WEBVTT

1
00:00:25.185 --> 00:00:27.214
<v Keelan McClymont>Captions test, test, test.

2
00:07:32.596 --> 00:07:33.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

3
00:07:33.560 --> 00:07:40.504
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am calling to order the Wednesday, February 11th, AM council meeting— meeting of the Portland City Council.

4
00:07:42.800 --> 00:07:44.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call the roll?

5
00:07:44.702 --> 00:07:45.060
<v Keelan McClymont>Good morning.

6
00:07:45.353 --> 00:07:45.728
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

7
00:07:45.841 --> 00:07:46.103
<v Olivia Clark>Present.

8
00:07:50.543 --> 00:07:51.079
<v Loretta Smith>Smith.

9
00:07:51.971 --> 00:07:54.877
<v Keelan McClymont>I think Councilor Smith might be joining online.

10
00:07:54.958 --> 00:07:56.353
<v Keelan McClymont>Let me just check really quick.

11
00:07:58.853 --> 00:07:59.805
<v Sameer Kanal>Nope.

12
00:08:00.062 --> 00:08:00.660
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

13
00:08:01.660 --> 00:08:01.869
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

14
00:08:02.627 --> 00:08:02.755
<v Candace Avalos>Here.

15
00:08:03.449 --> 00:08:03.982
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

16
00:08:04.401 --> 00:08:04.529
<v Jonathan Ader>Here.

17
00:08:04.836 --> 00:08:05.190
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

18
00:08:05.529 --> 00:08:05.642
<v Claire Adamsick>Here.

19
00:08:06.240 --> 00:08:07.300
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Koyama Lane.

20
00:08:07.641 --> 00:08:08.718
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

21
00:08:08.800 --> 00:08:09.845
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo.

22
00:08:10.415 --> 00:08:10.692
<v Ashley Plauschay>Here.

23
00:08:14.713 --> 00:08:15.038
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

24
00:08:15.850 --> 00:08:16.028
<v Heidi Brown>Here.

25
00:08:17.295 --> 00:08:17.523
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

26
00:08:18.675 --> 00:08:18.790
<v Keelan McClymont>Here.

27
00:08:19.098 --> 00:08:19.619
<v Loretta Smith>Zimmerman.

28
00:08:20.300 --> 00:08:20.365
<v Jonathan Ader>Here.

29
00:08:20.610 --> 00:08:20.851
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

30
00:08:21.754 --> 00:08:22.045
<v Raymond C. Lee>Here.

31
00:08:23.853 --> 00:08:26.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>And, Lindley, can we please read the rules of decorum?

32
00:08:26.353 --> 00:08:27.353
<v Unidentified speaker>I am glad to, President.

33
00:08:27.418 --> 00:08:27.805
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

34
00:08:28.209 --> 00:08:29.531
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome to Portland City Council.

35
00:08:29.661 --> 00:08:35.158
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

36
00:08:38.631 --> 00:08:42.076
<v Unidentified speaker>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

37
00:08:42.621 --> 00:08:46.611
<v Unidentified speaker>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

38
00:08:47.187 --> 00:08:49.191
<v Unidentified speaker>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

39
00:08:49.591 --> 00:08:51.258
<v Unidentified speaker>The presiding officer preserves order.

40
00:08:51.595 --> 00:08:59.750
<v Unidentified speaker>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

41
00:09:00.104 --> 00:09:02.042
<v Unidentified speaker>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

42
00:09:02.490 --> 00:09:04.942
<v Unidentified speaker>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

43
00:09:04.990 --> 00:09:05.167
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

44
00:09:05.552 --> 00:09:08.727
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

45
00:09:09.160 --> 00:09:12.498
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

46
00:09:13.076 --> 00:09:15.225
<v Unidentified speaker>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

47
00:09:15.337 --> 00:09:17.711
<v Unidentified speaker>When testifying, state your name for the record.

48
00:09:17.888 --> 00:09:19.364
<v Unidentified speaker>Your address is not necessary.

49
00:09:19.909 --> 00:09:27.017
<v Unidentified speaker>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent, and virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

50
00:09:27.610 --> 00:09:27.899
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

51
00:09:28.653 --> 00:09:29.423
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

52
00:09:30.240 --> 00:09:33.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, item number 1 on our agenda is approval of the agenda.

53
00:09:33.769 --> 00:09:37.692
<v Jamie Dunphy>Have there been any, uh, requests to Reorder or remove anything from the agenda?

54
00:09:39.720 --> 00:09:40.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't see any.

55
00:09:40.707 --> 00:09:43.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, if they're— without objections, can we—.

56
00:09:43.625 --> 00:09:43.738
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're—.

57
00:09:43.738 --> 00:09:47.933
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to, uh— oh, it does require a motion?

58
00:09:48.176 --> 00:09:48.321
<v Priya Dhanapal>No.

59
00:09:48.659 --> 00:09:49.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>No, great.

60
00:09:49.532 --> 00:09:52.696
<v Jamie Dunphy>Without objections, I'd like unanimous consent to accept the agenda.

61
00:09:53.664 --> 00:09:54.488
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great, thank you.

62
00:09:55.538 --> 00:09:56.538
<v Jamie Dunphy>Agenda is approved.

63
00:09:59.225 --> 00:10:01.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please call public communications.

64
00:10:02.166 --> 00:10:03.807
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Deborah Hayman.

65
00:10:10.549 --> 00:10:11.897
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, councilors.

66
00:10:17.190 --> 00:10:18.153
<v Deborah Hayman>My name is Deborah Hayman.

67
00:10:18.282 --> 00:10:29.926
<v Deborah Hayman>I'm a resident of District 1, and I'm here again because this council has demonstrated a disturbing pattern of deflecting responsibility and delivering ineffective half measures, which has eroded public confidence in your ability to lead.

68
00:10:29.975 --> 00:10:39.455
<v Deborah Hayman>Just last week, the city government announced it Found tens of millions of dollars in urgently needed unspent housing funds.

69
00:10:39.952 --> 00:10:47.759
<v Deborah Hayman>That kind of breakdown in oversight and lack of clear responsibility for it raises serious questions about this body's credibility and competence.

70
00:10:48.482 --> 00:10:52.595
<v Deborah Hayman>We're seeing that same breakdown in oversight and transparency with the McAdam ICE facility.

71
00:10:53.221 --> 00:11:00.546
<v Deborah Hayman>Instead of exercising your authority to protect Portlanders, you have pushed responsibility onto unelected departments and avoided direct accountability.

72
00:11:00.595 --> 00:11:00.691
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

73
00:11:01.398 --> 00:11:05.797
<v Deborah Hayman>Federal agents at the McAdam ICE facility have caused well-documented harm in our community.

74
00:11:06.294 --> 00:11:12.317
<v Deborah Hayman>They have consistently used tear gas, pepper balls, and other weapons against people exercising their First Amendment rights.

75
00:11:13.038 --> 00:11:25.548
<v Deborah Hayman>That violence has spilled into the surrounding neighborhood, exposing residents at the Grays Landing affordable housing complex to chemical agents inside their own homes and forcing Cottonwood School to relocate due to safety risks.

76
00:11:26.206 --> 00:11:31.328
<v Deborah Hayman>Once again, this is a public safety and civil rights issue, not a private business matter.

77
00:11:31.393 --> 00:11:31.504
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

78
00:11:31.922 --> 00:11:35.129
<v Deborah Hayman>And yet this council has no clear plan to protect people.

79
00:11:35.448 --> 00:11:43.273
<v Deborah Hayman>Instead, you have chosen to prioritize the property rights of landlord Stuart Lindquist over the safety and civil rights of Portlanders as a whole.

80
00:11:43.785 --> 00:11:45.085
<v Deborah Hayman>The people deserve better.

81
00:11:46.030 --> 00:11:54.625
<v Deborah Hayman>No other landlord and tenant in Portland have been afforded the acquiescence and accommodations that this city government has extended to Mr. Lindquist and his tenants.

82
00:11:55.169 --> 00:12:00.780
<v Deborah Hayman>No other landlord would be allowed to continue to host tenants who cause this much documented harm.

83
00:12:01.503 --> 00:12:08.364
<v Deborah Hayman>In September 2025, you issued a land use violation, and it has stalled with no clear timeline or public accountability.

84
00:12:08.956 --> 00:12:14.182
<v Deborah Hayman>In December, you passed a detention facility impact fee ordinance, and that too remains unimposed.

85
00:12:14.711 --> 00:12:18.623
<v Deborah Hayman>Even if implemented, it won't deter an agency with a massive federal budget.

86
00:12:19.681 --> 00:12:25.274
<v Deborah Hayman>In October, you codified Portland's sanctuary city status, but sanctuary without protection is just a slogan.

87
00:12:25.788 --> 00:12:32.183
<v Deborah Hayman>How can Portland be a sanctuary city when we cannot protect our community from repeated assaults on both their bodies and their civil rights?

88
00:12:32.264 --> 00:12:32.729
<v Deborah Hayman>Councilmember Loretta Smith.

89
00:12:33.884 --> 00:12:38.125
<v Deborah Hayman>Your lack of effective action is causing real harm, and Portlanders are paying the price.

90
00:12:38.702 --> 00:12:41.561
<v Deborah Hayman>We're losing faith that you are willing or able to protect us.

91
00:12:42.075 --> 00:12:47.647
<v Deborah Hayman>That loss of confidence is growing with every delay, every deflection, and every breakdown of oversight.

92
00:12:48.240 --> 00:12:48.336
<v Angelita Morillo>Order.

93
00:12:48.432 --> 00:12:52.143
<v Deborah Hayman>If you need additional expertise or capacity, bring it in.

94
00:12:53.090 --> 00:12:56.815
<v Deborah Hayman>If existing structures and strategies are failing, change them.

95
00:12:57.570 --> 00:13:03.495
<v Deborah Hayman>You have the power, obligation, and resources to do so, and our safety and civil rights depend on it.

96
00:13:04.970 --> 00:13:05.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

97
00:13:07.587 --> 00:13:11.014
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Addie Smith.

98
00:13:13.960 --> 00:13:14.926
<v Addie Smith>Good morning.

99
00:13:15.102 --> 00:13:22.043
<v Addie Smith>I am probably going to go over just by a few seconds, so I, uh, just by a few seconds, so I please, uh, appreciate if you bear with me.

100
00:13:22.671 --> 00:13:24.426
<v Addie Smith>Hello, my name is Addie Smith.

101
00:13:24.538 --> 00:13:27.341
<v Addie Smith>Today is Wednesday, February 11th, 2026.

102
00:13:27.501 --> 00:13:29.821
<v Addie Smith>I am speaking before the Portland City Council.

103
00:13:30.400 --> 00:13:41.883
<v Addie Smith>I've asked the City Council before to allow public commenters to As it stands, if a public commenter provides comment today, they aren't allowed to speak again until next month.

104
00:13:42.349 --> 00:13:43.104
<v Addie Smith>This is ridiculous.

105
00:13:43.168 --> 00:13:48.033
<v Addie Smith>This must change either with this group of city council members or newly elected city council members.

106
00:13:48.548 --> 00:13:49.961
<v Addie Smith>This change must be a priority.

107
00:13:50.379 --> 00:13:54.571
<v Addie Smith>If we want to speak at each city council meeting, there shouldn't be a rule stopping it.

108
00:13:54.971 --> 00:14:02.649
<v Addie Smith>Next, this newfound funding needs to go towards rental assistance to organizations like Self Enhancement and Oregon Eviction Prevention Rapid Response.

109
00:14:02.697 --> 00:14:03.307
<v Addie Smith>Councilmember response.

110
00:14:03.644 --> 00:14:08.953
<v Addie Smith>Do not provide funding to the United Way of Oregon as they do not disburse assistance to African Americans.

111
00:14:09.643 --> 00:14:13.638
<v Addie Smith>Oregon's Black unemployment is 7.7% and rising.

112
00:14:14.150 --> 00:14:16.269
<v Addie Smith>Oregon is the 2nd most racist state in the nation.

113
00:14:16.701 --> 00:14:23.775
<v Addie Smith>Employers in the state had no problem following the Trump administration's DEI requirements because they weren't using it anyway.

114
00:14:24.498 --> 00:14:29.486
<v Addie Smith>There are few positions, let alone corporate executive positions, with Black people in them in this state.

115
00:14:30.192 --> 00:14:41.186
<v Addie Smith>Rental assistance for Black and immigrant households must be a priority every month as long as unemployment in the Black community remains high, or as long as the Trump administration's racist DEI requirements are in place.

116
00:14:41.827 --> 00:14:47.572
<v Addie Smith>Next, Appeals Court Chief Judge Aaron Loggason and Appeal Commissioner Theresa Kidd are violating the law with impunity.

117
00:14:47.990 --> 00:14:48.969
<v Addie Smith>There's no oversight.

118
00:14:49.048 --> 00:14:49.706
<v Addie Smith>They're biased.

119
00:14:49.770 --> 00:14:56.654
<v Addie Smith>They lack discernment, professionalism, clarity, thought, truthfulness, and honesty, and literally look at the law and decide to do the opposite.

120
00:14:56.912 --> 00:15:00.813
<v Addie Smith>Black people aren't safe in Oregon, and we aren't leaving.

121
00:15:01.312 --> 00:15:05.774
<v Addie Smith>Oregon's Democrat governors are appointing racist, discriminatory judges to the bench.

122
00:15:05.967 --> 00:15:18.732
<v Addie Smith>Judges like Multnomah County Circuit Court Judges Monica Harrance, Michael Riedel, Mark Peterson, Washington County Judges Kathleen Proctor, Ricardo Menchaca, Brandon Thompson, Charles Bailey, Andrew Irwin, Eric Boucher.

123
00:15:19.471 --> 00:15:36.890
<v Addie Smith>Since the Epstein files are the largest child sex trafficking ring that includes Donald Trump is on everyone's mind, let me I would remind everyone that in Oregon, when judges and attorneys are arrested, charged, and convicted of CSAM, child porn, raping girls, and the like, the Oregon State Bar doesn't immediately terminate their license to practice law.

124
00:15:37.437 --> 00:15:40.615
<v Addie Smith>Attorneys are allowed to resign at their leisure or not at all.

125
00:15:41.065 --> 00:15:41.835
<v Addie Smith>Why is that?

126
00:15:42.590 --> 00:15:44.918
<v Addie Smith>I want to remind people that Democrats built ICE.

127
00:15:45.318 --> 00:15:48.240
<v Addie Smith>Everyone talks about ICE as if it's a Trump or Republican invention.

128
00:15:48.610 --> 00:15:57.682
<v Addie Smith>Trump weaponizes its novel cruelty, but Democrats built Trump gives ICE spectacle and impunity, but Democrats give it infrastructure.

129
00:15:58.003 --> 00:16:02.144
<v Addie Smith>Trump can only wield ICE because Democrats had already erected its machinery.

130
00:16:02.481 --> 00:16:10.317
<v Addie Smith>In 1996, under Bill Clinton, Democrats passed AEDPA and IIIRIRA, building the legal cage ICE would later inherit.

131
00:16:10.750 --> 00:16:15.873
<v Addie Smith>Clinton also implemented prevention through deterrence, pushing crossings into remote desert terrain.

132
00:16:16.386 --> 00:16:20.177
<v Addie Smith>Border deaths at this time rose from dozens per year to hundreds.

133
00:16:20.225 --> 00:16:20.514
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

134
00:16:20.706 --> 00:16:24.994
<v Addie Smith>More than 10,000 migrants are estimated to have died in the years following his legislation.

135
00:16:25.090 --> 00:16:27.691
<v Addie Smith>George Bush established ICE in 2003.

136
00:16:27.770 --> 00:16:28.398
<v Addie Smith>I'm almost done.

137
00:16:28.815 --> 00:16:32.942
<v Addie Smith>Under President Barack Obama, ICE was expanded, professionalized, and normalized.

138
00:16:33.149 --> 00:16:34.851
<v Addie Smith>ICE must be abolished.

139
00:16:35.238 --> 00:16:38.432
<v Addie Smith>I am also not voting for anyone who supports Israel.

140
00:16:38.769 --> 00:16:39.684
<v Addie Smith>Thank you for your time.

141
00:16:40.633 --> 00:16:41.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for being here today.

142
00:16:43.024 --> 00:16:44.663
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have James Lee.

143
00:16:57.514 --> 00:16:57.870
<v Bob Weinstein>Morning.

144
00:16:57.982 --> 00:16:59.192
<v James Bernard Lee>I am James Bernard Lee.

145
00:16:59.289 --> 00:17:03.259
<v James Bernard Lee>I reside in Southeast Portland and speak only for myself.

146
00:17:03.630 --> 00:17:04.953
<v James Bernard Lee>Thank you for hearing me today.

147
00:17:06.637 --> 00:17:08.512
<v James Bernard Lee>Do you know the word ergodic?

148
00:17:08.838 --> 00:17:23.202
<v James Bernard Lee>It is a concept of mathematical physics meaning What can be averaged over time can be averaged over space, like air molecules in this room, their average speed determining temperature, pressure, and density everywhere.

149
00:17:24.086 --> 00:17:30.237
<v James Bernard Lee>About 1900, a gentleman of Harvard opined sound in concert hall could be treated likewise.

150
00:17:30.991 --> 00:17:34.846
<v James Bernard Lee>In the 1970s, I and 2 others proved that erroneous.

151
00:17:35.634 --> 00:17:38.476
<v James Bernard Lee>Average sound made by orchestras could not be music.

152
00:17:38.540 --> 00:17:38.684
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

153
00:17:39.423 --> 00:17:44.130
<v James Bernard Lee>The last good concert hall, Boston Symphony Hall, opened in 1900.

154
00:17:44.964 --> 00:17:51.339
<v James Bernard Lee>For 56 years, I have urged architects to return to this paradigm of Boston, to no avail.

155
00:17:52.111 --> 00:17:57.700
<v James Bernard Lee>Lincoln Center in New York tried 4 times in 60 years to build an acceptable hall.

156
00:17:58.776 --> 00:18:07.769
<v James Bernard Lee>Lastly, in 2022, for $500 million, doing the same thing, expecting a different result at maximal expense.

157
00:18:07.882 --> 00:18:08.186
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

158
00:18:08.990 --> 00:18:14.750
<v James Bernard Lee>Our mayor has not got the memo, nor have the 15 ex officio worthies sitting at his table.

159
00:18:16.034 --> 00:18:19.564
<v James Bernard Lee>He owes me for disrupting the menace of Holly Brown's bullhorn.

160
00:18:20.383 --> 00:18:27.861
<v James Bernard Lee>In return, I asked him to hire me with modest retainer to assure Harvard's grievous sin would not be repeated here.

161
00:18:28.775 --> 00:18:30.958
<v James Bernard Lee>He remains ungrateful and ignorant.

162
00:18:32.065 --> 00:18:39.578
<v James Bernard Lee>26 Cooks unaware of the egoic fallacy Now simmer the ancient backward broth of Harvard here.

163
00:18:40.575 --> 00:18:46.134
<v James Bernard Lee>The accurate physics of concert halls I devised in 1970 will never change.

164
00:18:46.519 --> 00:18:47.708
<v James Bernard Lee>Pay attention, please.

165
00:18:48.703 --> 00:18:58.471
<v James Bernard Lee>In the 1960s, when I did rocket science at China Lake, projects like Sidewinder were thought too subtle and vital to be left to a large bureaucracy.

166
00:18:59.290 --> 00:19:07.398
<v James Bernard Lee>Bill McLean often gave a few competent and ingenious folk Modest funding and free range to do what they would.

167
00:19:08.309 --> 00:19:16.459
<v James Bernard Lee>I kept a disassembled 1A Sidewinder seeker head on my desk to remind myself of what exceptional people can do.

168
00:19:17.076 --> 00:19:17.515
<v James Bernard Lee>Thank you.

169
00:19:19.611 --> 00:19:20.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for being here.

170
00:19:22.992 --> 00:19:32.519
<v Keelan McClymont>The next 2 public communications canceled— Lacey Sutton and Jason Wilder— but we have Jonathan Ader, our alternate online.

171
00:19:33.605 --> 00:19:34.805
<v Keelan McClymont>Jonathan, go ahead and unmute.

172
00:19:38.296 --> 00:19:39.678
<v Jonathan Ader>Hi, my name is Jonathan Ader.

173
00:19:40.464 --> 00:19:44.577
<v Jonathan Ader>I am a Multnomah County Precinct Committee person living in Southwest Portland.

174
00:19:44.657 --> 00:19:46.810
<v Jamie Dunphy>Jonathan, I'm sorry, we're having a bit of a hard time hearing you.

175
00:19:47.228 --> 00:19:49.480
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are you able to get closer to the microphone or turn it up a little?

176
00:19:54.603 --> 00:19:55.619
<v Jonathan Ader>Can you hear me any better now?

177
00:19:57.383 --> 00:19:58.125
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

178
00:19:58.740 --> 00:19:58.919
<v Jonathan Ader>Okay.

179
00:19:59.000 --> 00:20:00.098
<v Jonathan Ader>My name is Jonathan Eater.

180
00:20:00.277 --> 00:20:18.915
<v Jonathan Ader>I'm a Multnomah County Precinct Committee person, and this is regarding ORS 153.058, which is a statute for a citizen to initiate a violation by a private person.

181
00:20:19.580 --> 00:20:21.236
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, Jonathan, we're still struggling to hear you.

182
00:20:22.333 --> 00:20:23.182
<v Jonathan Ader>I'm sorry.

183
00:20:23.248 --> 00:20:24.680
<v Jonathan Ader>Let me see if I can fix it.

184
00:20:26.769 --> 00:20:31.738
<v Jonathan Ader>I'll look in my settings and see if I can fix that.

185
00:20:32.288 --> 00:20:32.951
<v Jonathan Ader>Oh, let's see.

186
00:20:36.911 --> 00:20:38.369
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Keelan, for pausing his clock.

187
00:20:44.549 --> 00:20:45.153
<v Jonathan Ader>Is that any better?

188
00:20:46.067 --> 00:20:46.622
<v Jonathan Ader>Is that better now?

189
00:20:46.949 --> 00:20:47.617
<v Jamie Dunphy>That does seem better.

190
00:20:47.666 --> 00:20:48.416
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, sir.

191
00:20:49.288 --> 00:20:49.871
<v Jonathan Ader>Okay, great.

192
00:20:50.743 --> 00:20:52.586
<v Jonathan Ader>Okay, my name is Jonathan Eder.

193
00:20:52.846 --> 00:21:06.869
<v Jonathan Ader>I'm a Multnomah County Precinct Committee person living in Southwest Portland, and I'd like to talk about ORS 153.058.

194
00:21:07.825 --> 00:21:11.481
<v Jonathan Ader>That statute is initiation of a violation proceeding by private party.

195
00:21:12.699 --> 00:21:23.738
<v Jonathan Ader>And on Last November, pursuant to ORS 153.058, I filed a citizen complaint with the traffic department of the Multnomah County Circuit Court.

196
00:21:25.842 --> 00:21:41.705
<v Jonathan Ader>It was State v. Brian McMahon, and it stated that a person— it states that a person other than an enforcement officer may commence a violation proceeding by filing a complaint with a court that has jurisdiction over the alleged violation.

197
00:21:41.818 --> 00:21:41.900
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

198
00:21:43.680 --> 00:21:51.865
<v Jonathan Ader>However, ORS 153.058 only allows the city attorney or the district attorney to appear and present evidence at trial.

199
00:21:52.138 --> 00:21:56.471
<v Jonathan Ader>Consequently, I contacted the Multnomah County District Attorney to seek their cooperation.

200
00:21:56.923 --> 00:22:20.708
<v Jonathan Ader>I emailed the office several times with no response, called multiple times, left a message, subsequently visited and spoke with 2 investigators who informed me that the DA's office would not get involved in a The DA's refusal to participate in any traffic case effectively renders ORS 153.058 moot, and the state's case in this instance will be ultimately dismissed by the court.

201
00:22:20.756 --> 00:22:24.669
<v Jonathan Ader>And as such, the DA's office is thwarting the will of the legislature.

202
00:22:26.251 --> 00:22:32.755
<v Jonathan Ader>And this involves a former Lake Oswego police officer.

203
00:22:33.445 --> 00:22:38.834
<v Jonathan Ader>Uh, and it is not appropriate for the Portland Independent Police Review Board.

204
00:22:39.859 --> 00:22:50.907
<v Jonathan Ader>But, uh, I was concerned because this person, in my estimation, was threatening the safety of my community, and particularly in Hillsdale, particularly people who are elderly and disabled.

205
00:22:52.366 --> 00:22:55.878
<v Jonathan Ader>And, uh, the DA has resources.

206
00:22:56.070 --> 00:23:00.560
<v Jonathan Ader>There are 14,000 misdemeanor cases issued each year.

207
00:23:00.769 --> 00:23:07.176
<v Jonathan Ader>That involved the misdemeanor trial unit in Multnomah County, which deals with those issues.

208
00:23:08.185 --> 00:23:22.806
<v Jonathan Ader>And I would point out that our DA, Nathan Vasquez, actually criticized a Multnomah County Circuit Court judge for her refusal to hold a dangerous driver fully accountable, deeming her decision bewildering.

209
00:23:22.854 --> 00:23:28.132
<v Jonathan Ader>Well, I am bewildered, as this case would require— I'm sorry, I'll be done in a second.

210
00:23:28.181 --> 00:23:29.952
<v Jamie Dunphy>Minimal time 30 more seconds.

211
00:23:30.417 --> 00:23:31.090
<v Loretta Smith>You're fine.

212
00:23:31.380 --> 00:23:36.492
<v Jonathan Ader>And, um, uh, the, the, the, the trial's online.

213
00:23:37.150 --> 00:23:44.186
<v Jonathan Ader>Um, I have evidence, but as an elected official, I urgently request that the DA's office reconsider its position.

214
00:23:44.700 --> 00:23:48.898
<v Jonathan Ader>I urge the counsel, uh, assist, uh, in the state's case.

215
00:23:49.251 --> 00:23:59.039
<v Jonathan Ader>Otherwise, this statute will remain meaningless and offer no recourse for citizens to independently file a complaint seeking accountability Thank you very much.

216
00:23:59.704 --> 00:24:00.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for being here this morning.

217
00:24:01.423 --> 00:24:02.769
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes communications.

218
00:24:03.287 --> 00:24:04.017
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

219
00:24:05.246 --> 00:24:07.351
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, our next item is the committee referral report.

220
00:24:08.234 --> 00:24:13.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>For my colleagues and for folks watching at home, my office has referred several items to committee last week, some of which have already been heard.

221
00:24:14.789 --> 00:24:18.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>Those items are listed in the committee referral report, which is available online at portland.gov/auditor/council-clerk/committee-referral.

222
00:24:28.260 --> 00:24:33.607
<v Jamie Dunphy>Next item, before we get to the city administrator's report, we have a time-certain land use item.

223
00:24:34.890 --> 00:24:36.645
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please read item number 4?

224
00:24:37.662 --> 00:24:44.416
<v Keelan McClymont>Adopt the Affordable Housing Opportunities Project amendments to the comprehensive plan map and official zoning map.

225
00:24:46.230 --> 00:24:49.175
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the first reading of an ordinance.

226
00:24:49.273 --> 00:24:52.874
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have Claire Adamsick with Council Ops to give us a presentation.

227
00:24:52.922 --> 00:24:54.768
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please, Claire, take it away.

228
00:24:55.569 --> 00:24:57.352
<v Claire Adamsick>Good morning, Council President and councilors.

229
00:24:57.415 --> 00:25:01.798
<v Claire Adamsick>For the record, Claire Adamsick, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Homelessness and Housing Committee.

230
00:25:02.553 --> 00:25:12.248
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance before you, document number 2026-037, was heard in the Homelessness and Housing Committee on January 27th, where it was referred to full council with a recommendation to pass.

231
00:25:13.067 --> 00:25:24.144
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance amends the Portland Comprehensive Plan map and zoning map as specified in the Affordable Housing Opportunities Project recommended draft report, which is Exhibit B of the ordinance.

232
00:25:25.010 --> 00:25:32.540
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance also directs adoption of the findings of fact report and commentary, which are found in Exhibits A and B, as legislative intent and further findings.

233
00:25:33.375 --> 00:25:45.563
<v Claire Adamsick>The mapping amendments change zoning for 19 properties across the city that are owned by nonprofit and public affordable housing providers to allow development of additional affordable housing units or the preservation of existing units on those sites.

234
00:25:46.462 --> 00:25:55.952
<v Claire Adamsick>The full impact statement on this item includes information on financial and budgetary impacts and analysis, economic and real estate development impacts, and community impacts and community involvement.

235
00:25:57.157 --> 00:26:00.594
<v Claire Adamsick>7 People testified during the committee meeting on January 27th.

236
00:26:01.237 --> 00:26:04.030
<v Claire Adamsick>Written testimony is submitted via the MAP app.

237
00:26:04.271 --> 00:26:08.479
<v Claire Adamsick>There's a link to that in the committee staff summary, and that should be available elsewhere.

238
00:26:08.865 --> 00:26:15.994
<v Claire Adamsick>The general themes of the testimony the committee heard included reducing zoning barriers and adjusting other standards to facilitate affordable housing development.

239
00:26:16.042 --> 00:26:16.138
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

240
00:26:16.940 --> 00:26:38.334
<v Claire Adamsick>Concerns regarding fire and emergency response access for specific affordable properties, and a request to include the Tabor Heights United Methodist Church in the project with a zoning change that would allow— excuse me, having a technical issue— with a zoning change that would allow the development of affordable housing on that site.

241
00:26:38.848 --> 00:26:40.183
<v Claire Adamsick>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

242
00:26:40.280 --> 00:26:40.603
<v Claire Adamsick>Thank you.

243
00:26:42.146 --> 00:26:42.823
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Claire.

244
00:26:45.333 --> 00:26:49.652
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, are there any technical or clarifying questions to this before we move to public testimony?

245
00:26:49.748 --> 00:26:51.722
<v Candace Avalos>Council President, do I get to give my report?

246
00:26:52.478 --> 00:26:53.875
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh yeah, that comes from you.

247
00:26:54.002 --> 00:26:54.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, thanks.

248
00:26:54.967 --> 00:26:56.075
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please, Councilor Avalos.

249
00:26:57.134 --> 00:26:58.932
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, um, so yes, thank you.

250
00:26:58.997 --> 00:27:03.381
<v Candace Avalos>This ordinance comes to council from the Housing and Homelessness Committee where it was heard and passed unanimously.

251
00:27:04.038 --> 00:27:07.233
<v Candace Avalos>The proposal was also reviewed and recommended by the Planning Commission.

252
00:27:07.909 --> 00:27:11.441
<v Candace Avalos>The Affordable Housing Opportunities Project addresses a clear problem.

253
00:27:11.698 --> 00:27:19.183
<v Candace Avalos>Nonprofit and public housing providers already own land intended for affordable housing, but existing zoning creates unnecessary barriers and delays.

254
00:27:19.633 --> 00:27:25.788
<v Candace Avalos>So this ordinance removes those barriers by aligning zoning and comprehensive plan designations with the intended use of the sites.

255
00:27:26.493 --> 00:27:33.131
<v Candace Avalos>It allows affordable housing development and preservation to move with— move forward without requiring separate site-by-site zone changes.

256
00:27:33.788 --> 00:27:45.781
<v Candace Avalos>This ordinance is one tool in a broader housing strategy, so it does not on its own address the full spectrum of needs from shelter and temporary housing to long-term affordable housing, but It removes a key barrier where permanent housing is the goal.

257
00:27:46.375 --> 00:27:52.618
<v Candace Avalos>And this is a targeted map-only amendment, so it does not change zoning code standards and it does not add new funding.

258
00:27:53.373 --> 00:28:01.365
<v Candace Avalos>But this was approved with unanimous support from the committee and from the Planning Commission recommendation and is now before you for consideration.

259
00:28:01.864 --> 00:28:02.376
<v Candace Avalos>That's my report.

260
00:28:02.521 --> 00:28:02.778
<v Heidi Brown>Thanks.

261
00:28:02.843 --> 00:28:04.013
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

262
00:28:05.009 --> 00:28:08.845
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now, colleagues, anybody have any questions, technical or clarifying questions at this time?

263
00:28:10.048 --> 00:28:10.691
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark.

264
00:28:11.911 --> 00:28:12.231
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

265
00:28:12.392 --> 00:28:13.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

266
00:28:13.675 --> 00:28:15.087
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, President Dunphy.

267
00:28:15.746 --> 00:28:27.686
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I'm, uh, I think this is great that we've, um, we're updating things, updating our zoning code, um, outlining things, um, in the interest of building more affordable housing.

268
00:28:28.121 --> 00:28:34.749
<v Olivia Clark>But I have a concern that I just wanted to raise on, uh, number 10, the Sears Armory site.

269
00:28:36.578 --> 00:28:57.086
<v Olivia Clark>This is where the Multnomah Safe Rest Village resides, and I know quite a few neighbors came out and spoke against this change, and they're very concerned that this change in the zoning makes it a lot easier for the Safe Rest Village to remain there, and there's a lot of concern about that.

270
00:28:57.455 --> 00:29:00.605
<v Olivia Clark>I know the mayor and some of us are touring it tonight.

271
00:29:00.653 --> 00:29:03.989
<v Olivia Clark>I've toured it before, so I just want to get some clarification.

272
00:29:04.143 --> 00:29:04.314
<v Lee Armstrong>Yes.

273
00:29:05.575 --> 00:29:07.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>About what this really does.

274
00:29:07.661 --> 00:29:11.064
<v Olivia Clark>Does it really make it easier for the Safe Rest Village to remain?

275
00:29:11.192 --> 00:29:17.981
<v Olivia Clark>Because I think it's there under an emergency declaration, the housing emergency declaration.

276
00:29:19.137 --> 00:29:22.042
<v Olivia Clark>So maybe if somebody could clarify that for me, I'm concerned.

277
00:29:22.106 --> 00:29:26.761
<v Olivia Clark>Otherwise, I think I may be voting against this, even though I totally support the whole idea of this.

278
00:29:26.842 --> 00:29:30.308
<v Olivia Clark>I'm just concerned about the neighbors and the Safe Rest Village.

279
00:29:30.614 --> 00:29:32.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do we have staff from Planning and Sustainability who are able to speak to that?

280
00:29:42.278 --> 00:29:42.666
<v Olivia Clark>Welcome.

281
00:29:42.845 --> 00:29:43.638
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Thank you so much.

282
00:29:43.897 --> 00:29:47.851
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Um, good morning, Council President, Vice President, councilors.

283
00:29:48.515 --> 00:29:52.184
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Uh, Patricia Dieffendorfer, Chief Planner, Bureau of Planning and Sustainability, for the record.

284
00:29:52.958 --> 00:30:00.588
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Um, the— I, I'll let Bill speak to this, but I do believe that the EG-1 zone currently does not allow residential uses.

285
00:30:01.234 --> 00:30:05.159
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And that the Safe Rest Village is there due to the housing emergency.

286
00:30:06.720 --> 00:30:16.963
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>The CM-2 zone would allow for the Safe Rest Village to remain without the housing emergency, but would also allow other future uses.

287
00:30:17.719 --> 00:30:27.767
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>So the rationale behind this particular— the zone change for this particular property is to allow the Safe Rest Village in the near term, to allow the potential for—.

288
00:30:27.767 --> 00:30:28.048
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

289
00:30:28.432 --> 00:30:33.611
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Permanent affordable housing in the future because the current EG-2 zone does not allow housing.

290
00:30:34.910 --> 00:30:44.757
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And the CM-2 zone, which is the proposed zone, allows a wide variety of uses, both commercial, residential, and other kinds of uses.

291
00:30:45.012 --> 00:30:46.922
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And Bill, I don't know if you want to add anything.

292
00:30:47.434 --> 00:31:00.230
<v Bill Cunningham>I'll just add that, just to clarify, a safe rest village is a kind of shelter, and that is in a Particular category, which in the current EG-2 zone— I'm sorry, I should identify myself.

293
00:31:00.358 --> 00:31:03.338
<v Bill Cunningham>Bill Cunningham, Senior Planner with Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

294
00:31:03.759 --> 00:31:03.986
<v Jonathan Ader>Good morning.

295
00:31:04.663 --> 00:31:19.429
<v Bill Cunningham>I just wanted to clarify the point about the Safe Rest Village, and it is classified as a shelter, which is always a conditional use, which requires a land use review and a fair amount of process to move forward.

296
00:31:19.493 --> 00:31:33.432
<v Bill Cunningham>And it is true that that Safe Rest Village came in As part of the housing emergency ordinance, and changing the zoning to CM-2 would facilitate the ability to continue the Safe Rest Village without a land use review.

297
00:31:33.865 --> 00:31:34.909
<v Bill Cunningham>So that's certainly true.

298
00:31:36.241 --> 00:31:48.267
<v Bill Cunningham>And a key reason too for the zone change is to open up the possibility for more permanent affordable housing into the future, which currently is prohibited in the current EG-2 zone.

299
00:31:49.005 --> 00:31:51.574
<v Bill Cunningham>And something brought up by neighbors as well is a concern about—.

300
00:31:51.574 --> 00:31:51.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Herbold.

301
00:31:52.315 --> 00:31:56.605
<v Bill Cunningham>The possibility of having an emergency operations center on that site.

302
00:31:56.992 --> 00:32:05.359
<v Bill Cunningham>And I just wanted to clarify that the proposed CM-2 zone does allow public safety uses and emergency management uses.

303
00:32:05.857 --> 00:32:16.617
<v Bill Cunningham>So changing the zoning does not preclude the possibility of including emergency management uses on the site in the future, but it does open the opportunity for things like affordable housing.

304
00:32:18.369 --> 00:32:21.709
<v Olivia Clark>Well, I, I appreciate the explanation and I understand it.

305
00:32:21.934 --> 00:32:28.942
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I'm just concerned that it just makes it easier for the Safe Rest Village to stay there, um, forever or indeterminately.

306
00:32:29.056 --> 00:32:34.373
<v Olivia Clark>So, uh, I'm just signaling that I may vote against this despite all the other advantages.

307
00:32:34.470 --> 00:32:34.907
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

308
00:32:35.782 --> 00:32:37.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Council Vice President Clark.

309
00:32:37.488 --> 00:32:38.186
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

310
00:32:39.826 --> 00:32:40.167
<v Guy Benn>Thanks.

311
00:32:40.394 --> 00:32:41.905
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, appreciate this.

312
00:32:42.182 --> 00:32:59.874
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I, I, I appreciated the The presentation at our committee, as the chair mentioned, there's one thing that you said that I want to hone in on because I think it can lead to some misunderstandings in the grand public, which is that the zone allows a shelter to exist.

313
00:33:01.814 --> 00:33:09.773
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's a yes, but I'd also— I just want to note for public record, for everybody who's watching, is that the last— this mayor, the last 2 mayors, the 3 mayors in a row have been putting shelters up across the city.

314
00:33:09.837 --> 00:33:09.934
<v Lee Armstrong>Thank you.

315
00:33:13.713 --> 00:33:18.707
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because we have been opening them under emergency ordinance, emergency declarations.

316
00:33:19.452 --> 00:33:41.693
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I don't want any misunderstandings to happen in the public sphere, especially for, you know, obviously the 3 people in the queue here are all District 4 folks, that by changing the zoning of the Sears Armory location, that we are changing the zoning of the entire That somehow it is making the shelter, frankly, even easier to exist.

317
00:33:41.837 --> 00:33:45.813
<v Eric Zimmerman>It, it, it has the easiest path already to exist, which is an emergency declaration.

318
00:33:46.308 --> 00:33:49.162
<v Eric Zimmerman>The mayor has the choice on whether or not to continue to open that.

319
00:33:49.595 --> 00:33:52.191
<v Eric Zimmerman>The council has the choice whether or not to continue to fund that.

320
00:33:52.799 --> 00:33:58.200
<v Eric Zimmerman>The zoning is so divorced from, frankly, the decision of the shelter.

321
00:33:58.407 --> 00:34:04.580
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just want to be very, very clear that a vote in support today of this overall Are we calling it AHOP?

322
00:34:04.758 --> 00:34:05.448
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that what we're calling it?

323
00:34:05.704 --> 00:34:12.512
<v Eric Zimmerman>AHOP is not, you know, a nail in the coffin, so to speak, for a permanent shelter in a neighborhood.

324
00:34:12.561 --> 00:34:14.503
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I just, I have to be clear about that.

325
00:34:15.740 --> 00:34:23.817
<v Eric Zimmerman>And one of the questions I asked during committee when this came up, given the current zoning, I think it was called EG-1.

326
00:34:24.121 --> 00:34:24.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>EG-2.

327
00:34:25.213 --> 00:34:26.530
<v Eric Zimmerman>I asked EG-2.

328
00:34:26.820 --> 00:34:27.461
<v Eric Zimmerman>All right, thank you.

329
00:34:28.023 --> 00:34:32.052
<v Eric Zimmerman>I asked, Was that a deliberate zoning because that was our plan?

330
00:34:32.391 --> 00:34:43.534
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or a lot of times when we redo zones, we take a look at a thing like a US Army Reserve armory and we say, well, it's already in the neighborhood, it conforms to this.

331
00:34:43.599 --> 00:34:45.626
<v Eric Zimmerman>So plop, there's your zone for it.

332
00:34:45.692 --> 00:34:49.164
<v Eric Zimmerman>It wasn't a deliberate decision of this is what we want to see in that area.

333
00:34:49.871 --> 00:34:50.547
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's important.

334
00:34:50.594 --> 00:34:57.621
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I share that because there are— when we plan out neighborhoods and we think about the mix of commercial to residential to industrial, Right.

335
00:34:58.027 --> 00:35:04.480
<v Eric Zimmerman>Some of that is very deliberate, and other times we're applying a zone to what exists on the property already and probably has for 50 or more years.

336
00:35:04.737 --> 00:35:07.994
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'll be supportive today.

337
00:35:08.347 --> 00:35:26.356
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if you have concerns about the Sears Shelter or the Multnomah Safe Rest Village, I assure you that the zoning question is not the question to get wrapped around the axle about when it comes to the future of that.

338
00:35:26.420 --> 00:35:26.548
<v Jonathan Ader>Thank you.

339
00:35:28.201 --> 00:35:34.697
<v Eric Zimmerman>That concern should be given to this council as a funding body and to the mayor as an operating body.

340
00:35:35.469 --> 00:35:44.032
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that is a worthwhile engagement that I think we're all going to have to have for what is the length of SRBs in our community.

341
00:35:44.097 --> 00:35:47.960
<v Eric Zimmerman>We've seen some open, we've seen some close, we've seen some expand, we've seen some shrink.

342
00:35:48.590 --> 00:35:53.311
<v Eric Zimmerman>That— I'm fully ready to have that conversation, but I'm not placing that at the feet of the planning department.

343
00:35:53.360 --> 00:35:53.505
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

344
00:35:55.889 --> 00:36:06.757
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because, and I think this is a good thing, the executive has opened up through emergency ordinance and done their duties in a certain way regardless of zoning across the city.

345
00:36:07.744 --> 00:36:09.978
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for your explanation.

346
00:36:10.027 --> 00:36:11.661
<v Eric Zimmerman>It was very helpful during the brief.

347
00:36:11.806 --> 00:36:13.311
<v Eric Zimmerman>I said that during the committee.

348
00:36:13.407 --> 00:36:15.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>It was a great presentation, very clear to me.

349
00:36:15.929 --> 00:36:23.181
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've already had a few people reach out from different areas where they're an adjacent property or kind of interested in how to get on the next list.

350
00:36:23.246 --> 00:36:26.748
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that's very interesting in terms of the hunger for this.

351
00:36:26.795 --> 00:36:28.474
<v Eric Zimmerman>So appreciate the work.

352
00:36:28.974 --> 00:36:36.617
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for those in Multnomah Village, which I'm a neighbor of, this is not a permanent siting of a shelter.

353
00:36:36.664 --> 00:36:39.061
<v Eric Zimmerman>I can't underline, bold, and italics that enough.

354
00:36:39.320 --> 00:36:40.543
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I just want to be very clear about that.

355
00:36:40.606 --> 00:36:40.960
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks so much.

356
00:36:41.590 --> 00:36:42.253
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

357
00:36:42.512 --> 00:36:42.932
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

358
00:36:43.547 --> 00:36:47.302
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for letting your D4 councilors all stack up on this.

359
00:36:47.367 --> 00:36:48.873
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I appreciate your comments there, Councilor Zimmerman.

360
00:36:48.922 --> 00:36:50.135
<v Mitch Green>I think that's very similar to what I was going to say.

361
00:36:52.699 --> 00:36:52.795
<v Guy Benn>Okay.

362
00:36:53.199 --> 00:36:58.108
<v Mitch Green>You know, I'm going to support this one because we need more housing production.

363
00:36:58.382 --> 00:37:03.902
<v Mitch Green>And I think, you know, that's— it takes a long time to get to a place where changing the map, there's a lot of process and work that goes into it.

364
00:37:03.952 --> 00:37:09.318
<v Mitch Green>I don't want to delay necessary zoning that can open up capacity.

365
00:37:09.809 --> 00:37:15.527
<v Mitch Green>But the CM-2 is just a mixed-use zoning parcel designation.

366
00:37:15.882 --> 00:37:19.355
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, when I was in the Army, I was stationed at Sears Armory.

367
00:37:19.786 --> 00:37:23.945
<v Mitch Green>And I can tell you, it's an old building and it's a terrible use of land in the city.

368
00:37:24.860 --> 00:37:46.556
<v Mitch Green>And I think if anything, for neighbors who are worried about whether or not this like locks in what I think is a safe rest village that has not really honored its community agreements, frankly, this actually, you know, the potential for redevelopment of the site might actually force a change in the location or a different contemplation of how we would approach that.

369
00:37:46.605 --> 00:37:46.764
<v Bob Weinstein>Thank you.

370
00:37:47.469 --> 00:37:56.909
<v Mitch Green>You know, right now, because it is an underutilized parcel where there's no clear investment or use case, it's just a site of convenience.

371
00:37:56.956 --> 00:37:58.364
<v Mitch Green>And so I think that's why we have it there.

372
00:37:59.043 --> 00:38:00.855
<v Mitch Green>I'm definitely going to be supporting this.

373
00:38:01.581 --> 00:38:07.257
<v Mitch Green>And I think that, like, we need to stay laser-focused on making sure that, you know, we're going to do our site walk this afternoon.

374
00:38:07.650 --> 00:38:11.228
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's how we show up for these community members who are worried about this.

375
00:38:11.309 --> 00:38:12.710
<v Mitch Green>But I'm very supportive of this.

376
00:38:12.759 --> 00:38:12.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

377
00:38:14.487 --> 00:38:18.550
<v Mitch Green>I want to do more of the zoning around the city to create more housing opportunity.

378
00:38:18.697 --> 00:38:19.036
<v Bob Weinstein>Thanks.

379
00:38:20.802 --> 00:38:22.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark, and then we'll move to public testimony.

380
00:38:23.099 --> 00:38:25.139
<v Olivia Clark>Oh, thank you, Council President.

381
00:38:25.525 --> 00:38:27.920
<v Olivia Clark>All right, colleagues, that's very convincing.

382
00:38:28.048 --> 00:38:29.382
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that.

383
00:38:29.623 --> 00:38:39.989
<v Olivia Clark>And as a former housing advocate, I think you've turned me around by sending some strong messages to our constituents in Multnomah.

384
00:38:47.710 --> 00:38:47.985
<v Loretta Smith>Excellent.

385
00:38:48.230 --> 00:38:50.476
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call public testimony?

386
00:38:54.280 --> 00:38:56.987
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Lee Armstrong.

387
00:38:59.500 --> 00:39:00.824
<v Lee Armstrong>Hi there, can you hear me?

388
00:39:01.309 --> 00:39:01.648
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

389
00:39:02.521 --> 00:39:02.713
<v Loretta Smith>Great.

390
00:39:03.311 --> 00:39:10.054
<v Lee Armstrong>My name is Lee Armstrong, and I am here again on behalf of Habitat for Humanity Portland Region in support of the Affordable Housing Opportunities Project.

391
00:39:12.713 --> 00:39:18.693
<v Lee Armstrong>Habitat owns one of the properties that is proposed for rezoning on Northeast Prescott Street in the Cully neighborhood.

392
00:39:19.367 --> 00:39:26.485
<v Lee Armstrong>We plan to build 16 family-sized homes on the site to be affordable for households who are priced out of the for-profit housing market.

393
00:39:26.967 --> 00:39:32.802
<v Lee Armstrong>Rezoning this property to RM-1 will reduce both the cost and the time that we need to build these homes.

394
00:39:33.572 --> 00:39:40.195
<v Lee Armstrong>Habitat really appreciates that the AHOP team has been proactive in rezoning this property to help streamline the development process.

395
00:39:40.242 --> 00:39:40.355
<v Ashley Plauschay>Thank you.

396
00:39:41.530 --> 00:39:56.317
<v Lee Armstrong>You all are probably familiar with affordable homeownership programs for households below 80% of the area median income, but Habitat Portland Region actually sells most of the homes that we build to households between 35% and 60% of AMI.

397
00:39:57.137 --> 00:40:02.518
<v Lee Armstrong>These are families who would otherwise be rent burdened in the private market and potentially housing insecure.

398
00:40:04.090 --> 00:40:08.322
<v Lee Armstrong>Habitat Portland Region has a longstanding commitment to the Cully neighborhood.

399
00:40:08.563 --> 00:40:11.048
<v Lee Armstrong>Over the years, we have built more than 60 homes here.

400
00:40:11.706 --> 00:40:20.980
<v Lee Armstrong>In 2010, we helped form Living Cully, a coalition with a shared mission to prevent displacement for communities of color and low-income residents in the neighborhood.

401
00:40:21.878 --> 00:40:32.836
<v Lee Armstrong>As Cully faces increased real estate costs and investments through a new tax increment finance district, stabilizing households through permanently affordable house— homeownership is more important than ever.

402
00:40:34.009 --> 00:40:41.860
<v Lee Armstrong>The plan for this new development emphasizes efficient unit layouts, pedestrian-friendly design, and shared community green space.

403
00:40:42.760 --> 00:40:54.530
<v Lee Armstrong>Building on our track record with Earth Advantage Platinum construction standards, Prescott Street will be Habitat Portland Region's first net-zero homeownership development, complete with solar panels.

404
00:40:55.204 --> 00:41:09.824
<v Lee Armstrong>This development will reduce homeowner utility And if you look behind me as I move out of the way, this is a rendering of the project as it will look when the homes are completed.

405
00:41:11.579 --> 00:41:16.054
<v Lee Armstrong>Thank you very much for your support of the AHOP proposal and for your service to the City of Portland.

406
00:41:17.128 --> 00:41:17.878
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

407
00:41:21.206 --> 00:41:23.577
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Guy Ben.

408
00:41:28.514 --> 00:41:29.492
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning and welcome.

409
00:41:33.110 --> 00:41:33.351
<v Loretta Smith>Good morning.

410
00:41:33.704 --> 00:41:37.101
<v Guy Benn>Good morning, Councilors, President Dunphy, Vice President Clark.

411
00:41:37.231 --> 00:41:44.530
<v Guy Benn>My name is Guy Benn, and I am here today representing TriMet in my capacity as program manager of its Transit Oriented Development program.

412
00:41:46.750 --> 00:41:57.458
<v Guy Benn>TriMet strongly endorses the city's proposed Affordable Housing Opportunities program to support the delivery and preservation and renovation of affordable housing near Transit.

413
00:41:57.556 --> 00:42:04.630
<v Guy Benn>TriMet owns 2 properties in the Brooklyn neighborhood on Southeast 17th Avenue that are identified for rezoning through AHOP.

414
00:42:05.197 --> 00:42:20.217
<v Guy Benn>Located at the intersection of Southeast Rhone and Southeast Holgate Streets, TriMet has owned these properties since March 2011 and March 2012 respectively, when they were purchased for the Orange Line MAX construction, which was completed in 2015.

415
00:42:21.844 --> 00:42:26.019
<v Guy Benn>TriMet has a long history of supporting and delivering transit-oriented development across the city.

416
00:42:26.932 --> 00:42:41.097
<v Guy Benn>Learning from past experiences and from best practice and precedents in other U.S. cities, TriMet reestablished its Transit Oriented Development program in 2020 to accelerate the delivery of community-supported projects on its underused land.

417
00:42:41.996 --> 00:42:52.586
<v Guy Benn>Codified in TriMet's 2023 Regional TOD Plan, the program focuses on delivering housing and other catalytic development to help neighborhoods grow and prosper.

418
00:42:53.998 --> 00:43:03.710
<v Guy Benn>Rezoning Southeast 17th Avenue parcels through AHOP will unlock 2 prominent station, station adjacent sites for such catalytic development.

419
00:43:04.976 --> 00:43:23.514
<v Guy Benn>Although at first glance, these infill parcels appear to be good development sites, they are small and are zoned EG-1 General Employment, which since the adoption of the city's 2035 Comprehensive Plan in June 2016, has prohibited residential development.

420
00:43:24.809 --> 00:43:35.132
<v Guy Benn>As a result, and because they are too small for viable light industrial use, TriMet has been unable to bring any development to these sites, residential or commercial, for a decade.

421
00:43:37.222 --> 00:43:42.184
<v Guy Benn>Rezoning these parcels to Commercial Mixed Use 2 will finally unlock these parcels for development.

422
00:43:43.106 --> 00:43:50.476
<v Guy Benn>Our analyses indicate that this can enable the delivery of an estimated 80 to 100 affordable housing units across the 2 sites.

423
00:43:51.438 --> 00:44:02.543
<v Guy Benn>TriMet has heard the neighborhood's desire for active ground floor space, and it will continue to investigate the potential to include ground floor commercial space as CM-2 zoning allows.

424
00:44:03.842 --> 00:44:12.639
<v Guy Benn>Notwithstanding this, TriMet, like many in this room, recognizes that including commercial space in affordable development prevails the project.

425
00:44:13.239 --> 00:44:19.018
<v Guy Benn>Which typically adds 15 to 20% to the gross development costs, making it economically unviable.

426
00:44:20.159 --> 00:44:27.045
<v Guy Benn>Nonetheless, TriMet strongly believes CM2 remains the best approach and encourages council to support the AHOP proposals.

427
00:44:27.880 --> 00:44:42.927
<v Guy Benn>It appreciates the thoughtful, proactive, and collaborative approach by the BPS team leading the project and is excited to be part of this practical, cost-efficient, and effective initiative to help address the city's Thank you.

428
00:44:49.429 --> 00:44:52.974
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, sorry, next up we have Ashley Plauschay.

429
00:44:54.519 --> 00:44:54.858
<v Ashley Plauschay>Thank you.

430
00:44:54.922 --> 00:44:56.452
<v Ashley Plauschay>Good morning, I'm Ashley Plauschay.

431
00:44:56.534 --> 00:44:58.177
<v Ashley Plauschay>Thank you for the opportunity to testify.

432
00:44:58.869 --> 00:45:03.041
<v Ashley Plauschay>As a Brooklyn resident, I submitted detailed written comments as well yesterday for your review.

433
00:45:03.864 --> 00:45:06.329
<v Ashley Plauschay>I support the city's goal of increasing affordable housing.

434
00:45:07.032 --> 00:45:16.250
<v Ashley Plauschay>My comments are about the scale proposed for the TriMet properties directly next to 1 and 2-story homes and whose frontage is on 16th Avenue, a residential street.

435
00:45:16.972 --> 00:45:27.599
<v Ashley Plauschay>Under CM-1, buildings can be 35 feet tall, roughly 3 stories, which is already a meaningful increase in scale next to nearby R-2.5 and R-5 homes.

436
00:45:28.434 --> 00:45:31.367
<v Ashley Plauschay>Under CM-2, buildings can currently reach 4 stories.

437
00:45:31.704 --> 00:45:43.880
<v Ashley Plauschay>However, At the January 27th Homelessness and Housing Committee meeting, we learned of a separate housing bonus alignment initiative that's underway that would increase CM-2 height from 4 to 5 stories.

438
00:45:44.474 --> 00:45:50.378
<v Ashley Plauschay>That possibility was not part of earlier conversations with the community or the Portland Housing Bureau Commissioner's hearing.

439
00:45:51.117 --> 00:45:56.219
<v Ashley Plauschay>The discussion draft is not yet available for public review, and its first meeting is scheduled after this vote.

440
00:45:57.052 --> 00:46:01.545
<v Ashley Plauschay>After approving CM-2, it could lock in entitlements that may soon allow for even greater height.

441
00:46:02.211 --> 00:46:06.559
<v Ashley Plauschay>That represents a substantial shift in mass and intensity at this location.

442
00:46:07.469 --> 00:46:14.929
<v Ashley Plauschay>In past meetings, CM-2 was largely justified by the city for ground floor commercial uses, as well as a benefit for residents and the neighborhood.

443
00:46:15.590 --> 00:46:21.534
<v Ashley Plauschay>The developer with a letter of intent has indicated that commercial and service uses are unlikely to be financially viable.

444
00:46:22.306 --> 00:46:26.333
<v Ashley Plauschay>As such, the same number of housing units could still be delivered under CM-1.

445
00:46:27.806 --> 00:46:37.972
<v Ashley Plauschay>Further, if the only way that this project pencils is at a scale exceeding neighborhood compatibility, it raises a policy question about whether this is the right zoning for these specific locations.

446
00:46:38.806 --> 00:46:51.186
<v Ashley Plauschay>CM-1 still allows for meaningful housing development while better aligning with Policies 4.30 and 4.31, ensuring compatible scale transitions and protecting light, privacy, and neighborhood character.

447
00:46:52.036 --> 00:46:54.585
<v Ashley Plauschay>There are also practical livability considerations.

448
00:46:55.311 --> 00:47:03.934
<v Ashley Plauschay>A 50-plus unit building without adequate onsite parking would affect surrounding streets, particularly given that 17th and Holgate are not available for parking.

449
00:47:04.778 --> 00:47:12.661
<v Ashley Plauschay>Policy 5.11 emphasizes removing barriers for people in protected classes, including residents with disabilities.

450
00:47:13.418 --> 00:47:19.295
<v Ashley Plauschay>A large building without elevators or sufficient accessible parking raises long-term accessibility concerns.

451
00:47:19.342 --> 00:47:19.601
<v Lee Armstrong>Second.

452
00:47:20.596 --> 00:47:27.329
<v Ashley Plauschay>Finally, each map amendment can stand alone, so selecting CM-1 here would not affect other AHOP rezonings.

453
00:47:28.306 --> 00:47:31.048
<v Ashley Plauschay>Based on these policies, I recommend CM-1.

454
00:47:31.673 --> 00:47:36.034
<v Ashley Plauschay>I recommend CM-1 to better fit the stated objectives and the character of the neighborhood.

455
00:47:36.788 --> 00:47:45.572
<v Ashley Plauschay>If you have any questions if CM-2 is fully justified at this location, CM-1 is the more prudent approach to advance housing while respecting neighborhood scale.

456
00:47:49.333 --> 00:47:50.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for being here.

457
00:47:51.286 --> 00:47:52.733
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Jake Antles.

458
00:47:55.324 --> 00:47:56.134
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning and welcome.

459
00:47:57.347 --> 00:47:57.815
<v Jake Antles>Hello, everyone.

460
00:47:58.059 --> 00:48:00.146
<v Jake Antles>Um, my name is Jake Antles.

461
00:48:00.242 --> 00:48:05.550
<v Jake Antles>I live in the Cully neighborhood, and I'm a little out of sorts because I stayed up all night with my sick daughter.

462
00:48:05.969 --> 00:48:11.349
<v Jake Antles>Um, I just wanted to, um, just advocate, uh, for the Cully neighborhood.

463
00:48:12.047 --> 00:48:13.467
<v Jake Antles>And point out a few things.

464
00:48:14.210 --> 00:48:21.202
<v Jake Antles>I fully support the project and want to point out that it's largely a no-brainer, right?

465
00:48:21.476 --> 00:48:29.530
<v Jake Antles>Like, we're here looking at this and only one project had opposition statements per the report.

466
00:48:31.922 --> 00:48:37.427
<v Jake Antles>And all the zoning changes were modest, like RM-1 to RM-2, CX to RX.

467
00:48:38.684 --> 00:48:42.182
<v Jake Antles>RM-2 to CM-2, etc.

468
00:48:42.264 --> 00:48:47.396
<v Jake Antles>And the biggest change was for the Habitat project, which was R-7 to RM-1.

469
00:48:48.059 --> 00:48:52.675
<v Jake Antles>And, um, and even then, you know, a no-brainer, right?

470
00:48:53.257 --> 00:48:57.594
<v Jake Antles>It's right next to a school, so enhancing safe routes to school.

471
00:48:57.820 --> 00:49:07.059
<v Jake Antles>It's a block away from a city park, so even a dense project will have Access to green space, open space.

472
00:49:07.704 --> 00:49:28.262
<v Jake Antles>Um, and I just have to, you know, point out that the frustration as a community member who's seen— and a person who works in construction in a soft construction market that's wanting more opportunities for projects and currently furloughed because of lack of work.

473
00:49:29.402 --> 00:49:32.193
<v Jake Antles>Like, we need to make this process easier.

474
00:49:32.469 --> 00:49:42.246
<v Jake Antles>It's a complete waste of time and resources for it to spend over a year and a half to do all these common sense changes to our zoning code.

475
00:49:44.592 --> 00:49:52.230
<v Jake Antles>Like, and then, and then too, if you read the reasoning from Planning Sustainability, that reasoning can apply to all the adjacent parcels.

476
00:49:52.277 --> 00:50:08.588
<v Jake Antles>There's, there's really nothing precluding us In a bigger project, obviously, with community input, obviously, you know, it would take a— take some time, but we need to start working on it on a project to, to make all this a lot faster and a lot easier.

477
00:50:09.135 --> 00:50:18.922
<v Jake Antles>Um, for example, across from the Prescott, like, well, 2, 2 doors down from the Prescott Habitat project, there's a 1.78-acre church.

478
00:50:19.403 --> 00:50:34.329
<v Jake Antles>Um, one can imagine if trends hold that that church Might be vacant in 5, 10, 20 years, and that we could have, based on that density, you know, 32 homes right across from Scott School Elementary School.

479
00:50:35.193 --> 00:50:47.998
<v Jake Antles>And it just seems common sense, and the reasoning from Planning Sustainability carries over to that site without question, that this— that we should also be upzoning that site from R7 to RM-1.

480
00:50:48.141 --> 00:50:48.590
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

481
00:50:49.938 --> 00:50:50.659
<v Jake Antles>And, and it just—.

482
00:50:50.740 --> 00:50:50.932
<v Loretta Smith>It—.

483
00:50:51.253 --> 00:51:06.291
<v Jake Antles>Sorry, it might— I know my, my— the logic of this isn't, isn't clear, but we need broad upzoning around schools, around parks, um, around main streets like Prescott, along bus lines throughout our city.

484
00:51:07.045 --> 00:51:11.106
<v Jake Antles>Next to these, these, uh, TriMet stations, there's, there's low-density areas.

485
00:51:11.362 --> 00:51:13.193
<v Jake Antles>So that's, that's my, my testimony.

486
00:51:13.304 --> 00:51:14.106
<v Jake Antles>Thank you for your time.

487
00:51:14.652 --> 00:51:15.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

488
00:51:17.829 --> 00:51:19.514
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony for this item.

489
00:51:20.438 --> 00:51:22.125
<v Jamie Dunphy>Excellent.

490
00:51:22.367 --> 00:51:23.664
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we now move into discussion.

491
00:51:25.360 --> 00:51:25.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

492
00:51:26.603 --> 00:51:29.123
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

493
00:51:30.480 --> 00:51:40.396
<v Mitch Green>Um, I hope my D3 colleagues will permit me to speak about their district, but, um, as a person who used to live in Brooklyn and I'm right on the cusp, I feel like I've got some sort of, uh, uh, reasonable claim there.

494
00:51:41.170 --> 00:51:47.554
<v Mitch Green>Um, I just want to note that The parcels on Southeast 17th are currently just unutilized land.

495
00:51:48.298 --> 00:51:55.224
<v Mitch Green>They're unutilized land next to, next to like a MAX, like right along a MAX station.

496
00:51:55.416 --> 00:52:18.083
<v Mitch Green>And so when we think about the choice before us, we're not only thinking about creating opportunities to build more housing, but we're also creating opportunities to create the conditions through our land use considerations For TriMet to be a viable business enterprise in some sense, because they don't have an infinite money printer like the rest of us, right?

497
00:52:18.887 --> 00:52:26.367
<v Mitch Green>To make it possible for TriMet to be what we deserve, a world-class transit system, we have to build density around TriMet stops.

498
00:52:27.059 --> 00:52:29.563
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, Holgate and 17th is a TriMet stop.

499
00:52:29.949 --> 00:52:32.614
<v Mitch Green>And I see a big vacant lot there.

500
00:52:32.693 --> 00:52:34.556
<v Mitch Green>And so we need to go big here.

501
00:52:34.621 --> 00:52:34.717
<v Guy Benn>Thank you.

502
00:52:35.539 --> 00:52:52.014
<v Mitch Green>And we, you know, and I think the last person, Mr. Jake Antles, I think hit the nail on the head by saying that we do move too slowly when we consider this kind of stuff.

503
00:52:52.063 --> 00:52:54.552
<v Mitch Green>And that's not an indictment of staff.

504
00:52:54.650 --> 00:52:59.304
<v Mitch Green>That's not a sort of suggestion that people aren't working hard and taking their jobs seriously.

505
00:52:59.887 --> 00:53:05.054
<v Mitch Green>But it is a suggestion that perhaps We haven't enabled them to move faster.

506
00:53:05.637 --> 00:53:16.166
<v Mitch Green>And so I, I want to look at this as an opportunity to, to move forward much more quickly and much more systematically across our whole map on how to unlock this stuff.

507
00:53:16.213 --> 00:53:20.190
<v Mitch Green>So I'm strongly in support of this, and thank you.

508
00:53:21.304 --> 00:53:22.012
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

509
00:53:22.835 --> 00:53:24.320
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, any further discussion on this item?

510
00:53:24.400 --> 00:53:24.998
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

511
00:53:26.240 --> 00:53:31.632
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you so much, Council President, And thank you, Councilor Zimmerman, for your accurate read of during the technical questions.

512
00:53:31.679 --> 00:53:32.418
<v Dan Ryan>That was quite helpful.

513
00:53:32.626 --> 00:53:39.585
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you to the BPS team for seeing this through another round of necessary amendments to this comprehensive plan.

514
00:53:40.242 --> 00:53:42.456
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you to the Planning Commission for your recommendations.

515
00:53:42.568 --> 00:53:46.400
<v Dan Ryan>I had to peel away just before the vote, but I would've made it 5-0.

516
00:53:46.833 --> 00:53:54.978
<v Dan Ryan>We passed the shelter-to-housing zoning connected to the comprehensive plan in 2021, and it's really wonderful 5 years later to see these pragmatic updates.

517
00:53:55.027 --> 00:53:55.155
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

518
00:53:55.492 --> 00:53:56.358
<v Dan Ryan>That makes sense to me.

519
00:53:57.081 --> 00:53:58.733
<v Dan Ryan>I know Brandy and her team are out there.

520
00:53:59.005 --> 00:53:59.969
<v Dan Ryan>Hi, it's good to see you.

521
00:54:00.530 --> 00:54:06.242
<v Dan Ryan>And you're well aware of the challenge of siting the villages adjacent to residential homes.

522
00:54:06.644 --> 00:54:12.148
<v Dan Ryan>It does make it more challenging to manage the Good Neighbor Agreement, more challenging than, say, in an industrial zone.

523
00:54:12.501 --> 00:54:14.443
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that's the rub that we always have here.

524
00:54:15.068 --> 00:54:18.728
<v Dan Ryan>I think we just need to continue to provide extra construction for privacy.

525
00:54:19.240 --> 00:54:23.735
<v Dan Ryan>Maybe there's a fence zoning law that doesn't allow us to build them high enough.

526
00:54:23.798 --> 00:54:27.315
<v Dan Ryan>Maybe that could be altered in this emergency situation.

527
00:54:27.668 --> 00:54:34.989
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm hoping that we can have larger fences, especially in the north end, if I'm doing my directions right, where that's right against the residents.

528
00:54:35.519 --> 00:54:39.534
<v Dan Ryan>And perhaps in general, a larger fence around that property would be helpful.

529
00:54:40.673 --> 00:54:46.599
<v Dan Ryan>And I continue to hope that the provider is doing good neighbor work, which I'm proud that we instituted those.

530
00:54:46.679 --> 00:54:47.884
<v Dan Ryan>They were very hard to do, trust me.

531
00:54:47.963 --> 00:54:48.077
<v Jonathan Ader>Thank you.

532
00:54:49.007 --> 00:54:50.369
<v Dan Ryan>No one wanted to go through that.

533
00:54:51.251 --> 00:54:53.173
<v Dan Ryan>And we're getting there.

534
00:54:53.574 --> 00:54:58.800
<v Dan Ryan>I think the success you had at Peninsula Crossing demonstrates that you can work it out.

535
00:54:59.121 --> 00:55:01.813
<v Dan Ryan>And I hope that we can do the same at Multnomah Village.

536
00:55:02.085 --> 00:55:06.862
<v Dan Ryan>And I just know that sometimes fences makes for better relationships with neighbors.

537
00:55:07.199 --> 00:55:07.568
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

538
00:55:08.336 --> 00:55:09.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

539
00:55:09.362 --> 00:55:10.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

540
00:55:11.286 --> 00:55:12.311
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

541
00:55:13.530 --> 00:55:16.623
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And thank you to our team in the Thank you, Mayor.

542
00:55:16.672 --> 00:55:18.358
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you to the bureaus who brought this to us today.

543
00:55:18.503 --> 00:55:25.793
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am supportive of this measure, but I have a couple of points that I just would like to raise for the record and a question or two.

544
00:55:27.253 --> 00:55:50.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I worry that approaches like this can advantage already established housing developers, whether nonprofit or for-profit, who are able to come forward through the process and Doesn't give space for small groups who are trying to do the right thing with their properties but don't always have the connections to know about opportunities like this.

545
00:55:50.719 --> 00:55:59.010
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am really appreciative for that reason that during the committee hearing there was an offer made for anybody else with a project like this to bring it forward.

546
00:55:59.137 --> 00:56:05.614
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Obviously nobody who testified did so today, but I appreciate that we gave that opportunity to people.

547
00:56:06.947 --> 00:56:32.853
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Related to that, I am wondering how regularly we take actions like this, because I know that I do have a few projects in my district that are those, those smaller owners who don't always have the connections to know when something like this is happening, who weren't quite ready for the process before us today, but who in hearing about this process were interested and could take advantage of something like this in the future.

548
00:56:33.367 --> 00:56:43.398
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'd just like to make sure that for anybody like that who is paying attention, we get on the record how often we expect to do things like this and when further opportunities might come up.

549
00:56:44.425 --> 00:56:47.538
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Thank you so much for the question, uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

550
00:56:48.275 --> 00:56:55.400
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Um, so we did a similar project— the Bureau did a similar project to this in 2020 and 2021.

551
00:56:55.657 --> 00:57:02.380
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Actually, the focus, um, for those projects was faith-based organizations, and the, uh, process Yes.

552
00:57:02.476 --> 00:57:12.574
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>The process in 2020 did identify or lead to the identification of a few additional properties, and that's why the 2021 project happened.

553
00:57:12.670 --> 00:57:19.960
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>So if there is sufficient, you know, we'd be happy to talk to property owners of different locations.

554
00:57:20.409 --> 00:57:32.001
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>If there's sufficient interest, I think we can certainly investigate the opportunity to follow up with them and find future projects where we could address those properties.

555
00:57:32.353 --> 00:57:43.320
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>I wanted to just also mention that we, as you all know, we are undertaking an area planning process for the inner east area or geography of the city.

556
00:57:43.978 --> 00:58:03.186
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And to earlier comments from speakers about the need to look more holistically at larger swaths of the city and identify potential for creating more capacity for multi-dwelling housing and mixed use, The Inner East project is an example of a project where we have the opportunity to do that.

557
00:58:04.052 --> 00:58:15.045
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And it's also possible that some of these locations that you are thinking of, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, might be in that geography and we might have an opportunity to address those locations through that project.

558
00:58:15.815 --> 00:58:19.965
<v Eric Engstrom>Councilor, just to add briefly for the record, Eric Engstrom, Director of Planning and Sustainability.

559
00:58:21.423 --> 00:58:24.436
<v Eric Engstrom>I absolutely would like this to be a recurring kind of program.

560
00:58:24.500 --> 00:58:28.842
<v Eric Engstrom>It's, it's of course resource dependent and we've done a couple of these now, so I'd like to continue that.

561
00:58:29.532 --> 00:58:30.384
<v Eric Engstrom>Resource permitting.

562
00:58:30.561 --> 00:58:40.335
<v Eric Engstrom>And, and to echo what Patricia said, at any given time, the bread and butter of BPS's work is doing larger-scale land use planning over wider areas.

563
00:58:40.432 --> 00:58:42.342
<v Eric Engstrom>We're, we're embarking on the Southeast Plan.

564
00:58:42.454 --> 00:58:45.039
<v Eric Engstrom>We did the Southwest Corridor a couple years ago.

565
00:58:45.889 --> 00:58:52.197
<v Eric Engstrom>Of course, in the past, things like the Albina Plan, St. Johns Plan, Hollywood Plan— that is our bread and butter, and that's what we want to be doing.

566
00:58:53.434 --> 00:59:10.784
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both very much, and I appreciate you bringing up the Inner Eastside plan as well, because the other point that I wanted to make is, well, I think this is a really important process for these properties where we can make affordability happen more easily by changing some zoning all at once.

567
00:59:11.474 --> 00:59:15.353
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do think that we need to focus on the power of our land use system.

568
00:59:15.818 --> 00:59:30.034
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a very strong planning system in Portland that has allowed us to be deliberate in how we neighborhoods, to create walkable spaces, to ensure that there is employment near neighborhoods.

569
00:59:30.724 --> 00:59:47.583
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if we do too much of these one-offs— I know that one of my colleagues said this— these are places that were intended to be used for affordable housing, but if it wasn't zoned in this way, then it was at some point either intentionally or, as another colleague mentioned, perhaps unintentionally planned for something else.

570
00:59:47.632 --> 00:59:47.969
<v Priya Dhanapal>Councilmember Herbold.

571
00:59:48.626 --> 00:59:58.945
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And many of these changes are moving land out of employment designations into mixed-use designations, which of course still allow for some employment but a very different type of employment.

572
00:59:59.778 --> 01:00:09.362
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think any of the opportunities before us today would have provided the type of employment opportunities we might want there, so I don't think that's a problem in any of these cases.

573
01:00:10.114 --> 01:00:14.297
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I do want us to make sure that we're being careful about those types of changes.

574
01:00:14.360 --> 01:00:14.505
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

575
01:00:14.585 --> 01:00:31.509
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Of changes, that we're being deliberate, that to the point my constituent in Cully made, we're looking for those places like Northeast Prescott where we should probably do a whole lot of upzoning because that's a thoroughfare that could have a lot more density on it and not just one property but along many properties.

576
01:00:32.103 --> 01:00:37.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I hope that we're using this as an opportunity to catch the whoopsies.

577
01:00:37.963 --> 01:00:43.112
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Some of these are buildings that maybe don't actually comply with the zoning that's currently there.

578
01:00:43.193 --> 01:01:03.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It looks like in some cases that we're catching those one-offs, but that we don't neglect the broader work that's needed where we have the opportunity to balance not just our housing needs, but also our employment needs, our open space needs, the other things that make fantastic neighborhoods in our city that need to go along with these expanded employment opportunities.

579
01:01:04.175 --> 01:01:07.592
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just want to make sure that we're keeping that in mind as we make these changes.

580
01:01:08.105 --> 01:01:21.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to thank you all for all of your work on this, and I know that some of my constituents will be heartened to hear that there will be other opportunities to make sure that we can turn some of our housing potential land into land ready for housing to be built.

581
01:01:22.152 --> 01:01:23.405
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much, Council President.

582
01:01:23.661 --> 01:01:24.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

583
01:01:24.802 --> 01:01:25.733
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

584
01:01:26.807 --> 01:01:29.264
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President, and thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

585
01:01:29.376 --> 01:01:36.137
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think you took a couple of my questions I crossed off my list because you asked them, and I really like what you're bringing up.

586
01:01:36.266 --> 01:01:36.378
<v Claire Adamsick>It's—.

587
01:01:36.586 --> 01:01:43.028
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You have a very good handle on land use and development, my team is telling me right now, and I would love to talk more with you.

588
01:01:43.655 --> 01:01:47.237
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, so a couple of these questions I don't have to ask because you asked them.

589
01:01:47.768 --> 01:01:57.695
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, but I do want to ask, um, you know, my staff has heard from community members about a growing interest in affordable middle housing opportunities, kind of like cottage clusters.

590
01:01:58.353 --> 01:02:10.795
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, uh, I think we've heard people say this idea that There are Portlanders who are property rich but cash poor who are interested in doing things with their property to build something like affordable cottage clusters.

591
01:02:11.054 --> 01:02:26.248
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are there BPS projects underway or maybe some planned for the future that can explore opportunities for that affordable middle housing through zoning changes and/or technical assistance for existing people that own property?

592
01:02:27.739 --> 01:02:29.086
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Councilor, thanks for the question.

593
01:02:29.199 --> 01:02:38.833
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>So as, as you know, over, um, several, several years ago, over I think 2021 and 2022, the city adopted the residential infill project.

594
01:02:39.217 --> 01:02:53.811
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Um, that project facilitated exactly what you were describing, the ability to do, uh, 4 to 6 units cottage clusters in many different configurations on otherwise single dwelling zoned properties in the city.

595
01:02:54.550 --> 01:03:03.039
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And in fact, we've— the bureau has put out two— has done two annual reports thus far on the residential infill project.

596
01:03:03.135 --> 01:03:14.641
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And most of the housing that we're seeing right now in the city, particularly in 2023 and '24, were actually residential infill project types of projects, middle housing projects.

597
01:03:15.572 --> 01:03:22.199
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>As we all know, the sort of larger multi-dwelling and mixed-use projects are not happening in the city right now.

598
01:03:22.489 --> 01:03:25.489
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And so that's actually where we are seeing housing production.

599
01:03:26.083 --> 01:03:41.070
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And the city's regulations really already facilitate that and are consistent with state law that requires cities in Oregon to allow that and actually goes beyond the state laws.

600
01:03:41.583 --> 01:03:52.221
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And in fact, I'll say that there have been a few additional revisions to state law that require us to make some modifications to the city's zoning code.

601
01:03:52.268 --> 01:03:59.362
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>And those projects are projects that staff are currently working on and that the Planning Commission and Council will see in the not too distant future.

602
01:04:01.851 --> 01:04:02.336
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

603
01:04:02.579 --> 01:04:06.847
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How are we helping residents understand their options kind of besides reports?

604
01:04:06.960 --> 01:04:09.603
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are there other ways we're getting that info out?

605
01:04:11.911 --> 01:04:17.190
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>I think it's also a partnership with the bureau, the Portland Permitting and Development.

606
01:04:17.384 --> 01:04:29.503
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>They're the bureau that does the permitting and development review, and they're usually the bureau that property owners interact with first in order to understand what they can do with their property.

607
01:04:29.550 --> 01:04:37.369
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>So I think it's a partnership between the 2 bureaus to help people understand what the regulations are and how they are able to use them.

608
01:04:37.963 --> 01:04:51.748
<v Eric Engstrom>We also have, for the record again, Eric Kingstrom, we have a training program that some of our staff do, which is like a Land Use 101 presentation that we go out and, and meet with realtors or neighborhoods and, and give them that, that presentation.

609
01:04:51.797 --> 01:04:53.085
<v Eric Engstrom>So that's another route.

610
01:04:54.534 --> 01:05:00.420
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'll offer— I'm sure there are other councilors too— we have newsletters and we are meeting with constituents often.

611
01:05:00.695 --> 01:05:02.365
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think we, we can be boosting this.

612
01:05:03.719 --> 01:05:03.992
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

613
01:05:04.942 --> 01:05:05.971
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

614
01:05:06.550 --> 01:05:07.853
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, I put myself in the queue.

615
01:05:08.077 --> 01:05:11.262
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I want to just note, um, I'm a big fan of this.

616
01:05:11.726 --> 01:05:17.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that this is an opportunity for us to try and dig deep and get as much value out of these lands.

617
01:05:17.123 --> 01:05:22.391
<v Jamie Dunphy>And also, just as we heard from our colleagues at TriMet, actually get work going.

618
01:05:22.728 --> 01:05:30.260
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it's worth noting and relatively unique among city councils, but this is a pro-housing city council.

619
01:05:30.695 --> 01:05:39.175
<v Jamie Dunphy>We hear the concerns of neighbors about density and scale and scope, but this is a council that is dead set on building as much housing as we can.

620
01:05:39.286 --> 01:05:40.041
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I personally—.

621
01:05:40.041 --> 01:05:40.155
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Thank you.

622
01:05:40.492 --> 01:05:45.927
<v Jamie Dunphy>Love the idea of building density and height in the areas that can absolutely support it.

623
01:05:46.088 --> 01:05:58.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>And trying to find those vacant pieces of land that could be something bigger or better or helping the city, I think that's the greatest opportunity we have right now and something we should be doing everywhere.

624
01:05:58.918 --> 01:06:04.112
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I will note, though, the vast majority of vacant land right now is in East Portland.

625
01:06:04.226 --> 01:06:06.583
<v Jamie Dunphy>The rest of the city has been pretty well developed by and large.

626
01:06:06.630 --> 01:06:06.775
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

627
01:06:07.016 --> 01:06:29.443
<v Jamie Dunphy>But, and I've heard some testimony that some written testimony and some email testimony that I just want to call out because again, big supporter of this, but the Hazelwood, Centennial, and Gateway neighborhoods are slated to receive a fair amount of upzoning in this process and additional concentration of hopefully affordable housing units, which is great.

628
01:06:30.597 --> 01:06:33.501
<v Jamie Dunphy>But we also already have half the density of grocery stores in East Portland.

629
01:06:34.690 --> 01:06:43.567
<v Jamie Dunphy>We don't have the infrastructure or rapid transit availability to support a lot of the families who will be moving into this area.

630
01:06:43.969 --> 01:06:46.405
<v Jamie Dunphy>East Portland is home to 40% of all the kids in the city.

631
01:06:46.969 --> 01:06:48.355
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need to build affordable housing out there.

632
01:06:48.501 --> 01:06:49.547
<v Jamie Dunphy>It absolutely has to happen.

633
01:06:49.871 --> 01:07:01.467
<v Jamie Dunphy>But it has to come hand in glove with our economic development agency, Prosper Portland, going out and intentionally trying to site grocery stores and economic opportunities in East Portland.

634
01:07:01.518 --> 01:07:01.844
<v Claire Adamsick>Councilmember Herbold.

635
01:07:02.847 --> 01:07:10.317
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it has to come also with our colleagues at TriMet recognizing where the future of transit need is going to be.

636
01:07:10.797 --> 01:07:32.597
<v Jamie Dunphy>So let's do more of this, but also let's make sure, as has been said multiple times, that A, we're not concentrating affordable housing in neighborhoods that have also historically received the least in terms of services, in terms of economic development, and that where it makes sense, we are going as dense and as high as we can because we are a major city.

637
01:07:35.054 --> 01:07:36.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that's my soapbox.

638
01:07:37.139 --> 01:07:45.603
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue for conversation, this is a non-emergency ordinance and will be moving— hold on, I have a script.

639
01:07:48.516 --> 01:07:55.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>This item will be moving to a second reading on February 25th at 9:45 AM, time certain for our vote.

640
01:07:57.117 --> 01:07:57.858
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for being here.

641
01:07:58.664 --> 01:07:58.985
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Thank you.

642
01:07:59.371 --> 01:07:59.630
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

643
01:08:04.318 --> 01:08:07.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>And colleagues, we are now moving to our City Administrator report.

644
01:08:07.650 --> 01:08:08.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please read item number 5?

645
01:08:10.039 --> 01:08:13.606
<v Keelan McClymont>February 2026 City Administrator update.

646
01:08:14.849 --> 01:08:15.833
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator Lee.

647
01:08:17.333 --> 01:08:17.752
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

648
01:08:17.994 --> 01:08:24.914
<v Raymond C. Lee>I'll begin with a few opening comments, uh, before highlighting several key items from this month's report.

649
01:08:25.677 --> 01:08:33.690
<v Raymond C. Lee>This report continues our efforts to provide consistent, high-level operational transparency across service areas.

650
01:08:34.364 --> 01:08:44.466
<v Raymond C. Lee>It focuses on implementation progress, fiscal discipline, and areas where risk or complexity requires continued oversight.

651
01:08:45.108 --> 01:08:52.319
<v Raymond C. Lee>First, on homeless response, 2 additional shelters opened under the mayor's emergency overnight shelter plan.

652
01:08:52.976 --> 01:08:59.015
<v Raymond C. Lee>Adding 296 beds, including recovery-oriented beds at Southeast Grand.

653
01:08:59.497 --> 01:09:06.550
<v Raymond C. Lee>We also extended shelter hours during extreme cold conditions and will continue to do that as we see inclement weather.

654
01:09:07.112 --> 01:09:15.448
<v Raymond C. Lee>Portland Solutions continues to coordinate monthly resource fairs to connect vulnerable Portlanders with services.

655
01:09:16.524 --> 01:09:18.306
<v Raymond C. Lee>Second, on fiscal stewardship.

656
01:09:18.997 --> 01:09:22.590
<v Raymond C. Lee>Implementation of Green 10 budget note is underway.

657
01:09:22.926 --> 01:09:36.752
<v Raymond C. Lee>Most bureaus absorbed the 2% EMS reduction through discretionary spending controls such as travel, consulting, and administrative expenses while protecting union-represented positions.

658
01:09:36.800 --> 01:09:41.595
<v Raymond C. Lee>We will continue our written updates every 6 weeks on this matter.

659
01:09:42.573 --> 01:09:51.104
<v Raymond C. Lee>On major capital delivery, construction continues on the Bull Run Filtration Project now approximately 20% complete.

660
01:09:51.635 --> 01:10:01.880
<v Raymond C. Lee>A project delivery advisory team has been convened to strengthen governance and execution, and we expect updated costs and schedule analysis later this month.

661
01:10:02.618 --> 01:10:11.676
<v Raymond C. Lee>On public safety, the suspect in the shooting of the 2 PPB officers has been arrested, and both officers have been released from the hospital.

662
01:10:12.319 --> 01:10:15.204
<v Raymond C. Lee>And we're wishing them for speedy recovery as well.

663
01:10:15.252 --> 01:10:15.429
<v Jonathan Ader>Thank you.

664
01:10:15.942 --> 01:10:26.975
<v Raymond C. Lee>Portland Street Response is also undergoing enhanced training in partnership with PSU, temporary modifying operations to strengthen long-term service delivery.

665
01:10:28.033 --> 01:10:35.219
<v Raymond C. Lee>Also on traffic, fatalities has declined for the 2nd consecutive year, a 32% reduction from the prior year.

666
01:10:35.828 --> 01:10:41.472
<v Raymond C. Lee>Though 39 lives lost remains unacceptable, we'll continue to work in that endeavor.

667
01:10:41.520 --> 01:10:41.617
<v Jonathan Ader>Thank you.

668
01:10:42.804 --> 01:10:58.654
<v Raymond C. Lee>Now, with respect to the Detention Facility Impact Ordinance and activity at the ICE facility, we will continue to review the implementation of a temporary administrative rule to allow short-term enforcement while developing a permanent rule.

669
01:10:59.488 --> 01:11:07.894
<v Raymond C. Lee>Based on council feedback, we're gathering additional information across bureaus to ensure the rule is thorough and defensible from the outset.

670
01:11:08.023 --> 01:11:08.198
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

671
01:11:08.695 --> 01:11:15.953
<v Raymond C. Lee>A multiple bureau working group met last week and will continue to meet again this week to continue fact-finding.

672
01:11:16.466 --> 01:11:21.817
<v Raymond C. Lee>We expect to provide council with a clear timeline on next steps shortly.

673
01:11:22.250 --> 01:11:30.100
<v Raymond C. Lee>We're not publishing a temporary rule at this time until we address some questions that came out of our meeting with 2 of our councilors, with Green and Morillo.

674
01:11:31.045 --> 01:11:33.256
<v Raymond C. Lee>As you know, the administrative review is underway.

675
01:11:33.864 --> 01:11:39.729
<v Raymond C. Lee>The facility continues operating under existing land use approval during that process.

676
01:11:40.260 --> 01:11:49.555
<v Raymond C. Lee>In parallel, we are evaluating all available city mechanisms to address harmful conduct occurring at or around the facility.

677
01:11:50.533 --> 01:12:01.673
<v Raymond C. Lee>Finally, the city has received a claim notice related to the facility, and administration is coordinating closely with the City Attorney's Office regarding any implications.

678
01:12:02.349 --> 01:12:09.074
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are moving with urgency while ensuring our actions are legally sound and operationally executable.

679
01:12:09.122 --> 01:12:09.234
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

680
01:12:09.828 --> 01:12:13.869
<v Raymond C. Lee>I'll pause here and happy to answer any questions that council may have.

681
01:12:14.222 --> 01:12:20.926
<v Raymond C. Lee>We also have our DCAs and other staff from the City Administrator's Office to address any questions council may have.

682
01:12:21.697 --> 01:12:23.076
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, City Administrator Lee.

683
01:12:23.204 --> 01:12:24.055
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

684
01:12:25.354 --> 01:12:26.668
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, City Administrator Lee.

685
01:12:27.439 --> 01:12:29.844
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I'm glad you're here with us.

686
01:12:30.421 --> 01:12:32.185
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We haven't scared you away.

687
01:12:32.827 --> 01:12:33.484
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Appreciate you.

688
01:12:34.014 --> 01:12:51.313
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I, I do think we don't talk enough about what is working in our city and While I know it's not perfect, I do want to highlight the report's callout of PDX 311, which is meant to be the community's first call to help with questions, local government services within Multnomah County.

689
01:12:51.905 --> 01:13:04.265
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So really want to make sure folks also know you can call and talk to someone daily from 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM to ask questions, make requests, and reports about anything from potholes to broken lights.

690
01:13:04.842 --> 01:13:05.162
<v Lee Armstrong>Thank you.

691
01:13:05.515 --> 01:13:07.667
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And feedback about how that's going is welcome.

692
01:13:08.405 --> 01:13:15.261
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also want to give a shout out, quick shout out to Public Works and all the partners that have coordinated with the Winter Staycation.

693
01:13:15.327 --> 01:13:16.177
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's so fun.

694
01:13:16.851 --> 01:13:25.490
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Come downtown, support Portland by attending one of the many events you can choose from this weekend, like the Portland Winter Light Festival.

695
01:13:25.923 --> 01:13:26.726
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Go Alicia!

696
01:13:27.127 --> 01:13:28.412
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I taught her kid in 3rd grade.

697
01:13:29.216 --> 01:13:33.090
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The Portland Night Market, other Another— or other exciting activities.

698
01:13:33.829 --> 01:13:37.966
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I also want to talk about the Vision Zero Tableau dashboard.

699
01:13:38.029 --> 01:13:38.399
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

700
01:13:39.703 --> 01:13:40.717
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's detailed in the report.

701
01:13:41.490 --> 01:13:46.179
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And my question is, I would love to know if we can include some age-related data in there.

702
01:13:46.871 --> 01:13:57.532
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I've had some initial conversations with Public Works about disaggregating data by age, and we know that there have been variations in age-related trends.

703
01:13:57.967 --> 01:14:10.274
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So at the very least, I'd love to see data that, that tell that story of whether it's youth, elders, and who's experiencing the fatalities and serious injuries, um, possibly at disproportionate rates.

704
01:14:16.287 --> 01:14:21.359
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane, um, and thank you for your leadership in the Vision Zero space as well.

705
01:14:21.761 --> 01:14:31.184
<v Priya Dhanapal>We will absolutely work together with, uh, the citywide Vision Zero lead, Dana Dixon and also with our PBOT partners to make sure we, uh, we are able to do that.

706
01:14:31.555 --> 01:14:33.586
<v Priya Dhanapal>And if there's any issues, we will report back to you.

707
01:14:33.730 --> 01:14:34.230
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Thank you.

708
01:14:34.376 --> 01:14:34.971
<v Keelan McClymont>That sounds great.

709
01:14:35.181 --> 01:14:35.376
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

710
01:14:35.828 --> 01:14:37.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

711
01:14:37.845 --> 01:14:38.378
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

712
01:14:40.430 --> 01:14:42.932
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. President, and thank you, Mr. City Administrator.

713
01:14:43.158 --> 01:14:47.746
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate your update, um, both on the Green 10, uh, EMS cuts.

714
01:14:47.922 --> 01:14:53.952
<v Mitch Green>That's, you know, I think provides a high level of clarity that you're You're executing on that, so I appreciate that.

715
01:14:54.112 --> 01:15:05.416
<v Mitch Green>I also want to just acknowledge that I have seen responsiveness from your office and your DCAs on trying to implement the detention facility fee in this temporary rulemaking.

716
01:15:06.572 --> 01:15:11.244
<v Mitch Green>I know we've placed some pressure on and you guys have responded, and I think that's, that's how this new system is supposed to work.

717
01:15:12.673 --> 01:15:13.427
<v Mitch Green>So thank you for that.

718
01:15:13.476 --> 01:15:15.097
<v Mitch Green>We're going to continue to be engaged on that.

719
01:15:15.146 --> 01:15:16.335
<v Mitch Green>I know the community's watching.

720
01:15:16.961 --> 01:15:17.538
<v Bill Cunningham>Thank you.

721
01:15:17.891 --> 01:15:40.980
<v Mitch Green>I think I just wanted to raise, as you're working through that with all these bureaus, I'm sure you guys have seen it, but some other municipalities have had their mayors issue executive orders to train, to have their police train their body cams on ICE and other DHS entities to help in that fact-finding and kind of like transparency piece.

722
01:15:41.094 --> 01:15:42.908
<v Mitch Green>And so I hope that's something that we consider as well.

723
01:15:43.551 --> 01:15:43.777
<v Jake Antles>Thank you.

724
01:15:46.734 --> 01:15:48.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

725
01:15:49.400 --> 01:15:50.078
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

726
01:15:53.359 --> 01:15:54.475
<v Angelita Morillo>Hi, thank you all so much.

727
01:15:54.734 --> 01:15:57.078
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, City Administrator, I just wanted to say thank you.

728
01:15:57.239 --> 01:16:03.398
<v Angelita Morillo>I think we don't often say thank you when people do great things at the city, and I feel like this report was really detailed.

729
01:16:03.462 --> 01:16:07.212
<v Angelita Morillo>And I want to echo what Councilor Green said about our detention facility impact fee.

730
01:16:07.746 --> 01:16:12.752
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I feel very supported by you and your team on making sure that that's implemented quickly.

731
01:16:13.248 --> 01:16:32.208
<v Angelita Morillo>And so I just wanted to put that on the record that you have been responsive to our needs, concerns, making sure that it is both happening as, you know, it's matching the urgency that the community is requiring of us and that it is being done in a way that will be upheld in the courts and is going to serve Portlanders the best way possible.

732
01:16:32.273 --> 01:16:34.935
<v Angelita Morillo>So I appreciate those regular updates.

733
01:16:34.984 --> 01:16:39.025
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it's really something that my constituents desperately want and need and have been asking for.

734
01:16:39.073 --> 01:16:39.331
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

735
01:16:40.037 --> 01:16:57.079
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm also curious if, or maybe this is something that I would like to see, and I'm curious if you'd be interested in adding this to the report, just having regular updates about what sort of information gathering the city is doing with regards to the impacts of ICE at McAdam.

736
01:16:57.882 --> 01:17:02.315
<v Angelita Morillo>So is there tracking of tear gas deployment?

737
01:17:02.381 --> 01:17:05.769
<v Angelita Morillo>Is there tracking of air quality monitors being Added.

738
01:17:05.832 --> 01:17:21.011
<v Angelita Morillo>I know the county was interested in partnering with us to add air quality monitors down at McAdam, um, and that sort of thing so that we can get regular updates about what sort of information the permitting department is getting and where we're at in that process as well.

739
01:17:22.439 --> 01:17:25.279
<v Raymond C. Lee>I don't see an issue with us providing that information as well.

740
01:17:25.552 --> 01:17:29.243
<v Raymond C. Lee>We'll make sure we update in that and in our weekly reports to you also.

741
01:17:30.622 --> 01:17:31.810
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, that sounds wonderful.

742
01:17:31.890 --> 01:17:33.335
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, thank you so much, really appreciate your work.

743
01:17:34.313 --> 01:17:35.177
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

744
01:17:35.257 --> 01:17:35.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

745
01:17:36.636 --> 01:17:37.212
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

746
01:17:37.277 --> 01:17:37.645
<v Eric Engstrom>Good morning.

747
01:17:38.061 --> 01:17:46.859
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, before I get into a couple questions, just wanted to first, uh, say I really appreciated the shout out to Tatiana Elahalde and the city's language access program and the work across the enterprise.

748
01:17:47.372 --> 01:17:51.698
<v Sameer Kanal>Also Leslie Goodlow in housing for, uh, receiving the World Arts Foundation Lifetime Achievement Award.

749
01:17:52.323 --> 01:17:58.685
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, you're gonna hear this 3 or 4 times today, but tonight, 6 PM, the first meeting of the Community Board for Police Accountability.

750
01:17:58.748 --> 01:18:00.414
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to congratulate everybody involved in that.

751
01:18:00.671 --> 01:18:04.216
<v Sameer Kanal>1,926 Days after the ballot measure was adopted.

752
01:18:05.707 --> 01:18:09.908
<v Sameer Kanal>And very, very much going to— we'll have other items on that, so we'll talk about it later.

753
01:18:10.694 --> 01:18:21.087
<v Sameer Kanal>Also was very happy to see a couple things in here, specifically the discussion of the investment in both PSR, first responders, and violence prevention professionals.

754
01:18:22.563 --> 01:18:27.635
<v Sameer Kanal>The 38%, I think, percent decline in traffic fatalities, I'm very excited Thank you.

755
01:18:27.764 --> 01:18:28.713
<v Sameer Kanal>To see that reported.

756
01:18:28.971 --> 01:18:31.918
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll note here that we still have a lot of work to do in District 2.

757
01:18:34.850 --> 01:18:44.011
<v Sameer Kanal>Pivoting to questions here, I think I was really happy to see that there is a class comp study beginning in response to budget note Kanal 08.

758
01:18:44.430 --> 01:18:53.386
<v Sameer Kanal>I think one of the things that this report has done a great job of, both under previous administrator and yourself, is that when a councilor wrote a budget note, they've been brought in on that.

759
01:18:53.547 --> 01:18:55.952
<v Sameer Kanal>I have not been involved in the Kanal 08 one.

760
01:18:56.891 --> 01:19:10.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Assessing the deputy director classification, looking at whether or not we need so many of the high-level leadership in terms of the org chart and how much like a pair— how wide the base is compared to the top.

761
01:19:11.327 --> 01:19:12.530
<v Sameer Kanal>So we'd love to hear about that.

762
01:19:13.109 --> 01:19:19.082
<v Sameer Kanal>The first I heard about it was the email that went out to all supervisors and managers, and that since the budget note was adopted.

763
01:19:19.131 --> 01:19:20.608
<v Sameer Kanal>So we'd love to talk about that more with you.

764
01:19:20.832 --> 01:19:22.005
<v Jake Antles>Thank you.

765
01:19:22.765 --> 01:19:33.926
<v Sameer Kanal>On the Green 10 amendment, the EMS cut, I was curious, I don't think the original intent was to do 2% by every bureau that was involved in it, but just for the general fund on the whole.

766
01:19:34.457 --> 01:19:37.827
<v Sameer Kanal>Was the guidance given down that every bureau needs to individually do 2%?

767
01:19:38.488 --> 01:19:41.975
<v Sameer Kanal>Was the 2% applied at the service area or citywide level?

768
01:19:44.502 --> 01:19:48.694
<v Raymond C. Lee>I'll ask Jonas to kind of come up and touch upon some of that information.

769
01:19:48.873 --> 01:19:50.807
<v Raymond C. Lee>We've looked at it from 2 different approaches.

770
01:19:51.445 --> 01:19:57.248
<v Raymond C. Lee>We have looked at it from a service level, but also looked at it from the standpoint of looking at departments.

771
01:19:57.314 --> 01:20:01.368
<v Raymond C. Lee>But I'll let Jonas kind of give some further details on what that truly means.

772
01:20:01.481 --> 01:20:07.412
<v Sameer Kanal>Just to save time, I'll ask the second part of the question too here, which is, was a single professional services contract cut?

773
01:20:08.840 --> 01:20:09.993
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor, thank you for the question.

774
01:20:10.042 --> 01:20:12.381
<v Jamie Dunphy>For the record, Jonas Biery, Chief Financial Officer.

775
01:20:12.766 --> 01:20:20.523
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your first question, I don't recall, frankly, at the moment specifically what the guidance was and how it was applied, but happy to follow up and get that to you.

776
01:20:21.090 --> 01:20:28.287
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, and additionally, I, I can't tell you, um, in the details, uh, what they were, but we can certainly work and go back and gather that and provide it to you.

777
01:20:28.382 --> 01:20:29.253
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

778
01:20:29.414 --> 01:20:31.268
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I really appreciate the info on it.

779
01:20:31.429 --> 01:20:35.475
<v Sameer Kanal>I would just, uh, it was a little— that second part was just not clear to me, so I appreciate that.

780
01:20:36.108 --> 01:20:42.738
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, is 20 water main breaks a normal amount for a month in the city?

781
01:20:43.453 --> 01:20:46.984
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that— is there a pattern that you can speak to about the— if that's a high number?

782
01:20:47.033 --> 01:20:47.739
<v Sameer Kanal>Because it seemed high.

783
01:20:48.654 --> 01:20:58.113
<v Raymond C. Lee>And before, uh, DC jumps in on that, I asked that same question in every city I've been in about water main breaks, and a lot of it depends on the season.

784
01:20:58.386 --> 01:21:03.073
<v Raymond C. Lee>We start to see that more in our colder weather seasons, which we're in right now.

785
01:21:04.229 --> 01:21:09.823
<v Raymond C. Lee>As we have aging infrastructure throughout the city, we see this type of incidents happen.

786
01:21:10.743 --> 01:21:22.332
<v Raymond C. Lee>We can probably provide some trend analysis of what we've seen in years past, but from my history and experience, you typically see an uptick in those kind of water breaks during this season of the year.

787
01:21:24.368 --> 01:21:24.819
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thanks.

788
01:21:25.256 --> 01:21:26.658
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you, City Administrator.

789
01:21:26.724 --> 01:21:27.497
<v Priya Dhanapal>I think that's well said.

790
01:21:27.595 --> 01:21:30.932
<v Priya Dhanapal>And this is for the Portland Water Bureau.

791
01:21:30.997 --> 01:21:33.853
<v Priya Dhanapal>This is an average seasonal outcome.

792
01:21:34.430 --> 01:21:38.009
<v Priya Dhanapal>Happy to provide a trend analysis over the past few years if needed.

793
01:21:39.654 --> 01:21:44.863
<v Priya Dhanapal>And exactly for the reasons that City Administrator Lee mentioned, those are the reasons why we have breaks during this time of the year.

794
01:21:45.720 --> 01:21:45.800
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks.

795
01:21:45.849 --> 01:21:47.873
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I don't need anything super detailed.

796
01:21:47.921 --> 01:21:49.429
<v Sameer Kanal>Just, I wanted sort of high level.

797
01:21:49.720 --> 01:21:51.939
<v Sameer Kanal>It seemed high and I appreciate the info there.

798
01:21:53.779 --> 01:21:58.511
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so 2 last questions are both for, I think, for you, City Administrator Lee.

799
01:22:00.488 --> 01:22:12.203
<v Sameer Kanal>One is, when do we expect to hear the next piece of information on the land use violation allegation and process with relation to the ICE McAdam facility?

800
01:22:13.279 --> 01:22:20.009
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll just ask the follow-up right now, and I wanna be clear on that, that I am not asking for the names of individual staffers.

801
01:22:20.381 --> 01:22:21.819
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanna be super clear about that.

802
01:22:22.143 --> 01:22:30.560
<v Sameer Kanal>But which program name or email address, who in the administration can community members direct their input to on this is the other part of the question.

803
01:22:31.427 --> 01:22:33.292
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thanks for the question, Councilor Donnie Oliveira.

804
01:22:33.355 --> 01:22:45.326
<v Donnie Oliveira>For the record, uh, we expect— just for public records, uh, refresher— we are in the— currently in the middle of administrative review of an appeal to the notice of violation for the September land use notice.

805
01:22:46.208 --> 01:22:51.335
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, the attorneys for the building owner, uh, appealed that violation.

806
01:22:51.993 --> 01:22:59.681
<v Donnie Oliveira>There was a meeting at the end of December where they presented essentially their Their, um, their findings about why we should revoke the administrative violation.

807
01:23:00.260 --> 01:23:09.387
<v Donnie Oliveira>So staff and city attorneys are completing that review of that, those findings, and we'll make a determination by the end of this week on that appeal of our violation.

808
01:23:09.966 --> 01:23:17.586
<v Donnie Oliveira>That just will set off another scenario where the attorneys for the building can take action, and we'll follow up with counsel on those steps.

809
01:23:17.715 --> 01:23:19.414
<v Donnie Oliveira>So that's the first question.

810
01:23:19.511 --> 01:23:20.667
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we are moving forward with that process.

811
01:23:20.715 --> 01:23:20.827
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

812
01:23:21.212 --> 01:23:23.396
<v Sameer Kanal>And that piece at the end of this week will be public?

813
01:23:23.685 --> 01:23:23.878
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

814
01:23:24.039 --> 01:23:24.778
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thanks.

815
01:23:25.372 --> 01:23:27.429
<v Donnie Oliveira>And then, so that's that step right there.

816
01:23:27.637 --> 01:23:34.336
<v Donnie Oliveira>And then to your second question of who can the public talk to about this process, is that essentially the question?

817
01:23:35.091 --> 01:23:36.873
<v Sameer Kanal>About, yes, yes.

818
01:23:37.018 --> 01:23:40.938
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, I'd like to get back to you then and send that out maybe more publicly.

819
01:23:41.354 --> 01:23:46.494
<v Donnie Oliveira>We do have an email that the Bureau of the Permitting and Development Bureau has to take incoming questions and complaints.

820
01:23:46.895 --> 01:23:48.243
<v Donnie Oliveira>So I want to honor the distinction.

821
01:23:48.341 --> 01:23:52.577
<v Donnie Oliveira>If people have a complaint they want to file, we want people to continue to do that, to catch that formally.

822
01:23:53.314 --> 01:23:57.662
<v Donnie Oliveira>If the public's interested in just an update and clarity of what's happening, that's probably a different email.

823
01:23:57.728 --> 01:24:01.194
<v Donnie Oliveira>I'd like to get back to the, you know, to you, the administrator, so we can make that public.

824
01:24:01.675 --> 01:24:16.269
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, and I'm going to ask a question I've asked before, but it's because I got an email with, uh, or I got a video sent to me overnight of a Portland Permitting and Development employee standing outside of a building talking to protesters saying that council is responsible for the next step in this process.

825
01:24:16.849 --> 01:24:22.554
<v Sameer Kanal>Between council and the administration, who is currently responsible for the current step in the process on the land use violation process?

826
01:24:23.076 --> 01:24:24.381
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, that's permitting development.

827
01:24:24.930 --> 01:24:26.301
<v Donnie Oliveira>I, I'd love to see that video.

828
01:24:26.399 --> 01:24:28.221
<v Sameer Kanal>I just got it overnight, or I would have given you a heads up on it.

829
01:24:28.335 --> 01:24:29.368
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry to put you on the spot.

830
01:24:29.448 --> 01:24:29.802
<v Jake Antles>I appreciate it.

831
01:24:29.868 --> 01:24:31.078
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll happily send it your way.

832
01:24:31.319 --> 01:24:31.480
<v Loretta Smith>Yep.

833
01:24:31.787 --> 01:24:35.088
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, and then the last question I had is more of a request for next time.

834
01:24:35.671 --> 01:24:43.498
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I would love to start getting some information on contracts, specifically the long-term And if you wanna start with the really big ones, I would totally understand that.

835
01:24:43.563 --> 01:24:44.960
<v Sameer Kanal>I know this is an iterative process.

836
01:24:46.051 --> 01:24:54.546
<v Sameer Kanal>Contracts, because one of the things that happened last year is in the budget, we were leading up to the budget, we were told if it's a short-term contract, the mayor can just do it.

837
01:24:55.042 --> 01:25:00.582
<v Sameer Kanal>But if we get to, if it goes crossing the fiscal year, then it's gonna be approved in the budget.

838
01:25:00.646 --> 01:25:05.784
<v Sameer Kanal>But the way that the budget was presented did not separate out the list of contracts.

839
01:25:06.604 --> 01:25:13.417
<v Sameer Kanal>And because we do decision package-based budgeting, if it was effectively— it was, it was not in the documentation unless you knew where to look.

840
01:25:13.914 --> 01:25:16.100
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I would love to have a list of those contracts.

841
01:25:16.421 --> 01:25:25.899
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you wanted to start with the over $1 million ones, I would totally understand, to try and give us the clarity we need to be able to assess those in the budget process.

842
01:25:26.445 --> 01:25:27.329
<v Raymond C. Lee>We can accommodate that.

843
01:25:27.811 --> 01:25:28.310
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much.

844
01:25:28.695 --> 01:25:29.578
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

845
01:25:29.724 --> 01:25:30.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

846
01:25:30.768 --> 01:25:43.393
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Councilor Kanal, thank you also for calling out The ongoing question about budget note, specifically development colleagues, if there are other future budget notes that you all have questions about, this is a great venue for us to have those conversations about.

847
01:25:43.472 --> 01:25:48.492
<v Jamie Dunphy>So if we happen to, you know, if there's something you're waiting for, bring it up here or do it privately also.

848
01:25:49.534 --> 01:25:51.490
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane, are you still in the queue?

849
01:25:51.731 --> 01:25:52.485
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, Councilor Green.

850
01:25:53.319 --> 01:25:53.591
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

851
01:25:53.640 --> 01:25:58.371
<v Mitch Green>Just briefly, because Councilor Kanal, you touched on the water main breaks.

852
01:25:58.917 --> 01:26:05.521
<v Mitch Green>I think it's a good question to ask, but I also want to uplift and call out the excellent work by the Public Works service area.

853
01:26:05.601 --> 01:26:24.128
<v Mitch Green>This earlier last month on January 10th, there was a pretty significant water main break in my district on Southwest First Avenue that was restored very fast, and there was a lot of complicated work that went into it across the service area, and I never had a want for information on that.

854
01:26:24.242 --> 01:26:28.345
<v Mitch Green>Because our new One Water Director, Ting Lu, kept us up to speed every step of the way.

855
01:26:28.408 --> 01:26:29.739
<v Mitch Green>So kudos to your team.

856
01:26:30.252 --> 01:26:30.748
<v Mitch Green>Keep it up.

857
01:26:30.829 --> 01:26:33.137
<v Mitch Green>I think that that helps me communicate with my constituents.

858
01:26:33.538 --> 01:26:33.890
<v Bob Weinstein>Thanks.

859
01:26:34.579 --> 01:26:35.318
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

860
01:26:35.462 --> 01:26:36.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

861
01:26:36.984 --> 01:26:38.811
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

862
01:26:39.372 --> 01:26:41.890
<v Dan Ryan>I, um, much of what I was going to say has been said.

863
01:26:41.938 --> 01:26:42.563
<v Dan Ryan>I won't repeat it.

864
01:26:42.755 --> 01:26:48.975
<v Dan Ryan>I well acknowledge that I appreciated the details from Vision Zero, and, uh, I wanted to ask a question.

865
01:26:49.471 --> 01:26:51.458
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, Dan, I really appreciated the details.

866
01:26:52.076 --> 01:26:55.101
<v Dan Ryan>We had a meeting with you specifically, and that was helpful as well.

867
01:26:56.186 --> 01:27:03.399
<v Dan Ryan>Is the impairment information only about alcohol, correct?

868
01:27:06.931 --> 01:27:08.442
<v Priya Dhanapal>Councilor Ryan, thank you for the question.

869
01:27:08.555 --> 01:27:10.260
<v Priya Dhanapal>I'm going to have to get back to you on that.

870
01:27:11.234 --> 01:27:13.717
<v Priya Dhanapal>Dana Dickman will be getting back to you with more information.

871
01:27:14.199 --> 01:27:14.247
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

872
01:27:14.313 --> 01:27:18.658
<v Dan Ryan>And I know I sent an email, and if you did get back, I haven't heard the details on that yet, so thank you.

873
01:27:18.707 --> 01:27:19.525
<v Dan Ryan>That's why I asked.

874
01:27:19.654 --> 01:27:24.520
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I do think it's important that we have information that goes beyond alcohol.

875
01:27:24.648 --> 01:27:29.835
<v Dan Ryan>We need, I think, toxicology reports that give us the information on impairment that could go into substance abuse.

876
01:27:30.412 --> 01:27:36.417
<v Dan Ryan>This is just so, um, for substances, we just need information, and so it leaves, um, less guessing.

877
01:27:36.914 --> 01:27:37.943
<v Dan Ryan>And this is on all parties.

878
01:27:38.296 --> 01:27:39.355
<v Dan Ryan>It just is really helpful.

879
01:27:39.420 --> 01:27:44.635
<v Dan Ryan>So when you see only the impairment was alcohol, I just thought that part was And so I do appreciate that.

880
01:27:45.051 --> 01:27:45.452
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

881
01:27:45.595 --> 01:27:52.646
<v Dan Ryan>On a budget note that was passed, I just want to lift Victor, who was at Parks, is now overseeing the Storefront Program.

882
01:27:52.967 --> 01:27:55.354
<v Dan Ryan>He delivered a really wonderful report yesterday.

883
01:27:55.707 --> 01:28:01.140
<v Dan Ryan>I'm looking at the colleagues in the Economic Development Committee, and there's so much momentum.

884
01:28:01.364 --> 01:28:07.470
<v Dan Ryan>And the best part of it is the people who own storefronts, who are part of the community, are really being listened to.

885
01:28:07.662 --> 01:28:08.287
<v Dan Ryan>So their voices are being heard.

886
01:28:09.957 --> 01:28:16.015
<v Dan Ryan>My experience since I've been here at times is that the reports are too insider and we don't have the community voice.

887
01:28:16.465 --> 01:28:18.505
<v Dan Ryan>And so it was really refreshing to actually see that.

888
01:28:19.034 --> 01:28:28.573
<v Dan Ryan>And so I know that this will continue to have tension with that, those bodies at the table, but that's definitely a more— that's a product that everyone can get behind.

889
01:28:28.867 --> 01:28:29.355
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you.

890
01:28:29.421 --> 01:28:30.269
<v Dan Ryan>I wanted to lift that.

891
01:28:31.443 --> 01:28:32.291
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

892
01:28:33.920 --> 01:28:39.896
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, Can we please call item number 6?

893
01:28:39.945 --> 01:28:40.728
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, City Administrator.

894
01:28:45.811 --> 01:29:00.162
<v Keelan McClymont>Add nondiscrimination requirements for single occupant restrooms in Places of Public Accommodation Code to establish equal restroom access by requiring gender, gender-neutral signage at Code Section 23.01.071.

895
01:29:03.515 --> 01:29:06.252
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the second reading of an ordinance.

896
01:29:06.574 --> 01:29:08.748
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there any further discussion on this item?

897
01:29:13.756 --> 01:29:16.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing none, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

898
01:29:16.577 --> 01:29:16.885
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

899
01:29:18.359 --> 01:29:18.538
<v Jonathan Ader>Aye.

900
01:29:20.322 --> 01:29:20.855
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

901
01:29:21.195 --> 01:29:21.810
<v Dan Ryan>Absent.

902
01:29:22.184 --> 01:29:22.443
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

903
01:29:23.625 --> 01:29:23.640
<v Ashley Plauschay>Aye.

904
01:29:24.353 --> 01:29:25.033
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

905
01:29:25.487 --> 01:29:25.615
<v Lee Armstrong>Aye.

906
01:29:26.149 --> 01:29:26.604
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

907
01:29:28.505 --> 01:29:28.520
<v Ashley Plauschay>Aye.

908
01:29:30.099 --> 01:29:30.146
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Aye.

909
01:29:31.220 --> 01:29:31.561
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

910
01:29:32.863 --> 01:29:32.912
<v Heidi Brown>Aye.

911
01:29:34.320 --> 01:29:34.368
<v Donnie Oliveira>Aye.

912
01:29:39.563 --> 01:29:50.100
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.

913
01:29:50.574 --> 01:29:51.195
<v Jamie Dunphy>Amazing.

914
01:29:52.029 --> 01:30:01.064
<v Keelan McClymont>Can we please call item number Add appointed boards, commissions, and committees code.

915
01:30:01.274 --> 01:30:03.190
<v Keelan McClymont>Add Code Chapter 3.40.

916
01:30:05.154 --> 01:30:09.484
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

917
01:30:09.694 --> 01:30:12.796
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there any further discussion on our appointed boards and commissions?

918
01:30:16.467 --> 01:30:18.743
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no further hands in the queue, could we please call the roll?

919
01:30:22.750 --> 01:30:22.783
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

920
01:30:22.846 --> 01:30:24.850
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith, absent.

921
01:30:25.738 --> 01:30:28.854
<v Sameer Kanal>So sorry, I was trying to get to the thing, so I'm just going to be very brief.

922
01:30:29.420 --> 01:30:30.448
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm very supportive of this.

923
01:30:30.802 --> 01:30:35.854
<v Sameer Kanal>I do intend to continue the conversation about where it can go further, which was, I think, a lot of the conversation last time.

924
01:30:35.967 --> 01:30:36.693
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'll be voting aye.

925
01:30:36.773 --> 01:30:37.240
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

926
01:30:40.389 --> 01:30:40.438
<v Ashley Plauschay>Aye.

927
01:30:41.697 --> 01:30:41.729
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

928
01:30:43.213 --> 01:30:43.229
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

929
01:30:45.157 --> 01:30:45.204
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

930
01:30:45.820 --> 01:30:46.095
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

931
01:30:47.100 --> 01:30:47.149
<v Raymond C. Lee>Aye.

932
01:30:47.748 --> 01:30:48.088
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

933
01:30:48.396 --> 01:30:48.445
<v Lee Armstrong>Aye.

934
01:30:48.979 --> 01:30:49.190
<v Unidentified speaker>Green?

935
01:30:49.612 --> 01:30:49.791
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

936
01:30:50.050 --> 01:30:50.454
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

937
01:30:50.908 --> 01:30:50.957
<v Heidi Brown>Aye.

938
01:30:51.507 --> 01:30:51.832
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

939
01:30:53.619 --> 01:30:53.636
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

940
01:30:54.550 --> 01:30:58.384
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.

941
01:31:02.363 --> 01:31:02.783
<v Eric Engstrom>Excellent.

942
01:31:02.849 --> 01:31:14.456
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number— actually, uh, I'm going to use this as an opportunity to, to give everybody on the council a A bio break and take a brief ten-minute recess.

943
01:31:15.895 --> 01:31:16.784
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will reconvene.

944
01:43:38.654 --> 01:43:39.653
<v Raymond C. Lee>And we're back.

945
01:43:41.997 --> 01:43:43.226
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 8?

946
01:43:46.800 --> 01:43:57.697
<v Keelan McClymont>Accept removals from Community Board for Police Accountability recommended by administration due to ineligibility and cause, and appoint alternates to vacancies.

947
01:44:00.739 --> 01:44:01.158
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

948
01:44:01.256 --> 01:44:07.506
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, uh, first, uh, item on this, I would like to try and take up a technical amendment first.

949
01:44:07.555 --> 01:44:10.635
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to offer a technical amendment that is before us.

950
01:44:10.974 --> 01:44:19.926
<v Jamie Dunphy>Specifically, we learned that one additional alternate to the CBPA has resigned as of Sunday this week.

951
01:44:20.488 --> 01:44:33.327
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I have a technical amendment that is pre-filed called Dunphy 2, specifically adds language to just add that one additional alternate, Jason Ashley, also resigned and updates within the—.

952
01:44:33.408 --> 01:44:33.782
<v Claire Adamsick>Scandal.

953
01:44:36.085 --> 01:44:41.215
<v Jamie Dunphy>Makes the proper corrections throughout the remainder of the document to reflect that this individual has resigned.

954
01:44:41.296 --> 01:44:41.552
<v Priya Dhanapal>Second.

955
01:44:42.277 --> 01:44:42.679
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

956
01:44:43.338 --> 01:44:44.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that has been moved and seconded.

957
01:44:46.814 --> 01:44:55.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we also have a number of other amendments on the floor and some questions about where we are at this exact moment on this item.

958
01:44:59.154 --> 01:45:06.734
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to First look to our city attorney and see if she has any additional updates for— come on up, Heidi.

959
01:45:09.082 --> 01:45:12.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, uh, Heidi Brown is here.

960
01:45:15.207 --> 01:45:15.529
<v Lee Armstrong>Thank you.

961
01:45:15.787 --> 01:45:16.722
<v Heidi Brown>Good morning, Council.

962
01:45:17.141 --> 01:45:21.835
<v Heidi Brown>Council President, uh, Council, Heidi Brown, uh, City Attorney's Office.

963
01:45:22.829 --> 01:45:24.046
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, sorry.

964
01:45:25.311 --> 01:45:41.952
<v Heidi Brown>So one thing to update you on is that, uh, Yesterday I did take a look at the nondisclosure agreement, confidentiality agreement that we had drafted, and I made some narrowing of it to address— in an attempt to address Mr. Weinstein's concerns.

965
01:45:42.692 --> 01:46:02.555
<v Heidi Brown>It originally stated that any and all information they received would remain confidential, and instead what I did was I took the language that we have that applies under our administrative rules To our city employees, which is that confidential and restricted information would remain that way.

966
01:46:03.261 --> 01:46:04.095
<v Heidi Brown>And I added that in.

967
01:46:04.302 --> 01:46:24.953
<v Heidi Brown>I did also add in privileged information to be clear that we were talking about attorney-client privileged information because that is where, that's the sole area where we seem to be in disagreement between Mr. Weinstein and our office is around the disclosure of what our office views as attorney-client privileged information.

968
01:46:25.082 --> 01:46:25.291
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

969
01:46:26.582 --> 01:46:34.998
<v Heidi Brown>So I think Mr. Weinstein's fine with release, keeping confidential discipline information, investigation files, and all that information.

970
01:46:36.756 --> 01:46:45.314
<v Heidi Brown>And I also wanted to be clear that there are training materials that, as I said last week, I'm happy to disclose that only reference the law.

971
01:46:46.319 --> 01:46:53.996
<v Heidi Brown>The portions that reference our interpretation of the law are the portions that I would want to redact and not disclose.

972
01:46:54.045 --> 01:46:54.109
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

973
01:46:55.729 --> 01:47:12.947
<v Heidi Brown>So, and just to be clear about why that is, you know, given the board's job is to review investigative allegations of police misconduct and make determinations about whether there was misconduct, and if so, what's an appropriate level of discipline.

974
01:47:13.729 --> 01:47:20.698
<v Heidi Brown>And then from there, you know, we want to be able to uphold that discipline where it's warranted.

975
01:47:21.716 --> 01:47:27.085
<v Heidi Brown>And appropriate, that's very important for this Board from my perspective, 'cause I don't want it overturned.

976
01:47:27.725 --> 01:47:35.722
<v Heidi Brown>And if we disclose attorney-client privileged information, that will make it very challenging to uphold discipline.

977
01:47:36.716 --> 01:47:44.296
<v Heidi Brown>So that just in summary is where we are, is that I did suggest some alternative language.

978
01:47:45.034 --> 01:47:51.237
<v Heidi Brown>I'll let Mr. Weinstein respond to that broadly if he wants to, but just I can tell you narrowly that he was not satisfied.

979
01:47:51.284 --> 01:47:51.444
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

980
01:47:53.979 --> 01:47:54.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you very much.

981
01:47:55.206 --> 01:47:55.560
<v Heidi Brown>Thank you.

982
01:47:56.497 --> 01:48:03.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, colleagues, before we dive into the substance, I'd like to get Dunphy 2 just out of the way, if that is acceptable.

983
01:48:03.818 --> 01:48:06.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, this is a hopefully non-controversial technical amendment.

984
01:48:07.167 --> 01:48:11.369
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, unless there's any objection, I'd like to move to call the roll on that.

985
01:48:11.916 --> 01:48:14.823
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no objection, could we please call the roll on Dunphy 2?

986
01:48:16.215 --> 01:48:16.451
<v Claire Adamsick>Avalos.

987
01:48:17.057 --> 01:48:17.091
<v Heidi Brown>Aye.

988
01:48:17.984 --> 01:48:18.341
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oops, aye.

989
01:48:20.604 --> 01:48:22.475
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, absent.

990
01:48:22.605 --> 01:48:22.654
<v Ashley Plauschay>Aye.

991
01:48:24.301 --> 01:48:24.430
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

992
01:48:27.115 --> 01:48:27.164
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

993
01:48:29.448 --> 01:48:29.497
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

994
01:48:34.229 --> 01:48:34.601
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

995
01:48:36.073 --> 01:48:36.122
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

996
01:48:36.882 --> 01:48:37.189
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

997
01:48:37.934 --> 01:48:38.032
<v Lee Armstrong>Aye.

998
01:48:38.921 --> 01:48:42.006
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.

999
01:48:42.332 --> 01:48:43.032
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

1000
01:48:43.292 --> 01:48:44.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Moving to the queue, Councilor Kanal.

1001
01:48:45.427 --> 01:48:46.304
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mr. President.

1002
01:48:46.466 --> 01:48:49.856
<v Sameer Kanal>I move to divide the question on the report as follows.

1003
01:48:50.930 --> 01:49:14.134
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, it would be, uh, into 3 separate votes, one on everything that's not removed, uh, separated out, and the other 2 are— I'm pulling up the file here— um, to remove the, the line about Mr. Halsey And separately to remove the lines about Mr. Weinstein.

1004
01:49:14.181 --> 01:49:15.685
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm going to be very specific here.

1005
01:49:18.380 --> 01:49:20.067
<v Sameer Kanal>And sorry, I haven't closed the right tab here.

1006
01:49:20.179 --> 01:49:34.328
<v Sameer Kanal>So the first would be to separate out for a separate vote the second to last line prior to the table that begins Member Skyler Hugh Halsey, as well as the second line of the table for its own vote.

1007
01:49:34.442 --> 01:49:34.650
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

1008
01:49:36.292 --> 01:49:45.462
<v Sameer Kanal>A second vote would be held on the final line before the table, alternate Bob Weinstein, etc., and the 4th line of the table that also has Bob Weinstein's name.

1009
01:49:46.796 --> 01:49:48.770
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the 3rd vote would be on everything else.

1010
01:49:50.233 --> 01:49:58.889
<v Sameer Kanal>So we would have a vote on just accepting the resignations and all of that as a report, and then separately weigh the discussion on each of the 2 people separately.

1011
01:49:58.984 --> 01:50:08.546
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'd like to request the order be that, um, The Skyler Halsey part goes before the Bob Weinstein part, and I defer to you if you'd prefer to have the everything else part at the beginning or end.

1012
01:50:10.340 --> 01:50:16.123
<v Mitch Green>A point of information, just because it's going to happen a lot over the next hour or so, it's, it's Bob Weinstein.

1013
01:50:16.412 --> 01:50:16.654
<v Deborah Hayman>I think—.

1014
01:50:16.654 --> 01:50:17.377
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, I'm so sorry.

1015
01:50:17.440 --> 01:50:21.626
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, no, everyone's done it, but I, um, I haven't had an opportunity to correct everyone on that.

1016
01:50:21.706 --> 01:50:22.012
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1017
01:50:23.643 --> 01:50:23.868
<v Jamie Dunphy>Linley.

1018
01:50:24.192 --> 01:50:31.782
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, Council President, I just want to make sure when we divide the motion, what you're doing is voting on the underlying motion in separate parts.

1019
01:50:31.958 --> 01:50:45.372
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the framing of the 2 separated parts, I believe, would be, should Person A be removed, not should we take them out of the existing report.

1020
01:50:45.500 --> 01:50:47.167
<v Unidentified speaker>That would, that would be an amendment.

1021
01:50:47.586 --> 01:50:51.564
<v Unidentified speaker>But dividing the motion is, should we remove Person A, should we remove Person B.

1022
01:50:51.773 --> 01:50:59.494
<v Sameer Kanal>To clarify, that means that when we get to these 2 parts, A yes vote would involve removing the person from the board or as an alternate.

1023
01:50:59.753 --> 01:51:01.274
<v Sameer Kanal>A no vote would be to retain them.

1024
01:51:02.576 --> 01:51:04.033
<v Jamie Dunphy>Correct.

1025
01:51:04.551 --> 01:51:04.891
<v Addie Smith>Okay.

1026
01:51:05.814 --> 01:51:22.755
<v Jamie Dunphy>And just so I'm getting it through my thick skull, functionally we would be voting on the text of the entire thing minus the parts that you— that were pulled out, the names specifically, and then we would independently be going back and voting on The names individually?

1027
01:51:22.980 --> 01:51:23.255
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1028
01:51:25.014 --> 01:51:25.159
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1029
01:51:25.239 --> 01:51:26.030
<v Candace Avalos>Point of information.

1030
01:51:27.015 --> 01:51:30.777
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I understand that, but I guess can you just walk me one more time?

1031
01:51:30.824 --> 01:51:36.421
<v Candace Avalos>Because each of these 4 options are each of these scenarios.

1032
01:51:36.533 --> 01:51:37.484
<v Sameer Kanal>That's for the resolution.

1033
01:51:37.823 --> 01:51:39.210
<v Candace Avalos>Oh shoot, now I'm confused.

1034
01:51:39.890 --> 01:51:41.850
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, so say it one more time then, please.

1035
01:51:43.770 --> 01:51:57.809
<v Sameer Kanal>So my— the request for a division would mean that we vote on The parts of the report that have not been currently found controversial, parts related to resignations, the updating information, walking through how CEJIS happened, all that.

1036
01:51:58.658 --> 01:52:06.587
<v Sameer Kanal>Then we would vote on Skyler Halsey, where a yes vote would be to remove Skyler Halsey and a no vote would be to retain Skyler Halsey.

1037
01:52:07.582 --> 01:52:13.632
<v Sameer Kanal>And then we would vote on Bob Weinstein, where a yes vote would be to remove and a no vote would be to retain.

1038
01:52:13.680 --> 01:52:13.824
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1039
01:52:13.960 --> 01:52:15.737
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that accurate, the attorneys?

1040
01:52:16.884 --> 01:52:17.014
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1041
01:52:19.307 --> 01:52:20.876
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1042
01:52:23.090 --> 01:52:23.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>Wait, Councilor Zimmerman.

1043
01:52:24.983 --> 01:52:34.542
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think you just said a yes vote would be to remove, but that's the opposite, exact opposite of what the attorney had just said, which is a no vote.

1044
01:52:34.623 --> 01:52:36.676
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to let them confirm.

1045
01:52:38.082 --> 01:52:45.519
<v Eric Zimmerman>Takes them out of— because The vote is to keep their name in the report or not, and a no vote would basically say the name is removed.

1046
01:52:46.047 --> 01:52:50.635
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I just want to clarify because I think you guys just said opposite things here.

1047
01:52:51.340 --> 01:52:56.889
<v Sameer Kanal>Well, we're gonna, we're gonna have the discussion before we get to the vote, so I'm gonna let— I think we should let them confer and then explain it.

1048
01:52:57.208 --> 01:52:58.283
<v Sameer Kanal>But we'll make sure— I'm—.

1049
01:52:58.475 --> 01:52:58.492
<v Loretta Smith>I—.

1050
01:52:58.813 --> 01:53:04.746
<v Sameer Kanal>In the scenario of a division, my understanding is that a yes vote would be removing this person.

1051
01:53:05.707 --> 01:53:15.367
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, a yes vote would be The report, how the report frames that person, which is in those 2 instances it would be removal for cause.

1052
01:53:15.804 --> 01:53:19.483
<v Sameer Kanal>And a no vote would be retaining them as a member or alternate respectively.

1053
01:53:19.822 --> 01:53:20.208
<v Loretta Smith>Correct.

1054
01:53:20.403 --> 01:53:21.435
<v Unidentified speaker>And I put— I misstated.

1055
01:53:21.532 --> 01:53:23.837
<v Unidentified speaker>One is removal for cause, one is ineligibility.

1056
01:53:24.840 --> 01:53:25.323
<v Unidentified speaker>So just—.

1057
01:53:27.110 --> 01:53:28.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Point of information, Council President.

1058
01:53:29.445 --> 01:53:46.393
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm hoping that the councilor can explain why he's Suggesting this approach as opposed to doing this by amendment, just so that we can understand if there's— what the rationale is for approaching it this way, given that there had been discussion about amendments to do these things as well.

1059
01:53:48.033 --> 01:53:51.893
<v Jamie Dunphy>There— I can tell you that my— this came from at least partially from me.

1060
01:53:52.456 --> 01:54:08.438
<v Jamie Dunphy>The City Attorney's Office has been conferring about whether the right path forward is to do a series of serial amendments to try and remove and then re-add language versus what I think is a relatively more straightforward process of dividing the question before us.

1061
01:54:09.463 --> 01:54:11.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>So this came at my recommendation.

1062
01:54:11.917 --> 01:54:14.081
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for that clarification.

1063
01:54:14.176 --> 01:54:16.693
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman, did you get everything in your—.

1064
01:54:16.981 --> 01:54:19.514
<v Eric Zimmerman>I still have a— I have one request on it, or one question.

1065
01:54:20.106 --> 01:54:21.212
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

1066
01:54:22.496 --> 01:54:27.112
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would prefer a different order to your questions, Councilor Kanal.

1067
01:54:27.930 --> 01:54:35.619
<v Eric Zimmerman>Voting on the overall report before I know what's in it, if the votes, the separated questions don't go the way that I think, I may not support the overall.

1068
01:54:35.972 --> 01:54:42.507
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I would, I would offer actually that the overall report should be voted upon after we know the contents of it.

1069
01:54:43.213 --> 01:54:52.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>That would be, um, otherwise I think I would have to vote no against that report because as it stands right now, um, there are names that I don't agree with being included in the report.

1070
01:54:52.783 --> 01:55:02.398
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's my I'm happy to go with Skylar Halsey, followed by Bob Weinstein, followed by the full remaining parts of the report.

1071
01:55:02.640 --> 01:55:09.453
<v Sameer Kanal>My request would be that we discuss these together just because there is some conversation that I think might overlap here.

1072
01:55:10.676 --> 01:55:12.081
<v Sameer Kanal>And then when we get to the votes, do it.

1073
01:55:12.145 --> 01:55:13.115
<v Sameer Kanal>But I defer to you.

1074
01:55:13.502 --> 01:55:15.021
<v Jamie Dunphy>That sounds good.

1075
01:55:15.135 --> 01:55:17.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm checking with our city attorneys to make sure we're okay.

1076
01:55:18.350 --> 01:55:18.609
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1077
01:55:19.649 --> 01:55:28.757
<v Jamie Dunphy>The order will be— the division of the question will be that we are going to vote on the removal of Skylar Halsey.

1078
01:55:29.449 --> 01:55:36.543
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will vote on the removal of Bob Weinstein, and we will vote on the overall report before us.

1079
01:55:36.786 --> 01:55:37.416
<v Jamie Dunphy>Does that sound right?

1080
01:55:38.770 --> 01:55:41.833
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, we're moving to council discussion.

1081
01:55:47.238 --> 01:55:49.101
<v Jamie Dunphy>Anybody have further discussion about this?

1082
01:55:49.149 --> 01:55:50.113
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman, are you still in the queue?

1083
01:55:50.210 --> 01:55:50.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great, please.

1084
01:55:52.041 --> 01:55:52.587
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, colleagues.

1085
01:55:52.699 --> 01:56:11.042
<v Eric Zimmerman>Last week we heard from a number of testimonies, and one of the requests that I had made was that the bias information be included in the council documents so that we have an understanding for, uh, both the information we were hearing from public testimony but also a sense of what are we talking about when it comes to bias.

1086
01:56:11.934 --> 01:56:13.030
<v Eric Zimmerman>That was not included.

1087
01:56:13.144 --> 01:56:21.951
<v Eric Zimmerman>You've since been emailed that by the city administration, and I have sent it to the council clerk for inclusion into the record.

1088
01:56:23.643 --> 01:56:26.525
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just going to say that again because I know they're doing 2 things at once here.

1089
01:56:26.686 --> 01:56:31.252
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've sent that to the council clerk for inclusion into the record, the bias information.

1090
01:56:32.162 --> 01:56:39.873
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I just wanted to clarify that because I've, I've been asked a few times since my request last week why it wasn't included, and I think it just got missed.

1091
01:56:39.970 --> 01:56:46.427
<v Eric Zimmerman>So now it is in all your email boxes from the staff and headed to the council clerk to include in this agenda item.

1092
01:56:46.509 --> 01:56:46.768
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1093
01:56:47.350 --> 01:56:48.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1094
01:56:50.243 --> 01:56:53.039
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, any further conversation?

1095
01:56:53.461 --> 01:56:55.944
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, Councilor Avalos.

1096
01:56:56.395 --> 01:56:58.475
<v Candace Avalos>Oh, maybe a question first.

1097
01:56:58.555 --> 01:57:01.828
<v Candace Avalos>So as far as process, we are on the report.

1098
01:57:03.292 --> 01:57:06.599
<v Candace Avalos>What are like— because you were about to be like, we're gonna go into a vote.

1099
01:57:06.728 --> 01:57:07.836
<v Candace Avalos>What would have that vote been?

1100
01:57:08.189 --> 01:57:08.412
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Or no?

1101
01:57:08.654 --> 01:57:10.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh no, council discussion first.

1102
01:57:10.740 --> 01:57:17.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, but the order of the votes will be that we will vote on, uh, the inclusion of, uh, Skyler Halsey.

1103
01:57:17.578 --> 01:57:20.484
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will vote on the inclusion of Bob Weinstein.

1104
01:57:21.015 --> 01:57:24.001
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will vote on the underlying amended report.

1105
01:57:25.043 --> 01:57:26.938
<v Candace Avalos>And so right now we're in discussion broadly?

1106
01:57:27.211 --> 01:57:27.452
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1107
01:57:27.676 --> 01:57:30.518
<v Candace Avalos>But then do we need to move any of these amendments or No.

1108
01:57:30.582 --> 01:57:34.037
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because we divided the question, it is just a procedural vote.

1109
01:57:34.279 --> 01:57:36.337
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, why don't I— I'll get back in the queue after.

1110
01:57:36.400 --> 01:57:37.591
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let me get my mind right.

1111
01:57:37.880 --> 01:57:38.073
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks.

1112
01:57:38.154 --> 01:57:38.716
<v Loretta Smith>Great, thank you.

1113
01:57:38.989 --> 01:57:41.009
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1114
01:57:41.363 --> 01:57:41.606
<v Bob Weinstein>Thank you.

1115
01:57:41.703 --> 01:57:49.756
<v Mitch Green>So, so we're— anything germane to these 3 divisions, or I guess 2 divisions technically, is, is free for debate?

1116
01:57:50.063 --> 01:57:52.817
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, yeah, or, or discussion of the underlying report as well.

1117
01:57:53.203 --> 01:57:54.009
<v Mitch Green>Okay, great.

1118
01:57:54.170 --> 01:58:03.587
<v Mitch Green>Um, I want to speak to the, um, The suggestion that Skyler Halsey be removed, um, I do see the evidence that has been attached.

1119
01:58:04.493 --> 01:58:27.194
<v Mitch Green>It is in my inbox, and I think from what I can parse here, the primary reason why this person was, um, uh, concluded to be, uh, um, exhibiting bias is the repost of an ACAB meme, but That is a trans rights meme on the internet.

1120
01:58:27.596 --> 01:58:33.278
<v Mitch Green>That is, all capybaras are beautiful, and it has the trans flag in it.

1121
01:58:33.599 --> 01:58:40.771
<v Mitch Green>And if you know what context is in the case of, like, memes, you'll know that this is not about police.

1122
01:58:41.719 --> 01:58:49.326
<v Mitch Green>So if that's the case, I think that that's frankly a misreading of the social media context around this.

1123
01:58:49.421 --> 01:58:51.926
<v Mitch Green>The rest of them are, I think, fairly reasonable reposts of things that have been said.

1124
01:58:51.989 --> 01:58:52.663
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a misreading.

1125
01:58:52.439 --> 01:58:57.998
<v Mitch Green>Posts that anyone who is advocating for police accountability would do.

1126
01:58:58.176 --> 01:59:05.002
<v Mitch Green>I mean, I have done memes like these myself, and I don't think that I would be confused or associated with bias here.

1127
01:59:06.470 --> 01:59:15.391
<v Mitch Green>So for that reason, I think it was inappropriate to remove Skyler from the list, and I'll be voting, I guess, no on that item for this.

1128
01:59:16.488 --> 01:59:19.402
<v Mitch Green>So if you don't know, the all-cappy Bears are beautiful meme.

1129
01:59:19.497 --> 01:59:20.940
<v Mitch Green>You need to Google that right now.

1130
01:59:21.261 --> 01:59:21.630
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1131
01:59:22.399 --> 01:59:23.248
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1132
01:59:23.440 --> 01:59:24.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark.

1133
01:59:25.429 --> 01:59:27.015
<v Olivia Clark>Um, thank you, Mr. President.

1134
01:59:27.912 --> 01:59:58.117
<v Olivia Clark>Um, as we've wrestled this to the ground, it seems to me that maybe we're not going to do it today, but I do think we should come back and try to clarify even more what's in the NDA, especially around the training, the kinds of things that Heidi said on the dais, even though I know she's worked hard to try to clarify some of this, it's not clear enough for me around the training issue.

1135
01:59:59.193 --> 02:00:06.627
<v Olivia Clark>And there are laws that are discussed in training, but there's also, as she said, an interpretation of the law.

1136
02:00:06.836 --> 02:00:10.770
<v Olivia Clark>I think that should be highlighted and, and pulled out.

1137
02:00:11.720 --> 02:00:17.445
<v Olivia Clark>My sense is that the accountability board is supposed to be a neutral body.

1138
02:00:18.109 --> 02:00:27.832
<v Olivia Clark>And with all due respect to Councilor Green, I'm not convinced that reposting is neutral.

1139
02:00:28.864 --> 02:00:31.073
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm concerned about that.

1140
02:00:31.122 --> 02:00:34.101
<v Olivia Clark>I really thought the board was supposed to be a neutral body.

1141
02:00:34.247 --> 02:00:35.261
<v Olivia Clark>So I'll just leave it at that.

1142
02:00:36.438 --> 02:00:37.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Clark.

1143
02:00:37.791 --> 02:00:38.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

1144
02:00:39.345 --> 02:00:43.408
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you for helping me, uh, get clear on the process.

1145
02:00:43.471 --> 02:00:46.094
<v Candace Avalos>So I will go ahead and speak to the broader report now.

1146
02:00:48.390 --> 02:00:54.807
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I want to start by grounding this conversation in why the Community Board for Police Accountability exists in the first place.

1147
02:00:55.563 --> 02:01:05.939
<v Candace Avalos>The CBPA was created to provide independent community-based oversight of policing, particularly by centering voices that have historically been excluded from decisions about public safety and accountability.

1148
02:01:06.827 --> 02:01:23.528
<v Candace Avalos>I understand that the city is requesting removals based on eligibility and administrative requirements, and I also understand that some members were flagged through a review of social media activity for perceived bias either for or against the police, and that one member is being removed for not signing a required nondisclosure agreement.

1149
02:01:24.650 --> 02:01:27.715
<v Candace Avalos>My concern is not whether the city has authority to enforce requirements.

1150
02:01:27.842 --> 02:01:37.546
<v Candace Avalos>My concern is about how those standards are being applied, whether they are being applied consistently, And whether council has been given sufficient information to exercise its judgment responsibility— responsibly.

1151
02:01:37.658 --> 02:01:40.577
<v Candace Avalos>Now, I want to address the NDA issue real carefully.

1152
02:01:41.234 --> 02:01:55.488
<v Candace Avalos>As a former member of the Citizen Review Committee, I was required to sign confidentiality agreements because police accountability work involves extremely sensitive material, including arbitration records, personnel files, and legal strategy.

1153
02:01:55.984 --> 02:02:01.581
<v Candace Avalos>Those agreements are tied to protecting attorney-client privilege and preserving the integrity of disciplinary proceedings.

1154
02:02:02.094 --> 02:02:13.158
<v Candace Avalos>So if privileged legal information is disclosed improperly, it can be used in arbitration to weaken or overturn discipline decisions, and that risk is structural to how police labor agreements operate.

1155
02:02:14.521 --> 02:02:27.639
<v Candace Avalos>I understand that some community members view this primarily as a transparency issue, but— and transparency is important— but this question is fundamentally about protecting attorney-client privilege and ensuring that oversight bodies can function within the legal framework that exists.

1156
02:02:28.216 --> 02:02:29.644
<v Candace Avalos>And those are distinct considerations.

1157
02:02:30.461 --> 02:02:41.493
<v Candace Avalos>That doesn't mean that confidentiality agreements can't be examined or improved over time, but I think over or under the structure currently in place, signing that agreement is part of the responsibility of serving in this role.

1158
02:02:41.621 --> 02:02:44.971
<v Candace Avalos>And when that requirement isn't met, it creates a functional issue for the board's work.

1159
02:02:45.789 --> 02:02:50.198
<v Candace Avalos>Now, where I am far less comfortable is with the how the social media reviews were handled.

1160
02:02:50.841 --> 02:02:55.795
<v Candace Avalos>2 Members were presented to council for removal based on social media activity identified as biased.

1161
02:02:56.372 --> 02:03:04.693
<v Candace Avalos>Another member who has publicly expressed strong bias in favor of the police was not evaluated for bias in the same way, but was instead removed on an administrative basis.

1162
02:03:05.109 --> 02:03:11.489
<v Candace Avalos>And that distinction to me raises real questions about whether bias is being assessed evenly regardless of its direction.

1163
02:03:12.627 --> 02:03:19.793
<v Candace Avalos>If bias against policing is grounds for removal, then bias in favor of policing must be evaluated with the same seriousness and transparency.

1164
02:03:20.243 --> 02:03:21.444
<v Candace Avalos>And we have to be honest about context.

1165
02:03:21.510 --> 02:03:27.402
<v Candace Avalos>Next, policing already operates within a status quo that privileges police narratives and institutional power.

1166
02:03:27.947 --> 02:03:37.338
<v Candace Avalos>In that environment, criticism, skepticism, or lived experience with policing can too easily be framed as bias, while pro-police perspectives are treated as neutral.

1167
02:03:37.997 --> 02:03:45.671
<v Candace Avalos>The CBPA was intentionally designed to include people with lived experience, including people who have been harmed by or are deeply critical of policing systems.

1168
02:03:46.104 --> 02:04:02.909
<v Candace Avalos>And so if lived experience is treated as I also want to note that one of the members initially slated for removal has since resigned for unrelated reasons, and I want to thank her for her service and be clear that I did not intend to vote to remove her.

1169
02:04:03.659 --> 02:04:05.300
<v Candace Avalos>This is not about defending any individual.

1170
02:04:05.479 --> 02:04:11.420
<v Candace Avalos>It is about whether our process is fair, consistent, and aligned with the purpose of community-led police accountability.

1171
02:04:11.420 --> 02:04:24.350
<v Candace Avalos>And so as we move forward, I would like to see a clearer articulation of the criteria that we are using to determine whether or not of a member of the council is qualified to serve on the what constitutes disqualifying bias, how that standard is applied across the board, and how council is provided sufficient information to make these decisions with confidence.

1172
02:04:24.832 --> 02:04:30.304
<v Candace Avalos>Because getting this right really matters, especially as we have the first meeting today of the CBPA.

1173
02:04:30.465 --> 02:04:35.712
<v Candace Avalos>And as somebody who has been deeply involved in this work for many, many years, it took a lot to get to this point.

1174
02:04:36.225 --> 02:04:40.622
<v Candace Avalos>It's really fragile how we approach this, the seating of this first body.

1175
02:04:41.439 --> 02:04:42.996
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm just concerned about today's vote.

1176
02:04:43.092 --> 02:04:43.284
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1177
02:04:44.264 --> 02:04:52.530
<v Candace Avalos>Given wanting to make sure that we are ensuring the credibility of the CBPA and public trust in our broader accountability system.

1178
02:04:52.868 --> 02:04:58.631
<v Candace Avalos>I'm very eager to hear other councilors' arguments here, but that's kind of how I'm approaching this conversation.

1179
02:04:59.032 --> 02:05:00.637
<v Candace Avalos>I don't think I have any direct questions right now.

1180
02:05:00.702 --> 02:05:05.966
<v Candace Avalos>I feel like I've gotten those answered through the process of briefings and just discussing it on the dais so far.

1181
02:05:06.497 --> 02:05:10.685
<v Candace Avalos>But I really hope my colleagues consider what it looks like to evaluate these biases.

1182
02:05:10.783 --> 02:05:10.975
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1183
02:05:11.377 --> 02:05:23.286
<v Candace Avalos>And the fact that we are presented with some, we are presented with some members and we weren't presented with others to give the full context of how I'm making this decision, that's what deeply concerns me about this process.

1184
02:05:23.851 --> 02:05:24.158
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1185
02:05:25.646 --> 02:05:26.503
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1186
02:05:26.698 --> 02:05:27.231
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1187
02:05:28.864 --> 02:05:38.904
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, sorry, I forgot to ask my questions or raise comments about Bob Weinstein's concerns with The nondisclosure agreement.

1188
02:05:40.528 --> 02:05:52.157
<v Mitch Green>Heidi had mentioned that there was some effort to kind of engage in a back and forth to get to a place where a mutually agreeable agreement could be struck.

1189
02:05:53.435 --> 02:05:56.863
<v Mitch Green>But my understanding from that is we did not find that agreeability.

1190
02:05:56.911 --> 02:06:01.850
<v Mitch Green>So I guess I need to know more about what Bob's ongoing reservations are.

1191
02:06:02.545 --> 02:06:04.305
<v Mitch Green>We need to have, I think, a little bit more of that discussion.

1192
02:06:04.417 --> 02:06:04.530
<v Mitch Green>So—.

1193
02:06:04.530 --> 02:06:04.788
<v Bob Weinstein>Councilor Smith.

1194
02:06:05.309 --> 02:06:09.277
<v Mitch Green>So I can look at that clear-eyed because I'm not convinced either.

1195
02:06:09.519 --> 02:06:14.972
<v Mitch Green>So, you know, help me out, Bob, or, you know, whenever appropriate, I need to— we need to talk more about that.

1196
02:06:18.949 --> 02:06:23.256
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm not clear if I can call Bob.

1197
02:06:24.268 --> 02:06:29.652
<v Jamie Dunphy>If Mr. Weinstein is available and would like to answer Councilor Green's questions, I would invite him to the dais.

1198
02:06:30.993 --> 02:06:31.731
<v Jamie Dunphy>Never forget that one.

1199
02:06:31.796 --> 02:06:32.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just so you can do whatever you want.

1200
02:06:33.064 --> 02:06:33.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>I heard it.

1201
02:06:33.644 --> 02:06:36.872
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, and I'm gonna remember that.

1202
02:06:37.018 --> 02:06:37.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

1203
02:06:37.564 --> 02:06:38.881
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please introduce yourself for the record.

1204
02:06:39.106 --> 02:06:39.588
<v Bob Weinstein>Yeah, thank you.

1205
02:06:39.653 --> 02:06:41.453
<v Bob Weinstein>My name is Bob Weinstein, for the record.

1206
02:06:44.411 --> 02:06:45.680
<v Mitch Green>So thanks, Bob.

1207
02:06:45.824 --> 02:07:12.274
<v Bob Weinstein>Um, so help me understand what has transpired between last week when we discussed this to today with regards to this non-disclosure Yeah, Councilor Green and other council members, what has transpired since the meeting is late yesterday afternoon about 4:30, I received an email from Heidi Brown with a suggestion for an amendment.

1208
02:07:13.654 --> 02:07:30.265
<v Bob Weinstein>After review with people who understand the law and what attorney-client privilege means, I responded this morning and told her That while I appreciated the effort, my concerns were not addressed.

1209
02:07:30.996 --> 02:07:48.693
<v Bob Weinstein>And I offered language that said, here's a concept that I think both addresses my concerns while also clearly identifying the information which is properly confidential and agreeing to retain that information as confidential.

1210
02:07:48.868 --> 02:07:50.139
<v Bob Weinstein>Here's the language I sent her.

1211
02:07:50.921 --> 02:08:09.725
<v Bob Weinstein>The receiving party, me in this case, agrees that they will retain as confidential to the extent allowed by law and not disclose any and all confidential, privileged, or restricted information outside of the city related to any issues shared with the receiving party by the city.

1212
02:08:10.622 --> 02:08:30.708
<v Bob Weinstein>Then defined, confidential, privileged, or restricted information means any and all information, documents, and materials subject to nondisclosure As provided by the exemptions contained in ORS 192.345 and 192.355, the public record statutes.

1213
02:08:31.353 --> 02:08:40.060
<v Bob Weinstein>Those sections have long lists of exemptions, including attorney-client privilege and investigatory materials, et cetera.

1214
02:08:41.744 --> 02:09:12.859
<v Bob Weinstein>Final paragraph in what I suggested, information that is not confidential, privileged, or restricted under Oregon law, Including but not limited to general work product not related to a specific matter before the CPPA, training materials, and information consisting solely of citations to or summaries or discussions of publicly available law shall not be subject to this confidentiality agreement.

1215
02:09:13.164 --> 02:09:19.381
<v Bob Weinstein>So pretty much said, That the agreement should follow the law.

1216
02:09:20.328 --> 02:09:22.270
<v Bob Weinstein>It should follow what the council intended.

1217
02:09:22.479 --> 02:09:27.119
<v Bob Weinstein>It should follow what state law demands and requires.

1218
02:09:28.019 --> 02:09:36.512
<v Bob Weinstein>I think the significant difference, I did have a discussion with Heidi during the break, and there's 2 things.

1219
02:09:37.171 --> 02:09:55.752
<v Bob Weinstein>She, her language suggests that only the city can disclose anything that is provided to the board, including training materials that we all would say, hey, that's public, that I or other board members would not have the right to say, this is how we've been trained.

1220
02:09:55.815 --> 02:10:06.711
<v Bob Weinstein>In fact, from my perspective, all of that stuff should be on a future Community Board for Police Accountability dashboard so everybody could see, this is how—.

1221
02:10:06.774 --> 02:10:07.099
<v Patricia Dieffendorfer>Right.

1222
02:10:07.838 --> 02:10:09.438
<v Bob Weinstein>This is how people were trained.

1223
02:10:10.100 --> 02:10:26.248
<v Bob Weinstein>A key difference in what she told me and my many years of experience dealing with municipal attorneys, school district attorneys, and state attorneys general is as follows.

1224
02:10:26.930 --> 02:10:35.149
<v Bob Weinstein>Let's say there's a statute or a code and it's, you know, obviously been written by attorneys and it's— It's a statute.

1225
02:10:35.481 --> 02:10:40.738
<v Bob Weinstein>For lack of a better word, legalese, that a layperson may not understand what it means.

1226
02:10:41.315 --> 02:10:53.177
<v Bob Weinstein>So if I, as an alternate, or another board member says to the City Attorney's Office, what does that mean in plain language?

1227
02:10:53.658 --> 02:11:05.123
<v Bob Weinstein>And they say it, according to Heidi, and she can tell me or tell you if I'm misstating, that interpretation is confidential.

1228
02:11:05.220 --> 02:11:06.690
<v Bob Weinstein>It's attorney-client privilege.

1229
02:11:06.981 --> 02:11:07.935
<v Bob Weinstein>I don't think it is.

1230
02:11:08.047 --> 02:11:09.355
<v Bob Weinstein>It could be said in public.

1231
02:11:11.652 --> 02:11:16.130
<v Bob Weinstein>It's not pertaining to a specific person.

1232
02:11:16.548 --> 02:11:20.965
<v Bob Weinstein>So it doesn't involve a personnel matter with an identifiable person.

1233
02:11:21.222 --> 02:11:28.024
<v Bob Weinstein>It doesn't involve a certain case that's before or that's coming to the board.

1234
02:11:28.363 --> 02:11:36.478
<v Bob Weinstein>It's just An interpretation so a layperson can understand the meaning of a charter provision or a section of code.

1235
02:11:36.846 --> 02:11:39.077
<v Bob Weinstein>That's— those are the 2 differences.

1236
02:11:39.734 --> 02:11:48.926
<v Bob Weinstein>Only the city can decide what is disclosable, and those kinds of things that I mentioned would not be.

1237
02:11:49.359 --> 02:11:57.703
<v Bob Weinstein>Heidi mentioned to me that, which I know and you know, citizens who object to nondisclosure can go to the DA's office.

1238
02:11:58.220 --> 02:12:04.608
<v Bob Weinstein>Well, the average citizen does not know that you can go to the DA's office or how you do that.

1239
02:12:06.199 --> 02:12:10.475
<v Bob Weinstein>And from my perspective, those 2 issues remain a concern.

1240
02:12:12.180 --> 02:12:13.661
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's very helpful for me, Bob.

1241
02:12:13.805 --> 02:12:14.127
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1242
02:12:14.529 --> 02:12:16.574
<v Bob Weinstein>Okay, any other questions while I'm here?

1243
02:12:18.104 --> 02:12:19.279
<v Bob Weinstein>Okay, thank you very much.

1244
02:12:19.779 --> 02:12:20.262
<v James Bernard Lee>Thank you, Bob.

1245
02:12:20.987 --> 02:12:21.518
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knolke.

1246
02:12:24.462 --> 02:12:25.346
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1247
02:12:26.134 --> 02:12:39.938
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I, I think a couple things that have come up here is largely about whether or not we've— how we interpret as a group of, of councilors the piece of the charter that talks about who decides who's on this board.

1248
02:12:40.676 --> 02:12:54.042
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and it is council's ultimate decision, and that's a really important thing to keep in mind here because we're getting little pieces of inform— I've got Since this council meeting started, I've gotten 2 emails with more information, some of which I don't think all of us have had.

1249
02:12:54.108 --> 02:12:55.666
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's a lot of just trust us.

1250
02:12:56.742 --> 02:13:00.902
<v Sameer Kanal>I am willing to be deferential to the staff on a lot of these issues.

1251
02:13:01.256 --> 02:13:06.539
<v Sameer Kanal>And I have personally talked through a lot of these things because I've sought out that time and I feel very informed on it.

1252
02:13:06.796 --> 02:13:11.247
<v Sameer Kanal>But I also am aware that there's a conversation here that's broader than just this one issue.

1253
02:13:11.695 --> 02:13:15.354
<v Sameer Kanal>There's also conversation here I think there's a question here that's broader than just these 2 particular individuals.

1254
02:13:15.787 --> 02:13:21.092
<v Sameer Kanal>Because, for example, Councilor Clark referenced the need for the board to be neutral.

1255
02:13:21.557 --> 02:13:23.706
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think there's 2 questions that that brings up.

1256
02:13:23.865 --> 02:13:30.935
<v Sameer Kanal>One is, how do we determine what neutral is, obviously, in a place where nothing's exactly unbiased, nothing's exactly neutral?

1257
02:13:31.319 --> 02:13:34.462
<v Sameer Kanal>But the other piece of it is whether or not you apply that individually.

1258
02:13:34.943 --> 02:13:38.453
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think this group of 12 of us is a good example of that.

1259
02:13:38.533 --> 02:13:39.832
<v Sameer Kanal>We are representative of the city.

1260
02:13:40.554 --> 02:13:42.173
<v Sameer Kanal>But no one of us is representative of the city.

1261
02:13:42.221 --> 02:13:44.291
<v Sameer Kanal>No one of us is representative of even our whole district.

1262
02:13:44.707 --> 02:13:49.711
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's how I've been viewing this this entire time, because that's what the rules say in the charter.

1263
02:13:49.774 --> 02:13:56.479
<v Sameer Kanal>That's what the rules said for the most part in the code, with some very clear carve-outs for specific situations.

1264
02:13:56.671 --> 02:13:59.846
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's how I'm viewing and approaching this conversation.

1265
02:14:01.145 --> 02:14:10.064
<v Sameer Kanal>I am comfortable giving the, the process time to work itself out with relation to if there can be an agreement reached.

1266
02:14:10.706 --> 02:14:13.368
<v Sameer Kanal>I do understand the City Attorney's Office's position.

1267
02:14:13.417 --> 02:14:21.054
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm also hearing Bob's position here about this, and I'm likely to be deferential to that process.

1268
02:14:21.134 --> 02:14:24.663
<v Sameer Kanal>But that process doesn't happen if we vote yes on removing him today.

1269
02:14:25.208 --> 02:14:27.728
<v Sameer Kanal>That process just ends if we vote yes on removing him today.

1270
02:14:28.434 --> 02:14:37.247
<v Sameer Kanal>But I also want to just take something that he said and apply it to the other context as well, which is the idea that about whether or not transparency matters from the perspective of public trust.

1271
02:14:37.296 --> 02:15:03.859
<v Sameer Kanal>And that matters so much for the other, the other conversation about bias as well, because it's not the role, and we haven't tasked the City Attorney's Office with developing a system that can earn the trust of the public, which Councilor Avalos has mentioned is incredibly fragile because it has been 1,927 6 days since 82% of people voted for this, and it hasn't met yet, and it will in 6 and a half hours.

1272
02:15:03.907 --> 02:15:06.685
<v Sameer Kanal>And I am so excited, I'll be there with bells on.

1273
02:15:06.797 --> 02:15:16.114
<v Sameer Kanal>But the, uh, the process has, I think, lost trust with people who voted against it as well as people who voted for it.

1274
02:15:16.515 --> 02:15:23.725
<v Sameer Kanal>And having done a lot of the outreach in my previous role, uh, to people who voted no on that ballot measure as well as people who Yes.

1275
02:15:24.064 --> 02:15:34.548
<v Sameer Kanal>And I know this is something Councilor Ryan and I have talked about over the years, that it's not about building a system that works for the 82%, it's about building a system that works for 100% of Portlanders, that there is a fragile trust here.

1276
02:15:35.228 --> 02:16:02.713
<v Sameer Kanal>And basing it off of irony and internet memes and basing it off of a process with these checks that is very problematic because it flagged things outside of the look-fors, Um, that, that the city gave, regardless of what people think about the look-fors, um, that we gave for the social media search, um, which by the way appears to be limited only to Facebook, um, which is itself an interesting choice.

1277
02:16:03.226 --> 02:16:08.445
<v Sameer Kanal>But, uh, and I think that has to do with, uh, transparency and, and settings of, of privacy.

1278
02:16:08.525 --> 02:16:14.819
<v Sameer Kanal>But regardless of that, the— if you look at the, the second email we got today, you'll see a lot more than just that was flagged.

1279
02:16:15.845 --> 02:16:18.747
<v Sameer Kanal>A lot more than what we flagged to look for.

1280
02:16:19.194 --> 02:16:26.393
<v Sameer Kanal>On the 2 most common things in the word cloud that were given for Skylar Halsey's posts were Episcopal and church.

1281
02:16:27.851 --> 02:16:29.021
<v Sameer Kanal>Why are they even looking at that?

1282
02:16:29.728 --> 02:16:34.200
<v Sameer Kanal>So I have a huge problem with the way this particular process was handled.

1283
02:16:34.297 --> 02:16:36.316
<v Sameer Kanal>I think a lot of the other parts of this process were handled well.

1284
02:16:36.748 --> 02:16:39.859
<v Sameer Kanal>CJIS took time, but I think our staff did as well as they possibly could.

1285
02:16:39.940 --> 02:16:42.487
<v Sameer Kanal>Possibly could have done given the role of the state in that.

1286
02:16:42.615 --> 02:16:45.790
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I want to praise them for that part of it because I do think that was good.

1287
02:16:46.302 --> 02:16:56.787
<v Sameer Kanal>But there are concerns here I have about the implications on public trust that we will have if we simply accept without actually digging in or giving time for these processes to develop.

1288
02:16:57.188 --> 02:16:59.768
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wanted to, to make sure that that was framed here.

1289
02:17:00.153 --> 02:17:05.074
<v Sameer Kanal>One quick clarification: when we vote on it, it's not voting on the underlying, uh, report.

1290
02:17:05.459 --> 02:17:07.399
<v Sameer Kanal>It's voting on the remaining report.

1291
02:17:07.784 --> 02:17:11.444
<v Sameer Kanal>So that vote will not include anything about Skyler Halsey or Bob Weinstein.

1292
02:17:11.878 --> 02:17:13.852
<v Sameer Kanal>It will include just the resignations and removals.

1293
02:17:13.900 --> 02:17:14.847
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not like an amendment.

1294
02:17:15.153 --> 02:17:16.518
<v Sameer Kanal>So just wanted to clarify that for later.

1295
02:17:17.159 --> 02:17:17.319
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

1296
02:17:18.443 --> 02:17:19.310
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1297
02:17:19.888 --> 02:17:21.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I put myself in the queue, colleagues.

1298
02:17:21.751 --> 02:17:23.131
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have 2 very quick comments.

1299
02:17:23.421 --> 02:17:29.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I will say I really appreciate, uh, Heidi Brown, uh, for working to try and find a, a creative workaround.

1300
02:17:30.404 --> 02:17:34.095
<v Jamie Dunphy>I thought last week that, uh, Mr. Weinstein made some honestly compelling Yes.

1301
02:17:34.191 --> 02:17:38.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>Testimony about the way we were approaching NDAs.

1302
02:17:39.396 --> 02:17:50.316
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, I think if I'm— again, I'm not a lawyer, so I'm not— maybe I'm missing it, but I get the general impression that the question at this point is who decides what is confidential.

1303
02:17:50.413 --> 02:18:21.522
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I am inclined to trust the— or to default to trusting the attorneys who we have hired, specifically in the context of trying to thread this very specific needle, um, on police oversight with the, uh, with the, uh, consent agreement in place with the federal government, with the, um, ongoing— I mean, upcoming negotiations with PPA on their contract, and additionally the, um, sometimes litigious nature of a lot of these different things.

1304
02:18:21.635 --> 02:18:27.188
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am inclined to be, uh, deferential to our attorney, who I think has made a really good faith effort Thank you.

1305
02:18:27.236 --> 02:18:29.951
<v Jamie Dunphy>I appreciate the effort to try and find a path forward.

1306
02:18:31.093 --> 02:18:38.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>With regard to Mr. Hugh Halsey, Skyler Hugh Halsey, I don't know, I do also have concerns.

1307
02:18:39.689 --> 02:18:45.699
<v Jamie Dunphy>I too Googled the ACAB meme that had a picture of capybaras on it.

1308
02:18:45.810 --> 02:18:46.502
<v Jamie Dunphy>I was curious.

1309
02:18:46.679 --> 02:19:04.474
<v Jamie Dunphy>I typed in all capybaras are and found the same meme that Councilor Green was talking I also have concerns about, you know, I am of an era of the internet that embodies the idea that reposts do not mean endorsements.

1310
02:19:04.666 --> 02:19:20.877
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm interested to know, you know, what the— I couldn't tell from the supporting documents whether these were everything that was on this individual's Facebook page, which again, I also think it's odd to be talking about Facebook because Facebook is And that's another question.

1311
02:19:21.441 --> 02:19:28.194
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I'm also interested— I wasn't clear based on the totality of reposts or other content where this fit in.

1312
02:19:28.452 --> 02:19:29.779
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I didn't see anything in particular.

1313
02:19:29.843 --> 02:19:44.278
<v Jamie Dunphy>I certainly saw things that had a particular perspective, but I didn't see anything that really, for me, crossed a line or specifically crossed the line that our specific disqualification criteria called out.

1314
02:19:45.896 --> 02:19:51.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I am having a harder time with justifying removing that one.

1315
02:19:53.863 --> 02:19:56.061
<v Jamie Dunphy>But those are my 2 specific comments.

1316
02:19:56.110 --> 02:19:57.144
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I will take myself out.

1317
02:19:57.619 --> 02:19:58.586
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1318
02:20:00.879 --> 02:20:03.156
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

1319
02:20:03.688 --> 02:20:05.028
<v Loretta Smith>I apologize for not being there.

1320
02:20:05.398 --> 02:20:08.739
<v Loretta Smith>I'm down in Salem testifying with the mayor on the motor bill.

1321
02:20:10.979 --> 02:20:36.623
<v Loretta Smith>I wanted to go back to what Bob Weinstein said, and I think we have to really take a look at, you know, when we are following the charter, what's the interpretation and how we interpretate who is going to say what specific NDA we use.

1322
02:20:37.925 --> 02:20:38.413
<v Loretta Smith>Used.

1323
02:20:38.575 --> 02:20:49.603
<v Loretta Smith>And he said he had no problem with— actually, the only piece that he had a problem with was not acknowledging the training.

1324
02:20:50.719 --> 02:21:04.918
<v Loretta Smith>And as you know, as elected officials, everything that we do say on, on these devices when we, when we're doing public work, we have to— it has to be transparently seen to the public.

1325
02:21:05.706 --> 02:21:22.308
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, if that's the case, I think we should show the same difference to, uh, Bob Weinstein because he understands very well the things that you can— that you can and cannot bring forward.

1326
02:21:22.501 --> 02:21:24.974
<v Loretta Smith>But I think we need to have a larger conversation.

1327
02:21:25.695 --> 02:21:46.122
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I agree with some of the things you said, uh, Council President, because I think it's frustrating, particularly when we are trying to implement everything the way in which the charter committee and the people who voted for this, you know, said that we should.

1328
02:21:46.638 --> 02:21:51.406
<v Loretta Smith>So at this point, this next vote, I have a point of order.

1329
02:21:51.889 --> 02:21:54.837
<v Loretta Smith>So this next vote is not going to be on the removal.

1330
02:21:54.934 --> 02:22:03.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is just going to be on Councilor Smith, specifically, we will be doing 3 votes in a row.

1331
02:22:04.689 --> 02:22:13.994
<v Jamie Dunphy>The first vote will be to either whether or not to include the name of Hugh Schuyler Halsey in this report.

1332
02:22:14.155 --> 02:22:18.658
<v Jamie Dunphy>The second vote will be whether or not to include the name of Bob Weinstein in this report.

1333
02:22:18.996 --> 02:22:21.184
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the third vote will be on the overall report.

1334
02:22:21.264 --> 02:22:21.458
<v Claire Adamsick>Is that—.

1335
02:22:21.458 --> 02:22:21.586
<v Jonathan Ader>Thank you.

1336
02:22:22.002 --> 02:22:26.161
<v Sameer Kanal>Just to clarify, it's not about inclusion or not.

1337
02:22:26.802 --> 02:22:35.040
<v Sameer Kanal>It's we've broken the report up into 3 parts, and now the question is, do we adopt the part of the report that has Skyler Halsey in it?

1338
02:22:35.313 --> 02:22:35.425
<v Eric Zimmerman>Right.

1339
02:22:36.372 --> 02:22:37.545
<v Sameer Kanal>Adopting that will remove him.

1340
02:22:37.593 --> 02:22:39.567
<v Sameer Kanal>So yes would be to remove him, no would be to retain.

1341
02:22:40.403 --> 02:22:42.442
<v Sameer Kanal>Second, same thing on Bob Weinstein.

1342
02:22:43.021 --> 02:22:47.179
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes vote would be to, uh, remove, a no vote would be to retain.

1343
02:22:47.657 --> 02:22:49.283
<v Sameer Kanal>And the third vote is not on the overall.

1344
02:22:49.429 --> 02:22:52.665
<v Sameer Kanal>It is on everything but the parts related to those 2 people.

1345
02:22:52.825 --> 02:22:52.986
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1346
02:22:53.533 --> 02:22:54.420
<v Sameer Kanal>So the resignation—.

1347
02:22:54.420 --> 02:22:55.966
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1348
02:22:56.272 --> 02:22:56.449
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1349
02:22:56.932 --> 02:22:57.335
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1350
02:22:57.578 --> 02:22:58.629
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

1351
02:22:59.195 --> 02:22:59.631
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1352
02:23:00.408 --> 02:23:01.184
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1353
02:23:01.362 --> 02:23:02.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1354
02:23:03.966 --> 02:23:04.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1355
02:23:04.838 --> 02:23:07.460
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to ask a question of our attorney, if that's all right with you.

1356
02:23:07.609 --> 02:23:08.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

1357
02:23:08.594 --> 02:23:08.989
<v Loretta Smith>Heidi.

1358
02:23:16.659 --> 02:23:27.051
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>One of my colleagues mentioned that it would be nice to be able to continue the conversation that you started, it sounds like yesterday, with Bob.

1359
02:23:27.582 --> 02:23:32.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'll note, I appreciate that you tried to find a way to move forward with him.

1360
02:23:33.620 --> 02:23:36.158
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I wish those conversations had happened before the last minute.

1361
02:23:36.352 --> 02:23:43.682
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know sometimes that's hard, but It had been my hope that there would be some sort of resolution there before this came back to us today.

1362
02:23:45.156 --> 02:23:50.046
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In order to allow more time for that conversation, we would have to keep him on the list as an alternate.

1363
02:23:50.766 --> 02:23:57.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Currently, he doesn't meet the qualifications necessary to move on to the full board because he hasn't been through the training.

1364
02:23:59.102 --> 02:24:17.843
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we were today to keep him on the list as an alternate, and if we were to end up in a situation where he were the only alternate left, If he left and there were an opening on the board and he hadn't signed something, you hadn't come to an agreement, he had not finished the training and was therefore not qualified to be seated on the board, what would happen?

1365
02:24:20.295 --> 02:24:43.945
<v Heidi Brown>We would have to come back before you and request again his removal in that he had not signed the confidentiality agreement, or council would have to decide to remove the requirement for a confidentiality agreement, which would also require us to amend the DOJ settlement agreement because it is similarly reflected in there.

1366
02:24:44.879 --> 02:24:46.942
<v Heidi Brown>And that would also lead to likely bargaining.

1367
02:24:47.072 --> 02:24:50.457
<v Heidi Brown>So it would be involved.

1368
02:24:51.090 --> 02:25:06.638
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So in essence though, if we leave him on for now, either you reach some resolution here, And he completes the training and is eligible to be seated on the board if we need him, which we may or may not in the future.

1369
02:25:07.505 --> 02:25:23.627
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or you continue to remain at an impasse with him, and should another vacancy come up on the board and should he be the only alternate left available, you would come to us and say you can't seat him on the board without making these other more complicated changes.

1370
02:25:23.738 --> 02:25:32.858
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we either need to go out and recruit other alternates or have a vacancy on the board or do those other very complicated things you've just described.

1371
02:25:32.970 --> 02:25:40.565
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we never end up in a situation where he is seated on the board by default as the only person left if he hasn't completed the training.

1372
02:25:40.661 --> 02:25:41.399
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1373
02:25:42.828 --> 02:25:48.623
<v Heidi Brown>That is correct in that it is a requirement under code to sign a confidentiality agreement.

1374
02:25:48.864 --> 02:26:02.806
<v Heidi Brown>The only thing I would note is that Everybody went through the training and the background check and CJIS check and all that so that if you get to a point where you are facing putting somebody onto the board, they have completed the training.

1375
02:26:03.078 --> 02:26:06.742
<v Heidi Brown>They're required to complete the training within 6 months of appointment.

1376
02:26:06.790 --> 02:26:16.074
<v Heidi Brown>So alternates and regular board members all went through the training except Mr. Weinstein at the point at which he refused to sign the confidentiality agreement.

1377
02:26:16.121 --> 02:26:16.346
<v Heidi Brown>Thank you.

1378
02:26:18.093 --> 02:26:18.511
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Understood.

1379
02:26:18.558 --> 02:26:41.265
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What I'm, what I'm trying to get to, and I think I understand where we're landing, is if we remove him, the consequences— we have one fewer alternate, um, his background that he would have brought is not available in the future to, to add to the board, um, and we move forward.

1380
02:26:41.810 --> 02:26:50.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we If we keep him on, the consequence is there's more time to have the conversations about whether he's willing to sign something to then go through the trainings.

1381
02:26:50.300 --> 02:26:57.807
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But there is no situation in which if he's still not able to go through those trainings, we end up being asked to seat him on the board.

1382
02:26:59.472 --> 02:27:00.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that accurate?

1383
02:27:00.118 --> 02:27:00.165
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1384
02:27:00.343 --> 02:27:00.602
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay.

1385
02:27:01.165 --> 02:27:09.753
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That helps me just with a little bit of context setting and thinking about what the vote around His removal or not means.

1386
02:27:09.816 --> 02:27:11.967
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I really appreciate that.

1387
02:27:12.608 --> 02:27:37.820
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I just want to say out loud as we have these conversations that I fear that we sometimes conflate being for police accountability with being a police abolitionist, and I fear that on the other hand we sometimes conflate thinking that we need more police staffing with being unwilling to hold police accountable.

1388
02:27:37.950 --> 02:27:48.414
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And frankly, I'm not actually sure that we all have the same understanding of what it even means to support or oppose police and where the lines are on what support or oppose means.

1389
02:27:50.283 --> 02:28:18.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think we're having a lot of conversations about Portlanders and about our own beliefs using coded language that not everybody is interpreting And I just want to mention that because I'm sitting with that as we think about how we move forward and we— as we think about— Councilor Knoll, I think what you've described is balance as opposed to neutrality, um, and what neutrality means for this.

1390
02:28:19.407 --> 02:28:26.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I haven't actually decided where I'm landing on all of these votes, and I'm not saying this to try to change anybody's mind, but because I think it's really important to think about what neutrality means.

1391
02:28:26.300 --> 02:28:26.477
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1392
02:28:26.766 --> 02:28:38.791
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That as we all make up our minds, we're thinking carefully about what words we are using as coded language for meanings that— and beliefs that somebody may or may not actually hold.

1393
02:28:39.582 --> 02:28:40.566
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1394
02:28:40.808 --> 02:28:41.743
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1395
02:28:42.179 --> 02:28:45.076
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

1396
02:28:45.479 --> 02:28:46.655
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1397
02:28:47.492 --> 02:29:08.647
<v Angelita Morillo>First, I just want to say I think what Councilor Avalos laid out in her opening statement very much I will say that as someone who is closer— well, you know what, I'm not going to take up the position of top poster in the city because I think that goes to Councilor Green.

1398
02:29:09.450 --> 02:29:20.586
<v Angelita Morillo>But I think, you know, I come from a generation where people post a lot, and it's not always— you know, even in my Bluesky bio, I literally say, I'm a millennial.

1399
02:29:20.638 --> 02:29:20.721
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1400
02:29:21.056 --> 02:29:22.966
<v Angelita Morillo>A follow does not equal an endorsement.

1401
02:29:23.013 --> 02:29:27.010
<v Angelita Morillo>So I could be following an account, that doesn't mean that I like the person or that I support them.

1402
02:29:27.075 --> 02:29:29.289
<v Angelita Morillo>It could just mean I'm just following their feed and looking at it.

1403
02:29:29.802 --> 02:29:32.113
<v Angelita Morillo>I have people who don't like me who follow me all the time.

1404
02:29:32.531 --> 02:29:35.644
<v Angelita Morillo>I have people repost things, that sort of thing.

1405
02:29:35.772 --> 02:30:13.235
<v Angelita Morillo>So, uh, it's interesting to me the metric that is being used where a simple social media post or a repost could be weighed just as heavily as For example, we have people who are former city council candidates who ran for office, who had very public platforms, who publicly talked about their positions on things, who were endorsed by the police union, which ostensibly means that you are someone who is going to fight for the interests of police, which is why they endorsed you as the top people to be offered up for this.

1406
02:30:13.299 --> 02:30:13.412
<v Lee Armstrong>Yes.

1407
02:30:13.797 --> 02:30:23.790
<v Angelita Morillo>And that does not view— that does not show that they are biased, but a Bluesky or a Facebook repost can show a heavier bias than that.

1408
02:30:24.305 --> 02:30:39.545
<v Angelita Morillo>And that is extremely strange to me because one is a simple repost on social media and one is actually a demonstration that you have committed so heavily to supporting the police that their union thinks that you are worthy of their endorsement.

1409
02:30:39.701 --> 02:30:46.250
<v Angelita Morillo>And again, their endorsement means I am going to support the interests of police and their perspectives and their needs.

1410
02:30:48.569 --> 02:30:55.815
<v Angelita Morillo>So it's just, I think the metrics that are being used here to evaluate bias are very skewed.

1411
02:30:56.475 --> 02:31:08.283
<v Angelita Morillo>And in a social media age like we have now, it seems absurd to me that those types of things and that context that we know about people who are coming up here Councilor Smith.

1412
02:31:08.733 --> 02:31:12.423
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm not really understanding the logic there.

1413
02:31:13.305 --> 02:31:43.006
<v Angelita Morillo>And it is true that when you are upholding the status quo, which as it currently stands is that we have police and we have a system that for a very long time has excused the poor behaviors of police officers and the harms that have happened to Black and brown communities, that anyone who criticizes the status quo is going to be viewed as a radical, and anyone who is upholding the status quo is going to be viewed as the norm.

1414
02:31:43.793 --> 02:31:52.881
<v Angelita Morillo>I understand that there are people here who have been endorsed by the police who have also been critical of police, and I appreciate that there can be nuance there.

1415
02:31:53.362 --> 02:32:20.168
<v Angelita Morillo>But by that very logic, then you must also concede that just because you reposted something So, because I saw some folks here who were endorsed by the police raise their hands when I said that, and I'm just saying, if that itself is not enough to invalidate you, then why would a simple repost be enough?

1416
02:32:21.314 --> 02:32:24.344
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think the very metrics that were used here are just not— I think that's a great question.

1417
02:32:26.834 --> 02:32:58.909
<v Angelita Morillo>I really worry about who we are excluding, and especially because the reality is the people who are directly impacted by these issues, who do not have a political vested interest in gaining power by being endorsed by certain groups, they are going to speak passionately and they are going to speak from a different position because it is a personal issue for them than someone who I think that it is inherently a passionate issue when it's something that directly implicates you.

1418
02:32:59.440 --> 02:33:01.639
<v Angelita Morillo>So I guess I'll just leave it at that.

1419
02:33:01.639 --> 02:33:02.780
<v Angelita Morillo>I think I've made my point.

1420
02:33:02.959 --> 02:33:08.879
<v Angelita Morillo>But the metrics by which we are measuring people are very bizarre to me, and I don't think that they're right.

1421
02:33:09.840 --> 02:33:20.215
<v Angelita Morillo>And the idea that accountability is inherently an attack, or that accountability means you are inherently an abolitionist, or that accountability means you are inherently a racist, or that accountability means you are inherently a misogynist, or that accountability means you are inherently It does not seem to measure up to what is right.

1422
02:33:20.343 --> 02:33:27.391
<v Angelita Morillo>And frankly, even most abolitionists understand that they're not going to abolish police overnight.

1423
02:33:27.537 --> 02:33:33.635
<v Angelita Morillo>It's a very complicated political stance that most people have reduced in the media to something very simplified.

1424
02:33:35.367 --> 02:33:37.175
<v Angelita Morillo>So I will leave it at that.

1425
02:33:37.256 --> 02:33:39.210
<v Angelita Morillo>But I do have a lot of concerns around that.

1426
02:33:39.355 --> 02:33:40.728
<v Angelita Morillo>And I do also have concerns that this is supposed to be a public comment period.

1427
02:33:40.777 --> 02:33:41.359
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Smith, I'm sorry.

1428
02:33:41.486 --> 02:33:44.584
<v Angelita Morillo>To be a body handling legal matters that are very delicate.

1429
02:33:45.097 --> 02:34:06.918
<v Angelita Morillo>And if we have someone who feels that they are personally empowered to share things that should be private for the sake of upholding these legal standards, then we are going to be putting the work of the body in harm's way for the sake of the individual's satisfaction about making a public statement.

1430
02:34:09.145 --> 02:34:09.935
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

1431
02:34:10.129 --> 02:34:10.663
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

1432
02:34:12.375 --> 02:34:15.362
<v Candace Avalos>Like Loretta says, ditto, ditto, ditto to Councilor Murillo.

1433
02:34:15.459 --> 02:34:25.165
<v Candace Avalos>I really appreciate how you laid that out, and I want to talk a little bit more about the discussion around training because that seems to be where we have, um, a lot of the disagreement is being centered.

1434
02:34:25.775 --> 02:34:32.577
<v Candace Avalos>So the concern here is not about whether basic information like publicly available laws or general policy frameworks can be shared.

1435
02:34:32.871 --> 02:34:33.627
<v Candace Avalos>That's not the issue.

1436
02:34:34.156 --> 02:34:44.272
<v Candace Avalos>The issue is that these trainings can often include discussions of legal strategy, case analysis, arbitration dynamics, and advice provided by the City Attorney's Office.

1437
02:34:44.610 --> 02:34:47.661
<v Candace Avalos>So those conversations are protected by attorney-client privilege.

1438
02:34:48.046 --> 02:34:56.106
<v Candace Avalos>They are sensitive by design because they relate directly to how the city navigates discipline and arbitration in a system that is already legally precarious.

1439
02:34:56.573 --> 02:34:58.644
<v Candace Avalos>So protecting that privilege is not optional.

1440
02:34:59.030 --> 02:35:05.522
<v Candace Avalos>It is foundational to preserving the city's ability to successfully implement discipline And defend accountability decisions.

1441
02:35:05.958 --> 02:35:10.916
<v Candace Avalos>And if those strategic discussions are disclosed, they can be used to undermine cases in arbitration.

1442
02:35:11.174 --> 02:35:12.736
<v Candace Avalos>Seen it happen all the time, actually.

1443
02:35:13.245 --> 02:35:22.007
<v Candace Avalos>And so what gives me pause is the suggestion that an individual board member should be able to independently determine what is appropriate to disclose and what is not.

1444
02:35:22.073 --> 02:35:23.771
<v Candace Avalos>That is not your role as a board member.

1445
02:35:24.094 --> 02:35:31.748
<v Candace Avalos>The determination of what falls under attorney-client privilege is made by the city attorney because that office carries the responsibility and the liability.

1446
02:35:32.242 --> 02:35:38.940
<v Candace Avalos>For making complex legal judgments in an environment where arbitration outcomes can hinge on very narrow procedural details.

1447
02:35:39.388 --> 02:35:41.921
<v Candace Avalos>So this is not about whose personal judgment we agree with.

1448
02:35:42.192 --> 02:35:45.254
<v Candace Avalos>It is about respecting the legal framework that governs this work.

1449
02:35:45.782 --> 02:35:59.295
<v Candace Avalos>And when someone suggests that their individual view of what should be public supersedes the legal judgment of the city attorney, that raises real concerns for me about role clarity and the ability of the board to function within the legal structure that it needs to operate in.

1450
02:36:00.049 --> 02:36:14.138
<v Candace Avalos>We can and should continue evaluating whether the confidentiality framework is calibrated appropriately, but as it stands, protecting privileged discussions during trainings— mind you, during trainings of a brand new board— is not about limiting transparency.

1451
02:36:14.266 --> 02:36:18.567
<v Candace Avalos>It is about safeguarding the integrity and effectiveness of the accountability system itself.

1452
02:36:19.065 --> 02:36:30.078
<v Candace Avalos>And that public trust in this board depends not only on openness but also on its ability to operate responsibly within the law and successfully exercise the real authority that it now holds.

1453
02:36:30.144 --> 02:36:31.396
<v Candace Avalos>And that balance really matters.

1454
02:36:31.765 --> 02:36:38.432
<v Candace Avalos>So I want to make that crystal clear that this is not about your personal ideas of what you think needs to be disclosed to the public.

1455
02:36:38.736 --> 02:36:48.102
<v Candace Avalos>We have a duty to ensure that our city attorney has the ability to do the— navigate the legal system in a way that's not going to undermine their authority.

1456
02:36:48.293 --> 02:36:50.045
<v Candace Avalos>And so I do not agree with these arguments.

1457
02:36:50.301 --> 02:36:52.630
<v Candace Avalos>And I will not be supporting Bob for appointment.

1458
02:36:52.936 --> 02:36:53.129
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1459
02:36:53.578 --> 02:36:55.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1460
02:36:55.506 --> 02:36:57.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark— Vice President Clark.

1461
02:36:58.156 --> 02:36:59.264
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, President Dunphy.

1462
02:36:59.940 --> 02:37:01.626
<v Olivia Clark>It's hard to follow that.

1463
02:37:02.815 --> 02:37:15.632
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I, uh, I do agree that there's a lot of ambiguity around some of these issues, and I am very sensitive to the issue of fragility at this moment in time.

1464
02:37:15.842 --> 02:37:16.338
<v Olivia Clark>As well.

1465
02:37:17.270 --> 02:37:26.994
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I appreciate the comments of our formal— former council president, uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, trying to thread the needle here.

1466
02:37:27.235 --> 02:37:50.629
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate it because what I was going to suggest, but maybe you have a better suggestion, is that in trying to find the middle path here, that we give ourselves some more time, more time on trying to, uh, deal with bias, deal with confidentiality, And put these 2 people aside, put this vote aside, and do some more work here.

1467
02:37:50.756 --> 02:37:57.251
<v Olivia Clark>I think we're really wrestling with large societal issues that are bigger than us.

1468
02:37:58.409 --> 02:38:03.965
<v Olivia Clark>The issue of the internet and social media is bigger than me, that's for sure.

1469
02:38:04.384 --> 02:38:08.423
<v Olivia Clark>So I was going to try to suggest a middle path here if people would be open to it.

1470
02:38:09.470 --> 02:38:16.686
<v Olivia Clark>And I like Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's approach as well is giving ourselves more time to wrestle with some of these issues.

1471
02:38:17.957 --> 02:38:19.450
<v Olivia Clark>Not sure there's any interest in that.

1472
02:38:21.379 --> 02:38:22.552
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Clerk.

1473
02:38:25.349 --> 02:38:26.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1474
02:38:27.824 --> 02:38:29.656
<v Steve Novick>First of all, I have to— thank you, Mr. President.

1475
02:38:29.703 --> 02:38:35.757
<v Steve Novick>I have to respond to Councilor Murillo's suggestion that if you accept the endorsement of a group, that means you made a commitment to fight like hell for that group.

1476
02:38:36.773 --> 02:38:42.166
<v Steve Novick>What it means is that that group decided that you among the candidates were preferable to some other alternatives.

1477
02:38:42.310 --> 02:38:47.365
<v Steve Novick>And it means the candidate decided that they thought that on balance that endorsement wouldn't be bad to have.

1478
02:38:47.992 --> 02:39:00.494
<v Steve Novick>I have to say that I think Councilor Morillo's point isn't that far from saying that if an unconvicted murderer votes for me, then that means that I should be expected to represent the results, the interest of unconvicted murderers.

1479
02:39:00.541 --> 02:39:02.194
<v Steve Novick>I think that's a different issue.

1480
02:39:02.500 --> 02:39:11.457
<v Steve Novick>So in terms of Skylar Halsey, I mean, to me, I'm a little skeptical of the idea of bias for or against the police.

1481
02:39:11.650 --> 02:39:12.649
<v Steve Novick>That seems a little broad.

1482
02:39:12.795 --> 02:39:37.438
<v Steve Novick>But I think that the key thing is— one key factor is if there's discipline imposed on an officer, what can the city attorney expect to be raised in arbitration to undermine that And as to ACAB, I'm willing to accept the idea that that indicates nothing other than a bias in favor of capybaras.

1483
02:39:38.809 --> 02:39:48.956
<v Steve Novick>But one of Skylar Halsey's posts, it was a repost, but it was a repost of something saying, do you guys ever think undercover cops are no different from Nazi secret police?

1484
02:39:49.930 --> 02:40:07.121
<v Steve Novick>And to me, that does raise a concern that if there's discipline of a cop who was acting in undercover capacity, then you can assume that at least one voter was willing to impose whatever discipline on that undercover cop because they think they're equivalent to Nazi secret police.

1485
02:40:07.766 --> 02:40:12.583
<v Steve Novick>And I understand that there's a difference between repost and regular posting.

1486
02:40:12.630 --> 02:40:21.135
<v Steve Novick>I mean, the people who post a lot might think that, but I think that if you're in a legal proceeding and somebody raises that, Right.

1487
02:40:22.054 --> 02:40:23.320
<v Steve Novick>That's going to be a problem.

1488
02:40:23.802 --> 02:40:35.898
<v Steve Novick>So I am okay with the city's— with a determination that somebody's ineligible based on the likely usage of their posts in a disciplinary proceeding.

1489
02:40:36.557 --> 02:40:46.761
<v Steve Novick>And just as— I mean, it's slightly different, but if somebody says various, you know, biased in favor of police things, I do think that that would tend to undermine the public's faith in the police.

1490
02:40:46.808 --> 02:40:46.968
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

1491
02:40:51.175 --> 02:40:52.013
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1492
02:40:52.885 --> 02:40:57.181
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you.

1493
02:40:57.423 --> 02:41:03.549
<v Mitch Green>I, first of all, I want to react to Councilor Avalos's last line of argumentation.

1494
02:41:04.176 --> 02:41:05.447
<v Mitch Green>I have to agree 100%.

1495
02:41:05.608 --> 02:41:12.757
<v Mitch Green>I think what's at stake here is ensuring the fidelity of the process.

1496
02:41:13.201 --> 02:41:19.078
<v Mitch Green>And making sure that we can actually get to true accountability, which our Portlanders have been waiting a long time for.

1497
02:41:19.368 --> 02:41:22.594
<v Mitch Green>What is it, 1,900— what's the date number?

1498
02:41:22.658 --> 02:41:23.236
<v Mitch Green>What's the count?

1499
02:41:23.943 --> 02:41:25.051
<v Sameer Kanal>1,926.

1500
02:41:25.260 --> 02:41:27.363
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's a long time.

1501
02:41:28.375 --> 02:41:31.956
<v Mitch Green>For that reason, I'm also going to be hesitant to delay this, frankly.

1502
02:41:32.934 --> 02:41:35.922
<v Mitch Green>But I appreciate the creativity and thought.

1503
02:41:36.628 --> 02:41:37.897
<v Mitch Green>There may be a middle path.

1504
02:41:38.009 --> 02:41:38.298
<v Mitch Green>Who knows?

1505
02:41:39.078 --> 02:41:41.632
<v Mitch Green>But I just want to speak to this, the social media stuff again.

1506
02:41:41.682 --> 02:41:54.329
<v Mitch Green>And I just think, like, when we are looking for bias for or against, it is a very, I think, frankly, impossible standard, especially when you look solely at a slice of a person's thinking on it through, it looks like, almost exclusively Facebook posts.

1507
02:41:56.612 --> 02:42:01.611
<v Mitch Green>I want to read one of the posts that I think is really important because I think we're looking at a totality of intent here.

1508
02:42:03.025 --> 02:42:04.939
<v Mitch Green>There's a post from June 9th, 2020.

1509
02:42:05.673 --> 02:42:13.235
<v Mitch Green>That actually is much more substantive than any of the other memes, which the memes are like, you know, you can extract a lot of different meaning for that.

1510
02:42:13.299 --> 02:42:19.111
<v Mitch Green>But like when you look at a post that actually has an articulation of what a position is, that to me I think carries much more weight.

1511
02:42:19.238 --> 02:42:26.833
<v Mitch Green>So June 9th, 2020, there's a meme or a post that says, just to be clear what some folks are talking about when they say defund the police.

1512
02:42:27.652 --> 02:42:31.328
<v Mitch Green>And it's a discussion by Dr. Anthony James Hargraves.

1513
02:42:31.377 --> 02:42:31.504
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, I see it.

1514
02:42:31.569 --> 02:42:31.618
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1515
02:42:32.007 --> 02:42:35.386
<v Mitch Green>And it basically says defund the police does not mean eliminate all police funding.

1516
02:42:35.888 --> 02:42:37.658
<v Mitch Green>Defund the police means police will be funded.

1517
02:42:38.000 --> 02:42:38.958
<v Mitch Green>Police will not be overfunded.

1518
02:42:39.850 --> 02:42:41.252
<v Mitch Green>We're redistributing the city budget.

1519
02:42:41.332 --> 02:42:42.379
<v Mitch Green>Everyone gets a fair share.

1520
02:42:42.459 --> 02:42:48.037
<v Mitch Green>So there's a sort of vision of fairness, of budgets or moral documents.

1521
02:42:49.061 --> 02:42:53.290
<v Mitch Green>It goes on to say defund the police because police should focus on crimes and criminals.

1522
02:42:53.965 --> 02:42:55.459
<v Mitch Green>Police are not mental health counselors.

1523
02:42:55.894 --> 02:42:56.954
<v Mitch Green>Police are not social workers.

1524
02:42:57.019 --> 02:43:06.305
<v Mitch Green>And so that's That's the nature of this post, which is quite substantive and actually lays out a position for someone who might say, this is how I'm going to enter into a discussion.

1525
02:43:07.202 --> 02:43:16.804
<v Mitch Green>I think when we think about bias, we look to posts like that, not just kind of like hot takes from— what is it— the Barbie movie.

1526
02:43:17.059 --> 02:43:22.765
<v Mitch Green>You know, I mean, and like, you know, not great if you're trying to be judged by this standard.

1527
02:43:22.845 --> 02:43:23.119
<v Mitch Green>I get that.

1528
02:43:23.166 --> 02:43:23.263
<v Skylar Halsey>But like—.

1529
02:43:23.263 --> 02:43:24.031
<v Mitch Green>That's not what I'm talking about.

1530
02:43:24.129 --> 02:43:33.619
<v Mitch Green>This is also talking about in the context of a long history of COINTELPRO, a long history of secret police being used to undermine democratic movements.

1531
02:43:33.666 --> 02:43:42.727
<v Mitch Green>And so I understand this is challenging, but I just wanted to make sure folks didn't miss that very important substantive post there, which I think, in my view, settles the question.

1532
02:43:43.162 --> 02:43:43.467
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1533
02:43:44.029 --> 02:43:44.897
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1534
02:43:46.054 --> 02:43:47.564
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1535
02:43:47.836 --> 02:44:08.790
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm going to say one thing, and then I have a note, which is that I think the thing I wanted to bring up before that is just the idea that there's a process here.

1536
02:44:08.790 --> 02:44:11.010
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is a conversation that's been going on a long time.

1537
02:44:11.829 --> 02:44:19.809
<v Sameer Kanal>I think just shy of a year ago, we had our second meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee meeting where many of the things that we're talking about today were discussed.

1538
02:44:19.809 --> 02:44:19.850
<v Jonathan Ader>Thank you.

1539
02:44:20.066 --> 02:44:30.046
<v Sameer Kanal>Were brought up, specifically the idea that it is very difficult to determine bias because each of us has our own opinions and beliefs that bring us to it.

1540
02:44:30.415 --> 02:44:47.802
<v Sameer Kanal>The idea that, um, the, the application of to a group versus an individual member, the idea that there is a status quo bias that isn't necessarily inherently ideological but can be manifested, can manifest on a specific issue in a way that in alignment with one or another ideology.

1541
02:44:48.299 --> 02:44:54.646
<v Sameer Kanal>These are all things that have come up before, and I'll note that neutrality, unbiased— none of that actually appears in the charter.

1542
02:44:55.271 --> 02:45:09.355
<v Sameer Kanal>The charter says, uh, that the permission of the board— again, the board as an entity, not as an individual— is to independently investigate Portland Police Bureau sworn employees and supervisors thereof promptly, fairly, and impartially.

1543
02:45:10.093 --> 02:45:19.852
<v Sameer Kanal>And one of the things that came up in the last testimony was that the recommendation was to have larger groups within the 21 members.

1544
02:45:19.899 --> 02:45:56.888
<v Sameer Kanal>In fact, first to have a larger group of members than 21, but within that 21 to have a larger group sit on a panel so that individual members would not have as outsized of an influence on these decisions, but that our predecessors on the old city council took the recommendation from their staff to narrow that down so that 3 or 5 people sit on these And I think one of the things that, that we can look at is how do we ensure, you know, that the size of a panel or these other administrative decisions, but which are inherent to us because it is in code, not in their administrative rules, are things that we can do to try and give confidence to everybody.

1545
02:45:56.951 --> 02:46:03.457
<v Sameer Kanal>But the other piece that I wanted to bring up is that the system for determining this after the fact is very flawed.

1546
02:46:03.538 --> 02:46:03.715
<v Bill Cunningham>Yes.

1547
02:46:04.149 --> 02:46:08.996
<v Sameer Kanal>Because public trust is not part of the decision-making of the city attorney's office, and it shouldn't be.

1548
02:46:09.061 --> 02:46:10.167
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's the right call.

1549
02:46:12.097 --> 02:46:20.378
<v Sameer Kanal>And but that afterwards, the grievances that could be filed about this can only be filed by one side of the process, right?

1550
02:46:20.602 --> 02:46:28.335
<v Sameer Kanal>That's a the grievances that would go before an arbitrator can only be filed by the the the PPA.

1551
02:46:29.058 --> 02:46:29.429
<v Sameer Kanal>And so.

1552
02:46:29.559 --> 02:46:37.986
<v Sameer Kanal>So these are a factor in looking at potential bias, is that they looked at what might cause a problem with arbitration.

1553
02:46:38.459 --> 02:46:43.970
<v Sameer Kanal>But because that can only be initiated by one side, that standard is inherently biased.

1554
02:46:44.742 --> 02:46:46.926
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's a concern that has come through here.

1555
02:46:47.023 --> 02:46:57.254
<v Sameer Kanal>The other thing I wanted to mention on the agreement, the NDA, is that we do have a requirement for a confidentiality agreement.

1556
02:46:57.765 --> 02:47:03.085
<v Sameer Kanal>But, and that is in the settlement agreement, but it only says literally sign a confidentiality agreement.

1557
02:47:03.149 --> 02:47:03.918
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the exact words.

1558
02:47:04.014 --> 02:47:06.434
<v Sameer Kanal>It doesn't speak to the specifics of that.

1559
02:47:06.899 --> 02:47:12.813
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll also note that in the code, it refers to some— it says the CBPA member must sign a confidentiality agreement.

1560
02:47:13.068 --> 02:47:15.103
<v Sameer Kanal>So I do think there's a bigger conversation here.

1561
02:47:15.167 --> 02:47:18.421
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with everything else that Heidi said in her comments.

1562
02:47:18.468 --> 02:47:23.692
<v Sameer Kanal>I do think there was a good faith conversation, and I'm willing to allow that, to use my vote to allow that process to continue.

1563
02:47:23.740 --> 02:47:23.869
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

1564
02:47:23.966 --> 02:47:25.346
<v Sameer Kanal>To continue, but I wanted to mention that.

1565
02:47:25.844 --> 02:47:33.122
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll defer to you, but I did want to say, to note that Skyler Halsey is here and I appreciate the opportunity to speak more with them.

1566
02:47:33.750 --> 02:47:34.665
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

1567
02:47:34.729 --> 02:47:44.228
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, if anybody has any specific questions, as we gave time to Mr. Weinstein, if there are any specific questions from colleagues about Mr. Halsey, he's available.

1568
02:47:44.882 --> 02:47:45.471
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1569
02:47:46.959 --> 02:47:48.072
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Mr. President.

1570
02:47:52.319 --> 02:47:53.759
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am a little cautious.

1571
02:47:55.004 --> 02:48:05.691
<v Eric Zimmerman>It seems like because this document has, uh, a couple of names on it that we're, we're doing what I guess is kind of expected from our councils.

1572
02:48:05.756 --> 02:48:14.072
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're splitting as if it's a— these 2 people are against each other, they represent something against each other, and that, that is a little alarming for me.

1573
02:48:14.152 --> 02:48:17.674
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I, I'm going to steal a term from Councilor Avalos in terms of level setting.

1574
02:48:18.031 --> 02:48:36.024
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I, I think that's important because, um, I'm— it sounds like in some of the comments in the discussion that we're starting to call into question Mr. Weinstein's, um, bias calculator.

1575
02:48:37.474 --> 02:48:39.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's not why he's on the list today.

1576
02:48:39.164 --> 02:48:42.545
<v Eric Zimmerman>He's on the list, as we've said multiple times over and over, about the NDA.

1577
02:48:44.239 --> 02:48:49.061
<v Eric Zimmerman>But the way that some of this discussion is going, it's as if they're pitting those 2 issues against each other.

1578
02:48:49.127 --> 02:48:51.301
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just want to be cautious just in terms of that.

1579
02:48:52.951 --> 02:48:58.862
<v Eric Zimmerman>And as far as I can remember, having been a person who ran for office against Bob, he was not endorsed by the PPA.

1580
02:48:59.570 --> 02:49:02.614
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm looking to make sure that that's accurate.

1581
02:49:02.775 --> 02:49:03.308
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's accurate.

1582
02:49:03.355 --> 02:49:04.869
<v Eric Zimmerman>So he's not endorsed by the PPA.

1583
02:49:04.950 --> 02:49:08.105
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I— and I— that was said, and I— and I think it was in reference to Bob.

1584
02:49:08.170 --> 02:49:08.235
<v Priya Dhanapal>Yes.

1585
02:49:08.603 --> 02:49:09.611
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just wanted to clarify that.

1586
02:49:10.471 --> 02:49:17.013
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if we're going to go down this— so only 2 profiles got given to us out of the 25, right, Councilor Connell?

1587
02:49:17.094 --> 02:49:18.694
<v Eric Zimmerman>25 Members plus alternates?

1588
02:49:19.034 --> 02:49:19.584
<v Sameer Kanal>27.

1589
02:49:19.729 --> 02:49:20.424
<v Eric Zimmerman>27, Thank you.

1590
02:49:20.974 --> 02:49:28.396
<v Eric Zimmerman>Only 2 profiles were given to us, and I think that this is a perfectly healthy conversation about the bias.

1591
02:49:28.509 --> 02:49:29.317
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I, I really do.

1592
02:49:29.415 --> 02:49:30.790
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and for the most part, it's stayed there.

1593
02:49:30.918 --> 02:49:49.039
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I would ask that we The reason I'm not going to support Bob's name being included in this report is because I too think there is some room to work on this NDA and the standard of the NDA and keeping the CBPA transparent.

1594
02:49:51.299 --> 02:50:00.118
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I'm not sure why we're getting into a little bit of whether or not he's being assessed for a bias as well, and that, that's making me a bit uncomfortable.

1595
02:50:00.199 --> 02:50:08.486
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's important that we have a process in place that we can If we need to request the same file on all 27 members, by all means, let's rock and roll.

1596
02:50:09.440 --> 02:50:11.256
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think that's what we want to do.

1597
02:50:11.466 --> 02:50:29.578
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if we are taking these 2 individuals' names whose names have been called out as separate questions, it does lead me to question what lens we are making these determinations through.

1598
02:50:30.524 --> 02:50:34.981
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't have much concern in the staff process that brought us to this.

1599
02:50:35.157 --> 02:50:40.463
<v Eric Zimmerman>I do understand that this was not optimal, and I agree to a large extent with that.

1600
02:50:41.505 --> 02:50:50.819
<v Eric Zimmerman>But Mr. Weinstein is being added to this list by the staff for a specific reason, and it's very different than the reason that the other members were.

1601
02:50:50.885 --> 02:51:02.308
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I just— I'm hoping my colleagues will separate that out And not apply a biased lens to a person who the staff is not saying they have a concern in that perspective.

1602
02:51:03.972 --> 02:51:06.926
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I really don't have much comment on the other names that are on this list.

1603
02:51:07.103 --> 02:51:09.413
<v Eric Zimmerman>I was only moving to separate those questions.

1604
02:51:09.461 --> 02:51:11.156
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you, Councilor Knoll, for that.

1605
02:51:11.656 --> 02:51:17.200
<v Eric Zimmerman>I agree with separating out the Bob question, and I'll continue to do that.

1606
02:51:17.280 --> 02:51:29.121
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I hope we can be careful about which lens or what criteria we're applying Or are we just taking this up as a territorial or turf disagreement between 2 camps here?

1607
02:51:29.266 --> 02:51:31.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I can't quite tell where this discussion is going right now.

1608
02:51:31.899 --> 02:51:32.125
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1609
02:51:32.541 --> 02:51:33.361
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1610
02:51:33.505 --> 02:51:37.504
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I will note we have 15 minutes— 14 minutes left in this hearing.

1611
02:51:37.777 --> 02:51:45.371
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will almost certainly— no, we will certainly not be hearing item 9 today, and we will be moving that to tomorrow's afternoon.

1612
02:51:46.207 --> 02:51:47.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

1613
02:51:47.667 --> 02:51:49.834
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1614
02:51:50.621 --> 02:51:52.902
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, I appreciate that clarity, Councilor Zimmerman.

1615
02:51:53.094 --> 02:52:07.369
<v Angelita Morillo>I think I was talking about the process overall for what counts as bias and what does not count as bias and what's weighed, because we are also being asked to accept this report as a whole, and I have a lot of questions about how that report is done.

1616
02:52:08.829 --> 02:52:27.166
<v Angelita Morillo>I have to respond to Councilor Novick because I would say, you know, you made the claim that Well, if you get an endorsement, then that means that— and you say that that influences whether or not someone is going to be fighting for the interests of a certain group, then if a convicted murderer votes for you, then surely you must support murder.

1617
02:52:28.595 --> 02:52:31.951
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't think a convicted murderer— does he have a super PAC?

1618
02:52:32.851 --> 02:52:34.441
<v Angelita Morillo>Does he have an endorsement process?

1619
02:52:35.019 --> 02:52:38.860
<v Angelita Morillo>Does he have sway in political circles where policy Yes.

1620
02:52:38.860 --> 02:52:38.860
<v Candace Avalos>—.

1621
02:52:38.860 --> 02:52:42.930
<v Angelita Morillo>Is created and passed and impacts thousands of people in the city of Portland?

1622
02:52:43.260 --> 02:52:49.319
<v Angelita Morillo>Because if not, then that is a false equivalency about the power that an endorsement holds.

1623
02:52:49.319 --> 02:53:03.440
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'll also note that some people seek endorsements and they don't get them, not because they aren't values aligned with that group or their interests, but because maybe they didn't have— they weren't perceived to have the juice to actually be a top candidate.

1624
02:53:04.209 --> 02:53:06.424
<v Angelita Morillo>So that is also something to consider.

1625
02:53:07.131 --> 02:53:30.029
<v Angelita Morillo>But what I am again saying, and I think what Councilor Green has pointed out repeatedly, and what I appreciate about Councilor Green pointing out the more nuanced post, is that we are using a very narrow metric to judge people's political perspectives and their abilities to be biased or non-biased when there is much greater political context and I think much more heavy Thank you.

1626
02:53:30.076 --> 02:53:36.514
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think that this is a community context around the powers that people have and don't have and who supports them.

1627
02:53:36.980 --> 02:53:40.995
<v Angelita Morillo>And that absolutely does influence the way that people move through politics.

1628
02:53:41.236 --> 02:53:46.198
<v Angelita Morillo>And this is a political question because it is a question about power.

1629
02:53:46.309 --> 02:53:51.222
<v Angelita Morillo>It is a question about who gets heard and who doesn't get heard and whose perspectives are prioritized.

1630
02:53:52.331 --> 02:53:54.594
<v Angelita Morillo>So I just want to clear that up.

1631
02:53:54.658 --> 02:54:04.441
<v Angelita Morillo>That's part of my I think that's a concern in this entire process, not just related to Mr. Weinstein and not just related to the people that we have here as a whole.

1632
02:54:05.163 --> 02:54:16.149
<v Angelita Morillo>But to act like the things that people ran on, the endorsements that they sought, the endorsements that they have don't influence them, I think is a little naive.

1633
02:54:17.226 --> 02:54:33.983
<v Angelita Morillo>And I would like that all of these factors be taken into account more than just And again, I think that for Skyler specifically with that post that Councilor Green pointed out that showed the nuance of their perspective, that's really critical.

1634
02:54:34.240 --> 02:54:39.093
<v Angelita Morillo>That to me shows substance that I, I haven't heard anyone discuss.

1635
02:54:39.254 --> 02:54:39.929
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you.

1636
02:54:40.506 --> 02:54:41.584
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

1637
02:54:41.712 --> 02:54:42.661
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1638
02:54:43.238 --> 02:54:44.266
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1639
02:54:44.363 --> 02:54:58.847
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we are hearing a lot about the about each other's beliefs, about each other's values, about the potential beliefs and values of people who may or may not be on this board.

1640
02:55:01.042 --> 02:55:12.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, if I remember back to a year ago when we first moved a slate of candidates for this board, there were a broad range of life experiences and beliefs represented.

1641
02:55:13.363 --> 02:55:23.631
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With or without the 2 individuals whose names are before us today, there will be a broad range of perspectives, life experiences, and beliefs represented on this board.

1642
02:55:23.775 --> 02:55:38.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The alternates who we will use to replace individuals who have stepped off the board or been removed from the board represent a broad— people with a broad range of life experiences and backgrounds and values.

1643
02:55:40.385 --> 02:55:48.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>2 Changes today are not going to upset the balance of this board.

1644
02:55:48.595 --> 02:55:56.084
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I want to offer my apologies to the 2 individuals who we are debating, that so much has become about who you are as people.

1645
02:55:57.336 --> 02:56:09.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because my guess is— I don't know either of you personally, but my guess is that you both signed up to do this out of a care for your neighbors, for your communities, and for our city as a whole.

1646
02:56:10.941 --> 02:56:14.197
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And nobody should be calling into question what your motivations were.

1647
02:56:15.961 --> 02:56:19.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At the end of the day, yes, the buck stops with us, and these are our appointments.

1648
02:56:20.810 --> 02:56:28.727
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we cannot be in the process of reviewing every single potential interest of bias for every single member of this board.

1649
02:56:29.540 --> 02:56:38.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We cannot be in the process of wordsmithing what the right level of confidentiality should be.

1650
02:56:39.084 --> 02:56:44.879
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to trust our staff to do this work just as neutrally as we want our board members to act.

1651
02:56:45.665 --> 02:56:53.689
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm concerned, frankly, that no matter what happens today, there will be people who do not believe that this process is neutral and believe that there's bias in it at this point.

1652
02:56:54.315 --> 02:56:55.647
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's not where I want us to be.

1653
02:56:56.256 --> 02:56:58.343
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is unfortunately where Thank you.

1654
02:56:59.015 --> 02:57:12.828
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a process that needs iterative work, and processes that need iterative work where people's well-being hangs in the livelihood, where people's livelihoods hang in the balance, isn't ideal.

1655
02:57:13.165 --> 02:57:15.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But again, it is where we sit.

1656
02:57:16.129 --> 02:57:24.977
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In an earlier conversation with staff, I had the opportunity to dig a little deeper into the, the bias pieces here.

1657
02:57:25.666 --> 02:57:45.477
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I suggested that the search for expressions of bias must in the future be significantly broader than it was this time, because I do think that it caught certain things that some people might say or places where some people might speak, and it didn't look in other places where people might speak.

1658
02:57:46.602 --> 02:57:48.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to make sure that we're applying things evenly.

1659
02:57:49.025 --> 02:57:55.190
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I also know that we are at our best when we set standards that apply universally and allow process to play out.

1660
02:57:56.329 --> 02:58:02.877
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We absolutely should evaluate and optimize this process going forward, but today we are digging into the weeds.

1661
02:58:04.192 --> 02:58:09.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want us to consider whether our early direction was right or clear enough as we look at the next group.

1662
02:58:10.291 --> 02:58:16.663
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We had a committee, in fact, that looked at whether we were giving the right direction and decided not to move changes forward.

1663
02:58:17.513 --> 02:58:18.684
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't sit on that committee.

1664
02:58:19.295 --> 02:58:26.102
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know why that decision was made, but we gave direction to staff and we have their recommendations before us.

1665
02:58:26.296 --> 02:58:55.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So colleagues, I am leaning toward moving forward in my votes with our staff direction across the board here, because what we are starting to do is dig into the weeds and make accusations about multiple people— members of the board who are— whose names are before us, and members of the board whose names are not before us today and at each other in a way that I don't think is the work that we are supposed to be doing.

1666
02:58:56.182 --> 02:58:56.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1667
02:58:58.013 --> 02:58:59.523
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1668
02:58:59.861 --> 02:59:00.454
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1669
02:59:01.548 --> 02:59:01.789
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1670
02:59:01.885 --> 02:59:03.010
<v Mitch Green>I've got my eye on the time here.

1671
02:59:03.090 --> 02:59:05.066
<v Mitch Green>I just want to respond to Councilor Zimmerman.

1672
02:59:05.259 --> 02:59:09.779
<v Mitch Green>You've raised an important question that deserves distinction and clarification of intent here.

1673
02:59:10.488 --> 02:59:21.296
<v Mitch Green>Um, I think my My hesitancy with seating Bob at this point has absolutely nothing to do with, like, suggestion for bias.

1674
02:59:21.569 --> 02:59:26.738
<v Mitch Green>I'll note that, you know, Bob and I are probably a mile apart on politics.

1675
02:59:27.237 --> 02:59:28.638
<v Mitch Green>I knew Bob during the campaign.

1676
02:59:29.270 --> 02:59:34.528
<v Mitch Green>We had a fairly collegial relationship because I think, I think he's an honest operator.

1677
02:59:34.882 --> 02:59:35.272
<v Mitch Green>I really do.

1678
02:59:35.352 --> 02:59:37.893
<v Mitch Green>I just, I just completely disagree with him on so many things, and that's okay.

1679
02:59:37.957 --> 02:59:38.119
<v Mitch Green>He does me.

1680
02:59:38.183 --> 02:59:47.224
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Bob has targeted me personally as a private citizen for things he thinks I'm doing that are wrong, which is completely within his right, even if I disagree.

1681
02:59:47.930 --> 02:59:54.959
<v Mitch Green>I voted for Bob in the initial round because I did believe he would be an impartial and unbiased operator on the board.

1682
02:59:55.537 --> 03:00:10.110
<v Mitch Green>I just have deep reservations with his unwillingness to accept a very specific part of this nondisclosure agreement, which again is his right, but then as, as an elected leader, I do have to hold the line on the legal interpretation piece of the attorney-client privilege.

1683
03:00:10.110 --> 03:00:13.750
<v Mitch Green>And so if there's a world in which he can move past that, I would vote for him, to be honest.

1684
03:00:13.750 --> 03:00:14.899
<v Mitch Green>But that's kind of where I'm at.

1685
03:00:15.209 --> 03:00:19.760
<v Mitch Green>So I don't think anyone's actually made a suggestion towards Bob's intent today, just to be clear, because I haven't heard that.

1686
03:00:19.870 --> 03:00:25.290
<v Mitch Green>It's been about this legal— this, uh, confidentially— confidentially— confidential— you know what I'm trying to say.

1687
03:00:25.350 --> 03:00:27.329
<v Mitch Green>That's, that's what that's about.

1688
03:00:27.920 --> 03:00:29.770
<v Mitch Green>Um, uh, and that's all I'm going to say.

1689
03:00:29.770 --> 03:00:30.270
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1690
03:00:30.270 --> 03:00:31.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1691
03:00:31.329 --> 03:00:31.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1692
03:00:33.745 --> 03:00:34.099
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1693
03:00:34.372 --> 03:00:49.288
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I first want to just clarify, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, I agreed with the majority of what you said, but with relation to the committee, were you referring to the February hearing in which, uh, my resolution came up at the committee— Community and Public Safety Committee meeting?

1694
03:00:49.659 --> 03:01:03.531
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think there was a resolution that you brought forward, and I believe there was other more general discussion about this process in the committee that you and Okay, so just to clarify, there was minimal councilor discussion.

1695
03:01:03.611 --> 03:01:06.326
<v Sameer Kanal>What happened that day is we had a lot of public testimony on it.

1696
03:01:06.440 --> 03:01:20.387
<v Sameer Kanal>It got towards the end, and, uh, I felt very uncomfortable, as did some of my colleagues on that committee, uh, pushing a vote forward without having time to discuss it, or without— and also we would have had to have, um, cut off people from testifying.

1697
03:01:20.820 --> 03:01:22.958
<v Sameer Kanal>The item was continued to a further agenda and then had to be moved to the agenda.

1698
03:01:23.022 --> 03:01:23.135
<v Jake Antles>Thank you.

1699
03:01:23.216 --> 03:01:26.538
<v Sameer Kanal>Has not to date been placed on agenda, so it kind of lingers in limbo.

1700
03:01:26.602 --> 03:01:30.630
<v Sameer Kanal>But there was some explanation ahead of time, and that was pretty much it.

1701
03:01:31.095 --> 03:01:39.281
<v Sameer Kanal>So I wouldn't characterize it as— it's definitely not an action taken by committee, but I wouldn't characterize it as a decision not to act either.

1702
03:01:39.505 --> 03:01:39.810
<v Lee Armstrong>It was—.

1703
03:01:40.147 --> 03:01:51.816
<v Sameer Kanal>And just to be clear what it was, it was a request to have the city attorney start talking about changing with PPA, start talking about changing this to be more clear.

1704
03:01:51.880 --> 03:01:52.024
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1705
03:01:52.505 --> 03:01:57.441
<v Sameer Kanal>And there was a conversation at the committee level as to what that would look like as well.

1706
03:01:57.569 --> 03:01:58.564
<v Sameer Kanal>But that's pretty much it there.

1707
03:01:59.012 --> 03:02:05.663
<v Sameer Kanal>With relation to the broader sentiment, I think it is fair to put the process into a place of scrutiny.

1708
03:02:05.983 --> 03:02:06.880
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a fair job.

1709
03:02:06.929 --> 03:02:08.099
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's our job to do.

1710
03:02:08.691 --> 03:02:17.584
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll just say for myself, I understand that everybody has— and this just to kill the metaphor, I guess, by belaboring it too strongly— it's okay for a gardener to get into the weeds.

1711
03:02:18.308 --> 03:02:18.565
<v Steve Novick>Right.

1712
03:02:18.806 --> 03:02:21.376
<v Sameer Kanal>If you have that expertise, it's okay to get into those weeds.

1713
03:02:21.520 --> 03:02:25.936
<v Sameer Kanal>And I've been involved for 1,600-plus of those 1,900 days in this process.

1714
03:02:26.018 --> 03:02:27.351
<v Sameer Kanal>So I am going to get into it.

1715
03:02:27.542 --> 03:02:35.075
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that this is something that it's particularly important because of the fact that it was so strongly supported.

1716
03:02:35.123 --> 03:02:36.023
<v Sameer Kanal>It was a vote of the people.

1717
03:02:36.458 --> 03:02:43.668
<v Sameer Kanal>And this council's— our predecessors primarily have a pattern of kind of disregarding what they have seen from the voters.

1718
03:02:45.370 --> 03:02:46.608
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't think that's true.

1719
03:02:46.752 --> 03:02:51.681
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we owe it to the people to give them a process that lives up to the charter.

1720
03:02:51.729 --> 03:02:57.525
<v Sameer Kanal>And one of the challenges we're facing right now is that there are challenges between the code that the last council adopted and the charter.

1721
03:02:58.136 --> 03:03:09.039
<v Sameer Kanal>But with relation to bias specifically, I think it's fair to say that the evaluators of bias and the evaluation process of bias has to itself be unbiased.

1722
03:03:09.086 --> 03:03:09.215
<v Unidentified speaker>I agree.

1723
03:03:09.536 --> 03:03:12.291
<v Sameer Kanal>That's a fair question to, to try to get an answer to.

1724
03:03:12.661 --> 03:03:16.650
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's not about the people, the individuals, it's about the system that we created.

1725
03:03:17.004 --> 03:03:18.781
<v Sameer Kanal>And by the way, we didn't create that system.

1726
03:03:18.845 --> 03:03:19.920
<v Sameer Kanal>We didn't look at the look-fors.

1727
03:03:19.968 --> 03:03:21.281
<v Sameer Kanal>That was all on the administrative side.

1728
03:03:21.635 --> 03:03:22.836
<v Sameer Kanal>So this is the time to look at that.

1729
03:03:23.253 --> 03:03:24.439
<v Sameer Kanal>I know there's only 2 minutes left.

1730
03:03:24.534 --> 03:03:31.329
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to ask if Skyler Halsey, who's been waiting online, has anything that they would like to say before we pass it back.

1731
03:03:31.666 --> 03:03:46.341
<v Sameer Kanal>But I also want to note one procedural note for the council president, which is that if we were to not vote on this today, which is fine, whether we table it, whether we vote no, whatever, Skyler Halsey is a member of this, this board tonight, and Bob Weinstein is an alternate of this board tonight when it holds its first meeting.

1732
03:03:46.695 --> 03:03:48.682
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm okay with that, but I want everybody to know it.

1733
03:03:49.183 --> 03:03:52.251
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so I just wanted to ask if, if Skyler had anything they'd like to say.

1734
03:03:56.895 --> 03:04:00.033
<v Skylar Halsey>Hey friends, um, do I have to wait to be recognized, or is that—.

1735
03:04:00.066 --> 03:04:00.262
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Go ahead.

1736
03:04:00.472 --> 03:04:01.010
<v Skylar Halsey>Good to go ahead.

1737
03:04:01.189 --> 03:04:01.513
<v Lee Armstrong>All right, thank you.

1738
03:04:03.936 --> 03:04:05.409
<v Skylar Halsey>I didn't have anything prepared.

1739
03:04:05.556 --> 03:04:13.685
<v Skylar Halsey>This kind of came in last minute, and so thank you for Councilmember Kanal and Lisa on his team for helping to make that happen.

1740
03:04:15.971 --> 03:04:22.268
<v Skylar Halsey>I just want to say that ultimately, as long as this process moves forward, that's where my value structure is.

1741
03:04:22.316 --> 03:04:26.828
<v Skylar Halsey>I think that having citizen oversight of our police is increasingly important.

1742
03:04:26.895 --> 03:04:48.343
<v Skylar Halsey>Councilmember And more apparently necessary, and I I just think that anything that is a stumbling block after four years in this process, even if it's unintentional, is showcasing how the system as it exists works against folks that are trying to make that happen.

1743
03:04:49.559 --> 03:04:52.253
<v Skylar Halsey>So anything that stalls this process is.

1744
03:04:54.037 --> 03:05:01.831
<v Skylar Halsey>Is just maintaining, uh, things as they are rather than as was elected 5 years ago, was voted on 5 years ago.

1745
03:05:02.311 --> 03:05:03.002
<v Skylar Halsey>Uh, thank you so much.

1746
03:05:04.172 --> 03:05:11.709
<v Sameer Kanal>So just a point of information, my point in bringing that up earlier is that nothing we do on this, whether we vote yes, vote no, or don't vote on it, can stall it.

1747
03:05:11.773 --> 03:05:12.993
<v Sameer Kanal>That board is meeting tonight.

1748
03:05:13.057 --> 03:05:14.933
<v Sameer Kanal>We're just deciding who's on it tonight or not.

1749
03:05:15.445 --> 03:05:21.478
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and so there, I don't think that there's an impact either way that that meeting's not Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1750
03:05:22.200 --> 03:05:24.128
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I have one last thing to say.

1751
03:05:24.593 --> 03:05:31.513
<v Jamie Dunphy>In 2011, 2012, 2013, I served on the predecessor to the predecessor to the predecessor to the predecessor of this board.

1752
03:05:31.915 --> 03:05:33.697
<v Jamie Dunphy>I served on the Community Police Relations Committee.

1753
03:05:33.745 --> 03:05:33.969
<v Skylar Halsey>I have—.

1754
03:05:34.709 --> 03:05:40.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>I started my career working in crime reduction and gang prevention in a middle school.

1755
03:05:40.906 --> 03:05:42.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>I care deeply about accountable policing.

1756
03:05:43.234 --> 03:05:44.165
<v Jamie Dunphy>I care about public safety.

1757
03:05:44.213 --> 03:05:45.145
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have been doing this for 20 years.

1758
03:05:45.192 --> 03:05:45.305
<v Bill Cunningham>Thank you.

1759
03:05:45.370 --> 03:05:50.109
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've been doing this work for, for, uh, not as intensely as many of my colleagues, but for many years.

1760
03:05:50.927 --> 03:05:56.326
<v Jamie Dunphy>I really care about this procedure, this body, this new system being successful.

1761
03:05:57.193 --> 03:06:00.310
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have also had the opportunity to work with Heidi Brown.

1762
03:06:00.424 --> 03:06:05.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've had an opportunity to work with, uh, the attorneys from the, the Portland Police Association.

1763
03:06:06.191 --> 03:06:11.685
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I came into this hearing today and last time honestly offended.

1764
03:06:11.734 --> 03:06:11.831
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

1765
03:06:12.538 --> 03:06:14.884
<v Jamie Dunphy>At the suggestion that Schuyler would be removed.

1766
03:06:15.606 --> 03:06:22.313
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that first, I think I firmly believe that reposts do not inherently mean endorsements.

1767
03:06:23.007 --> 03:06:25.886
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm a strong believer in the First Amendment in this situation.

1768
03:06:26.403 --> 03:06:29.844
<v Jamie Dunphy>I mean, I guess in most situations that's, you know what I'm saying?

1769
03:06:30.022 --> 03:06:30.733
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry.

1770
03:06:31.733 --> 03:06:40.718
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I also recognize that this entire conversation, the previous one we had, are all now part of a public record that is also in the hands of the PPA.

1771
03:06:41.670 --> 03:06:47.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>And when we have future arbitration, I worry that this will be used to undermine the process.

1772
03:06:49.073 --> 03:06:56.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I really care about the outcome, unfortunately, more than specifically Mr. Halsey's inclusion on it.

1773
03:06:57.681 --> 03:07:00.407
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I want to make sure that this is successful.

1774
03:07:00.456 --> 03:07:09.377
<v Jamie Dunphy>So my opinions have changed largely since we walked in here, and I am eager to move Councilor Kanal, last word.

1775
03:07:10.675 --> 03:07:14.666
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just want to ask, does that mean that if hypothetically—.

1776
03:07:14.666 --> 03:07:30.184
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm not going to do this— I chose to assert and spend a lot of time asserting and putting into the public record that some other member of this body was biased, that the very fact that we have this discussion makes it more or less likely that we're going to remove someone?

1777
03:07:30.298 --> 03:07:32.269
<v Sameer Kanal>Because that seems like an incredibly unfair standard.

1778
03:07:32.753 --> 03:07:48.700
<v Sameer Kanal>That if we're going to have the conversation impact our votes, that any one of us could just say, hey, this person— I'm not picking on anyone in particular, I'm not going to use a name as a hypothetical— is biased or is unsuited, or if I just come up with something random that's never been brought up.

1779
03:07:49.006 --> 03:07:54.941
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just want to raise that as a concern here, that that can't be the only standard that determines it.

1780
03:07:55.168 --> 03:07:56.030
<v Sameer Kanal>I just, I had to float it.

1781
03:07:56.078 --> 03:07:56.615
<v Sameer Kanal>I apologize.

1782
03:07:57.200 --> 03:07:57.672
<v Eric Engstrom>That's—.

1783
03:07:58.234 --> 03:07:58.764
<v Jamie Dunphy>A fair point.

1784
03:08:00.551 --> 03:08:05.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, I would like to move to the divided question that we have now.

1785
03:08:06.041 --> 03:08:08.831
<v Eric Zimmerman>Make sure we really clarify so we all know exactly what we're voting on.

1786
03:08:08.896 --> 03:08:09.073
<v Skylar Halsey>Very clearly.

1787
03:08:09.510 --> 03:08:17.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>The first item that I'm going to ask colleagues to vote on is the, uh, with regard to Skylar Halsey.

1788
03:08:17.849 --> 03:08:29.299
<v Jamie Dunphy>If I— if you vote yes on this vote, that is to remove Mr. A no vote is to keep him on the board.

1789
03:08:30.058 --> 03:08:30.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Am I correct?

1790
03:08:30.882 --> 03:08:31.254
<v Jake Antles>Is that okay?

1791
03:08:31.690 --> 03:08:33.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm looking for everybody because I want to baby step this.

1792
03:08:33.656 --> 03:08:33.915
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

1793
03:08:34.690 --> 03:08:36.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call the roll on the first part?

1794
03:08:37.257 --> 03:08:38.110
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

1795
03:08:41.726 --> 03:08:41.967
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1796
03:08:43.333 --> 03:08:44.137
<v Angelita Morillo>No.

1797
03:08:45.760 --> 03:08:45.936
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1798
03:08:49.459 --> 03:08:49.636
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No.

1799
03:08:51.881 --> 03:08:53.076
<v Heidi Brown>No.

1800
03:08:53.819 --> 03:08:53.869
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1801
03:08:55.759 --> 03:08:55.808
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1802
03:08:57.298 --> 03:08:57.557
<v Priya Dhanapal>No.

1803
03:09:00.697 --> 03:09:01.134
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

1804
03:09:02.331 --> 03:09:02.655
<v James Bernard Lee>No.

1805
03:09:06.780 --> 03:09:15.566
<v Keelan McClymont>So the motion to divide Has failed.

1806
03:09:17.896 --> 03:09:18.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1807
03:09:19.567 --> 03:09:20.595
<v Keelan McClymont>Which means—.

1808
03:09:20.950 --> 03:09:25.218
<v Sameer Kanal>The divided portion has— the divided portion has failed, right?

1809
03:09:25.688 --> 03:09:27.239
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The motion to divide has not failed.

1810
03:09:27.304 --> 03:09:28.209
<v Sameer Kanal>That, that already—.

1811
03:09:28.451 --> 03:09:39.208
<v Unidentified speaker>The divided portion, which would remove Mr. Hulsey from— I'm going to screw up the acronym— from the group, fails.

1812
03:09:40.838 --> 03:09:43.069
<v Keelan McClymont>So the member remains on the board.

1813
03:09:43.471 --> 03:09:44.403
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is very confusing.

1814
03:09:44.980 --> 03:09:47.372
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for your patience in helping us work through this.

1815
03:09:47.870 --> 03:09:48.640
<v Candace Avalos>Point of information.

1816
03:09:48.689 --> 03:09:53.552
<v Candace Avalos>So in other words, Mr. Halsey remains on the board as a result of this vote?

1817
03:09:54.050 --> 03:09:54.194
<v Heidi Brown>Yes.

1818
03:09:54.885 --> 03:09:56.378
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1819
03:09:57.502 --> 03:10:01.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please call the roll on the question of Mr. Weinstein?

1820
03:10:02.959 --> 03:10:03.184
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

1821
03:10:03.843 --> 03:10:07.503
<v Jamie Dunphy>Wait, yeah, just again, a yes vote is to remove.

1822
03:10:09.045 --> 03:10:12.368
<v Jamie Dunphy>To follow the staff recommendation as written in here and include him in removal.

1823
03:10:12.433 --> 03:10:18.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>A no vote is to not— to keep him on the board as an alternate.

1824
03:10:18.275 --> 03:10:18.663
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1825
03:10:19.950 --> 03:10:21.254
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

1826
03:10:25.730 --> 03:10:27.004
<v Loretta Smith>A no vote is to keep it?

1827
03:10:27.425 --> 03:10:31.733
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, correct.

1828
03:10:32.138 --> 03:10:33.254
<v Loretta Smith>Keep the names on the list?

1829
03:10:33.843 --> 03:10:34.734
<v Sameer Kanal>No, a no vote is to—.

1830
03:10:34.993 --> 03:10:35.186
<v James Bernard Lee>Sorry.

1831
03:10:35.931 --> 03:10:41.369
<v Jamie Dunphy>A no vote will keep Mr. Weinstein as an alternate on the board.

1832
03:10:42.418 --> 03:10:43.132
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1833
03:10:44.546 --> 03:10:44.643
<v Bob Weinstein>No.

1834
03:10:46.412 --> 03:10:47.629
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1835
03:10:48.441 --> 03:10:48.570
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1836
03:10:50.543 --> 03:10:50.995
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

1837
03:10:52.060 --> 03:10:52.415
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1838
03:10:53.191 --> 03:10:53.416
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

1839
03:10:53.530 --> 03:10:54.352
<v Loretta Smith>5-3.

1840
03:10:54.902 --> 03:10:55.128
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1841
03:10:57.145 --> 03:10:57.693
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

1842
03:10:59.530 --> 03:10:59.738
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes.

1843
03:11:03.971 --> 03:11:04.165
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

1844
03:11:06.295 --> 03:11:06.569
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1845
03:11:09.141 --> 03:11:09.368
<v Olivia Clark>No.

1846
03:11:11.309 --> 03:11:11.439
<v Heidi Brown>Yes.

1847
03:11:12.280 --> 03:11:12.394
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

1848
03:11:16.170 --> 03:11:16.443
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1849
03:11:19.880 --> 03:11:28.438
<v Keelan McClymont>The division is approved, which means The member is removed from the board.

1850
03:11:28.682 --> 03:11:32.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please call the roll on the remainder of the report?

1851
03:11:34.530 --> 03:11:34.773
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

1852
03:11:35.213 --> 03:11:39.584
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, and again, a yes is to accept the report, no is to not accept the report.

1853
03:11:40.206 --> 03:11:41.170
<v Sameer Kanal>It's the rest of—.

1854
03:11:41.170 --> 03:11:41.733
<v Jamie Dunphy>The rest of the report.

1855
03:11:41.829 --> 03:11:42.762
<v Sameer Kanal>The rest of the report.

1856
03:11:42.810 --> 03:11:44.322
<v Sameer Kanal>So this is just the resignations, the—.

1857
03:11:44.483 --> 03:11:44.675
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1858
03:11:44.869 --> 03:11:45.559
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, all that stuff.

1859
03:11:45.609 --> 03:11:46.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is approving the rest of the report.

1860
03:11:46.895 --> 03:11:48.677
<v Sameer Kanal>Either of these 2 people we just talked about.

1861
03:11:49.156 --> 03:11:49.670
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

1862
03:11:50.165 --> 03:11:51.537
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, so then yes.

1863
03:11:58.375 --> 03:11:59.033
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

1864
03:11:59.822 --> 03:12:03.935
<v Dan Ryan>Point of clarification, sorry, that was, uh, rushed for me.

1865
03:12:04.322 --> 03:12:11.236
<v Dan Ryan>So if the vote here is about the totality, it's whatever we didn't— the 2 that we just voted on, the other part, it's the—.

1866
03:12:11.334 --> 03:12:13.352
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's everything that we haven't voted on so far.

1867
03:12:13.433 --> 03:12:15.935
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're basically voting on a report because we divided them.

1868
03:12:16.103 --> 03:12:16.608
<v Dan Ryan>Got it.

1869
03:12:16.709 --> 03:12:18.537
<v Dan Ryan>But suddenly I thought this This was a big enchilada.

1870
03:12:18.698 --> 03:12:19.566
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, um, aye.

1871
03:12:22.397 --> 03:12:22.430
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1872
03:12:23.186 --> 03:12:23.588
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo.

1873
03:12:26.094 --> 03:12:26.127
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1874
03:12:27.556 --> 03:12:27.685
<v Heidi Brown>Aye.

1875
03:12:29.584 --> 03:12:30.006
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

1876
03:12:30.477 --> 03:12:30.494
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1877
03:12:31.128 --> 03:12:31.435
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

1878
03:12:32.610 --> 03:12:32.641
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1879
03:12:33.204 --> 03:12:35.344
<v Keelan McClymont>The report is accepted with 12 yes votes.

1880
03:12:35.843 --> 03:12:42.869
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we are going to carry item 9 over to tomorrow, Thursday afternoon's council hearing, and with that, I recess.

1881
03:12:44.153 --> 03:12:46.613
<v Jamie Dunphy>The City Council session.

1882
03:12:47.391 --> 03:12:47.602
<v Jake Antles>Thank you.

