WEBVTT

1
00:07:56.249 --> 00:07:59.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon, friends and family.

2
00:07:59.620 --> 00:08:05.194
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm calling to order this work session on the Office of Independent Review report.

3
00:08:06.607 --> 00:08:11.488
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, the Office of Independent Review group works with the city to review officer-involved shootings.

4
00:08:11.843 --> 00:08:14.862
<v Jamie Dunphy>They review these events and offer the city feedback on policy.

5
00:08:15.295 --> 00:08:17.694
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is OIR's 9th periodic Report.

6
00:08:17.872 --> 00:08:22.857
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today's work session will be presided over our Community and Public Safety co-chairs, Councilors Kanal and Novick.

7
00:08:23.423 --> 00:08:25.041
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilors, who am I passing the gavel to?

8
00:08:26.012 --> 00:08:27.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor, take it away.

9
00:08:27.531 --> 00:08:27.870
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

10
00:08:30.939 --> 00:08:32.345
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks everybody for being here.

11
00:08:32.701 --> 00:08:34.672
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Councilor Novick and I co-chair the committee.

12
00:08:34.720 --> 00:08:36.446
<v Sameer Kanal>We're going to co-chair this, uh, session.

13
00:08:36.494 --> 00:08:39.184
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll take the first part and then pass it to him to facilitate later.

14
00:08:39.716 --> 00:08:48.142
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, first I want to start— I think that, um, we're passing it just to Deputy Director Am I going to do the introduction?

15
00:08:48.190 --> 00:08:50.068
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, well then we'll pass it to DCA Warren.

16
00:08:50.166 --> 00:08:51.418
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much to everyone for being here.

17
00:08:51.499 --> 00:08:53.041
<v Tracy Warren>Good afternoon, Council.

18
00:08:53.730 --> 00:08:55.691
<v Tracy Warren>Um, my name is Tracy Warren.

19
00:08:55.739 --> 00:08:58.614
<v Tracy Warren>I'm the Deputy City Administrator for Operations.

20
00:08:59.207 --> 00:09:05.246
<v Tracy Warren>Beside me I have Kelsey Lloyd, who is acting as the Independent Police Review Director.

21
00:09:06.195 --> 00:09:11.624
<v Tracy Warren>Kelsey's going to give some opening remarks, and then we're going to move through the OIR report.

22
00:09:12.538 --> 00:09:30.101
<v Tracy Warren>We'll talk about background and history, methodology, brief incident overview, the OIR recommendations, and then we'll have PPB give a summary response to recommendations, and then we'll do questions and answers and a full discussion with council.

23
00:09:30.777 --> 00:09:31.899
<v Tracy Warren>So I'll turn it over to Kelsey.

24
00:09:32.350 --> 00:09:39.315
<v Sameer Kanal>Just real quick before you come in, I didn't get your title right, uh, so Acting Director Thank you.

25
00:09:39.971 --> 00:09:43.340
<v Kelsey Lloyd>Thank you and good afternoon, members of council.

26
00:09:43.821 --> 00:09:46.802
<v Kelsey Lloyd>I am Kelsey Lloyd, Deputy Director of the Independent Police Review.

27
00:09:47.445 --> 00:09:51.085
<v Kelsey Lloyd>IPR holds the contract with the OIR Group that produced this report.

28
00:09:51.518 --> 00:10:00.144
<v Kelsey Lloyd>As you may know, city code requires IPR to retain an outside expert to review completed investigations of officer-involved shootings and in-custody deaths.

29
00:10:00.914 --> 00:10:03.801
<v Kelsey Lloyd>Since 2010, the OIR Group have been those outside experts.

30
00:10:04.442 --> 00:10:07.875
<v Kelsey Lloyd>There have been 8 of these reports, and each one has been presented to City Council.

31
00:10:08.758 --> 00:10:13.442
<v Kelsey Lloyd>This current report covers 10 incidents that occurred between 2019 and 2022.

32
00:10:14.452 --> 00:10:25.922
<v Kelsey Lloyd>Every incident involving the use of deadly force or a death in custody undergoes an administrative investigation, training division review, and consideration by the Police Review Board that recommends findings to the Chief of Police.

33
00:10:26.580 --> 00:10:31.086
<v Kelsey Lloyd>IPR reviews all administrative investigations and is a voting member of the Police Review Board.

34
00:10:32.499 --> 00:10:42.943
<v Kelsey Lloyd>OIR only reviews closed cases that have fully completed that administrative review process, so they are able to examine the incident itself as well as the ensuing investigation and accountability process.

35
00:10:43.730 --> 00:10:51.239
<v Kelsey Lloyd>The administrative process, process can take time to complete, so there is often a gap between the incidents themselves and OIR's ability to review them.

36
00:10:52.586 --> 00:10:59.966
<v Kelsey Lloyd>During their reviews, they have access to the complete case file and meet with IPR and Police Bureau staff as needed for additional information while working on the report.

37
00:11:01.379 --> 00:11:11.080
<v Kelsey Lloyd>Although the incidents covered in this report occurred a few years ago, IPR has worked to ensure that all critical incidents receive a review by the OIR group to increase transparency for the community.

38
00:11:11.754 --> 00:11:22.754
<v Kelsey Lloyd>These reports are extremely valuable because they provide a thorough, objective review of the most serious uses of force by Portland Police, conducted by experts with extensive experience in evaluating these incidents.

39
00:11:23.221 --> 00:11:26.979
<v Kelsey Lloyd>They touch on important issues that are crucial to the police bureau and the city going forward.

40
00:11:27.149 --> 00:11:38.399
<v Kelsey Lloyd>In the years the city has been working with OIR, they have met with elected officials and their staff, community advocacy groups, and leadership at Portland Police many times, developing good relationships that go back many years.

41
00:11:39.179 --> 00:11:50.879
<v Kelsey Lloyd>I understand that you're taking public testimony tomorrow, but I wanted to mention that there will also be a public meeting tonight at 6:00 PM hosted by the Citizen Review Committee, and OIR folks will be there to answer questions about this report.

42
00:11:51.220 --> 00:11:55.220
<v Kelsey Lloyd>I hope everyone's had a chance to review the report, and we thank you for your time and attention.

43
00:11:55.799 --> 00:11:57.139
<v Kelsey Lloyd>I'll hand it over now to Julie Ruhland with the OIR group.

44
00:11:57.139 --> 00:11:57.220
<v Kelsey Lloyd>Thank you, Councilor Ruhland.

45
00:12:00.288 --> 00:12:00.913
<v Julie Ruhlin>Good afternoon.

46
00:12:02.308 --> 00:12:07.822
<v Julie Ruhlin>Happy, so happy to be here in Portland and experiencing your new form of government.

47
00:12:07.918 --> 00:12:09.523
<v Julie Ruhlin>We've been here many times in the past.

48
00:12:10.467 --> 00:12:11.477
<v Julie Ruhlin>My name is Julie Ruhlin.

49
00:12:11.525 --> 00:12:15.549
<v Julie Ruhlin>I'm with OIR Group, and my colleague Mike Gianacco also.

50
00:12:15.693 --> 00:12:19.028
<v Julie Ruhlin>And I think Mike's going to get us started with the first slide.

51
00:12:20.423 --> 00:12:20.727
<v Michael Gianacco>Okay.

52
00:12:21.609 --> 00:12:22.746
<v Michael Gianacco>Can we move to the next slide?

53
00:12:23.292 --> 00:12:25.952
<v Michael Gianacco>So I thought maybe— good afternoon, all.

54
00:12:26.450 --> 00:12:30.370
<v Michael Gianacco>Again, Michael Gianacco with OIR Group, and it's great to Thank you, Council President.

55
00:12:30.370 --> 00:12:30.370
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you, Mayor.

56
00:12:30.370 --> 00:12:32.809
<v Michael Gianacco>It's great to be back in Portland.

57
00:12:32.809 --> 00:12:40.399
<v Michael Gianacco>Appreciate the opportunity to engage with you all, councilors, city leadership, as well as your community.

58
00:12:40.909 --> 00:12:49.470
<v Michael Gianacco>And we look forward to the community engagement this evening as well as the formal presentation at your formal meeting tomorrow.

59
00:12:49.779 --> 00:13:00.370
<v Michael Gianacco>We thought it might be helpful since there are some new folks we have not engaged in to this point to give you a little bit of history about us and our work and our— particularly our work in Portland and Oregon.

60
00:13:04.731 --> 00:13:18.828
<v Michael Gianacco>We began our work as oversight professionals, police professionals, in 2001 when we ended up getting an assignment to oversee the LA County Sheriff's Department in Los Angeles.

61
00:13:19.663 --> 00:13:38.375
<v Michael Gianacco>Prior to that time, Julie had been involved in civil rights work for a private firm as well as working for a special counsel in Los Angeles involving oversight prior to the existence of the OIR group in Los Angeles.

62
00:13:39.210 --> 00:13:55.272
<v Michael Gianacco>I, on the other hand, had been doing work as a federal prosecutor for the Civil Rights Division, and that included engaging in prosecuting hate crimes, human trafficking, human modern-day slavery, as well as police misconduct.

63
00:13:55.657 --> 00:14:12.100
<v Michael Gianacco>And as a result of that opportunity that I did for about 15 years, first in Washington but really all over the country, I was involved in prosecuting And I moved to Los Angeles in '94.

64
00:14:12.100 --> 00:14:14.220
<v Michael Gianacco>I did that in '86 throughout the country.

65
00:14:14.220 --> 00:14:27.649
<v Michael Gianacco>In '94, I moved to Los Angeles, and I ended up doing additional work as a prosecutor of police misconduct in the Central District of California in the U.S. Attorney's Office.

66
00:14:29.039 --> 00:14:33.720
<v Michael Gianacco>Topical, and thinking back on this, one of my most significant cases as a prosecutor in Los Angeles was the murder of Rodney King.

67
00:14:33.720 --> 00:14:33.740
<v Michael Gianacco>Yes.

68
00:14:36.212 --> 00:14:54.903
<v Michael Gianacco>And I believe this may be the last prosecution, successful prosecution, in the West Coast, but I was able to successfully prosecute an INS, which is what ICE used to be called, an INS detention officer for using excessive force against a detainee in Terminal Island.

69
00:14:55.706 --> 00:15:00.706
<v Michael Gianacco>So based on that experience, I ended up moving into the world of oversight.

70
00:15:01.043 --> 00:15:07.408
<v Michael Gianacco>After about 9 years in oversight, we were engaged by your city to conduct Thank you.

71
00:15:07.474 --> 00:15:13.677
<v Michael Gianacco>We were asked to conduct a review of a very controversial in-custody death, the death of James Chassie.

72
00:15:15.316 --> 00:15:20.157
<v Michael Gianacco>And that ended up beginning the beginning of our continued engagement with the city.

73
00:15:20.676 --> 00:15:47.022
<v Michael Gianacco>While the Chassie in-custody death was a one-off assignment, we ended up being asked by the then auditor who oversaw this project at the time to start to conduct Regular reviews of all in-custody deaths and officer-involved shootings involving members of the Portland Police Bureau, and have been doing that regularly since that time.

74
00:15:47.534 --> 00:15:57.777
<v Michael Gianacco>So we've had a significant and long engagement with your city with regard to this kind of work and appreciate the opportunity to present this new spate of cases and our review from them.

75
00:15:58.514 --> 00:16:09.134
<v Michael Gianacco>Our work also has caused us to be involved in other auditing functions throughout the country, primarily in California, but not exclusively so.

76
00:16:09.985 --> 00:16:16.152
<v Michael Gianacco>We have done projects for other jurisdictions in Oregon, for example, as a result of this engagement, I believe.

77
00:16:16.568 --> 00:16:27.360
<v Michael Gianacco>So we have done work in West Linn, we've done work for Tigard, City of Tigard, City of Springfield, and Clackamas County, just to name a few of the assignments we've had in your state.

78
00:16:27.841 --> 00:16:33.696
<v Michael Gianacco>So we come to that, to this project with Quite a bit of experience.

79
00:16:33.760 --> 00:16:50.047
<v Michael Gianacco>We have probably, unfortunately, during the course of the years that we've been doing this, over 20 years doing this, reviewed over 500 officer-involved shootings and a significant amount of in-custody deaths as well as part of that work.

80
00:16:51.014 --> 00:16:53.969
<v Michael Gianacco>But everyone is different and everyone presents different challenges.

81
00:16:54.243 --> 00:17:05.432
<v Michael Gianacco>And one thing about Our approach and our focus is that our work is not to investigate the incident.

82
00:17:05.817 --> 00:17:07.242
<v Michael Gianacco>That's already been done, right?

83
00:17:07.804 --> 00:17:09.647
<v Michael Gianacco>That is not going to— that is not our work.

84
00:17:10.625 --> 00:17:17.342
<v Michael Gianacco>There are times in which we are asked by jurisdictions to do an investigation, but that's not the scope of this assignment.

85
00:17:18.384 --> 00:17:27.184
<v Michael Gianacco>And we are also really not focused on the conduct of the particular officer who may be involved in an in-custody death or officer-involved shooting.

86
00:17:27.682 --> 00:17:29.348
<v Michael Gianacco>Again, that's the responsibility of the city.

87
00:17:29.396 --> 00:17:29.588
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

88
00:17:30.407 --> 00:17:39.825
<v Michael Gianacco>At this point, the Bureau, to conduct the investigation and also to ensure that there is a robust review process.

89
00:17:40.386 --> 00:17:43.259
<v Michael Gianacco>So the conduct of the individual officer is not our focus.

90
00:17:43.723 --> 00:17:57.410
<v Michael Gianacco>What our focus is, is really on evaluating the strength of the investigation that is conducted into these serious incidents and evaluate the strength of that investigation.

91
00:17:57.458 --> 00:17:58.388
<v Michael Gianacco>And then we will make recommendations to the city council.

92
00:17:59.046 --> 00:18:17.000
<v Michael Gianacco>As well as taking a critical review of the subsequent review that is conducted by the Bureau with regard to accountability, with regard to policy development, with regard to other reforms that might emanate from these tragic incidents.

93
00:18:17.497 --> 00:18:30.353
<v Michael Gianacco>The way we see it is that, you know, obviously whenever an incident involving the ultimate force that officers are authorized to use under the appropriate circumstances is done, that it be done judiciously.

94
00:18:30.401 --> 00:18:30.497
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

95
00:18:31.515 --> 00:18:33.580
<v Michael Gianacco>That it be done within policy and within the law.

96
00:18:35.549 --> 00:19:32.924
<v Michael Gianacco>But in addition to that, every incident in our view ought to be looked at holistically, completely, and thoroughly with a look towards whether the incident itself presents learning lessons, both with regard to training officers at large, both with regard to providing— seeing whether the guidance provided to officers at the time Was sufficient, and if not, to increase that level of guidance and supervision, and to determine whether there are other remedial measures either at the individual officer level or at the bureau level writ large that might be appropriate with regard to one goal, and that goal is really to better prepare the bureau should officers be faced with a similar set of circumstances and a similar set of challenges, and the.

97
00:19:32.990 --> 00:19:50.253
<v Michael Gianacco>The idea is that if in fact there is a robust review and a sufficient response and some remediation either at the bureau level or at the individual officer level, that will reduce the likelihood that there will be a future deadly force incident.

98
00:19:50.798 --> 00:20:00.673
<v Michael Gianacco>What we have found in the past, and I'm not speaking to Portland here, but for agencies that do not do that kind of review, they're only destined to repeat the problems of the past, right?

99
00:20:01.298 --> 00:20:03.880
<v Michael Gianacco>I'm not the first person to have said that, but I really endorse it.

100
00:20:04.424 --> 00:20:04.760
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

101
00:20:05.068 --> 00:20:09.301
<v Michael Gianacco>Is concomitant with the way in which we do our work.

102
00:20:10.930 --> 00:20:16.319
<v Michael Gianacco>As I indicated earlier, our work started with regard to the 2010 report.

103
00:20:16.836 --> 00:20:20.981
<v Michael Gianacco>That was a review of an incident that had already been 4 years old.

104
00:20:21.594 --> 00:20:36.219
<v Michael Gianacco>And if you, if you ever take a chance and look at the chassis incident, we talk about some of the challenges that waiting that long to do a review has with regard to Intervention, remediation, improvement.

105
00:20:36.592 --> 00:20:49.436
<v Michael Gianacco>Because if you have to wait 4 years before you finally get to that improvement phase, then you are— there's 4 years in which future incidents could occur that are going to be plagued with the same kinds of issues.

106
00:20:51.267 --> 00:21:02.047
<v Michael Gianacco>With regard to the 9 reports that we have now compiled between 2012 and 2026, we are up to 75 critical incidents as part of those 9 reports.

107
00:21:02.113 --> 00:21:04.473
<v Michael Gianacco>They're featured Thank you.

108
00:21:04.521 --> 00:21:05.982
<v Michael Gianacco>They are featured on the city's website.

109
00:21:06.432 --> 00:21:07.684
<v Michael Gianacco>Anyone can access them.

110
00:21:08.278 --> 00:21:16.211
<v Michael Gianacco>And what we most appreciate about the scope of work that you have provided us and given us the opportunity to do is that level of transparency.

111
00:21:16.661 --> 00:21:30.730
<v Michael Gianacco>So we're able to write publicly about the good, the bad, and the indifferent with regard to all of the incidents that we have had a chance to review and speak candidly and publicly about them.

112
00:21:31.409 --> 00:21:44.821
<v Michael Gianacco>And that's a testament to, I think, the city's interest in ensuring a thorough process and accountability and transparency with regard to these tragic events.

113
00:21:45.451 --> 00:21:55.086
<v Michael Gianacco>You know, in order for officers to do their work, we imbue them with great authority, great authority, and no other profession is given that authority by us.

114
00:21:56.804 --> 00:21:59.049
<v Michael Gianacco>Individuals, residents of the United States.

115
00:22:00.413 --> 00:22:04.874
<v Michael Gianacco>And that awesome authority is authority to detain and arrest individuals.

116
00:22:05.467 --> 00:22:19.825
<v Michael Gianacco>But even a greater authority is also imbued to officers, and that's the authority to use force under appropriate circumstances in order to effectuate arrests, to stop resistance, to keep us safe.

117
00:22:20.547 --> 00:22:28.694
<v Michael Gianacco>But to the degree that force is the ultimate authority intrudes on our Fourth Amendment necessarily.

118
00:22:29.849 --> 00:22:40.080
<v Michael Gianacco>It must be done judicially and with best practices, and in all cases, if at all possible, to be avoided, that use of force.

119
00:22:40.914 --> 00:22:44.811
<v Michael Gianacco>And so that's our goal and that's our objective, and that sort of lays out our precepts.

120
00:22:45.326 --> 00:22:46.192
<v Michael Gianacco>Julie, I'll turn it to you.

121
00:22:46.352 --> 00:22:47.618
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yeah, next slide, please.

122
00:22:49.179 --> 00:22:58.369
<v Julie Ruhlin>Just real quick, as Mike said, our goal in these reports is to review the bureau's own internal work and the work that's done.

123
00:22:58.467 --> 00:23:05.218
<v Julie Ruhlin>And so we review the complete investigative file, and that's often, you know, many thousands of pages or thousands of pages.

124
00:23:05.652 --> 00:23:21.241
<v Julie Ruhlin>It includes the detective's criminal investigation, the bureau's internal affairs investigation, any video that's available, and, you know, that's In these cases, there's not a lot of video available.

125
00:23:21.289 --> 00:23:26.087
<v Julie Ruhlin>We're really happy to see Bureau members now wearing the body-worn cameras.

126
00:23:26.297 --> 00:23:30.965
<v Julie Ruhlin>Most of the agencies we have worked with have had those for a number of years.

127
00:23:31.013 --> 00:23:35.618
<v Julie Ruhlin>So getting to review video of incidents has really become quite routine.

128
00:23:35.682 --> 00:23:40.320
<v Julie Ruhlin>So we're grateful and happy to see that the Bureau has taken that step.

129
00:23:40.384 --> 00:23:43.257
<v Julie Ruhlin>The city has taken that step to equip its officers.

130
00:23:43.432 --> 00:23:44.058
<v Julie Ruhlin>Councilor Smith.

131
00:23:44.476 --> 00:23:48.180
<v Julie Ruhlin>The training division review is another big piece of this file.

132
00:23:48.260 --> 00:24:04.664
<v Julie Ruhlin>And it's really, we've talked about it repeatedly in all of our reports, but it bears repeating that that document is really a testament to the bureau's commitment to using these events as a learning opportunity.

133
00:24:05.900 --> 00:24:36.770
<v Julie Ruhlin>There aren't other, we work with a lot of other agencies and we just don't see a training division that is so forthcoming with its Critique of officers' performance and willingness to sort of go dive deep into an incident, evaluate all of the decisions made, and then to lay that out in written form is pretty remarkable and something we are always complimentary of when we do these reports.

134
00:24:37.557 --> 00:24:54.474
<v Julie Ruhlin>And so it really is a very useful piece of this file, and we talk repeatedly in this report about the things that that are identified by training as part of the sort of opportunities for learning and growth and needed improvements.

135
00:24:55.426 --> 00:24:58.815
<v Julie Ruhlin>So that's a big piece of our review as well.

136
00:24:59.298 --> 00:25:05.161
<v Julie Ruhlin>We look at the grand jury transcripts when these cases have gone to grand jury and review those.

137
00:25:06.308 --> 00:25:23.733
<v Julie Ruhlin>And then all of the documents that talk about the internal review process and the Police Review Board decisions and how those decisions make their way up through the chief's office and ultimately where those land.

138
00:25:25.059 --> 00:25:25.371
<v Julie Ruhlin>Next slide.

139
00:25:27.240 --> 00:25:32.826
<v Julie Ruhlin>So in this report, it is our 9th report, there are 10 incidents.

140
00:25:33.586 --> 00:25:36.892
<v Julie Ruhlin>2 Of those are fatal officer-involved shootings.

141
00:25:37.892 --> 00:25:52.714
<v Julie Ruhlin>3 Of them are shootings in which the individual was hit, 4 of them are shootings where the officer fired at somebody but did not hit them.

142
00:25:53.779 --> 00:26:10.362
<v Julie Ruhlin>And just, again, I want to compliment the Bureau on its willingness, the fact that the non-hit shootings get the exact same investigative treatment, exact same treatment by the training division as a hit shooting.

143
00:26:10.539 --> 00:26:10.829
<v Julie Ruhlin>Thank you.

144
00:26:11.713 --> 00:26:16.761
<v Julie Ruhlin>The fact that somebody did not get hit does not mean that we don't take this very seriously.

145
00:26:16.843 --> 00:26:18.661
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's still an exercise of deadly force.

146
00:26:19.220 --> 00:26:22.527
<v Julie Ruhlin>And again, that's not something that we see in every agency.

147
00:26:22.945 --> 00:26:27.286
<v Julie Ruhlin>Often the non-hit shootings are kind of like no harm, no foul.

148
00:26:27.479 --> 00:26:29.269
<v Julie Ruhlin>And that, that is not the way we see it.

149
00:26:29.349 --> 00:26:30.880
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's not the way your bureau sees it.

150
00:26:31.105 --> 00:26:32.105
<v Julie Ruhlin>And we think that's a good thing.

151
00:26:33.022 --> 00:26:40.300
<v Julie Ruhlin>And then there was one incident where the individual— there's a standoff in a car, a long standoff with officers.

152
00:26:40.743 --> 00:26:40.973
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yeah.

153
00:26:43.217 --> 00:26:47.126
<v Julie Ruhlin>And ultimately, that person in the car had a gun and took his own life.

154
00:26:47.722 --> 00:26:51.278
<v Julie Ruhlin>So that was the 10th of those incidents.

155
00:26:52.539 --> 00:27:01.531
<v Julie Ruhlin>Throughout the report, we address a number of issues, including pre-shooting tactics and the decision-making that go into, that sort of led up to the uses of force.

156
00:27:03.217 --> 00:27:12.296
<v Julie Ruhlin>And these things that kind of, we'll get to the recommendations in a minute, but we also talk about consistency in addressing the recommendations that come from a lot of different pieces of the review process.

157
00:27:12.472 --> 00:27:12.778
<v Julie Ruhlin>Thank you.

158
00:27:16.593 --> 00:27:26.067
<v Julie Ruhlin>We talked— one of the themes is, is looking at shooting at moving vehicles, and then the delays that are— that resulted from litigation in, in these cases.

159
00:27:27.306 --> 00:27:30.731
<v Julie Ruhlin>We make 7 recommendations, and again, we will get to those.

160
00:27:30.827 --> 00:27:36.544
<v Julie Ruhlin>They deal with the review process and follow-up, investigative protocols, training, and timing of reviews.

161
00:27:37.868 --> 00:27:38.644
<v Julie Ruhlin>Next slide, please.

162
00:27:42.087 --> 00:27:46.015
<v Julie Ruhlin>And again, we didn't wanna walk through each of these incidents.

163
00:27:47.057 --> 00:28:00.151
<v Julie Ruhlin>And so just in terms of breaking them down and looking sort of thematically, there are 3 incidents where bureau members shot at a moving vehicle or at a vehicle.

164
00:28:00.776 --> 00:28:06.594
<v Julie Ruhlin>And that is sort of an interesting, certainly timely after what we've seen in Minneapolis.

165
00:28:07.250 --> 00:28:21.683
<v Julie Ruhlin>And it's a thing that, it's an issue It's an issue that is addressed by very strict policy, and it's a concern in all of the work we do when you see the shooting at vehicles.

166
00:28:21.731 --> 00:28:25.022
<v Julie Ruhlin>And there are a number of very particular concerns about that.

167
00:28:26.271 --> 00:28:37.161
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's interesting that there were 3 of those incidents in this set of cases because it's not something that historically we had seen in prior reports.

168
00:28:37.226 --> 00:28:38.104
<v Julie Ruhlin>So it was kind of—.

169
00:28:38.104 --> 00:28:38.201
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yeah.

170
00:28:40.394 --> 00:28:52.846
<v Julie Ruhlin>I'm not trying to make more of it than— other than a statistical blip, but it was just sort of an interesting observation that there were 3 in this after, you know, so many years where we just didn't see that come up.

171
00:28:54.566 --> 00:29:01.297
<v Julie Ruhlin>4 Of these incidents involved people who were in some kind of mental health crisis or had a suicidal intent.

172
00:29:02.008 --> 00:29:11.309
<v Julie Ruhlin>And again, that is a common repeat theme that we've seen, not just in Portland, but really everywhere as law enforcement Thank you.

173
00:29:11.309 --> 00:29:11.309
<v Julie Ruhlin>So, this is a very important document.

174
00:29:11.309 --> 00:29:11.309
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's a very important document for us to have.

175
00:29:11.309 --> 00:29:18.180
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's a very important document for the city of Portland to have as it grapples with how to deal with people who are in profound behavioral health crises.

176
00:29:18.430 --> 00:29:35.990
<v Julie Ruhlin>And then in these— this set of cases, we see officers responding to a number of different types of calls, different scenarios, including a domestic dispute, a couple of cases where they're tracking down stolen vehicles, performing a warrant service.

177
00:29:37.020 --> 00:29:38.103
<v Julie Ruhlin>Public disturbance.

178
00:29:39.685 --> 00:29:46.836
<v Julie Ruhlin>One subject who was being pursued for a home invasion, and then criminal trespassing.

179
00:29:49.031 --> 00:29:49.952
<v Julie Ruhlin>Next slide, please.

180
00:29:52.049 --> 00:30:00.483
<v Julie Ruhlin>So our recommendations, they're intentionally out of order just because of the way it made sense to us to discuss them.

181
00:30:00.645 --> 00:30:02.833
<v Julie Ruhlin>So the numbers jump around.

182
00:30:02.897 --> 00:30:03.028
<v Julie Ruhlin>Thank you.

183
00:30:04.096 --> 00:30:08.153
<v Julie Ruhlin>Our recommendations are driven by what we see in the cases that we review.

184
00:30:09.018 --> 00:30:20.703
<v Julie Ruhlin>So we've grouped them here, but just, we'll talk briefly about the sort of, about the recommendation and why it's included in this report.

185
00:30:21.506 --> 00:30:22.740
<v Julie Ruhlin>Take this, take number 1.

186
00:30:23.589 --> 00:30:24.295
<v Michael Gianacco>Yes, thank you.

187
00:30:25.690 --> 00:30:32.615
<v Michael Gianacco>So we will go through the recommendations and the rest of our presentation will focus on the recommendations themselves.

188
00:30:33.271 --> 00:30:35.539
<v Michael Gianacco>I think it really is important to have Thank you.

189
00:30:35.539 --> 00:30:35.539
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you, Mayor.

190
00:30:35.539 --> 00:30:35.539
<v Michael Gianacco>Council President Jamie Dunphy.

191
00:30:35.539 --> 00:30:35.539
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you, Mayor.

192
00:30:35.539 --> 00:30:54.759
<v Michael Gianacco>I appreciate the opportunity to give a factual recitation of each of the events, each of the incidents, for mere transparency purposes, as well as to give a better understanding for what became the organic reason for the recommendations that we have made, rather than just putting out the recommendations by themselves.

193
00:30:55.480 --> 00:31:04.079
<v Michael Gianacco>But each of these recommendations do stem from these incidents that are the focus of our work.

194
00:31:04.079 --> 00:31:16.478
<v Michael Gianacco>And the way these cases come to us and the reason that there are these cases is that the way the contract has been structured is that there will be a certain time period in which the cases are closed.

195
00:31:16.912 --> 00:31:25.748
<v Michael Gianacco>And during that time period, all the cases that are closed during that time period then come to us for review and then become the foundation of our report.

196
00:31:26.150 --> 00:31:27.355
<v Michael Gianacco>So that's how that works.

197
00:31:28.576 --> 00:31:37.209
<v Michael Gianacco>So looking at the invest— at the recommendations and trying to put a little more meat on the bones with regard to What those recommendations are intended to accomplish.

198
00:31:38.308 --> 00:31:41.996
<v Michael Gianacco>The first one has to do with the Bureau's review process.

199
00:31:44.369 --> 00:32:01.260
<v Michael Gianacco>And as Julie indicated, and I concur, of course, that this is all comparative, but the Bureau is quite significantly ahead of many other similar-sized agencies that we work with, with regard to a robust review process.

200
00:32:01.308 --> 00:32:01.501
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

201
00:32:02.949 --> 00:32:21.431
<v Michael Gianacco>So what that means is that both internally and eventually by the chief, but even before that by the police review board, there is a review, a formal review of officers' conduct, supervisors' conduct.

202
00:32:22.368 --> 00:32:30.904
<v Michael Gianacco>So that review formally forces the review board and eventually the officer, the chief, to come to certain dispositions.

203
00:32:31.852 --> 00:32:44.116
<v Michael Gianacco>Or decisions, if you will, with regard to whether the performance, the conduct of the officers or supervisors met expectations, were within policy, and were within the law.

204
00:32:44.715 --> 00:32:53.436
<v Michael Gianacco>Obviously, the district attorney has a different responsibility, and that is to evaluate whether or not any of the conduct rises to the level of criminality.

205
00:32:54.430 --> 00:33:11.147
<v Michael Gianacco>And the DA does that, and that's, you know, where the grand jury comes into But the Bureau has an independent responsibility, again, to ensure that the performance of its officers are consistent with their expectations as set out by Bureau policy.

206
00:33:13.359 --> 00:33:15.315
<v Michael Gianacco>And the way they do that is a very formal way.

207
00:33:15.412 --> 00:33:25.011
<v Michael Gianacco>So with regard to the actual decision to use deadly force, that is something that is evaluated formally.

208
00:33:25.093 --> 00:33:32.982
<v Michael Gianacco>So the review board initially and eventually the chief Chief will be making a decision with this question in mind.

209
00:33:33.644 --> 00:33:44.779
<v Michael Gianacco>Did the use of deadly force by any officer— sometimes it's multiple officers— was that consistent with policy, or was the shooting out of policy?

210
00:33:45.362 --> 00:33:50.241
<v Michael Gianacco>And over the past years, there have been occasional times in which the shooting has been found to be out of policy.

211
00:33:50.451 --> 00:33:52.244
<v Michael Gianacco>Not often, but it has occurred.

212
00:33:53.993 --> 00:33:58.707
<v Michael Gianacco>In this set of cases, there are no cases in which That decision was made.

213
00:33:59.107 --> 00:34:02.319
<v Michael Gianacco>But the decision is being made on each of these incidents.

214
00:34:03.588 --> 00:34:14.653
<v Michael Gianacco>In addition, pursuant to a recommendation we made maybe 10 years ago, the Bureau also agreed to make a formal decision with regard to what we call post-incident conduct.

215
00:34:15.248 --> 00:34:38.862
<v Michael Gianacco>And the way this came about was we saw a couple cases in our review process in which there were some concerns raised by us and by the Bureau themselves about whether or not, for example, the medical aid that is provided to the downed individual after the shooting was sufficiently timely, was sufficiently robust.

216
00:34:39.246 --> 00:34:53.047
<v Michael Gianacco>There are also some concerns about the management of the scene, you know, the, the way in which the scene is held, the protocols with regard to getting forensic people there to start to the forensic investigation, etc.

217
00:34:53.690 --> 00:35:09.900
<v Michael Gianacco>And so as a result of those concerns and pursuant to a recommendation that we made, the Bureau agreed to also, in addition to looking at the shooting decision, to also evaluate the post-incident management of the scene.

218
00:35:10.445 --> 00:35:13.911
<v Michael Gianacco>Was medical aid provided in a timely way?

219
00:35:14.858 --> 00:35:22.652
<v Michael Gianacco>Were supervisors effectively managing the scene and ensuring a robust processing of evidence.

220
00:35:23.277 --> 00:35:33.391
<v Michael Gianacco>And those are the 2 areas in which, since that time, the Bureau in every case is making a yes/no determination with regard to that.

221
00:35:33.697 --> 00:35:43.715
<v Michael Gianacco>And also, if there are issues with regard to maybe not a violation but performance issues that should be addressed, the Bureau uses those mechanisms to do that.

222
00:35:45.318 --> 00:35:59.112
<v Michael Gianacco>What we haven't seen, though, is that there hasn't been a formal assessment or evaluation, yes, no, in or out of policy, with regard to what we call pre-shooting conduct.

223
00:36:00.538 --> 00:36:08.773
<v Michael Gianacco>Another term that you may hear about is whether or not there was appropriate attempts at de-escalation leading up to the shooting.

224
00:36:09.188 --> 00:36:11.849
<v Michael Gianacco>That's also part of pre-shooting conduct.

225
00:36:12.409 --> 00:36:33.027
<v Michael Gianacco>Another way of describing it And what we have learned over the course of our review of these, you know, 500-plus incidents is oftentimes the decisions that are made pre-shooting often contribute to the eventual decision to use deadly force, right?

226
00:36:33.364 --> 00:37:02.744
<v Michael Gianacco>So if there are decisions made that cause the officer to get too close to the individual, to cause the officer to move too quickly towards the individual, to cause the officer to use excessive force, where there wasn't sufficient thought to deploy de-escalation tactics, that can cause the shooting itself to be more inevitable than if there was more careful consideration of some of these other concepts.

227
00:37:03.260 --> 00:37:11.485
<v Michael Gianacco>So oftentimes it's those pre-shooting decisions that sort of drive the train, leading ultimately to the use of deadly force, if that makes sense.

228
00:37:11.583 --> 00:37:35.503
<v Michael Gianacco>And while, as Julian The training reviews that have been in existence since we began our project 15 years ago, while as I said, those protocols look at the shooting itself and make formal decision, and training review looks at that and looks at the post-shooting management of the scene.

229
00:37:35.922 --> 00:37:41.737
<v Michael Gianacco>The training review also does look at pre-shooting conduct and evaluates that pre-shooting conduct.

230
00:37:42.603 --> 00:37:55.623
<v Michael Gianacco>And makes determinations about that pre-shooting conduct in their training review, whether it met expectations, what's consistent with training that the Bureau provides, what's consistent with policy.

231
00:37:57.688 --> 00:38:11.780
<v Michael Gianacco>The hole that we have seen in the system, though, and that forms the basis for this recommendation, is that, as I talked about, the yes/no decisions on the shooting itself, the yes/no decision about about the post-incident management.

232
00:38:12.326 --> 00:38:15.891
<v Michael Gianacco>There is no yes/no decision with regard to pre-shooting conduct.

233
00:38:16.293 --> 00:38:27.777
<v Michael Gianacco>So the shooting review board— Police Review Board is not required to make an evaluation about whether or not the pre-shooting conduct met expectations.

234
00:38:28.726 --> 00:38:35.952
<v Michael Gianacco>The chief is not required to make a formal evaluation of whether the officer's pre-shooting conduct Yes.

235
00:38:37.010 --> 00:38:43.213
<v Michael Gianacco>Met expectations, was consistent with training, or was in violation of expectations.

236
00:38:43.871 --> 00:38:50.298
<v Michael Gianacco>And the recommendation is intended to reform that system so that there is a yes/no on that.

237
00:38:51.260 --> 00:38:54.114
<v Michael Gianacco>And that's really the essence of the recommendation.

238
00:38:54.786 --> 00:39:13.266
<v Michael Gianacco>What we'd like to see in our recommendation is intended to formalize what the training review is doing And requiring the board, as well as the chief eventually, upon receiving the recommendations from the board, to make that determination.

239
00:39:14.980 --> 00:39:21.869
<v Michael Gianacco>And what that means isn't necessarily that someone's going to be fired behind it or that someone's going to be found out of policy with regard to that.

240
00:39:22.257 --> 00:39:24.829
<v Michael Gianacco>That could happen on an egregious situation.

241
00:39:25.427 --> 00:40:00.164
<v Michael Gianacco>But really, more frequently is what we would see is that as a result of that, that yes/no evaluation, uh, that the involved officer might be sent to additional training, that the involved officer, if the performance seems to be somewhat suboptimal, could be, could be, uh, subject to briefing, uh, and, uh, targeted training so that that officer or set of officers that are involved in the incident are better prepared to handle the next challenge in their career.

242
00:40:00.934 --> 00:40:02.393
<v Michael Gianacco>And it's as simple as that.

243
00:40:02.954 --> 00:40:04.684
<v Michael Gianacco>And so that's recommendation 1.

244
00:40:06.175 --> 00:40:15.583
<v Julie Ruhlin>Okay, I'm gonna jump to recommendation 6, which has to do with sort of a structured response to recommendations that come internally from the review process.

245
00:40:15.760 --> 00:40:19.318
<v Julie Ruhlin>And so there is this very multilayered review, right?

246
00:40:19.382 --> 00:40:20.632
<v Julie Ruhlin>There's a training division review.

247
00:40:20.824 --> 00:40:24.496
<v Julie Ruhlin>Sometimes they have— very often they have— the training division makes Yes.

248
00:40:24.672 --> 00:40:25.762
<v Julie Ruhlin>The Chief of Police makes recommendations.

249
00:40:26.740 --> 00:40:29.210
<v Julie Ruhlin>Police Review Board sometimes makes recommendations.

250
00:40:29.786 --> 00:40:37.467
<v Julie Ruhlin>There is a commander who reviews the whole file, the reporting unit manager, who sometimes makes recommendations.

251
00:40:37.724 --> 00:40:52.842
<v Julie Ruhlin>Things that might have to do with training issues, of course, or, you know, different types of equipment that the bureau should be looking at, or there are just a wide range of recommendations that we see come up.

252
00:40:52.940 --> 00:40:53.179
<v Julie Ruhlin>Thank you.

253
00:40:53.324 --> 00:41:07.039
<v Julie Ruhlin>So recommendations come up in these files, and the bureau has historically been sort of inconsistent in the way those recommendations get either formally accepted or rejected.

254
00:41:07.617 --> 00:41:14.313
<v Julie Ruhlin>A question about, you know, who's in charge of them, who's going to do, you know, what it will take to implement this recommendation.

255
00:41:14.362 --> 00:41:15.853
<v Julie Ruhlin>Do we think it's a good recommendation?

256
00:41:16.909 --> 00:41:18.576
<v Julie Ruhlin>All that sort of formal consideration.

257
00:41:21.096 --> 00:41:42.153
<v Julie Ruhlin>Kind of a repeat recommendation we've made over the course of a few reports, and that is to just really create a more crystallized process where you can take all of those recommendations and say yes, no, and if so, who's in charge of doing it and what's the report back and what's the due date.

258
00:41:42.574 --> 00:41:58.972
<v Julie Ruhlin>We see this, some agencies manage this very well where they have a You know, specific action items coming out of each incident, and then somebody assigned to track the implementation of that and kind of make sure that there's the follow-through.

259
00:42:00.208 --> 00:42:04.588
<v Julie Ruhlin>I believe that many of the recommendations that we see in these reports do get done.

260
00:42:05.742 --> 00:42:12.288
<v Julie Ruhlin>I think training follows through and adapts its training in accordance with what it's seen.

261
00:42:12.335 --> 00:42:18.322
<v Julie Ruhlin>I'm not saying that the recommendations are They're not always done or they're not, you know, or they're ignored.

262
00:42:19.307 --> 00:42:32.019
<v Julie Ruhlin>But I think without the formal process and the sort of mechanism for going back and checking and ensuring that they got implemented, things can fall through the cracks and you can kind of lose track of things.

263
00:42:32.068 --> 00:42:41.351
<v Julie Ruhlin>So that has been, like I said, a recommendation we've made before and we reiterate it here in our recommendation number 6.

264
00:42:41.400 --> 00:42:41.496
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

265
00:42:44.280 --> 00:42:44.684
<v Olivia Clark>Thanks.

266
00:42:44.780 --> 00:42:52.990
<v Michael Gianacco>Going to the next recommendation, which we number 7, and this is all because they stem from the chronology of cases, and that's why they're out of order here.

267
00:42:54.621 --> 00:42:56.429
<v Michael Gianacco>And this is really pretty straightforward.

268
00:42:58.085 --> 00:43:08.416
<v Michael Gianacco>Over the years that we've been doing this since the beginning, and we learned in CHASSI some of the downsides of waiting a long time to effectuate any reviews or improvements.

269
00:43:08.909 --> 00:43:09.070
<v Michael Gianacco>Yes.

270
00:43:09.264 --> 00:43:13.376
<v Michael Gianacco>Because in that case, it took 4 years before any improvements were even thought of.

271
00:43:14.262 --> 00:43:18.891
<v Michael Gianacco>And in fact, some of the investigation was stalled while the litigation went forward.

272
00:43:23.474 --> 00:43:37.702
<v Michael Gianacco>Over the years that we've been doing this, we have been reviewing cases that are in active litigation and reporting on them without any untoward circumstances or significant adverse effect on the litigation posture, etc.

273
00:43:37.820 --> 00:43:39.213
<v Michael Gianacco>Et cetera.

274
00:43:39.358 --> 00:43:53.612
<v Michael Gianacco>But this time, 2 cases were held back from us that were in litigation with the issue of concern that the review, our independent review, should not occur until that litigation was over.

275
00:43:54.030 --> 00:44:05.237
<v Michael Gianacco>That was a divergence from the practice that we had been living under for the 10-plus years we've been doing this work for your city, and it caused us some concern.

276
00:44:05.382 --> 00:44:06.070
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

277
00:44:10.773 --> 00:44:28.641
<v Michael Gianacco>If any kind of transparency, any kind of recommendations coming out of our review are forestalled until the litigation is over, that could mean that it could be years and many years depending on the length of litigation.

278
00:44:29.302 --> 00:44:32.302
<v Michael Gianacco>Those of you involved in litigation know sometimes how long.

279
00:44:32.367 --> 00:44:32.465
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

280
00:44:33.672 --> 00:44:36.159
<v Michael Gianacco>It takes to get done.

281
00:44:36.826 --> 00:44:53.639
<v Michael Gianacco>That means that during those years, any reform or learning coming out of our report will be forestalled until we're finally able to access the information and then report to you and to your community and to the bureau itself on what we see.

282
00:44:55.492 --> 00:45:11.326
<v Michael Gianacco>And so our recommendation is to go back to the way— the practice that we have been living under for the 10-plus years and not hold back a case for our review simply because it's under current litigation.

283
00:45:12.800 --> 00:45:20.943
<v Michael Gianacco>We have had an opportunity to review the chief's response to our recommendations and note that he is in agreement with this recommendation.

284
00:45:21.538 --> 00:45:43.371
<v Michael Gianacco>He has asked, though, that as part of that, if we are to go back to a situation in which there in which we are reviewing a case in active litigation, that we simply prepare— share a draft of that report with your city attorney to make sure that we are factually on the same page with regard to our recitation of incidents.

285
00:45:43.853 --> 00:45:51.967
<v Michael Gianacco>We have no problem if in fact that ends up being the system, because in many jurisdictions we do exactly that anyway.

286
00:45:52.465 --> 00:46:01.375
<v Michael Gianacco>So we don't have a problem with that being part of Uh, uh, of the implementation of this recommendation if we end up going back to that system.

287
00:46:02.728 --> 00:46:03.438
<v Julie Ruhlin>Next slide, please.

288
00:46:06.769 --> 00:46:07.271
<v Julie Ruhlin>This one's you.

289
00:46:09.206 --> 00:46:17.481
<v Michael Gianacco>Yeah, um, there was an incident in which, um, a parked vehicle was used as an attempt to box, uh, or to keep, uh, an individual from fleeing.

290
00:46:18.061 --> 00:46:20.960
<v Michael Gianacco>That didn't end up well, um, for a whole lot of reasons.

291
00:46:21.074 --> 00:46:25.963
<v Michael Gianacco>It wasn't very successful, um, and, um, Aye.

292
00:46:26.509 --> 00:46:29.639
<v Michael Gianacco>And using a parked vehicle in that way can be problematic.

293
00:46:30.844 --> 00:46:41.858
<v Michael Gianacco>And so our recommendation was intended to raise this issue with the bureau and to update its training curriculum and its guidance to officers appropriately.

294
00:46:42.547 --> 00:46:51.010
<v Michael Gianacco>And we have learned through the— again, through the chief's response that there has been some reform here that I believe satisfies this recommendation.

295
00:46:51.074 --> 00:47:01.831
<v Michael Gianacco>So we appreciate that the bureau has taken this recommendation up and has recognized even before our recommendation was made that they have addressed this issue.

296
00:47:02.500 --> 00:47:15.699
<v Michael Gianacco>By the way, on the shooting at vehicles cases of the blip that Julie referenced, it's heartening to see that since that time there haven't been these kinds of incidents.

297
00:47:16.514 --> 00:47:36.860
<v Michael Gianacco>And I do think that's because training really upped its game after these 3 incidents and did really through training really impressed upon its officers the concerns raised when deadly force is used against a moving vehicle.

298
00:47:37.487 --> 00:47:39.579
<v Julie Ruhlin>You got the next one too.

299
00:47:41.969 --> 00:47:42.543
<v Michael Gianacco>Okay, the next one.

300
00:47:44.349 --> 00:47:49.211
<v Michael Gianacco>Yeah, number 3, just again comes out of one of the cases we looked at.

301
00:47:49.998 --> 00:47:52.269
<v Michael Gianacco>And this was a shooting at moving vehicles case.

302
00:47:53.746 --> 00:48:16.255
<v Michael Gianacco>And in fact, as indicated in the report, the officer indicated that the reason that he shot at the moving vehicle is because the moving vehicle was coming in his path and he felt that he wasn't able to get out of the way of the vehicle in sufficient time and was concerned for his safety and therefore fired a number of rounds.

303
00:48:22.329 --> 00:48:41.771
<v Michael Gianacco>However, the photographic evidence that was conducted as a result of the investigation that the Bureau did showed that, in fact, the bullet holes into the vehicle were, with maybe one exception, all into the side of the vehicle.

304
00:48:43.233 --> 00:48:51.920
<v Michael Gianacco>Which means that knowing physics, you're likely not going to be able to shoot into the side of the vehicle if you are positioned in the front of the vehicle.

305
00:48:53.885 --> 00:49:04.143
<v Michael Gianacco>And our recommendation is simply that that was a discrepancy between the evidence, the photographic evidence, the evidence of the truck, and the officer's account.

306
00:49:04.697 --> 00:49:07.222
<v Michael Gianacco>And what we didn't see was— I'm sorry, I didn't hear you.

307
00:49:08.378 --> 00:49:31.431
<v Michael Gianacco>The internal affairs investigator challenging that discrepancy or addressing that discrepancy during the officer's interview, nor did we see it being considered as part of the analysis in determining whether the officer's account was consistent with the evidence, and if not, if there's an explanation for why there was an inconsistency.

308
00:49:32.012 --> 00:49:45.458
<v Michael Gianacco>But primarily, the officer, since the officer wasn't ever questioned about that, that wasn't able to explain why there might be discrepancy between his account of the incident and the physical evidence demonstrated by the physical bullet hole evidence.

309
00:49:45.974 --> 00:49:55.469
<v Michael Gianacco>So we've asked as part of the recommendation that these kind of discrepancies, if they're identified, be addressed during the investigative process.

310
00:49:57.708 --> 00:50:05.643
<v Julie Ruhlin>Recommendation 4 goes to a piece regarding The dispatch and how calls get dispatched out to officers.

311
00:50:06.867 --> 00:50:22.280
<v Julie Ruhlin>And it's, you know, it's often the police response begins with the dispatcher, and a dispatcher can play a critical role in how prepared an officer is when he or she arrives at that call based on, you know, the information that they've gotten from dispatch.

312
00:50:23.536 --> 00:50:32.172
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's— we have talked in past reports about the Bureau of Emergency Communications and, and made various recommendations about how it should be involved.

313
00:50:32.253 --> 00:50:32.318
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yes.

314
00:50:34.416 --> 00:50:41.114
<v Julie Ruhlin>In some of these, uh, post-critical incident reviews and, and examining its own role in that.

315
00:50:41.257 --> 00:50:46.065
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's a little outside our scope because BOIC is, you know, not part of the police bureau.

316
00:50:46.208 --> 00:51:00.920
<v Julie Ruhlin>And, um, I think it's just as a— it's, it's interesting that I, I think you're— I don't entirely know everything about your new form of city government, but, um, you know, I think in the past Yes.

317
00:51:00.967 --> 00:51:03.389
<v Julie Ruhlin>In the past, the bureaus were very siloed, right?

318
00:51:03.518 --> 00:51:14.550
<v Julie Ruhlin>And so if something was happening in the police bureau and BOET, like those, there wasn't always great ability to work across those bureaus.

319
00:51:14.646 --> 00:51:18.143
<v Julie Ruhlin>And I think that's a goal of your new city government.

320
00:51:18.190 --> 00:51:26.177
<v Julie Ruhlin>So I think that this is a promising sort of area for perhaps some growth and new communication between the bureaus.

321
00:51:27.878 --> 00:51:43.242
<v Julie Ruhlin>This recommendation really stemmed from an incident in which an individual went into a store, a convenience store, and was acting erratically and refused to leave and had eaten some food.

322
00:51:43.291 --> 00:51:52.619
<v Julie Ruhlin>The store owner, the store manager, the employee called 911 and reported this behavior.

323
00:51:53.070 --> 00:52:01.514
<v Julie Ruhlin>The critical piece of it is that the individual had asked the store manager to call the police.

324
00:52:02.110 --> 00:52:11.237
<v Julie Ruhlin>And that— the store manager reported that to dispatch, but that piece of information did not go to the officers when dispatcher sent them out.

325
00:52:11.318 --> 00:52:15.025
<v Julie Ruhlin>It was just a sort of unwanted person's call.

326
00:52:15.364 --> 00:52:16.724
<v Julie Ruhlin>He's eaten food and won't leave.

327
00:52:17.306 --> 00:52:17.565
<v Julie Ruhlin>Okay.

328
00:52:18.599 --> 00:52:26.940
<v Julie Ruhlin>So, you know, it seems like a minor point, but, and we don't know, you can't say how things might have gone differently.

329
00:52:28.014 --> 00:52:40.300
<v Julie Ruhlin>But as it turns out, this individual said after the incident, it was a non-fatal shooting, he said that he was trying to get police to shoot and kill him, right?

330
00:52:40.382 --> 00:52:49.646
<v Julie Ruhlin>So it's that little extra bit of information, if the officers had known going in that this person person was asking for a police response.

331
00:52:50.244 --> 00:52:53.094
<v Julie Ruhlin>He was not just being disruptive and not leaving.

332
00:52:53.159 --> 00:52:55.005
<v Julie Ruhlin>He actually wanted the police to come.

333
00:52:56.489 --> 00:53:10.251
<v Julie Ruhlin>Again, I can't get inside the, inside the minds of those officers, but perhaps they might have recognized it going in as a mental health call, and perhaps that might have shifted some, in some subtle ways, the way they approached the call.

334
00:53:10.722 --> 00:53:27.409
<v Julie Ruhlin>And so it was really just this recommendation is, is again meant to encourage that communication between the police bureau, what they learn from these shootings, and to get that information back to dispatchers so that these kind of responses can be improved.

335
00:53:30.847 --> 00:53:31.346
<v Michael Gianacco>Last one.

336
00:53:31.572 --> 00:53:42.449
<v Michael Gianacco>Yeah, the last recommendation has to do with putting some guardrails on what is called a PIT maneuver, which Which is a pursuit intervention technique.

337
00:53:42.949 --> 00:54:10.865
<v Michael Gianacco>And what that means is that when an officer is engaging and wants to detain a suspect, that instead of pursuing them, instead of trying to pull them over, and if they're nonresponsive and are not complying with directives, that the officer actually uses his vehicle or her vehicle to actually strike the subject vehicle and try to disable it.

338
00:54:12.760 --> 00:54:21.646
<v Michael Gianacco>We have seen in other jurisdictions where this has gone very wrong and resulted in injury either to the officer or to the subject.

339
00:54:22.226 --> 00:54:33.864
<v Michael Gianacco>And in fact, there was a case a number of years ago in Portland involving a van that ended up flipping over, and there was injury as a result of the deployment of a PIT maneuver against a van.

340
00:54:34.389 --> 00:54:56.195
<v Michael Gianacco>So The interesting thing here is that the officer recognized that the type of violation that the individual was suspected of committing did not meet the criteria to pursue the subject, but there are no similar guardrails with regard to engaging in a PIT maneuver.

341
00:54:56.244 --> 00:55:01.543
<v Michael Gianacco>So instead, the officer uses PIT maneuver to disable the subject.

342
00:55:01.882 --> 00:55:11.172
<v Michael Gianacco>It was successful in this case, but as a result, it resulted in the officer sort of being alone with this individual, and it took a while before help got there.

343
00:55:12.711 --> 00:55:30.394
<v Michael Gianacco>In our view, our recommendation— and this is a current policy— recommends that before a PIT maneuver is engaged in, that there be strong consideration of consulting a supervisor over the radio before doing that.

344
00:55:31.304 --> 00:55:32.974
<v Michael Gianacco>But there's no requirement that that be done.

345
00:55:33.784 --> 00:55:35.938
<v Michael Gianacco>That they get their supervisory approval.

346
00:55:36.521 --> 00:55:45.679
<v Michael Gianacco>Many jurisdictions that we work with have that requirement before a pit maneuver can be deployed for the various reasons that I've suggested.

347
00:55:47.335 --> 00:55:49.873
<v Michael Gianacco>And so that's what our recommendation here is in this case.

348
00:55:50.340 --> 00:55:52.461
<v Michael Gianacco>And I think that ends our recommendations.

349
00:55:52.976 --> 00:55:55.804
<v Julie Ruhlin>I think that, that's, that's all we have in terms of a presentation.

350
00:55:55.867 --> 00:56:02.128
<v Julie Ruhlin>We are really happy to answer your questions Thank you.

351
00:56:02.418 --> 00:56:12.820
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'll just clarify with the council president, I've seen 2 versions of this, uh, but I— we do need to also have PPB, uh, come up, and I, I wanted to verify with you that you'd like that before we open up the Q&A.

352
00:56:14.760 --> 00:56:16.668
<v Michael Gianacco>Honestly, I'll let you guys—.

353
00:56:16.701 --> 00:56:17.623
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we might do that.

354
00:56:17.898 --> 00:56:22.253
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and so I might have a little bit of musical chairs if you don't mind.

355
00:56:22.302 --> 00:56:23.978
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but thank you so much for the presentation.

356
00:56:25.364 --> 00:56:27.114
<v Sameer Kanal>We have a presentation.

357
00:56:27.291 --> 00:56:32.702
<v Sameer Kanal>I will note we're a little over time, so just flagging for our next presenters and for councilors as well.

358
00:56:33.297 --> 00:56:49.577
<v Sameer Kanal>And our next presenters to discuss the PPB response to the recommendation, I think we have Chief of Police Bob Day, Commander of the Professional Standards Division Jeffrey Bell, Captain of the Training Division David Jackson, and Andrew Jensen, who's a sergeant in the Specialized Resources Division.

359
00:56:50.039 --> 00:56:55.079
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, please let me know if you swap someone, um, but otherwise I'll hand it over to you, Chief.

360
00:56:55.079 --> 00:56:55.909
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for being here.

361
00:56:56.380 --> 00:56:57.039
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

362
00:56:57.039 --> 00:56:59.920
<v Bob Day>Uh, good afternoon, Council President, Vice President, councilors.

363
00:56:59.920 --> 00:57:00.599
<v Bob Day>I'm Bob Day.

364
00:57:00.599 --> 00:57:02.159
<v Bob Day>I'm Chief of Police for City of Portland.

365
00:57:02.659 --> 00:57:12.269
<v Bob Day>To my left, your right, is, uh, Commander Jeff Bell, Professional Standards Division, Captain Dave Jackson from our Training Division, and Sergeant Jensen oversees our drone program.

366
00:57:12.300 --> 00:57:16.440
<v Bob Day>Uh, grateful to be here, appreciate OIR and their good work.

367
00:57:16.440 --> 00:57:17.880
<v Bob Day>Um, we've been together a long time.

368
00:57:17.880 --> 00:57:21.418
<v Bob Day>I can remember when they started and And, you know, a little context.

369
00:57:21.498 --> 00:57:22.923
<v Bob Day>It's been about 16 years.

370
00:57:24.222 --> 00:57:26.016
<v Bob Day>They've reviewed 75 critical incidents.

371
00:57:26.161 --> 00:57:30.039
<v Bob Day>Bureau averages about roughly 200,000 calls a year.

372
00:57:30.568 --> 00:57:38.083
<v Bob Day>So, you know, some quick math there puts us in the several million range of calls for service, and 75 critical incidents are super important.

373
00:57:38.418 --> 00:57:50.443
<v Bob Day>But I also think it's important to remember in context that the good work that the men and women of Portland Police Bureau do every day in managing high-stress critical incidents that don't rise to the level level of force that is necessary for this outside review.

374
00:57:50.523 --> 00:57:51.458
<v Bob Day>But we welcome that.

375
00:57:52.940 --> 00:57:59.036
<v Bob Day>That same time period, some of the things we're gonna talk about today are just, you know, the ever-evolving changes in the Police Bureau.

376
00:57:59.117 --> 00:58:01.347
<v Bob Day>And just as context, there's been 9 chiefs.

377
00:58:01.396 --> 00:58:03.887
<v Bob Day>I'm the 10th chief since OIR started their first report.

378
00:58:04.452 --> 00:58:11.952
<v Bob Day>So that does factor into some of the recommendations and things that we've been trying to address under my leadership.

379
00:58:12.050 --> 00:58:16.635
<v Bob Day>None of those are to be taken as excuses, just simply some observations that I think are important.

380
00:58:17.862 --> 00:58:22.447
<v Bob Day>As we look at the entire context of what we're trying to address and improve upon.

381
00:58:22.510 --> 00:58:27.608
<v Bob Day>So both Mike and Julie, we've had a lot of conversations over the years, including this morning.

382
00:58:27.655 --> 00:58:30.413
<v Bob Day>I just appreciate and respect the work they do.

383
00:58:31.005 --> 00:58:41.503
<v Bob Day>And on a final note, should we still be here an hour and a half from now due to a scheduling conflict, I will need to step out at about 4:27 to take a phone call that wasn't anticipated as the setup.

384
00:58:41.568 --> 00:58:45.351
<v Bob Day>So not abandoning you, but you'll be in good hands from me.

385
00:58:45.431 --> 00:58:45.559
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

386
00:58:45.672 --> 00:58:47.117
<v Bob Day>The remainder of the time.

387
00:58:48.864 --> 00:58:52.393
<v Bob Day>So let's go ahead and just jump into our response to the recommendations.

388
00:58:52.458 --> 00:58:56.376
<v Bob Day>They've already covered them, and so we'll just kind of give you a little overview.

389
00:58:57.336 --> 00:59:02.353
<v Bob Day>The one regarding the pre-shooting tactical decision-making, we agree with this recommendation.

390
00:59:03.932 --> 00:59:11.222
<v Bob Day>I will say that, and I think it was highlighted in their report, that we do look at that in a training, from a training standpoint.

391
00:59:11.286 --> 00:59:11.447
<v Bob Day>Yes.

392
00:59:11.942 --> 00:59:19.746
<v Bob Day>But in terms of the yes/no decision-making policy piece, we're going to add that under our satisfactory performance.

393
00:59:19.971 --> 00:59:32.849
<v Bob Day>Section 2, the directive says this subject sets performance— this subsection sets performance standards for decision-making during confrontations and requires that members use sound tactics and good decision-making during a confrontation.

394
00:59:32.896 --> 00:59:35.112
<v Bob Day>So that will encompass the entire event.

395
00:59:35.161 --> 00:59:40.822
<v Bob Day>So we will be adopting this specific review, as you can see Okay.

396
00:59:40.871 --> 00:59:43.650
<v Bob Day>For the Internal Affairs Department, for the Internal Affairs reviews.

397
00:59:44.007 --> 00:59:50.188
<v Bob Day>So, and I'm just gonna go through these quickly for the sake of time and we can come back if you want.

398
00:59:50.728 --> 00:59:51.809
<v Bob Day>If something different, let me know.

399
00:59:51.875 --> 00:59:59.242
<v Bob Day>So number 2, evaluate the efficacy of parked vehicles box-in.

400
00:59:59.840 --> 01:00:04.289
<v Bob Day>We agree with this and we are putting that into practice.

401
01:00:04.516 --> 01:00:19.271
<v Bob Day>And Captain Jensen, excuse me, Captain Jackson can explain more as it relates to the training we've done over the last couple years But suffice it to say that we are in agreement with this evaluation, this recommendation, and have been implementing that.

402
01:00:19.353 --> 01:00:26.563
<v Bob Day>And we have training that we will be providing in the 2026 in-service to our members, so we can go into more detail to that if necessary.

403
01:00:28.177 --> 01:00:28.693
<v Bob Day>Next slide, please.

404
01:00:31.170 --> 01:00:33.878
<v Bob Day>Discrepancies between officer statements, physical evidence.

405
01:00:34.007 --> 01:00:34.362
<v Bob Day>We agree.

406
01:00:35.217 --> 01:00:40.751
<v Bob Day>We have a discrepancy section highlighted now in our process, so we are in—.

407
01:00:40.751 --> 01:00:41.025
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

408
01:00:41.762 --> 01:00:45.079
<v Bob Day>Agreement with that, and that is currently in practice.

409
01:00:46.277 --> 01:00:50.869
<v Bob Day>Number 4, PPB should work with BOEC.

410
01:00:51.610 --> 01:01:07.327
<v Bob Day>BOEC's response, speaking on behalf of Acting Director Modzley, but of course we have the subject matter experts sitting right behind me if DCA Causie wants to jump in, but we are in agreement and there has been additional training offered and received up at 911.

411
01:01:08.286 --> 01:01:19.501
<v Bob Day>Excuse me, specific to callers with suicidal ideology or suicidal intent, and then how that's communicated and relayed between the bureaus.

412
01:01:21.059 --> 01:01:21.755
<v Bob Day>Number 5.

413
01:01:24.248 --> 01:01:29.184
<v Bob Day>This is the recommendation requiring permission prior to a PIT.

414
01:01:29.264 --> 01:01:34.443
<v Bob Day>This is the singular recommendation that we have some disagreement on, and I'll go into a little bit more detail why.

415
01:01:35.081 --> 01:01:42.793
<v Bob Day>Once again, for perspective, rough numbers, we've seen about 230 recommendations come in from OIR in the time period we've been working with them.

416
01:01:42.873 --> 01:01:45.309
<v Bob Day>And I think we've adopted all but 7 of those.

417
01:01:45.422 --> 01:01:51.786
<v Bob Day>So it is unusual for us to not necessarily accept all of 'em, but we appreciate the recommendations.

418
01:01:51.833 --> 01:01:59.976
<v Bob Day>But they are recommendations as we look at other Bureau needs, community expectations, as well as my own vision direction for the organization.

419
01:02:00.954 --> 01:02:02.045
<v Bob Day>So a couple thoughts on this.

420
01:02:02.237 --> 01:02:06.405
<v Bob Day>One, rarely does a pursuit intervention technique happen in a vacuum.

421
01:02:06.501 --> 01:02:08.768
<v Bob Day>In other words, officers are generally on the air.

422
01:02:08.994 --> 01:02:13.945
<v Bob Day>They're describing the circumstances, the situation of which they're gonna make— take this action.

423
01:02:15.023 --> 01:02:18.818
<v Bob Day>So my confidence is that we have sergeants that are monitoring the air.

424
01:02:18.898 --> 01:02:34.985
<v Bob Day>If the sergeant hears something that is not appropriate or doesn't sound like it's in line or necessary, my expectation that they would be responsible for stepping up and, you know, so making sure that they exercise their authority, which they could, to say, no, that's not allowed.

425
01:02:36.724 --> 01:02:48.963
<v Bob Day>The part that's really more important to me from a cultural standpoint is that we have a tendency, particularly in bureaucratic organizations, to want to push things up versus push things down.

426
01:02:49.235 --> 01:02:53.597
<v Bob Day>And I like to see— a phrase that I use oftentimes in the organization is own your position.

427
01:02:53.806 --> 01:02:57.271
<v Bob Day>I like to see personal accountability for decision-making that we have.

428
01:02:57.318 --> 01:03:04.007
<v Bob Day>We train our officers in PIT, we train them what to look for, we expect them to be able to articulate that and manage that and then own that decision.

429
01:03:04.054 --> 01:03:04.199
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

430
01:03:04.775 --> 01:03:12.596
<v Bob Day>The sergeant is not going to be in position to evaluate whether anything that the officer's seeing is actually happening or not.

431
01:03:13.509 --> 01:03:16.425
<v Bob Day>They're simply relying upon what's being said over the radio.

432
01:03:17.130 --> 01:03:27.945
<v Bob Day>There may be occasions where the PIT needs to occur before that person can actually respond to be able to, you know, provide that if a sergeant isn't readily available.

433
01:03:28.570 --> 01:03:37.434
<v Bob Day>And the reasoning behind the PIT is to try and To try and prevent the weaponization of the vehicle, to try and take it out of the context so that it's safer for all.

434
01:03:38.827 --> 01:03:41.297
<v Bob Day>You know, this is a small distinction.

435
01:03:41.344 --> 01:03:42.884
<v Bob Day>I'm aware of agencies that do this.

436
01:03:42.947 --> 01:03:44.663
<v Bob Day>I'm aware of agencies that don't do this.

437
01:03:45.096 --> 01:03:47.869
<v Bob Day>This is not considered universal.

438
01:03:48.284 --> 01:03:59.184
<v Bob Day>And for me, it's really less about whether or not, you know, we accept or do not accept the recommendation, is more about what I'm trying to develop from a cultural standpoint.

439
01:03:59.329 --> 01:04:07.793
<v Bob Day>I want our officers to be responsible for their decision-making, and they will still be responsible even if they ask for supervisory approval.

440
01:04:08.722 --> 01:04:10.005
<v Bob Day>But I do not see the need for it.

441
01:04:10.085 --> 01:04:20.489
<v Bob Day>I believe that the process— and Captain Jackson can talk about our training around PIT— already encompasses the goal, which is to make sure that they're within policy, they're consistent with our training.

442
01:04:20.922 --> 01:04:29.181
<v Bob Day>I would finally add that all of our PIT techniques are considered use of force, so they're all reviewed through our after-action force reporting process.

443
01:04:29.650 --> 01:04:34.052
<v Bob Day>And as I said earlier, we're taking into consideration decision-making beforehand, et cetera, et cetera.

444
01:04:34.101 --> 01:04:40.393
<v Bob Day>So that would all be encumbered in that ultimate report as to whether or not it was in or out of policy.

445
01:04:40.458 --> 01:04:45.655
<v Bob Day>So this is the singular recommendation that we do have some disagreement with.

446
01:04:46.268 --> 01:04:46.929
<v Bob Day>Number 6.

447
01:04:49.092 --> 01:04:51.690
<v Bob Day>This is already partially in practice.

448
01:04:51.755 --> 01:04:58.923
<v Bob Day>We're in the process of making sure that we can, you know, better account for these action items.

449
01:04:59.132 --> 01:05:01.253
<v Bob Day>I thought Julie was very gracious.

450
01:05:01.382 --> 01:05:03.873
<v Bob Day>I think she said historically not included.

451
01:05:04.210 --> 01:05:09.190
<v Bob Day>We have failed in this area, and there really is no excuse for that.

452
01:05:09.271 --> 01:05:12.597
<v Bob Day>I mean, we have plenty of systems available, and there's certainly many today.

453
01:05:13.353 --> 01:05:14.557
<v Bob Day>We should be better at this.

454
01:05:14.733 --> 01:05:16.822
<v Bob Day>It's been a priority of mine since I've returned.

455
01:05:17.449 --> 01:05:18.525
<v Bob Day>Commander Bell has been leading this effort.

456
01:05:18.574 --> 01:05:18.686
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

457
01:05:19.795 --> 01:05:25.094
<v Bob Day>Both in the area of making sure that we have, you know, appropriate software and then we have the appropriate follow-through.

458
01:05:25.960 --> 01:05:33.523
<v Bob Day>One of the things that I recognize in sitting in this chair more so than my previous experience is just the transitory nature of the Bureau.

459
01:05:33.588 --> 01:05:35.418
<v Bob Day>People come and go so regularly.

460
01:05:36.317 --> 01:05:41.648
<v Bob Day>I was advised today that 75% of our Bureau has 10 years on or less, right?

461
01:05:41.695 --> 01:05:48.719
<v Bob Day>So I mean, 75% of the Police Bureau wasn't even working here When these events— not these events today, but when OIR started their relationship with us.

462
01:05:48.768 --> 01:05:55.675
<v Bob Day>So, you know, recognizing that it is so transitory and people come and go, hold numerous positions.

463
01:05:55.722 --> 01:05:57.148
<v Bob Day>I already mentioned the chief piece.

464
01:05:57.646 --> 01:05:59.119
<v Bob Day>None of that is acceptable.

465
01:05:59.184 --> 01:06:06.443
<v Bob Day>We have a responsibility when these recommendations come in to follow through with them, for them to be assigned, and for us to be able to point to completion.

466
01:06:06.956 --> 01:06:08.382
<v Bob Day>I do appreciate Julie's comments.

467
01:06:08.782 --> 01:06:13.516
<v Bob Day>I'm confident that many of these have But if you can't show your work, doesn't really matter.

468
01:06:13.871 --> 01:06:22.530
<v Bob Day>So just know that we are moving in this direction and hopefully sometime in the near future we can come back.

469
01:06:22.610 --> 01:06:24.125
<v Bob Day>Jeff can give a more full report.

470
01:06:24.188 --> 01:06:27.184
<v Bob Day>He's got some numbers and ideas around that.

471
01:06:27.505 --> 01:06:38.070
<v Bob Day>And then the final one, number 7, was already highlighted regarding the City Attorney and regarding litigation and the review of the report.

472
01:06:38.119 --> 01:06:49.224
<v Bob Day>So going forward, we will be be making sure that even if there's ongoing litigation, that OIR, whoever has that outside, whoever that outside entity is, has that information.

473
01:06:49.722 --> 01:06:54.987
<v Bob Day>The last thing I'll add, thank you, Councilor Avalos, for sending over a series of questions ahead of time.

474
01:06:55.052 --> 01:06:56.128
<v Bob Day>Appreciate that very much.

475
01:06:57.027 --> 01:07:04.862
<v Bob Day>We do have responses to that, not in a slideshow, but happy to address that either during Q&A or we can send you back an email or however you want to do that.

476
01:07:04.911 --> 01:07:05.039
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

477
01:07:05.250 --> 01:07:07.179
<v Bob Day>So, uh, appreciate that.

478
01:07:07.670 --> 01:07:10.239
<v Bob Day>Tried to make up a little time for you, Councilor.

479
01:07:10.239 --> 01:07:11.179
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chief.

480
01:07:11.179 --> 01:07:15.119
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so we're going to move into, uh, Q&A from, from councilors.

481
01:07:15.119 --> 01:07:19.559
<v Sameer Kanal>We may have a little bit of musical chairs, so I don't know if you want to have a couple folks stay and rotate.

482
01:07:19.880 --> 01:07:22.940
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but I'm going to pass it over to Councilor Novick to moderate that.

483
01:07:22.940 --> 01:07:28.639
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't actually have the gavel yet, so if you want it, you can talk to the council president about it, but I'll pass it over.

484
01:07:28.639 --> 01:07:36.686
<v Sameer Kanal>While just— I did want to also just note for the public and all this, uh, folks who are here that they're, you know, a lot of the the, the specifics in this are, are pretty heavy.

485
01:07:37.344 --> 01:07:50.010
<v Sameer Kanal>And as we're working through, um, reading the report, um, I think it's, it's going to be normal for people to have, uh, personal reactions to that, perhaps more so as we get into the public this evening at the CRC and tomorrow in the council meeting.

486
01:07:50.123 --> 01:07:52.097
<v Sameer Kanal>But I just wanted to acknowledge that, put it into this space.

487
01:07:52.708 --> 01:07:53.751
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll pass it over to my co-chair.

488
01:07:54.778 --> 01:07:56.721
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Co-Chair Kanal.

489
01:07:57.251 --> 01:08:01.327
<v Steve Novick>Um, so we're going to move into questions followed by council discussion.

490
01:08:01.423 --> 01:08:04.442
<v Steve Novick>Councilors, Or is that a legacy hand?

491
01:08:04.911 --> 01:08:05.733
<v Eric Zimmerman>No, no, that's great.

492
01:08:07.489 --> 01:08:08.614
<v Eric Zimmerman>Don't really know who's running this meeting.

493
01:08:08.871 --> 01:08:13.677
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, um, so I— thanks, Chief, for that rundown.

494
01:08:13.949 --> 01:08:18.793
<v Eric Zimmerman>My questions are actually 2, and I, I walked in after you all had introduced yourselves from the other group.

495
01:08:19.588 --> 01:08:22.251
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, on—.

496
01:08:22.298 --> 01:08:33.984
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm going to go to the recommendation regarding pre-tactical decision-making, and the first question I had there was when does Was this for OIR?

497
01:08:34.356 --> 01:08:34.487
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

498
01:08:34.762 --> 01:08:35.363
<v Bob Day>Yeah, right.

499
01:08:36.630 --> 01:08:39.436
<v Bob Day>So, uh, Jeff, why don't you and I just— we'll just kind of come back and forth.

500
01:08:39.485 --> 01:08:39.971
<v Bob Day>Let's do that.

501
01:08:44.311 --> 01:08:45.038
<v Eric Zimmerman>I said pre-tactical.

502
01:08:45.136 --> 01:08:47.448
<v Eric Zimmerman>I guess it's pre-shooting tactical decision-making.

503
01:08:47.497 --> 01:08:49.404
<v Eric Zimmerman>And my question is, when does that begin?

504
01:08:49.484 --> 01:08:53.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know it ends the moment a weapon is fired, right?

505
01:08:56.182 --> 01:08:57.555
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you for the question, Councilor.

506
01:09:03.398 --> 01:09:12.016
<v Michael Gianacco>The question is the pre-shooting decisions begin— can begin as early as the call for service.

507
01:09:13.291 --> 01:09:21.552
<v Michael Gianacco>And the way in which— and some of that responsibility is going to be at the dispatcher's, you know, behest.

508
01:09:21.666 --> 01:09:33.828
<v Michael Gianacco>But once that officer is dispatched or once that officer begins to make observations, with regard to suspected criminal activity or a need to engage with a subject, that's when the decision-making tree begins.

509
01:09:35.207 --> 01:09:59.609
<v Michael Gianacco>And all through that process, the approach, if there's a pursuit, the pursuit, the way in which the officer engages, if it's a vehicle stop, all of that, all of those decisions will lead up, can lead up and impact There is a concept that is becoming more and more considered.

510
01:09:59.609 --> 01:10:09.350
<v Michael Gianacco>In fact, the Supreme Court actually considered this in its last session, and that's this concept of what is called officer-created jeopardy.

511
01:10:09.369 --> 01:10:18.470
<v Michael Gianacco>And what that means is that an officer puts themselves in a situation that jeopardizes their own safety and then results in a results situation where they are not in control of the situation.

512
01:10:18.470 --> 01:10:22.284
<v Michael Gianacco>So if you're in a situation where you're in the officer feeling the need to use deadly force.

513
01:10:22.783 --> 01:10:39.833
<v Michael Gianacco>So in the case that the Supreme Court heard out of Texas, the officer had stopped an individual on the freeway and was engaging with that officer— with that individual on the freeway at the side of the road by the driver's door.

514
01:10:42.041 --> 01:10:47.252
<v Michael Gianacco>The driver decided he was going to move away, and so puts his car into gear.

515
01:10:47.783 --> 01:10:56.448
<v Michael Gianacco>And instead of the officer taking precautions and moving away from the incident, which was— I think he was stopped because he had outstanding tickets.

516
01:10:59.036 --> 01:11:04.238
<v Michael Gianacco>And instead of that, the officer jumps onto the floorboard of the car.

517
01:11:05.237 --> 01:11:06.219
<v Michael Gianacco>The car speeds away.

518
01:11:06.766 --> 01:11:23.332
<v Michael Gianacco>The officer is now in peril and then feels constrained So the incident that— at the moment that the officer used deadly force, clearly there was fear and justifiable fear that justifies the use of deadly force.

519
01:11:23.990 --> 01:11:29.225
<v Michael Gianacco>But it was the officer's decision that put him in peril that caused that decision to occur.

520
01:11:29.514 --> 01:11:30.831
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm well aware of the concept.

521
01:11:30.895 --> 01:11:34.346
<v Michael Gianacco>That's the example, Councilor Zimmerman, that I'm talking about.

522
01:11:34.572 --> 01:11:35.261
<v Eric Zimmerman>I understand that.

523
01:11:36.396 --> 01:11:39.997
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, so you said as early as maybe the call for service.

524
01:11:40.350 --> 01:11:44.627
<v Eric Zimmerman>You also, in your explanation of this recommendation, you talked a lot about training though.

525
01:11:46.037 --> 01:11:52.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>So to some extent it's even before that is how are we training decision-making to a little bit degree.

526
01:11:52.805 --> 01:11:54.965
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I don't want to complicate.

527
01:11:55.046 --> 01:12:00.860
<v Eric Zimmerman>But your point about the concept of officer-created jeopardy is I understand that.

528
01:12:03.855 --> 01:12:25.153
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I wasn't able to tell from your presentation is you used the term decision-making or decision to use force versus reaction, and that caught me because of sometimes we react based on training, and you could argue it's a decision.

529
01:12:26.396 --> 01:12:29.935
<v Eric Zimmerman>It can be hard to articulate the differences between different incidents.

530
01:12:30.020 --> 01:12:30.149
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

531
01:12:30.197 --> 01:12:38.970
<v Eric Zimmerman>There are instances when we are in that moment versus a more deliberate decision to use deadly force.

532
01:12:39.326 --> 01:12:56.494
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I hope that we can separate out those incidents because the reactionary decision-making, just from my own level of experience, is highly related Okay.

533
01:12:57.925 --> 01:13:02.567
<v Eric Zimmerman>And deliberate decision-making is highly related to policy.

534
01:13:04.045 --> 01:13:05.682
<v Eric Zimmerman>But that didn't really come off the pages.

535
01:13:05.730 --> 01:13:11.079
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I don't know when we're talking about these incidences what it is necessarily in terms of that piece of it.

536
01:13:11.127 --> 01:13:31.515
<v Eric Zimmerman>So from a where to take the chief's recommendations or his response to those recommendations on different pieces is a little hard to know what part of the organization we Can you talk a little bit, and I just caught the tail end when you were introducing yourselves, can you talk a little bit about on your team who your tactical experts, your subject matter experts are?

537
01:13:32.766 --> 01:13:52.220
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think you described yourself as a former federal prosecutor, but from, I'm wondering where in your evaluation is a tactical lens and a tactical experience used Do you have any tacticians?

538
01:13:53.989 --> 01:13:54.509
<v Michael Gianacco>Yes, Councilor.

539
01:13:55.078 --> 01:14:13.408
<v Michael Gianacco>I am a— I've been certified by numerous courts, administrative courts, federal courts, state courts, in criminal context, administrative context, as well as civil context, and have been certified as a use of force expert in all of those jurisdictions.

540
01:14:15.703 --> 01:14:16.890
<v Eric Zimmerman>And those are great credentials.

541
01:14:17.645 --> 01:14:20.617
<v Eric Zimmerman>Have you ever been in a tactical situation yourself?

542
01:14:21.403 --> 01:14:29.416
<v Michael Gianacco>I've gone through training and have certainly engaged in simulations and helped develop training with regard to tactical situations.

543
01:14:29.769 --> 01:14:29.881
<v Tracy Warren>Okay.

544
01:14:30.811 --> 01:14:31.278
<v Dave Jackson>It's helpful.

545
01:14:31.454 --> 01:14:44.818
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's a missing part of your organization because I think it's an important lens to have here for those who can describe I can describe what your heartbeat feels like in the moment, and it is just different than in training.

546
01:14:45.010 --> 01:14:48.887
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I wish that we had that perspective involved in your recommendations.

547
01:14:48.935 --> 01:14:57.076
<v Eric Zimmerman>It would help when the blood flows from your brain and you can't feel yourself and you see about this much of the aperture.

548
01:14:58.246 --> 01:15:08.886
<v Eric Zimmerman>None of that comes out in this, and I wish that it did because I think combining that with some of these recommendations would would be a strong additional lens.

549
01:15:12.606 --> 01:15:22.238
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really do appreciate that you brought up some of the decision— pre-decision-making in that, you know, I'll use the term you introduced, which was officer-created jeopardy.

550
01:15:26.409 --> 01:15:28.488
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm challenged, you know, that's the difference, right?

551
01:15:28.537 --> 01:15:34.592
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's the difference between stopping your patrol vehicle 20 feet away Right.

552
01:15:34.673 --> 01:15:41.713
<v Eric Zimmerman>That introduces that situation where force can be avoided if we avoid putting ourselves into a position.

553
01:15:41.762 --> 01:15:43.636
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's just an important part to get out here.

554
01:15:46.649 --> 01:15:48.952
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think this was the recommendation that we saw.

555
01:15:49.064 --> 01:15:56.014
<v Eric Zimmerman>You were hoping to have eventually a— to move the pre-decision, pre-shooting tactical decision-making into a yes/no.

556
01:15:56.177 --> 01:15:56.685
<v Eric Zimmerman>Did they follow?

557
01:15:56.750 --> 01:15:57.158
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes/no.

558
01:15:58.408 --> 01:16:03.532
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I am cautious with that.

559
01:16:04.326 --> 01:16:09.603
<v Eric Zimmerman>Your quote was, it's as simple as that, and I'll just tell you it's not.

560
01:16:09.829 --> 01:16:20.796
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm, I'm concerned that we use that kind of words here, not because it's not wrong that we should go through it, and I appreciate the nuance that the chief introduced here, but as simple as that.

561
01:16:20.909 --> 01:16:26.841
<v Eric Zimmerman>The thing is, is in this community, if there comes a report out that says an officer Thank you.

562
01:16:27.851 --> 01:16:42.796
<v Eric Zimmerman>Even though we say it's as simple as that, as whether or not you parked your vehicle 20 feet away or 10 feet away, there is, there is a loud voice in this community who'll say he violated a policy, she violated a policy, now can them and get them out of here.

563
01:16:43.662 --> 01:16:45.716
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I don't think that that's what you were recommending.

564
01:16:45.988 --> 01:17:06.271
<v Eric Zimmerman>You actually said it, we can retrain, we can talk about situations, but to put a yes/no category One, I don't think that we are mentally capable, organizationally capable of encompassing policy that will— or developing policy that will encompass every each that a person will encounter.

565
01:17:06.994 --> 01:17:15.694
<v Eric Zimmerman>But the way that the chief described it, which is more of a, was this in— were these behaviors prior to critical incidents?

566
01:17:15.823 --> 01:17:19.948
<v Eric Zimmerman>Were they— are they meeting my— as chief, I'm putting— I'm speaking as chief here.

567
01:17:20.092 --> 01:17:21.618
<v Eric Zimmerman>Were they meeting my standard that I expect of my officers?

568
01:17:21.682 --> 01:17:22.469
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a great way to put it.

569
01:17:22.550 --> 01:17:22.694
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

570
01:17:22.743 --> 01:17:30.337
<v Eric Zimmerman>Which is less of a yes/no on individual moments and more of a yes/no on the holistic actions from call to incident.

571
01:17:31.109 --> 01:18:01.057
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just, I offer that up because it came off a little bit like there should be the ability to do a yes/no along the checklist that would give me concern given how robust our public will get if we have one officer who did one thing that was Out of policy, but if the chief determined holistically that maybe they could have parked 50 feet away, but they only parked 20 feet away, that that caused a problem, that probably can be retrained.

572
01:18:01.814 --> 01:18:02.958
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I just kind of offer that up.

573
01:18:03.024 --> 01:18:05.279
<v Eric Zimmerman>It seemed to be lacking in what I saw there.

574
01:18:09.213 --> 01:18:15.025
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to thank you, Chief, for your explanation on the ownership at your level.

575
01:18:15.220 --> 01:18:16.844
<v Eric Zimmerman>I believe strongly in ownership at your level.

576
01:18:17.516 --> 01:18:23.270
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that the elevating of decisions is the scapegoating of good decision-making as well.

577
01:18:23.382 --> 01:18:27.823
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so there are some things that do, and I agree with you in your assessment of that.

578
01:18:28.416 --> 01:18:31.685
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that's the kind of officer that I hope we are enabling.

579
01:18:32.679 --> 01:18:38.786
<v Eric Zimmerman>But that comes with a host of training standards, cultural standards, et cetera.

580
01:18:38.833 --> 01:18:44.908
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I hear you loud and clear on that, and I didn't want that to be lost because I actually think that's how we have the safest city.

581
01:18:45.005 --> 01:18:45.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

582
01:18:46.770 --> 01:18:55.393
<v Eric Zimmerman>Most de-escalating force possible is if we elevate the empowerment of the person who interacts on the ground in the moment.

583
01:18:55.442 --> 01:18:57.640
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I thank you for responding in that way.

584
01:18:57.704 --> 01:19:01.414
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the presentation was generally very easy to track.

585
01:19:01.479 --> 01:19:02.250
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you both.

586
01:19:03.485 --> 01:19:08.287
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then also for the PPB, your responses were very clear of yes, kind of yes, no.

587
01:19:09.363 --> 01:19:10.229
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you for that.

588
01:19:10.310 --> 01:19:10.631
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Herbold.

589
01:19:12.632 --> 01:19:13.246
<v Steve Novick>President Dunphy.

590
01:19:13.310 --> 01:19:14.019
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

591
01:19:14.743 --> 01:19:23.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think my question might be for the chief with regard to the PIT maneuver recommendation and the change.

592
01:19:23.692 --> 01:19:33.699
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm recalling specifically a lawsuit that this body had to approve a while back in which a PIT maneuver was done against the wrong vehicle.

593
01:19:34.121 --> 01:19:36.681
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was a similar color and style, but it wasn't the right vehicle.

594
01:19:37.431 --> 01:19:38.394
<v Jamie Dunphy>Was that the incident?

595
01:19:38.457 --> 01:19:40.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>I mean, I don't know if we can use this, but I won't even ask.

596
01:19:41.840 --> 01:20:00.592
<v Jamie Dunphy>It may not be the incident in question here, but if we are rejecting the recommendation around supervisors for PIT, and I understand what a supervisor is going to be able to see, et cetera, et cetera, but if we are rejecting that, are we making policy changes in light of that specific lawsuit that we settled?

597
01:20:01.457 --> 01:20:05.047
<v Bob Day>Yeah, so that one you're speaking of is not part of the OIR review.

598
01:20:05.095 --> 01:20:10.619
<v Bob Day>It's separate from But Captain Jackson can provide maybe just a couple minutes of what we've been doing around PIT.

599
01:20:10.940 --> 01:20:22.261
<v Bob Day>I don't know if you can answer specific to that lawsuit, but do you want to be able to touch on just a couple of examples about recent PIT training and future PIT training that is on the schedule?

600
01:20:22.743 --> 01:20:27.432
<v Jeff Bell>Actually, Chief, if you don't mind, I can talk specifically about that particular case.

601
01:20:27.947 --> 01:20:32.877
<v Jeff Bell>That was an issue with decision-making and officers not identifying the correct vehicle.

602
01:20:34.170 --> 01:20:40.864
<v Jeff Bell>I don't believe that consulting with a sergeant would've made any difference, 'cause I think they would've said, no, we've got the right vehicle.

603
01:20:40.945 --> 01:20:44.773
<v Jeff Bell>And upon further review, it was clear that they did not, which is why.

604
01:20:45.081 --> 01:20:51.957
<v Jeff Bell>And so there were investigations, there was corrective action to go along with that.

605
01:20:52.890 --> 01:20:58.213
<v Jeff Bell>So obviously it involved a PIT, but not quite in the same context here.

606
01:20:58.261 --> 01:20:58.376
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

607
01:21:01.457 --> 01:21:01.573
<v Bob Day>Okay.

608
01:21:01.771 --> 01:21:13.310
<v Dave Jackson>And so to cover the, the PIT training, or pursuit vehicle operators training, our Advanced Academy, they currently go through around 34 hours, approximately 34 hours of training, and that's all patrol vehicle operations and all specific to PIT.

609
01:21:14.421 --> 01:21:17.331
<v Dave Jackson>But we have 2 full-time instructors out there that conduct this.

610
01:21:18.997 --> 01:21:23.938
<v Dave Jackson>They conduct in the Advanced Academy approximately 80 PITs, which is quite a few repetitions they're going through out on our pad.

611
01:21:25.591 --> 01:21:32.527
<v Dave Jackson>In addition, we do approximately a little over 2 hours in PVO training coming up in '26.

612
01:21:33.217 --> 01:21:42.836
<v Dave Jackson>And then in '27, we're also going to be— our plan is to go to PIR, Portland International Raceway, and do additional training out there in terms of high-speed driving, pit maneuvers.

613
01:21:43.751 --> 01:21:47.380
<v Dave Jackson>And that'll be coming in '27, and that'll be a full-day training for operations.

614
01:21:47.845 --> 01:21:49.498
<v Dave Jackson>So we're always training, we're always learning.

615
01:21:49.579 --> 01:22:00.100
<v Bob Day>And just to emphasize one final comment, I mean, they are Category 3 use of force, so everyone's going to be reviewed.

616
01:22:00.359 --> 01:22:03.079
<v Bob Day>And I just want to— one other comment, Councilor Kanal.

617
01:22:03.079 --> 01:22:17.279
<v Bob Day>I appreciate you recognizing the sensitivity of this conversation and regret that I didn't highlight that myself at the beginning when I was throwing out some of those statistics, because although it's 75 within the cast of millions of calls for service, those 75 are very important.

618
01:22:17.279 --> 01:22:17.340
<v Bob Day>Thank you, Mayor.

619
01:22:18.345 --> 01:22:21.078
<v Bob Day>And so I just appreciate you recognizing that.

620
01:22:21.141 --> 01:22:30.845
<v Bob Day>And I want you to hear from me and hear from the organization that was not in any way, shape, or form meant to dismiss the seriousness of the reviews that are being done.

621
01:22:30.911 --> 01:22:32.125
<v Bob Day>So thank you for highlighting that.

622
01:22:34.131 --> 01:22:34.375
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

623
01:22:34.634 --> 01:22:36.682
<v Jamie Dunphy>My last question is for OIR.

624
01:22:37.858 --> 01:22:42.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>In the past, there has been a recommendation from your reports about the 48-hour rule.

625
01:22:43.961 --> 01:22:50.851
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe that the 48-hour rule at that point when you recommended it, however many years ago, the recommendation was rejected by the chief at the time.

626
01:22:52.135 --> 01:23:02.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do you all ever reintroduce previous recommendations, or do you just sort of assume that, that if the leadership at the time says no, then it's no and we move forward?

627
01:23:03.198 --> 01:23:08.234
<v Jamie Dunphy>Or how are you thinking about that, and is that still something that you all would be recommending broadly?

628
01:23:09.229 --> 01:23:11.121
<v Michael Gianacco>Yeah, thank you for the question.

629
01:23:11.873 --> 01:23:19.395
<v Michael Gianacco>The answer is yes, we do come back at times times to engage again on a particular recommendation.

630
01:23:20.072 --> 01:23:21.600
<v Michael Gianacco>We still do have concerns.

631
01:23:21.680 --> 01:23:31.091
<v Michael Gianacco>I think ideally, in a perfect world, we would like to see interviews conducted more close in time to the event and still are of that view.

632
01:23:31.755 --> 01:24:11.568
<v Michael Gianacco>But we also recognize that every time we come back, we don't want to continue to hammer that same recommendation, although we will be revisiting it, I'm sure, if we are engaged in future And as an example of that, President— Council President, we initially made a recommendation that supervisors should ordinarily not get involved in tactical operations, especially if there are line officers on scene, that they should refrain and should be supervising the incident rather than engaging themselves.

633
01:24:12.355 --> 01:24:16.530
<v Michael Gianacco>That was initially made as a recommendation.

634
01:24:18.539 --> 01:24:23.559
<v Michael Gianacco>There wasn't real acceptance of that, so we came back, and eventually— and now there is acceptance.

635
01:24:23.671 --> 01:24:31.462
<v Michael Gianacco>And so now there is policy and guidelines that effectuate that recommendation that was made maybe in year 2.

636
01:24:31.994 --> 01:24:33.752
<v Michael Gianacco>Maybe it took year 7 before we got there.

637
01:24:35.234 --> 01:24:40.166
<v Bob Day>Jeff, can you speak to the interview 48-hour rule interview, just what the—.

638
01:24:40.551 --> 01:24:40.920
<v Steve Novick>What we're doing?

639
01:24:42.220 --> 01:24:52.331
<v Jeff Bell>Yeah, I, I— it's— I mean, it's a subject of bargaining, and so that, that's where the— and I've not been involved in any of the bargaining, but I, I know that's where, that's where the issue has, has been.

640
01:24:52.893 --> 01:24:56.729
<v Bob Day>Um, but we're interviewing, we're interviewing, we're interviewing within 48 hours.

641
01:24:57.162 --> 01:24:58.975
<v Bob Day>Yeah, we are interviewing within 48 hours.

642
01:24:59.072 --> 01:25:09.103
<v Jeff Bell>And, and prior to the recommendations, it was typically 72 to 96, so 3 to 4 Councilor Avalos.

643
01:25:15.177 --> 01:25:20.595
<v Tracy Warren>Okay, so, um, well, thank you, Chief, for, uh, letting me know that you've got some prepared answers.

644
01:25:20.725 --> 01:25:24.081
<v Tracy Warren>I think I will just bring some of them to the table here.

645
01:25:24.920 --> 01:25:36.527
<v Tracy Warren>Um, I was listening to the discussion around the pre-shooting tactical decision-making stuff and And I think my only other remaining question— well, 2, I guess.

646
01:25:36.671 --> 01:25:41.150
<v Tracy Warren>Can you tell me more about what you mean when you say partially in practice?

647
01:25:41.311 --> 01:25:43.414
<v Tracy Warren>Could you just explain what that looks like?

648
01:25:43.720 --> 01:25:53.368
<v Tracy Warren>And then I would love to hear if there are any specific barriers, policy, legal, or operational, that prevent the Bureau from adopting that recommendation in full.

649
01:25:54.476 --> 01:25:58.395
<v Bob Day>Well, just one example I give— I apologize, I was looking for where I put your questions here.

650
01:25:58.443 --> 01:25:59.694
<v Bob Day>I know they have them out in front of them.

651
01:26:00.512 --> 01:26:06.800
<v Bob Day>Regarding partially in practice, I don't ever want to come before you and, you know, overpromise and underdeliver.

652
01:26:06.847 --> 01:26:08.644
<v Bob Day>I try to be as transparent as possible.

653
01:26:08.771 --> 01:26:17.015
<v Bob Day>And so, for example, partially in practice on the tracking of recommendations, you know, we don't have that completely built.

654
01:26:17.095 --> 01:26:17.978
<v Bob Day>We're working on it.

655
01:26:18.057 --> 01:26:27.659
<v Bob Day>We have a software program, but I can't sit here and tell you that every recommendation that's come in in the last year through the various reviews is being It's somewhere.

656
01:26:27.659 --> 01:26:28.600
<v Bob Day>It's sitting somewhere.

657
01:26:29.260 --> 01:26:32.279
<v Bob Day>But so that's a reference to partially in practice.

658
01:26:32.279 --> 01:26:34.789
<v Bob Day>I want to be able to come back and say, here's what we're doing.

659
01:26:35.380 --> 01:26:37.439
<v Bob Day>Here's what— this happens, this happens, and then this happens.

660
01:26:37.439 --> 01:26:39.039
<v Bob Day>And we're just— we haven't been able to do that.

661
01:26:39.039 --> 01:26:41.840
<v Bob Day>Some of that is, you know, cleanup.

662
01:26:41.840 --> 01:26:45.880
<v Bob Day>This one recommendation I just referenced is one that OIR has brought forward in the past.

663
01:26:45.880 --> 01:26:48.380
<v Bob Day>Some of these are new recommendations, so we're responding to it.

664
01:26:48.380 --> 01:26:51.560
<v Bob Day>And I've mentioned before, you know, nimbleness and speed is not always not the answer.

665
01:26:52.014 --> 01:26:55.565
<v Bob Day>A strong suit of PPP at times, especially when it comes to new systems.

666
01:26:56.835 --> 01:27:06.694
<v Bob Day>But know that we're working on them and happy to come back, provide a 30, 60, 90-day, whatever feedback loop, just so you know that we're closing those gaps.

667
01:27:08.136 --> 01:27:09.818
<v Tracy Warren>That actually leads into one of my other questions.

668
01:27:09.914 --> 01:27:15.444
<v Tracy Warren>So let's expand on that a bit because, and as you noted, there's been 10 chiefs.

669
01:27:15.735 --> 01:27:20.320
<v Tracy Warren>And of course we know that with transition, things fall through the cracks for sure.

670
01:27:21.170 --> 01:27:26.585
<v Tracy Warren>I'm curious what, in general, who is like, who is the holder, right?

671
01:27:26.632 --> 01:27:31.487
<v Tracy Warren>Who is responsible for overseeing the recommendation tracking as a whole?

672
01:27:32.320 --> 01:27:37.030
<v Tracy Warren>And, you know, you're starting to say like you want to make sure that you can bring things back to us.

673
01:27:37.623 --> 01:27:45.682
<v Tracy Warren>I guess how do you think council will be informed about recommendations that are repeatedly identified but have remained unresolved?

674
01:27:46.179 --> 01:27:47.733
<v Bob Day>Yeah, so I don't say this flippantly.

675
01:27:47.796 --> 01:27:49.416
<v Bob Day>I mean, ultimately I'm the holder of all that.

676
01:27:49.479 --> 01:27:50.729
<v Bob Day>I always take that responsibility.

677
01:27:50.985 --> 01:27:53.877
<v Bob Day>That's certainly under my purview.

678
01:27:54.938 --> 01:27:58.006
<v Bob Day>But we also know that I'm not going to be able to hold everything.

679
01:27:58.150 --> 01:28:01.975
<v Bob Day>So right now we're relying upon the Professional Standards Division.

680
01:28:03.275 --> 01:28:05.797
<v Bob Day>And that's part of why it's partially in practice.

681
01:28:05.926 --> 01:28:08.689
<v Bob Day>I think a lot of stuff comes out of the Training Division as well.

682
01:28:08.753 --> 01:28:11.163
<v Bob Day>Those are the 2 primary receivers of it.

683
01:28:11.469 --> 01:28:17.878
<v Bob Day>But right now the direction is to the Professional Standards Commander to— We'll funnel everything to that position.

684
01:28:18.889 --> 01:28:24.931
<v Bob Day>So it does allow for a greater deal of oversight and accountability.

685
01:28:25.590 --> 01:28:32.018
<v Bob Day>And as those directions come out for so-and-so to follow up on this, you know, they're speaking on behalf of the chief.

686
01:28:32.082 --> 01:28:34.118
<v Bob Day>It's not like, oh, I just wish somebody would get to this.

687
01:28:34.181 --> 01:28:38.252
<v Bob Day>So we're trying to build in some structure to make sure that there's actual follow-through.

688
01:28:39.055 --> 01:28:41.106
<v Jeff Bell>And Chief, I can add to that a little bit.

689
01:28:41.490 --> 01:28:44.744
<v Jeff Bell>So it's real easy to say, yes, we accept it and we're going to work on it.

690
01:28:46.127 --> 01:28:48.795
<v Jeff Bell>I can tell you the actual plan, what we have.

691
01:28:48.859 --> 01:28:58.307
<v Jeff Bell>So we have been tracking recommendations from OIR reports from police review boards for at least 15 years that I can find records for.

692
01:29:00.304 --> 01:29:03.203
<v Jeff Bell>They've had different homes in different parts of the bureau.

693
01:29:03.266 --> 01:29:04.248
<v Jeff Bell>We're a large bureau.

694
01:29:04.716 --> 01:29:14.235
<v Jeff Bell>And as it's moved back and forth and people have moved, you know, it's, I, I'm just going to be honest, we haven't done a good job of maintaining that.

695
01:29:14.315 --> 01:29:30.670
<v Jeff Bell>So my plan going forward, I'm working with our policy group to develop a policy so that we actually have a directive in writing that future folks can refer to, that the public can refer to, that the council can refer to, that says this is what our process is when we get recommendations.

696
01:29:31.215 --> 01:29:34.020
<v Jeff Bell>Anybody in the bureau gets a recommendation, it will come to me.

697
01:29:34.405 --> 01:29:37.194
<v Jeff Bell>I have someone on my staff that will actively track those.

698
01:29:37.307 --> 01:30:04.731
<v Jeff Bell>We have a software solution actually in in SharePoint that we've got almost all built out with a workflow to make it really easy so that we can, when the chief or the deputy chief makes a decision, yes, we are going to do something with this, there's tracking, there'll be reporting so that we can report on, hey, OIR's 9th report, here's all the recommendations, here's what we've done, here's, you know, the policy that we developed because of that.

699
01:30:05.122 --> 01:30:05.319
<v Jeff Bell>But—.

700
01:30:06.323 --> 01:30:22.106
<v Jeff Bell>But again, I'm working with our directive, our policy folks to create a directive that actually says all this, that will designate people who are in charge so that— and again, these are real concrete steps to be able to be accountable for these recommendations.

701
01:30:22.154 --> 01:30:23.936
<v Jeff Bell>So that's where we're headed with this.

702
01:30:24.707 --> 01:30:26.779
<v Jeff Bell>We're actually just testing it out this week.

703
01:30:27.197 --> 01:30:30.167
<v Jeff Bell>We were actually working on it before the recommendations came out.

704
01:30:30.231 --> 01:30:31.259
<v Jeff Bell>We recognized the issue.

705
01:30:31.340 --> 01:30:46.007
<v Jeff Bell>That, um, and I appreciate, um, Julie's, uh, kind words about how— I mean, we believe most of this stuff has been, has been acted upon, um, but if we can't prove it, then I, I, you know, that, that, that doesn't help anybody.

706
01:30:46.072 --> 01:30:53.189
<v Jeff Bell>So, so these are the concrete plans going forward that we're trying to do so that we can be accountable for when we get recommendations.

707
01:30:53.688 --> 01:30:57.735
<v Jeff Bell>This is what— this is who we assigned it to, this is what we've done, and, and we can show our work.

708
01:30:57.784 --> 01:30:57.881
<v Dave Jackson>Thank you.

709
01:31:00.055 --> 01:31:00.846
<v Tracy Warren>Well, that sounds great.

710
01:31:01.041 --> 01:31:16.202
<v Tracy Warren>Sounds like you're on the right track, and good timing with the CBPA coming online, because I'm sure that's going to be a big part of your relationship, right, of just making sure that the public can understand the way you're implementing changes and also, you know, how, um, the effectiveness of those changes.

711
01:31:16.329 --> 01:31:17.712
<v Tracy Warren>I think it maybe is another layer.

712
01:31:17.824 --> 01:31:22.520
<v Tracy Warren>If I didn't— I don't know if you said that, but if not, another layer I'd love to explore in that reporting.

713
01:31:23.349 --> 01:31:27.505
<v Tracy Warren>Um, okay, I wanted to ask I wanted to ask something about within policy, right?

714
01:31:27.586 --> 01:31:30.162
<v Tracy Warren>This is kind of a constant quandary.

715
01:31:31.930 --> 01:31:32.783
<v Tracy Warren>I don't know what you want to call it.

716
01:31:33.234 --> 01:31:51.240
<v Tracy Warren>But I think that, you know, there are several incidents that were reviewed that are deemed within policy, even when OIR is saying that there was poor planning or unsafe positioning or officer-created jeopardy, rushed engagement that escalates risk, right?

717
01:31:51.502 --> 01:31:51.929
<v Tracy Warren>Yes.

718
01:31:52.880 --> 01:31:56.975
<v Tracy Warren>Responds to those findings by noting that it complied with existing policy and training.

719
01:31:57.474 --> 01:32:09.426
<v Tracy Warren>So I'm curious, tell me more about how does PPB distinguish between conduct that's within policy and conduct that reflects avoidable and poor tactical choices that nonetheless do lead to deadly force?

720
01:32:10.003 --> 01:32:20.204
<v Tracy Warren>And the follow-up to that is when OIR training identifies tactical shortcomings but a use of force is still deemed justified, how is that tension documented and addressed?

721
01:32:24.801 --> 01:32:25.809
<v Bob Day>So a couple things.

722
01:32:25.873 --> 01:32:29.416
<v Bob Day>You know, when you, you have policy, you have training, and then you have application.

723
01:32:30.381 --> 01:32:35.314
<v Bob Day>And the theory is that those are going to line up, like they should work in unison with one another.

724
01:32:35.862 --> 01:32:58.283
<v Bob Day>But we also recognize, and, and this is— I don't want to put words in Councilor Zimmerman's mouth, but this recognizes the significance of policy and the role of policy and how, um, you know, as it relates to training in the sense that policy needs to have the ability to encompass a greater set of circumstances, need to be able to encompass the entire context.

725
01:32:58.730 --> 01:33:02.832
<v Bob Day>And training is oftentimes we look at this event, we look at this event, we look at this event.

726
01:33:02.896 --> 01:33:05.701
<v Bob Day>And so it's not as if they're not in alignment.

727
01:33:05.796 --> 01:33:10.091
<v Bob Day>Policy is what the decision is going to be made around regarding discipline.

728
01:33:11.229 --> 01:33:14.176
<v Bob Day>But we know that there is room to move within that.

729
01:33:14.273 --> 01:33:16.948
<v Bob Day>And the courts have been clear about that when they, you know, Courts.

730
01:33:17.012 --> 01:33:20.634
<v Bob Day>I have Heidi Brown here, so she can correct me if I'm wrong, or maybe she stepped out.

731
01:33:20.698 --> 01:33:23.358
<v Bob Day>But sorry, maybe somebody.

732
01:33:23.886 --> 01:33:35.806
<v Bob Day>But the courts have been clear around the Graham standard, reasonableness, you know, things like that that allow us— sorry, Heidi— that allow us to have that flexibility within the policy.

733
01:33:36.302 --> 01:33:40.742
<v Bob Day>I will say, though, that it's really paramount to me that these things do line up.

734
01:33:40.886 --> 01:33:44.667
<v Bob Day>I mean, we don't want to have something— we can't have something in training that's not consistent with policy.

735
01:33:44.730 --> 01:33:44.907
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

736
01:33:45.115 --> 01:33:56.466
<v Bob Day>So yes, it is a broader area to work about, but the training is what we want to continue to refine and work on in many of the recommendations that they have made.

737
01:33:56.996 --> 01:34:00.463
<v Bob Day>And that is why we have such a review, a robust training review.

738
01:34:00.769 --> 01:34:02.407
<v Bob Day>We're not required to do the training review.

739
01:34:02.534 --> 01:34:11.269
<v Bob Day>As was highlighted, it's something very unique that we would go through it with such a fine-tooth comb and point out all the areas that we can improve upon from a training standpoint.

740
01:34:11.317 --> 01:34:11.429
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

741
01:34:12.225 --> 01:34:14.604
<v Bob Day>Most agencies look at it and go, is it in policy?

742
01:34:14.653 --> 01:34:15.511
<v Bob Day>Is it out of policy?

743
01:34:15.689 --> 01:34:17.792
<v Bob Day>Okay, that's what we're going to deal with.

744
01:34:17.872 --> 01:34:22.103
<v Bob Day>And so we've added this additional piece to highlight.

745
01:34:22.569 --> 01:34:30.969
<v Bob Day>So we know there's a discrepancy there, but we're also not going to use that in the— from the policy point, from the discipline standpoint.

746
01:34:31.033 --> 01:34:32.813
<v Bob Day>We need to stay within the boundaries of the policy.

747
01:34:34.966 --> 01:34:35.161
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

748
01:34:35.208 --> 01:34:36.355
<v Tracy Warren>That's helpful to understand.

749
01:34:36.984 --> 01:34:41.425
<v Tracy Warren>And, you know, especially the part of like how that tension is documented and reflected upon to reduce repetition.

750
01:34:43.409 --> 01:34:44.435
<v Tracy Warren>I think that repetition is really key.

751
01:34:44.500 --> 01:34:48.929
<v Tracy Warren>So I'd love to continue, you know, talking with you and hearing how you're addressing that.

752
01:34:49.649 --> 01:34:49.698
<v Tracy Warren>Right.

753
01:34:49.762 --> 01:34:54.992
<v Tracy Warren>All right, my last question is regarding mental health crises.

754
01:34:55.818 --> 01:35:01.547
<v Tracy Warren>And this is, you know, at the core, right, of a lot of the issues that we've struggled with in community.

755
01:35:01.645 --> 01:35:08.221
<v Tracy Warren>So at least 4 of the incidents reviewed involved individuals experiencing acute mental health crises or suicidal ideation.

756
01:35:08.739 --> 01:35:15.094
<v Tracy Warren>And you all note that there have been improvements in crisis negotiation and training and coordination with BOEC, which is great.

757
01:35:15.559 --> 01:35:20.438
<v Tracy Warren>And you all noted as well that it's in practice, you all are adhering to those recommendations.

758
01:35:21.015 --> 01:35:30.692
<v Tracy Warren>But can you tell me a little more about how PPB is evaluating when a situation has reached the limits of what police-led intervention can safely accomplish?

759
01:35:31.286 --> 01:35:45.069
<v Tracy Warren>And especially what it looks like for officers or supervisors to slow down or shift strategy when it becomes apparent that police engagement might Yeah, and I appreciated that question.

760
01:35:45.164 --> 01:35:45.726
<v Bob Day>I saw that earlier.

761
01:35:45.838 --> 01:35:54.180
<v Bob Day>It was probably the single question that challenged me the most to be— because I've never been succinct in much of anything I say— but try and be succinct.

762
01:35:54.246 --> 01:36:05.908
<v Bob Day>I mean, this is a conversation I would love to expand with you and your office because, well, it's so relevant and prevalent to what we're doing right now, but it also has a massive amount of complexity to it.

763
01:36:05.957 --> 01:36:17.170
<v Bob Day>And as I read that a couple of times and thought I don't have a yes or no or a finite point on it right now, but the things that you highlighted do factor into that.

764
01:36:17.170 --> 01:36:33.729
<v Bob Day>The expectations we have around de-escalation, the expectations that we have around our enhanced training with, you know, that you've already highlighted, our expectations around just that ongoing community sensitivity to, you know, is this person, you know, experiencing a crisis.

765
01:36:33.729 --> 01:36:36.590
<v Bob Day>I mean, there are so many factors that are going into this because it is a very complex issue.

766
01:36:36.590 --> 01:36:38.771
<v Bob Day>I is think it's important to note that a daily challenge for us.

767
01:36:38.851 --> 01:36:44.467
<v Bob Day>If you ever listen to the police radio, I rarely hear a call come out that doesn't have a mental health component to it.

768
01:36:44.949 --> 01:36:49.908
<v Bob Day>So your question, very specific about sort of where is that moment in time, I don't have that.

769
01:36:50.244 --> 01:36:57.240
<v Bob Day>But I do have an expectation, and I believe our training and policy continues to drive us to try and find that finer point.

770
01:36:57.626 --> 01:37:03.018
<v Bob Day>Um, and these reviews that are being done right here provide information into that.

771
01:37:03.097 --> 01:37:06.323
<v Bob Day>So it's why it's critical we keep Thank you.

772
01:37:06.386 --> 01:37:07.686
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, I know it's a hard question.

773
01:37:07.734 --> 01:37:11.971
<v Tracy Warren>I just wanted to raise it and, and also so that my colleagues can kind of grapple with it too.

774
01:37:12.020 --> 01:37:16.737
<v Tracy Warren>And it's definitely a policy discussion that we need to have about how we're filling some of those gaps.

775
01:37:16.818 --> 01:37:34.676
<v Tracy Warren>And I'll just leave you with, um, you know, I would love to see some analysis on how you are assessing repeated, uh, encounters with individuals, um, who are in crisis and how those are indicators of broader system gaps beyond policing that we need to be addressing.

776
01:37:35.591 --> 01:37:45.716
<v Tracy Warren>And so I just want to flag that I really, I would love to engage with the Bureau on how to fill that gap with some of the other solutions that I know many councilors have been putting forward.

777
01:37:45.764 --> 01:37:49.470
<v Tracy Warren>We're going to get into budget discussions soon, so I just wanted to lift that up.

778
01:37:49.694 --> 01:37:57.332
<v Tracy Warren>And thank you, I appreciate the work that you all have been doing to try to fill some of those gaps with your training and your crisis negotiation and all that.

779
01:37:57.814 --> 01:38:00.862
<v Tracy Warren>But definitely still an area that we need to continue to improve on.

780
01:38:01.567 --> 01:38:02.769
<v Tracy Warren>Uh, that's all my questions for today.

781
01:38:02.881 --> 01:38:03.234
<v Tracy Warren>Oh, did you have a—.

782
01:38:03.234 --> 01:38:07.159
<v Bob Day>Just clarify one thing on that last comment, uh, analysis, repeated encounters.

783
01:38:07.496 --> 01:38:15.588
<v Bob Day>So I know one of these cases was a repeated encounter, um, where, you know, officer had been with the person before, had been able to escalate, and the second time around didn't.

784
01:38:15.668 --> 01:38:21.550
<v Bob Day>But, you know, deferred to that officer the second time around in an attempt because they believe that he might have a rapport.

785
01:38:22.078 --> 01:38:33.920
<v Bob Day>Um, and, um, so those are the kind of things you're looking for in terms of kind of like, you know, people that we're, that we're having repeated encounters with and kind of can we show, you know, various outcomes, something to that effect.

786
01:38:34.000 --> 01:38:35.041
<v Bob Day>I'm just clarifying.

787
01:38:35.313 --> 01:38:37.733
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, I think it just speaks to the broader issue.

788
01:38:38.117 --> 01:38:47.345
<v Tracy Warren>Like, it, it kind of intersects with, um, for example, how officers are now engaging with the unhoused population and, you know, where does that overlap appear, right?

789
01:38:47.409 --> 01:39:08.274
<v Tracy Warren>If you're engaging with somebody in crisis, whether it's in crisis because they're housing unstable and that creates crisis, whether there's mental health issues, just trying to understand like what it looks like for you all to document repeated encounters with people and where there might be off-ramps for, you know, you all as a bureau to say, okay, we've had this person for these reasons multiple times.

790
01:39:08.578 --> 01:39:18.033
<v Tracy Warren>What are the other avenues or other tools that we have to address it so that it doesn't continue to escalate each time you have to have an encounter with that person, right?

791
01:39:18.096 --> 01:39:18.145
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah.

792
01:39:18.193 --> 01:39:26.792
<v Tracy Warren>So just recognizing the intersectionality of all the issues that we're dealing with, especially with folks on the streets and want to brainstorm some policy solutions.

793
01:39:27.131 --> 01:39:27.503
<v Bob Day>Yeah, great.

794
01:39:27.632 --> 01:39:28.213
<v Bob Day>Okay, thank you.

795
01:39:28.376 --> 01:39:28.730
<v Tracy Warren>Sounds good.

796
01:39:28.828 --> 01:39:29.409
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you so much.

797
01:39:31.529 --> 01:39:33.412
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Koyama Lane, who I inadvertently overlooked.

798
01:39:33.798 --> 01:39:34.265
<v Steve Novick>My apologies.

799
01:39:34.685 --> 01:39:35.216
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Totally fine.

800
01:39:36.213 --> 01:39:38.145
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, all of you, for being here.

801
01:39:38.243 --> 01:39:42.025
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This feels very helpful, and I appreciate your commitment to your work.

802
01:39:43.377 --> 01:39:53.644
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I also want to say, Chief Day, and to your chief, Mr. King, I really appreciate how responsive you are and how open you are to conversations.

803
01:39:54.902 --> 01:40:03.987
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am surprised at how quickly you all will respond to me and how you're open to have conversations, even ones that are not easy.

804
01:40:04.199 --> 01:40:05.626
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So thank you very much.

805
01:40:07.967 --> 01:40:11.569
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>One of my first questions is around mental health responses for OIR.

806
01:40:12.523 --> 01:40:22.484
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I believe 3 or 4 different ones were highlighted, and I agree with the assessment that Mr. Tran's case outcome means he fits into that.

807
01:40:23.015 --> 01:40:29.162
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can we hear a bit more about the definitions and how you evaluate whether or not events relate to mental health?

808
01:40:31.560 --> 01:40:36.779
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yeah, I mean, it's sort of, you just have to look at all of the circumstances, right?

809
01:40:37.104 --> 01:40:51.100
<v Julie Ruhlin>With Mr. Tran's case, the officers, you know, there was no indication that there was a mental health component there.

810
01:40:52.051 --> 01:40:56.597
<v Julie Ruhlin>But I think the outcome speaks to the fact that there was.

811
01:40:56.662 --> 01:41:01.599
<v Julie Ruhlin>So, you know, it's— there's no clean way to categorize that.

812
01:41:01.792 --> 01:41:09.350
<v Julie Ruhlin>I mean, the best I can say is we often will look at, like, what did the officers know going in and what would— or should have known?

813
01:41:09.447 --> 01:41:11.220
<v Julie Ruhlin>You know, how could— what information was available to them?

814
01:41:11.315 --> 01:41:11.944
<v Julie Ruhlin>Councilor Smith.

815
01:41:12.817 --> 01:41:24.207
<v Julie Ruhlin>To help people, you know, to aid in that assessment that could have said, okay, this isn't— this is not just somebody who's, you know, robbing a store.

816
01:41:24.287 --> 01:41:25.793
<v Julie Ruhlin>This is somebody who's in crisis.

817
01:41:26.377 --> 01:41:41.750
<v Julie Ruhlin>And that, you know, there's still the criminal component in these cases often, but I think the officer's approach can and should often be different when they recognize that there's that mental health component.

818
01:41:41.800 --> 01:41:42.015
<v Julie Ruhlin>Councilor Smith.

819
01:41:42.275 --> 01:41:45.198
<v Julie Ruhlin>I don't know if that is helpful.

820
01:41:46.386 --> 01:41:46.787
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

821
01:41:47.734 --> 01:42:00.837
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I appreciated how the report raised the idea of handling situations where police are not necessarily interacting with someone with a gun, but maybe someone who's operating a vehicle or someone with a sharp object.

822
01:42:01.319 --> 01:42:06.826
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can we hear how the decision to use use of force might be different in these different cases?

823
01:42:10.212 --> 01:42:19.072
<v Julie Ruhlin>I think, you know, those are 2 very different— the, the shooting at cars is kind of a subcategory in itself, and, and there's so many different considerations.

824
01:42:19.681 --> 01:42:32.472
<v Julie Ruhlin>The, the presence of a knife or some kind of edged weapon, again, that's a— there's very sort of specific kind of tactical considerations that you look at, uh, when, when that's present.

825
01:42:32.841 --> 01:42:42.453
<v Julie Ruhlin>Um, so Do you— I mean, should we break it down each one, or are you just sort of saying, you know, something that's— how do you approach something that's not a gun?

826
01:42:43.270 --> 01:42:47.282
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I mean, and this can also be for either if PPB wants to respond to.

827
01:42:47.715 --> 01:42:50.811
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's all about the threat assessment, essentially, right?

828
01:42:50.891 --> 01:42:56.314
<v Julie Ruhlin>You know, what is the threat posed and what needs to be our response to that threat?

829
01:42:57.149 --> 01:42:57.373
<v Dan Ryan>Correct.

830
01:42:57.565 --> 01:42:59.331
<v Bob Day>Dave, do you want to touch on any of that from a training perspective?

831
01:42:59.716 --> 01:43:01.113
<v Dave Jackson>And that's just training.

832
01:43:01.162 --> 01:43:03.604
<v Dave Jackson>That's, you know, everything kind of interweaves together.

833
01:43:03.668 --> 01:43:08.359
<v Dave Jackson>I mean, it's control tactics, that's going to be patrol procedures, it's going to be, you know, our firearms program.

834
01:43:08.408 --> 01:43:15.122
<v Dave Jackson>It's all going to be how they kind of intersect and kind of how you're assessing that, and then kind of how it all applies to GRAM and policy or directives.

835
01:43:15.894 --> 01:43:21.355
<v Bob Day>And what Dave's referring to is we went to a model a few years back where we now integrate all of that.

836
01:43:21.420 --> 01:43:28.743
<v Bob Day>So if you are on the range, it's not just about being on the range, it's about incorporating all of these other aspects.

837
01:43:28.806 --> 01:43:32.256
<v Bob Day>So it's not— they're not happening independent of one another.

838
01:43:32.641 --> 01:43:38.689
<v Bob Day>You take what happens in control tactics or patrol procedures or whatever, and they all intersect.

839
01:43:38.753 --> 01:43:52.167
<v Bob Day>And so that we are trying to demonstrate, I think, to get to your point, Councilor, is, you know, so that they're equipped and prepared to make the appropriate evaluation based upon the facts presented in front of them.

840
01:43:52.215 --> 01:43:52.327
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

841
01:43:52.520 --> 01:43:57.097
<v Bob Day>Versus saying, well, if this or this or this— no, but more of a holistic looking.

842
01:43:57.389 --> 01:44:03.974
<v Bob Day>We really are asking our officers to do the impossible, but we want them to look at the whole entirety to the best of their ability.

843
01:44:06.119 --> 01:44:19.930
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, and kind of where this came from was page 15, the quote where it says, and with so many other PBB officer-involved shootings we've reviewed, this case raises questions about the options officers have when responding to subjects with knives or other edged, uh, weapons.

844
01:44:20.125 --> 01:44:29.844
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Was just— thought that that kind of opened up some interesting conversation around the other options, and if, if anyone wanted to expand, but that's fine if kind of that's it.

845
01:44:29.972 --> 01:44:44.916
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yeah, yeah, I, I think we have seen a number of, uh, these officer-involved shootings that involve subjects with edged weapons, and it's a, it's a, you know, it, it's an issue that law enforcement everywhere is Yes.

846
01:44:45.171 --> 01:44:46.823
<v Julie Ruhlin>Sort of grappling with.

847
01:44:47.238 --> 01:44:54.707
<v Julie Ruhlin>And, you know, um, there aren't always great, um, responses, right?

848
01:44:54.850 --> 01:45:03.631
<v Julie Ruhlin>I mean, sometimes there are tasers and there are, there are less lethal tools that sometimes work and sometimes don't.

849
01:45:03.680 --> 01:45:11.146
<v Julie Ruhlin>But if you're— if you've got someone charging at you with a knife, can you rely on a taser to maybe work or not?

850
01:45:11.612 --> 01:45:15.257
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's, um, it's a challenge, right?

851
01:45:15.322 --> 01:45:19.726
<v Julie Ruhlin>Because the knife can do a lot of damage and can kill someone.

852
01:45:20.520 --> 01:45:30.323
<v Julie Ruhlin>Um, and, and so the, the training in is that you respond to a deadly threat, you know, in, in the way that your training teaches.

853
01:45:30.435 --> 01:45:45.051
<v Julie Ruhlin>And, and there aren't— I know that there have been various tools that people are out there marketing and trying to use to address how do you subdue somebody with a knife.

854
01:45:45.747 --> 01:45:49.841
<v Julie Ruhlin>And they all— there's no easy answer to that.

855
01:45:50.036 --> 01:45:52.367
<v Julie Ruhlin>There really hasn't been a great solution.

856
01:45:56.454 --> 01:45:58.463
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My last question is more for PPB.

857
01:45:58.545 --> 01:46:05.786
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The report mentioned kind of a theme that there could have been better communication and planning among officers before coordinating actions.

858
01:46:06.583 --> 01:46:12.139
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>As well as situations where it wasn't clear who the incident commander was for a specific response.

859
01:46:12.203 --> 01:46:20.118
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm just wondering if anyone wants to speak to this and share actions that have been or could be taken to improve this, to mitigate this.

860
01:46:21.193 --> 01:46:26.539
<v Bob Day>Yeah, and I think we have some of that training we've done, training we've done since then.

861
01:46:26.957 --> 01:46:35.128
<v Dave Jackson>Yeah, so currently a lot of our training, we end up going through a scenario-based training as well, usually at our end service as well as our Advanced Academy as well as the Basic Academy.

862
01:46:35.176 --> 01:46:41.551
<v Dave Jackson>So it kind of gives people those building blocks in terms of identifying a leader, whether that's a supervisor on scene or if a supervisor's not on scene.

863
01:46:42.546 --> 01:46:46.417
<v Dave Jackson>But then we also— our Sergeant's Academy, it's an 80-hour Sergeant's Academy.

864
01:46:46.480 --> 01:46:50.703
<v Dave Jackson>Part of that is, you know, critical incident management, going through that process.

865
01:46:50.800 --> 01:47:08.810
<v Dave Jackson>We now send everybody who's actually on our sergeant's list— so that would be people who are either in an acting capacity or want to be sergeants— so we've been Then we also have people going through ICS training, which is the incident command structure that's put on by FEMA.

866
01:47:08.810 --> 01:47:15.590
<v Dave Jackson>So that way it kind of sets up that as well as far as organizational compartmentalizing different incidents.

867
01:47:15.590 --> 01:47:20.880
<v Dave Jackson>And you can build those incidents out either from 2-officer response all the way out to a big tactical event.

868
01:47:21.449 --> 01:47:27.970
<v Bob Day>So when I'm driving around and I'm listening to the police radio, one of the things that I'm listening to on these critical incidents is exactly that, Councilor.

869
01:47:27.970 --> 01:47:28.170
<v Bob Day>You know, how are they coordinating with the fire department?

870
01:47:29.735 --> 01:47:33.396
<v Bob Day>How are they coordinating, identifying resources?

871
01:47:34.569 --> 01:47:38.117
<v Bob Day>Yesterday, I listened as going to an evening meeting, but State Police got on the air.

872
01:47:38.181 --> 01:47:41.039
<v Bob Day>They were behind somebody with stolen license plates on their car.

873
01:47:41.152 --> 01:47:42.934
<v Bob Day>So Portland officers are responding.

874
01:47:42.998 --> 01:47:44.251
<v Bob Day>So I'm like, okay, what's our role?

875
01:47:44.765 --> 01:47:45.487
<v Bob Day>Who's in charge?

876
01:47:45.568 --> 01:47:51.957
<v Bob Day>Who's got— I mean, so those are things that we're really growing into, but there are always going to be areas that we're going to need to emphasize.

877
01:47:52.215 --> 01:47:55.088
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

878
01:47:58.635 --> 01:48:01.523
<v Steve Novick>I've got a question for Michael and Julie.

879
01:48:01.859 --> 01:48:06.769
<v Steve Novick>Michael, first of all, I want to tell you that we share the experience of having once worked for the Justice Department.

880
01:48:06.912 --> 01:48:15.112
<v Steve Novick>I was with the Civil Enforcement Section of the Environment Division, so we've both been having the experience of watching our once proud divisions gutted over the past year.

881
01:48:16.538 --> 01:48:27.055
<v Steve Novick>The question I have for the two of you is, several months ago I stumbled across an article that indicated that there are huge disparities between jurisdictions as to how often the police shoot people.

882
01:48:27.793 --> 01:48:35.295
<v Steve Novick>As I recall, the data I saw indicated that if you live in St. Louis, you're 150 times as likely to be shot by the police as if you live in New York City.

883
01:48:35.889 --> 01:48:46.779
<v Steve Novick>And I was wondering if you were familiar with any research on what those disparities are and if there's any indication that there's policy or training differences which account for those huge disparities.

884
01:48:47.457 --> 01:48:53.347
<v Steve Novick>I mean, does New York have some secret don't-shoot-people training or policy sauce that we should be emulating?

885
01:48:55.358 --> 01:49:03.905
<v Michael Gianacco>Appreciate the question, and I also appreciate our shared experience to see how the federal government has gone about its business these days.

886
01:49:09.314 --> 01:49:12.637
<v Michael Gianacco>But there needs to be more work done.

887
01:49:15.863 --> 01:49:32.858
<v Michael Gianacco>One of the things that is very difficult in this arena of trying to evaluate data across agencies is that, one, many agencies are reluctant and sometimes intentionally reluctant to provide that information.

888
01:49:33.844 --> 01:49:39.323
<v Michael Gianacco>So there, for example, is no national database on officer-involved shootings that anyone can truly compare across agencies.

889
01:49:39.371 --> 01:49:39.904
<v Michael Gianacco>I think that's a good point.

890
01:49:40.970 --> 01:49:47.704
<v Michael Gianacco>The best databases that have been collected in that arena are ones that have been done by media sources, which is unfortunate.

891
01:49:49.750 --> 01:49:51.886
<v Michael Gianacco>And so that's a problem.

892
01:49:52.210 --> 01:50:00.185
<v Michael Gianacco>The other problem is that the way in which this information is reported locally by various jurisdictions varies.

893
01:50:00.557 --> 01:50:07.145
<v Michael Gianacco>So for example, we were asked to do an evaluation of taser use across the state of California.

894
01:50:09.756 --> 01:50:13.228
<v Michael Gianacco>And that information in many of the counties is there.

895
01:50:13.456 --> 01:50:14.498
<v Michael Gianacco>Some of it isn't there.

896
01:50:15.069 --> 01:50:21.470
<v Michael Gianacco>But then the way in which it's reported, the way in which it's counted varies, and then it makes it very difficult.

897
01:50:21.810 --> 01:50:55.996
<v Michael Gianacco>To get to your question though, with that preface, is that I do think that there is a correlation between the number of people who are incarcerated Training, hiring, supervision, and those robust and careful consideration in all 3 areas, I think, do contribute to the less likelihood that there will be a deadly force incident in any particular jurisdiction.

898
01:50:56.755 --> 01:51:02.777
<v Michael Gianacco>And Bureau recognizes this and I think is continuing to work in all 3 capacities.

899
01:51:02.824 --> 01:51:02.953
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

900
01:51:04.145 --> 01:51:25.346
<v Michael Gianacco>In contrast to a jurisdiction I will not name, uh, in those areas where there's very little supervision, insufficient training that's being collapsed, and no real hiring standards anymore, what do you think is going to happen with regard to uses of force and uses of deadly force?

901
01:51:25.813 --> 01:51:26.970
<v Michael Gianacco>It's not going to be good.

902
01:51:27.211 --> 01:51:28.447
<v Michael Gianacco>It's not going to be a good ending.

903
01:51:28.720 --> 01:51:38.282
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Thank you, and I hope it'll be okay, although you're not being paid for this, I might give you a call and follow up on this discussion subsequently.

904
01:51:38.345 --> 01:51:39.212
<v Steve Novick>Yes, you may, sir.

905
01:51:39.469 --> 01:51:39.869
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

906
01:51:40.430 --> 01:51:41.136
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Clark.

907
01:51:42.501 --> 01:51:43.961
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

908
01:51:45.180 --> 01:51:51.082
<v Olivia Clark>Just, I want to check my takeaways from today, and first of all, thank you all.

909
01:51:51.500 --> 01:51:56.043
<v Olivia Clark>I think the materials that you provided us were excellent, easy to understand, Thank you.

910
01:51:56.092 --> 01:52:02.762
<v Olivia Clark>It was very intense, particularly for a civilian that doesn't have experience with police, but they were excellent.

911
01:52:03.180 --> 01:52:19.037
<v Olivia Clark>So my takeaways, very high level, there are lots of specific ones, but from your presentation, I think I heard that our Bureau is very responsive, that they've invested in training, and most recently in de-escalation.

912
01:52:21.172 --> 01:52:30.485
<v Olivia Clark>And in fact, what I think I heard you say is that we're ahead of the curve compared to other cities and other bureaus around the country.

913
01:52:32.210 --> 01:52:35.640
<v Olivia Clark>So our bureau's leadership is proactive.

914
01:52:36.171 --> 01:52:38.313
<v Olivia Clark>And I guess I wanted to ask you a question.

915
01:52:38.362 --> 01:52:40.310
<v Olivia Clark>Maybe it's unfair, you can't answer this.

916
01:52:40.390 --> 01:52:47.011
<v Olivia Clark>It kind of keys off of Councilor Novick, but would you consider our police bureau a progressive bureau?

917
01:52:51.056 --> 01:52:58.351
<v Michael Gianacco>At the risk of insulting other clients and other engagements that we have, I would say that.

918
01:52:59.703 --> 01:53:01.297
<v Michael Gianacco>Maybe I would say it in a different way.

919
01:53:02.859 --> 01:53:11.332
<v Michael Gianacco>When we began our engagement with the Bureau, and this is true in other organizations as well, there was a lot of low-hanging fruit, if you will.

920
01:53:11.850 --> 01:53:17.851
<v Michael Gianacco>There were a lot of things that definitely deserved consideration and change and reform.

921
01:53:18.483 --> 01:53:19.453
<v Michael Gianacco>And even at the beginning of that engagement, Yes.

922
01:53:21.301 --> 01:53:27.524
<v Michael Gianacco>The bureau leadership, you know, 9 chiefs ago was also responsive to our suggestions.

923
01:53:28.841 --> 01:53:38.913
<v Michael Gianacco>I would say that one way of looking at it is now we are involved in oversight at sort of a graduate level instead of Oversight 101, which is good.

924
01:53:39.331 --> 01:53:42.458
<v Michael Gianacco>That doesn't mean you cannot continue to get better and improve.

925
01:53:42.939 --> 01:53:48.650
<v Michael Gianacco>And one of the things we appreciate in working with the bureau is their interest in continuing to get better and better and better.

926
01:53:48.795 --> 01:53:48.890
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

927
01:53:51.525 --> 01:53:53.748
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

928
01:53:53.796 --> 01:53:55.118
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that answer.

929
01:53:58.640 --> 01:54:03.351
<v Steve Novick>Before we continue, I've got notes reminding me to take a 10-minute break at some point.

930
01:54:03.431 --> 01:54:10.971
<v Steve Novick>I'm curious whether people think that we need a bio break or that we think that we can conclude the questions and discussion in short enough time that that's not worthwhile.

931
01:54:12.502 --> 01:54:13.716
<v Steve Novick>How many think we need a break?

932
01:54:15.060 --> 01:54:16.140
<v Steve Novick>Um, couple do.

933
01:54:16.542 --> 01:54:17.573
<v Steve Novick>Okay, a couple is enough.

934
01:54:18.154 --> 01:54:22.055
<v Steve Novick>So let's take 6 minutes and come back at 3:56.

935
01:54:23.377 --> 01:54:23.716
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

936
01:54:30.569 --> 01:54:31.925
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

937
02:01:29.067 --> 02:01:32.134
<v Steve Novick>It appears that we are mostly back We're back.

938
02:01:32.198 --> 02:01:34.735
<v Steve Novick>So let's get going again.

939
02:01:35.474 --> 02:01:37.802
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal, you were next in the queue.

940
02:01:38.204 --> 02:01:39.907
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, we're coming back.

941
02:01:39.987 --> 02:01:45.207
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I have my questions and I have a bunch of comments for later, but we'll do the questions now.

942
02:01:45.270 --> 02:01:49.863
<v Sameer Kanal>They're all OIR-related, I think, although IPR might get one of them sort of on the side.

943
02:01:50.650 --> 02:01:55.838
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to why this one, the gap between this report and the previous one, was longer than before?

944
02:01:57.520 --> 02:02:09.520
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm trying to understand how we can build a system that gets more timely responses because— and I don't put the blame on you, I'm just trying to address it because I think these incidents are 3.5 to 6 years ago is the range of what we're talking about here.

945
02:02:09.923 --> 02:02:13.251
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't know if this is an IPR contracting question, so that's why I wanted to flag it.

946
02:02:13.703 --> 02:02:15.430
<v Julie Ruhlin>It was a little bit of a contracting question.

947
02:02:15.496 --> 02:02:28.863
<v Julie Ruhlin>So, you know, I think the way these cycles work is you can sort of Just renew the contract for a certain number, and then at some point there has to be an entirely new contract.

948
02:02:29.488 --> 02:02:47.219
<v Julie Ruhlin>And between our last report and the next contract, I think that was like, I don't exactly know, there was a long time that passed between when the next contract got finalized.

949
02:02:47.619 --> 02:02:48.533
<v Julie Ruhlin>Was a piece of legislation.

950
02:02:48.757 --> 02:02:49.640
<v Bob Day>Okay.

951
02:02:49.770 --> 02:02:53.046
<v Sameer Kanal>Do you know when— what the next cycle is right now, or is that still in progress?

952
02:02:53.302 --> 02:02:59.726
<v Julie Ruhlin>Uh, it's, you know, our contract is done, uh, in, I think, January 31st.

953
02:02:59.920 --> 02:03:03.998
<v Julie Ruhlin>So, um, it— I'm not sure where that gets taken up.

954
02:03:05.461 --> 02:03:07.146
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll follow up offline about that.

955
02:03:07.435 --> 02:03:10.872
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, in your other cities, do you review other types of incidents?

956
02:03:11.612 --> 02:03:14.037
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, you do deadly force here, officer-involved shootings.

957
02:03:14.100 --> 02:03:17.360
<v Sameer Kanal>Are there other types of police incident that you review?

958
02:03:18.051 --> 02:03:18.453
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do.

959
02:03:18.533 --> 02:03:22.595
<v Julie Ruhlin>We're engaged in, in various ways in different jurisdictions.

960
02:03:23.255 --> 02:03:36.358
<v Julie Ruhlin>There are some places where we serve as the independent police auditor, and we get complaints from the public and help shepherd those through an internal investigation process.

961
02:03:37.466 --> 02:03:49.333
<v Julie Ruhlin>We look at, we look at uses of force routinely that are, you know, non-deadly uses of in other jurisdictions and do audits or reports on those.

962
02:03:49.462 --> 02:03:59.805
<v Julie Ruhlin>So there are some places where we are very engaged in all internal affairs investigations, not just things relating to critical incidents.

963
02:04:00.109 --> 02:04:00.319
<v Michael Gianacco>Yes.

964
02:04:00.591 --> 02:04:00.929
<v Michael Gianacco>Thanks.

965
02:04:02.213 --> 02:04:09.505
<v Sameer Kanal>There are 2 cases in this where officers used chemical weapons to get a person to leave their vehicle.

966
02:04:10.787 --> 02:04:12.310
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wanted to ask this.

967
02:04:12.407 --> 02:04:16.958
<v Sameer Kanal>One of those is the one in which a person committed suicide as part of it.

968
02:04:17.376 --> 02:04:18.305
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you comment?

969
02:04:18.497 --> 02:04:27.762
<v Sameer Kanal>There's not much on the specific question around the use of chemical weapons, broadly, or about the use of it as a tactic to get people to exit their vehicles.

970
02:04:27.859 --> 02:04:28.659
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to that?

971
02:04:29.637 --> 02:04:35.905
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yeah, I mean, it is a common practice if there is the need to get somebody out of a vehicle.

972
02:04:36.371 --> 02:04:43.887
<v Julie Ruhlin>And I think the The question for us is, you know, what steps are taken before that decision?

973
02:04:44.546 --> 02:04:48.569
<v Julie Ruhlin>What kind of preparations are being made for when the person does come out, right?

974
02:04:48.618 --> 02:04:51.496
<v Julie Ruhlin>Like, how are you ready for when they come out?

975
02:04:52.536 --> 02:04:58.944
<v Julie Ruhlin>And, you know, have you exhausted all other possibilities, other ways to get the person out?

976
02:04:59.009 --> 02:05:01.585
<v Julie Ruhlin>So, and, you know, what is the exigency, right?

977
02:05:01.649 --> 02:05:02.103
<v Julie Ruhlin>Like, is it—.

978
02:05:02.103 --> 02:05:02.631
<v Julie Ruhlin>Councilor Smith.

979
02:05:02.886 --> 02:05:05.436
<v Julie Ruhlin>How do you need to get— why do you need them out?

980
02:05:06.438 --> 02:05:08.666
<v Julie Ruhlin>What other things have you done to try to get them out?

981
02:05:09.037 --> 02:05:17.011
<v Julie Ruhlin>And how have you prepared for their coming out if that's what's gonna happen when you introduce the chemicals?

982
02:05:17.837 --> 02:05:18.516
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks.

983
02:05:18.564 --> 02:05:20.457
<v Sameer Kanal>I might wanna follow up with you offline on that.

984
02:05:20.506 --> 02:05:25.646
<v Sameer Kanal>I think I'll add my name to the list with Councilor Novick about following up.

985
02:05:27.189 --> 02:05:30.208
<v Sameer Kanal>On page 63, you talk about the training division recommendation.

986
02:05:30.917 --> 02:05:32.972
<v Sameer Kanal>You talk about the lack of a formal mechanism.

987
02:05:33.037 --> 02:05:34.850
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate the chief's candor on that.

988
02:05:35.269 --> 02:05:52.497
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to ask if you had specific recommendations for what that new system would be for PPB, and also if you had thoughts on recommendations for non-PPB processes to review the training division recommendations, given that our new police oversight system has policy recommendation functions.

989
02:05:52.930 --> 02:05:53.171
<v Sameer Kanal>Right.

990
02:05:53.235 --> 02:05:55.564
<v Sameer Kanal>That'll be coming online in a couple weeks here.

991
02:05:55.949 --> 02:05:56.206
<v Julie Ruhlin>Right.

992
02:05:56.686 --> 02:06:04.048
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yeah, I mean, I just think it's important that the training division makes a lot of really thoughtful recommendations.

993
02:06:04.145 --> 02:06:07.626
<v Julie Ruhlin>They're very much into the details of these cases.

994
02:06:08.475 --> 02:06:15.581
<v Julie Ruhlin>And, you know, some of them are just things that they can do on their own, you know, and they're almost like recommendations to themselves.

995
02:06:15.628 --> 02:06:17.442
<v Julie Ruhlin>In our next training, we need to do this.

996
02:06:17.779 --> 02:06:17.875
<v Julie Ruhlin>Sure.

997
02:06:17.954 --> 02:06:29.686
<v Julie Ruhlin>But some of them are things that maybe require broader bureau involvement or that might require additional or that might, you know, involve some new piece of equipment.

998
02:06:30.510 --> 02:06:42.613
<v Julie Ruhlin>And those are things that just, we think the bureau as a whole, and not just the training division, needs to be evaluating and saying yes or no.

999
02:06:43.100 --> 02:06:46.931
<v Julie Ruhlin>We think this is a good idea, and this is what we're going to do to move forward with it.

1000
02:06:48.555 --> 02:06:56.458
<v Julie Ruhlin>I think, you know, Commander Bell's talked about the new approach they have for tracking those, and I think that will be important.

1001
02:06:57.069 --> 02:07:16.543
<v Julie Ruhlin>Um, I, I— yeah, it's really about creating that sort of formal list of what's coming out of this and, and what actions are we expecting to be taken, what is the deadline for taking that action, and, and just formalizing that out of each of these.

1002
02:07:17.923 --> 02:07:18.180
<v Olivia Clark>Thanks.

1003
02:07:18.404 --> 02:07:19.622
<v Sameer Kanal>Did that get I think so.

1004
02:07:19.943 --> 02:07:23.228
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I'm— I think it's a longer conversation or it's this.

1005
02:07:23.452 --> 02:07:24.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>I feel like—.

1006
02:07:24.332 --> 02:07:24.381
<v Michael Gianacco>Yeah.

1007
02:07:24.654 --> 02:07:35.595
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and then the, the last question I had was about the 3rd recommendation, and I want to stress that, um, I actually think that practice on the whole is stronger than the recommendation.

1008
02:07:36.668 --> 02:07:53.081
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, that's my, my question about it, and I, I want to be clear on that because we reviewed an incident where, um, regardless of the finding on whether or not there was misconduct, the police bureau, uh, issued discipline because the officer had, uh, because of the discrepancies in the investigation.

1009
02:07:53.193 --> 02:07:59.207
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's what I mean when I say PPB practice seemed to me to be higher than the recommended level here.

1010
02:07:59.305 --> 02:08:08.431
<v Sameer Kanal>So your quote is, where photographic or forensic evidence conflicts with an officer's account of the incident, the bureau's investigation should examine and ask the officer to explain the potential discrepancy.

1011
02:08:08.832 --> 02:08:20.871
<v Sameer Kanal>And as I noted in that example I just gave, the, the bureau has, uh, rules where dishonesty is itself misconduct, independent of whatever the under And in that particular example, as well as many others, that has come up.

1012
02:08:21.256 --> 02:08:30.275
<v Sameer Kanal>So my question is, ask the officer to explain, is that a strong enough recommendation, or are we— it almost seemed like it was lowering the suggested standard for PBB.

1013
02:08:31.648 --> 02:08:44.179
<v Michael Gianacco>Yeah, Councilor, I would answer your question this way, and that is what we would have liked to have seen at the outset is a more specific recommendation.

1014
02:08:45.000 --> 02:08:54.229
<v Michael Gianacco>In this case, I don't think there was because it was a non-hit, but the detectives do an initial investigation.

1015
02:08:54.600 --> 02:09:01.680
<v Michael Gianacco>At some point during the internal investigation, the officer is routinely interviewed.

1016
02:09:01.680 --> 02:09:10.600
<v Michael Gianacco>And in that interview, that's where I think there was a shortcoming, in that the officer wasn't afforded the opportunity to, hey, look at this truck here, look at this person here, look at this vehicle here.

1017
02:09:11.229 --> 02:09:19.354
<v Michael Gianacco>And explain to me that if you were in front of the truck thinking you were being aggressed upon when you shot, well, why are the bullet holes all in the side of the truck?

1018
02:09:19.740 --> 02:09:22.936
<v Michael Gianacco>That's the kind of question you want, and maybe the officer has an explanation.

1019
02:09:23.595 --> 02:09:27.385
<v Michael Gianacco>I wouldn't jump necessarily to the fact that the officer was being dishonest.

1020
02:09:27.867 --> 02:09:35.817
<v Michael Gianacco>In the heat of the moment, split-second decision, a lot of moving parts, there may be a reasonable explanation for that.

1021
02:09:36.122 --> 02:09:39.286
<v Michael Gianacco>But in our view, that wasn't sufficiently plumbed during that initial investigation.

1022
02:09:39.333 --> 02:09:39.622
<v Michael Gianacco>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1023
02:09:40.618 --> 02:09:41.197
<v Sameer Kanal>That makes sense.

1024
02:09:41.519 --> 02:09:43.398
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for clarifying the immediacy of that.

1025
02:09:44.088 --> 02:09:50.273
<v Sameer Kanal>My last question was, you talked through the process of who you speak to, and it's a lot about different parts of PPBA.

1026
02:09:50.432 --> 02:09:53.002
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously, I know that you speak to IPR as well.

1027
02:09:53.083 --> 02:10:02.511
<v Sameer Kanal>As part of this process, when you're sort of reviewing reviews, do you speak to other parts of the review process, like members of the PRB, members of the CRC?

1028
02:10:02.720 --> 02:10:11.354
<v Sameer Kanal>Should we expect that if you continue if we end up renewing the contract, that you'd be speaking eventually to CBPA members who are part of this evaluation?

1029
02:10:11.677 --> 02:10:13.618
<v Sameer Kanal>Or is that outside the scope of what you do?

1030
02:10:15.351 --> 02:10:19.234
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yeah, we, you know, we look at the written documents.

1031
02:10:20.108 --> 02:10:24.297
<v Julie Ruhlin>I don't think that it— we never have reached out and spoken to a PRB member.

1032
02:10:24.345 --> 02:10:24.970
<v Julie Ruhlin>It's not really—.

1033
02:10:25.090 --> 02:10:25.738
<v Michael Gianacco>Yes, we have.

1034
02:10:27.429 --> 02:10:28.466
<v Julie Ruhlin>Okay, never mind.

1035
02:10:28.935 --> 02:10:29.260
<v Julie Ruhlin>I mean—.

1036
02:10:29.260 --> 02:10:35.238
<v Michael Gianacco>Councilor Kanal, yeah, yeah, there were times and there still are times that we had some concerns about the PRB process.

1037
02:10:37.554 --> 02:10:44.484
<v Michael Gianacco>And in fact, we did talk to the civilian members of the process as part of our review process when we were looking at that particular piece.

1038
02:10:44.949 --> 02:10:46.233
<v Michael Gianacco>So that is true.

1039
02:10:46.779 --> 02:10:50.148
<v Michael Gianacco>We regularly talk to CRC members about the output of our report.

1040
02:10:50.307 --> 02:10:51.960
<v Michael Gianacco>We're going to be doing that later this evening.

1041
02:10:52.729 --> 02:10:54.479
<v Michael Gianacco>So we do engage regularly with that.

1042
02:10:54.880 --> 02:11:02.083
<v Michael Gianacco>And then we also engage, particularly at the time of the release of our report, with any general member of the public who wants to talk to us in any way.

1043
02:11:02.372 --> 02:11:02.708
<v Michael Gianacco>Thank you.

1044
02:11:02.805 --> 02:11:19.779
<v Michael Gianacco>In fact, there have been times in which during those meetings we have talked to individuals related to individuals who have been killed as a result of deadly force incidents, and they have appreciated that transparency that we've been able to give as part of our assignment.

1045
02:11:19.828 --> 02:11:21.586
<v Michael Gianacco>So I do not see that as outside our scope.

1046
02:11:21.974 --> 02:11:25.109
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, and I'm assuming as well that you're speaking to the non-sworn folks.

1047
02:11:25.158 --> 02:11:31.435
<v Sameer Kanal>I think— forgive me if I forget his name, but I think it's Christopher Was over at the PRB.

1048
02:11:31.613 --> 02:11:32.595
<v Bob Day>He went to work for fire.

1049
02:11:33.046 --> 02:11:34.993
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, that's unfortunate.

1050
02:11:35.154 --> 02:11:39.600
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, but when he was there, I think he was the, uh, the coordinator of the PRB for a while.

1051
02:11:39.664 --> 02:11:41.564
<v Sameer Kanal>So I assume you talked to folks like that as well.

1052
02:11:41.840 --> 02:11:42.423
<v Michael Gianacco>That is correct.

1053
02:11:42.569 --> 02:11:42.878
<v Michael Gianacco>Yes, sir.

1054
02:11:42.992 --> 02:11:43.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great.

1055
02:11:43.625 --> 02:11:45.439
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thank you, and I'll pass it back to you, Coach.

1056
02:11:45.810 --> 02:11:49.819
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1057
02:11:50.801 --> 02:11:51.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1058
02:11:51.929 --> 02:11:53.925
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just have a couple of questions.

1059
02:11:54.037 --> 02:11:55.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here today, all of you.

1060
02:11:57.042 --> 02:12:06.737
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And before I ask my questions, Councilor Kanal, you were asking about what comes next for this review, and you didn't quite say we should keep this going, but I think you implied it.

1061
02:12:06.817 --> 02:12:07.938
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm going to say—.

1062
02:12:08.097 --> 02:12:08.643
<v Sameer Kanal>We should keep this going.

1063
02:12:08.722 --> 02:12:19.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope that this is a practice that we continue even under our new forms of accountability, even under our new form of government, even if we are not required to in the future.

1064
02:12:19.635 --> 02:12:24.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it's helpful just to have the transparency of an outside Thank you.

1065
02:12:24.779 --> 02:12:26.494
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1066
02:12:26.832 --> 02:12:32.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You were asked a somewhat subjective question earlier, and I'm, I'm going to continue us in the direction of subjective questions.

1067
02:12:34.371 --> 02:12:42.664
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You've looked at, between the two of you, a lot of different police departments across the country, some bigger, some smaller, some similarly sized.

1068
02:12:44.011 --> 02:12:49.882
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How has our response and our follow-up been compared to other entities?

1069
02:12:49.947 --> 02:12:58.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what I'm trying to understand because we're a new body here, is, is our response timely?

1070
02:12:58.399 --> 02:12:59.029
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is it thorough?

1071
02:12:59.420 --> 02:13:10.153
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When you come back and do a next iteration of a report, are you seeing the same mistakes happening even if we say on paper that we've changed policy, or are you seeing improvement?

1072
02:13:11.572 --> 02:13:29.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is this working, and is it working enough as we hold ourselves up to how things are going I would say that generally, generally speaking, the level of responsiveness is high.

1073
02:13:29.380 --> 02:13:38.130
<v Michael Gianacco>The commitment, I think, to evaluating our recommendations and then deciding whether or not to implement or accept them is also high.

1074
02:13:39.300 --> 02:13:47.640
<v Michael Gianacco>I am not unhappy, for example, in this group of recommendations, that one of the recommendations wasn't completely implemented.

1075
02:13:47.640 --> 02:13:47.760
<v Michael Gianacco>I think that's a good thing.

1076
02:13:51.407 --> 02:13:52.756
<v Michael Gianacco>That's fine for us.

1077
02:13:53.511 --> 02:14:05.634
<v Michael Gianacco>What we don't like is when a mayor or somebody in another jurisdiction receives our report and says, you know, we looked at this report and within 24 hours all the recommendations will be implemented.

1078
02:14:06.289 --> 02:14:07.082
<v Michael Gianacco>That's a bad sign.

1079
02:14:07.453 --> 02:14:11.872
<v Michael Gianacco>That means to me that the report's going into a bookshelf and never coming out again.

1080
02:14:12.615 --> 02:14:14.686
<v Michael Gianacco>And that's exactly what happened in the one case I'm talking about.

1081
02:14:14.752 --> 02:14:15.140
<v Michael Gianacco>I think that's a good point.

1082
02:14:15.729 --> 02:14:19.250
<v Michael Gianacco>So I don't have a problem with that.

1083
02:14:19.636 --> 02:14:34.206
<v Michael Gianacco>I would say, and Chief Day has already mentioned this, and I do think that the revolving chairs at the leadership level of the organization over the past 10 years has, I think, caused there to be a lack of continuity.

1084
02:14:34.722 --> 02:14:41.634
<v Michael Gianacco>So, you know, we'll engage with one chief, and then by the time we come back, there's 2 more chiefs that have, you know, come and gone.

1085
02:14:41.682 --> 02:14:49.548
<v Michael Gianacco>And so the representations made by that chief Chief, you know, don't necessarily get put into a memo for the successor.

1086
02:14:50.337 --> 02:14:52.365
<v Michael Gianacco>And I do think that has been a continuity issue.

1087
02:14:53.729 --> 02:14:55.865
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chief.

1088
02:14:55.947 --> 02:15:00.592
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Some of the recommendations in the report, it says, are partially implemented.

1089
02:15:01.670 --> 02:15:03.743
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Presumably that means there's more work to do.

1090
02:15:04.944 --> 02:15:19.738
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What does that timeline look like, and are there things that you What do you need us to do as council in terms of directives on policy that would help you to make sure you can fully implement the recommendations that you believe should be implemented?

1091
02:15:21.212 --> 02:15:23.440
<v Bob Day>I really wish I would've anticipated that question.

1092
02:15:23.890 --> 02:15:24.546
<v Bob Day>Sorry.

1093
02:15:24.739 --> 02:15:27.913
<v Bob Day>Because it's an excellent question and I just don't have an answer.

1094
02:15:28.409 --> 02:15:33.154
<v Bob Day>But it's very reasonable and I'm gonna have to— we're gonna have to dig into that.

1095
02:15:34.197 --> 02:15:39.822
<v Bob Day>As we were going over these recommendations and our responses, It didn't occur to me, but it's a very valid question.

1096
02:15:39.886 --> 02:15:43.988
<v Bob Day>So let's— let me get back and we can send something out in writing.

1097
02:15:44.037 --> 02:15:46.984
<v Bob Day>We'll work through Bree to get something out to everybody.

1098
02:15:47.417 --> 02:15:48.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd love to see follow-up on that.

1099
02:15:49.003 --> 02:15:49.484
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1100
02:15:49.581 --> 02:15:53.795
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I appreciate you owning the buck stopping with you on implementation.

1101
02:15:54.452 --> 02:16:10.635
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also think that under the new form of government, to some extent, ensuring that these recommendations outlast you takes some responsibility for So I hope that through our Community and Public Safety Committee, we're able to do the follow-up and maybe sit down with you.

1102
02:16:11.506 --> 02:16:20.542
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You tell us the right amount of time based on what you need for that implementation, but a year from now, whatever that is, at some interim period to say, have these been fully implemented?

1103
02:16:20.591 --> 02:16:21.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How are we doing?

1104
02:16:21.930 --> 02:16:22.871
<v Bob Day>Yeah, no, I appreciate that.

1105
02:16:22.918 --> 02:16:24.769
<v Bob Day>That's a great, great thing to highlight.

1106
02:16:25.759 --> 02:16:25.855
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1107
02:16:25.921 --> 02:16:26.246
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

1108
02:16:28.680 --> 02:16:28.971
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Ryan.

1109
02:16:30.256 --> 02:16:39.808
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Novick, and thank you, OIR, Portland Police Bureau leadership, and my fellow colleagues on council for this really helpful dialogue we're having today.

1110
02:16:40.210 --> 02:16:46.296
<v Dan Ryan>I've been through a few of these, and I would say this one seems the most thorough, and I appreciate that.

1111
02:16:47.034 --> 02:16:54.549
<v Dan Ryan>I want to also do something real quick here, and that's, um, I found attending the Police Community Academy— it was a year ago— uh, was so helpful.

1112
02:16:55.350 --> 02:16:56.629
<v Dan Ryan>And I do have a question.

1113
02:16:56.888 --> 02:16:59.304
<v Dan Ryan>And when is your next— when is the next one?

1114
02:16:59.742 --> 02:17:02.869
<v Dan Ryan>And of course, encouraging my colleagues to consider attending.

1115
02:17:06.380 --> 02:17:06.961
<v Dave Jackson>So I can answer.

1116
02:17:07.010 --> 02:17:10.512
<v Dave Jackson>Our next one is scheduled for April of 2026.

1117
02:17:10.560 --> 02:17:11.707
<v Dave Jackson>I can look up the exact date.

1118
02:17:11.754 --> 02:17:13.061
<v Dave Jackson>And then same with November.

1119
02:17:13.481 --> 02:17:16.128
<v Dave Jackson>So we can make sure to get an email out with those exact dates for you.

1120
02:17:16.192 --> 02:17:17.822
<v Dave Jackson>But we have 2 planned for 2026.

1121
02:17:18.144 --> 02:17:18.370
<v Dan Ryan>Right.

1122
02:17:18.790 --> 02:17:27.691
<v Dan Ryan>There was something about doing That training, and that allowed me to experience these reports now in a bit with a deeper lens, and I just want to acknowledge that.

1123
02:17:27.885 --> 02:17:33.763
<v Dan Ryan>And I know that Councilor Novick was there as well, and I'm sure others might have participated in this in the past.

1124
02:17:34.325 --> 02:17:42.115
<v Dan Ryan>My question is in the complex category of mental health, which I often place under behavioral health, which so it includes both mental health and addictions.

1125
02:17:42.742 --> 02:17:52.043
<v Dan Ryan>Um, Chief Day, you made it clear in some earlier conversations that— I don't know if your word was many, but most incidences, um, often have a mental health component.

1126
02:17:52.123 --> 02:17:53.245
<v Dan Ryan>Was that a fair statement?

1127
02:17:53.727 --> 02:17:54.639
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, yes.

1128
02:17:55.889 --> 02:18:23.119
<v Dan Ryan>And that, that should not surprise any of us because we reside in the state of Oregon, in the county of Multnomah, where we are known across the country, unfortunately, as having a very poor ranking in terms of mental health and behavioral In fact, there's many studies that objectively compare us that we have the highest number of untreated people suffering from behavioral health and mental health incidents in our community.

1129
02:18:24.192 --> 02:18:28.263
<v Dan Ryan>So that, that kind of made sense when that was offered earlier.

1130
02:18:28.424 --> 02:18:33.408
<v Dan Ryan>BOEC was mentioned, and I thought rightly so, as a partner in public safety response.

1131
02:18:34.114 --> 02:18:41.602
<v Dan Ryan>As such, in terms of mental health, behavioral health, I asked this question: outside of the own— your own bureau, Bureau's Behavioral Health Unit.

1132
02:18:41.665 --> 02:18:42.485
<v Dan Ryan>This is for you, Chief.

1133
02:18:42.565 --> 02:18:43.864
<v Dan Ryan>I know you have to get to a call soon.

1134
02:18:43.993 --> 02:18:44.876
<v Dan Ryan>Try to get this in.

1135
02:18:45.422 --> 02:18:53.301
<v Dan Ryan>How are we evaluating the other public safety units we are investing big dollars in, such as Portland Street Response?

1136
02:18:53.702 --> 02:18:55.180
<v Dan Ryan>We also have CHAT through fire.

1137
02:18:55.933 --> 02:19:02.497
<v Dan Ryan>We invest in these first response systems to work with police in this complex area of mental health.

1138
02:19:02.546 --> 02:19:06.189
<v Dan Ryan>So are we reviewing these expenditures, these big investments?

1139
02:19:07.314 --> 02:19:21.799
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, Councilor, and I think that this is a great question.

1140
02:19:21.864 --> 02:19:30.066
<v Bob Day>I think it's a question maybe more poised for DCA Cossi and, and PSSA because so many of these programs now are falling within the service area.

1141
02:19:31.022 --> 02:19:36.257
<v Bob Day>But to my knowledge, we haven't done that level of robust review for these other programs.

1142
02:19:36.370 --> 02:19:48.387
<v Bob Day>But going forward, I think that's really good insight to just make sure that we're all— I think there's a scrutiny for all of the programs because they are becoming more interconnected.

1143
02:19:48.435 --> 02:19:55.263
<v Bob Day>I know it's a passion of mine that we continue to interact more, PSR, CHAT, and Project Respond.

1144
02:19:55.763 --> 02:20:04.847
<v Bob Day>I know Project Respond is the county, but I just, you know, wanted to highlight But I'm not aware off the top of my head about that review for those programs.

1145
02:20:05.236 --> 02:20:07.869
<v Bob Day>But I would encourage DCA Causie and you to have that conversation.

1146
02:20:11.265 --> 02:20:26.664
<v Dan Ryan>And OIR, there's other public safety systems around the country that you work with that perhaps have done similar investments to improve their response, street response, for mental health and behavioral health issues in coordination with law enforcement?

1147
02:20:26.932 --> 02:20:29.478
<v Dan Ryan>With the public health system that includes police.

1148
02:20:30.138 --> 02:20:35.843
<v Dan Ryan>Have you integrated those big public investments into your findings?

1149
02:20:38.807 --> 02:20:44.009
<v Dan Ryan>I think we're innovative here, so I'm trying to get the evaluation aligned with our innovations.

1150
02:20:44.138 --> 02:20:45.555
<v Dan Ryan>Again, these are big investments.

1151
02:20:46.340 --> 02:20:46.516
<v Michael Gianacco>Right.

1152
02:20:46.677 --> 02:21:05.922
<v Julie Ruhlin>We, you know, we engage primarily with law enforcement, but we have in some of our with other jurisdictions conducted audits or reviews of the sort of joint response mechanisms that have been created by those agencies.

1153
02:21:06.500 --> 02:21:12.345
<v Julie Ruhlin>And so we will do— we'll take a look at, you know, how is this co-response model working?

1154
02:21:12.843 --> 02:21:32.329
<v Julie Ruhlin>Let's, you know, pick out a sampling of calls and watch the video and look at Thank you.

1155
02:21:32.329 --> 02:21:45.670
<v Dan Ryan>I do think it's important as we continue to make more and more investments into behavioral health and mental health investments in public safety outside of police, with the hope that they were supposed to be integrated, that we continue to look at those types of things.

1156
02:21:45.709 --> 02:21:51.041
<v Dan Ryan>It's very important for us in our analysis and evaluation to start including that broader lens.

1157
02:21:51.703 --> 02:21:51.881
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1158
02:21:52.270 --> 02:21:53.110
<v Dan Ryan>Um, would you agree?

1159
02:21:54.413 --> 02:21:54.686
<v Bob Day>We do.

1160
02:21:54.960 --> 02:21:55.960
<v Julie Ruhlin>Yeah.

1161
02:21:56.105 --> 02:21:56.992
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, thank you.

1162
02:21:57.379 --> 02:21:57.573
<v Olivia Clark>Sure.

1163
02:22:01.147 --> 02:22:02.784
<v Steve Novick>I see no one else in the queue.

1164
02:22:03.174 --> 02:22:05.361
<v Steve Novick>Can we thank our guests and let them go?

1165
02:22:05.701 --> 02:22:05.944
<v Jamie Dunphy>Or—.

1166
02:22:06.075 --> 02:22:06.900
<v Michael Gianacco>Oh, Councilor Kanal.

1167
02:22:07.209 --> 02:22:11.022
<v Sameer Kanal>Just wanted to clarify, are, are we moving into discuss— we had Q&A followed by discussion.

1168
02:22:12.023 --> 02:22:12.235
<v Steve Novick>Right.

1169
02:22:12.349 --> 02:22:16.698
<v Steve Novick>I was going to say, if we can let our guests go, then the question is whether we— people want to have some discussion.

1170
02:22:19.239 --> 02:22:20.631
<v Steve Novick>So we can let our guests go.

1171
02:22:22.200 --> 02:22:24.145
<v Steve Novick>Thank you very, very much.

1172
02:22:24.566 --> 02:22:29.251
<v Steve Novick>Really appreciate the presentations and the thoughtful discussion and answers to questions.

1173
02:22:32.010 --> 02:22:36.255
<v Steve Novick>So if you want to stick around and hear a discussion, that's fine.

1174
02:22:36.320 --> 02:22:40.405
<v Steve Novick>But if you want to Thank you.

1175
02:22:40.792 --> 02:22:42.069
<v Julie Ruhlin>Thank you very much.

1176
02:22:47.430 --> 02:22:48.200
<v Steve Novick>Colleagues, any discussion?

1177
02:22:48.827 --> 02:22:49.423
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal.

1178
02:22:50.916 --> 02:22:51.817
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Coach Novick.

1179
02:22:52.025 --> 02:22:56.511
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, while they're still here, some of them are, I just wanted to start by just thanking everybody again.

1180
02:22:57.091 --> 02:23:06.442
<v Sameer Kanal>I also noted, in addition to, um, the City Operations ECA, Independent Police Review Leadership at PPB, We also have PSSA leadership and the city attorneys back there.

1181
02:23:06.843 --> 02:23:19.896
<v Sameer Kanal>And, uh, but with relation to OIR Group, um, I'm generally pretty skeptical about contracting out work, uh, but I, I have found in my experience, uh, with OIR Group that, that you do very professional work and for the city, and I appreciate it quite a bit.

1182
02:23:20.393 --> 02:23:37.662
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I also wanted to thank you for a recommendation that you put into the previous report, um, and that PPB implemented and that you recognize the implementation of around avoiding the inevitability framing around so-called suicide-by-cop incidents, as well as the post-incident conduct piece that you already talked about.

1183
02:23:37.709 --> 02:23:44.059
<v Sameer Kanal>These are both really important improvements that I think came in part due to your recommendation and PPB implementing it.

1184
02:23:44.637 --> 02:23:46.914
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to give maybe a little additional good news.

1185
02:23:47.652 --> 02:23:53.936
<v Sameer Kanal>You discussed— OIR Group discussed silos and how they hope the new form of government helps break those down between PPB and BOEC.

1186
02:23:55.123 --> 02:23:58.920
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to point out that actually this coordination predates the new form of government, beginning Thank you.

1187
02:23:58.920 --> 02:23:58.920
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1188
02:23:58.920 --> 02:23:58.920
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

1189
02:23:58.920 --> 02:24:11.620
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate the work that's been done with the creation of the Community Safety Division in 2021, then led by Mike Myers, who had previously led both FIRE and PBEM, and now as the Public Safety Service Area, led by Bob Cazzi, who is formerly the director of BOEC.

1190
02:24:11.620 --> 02:24:21.569
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think— I'm hoping that the next report, even if it doesn't go all the way to 2025, shows improvement on the siloing even prior to the advent of the new government.

1191
02:24:22.500 --> 02:24:24.600
<v Sameer Kanal>Also appreciated the candor from Chief Day about recommendations.

1192
02:24:24.629 --> 02:24:26.031
<v Sameer Kanal>Recommendation 6 and its history.

1193
02:24:28.370 --> 02:24:37.577
<v Sameer Kanal>One thing that I really wanted to talk about was the— and Councilor Avalos spoke about this in her questions— about how we document when activity is in policy and nonetheless not ideal.

1194
02:24:38.334 --> 02:25:05.989
<v Sameer Kanal>This policy review that OIR Group does is pretty much the closest thing we have in the City of Portland to a concept called sentinel event reviews, which are when you review something not to assign blame or determine a response that's backward-looking, but to learn from it and On page 7 of the report, it says we advocate for a systemic approach— sorry, systematic approach that would make this practice consistent with a formal process for centralized consideration and documentation of all recommendations stemming from a critical incident.

1195
02:25:06.100 --> 02:25:09.719
<v Sameer Kanal>And that critical incident could involve multiple people, multiple agencies as well.

1196
02:25:09.719 --> 02:25:12.110
<v Sameer Kanal>It's about prevention of recurrence, not blame.

1197
02:25:12.120 --> 02:25:18.020
<v Sameer Kanal>And I appreciate that the OIR group does it for us in this specifically narrow subset.

1198
02:25:18.020 --> 02:25:20.020
<v Sameer Kanal>This was recommended for the new oversight board to do.

1199
02:25:20.010 --> 02:25:20.170
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank I think that's a good you.

1200
02:25:20.120 --> 02:25:20.139
<v Sameer Kanal>Idea.

1201
02:25:20.281 --> 02:25:28.118
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's something that we need to do, by the way, for all sentinel events that may occur, not just those involving use of deadly force or officer-involved shootings.

1202
02:25:28.486 --> 02:25:30.527
<v Sameer Kanal>The old council did not put that into code.

1203
02:25:30.879 --> 02:25:33.224
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I really think that this is important to do.

1204
02:25:33.529 --> 02:25:38.120
<v Sameer Kanal>And frankly, having us do it, even if OIR Group is doing it in this narrow set, is to avoid that lag.

1205
02:25:38.907 --> 02:25:41.814
<v Sameer Kanal>Because if it's happening live, that might happen a little bit faster.

1206
02:25:41.879 --> 02:25:45.667
<v Sameer Kanal>And we've seen this in Seattle, Minneapolis, D.C., a lot of other places as well.

1207
02:25:47.074 --> 02:25:48.701
<v Sameer Kanal>But that's sort of the specific thing.

1208
02:25:48.765 --> 02:25:51.795
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to take a step back and just say I appreciate this conversation.

1209
02:25:51.906 --> 02:25:53.711
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's really important that we talk about it now.

1210
02:25:55.059 --> 02:26:01.129
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not because we think police are bad or want to punish them for any mistakes, but because this activity is good governance.

1211
02:26:01.532 --> 02:26:10.779
<v Sameer Kanal>When we give city employees the tools and right to use force up to and including taking Portlanders' lives, we have to do the due diligence to review, consider, and remember the lives lost or lives that could have been lost.

1212
02:26:11.197 --> 02:26:21.645
<v Sameer Kanal>It's oversight, it's accountability, it's our responsibility, and I'm I'm particularly heartened by this process happening now in light of seeing what happens in Minneapolis when you don't do this work.

1213
02:26:21.725 --> 02:26:28.596
<v Sameer Kanal>Because what's happening in Minneapolis is what happens when law enforcement is devoid of accountability and allowed to operate without any oversight or restraint.

1214
02:26:29.656 --> 02:26:31.791
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's important that we make sure it doesn't happen here in Portland.

1215
02:26:31.888 --> 02:26:34.522
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's what this process does, and it has done for many years.

1216
02:26:34.939 --> 02:26:36.319
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to recognize that that's been good too.

1217
02:26:36.801 --> 02:26:52.816
<v Sameer Kanal>And the last thing I wanted to mention that's specific here is Um, we currently do not include officer-involved shootings in our shooting data on the PPV open data portal, and I wanted to highlight the Alliance for Safe Oregon, um, that recommendation that they've been making for a few years that we include that in the data dashboard.

1218
02:26:53.430 --> 02:26:54.849
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'll, I'll stop here.

1219
02:26:55.203 --> 02:26:55.542
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1220
02:26:57.301 --> 02:26:58.882
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, thanks.

1221
02:26:58.931 --> 02:27:03.066
<v Olivia Clark>I just wanted to ask Councilor Kanal, when you say sentinel events, I'm familiar with those.

1222
02:27:03.131 --> 02:27:04.198
<v Olivia Clark>I was on a hospital board.

1223
02:27:04.262 --> 02:27:08.505
<v Olivia Clark>We reviewed them all the You know, scissors left inside of people, that kind of thing.

1224
02:27:10.334 --> 02:27:10.912
<v Olivia Clark>It really happens.

1225
02:27:13.159 --> 02:27:14.161
<v Olivia Clark>Sponges, whatever.

1226
02:27:14.726 --> 02:27:21.721
<v Olivia Clark>So are you— I wasn't sure I understood what you were suggesting, that you want sentinel events to be reviewed by the council?

1227
02:27:22.433 --> 02:27:23.049
<v Olivia Clark>Is that what you're saying?

1228
02:27:23.469 --> 02:27:25.558
<v Sameer Kanal>No, I think the city doing it internally.

1229
02:27:26.476 --> 02:27:28.798
<v Sameer Kanal>If it's— so I'll give you an example.

1230
02:27:28.845 --> 02:27:38.029
<v Sameer Kanal>Seattle did a sentinel event review not on any individual individual officer's conduct, although that was mentioned in passing, but on the police's response to the 2020 protests.

1231
02:27:38.414 --> 02:27:58.704
<v Sameer Kanal>And it started that process in 2021, and it continued for a few years, but it was not 3.5 to 6 years later in the way that sometimes when there's a possibility of it affecting an individual officer's employment or criminal charges or even civil litigation, there's often pressure to delay or some reason to delay.

1232
02:27:58.770 --> 02:27:58.930
<v Sameer Kanal>Delay.

1233
02:27:59.507 --> 02:28:14.593
<v Sameer Kanal>Whereas when it's explicitly separated from any possibility of blame or, you know, punishment or discipline or whatever the terminology is, sometimes it's just helpful to see like, what if something that happened in 2020 happened again in 2022?

1234
02:28:15.509 --> 02:28:20.420
<v Sameer Kanal>How do we learn from how we responded to it the first time and do better the second time?

1235
02:28:20.789 --> 02:28:22.956
<v Sameer Kanal>And in the case of police, it's often not just police.

1236
02:28:23.036 --> 02:28:23.854
<v Sameer Kanal>It involves BOEC.

1237
02:28:23.918 --> 02:28:29.345
<v Olivia Clark>It involves like And I'm assuming that sentinel event in this situation would be beyond the critical incident.

1238
02:28:29.394 --> 02:28:32.349
<v Olivia Clark>It would be broader than that, or just a critical incident?

1239
02:28:32.429 --> 02:28:35.415
<v Sameer Kanal>In the context of policing, it is usually broader than that.

1240
02:28:35.800 --> 02:28:43.603
<v Sameer Kanal>It is often, you know, multiple related events that are kind of one thing, but not an individual, you know, use of force.

1241
02:28:43.828 --> 02:28:46.847
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, I just want to make sure that we were not going to review all those sentinel events.

1242
02:28:47.023 --> 02:28:48.967
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh no, that would be a lot.

1243
02:28:52.520 --> 02:28:53.004
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Green.

1244
02:28:54.637 --> 02:28:55.138
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you.

1245
02:28:55.218 --> 02:28:59.453
<v Mitch Green>And I, I also want to, um, I just want to say thanks for the discussion today.

1246
02:28:59.503 --> 02:29:03.183
<v Mitch Green>I thought that was just really helpful for me, um, for all of us, I think, for the city.

1247
02:29:03.842 --> 02:29:05.529
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I missed what you said there, Councilor.

1248
02:29:05.609 --> 02:29:11.344
<v Mitch Green>What page in the report, um, that you, you were referencing back to the report, uh, in the context of these events?

1249
02:29:11.394 --> 02:29:12.301
<v Michael Gianacco>And I just think I missed—.

1250
02:29:12.301 --> 02:29:15.904
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, it's page 7 of the report.

1251
02:29:15.985 --> 02:29:22.623
<v Mitch Green>It's in the introductory I'll read up on that because I thought what you said there was interesting.

1252
02:29:24.610 --> 02:29:35.783
<v Mitch Green>You know, I think the other thing that I'd like to say in this point, and it's not directly related to the report we just received, but it is also about police oversight, and I don't know where else to talk about it in timely fashion, so I'll just do it here.

1253
02:29:37.608 --> 02:29:45.583
<v Mitch Green>I attended the— there was a very interesting conversation last night out in East Portland Thank you.

1254
02:29:47.481 --> 02:29:56.034
<v Mitch Green>I came away from that feeling— this was a very evidence-based approach, and the conversation that unfolded in that room I thought was very interesting and very promising.

1255
02:29:57.021 --> 02:30:08.647
<v Mitch Green>What I saw was officers who were engaged specifically with activity with folks who have been Yes.

1256
02:30:08.775 --> 02:30:17.704
<v Mitch Green>Protesting down specifically at the McAdam facility, just like engaging with those protesters at the McAdam facility, and they were not getting overly defensive about it.

1257
02:30:17.769 --> 02:30:22.962
<v Mitch Green>And it was sort of a kind of acknowledgment that this is an important conversation to have and that we should keep having it.

1258
02:30:23.042 --> 02:30:32.566
<v Mitch Green>And I thought that that was an interesting other— another dimension to our oversight apparatus that I think is really important to continue to invest resources in.

1259
02:30:32.997 --> 02:30:50.595
<v Mitch Green>I know we're not talking about policy here at the work session, But, um, it— I think it allows us as councilors who receive those sorts of complaints, or, hey, this happened down here at the ICE facility, to have another layer of context and know that we're, we're doing this sort of dialogue officer-based approach, and there's this evidence-based approach.

1260
02:30:50.675 --> 02:31:08.882
<v Mitch Green>So if you guys didn't— were not able to attend that, or if you see other opportunities to attend it if they do it in the future, I highly recommend it because I thought there was a really interesting dialogue going, specifically some of our constituents Councilor who've been down there engaged in like shouting matches with the police, and, and they kind of like, they, they continue talking.

1261
02:31:08.931 --> 02:31:12.279
<v Mitch Green>So I, I was like, I think this is something we need to continue to encourage and invest.

1262
02:31:12.505 --> 02:31:16.128
<v Mitch Green>So I know it's a little off topic, but it's not wholly off topic.

1263
02:31:16.420 --> 02:31:16.774
<v Michael Gianacco>Thanks.

1264
02:31:17.648 --> 02:31:18.424
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Avalos.

1265
02:31:21.126 --> 02:31:23.682
<v Tracy Warren>I was playing, uh, tag with Sameer in the queue.

1266
02:31:23.729 --> 02:31:27.336
<v Tracy Warren>I was trying to go after him, um, because I was curious what you were gonna say.

1267
02:31:29.013 --> 02:31:31.644
<v Tracy Warren>That's a good point, and I'm so sad that I missed it.

1268
02:31:31.899 --> 02:31:34.226
<v Tracy Warren>I really wanted to head out there but couldn't.

1269
02:31:34.450 --> 02:31:46.013
<v Tracy Warren>But yeah, I think what you're raising is just a broader discussion that we hopefully will start having in the coming weeks as we continue to see the escalation of the federal government.

1270
02:31:46.236 --> 02:31:48.738
<v Tracy Warren>And we need to have a plan.

1271
02:31:48.962 --> 02:31:52.041
<v Tracy Warren>We need to have a way to protect our community.

1272
02:31:53.052 --> 02:31:55.090
<v Tracy Warren>I think it was in Minneapolis I'm curious about Minneapolis.

1273
02:31:55.138 --> 02:32:06.110
<v Tracy Warren>The police there are like really taking a different and interesting stand, trying to be a bit of a buffer between ICE and federal enforcement and the community.

1274
02:32:06.927 --> 02:32:25.372
<v Tracy Warren>I saw a news article about it earlier today, so I don't know all the details of how they actualize that, but I'm very curious about what that looks like and just in general, you know, how we as a municipal government are supposed to respond to the federal government, right?

1275
02:32:25.646 --> 02:32:38.149
<v Tracy Warren>Especially because, you know, uniquely, especially when it comes to the OIR and the settlement agreement, that was the federal government intervening in our local government to say, you know, local government needed to do things better.

1276
02:32:39.159 --> 02:32:41.308
<v Tracy Warren>And their oversight was really critical.

1277
02:32:41.805 --> 02:32:47.959
<v Tracy Warren>And now it's like we don't have their oversight because they're the ones who are the baddies now, right?

1278
02:32:48.007 --> 02:32:50.284
<v Tracy Warren>So it's like— It's just a meme, guys.

1279
02:32:50.781 --> 02:33:05.897
<v Tracy Warren>And so I just— I'm really concerned about how we are supposed to act given the difference in power and our limitations of our local police and government.

1280
02:33:06.041 --> 02:33:13.938
<v Tracy Warren>But yeah, I just flag it as an interesting conversation I hope we have and for our police force to engage with us.

1281
02:33:14.066 --> 02:33:23.592
<v Tracy Warren>And I would also love to— maybe we could just do some looking around the country and seeing how some of the other police forces are responding, because I think everyone Everyone's kind of taking a unique approach.

1282
02:33:24.511 --> 02:33:26.818
<v Tracy Warren>But yeah, I would love for us as a council to have that discussion.

1283
02:33:28.139 --> 02:33:37.118
<v Tracy Warren>And overall, you know, we really need to strengthen how we protect our communities against these forces, and I see the police as being a critical role in that.

1284
02:33:40.520 --> 02:33:45.938
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman.

1285
02:33:46.860 --> 02:33:50.129
<v Eric Zimmerman>Riffing a little bit where Councilor Avalos took us, I Thank you.

1286
02:33:50.627 --> 02:34:13.022
<v Eric Zimmerman>I also appreciate, you know, this type of endeavor that we have taken on in Portland, the fact that our significant amount of leadership from our bureau is here, the fact that this group has, I think I heard, 16 years of a relationship, is the way in which departments get to be better at what they do.

1287
02:34:16.293 --> 02:34:17.948
<v Eric Zimmerman>We are always going to face a problem.

1288
02:34:18.204 --> 02:34:19.778
<v Eric Zimmerman>Somebody is going to let us down.

1289
02:34:20.709 --> 02:34:28.094
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that letdown, I want to remind us and I remind myself that it doesn't speak for the values or the intent of the department.

1290
02:34:28.560 --> 02:34:41.292
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that matters a lot to me because the intent and the leadership and the philosophy behind the department, the city, and our partners who help us be better is how we get through the day when somebody lets us down.

1291
02:34:41.341 --> 02:34:41.436
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1292
02:34:42.409 --> 02:34:54.809
<v Eric Zimmerman>And whether it was a well-meaning mistake that resulted in terrible actions or malicious, any large organization involved in big work like this is gonna have a bad day.

1293
02:34:55.555 --> 02:35:03.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I've always been proud of the Portland Police Bureau's work within my community, right?

1294
02:35:04.022 --> 02:35:11.290
<v Eric Zimmerman>And policing is not inherently, or has not inherently been a thing for the LGBT community to be a part of.

1295
02:35:11.341 --> 02:35:11.406
<v Eric Zimmerman>Right.

1296
02:35:11.520 --> 02:35:14.379
<v Eric Zimmerman>To feel as good about as it does in Portland.

1297
02:35:14.442 --> 02:35:29.895
<v Eric Zimmerman>But because of training and because of policies and because of conversations like this, my community sits, I think, in a better position than maybe in some other cities because of that deliberate engagement, deliberate discussions about these types of topics.

1298
02:35:29.942 --> 02:35:32.064
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm really thankful for that.

1299
02:35:32.416 --> 02:35:39.967
<v Eric Zimmerman>And to, to compare that to the rapid and rampant increase of what we're seeing at the federal level.

1300
02:35:40.759 --> 02:35:46.485
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I was trying to think of another time when a law enforcement agency hired as many people or got as much of a cash infusion.

1301
02:35:46.977 --> 02:35:51.951
<v Eric Zimmerman>I can't think of a single time in our history, in our government's history, right?

1302
02:35:52.032 --> 02:35:53.897
<v Eric Zimmerman>The FBI started out as a few people.

1303
02:35:54.269 --> 02:35:55.306
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's grown, obviously.

1304
02:35:56.601 --> 02:35:59.079
<v Eric Zimmerman>Most police forces started out as a few people.

1305
02:36:00.655 --> 02:36:05.088
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think World War II may have been the last, maybe Vietnam, I think that's a very fair point.

1306
02:36:05.153 --> 02:36:18.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>When a military paramilitary organization got such an infusion and such a large influx of people given an enormous amount of authority, and to even think that those are comparable in their duties is, is a hell of a stretch there.

1307
02:36:19.461 --> 02:36:22.494
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I don't think there's any conversation about accountability.

1308
02:36:22.590 --> 02:36:30.738
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think there's any conversation about this level of nuance that we saw today that is happening within the Department of Homeland Security.

1309
02:36:32.825 --> 02:36:56.193
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that I'm going to be very careful as we go forward to make sure that the actions of the federal government's law enforcement activities, they represent the federal government's law enforcement activities and, in my opinion, the failure of them, and not speak for other people who are in the line of— or in the profession of law enforcement.

1310
02:36:56.943 --> 02:36:58.502
<v Eric Zimmerman>I value the profession a lot.

1311
02:36:58.549 --> 02:37:04.896
<v Eric Zimmerman>I value the fact that we put resources at a professional standards division, and it's going to get harder.

1312
02:37:05.057 --> 02:37:29.040
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's going to get harder to figure out the best way cities across America are dealing with this in terms of how to use our professional forces who are members of our community dealing with a federal force who has very little training, in my opinion, and very value or cultural base in police standards.

1313
02:37:29.699 --> 02:37:32.011
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that's gonna be very tough for everybody.

1314
02:37:33.326 --> 02:37:45.416
<v Eric Zimmerman>But this is the way that policing should be occurring in all communities, is that policing should involve community feedback, professional outside feedback, and internal opinions about the direction in which the department goes.

1315
02:37:45.690 --> 02:37:46.300
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's all things.

1316
02:37:46.349 --> 02:37:47.842
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's not just one or the other.

1317
02:37:50.072 --> 02:37:54.067
<v Eric Zimmerman>I too, Councilor Avalos, am interested in where we go here with some of those other things.

1318
02:37:54.131 --> 02:38:04.458
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I know it is similarly unrelated somewhat to the discussion at point, but it is such a pressing topic for us as a community and all communities in the United States right now.

1319
02:38:07.306 --> 02:38:35.405
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I am saddened because there was a time in this country when we would be very glad if a local police officer or a senior leader got to go to something like the FBI's Academy or got to train at the Federal Law Enforcement Training Facility, FLETC, which used to have great clout.

1320
02:38:36.191 --> 02:38:49.183
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I don't want to lose that, but it's hard to keep those things in good memory of like right now how to engage in those areas that should be helping us professionally are almost seen as unworkable right now.

1321
02:38:49.811 --> 02:38:51.584
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that worries me a lot.

1322
02:38:52.372 --> 02:39:07.293
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I don't have answers for that, but I do keep it front of mind for where do we look for professionalism in the industry when our norms have been broken by the current administration.

1323
02:39:07.343 --> 02:39:22.324
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't know where we're going to look, but I think our learning I appreciate that.

1324
02:39:24.033 --> 02:39:30.843
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, uh, I think we should definitely be consulting with our training division to understand what the sources that they already are using are.

1325
02:39:30.988 --> 02:39:35.132
<v Sameer Kanal>And I know there's a training advisory council that I was remiss earlier in not shouting out the work of as well.

1326
02:39:35.198 --> 02:39:35.408
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Kanal.

1327
02:39:36.069 --> 02:39:36.390
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1328
02:39:37.952 --> 02:39:49.213
<v Sameer Kanal>Just to speak to something that came up a couple times, I have no doubts that this particular process of reporting has made PPB better, and that council being a part of that process and reviewing it is key to that.

1329
02:39:49.534 --> 02:39:53.039
<v Sameer Kanal>Speaking only for myself, I do want to encourage the continuation of this particular contract.

1330
02:39:54.360 --> 02:39:56.828
<v Sameer Kanal>Switching gears to Councilor Ryan's comments, 2 points.

1331
02:39:56.975 --> 02:39:59.233
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with your point about the Community Police Academy.

1332
02:39:59.671 --> 02:40:06.668
<v Sameer Kanal>I think having as many sources of information about policing as possible from within the Bureau and also outside of it is really helpful.

1333
02:40:06.781 --> 02:40:15.179
<v Sameer Kanal>I've participated in that and done a few ride-alongs now, as well as talking to a lot of folks who are external to police but experts or researchers.

1334
02:40:15.853 --> 02:40:18.711
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a good way to broaden everyone's knowledge.

1335
02:40:18.760 --> 02:40:20.959
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'll just co-sign that recommendation and expand it.

1336
02:40:21.538 --> 02:40:24.379
<v Sameer Kanal>Then I also want to fully 100% agree about the need for review.

1337
02:40:24.604 --> 02:40:35.170
<v Sameer Kanal>PSR, with a budget over $10 million, has had the most extensive review, the top-to-bottom review, in a way that no other part of our public safety has had in a single place, twice, like from a single researcher.

1338
02:40:35.586 --> 02:40:41.784
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I appreciate Councilor Ryan's support of perhaps scaling up that review for everyone across public safety.

1339
02:40:41.849 --> 02:40:48.465
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't know if anyone from PSSA is still here behind the pillar, but— oh yeah, but maybe we can talk about that.

1340
02:40:48.609 --> 02:40:58.965
<v Sameer Kanal>And finally, I wanted to just go back to something that Councilor Avalos talked about I referenced it earlier, but the terminology sometimes matters a lot.

1341
02:40:59.781 --> 02:41:15.014
<v Sameer Kanal>When we talk about public trust building, I think the old council made a choice of labeling when we do investigations that the allegation is sustained or not sustained, and that's the only set of choices available to the review in the new system that's about to come online.

1342
02:41:15.500 --> 02:41:17.438
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that breeds less trust than the original recommendation, which was to have a more robust system.

1343
02:41:17.486 --> 02:41:17.680
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1344
02:41:17.819 --> 02:41:32.129
<v Sameer Kanal>Which was that the officer's conduct was in policy, out of policy, insufficient evidence, or unfounded, which allows for a complete exoneration rather than simply— or a finding of exoneration rather than simply we didn't know.

1345
02:41:32.691 --> 02:41:40.520
<v Sameer Kanal>And it conflates 3 different types of why someone's not found to be— or an allegation is not found to be sustained or conduct not out of policy.

1346
02:41:41.018 --> 02:41:55.467
<v Sameer Kanal>So having those additional options along with other extra findings findings can help the public understand what exactly happened or what the finding was and might help folks understand why they're not seeing what they might have expected going in in a way that breeds public trust.

1347
02:41:56.012 --> 02:41:57.968
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I really appreciate you bringing that up.

1348
02:41:58.049 --> 02:42:02.924
<v Sameer Kanal>And since we were a little bit off topic, but in the broader context of it, I agree.

1349
02:42:03.645 --> 02:42:16.952
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm very excited to continue the conversation that Councilor Green talked about because as you said, it's going to be a bigger thing as Yes, thank you, Councilor Novick.

1350
02:42:17.113 --> 02:42:21.653
<v Dan Ryan>Just a clarification, Councilor Kanal, so you're— thank you for the shoutouts.

1351
02:42:21.862 --> 02:42:43.075
<v Dan Ryan>Um, you're saying that you would like the investment that we did with Portland Street Response with the studies that Portland State University did, you would like to expand that, or you'd like to expand the mental health, behavioral health supports we have, whether it's CHAT or PSR, That's what I was mentioning.

1352
02:42:43.443 --> 02:42:44.629
<v Dan Ryan>I just couldn't tell what you said there.

1353
02:42:45.031 --> 02:42:47.099
<v Sameer Kanal>May I respond to that?

1354
02:42:47.195 --> 02:42:47.388
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1355
02:42:47.900 --> 02:42:51.075
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so thanks for clarifying that.

1356
02:42:51.203 --> 02:42:54.251
<v Sameer Kanal>I interpreted your comment as more the former.

1357
02:42:54.331 --> 02:42:54.907
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with that.

1358
02:42:54.971 --> 02:42:58.034
<v Sameer Kanal>Doesn't necessarily have to be PSU forever, but I think they did a good job.

1359
02:42:58.114 --> 02:43:01.065
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm not opposed to them either.

1360
02:43:01.626 --> 02:43:06.004
<v Sameer Kanal>With relation to the other piece of it, I don't know every piece of expertise.

1361
02:43:06.661 --> 02:43:08.568
<v Sameer Kanal>I asked a few specific questions about OIR.

1362
02:43:08.842 --> 02:43:15.405
<v Sameer Kanal>Groups' expertise and what they can work on beyond simply the 2 things that we talked about.

1363
02:43:15.742 --> 02:43:19.289
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't know if it extends to evaluating mobile crisis, street medicine, things like that.

1364
02:43:19.352 --> 02:43:20.509
<v Sameer Kanal>So I can't speak to that.

1365
02:43:20.941 --> 02:43:23.895
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do think it's worth having these evaluations across it.

1366
02:43:24.311 --> 02:43:30.378
<v Sameer Kanal>I know that Councilor Novick has also talked about these sorts of things in terms of evaluating things like clearance rates as well.

1367
02:43:30.586 --> 02:43:35.449
<v Sameer Kanal>And there is also, I think, benefit to having these extend beyond just police as well.

1368
02:43:35.545 --> 02:43:54.486
<v Sameer Kanal>And some situations so that we're not having to get too deep into the specific nature of each type of first response, but we're also able to share across an entire service area metrics that we can use for eventual decisions on policy or investment or whatever else.

1369
02:43:55.226 --> 02:43:55.756
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope that helps.

1370
02:43:56.688 --> 02:43:57.556
<v Dan Ryan>It does help.

1371
02:43:57.636 --> 02:43:59.274
<v Dan Ryan>I think it's a longer conversation.

1372
02:43:59.420 --> 02:44:11.560
<v Dan Ryan>I think as we continue to invest more and more in alternative responses, we have to make sure that they're accountable within the system of public safety and not treat them as silos.

1373
02:44:12.462 --> 02:44:14.909
<v Dan Ryan>The last thing I want to do is keep building more silos.

1374
02:44:16.165 --> 02:44:18.837
<v Michael Gianacco>Thanks.

1375
02:44:20.608 --> 02:44:28.019
<v Steve Novick>Seeing no one else in the queue, I think I'll bring us to a close a little bit early after making a few off-topic remarks of my own.

1376
02:44:28.942 --> 02:44:36.204
<v Steve Novick>First of all, Councilor Avalos, I think it's a really interesting idea to hear what other police forces are doing in our sister cities in this situation.

1377
02:44:36.638 --> 02:44:47.120
<v Steve Novick>We had a great conversation with people, staff from city councils in other cities in public safety on the federal response a couple of months ago because Lisa Freeman knows people all over the country.

1378
02:44:48.404 --> 02:44:56.739
<v Steve Novick>And I think that Chief Day has been talking to his colleagues all over the country, and maybe we could see if some of them are willing to have a conversation Thank you, Mayor Wilson, for having this conversation with us.

1379
02:44:56.739 --> 02:45:02.590
<v Steve Novick>I also wanted to second or third Councilor Ryan's suggestion of going to the Civilian Academy.

1380
02:45:03.000 --> 02:45:05.819
<v Steve Novick>I've gone through it twice, in 2013 and last year.

1381
02:45:05.819 --> 02:45:10.090
<v Steve Novick>My impression going through it last year was that it seemed more interesting and perhaps more realistic.

1382
02:45:10.399 --> 02:45:14.940
<v Steve Novick>I did get myself shot both times, hypothetically speaking, but, you know, the embarrassment wore off.

1383
02:45:16.059 --> 02:45:33.256
<v Steve Novick>And finally, I just wanted to say about Minneapolis that one of the New York Times columnists yesterday had a column saying maybe Minneapolis is Trump's Waterloo, that there's some indication that maybe there's enough backlash that they will start to back off and change their conduct.

1384
02:45:33.802 --> 02:45:35.534
<v Steve Novick>I fervently hope that was— that is true.

1385
02:45:36.224 --> 02:45:44.114
<v Steve Novick>And it puts me in mind of a conversation I had in November 1990 when Paul Wellstone was elected to the Senate in Minneapolis.

1386
02:45:44.483 --> 02:45:55.200
<v Steve Novick>And the next morning I found his campaign office number by calling 555-1212, like you did in those days, and, uh, and said, I was— hi, my name's Steve, and I was calling to say congratulations.

1387
02:45:55.311 --> 02:45:58.378
<v Steve Novick>And the young woman who answered the phone said, thank you, thank you.

1388
02:45:58.746 --> 02:46:00.128
<v Steve Novick>Well, you know, this is Minnesota.

1389
02:46:00.449 --> 02:46:01.604
<v Steve Novick>Miracles can happen here.

1390
02:46:02.520 --> 02:46:04.221
<v Steve Novick>So maybe that will prove true now too.

1391
02:46:05.184 --> 02:46:09.487
<v Steve Novick>And now, using my hook as a gavel, I bring this meeting, this work session to a close.

1392
02:46:10.306 --> 02:46:11.718
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

