WEBVTT

1
00:02:06.403 --> 00:02:10.599
<v Loretta Smith>Can you all hear me?

2
00:02:10.681 --> 00:02:11.713
<v Loretta Smith>This is Councilor Smith.

3
00:02:15.348 --> 00:02:16.688
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hi, Councilor Smith.

4
00:02:16.786 --> 00:02:18.658
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, this is Christina with the Council Clerk's Office.

5
00:02:18.723 --> 00:02:23.110
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think they've opened up the room yet, but I can hear you just Okay, perfect.

6
00:02:23.271 --> 00:02:24.207
<v Loretta Smith>I just wanted to make sure.

7
00:02:24.724 --> 00:02:26.967
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Yeah, thank you.

8
00:02:27.501 --> 00:02:28.518
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sure.

9
00:04:07.969 --> 00:04:08.579
<v Angelita Morillo>Good morning.

10
00:04:08.740 --> 00:04:08.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning.

11
00:04:09.076 --> 00:04:14.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is about time to start our meeting, but before we get started, we do have a pre-gavel this morning.

12
00:04:15.018 --> 00:04:21.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Today is International Human Rights Day, and I'd like to turn it over to Councilor Kanal for a related pre-gavel.

13
00:04:21.617 --> 00:04:27.990
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President, and thank you for enabling us to request 2 human— or sorry, 2 pre-gavel ceremonies every year.

14
00:04:28.665 --> 00:04:42.824
<v Sameer Kanal>Back in January, I requested one today because December 10th is a council meeting, and also Human Rights Day, which is the annual celebration on December 10th of the anniversary of the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

15
00:04:43.737 --> 00:04:55.322
<v Sameer Kanal>Human rights conceptually influence everything that I do in this space, and I wanted to take the opportunity to recognize it and talk about how this lens and these concepts are applicable to local government.

16
00:04:55.370 --> 00:05:02.595
<v Sameer Kanal>So we've invited 3 speakers, and then I'll close us out over the next few minutes to just speak to that particular aspect of their work.

17
00:05:02.723 --> 00:05:10.002
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll bring up Director of the Office of Equity and Human Rights, Jeff Selby, as well as the president of World Oregon, Derek Olson.

18
00:05:10.661 --> 00:05:14.728
<v Sameer Kanal>And then after that, we'll have Councilor Jamie Dunphy and myself to speak today.

19
00:05:14.791 --> 00:05:17.233
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much for everyone for being here.

20
00:05:17.848 --> 00:05:20.776
<v Sameer Kanal>And Director Selby, please, please feel free to start when you're ready.

21
00:05:20.937 --> 00:05:21.908
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

22
00:05:23.170 --> 00:05:23.817
<v Jeff Selby>Thank you, Councilor.

23
00:05:24.011 --> 00:05:29.689
<v Jeff Selby>Community members, Council President, Council Vice President, city councilors, City Administrator Jordan.

24
00:05:30.725 --> 00:05:31.906
<v Jeff Selby>For the record, I'm Jeff Selby.

25
00:05:32.019 --> 00:05:37.841
<v Jeff Selby>I use he/him pronouns, and I have the privilege of leading the Office of Equity and Human Rights for the City of Portland.

26
00:05:38.427 --> 00:05:41.065
<v Jeff Selby>I'd like to thank Councilor Kanal for inviting me to speak today.

27
00:05:41.526 --> 00:05:54.843
<v Jeff Selby>And as he reminds us, every year since 1948, we celebrate the anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights to focus on protection and dignity for all people.

28
00:05:55.954 --> 00:06:02.884
<v Jeff Selby>My team at the Office of Equity and Human Rights serves as the conscience of the city, as you will, if you will.

29
00:06:03.694 --> 00:06:05.740
<v Jeff Selby>As you've probably heard me say before, Yes.

30
00:06:06.478 --> 00:06:11.214
<v Jeff Selby>Equity and human rights are not separate practices or an afterthought.

31
00:06:12.098 --> 00:06:19.358
<v Jeff Selby>They are tenets of responsible, accountable, and transparent government and are really just good governance.

32
00:06:20.305 --> 00:06:24.769
<v Jeff Selby>We continue to encounter barriers to our work, and the hits just keep on coming.

33
00:06:25.605 --> 00:06:34.968
<v Jeff Selby>Yesterday, the U.S. Department of Justice announced that they're repealing 50-year-old disparate impact standards, which will make it harder to challenge potential bias in housing.

34
00:06:35.545 --> 00:06:40.338
<v Jeff Selby>Criminal law, employment, environmental regulations, and other policy areas.

35
00:06:41.428 --> 00:06:47.536
<v Jeff Selby>It is more important than ever for the City of Portland to reaffirm its commitment to equity and human rights.

36
00:06:48.466 --> 00:06:57.250
<v Jeff Selby>Given existing and forthcoming civil and human rights challenges, we must take note of our responsibility and our promise to the many communities we serve.

37
00:06:58.389 --> 00:07:07.012
<v Jeff Selby>We must remember our challenging history and ensure we work every day to earn our community members' trust and ensure protection and dignity for all people.

38
00:07:07.110 --> 00:07:07.672
<v Jeff Selby>Portlanders.

39
00:07:08.120 --> 00:07:17.949
<v Jeff Selby>I would like to thank my team and all the equity managers and practitioners in the city who move this work forward every day, often under trying circumstances.

40
00:07:18.865 --> 00:07:27.264
<v Jeff Selby>I look forward to a unified, more focused, and robust equity and human rights structure at the city under the leadership of a chief equity officer.

41
00:07:28.098 --> 00:07:44.845
<v Jeff Selby>I will leave you with a reminder that human rights are positive, human rights are essential, good morning, Council President, Council Members, and Mayor Wilson.

42
00:07:45.290 --> 00:07:46.170
<v Derek Olson>My name is Derek Olson.

43
00:07:46.235 --> 00:07:50.425
<v Derek Olson>I'm the president of World Oregon, also known as the World Affairs Council of Oregon.

44
00:07:50.970 --> 00:07:59.088
<v Derek Olson>We are a nonpartisan nonprofit whose mission is to connect our community with the world through learning and dialogue on global issues such as human rights today.

45
00:07:59.701 --> 00:08:07.870
<v Derek Olson>We do this through public programs, K-12 engagement, and hosting international visitors in partnership with the US Department of State and US embassies worldwide.

46
00:08:08.351 --> 00:08:15.692
<v Derek Olson>Founded in 1950, we're celebrating our 75th anniversary this year of convening and catalyzing conversations about human rights and other critical issues.

47
00:08:16.670 --> 00:08:22.826
<v Derek Olson>We're fortunate to have Chido Diliwayo, International Relations Director for the City of Portland, serve on our Board of Advisors.

48
00:08:23.403 --> 00:08:26.786
<v Derek Olson>And with our help, our Young Leaders in Action high school group is meeting with the mayor later this week.

49
00:08:27.362 --> 00:08:35.068
<v Derek Olson>I was honored to be asked by Councilor Kanal, who I've worked with previously on College Model United Nations, to say a few brief remarks today thank you, Councilor Dan Ryan.

50
00:08:35.068 --> 00:08:35.068
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Mayor.

51
00:08:35.068 --> 00:08:36.589
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Dan Ryan, thank you for your remarks today on Human Rights Day.

52
00:08:36.589 --> 00:08:54.438
<v Derek Olson>As he noted, it is, uh, on this day in 1948 that the UN General Assembly issued the bold and visionary Universal Declaration of Human Rights, laying out 30 articles pertaining to fundamental freedoms and rights that have shaped our understanding and aspirations as nations of the world ever since.

53
00:08:54.849 --> 00:08:58.869
<v Derek Olson>It was the visionary Eleanor Roosevelt who chaired the committee that drafted the declaration.

54
00:08:59.528 --> 00:09:09.287
<v Derek Olson>Since its adoption in 1948, The Universal Declaration of Human Rights has been translated into more than 500 languages and has inspired the constitutions of many newly independent states and democracies.

55
00:09:10.826 --> 00:09:16.825
<v Derek Olson>Together, we can all contribute to and build essential leadership and institutions and systems that can safeguard human rights.

56
00:09:16.889 --> 00:09:20.284
<v Derek Olson>As the previous speaker noted, human rights are nonpartisan.

57
00:09:21.645 --> 00:09:33.375
<v Derek Olson>And strongly believe that a prosperous, more peaceful world is only possible through engagement and exchange, protecting and preserving every individual's humanity to ensure that every individual can live a life of dignity.

58
00:09:33.682 --> 00:09:36.350
<v Derek Olson>Human rights begin at home but are global.

59
00:09:37.009 --> 00:09:42.878
<v Derek Olson>International engagement, learning other languages and cultures, and caring about what happens around the world is not a luxury, it is a necessity.

60
00:09:44.190 --> 00:09:53.041
<v Derek Olson>Together we can nurture and support these rights with education, exchange, and dialogue, beginning with our youth and onto the path of lifelong learning, both locally and globally.

61
00:09:54.642 --> 00:10:09.726
<v Derek Olson>And to close, I invite council members and residents of the great city of Portland to join World Oregon and our partner nonprofit organizations to be ambassadors for the thank you.

62
00:10:10.871 --> 00:10:14.572
<v Jamie Dunphy>And thank you, Councilor Kanal, for bringing this pre-gavel.

63
00:10:15.009 --> 00:10:16.336
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for inviting me to speak as well.

64
00:10:17.192 --> 00:10:28.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, I had the pleasure of meeting Jeff Selby almost 15 years ago in my capacity serving on the Community and Police Relations Committee, which was a subcommittee of the Human Rights Council.

65
00:10:29.118 --> 00:10:57.544
<v Jamie Dunphy>I got to serve with— it was roughly— it was an outdated model that maybe wasn't as effective as some of the models we have now, but it was a wonderful opportunity to have community members, members of the Portland Police, and members of the Human Rights Council meeting regularly to talk about how we move forward as a community, how we ensure that we have a police bureau that centers human rights and centers the dignity and autonomy of all people.

66
00:10:57.673 --> 00:10:58.394
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

67
00:10:59.197 --> 00:11:04.957
<v Jamie Dunphy>Clearly these systems have moved on, but I also think that we have lost something in the years since then.

68
00:11:05.070 --> 00:11:18.034
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that the Human Rights Council brought a lot, or Human Rights Commission brought a lot to the city, and I'm really eager to see that move forward again and bring it back now with this new form of government where we think we can actually meaningfully embrace it again.

69
00:11:19.094 --> 00:11:21.854
<v Jamie Dunphy>It got lost in the city in a lot of ways in the previous council.

70
00:11:21.902 --> 00:11:30.952
<v Jamie Dunphy>So this is a better time than ever for us to contemplate bringing back a Human Rights Commission to this city with Councilmember Herbold.

71
00:11:31.000 --> 00:11:31.596
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

72
00:11:31.676 --> 00:12:09.077
<v Jamie Dunphy>With so much going on at the national level, so much happening internationally, now is a time for the City of Portland to double down on our role within the global community as a leader, ensuring dignity and basic respect for all of our community members, and trying to demonstrate to the world that the picture that happens in Washington, D.C. is not the total picture of what is happening in this country, that I have friends who live far who are worried about about what is happening, worried about visiting from Europe or Canada or the Global South.

73
00:12:11.070 --> 00:12:12.067
<v Jamie Dunphy>But Portland is different.

74
00:12:12.148 --> 00:12:17.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Portland values are on— when Portland values are on display, there's no one in the world that can doubt us.

75
00:12:17.364 --> 00:12:19.971
<v Jamie Dunphy>And there is a reason that I choose to call this place home.

76
00:12:20.020 --> 00:12:28.551
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so I look forward to working with my council colleagues on an effort to bring back the Human Rights Commission and to lead with those values.

77
00:12:28.599 --> 00:12:28.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

78
00:12:29.102 --> 00:12:29.423
<v Jamie Dunphy>Every day.

79
00:12:29.600 --> 00:12:31.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you for the opportunity to chat.

80
00:12:31.769 --> 00:12:36.779
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to Director Selby, to Will Oregon President Olson, and to Councilor Dunphy for speaking.

81
00:12:36.892 --> 00:12:38.322
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks again for everyone for being here.

82
00:12:38.433 --> 00:12:45.645
<v Sameer Kanal>This year is an important day to recognize Human Rights Day, both because of the threats to human rights internationally and those in the United States.

83
00:12:46.047 --> 00:12:59.416
<v Sameer Kanal>It's often alleged that the concept of human rights is some international idea, not particularly relevant to the United States or to local government, but the concept of dignity for all human beings is vital to the American system, to Portland values, and to individual Portlanders.

84
00:13:00.009 --> 00:13:09.527
<v Sameer Kanal>And when anyone's dignity is violated, whether it's in Portugal or Palestine or Pennsylvania or Pasadena or Portland, it weakens protections that ultimately guard Portlanders as well.

85
00:13:10.183 --> 00:13:17.826
<v Sameer Kanal>And as Mr. Olson pointed out, it was an American First Lady, Eleanor Roosevelt, who was one of the key leaders in making the Universal Declaration for Human Rights happen in the first place.

86
00:13:18.515 --> 00:13:20.918
<v Sameer Kanal>We have in the past had larger celebrations of this day.

87
00:13:21.159 --> 00:13:22.105
<v Sameer Kanal>We need to get back to that again.

88
00:13:22.153 --> 00:13:22.328
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

89
00:13:22.966 --> 00:13:34.378
<v Sameer Kanal>One way we can do that is bringing back the Human Rights Commission to bring regular Portlanders back into the planning process of this event, this day, and more broadly, the integration of human rights into our decision-making processes at the City of Portland.

90
00:13:34.798 --> 00:13:46.339
<v Sameer Kanal>Much in the way that the New Portlanders Policy Commission helps us not only plan but boost the awareness and participation of Welcoming Week, a strong Human Rights Commission can help us use this date each year to boost this entire conversation.

91
00:13:47.101 --> 00:13:52.308
<v Sameer Kanal>The Human Rights Commission had in its membership or its subcommittee membership people like Jamie Dunphy, as well as Adam Murray from Councilor Smith's office.

92
00:13:53.871 --> 00:13:59.245
<v Sameer Kanal>It is required by City Code Chapter 3.129, and I intend to file legislation and bring it back in 2026.

93
00:13:59.630 --> 00:14:13.202
<v Sameer Kanal>But beyond the commission alone, ensuring that human rights are a part of the way we think about the decisions we might make or are making at the city will help us not only ensure better policymaking, but that the impacts on each and every Portlander are taken into account.

94
00:14:13.845 --> 00:14:14.839
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate you all being here.

95
00:14:14.967 --> 00:14:16.202
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much, Madam President.

96
00:14:17.533 --> 00:14:18.303
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, councilors.

97
00:14:18.721 --> 00:14:19.796
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both for being here.

98
00:14:20.085 --> 00:14:23.663
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, did you have a question about this pre-gavel, or are you in the queue for something else?

99
00:14:26.128 --> 00:14:32.418
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, uh, colleagues, it is 9:42 on Wednesday, December 10th.

100
00:14:32.547 --> 00:14:34.381
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am calling to order our City Council meeting.

101
00:14:34.898 --> 00:14:36.206
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

102
00:14:36.996 --> 00:14:37.369
<v Keelan McClymont>Good morning.

103
00:14:37.546 --> 00:14:37.821
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

104
00:14:38.192 --> 00:14:38.402
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

105
00:14:38.918 --> 00:14:39.080
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

106
00:14:39.725 --> 00:14:39.822
<v Mitch Green>Here.

107
00:14:40.081 --> 00:14:40.436
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimerson?

108
00:14:40.629 --> 00:14:40.743
<v Steve Novick>Here.

109
00:14:41.114 --> 00:14:41.404
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

110
00:14:43.131 --> 00:14:43.455
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

111
00:14:43.938 --> 00:14:44.229
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

112
00:14:44.341 --> 00:14:44.697
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

113
00:14:45.003 --> 00:14:45.407
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

114
00:14:46.115 --> 00:14:46.519
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

115
00:14:47.486 --> 00:14:49.615
<v Keelan McClymont>Sorry, thank you, Councilor Kanal.

116
00:14:50.131 --> 00:14:50.197
<v Steve Novick>Here.

117
00:14:51.450 --> 00:14:51.739
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

118
00:14:52.188 --> 00:14:52.284
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

119
00:14:52.509 --> 00:14:53.056
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

120
00:14:53.312 --> 00:14:53.409
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

121
00:14:54.855 --> 00:14:55.306
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

122
00:14:55.722 --> 00:14:56.011
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

123
00:14:56.302 --> 00:14:56.639
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

124
00:14:56.702 --> 00:14:56.975
<v Steve Novick>Here.

125
00:14:57.779 --> 00:14:58.278
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

126
00:14:59.755 --> 00:15:00.028
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

127
00:15:00.317 --> 00:15:00.591
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

128
00:15:00.639 --> 00:15:03.294
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Lindley, could you please read our rules of decorum?

129
00:15:03.456 --> 00:15:04.727
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, thanks, Council President.

130
00:15:04.825 --> 00:15:06.274
<v Keelan McClymont>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

131
00:15:06.354 --> 00:15:12.071
<v Keelan McClymont>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

132
00:15:15.250 --> 00:15:22.980
<v Keelan McClymont>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

133
00:15:23.173 --> 00:15:25.197
<v Keelan McClymont>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

134
00:15:25.727 --> 00:15:27.928
<v Keelan McClymont>The presiding order— officer preserves order.

135
00:15:27.993 --> 00:15:35.510
<v Keelan McClymont>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

136
00:15:36.169 --> 00:15:38.403
<v Keelan McClymont>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

137
00:15:38.676 --> 00:15:41.342
<v Keelan McClymont>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

138
00:15:41.889 --> 00:15:44.635
<v Keelan McClymont>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

139
00:15:44.701 --> 00:15:44.828
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

140
00:15:45.172 --> 00:15:48.364
<v Keelan McClymont>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

141
00:15:49.186 --> 00:15:51.589
<v Keelan McClymont>Your testimony today should address the matter being considered.

142
00:15:52.029 --> 00:15:54.014
<v Keelan McClymont>When testifying, state your name for the record.

143
00:15:54.158 --> 00:15:55.692
<v Keelan McClymont>Your address is not necessary.

144
00:15:56.240 --> 00:15:58.999
<v Keelan McClymont>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

145
00:15:59.466 --> 00:16:02.874
<v Keelan McClymont>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls their name.

146
00:16:03.181 --> 00:16:03.552
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

147
00:16:05.946 --> 00:16:08.614
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much, colleagues.

148
00:16:08.678 --> 00:16:11.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first item on our agenda today is agenda approval.

149
00:16:12.544 --> 00:16:19.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are not any changes to the agenda that have been filed, and nothing has been pulled off of the consent agenda.

150
00:16:19.889 --> 00:16:24.547
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any changes or additions to the agenda that anyone would like to request?

151
00:16:26.642 --> 00:16:29.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, not seeing any, uh, we will move forward.

152
00:16:31.020 --> 00:16:33.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next item on the agenda is public communication.

153
00:16:33.599 --> 00:16:35.383
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call up our first guest?

154
00:16:35.990 --> 00:16:37.876
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Eugene Jackson.

155
00:16:46.107 --> 00:16:46.486
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

156
00:16:46.602 --> 00:16:47.278
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for joining us.

157
00:16:47.328 --> 00:16:47.725
<v Eugene Jackson>Hello, everyone.

158
00:16:47.923 --> 00:16:49.474
<v Eugene Jackson>My name is Gene Jackson.

159
00:16:50.635 --> 00:17:07.519
<v Eugene Jackson>And I guess first I'd like to say that just listening to this and then seeing the announcement for Chief Executive— Chief Equity Officer, and I'm trying to figure out— I'm so confused on that simply because we don't have DEI anymore.

160
00:17:08.378 --> 00:17:14.057
<v Eugene Jackson>I hope this is a foundation of something that's going to come in the near future.

161
00:17:14.990 --> 00:17:22.734
<v Eugene Jackson>But I'd like to say good morning again, and I would like to thank all of those who read my homeless proposal.

162
00:17:23.461 --> 00:17:51.603
<v Eugene Jackson>But I failed to mention in that proposal that it would cut down on lice, domestic violence of the homeless people, domestic violence, bedbugs, spider bites, Child abuse, rape, prevent ICE from entry, and free police up to do— deal with other criminal activities, especially drug trafficking.

163
00:17:52.589 --> 00:17:57.122
<v Eugene Jackson>It's also going to take more overnight— more than overnight shelters.

164
00:17:57.365 --> 00:18:07.138
<v Eugene Jackson>As you noticed last week, the last meeting, when Councilor Smith had mentioned that.

165
00:18:07.220 --> 00:18:07.299
<v Clare Adamsick>Yes.

166
00:18:07.787 --> 00:18:16.267
<v Eugene Jackson>And, uh, and mentioned at the last council meeting also how devastating the sweeps are emotionally and physically.

167
00:18:16.941 --> 00:18:19.125
<v Eugene Jackson>Uh, that was mentioned by Councilor Morillo.

168
00:18:20.153 --> 00:18:28.151
<v Eugene Jackson>Uh, something new, bold, and a real commitment to saving this city and the lives of our citizens, uh, has to be done.

169
00:18:29.146 --> 00:18:40.492
<v Eugene Jackson>Uh, Nordstrom Rack is closing, and if we lose Nordstrom Department Store, that would be like the Titanic sinking and everything around it going down in a swirl.

170
00:18:44.202 --> 00:18:48.157
<v Eugene Jackson>I love this city, and I just hate to see what it has come to.

171
00:18:48.857 --> 00:18:54.257
<v Eugene Jackson>Maybe you can start with that $21 million in other funds that the mayor had been hiding from you.

172
00:18:55.011 --> 00:19:08.964
<v Eugene Jackson>I noticed that at the last meeting, Councilor Smith's second request to the administration was to let council know as soon as they get new money in and not once they you know, hide it until they can find out what they want to spend it on.

173
00:19:09.877 --> 00:19:22.907
<v Eugene Jackson>Further, if the NFL came here and offered you a team, an NFL team here, you would find the money to build them a stadium if that's what their request is.

174
00:19:24.286 --> 00:19:39.603
<v Eugene Jackson>I am still angry and disappointed with you allowing the mayor to end DEI and prime contractor development program with a lie, which you will regret starting with more people, more lines at food pantries.

175
00:19:39.731 --> 00:19:48.449
<v Eugene Jackson>Other people in major cities would never even consider such an insidious act upon the citizens of color.

176
00:19:48.708 --> 00:19:50.292
<v Eugene Jackson>I'll just leave it there.

177
00:19:52.088 --> 00:19:59.842
<v Eugene Jackson>And except Ovation— can I just say that Ovation Coffee is looking at opening up across the street where we lost Starbucks?

178
00:20:00.019 --> 00:20:00.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

179
00:20:02.380 --> 00:20:04.795
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much for being here and for sharing that news.

180
00:20:06.500 --> 00:20:08.114
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Brandon Morgove.

181
00:20:12.059 --> 00:20:12.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

182
00:20:12.252 --> 00:20:12.702
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning.

183
00:20:13.298 --> 00:20:13.669
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Good morning.

184
00:20:14.410 --> 00:20:19.256
<v Brandon Morgove>Um, I will touch on a couple of themes of the, the gentleman before me.

185
00:20:19.336 --> 00:20:22.332
<v Brandon Morgove>Uh, actually, uh, it's interesting this thing is called human rights.

186
00:20:22.380 --> 00:20:28.455
<v Brandon Morgove>That was kind of the name of, uh, what my talk was going to be, um, because I tried to put it into 10 words.

187
00:20:28.568 --> 00:20:30.556
<v Brandon Morgove>Anyways, start quickly.

188
00:20:31.453 --> 00:20:40.142
<v Brandon Morgove>First off, I'm gonna talk about 3 things for the homeless, 3 things, and then give you a brief— so first off, when it comes to the homeless, you have 2 main approaches.

189
00:20:40.205 --> 00:20:47.307
<v Brandon Morgove>Maybe the DA Nathan Vasquez, who wants to lock everybody up, and the liberal approach, which wants to get everybody houses.

190
00:20:48.141 --> 00:20:58.449
<v Brandon Morgove>What these both have in common is that one side doesn't care enough to be flexible, while the other side doesn't care enough to be hard in the right ways, and neither asks much of the general Portlander other than to raise taxes.

191
00:20:58.512 --> 00:20:58.656
<v Brandon Morgove>Thank you.

192
00:20:59.185 --> 00:21:02.539
<v Brandon Morgove>Here are 3 simple things which can help improve the homeless situation.

193
00:21:02.636 --> 00:21:11.960
<v Brandon Morgove>First one, this goes a little against the camping ban, is to give some camps temporary permits along with lockable trash cans and a trash pickup date.

194
00:21:12.104 --> 00:21:13.194
<v Brandon Morgove>I was homeless for about a year.

195
00:21:13.788 --> 00:21:18.411
<v Brandon Morgove>I would bag my trash and throw it over a fence where a business had a fenced-off dumpster half the time.

196
00:21:19.164 --> 00:21:35.426
<v Brandon Morgove>This policy could reduce the need to spend so much money cleaning up the camps and give some of the homeless who are responsible A few months to make up their own minds peacefully should allow some of them that freedom and dignity instead of the complete control you are trying to exercise.

197
00:21:36.580 --> 00:21:42.304
<v Brandon Morgove>My second issue is extending the stays to longer than 2 weeks for the medically needy homeless.

198
00:21:43.057 --> 00:21:45.974
<v Brandon Morgove>Many of them have injuries that will take longer than 2 weeks to heal.

199
00:21:46.519 --> 00:21:50.174
<v Brandon Morgove>Do you expect them to go injured to overnight congregate shelters?

200
00:21:50.751 --> 00:21:54.021
<v Brandon Morgove>Those places usually don't have the basic human amenities.

201
00:21:54.134 --> 00:21:55.352
<v Brandon Morgove>We are talking about human rights here, right?

202
00:21:56.137 --> 00:21:57.483
<v Brandon Morgove>To keep oneself clean and hygienic.

203
00:21:57.564 --> 00:21:58.076
<v Brandon Morgove>Councilor Loretta Smith.

204
00:21:59.426 --> 00:22:06.461
<v Brandon Morgove>My last issue is to get some temporary shower facilities to both the overnight shelters and to the emergency shelters.

205
00:22:07.057 --> 00:22:11.682
<v Brandon Morgove>You have like 3 shower trucks which sit idle at Cultivate Initiatives.

206
00:22:12.260 --> 00:22:15.345
<v Brandon Morgove>And hopefully you guys— any of you guys familiar with Cultivate Initiatives?

207
00:22:16.228 --> 00:22:20.276
<v Brandon Morgove>So I don't know if you guys like to go to a crowded shelter where a bunch of people don't have access to a shower.

208
00:22:20.324 --> 00:22:23.489
<v Brandon Morgove>Now, if you wonder why people don't want to stay there, perhaps get some showers there.

209
00:22:23.665 --> 00:22:27.873
<v Brandon Morgove>Anyways, get the shower trucks over to the night shelters.

210
00:22:27.936 --> 00:22:37.135
<v Brandon Morgove>Give Cultivate Initiatives $1 million out of the $22 million to create a job program for some of the homeless or those in recovery to clean those showers.

211
00:22:37.650 --> 00:22:41.486
<v Brandon Morgove>And keep the overnight shelters open earlier than 7 or 8 PM.

212
00:22:41.567 --> 00:22:48.614
<v Brandon Morgove>Open them at 5 PM most nights so people have just a little time to shower and relax for their likely hellish lives.

213
00:22:49.192 --> 00:22:51.151
<v Brandon Morgove>I'm not asking you to be kind or weird.

214
00:22:51.696 --> 00:22:52.932
<v Raymond C. Lee III>The city just needs to be decent.

215
00:22:52.980 --> 00:22:53.076
<v Joseph Perez>Thank you.

216
00:22:53.980 --> 00:22:56.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

217
00:22:56.390 --> 00:22:57.480
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Hey, you're welcome.

218
00:22:57.509 --> 00:22:59.490
<v Brandon Morgove>If any of you guys want to get back to me, please do.

219
00:22:59.529 --> 00:23:00.730
<v Brandon Morgove>Mayor, I met with Rahel.

220
00:23:00.730 --> 00:23:01.670
<v Brandon Morgove>I know she has my email.

221
00:23:01.670 --> 00:23:02.990
<v Brandon Morgove>I appreciate you get back to me.

222
00:23:03.609 --> 00:23:04.829
<v Brandon Morgove>Uh, Sameer Kanal, I met Mac.

223
00:23:04.829 --> 00:23:05.390
<v Brandon Morgove>He didn't get back to me.

224
00:23:05.390 --> 00:23:07.799
<v Brandon Morgove>I have a whole plan for to build a shower facility at Gateway.

225
00:23:08.069 --> 00:23:11.609
<v Jamie Dunphy>You want the masks clean, you want the city clean, start treating people decent.

226
00:23:11.609 --> 00:23:12.309
<v Brandon Morgove>Human rights.

227
00:23:12.309 --> 00:23:13.880
<v Brandon Morgove>Do people have a right to shower at night?

228
00:23:13.910 --> 00:23:15.809
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate your comments.

229
00:23:15.809 --> 00:23:17.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to hear from others as well.

230
00:23:18.730 --> 00:23:21.384
<v Brandon Morgove>Next I want some of you guys to get back to me, please.

231
00:23:22.477 --> 00:23:24.824
<v Brandon Morgove>You want the city improved, you listen to me.

232
00:23:26.599 --> 00:23:29.246
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have David Straub, um, joining us online.

233
00:23:30.970 --> 00:23:31.260
<v David Straub>Thank you.

234
00:23:31.326 --> 00:23:32.801
<v David Straub>Greetings, Councilor Ramey Wilson.

235
00:23:32.932 --> 00:23:34.001
<v David Straub>My name is David Straub.

236
00:23:34.568 --> 00:23:38.428
<v David Straub>They say the definition of crazy is doing the same thing and expecting a different result.

237
00:23:39.001 --> 00:23:42.204
<v David Straub>I've lived in Belmont for more than 20 years, and the result is not looking good.

238
00:23:42.884 --> 00:23:49.173
<v David Straub>While the mayor made good progress on his shelter plan, adding about 1,000 beds, The unsheltered population also increased by 1,000.

239
00:23:49.589 --> 00:23:54.114
<v David Straub>Clearly something is not working, including for substance use treatment, and hasn't for a while.

240
00:23:54.804 --> 00:24:01.173
<v David Straub>And though a city should continue to be a magnet for those needing help, the help we give must change if we want a different outcome.

241
00:24:01.926 --> 00:24:07.526
<v David Straub>To start, the camping ban is an opportunity because the only way we'll make progress is by measuring what the problem is.

242
00:24:08.038 --> 00:24:12.578
<v David Straub>We should limit camping to sanctioned areas, wide open fields for now if need be.

243
00:24:12.932 --> 00:24:21.694
<v David Straub>Where people can be counted, and we have to separate out the small contingent that are troublemakers, as they have an outsized role on resident safety while also holding others back.

244
00:24:22.240 --> 00:24:27.200
<v David Straub>Put them far from downtown and wraparound services to incentivize them to engage in good social behavior.

245
00:24:28.082 --> 00:24:32.159
<v David Straub>The remainder should be given shelter but also required to take behavioral wellness classes.

246
00:24:32.592 --> 00:24:33.522
<v David Straub>We are not a charity.

247
00:24:33.940 --> 00:24:38.803
<v David Straub>We should help people 24/7 who help themselves, and we must give them the chance to do so.

248
00:24:38.851 --> 00:24:38.946
<v David Straub>Thank you.

249
00:24:39.571 --> 00:24:40.967
<v David Straub>We must scale mental health care.

250
00:24:42.121 --> 00:24:48.548
<v David Straub>For those who pass safety and socialization thresholds, I'm sure we can find community members willing to host them for a reasonable fee.

251
00:24:49.253 --> 00:24:53.037
<v David Straub>After all, there's no such thing as affordable housing, and that strategy hasn't seemed to help.

252
00:24:53.662 --> 00:24:56.612
<v David Straub>At best, there is subsidized housing, which is a cost to us all.

253
00:24:57.444 --> 00:25:05.428
<v David Straub>Instead, we can put money in Portlanders' pockets and help them convert garages, improve basements, and when a person is solid, perhaps even a spare room, all to rent.

254
00:25:05.491 --> 00:25:05.876
<v David Straub>Thank you.

255
00:25:06.742 --> 00:25:07.945
<v David Straub>We have the space already.

256
00:25:08.907 --> 00:25:11.875
<v David Straub>Finally, and most importantly, we need to make this a community event.

257
00:25:12.339 --> 00:25:15.434
<v David Straub>Aggregating a bunch of people who are struggling only hides the problem.

258
00:25:15.884 --> 00:25:17.070
<v David Straub>We need to get everyone involved.

259
00:25:17.567 --> 00:25:20.838
<v David Straub>Have them take the wellness classes too, to learn about constructive support.

260
00:25:21.576 --> 00:25:32.048
<v David Straub>Then they can integrate the unsheltered back into the neighborhoods, but unlike the abusive and disadvantaged situations from where they came, into the compassionate and independent environment for which Portland is known.

261
00:25:32.321 --> 00:25:35.069
<v David Straub>But has been unable to transition them to so far.

262
00:25:35.840 --> 00:25:39.440
<v David Straub>Let's focus on building people as much as others focus on building companies.

263
00:25:40.018 --> 00:25:48.439
<v David Straub>Emotions are a team sport, and there is no better place than PDX to show the country how elevating others can be done properly and efficiently for the benefit, benefit of all.

264
00:25:49.275 --> 00:25:50.608
<v David Straub>I'd be happy to furnish more details.

265
00:25:51.410 --> 00:25:52.038
<v David Straub>Thank you for your time.

266
00:25:53.826 --> 00:25:54.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

267
00:25:55.045 --> 00:25:57.166
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate hearing the proposal and the details.

268
00:25:58.558 --> 00:26:00.087
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Mark Sherman.

269
00:26:03.013 --> 00:26:03.603
<v Mark Sherman>Phone is off.

270
00:26:03.750 --> 00:26:05.009
<v Mark Sherman>I am so sorry for that.

271
00:26:07.327 --> 00:26:07.895
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It happens.

272
00:26:07.961 --> 00:26:09.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

273
00:26:09.258 --> 00:26:12.112
<v Mark Sherman>So much better when it happens to somebody else though.

274
00:26:14.789 --> 00:26:16.242
<v Mark Sherman>Uh, I want to thank you guys.

275
00:26:16.421 --> 00:26:24.544
<v Mark Sherman>I think the City Council in general does a really good job, and my comments are going to be directed toward, unfortunately, Dan Ryan.

276
00:26:24.659 --> 00:26:27.104
<v Mark Sherman>But don't take it personal, and if you do, I'll buy you a beer sometime.

277
00:26:27.587 --> 00:26:28.278
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

278
00:26:28.534 --> 00:26:34.210
<v Mark Sherman>So it's about your email that went out a couple weeks ago that referred to the National Socialist Playbook.

279
00:26:34.611 --> 00:26:44.086
<v Mark Sherman>I don't want you to feel that that was unique because that happened in Miami a while back when a candidate running for mayor said everybody else was using a socialist playbook.

280
00:26:44.791 --> 00:26:55.597
<v Mark Sherman>And my favorite happened about 5 years ago in Pennsylvania where a state representative, Republican, referred to the Democratic National Socialist Party as the Nazi Party.

281
00:26:56.874 --> 00:27:01.786
<v Mark Sherman>The USSR is all using the same socialist playbook.

282
00:27:02.737 --> 00:27:04.539
<v Mark Sherman>And I know that you probably apologize.

283
00:27:04.605 --> 00:27:10.387
<v Mark Sherman>I heard something about the playbook had gotten changed to like the Democratic Socialists of America playbook.

284
00:27:10.500 --> 00:27:15.627
<v Mark Sherman>And I just wonder if you guys have that playbook, because I've been there since they founded in '82.

285
00:27:16.597 --> 00:27:17.503
<v Mark Sherman>I don't have a playbook.

286
00:27:17.892 --> 00:27:20.963
<v Mark Sherman>I would've had one that would've been published in Cuba.

287
00:27:21.045 --> 00:27:22.872
<v Mark Sherman>That's how long ago I've been a socialist.

288
00:27:22.920 --> 00:27:23.825
<v Mark Sherman>So you don't have it.

289
00:27:23.890 --> 00:27:23.939
<v Mark Sherman>No.

290
00:27:24.782 --> 00:27:34.855
<v Mark Sherman>But when you send that email out like that, what happens is it's called negative political campaigning and it demonizes everybody else who has the issue opposite yours.

291
00:27:35.913 --> 00:27:47.587
<v Mark Sherman>That, if you guys are part of the HR protection system, you need to file a claim because harassing other councilors for their views during work time is not appropriate.

292
00:27:48.838 --> 00:27:49.656
<v Mark Sherman>You're not the first.

293
00:27:49.865 --> 00:27:53.923
<v Mark Sherman>I've seen those emails come from the mayor, but they're a little less— they're a little more tapered down.

294
00:27:54.002 --> 00:27:54.115
<v Mark Sherman>Thank you.

295
00:27:56.986 --> 00:27:58.114
<v Mark Sherman>And I think that's serious.

296
00:27:58.355 --> 00:28:01.078
<v Mark Sherman>But you had a lot of cool buzzwords in there.

297
00:28:01.160 --> 00:28:06.976
<v Mark Sherman>You talked about staying the course that Ronald Reagan said, and of course he's no longer the number one president.

298
00:28:07.763 --> 00:28:18.729
<v Mark Sherman>And there's things like poking the bear and all the shenanigans about what you guys were doing with RealPage, even though the state, the Justice Department under Trump was also doing the same thing.

299
00:28:18.858 --> 00:28:20.403
<v Mark Sherman>So he must be using the same playbook.

300
00:28:20.452 --> 00:28:20.534
<v Mark Sherman>Yeah.

301
00:28:21.287 --> 00:28:22.449
<v Mark Sherman>Which is scary, right?

302
00:28:24.175 --> 00:28:28.277
<v Mark Sherman>As negative campaigning, that means— and I don't think you wrote that.

303
00:28:28.777 --> 00:28:30.458
<v Mark Sherman>I think that was written by a PR firm.

304
00:28:30.877 --> 00:28:43.145
<v Mark Sherman>And that means to me lobbyists are using emails from councilors, that there's not disclosure happening, that you're not filing campaign filings with the Election Commission.

305
00:28:43.339 --> 00:28:50.926
<v Mark Sherman>And I think there should be an investigation in general about people when they use city emails to attack each other.

306
00:28:51.438 --> 00:28:52.656
<v Mark Sherman>And I think that that should stop.

307
00:28:56.883 --> 00:28:57.792
<v Mark Sherman>I got 30 seconds.

308
00:28:57.857 --> 00:29:01.286
<v Mark Sherman>So I'm going to say, hey, I got a lot of time here.

309
00:29:02.180 --> 00:29:05.842
<v Mark Sherman>Can I give it to someone else or can I just say you guys in general are doing a great job?

310
00:29:05.939 --> 00:29:06.878
<v Mark Sherman>I like your coffees.

311
00:29:07.462 --> 00:29:09.309
<v Mark Sherman>I like being— have a chance to meet you guys.

312
00:29:09.423 --> 00:29:10.638
<v Mark Sherman>I know you're trying really hard.

313
00:29:12.376 --> 00:29:14.390
<v Mark Sherman>I am a socialist, but I don't have a playbook.

314
00:29:14.711 --> 00:29:18.318
<v Mark Sherman>And I really think you guys need to raise the bar quite a bit because that set it pretty low.

315
00:29:21.968 --> 00:29:27.729
<v Mark Sherman>And like I say, if you go through Dan's email, it looks like someone else wrote that.

316
00:29:27.874 --> 00:29:29.337
<v Mark Sherman>That's just too well done.

317
00:29:29.403 --> 00:29:33.558
<v Mark Sherman>I'm not saying you can't write, I'm just saying that was too well done from a political—.

318
00:29:33.558 --> 00:29:34.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to wrap it up, I'm sorry.

319
00:29:35.922 --> 00:29:36.116
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All right.

320
00:29:36.181 --> 00:29:37.913
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for being here.

321
00:29:38.042 --> 00:29:39.594
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate the feedback.

322
00:29:41.336 --> 00:29:42.684
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Michael Woods.

323
00:29:49.432 --> 00:29:49.881
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

324
00:29:49.992 --> 00:29:50.362
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning.

325
00:29:51.662 --> 00:29:52.304
<v Michael Woods>Good morning, everybody.

326
00:29:52.384 --> 00:29:53.555
<v Michael Woods>Thanks for having me here.

327
00:29:54.067 --> 00:29:55.463
<v Michael Woods>Again, my name is Michael Woods.

328
00:29:55.913 --> 00:30:02.267
<v Michael Woods>I'm a PSU Community Urban Studies and Planning major looking to apply for the graduate school next month.

329
00:30:03.308 --> 00:30:04.271
<v Michael Woods>Some of you may know me.

330
00:30:04.415 --> 00:30:07.432
<v Michael Woods>I serve the Buckman Community Association Board.

331
00:30:07.480 --> 00:30:10.096
<v Michael Woods>I'm also on the TIF District for the Central East Side.

332
00:30:11.718 --> 00:30:16.388
<v Michael Woods>I am a fierce, often annoying advocate for pedestrians and pretty much anything non-cars.

333
00:30:17.559 --> 00:30:24.165
<v Michael Woods>I've lived in cities my whole life, New York, DC, Vegas, and here, and I had never been hit by a car until I moved to Portland.

334
00:30:25.198 --> 00:30:28.532
<v Michael Woods>I've now been hit by cars 4 times, all downtown.

335
00:30:30.140 --> 00:30:33.588
<v Michael Woods>First time was leaving school, actually was going to school in 2023.

336
00:30:33.768 --> 00:30:36.094
<v Michael Woods>Second time was leaving school in 2024.

337
00:30:37.452 --> 00:30:40.069
<v Michael Woods>After that second one, I decided to move downtown.

338
00:30:41.210 --> 00:30:42.317
<v Michael Woods>You know, why risk my body?

339
00:30:43.009 --> 00:30:43.521
<v Michael Woods>I'm young.

340
00:30:43.714 --> 00:30:45.705
<v Michael Woods>What, don't wanna, you know, risk my body?

341
00:30:45.753 --> 00:30:46.653
<v Michael Woods>So I moved downtown.

342
00:30:46.990 --> 00:30:48.676
<v Michael Woods>I now live on Park and Market.

343
00:30:49.094 --> 00:30:55.307
<v Michael Woods>Since moving to Park and Market, I've been hit by 2 more cars on my 1-block commute to school.

344
00:30:56.159 --> 00:30:57.041
<v Michael Woods>That is 1 block.

345
00:30:58.246 --> 00:31:05.672
<v Michael Woods>The problem, if you look at the street for context on Park and Market, there's no sidewalk and cars pull up.

346
00:31:06.378 --> 00:31:12.131
<v Michael Woods>Cars, when they pull up there, pull up with the entire car beyond the stop sign every single time without fail.

347
00:31:12.339 --> 00:31:15.813
<v Michael Woods>You go up there, you will see every single car pull up beyond the stop sign.

348
00:31:18.510 --> 00:31:19.757
<v Michael Woods>I don't take that street anymore.

349
00:31:20.130 --> 00:31:22.978
<v Michael Woods>I walk down 10th Avenue because Park is unsafe for me.

350
00:31:23.203 --> 00:31:27.298
<v Michael Woods>Living on Park and Market, I can't cross to the Park Blocks and I can't take the streetcar.

351
00:31:27.365 --> 00:31:27.500
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

352
00:31:29.032 --> 00:31:30.476
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Yeah.

353
00:31:31.821 --> 00:31:37.096
<v Michael Woods>Yeah, the street is inherently dangerous and it's unfortunate that I can't use the park blocks or take the streetcar because of that.

354
00:31:37.689 --> 00:31:40.863
<v Michael Woods>I wouldn't be here if I felt I had any other way to make this change.

355
00:31:41.279 --> 00:31:44.422
<v Michael Woods>I have sent multiple requests off to PBOT.

356
00:31:44.501 --> 00:31:46.746
<v Michael Woods>I've sent multiple communications out.

357
00:31:47.067 --> 00:31:53.351
<v Michael Woods>Never have I gotten a response back that said, hey, we'll, you know, take a look at the daylighting or take a look at the parking here.

358
00:31:53.799 --> 00:31:57.165
<v Michael Woods>And it's not just for this intersection because I work with other neighborhoods.

359
00:31:57.967 --> 00:32:00.035
<v Michael Woods>There are multiple places in Buckman that I tried.

360
00:32:00.212 --> 00:32:03.564
<v Michael Woods>To no avail to get parking removed from.

361
00:32:05.960 --> 00:32:10.183
<v Michael Woods>Yeah, my request is just please at least remove those 2 parking spots from Park and Market.

362
00:32:10.570 --> 00:32:18.659
<v Michael Woods>Like, it's— that's part of the South Park Block Master Plan, the 2035 Comprehensive Transportation Plan, Vision Zero.

363
00:32:19.580 --> 00:32:25.454
<v Michael Woods>Not those 2 parking spots kind of are a linchpin that makes that entire intersection unusable to many people.

364
00:32:27.095 --> 00:32:28.490
<v Michael Woods>Yeah, that's all I got.

365
00:32:29.431 --> 00:32:29.707
<v Michael Woods>Thank you.

366
00:32:29.756 --> 00:32:30.778
<v Michael Woods>Sorry, I'm a little uncomfortable.

367
00:32:30.826 --> 00:32:33.762
<v Michael Woods>It's a different experience being out here talking to y'all like this.

368
00:32:34.630 --> 00:32:35.578
<v Michael Woods>So yeah, thanks for hearing me.

369
00:32:35.627 --> 00:32:41.744
<v Michael Woods>I just, yeah, I'm young and it's unfortunate that even I feel uncomfortable crossing Park and Market.

370
00:32:42.630 --> 00:32:43.371
<v Michael Woods>Yeah, thank you.

371
00:32:43.596 --> 00:32:45.480
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here and for bringing that concern.

372
00:32:45.594 --> 00:32:49.446
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I saw nods from some of the members of our Transportation and Infrastructure Committee.

373
00:32:49.559 --> 00:32:53.638
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I know folks have heard this and I'm sure there will be follow-up conversation.

374
00:32:54.905 --> 00:32:56.863
<v Michael Woods>Yeah, I've put my email in there.

375
00:32:56.928 --> 00:33:06.498
<v Michael Woods>I'm a PSU urban planning student, so I work, you know, I go to school directly for this, and I'm going to work to try to be kind of ingratiated in here and work with you guys more in the future.

376
00:33:06.952 --> 00:33:10.347
<v Michael Woods>This is kind of my first step into making a safer downtown.

377
00:33:11.242 --> 00:33:11.824
<v Michael Woods>Yeah, thank you.

378
00:33:12.357 --> 00:33:12.794
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

379
00:33:17.851 --> 00:33:19.224
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes public communications.

380
00:33:20.733 --> 00:33:25.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan, and thank you to everybody who came today to share your experiences in the city with us.

381
00:33:26.654 --> 00:33:32.702
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, colleagues, the next item on the agenda is the committee referral list.

382
00:33:33.472 --> 00:33:45.602
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we have referred over the last week annexation of a property on Hilltop Lane to Climate, Resilience, and Land Use, adding nondiscrimination requirements for single Thank you.

383
00:33:45.747 --> 00:33:46.676
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All right, thank you, Mayor.

384
00:33:46.724 --> 00:33:47.445
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have 2 motions before us.

385
00:33:48.327 --> 00:33:52.384
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Adding code to establish a data privacy office to Community and Public Safety.

386
00:33:53.202 --> 00:33:59.201
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Adding appointments to our code, processes on appointments to our code in the Governance Committee.

387
00:33:59.874 --> 00:34:03.369
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Confirming appointments to the Portland Elections Commission in the Governance Committee.

388
00:34:04.107 --> 00:34:10.088
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Accessing property for sidewalk, curb, and driveway repair to the Finance Committee, 2 related items there.

389
00:34:10.858 --> 00:34:20.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Amending the intergovernmental agreement with Multnomah County for the Revenue Division to administer the School for All program tax to the Finance Committee.

390
00:34:20.746 --> 00:34:27.407
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Requesting the City Budget Office provide balanced program offer information for Portland Parks and Recreation as a pilot to the Finance Committee.

391
00:34:28.148 --> 00:34:34.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And a resolution to support an independent police review employees to the Committee on Community and Public Safety.

392
00:34:36.032 --> 00:34:41.476
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next item on our agenda is a time-certain item that we are taking up before consent today.

393
00:34:41.639 --> 00:34:43.545
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please Please call agenda item 4.

394
00:34:46.913 --> 00:34:51.041
<v Keelan McClymont>Appoint Raymond C. Lee III as City Administrator.

395
00:34:52.309 --> 00:34:52.711
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

396
00:34:53.697 --> 00:35:06.043
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, colleagues, we have before us today, um, a resolution from the mayor with a recommendation for our city's next city administrator.

397
00:35:07.130 --> 00:35:29.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, As you know, there's been a long process that the city has gone through to, a year or so ago, gain insight from Portlanders about what they hoped to see in our city's next administrator, and then a recruitment process nationally that led us to this point.

398
00:35:29.748 --> 00:35:34.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to turn it over to the mayor to provide us with a thank you.

399
00:35:34.030 --> 00:35:34.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

400
00:35:34.030 --> 00:35:42.550
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll start with a brief introduction, and then we'll hear directly from Mr. Raymond Lee, the mayor's nominee to be our next city administrator.

401
00:35:43.170 --> 00:36:02.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will turn to public testimony, and then we have about an hour set aside for councilors to ask questions, Mr. Lee, of you and, and your experience and what you would plan to bring to our city, and to have a discussion before we turn it back over to you for a few minutes of closing remarks, and then we'll move to a vote.

402
00:36:03.159 --> 00:36:05.309
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So with that, Mr. Mayor, would you like to kick us off?

403
00:36:05.614 --> 00:36:06.208
<v Keith Wilson>Yes, thank you.

404
00:36:06.273 --> 00:36:08.936
<v Keith Wilson>Good morning, council colleagues and staff and members of the public.

405
00:36:08.983 --> 00:36:09.963
<v Keith Wilson>Appreciate your time today.

406
00:36:11.150 --> 00:36:14.166
<v Keith Wilson>Today marks an important milestone in Portland's new form of government.

407
00:36:15.257 --> 00:36:34.989
<v Keith Wilson>We are here to confirm the city's first-term, long-term city administrator, a role that will oversee day-to-day operations across more than 2 dozen bureaus and departments, ensuring accountability I'm proud to present Raymond Lee as my nominee for this position.

408
00:36:35.896 --> 00:36:42.378
<v Keith Wilson>Raymond brings nearly 2 decades of municipal leadership experience spanning Greeley, Colorado, Dallas, and Amarillo, Texas.

409
00:36:43.125 --> 00:36:52.614
<v Keith Wilson>Most recently, he served as a city manager of Greeley, where he managed 1,600 employees and a $515 million budget serving 116,000 residents.

410
00:36:52.710 --> 00:36:53.338
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

411
00:36:53.472 --> 00:36:54.161
<v Keith Wilson>Community members.

412
00:36:55.157 --> 00:37:05.963
<v Keith Wilson>Raymond has consistently demonstrated values-based leadership, innovation, and a deep commitment to public service, and his track record shows he can deliver results while building trust and collaboration.

413
00:37:07.039 --> 00:37:13.623
<v Keith Wilson>A few of Raymond's accomplishments include revitalizing Greeley's urban core through public-private partnerships.

414
00:37:14.650 --> 00:37:22.777
<v Keith Wilson>He led a $1.1 billion entertainment and housing district project with a proposed 10,000-seat arena and multimodal transit hub.

415
00:37:24.063 --> 00:37:29.903
<v Keith Wilson>He launched Housing Solutions and Homelessness Services departments to transition residents into permanent housing.

416
00:37:31.777 --> 00:37:42.942
<v Keith Wilson>He advanced sustainability and climate resilience initiatives across infrastructure and water systems in Greeley, and transforming development review processes to accelerate affordable housing production.

417
00:37:44.192 --> 00:37:54.612
<v Keith Wilson>These achievements reflect the kind of forward-looking leadership Portland needs as we navigate challenges and opportunities in housing, climate resilience, and community trust.

418
00:37:56.150 --> 00:37:59.987
<v Keith Wilson>I want to take a moment to recognize the council's direct involvement in this hiring process.

419
00:38:00.215 --> 00:38:02.045
<v Keith Wilson>I appreciate your time and your investment.

420
00:38:03.166 --> 00:38:09.239
<v Keith Wilson>Each of you participated in interview panels and provided thoughtful input and shaped this decision.

421
00:38:09.288 --> 00:38:16.615
<v Keith Wilson>Your perspectives ensured that our choice reflects not only the mayor's office, but also the collective priorities of Portland's elected leadership.

422
00:38:17.916 --> 00:38:25.284
<v Keith Wilson>This collaborative approach strengthens the legitimacy of today's confirmation and underscores our shared commitment to effective governance.

423
00:38:26.489 --> 00:38:32.300
<v Keith Wilson>Portland is a remarkable city with passionate residents, talented employees, and a strong sense of purpose.

424
00:38:33.233 --> 00:38:44.742
<v Keith Wilson>While we have faced and will face real challenges, this transition gives us a rare opportunity to reset, to reconnect, and strengthen how we serve the community and Portland for generations to come.

425
00:38:45.898 --> 00:38:55.543
<v Keith Wilson>Raymond's leadership will help us build a strong foundation for this new form of government, one that is aligned, it is trusted, and it's focused on meaningful results.

426
00:38:56.570 --> 00:39:01.144
<v Keith Wilson>Colleagues, I ask for your support in confirming Raymond C. Lee as Portland's City Administrator.

427
00:39:01.257 --> 00:39:01.336
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

428
00:39:02.027 --> 00:39:11.485
<v Keith Wilson>His experience, vision, and commitment to public service will help unlock a new chapter of safety, innovation, and shared prosperity for our city.

429
00:39:12.224 --> 00:39:14.152
<v Keith Wilson>Now I'm proud to introduce Raymond Lee.

430
00:39:15.211 --> 00:39:18.070
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you, Mayor, and, uh, thank God for this opportunity.

431
00:39:18.583 --> 00:39:22.471
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Mayor, I appreciate your support and your words as we go through this process today.

432
00:39:23.643 --> 00:39:28.896
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This has been a very thorough process, I must say, to get us to the point that we are today.

433
00:39:29.570 --> 00:39:43.548
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I want to thank the council members, as I went through the interview process and hearing your questions and your comments and really trying to address some of the key things that you saw that you want to see in the first city administrator.

434
00:39:44.110 --> 00:39:55.054
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I want to thank the public as well too, the public and citizens of this community, the businesses of this community, the ones who have reached out to me to pull my coattails to have a conversation with me.

435
00:39:55.503 --> 00:40:08.351
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I truly appreciate your candidacy, your honesty, and your transparency with me as we went through this process and sharing your overall views and thoughts on how we can make a better Portland than what we have today.

436
00:40:09.297 --> 00:40:22.141
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This has been a monumental achievement for this city to transition itself to where we are today, and a lot of people don't understand what's all entailed in that.

437
00:40:22.927 --> 00:40:24.099
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This— so I give kudos.

438
00:40:24.163 --> 00:40:24.275
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

439
00:40:24.675 --> 00:40:32.639
<v Raymond C. Lee III>To this elected body for stepping into that role and to really help move this city forward in a productive way.

440
00:40:32.894 --> 00:40:34.432
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Because there is a better way to governance.

441
00:40:34.865 --> 00:40:37.637
<v Raymond C. Lee III>There is a better way to provide services to the community.

442
00:40:37.989 --> 00:40:41.804
<v Raymond C. Lee III>There is a better way to help businesses grow within our community.

443
00:40:42.300 --> 00:40:46.771
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And the individuals in this room today are helping shape that for our community.

444
00:40:47.507 --> 00:40:53.099
<v Raymond C. Lee III>My career and why I've been driven to public service has really started at a very young age.

445
00:40:53.614 --> 00:40:56.655
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, I come from a family of public administrators.

446
00:40:57.157 --> 00:40:59.164
<v Raymond C. Lee III>My mother was a city manager.

447
00:40:59.211 --> 00:41:03.481
<v Raymond C. Lee III>My father spent 30 years in the Dallas Fire Department.

448
00:41:03.902 --> 00:41:06.197
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So this wasn't anything that came lightly.

449
00:41:06.699 --> 00:41:08.525
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This is purpose-driven work for me.

450
00:41:08.880 --> 00:41:16.650
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I truly believe this type of work is a calling for individuals to be able to step into and be able to do at a very high level.

451
00:41:17.557 --> 00:41:23.123
<v Raymond C. Lee III>My career almost spans over 20 years in many different positions throughout my career.

452
00:41:25.335 --> 00:41:37.336
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Starting from my home city in Dallas, Texas, a very progressive city where we were moving the needle to try to provide a better quality of life for everyone within that community.

453
00:41:38.411 --> 00:41:54.409
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Various executive and leadership roles in there to really sharpen my toolset and my skills on how to better serve a community that has all different types of needs and desires and wants and socioeconomic status within the community.

454
00:41:54.987 --> 00:42:05.983
<v Raymond C. Lee III>From there, I transitioned to Amarillo, which is a very different community than Dallas, but a very progressive community from the standpoint of what they're trying to achieve from a fiscal standpoint.

455
00:42:06.639 --> 00:42:17.793
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, that really prepared me of how to really set up strategic planning and develop a vision and clarity around that vision and how we were going to achieve that vision as an organization.

456
00:42:19.173 --> 00:42:26.231
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Transitioning to Greeley was another major milestone for me and really focusing in on how do we change culture?

457
00:42:26.856 --> 00:42:36.657
<v Raymond C. Lee III>How do we change an organization that is growing at a rapid pace and to provide services not only that citizens need today, but what citizens will need in the future?

458
00:42:37.282 --> 00:42:57.378
<v Raymond C. Lee III>All this education background, obtaining my master's in public administration and my undergraduate in public administration, Continuing education from Harvard to Cornell to Yale all prepared me for where we are today and the moment that Portland is facing today.

459
00:42:58.070 --> 00:43:00.784
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I'm very excited about this opportunity.

460
00:43:00.896 --> 00:43:04.637
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'm excited about what the future has in store for this great city.

461
00:43:04.847 --> 00:43:12.635
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'm excited about the opportunity to be able to partner with this City Council and with the mayor to really shape what that future would be for Portland.

462
00:43:12.764 --> 00:43:12.989
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

463
00:43:13.182 --> 00:43:13.313
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

464
00:43:13.574 --> 00:43:16.650
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I must say, this is a pivotal time for this city.

465
00:43:18.329 --> 00:43:22.007
<v Raymond C. Lee III>There is a tremendous amount of things that are happening right now.

466
00:43:23.186 --> 00:43:29.637
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Portland has that spotlight, and everybody is watching how this city will be able to maneuver through this.

467
00:43:30.239 --> 00:43:32.807
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Is this a new way of providing services?

468
00:43:33.463 --> 00:43:37.378
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Is this a new way of governing an organization in the city?

469
00:43:38.280 --> 00:43:41.824
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This will be the test model, and all of us are in this together.

470
00:43:42.253 --> 00:43:50.262
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I'm willing to be a willing partner with this council and with the mayor to help shape what that will look like for us as we move forward.

471
00:43:50.777 --> 00:43:55.945
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, I've seen local government at its best, and I've seen local government at its worst.

472
00:43:58.056 --> 00:44:04.800
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This opportunity is pivotal for us to be able to shape what that story is for Portland as we move forward.

473
00:44:05.396 --> 00:44:13.496
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And my job is how do I take the vision That this council has and that the mayor has and turn that vision into reality.

474
00:44:14.074 --> 00:44:25.648
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And really partnering with our great city staff and how we shape that is going to be fundamental to how we are accomplishing the vision, the priorities that you have as a city council.

475
00:44:25.985 --> 00:44:35.329
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'm just gracious and humble and honored to be able to sit before you today and be a part of this great milestone for the city of Portland.

476
00:44:35.393 --> 00:44:35.505
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

477
00:44:38.454 --> 00:44:40.619
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much, Mr. Mayor.

478
00:44:40.715 --> 00:44:42.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for your work in bringing us forward a nominee.

479
00:44:43.219 --> 00:44:58.239
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Mr. Lee, we have appreciated the opportunity to get to know you a little bit through the process and are looking forward to hearing more from you today about what your, uh, what your experience has looked like and what you bring to our city.

480
00:45:00.289 --> 00:45:02.144
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, do we have anybody signed up for public testimony?

481
00:45:02.873 --> 00:45:03.498
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

482
00:45:03.914 --> 00:45:08.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, then colleagues, we will move into a discussion.

483
00:45:08.804 --> 00:45:29.731
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will note there was some feedback that there hadn't been enough outreach to try to bring people in for public testimony earlier this week, and we did make sure that the council social media pages posted something with links to sign up to try to drum up some encouragement from Portlanders to weigh in today.

484
00:45:30.934 --> 00:45:37.878
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we will move forward with our questions, which I know for many of us are influenced by feedback that we did get from our constituents.

485
00:45:37.927 --> 00:45:40.621
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So hopefully we can pull in Portlanders' voices in that way.

486
00:45:41.422 --> 00:45:54.398
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What I'd like us to do, because I know there are at least a few of our colleagues with a number of questions, is limit it to your top 2 questions or comments first so that everybody can have an opportunity to ask something.

487
00:45:55.072 --> 00:46:06.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then I assume we will have more time after that and we will get back to additional questions that everybody has, but I do want to make sure that everybody who wants to get some, some questions in has the time to do so.

488
00:46:07.329 --> 00:46:08.518
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Who would like to kick us off?

489
00:46:11.650 --> 00:46:14.336
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I've never seen us be so slow to rush to the queue, colleagues.

490
00:46:15.331 --> 00:46:16.894
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, go right ahead.

491
00:46:18.010 --> 00:46:24.164
<v Steve Novick>First of all, Mr. Lee, if you can figure out what the visions of any of us are individually, let alone collectively, my hat's off to you.

492
00:46:25.773 --> 00:46:29.726
<v Steve Novick>I think that we have like 12 different sets of visions and different topics.

493
00:46:30.096 --> 00:46:35.793
<v Steve Novick>And frankly, Mr.— I have to tell you that I have no idea what the mayor's vision is for the city other than building up a bunch of homeless shelters.

494
00:46:36.619 --> 00:46:38.385
<v Steve Novick>So look forward to your report on that.

495
00:46:39.632 --> 00:46:52.335
<v Steve Novick>I have a possibly unfair question, which is we've had a problem with the council and the executive in terms of figuring out how council members communicate with city staff.

496
00:46:52.541 --> 00:46:52.594
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

497
00:46:53.594 --> 00:47:01.952
<v Steve Novick>Last fall, the city staff were told you cannot communicate with city councilors except through your deputy city administrators.

498
00:47:02.532 --> 00:47:06.121
<v Steve Novick>And some of us, particularly me, jumped up and down and yelled and screamed and said that's ridiculous.

499
00:47:06.186 --> 00:47:13.025
<v Steve Novick>We should need to be able to call up staff in order to get basic information to help inform our decisions.

500
00:47:13.769 --> 00:47:30.130
<v Steve Novick>And the mayor or Jordan sent out something saying no, it's okay to communicate with however, I know for a fact that there are a bunch of city employees who don't think they really are allowed to communicate with councilors and won't say anything until they've gone through channels.

501
00:47:30.429 --> 00:47:38.050
<v Steve Novick>It's not just that they'll CC their— I mean, I understand they're supposed to CC their superiors if they communicate with us, but they feel like they can't communicate at all.

502
00:47:38.110 --> 00:47:48.469
<v Steve Novick>And I actually had a conversation with a high-ranking official at one of our other local governments last week who said she's talked to city of Portland employees and they are frustrated with the question of how exactly they're expected to and allowed to communicate with us.

503
00:47:48.469 --> 00:47:48.510
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

504
00:47:50.130 --> 00:47:51.715
<v Steve Novick>Allowed to communicate with councilors.

505
00:47:53.565 --> 00:48:03.117
<v Steve Novick>And I think that that is a— I mean, I understand concerns from the executive about councilors like telling individual line staff what to do.

506
00:48:03.181 --> 00:48:04.148
<v Steve Novick>We shouldn't do that.

507
00:48:04.550 --> 00:48:14.032
<v Steve Novick>But we need to be able to communicate with line staff in order to get information and frankly to be able to prevent us from doing stupid things that we might do if we don't have that information.

508
00:48:14.635 --> 00:48:24.789
<v Steve Novick>So I'm just telling you that that's a problem and asking you what will your approach be to trying to figure out a good model for communication between city staff and councilors?

509
00:48:26.184 --> 00:48:36.550
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Throughout my career, the best thing is have a framework in place, one that we agree upon of how we move forward as it relates to communicating and getting things done.

510
00:48:36.614 --> 00:48:45.505
<v Raymond C. Lee III>There's a difference between asking a staff member for some information or conveying a concern that you're hearing from the public as it relates to a city service.

511
00:48:46.251 --> 00:48:52.652
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And developing that framework as it relates to city services and how we as staff are following up with you.

512
00:48:52.733 --> 00:49:06.032
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Because one of my biggest things is assuring that we are responsive to council, we're responsive to the citizens of this community, and that we're following through in what we say we were going to do as an organization.

513
00:49:07.847 --> 00:49:14.844
<v Raymond C. Lee III>As it relates to information and getting information to council, that is a very sensitive subject.

514
00:49:14.987 --> 00:49:23.514
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think from the standpoint of ensuring that when we give information to council, that we're giving that information to everyone that sits on city council.

515
00:49:23.626 --> 00:49:39.380
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We've been in situations before where a council member will ask for a certain piece of information and we get that information to a city council member and the colleagues are left in the dark as it relates to how that information may inform a future council decision.

516
00:49:40.197 --> 00:49:53.565
<v Raymond C. Lee III>One of the key things that I'll be strong upon in ensuring that we do as a leadership team and as city staff is ensuring that when council members are requesting that information, that we're getting that information to the full body.

517
00:49:54.079 --> 00:50:07.574
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And the only way to be able to do that is to be in the loop of what those questions are, what those concerns are, and making sure that we have a formal process of tracking that information and getting that information to the council as a whole.

518
00:50:08.905 --> 00:50:12.159
<v Raymond C. Lee III>There is a million different things happening in the city of Portland.

519
00:50:12.831 --> 00:50:22.815
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I cannot expect for everything to hit my desk and for me to be a bottleneck in that and getting information to this body and to the mayor as a whole.

520
00:50:23.471 --> 00:50:30.666
<v Raymond C. Lee III>My goal is to ensure that I'm informed, that our leadership team and our deputy city administrators are informed of what's happening.

521
00:50:31.434 --> 00:50:47.474
<v Raymond C. Lee III>There's certain things that have a political lens to it as well that staff needs to be aware of and ensuring that we're getting council the information in a timely fashion that gets you prepared to have conversations that you are going to have in the community.

522
00:50:48.072 --> 00:51:07.054
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But my whole goal is to be transparent about the information that we are giving to the council as a whole, as individuals, as a whole, and make sure that we have a process in place that we can be able to track that information and be sure that we're following through on the things that we said we were going to do.

523
00:51:12.697 --> 00:51:13.516
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, follow-up?

524
00:51:14.706 --> 00:51:18.373
<v Steve Novick>Yes, I just want to say that I understand where you're coming from.

525
00:51:18.503 --> 00:51:30.268
<v Steve Novick>However, if I ask a question to a staffer like I asked the other day, and I did CC leadership on this, how much money is the Portland Clean Energy Fund invested in bicycle-related projects?

526
00:51:31.041 --> 00:51:33.766
<v Steve Novick>And the response is to reply all to all councilors' offices.

527
00:51:34.222 --> 00:51:38.550
<v Steve Novick>Then I think that the other councilors' offices will be confused and their emails will be cluttered.

528
00:51:39.030 --> 00:51:44.273
<v Steve Novick>So maybe that's the best way to do it, but I just want you to answer that question.

529
00:51:44.320 --> 00:51:48.938
<v Steve Novick>Do you think literally every question one of us asks, that has to be reply all to all the councilors?

530
00:51:49.755 --> 00:51:52.159
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It may not be reply all in that instance.

531
00:51:52.737 --> 00:52:08.659
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What I've typically done in my career, there's memorandums that we'll send out towards the end of the week or monthly to council just to keep them apprised of what's happening in the city, different things that may be of interest to them as Councilors and making sure that we're getting that information.

532
00:52:09.077 --> 00:52:18.036
<v Raymond C. Lee III>If that question is leading to a decision that will be coming forth this body to be deciding or deliberating on, that is information that I would want to share.

533
00:52:18.485 --> 00:52:27.735
<v Raymond C. Lee III>If you're just telling me, Raymond, there's a pothole at this intersection, no, uh, we will respond to that and get that taken care of, uh, as it relates to you.

534
00:52:28.264 --> 00:52:45.155
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But since this is an interesting dynamic, as we have 3 different councilors serving in a particular district, I would want to make sure that other councilors within that district are aware of that because they may get that same concern or complaint as well.

535
00:52:45.541 --> 00:52:52.472
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And we want to make sure that we're addressing that and we're not duplicating efforts as staff as it relates to communication and resolving those issues.

536
00:52:55.481 --> 00:52:56.472
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Anything further, councilor?

537
00:52:57.262 --> 00:52:58.643
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

538
00:52:58.853 --> 00:52:59.608
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

539
00:53:00.619 --> 00:53:01.518
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

540
00:53:01.985 --> 00:53:03.286
<v Olivia Clark>Welcome, so good to see you.

541
00:53:03.429 --> 00:53:05.085
<v Olivia Clark>I am so pleased that you are here.

542
00:53:06.161 --> 00:53:08.056
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate your opening remarks.

543
00:53:08.666 --> 00:53:14.030
<v Olivia Clark>You actually said some of the things that I wanted to say back to you about pivotal moment and culture change.

544
00:53:14.110 --> 00:53:14.784
<v Olivia Clark>So important.

545
00:53:14.833 --> 00:53:16.969
<v Olivia Clark>I talk about culture change all the time.

546
00:53:18.463 --> 00:53:27.465
<v Olivia Clark>We have had growing pains, and I'm sure you know that, and we've stumbled on occasion, So I know that you're going to facilitate us, our improvement there.

547
00:53:27.998 --> 00:53:38.079
<v Olivia Clark>My question to you is, this is an issue that's come up in the Governance Committee among a few of us, is that we have never had the benefit of a strategic planning session.

548
00:53:38.273 --> 00:53:45.963
<v Olivia Clark>And I don't remember if we talked about this in our interview process, but I guess what I would like to know is how you would approach that.

549
00:53:46.027 --> 00:53:48.699
<v Olivia Clark>We are working on a resolution in the Governance Committee.

550
00:53:48.780 --> 00:53:48.844
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

551
00:53:49.775 --> 00:53:55.010
<v Olivia Clark>To set up a strategic planning process involving you, or perhaps you leading it.

552
00:53:55.170 --> 00:54:01.050
<v Olivia Clark>I'm not sure yet, but I'd love to have you or hear your comments about how you would do that with us.

553
00:54:02.302 --> 00:54:08.293
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think a strategic plan is the most vital document that an organization has.

554
00:54:08.967 --> 00:54:18.407
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It sets the roadmap on what are our priorities as an organization, what is our vision, And how we plan on achieving that as an organization.

555
00:54:19.240 --> 00:54:28.012
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And it also develops measurements, key performance indicators within that, to be able to track how successful we are as an organization.

556
00:54:28.782 --> 00:54:33.239
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That strategic plan provides clarity to the organization regarding where we're going.

557
00:54:33.978 --> 00:54:39.012
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It provides a strategic roadmap on how we plan on getting there as an organization.

558
00:54:40.086 --> 00:55:01.742
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This is going to be a crucial step And changing how we do business as an organization and having that as a guiding document and really using that document to inform how do we move budgetary decisions forward, how do we move policy decisions forward, and what are our true priorities as a city.

559
00:55:02.579 --> 00:55:06.547
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But we have to build the foundation first before we even get to a strategic plan.

560
00:55:07.302 --> 00:55:19.364
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We have to set the groundwork and the foundation to be able to move forward with a strategic plan and create the environment where a strategic plan can be successful, not only for the council, but for staff as well.

561
00:55:20.168 --> 00:55:28.327
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Right now, you know, as we build towards that, it's really going to be narrowing what are our true priorities as an organization.

562
00:55:28.905 --> 00:55:32.101
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What are we trying to work for in this next year or 2?

563
00:55:32.536 --> 00:55:41.088
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And the strategic plan, in my mind, has to be at the top of that list on really setting that direction on where we're heading as an organization.

564
00:55:41.681 --> 00:55:51.355
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Without that direction, we're all throwing darts in the dark and hoping that we hit the bullseye as it relates to what we're trying to achieve as an organization.

565
00:55:52.028 --> 00:56:02.152
<v Raymond C. Lee III>The question that we're gonna have to ask ourselves as we go through this strategic planning process is also what is the public's input into this as well?

566
00:56:03.260 --> 00:56:09.490
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What is their role in help shaping the future direction that we'll be heading as an organization?

567
00:56:10.085 --> 00:56:23.057
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And what will be our role in helping and ensuring that that happens as leaders within this organization to help better shape what the next 3 to 5 years will look like for our organization and for our community?

568
00:56:23.572 --> 00:56:26.012
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But it's— in my mind, it is vital.

569
00:56:26.059 --> 00:56:26.268
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

570
00:56:26.847 --> 00:56:35.373
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That we have this document to give direction to staff and to the community of what we're doing and how we're doing it.

571
00:56:37.170 --> 00:56:37.914
<v Olivia Clark>Just one follow-up.

572
00:56:37.996 --> 00:56:38.822
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for that.

573
00:56:38.985 --> 00:56:39.860
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate that.

574
00:56:40.217 --> 00:56:51.648
<v Olivia Clark>Just to riff off a little bit about what my councilor to my right said, you're going to have 12 different ideas, 12 different desires, 12 different goals.

575
00:56:52.889 --> 00:56:58.338
<v Olivia Clark>I'm going to be interested in how you manage that before we get to that strategic planning process that you identified.

576
00:56:58.739 --> 00:57:01.699
<v Olivia Clark>You don't have to answer that right now, but I'm just going to put that out there.

577
00:57:02.052 --> 00:57:02.728
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

578
00:57:03.259 --> 00:57:06.186
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That's some of the pre-work that I was talking about we have to do before we even get there.

579
00:57:07.679 --> 00:57:07.938
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

580
00:57:08.036 --> 00:57:08.817
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

581
00:57:09.092 --> 00:57:09.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

582
00:57:10.701 --> 00:57:12.601
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. Lee.

583
00:57:12.650 --> 00:57:13.496
<v Mitch Green>I'm glad that you're here today.

584
00:57:14.936 --> 00:57:18.606
<v Mitch Green>I was excited to see your candidacy advance to the point that it did.

585
00:57:19.030 --> 00:57:19.721
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mayor.

586
00:57:19.784 --> 00:57:19.914
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

587
00:57:20.010 --> 00:57:21.666
<v Mitch Green>Glad we're able to have this conversation here today.

588
00:57:21.827 --> 00:57:22.938
<v Mitch Green>So I'll just get right into it.

589
00:57:22.985 --> 00:57:24.016
<v Mitch Green>I just have 2 questions.

590
00:57:24.369 --> 00:57:32.824
<v Mitch Green>The first question is a little bit related, I think, to Councilor Novick's, but I want to address it from the standpoint of the charter duties of the city administrator.

591
00:57:33.630 --> 00:57:41.661
<v Mitch Green>So Article 4, Section 2-406 outlines the duties, powers of the city administration, but primarily the duties.

592
00:57:43.226 --> 00:57:53.929
<v Mitch Green>And one of the key provisions under that that section requires that the city administration keep, quote, keep the council at all times fully advised as to the financial condition and needs of the city.

593
00:57:54.842 --> 00:58:04.831
<v Mitch Green>So I guess I'd ask you, how do you interpret— what does it mean to keep the council fully advised at all times of the financial condition of the city?

594
00:58:05.650 --> 00:58:07.429
<v Mitch Green>And then maybe we can kind of go from there.

595
00:58:07.735 --> 00:58:07.878
<v Joseph Perez>Yes.

596
00:58:08.311 --> 00:58:28.108
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, in my previous roles, what I've always been keen on, and this is something that That in my mind is critical for council to be able to understand where we stand financially is holding quarterly kind of work session updates to kind of brief council where we are financially as an organization and where we are from a budgetary standpoint.

597
00:58:28.574 --> 00:58:37.213
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This has been key things that we have been able to do to just be able to be aware of what changes may be happening from a forecast standpoint.

598
00:58:37.646 --> 00:58:46.224
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What we've also done from a budgetary standpoint 'Cause the financial arm and budgetary are in the same family, but they're different to a certain degree.

599
00:58:47.186 --> 00:58:58.298
<v Raymond C. Lee III>From a budgetary standpoint, what we have done is kind of monthly kind of budget, monthly memos to council to kind of let them know where we are from a budgetary standpoint as an organization.

600
00:58:58.347 --> 00:59:16.818
<v Raymond C. Lee III>If there was any major thing that may be a change within it, if there was major appropriations depending on what the city charter has outlined in it as it relates to council's approval and that ensuring that council is well aware of what's happening before it comes to the actual dais for you to vote on.

601
00:59:17.731 --> 00:59:36.954
<v Raymond C. Lee III>One of the key things that we want to make sure is that the council is well informed on the things that you're going to have to be voting on or things that you're going to get questioned on as it relates to people in the community and the concerns that they may have regarding the direction that the city may be heading, if it's from a financial standpoint or if it's from a service standpoint.

602
00:59:37.003 --> 00:59:37.114
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

603
00:59:37.452 --> 00:59:46.793
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We have the same level of importance on that as a staff, that we're making sure that you're informed about what those are, what does it mean to the organization.

604
00:59:47.467 --> 00:59:58.204
<v Raymond C. Lee III>As different priorities come up as it relates to different programs, that council is fully aware of what is the budgetary impact on moving forward with that policy decision.

605
00:59:58.702 --> 01:00:01.382
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So you— to do that, you have to know what the numbers are.

606
01:00:01.445 --> 01:00:15.413
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You have to be well informed about what those decisions and trigger points are as we go through a year that may change how we look at something or view something, how we may need to modify our budget overall.

607
01:00:15.862 --> 01:00:32.119
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But it's critical in my mind, as you're making policy decisions as a legislative body, that you understand the numbers that are impacting how the city may implement that and how the city may be able to move forward and evaluate that.

608
01:00:32.617 --> 01:00:41.197
<v Raymond C. Lee III>As a successful program or a program that we need to come back to council because we're not seeing the impact that we want to see overall.

609
01:00:41.630 --> 01:00:45.469
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And this kind of goes back to kind of how do I look at budgeting overall.

610
01:00:45.742 --> 01:00:48.442
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'm a very big priority budget person.

611
01:00:48.876 --> 01:01:03.469
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It goes back to Councilwoman Clark's comments earlier of really designating what our priorities are and funding things that really move the needle to accomplish the priorities that we have set out as an organization, and that's critical.

612
01:01:04.416 --> 01:01:07.445
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, and I appreciate your focus on priority budgeting.

613
01:01:08.518 --> 01:01:10.795
<v Mitch Green>So just to follow up on that, thank you for that answer.

614
01:01:11.565 --> 01:01:21.840
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Smith earlier in the year filed a resolution to require the city administrator to notify council of any significant meaningful changes in our fund balances within a 2-week reporting period.

615
01:01:22.369 --> 01:01:32.659
<v Mitch Green>And this last summer, the city administrator, or at least one of the the DCAs became aware of a significant change in our fund balances as early as late July, perhaps.

616
01:01:33.367 --> 01:01:37.480
<v Mitch Green>Um, and council was notified of that balance in late November.

617
01:01:38.371 --> 01:01:48.644
<v Mitch Green>And so my question to you would be, if you were in that seat at that time, would you have told council within 2 weeks of that fund balance change, or would you have sort of waited that long?

618
01:01:49.675 --> 01:01:58.989
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What I would do— and it always depends on the situation at hand and what we're faced with, and me truly understanding if that's an accurate number Or is that a number that we think is?

619
01:01:59.166 --> 01:02:22.088
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And what I have always done throughout my career is I may pull your coattail from the standpoint of letting council know that, hey, we are aware of something, we're evaluating to be able to see what that real number is, and we'll be following up, or I will be personally following up with you to keep you apprised of where we are with evaluating that situation.

620
01:02:22.748 --> 01:02:26.282
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And one of the key things that I will share with council as well, and how do we set that?

621
01:02:26.331 --> 01:02:26.396
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

622
01:02:27.606 --> 01:02:29.052
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Platform to be able to do that.

623
01:02:29.695 --> 01:02:38.159
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, I plan on having meetings, regular routine meetings with this body as individuals to meet with you.

624
01:02:38.224 --> 01:02:52.775
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And these are the type of discussions that we will have so you're well aware of the things that are on my plate and the things that I'm focusing on, or things that may be coming to your attention very soon or that you need to be aware of because it may hit the public eye.

625
01:02:52.873 --> 01:02:52.985
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

626
01:02:53.402 --> 01:02:54.331
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Very shortly.

627
01:02:54.699 --> 01:03:01.382
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So it's hard to say right off the bat what I would weigh it because I don't know the full details of that situation.

628
01:03:01.893 --> 01:03:15.947
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But kind of rule of thumb for me is, is make sure that I'm meeting with council on a regular basis so we have the opportunity to have this conversation as it relates to matters that may be coming to the full body for future discussion.

629
01:03:16.396 --> 01:03:16.893
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for that.

630
01:03:16.956 --> 01:03:20.786
<v Mitch Green>And I think for me, what's going to sort of inform my decision today Mm-hmm.

631
01:03:20.947 --> 01:03:35.476
<v Mitch Green>Is understanding what you weigh in terms of the public trust and transparency in the public trust versus, you know, how long does it take to get maybe the right and perfect and true answer out to council to avoid embarrassment?

632
01:03:35.557 --> 01:03:42.637
<v Mitch Green>Because what I don't want to do is confirm a city administrator who wants to hold information back 'cause they're worried about embarrassing the city.

633
01:03:42.958 --> 01:03:47.630
<v Mitch Green>And I'm not suggesting that's what happened last summer, but I think that's on folks' minds right now.

634
01:03:47.679 --> 01:03:48.739
<v Mitch Green>It's on my mind for sure.

635
01:03:49.777 --> 01:03:50.652
<v Mitch Green>So thanks for that answer.

636
01:03:50.719 --> 01:03:51.541
<v Mitch Green>It gives me some insight.

637
01:03:53.070 --> 01:03:56.503
<v Mitch Green>Just to finish out, I want to follow up on Steve— Councilor Novick's question.

638
01:03:58.297 --> 01:04:05.483
<v Mitch Green>I appreciated your answers to his question on the relationship between communicating with staff and the administrative side with the City Council.

639
01:04:06.130 --> 01:04:14.847
<v Mitch Green>But I guess I would ask, do you think City Council as legislators should be able to directly address bureau directors?

640
01:04:14.896 --> 01:04:15.009
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

641
01:04:16.077 --> 01:04:23.981
<v Mitch Green>And have a reasonable expectation that they will get back to them in a meaningful timeframe to allow them to engage in legislation?

642
01:04:25.135 --> 01:04:25.360
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

643
01:04:26.594 --> 01:04:31.822
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And it goes back to, and I'm gonna kind of touch upon your last question and feed it into this question as well.

644
01:04:32.382 --> 01:04:33.697
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It's always about transparency.

645
01:04:34.931 --> 01:04:43.269
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That has been a huge thing throughout my career is ensuring good, bad, or indifferent, we have to be able to get the information out to our public.

646
01:04:43.735 --> 01:04:46.284
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And so So they are aware of what's happening.

647
01:04:46.621 --> 01:04:48.257
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What are we planning on doing to address it?

648
01:04:48.304 --> 01:04:58.456
<v Raymond C. Lee III>If it's one of those situations where it's something where there's opportunity for growth for the organization and how we may have handled something in the past, we always want to be transparent about that.

649
01:04:58.744 --> 01:05:03.923
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We never want to hide information, and that is never the role of government to hide information.

650
01:05:04.436 --> 01:05:10.498
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It is to be transparent with what's happening within the organization and how do we plan to move forward as an organization.

651
01:05:10.563 --> 01:05:10.755
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

652
01:05:11.813 --> 01:05:16.269
<v Raymond C. Lee III>There always are timeframes, and I'm very big on service level agreements.

653
01:05:17.264 --> 01:05:22.025
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We were using 'em in Dallas as it relates to kind of that timeframe that we felt suitable.

654
01:05:22.538 --> 01:05:29.110
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And this was an agreement between us and the city council as it relates to what is that timeframe to respond back to the council.

655
01:05:29.606 --> 01:05:39.835
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Now, we might not have a direct answer, a response to your question, but you know, one rule of thumb that we've always had was at least follow back up in 3 days and a follow-up in another 3 days.

656
01:05:40.364 --> 01:05:42.094
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So council is aware of where we are.

657
01:05:42.143 --> 01:05:42.318
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

658
01:05:42.815 --> 01:05:43.826
<v Raymond C. Lee III>In evaluating that.

659
01:05:44.259 --> 01:05:58.911
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Now, that may not give you a full report in that, but it's at least a touch base so you know that we are aware of your situation and that we're still trying to address your situation or your concern or your request for information as a whole.

660
01:05:59.423 --> 01:06:03.800
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And this is something that I will continue to want to do as we move into this.

661
01:06:03.927 --> 01:06:24.318
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'll be working with you as a collective body and really trying to figure out what is that for this body and what is considered responsive from that standpoint and what is adequate to be able to get information to council in a timely manner that you feel that you're getting the information that you need and it's accurate information that you're getting as well.

662
01:06:24.670 --> 01:06:28.567
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And we're not backpedaling 3 days later trying to change that information.

663
01:06:29.000 --> 01:06:35.123
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So the biggest thing in this is ensuring that we get you accurate information, but also make sure it's timely as well.

664
01:06:35.170 --> 01:06:35.282
<v Robert Pyle>Thank you.

665
01:06:36.875 --> 01:06:37.197
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

666
01:06:37.344 --> 01:06:44.688
<v Mitch Green>I think that's it for now, Madam President, and thanks for answering those questions, and I'll provide space for my colleagues.

667
01:06:45.079 --> 01:06:45.242
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

668
01:06:45.420 --> 01:06:46.132
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

669
01:06:46.472 --> 01:06:47.315
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for the answers.

670
01:06:47.380 --> 01:06:48.239
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy.

671
01:06:49.731 --> 01:06:50.233
<v Jeff Selby>Thank you.

672
01:06:54.119 --> 01:07:06.228
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've been trying to frame this as a question, but largely as my colleagues have been talking, it's mostly now evolved into a comment, and I'm sort of riffing off of what my colleagues have said about the The relationship between the administration and the City Council and information sharing.

673
01:07:06.742 --> 01:07:19.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Specifically, we've been under an immense period of transition for the last 2 years, moving first into a service area model and then condensing those service areas down.

674
01:07:20.503 --> 01:07:31.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>Additionally, we're doing some right-sizing of staffing and things around, you know, making sure we have streamlined HR and communications and procurement and things like that.

675
01:07:32.206 --> 01:07:38.465
<v Jamie Dunphy>It has led to some enormous frustration in my office because I still don't fully understand how the city is structured.

676
01:07:39.170 --> 01:07:40.213
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know who to talk to.

677
01:07:40.614 --> 01:07:47.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think that as you are starting to explore and understand and learn the city, you will see some efficiencies that need to be improved.

678
01:07:47.675 --> 01:07:52.635
<v Jamie Dunphy>You will see some, uh, uh, confusing structural issues.

679
01:07:52.891 --> 01:07:54.672
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would hope that you would sort of yes.

680
01:07:54.769 --> 01:08:07.146
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do you sort of plan on taking what you learn about the city structure and translating it, even if it's an iterative process, so that we can have a better understanding of how to navigate the bureaucracy right now?

681
01:08:08.543 --> 01:08:17.194
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we would be very open to, you know, in concert with the mayor, obviously, but about what those next steps and structural changes are going to be around service delivery.

682
01:08:18.511 --> 01:08:22.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>In addition to just the simple act of communication, do I go to the Deputy City Administrator?

683
01:08:22.845 --> 01:08:23.904
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do I go to a director?

684
01:08:24.050 --> 01:08:25.878
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do I go to frontline staff.

685
01:08:26.680 --> 01:08:29.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>It would be really good to just have a better understanding.

686
01:08:29.664 --> 01:08:33.965
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is something we specifically, my office, has been trying to get an org chart and an iterative org chart.

687
01:08:34.012 --> 01:08:40.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I would hope that you would keep that in mind as you are learning about the nuances of this city and how we could do it better.

688
01:08:40.895 --> 01:08:48.436
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that's my one sort of nerdy inside game that I'd really like you to help us with.

689
01:08:49.238 --> 01:08:50.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>The other one's an outside game.

690
01:08:50.521 --> 01:09:00.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I want to be a little bit sensitive about this, but Portland— I'm really incredibly grateful that you have come to choose to call Portland home and to help us lead this next great chapter.

691
01:09:01.350 --> 01:09:10.783
<v Jamie Dunphy>But Portland is a weird place, and it's weird in that we have naked bike rides and voodoo donuts and things like that, but we're also a very passive-aggressive city sometimes.

692
01:09:11.216 --> 01:09:19.320
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have a really bad— we have a deep history of racism, and it is not a history It's not a long— it's not an ancient history.

693
01:09:20.872 --> 01:09:49.527
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have seen in my 20 years of public service in this community repeatedly as we attract national top talent of individuals who also happen to be people of color, and we as a community will lift them up on a pedestal without any of the supports or the networks or the grace or the the dignity that we need to help this person be successful, and then we start throwing things at that person.

694
01:09:49.606 --> 01:09:53.268
<v Jamie Dunphy>And when they inevitably fall, the city collectively shrugs our shoulders.

695
01:09:53.604 --> 01:09:54.712
<v Jamie Dunphy>I do not want to see that happening.

696
01:09:54.809 --> 01:10:00.043
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to see the talent and the passion and the experience that you have to help our city grow.

697
01:10:00.524 --> 01:10:07.493
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so from my office, at the very least, I will tell you that I want to be one of those resources to help you be successful in this job.

698
01:10:07.751 --> 01:10:18.194
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is in all of our best interests that you are successful and that we as a collective do not allow some of the bad behavior that this community has done to happen here.

699
01:10:18.340 --> 01:10:24.131
<v Jamie Dunphy>We want to see you succeed and want to keep those lines of communication and those lines of support happening.

700
01:10:24.179 --> 01:10:34.643
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I just want to extend that to you first and just flag it publicly and let the community know that I— we're gonna say the quiet part out loud and that it is time.

701
01:10:34.707 --> 01:10:39.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a new chapter, and we are going to do everything we can to make sure that you are successful in this position.

702
01:10:39.230 --> 01:10:46.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you for your, your vote of confidence in Portland at this moment, and you have my partnership in, in making sure that we can lead this city forward.

703
01:10:46.770 --> 01:10:47.140
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

704
01:10:48.720 --> 01:10:49.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

705
01:10:49.994 --> 01:10:50.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos.

706
01:10:53.480 --> 01:10:55.256
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy.

707
01:10:55.322 --> 01:10:56.806
<v Candace Avalos>That is— that's tea.

708
01:10:57.194 --> 01:10:57.596
<v Candace Avalos>That's tea.

709
01:10:58.050 --> 01:10:58.769
<v Candace Avalos>Um, agree.

710
01:10:59.702 --> 01:11:03.631
<v Candace Avalos>So congratulations on your appointment as administrator.

711
01:11:03.855 --> 01:11:12.421
<v Candace Avalos>As you have heard from all of us, this is a really pivotal moment for our city, and your leadership is going to help shape how this new form of government comes to life.

712
01:11:13.159 --> 01:11:17.891
<v Candace Avalos>As we continue implementing this historic transition, I expect you to lead in this new system.

713
01:11:18.389 --> 01:11:30.149
<v Candace Avalos>Portlanders need an administrator who is committed to making this government work as intended, with clearer accountability, stronger coordination, and a partnership built on trust between the executive and the legislative branches.

714
01:11:30.969 --> 01:11:33.442
<v Candace Avalos>I also want to emphasize the importance of accessibility.

715
01:11:34.115 --> 01:11:41.390
<v Candace Avalos>Portlanders deserve an administrator who is present, who listens, who understands the lived experiences of the people that we serve.

716
01:11:42.064 --> 01:11:52.212
<v Candace Avalos>And so I expect you to do the hard work of getting to know our communities across neighborhoods, languages, cultures, identities, and to make yourself genuinely accessible to the public.

717
01:11:53.689 --> 01:11:57.690
<v Candace Avalos>Finally, I also hope that you will help be a bridge between our 2 branches of government.

718
01:11:57.948 --> 01:12:10.835
<v Candace Avalos>As you can hear from my colleagues, we don't feel that that bridge is strong right now, and you're coming at a pivotal moment where we expect you to urgently take the lead on how to strengthen that bridge between our government.

719
01:12:11.639 --> 01:12:17.905
<v Candace Avalos>Success under this new model requires collaboration and transparency and shared understanding of our goals, as you know, and so I look forward to working with you on that.

720
01:12:17.970 --> 01:12:18.274
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

721
01:12:18.340 --> 01:12:19.654
<v Candace Avalos>Working with you in that spirit.

722
01:12:20.697 --> 01:12:22.172
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you again for your service.

723
01:12:23.182 --> 01:12:29.261
<v Candace Avalos>Before I close, I have a few questions that I think are important both for the council but also for the public to hear from you.

724
01:12:29.984 --> 01:12:39.734
<v Candace Avalos>So first and foremost, how will you ensure that both council and the public have clear, regular visibility into your administration's performance and your decision-making?

725
01:12:40.184 --> 01:12:47.208
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, one of the things that is critical as we move forward, and I talked about this a little bit earlier, is transparency.

726
01:12:47.417 --> 01:12:49.377
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'm very big on dashboards.

727
01:12:49.957 --> 01:13:02.712
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And as we start really outlining what are some of those key priorities that we have as an organization, where we are from a financial standpoint, is creating those dashboards and making those dashboards public-facing.

728
01:13:03.307 --> 01:13:13.734
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, we've been able to do that in my previous city where we have made forward-facing information as it relates to our police, our major projects, how we're spending on those major projects.

729
01:13:13.783 --> 01:13:13.878
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

730
01:13:13.992 --> 01:13:18.710
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Kind of whether those major milestones within those major projects.

731
01:13:18.966 --> 01:13:25.515
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think that is a huge component of transparency and letting the public know where we are as an organization.

732
01:13:25.931 --> 01:13:26.846
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Are we on point?

733
01:13:27.311 --> 01:13:31.243
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And actually showing— there's nothing wrong with having red on a dashboard.

734
01:13:31.548 --> 01:13:38.193
<v Raymond C. Lee III>There's something that is causing that, that we all need to be aware of to make sure that we're addressing that as an organization.

735
01:13:38.626 --> 01:13:40.279
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And being transparent and honest with that.

736
01:13:40.697 --> 01:13:49.832
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Is critical as it relates to communicating not only to our City Council, but also to our public on how are we doing overall as an organization.

737
01:13:50.265 --> 01:14:05.632
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And as we move through developing a strategic plan as an organization, putting that strategic plan on a dashboard as well, and really showing the public what are we doing, where are we moving the needle, where we're not moving the needle.

738
01:14:05.680 --> 01:14:05.777
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

739
01:14:06.386 --> 01:14:07.972
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Where are there opportunities for growth?

740
01:14:08.871 --> 01:14:10.136
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And what are those opportunities?

741
01:14:10.314 --> 01:14:10.939
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Is it funding?

742
01:14:11.131 --> 01:14:13.454
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Is it resources from a staffing standpoint?

743
01:14:13.840 --> 01:14:20.925
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Is it because, you know, we're just not ready as an organization to move that initiative forward because we're about to make some other policy decisions?

744
01:14:20.988 --> 01:14:25.510
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And making sure that's clear and transparent to the community is essential.

745
01:14:26.262 --> 01:14:37.393
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It has to be part of the fabric of who we are as an organization and part of the culture as an organization of how we present information and move information forward as an organization.

746
01:14:37.907 --> 01:14:40.426
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And we will have to take this show on the road as well.

747
01:14:41.036 --> 01:15:04.645
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This is going to be times where we're going to have to, and I believe it should be standard, that in the beginning I would like to be the council members' partner in that, in going to and talking to the citizens within your respective districts about what's happening as an organization and kind of what are those key things that May be troubling for us as an organization to move some of these initiatives forward, because I want people to feel heard.

748
01:15:05.256 --> 01:15:10.345
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think the biggest thing that we have in any organization— every organization struggles with this.

749
01:15:10.425 --> 01:15:11.981
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It's not just a Portland thing.

750
01:15:13.378 --> 01:15:15.225
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Are people feeling heard?

751
01:15:16.573 --> 01:15:22.127
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And if people are not feeling heard, that's when they show up to these meetings and have a ton of things to say.

752
01:15:22.993 --> 01:15:29.078
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And as long as we are creating the avenue and the platform for people to talk and to be heard and that they feel we are listening—.

753
01:15:29.078 --> 01:15:29.479
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilmember Herbold.

754
01:15:30.216 --> 01:15:32.126
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Uh, to them, everything is not going to be a yes.

755
01:15:32.783 --> 01:15:45.585
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We're not going to be able to address every single concern that a citizen have because of a financial predicament that we may not be able to address it, or it may be a policy decision not to address that.

756
01:15:46.033 --> 01:16:00.329
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But long as people feel heard and that we're trying to move the needle to make this a better community overall for everyone, we're trying to enhance not only the quality of life but the quality of place and where people are living within our community.

757
01:16:00.329 --> 01:16:09.750
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That is the essential thing that we have to make sure and ensure that we're doing for the citizens and the businesses and also the visitors of our community.

758
01:16:09.989 --> 01:16:11.949
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

759
01:16:11.949 --> 01:16:13.229
<v Candace Avalos>I appreciate that answer.

760
01:16:13.229 --> 01:16:18.130
<v Candace Avalos>And I think I would just add, though, that to be heard is one thing.

761
01:16:18.130 --> 01:16:22.729
<v Candace Avalos>To operationalize and structure the way you make decisions by what you hear is another.

762
01:16:22.877 --> 01:16:23.261
<v Candace Avalos>Mm-hmm.

763
01:16:23.646 --> 01:16:30.042
<v Candace Avalos>And so my next question is, what commitments can you make today about how you will show up in community, not just downtown, Mm-hmm.

764
01:16:30.716 --> 01:16:33.088
<v Candace Avalos>But across districts, across culture, identity?

765
01:16:33.185 --> 01:16:35.092
<v Candace Avalos>How are you gonna show up for all Portlanders?

766
01:16:36.551 --> 01:16:44.567
<v Raymond C. Lee III>One of this, I'm gonna need your help in really helping me, letting me know these places that I need to be, the places I need to be engaged in.

767
01:16:45.063 --> 01:16:48.510
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know your community way better than I know Portland today.

768
01:16:48.990 --> 01:16:56.252
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know those key stakeholders, and I've already started touching point with a lot of different key stakeholders with within the community.

769
01:16:56.685 --> 01:17:08.600
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But I'm going to be leaning heavy on this council to help shape what does that look like as we move forward in those connections I need to make and really touching point with people, everyday people in this community.

770
01:17:08.953 --> 01:17:20.788
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This goes back to kind of as I roll out, I want to get out in the community and have town halls with the council members hand in hand to really meet the individuals within the community.

771
01:17:20.837 --> 01:17:20.997
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

772
01:17:21.525 --> 01:17:27.283
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Who are shaping the things that we do as a community and who are the heartbeat of this community.

773
01:17:27.652 --> 01:17:30.217
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So I would say I can't do this by myself.

774
01:17:30.603 --> 01:17:43.399
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This is going to be an effort that I'll be leaning on the mayor and the city council to be able to help shape what that looks like, and our city staff to make sure that I'm in the right room at the right time and having the conversations that need to be had.

775
01:17:43.976 --> 01:17:46.189
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But I know I don't know everything.

776
01:17:46.462 --> 01:17:47.296
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I don't know everyone.

777
01:17:47.360 --> 01:17:47.488
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

778
01:17:48.069 --> 01:18:03.994
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But I think as a collective body, as the individuals in this room and the key stakeholders within the community, we'll be able to shape what that looks like in this first year of my tenure as city administrator to make sure that I'm in those right rooms with the right people.

779
01:18:06.423 --> 01:18:14.150
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Smith, Dunphy, and I represent a district that has long felt disconnected from City Hall, has— does not have trust with City Hall.

780
01:18:14.230 --> 01:18:37.202
<v Candace Avalos>So I would say, I would suggest That you pilot those ideas, those efforts in our district, because I think if you can be successful in getting East Portlanders to be a part of the process, your decision-making, to feel like their values and ideas are being heard and reflected in those decisions, that's gonna make a big impression not only on Portlanders, but on us who are trying to help usher that voice into City Hall.

781
01:18:37.667 --> 01:18:50.592
<v Candace Avalos>So lastly, what can Portlanders and this council expect from you in the first 90 days the first thing, you're going to see me out in the community.

782
01:18:51.685 --> 01:19:01.759
<v Raymond C. Lee III>These first 90 days is going to be essential of how I split up my time between city staff and ensuring that city staff has the time to be able to spend with me, but also the public as well.

783
01:19:01.887 --> 01:19:20.351
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I really feel for the staff that works with me because I know that's going to be a hard thing to do to make sure that, that time is equally split up between the things that I'm doing internally into the organization, into the operations of the organization, but also externally and having a presence within the community.

784
01:19:20.787 --> 01:19:34.998
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And this first 90 days is gonna be a listening tour to really listen to not only to the city council, but to staff and to the community of what's happening well within our organization and in our community, and what are those opportunities for growth?

785
01:19:35.587 --> 01:19:37.850
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Within our organization and within the community.

786
01:19:38.252 --> 01:19:45.912
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Those first 90 days will be really shaping and some of the groundwork that we talked about earlier before we can move forward with a strategic plan.

787
01:19:46.506 --> 01:20:00.056
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I have to have a good setting of where we are today and what are those areas that we have room to grow today and what are those areas that we are phenomenal at as a staff and as a leadership team in moving forward.

788
01:20:00.475 --> 01:20:10.094
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Once I have that firm understanding, then we can move forward to some of those transactional things that need to take place within the organization to ensure that the organization is moving forward.

789
01:20:11.088 --> 01:20:20.740
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I don't want to have knee-jerk reactions as it relates to the things and comments that I hear from the organization overall, from the community.

790
01:20:20.805 --> 01:20:32.706
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I want to be able to take that in and be able to digest that and strategically plan how do we move forward and work with my team on how we move those things forward and work with this City Council regarding how do we move these things forward.

791
01:20:32.753 --> 01:20:33.042
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

792
01:20:33.588 --> 01:20:38.516
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Because if the community is not feeling the change, is there change really happening?

793
01:20:38.628 --> 01:20:41.838
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's the real question that we have to really figure out.

794
01:20:42.064 --> 01:20:44.648
<v Raymond C. Lee III>How do we measure change for our community?

795
01:20:44.728 --> 01:20:47.746
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What does success look like for our organization?

796
01:20:48.243 --> 01:21:00.634
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's gonna be a collaborative approach between us, the mayor, and the city council to really figure out what does that look like for our organization, for our community, and how are we measuring and gauging that?

797
01:21:00.779 --> 01:21:06.605
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And going back to the transparency model of how we're communicating and showing the community how we're moving to this.

798
01:21:07.038 --> 01:21:08.403
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But this is a change of culture.

799
01:21:09.029 --> 01:21:11.886
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I can tell you right now, change of cultures don't happen in a year.

800
01:21:12.417 --> 01:21:20.009
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We can see steady progress towards that movement, but culture change takes 3 to 5 years to change a culture of the organization.

801
01:21:20.506 --> 01:21:26.671
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Doesn't mean we don't have many milestones within that, and we celebrate those milestones that we're making as an organization.

802
01:21:27.185 --> 01:21:31.807
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But we have to be realistic about what the challenges that we're faced with, with as an organization.

803
01:21:31.872 --> 01:21:32.096
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

804
01:21:32.403 --> 01:21:38.987
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And how we plan on tackling those challenges as we move forward collectively as leaders of this great city.

805
01:21:41.203 --> 01:21:42.779
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you very much for your answers.

806
01:21:43.037 --> 01:21:47.944
<v Candace Avalos>I am giving you my commitment to partnership, to some patience.

807
01:21:48.121 --> 01:21:48.699
<v Candace Avalos>The bar's high.

808
01:21:49.327 --> 01:21:50.019
<v Candace Avalos>I'll give you a little patience.

809
01:21:51.225 --> 01:21:54.511
<v Candace Avalos>And lastly, you're my new pillar pal, so we got to be tight.

810
01:21:54.641 --> 01:21:54.836
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Tight.

811
01:21:55.192 --> 01:21:55.451
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

812
01:21:55.596 --> 01:21:56.131
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you again.

813
01:21:57.231 --> 01:21:57.960
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

814
01:21:58.041 --> 01:21:58.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for the answers.

815
01:21:59.092 --> 01:21:59.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Morillo.

816
01:22:01.588 --> 01:22:02.567
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

817
01:22:02.951 --> 01:22:09.908
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you for your presentation, Mayor, and thank you so much, Raymond, for being here today and for letting us ask you all these questions.

818
01:22:10.085 --> 01:22:11.783
<v Angelita Morillo>I really appreciated your interview.

819
01:22:11.863 --> 01:22:26.019
<v Angelita Morillo>I felt like you gave us very specific answers, and I'm specifically very excited about your constant discussions about having more public accessibility around what we are working on as a city and where we are at with those issues.

820
01:22:26.180 --> 01:22:35.414
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that's something that the public really needs to see in order to have faith in our new system, and that's something that you spoke a lot about during your interviews and that I hear you're bringing up now, so I appreciate that.

821
01:22:36.555 --> 01:22:48.104
<v Angelita Morillo>I think like many of my colleagues, we've had discussions as we're implementing this new form of government about the flow of information and, you know, how councilors get information from bureau staff in order to create policies.

822
01:22:48.617 --> 01:22:57.802
<v Angelita Morillo>I personally think that city staff are some of the highest experts in our community, and I don't just mean the folks who are higher up.

823
01:22:57.931 --> 01:22:59.525
<v Angelita Morillo>I mean people who are frontline workers.

824
01:22:59.637 --> 01:23:04.694
<v Angelita Morillo>They sometimes know far better than we do or anybody else what needs to be done at the city.

825
01:23:05.293 --> 01:23:11.520
<v Angelita Morillo>So I kind of wanted to ask a few follow-up questions regarding some of Councilor Novick's questions earlier.

826
01:23:11.826 --> 01:23:21.024
<v Angelita Morillo>Do you believe that frontline staff should be empowered to support the work of council and to support the policy development for council offices?

827
01:23:21.274 --> 01:23:21.356
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

828
01:23:21.500 --> 01:23:23.350
<v Angelita Morillo>What specifically does that look like to you?

829
01:23:24.413 --> 01:23:27.520
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I look at it from the standpoint of policy for the city as a whole.

830
01:23:29.069 --> 01:23:37.176
<v Raymond C. Lee III>The frontline staff are gonna be the individuals that are ensuring that the policy decisions that are made at this dais is actually being implemented and done.

831
01:23:37.449 --> 01:23:40.563
<v Raymond C. Lee III>They are the bloodline of this organization to ensure that happens.

832
01:23:41.144 --> 01:23:59.771
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And they have to play a role in working through their leadership within their departments to ensure that their voices are being heard as it relates to whatever policy decision that is being considered at the dais is something that can truly be implemented or is gonna require additional resources to be able to get that job done.

833
01:24:00.430 --> 01:24:11.256
<v Raymond C. Lee III>One thing that we have done successfully in organizations that I've been in and something that I would love to be able to do here, if not yet established within this organization, is have employee advisory committees.

834
01:24:12.076 --> 01:24:16.637
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And these employee advisory committees really help shape kind of what's happening.

835
01:24:16.975 --> 01:24:24.074
<v Raymond C. Lee III>How are the different policy decisions or leadership decisions from a procedural standpoint are impacting the day-to-day employee.

836
01:24:25.264 --> 01:24:31.126
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Labor groups will play a major role in that as well in shaping what that means for us overall.

837
01:24:31.608 --> 01:24:46.994
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But we cannot make decisions as leaders within the organization and for the city and not take into account the impact it would have on the everyday employee that is administering this policy decision.

838
01:24:47.572 --> 01:24:48.614
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Is it realistic?

839
01:24:49.497 --> 01:24:50.556
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Is it attainable?

840
01:24:51.279 --> 01:25:00.185
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And have them help us develop what is measurable from this standpoint to actually be able to tell us, is it being successfully done overall?

841
01:25:00.506 --> 01:25:16.791
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So employees have to play a major role in any policy decision that is being had, and they have to have a seat at the table as it relates to how we are shaping policy that will not only have impact on the community, but have impact on our employees as well.

842
01:25:17.110 --> 01:25:30.884
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's a key thing for me as we move forward, is that I'm being that voice for the employees as well and ensuring that things that we're doing as leaders in this organization, that is having the impact on them.

843
01:25:30.980 --> 01:25:40.600
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Because not only do we want to improve the quality of life for our citizens, but we want to enhance the quality of the work environment for our employees as well.

844
01:25:40.680 --> 01:25:40.889
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

845
01:25:41.338 --> 01:25:43.119
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So to— short answer, yes.

846
01:25:44.051 --> 01:25:54.417
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Employees have to play a role in how we develop policy, but we also have to develop the framework of how does that happen as an organization.

847
01:25:54.948 --> 01:25:56.376
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's gonna be the key thing.

848
01:25:56.729 --> 01:26:07.161
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What is that framework and how do we engage and how do we bring staff forward to be able to help infuse their expertise in the formation of policy?

849
01:26:08.550 --> 01:26:12.229
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

850
01:26:12.229 --> 01:26:22.439
<v Angelita Morillo>While I appreciate the discussion about impacts to staff, I think part of what I'm trying to get at more is— that's important, but I'm talking more about policy development.

851
01:26:22.829 --> 01:26:32.970
<v Angelita Morillo>So if we have city staff that are experts in certain spaces, but they're not necessarily at the deputy city administrator level, or they are more frontline staff, how do we plan to add those folks to staff?

852
01:26:32.970 --> 01:26:33.090
<v Clare Adamsick>I think that's a great question.

853
01:26:36.770 --> 01:26:49.447
<v Angelita Morillo>How do we create a system where we are— or do you believe in having a system where we are affirmatively taking their ideas and not just policies that are already existing, but novel ideas that haven't come forward yet?

854
01:26:50.362 --> 01:26:52.578
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think we have to set up the framework to be able to do that.

855
01:26:52.692 --> 01:26:59.969
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think it's essential that we have it, but I think we have to figure out what works best for this city and how do we do that.

856
01:27:00.707 --> 01:27:02.792
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And it goes back to prioritization as well too.

857
01:27:03.369 --> 01:27:16.573
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, I want to make sure that we're creating the space where staff has the opportunity to be innovative and bring forth those ideas that will have policy implications about how City Council may want to move things forward.

858
01:27:16.846 --> 01:27:23.055
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think staff plays a pivotal role in that, but it's also creating the environment for them to be successful at doing that.

859
01:27:23.488 --> 01:27:25.717
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's the key thing that I want to make sure that we're focusing on.

860
01:27:25.814 --> 01:27:25.990
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

861
01:27:26.457 --> 01:27:32.145
<v Raymond C. Lee III>As we create this framework is how are we creating the environment for them to be able to do that?

862
01:27:32.980 --> 01:27:41.787
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Because we can very be caught into the day-to-day of putting out the fires of today and not thinking about futuristic things about how do we improve our city.

863
01:27:42.220 --> 01:27:48.872
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's a change in culture and a change of mindset of how we move those things forward as an organization and as staff.

864
01:27:49.130 --> 01:27:58.444
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I just wanna make sure that we have the framework in the culture as an organization to be able to do that, because I think it's very vital that we are doing that.

865
01:27:59.729 --> 01:28:05.445
<v Angelita Morillo>Can you be a bit more specific about what that framework would look like and who gets a seat at the table and who doesn't?

866
01:28:06.618 --> 01:28:17.198
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It's hard to say what it will look like today because I would want to be able to get in to see what's actually happening now as an organization and how these things are coming forward, how staff is being engaged.

867
01:28:18.033 --> 01:28:19.122
<v Raymond C. Lee III>To actually do this.

868
01:28:19.555 --> 01:28:29.381
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, different things work for different organizations, and I don't wanna take one model that I've previously done and try to say, oh, this is gonna work for Portland and be great for Portland.

869
01:28:29.671 --> 01:28:31.850
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So I don't wanna be able to do that to you today.

870
01:28:32.219 --> 01:28:41.676
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But what you have a commitment from me is, is to be able to sit down with this body to try to work through what that looks like for us long-term and immediate.

871
01:28:41.917 --> 01:29:01.381
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But what does that look like for an organization that we're gonna have a tremendous amount of policy changes, a tremendous amount of evolution as we grow and evolve as an organization and as a city, and how are we having that constant process improvement and looking at how do we move things forward as leaders within this organization.

872
01:29:01.574 --> 01:29:03.020
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's a commitment you have from me.

873
01:29:04.144 --> 01:29:05.235
<v Angelita Morillo>I appreciate that so much.

874
01:29:05.476 --> 01:29:11.578
<v Angelita Morillo>Well, I certainly look forward to working with you and doing a deep dive on all of these systems and how we can pass policy together.

875
01:29:11.626 --> 01:29:13.617
<v Angelita Morillo>So really appreciate your time today.

876
01:29:13.841 --> 01:29:14.162
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

877
01:29:14.260 --> 01:29:14.676
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

878
01:29:15.382 --> 01:29:15.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

879
01:29:16.104 --> 01:29:16.953
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for the answers.

880
01:29:17.002 --> 01:29:17.676
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

881
01:29:17.868 --> 01:29:22.695
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Madam President, and good morning, Mayor Wilson, and a warm welcome to you, Mr. Raymond Lee.

882
01:29:23.962 --> 01:29:32.350
<v Dan Ryan>Welcoming— welcome to these chambers where, as a city administrator, you'll be sitting right over there and we'll be spending a lot of time together.

883
01:29:33.279 --> 01:29:34.386
<v Dan Ryan>So welcome to Wednesday.

884
01:29:34.466 --> 01:29:34.835
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

885
01:29:35.493 --> 01:29:40.944
<v Dan Ryan>Through the recruitment process, I've been impressed not only with your experience and knowledge, but your poise and your authenticity.

886
01:29:41.747 --> 01:29:48.247
<v Dan Ryan>I was taken with your track record of shaking things up towards a data-driven continuous improvement culture.

887
01:29:48.408 --> 01:29:50.238
<v Dan Ryan>What are you, a brown belt in Six Sigma?

888
01:29:50.335 --> 01:29:51.554
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Green, green belt right now.

889
01:29:51.859 --> 01:29:54.363
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, I'm sure that will go up to brown eventually.

890
01:29:54.988 --> 01:30:03.783
<v Dan Ryan>Um, for those that don't know what that means, it's a way of, um, you become skilled in continuous improvement, and there's this thing called Six Sigma.

891
01:30:04.137 --> 01:30:09.048
<v Dan Ryan>I will now stop being a nerd about this with But I look forward to doing it offline.

892
01:30:09.679 --> 01:30:11.293
<v Dan Ryan>I was taken with your track record, though.

893
01:30:11.375 --> 01:30:17.880
<v Dan Ryan>It was so exciting to do dialogue with you on this topic in our interview, and I have faith that you will lead our city in a brave new direction.

894
01:30:18.380 --> 01:30:27.597
<v Dan Ryan>The selection of a city administrator marks the biggest milestone for the city under the new charter changes, second, second in mind to all of us being elected last year.

895
01:30:28.716 --> 01:30:29.881
<v Dan Ryan>So here's the questions.

896
01:30:31.698 --> 01:30:35.747
<v Dan Ryan>In my opinion, we've struggled to set up data-driven accountability in the private sector in Oregon.

897
01:30:36.458 --> 01:30:38.832
<v Dan Ryan>In Multnomah County, and at the city.

898
01:30:40.034 --> 01:30:42.537
<v Dan Ryan>And the public is begging for us to be more accountable.

899
01:30:43.498 --> 01:30:49.320
<v Dan Ryan>I had to go to great lengths as a former commissioner where you had a lot more influence to insist on such practices.

900
01:30:49.993 --> 01:30:55.783
<v Dan Ryan>And the former director at the Bureau of Development Services Permitting was supportive, and we got there.

901
01:30:56.634 --> 01:31:03.369
<v Dan Ryan>Once those permitting datasets were established and maintained, the entire process of reforming permitting system began to take off.

902
01:31:04.572 --> 01:31:07.411
<v Dan Ryan>As you know, that soil work does take time.

903
01:31:07.652 --> 01:31:09.608
<v Dan Ryan>It's very time-consuming, and it's action.

904
01:31:10.282 --> 01:31:10.377
<v Steve Novick>Yep.

905
01:31:10.922 --> 01:31:11.725
<v Dan Ryan>It's bold action.

906
01:31:12.527 --> 01:31:27.136
<v Dan Ryan>Tell me how you brought along the culture in Greeley, Colorado, to lean into becoming a data-driven culture, and what lessons did you learn that will help you do the same here in, I would say, a more independently rugged Portland, Oregon?

907
01:31:27.586 --> 01:31:38.239
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, what we created in Greeley was a performance and data analytics position and department for our organization.

908
01:31:38.898 --> 01:31:42.378
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Coming into the organization, we didn't have performance matrix.

909
01:31:42.845 --> 01:31:48.974
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, we had things where I would say we were counting widgets, uh, how many potholes we fill.

910
01:31:49.487 --> 01:31:53.240
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And to the everyday citizen, what does that truly mean?

911
01:31:53.979 --> 01:32:01.247
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And really trying to develop performance matrix that truly speak to telling a story on how we're providing a service.

912
01:32:02.001 --> 01:32:06.171
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Are we performing at the level that we need to be performing to provide that service?

913
01:32:06.524 --> 01:32:11.530
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Or are there capacity issues as it relates to our ability to perform that service?

914
01:32:11.963 --> 01:32:27.301
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We started small and really working with our budget and using our budget as that tool to really develop 3 performance metrics for every single department that tells a story about how that department is doing Overall.

915
01:32:27.912 --> 01:32:46.685
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And from there, what we started doing, and I started with our public safety arm of our organization because we always talk about data, but public safety is probably the biggest entity that really uses that data to really— you really use that data of how we move forward, how they implement policy, and how they move resources as a whole.

916
01:32:47.199 --> 01:32:52.885
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We started up quarterly reviews with our public safety arm to actually go through the data.

917
01:32:53.462 --> 01:32:53.911
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And sit down.

918
01:32:54.087 --> 01:32:57.917
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I just didn't want to see, and I said this earlier, just the green within this.

919
01:32:58.332 --> 01:33:14.740
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I wanted to be able to see those areas of improvement that we have as an organization, because it's critical to be able to know where those things are, because we have to understand the root cause of what's happening and what is causing the problems within our organization or within a respective bureau or department.

920
01:33:15.413 --> 01:33:16.422
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That was essential.

921
01:33:17.320 --> 01:33:31.529
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Just this last year, we moved it to where it was quarterly management reviews with the executive leadership team, where the executive leadership team was going through this same dialogue on how we're doing and how we're performing overall as an organization.

922
01:33:31.886 --> 01:33:34.280
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It wasn't an aha or a got you session.

923
01:33:34.863 --> 01:33:45.194
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It was a session to ensure that everyone in this city had clarity on where we were heading as an organization and what was impeding us to be able to achieve some of those things.

924
01:33:45.614 --> 01:33:46.422
<v Raymond C. Lee III>'Cause sometimes it's other departments.

925
01:33:46.471 --> 01:33:46.536
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

926
01:33:47.273 --> 01:33:50.689
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That are impeding our ability to be able to achieve the things that we have.

927
01:33:51.188 --> 01:34:04.488
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So it goes back to what I talked about earlier of creating that environment where we're having these conversations and that we are having this dialogue as leaders within our organization to be able to move key things forward as an organization.

928
01:34:04.921 --> 01:34:12.076
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But the first thing was developing the baseline data within our organization, which we didn't have in a lot of different areas.

929
01:34:12.140 --> 01:34:12.444
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

930
01:34:13.024 --> 01:34:15.890
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And setting that benchmark of what that is.

931
01:34:16.390 --> 01:34:23.465
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Also bringing in data from other cities as well that may be comparable to what we're doing as an organization.

932
01:34:23.885 --> 01:34:33.435
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It sometimes is— some police chiefs will argue with this as well too, but it's always key to be able to see your crime rate compared to another crime rate.

933
01:34:33.677 --> 01:34:35.743
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Now, what's built into that crime rate will vary.

934
01:34:36.097 --> 01:34:42.118
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Different cities verify it differently as it relates to them looking at their crime rate and what's built into that number.

935
01:34:42.207 --> 01:34:42.279
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

936
01:34:42.903 --> 01:35:04.048
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But looking at our benchmark cities and seeing how we compare against our benchmark cities is essential because we are in competition as it relates to other cities throughout this nation, ensuring that we have the best services that we can provide to a community and that we're recruiting and retaining the best talent within our city as a whole.

937
01:35:04.658 --> 01:35:09.905
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So as we look at how do we build this, it starts at the very infant stages.

938
01:35:10.804 --> 01:35:14.752
<v Raymond C. Lee III>One, how are we measuring success and what does success look like?

939
01:35:15.217 --> 01:35:26.871
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And how we're measuring that will be essential on how do we tell the story of how we are improving as an organization or areas that we're doing quite well as an organization.

940
01:35:27.112 --> 01:35:31.172
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Then building that off into where we're bringing other people into the conversation.

941
01:35:31.686 --> 01:35:38.600
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And what I've always seen success in doing is having a meeting with the City Council and it really depends on the City Council.

942
01:35:38.729 --> 01:36:02.192
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But what I've seen success in doing is doing a yearly check-in with the City Council as it relates to all those performance measures to kind of give the full document, but have a presentation that's kind of abbreviated version of that, 'cause we'll be in here probably till midnight to actually go through all that information, but give you the opportunity to be able to ask critical questions.

943
01:36:02.545 --> 01:36:06.247
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But a lot of those critical questions should be answered within the document itself.

944
01:36:06.295 --> 01:36:06.470
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

945
01:36:07.032 --> 01:36:13.315
<v Raymond C. Lee III>As it relates to why we may not be hitting that measure point and what are we doing to fix that as well.

946
01:36:14.229 --> 01:36:14.582
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

947
01:36:14.984 --> 01:36:22.983
<v Dan Ryan>If you heard some giggles, it's because we have this thing called Council After Dark once a month, and we often have stayed almost to midnight.

948
01:36:23.078 --> 01:36:28.801
<v Dan Ryan>So yeah, I really appreciate that you distinguish between inputs and outcomes.

949
01:36:29.074 --> 01:36:29.203
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

950
01:36:29.539 --> 01:36:35.203
<v Dan Ryan>I think government has a tendency to measure success always about Oh, we got money out the door, so what did it do?

951
01:36:35.797 --> 01:36:37.966
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that's— you get it.

952
01:36:38.865 --> 01:36:41.515
<v Dan Ryan>I mentioned this to you personally and to the mayor as well.

953
01:36:41.595 --> 01:36:44.777
<v Dan Ryan>I think your time in the Mountain West, was it 5 years?

954
01:36:45.194 --> 01:36:46.511
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Yes, almost, January.

955
01:36:46.881 --> 01:36:50.719
<v Dan Ryan>I think that experience was a stepping stone to adapting to Portland.

956
01:36:51.233 --> 01:36:55.457
<v Dan Ryan>In other words, it's an easier leap when you're coming directly than coming directly from Dallas.

957
01:36:55.730 --> 01:36:58.429
<v Dan Ryan>I'll just say that because I've experienced that many times.

958
01:36:59.502 --> 01:37:03.859
<v Dan Ryan>How did you adapt to Greeley when you moved from Dallas?

959
01:37:04.550 --> 01:37:06.131
<v Dan Ryan>And what was your thinking on that?

960
01:37:06.277 --> 01:37:15.216
<v Dan Ryan>And how would you take those experiences and use those as you adapt now from the Mountain West to the great Pacific Northwest?

961
01:37:16.104 --> 01:37:21.134
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know what I always say, it wasn't a huge adjustment for me to go to Greeley.

962
01:37:23.725 --> 01:37:41.622
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Majority of my career was with the City of Dallas, but I also spent some time in Amarillo, which was a very agriculture Uh, community, blue-collar community, uh, that really valued, uh, the cost of government and how we move things forward from that standpoint.

963
01:37:42.926 --> 01:37:46.935
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That right there prepared me because I challenged myself when I left Dallas.

964
01:37:47.113 --> 01:37:56.304
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And, you know, I didn't know if I was good because I knew the Dallas way and I was good with an organization that I understood the framework and everything within it.

965
01:37:56.385 --> 01:37:59.430
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Uh, And that was part of the reason why I left Dallas.

966
01:37:59.846 --> 01:38:01.036
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I wanted a different challenge.

967
01:38:01.469 --> 01:38:20.463
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I wanted to be able to challenge my skill set and add to my toolkit, to be in a totally different type of community that didn't have the resources that a Dallas have or the depth and talent that a Dallas had, but had all the grit in the world to be a first-class city and to provide first-class services.

968
01:38:21.057 --> 01:38:35.944
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think that was the big That was the biggest adjustment for me and the biggest flex for me to be able to go from a city that had a tremendous amount of assets and resources to a community where we had to be innovative about how do we move and create new programs and new projects.

969
01:38:36.425 --> 01:38:43.698
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Coming into a new, any new city is getting adapted to the culture and the values of that community.

970
01:38:44.211 --> 01:38:48.119
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And doing that, it goes back to some of the conversations that we had earlier.

971
01:38:48.393 --> 01:38:52.029
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It's getting out in the community and having conversations with people in the community.

972
01:38:53.024 --> 01:39:07.289
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Letting them put a name to a face with me and for me to be able to put a name and face together for them as well is essential in creating that relationship and trust between what's happening as the change happens overall.

973
01:39:07.805 --> 01:39:27.198
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think one of the biggest things for anything, because Greeley was my smallest community that I ever served in, was really understanding the small town feel of of the interest and the input that people want to do and be able to touch and feel you as a leader within the organization.

974
01:39:27.711 --> 01:39:41.069
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And some of those same attributes I found and I grew from to say you can apply that to larger cities and be successful in how do you interact and relate to the everyday citizen within the community.

975
01:39:41.646 --> 01:39:43.154
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I have lived experience.

976
01:39:44.470 --> 01:39:48.655
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, this is part of the reason why I chose Portland as a host.

977
01:39:48.752 --> 01:39:49.121
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

978
01:39:50.068 --> 01:40:14.322
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I chose Portland because I truly felt the attributes that I've learned from all of my stops in my career, that this was made for me to be able to step into this role and be able to apply those things to try to help this community connect more to the government that is serving them, and for us to be able to connect more to the people that we serve on a day-to-day basis.

979
01:40:14.738 --> 01:40:14.931
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

980
01:40:15.717 --> 01:40:22.239
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So I don't think there's gonna be a huge change for me as it relates to how I'm connecting to people overall.

981
01:40:22.511 --> 01:40:26.725
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think the biggest change for me is getting to learn the nuances, the neighborhoods.

982
01:40:27.783 --> 01:40:42.220
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's why I'll be leaning on the people in the room to help me figure those things out, 'cause that's gonna be essential for me and my success as a city administrator, making sure that I'm making those connections at the level that they need to be made at.

983
01:40:42.301 --> 01:40:42.412
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

984
01:40:43.087 --> 01:40:45.828
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that there's accountability there as well.

985
01:40:46.454 --> 01:40:54.634
<v Raymond C. Lee III>If we're saying it's something as an organization we're going to do, that we're actually doing that, and it's not something that we said and something we forgot about.

986
01:40:55.194 --> 01:40:59.829
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's going to be a partnership between us to ensure that we're following through on those things.

987
01:41:00.182 --> 01:41:02.877
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But I'm excited about this opportunity.

988
01:41:02.925 --> 01:41:07.864
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'm excited about the future of Portland, and I'm excited about the work that we have ahead of us.

989
01:41:07.961 --> 01:41:08.168
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

990
01:41:08.282 --> 01:41:15.685
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Us because it's challenging work, but it's legacy work that we'll be doing and really helping shaping the future of this community.

991
01:41:17.394 --> 01:41:18.475
<v Dan Ryan>Now say Willamette.

992
01:41:18.895 --> 01:41:19.363
<v Dan Ryan>Willamette.

993
01:41:19.702 --> 01:41:20.266
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Willamette.

994
01:41:22.445 --> 01:41:34.301
<v Dan Ryan>Finally, as an FYI, the Governance Committee did pass strategic priority legislation on Monday, and this timely item will be coming to the council next week so we can land a sage practice at the beginning of the new year.

995
01:41:34.907 --> 01:41:36.716
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor.

996
01:41:40.060 --> 01:41:44.369
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Councilor Novick, you've asked some questions, so we'll go to folks who haven't yet.

997
01:41:45.052 --> 01:41:46.305
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, go right ahead.

998
01:41:49.043 --> 01:41:49.673
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Mr. Lee.

999
01:41:49.755 --> 01:41:50.432
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Mayor.

1000
01:41:50.885 --> 01:41:53.292
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I have no questions for you.

1001
01:41:53.565 --> 01:41:54.405
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've already interviewed you.

1002
01:41:54.761 --> 01:41:56.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>I take a different approach today.

1003
01:41:56.699 --> 01:42:01.881
<v Eric Zimmerman>Having, uh, been a deputy city manager, I understand the The scrutiny that you've gone through.

1004
01:42:01.979 --> 01:42:02.931
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for stepping up.

1005
01:42:02.997 --> 01:42:15.993
<v Eric Zimmerman>I told the mayor that I was actually in favor and would support any one of the 3 finalists who came because I believe in the executive's ability to appoint who they think they need to lead this organization.

1006
01:42:16.346 --> 01:42:18.935
<v Eric Zimmerman>And you've been chosen by this mayor, and I'll be supporting that.

1007
01:42:19.884 --> 01:42:25.563
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, this, this city is a barge now.

1008
01:42:27.291 --> 01:42:33.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>And yet it has evolved from a bunch of disparate bureau rafts in its previous era.

1009
01:42:33.266 --> 01:42:33.572
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1010
01:42:34.600 --> 01:42:41.972
<v Eric Zimmerman>There are some people who have chosen to get on the barge and help us row in that direction, and there are some who are still trying to paddle the water out of their bureaus.

1011
01:42:43.208 --> 01:42:49.201
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am really looking forward to your leadership in helping get us all on the same barge and rowing in the same direction.

1012
01:42:49.715 --> 01:42:55.966
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for those who remain on their rafts, I support you in bringing in your own team to lead this organization the direction you want to go.

1013
01:42:56.368 --> 01:43:07.488
<v Eric Zimmerman>I believe that strongly, and I'm saying it here on the record so that everybody knows where I stand when Mr. Lee brings forward any changes that we needed to see to get this city to the organization which the voters put us in charter.

1014
01:43:07.875 --> 01:43:11.916
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we are still lagging with a foggy remembrance of the old system.

1015
01:43:12.095 --> 01:43:13.311
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you for stepping up.

1016
01:43:13.377 --> 01:43:15.081
<v Eric Zimmerman>You have a lot of work ahead of you.

1017
01:43:15.162 --> 01:43:24.551
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, The part of this city rowing in the right direction is that the city administration has to have a spine, right?

1018
01:43:24.695 --> 01:43:29.091
<v Eric Zimmerman>We will come up with good ideas, but we will also come up with some bad ideas.

1019
01:43:29.349 --> 01:43:33.471
<v Eric Zimmerman>It doesn't work if the city administration does not have an opinion on our legislation.

1020
01:43:34.082 --> 01:43:43.532
<v Eric Zimmerman>We may disagree and we may still pass stuff, but it requires you to enter the knowledge void and get into the mix with us about what is good and what yes.

1021
01:43:43.725 --> 01:43:45.731
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm welcoming that in the future.

1022
01:43:45.811 --> 01:44:01.418
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to know the city administration's official position on legislation that we are looking at as a— as the legislative body, because I think if we are operating without that knowledge, our legislation cannot be as successful as it should be.

1023
01:44:01.627 --> 01:44:18.838
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so while it is new to Portland, that is not new to those of us who've worked in the The city council-manager form of government, the mayor-form— the mayor-manager form of government, and those who have existence— or excuse me, experience in ICMA.

1024
01:44:18.886 --> 01:44:19.592
<v Eric Zimmerman>Mm-hmm.

1025
01:44:19.913 --> 01:44:25.548
<v Eric Zimmerman>You might be inheriting the only city with no senior staff with any ICMA experience in America.

1026
01:44:26.190 --> 01:44:38.729
<v Eric Zimmerman>I encourage you to make that one of your foundational pieces for if you want to be a senior leader in this organization, start getting involved with people who work in this type of form of government in other So that's another note to you.

1027
01:44:38.953 --> 01:44:47.704
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I will say, this may be one of the few cities in America that when the city administrator is named, I don't see all DCAs or bureau directors in this room.

1028
01:44:48.266 --> 01:44:50.917
<v Eric Zimmerman>That might not be a nod or a knock to them.

1029
01:44:50.997 --> 01:44:56.585
<v Eric Zimmerman>They may not know that that is the norm and the expectation, but I'm saying it into this camera and on this microphone.

1030
01:44:57.243 --> 01:44:59.828
<v Eric Zimmerman>You have a cultural change that we've noted today.

1031
01:44:59.988 --> 01:45:00.229
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1032
01:45:01.337 --> 01:45:07.421
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is going to take your encouragement to get people to understand how this system is going to be successful.

1033
01:45:07.533 --> 01:45:13.087
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I am very excited for you because in our interview you got praise from my notes.

1034
01:45:13.296 --> 01:45:14.644
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciated what you brought.

1035
01:45:15.302 --> 01:45:32.735
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I also just want to end, you know, colleagues, I'm involved with a network of other gay elected officials across the United States and the world, and I've had 3 members of the LGBT community who are elected officials from Denver, Cincinnati, and one in the state of Oregon who've reached out to me.

1036
01:45:33.688 --> 01:45:37.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm highlighting that— and they reached out to me in support of you, Raymond.

1037
01:45:37.916 --> 01:45:49.759
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm highlighting that because in Portland, it sometimes has given us pause to bring a person from the South for my community, right?

1038
01:45:49.823 --> 01:45:54.868
<v Eric Zimmerman>The South is not a place that my community necessarily thinks of as always a welcoming part of our country.

1039
01:45:55.697 --> 01:46:01.657
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so for people who look at your resume, uh, that can give them pause.

1040
01:46:01.720 --> 01:46:02.890
<v Eric Zimmerman>It doesn't give me pause.

1041
01:46:03.148 --> 01:46:08.787
<v Eric Zimmerman>As one of the out and outspoken members of the gay community in Portland, I'm fully supportive of you.

1042
01:46:09.235 --> 01:46:22.814
<v Eric Zimmerman>My 3 colleagues from other parts of this, this country who've reached out to say, I support Raymond Lee as your next city administrator, that means something because only 3 people reached out and all of them are a member of my community and all of them them support you.

1043
01:46:23.363 --> 01:46:24.640
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for stepping up.

1044
01:46:25.125 --> 01:46:29.440
<v Eric Zimmerman>Lastly, I hope you'll make Portland your residence, and I look forward to that.

1045
01:46:29.489 --> 01:46:35.292
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know it's not part of our legal requirements, but many cities it is, and I— so I look forward to you making Portland your residence.

1046
01:46:36.402 --> 01:46:39.818
<v Eric Zimmerman>The Pearl District is great, but so are other parts of District 4.

1047
01:46:41.743 --> 01:46:43.864
<v Raymond C. Lee III>FYI, I will be living in Portland.

1048
01:46:44.496 --> 01:46:45.386
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1049
01:46:45.532 --> 01:46:51.679
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate that so much, and with that, I just— a resounding support for you.

1050
01:46:51.806 --> 01:46:52.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1051
01:46:52.431 --> 01:46:58.279
<v Eric Zimmerman>And a resounding support for you, Mayor, because I believe you deserve the executive you need to run this city the direction you need to go.

1052
01:46:58.456 --> 01:47:02.894
<v Eric Zimmerman>We will cross-check you if we don't like the direction, but you need the administrator to get the work done.

1053
01:47:03.327 --> 01:47:03.904
<v Eric Zimmerman>You have my support.

1054
01:47:04.304 --> 01:47:04.929
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor.

1055
01:47:06.131 --> 01:47:06.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1056
01:47:07.171 --> 01:47:07.908
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1057
01:47:09.175 --> 01:47:09.655
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1058
01:47:09.815 --> 01:47:10.890
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

1059
01:47:11.097 --> 01:47:16.337
<v Loretta Smith>I am so pleased to be here today and want to congratulate the mayor too.

1060
01:47:17.347 --> 01:47:23.914
<v Loretta Smith>On bringing you on because it is a huge— I look at it as an opportunity.

1061
01:47:24.349 --> 01:47:24.765
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

1062
01:47:24.894 --> 01:47:30.385
<v Loretta Smith>We are at a crossroads and we do need that leadership at the top.

1063
01:47:31.155 --> 01:47:55.784
<v Loretta Smith>And I believe that you being here, being here before time, talking to folks, and as I was listening to you, In the interview, and I was with District 4 when we interviewed you, and I was thinking, wow, I like the idea that you talked about a strategic plan.

1064
01:47:57.041 --> 01:48:03.542
<v Loretta Smith>I like the idea that you, you are not quick to deliver a response.

1065
01:48:03.800 --> 01:48:15.938
<v Loretta Smith>You, you said here today we have to figure out a framework, and I think that's good because people will try to box you into a particular answer.

1066
01:48:16.570 --> 01:48:19.003
<v Loretta Smith>And so for me, you passed the first test.

1067
01:48:22.453 --> 01:48:35.216
<v Loretta Smith>As a new person, and I was a new elected in 2010, and when your family comes out, we'll figure out what church they go to when your wife and family comes out.

1068
01:48:35.653 --> 01:48:42.898
<v Loretta Smith>But I got a call from my Aunt Doris, and she said, I need to talk to you about something.

1069
01:48:43.590 --> 01:48:44.613
<v Loretta Smith>She said, we need to talk.

1070
01:48:44.743 --> 01:48:47.167
<v Loretta Smith>And you know when somebody said we need to talk, it's real serious.

1071
01:48:48.286 --> 01:48:53.471
<v Loretta Smith>So she said, why are you taking those, uh, bus passes from the kids?

1072
01:48:55.135 --> 01:48:56.587
<v Loretta Smith>And I said, I don't know what you're talking about.

1073
01:48:56.667 --> 01:49:00.752
<v Loretta Smith>She said, well, Mother Williams from the church said that you're taking the bus passes from the kids.

1074
01:49:01.027 --> 01:49:05.703
<v Loretta Smith>I said, I have not even had one budget session, I don't know what she's talking about.

1075
01:49:06.492 --> 01:49:12.292
<v Loretta Smith>And so you will find that you will have people who will call you and ask you about stuff that you don't even know about.

1076
01:49:13.000 --> 01:49:21.386
<v Loretta Smith>So I went to the chair and I said, can you tell— did you keep the bus passes in the— in your budget that you have to drop at the county?

1077
01:49:21.435 --> 01:49:21.693
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Mm-hmm.

1078
01:49:21.837 --> 01:49:24.505
<v Loretta Smith>And he said, yes, they're in there.

1079
01:49:24.970 --> 01:49:25.710
<v Loretta Smith>I said, thank you.

1080
01:49:25.854 --> 01:49:30.609
<v Loretta Smith>I said, because my aunt is on the phone and she she's talking about Ms. Williams is mad at me.

1081
01:49:31.091 --> 01:49:31.989
<v Loretta Smith>I just got elected.

1082
01:49:32.037 --> 01:49:37.095
<v Loretta Smith>I've only been on the job for maybe a couple of months, and so I have no idea what they're talking about.

1083
01:49:37.448 --> 01:49:45.766
<v Loretta Smith>So if you get those kinds of questions from Doris E. Smith or from Ms. Williams, come talk to me.

1084
01:49:46.087 --> 01:49:46.666
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Gotcha.

1085
01:49:46.987 --> 01:49:53.537
<v Loretta Smith>Because they will have an expectation that you know everything in this budget and everything about this city.

1086
01:49:54.277 --> 01:50:01.643
<v Loretta Smith>I am also amazed that, um, Councilor Clark and Councilor Zimmerman had both of my questions.

1087
01:50:02.703 --> 01:50:09.059
<v Loretta Smith>I had the same question that you had in regards to the city administrator's job.

1088
01:50:09.765 --> 01:50:14.050
<v Loretta Smith>You looked at, uh, section subsection K under the city administrator.

1089
01:50:14.179 --> 01:50:29.640
<v Loretta Smith>I also looked at subsection K and was going to ask that question too, but I'm also asking the question around subsection E. And what subsection E says is execute and enforce all laws adopted by council.

1090
01:50:29.903 --> 01:50:32.283
<v Loretta Smith>So I guess we kind of had both of the same 2 questions.

1091
01:50:33.380 --> 01:50:44.217
<v Loretta Smith>Section 2-406 in the charter under the city administrator, it says that the city administrator will execute and enforce all laws adopted by council.

1092
01:50:44.604 --> 01:50:44.895
<v Eugene Jackson>Yes.

1093
01:50:45.659 --> 01:50:50.252
<v Loretta Smith>And my colleague has already brought up the 9/12ths that I put forward in February.

1094
01:50:50.835 --> 01:51:04.265
<v Loretta Smith>And since you are responsible for the execution of all the laws and ordinances, my expectation is that transparency is truly something that you believe in.

1095
01:51:04.490 --> 01:51:04.733
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

1096
01:51:04.877 --> 01:51:22.347
<v Loretta Smith>And I think it's so important that when we do get dollars into this community and into this city, that we know about those dollars as well, because it's really important that we're able to not only know about them, we have to authorize them and then appropriate them.

1097
01:51:22.461 --> 01:51:22.734
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

1098
01:51:23.311 --> 01:51:29.927
<v Loretta Smith>I know that we kind of went— if you watched any of our committees yesterday, we took some things out of order.

1099
01:51:30.859 --> 01:51:40.494
<v Loretta Smith>We passed a committee bill for housing out of the Housing Committee, and we spoke of some dollars, but those dollars haven't been authorized.

1100
01:51:40.815 --> 01:51:40.929
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1101
01:51:40.993 --> 01:51:45.585
<v Loretta Smith>They have to be authorized before we can actually make that into an ordinance.

1102
01:51:45.649 --> 01:51:48.828
<v Loretta Smith>And I want to be clear and let folks know, I do know the process.

1103
01:51:49.823 --> 01:51:50.402
<v Loretta Smith>We did that.

1104
01:51:50.449 --> 01:51:54.256
<v Loretta Smith>It was already in spaces where it was ready to go.

1105
01:51:54.560 --> 01:52:04.500
<v Loretta Smith>But I just want to let you know, I understand that it has to be authorized before we can take those dollars and put into our budget and recognize as money that we have available.

1106
01:52:06.590 --> 01:52:17.814
<v Loretta Smith>This idea of you coming with us to town hall meetings and to, uh, go into our communities, I'm excited about that.

1107
01:52:17.992 --> 01:52:18.248
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

1108
01:52:19.037 --> 01:52:20.097
<v Loretta Smith>I think that is important.

1109
01:52:20.177 --> 01:52:23.601
<v Loretta Smith>It is upon us to help make you successful.

1110
01:52:23.761 --> 01:52:25.277
<v Loretta Smith>I agree with Councilor Dunphy.

1111
01:52:25.697 --> 01:52:32.965
<v Loretta Smith>It is upon us to make you the success that you need to be to be able to lead us into the future.

1112
01:52:33.060 --> 01:52:33.429
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

1113
01:52:34.118 --> 01:52:37.957
<v Loretta Smith>I am so shocked, just as, uh, uh, Councilor Zimmerman is.

1114
01:52:39.096 --> 01:52:54.029
<v Loretta Smith>I would've expected every single DCA, every single department head to be sitting in here watching these confirmation hearings, making sure that they give you support, because I think there is a culture that people just don't understand.

1115
01:52:54.141 --> 01:52:54.655
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

1116
01:52:55.168 --> 01:53:04.509
<v Loretta Smith>They don't understand what it takes to make sure that you are successful just as much as you said you want to make sure all your employees are successful.

1117
01:53:05.103 --> 01:53:06.819
<v Loretta Smith>That is a two-way street.

1118
01:53:07.060 --> 01:53:07.220
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1119
01:53:07.845 --> 01:53:14.215
<v Loretta Smith>Now, I talked to our human resources about some things that I was concerned about, about your severance package, and I won't go into detail here.

1120
01:53:14.824 --> 01:53:31.792
<v Loretta Smith>I should have called the mayor first and explained to him what I was thinking, but I want to make sure that your severance package is equal to what folks are getting below you, that you have the same access to a severance package that is equal.

1121
01:53:32.546 --> 01:53:38.813
<v Loretta Smith>And like I said, I won't go into the deep— I don't think we need to do an ordinance to get that right.

1122
01:53:38.974 --> 01:53:51.279
<v Loretta Smith>I just think that I need to make sure that when we're on a day that we're talking about human rights in employment, transportation, education, you don't have a labor union to represent you.

1123
01:53:51.328 --> 01:53:51.505
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1124
01:53:51.842 --> 01:53:52.484
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1125
01:53:52.886 --> 01:53:56.550
<v Loretta Smith>But I can guarantee you, if I see something, I'm going to say something.

1126
01:53:57.288 --> 01:54:01.722
<v Loretta Smith>And I said something yesterday, and I saw something, and I said it again today.

1127
01:54:02.350 --> 01:54:14.817
<v Loretta Smith>And I— my expectation is I am going to allow our DCAs to go back and review that with you and make those changes before I try to use the big stick and do an ordinance.

1128
01:54:15.042 --> 01:54:16.070
<v Loretta Smith>That's not necessary.

1129
01:54:17.307 --> 01:54:20.961
<v Loretta Smith>They just need to go back and change it and make it equal.

1130
01:54:21.154 --> 01:54:30.484
<v Loretta Smith>I want to make sure that you're being treated with the same dignity and respect and the same kind of benefits that other employees are getting here at the City of Portland.

1131
01:54:31.743 --> 01:54:39.354
<v Loretta Smith>My last issue is we have one more— I think we have one more council meeting after this.

1132
01:54:39.644 --> 01:54:39.886
<v Robert Pyle>Yes.

1133
01:54:40.014 --> 01:54:52.273
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know if you're going to be in town, but I really want to tell folks I have seen you out in the community since you landed here on November 19th, and you've been all over the place.

1134
01:54:52.770 --> 01:54:56.315
<v Loretta Smith>I saw you at the Oregon Business Plan on, on Monday.

1135
01:54:56.475 --> 01:55:08.894
<v Loretta Smith>I was invited to different places and spaces, to private meetings, to, uh, to meet with you, and I declined those because I said I need to make sure that we have a confirmation first before I have any kind of private meeting with you.

1136
01:55:09.230 --> 01:55:14.409
<v Loretta Smith>But I just want to tell you, from me to you, it has been great to see you out in the community.

1137
01:55:14.842 --> 01:55:22.539
<v Loretta Smith>It has been great to know I have been contacted by labor organizations that you specifically went and reached out to.

1138
01:55:23.085 --> 01:55:29.322
<v Loretta Smith>And I know for a fact that you don't have a lot of labor unions in, in your background in, in doing outreach.

1139
01:55:29.417 --> 01:55:43.943
<v Loretta Smith>You, you have police labor contracts, but we have many labor unions, and that will be 30 to 40% of your So it was really good to hear that you had already— because that was going to be my main question to you.

1140
01:55:44.264 --> 01:55:51.849
<v Loretta Smith>How do you come to a city that is— most of its employees have a collective bargaining agreement?

1141
01:55:52.378 --> 01:55:56.541
<v Loretta Smith>How do you give that direction when you have not had that experience?

1142
01:55:57.359 --> 01:56:16.176
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that because you've had the experience with the police bargaining, that that is going to be critical, but I appreciate you reaching out to those building trades and those folks who really make up this city's fabric of the labor community, that you did that on your own and we didn't do that.

1143
01:56:16.337 --> 01:56:17.862
<v Loretta Smith>So, uh, kudos to you.

1144
01:56:18.488 --> 01:56:34.774
<v Loretta Smith>I appreciate you willing to take on this big, huge challenge and make sure that, um, I can do whatever I can do to make your, uh, your stay here as enjoyable but I have to warn you, I will ask you a very direct question, and it'll be about money.

1145
01:56:35.432 --> 01:56:46.164
<v Loretta Smith>So, um, just know I want to say welcome to you and your family, and we have some churches that I can recommend that when your wife comes that you do that.

1146
01:56:46.341 --> 01:56:47.046
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you.

1147
01:56:47.271 --> 01:56:47.609
<v Ron Zito>Thank you.

1148
01:56:47.929 --> 01:56:51.555
<v Mitch Green>Point of clarification real quick, I, I think you refer to me as Councilor Zimmerman.

1149
01:56:51.603 --> 01:56:52.869
<v Mitch Green>That happens a lot in this city.

1150
01:56:53.384 --> 01:56:57.523
<v Mitch Green>We look the same, I understand that, but I just wanted to say We both said the same thing.

1151
01:56:57.893 --> 01:57:08.247
<v Loretta Smith>He was saying— no, when I said Councilor Zimmerman, I was saying, um, what I was saying was that Councilor Zimmerman had noted that there were no DCAs there.

1152
01:57:08.471 --> 01:57:09.724
<v Loretta Smith>All right, you got it.

1153
01:57:10.301 --> 01:57:21.636
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so, but you— we are on the same page too much, and I'm starting to, to, to— I need to make that distinction that you are a democratic socialist and I'm a social justice, um, capitalist.

1154
01:57:21.893 --> 01:57:29.068
<v Loretta Smith>So, but we're, we're intersecting, and I'm, I'm, I'm not feeling really good about I'm getting some togetherness vibes about that.

1155
01:57:29.229 --> 01:57:32.262
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm feeling really good about the intersection, for what it's worth.

1156
01:57:35.577 --> 01:57:59.291
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Councilor, you took a couple of the things I was going to say, but I, I do want to start, Mr. Lee, by just, uh, noting that while Councilor Zimmerman will show you all of the beautiful condos in the Pearl, there are some fantastic neighborhoods in North and Northeast Portland that are much much closer to the churches that Councilor Smith is going to take you to, and I am happy to show you some beautiful neighborhoods in District 2 as well.

1157
01:58:03.329 --> 01:58:18.775
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Lee, you've gotten a number of questions from my colleagues about communication, about the, the relationship between the administration and council, and I want to ask a question along a similar line but a little bit broader.

1158
01:58:18.948 --> 01:58:19.556
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mm-hmm.

1159
01:58:19.653 --> 01:58:26.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that is that we are still making our way into the norms of this new form of government.

1160
01:58:27.090 --> 01:58:34.445
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think there are still some questions about whether this is a strong mayor or a strong council or a strong city administrator form of government.

1161
01:58:35.264 --> 01:59:01.530
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm wondering if you can just describe to us a little bit what you see as the role of the city administrator and the administration vis-à-vis both the executive and the legislative branches of the city and how you see your job as you work in a city that really, in a sense, has 3 separate bodies helping to run our city, the legislative, executive, and administrative.

1162
01:59:02.685 --> 01:59:08.565
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I see the city administrator role as the person that runs the day-to-day operations of this organization.

1163
01:59:09.479 --> 01:59:22.685
<v Raymond C. Lee III>In doing that, that role also ensures that council is well informed regarding the decisions and policy decisions that they will be making that will have impact on the day-to-day operations of this organization.

1164
01:59:23.341 --> 01:59:34.948
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think there has to be a partnership there as it relates to how do we move things forward as a leadership, 'cause I do see us collectively as the leaders of this community.

1165
01:59:35.685 --> 01:59:48.975
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And it's gonna be essential as we move forward as leaders of this community that we have clear define of how we engage and how do we move things forward collectively as a unit.

1166
01:59:49.554 --> 02:00:07.755
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But when it comes to the day-to-day operations, I'm just taking the policy that this board has said they want to move forward with and engaging with you from the standpoint of what my recommendation and what staff's recommendation is on that, but making sure that is implemented and that it is working.

1167
02:00:07.868 --> 02:00:21.694
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And if it's not working, be able to come back to this body and tell them why and what's happening to cause whatever policy decision that's being made not to have the impact that it was planned to have as it relates to it.

1168
02:00:22.163 --> 02:00:39.623
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's one of the key things that I see my role, making sure that one, staff is following through and that I'm partnering with staff to move any roadblocks that they have to getting things done that as council has set forth out that they want to do, but also engaging with this elected body.

1169
02:00:40.127 --> 02:00:43.733
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But also on top of that, my job is a little tricky 'cause I'm engaging with the public as well.

1170
02:00:43.782 --> 02:00:43.895
<v Robert Pyle>Yes.

1171
02:00:44.152 --> 02:00:52.932
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And ensuring that I'm communicating with the public regarding what's happening and how it's happening, and if it's not, what's happening overall.

1172
02:00:53.510 --> 02:01:09.966
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Those are key roles of this position, and that partnership is huge with the mayor and ensuring the mayor, as the CEO of the organization, that we are working hand in hand and we're partnering to ensure that the priorities that he has set out as well.

1173
02:01:10.030 --> 02:01:10.207
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1174
02:01:10.671 --> 02:01:12.162
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That those are being accomplished.

1175
02:01:12.659 --> 02:01:19.105
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And those are key things of balancing act that has to happen for this to be successful.

1176
02:01:19.234 --> 02:01:23.996
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But for it to truly be successful, everyone has to understand what their role is.

1177
02:01:24.060 --> 02:01:38.137
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's part of when we go through this kind of priority setting, this is some of the framework setting that we're gonna have to do as well, that everybody's clear on what their role's in, how we engage with each other, and how do we move things forward, and how do we make decisions.

1178
02:01:38.363 --> 02:01:38.587
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1179
02:01:39.117 --> 02:01:43.837
<v Raymond C. Lee III>As leaders as it relates to direction for this city.

1180
02:01:44.496 --> 02:01:47.210
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, these are gonna be challenging times.

1181
02:01:47.643 --> 02:01:53.503
<v Raymond C. Lee III>A lot of cities have gone through this 50 and almost 100 years ago as it relates to it.

1182
02:01:53.824 --> 02:01:57.083
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But I see this as a pivotal time for this community.

1183
02:01:57.597 --> 02:02:03.265
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Very few government organizations and cities ever press the reset button.

1184
02:02:03.329 --> 02:02:03.555
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1185
02:02:05.222 --> 02:02:06.681
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This is a reset button time.

1186
02:02:07.547 --> 02:02:14.777
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We defined how do we move forward and how we govern, and that is going to be essential.

1187
02:02:14.841 --> 02:02:16.524
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Will there be growing pains in this?

1188
02:02:17.005 --> 02:02:17.373
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Yes.

1189
02:02:18.110 --> 02:02:19.890
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Will we have disagreements?

1190
02:02:20.211 --> 02:02:20.578
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Yes.

1191
02:02:21.797 --> 02:02:26.270
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But we should always have alignment for what's the greater good of this community.

1192
02:02:27.247 --> 02:02:31.015
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's the key thing that I want to focus on is what is that alignment?

1193
02:02:31.095 --> 02:02:31.414
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1194
02:02:31.993 --> 02:02:36.119
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That we have as leaders of this organization?

1195
02:02:36.729 --> 02:02:39.170
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And how do we plan on achieving that alignment?

1196
02:02:39.845 --> 02:02:44.131
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And my role will play a major component of that and ensure that it's happening.

1197
02:02:44.260 --> 02:02:56.817
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And if it's not happening, to call it out that it's not happening as an organization, but not just call it out and walk away, but call it out and say, hey, how do we get better ensuring that we have our alignment and purpose all together again?

1198
02:02:56.864 --> 02:02:57.024
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1199
02:02:59.246 --> 02:02:59.505
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1200
02:02:59.569 --> 02:03:00.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate that.

1201
02:03:01.088 --> 02:03:08.641
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was going to ask a question about trust and accountability with the public, but I think that some of my colleagues have touched on that in pretty meaningful ways with you.

1202
02:03:08.707 --> 02:03:15.337
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'd like to go back to a topic that Councilor Smith first raised, which is our labor partners.

1203
02:03:17.021 --> 02:03:20.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The City of Portland has a bargaining-heavy environment.

1204
02:03:20.305 --> 02:03:20.515
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mm-hmm.

1205
02:03:20.563 --> 02:03:25.037
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a labor union-heavy environment, but the way we work with our labor unions is also bargaining heavy.

1206
02:03:26.591 --> 02:03:30.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as you've noted, we're in a time of pretty significant organizational change.

1207
02:03:30.157 --> 02:03:45.467
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm wondering how you work with our represented employees and the, the unions that they have formed to help represent them as we move through what will continue to be, I think, a year of change over the next year.

1208
02:03:47.679 --> 02:03:49.493
<v Raymond C. Lee III>My goal is to communicate and be present.

1209
02:03:49.840 --> 02:04:15.595
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Listen, you know, as we go through negotiations, if the first time you hear or see from staff, and I know we have great staff that does our labor bargaining, collective bargaining work as an organization, and partnering with them and when I need to be in a room and having conversations, not at the bargaining time, but before bargaining even starts to ensure that we and I have a firm understanding of what are the asks.

1210
02:04:15.725 --> 02:04:15.823
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Yeah.

1211
02:04:16.567 --> 02:04:24.436
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And they have a firm understanding where we are as an organization and being very transparent and honest with our collective bargaining groups of where we are.

1212
02:04:24.533 --> 02:04:32.627
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'm very big on interest-based negotiations and making sure that everyone's best interest, that we're taking care of that.

1213
02:04:32.996 --> 02:04:34.166
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That is huge for me.

1214
02:04:34.774 --> 02:04:39.070
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But it all starts on building that relationship from the very beginning.

1215
02:04:39.984 --> 02:04:49.095
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And as Councilwoman Smith spoke about earlier, that was part of the reason why I wanted to meet with some of our labor groups because these are our everyday employees.

1216
02:04:49.207 --> 02:04:53.685
<v Raymond C. Lee III>These are the people that ensuring when people flush the toilet that it actually goes somewhere.

1217
02:04:53.942 --> 02:04:58.773
<v Raymond C. Lee III>These are the individuals that are ensuring that the lights are on and the equipment is working in this room.

1218
02:04:59.302 --> 02:05:03.539
<v Raymond C. Lee III>These are the individuals that are filling the potholes in our community.

1219
02:05:04.373 --> 02:05:15.604
<v Raymond C. Lee III>These are the individuals that are ensuring that I can do the things that I can do and be successful as at doing it because they're carrying through the day-to-day work, ensuring that this city is functional.

1220
02:05:16.485 --> 02:05:17.704
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And it's a thankless job.

1221
02:05:18.635 --> 02:05:29.524
<v Raymond C. Lee III>They don't get the kudos and the thank-yous all the time, but they are the ones that ensuring that this is a safe, secure, purposeful community.

1222
02:05:30.118 --> 02:05:35.890
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I want to make sure that I'm touching base with them and they understand that from the beginning, that I see their value.

1223
02:05:35.970 --> 02:05:36.067
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1224
02:05:37.779 --> 02:05:44.043
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I support them, but also we have to do what's in the best interest of this city.

1225
02:05:45.027 --> 02:05:48.311
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And as staff, we're negotiating on behalf of this body.

1226
02:05:49.454 --> 02:05:55.154
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And as this body, I have to have conversations with as well regarding what are those parameters.

1227
02:05:55.429 --> 02:06:02.600
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And you're going to need information from me and from our staff regarding what our structure is and our framework is to make some of these decisions.

1228
02:06:02.648 --> 02:06:02.761
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1229
02:06:03.713 --> 02:06:12.432
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But if we're going into a room with not having co-created those relationships, we're already starting behind the 8-ball in those conversations.

1230
02:06:12.786 --> 02:06:27.172
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I wanna make sure that we're well advanced in our relationships, our communication, how we're going to engage to ensure that it's a purposeful and intentional way of collectively bargaining with our employees.

1231
02:06:27.237 --> 02:06:27.333
<v Derek Olson>Thank you.

1232
02:06:29.068 --> 02:06:29.421
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1233
02:06:29.550 --> 02:06:30.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate that.

1234
02:06:30.675 --> 02:06:51.798
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll note that I have also seen you around in many spaces and heard from folks who have been meeting with you this week, and I do appreciate both your, your clear statement on the record that your intention is to live in our fine city and the fact that you came out early before this meeting today to get to know people here and didn't just fly in for the confirmation hearing itself.

1235
02:06:52.152 --> 02:06:55.814
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's showing a commitment to the community that you are coming to serve, and I appreciate that.

1236
02:06:55.863 --> 02:06:55.975
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1237
02:06:56.311 --> 02:06:56.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1238
02:06:57.902 --> 02:06:58.609
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1239
02:06:59.266 --> 02:07:00.086
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1240
02:07:00.728 --> 02:07:07.841
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, first to Mr. Mayor, thank you for your inclusion of councilors in this process, for bringing us a candidate on the timeline very similar to what we discussed back in February.

1241
02:07:08.177 --> 02:07:09.511
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, remember that meeting very well.

1242
02:07:10.201 --> 02:07:16.094
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm in no way disappointed in how this has gone and the candidate, and I'm looking forward to asking some questions and doing due diligence.

1243
02:07:16.141 --> 02:07:21.296
<v Sameer Kanal>But I wanted to start by thanking you both for the strength of the finalist pool and for the, the nomination.

1244
02:07:22.002 --> 02:07:23.462
<v Sameer Kanal>I did want to mention a process note.

1245
02:07:23.511 --> 02:07:34.520
<v Sameer Kanal>I am disappointed that after the February 5th meeting where Mr. Jordan's extension got dozens of people weighing in on a 6-month extension in public testimony, that there are only 2 written testimonies and no oral testimony today.

1246
02:07:35.146 --> 02:07:50.765
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I wanted to take this opportunity to ask you and Mr. Lee, if appointed, to look strongly at the Office of Community Engagement and improving on its performance from 2025, because— and also its structure, because council clearly needs to be more involved in the management of community engagement to ensure that success.

1247
02:07:51.939 --> 02:07:54.541
<v Sameer Kanal>Mr. Lee, I really appreciate your commitment to being out in community.

1248
02:07:54.604 --> 02:07:58.252
<v Sameer Kanal>I can tell you from my personal experience, this building will hold you here if you let it.

1249
02:07:58.829 --> 02:08:01.110
<v Sameer Kanal>And that intentionality is super important.

1250
02:08:01.255 --> 02:08:03.777
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think I'll be the first to invite you to join me at a town hall.

1251
02:08:04.226 --> 02:08:06.314
<v Sameer Kanal>I do them monthly, and you'll come to District 2.

1252
02:08:06.460 --> 02:08:08.676
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with Council President, we obviously share a district there.

1253
02:08:09.350 --> 02:08:10.988
<v Sameer Kanal>I also appreciate the breadth of your experience.

1254
02:08:11.118 --> 02:08:11.969
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll add one quick note.

1255
02:08:12.016 --> 02:08:13.929
<v Sameer Kanal>If you think Dallas is Buckle up.

1256
02:08:15.164 --> 02:08:19.100
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, I won't be asking much about this here.

1257
02:08:19.404 --> 02:08:33.136
<v Sameer Kanal>I did in, in the interviews ask about getting council information both in general from the administration, uh, including without retaliation to rank-and-file employees all the way up to bureau directors and DCAs, but also ensuring that, uh, information goes to all 12 councilors, not just one.

1258
02:08:33.216 --> 02:08:34.421
<v Sameer Kanal>And I appreciated that answer.

1259
02:08:34.759 --> 02:08:47.854
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope we can get to a place where we have like an intranet page where those medium and high, uh, profile councilor requests and and responses are aggregated so that we're not delaying the overall process to ensure everybody gets something or forcing you to read an individual email for each thing.

1260
02:08:48.710 --> 02:08:51.064
<v Sameer Kanal>Finally, I appreciate your response on collective bargaining.

1261
02:08:51.112 --> 02:08:54.220
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we've seen some of the problems you just identified very recently here.

1262
02:08:54.268 --> 02:08:59.212
<v Sameer Kanal>So to my questions, and I have a bunch, I'll do 2 now.

1263
02:09:01.279 --> 02:09:06.953
<v Sameer Kanal>You would be in a unique role in this system in that you report day to day to the mayor but also have a responsibility to council.

1264
02:09:07.403 --> 02:09:19.430
<v Sameer Kanal>The degree to which I agree or disagree with Councilor Zimmerman's point about, you know, providing an administration position is the degree to which hearing that position is different in reality and perception from the mayor's position.

1265
02:09:19.863 --> 02:09:21.805
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't mean disagreeing with the mayor.

1266
02:09:21.854 --> 02:09:29.064
<v Sameer Kanal>What I mean is what the council president was referring to as a distinction of branch of government between the executive and the administration.

1267
02:09:29.512 --> 02:09:30.668
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't think that's happened this year.

1268
02:09:31.037 --> 02:09:31.342
<v Sameer Kanal>Mm-hmm.

1269
02:09:31.807 --> 02:09:33.427
<v Sameer Kanal>At all personally, but I would like it to.

1270
02:09:33.988 --> 02:09:46.240
<v Sameer Kanal>And specifically, we recently had a situation where the city administrator sent memos to the whole council on the eve of Councilor Morillo and Green's proposal for a detention facility impact fee at council that, that was fairly oppositional to it.

1271
02:09:46.721 --> 02:09:48.180
<v Sameer Kanal>This was off-putting to me.

1272
02:09:48.261 --> 02:09:52.301
<v Sameer Kanal>It made me wonder if I should expect late-game memos from the administrator's office as well.

1273
02:09:52.912 --> 02:09:56.583
<v Sameer Kanal>So my question is, how do you see your relationship and responsibility to this body?

1274
02:09:56.824 --> 02:10:04.823
<v Sameer Kanal>What do you think what do you think the role of the city administrator's opinion is, both in terms of expressing opinions and the timeliness of those opinions relative to decisions?

1275
02:10:05.240 --> 02:10:15.307
<v Sameer Kanal>What do you see as the limits to that, to what the city administrator should be providing impact or input about in terms of impact, implementation, operational implications, things like that?

1276
02:10:15.581 --> 02:10:29.378
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Yeah, I see the city administrator role as a service role in ensuring that I'm serving Not only our mayor, but our elected body as well, as it relates to the decisions that have to be made.

1277
02:10:29.796 --> 02:10:36.551
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, before a lot of things come to City Council, you know, there will have to be dialogue.

1278
02:10:36.904 --> 02:10:46.217
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Now, there's instances, and I know the way that the structure is set up for things to go through committee and for things to go to that committee and be recommended to go to the full body for decision-making.

1279
02:10:47.676 --> 02:11:08.882
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And what I would love to be able to see in this is from an administration standpoint, As it relates to what the city's recommendation may be, is for that to be starting at the committee level and bringing that to the committee level as it relates to what our recommendation is, our professional expertise is on that matter and our professional recommendation.

1280
02:11:09.395 --> 02:11:19.377
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I think that is essential in helping shaping and informing, at least at the committee level, what the staff's recommendation is overall.

1281
02:11:19.954 --> 02:11:31.023
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And and that's before it ever gets to the full body as it relates to briefing the full body, either in a work session or an agenda item during the actual briefing of that matter to the full body.

1282
02:11:32.319 --> 02:11:37.578
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But this is also why I say, you know, we have controversial items that will be coming forth this body.

1283
02:11:39.119 --> 02:11:48.479
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And having the ability to have these meetings with individual council members, for me, is essential to be able to sit down and be able to have this conversation and hear from you.

1284
02:11:48.979 --> 02:11:53.546
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What are those pinch points for you as it relates to making a decision on this?

1285
02:11:54.126 --> 02:11:57.448
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And there will be times where there will be disagreements on that.

1286
02:11:57.917 --> 02:12:02.108
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's the beautiful thing of democracy in this.

1287
02:12:02.529 --> 02:12:14.842
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But I wanna make sure that I'm giving you all the accurate information and all the expertise that I have through my network and through my own knowledge base and through our staff.

1288
02:12:15.765 --> 02:12:22.351
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That is helping you make the best informed decision that you can make that will have an impact on this community.

1289
02:12:22.885 --> 02:12:27.137
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So from a time perspective, I like to start early as we have the information.

1290
02:12:27.720 --> 02:12:38.199
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And if it's something that we don't have yet an opinion on, to see, is it something that we can delay making that recommendation?

1291
02:12:38.247 --> 02:12:40.823
<v Raymond C. Lee III>'Cause I don't want to give you information.

1292
02:12:40.904 --> 02:12:40.984
<v Angelita Morillo>Right.

1293
02:12:41.728 --> 02:12:45.181
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That is not 100% accurate.

1294
02:12:45.984 --> 02:12:51.078
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's the challenge I'm gonna be, and I'm a commitment to excellence from me.

1295
02:12:51.141 --> 02:12:56.331
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So I'm a stickler on always improving and how we can get better at doing something.

1296
02:12:56.765 --> 02:12:58.902
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And we'll have those conversations internally.

1297
02:12:59.336 --> 02:13:01.423
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I know the mayor will have those conversations as well.

1298
02:13:01.503 --> 02:13:03.978
<v Raymond C. Lee III>How do we get better at doing that?

1299
02:13:04.716 --> 02:13:09.344
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But I wanna make sure everything that comes outta our office is accurate.

1300
02:13:09.921 --> 02:13:24.507
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And if it is, and that's hard to say it won't ever happen, but if it does happen, that we're responsive in the manner that we respond to you to get you the information that you need and tell you why the original information was not accurate.

1301
02:13:25.422 --> 02:13:33.359
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I don't want to be in a situation where we're backpedaling on matters that we didn't need to have to backpedal on.

1302
02:13:33.712 --> 02:13:35.815
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We just need to do our due diligence to get you the information.

1303
02:13:35.864 --> 02:13:36.009
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1304
02:13:37.246 --> 02:13:37.984
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1305
02:13:38.048 --> 02:13:40.618
<v Sameer Kanal>I think in the interview I asked you a similar question.

1306
02:13:40.682 --> 02:13:43.204
<v Sameer Kanal>You said no surprises, and I appreciate that.

1307
02:13:43.252 --> 02:13:45.726
<v Sameer Kanal>I think in this context, it's no surprises and no ambushes.

1308
02:13:45.920 --> 02:13:47.204
<v Sameer Kanal>Those are the things that are—.

1309
02:13:47.204 --> 02:13:47.686
<v Raymond C. Lee III>100%.

1310
02:13:48.185 --> 02:13:49.952
<v Sameer Kanal>From at least me and my expectation.

1311
02:13:50.015 --> 02:13:53.983
<v Sameer Kanal>My second question, this last year was a difficult budget year.

1312
02:13:54.658 --> 02:13:56.070
<v Sameer Kanal>We know we'll have another difficult one ahead.

1313
02:13:56.377 --> 02:14:01.628
<v Sameer Kanal>On numerous occasions, this council has asked the administration to look at management bloat and outside contractors.

1314
02:14:01.720 --> 02:14:06.382
<v Sameer Kanal>Before cutting frontline staff, including our represented staff who deliver direct services.

1315
02:14:06.898 --> 02:14:18.136
<v Sameer Kanal>And one of the primary reasons we chose to move to a form of government that has a city administrator is because we desperately needed professionals who are willing to make difficult decisions for the good of city structure and the city at large.

1316
02:14:18.649 --> 02:14:23.734
<v Sameer Kanal>And so do you broadly feel empowered to make tough decisions that would require those big changes?

1317
02:14:24.170 --> 02:14:27.703
<v Sameer Kanal>And more specifically, what are your views on management bloat, span of control, and the need to streamline city government?

1318
02:14:28.926 --> 02:14:38.127
<v Sameer Kanal>The way we structure our city at those high levels, what are your guiding principles that you would look at in terms of where, if there need to be staff reductions, you would look to make those?

1319
02:14:38.480 --> 02:14:38.704
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

1320
02:14:39.185 --> 02:14:44.042
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Yeah, when I look at kind of the administrator's responsibility, yes.

1321
02:14:44.971 --> 02:14:45.949
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Short answer, yes.

1322
02:14:46.399 --> 02:14:49.507
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I do feel empowered to be able to make those decisions.

1323
02:14:50.662 --> 02:14:59.403
<v Raymond C. Lee III>When we look at it, and council will play a major role in this, I'm a huge component, and I've said I think we discussed this through the interview process as well, of priority-based budgeting.

1324
02:15:00.189 --> 02:15:12.658
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'm not a— I'm a huge fan of strategically addressing and ensuring that we're funding the things that we say are important to us as an organization and letting the numbers back that.

1325
02:15:13.188 --> 02:15:16.444
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Not funding something that is underperforming is essential.

1326
02:15:16.814 --> 02:15:21.949
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That's why the performance matrix, the key performance indicators, outcomes are truly important.

1327
02:15:22.061 --> 02:15:22.479
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1328
02:15:23.313 --> 02:15:33.465
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We first have to understand what the true price of government is for us and what is it costing us to provide the services that we're providing day in and day out as an organization.

1329
02:15:34.779 --> 02:15:36.929
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Those are the key things that we're going to be looking at.

1330
02:15:37.649 --> 02:15:39.527
<v Raymond C. Lee III>One, how's the organization performing?

1331
02:15:39.591 --> 02:15:41.097
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What's the true price of that?

1332
02:15:41.498 --> 02:15:46.614
<v Raymond C. Lee III>What are the priorities of the City Council and the mayor, and how are we moving those things forward?

1333
02:15:47.047 --> 02:15:48.219
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And then we're going to have dialogue about that.

1334
02:15:48.283 --> 02:15:48.475
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1335
02:15:49.153 --> 02:16:01.384
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It's going to cause for us to sit in your room, potentially maybe for a budget retreat, to actually sit down and talk about what those priorities truly are and how we're moving the organization forward.

1336
02:16:02.413 --> 02:16:09.609
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Without that, it's hard to make strategic decisions regarding what is funded and what is not funded.

1337
02:16:11.525 --> 02:16:15.470
<v Raymond C. Lee III>We need that direction and we need that assistance, and the mayor will be providing a lot of that.

1338
02:16:15.649 --> 02:16:22.667
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I know he will have a tremendous amount of contact back as well with council as well regarding the priorities that he has as well.

1339
02:16:23.631 --> 02:16:36.363
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But sitting down and being able to get through that and digest that, staff can strategically go back and make some crucial decisions and be able to talk through council why certain decisions were being made.

1340
02:16:37.841 --> 02:16:54.335
<v Raymond C. Lee III>The mayor will, you know, and I will assist the mayor in producing a balanced budget that comes to this body, that this team feels it can truly execute on to achieve the vision that the leaders of this organization have and feel that can be done.

1341
02:16:55.570 --> 02:16:57.559
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But this is not something that we do in a vacuum.

1342
02:16:57.977 --> 02:16:59.966
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This is not something that we can do overnight.

1343
02:17:00.382 --> 02:17:07.808
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Budget is year-round from the standpoint of how we're evaluating and making decisions regarding how we move forward.

1344
02:17:08.467 --> 02:17:23.433
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And we'll be looking at how do we bring those kind of concepts of how we look at municipal budgeting moving forward and what are the ramifications for some of the decisions we're making today and what are those long-term impacts that are gonna have on us financially.

1345
02:17:24.091 --> 02:17:45.009
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I'm a strong believer in having that type of information, trend analysis information to understand how programs have been performing overall and how we have been expending overall to make key informed decisions regarding how do we move budget, which is one of the largest policy documents that we will have as an organization forward.

1346
02:17:46.754 --> 02:17:55.970
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, and I do hope you'll consider keeping and iterating on the City Administrator Jordan's budget recommendations that came out on February 28th of last year.

1347
02:17:56.036 --> 02:17:57.522
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it was a great document.

1348
02:17:57.895 --> 02:18:07.894
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to, before I pass, just to follow up on the part about management bloat, because I think the cuts were disproportionately targeted at rank-and-file staff this year.

1349
02:18:09.132 --> 02:18:10.367
<v Sameer Kanal>When staff reductions happen.

1350
02:18:10.415 --> 02:18:12.146
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wondered if you could speak to that a little bit.

1351
02:18:13.203 --> 02:18:17.032
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I would have to further evaluate it and see why those decisions were being made.

1352
02:18:17.322 --> 02:18:28.490
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It's hard for me to make a call on it right now to not understand the full background as it relates to why certain decisions were made as it relates to the previous— this current budget year that we're in.

1353
02:18:29.067 --> 02:18:40.577
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But most definitely, once I get the opportunity to review those things, I can have a more informed informed and engaged conversation with you as it relates to why certain decisions were made and, and go from there.

1354
02:18:41.092 --> 02:18:44.539
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But give me some time to actually take a look at it and evaluate it.

1355
02:18:45.486 --> 02:18:45.677
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1356
02:18:45.983 --> 02:18:46.799
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1357
02:18:47.200 --> 02:18:47.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1358
02:18:48.789 --> 02:18:53.471
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we had scheduled 2 hours for this agenda item, which would have put us at 11:48.

1359
02:18:53.520 --> 02:18:58.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 11:47, and I'd like to make sure that Mr. Lee has time for some closing remarks.

1360
02:18:58.650 --> 02:19:18.414
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see that there are folks in the I'm wondering if any of the questions you are hoping to ask will change your mind about the vote today, or if we can move forward and get additional questions to Mr. Lee via email, which also does create a public record that can be easily shared if it's something that you were hoping to get out to the public.

1361
02:19:20.935 --> 02:19:24.343
<v Mitch Green>I mean, my vote still depends upon a question that I want to ask.

1362
02:19:24.666 --> 02:19:28.915
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, let's get one more question in then for anybody who needs to.

1363
02:19:29.569 --> 02:19:32.489
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. Lee, for this long conversation.

1364
02:19:33.329 --> 02:19:45.010
<v Mitch Green>We talked earlier about sort of in response to questions about staff and communication, and you had offered to set up a framework, which I think that's a really good way to think about things.

1365
02:19:45.670 --> 02:20:09.825
<v Mitch Green>In the context of that framework, what are you going to need from City Council to be supported in making sure that staff, and particularly rank-and-file staff, and even non-represented, you know, supervisory staff do not have fear of retaliation for communicating with a city councilor or any other elected official because they think that that communication might then set themselves up for retribution.

1366
02:20:09.873 --> 02:20:10.600
<v Mitch Green>Does that make sense?

1367
02:20:11.236 --> 02:20:11.833
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It makes sense.

1368
02:20:11.960 --> 02:20:20.691
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And we have personnel rules that guide us in those type of things as it relates to anybody feeling like they're being retaliated against.

1369
02:20:21.305 --> 02:20:23.209
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I have an open-door policy as well.

1370
02:20:23.579 --> 02:20:34.288
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, if staff feels that way, that something has, You know, had a negative impact on them for information that they shared, that they have that conversation with me.

1371
02:20:34.817 --> 02:20:43.245
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But there is chain of command in all of this as it relates to how we share information and how we get things out to the public.

1372
02:20:43.711 --> 02:20:52.493
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, the key thing for me is, one, that we're honest, that we're transparent regarding the information, but we understand the why behind it.

1373
02:20:52.941 --> 02:20:53.938
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And sometimes Yes.

1374
02:20:54.018 --> 02:20:58.269
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And sometimes those things have— you have a different set of lens that you're looking through.

1375
02:20:58.879 --> 02:21:01.270
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I'm putting myself in your shoes.

1376
02:21:01.686 --> 02:21:09.034
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And, you know, if you're receiving information and you don't understand the why behind it, it's hard for you to be able to do anything with it.

1377
02:21:09.484 --> 02:21:13.816
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And sometimes you can get information from staff without explaining the why.

1378
02:21:14.120 --> 02:21:19.254
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Just, you asked that question, I'm gonna answer it without giving you context of why.

1379
02:21:19.816 --> 02:21:21.825
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This is happening or why it didn't happen.

1380
02:21:22.243 --> 02:21:38.521
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And that's the one thing that I'll be stressing to our team as we release information to council, that we give them the context behind it and not just give you raw data and leave you to figure it out one way or another.

1381
02:21:38.793 --> 02:21:40.208
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But it has to be communication.

1382
02:21:40.641 --> 02:21:50.549
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I don't expect any employee, and it's not the culture that I want to have, as a leader of the organization that there's retaliation against employees.

1383
02:21:50.549 --> 02:21:54.170
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But I want to make sure that you have the full context of what happened.

1384
02:21:54.170 --> 02:22:02.530
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And if there was any type of thing that's a personnel matter, that let us have that conversation one-on-one to kind of talk through what that is.

1385
02:22:03.610 --> 02:22:05.770
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1386
02:22:06.059 --> 02:22:07.129
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1387
02:22:07.129 --> 02:22:09.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark, did you have a question that you needed to ask before we vote?

1388
02:22:10.030 --> 02:22:10.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1389
02:22:10.450 --> 02:22:11.149
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1390
02:22:12.468 --> 02:22:14.567
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1391
02:22:14.792 --> 02:22:18.719
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, there are some staff in the city that don't report to the city administrator.

1392
02:22:19.200 --> 02:22:26.047
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, council staff, mayor's office staff, but there are 3 in the administration, um, I believe as well that under the charter don't.

1393
02:22:26.094 --> 02:22:33.372
<v Sameer Kanal>So we're talking the police chief, the city attorney, and then also the FPDR, Fire Police Disability Retirement Fund administrator, has a council appointment process.

1394
02:22:33.421 --> 02:22:41.230
<v Sameer Kanal>I think they might be in the org chart anyway with a direct line, but But all 3 of these in some way, 2 very directly relate to public safety.

1395
02:22:41.888 --> 02:22:54.947
<v Sameer Kanal>And you mentioned public safety before, and I wanted to talk about how your— what your approach will be to ensuring that the city moves in a council-set direction, including with those staff that you don't directly manage in the public safety space.

1396
02:22:55.363 --> 02:22:59.245
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Yeah, it's collaboration and communication that we're on the same page.

1397
02:22:59.309 --> 02:23:09.254
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I've been in that situation where my previous role where there were Council only had 3 employees, myself, the city attorney, and the municipal judge.

1398
02:23:10.441 --> 02:23:20.208
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And the biggest thing with that is having constant communication with my colleague, 'cause that is my colleague, and ensuring that we're on the same page of how we're moving forward.

1399
02:23:20.640 --> 02:23:28.963
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Because I don't ever want either one of us to be in a situation where we're providing information that the other person doesn't or not aware of.

1400
02:23:29.012 --> 02:23:29.349
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Smith.

1401
02:23:30.086 --> 02:23:35.636
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And then they're getting questioned on that information by someone on council or the mayor as well.

1402
02:23:36.021 --> 02:23:53.968
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So ensuring that we're having regular set meetings as well, so I have a full understanding of where they're being charged with, the direction that council or the mayor is giving them as well, and that I can help them achieve the things that they have on their plate as leaders in this organization.

1403
02:23:54.400 --> 02:23:55.636
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This is a team environment.

1404
02:23:55.683 --> 02:23:58.635
<v Raymond C. Lee III>This is a, a one Portland organization.

1405
02:23:59.115 --> 02:24:05.269
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And we all have or need to have the same alignment in that to ensure that we're achieving the things that we have.

1406
02:24:05.781 --> 02:24:24.547
<v Raymond C. Lee III>But it first starts with that collaboration, that communication and relationship building with each other, and then being engaged in my meetings as well as we talk about different rollouts of different initiatives, policy decisions, or administrative actions that may be taking place within the organization.

1407
02:24:24.594 --> 02:24:24.691
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1408
02:24:25.252 --> 02:24:34.273
<v Raymond C. Lee III>That they're fully aware of that and the impacts of that, because they will have probably some input as well of what that may mean for their respective areas.

1409
02:24:34.627 --> 02:24:40.202
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And not do it after the fact, but engaging with them beforehand so they can have that input.

1410
02:24:40.251 --> 02:24:44.897
<v Raymond C. Lee III>So anything that we're moving forward, we're moving forward as a collective body and leadership team.

1411
02:24:45.586 --> 02:24:45.780
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1412
02:24:45.987 --> 02:24:46.485
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1413
02:24:47.590 --> 02:24:48.246
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1414
02:24:48.391 --> 02:24:50.058
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you everybody for the flexibility.

1415
02:24:50.235 --> 02:24:50.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Mr.

1416
02:24:51.451 --> 02:24:55.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I assume that you will be getting some additional questions via email from some of my colleagues.

1417
02:24:56.806 --> 02:25:01.101
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to give you just a few minutes for closing remarks before we move to a vote.

1418
02:25:01.613 --> 02:25:03.888
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Okay, well, I just wanna say thank you.

1419
02:25:05.236 --> 02:25:06.277
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you for the support.

1420
02:25:06.918 --> 02:25:08.120
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you for the confidence.

1421
02:25:08.441 --> 02:25:18.569
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you for your time in engaging with me, not only today, but as you have, different council members have seen me out in the community, have come up and spoken to me.

1422
02:25:19.659 --> 02:25:20.524
<v Raymond C. Lee III>It means a lot.

1423
02:25:20.781 --> 02:25:23.399
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You know, I know this is not a light decision.

1424
02:25:24.332 --> 02:25:31.752
<v Raymond C. Lee III>There's a lot that goes behind the decision that this body has to make as it relates to the future of this organization.

1425
02:25:32.490 --> 02:25:36.168
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I just want to let you know you have a partner in this.

1426
02:25:36.843 --> 02:25:38.481
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You're not doing this by yourselves.

1427
02:25:38.530 --> 02:25:46.127
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You're not out there by yourselves as it relates to the governance of this organization and of this community and as leaders of this great city.

1428
02:25:46.191 --> 02:25:46.496
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1429
02:25:47.683 --> 02:25:56.334
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You have a partner in me that's willing to collaborate with you, that's willing to help shape how we move things forward collectively as one unit.

1430
02:25:57.521 --> 02:25:58.691
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I'll, I'll say this again.

1431
02:25:58.738 --> 02:26:11.236
<v Raymond C. Lee III>I know we're not going to always agree, and I know everybody on the dais is not going to always agree, but as long as we have the best interests of this community, I think everything else we can figure out.

1432
02:26:11.877 --> 02:26:14.568
<v Raymond C. Lee III>And I believe this is a great community with a ton of potential.

1433
02:26:14.632 --> 02:26:14.808
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

1434
02:26:15.757 --> 02:26:28.606
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Has all the right ingredients, and everybody's watching to see how this thing plays out for Portland, because it's going to tell a story about how governance can truly be done and can it be done differently.

1435
02:26:30.302 --> 02:26:31.513
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You have my full commitment.

1436
02:26:32.402 --> 02:26:48.865
<v Raymond C. Lee III>You have my full faith in this group that we can move this thing forward, and I thank you for your time, your energy, your effort, to continuing the work of this great city, and I look forward to partnering with you and working with you for the years to come.

1437
02:26:49.190 --> 02:26:49.416
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1438
02:26:51.531 --> 02:26:52.409
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1439
02:26:52.506 --> 02:26:55.288
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, any further discussion before we move to a vote?

1440
02:26:57.427 --> 02:26:57.782
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Keelan.

1441
02:26:58.138 --> 02:26:59.155
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, Councilor Kanal.

1442
02:27:00.058 --> 02:27:13.375
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I just wanted to— I think I had a sort of unique role, uh, in a previous vote in February as, as the one person who voted no on that extension, which had nothing to do with, uh, with, uh, the Administrator Jordan, but was a structural thing.

1443
02:27:13.792 --> 02:27:18.560
<v Sameer Kanal>I think those issues have been resolved to my satisfaction as well, and I think it's important to acknowledge that.

1444
02:27:18.656 --> 02:27:21.701
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to say thank you for that, and you'll see my vote in a moment.

1445
02:27:22.087 --> 02:27:22.781
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1446
02:27:23.474 --> 02:27:24.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

1447
02:27:25.968 --> 02:27:26.387
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1448
02:27:27.239 --> 02:27:27.288
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1449
02:27:27.979 --> 02:27:28.269
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1450
02:27:29.185 --> 02:27:29.878
<v Mitch Green>Welcome to Portland.

1451
02:27:30.216 --> 02:27:30.377
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1452
02:27:30.810 --> 02:27:31.245
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1453
02:27:31.583 --> 02:27:31.727
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

1454
02:27:32.906 --> 02:27:32.922
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1455
02:27:35.219 --> 02:27:35.268
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1456
02:27:37.228 --> 02:27:37.277
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1457
02:27:38.835 --> 02:27:39.060
<v Sameer Kanal>Welcome.

1458
02:27:39.398 --> 02:27:39.558
<v Joseph Perez>Aye.

1459
02:27:40.909 --> 02:27:40.925
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1460
02:27:41.759 --> 02:27:43.211
<v Keelan McClymont>Coyama Lane, absent.

1461
02:27:44.518 --> 02:27:45.317
<v Angelita Morillo>Welcome to Portland.

1462
02:27:45.497 --> 02:27:45.547
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Aye.

1463
02:27:46.886 --> 02:27:47.861
<v Steve Novick>Rock Chalk Jayhawk.

1464
02:27:48.185 --> 02:27:48.218
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1465
02:27:53.209 --> 02:27:55.664
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Turtle Guinea.

1466
02:27:56.293 --> 02:27:57.327
<v Keelan McClymont>Resolution is adopted.

1467
02:28:01.106 --> 02:28:04.084
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, thank you for bringing us forward a nominee.

1468
02:28:04.180 --> 02:28:05.950
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Mr. Lee, welcome to Portland.

1469
02:28:06.031 --> 02:28:07.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We look forward to working with you.

1470
02:28:15.893 --> 02:28:16.542
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just the one time.

1471
02:28:16.656 --> 02:28:17.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just the one time.

1472
02:28:18.329 --> 02:28:20.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate the acknowledgment, Councilor.

1473
02:28:23.500 --> 02:28:24.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, it is just about noon.

1474
02:28:24.932 --> 02:28:25.728
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would like to take a recess.

1475
02:28:25.886 --> 02:28:32.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to get us through one or two more things and then we will take a lunch break and we'll need to come back to finish the rest of the agenda.

1476
02:28:33.870 --> 02:28:36.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, I believe the next item on the agenda is the consent agenda.

1477
02:28:37.045 --> 02:28:37.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1478
02:28:37.871 --> 02:28:38.308
<v Keelan McClymont>That's correct.

1479
02:28:38.908 --> 02:28:42.066
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, let's move to a vote.

1480
02:28:43.290 --> 02:28:43.548
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1481
02:28:44.643 --> 02:28:44.691
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1482
02:28:45.367 --> 02:28:45.592
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1483
02:28:46.735 --> 02:28:46.816
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1484
02:28:47.411 --> 02:28:47.845
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1485
02:28:48.120 --> 02:28:48.200
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1486
02:28:48.683 --> 02:28:49.213
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1487
02:28:49.712 --> 02:28:49.762
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1488
02:28:50.679 --> 02:28:51.066
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1489
02:28:51.404 --> 02:28:51.565
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1490
02:28:53.290 --> 02:28:53.322
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1491
02:28:53.986 --> 02:28:54.165
<v Unidentified speaker>Noll.

1492
02:28:55.006 --> 02:28:56.691
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, voters of Multnomah County Elections.

1493
02:28:56.870 --> 02:28:56.918
<v Eugene Jackson>Aye.

1494
02:28:58.328 --> 02:28:58.361
<v Clare Adamsick>Aye.

1495
02:28:58.977 --> 02:28:59.025
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1496
02:29:02.387 --> 02:29:02.467
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1497
02:29:02.852 --> 02:29:02.900
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Aye.

1498
02:29:04.315 --> 02:29:11.154
<v Keelan McClymont>The consent agenda is approved with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.

1499
02:29:11.967 --> 02:29:15.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we are going to see what we can do on this next agenda item.

1500
02:29:15.459 --> 02:29:16.938
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're moving to the regular agenda.

1501
02:29:17.003 --> 02:29:18.123
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call agenda?

1502
02:29:18.340 --> 02:29:27.611
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 7, authorize Director of the Bureau of Human Resources to offer an employment agreement to the City Administrator.

1503
02:29:28.542 --> 02:29:29.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

1504
02:29:29.282 --> 02:29:39.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we just extended an appointment to a new City Administrator, and we need to approve an offer to this City Administrator.

1505
02:29:40.514 --> 02:29:46.922
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This has not been through a committee, so we're moving to a staff presentation instead of a regular thank you, Councilor Smith.

1506
02:29:47.003 --> 02:29:47.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll now move into our committee overview.

1507
02:29:47.676 --> 02:29:57.888
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have Ron Zito, our interim director of the Bureau of Human Resources, here to go over what this agreement looks like, and then we will move into some discussion and public testimony.

1508
02:29:58.594 --> 02:29:59.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ron, go right ahead.

1509
02:30:00.264 --> 02:30:02.593
<v Ron Zito>Council President, good morning, Mayor.

1510
02:30:02.754 --> 02:30:04.022
<v Ron Zito>Good morning, city councilors.

1511
02:30:04.376 --> 02:30:05.147
<v Ron Zito>Thank you for the time.

1512
02:30:05.243 --> 02:30:06.398
<v Ron Zito>For the record, I'm Ron Zito.

1513
02:30:06.447 --> 02:30:09.161
<v Ron Zito>I'm the interim director for the Bureau of Human Resources.

1514
02:30:09.898 --> 02:30:11.873
<v Ron Zito>And first, thank you for consideration of this agreement.

1515
02:30:11.922 --> 02:30:21.155
<v Ron Zito>For the item I'm bringing forward today, which seeks to authorize an extension of an employment agreement to our incoming city administrator, which you just confirmed a moment ago.

1516
02:30:21.941 --> 02:30:35.815
<v Ron Zito>I have a couple of slides here to take you through that has some additional background on our current practice here at the city, some references to this approach as a common practice amongst other cities, and then a brief review of what you might find in one of our employment agreements here at the city.

1517
02:30:36.906 --> 02:30:41.290
<v Mark Sherman>So if we thank you.

1518
02:30:41.868 --> 02:30:47.856
<v Ron Zito>So currently the city offers employment agreements to our deputy city administrators and our regularly appointed bureau directors.

1519
02:30:48.370 --> 02:30:56.769
<v Ron Zito>This is defined under our Human Resources Administrative Rule 8.04, and the practice for this started almost 15 years ago in 2011.

1520
02:30:57.522 --> 02:31:18.261
<v Ron Zito>A key provision of these agreements in the rule provides that in the event of termination without cause during the agreement, the city will pay the employee The payment is a lump sum equal to 1 year of the individual's salary for the first year of the contract and 6 months of their annual salary for the remaining years of the agreement, conditioned upon the execution of a targeted severance agreement.

1521
02:31:18.567 --> 02:31:20.605
<v Ron Zito>So that's our current practice here at the city.

1522
02:31:20.671 --> 02:31:22.191
<v Ron Zito>If we could jump to the next slide, please.

1523
02:31:23.930 --> 02:31:24.284
<v Ron Zito>Thank you.

1524
02:31:25.011 --> 02:31:35.533
<v Ron Zito>And I also just want to offer— it was mentioned earlier in the session here— ICMA, which is the International Council of Mayors, Offering employment contracts across leadership roles within public agencies is a common and a competitive practice.

1525
02:31:36.128 --> 02:31:52.167
<v Ron Zito>And like we heard earlier, ICMA, who is a leading professional association for city and county managers, is a big advocate of employment contracts between administrative officers and the municipality they serve, especially as a tool to ensure stability between the governing body and the manager.

1526
02:31:53.130 --> 02:32:07.436
<v Ron Zito>And some of their research on this topic topic, they emphasize that these agreements serve multiple purposes, but in brief, they establish clear expectations and accountability by defining duties and creating clarity around core topics such as outside employment and reporting relationships.

1527
02:32:08.255 --> 02:32:15.915
<v Ron Zito>They protect the city from legal and financial risk by outlining compensation and benefits, evaluation terms, and defining separation procedures.

1528
02:32:16.027 --> 02:32:21.469
<v Ron Zito>And finally, they facilitate smooth transitions by clarifying notice periods and severance options available.

1529
02:32:22.305 --> 02:32:33.786
<v Ron Zito>Now, the position of city administrator is a new role for the City of Portland, but similar-sized cities and peer cities routinely offer these agreements to their city managers and city administrators as part of their overall employment package.

1530
02:32:34.396 --> 02:32:50.260
<v Ron Zito>Just a few brief examples would include City of Seattle, Sacramento, Las Vegas, San Antonio, to name a few, but also some local neighbor cities such as Vancouver, Salem, Eugene, even Forest Grove all offer their city managers an agreement as well.

1531
02:32:51.415 --> 02:32:53.278
<v Ron Zito>And just one more slide if I could.

1532
02:32:53.359 --> 02:32:53.744
<v Ron Zito>Thank you.

1533
02:32:55.109 --> 02:33:01.354
<v Ron Zito>So finally, just to give you a sense of what terms we include in our current agreements here at the city, I would offer and highlight these.

1534
02:33:01.467 --> 02:33:03.505
<v Ron Zito>They generally designate a 3-year term.

1535
02:33:03.779 --> 02:33:05.336
<v Ron Zito>They define salary and benefits.

1536
02:33:05.801 --> 02:33:08.531
<v Ron Zito>They set expectations for faithful service and performance.

1537
02:33:08.933 --> 02:33:11.148
<v Ron Zito>They commit to an annual performance evaluation.

1538
02:33:11.502 --> 02:33:15.404
<v Ron Zito>They define terms for the termination without cause or with cause.

1539
02:33:15.997 --> 02:33:27.415
<v Ron Zito>They provide for the extension of a severance offer if the separation is for without cause, and they outline notice for the cause of separation and the process for discussing the cause of that discharge.

1540
02:33:28.040 --> 02:33:34.478
<v Ron Zito>They also prohibit subcontracting of the role, and they speak to automatic termination in the event of an inability to serve.

1541
02:33:35.522 --> 02:33:36.679
<v Ron Zito>So with that, I just want.

1542
02:33:36.760 --> 02:33:46.146
<v Ron Zito>I wanted to close by saying, um, that's a quick recap of where we stand today, why we intend to offer this, and I'm happy to answer any questions you might have about the ordinance.

1543
02:33:47.204 --> 02:33:47.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mr. Zito.

1544
02:33:48.022 --> 02:33:51.040
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, is there anything you'd like to add before we take some questions?

1545
02:33:51.504 --> 02:33:51.969
<v Keith Wilson>No, thank you.

1546
02:33:52.034 --> 02:33:55.388
<v Keith Wilson>It was a competitive negotiation and it was a competitive offer.

1547
02:33:56.287 --> 02:34:04.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, um, councilors, I do believe we have some public testimony, but let's take any questions for Mr. Zito now, and then we can have any discussion after testimony.

1548
02:34:08.567 --> 02:34:16.234
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I just, I appreciate that you're laying out very clearly, Mr. Zito, that the severance is conditional upon a no-cause dismissal.

1549
02:34:16.799 --> 02:34:26.108
<v Mitch Green>And so after we get through testimony, I'll probably want to engage a little bit with the mayor and you to discuss sort of expectations on our tenure of our new CA.

1550
02:34:26.188 --> 02:34:30.924
<v Mitch Green>But I think the public is watching on the severance issue and wanting to know that it's not something we just lean on.

1551
02:34:31.004 --> 02:34:31.136
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1552
02:34:36.110 --> 02:34:36.468
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absolutely.

1553
02:34:36.566 --> 02:34:37.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1554
02:34:37.299 --> 02:34:37.933
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1555
02:34:39.659 --> 02:34:40.474
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

1556
02:34:41.843 --> 02:34:49.743
<v Loretta Smith>As I listened to you and I looked at your presentation, you put this— you gave this new agreement for DCAs and for bureau heads.

1557
02:34:50.227 --> 02:34:56.327
<v Loretta Smith>We just paid someone $241,000, their full salary, and they've been here for 2 years.

1558
02:34:58.028 --> 02:35:02.575
<v Loretta Smith>We're talking about a city manager, which is different from a DCA.

1559
02:35:03.368 --> 02:35:08.224
<v Loretta Smith>The original DCAs had 3-year contracts with full benefits.

1560
02:35:08.774 --> 02:35:20.186
<v Loretta Smith>And so for me, the language that this city administrator put forward, it was not for the city administrators, for the DCAs and for the bureau heads.

1561
02:35:20.881 --> 02:35:37.577
<v Loretta Smith>And so we are establishing something and we want people This, this city administrator position, they last anywhere between 3 and 5 years, but we need to have a severance package that is equal to the position.

1562
02:35:39.450 --> 02:35:48.870
<v Loretta Smith>And if others have gotten a full 12, 12, and 12, he needs to get— as the city administrator, he needs to have a 12, 12, and 12 as well.

1563
02:35:49.582 --> 02:35:57.236
<v Loretta Smith>It needs to be fair because it is not in the language that the city administrator and previous DCAs, they got 12, 12, and 12.

1564
02:35:57.736 --> 02:36:00.183
<v Loretta Smith>And so I'm not understanding this right now.

1565
02:36:00.554 --> 02:36:01.324
<v Loretta Smith>It doesn't look good.

1566
02:36:01.373 --> 02:36:02.137
<v Loretta Smith>It's not a good look.

1567
02:36:05.113 --> 02:36:20.309
<v Ron Zito>If I may, Councilor, just to give some brief history on where we've been with these agreements, uh, in the past, uh, and this, this was probably goes a few years back, uh, we did offer our directors who then reported directly to commissioners, 12, 12, and 12, a 3-year agreement.

1568
02:36:20.453 --> 02:36:28.370
<v Ron Zito>And at the end of that 3-year agreement, there was an option to automatically just renew, and so renew for another year at a time.

1569
02:36:28.868 --> 02:36:38.245
<v Ron Zito>In January of this year, as we moved to the new form of government, we did adjust those contracts for incoming directors to be a 12, 6, and 6 option.

1570
02:36:39.480 --> 02:36:41.360
<v Ron Zito>So that's just the history of where we've been.

1571
02:36:41.568 --> 02:36:55.125
<v Ron Zito>We did have a recent and again, you're talking about directors.

1572
02:36:55.173 --> 02:36:56.465
<v Loretta Smith>You're not talking about the city administrator.

1573
02:36:57.159 --> 02:37:06.358
<v Loretta Smith>The city administrator's severance package should equal his position, whoever it is, and it should be the 12, 12, and 12.

1574
02:37:06.864 --> 02:37:08.093
<v Keith Wilson>May I run that back?

1575
02:37:09.066 --> 02:37:09.371
<v Loretta Smith>Please.

1576
02:37:09.549 --> 02:37:18.936
<v Keith Wilson>When we've taken over this journey along the new form of government, learning what the previous agreements were, there was so much transition.

1577
02:37:19.387 --> 02:37:25.218
<v Keith Wilson>The 12 was offered in some cases for all these new directors and DCAs and such.

1578
02:37:26.521 --> 02:37:30.202
<v Keith Wilson>In January, we discussed this and we moved to a more operational approach.

1579
02:37:30.460 --> 02:37:39.899
<v Keith Wilson>These jobs that we're offering are permanent jobs, and we've shifted to a 12-month severance in the first year and 6 for the subsequent years going forward.

1580
02:37:40.043 --> 02:37:42.979
<v Keith Wilson>And that's what all of our senior leaders have been brought in since then.

1581
02:37:43.798 --> 02:37:44.183
<v Loretta Smith>Correct.

1582
02:37:44.295 --> 02:37:46.027
<v Loretta Smith>I, I understand exactly what you're saying.

1583
02:37:46.797 --> 02:37:53.549
<v Loretta Smith>It's not a good look when you have just given less than 30 days, a full 12 after the second year.

1584
02:37:53.759 --> 02:37:55.796
<v Loretta Smith>We're speaking about the administrator.

1585
02:37:55.843 --> 02:37:58.185
<v Loretta Smith>We're not speaking about the DCAs.

1586
02:37:58.811 --> 02:38:05.279
<v Loretta Smith>They are not on the same level, and they need to have the same protection protections that the previous ones had.

1587
02:38:05.712 --> 02:38:12.763
<v Loretta Smith>And we're— today we're not talking about approving a DCA contract, we're talking about a city administrator.

1588
02:38:14.129 --> 02:38:16.153
<v Loretta Smith>And it doesn't feel good.

1589
02:38:16.555 --> 02:38:19.253
<v Loretta Smith>It just— it's not a good look and it doesn't feel good.

1590
02:38:19.527 --> 02:38:21.774
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1591
02:38:22.963 --> 02:38:23.702
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

1592
02:38:24.217 --> 02:38:35.659
<v Steve Novick>Mr. President, I just wanted to note that my understanding of the way it works in Vegas is That if you get severance, you can either take 1 year of severance, you can take a double or nothing option based on the outcome of a hand of blackjack.

1593
02:38:35.772 --> 02:38:36.784
<v Steve Novick>So I just wanted to clarify that.

1594
02:38:37.850 --> 02:38:38.433
<v Joseph Perez>Thank you, Councilor.

1595
02:38:39.019 --> 02:38:39.977
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1596
02:38:40.300 --> 02:38:41.015
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

1597
02:38:41.112 --> 02:38:41.600
<v Loretta Smith>Point of order.

1598
02:38:42.753 --> 02:38:45.935
<v Loretta Smith>This is a very serious thing and I'm not joking.

1599
02:38:47.510 --> 02:38:50.076
<v Loretta Smith>And so I want people to take this seriously.

1600
02:38:51.242 --> 02:38:55.686
<v Loretta Smith>And as we are doing these contracts, they don't have labor unions.

1601
02:38:56.061 --> 02:38:58.727
<v Loretta Smith>To protect them about their contracts.

1602
02:38:58.775 --> 02:39:03.720
<v Loretta Smith>They don't know the history of what others have gotten before they got here.

1603
02:39:04.346 --> 02:39:09.452
<v Loretta Smith>So I do know, and that is why I'm speaking up.

1604
02:39:10.336 --> 02:39:14.221
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I didn't know I'd need to speak, but I am supportive of this offer.

1605
02:39:14.623 --> 02:39:21.207
<v Dan Ryan>Mayor, when you said it was a competitive negotiation and a competitive offer, that's all I needed to hear.

1606
02:39:22.029 --> 02:39:26.977
<v Dan Ryan>I want our city administrator to have the skill sets to know how to do this, and it sounds like he did.

1607
02:39:27.041 --> 02:39:27.218
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1608
02:39:27.299 --> 02:39:28.201
<v Dan Ryan>I'll be supportive.

1609
02:39:29.864 --> 02:39:31.486
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1610
02:39:31.861 --> 02:39:34.138
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other questions before we move to public testimony?

1611
02:39:37.810 --> 02:39:38.149
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

1612
02:39:39.748 --> 02:39:42.219
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call up our first testifiers?

1613
02:39:43.140 --> 02:39:46.081
<v Keelan McClymont>We have Joseph Perez joining us online.

1614
02:39:47.959 --> 02:39:48.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Joseph.

1615
02:39:48.808 --> 02:39:49.423
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please go ahead.

1616
02:39:51.549 --> 02:39:52.435
<v Keelan McClymont>Joseph, you're muted.

1617
02:39:59.329 --> 02:40:00.649
<v Keelan McClymont>You're, you're still muted.

1618
02:40:03.690 --> 02:40:04.046
<v Steve Novick>Can you hear me now?

1619
02:40:04.450 --> 02:40:05.519
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, we can hear you.

1620
02:40:06.134 --> 02:40:06.602
<v Joseph Perez>Thank you so much.

1621
02:40:06.942 --> 02:40:12.269
<v Joseph Perez>Um, I'm excited to see a new city administrator who will bring fresh perspectives and new ideas to Portland.

1622
02:40:12.938 --> 02:40:26.067
<v Joseph Perez>I'm excited to see experiences and approaches from Greeley and other cities that will identify areas for improvement, challenge the status quo, encourage innovation, inspire a shared vision, and enable others to act.

1623
02:40:26.324 --> 02:40:35.125
<v Joseph Perez>And I expect that the new city administrator will have special expertise and skills and knowledge and ability to model, model the way and encourage our hearts.

1624
02:40:36.006 --> 02:40:51.860
<v Joseph Perez>This new city administrator, starting with a blank slate, free from the existing social history, internal conflicts, and political dynamics within city This neutrality should help to ensure objective decision-making and the fair, nonpartisan implementation of city council policies.

1625
02:40:52.775 --> 02:41:04.933
<v Joseph Perez>This new administrator has expertise in public administration, budgeting, strategic planning, and that should enable the council to focus on their business and policymaking, etc., and setting new policies as well.

1626
02:41:05.399 --> 02:41:09.993
<v Joseph Perez>And I expect the city administrator to be a leader in implementing city goals like Vision Zero.

1627
02:41:10.746 --> 02:41:22.347
<v Joseph Perez>Climate action and modal shift and make progress on innovative programs like the bike bus, the bicycle bus where kids get to bicycle to school often and with joy.

1628
02:41:23.262 --> 02:41:28.219
<v Joseph Perez>And I don't expect their— the city administrator to be constrained by old habits or practices.

1629
02:41:28.397 --> 02:41:34.253
<v Joseph Perez>And so also the new city administrator should establish authority and a clear command structure.

1630
02:41:35.152 --> 02:41:38.280
<v Joseph Perez>Under the new charter, the mayor can dismiss the city administrator without city council approval.

1631
02:41:38.344 --> 02:41:38.521
<v Joseph Perez>Thank you.

1632
02:41:39.066 --> 02:41:41.309
<v Joseph Perez>But the mayor must advise the council before removal.

1633
02:41:41.389 --> 02:41:44.898
<v Joseph Perez>The council has the power to remove the administrator for cause, which I believe is 9 votes.

1634
02:41:45.667 --> 02:41:54.545
<v Joseph Perez>Subject to the confirmation, which just happened, the mayor appoints the city administrator and holds significant executive power, whereas the council needs 9 votes.

1635
02:41:55.346 --> 02:41:58.503
<v Joseph Perez>This creates a strong incentive for the administrator to be loyal to the mayor.

1636
02:41:59.191 --> 02:42:01.244
<v Joseph Perez>To me, this is not what the charter reform is supposed to bring.

1637
02:42:01.355 --> 02:42:05.088
<v Joseph Perez>I thought the charter would create a city administrator position that was more answerable to city council.

1638
02:42:05.170 --> 02:42:07.769
<v Joseph Perez>With a simple majority regardless of how many votes are needed.

1639
02:42:08.105 --> 02:42:13.463
<v Joseph Perez>I hope that there is a way, as Councilor Smith just mentioned, for the city administrator to have significant independence.

1640
02:42:14.170 --> 02:42:24.084
<v Joseph Perez>I think this 3-year contract the administrator has offered is, is okay, is fine, but the contract should be carefully examined for opportunities to give the city administrator appropriate compensation.

1641
02:42:24.533 --> 02:42:29.636
<v Joseph Perez>Please consider changing the 6-month subsequent time to 1 year or more, possibly 3 years.

1642
02:42:29.733 --> 02:42:37.157
<v Joseph Perez>I agree with Councilor I want to remind the City Council the majority of people in Portland want to ride transit, and almost 50% want to ride bicycles.

1643
02:42:37.207 --> 02:42:42.611
<v Joseph Perez>And I want to recommend incentivizing cross-bureau work and joint bureau budgeting.

1644
02:42:42.899 --> 02:42:49.201
<v Joseph Perez>The Portland Insights survey shows that people want to take transit and do things safely.

1645
02:42:50.101 --> 02:42:53.950
<v Joseph Perez>Please remember, people who ride bikes are interested but concerned, or concerned about feeling safe.

1646
02:42:54.431 --> 02:42:56.434
<v Joseph Perez>Invest in Portland bikeways, make them safe.

1647
02:42:57.078 --> 02:42:57.971
<v Joseph Perez>The High Crash Network.

1648
02:42:58.199 --> 02:43:00.617
<v Joseph Perez>Also, uh, thank you, Councilor Murillo.

1649
02:43:00.730 --> 02:43:02.808
<v Joseph Perez>I think there should be an employee suggestion box.

1650
02:43:03.355 --> 02:43:07.358
<v Joseph Perez>Change is hard, and innovative ideas may need support outside the bureau they work for.

1651
02:43:07.906 --> 02:43:10.907
<v Joseph Perez>I invite you to learn Portland by riding bicycle, Mr. Lee.

1652
02:43:11.343 --> 02:43:13.040
<v Joseph Perez>The city is truly a marvelous place.

1653
02:43:13.316 --> 02:43:14.113
<v Joseph Perez>I love living here.

1654
02:43:14.195 --> 02:43:16.781
<v Joseph Perez>I think you will love— I know you will love living here as well.

1655
02:43:16.879 --> 02:43:17.415
<v Joseph Perez>Thank you so much.

1656
02:43:20.113 --> 02:43:20.990
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1657
02:43:21.520 --> 02:43:22.331
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

1658
02:43:23.486 --> 02:43:28.614
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, colleagues, is there any further discussion before we move to a vote on this offer?

1659
02:43:29.272 --> 02:43:29.960
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

1660
02:43:31.274 --> 02:43:31.899
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you.

1661
02:43:32.059 --> 02:43:36.818
<v Mitch Green>Um, I support the offer as, as brought forward.

1662
02:43:37.188 --> 02:43:46.754
<v Mitch Green>Um, I, I just have to make a comment about whether or not, you know, senior executives have a labor union representative.

1663
02:43:47.138 --> 02:43:55.763
<v Mitch Green>The reason why we have labor unions is because you have senior executives who control the corporation, control the firm, and oppress the working class.

1664
02:43:56.435 --> 02:43:58.487
<v Mitch Green>And so they organize for better wages.

1665
02:43:59.386 --> 02:44:05.220
<v Mitch Green>When you're at the level of a senior executive, you negotiate with a lot more market power than an individual worker has.

1666
02:44:05.413 --> 02:44:09.709
<v Mitch Green>So to Councilor Ryan's point, it was a competitive offer and he agreed upon it.

1667
02:44:09.822 --> 02:44:10.832
<v Mitch Green>That is a transaction.

1668
02:44:11.248 --> 02:44:12.483
<v Mitch Green>He is being fairly compensated.

1669
02:44:12.932 --> 02:44:21.334
<v Mitch Green>If he was not being fairly compensated, he would not So that's the way I think about it, and I just— I can't let it stand that we need to think about labor unions for city administrators.

1670
02:44:23.280 --> 02:44:37.523
<v Mitch Green>I do want to stress, though, that there are corners of this city, and I suspect it's a majority of Portlanders, who for right or wrong reasons are worried about the rate at which we've paid out severances in this city.

1671
02:44:38.397 --> 02:44:40.031
<v Mitch Green>And I know you care about that too, Mr. Mayor.

1672
02:44:40.505 --> 02:44:43.302
<v Mitch Green>And I know that's why you spent a lot of time trying to find the right person for this job.

1673
02:44:43.369 --> 02:44:43.433
<v Robert Pyle>I do.

1674
02:44:44.378 --> 02:44:52.750
<v Mitch Green>And so if we're going to use this severance tool, it really does need to be for a no-cause dismissal as a last resort.

1675
02:44:53.963 --> 02:44:58.270
<v Mitch Green>I believe that you recruited him and brought him for an appointment because you want him to be here for a tenure.

1676
02:44:59.122 --> 02:45:09.842
<v Mitch Green>And so if we get into a situation where we feel like the city administrator is not the right fit for the city, I hope that we can have a conversation about giving him an opportunity to be the right fit for the city.

1677
02:45:09.890 --> 02:45:10.054
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1678
02:45:10.850 --> 02:45:15.168
<v Mitch Green>So that we don't find ourselves in a situation where we have to dismiss a city administrator and pay them out of severance.

1679
02:45:15.720 --> 02:45:17.831
<v Mitch Green>So that's kind of my piece on that.

1680
02:45:18.878 --> 02:45:23.206
<v Mitch Green>I think it's okay to change your severance policy over time and not get locked into the forever past.

1681
02:45:23.994 --> 02:45:25.314
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to support this today.

1682
02:45:25.539 --> 02:45:25.861
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1683
02:45:26.487 --> 02:45:27.227
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1684
02:45:27.370 --> 02:45:28.013
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1685
02:45:31.726 --> 02:45:32.384
<v Loretta Smith>Correct something.

1686
02:45:32.432 --> 02:45:37.703
<v Loretta Smith>I did not say that I wanted a union for the city administrator or the executive at all.

1687
02:45:39.325 --> 02:45:50.920
<v Loretta Smith>I said it does not look good for someone to come in and get less of a severance who is the city administrator, not a DCA or even a department head.

1688
02:45:51.498 --> 02:45:55.924
<v Loretta Smith>The department head had a better severance package than this city administrator.

1689
02:45:56.264 --> 02:45:58.745
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm talking about fairness, Councilor Green.

1690
02:45:59.425 --> 02:46:00.350
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I'm talking about.

1691
02:46:00.545 --> 02:46:01.014
<v Mitch Green>Paid a lot more than that.

1692
02:46:03.781 --> 02:46:06.768
<v Loretta Smith>And it was a very competitive salary.

1693
02:46:06.833 --> 02:46:08.694
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not complaining about the salary.

1694
02:46:08.824 --> 02:46:13.063
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just saying what it looks like, Mayor Wilson.

1695
02:46:13.961 --> 02:46:19.067
<v Loretta Smith>It does not look good that we have a man who comes here.

1696
02:46:20.304 --> 02:46:21.989
<v Loretta Smith>He did not— I don't know what he got in his package.

1697
02:46:22.069 --> 02:46:27.240
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know if he got a move package or what that looks like.

1698
02:46:27.947 --> 02:46:28.878
<v Loretta Smith>These positions are tough.

1699
02:46:28.926 --> 02:46:29.055
<v Mitch Green>I agree.

1700
02:46:29.617 --> 02:46:30.804
<v Loretta Smith>This is a new position.

1701
02:46:31.236 --> 02:46:34.701
<v Loretta Smith>This is 12 people here that he has to adapt to.

1702
02:46:35.808 --> 02:46:39.387
<v Loretta Smith>And trust me, if 9 folks get together and say they want him gone, he's gone.

1703
02:46:40.461 --> 02:46:48.147
<v Loretta Smith>And there are no other protections that, that would allow him to move forward to get something comparable somewhere else.

1704
02:46:48.227 --> 02:46:50.167
<v Loretta Smith>It takes time at that level.

1705
02:46:50.408 --> 02:46:51.179
<v Loretta Smith>And that's all I'm saying.

1706
02:46:51.274 --> 02:46:54.772
<v Loretta Smith>I just wanted to let you know it does not look good in the community.

1707
02:46:54.820 --> 02:46:54.916
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1708
02:46:55.623 --> 02:47:01.409
<v Loretta Smith>For this man to come here to get something less than people who are under him have received.

1709
02:47:02.037 --> 02:47:04.813
<v Loretta Smith>That's all I was bringing the attention to.

1710
02:47:08.672 --> 02:47:09.431
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1711
02:47:09.706 --> 02:47:34.193
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I know that one of the points you made in your first statement was about what previous, previous people at the city have received, and so I want to just ask a question to try to provide perhaps some context that might give our colleagues a little bit of, um, of comfort in what's currently on the table.

1712
02:47:34.306 --> 02:47:45.156
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I hate to put you on the spot, Mr. Jordan, but as our city's only previous city administrator, are you comfortable sharing with us if you have a severance as part of your contract?

1713
02:47:45.834 --> 02:47:46.093
<v Mitch Green>Sure.

1714
02:47:46.302 --> 02:47:56.762
<v Mitch Green>I have no severance as part of my contract, but I entered into this I took this job knowing that it was temporary and knowing that I'd already failed at retirement twice.

1715
02:47:58.057 --> 02:48:05.295
<v Mitch Green>And so I came to the job in a unique set of circumstances, and I don't think it applies in any way to this situation.

1716
02:48:05.407 --> 02:48:07.838
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate the question, Madam President.

1717
02:48:08.099 --> 02:48:18.046
<v Mitch Green>Maybe for a little bit of context, Ron made the point that we have had severance policy in the city for a long time.

1718
02:48:18.110 --> 02:48:18.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right.

1719
02:48:19.307 --> 02:48:25.346
<v Mitch Green>And at one point, all directors reported directly to elected officials.

1720
02:48:26.277 --> 02:48:34.319
<v Mitch Green>And the idea of severance for employees who serve at the pleasure of electeds is an industry standard.

1721
02:48:34.929 --> 02:48:37.604
<v Mitch Green>And all cities do it, but they do it in a different way.

1722
02:48:39.094 --> 02:48:40.601
<v Mitch Green>Even smaller cities do it.

1723
02:48:41.337 --> 02:48:50.879
<v Mitch Green>And the reason it's an industry standard is because it protects the employee but it also protects the hiring entity.

1724
02:48:52.790 --> 02:48:58.960
<v Mitch Green>You expect people in these roles to bring you bad news, and you expect them to do it promptly.

1725
02:48:59.170 --> 02:49:01.217
<v Mitch Green>You expect them to do it wholeheartedly.

1726
02:49:02.185 --> 02:49:11.186
<v Mitch Green>And it is a high-wire act, and you are subject to the pleasure of the elected— either the elected body or an individual elected.

1727
02:49:12.193 --> 02:49:25.338
<v Mitch Green>And so So it is, that severance concept is for the protection of both, both the employee and the employer in the day-to-day operation of a very complicated organization.

1728
02:49:25.777 --> 02:49:27.864
<v Mitch Green>So I wanted to put that context around it.

1729
02:49:28.772 --> 02:49:38.347
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, to your point, this body with 7 votes can award any amount of severance you wish.

1730
02:49:38.427 --> 02:49:38.477
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Yes.

1731
02:49:40.652 --> 02:49:45.769
<v Mitch Green>The reason it was brought forward the way it is, is because that's the current policy of the city.

1732
02:49:46.399 --> 02:49:50.121
<v Mitch Green>We do have a few directors that are on a legacy.

1733
02:49:50.201 --> 02:49:51.766
<v Mitch Green>I don't know that we have any left anymore.

1734
02:49:51.816 --> 02:49:51.977
<v Joseph Perez>Yes.

1735
02:49:52.493 --> 02:49:56.236
<v Mitch Green>But we have had directors on this from the previous policy.

1736
02:49:56.834 --> 02:50:00.224
<v Mitch Green>And that, for the public's sake, that's the reason that this has happened.

1737
02:50:02.015 --> 02:50:03.691
<v Mitch Green>I don't disagree that it's a bad look.

1738
02:50:05.370 --> 02:50:06.140
<v Mitch Green>I don't disagree at all.

1739
02:50:06.815 --> 02:50:09.047
<v Mitch Green>And I know you made your point and I appreciate the point.

1740
02:50:10.202 --> 02:50:16.593
<v Mitch Green>And I just wanted to make sure the public knew this body with 7 votes can give award severance in any way it wishes.

1741
02:50:17.668 --> 02:50:18.310
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam President.

1742
02:50:18.938 --> 02:50:19.772
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mr. Jordan.

1743
02:50:19.820 --> 02:50:26.050
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I do understand that your situation is quite different than bringing in somebody to a more permanent position.

1744
02:50:26.886 --> 02:50:36.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Smith, I wanna say, the quiet piece a little bit louder, which is that we know that people of color and women don't always negotiate in the same way that white men do.

1745
02:50:37.567 --> 02:50:47.129
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we have a person of color before us coming to help run our city, and we want to make sure that what we offer is fair.

1746
02:50:47.932 --> 02:50:54.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I feel comfortable with this because I've been a strong supporter of moving in the direction of a contract like this for all of our leadership.

1747
02:50:54.842 --> 02:51:10.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I hope, Mr. Mayor, that if there are still Bureau directors who are on legacy contracts that as soon as those come up, they are renewed to the level that is comparable to what we are asking our city administrator to accept.

1748
02:51:11.731 --> 02:51:23.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to both ensure that we have good people who we recruit and that we protect both them and ourselves as we need them to make hard decisions, and that we look out for the bottom line for our city.

1749
02:51:23.382 --> 02:51:23.495
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1750
02:51:24.947 --> 02:51:50.415
<v Steve Novick>I have to say that I feel totally convinced that if we as a council decided spontaneously on our own to extend a more generous severance package, then that was part— that would be a fair compromise.

1751
02:51:50.530 --> 02:51:55.316
<v Steve Novick>That which was part of the package that Mr. Lee accepted in agreeing to take this job.

1752
02:51:56.007 --> 02:51:58.031
<v Steve Novick>I think the community would not be very pleased with that.

1753
02:51:58.513 --> 02:52:02.112
<v Steve Novick>I think the community would be saying we're throwing money away for nothing, potentially.

1754
02:52:03.045 --> 02:52:04.940
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1755
02:52:05.245 --> 02:52:08.893
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any more conversation before we move to a vote?

1756
02:52:10.162 --> 02:52:11.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1757
02:52:11.993 --> 02:52:16.603
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President, and thank you for highlighting, I think, as you put it, the quiet part out loud.

1758
02:52:17.134 --> 02:52:24.340
<v Sameer Kanal>I think I think that separate from this discussion but related, we need to do our part to be supportive of people in these roles.

1759
02:52:24.917 --> 02:52:29.797
<v Sameer Kanal>And often the conversation gets limited to just the, the moment of the hiring.

1760
02:52:31.015 --> 02:52:41.913
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is true for all of our employees, but that ongoing support, uh, for, for all of our employees, in particular those who might be from marginalized communities, is very important.

1761
02:52:41.960 --> 02:52:42.940
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't want to lose that.

1762
02:52:43.084 --> 02:52:49.594
<v Sameer Kanal>So my, my only point And speaking now is to say let's not forget this conversation after whatever this vote may be.

1763
02:52:50.986 --> 02:52:51.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1764
02:52:52.022 --> 02:52:53.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, any more discussion?

1765
02:52:54.700 --> 02:52:57.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, we will move to a vote.

1766
02:52:58.039 --> 02:53:02.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is an emergency ordinance so that we can extend an offer immediately.

1767
02:53:02.459 --> 02:53:04.233
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It does require 9 votes to pass.

1768
02:53:04.540 --> 02:53:05.727
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

1769
02:53:06.506 --> 02:53:06.783
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

1770
02:53:07.238 --> 02:53:07.402
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1771
02:53:08.051 --> 02:53:08.280
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

1772
02:53:08.620 --> 02:53:08.670
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1773
02:53:09.125 --> 02:53:09.433
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

1774
02:53:10.043 --> 02:53:10.173
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1775
02:53:11.154 --> 02:53:11.202
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Aye.

1776
02:53:12.763 --> 02:53:12.811
<v Michael Woods>Aye.

1777
02:53:14.452 --> 02:53:14.501
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1778
02:53:15.176 --> 02:53:15.192
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1779
02:53:17.595 --> 02:53:17.709
<v Derek Olson>Aye.

1780
02:53:19.861 --> 02:53:19.990
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1781
02:53:20.685 --> 02:53:27.721
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.

1782
02:53:28.994 --> 02:53:29.896
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, colleagues.

1783
02:53:29.959 --> 02:53:32.245
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are just about 3 hours in.

1784
02:53:32.295 --> 02:53:37.468
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a few more things on the agenda that I don't think we can get through Um, immediately.

1785
02:53:37.548 --> 02:53:40.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I would like to have us take a half-hour break.

1786
02:53:41.402 --> 02:53:45.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will come back at 12:51 to finish out our meeting.

1787
02:53:46.122 --> 02:53:47.921
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1788
03:27:18.593 --> 03:27:20.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome back, councilors.

1789
03:27:20.295 --> 03:27:23.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are, um, calling our meeting back to order.

1790
03:27:24.453 --> 03:27:41.646
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we are going to open agenda items 8 and 9 together because we have presentations, I believe, from the same We will take the discussion separately since they are, uh, slightly different, I believe, in, in where that discussion will go.

1791
03:27:41.807 --> 03:27:44.503
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But Keelan, could you please call agenda items 8 and 9?

1792
03:27:45.032 --> 03:28:05.882
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 8, ratify a successor collective bargaining agreement with American Federation of State, County, Municipal Employees Local 189 for represented employees within the Office of Independent Police Review for the terms and conditions conditions of employment of represented employees in the Independent Police Review Bargaining Unit.

1793
03:28:06.509 --> 03:28:21.007
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 9, ratify collective bargaining agreement with the Portland Police Association for represented Emergency Communications Supervisor 1 employees within the Bureau of Emergency Communications for 2025 through 2027.

1794
03:28:21.377 --> 03:28:22.388
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1795
03:28:23.288 --> 03:28:31.787
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Ron, Kim, Annemarie, um, wait a minute, I have the wrong names up here for some of you.

1796
03:28:32.871 --> 03:28:34.045
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, apologies.

1797
03:28:34.784 --> 03:28:43.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we are going to take your overview of both of these items, and then we'll have, um, public testimony and discussion on each.

1798
03:28:43.863 --> 03:28:52.123
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, because we hear updates on these in, um, executive sessions, they don't go through committee, they come straight to council.

1799
03:28:52.191 --> 03:29:00.390
<v Ron Zito>So we'll thank you, Council President, and officially good afternoon, city councilors.

1800
03:29:00.969 --> 03:29:02.273
<v Ron Zito>Again, Ron Zito.

1801
03:29:02.338 --> 03:29:09.257
<v Ron Zito>I'm the interim director for the Bureau of Human Resources, and I'm joined today by a number of our labor relations team members.

1802
03:29:09.989 --> 03:29:13.813
<v Ron Zito>To my right is Kim Fouts, lead negotiator for the IPR contract.

1803
03:29:13.990 --> 03:29:17.701
<v Ron Zito>To my left is Annemarie Kevorkian-Maddy, lead negotiator for the BOEC contract.

1804
03:29:17.750 --> 03:29:17.927
<v Ron Zito>Hi, everyone.

1805
03:29:18.634 --> 03:29:18.809
<v Ron Zito>Okay.

1806
03:29:18.873 --> 03:29:24.782
<v Ron Zito>I think we're going to take these in turn.

1807
03:29:24.896 --> 03:29:28.909
<v Ron Zito>So if we could go to the next slide, we will focus in on AFSCME IPR.

1808
03:29:29.808 --> 03:29:36.712
<v Ron Zito>So we are pleased to be able to present to you this afternoon 2 agreements, the first of which is our AFSCME Independent Police Review.

1809
03:29:37.323 --> 03:29:39.074
<v Ron Zito>It's a successor contract.

1810
03:29:39.652 --> 03:29:43.216
<v Ron Zito>And before I provide a summary on this, I just want to take a moment to thank our AFSCME IPR team for their hard work.

1811
03:29:43.280 --> 03:29:43.377
<v Ron Zito>Thank you.

1812
03:29:43.585 --> 03:29:46.613
<v Ron Zito>AFSCME labor partners, as well as the city bargaining team members.

1813
03:29:47.271 --> 03:29:59.113
<v Ron Zito>Reaching this agreement was not an easy task for either party, and this was uniquely complicated given the impending transition for Independent Police Review Office to the new Office of Community-Based Police Accountability.

1814
03:30:00.106 --> 03:30:17.478
<v Ron Zito>Now, as a reminder, this unit represents 11 members across 5 classifications within Independent Police Review, and the Parties began bargaining the successor contract in January of this year, and we reached a comprehensive tentative agreement on November 10th.

1815
03:30:18.153 --> 03:30:24.575
<v Ron Zito>Just about 7 days later, AFSCME leadership confirmed with the city that their membership did ratify this tentative agreement before you today.

1816
03:30:25.459 --> 03:31:05.350
<v Ron Zito>Now, if approved by council, this agreement would run for 3 years from July 1st, 2025 to June 30th, 2028, and some of the key provisions for this new agreement the revised employment agreement would include an updated retention bonus schedule that moves some of the money into the first year of the contract, a new transition article with a number of commitments and guarantees provided to IPR staff, including advance notice of hiring by the new OCPA director, review and feedback on resume and cover letters, a guaranteed interview with the director of OCPA prior to conducting interviews with external candidates, priority reemployment afforded thank you.

1817
03:31:05.350 --> 03:31:16.709
<v Ron Zito>And for those not selected by the new oversight board, they'd get guaranteed placement into regular status existing vacancies or the creation of regular status positions performing substantially equivalent work.

1818
03:31:16.709 --> 03:31:24.879
<v Ron Zito>And for those finally choosing perhaps separation, staff would be eligible to receive paid administrative leave for 30 days prior to the effective day of that layoff.

1819
03:31:25.409 --> 03:31:25.889
<v Ron Zito>The position would the be posted on parties the city's website.

1820
03:31:26.170 --> 03:31:36.298
<v Ron Zito>Also agreed on maintaining status quo on several IPR articles for any represented staff moving into a new AFSCME-OPA bargaining unit when that's ratified.

1821
03:31:36.701 --> 03:31:43.539
<v Ron Zito>That would include Article 32, which is discipline and discharge, and Article 33, which is grievances, complaints, and arbitration.

1822
03:31:44.545 --> 03:31:49.739
<v Ron Zito>Finally, in regard to the financial impact, the total new spending on this agreement would not exceed $161,500.

1823
03:31:51.932 --> 03:31:57.460
<v Ron Zito>And that actual cost would depend on the number of current employees who remain eligible for the retention bonuses that I mentioned earlier.

1824
03:31:58.358 --> 03:32:05.231
<v Ron Zito>So with that, I'm going to stop there, perhaps answer any questions related to IPR before we move on to the BOEC contract.

1825
03:32:06.657 --> 03:32:07.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, colleagues.

1826
03:32:07.796 --> 03:32:09.270
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll take technical questions now.

1827
03:32:09.462 --> 03:32:12.058
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll hold discussion until after we hear public testimony.

1828
03:32:12.122 --> 03:32:12.891
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1829
03:32:13.565 --> 03:32:14.477
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1830
03:32:14.525 --> 03:32:15.551
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for being here, everyone.

1831
03:32:16.272 --> 03:32:27.138
<v Sameer Kanal>Ron, to the you said that there's a guaranteed interview with the director of OCPA, but there's also a guaranteed decision prior to opening it up.

1832
03:32:27.203 --> 03:32:29.820
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to that a little bit, how that would work logistically?

1833
03:32:30.478 --> 03:32:31.827
<v Ron Zito>Yeah, that's correct, Councilor.

1834
03:32:32.342 --> 03:32:39.824
<v Ron Zito>They— once we hire a new director for OCPA, they would interview any interested folks coming over from IPR.

1835
03:32:40.531 --> 03:32:43.485
<v Ron Zito>They would go through that interview process and then be afforded a decision.

1836
03:32:48.347 --> 03:32:52.846
<v Sameer Kanal>And the director would not be able to see external candidates until after that, correct?

1837
03:32:53.090 --> 03:32:53.509
<v Ron Zito>That is correct.

1838
03:32:54.171 --> 03:32:54.363
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1839
03:32:55.445 --> 03:32:56.978
<v Sameer Kanal>I have a second question, if that's okay.

1840
03:32:57.236 --> 03:32:57.608
<v Olivia Clark>Right ahead.

1841
03:32:58.367 --> 03:33:09.734
<v Sameer Kanal>The 6-month notice that you mentioned of advance hiring, advance notice of hiring by the new OCPA director, can you speak to how that would functionally operate?

1842
03:33:09.782 --> 03:33:09.863
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

1843
03:33:11.077 --> 03:33:16.960
<v Ron Zito>Yes, we would anticipate that if this were ratified today, we'd offer a pretty quick notification of the intent to hire.

1844
03:33:17.345 --> 03:33:26.403
<v Ron Zito>We do— we are not in a place where we've hired an OCPA director this time, but the 6-month runway, we want to make sure that we are on the right side of and we give adequate notice.

1845
03:33:26.467 --> 03:33:28.085
<v Ron Zito>So that would happen pretty promptly.

1846
03:33:28.583 --> 03:33:42.004
<v Sameer Kanal>So if, for example, the new director were to decide to create a function that was— because there are many functions that are not currently authorized for the CBPA, OCPA structure, but were recommended by, for example, the Police Accountability Commission.

1847
03:33:42.278 --> 03:33:55.995
<v Sameer Kanal>If they were to create a unit like that that might have a manager as well as some employees within it, would you need to give 6 months' notice before the manager was hired, go through that process of hiring a manager, and then give 6 months' notice before starting to hire the other folks?

1848
03:33:56.075 --> 03:33:56.861
<v Sameer Kanal>Would it overlap?

1849
03:33:56.941 --> 03:33:58.801
<v Sameer Kanal>How would that functionally work?

1850
03:33:59.588 --> 03:34:01.272
<v Ron Zito>It's a great question, Councilor.

1851
03:34:01.352 --> 03:34:06.074
<v Ron Zito>And I, you know, Speaking frankly, we didn't get into that level of dialogue over this provision.

1852
03:34:06.588 --> 03:34:12.555
<v Ron Zito>However, I think our intent would be to err on the side of further notice, you know, as much advance notice as possible.

1853
03:34:14.239 --> 03:34:14.483
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1854
03:34:14.596 --> 03:34:15.247
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1855
03:34:16.141 --> 03:34:16.791
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1856
03:34:16.872 --> 03:34:19.198
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other questions before we move to the next contract?

1857
03:34:21.219 --> 03:34:24.416
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, let's move to the second contract.

1858
03:34:25.540 --> 03:34:26.106
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Good afternoon.

1859
03:34:27.516 --> 03:34:36.592
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>For the record, I'm Anne-Marie Kiborkian-Maddy, Labor Relations and I'm here to talk about the ordinance for BOEC supervisors.

1860
03:34:36.703 --> 03:34:39.722
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>They are newly represented by the Portland Police Association.

1861
03:34:40.558 --> 03:34:43.384
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>There are currently 14 incumbents in this classification.

1862
03:34:43.448 --> 03:34:48.875
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It's a single classification bargaining unit, Emergency Communications Supervisor 1.

1863
03:34:50.255 --> 03:34:58.316
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>This is an initial contract, and it's modeled off of the collective bargaining agreement for the dispatchers and call takers who are also represented by PPA.

1864
03:34:58.459 --> 03:34:58.637
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Thank you.

1865
03:34:59.606 --> 03:35:20.146
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>And the interest here was to create an agreement that provides similar benefits to incentivize staff to professionally develop and consider promotion into the supervisory rank, leading to a long career with the city and a commitment to the profession and to the community that is served.

1866
03:35:22.069 --> 03:35:25.299
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Because it is an initial contract, everything is essentially new.

1867
03:35:25.462 --> 03:35:27.918
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>I'll just try and cover a few of the highlights for you.

1868
03:35:28.943 --> 03:35:33.994
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>First of all, this recognizes that the Police Association is the sole and exclusive bargaining agent.

1869
03:35:34.939 --> 03:35:42.778
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It provides some economic benefits, including an increased shift differential to match the rank-and-file dispatchers and call takers.

1870
03:35:43.514 --> 03:35:47.635
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It establishes bureau practice for how overtime is hired in this group.

1871
03:35:48.740 --> 03:35:57.192
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It establishes practices for— a practice, rather, for vacation approvals and the number of staff that can be on thank you.

1872
03:35:58.393 --> 03:36:01.378
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It maintains the status quo for their health and life benefits.

1873
03:36:02.420 --> 03:36:12.425
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It establishes a voluntary employment benefit that allows for a percentage of their sick leave to roll over into an account upon retirement from the bureau.

1874
03:36:14.040 --> 03:36:24.245
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It also establishes that this group is strike prohibited and therefore subject to interest arbitration for any sort of dispute resolution, and that is in alignment with all other, uh, telecommunicators.

1875
03:36:24.454 --> 03:36:36.950
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It also establishes the grievance process for dispute resolution and provides city-paid holidays in accordance with HRARs, allows for a labor management committee to be established for the supervisory group.

1876
03:36:38.870 --> 03:36:48.314
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Other economics— it moves this group from a grade to steps, ensuring that employees will receive an annual increase of at least 3% annually.

1877
03:36:48.465 --> 03:36:48.900
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Thank you.

1878
03:36:50.379 --> 03:37:04.006
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It will afford them an opportunity to have their COLA that was provided to them on July 1st, 2025, to be recalculated to the full 2.4% and paid retroactively to July 1st.

1879
03:37:04.314 --> 03:37:07.703
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>That is in alignment with how we have paid our other represented staff.

1880
03:37:09.384 --> 03:37:28.788
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It also creates a few new pay premiums, again, to keep alignment with the rank-and-file dispatch contract, including a DPSST premium— that is the Department of Public Safety and Standards training for intermediate or advanced telecommunicators.

1881
03:37:29.465 --> 03:37:44.961
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>It establishes that the supervisor group will also be affected, or rather eligible for the accreditation premium, which is a premium that was designed around organizational excellence thank you.

1882
03:37:46.174 --> 03:37:59.385
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>And it establishes a coach premium pay as well so that the supervisor group can provide mentorship and leadership opportunities to newly hired supervisors.

1883
03:38:00.127 --> 03:38:05.735
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>And lastly, the bureau is also establishing an educational fund to provide professional development.

1884
03:38:06.125 --> 03:38:07.536
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>This will be in the amount of $4,000.

1885
03:38:08.504 --> 03:38:11.484
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Per fiscal year beginning July 1st, 2026.

1886
03:38:12.433 --> 03:38:22.465
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Um, the cost of the full contract for these employees is just under $224,000 spread over 2 years.

1887
03:38:23.323 --> 03:38:32.262
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>That will— the bureau will assume those costs as part of their budget, so there is no ask from council to provide any additional money.

1888
03:38:33.011 --> 03:38:36.433
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>I think I think that's— I think that is probably the list of highlights there.

1889
03:38:36.576 --> 03:38:48.814
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>I would like to say, uh, thank you to our partners at the table, uh, PPA, the leadership team at BOEC, and the support staff in BHR who, uh, provide valuable collaboration and made this agreement possible.

1890
03:38:49.007 --> 03:38:50.137
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>I'm happy to answer any questions.

1891
03:38:51.662 --> 03:38:52.049
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1892
03:38:52.387 --> 03:38:53.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark?

1893
03:38:53.757 --> 03:38:59.176
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I think you answered this question, but let me just, um, ask you to elaborate a little bit more on the coaching premium.

1894
03:38:59.551 --> 03:39:01.075
<v Olivia Clark>Just how that works and what that is.

1895
03:39:01.413 --> 03:39:13.400
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>So, um, it's more frequently known as, uh, like field training officer, uh, if you are in field for police officers, and for certified training officers for BOEC for telecommunications.

1896
03:39:13.496 --> 03:39:17.460
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>And so there is no equivalent, uh, in the supervisory world.

1897
03:39:17.540 --> 03:39:41.244
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>So this would be an opportunity for newly hired supervisors to work with their peers who will provide on-the-job training, provide some guidance to them, feedback, And what's it, 8% of— Yeah, 8% of the employee's base rate of pay.

1898
03:39:42.845 --> 03:39:55.575
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>And that's a fixed amount, so that amount is only going to be paid while the training is actually underway and will not be in effect after the trainee has certified.

1899
03:39:55.639 --> 03:39:55.769
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Thank you.

1900
03:39:56.375 --> 03:39:58.434
<v Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddy>Uh, and become independent to work on their own.

1901
03:40:02.030 --> 03:40:03.629
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, any other questions?

1902
03:40:05.436 --> 03:40:07.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you all.

1903
03:40:07.131 --> 03:40:13.594
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please don't go far, we may have more questions, but I do want to, um, hear from members of the public who are signed up for testimony.

1904
03:40:15.362 --> 03:40:16.086
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1905
03:40:16.569 --> 03:40:17.793
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, I thought we had somebody.

1906
03:40:17.954 --> 03:40:18.469
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry.

1907
03:40:18.888 --> 03:40:21.206
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, um, my apologies.

1908
03:40:21.463 --> 03:40:23.234
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I I missed that one.

1909
03:40:23.650 --> 03:40:29.043
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any other discussion on either of these collective bargaining agreements then before we move to votes?

1910
03:40:29.123 --> 03:40:30.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, go right ahead.

1911
03:40:30.728 --> 03:40:32.301
<v Sameer Kanal>Can I start with a request for information?

1912
03:40:32.415 --> 03:40:39.106
<v Sameer Kanal>Is the intent to do discussion on IPR and then vote and then a discussion on BOEC and vote, or how do you wanna—.

1913
03:40:39.700 --> 03:40:40.985
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that will keep this cleaner.

1914
03:40:41.146 --> 03:40:54.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, we opened them together in order to let staff come up and present more seamlessly, but why don't we We'll stick to discussion on agenda item number 8, which is the contract related to employees at the Independent Police Review.

1915
03:40:54.442 --> 03:40:57.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll take a vote there and then move on to agenda item 9.

1916
03:40:57.710 --> 03:40:59.102
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are you in the queue for agenda item 8?

1917
03:40:59.512 --> 03:40:59.709
<v Robert Pyle>Yes.

1918
03:40:59.986 --> 03:41:00.708
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, go right ahead.

1919
03:41:02.409 --> 03:41:03.038
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1920
03:41:03.086 --> 03:41:04.022
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to the presenters.

1921
03:41:04.796 --> 03:41:08.923
<v Sameer Kanal>First, I wanna thank the employees at Independent Police Review for staying with the city and with the system.

1922
03:41:09.117 --> 03:41:12.906
<v Sameer Kanal>This includes all the employees, particularly but not limited to the represented workers.

1923
03:41:13.120 --> 03:41:16.152
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a small team, and any labor issue affects everyone who's worked there.

1924
03:41:16.665 --> 03:41:18.574
<v Sameer Kanal>I've had the privilege of working with many of these employees.

1925
03:41:18.622 --> 03:41:22.297
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm appreciative of their professionalism, their dedication, and the high quality of their work.

1926
03:41:22.778 --> 03:41:30.318
<v Sameer Kanal>I also think it's important to state this emphatically: I've never held you responsible, nor will I today, for the shortcomings of the system in which you work.

1927
03:41:31.137 --> 03:41:38.629
<v Sameer Kanal>IPR is not responsible for the decisions made on accountability choices by other decision makers, including mayors and police chiefs past, because you present.

1928
03:41:39.367 --> 03:41:44.128
<v Sameer Kanal>Excellent information and investigation to them, and they sometimes go a different way than you recommend.

1929
03:41:44.593 --> 03:41:47.942
<v Sameer Kanal>I know also many of you have advocated for positive changes to this system.

1930
03:41:48.761 --> 03:41:54.340
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's been very valid for workers anywhere to want stability and security, and for asking for it in this bargaining process.

1931
03:41:54.451 --> 03:42:02.932
<v Sameer Kanal>Three years ago, the city made a unique commitment to guarantee post-transition jobs for IPR employees in the city—not necessarily in the new oversight system.

1932
03:42:03.413 --> 03:42:04.534
<v Sameer Kanal>No other union had received this.

1933
03:42:04.600 --> 03:42:13.356
<v Sameer Kanal>In their contract, and that recognized the unique role, uniqueness of federal oversight of our policing practices, including oversight and your dedication.

1934
03:42:14.031 --> 03:42:23.463
<v Sameer Kanal>3 Years on, this transition has been slowed down, not by workers, but by previous leadership of the city, and we're now bargaining another contract that shouldn't have been needed because this transition should be farther along by now.

1935
03:42:24.299 --> 03:42:37.926
<v Sameer Kanal>I've worked on these specific parts of the charter and settlement agreement that I'm going to talk about in a moment for 4 years, including as a project manager of the Police Accountability Commission, as support staff for other advisory groups focused on these requirements, and now as a councilor and co-chair of the Community and Public Safety Committee.

1936
03:42:38.056 --> 03:42:43.219
<v Sameer Kanal>It's the part of the charter that I know best, and in working with— working on it, I worked with many of these employees.

1937
03:42:43.877 --> 03:42:45.801
<v Sameer Kanal>This has been a difficult bargaining conversation.

1938
03:42:45.897 --> 03:42:52.568
<v Sameer Kanal>It's in part because we know IPR's current positions are going to go away, which can be demoralizing, difficult, and raise concerns.

1939
03:42:53.259 --> 03:42:57.129
<v Sameer Kanal>One original request that was widely reported was to have guaranteed jobs in the new system.

1940
03:42:57.613 --> 03:43:07.174
<v Sameer Kanal>While it is perfectly fair to ask for this, this was clearly and accurately labeled as a violation of Charter Section 2-1005, which empowers the new system's director to make hiring decisions.

1941
03:43:07.722 --> 03:43:16.708
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think the continued conversations resolved this concern, and the proposed labor agreement that we're voting on today, in my view, does not violate Charter 2-1005.

1942
03:43:16.983 --> 03:43:19.588
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to thank BHR as well as AFSCME for that.

1943
03:43:19.994 --> 03:43:28.871
<v Sameer Kanal>However, there remain 2 additional concerns, 2-1006, And the timeline required by the settlement agreement with the federal government, paragraph 195.

1944
03:43:29.561 --> 03:43:35.163
<v Sameer Kanal>The first of which says the board shall have authority to exercise independent judgment in performing all legally assigned powers and duties.

1945
03:43:35.515 --> 03:43:43.941
<v Sameer Kanal>The city council, mayor, city administrator, auditor, and city departments, bureaus, and other administrative agencies shall not interfere in the exercise of the board's independent judgment.

1946
03:43:44.423 --> 03:44:00.493
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, yet as we have just heard from human resources, if we approve this agreement, it will keep the director from even knowing what other other candidates are out there until after IPR employees are interviewed for jobs and a decision is made by the director on whether or not to hire them before even starting to look at external candidates.

1947
03:44:00.959 --> 03:44:10.736
<v Sameer Kanal>In my personal view, this is clearly a violation of the independent judgment clause, and as the, the clause specifically states that City Council cannot interfere, voting for this would be interference in my view.

1948
03:44:11.459 --> 03:44:24.475
<v Sameer Kanal>But that does not prohibit us from providing advice or professional opinion, which is why I filed a letter with the staff that will be supporting the future director, providing my professional opinion and advice that the new director look strongly at and hire the IPR employees for jobs in the new system.

1949
03:44:24.570 --> 03:44:28.212
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll say once again, I expect the overwhelming majority of these employees to be hired.

1950
03:44:28.646 --> 03:44:30.235
<v Sameer Kanal>The issue is about the requirement.

1951
03:44:30.636 --> 03:44:38.641
<v Sameer Kanal>And then secondly, the settlement agreement requires that within 12 months of the council's adoption of the city code provisions, a new board will be staffed and able to take on cases.

1952
03:44:39.379 --> 03:44:41.095
<v Sameer Kanal>The deadline for that is January 2nd, this coming Wednesday.

1953
03:44:41.225 --> 03:44:41.416
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1954
03:44:41.530 --> 03:45:05.147
<v Sameer Kanal>We're nowhere near this, and providing 6 months notice to the bargaining unit when a new position is to be hired, and as we just heard, providing more notice when, when there's ambiguity, will create overlapping or even cascading delays in hiring, which will put us out of the settlement agreement even, even further and also delay implementation of something that the community has been waiting, as of today, 1,863 days to see implemented.

1955
03:45:06.591 --> 03:45:10.264
<v Sameer Kanal>When I was campaigning for this office, I made a very clear promise I would never violate the will of the voters.

1956
03:45:10.602 --> 03:45:12.536
<v Sameer Kanal>I would never say to voters, I know better than you.

1957
03:45:12.617 --> 03:45:16.128
<v Sameer Kanal>I would never undermine democracy that way, specifically on this part of the charter.

1958
03:45:16.826 --> 03:45:21.438
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also promised I would never stand against police accountability, including by tying the hands of the new system.

1959
03:45:21.778 --> 03:45:23.686
<v Sameer Kanal>And in my view, this labor agreement does both.

1960
03:45:24.422 --> 03:45:44.700
<v Sameer Kanal>And so while I recognize that my labor friends and allies and colleagues up here may feel differently than I do on the analysis or decision here, and by the way, I respect whatever choices you make, and I'm committed to continuing the conversation with anyone who's while I strongly support workers' rights and do not take voting on a collective bargaining agreement lightly, my experience tells me that this violates the Charter and the promise I made.

1961
03:45:45.087 --> 03:45:46.524
<v Sameer Kanal>I can't bargain away the will of the people.

1962
03:45:46.751 --> 03:45:48.058
<v Sameer Kanal>I can't vote to violate the Charter.

1963
03:45:48.447 --> 03:45:50.239
<v Sameer Kanal>And as a result, I'll be voting no on this agreement.

1964
03:45:50.708 --> 03:45:51.403
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1965
03:45:52.430 --> 03:45:53.272
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1966
03:45:53.433 --> 03:45:57.308
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any other discussion on this, on this contract?

1967
03:45:59.754 --> 03:46:02.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, this is an emergency ordinance.

1968
03:46:02.774 --> 03:46:03.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, you have the floor.

1969
03:46:05.432 --> 03:46:20.918
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to say that although I come to a different conclusion on this issue, I really respect Councilor Kanal's commitment to principle and looking at things through the lens of how he sees the language of the Charter rather than what's expedient.

1970
03:46:21.079 --> 03:46:25.715
<v Steve Novick>And I come to a different conclusion, but I really respect your— the way you approach these issues.

1971
03:46:28.220 --> 03:46:28.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1972
03:46:31.167 --> 03:46:33.792
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I guess I'll just chime in and say that I agree.

1973
03:46:33.953 --> 03:46:39.058
<v Candace Avalos>I totally understand the logic and it is a really tricky position to be in.

1974
03:46:39.121 --> 03:46:46.102
<v Candace Avalos>I know that everybody worked really hard to come to a conclusion that we could— so that we could come here and vote on this today.

1975
03:46:46.393 --> 03:46:56.838
<v Candace Avalos>It is challenging for me because I do believe that it is in conflict with some of what the charter says and also what the intent is of the folks who put forward that charter amendment.

1976
03:46:57.467 --> 03:46:58.146
<v Candace Avalos>Me being one of them.

1977
03:46:58.825 --> 03:47:09.672
<v Candace Avalos>I am going to choose to vote yes today to move this forward and hope that we can continue to discuss how we meet the charter's intent as we're implementing the new system.

1978
03:47:10.969 --> 03:47:11.308
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thanks.

1979
03:47:11.516 --> 03:47:12.823
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1980
03:47:14.063 --> 03:47:20.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I wasn't planning on saying something, but I want to offer some gratitude to our bargaining team.

1981
03:47:21.734 --> 03:47:24.361
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have always believed, and I've Councilor Smith.

1982
03:47:24.476 --> 03:47:32.683
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think I've sat on both sides of the bargaining table, that the best contracts come when each side hears what the other side is asking for.

1983
03:47:33.040 --> 03:47:41.277
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And even if you can't provide the initial ask, find a way to meet the underlying need, to meet the reason for the ask.

1984
03:47:41.779 --> 03:47:43.335
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we don't always get that right.

1985
03:47:44.420 --> 03:47:48.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it took a lot of time on this one, and it took a strike, which is hard.

1986
03:47:49.673 --> 03:48:17.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I think, I hope we may have gotten to a place And I just want to express my gratitude for both the city's bargaining team and also the team from AFSCME and our employees at Independent Police Review taking the time to try to figure out how to meet the needs of our employees in a way that also, I believe, and as my colleagues said, I disagree with the interpretation, but understand where you're coming from, but I believe does meet the needs of our employees.

1987
03:48:17.351 --> 03:48:17.478
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1988
03:48:18.064 --> 03:48:22.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Meet the legal requirements that we had to be able to bring us this contract.

1989
03:48:22.977 --> 03:48:23.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So thank you.

1990
03:48:25.399 --> 03:48:26.379
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, any other discussion?

1991
03:48:27.853 --> 03:48:28.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1992
03:48:28.340 --> 03:48:29.895
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is an emergency ordinance.

1993
03:48:29.959 --> 03:48:31.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It needs 9 votes to pass.

1994
03:48:31.726 --> 03:48:33.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, can you please call the roll?

1995
03:48:33.799 --> 03:48:34.072
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1996
03:48:34.459 --> 03:48:34.475
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1997
03:48:34.941 --> 03:48:35.166
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1998
03:48:35.665 --> 03:48:35.682
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1999
03:48:36.148 --> 03:48:36.470
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2000
03:48:36.792 --> 03:48:36.841
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2001
03:48:37.355 --> 03:48:37.662
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2002
03:48:37.920 --> 03:48:38.081
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2003
03:48:38.659 --> 03:48:39.031
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2004
03:48:39.288 --> 03:48:39.465
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2005
03:48:39.804 --> 03:48:40.076
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2006
03:48:40.656 --> 03:48:40.704
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2007
03:48:41.300 --> 03:48:41.686
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2008
03:48:41.896 --> 03:48:42.201
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

2009
03:48:42.700 --> 03:48:43.233
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

2010
03:48:45.329 --> 03:48:45.345
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

2011
03:48:46.135 --> 03:48:46.263
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2012
03:48:47.825 --> 03:48:47.906
<v Jeff Selby>Aye.

2013
03:48:48.325 --> 03:48:48.436
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Aye.

2014
03:48:49.918 --> 03:48:55.371
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with 10 yes votes, 1 no vote, and 1 absent.

2015
03:48:56.809 --> 03:48:57.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2016
03:48:58.853 --> 03:49:09.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any discussion on agenda item 9, which is the ratification of the bargaining agreement with the Portland Police Association representing emergency communications?

2017
03:49:13.399 --> 03:49:13.816
<v Michael Woods>Thanks.

2018
03:49:14.155 --> 03:49:20.774
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, the unionization of our 911 supervisors is a long overdue and powerful step to supporting the public safety ecosystem.

2019
03:49:20.838 --> 03:49:22.156
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm really proud to support this one.

2020
03:49:22.253 --> 03:49:24.831
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to thank BHR for doing this one the right way.

2021
03:49:26.615 --> 03:49:33.748
<v Sameer Kanal>I am really excited to strengthen the workforce, elevate professional standards, and invest in the people that make our emergency response systems function.

2022
03:49:34.263 --> 03:49:48.614
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that by gaining a formal voice in the working conditions of our first responders, conditions, training, and operational policies, ECSs help build a more resilient, equitable, and sustainable 911 system that better serves both the professionals within it and the communities that rely around on them around the clock.

2023
03:49:48.679 --> 03:49:51.851
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm particularly happy to see the shift differential component of that.

2024
03:49:51.898 --> 03:49:53.212
<v Sameer Kanal>So thank you for making that happen.

2025
03:49:53.261 --> 03:49:54.447
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll be proud to vote yes on this.

2026
03:49:54.591 --> 03:49:54.879
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

2027
03:49:55.648 --> 03:49:56.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2028
03:49:57.011 --> 03:49:59.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other discussion on this bargaining agreement?

2029
03:50:00.921 --> 03:50:01.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2030
03:50:01.577 --> 03:50:03.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Again, this is an emergency ordinance.

2031
03:50:03.324 --> 03:50:07.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It needs 9 votes to Aye.

2032
03:50:07.389 --> 03:50:07.649
<v Keelan McClymont>I especially like the coaching premium.

2033
03:50:07.649 --> 03:50:07.649
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2034
03:50:07.649 --> 03:50:07.649
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Smith?

2035
03:50:07.649 --> 03:50:07.649
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2036
03:50:07.649 --> 03:50:07.969
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Green?

2037
03:50:08.370 --> 03:50:09.370
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2038
03:50:09.370 --> 03:50:09.989
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Zimmerman?

2039
03:50:09.989 --> 03:50:10.409
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2040
03:50:10.409 --> 03:50:11.350
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Avalos?

2041
03:50:11.350 --> 03:50:11.670
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2042
03:50:11.670 --> 03:50:12.750
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Dunphy?

2043
03:50:12.750 --> 03:50:13.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2044
03:50:13.129 --> 03:50:13.930
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Green?

2045
03:50:13.930 --> 03:50:14.610
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2046
03:50:14.610 --> 03:50:14.610
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Zimmerman?

2047
03:50:14.610 --> 03:50:14.610
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2048
03:50:14.610 --> 03:50:15.309
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Morillo?

2049
03:50:18.219 --> 03:50:19.170
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2050
03:50:19.170 --> 03:50:19.889
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Novick?

2051
03:50:19.889 --> 03:50:22.149
<v Steve Novick>I especially like the coaching premium.

2052
03:50:22.149 --> 03:50:22.649
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2053
03:50:22.649 --> 03:50:23.809
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney?

2054
03:50:24.040 --> 03:50:24.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2055
03:50:24.989 --> 03:50:28.709
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.

2056
03:50:28.709 --> 03:50:29.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2057
03:50:30.761 --> 03:50:33.661
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call our final agenda item?

2058
03:50:36.806 --> 03:50:44.581
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 10, require city administrator to prepare a report with recommendations to reform the city design review process.

2059
03:50:45.229 --> 03:50:45.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, colleagues.

2060
03:50:45.985 --> 03:50:49.439
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a traditional out-of-a-committee agenda item today.

2061
03:50:49.600 --> 03:50:57.542
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's one of them, um, and we have Claire here to give us a committee staff summary from the Climate Resilience and Land Use Committee.

2062
03:50:57.638 --> 03:50:58.343
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please go right ahead.

2063
03:50:59.081 --> 03:51:00.763
<v Clare Adamsick>Good afternoon, Madam President and councilors.

2064
03:51:00.843 --> 03:51:04.914
<v Clare Adamsick>Clare Adamsick, council policy analyst and staff to the Climate Resilience and Land Use Committee.

2065
03:51:05.570 --> 03:51:15.969
<v Clare Adamsick>The resolution before you, document number 2025-446, was heard in committee, in the Climate Committee, on November 13th, where it was referred to council with the recommendation it be adopted.

2066
03:51:16.804 --> 03:51:39.576
<v Clare Adamsick>The resolution requires the city administrator to deliver a report to council on Portland's design review process, including but not limited to an overview of relevant land use laws, review types and related fees, procedures and timelines, an overview of where design guidelines apply to specific zoning designations in the city, and an analysis of the impacts of the design review process on commercial and residential development.

2067
03:51:40.379 --> 03:51:47.685
<v Clare Adamsick>The city administrator is also directed to prepare a set of recommendations outlining a legislative pathway to reform the city's design review process yes.

2068
03:51:48.102 --> 03:51:54.255
<v Clare Adamsick>Including potential changes to relevant chapters of Portland City Code in support of increasing residential and commercial development.

2069
03:51:54.993 --> 03:51:59.752
<v Clare Adamsick>The full impact statement on this item includes information on financial and budgetary impacts and analysis.

2070
03:52:01.243 --> 03:52:04.111
<v Clare Adamsick>2 People testified during the committee meeting on November 13th.

2071
03:52:04.608 --> 03:52:07.700
<v Clare Adamsick>No one submitted written testimony on this item prior to committee action.

2072
03:52:08.693 --> 03:52:14.072
<v Clare Adamsick>The general themes of the testimony the committee heard included examples of historic resources sorry.

2073
03:52:14.429 --> 03:52:19.602
<v Clare Adamsick>Historic resource review processes that impacted the total number of housing units on a particular project.

2074
03:52:20.409 --> 03:52:26.440
<v Clare Adamsick>A suggestion to include analysis of historic resource review as part of the design review analysis directed by the resolution.

2075
03:52:27.222 --> 03:52:32.045
<v Clare Adamsick>And finally, costs connected with discretionary review processes, including the cost of appeals.

2076
03:52:32.481 --> 03:52:33.906
<v Clare Adamsick>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

2077
03:52:34.165 --> 03:52:34.407
<v Lacey Sutton>Thank you.

2078
03:52:35.620 --> 03:52:37.934
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much, Claire.

2079
03:52:38.734 --> 03:52:43.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor This says Councilor Clark, but that's not right.

2080
03:52:43.340 --> 03:52:46.689
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, Councilor Murillo, I'm not sure who chaired this meeting.

2081
03:52:48.850 --> 03:52:49.382
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Help me out here.

2082
03:52:50.416 --> 03:52:52.778
<v Sameer Kanal>To be honest, I can't remember either.

2083
03:52:53.004 --> 03:52:56.301
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Would either of you like to add anything to our committee staff summary?

2084
03:52:57.030 --> 03:53:01.199
<v Angelita Morillo>You know, since I'm bringing this with Councilor Zimmerman, it's our first—.

2085
03:53:01.199 --> 03:53:01.875
<v Loretta Smith>Take it away.

2086
03:53:02.132 --> 03:53:03.179
<v Angelita Morillo>It's our next thing together.

2087
03:53:03.726 --> 03:53:11.054
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, uh, I don't think I have anything else to add to the Staff summaries, Claire did it very well in my opinion.

2088
03:53:11.326 --> 03:53:17.829
<v Angelita Morillo>But yeah, I think we've seen just to add a little bit of color is a lot of support from different housing groups that want us to build more housing in Portland.

2089
03:53:18.166 --> 03:53:29.727
<v Angelita Morillo>I think we all know that this is a big issue in our city that we don't have enough units, and we just don't have a variety of the building types and creative design that maybe we want to be seeing because of some of the things that encumber people.

2090
03:53:29.791 --> 03:53:32.328
<v Angelita Morillo>So I've seen a lot of support from different groups.

2091
03:53:32.641 --> 03:53:39.452
<v Angelita Morillo>Like Portland Neighbors Welcome, and I should have had a better list, I'm sorry.

2092
03:53:40.031 --> 03:53:57.611
<v Angelita Morillo>But Councilor Zimmerman will give an overview of the policy, and I think the main goal of this is really to just make sure that we're actually looking at the things that are inhibiting the progress as far as building housing in Portland and having the staff bring us a variety of options that we can— a menu of options for us to choose from.

2093
03:53:57.659 --> 03:53:57.836
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Mayor.

2094
03:53:58.082 --> 03:53:59.658
<v Angelita Morillo>About what we want to do moving forward.

2095
03:54:00.254 --> 03:54:02.394
<v Angelita Morillo>And with that, I will pass it to Councilor Zimmerman.

2096
03:54:02.891 --> 03:54:03.584
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

2097
03:54:05.145 --> 03:54:05.825
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thank you.

2098
03:54:06.947 --> 03:54:11.628
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Morillo hit it on the head, and I think that this is an interesting resolution.

2099
03:54:13.889 --> 03:54:26.558
<v Eric Zimmerman>The majority of places where this applies is in, is in our district, in District 4, but it has an impact on all Portlanders, and there are stakeholders from across the city who who have an opinion on design review.

2100
03:54:26.622 --> 03:54:29.655
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think during the campaign, a lot of us heard about design review.

2101
03:54:30.850 --> 03:54:40.306
<v Eric Zimmerman>One option that we could have done is to bring a set of values onto design review and force the function.

2102
03:54:40.629 --> 03:54:45.481
<v Eric Zimmerman>We could have set a moratorium, or we could have said this one aspect is good and this one aspect is bad.

2103
03:54:46.043 --> 03:54:47.538
<v Eric Zimmerman>We could have gone about that path.

2104
03:54:47.666 --> 03:54:49.209
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think there were some desires to do that.

2105
03:54:49.337 --> 03:55:08.331
<v Eric Zimmerman>But Councilor Morillo and I in our discussions about it, and given the nature of design review and the fact that there are many people who will cite a time when design review resulted in a positive outcome, have brought this to you and through committee as a desire to work with the administration for what can we tackle.

2106
03:55:08.586 --> 03:55:15.736
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we've set, I think, an aggressive but not an overly aggressive timeline so that we see a report in the reasonable future.

2107
03:55:15.800 --> 03:55:15.977
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

2108
03:55:16.843 --> 03:55:30.644
<v Eric Zimmerman>That we understand the levers that can be moved on design review, where the staff perspective is at on various pieces of design review, because small changes have happened over the years, but they're probably not well known right now.

2109
03:55:30.724 --> 03:55:39.212
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so from a development community standpoint, from a neighborhood activist standpoint, and from housing advocate standpoint, there is a lot of churn on this topic.

2110
03:55:39.790 --> 03:55:56.649
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so what we'll see here and what I, what I hope what I hope that Councilor Murillo's office and mine, as well as the city bureaus, can bring to you are eventually a set of low-hanging fruit, maybe higher-up fruit, and the things we're going to really have to work hard to get to fix.

2111
03:55:57.202 --> 03:55:58.227
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that's a good approach.

2112
03:55:59.069 --> 03:56:05.682
<v Eric Zimmerman>It also allows us that if we're not feeling the aggressiveness, we can still push.

2113
03:56:06.135 --> 03:56:07.930
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's push and pull in these types of things.

2114
03:56:07.994 --> 03:56:09.504
<v Eric Zimmerman>We want to see what the staff can bring us before we overreach.

2115
03:56:09.574 --> 03:56:09.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a good approach.

2116
03:56:10.095 --> 03:56:15.108
<v Eric Zimmerman>Lord on that, but we also want to make sure that the seriousness of reform is present.

2117
03:56:15.204 --> 03:56:16.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that's what we're getting here today.

2118
03:56:18.540 --> 03:56:34.459
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and I think this will invite advocates on both sides of this issue, even though I fall more squarely in the category of I'm probably a less of a design review should exist than there should more of it exist person.

2119
03:56:34.993 --> 03:56:48.980
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I know there are people who really value it, and I think we can Bring some of that in to be helpful without— I always say the time of stopping your neighbor's housing development from going forward because you don't like the color of the glass that they're using, I think that should be over.

2120
03:56:49.799 --> 03:57:00.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we get to win that message better if we do it in this collaborative, staff-supported way than if I just bring a bunch of Zimmerman values only and she brings a bunch of Murillo values only.

2121
03:57:00.429 --> 03:57:02.485
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's what we're hoping to have your support with today.

2122
03:57:03.622 --> 03:57:15.613
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the aggressiveness of the timeline I wanted to mention is intended to also be a 3rd rung to the SDC waiver that we are currently within, in 3 years.

2123
03:57:15.790 --> 03:57:25.842
<v Eric Zimmerman>If the design review remains a timeline crunch while SDCs are waived, we will have missed at least one of the major opportunities, I believe.

2124
03:57:26.002 --> 03:57:26.772
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you.

2125
03:57:27.093 --> 03:57:34.163
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate bringing this with Councilor Councilor Morillo and through Councilor Novick and Morillo's committee and the questions we got that day and the support.

2126
03:57:34.260 --> 03:57:36.801
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I appreciate the staff who supported us in the bureaus.

2127
03:57:37.220 --> 03:57:37.543
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's all.

2128
03:57:39.254 --> 03:57:40.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilors.

2129
03:57:40.384 --> 03:57:44.497
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, are there any technical questions before we move to public testimony?

2130
03:57:44.563 --> 03:57:47.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do actually have public testimony on this one.

2131
03:57:48.272 --> 03:57:50.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy, are you— further discussion later?

2132
03:57:51.191 --> 03:57:51.352
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2133
03:57:51.497 --> 03:57:52.094
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark?

2134
03:57:52.966 --> 03:57:53.578
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan?

2135
03:57:54.587 --> 03:57:55.138
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green?

2136
03:57:56.126 --> 03:57:56.272
<v Keelan McClymont>Later.

2137
03:57:56.628 --> 03:57:57.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, perfect.

2138
03:57:58.328 --> 03:58:00.191
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Claire, thank you so much for being here today.

2139
03:58:00.595 --> 03:58:03.478
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could we please call up members of the public who are here to testify?

2140
03:58:04.721 --> 03:58:05.841
<v Keelan McClymont>We have 2 people signed up.

2141
03:58:05.939 --> 03:58:08.583
<v Keelan McClymont>First up is Robert Pyle joining online.

2142
03:58:09.004 --> 03:58:09.847
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Mr. Pyle.

2143
03:58:09.913 --> 03:58:10.415
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

2144
03:58:12.030 --> 03:58:12.868
<v Robert Pyle>Good afternoon, Council.

2145
03:58:13.093 --> 03:58:14.528
<v Robert Pyle>Uh, my name is Robert Pyle.

2146
03:58:14.592 --> 03:58:16.333
<v Robert Pyle>I'm the principal of Oakleaf Redevelopment.

2147
03:58:16.816 --> 03:58:28.273
<v Robert Pyle>We build 100% solar-powered infill multifamily communities We support the resolution introduced by Councilor Zimmerman and Murillo and are grateful to them both for their leadership on this issue.

2148
03:58:29.129 --> 03:58:36.159
<v Robert Pyle>This is a key opportunity to help expedite entitlements and lower production costs, the 2 things we need to stimulate more housing supply.

2149
03:58:37.889 --> 03:58:46.230
<v Robert Pyle>I encourage you all to focus on item number 1 of the be it further resolved section, directing the city administrator to prepare, quote, options for temporary exemption on design review requirements.

2150
03:58:46.279 --> 03:58:46.825
<v Robert Pyle>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2151
03:58:48.174 --> 03:58:50.456
<v Robert Pyle>This should be the focus of this resolution and this conversation.

2152
03:58:51.211 --> 03:59:02.265
<v Robert Pyle>More comprehensive reforms are appropriate and should be pursued in parallel, but the immediate need, as Councilor Zimmerman noted, is to temporarily suspend these requirements, similar to the temporary STC exemptions.

2153
03:59:03.719 --> 03:59:12.795
<v Robert Pyle>And much like Councilor Zimmerman's polka dot jacket and pink shirt and Councilor Murillo's cherry sweater during the November 13th Climate and Land Use Committee meeting, our urban fabric benefits from a diversity of shapes.

2154
03:59:15.304 --> 03:59:19.943
<v Robert Pyle>But most importantly, design review adds a layer of time and cost for subjective benefit.

2155
03:59:20.860 --> 03:59:29.209
<v Robert Pyle>A temporary exemption of these regulations is a perfect example of something that can be done quickly and will have an immediate impact on the time and cost to deliver new units citywide.

2156
03:59:30.574 --> 03:59:37.093
<v Robert Pyle>I urge you to adopt the resolution and ultimately to temporarily suspend the application of design review while undergoing more comprehensive reform.

2157
03:59:37.638 --> 03:59:37.896
<v Robert Pyle>Thank you.

2158
03:59:37.959 --> 03:59:38.087
<v Eugene Jackson>Thank you.

2159
03:59:39.939 --> 03:59:40.891
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you very much.

2160
03:59:41.407 --> 03:59:43.879
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Lacey Sutton.

2161
03:59:47.963 --> 03:59:48.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

2162
03:59:49.182 --> 03:59:51.001
<v Lacey Sutton>Hi, hi again.

2163
03:59:52.185 --> 03:59:53.533
<v Lacey Sutton>My name is Lacey Sutton.

2164
03:59:54.350 --> 04:00:02.496
<v Lacey Sutton>Last week I testified about Cherry Blossom, which the city allowed Habitat for Humanity to build without meeting any condition of fire access and water supply.

2165
04:00:03.156 --> 04:00:13.007
<v Lacey Sutton>I'm here today to talk about how our problems begin with land During a 2016 review, a design commissioner asked, how are you getting away with that dead end for fire?

2166
04:00:13.858 --> 04:00:17.719
<v Lacey Sutton>Dead end roads over 300 feet require a turnaround for fire trucks.

2167
04:00:18.521 --> 04:00:27.126
<v Lacey Sutton>So the architect responded, there's pathways with the Portland Fire Department by using sprinklers with the townhomes, as well as certain street widths based on height.

2168
04:00:27.816 --> 04:00:37.046
<v Lacey Sutton>The commission went on to approve 29-foot-11-inch tall townhome Apartments, which require sprinklers on a 26-foot-wide road.

2169
04:00:38.091 --> 04:00:42.773
<v Lacey Sutton>Habitat purchased the property, but that is not what they wanted to build on it.

2170
04:00:43.015 --> 04:00:48.307
<v Lacey Sutton>They submitted plans for townhouses, which didn't require fire sprinklers under the residential code.

2171
04:00:48.888 --> 04:00:50.840
<v Lacey Sutton>This put the dead end back on the map.

2172
04:00:51.049 --> 04:00:58.869
<v Lacey Sutton>They also increased building height by 2 feet, triggering the need for aerial ladder trucks, but the road width was narrowed to below the 26-foot 6 feet they require.

2173
04:00:59.654 --> 04:01:13.802
<v Lacey Sutton>In 2019, the Fire Bureau flagged what they called significant issues in the plans, but after a last-minute phone call with the architect, they signed off on them just in time for Habitat to get a Type 2 land use review before their Type 3 approval expired.

2174
04:01:14.556 --> 04:01:22.022
<v Lacey Sutton>That review, which was performed by a single person, described only minor changes to the plans and stated explicitly that building height had not been changed.

2175
04:01:22.727 --> 04:01:26.750
<v Lacey Sutton>The Fire Bureau's land use response in 2020 is blank.

2176
04:01:28.610 --> 04:01:30.388
<v Lacey Sutton>Land use had conditions of approval.

2177
04:01:30.533 --> 04:01:36.170
<v Lacey Sutton>One was for vertical balcony railings, but Habitat installed horizontal bars which children climb like ladders.

2178
04:01:36.845 --> 04:01:47.729
<v Lacey Sutton>Under Title 33, it's 33.700.030, it is unlawful to violate a land use decision or conditions of a land use approval.

2179
04:01:48.703 --> 04:01:50.814
<v Lacey Sutton>But they did, and nothing happened.

2180
04:01:51.802 --> 04:01:56.691
<v Lacey Sutton>There are so many other issues at Cherry Blossom, too many to get into today.

2181
04:01:57.397 --> 04:02:01.756
<v Lacey Sutton>I emailed dozens of people at Portland Permitting and Development every day for months.

2182
04:02:01.997 --> 04:02:03.023
<v Lacey Sutton>They ignored me.

2183
04:02:03.905 --> 04:02:06.198
<v Lacey Sutton>In April, I met with Habitat CEO.

2184
04:02:06.613 --> 04:02:13.570
<v Lacey Sutton>I showed him the certificate of compliance with his signature on it stating any and all revisions to the plans had been disclosed.

2185
04:02:14.004 --> 04:02:15.575
<v Lacey Sutton>He promised me answers.

2186
04:02:16.072 --> 04:02:21.994
<v Lacey Sutton>The next day, he disinvited me and my neighbors from Habitat's fundraiser, and that was the last I heard from him.

2187
04:02:22.769 --> 04:02:28.272
<v Lacey Sutton>If I'm wrong, if they did everything right, why won't anyone explain it to me?

2188
04:02:30.114 --> 04:02:49.189
<v Lacey Sutton>I was looking at this proposal to reform the land use process and just feeling like these conversations are always about making it easier for affordable housing developers, making it easier for the people with the money and the influence and the power, but what about the people who live in these homes?

2189
04:02:50.192 --> 04:02:58.497
<v Lacey Sutton>If the city is going to make it easier to build, make it harder to cut corners and make builders fix it when they do.

2190
04:02:59.324 --> 04:02:59.664
<v Lacey Sutton>Thank you.

2191
04:03:00.764 --> 04:03:01.524
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

2192
04:03:01.655 --> 04:03:07.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I want to thank both of our testifiers today for their patience with what was a long morning.

2193
04:03:08.906 --> 04:03:09.653
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That completes testimony.

2194
04:03:09.729 --> 04:03:11.653
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you, Keelan.

2195
04:03:12.566 --> 04:03:14.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, that moves us into discussion.

2196
04:03:14.810 --> 04:03:15.549
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy.

2197
04:03:15.612 --> 04:03:16.334
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2198
04:03:16.912 --> 04:03:19.427
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilors Morillo and Zimmerman, thank you for bringing this forward.

2199
04:03:20.245 --> 04:03:30.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am trusting the process that you have created, which does sound very thoughtful and incorporates the best advice from the professionals.

2200
04:03:30.906 --> 04:03:34.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would've brought a resolution forward and just suspended it personally.

2201
04:03:36.456 --> 04:03:36.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2202
04:03:37.243 --> 04:03:51.256
<v Jamie Dunphy>As Robert, the testifier, said, I do think that there's an urgency that we need to think about tying a temporary suspension to the temporary suspension of SDCs and some deeper, longer-term reforms that are necessary.

2203
04:03:52.899 --> 04:03:57.495
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, I was taken aback earlier this year walking around downtown Seattle.

2204
04:03:57.914 --> 04:04:00.219
<v Jamie Dunphy>I had not walked around downtown Seattle for quite a while.

2205
04:04:02.426 --> 04:04:07.242
<v Jamie Dunphy>Truly impressive new buildings and new facades on old buildings that I had never seen.

2206
04:04:07.995 --> 04:04:09.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>Different materials, interesting designs.

2207
04:04:10.308 --> 04:04:27.513
<v Jamie Dunphy>And in the year that I have been here in this job, I've met with developers and designers who are saying that we have some of the world's best architects and designers and creatives living right here in the city and working everywhere else.

2208
04:04:27.706 --> 04:04:37.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>But here, and we are getting a lot of ugly three over ones or four over ones that are looking identical because they know that's what will get through design review.

2209
04:04:38.543 --> 04:04:42.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I don't blame the individuals on design review for approving things.

2210
04:04:43.136 --> 04:04:43.568
<v Jamie Dunphy>I get it.

2211
04:04:43.682 --> 04:04:44.806
<v Jamie Dunphy>I get that that's what it is.

2212
04:04:44.886 --> 04:04:49.477
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is incumbent on us to understand like what kind of a city do we want to live in?

2213
04:04:49.879 --> 04:04:53.299
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I personally want to live in a city that is filled with interesting, vibrant.

2214
04:04:53.716 --> 04:04:57.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>Buildings that are not dated by the time they are opening.

2215
04:04:58.604 --> 04:05:06.427
<v Jamie Dunphy>I really want to see the creative community of Portland contribute that creativity to the built environment here.

2216
04:05:06.636 --> 04:05:09.585
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so we can feel proud about this city as though it is moving forward.

2217
04:05:09.923 --> 04:05:11.558
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are not the city we were in the '80s.

2218
04:05:11.765 --> 04:05:13.721
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are not the city we were in the 1880s.

2219
04:05:13.834 --> 04:05:16.157
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we should look like it as these things advance.

2220
04:05:16.959 --> 04:05:27.254
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think back to, I believe it was 2018, When the design review denied the Jupiter II the cladding on the outside of their building.

2221
04:05:27.317 --> 04:05:30.862
<v Jamie Dunphy>They have an odd, vaguely amorphous shape to the outside.

2222
04:05:31.230 --> 04:05:32.611
<v Jamie Dunphy>Traditional siding wouldn't work.

2223
04:05:32.995 --> 04:05:35.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>They wanted to put asphalt roofing shingles on the side of the building.

2224
04:05:36.075 --> 04:05:37.117
<v Jamie Dunphy>Design review said no.

2225
04:05:37.245 --> 04:05:43.003
<v Jamie Dunphy>And after multiple months and hundreds of thousands of dollars of extra time, the city council unanimously approved it.

2226
04:05:43.579 --> 04:05:44.942
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to move us in that direction.

2227
04:05:45.039 --> 04:05:55.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want us to be able to I understand that there are historic consistency issues in particularly historic neighborhoods.

2228
04:05:55.837 --> 04:06:04.004
<v Jamie Dunphy>I understand we don't want to put a 20-story building in the middle of single-story developments as it is, or, you know, all these other reasons.

2229
04:06:04.389 --> 04:06:08.695
<v Jamie Dunphy>But we've got to be interesting and vibrant and attracting new kind of attention.

2230
04:06:09.129 --> 04:06:11.394
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that that is another part of why we are not seeing any cranes in the sky.

2231
04:06:11.442 --> 04:06:11.827
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that's a great point.

2232
04:06:12.609 --> 04:06:17.983
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that if somebody really wanted to build here, they'd find a way, but they are taking their talents elsewhere.

2233
04:06:18.047 --> 04:06:21.623
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so I'm really gonna be enthusiastic to support this.

2234
04:06:22.217 --> 04:06:24.832
<v Jamie Dunphy>I do hope this comes back aggressively.

2235
04:06:25.088 --> 04:06:27.317
<v Jamie Dunphy>And thank you both for your leadership on this.

2236
04:06:28.248 --> 04:06:29.259
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2237
04:06:29.338 --> 04:06:30.397
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

2238
04:06:31.424 --> 04:06:32.338
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor President.

2239
04:06:32.965 --> 04:06:34.376
<v Olivia Clark>Kudos to my colleagues.

2240
04:06:34.568 --> 04:06:35.884
<v Olivia Clark>I'm really happy to see this.

2241
04:06:36.718 --> 04:06:39.588
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know if anybody saw the New York Times article on Beverly Hills.

2242
04:06:39.670 --> 04:06:47.941
<v Olivia Clark>Hills, um, and the development going on in Beverly Hills and the developers just, um, thumbing their nose at the city was pretty interesting.

2243
04:06:48.278 --> 04:06:54.959
<v Olivia Clark>I think there's some lessons there for us, um, not about design review necessarily, but, um, this is very interesting article.

2244
04:06:55.585 --> 04:06:57.466
<v Olivia Clark>Um, and I know what you're talking about, Councilor Dunphy.

2245
04:06:57.530 --> 04:07:04.034
<v Olivia Clark>It's sort of like they're not quite Soviet style, you know, but, but sort of, um, just all kind of looking alike.

2246
04:07:04.114 --> 04:07:04.371
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

2247
04:07:04.902 --> 04:07:12.547
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I have— my question is Is the, the results of this, are they going to come back to your committee, Councilor Novick, in 120 days?

2248
04:07:12.659 --> 04:07:13.853
<v Olivia Clark>Is it your committee they're going to?

2249
04:07:15.496 --> 04:07:17.542
<v Steve Novick>I confess, I confess I forget.

2250
04:07:17.608 --> 04:07:22.893
<v Steve Novick>Was it to the full council or is it to our committee or to housing?

2251
04:07:22.989 --> 04:07:23.699
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know what—.

2252
04:07:23.715 --> 04:07:24.875
<v Raymond C. Lee III>To council.

2253
04:07:28.173 --> 04:07:41.211
<v Eric Zimmerman>If I, as the sponsor of it, I think, I think I would be comfortable whichever place it went, but ultimately the way it's written, uh, now for there be it resolved, city administrator shall deliver a report to council.

2254
04:07:42.462 --> 04:07:45.014
<v Olivia Clark>Well, it seems like it should go to a committee.

2255
04:07:45.304 --> 04:07:46.025
<v Eric Zimmerman>It makes a lot of sense to me.

2256
04:07:46.090 --> 04:07:50.680
<v Olivia Clark>Take their recommendations and turn them into whether ordinances or resolutions.

2257
04:07:50.744 --> 04:08:12.336
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe the report should come to full council so we can all see it, and from that report somebody could put together an ordinance or resolution that would then go I assume that once we get that report, the carriers of this original resolution would likely move in that direction and we would get that to the correct committee at that time.

2258
04:08:13.299 --> 04:08:13.683
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

2259
04:08:14.084 --> 04:08:15.399
<v Olivia Clark>I just wanna make sure there's action.

2260
04:08:16.235 --> 04:08:24.045
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, so yeah, 120 days from the date that it's passed, which would be after today if it does get passed, it would go back to full council.

2261
04:08:24.110 --> 04:08:34.681
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think, I don't feel super strongly about it, but I think it's important for it to go to full council Because all of you have different needs and opinions in your districts and different constituencies that you're answering to.

2262
04:08:35.197 --> 04:08:41.180
<v Angelita Morillo>And my guess is that after you hear the report, maybe you'll come with amendments or things that you want to work on at the committee.

2263
04:08:41.677 --> 04:08:45.100
<v Angelita Morillo>And that can only happen if everybody gets to have the same briefing at the same time.

2264
04:08:45.212 --> 04:08:52.424
<v Angelita Morillo>So that's what I would push for so that then folks could come to committee and testify and do all the other sorts of committee things that we want to happen.

2265
04:08:52.617 --> 04:08:52.954
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Thanks.

2266
04:08:57.744 --> 04:08:58.306
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Anything further?

2267
04:08:58.852 --> 04:08:59.478
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

2268
04:08:59.655 --> 04:09:01.197
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, uh, thank you, Madam President.

2269
04:09:01.438 --> 04:09:04.876
<v Dan Ryan>On that topic, I, I think it could be both, so just thought I'd say that.

2270
04:09:05.358 --> 04:09:10.385
<v Dan Ryan>Um, let's see, I just want to thank you, councilors, and what a dynamic duo you are.

2271
04:09:11.300 --> 04:09:15.942
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I kind of missed the— you had polka dots, you had— was it strawberries or raspberries?

2272
04:09:16.296 --> 04:09:20.280
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, let me add this into my official briefing from the committee because I failed to do this.

2273
04:09:21.192 --> 04:09:25.888
<v Angelita Morillo>We did not plan to wear exciting outfits that day, but I mean, I have cheetah print behind me, so you know how it is.

2274
04:09:26.801 --> 04:09:35.086
<v Angelita Morillo>But Zimmerman wore a very exciting polka dot outfit that day, and I wore a cherry sweater, and we were talking about how we don't want to have boring buildings in Portland, Oregon.

2275
04:09:35.375 --> 04:09:37.345
<v Angelita Morillo>We want to keep Portland weird, not Portland beige.

2276
04:09:37.939 --> 04:09:43.420
<v Angelita Morillo>Even though we have a lot of millennials on council and there's a millennial gray thing going on, we can't have that in our city.

2277
04:09:43.468 --> 04:09:44.444
<v Angelita Morillo>We got to keep Portland weird.

2278
04:09:44.510 --> 04:09:45.534
<v Angelita Morillo>So we had our outfits.

2279
04:09:45.583 --> 04:09:45.694
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2280
04:09:46.852 --> 04:09:48.408
<v Angelita Morillo>Sorry, shots fired at the millennials.

2281
04:09:48.987 --> 04:09:50.480
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm a Zillennial, so I can say that.

2282
04:09:51.493 --> 04:10:02.655
<v Angelita Morillo>But yeah, I think just in the spirit of wanting to make sure that we have interesting and creative people invited to our city to create new pieces of art, including our buildings, that was something we laughed about a little bit.

2283
04:10:03.683 --> 04:10:07.569
<v Dan Ryan>Well, this baby and the baby boomer really likes the leopard getup you brought today.

2284
04:10:07.729 --> 04:10:08.436
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

2285
04:10:09.480 --> 04:10:16.915
<v Dan Ryan>This resolution will help our city creatively promote housing Housing production and development in general, and I plan to support this resolution like I did in the committee.

2286
04:10:17.510 --> 04:10:27.014
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to remind us at the committee meeting we had a few testifiers bring up the Historic Landmark Commission's authority and their de facto override of zoning processes in the review process.

2287
04:10:27.625 --> 04:10:35.573
<v Dan Ryan>I just would love to bring that up again for BPS and PP&D to include in their scope of review and suggestions for updates.

2288
04:10:35.670 --> 04:10:37.210
<v Dan Ryan>I want to make sure I daylighted that at council.

2289
04:10:37.259 --> 04:10:37.355
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

2290
04:10:37.484 --> 04:10:37.756
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

2291
04:10:38.077 --> 04:10:39.057
<v Dan Ryan>I'll be voting aye.

2292
04:10:40.308 --> 04:10:40.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2293
04:10:41.433 --> 04:10:44.995
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, would you like to make an argument for Millennial Gray?

2294
04:10:46.006 --> 04:10:48.221
<v Mitch Green>I, I don't want to make an argu— thank you, Madam President.

2295
04:10:48.270 --> 04:11:03.870
<v Mitch Green>I don't want to make an argument for Millennial Gray, but as a person over here taking knives and bullets as a millennial, uh, I did— I do want to advocate that while I actually prefer the sort of brutalist aesthetic and the mid-century modern aesthetic, uh, I don't think I should impose I think that's right.

2296
04:11:03.918 --> 04:11:12.219
<v Mitch Green>I don't think that the mayor should impose that or any sort of institution should impose that on the rest of the city, which is why I'm really grateful that the two of you are working together to bring this forward.

2297
04:11:12.975 --> 04:11:22.174
<v Mitch Green>You know, I've always kind of wondered what's the right balance in moving policy forward between sort of a resolution approach or a codification approach.

2298
04:11:22.833 --> 04:11:26.381
<v Mitch Green>And I think that this strikes that balance for me.

2299
04:11:26.461 --> 04:11:35.389
<v Mitch Green>And what I needed to hear, I heard from Councilor Zimmerman, was that it preserves the optionality to say, you know, we're not satisfied with the pace of this work.

2300
04:11:35.438 --> 04:11:38.407
<v Mitch Green>We're going to push you a little bit.

2301
04:11:38.728 --> 04:11:41.121
<v Mitch Green>Both of you have sharp enough elbows that I know that you'll get it done.

2302
04:11:41.860 --> 04:11:50.674
<v Mitch Green>And I also, you know, I met with a group of developers recently that were just really trying to impress upon me how difficult it is to build in this city.

2303
04:11:50.771 --> 04:11:52.231
<v Mitch Green>And I was like, no, I get it.

2304
04:11:52.457 --> 04:12:01.817
<v Mitch Green>And I think you should understand that you probably have the most pro-housing and pro-build council that you— that we've had in a long time.

2305
04:12:02.573 --> 04:12:31.236
<v Mitch Green>And despite some of the other more sort of loud points of disagreement, and we're oftentimes sort of presented as a divided council, you're going to see opportunities like this where people kind of come together even though they've got some pretty big ideological differences elsewhere to say this is some urgent work that needs be done because we're going to elevate the needs of working-class renters who need a place to live at a cost we can afford above some sort of, um, bygone aesthetic.

2306
04:12:31.959 --> 04:12:37.083
<v Mitch Green>And so for that reason, I'm strongly supportive of this, and I'm really grateful for you guys bringing it forward.

2307
04:12:37.902 --> 04:12:40.471
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2308
04:12:40.648 --> 04:12:41.676
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

2309
04:12:42.977 --> 04:12:49.949
<v Steve Novick>First of all, um, from my perspective, the Cold War looks pretty good right now, so the assumption that Soviet silos is an insult is something I take Objection to.

2310
04:12:50.832 --> 04:13:01.558
<v Steve Novick>Um, more seriously, I need to ask a question which I should have asked in committee, which is, did the sponsors talk to folks from the Design Commission about this before bringing it forward?

2311
04:13:04.311 --> 04:13:04.810
<v Eric Zimmerman>I did not.

2312
04:13:05.132 --> 04:13:26.171
<v Eric Zimmerman>And one of the intents and one of the things I spoke to was— and actually, I think I've texted our, our, our, um, DCAs— I want to be invited to the design review meeting to understand the work as it is happening, because with all the fervor around this topic, I didn't feel like I have been able to examine how does that work happen.

2313
04:13:26.907 --> 04:13:31.028
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then part of this is to include them in that work.

2314
04:13:31.092 --> 04:13:31.203
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

2315
04:13:31.637 --> 04:13:45.740
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that was a big reason for me why I didn't think an ordinance at this time or a set of recommendations at this time would've been appropriate, because I consider that part of the the stakeholder group that has to be engaged on this, and that's what this will do.

2316
04:13:47.579 --> 04:13:59.612
<v Steve Novick>Okay, I just want to— I understand that, but I just— a couple days ago, and to be honest, I didn't read the whole thing until now, my office got an email from a member of the Design Commission.

2317
04:14:00.049 --> 04:14:09.113
<v Steve Novick>And I think that because they're the volunteers that, you know, have been appointed to think about this stuff, I think that I want to just sort of give a chance for her voice to be heard.

2318
04:14:10.680 --> 04:14:28.298
<v Steve Novick>She says that in the past 7 years, per code, the commission has presented the State of the City Design Report to the City Council, which has given the commission an opportunity to have a conversation with council members about development in the city and develop a better understanding of the council issues related to development in general and the design review process in particular.

2319
04:14:28.847 --> 04:14:35.950
<v Steve Novick>The commission submitted its 2024 written report to the current city council members last April, as usual and requested a date for formal presentation.

2320
04:14:36.448 --> 04:14:38.101
<v Steve Novick>The commission has never received a response.

2321
04:14:38.791 --> 04:14:54.414
<v Steve Novick>The commission was recently informed that last month the Climate Resilience and Land Use Committee discussed the impact of the design review— of design review on housing and commercial development in Portland and is considering a resolution to require the city administrator to prepare a report with recommendations to reform the city's design review process.

2322
04:14:55.488 --> 04:14:58.908
<v Steve Novick>It is unfortunate that no one from the Design Commission was invited to participate in that meeting.

2323
04:14:59.262 --> 04:15:02.679
<v Steve Novick>Which may have addressed several concerns and questions expressed by a few committee members.

2324
04:15:02.968 --> 04:15:21.898
<v Steve Novick>I'm writing to ask if you, as the co-chair of this committee, are willing to invite the commission to your next meeting so that we can present our annual report, which fully explains why design review matters, how it allows the developers to go around the strict standards written in the code, and a myriad of recent process improvements that have been made in the past couple of years to expedite review and permitting.

2325
04:15:21.947 --> 04:15:22.188
<v Steve Novick>Mm-hmm.

2326
04:15:22.909 --> 04:15:25.653
<v Steve Novick>And I read that just to make Councilor Smith.

2327
04:15:26.118 --> 04:15:41.615
<v Steve Novick>I mean, I have the same sort of philosophical outlook on barriers to building new housing that some of my colleagues have expressed, but I do think that we should be careful to make sure that the volunteers who are serving on our boards and commissions should feel heard.

2328
04:15:42.417 --> 04:15:57.183
<v Steve Novick>So again, and obviously it didn't even occur to me to ask this question when you brought this forward, but I think that probably behooves us to sort of remember There's people whose job, you know, whose volunteer job it is to look at this stuff and to bring them in on the front end.

2329
04:15:57.231 --> 04:16:02.404
<v Steve Novick>I mean, I think that the administrator will consult with the members of the Design Review Commission in doing this report.

2330
04:16:03.431 --> 04:16:13.164
<v Steve Novick>I hope, Councilor Murillo, that even if not your next meeting, we can find time in the Climate Resilience and Land Use Committee to hear from members of the commission before the full council gets this report.

2331
04:16:13.244 --> 04:16:15.845
<v Steve Novick>So we're sort of— give additional information to us.

2332
04:16:16.856 --> 04:16:19.170
<v Steve Novick>So I realize there was no No ill intent here.

2333
04:16:19.235 --> 04:16:26.843
<v Steve Novick>And again, I intend to vote yes, but I just think it's a reminder to us when we present anything, it's like, oh wait, is there a board or commission that deals with this?

2334
04:16:27.069 --> 04:16:31.427
<v Steve Novick>And should maybe we talk to them first so they don't feel disrespected and so we hear their perspective?

2335
04:16:33.788 --> 04:16:34.458
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2336
04:16:34.604 --> 04:16:35.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate that.

2337
04:16:39.680 --> 04:16:43.335
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I wanna thank my colleagues for not just suspending design review.

2338
04:16:43.479 --> 04:16:43.623
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2339
04:16:43.672 --> 04:16:43.769
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2340
04:16:43.849 --> 04:16:55.137
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And for actually bringing this forward and having a discussion about it, because as you noted, there are different values not only around this dais but across the city around what design of our city should look like.

2341
04:16:55.859 --> 04:17:11.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while this may seem like a technical change that will allow us to build more housing more quickly, it is also a critical piece in the conversation about what the future of our city looks like, feels like, and how that affects life in our city.

2342
04:17:11.409 --> 04:17:22.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that's a conversation that matters a lot to me and that I think is a big part of our jobs, actually, as city councilors, to help to guide our city forward into its future.

2343
04:17:23.842 --> 04:17:33.968
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want us to be able to have a comprehensive discussion about design review that moves beyond a binary choice between maintaining the status quo and abolishing the system completely.

2344
04:17:34.265 --> 04:17:35.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what you've brought Councilmember Herbold.

2345
04:17:35.280 --> 04:17:35.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

2346
04:17:35.280 --> 04:17:35.459
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate the opportunity to speak about this today.

2347
04:17:35.459 --> 04:17:36.579
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Gives us that opportunity.

2348
04:17:37.459 --> 04:17:55.540
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to make sure that as we get the report back from the administration, we have the opportunity to explore multiple reforms and alternatives, to look at targeted adjustments that support our housing supply and also what our city looks and feels like.

2349
04:17:55.540 --> 04:18:01.379
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm hoping that the recommendations, plural, part of this is taken seriously by staff as they move forward.

2350
04:18:01.422 --> 04:18:14.693
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm hoping that what we're brought is not just some choices that talk about fixes to the system, but choices that lay out impacts to the system.

2351
04:18:15.432 --> 04:18:20.416
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What would the result be of a change on what the future of our city looks like?

2352
04:18:20.576 --> 04:18:28.158
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What would a result be of a change not just on how quickly somebody moves through the process, but what might or might not be allowed?

2353
04:18:28.576 --> 04:18:34.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And how it might incentivize or disincentivize people from building the same thing over and over again.

2354
04:18:35.416 --> 04:18:49.466
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think the goal here is to have a more streamlined process, an interesting city, and a city that also, to Councilor Dunphy's point, is building things that are very interesting but also in the right place for what they are.

2355
04:18:50.494 --> 04:18:53.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think we can have a city that does all of those things.

2356
04:18:53.224 --> 04:18:58.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope that we Councilor Donnie Oliveira brought a report that helps to guide us in that discussion as we move forward.

2357
04:19:00.662 --> 04:19:01.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

2358
04:19:04.121 --> 04:19:05.040
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

2359
04:19:05.716 --> 04:19:06.987
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm broadly supportive of this.

2360
04:19:07.969 --> 04:19:11.012
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to Councilors Morillo and Zimmerman for bringing it forward.

2361
04:19:11.076 --> 04:19:24.425
<v Sameer Kanal>The only thing I wanted to add is that Councilor Dunphy in committee mentioned wanting to explore a carve-out for commercial to residential conversions, and I just wanted to express my support for that to the staff that might be hearing this and, and looking at legislative intent as you implement it.

2362
04:19:24.668 --> 04:19:24.895
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2363
04:19:26.528 --> 04:19:27.093
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2364
04:19:27.174 --> 04:19:27.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

2365
04:19:30.477 --> 04:19:30.783
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

2366
04:19:31.024 --> 04:19:35.504
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, these are all— I appreciate those who are supportive and the questions that we've gotten.

2367
04:19:36.020 --> 04:19:52.970
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, one of the things that the staff mentioned when we presented this at the committee was the difference between— or the sometimes where we confuse design with, with zoning, and what can go up in a certain property or a certain piece of land is related to zoning.

2368
04:19:53.628 --> 04:19:56.015
<v Eric Zimmerman>What it looks like when it goes up is the design.

2369
04:19:56.352 --> 04:20:09.028
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I say that because this is not about putting a 25-foot tower in the residential neighborhoods of Eastmoreland or Irvington or 148th and Stark.

2370
04:20:10.389 --> 04:20:21.899
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is about I think what I'm saying is I'm serious about saying when a 25-foot tower wants to go in downtown Portland, where there are already many, that we need to be serious about what kind of design review we actually apply to them.

2371
04:20:22.591 --> 04:20:27.936
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I shared with folks is I don't think we live in a Portland where the Koin Tower could ever be built again.

2372
04:20:28.835 --> 04:20:35.242
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think we live in a Portland where the Wells Fargo Tower next to us could ever be built again.

2373
04:20:35.354 --> 04:20:36.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>Those are vastly different buildings.

2374
04:20:36.478 --> 04:20:37.264
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a different issue.

2375
04:20:37.361 --> 04:20:40.295
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aesthetically pleasing or not pleasing buildings.

2376
04:20:40.888 --> 04:20:49.239
<v Eric Zimmerman>But the point is, is that our system has said there is about 1 or 2 types that get through, and if you want to be successful with your timeline, you conform to that.

2377
04:20:50.185 --> 04:20:58.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I offer those as 2 unique buildings in our community that meet people's needs and desires differently, and that is the point.

2378
04:20:59.083 --> 04:21:01.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uncontroversial is not the goal here.

2379
04:21:02.513 --> 04:21:07.970
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uncontroversial gets you Slabtown, where all but 3 buildings are the same color.

2380
04:21:08.308 --> 04:21:10.235
<v Eric Zimmerman>They are almost all the same height.

2381
04:21:11.359 --> 04:21:16.720
<v Eric Zimmerman>We like controversy if it's about, I like red or I don't like red, I like blue or I don't like blue.

2382
04:21:17.218 --> 04:21:19.434
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's not— we're not trying to solve for the most boring.

2383
04:21:19.708 --> 04:21:25.263
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I say that because it's not about neighborhood conformity, and that is important.

2384
04:21:25.953 --> 04:21:35.995
<v Eric Zimmerman>I also am— I want to highlight the Councilor Novick, I think your question, your concern is very well taken, and I really appreciate it bringing it up.

2385
04:21:37.826 --> 04:21:54.104
<v Eric Zimmerman>And as the person sponsoring this who probably has more of my residents are the members of our community who are skeptical of reforming design review, this is a risky proposition.

2386
04:21:54.379 --> 04:22:10.360
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it is that, and yet I say it because it is still I have made an assessment that design review is slowing not just commercial but also residential, and I'm willing to have deep conversations with people who will be upset with me about it in order to further that cause.

2387
04:22:11.099 --> 04:22:16.510
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'll just reiterate, zoning is different than design.

2388
04:22:16.815 --> 04:22:19.626
<v Eric Zimmerman>Neighborhood conformity, I don't believe that this puts that at risk.

2389
04:22:19.931 --> 04:22:23.575
<v Eric Zimmerman>And where those concerns exist, this resolution allows us to move forward with the zoning.

2390
04:22:23.639 --> 04:22:23.913
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

2391
04:22:24.041 --> 04:22:28.634
<v Eric Zimmerman>That process to be unearthed and discovered before we bring back a set of recommendations.

2392
04:22:28.811 --> 04:22:29.072
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

2393
04:22:30.921 --> 04:22:31.503
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2394
04:22:31.584 --> 04:22:32.372
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Morillo.

2395
04:22:34.064 --> 04:22:35.609
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

2396
04:22:35.995 --> 04:22:44.023
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, I agree with everything Councilor Zimmerman laid out, and I just want to say that I never think that there's any harm in us gathering more information as councilors.

2397
04:22:44.458 --> 04:22:46.322
<v Angelita Morillo>That is all that this resolution is asking for.

2398
04:22:46.370 --> 04:22:54.844
<v Angelita Morillo>It's asking for the experts to go back, look at the design review process and give us a menu of options about what it would look like to change design review.

2399
04:22:55.389 --> 04:23:07.617
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't believe that design review touches on safety in building, and I know that's something that someone who testified brought up, and I want to make sure that that's not something that I would ever want to cut back on because I think that's incredibly important.

2400
04:23:08.353 --> 04:23:12.681
<v Angelita Morillo>This is about the design of buildings from a more artistic perspective, I would say.

2401
04:23:13.802 --> 04:23:19.597
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think that as council, Well, I tend to be someone who wants to push policy a lot faster.

2402
04:23:19.679 --> 04:23:20.899
<v Angelita Morillo>I really hate bureaucracy.

2403
04:23:20.948 --> 04:23:21.896
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't know if you've noticed that.

2404
04:23:22.489 --> 04:23:33.093
<v Angelita Morillo>But I think that Councilor Zimmerman and I worked together and we brought forward a proposal that will give us time to get that research, that will give us time to talk to all the experts, including the Design Review Committee.

2405
04:23:33.318 --> 04:23:45.809
<v Angelita Morillo>And I look forward to seeing what my colleagues have to say about that when we bring it back to full council, because we really do have to change the way that we build in Portland, and this is our opportunity to get that information so that we can make those tough choices.

2406
04:23:45.941 --> 04:23:47.034
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you so much, everyone.

2407
04:23:48.652 --> 04:23:49.198
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2408
04:23:49.375 --> 04:23:50.065
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

2409
04:23:51.929 --> 04:23:52.893
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

2410
04:23:52.988 --> 04:23:55.432
<v Loretta Smith>I want to thank the sponsors of this.

2411
04:23:56.121 --> 04:24:07.269
<v Loretta Smith>This feels really good, and it feels like a positive step to encourage more development by providing recommendations for council to reduce policy barriers in accordance with, with our goals.

2412
04:24:08.229 --> 04:24:18.460
<v Loretta Smith>And it also speaks to the intent of balancing the recommendations of outgoing and ingoing city administrators.

2413
04:24:20.091 --> 04:24:23.075
<v Loretta Smith>That is probably going to need a little bit more clarity.

2414
04:24:24.286 --> 04:24:30.577
<v Loretta Smith>And I have a question in terms of the economic opportunities analysis.

2415
04:24:31.985 --> 04:24:42.623
<v Loretta Smith>Will these recommendations be useful in in making sure that they're considered and how they're sequenced at all?

2416
04:24:44.272 --> 04:24:44.709
<v Jeff Selby>I sure hope so.

2417
04:24:44.838 --> 04:24:45.227
<v Olivia Clark>Either one of you.

2418
04:24:45.485 --> 04:24:46.709
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's the intent.

2419
04:24:46.838 --> 04:24:47.112
<v Eric Zimmerman>I hope so.

2420
04:24:47.177 --> 04:24:47.323
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

2421
04:24:47.403 --> 04:24:52.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's an area that we feel like there's a big question mark and we'd like to answer the question mark.

2422
04:24:53.069 --> 04:24:54.527
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay, perfect.

2423
04:24:55.110 --> 04:24:56.308
<v Loretta Smith>Well, thank you for bringing this forward.

2424
04:24:57.960 --> 04:24:58.762
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2425
04:25:01.198 --> 04:25:07.103
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, before we move to a vote, I just want to take a minute to address the testifier who brought up concerns with our community.

2426
04:25:07.152 --> 04:25:14.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ms. Sutton, I know that you've been here twice now, and it's sometimes difficult to give us information and not really know what's happening with it.

2427
04:25:15.577 --> 04:25:21.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that some of our colleagues who represent District 1 have been working with you, or members of their teams have.

2428
04:25:22.639 --> 04:25:24.132
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We hear your concerns.

2429
04:25:25.368 --> 04:25:26.843
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I personally, Councilor Wilson.

2430
04:25:26.924 --> 04:25:27.148
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

2431
04:25:27.212 --> 04:25:39.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I take very seriously the fact that there are safety concerns that have been raised, and I think it's important to make sure that we have a culture in our city of doing what is right in the long term, even if it's hard in the short term.

2432
04:25:39.861 --> 04:25:51.916
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't have the background to know exactly what happened here and what occurred, but I do want to make sure that you know that we'll check in with our colleagues in the district who have been working with you.

2433
04:25:52.126 --> 04:25:59.387
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And, uh, make sure that they have everything they need to continue to, to work with you and your, um, neighbors.

2434
04:26:01.443 --> 04:26:03.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any other discussion before we move to a vote?

2435
04:26:06.702 --> 04:26:07.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2436
04:26:07.490 --> 04:26:08.278
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan.

2437
04:26:09.755 --> 04:26:10.157
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

2438
04:26:10.382 --> 04:26:10.431
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2439
04:26:11.201 --> 04:26:11.411
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

2440
04:26:11.909 --> 04:26:12.038
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2441
04:26:12.728 --> 04:26:13.082
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

2442
04:26:13.435 --> 04:26:13.484
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2443
04:26:14.158 --> 04:26:14.704
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

2444
04:26:14.881 --> 04:26:15.058
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2445
04:26:15.670 --> 04:26:15.834
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

2446
04:26:16.180 --> 04:26:16.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2447
04:26:16.772 --> 04:26:17.152
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

2448
04:26:17.745 --> 04:26:17.795
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2449
04:26:18.486 --> 04:26:18.816
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

2450
04:26:19.013 --> 04:26:19.064
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2451
04:26:19.894 --> 04:26:19.926
<v Lacey Sutton>Aye.

2452
04:26:20.396 --> 04:26:20.427
<v Eugene Jackson>Aye.

2453
04:26:21.448 --> 04:26:23.974
<v Raymond C. Lee III>Oh, aye.

2454
04:26:24.183 --> 04:26:24.929
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm sorry.

2455
04:26:25.350 --> 04:26:25.447
<v Jeff Selby>Aye.

2456
04:26:26.143 --> 04:26:26.548
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

2457
04:26:26.854 --> 04:26:26.904
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2458
04:26:27.729 --> 04:26:27.971
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

2459
04:26:28.474 --> 04:26:28.652
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2460
04:26:29.541 --> 04:26:33.377
<v Keelan McClymont>The resolution is adopted with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.

2461
04:26:34.770 --> 04:26:35.661
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, colleagues.

2462
04:26:35.920 --> 04:26:41.772
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I appreciate the added time for us to run a little bit into the afternoon today to get through our agenda.

2463
04:26:42.404 --> 04:26:46.582
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we have a busy day tomorrow, so carrying things over Thank you.

2464
04:26:46.646 --> 04:26:47.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

2465
04:26:47.208 --> 04:26:48.524
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate the opportunity to be here.

2466
04:26:48.588 --> 04:26:49.504
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm glad we made it.

2467
04:26:50.179 --> 04:26:52.716
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And with that, I will adjourn our meeting.

