.

710
01:10:31.617 --> 01:10:32.097
<v Adrian Delgado>There is something there.

711
01:10:32.659 --> 01:10:39.252
<v Jonas Biery>We know there's a delta, but again, those are two, you know, it's not exactly apples to apples.

712
01:10:39.317 --> 01:10:41.050
<v Jonas Biery>It's maybe two different flavors of apples.

713
01:10:41.162 --> 01:10:50.533
<v Jonas Biery>And so we want to make sure that when we communicate that to council, we don't, for example, suggest that there's money available to repurpose when that's not true.

714
01:10:50.871 --> 01:10:56.606
<v Jonas Biery>Because what we, what we really would not prefer for council is to encourage you to make a decision based upon information that's not—.

715
01:10:56.880 --> 01:10:59.002
<v Loretta Smith>That has not been validated.

716
01:10:59.469 --> 01:11:01.819
<v Loretta Smith>But it's some apples that we don't know about right now.

717
01:11:02.672 --> 01:11:03.445
<v Jonas Biery>Well, we know about them now.

718
01:11:04.056 --> 01:11:04.797
<v Loretta Smith>We know about them now.

719
01:11:04.943 --> 01:11:12.688
<v Loretta Smith>So there are some apples out there that we have not included to the 106, right?

720
01:11:13.541 --> 01:11:18.640
<v Jonas Biery>I mean, it's— I Again, I would just answer it's a difference.

721
01:11:18.770 --> 01:11:29.684
<v Jonas Biery>I want to be cautious that we're sometimes conflating what's in the audit, which is different, a different standard than what is in the budget.

722
01:11:29.828 --> 01:11:31.720
<v Jonas Biery>And so it may be true, Councilor.

723
01:11:31.769 --> 01:11:31.994
<v Loretta Smith>So is it?

724
01:11:32.520 --> 01:11:34.922
<v Loretta Smith>So yeah, it may be true and it's likely to be true.

725
01:11:34.970 --> 01:11:36.488
<v Jonas Biery>I just want to be really cautious that we're—.

726
01:11:36.568 --> 01:11:37.922
<v Loretta Smith>I know, I won't mess with that, Jonas.

727
01:11:37.971 --> 01:11:39.503
<v Loretta Smith>Don't try to protect yet.

728
01:11:39.585 --> 01:11:39.875
<v Loretta Smith>It's okay.

729
01:11:40.307 --> 01:11:40.662
<v Candace Avalos>It's okay.

730
01:11:40.742 --> 01:11:41.032
<v Loretta Smith>It's okay.

731
01:11:41.595 --> 01:11:52.978
<v Loretta Smith>Um, but when we give information to our auditor, we have to give them the entire amount, and it appears that we did not give our auditor the entire amount.

732
01:11:53.671 --> 01:12:06.347
<v Loretta Smith>I'm concerned and I'm troubled, and I have just— and you're going to get one of these— I have to go back to my foundation, Multnomah County.

733
01:12:09.359 --> 01:12:10.622
<v Loretta Smith>And my staff is going to give you one.

734
01:12:10.671 --> 01:12:12.296
<v Loretta Smith>I just gave all the councilors one.

735
01:12:12.542 --> 01:12:13.444
<v Loretta Smith>This is so simple.

736
01:12:15.036 --> 01:12:16.835
<v Loretta Smith>It gives you a snapshot.

737
01:12:16.963 --> 01:12:20.402
<v Loretta Smith>And you remember when I always tell you, give me a— give me a spreadshot, Jonas.

738
01:12:20.514 --> 01:12:22.073
<v Loretta Smith>Give me a spreadshot— spreadsheet.

739
01:12:23.567 --> 01:12:32.431
<v Loretta Smith>This tells every piece of money in the local government, and it has a number on it, and it shows Yes.

740
01:12:32.511 --> 01:12:35.335
<v Loretta Smith>It tells if it was funded the previous year and for what.

741
01:12:35.944 --> 01:12:45.358
<v Loretta Smith>And it tells how much general fund money is in that particular program offer, how much other funds, and how much restricted funds.

742
01:12:45.421 --> 01:12:46.095
<v Loretta Smith>It's just real easy.

743
01:12:46.144 --> 01:12:46.850
<v Loretta Smith>It's real simple.

744
01:12:47.811 --> 01:12:54.515
<v Loretta Smith>I would like us to go to this format so that we can clearly see if there are things that are taken out.

745
01:12:54.885 --> 01:13:00.497
<v Loretta Smith>And we can see from one page, did the bureau use all their money from the previous year?

746
01:13:00.658 --> 01:13:02.375
<v Loretta Smith>And we can see they only used Yes.

747
01:13:03.627 --> 01:13:06.935
<v Loretta Smith>So we have that money that's going to be part of our beginning working balance.

748
01:13:07.465 --> 01:13:08.139
<v Loretta Smith>It is so simple.

749
01:13:08.268 --> 01:13:11.863
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know what kind of accounting we use here, but it is not working.

750
01:13:13.324 --> 01:13:18.944
<v Loretta Smith>And so for me, if we could go to something like this, that would be so much more helpful.

751
01:13:19.426 --> 01:13:24.275
<v Loretta Smith>I don't need a storybook of 20 pages of you giving me a story of this money and that money.

752
01:13:24.340 --> 01:13:25.304
<v Loretta Smith>That's not clear to me.

753
01:13:25.609 --> 01:13:27.198
<v Loretta Smith>I only know how to deal in numbers.

754
01:13:28.787 --> 01:13:36.582
<v Loretta Smith>Numbers are so important, and I, I appreciate you admitting that there is some more apples out there, but we just don't know how many.

755
01:13:38.286 --> 01:13:44.617
<v Loretta Smith>And I am going to, uh, give back my time to the chairwoman so we can go forward.

756
01:13:45.033 --> 01:13:52.487
<v Loretta Smith>But I would have never had this meeting for the note before we had our oversight meeting because this— it doesn't make sense to keep beating a dead horse on this.

757
01:13:52.534 --> 01:14:02.636
<v Loretta Smith>But we do need to know all of those numbers Okay, thank you, Councilor.

758
01:14:02.733 --> 01:14:03.829
<v Candace Avalos>We are at 10:39.

759
01:14:03.926 --> 01:14:15.054
<v Candace Avalos>What we have— and we were ahead of schedule, so we've had a lot more time to, um, discuss, but we're going to go until 11 for technical questions, take a 10-minute break, and then come back for the rest of the discussion.

760
01:14:16.121 --> 01:14:16.994
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

761
01:14:17.755 --> 01:14:23.324
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Avalos, and thank you, Council President, for setting aside time for the conversation today as well.

762
01:14:24.737 --> 01:14:29.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Jonas, I really appreciate the answer you just gave on the $137, I believe it is, million.

763
01:14:31.037 --> 01:14:36.738
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are clearly still gaps, but you started to explain to us why some of those gaps exist.

764
01:14:37.256 --> 01:14:42.078
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to see that on paper, on these charts that we have here, as soon as possible.

765
01:14:42.725 --> 01:14:54.747
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that we need to develop a relationship where we can give you space to bring us early information that might not be complete, but we can only do that if we get And that's a piece that has not been totally consistent here.

766
01:14:54.845 --> 01:14:56.369
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So thank you for the start.

767
01:14:56.515 --> 01:14:57.252
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate it.

768
01:14:58.521 --> 01:15:08.524
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I recognize that we're inserting ourselves not just in some cases at the project level, but also in directing funds to specific programs different from your normal course of action.

769
01:15:09.423 --> 01:15:14.835
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we're not giving you broader policy guidance beyond these dollars about whether that's a permanent change or a temporary change.

770
01:15:14.979 --> 01:15:15.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a good point.

771
01:15:16.090 --> 01:15:17.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right now, these dollars change.

772
01:15:18.760 --> 01:15:27.546
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're here because there was incomplete information and broken trust and some budget and accounting inconsistencies that I know we are in the process of correcting.

773
01:15:29.430 --> 01:15:33.582
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Jonas, I know we've talked about making sure those are corrected in every bureau.

774
01:15:35.755 --> 01:15:48.131
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But for better or worse, at this point in the conversation, we have a lot of interested stakeholders and a lot of programs on the table that for each item in councilor amendments, at least one person up here cares about greatly.

775
01:15:49.095 --> 01:16:01.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So what I want to try to understand better are the $30.4 million in uncommitted funds, because I think our decisions are threefold.

776
01:16:01.591 --> 01:16:10.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What are we going to do to avoid a situation like this in the future so that we're not digging into the work that we generally ask you to do, Mr.

777
01:16:10.090 --> 01:16:10.609
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

778
01:16:10.609 --> 01:16:10.609
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

779
01:16:10.609 --> 01:16:12.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Bonaccort.

780
01:16:12.989 --> 01:16:23.239
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And with the funds before us, whether we want to dig into that $30.4 million in uncommitted dollars or any of the other funds outside of that, and if so, what our priorities are.

781
01:16:23.609 --> 01:16:26.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I want to look at Tables 1 and 2.

782
01:16:26.090 --> 01:16:28.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've talked a fair amount about Table 2.

783
01:16:28.770 --> 01:16:30.810
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I fully understand the $8.6 million.

784
01:16:30.810 --> 01:16:41.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think the last explanation about the $11.1 million, that there's a fair amount of flexibility there as long as it is tied to the fee helps to clear up the final questions I had there.

785
01:16:42.662 --> 01:16:51.351
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But on Table 1, I don't think we've spent as much time understanding the planned uses and the potential uses.

786
01:16:52.509 --> 01:17:01.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So under planned uses, there's a fair amount of money here listed for a 2028 new construction solicitation, an OFA in 2028.

787
01:17:02.878 --> 01:17:06.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Why are these funds set aside to use in 2028?

788
01:17:07.353 --> 01:17:09.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When we know we have a housing crisis now?

789
01:17:09.268 --> 01:17:16.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you explain the thinking at the Bureau in waiting an additional 2 years to even talk about those funds?

790
01:17:18.630 --> 01:17:19.192
<v Michael Bonacore>Sure.

791
01:17:19.609 --> 01:17:38.349
<v Michael Bonacore>So, you know, given the decline in bond funds and in TIF, we just, you know, going forward, unless there is new revenue, are not going to be able to accrue money at a pace that allows us to do annual solicitations.

792
01:17:39.890 --> 01:17:48.012
<v Michael Bonacore>So I think this is just a projection of we do one, you know, for preservation next year and do a new construction in 2028.

793
01:17:51.363 --> 01:18:10.717
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there reasons not to spend it sooner given the housing crisis that we're in right now other than just looking out and knowing that we won't have Yeah, I mean, entirely a policy, you know, and strategic debate for you all to have.

794
01:18:10.909 --> 01:18:12.369
<v Michael Bonacore>I completely understand the question.

795
01:18:13.042 --> 01:18:24.171
<v Michael Bonacore>I would say, you know, we've been in a crisis and I think we anticipate in 2 or 3 years we will continue to be in a crisis and very far behind in our, you know, housing production needs.

796
01:18:25.086 --> 01:18:27.618
<v Michael Bonacore>And so I think that's a really important conversation to have.

797
01:18:29.095 --> 01:18:37.140
<v Michael Bonacore>But again, as I've said, you know, there's a very real timing strategy question for you all to have.

798
01:18:37.189 --> 01:18:40.287
<v Michael Bonacore>And I, you know, completely appreciate that.

799
01:18:40.497 --> 01:18:40.801
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

800
01:18:40.881 --> 01:18:45.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I understand that sometimes there's a need to balance staff capacity and things like that.

801
01:18:45.314 --> 01:18:53.164
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do think that waiting because we will still be in a crisis when we could start building more housing sooner is difficult.

802
01:18:55.253 --> 01:19:04.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>On the construction excise tax buckets, it looks like there's $10.7 total in funding in that planned uses but not committed uses category.

803
01:19:05.775 --> 01:19:10.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What are the full restrictions there?

804
01:19:10.231 --> 01:19:11.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know we heard the breakdown.

805
01:19:11.748 --> 01:19:17.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's 35% for affordable production and preservation of 60% AMI or less.

806
01:19:18.021 --> 01:19:18.247
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

807
01:19:18.760 --> 01:19:18.952
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

808
01:19:19.752 --> 01:19:23.729
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It sounds like that provision is in code.

809
01:19:24.738 --> 01:19:26.774
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I guess a couple of specific questions.

810
01:19:27.463 --> 01:19:33.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is the affordable production piece of that also tied to 60% AMI or less?

811
01:19:34.806 --> 01:19:35.416
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>First question.

812
01:19:36.569 --> 01:19:48.354
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, second question, are those restrictions in our code or are they in an agreement with the State when we started levying these taxes?

813
01:19:49.337 --> 01:20:06.515
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And third question, are there any other restrictions around how we spend the funds in terms of a breakdown between production and preservation, or what counts as preservation that we should know about as we think about that bucket of funds?

814
01:20:08.609 --> 01:20:10.304
<v Michael Bonacore>I'm mostly going to defer to Adrienne.

815
01:20:10.351 --> 01:20:18.978
<v Michael Bonacore>I think on the last part though, I don't think there's anything that defines a certain percentage has to be spent on new production versus preservation.

816
01:20:21.130 --> 01:20:21.323
<v Adrian Delgado>Yes.

817
01:20:21.404 --> 01:20:26.734
<v Adrian Delgado>So, okay, catch me if I am not answering your question, please, and redirect.

818
01:20:29.859 --> 01:20:37.555
<v Adrian Delgado>But I think we're just talking about these funds being in that 35% category, and we're going to do a check on the exact breakdown.

819
01:20:37.672 --> 01:20:47.440
<v Adrian Delgado>But yes, correct that they must be used— so statutorily, they must be used for affordable housing.

820
01:20:48.987 --> 01:21:09.002
<v Adrian Delgado>When the city enacted the tax, it adopted an ordinance and it defined the use as affordable housing by the Housing Bureau, affordable housing production and preservation of units at or below 60% So right now, that is the city's restriction.

821
01:21:09.935 --> 01:21:19.175
<v Adrian Delgado>It would— the city could amend the ordinance and amend the code to redefine affordable housing.

822
01:21:19.789 --> 01:21:30.371
<v Adrian Delgado>So if you wanted to use it, you know, you wanted to allow it to go up to 120% because for CET, that is the use the city wanted, the way that the city wanted to define affordable housing, that would be possible.

823
01:21:30.418 --> 01:21:30.515
<v Adrian Delgado>Thank you.

824
01:21:32.908 --> 01:21:55.895
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And on the preservation, is there a definition for preservation attached to this, or is preservation here meaning solely new roof, things that keep things in production, things spending money to re-up the length of time something is in operation?

825
01:21:55.961 --> 01:21:55.993
<v Loretta Smith>No.

826
01:22:11.579 --> 01:22:21.829
<v Adrian Delgado>I'm not aware that preservation is defined in code by the city, and so we would just go to the general dictionary definition, which is— I'm going to assume that it's the preservation of existing I'm housing.

827
01:22:22.077 --> 01:22:25.904
<v Adrian Delgado>Sorry, I don't have my computer in front of me to look it up— relatively broad.

828
01:22:27.180 --> 01:22:39.795
<v Adrian Delgado>So I'm not sure I understand what you mean by filling units, but I think Michael could probably speak a little bit more on how preservation has been interpreted by the Housing Bureau in the past.

829
01:22:41.432 --> 01:22:41.820
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Director?

830
01:22:42.322 --> 01:22:42.515
<v Adrian Delgado>Sure.

831
01:22:42.710 --> 01:22:46.862
<v Michael Bonacore>I mean, primarily in the ways that you've articulated.

832
01:22:46.911 --> 01:22:47.412
<v Michael Bonacore>Can you say—.

833
01:22:47.412 --> 01:23:01.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could you say more about We've had a lot of conversations as a council about the unfilled units in some of our affordable housing complexes around the city and what we might be able to do, what tools we might have in order to ensure that those units are filled.

834
01:23:02.425 --> 01:23:10.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm wondering if preservation dollars as defined here could be used in those cases or not.

835
01:23:10.403 --> 01:23:40.484
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'll return to the fact that I understand that what we're talking about is getting into the weeds And later I will talk about whether that is a good thing or not, but I'm trying to understand all of the parameters for what I consider the only pot of money we should be— or pots of money we should be looking at, which are the original $20.7 million in RSOs that we've talked about, and then the $30.4 million identified in planned but not committed uses on Tables 1 and 2.

836
01:23:40.565 --> 01:23:40.793
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Herbold.

837
01:23:44.684 --> 01:23:46.190
<v Michael Bonacore>I think conceptually, yes.

838
01:23:46.872 --> 01:23:56.301
<v Michael Bonacore>It really, I think, just becomes a question of— I mean, I know you have given some thought to security enhancements at properties.

839
01:23:56.350 --> 01:23:58.045
<v Michael Bonacore>Is that the sort of thing you might be thinking about?

840
01:23:58.092 --> 01:24:09.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Security enhancements, mortgage buydowns that allow for rent to be lowered for targeted units, support with turning over units That have been heavily damaged.

841
01:24:10.037 --> 01:24:18.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those are 3 examples of things that I have heard from providers and have had conversations with colleagues about.

842
01:24:19.801 --> 01:24:32.377
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, I think, you know, depending on the specific intervention, we'd want to just check in with legal, but I believe those are all in the spirit of preservation.

843
01:24:33.729 --> 01:24:33.997
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

844
01:24:34.099 --> 01:24:34.905
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

845
01:24:35.592 --> 01:24:38.211
<v Candace Avalos>All right, Councilor Ryan.

846
01:24:38.708 --> 01:24:40.378
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Chair Avalos.

847
01:24:40.796 --> 01:24:43.204
<v Dan Ryan>Clearly it was needed to take a collective breath on this today.

848
01:24:43.847 --> 01:24:48.006
<v Dan Ryan>Um, first of all, I know that each housing project is very complicated.

849
01:24:48.505 --> 01:24:52.470
<v Dan Ryan>There's multiple revenue streams which ask for different reporting guidelines.

850
01:24:53.851 --> 01:25:12.536
<v Dan Ryan>Looking at, looking at the entire bureau and cleaning it up to improve standards is a lot of work, and I want to thank you, Jonas, And for working with your boss, City Administrator Lee, and your team for the many hours you're devoting to this at Portland Housing Bureau and for the entire city.

851
01:25:13.939 --> 01:25:22.127
<v Dan Ryan>I'm looking for additional clarity as I struggled to achieve that when Councilor Novick was asking questions, and I apologize if this is repetition.

852
01:25:22.992 --> 01:25:28.725
<v Dan Ryan>Yet, as I always say in the education space, it is the key to learning, and I have found that adults need it even more than children.

853
01:25:28.774 --> 01:25:28.886
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

854
01:25:29.765 --> 01:25:35.573
<v Dan Ryan>So let's stay with trying to get to the bottom of how much we really can spend on general fund.

855
01:25:38.560 --> 01:25:43.703
<v Dan Ryan>When— first, when I— when— what is the annual operational budget for Portland Housing Bureau?

856
01:25:44.771 --> 01:25:47.181
<v Dan Ryan>The entire bureau, not each program.

857
01:25:47.664 --> 01:25:54.105
<v Dan Ryan>The total that is needed since it's not legally available from restricted accounts to function as a bureau.

858
01:25:54.521 --> 01:25:55.453
<v Dan Ryan>I think that number is $36 million.

859
01:25:55.520 --> 01:25:55.752
<v Candace Avalos>$36 Million.

860
01:26:00.408 --> 01:26:02.582
<v Dan Ryan>Based on an email dialogue that we've had.

861
01:26:02.680 --> 01:26:03.296
<v Dan Ryan>Is that correct?

862
01:26:06.112 --> 01:26:07.552
<v Michael Bonacore>My team will get me an answer.

863
01:26:07.796 --> 01:26:15.212
<v Dan Ryan>Jonas, I think I'm just daylighting what the dialogue that you've had with my chief of staff, and I thought it was important to make sure we all heard that.

864
01:26:16.739 --> 01:26:17.293
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, thank you.

865
01:26:17.342 --> 01:26:21.643
<v Jonas Biery>And I don't know the number either, if that's the question, Councilor.

866
01:26:21.708 --> 01:26:26.354
<v Dan Ryan>So Okay, you wanna hear the question again?

867
01:26:27.061 --> 01:26:29.744
<v Jonas Biery>Sure, if you'd be willing to, thank you.

868
01:26:29.792 --> 01:26:30.211
<v Steve Novick>Sure.

869
01:26:31.382 --> 01:26:33.215
<v Dan Ryan>The entire bureau, not each program.

870
01:26:33.568 --> 01:26:37.536
<v Dan Ryan>And I understand, Adrian, you were kind of breaking it down with each line item of each program.

871
01:26:37.729 --> 01:26:40.378
<v Dan Ryan>That's a lot for us to churn.

872
01:26:40.942 --> 01:26:47.029
<v Dan Ryan>And I would advise that it's better to digest that for us in total as we go into budget season.

873
01:26:47.945 --> 01:26:51.890
<v Dan Ryan>And so the question is, The entire bureau, not each program.

874
01:26:51.954 --> 01:27:01.216
<v Dan Ryan>The total that is needed, since it's not legally available from restricted accounts— again, that's very complicated accounting practices— to function the housing bureau.

875
01:27:01.701 --> 01:27:10.306
<v Dan Ryan>And the number that we had in dialogue with our office with you that I thought would be a softball to just get out to the whole council is $36,554,000.

876
01:27:14.650 --> 01:27:17.832
<v Michael Bonacore>I'm waiting for an answer from my Okay.

877
01:27:18.076 --> 01:27:19.305
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah.

878
01:27:20.908 --> 01:27:28.671
<v Dan Ryan>And while we're waiting for that, where I'm coming from is just about operational survival for the entire city as we wrestle with the upcoming budget.

879
01:27:29.492 --> 01:27:38.573
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm trying to use this opportunity to know if we can allocate some of that as we go forward legally into the '26-'27 budget.

880
01:27:39.442 --> 01:27:43.048
<v Dan Ryan>And I know that you, Donnie, and legal counsel are working on it.

881
01:27:43.913 --> 01:27:51.668
<v Dan Ryan>But I need to know the total number of dollars that could be eligible, that could be transferred to the general fund going into the '26-'27 budget.

882
01:27:52.568 --> 01:27:57.497
<v Dan Ryan>And I'd like to, before decisions are made on how we do the budgeting for next year.

883
01:27:57.707 --> 01:27:58.332
<v Michael Bonacore>I'm sorry, Councilor—.

884
01:27:58.332 --> 01:28:00.226
<v Dan Ryan>If you don't have that today, let me just finish.

885
01:28:00.292 --> 01:28:00.564
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It'll help.

886
01:28:00.613 --> 01:28:01.110
<v Michael Bonacore>I'm sorry.

887
01:28:01.720 --> 01:28:03.198
<v Dan Ryan>If not for today, that is fine.

888
01:28:03.246 --> 01:28:08.689
<v Dan Ryan>But I hope that we have clarity on this amount as we go into the '26-'27 budget deliberations.

889
01:28:10.101 --> 01:28:12.862
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, and I apologize, I may not have understood.

890
01:28:12.975 --> 01:28:19.105
<v Michael Bonacore>I may not understand your question, but there is about $12 million in general fund total in the Bureau.

891
01:28:19.876 --> 01:28:20.726
<v Michael Bonacore>Is that your question?

892
01:28:20.854 --> 01:28:34.368
<v Dan Ryan>And that's the money that you can use that's legal, that those restricted accounts are trued up, but you still need that much money to operate your Bureau in general fund money.

893
01:28:34.460 --> 01:28:38.073
<v Dan Ryan>Because we know that we're in a general fund operational crisis in terms of revenue.

894
01:28:38.622 --> 01:28:39.944
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm trying to get to the bottom of that.

895
01:28:40.024 --> 01:28:42.332
<v Michael Bonacore>Yes, we need the $12 million in general fund.

896
01:28:42.476 --> 01:28:45.148
<v Dan Ryan>So it's $12 million, not $36 million.

897
01:28:47.158 --> 01:28:50.730
<v Jonas Biery>I believe— I'm not totally positive, Councilor, but we can follow up.

898
01:28:50.796 --> 01:28:54.335
<v Jonas Biery>I believe part of that includes maybe some of the pass-through money to the county.

899
01:28:55.877 --> 01:28:57.315
<v Jonas Biery>So, but we'll need to—.

900
01:28:57.315 --> 01:28:59.699
<v Michael Bonacore>Oh, that is where a larger number would come from.

901
01:28:59.831 --> 01:29:10.515
<v Dan Ryan>And I can live with with this moment that we have a gap here, but I hope that there can be some focus on that sooner than later because I think it'll be very helpful for the big picture.

902
01:29:11.239 --> 01:29:12.672
<v Dan Ryan>Does that make sense?

903
01:29:12.786 --> 01:29:13.171
<v Michael Bonacore>It does, yeah.

904
01:29:13.252 --> 01:29:23.679
<v Michael Bonacore>So there's about $31 million that passes in general fund that passes through the Bureau to Homeless Services Division at the county.

905
01:29:24.128 --> 01:29:25.284
<v Michael Bonacore>So that doesn't stay in the Bureau.

906
01:29:25.478 --> 01:29:29.012
<v Michael Bonacore>And then apart from that, there's about $12 million in general fund that's—.

907
01:29:29.012 --> 01:29:29.996
<v Dan Ryan>That's a past practice.

908
01:29:31.556 --> 01:29:46.109
<v Dan Ryan>So I would— for me, it'd be more helpful to know what you would need without passing money on to the county, because to me that doesn't do much for our operational budget for '26-'27.

909
01:29:49.096 --> 01:29:53.018
<v Michael Bonacore>Are you asking if we need the $12 million in general fund that we currently have?

910
01:29:53.837 --> 01:29:59.805
<v Dan Ryan>I'm asking because of the very complicated accounting structures when you have multiple Yes.

911
01:29:59.854 --> 01:30:08.779
<v Dan Ryan>So we have several restricted accounts, and each of them— government, foundation, wherever they're coming from— has different reporting requirements.

912
01:30:09.470 --> 01:30:12.640
<v Dan Ryan>Some will allow you to use general— some of that funds for general funds.

913
01:30:12.753 --> 01:30:14.216
<v Dan Ryan>Some have different requirements.

914
01:30:14.689 --> 01:30:16.282
<v Dan Ryan>That's what I have always discovered.

915
01:30:17.261 --> 01:30:26.324
<v Dan Ryan>So I always found it challenging to get to the bottom line of how much money you need in the general fund as we go into the budget season '26-'27.

916
01:30:27.957 --> 01:30:39.514
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm hoping that all of this truing up and cleaning up will give us some clarity on that so we could perhaps use that money for '26-'27 since we have a general fund crisis.

917
01:30:39.659 --> 01:30:44.914
<v Dan Ryan>I'm looking over there now so that this could help us as we build our budget for '26-'27.

918
01:30:48.079 --> 01:30:48.858
<v Dan Ryan>That's where I'm coming from.

919
01:30:48.922 --> 01:30:50.804
<v Dan Ryan>No gotcha here, trying to be helpful.

920
01:30:51.095 --> 01:30:52.215
<v Dan Ryan>You understand what I'm asking?

921
01:30:52.311 --> 01:30:52.426
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

922
01:30:52.761 --> 01:30:53.838
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, City Administrator.

923
01:30:55.237 --> 01:30:58.353
<v Dan Ryan>And then technical question number 2, it's my final one.

924
01:30:59.091 --> 01:31:11.576
<v Dan Ryan>Going forward, we can either accept the previous allocated amounts that have been provided for us today, 'cause today I think was a little bit of air out of the balloon, like, oh, all of this was already mostly accounted for.

925
01:31:11.896 --> 01:31:41.672
<v Dan Ryan>So I need to know what we're doing today and what we're doing going forward is we can undo and seek a different focus Or we live with what you have in this document that I just listened to earlier in the session, where in fact, oh, there's not as much as we thought because it was allocated, in fact planned expectations for the following reasons.

926
01:31:42.996 --> 01:31:55.559
<v Michael Bonacore>Yes, I think the conversation as I understand it that I've I've heard from you all is that there's clarity that the $21 million, $20.7 million in RSO funds needs to be allocated by council.

927
01:31:56.314 --> 01:32:06.286
<v Michael Bonacore>And then a decision needs to be made about whether proposed uses, particularly in CET and short-term rental, will be allocated from—.

928
01:32:06.286 --> 01:32:09.449
<v Dan Ryan>And I think it's helpful not to use acronyms so public's listening.

929
01:32:09.497 --> 01:32:09.626
<v Jonas Biery>Sorry.

930
01:32:10.444 --> 01:32:13.175
<v Michael Bonacore>In construction excise tax or in short-term rental bucket.

931
01:32:13.431 --> 01:32:21.000
<v Michael Bonacore>That are proposed uses but not committed, whether Council wants to make allocations of those funds.

932
01:32:21.787 --> 01:32:22.606
<v Dan Ryan>Very helpful, Michael.

933
01:32:22.686 --> 01:32:23.270
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate that.

934
01:32:23.626 --> 01:32:24.967
<v Dan Ryan>So those are technical questions.

935
01:32:25.016 --> 01:32:25.600
<v Dan Ryan>They're now over.

936
01:32:25.761 --> 01:32:29.207
<v Dan Ryan>Strategic questions start to get us into the next step, and I'll stop.

937
01:32:29.789 --> 01:32:30.081
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

938
01:32:32.689 --> 01:32:33.413
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, colleagues.

939
01:32:33.493 --> 01:32:37.100
<v Candace Avalos>So timing-wise, we have 3 more minutes technically.

940
01:32:37.198 --> 01:32:39.274
<v Candace Avalos>I'm willing to give it a little bit more time.

941
01:32:39.735 --> 01:32:42.654
<v Candace Avalos>We've got a couple of folks here on the list.

942
01:32:42.783 --> 01:32:52.820
<v Candace Avalos>Um, everybody is on their second round, so before I move to second round folks, I want to ask if Councilor Koyama Lane or Council President Dunphy have anything they want to ask.

943
01:32:53.944 --> 01:32:55.386
<v Candace Avalos>Just making space for you if you need it.

944
01:32:55.724 --> 01:33:00.181
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, so why don't we aim to go until about 11:05 if that's okay?

945
01:33:00.261 --> 01:33:02.764
<v Candace Avalos>Just get this last round of technical questions and then we'll take a break.

946
01:33:03.309 --> 01:33:03.869
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Novick.

947
01:33:04.511 --> 01:33:05.601
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

948
01:33:06.467 --> 01:33:23.867
<v Steve Novick>So what I think that what council is sort of considering in broad strokes is choosing between rent assistance, preservation of existing affordable housing, building new housing, and the general fund.

949
01:33:24.528 --> 01:33:35.567
<v Steve Novick>And I'm glad that we've sort of highlighted today that if council did nothing, $19.7 million would go to preserving and presumably maximizing the use of and occupancy of existing affordable housing.

950
01:33:35.631 --> 01:33:35.680
<v Olivia Clark>Right.

951
01:33:36.640 --> 01:33:41.916
<v Steve Novick>So if we decide to reduce that amount below $19 million, we're reducing the amount for that purpose.

952
01:33:43.819 --> 01:33:48.847
<v Steve Novick>Intuitively, to me, it seems like maximizing our existing affordable housing is pretty good bang for the buck.

953
01:33:48.929 --> 01:34:06.903
<v Steve Novick>But could you give us some thoughts as to how we would go about evaluating the relative bang for the buck of preservation of existing affordable housing, providing rent assistance, I can take a shot.

954
01:34:07.693 --> 01:34:21.027
<v Michael Bonacore>I think maybe one clarification that may be helpful is that I think a lot of the consideration that's being given to the $21 million is referred to as rent assistance.

955
01:34:21.350 --> 01:34:23.793
<v Michael Bonacore>The Bureau itself has even used that term.

956
01:34:24.328 --> 01:34:28.439
<v Michael Bonacore>And I think folks often think of rent assistance as an ongoing subsidy.

957
01:34:29.038 --> 01:34:50.896
<v Michael Bonacore>And I think a lot of what is being contemplated is really around eviction legal defense and sort of short-term interventions that could include some amount of financial assistance to like cover back rent, but not ongoing rent assistance like what folks think of as the sort of programs that the county or Home Forward runs.

958
01:34:51.819 --> 01:34:52.805
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah.

959
01:34:53.256 --> 01:35:01.743
<v Michael Bonacore>So, If we're torturing fruit analogies, I think we're, you know, we're apples and oranges and bananas.

960
01:35:02.496 --> 01:35:02.608
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's—.

961
01:35:02.801 --> 01:35:20.386
<v Michael Bonacore>There are lots of different considerations that go into sort of immediate-term interventions that respond to the precarity of renters today and sort of the longer-term needs that are understood in the affordable housing portfolio.

962
01:35:22.692 --> 01:35:28.832
<v Michael Bonacore>And I think that's, I'm not trying to duck it, but that's really a debate for all of you to have.

963
01:35:30.231 --> 01:35:41.628
<v Michael Bonacore>You know, in terms of how to, you know, sort of assess the value of bang for the buck, that would be an exercise we'd have to put some thought into.

964
01:35:43.148 --> 01:35:44.377
<v Steve Novick>I'd appreciate that exercise.

965
01:35:44.440 --> 01:35:50.194
<v Steve Novick>I mean, just looking at Councilor Smith's proposal, Rent assistance for tenants is $3.9 million.

966
01:35:50.626 --> 01:35:54.167
<v Steve Novick>Rent assistance and rapid rehousing for tenants facing eviction is $2 million.

967
01:35:54.471 --> 01:35:58.573
<v Steve Novick>Rent assistance for individuals experiencing homelessness, sheltered housing, that's the mayor's thing, is $3 million.

968
01:35:59.038 --> 01:36:01.105
<v Steve Novick>There is the right to counsel thing, that's $1.9 million.

969
01:36:01.185 --> 01:36:09.054
<v Steve Novick>But most of it is just what Councilor Loretta Smith is suggesting, and I think what we've just talked about before, is rent assistance.

970
01:36:09.198 --> 01:36:32.228
<v Steve Novick>And I, to me, if you could have used that $19 million for rent assistance before, but you decided you wanted to use it to preserve and expand the— increase the use of existing affordable housing, then I would hope that you've gone through sort of an exercise of concluding that preserving and maximizing the value of existing affordable housing is preferable.

971
01:36:32.742 --> 01:36:40.158
<v Steve Novick>So if somebody in the past— I know, Mr. Bhattacharya, you're new— but if somebody in the past has gone through that exercise, I'd like to see it.

972
01:36:40.823 --> 01:36:52.349
<v Steve Novick>If you could try to come up with some justification or withdrawal of justification for spending that money on preservation rather than rent assistance, I'd like to see it.

973
01:36:52.914 --> 01:36:54.078
<v Michael Bonacore>And I apologize, Councilor.

974
01:36:54.368 --> 01:36:55.904
<v Michael Bonacore>I don't think I had the right frame.

975
01:36:56.680 --> 01:37:10.137
<v Michael Bonacore>I think in Councilor Smith's proposal and the slow the flow inflow, there are proposed uses that are very consistent with how RSO, the Renter Services Office, would deploy those funds.

976
01:37:11.654 --> 01:37:25.488
<v Michael Bonacore>And then in these, in the construction excise tax and short-term rent assistance buckets that are available, those are the ways that in the normal course of business, PHB would deploy those funds.

977
01:37:26.006 --> 01:37:38.796
<v Michael Bonacore>And so that's not to say that other, I mean, we're in a position where we're trying to not put our finger on the scale of what council might propose and what we think of it or not.

978
01:37:39.229 --> 01:37:45.868
<v Michael Bonacore>We're just sort of saying these are the ways that we would typically deploy the resources based on the category of funding that they come from.

979
01:37:47.565 --> 01:37:56.756
<v Steve Novick>Okay, but I would be careful about avoiding putting your finger on the scale because you guys are the experts and I want to hear what the experts have to say.

980
01:37:57.426 --> 01:38:16.599
<v Steve Novick>And I want to clarify that I'm sort of thinking of this as what Councilor Smith has put on the table as a $40 million pot of money, $19 million of which would, if council didn't move, would've gone to preservation and Maximization of existing affordable housing and what factors we should be looking at if we're trying to decide whether to reduce that amount.

981
01:38:17.243 --> 01:38:17.485
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

982
01:38:17.646 --> 01:38:26.560
<v Michael Bonacore>And I would say this presentation of our planned uses is our proposed, you know, consideration for you all.

983
01:38:26.881 --> 01:38:27.251
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

984
01:38:30.658 --> 01:38:33.006
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, Councilor Murillo.

985
01:38:33.215 --> 01:38:34.278
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

986
01:38:36.167 --> 01:38:37.581
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm going to ask one last question.

987
01:38:37.628 --> 01:38:39.266
<v Angelita Morillo>I'll try to be as clear as possible.

988
01:38:39.619 --> 01:38:41.337
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it's important to get it on the record.

989
01:38:41.979 --> 01:38:54.938
<v Angelita Morillo>So if the ACFR balances are not accurate, then why was the guidance provided by the City Budget Office to the city financial analysts to reconcile their budgeted beginning fund balances to those numbers?

990
01:38:55.693 --> 01:39:00.831
<v Angelita Morillo>Because you've suggested that the analysis that me and my office have done is incomplete, which is okay.

991
01:39:01.786 --> 01:39:05.197
<v Angelita Morillo>But you are also asking bureaus to use the same numbers in the spring TAO.

992
01:39:06.296 --> 01:39:09.707
<v Angelita Morillo>So I'm just not understanding the difference there.

993
01:39:11.479 --> 01:39:16.070
<v Jonas Biery>Councilor, the balances in the ACFR are accurate as audited by the external auditor.

994
01:39:20.380 --> 01:39:20.492
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

995
01:39:20.975 --> 01:39:26.595
<v Angelita Morillo>Well, I guess we'll see who's right in a few weeks regarding the $137 million.

996
01:39:27.800 --> 01:39:38.640
<v Angelita Morillo>But, uh, there— I'm telling my colleagues now, I think that there is more money there, and we will have to take a look at that.

997
01:39:38.948 --> 01:39:41.695
<v Angelita Morillo>So I will hold off further questions.

998
01:39:41.777 --> 01:39:42.773
<v Angelita Morillo>I know we're at break time.

999
01:39:44.869 --> 01:39:45.288
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1000
01:39:45.369 --> 01:39:48.802
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, we are at time, so I'm going to give you the last word if you want to take a couple minutes.

1001
01:39:48.979 --> 01:39:49.060
<v Adrian Delgado>Okay.

1002
01:39:49.399 --> 01:39:49.882
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1003
01:39:50.028 --> 01:39:50.947
<v Loretta Smith>Um, thank you, Madam Chair.

1004
01:39:51.479 --> 01:39:56.659
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to go backwards I'll start and, and talk about Smith 1, which is $41 million.

1005
01:39:57.206 --> 01:40:12.422
<v Loretta Smith>It puts $20.7 million into rent assistance to help folks who are facing eviction, and it also puts rent assistance in for folks who are in shelter.

1006
01:40:13.194 --> 01:40:18.078
<v Loretta Smith>And the other $8 million, I put actually $5.1 million back into the general fund.

1007
01:40:18.143 --> 01:40:18.255
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

1008
01:40:19.457 --> 01:40:23.962
<v Loretta Smith>And the, the balance of the $8.6 million goes to a project.

1009
01:40:24.747 --> 01:40:35.439
<v Loretta Smith>And as you said, um, Michael, the short-term money, we have identified, uh, projects that could be used, and none of these require any code changes at all.

1010
01:40:35.502 --> 01:40:37.715
<v Loretta Smith>They're not outside of the restricted areas.

1011
01:40:38.146 --> 01:40:40.055
<v Loretta Smith>So we did a, a good mix.

1012
01:40:40.135 --> 01:40:46.514
<v Loretta Smith>But to, to really close this with the point that Councilor Elana Councilor Smith.

1013
01:40:46.579 --> 01:40:47.550
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Smith, I agree with what Councilor Pirtle-Guiney said.

1014
01:40:47.648 --> 01:40:49.012
<v Loretta Smith>We are in a housing crisis.

1015
01:40:51.605 --> 01:40:57.453
<v Loretta Smith>You all failed to identify purposes for the monies, and we weren't shown it.

1016
01:40:57.871 --> 01:41:11.617
<v Loretta Smith>So at this point, we need to deal with the housing crisis, and some of that housing crisis should be dealt with in terms of homeownership, keeping people in their homes who are actually getting ready to be evicted from their homes.

1017
01:41:11.923 --> 01:41:14.368
<v Loretta Smith>And if we don't do that, they're going to be out on our Yes.

1018
01:41:14.689 --> 01:41:22.623
<v Loretta Smith>It's going to cost us more to serve them if they're in a homeless shelter, um, as opposed to, uh, serving them while they're in their homes.

1019
01:41:23.009 --> 01:41:26.855
<v Loretta Smith>So those dollars, um, we try to put them in the right buckets.

1020
01:41:27.256 --> 01:41:40.288
<v Loretta Smith>And if there's something that you see that's in a wrong bucket, I'd just like to, to know what that looks like, because I worked on this with Ruth from the, uh, City Budget Office, and we tried to make sure that we didn't have to have any additional code changes.

1021
01:41:40.369 --> 01:41:40.561
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1022
01:41:40.882 --> 01:41:42.087
<v Loretta Smith>To that $41 million.

1023
01:41:42.810 --> 01:41:47.387
<v Loretta Smith>But if there's something wrong, if we have it in the wrong bucket, let us know and we will change it.

1024
01:41:47.854 --> 01:41:49.733
<v Loretta Smith>But we know we're in a housing crisis.

1025
01:41:49.797 --> 01:42:06.404
<v Loretta Smith>We passed the Slow the Flow to Homelessness, which identified that we should be putting some of these resources into rent assistance in addition to building additional affordable housing and affordable first-time homebuyer projects.

1026
01:42:07.033 --> 01:42:08.432
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Smith.

1027
01:42:08.627 --> 01:42:10.912
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know about the $62 million.

1028
01:42:11.041 --> 01:42:14.453
<v Loretta Smith>I'm only really concerned about the $40— about the $41 million.

1029
01:42:14.984 --> 01:42:23.328
<v Loretta Smith>I think those dollars are dollars that we can actually mark up and get on the streets before June 30th.

1030
01:42:23.393 --> 01:42:33.095
<v Loretta Smith>If we don't get that on the streets before June 30th, it's going to be— it's going to be impossible for us to meet the need of people who are being evicted.

1031
01:42:35.579 --> 01:42:42.605
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1032
01:42:47.766 --> 01:42:50.430
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you to our panel of experts here.

1033
01:42:50.527 --> 01:42:51.899
<v Candace Avalos>We appreciate your time.

1034
01:42:52.382 --> 01:42:55.305
<v Candace Avalos>So we are going to take a quick recess.

1035
01:42:55.368 --> 01:42:56.192
<v Candace Avalos>It is 11:08.

1036
01:42:56.256 --> 01:43:00.060
<v Candace Avalos>Please be back at 11:18 and we'll begin the second half of our discussion.

1037
01:43:00.542 --> 01:43:00.831
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1038
01:55:21.858 --> 01:55:25.983
<v Candace Avalos>Do we have any councilors lingering out there?

1039
01:55:28.872 --> 01:55:43.882
<v Candace Avalos>All right, we are going to return to our discussion.

1040
01:55:45.033 --> 01:55:46.685
<v Candace Avalos>Let everybody get settled.

1041
01:55:50.279 --> 01:55:50.332
<v Michael Bonacore>Okay.

1042
01:55:52.369 --> 01:55:52.529
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1043
01:55:52.594 --> 01:55:58.060
<v Candace Avalos>So before moving through these discussion prompts, I want to briefly frame this portion of the work session.

1044
01:55:58.814 --> 01:56:09.601
<v Candace Avalos>So over the past several months, council has had substantial conversations about housing investments, including prevention strategies, housing production, and longer-term structural approaches.

1045
01:56:10.099 --> 01:56:12.663
<v Candace Avalos>And today's conversation is meant to build on that work.

1046
01:56:13.240 --> 01:56:25.247
<v Candace Avalos>The goal is not necessarily to make final decisions— thank you— in this moment, but to surface where there may already be alignments and where councilors may have additional ideas or priorities That we should consider.

1047
01:56:25.905 --> 01:56:30.960
<v Candace Avalos>I'm going to walk through a few discussion prompts one at a time so we can move through them in an organized way.

1048
01:56:31.586 --> 01:56:35.340
<v Candace Avalos>And so you, uh, councilors all received these questions ahead of time.

1049
01:56:35.837 --> 01:56:42.801
<v Candace Avalos>The way that we have it timed out, I mean, it's like about 10-ish minutes per question, so I'll do my best to keep us moving.

1050
01:56:43.297 --> 01:56:49.426
<v Candace Avalos>Um, but also feel free, uh, to use your time to speak on, uh, on any question if that feels appropriate.

1051
01:56:49.490 --> 01:56:51.144
<v Candace Avalos>So we don't have to be super structured.

1052
01:56:51.640 --> 01:56:53.229
<v Candace Avalos>Um, but we will start with question 1.

1053
01:56:54.222 --> 01:57:14.470
<v Candace Avalos>And so what we wanted to do, because we have again been building this conversation, wanted to provide the essentially all of the amendments that were being introduced to see if your understanding of our current options or constraints currently before council is what we see here.

1054
01:57:14.600 --> 01:57:18.270
<v Candace Avalos>So, and if not, I want to hear what might be missing from the framework.

1055
01:57:18.335 --> 01:57:23.047
<v Candace Avalos>Are there categories or constraints that you believe should be clarified before we move further into discussion allocation?

1056
01:57:23.145 --> 01:57:29.859
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Smith, So we're just going to kind of get grounded on what's been in front of us and get some feedback about that.

1057
01:57:29.972 --> 01:57:32.319
<v Candace Avalos>And then we'll go through each individual bucket.

1058
01:57:32.623 --> 01:57:45.350
<v Candace Avalos>We have it broken up to talk about what should the rental services type investments be, what should the development projects investments be, what kind of money do we want to set aside in contingency or perhaps set up for social housing.

1059
01:57:45.817 --> 01:57:49.255
<v Candace Avalos>And then lastly, what kind of money do we need to set aside for general fund.

1060
01:57:50.291 --> 01:57:52.574
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, let me look at my queue.

1061
01:57:52.655 --> 01:57:54.405
<v Candace Avalos>I see we've got Councilor Green first.

1062
01:57:54.519 --> 01:57:55.231
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead and kick it off.

1063
01:57:56.533 --> 01:57:57.712
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1064
01:57:58.149 --> 01:57:59.896
<v Mitch Green>About how much time do I have?

1065
01:58:00.413 --> 01:58:03.649
<v Candace Avalos>We're going to do about 10-ish minutes each question, but we'll just kind of go from there.

1066
01:58:04.576 --> 01:58:04.833
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

1067
01:58:05.798 --> 01:58:12.688
<v Mitch Green>Colleagues, I've actually passed out a brief write-up to help kind of organize my thoughts in advance of this session.

1068
01:58:13.876 --> 01:58:20.421
<v Mitch Green>My staff As well as staff from Councilor Morillo's office kind of helped put this together.

1069
01:58:20.613 --> 01:58:22.231
<v Mitch Green>And so I've handed this out.

1070
01:58:23.256 --> 01:58:35.610
<v Mitch Green>But I think the way I want to enter this discussion today, just speaking for myself at this juncture, is that I want to hit the reset switch a little bit on where we have been in this conversation over the last couple months.

1071
01:58:35.931 --> 01:58:57.966
<v Mitch Green>So I don't really want to start from any particular named amendments or any previous set of proposals, but really think about what are the salient themes that came out of all those discussions and try to divide it between both demand-side interventions as well as supply-side interventions, because those are both critical to the housing problem.

1072
01:58:59.826 --> 01:59:06.110
<v Mitch Green>I want to think about approaching this discussion in terms of 2 tiers of council action.

1073
01:59:07.208 --> 01:59:28.965
<v Mitch Green>Tier 1 being I don't think there's a sort of immediate requirement to act now on the $20.7 million because I think we all understand that that's probably the area where we have the most council discretion and the intended use of those funds are very much about helping tenants not be evicted, right?

1074
01:59:29.175 --> 01:59:31.819
<v Mitch Green>And making sure they stay housed or get rehoused.

1075
01:59:33.338 --> 01:59:34.765
<v Mitch Green>They have access to a lawyer and so on and so forth.

1076
01:59:36.121 --> 01:59:41.448
<v Mitch Green>And then there's this second tier, which is more of a call for strategic programming.

1077
01:59:42.105 --> 01:59:49.695
<v Mitch Green>And Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, you had— you got onto a number that I— that's consistent with my number, which is $30.4 million.

1078
01:59:51.011 --> 02:00:02.725
<v Mitch Green>And we had confirmed previously that if we were to consider $34— $30.4 million, we would be engaging with a sort of intervention in a sense of Okay.

1079
02:00:02.805 --> 02:00:09.020
<v Mitch Green>We're not doing a lot of staff planning on what we think the out-year notice of funding availability buckets are.

1080
02:00:09.645 --> 02:00:12.921
<v Mitch Green>And I think we need to be honest about that.

1081
02:00:13.179 --> 02:00:19.199
<v Mitch Green>And then I finally have this like last category, which is we've talked about the Broadway corridor a lot in these previous discussions.

1082
02:00:19.826 --> 02:00:42.859
<v Mitch Green>And as we went through this, I wouldn't do this for any other TIF line item, but I think in the context of the Broadway corridor, I think it's appropriate for us to sort of contemplate Earmarking the $4.8 million of unallocated housing set-aside funds, expanding our use of those funds to make it available for gap funding for that project, which we can get into that discussion.

1083
02:00:44.958 --> 02:00:54.493
<v Mitch Green>Um, and so I think in Tier 1, I'd really like to see us think about dividing the $20.7 million as follows.

1084
02:00:55.493 --> 02:01:00.359
<v Mitch Green>Um, $9 million for For sort of short-term demand-side rent assistance.

1085
02:01:02.009 --> 02:01:05.918
<v Mitch Green>Could help 450 to 4,500 households stay stabilized.

1086
02:01:07.550 --> 02:01:12.972
<v Mitch Green>We can have a discussion on how to condition that bucket, but I really didn't want to get into the weeds.

1087
02:01:13.087 --> 02:01:14.235
<v Mitch Green>I want to keep this pretty high level.

1088
02:01:16.983 --> 02:01:18.935
<v Mitch Green>$1.9 Million for eviction defense.

1089
02:01:19.000 --> 02:01:22.967
<v Mitch Green>That's a number that we've floated up and kind of tested a couple different times.

1090
02:01:25.038 --> 02:01:45.380
<v Mitch Green>To me, that's going to be another demand-side intervention that I think is the most humane way and also the most cost-efficient way to keep someone housed and provide meaningful legal defense dollars for that work.

1091
02:01:46.677 --> 02:01:49.030
<v Mitch Green>And then finally, $8.8 million in emergency assistance.

1092
02:01:49.095 --> 02:01:49.274
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1093
02:01:50.730 --> 02:01:55.581
<v Mitch Green>What I think is actually a supply-side solution, which is rent buydowns or mortgage buydowns.

1094
02:01:55.949 --> 02:02:00.511
<v Mitch Green>We've talked about it in 2 different ways here, which gets to the stabilization question.

1095
02:02:00.929 --> 02:02:22.819
<v Mitch Green>And the reason why I think that that's a really important intervention, colleagues, is that it's really tough to be a member of the public and hear all these headlines that say, okay, $21 million today, $40 million tomorrow, $106 million the next day, and then read another headline that says there's 1,800 units That's really tough.

1096
02:02:22.819 --> 02:02:26.619
<v Mitch Green>And it's our job to close the loop on that.

1097
02:02:26.619 --> 02:02:44.520
<v Mitch Green>And so I think if we step up and say, look, we have— we're taking action to correct a failure to allocate these funds, and we step in and say we are going to preserve what we have because it is the most cost-effective way to make those units available, and we've talked about different ways to preserve those units, I think that's a really good thing.

1098
02:02:44.520 --> 02:02:44.560
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1099
02:02:44.641 --> 02:02:45.060
<v Mitch Green>Those units.

1100
02:02:45.108 --> 02:02:46.537
<v Mitch Green>I've had some conversations with REACH.

1101
02:02:47.114 --> 02:02:48.784
<v Mitch Green>I've had some conversations with Home Forward.

1102
02:02:49.877 --> 02:02:59.622
<v Mitch Green>There's a universe in which we can be very effective in this intervention that I think we can show voters that at roughly $60,000 a unit, we can bring those units back into serviceability.

1103
02:03:00.055 --> 02:03:01.516
<v Mitch Green>That's very cost-effective.

1104
02:03:01.903 --> 02:03:06.158
<v Mitch Green>And then we can move into— I'm probably burning my clock down, but we can move into Tier 2.

1105
02:03:06.238 --> 02:03:10.059
<v Mitch Green>And this is where I actually really do think we should step in and talk about what our priorities are.

1106
02:03:10.300 --> 02:03:20.760
<v Mitch Green>I think we have a generational opportunity with this one-time money, and it is one-time money, to maybe do some pilot social housing acquisition.

1107
02:03:20.859 --> 02:03:27.100
<v Mitch Green>You know, let's go out and buy something from the market while it is on sale, because we will not have that opportunity again.

1108
02:03:27.859 --> 02:03:34.949
<v Mitch Green>We have a short window of time where we can step in for pennies on the dollar, acquire an asset, call it social housing.

1109
02:03:35.319 --> 02:03:35.979
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

1110
02:03:36.640 --> 02:03:46.631
<v Mitch Green>And then I think that if we're going to talk about— there's been a lot of really, like, good proposals for good projects that have, you know, specific names attached to them for gap funding.

1111
02:03:46.695 --> 02:03:54.195
<v Mitch Green>I think we can allocate some money to, um, uh, to provide soft debt capital for that gap funding.

1112
02:03:55.545 --> 02:04:02.106
<v Mitch Green>So create a pool of money to say for basically, you know, 0% or 1%, something less than 1%.

1113
02:04:02.203 --> 02:04:02.283
<v Michael Bonacore>1%.

1114
02:04:03.283 --> 02:04:12.795
<v Mitch Green>We can loan a long-dated loan to you to close your capital stack so you can actually get the shovels in the ground, as opposed to just a grant that goes out and we don't get it back.

1115
02:04:12.972 --> 02:04:14.618
<v Mitch Green>So that's how I would like to approach this conversation.

1116
02:04:16.319 --> 02:04:41.608
<v Mitch Green>I'm willing to kind of answer any questions as we get into this, like, cross-dais dialogue, but I was really hoping to reset the conversation about high-level prioritization, 2 tiers, and And really make sure that we're talking about $55.9 million or slightly less than that if you don't count that TIF district stuff and not the full $106 million because that's just not at our disposal.

1117
02:04:41.720 --> 02:04:45.279
<v Mitch Green>So I'll leave it there for now and look forward to the conversation.

1118
02:04:48.069 --> 02:04:48.744
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor.

1119
02:04:49.372 --> 02:04:49.807
<v Candace Avalos>Love this.

1120
02:04:50.016 --> 02:04:51.530
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's a very good place to start.

1121
02:04:52.029 --> 02:04:53.881
<v Candace Avalos>Council President Dunphy.

1122
02:04:54.122 --> 02:04:54.462
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1123
02:04:54.525 --> 02:04:56.506
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, Councilor Green, I really appreciate this.

1124
02:04:56.618 --> 02:05:08.453
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is really It really sort of boils down to me some of the conversations we've been having and the universe of ideas that have been out there and then sort of tries to bring it back based off the information we heard today.

1125
02:05:08.551 --> 02:05:18.712
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just want to verify though, in this scenario, while I like the 2-tier approach, just to be explicit, you would not envision returning any dollars to the general fund?

1126
02:05:21.867 --> 02:05:22.548
<v Jonas Biery>I don't have that, Alex.

1127
02:05:24.829 --> 02:05:24.926
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1128
02:05:24.975 --> 02:05:31.631
<v Jamie Dunphy>Otherwise, I mean, like beyond that, this all really feels consistent and interesting.

1129
02:05:32.630 --> 02:05:39.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>Also the river, the TIF, I gotta say that the TIF, the River District TIF reallocation makes a lot of sense to me.

1130
02:05:40.847 --> 02:05:44.868
<v Jamie Dunphy>Those are supposed to be dollars that are used towards creation or acquisition of housing dollars.

1131
02:05:45.288 --> 02:05:46.757
<v Jamie Dunphy>River District doesn't exist.

1132
02:05:47.469 --> 02:05:52.548
<v Jamie Dunphy>And there's been obviously a lot of conversation on this dais about the future of the Broadway corridor parcel sales.

1133
02:05:53.452 --> 02:06:06.087
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I think this is a really great framework for us to be thinking about this and to start moving towards some consensus around.

1134
02:06:06.524 --> 02:06:08.364
<v Jamie Dunphy>So good job.

1135
02:06:08.445 --> 02:06:08.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1136
02:06:12.801 --> 02:06:13.011
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

1137
02:06:13.125 --> 02:06:15.658
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Novick.

1138
02:06:16.609 --> 02:06:17.438
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1139
02:06:18.381 --> 02:06:27.489
<v Steve Novick>One preliminary question I have is All of the various proposed rent assistance categories, is that short-term rent assistance?

1140
02:06:27.635 --> 02:06:32.279
<v Steve Novick>How many people does that— do those pots envision giving people rent assistance for how many years?

1141
02:06:34.904 --> 02:06:39.847
<v Candace Avalos>Maybe I can start to answer that, and then I don't know if maybe Councilor Green, you want to add to it.

1142
02:06:39.976 --> 02:06:47.494
<v Candace Avalos>I think ultimately the way that we programmed it originally was trying to fill these short gaps, and there's actually lots of different ways to do rent assistance.

1143
02:06:47.707 --> 02:06:53.359
<v Candace Avalos>So it definitely is not on the far end of we're providing rent assistance for years and years to come.

1144
02:06:53.712 --> 02:07:04.389
<v Candace Avalos>It's more so that there are a lot of people that are about to be evicted or they're a couple months behind and being able to help them fill that gap and get stable so that they can stay in their house and continue.

1145
02:07:04.533 --> 02:07:11.163
<v Candace Avalos>Because often a lot of times it's not that people have no income, it's just that, you know, life and other things, right, they get behind.

1146
02:07:11.212 --> 02:07:23.492
<v Candace Avalos>And so the way we structured, we had it in a couple of different Because, for example, we made sure that we were ensuring dollars would get to immigrant families in particular since they have been cut off from federal resources, things like that.

1147
02:07:23.573 --> 02:07:28.006
<v Candace Avalos>So overall, to answer your question, the intent is kind of like gap financing for buildings.

1148
02:07:28.055 --> 02:07:30.280
<v Candace Avalos>It's like gap financing for humans so that they stay in their home.

1149
02:07:31.750 --> 02:07:31.990
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1150
02:07:33.230 --> 02:07:41.313
<v Steve Novick>So I would like us to have an extensive discussion about rent— temporary rent assistance versus permanent rent assistance.

1151
02:07:41.942 --> 02:07:50.630
<v Steve Novick>What Councilor Green is focused on, which is stabilizing existing affordable housing, because having affordable housing is itself rent assistance.

1152
02:07:50.902 --> 02:07:52.328
<v Steve Novick>It's long-term rent assistance.

1153
02:07:52.505 --> 02:07:55.181
<v Steve Novick>It means that there are units that are available at a lower rent.

1154
02:07:55.871 --> 02:08:05.823
<v Steve Novick>And if there, there are units that are not being filled and we could do something that helps fill them, then that is a form of rent assistance for the people in those, those units.

1155
02:08:06.529 --> 02:08:18.055
<v Steve Novick>If some of these affordable housing providers are at risk of collapsing, Then that means a whole bunch more people are evicted and the properties theoretically will be picked up, you know, to be used for unaffordable rents.

1156
02:08:19.211 --> 02:08:28.430
<v Steve Novick>And I also just want to underscore something I said before, which is that we do not have a short-term crisis that we can expect will end in the next couple of years.

1157
02:08:29.185 --> 02:08:35.016
<v Steve Novick>We have an ongoing crisis which we can't anticipate is going to end in the next couple of years.

1158
02:08:35.756 --> 02:08:46.557
<v Steve Novick>And in the context of that ongoing crisis, the county has spent tens of millions, in fact, I think hundreds of millions of dollars on rent assistance, and that has not been sufficient to slow the inflow.

1159
02:08:47.108 --> 02:08:55.980
<v Steve Novick>So I am worried about our adding $9 million additional to what the county has done, which has not been sufficient to slow the inflow.

1160
02:08:58.137 --> 02:09:09.667
<v Steve Novick>And my belief, and it'd be nice to see some more testimony on this, is that we get more bang for our buck by preserving and enhancing the use of existing affordable housing.

1161
02:09:10.405 --> 02:09:15.322
<v Steve Novick>I also want to say that I'm going to vote no on anything that only allocates the $20 million.

1162
02:09:15.643 --> 02:09:24.720
<v Steve Novick>I think that Councilor Smith is doing the right way by looking at all $40 million at one time, and plus maybe this $10 million in CET money that I haven't focused on.

1163
02:09:25.137 --> 02:09:32.109
<v Steve Novick>So I think that we should focus on the big picture rather than debate just $20 million.

1164
02:09:32.190 --> 02:09:32.335
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1165
02:09:34.880 --> 02:09:40.260
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1166
02:09:40.260 --> 02:09:42.060
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1167
02:09:42.060 --> 02:09:43.449
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1168
02:09:44.199 --> 02:09:54.300
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, I'm looking at this sheet that Councilor Green handed out, and I do think, Councilor Green, that you are looking at the right amount of money, the right buckets of money.

1169
02:09:54.300 --> 02:09:58.720
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as we have the conversation today, I hope that we're not focused on the $160 million.

1170
02:09:58.710 --> 02:09:58.899
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>$4.82 I think that we're focused on the $100 million.

1171
02:09:58.966 --> 02:09:59.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Million.

1172
02:09:59.399 --> 02:10:04.057
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>$4.82 Million, but we're looking at the $20.7 and the $3.4, perhaps that $4.82.

1173
02:10:04.185 --> 02:10:05.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have some questions about that.

1174
02:10:06.354 --> 02:10:11.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think that means we need to spend all— what is that— $41.1 million.

1175
02:10:12.618 --> 02:10:21.387
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And there is a conversation we have not had about whether we should be allocating that $30.4 or not.

1176
02:10:21.694 --> 02:10:27.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we're going to allocate some of that, I agree, Councilor Novick, we should do that We should have a pack— well, as we do the 20.7.

1177
02:10:28.463 --> 02:10:29.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a work session.

1178
02:10:29.349 --> 02:10:30.797
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We won't allocate anything today.

1179
02:10:31.764 --> 02:10:37.297
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We should have a package that looks comprehensively at the needs in our community and what we are going to do with that.

1180
02:10:41.846 --> 02:10:51.842
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Spending that— there's a lot of things on the list we've talked about, colleagues, that I'm really interested in us funding, projects that I think we need to get going.

1181
02:10:51.895 --> 02:10:52.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1182
02:10:53.520 --> 02:10:56.185
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Work on the mortgage buydowns that I think is critical.

1183
02:10:57.132 --> 02:11:07.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I recognize that every dollar we spend out of that $30.4 million pot is us saying to our bureau, we're turning your processes upside down.

1184
02:11:09.336 --> 02:11:17.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Maybe we do that one time because there were these accounting variances that led to some different information.

1185
02:11:18.667 --> 02:11:21.309
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we say this is one time where we're willing to go in that direction.

1186
02:11:21.436 --> 02:11:31.257
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I can be comfortable with that, but only if we're being clear about this choice that we're making to turn our normal funding processes on their heads.

1187
02:11:33.764 --> 02:12:09.823
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am wondering about the $4.8 million because the first that I had heard about us using those dollars was today, and I know we're talking more than debating, Councilor Avalos, but I'm wondering if I'm wondering if we can ask our administrative team who's still up here with us to talk about whether there are other projects that the $4.8 million were being considered for, not necessarily things they've been allocated to, but are there 2 or 3 things that that has been in the back of people's minds for that we should know about so we understand the trade-offs, or is that truly money that has no trade-offs at this point?

1188
02:12:10.400 --> 02:12:13.015
<v Candace Avalos>I think it's totally fine to ask those questions if you are prepared to respond.

1189
02:12:15.091 --> 02:12:22.701
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, I will have my team message me if I get this incorrect or if there's something I'm not aware of.

1190
02:12:22.765 --> 02:12:30.564
<v Michael Bonacore>But I believe we represented those funds as we did because there really is not anything that we would otherwise recommend.

1191
02:12:31.500 --> 02:12:36.092
<v Michael Bonacore>So there are often, you know, sort of opportunistic opportunities that happen.

1192
02:12:36.447 --> 02:12:56.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's the possibility of making that available through a solicitation, but there's not, They're not tied up in any conversations with PSU or any conversations with the Diamond Project or any conversations with any other speculative development that we're having with other folks?

1193
02:12:57.305 --> 02:12:57.935
<v Michael Bonacore>That's correct.

1194
02:12:57.983 --> 02:12:58.289
<v Mitch Green>Correct.

1195
02:12:58.774 --> 02:12:59.838
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1196
02:12:59.887 --> 02:13:00.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's really helpful.

1197
02:13:02.529 --> 02:13:07.323
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, I know we're on the first question, but a couple of other people have talked about question number 2.

1198
02:13:07.853 --> 02:13:11.867
<v Candace Avalos>And feel free to go ahead and just talk through all the questions.

1199
02:13:11.930 --> 02:13:16.555
<v Candace Avalos>I don't want to— it sounds like we want it a little bit more fluid, so you can answer any of the questions.

1200
02:13:16.604 --> 02:13:17.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go ahead.

1201
02:13:17.967 --> 02:13:23.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just want to second the questions that Councilor Novick was asking about rent assistance.

1202
02:13:23.828 --> 02:13:37.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When we have one-time dollars as an entity that is often tasked with providing infrastructure And does less, not none, but less on the service provision side.

1203
02:13:38.011 --> 02:13:40.399
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we have one-time dollars before us.

1204
02:13:41.377 --> 02:13:49.002
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am not excited about spending any one-time dollars on ongoing program needs.

1205
02:13:50.444 --> 02:13:52.817
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They will leave us with a cliff down the road.

1206
02:13:53.104 --> 02:13:53.618
<v Olivia Clark>Second.

1207
02:13:53.793 --> 02:13:57.847
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They will leave us with those budget holes that we are looking at right now down the road.

1208
02:13:58.777 --> 02:14:06.814
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will make promises to community organizations that are helping people day in and day out that we cannot fulfill a few years from now.

1209
02:14:09.990 --> 02:14:24.493
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while I understand the importance, the critical importance of rent assistance, I don't think it is the right use or best use for these dollars.

1210
02:14:24.768 --> 02:14:49.122
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I hope that we focus as much as we can on things that have long-term effects for one-time purchases like construction, constructing new infrastructure, like those mortgage buydowns that I think can be used for not only lowering rent but addressing the other issues that make units unrentable, some of the turnover and security issues as well.

1211
02:14:51.712 --> 02:14:54.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope that that is a focus of our conversation.

1212
02:14:54.216 --> 02:14:55.654
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1213
02:14:55.756 --> 02:14:58.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sure I'll, I'll address more of the questions as we move through.

1214
02:14:59.640 --> 02:15:00.154
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good.

1215
02:15:00.909 --> 02:15:04.409
<v Candace Avalos>Colleagues, without objection, Mayor Wilson would like to insert the discussion.

1216
02:15:04.939 --> 02:15:06.288
<v Candace Avalos>Is that all right?

1217
02:15:06.930 --> 02:15:07.347
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead, Mayor.

1218
02:15:08.198 --> 02:15:08.873
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Chair.

1219
02:15:08.938 --> 02:15:10.912
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, councilors, for this opportunity.

1220
02:15:11.009 --> 02:15:14.364
<v Keith Wilson>I'd like to make some recommendations for your consideration.

1221
02:15:15.199 --> 02:15:18.748
<v Keith Wilson>We're making these decisions that are all good.

1222
02:15:19.519 --> 02:15:20.997
<v Keith Wilson>There are no bad decisions here.

1223
02:15:21.686 --> 02:15:25.604
<v Keith Wilson>But they're being made underneath the umbrella of a fiscal crisis that our city is facing.

1224
02:15:26.342 --> 02:15:33.777
<v Keith Wilson>This afternoon, you're going to be presented with the spring TAL and the budget deficit that we have right now today.

1225
02:15:34.242 --> 02:15:35.238
<v Keith Wilson>It's about $18 million.

1226
02:15:36.457 --> 02:15:48.242
<v Keith Wilson>The first recommendation that I, I'd like you to consider is taking a portion of these funds and addressing the immediate concern that we have to reduce service impacts and employee reductions.

1227
02:15:48.899 --> 02:15:49.478
<v Keith Wilson>That's first.

1228
02:15:50.264 --> 02:15:58.735
<v Keith Wilson>The second, and only my second request other than a few comments, would be to also focus on rent assistance for those currently experiencing homelessness.

1229
02:15:59.426 --> 02:16:04.384
<v Keith Wilson>We've had a really good year and we've worked very hard to bring people from the street into shelter.

1230
02:16:04.961 --> 02:16:09.502
<v Keith Wilson>I hope you join me to work as equally as hard to help people from shelter into housing.

1231
02:16:10.256 --> 02:16:12.390
<v Keith Wilson>And what's good news is that we have available housing.

1232
02:16:13.128 --> 02:16:21.770
<v Keith Wilson>We have thousands of affordable housing units that are available Today, we can house individuals within 5 months versus building housing, which will take 5 years.

1233
02:16:22.347 --> 02:16:31.661
<v Keith Wilson>So I hope that you join me in that immediacy of using these funds and looking at that one particular line item and seeing if you can plus up if you see possible.

1234
02:16:32.221 --> 02:16:34.674
<v Keith Wilson>2 Other points I want to make regarding Williams and Russell.

1235
02:16:35.412 --> 02:16:40.925
<v Keith Wilson>The state just passed legislation yesterday to bring $10 million into Williams and Russell.

1236
02:16:41.183 --> 02:16:45.418
<v Keith Wilson>And so anytime we can share and add funds to get that project going.

1237
02:16:45.996 --> 02:16:49.800
<v Keith Wilson>That just allows us to move faster to build housing quick for those in need.

1238
02:16:50.427 --> 02:16:52.754
<v Keith Wilson>And then the last and final is Broadway Corridor.

1239
02:16:53.782 --> 02:17:02.404
<v Keith Wilson>While the government did not pass funding to partner on that, I had a conversation with the governor earlier today regarding Broadway Corridor.

1240
02:17:02.629 --> 02:17:17.389
<v Keith Wilson>It is one of her single most important priorities to do 2 things: build affordable housing and then take that space in our downtown core and get construction workers moving and getting that housing moving as fast as possible.

1241
02:17:17.439 --> 02:17:19.933
<v Keith Wilson>So I just wanted to convey that priority to you from her.

1242
02:17:20.326 --> 02:17:21.736
<v Keith Wilson>So thank you for this opportunity, Chair.

1243
02:17:21.784 --> 02:17:22.292
<v Keith Wilson>I appreciate it.

1244
02:17:23.912 --> 02:17:24.400
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good.

1245
02:17:25.102 --> 02:17:25.657
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Kanal.

1246
02:17:26.849 --> 02:17:27.698
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

1247
02:17:28.916 --> 02:17:34.998
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so much good stuff in here, and I appreciate the conversation, and I appreciate the having something to react to.

1248
02:17:35.095 --> 02:17:38.935
<v Sameer Kanal>So thank you to Councilor Green, and I think Councilor Morillo and teams for this.

1249
02:17:39.756 --> 02:17:45.825
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to start by saying I think I agree on what the scope of the dollars are that we're looking at.

1250
02:17:47.724 --> 02:17:59.976
<v Sameer Kanal>Not necessarily— I'm not as concerned about the idea of adjusting what was penciled in because of the fact that it was penciled by bureau staff.

1251
02:18:00.379 --> 02:18:05.304
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do think that the ones that have specific projects are better left alone in this moment.

1252
02:18:05.400 --> 02:18:07.344
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not necessarily making a broader Understatement there.

1253
02:18:07.779 --> 02:18:15.843
<v Sameer Kanal>So looking at the 58.1 as, as already committed is, is something I'm comfortable doing, um, with a couple questions I have around CET.

1254
02:18:16.453 --> 02:18:21.019
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think, um, that's the part that I'm interested in is already in the 30.4, I believe.

1255
02:18:21.516 --> 02:18:24.072
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'll verify that later and, and, and update.

1256
02:18:24.184 --> 02:18:31.295
<v Sameer Kanal>But, um, as we get into what is good to look at, there are a few things here that I wanted to, to talk about.

1257
02:18:31.699 --> 02:18:43.879
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, First, the thing that I think has been missing this whole time is activating our spaces through the use of some of the short-term rental dollars for in-house economic development on the tourism side.

1258
02:18:44.329 --> 02:18:46.126
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not talking about millions and millions of dollars.

1259
02:18:46.174 --> 02:18:59.425
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm talking about helping events that are coming to Portland to be more successful, be larger, and help occupy more of those rental units, both in terms of Airbnb-type rentals and in terms of hotels downtown.

1260
02:18:59.554 --> 02:19:03.456
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's an investment in our future that will yield more money down the road.

1261
02:19:04.515 --> 02:19:07.502
<v Sameer Kanal>I have been an event planner in Portland.

1262
02:19:07.582 --> 02:19:10.858
<v Sameer Kanal>It is not always easy to do, and it's not always easy to scale here.

1263
02:19:10.953 --> 02:19:13.074
<v Sameer Kanal>So I do think that that's a piece that's missing.

1264
02:19:13.121 --> 02:19:17.377
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not talking about tens of millions of dollars here, but I do think that that's a part of it.

1265
02:19:17.842 --> 02:19:23.992
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's a good way to pivot into the general fund conversation because I think that's the mechanism, and I'm very comfortable with that.

1266
02:19:24.807 --> 02:19:27.816
<v Sameer Kanal>Request from the mayor, given that we're looking at this larger group.

1267
02:19:27.881 --> 02:19:34.048
<v Sameer Kanal>If we were just looking at the $20.7 million, I think there's a— the universe gets so small that it's harder to look at the general fund.

1268
02:19:34.095 --> 02:19:43.790
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think if we are talking about the, the, uh, $54 or $55 million, $55.9 million, then I think it makes sense to look at the general fund as well.

1269
02:19:45.527 --> 02:19:51.426
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, with relation to these tiers and what has been proposed, I'm a big supporter of rent Thank you.

1270
02:19:51.522 --> 02:19:59.085
<v Sameer Kanal>On the rent/mortgage buydowns, I think a permanent 18% reduction is a really valuable thing to look at.

1271
02:19:59.149 --> 02:20:05.573
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe that was the estimate we looked at for a couple hundred units there, and that would help us.

1272
02:20:06.279 --> 02:20:16.731
<v Sameer Kanal>When we looked at the math for 60 to 120% AMI, I think it was yesterday, day before, there was a time where we were looking at tables and just seeing how big of a difference that is Yes.

1273
02:20:17.213 --> 02:20:31.095
<v Sameer Kanal>In the affordability and how, how frankly some of what we consider affordable housing is not only not different from the market in a substantial way, but not even affordable at all.

1274
02:20:31.531 --> 02:20:34.394
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it really drew attention to that.

1275
02:20:34.684 --> 02:20:36.332
<v Sameer Kanal>Big supporter of eviction defense.

1276
02:20:36.397 --> 02:20:42.147
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with the mayor about the rental assistance piece for those trying to get from shelter into housing.

1277
02:20:42.194 --> 02:20:48.219
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd also like to look at the original purpose that Councilor Avalos has been beating the drum on this whole time, which is slowing the inflow.

1278
02:20:48.670 --> 02:21:00.748
<v Sameer Kanal>It is, I would put preventing someone from becoming houseless always as the highest priority there, followed by what the mayor requested of trying to get someone who is currently in shelter into housing.

1279
02:21:01.904 --> 02:21:09.588
<v Sameer Kanal>The piece I wanted to talk about here from this Tier 2, the social housing acquisition, I'm very, very, very supportive of.

1280
02:21:10.904 --> 02:21:17.291
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm actually okay with the $4.8 million going to to Broadway corridor given the TIF River District restriction.

1281
02:21:17.629 --> 02:21:23.233
<v Sameer Kanal>I am surprised to be saying that as much as anybody else might be hearing me say that, uh, just because of that restriction.

1282
02:21:23.730 --> 02:21:29.816
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but given that it already has $5 million, I think $9.8 million is, is more than enough for one thing.

1283
02:21:30.555 --> 02:21:36.800
<v Sameer Kanal>And I would like to see that other $800,000 be looked at for some of the other priorities we talked about, including that tourism piece.

1284
02:21:37.540 --> 02:21:38.213
<v Dan Ryan>And I'll leave it there.

1285
02:21:41.970 --> 02:21:42.742
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you.

1286
02:21:42.950 --> 02:21:49.115
<v Candace Avalos>So what I'm going to do, um, I'm going to keep going with first rounds if that's okay.

1287
02:21:49.197 --> 02:21:50.529
<v Candace Avalos>So Councilor Green, I'll come back to you.

1288
02:21:50.641 --> 02:21:59.488
<v Candace Avalos>We'll do Councilor Koyama Lane, Councilor Murillo, and then I'll do the second round with, um, Novick— or Green and Novick— and then I'll open up the next 2 questions when we go there.

1289
02:21:59.778 --> 02:22:00.532
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1290
02:22:00.740 --> 02:22:01.736
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair.

1291
02:22:02.747 --> 02:22:04.627
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, thank you for this work.

1292
02:22:05.398 --> 02:22:09.117
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The teams of Councilor— Councilors Green and Murillo.

1293
02:22:09.745 --> 02:22:17.250
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am wondering if it's— since we're all kind of looking at this and I don't think members of the public get to see it, can it be something that is put up as a—.

1294
02:22:17.975 --> 02:22:18.361
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great.

1295
02:22:18.458 --> 02:22:18.989
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Meeting materials.

1296
02:22:19.166 --> 02:22:19.907
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Great.

1297
02:22:22.486 --> 02:22:37.948
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I have heard in different conversations in community that some different explanations of rent buydown, and so for me, I think it would be I don't know if it's you all or even if Councilor Green, you want to clarify.

1298
02:22:37.996 --> 02:22:47.393
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm hearing folks talk about using the funds to lower rents going forward so you can do some sort of restructuring of debt.

1299
02:22:47.458 --> 02:22:57.608
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then I've also heard it being talked about as for some of the affordable housing providers that are kind of underwater, helping them out with their debt, which might not lower rents.

1300
02:22:57.656 --> 02:22:58.104
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, so I think that's a great question.

1301
02:22:58.442 --> 02:23:03.129
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so if someone wants to clarify, that would be helpful.

1302
02:23:06.028 --> 02:23:09.492
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, go ahead, Michael.

1303
02:23:10.861 --> 02:23:11.907
<v Michael Bonacore>Sure, sure.

1304
02:23:12.295 --> 02:23:21.951
<v Michael Bonacore>Councilor, as I've said, rent buydowns as a strategy is something newer for the Housing Bureau.

1305
02:23:22.435 --> 02:23:28.003
<v Michael Bonacore>We've described a couple of recent specific projects that were in the development pipeline.

1306
02:23:28.646 --> 02:23:37.552
<v Michael Bonacore>And so we had the opportunity to restructure debt and get those buydowns before the property went into operation.

1307
02:23:38.599 --> 02:23:50.978
<v Michael Bonacore>And when something is in development and in that state, it's a little bit easier to sort of do that restructuring.

1308
02:23:51.903 --> 02:23:56.426
<v Michael Bonacore>It is possible to do once a building is in operation.

1309
02:23:57.100 --> 02:24:10.075
<v Michael Bonacore>And I think you get to the question of, are you simply buying down debt to help stabilize operations versus buydowns, is a question of how much you're investing, essentially.

1310
02:24:11.230 --> 02:24:22.331
<v Michael Bonacore>And so we've got definitely a lot of providers who need— who would need debt buydown, who would benefit from debt buydowns To sort of stabilize the financial performance of their portfolio.

1311
02:24:24.136 --> 02:24:28.225
<v Michael Bonacore>And could also, you know, tenants could benefit from rent buydowns.

1312
02:24:28.900 --> 02:24:42.414
<v Michael Bonacore>And the reason there's not sort of a comprehensive answer for this is 'cause we haven't really had a full strategy developed and we haven't had sort of like a big pot of money where we could make this available.

1313
02:24:42.461 --> 02:24:46.424
<v Michael Bonacore>So we're relatively young in our experience of making it work.

1314
02:24:46.570 --> 02:24:48.018
<v Michael Bonacore>And there are, I'm sure, Yeah.

1315
02:24:48.817 --> 02:24:54.462
<v Michael Bonacore>Approaches that we haven't even, you know, we haven't tried yet, but that exist out there.

1316
02:24:55.155 --> 02:24:56.022
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, thank you.

1317
02:24:56.200 --> 02:24:57.486
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks for explaining that.

1318
02:24:57.583 --> 02:24:59.193
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We might want to get clear on that.

1319
02:24:59.257 --> 02:25:08.490
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think for me in supporting that, I would— I want to see like rents going forward being able to be lower to be part of that.

1320
02:25:09.270 --> 02:25:13.012
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Did you want to add on to what you were thinking, Councilor Green, and explain?

1321
02:25:13.304 --> 02:25:17.269
<v Mitch Green>I'll just wait until I come back around and then— Just know that I'm gonna respond to that point too.

1322
02:25:17.364 --> 02:25:18.746
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, great.

1323
02:25:19.293 --> 02:25:32.990
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I know that we're still working all this out, but if we were to be talking about more of the short-term stabilization, giving bridges of rent assistance, is that something we can do in-house?

1324
02:25:33.507 --> 02:25:38.906
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We would be doing it as the Bureau, or is it something we'd be contracting out to others to help us do?

1325
02:25:40.695 --> 02:25:45.077
<v Michael Bonacore>There are approaches to eviction prevention and eviction legal defense that exist in-house.

1326
02:25:47.111 --> 02:25:54.851
<v Michael Bonacore>And so we could, we could do that as long as council didn't sort of prescribe something that was outside the scope of what we're already doing.

1327
02:25:55.122 --> 02:26:03.150
<v Michael Bonacore>And I will just offer as well, Councilor, on that, on that last question that I said that there's sort of a universe of possibilities for rent buydown.

1328
02:26:03.215 --> 02:26:10.618
<v Michael Bonacore>But if you all sort of appropriate this money and say, you know, we, we want this to go towards this specific thing, like, we can, we can make that happen.

1329
02:26:10.986 --> 02:26:13.854
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And does it need to be— you were saying it needs to be a certain amount of money too?

1330
02:26:14.079 --> 02:26:17.486
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So it has to be a— depends how large the chunk is for you?

1331
02:26:17.647 --> 02:26:20.262
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, and that's really a question from project to project.

1332
02:26:20.326 --> 02:26:33.992
<v Michael Bonacore>I mean, if we're looking at a number in the $8 to $9 million range, I would anticipate we could probably do 2 or 3 projects and get maybe in the realm of 150 units.

1333
02:26:34.105 --> 02:26:34.644
<v Loretta Smith>Great.

1334
02:26:34.888 --> 02:26:35.556
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, thank you.

1335
02:26:35.620 --> 02:26:36.566
<v Michael Bonacore>But that's very soft math.

1336
02:26:37.952 --> 02:26:45.465
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, and then I just want to point out that we are talking about $40-ish million, which is a lot.

1337
02:26:45.690 --> 02:26:55.475
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, um, you know, it's seeming like we don't actually— we don't have to choose between one-time rent assistance and helping affordable housing providers.

1338
02:26:56.052 --> 02:27:01.451
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, it sounds like we can be able to possibly do both, which is great.

1339
02:27:01.595 --> 02:27:18.244
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, um, at first glance, and what I'm hearing a lot from constituents, is I am going to be making sure legal services are part of the package that I support, and keeping tenants housed, and also getting people into housing too.

1340
02:27:18.969 --> 02:27:19.889
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thanks.

1341
02:27:20.245 --> 02:27:22.826
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1342
02:27:22.907 --> 02:27:23.424
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Morillo.

1343
02:27:25.569 --> 02:27:37.006
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, you know, I put my hand down because I honestly think Councilor Green and I are saying the same thing, and in the spirit of us leaving at some point, I will just not repeat people's Sounds good.

1344
02:27:37.072 --> 02:27:44.289
<v Candace Avalos>Well then, with that, why don't I just open up the next 2 questions just so the public knows what we're responding to, and then we'll keep the conversation going.

1345
02:27:45.170 --> 02:27:53.629
<v Candace Avalos>So the next 2 are to talk about these 2 particular buckets around rental eviction prevention, all of that, and development projects.

1346
02:27:54.001 --> 02:28:07.022
<v Candace Avalos>So question 2 is about— the question is, which of these programs would you prioritize retaining at their current level Are there any programs that councilors believe should be scaled up, either because of demand, impact, or urgency?

1347
02:28:07.681 --> 02:28:12.718
<v Candace Avalos>And are there any modifications or new investments related to rental services that councilors would like to raise for consideration?

1348
02:28:13.456 --> 02:28:18.494
<v Candace Avalos>And then the second question is, which of the development projects currently identified would you prioritize retaining?

1349
02:28:18.685 --> 02:28:23.162
<v Candace Avalos>Are there projects or development strategies that councilors believe should be scaled up or expanded?

1350
02:28:23.563 --> 02:28:28.055
<v Candace Avalos>And are there new ideas or approaches related to housing development that councilors would like the group to consider?

1351
02:28:28.996 --> 02:28:33.655
<v Candace Avalos>So go ahead and pop in the queue if you'd like to talk to those questions, but we'll kick it off with Councilor Green.

1352
02:28:35.632 --> 02:28:36.612
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1353
02:28:36.676 --> 02:28:41.706
<v Mitch Green>And conveniently, my response to Novick is right on in the spirit of the question.

1354
02:28:41.754 --> 02:28:47.325
<v Mitch Green>So I think you're posing the right question, Councilor, that we need to start to test these trade-offs here.

1355
02:28:49.020 --> 02:28:55.176
<v Mitch Green>Rent assistance on the one hand and these other kind of more maybe perhaps long-term sorts of interventions.

1356
02:28:55.226 --> 02:28:59.995
<v Mitch Green>But I But I must— I do have to say that we don't have to make a binary choice.

1357
02:29:00.755 --> 02:29:11.631
<v Mitch Green>I think what we need to do is we need to figure out what is the right blend here, because again, rent assistance is a demand-side intervention that works alongside those other supply-side interventions.

1358
02:29:12.409 --> 02:29:18.837
<v Mitch Green>This is what we get from the practitioners with experience in this space.

1359
02:29:20.338 --> 02:29:22.474
<v Mitch Green>You can help keep someone stabilized with rent assistance.

1360
02:29:22.556 --> 02:29:24.218
<v Mitch Green>Not everyone is in an affordable housing unit.

1361
02:29:25.959 --> 02:29:29.359
<v Mitch Green>And so let's have the discussion.

1362
02:29:29.618 --> 02:29:36.013
<v Mitch Green>But I wouldn't— would not support sort of zeroing out of a kind of rent assistance bucket.

1363
02:29:36.809 --> 02:29:39.296
<v Mitch Green>To the mayor's proposals, I appreciate you laying those on the table.

1364
02:29:40.156 --> 02:29:42.397
<v Mitch Green>Helps me see where you're thinking, and it's very close to how I'm thinking.

1365
02:29:43.110 --> 02:29:49.781
<v Mitch Green>So when we drafted this, I took a step back and got up to a higher level of resolution when we think about rental assistance.

1366
02:29:49.831 --> 02:29:49.944
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1367
02:29:50.020 --> 02:29:59.156
<v Mitch Green>Let's just, let's just have a bucket for rental assistance and let's give direction when we allocate this to say it should be in line with the priorities of folks we're trying to serve right now.

1368
02:29:59.765 --> 02:30:03.652
<v Mitch Green>I think that we should make rental assistance available for folks who are unhoused who need to get into housing.

1369
02:30:03.843 --> 02:30:04.710
<v Mitch Green>I think that's critical.

1370
02:30:05.048 --> 02:30:06.638
<v Mitch Green>That's crucial.

1371
02:30:07.393 --> 02:30:13.959
<v Mitch Green>We can adjust how we use that and who's the right recipient based upon how the conditions change, I think.

1372
02:30:14.087 --> 02:30:15.308
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

1373
02:30:15.972 --> 02:30:18.647
<v Mitch Green>I want to respond to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1374
02:30:20.920 --> 02:30:35.105
<v Mitch Green>Um, you know, earlier on you had sort of raised up the bigger philosophical question of we need to determine whether or not we're going to ask the Bureau to change their existing NOFA plans and whether we think that's appropriate.

1375
02:30:35.236 --> 02:30:46.344
<v Mitch Green>I, I'll just make the case that I think it is appropriate just because while I understand the need to smooth out your resources over time, so that's There's something there 2, 3 years in the road, down the road.

1376
02:30:48.159 --> 02:30:57.028
<v Mitch Green>That's a sort of like planning practice in the absence of shocks and sort of emergent conditions that you don't necessarily know about ahead of time.

1377
02:30:57.188 --> 02:31:07.856
<v Mitch Green>I think we're in one of those crisis shocks where we have, we have opportunities to seize on investments right now that are probably going to be lower cost than a few years down the road.

1378
02:31:07.908 --> 02:31:18.682
<v Mitch Green>And so we might be to stitch together some solutions that get some things in the pipeline or convert— you know, I had a conversation recently with the folks who are involved in the co-op discussion space.

1379
02:31:20.567 --> 02:31:21.393
<v Mitch Green>They're well organized.

1380
02:31:21.441 --> 02:31:23.252
<v Mitch Green>They're ready to turn apartments into co-ops.

1381
02:31:23.299 --> 02:31:24.237
<v Mitch Green>They just don't have capital.

1382
02:31:24.949 --> 02:31:33.863
<v Mitch Green>So we could enter in this space under the broad banner of social housing and say one of the first things we could do is provide renters an opportunity to now have an equity stake in their building.

1383
02:31:33.913 --> 02:31:35.625
<v Mitch Green>That's something we can do right Right now.

1384
02:31:36.186 --> 02:31:43.460
<v Mitch Green>And so, you know, that's kind of— that's— so I'm making the case, I guess, for us to think about intervening on those plans.

1385
02:31:44.199 --> 02:31:57.799
<v Mitch Green>And then finally, Councilor Koyama Lane, I had started this conversation, was inspired by the rent buydown presentation at the Finance Committee, I think on the 12th of January, started on the rent buydown implementation of mortgage buydowns.

1386
02:31:57.862 --> 02:31:59.405
<v Mitch Green>But then I had broader conversations.

1387
02:31:59.468 --> 02:32:10.332
<v Mitch Green>I met with REACH They made the case that there's actually— the challenges facing these providers are different depending upon the building, depending upon the institution.

1388
02:32:10.379 --> 02:32:12.463
<v Mitch Green>And so some flexibility might be desired.

1389
02:32:13.472 --> 02:32:15.036
<v Mitch Green>We could have a prioritization schedule.

1390
02:32:16.539 --> 02:32:21.622
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to share— I'll forward you an email that I got from Madison Moskowitz who said let's look to Seattle.

1391
02:32:22.219 --> 02:32:23.721
<v Mitch Green>Actually, Seattle has a program like this.

1392
02:32:23.817 --> 02:32:28.719
<v Mitch Green>They have an intake form where you fill out Kind of what your purpose for the request for funds would be.

1393
02:32:29.170 --> 02:32:33.808
<v Mitch Green>And that could be a way for the bureau to develop a program around this and engage in a prioritization process.

1394
02:32:33.808 --> 02:32:40.790
<v Mitch Green>So I thought that was interesting to share a best practice or an existing practice from Seattle and just kind of lay that on the table there.

1395
02:32:40.889 --> 02:32:45.670
<v Mitch Green>So I'm not dogmatic, I guess what I'm saying, about how to use this category of debt buydown.

1396
02:32:45.670 --> 02:32:47.549
<v Mitch Green>I just want to use it, frankly.

1397
02:32:47.950 --> 02:32:49.989
<v Mitch Green>I would like it to be for rents lowered, though.

1398
02:32:50.590 --> 02:32:52.709
<v Mitch Green>And that's how— if, like, if I was advocating for something, I'd want to see it for rents lowered.

1399
02:32:52.697 --> 02:32:52.750
<v Michael Bonacore>It Thank you.

1400
02:32:52.777 --> 02:32:54.103
<v Mitch Green>To be like the priority.

1401
02:32:54.167 --> 02:32:55.558
<v Mitch Green>Like, we can have scoring matrices.

1402
02:32:55.608 --> 02:32:57.515
<v Mitch Green>We have that on our grant making all the time.

1403
02:32:57.742 --> 02:32:59.084
<v Mitch Green>So I'll leave it there.

1404
02:33:01.500 --> 02:33:01.677
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1405
02:33:01.759 --> 02:33:02.406
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Novick.

1406
02:33:03.055 --> 02:33:09.436
<v Steve Novick>Madam Chair, if you'll forgive me, I want to clarify a couple of things that might not be directly responsive to these couple of questions.

1407
02:33:10.841 --> 02:33:18.370
<v Steve Novick>Okay, so first of all, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, I hear what you're saying about we don't have to allocate the second— the $30 million pot now.

1408
02:33:19.279 --> 02:33:30.247
<v Steve Novick>My concern is that, for example, I mean, I like Councilor Green's idea of spending $8.5 million of the $20 million on rent buydowns, et cetera.

1409
02:33:31.068 --> 02:33:36.816
<v Steve Novick>But I worry that if we do that, people might think of that as a ceiling rather than a floor.

1410
02:33:37.266 --> 02:33:40.332
<v Steve Novick>And the assumption might be that we don't use any of the $30 million for that.

1411
02:33:40.981 --> 02:33:43.046
<v Steve Novick>And I'd actually probably like to see the number higher.

1412
02:33:43.128 --> 02:33:44.119
<v Steve Novick>So that's my hesitation.

1413
02:33:44.183 --> 02:33:44.248
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1414
02:33:46.227 --> 02:34:00.987
<v Steve Novick>And let's see, I— but sort of along the same lines, I am not— I actually rather like Councilor Green's and Councilor Murillo's proposal.

1415
02:34:01.852 --> 02:34:14.898
<v Steve Novick>I might sort of want to tweak it and say let's maybe have more flexibility for more affordable housing buydowns versus social housing, but I sort of like the mix of Long-term versus short-term in it.

1416
02:34:16.433 --> 02:34:25.995
<v Steve Novick>One, so I mean, again, by saying that I don't want to vote on Councilor Green's initial $20 million proposal, that doesn't mean that it's an objection to the proposal overall.

1417
02:34:27.606 --> 02:34:40.475
<v Steve Novick>The other thing I wanted to say though, in terms of urgency, is that if we're going to get money for the general fund, then my understanding is that has to come out of part of the second bucket, which is the short-term rental 2% part.

1418
02:34:40.556 --> 02:34:40.636
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1419
02:34:41.549 --> 02:34:55.828
<v Steve Novick>So if we don't, uh, I feel some urgency to say we're going to spend a chunk of that money on the general fund, which is another reason I'm not totally comfortable with the idea of saying we'll just vote on the $20 million and not vote on anything else.

1420
02:35:00.326 --> 02:35:00.745
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1421
02:35:01.211 --> 02:35:01.936
<v Candace Avalos>Council President.

1422
02:35:02.179 --> 02:35:02.646
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1423
02:35:03.852 --> 02:35:08.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I have 2 additional sort of points to this, and, and it's not I'm not— so for—.

1424
02:35:09.674 --> 02:35:09.980
<v Michael Bonacore>Okay.

1425
02:35:12.311 --> 02:35:21.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't believe that we should be spending money supporting units above 60% AMI broadly.

1426
02:35:23.093 --> 02:35:30.396
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that it's, you know, been stated over and over again that roughly right now, 60% AMI unit is market rent.

1427
02:35:32.240 --> 02:35:34.038
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think we need to be a little tighter about this.

1428
02:35:34.119 --> 02:35:38.091
<v Jamie Dunphy>I understand that there are some federal requirements around LIHTC and things like that.

1429
02:35:40.139 --> 02:35:52.804
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I think broadly, philosophically, this— that public dollars in the housing market should only be used to fill spaces where the private market won't meet.

1430
02:35:53.191 --> 02:35:54.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>They're not building 30% units.

1431
02:35:54.727 --> 02:35:56.102
<v Jamie Dunphy>They're not building 40% units.

1432
02:35:57.540 --> 02:36:01.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that is the only reason why I think we should be investing in housing broadly.

1433
02:36:03.720 --> 02:36:19.746
<v Jamie Dunphy>The other sort of philosophical point that I'm— I guess I don't know if we can— I don't know if this is a policy thing or something to discuss now, but something that Councilor Green started to touch on, which is that right now we are largely a pass-through organization.

1434
02:36:20.406 --> 02:36:27.985
<v Jamie Dunphy>That when we are investing in housing, we take public dollars and we cut a check and we put it out into the public, but we don't have anything 10 years later.

1435
02:36:28.032 --> 02:36:28.594
<v Jamie Dunphy>We don't own any assets.

1436
02:36:29.161 --> 02:36:31.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>We don't have that continued ownership stake.

1437
02:36:31.989 --> 02:36:55.025
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know if this is a thing, but if we are going to buy down rents, if we're going to buy down the mortgages, is there an opportunity for us to have an ongoing ownership stake or an ongoing asset for the city to be able to claim and also insure over the long term, I guess?

1438
02:36:55.090 --> 02:36:55.155
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1439
02:36:56.662 --> 02:36:56.854
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

1440
02:36:57.065 --> 02:37:00.051
<v Jamie Dunphy>We don't do great over long-term maintenance and things like that.

1441
02:37:00.148 --> 02:37:13.813
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I'm just thinking more broadly, like if we have one-time dollars and we're talking about maximizing the impact of those one-time dollars, I just worry that if we just cut a check, then that is the end of it.

1442
02:37:14.536 --> 02:37:20.490
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I don't know how to, I mean, like ultimately social housing is, that is a core tenet of what we're trying to think about.

1443
02:37:21.791 --> 02:37:25.720
<v Jamie Dunphy>Maintaining a public asset as a values proposition.

1444
02:37:27.128 --> 02:37:40.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>But those are sort of like the— those 2 points that like, how affordable is affordable and what does the city have after we are done are things that I'm just really continue to be concerned about broadly about our housing policy.

1445
02:37:40.954 --> 02:37:46.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>But also if there's ways that we can reflect any of that in how we are doing this or if this is an opportunity for us to think about that.

1446
02:37:46.298 --> 02:37:46.412
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1447
02:37:46.572 --> 02:37:47.844
<v Jamie Dunphy>Us to start pivoting.

1448
02:37:48.504 --> 02:37:53.146
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think there's a real— I think those are really important considerations.

1449
02:37:54.617 --> 02:37:54.810
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

1450
02:37:56.638 --> 02:37:58.224
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so we're at 12:03.

1451
02:37:58.352 --> 02:37:59.533
<v Candace Avalos>We go until 12:30.

1452
02:38:00.198 --> 02:38:04.050
<v Candace Avalos>And I was about to say, I haven't heard from Smith, Zimmerman, Ryan.

1453
02:38:04.328 --> 02:38:05.161
<v Candace Avalos>Great, get in there.

1454
02:38:05.716 --> 02:38:06.156
<v Candace Avalos>Clark.

1455
02:38:06.809 --> 02:38:08.769
<v Candace Avalos>So I'd love to start seeing you in the queue.

1456
02:38:10.100 --> 02:38:13.916
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Kanal, I think, did you take yourself out to go after?

1457
02:38:14.110 --> 02:38:15.540
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, so go ahead, Councilor Smith.

1458
02:38:17.569 --> 02:38:19.004
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, thank you, Madam Chair.

1459
02:38:20.263 --> 02:38:21.489
<v Loretta Smith>I agree with everyone.

1460
02:38:21.619 --> 02:38:25.072
<v Loretta Smith>I think we need to spend some of those dollars on, uh, rent assistance.

1461
02:38:25.409 --> 02:38:34.733
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I also believe the 2% money that we have the $8.6 million in, in my proposal, it, it gives $5 million back to the general fund.

1462
02:38:34.781 --> 02:38:35.909
<v Loretta Smith>I think that's going to be very important.

1463
02:38:36.925 --> 02:38:49.424
<v Loretta Smith>And I also think that we need to support some of those, um, projects that need this last gap funding, like Williams and Russell, Broadway Corridor, and Self-Enhancement Homeownership Program.

1464
02:38:49.489 --> 02:38:50.555
<v Loretta Smith>That's going to be great.

1465
02:38:51.252 --> 02:38:56.066
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to address something that the council president said about having assets.

1466
02:38:56.179 --> 02:38:57.362
<v Loretta Smith>I'm all about having assets.

1467
02:38:57.426 --> 02:38:58.448
<v Loretta Smith>I think that's important.

1468
02:38:59.000 --> 02:39:06.477
<v Loretta Smith>But with assets, just like the assets we currently have in our public works system, they require ongoing maintenance and ongoing money.

1469
02:39:06.638 --> 02:39:06.718
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1470
02:39:06.948 --> 02:39:17.242
<v Loretta Smith>So as we're talking about buying these assets, if we're not putting in the budget long-term maintenance for ongoing dollars, that comes with the cost.

1471
02:39:17.290 --> 02:39:18.364
<v Loretta Smith>It's not a one and done.

1472
02:39:18.974 --> 02:39:23.847
<v Loretta Smith>So, and if we're not planning to sell that asset, we don't really get a lot out of it.

1473
02:39:23.929 --> 02:39:25.691
<v Loretta Smith>We're going to be putting more money into it.

1474
02:39:26.076 --> 02:39:30.871
<v Loretta Smith>So that's why I really like the idea of helping the community-based developers.

1475
02:39:31.545 --> 02:39:33.004
<v Loretta Smith>We help them with their gap funding.

1476
02:39:33.067 --> 02:39:33.501
<v Loretta Smith>They do it.

1477
02:39:33.549 --> 02:39:34.063
<v Loretta Smith>We don't have to maintain it.

1478
02:39:34.111 --> 02:39:34.415
<v Adrian Delgado>Councilor Smith.

1479
02:39:34.479 --> 02:39:34.754
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1480
02:39:34.916 --> 02:39:39.487
<v Loretta Smith>But if we do buy the social housing thing, we are going to have to maintain it.

1481
02:39:39.536 --> 02:39:40.655
<v Loretta Smith>So that's going to be another bucket.

1482
02:39:41.459 --> 02:39:46.735
<v Loretta Smith>And then we're going to have to figure out how do we maintain it and what do we take out of our current budget.

1483
02:39:47.291 --> 02:39:49.002
<v Loretta Smith>And that's the other issue.

1484
02:39:49.647 --> 02:39:55.810
<v Loretta Smith>The last thing that I'm concerned about, and we'll talk about this later, is the realignment process for the city.

1485
02:39:56.568 --> 02:39:58.887
<v Loretta Smith>They're being asked for 3%, 10%, I think 20%.

1486
02:39:58.986 --> 02:40:05.047
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not We're not sure what's going to become of that realignment.

1487
02:40:05.560 --> 02:40:19.320
<v Loretta Smith>So not knowing that and seeing what we have forward, I think we need to quickly support these projects that Green put out and get that done right now for '25-'26.

1488
02:40:19.757 --> 02:40:28.867
<v Loretta Smith>The other question that I have, Michael, I know we've talked before about the rental assistance, and at this late date now, we talked about it in December and January.

1489
02:40:28.934 --> 02:40:29.002
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1490
02:40:29.079 --> 02:40:29.255
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1491
02:40:29.834 --> 02:40:34.511
<v Loretta Smith>If we do the rent assistance, it's going to take until after July 1st.

1492
02:40:35.121 --> 02:40:51.110
<v Loretta Smith>One of the proposals that I had put forward was to identify community-based organizations like the Sun School groups who do rental assistance to actually appropriate that to them so they can get it out on the floor before July 1st.

1493
02:40:51.528 --> 02:41:03.787
<v Loretta Smith>So is your sense still that if we kept the rental assistance and kept it in the Portland Housing Bureau, that we will not be able to get it out until after June 30th?

1494
02:41:05.897 --> 02:41:14.084
<v Michael Bonacore>I think for potentially for something like a new program, like eviction legal defense, which we don't currently do, that will take longer.

1495
02:41:15.477 --> 02:41:21.286
<v Loretta Smith>Not that the rental assistance, the actual to help people who are being evicted that are in their homes and we want to keep them there.

1496
02:41:22.246 --> 02:41:29.630
<v Loretta Smith>We had talked about that it would take a long time for you to put out an RFP for that, and it probably wouldn't happen until after the first of the year.

1497
02:41:30.343 --> 02:41:36.540
<v Loretta Smith>I'm saying we have existing programs that we work with, with Multnomah County and with the Sun School programs.

1498
02:41:36.961 --> 02:41:39.778
<v Loretta Smith>They are doing— they've all run out of their rental assistance money.

1499
02:41:40.399 --> 02:41:48.304
<v Loretta Smith>And I've talked to a few of them, and they can put those dollars on the street fairly quickly in the realm of $250,000 to $300,000.

1500
02:41:48.352 --> 02:41:48.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1501
02:41:49.229 --> 02:41:59.522
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm saying if we did pass a rental assistance bucket and we sent it back to PHB, would you be able to get it out before June 30th?

1502
02:42:01.927 --> 02:42:11.058
<v Michael Bonacore>If what, um, if what gets passed aligns with work that we're already doing and we can increase contracts, then we can get that money out.

1503
02:42:11.139 --> 02:42:16.748
<v Michael Bonacore>If it's something new that we're not doing or we need to have a different scope, then it would take longer.

1504
02:42:17.132 --> 02:42:20.603
<v Loretta Smith>So, and we're not doing that because we're not in the business of rental assistance right now.

1505
02:42:20.667 --> 02:42:21.927
<v Loretta Smith>We would have to do an RFP.

1506
02:42:22.299 --> 02:42:31.710
<v Loretta Smith>We have old programs that we did during ARPA that we would have to, to, um, we, we'd have to activate those folks, and that would be a process.

1507
02:42:32.878 --> 02:42:36.240
<v Michael Bonacore>If we were running a rent assistance program that we don't currently exist, that's right.

1508
02:42:36.532 --> 02:42:49.858
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, so that's why I was suggesting to directly appropriate these funds to programs are currently doing it, they got reduced on the state level and they can get those funds out before June 30th.

1509
02:42:49.938 --> 02:42:55.282
<v Loretta Smith>If not, I mean, what's the purpose of us identifying rental assistance?

1510
02:42:55.700 --> 02:43:04.175
<v Loretta Smith>And the monies that we don't do here, that it can roll over, but I think there's a certain amount of this money that needs to get out of the door before June 30th.

1511
02:43:05.236 --> 02:43:18.627
<v Michael Bonacore>So I, again, I don't have a lot of experience and the city doesn't have a relationship with SunSchool, so I believe I believe the mechanism here would be an intergovernmental agreement between the city and the county to move that money through their system.

1512
02:43:18.787 --> 02:43:19.012
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Right.

1513
02:43:19.188 --> 02:43:20.469
<v Loretta Smith>But they would get it directly.

1514
02:43:20.549 --> 02:43:21.719
<v Loretta Smith>It wouldn't come through PHB.

1515
02:43:21.768 --> 02:43:29.861
<v Loretta Smith>It would come from PHB, but it, it wouldn't be that they would actually be able to actually do this right now, right?

1516
02:43:30.261 --> 02:43:35.533
<v Michael Bonacore>I believe once we did an IGA, if the county system can accommodate that, then yes.

1517
02:43:36.031 --> 02:43:36.656
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1518
02:43:37.297 --> 02:43:38.370
<v Loretta Smith>And they can do it directly.

1519
02:43:38.578 --> 02:43:39.844
<v Loretta Smith>We don't have to give it to the county.

1520
02:43:40.037 --> 02:43:44.148
<v Loretta Smith>We can give it directly to the SUN school systems who are already doing Thank you.

1521
02:43:44.552 --> 02:43:55.474
<v Loretta Smith>Some of those programs are already in our system, like Latino Network, ERCO, Multnomah Metropolitan Housing and Family Services.

1522
02:43:55.733 --> 02:44:05.220
<v Loretta Smith>And then we also have Self-Enhancement, who also is a SUN School provider that provides for rent assistance in every district in the city of Portland.

1523
02:44:06.028 --> 02:44:14.673
<v Loretta Smith>And, and, and that's the only reason why I didn't think about doing it with PHB was because of the conversation that we had.

1524
02:44:15.699 --> 02:44:28.666
<v Loretta Smith>The second piece is that if we do carry over money, if there are dollars that we carry over, would you actually RFP those dollars?

1525
02:44:29.341 --> 02:44:33.764
<v Loretta Smith>Because we're not going to do this after— this is one time only, and I've been telling people this is one time only money.

1526
02:44:33.828 --> 02:44:34.998
<v Loretta Smith>This is not our book of business.

1527
02:44:37.001 --> 02:44:43.369
<v Loretta Smith>Would you also have to RFP those dollars after July 1st, those funds that we don't use before the 30th?

1528
02:44:46.513 --> 02:44:55.699
<v Michael Bonacore>If there's, if there's money that we move out before June— before July 1st, we won't have to do something after July 1st.

1529
02:44:55.941 --> 02:45:08.932
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, but I think in the slow the flow, we put money in for this fiscal year and next fiscal And so I'm just trying to figure out how we do that and what adjustments we, we make in amendments.

1530
02:45:10.594 --> 02:45:14.274
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, may I hop in for maybe just to help sort this out?

1531
02:45:15.905 --> 02:45:20.126
<v Donnie Oliveira>In the Slow the Flow proposal, there was money, you know, forecasted in multiple years.

1532
02:45:20.382 --> 02:45:26.520
<v Donnie Oliveira>Each year, those, those resources would have to be budgeted in our budgeting process, even though they were committed to the program.

1533
02:45:26.889 --> 02:45:31.983
<v Donnie Oliveira>For the bureau to spend the dollars, they would still, through a budget action, have to be authorized to be spent, right?

1534
02:45:32.031 --> 02:45:33.649
<v Donnie Oliveira>So in that case, we would do that.

1535
02:45:33.988 --> 02:45:40.637
<v Donnie Oliveira>In the event that money was not spent, we would use the fall TAO to true up the dollars to be carried, carried forward, right?

1536
02:45:40.896 --> 02:45:41.751
<v Loretta Smith>So that would be good.

1537
02:45:41.993 --> 02:45:43.010
<v Donnie Oliveira>There would always be an action.

1538
02:45:43.283 --> 02:45:43.347
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1539
02:45:43.429 --> 02:45:50.781
<v Loretta Smith>And so the purpose would be to put all the money for rent assistance in '25-'26 so that it can roll over and we don't have to reauthorize it.

1540
02:45:51.005 --> 02:45:52.614
<v Mitch Green>Perhaps.

1541
02:45:52.871 --> 02:46:01.443
<v Donnie Oliveira>I think that's— I think that we'd want to let the Bureau staff provide their their best, you know, best guess of implementation for, you know, practicality.

1542
02:46:02.013 --> 02:46:02.550
<v Loretta Smith>Well, thank you.

1543
02:46:03.469 --> 02:46:03.825
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1544
02:46:06.314 --> 02:46:07.429
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, Councilor Zimmerman.

1545
02:46:10.918 --> 02:46:11.225
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1546
02:46:11.370 --> 02:46:19.600
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I think most everybody knows I'm probably in the camp of creating more units is, is my number one priority.

1547
02:46:20.816 --> 02:46:27.217
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and so I think that I think this mix that's being discussed is generally, I understand it, supportive.

1548
02:46:27.441 --> 02:46:37.299
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's something I want to tap into a little bit though with your comments, Council President, about what level of AMI we should be investing in.

1549
02:46:37.493 --> 02:46:41.907
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I think those are really salient points and they're easy to track.

1550
02:46:43.096 --> 02:46:45.247
<v Eric Zimmerman>And here's the other part of that conversation.

1551
02:46:46.324 --> 02:46:53.933
<v Eric Zimmerman>When we talk about So I'm a believer that mixed-income buildings and mixed-income neighborhoods are the healthiest type, right?

1552
02:46:53.996 --> 02:46:55.099
<v Eric Zimmerman>Like, that's where I come from.

1553
02:46:56.259 --> 02:47:10.176
<v Eric Zimmerman>The Pearl District is one of those where lots of affordable, lots of middle, and certainly some luxury balance has brought that community into a densely populated sector of our city.

1554
02:47:11.739 --> 02:47:35.305
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if we believe that density is the future for urban planning, which I'm one of those people, We're in a situation right now where, you know, in Northwest Portland, if you get into the numbers of Northwest with the alphabet, it's going— those are filled, those buildings are filled with what would and should be naturally affordable units.

1555
02:47:36.289 --> 02:47:50.271
<v Eric Zimmerman>But because our capacity is so stretched in our community, we have people who make perfectly healthy salaries who are, I I guess renting or buying downs in, in a way, because that's what's available at a high level, right?

1556
02:47:50.335 --> 02:47:59.795
<v Eric Zimmerman>That, that what I would say is they should be competing with other units, but because they're not, those owners of those, you know, 4-brick— and I'm talking the old ones, right?

1557
02:47:59.859 --> 02:48:01.918
<v Eric Zimmerman>And a lot of us as young people lived in them at different times.

1558
02:48:02.806 --> 02:48:07.519
<v Eric Zimmerman>Those are now getting a rate that I would say has put us out of balance.

1559
02:48:07.906 --> 02:48:08.373
<v Steve Novick>And so—.

1560
02:48:09.495 --> 02:48:25.727
<v Eric Zimmerman>That balance matters because if you think about Broadway Corridor, which is an extension of the Pearl District, it will be the next, I hope, mixed-income, densely populated, uh, mixed building income as well.

1561
02:48:27.552 --> 02:48:33.386
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is where, at least in that district, where rents are higher than they are in other parts of the city.

1562
02:48:34.493 --> 02:48:37.481
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that there can be an argument in limited Very limited use.

1563
02:48:37.547 --> 02:48:50.135
<v Eric Zimmerman>Very limited use that we want to incentivize that some AMI, not a certain percentage of it, but just some average folks, middle incomes, are able to be there as well.

1564
02:48:50.471 --> 02:49:08.362
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I think will happen in the Broadway corridor if we don't look at at least a little bit, and it's— we're talking one building, is that we'll have one highly subsidized unit, highly, like the lowest AMI, and then We hope on, on, on a, you know, a whisper, if you will.

1565
02:49:08.476 --> 02:49:20.165
<v Eric Zimmerman>We hope that others will eventually pencil in projects, but those will pencil in fully at market, and we will leave out essentially families, uh, below the $150,000.

1566
02:49:21.472 --> 02:49:29.051
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or I think even if we're really talking about 2-bedroom areas, we're really leaving out families in large numbers that would fall into the middle class for families.

1567
02:49:29.806 --> 02:49:51.277
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if we make those choices of, of not putting a little bit of money to make sure that we have some, some restricted units in certain buildings available at what is right now— it's, it's terrible that we have to talk about it, but we have to incentivize middle-income units to be built in parts of this city.

1568
02:49:51.469 --> 02:50:07.146
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's where I would just ask that you be open to Sometimes there's— if we want to create a mixed-income development, and I think that we do in Broadway Corridor as a planned community, that it might take us incentivizing some of that.

1569
02:50:07.210 --> 02:50:20.795
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just, I offer that as a challenge because at the same time, I think it's responsible that we make an estimate that if the market is not going to develop, because that was your words, if the market is not building, well, right now— It's not.

1570
02:50:21.412 --> 02:50:28.915
<v Eric Zimmerman>The market in the downtown areas is not building apartments that can be afforded by the by the a middle income person or family.

1571
02:50:29.683 --> 02:50:42.058
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's not unusual in District Four to have a three thousand dollar rent for a rental apartment in Slabtown, and and that is that is a challenging number for a lot of income levels.

1572
02:50:42.957 --> 02:50:47.269
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I offer it because I think we're a council, and I think we're a city whose urban planning.

1573
02:50:48.478 --> 02:50:56.998
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we're a city whose urban planning believes in mixed income, and there will be some places that that's going to be more expensive to incentivize.

1574
02:50:58.149 --> 02:50:59.179
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we can make that choice.

1575
02:50:59.388 --> 02:51:04.581
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's just that it may take longer to incent— it may take longer for it to come to fruition if it's not incentivized.

1576
02:51:04.757 --> 02:51:07.563
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or we may create a canyon.

1577
02:51:08.873 --> 02:51:12.740
<v Eric Zimmerman>Market rate, high dollar, and the most subsidized, very low dollar.

1578
02:51:12.789 --> 02:51:13.468
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's what we're doing.

1579
02:51:14.194 --> 02:51:19.438
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I don't know that that's the healthiest community that can be built in different sectors of our city.

1580
02:51:19.502 --> 02:51:23.057
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I offer that up in limited scope.

1581
02:51:23.104 --> 02:51:27.718
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that we have to consider the zip code in which we're trying to incentivize development.

1582
02:51:32.257 --> 02:51:51.738
<v Eric Zimmerman>In terms of the Housing Bureau's production, right, I am in large favor of helping in concept, the idea of helping restructure a mortgage for an affordable housing building to allow them to reduce their rents.

1583
02:51:53.319 --> 02:52:20.237
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I think would be helpful is why we, collective we, allow a system to exist where you were subsidized to build it, you bring the rent in, and it should be to maintain it, pay the mortgage, and hopefully put some staff around it.

1584
02:52:23.213 --> 02:52:38.032
<v Eric Zimmerman>The continual bailout is a concern for me because most everybody who can't get A renter at a certain dollar amount, they lower their rent so that they don't go 6 months with a vacancy.

1585
02:52:38.210 --> 02:52:51.007
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm having a tough time swallowing the 6-month Home Forward pill right now, because if we do this bailout, it is, it is to a group who has 6-month vacancies.

1586
02:52:51.266 --> 02:52:56.587
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for, I think, a general person in the public, we go, excuse me, like, lower the damn rent.

1587
02:52:56.636 --> 02:52:56.684
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah.

1588
02:52:57.523 --> 02:52:58.470
<v Eric Zimmerman>If you can't get a renter.

1589
02:52:59.305 --> 02:53:00.781
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what are those structural things?

1590
02:53:00.909 --> 02:53:03.270
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can we articulate some of those structural things?

1591
02:53:03.847 --> 02:53:13.269
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it has been said in some circles that the way some of these organizations stay afloat is by floating the next construction project.

1592
02:53:13.316 --> 02:53:15.099
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's how they keep their staff on board.

1593
02:53:15.805 --> 02:53:21.871
<v Eric Zimmerman>So before we commit to buying down their mortgages, can we, can we get an understanding that the system actually isn't rotten to its core?

1594
02:53:21.920 --> 02:53:22.385
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1595
02:53:23.189 --> 02:53:47.438
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because if, if I have a $100 million asset, a building, and I subsidize the rent because y'all, the government, helped me subsidize the building of that, or the, the construction of that building, my expenses month in and month out should be the note, should be building maintenance, right?

1596
02:53:47.712 --> 02:53:47.858
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

1597
02:53:48.513 --> 02:53:52.334
<v Eric Zimmerman>In an ownership model, we'd call that the HOA, but in a rental model.

1598
02:53:53.074 --> 02:53:55.434
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what is the rent going to?

1599
02:53:55.900 --> 02:54:05.939
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because as much as I want to get down with the mortgage adjustment stuff, I need to understand why they didn't do what everybody else would've done, which was lower the damn rent.

1600
02:54:06.903 --> 02:54:09.070
<v Eric Zimmerman>Like, what's going on with that system?

1601
02:54:09.873 --> 02:54:11.127
<v Michael Bonacore>Sure, I'll do my best, Councilor.

1602
02:54:12.507 --> 02:54:30.637
<v Michael Bonacore>So, you know, I think, I think when we think about the collective we, the collective we as funding jurisdictions, federal government, have historically required underwriting criteria that are very tight.

1603
02:54:31.518 --> 02:54:37.702
<v Michael Bonacore>It's understood that in a number of years, those projects will be underwater, and that's happening now faster.

1604
02:54:38.327 --> 02:55:08.208
<v Michael Bonacore>So I think one of the, One of the critical things for us and for our jurisdictional funding partners is to revisit how we're doing the underwriting and building in things like, you know, expectations around security systems and understanding that operating expenses have escalated in a way, particularly with populations who are experiencing acute behavioral challenges.

1605
02:55:08.465 --> 02:55:08.625
<v Adrian Delgado>Thank you.

1606
02:55:11.015 --> 02:55:15.335
<v Michael Bonacore>Health issues that the game has fundamentally changed.

1607
02:55:15.385 --> 02:55:26.347
<v Michael Bonacore>And so we have to change our game because if we continue to do it the way we have, we're setting folks up to fail and then telling them that they have— that they've failed.

1608
02:55:27.129 --> 02:55:28.865
<v Michael Bonacore>So I think, you know, there's a—.

1609
02:55:28.865 --> 02:55:31.608
<v Eric Zimmerman>Before you go on, Michael, can I ask just a clarifying question with that?

1610
02:55:31.689 --> 02:55:32.549
<v Eric Zimmerman>'Cause that's very helpful.

1611
02:55:32.597 --> 02:55:38.179
<v Eric Zimmerman>So let's say, You know, Zimmerman CDC built a building, right?

1612
02:55:38.403 --> 02:55:50.458
<v Eric Zimmerman>And 15 years ago, it was essentially, you know, it was affordable, it was restricted, but today I have a security concern, so I've got to have a staff on for that.

1613
02:55:50.586 --> 02:55:56.342
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have a behavioral health acute— acuity issue, so now I've— I'm bringing in maybe case managers or social workers.

1614
02:55:57.014 --> 02:56:08.415
<v Eric Zimmerman>And what you're saying is that because that need is there, that the housing The, the organization, the nonprofit, is actually buying that instead of Multnomah County placing that service in that building?

1615
02:56:08.575 --> 02:56:12.088
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that what is— when you say building expenses have gone up?

1616
02:56:12.489 --> 02:56:12.729
<v Michael Bonacore>Yes.

1617
02:56:13.210 --> 02:56:26.088
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, so our social services agency, Multnomah County, is not saying, oh, we have a concentration of an acuity at this building, we're going to place a behavioral health specialist in the building.

1618
02:56:26.886 --> 02:56:29.164
<v Eric Zimmerman>Now it's just on the backs of those CDCs.

1619
02:56:29.697 --> 02:56:30.811
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would be hiring my own.

1620
02:56:30.907 --> 02:56:33.379
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that kind of what we're talking about when we say that?

1621
02:56:35.364 --> 02:56:45.198
<v Michael Bonacore>There are definitely a lot of unfunded, unsupported supports and expenses that the providers are bearing themselves.

1622
02:56:46.906 --> 02:57:19.368
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I have heard from a number that they are, Forced may be as strong as a word we can go to, but they are having conversations about what type of client they can and cannot take on, and they are feeling like they've really got to lay that out now because they're not equipped— is the language that's been used with me— not equipped to take certain types of clients, and that, that has not bode well for them, I guess, in terms of how either the county or Home Forward Treats them, works with them, places them.

1623
02:57:24.118 --> 02:57:25.889
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, sorry I interrupted you.

1624
02:57:26.180 --> 02:57:26.277
<v Adrian Delgado>Yeah.

1625
02:57:26.372 --> 02:57:28.467
<v Michael Bonacore>No, no, I've heard that.

1626
02:57:28.595 --> 02:57:31.075
<v Michael Bonacore>I've heard providers express that as well.

1627
02:57:32.029 --> 02:57:52.525
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, so if we, if an affordable housing program A subsidized affordable building has vacancies and they can't get— they can't just lower— because I guess I'll put it this way, right?

1628
02:57:52.574 --> 02:57:55.798
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've got a mortgage due every, every month and it's, it's a certain number.

1629
02:57:55.861 --> 02:58:01.971
<v Eric Zimmerman>And a lot of people have been in this position, which is, yeah, most months I can make the whole mortgage.

1630
02:58:02.661 --> 02:58:04.970
<v Eric Zimmerman>On some months, maybe I'm only making a portion of it.

1631
02:58:05.885 --> 02:58:13.162
<v Eric Zimmerman>But the opposite— so maybe, you know, you come in at that Point, but to take no rent is what I think people are not understanding.

1632
02:58:13.209 --> 02:58:22.663
<v Eric Zimmerman>So why has the choice been not to take any rent on those vacancies instead of just taking less than you had hoped to take from a business decision-making?

1633
02:58:22.889 --> 02:58:26.018
<v Eric Zimmerman>What is that math that goes on at an affordable project?

1634
02:58:28.250 --> 02:58:32.242
<v Michael Bonacore>I'm conscious that the Director of Housing Oregon is in the audience listening to my answer.

1635
02:58:32.388 --> 02:58:32.828
<v Jamie Dunphy>Awesome.

1636
02:58:35.889 --> 02:58:43.735
<v Michael Bonacore>You know, I think there's that issue of, you know, structurally, how are you setting yourself up to pay your bills?

1637
02:58:44.006 --> 02:58:48.227
<v Michael Bonacore>And so I know that folks are considering, you know, things like rent reduction.

1638
02:58:49.156 --> 02:58:54.772
<v Michael Bonacore>I think what's often lost is that the literal vacancies are also paired with economic vacancies.

1639
02:58:54.835 --> 02:58:59.792
<v Michael Bonacore>So they have also a lot of apartments that are filled with folks who are not able to pay their rent.

1640
02:58:59.953 --> 02:59:10.867
<v Michael Bonacore>And so Just the combination of these expenses, uh, and, and lack of revenue stacking up against each other just creates a really bad circumstance.

1641
02:59:11.106 --> 02:59:12.612
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's a very helpful answer.

1642
02:59:13.350 --> 02:59:40.168
<v Eric Zimmerman>It makes me wonder why the CDCs don't fill the units and then come instead of saying we need help readjusting, why don't they come and say, hey, we're not going to make our note this month to Home Forward, to the city, to the County instead while those units remain filled, because I think it has been very difficult to be an advocate for helping a system who made choices to keep things vacant.

1643
02:59:40.570 --> 02:59:51.013
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if they said all of our units are filled but we're not going to make our note this year and that's going to cost a certain number, I think that seems like, okay, let's rally.

1644
02:59:52.336 --> 03:00:00.700
<v Eric Zimmerman>I almost feel like we're in an upside-down world In terms of the— I don't know if it's chicken and egg conversation, but that's concerning.

1645
03:00:01.218 --> 03:00:12.752
<v Eric Zimmerman>The vacancy has been the concerning umbrella since this money started getting discussed, but then you throw these HomeForward articles that have been coming out and they're very troubling.

1646
03:00:13.025 --> 03:00:19.346
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so to this question of helping them out, that's where I go, is, is this system to its core rotten?

1647
03:00:19.459 --> 03:00:30.560
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I I have said multiple times on the record that I am somewhat in favor of an asset approach to this, which is I know how much it costs to maintain a building from one year to the next.

1648
03:00:30.625 --> 03:00:33.754
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's a fairly common industry that exists.

1649
03:00:33.834 --> 03:00:38.554
<v Eric Zimmerman>We could just do that instead of this strange system.

1650
03:00:38.729 --> 03:00:47.897
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I'm having a tough time wanting to put more money at that system, and yet it's the system we have right now to develop So I'm struggling there a little bit.

1651
03:00:48.445 --> 03:00:52.699
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, thank you for helping put some light on some of those questions.

1652
03:00:52.747 --> 03:00:53.216
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate it.

1653
03:00:53.296 --> 03:00:53.618
<v Michael Bonacore>Anytime.

1654
03:00:55.626 --> 03:00:57.297
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1655
03:00:57.474 --> 03:01:05.350
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I will flag for the group that one, we are going to have a very robust discussion about this last topic in the Housing Committee soon.

1656
03:01:05.609 --> 03:01:10.528
<v Candace Avalos>Um, we just couldn't make it happen before the committees changed over, but that will be planned in April.

1657
03:01:11.076 --> 03:01:16.077
<v Candace Avalos>Um, timing-wise, I have been given the green light to extend us till 12:45.

1658
03:01:16.415 --> 03:01:19.400
<v Candace Avalos>There are a couple people here who have not spoken yet, so I'm going to get to them first.

1659
03:01:20.123 --> 03:01:21.778
<v Candace Avalos>Let's try to wrap it up by 12:45.

1660
03:01:21.986 --> 03:01:22.902
<v Candace Avalos>So, Councilor Ryan.

1661
03:01:23.271 --> 03:01:24.667
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1662
03:01:25.182 --> 03:01:38.878
<v Dan Ryan>Content setting real quick, just remember that local governments received boatloads of one-time money from both Trump 1 and Biden ARPA, and we continue to be kind of haunted by that, not just in the Housing Bureau but throughout the city.

1663
03:01:41.218 --> 03:01:43.125
<v Dan Ryan>There's project work that was done.

1664
03:01:43.718 --> 03:01:44.775
<v Dan Ryan>We knew there was a cliff.

1665
03:01:44.840 --> 03:01:49.309
<v Dan Ryan>Providers were aware that this would be a cliff, and we keep moving the ball down the field.

1666
03:01:49.647 --> 03:01:58.027
<v Dan Ryan>And so I'm in the camp of when are we going to say that we're not in the business of doing housing vouchers and rent vouchers?

1667
03:01:58.603 --> 03:01:59.822
<v Dan Ryan>And so I'll just end with that.

1668
03:01:59.997 --> 03:02:01.391
<v Dan Ryan>I'm trying to be brief because of time.

1669
03:02:02.530 --> 03:02:08.203
<v Dan Ryan>And you know, when we met as a Housing Committee, Chair Avalos, we had a presentation about the system from streets to stability.

1670
03:02:08.397 --> 03:02:09.712
<v Dan Ryan>We went all the way to homeownership.

1671
03:02:10.644 --> 03:02:14.110
<v Dan Ryan>And the tone of that meeting was that rent assistance was the county's rules, not ours.

1672
03:02:14.638 --> 03:02:17.753
<v Dan Ryan>Building infrastructure was more in our vein.

1673
03:02:18.265 --> 03:02:20.128
<v Dan Ryan>And so I'm in the camp of build, build, build.

1674
03:02:20.415 --> 03:02:23.947
<v Dan Ryan>North, northeast, yes, I said the Broadway corridor, et cetera.

1675
03:02:24.138 --> 03:02:27.413
<v Dan Ryan>So I appreciate my colleagues that have proposals like that.

1676
03:02:28.280 --> 03:02:33.558
<v Dan Ryan>I will say I think legal assistance is more bang for the buck at this moment to keeping people stabilized in their homes.

1677
03:02:34.056 --> 03:02:34.632
<v Dan Ryan>I like that.

1678
03:02:35.434 --> 03:02:44.299
<v Dan Ryan>I want to talk about a systemic solution to rental buydown, which has come up several times when I would speak with the legislative priorities of the city.

1679
03:02:44.957 --> 03:02:47.618
<v Dan Ryan>There's a big gap between 30% and 60% AMI.

1680
03:02:48.340 --> 03:02:55.618
<v Dan Ryan>We all know that 45% is more of a sweet spot for workforce housing, and I hope someday that that becomes a thing and that we can see that.

1681
03:02:55.713 --> 03:02:58.006
<v Dan Ryan>Until then, I could live with the rental buydown.

1682
03:02:58.423 --> 03:03:02.945
<v Dan Ryan>But if you look at the data, It's around 45% for workforce, and that's been needed.

1683
03:03:02.994 --> 03:03:03.924
<v Dan Ryan>It's been talked about.

1684
03:03:04.037 --> 03:03:07.854
<v Dan Ryan>For some reason, Salem and in Washington, we haven't moved the needle on that.

1685
03:03:09.186 --> 03:03:17.880
<v Dan Ryan>Mr. Mayor, shelter services are fine if the participants are seen, served, and assisted to permanent housing, prioritizing those seeking recovery and engaging with the workforce.

1686
03:03:18.635 --> 03:03:26.478
<v Dan Ryan>As such, supporting organizations like, say, Ground Score that connect the dots to the workforce and building their agency to thrive in the long term.

1687
03:03:27.713 --> 03:03:37.620
<v Dan Ryan>And I don't understand why Portland Street Response can't help transport participants from shelters in the overnight when they close too early, but they close, to day shelters.

1688
03:03:38.054 --> 03:03:38.807
<v Dan Ryan>I hope to see that.

1689
03:03:39.015 --> 03:03:45.236
<v Dan Ryan>It's really hard to read the stories about people suffering trying to get from the overnight shelter to the day shelters.

1690
03:03:46.630 --> 03:03:56.488
<v Dan Ryan>Finally, there's a growing concern that's come up that we can't ignore, and that is, as mentioned, but I'm just going to underscore it, the Vacancy rates due to slow turnaround, which we all agree is unacceptable.

1691
03:03:57.185 --> 03:03:59.164
<v Dan Ryan>The turnover time is very unacceptable.

1692
03:03:59.618 --> 03:04:00.477
<v Dan Ryan>And the other, safety.

1693
03:04:01.030 --> 03:04:08.388
<v Dan Ryan>The stories from elders on fixed income who don't feel safe in their own hallway has to be the responsibility of the city with the providers.

1694
03:04:10.048 --> 03:04:12.541
<v Dan Ryan>And I know I have been asking for this to be on the agenda.

1695
03:04:12.606 --> 03:04:14.210
<v Dan Ryan>We've had emails about this exchange.

1696
03:04:14.274 --> 03:04:17.272
<v Dan Ryan>I was disappointed that we haven't added on the agenda yet.

1697
03:04:17.661 --> 03:04:17.985
<v Jamie Dunphy>Chair Avalos.

1698
03:04:18.342 --> 03:04:23.183
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm happy to hear that you're going to get it on there, but I do believe we're denying that and we're delaying that too long.

1699
03:04:24.273 --> 03:04:31.968
<v Dan Ryan>Just last night, I had 2 people in the audience when we had our forum come up to me and mention that they don't feel safe in their affordable housing units.

1700
03:04:32.610 --> 03:04:34.742
<v Dan Ryan>It's hard to sleep at night when you keep hearing those stories.

1701
03:04:35.976 --> 03:04:36.938
<v Dan Ryan>So let's just be better.

1702
03:04:37.018 --> 03:04:43.318
<v Dan Ryan>Let's just do a better job taking care of the affordable housing that exists in our market as soon as possible, and we can get more units back to sell.

1703
03:04:43.382 --> 03:04:43.638
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1704
03:04:45.127 --> 03:04:48.810
<v Dan Ryan>So those are just some of my big picture ways of thinking as I make decisions.

1705
03:04:48.924 --> 03:04:50.806
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, colleagues, for the proposals you've put out there.

1706
03:04:51.481 --> 03:04:54.505
<v Dan Ryan>And I wanted to daylight where my thinking is at this time.

1707
03:04:56.520 --> 03:04:57.472
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1708
03:04:57.828 --> 03:05:01.564
<v Candace Avalos>And just to be clear, you sent me a request and I said that I was gonna put it in the agenda.

1709
03:05:01.806 --> 03:05:05.782
<v Candace Avalos>I can't make a request happen within a couple of weeks, especially when I have other people coming in.

1710
03:05:05.847 --> 03:05:07.125
<v Candace Avalos>So I was not ignoring your request.

1711
03:05:07.546 --> 03:05:08.290
<v Candace Avalos>We are working on it.

1712
03:05:08.338 --> 03:05:09.795
<v Candace Avalos>We just couldn't make it happen on the timeline you wanted.

1713
03:05:10.216 --> 03:05:11.659
<v Dan Ryan>I understand, but it was weeks ago.

1714
03:05:12.621 --> 03:05:12.766
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Right.

1715
03:05:13.263 --> 03:05:16.166
<v Candace Avalos>And I have my committee agendas planned out for several weeks.

1716
03:05:16.888 --> 03:05:21.043
<v Candace Avalos>So just like any other agenda, you can't just do it the next week just because you want to.

1717
03:05:21.363 --> 03:05:22.246
<v Dan Ryan>I understand.

1718
03:05:22.486 --> 03:05:23.802
<v Dan Ryan>I just think it's an urgent issue.

1719
03:05:24.268 --> 03:05:24.653
<v Candace Avalos>I agree.

1720
03:05:24.748 --> 03:05:28.870
<v Candace Avalos>I just would appreciate a little bit of grace of scheduling like we tend to give everybody else.

1721
03:05:29.175 --> 03:05:32.014
<v Candace Avalos>So please do not persecute me for not doing something that I'm clearly doing.

1722
03:05:32.673 --> 03:05:33.265
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Clark.

1723
03:05:34.757 --> 03:05:35.944
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1724
03:05:36.218 --> 03:05:39.636
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm really glad to hear that you This conversation will continue in your committee.

1725
03:05:40.132 --> 03:05:42.588
<v Olivia Clark>That was one of my questions, that you will continue the conversation.

1726
03:05:43.326 --> 03:05:43.439
<v Adrian Delgado>Yes.

1727
03:05:43.584 --> 03:05:50.452
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, I am not— I haven't firmly made up my mind about anything, but I can tell you what some of my priorities are.

1728
03:05:51.078 --> 03:06:01.542
<v Olivia Clark>I've been trying to balance the sort of clear and present danger or the immediate dangers that we confront with future investments and ongoing needs for affordable housing.

1729
03:06:02.072 --> 03:06:04.800
<v Olivia Clark>So under that clear and present danger, I would put the general fund.

1730
03:06:04.944 --> 03:06:06.453
<v Olivia Clark>I mean, that's a high priority for me.

1731
03:06:07.416 --> 03:06:15.733
<v Olivia Clark>I'm very, very concerned about what we're going to be dealing with in the next budget cycle.

1732
03:06:16.760 --> 03:06:19.762
<v Olivia Clark>Mr. Mayor, I may disagree with you on the no bad decisions.

1733
03:06:20.902 --> 03:06:26.568
<v Olivia Clark>I'm concerned about what you've heard some of my colleagues say about the vacancy rates, the bailouts.

1734
03:06:26.682 --> 03:06:29.395
<v Olivia Clark>I'm very concerned about where we invest dollars.

1735
03:06:30.293 --> 03:06:32.524
<v Olivia Clark>And I've also floated the idea of, do we have too many nonprofits in Portland?

1736
03:06:32.621 --> 03:06:34.018
<v Olivia Clark>I think we have too many nonprofits.

1737
03:06:33.986 --> 03:06:35.254
<v Olivia Clark>Do we have too many providers?

1738
03:06:35.672 --> 03:06:40.503
<v Olivia Clark>Should we be looking at consolidating, um, some of these CDCs or some of these organizations?

1739
03:06:40.566 --> 03:06:44.001
<v Olivia Clark>Because I think of all the admin costs that are— that they're incurring.

1740
03:06:44.739 --> 03:06:51.255
<v Olivia Clark>Um, but I am concerned that there, there might be some, might be some bad decisions and some other, uh, lenses that we should apply.

1741
03:06:52.042 --> 03:06:57.323
<v Olivia Clark>I am very interested in the Broadway corridor because I see it as a game changer for the downtown.

1742
03:06:58.076 --> 03:07:05.719
<v Olivia Clark>And I know I beat this drum a lot, But the downtown is our economic engine for the entire city, and it's going to link neighborhoods.

1743
03:07:05.768 --> 03:07:07.518
<v Olivia Clark>It's going to have different levels of housing.

1744
03:07:08.191 --> 03:07:09.252
<v Olivia Clark>It's a game changer.

1745
03:07:09.332 --> 03:07:16.831
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm definitely interested in investing in that project and some of the other development projects I'm interested in.

1746
03:07:17.569 --> 03:07:18.596
<v Olivia Clark>I don't have any questions.

1747
03:07:18.645 --> 03:07:23.204
<v Olivia Clark>I'll just leave it there and look forward to the outcome of your discussion in the Housing Committee.

1748
03:07:23.992 --> 03:07:24.328
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1749
03:07:24.489 --> 03:07:24.779
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1750
03:07:26.978 --> 03:07:35.567
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so now we're going to back to, uh, Councilor Kanal, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, and we're going to close it out with Councilor Green.

1751
03:07:36.129 --> 03:07:37.847
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1752
03:07:38.200 --> 03:07:43.066
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, quick round of what I've agreed with that I really wanted to bring up again.

1753
03:07:43.259 --> 03:07:46.951
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, agreeing with Councilor Koyama Lane on eviction representation being a core priority.

1754
03:07:47.031 --> 03:07:48.429
<v Sameer Kanal>I know Councilor Ryan mentioned that too.

1755
03:07:49.055 --> 03:07:51.157
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree completely with Councilor Dunphy on ownership Yes.

1756
03:07:51.543 --> 03:08:02.541
<v Sameer Kanal>You know, in the sports world, they do sell-ons in the contract, even just something at that later stage where you've— we've invested, and then if the property's transferred, we get a cut of the sale amount.

1757
03:08:03.103 --> 03:08:16.398
<v Sameer Kanal>But I'd also like to talk about conditions associated with these sorts of projects, including vacancy rates being below a certain amount after a certain length of time, 6 months, under 5%, something like that kind of framing, as well as unit types.

1758
03:08:16.896 --> 03:08:19.108
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, density and, and type variation.

1759
03:08:19.620 --> 03:08:28.257
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, we need to move away from studios and 1-bedrooms and start really forcing the conditions of our money being 2, 3, and 4-bedroom units.

1760
03:08:28.834 --> 03:08:34.186
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I agree with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney about not just rent buydowns but also the security upgrades as part of preservation.

1761
03:08:34.763 --> 03:08:36.911
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to shout out the mayor's comment on Williams and Russell.

1762
03:08:36.959 --> 03:08:40.725
<v Sameer Kanal>I forgot to do that the first time, but also, uh, Urban Plaza and SEI as well.

1763
03:08:40.789 --> 03:08:42.215
<v Sameer Kanal>I was really grateful to see those in here.

1764
03:08:42.856 --> 03:08:56.565
<v Sameer Kanal>And finally, the assessment of what Councilor Green was saying about shocks and emergent conditions changing our approach to some of our prior pencilings, I think is a really smart way of framing why some of these should change.

1765
03:08:57.864 --> 03:09:00.721
<v Sameer Kanal>2 Slightly less rapid-fire here.

1766
03:09:01.155 --> 03:09:07.351
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to start by saying I have a strong, strong disagreement about Portland Street Response being repurposed for something outside of its purpose.

1767
03:09:07.752 --> 03:09:09.950
<v Sameer Kanal>Portland Street Response is not a homelessness response program.

1768
03:09:10.014 --> 03:09:12.916
<v Sameer Kanal>It is a behavioral health Public safety, first responder.

1769
03:09:13.433 --> 03:09:31.049
<v Sameer Kanal>However, I agree with Councilor Ryan that we do need to solve the day-night time gap transport issue with siting, with lobbying TriMet on transit for places like St. Johns where there just isn't connectivity, and hours extensions so that there isn't a time gap in the first place with no service being offered.

1770
03:09:32.064 --> 03:09:39.395
<v Sameer Kanal>And then finally, I— and I'm building off of what Councilor Zimmerman said, and I agree with what he said— vacancies are a huge part of the problem.

1771
03:09:39.513 --> 03:09:40.329
<v Sameer Kanal>They are the enemy.

1772
03:09:40.449 --> 03:09:43.603
<v Sameer Kanal>They're They're much cheaper to fill a vacancy than it is to build a new place.

1773
03:09:44.314 --> 03:09:52.104
<v Sameer Kanal>We know that Oregon statewide has over 6 to 1 as its ratio of vacant properties, residential properties, to homeless people.

1774
03:09:52.861 --> 03:10:02.676
<v Sameer Kanal>That is from a couple years ago, the stat, but it's pretty well supported by data from around the country as well as earlier stats in Oregon.

1775
03:10:03.530 --> 03:10:06.640
<v Sameer Kanal>I think, you know, we put up a vacancy, a vacant property fee.

1776
03:10:06.691 --> 03:10:13.685
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope I hope that that is something we can do in time for it to be relevant to this year's budget conversation.

1777
03:10:13.734 --> 03:10:35.586
<v Sameer Kanal>But also the conversation around Home Forward and its vacancy, which relates to everything that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney said and all of that, I think has to be its own topic that we— it's adjacent to, it's related to this, but we're not going to be able to solve a lot of our other problems in this space if we have a 14% vacancy rate at Home Forward.

1778
03:10:35.635 --> 03:10:35.746
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1779
03:10:36.436 --> 03:10:37.960
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm not blaming them.

1780
03:10:38.058 --> 03:10:40.543
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not saying it's their fault and they need to do better necessarily.

1781
03:10:40.625 --> 03:10:42.469
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to understand the reasons for it.

1782
03:10:42.854 --> 03:10:51.870
<v Sameer Kanal>And if that requires— some of these interventions are pretty basic, like key fob entry swiping when you enter the building so that there's some level of access control.

1783
03:10:52.576 --> 03:10:57.085
<v Sameer Kanal>And we can solve that with this money because it's not actually that expensive and it is a one-time cost.

1784
03:10:57.454 --> 03:10:59.027
<v Sameer Kanal>So I do really want to look at that.

1785
03:10:59.299 --> 03:11:08.806
<v Sameer Kanal>And because if we are able to bring some of these buildings back to 100% filled, we are going to solve a lot of the, the other problems, or at least alleviate some of the symptoms of them.

1786
03:11:09.597 --> 03:11:12.766
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

1787
03:11:14.465 --> 03:11:15.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1788
03:11:15.337 --> 03:11:23.156
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to just flag a couple of things that haven't been a major part of the conversation and speak to money that we may not spend.

1789
03:11:23.495 --> 03:11:33.981
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is I've heard a couple of people refer to Councilor Smith's proposal, and for members of the public who are listening in, that's not on the grid before us.

1790
03:11:34.061 --> 03:11:38.126
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That grid just includes proposals that spent the original $20.7 million.

1791
03:11:38.478 --> 03:11:53.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is another proposal that has been floating out there that is posted to some past meetings, I believe, that, that wasn't posted for today, that spends into that additional $30.4 million bucket, though not all of it, and includes some additional projects.

1792
03:11:53.319 --> 03:11:54.394
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

1793
03:11:54.570 --> 03:12:00.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As it relates to the projects, I— there's some really important projects on there.

1794
03:12:00.555 --> 03:12:09.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The Urban Plaza funding will help us leverage a necessary conversation amongst the owner and tenant there.

1795
03:12:10.340 --> 03:12:16.820
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the Self Enhancement Inc. and Williams and Russell projects both include homeownership pieces.

1796
03:12:17.415 --> 03:12:20.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have not talked at all about homeownership today, but if Councilor Smith.

1797
03:12:20.318 --> 03:12:36.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we actually want to look at long-term guarantees that people will have more affordability, homeownership, a mortgage doesn't go up over time the way that rent does, and that has to be a part of our conversation if what we want to do is stabilize working families.

1798
03:12:36.912 --> 03:12:42.518
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And those 2 projects involve homeownership opportunities for low-income families.

1799
03:12:42.629 --> 03:12:56.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it is absolutely critical that if we decide Councilor Novick, I understand the confusion in what I said before.

1800
03:12:56.507 --> 03:13:11.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was agreeing with you that we should spend all money at the same time, but pointing out that we may not want to spend the whole $51.1 million, that there may be the $40 million proposal that Councilor Smith put forward that's a more appropriate level for us to spend.

1801
03:13:11.475 --> 03:13:11.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a good point.

1802
03:13:12.012 --> 03:13:12.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Us to spend at.

1803
03:13:13.761 --> 03:13:28.507
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And to that note, I just want to flag a couple of things because I suspect that as we move through this conversation, we will say to the Housing Bureau, there's some of this money that maybe we are not allocating specifically.

1804
03:13:29.165 --> 03:13:36.611
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if we do that, colleagues, I hope that we do that and say, but Housing Bureau, we want you to get that money out the door as quickly as possible.

1805
03:13:37.447 --> 03:13:44.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't want to leave dollars Going out in 2028 requests when we have a crisis right now.

1806
03:13:45.859 --> 03:13:50.644
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also hope that when we do that, we start to address who those dollars go to.

1807
03:13:51.077 --> 03:14:04.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I hope that at some point— it's not this conversation, but it is related to these dollars, so I'm going to say it now— we have a conversation about whether we should be giving money for new construction to nonprofits that have vacancy rates above Thank you.

1808
03:14:05.222 --> 03:14:15.141
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A certain percent, because the only way that we start to bring down those vacancy rates is if we have some incentives for doing so, and we have millions of dollars of incentives.

1809
03:14:16.120 --> 03:14:23.440
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, so I hope that as we transition from this conversation to what comes next, that that is something we are willing to talk about.

1810
03:14:23.938 --> 03:14:29.907
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's a lot of other things that were said that I agree with, but I wanted to just add those new things to the conversation while we had the opportunity.

1811
03:14:30.021 --> 03:14:30.986
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank Thank you, Councilor.

1812
03:14:32.329 --> 03:14:32.620
<v Candace Avalos>Great.

1813
03:14:33.006 --> 03:14:33.378
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Green.

1814
03:14:35.344 --> 03:14:37.167
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor Avalos, and thanks, colleagues.

1815
03:14:37.263 --> 03:14:41.038
<v Mitch Green>I've said a lot today, but I really appreciate this fluid discussion.

1816
03:14:41.626 --> 03:14:46.654
<v Mitch Green>Um, I got back in the queue because I, I wanted to respond to some of what Councilor Zimmerman was saying.

1817
03:14:46.702 --> 03:15:04.006
<v Mitch Green>I think it's important that when we agree on something, that we, we raise it up and highlight it, because it's, um, it's important to, uh, to recognize our points of agreement I agree 100% that mixed-income neighborhoods are the model.

1818
03:15:04.716 --> 03:15:06.004
<v Mitch Green>I think that is the future.

1819
03:15:06.149 --> 03:15:08.925
<v Mitch Green>That's what I like about the potential of this Broadway project.

1820
03:15:09.555 --> 03:15:11.459
<v Mitch Green>I just don't think AMIs are the way to do it.

1821
03:15:12.120 --> 03:15:14.427
<v Mitch Green>I think you do it through cost-based rent.

1822
03:15:14.638 --> 03:15:17.192
<v Mitch Green>I think you do it through things like limited equity co-ops.

1823
03:15:19.206 --> 03:15:21.702
<v Mitch Green>But I think on the merits of the outcome, I think it's a great idea.

1824
03:15:21.819 --> 03:15:22.085
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1825
03:15:22.545 --> 03:15:26.939
<v Mitch Green>Couldn't agree more on the mixed-income neighborhood concept.

1826
03:15:26.986 --> 03:15:28.280
<v Mitch Green>That's what we learned in Vienna, by the way.

1827
03:15:30.920 --> 03:15:41.637
<v Mitch Green>On homeownership, we have talked about that a couple times today, and I'll just say again, limited equity co-ops are a form of homeownership that provide the same sort of benefit mortgage does.

1828
03:15:42.756 --> 03:15:46.041
<v Mitch Green>My mortgage goes up though because my taxes go up, so we just need to be clear on that.

1829
03:15:47.061 --> 03:15:48.638
<v Mitch Green>And so if we think about I think that's a fair point.

1830
03:15:48.782 --> 03:16:04.084
<v Mitch Green>When you think about social housing broadly defined to include limited equity co-ops, that is in the same universe of that permanency, of that sort of cost stability that you get from the traditional fee simple model of single-family homeownership.

1831
03:16:04.709 --> 03:16:29.530
<v Mitch Green>And I just worry that if we focus on the old model in exclusion, I'm not suggesting anyone is, we're just not going to stretch our dollars as much because you can't provide that level of homeownership access to as many people if it's just $100,000 a shot or $200,000 a shot to a person versus underwriting their purchase of a building they already live in to now have equity in that.

1832
03:16:29.530 --> 03:16:31.620
<v Mitch Green>So I just, I wanted to float that there.

1833
03:16:32.469 --> 03:16:34.510
<v Mitch Green>That conversation should mature as we have these conversations.

1834
03:16:34.729 --> 03:16:42.110
<v Mitch Green>But I just, I wanted to close by saying that we've talked a lot about the Portland Housing Bureau today, but I just want to say directly, the Portland Housing Bureau, you do excellent work.

1835
03:16:42.110 --> 03:16:42.149
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you.

1836
03:16:42.406 --> 03:16:45.315
<v Mitch Green>And I thank you so much, Michael, to you and your staff.

1837
03:16:46.729 --> 03:16:54.538
<v Mitch Green>You know, it's got to— it has to have been difficult to think about what council has said over the last 6 months, what the public has said.

1838
03:16:55.492 --> 03:17:01.125
<v Mitch Green>But I know I've met many of the soldiers in the trenches there, and they're in this work because they're pouring their hearts into it.

1839
03:17:01.237 --> 03:17:02.181
<v Mitch Green>So just wanted to say that.

1840
03:17:05.448 --> 03:17:05.721
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1841
03:17:06.253 --> 03:17:22.772
<v Steve Novick>I was putting myself at the end, but I see that you're back in the queue, Novick, if you want to take a minute, and then I would like to end I just wanted to note for the record that Councilors Green and Murillo have promised me that they will produce an actual social housing banner, and I'm looking forward to seeing the size and the color scheme.

1842
03:17:23.558 --> 03:17:24.617
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, good to know.

1843
03:17:25.885 --> 03:17:27.457
<v Candace Avalos>Um, thank you, colleagues.

1844
03:17:27.505 --> 03:17:28.485
<v Candace Avalos>So we've got a couple minutes.

1845
03:17:28.532 --> 03:17:30.088
<v Candace Avalos>I'll just end with a couple of my thoughts.

1846
03:17:30.153 --> 03:17:34.148
<v Candace Avalos>First, I'll just say, um, I have been taking copious notes as well as my staff.

1847
03:17:34.228 --> 03:17:39.588
<v Candace Avalos>We're trying to just collaborate and see where are the alignment, what, um, what are new things that we heard.

1848
03:17:40.484 --> 03:17:43.061
<v Candace Avalos>So I'll make sure that we report back what we heard.

1849
03:17:43.610 --> 03:17:47.250
<v Candace Avalos>I agree with a lot of what has been said.

1850
03:17:47.770 --> 03:17:57.525
<v Candace Avalos>I just want to put a finer point on the conversation around eviction prevention and rental assistance.

1851
03:17:57.751 --> 03:18:05.225
<v Candace Avalos>I think— let me start by saying yes, millions of dollars have been spent, but those dollars have not been spent evenly over time.

1852
03:18:06.438 --> 03:18:16.573
<v Candace Avalos>Out of the 18,000-some evictions prevented with SHS funds across the region, 2/3 occurred between July of '21 and June of '23.

1853
03:18:17.423 --> 03:18:21.849
<v Candace Avalos>And since then, spending has slowed significantly, especially in this last year at the state level.

1854
03:18:22.635 --> 03:18:29.962
<v Candace Avalos>For example, in Multnomah County, only 167 evictions were prevented with SHS dollars between July and September of last year.

1855
03:18:30.108 --> 03:18:32.000
<v Candace Avalos>So that's 55 households Councilor Smith.

1856
03:18:32.000 --> 03:18:32.000
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mayor.

1857
03:18:32.000 --> 03:18:40.000
<v Candace Avalos>So the city has been able to house 1,000 households per month, and that is a fraction of the need considering the county averages roughly 1,000 eviction filings for nonpayment of rent every month.

1858
03:18:40.239 --> 03:18:47.790
<v Candace Avalos>So in other words, thousands of people each month are on the verge of falling into homelessness because they can't make rent, and that same trend is happening at the city level.

1859
03:18:49.180 --> 03:18:58.739
<v Candace Avalos>And I think ultimately, you know, what I heard from the mayor as well, I agree that it's one thing to have, you know, shelters or all of these other measures that we're doing to get people out Councilor Smith.

1860
03:18:58.805 --> 03:19:07.198
<v Candace Avalos>We can get people out of crisis from the street, but if we don't have a way for them to go, we don't have a house for them to go into or dollars to help them get into that house, then it's kind of futile.

1861
03:19:07.599 --> 03:19:16.056
<v Candace Avalos>So I think that it is critical in my view that, and it is our responsibility to help address that.

1862
03:19:16.183 --> 03:19:19.940
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that we can do that with the rental services dollars, which is what they are made for.

1863
03:19:21.063 --> 03:19:22.700
<v Candace Avalos>So that's the main thing.

1864
03:19:22.827 --> 03:19:28.121
<v Candace Avalos>I think ultimately I feel really good about I'm hearing, because I do hear a lot of alignment between us.

1865
03:19:28.459 --> 03:19:31.875
<v Candace Avalos>It sounds like people want a braided, blended approach to these dollars.

1866
03:19:32.003 --> 03:19:38.772
<v Candace Avalos>I'm also seeing that there's some discussion about how much of the dollars people feel is allocatable, if that's a word.

1867
03:19:39.765 --> 03:19:42.139
<v Candace Avalos>And so I think that's something we'll need to suss out.

1868
03:19:42.252 --> 03:19:49.356
<v Candace Avalos>But I'll just close by thanking our amazing staff who have brought great knowledge to us, thanking my councilors.

1869
03:19:49.853 --> 03:19:57.167
<v Candace Avalos>I think that we had a fruitful discussion, and I will be discussing with Council President How we take what we learned today and move forward.

1870
03:19:57.889 --> 03:19:59.525
<v Candace Avalos>And with that, we will end the work session.

1871
03:19:59.799 --> 03:20:00.023
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

