WEBVTT

1
00:04:17.708 --> 00:04:17.966
<v Unidentified speaker>Cool.

2
00:04:18.194 --> 00:04:19.084
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

3
00:04:19.165 --> 00:04:25.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm calling to order the meeting of the Portland City Council for the morning of Wednesday, February 4th.

4
00:04:26.281 --> 00:04:27.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>May I please call the roll?

5
00:04:29.281 --> 00:04:29.670
<v Keelan McClymont>Good morning.

6
00:04:30.011 --> 00:04:30.319
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

7
00:04:30.675 --> 00:04:30.903
<v Candace Avalos>Here.

8
00:04:33.959 --> 00:04:34.297
<v Keelan McClymont>Here.

9
00:04:35.084 --> 00:04:35.245
<v Unidentified speaker>Here.

10
00:04:35.567 --> 00:04:35.663
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

11
00:04:35.968 --> 00:04:36.098
<v Keelan McClymont>Here.

12
00:04:36.146 --> 00:04:36.242
<v Unidentified speaker>Here.

13
00:04:36.370 --> 00:04:36.805
<v David Pearl>Here.

14
00:04:37.095 --> 00:04:37.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

15
00:04:37.980 --> 00:04:38.252
<v Keelan McClymont>Here.

16
00:04:39.122 --> 00:04:39.314
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

17
00:04:39.442 --> 00:04:41.196
<v Dan Ryan>I will be, um, online today.

18
00:04:41.533 --> 00:04:43.399
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, thanks everyone, don't want to spread germs.

19
00:04:44.689 --> 00:04:45.624
<v Unidentified speaker>Here.

20
00:04:46.880 --> 00:04:47.154
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

21
00:04:48.266 --> 00:04:48.379
<v Steve Novick>Here.

22
00:04:48.911 --> 00:04:49.250
<v Keelan McClymont>Here.

23
00:04:50.264 --> 00:04:50.377
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

24
00:04:56.471 --> 00:04:58.036
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, everybody.

25
00:05:00.221 --> 00:05:01.752
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please note Councilor Kanal is here as well.

26
00:05:03.329 --> 00:05:03.377
<v Jonas Biery>Hi.

27
00:05:03.750 --> 00:05:07.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, first thing on our agenda is agenda approval.

28
00:05:07.891 --> 00:05:09.653
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there any requests to amend?

29
00:05:09.735 --> 00:05:12.822
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, oh, and could we please read the rules of decorum?

30
00:05:12.983 --> 00:05:13.387
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

31
00:05:14.353 --> 00:05:15.012
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good flag.

32
00:05:16.365 --> 00:05:17.992
<v Mitch Green>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

33
00:05:18.055 --> 00:05:24.194
<v Mitch Green>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

34
00:05:27.290 --> 00:05:31.103
<v Jamie Dunphy>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's website webpage.

35
00:05:31.663 --> 00:05:35.559
<v Mitch Green>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

36
00:05:35.992 --> 00:05:38.252
<v Mitch Green>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

37
00:05:38.797 --> 00:05:40.480
<v Mitch Green>The presiding officer preserves order.

38
00:05:40.641 --> 00:05:49.024
<v Mitch Green>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

39
00:05:49.922 --> 00:05:52.230
<v Mitch Green>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

40
00:05:52.646 --> 00:05:55.196
<v Mitch Green>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

41
00:05:55.629 --> 00:05:58.963
<v Mitch Green>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

42
00:05:59.540 --> 00:06:05.812
<v Mitch Green>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene Your testimony should address a matter being considered.

43
00:06:06.374 --> 00:06:08.461
<v Mitch Green>When testifying, state your name for the record.

44
00:06:08.846 --> 00:06:10.307
<v Mitch Green>Your address is not necessary.

45
00:06:10.771 --> 00:06:13.886
<v Mitch Green>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

46
00:06:14.382 --> 00:06:17.946
<v Mitch Green>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

47
00:06:18.091 --> 00:06:18.396
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

48
00:06:19.117 --> 00:06:20.257
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

49
00:06:21.124 --> 00:06:27.415
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I will note that some items have been pulled from the consent agenda and have been moved, uh, to be read after item 11.

50
00:06:28.351 --> 00:06:33.084
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there any other, uh, changes to the order of the agenda?

51
00:06:35.670 --> 00:06:36.091
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, sir.

52
00:06:36.252 --> 00:06:38.697
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, do I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

53
00:06:39.004 --> 00:06:42.843
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing happy little nods, the agenda is approved.

54
00:06:43.394 --> 00:06:44.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can you please call public communications?

55
00:06:49.314 --> 00:06:51.088
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Jim Rice.

56
00:06:53.911 --> 00:06:54.601
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Jim.

57
00:06:54.668 --> 00:06:56.002
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please introduce yourself for the record.

58
00:06:58.632 --> 00:06:59.500
<v Jim Rice>My name is Jim Rice.

59
00:07:00.884 --> 00:07:09.708
<v Jim Rice>Council members, amazing, caring citizens, small businesses are the culture soul of Portland, and we are at risk of losing it.

60
00:07:10.161 --> 00:07:14.805
<v Jim Rice>I'm a small business owner who survived the pandemic, riots, and being burglarized 15 times.

61
00:07:15.485 --> 00:07:17.314
<v Jim Rice>But we are now entering our darkest time.

62
00:07:18.322 --> 00:07:25.139
<v Jim Rice>Over the last 3 years, I've watched over 100 businesses with hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of jobs leaving our neighborhood.

63
00:07:25.139 --> 00:07:30.699
<v Jim Rice>Most, like REI, stating safety, homeless, and crime as the primary reasons.

64
00:07:30.699 --> 00:07:33.750
<v Jim Rice>Others failed because people stopped coming to Portland.

65
00:07:33.959 --> 00:07:41.339
<v Jim Rice>The inconvenient truth is 43% of small businesses here in Portland are losing money, not including those marginally in the black.

66
00:07:41.339 --> 00:07:50.319
<v Jim Rice>That's over 10,900 businesses that are on the ropes, potentially impacting 70,000 to 100,000 employees.

67
00:07:50.459 --> 00:07:53.560
<v Jim Rice>25,000 Jobs have been lost in the past year and a lot more to come.

68
00:07:53.560 --> 00:07:57.939
<v Jim Rice>Councilmember We are now ranked in the top 10 worst places for business survival.

69
00:07:58.581 --> 00:08:08.089
<v Jim Rice>We are fighting to make payroll for our teams, desperately trying to survive while fighting against cascading taxes, crime, shocking homeless issues, and inflation.

70
00:08:09.084 --> 00:08:10.815
<v Jim Rice>I'm meeting with business owners across the city.

71
00:08:11.233 --> 00:08:12.660
<v Jim Rice>All of them have horrific stories.

72
00:08:13.156 --> 00:08:21.382
<v Jim Rice>67% Have been hit by crime in the past year, unmanageable homeless issues, lack of 911 response, and the feeling that we are totally on our own.

73
00:08:21.511 --> 00:08:21.639
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

74
00:08:22.233 --> 00:08:23.211
<v Jim Rice>And no one seems to care.

75
00:08:24.064 --> 00:08:27.291
<v Jim Rice>I, like many, have stopped reporting crimes as it's a waste of time.

76
00:08:27.452 --> 00:08:28.754
<v Jim Rice>Police don't have the capacity.

77
00:08:29.059 --> 00:08:31.276
<v Jim Rice>We have half the police officers of an average city.

78
00:08:32.191 --> 00:08:35.130
<v Jim Rice>Many owners I'm meeting with are talking about leaving Oregon.

79
00:08:35.708 --> 00:08:41.604
<v Jim Rice>I'm watching streams of regular customers leaving every week, not for the suburbs, but leaving the state.

80
00:08:41.812 --> 00:08:45.731
<v Jim Rice>They too have given up on our government's ability to fix our problems.

81
00:08:46.631 --> 00:08:47.418
<v Jim Rice>Businesses leaving.

82
00:08:47.707 --> 00:08:50.991
<v Jim Rice>Citizens leaving, jobs leaving, tax revenue leaving.

83
00:08:51.841 --> 00:08:57.993
<v Jim Rice>Your $67 million financial gap is just the beginning, though I understand you found $21 million in the couch cushions.

84
00:08:58.649 --> 00:09:01.822
<v Jim Rice>You may want to look under all the cushions because the coming years are going to be worse.

85
00:09:03.216 --> 00:09:04.835
<v Jim Rice>Portland has started the death spiral.

86
00:09:05.091 --> 00:09:06.836
<v Jim Rice>Soon you're not going to be able to stop it.

87
00:09:08.102 --> 00:09:09.769
<v Jim Rice>You are presented with a lot of issues.

88
00:09:09.945 --> 00:09:11.067
<v Jim Rice>This is extremely serious.

89
00:09:11.964 --> 00:09:18.024
<v Jim Rice>Councilors, are you focused on fixing the issues causing your financial problems while saving the soul of our city.

90
00:09:18.846 --> 00:09:23.025
<v Jim Rice>Ask yourselves, what would a small business or investor—.

91
00:09:23.283 --> 00:09:23.509
<v Dan Ryan>What would—.

92
00:09:23.849 --> 00:09:23.994
<v Loretta Smith>What—.

93
00:09:24.897 --> 00:09:25.977
<v Jim Rice>Why would they want to stay?

94
00:09:26.107 --> 00:09:27.607
<v Jim Rice>Why would a small business want to stay?

95
00:09:28.285 --> 00:09:31.014
<v Jim Rice>What are you doing to be able to help small businesses survive?

96
00:09:31.756 --> 00:09:36.788
<v Jim Rice>What will be the impact to your budget and Portland when these businesses continue to fail?

97
00:09:39.269 --> 00:09:42.221
<v Jim Rice>Truly, the future of Portland is in your hands.

98
00:09:42.336 --> 00:09:42.434
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

99
00:09:43.182 --> 00:09:43.489
<v Jim Rice>Thank you.

100
00:09:43.989 --> 00:09:44.408
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

101
00:09:47.775 --> 00:09:50.563
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Jesse Akins.

102
00:09:55.929 --> 00:09:56.851
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, good morning Portland.

103
00:09:57.094 --> 00:09:58.274
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, I am Jesse Akins.

104
00:09:58.404 --> 00:10:01.591
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a disabled veteran of the United States Army.

105
00:10:01.673 --> 00:10:03.322
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hey Jesse, we are having a hard time hearing you.

106
00:10:03.566 --> 00:10:05.201
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, I had a feeling you would say that because—.

107
00:10:05.201 --> 00:10:05.886
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, friend.

108
00:10:06.881 --> 00:10:08.626
<v Unidentified speaker>How is that?

109
00:10:08.692 --> 00:10:09.067
<v Steve Novick>Is that better?

110
00:10:09.556 --> 00:10:11.142
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, yes, much better.

111
00:10:11.318 --> 00:10:14.458
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, Zoom is not optimized for me right now.

112
00:10:15.004 --> 00:10:17.600
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so I, again, I'm Jesse Akins.

113
00:10:17.648 --> 00:10:19.602
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a Portland resident of District 3.

114
00:10:19.763 --> 00:10:21.398
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a disabled combat Army veteran.

115
00:10:21.509 --> 00:10:23.928
<v Unidentified speaker>Get it all screwed up because of the volume.

116
00:10:23.993 --> 00:10:24.763
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks, volume.

117
00:10:25.932 --> 00:10:27.647
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyways, I'm just here for a couple of short things.

118
00:10:27.982 --> 00:10:45.263
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I was going to say some other things, but, um, in regards to, uh, what happened at the The protest over the— recently where, where a lot of civilians were gassed, um, and shot with pepper balls and, and things like that.

119
00:10:45.392 --> 00:10:46.049
<v Unidentified speaker>I wasn't there.

120
00:10:46.226 --> 00:10:47.302
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm disabled, like I said.

121
00:10:47.801 --> 00:10:53.407
<v Unidentified speaker>Showing up to those kinds of things is very disastrous for my health when that sort of thing happens.

122
00:10:54.225 --> 00:10:59.750
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I would love to show up at more protests for a variety of reasons.

123
00:11:00.249 --> 00:11:01.549
<v Unidentified speaker>I can't because they're not safe for me.

124
00:11:01.629 --> 00:11:01.807
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

125
00:11:04.831 --> 00:11:07.530
<v Unidentified speaker>So, and many others, and it's far worse for many others.

126
00:11:08.847 --> 00:11:20.268
<v Unidentified speaker>And the reason I bring this up is because we keep talking about the Supremacy Clause and the things that we can't do and the things that we can't do and the things that we can't do, but we don't talk about what we can do and what we have done in the past.

127
00:11:20.750 --> 00:11:27.360
<v Unidentified speaker>And what I've personally seen in the past in our city and many others across the country is the police acting as a bully.

128
00:11:27.424 --> 00:11:27.573
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

129
00:11:27.659 --> 00:11:32.797
<v Unidentified speaker>Bulwark between hostile elements towards protesters.

130
00:11:33.294 --> 00:11:53.365
<v Unidentified speaker>Normally we've seen that in the cases of right-wing protesters being bulwarked against not right-wing protesters, neo-Nazis, white supremacists being bulwarked against others, aka the police with their backs towards the right wing and the neo-Nazis and the white supremacists, but not the other people.

131
00:11:55.452 --> 00:11:57.379
<v Unidentified speaker>Why can't we do something like that?

132
00:11:57.797 --> 00:12:06.145
<v Unidentified speaker>Police, they're not arresting, they're not engaging, they're simply acting as a bulwark between the people and the hostile entities.

133
00:12:06.948 --> 00:12:09.678
<v Unidentified speaker>Hostile entity opens fire, where are the rounds going to go?

134
00:12:09.903 --> 00:12:12.537
<v Unidentified speaker>Into police shields rather than children.

135
00:12:13.211 --> 00:12:17.065
<v Unidentified speaker>Just a suggestion for our further deliberation on the subject.

136
00:12:17.947 --> 00:12:18.542
<v Unidentified speaker>Something to consider.

137
00:12:18.621 --> 00:12:18.783
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

138
00:12:19.072 --> 00:12:20.022
<v Unidentified speaker>Something to think about.

139
00:12:20.424 --> 00:12:26.317
<v Unidentified speaker>And as a side note, I would like to say that the soul of Portland is not REI.

140
00:12:27.768 --> 00:12:29.072
<v Unidentified speaker>That's just my opinion.

141
00:12:29.153 --> 00:12:34.298
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, I hope you all have a wonderful day, um, and we have some progress today.

142
00:12:34.443 --> 00:12:34.717
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

143
00:12:35.572 --> 00:12:37.342
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Jesse.

144
00:12:38.336 --> 00:12:39.947
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Julie Winters.

145
00:12:46.524 --> 00:12:48.360
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi there, folks.

146
00:12:49.649 --> 00:12:51.888
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, for the record, my name is Julie Winters.

147
00:12:53.397 --> 00:12:59.192
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of you may have seen me before, some of you may have not.

148
00:13:01.429 --> 00:13:02.985
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I'm going to try and make this really quick.

149
00:13:04.519 --> 00:13:11.125
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, first question, are you all required to review the PCC EP footage?

150
00:13:11.173 --> 00:13:11.239
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

151
00:13:13.153 --> 00:13:15.145
<v Unidentified speaker>And the PCC EP listening sessions?

152
00:13:17.440 --> 00:13:22.193
<v Unidentified speaker>Can I just see a show of hands if anyone did for the, for the death of Damien Johnson?

153
00:13:23.923 --> 00:13:24.236
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone?

154
00:13:25.658 --> 00:13:26.681
<v Unidentified speaker>Did any of you see that?

155
00:13:29.482 --> 00:13:31.158
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Ms. Lane.

156
00:13:32.428 --> 00:13:44.515
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm not going to go over my story again because I've been posting the body cams of it for a year now.

157
00:13:45.817 --> 00:13:56.727
<v Unidentified speaker>But to put it shortly, I was suffocated to death by 2 Portland police officers in a belly-prone position a year ago, December 7th, 2024.

158
00:13:56.777 --> 00:13:58.193
<v Unidentified speaker>I was shot with ketamine against my will.

159
00:13:59.528 --> 00:14:04.073
<v Unidentified speaker>I was then brought to Legacy Emanuel, and I woke up with a Jane Doe tag around my wrist.

160
00:14:07.500 --> 00:14:08.452
<v Unidentified speaker>They never gave me a lawyer.

161
00:14:10.216 --> 00:14:15.783
<v Unidentified speaker>Then they dropped my charges 9 months later after not giving me my constitutionally protected right to a lawyer.

162
00:14:17.115 --> 00:14:24.044
<v Unidentified speaker>I have 2 and a half hours worth of body cams that prove that there's a cover-up.

163
00:14:26.047 --> 00:14:26.207
<v Unidentified speaker>They—.

164
00:14:26.207 --> 00:14:30.285
<v Unidentified speaker>Somebody in DA's office messed up and gave me all of their internal affairs body cams too.

165
00:14:33.916 --> 00:14:39.125
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, 3 days after the PCC EP listening session, the DA dropped my charges.

166
00:14:40.600 --> 00:15:02.182
<v Unidentified speaker>They charged me with assaulting the officer that hit me 17 times in the face, and then his trainee had me on the ground with my hands behind the back— behind my back— and sat there until I was no longer breathing, didn't have a pulse, and Didn't have any type of response at all.

167
00:15:03.610 --> 00:15:16.471
<v Unidentified speaker>Between that time and the time that I woke up in the back of an AMR ambulance and begged the people like they—I mean—I don't remember that time, but I woke up in the back of an ambulance with somebody trying to stick a needle in me, and I lost it.

168
00:15:17.339 --> 00:15:23.664
<v Unidentified speaker>Now, then I woke up again after the ketamine started to wear off in Legacy Emanuel with.

169
00:15:24.227 --> 00:15:25.774
<v Unidentified speaker>I see that.

170
00:15:26.644 --> 00:15:30.513
<v Unidentified speaker>But anyways, long story short, I wasn't a suspect in a crime.

171
00:15:30.787 --> 00:15:32.059
<v Unidentified speaker>I was asking for help.

172
00:15:33.302 --> 00:15:46.995
<v Unidentified speaker>I had broken an axle on my car, and your city public safety officer refused to call an ambulance because I mentioned that maybe the EMTs could check my cat out.

173
00:15:48.597 --> 00:15:55.934
<v Unidentified speaker>But I also like Have my leg needed to be checked out too, but she decided because of my cat that she wasn't going to call an ambulance.

174
00:15:57.364 --> 00:16:01.778
<v Unidentified speaker>I would really like to avoid a long and costly litigation process between all of you.

175
00:16:03.080 --> 00:16:03.658
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

176
00:16:03.706 --> 00:16:07.880
<v Unidentified speaker>And, and, and the chief of police, Bob Day, who acts like he doesn't know.

177
00:16:08.458 --> 00:16:08.875
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

178
00:16:08.956 --> 00:16:09.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, we have to—.

179
00:16:09.744 --> 00:16:12.489
<v Unidentified speaker>I know, but it's very important.

180
00:16:12.552 --> 00:16:18.745
<v Unidentified speaker>That's the thing, I've been writing to all of you Over and over again for months now.

181
00:16:19.975 --> 00:16:21.850
<v Unidentified speaker>I've gotten a response from—.

182
00:16:21.850 --> 00:16:22.740
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, thank you.

183
00:16:22.869 --> 00:16:25.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have, we have to move to the next person, unfortunately.

184
00:16:26.288 --> 00:16:26.562
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm sorry.

185
00:16:26.739 --> 00:16:28.284
<v Unidentified speaker>Please show respect to your constituents.

186
00:16:28.768 --> 00:16:29.057
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

187
00:16:29.153 --> 00:16:33.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, I'm sorry, but I— we do have a time limit on here and we're 40 seconds over.

188
00:16:33.210 --> 00:16:33.565
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm sorry.

189
00:16:34.370 --> 00:16:37.419
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

190
00:16:37.711 --> 00:16:44.001
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland Police Department is complicit in the near murder of me And are still attempting to cover it up.

191
00:16:44.082 --> 00:16:46.129
<v Unidentified speaker>DA Vasquez refiled the charges.

192
00:16:46.629 --> 00:16:48.433
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have David Pearl.

193
00:16:50.386 --> 00:16:52.496
<v Unidentified speaker>And this is how I get treated.

194
00:16:54.365 --> 00:16:55.542
<v Unidentified speaker>Duly noted.

195
00:16:56.817 --> 00:16:57.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for being here.

196
00:16:59.913 --> 00:17:04.416
<v Unidentified speaker>Police are corrupt as hell, and you guys won't do anything about any of it.

197
00:17:05.462 --> 00:17:06.186
<v David Pearl>Name for the record?

198
00:17:06.364 --> 00:17:06.863
<v David Pearl>David Pearl.

199
00:17:08.208 --> 00:17:12.893
<v David Pearl>In the end, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends.

200
00:17:14.257 --> 00:17:23.915
<v David Pearl>Martin Luther King Jr. As we watch the Trump regime wreak havoc on Minneapolis, we must be ever vigilant in protecting our own people, people's lives and liberties.

201
00:17:25.134 --> 00:17:31.857
<v David Pearl>As the reality is, this is only the beginning, and these escalations and assaults on our rights and freedoms will only continue to get worse.

202
00:17:32.194 --> 00:17:32.596
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, it will.

203
00:17:33.076 --> 00:17:37.422
<v David Pearl>However, our governor and mayor have continued in failing Sorry.

204
00:17:37.923 --> 00:17:40.482
<v David Pearl>In providing anything more than just lip service.

205
00:17:41.340 --> 00:17:46.843
<v David Pearl>Thousands of peaceful protesters, including children and seniors, were gassed by ICE just over the weekend.

206
00:17:47.742 --> 00:17:55.989
<v David Pearl>The immediate response was to create a council to create plans of attack with implementation by May 30th.

207
00:17:56.490 --> 00:18:04.016
<v David Pearl>This response is a direct admission by our elected leaders that they are clueless as to how to stop the federal government's overreach.

208
00:18:05.076 --> 00:18:12.195
<v David Pearl>Which is particularly troubling as it was leaked that after Minneapolis, they are directing their assaults to our city of Portland.

209
00:18:13.141 --> 00:18:20.306
<v David Pearl>Our leaders must rise to the occasion and provide meaningful strategy of how to protect our city, not in 4 months, but today.

210
00:18:21.275 --> 00:18:24.385
<v David Pearl>While the lack of action is frustrating, it is anything but surprising.

211
00:18:26.268 --> 00:18:33.673
<v David Pearl>Historians have spent decades analyzing the question as to why people do not stand up against the forms of injustice we are seeing.

212
00:18:33.769 --> 00:18:33.948
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

213
00:18:34.607 --> 00:18:35.079
<v Candace Avalos>The answer?

214
00:18:36.057 --> 00:18:36.936
<v David Pearl>They thought we were safe.

215
00:18:38.930 --> 00:18:44.403
<v David Pearl>They thought if they focused on their jobs, they were doing what was best for themselves and families, and that this would eventually pass.

216
00:18:45.250 --> 00:18:45.827
<v David Pearl>They were safe.

217
00:18:46.406 --> 00:18:52.419
<v David Pearl>They thought that their positions of power and influence was too important, that nothing would happen to them.

218
00:18:52.998 --> 00:18:53.608
<v David Pearl>They were safe.

219
00:18:54.329 --> 00:18:59.107
<v David Pearl>They thought that if they aided their oppressors' causes, that they would be seen as one of the good ones.

220
00:18:59.916 --> 00:19:00.510
<v David Pearl>They were safe.

221
00:19:01.682 --> 00:19:09.676
<v David Pearl>As neighbors were removed from their homes and publicly assailed in the streets, clearly those targeted had done something wrong and deserved it.

222
00:19:10.126 --> 00:19:10.978
<v David Pearl>Couldn't be them.

223
00:19:11.876 --> 00:19:17.046
<v David Pearl>As judges and political opposition were stripped of their titles and replaced, trust in the system.

224
00:19:17.832 --> 00:19:26.277
<v David Pearl>And finally, when the ranks were purged of what the regime deemed useful idiots, they still desperately clung to the belief that this must be a mistake.

225
00:19:26.340 --> 00:19:26.469
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

226
00:19:26.982 --> 00:19:29.840
<v David Pearl>That they had done nothing wrong and that they were still safe.

227
00:19:30.371 --> 00:19:38.590
<v David Pearl>If you are anything but a white Christian male nationalist, you should be deeply concerned as to what is happening in our country.

228
00:19:39.425 --> 00:19:46.218
<v David Pearl>You are not safe, and we need everyone in our public office to be taking steps that proactively combat these escalations.

229
00:19:47.196 --> 00:19:49.925
<v David Pearl>We need immediate action and leadership, and we need it today.

230
00:19:50.327 --> 00:19:50.808
<v David Pearl>Thank you.

231
00:19:51.307 --> 00:19:52.205
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here.

232
00:19:56.332 --> 00:19:58.160
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Addie Smith.

233
00:20:03.059 --> 00:20:03.545
<v Keelan McClymont>Addie Smith.

234
00:20:06.002 --> 00:20:09.124
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, um, the alternate, Kenny Gonzalez.

235
00:20:13.613 --> 00:20:13.903
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

236
00:20:14.421 --> 00:20:14.953
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning.

237
00:20:17.265 --> 00:20:19.397
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Kenny Gonzalez.

238
00:20:20.251 --> 00:20:31.101
<v Unidentified speaker>I come here to review Section 1983, which allows us to sue anyone in any government-playing role.

239
00:20:32.029 --> 00:21:03.606
<v Unidentified speaker>And to that fact, I want to say, before that ends up happening and affects every single one of you, help me in a way kind of establish the U.S. Code 42 U.S. Code Section 1983, due to the fact of Trump's policies are hurting all our young ones from having good healthy food since schools should provide healthy meals.

240
00:21:04.346 --> 00:21:18.949
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a domino effect going on here because if you— if the kids can't go to school, That affects the parents coming to pick one of the two to stay home and watch the kids.

241
00:21:19.768 --> 00:21:27.384
<v Unidentified speaker>And it as well affects bringing in money to support the house, so they make less.

242
00:21:28.461 --> 00:21:42.539
<v Unidentified speaker>I have the rights under the city, which remains in the county and got— and goes into The county is followed to the state and so on.

243
00:21:42.604 --> 00:21:51.260
<v Unidentified speaker>The domino effect again, as I bring back, our laws were put in play for the people, by the people.

244
00:21:51.711 --> 00:21:58.805
<v Unidentified speaker>Trump has no right to deprive— sorry for my spelling—.

245
00:21:59.079 --> 00:22:00.615
<v Steve Novick>Deprive.

246
00:22:06.808 --> 00:22:25.315
<v Unidentified speaker>Deprived the people from food or shelter, which, uh, due to the lack of making money, because money seems to hold more power and value than a human life or voice.

247
00:22:25.957 --> 00:22:28.507
<v Unidentified speaker>Money talks more than humans.

248
00:22:29.115 --> 00:22:33.403
<v Unidentified speaker>Some Voices are shut out when it comes to money.

249
00:22:34.401 --> 00:22:50.896
<v Unidentified speaker>Now we come back to the domino effect going on and needing to point out we are at war with Trump and the federal government because Trump is acting as a terrorist.

250
00:22:51.383 --> 00:22:52.338
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

251
00:22:54.396 --> 00:23:14.443
<v Unidentified speaker>You have 30 more seconds if you need it, so Okay, and then I have here about the legislative, executive, and judicial branch about starting a cycle with the ground form with 3 connectors are needed, but keep in mind you only need 2 to form a cycle.

252
00:23:15.164 --> 00:23:29.442
<v Unidentified speaker>So we have all 3, but the judicial branch wants to check the executive branch But they need to check the legislative branch before jumping into the executive.

253
00:23:29.781 --> 00:23:30.347
<v Unidentified speaker>That is all.

254
00:23:30.671 --> 00:23:31.075
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

255
00:23:31.301 --> 00:23:32.578
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here this morning.

256
00:23:33.378 --> 00:23:34.941
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes communications.

257
00:23:35.537 --> 00:23:36.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

258
00:23:38.114 --> 00:23:40.932
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, next on our agenda is the committee referral report.

259
00:23:41.335 --> 00:23:48.203
<v Jamie Dunphy>For colleagues and folks watching at home, my office has referred several items to committee last week, some of which have already been heard.

260
00:23:48.942 --> 00:23:52.935
<v Jamie Dunphy>Those items are listed on the committee referral report, which is available online at portland.gov/auditor.

261
00:23:54.056 --> 00:24:01.835
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor McClymont, can we please call item 4?

262
00:24:02.865 --> 00:24:15.711
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 4, time certain, add nondiscrimination requirements for single occupant restrooms in places of public accommodation code to establish equal restroom access by requiring gender-neutral signage.

263
00:24:16.182 --> 00:24:17.852
<v Keelan McClymont>Add Code Section 23.01.071.

264
00:24:19.635 --> 00:24:22.413
<v Jamie Dunphy>And colleagues, this is the first reading of an ordinance.

265
00:24:22.605 --> 00:24:27.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have Christopher Hare with us to give a staff summary report.

266
00:24:28.082 --> 00:24:31.630
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you and good morning, Council President, Council.

267
00:24:31.693 --> 00:24:38.598
<v Christopher Hare>For the record, Christopher Hare, Council Operations Policy Analyst, and reading on behalf of Craig Cook, who until recently staffed the Arts and Economy Committee.

268
00:24:39.481 --> 00:24:50.497
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance document 2025-475 was considered in the Arts and Economy Committee on December 9th, where it was referred to Council as amended with a recommendation to be passed as amended.

269
00:24:50.961 --> 00:25:05.768
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance adds City Code Section 23.01.071 to require that single occupant restrooms in places of public accommodation be available for use by any person regardless of sex or gender identity, and that appropriate all-user signage be posted.

270
00:25:06.586 --> 00:25:12.826
<v Christopher Hare>It does not require the creation of new single occupant restrooms or physical modifications to existing facilities.

271
00:25:13.403 --> 00:25:25.457
<v Christopher Hare>The city administrator is responsible for directing notice and enforcement with a recommended best The ordinance directs the practice of providing notice and sample compliant signage to applicable places of public accommodation in 2026.

272
00:25:25.842 --> 00:25:28.538
<v Christopher Hare>Noncompliance may be reported to code review through 311.

273
00:25:29.068 --> 00:25:31.925
<v Christopher Hare>Existing staff resources may be used to develop sample signage.

274
00:25:32.440 --> 00:25:37.817
<v Christopher Hare>Enforcement costs are undetermined and will depend on the enforcement approach.

275
00:25:38.123 --> 00:25:47.547
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance directs that funding for applicable costs, including notification to affected businesses, be identified in the fiscal year 2026-27 city budget.

276
00:25:47.595 --> 00:25:47.739
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

277
00:25:48.337 --> 00:25:51.353
<v Christopher Hare>The committee adopted an amendment prior to moving the item to full council.

278
00:25:51.417 --> 00:25:56.069
<v Christopher Hare>The effects of the amendments on the original ordinance are summarized in the committee staff summary posted online.

279
00:25:56.779 --> 00:26:04.096
<v Christopher Hare>The full impact statements on this item includes financial and budgetary impacts, economic and real estate impacts, community impacts, and community involvement.

280
00:26:04.779 --> 00:26:09.726
<v Christopher Hare>2 Individuals provided verbal testimony and 5 people submitted written testimony prior to committee action.

281
00:26:10.460 --> 00:26:18.390
<v Christopher Hare>General themes included importance of this policy for the LGBTQIA2S+ community and gender nonconforming individuals, Thank you.

282
00:26:18.390 --> 00:26:18.390
<v Christopher Hare>Councilmember Herbold.

283
00:26:18.390 --> 00:26:18.390
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

284
00:26:18.390 --> 00:26:18.390
<v Christopher Hare>I would like to thank the staff for their work on this ordinance.

285
00:26:18.390 --> 00:26:18.390
<v Christopher Hare>I would like to highlight the following key points.

286
00:26:18.390 --> 00:26:26.599
<v Christopher Hare>Importance of this policy for families with children and using all-user terminology in plain language so all members of the public can understand.

287
00:26:27.029 --> 00:26:32.150
<v Christopher Hare>Importance of quality restrooms for customer impressions of businesses.

288
00:26:32.150 --> 00:26:34.609
<v Christopher Hare>Restroom access as a matter of dignity and fairness.

289
00:26:34.650 --> 00:26:41.079
<v Christopher Hare>Concerns about impacts on religious facilities that maintain separation of the sexes as a matter of religious belief.

290
00:26:41.269 --> 00:26:43.250
<v Christopher Hare>And this concludes the committee staff summary.

291
00:26:43.250 --> 00:26:43.730
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

292
00:26:44.717 --> 00:26:45.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Christopher.

293
00:26:45.759 --> 00:26:53.501
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I— this came out of Arts and Economy, so I do not recall if it was Councilor Green or Councilor Ryan who were in charge that day.

294
00:26:54.768 --> 00:26:56.386
<v Mitch Green>I don't remember either.

295
00:26:56.819 --> 00:26:57.173
<v Jamie Dunphy>Fair enough.

296
00:26:57.221 --> 00:26:59.272
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, Councilor Ryan, I see your hand in there.

297
00:26:59.320 --> 00:27:03.008
<v Jamie Dunphy>Did you have, uh— were you chairing this meeting, Councilor Ryan, when this came?

298
00:27:03.888 --> 00:27:04.787
<v Dan Ryan>I can't recall that.

299
00:27:04.914 --> 00:27:07.448
<v Dan Ryan>I can recall this though, and I think it'll be helpful.

300
00:27:07.800 --> 00:27:14.675
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I learned the logic behind this actually from You, Councilor Dunphy, at that time— that was your title— and Arts and Economy.

301
00:27:15.093 --> 00:27:20.814
<v Dan Ryan>And it was confirmed this would not be a barrier, uh, a big cost driver for small businesses.

302
00:27:20.958 --> 00:27:23.329
<v Dan Ryan>As you recall, that was my— most of my questions.

303
00:27:23.425 --> 00:27:35.380
<v Dan Ryan>And I appreciate that you went to great lengths to make this simple and not, um— Let's just say there weren't a lot of details that said you had to add this, this, this, this, this, and this that would cost X amount of money.

304
00:27:35.605 --> 00:27:37.525
<v Dan Ryan>And that was I think my concern with others.

305
00:27:38.301 --> 00:27:46.932
<v Dan Ryan>So I wanted to say I just appreciate Council President's passion for this issue, and I know that it started back when you were a staffer for Commissioner Fish, rest in peace.

306
00:27:47.093 --> 00:27:50.067
<v Dan Ryan>And I just think it's cool that you're seeing this to the finish line.

307
00:27:50.292 --> 00:27:51.355
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate your dedication.

308
00:27:51.998 --> 00:27:52.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

309
00:27:54.326 --> 00:27:58.576
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilors Pirtle-Guiney and Councilor Koyama Lane are also co-sponsors on this.

310
00:27:58.641 --> 00:28:00.765
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to give you each an opportunity to speak on this.

311
00:28:00.829 --> 00:28:01.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

312
00:28:03.579 --> 00:28:09.435
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President, and thank you for bringing this policy forward and inviting us to co-sponsor it with you.

313
00:28:10.720 --> 00:28:27.388
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, when Councilor Dunphy approached me about this policy, we had a lot of conversations about the impact and how we could take something that is a small change with a low implementation burden, as Councilor Ryan mentioned, that will make a big difference for a lot of Portlanders.

314
00:28:28.383 --> 00:28:31.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This ordinance matters a lot to me, and I want to flag 3 quick things.

315
00:28:32.134 --> 00:28:33.656
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is the timely issue.

316
00:28:33.737 --> 00:28:43.531
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know we're dealing with a federal administration that is engaged in an all-out assault on families who don't fit their narrow definition of what they think our country should look like.

317
00:28:44.237 --> 00:28:55.126
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And for many people in my community, in the LGBTQ community, there are still everyday fears around something as basic as where to use the restroom.

318
00:28:55.722 --> 00:28:58.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A policy like this can help my community.

319
00:28:59.184 --> 00:29:01.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But this policy affects my family on another level as well.

320
00:29:02.390 --> 00:29:04.760
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am a mom of 2 kids, a son and a daughter.

321
00:29:05.536 --> 00:29:21.556
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And when we are out, when my son was little, I got to explain to him why when he was with me we used one restroom and when he was alone he used a different restroom, even if both restrooms were single-stall restrooms.

322
00:29:22.397 --> 00:29:38.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And now that he's older and often offers to take his sister to the bathroom when we're out, which is fantastic that they are old enough to do that, at 10 years old he is faced with the decision of which restroom to use with his little sister.

323
00:29:39.194 --> 00:29:50.663
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's confusing, it is stressful, and more importantly, it is a wholly unnecessary choice when you're dealing with 2 single stall My family is not unique.

324
00:29:50.971 --> 00:30:00.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is something that can help anybody on those days when there is a line for one restroom and an open restroom right next to it, and they are both single stall restrooms.

325
00:30:02.150 --> 00:30:14.907
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy and I talked a lot about how this policy would affect the businesses that we are asking to make a change, because while I think the impacts here are really important, I also wanted to make sure that the implementation was simple.

326
00:30:15.656 --> 00:30:19.813
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we've come up with something that only applies to existing restrooms.

327
00:30:20.230 --> 00:30:22.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Nobody is required to build something new.

328
00:30:23.054 --> 00:30:31.124
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Gives space for the city administrator to flexibly implement this, but also provides some guidelines to ensure that there's not a heavy burden for our businesses.

329
00:30:32.182 --> 00:30:40.509
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And at the end of the day, gives us a quick outcome that can make a difference in every single Portlander's experience when they are out in our city.

330
00:30:41.185 --> 00:30:45.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope that we can gain your support today and am proud to be a part of bringing this forward.

331
00:30:46.529 --> 00:30:47.272
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

332
00:30:47.353 --> 00:30:48.386
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

333
00:30:49.695 --> 00:30:51.003
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you so much, Council President.

334
00:30:51.230 --> 00:30:59.731
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm proud to be a co-sponsor of this ordinance alongside you, Council President Dunphy, and alongside Council President Emeritus Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

335
00:31:01.260 --> 00:31:13.872
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to recognize the hard work of the city staff and our predecessors in carrying the torch from the late Commissioner Nick Fish and then Senior Policy Director Jamie Dunphy to today.

336
00:31:14.579 --> 00:31:18.352
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I wanna thank Michelle Rodriguez, former head of staff to Commissioner Maps.

337
00:31:18.626 --> 00:31:22.392
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you to Anne Milligan, Senior Deputy City Attorney.

338
00:31:22.909 --> 00:31:32.555
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you to Lex Yakoschowski, LGBTQIA2S+ Policy Analyst with the Office of Equity and Human Rights.

339
00:31:33.136 --> 00:31:36.726
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to really, really thank Aubrey Chen, Woo!

340
00:31:37.170 --> 00:31:46.979
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Former LGBTQIA2S+ policy analyst, who is the absolute best and is now currently an incredible policy aide in my office.

341
00:31:47.622 --> 00:31:57.881
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And last but not least, to thank all of the community organizations and business associations that have supported the various iterations of this ordinance over many years.

342
00:31:58.009 --> 00:32:03.019
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm really proud of all of your work, and I'm proud to help carry this work over the finish line.

343
00:32:03.180 --> 00:32:03.531
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

344
00:32:04.253 --> 00:32:05.423
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

345
00:32:05.760 --> 00:32:11.917
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we had a full presentation of this at committee, um, and I— we typically do not do additional committees.

346
00:32:12.015 --> 00:32:16.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, um, there has been some staff turnover at the Bureau of Planning— of, uh, Permitting and Development.

347
00:32:17.000 --> 00:32:20.497
<v Jamie Dunphy>We now have a new permanent director who was not here when we voted on this in committee.

348
00:32:20.930 --> 00:32:25.564
<v Jamie Dunphy>He is here, uh, if there are, uh, technical questions from anybody, uh, right?

349
00:32:25.644 --> 00:32:30.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also have staff, uh, I also have Lex here as well to provide any technical questions or background.

350
00:32:30.872 --> 00:32:35.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>If any colleagues have any, uh, before we get into, uh, public testimony.

351
00:32:39.210 --> 00:32:46.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will just note, um, I want to very much thank the administration and, uh, PP&D and the city administrator.

352
00:32:46.542 --> 00:32:54.833
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have been working very closely to make sure that we can find the most cost-effective, uh, and streamlined and easy, low-burden way to implement this.

353
00:32:55.334 --> 00:33:02.105
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, we will note there, there is a, a minimal cost for That is currently projected for printing and mailing.

354
00:33:02.683 --> 00:33:11.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>My office has been working in regular communication with the city administrator and with the PP&D team to find what the funding considerations would be.

355
00:33:11.519 --> 00:33:16.136
<v Jamie Dunphy>And specifically, that is to mail a letter to the businesses.

356
00:33:16.250 --> 00:33:28.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>And my hope specifically is that we may even go as far as designing a postcard that we could send to businesses, and they can just literally tape that postcard over the existing sign at their bathroom.

357
00:33:30.179 --> 00:33:39.462
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are— so I am ongoing committed to seeing this implemented in the most cost-effective and efficient way and to reduce the burden on our businesses wherever possible.

358
00:33:42.248 --> 00:33:44.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>Still seeing no hands in the queue.

359
00:33:45.123 --> 00:33:47.288
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please move to testimony?

360
00:33:49.883 --> 00:33:52.733
<v Keelan McClymont>First up for testimony, we have Merrilee Carr.

361
00:34:04.509 --> 00:34:05.303
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning and welcome.

362
00:34:05.902 --> 00:34:06.517
<v Merrilee Carr>Good morning.

363
00:34:09.851 --> 00:34:10.791
<v Loretta Smith>Can you hear me?

364
00:34:11.389 --> 00:34:11.583
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

365
00:34:11.956 --> 00:34:12.295
<v Merrilee Carr>Cool.

366
00:34:12.766 --> 00:34:13.617
<v Merrilee Carr>I'm Mira Lee Carr.

367
00:34:14.856 --> 00:34:19.829
<v Merrilee Carr>Um, thank you, Council President Dunphy, councilors, and Administrator Lee.

368
00:34:20.362 --> 00:34:21.534
<v Merrilee Carr>For this opportunity.

369
00:34:22.675 --> 00:34:30.335
<v Merrilee Carr>I'm the president of FLUSH, P-H-L-U-S-H, which helped create the Portland Loo 20 years ago.

370
00:34:31.282 --> 00:34:42.010
<v Merrilee Carr>I'm also a family physician, retired, a Neighborhood Emergency Team, NET, team leader, and a NET CERT regional trainer in disaster sanitation.

371
00:34:42.588 --> 00:34:46.795
<v Merrilee Carr>My class is titled You Survive the Earthquake but Die of Dysentery.

372
00:34:46.860 --> 00:34:46.956
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

373
00:34:48.722 --> 00:34:49.686
<v Merrilee Carr>Sad but true.

374
00:34:50.393 --> 00:34:52.961
<v Merrilee Carr>Portland has terrible bathroom access.

375
00:34:53.427 --> 00:34:57.746
<v Merrilee Carr>It turns off tourists and discourages Portlanders from going out.

376
00:34:58.324 --> 00:35:03.574
<v Merrilee Carr>Access is worse since the pandemic's, so to speak, antitrust effect.

377
00:35:04.440 --> 00:35:11.715
<v Merrilee Carr>Loss of trust has closed off many restrooms in private establishments that used to be open to whoever needed them.

378
00:35:12.532 --> 00:35:15.969
<v Merrilee Carr>Public facilities are also very unevenly distributed.

379
00:35:16.407 --> 00:35:18.565
<v Merrilee Carr>In downtown, it's merely bad.

380
00:35:18.987 --> 00:35:27.193
<v Merrilee Carr>But in long-neglected East Portland, they, they are so hard to find that human waste is commonly seen in public.

381
00:35:28.449 --> 00:35:36.744
<v Merrilee Carr>The current proposal to relabel all single-occupant restrooms all-user is a great example of creative repurposing.

382
00:35:37.485 --> 00:35:43.686
<v Merrilee Carr>There is no practical reason for single-occupant facilities to have a gendered label at all.

383
00:35:43.800 --> 00:35:43.849
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

384
00:35:43.998 --> 00:35:48.985
<v Merrilee Carr>It only makes the facility inaccessible to people who don't match the signage.

385
00:35:50.429 --> 00:35:55.554
<v Merrilee Carr>Single-user restrooms function equally well for all genders and most species.

386
00:35:58.251 --> 00:36:02.543
<v Merrilee Carr>With this inexpensive change, you will make more restrooms available.

387
00:36:03.643 --> 00:36:05.469
<v Merrilee Carr>But we can't stop there.

388
00:36:06.398 --> 00:36:09.918
<v Merrilee Carr>Portland needs more public restrooms, a lot more.

389
00:36:10.427 --> 00:36:18.235
<v Merrilee Carr>To become once again a place that welcomes visitors and cultivates vibrant connections among its inhabitants.

390
00:36:19.182 --> 00:36:28.469
<v Merrilee Carr>20 Years ago, a broad multi-stakeholder design process asked how a modern public restroom should look and function.

391
00:36:29.224 --> 00:36:33.257
<v Merrilee Carr>The result was the Portland Loo, now installed around the world.

392
00:36:33.898 --> 00:36:43.106
<v Merrilee Carr>I think it's time to repeat that inquiry for the post-pandemic city with newly available technology and building materials.

393
00:36:43.780 --> 00:36:44.713
<v Merrilee Carr>Flushing is ready.

394
00:36:45.050 --> 00:36:45.773
<v Merrilee Carr>Let's talk.

395
00:36:46.030 --> 00:36:46.418
<v Merrilee Carr>Thank you.

396
00:36:46.742 --> 00:36:47.373
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

397
00:36:51.038 --> 00:36:53.858
<v Jamie Dunphy>Also, I just needed to comment that you have fantastic earrings.

398
00:36:54.440 --> 00:36:56.934
<v Jamie Dunphy>Folks who can't see, they're tiny toilet paper rolls.

399
00:36:57.369 --> 00:36:59.108
<v Merrilee Carr>They're, they're my teaching earrings.

400
00:36:59.445 --> 00:36:59.800
<v Jamie Dunphy>Amazing.

401
00:36:59.864 --> 00:37:00.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

402
00:37:00.090 --> 00:37:00.815
<v Sameer Kanal>They really break the ice.

403
00:37:04.168 --> 00:37:06.545
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Lindsay Perez.

404
00:37:06.898 --> 00:37:09.628
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, Lindsay.

405
00:37:10.817 --> 00:37:10.978
<v Unidentified speaker>Wow.

406
00:37:11.860 --> 00:37:13.130
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, good morning, councilors.

407
00:37:13.306 --> 00:37:14.173
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your time.

408
00:37:14.688 --> 00:37:16.021
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, my name is Lindsay Perez.

409
00:37:16.197 --> 00:37:23.086
<v Unidentified speaker>I am a Two-Spirit Tongva human, uh, born and raised in Southern California, but I have resided in District 3 for the last 5 years.

410
00:37:23.746 --> 00:37:36.356
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, for the past 3 years I have worked as a youth advocate at the Sexual Minority Youth Resource Center AKA SMERC, at New Avenues for Youth, one of many Portland-based nonprofits working with the houseless youth continuum.

411
00:37:37.096 --> 00:37:46.416
<v Unidentified speaker>In my role, I support at-risk and houseless queer youth every single day as they navigate basic needs, safety, and belonging in public spaces across our city.

412
00:37:47.460 --> 00:37:54.402
<v Unidentified speaker>In my work, I see how restroom access can determine whether a person feels welcome enough to enter a space at all.

413
00:37:55.750 --> 00:38:01.329
<v Unidentified speaker>If someone has to pause and ask, am I allowed to be here just to use the bathroom?

414
00:38:01.987 --> 00:38:05.563
<v Unidentified speaker>That's a failure not only of accessibility but of human decency.

415
00:38:06.380 --> 00:38:22.110
<v Unidentified speaker>All-user signage lowers barriers for everyone— parents with kids, such as you, uh, Councilor, um, people with disabilities or caregivers, folks with medical needs, and yes, trans and non-binary and gender-expansive community alike.

416
00:38:23.153 --> 00:38:31.065
<v Unidentified speaker>I come before you today to share my testimony in support of adding nondiscrimination requirements for single occupant restrooms in public spaces.

417
00:38:31.818 --> 00:38:34.081
<v Unidentified speaker>Gender-neutral restrooms are not complicated.

418
00:38:34.708 --> 00:38:36.360
<v Unidentified speaker>They simply make sense for humans.

419
00:38:37.050 --> 00:38:40.211
<v Unidentified speaker>Single occupancy restrooms already serve one person at a time.

420
00:38:40.644 --> 00:38:44.063
<v Unidentified speaker>Assigning them a gender doesn't increase safety or functionality.

421
00:38:44.480 --> 00:38:49.407
<v Unidentified speaker>It only adds unnecessary barriers created by socially manufactured ideas about gender and sex.

422
00:38:49.503 --> 00:38:49.614
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

423
00:38:50.643 --> 00:39:00.668
<v Unidentified speaker>At the end of the day, everybody poops, and I support this ordinance with the hope that it will increase comfort, dignity, and accessibility for all humans in Portland to take care of theirs.

424
00:39:01.409 --> 00:39:09.614
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, thank you for your practical and compassionate step towards creating a more inclusive environment for all, uh, Senator— uh, Councilor, uh, Dunphy, and I appreciate all of your time.

425
00:39:10.561 --> 00:39:11.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here.

426
00:39:15.088 --> 00:39:17.063
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Danielle Morris.

427
00:39:21.896 --> 00:39:22.268
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

428
00:39:25.277 --> 00:39:28.224
<v Daniel Morris>Good morning, Councilor Duffy— Dunphy and councilors.

429
00:39:28.402 --> 00:39:29.528
<v Daniel Morris>My name is Daniel Morris.

430
00:39:29.690 --> 00:39:32.931
<v Daniel Morris>I was born in Emmanuel Hospital many decades ago.

431
00:39:33.480 --> 00:39:34.641
<v Daniel Morris>I reside near Portland.

432
00:39:34.786 --> 00:39:41.110
<v Daniel Morris>I run a business here, and I represent the Oregon Pride in Business Advocacy Committee, commonly known as ORPIB.

433
00:39:41.585 --> 00:39:54.869
<v Daniel Morris>I'm here to support The proposed resolution regarding the City Code 2301.071, which simply requires the single occupant restrooms in places in public accommodation be designated as gender-neutral signage.

434
00:39:55.686 --> 00:40:06.052
<v Daniel Morris>I'm speaking not only as an advocate for inclusion and equitable access, but also as a member of this community who believes in clarity and fairness in public places.

435
00:40:07.030 --> 00:40:12.882
<v Daniel Morris>I also want to note that ORPIB has reviewed and approved this And is in support of this ordinance.

436
00:40:13.699 --> 00:40:15.224
<v Daniel Morris>This ordinance is straightforward.

437
00:40:15.929 --> 00:40:24.094
<v Daniel Morris>It ensures single occupant restrooms are clearly labeled as all-user restrooms rather than gendered signs like men or women.

438
00:40:24.288 --> 00:40:25.860
<v Daniel Morris>It does not require construction.

439
00:40:26.373 --> 00:40:30.994
<v Daniel Morris>It does not require renovation, and it doesn't require the addition of any new restrooms.

440
00:40:31.650 --> 00:40:36.768
<v Daniel Morris>It simply standardizes signage so that people entering public spaces know their options.

441
00:40:37.266 --> 00:40:39.096
<v Daniel Morris>Clearly and respectfully.

442
00:40:40.556 --> 00:40:51.532
<v Daniel Morris>Requiring gender-neutral signage improves accessibility for caregivers, people with personal attendants, families, and anyone who may not be served with a, a standard traditional gendered sign.

443
00:40:52.045 --> 00:41:03.552
<v Daniel Morris>It supports non-discrimination principles already reflected in local and state law, aligns along also with practices in our peer cities that have successfully adopted similar signage standards.

444
00:41:03.601 --> 00:41:03.697
<v Merrilee Carr>Thank you.

445
00:41:04.163 --> 00:41:05.943
<v Daniel Morris>Importantly, the cost is minimal.

446
00:41:06.746 --> 00:41:12.396
<v Daniel Morris>Signage is inexpensive, and the city's guidance and notification will help businesses transition smoothly.

447
00:41:13.070 --> 00:41:19.972
<v Daniel Morris>This is a common-sense, low-cost way to ensure that our city's public accommodations are welcome and navigable for everyone.

448
00:41:20.452 --> 00:41:23.710
<v Daniel Morris>I respectfully urge the council to adopt this ordinance.

449
00:41:24.065 --> 00:41:28.204
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you for your time, your interest, and I'm happy to answer any questions.

450
00:41:28.349 --> 00:41:29.007
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

451
00:41:31.556 --> 00:41:32.722
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here this morning.

452
00:41:32.786 --> 00:41:32.981
<v David Pearl>Thank you.

453
00:41:34.809 --> 00:41:36.072
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

454
00:41:37.010 --> 00:41:37.911
<v Jamie Dunphy>Fantastic.

455
00:41:38.168 --> 00:41:42.536
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, any debate or discussion or questions?

456
00:41:42.744 --> 00:41:51.730
<v Jamie Dunphy>Again, we have staff in the room if there are any technical questions on implementation or cost, but I see no hands in the queue.

457
00:41:51.793 --> 00:41:52.423
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's a good sign.

458
00:41:53.710 --> 00:41:55.764
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, pausing for 5 seconds.

459
00:41:59.737 --> 00:42:02.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>This item will now move to a second— oh, oh, Councilor Koyama Lane.

460
00:42:02.965 --> 00:42:03.864
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

461
00:42:03.943 --> 00:42:19.965
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I just want to quickly point out that, um, when looking back at the timelines of meetings of when this was revived, that I heard that, uh, the initial proposal was from the City of Portland's Queer Alliance Employee Resource Group, um, really boosting and magnifying this.

462
00:42:20.061 --> 00:42:29.625
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then there was a Street Roots article, and then We also got involved, but it just is a reminder to me of how important and valuable our employee resource groups are.

463
00:42:30.570 --> 00:42:30.987
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

464
00:42:31.052 --> 00:42:31.646
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

465
00:42:32.976 --> 00:42:33.554
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

466
00:42:34.485 --> 00:42:46.579
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to say that I'm surprised and appalled that there are such things as single-gender, single-occupancy bathrooms, which just seems, you know, one other example of the endless capacity of humans for folly.

467
00:42:47.798 --> 00:42:48.858
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

468
00:42:50.190 --> 00:42:50.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

469
00:42:51.063 --> 00:43:03.052
<v Jamie Dunphy>Council President, Councilors, colleagues, as a proud girl dad and as the person who has been working on this policy for almost a decade now, honestly, I wanna apologize to the community for it taking this long to get to this point.

470
00:43:03.440 --> 00:43:17.007
<v Jamie Dunphy>I wanna thank Commissioner Maps, who at the end of the old form of City Council desperately tried to get this passed as one last policy, and for a variety of technical reasons, it couldn't happen.

471
00:43:18.389 --> 00:43:22.271
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it is over a year before we were able to get it done in this new form.

472
00:43:22.771 --> 00:43:24.001
<v Jamie Dunphy>Policy takes a long time.

473
00:43:24.050 --> 00:43:25.246
<v Jamie Dunphy>The community is ready for this.

474
00:43:26.260 --> 00:43:31.275
<v Jamie Dunphy>The lack of pushback is the obvious sign that we are well past and actually we are playing catch-up now.

475
00:43:31.356 --> 00:43:34.458
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, this item will be moving to a second reading.

476
00:43:36.360 --> 00:43:37.735
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call the next item?

477
00:43:40.603 --> 00:43:43.324
<v Keelan McClymont>The next item is the consent agenda.

478
00:43:44.637 --> 00:43:57.914
<v Keelan McClymont>We've had 2 items pulled from the consent agenda, items 2026-017 and item 2026-018.

479
00:43:59.563 --> 00:43:59.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>Wonderful.

480
00:44:00.226 --> 00:44:05.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, do I have unanimous consent to approve the remainder of the consent agenda?

481
00:44:05.951 --> 00:44:07.260
<v Raymond C. Lee>Oh, oh, oh, hi.

482
00:44:07.518 --> 00:44:17.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>So sorry, the consent agenda does require Then let's move to a roll call vote, please.

483
00:44:17.768 --> 00:44:18.476
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, thank you.

484
00:44:19.039 --> 00:44:19.521
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

485
00:44:19.940 --> 00:44:20.019
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

486
00:44:21.242 --> 00:44:21.612
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

487
00:44:22.512 --> 00:44:22.559
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

488
00:44:23.717 --> 00:44:24.103
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

489
00:44:24.521 --> 00:44:24.570
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

490
00:44:25.244 --> 00:44:26.032
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

491
00:44:26.371 --> 00:44:26.418
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

492
00:44:27.496 --> 00:44:27.788
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

493
00:44:28.548 --> 00:44:28.565
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

494
00:44:29.536 --> 00:44:30.152
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

495
00:44:30.735 --> 00:44:30.784
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

496
00:44:31.804 --> 00:44:32.143
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

497
00:44:32.677 --> 00:44:32.726
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

498
00:44:33.487 --> 00:44:33.925
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

499
00:44:34.054 --> 00:44:34.103
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

500
00:44:34.913 --> 00:44:35.284
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

501
00:44:35.512 --> 00:44:35.559
<v Raymond C. Lee>Aye.

502
00:44:36.108 --> 00:44:36.335
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

503
00:44:36.675 --> 00:44:36.722
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

504
00:44:37.353 --> 00:44:37.871
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

505
00:44:38.065 --> 00:44:38.114
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

506
00:44:38.793 --> 00:44:39.166
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

507
00:44:40.072 --> 00:44:40.121
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

508
00:44:41.204 --> 00:44:44.262
<v Keelan McClymont>The consent agenda is approved with 12 yes votes.

509
00:44:44.521 --> 00:44:45.039
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

510
00:44:45.121 --> 00:44:49.391
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please now move to item 9?

511
00:44:52.695 --> 00:45:07.858
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 9, exempt certain code requirements under City Code Chapter 17.93, renaming city streets for the proposed renaming of a portion of Southwest Jackson Street to Southwest Rose Hill Street.

512
00:45:08.583 --> 00:45:13.260
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues will recall we had a, uh, first reading of this last week.

513
00:45:13.648 --> 00:45:17.746
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, are there any further questions or concerns from colleagues?

514
00:45:19.927 --> 00:45:24.027
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing none, could we please call the roll?

515
00:45:24.496 --> 00:45:24.802
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

516
00:45:25.222 --> 00:45:25.351
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

517
00:45:26.061 --> 00:45:26.416
<v Loretta Smith>Smith.

518
00:45:28.039 --> 00:45:28.088
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

519
00:45:31.105 --> 00:45:31.152
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

520
00:45:32.894 --> 00:45:32.960
<v Raymond C. Lee>Aye.

521
00:45:36.282 --> 00:45:36.686
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

522
00:45:37.009 --> 00:45:37.882
<v Steve Novick>Down with Andrew Jackson.

523
00:45:38.125 --> 00:45:38.172
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

524
00:45:39.177 --> 00:45:39.355
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

525
00:45:39.824 --> 00:45:40.001
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

526
00:45:41.539 --> 00:45:41.911
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

527
00:45:42.333 --> 00:45:42.494
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

528
00:45:43.061 --> 00:45:43.335
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

529
00:45:43.789 --> 00:45:43.967
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

530
00:45:44.597 --> 00:45:47.181
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with 12 yes votes.

531
00:45:50.827 --> 00:45:53.804
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please read item number 10?

532
00:45:58.125 --> 00:46:06.603
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 10, require city administrator to release public records in reference to unspent surplus funds and schedule an oversight hearing.

533
00:46:07.824 --> 00:46:08.018
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

534
00:46:08.114 --> 00:46:15.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, uh, this is the— this is our resolution that we'll be reading on the, uh, oversight hearing.

535
00:46:15.318 --> 00:46:17.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, recent developments have made this item particularly timely.

536
00:46:18.820 --> 00:46:22.702
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, this resolution Is to adopt a process for council oversight.

537
00:46:23.425 --> 00:46:25.800
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are here to potentially schedule a hearing.

538
00:46:26.007 --> 00:46:27.371
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are not here to hold one today.

539
00:46:28.800 --> 00:46:36.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll hear from the administration tomorrow afternoon, and we can ask questions specific to the discovery of Housing Bureau funds then.

540
00:46:37.255 --> 00:46:42.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today we're considering, should council use our oversight powers on these matters?

541
00:46:42.275 --> 00:46:44.505
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is this the right way that we use those powers?

542
00:46:44.731 --> 00:46:45.548
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

543
00:46:46.382 --> 00:46:52.974
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will just note again, we are not having the oversight hearing today, and under Robert's Rules, debate on an item must be confined to the merits of the pending motion.

544
00:46:53.021 --> 00:46:55.476
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I expect our body to observe the rules in the chamber today.

545
00:46:56.309 --> 00:46:58.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm gonna turn this over to Councilor Mitch Green.

546
00:46:59.693 --> 00:47:02.018
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

547
00:47:02.418 --> 00:47:09.202
<v Mitch Green>Before I get into— I have a short presentation that I'm gonna share, but before I get into that, I just wanna thank my co-sponsors for joining me on this.

548
00:47:09.715 --> 00:47:16.246
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Avalos, who's the chair of the Housing and Homelessness Committee, And Councilor Morillo for your stalwart oversight stance.

549
00:47:16.375 --> 00:47:18.429
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for your help in developing this and support for this.

550
00:47:19.344 --> 00:47:24.416
<v Mitch Green>Before I get into the presentation, I think I'd just like to offer my co-sponsors a few minutes to offer remarks as well.

551
00:47:24.481 --> 00:47:25.974
<v Mitch Green>So I'll just begin with Councilor Avalos.

552
00:47:26.311 --> 00:47:26.568
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

553
00:47:27.594 --> 00:47:28.461
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor Green.

554
00:47:29.697 --> 00:47:33.967
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, colleagues, so I think I just wanna start off by naming the elephant in the room.

555
00:47:34.032 --> 00:47:53.489
<v Candace Avalos>This is uncomfortable, but this is also really important what we're gonna be talking about because this resolution is centered on the nearly $21 million in unspent But also this weekend, we were informed that the Portland Housing Bureau may also have millions of dollars sitting unspent in the housing investment fund.

556
00:47:53.489 --> 00:47:59.889
<v Candace Avalos>That pattern really matters, and it gets to the heart of why Portlanders voted for stronger oversight powers under a new form of government.

557
00:48:00.530 --> 00:48:06.090
<v Candace Avalos>Under the old system, bureaus operated in silos and accounting practices varied widely across the city.

558
00:48:06.090 --> 00:48:12.929
<v Candace Avalos>Commissioners were structurally incentivized to protect their own bureaus, which created a culture where full financial transparency was often discouraged.

559
00:48:12.929 --> 00:48:12.969
<v Candace Avalos>Councilmember Herbold.

560
00:48:14.291 --> 00:48:21.483
<v Candace Avalos>So this resolution before us today is not about just any one bureau or not about assigning blame to any individual.

561
00:48:21.740 --> 00:48:30.697
<v Candace Avalos>It is about whether our new system is working the way Portlanders were promised that it would, with real transparency, shared accountability, and responsible stewardship of public dollars.

562
00:48:31.452 --> 00:48:39.655
<v Candace Avalos>This resolution allows council and the public to understand what happened, how information was shared, and whether our current procedures are sufficient to prevent situations like this going forward.

563
00:48:39.704 --> 00:48:40.088
<v Candace Avalos>Councilmember Loretta Smith.

564
00:48:40.427 --> 00:48:48.869
<v Candace Avalos>So today we have an opportunity to model what oversight looks like under this new charter, not as punishment, but as a normal, necessary function of a healthy government.

565
00:48:49.192 --> 00:48:49.563
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

566
00:48:50.646 --> 00:48:51.664
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

567
00:48:52.018 --> 00:48:52.713
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Morillo.

568
00:48:53.780 --> 00:48:55.219
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Green.

569
00:48:56.206 --> 00:49:00.447
<v Angelita Morillo>I really appreciate and echo everything that Councilor Avalos laid out as the housing chair.

570
00:49:00.737 --> 00:49:07.367
<v Angelita Morillo>And I want to remind my colleagues that as the legislative body, we exercise 3 core authorities.

571
00:49:08.126 --> 00:49:10.679
<v Angelita Morillo>We have oversight, budget, and legislation.

572
00:49:11.192 --> 00:49:12.572
<v Angelita Morillo>And those are not separate tools.

573
00:49:12.637 --> 00:49:14.465
<v Angelita Morillo>They are meant to function in concert.

574
00:49:14.963 --> 00:49:25.106
<v Angelita Morillo>And oversight is arguably the main part of this because it enables both budgeting and legislation, because it is how we learn that government actually works together.

575
00:49:25.556 --> 00:49:33.548
<v Angelita Morillo>And we need to study the failures from the bottom up, not by legislating from vibes or pretending that we are experts in outsourcing our thinking.

576
00:49:33.869 --> 00:49:38.590
<v Angelita Morillo>We need to make sure that we actually have accurate data so that we can legislate from an informed position.

577
00:49:39.666 --> 00:49:43.730
<v Angelita Morillo>Oversight is where gaps, failures, and missed opportunities actually become visible.

578
00:49:44.179 --> 00:49:55.565
<v Angelita Morillo>And once those realities are made visible by detailed accounting and oversight, they naturally inform how and where we exercise our budget authority and how we legislate deliberately and transparently for the public.

579
00:49:56.224 --> 00:50:00.481
<v Angelita Morillo>That is why an oversight hearing on lost or mismanaged funds is not backwards looking.

580
00:50:00.528 --> 00:50:00.625
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

581
00:50:01.202 --> 00:50:11.440
<v Angelita Morillo>It is one of the highest forms of state capacity, learning from failure in order to allocate resources more wisely and design rules or plans that prevent recurrence of government failures.

582
00:50:12.179 --> 00:50:23.235
<v Angelita Morillo>Historically, the city has relied way too heavily on a system where individual elected officials were expected to personally manage complex bureaus, hoping that the right skills, judgment, and bandwidth happened to align.

583
00:50:24.054 --> 00:50:27.969
<v Angelita Morillo>That structure produced silos and overreliance on unaccountable systems.

584
00:50:28.387 --> 00:50:37.284
<v Angelita Morillo>Or staff, which is increasingly a problem if we do have staff turnover in bureaus because there is information that is lost with every person that leaves.

585
00:50:38.264 --> 00:50:40.818
<v Angelita Morillo>We correct that by embracing our oversight role.

586
00:50:41.557 --> 00:50:51.581
<v Angelita Morillo>Oversight is how council governs as a body, building the expertise necessary to translate public interest and mass politics into policy that actually functions in city bureaucracy.

587
00:50:52.094 --> 00:50:55.644
<v Angelita Morillo>It is how we restore public trust and ensure accountability as stewards of city funds.

588
00:50:55.708 --> 00:50:56.335
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Loretta Smith.

589
00:50:56.833 --> 00:51:01.693
<v Angelita Morillo>And it is how we move from a city that reacts to problems to one that systematically prevents them.

590
00:51:02.527 --> 00:51:22.836
<v Angelita Morillo>We are facing one of the toughest budget cycles I have ever seen, and I had worked in the prior form of government, and we are being asked to make incredibly tough decisions about precious programs that are being cut, about important staff that may need to be cut, and we cannot appropriately do our jobs if we do not have all of the information in front of us.

591
00:51:23.045 --> 00:51:26.195
<v Angelita Morillo>About the exact number of dollars that we have to work with.

592
00:51:26.693 --> 00:51:34.139
<v Angelita Morillo>So I would really urge my colleagues to understand that this is part of our role as City Council is to engage in that oversight work.

593
00:51:34.559 --> 00:51:43.963
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm very grateful that Councilor Green brought this forward and that we are going to hopefully show what it means to be responsible with people's public dollars.

594
00:51:44.219 --> 00:51:44.541
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

595
00:51:46.487 --> 00:51:48.708
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for your comments and your support, Councilor Morillo.

596
00:51:49.947 --> 00:51:52.911
<v Mitch Green>Uh, Keelan, if I just want to share a presentation, I just share my screen?

597
00:51:52.960 --> 00:51:53.958
<v Mitch Green>Is it, is it that simple?

598
00:51:54.054 --> 00:51:54.425
<v Mitch Green>Okay, great.

599
00:51:54.958 --> 00:51:58.534
<v Mitch Green>Bear with me as I fuddle my way through this.

600
00:51:58.972 --> 00:52:00.492
<v Mitch Green>Um, hopefully it's not too awkward.

601
00:52:01.333 --> 00:52:03.969
<v Dan Ryan>All right, there it is.

602
00:52:08.315 --> 00:52:08.851
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

603
00:52:10.659 --> 00:52:11.213
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

604
00:52:19.271 --> 00:52:19.911
<v Mitch Green>It is awkward.

605
00:52:24.659 --> 00:52:26.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>Don't worry, everyone is waiting and judging you.

606
00:52:26.463 --> 00:52:26.952
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, that's right.

607
00:52:28.900 --> 00:52:31.047
<v Mitch Green>So that's what I want to share.

608
00:52:34.519 --> 00:52:35.907
<v Mitch Green>Are you guys seeing a presentation?

609
00:52:36.184 --> 00:52:36.429
<v Merrilee Carr>Yes.

610
00:52:36.608 --> 00:52:36.838
<v Raymond C. Lee>Okay.

611
00:52:37.081 --> 00:52:37.458
<v Unidentified speaker>Kind of.

612
00:52:38.240 --> 00:52:40.429
<v Mitch Green>If I, if I do that, is that better?

613
00:52:42.097 --> 00:52:42.418
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

614
00:52:42.657 --> 00:52:43.780
<v Mitch Green>Okay, thank you.

615
00:52:43.940 --> 00:52:44.356
<v Mitch Green>Hooray.

616
00:52:45.253 --> 00:52:55.943
<v Mitch Green>Okay, colleagues, I have a short presentation that I'm using to sort of walk you through essentially the context that gave cause to the resolution as well as simply what it does.

617
00:52:56.007 --> 00:52:57.914
<v Mitch Green>So the method and the process here.

618
00:52:57.978 --> 00:53:06.039
<v Mitch Green>So it's a resolution that's very specifically focused on a particular episode around these fund balances that have been in the news.

619
00:53:06.599 --> 00:53:10.596
<v Mitch Green>It's really focused on the $21 million from last fall, last summer and fall.

620
00:53:10.643 --> 00:53:11.248
<v Mitch Green>So I'll get into that.

621
00:53:13.277 --> 00:53:20.081
<v Mitch Green>Gonna describe the purpose, the timeline of context here, why we're doing this in the first place, the method and the process.

622
00:53:20.130 --> 00:53:21.807
<v Mitch Green>Then we— I can open up for questions to you guys.

623
00:53:23.619 --> 00:53:26.516
<v Mitch Green>So, you know, you've all seen the press on this.

624
00:53:26.646 --> 00:53:40.927
<v Mitch Green>There's been a range of reporting on the discovery of, You know, roughly $21 million of unspent and unbudgeted and unaccounted for funds that were discovered in the Portland Housing Bureau.

625
00:53:41.313 --> 00:53:46.820
<v Mitch Green>And then there's been subsequent reporting on an even later, a newer tranche of this.

626
00:53:48.056 --> 00:53:56.213
<v Mitch Green>And so the context here is that the public was made aware of this at the same time council was made aware of this money and rightfully have a lot of questions.

627
00:53:57.996 --> 00:53:59.460
<v Mitch Green>When did the city know about this?

628
00:54:00.110 --> 00:54:04.485
<v Mitch Green>Why were we not using these monies to support Portlanders in need at the time?

629
00:54:05.719 --> 00:54:28.853
<v Mitch Green>And frankly, just a sort of fundamental question of, does the City Council, who is the body responsible for appropriating monies and also developing policy, are they willing to step in and ask questions through an oversight lens when we are found with discrepancies on the administration's So those are the public questions that I think provide the context and impetus for this.

630
00:54:30.699 --> 00:54:43.157
<v Mitch Green>Just by way of context here and grounding, you know, Council's this legislative body that has both the power and I would argue the duty to exercise that oversight role.

631
00:54:44.940 --> 00:54:49.498
<v Mitch Green>You know, when we pass laws and we develop our budgets, we don't do that and then walk away.

632
00:54:50.460 --> 00:54:55.748
<v Mitch Green>We do that with the intention of making sure that the administration executes to those priorities.

633
00:54:56.981 --> 00:54:58.815
<v Mitch Green>I would argue that it's especially important.

634
00:54:58.864 --> 00:55:16.545
<v Mitch Green>It was always important to do oversight for City Council, but it's especially important in the new form of government that's post-charter, which really does separate the legislative function from the executive side, because we no longer have any executive authority at all.

635
00:55:17.027 --> 00:55:17.494
<v Mitch Green>We don't.

636
00:55:19.846 --> 00:55:22.005
<v Mitch Green>We don't tell the city administrator how to execute our will.

637
00:55:22.184 --> 00:55:24.117
<v Mitch Green>We provide that will through legislation.

638
00:55:25.210 --> 00:55:27.168
<v Mitch Green>So we do need to come back and do the oversight when necessary.

639
00:55:29.710 --> 00:55:44.221
<v Mitch Green>And I think given the nature of these fund balance discoveries and the fact that council was not informed in a timely fashion when these significant sums were first identified over the summer, I think presents serious risks for the city.

640
00:55:44.318 --> 00:55:44.416
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

641
00:55:44.550 --> 00:55:45.351
<v Mitch Green>Of the public trust.

642
00:55:45.927 --> 00:55:47.481
<v Mitch Green>And I've already heard that from my constituents.

643
00:55:47.545 --> 00:55:48.619
<v Mitch Green>We've read that in the press.

644
00:55:48.746 --> 00:56:04.447
<v Mitch Green>And I do want to note, however, and this is really important, and it's in the spirit of being fair here, is that my understanding is that the most recent discovery of even more money was actually quite timely in terms of the communication.

645
00:56:04.527 --> 00:56:10.021
<v Mitch Green>I understand that as soon as Ruth found this money, first thing she did was pick up the phone and call the council president.

646
00:56:10.070 --> 00:56:18.197
<v Mitch Green>So when I talk about the period of timeliness and communication, I really do— I really am confining that to the The August through November period.

647
00:56:18.469 --> 00:56:22.115
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a really important piece to bring into this discussion.

648
00:56:22.485 --> 00:56:26.340
<v Mitch Green>And for the public following along, there is a distinction there.

649
00:56:26.644 --> 00:56:40.041
<v Mitch Green>That doesn't mean that we don't— of course it adds context here, but I think if we do this oversight work on the $21 million period, it will help us be better for how we think about this broader auditing conversation going forward.

650
00:56:40.956 --> 00:56:51.081
<v Mitch Green>And then finally, I think, The way that— if you have a lack of public trust in government, the obligation to restore that public trust falls to City Council, right?

651
00:56:51.144 --> 00:56:54.048
<v Mitch Green>We were the ones who appropriated the money in the first place to develop the laws.

652
00:56:54.577 --> 00:56:57.257
<v Mitch Green>We can't cast blame to the administration.

653
00:56:57.306 --> 00:57:04.621
<v Mitch Green>We can't kick— sorry, we can't kick the can over, pass the buck, so to speak, to the city administrator or the mayor on this.

654
00:57:04.701 --> 00:57:08.246
<v Mitch Green>This really is City Council's obligation to restore that public trust through this oversight action.

655
00:57:08.295 --> 00:57:08.454
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

656
00:57:09.134 --> 00:57:10.847
<v Mitch Green>So that's why I'm motivating this.

657
00:57:12.835 --> 00:57:38.746
<v Mitch Green>For context, colleagues, the timeline that I think provides the impetus for this resolution, and it's described in the whereas clauses, is that on August 8th, Council was notified by the then City Administrator Michael Jordan that we should expect a mid-year budget shortfall driven primarily by Underperformance, if you will, in our business license taxes on the order of about $12 million.

658
00:57:39.259 --> 00:57:48.893
<v Mitch Green>So that's the information that we were provided in August to let us know that we had to prepare for a technical accounting adjustment ordinance in the fall that would close that gap.

659
00:57:49.134 --> 00:57:50.628
<v Mitch Green>There would be some cuts involved.

660
00:57:50.900 --> 00:57:52.393
<v Mitch Green>So that's what we know on August 8th.

661
00:57:53.630 --> 00:58:06.297
<v Mitch Green>But what we didn't know is that also in August, the Portland Housing Bureau had discovered A significant amount of money that was not in the budget and was not accounted for.

662
00:58:06.489 --> 00:58:16.177
<v Mitch Green>And while there was some uncertainty in the range of what that balance was, we know that as early as late August, that was communicated to be at least $11 million.

663
00:58:16.436 --> 00:58:19.938
<v Mitch Green>So there's some uncertainty of the fund balance, but we know that there's significant fund balance.

664
00:58:20.327 --> 00:58:23.581
<v Mitch Green>And I'll note that that's at the same scale as the shortfall in the BLT.

665
00:58:23.731 --> 00:58:28.914
<v Mitch Green>And so when we think about whether it's A significant discrepancy to share with council.

666
00:58:29.427 --> 00:58:36.701
<v Mitch Green>If it's the same magnitude as the thing that's driving your TAO adjustment requirement, that is significant in my view.

667
00:58:37.262 --> 00:58:42.565
<v Mitch Green>By October, council is then presented with a TAO proposal by the city administrator.

668
00:58:42.646 --> 00:58:44.760
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, we've got a work session on this.

669
00:58:44.824 --> 00:58:48.494
<v Mitch Green>I think it was October 22nd, if I have my memory right.

670
00:58:49.199 --> 00:58:49.871
<v Mitch Green>It's late October.

671
00:58:50.737 --> 00:58:53.684
<v Mitch Green>And then through October and mid-November, we debate.

672
00:58:53.780 --> 00:58:54.068
<v Daniel Morris>Thank you.

673
00:58:54.182 --> 00:58:55.123
<v Mitch Green>We consider amendments.

674
00:58:55.172 --> 00:59:01.358
<v Mitch Green>We move the TAO through the Finance Committee and then the full council, all while we still don't know about this money.

675
00:59:01.697 --> 00:59:12.548
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so council's considering a fall TAO without knowledge that there is potentially significant sums that need to be brought into that ordinance to balance our books.

676
00:59:13.882 --> 00:59:20.474
<v Mitch Green>And then we find out on November 20th, after we've gone through that TAO process, that there is $21 million.

677
00:59:20.556 --> 00:59:20.867
<v Daniel Morris>That's right.

678
00:59:21.809 --> 00:59:36.391
<v Mitch Green>So, and that's when you start to see reporting from the public saying, trying to draw a linkage between other events that happened this summer related to the Portland Housing Bureau, but as well as sort of casting doubt on our ability to govern, frankly.

679
00:59:38.351 --> 00:59:43.476
<v Mitch Green>And then in December, I worked to develop an oversight methodology.

680
00:59:43.751 --> 00:59:46.447
<v Mitch Green>I joined with some co-sponsors and I tried to bring this forward for a 9/12 session.

681
00:59:46.496 --> 00:59:46.965
<v Mitch Green>I think that's what we're going to do.

682
00:59:47.039 --> 01:00:01.454
<v Mitch Green>Agenda item for the last council meeting of the month because there were still unresolved questions surrounding this money, and I felt it was necessary to engage in some sort of a formal step more formally into the oversight space.

683
01:00:02.385 --> 01:00:07.148
<v Mitch Green>That didn't get the support of 9/12, although I do want to thank the 7 councilors who did join me in that.

684
01:00:08.623 --> 01:00:09.552
<v Mitch Green>And now here we are.

685
01:00:09.697 --> 01:00:11.061
<v Mitch Green>It's February 2026.

686
01:00:11.510 --> 01:00:13.657
<v Mitch Green>We were notified yesterday or 2 days ago.

687
01:00:13.706 --> 01:00:13.898
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

688
01:00:15.121 --> 01:00:17.922
<v Mitch Green>Of potentially much more money being available.

689
01:00:19.228 --> 01:00:21.757
<v Mitch Green>And so I think that's just the next, the latest piece of context.

690
01:00:21.804 --> 01:00:24.688
<v Mitch Green>And now we're here discussing this resolution today.

691
01:00:27.018 --> 01:00:28.039
<v Mitch Green>So how do we go about this?

692
01:00:28.135 --> 01:00:36.737
<v Mitch Green>You know, we don't have— our charter gives us investigatory power, but we don't really have any adopted rules that clarify how we might do oversight.

693
01:00:36.818 --> 01:00:39.168
<v Mitch Green>So the resolution contemplates a process.

694
01:00:40.811 --> 01:00:49.211
<v Mitch Green>When we think of oversight, I want to say that oversight always exists on a scale between informal and formal.

695
01:00:49.581 --> 01:00:53.387
<v Mitch Green>So there's different ways to do oversight with varying degrees of formality.

696
01:00:53.981 --> 01:01:02.815
<v Mitch Green>I would just say we do it all the time in the most informal sense when we ask a casual inquiry from the dais of a bureau director or the city administrator or the mayor.

697
01:01:02.878 --> 01:01:06.733
<v Mitch Green>We do it when we send emails to the administration saying, hey, I heard this from my constituents.

698
01:01:06.829 --> 01:01:07.135
<v Mitch Green>I have a question.

699
01:01:08.353 --> 01:01:11.445
<v Mitch Green>They believe that it's like maybe not in line with our policies.

700
01:01:12.503 --> 01:01:13.800
<v Mitch Green>Can I get some more information on this?

701
01:01:13.880 --> 01:01:15.820
<v Mitch Green>And that's a normal routine part of the work.

702
01:01:15.884 --> 01:01:18.817
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's where oversight should normally live.

703
01:01:19.168 --> 01:01:21.684
<v Mitch Green>Very informal, non-adversarial.

704
01:01:22.117 --> 01:01:25.018
<v Mitch Green>It's just really sort of our constant engagement.

705
01:01:25.818 --> 01:01:31.795
<v Mitch Green>At the most formal expression of this, council would invoke subpoenas and make people swear in under oath.

706
01:01:32.389 --> 01:01:33.878
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's something we want to avoid.

707
01:01:33.943 --> 01:01:34.119
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

708
01:01:34.873 --> 01:01:35.996
<v Mitch Green>And used very, very sparingly.

709
01:01:36.543 --> 01:01:40.315
<v Mitch Green>And so the method that I've contemplated here sits somewhere in the middle.

710
01:01:41.373 --> 01:01:58.965
<v Mitch Green>It's formal because we're passing a resolution to say this body's going to invoke that power, but we're nowhere near directing the auditor to go out and issue subpoenas and having people lawyer up and put their hand on the sacred text of their choice and say, I swear that what I'm about to say is true.

711
01:01:59.045 --> 01:01:59.798
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a good point.

712
01:02:00.396 --> 01:02:04.110
<v Mitch Green>So this is really a kind of middle ground in terms of formality.

713
01:02:06.179 --> 01:02:12.090
<v Mitch Green>And just to remind you of the charter authority that gives us, I would say, just not only the power but the duty here.

714
01:02:13.519 --> 01:02:25.735
<v Mitch Green>You know, the underlying motive here and contemplation in our charter is that in order for council to do its legislative function, right, if we're to do our work well, we need to have the information that we need to do that work.

715
01:02:25.784 --> 01:02:25.898
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

716
01:02:26.106 --> 01:02:42.284
<v Mitch Green>And if we find we're in a situation where we don't have that, the full picture, or there's key facts missing, then we are empowered by Charter Section 2-109 to compel the production of books, documents, evidence.

717
01:02:42.751 --> 01:02:47.414
<v Mitch Green>We can go so far as issuing subpoenas for folks to show up and talk to us.

718
01:02:48.398 --> 01:02:49.947
<v Mitch Green>But we don't do that here in this resolution.

719
01:02:49.994 --> 01:02:51.797
<v Mitch Green>We're just simply saying we want to collect these records.

720
01:02:51.853 --> 01:02:51.961
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

721
01:02:52.702 --> 01:03:09.679
<v Mitch Green>We want to bring this into the Council Ops to help us collate this, and then we're going to schedule an oversight hearing with invitations, not summons, to come and talk to us and answer to a structured set of questions that are also in the resolution, with plenty of time for folks to get ready for that.

722
01:03:09.760 --> 01:03:12.228
<v Mitch Green>So in the resolution itself, it documents a process.

723
01:03:12.726 --> 01:03:22.657
<v Mitch Green>The first, if we adopt this resolution today, it would direct the city administrator to share Relevant public records with council and council operations by February 20th.

724
01:03:23.315 --> 01:03:37.911
<v Mitch Green>So that's sort of going through and saying what's responsive in our record surrounding the questions that follow here in item 3, and then getting that to council ops and also councilors to start to consume and think about in advance of an oversight hearing.

725
01:03:38.809 --> 01:03:54.367
<v Mitch Green>The step 2 in the process really asks council ops to help us be this sort of Independent arbiter of like, here's the information we collected in this process and here's what we got from the city, but also here's what we got from other sources because there's other information that's floating out there too.

726
01:03:54.851 --> 01:04:04.688
<v Mitch Green>And I think it's really important for council to be able to delineate between, you know, here's what a journalist submitted as part of their reporting versus what we actually get from our own internal systems.

727
01:04:04.802 --> 01:04:05.516
<v Mitch Green>It's really important.

728
01:04:06.003 --> 01:04:08.827
<v Mitch Green>And it's also important that this doesn't just go to Councilor Green's inbox.

729
01:04:08.876 --> 01:04:08.925
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

730
01:04:09.016 --> 01:04:12.019
<v Mitch Green>And then I'm the one sifting through the data and then I'm saying, here's what I found.

731
01:04:12.405 --> 01:04:20.201
<v Mitch Green>It needs to go to all of us and it needs to go to council ops to help them do this, help us do this independently and with some objectivity here.

732
01:04:21.168 --> 01:04:29.409
<v Mitch Green>So the dates that you see in here are actually in the amendment that I'm going to move after I talk about this because I first wrote this thing months ago.

733
01:04:29.472 --> 01:04:30.898
<v Mitch Green>So obviously you need to shift the dates.

734
01:04:31.742 --> 01:04:35.485
<v Mitch Green>But then finally, council president will schedule an oversight hearing no later than March 6th.

735
01:04:35.550 --> 01:04:35.597
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

736
01:04:36.614 --> 01:04:38.110
<v Mitch Green>With invitations for testimony.

737
01:04:38.157 --> 01:04:50.610
<v Mitch Green>So again, we're not compelling anyone to show up, but we're saying we would like you to show up and answer, help us, you know, get some clarity on the information we found for relevant individuals to address the following questions.

738
01:04:50.659 --> 01:04:58.083
<v Mitch Green>And these are just outlined in the resolution because I wanted this to be focused and not just a scattershot of whatever, wherever the heck I'm thinking about that day.

739
01:04:58.148 --> 01:05:01.135
<v Mitch Green>Like, let's, let's really focus on these very specific questions, which is.

740
01:05:01.184 --> 01:05:01.344
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

741
01:05:01.762 --> 01:05:06.465
<v Mitch Green>What happened to the funds and what led them to— what led to them not being spent in prior years?

742
01:05:07.684 --> 01:05:08.711
<v Mitch Green>Who was aware of the funds?

743
01:05:08.903 --> 01:05:10.766
<v Mitch Green>At what point in time was each party made aware?

744
01:05:11.231 --> 01:05:13.349
<v Mitch Green>Why was council not informed in a timely manner?

745
01:05:13.880 --> 01:05:22.675
<v Mitch Green>Third, what dynamics led to this information not being shared with council, and what was the sequence of events given that council had received differing accounts of what has occurred?

746
01:05:23.027 --> 01:05:27.456
<v Mitch Green>That's where you get this engagement with this outside narrative construction through the press.

747
01:05:28.510 --> 01:05:28.798
<v Unidentified speaker>Right.

748
01:05:29.088 --> 01:05:49.818
<v Mitch Green>And then finally, to what degree decisions were made around these funds and when information was or wasn't shared as it pertains to the development of the Fall Towel, which I think is absolutely critical because, again, some people in the city government had information about money in the development of the Fall Towel and others did not, and specifically council did not.

749
01:05:50.548 --> 01:05:52.106
<v Mitch Green>So that's really important to figure out.

750
01:05:52.414 --> 01:05:54.344
<v Mitch Green>So that's the process outlined by the resolution.

751
01:05:56.340 --> 01:05:59.101
<v Mitch Green>And it leaves it to the council president to schedule these oversight hearings.

752
01:06:02.012 --> 01:06:10.543
<v Mitch Green>And then I'll just note that after I'm done with this, I'm gonna move Green 1, which just adjusts the underlying to have the dates that are matched on this slide.

753
01:06:10.606 --> 01:06:13.237
<v Mitch Green>So maybe I'll leave this slide up here and we can just move into questions.

754
01:06:14.242 --> 01:06:14.371
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

755
01:06:14.565 --> 01:06:18.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>We can do technical clarifying questions from councilors in queue.

756
01:06:19.666 --> 01:06:25.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green, Have you moved the amendment specifically so public testimony can be reacting to the actual language?

757
01:06:25.610 --> 01:06:29.907
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll vote on the testimony, or we'll vote after testimony on the amendment and then vote on the resolution.

758
01:06:31.369 --> 01:06:32.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark?

759
01:06:34.621 --> 01:06:36.052
<v Olivia Clark>I don't have clarifying questions.

760
01:06:36.164 --> 01:06:36.327
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

761
01:06:36.554 --> 01:06:38.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick?

762
01:06:39.375 --> 01:06:40.597
<v Steve Novick>Yes, thank you, Mr. President.

763
01:06:41.079 --> 01:06:47.860
<v Steve Novick>My question, Councilor Green, is about what relevance this Information might have had to the TAO.

764
01:06:48.326 --> 01:06:59.498
<v Steve Novick>As I recall, one of the major issues with the TAO was what reaction was the council going to make to the prospect of a general fund shortfall in this year.

765
01:07:00.347 --> 01:07:10.110
<v Steve Novick>And although I proposed taking some of this housing money and putting it into the general fund, it appears I was in a distinct minority.

766
01:07:10.702 --> 01:07:16.972
<v Steve Novick>So I'm just wondering how you think that the information would've affected what we did about the TAO?

767
01:07:18.775 --> 01:07:21.177
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I mean, I can tell you straight up that, Councilor, it's a great question.

768
01:07:22.260 --> 01:07:36.789
<v Mitch Green>Had I any indication early on whatsoever that there was RSO funds or restricted funds related to housing and tenant stabilization or rental assistance, my participation in an amendment process would look differently.

769
01:07:38.019 --> 01:07:41.755
<v Mitch Green>Like if you'll recall in Morillo 1, we were trying to get money for rent assistance.

770
01:07:43.108 --> 01:07:48.632
<v Mitch Green>And we were paying for it by, in part, cutting into the impact reduction program.

771
01:07:49.708 --> 01:07:58.748
<v Mitch Green>It's entirely likely that I would not have gone down that very controversial road had I known that there was $21 million or maybe even $10 million at play in that.

772
01:07:59.822 --> 01:08:01.766
<v Mitch Green>Those negotiations could have been quite different.

773
01:08:01.911 --> 01:08:03.338
<v Mitch Green>Those conversations could have been quite different.

774
01:08:03.420 --> 01:08:06.148
<v Mitch Green>But in the absence of that information, I didn't know that.

775
01:08:06.326 --> 01:08:07.867
<v Mitch Green>And so— I think that's a fair point.

776
01:08:08.235 --> 01:08:11.126
<v Mitch Green>I'm speaking for my part and how I engaged in that process.

777
01:08:11.222 --> 01:08:12.635
<v Mitch Green>That would have been really critical information.

778
01:08:12.748 --> 01:08:29.640
<v Mitch Green>But I think what I'm more worried about fundamentally is if we're developing a TAO that looks at all of our fund balances and we're not considering the inclusion of this new money that's being found.

779
01:08:29.689 --> 01:08:34.844
<v Mitch Green>So we're, you know, we're putting forward an adjustment ordinance that it's not balanced anyway.

780
01:08:34.891 --> 01:08:35.646
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a fair point.

781
01:08:35.823 --> 01:08:37.372
<v Mitch Green>Because we have not allocated those monies.

782
01:08:37.421 --> 01:08:38.533
<v Mitch Green>So there's that piece too.

783
01:08:38.613 --> 01:08:40.516
<v Mitch Green>So I'm not sure if that answers your question.

784
01:08:44.435 --> 01:08:48.122
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

785
01:08:48.962 --> 01:08:59.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, I'm looking at the new dates on your amendment, and I am just wondering if you ran those dates by the administration.

786
01:08:59.118 --> 01:09:01.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are they going to be able to meet those dates?

787
01:09:01.289 --> 01:09:04.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Same for Council Operations and Council President.

788
01:09:04.396 --> 01:09:08.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are you going to be able to schedule this work session by March 6th?

789
01:09:08.712 --> 01:09:10.226
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know how backed up our calendar is.

790
01:09:13.801 --> 01:09:23.960
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I can— I'll start with the— you know, I did check in with Council Ops, and I think the initial concern was like, whoa, these dates are— I have to get this data tomorrow because the underlying didn't have those adjusted.

791
01:09:24.007 --> 01:09:38.185
<v Mitch Green>But I think when we first anticipated this in December, The general lag periods that are built into this were workable for council ops, and with the amendment that's in play pushing it out, I didn't get any pushback.

792
01:09:38.233 --> 01:09:43.521
<v Mitch Green>Dana, you're here, so you can speak for yourself, but it seems like that's workable on the council ops side.

793
01:09:44.067 --> 01:09:53.505
<v Mitch Green>No, I haven't talked to CA Lee on this specifically on whether they can execute the gathering of the data request, but it is 2 weeks from today.

794
01:09:53.552 --> 01:09:53.664
<v David Pearl>Thank you.

795
01:09:54.483 --> 01:09:58.994
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>City Administrator, is that something that we can expect you all to be able to successfully meet?

796
01:10:00.167 --> 01:10:00.969
<v Raymond C. Lee>I believe so.

797
01:10:01.145 --> 01:10:07.536
<v Raymond C. Lee>We'll treat it like a regular open records request and try to process and get it through the process in that manner.

798
01:10:08.274 --> 01:10:08.756
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

799
01:10:09.077 --> 01:10:09.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President?

800
01:10:11.180 --> 01:10:16.766
<v Jamie Dunphy>With action by council today, my team and council ops will work starting today to find time to schedule this.

801
01:10:17.039 --> 01:10:18.533
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have every confidence that we will.

802
01:10:19.127 --> 01:10:22.627
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have dates available that aren't already filled with work session needs.

803
01:10:23.000 --> 01:10:24.708
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe we will be able to find a spot, a time.

804
01:10:25.047 --> 01:10:26.079
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

805
01:10:29.000 --> 01:10:29.613
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

806
01:10:31.564 --> 01:10:32.710
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

807
01:10:33.015 --> 01:10:55.470
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I just have a question about, in terms of whether the questions that the resolution outlines, some questions that are going to be able to be asked in this, uh, hearing, and I wanted to understand if that list was exhaustive, uh, or if there are other questions that would be— is it designed that this is the of it exclusively, or could we talk about other things in it, either by virtue of adding that to the resolution or just bringing them up live?

808
01:10:56.368 --> 01:10:57.122
<v Mitch Green>It's a good question.

809
01:10:57.171 --> 01:11:14.507
<v Mitch Green>So my intent by putting the specific questions in there was to sort of model what we've seen in some other styles, in particular in Baltimore, where they say, we'd like the infrastructure bureau to show up and present on this item, and here are some very specific questions you want to be prepared for.

810
01:11:14.572 --> 01:11:30.572
<v Mitch Green>And so I think the idea is to provide these as a general enough skeleton there To give the city administrator enough of a focus frame to do that records request, because you can't really— you can't do that public records gathering if you don't really know what the scope is limited to.

811
01:11:30.653 --> 01:11:42.831
<v Mitch Green>But once we get the information for us to digest and we show up to this oversight hearing, I think that we are free to explore any line of questioning that's relevant to that.

812
01:11:43.234 --> 01:11:56.274
<v Mitch Green>So if there's not a very specific edge case, Or if there's not an aspect of this that's not contemplated here, that's in part because we don't necessarily know what the full scopes of questions are going to be until we see the information come back.

813
01:11:56.819 --> 01:12:04.591
<v Mitch Green>And then the resolution leaves it open for the council president to schedule as many oversight hearings as are necessary to sort of close the question.

814
01:12:05.615 --> 01:12:11.497
<v Mitch Green>So the very first one is sort of our opportunity to react to what information is collated and collected for us.

815
01:12:12.105 --> 01:12:21.543
<v Mitch Green>But where we go from there, I think, is going to depend upon, you know, our judgment as a body and the presiding officer's judgment as to whether we're engaged in relevant questioning.

816
01:12:21.976 --> 01:12:36.301
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's also part of what we're trying to establish here in terms of norms, because what I really want to avoid is this becoming a sort of like, you know, what's the word I'm looking for, like a kangaroo court in some sense.

817
01:12:36.398 --> 01:12:36.557
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

818
01:12:37.118 --> 01:12:38.896
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, this really needs to be productive.

819
01:12:39.347 --> 01:12:47.097
<v Mitch Green>And I can't stress enough that like this isn't trying to do a gotcha on any particular aspect of this city, but say, here are some questions for us to focus on.

820
01:12:48.899 --> 01:12:52.113
<v Mitch Green>We can't rule out that there aren't new questions that emerge from that, if that makes sense.

821
01:12:53.099 --> 01:13:04.864
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I'm reading it because it says, including without limitation communications and other information pertinent to understanding the following questions, just trying to understand which part is the without limitation here.

822
01:13:05.246 --> 01:13:14.095
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm broadly supportive of it, but I'm trying to understand, especially as it relates to the 4th question, to what degree were decisions made around these funds and what information was or wasn't shared?

823
01:13:14.302 --> 01:13:17.076
<v Sameer Kanal>And then it says, as it pertains to development of the Fall Tower proposal.

824
01:13:17.588 --> 01:13:28.667
<v Sameer Kanal>And so the questions that I'm interested in also adding to this are, how many, if any, positions have been eliminated at the Housing Bureau in the course of the time since this money started being accrued?

825
01:13:29.051 --> 01:13:31.118
<v Sameer Kanal>Would any of those positions have been able to be funded?

826
01:13:31.953 --> 01:13:36.411
<v Sameer Kanal>By these dollars given the restrictions that the money has in all of these streams?

827
01:13:36.908 --> 01:13:41.206
<v Sameer Kanal>Were any of the positions filled or were they all vacant at the time of their elimination?

828
01:13:41.719 --> 01:13:44.588
<v Sameer Kanal>And then just related to that, if any of those positions are represented.

829
01:13:44.942 --> 01:13:53.729
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I think that that's maybe outside the scope of the TAO, except as it relates to the explanation you were giving, Councilor Green, about the amendment, Morillo 1.

830
01:13:54.306 --> 01:14:05.033
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do think that it was relevant to previous budget cycles, including So I'm trying to understand if that's something that, that maybe the information that we get will lead us to those questions.

831
01:14:05.081 --> 01:14:11.630
<v Sameer Kanal>But I at least wanted to mention that out loud from a legislative intent perspective, that that is something I'm interested in asking about.

832
01:14:12.487 --> 01:14:13.893
<v Mitch Green>No, that's noted there.

833
01:14:14.119 --> 01:14:14.362
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

834
01:14:15.090 --> 01:14:16.076
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

835
01:14:20.131 --> 01:14:24.315
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President Dunphy.

836
01:14:25.310 --> 01:14:43.541
<v Loretta Smith>I have a, um, couple of technical questions that I need DCA Oliveira and CFO Biery and Director Bonacar to ask before I can make an educated vote on this particular piece.

837
01:14:44.045 --> 01:14:45.783
<v Loretta Smith>Could they come up here for a second?

838
01:14:52.354 --> 01:14:59.278
<v Jamie Dunphy>And as our staff are approaching, I will recall we're not— we're mostly focusing on process at this moment, not on the specifics.

839
01:14:59.761 --> 01:15:00.887
<v Loretta Smith>And that's what I'm— yeah, perfect.

840
01:15:00.952 --> 01:15:10.324
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to make sure we're talking about today having a— our first oversight.

841
01:15:11.510 --> 01:15:15.957
<v Loretta Smith>But before we can have an oversight, I need to know who to talk to.

842
01:15:16.609 --> 01:15:26.167
<v Loretta Smith>So can you explain to me, um, CFO Biery, how do you all get information from the bureaus?

843
01:15:26.668 --> 01:15:29.476
<v Loretta Smith>Not just the Portland Housing Bureau, but all of the bureaus.

844
01:15:30.622 --> 01:15:32.188
<v Loretta Smith>You all don't handle that information.

845
01:15:32.235 --> 01:15:34.076
<v Loretta Smith>That comes directly from the bureaus.

846
01:15:34.270 --> 01:15:41.606
<v Loretta Smith>And if I think this in my head, that you depend on them to give you the information, you don't gather the information.

847
01:15:42.266 --> 01:15:48.403
<v Loretta Smith>So could you explain to me how do you all get the information, the financial budget information?

848
01:15:48.612 --> 01:15:54.104
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, Councilor, I'll attempt and let me know if I'm not answering the question the way you're looking for it.

849
01:15:54.153 --> 01:15:56.738
<v Jonas Biery>For the record, Jonas Biery, the city's Chief Financial Officer.

850
01:15:57.927 --> 01:16:07.581
<v Jonas Biery>So the primary method of gathering this information is through the budget development process managed through the City Budget Office and Ruth Levine, Director of that office, as mentioned earlier.

851
01:16:08.529 --> 01:16:23.207
<v Jonas Biery>So typically as that budget, annual budget development effort occurs, there's a coordinated effort between the bureaus and the City Budget Office to submit, as the bureaus submit that information.

852
01:16:23.386 --> 01:16:23.547
<v Unidentified speaker>Right.

853
01:16:23.887 --> 01:16:34.082
<v Jonas Biery>The Budget Office with other participation kind of reviews, assesses, and translates that information into the budget document.

854
01:16:34.405 --> 01:16:44.015
<v Jonas Biery>We then also have periodic checkpoints, as you know, the technical adjustment ordinances which are an opportunity to get eyes on that as well.

855
01:16:44.064 --> 01:16:46.070
<v Jonas Biery>So that's generally the process.

856
01:16:46.136 --> 01:16:47.203
<v Loretta Smith>This is not your data.

857
01:16:47.269 --> 01:16:50.305
<v Loretta Smith>This is the bureau's data that comes to you.

858
01:16:52.811 --> 01:16:57.886
<v Jonas Biery>The bureau submits information through the city budget systems based upon the guidance that's provided.

859
01:16:59.287 --> 01:17:03.337
<v Jonas Biery>And so I just want to be— the source of the information is the bureaus.

860
01:17:04.087 --> 01:17:05.127
<v Jonas Biery>It comes to the council.

861
01:17:05.421 --> 01:17:08.796
<v Jonas Biery>Budget Office to help manage that, and it becomes— it's city data.

862
01:17:08.860 --> 01:17:09.792
<v Jonas Biery>I just want to be clear about it.

863
01:17:09.856 --> 01:17:10.579
<v Jonas Biery>It's not owned by—.

864
01:17:10.579 --> 01:17:11.141
<v Loretta Smith>It's all city data.

865
01:17:11.206 --> 01:17:18.194
<v Loretta Smith>But what I'm trying to differentiate between, because if we're going to try to get information, we need to know where the data originates from.

866
01:17:18.420 --> 01:17:18.613
<v Loretta Smith>Correct.

867
01:17:18.661 --> 01:17:20.252
<v Loretta Smith>So it doesn't originate from you.

868
01:17:21.152 --> 01:17:37.569
<v Loretta Smith>And the reason why I wanted to talk to you too, DC Oliveira, that information for your particular departments that are under your purview, Is that information that you get from the bureaus as well?

869
01:17:37.698 --> 01:17:42.613
<v Loretta Smith>This is not information that you actually come up with, it's from the bureaus, correct?

870
01:17:43.417 --> 01:17:44.702
<v Mitch Green>DC Oliveira, for the record.

871
01:17:44.878 --> 01:17:45.520
<v Mitch Green>Donnie Oliveira.

872
01:17:45.586 --> 01:17:46.148
<v Mitch Green>Correct, Councilor.

873
01:17:46.951 --> 01:17:52.814
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so then my next question is going to be to, uh, Director Bonacar.

874
01:17:53.471 --> 01:17:57.118
<v Loretta Smith>So do you create the information?

875
01:17:57.310 --> 01:18:08.904
<v Loretta Smith>So when we're asking for information, we're going to call this oversight hearing, if this passes, do you have like finance people in your department that creates this information, or— and then they give it to the director?

876
01:18:08.953 --> 01:18:10.478
<v Loretta Smith>Because you're the director, correct?

877
01:18:10.863 --> 01:18:11.121
<v Jamie Dunphy>Correct.

878
01:18:11.280 --> 01:18:14.733
<v Loretta Smith>But you have individual— you have a whole finance team, correct?

879
01:18:14.894 --> 01:18:15.215
<v Jonas Biery>Correct.

880
01:18:16.033 --> 01:18:17.800
<v Loretta Smith>And how many of those people do you have?

881
01:18:18.345 --> 01:18:22.569
<v Loretta Smith>Because I think that's going to be very important when we're sending out invitations.

882
01:18:22.921 --> 01:18:25.363
<v Loretta Smith>We need to know who to send the invitation to.

883
01:18:27.737 --> 01:18:30.336
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think there, there will be clarity on who that should be.

884
01:18:30.463 --> 01:18:31.010
<v Mitch Green>I, I think—.

885
01:18:31.010 --> 01:18:33.239
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, how many finance people do you have in your department?

886
01:18:33.287 --> 01:18:35.694
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think the team is about 8 or 9 folks.

887
01:18:35.757 --> 01:18:46.811
<v Loretta Smith>So you have about 8 or 9 people who are responsible for different sources of money that comes into your department, who's responsible for keeping track of all this information, correct?

888
01:18:46.908 --> 01:18:47.212
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

889
01:18:47.469 --> 01:19:07.101
<v Loretta Smith>So I just want to make sure, um, Councilor Green, that we're clear because A lot of us may think that we're going to talk to Ruth and Jonas and, uh, DC Oliveira only, but that's not, that's not the ticket from what I understand.

890
01:19:07.697 --> 01:19:17.378
<v Loretta Smith>We have to talk to those 8 or 9 people who are directly responsible for keeping track of the dollars in those, in those bureaus.

891
01:19:18.476 --> 01:19:29.827
<v Loretta Smith>And so I think we have been kind of led in a different way, as if CFO Biery is responsible for the data.

892
01:19:30.533 --> 01:19:41.845
<v Loretta Smith>But that data comes from a department that comes from a particular group of finance officers who actually do the numbers and are responsible.

893
01:19:42.425 --> 01:19:45.551
<v Loretta Smith>And so I have one more question for you, CFO Biery.

894
01:19:45.618 --> 01:19:45.685
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

895
01:19:46.213 --> 01:19:49.216
<v Loretta Smith>Oh no, no, I'll go back to Director Bonacourt.

896
01:19:49.279 --> 01:19:56.393
<v Loretta Smith>So do all of the, the different pots of money, do they get reported every year?

897
01:19:56.618 --> 01:20:06.621
<v Loretta Smith>Do you know that the 3 that actually got reported late or have a surplus, are they required to, to report every single year?

898
01:20:10.175 --> 01:20:11.421
<v Jamie Dunphy>For the record, yes.

899
01:20:11.641 --> 01:20:11.770
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

900
01:20:11.882 --> 01:20:12.668
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so they are.

901
01:20:12.845 --> 01:20:26.042
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so make sure you put that as a part of your questioning, because if they're supposed to report every year with that large of a surplus, it appears that it wasn't just one year.

902
01:20:26.572 --> 01:20:31.645
<v Loretta Smith>It appears that there probably were multiple years that these funds built up.

903
01:20:32.207 --> 01:20:38.418
<v Loretta Smith>So I want to make sure that we're asking the right questions of the people when we actually have an oversight.

904
01:20:39.238 --> 01:20:47.570
<v Loretta Smith>Um, the other issue is, is there a timeline from which we are supposed to get the information when you end your budget session?

905
01:20:47.747 --> 01:20:58.262
<v Loretta Smith>Um, Director Bonacar, is there a timeline that you're supposed to go by to make sure that CFO Biery has all the information?

906
01:20:58.520 --> 01:21:00.189
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, like, do you have like a checklist?

907
01:21:00.591 --> 01:21:19.559
<v Loretta Smith>Like, okay, I want to make sure that this— the rental assistance— I want to make sure that the Airbnb money I want to make sure— is there a process that you all have internally to get the information to Ruth, who is at the Central Budgeting Office, and to your DCA, who is your direct supervisor?

908
01:21:19.639 --> 01:21:24.908
<v Loretta Smith>Do you have a checklist that you mark off every year when you're doing this?

909
01:21:25.421 --> 01:21:29.935
<v Loretta Smith>And I know you just became the, the new interim director.

910
01:21:29.983 --> 01:21:33.019
<v Loretta Smith>We had a previous director that was terminated a couple of months ago.

911
01:21:33.592 --> 01:21:38.969
<v Loretta Smith>But she was here for 3 years and you were the assistant director, but you should know some of this protocol.

912
01:21:39.359 --> 01:21:44.936
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm just trying to figure out so that we know what the protocol is so that we're asking the right questions.

913
01:21:45.083 --> 01:21:46.123
<v Dan Ryan>She was not here for 3 years.

914
01:21:47.380 --> 01:21:48.329
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, she was here for 2 years.

915
01:21:48.377 --> 01:21:57.478
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for, for, um, but she was here for 2 years and she resigned.

916
01:21:57.801 --> 01:21:58.270
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

917
01:21:58.997 --> 01:22:11.445
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, she separated from the city, but That's— I know some of this falls on the previous director, but I'm trying to figure out, is there a natural protocol that everybody has to follow every year when we go down the budget cycle?

918
01:22:11.654 --> 01:22:13.787
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I'm trying to figure out.

919
01:22:14.140 --> 01:22:14.445
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is.

920
01:22:14.878 --> 01:22:25.547
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just for the record, I served previously as the interim director for the Portland Housing Bureau and then spent a little bit of transition time with Helmi as she sort of onboarded and moved from California.

921
01:22:25.853 --> 01:22:26.173
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

922
01:22:26.912 --> 01:22:31.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>So still in a learning process, but the broad answer to your question is yes.

923
01:22:31.413 --> 01:22:31.686
<v Loretta Smith>Is yes.

924
01:22:31.863 --> 01:22:33.081
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so we can expect that.

925
01:22:33.145 --> 01:22:45.067
<v Loretta Smith>So if we ask some questions like that of the financial folks who— the 8 people who are responsible for this— that they should know about when they reported monies.

926
01:22:45.259 --> 01:22:56.516
<v Loretta Smith>So that, I mean, that's going to get to the— that's going to get to it if they reported the money or not, because it sounds like they're supposed to report the money annually And it appears that we have a surplus that covered it multi-years.

927
01:23:00.171 --> 01:23:01.184
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just making a statement.

928
01:23:01.231 --> 01:23:08.381
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just, I'm just saying, so, so when we ask those questions, that they won't be surprised that you said that there's a protocol.

929
01:23:08.525 --> 01:23:15.417
<v Loretta Smith>And if we ask them and they say it's not a protocol, then we need to be believing what you and DCA Oliveira are saying.

930
01:23:16.173 --> 01:23:27.698
<v Loretta Smith>Because you can understand right now that all of us Individually and collectively, we are really trying to figure out how to reconcile because we're feeling uncomfortable right now.

931
01:23:27.938 --> 01:23:31.833
<v Jamie Dunphy>And again, Councilor, I would just— we're starting to edge into some of the content rather than process.

932
01:23:31.930 --> 01:23:32.844
<v Loretta Smith>I'm making a statement.

933
01:23:32.908 --> 01:23:35.104
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just saying what I feel uncomfortable about.

934
01:23:35.231 --> 01:23:46.103
<v Loretta Smith>But what will make me feel more comfortable is I know that they have a protocol, and if we ask a question, that they should be able to answer those questions within the line.

935
01:23:46.215 --> 01:24:08.068
<v Loretta Smith>And the last question that I have for, for you, um, I understand that you don't want to make this a kangaroo court, um, Councilor Green, and I'm just wondering, to avoid that, why don't we just call this actual hearing in our Arts and Economy, under which, uh, the Housing Bureau brings all their issues to?

936
01:24:08.292 --> 01:24:09.287
<v Loretta Smith>Why don't we just do that?

937
01:24:09.497 --> 01:24:24.563
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, so I've got a I thought about that, and what the charter says, 2-106 or 109, is that council as a body or a duly designated committee can do oversight.

938
01:24:24.722 --> 01:24:41.961
<v Mitch Green>We don't have that power conferred on our individual committees, and I think that there's— this is a matter of significance such that every— all 12 of us who are elected should be at the in the room where you're asking the questions and you're engaging with this discovery process, not, not a subcommittee of council.

939
01:24:42.282 --> 01:24:42.457
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

940
01:24:42.521 --> 01:24:52.877
<v Loretta Smith>So that's what I think it's really important for us to do it in this formal way.

941
01:24:53.984 --> 01:25:00.439
<v Loretta Smith>Um, but one thing that I would change is I don't believe that Council Ops need to be responsible for this, for putting this together.

942
01:25:00.502 --> 01:25:01.948
<v Loretta Smith>I think this is so important.

943
01:25:02.108 --> 01:25:06.613
<v Loretta Smith>If we're going to do this, That needs to come out of the council president's office.

944
01:25:07.238 --> 01:25:12.637
<v Loretta Smith>The council president needs to be in charge of this whole process and putting this on, not council ops.

945
01:25:13.872 --> 01:25:15.442
<v Mitch Green>Just, just let me clarify here.

946
01:25:15.729 --> 01:25:40.313
<v Mitch Green>Council ops is only just handling, like, receiving the data from the city administrator as well as, like, journalists who might have some information on this and providing repository for us to, um, to access The council president will actually do the scheduling of the oversight hearings themselves, engage in the invitations based upon the outcome of that discovery, and then allow us to structure this.

947
01:25:40.730 --> 01:25:41.195
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

948
01:25:41.292 --> 01:25:42.030
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I'm saying.

949
01:25:42.095 --> 01:25:52.159
<v Loretta Smith>So I want to make it clear that Council Ops is not responsible for this, that we have an elected person who is our council president who should be running this show, not Council Ops.

950
01:25:52.288 --> 01:25:56.077
<v Loretta Smith>I don't want them to think in no kind of way that they're the last word on this.

951
01:25:56.157 --> 01:26:11.359
<v Loretta Smith>It needs to come from our, our council president, and that needs to be made clear And I'll just note for the record, the buck stops with me, but Councilor Lott— I wanted to be clear that it stops with you because this, this actual resolution doesn't, doesn't make it seem like that.

952
01:26:11.359 --> 01:26:12.970
<v Loretta Smith>It makes it seem like they're the last stop.

953
01:26:13.300 --> 01:26:14.140
<v Loretta Smith>You're the last stop.

954
01:26:14.140 --> 01:26:14.779
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

955
01:26:14.779 --> 01:26:18.020
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you very much for, uh, giving me that technical information.

956
01:26:18.380 --> 01:26:19.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

957
01:26:19.460 --> 01:26:21.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

958
01:26:21.199 --> 01:26:22.000
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

959
01:26:22.220 --> 01:26:31.702
<v Steve Novick>Uh, I just wanted to actually, if you could stay, um, uh, DCA Biery, um, Mr. Bonaccart, the question— I wanna follow up on something that Councilor Smith already alluded to.

960
01:26:32.104 --> 01:26:39.652
<v Steve Novick>Is it true, do we know that actually this money was accumulating for more than one year, that it's probably over several years?

961
01:26:41.778 --> 01:26:46.382
<v Jonas Biery>Councilor, I believe that that's true, that the balance as it exists accumulated.

962
01:26:46.431 --> 01:26:51.118
<v Jonas Biery>It's not as binary as that because there's funds that come in and funds that go out.

963
01:26:51.199 --> 01:26:52.713
<v Jonas Biery>And so it's difficult to track that.

964
01:26:53.051 --> 01:26:57.939
<v Jonas Biery>But I do believe it was not, A point-in-time activity.

965
01:26:57.939 --> 01:27:08.149
<v Jonas Biery>I also just maybe take a quick moment to be clear about sort of the reality of legacy systems that existed prior to this form of government that do not exist today.

966
01:27:08.399 --> 01:27:23.840
<v Jonas Biery>And so I just think that's really important consideration as we're talking about, you know, the kind of maybe the root causes that led us here are not the same as the reality that we face in our financial oversight and management systems today.

967
01:27:23.840 --> 01:27:24.659
<v Jonas Biery>And so I just think that's important consideration for— Thank you.

968
01:27:26.460 --> 01:27:30.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

969
01:27:30.079 --> 01:27:32.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

970
01:27:32.880 --> 01:27:36.359
<v Sameer Kanal>Hi, uh, just quick technical question because that just opened the door.

971
01:27:36.359 --> 01:27:42.020
<v Sameer Kanal>You operate on, on first in, first out though, in terms of how you're— when you're talking about things that accumulate over years, right?

972
01:27:42.020 --> 01:27:47.199
<v Sameer Kanal>Like, what's your basis for, um, kind of have to make a working assumption?

973
01:27:47.199 --> 01:28:00.983
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, Councilor, I think— I mean, we're, we're, we're— I want to be careful that we're not kind of conflating because there's sort of the accounting principle of first in, first out, and that may be different from the way that You know, fund dollars are tracked in various funds and subfunds.

974
01:28:01.903 --> 01:28:02.386
<v Sameer Kanal>Fair enough.

975
01:28:03.033 --> 01:28:05.469
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I just wanted to— that's my only question for you.

976
01:28:05.518 --> 01:28:14.948
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't know if anyone else has, but I wanted to just talk about one quick thing related to the question that Councilor Smith asked about why this isn't going to committee and the assignment.

977
01:28:17.003 --> 01:28:20.703
<v Sameer Kanal>We have talked about potentially that being a role of the Committee of the Whole in the future.

978
01:28:21.645 --> 01:28:22.699
<v Sameer Kanal>That's a good idea.

979
01:28:23.511 --> 01:28:29.122
<v Sameer Kanal>It wouldn't necessarily have to be there, but it's an option in the future should we allow for that creation and then create it.

980
01:28:29.604 --> 01:28:33.578
<v Sameer Kanal>But that wouldn't happen before the timeline that this document lays out.

981
01:28:33.627 --> 01:28:42.268
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to clarify that effectively, as of this moment, our only option is to have it be the full council if we're going to do a formalized process.

982
01:28:42.347 --> 01:28:43.438
<v Sameer Kanal>And I do think we should.

983
01:28:43.694 --> 01:28:43.951
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

984
01:28:44.095 --> 01:28:45.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

985
01:28:45.554 --> 01:28:46.194
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

986
01:28:47.220 --> 01:28:47.557
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

987
01:28:47.622 --> 01:28:54.134
<v Eric Zimmerman>Just a couple of technical questions, and I I truly don't know who the right source to ask or to answer these would be.

988
01:28:55.161 --> 01:29:01.867
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm wondering how staff will appear, and then I guess the A to that would be how do unionized staff appear?

989
01:29:03.262 --> 01:29:05.076
<v Eric Zimmerman>Does the city attorney represent them?

990
01:29:05.509 --> 01:29:06.904
<v Eric Zimmerman>Does the union represent them?

991
01:29:07.145 --> 01:29:09.247
<v Eric Zimmerman>Do we expect legal representation to occur?

992
01:29:10.722 --> 01:29:20.434
<v Eric Zimmerman>And considering that a significant part of the situation Probably a major source of information would be the former housing director.

993
01:29:22.387 --> 01:29:34.386
<v Eric Zimmerman>What authorities does the council have if such a hearing were to occur to get information from the head of the organization that is in question, which is the former housing director, since she's separated with a large payment agreement out in severance?

994
01:29:34.435 --> 01:29:38.344
<v Eric Zimmerman>So do we have the ability to get information from her?

995
01:29:39.523 --> 01:29:39.828
<v Daniel Morris>And—.

996
01:29:41.655 --> 01:30:12.921
<v Eric Zimmerman>How will the council, because this would be a new step, how will the council receive, I'm gonna call it training, on what this can look like, should look like, probably from our city attorney, and to make sure that we don't turn into what I'm very concerned will be is, an inquiry that really jumps the bounds of good order.

997
01:30:13.195 --> 01:30:17.375
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's kind of where some of my technical questions lie right now before we discuss.

998
01:30:19.238 --> 01:30:20.814
<v Mitch Green>I can speak to some of that.

999
01:30:22.755 --> 01:30:30.793
<v Mitch Green>In terms of the, how do you compel someone who maybe doesn't work here anymore or may be relevant to the questioning to show up?

1000
01:30:32.060 --> 01:30:39.412
<v Mitch Green>What the structure that we're contemplating in this specific resolution is To stop short of actually issuing summons and subpoenas.

1001
01:30:40.167 --> 01:30:45.371
<v Mitch Green>And so if people choose not to show up, then I think they choose not to show up.

1002
01:30:45.466 --> 01:30:53.498
<v Mitch Green>And then it's up to us to decide whether or not that is a gap in our line of questioning, and then to contemplate taking the next step to direct.

1003
01:30:53.739 --> 01:31:11.095
<v Mitch Green>I think the way the charter would lay it out, or per city attorney's guidance to me when I was thinking through this, was to then say, okay, if you have a discrete Very specific person that you want to show up who's not gonna accept the invitation, then you would direct the auditor or the mayor to issue a subpoena.

1004
01:31:11.158 --> 01:31:13.149
<v Mitch Green>And at that point, you need to give 'em plenty of time.

1005
01:31:13.244 --> 01:31:14.256
<v Mitch Green>And then we've entered a whole new world.

1006
01:31:14.850 --> 01:31:22.472
<v Mitch Green>So I think in this structure here, I'm not contemplating that we actually compel people who don't wanna show up to show up.

1007
01:31:23.739 --> 01:31:30.431
<v Mitch Green>What I'm thinking in terms of staff is it's an invitation for staff to come up and engage in a line of questioning.

1008
01:31:30.496 --> 01:31:31.925
<v Mitch Green>And I think it's incumbent on us to be—.

1009
01:31:31.925 --> 01:31:32.117
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1010
01:31:32.229 --> 01:31:42.564
<v Mitch Green>Fair and not put them in a situation where there are— we're saying, okay, you're under oath, any false— anything you say is a lie here, because we're not putting them under oath.

1011
01:31:43.221 --> 01:31:51.073
<v Mitch Green>And so in some sense, it's not terribly different than any time that we do talk to them up here in our work sessions or our committee work.

1012
01:31:51.490 --> 01:31:58.429
<v Mitch Green>The only difference is that we're intentionally inviting them based upon information that we would get in the data collection system or process.

1013
01:31:58.493 --> 01:31:58.621
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1014
01:32:04.353 --> 01:32:05.046
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Heidi Brown.

1015
01:32:05.112 --> 01:32:07.354
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on up, City Attorney.

1016
01:32:09.750 --> 01:32:10.828
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, Council.

1017
01:32:10.942 --> 01:32:13.457
<v Unidentified speaker>Council President, Council Vice President, all of you.

1018
01:32:13.524 --> 01:32:21.537
<v Unidentified speaker>Heidi Brown, for the record, she/her pronouns, and I'm with the City Attorney's Office, and I'm acting City Attorney while our City Attorney is out.

1019
01:32:23.954 --> 01:32:26.787
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor, you had a question about who represents the city.

1020
01:32:27.323 --> 01:32:34.114
<v Unidentified speaker>People in this process, you know, so our office represents the city as an organization.

1021
01:32:35.350 --> 01:32:38.595
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we provide advice to the city as an organization.

1022
01:32:38.738 --> 01:32:49.224
<v Unidentified speaker>So if an individual employee wanted to bring an attorney with them, we would need to look at that.

1023
01:32:49.320 --> 01:32:50.653
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, because, so—.

1024
01:32:50.750 --> 01:32:52.082
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1025
01:32:52.515 --> 01:33:02.009
<v Unidentified speaker>You're talking about an employment investigation, not a criminal or civil liability investigation, and we have a right to ask our employees questions.

1026
01:33:04.037 --> 01:33:14.194
<v Unidentified speaker>If they're questions that could— that the employee reasonably believes could lead to discipline, then we give them the right to have a union representative present with them.

1027
01:33:14.715 --> 01:33:24.394
<v Unidentified speaker>Their role, though, is very limited in that we still have a right as an employer to ask So it's not an easy question.

1028
01:33:25.087 --> 01:33:43.762
<v Unidentified speaker>If you wanted to— if you have concerns about conduct by city employees, one option would be to request that the city administrator have the Bureau of Human Resources do an investigation to see if misconduct has occurred.

1029
01:33:44.150 --> 01:33:57.055
<v Unidentified speaker>So for example, we get complaints about We get complaints to the Ombuds Office at times or to the Auditor's Office at times that may be within their purview, but sometimes they're not and they allege misconduct by an employee.

1030
01:33:57.136 --> 01:34:00.021
<v Unidentified speaker>And those investigations get referred over to the Bureau of Human Resources.

1031
01:34:01.394 --> 01:34:12.152
<v Unidentified speaker>So, you know, that is one way to proceed that would kind of fall within our normal process and then also have an investigation occur.

1032
01:34:12.251 --> 01:34:12.564
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1033
01:34:13.766 --> 01:34:21.090
<v Unidentified speaker>In our normal manner, which would allow them to bring their union representative with them rather than at a public setting, which makes it a little more challenging.

1034
01:34:21.671 --> 01:34:28.050
<v Unidentified speaker>And then, you know, you can certainly request that that investigative file be presented to you as part of this investigation.

1035
01:34:28.810 --> 01:34:31.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for that explanation.

1036
01:34:36.399 --> 01:34:46.295
<v Eric Zimmerman>It seems to me that some information that would come out of such a hearing by March 6 could result in an employee disciplinary, uh, investigation.

1037
01:34:48.418 --> 01:34:50.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's concerning for me.

1038
01:34:50.511 --> 01:35:04.729
<v Eric Zimmerman>That the— I will also say that before I get into other statements, the timelines I do think are quite aggressive for a reasonable amount of time to pull data and, and get— I mean, I certainly would not appear without representation in front of this body based on the way that this is going.

1039
01:35:04.778 --> 01:35:14.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I— this is why I'm asking my questions about this, because From what I understand in our discussions with Ruth, a number of her employees are unionized employees.

1040
01:35:14.865 --> 01:35:21.179
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if I was a union rep, I'd die on that dais before I came and let my employee come in without representation.

1041
01:35:21.307 --> 01:35:24.112
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I would be very concerned about that.

1042
01:35:24.176 --> 01:35:42.018
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so given that, I do think the timeline is worth discussion if this goes forward, because I think that the timeline as it stands doesn't look like a timeline that would get Any participation, because if you're up against a bad timeline, you choose just not to go, to make the point.

1043
01:35:42.099 --> 01:35:46.969
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so this is where I think representation is probably going to come into part of this if this goes forward.

1044
01:35:47.016 --> 01:35:56.983
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so, um, and I, and I certainly believe that if this goes forward, it will result in some decision-making about employee conduct.

1045
01:35:57.779 --> 01:36:02.755
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, investigations from what comes out of that table.

1046
01:36:03.027 --> 01:36:05.050
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you, Heidi, for that.

1047
01:36:05.177 --> 01:36:11.484
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it is— there's a lot of gray area here and some real unknowns that, um, I'm going to keep listening.

1048
01:36:11.533 --> 01:36:12.657
<v Eric Zimmerman>That gives me a lot of pause here.

1049
01:36:13.266 --> 01:36:15.819
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1050
01:36:16.332 --> 01:36:18.836
<v Unidentified speaker>Are there any other questions for me right now, or I can step away?

1051
01:36:18.884 --> 01:36:19.172
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here.

1052
01:36:20.264 --> 01:36:20.905
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thank you.

1053
01:36:21.146 --> 01:36:21.547
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1054
01:36:22.094 --> 01:36:24.564
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, Councilor Smith?

1055
01:36:25.158 --> 01:36:35.220
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, I just want to clarify, will we be able to have our own questions at this Yeah, just let me, let me walk through the process again.

1056
01:36:35.416 --> 01:36:35.529
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1057
01:36:35.610 --> 01:37:00.304
<v Mitch Green>So if we pass this today, the directive to the city administrator will be in the span of about 2 weeks, which is the time it takes for any public rec— that's the timeline on most public records requests anyway, to go through and gather all the responsive data, the records that are inside of our city and supply that to Council Ops and, and us directly, simultaneously, by the way.

1058
01:37:01.027 --> 01:37:07.192
<v Mitch Green>Um, and then we will review the full gamut of information that has been collected by February 27th.

1059
01:37:08.251 --> 01:37:13.661
<v Mitch Green>And then from there, we draft our own questions that we are prepared to show up on March 6th with.

1060
01:37:14.752 --> 01:37:30.895
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, when we do that work, it's going to be really important that we keep in mind that we're, we're not asking anyone to place them We're not placing anyone under oath, and so the questions need to be really, uh, pre-decisional, non-judgmental, just sort of like, help me understand what I have found in this record.

1061
01:37:30.975 --> 01:37:31.988
<v Mitch Green>That, that's how I'm thinking about it.

1062
01:37:32.759 --> 01:37:52.498
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, and since we found out about this latest money, shouldn't we be adding an amendment to also find out how this latest money was not given to us as well, even though Ruth When she found out about it, she immediately told Council President.

1063
01:37:53.076 --> 01:38:02.992
<v Loretta Smith>But it appears to me that this other money has been sitting there for multiple years too, and we didn't find out about it in the last 3 years.

1064
01:38:03.280 --> 01:38:06.954
<v Loretta Smith>So we should also have that conversation too.

1065
01:38:07.019 --> 01:38:11.896
<v Loretta Smith>How did this money— it's the same department and it goes into the same investment trust fund.

1066
01:38:12.490 --> 01:38:16.277
<v Mitch Green>I, I would say that that's probably something we should debate in the substantive part of this.

1067
01:38:17.051 --> 01:38:26.936
<v Mitch Green>There's a reason why I'm limiting it to the '21, but I would love to get in that argument with you, or not argument, but that discussion with you, because there's good reasons why I've chosen that.

1068
01:38:27.064 --> 01:38:28.287
<v Mitch Green>It's not really technical, though.

1069
01:38:28.896 --> 01:38:35.341
<v Mitch Green>I think that if we can understand what happened in that period of time, we probably have most of our questions answered for this new money, frankly.

1070
01:38:35.470 --> 01:38:36.023
<v Loretta Smith>Not necessarily.

1071
01:38:36.070 --> 01:38:37.958
<v Loretta Smith>It's a different pot of money, but there are two there.

1072
01:38:38.121 --> 01:38:45.043
<v Loretta Smith>So that we're clear technically, and Maybe one of the, the CFO or the, or the DCA can answer this.

1073
01:38:46.055 --> 01:38:50.224
<v Loretta Smith>Which pots of money go into the investment housing fund?

1074
01:38:51.618 --> 01:38:54.649
<v Loretta Smith>Isn't it just the rental assistance and the—.

1075
01:38:55.997 --> 01:38:59.797
<v Mitch Green>We're going to get, we're going to get a memo, I think, tomorrow that's going to explain a lot of that.

1076
01:38:59.862 --> 01:39:00.359
<v Mitch Green>But I think—.

1077
01:39:00.728 --> 01:39:08.569
<v Loretta Smith>But we need to know this now before we ask the question, because that, that leads me to another question, why we're not asking about this new $15 million in addition.

1078
01:39:09.015 --> 01:39:13.957
<v Loretta Smith>Because it's been sitting there too, and it's from the same department.

1079
01:39:14.006 --> 01:39:23.318
<v Loretta Smith>So it's the same directive or non-directive that was given not to expose those dollars to the council.

1080
01:39:24.490 --> 01:39:34.207
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Wright, what I'm really trying to avoid in this is leading this line of questioning by concluding that there's been wrongdoing.

1081
01:39:34.420 --> 01:39:34.532
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1082
01:39:35.076 --> 01:39:43.185
<v Mitch Green>What I'm really trying to do is say, here are 4 specific questions that will help us gather some information that we can review in an impartial way.

1083
01:39:43.664 --> 01:39:50.684
<v Mitch Green>So that way, when we go into an oversight hearing, we know what kind of questions to ask to close the books on a very specific period of history.

1084
01:39:51.180 --> 01:39:51.533
<v Mitch Green>I understand.

1085
01:39:51.677 --> 01:39:57.895
<v Mitch Green>I mean, I also think that the context of the new money is very relevant to why we need to have this discussion and set these norms.

1086
01:39:58.328 --> 01:39:58.520
<v Mitch Green>But I'm—.

1087
01:39:58.568 --> 01:39:59.337
<v Loretta Smith>There's a pattern.

1088
01:39:59.592 --> 01:40:06.064
<v Mitch Green>But I'm really worried that We're going to muddle the scope of this by trying to add in stuff that we haven't even let—.

1089
01:40:06.194 --> 01:40:08.250
<v Loretta Smith>So, okay, I'll keep it to the 21.

1090
01:40:08.539 --> 01:40:14.436
<v Loretta Smith>You need to tell me how many— what monies go into this housing investment fund for the first 21?

1091
01:40:15.256 --> 01:40:17.810
<v Loretta Smith>What, what are the 2 pots of money that we're going to be discussing?

1092
01:40:17.988 --> 01:40:22.229
<v Mitch Green>We, we are going to get a memo tomorrow from the city administrator that explains.

1093
01:40:22.341 --> 01:40:24.703
<v Loretta Smith>Shouldn't you have had that before you put this resolution out?

1094
01:40:24.752 --> 01:40:28.061
<v Mitch Green>I put this resolution out before we learned about 15 new more million dollars.

1095
01:40:28.126 --> 01:40:29.698
<v Loretta Smith>But we're not adding it, so it doesn't matter.

1096
01:40:30.358 --> 01:40:32.493
<v Loretta Smith>So you should know what pots go in.

1097
01:40:32.622 --> 01:40:34.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we're getting into substance, not technical.

1098
01:40:35.109 --> 01:40:40.440
<v Loretta Smith>It is technical because I need to technically know which pots of money are we talking about before I vote on it.

1099
01:40:41.596 --> 01:40:48.998
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, this is about us understanding what conversations happen in the city, what decision-making look like in the city.

1100
01:40:49.159 --> 01:40:56.988
<v Mitch Green>It's not about balances of funds necessarily so much as it is about understanding why we were not disclosed a certain amount of information during a period of time.

1101
01:40:57.036 --> 01:40:58.109
<v Mitch Green>So, so I'm not getting—.

1102
01:40:58.141 --> 01:41:00.996
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Green, if it's not about balance of the money, why are we having this?

1103
01:41:01.347 --> 01:41:01.845
<v Loretta Smith>Why are we talking about this?

1104
01:41:01.908 --> 01:41:04.121
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a debate at this point, not clarification.

1105
01:41:04.457 --> 01:41:05.612
<v Loretta Smith>It's clarification to me.

1106
01:41:05.740 --> 01:41:06.702
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is a back and forth.

1107
01:41:07.198 --> 01:41:07.456
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1108
01:41:07.904 --> 01:41:11.302
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, there is a question, so I'm asking we hold the debate to the end.

1109
01:41:11.671 --> 01:41:18.917
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have folks who are signed up to testify, and I have a couple other voices for technical clarification, and then we will move forward to public testimony.

1110
01:41:19.301 --> 01:41:20.055
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Maria.

1111
01:41:21.225 --> 01:41:22.877
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1112
01:41:23.390 --> 01:41:34.707
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, I just want to clarify from some of the questions and comments that we've received, you know, I think that there is the impression that if we do an oversight hearing, then we will find wrongdoing, and that's not true.

1113
01:41:34.851 --> 01:41:43.043
<v Angelita Morillo>The whole point of an investigation and discussion is so that we can get to the bottom of this without any presuppositions of what the outcomes might be.

1114
01:41:44.454 --> 01:41:48.413
<v Angelita Morillo>The administrative side does not seem to think that this timeline is too aggressive.

1115
01:41:48.478 --> 01:41:49.984
<v Angelita Morillo>That is only coming from this legislative body.

1116
01:41:50.859 --> 01:42:02.409
<v Angelita Morillo>If we have around $40 million in the city of Portland that's going missing while we're telling people we're going to cut beloved services, we should be getting to the bottom of this.

1117
01:42:02.409 --> 01:42:06.300
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's a dereliction of duty for us not to do that as a council body.

1118
01:42:06.449 --> 01:42:13.090
<v Angelita Morillo>And I bet if we did that through a committee, that people would then complain that they didn't get to hear it and have a discussion on it together.

1119
01:42:13.449 --> 01:42:15.359
<v Angelita Morillo>So I really want us to get into the testimony.

1120
01:42:15.670 --> 01:42:16.449
<v Loretta Smith>I do think that we need to get to the bottom of this.

1121
01:42:16.449 --> 01:42:16.489
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Smith.

1122
01:42:20.199 --> 01:42:30.092
<v Angelita Morillo>Again, this, this might just be a simple result of us having turnover at high leadership in the bureau over and over again and not passing on that information, and that's why the dollars went missing.

1123
01:42:30.204 --> 01:42:37.372
<v Angelita Morillo>It could be something as innocent as that, but that still means that there's an issue with our systems and how we track funding that needs to be addressed.

1124
01:42:37.693 --> 01:42:43.945
<v Angelita Morillo>So that is what I am hoping this will uncover so that we can rectify our systems moving forward, and I just wanted to make that very clear.

1125
01:42:44.010 --> 01:42:44.538
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Loretta Smith.

1126
01:42:45.442 --> 01:42:50.752
<v Jamie Dunphy>And again, I will remind my colleagues, we are in technical clarifying question time.

1127
01:42:50.832 --> 01:42:52.248
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will get to debate in a few minutes.

1128
01:42:53.060 --> 01:42:53.984
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1129
01:42:54.664 --> 01:42:57.891
<v Sameer Kanal>Move to limit debate on the technical questions to the current queue.

1130
01:43:00.439 --> 01:43:03.095
<v Sameer Kanal>So everybody in the queue with their hand up would still be able to ask their questions.

1131
01:43:03.193 --> 01:43:03.627
<v Dan Ryan>Great.

1132
01:43:03.853 --> 01:43:04.561
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1133
01:43:06.349 --> 01:43:07.524
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1134
01:43:08.119 --> 01:43:11.304
<v Eric Zimmerman>My technical question about how will the city attorney train us on how to—.

1135
01:43:11.304 --> 01:43:12.311
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, Councilor Zimmerman.

1136
01:43:12.729 --> 01:43:13.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Point of order.

1137
01:43:13.846 --> 01:43:15.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a motion on the table.

1138
01:43:15.320 --> 01:43:17.619
<v Eric Zimmerman>My bad.

1139
01:43:18.462 --> 01:43:22.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>We have to vote for— okay, whatever you want, Alana.

1140
01:43:22.503 --> 01:43:28.876
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I, I— if the person who made the motion wants to remove it since there's only one person in the queue, I'm fine with that, Councilor.

1141
01:43:29.020 --> 01:43:33.021
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we have a motion on the table and I want to make sure that we close that.

1142
01:43:33.377 --> 01:43:38.038
<v Sameer Kanal>And just to be clear, either way, Councilor Zimmerman would still be able to speak at anyone else whose hand is up now.

1143
01:43:38.639 --> 01:43:41.743
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, vote on the motion.

1144
01:43:42.890 --> 01:43:53.837
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, so, um, just to clarify, Councilor Kanal made the motion to limit debate to those in the queue, and I think Councilor Novick seconded.

1145
01:43:54.047 --> 01:43:54.305
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

1146
01:43:54.451 --> 01:43:54.869
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1147
01:43:56.146 --> 01:44:01.141
<v Keelan McClymont>All right, we'll call the roll on this motion.

1148
01:44:02.046 --> 01:44:02.354
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1149
01:44:02.613 --> 01:44:02.693
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1150
01:44:03.453 --> 01:44:03.809
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1151
01:44:05.523 --> 01:44:05.572
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1152
01:44:06.569 --> 01:44:07.019
<v Keelan McClymont>Bertel-Guiney.

1153
01:44:08.000 --> 01:44:08.256
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

1154
01:44:11.698 --> 01:44:12.005
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

1155
01:44:15.074 --> 01:44:15.252
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1156
01:44:17.565 --> 01:44:17.613
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1157
01:44:18.529 --> 01:44:18.658
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1158
01:44:20.297 --> 01:44:20.377
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1159
01:44:21.421 --> 01:44:21.470
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1160
01:44:22.130 --> 01:44:25.725
<v Keelan McClymont>The motion carries with 11 yes votes and 1 no vote.

1161
01:44:26.453 --> 01:44:27.570
<v Eric Zimmerman>Glad we could do that.

1162
01:44:27.814 --> 01:44:36.283
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I still didn't have my technical question answered about how the City Attorney intends to train the City Council to conduct such an inquiry.

1163
01:44:36.862 --> 01:44:38.854
<v Eric Zimmerman>We've been trained for a lot of our different roles.

1164
01:44:38.949 --> 01:44:39.497
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is new.

1165
01:44:39.689 --> 01:44:47.791
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what is the training plan to ensure that we stick to questions that would be appropriate for whatever this is about to turn into?

1166
01:44:48.243 --> 01:44:49.882
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can you lay out that training plan?

1167
01:44:51.520 --> 01:45:05.411
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, Councilor, since this is the first time it's come up, then I don't know that we have a plan, but what I could tell you That I can just think of would be, I do think that having people trained in investigations is helpful to have.

1168
01:45:05.458 --> 01:45:14.944
<v Unidentified speaker>So one option, maybe council wants to hire an outside investigator to perform the investigation for you and then bring forward a report from which you could then gather information.

1169
01:45:15.635 --> 01:45:21.060
<v Unidentified speaker>As the auditor's office does also, as I said earlier, they do investigations.

1170
01:45:21.797 --> 01:45:23.787
<v Unidentified speaker>And then HR, of course, does investigations.

1171
01:45:23.851 --> 01:45:24.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1172
01:45:24.988 --> 01:45:33.832
<v Unidentified speaker>But the, you know, the first option would be hiring an outside investigator, and that might be more appealing to all of you because, because that's somebody who's trained in that.

1173
01:45:35.462 --> 01:45:56.087
<v Unidentified speaker>Getting you all trained in that, you know, would, would take work, of course, because investigators, you know, and it depends on how much training you want, et cetera, to be able to assess whether or not there was some, whether or not this occurred, whether somebody engaged in any wrongdoing.

1174
01:45:56.150 --> 01:45:58.444
<v Unidentified speaker>And it really depends on what questions you're asking.

1175
01:45:58.555 --> 01:46:02.051
<v Unidentified speaker>And I did see the questions and I don't have 'em in the top of my head right this second.

1176
01:46:02.403 --> 01:46:13.512
<v Unidentified speaker>But I think some of the questions that I'm hearing today that you're concerned about would be helpful to have somebody who, you know, has some extensive training and is experienced in performing investigations.

1177
01:46:13.560 --> 01:46:19.511
<v Eric Zimmerman>I asked that question 'cause I assume there are some questions that are Permissible and some that would not be.

1178
01:46:20.057 --> 01:46:33.582
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's similar if we're ever on a hiring panel, we usually get a brief about like how you conduct that panel, what's an appropriate line of questions, et cetera, so that we are conducting that duty appropriately.

1179
01:46:34.271 --> 01:46:43.501
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so in a world where there are no parameters on the 12 councilors who are questioning, that's why I'm asking that.

1180
01:46:43.550 --> 01:46:46.262
<v Eric Zimmerman>It seems like there would need to be some sort of training about what that looks like.

1181
01:46:46.328 --> 01:46:46.457
<v Jonas Biery>Sure.

1182
01:46:47.175 --> 01:46:49.962
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would certainly want it before I participated in such a thing.

1183
01:46:50.398 --> 01:46:52.105
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's a good question, Councilor.

1184
01:46:52.154 --> 01:46:54.055
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for clarifying what you were asking.

1185
01:46:54.104 --> 01:46:58.110
<v Unidentified speaker>I didn't understand that part of it, and that's a good point.

1186
01:46:59.550 --> 01:47:29.750
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, for an employer investigation, and you're acting as a legislative body investigation, you're looking into this, there's the parameters are really around If you were to ask questions that were completely outside of the investigation, for example, if you're doing an investigation into this and you ask somebody whether they have a driver's license and they're driving off duty without one, that really has nothing to do with this.

1187
01:47:30.615 --> 01:47:35.091
<v Unidentified speaker>If you ask somebody about their private life, for example, that really doesn't have anything to do with this.

1188
01:47:36.266 --> 01:47:39.905
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, their marital status or things like that, they really don't have anything to do with this.

1189
01:47:40.242 --> 01:47:47.021
<v Unidentified speaker>That would be going beyond the scope that could be viewed as an unreasonable invasion of their privacy.

1190
01:47:48.240 --> 01:48:06.338
<v Unidentified speaker>But to the extent you're staying within the scope of what this is about and related to determining what happened with the funds, what's the practice been at the bureau, how the funds are reported, that is within the scope of, you know, your job as a legislative body and the city's job as a city.

1191
01:48:06.563 --> 01:48:06.707
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1192
01:48:06.819 --> 01:48:12.663
<v Unidentified speaker>City executive branch and administrative branch's job to have that oversight.

1193
01:48:13.177 --> 01:48:15.296
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, and then, so no training plan has been established.

1194
01:48:15.362 --> 01:48:23.646
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then I wanna make sure that I understood some of your opening comments, Councilor, that you said there have been no procedures for what this hearing would look like that have been established.

1195
01:48:23.694 --> 01:48:26.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>So we've gotta establish procedural, like how do we just go through the motions?

1196
01:48:26.987 --> 01:48:29.105
<v Eric Zimmerman>Like how does the Council President conduct such a hearing?

1197
01:48:29.652 --> 01:48:31.096
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is still to be determined.

1198
01:48:32.140 --> 01:48:32.284
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1199
01:48:32.944 --> 01:48:39.960
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I mean, I think what I'm contemplating in the resolution is whether or not this body thinks it's appropriate to step into that more formal space.

1200
01:48:40.971 --> 01:48:57.381
<v Mitch Green>I think it leaves a lot to the city— I'm sorry, the council president as the presiding officer to determine what, you know, what the rules of decorum are and how we would conduct ourselves, how to sort of limit our councilors in terms of their questioning.

1201
01:48:57.430 --> 01:49:06.975
<v Mitch Green>And so We can have that conversation, but, um, until, until I know whether this body is willing to even go into that space, um, that seems like an unnecessary level of detail.

1202
01:49:07.073 --> 01:49:14.288
<v Unidentified speaker>And of course, our office is happy to work with Council President or any of you on, on, uh, what this could look like.

1203
01:49:16.043 --> 01:49:16.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perfect.

1204
01:49:16.527 --> 01:49:21.065
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, uh, colleagues, it is 11:15.

1205
01:49:21.114 --> 01:49:22.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have folks signed up to testify.

1206
01:49:22.966 --> 01:49:24.721
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm wondering if folks want to take a very quick Yes.

1207
01:49:25.122 --> 01:49:25.621
<v Dan Ryan>Bio break?

1208
01:49:25.926 --> 01:49:26.103
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

1209
01:49:26.391 --> 01:49:31.835
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, um, we're gonna take a 10-minute recess and we'll be back at 11:25.

1210
01:49:32.188 --> 01:49:33.087
<v Dan Ryan>Everybody go pee.

1211
02:00:52.034 --> 02:00:54.164
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are back.

1212
02:00:54.393 --> 02:00:56.377
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for your patience.

1213
02:00:56.766 --> 02:00:58.198
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call up public testimony?

1214
02:01:00.868 --> 02:01:10.551
<v Keelan McClymont>All right, first up We have Terry Harris, followed by Benjamin Gilbert and Hugo Flores.

1215
02:01:12.359 --> 02:01:12.764
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Terry.

1216
02:01:14.724 --> 02:01:15.567
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, thank you all.

1217
02:01:15.792 --> 02:01:17.056
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for this opportunity.

1218
02:01:17.266 --> 02:01:19.001
<v Unidentified speaker>Appreciate it as always.

1219
02:01:19.583 --> 02:01:20.942
<v Unidentified speaker>Terry Harris, for the record.

1220
02:01:21.682 --> 02:01:27.628
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I'm gonna try and be pretty quick, um, but I have a lot to say here.

1221
02:01:29.648 --> 02:01:58.466
<v Unidentified speaker>The Governance Committee has heard me a little bit, and based on the conversation that, that y'all just had, I kind of want to go back to Councilor Green's spectrum of oversight and just point out that if you were doing investigative stuff and require lawyers and, uh, that level of thing That's not what this resolution should be about.

1222
02:02:00.140 --> 02:02:05.875
<v Unidentified speaker>This— and let me just say that this resolution as a way to do oversight is the right way to do it.

1223
02:02:07.351 --> 02:02:09.881
<v Unidentified speaker>It is a common practice elsewhere.

1224
02:02:10.479 --> 02:02:12.542
<v Unidentified speaker>And I know Councilor Green mentioned Baltimore.

1225
02:02:13.760 --> 02:02:15.131
<v Unidentified speaker>This is exactly how it's done.

1226
02:02:15.713 --> 02:02:19.896
<v Unidentified speaker>You give notice and a time to respond.

1227
02:02:19.961 --> 02:02:20.090
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1228
02:02:20.984 --> 02:02:22.573
<v Unidentified speaker>It's scoped in advance.

1229
02:02:23.551 --> 02:02:33.023
<v Unidentified speaker>You focus on documents and, um, delivering the materials to the council, and then there's a public hearing to air it all out.

1230
02:02:33.746 --> 02:02:36.329
<v Unidentified speaker>That's, that's where you are right now.

1231
02:02:36.635 --> 02:02:38.047
<v Unidentified speaker>You're not doing an investigation.

1232
02:02:38.962 --> 02:02:41.050
<v Unidentified speaker>Nobody should be worried for their job.

1233
02:02:41.756 --> 02:02:45.543
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, this is not where you need to be right now.

1234
02:02:46.331 --> 02:02:56.819
<v Unidentified speaker>You do want, as Councilor Kanal says the space to do further investigation and things that should come out of it.

1235
02:02:57.172 --> 02:03:10.110
<v Unidentified speaker>For example, I think you might find that the Housing Investment Fund needs an investigation as to what that's for, what goes in it, what comes out of it, who manages it.

1236
02:03:10.673 --> 02:03:14.451
<v Unidentified speaker>But that's a whole separate thing from what this hearing should be.

1237
02:03:15.849 --> 02:03:28.645
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, finally, I'll say that what— at this level, you should be considering if this were a rule of council, a council rule, what would that rule look like?

1238
02:03:29.335 --> 02:03:32.208
<v Unidentified speaker>And that rule would look kind of like this resolution.

1239
02:03:32.787 --> 02:03:37.538
<v Unidentified speaker>So I support the resolution, and, um, I encourage you all to pass it.

1240
02:03:38.244 --> 02:04:00.435
<v Unidentified speaker>And finally, I think moving Beyond this resolution, the first thing that happens is it's a collaboration with the city attorney, with the city administrator, the council president's office, and the sponsor to manage that hearing and the information that goes into it and the scoping of that hearing.

1241
02:04:01.171 --> 02:04:05.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, this is for you all, of course, to learn, but it's also for the public.

1242
02:04:05.740 --> 02:04:06.975
<v Unidentified speaker>It's for the public trust.

1243
02:04:07.038 --> 02:04:08.048
<v Unidentified speaker>It's for accountability.

1244
02:04:08.500 --> 02:04:16.417
<v Unidentified speaker>It's for transparency, it's for rumor control, and ultimately, hopefully, a process improvement.

1245
02:04:16.984 --> 02:04:23.768
<v Unidentified speaker>So I encourage you all to pass this kind of as is and roll with it collaboratively.

1246
02:04:25.451 --> 02:04:25.823
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1247
02:04:26.275 --> 02:04:26.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1248
02:04:27.552 --> 02:04:27.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Ben.

1249
02:04:30.704 --> 02:04:32.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello, my name is Ben Gilbert.

1250
02:04:32.822 --> 02:04:34.583
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm a volunteer lobbyist with the Portland DSA.

1251
02:04:35.167 --> 02:04:39.539
<v Mitch Green>I support this because it has been concerning seeing unbudgeted money pop up.

1252
02:04:40.412 --> 02:04:46.555
<v Mitch Green>Transparency is important, especially as we face a strained budget where there are so many needs and not enough funds.

1253
02:04:47.079 --> 02:04:47.390
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1254
02:04:47.471 --> 02:04:47.945
<v David Pearl>Yield my time.

1255
02:04:49.789 --> 02:04:50.082
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1256
02:04:51.673 --> 02:05:01.261
<v Keelan McClymont>Hugo Flores, Mark Jackson, and Christopher Olson.

1257
02:05:17.047 --> 02:05:19.432
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome, Council President and members of the council.

1258
02:05:19.514 --> 02:05:31.359
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Pastor Mark Jackson, representing the board membership of Oasis of Praise in District 3 and also the Coalition of African and African-American Pastors spread abroad, the Portland metro area.

1259
02:05:31.969 --> 02:05:36.471
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, as I sit and listen, I want to go into prayer, if I'd be honest.

1260
02:05:37.096 --> 02:05:50.332
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, but, um, I just want to underscore the importance of really establishing and strengthening public trust, um, in you all's leadership and decision-making in this present time on this agenda.

1261
02:05:50.957 --> 02:06:04.814
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, the community needs to trust its decision-makers, its bureaus, I would also underscore the importance of administering an all-bureau audit because these are taxpayer dollars.

1262
02:06:05.328 --> 02:06:09.837
<v Unidentified speaker>We're talking about while we are trying to grapple with a housing crisis.

1263
02:06:10.608 --> 02:06:22.707
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to underscore the importance as these 2 organizations I represent today, we have administered millions of dollars with city contracts with the Bureau of Housing and also with DAS at the state level.

1264
02:06:22.756 --> 02:06:26.302
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're not a novice to the crises and how to administer resources.

1265
02:06:26.350 --> 02:06:26.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1266
02:06:27.055 --> 02:06:50.623
<v Unidentified speaker>So as this council reimagines how to disburse these funds, our hope is that there will be some real clear direction to the Housing Bureau to really look at faith-based organizations and houses of worship who often don't get contracts but do tremendous work in the community, specifically Oasis of Praise in District 3, in a service desert.

1267
02:06:51.185 --> 02:06:56.506
<v Unidentified speaker>We've been trying to secure $2 million to acquire our property and to renovate.

1268
02:06:56.811 --> 02:07:11.212
<v Unidentified speaker>To continue doing what we've done for the past 27 years, including providing housing services from warming centers to temporary housing of those who are unsheltered, to ensure we continue to underscore safe communities.

1269
02:07:11.742 --> 02:07:19.551
<v Unidentified speaker>So this is a seminal moment for our city, and the mantle of leadership and humility and grace is upon each of you all.

1270
02:07:19.984 --> 02:07:28.628
<v Unidentified speaker>And I hope as a community You all be thoughtful and keep this process humanized and not just technical.

1271
02:07:28.710 --> 02:07:29.587
<v Unidentified speaker>We're talking about lives.

1272
02:07:30.300 --> 02:07:30.895
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1273
02:07:31.297 --> 02:07:32.087
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

1274
02:07:33.474 --> 02:07:35.375
<v Keelan McClymont>Christopher Olson is joining us online.

1275
02:07:37.300 --> 02:07:40.037
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, hi, good morning, councilors, uh, Council President Dunphy.

1276
02:07:40.795 --> 02:07:49.273
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, just for the record, my name is Chris Olson and I live in District 2, and I'm a member of the Portland Democratic Socialists of America Housing Working Group, and I'm a tenant advocate.

1277
02:07:49.449 --> 02:07:55.712
<v Unidentified speaker>But today I'll be speaking just for myself as one of the many, many of Portland's frustrated renters.

1278
02:07:56.529 --> 02:08:02.181
<v Unidentified speaker>First, I want to say I fully support this resolution and investigation into the Housing Bureau.

1279
02:08:02.551 --> 02:08:17.064
<v Unidentified speaker>We need answers to the burning question as to why that during a housing crisis declared by the city over 10 years ago that this bureau has sat on the people's money and allowed thousands to be evicted from our streets or failed to provide provide or build any more affordable housing.

1280
02:08:17.963 --> 02:08:25.873
<v Unidentified speaker>At best, this is a broken system in need of repair, and at worst, it's a deliberate sabotage of public sector efforts to ease the burden of housing costs.

1281
02:08:26.627 --> 02:08:36.015
<v Unidentified speaker>$35 Million or more at this point is not a small sum of money, especially when we are told in a budget crisis where jobs will be lost and programs will be cut.

1282
02:08:36.577 --> 02:08:45.817
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to say I want the City Council not to just merely investigate this matter, but there needs to be a full audit of all the city's finances by 3rd party, I think, before the end of this year.

1283
02:08:46.377 --> 02:08:52.407
<v Unidentified speaker>If any other bureaus have mismanaged funds as poorly as the Housing Bureau, an audit should pay for itself many times over.

1284
02:08:53.096 --> 02:09:02.829
<v Unidentified speaker>Every nickel and dime needs to be accounted for, or the taxpayers will lose trust in our new form of government, even though this is likely the result of the previous government.

1285
02:09:03.439 --> 02:09:07.528
<v Unidentified speaker>Please audit the city's finances and make sure our citizens can trust their government with their money.

1286
02:09:08.265 --> 02:09:11.118
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll end with this, with some of the technical questions that I heard.

1287
02:09:11.551 --> 02:09:17.529
<v Unidentified speaker>It sounded like to me some of the council has been fishing for— or councilors are fishing for excuses not to hold this oversight hearing.

1288
02:09:18.202 --> 02:09:23.377
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sorry, but this is what you were elected to do and what you signed up for, and so please do your jobs.

1289
02:09:23.569 --> 02:09:24.530
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll yield the rest of my time.

1290
02:09:24.756 --> 02:09:25.028
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1291
02:09:26.118 --> 02:09:26.823
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1292
02:09:27.815 --> 02:09:29.065
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

1293
02:09:29.755 --> 02:09:32.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Councilor Green.

1294
02:09:33.488 --> 02:09:34.305
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

1295
02:09:34.386 --> 02:09:47.878
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd just like to formally move Green 1, which just amends those dates We have a motion and a second on the amendment to update the language of the amendment with dates.

1296
02:09:48.845 --> 02:09:50.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>Any discussion?

1297
02:09:52.613 --> 02:09:53.274
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knol.

1298
02:09:53.740 --> 02:09:57.475
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I just wanted to get a little more clarity on why exactly 2 weeks.

1299
02:09:57.524 --> 02:10:01.238
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's, it's a fair question to ask how long it would take.

1300
02:10:01.625 --> 02:10:03.443
<v Sameer Kanal>We were discussing this in December.

1301
02:10:03.550 --> 02:10:07.371
<v Sameer Kanal>December, there was a little bit longer of a lag than what's being added here.

1302
02:10:07.853 --> 02:10:12.911
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just was curious why 2 weeks, why not 1, why not 3, if you could just speak to that a little bit.

1303
02:10:13.055 --> 02:10:23.587
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, just, I think the way that we started with this was like, if you're a member of the public and you do a public records request, there's 2 weeks to fulfill that requirement.

1304
02:10:24.054 --> 02:10:45.123
<v Mitch Green>And so I think in this regard, if we adopt this today, that's about 2 weeks For the city administrator to gather those records as if it were a public records request, and then 1 week to take those records and put them on 1 SharePoint site in council operations, and for us to consider.

1305
02:10:46.216 --> 02:10:55.243
<v Mitch Green>I didn't— I wanted to balance this between, you know, being responsive to the moment we're in because we do have a huge public trust risk out there right now.

1306
02:10:56.716 --> 02:10:59.539
<v Mitch Green>And also providing a meaningful amount of actionable time.

1307
02:11:01.314 --> 02:11:01.943
<v Raymond C. Lee>Great, thanks.

1308
02:11:02.587 --> 02:11:03.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1309
02:11:04.201 --> 02:11:04.668
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1310
02:11:05.250 --> 02:11:05.572
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1311
02:11:05.685 --> 02:11:14.141
<v Loretta Smith>So will this data be shared with the public via Council Ops before we actually do the, do the hearing?

1312
02:11:17.395 --> 02:11:31.271
<v Mitch Green>I, I don't think that it's directed in the resolution that Council Ops makes this a public-facing Um, when we have the hearing, all this will become public as we talk about this, uh, publicly.

1313
02:11:32.414 --> 02:11:41.127
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, can we please call the roll on the amendment?

1314
02:11:41.273 --> 02:11:41.643
<v Jamie Dunphy>Green 1.

1315
02:11:42.801 --> 02:11:42.817
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1316
02:11:43.429 --> 02:11:43.476
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1317
02:11:45.761 --> 02:11:46.002
<v David Pearl>No.

1318
02:11:46.422 --> 02:11:46.574
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1319
02:11:47.166 --> 02:11:47.335
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1320
02:11:50.835 --> 02:11:50.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1321
02:11:51.471 --> 02:11:51.652
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1322
02:11:52.536 --> 02:11:52.551
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1323
02:11:53.680 --> 02:11:53.729
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1324
02:11:54.416 --> 02:11:54.530
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1325
02:11:54.824 --> 02:11:54.873
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1326
02:11:55.395 --> 02:11:55.412
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1327
02:11:55.881 --> 02:11:55.913
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1328
02:11:57.497 --> 02:12:03.024
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 12 yes votes.

1329
02:12:04.300 --> 02:12:04.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

1330
02:12:04.882 --> 02:12:10.052
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, uh, we are now in open discussion of the underlying now amended resolution.

1331
02:12:11.140 --> 02:12:12.771
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith, is that a legacy hand?

1332
02:12:13.376 --> 02:12:14.323
<v Jamie Dunphy>Apologies.

1333
02:12:14.421 --> 02:12:15.073
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal?

1334
02:12:15.420 --> 02:12:19.432
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I had a question that actually was technical and I forgot to ask it earlier.

1335
02:12:19.725 --> 02:12:34.615
<v Sameer Kanal>In the very last, therefore be it resolved, I just wanted to clarify the legislative intent here of whether or not the intent is for the council president to schedule the hearing by the date or that the council president is to schedule that the hearing will occur by the date.

1336
02:12:35.956 --> 02:12:36.425
<v Jamie Dunphy>Second question.

1337
02:12:40.074 --> 02:12:41.140
<v Mitch Green>I'm glad you caught that.

1338
02:12:41.206 --> 02:12:42.158
<v Mitch Green>I'm not surprised you did.

1339
02:12:44.368 --> 02:12:51.894
<v Mitch Green>I think that my intent when we drafted this was probably to get the meeting to be heard no later than March 6th.

1340
02:12:53.636 --> 02:13:01.730
<v Mitch Green>But if it's— if it pleases the body and if we think it gives us a little more time to be practical, I'm willing to read this with any interpretation.

1341
02:13:01.779 --> 02:13:05.594
<v Mitch Green>Like, if he's like, okay, I've identified a meeting by March 6th, I guess that's fine.

1342
02:13:05.658 --> 02:13:10.636
<v Mitch Green>But I really did want this to be like, We have this hearing by March 6th.

1343
02:13:10.685 --> 02:13:20.375
<v Mitch Green>If that's too much of a time pressure, then just putting that sort of stage gate for the council president to figure out when that goes in is probably fine for me.

1344
02:13:20.519 --> 02:13:24.081
<v Sameer Kanal>For me personally, I'm good with it being held by March 6th.

1345
02:13:24.145 --> 02:13:25.188
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not trying to argue.

1346
02:13:25.412 --> 02:13:26.967
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to be sure that there was clarity.

1347
02:13:27.417 --> 02:13:36.113
<v Sameer Kanal>And if the intent was to schedule it, that the date would be confirmed by March 6th, then if we would need to put I don't think this is going to happen.

1348
02:13:36.161 --> 02:13:36.914
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to be clear on that.

1349
02:13:36.979 --> 02:13:43.733
<v Sameer Kanal>But if on March 5th, the statement is made that by the council president that we're going to have it in December, right?

1350
02:13:43.780 --> 02:13:45.770
<v Sameer Kanal>Like just trying to get some clarity around that.

1351
02:13:45.819 --> 02:13:51.546
<v Sameer Kanal>So if your intention as a sponsor is that it's the date that the thing occurs by, I'm good with that.

1352
02:13:51.802 --> 02:13:54.962
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted that to be clear for interpretation after we adopt it.

1353
02:13:55.011 --> 02:13:56.775
<v Sameer Kanal>And if people want more time, we can adjust the date.

1354
02:13:57.113 --> 02:13:58.252
<v Mitch Green>I mean, that's my intent.

1355
02:13:58.621 --> 02:13:58.716
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1356
02:13:58.957 --> 02:14:00.288
<v Sameer Kanal>That's— thank you for clarifying.

1357
02:14:02.047 --> 02:14:02.854
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

1358
02:14:02.952 --> 02:14:03.596
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark.

1359
02:14:05.128 --> 02:14:06.306
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

1360
02:14:07.630 --> 02:14:16.403
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, I really appreciate the discussion that we've had so far, the reminders of what our responsibilities are as a council.

1361
02:14:16.498 --> 02:14:26.889
<v Olivia Clark>It's been very fruitful, and I have consistently wanted a better definition of oversight, and I think that we still need to tease that out in governance.

1362
02:14:27.637 --> 02:14:35.260
<v Olivia Clark>I think that Councilor Koyama Lane is interested in that as well, and we can use some of the material that you put together to do that.

1363
02:14:35.567 --> 02:14:40.886
<v Olivia Clark>But I think we still have a long way to go on what is governance, how we define it.

1364
02:14:42.890 --> 02:14:53.908
<v Olivia Clark>But colleagues, I also want to say that a lot of the information that we're requesting, the questions that you're asking, we've already reviewed all of this.

1365
02:14:54.122 --> 02:14:59.778
<v Olivia Clark>In an executive session, and, uh, most of it, maybe not all of it, but the bulk of it.

1366
02:15:00.051 --> 02:15:04.597
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm really concerned that it feels, um, punitive to me.

1367
02:15:05.032 --> 02:15:11.636
<v Olivia Clark>I know, despite the assurances of some of my colleagues, um, that they're not concerned with punishment.

1368
02:15:12.118 --> 02:15:21.243
<v Olivia Clark>And believe me, I, you know, I worked for a regulatory agency once where— and you've heard me say I think it's important to hang people high sometimes, but this is not That kind of a situation.

1369
02:15:21.739 --> 02:15:26.970
<v Olivia Clark>And in fact, the administration has already shown a change since that time.

1370
02:15:27.114 --> 02:15:29.136
<v Olivia Clark>They've already course-corrected.

1371
02:15:29.873 --> 02:15:32.264
<v Olivia Clark>So it feels a little punitive to me.

1372
02:15:32.488 --> 02:15:39.692
<v Olivia Clark>And I do believe that, as I said, we need more definition of what oversight is.

1373
02:15:40.430 --> 02:15:44.985
<v Olivia Clark>But we also need to be very sensitive to the fact that we are in a transition.

1374
02:15:45.033 --> 02:15:45.997
<v Olivia Clark>We are still transitioning.

1375
02:15:46.060 --> 02:15:46.157
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1376
02:15:46.270 --> 02:15:46.478
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith.

1377
02:15:46.542 --> 02:15:46.765
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Mayor.

1378
02:15:46.829 --> 02:15:49.795
<v Olivia Clark>I think we're in a transition from an old form of government to a new form of government.

1379
02:15:50.484 --> 02:15:55.051
<v Olivia Clark>And I think what happened was really a legacy of that old form of government.

1380
02:15:55.659 --> 02:16:14.283
<v Olivia Clark>And I guess I don't feel the need to rehash all of that because I also want to create this new culture, a culture where city employees feel comfortable in coming forward with mistakes or coming forward with errors, knowing that There's no fear of punishment.

1381
02:16:14.894 --> 02:16:25.555
<v Olivia Clark>So I don't feel a guarantee here that this isn't a— I don't want to say Spanish Inquisition, but that this isn't punitive.

1382
02:16:25.923 --> 02:16:27.850
<v Olivia Clark>That's my concern here.

1383
02:16:27.914 --> 02:16:31.399
<v Olivia Clark>I'll just leave that for other people to discuss.

1384
02:16:32.490 --> 02:16:43.549
<v Olivia Clark>Certainly willing to hear more about that, but I'm very, very interested in how we define oversight Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1385
02:16:43.710 --> 02:16:44.422
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1386
02:16:45.472 --> 02:16:46.379
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1387
02:16:48.156 --> 02:16:57.119
<v Steve Novick>Um, I understand the impulse for this, and I'm not going to accuse Councilor Green of being a kangaroo or a wombat or a koala or any other Australian animal.

1388
02:16:57.764 --> 02:17:02.450
<v Steve Novick>Um, I— and I expect this to pass.

1389
02:17:02.772 --> 02:17:04.777
<v Steve Novick>Um, that again, I understand the impulse for it.

1390
02:17:05.070 --> 02:17:07.317
<v Steve Novick>But I want to explain why I'm going to vote against it.

1391
02:17:08.040 --> 02:17:10.656
<v Steve Novick>I think this is entirely backward-looking.

1392
02:17:11.010 --> 02:17:20.801
<v Steve Novick>What I want to know is what steps is the administration taking to ensure that we know and they know what money is available in various pots.

1393
02:17:20.962 --> 02:17:29.888
<v Steve Novick>And especially, and I've told DCA Biery this directly, I want them to be shouting from the rooftops why this can't happen with the general fund.

1394
02:17:30.416 --> 02:17:31.412
<v Steve Novick>Because the worst—.

1395
02:17:31.412 --> 02:17:32.520
<v Merrilee Carr>I think that's a good point.

1396
02:17:33.483 --> 02:17:46.167
<v Steve Novick>I mean, my big concern about this is that the public is going to think that we don't really have a deficit in the general fund of tens of billions of dollars, and we don't have to cut police, fire, and parks because there's money in the couch cushions.

1397
02:17:46.632 --> 02:17:51.268
<v Steve Novick>So we need reassurance and explanation as to why that's not going to happen.

1398
02:17:51.379 --> 02:17:58.549
<v Steve Novick>As far as this resolution, however, to me, there's 3 questions I think I already know the answer to.

1399
02:17:59.064 --> 02:18:02.094
<v Steve Novick>And another question which worries me: what happened to the funds?

1400
02:18:02.209 --> 02:18:04.218
<v Steve Novick>What led to them not being spent in previous years?

1401
02:18:04.850 --> 02:18:07.826
<v Steve Novick>Well, the relevant people didn't know they were there, so that's why they weren't spent.

1402
02:18:07.891 --> 02:18:11.194
<v Steve Novick>I'm sure that if people had known they were there— everybody always wants to spend money.

1403
02:18:11.862 --> 02:18:15.219
<v Steve Novick>And the other questions are: what dynamics led to this information not being shared with council?

1404
02:18:15.897 --> 02:18:21.225
<v Steve Novick>To what degree— then the fourth is: what degree were decisions made around these funds and what information was or wasn't shared?

1405
02:18:22.095 --> 02:18:24.354
<v Steve Novick>And I've heard the administration's answer to that too.

1406
02:18:24.468 --> 02:18:25.468
<v Steve Novick>Their answer is that— I'm sorry, I'm sorry.

1407
02:18:26.137 --> 02:18:33.727
<v Steve Novick>They didn't share information with council where they didn't know they could trust the information or they had information in a useful form for us to use.

1408
02:18:34.593 --> 02:18:35.927
<v Steve Novick>I don't think their answer is going to change.

1409
02:18:36.667 --> 02:18:44.872
<v Steve Novick>And I think they got the message from councilors that we want to know stuff as soon as there is anything to know, even if the information isn't particularly reliable.

1410
02:18:45.435 --> 02:18:52.507
<v Steve Novick>And as Councilor Green noted, in this latest incident, the budget director called the council president immediately and said, hey, we found some more money.

1411
02:18:52.587 --> 02:18:52.684
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1412
02:18:53.211 --> 02:18:56.031
<v Steve Novick>So it seems like the message has been received.

1413
02:18:57.361 --> 02:19:07.440
<v Steve Novick>One question which we haven't addressed, heard addressed in detail, I don't think, is who was aware of the funds, at what point in time was each party made aware, and why was it made aware?

1414
02:19:08.032 --> 02:19:11.655
<v Steve Novick>And that, for the old folks here, is the Watergate question.

1415
02:19:12.183 --> 02:19:14.201
<v Steve Novick>What did Helmi Hisarik know and when did she know it?

1416
02:19:14.906 --> 02:19:28.993
<v Steve Novick>And I'm worried about going down that rabbit hole because I think we wind up necessarily talking about personalities And I just don't think that, I mean, if somebody had stolen money, obviously we wanna know who was complicit in the stealing and, you know, have them arrested.

1417
02:19:29.120 --> 02:19:35.543
<v Steve Novick>But in this case, I don't know what the value is of the what did Helmi Hystarik know and when did she know it question.

1418
02:19:35.944 --> 02:19:37.727
<v Steve Novick>So again, I expect this to pass.

1419
02:19:37.791 --> 02:19:39.236
<v Steve Novick>I understand the impulse behind it.

1420
02:19:39.799 --> 02:19:43.155
<v Steve Novick>I will note that I don't see that there's a huge public outcry for this.

1421
02:19:43.251 --> 02:19:45.146
<v Steve Novick>We had 4 people giving public testimony.

1422
02:19:45.257 --> 02:19:46.045
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1423
02:19:50.554 --> 02:19:51.429
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1424
02:19:51.510 --> 02:19:52.238
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

1425
02:19:54.280 --> 02:19:55.155
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1426
02:19:57.381 --> 02:20:02.685
<v Angelita Morillo>We did have an executive session on this matter, and I'll be frank, I'll only speak for myself.

1427
02:20:02.829 --> 02:20:06.916
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't feel satisfied with the information that we received in the executive session.

1428
02:20:07.742 --> 02:20:11.689
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think that this is a matter of public interest and public transportation.

1429
02:20:11.799 --> 02:20:27.173
<v Angelita Morillo>Transparency because Portlanders' tax dollars are being given to us and we are being asked to be responsible with those dollars and to fund the services that people want and to cut many of the beloved services that we no longer have funding for.

1430
02:20:28.567 --> 02:20:49.396
<v Angelita Morillo>Accountability is not a punishment, but we need to know what is going on because it is bonkers to me That we are acting like even if someone under the best intentions, whoopsie-doo, misplaced $40 million, that that is not something the council should look into.

1431
02:20:51.282 --> 02:20:52.665
<v Angelita Morillo>That's bonkers to me.

1432
02:20:53.210 --> 02:20:56.102
<v Angelita Morillo>We need to know exactly how things ended up that way.

1433
02:20:56.488 --> 02:21:02.353
<v Angelita Morillo>Even if under the best intentions and the best circumstances that happened, there is clearly a systems issue here.

1434
02:21:03.798 --> 02:21:21.924
<v Angelita Morillo>And we are also not talking about, you know, we are talking about highly paid, high expertise staff who are choosing to work in government, which means that we are doing work for the people in the public interest.

1435
02:21:22.439 --> 02:21:32.563
<v Angelita Morillo>The requirements for our jobs as people in government is higher than for a job in the private sector because we are serving the public.

1436
02:21:33.653 --> 02:21:35.879
<v Angelita Morillo>And that is not an attack for anybody.

1437
02:21:36.153 --> 02:21:51.183
<v Angelita Morillo>That is just we need to change the culture and the expectation threshold here when we are serving the public, from people who are making $300,000 a year at the city to people who are doing frontline work that goes underappreciated.

1438
02:21:52.561 --> 02:21:58.489
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm also kind of frustrated, frankly, that we are going to slow things down again.

1439
02:21:59.165 --> 02:22:07.626
<v Angelita Morillo>This council body has struggled to put out policy, has struggled to be productive, and we are over a year in office now.

1440
02:22:09.654 --> 02:22:14.301
<v Angelita Morillo>We cannot wait for the Governance Committee to keep going through this process.

1441
02:22:14.800 --> 02:22:22.470
<v Angelita Morillo>We need the council body as a whole to make this decision together because it's a process that we're going to be doing for a long time.

1442
02:22:23.288 --> 02:22:28.182
<v Angelita Morillo>And the council committee structures are being changed right now under the new council president.

1443
02:22:28.503 --> 02:22:30.895
<v Angelita Morillo>So we, we might not have a governance committee, who knows?

1444
02:22:31.070 --> 02:22:35.950
<v Angelita Morillo>And then we'll have a council of the whole, in which case we would be making that decision together anyways.

1445
02:22:36.543 --> 02:22:41.245
<v Angelita Morillo>But I think that there is a certain point where you are going to perfect the process through action.

1446
02:22:42.145 --> 02:22:46.301
<v Angelita Morillo>This— the reality is this is the first time our new government body is doing this process.

1447
02:22:46.397 --> 02:22:48.291
<v Angelita Morillo>We've never done this before under the new government.

1448
02:22:48.340 --> 02:22:48.709
<v Olivia Clark>Councilmember Herbold.

1449
02:22:49.207 --> 02:22:57.375
<v Angelita Morillo>And that means that sometimes you have to do it, and then you're going to figure out the process as you go along, because that's just the way things work sometimes.

1450
02:22:58.112 --> 02:23:00.055
<v Angelita Morillo>But this is an urgent matter to me.

1451
02:23:00.215 --> 02:23:02.013
<v Angelita Morillo>We are about to enter the budget season.

1452
02:23:02.541 --> 02:23:08.528
<v Angelita Morillo>It starts in June, but really, we all know that budget season started a few months ago as we're making these decisions.

1453
02:23:08.977 --> 02:23:29.611
<v Angelita Morillo>So I don't feel like, as a representative of District 3, that I can make accurate assessments of the budget of the process, of the dollars before us, and that I can look my constituents in the eye and tell them that I did everything I could to find dollars to fund things so that I didn't have to cut the thing that they cared about if I don't actually trust the process that we have laid out here.

1454
02:23:31.138 --> 02:23:36.953
<v Angelita Morillo>So I would really urge my colleagues, you know, we, we as a council body are very lethargic.

1455
02:23:37.115 --> 02:23:38.299
<v Angelita Morillo>We slow things down.

1456
02:23:38.978 --> 02:23:39.918
<v Angelita Morillo>We don't get a lot done.

1457
02:23:40.617 --> 02:23:47.665
<v Angelita Morillo>I think we need to just Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

1458
02:23:49.575 --> 02:23:51.452
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1459
02:23:51.711 --> 02:23:56.715
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President, and thank you for those that brought this item.

1460
02:23:56.763 --> 02:24:03.093
<v Dan Ryan>It's been a good debate so far, and also the testimony was helpful, and I agreed with much of it.

1461
02:24:03.463 --> 02:24:05.093
<v Dan Ryan>I'm a big advocate for oversight.

1462
02:24:05.222 --> 02:24:08.027
<v Dan Ryan>Policy seldom is felt on the ground for a couple years.

1463
02:24:08.652 --> 02:24:15.521
<v Dan Ryan>So I tend to be very dogged about following them, following them along so they actually are felt by the good people that live here in Portland.

1464
02:24:16.130 --> 02:24:24.011
<v Dan Ryan>I also want to get to the bottom of this, and this is about the financial controls at Portland Housing Bureau, specifically the rental office.

1465
02:24:25.263 --> 02:24:29.275
<v Dan Ryan>I think that we're missing the boat by not going at it this way.

1466
02:24:29.420 --> 02:24:37.429
<v Dan Ryan>I think an independent audit, which was mentioned by people who testified, of Portland Housing Bureau's financial controls is what I think we should be voting on.

1467
02:24:37.493 --> 02:24:37.684
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1468
02:24:38.290 --> 02:24:38.628
<v Dan Ryan>Today.

1469
02:24:39.048 --> 02:24:40.177
<v Dan Ryan>That will build trust.

1470
02:24:41.049 --> 02:24:44.792
<v Dan Ryan>The big picture item of oversight needs more work.

1471
02:24:45.610 --> 02:24:47.353
<v Dan Ryan>This isn't the big picture.

1472
02:24:47.725 --> 02:24:54.201
<v Dan Ryan>This is, this is going up, in my opinion, a microaggression of one incident where there's personalities connected to it.

1473
02:24:55.412 --> 02:25:02.106
<v Dan Ryan>This specific issue, we have an executive committee meeting, which was just mentioned, on the 11th of December.

1474
02:25:02.914 --> 02:25:05.643
<v Dan Ryan>I, I know that all of us, I think we're all in attendance.

1475
02:25:05.691 --> 02:25:05.838
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

1476
02:25:06.560 --> 02:25:15.904
<v Dan Ryan>And I did receive information at that executive session that allowed me to feel good about the process going forward on this HR issue.

1477
02:25:17.920 --> 02:25:19.693
<v Dan Ryan>This is punitive in my opinion.

1478
02:25:19.790 --> 02:25:22.066
<v Dan Ryan>It doesn't get— it doesn't build trust.

1479
02:25:22.372 --> 02:25:28.613
<v Dan Ryan>This also does not get to the bottom of the recent shoes that have been dropping at the Housing Bureau.

1480
02:25:28.924 --> 02:25:30.950
<v Dan Ryan>An audit gets to the bottom of it.

1481
02:25:31.637 --> 02:25:38.899
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate I just hope we can go about it the right way.

1482
02:25:39.530 --> 02:25:43.270
<v Dan Ryan>We need to focus on principles, not personalities.

1483
02:25:43.270 --> 02:25:44.170
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1484
02:25:44.170 --> 02:25:45.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1485
02:25:45.469 --> 02:25:46.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Eric Green.

1486
02:25:47.530 --> 02:25:48.959
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yeah, thank you, colleagues.

1487
02:25:49.829 --> 02:25:56.370
<v Mitch Green>I just want to speak to the question of whether or not we got our answers— our questions answered during an executive session.

1488
02:25:56.969 --> 02:25:59.010
<v Mitch Green>That executive session, which I won't go into detail about, Talk was held on March 15th.

1489
02:25:59.141 --> 02:26:04.576
<v Mitch Green>About the contents of it because it was an executive session, but that was narrowly focused on a personnel issue.

1490
02:26:04.913 --> 02:26:12.897
<v Mitch Green>That was narrowly focused on the matter of the prior, um, PHB director's, uh, termination or resignation.

1491
02:26:13.569 --> 02:26:15.045
<v Mitch Green>That's what the focus of that was on.

1492
02:26:15.799 --> 02:26:27.909
<v Mitch Green>Um, I did try to ask questions about the timeline that I'm worried about here and I'm concerned about, and as soon as I started to do that, I was shut down by some of my colleagues who said this is actually a policy discussion.

1493
02:26:28.409 --> 02:26:31.024
<v Mitch Green>This is actually something outside the bounds of an executive session.

1494
02:26:31.074 --> 02:26:34.521
<v Mitch Green>If we're to continue to do this, we will be in violation of public meetings law.

1495
02:26:35.120 --> 02:26:39.777
<v Mitch Green>And so I said, okay, I'm going to pursue a resolution that's very public so we can actually do this.

1496
02:26:40.293 --> 02:26:49.694
<v Mitch Green>So what you're talking about— what we're talking about here is actually recognition that, um, that this broader consideration is actually beyond the scope of an executive session.

1497
02:26:50.296 --> 02:26:56.075
<v Mitch Green>And even if we got all of our questions answered inside of that session, the public doesn't.

1498
02:26:57.120 --> 02:26:57.939
<v Mitch Green>This is for the public.

1499
02:26:58.581 --> 02:27:06.560
<v Mitch Green>So it's not good enough for the public to say, okay, well, some councilors were told behind closed doors what actually happened here, so it's good, trust us.

1500
02:27:06.801 --> 02:27:07.781
<v Mitch Green>Because it's not good.

1501
02:27:08.054 --> 02:27:08.745
<v Mitch Green>They don't trust us.

1502
02:27:09.836 --> 02:27:36.013
<v Mitch Green>I think that if we're going to go out in the years to come and ask the city of Portland or ask people in our community, residents of the broader metro region to say yes to a new bond or yes to a new tax proposal, they're going to look at us and say, why should I trust you with new money when you're not even willing to engage in very routine and normal oversight practices that other cities do when they have a sort of multi-bicameral system of government?

1503
02:27:36.495 --> 02:27:43.406
<v Mitch Green>That's what we're trying to do here, and our refusal to do it would be a signal to constituents that we don't take our jobs seriously.

1504
02:27:44.873 --> 02:27:51.881
<v Mitch Green>And so that's— I just wanted to make it very clear that when we went into executive session on December 11th, it wasn't about the questions I'm asking.

1505
02:27:52.319 --> 02:27:54.593
<v Mitch Green>It was about a personnel matter, which we can't talk about here.

1506
02:27:55.549 --> 02:27:55.971
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1507
02:27:58.939 --> 02:27:59.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1508
02:27:59.935 --> 02:28:00.638
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

1509
02:28:02.878 --> 02:28:03.467
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, thank you.

1510
02:28:05.149 --> 02:28:12.304
<v Candace Avalos>I just want to start by saying I definitely agree with the overall notion that we don't want to create a culture of And that is not the intent.

1511
02:28:12.690 --> 02:28:22.532
<v Candace Avalos>And also, us doing our jobs to ensure that we have the right information to make the decisions that we need to make requires transparency, requires public visibility.

1512
02:28:23.673 --> 02:28:30.609
<v Candace Avalos>And, but I think us creating that trust with the administrative branch is doing exactly this, right?

1513
02:28:30.656 --> 02:28:39.795
<v Candace Avalos>Because without that trust, then we're gonna continue to Encourage fear of talking to us about what's going on.

1514
02:28:40.291 --> 02:28:46.282
<v Candace Avalos>I think ultimately this is also about creating a mechanism for the public to receive the same information that we get.

1515
02:28:46.572 --> 02:28:56.691
<v Candace Avalos>An executive session, as Councilor Green has already described, it wasn't about this in the first place, but even if it was, that is not the proper way to communicate to the public and earn their trust.

1516
02:28:57.316 --> 02:29:19.824
<v Candace Avalos>'Cause I think at the end of the day, if people are worried about how the public is perceiving us and how the public might think see this as us not being fiscally responsible, as us abdicating our duties for financial stewardship, then we have a duty to correct that record in a visible way and create a plan that's going to ensure that we can minimize these kinds of oversights in the future.

1517
02:29:19.904 --> 02:29:30.415
<v Candace Avalos>So there's a real narrative problem that we have to discuss, especially at a moment when the community, as Councilor Green just stated, does not trust us with dollars, does not trust that we are putting them in the right place.

1518
02:29:30.479 --> 02:29:30.784
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1519
02:29:31.121 --> 02:29:37.954
<v Candace Avalos>And when $40 million, about $40 million shows up, that creates a real distrust.

1520
02:29:38.501 --> 02:29:49.456
<v Candace Avalos>Ultimately, it's clear though, regardless of where you're landing on this issue, on this particular resolution, that there is a desire from everybody to set some norms and procedures for our oversight powers.

1521
02:29:50.209 --> 02:29:53.691
<v Candace Avalos>So I definitely am interested in us continuing that conversation.

1522
02:29:54.059 --> 02:29:57.042
<v Candace Avalos>But to me, this is the beginning of that conversation.

1523
02:29:57.106 --> 02:29:58.293
<v Candace Avalos>Passing this resolution is the first step.

1524
02:29:58.342 --> 02:29:58.727
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Smith.

1525
02:29:58.840 --> 02:30:09.222
<v Candace Avalos>Step for us to open up that door and then to create a framework from here, um, that we can replicate in the future for how we engage with the administration, um, when we need answers.

1526
02:30:09.511 --> 02:30:11.915
<v Candace Avalos>So I would really encourage folks to see it in that way.

1527
02:30:12.011 --> 02:30:18.869
<v Candace Avalos>I know that there's a lot of questions that are still unanswered, but I don't think we can not answer those questions, um, if we don't move forward.

1528
02:30:19.365 --> 02:30:19.606
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1529
02:30:19.942 --> 02:30:21.192
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1530
02:30:21.385 --> 02:30:22.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1531
02:30:23.291 --> 02:30:24.286
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1532
02:30:24.494 --> 02:30:30.045
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I have A number of remarks I'd like to make, but I do have a question first.

1533
02:30:30.125 --> 02:30:37.550
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, you have run things in a way where we've had different people running different meetings.

1534
02:30:38.212 --> 02:30:41.683
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Who do you intend to have run this?

1535
02:30:41.894 --> 02:30:45.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not sure if it's gonna technically be a work session or what it will be.

1536
02:30:46.227 --> 02:30:56.914
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, with regard to this, I intend to run it since this is our first Our first oversight, and we do not have formally delegated oversight to any of the committees.

1537
02:30:57.188 --> 02:30:58.376
<v Jamie Dunphy>I intend to oversee it.

1538
02:30:58.778 --> 02:30:59.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1539
02:31:03.115 --> 02:31:16.311
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, Councilor Green and I have had a number of conversations over the last year, really, about oversight, and over the last couple of months about this resolution in particular.

1540
02:31:17.626 --> 02:31:24.796
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As you know, Councilor, I went back and forth before deciding ultimately to join you in attempting to move it forward last year.

1541
02:31:26.047 --> 02:31:31.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I agree with Councilor Murillo that oversight is one of the most important things that we do as a body.

1542
02:31:32.462 --> 02:31:42.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while we've had some discussion about us not having delved into how we do oversight, I actually don't think we ever needed to delve into how we do oversight.

1543
02:31:42.905 --> 02:31:45.439
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think oversight should be something ongoing.

1544
02:31:45.968 --> 02:31:46.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Something casual.

1545
02:31:46.915 --> 02:31:51.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I've said before at this dais that oversight should be part of the normal committee process.

1546
02:31:52.450 --> 02:32:11.029
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We should see its regular use on committee agendas where we hold conversation about how program implementation is going with DCAs and bureau directors, where we talk about what budget spend looks like midway through the year so that where there are bureaus of particular interest, we know how things are going.

1547
02:32:12.009 --> 02:32:22.751
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Where we discuss with bureau directors and deputy city administrators as a committee in public what we're hearing from our constituents and what we hope to see from the administrative branch.

1548
02:32:23.970 --> 02:32:27.775
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We should be able to ask for information casually and receive it.

1549
02:32:28.868 --> 02:32:30.538
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I've never had a problem doing that.

1550
02:32:30.810 --> 02:32:36.558
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know many people here have asked for information and received it over the past year, and that's happened in committees.

1551
02:32:36.639 --> 02:32:39.171
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At times, but not often enough.

1552
02:32:40.261 --> 02:32:44.731
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oversight should not be controversial or adversarial or scary.

1553
02:32:46.126 --> 02:32:50.581
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we do have given to us through the charter more formal oversight powers.

1554
02:32:51.254 --> 02:32:56.622
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if our relationship with the administration is healthy, I don't think we should ever have to use it.

1555
02:32:56.942 --> 02:33:01.782
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if and when we do need it, it should only be after multiple steps of escalation.

1556
02:33:01.831 --> 02:33:01.926
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1557
02:33:03.500 --> 02:33:05.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We start with a casual conversation.

1558
02:33:05.908 --> 02:33:08.028
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>An ask for something hard is denied.

1559
02:33:08.718 --> 02:33:11.543
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We go to the press about that refusal to talk.

1560
02:33:11.850 --> 02:33:12.877
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We build the pressure.

1561
02:33:13.375 --> 02:33:17.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We add— we send out another invitation to a committee hearing.

1562
02:33:18.850 --> 02:33:21.869
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And only then do we move to a resolution like this.

1563
02:33:22.688 --> 02:33:27.472
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Only after multiple other steps do we even mention the word subpoena.

1564
02:33:27.521 --> 02:33:27.648
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1565
02:33:28.484 --> 02:33:42.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Frankly, I don't actually think the Baltimore model should be our regular model because I think our relationship with the administration should be one where we have these conversations as a regular part of our work in committees.

1566
02:33:43.502 --> 02:33:46.634
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This resolution is an escalation, and it's one that I don't think we need yet.

1567
02:33:47.662 --> 02:33:53.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think we've gone through all the steps, including robust committee work on this process.

1568
02:33:53.653 --> 02:33:53.764
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1569
02:33:54.006 --> 02:33:57.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And to be clear, I don't need to be in every conversation.

1570
02:33:58.514 --> 02:34:05.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are a body with committees, and in agreeing to that, we agreed that we would not each be in every conversation.

1571
02:34:07.984 --> 02:34:16.338
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also recognize that there's considerable public interest, and there have been an abundance of questions from my colleagues about this topic.

1572
02:34:16.820 --> 02:34:23.379
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And frankly, I am not convinced that if we do anything other than this, those questions will go away.

1573
02:34:24.462 --> 02:34:30.578
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am not convinced that everybody up here will be satisfied until we move through this process.

1574
02:34:31.659 --> 02:34:33.543
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are records that do need to be made public.

1575
02:34:34.690 --> 02:34:43.575
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Portlanders deserve to get the full story of what has happened, and I don't see my colleagues leaning into doing that in the way that I think it should be done.

1576
02:34:45.420 --> 02:34:58.486
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I hope that we can all agree that it should not be done as a punitive It must be a fact-finding mission so that Portlanders can fully understand the challenges and opportunities of transitioning to a new form of government.

1577
02:34:59.128 --> 02:35:15.388
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And my understanding from what we've heard today from the carrier and from what I've heard in conversations with the council president is that they are committed to this being a fact-finding and transparency process, not a process to find blame.

1578
02:35:16.272 --> 02:35:20.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not something that could, as my colleague noted, lead to a disciplinary action.

1579
02:35:20.760 --> 02:35:22.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That would be wholly inappropriate.

1580
02:35:25.350 --> 02:35:34.483
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not something— not only not something that presupposes wrongdoing, but specifically something focused on improvements and not on finding wrongdoing at all.

1581
02:35:35.771 --> 02:35:44.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This should be a process that allows us to improve the work and come away with a better understanding of how our funds have worked in the past.

1582
02:35:45.066 --> 02:35:50.355
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And allow the administration to come away with a better understanding of how we'd like things to work moving forward.

1583
02:35:50.992 --> 02:35:51.442
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's it.

1584
02:35:52.506 --> 02:36:00.531
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To that end, I actually think the first 3 questions here can lead us to a discussion where we can make important statements about how this could be better in the future.

1585
02:36:01.920 --> 02:36:10.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll share, though, that hearing many of my colleagues' questions today, Council President, I'm concerned we won't stick to the questions on the page.

1586
02:36:11.833 --> 02:36:16.757
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm concerned we won't have a forward-looking discussion stemming from the answers to those questions.

1587
02:36:17.736 --> 02:36:21.933
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am concerned this won't be a fact-finding and transparency process.

1588
02:36:23.799 --> 02:36:24.934
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope we can stick to it.

1589
02:36:25.779 --> 02:36:43.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Portlanders are watching, and I believe our constituents want a process with more oversight, but I do not think that they want the aggressive interrogation that we see at the federal level, where we go after hardworking public employees whose work we should respect.

1590
02:36:44.834 --> 02:36:51.966
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If this becomes that, this process will absolutely lose my support and frankly my participation.

1591
02:36:53.690 --> 02:37:05.620
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we as a body deserve the chance to prove that we can do this respectfully and that we can create an environment of oversight that is free from fear for our public employees.

1592
02:37:07.430 --> 02:37:22.525
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am leaning right now toward voting yes to give us that chance, but I hope we all take very seriously the trust that the public has put in us to do oversight and the trust that we will lose if we turn this into a joke.

1593
02:37:23.590 --> 02:37:24.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1594
02:37:24.671 --> 02:37:25.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1595
02:37:26.123 --> 02:37:27.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I'll note that it is 12:03.

1596
02:37:27.818 --> 02:37:31.635
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have 5 additional councilors in the queue, and we have 3 more items to get to today.

1597
02:37:32.636 --> 02:37:33.346
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1598
02:37:34.719 --> 02:37:36.917
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, thank you.

1599
02:37:38.468 --> 02:37:52.210
<v Loretta Smith>I was just thinking about this because not only does this $21 million, um, give us reason for looking a little bit deeper, but I went back a little deeper than that.

1600
02:37:53.373 --> 02:37:55.718
<v Loretta Smith>I went back to The TAO.

1601
02:37:56.058 --> 02:37:56.254
<v Loretta Smith>The TAO.

1602
02:37:57.583 --> 02:38:14.119
<v Loretta Smith>And in the TAO, there is an exhibit that says $2.449 million was given to the housing trust fund.

1603
02:38:15.126 --> 02:38:17.443
<v Loretta Smith>So we may have to open this up if we pass this.

1604
02:38:18.772 --> 02:38:26.222
<v Loretta Smith>And in that trust fund, that housing investment trust fund, it was a red— it was like it It was in the red for $2.449 million.

1605
02:38:28.143 --> 02:38:35.590
<v Loretta Smith>And so I got to thinking, wow, we just learned that there's $21 million in that trust fund.

1606
02:38:36.203 --> 02:38:42.764
<v Loretta Smith>So how did we owe it $2.4— trying to find the number— $2.449 million?

1607
02:38:44.701 --> 02:38:57.706
<v Loretta Smith>So it's not going to be just about this $21 Um, when Councilor Morillo says we're, we're not going to be looking for wrongdoing, well, what is malfeasance?

1608
02:38:59.825 --> 02:39:18.318
<v Loretta Smith>What if a housing director— we already know because we passed it— put forward $2.49 million and we paid them another $2.4 million And they actually had a surplus and not a deficit.

1609
02:39:19.442 --> 02:39:25.156
<v Loretta Smith>So I got a problem with that because I already know that that's something that we already did because that's something that the Housing Bureau put forward.

1610
02:39:26.632 --> 02:39:55.135
<v Loretta Smith>And knowing that, this is a bigger issue than the $21 million, and I feel like we need to figure out how to get to that point because I'm looking We put $2,449,339 in the TAO for short-term rental funding to the Housing Investment Fund.

1611
02:39:56.022 --> 02:39:56.653
<v Loretta Smith>We paid that.

1612
02:39:56.733 --> 02:40:00.351
<v Loretta Smith>We did that because that's what they said, they were in deficit.

1613
02:40:00.625 --> 02:40:02.224
<v Loretta Smith>But really, they were not in deficit.

1614
02:40:02.400 --> 02:40:05.260
<v Loretta Smith>I don't really need this hearing to let me know that they did something wrong.

1615
02:40:05.308 --> 02:40:15.318
<v Loretta Smith>Councilwoman Smith, They took $2.449 million from our general fund to fill their fund because they said they had to have a certain amount of money in there.

1616
02:40:15.384 --> 02:40:17.614
<v Loretta Smith>So let me go to the FIN.

1617
02:40:21.109 --> 02:40:25.718
<v Loretta Smith>In the Housing Investment Fund, the managing bureau is the Portland Housing Bureau.

1618
02:40:26.463 --> 02:40:31.781
<v Loretta Smith>The Housing Investment Fund supports the city's housing initiatives, all of which Yes.

1619
02:40:31.878 --> 02:40:41.764
<v Loretta Smith>Serve to develop or preserve affordable housing in Portland or help low- and moderate-income individuals to access affordable housing.

1620
02:40:45.138 --> 02:40:47.996
<v Loretta Smith>There are no reserve requirements in this fund.

1621
02:40:50.799 --> 02:40:58.829
<v Loretta Smith>Per financial policy, contingency funds should be used to address reasonable but unforeseen requirements Within the fiscal year.

1622
02:40:59.380 --> 02:41:04.388
<v Loretta Smith>There are no minimum or maximum contingency requirements for the Housing Investment Fund.

1623
02:41:04.858 --> 02:41:16.524
<v Loretta Smith>So now that we've level set, we didn't have to give that money to the Housing Investment Fund during the TAO, the $2.449,339 million.

1624
02:41:17.490 --> 02:41:22.531
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm going to ask this of the, um, you weren't here, city.

1625
02:41:23.190 --> 02:41:33.788
<v Loretta Smith>Administrator Raymond Lee, tell me what this is when we have a bureau who asks for money and they— I'm looking at it and I can send you, I will forward it to you.

1626
02:41:35.145 --> 02:41:39.538
<v Loretta Smith>They asked for money, said that they were in deficit, but now we find out they got $21 million.

1627
02:41:40.959 --> 02:41:41.766
<v Loretta Smith>What you gonna do about it?

1628
02:41:43.355 --> 02:41:44.552
<v Loretta Smith>Because we don't have to have a hearing.

1629
02:41:44.665 --> 02:41:46.735
<v Loretta Smith>I don't need to wait until March 6th.

1630
02:41:46.832 --> 02:41:49.564
<v Loretta Smith>I need the administration and the executive to act.

1631
02:41:49.628 --> 02:41:50.000
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1632
02:41:50.733 --> 02:41:51.790
<v Loretta Smith>Because now we know.

1633
02:41:52.078 --> 02:41:53.200
<v Loretta Smith>We don't have to investigate.

1634
02:41:53.297 --> 02:41:56.119
<v Loretta Smith>We got something for sure right here.

1635
02:41:56.920 --> 02:41:58.780
<v Loretta Smith>Somebody needs to tell me something right now.

1636
02:41:58.987 --> 02:42:00.237
<v Loretta Smith>I don't need to go to a hearing.

1637
02:42:00.992 --> 02:42:05.913
<v Loretta Smith>Why did you ask me for $2.449 million when you had $21 million already there?

1638
02:42:06.040 --> 02:42:07.194
<v Loretta Smith>You didn't have a deficit.

1639
02:42:07.548 --> 02:42:14.103
<v Jamie Dunphy>Again, Councilor, we are on the topic of the oversight hearing, but not the, the substance of what the oversight hearing—.

1640
02:42:14.103 --> 02:42:24.201
<v Loretta Smith>Well, what I'm saying is I don't need an oversight hearing Because we have something in front of us right now that can be actually dealt with in the City Administrator's office, in the mayor's office.

1641
02:42:25.020 --> 02:42:41.690
<v Loretta Smith>We can actually go get a third-party investigator now to look at this entire thing so that it doesn't turn into a kangaroo court, because there are so many issues relating to this, and there are so many different asks and requests.

1642
02:42:42.251 --> 02:42:48.738
<v Loretta Smith>And then when I just looked at this, I went back on the towel and I said, Well, we've already— we already know we've been due.

1643
02:42:48.787 --> 02:42:51.250
<v Loretta Smith>So there has been some wrongdoing, um, Councilor Morillo.

1644
02:42:51.540 --> 02:42:53.954
<v Loretta Smith>It's already some wrongdoing done.

1645
02:42:54.213 --> 02:42:55.088
<v Loretta Smith>I see it right here.

1646
02:42:55.459 --> 02:42:56.185
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm not seeing that.

1647
02:42:56.540 --> 02:43:00.105
<v Loretta Smith>So, um, well, somebody did something.

1648
02:43:00.171 --> 02:43:01.913
<v Loretta Smith>They said it's in negative, it's in red.

1649
02:43:02.349 --> 02:43:04.042
<v Loretta Smith>They said they need $2.449 million.

1650
02:43:04.108 --> 02:43:04.688
<v Loretta Smith>We gave it to them.

1651
02:43:04.753 --> 02:43:07.985
<v Loretta Smith>We voted for it and we gave it to them already.

1652
02:43:08.602 --> 02:43:11.477
<v Loretta Smith>So that's something that the administration— that's their job.

1653
02:43:11.893 --> 02:43:13.454
<v Loretta Smith>These bureaus report to them.

1654
02:43:14.291 --> 02:43:15.209
<v Loretta Smith>They need to handle this.

1655
02:43:15.273 --> 02:43:18.350
<v Loretta Smith>When things come to their light, they have to deal with it.

1656
02:43:18.397 --> 02:43:25.647
<v Loretta Smith>And I want to give these folks an opportunity to deal with it and tell us what they going to do about it.

1657
02:43:26.147 --> 02:43:26.469
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1658
02:43:26.680 --> 02:43:27.406
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1659
02:43:27.682 --> 02:43:28.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

1660
02:43:30.979 --> 02:43:32.047
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1661
02:43:32.992 --> 02:43:35.317
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I just want to start by saying one thing here.

1662
02:43:35.677 --> 02:43:43.731
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I imagine that the city administrator Raymond Lee is gonna be one of the people who's asking— answering, sorry, questions over the course of this process.

1663
02:43:43.940 --> 02:43:45.641
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is more for the public and the media.

1664
02:43:45.706 --> 02:43:53.218
<v Sameer Kanal>It'll be tempting or perhaps simply easy to say he's the guy answering the questions and connect that with an assumption that he'd be explaining what he did.

1665
02:43:53.811 --> 02:44:05.657
<v Sameer Kanal>But I wanna state up front here that the administrator started a month ago, and I'd ask that those covering this in media or even just talking about it on social media understand that the problem we're talking about predates the tenure of actually not just him, but just about everybody up here.

1666
02:44:05.722 --> 02:44:05.882
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1667
02:44:05.979 --> 02:44:06.108
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

1668
02:44:06.877 --> 02:44:15.450
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and that's part of trying to create a culture where people feel comfortable coming up and saying, this problem happened, let's fix it together, uh, with council as early as possible.

1669
02:44:15.787 --> 02:44:27.532
<v Sameer Kanal>Because if we— and by we, I don't mean just this side of the dais, but the entire city— end up lazily blaming the person answering the questions, we're going to not do right by all of our employees, in particular our most prominent employee at the city.

1670
02:44:28.431 --> 02:44:34.219
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I also want to double down on something Councilor Green said in point out that this is a tactic we've seen in this building quite a bit.

1671
02:44:34.283 --> 02:44:40.799
<v Sameer Kanal>When there are 2 ways to do something and someone chooses one way to attempt it, they're told this isn't the right way, do it the other way.

1672
02:44:41.361 --> 02:44:45.359
<v Sameer Kanal>And then when they try the other way, the same people say this isn't the right way, do it the first way.

1673
02:44:45.614 --> 02:44:53.977
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Green did ask questions in the executive session and was told that ORS 192.660 didn't allow for those questions in that executive session on December 11th.

1674
02:44:54.265 --> 02:44:55.854
<v Sameer Kanal>And by the way, I agree with that interpretation.

1675
02:44:56.208 --> 02:45:04.280
<v Sameer Kanal>But then when it's said here that that this should be covered in the executive session, it starts to feel like it's not a real argument at all, but instead just the status quo telling people to let it go.

1676
02:45:05.000 --> 02:45:06.190
<v Sameer Kanal>Taxpayers aren't letting this go.

1677
02:45:06.399 --> 02:45:07.840
<v Sameer Kanal>Public broadly isn't letting this go.

1678
02:45:07.840 --> 02:45:09.459
<v Sameer Kanal>And because of that, I don't think we should let it go.

1679
02:45:10.020 --> 02:45:15.469
<v Sameer Kanal>Another example, by the way, is when someone suggests a change to the structure of an oversight board, they're told you have to bargain this first.

1680
02:45:15.700 --> 02:45:20.799
<v Sameer Kanal>And then when they try to then ask the city attorneys to start bargaining on it, the response is you can't start to bargain until you have the policy.

1681
02:45:21.360 --> 02:45:29.137
<v Sameer Kanal>And while that's on another topical area, I think it's relevant here because of the exact thing that Councilor As Morillo said, accountability is not punishment, but it is often perceived as such.

1682
02:45:29.716 --> 02:45:36.268
<v Sameer Kanal>I also want to disagree with the idea that oversight should be done in committee, though I do think it should start informally and escalate.

1683
02:45:36.460 --> 02:45:39.061
<v Sameer Kanal>I have philosophical and practical disagreements about doing it in committee.

1684
02:45:39.158 --> 02:45:51.413
<v Sameer Kanal>Philosophically, sometimes you just do need more formalized processes, and only 5 of us shouldn't be able to do oversight on housing just because we're the only ones on the committee when it is among the most prominent topics that we hear about in our community.

1685
02:45:51.460 --> 02:45:51.557
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1686
02:45:52.808 --> 02:46:00.849
<v Sameer Kanal>As for practically, committees just don't have the time, and we need to recognize that the full council is the most flexible part from a scheduling perspective of our current system.

1687
02:46:01.329 --> 02:46:05.935
<v Sameer Kanal>Council has often gone over, and committees, while they have done so, have only done so for a little bit at a time.

1688
02:46:06.706 --> 02:46:16.382
<v Sameer Kanal>Keep in mind that there have been in the last 4 weeks people shaming others for committees running over time and simultaneously saying more should be done in committee.

1689
02:46:16.897 --> 02:46:18.468
<v Sameer Kanal>This is not a real suggestion.

1690
02:46:19.224 --> 02:46:24.200
<v Sameer Kanal>It is a way of saying do less, care about fewer things, and effectively accept the status quo.

1691
02:46:24.682 --> 02:46:26.897
<v Sameer Kanal>Well, we have seen what the status quo has gotten us.

1692
02:46:27.073 --> 02:46:29.336
<v Sameer Kanal>It has led to some bad outcomes, and it's time to start fixing them.

1693
02:46:30.122 --> 02:46:36.897
<v Sameer Kanal>I will say that this is not— if I was building it perfectly from scratch, and I imagine everyone here would agree with it, this is not perfect.

1694
02:46:37.025 --> 02:46:38.663
<v Sameer Kanal>No piece of legislation is perfect.

1695
02:46:38.985 --> 02:46:45.934
<v Sameer Kanal>I wish we'd had a year of discussions leading up to a process for oversight, but I want to say it's still worth doing because it is a vast improvement.

1696
02:46:46.343 --> 02:46:47.371
<v Sameer Kanal>On what we have now.

1697
02:46:47.746 --> 02:46:51.274
<v Sameer Kanal>This is precedent setting, and this is the right topic to set that precedent with.

1698
02:46:51.819 --> 02:46:56.631
<v Sameer Kanal>I am frustrated we didn't get to this conversation before today, and I'm grateful that the sponsors brought it forward now.

1699
02:46:58.775 --> 02:47:02.424
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm looking forward to being a part of this process and the conversations that we have.

1700
02:47:02.808 --> 02:47:15.337
<v Sameer Kanal>I do think that we may need to expand not the scope in the— expand the scope in the context of what we're talking about, about not how we're talking about it, because I do agree with everyone's point that this is not necessarily about wrongdoing.

1701
02:47:15.386 --> 02:47:17.585
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not necessarily about any person.

1702
02:47:17.682 --> 02:47:22.819
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll also note that the sponsors of this document are not the people who've been bringing up specific employee names today.

1703
02:47:23.414 --> 02:47:24.393
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's really important.

1704
02:47:24.441 --> 02:47:31.040
<v Sameer Kanal>These are straw man arguments when you bring up people that might be theoretically targeted by this when nobody else is doing that.

1705
02:47:31.088 --> 02:47:32.950
<v Sameer Kanal>The people proposing this have not done that.

1706
02:47:33.433 --> 02:47:39.952
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I'd ask that we avoid the straw man and just look at what the document says because there's nothing in here I read the whole thing.

1707
02:47:40.552 --> 02:47:41.639
<v Sameer Kanal>I would suggest others do it too.

1708
02:47:41.931 --> 02:47:48.317
<v Sameer Kanal>There's nothing in here that actually talks about some sort of sanction or punishment to employees.

1709
02:47:49.138 --> 02:47:50.620
<v Sameer Kanal>So I intend to vote yes on this.

1710
02:47:50.781 --> 02:47:56.486
<v Sameer Kanal>I intend to help make this successful and look forward to taking it as a precedent and revising it and making it better in the future.

1711
02:47:58.101 --> 02:47:59.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1712
02:47:59.618 --> 02:48:00.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I put myself in the queue.

1713
02:48:01.569 --> 02:48:03.975
<v Jamie Dunphy>I wanna just very briefly, well, first I wanna note it is 12:15.

1714
02:48:04.906 --> 02:48:08.384
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't think there's any situation in which we're gonna be getting to the last 3 items today.

1715
02:48:10.806 --> 02:48:12.268
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we will have to come back to that.

1716
02:48:12.657 --> 02:48:28.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>I wanna say I came into this hearing bullish and very supportive, and I have to be honest, I have grown 3 significant worries since this hearing started about whether I think this is the right idea.

1717
02:48:28.638 --> 02:48:34.063
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will be honest, I am, deeply opposed to calling frontline staff to testify before us.

1718
02:48:34.319 --> 02:48:46.893
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe that responsibility rolls uphill, and while they may have specific information that is vital for us to know, it is incumbent upon their supervisors to get that information in a way that they can convey it to us.

1719
02:48:47.486 --> 02:48:54.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that we should not be speaking with anybody below a director level, and it will be incumbent on those directors to get as much information.

1720
02:48:55.113 --> 02:48:59.064
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will not be supportive of calling any frontline staff to testify before us.

1721
02:48:59.564 --> 02:49:07.225
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am deeply worried about a line of questioning from this body regarding an HR investigation into the former director.

1722
02:49:08.111 --> 02:49:16.538
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is a private internal conversation that we've already started to touch on a little bit too much in this conversation, and it makes me deeply uncomfortable.

1723
02:49:16.877 --> 02:49:21.682
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I have no guarantees that we won't cross into that line while we are in our hearing.

1724
02:49:21.795 --> 02:49:31.087
<v Jamie Dunphy>And And third, I am worried about this body's ability to, uh, not cross those lines with regard to specific questions that are outside of the scope of this investigation.

1725
02:49:31.825 --> 02:49:42.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I at this point believe that the best option for us would be to hire a private investigator to present this information and someone that we could grill in that capacity.

1726
02:49:42.274 --> 02:49:46.463
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I will note that that is likely to be very expensive and will not be done by March 6th.

1727
02:49:46.994 --> 02:49:56.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I The early estimates would probably be that that would be a $50,000 to $100,000 cost and would probably take 1 to 2 months minimum in order for us to accomplish that.

1728
02:49:57.593 --> 02:49:59.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>My question is to the city administrator.

1729
02:50:01.174 --> 02:50:10.977
<v Jamie Dunphy>One, are there any other deep concerns that you have about how this is framing that this— that the legislature— legislative body should be responsive to in order to make sure that we land this?

1730
02:50:11.059 --> 02:50:11.273
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes.

1731
02:50:11.537 --> 02:50:17.644
<v Jamie Dunphy>And second, if this does not pass, pass today because I am not counting votes and I don't have a clear sense of who is voting where.

1732
02:50:18.237 --> 02:50:23.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, how do you intend to, uh, move forward regardless?

1733
02:50:24.286 --> 02:50:31.584
<v Raymond C. Lee>I'll start with the second part of this question, and we will have to conduct an audit of the situation.

1734
02:50:31.648 --> 02:50:34.601
<v Raymond C. Lee>And it's just not this one specific item.

1735
02:50:34.697 --> 02:50:37.792
<v Raymond C. Lee>We'll be really looking at the city as a whole in the process.

1736
02:50:38.227 --> 02:50:40.039
<v Raymond C. Lee>We have a ton of restricted funds.

1737
02:50:40.391 --> 02:50:57.365
<v Raymond C. Lee>Throughout our city that we want to pay close attention to and how those dollars are being spent or how, how are they being accounted for as an organization and how are we using those funds to really move forward the priorities that the City Council has overall.

1738
02:50:57.782 --> 02:50:59.290
<v Raymond C. Lee>That's one component of it.

1739
02:51:00.447 --> 02:51:12.050
<v Raymond C. Lee>Once we look at this information holistically, typically in a situation like this, There are several different ways to get to the bottom line of what has caused this situation to happen.

1740
02:51:12.709 --> 02:51:31.190
<v Raymond C. Lee>And in a typical situation like this, I probably more than likely would've done a formal investigation into a matter like this where we have the opportunity and the time of having a professional come in and truly ask the questions and gather all the information and to produce a report.

1741
02:51:31.271 --> 02:51:31.367
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1742
02:51:31.479 --> 02:51:49.127
<v Raymond C. Lee>Report, uh, to me as a result of what came out of this investigation, any actions that need to be taken moving forward, what changes may need to be taking place in the organization to ensure that this type of issue doesn't happen again and move forward.

1743
02:51:49.623 --> 02:52:14.289
<v Raymond C. Lee>That's typically how we would set something up like this from an administration standpoint, and we would schedule a work session or a meeting with the City Council to go through those results and then kind of say what is administration actually putting into action today and what will require some time for us to be able to put in place if it requires additional personnel or oversight from that standpoint.

1744
02:52:15.193 --> 02:52:23.789
<v Raymond C. Lee>From there, we would take direction from City Council if there's anything extra that they would like to see added to this or they have further follow-up questions.

1745
02:52:24.296 --> 02:52:28.752
<v Raymond C. Lee>As it relates to the results of the investigation.

1746
02:52:29.200 --> 02:52:33.496
<v Raymond C. Lee>But typically that would be the normal format for something like this to happen.

1747
02:52:33.850 --> 02:52:50.825
<v Raymond C. Lee>And the oversight component of it really is that oversight and council asking the questions that came out of the investigation and, you know, honestly holding the administration accountable for the things that come out of that investigation and things that we say we were gonna move forward with as an organization.

1748
02:52:50.872 --> 02:52:51.065
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

1749
02:52:51.322 --> 02:53:08.231
<v Raymond C. Lee>And having follow-up conversations with the full body of the City Council with where are we in the process of reviewing that information, implementing, uh, those recommendations, and what has been the outcomes of those, uh, results from the investigation.

1750
02:53:09.773 --> 02:53:10.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, sir.

1751
02:53:12.040 --> 02:53:12.810
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1752
02:53:13.308 --> 02:53:18.843
<v Jamie Dunphy>And just, colleagues, just to be clear, we have 10 minutes and 7 colleagues on the— 6 colleagues in the Thank you.

1753
02:53:19.727 --> 02:53:20.610
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

1754
02:53:21.269 --> 02:53:28.257
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So it's clear that we have governance work to do, ideally in a collaborative way with our city administrator.

1755
02:53:28.788 --> 02:53:34.218
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We need to explore clearer structures and systems for oversight, and that's long-term work.

1756
02:53:34.974 --> 02:53:38.363
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And as the current chair of the Governance Committee, I'm committed to doing this work.

1757
02:53:38.588 --> 02:53:40.147
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think many of my colleagues are also.

1758
02:53:41.480 --> 02:53:46.542
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And it's also clear that community right now is really confused And many of them are angry.

1759
02:53:47.120 --> 02:53:52.183
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I had a Lyft driver just tell me like, that's weird, you guys keep finding money, the other day.

1760
02:53:52.504 --> 02:53:56.879
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think it makes sense that community is confused and many are angry.

1761
02:53:57.495 --> 02:54:01.280
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Trust is eroded when we keep uncovering funds.

1762
02:54:03.075 --> 02:54:07.416
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And it's also a good thing at the end of the day to get more money than to find out we have less.

1763
02:54:09.444 --> 02:54:12.200
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And— This is also a perception thing.

1764
02:54:12.890 --> 02:54:20.215
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So the perception becomes that information that they have is incomplete or withheld, and that's not acceptable.

1765
02:54:20.263 --> 02:54:22.013
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's not what we want the public to be thinking.

1766
02:54:22.753 --> 02:54:42.799
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'll say, as someone who is oftentimes uplifting our city staff publicly, encouraging this body to be thinking about, you know, how we're speaking about staff and how we're acting, I'm oftentimes the first one to raise my hand To do work behind the scenes to be like, how can we make sure the executive branch and legislative branch are communicating well?

1767
02:54:43.247 --> 02:54:45.272
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How can I help with labor negotiations?

1768
02:54:45.336 --> 02:54:47.040
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What tours can I go on with different bureaus?

1769
02:54:47.826 --> 02:54:55.665
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think all of that I can hold true and also at the same time say that this resolution really matters to a lot of our community members.

1770
02:54:56.325 --> 02:55:00.887
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It matters because it's us plainly saying we take oversight seriously.

1771
02:55:01.305 --> 02:55:03.699
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We're responding to what the public is demanding.

1772
02:55:03.763 --> 02:55:03.875
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1773
02:55:03.971 --> 02:55:07.792
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Transparency, clarity, accountability around public dollars.

1774
02:55:08.869 --> 02:55:11.453
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And today, right now, we owe the public honesty.

1775
02:55:11.838 --> 02:55:19.577
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We owe them clear accounting of these funds, how they're being used, why they were not identified sooner, how we're going to move forward in a different way.

1776
02:55:20.092 --> 02:55:22.130
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I don't think transparency is optional.

1777
02:55:22.195 --> 02:55:23.448
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think it's our responsibility.

1778
02:55:23.897 --> 02:55:32.085
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So for me, supporting this resolution is one concrete step towards rebuilding that trust, and it doesn't replace the broader governance obligations that we have.

1779
02:55:32.134 --> 02:55:32.343
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1780
02:55:32.551 --> 02:55:38.469
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But it does demonstrate that we hear community and that we're prepared to move forward differently.

1781
02:55:39.065 --> 02:55:41.156
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1782
02:55:41.237 --> 02:55:41.941
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1783
02:55:43.956 --> 02:55:44.726
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, Mr. President.

1784
02:55:47.191 --> 02:55:49.153
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think this has been a hard topic for me.

1785
02:55:49.200 --> 02:56:01.495
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that I've been quite outspoken in previous sessions and iterations about my desire for The city to realign itself into this new form of government more quickly.

1786
02:56:01.623 --> 02:56:08.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that that has been one of the great, um, miss shots over the last 2 years.

1787
02:56:09.461 --> 02:56:17.444
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I— and so I'm weighing the forcing functions, and I think that this is one of those forcing functions.

1788
02:56:19.779 --> 02:56:21.354
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, the oversight is good.

1789
02:56:22.345 --> 02:56:24.556
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Koyama Lane brings up important points.

1790
02:56:24.637 --> 02:56:36.449
<v Eric Zimmerman>The fact The fact that we have random members of our community who are so in tune with the fact of the silliness that is the City of Portland's financial system is deeply concerning.

1791
02:56:37.681 --> 02:56:45.007
<v Eric Zimmerman>As the finance chair, I issued a letter to you and the mayor yesterday about significant, bold public change.

1792
02:56:46.388 --> 02:57:01.439
<v Eric Zimmerman>I still think that that change rests within your, as in the mayor's, Administrative purview, and you all have a duty for better communication with the council to alleviate a lot of what we're hearing today and over the last several months.

1793
02:57:03.593 --> 02:57:04.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I also—.

1794
02:57:04.960 --> 02:57:18.114
<v Eric Zimmerman>There have been a few people, and I've really appreciated my councilors' colleagues who've brought up just like, how do we encourage the culture that allows problems to be identified without people being scared of bringing problems forward?

1795
02:57:18.180 --> 02:57:18.325
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1796
02:57:18.512 --> 02:57:21.495
<v Eric Zimmerman>For me, that is foundational to this topic.

1797
02:57:22.506 --> 02:57:29.388
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in a world where I care about the realignment of the system, I want space to be able to exist for that.

1798
02:57:29.436 --> 02:57:36.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>So in one sense, it's really crummy that over the last few months we've now had a couple of times where we've, quote, found money under the cushion.

1799
02:57:37.346 --> 02:57:42.144
<v Eric Zimmerman>At the same time, the fact that all bureaus now work for the same boss is why that's happening.

1800
02:57:43.459 --> 02:57:47.763
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so That is a good thing, even though it's an embarrassing story.

1801
02:57:49.000 --> 02:57:50.172
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want more of it to happen.

1802
02:57:50.525 --> 02:57:55.793
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't hope that there are $20 million cushions, but I do expect that there are probably others.

1803
02:57:56.210 --> 02:58:04.467
<v Eric Zimmerman>That goes along with this council has clearly sent a signal to the bureaus that the carryover ideas are changing.

1804
02:58:04.739 --> 02:58:06.716
<v Eric Zimmerman>The old method is changing.

1805
02:58:07.229 --> 02:58:09.927
<v Eric Zimmerman>The clarity of your budget in this budget cycle is changing.

1806
02:58:10.040 --> 02:58:10.233
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1807
02:58:10.329 --> 02:58:12.023
<v Eric Zimmerman>Season is changing.

1808
02:58:12.604 --> 02:58:14.864
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I admit that that's going to take a while to implement.

1809
02:58:17.430 --> 02:58:24.525
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I, I think a lot about how we encourage that culture to be a thing.

1810
02:58:24.720 --> 02:58:32.613
<v Eric Zimmerman>I also don't know that this resolution will be accomplished without doing what the council president indicated about going into that line level.

1811
02:58:33.004 --> 02:58:46.157
<v Eric Zimmerman>My questions to the city attorney were, were They are quite literally my biggest concern issues around how will an employee show up if they get the, you know, the letter from the City Council.

1812
02:58:46.254 --> 02:58:48.549
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that idea to me is very concerning.

1813
02:58:48.807 --> 02:58:54.167
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that that could be a point in our existence as a body.

1814
02:58:54.762 --> 02:58:55.501
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am not there.

1815
02:58:55.886 --> 02:59:08.370
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am not to the point where I think this can only be fixed with some sort of inquiry in a public setting that I think would be detrimental to the will lead to employee-based disciplinary investigations.

1816
02:59:08.418 --> 02:59:10.552
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I have a lot of concern for that.

1817
02:59:11.354 --> 02:59:21.220
<v Eric Zimmerman>And when Councilor Green told me about this resolution, it was before the executive session, and I indicated that I was somewhat open to the idea.

1818
02:59:22.022 --> 02:59:25.986
<v Eric Zimmerman>After that executive session, I have been immediately closed to the idea.

1819
02:59:26.209 --> 02:59:39.376
<v Eric Zimmerman>The feeding frenzy that I saw happen during that executive session Is what makes me believe to my core that this would be an experience that the City Council cannot recover from.

1820
02:59:39.681 --> 02:59:52.426
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we would be well within the city's right to send a charter amendment forward to correct the City Council if we endanger, frankly, the city government with whatever this could be.

1821
02:59:53.388 --> 02:59:57.845
<v Eric Zimmerman>That feeding frenzy is not something I'm gonna support because I don't think we will stop at directors.

1822
02:59:57.941 --> 02:59:59.352
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think we will stop at DCAs.

1823
02:59:59.561 --> 03:00:06.754
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that this will do the opposite of creating a culture where it's okay to raise the flag and say, I think I've found something that was a problem.

1824
03:00:07.574 --> 03:00:17.881
<v Eric Zimmerman>It will actually say, I'm scared to death that I found something that was a problem, and I don't know how to raise it until you figure out whomever's got the best relationship to bring it forward.

1825
03:00:18.027 --> 03:00:22.763
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's not a system, that's a broken culture to me.

1826
03:00:23.486 --> 03:00:24.898
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Wilson.

1827
03:00:28.484 --> 03:00:29.786
<v Eric Zimmerman>I wish it wasn't so.

1828
03:00:30.347 --> 03:00:39.804
<v Eric Zimmerman>I also think that the mayor and the administrator do owe us some more information and more how you gonna fix it talk.

1829
03:00:40.434 --> 03:01:04.765
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I'm not to the point of being able to support this resolution today, and I hope that if this does pass, That the administration very much consider how we prepare employees before they have to come in front of this body, because I am concerned that we will, like I said, create a system that's hard to recover from.

1830
03:01:09.610 --> 03:01:13.561
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've thought through some things that I thought I might be able to propose as amendments that would change it.

1831
03:01:13.611 --> 03:01:14.923
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just don't think that that's there.

1832
03:01:14.987 --> 03:01:15.393
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think this is—.

1833
03:01:15.393 --> 03:01:15.684
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Smith.

1834
03:01:16.120 --> 03:01:24.286
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think the evidence is tenuous enough and it's live wire enough that I actually, I think it would be better for the City Council to walk away from this resolution.

1835
03:01:25.420 --> 03:01:26.900
<v Eric Zimmerman>We have shown our frustration.

1836
03:01:26.965 --> 03:01:31.296
<v Eric Zimmerman>We have shown our deep and serious misgivings about how this has occurred.

1837
03:01:32.175 --> 03:01:50.431
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I do think that what I'm hearing from the CFO, from the CBO, from the city administrator, and from the director of the Housing Bureau is that They are still figuring out what the path forward is, but that they are on the path, that they want to be on the path, and that's important.

1838
03:01:50.592 --> 03:01:57.715
<v Eric Zimmerman>If they were telling me that they think that this is a problem made up in city councilors' heads only, I'd take a different approach.

1839
03:01:57.795 --> 03:02:04.181
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I don't think that they're denying that there is a concern, and because of that, I think I've got teammates that can get us to the goal line.

1840
03:02:04.790 --> 03:02:07.597
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm not prepared to support this, and—.

1841
03:02:08.159 --> 03:02:08.656
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1842
03:02:10.005 --> 03:02:18.587
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Dunphy, I— President Dunphy, I appreciate some of the points that you brought up because, uh, you said it better, I think, in a lot of ways of where some of my great concerns exist.

1843
03:02:18.637 --> 03:02:19.136
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you.

1844
03:02:19.748 --> 03:02:20.684
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1845
03:02:20.862 --> 03:02:21.379
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1846
03:02:23.363 --> 03:02:25.494
<v Steve Novick>One of the questions this— thank you, Mr. President.

1847
03:02:25.558 --> 03:02:32.323
<v Steve Novick>One of the questions this resolution says we're going to ask is who is aware of the funds, at what point in time was each party made aware.

1848
03:02:33.433 --> 03:02:35.764
<v Steve Novick>You cannot answer that question without talking about individuals.

1849
03:02:36.724 --> 03:02:41.380
<v Steve Novick>I raised the name Helmi Historik as an example of an individual of whom that question would definitely be asked.

1850
03:02:42.584 --> 03:02:46.888
<v Steve Novick>I can name a few others of whom we would definitely be asked that question if we pass this resolution.

1851
03:02:48.220 --> 03:02:53.985
<v Steve Novick>If we pass this resolution with that question, then we'll also have to ask, what did Michael Jordan know and when did he know it?

1852
03:02:54.146 --> 03:02:55.832
<v Steve Novick>What did Donnie Oliveira know and when did he know it?

1853
03:02:55.976 --> 03:02:57.486
<v Steve Novick>What did Jonas Biery know and when did he know it?

1854
03:02:57.743 --> 03:02:59.347
<v Steve Novick>What did Keith Wilson know and when did he know it?

1855
03:02:59.925 --> 03:03:01.147
<v Steve Novick>That is not a straw man argument.

1856
03:03:01.210 --> 03:03:01.338
<v Steve Novick>Yes, it is.

1857
03:03:01.774 --> 03:03:10.331
<v Steve Novick>That is a natural, automatic consequence of passing this resolution with that question, and I think it has to be an intended consequence as well.

1858
03:03:13.040 --> 03:03:13.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1859
03:03:14.020 --> 03:03:14.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

1860
03:03:16.862 --> 03:03:21.137
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I think that's a, that's a fair point what Councilor Novick is saying here.

1861
03:03:21.409 --> 03:03:31.164
<v Sameer Kanal>I— my earlier comment was not about the bringing up of the name as a point of, of conversation, but about the idea that it's It's targeted in a punitive sense, right?

1862
03:03:31.227 --> 03:03:33.281
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's not a comment that you were making.

1863
03:03:33.328 --> 03:03:35.461
<v Sameer Kanal>I wasn't referring to your prior comment there, Councilor Novick.

1864
03:03:35.799 --> 03:03:45.871
<v Sameer Kanal>I do wanna respond to something, to the points that Councilor, the Council President raised and say that I agree with the concerns you raised, but I also think that these are not things that this document does.

1865
03:03:46.129 --> 03:03:50.105
<v Sameer Kanal>They're things that could theoretically go wrong, but which there are guardrails against.

1866
03:03:50.154 --> 03:03:56.715
<v Sameer Kanal>And unlike for the other 11 of us, actually, you are actually the guardrail in many of these particular cases as Council President.

1867
03:03:56.843 --> 03:03:56.986
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1868
03:03:57.532 --> 03:04:01.578
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's fair to say, and I'm also opposed to calling in frontline staff to testify.

1869
03:04:02.734 --> 03:04:04.291
<v Sameer Kanal>As a presiding officer, you can avoid that.

1870
03:04:04.340 --> 03:04:11.628
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we all agree that there's somewhere that there needs to be a horizontal line in the org chart below which we're not bringing in people to come in.

1871
03:04:11.981 --> 03:04:20.281
<v Sameer Kanal>We could say it's DCAs or directors or deputy directors or somewhere in there, and maybe we'd all differ on where exactly we draw it, but I think conceptually there's an agreement there.

1872
03:04:21.292 --> 03:04:23.316
<v Sameer Kanal>If that needs to be written in, we can amend that in.

1873
03:04:23.363 --> 03:04:31.907
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's fair to say that But I also think— and I also think that would resolve some of Councilor Zimmerman's question around employee protections, which by the way are good questions and worth exploring the answers to.

1874
03:04:32.356 --> 03:04:35.884
<v Sameer Kanal>Secondly, you mentioned not wanting an HR investigation into the former director.

1875
03:04:36.349 --> 03:04:38.352
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we just covered that.

1876
03:04:38.465 --> 03:04:42.135
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not part of the conversation if we need to adjust what we're talking about here.

1877
03:04:42.520 --> 03:04:50.710
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think there's a pattern that we see sometimes, and it's borne out in statistics— shout out to Rose City Reform— about whether or not we're going to just vote no.

1878
03:04:51.337 --> 03:04:54.382
<v Sameer Kanal>On something or actually try to improve it in this body.

1879
03:04:55.204 --> 03:04:59.893
<v Sameer Kanal>And if there's a concern, these seem like a relatively minor thing to adjust language on that.

1880
03:05:00.360 --> 03:05:06.191
<v Sameer Kanal>Third, you said you were worried about the body's ability to avoid crossing the lines, and this is a very long code reference.

1881
03:05:06.255 --> 03:05:10.313
<v Sameer Kanal>It's 3.02.040.b.1.b.6.

1882
03:05:11.424 --> 03:05:16.777
<v Sameer Kanal>Council President, quote, ensures councilors confine themselves to the question under debate and refrain from personal criticism.

1883
03:05:16.825 --> 03:05:17.022
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1884
03:05:17.413 --> 03:05:17.685
<v Sameer Kanal>End quote.

1885
03:05:17.750 --> 03:05:20.691
<v Sameer Kanal>So in that case, you are also the guardrail if you're presiding over this.

1886
03:05:21.414 --> 03:05:28.997
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll also note that you said that you'd prefer to hire a private investigator to present this information, and that could be someone that we could grill in that capacity.

1887
03:05:29.063 --> 03:05:30.171
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with that preference.

1888
03:05:30.734 --> 03:05:35.425
<v Sameer Kanal>I also agree with your assessment that we don't have the money budgeted for it, uh, or the time by March 6th.

1889
03:05:35.810 --> 03:05:44.250
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we don't need the perfect to be the enemy of the good, and we can— if this process continues or if there are future oversight Hearings, we might need to talk about.

1890
03:05:44.395 --> 03:05:46.665
<v Sameer Kanal>I think the time constraint would be resolved by that.

1891
03:05:47.084 --> 03:06:00.501
<v Sameer Kanal>But philosophically, we can't have oversight require us, especially of lost or found money, require us to find more money to use for the oversight, because otherwise we won't have the— we'll never use this piece of the charter.

1892
03:06:01.141 --> 03:06:10.468
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I think that that's not just about the, the big picture of hearings, which I, by the way, agree with, uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney about not wanting this to be like Congress.

1893
03:06:10.516 --> 03:06:10.565
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

1894
03:06:11.879 --> 03:06:17.605
<v Sameer Kanal>But about even the sort of midpoint of that formal to informal scale that Councilor Green is talking about.

1895
03:06:17.670 --> 03:06:22.290
<v Sameer Kanal>So I guess what I'm trying to say is there are theoretical things that could go wrong.

1896
03:06:23.269 --> 03:06:28.081
<v Sameer Kanal>And there's a question of how speculate— how each of us speculates whether they would or wouldn't.

1897
03:06:28.402 --> 03:06:49.925
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think I have faith that whoever is presiding over this, if brought in early by the council president, or if it is the council president, as it would be in this case, case, would have a knowledge of what the things we're trying to avoid are and would have the empowerment under the structures that we have and the rules that we already have to exercise that authority and avoid those problems.

1898
03:06:50.311 --> 03:06:50.487
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1899
03:06:50.873 --> 03:06:52.093
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1900
03:06:52.254 --> 03:06:53.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, it is 12:33.

1901
03:06:54.004 --> 03:07:02.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have asked our staff to stay a little long so we can finish this item, and I am desperate to try and get the appointments that were pulled from the agenda also done today.

1902
03:07:02.772 --> 03:07:05.545
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will not be hearing our item on the ABC code.

1903
03:07:06.041 --> 03:07:08.061
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will be having that first thing tomorrow.

1904
03:07:09.023 --> 03:07:10.353
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1905
03:07:11.427 --> 03:07:13.753
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

1906
03:07:13.977 --> 03:07:20.052
<v Loretta Smith>I was thinking about some of the things that the council, former council president said, and Council Zimmerman.

1907
03:07:20.549 --> 03:07:28.805
<v Loretta Smith>I think we can, you know, call upon the administration and the mayor to look into this because we haven't done that.

1908
03:07:29.381 --> 03:07:35.168
<v Loretta Smith>We haven't asked them to do anything, and so we need to give them an opportunity.

1909
03:07:35.233 --> 03:07:47.399
<v Loretta Smith>And they haven't spoken out about this yet, about the $21 million, and I think we need to give them the opportunity to correct this and give us an understanding of what's happening and what's, what's going to happen going forward.

1910
03:07:47.977 --> 03:07:52.322
<v Loretta Smith>But I don't know that I will be voting in support of this.

1911
03:07:52.450 --> 03:08:05.358
<v Loretta Smith>I am a big proponent of oversight, but I think until we actually get some rules of engagement at oversight, I don't want to put this out there yet.

1912
03:08:06.100 --> 03:08:06.295
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1913
03:08:07.176 --> 03:08:07.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1914
03:08:08.189 --> 03:08:09.038
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1915
03:08:10.130 --> 03:08:11.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1916
03:08:14.739 --> 03:08:16.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, may I ask a question of the city administrator?

1917
03:08:16.523 --> 03:08:17.070
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

1918
03:08:18.147 --> 03:08:24.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>City Administrator Lee, there are a number of pieces of information that this resolution asks you to produce.

1919
03:08:25.325 --> 03:08:29.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Presumably, you know what those all are, where they lie.

1920
03:08:30.263 --> 03:08:32.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We could get to them rather quickly.

1921
03:08:33.837 --> 03:08:40.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we were to ask for those pieces of information outside of this resolution, would your intent be to get those to us in a timely fashion?

1922
03:08:41.906 --> 03:08:42.790
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes, it would be.

1923
03:08:42.888 --> 03:08:55.640
<v Raymond C. Lee>And it may be one of those situations I feed you information as I get it, because even within, you know, a normal Open records requests, we would have a certain amount of time to get information in.

1924
03:08:56.058 --> 03:09:01.934
<v Raymond C. Lee>But that's also taken into consideration where those different outlets of information may be coming from.

1925
03:09:02.400 --> 03:09:13.865
<v Raymond C. Lee>If we're looking at personal devices where we have to go through people's hard drives, and once we figure out who all hard drives we have to go through, that may extend some of that timeframe to get that information.

1926
03:09:14.218 --> 03:09:17.287
<v Raymond C. Lee>But we would start sending those batches of information over.

1927
03:09:17.334 --> 03:09:17.495
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

1928
03:09:17.817 --> 03:09:28.103
<v Raymond C. Lee>As we got them, and it may extend past that normal timeframe, but we will still— it'll really depend on where we're trying to gather that information from.

1929
03:09:28.748 --> 03:09:32.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If this doesn't pass today, I don't know what the vote count is.

1930
03:09:32.462 --> 03:09:38.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If this doesn't pass today, would you be willing to still get us this information by February 20th?

1931
03:09:40.010 --> 03:09:41.788
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes, I will still be committed to doing that.

1932
03:09:42.097 --> 03:09:42.488
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1933
03:09:44.493 --> 03:09:48.353
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not sure if our CFO is still in the room.

1934
03:09:48.739 --> 03:09:49.207
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes, he is.

1935
03:09:49.334 --> 03:09:51.556
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was hoping— do you mind if we call him up?

1936
03:09:51.652 --> 03:09:51.941
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please.

1937
03:09:52.296 --> 03:09:53.197
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1938
03:09:55.770 --> 03:09:56.658
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome back, Jonas.

1939
03:09:58.632 --> 03:10:11.625
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Biery, are the funds— not the $20.7 million, but the more recent funds that you've shared some information with us about.

1940
03:10:12.349 --> 03:10:18.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are any of those funds eligible for use for paying for an outside auditor?

1941
03:10:20.391 --> 03:10:22.496
<v Jonas Biery>Again, for the record, Jonas Biery, Chief Financial Officer.

1942
03:10:22.545 --> 03:10:23.750
<v Jonas Biery>That's a great question, Councilor.

1943
03:10:23.926 --> 03:10:24.584
<v Jonas Biery>I don't know.

1944
03:10:24.648 --> 03:10:28.441
<v Jonas Biery>We're doing due diligence on the flexibility around those other funds.

1945
03:10:28.488 --> 03:10:31.325
<v Jonas Biery>That's one of the outstanding questions we want to get pinned down before we get back to you.

1946
03:10:31.406 --> 03:10:38.304
<v Jonas Biery>But I will add that to the list of due diligence, and that information will be returning to you ASAP this week.

1947
03:10:38.865 --> 03:10:39.105
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1948
03:10:39.265 --> 03:10:43.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think the council president said that an audit would be somewhere between $50,000 and $100,000.

1949
03:10:43.740 --> 03:10:44.718
<v Jamie Dunphy>I was looking at an investigator.

1950
03:10:45.103 --> 03:10:45.825
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or an investigator.

1951
03:10:45.922 --> 03:10:46.082
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

1952
03:10:46.628 --> 03:10:51.968
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, is that about the amount, City Administrator, that you would expect to pay if we asked for an audit?

1953
03:10:52.881 --> 03:10:54.037
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes, for an audit itself.

1954
03:10:54.165 --> 03:10:57.966
<v Raymond C. Lee>Investigation may vary depending on the attorney that we use and their hourly rate.

1955
03:10:58.495 --> 03:11:04.318
<v Raymond C. Lee>Uh, that may vary, but if you're looking at an actual audit of it, That's, that's close to it.

1956
03:11:04.944 --> 03:11:05.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1957
03:11:05.475 --> 03:11:21.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And do we have— I was thinking, I'm sorry, about those newly discussed funds because they are related to what we're talking about here and presumably, though we're still waiting to find out, not fully allocated to other uses.

1958
03:11:22.029 --> 03:11:28.354
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If those funds weren't available, are there other funds that would be available for an audit like this, Mr. City Administrator or Mr. CFO?

1959
03:11:28.996 --> 03:11:30.986
<v Raymond C. Lee>I would say we'd have to find the funds to do that.

1960
03:11:31.243 --> 03:11:39.793
<v Raymond C. Lee>And that's something that we've already had conversations about moving down that direction and really trying to find funds that we could earmark for a project like this.

1961
03:11:40.307 --> 03:11:54.457
<v Raymond C. Lee>And it goes into a bigger question of us looking holistically at our system of our different financial funds that we have and ensuring that we have a schedule of how we may be looking at evaluating and auditing those funds as well.

1962
03:11:54.521 --> 03:11:54.617
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1963
03:11:55.146 --> 03:11:55.578
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Understood.

1964
03:11:55.628 --> 03:12:06.805
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think what I'm hearing is probably we could find it, but you can't give me a guarantee today that those funds or any others would be available, which I was hoping we would have something a little bit stronger than that.

1965
03:12:06.869 --> 03:12:10.798
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I, I'm hearing a lean yes, but not a for sure yes, I think.

1966
03:12:11.343 --> 03:12:25.950
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think when we look at the questions that are being asked of this city, we have to be able to find those funds to be able to do that, to bring back the credibility and trust from the public as it relates to how these dollars are being expensed.

1967
03:12:26.174 --> 03:12:30.998
<v Raymond C. Lee>And we have to be able to find those funds to be able to do that due diligence.

1968
03:12:31.720 --> 03:12:32.120
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1969
03:12:32.505 --> 03:12:33.579
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And thank you, Mr. CFO.

1970
03:12:35.070 --> 03:12:42.316
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, part of our public meetings law means that we don't always get to iterate before we're up here.

1971
03:12:42.379 --> 03:12:43.663
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't always know where people are.

1972
03:12:43.743 --> 03:12:59.075
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And sometimes that means we inadvertently are forced into a position of putting our colleagues I share all of the concerns that you mentioned about how this process would go.

1973
03:12:59.621 --> 03:13:01.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You said it, I think, much more succinctly than I did.

1974
03:13:02.513 --> 03:13:10.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while I, I know that some of our colleagues have said you can prevent that, I also, having presided over this body, know that you can't always prevent that with this body.

1975
03:13:12.274 --> 03:13:13.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I heard you say that you would prefer an audit.

1976
03:13:13.647 --> 03:13:13.939
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would prefer an audit.

1977
03:13:15.699 --> 03:13:36.047
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you would truly prefer an audit, I am offering to work with you and our administration to find the funds for an audit, perhaps pause this process and give the opportunity for us to figure out if we can use some of those housing dollars to do this differently.

1978
03:13:36.502 --> 03:13:55.049
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't mean to put you on the spot, but we don't have other opportunities to hear each And before you answer, Council President, I just want to say that I was going to make a case about why it's important for the council body to use our powers for this specifically, if you'd like to hear that before making an answer.

1979
03:13:55.433 --> 03:14:03.176
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will just respond very briefly by saying I am intent on getting this information out in a way that the public can have it.

1980
03:14:04.572 --> 03:14:06.575
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am indifferent to the vehicle that it takes.

1981
03:14:07.472 --> 03:14:20.691
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am inclined to support my colleagues at this point, but I have deep concerns about not only the things that I raised, but also my ability to prevent some of those lines from being crossed, candidly.

1982
03:14:21.653 --> 03:14:26.972
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, I don't think we have time for amendments right now.

1983
03:14:27.181 --> 03:14:27.742
<v Jamie Dunphy>Probably not.

1984
03:14:27.983 --> 03:14:49.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we did, I might propose that we take the body's temperature by voting on an amendment I don't know where people would be about keeping the information gathering pieces in here, removing the last resolved with the hearing, and instead saying, be it further resolved that the city administrator identify funds for an audit no later than X date.

1985
03:14:49.656 --> 03:14:53.893
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think we have time for that right now, so I'm not going to propose that.

1986
03:14:53.972 --> 03:15:02.014
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if there is a way to have more time for this, I don't know what the body's temperature would be on something like Thank you.

1987
03:15:02.962 --> 03:15:04.551
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

1988
03:15:05.129 --> 03:15:06.157
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1989
03:15:07.218 --> 03:15:13.334
<v Angelita Morillo>I fear that this body is going to engage in a dereliction of our duties out of fear of not being Portland polite.

1990
03:15:14.282 --> 03:15:25.264
<v Angelita Morillo>That's what I'm hearing right now, because the charter inherently gives us the power to do investigative oversight, and I don't know why there is such immense queasiness about using the powers of the charter to do that.

1991
03:15:25.505 --> 03:15:31.123
<v Angelita Morillo>That the charter has delegated to us to do the work that we were elected to do.

1992
03:15:31.798 --> 03:15:53.659
<v Angelita Morillo>Section 2-109, titled Investigations, says that in aid of its legislative function, the council or a committee of the council duly authorized by it may investigate any board or department of the city government and the official acts and conduct of any city officer, employee, or agent, and for the purpose of ascertaining It goes on.

1993
03:15:53.756 --> 03:15:54.703
<v Angelita Morillo>I won't read the whole thing.

1994
03:15:55.362 --> 03:16:01.468
<v Angelita Morillo>That is our authority under charter, which the public voted for and that we were elected to do.

1995
03:16:01.725 --> 03:16:05.916
<v Angelita Morillo>So we can be fact gatherers and finders.

1996
03:16:06.126 --> 03:16:18.207
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think the fact that we are terrified of having to find $100,000 to find an independent investigator means that we don't have money, which means that it's even more important that we have the authority to do that.

1997
03:16:18.271 --> 03:16:18.463
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1998
03:16:18.399 --> 03:16:18.448
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1999
03:16:18.512 --> 03:16:24.520
<v Angelita Morillo>That when $40 million goes missing and then we find it, that we figure out how the heck that happened.

2000
03:16:24.856 --> 03:16:35.448
<v Angelita Morillo>No, $100,000 should be a drop in the bucket in a multi-billion dollar budget, or in a billion dollar budget, but it's not because we are in such dire straits.

2001
03:16:36.217 --> 03:16:45.367
<v Angelita Morillo>So while there is space for us to hire a third party to do some of this work, the charter actually asks us to exercise that muscle.

2002
03:16:45.495 --> 03:16:48.049
<v Angelita Morillo>It asks us to become experts in this process.

2003
03:16:49.029 --> 03:17:02.429
<v Angelita Morillo>We have an opportunity to strengthen our authority, our information gathering, our ability to serve the public transparently, and we are just choosing to abdicate that duty because it is uncomfortable, is what I'm hearing.

2004
03:17:03.649 --> 03:17:21.094
<v Angelita Morillo>And we are in an inherently uncomfortable role in what is possibly the most uncomfortable time to be a representative of the public So we have to lean into our authority, our duty to look into this and establish the facts.

2005
03:17:21.783 --> 03:17:28.917
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that there is an inherent hypocrisy too, that we should look into this.

2006
03:17:30.137 --> 03:17:32.750
<v Angelita Morillo>The accusation about personalities was thrown in.

2007
03:17:32.845 --> 03:17:34.176
<v Angelita Morillo>I have no idea what that's all about.

2008
03:17:34.465 --> 03:17:52.871
<v Angelita Morillo>What I know is that my constituents are also asking me, And we cannot allow Portland polite and our queasiness and discomfort over what is a very concerning situation to prevent us from doing our duties.

2009
03:17:53.565 --> 03:17:59.575
<v Angelita Morillo>So the charter outlines this very clearly, and we have a responsibility to vote and do this.

2010
03:18:00.179 --> 03:18:03.536
<v Angelita Morillo>The administration has already stated that they can do this.

2011
03:18:03.602 --> 03:18:03.977
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilwoman?

2012
03:18:05.092 --> 03:18:08.316
<v Angelita Morillo>And we have a responsibility to act in response.

2013
03:18:09.093 --> 03:18:11.590
<v Angelita Morillo>So I really hope that this goes through today.

2014
03:18:12.129 --> 03:18:23.521
<v Angelita Morillo>I hope that we will shorten our discussion and that we will move to a vote to get this, get the ball rolling on this, because we cannot keep waiting when we are in, we're already in budget season.

2015
03:18:25.209 --> 03:18:50.284
<v Angelita Morillo>We are about to have community listening sessions where we are going to have the community come and test We owe it to them to tell them how we plan to be responsible with their dollars, and we also have to have an expectation that high-level, high-ranking city employees who are in charge of these funds are also responsible for those dollars.

2016
03:18:50.640 --> 03:18:51.788
<v Angelita Morillo>That is not a witch hunt.

2017
03:18:52.175 --> 03:18:55.521
<v Angelita Morillo>That is the basic responsibility of your job as a public servant to be accountable to the people of Portland.

2018
03:18:55.568 --> 03:18:55.715
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2019
03:18:59.755 --> 03:19:03.236
<v Angelita Morillo>We have a high threshold of responsibility that we owe to the public.

2020
03:19:03.846 --> 03:19:06.461
<v Angelita Morillo>And this to me is purely fact-finding.

2021
03:19:06.751 --> 03:19:07.969
<v Angelita Morillo>We need to know what happened.

2022
03:19:08.675 --> 03:19:21.477
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm going to emphasize again, if Councilor Green has brought up alternatives, was asking questions during executive session, and he was told to stand down and not ask those questions, and then he is bringing forward a proposal that allows us to ask these questions, I think that's a good thing.

2023
03:19:21.542 --> 03:19:21.686
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2024
03:19:22.072 --> 03:19:34.260
<v Angelita Morillo>In the ways that we were told we have to, and now we are being told we can't do that again, then how exactly are we as a legislative body supposed to get the answers we need about the budget to make decisions on behalf of the public?

2025
03:19:34.644 --> 03:19:37.995
<v Angelita Morillo>I cannot vote on a budget without all of this information.

2026
03:19:39.150 --> 03:19:48.019
<v Angelita Morillo>So do not engage in a dereliction of your duty because of Portland polite discomfort around finding $40 million under the couch cushions.

2027
03:19:48.083 --> 03:19:48.259
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

2028
03:19:48.995 --> 03:19:50.777
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

2029
03:19:50.858 --> 03:19:51.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

2030
03:19:53.450 --> 03:19:54.212
<v Mitch Green>Colleagues, I'll be brief.

2031
03:19:56.125 --> 03:19:57.307
<v Mitch Green>I just want to make 2 points here.

2032
03:19:59.200 --> 03:20:27.986
<v Mitch Green>The suggestion that we should rely upon an independent investigator or auditor, I understand the appeal, but frankly, that's the approach we took last year when we approached the Zenith oversight question, because I think at that time, even I was a little bit apprehensive about making a decision about whether or not we should Invoking the Section 2, 109 sections of the charter that put council into a formal oversight capacity, especially when we're such— so new as a body.

2033
03:20:28.050 --> 03:20:31.566
<v Mitch Green>And so what we did as a compromise, we said, well, we'll have the city do this.

2034
03:20:32.190 --> 03:20:34.799
<v Mitch Green>We'll trust that the city administrator can set this up.

2035
03:20:35.587 --> 03:20:37.134
<v Mitch Green>And they set that up.

2036
03:20:37.440 --> 03:20:54.146
<v Mitch Green>And if we found that there were conflicts of interest inside of that own determination, And so at, at the suggestion of myself and Councilor Murillo, who were the carriers of this resolution primarily, uh, the mayor said, okay, fine, I think it's a good idea actually to find some money for an independent investigator.

2037
03:20:54.771 --> 03:20:56.822
<v Mitch Green>That's still underway, and that's not even done.

2038
03:20:57.558 --> 03:21:07.076
<v Mitch Green>And so I think what's going to happen here, colleagues, if we don't pass this and we say, well, we'll maybe do it down the road with an independent investigator, is it will take us many months to identify the money.

2039
03:21:07.750 --> 03:21:11.278
<v Mitch Green>It will take us Maybe as long as that to identify a contractor.

2040
03:21:11.983 --> 03:21:13.795
<v Mitch Green>It will take us a long time to get through procurement.

2041
03:21:13.843 --> 03:21:20.817
<v Mitch Green>And by the time that we have signed a contract to do whatever that investigation looks like with a scope, we will be past the next budget.

2042
03:21:21.844 --> 03:21:29.284
<v Mitch Green>We will have gone through a budget setting crisis where— a process where we will have to have closed $120 million of a deficit.

2043
03:21:30.600 --> 03:21:31.465
<v Mitch Green>So those are the stakes.

2044
03:21:31.865 --> 03:21:44.837
<v Mitch Green>And I think that— I think if we don't pass this today, I hope you're all prepared to go out and talk to your constituents and the public and say, I didn't think it was necessary to step into our oversight power on this one.

2045
03:21:44.966 --> 03:21:47.922
<v Mitch Green>I'm just going to go ahead and say this is behind us.

2046
03:21:48.515 --> 03:21:49.334
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to trust us.

2047
03:21:50.090 --> 03:21:51.198
<v Mitch Green>It's just $21 million.

2048
03:21:52.049 --> 03:21:53.190
<v Mitch Green>It's not that big of a deal.

2049
03:21:53.318 --> 03:21:54.652
<v Mitch Green>Let's just move forward.

2050
03:21:55.085 --> 03:21:56.900
<v Mitch Green>We can figure out how to deal with it the next time.

2051
03:21:56.996 --> 03:22:00.242
<v Mitch Green>Because I don't think for the public there's a next time on trust.

2052
03:22:00.547 --> 03:22:01.093
<v Mitch Green>I really don't.

2053
03:22:01.173 --> 03:22:17.600
<v Mitch Green>I think that we've lost And, you know, on the question of creating a culture, making sure we don't create a culture of fear, I'm actually really worried that there's already a culture of fear inside of the city executive apparatus all the way down to the rank and file.

2054
03:22:18.260 --> 03:22:26.936
<v Mitch Green>What I hope that this process is able to daylight is whether or not individual employees were ever told that they shouldn't bring information to the mayor.

2055
03:22:26.985 --> 03:22:27.514
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a fair question.

2056
03:22:27.641 --> 03:22:32.807
<v Mitch Green>Council were ever told that they shouldn't communicate something that they found because it might be embarrassing for the city.

2057
03:22:33.844 --> 03:22:40.541
<v Mitch Green>We have one person's account saying that that's what she was told, but I don't know if that's true because I haven't seen the full record.

2058
03:22:41.025 --> 03:22:52.138
<v Mitch Green>And until we're willing to go and engage in that record, we're going to, we're going to continue to have lingering out there a suggestion by a former bureau director saying, I was told not to tell council about this because it's bad PR.

2059
03:22:52.898 --> 03:22:59.003
<v Mitch Green>And colleagues, if we're going to let that stand, Without looking at the record ourselves and saying, you know what, that's actually a misstatement.

2060
03:23:00.379 --> 03:23:03.114
<v Mitch Green>At no point were staff ever told to keep this quiet.

2061
03:23:04.096 --> 03:23:11.587
<v Mitch Green>Then what we were basically accepting is to say that that sort of suggestion is completely acceptable in this city.

2062
03:23:11.828 --> 03:23:12.440
<v Mitch Green>And I don't think it is.

2063
03:23:13.523 --> 03:23:22.743
<v Mitch Green>So I'm very concerned that we're not going to pass this and that 6 months from now we're going to have a city government that's going to say, Great.

2064
03:23:22.888 --> 03:23:38.927
<v Mitch Green>You're adopting a new budget and you never dealt with the prior lapse in the previous budget, and you never dealt with the fact that during the mid-year budget adjustment process, you thought it was acceptable to not be told about $21 million, or at least $12 million during that.

2065
03:23:39.774 --> 03:23:41.006
<v Mitch Green>So those are the stakes, colleagues.

2066
03:23:41.282 --> 03:23:46.145
<v Mitch Green>We can't outsource our duty to some third-party private contractor.

2067
03:23:46.452 --> 03:23:47.149
<v Mitch Green>We have to do this ourselves.

2068
03:23:47.199 --> 03:23:47.296
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

2069
03:23:47.777 --> 03:23:48.933
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

2070
03:23:48.997 --> 03:23:49.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

2071
03:23:51.086 --> 03:23:53.513
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, I'm sorry, I know you're trying to wrap us up.

2072
03:23:53.737 --> 03:23:55.715
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Since I last spoke, 2 things happened.

2073
03:23:55.907 --> 03:24:02.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>One is I was told by one of my colleagues that if we don't pass this, we are saying we can't ask questions and derelicting our duties.

2074
03:24:02.399 --> 03:24:08.297
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I wanna be really clear that I think there are a lot of different ways that oversight can be done.

2075
03:24:09.004 --> 03:24:11.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are ways that I think oversight should have been done this year.

2076
03:24:13.325 --> 03:24:16.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That nobody with a gavel did, a committee gavel.

2077
03:24:18.325 --> 03:24:27.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I don't appreciate being told at the dais that we are derelicting duties if we have different views on how oversight should happen.

2078
03:24:27.507 --> 03:24:32.556
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I've also heard a desperation to use a specific type of oversight that makes me really uncomfortable.

2079
03:24:33.292 --> 03:24:38.148
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The second thing that happened is that the city administrator said to me there are funds available if we want to do an investigation.

2080
03:24:38.261 --> 03:24:38.629
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a good thing.

2081
03:24:38.968 --> 03:24:47.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or some sort of audit that's within our ability as the administrative and the legislative branches and doesn't step on the toes of the auditor.

2082
03:24:48.097 --> 03:24:49.347
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think there are ways we can do that.

2083
03:24:50.064 --> 03:24:56.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I apologize, Mr. President, but I am going to propose an amendment to see where council is at.

2084
03:24:56.868 --> 03:25:27.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I would propose that we delete the final be it resolved And replace it with language that says, be it resolved that council directs the city administrator to begin an investigation or audit of finances at the Portland Housing Bureau so that we have full information along with the records that have been requested.

2085
03:25:30.132 --> 03:25:31.201
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would entertain a second.

2086
03:25:32.020 --> 03:25:34.522
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's been an amendment moved by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

2087
03:25:34.570 --> 03:25:35.156
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there a second?

2088
03:25:37.317 --> 03:25:37.787
<v Steve Novick>Second.

2089
03:25:39.176 --> 03:25:40.971
<v Jamie Dunphy>Second from Councilor Novick by a hair.

2090
03:25:43.024 --> 03:25:45.305
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, discussion on the amendment?

2091
03:25:46.547 --> 03:25:47.898
<v Jamie Dunphy>Folks in the queue to the amendment?

2092
03:25:48.156 --> 03:25:48.784
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

2093
03:25:50.587 --> 03:25:56.029
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I guess I was in the queue to talk about this idea of an audit and then it became relevant to the amendment.

2094
03:25:57.095 --> 03:25:59.441
<v Sameer Kanal>Has anyone talked to the auditor?

2095
03:25:59.602 --> 03:26:07.310
<v Sameer Kanal>Because given that Councilor Green brought up the Zenith resolution, that was a conversation that happened in the Zenith resolution as we use the word audit.

2096
03:26:07.775 --> 03:26:14.087
<v Sameer Kanal>And we do have a 14th elected official in this government that we don't talk enough about and the importance of that role.

2097
03:26:14.682 --> 03:26:16.626
<v Sameer Kanal>But she said no.

2098
03:26:17.027 --> 03:26:19.003
<v Sameer Kanal>She said no in Zenith, or she said no about this one?

2099
03:26:19.596 --> 03:26:20.094
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

2100
03:26:20.143 --> 03:26:25.860
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so I, I don't, I don't know if anyone's asked her on this one, and, and I think She had the right to say no, by the way.

2101
03:26:26.566 --> 03:26:29.699
<v Sameer Kanal>That's written into the charter, the way we've set up our government.

2102
03:26:30.662 --> 03:26:35.224
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I think that that might be— it's possible that that would happen again.

2103
03:26:35.272 --> 03:26:39.944
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't want to speak for the auditor, but I don't think anyone should until we've asked that office.

2104
03:26:40.411 --> 03:26:42.257
<v Sameer Kanal>So I don't support that.

2105
03:26:42.322 --> 03:26:48.103
<v Sameer Kanal>And the other piece of it, again, because Councilor Green brought up the Zenith resolution, is that that hasn't happened yet.

2106
03:26:48.344 --> 03:26:50.400
<v Sameer Kanal>And so it's not that I don't think that I do.

2107
03:26:50.931 --> 03:27:03.045
<v Sameer Kanal>It's that the idea of replacing it with— sorry, replacing the final be it further resolved with that seems to me to leave a pretty big gap.

2108
03:27:03.993 --> 03:27:16.668
<v Sameer Kanal>And I will say that I'm open to a later, outside the scope of this document conversation about how oversight could be done in the committee context, but it will require council president saying yes to that.

2109
03:27:16.750 --> 03:27:18.769
<v Sameer Kanal>To request for more time when those come up.

2110
03:27:19.426 --> 03:27:23.370
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's a thing that just hasn't been— that hasn't happened so far.

2111
03:27:23.450 --> 03:27:29.397
<v Sameer Kanal>So I would love to have that conversation outside of the scope of this document, hopefully after we pass this document.

2112
03:27:30.070 --> 03:27:30.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

2113
03:27:30.888 --> 03:27:33.292
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo, to the amendment.

2114
03:27:33.532 --> 03:27:33.870
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2115
03:27:34.719 --> 03:27:41.725
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm going to be honest, I have no idea what casual oversight means because that is not defined.

2116
03:27:41.789 --> 03:27:43.264
<v Angelita Morillo>That means you could ask a question Thank you.

2117
03:27:43.313 --> 03:27:45.683
<v Angelita Morillo>You can ask a question, maybe you'll get an answer, maybe you won't.

2118
03:27:46.360 --> 03:27:49.036
<v Angelita Morillo>Maybe there will be proof of that answer, maybe there won't be.

2119
03:27:49.665 --> 03:27:50.842
<v Angelita Morillo>That doesn't mean anything.

2120
03:27:51.579 --> 03:27:56.593
<v Angelita Morillo>What does mean something is the power that is outlined for us in the charter about what council can do.

2121
03:27:57.191 --> 03:28:02.465
<v Angelita Morillo>And we do not have to continuously outsource our legislative power to somebody else.

2122
03:28:04.405 --> 03:28:06.281
<v Angelita Morillo>City Administrator, I think you are fabulous.

2123
03:28:06.653 --> 03:28:09.514
<v Angelita Morillo>I fully trust that you would carry this out extremely well.

2124
03:28:09.725 --> 03:28:10.274
<v Angelita Morillo>There is no question about that.

2125
03:28:12.063 --> 03:28:21.444
<v Angelita Morillo>The question is why my colleagues feel like we shouldn't do what is, again, explicitly within our power to do when it applies to the entire city.

2126
03:28:22.505 --> 03:28:28.643
<v Angelita Morillo>The reason this should not just go to a committee with 5 people is because we are the budget authority.

2127
03:28:29.334 --> 03:28:31.855
<v Angelita Morillo>We have the power of the purse, all of us.

2128
03:28:32.563 --> 03:28:34.620
<v Angelita Morillo>There is $40 million on the line.

2129
03:28:34.667 --> 03:28:36.338
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't, I don't understand why we shouldn't be able to do this.

2130
03:28:36.434 --> 03:28:36.949
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Loretta Smith.

2131
03:28:37.046 --> 03:28:44.628
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't understand how this is not a matter of urgency for my colleagues when we keep telling the public that we have to cut things.

2132
03:28:47.030 --> 03:29:17.939
<v Angelita Morillo>It is a dereliction of our duty as the people who have the power of the purse, as the people who are outlined to do investigations, as the people who are answerable to our districts and to our constituents when that parks bathroom gets cut, when we have less police officers on our streets, when we have to close parks, when we have to close libraries, when we have to close If we are scrounging for the thought of getting $100,000 for an independent investigation, then we have even more of a responsibility to figure out where that money went.

2133
03:29:18.486 --> 03:29:24.574
<v Angelita Morillo>So we need to direct the collection of information and the conversation surrounding it.

2134
03:29:26.164 --> 03:29:30.007
<v Angelita Morillo>It's great if the administration and the executive side want to provide information to us, but we need to be able to ask for it.

2135
03:29:30.056 --> 03:29:30.347
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Smith.

2136
03:29:30.556 --> 03:29:30.603
<v Angelita Morillo>Us.

2137
03:29:30.731 --> 03:29:31.388
<v Angelita Morillo>That's wonderful.

2138
03:29:31.452 --> 03:29:33.135
<v Angelita Morillo>Having a fluid conversation is great.

2139
03:29:33.680 --> 03:29:45.778
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, but this is for the benefit of the public, and I genuinely feel that, uh, there is a crisis happening right now for our institutional legitimacy as a newly founded council.

2140
03:29:46.434 --> 03:29:47.780
<v Angelita Morillo>We are a year into this.

2141
03:29:48.277 --> 03:29:53.324
<v Angelita Morillo>It is time to exercise our muscles, and that muscle also includes oversight.

2142
03:29:53.980 --> 03:29:58.485
<v Angelita Morillo>So, um, I don't think doing this more casually Councilor Smith.

2143
03:29:58.549 --> 03:29:59.575
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that a timely response is beneficial at this time.

2144
03:29:59.640 --> 03:30:11.860
<v Angelita Morillo>We have seen what a casual response gets us, and a casual response gets us a few months down the line finding another roughly $15 to $20 million that we have no idea where it was spent.

2145
03:30:13.064 --> 03:30:18.009
<v Angelita Morillo>That's not— that is not any way for us to be able to make budget decisions in the months to come.

2146
03:30:18.058 --> 03:30:19.068
<v Angelita Morillo>It's just not possible.

2147
03:30:19.904 --> 03:30:23.211
<v Angelita Morillo>So I really hope that we will vote this through today.

2148
03:30:23.902 --> 03:30:24.993
<v Angelita Morillo>We need the hearing.

2149
03:30:25.185 --> 03:30:26.998
<v Angelita Morillo>We need public information.

2150
03:30:27.817 --> 03:30:38.280
<v Angelita Morillo>We need all of this to be cleared up, and we should make no assumptions as a legislative body who will be reviewing the information that comes before us before it comes to us.

2151
03:30:38.825 --> 03:30:44.570
<v Angelita Morillo>But when that information comes to us, then we will have to make decisions.

2152
03:30:44.827 --> 03:30:53.717
<v Angelita Morillo>There will be authority about what happens, and we are representatives of the public, of the people, who are giving us their tax dollars first and foremost.

2153
03:30:54.245 --> 03:31:03.068
<v Angelita Morillo>So I really hope that this council will take the oversight of these dollars more seriously, and it's not something that can be casual, and it's not something that can be done in committee.

2154
03:31:03.213 --> 03:31:04.897
<v Angelita Morillo>It has to be done with the entire council.

2155
03:31:05.042 --> 03:31:07.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Maria.

2156
03:31:08.362 --> 03:31:15.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator, I didn't put my hand up in the queue, but I was intending to ask to this amendment specifically.

2157
03:31:15.790 --> 03:31:21.421
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could you give me a little clearer— could you clarify for us Uh, about timing, costs, uh, available expenses, etc.?

2158
03:31:22.288 --> 03:31:36.355
<v Raymond C. Lee>From a timing perspective, we can run this pretty quickly, and we could run on a contract through our City Attorney's Office to get this done, uh, faster than our normal typical procurement process that we would take this through.

2159
03:31:37.046 --> 03:31:39.260
<v Raymond C. Lee>From a financial standpoint, not sure.

2160
03:31:39.371 --> 03:31:52.911
<v Raymond C. Lee>It depends on the company that we choose, uh, but there is money, uh, through the city and Potentially could be the Housing Bureau that we could use to actually do this audit or investigation of these funds.

2161
03:31:53.327 --> 03:32:11.039
<v Raymond C. Lee>And what I would also say to the City Council as well, we still have the option to coming back to this full body once this audit and report is done and report back to this full body the results of the audit or the investigation.

2162
03:32:11.311 --> 03:32:17.997
<v Raymond C. Lee>So you can— everyone in this council can have that information and it can be discussed in an open forum as well.

2163
03:32:18.447 --> 03:32:30.969
<v Raymond C. Lee>There may be some attorney-client privilege in this, and our city attorney will navigate us through that component of it if we need to go into any executive session to discuss a component of it that is attorney-client privilege.

2164
03:32:31.434 --> 03:32:38.619
<v Raymond C. Lee>But my objective in this would be to come back to the full council to debrief them on the results of the audit and investigation.

2165
03:32:38.666 --> 03:32:38.795
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

2166
03:32:40.938 --> 03:32:41.584
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, sir.

2167
03:32:43.281 --> 03:32:43.815
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

2168
03:32:51.036 --> 03:32:57.915
<v Loretta Smith>Um, Councilor Murillo, you gave me something to think about because you talked about the $41 million.

2169
03:33:00.268 --> 03:33:12.364
<v Loretta Smith>If we're only going to be talking about the $21 million and not the $15 or $20 million And I don't know that I can totally support this, but I think if we're going to talk about it, we need to talk about it fully.

2170
03:33:15.876 --> 03:33:23.218
<v Loretta Smith>If we're going to have this oversight hearing, we need to talk about everything.

2171
03:33:25.549 --> 03:33:49.974
<v Loretta Smith>So if we're not talking about everything and we're only going to do the $21 million, I don't know how I can vote for And we can put an amendment on the table to do the 40— to do the $15 to $20 million or $30 million plus, because I've been told several numbers.

2172
03:33:53.210 --> 03:33:59.885
<v Mitch Green>May I just direct— Councilor, I think that's important I think that's a reasonable stance to take as you go into this.

2173
03:34:00.046 --> 03:34:09.311
<v Mitch Green>We have to ask the questions that encompass— get a handle around the broader scope of the big problem, and that includes the new information.

2174
03:34:09.985 --> 03:34:31.316
<v Mitch Green>I would just say that the underlying resolution that I proposed doesn't stop us from expanding on the nature of whether or not, you know, in the course of your own self-correction of the $21 million, What, what practices have you put in place, for instance, that have led to the discovery of, of the new money?

2175
03:34:31.494 --> 03:34:33.483
<v Mitch Green>Like, I, I don't see this as mutually exclusive.

2176
03:34:33.531 --> 03:34:39.638
<v Mitch Green>So I think if, if you supported the underlying, it gives you plenty of space to have the dialogue around the full set of money.

2177
03:34:40.156 --> 03:34:41.449
<v Mitch Green>It's just— that's just my view on it.

2178
03:34:42.780 --> 03:34:43.218
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2179
03:34:43.690 --> 03:34:47.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, can we call the roll on the amendment?

2180
03:34:47.834 --> 03:34:49.038
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Pirtle-Guiney, 1.

2181
03:34:49.469 --> 03:34:50.227
<v Jamie Dunphy>I guess.

2182
03:34:52.500 --> 03:34:52.726
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos?

2183
03:34:53.161 --> 03:34:53.370
<v Candace Avalos>No.

2184
03:34:54.547 --> 03:34:54.902
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2185
03:34:55.724 --> 03:34:55.966
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2186
03:34:57.239 --> 03:34:57.480
<v Angelita Morillo>Kanal?

2187
03:34:57.737 --> 03:34:57.897
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2188
03:34:58.638 --> 03:34:59.039
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

2189
03:34:59.424 --> 03:34:59.602
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2190
03:35:00.325 --> 03:35:00.613
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

2191
03:35:01.513 --> 03:35:01.691
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2192
03:35:02.575 --> 03:35:03.105
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

2193
03:35:03.442 --> 03:35:03.603
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

2194
03:35:04.406 --> 03:35:04.888
<v Steve Novick>Murillo?

2195
03:35:05.290 --> 03:35:05.531
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2196
03:35:06.239 --> 03:35:06.513
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

2197
03:35:07.139 --> 03:35:07.188
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2198
03:35:08.072 --> 03:35:08.505
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2199
03:35:08.907 --> 03:35:08.956
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2200
03:35:09.808 --> 03:35:10.016
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2201
03:35:10.354 --> 03:35:10.515
<v Raymond C. Lee>No.

2202
03:35:11.335 --> 03:35:11.786
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2203
03:35:12.299 --> 03:35:12.460
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

2204
03:35:13.585 --> 03:35:14.036
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2205
03:35:17.625 --> 03:35:17.724
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2206
03:35:18.149 --> 03:35:21.530
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment fails with 4 yes votes and 8 no votes.

2207
03:35:24.102 --> 03:35:33.438
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, and I believe most folks have talked at least once, if not twice, are we ready to move to a final vote on the underlying resolution?

2208
03:35:33.876 --> 03:35:34.962
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can you please call the roll?

2209
03:35:35.904 --> 03:35:36.195
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

2210
03:35:36.780 --> 03:35:36.828
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

2211
03:35:37.315 --> 03:35:37.656
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Smith.

2212
03:35:46.431 --> 03:35:46.479
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2213
03:35:48.966 --> 03:35:52.344
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With the hope that we live up to our best selves.

2214
03:35:54.549 --> 03:35:54.596
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2215
03:35:58.371 --> 03:35:59.015
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No.

2216
03:35:59.886 --> 03:35:59.966
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

2217
03:36:00.932 --> 03:36:00.980
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2218
03:36:02.236 --> 03:36:02.316
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2219
03:36:02.558 --> 03:36:02.799
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

2220
03:36:04.586 --> 03:36:04.797
<v Olivia Clark>No.

2221
03:36:06.245 --> 03:36:06.406
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2222
03:36:08.844 --> 03:36:08.942
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2223
03:36:09.382 --> 03:36:09.759
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2224
03:36:11.938 --> 03:36:11.986
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2225
03:36:13.136 --> 03:36:18.477
<v Keelan McClymont>The resolution as amended is adopted with 8 yes votes and 4 no votes.

2226
03:36:20.360 --> 03:36:20.834
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

2227
03:36:22.200 --> 03:36:41.183
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I'd like to ask unanimous consent to adjust our agenda to move the 2 items that were removed from the consent agenda, uh, to the— bring those 2 items forward, um, and we will be moving I'd like to move item 11 to the top of tomorrow's afternoon session.

2228
03:36:42.275 --> 03:36:44.958
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do I have unanimous consent to adjust the agenda as such?

2229
03:36:45.728 --> 03:36:47.768
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing a lot of nods and hungry faces.

2230
03:36:48.361 --> 03:36:51.253
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we call the items that have been called?

2231
03:36:51.751 --> 03:36:53.421
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do we read them separately or do we— okay.

2232
03:36:53.501 --> 03:36:54.673
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, we'll read them separate.

2233
03:36:54.786 --> 03:37:07.247
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, this is item 7, appoint Teresa Carr to the Home Forward Board of Commissioners for a term to Thank you.

2234
03:37:07.328 --> 03:37:09.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do we have— do we do staff presentations on these?

2235
03:37:10.610 --> 03:37:10.674
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

2236
03:37:11.474 --> 03:37:13.545
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, because it came off consent, we do not do a staff presentation.

2237
03:37:15.139 --> 03:37:16.134
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, is there any discussion?

2238
03:37:18.072 --> 03:37:21.059
<v Candace Avalos>Council President, did you want me to do my chair report with them?

2239
03:37:21.125 --> 03:37:21.461
<v Jamie Dunphy>That would be perfect.

2240
03:37:21.525 --> 03:37:21.943
<v Jamie Dunphy>That'd be great.

2241
03:37:22.007 --> 03:37:22.458
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2242
03:37:22.811 --> 03:37:24.016
<v Candace Avalos>We're on Theresa Carr, right?

2243
03:37:24.337 --> 03:37:24.450
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

2244
03:37:24.658 --> 03:37:24.819
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

2245
03:37:25.847 --> 03:37:30.454
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, so this resolution appoints Theresa Carr to the Home Forward Board of Commissioners to fill a vacant seat.

2246
03:37:30.985 --> 03:37:39.665
<v Candace Avalos>Portland City Council approval is required by state law for these appointments, and filling the seat ensures that the board can maintain their quorum and continue making timely decisions.

2247
03:37:39.763 --> 03:37:44.082
<v Candace Avalos>There was no financial impact, and this was heard and approved unanimously in committee.

2248
03:37:44.469 --> 03:37:44.712
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

2249
03:37:45.101 --> 03:37:45.813
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2250
03:37:47.590 --> 03:37:48.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

2251
03:37:50.165 --> 03:37:51.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

2252
03:37:51.067 --> 03:37:52.210
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>May I ask a question of the chair?

2253
03:37:52.501 --> 03:37:52.888
<v Jonas Biery>Absolutely.

2254
03:37:54.191 --> 03:38:24.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos, was there any conversation with this There was some discussion with this appointee about that, and, you know, obviously the item wasn't to enumerate on those issues, but they were raised.

2255
03:38:25.329 --> 03:38:26.198
<v Candace Avalos>So that she was aware.

2256
03:38:26.262 --> 03:38:30.375
<v Candace Avalos>She— I can't remember what she said, but she gave her feedback on that and that that was of importance to her.

2257
03:38:30.695 --> 03:38:31.514
<v Candace Avalos>She served on the board.

2258
03:38:32.206 --> 03:38:32.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2259
03:38:32.608 --> 03:38:33.587
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate that.

2260
03:38:33.731 --> 03:38:41.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have some significant concerns that I have heard from constituents about security in at least one, and I believe multiple, Home Forward buildings in my district.

2261
03:38:41.540 --> 03:38:45.684
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I appreciate that you all took the time to ask questions about those things.

2262
03:38:45.989 --> 03:38:47.451
<v Dan Ryan>For the record, I asked those questions.

2263
03:38:47.629 --> 03:38:47.902
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

2264
03:38:48.689 --> 03:38:51.661
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Ryan, for representing our district in that way.

2265
03:38:53.863 --> 03:38:54.351
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

2266
03:38:55.000 --> 03:39:00.534
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, actually, before I comment, Councilor Ryan, can you say a little bit more about what the responses were to those questions?

2267
03:39:03.319 --> 03:39:06.385
<v Dan Ryan>Um, it was limited because of the scope of the conversation.

2268
03:39:06.611 --> 03:39:08.950
<v Dan Ryan>I think my intent was to daylight them.

2269
03:39:09.337 --> 03:39:11.950
<v Dan Ryan>Um, on the spot at this moment, I can't recall.

2270
03:39:12.015 --> 03:39:19.009
<v Dan Ryan>I'd have to go back and look, so I'm not going to take more time in this meeting to, um, That's fair.

2271
03:39:19.602 --> 03:39:29.975
<v Dan Ryan>What was important is that we were transparent about the fact that it has been reported, highly reported, and we needed transparency when we were on this topic.

2272
03:39:30.361 --> 03:39:32.304
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

2273
03:39:32.850 --> 03:39:36.125
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, so at this dais, I've brought up Louisa Flowers.

2274
03:39:36.221 --> 03:39:39.159
<v Sameer Kanal>I know, um, my colleagues in, in District 2 have brought it up as well.

2275
03:39:39.288 --> 03:39:43.110
<v Sameer Kanal>We've also talked, and many folks up here have brought up the 1 in 7, um, Yes.

2276
03:39:43.157 --> 03:39:47.302
<v Sameer Kanal>—Units being vacant in Home Forward properties and that this is something we absolutely have to address.

2277
03:39:47.559 --> 03:39:49.022
<v Sameer Kanal>And these 2 things are interrelated, right?

2278
03:39:49.086 --> 03:39:56.156
<v Sameer Kanal>One of the major reasons why we see— it's not the only reason, but one of the major reasons why we see vacancies in Home Forward is the feelings related to safety.

2279
03:39:56.300 --> 03:39:59.834
<v Sameer Kanal>I asked the mayor and the mayor agreed to come with me on a tour of Home Forward.

2280
03:40:00.156 --> 03:40:04.591
<v Sameer Kanal>I guess in absentia would ask if the Home Forward board would be willing to come do that.

2281
03:40:04.688 --> 03:40:11.595
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll also note that this morning there was an article in Willamette Week around the Dawson And Park Apartments, which I've also been hearing about.

2282
03:40:12.046 --> 03:40:20.943
<v Sameer Kanal>I was at the Eliot Neighborhood Association a little while ago last week, and that came up there as well, the issues around that particular Home Forward property.

2283
03:40:21.683 --> 03:40:25.441
<v Sameer Kanal>The title of today's article is A Drug Market Moves into a Home Forward Apartment Building.

2284
03:40:26.436 --> 03:40:28.316
<v Sameer Kanal>So there are some significant issues there.

2285
03:40:28.509 --> 03:40:29.488
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not going to vote.

2286
03:40:29.809 --> 03:40:35.046
<v Sameer Kanal>I would never— because of the way this structure is set up, Gresham gets to appoint who they want.

2287
03:40:35.094 --> 03:40:35.254
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2288
03:40:35.495 --> 03:40:40.950
<v Sameer Kanal>And we're going to vote yes on it is how I view it to honor that agreement.

2289
03:40:41.527 --> 03:40:52.418
<v Sameer Kanal>But I did want— I was hoping to have the opportunity to ask for people to come and see it for themselves with me and to come and, you know, form an opinion based on firsthand knowledge.

2290
03:40:52.594 --> 03:41:02.813
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll invite anyone who's interested in doing that from the press, from the council, from the Home Forward board to come see these particular properties and see what we can do about it because it's unacceptable.

2291
03:41:02.861 --> 03:41:02.957
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2292
03:41:03.182 --> 03:41:06.003
<v Sameer Kanal>That has nothing to do with Teresa Carr.

2293
03:41:06.066 --> 03:41:07.300
<v Sameer Kanal>She seems highly qualified.

2294
03:41:07.654 --> 03:41:16.422
<v Sameer Kanal>It's nothing to do with the appointment process, which I would normally ask questions about, but because Gresham has this authority, I won't be questioning them on that.

2295
03:41:16.967 --> 03:41:21.295
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to honor that agreement, but I do think it's worth taking the opportunity to daylight that and again ask.

2296
03:41:21.536 --> 03:41:29.790
<v Sameer Kanal>And I hope— feel free to reach out if you're hearing this, anybody on that side of it, to reach out to my office, and I'd be happy to bring you along on a tour.

2297
03:41:29.870 --> 03:41:30.031
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

2298
03:41:30.734 --> 03:41:31.299
<v Sameer Kanal>With the mayor and I.

2299
03:41:31.525 --> 03:41:31.816
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

2300
03:41:32.415 --> 03:41:33.481
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

2301
03:41:35.906 --> 03:41:36.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

2302
03:41:36.310 --> 03:41:39.868
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

2303
03:41:42.056 --> 03:41:42.234
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2304
03:41:44.386 --> 03:41:44.434
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2305
03:41:45.194 --> 03:41:45.372
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2306
03:41:47.379 --> 03:41:47.557
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2307
03:41:48.835 --> 03:41:48.885
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2308
03:41:49.492 --> 03:41:49.672
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2309
03:41:50.311 --> 03:41:50.361
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2310
03:41:51.951 --> 03:41:52.115
<v Raymond C. Lee>Aye.

2311
03:41:56.377 --> 03:41:56.408
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2312
03:41:56.778 --> 03:41:56.826
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2313
03:41:57.341 --> 03:41:57.356
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2314
03:41:57.743 --> 03:41:57.918
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2315
03:41:58.240 --> 03:41:58.643
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2316
03:41:59.028 --> 03:41:59.076
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2317
03:41:59.927 --> 03:42:02.740
<v Keelan McClymont>The resolution is adopted with 12 yes votes.

2318
03:42:03.302 --> 03:42:04.925
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call item number 8?

2319
03:42:08.280 --> 03:42:16.528
<v Keelan McClymont>Appoint and reappoint members to the Building Code Board of Appeal for terms to expire February 3rd, 2029.

2320
03:42:16.640 --> 03:42:16.835
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2321
03:42:16.885 --> 03:42:18.654
<v Jamie Dunphy>Did this also go through the Housing Bureau?

2322
03:42:18.752 --> 03:42:20.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, Councilor Avalos.

2323
03:42:20.293 --> 03:42:20.471
<v Candace Avalos>Great.

2324
03:42:21.104 --> 03:42:25.908
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, so this is a confirmation for appointments and reappointments to the Building Code Board of Appeal.

2325
03:42:26.503 --> 03:42:33.310
<v Candace Avalos>The board plays an important role in hearing building code appeals and ensuring safety while allowing flexibility when alternative approaches meet the intent of the code.

2326
03:42:34.450 --> 03:42:42.542
<v Candace Avalos>This is 2 new appointments and 3 reappointments, all filling all of the positions on the board through February of 2029.

2327
03:42:43.522 --> 03:42:45.225
<v Candace Avalos>And it was passed unanimously out of committee.

2328
03:42:45.466 --> 03:42:45.787
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

2329
03:42:46.590 --> 03:42:47.311
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor.

2330
03:42:47.698 --> 03:42:49.334
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, any questions or discussion?

2331
03:42:52.622 --> 03:42:53.506
<v Jamie Dunphy>Pausing for a second.

2332
03:42:53.603 --> 03:42:55.677
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

2333
03:42:56.480 --> 03:43:00.099
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, Council President, this is a report, so we'll want to make a motion.

2334
03:43:00.179 --> 03:43:01.131
<v Jamie Dunphy>I need a motion and a second.

2335
03:43:01.245 --> 03:43:01.730
<v Candace Avalos>So moved.

2336
03:43:02.362 --> 03:43:02.816
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

2337
03:43:03.189 --> 03:43:05.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>Moved by Councilor Avalos, seconded by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

2338
03:43:07.545 --> 03:43:09.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we now take the roll?

2339
03:43:10.850 --> 03:43:11.597
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, thank you.

2340
03:43:12.004 --> 03:43:12.314
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2341
03:43:12.509 --> 03:43:12.656
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2342
03:43:13.225 --> 03:43:13.533
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2343
03:43:13.957 --> 03:43:14.005
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2344
03:43:15.259 --> 03:43:15.470
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

2345
03:43:17.319 --> 03:43:17.416
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2346
03:43:18.033 --> 03:43:18.083
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2347
03:43:19.170 --> 03:43:19.218
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2348
03:43:20.322 --> 03:43:20.501
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2349
03:43:21.603 --> 03:43:21.620
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2350
03:43:22.415 --> 03:43:22.465
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2351
03:43:23.227 --> 03:43:23.244
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2352
03:43:24.039 --> 03:43:24.087
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2353
03:43:25.834 --> 03:43:26.011
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2354
03:43:27.433 --> 03:43:27.513
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2355
03:43:27.933 --> 03:43:34.297
<v Keelan McClymont>The report is accepted with 12 yes votes.

2356
03:43:35.105 --> 03:43:39.891
<v Jamie Dunphy>Item number 11 will be heard at the beginning of our, uh, meeting tomorrow.

2357
03:43:39.988 --> 03:43:45.354
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is a first reading of a non-emergency ordinance Uh, we are adjourned until then?

2358
03:43:45.468 --> 03:43:45.968
<v Keelan McClymont>Recessed.

2359
03:43:46.096 --> 03:43:47.032
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are recessed until then.

2360
03:43:47.146 --> 03:43:47.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

