WEBVTT

1
00:09:16.422 --> 00:09:17.115
<v Keith Wilson>Good morning.

2
00:09:17.212 --> 00:09:20.019
<v Keith Wilson>I am going to call to order today's Portland City Council meeting.

3
00:09:20.197 --> 00:09:24.763
<v Keith Wilson>It is Wednesday, October 29th at 9:34 AM.

4
00:09:25.441 --> 00:09:26.929
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

5
00:09:28.682 --> 00:09:33.889
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, sorry, sorry, just a moment.

6
00:09:34.052 --> 00:09:35.695
<v Olivia Clark>That's okay.

7
00:09:35.841 --> 00:09:37.403
<v Keelan McClymont>Clerk.

8
00:09:42.765 --> 00:09:42.975
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

9
00:09:43.328 --> 00:09:43.457
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

10
00:09:44.873 --> 00:09:45.193
<v Mitch Green>Present.

11
00:09:45.740 --> 00:09:46.174
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

12
00:09:46.464 --> 00:09:46.673
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

13
00:09:47.027 --> 00:09:47.332
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

14
00:09:47.927 --> 00:09:48.378
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

15
00:09:48.650 --> 00:09:48.764
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

16
00:09:49.214 --> 00:09:49.567
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

17
00:09:50.789 --> 00:09:51.371
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

18
00:09:51.548 --> 00:09:51.841
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

19
00:09:52.099 --> 00:09:52.196
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

20
00:09:52.664 --> 00:09:53.296
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

21
00:09:54.541 --> 00:09:55.091
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo.

22
00:09:55.980 --> 00:09:56.254
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

23
00:09:57.791 --> 00:09:58.147
<v Keith Wilson>Sorry.

24
00:09:58.745 --> 00:10:00.168
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Koyama Lane is online.

25
00:10:00.350 --> 00:10:01.044
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, thank you.

26
00:10:01.577 --> 00:10:02.484
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Councilor.

27
00:10:02.969 --> 00:10:03.453
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

28
00:10:03.582 --> 00:10:03.808
<v Steve Novick>Here.

29
00:10:04.730 --> 00:10:05.119
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

30
00:10:05.394 --> 00:10:05.732
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

31
00:10:07.721 --> 00:10:09.952
<v Keith Wilson>And could we please get the rules of order into quorum?

32
00:10:14.192 --> 00:10:15.886
<v Keelan McClymont>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

33
00:10:16.032 --> 00:10:22.985
<v Keelan McClymont>To testify before council in person or virtually, you may— must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

34
00:10:26.265 --> 00:10:29.774
<v Keelan McClymont>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

35
00:10:30.323 --> 00:10:34.447
<v Keelan McClymont>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

36
00:10:34.851 --> 00:10:37.124
<v Keelan McClymont>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

37
00:10:37.652 --> 00:10:39.623
<v Keelan McClymont>The presiding officer preserves order.

38
00:10:39.958 --> 00:10:48.595
<v Keelan McClymont>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

39
00:10:49.587 --> 00:10:51.798
<v Keelan McClymont>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

40
00:10:52.216 --> 00:10:54.602
<v Keelan McClymont>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

41
00:10:55.100 --> 00:10:59.424
<v Keelan McClymont>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

42
00:10:59.985 --> 00:11:03.335
<v Keelan McClymont>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

43
00:11:04.152 --> 00:11:06.698
<v Keelan McClymont>Your testimony should address the matters being considered.

44
00:11:07.052 --> 00:11:09.283
<v Keelan McClymont>When testifying, state your name for the record.

45
00:11:09.623 --> 00:11:11.061
<v Keelan McClymont>Your address is not necessary.

46
00:11:11.577 --> 00:11:14.485
<v Keelan McClymont>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

47
00:11:15.399 --> 00:11:19.153
<v Unidentified speaker>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls for your name.

48
00:11:19.349 --> 00:11:19.722
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

49
00:11:21.201 --> 00:11:21.981
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you very much.

50
00:11:23.296 --> 00:11:27.986
<v Keith Wilson>Colleagues, the first item on our agenda is approval of the agenda.

51
00:11:28.517 --> 00:11:32.774
<v Keith Wilson>Um, usually this moves very quickly, but I'm going to mix us up a little bit today.

52
00:11:32.870 --> 00:11:37.389
<v Keith Wilson>I will I want to start by flagging that one item has been removed from the consent agenda.

53
00:11:37.437 --> 00:11:38.980
<v Keith Wilson>That's item number 5.

54
00:11:39.107 --> 00:11:41.533
<v Keith Wilson>Item number 4 remains on the consent agenda.

55
00:11:42.562 --> 00:12:01.681
<v Keith Wilson>I am going to put forward a motion to suspend the rules and add a resolution, which I am passing out right now, which I know many of you saw yesterday, authorizing council to continue operating under the current City Code Chapter 3.02.

56
00:12:01.761 --> 00:12:16.705
<v Keith Wilson>We passed an ordinance at the beginning of the year making some changes to 3.02 and stating that the council president would bring back any further changes or an affirmation that we would continue operating under 3.02 by the end of October.

57
00:12:17.684 --> 00:12:28.131
<v Keith Wilson>Given the extensive work that the Governance Committee has done and a proposal that I have in the works right now that you all will see soon, I thought we had met that requirement.

58
00:12:28.662 --> 00:12:47.166
<v Keith Wilson>I recently learned that that requirement was far more technical and specific than I had remembered, and we actually need to affirmatively vote at this meeting by the end of the year to— or by the end of the month, I apologize— to continue to do our work under 3.02 as it currently stands.

59
00:12:47.309 --> 00:12:52.433
<v Keith Wilson>What you have before you is a resolution which would state that we would do so.

60
00:12:52.562 --> 00:12:52.739
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

61
00:12:53.495 --> 00:12:55.125
<v Keith Wilson>I would entertain a second.

62
00:12:57.340 --> 00:12:57.583
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

63
00:12:57.649 --> 00:12:58.072
<v Keelan McClymont>Second.

64
00:12:59.096 --> 00:13:02.774
<v Keith Wilson>I think Councilor Dunphy was first out of the gate there.

65
00:13:03.919 --> 00:13:07.798
<v Keith Wilson>The attorneys have shared that this is not a debatable motion.

66
00:13:09.032 --> 00:13:11.139
<v Keith Wilson>So we move directly to a vote.

67
00:13:11.221 --> 00:13:15.389
<v Keith Wilson>This vote, because it is a rules suspension, requires 9 votes to pass.

68
00:13:15.842 --> 00:13:17.076
<v Keelan McClymont>Clerk.

69
00:13:23.960 --> 00:13:23.975
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

70
00:13:24.586 --> 00:13:47.019
<v Keith Wilson>What this is changing, can you yes, this is not changing anything.

71
00:13:47.292 --> 00:13:57.549
<v Keith Wilson>This is stating that we are fulfilling the requirement that we passed earlier this year by affirmatively stating that we will continue operating under 3.2 as it's currently written.

72
00:13:58.144 --> 00:14:13.898
<v Keith Wilson>I believe that this also refers to the fact that I do have changes that will be coming to the Governance Committee to debate about 3.02 in the works, which we may or may not see at this council depending on the actions taken by the Governance Committee.

73
00:14:18.110 --> 00:14:22.234
<v Loretta Smith>I don't understand it, but, um, aye.

74
00:14:22.842 --> 00:14:23.148
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

75
00:14:23.485 --> 00:14:26.131
<v Dan Ryan>Hey, I look forward to these conversations in governance.

76
00:14:26.436 --> 00:14:26.596
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

77
00:14:27.158 --> 00:14:27.960
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Janae Malane.

78
00:14:29.003 --> 00:14:29.051
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

79
00:14:29.371 --> 00:14:30.285
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Murillo.

80
00:14:31.008 --> 00:14:31.024
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

81
00:14:31.249 --> 00:14:32.067
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Novick.

82
00:14:32.772 --> 00:14:36.013
<v Steve Novick>Although I kind of like the idea of an enforced vacation because it's illegal for us to operate.

83
00:14:36.140 --> 00:14:36.173
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

84
00:14:36.557 --> 00:14:37.808
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

85
00:14:38.466 --> 00:14:38.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

86
00:14:39.509 --> 00:14:41.787
<v Keelan McClymont>The motion carries with 10 aye votes.

87
00:14:43.296 --> 00:14:44.227
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, colleagues.

88
00:14:44.485 --> 00:14:49.044
<v Keith Wilson>Are there any other additions or changes?

89
00:14:49.398 --> 00:14:56.076
<v Keith Wilson>Oh, and I should note, we will place that at the end of today's agenda, and that will be open for public comment.

90
00:14:56.221 --> 00:15:00.220
<v Keith Wilson>So if the public would like to make comments, please talk to Keelan to sign up.

91
00:15:01.023 --> 00:15:06.354
<v Keith Wilson>Are there any other motions to reorder the agenda or add items to the agenda?

92
00:15:10.168 --> 00:15:15.865
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, seeing none, do we have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

93
00:15:18.559 --> 00:15:20.784
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, thank you, colleagues.

94
00:15:20.899 --> 00:15:23.221
<v Keith Wilson>The next item on our agenda is public communication.

95
00:15:23.335 --> 00:15:25.008
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, can you please call up our first guest?

96
00:15:25.863 --> 00:15:27.727
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Blake Schell.

97
00:15:41.934 --> 00:15:42.649
<v Blake Schell>Hi, good morning.

98
00:15:48.100 --> 00:15:48.563
<v Unidentified speaker>Go right ahead.

99
00:15:50.679 --> 00:15:57.000
<v Blake Schell>I'm Blake Schell, director of Oregon Contemporary, here on behalf of the Coalition Portland Arts and Culture for Equity.

100
00:15:57.664 --> 00:16:00.897
<v Blake Schell>Portland's arts funding challenges are rooted in scarcity.

101
00:16:01.419 --> 00:16:10.118
<v Blake Schell>According to SMU DataArts, we rank 17th in the nation for artistic vibrancy, but 172nd for government support.

102
00:16:10.599 --> 00:16:14.943
<v Blake Schell>Our arts thrive despite, not because of, government funding.

103
00:16:15.712 --> 00:16:23.697
<v Blake Schell>In New York, SMU reports that 48% of artists make a living on gigs or freelance work, and only 8 are full-time workers.

104
00:16:24.274 --> 00:16:28.009
<v Blake Schell>In our smaller arts economy, that gap is likely even wider.

105
00:16:28.523 --> 00:16:34.326
<v Blake Schell>The Big 5 are important employers, but they are not the primary source of income for artists here.

106
00:16:34.390 --> 00:16:34.519
<v Blake Schell>Thank you.

107
00:16:35.352 --> 00:16:40.769
<v Blake Schell>Most artists earn through gigs, teaching, and creative side work that keeps this ecosystem alive.

108
00:16:41.442 --> 00:16:49.024
<v Blake Schell>Last year, the Office of Arts and Culture removed equity metrics from the art tax grants and distributed funds solely based on budget size.

109
00:16:49.760 --> 00:16:54.874
<v Blake Schell>As a result, 45 of 80 groups lost funding while only the big 5 saw increases.

110
00:16:55.644 --> 00:17:03.369
<v Blake Schell>Smaller orgs regularly employ Portland artists and afford— offer affordable, often free arts access across our neighborhoods.

111
00:17:04.096 --> 00:17:13.361
<v Blake Schell>Prioritizing large institutions with endowments, greater funding, and fewer local artists is funneling money to money and power to power.

112
00:17:13.907 --> 00:17:21.125
<v Blake Schell>The art tax supports K-12 arts education and making arts and culture available to underserved communities.

113
00:17:21.641 --> 00:17:25.864
<v Blake Schell>In 2024, that mandate was changed without warning or oversight.

114
00:17:27.807 --> 00:17:29.722
<v Blake Schell>We met with the office and multiple committees.

115
00:17:29.901 --> 00:17:32.429
<v Blake Schell>No correction— corrective action was taken.

116
00:17:32.493 --> 00:17:33.588
<v Blake Schell>We are now entering a second year of harm to our community.

117
00:17:36.568 --> 00:17:40.969
<v Blake Schell>Portland voters expected the art tax to expand access, not diminish it.

118
00:17:41.402 --> 00:17:47.953
<v Blake Schell>We asked the city to restore funding for the 45 and to realign arts funding with its original intent.

119
00:17:48.386 --> 00:18:00.156
<v Blake Schell>Prioritize groups that provide low or no-cost access, employ local artists, and do deep community work with underserved Portlanders, all without other significant funding.

120
00:18:00.912 --> 00:18:07.221
<v Blake Schell>Our vision is clear: support smaller orgs offering greater access citywide and the artists who make Portland what it is.

121
00:18:07.815 --> 00:18:13.442
<v Blake Schell>We need explicit equity and access measures provided, protected from politics.

122
00:18:13.748 --> 00:18:19.888
<v Blake Schell>And as costs rise while the art tax stays flat, we need change to provide more funding overall.

123
00:18:20.707 --> 00:18:25.421
<v Blake Schell>There are over 500 arts nonprofits here, and most don't receive city funding.

124
00:18:26.816 --> 00:18:33.694
<v Blake Schell>The arts give us agency, community, and the power to imagine change, and that's why they're under federal attack.

125
00:18:34.034 --> 00:18:36.023
<v Blake Schell>And why we must protect them locally.

126
00:18:36.686 --> 00:18:39.760
<v Blake Schell>We're asking for a bold vision in support of the arts.

127
00:18:39.840 --> 00:18:43.353
<v Blake Schell>Help us to keep Portland as vibrant as the artists who live here.

128
00:18:43.887 --> 00:18:44.375
<v Blake Schell>Thank you.

129
00:18:45.689 --> 00:18:50.442
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you very much for being here, and we see supporters, uh, behind you as well.

130
00:18:55.260 --> 00:18:57.585
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Harper Hoverkamp.

131
00:19:00.210 --> 00:19:00.724
<v Keith Wilson>Welcome.

132
00:19:00.807 --> 00:19:01.905
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for being here today.

133
00:19:09.786 --> 00:19:10.388
<v Harper Haverkamp>Uh, good morning.

134
00:19:10.813 --> 00:19:12.539
<v Harper Haverkamp>For the record, my name is Harper Haverkamp.

135
00:19:12.768 --> 00:19:14.233
<v Harper Haverkamp>I'm speaking today as an individual.

136
00:19:15.009 --> 00:19:20.805
<v Harper Haverkamp>This summer, I heard that some councilors were brainstorming ordinances to support the LGBTQ community.

137
00:19:21.480 --> 00:19:27.835
<v Harper Haverkamp>In my opinion, the decriminalization of sex work should be at the forefront of any such policy discussion.

138
00:19:28.829 --> 00:19:34.659
<v Harper Haverkamp>Let's reflect on the legacy of Black trans elder Miss Major, who passed earlier this month.

139
00:19:35.252 --> 00:19:45.704
<v Harper Haverkamp>Miss Major was not only at Stonewall, but she spent decades as a sex worker while also supporting the trans community materially and spiritually.

140
00:19:46.652 --> 00:19:55.000
<v Harper Haverkamp>The basis of her politics and activism was how she made ends meet and how police and institutions impeded her survival.

141
00:19:56.125 --> 00:19:58.067
<v Harper Haverkamp>This isn't history of a different era.

142
00:19:58.854 --> 00:20:13.223
<v Harper Haverkamp>Today, trans people, women like me, still perform this work and are suffering harm and abuse regularly under the yoke of criminalization, which make us less safe, more marginalized, and legally disenfranchised.

143
00:20:13.931 --> 00:20:25.911
<v Harper Haverkamp>Yet the many forms of sex work in Portland, which has more strip clubs per capita than anywhere else in the country, are valuable, vital, and remain highly in demand as a form of work.

144
00:20:26.539 --> 00:20:58.484
<v Harper Haverkamp>If council wishes to support the trans community through policy or the broader LGBTQ community, there are three things you can do: one, direct the city to lobby the Oregon Legislature and Governor to revive and pass the 2023 decriminalization public health studies that were within Senate Bill 5506 from 2023; two, pass our own city's specific bill to fund studies around public health and a path forward which incorporate global best practices to repeal or amend Portland city ordinances that do exist and pertain to prostitution.

145
00:20:59.253 --> 00:21:06.672
<v Harper Haverkamp>3, Direct PPB to stop enforcing, harassing, and arresting sex workers, especially along 82nd.

146
00:21:07.729 --> 00:21:16.365
<v Harper Haverkamp>The Oregon Safer Workers Coalition has a comprehensive legal report on best practices regarding criminal decriminalization in Oregon, which I will email to you all.

147
00:21:17.167 --> 00:21:22.932
<v Harper Haverkamp>And I hope that at least one of you have the courage, conviction, and moral clarity to engage with this.

148
00:21:23.750 --> 00:21:30.446
<v Harper Haverkamp>As a former sex worker myself, I ask that you listen, learn, and act, and bring trans and queer sex workers to the table.

149
00:21:30.768 --> 00:21:33.000
<v Harper Haverkamp>Stonewall was 56 years ago.

150
00:21:33.577 --> 00:21:41.509
<v Harper Haverkamp>Don't let the buzz over restrooms and pronouns distract you from this real enduring demand from over 50 years ago that's still alive today.

151
00:21:42.137 --> 00:21:42.694
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you so much.

152
00:21:43.121 --> 00:21:44.875
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for being here.

153
00:21:47.259 --> 00:21:49.111
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Eve Ashkar.

154
00:22:02.933 --> 00:22:05.854
<v Keelan McClymont>Eve Ashkar.

155
00:22:09.236 --> 00:22:10.450
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Donna Cohen.

156
00:22:14.309 --> 00:22:16.500
<v Donna Cohen>Would you put up the first slide, please?

157
00:22:18.541 --> 00:22:18.881
<v Keith Wilson>Um, welcome.

158
00:22:18.944 --> 00:22:19.784
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for being here.

159
00:22:19.913 --> 00:22:24.835
<v Keith Wilson>And, um, colleagues, I'll draw your attention to the fact that we do have written testimony posted as well.

160
00:22:25.238 --> 00:22:26.045
<v Keith Wilson>Yes, thank you.

161
00:22:26.673 --> 00:22:28.660
<v Donna Cohen>Um, councilors, my name is Donna Cohen.

162
00:22:28.709 --> 00:22:29.971
<v Donna Cohen>I live in St. Johns.

163
00:22:30.553 --> 00:22:36.121
<v Donna Cohen>Uh, this, uh, picture shows you what separates the North Peninsula from the rest of Portland.

164
00:22:36.857 --> 00:22:38.365
<v Donna Cohen>Um, next slide, please.

165
00:22:38.541 --> 00:22:42.806
<v Donna Cohen>And this shows you the location of these bridges and the tunnel.

166
00:22:43.383 --> 00:22:49.233
<v Donna Cohen>60,000 people who live and work on the North Peninsula are at risk when the earthquake hits.

167
00:22:49.682 --> 00:23:11.003
<v Donna Cohen>People from every district in Portland will be trapped to die a quick death if a toxic cloud from the CEI hub comes from across the river, or perhaps a slow one as water food and medical help is unavailable due to this area having no lifeline to the rest of Portland after the railroad bridges and the tunnel collapse.

168
00:23:11.662 --> 00:23:17.945
<v Donna Cohen>Portsmouth and University Park, along with UP students, will be included if liquefaction along Columbia Boulevard occurs.

169
00:23:17.993 --> 00:23:19.356
<v Donna Cohen>That's the orange area.

170
00:23:20.061 --> 00:23:22.499
<v Donna Cohen>These people are constituents of all of you.

171
00:23:23.204 --> 00:23:24.295
<v Donna Cohen>This is fixable.

172
00:23:24.487 --> 00:23:31.156
<v Donna Cohen>We tried getting money towards a new bridge at Columbia Boulevard last legislative session, and 130 community members testified.

173
00:23:31.221 --> 00:23:31.429
<v Donna Cohen>Thank you.

174
00:23:31.925 --> 00:23:36.431
<v Donna Cohen>We held a rally and had coverage on 2 TV stations, but the bill failed.

175
00:23:36.750 --> 00:23:52.107
<v Donna Cohen>Can you imagine what it's like for the community to hear our mayor twice testify to the state for money for potholes and other transportation concerns while never mentioning the need for an emergency route to save the lives of tens of thousands of people?

176
00:23:53.165 --> 00:24:08.135
<v Donna Cohen>Other efforts, neighborhood leaders meeting with council staff, making requests for council to advocate to PBIM, making requests to staff of councilors on the public safety and Transportation committees to get agenda items on this issue have failed.

177
00:24:08.792 --> 00:24:20.153
<v Donna Cohen>City councilors have not spent one minute of council business focused on the lives of the tens of thousands that are in danger, yet council has had time to discuss hot dog stands and trees.

178
00:24:20.747 --> 00:24:24.079
<v Donna Cohen>It is way past time for council to be talking about this threat.

179
00:24:24.576 --> 00:24:26.530
<v Donna Cohen>We ask, one, for a task force.

180
00:24:26.932 --> 00:24:46.882
<v Donna Cohen>Several community members have come together along with a PBOT staff member and agree that a task force needs to be set up by council, one with neighbors, reps from the port, University of Portland, experts from PBOT and PBEM, and councilors to have an ongoing discussion on options for making the North Peninsula seismically resilient with an emergency route.

181
00:24:47.282 --> 00:24:49.865
<v Donna Cohen>2, Policy committees agenda items.

182
00:24:49.929 --> 00:24:58.719
<v Donna Cohen>We ask that this issue be placed on the agendas of all relevant policy committees so that representatives from PBOT, PBEM, and community leaders can discuss this issue.

183
00:24:59.462 --> 00:25:06.133
<v Donna Cohen>Council shouldn't wait any longer to treat this very serious issue with the consideration it deserves.

184
00:25:06.309 --> 00:25:07.359
<v Donna Cohen>Thank you.

185
00:25:08.570 --> 00:25:10.048
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you very much for being here today.

186
00:25:18.650 --> 00:25:22.031
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Brian Owendoff.

187
00:25:25.228 --> 00:25:25.903
<v Unidentified speaker>Morning, councilors.

188
00:25:25.967 --> 00:25:27.364
<v Unidentified speaker>Brian Ohendoff, District 4.

189
00:25:27.973 --> 00:25:33.272
<v Unidentified speaker>Today marks the 301st day since this Portland City Council has been in office.

190
00:25:33.738 --> 00:25:41.204
<v Unidentified speaker>In that time frame, we've seen passionate speeches, symbolic resolutions, and even an international junket to Vienna.

191
00:25:41.381 --> 00:25:49.810
<v Unidentified speaker>What we haven't seen is meaningful progress on the 3 most urgent issues facing Portland: safety, mental health, and substance use disorder.

192
00:25:50.115 --> 00:25:51.334
<v Unidentified speaker>And economic development.

193
00:25:51.959 --> 00:26:01.913
<v Unidentified speaker>The City Council, particularly the DSA members, have shown a troubling pattern of focusing on national and international issues that fall far outside the scope of city governance.

194
00:26:02.315 --> 00:26:04.125
<v Unidentified speaker>It's time to get back to the basics.

195
00:26:05.039 --> 00:26:10.458
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's be clear, Portland City Council is not Congress, it's not the State Department, and it's not the United Nations.

196
00:26:11.050 --> 00:26:13.439
<v Unidentified speaker>It has no authority over the Israeli conflict.

197
00:26:14.031 --> 00:26:16.628
<v Unidentified speaker>It has no authority over federal immigration policy.

198
00:26:17.288 --> 00:26:19.038
<v Unidentified speaker>And has no authority over the Pentagon.

199
00:26:19.376 --> 00:26:21.176
<v Unidentified speaker>The council's time and energy are finite.

200
00:26:21.385 --> 00:26:26.542
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland residents deserve leaders who focus on pressing challenges in their own backyard.

201
00:26:28.130 --> 00:26:35.375
<v Unidentified speaker>The 3 biggest issues confronting Portland today sit right at the base of Maslow's hierarchy of needs: safety, stability, and economic opportunity.

202
00:26:36.051 --> 00:26:46.471
<v Unidentified speaker>A recent report based on FBI data listed Portland as the 2nd worst city for total crime in America, with a total crime exceeding 195% higher than the national average.

203
00:26:46.968 --> 00:26:55.605
<v Unidentified speaker>So many Portland residents and business owners don't bother reporting crimes unless they need a police report for insurance, and our courts are focused on restorative justice.

204
00:26:56.501 --> 00:26:58.729
<v Unidentified speaker>Our crime rate is much higher than reported.

205
00:26:59.625 --> 00:27:01.981
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland is also in the middle of a humanitarian crisis.

206
00:27:02.190 --> 00:27:03.615
<v Unidentified speaker>Overdoses are at record highs.

207
00:27:03.743 --> 00:27:04.945
<v Unidentified speaker>Mental health is untreated.

208
00:27:05.009 --> 00:27:09.703
<v Unidentified speaker>Homeless encampments continue to strain public spaces and services and cause damage to our environment.

209
00:27:10.057 --> 00:27:13.196
<v Unidentified speaker>Oregon is now ranked 4th highest per capita for homelessness in America.

210
00:27:13.932 --> 00:27:16.159
<v Unidentified speaker>Worst for mental health and second in addiction.

211
00:27:16.306 --> 00:27:19.962
<v Unidentified speaker>You combine these 3 and that is what we have, a perfect deadly storm.

212
00:27:21.730 --> 00:27:24.001
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland has lost over 10,000 jobs.

213
00:27:24.196 --> 00:27:27.167
<v Unidentified speaker>City Council needs to focus on ways to retain existing companies.

214
00:27:28.230 --> 00:27:34.718
<v Unidentified speaker>On October 17th, 6 Portland City Council members pledged to investigate the city's connections to Israeli military.

215
00:27:34.798 --> 00:27:40.625
<v Unidentified speaker>The investigation singles out only one group of Portlanders, those that are Jewish or have ties to Israel.

216
00:27:41.332 --> 00:27:45.884
<v Unidentified speaker>The investigation will focus on several things that have no purview whatsoever to City Council.

217
00:27:46.478 --> 00:27:59.559
<v Unidentified speaker>City Councilor Morillo reposted DSA's message on her personal social media and added, also just wanted to add that members of the Jewish Federation were allowed on the call and their org is very pro-Israel.

218
00:28:00.953 --> 00:28:03.680
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not too late, but time is running out.

219
00:28:03.776 --> 00:28:10.428
<v Unidentified speaker>The next 4 months will determine whether Portland is on a path for recovery in 4 years or stagnation for 40.

220
00:28:10.893 --> 00:28:13.971
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't need symbolic gestures or ideological distractions.

221
00:28:14.035 --> 00:28:21.696
<v Unidentified speaker>We need competent governance focused on the needs of the city residents and the core responsibilities: public safety, infrastructure, economic growth, and public health.

222
00:28:22.433 --> 00:28:24.278
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't need ideological purity tests.

223
00:28:24.438 --> 00:28:25.255
<v Unidentified speaker>We need competence.

224
00:28:25.640 --> 00:28:33.959
<v Unidentified speaker>We need leaders groomed in real-world experience who understand to manage the complex city, not activists chasing utopian fantasies.

225
00:28:34.219 --> 00:28:35.376
<v Unidentified speaker>At taxpayer expense.

226
00:28:35.523 --> 00:28:35.817
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

227
00:28:36.665 --> 00:28:37.595
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for being here.

228
00:28:39.258 --> 00:28:40.529
<v Keelan McClymont>Completes communications.

229
00:28:41.511 --> 00:28:42.140
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Keelan.

230
00:28:43.282 --> 00:28:47.098
<v Keith Wilson>Colleagues, the next item on the agenda is the committee referral list.

231
00:28:47.469 --> 00:28:50.391
<v Keith Wilson>Uh, we don't actually have anything on the committee referral list this week.

232
00:28:50.634 --> 00:28:51.991
<v Keith Wilson>We had a whole lot the last few weeks.

233
00:28:52.816 --> 00:28:58.053
<v Keith Wilson>That brings us to the consent agenda, which has one item on it, agenda item number 4.

234
00:28:58.250 --> 00:28:59.780
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, could you please call roll on the consent agenda?

235
00:29:02.786 --> 00:29:03.807
<v Keelan McClymont>Clerk.

236
00:29:04.148 --> 00:29:04.246
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

237
00:29:04.781 --> 00:29:04.992
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

238
00:29:05.414 --> 00:29:05.576
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

239
00:29:05.934 --> 00:29:06.339
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

240
00:29:06.648 --> 00:29:06.730
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

241
00:29:07.118 --> 00:29:07.428
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

242
00:29:07.769 --> 00:29:07.931
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

243
00:29:08.240 --> 00:29:08.480
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

244
00:29:08.900 --> 00:29:09.028
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

245
00:29:10.124 --> 00:29:10.397
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

246
00:29:13.973 --> 00:29:15.086
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry, just looking.

247
00:29:15.375 --> 00:29:21.711
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, um, these are for the appointments to the— okay, I know that we're not having debate.

248
00:29:21.775 --> 00:29:27.349
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to say this, um, I found, uh, most of the appointments to be just fine.

249
00:29:27.957 --> 00:29:34.363
<v Dan Ryan>I am concerned that we don't have enough people with knowledge about housing development and economic development.

250
00:29:34.813 --> 00:29:41.460
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm hoping those that lack that experience lean into those on their committees that have that experience.

251
00:29:42.021 --> 00:29:45.747
<v Dan Ryan>That's what I need to say, 'cause we are in an economic development challenge crisis right now.

252
00:29:45.940 --> 00:29:46.133
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

253
00:29:46.759 --> 00:29:47.064
<v Unidentified speaker>I vote aye.

254
00:29:48.284 --> 00:29:48.814
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

255
00:30:04.694 --> 00:30:04.983
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo.

256
00:30:05.144 --> 00:30:05.209
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

257
00:30:06.509 --> 00:30:06.895
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

258
00:30:07.136 --> 00:30:07.184
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

259
00:30:09.065 --> 00:30:11.924
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, I am seeing Councilor Kanal online.

260
00:30:11.972 --> 00:30:14.192
<v Keith Wilson>Yeah, I'm seeing Councilor Kanal has joined the meeting.

261
00:30:14.289 --> 00:30:16.756
<v Keith Wilson>I was going to flag that after you finished the roll call.

262
00:30:22.089 --> 00:30:22.105
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

263
00:30:22.606 --> 00:30:26.532
<v Keelan McClymont>The consent agenda is approved with 9 yes votes.

264
00:30:26.969 --> 00:30:27.548
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Keelan.

265
00:30:27.613 --> 00:30:30.297
<v Keith Wilson>And Councilor Kanal, welcome.

266
00:30:32.192 --> 00:30:33.445
<v Keith Wilson>Are you with us for the rest of the meeting?

267
00:30:34.442 --> 00:30:44.598
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm actually only here for the consent agenda, and I wanted to express my support in public for a consent agenda voting yes on something that includes appointments because of the work session.

268
00:30:45.340 --> 00:30:46.989
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's why I joined.

269
00:30:47.248 --> 00:30:47.749
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much.

270
00:30:48.733 --> 00:30:50.786
<v Keith Wilson>Thanks, Councilor.

271
00:30:57.039 --> 00:31:00.055
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, Keelan, that moves us to our regular agenda.

272
00:31:00.134 --> 00:31:01.941
<v Keith Wilson>Can you please read item 6 for us?

273
00:31:03.633 --> 00:31:19.536
<v Keelan McClymont>Authorize City Attorney to settle lawsuit related to construction of the streetcar approach ramp located near Southeast thank you and welcome.

274
00:31:19.825 --> 00:31:24.933
<v Keith Wilson>We have Beth from our City Attorney's Office, Beth Woodard, and Millicent from PBOT here.

275
00:31:25.871 --> 00:31:27.146
<v Keith Wilson>Beth, would you like to go right ahead?

276
00:31:27.728 --> 00:31:29.003
<v Beth Woodard>Yes, good morning, Council.

277
00:31:29.101 --> 00:31:32.240
<v Beth Woodard>For the record, I'm Senior Deputy City Attorney Beth Woodard.

278
00:31:33.240 --> 00:31:48.990
<v Beth Woodard>Today's proposed settlement resolves claims brought by the city against Trimet and Stacy and Witbeck, Inc., related to phased construction of a portion of the streetcar system, specifically the streetcar on-grade approach ramp located at Southeast 2nd Avenue.

279
00:31:49.711 --> 00:31:58.957
<v Beth Woodard>The approach structure is an on-grade ramp that connects the OMSI streetcar platform to the viaduct which spans the Union Pacific Railroad tracks.

280
00:31:59.710 --> 00:32:02.866
<v Beth Woodard>The 2nd phase of construction was completed in 2015.

281
00:32:02.914 --> 00:32:03.075
<v Beth Woodard>Thank you.

282
00:32:04.710 --> 00:32:11.186
<v Beth Woodard>The necessary transit alignments in this area required locating the approach ramp on a geotechnically challenged site.

283
00:32:11.988 --> 00:32:17.294
<v Beth Woodard>At the completion of construction, the city noticed atypical settlement at the location.

284
00:32:17.982 --> 00:32:27.280
<v Beth Woodard>The city self-monitored the location from 2015 to 2018 and completed accelerated maintenance and repairs to maintain service.

285
00:32:28.242 --> 00:32:34.798
<v Beth Woodard>The city hired a geotechnical consultant to more, more fully monitor the approach structure from 2018 to 2023.

286
00:32:34.846 --> 00:32:34.974
<v Beth Woodard>Thank you.

287
00:32:36.273 --> 00:32:43.346
<v Beth Woodard>The consultant's findings issued in 2021 indicated the structure required significant near-term repair.

288
00:32:44.196 --> 00:32:58.615
<v Beth Woodard>The city then hired an engineering consultant to provide mitigation analysis and provide preliminary estimates for repairs necessary to bring the structure into compliance with its anticipated design life of 75 years.

289
00:32:59.913 --> 00:33:09.565
<v Beth Woodard>In March 2022, the city filed a lawsuit against TriMet and Stacy and Whitback for work related to the second phase of design and construction of the structure.

290
00:33:10.589 --> 00:33:22.255
<v Beth Woodard>To resolve these claims, the parties have agreed to a proposed settlement agreement including the following terms: a $7.5 million lump sum payment to the city earmarked for repairs to this structure.

291
00:33:23.249 --> 00:33:31.388
<v Beth Woodard>TriMet will additionally provide in-kind services to the city in the form of securing alternate funding sources for the repairs.

292
00:33:31.436 --> 00:33:31.580
<v Beth Woodard>Thank you.

293
00:33:32.989 --> 00:33:47.605
<v Beth Woodard>TriMet will also provide technical assistance for the repairs and will provide bus bridging and other service interruption assistance at no cost, provided that the repairs are performed concurrent with TriMet's planned improvements in the area.

294
00:33:48.789 --> 00:33:57.036
<v Beth Woodard>The city, the bureau, and the city administrator— the city attorney's office, the bureau, and the city administrator recommend approval of the settlement.

295
00:33:58.050 --> 00:34:02.255
<v Beth Woodard>And this concludes my prepared remarks, but we are happy to answer any questions that you may have.

296
00:34:04.319 --> 00:34:04.921
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you very much.

297
00:34:05.147 --> 00:34:10.248
<v Keith Wilson>And Keelan, just so we know how to do questions, do we have anybody who's signed up for public testimony?

298
00:34:12.132 --> 00:34:12.775
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

299
00:34:13.177 --> 00:34:19.971
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, so colleagues, if you have any technical questions, other questions, or comments, we can take that all together now.

300
00:34:22.206 --> 00:34:22.900
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Ryan.

301
00:34:24.695 --> 00:34:25.032
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

302
00:34:25.320 --> 00:34:27.132
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President, and thank you.

303
00:34:27.181 --> 00:34:31.625
<v Dan Ryan>It's good to see you, Director Williams, and I appreciate the presentation by our city debt manager.

304
00:34:32.378 --> 00:34:34.128
<v Dan Ryan>Are you the debt manager?

305
00:34:34.737 --> 00:34:37.030
<v Beth Woodard>I'm just in the City Attorney's Office.

306
00:34:37.143 --> 00:34:37.704
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, okay.

307
00:34:38.090 --> 00:34:41.137
<v Dan Ryan>I think I got information from the city's debt manager on this.

308
00:34:41.202 --> 00:34:41.795
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, great.

309
00:34:41.923 --> 00:34:42.003
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

310
00:34:42.277 --> 00:34:52.222
<v Dan Ryan>Anyway, I know we're talking about debt financing and legal stuff at the moment, but I want to just acknowledge this milestone because we talk a lot about and when I was— yeah.

311
00:34:53.009 --> 00:34:53.940
<v Keith Wilson>Can I pause you?

312
00:34:54.291 --> 00:34:54.516
<v Eric Zimmerman>Why?

313
00:34:55.480 --> 00:34:57.838
<v Keith Wilson>We are on the settlement issue.

314
00:34:57.918 --> 00:34:59.184
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, I'm on the wrong issue.

315
00:34:59.248 --> 00:35:02.440
<v Keith Wilson>We'll have Director Williams here for both of those.

316
00:35:02.634 --> 00:35:04.141
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, pretend it never happened.

317
00:35:04.237 --> 00:35:06.018
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to crawl in a hole right now.

318
00:35:06.547 --> 00:35:12.001
<v Dan Ryan>And sorry, I got off on a few points this morning because the numbers changed.

319
00:35:12.193 --> 00:35:13.188
<v Dan Ryan>So I apologize.

320
00:35:14.007 --> 00:35:17.215
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry, now I know why you're not the debt manager and I'm on the wrong topic.

321
00:35:17.472 --> 00:35:17.583
<v Loretta Smith>Bye.

322
00:35:18.338 --> 00:35:19.943
<v Keith Wilson>I'm sorry, Councilor.

323
00:35:20.215 --> 00:35:20.920
<v Dan Ryan>It's all right.

324
00:35:21.001 --> 00:35:21.963
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks for saving me.

325
00:35:22.268 --> 00:35:26.199
<v Keith Wilson>Call me earlier next time.

326
00:35:26.295 --> 00:35:26.952
<v Olivia Clark>It took me a minute.

327
00:35:27.032 --> 00:35:28.460
<v Dan Ryan>If I was you, I would've been like, stop.

328
00:35:29.007 --> 00:35:39.338
<v Keith Wilson>I'll just say while we wait to see if others have comments that I appreciate your work and the Attorney's Office— Attorney Office's work on this broadly.

329
00:35:39.530 --> 00:35:46.958
<v Keith Wilson>I know that these issues where we have many local governments working on overlapping projects are always difficult ones.

330
00:35:48.188 --> 00:35:56.519
<v Keith Wilson>It sounds like we'll probably need to do future work at this site, and knowing that we have a large portion of that covered already is very helpful.

331
00:35:56.878 --> 00:35:57.835
<v Keith Wilson>So thank you.

332
00:35:59.297 --> 00:35:59.914
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Smith.

333
00:36:02.039 --> 00:36:03.014
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

334
00:36:03.599 --> 00:36:08.010
<v Loretta Smith>Director Williams, um, this is the, the $7.5 million?

335
00:36:08.380 --> 00:36:08.768
<v Harper Haverkamp>Yes, ma'am.

336
00:36:09.186 --> 00:36:24.925
<v Loretta Smith>And where will those funds lie in the, um, in our system because I have a concern that I want to make sure that we separate this money from the general tax, gas tax money, and that this, this project is actually going to happen 3 years from now.

337
00:36:25.710 --> 00:36:30.677
<v Loretta Smith>So I want to make sure that we still have it and it's— and it is appropriately, um, set aside.

338
00:36:31.302 --> 00:36:31.782
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, absolutely.

339
00:36:31.862 --> 00:36:33.177
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, uh, so much, Councilors.

340
00:36:33.257 --> 00:36:35.500
<v Keith Wilson>Millicent Williams, Director of the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

341
00:36:35.869 --> 00:36:36.653
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for the question.

342
00:36:37.070 --> 00:36:42.427
<v Keith Wilson>Um, I can assure you that the money will be appropriately earmarked and set aside specifically for this project.

343
00:36:42.780 --> 00:36:50.985
<v Keith Wilson>The guidance that we received when we were working through the settlement agreement was that these funds could be used for nothing other than the structure.

344
00:36:51.307 --> 00:37:07.543
<v Keith Wilson>So with that in mind, I can assure you that that's going to be the case based on the legal expectation, but also the bureau does have a history of segregating out funds and dedicating those funds to specific projects based on the funding source and the requirements within those funding sources.

345
00:37:07.590 --> 00:37:07.735
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

346
00:37:08.550 --> 00:37:08.793
<v Keith Wilson>Guidelines.

347
00:37:09.068 --> 00:37:14.492
<v Keith Wilson>So you should not worry about whether or not this funding will go directly to this project.

348
00:37:14.653 --> 00:37:16.001
<v Keith Wilson>I can assure you that that will be the case.

349
00:37:16.719 --> 00:37:16.931
<v Loretta Smith>Excellent.

350
00:37:17.079 --> 00:37:17.487
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

351
00:37:17.568 --> 00:37:17.829
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

352
00:37:19.755 --> 00:37:21.534
<v Keith Wilson>Colleagues, any other comments or questions?

353
00:37:24.420 --> 00:37:24.619
<v Keith Wilson>Okay.

354
00:37:24.871 --> 00:37:26.628
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

355
00:37:28.311 --> 00:37:29.387
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

356
00:37:29.597 --> 00:37:29.630
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

357
00:37:30.429 --> 00:37:30.639
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

358
00:37:30.981 --> 00:37:31.112
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

359
00:37:32.300 --> 00:37:32.382
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

360
00:37:33.034 --> 00:37:33.407
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

361
00:37:34.929 --> 00:37:34.978
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

362
00:37:35.739 --> 00:37:35.918
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

363
00:37:36.224 --> 00:37:37.179
<v Dan Ryan>And another thing— no, aye.

364
00:37:42.364 --> 00:37:45.429
<v Keith Wilson>I believe she had to drop off the call— off the meeting for a few minutes.

365
00:37:48.952 --> 00:37:49.050
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

366
00:37:49.215 --> 00:37:50.788
<v Steve Novick>Great to approve a settlement.

367
00:37:50.836 --> 00:37:51.427
<v Steve Novick>We're getting money.

368
00:37:54.135 --> 00:37:54.150
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

369
00:37:54.927 --> 00:37:54.976
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

370
00:37:56.139 --> 00:37:57.092
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you both for being—.

371
00:37:57.528 --> 00:37:59.695
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, sorry, the ordinance is passed with 9 yes votes.

372
00:38:00.344 --> 00:38:01.719
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you both for being here today.

373
00:38:01.800 --> 00:38:02.384
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

374
00:38:03.581 --> 00:38:07.724
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, could you please call agenda item 7 for us?

375
00:38:10.329 --> 00:38:19.646
<v Keelan McClymont>Authorize revenue bonds in an amount sufficient to provide not more than $41 million to finance city fleet maintenance, facility improvements, and related costs.

376
00:38:22.110 --> 00:38:22.467
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

377
00:38:22.695 --> 00:38:27.003
<v Keith Wilson>And colleagues, I believe we have a committee staff summary from Christopher Herr.

378
00:38:27.731 --> 00:38:29.393
<v Keith Wilson>I think this came through the Finance Committee.

379
00:38:30.978 --> 00:38:32.456
<v Keith Wilson>Apologies.

380
00:38:34.079 --> 00:38:34.594
<v Keith Wilson>Welcome.

381
00:38:35.204 --> 00:38:35.686
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

382
00:38:35.782 --> 00:38:38.240
<v Christopher Hare>Good morning, Madam President, councilors.

383
00:38:39.976 --> 00:38:44.385
<v Christopher Hare>So for the record, Christopher Hare, Council Policy Analyst, and I serve as staff to the Finance Committee.

384
00:38:45.108 --> 00:38:53.483
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance before you, document number 2025-404, was considered in the Finance Committee on October 20th, where it was referred to council with a recommendation to pass.

385
00:38:54.251 --> 00:39:07.916
<v Christopher Hare>This ordinance authorizes the city to issue revenue bonds pursuant to ORS 287A.150 and related statutes in an amount up to $41 million to finance improvements to the city's fleet maintenance facility.

386
00:39:08.353 --> 00:39:18.398
<v Christopher Hare>The improvements include construction and upgrades to a maintenance garage, office, and parts area, installation of electric vehicle charging stations, and other related project costs.

387
00:39:19.052 --> 00:39:31.168
<v Christopher Hare>The total principal amount of bonds to be sold is estimated not to exceed $43.9 million, Accounting for, at a conservative estimate, $1.9 to $2.9 million for financing and issuance costs.

388
00:39:31.880 --> 00:39:44.913
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance further authorizes the issuance of refunding bonds under ORS 287A.360 to 287A.375 if any of the authorized bonds are used for interim financing.

389
00:39:45.818 --> 00:40:04.128
<v Christopher Hare>These refunding bonds may be issued in amounts sufficient to repay interim financing and cover the costs all bonds authorized under this ordinance will be secured by the city's full faith credit and available general funds, and bond proceeds may only be used to pay project costs and expenses related to issuing, paying, or refunding the bonds.

390
00:40:04.623 --> 00:40:13.211
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance does not authorize any new taxes, and no bond may be sold or purchase agreements executed until the ordinance takes effect 30 days after passage.

391
00:40:13.773 --> 00:40:25.681
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance additionally designates the city administrator, chief financial officer, city treasurer, debt manager, or a designee of the City Administrator to act as an authorized officer to carry out the necessary actions to issue and manage the bonds.

392
00:40:26.338 --> 00:40:53.295
<v Christopher Hare>Authorized officers may issue bonds in one or more series at different times or in combination with other council-authorized revenue bonds, use bond proceeds for interim or long-term financing, including establishing lines of credit or refunding prior bonds, prepare, authorize, and distribute official statements and disclosure documents, set final terms for each bond series, including principal amounts, maturity schedules, interest rates, prices and payment terms and manage the sale or negotiation process.

393
00:40:53.617 --> 00:40:57.952
<v Christopher Hare>Ensure continuing disclosure compliance with SEC Rules 15 through .

394
00:40:58.659 --> 00:41:05.067
<v Christopher Hare>Finalize and execute bond declarations and related legal documents, including covenants benefiting beholders or credit providers.

395
00:41:05.661 --> 00:41:08.952
<v Christopher Hare>Appoint and enter into agreements with service providers as needed.

396
00:41:09.130 --> 00:41:16.565
<v Christopher Hare>Issue bonds as tax-exempt, taxable, or federally subsidized tax credit bonds and take all actions necessary to maintain eligibility.

397
00:41:16.981 --> 00:41:25.525
<v Christopher Hare>Obtain bond insurance or credit enhancements as appropriate, execute any documents, and take other actions deemed advantageous to the city in connection with the bonds.

398
00:41:26.117 --> 00:41:32.465
<v Christopher Hare>The full impact statement of this item includes a financial and budget impacts and analysis and 100% renewable goal impacts.

399
00:41:32.931 --> 00:41:36.233
<v Christopher Hare>There was no verbal or written testimony on this ordinance prior to committee action.

400
00:41:36.536 --> 00:41:37.786
<v Christopher Hare>This concludes the committee staff summary.

401
00:41:38.139 --> 00:41:38.380
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

402
00:41:39.326 --> 00:41:40.112
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Christopher.

403
00:41:40.864 --> 00:41:42.949
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Zimmerman, do you have anything to add?

404
00:41:43.028 --> 00:41:44.358
<v Keith Wilson>You were presiding over this meeting.

405
00:41:44.760 --> 00:41:44.922
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

406
00:41:45.199 --> 00:41:48.123
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's a good recap by the council ops staff.

407
00:41:48.221 --> 00:41:48.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for that.

408
00:41:50.679 --> 00:41:52.503
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that councilors should dig into this.

409
00:41:52.552 --> 00:41:53.585
<v Eric Zimmerman>The questions will be welcomed.

410
00:41:53.634 --> 00:42:02.275
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's kind of an unusual setup, and I think that we should have that discussion and we should be asking questions about owner's rep, about ownership of the property, et cetera.

411
00:42:02.322 --> 00:42:05.541
<v Eric Zimmerman>So with that, I would say let's open it up, Madam President.

412
00:42:06.219 --> 00:42:06.461
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

413
00:42:07.255 --> 00:42:08.822
<v Keith Wilson>I see a number of folks in the queue.

414
00:42:08.887 --> 00:42:10.514
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, do we have public testimony?

415
00:42:11.762 --> 00:42:12.612
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up for this.

416
00:42:13.126 --> 00:42:15.577
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, Councilor Clark, go right ahead.

417
00:42:16.347 --> 00:42:17.918
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, thank you, Madam President.

418
00:42:17.998 --> 00:42:19.168
<v Olivia Clark>I don't have any questions.

419
00:42:19.217 --> 00:42:20.483
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's a very thorough report.

420
00:42:20.579 --> 00:42:22.550
<v Olivia Clark>I think you did a great job in the Finance Committee.

421
00:42:23.047 --> 00:42:36.576
<v Olivia Clark>What I wanted to say is, you know, a lot of us had heard about the Kirby Garage for years, and finally, um, some of us were given tours of the garage and finally figured out just what a disaster this has been for years.

422
00:42:36.831 --> 00:42:42.048
<v Olivia Clark>And I wanted to thank uh, Maddie Sauter for the tours and all of her staff.

423
00:42:42.706 --> 00:42:53.434
<v Olivia Clark>But also, I really want to applaud, um, all of the city employees who have worked there for years under duress and, and made it function.

424
00:42:54.094 --> 00:42:55.041
<v Olivia Clark>Um, it's amazing.

425
00:42:55.153 --> 00:42:59.538
<v Olivia Clark>It's cramped, it's wet, uh, it's got a leaking roof, it's dangerous.

426
00:42:59.795 --> 00:43:04.998
<v Olivia Clark>And I just applaud, um, all the people who work there and, and made it function.

427
00:43:05.592 --> 00:43:10.768
<v Olivia Clark>And now we're moving to a safer workplace, the Cutter facility, eventually.

428
00:43:11.041 --> 00:43:16.360
<v Olivia Clark>And I think that the arrangements, the long-term lease and potential purchases, is a good deal.

429
00:43:17.369 --> 00:43:22.065
<v Olivia Clark>I do have one question though about the retirement of the bonds.

430
00:43:22.722 --> 00:43:26.231
<v Olivia Clark>And I don't know if this is a— who can answer this question, but—.

431
00:43:26.568 --> 00:43:28.572
<v Keith Wilson>We happen to have our city debt manager here today.

432
00:43:28.668 --> 00:43:28.844
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

433
00:43:28.972 --> 00:43:29.389
<v Olivia Clark>Oh, super.

434
00:43:29.693 --> 00:43:30.878
<v Olivia Clark>Hello, city debt manager.

435
00:43:31.804 --> 00:43:35.266
<v Olivia Clark>I think we had— that was foreshadowed by one Councilor Ryan.

436
00:43:37.519 --> 00:43:38.335
<v Olivia Clark>Yes, it was foretold.

437
00:43:40.213 --> 00:43:45.516
<v Olivia Clark>The way that we're retiring these is an assessment across all of the bureaus.

438
00:43:45.614 --> 00:43:46.601
<v Olivia Clark>Is that correct?

439
00:43:46.827 --> 00:43:47.539
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes, that's correct.

440
00:43:47.635 --> 00:43:49.768
<v Olivia Clark>And can you talk a little bit about that?

441
00:43:49.818 --> 00:44:03.516
<v Olivia Clark>I'm concerned about these, the way we do this and the assessments and what alternatives there might be in the future for this kind of financing and whether or not this is way of doing it across other governments.

442
00:44:03.581 --> 00:44:10.373
<v Olivia Clark>I think I remember state government doing this kind of thing for certain functions, but can you expand a little bit on that for us?

443
00:44:10.648 --> 00:44:11.277
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so—.

444
00:44:11.632 --> 00:44:13.489
<v Keith Wilson>Could you introduce yourself for the record?

445
00:44:13.748 --> 00:44:14.297
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

446
00:44:14.619 --> 00:44:16.800
<v Christopher Hare>Matt Giurach, debt manager, for the record.

447
00:44:18.500 --> 00:44:26.903
<v Eric Zimmerman>So the debt service is essentially embedded within interagency charges that are passed through to all of the users of the facility.

448
00:44:27.485 --> 00:44:35.117
<v Unidentified speaker>So annually, they'll pay a charge to, you know, run the operations and also pay debt service.

449
00:44:35.471 --> 00:44:41.159
<v Mitch Green>And so it's embedded essentially in that interagency charge conventionally.

450
00:44:41.818 --> 00:44:45.585
<v Olivia Clark>Can you give us a sense of the size of that assessment?

451
00:44:46.730 --> 00:44:57.987
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I believe the debt service estimate It was around $3.3 million for 20 years.

452
00:44:58.260 --> 00:45:03.335
<v Olivia Clark>And so that's spread across the bureaus that use the Future Cutter?

453
00:45:03.739 --> 00:45:04.190
<v Mitch Green>That's correct.

454
00:45:04.286 --> 00:45:06.643
<v Olivia Clark>And it's proportionate to their use?

455
00:45:06.967 --> 00:45:08.065
<v Olivia Clark>Is that how it works?

456
00:45:08.646 --> 00:45:09.469
<v Dan Ryan>I believe so.

457
00:45:11.019 --> 00:45:12.679
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, my name is Aaron Beck.

458
00:45:12.759 --> 00:45:23.384
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm with Business Operations, and I can elaborate a little bit more on the rate rates that we're charging the bureaus that will include the Cutter debt service, lease, and operations and maintenance.

459
00:45:23.865 --> 00:45:27.800
<v Unidentified speaker>Basically, that will be flowing through what we refer to as the fixed vehicle rates.

460
00:45:28.601 --> 00:45:36.967
<v Unidentified speaker>So every vehicle that the bureaus own will include a component in it for the Cutter Garage.

461
00:45:37.369 --> 00:45:42.347
<v Unidentified speaker>So basically, anybody— any bureau with a vehicle will be paying for the Cutter Garage.

462
00:45:42.753 --> 00:45:45.302
<v Olivia Clark>Leveraged on their use, their number of vehicles?

463
00:45:45.739 --> 00:45:46.320
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's correct.

464
00:45:46.932 --> 00:45:53.737
<v Olivia Clark>And is this, I don't know who can answer this question, but is this sort of a normal way of retiring the debt in other local governments?

465
00:45:54.614 --> 00:45:55.894
<v Dan Ryan>I believe so, yes.

466
00:45:56.333 --> 00:45:56.722
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

467
00:45:57.371 --> 00:45:57.858
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

468
00:45:57.954 --> 00:45:58.215
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

469
00:46:00.277 --> 00:46:00.972
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

470
00:46:01.085 --> 00:46:01.585
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you both.

471
00:46:01.648 --> 00:46:04.521
<v Keith Wilson>I suspect we may have other questions, so don't go far, please.

472
00:46:05.182 --> 00:46:05.893
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Ryan.

473
00:46:07.376 --> 00:46:08.603
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thank you, Madam President.

474
00:46:08.731 --> 00:46:12.414
<v Dan Ryan>Well, as I was saying, it's, thank you for the report, Christopher.

475
00:46:12.686 --> 00:46:17.625
<v Dan Ryan>And I really appreciate the work that went into this from the debt manager.

476
00:46:17.898 --> 00:46:23.992
<v Dan Ryan>And I think we are talking about debt financing, and I actually did my homework there, and I think that you're doing everything right there.

477
00:46:24.072 --> 00:46:28.465
<v Dan Ryan>But I just wanted to add on to what Councilor Clark was saying, what a big deal this is.

478
00:46:29.284 --> 00:46:32.715
<v Dan Ryan>We did that tour in 2021, and it was really depressing.

479
00:46:33.548 --> 00:46:38.681
<v Dan Ryan>We did a tour of all the infrastructure, but that one in particular really stood out because the urgency.

480
00:46:38.744 --> 00:46:38.889
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

481
00:46:39.146 --> 00:46:46.818
<v Dan Ryan>And that was, again, it's a century-old building, too small, was never meant to be the city's fleet maintenance function.

482
00:46:47.186 --> 00:46:51.552
<v Dan Ryan>And for years flags were raised about this and there were no viable solutions on the table.

483
00:46:52.306 --> 00:46:57.795
<v Dan Ryan>It was not worth the investment to renovate or replace it, basically because where it's located as well.

484
00:46:58.164 --> 00:47:00.860
<v Dan Ryan>And it was cost prohibitive to purchase another location to build.

485
00:47:01.005 --> 00:47:03.043
<v Dan Ryan>So this has been lingering for some time.

486
00:47:03.460 --> 00:47:04.744
<v Dan Ryan>The solution is a leased space.

487
00:47:05.001 --> 00:47:09.699
<v Dan Ryan>Partnering with the property owner that will allow for the build-out and modern city fleet facility.

488
00:47:10.132 --> 00:47:12.987
<v Dan Ryan>The bond financing allows for that work to be done.

489
00:47:14.365 --> 00:47:15.440
<v Dan Ryan>I want to give credit where it's due.

490
00:47:16.706 --> 00:47:25.797
<v Dan Ryan>Maddie Sauter, you have been on this, and every conversation I seem to have with you the last 5 years would often circle to this.

491
00:47:26.472 --> 00:47:28.059
<v Dan Ryan>So take a bow.

492
00:47:28.731 --> 00:47:29.806
<v Dan Ryan>I assume this will pass.

493
00:47:30.592 --> 00:47:32.693
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you for being a champion and being persistent.

494
00:47:32.773 --> 00:47:32.900
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

495
00:47:34.572 --> 00:47:38.170
<v Dan Ryan>You moved a once-in-a-generation shift for most of our city bureau operations.

496
00:47:38.766 --> 00:47:45.032
<v Dan Ryan>In local government, we often put a lot of energy into important improvements efforts without seeing the results of those efforts.

497
00:47:46.141 --> 00:47:47.378
<v Dan Ryan>That was the case with the Kirby Garage.

498
00:47:47.523 --> 00:47:54.079
<v Dan Ryan>It can take decades of incremental progress on large projects, particularly those that don't have dedicated funding sources.

499
00:47:54.753 --> 00:48:09.643
<v Dan Ryan>So because of these accomplishments and the professionalism of our public servants, I'm really delighted that we're moving forward on this, and we just have to make sure we keep our fiscal house in order so that our bond rating remains high, which will save us a lot of money throughout the duration of this project.

500
00:48:09.996 --> 00:48:10.302
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

501
00:48:12.235 --> 00:48:12.927
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

502
00:48:13.362 --> 00:48:13.974
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Green.

503
00:48:16.260 --> 00:48:16.822
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you.

504
00:48:16.887 --> 00:48:33.826
<v Mitch Green>I just— this was a really rich discussion in the Finance Committee, and a couple of things that we flagged and I just wanted to raise for the full body was the quality, I think I appreciated the quality of the clarity and transparency in the presentation on the estimated cost allocations and debt service.

505
00:48:33.873 --> 00:48:39.335
<v Mitch Green>So if you're following along at home, it's slide 7 in the presentation attached to this item.

506
00:48:39.398 --> 00:48:50.208
<v Mitch Green>But, you know, they give you the repayment schedule over the lifetime of the bond, which is the $3.4 million annual— on an annual basis, but it also shows you which bureaus pay it.

507
00:48:50.786 --> 00:48:58.570
<v Mitch Green>And that it's roughly 34% of general fund bureaus will shoulder the cost of the internal service charge.

508
00:48:59.949 --> 00:49:12.130
<v Mitch Green>You know, I think in the absence of other types of revenue streams that pay back these sorts of costs, I struggle to think of a different compensation model and cost allocation model that makes sense.

509
00:49:12.226 --> 00:49:15.307
<v Mitch Green>But I do appreciate my colleague here asking the question.

510
00:49:16.784 --> 00:49:35.670
<v Mitch Green>I think for me, this is a slam dunk because we currently are dealing with a situation where we face essentially a growing liability of operations and maintenance cost because we have a capacity or an asset that has very limited capacity value.

511
00:49:36.253 --> 00:49:57.329
<v Mitch Green>And so you have the situation, I think, Mattie, you had talked about how there's, given the constraints on the current Cutter Garage, that there are folks— or I'm sorry, the Kirby Garage— that there are folks in bureaus who think, okay, well, I have to have maybe an extra couple trucks, 2, 3 couple trucks, because I don't know when I'm going to get my asset back.

512
00:49:57.827 --> 00:50:10.206
<v Mitch Green>And so making this investment, while we do incur the $3.4 million per year, I'm pretty confident that that's going to result in some savings across our enterprise as we were able to make more efficient use of our resources and staff time.

513
00:50:10.271 --> 00:50:15.159
<v Mitch Green>And so, and echo the praise to the staff who've been able to managing these conditions for so long.

514
00:50:15.255 --> 00:50:18.135
<v Mitch Green>I was there and I was kind of like, you know, there's a sloped floor.

515
00:50:18.248 --> 00:50:20.871
<v Mitch Green>You shouldn't have sloped floors in a maintenance shop.

516
00:50:20.934 --> 00:50:24.041
<v Mitch Green>I felt like I was a crooked little man in a crooked little house in a enchanted forest.

517
00:50:25.929 --> 00:50:29.115
<v Mitch Green>So I will be voting yes when this finally does come before.

518
00:50:29.905 --> 00:50:43.811
<v Mitch Green>Finally, if you're interested in bond finance, the last slide here, second to last slide, does give you a sense of what our recent issuances for our limited tax revenue bonds have been priced, and it's pretty favorable.

519
00:50:44.621 --> 00:50:52.164
<v Mitch Green>And so I think I appreciate that the package before us assumes a 5% cost of capital.

520
00:50:53.016 --> 00:50:57.637
<v Mitch Green>There's the potential that we can probably do a little bit better than that when we do finally place these bonds.

521
00:50:57.686 --> 00:51:05.597
<v Mitch Green>And so I think that's a credit to our commitment to our financial reserves policies at the city.

522
00:51:06.871 --> 00:51:09.409
<v Mitch Green>And I'm looking forward to more opportunity there.

523
00:51:09.474 --> 00:51:10.023
<v Mitch Green>So thank you.

524
00:51:12.045 --> 00:51:12.789
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

525
00:51:13.014 --> 00:51:13.726
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Dunphy.

526
00:51:13.920 --> 00:51:14.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

527
00:51:14.826 --> 00:51:28.005
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mostly want to reflect the comments my colleagues have already said and give my thanks to Maddie for giving a tour of the Kirby Garage and the terrible conditions that our workers have been enduring.

528
00:51:28.342 --> 00:51:33.085
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's been over 3 and a half years since the Willamette Week first called out how terrible the conditions were.

529
00:51:33.668 --> 00:51:39.083
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm glad the City Council is jumping on this in our first year to try and finish the work.

530
00:51:40.356 --> 00:51:49.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>More than anything, I have been stuck with the image of the sloped floors and the requirement that at least one mechanic has to lay on their back in a puddle at the bottom of the slope.

531
00:51:50.512 --> 00:52:00.086
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's unreasonable beyond the lack of heating and cooling options in the seasonal, you know, seasonal fluctuations.

532
00:52:00.135 --> 00:52:05.429
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, uh, enthusiastic about getting this done, and let's, uh, get rid of the Kirby Garage and move over to Cutter.

533
00:52:05.655 --> 00:52:06.248
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

534
00:52:07.677 --> 00:52:08.302
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

535
00:52:08.382 --> 00:52:09.137
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Smith.

536
00:52:09.907 --> 00:52:10.869
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

537
00:52:10.965 --> 00:52:11.784
<v Loretta Smith>Is, is Maddie here?

538
00:52:12.795 --> 00:52:14.592
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, I'm sorry.

539
00:52:14.721 --> 00:52:20.882
<v Loretta Smith>I just wanted to personally thank you, and I think all the commissioners, councilors up here, they've said the same thing.

540
00:52:21.315 --> 00:52:23.065
<v Loretta Smith>It was so important for us to see this.

541
00:52:23.242 --> 00:52:35.793
<v Loretta Smith>It's one thing to read about it, and we have never been there before, But to actually go see it, um, you and your, um, staff were great in making sure that all of us had an opportunity to go see it.

542
00:52:36.034 --> 00:52:36.791
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you.

543
00:52:36.840 --> 00:52:48.414
<v Loretta Smith>I know you're probably like, okay, I don't need all this praise, but, but you do, because oftentimes people put things on the agenda and they never even offer to let us see what we're talking about.

544
00:52:48.978 --> 00:52:50.072
<v Loretta Smith>But, but you did that.

545
00:52:50.586 --> 00:52:54.898
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, the question that I have, as I'm I'm looking at the financial and budgetary impacts.

546
00:52:54.945 --> 00:52:58.907
<v Loretta Smith>This is not necessarily for you, Mattie, but, um, for our staff.

547
00:52:59.467 --> 00:53:06.813
<v Loretta Smith>It said that with the issuance of the bonds, the Cutter Garage will have approximately $7 million of ongoing costs.

548
00:53:06.925 --> 00:53:18.278
<v Loretta Smith>So this is new costs that I'm thinking that this is, including debt service, which we already talked about for the $3.3 million, operating and maintenance.

549
00:53:18.728 --> 00:53:23.844
<v Loretta Smith>So can you explain to me what the additional $4 million— I mean, I see that.

550
00:53:24.389 --> 00:53:27.934
<v Loretta Smith>Can you kind of break that out for me above and beyond what we're doing right now?

551
00:53:28.014 --> 00:53:38.358
<v Loretta Smith>Because we're doing maintenance right now, so why would we need additional maintenance dollars on top of the $3.3 million in debt costs?

552
00:53:39.481 --> 00:53:48.306
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, the difference between the 2 numbers is the annual lease cost, which is new for the city out there at the Cutter Garage.

553
00:53:48.851 --> 00:53:57.699
<v Unidentified speaker>And then there are additional maintenance or just ongoing costs with a newer facility because we want to really keep it up in good shape.

554
00:53:58.342 --> 00:54:01.873
<v Unidentified speaker>And then there's another component which is what we would call major maintenance.

555
00:54:02.420 --> 00:54:17.411
<v Unidentified speaker>And this is something that when we go into the Cutter Garage, we want to make sure that we're annually, annually setting aside 3 of the replacement value of all the improvements that we did to that facility so that we can keep it in good shape throughout the term of the lease.

556
00:54:18.389 --> 00:54:24.260
<v Unidentified speaker>So the combination of all of those makes up the— or comes to the $7 million.

557
00:54:24.597 --> 00:54:25.949
<v Loretta Smith>Are we leasing it to ourselves?

558
00:54:26.710 --> 00:54:28.420
<v Unidentified speaker>We're leasing it from a third party.

559
00:54:28.925 --> 00:54:29.119
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

560
00:54:30.407 --> 00:54:32.003
<v Loretta Smith>And they didn't identify who that was?

561
00:54:33.831 --> 00:54:38.476
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so we are leasing it from the Melitus Company.

562
00:54:38.588 --> 00:54:39.775
<v Keith Wilson>Company, basically.

563
00:54:40.016 --> 00:54:54.315
<v Unidentified speaker>And just to provide a little bit of context, so best practices in facility management is that every year you set aside 3% of the replacement value of a facility to help support the building systems that fail while you're in that facility.

564
00:54:54.476 --> 00:54:58.809
<v Unidentified speaker>You can think of in your house, it's the roof or the sewer line, et cetera.

565
00:54:58.954 --> 00:54:59.532
<v Olivia Clark>Things fail.

566
00:55:00.094 --> 00:55:02.661
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a triple net lease, which we rarely get into.

567
00:55:02.742 --> 00:55:05.679
<v Unidentified speaker>We try to do full-service leases as much as we can.

568
00:55:06.097 --> 00:55:10.809
<v Unidentified speaker>But when you are in this long of a lease, often the only option available is a triple net lease.

569
00:55:10.873 --> 00:55:13.876
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that puts you on the hook for some of the major maintenance funding.

570
00:55:13.940 --> 00:55:25.050
<v Unidentified speaker>So the landlord is responsible for a portion of it, but you also have to set aside money for certain contributions you may need to make to building systems.

571
00:55:25.099 --> 00:55:28.101
<v Unidentified speaker>And then of course within the shell, you have your systems as well.

572
00:55:28.166 --> 00:55:30.909
<v Unidentified speaker>So we'll have our own HVAC, for example, within that area.

573
00:55:31.579 --> 00:55:41.670
<v Unidentified speaker>So one of the concerns that we have and something that's happened citywide is that the city does not set aside 3% of the replacement value for facilities when we maintain them.

574
00:55:41.766 --> 00:55:44.690
<v Unidentified speaker>Even this facility doesn't have— we're not hitting that target.

575
00:55:45.204 --> 00:55:57.175
<v Unidentified speaker>That is a budget note that's been in existence for probably almost a decade now, is to bring that major maintenance funding up in our rates, but we've never had the institutional support and financial capacity to do that.

576
00:55:57.592 --> 00:56:02.971
<v Unidentified speaker>At the Kirby Garage, the major maintenance was almost zero.

577
00:56:03.469 --> 00:56:05.219
<v Unidentified speaker>So the net increase that you see—.

578
00:56:05.219 --> 00:56:06.407
<v Loretta Smith>But you had to increase that.

579
00:56:06.503 --> 00:56:13.215
<v Unidentified speaker>In prices, it's going from basically 0% or very, very little to the appropriate amount.

580
00:56:13.262 --> 00:56:17.742
<v Unidentified speaker>So we decided since we're doing a new facility, let's do it the right way.

581
00:56:17.902 --> 00:56:21.916
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that structure reflects a bunch of new costs that don't exist.

582
00:56:22.302 --> 00:56:35.409
<v Unidentified speaker>One of those costs, the debt service, will go away in 20 years, but ideally, The buildup of funding for major maintenance will help avoid some of the challenges that we're currently having at Kirby Garage because we'll have money as we go to invest in systems as they start to fail.

583
00:56:36.436 --> 00:56:46.429
<v Loretta Smith>And Director Sautter, this is very important because we passed a resolution in the transportation infrastructure to do an evaluation of all of our assets.

584
00:56:46.815 --> 00:56:50.864
<v Loretta Smith>And so understanding that too, that I didn't know that information.

585
00:56:50.911 --> 00:56:55.360
<v Loretta Smith>So as we're looking at that and we get the report back, from the city administrator.

586
00:56:55.795 --> 00:57:00.547
<v Loretta Smith>And you all, I think you're probably working on the, on the committee that is going to bring it all back.

587
00:57:01.172 --> 00:57:10.244
<v Loretta Smith>Those are the kind of things that we also need to keep in mind as we're talking about how do we deal with maintaining our assets that we do have, what is going to be the cost point.

588
00:57:10.581 --> 00:57:16.103
<v Loretta Smith>And so I didn't think about that, and I was looking at this and I was like, well, where did this extra $4 million come from?

589
00:57:16.521 --> 00:57:24.108
<v Loretta Smith>But the other piece that, that you all did not talk about I know we're voting on the debt service and doing the bonds.

590
00:57:24.878 --> 00:57:25.518
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

591
00:57:25.648 --> 00:57:33.534
<v Loretta Smith>But the thing that we're talking about is that we're also creating an apprenticeship program with PCC.

592
00:57:34.465 --> 00:57:39.755
<v Loretta Smith>And currently there are no apprenticeship programs that deal with maintenance of this kind.

593
00:57:40.411 --> 00:57:43.907
<v Loretta Smith>And so in addition to this, this is also gonna help us to create jobs.

594
00:57:45.536 --> 00:57:51.309
<v Loretta Smith>Authored a, uh, a resolution around apprenticeships that we passed in the Labor and Workforce Committee.

595
00:57:51.744 --> 00:57:57.467
<v Loretta Smith>And so this— these are the kinds of things that I think that we all need to know about, and that's happening in addition to this.

596
00:57:58.016 --> 00:58:08.750
<v Loretta Smith>And so, um, I just want to say thank you, thank you, thank you for this, because it is also, uh, expanding our base of knowledge of, of, you know, and creating jobs.

597
00:58:09.041 --> 00:58:10.688
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you so much.

598
00:58:12.623 --> 00:58:12.760
<v Loretta Smith>Welcome.

599
00:58:13.050 --> 00:58:13.800
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

600
00:58:15.353 --> 00:58:22.987
<v Keith Wilson>Um, I said a lot about this in committee, so I'm not going to say much right now, but this is absolutely necessary.

601
00:58:23.291 --> 00:58:25.206
<v Keith Wilson>It is being done responsibly.

602
00:58:25.481 --> 00:58:30.344
<v Keith Wilson>Our city needs this for efficient operations, and our employees who work in the garage need this as well.

603
00:58:31.117 --> 00:58:49.887
<v Keith Wilson>I did want to note that a piece of the conversation in the Finance Committee was about why this i often look to figure out how we can save costs in the long run, even if that means a little more cost upfront, and sometimes purchasing is a good way to do that.

604
00:58:50.592 --> 00:59:01.798
<v Keith Wilson>I was very convinced by your answers, Maddie, about the flexibility that we might need in the future and the fact that doing a lease now so that we can reevaluate where we need these offices is a good way to do that.

605
00:59:01.847 --> 00:59:01.958
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

606
00:59:02.039 --> 00:59:09.567
<v Keith Wilson>Operations in the future is a conversation that we can have without the sunk costs of having purchased a building now.

607
00:59:10.177 --> 00:59:22.342
<v Keith Wilson>I just wanted to note that because I really appreciated the deal— the detail you went into in explaining that calculation, both from a fiscal perspective and also from just a practicability for city operations.

608
00:59:22.471 --> 00:59:23.418
<v Keith Wilson>So thank you.

609
00:59:24.621 --> 00:59:25.391
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Zimmerman.

610
00:59:26.869 --> 00:59:27.077
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

611
00:59:27.126 --> 00:59:34.990
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have a few questions, but since one is related to the point you just brought up, I'd actually I would like it if the bureau director can go into that a little bit.

612
00:59:35.103 --> 00:59:35.443
<v Eric Zimmerman>For—.

613
00:59:35.572 --> 00:59:41.590
<v Eric Zimmerman>To ask the city to invest $41 million into a piece of property we don't own, for me, is a big lift.

614
00:59:42.951 --> 00:59:55.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to be confident that not including the property costs was not a tactic to keep the bond low in order to get the bond through.

615
00:59:56.579 --> 00:59:56.949
<v Eric Zimmerman>Right.

616
00:59:57.806 --> 01:00:07.838
<v Eric Zimmerman>The case has been deeply made, and I agree that especially for those Launa workers who are in the shop, I mean, they have been doing a great job with what they have, and we need a new shop.

617
01:00:08.641 --> 01:00:14.820
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is a lift though, and in my career, highly unusual to invest this much money in someone else's property.

618
01:00:15.719 --> 01:00:18.864
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can you talk about a little bit what Council President alluded to there?

619
01:00:19.876 --> 01:00:20.550
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, for sure.

620
01:00:21.577 --> 01:00:36.226
<v Unidentified speaker>So we actually already made 2 attempts to do what I think common knowledge suggests, which is that you should procure a property and own it or build a purpose-built facility for this type of technical operation.

621
01:00:36.739 --> 01:00:38.150
<v Unidentified speaker>So we made a run at that.

622
01:00:38.246 --> 01:00:42.081
<v Unidentified speaker>I can't exactly remember the years, but it was probably '20, '21.

623
01:00:42.545 --> 01:00:43.300
<v Olivia Clark>'22.

624
01:00:43.862 --> 01:00:46.893
<v Unidentified speaker>That didn't make it out of committee at the OMF level.

625
01:00:47.311 --> 01:00:52.541
<v Unidentified speaker>And then we made an effort the second time to get funding to buy land.

626
01:00:52.942 --> 01:01:01.115
<v Unidentified speaker>So that we could then do programming and go out for a bond of some kind, either this type of bond or maybe even a general obligation bond.

627
01:01:01.195 --> 01:01:06.719
<v Unidentified speaker>So both of those efforts were attempted and didn't pass muster because they were too expensive.

628
01:01:07.409 --> 01:01:11.489
<v Unidentified speaker>So that is part of the reason that we switched tactics to this approach.

629
01:01:11.971 --> 01:01:25.025
<v Unidentified speaker>But there is, as Councilor Pirtle-Guiney explained, a bigger picture challenge, which is within the facility and land management, which has come up, I think, a couple of times when we've come to the table here.

630
01:01:25.074 --> 01:01:31.898
<v Unidentified speaker>It came up with a small parcel on Southeast Powell where we prompted a discussion about land management and what that looks like.

631
01:01:31.961 --> 01:01:34.338
<v Unidentified speaker>It's coming up, I think, in the asset management strategy.

632
01:01:34.596 --> 01:01:36.715
<v Unidentified speaker>It's been decided where it will be addressed.

633
01:01:37.340 --> 01:01:43.009
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a challenge, which is that facilities are a particularly decayed asset base for the city.

634
01:01:43.684 --> 01:01:45.659
<v Unidentified speaker>We would like to see— Councilor Loretta Smith.

635
01:01:46.012 --> 01:01:53.148
<v Unidentified speaker>More enhanced and comprehensive long-range facility planning by portfolio, whether it's public safety, public works, et cetera.

636
01:01:53.277 --> 01:01:55.443
<v Unidentified speaker>We just completed a public safety master plan actually.

637
01:01:56.119 --> 01:02:07.021
<v Unidentified speaker>And one of the findings of that, and I think you'll find the same in a public works plan should it launch, is that the city needs large acreages of land in order to do what it needs to do.

638
01:02:07.798 --> 01:02:12.061
<v Unidentified speaker>And that is really hard to find within an urban growth boundary like we have.

639
01:02:12.110 --> 01:02:12.157
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

640
01:02:12.382 --> 01:02:24.090
<v Unidentified speaker>That's even a particularly added challenge when you think about seismic requirements and what we are really expecting from resilient public works organizations or resilient public safety organizations, et cetera.

641
01:02:24.748 --> 01:02:36.360
<v Unidentified speaker>So until we solve the land problem and understand how we're gonna find these parcels and obtain these parcels to build the facilities that we need, we can't exactly solve for a long-term facilities problem.

642
01:02:36.985 --> 01:02:42.230
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we are waiting for the city to effectively take shape in that.

643
01:02:42.293 --> 01:02:46.367
<v Unidentified speaker>I think the asset management strategy is gonna suggest some approaches to that.

644
01:02:47.023 --> 01:02:50.840
<v Unidentified speaker>But we are in a situation with Kirby where we can't really wait any longer.

645
01:02:51.097 --> 01:03:07.630
<v Unidentified speaker>And so thus, this approach worked not just financially, but also from a space and time standpoint, which is we have a 23-year lease that is long enough with 2 10-year extensions for us to feel like that would be the normal lifecycle of a building anyway.

646
01:03:07.773 --> 01:03:23.677
<v Unidentified speaker>And so this is probably a warranted investment, but it's not such a sunk cost that if we end up being able to find a parcel of land and build a Public Works campus, that we wouldn't be able to then also program in a City Fleet operation in that campus to support that.

647
01:03:24.271 --> 01:03:30.809
<v Unidentified speaker>So we were, you know, sometimes you're not in the most optimal situation, you're in what is the least suboptimal situation.

648
01:03:30.922 --> 01:03:32.626
<v Unidentified speaker>And I would say that was the situation here.

649
01:03:33.413 --> 01:03:48.650
<v Unidentified speaker>So over time, our sort of next I think the next step is to, you know, we're trying to steward internally discussions about land management for facility needs, not just for public needs like housing, but also for city needs, how we would approach that.

650
01:03:48.809 --> 01:03:56.018
<v Unidentified speaker>And then what does that mean for consolidated long-range facility planning and investment to benefit city operations?

651
01:03:56.516 --> 01:03:57.992
<v Unidentified speaker>Because they're vital facilities.

652
01:03:58.041 --> 01:04:02.007
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, you think of the 911 center or police precincts or fire stations, they're not nonessential.

653
01:04:02.070 --> 01:04:02.166
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

654
01:04:02.989 --> 01:04:03.119
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

655
01:04:03.507 --> 01:04:07.119
<v Eric Zimmerman>I mean, I certainly think 43 years falls in the long-term planning category.

656
01:04:07.168 --> 01:04:10.085
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what is the valuation of the lot that we are taking over?

657
01:04:11.637 --> 01:04:13.849
<v Unidentified speaker>I do not know the answer to that offhand.

658
01:04:14.400 --> 01:04:14.561
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

659
01:04:14.786 --> 01:04:16.757
<v Unidentified speaker>The value of the parcel that we're on?

660
01:04:16.983 --> 01:04:18.114
<v Eric Zimmerman>The other guy's property.

661
01:04:18.275 --> 01:04:18.777
<v Unidentified speaker>The other guy's property.

662
01:04:18.826 --> 01:04:18.954
<v Unidentified speaker>I do not know.

663
01:04:19.003 --> 01:04:22.440
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we're about to add $41 million worth of work to it.

664
01:04:22.635 --> 01:04:33.070
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we're really talking about $100 million worth of value add to that piece of property that if we were to buy it in 23 or 43 years, we've deeply increased the odds.

665
01:04:33.117 --> 01:04:35.351
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm curious on 2 fronts.

666
01:04:35.592 --> 01:04:46.844
<v Eric Zimmerman>What is in the lease agreement to guarantee our position that if— I think you said Maltese sells this to Smith— that Smith doesn't then want to renegotiate?

667
01:04:46.940 --> 01:04:54.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then also, what parameters exist in the lease for our rent-to-own situation so that we can recognize the value that we put into it?

668
01:04:55.297 --> 01:04:56.675
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so we have an option to buy.

669
01:04:56.981 --> 01:04:58.920
<v Unidentified speaker>So we have right of first refusal on the buy.

670
01:04:59.833 --> 01:05:03.277
<v Unidentified speaker>So if it goes to market, we're the first group to look at that.

671
01:05:03.838 --> 01:05:11.193
<v Unidentified speaker>And then there is just of note a second unused warehouse adjacent to what we're building out.

672
01:05:11.947 --> 01:05:15.103
<v Unidentified speaker>We have right of first refusal on that property as well.

673
01:05:15.248 --> 01:05:20.568
<v Unidentified speaker>So that would be if other city functions wanted to go and co-locate with us.

674
01:05:20.615 --> 01:05:24.253
<v Unidentified speaker>So for example, Fire has its own fleet operation.

675
01:05:24.302 --> 01:05:27.619
<v Unidentified speaker>It's the only operation that's separate from City Fleets for vehicles.

676
01:05:28.211 --> 01:05:32.025
<v Unidentified speaker>So they're on a property that is suboptimal for those operations.

677
01:05:32.619 --> 01:05:41.030
<v Unidentified speaker>If they wanted to and were able to move to that facility, that might be a good co-location to save on operations like parts management, et cetera.

678
01:05:41.751 --> 01:05:44.829
<v Unidentified speaker>BTS has a slightly adjacent function.

679
01:05:44.876 --> 01:05:47.264
<v Unidentified speaker>They do all of the radio upfitting for police vehicles.

680
01:05:47.313 --> 01:05:47.521
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

681
01:05:47.826 --> 01:05:49.735
<v Unidentified speaker>That's currently done at the PCC building.

682
01:05:50.329 --> 01:05:53.476
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that's another potential adjacency that we could create.

683
01:05:53.556 --> 01:06:06.333
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, but I'm not hearing that there's any protection for our investment to be recognized because I see today if we were in a purchase agreement, that lot has a number to it without all of our improvements on it.

684
01:06:06.927 --> 01:06:15.355
<v Eric Zimmerman>Tomorrow they list it for an exorbitant amount and now we have first right of refusal, but it's a huge number because we improved that lot.

685
01:06:16.514 --> 01:06:32.797
<v Eric Zimmerman>Lot, uh, or have we just given a situation for 2 entities to increase valuation on a lot and have us either over the barrel or having to read— or having to not be able to execute because we've now increased this lot price by so much?

686
01:06:36.036 --> 01:06:36.648
<v Unidentified speaker>Question.

687
01:06:36.746 --> 01:06:40.628
<v Unidentified speaker>I, you know, we're doing pretty customized— well, let's see.

688
01:06:41.400 --> 01:06:48.782
<v Unidentified speaker>We're doing pretty customized investments in that facility, so I don't think there's any other fleet operator that they're— the values that we're putting in there are only for us.

689
01:06:48.847 --> 01:06:54.778
<v Unidentified speaker>But I do agree that would put us over a barrel in the sense that everybody knows how much we've spent on this.

690
01:06:55.054 --> 01:06:58.869
<v Unidentified speaker>And so you wanna stay here, I'm gonna double your rent, for example.

691
01:06:59.045 --> 01:07:00.813
<v Unidentified speaker>So I suppose that is a possibility.

692
01:07:01.929 --> 01:07:03.458
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm less concerned about the doubling of the rent.

693
01:07:03.507 --> 01:07:08.768
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm more concerned with this idea that we are the entity increasing someone else's liability.

694
01:07:10.074 --> 01:07:16.400
<v Eric Zimmerman>And because we have first right of refusal, that sounds like it might be a good option for us to acquire that property in the future.

695
01:07:16.840 --> 01:07:34.079
<v Eric Zimmerman>But now instead of a blank piece of land or a lean-to piece of land, we've got a piece of land with, I think, probably a future $50 million to $100 million piece of improvement on top of it that we might not even be able to fathom purchasing the land for.

696
01:07:34.161 --> 01:07:34.679
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a great point.

697
01:07:34.945 --> 01:07:37.514
<v Eric Zimmerman>From out because somebody else can give them a bigger number.

698
01:07:37.610 --> 01:07:39.519
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's what I'm curious how we protect our value.

699
01:07:40.498 --> 01:07:42.762
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I guess I would have to think about that a bit.

700
01:07:42.826 --> 01:07:51.943
<v Unidentified speaker>The tenant improvements that we're making are so specialized to a fleet operation that I don't know that there's another fleet operation that would come in and say, well, I'm going to buy that instead.

701
01:07:52.070 --> 01:07:54.735
<v Eric Zimmerman>But except that Swan Island has a lot of fleets, right?

702
01:07:54.782 --> 01:07:54.960
<v Michael Jordan>It does.

703
01:07:55.023 --> 01:07:56.644
<v Eric Zimmerman>A lot of big trucks that operate on that.

704
01:07:56.708 --> 01:07:58.731
<v Eric Zimmerman>In fact, I think it's almost the only thing that operates there.

705
01:07:58.795 --> 01:08:11.456
<v Eric Zimmerman>So it's not beyond me that It's not beyond me that Daimler could expand into this place in that sense because we have big trucks, we have small trucks, other people have big trucks, other people have small trucks.

706
01:08:12.161 --> 01:08:24.068
<v Eric Zimmerman>Maybe the— but in 43 years, if there's not a fleet who is challenging the City of Portland's fleet at that site, I'd be surprised by that because of the business that happens in this location.

707
01:08:24.756 --> 01:08:27.625
<v Eric Zimmerman>So for that, I do have some concerns in that area.

708
01:08:27.672 --> 01:08:27.896
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

709
01:08:27.944 --> 01:08:28.104
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

710
01:08:28.747 --> 01:08:47.145
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that that hasn't really been, to me, fleshed out in enough of a way by the Bureau to— for such a significant investment and what is different than most of the bonding that we do on improvements that we do in government.

711
01:08:48.385 --> 01:09:00.041
<v Eric Zimmerman>The other piece, and I really appreciated the 3% maintenance reserve, I would like to see, of course, our facilities in each building having that reserve to it.

712
01:09:00.298 --> 01:09:02.367
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I hear those notes that we're missing.

713
01:09:03.797 --> 01:09:17.257
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm also— I am wondering how the bureau, how you are going to tackle this with the customers, right?

714
01:09:17.305 --> 01:09:24.042
<v Eric Zimmerman>The customers in the presentation are all those who are paying for this building and out of their off the top of their budget each year.

715
01:09:24.974 --> 01:09:28.073
<v Eric Zimmerman>PBOT, water, parks, other, police, fire, BES.

716
01:09:29.068 --> 01:09:44.064
<v Eric Zimmerman>And when one of the common themes I hear from all other bureaus is that they feel like they're screaming into the void when it comes to internal service funds, internal service rates, how to feel like the customer in their relationship with facilities.

717
01:09:45.123 --> 01:09:50.701
<v Eric Zimmerman>And this is much less about I think that that's not what I'm talking about.

718
01:09:50.765 --> 01:10:16.311
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I'm talking about is the occupant of a building feeling like they are— I am wondering, and I want to make sure that these bond rates— excuse me, these debt service payments are not contributing to increased internal service rates when that remains a very big question mark in our organization about the validity of what customers are feeling.

719
01:10:16.425 --> 01:10:29.634
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to make sure that these are separated out, that fleet isn't going to cause any sort of other wrinkle with a part of our organization I think that is going through a let's figure it out and make sure that our rates are all true to one another.

720
01:10:30.051 --> 01:10:37.921
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because this is an area that I haven't been able to get a coherent answer on yet for the direction that we're going and how to improve that customer relationship.

721
01:10:37.970 --> 01:10:45.136
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I, I think of the bureaus as customers of facilities, but they don't often portray that to me.

722
01:10:50.461 --> 01:10:55.047
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm not exactly sure what the question is, but—.

723
01:10:55.047 --> 01:11:20.118
<v Eric Zimmerman>So do you think that— to make it easier, do you think that the Bureau is positioned to take on this project and work with with all of the bureaus, all of the departments to ensure that our internal service rates are more transparent and that the customer service relationship is improved?

724
01:11:21.480 --> 01:11:28.314
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so there was an evaluation done by a third-party consultant related to internal service rates earlier this year.

725
01:11:28.460 --> 01:11:32.823
<v Unidentified speaker>In fact, the first Internal Service Fund governance meeting is actually this afternoon.

726
01:11:33.578 --> 01:11:56.693
<v Unidentified speaker>And the first order of business for that committee is to help ensure that the bureaus as customers have a better comprehension of the actual escalation in costs that are creating internal service fund charges as compared to what has historically been communicated to the bureaus, which was just the rate of inflation.

727
01:11:57.161 --> 01:11:58.130
<v Unidentified speaker>So there's a big delta there.

728
01:11:58.582 --> 01:12:02.006
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, internal service funds don't, Fundamentally generate their own costs.

729
01:12:02.104 --> 01:12:08.981
<v Unidentified speaker>They're just accounting vessels through which the costs of the city flow to provide those types of services.

730
01:12:09.029 --> 01:12:26.340
<v Unidentified speaker>So to control Internal Service Fund costs, we are really talking about controlling city costs, and that's making sure we have a strategic plan, that we have efficient bureau operations, that people participate in, you know, standards where possible because those reduce long-term costs.

731
01:12:26.389 --> 01:12:27.835
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think there's a more holistic— Yeah.

732
01:12:27.930 --> 01:12:28.335
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

733
01:12:28.514 --> 01:12:33.126
<v Unidentified speaker>Discussion about, you know, really what is it that drives a cost within the city.

734
01:12:33.726 --> 01:12:41.123
<v Unidentified speaker>Within that, I do think that we aspire to have a customer service orientation.

735
01:12:43.359 --> 01:12:49.266
<v Unidentified speaker>I do think it's been really hard to communicate why we have rules about some of the things that we do.

736
01:12:51.710 --> 01:12:54.365
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, like for example, why would we buy standardized furniture?

737
01:12:54.895 --> 01:12:55.088
<v Unidentified speaker>Right?

738
01:12:55.153 --> 01:12:57.190
<v Unidentified speaker>Why is that an issue here?

739
01:12:57.479 --> 01:13:00.095
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's because it's warrantied, it's commercial grade.

740
01:13:00.608 --> 01:13:04.893
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a little more expensive upfront, but over time, the lifecycle cost of that is lower.

741
01:13:05.806 --> 01:13:11.856
<v Unidentified speaker>In fact, when we built out City Hall, we saved over $600,000 because we have a furniture standard.

742
01:13:11.921 --> 01:13:15.483
<v Unidentified speaker>So we were able to reuse furniture from PBOT and deploy it here.

743
01:13:16.189 --> 01:13:27.231
<v Unidentified speaker>So I don't know that that has to be a tense conversation in terms of being able to create some mobility for people when they want things that are different than what is standard.

744
01:13:27.793 --> 01:13:43.592
<v Unidentified speaker>But I do feel like holistically it is important for the city to at least understand that when we have a lot of variation in things, we end up with a lot of costs because we end up kind of with a boutique service as opposed to a standardized array of public services that we're trying to offer everybody.

745
01:13:43.640 --> 01:13:46.899
<v Unidentified speaker>So in fleet, for example, we do have standardized equipment.

746
01:13:47.157 --> 01:13:53.606
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, not— one of the biggest wins we've had recently is getting people to not have to have their Dodge pickup.

747
01:13:53.814 --> 01:13:57.068
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't have Dodge pickups, we have Ford pickups.

748
01:13:57.180 --> 01:14:01.970
<v Unidentified speaker>And that helps with parts, it helps with training, it helps with efficient maintenance.

749
01:14:02.307 --> 01:14:07.243
<v Unidentified speaker>So one of the challenges I think in charter reform is just changing the culture of the city.

750
01:14:07.610 --> 01:14:10.030
<v Unidentified speaker>We are a culture of a lot, we have a lot of autonomy here.

751
01:14:10.158 --> 01:14:12.050
<v Unidentified speaker>We have a lot of expectations of autonomy.

752
01:14:12.787 --> 01:14:14.341
<v Unidentified speaker>And autonomy is very expensive.

753
01:14:14.404 --> 01:14:20.257
<v Unidentified speaker>And so trying to help people understand that as one city, that means sometimes we don't get all that we want.

754
01:14:20.337 --> 01:14:23.568
<v Unidentified speaker>We get what we want within an array of things.

755
01:14:23.615 --> 01:14:26.734
<v Unidentified speaker>That's just a much more efficient and cost-effective way to run the city.

756
01:14:27.150 --> 01:14:36.460
<v Unidentified speaker>But I do agree that balancing that has to happen in relation to understanding that, communicating that, and then creating options and being flexible where possible.

757
01:14:37.140 --> 01:14:48.864
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think we're all on that learning path together, trying to make sure that people have a balance between cost-effective, warranted standard options and— You know, a desire to personalize a little bit.

758
01:14:48.930 --> 01:14:51.931
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we're learning that balance as well right now.

759
01:14:52.445 --> 01:14:54.002
<v Unidentified speaker>It's— we're going from a culture of—.

760
01:14:54.002 --> 01:14:54.083
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

761
01:14:54.163 --> 01:14:54.805
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think a lot of this—.

762
01:14:54.951 --> 01:14:55.560
<v Eric Zimmerman>It would be crazy to—.

763
01:14:55.818 --> 01:15:00.185
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think a lot of what I've heard actually existed far before this change in government.

764
01:15:00.394 --> 01:15:03.220
<v Eric Zimmerman>These are bureaus that have existed for decades, if not longer.

765
01:15:03.300 --> 01:15:11.377
<v Eric Zimmerman>But moving on, with respect to the project, will you plan to bring on an owner's rep for this, or is this going to be managed internally?

766
01:15:12.932 --> 01:15:15.996
<v Unidentified speaker>For design and construction?

767
01:15:16.621 --> 01:15:16.782
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

768
01:15:17.422 --> 01:15:19.139
<v Unidentified speaker>We're bringing on an owner's rep right now.

769
01:15:19.765 --> 01:15:22.345
<v Unidentified speaker>So in fact, this week we're bringing on an owner's rep.

770
01:15:22.555 --> 01:15:26.659
<v Eric Zimmerman>And will that be coming back to council for action or approval of that contract, or how's that work?

771
01:15:26.948 --> 01:15:29.337
<v Unidentified speaker>No, that— there's already an existing contract with the city.

772
01:15:29.675 --> 01:15:31.952
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a contract with Cumming Group.

773
01:15:32.079 --> 01:15:33.219
<v Unidentified speaker>It's owned by BES.

774
01:15:33.298 --> 01:15:39.024
<v Unidentified speaker>So all we do is put a purchase order together, and they'll be overseeing construction administration.

775
01:15:39.840 --> 01:15:41.046
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thank you, Madam President.

776
01:15:42.579 --> 01:15:44.442
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

777
01:15:44.555 --> 01:15:50.872
<v Keith Wilson>Uh, colleagues, I believe most folks in the queue have spoken once already, so I'm going to, uh, jump to Councilor Novick.

778
01:15:54.689 --> 01:16:14.387
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to note that— I mean, first of all, I want to reiterate everything that everybody has said about, um, the thanks due to the employees who've been working in this facility under dire circumstances for years, and thank Maddie for her very clear, crisp, direct, and blunt explanation of the issues having to do with the garage.

779
01:16:15.463 --> 01:16:25.483
<v Steve Novick>On the issue of the internal service charges, I mean, one thing I wanted to note is that from the perspective of the taxpayer or ratepayer, I think it generally doesn't matter what bureau is paying for something.

780
01:16:25.578 --> 01:16:28.356
<v Steve Novick>They want to be sure that they're getting good value for what they're paying for.

781
01:16:28.742 --> 01:16:32.932
<v Steve Novick>I mean, there are some variations on like Property taxpayers versus water ratepayers.

782
01:16:33.032 --> 01:16:34.167
<v Steve Novick>But I think in general, people don't care.

783
01:16:35.819 --> 01:16:46.502
<v Steve Novick>In terms of how the bureaus feel, obviously we should be able to articulate why the charging mechanisms and the distribution is fair.

784
01:16:48.405 --> 01:16:56.193
<v Steve Novick>We also need to be aware of that there are some bureaus for which it is kind of easier to absorb costs than others.

785
01:16:56.243 --> 01:16:56.292
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

786
01:16:56.626 --> 01:17:07.207
<v Steve Novick>I mean, obviously they don't like doing it, and we don't either, but the water bureau can— or the sewer bureau can simply raise rates to cover costs.

787
01:17:07.704 --> 01:17:12.988
<v Steve Novick>PBOT, which is always in dire financial straits, has no similar way to do anything.

788
01:17:13.565 --> 01:17:23.440
<v Steve Novick>So it's our job as the council to be sure that when we are loading costs onto bureaus with no money, we take that into account in figuring out how we get them more money.

789
01:17:24.243 --> 01:17:37.551
<v Steve Novick>I also just— I mean, having these charges go out to bureaus should have the effect of getting the bureaus more invested in keeping down the overall cost for this kind of service.

790
01:17:38.289 --> 01:17:56.807
<v Steve Novick>And as has been noted before, I think Councilor Clark was pointing out that the current situation in the Kirby Garage— you've— or maybe it wasn't Councilor Fateh who was— that has had the distorting effect of bureaus thinking they need to buy more trucks because they don't think they would always have access to ones they have.

791
01:17:57.250 --> 01:17:57.980
<v Steve Novick>Was that with Councilor Green?

792
01:17:58.824 --> 01:18:02.140
<v Steve Novick>Anyway, that's my rambling contribution to the discussion.

793
01:18:03.827 --> 01:18:04.421
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

794
01:18:04.550 --> 01:18:05.675
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Green, back to you.

795
01:18:06.751 --> 01:18:07.104
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

796
01:18:07.457 --> 01:18:14.932
<v Mitch Green>I had originally put my hand up because I was anticipating we would go down the discussion of the ownership versus the lease, and I'm glad we had that discussion.

797
01:18:14.983 --> 01:18:15.466
<v Mitch Green>It's really important.

798
01:18:16.409 --> 01:18:23.149
<v Mitch Green>I'd just like to offer that this is timely because of the asset management work that we're planning to do.

799
01:18:23.779 --> 01:18:39.297
<v Mitch Green>But note that in any large enterprise that has to face an intergenerational investment problem, it's pretty typical to engage in flexible contracts that provide what's called option value.

800
01:18:39.395 --> 01:18:39.751
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

801
01:18:39.944 --> 01:18:46.523
<v Mitch Green>And so I'll just I can provide an example from the standpoint of my prior career, which is in the energy business.

802
01:18:48.010 --> 01:18:54.014
<v Mitch Green>You know, Bonneville Power Administration can work with one of its customers to build a new power plant, and they would own that.

803
01:18:54.646 --> 01:19:03.167
<v Mitch Green>But it may not be the most viable or long-term cost-efficient solution when you have an uncertain future.

804
01:19:03.621 --> 01:19:06.632
<v Mitch Green>And to your point, Maddie, the ideal state is—.

805
01:19:06.681 --> 01:19:07.042
<v Mitch Green>I'm sorry.

806
01:19:08.704 --> 01:19:12.211
<v Mitch Green>Is a campus, like sort of a public works campus, if you will.

807
01:19:12.985 --> 01:19:19.780
<v Mitch Green>But there's a lot of unknowns before we can really chart that course and put that to voters to say, is this something that you want to pay for?

808
01:19:20.087 --> 01:19:22.470
<v Mitch Green>Because we're still getting a handle on our asset management problem.

809
01:19:23.228 --> 01:19:30.467
<v Mitch Green>And so I think I'm sympathetic to the argument of like, well, what is our exposure going to be at the lease option?

810
01:19:30.970 --> 01:19:33.323
<v Mitch Green>You know, at the end of the lease, do we want to buy it?

811
01:19:33.436 --> 01:19:34.086
<v Mitch Green>Do we not want to?

812
01:19:34.313 --> 01:19:35.480
<v Mitch Green>Or do we have to kind of roll forward on the lease?

813
01:19:35.529 --> 01:19:35.578
<v Mitch Green>Right.

814
01:19:36.103 --> 01:19:50.586
<v Mitch Green>Those are reasonable questions to ask, but I think that we might find ourselves in a situation where the Cutter location is no longer the appropriate location for the future state of our Public Works campus, if you will.

815
01:19:51.501 --> 01:20:04.524
<v Mitch Green>We might be able to imagine a situation where there is a zoning change that allows for a different contemplation of different parts of of land acquisition around the city or a partnership with the port or whatever.

816
01:20:04.845 --> 01:20:20.579
<v Mitch Green>The point being is this provides some certainty on cost right now so that way we can get out of the business of the uncertain operations and maintenance cost that comes from the bottlenecks that we experience with the Kirby Garage.

817
01:20:20.710 --> 01:20:26.773
<v Mitch Green>It allows us to move forward right now rather than continuing to wonder if we're going to make the right sunk cost investment.

818
01:20:26.869 --> 01:20:27.194
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

819
01:20:27.381 --> 01:20:28.775
<v Mitch Green>For the bigger contemplation.

820
01:20:28.824 --> 01:20:32.319
<v Mitch Green>And so I see this as part of the option value exercise.

821
01:20:32.511 --> 01:20:32.640
<v Mitch Green>It's—.

822
01:20:32.815 --> 01:20:37.978
<v Mitch Green>I didn't see it presented formally in those terms, but this is what I see when I see, you know, this fits into my experience.

823
01:20:38.555 --> 01:20:45.320
<v Mitch Green>So when we do the asset management work, I hope that we're also talking about option value in our investment decisions as well.

824
01:20:45.560 --> 01:20:48.414
<v Mitch Green>So I just wanted to share that with my colleagues here.

825
01:20:49.824 --> 01:21:14.389
<v Unidentified speaker>If I could reply to that, I just want to say that that is a A very keen understanding of the challenge that we need to solve in the asset management strategy related to land and facilities, which is facilities are one of the only types of asset bases that also fail, fail in quotes, not just of condition or age or obsolescence, but because of their location.

826
01:21:14.662 --> 01:21:18.920
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we already see that right now, for example, with public safety assets, is that they're in the wrong space.

827
01:21:19.096 --> 01:21:22.050
<v Unidentified speaker>They're in the wrong place because we've had all these demographic changes.

828
01:21:22.564 --> 01:21:33.091
<v Unidentified speaker>So exactly as we— one of the most interesting and complicated parts of managing this type of asset is that you're interfacing with these demographic changes and you're interfacing with the market.

829
01:21:33.317 --> 01:21:43.444
<v Unidentified speaker>And so creating optionality, being able to take advantage of opportunities and shifting for something that is fundamentally very expensive is very— it's unique and it's challenging.

830
01:21:43.507 --> 01:21:44.439
<v Unidentified speaker>It's different than roads.

831
01:21:44.520 --> 01:21:45.016
<v Unidentified speaker>Et cetera.

832
01:21:45.435 --> 01:21:48.341
<v Unidentified speaker>So that is why I think it's so complicated.

833
01:21:48.404 --> 01:21:51.583
<v Unidentified speaker>And maybe that's why it's simmering down here is 'cause it's so complex.

834
01:21:51.680 --> 01:22:02.680
<v Unidentified speaker>But I appreciate that because that is exactly what we're trying to figure out is how do we future-proof this a little bit so that we're in the right place now, but we're not in the wrong place 20 years from now or 40 years from now.

835
01:22:02.872 --> 01:22:02.952
<v Unidentified speaker>So.

836
01:22:03.096 --> 01:22:04.109
<v Mitch Green>Appreciate that.

837
01:22:04.204 --> 01:22:06.725
<v Mitch Green>And just to finish the analogy, 'cause I realize I didn't.

838
01:22:07.416 --> 01:22:12.085
<v Mitch Green>So instead of buying, building the plant, Bonneville purchases Engages in long-term power purchase agreements.

839
01:22:12.359 --> 01:22:13.394
<v Mitch Green>So that's the analogy here.

840
01:22:13.797 --> 01:22:14.201
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

841
01:22:16.284 --> 01:22:17.077
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

842
01:22:17.512 --> 01:22:18.239
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Clark.

843
01:22:18.725 --> 01:22:19.354
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam Chair.

844
01:22:20.029 --> 01:22:26.654
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I originally, like you, uh, had put my hand up because I wanted to ask about ownership, but I think we've kind of beat that to death.

845
01:22:27.505 --> 01:22:32.592
<v Olivia Clark>However, I would just say that maybe at the first term, the first 20 years, we asked the Melita family to just donate it.

846
01:22:33.481 --> 01:22:38.432
<v Olivia Clark>You know, they— there could be certain advantages for that big family to donate it to us.

847
01:22:40.462 --> 01:22:51.204
<v Olivia Clark>I'm glad you were talking about asset management and a maintenance reserve because I want to put a point on that, that we should talk about that when we have our asset management discussion.

848
01:22:51.318 --> 01:22:56.904
<v Olivia Clark>And we're going to get a quarterly report in our committee where— how it's going on asset management.

849
01:22:56.969 --> 01:22:58.265
<v Olivia Clark>And I would like to at least have that conversation.

850
01:22:59.483 --> 01:23:14.381
<v Olivia Clark>How we fund it, I don't know, but I think we should be talking and for your comment, Councilor Green, about future-proofing and what we know and don't know, at least the— we're going to have a discussion about the water treatment plant here in just a moment.

851
01:23:15.012 --> 01:23:23.962
<v Olivia Clark>And they actually purchased property, I think in 1971, something like that, out in knowing that they were going to need something at some point.

852
01:23:24.365 --> 01:23:27.957
<v Olivia Clark>And then other issues come up as a result of that because of the location.

853
01:23:28.006 --> 01:23:28.055
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

854
01:23:28.668 --> 01:23:34.929
<v Olivia Clark>So these issues are really complex, but I appreciate the conversation about thinking forward about what we need.

855
01:23:35.056 --> 01:23:36.229
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that.

856
01:23:36.823 --> 01:23:42.215
<v Olivia Clark>And also your comment about autonomy, or maybe it was actually Councilor Zimmerman's.

857
01:23:42.536 --> 01:23:44.077
<v Eric Zimmerman>If it was a good question, it was me.

858
01:23:44.206 --> 01:23:45.875
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, undoubtedly.

859
01:23:46.307 --> 01:23:54.835
<v Olivia Clark>But I constantly talk about the culture change that we're going through with the bureaus and kind of the new world order how we think about things.

860
01:23:55.368 --> 01:23:58.721
<v Olivia Clark>And that question about autonomy, I think, is really the crux of it.

861
01:23:58.914 --> 01:24:00.786
<v Olivia Clark>And, um, you're doing a great job.

862
01:24:00.947 --> 01:24:02.528
<v Olivia Clark>I just— I really appreciate what you're doing.

863
01:24:03.195 --> 01:24:09.766
<v Olivia Clark>Um, but great— this has been a great discussion for, uh, future discussions as well, not just on, uh, Kirby and Cutter.

864
01:24:10.090 --> 01:24:10.639
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you.

865
01:24:12.332 --> 01:24:12.926
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

866
01:24:12.975 --> 01:24:13.666
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Smith.

867
01:24:15.225 --> 01:24:16.654
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

868
01:24:17.055 --> 01:24:37.315
<v Loretta Smith>Um, Finance Chair Zimmerman, I, I think I know where you were kind of going with this, because I think we have to have a bigger conversation about, you know, what has our internal service fees been over the past 20 years and how have we increased our internal services over the years.

869
01:24:38.055 --> 01:24:56.971
<v Loretta Smith>And if it gets to the point that we are taxing each other or billing each other to death and not bringing in new revenue, we're going to get to the point where we're spending 50% of our actual budgets on internal services when we need to be figuring out how to bring in new revenue.

870
01:24:57.484 --> 01:24:59.503
<v Loretta Smith>Like, we have the Bull Run coming up next.

871
01:24:59.551 --> 01:25:08.750
<v Loretta Smith>We've lost 4 customers, uh, water customers— Rockwood, Gresham— that we don't have when we build this new Bull Run.

872
01:25:08.943 --> 01:25:14.198
<v Loretta Smith>So we need to figure out how to bring in new revenue and not charge ourselves to death.

873
01:25:14.262 --> 01:25:14.439
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

874
01:25:15.417 --> 01:25:20.257
<v Loretta Smith>With our current budget, particularly since we are losing money.

875
01:25:20.386 --> 01:25:22.582
<v Loretta Smith>We're having big gaps in our budgets.

876
01:25:23.112 --> 01:25:30.597
<v Loretta Smith>And as someone talked about earlier, and Dan Ryan said, we need to be about the business of economic development.

877
01:25:31.382 --> 01:25:32.649
<v Loretta Smith>And so I hear you.

878
01:25:32.746 --> 01:25:37.988
<v Loretta Smith>I heard what you were saying, and maybe that might be something that you want to bring up in the Finance Committee as we're looking.

879
01:25:38.036 --> 01:25:38.452
<v Loretta Smith>I didn't know.

880
01:25:38.533 --> 01:25:57.333
<v Loretta Smith>It was good to know that, um, we're looking at internal services, but I have a huge problem with how we're being, um, uh, and I won't say taxed, but how we're being charged through the Internal Services, uh, Division, because it takes up a lot of our budgets, and we have a very small budget compared to others in the city of Portland.

881
01:25:57.686 --> 01:26:02.948
<v Loretta Smith>But I thank you for what you're doing, but I think we need to— we do need to follow back up on that conversation.

882
01:26:03.783 --> 01:26:04.168
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

883
01:26:04.265 --> 01:26:05.788
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

884
01:26:05.868 --> 01:26:06.559
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Ryan.

885
01:26:07.554 --> 01:26:08.020
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you.

886
01:26:08.115 --> 01:26:09.078
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

887
01:26:09.224 --> 01:26:10.796
<v Dan Ryan>I'm enjoying this conversation.

888
01:26:10.845 --> 01:26:15.628
<v Dan Ryan>It feels like we're in a work session suddenly, but so it's hard not to drift into that type of thinking.

889
01:26:16.222 --> 01:26:18.326
<v Dan Ryan>I just, I have to hear from you, Christopher.

890
01:26:18.390 --> 01:26:20.396
<v Dan Ryan>What was the vote again from the Finance Committee?

891
01:26:21.746 --> 01:26:28.344
<v Christopher Hare>Yes, the vote was a 4 ayes and 1 absent.

892
01:26:28.744 --> 01:26:29.500
<v Dan Ryan>1 Absent, okay.

893
01:26:30.094 --> 01:26:36.412
<v Dan Ryan>And we're all up, maybe I just look to you, Chair, Were these issues discussed in the committee as well?

894
01:26:37.814 --> 01:26:38.475
<v Dan Ryan>Some of them were.

895
01:26:38.796 --> 01:26:39.360
<v Dan Ryan>Some of them were.

896
01:26:39.603 --> 01:26:43.064
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that the ownership discussion happened.

897
01:26:43.612 --> 01:26:51.314
<v Eric Zimmerman>There was a question that has gone still unanswered regarding, I think, the overall costs of maintenance at the new facility.

898
01:26:53.043 --> 01:26:59.752
<v Eric Zimmerman>There was not a conversation at that time about the internal service rates.

899
01:26:59.833 --> 01:27:11.684
<v Eric Zimmerman>For me, since I asked some of those questions, That's come from the position of diving further into how we're building it back and understanding those.

900
01:27:12.293 --> 01:27:13.386
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'd say it was partial.

901
01:27:13.627 --> 01:27:15.296
<v Eric Zimmerman>So it should still be supported.

902
01:27:15.634 --> 01:27:17.625
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think that that's the line of questioning.

903
01:27:18.298 --> 01:27:29.662
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that what's important is that— what's important to me as a finance chair is that you all understood we were about to invest, I think, Quite largely in a piece of property we don't own.

904
01:27:30.015 --> 01:27:36.024
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for me, in my almost 20 years of government, that seemed out of the norm for me.

905
01:27:37.211 --> 01:27:48.108
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then with respect to the internal service rates, this is the only government that I've worked at where even in my own, I cannot make heads or tails for how internal service rates are charged back.

906
01:27:48.621 --> 01:27:51.088
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I actually don't think we're in a normal situation there.

907
01:27:51.873 --> 01:27:51.970
<v Loretta Smith>And so—.

908
01:27:51.970 --> 01:27:52.914
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a fair point.

909
01:27:53.814 --> 01:28:11.188
<v Eric Zimmerman>The more I dug into that between finance and this hearing, Councilor, I grew concerned that we have this one study going on and I didn't want to see it supplanted by a debt service that wasn't accurate to just that debt service.

910
01:28:11.235 --> 01:28:14.158
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's where my questions came from.

911
01:28:14.221 --> 01:28:15.764
<v Eric Zimmerman>I still think it should be supportive.

912
01:28:15.811 --> 01:28:20.762
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think any of us who've seen this Cutter Garage, would know it needs to be replaced.

913
01:28:20.859 --> 01:28:22.907
<v Eric Zimmerman>Excuse me, Kirby Garage knows it needs to be replaced.

914
01:28:23.134 --> 01:28:31.481
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I didn't want 6 months from now you to come and say, Chair of Finance, you didn't tell us we were investing in a non-Portland-owned piece of property.

915
01:28:31.546 --> 01:28:33.488
<v Eric Zimmerman>I wanted that to be very clear to everybody.

916
01:28:34.525 --> 01:28:36.090
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, that's fair.

917
01:28:36.154 --> 01:28:41.703
<v Dan Ryan>And I actually need to hear that based on not being on the committee and trying to follow what's happening in this dialogue.

918
01:28:43.636 --> 01:28:44.930
<v Dan Ryan>That's really what I wanted to say.

919
01:28:45.011 --> 01:28:51.837
<v Dan Ryan>I will say that I'm more accustomed to knowing that this practice of doing long-term leases is pretty standard in the marketplace.

920
01:28:52.096 --> 01:29:07.524
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm not as bothered by that as much as I'm liking the elevated conversation we were having that does start to get to, I think, a workshop, a work session that we could have on this topic in general because we're starting to get a much bigger picture than that, which I think is healthy.

921
01:29:07.788 --> 01:29:08.052
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

922
01:29:08.860 --> 01:29:09.587
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

923
01:29:11.989 --> 01:29:15.454
<v Keith Wilson>Colleagues, seeing no other debate or discussion?

924
01:29:15.568 --> 01:29:16.900
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Smith, final words?

925
01:29:17.012 --> 01:29:18.024
<v Loretta Smith>Just final words.

926
01:29:18.555 --> 01:29:23.646
<v Loretta Smith>So as you talked about that, uh, Councilor, uh, Ryan, I have a question.

927
01:29:24.000 --> 01:29:28.417
<v Loretta Smith>Did we put out an RFP for this, or is this a sole source agreement?

928
01:29:28.882 --> 01:29:31.051
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, an RFP for the property?

929
01:29:31.533 --> 01:29:32.304
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, to do the lease.

930
01:29:32.899 --> 01:29:33.926
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, no.

931
01:29:33.975 --> 01:29:36.336
<v Unidentified speaker>So leasing doesn't go through the procurement process.

932
01:29:36.752 --> 01:29:39.628
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, leasing is an independent function.

933
01:29:40.527 --> 01:29:48.936
<v Unidentified speaker>We have a 3-mile radius that we have to maintain, or ideal, would be ideal to maintain right now in adjacency to PBOT.

934
01:29:49.835 --> 01:29:59.496
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that greatly, between the acreage and square footage and the radius with PBOT, it greatly delimits what properties were even considerable.

935
01:29:59.560 --> 01:30:01.662
<v Unidentified speaker>And so it basically led us to Swan Island.

936
01:30:02.273 --> 01:30:04.583
<v Unidentified speaker>And then within that, we're just waiting for the market.

937
01:30:04.648 --> 01:30:06.444
<v Loretta Smith>No, I do understand, but there's a bigger issue here.

938
01:30:06.510 --> 01:30:06.734
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

939
01:30:07.167 --> 01:30:26.296
<v Loretta Smith>And when we're spending this kind of money and we have a lease— and what I was trying to explain during the budget cycle when I put forward a budget note, that we need to be seeing all contracts, particularly these multimillion-dollar contracts, before they come up and we get surprised by them.

940
01:30:26.440 --> 01:30:27.595
<v Loretta Smith>Like I said, I support this.

941
01:30:27.868 --> 01:30:28.944
<v Loretta Smith>There's— I'm not saying that.

942
01:30:29.007 --> 01:30:33.324
<v Loretta Smith>But what I'm saying is we need to see contracts like the previous council saw them.

943
01:30:34.144 --> 01:30:44.932
<v Loretta Smith>Before you sign off on them, because I just can't imagine having this, this huge contract without having council's eyes on them.

944
01:30:45.046 --> 01:30:51.211
<v Loretta Smith>And it's going to cost— it's going to cost our council, our city, a considerable amount of money.

945
01:30:51.467 --> 01:30:54.582
<v Loretta Smith>And that part, you don't have to answer, Mattie.

946
01:30:54.774 --> 01:31:02.015
<v Loretta Smith>Just— I, I'm just, I'm just saying, I am saying this for the benefit of the chair of the Finance Committee because there's some things that we need to course correct.

947
01:31:02.064 --> 01:31:02.208
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

948
01:31:06.234 --> 01:31:07.051
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

949
01:31:07.389 --> 01:31:17.765
<v Keith Wilson>And I think there are a lot of different ways that the city enters into agreements to spend money, some of which are captured in the language to come to us and some of which are not.

950
01:31:18.694 --> 01:31:20.282
<v Unidentified speaker>May I briefly— Would you like to?

951
01:31:20.506 --> 01:31:21.854
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, it actually did go to Council.

952
01:31:21.934 --> 01:31:23.136
<v Unidentified speaker>It was just the last Council.

953
01:31:23.248 --> 01:31:25.622
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's why we— so we signed the lease.

954
01:31:26.552 --> 01:31:28.364
<v Unidentified speaker>So we were already under the lease.

955
01:31:29.020 --> 01:31:32.800
<v Unidentified speaker>Contract at this site for the lease by July 1st of last year.

956
01:31:32.847 --> 01:31:35.760
<v Unidentified speaker>So otherwise, future process—.

957
01:31:35.872 --> 01:31:36.257
<v Olivia Clark>I understand.

958
01:31:36.676 --> 01:31:37.110
<v Loretta Smith>I saw it.

959
01:31:37.158 --> 01:31:37.465
<v Olivia Clark>I saw it.

960
01:31:37.577 --> 01:31:39.168
<v Loretta Smith>I knew they wanted to be under the previous council.

961
01:31:41.902 --> 01:31:42.207
<v Keith Wilson>Okay.

962
01:31:42.368 --> 01:31:42.707
<v Keith Wilson>Okay.

963
01:31:43.190 --> 01:31:44.720
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Ryan, did you have something additional?

964
01:31:45.106 --> 01:31:47.877
<v Dan Ryan>Oh no, that was a, a mistake.

965
01:31:48.408 --> 01:31:48.729
<v Keith Wilson>Okay.

966
01:31:50.453 --> 01:31:55.150
<v Keith Wilson>Seeing no other questions, thank you all for being here and for the robust discussion.

967
01:31:55.264 --> 01:32:03.582
<v Keith Wilson>We know this is a really important decision for all of your teams, for our city employees, and for the future efficient operations of our city.

968
01:32:04.100 --> 01:32:08.720
<v Keith Wilson>We will move this item to second reading at a future council meeting.

969
01:32:10.954 --> 01:32:11.859
<v Keith Wilson>Um, thank you very much.

970
01:32:15.872 --> 01:32:18.123
<v Keith Wilson>Can you please read agenda item 8 for us?

971
01:32:20.501 --> 01:32:39.248
<v Keelan McClymont>Authorize the city to acquire certain permanent and temporary rights necessary for construction of the 3260 Southwest Upper Drive North to 3139 Southwest Upper Drive project through negotiation or exercise of the city's eminent domain authority.

972
01:32:41.079 --> 01:32:42.734
<v Keith Wilson>Mr. Hare.

973
01:32:42.896 --> 01:32:43.045
<v Harper Haverkamp>This is—.

974
01:32:43.158 --> 01:32:49.752
<v Christopher Hare>Good morning once again, Madam President, councilors, For the record, Christopher Hare, Council Policy Analyst, and I serve as staff to the Finance Committee.

975
01:32:50.137 --> 01:32:58.631
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance before you, document number 2025-405, was considered in the Finance Committee on October 20th, where it was referred to Council with a recommendation to pass.

976
01:32:59.210 --> 01:33:10.546
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance authorizes the acquisition of certain permanent and temporary property rights necessary for the 3260 Southwest Upper Drive North to 3139 Southwest Upper Drive project.

977
01:33:11.155 --> 01:33:12.746
<v Christopher Hare>To replace an 80-year-old water main.

978
01:33:13.420 --> 01:33:26.443
<v Christopher Hare>The acquisitions will affect 10 property owners, and the specific property rights will include 14 permanent easements and 5 temporary easements on or adjacent to the existing private drive, as shown in the Exhibit A attached.

979
01:33:27.373 --> 01:33:46.610
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance grants the Water Bureau the authority to use eminent domain pursuant to Section 9-108 of the City Charter and in accordance with eminent domain procedures provided for in Oregon Revised Statutes Chapter 5, Eminent Domain, Public Acquisition of Property, to acquire the interests if voluntary agreements cannot be reached with property owners.

980
01:33:47.283 --> 01:33:53.484
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance authorizes Water Bureau staff and the City Attorney's Office to negotiate with affected property owners regarding compensation.

981
01:33:53.869 --> 01:34:07.445
<v Christopher Hare>If negotiations are unsuccessful, the city may initiate and pursue condemnation proceedings to determine just compensation or resolve other matters appropriate for judicial review without expanding the jurisdiction of the court beyond those determinations.

982
01:34:08.280 --> 01:34:29.170
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance also, in accordance with ORS 35.265, authorizes the Water Bureau to evaluate the continuing necessity of each acquisition and, as appropriate, reduce or abandon any acquisition identified in Exhibit A. Additionally, it authorizes the creation of a subfund in an amount estimated to cover just compensation for each property interest.

983
01:34:29.475 --> 01:34:33.939
<v Christopher Hare>If necessary, funds may be deposited with the court where legal proceedings are initiated.

984
01:34:34.372 --> 01:34:47.255
<v Christopher Hare>And finally, the ordinance authorizes the Water Bureau, City Auditor, or their designees to pay obligations, agreements, or relocation benefits related to the project from the Water Fund once approved by the appropriate authorities.

985
01:34:47.993 --> 01:34:54.329
<v Christopher Hare>All costs associated with the acquisitions authorized will be charged to the Water Fund for the FY 2025-26 budget.

986
01:34:55.051 --> 01:34:59.929
<v Christopher Hare>The full impact statements on this item includes a financial and budgets impact and analysis and community impact.

987
01:35:00.105 --> 01:35:01.726
<v Christopher Hare>And community involvement.

988
01:35:02.369 --> 01:35:05.548
<v Christopher Hare>There was no verbal or written testimony on this ordinance prior to committee action.

989
01:35:05.917 --> 01:35:07.395
<v Christopher Hare>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

990
01:35:07.572 --> 01:35:08.005
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

991
01:35:08.855 --> 01:35:09.643
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Christopher.

992
01:35:09.996 --> 01:35:12.597
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Zimmerman, do you have anything you'd like to add?

993
01:35:13.529 --> 01:35:14.588
<v Eric Zimmerman>No, this is good.

994
01:35:14.653 --> 01:35:15.520
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Christopher.

995
01:35:16.579 --> 01:35:19.759
<v Eric Zimmerman>Just note that Councilor Green and I both sit on this committee.

996
01:35:19.871 --> 01:35:33.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>This piece of property that we're discussing is in our district and it's in the old parts where I'm sure pipe was being installed before we even had words like easement in the government.

997
01:35:33.271 --> 01:35:40.811
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think this is probably welcomed by the folks who live nearby and certainly needed by city infrastructure.

998
01:35:41.117 --> 01:35:42.577
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for the time on that.

999
01:35:43.202 --> 01:35:43.908
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1000
01:35:44.918 --> 01:35:47.117
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, do we have any public testimony?

1001
01:35:47.966 --> 01:35:48.672
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1002
01:35:49.073 --> 01:35:49.411
<v Keith Wilson>Okay.

1003
01:35:49.859 --> 01:35:51.817
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Smith, is your hand in the queue for this item?

1004
01:35:53.119 --> 01:35:54.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, thank you.

1005
01:35:54.349 --> 01:36:04.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I don't know who to ask this to, but I— similar to the Pleasant Valley neighborhood lack of response, I'm a little worried that there isn't testimony from any of the property owners.

1006
01:36:05.043 --> 01:36:11.512
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do we know, have we heard from the property owners who are affected by this in a positive or negative way?

1007
01:36:13.289 --> 01:36:14.944
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, interim director of the Water Bureau.

1008
01:36:15.350 --> 01:36:16.796
<v Unidentified speaker>I do have staff online.

1009
01:36:16.926 --> 01:36:24.271
<v Unidentified speaker>Keith Keith Walker and Ben Garcia, and we have had some contact with the owners.

1010
01:36:24.319 --> 01:36:27.438
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know if Keith or Ben want to talk about that.

1011
01:36:33.126 --> 01:36:33.564
<v Keith Wilson>Go right ahead.

1012
01:36:33.613 --> 01:36:34.408
<v Sameer Kanal>I can talk about that.

1013
01:36:34.505 --> 01:36:37.801
<v Keith Wilson>Ben Garcia, for the record, um, Water Bureau Right-of-Way Section.

1014
01:36:38.432 --> 01:36:42.954
<v Sameer Kanal>We have had some extensive outreach to the property owners affected by the project.

1015
01:36:43.988 --> 01:36:53.885
<v Sameer Kanal>We personally have talked to almost all the property owners, and many of them are aware of the need to replace this infrastructure due to some recent leaks in the area.

1016
01:36:54.993 --> 01:36:56.680
<v Keith Wilson>And they've been aware of the project for—.

1017
01:36:57.097 --> 01:36:59.105
<v Sameer Kanal>The project need for quite some time.

1018
01:37:00.054 --> 01:37:02.689
<v Keith Wilson>So there have been a lot of conversations with property owners.

1019
01:37:06.250 --> 01:37:08.557
<v Mitch Green>This is Keith Walker, Portland Water Bureau.

1020
01:37:09.407 --> 01:37:22.582
<v Sameer Kanal>I would also mention that the, the easement areas, both permanent and temporary for construction-only areas, are primarily in the existing access roadway, which is private.

1021
01:37:22.679 --> 01:37:34.586
<v Sameer Kanal>So that is the goal of the easement, is to gain access to that and to abandon an old easement which is only 10 feet wide.

1022
01:37:34.650 --> 01:37:34.795
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1023
01:37:34.956 --> 01:37:36.627
<v Sameer Kanal>And in very steep terrain.

1024
01:37:36.884 --> 01:37:45.012
<v Keith Wilson>And the goal is replace the 70-year-old pipe, which is a galvanized pipe, it's prone to failure.

1025
01:37:46.496 --> 01:38:04.257
<v Sameer Kanal>And also remove that risk of the old existing easement, which is their water supply, which due to the steepness, if we had to work on that on an emergency basis, it It could incur additional risk to our neighbors there.

1026
01:38:05.350 --> 01:38:05.511
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

1027
01:38:05.752 --> 01:38:07.436
<v Steve Novick>So thank you.

1028
01:38:08.497 --> 01:38:08.881
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1029
01:38:10.167 --> 01:38:14.694
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am certain that this is a vital infrastructure upgrade.

1030
01:38:14.823 --> 01:38:21.068
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm positive that this is what is necessary, and I'm certain that the neighbors are probably going to be supportive.

1031
01:38:21.565 --> 01:38:33.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will just note, maybe for any city employees who are listening, We gotta make sure we are positively hearing from folks in a way on these items.

1032
01:38:35.365 --> 01:38:36.648
<v Jamie Dunphy>Silence is not consent.

1033
01:38:37.117 --> 01:38:52.431
<v Jamie Dunphy>And just as with, you know, I don't know if there was outreach done to the neighborhood association in the neighborhood or any additional work around there, but, and I'm not, it's not gonna impact my feelings on supporting this.

1034
01:38:52.497 --> 01:38:59.537
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just wanna note that I think it is, If we're taking property and nobody has said anything, that feels concerning to me.

1035
01:38:59.875 --> 01:39:04.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>I trust that the staff are doing a good job of maintaining those relationships, but I just wanted to flag that again.

1036
01:39:04.978 --> 01:39:05.675
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you.

1037
01:39:07.393 --> 01:39:09.418
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor, for bringing up that important point.

1038
01:39:10.800 --> 01:39:13.072
<v Keith Wilson>Colleagues, any other discussion on this agenda item?

1039
01:39:15.136 --> 01:39:15.412
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1040
01:39:15.896 --> 01:39:20.905
<v Keith Wilson>Seeing none, we will move this to a second reading at our next meeting.

1041
01:39:23.863 --> 01:39:26.601
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan gets— oh, okay.

1042
01:39:26.828 --> 01:39:29.744
<v Keith Wilson>You look like you had something with that item before we moved on.

1043
01:39:30.051 --> 01:39:30.195
<v Keith Wilson>Sorry.

1044
01:39:30.614 --> 01:39:32.274
<v Keith Wilson>Um, thank you both for being here.

1045
01:39:33.532 --> 01:39:35.822
<v Keith Wilson>Uh, Keelan, could you please read agenda item 9 for us?

1046
01:39:36.822 --> 01:39:41.212
<v Keelan McClymont>Accept the Bull Run Treatment Project's 2025 annual report.

1047
01:39:41.606 --> 01:39:42.527
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1048
01:39:42.609 --> 01:39:44.167
<v Keith Wilson>And we have a committee staff summary.

1049
01:39:46.247 --> 01:39:46.742
<v Keith Wilson>Go right ahead.

1050
01:39:48.065 --> 01:39:49.606
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning, Madam President and councilors.

1051
01:39:49.671 --> 01:39:54.295
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, Claire Adamsick, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee.

1052
01:39:55.113 --> 01:40:03.094
<v Unidentified speaker>The report before you, document number 2025-383, requests acceptance of the Bull Run Treatment Project's 2025 annual report.

1053
01:40:03.800 --> 01:40:12.679
<v Unidentified speaker>The report provides an update on the Bull Run filtration projects and the improved corrosion control treatment project and related milestones to maintain compliance with federal safe drinking water regulations.

1054
01:40:13.514 --> 01:40:25.940
<v Unidentified speaker>The full impact statement on this item includes information on financial and budgetary impacts and analysis, economic and real estate development impacts, community impacts and community involvement, and on the city's 100% renewable goal.

1055
01:40:27.064 --> 01:40:37.484
<v Unidentified speaker>And excuse me, I failed to say that the committee met and recommended that the passage of this, or that the report be accepted on October 6th, 2025.

1056
01:40:38.304 --> 01:40:39.050
<v Unidentified speaker>At that meeting, Thank you.

1057
01:40:39.050 --> 01:40:39.050
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mayor.

1058
01:40:39.050 --> 01:40:39.050
<v Unidentified speaker>So, as noted in the agenda, this is a public comment item.

1059
01:40:39.050 --> 01:40:39.050
<v Unidentified speaker>We have 2 public comments.

1060
01:40:39.050 --> 01:40:39.850
<v Unidentified speaker>The first is in response to the public comment item that was posted to the council agenda prior to the committee meeting.

1061
01:40:39.850 --> 01:40:43.680
<v Unidentified speaker>11 People submitted written testimony on these items prior to committee action.

1062
01:40:44.289 --> 01:40:52.810
<v Unidentified speaker>There's also a Water Bureau memo that's posted to the council agenda item, which is in response to that written testimony that's available for your reference.

1063
01:40:52.810 --> 01:40:57.649
<v Unidentified speaker>And one person submitted written testimony prior to full council agenda posting.

1064
01:40:57.649 --> 01:41:04.409
<v Unidentified speaker>The general themes of that written testimony included concerns about increased project costs due to construction delays and conditional use approval.

1065
01:41:05.618 --> 01:41:12.295
<v Unidentified speaker>Requests for improved forecasting of impacts to ratepayers in light of project costs and fewer customers to absorb overall costs.

1066
01:41:13.354 --> 01:41:16.997
<v Unidentified speaker>Suggestions regarding the use of ultraviolet or other alternative treatment options.

1067
01:41:17.591 --> 01:41:28.345
<v Unidentified speaker>And finally, community impact— community and economic impacts of the filtration plant's construction due to potential road closures or detours that impact small businesses along haul routes.

1068
01:41:28.729 --> 01:41:29.340
<v Unidentified speaker>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

1069
01:41:29.387 --> 01:41:29.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1070
01:41:29.548 --> 01:41:30.430
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator Tracy Warren.

1071
01:41:31.585 --> 01:41:31.907
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1072
01:41:31.988 --> 01:41:34.902
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Clark, you were presiding over this meeting.

1073
01:41:34.949 --> 01:41:35.868
<v Keith Wilson>Anything you'd like to add?

1074
01:41:36.012 --> 01:41:36.238
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1075
01:41:36.319 --> 01:41:39.525
<v Olivia Clark>Just thank you, and thank you, Claire, for that summary.

1076
01:41:40.997 --> 01:41:54.938
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, this is a report that was required by a previous council in, I think it was 2017 or 2018, required that the bureau bring a report, an annual report.

1077
01:41:55.524 --> 01:42:04.909
<v Olivia Clark>So that's the The origin of this, um, you know, the previous council dealt with different options on the treatment plant.

1078
01:42:05.408 --> 01:42:13.051
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I think now, um, in hindsight, they made absolutely the right decision to, um, have the plant that we're building now.

1079
01:42:13.596 --> 01:42:21.962
<v Olivia Clark>It went from Cryptosporidium to something much larger, uh, around impacts of climate change, which are very, very serious.

1080
01:42:22.805 --> 01:42:30.286
<v Olivia Clark>Interesting that we just had a conversation about facilities when the Water Bureau had purchased this land sometime in the early '70s, I believe.

1081
01:42:30.965 --> 01:42:41.368
<v Olivia Clark>And, you know, we've had conversations about how it was held up at LUBA, but construction has restarted, I think, maybe this July.

1082
01:42:42.479 --> 01:42:45.655
<v Olivia Clark>So we did have a very robust conversation in committee.

1083
01:42:47.788 --> 01:42:53.243
<v Olivia Clark>We talked about all kinds of things, including impact to minority contractors due to the shutdown.

1084
01:42:55.467 --> 01:43:08.895
<v Olivia Clark>And we also talked about the hope and desire that the largesse of this project does not end up cannibalizing the operating funds of the Water Bureau and how we finance this.

1085
01:43:10.394 --> 01:43:13.105
<v Olivia Clark>In any event, I welcome questions.

1086
01:43:13.203 --> 01:43:18.980
<v Olivia Clark>I know there's lots and lots of interest in this, as evidenced both by citizen input and our own conversations.

1087
01:43:19.029 --> 01:43:19.158
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1088
01:43:19.533 --> 01:43:23.858
<v Olivia Clark>So I really appreciate the work of the Water Bureau in bringing this forward.

1089
01:43:27.199 --> 01:43:27.765
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1090
01:43:28.105 --> 01:43:28.559
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Claire.

1091
01:43:29.966 --> 01:43:32.134
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, do we have anybody signed up for public testimony?

1092
01:43:32.878 --> 01:43:33.461
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1093
01:43:33.930 --> 01:43:39.761
<v Keith Wilson>Okay then, colleagues, let's take any technical questions, other questions, or discussion altogether on this report.

1094
01:43:40.471 --> 01:43:43.069
<v Keith Wilson>Is there anybody who'd like to ask a question?

1095
01:43:46.747 --> 01:43:46.923
<v Keith Wilson>Okay.

1096
01:43:47.292 --> 01:43:48.192
<v Keith Wilson>Oh, Councilor Novick.

1097
01:43:48.978 --> 01:43:54.257
<v Steve Novick>Um, let's see, is this our one chance to ask a question, or can we wait until we've heard the report to ask questions?

1098
01:43:54.916 --> 01:44:15.332
<v Keith Wilson>Uh, generally, because this was well vetted in committee, what we have done in council, like with previous items today, is just move into questions, assuming that folks have had the opportunity to do background research or check with their colleagues okay, thank you, Madam President.

1099
01:44:16.073 --> 01:44:30.393
<v Steve Novick>So I just think that it's good to take any opportunity to have a discussion about an issue that we periodically hear about from constituents, which is, um, why did you choose to do the filtration plant as opposed to ultraviolet treatment?

1100
01:44:30.730 --> 01:44:34.828
<v Steve Novick>Isn't it incredibly expensive, uh, given that the costs keep on rising?

1101
01:44:35.105 --> 01:44:46.844
<v Steve Novick>And I, I think that it's fair to say that the cost of the treatment plant plays a pretty significant role in the projected increase in the combined water sewer bill for a single-family home by about $30 over the next 5 years.

1102
01:44:46.891 --> 01:44:47.421
<v Steve Novick>Is that right?

1103
01:44:48.320 --> 01:44:48.963
<v Unidentified speaker>That's correct.

1104
01:44:49.060 --> 01:44:51.435
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Queesha Light, interim director of the Water Bureau.

1105
01:44:51.533 --> 01:44:52.029
<v Unidentified speaker>That's correct.

1106
01:44:52.078 --> 01:44:55.113
<v Unidentified speaker>It's going to be probably around $40 additional.

1107
01:44:56.028 --> 01:45:15.622
<v Steve Novick>So I think that it's useful just to sort of spell out in public whenever we can what the consequences would be if we either had originally decided that we're not going to do this, we're just going to do ultraviolet treatment, or what the consequences would be if we suddenly decided now we wanted to switch.

1108
01:45:16.846 --> 01:45:28.605
<v Steve Novick>One of the benefits of, as I understand it, of the treatment plant is that it makes the system more resilient to wildfires and earthquakes.

1109
01:45:28.670 --> 01:45:28.734
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1110
01:45:29.328 --> 01:45:39.801
<v Steve Novick>So could you take a little time to sort of spell out what might happen in an earthquake or huge wildfire to the water system without the treatment plant and what we think will happen with the treatment plant?

1111
01:45:39.947 --> 01:45:43.305
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll let you take the technical pieces of that.

1112
01:45:43.787 --> 01:45:44.028
<v Loretta Smith>Sure.

1113
01:45:44.525 --> 01:45:45.779
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm David Peters.

1114
01:45:45.971 --> 01:45:51.884
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm an engineering manager with the Water Bureau overseeing the Bull Run filtration facilities.

1115
01:45:52.783 --> 01:46:01.453
<v Unidentified speaker>And the question about what, what would happen if We didn't have filtration and we had an emergency event.

1116
01:46:02.081 --> 01:46:04.189
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll use the case of a forest fire.

1117
01:46:04.855 --> 01:46:20.947
<v Unidentified speaker>If we had a forest fire in the Bull Run Watershed and a significant portion of the watershed was burned, what happens is during the winter when the rains come back, all of that burned material gets washed into the reservoirs.

1118
01:46:21.608 --> 01:46:35.518
<v Unidentified speaker>And if you don't have a treatment system like filtration, it could be years for that sediment to filter out of the water to where the water could be usable, drinkable again.

1119
01:46:36.283 --> 01:46:43.395
<v Unidentified speaker>In the meantime, we're going to a secondary source, which is our groundwater system, to provide water during those times.

1120
01:46:43.909 --> 01:46:47.824
<v Unidentified speaker>Our groundwater system, however, is only sized for what I call a 3-day event.

1121
01:46:47.890 --> 01:46:48.073
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1122
01:46:48.305 --> 01:46:49.011
<v Unidentified speaker>3 Seasons.

1123
01:46:49.622 --> 01:46:57.746
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's not enough capacity to be used during the summer to provide all of our demands during our peaks during a hot summer.

1124
01:46:58.661 --> 01:47:00.859
<v Unidentified speaker>But it can be used in the shoulder seasons.

1125
01:47:00.940 --> 01:47:03.670
<v Unidentified speaker>It can be used during the winter to meet those demands.

1126
01:47:03.734 --> 01:47:11.006
<v Unidentified speaker>So we'd have a deficit of clean drinking water that we could provide to our customers.

1127
01:47:11.664 --> 01:47:12.387
<v Unidentified speaker>And in—.

1128
01:47:13.430 --> 01:47:13.623
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

1129
01:47:13.832 --> 01:47:14.490
<v Unidentified speaker>You mentioned UV.

1130
01:47:15.198 --> 01:47:18.024
<v Unidentified speaker>UV would not have solved that problem.

1131
01:47:18.988 --> 01:47:20.756
<v Unidentified speaker>It does not remove sediments.

1132
01:47:20.917 --> 01:47:25.543
<v Unidentified speaker>It specifically is focused on inactivation of Cryptosporidium.

1133
01:47:26.042 --> 01:47:33.640
<v Unidentified speaker>And so it wouldn't solve problems like landslides or wildfires or storm events that would happen in the Bow Run Watershed.

1134
01:47:33.689 --> 01:47:36.307
<v Unidentified speaker>In those cases, we would still be shutting that system down.

1135
01:47:37.529 --> 01:47:40.757
<v Steve Novick>And it's the same kind of rationale applied to the effects of an earthquake.

1136
01:47:40.837 --> 01:47:53.265
<v Unidentified speaker>An earthquake also It could, if it creates landslides in the watershed.

1137
01:47:55.167 --> 01:48:07.846
<v Unidentified speaker>What I'd like to say is the 2 supplies that we have, our groundwater and our surface water, are structured to benefit us during different emergencies.

1138
01:48:08.329 --> 01:48:13.703
<v Unidentified speaker>So our groundwater system is down by the Columbia River in areas that are liquefiable.

1139
01:48:14.539 --> 01:48:20.506
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's likely that that system might be impacted more than our Bull Run system.

1140
01:48:20.636 --> 01:48:30.043
<v Unidentified speaker>Our Bull Run system is up in the hills on the basalt, and it would be less likely affected by an earthquake.

1141
01:48:30.954 --> 01:48:33.780
<v Unidentified speaker>But an earthquake could create a landslide up there.

1142
01:48:33.831 --> 01:48:33.896
<v Keith Wilson>Hmm.

1143
01:48:34.103 --> 01:48:37.739
<v Unidentified speaker>That if we have filtration, we'd be able to continue to provide.

1144
01:48:38.726 --> 01:48:47.225
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think that's the benefit of having the multi-source system that we have, is to protect us against the different types of risks that we have.

1145
01:48:50.466 --> 01:49:01.806
<v Steve Novick>Another question is, if we just, in addition to what we just discussed, if we just refuse to do anything, what could the Oregon Health Authority or EPA actually do to us?

1146
01:49:04.822 --> 01:49:08.048
<v Unidentified speaker>We have one, a compliance agreement that we're under.

1147
01:49:08.289 --> 01:49:19.368
<v Unidentified speaker>So the option to do nothing, we long signed away that because we're on an agreement that says we will deliver filtration by the end of September of 2027.

1148
01:49:20.155 --> 01:49:34.573
<v Unidentified speaker>But if we do not, we one, run the risk of the EPA coming in and taking over our system, right, and saying that our water is not of the quality where it can be delivered, which means that impacts our hospitals, that impacts our businesses.

1149
01:49:34.622 --> 01:49:36.903
<v Unidentified speaker>That is not just us.

1150
01:49:37.078 --> 01:49:39.310
<v Unidentified speaker>It means a shutdown of our city, essentially.

1151
01:49:40.130 --> 01:49:45.573
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think the other piece that we look at is if they say that, that impacts our bond rating.

1152
01:49:45.670 --> 01:49:52.444
<v Unidentified speaker>We can no longer get the bonds at— we can't get the low-cost interest that we need for capital projects.

1153
01:49:52.766 --> 01:50:04.412
<v Steve Novick>I think I might be making this up, but I think I heard somewhere that one thing OHA could do if we're not in compliance is like order us to tell people to boil their water every day.

1154
01:50:05.039 --> 01:50:05.152
<v Jamie Dunphy>You—.

1155
01:50:05.521 --> 01:50:08.510
<v Unidentified speaker>We could tell people to boil their water every single day.

1156
01:50:08.815 --> 01:50:16.720
<v Unidentified speaker>And so to have us in a continuous state of boil water is rough, but no hospital can do that, right?

1157
01:50:17.878 --> 01:50:18.645
<v Steve Novick>Thank you very much.

1158
01:50:18.779 --> 01:50:24.029
<v Steve Novick>I mean, I know you've gone over this before, but I just think it's important to daylight it whenever we get a chance.

1159
01:50:24.270 --> 01:50:24.689
<v Unidentified speaker>I thank you.

1160
01:50:24.752 --> 01:50:25.490
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate it.

1161
01:50:25.539 --> 01:50:30.998
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it's important that the public hears and understands this over and over because this is an expensive endeavor.

1162
01:50:31.818 --> 01:50:32.235
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1163
01:50:33.503 --> 01:50:34.547
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1164
01:50:34.853 --> 01:50:35.479
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Dunphy.

1165
01:50:35.783 --> 01:50:36.234
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1166
01:50:36.297 --> 01:50:46.045
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I do just want to take an opportunity to reflect the real fear and concern that I hear from constituents every day about this project.

1167
01:50:46.832 --> 01:50:51.837
<v Jamie Dunphy>Both neighbors who have been neighbors of the project itself who are lobbying.

1168
01:50:51.948 --> 01:50:52.911
<v Jamie Dunphy>They're not in the city of Portland.

1169
01:50:52.975 --> 01:50:56.425
<v Jamie Dunphy>They're not my constituents, but they are very organized and passionate.

1170
01:50:57.162 --> 01:50:59.632
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this is absolutely impacting their community.

1171
01:50:59.744 --> 01:51:16.523
<v Jamie Dunphy>But also, I really want to just acknowledge the genuine strain that this will put on families, especially low-income families who are a lot of times living paycheck to paycheck and seeing a huge increase on their water bill like this is going to hurt.

1172
01:51:16.881 --> 01:51:18.314
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's going to require sacrifice.

1173
01:51:20.456 --> 01:51:29.113
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I do agree that the need to respond to climate change is very important, that a fire would absolutely be devastating.

1174
01:51:29.177 --> 01:51:34.708
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we had similar situations, you know, this last couple years where the fire has gotten pretty close.

1175
01:51:36.219 --> 01:51:42.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that's a real concern, but it is a secondary concern to what the previous city councils talked about.

1176
01:51:43.318 --> 01:51:49.375
<v Jamie Dunphy>When this plan first moved forward, I was working in Nick Fish's office and climate change was not the reason we were responding.

1177
01:51:49.422 --> 01:51:51.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>The reason we were responding was Cryptosporidium.

1178
01:51:51.970 --> 01:51:57.386
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the conversations at that time, the cost of this facility was a quarter of what it is now.

1179
01:51:58.701 --> 01:51:59.838
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just need the daylight.

1180
01:52:00.304 --> 01:52:01.474
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is a real concern.

1181
01:52:01.601 --> 01:52:12.398
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if we are going to not only put this cost on top of the bills of ratepayers going forward, We need to keep a really careful eye on all the additional costs that we're going to be having.

1182
01:52:13.216 --> 01:52:21.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>In Nick Fish's office at the time, the mandate coming from Nick was that we didn't increase the water bill by more than 5% every year.

1183
01:52:23.314 --> 01:52:32.984
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have had to move away from that as a standard, as a combined rate increase, understanding there's differences between water and BES.

1184
01:52:33.163 --> 01:52:48.547
<v Jamie Dunphy>And there's a lot of good reasons for that, but I really, really implore the future one Water Bureau to keep an eye on anything we can do to keep costs down year over year because this is genuinely going to impact people for generations.

1185
01:52:49.000 --> 01:52:55.922
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hopefully the benefits will outweigh the costs, but I just needed to voice those concerns that I'm hearing a lot.

1186
01:52:58.173 --> 01:52:59.064
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1187
01:52:59.145 --> 01:52:59.761
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Ryan.

1188
01:53:01.318 --> 01:53:02.614
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

1189
01:53:03.042 --> 01:53:07.487
<v Dan Ryan>I feel like there's gremlins in my computer right now.

1190
01:53:07.855 --> 01:53:09.108
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, one second.

1191
01:53:09.461 --> 01:53:09.717
<v Dan Ryan>There we go.

1192
01:53:09.845 --> 01:53:10.872
<v Keith Wilson>We're on agenda item 9.

1193
01:53:11.050 --> 01:53:14.725
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, I know that, but the thing just went wild and went away from the screen.

1194
01:53:15.158 --> 01:53:16.489
<v Dan Ryan>I'm here, I'm present.

1195
01:53:16.746 --> 01:53:17.613
<v Dan Ryan>It's almost Halloween.

1196
01:53:17.966 --> 01:53:18.896
<v Dan Ryan>It's beautiful outside.

1197
01:53:19.250 --> 01:53:19.426
<v Dan Ryan>Hi.

1198
01:53:20.372 --> 01:53:24.144
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator Priya Dhanapal, for being here today.

1199
01:53:24.609 --> 01:53:29.904
<v Dan Ryan>And I want to acknowledge your steady leadership at the Water Bureau, particularly you, Director Keisha Light.

1200
01:53:30.305 --> 01:53:36.301
<v Dan Ryan>You've really navigated an extremely complex project and you've been moving through it with a lot of recent hurdles.

1201
01:53:36.877 --> 01:53:40.146
<v Dan Ryan>I think we've all been reading about them, but I'm not in your shoes.

1202
01:53:40.340 --> 01:53:45.036
<v Dan Ryan>So I just want to thank you for all that you've been going through to get this project back online.

1203
01:53:45.533 --> 01:53:46.606
<v Dan Ryan>And it is back online.

1204
01:53:46.671 --> 01:53:47.247
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you.

1205
01:53:47.328 --> 01:53:48.594
<v Dan Ryan>It's great to hear that update.

1206
01:53:49.395 --> 01:53:55.229
<v Dan Ryan>I benefit from the 4-year term as a commissioner prior to this to understand the complex evolution of this project.

1207
01:53:55.326 --> 01:54:00.748
<v Dan Ryan>And I really appreciate the questions that were raised by 2 of my colleagues just prior to me speaking.

1208
01:54:01.488 --> 01:54:03.625
<v Dan Ryan>And yes, it's really complex.

1209
01:54:03.689 --> 01:54:08.944
<v Dan Ryan>And I highly suggest that we have all the councilors eventually do field trips up to Bull Run.

1210
01:54:09.457 --> 01:54:15.259
<v Dan Ryan>It's something that I waited about a year to do, and it was so beneficial to finally spend time up there.

1211
01:54:15.323 --> 01:54:20.512
<v Dan Ryan>I spent almost the entire day up there asking questions, just seeing the complexity.

1212
01:54:21.171 --> 01:54:34.444
<v Dan Ryan>And you can't leave but noticing that we have, right, Under our nose or not far from us, just the most precious resource that every city wishes they had, which is pure water, drinkable water that is close to our city.

1213
01:54:35.086 --> 01:54:42.337
<v Dan Ryan>It's— I can't think of a more important asset for our city on so many levels in terms of the decades that are moving forward.

1214
01:54:42.770 --> 01:54:47.984
<v Dan Ryan>So it's been frustrating, of course, to all of us to see the cost escalate.

1215
01:54:48.851 --> 01:54:59.653
<v Dan Ryan>I think that you've handled all of the questions well, but I'm going to pivot to something that I want to daylight for my colleagues because it's been my main reason to support this from the beginning.

1216
01:55:00.470 --> 01:55:07.680
<v Dan Ryan>And it goes even beyond the fact that this will be such an important, precious asset for Portland that others will really want to hook up to it.

1217
01:55:07.841 --> 01:55:17.103
<v Dan Ryan>I have faith, Councilor Smith, that other municipalities will want to play once this is all done because it'll be a very sacred resource, I think, as we move forward.

1218
01:55:17.150 --> 01:55:18.092
<v Dan Ryan>Unfortunately, Unfortunately.

1219
01:55:18.368 --> 01:55:19.725
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm really glad we're protecting it.

1220
01:55:20.306 --> 01:55:25.560
<v Dan Ryan>This project also has such an opportunity to really go deep into workforce development.

1221
01:55:26.020 --> 01:55:34.003
<v Dan Ryan>You can— I picture the student graduating from a high school locally, especially out in East Portland, and getting into a pre-apprentice program.

1222
01:55:34.261 --> 01:55:41.305
<v Dan Ryan>And in the duration of this project, they have the opportunity to get the skills to move up to apprentice, to move up to journey person.

1223
01:55:41.974 --> 01:55:47.217
<v Dan Ryan>And that means there's steadily improving their opportunity to have a living wage for the rest of their life.

1224
01:55:47.859 --> 01:55:53.926
<v Dan Ryan>And so we talk a lot about equity opportunities and workforce, and I think we have such a golden opportunity here.

1225
01:55:54.279 --> 01:56:04.069
<v Dan Ryan>And so I want to keep tracking those numbers as we move along on who the workforce is, who we're hiring, and what the demographic makeup is at the pre-apprenticeship level.

1226
01:56:04.422 --> 01:56:08.788
<v Dan Ryan>So we really get to the heart of the matter of having impact on something that we talk a lot about.

1227
01:56:08.837 --> 01:56:08.948
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1228
01:56:09.301 --> 01:56:12.706
<v Dan Ryan>But seldom do we have such a crisp, clear, concrete opportunity to do that.

1229
01:56:13.091 --> 01:56:18.213
<v Dan Ryan>So I just wanted to daylight that since it's a new council and I hadn't had a chance to say that in front of all of them.

1230
01:56:19.096 --> 01:56:22.774
<v Dan Ryan>I have full faith in you, Keisha, and your team at the Water Bureau.

1231
01:56:23.110 --> 01:56:32.841
<v Dan Ryan>I did read through this because this report annually has been of interest, and I thought this one was the most improved of all of the reports that I've seen in the 4 years that I've studied it.

1232
01:56:32.921 --> 01:56:33.467
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you.

1233
01:56:33.788 --> 01:56:34.335
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1234
01:56:35.315 --> 01:56:35.981
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1235
01:56:36.046 --> 01:56:36.663
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Green.

1236
01:56:38.547 --> 01:56:39.295
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you.

1237
01:56:39.440 --> 01:56:50.278
<v Mitch Green>I mean, these are really important things that we need to engage on, and I understand, Councilor Novick, I appreciate the ways you posed some of those questions 'cause it places into public a lot of what we're receiving in our inboxes.

1238
01:56:51.993 --> 01:57:06.994
<v Mitch Green>I think the things for me that reinforce my commitment to this project is that the cost of not doing anything Is a significant burden that future generations will bear because wildfire risk is only increasing.

1239
01:57:08.670 --> 01:57:15.914
<v Mitch Green>And correct me if I'm wrong, but the efficacy of a UV filtration approach is a function of turbidity in the water.

1240
01:57:16.189 --> 01:57:20.229
<v Mitch Green>So if you've got too much sedimentation in the water, it's not going to be as effective anyway.

1241
01:57:20.295 --> 01:57:37.655
<v Mitch Green>And so I know that the original conversations was about Cryptosporidium, but I think it was good that we contemplated other coincidental benefits that would result from the investment in an infrastructure plant that will increase our regional resiliency.

1242
01:57:39.197 --> 01:57:54.823
<v Mitch Green>We can't ignore the cost control problems, but I'll just note that the cost control issues related to, or the cost escalation issues related to this project are the same issues that plague every other construction project, particularly in the post-pandemic period, which is rising inflation.

1243
01:57:54.984 --> 01:57:59.472
<v Mitch Green>And I'm the city's representative to the Regional Water Providers Consortium for the City of Portland.

1244
01:57:59.521 --> 01:58:15.135
<v Mitch Green>In our last meeting, we did introduce the topic of maybe reconsidering joint purchase arrangements to pool our resources and purchase ahead of demand the infrastructure inputs.

1245
01:58:15.520 --> 01:58:21.002
<v Mitch Green>So that way we can have a kind of buffer stock of those commodity inputs to control our costs.

1246
01:58:21.065 --> 01:58:23.422
<v Mitch Green>Now, the City of Portland would be the biggest mover in that.

1247
01:58:24.305 --> 01:58:35.896
<v Mitch Green>So in the spirit of making sure that we're approaching this regional problem with some sort of solidarity, mutual aid, that I think those benefits need to be extended to our partners in the consortium.

1248
01:58:36.377 --> 01:58:40.435
<v Mitch Green>And maybe they'll come on back, as the councilor noted, is a risk of them leaving.

1249
01:58:40.868 --> 01:58:54.479
<v Mitch Green>But, you know, Director Light, you hit on a really important consideration, which is if we get into a situation where we fail to live up to the terms of our What is it?

1250
01:58:54.559 --> 01:59:02.042
<v Mitch Green>Compliance obligation, then we're leaving our economic actors who rely upon steady water out in the lurch.

1251
01:59:02.106 --> 01:59:15.694
<v Mitch Green>And that is a serious risk to our economic development prospects, not only in a time where we're sort of trying to understand how we can accelerate our economic development, but forestall a bigger decline.

1252
01:59:16.047 --> 01:59:32.000
<v Mitch Green>So if we have big major institutions who maybe think twice on locating in our city because they're not sure we're willing to back our major infrastructure requirements, that is just going to accelerate the doom loop, and we can't afford that.

1253
01:59:32.560 --> 01:59:39.127
<v Mitch Green>And so I think, you know, when we think about rate schedules and rate trajectories over time, I mean, we don't have to be passive.

1254
01:59:40.025 --> 01:59:44.873
<v Mitch Green>You know, we can always make choices in our budget on what to subsidize and what not to subsidize.

1255
01:59:44.921 --> 01:59:45.645
<v Mitch Green>So that's always up to us.

1256
01:59:45.693 --> 01:59:45.805
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1257
01:59:45.981 --> 01:59:50.430
<v Mitch Green>We have the low-income discount program, which we must continue to emphasize is there.

1258
01:59:51.345 --> 01:59:55.520
<v Mitch Green>But also the way that you deal with fixed-cost disease, which is what this is, is to grow.

1259
01:59:56.340 --> 02:00:01.430
<v Mitch Green>You grow your way out of a fixed-cost problem because you spread the fixed costs over a larger and larger base.

1260
02:00:02.682 --> 02:00:26.801
<v Mitch Green>And so, you know, as you're getting those sort of roadshows from Prosper Portland's TIF districts, what you'll note is that there's a dedication and emphasis on infrastructure spend in the new TIF districts, particularly in Westside, something like 20% of the new TIF resources are going to be about upscaling our infrastructure capacity so we can enable more dense development, which will allow us to spread our costs over a larger base.

1261
02:00:26.929 --> 02:00:28.100
<v Mitch Green>That's where we have to go, colleagues.

1262
02:00:29.417 --> 02:00:37.333
<v Mitch Green>It's really imperative for us to clear the bottlenecks and red tape to housing production and commercial production in this city.

1263
02:00:37.445 --> 02:00:38.634
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1264
02:00:39.082 --> 02:00:52.225
<v Mitch Green>I, again, I'm gonna keep hammering this, but we absolutely must upzone large swaths of this city and we can't wait 3 years of process to get that done or else we're gonna be 3 years later on getting our fixed costs spread out over a larger base and lowering the rate trajectory on average for every ratepayer.

1265
02:00:52.288 --> 02:00:53.769
<v Mitch Green>So that's my spiel.

1266
02:00:54.363 --> 02:01:06.664
<v Mitch Green>And I'm excited to see us moving forward on this and, you know, appreciate your frank willingness to kind of share some of the tough truths out there.

1267
02:01:06.716 --> 02:01:06.819
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1268
02:01:07.311 --> 02:01:10.966
<v Mitch Green>As we hear from community members who are pretty upset about the cost problem.

1269
02:01:11.542 --> 02:01:11.798
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1270
02:01:12.984 --> 02:01:15.083
<v Unidentified speaker>Council President, may I say one thing too?

1271
02:01:15.228 --> 02:01:15.708
<v Keith Wilson>Right ahead.

1272
02:01:16.686 --> 02:01:21.109
<v Unidentified speaker>Because you're right, we do need to be able to spread those costs across more people.

1273
02:01:21.573 --> 02:01:30.997
<v Unidentified speaker>And what we're seeing, and I know we talked about this in the T&I committee, is what we're seeing is multifamily being built, and we need that multifamily to be built with separate meters.

1274
02:01:31.734 --> 02:01:35.328
<v Unidentified speaker>Without that, That's not more people to spread those costs across.

1275
02:01:35.376 --> 02:01:43.530
<v Unidentified speaker>And then we have to start having a different type of cost causation, cost allocation conversation, and which we know we need to do anyway.

1276
02:01:43.675 --> 02:01:47.005
<v Unidentified speaker>But that is where we are right now.

1277
02:01:47.295 --> 02:01:52.930
<v Unidentified speaker>We— getting more people living in multifamily doesn't spread those costs across more people.

1278
02:01:53.672 --> 02:01:55.609
<v Unidentified speaker>It just doesn't do that in our system.

1279
02:01:57.886 --> 02:01:58.012
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1280
02:01:58.203 --> 02:01:58.971
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for noting that.

1281
02:02:01.601 --> 02:02:04.576
<v Keith Wilson>I'm looking to the vice chair of our Housing Committee as I say that.

1282
02:02:06.949 --> 02:02:08.101
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Smith, go right ahead.

1283
02:02:08.612 --> 02:02:09.039
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1284
02:02:09.104 --> 02:02:09.764
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for the report.

1285
02:02:10.909 --> 02:02:12.051
<v Loretta Smith>I want to go back to something.

1286
02:02:12.395 --> 02:02:18.304
<v Loretta Smith>Who are the 4 wholesale customers that have decided to back out of the Bull Run after it's completed?

1287
02:02:19.146 --> 02:02:23.054
<v Unidentified speaker>TVWD, Lusted Hill, Rockwood, and Gresham.

1288
02:02:24.458 --> 02:02:24.590
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1289
02:02:25.016 --> 02:02:28.353
<v Loretta Smith>Do we have a strategic plan to increase the customer base?

1290
02:02:30.239 --> 02:02:34.385
<v Unidentified speaker>So we have, we're, you know, we have conversations.

1291
02:02:34.689 --> 02:02:36.603
<v Unidentified speaker>We're definitely having conversations with folks around.

1292
02:02:36.682 --> 02:02:38.819
<v Unidentified speaker>No master plan on that one yet.

1293
02:02:39.333 --> 02:02:44.796
<v Unidentified speaker>That is definitely something that we have, as our leadership team within Water Bureau, been looking at.

1294
02:02:44.909 --> 02:02:56.087
<v Unidentified speaker>Not only, you know, what are the other revenue streams, but how do we We create a system and that those utilities— those utilities won't want— those cities will want to come back.

1295
02:02:57.130 --> 02:03:07.248
<v Unidentified speaker>The challenge we have is, you know, they— you have to build out the system too for people to connect to you, all the things that come with that.

1296
02:03:07.443 --> 02:03:11.442
<v Unidentified speaker>Or you take TVWD, they're investing in their own facility.

1297
02:03:12.234 --> 02:03:17.181
<v Unidentified speaker>Their facility is costing them at this point about $1.6 or something like that billion.

1298
02:03:17.229 --> 02:03:17.502
<v Priya Dhanapal>Billion.

1299
02:03:18.096 --> 02:03:27.136
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so, but what we do have with them is emergency agreements, right, um, that we're working through.

1300
02:03:27.810 --> 02:03:32.579
<v Unidentified speaker>I think there's the potential that we, you know, Rockwood and Gresham could come back.

1301
02:03:32.644 --> 02:03:41.417
<v Unidentified speaker>They're, they're relying solely on groundwater going forward, and there's the potential because of filtration that we may see some of that exactly.

1302
02:03:41.596 --> 02:03:44.917
<v Loretta Smith>So did they give us any indication why they left?

1303
02:03:48.556 --> 02:03:53.380
<v Unidentified speaker>I will— I can only tell you what I have learned over this time.

1304
02:03:53.573 --> 02:03:54.444
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of it is cost.

1305
02:03:55.355 --> 02:03:55.515
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1306
02:03:55.564 --> 02:04:03.646
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of it is wanting to have more control, and some of it is just politics that has existed for years between the cities.

1307
02:04:04.273 --> 02:04:06.234
<v Unidentified speaker>And some of it I've been told.

1308
02:04:06.298 --> 02:04:12.510
<v Unidentified speaker>It's just, you know, how we are able to share ownership when it comes to the Bull Run.

1309
02:04:12.557 --> 02:04:15.671
<v Loretta Smith>So yeah, very complex relationships.

1310
02:04:15.895 --> 02:04:27.130
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I'd like to see if DCA Dhanapal could come up here because I, I, I have an idea that I want to throw out at you guys because you just said something very important.

1311
02:04:27.210 --> 02:04:28.510
<v Loretta Smith>I had these in my talking points.

1312
02:04:29.072 --> 02:04:35.072
<v Loretta Smith>When you say you have to build out the system, you know, the warm Warm Springs Reservation, they're always out of water.

1313
02:04:35.231 --> 02:04:40.780
<v Loretta Smith>They're always having to boil it, having to have restricted use of their water source.

1314
02:04:41.166 --> 02:04:48.686
<v Loretta Smith>Have we tried to reach out to them to see if they could actually be one of our customers?

1315
02:04:50.162 --> 02:04:52.376
<v Keith Wilson>I'm going to check with the water— sorry, for the record.

1316
02:04:52.423 --> 02:04:53.449
<v Loretta Smith>Or maybe it's too far.

1317
02:04:53.530 --> 02:04:55.230
<v Loretta Smith>Just, I'm just trying to think.

1318
02:04:55.295 --> 02:05:03.734
<v Loretta Smith>I was reading some articles last night about them and their water, and was like, well, maybe, um, there could be a relationship.

1319
02:05:05.252 --> 02:05:06.127
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1320
02:05:06.305 --> 02:05:08.506
<v Keith Wilson>Uh, this is Priya Dhanapal, DCA for Public Works.

1321
02:05:08.733 --> 02:05:13.798
<v Keith Wilson>Um, and we have not reached out to the, uh, to that particular customer, potential customer.

1322
02:05:14.252 --> 02:05:21.898
<v Keith Wilson>We can, uh, look into, look into that, and we're always open for ideas on, um, connecting with future potential customers.

1323
02:05:22.237 --> 02:05:22.948
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, thank you.

1324
02:05:23.061 --> 02:05:30.399
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to say ditto, ditto, ditto to my, um, District 1 colleague in regards to the cost.

1325
02:05:31.189 --> 02:05:41.210
<v Loretta Smith>It is costing, and I know every DCA is hearing this across the board because we're infrastructure government, but the cost of the water is incredible.

1326
02:05:41.257 --> 02:05:43.402
<v Loretta Smith>I looked at my bill last night and paid it.

1327
02:05:43.451 --> 02:05:46.850
<v Loretta Smith>I was like, wow, this is huge.

1328
02:05:47.190 --> 02:05:48.971
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm just one person that uses water.

1329
02:05:49.538 --> 02:06:03.296
<v Loretta Smith>So, I can imagine what it looks like for the use of a family, and on top of the water and everything else is going up, the food, and it's just a nightmare across the board.

1330
02:06:03.344 --> 02:06:08.536
<v Loretta Smith>And we have the federal government who's not working right now and they're closed down.

1331
02:06:08.969 --> 02:06:16.195
<v Loretta Smith>So that is just adding to all the stress of what we have to pay for and how things are going to rise rapidly.

1332
02:06:16.260 --> 02:06:17.349
<v Loretta Smith>But I do want to say that— Councilor Loretta Smith.

1333
02:06:17.782 --> 02:06:25.612
<v Loretta Smith>Our district, I say District 1 is probably one of the most dynamic districts in the city, and I believe it is the new front door to the city of Portland.

1334
02:06:26.189 --> 02:06:29.381
<v Loretta Smith>But we have some challenges.

1335
02:06:30.119 --> 02:06:41.847
<v Loretta Smith>The average, uh, salary of a family in District 1 is $60,000 a year compared to the average salary in the other 3 districts of $90,000, average $92,000.

1336
02:06:41.993 --> 02:06:43.789
<v Loretta Smith>So I just wanted to keep that in mind.

1337
02:06:43.854 --> 02:06:46.262
<v Loretta Smith>I know we have to build something, and I know we have to pay for it.

1338
02:06:46.889 --> 02:06:56.505
<v Loretta Smith>And we, we, we, we cannot actually pay for this on the backs of an internal service fee, uh, because it takes a lot of money to, to build one of these.

1339
02:06:56.618 --> 02:07:06.314
<v Loretta Smith>And I appreciate, um, the partnership that we have with the federal government in terms of helping us to, um, have the resources to actually build this.

1340
02:07:07.037 --> 02:07:09.237
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, it's, it's needed.

1341
02:07:09.301 --> 02:07:09.396
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1342
02:07:10.006 --> 02:07:16.445
<v Loretta Smith>But I just want to just say ditto to what my partner is saying as well, and thank you.

1343
02:07:16.846 --> 02:07:17.681
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1344
02:07:17.810 --> 02:07:19.063
<v Keith Wilson>If I may add one thing.

1345
02:07:19.175 --> 02:07:19.448
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1346
02:07:19.896 --> 02:07:24.328
<v Keith Wilson>Yes, uh, the, um, bills across, across everywhere is going up.

1347
02:07:24.488 --> 02:07:35.086
<v Keith Wilson>The one thing that I do want to mention is, um, for those who are not able to afford the bill or have difficulties, we have a robust affordability program and financial assistance program.

1348
02:07:35.149 --> 02:07:40.587
<v Keith Wilson>So um, just an opportunity for people to reach out to the Water Bureau to learn how, how we can best support them.

1349
02:07:42.135 --> 02:07:43.289
<v Loretta Smith>Would I qualify for that?

1350
02:07:45.050 --> 02:07:50.118
<v Loretta Smith>I didn't get a COLA this year, so, um, I won't be able to pay any of those high bills.

1351
02:07:50.671 --> 02:07:52.836
<v Loretta Smith>Maybe when I get a COLA, I, I'll be able to do that.

1352
02:07:52.917 --> 02:07:54.676
<v Loretta Smith>But, um, just, just checking.

1353
02:07:54.871 --> 02:08:00.155
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, look, we are trying to, but this is why we are doing our smart discount.

1354
02:08:00.222 --> 02:08:00.453
<v Keelan McClymont>We're—.

1355
02:08:00.554 --> 02:08:08.167
<v Unidentified speaker>That high that's why this pilot is so important, because it is trying to help us think about how can we get just even a small discount.

1356
02:08:08.489 --> 02:08:25.921
<v Unidentified speaker>Because when we did the randomized trial, what we heard from people who got 10% or 20% that they weren't expecting is that that made the difference between them being able to pay that full bill that month, because they, they got an unexpected discount, which tells us that there is a need.

1357
02:08:26.230 --> 02:08:26.377
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

1358
02:08:26.811 --> 02:08:37.858
<v Unidentified speaker>It might not be the 60% or the 80% that some of our other customers are getting, but just a 10% or 5% can make a difference and let people know that we get it and we understand.

1359
02:08:37.985 --> 02:08:41.164
<v Unidentified speaker>So we are looking at all those things, and I do hear you all.

1360
02:08:41.244 --> 02:08:44.488
<v Unidentified speaker>It is the thing that we spend a lot of time thinking about.

1361
02:08:44.777 --> 02:08:47.811
<v Loretta Smith>And just for those folks who are watching this, I was just kidding.

1362
02:08:47.908 --> 02:08:51.311
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not asking for something from my local government.

1363
02:08:51.858 --> 02:08:52.467
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1364
02:08:52.949 --> 02:08:57.443
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1365
02:08:57.636 --> 02:08:58.759
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for the discussion.

1366
02:08:58.823 --> 02:08:59.706
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Clark.

1367
02:09:00.989 --> 02:09:01.953
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

1368
02:09:02.435 --> 02:09:04.184
<v Olivia Clark>Um, just a couple of things.

1369
02:09:04.440 --> 02:09:15.289
<v Olivia Clark>I, uh, want to echo what my, um, colleague here said about the cost escalation, um, inflation, tariffs, but also the delay.

1370
02:09:15.916 --> 02:09:22.283
<v Olivia Clark>And the delay was brought about by neighbors using the land use system to object to the facility.

1371
02:09:22.346 --> 02:09:29.685
<v Olivia Clark>So I just want to make sure everybody knows that, that, that's— it's not our fault, um, that some of these costs went up.

1372
02:09:30.021 --> 02:09:44.378
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I also, uh, wanted to add that when I first, uh, we first started meeting as the T&I committee and we had water in, I was just flabbergasted by this, uh, program that you have to assist low-income people.

1373
02:09:44.619 --> 02:09:49.655
<v Olivia Clark>And in fact, we talked about it being transferable across potentially other programs, other bureaus.

1374
02:09:50.091 --> 02:09:57.235
<v Olivia Clark>And the innovation that you're employing on the system is just admirable and really, really appreciated.

1375
02:09:57.591 --> 02:09:58.868
<v Olivia Clark>Just one last point.

1376
02:09:59.514 --> 02:10:08.345
<v Olivia Clark>I think that Portland is one of the last cities, maybe of our size, to have unfiltered water.

1377
02:10:08.409 --> 02:10:11.734
<v Olivia Clark>We're kind of behind the rest of the country in doing that.

1378
02:10:11.798 --> 02:10:11.927
<v Keith Wilson>Yes.

1379
02:10:12.662 --> 02:10:16.364
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Ryan, we've had a— we have fabulous water.

1380
02:10:16.909 --> 02:10:20.533
<v Olivia Clark>We have a great system, and it tastes really great.

1381
02:10:20.837 --> 02:10:24.220
<v Olivia Clark>But we are one of the last in the country to actually filter it all.

1382
02:10:24.940 --> 02:10:28.707
<v Olivia Clark>So we're kind of behind in that way.

1383
02:10:29.332 --> 02:10:34.912
<v Olivia Clark>But thank you very much for presenting that report, and I hope everybody votes positively on this.

1384
02:10:36.145 --> 02:10:36.867
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1385
02:10:36.947 --> 02:10:52.207
<v Keith Wilson>And I just want, before we move on, to express I just want to express my gratitude to the committee for your work on this because this is exactly the type of work that needs a deep dive, exactly the type of project that needs the oversight that council can provide.

1386
02:10:52.672 --> 02:11:00.402
<v Keith Wilson>But we know that we don't have the time to provide the deep level of oversight over every important project in the city in this body.

1387
02:11:00.804 --> 02:11:08.538
<v Keith Wilson>There's just too much and there are too many, too many of us to weigh in on every single project with this level of detail.

1388
02:11:08.603 --> 02:11:20.859
<v Keith Wilson>So I appreciate our colleagues on the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee for doing a deep dive on this and for what I know will be continued oversight work as the project moves forward.

1389
02:11:20.908 --> 02:11:25.411
<v Keith Wilson>I'm glad that it's back up and running, and I'm glad that we have such a thorough report before us today.

1390
02:11:25.490 --> 02:11:27.782
<v Keith Wilson>So thank you to all of you for that report as well.

1391
02:11:29.176 --> 02:11:36.567
<v Keith Wilson>Colleagues, I don't see any other hands in the queue, so I would entertain a motion to adopt the report.

1392
02:11:36.922 --> 02:11:37.682
<v Olivia Clark>Move to adopt.

1393
02:11:39.268 --> 02:11:39.559
<v Steve Novick>Second.

1394
02:11:41.014 --> 02:11:45.070
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, I think we're going to take Councilor Clark on the motion and Councilor Novick on the second.

1395
02:11:46.789 --> 02:11:47.904
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

1396
02:11:48.421 --> 02:11:49.164
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

1397
02:11:49.551 --> 02:11:49.600
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1398
02:11:50.296 --> 02:11:50.488
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

1399
02:11:50.926 --> 02:11:50.974
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1400
02:11:51.572 --> 02:11:51.911
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

1401
02:11:52.136 --> 02:11:52.314
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1402
02:11:52.573 --> 02:11:53.574
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

1403
02:11:54.076 --> 02:11:54.091
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1404
02:11:55.225 --> 02:11:55.354
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

1405
02:11:56.024 --> 02:11:56.073
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1406
02:11:57.832 --> 02:11:58.175
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

1407
02:12:00.939 --> 02:12:00.956
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1408
02:12:03.199 --> 02:12:03.377
<v Harper Haverkamp>Aye.

1409
02:12:04.152 --> 02:12:04.782
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

1410
02:12:05.121 --> 02:12:06.460
<v Keith Wilson>No, she's not returned yet.

1411
02:12:06.993 --> 02:12:07.283
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

1412
02:12:07.945 --> 02:12:07.993
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1413
02:12:09.060 --> 02:12:09.252
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1414
02:12:09.639 --> 02:12:09.686
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1415
02:12:10.524 --> 02:12:10.877
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1416
02:12:12.212 --> 02:12:12.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1417
02:12:13.355 --> 02:12:15.850
<v Keelan McClymont>The report is accepted with 10 yes votes.

1418
02:12:16.636 --> 02:12:16.929
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1419
02:12:16.976 --> 02:12:22.768
<v Keith Wilson>And I'll note for folks watching, um, Councilor Koyama Lane did have to jump to some other business.

1420
02:12:22.898 --> 02:12:33.373
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Kanal, who was We've got a little bit of movement online, but folks are keeping in touch with Keelan so that she can keep the roll counts appropriately.

1421
02:12:35.359 --> 02:12:38.798
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, we are back to agenda item number 5.

1422
02:12:38.846 --> 02:12:40.591
<v Keith Wilson>Could you please read the agenda item for us?

1423
02:12:43.560 --> 02:12:47.920
<v Keelan McClymont>Appoint and reappoint members to the Development Review Advisory Committee.

1424
02:12:48.841 --> 02:12:49.905
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1425
02:12:51.264 --> 02:12:55.970
<v Keith Wilson>We don't— there is a committee staff summary prepared online because this was on the consent agenda.

1426
02:12:56.018 --> 02:12:58.974
<v Keith Wilson>We don't have a verbal report for it.

1427
02:12:59.054 --> 02:13:02.507
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Avalos was the committee chair and she is absent today.

1428
02:13:02.587 --> 02:13:08.451
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Dunphy, is there anything you would like to share with us about these appointments coming out of the Homelessness and Housing Committee?

1429
02:13:08.771 --> 02:13:14.828
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I actually chaired this meeting and there were some fantastic folks who were willing to volunteer their time.

1430
02:13:16.403 --> 02:13:16.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>We were impressed.

1431
02:13:17.131 --> 02:13:21.152
<v Jamie Dunphy>They stood up to our scrutiny and our pointed questions.

1432
02:13:22.869 --> 02:13:26.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is an interesting board, just broadly.

1433
02:13:26.372 --> 02:13:39.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>DRAC is an interesting one that deals with some tricky issues, and I appreciate the sort of prescriptive way that they have built out different membership categories for members, and it has seemed to be going well.

1434
02:13:39.438 --> 02:13:50.451
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm excited for the folks who thank you so much.

1435
02:13:50.708 --> 02:13:53.338
<v Keith Wilson>And Councilor Knoll, you pulled this off of consent.

1436
02:13:53.387 --> 02:13:54.863
<v Keith Wilson>Is there anything you'd like to share with us?

1437
02:13:57.460 --> 02:14:01.113
<v Sameer Kanal>Nothing specific to the people who are being appointed.

1438
02:14:01.274 --> 02:14:07.689
<v Sameer Kanal>I had a couple, you know, general questions about the structure of it that I've asked.

1439
02:14:08.092 --> 02:14:10.859
<v Sameer Kanal>Separately and we'll continue to follow up there.

1440
02:14:11.536 --> 02:14:20.609
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to note that I did leave the other item on consent agenda because the full council did discuss it already.

1441
02:14:20.658 --> 02:14:23.359
<v Sameer Kanal>So thank you for that opportunity.

1442
02:14:24.404 --> 02:14:25.162
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1443
02:14:25.872 --> 02:14:30.796
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, has anybody signed up for public testimony since this was removed from the consent agenda?

1444
02:14:31.119 --> 02:14:31.846
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1445
02:14:32.492 --> 02:14:33.429
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, colleagues.

1446
02:14:34.095 --> 02:14:38.828
<v Keith Wilson>We do have Mr. Caron here from PP&D if there are any questions.

1447
02:14:39.021 --> 02:14:41.073
<v Keith Wilson>Does anybody have any questions or comments?

1448
02:14:42.500 --> 02:14:43.356
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Smith, are you in the queue?

1449
02:14:43.405 --> 02:14:44.086
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, I'm in the queue.

1450
02:14:44.134 --> 02:14:44.570
<v Keith Wilson>Go right ahead.

1451
02:14:44.619 --> 02:14:45.801
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much, Madam President.

1452
02:14:45.850 --> 02:14:46.465
<v Loretta Smith>I have a question.

1453
02:14:46.578 --> 02:15:10.594
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not familiar with this particular committee and not quite sure what the mission and vision of this Go right ahead.

1454
02:15:10.980 --> 02:15:11.302
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1455
02:15:11.528 --> 02:15:13.122
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, I'm Ross Caron.

1456
02:15:13.317 --> 02:15:18.327
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm with Portland Permitting Development, and I am the liaison to the Development Review Advisory Committee.

1457
02:15:19.947 --> 02:15:48.166
<v Unidentified speaker>The committee is, is a, is a citizen volunteer or community volunteer advisory committee, and as was mentioned, it has representatives from both the community as well as our industry partners that are involved in the development review and permitting process, and really acts as an advisory committee for changes to codes, rules, and processes within PP&D as well as with our partner bureaus that also are involved in the development review process.

1458
02:15:48.855 --> 02:16:11.912
<v Unidentified speaker>So the committee members both advise, make recommendations, and also anytime we make changes or improvements, we engage that group to get community and industry partner feedback that we then take into consideration or act on as we move those changes through our legislative processes or just process improvement processes.

1459
02:16:13.811 --> 02:16:23.394
<v Unidentified speaker>The members are appointed to the 3-year terms there are 17 members in total, and they have the option to serve one second term.

1460
02:16:24.565 --> 02:16:41.408
<v Unidentified speaker>And their immediate responsibilities are joining the committee and then, you know, representing the different perspectives or the different seats on the committee in advising the city on changes, codes, and rules related to permitting.

1461
02:16:42.822 --> 02:16:48.314
<v Loretta Smith>So will they actually look at— we did the system development charges waivers.

1462
02:16:48.569 --> 02:16:55.619
<v Loretta Smith>Are they going to be looking at that to see if that program is actually working and how it's working and where it's working at?

1463
02:16:56.679 --> 02:17:06.618
<v Unidentified speaker>They— so they were involved in— they were engaged in that, the SDC waivers, providing feedback and perspectives from the community.

1464
02:17:08.310 --> 02:17:15.593
<v Unidentified speaker>And as we monitor the performance of that, we will be reporting that back out to the Development Review Advisory Committee.

1465
02:17:16.979 --> 02:17:25.879
<v Loretta Smith>I know this is off topic, but have we experienced an overwhelming response to our waiver?

1466
02:17:26.329 --> 02:17:27.924
<v Loretta Smith>Have we gotten more people?

1467
02:17:28.367 --> 02:17:41.112
<v Loretta Smith>I see Administrator Jordan, he's cringing over here, but I'm just curious to know, this was months ago and we were told that people are in the queue and all they need to do is get this waiver.

1468
02:17:41.257 --> 02:17:42.996
<v Loretta Smith>And so I'm wondering, has it worked yet?

1469
02:17:44.981 --> 02:17:54.179
<v Unidentified speaker>I did— I could— we could— I could, um, follow up with our deputy director and director and, and, and follow up with you on that.

1470
02:17:54.244 --> 02:17:55.055
<v Unidentified speaker>But I, I don't know.

1471
02:17:55.136 --> 02:17:55.233
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

1472
02:17:55.314 --> 02:18:00.601
<v Loretta Smith>If you can talk to me offline and kind of give me a a lay of the land.

1473
02:18:01.788 --> 02:18:02.189
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1474
02:18:02.574 --> 02:18:03.102
<v Unidentified speaker>You're welcome.

1475
02:18:03.856 --> 02:18:04.610
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1476
02:18:04.738 --> 02:18:05.268
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Green?

1477
02:18:06.759 --> 02:18:14.055
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, just very briefly, I just wanted to note that I appreciated seeing the bio summaries kind of clearly laid out.

1478
02:18:15.097 --> 02:18:25.297
<v Mitch Green>Every single one of those people made it very clear that their purpose is making sure that we are overcoming the hurdles to housing production and broad development in this city.

1479
02:18:26.163 --> 02:18:30.092
<v Mitch Green>Respecting other nuances of the broad array of things we should care about in our built environment.

1480
02:18:30.813 --> 02:18:34.629
<v Mitch Green>That's going to continue to be very important to me for all the reasons I've already said.

1481
02:18:34.726 --> 02:18:37.036
<v Mitch Green>So happy to support these appointees.

1482
02:18:37.629 --> 02:18:38.270
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1483
02:18:38.431 --> 02:18:39.103
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Ryan.

1484
02:18:39.313 --> 02:18:40.049
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, 2 things.

1485
02:18:40.114 --> 02:18:41.862
<v Dan Ryan>One is, thanks, good to see you.

1486
02:18:41.975 --> 02:18:51.436
<v Dan Ryan>I thought that the DRAC appointments were just outstanding, and we had such good dialogue at the meeting about their values and why they're serving and also their IQ.

1487
02:18:52.127 --> 02:18:53.717
<v Dan Ryan>About what it takes to do development.

1488
02:18:54.697 --> 02:18:56.528
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Smith, I really appreciate your question.

1489
02:18:56.784 --> 02:18:58.711
<v Dan Ryan>Our office has really been trying to track that.

1490
02:18:59.032 --> 02:19:07.370
<v Dan Ryan>We're seeing some good trends on pulling permits for housing developments that are, say, under 19 units, 19 and below, and we kind of know why that is.

1491
02:19:07.884 --> 02:19:14.469
<v Dan Ryan>But other than that, I really haven't seen a lot, but that's better than what was happening for months prior to that.

1492
02:19:14.727 --> 02:19:24.653
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm hoping that even though it's a really disappointing year in terms of pulling permits and doing any economic development in Portland, we are seeing some upticks in the smaller units.

1493
02:19:25.132 --> 02:19:27.377
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, at least in North— at least in District 2.

1494
02:19:27.681 --> 02:19:27.938
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1495
02:19:29.203 --> 02:19:29.797
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1496
02:19:29.844 --> 02:19:30.549
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Dunphy.

1497
02:19:31.302 --> 02:19:37.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I just wanted to, uh, very quickly point out to my colleagues, because I screwed this up in committee, DRAC is not design review, by the way.

1498
02:19:38.018 --> 02:19:39.091
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is development review.

1499
02:19:39.171 --> 02:19:40.485
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is a separate conversation.

1500
02:19:40.981 --> 02:19:42.665
<v Jamie Dunphy>I screwed that up in committee, I think, maybe twice.

1501
02:19:42.745 --> 02:19:46.147
<v Jamie Dunphy>So So just wanted to make sure that's very obvious for everybody.

1502
02:19:47.077 --> 02:19:50.192
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor, for that clarification, both for us and for others listening.

1503
02:19:50.867 --> 02:19:51.557
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Kanal.

1504
02:19:52.953 --> 02:19:53.836
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1505
02:19:54.799 --> 02:20:07.772
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to first echo and appreciate Councilor Smith's questions and ask for the same data as well, and I guess also from Councilor Ryan also, but, and also echo everything that Councilor Green said.

1506
02:20:08.204 --> 02:20:18.390
<v Sameer Kanal>My question was, As to whether or not— or it's maybe not, uh, yes or no, actually— the, the level of detail that goes into these individual slots.

1507
02:20:19.033 --> 02:20:32.181
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, are there any of the particular, um, positions and, uh, specific backgrounds that an individual needs to be on DRAC which are more challenging to fill or to find applicants for?

1508
02:20:37.141 --> 02:20:37.512
<v Keelan McClymont>That's—.

1509
02:20:37.528 --> 02:20:44.540
<v Unidentified speaker>I've, I've been the liaison to DRAC for the last almost 2 years, and we've filled a number of seats.

1510
02:20:45.983 --> 02:20:52.447
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so I don't know, Councilor Kanal, if I have the, the information to, to respond to that question.

1511
02:20:53.270 --> 02:20:58.047
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, but I, I— we, we generally have pretty good turnout.

1512
02:20:58.465 --> 02:20:58.754
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry.

1513
02:20:59.799 --> 02:21:05.126
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd be happy to follow up sure, I will do that.

1514
02:21:05.191 --> 02:21:05.628
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1515
02:21:07.052 --> 02:21:07.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1516
02:21:08.413 --> 02:21:09.271
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1517
02:21:09.789 --> 02:21:11.845
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, councilors, colleagues.

1518
02:21:12.493 --> 02:21:25.788
<v Keith Wilson>Seeing no one else in the queue, and with my gratitude to everybody who has stepped forward to serve in these roles on behalf of all residents of the city, I think we should move to a vote.

1519
02:21:25.869 --> 02:21:27.131
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, can you please call the roll?

1520
02:21:28.470 --> 02:21:30.382
<v Keelan McClymont>Madam President, this is a—.

1521
02:21:30.703 --> 02:21:32.215
<v Keith Wilson>Oh, this is a report, isn't it?

1522
02:21:32.310 --> 02:21:33.596
<v Keith Wilson>This is listed as a report.

1523
02:21:33.661 --> 02:21:34.448
<v Keith Wilson>I apologize.

1524
02:21:34.625 --> 02:21:37.520
<v Keith Wilson>I would entertain a motion to adopt the report.

1525
02:21:37.698 --> 02:21:38.102
<v Unidentified speaker>So moved.

1526
02:21:38.361 --> 02:21:38.798
<v Dan Ryan>Second.

1527
02:21:38.846 --> 02:21:39.299
<v Sameer Kanal>Second.

1528
02:21:39.656 --> 02:21:42.195
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, Councilor Dunphy and then Councilor Ryan, I believe.

1529
02:21:42.520 --> 02:21:42.698
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1530
02:21:44.009 --> 02:21:44.349
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1531
02:21:45.126 --> 02:21:45.174
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1532
02:21:46.745 --> 02:21:46.924
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1533
02:21:47.425 --> 02:21:47.862
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1534
02:21:48.057 --> 02:21:48.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1535
02:21:49.110 --> 02:21:49.450
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1536
02:21:49.740 --> 02:21:49.903
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1537
02:21:50.972 --> 02:21:51.271
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1538
02:21:51.951 --> 02:21:52.001
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1539
02:21:52.217 --> 02:21:53.112
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1540
02:21:54.047 --> 02:21:54.224
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1541
02:21:55.012 --> 02:21:55.060
<v Beth Woodard>Aye.

1542
02:21:58.070 --> 02:21:58.119
<v Beth Woodard>Aye.

1543
02:22:00.164 --> 02:22:00.211
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1544
02:22:02.900 --> 02:22:02.949
<v Keith Wilson>Aye.

1545
02:22:04.029 --> 02:22:06.352
<v Keelan McClymont>The report is accepted with 10 yes votes.

1546
02:22:06.950 --> 02:22:07.725
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Keelan.

1547
02:22:08.549 --> 02:22:11.066
<v Keith Wilson>And we do have one additional agenda item.

1548
02:22:11.292 --> 02:22:13.593
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, could you please call agenda item 10?

1549
02:22:16.129 --> 02:22:24.519
<v Keelan McClymont>Authorize council to continue operating under the current thank you, Keelan.

1550
02:22:24.615 --> 02:22:28.173
<v Keith Wilson>And colleagues, you do all have a paper copy of this in front of you.

1551
02:22:28.270 --> 02:22:38.930
<v Keith Wilson>And for folks watching online or in the room or who do better on screen, this is now posted as item 10 on today's agenda as well.

1552
02:22:40.780 --> 02:22:43.018
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, do we have anybody signed up for public testimony?

1553
02:22:44.909 --> 02:22:45.327
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1554
02:22:45.380 --> 02:22:45.799
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Councilor McClymont.

1555
02:22:46.173 --> 02:22:53.271
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, so I would draw your attention, colleagues, to the first whereas and the first therefore as the real meat of this.

1556
02:22:54.105 --> 02:23:06.327
<v Keith Wilson>We passed an emergency ordinance previously that required me as council president to ensure that we had a proposal to replace or extend Chapter 3.02 of City Code no later than October 31st.

1557
02:23:06.873 --> 02:23:26.975
<v Keith Wilson>Given the enormous work that has been done in the Governance Committee, including some updates via resolution to our rules and a package that I have in the works right now that I have been working with the council vice president to make sure we have time to hear before the end of this year.

1558
02:23:27.652 --> 02:23:31.246
<v Keith Wilson>I had thought that perhaps we had met the requirements there.

1559
02:23:31.861 --> 02:23:38.869
<v Keith Wilson>I recently learned that the language that we passed was far more prescriptive than I had recalled and that we did need to do something.

1560
02:23:38.998 --> 02:23:39.549
<v Keith Wilson>So today, Thank you.

1561
02:23:39.956 --> 02:23:54.729
<v Keith Wilson>I have something brought forward for us which says, therefore be it resolved, the council will continue operating under the current language in Chapter 3.02 of City Code, which allows us without making any changes today to meet that requirement.

1562
02:23:55.515 --> 02:24:06.504
<v Keith Wilson>This resolution also notes that I do have a package in the works, which we will be posting as soon as it is through legal review where it is sitting right now.

1563
02:24:06.552 --> 02:24:06.697
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1564
02:24:07.628 --> 02:24:10.066
<v Keith Wilson>I'm very interested in what my colleague is cooking.

1565
02:24:11.559 --> 02:24:19.841
<v Keith Wilson>And we will have that posted and before the Governance Committee, likely on the Governance Committee agenda next month.

1566
02:24:19.905 --> 02:24:26.772
<v Keith Wilson>I would encourage anybody not on that committee who has an interest in the topic to come testify there and share your thoughts with us.

1567
02:24:27.703 --> 02:24:42.334
<v Keith Wilson>One of the things that we hadn't discussed when we first passed the emergency ordinance Earlier this year was that if something didn't make it to full council because we couldn't get agreement in committee, we wouldn't be able to fulfill this requirement.

1568
02:24:42.770 --> 02:24:53.376
<v Keith Wilson>That's why we didn't just extend the date of the requirement, but are instead specifying until something else comes forward, we will continue to operate under our city code as it currently stands.

1569
02:24:53.684 --> 02:24:54.790
<v Keith Wilson>We've developed norms.

1570
02:24:55.472 --> 02:24:57.129
<v Keith Wilson>We have been doing this.

1571
02:24:57.976 --> 02:25:03.689
<v Keith Wilson>And That gives us the flexibility to have the conversations that we need to moving forward.

1572
02:25:06.250 --> 02:25:07.230
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Kanal.

1573
02:25:09.564 --> 02:25:10.465
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1574
02:25:10.771 --> 02:25:17.806
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I have a question for you about the second, therefore the second be it further resolved.

1575
02:25:18.436 --> 02:25:33.731
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, currently under city code, uh, 3.02.020, It says that ordinances amending council rules generally will be assigned to the full council without committee consideration.

1576
02:25:35.207 --> 02:25:40.224
<v Sameer Kanal>But in the there be it further resolved, it says that will go to the Governance Committee.

1577
02:25:40.800 --> 02:25:43.638
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just wanted to understand the legislative intent there.

1578
02:25:44.584 --> 02:25:45.322
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to that, please?

1579
02:25:45.690 --> 02:25:55.310
<v Keith Wilson>The Governance Committee has been having a number of conversations about how council operates generally, many of which were not in ordinance form.

1580
02:25:55.470 --> 02:26:00.272
<v Keith Wilson>They were in resolution form or in the form of conversations about a potential handbook.

1581
02:26:00.865 --> 02:26:18.014
<v Keith Wilson>Because those conversations are very related to some of the items contained in the ordinance, I felt that there was a compelling reason to make sure that there was some cohesiveness in those conversations by placing it in governance where the rest of that work is taking place.

1582
02:26:18.272 --> 02:26:19.299
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1583
02:26:19.772 --> 02:26:25.204
<v Sameer Kanal>And is, is just to clarify further, is the document that you're intending to bring an ordinance or a resolution?

1584
02:26:26.522 --> 02:26:28.209
<v Keith Wilson>That document will be an ordinance.

1585
02:26:31.109 --> 02:26:31.351
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

1586
02:26:32.480 --> 02:26:35.968
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, is this just a question time or is this also open debate?

1587
02:26:36.816 --> 02:26:41.171
<v Keith Wilson>Uh, we do not have public testimony signed up, so we can take questions or debate.

1588
02:26:42.456 --> 02:26:47.511
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, then I will continue and say that I, I'm a strong supporter of the, the way the code is now.

1589
02:26:47.725 --> 02:27:03.190
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm concerned about creating a, uh, either a precedent of resolutions that defy code, or, uh, and obviously this is not a direct defiance because it does say generally, um, but one that, that is sort of in a different space, uh, than the spirit of the code.

1590
02:27:03.768 --> 02:27:05.662
<v Sameer Kanal>So that is my primary concern.

1591
02:27:05.790 --> 02:27:12.968
<v Sameer Kanal>I am grateful for you, and I think the Council Vice President as well, bringing forward to, uh, a document to do this, um, in the first place.

1592
02:27:13.240 --> 02:27:19.958
<v Sameer Kanal>But that is my concern, is that this would go back to governance when, as opposed to a work session or a full council discussion.

1593
02:27:20.950 --> 02:27:29.389
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, and I'll also mention that the, the requirement under the old, the ordinance in January is to bring something to the council agenda.

1594
02:27:29.923 --> 02:27:37.301
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, this would check that box, but it's sort of about the idea that the full, full council will get to talk about this first.

1595
02:27:38.041 --> 02:27:43.399
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I'll also, um, I think I already made that point, so I will stop there.

1596
02:27:43.593 --> 02:27:43.853
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1597
02:27:45.539 --> 02:27:46.171
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1598
02:27:46.364 --> 02:27:48.358
<v Keith Wilson>Is there any other discussion to the resolution?

1599
02:27:51.648 --> 02:27:52.355
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Zimmerman.

1600
02:27:53.416 --> 02:27:55.634
<v Eric Zimmerman>I share some concerns with Councilor Kanal.

1601
02:27:56.228 --> 02:28:08.209
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I think that, uh, what I've seen so far as a preview for some sort of handbook or guidance and things of that nature is Not going to meet my expectation.

1602
02:28:08.664 --> 02:28:31.212
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm not— I guess by extending this, I want to make sure that we're not also signaling to you all that you should expect that what comes out of, you know, a small group is going to be broadly accepted without having a much bigger discussion on this.

1603
02:28:31.261 --> 02:28:31.906
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a fair point.

1604
02:28:32.647 --> 02:28:37.291
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think Councilor Kanal's points make some sense to me on that.

1605
02:28:38.376 --> 02:29:00.996
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I've said multiple times where I think when a council attempts to do things like a, you know, a workbook or whatever that has been, that kind of reeks to me of some of the transition team stuff where we really saw them get sideways with the role of the city council in this new form of government.

1606
02:29:01.048 --> 02:29:01.352
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a fair point.

1607
02:29:01.456 --> 02:29:12.448
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that they were speaking and they made plans, and it took us months to overcome those issues, uh, when they subjugated us to the far side of this government.

1608
02:29:12.752 --> 02:29:15.236
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, uh, I don't want anything that resembles that.

1609
02:29:15.347 --> 02:29:17.447
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm taking this in.

1610
02:29:17.512 --> 02:29:30.836
<v Eric Zimmerman>I see— I understand the administrative piece that you're seeking here, and also signaling to those of you who sit governance of, um, this is due a big So that's all.

1611
02:29:30.981 --> 02:29:31.306
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1612
02:29:31.548 --> 02:29:34.038
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1613
02:29:34.119 --> 02:29:51.433
<v Keith Wilson>And I'll just note that I don't think support for this administrative vote today says anything about whether somebody would support a package brought forward, a handbook which is separate from that package, or any other potential rule or code change in the future.

1614
02:29:51.980 --> 02:29:52.127
<v Keith Wilson>Thanks.

1615
02:29:53.271 --> 02:29:53.754
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Smith.

1616
02:29:55.977 --> 02:29:56.998
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

1617
02:29:57.047 --> 02:30:01.793
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just trying to figure out what will this— what powers will this give you that you don't have right now?

1618
02:30:03.809 --> 02:30:04.456
<v Keith Wilson>Absolutely none.

1619
02:30:04.632 --> 02:30:07.395
<v Keith Wilson>This just fulfills an administrative requirement.

1620
02:30:08.688 --> 02:30:09.915
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay.

1621
02:30:11.578 --> 02:30:14.474
<v Loretta Smith>And we had to do it today because of what?

1622
02:30:15.541 --> 02:30:17.289
<v Loretta Smith>Or by the end of November because of why?

1623
02:30:17.968 --> 02:30:36.097
<v Keith Wilson>Uh, we passed an ordinance where we changed some of the rules that we operate under in code and 3.02 at the beginning of the year, which set a deadline of October 31st to essentially either reaffirm the code or bring a package of changes to the code.

1624
02:30:36.323 --> 02:30:37.448
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay, I got it.

1625
02:30:39.280 --> 02:30:40.595
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Kanal, something additional?

1626
02:30:45.091 --> 02:31:00.324
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, so my understanding, and I'm finding the exact words here, is that the, the, the— and I don't want to be too, too cute about it, but it does say that, you know, it has to be placed on the council agenda by today.

1627
02:31:00.404 --> 02:31:11.349
<v Sameer Kanal>I think my understanding, and, and that's an ordinance that, that I put forward back in January, obviously a lot of other people, in particular Councilor Zimmerman, were involved in developing it as well.

1628
02:31:11.576 --> 02:31:27.576
<v Sameer Kanal>But my, my, my thought process at the time was that I wanted to make sure that we were time was that anything that would extend it would also need to be an ordinance, um, so that there would be— that not that we would have to vote on something today, but that there would be a first discussion on it today.

1629
02:31:28.218 --> 02:31:39.112
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so I think that's a, um, consideration for this conversation is whether or not acting on it today is the necessity.

1630
02:31:39.771 --> 02:31:51.699
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, having said that, I I think that this is on the whole a very good approach to how to address the need from Ordinance 192021.

1631
02:31:52.355 --> 02:32:01.668
<v Sameer Kanal>I think the concern I have is the exact words in the governance committee at the end of the final be it further resolved.

1632
02:32:02.069 --> 02:32:11.493
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that addresses the concern that Councilor Zimmerman stated and that I alluded to about broader conversation being necessary.

1633
02:32:11.927 --> 02:32:23.040
<v Sameer Kanal>So my proposal at this time would be, I think, to amend out the final 4 words of the— therefore, of the be it further resolved.

1634
02:32:23.088 --> 02:32:27.575
<v Sameer Kanal>This is the 2nd resolved, so removing the words in the Governance Committee.

1635
02:32:30.064 --> 02:32:32.738
<v Keith Wilson>Colleagues, is there a second to that proposed amendment?

1636
02:32:32.805 --> 02:32:33.066
<v Keelan McClymont>Second.

1637
02:32:34.319 --> 02:32:41.217
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, is there discussion to the proposed amendment which would remove the words in the Governance Committee from the second resolved?

1638
02:32:49.760 --> 02:32:52.345
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, seeing no discussion— oh, Councilor Ryan.

1639
02:32:53.752 --> 02:33:00.492
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Knoll, are, are you saying that you don't want the Governance Committee to dive into the details of this before it comes to the full council?

1640
02:33:02.180 --> 02:33:04.614
<v Sameer Kanal>I think the— may I respond, Madam President?

1641
02:33:05.099 --> 02:33:05.825
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, that's—.

1642
02:33:05.825 --> 02:33:06.389
<v Keith Wilson>I asked directly.

1643
02:33:07.729 --> 02:33:11.324
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's hard to tell on Zoom whether to jump in or not.

1644
02:33:11.453 --> 02:33:29.032
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, the, the effect of this amendment would be to no longer prescribe that it goes to the Governance Committee, which I think is more in line with the original intent of the ordinance, that the proposal to replace or extend the code would come to the full council.

1645
02:33:29.081 --> 02:33:31.682
<v Sameer Kanal>That's what Ordinance 192021 does say.

1646
02:33:33.174 --> 02:33:46.438
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there are a lot of conversations that have already had— have occurred at governance, as the council president mentioned, which will feed into the development of whatever the next proposal is, but that it should come to a broader discussion first.

1647
02:33:47.161 --> 02:33:51.673
<v Sameer Kanal>This amendment would not mandate that, but simply not mandate that it goes to governance first.

1648
02:33:51.720 --> 02:33:51.849
<v Blake Schell>Thank you.

1649
02:33:55.671 --> 02:34:05.721
<v Dan Ryan>So I think you answered my question that it should just come directly to council, but not be further vetted in governance, which hasn't really had this direct conversation yet.

1650
02:34:06.091 --> 02:34:09.270
<v Dan Ryan>I sit on governance, so I do understand what we've been doing.

1651
02:34:10.184 --> 02:34:14.424
<v Dan Ryan>And I was happy this was on the docket so we could actually get into the details of it.

1652
02:34:15.338 --> 02:34:16.495
<v Dan Ryan>So what am I missing?

1653
02:34:16.864 --> 02:34:20.943
<v Dan Ryan>I'm trying to figure out what your problem you're trying to solve with your amendment.

1654
02:34:21.282 --> 02:34:27.254
<v Sameer Kanal>If it relates to council rules, it should go to 12 of us after governance works on it.

1655
02:34:28.703 --> 02:34:36.951
<v Sameer Kanal>The current city council code, which I read, is that things that amend council rules generally go to the full council without committee consideration.

1656
02:34:37.468 --> 02:34:38.921
<v Sameer Kanal>We all voted to approve that.

1657
02:34:39.097 --> 02:34:45.439
<v Sameer Kanal>That was a, um, a decision we made intentionally to ensure that the full council was weighing in on it.

1658
02:34:45.813 --> 02:34:50.693
<v Sameer Kanal>Not having it be shaped exclusively by a subset.

1659
02:34:50.934 --> 02:34:55.174
<v Dan Ryan>I believe in the Governance Committee, and so I won't be supporting this amendment.

1660
02:34:55.351 --> 02:34:56.941
<v Dan Ryan>I think that you can do both.

1661
02:34:57.054 --> 02:35:02.336
<v Dan Ryan>You can have it be vetted out in the details in a Governance Committee, and then we can bring it to the full council.

1662
02:35:03.219 --> 02:35:03.798
<v Dan Ryan>So thanks.

1663
02:35:04.183 --> 02:35:06.576
<v Dan Ryan>I won't be supporting the amendment based on this conversation.

1664
02:35:06.769 --> 02:35:07.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

1665
02:35:07.492 --> 02:35:08.279
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1666
02:35:08.536 --> 02:35:09.177
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Clark.

1667
02:35:10.527 --> 02:35:12.951
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, I don't understand this amendment.

1668
02:35:13.209 --> 02:35:15.472
<v Olivia Clark>It doesn't preclude us from discussing it.

1669
02:35:15.745 --> 02:35:17.814
<v Olivia Clark>In Governance Committee, right?

1670
02:35:18.390 --> 02:35:19.689
<v Dan Ryan>It sounds like he doesn't want us to.

1671
02:35:19.930 --> 02:35:20.329
<v Olivia Clark>He doesn't?

1672
02:35:20.570 --> 02:35:20.810
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1673
02:35:21.115 --> 02:35:26.358
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Kanal, you don't want us to discuss this in Governance Committee, but you're not precluding us from doing that?

1674
02:35:27.063 --> 02:35:27.879
<v Keith Wilson>Go ahead, Councilor.

1675
02:35:29.130 --> 02:35:34.852
<v Sameer Kanal>This is, I think, being shaped in both questions as what do I want or not.

1676
02:35:34.917 --> 02:35:35.846
<v Sameer Kanal>This is what the code says.

1677
02:35:36.601 --> 02:35:45.815
<v Sameer Kanal>The code says that ordinances, emergency ordinances and ordinances amending council rules Generally will be referred to the full council without committee consideration.

1678
02:35:46.185 --> 02:35:48.644
<v Sameer Kanal>So this simply keeps this resolution in line with that code.

1679
02:35:55.043 --> 02:35:57.109
<v Keith Wilson>Did you have follow-up, Councilor?

1680
02:35:58.656 --> 02:36:04.530
<v Olivia Clark>Well, as the sponsor of this resolution, I'd be curious to know how you feel about it, Madam President.

1681
02:36:08.034 --> 02:36:10.506
<v Keith Wilson>Let me take Councilor Green's question and then I'm happy to weigh in.

1682
02:36:10.781 --> 02:36:11.799
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Green, go right ahead.

1683
02:36:13.139 --> 02:36:13.494
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1684
02:36:14.361 --> 02:36:41.156
<v Mitch Green>I understand the intent of this amendment to be about precedent setting, and I think what I'm hearing from Councilor Kanal is that we change— we all agreed upon an ordinance that changed our code and rules of procedure that says changes to our own rules go straight to City Council, the full body, and not be passed through committees by other policies.

1685
02:36:41.252 --> 02:36:42.760
<v Mitch Green>And that was our intent when we passed this.

1686
02:36:42.888 --> 02:37:09.625
<v Mitch Green>And so I think what I'm hearing from Councilor Kanal is concern that using a resolution to— however expedient this is, and it's— I agree that it's a good solution to our current problem— could establish some very confusing precedent that we actually can send matters before council in terms of our rules to another committee, even though we've said in our and so that's how I'm reading this.

1687
02:37:10.077 --> 02:37:14.806
<v Mitch Green>I don't see any desire to prevent discussion on a committee.

1688
02:37:14.853 --> 02:37:18.359
<v Mitch Green>I mean, committees can always discuss anything they want by the chair's prerogative.

1689
02:37:18.971 --> 02:37:28.777
<v Mitch Green>And so I think I would encourage the Governance Committee to continue to have these robust conversations and maybe present a comment by the committee to the full council when we consider these rules.

1690
02:37:29.372 --> 02:37:30.500
<v Mitch Green>That would continue, I think, in the same spirit.

1691
02:37:30.548 --> 02:37:30.645
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1692
02:37:30.790 --> 02:37:37.415
<v Mitch Green>Spirit, but, um, I, I share that concern about establishing precedent that deviates from our code by a resolution.

1693
02:37:39.734 --> 02:37:41.028
<v Mitch Green>So I'll be, I'll be supporting the amendment.

1694
02:37:41.835 --> 02:37:42.417
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1695
02:37:42.483 --> 02:37:43.177
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Smith.

1696
02:37:45.878 --> 02:37:47.414
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, uh, Madam President.

1697
02:37:47.495 --> 02:37:52.000
<v Loretta Smith>I have, um, legal counsel, please advise.

1698
02:37:52.682 --> 02:37:56.105
<v Loretta Smith>Can a resolution change an ordinance?

1699
02:38:00.792 --> 02:38:05.659
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, no, a resolution cannot change an ordinance.

1700
02:38:05.789 --> 02:38:10.863
<v Loretta Smith>So what we're doing here is not going to be able to change it unless we do it in an ordinance, right?

1701
02:38:15.819 --> 02:38:17.141
<v Unidentified speaker>So they are—.

1702
02:38:17.433 --> 02:38:22.559
<v Keith Wilson>Let's see what it says.

1703
02:38:38.932 --> 02:38:45.136
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor, I don't believe what we're doing is attempting to change an ordinance in this resolution.

1704
02:38:45.247 --> 02:38:51.361
<v Keith Wilson>We're just affirming in this resolution that we will continue operating under the current language that is in code.

1705
02:38:53.233 --> 02:38:57.354
<v Loretta Smith>That seems like that's changing an ordinance to me.

1706
02:38:58.289 --> 02:39:08.394
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just trying to be clear because I didn't think you could have a resolution to change the, the kind of direction that an ordinance is already given.

1707
02:39:13.501 --> 02:39:31.997
<v Olivia Clark>I just want legal counsel to tell me if this is legal to Madam President, while legal researches this, if we don't pass this today, what happens?

1708
02:39:32.063 --> 02:39:33.828
<v Olivia Clark>Do you go to jail or what happens?

1709
02:39:36.345 --> 02:39:45.028
<v Keith Wilson>In my experience, there are plenty of times where bodies don't actually comply with their own requirements, and unless somebody calls them on it, nothing happens.

1710
02:39:45.149 --> 02:39:45.471
<v Keith Wilson>What happens?

1711
02:39:46.372 --> 02:39:51.268
<v Keith Wilson>I think what happens is you all give me a firm finger wagging.

1712
02:39:53.590 --> 02:40:21.430
<v Keith Wilson>I would say having brought multiple things both to Council and Governance Committee and having discussed many things brought by my colleagues and having passed at this body items that came out of the Governance Committee but that were not ordinances amending 3.02, that we have done significant work that this speaks to, even if we haven't met the specific requirements.

1713
02:40:21.478 --> 02:40:28.350
<v Keith Wilson>So I would hope that even if this doesn't pass, we are comfortable with where we sit.

1714
02:40:28.415 --> 02:40:32.281
<v Keith Wilson>But I wanted to make sure we were dotting every i and crossing every t, which is why I brought it forward.

1715
02:40:32.361 --> 02:40:39.391
<v Loretta Smith>And so for me, I'm comfortable with it, but I just want to know what the— I just need to know what is legal and what is not.

1716
02:40:40.066 --> 02:40:49.301
<v Loretta Smith>And so for us to be spending a lot of time on something that's not even— it's not, it's, it's not in statute that we can do this.

1717
02:40:49.495 --> 02:40:56.643
<v Loretta Smith>So why are we talking about it here until we can actually talk about it in a work session or in a bigger conversation that we need to have?

1718
02:40:56.691 --> 02:40:56.915
<v Olivia Clark>This is—.

1719
02:40:57.591 --> 02:41:00.738
<v Loretta Smith>I, I'm just kind of thrown off because I didn't know anything about it.

1720
02:41:00.802 --> 02:41:02.007
<v Loretta Smith>Go, go ahead, legal counsel.

1721
02:41:02.649 --> 02:41:05.360
<v Unidentified speaker>Through Uh, this is Alan Yoder, uh, Deputy City Attorney.

1722
02:41:05.552 --> 02:41:14.001
<v Unidentified speaker>Through resolution, the City Council, um, can agree to extend, um, the current rules that it's working under.

1723
02:41:17.379 --> 02:41:17.781
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1724
02:41:19.632 --> 02:41:22.770
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1725
02:41:26.356 --> 02:41:27.173
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor—.

1726
02:41:27.173 --> 02:41:30.513
<v Keith Wilson>Hold on— Councilor Novick, have you spoken to this yet?

1727
02:41:31.513 --> 02:41:31.995
<v Steve Novick>I have not.

1728
02:41:32.075 --> 02:41:32.751
<v Keith Wilson>Go right ahead.

1729
02:41:33.264 --> 02:41:34.951
<v Steve Novick>I, I just have a question from Councilor Kanal.

1730
02:41:35.048 --> 02:41:38.292
<v Steve Novick>Sorry, I just pulled up the, um, proposal.

1731
02:41:39.064 --> 02:41:47.675
<v Steve Novick>Were you saying that what you would do is in the second, in, in the be it further resolved, uh, just cross out the words in the Governance Committee?

1732
02:41:49.988 --> 02:41:50.119
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1733
02:41:52.433 --> 02:41:53.647
<v Steve Novick>Okay, thank you.

1734
02:41:59.198 --> 02:42:00.551
<v Keith Wilson>I apologize, Councilor Zimmerman.

1735
02:42:00.728 --> 02:42:02.631
<v Keith Wilson>You spoke to the underlying but not the amendment.

1736
02:42:02.680 --> 02:42:03.744
<v Keith Wilson>I should not have skipped over you.

1737
02:42:03.808 --> 02:42:04.308
<v Keith Wilson>Go right ahead.

1738
02:42:04.372 --> 02:42:04.566
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1739
02:42:04.679 --> 02:42:10.736
<v Eric Zimmerman>For the— for this, I would just like to limit debate and get to the question of this amendment, and then so we can move on back to the whole.

1740
02:42:12.963 --> 02:42:13.433
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1741
02:42:13.836 --> 02:42:22.020
<v Keith Wilson>I'm going to try to move us without taking a vote on that because I think we just have Councilor Kanal and my answer to Councilor Clark.

1742
02:42:23.486 --> 02:42:24.176
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Kanal.

1743
02:42:25.397 --> 02:42:28.963
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I actually wanted to speak in, in your defense here, Madam President.

1744
02:42:29.028 --> 02:42:35.597
<v Sameer Kanal>The, the ordinance actually just requires that you put something on the agenda, uh, not that the council actually passes it.

1745
02:42:35.918 --> 02:42:42.006
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I don't think it would be fair to require the council president to ensure passage or failure of an item.

1746
02:42:42.584 --> 02:42:47.645
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and this— the original January ordinance does not do that, so we're actually already in compliance.

1747
02:42:47.822 --> 02:42:52.513
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's not to say that we shouldn't try to pass something good, but I just wanted to flag that.

1748
02:42:54.149 --> 02:43:09.281
<v Sameer Kanal>And I do think that the other piece of this, to Councilor Smith's point, is that having legislative intent through a resolution to be an exception to the generally is where I draw a line here.

1749
02:43:09.329 --> 02:43:13.103
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't want to say that this item is an exception to the code.

1750
02:43:13.653 --> 02:43:16.906
<v Sameer Kanal>Where it says generally things will go to the full council.

1751
02:43:17.180 --> 02:43:21.720
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's where I think the amendment is particularly relevant here.

1752
02:43:21.849 --> 02:43:24.093
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's keeping it to the amendment at hand.

1753
02:43:24.271 --> 02:43:24.561
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1754
02:43:26.630 --> 02:43:27.358
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor.

1755
02:43:27.665 --> 02:43:31.626
<v Keith Wilson>And Councilor Clark, I said I would get back to your question to me.

1756
02:43:31.707 --> 02:43:34.315
<v Keith Wilson>I wanted to make sure all of our colleagues had time to speak as well.

1757
02:43:35.596 --> 02:43:40.233
<v Keith Wilson>Frankly, I'm very comfortable with the language that I Thank you.

1758
02:43:40.298 --> 02:43:40.506
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Mayor.

1759
02:43:40.555 --> 02:43:45.272
<v Keith Wilson>So the ordinance that was brought forward, the code, as Councilor Knoll pointed out, says generally.

1760
02:43:47.139 --> 02:44:05.266
<v Keith Wilson>After passing that code, because that is something that was added this year, this body then created committees, including creating a governance committee whose direction includes periodically reviewing council rules and procedures.

1761
02:44:07.926 --> 02:44:10.861
<v Keith Wilson>Things that, depending on your reading, may contradict some.

1762
02:44:11.052 --> 02:44:15.236
<v Keith Wilson>I would also note that committees give recommendations to inform full council.

1763
02:44:15.317 --> 02:44:21.377
<v Keith Wilson>They don't create any law or provide any direction on their own.

1764
02:44:21.602 --> 02:44:26.395
<v Keith Wilson>So something coming out of committee to full council would still be fully debated here.

1765
02:44:27.245 --> 02:44:29.745
<v Keith Wilson>I'm very comfortable with the language I brought forward.

1766
02:44:29.889 --> 02:44:32.599
<v Keith Wilson>I also am not— Councilor Loretta Smith.

1767
02:44:34.132 --> 02:44:39.407
<v Keith Wilson>I don't feel held back from my ability to do the work that I need to if we vote for the amendment.

1768
02:44:39.992 --> 02:45:00.507
<v Keith Wilson>I would note that our Vice President who chairs Governance is not here today, unfortunately, and she has done incredible work leading a discussion about our operations, both within code and within resolution that guide us under our rules and procedures that are outside of code.

1769
02:45:00.605 --> 02:45:00.835
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1770
02:45:02.420 --> 02:45:11.355
<v Keith Wilson>Frankly, I wanted to give her the respect of making sure this could be part of those broader conversations, which is why my intent has been to send it to the Governance Committee.

1771
02:45:14.559 --> 02:45:18.652
<v Keith Wilson>Seeing no one else in the queue, Councilor Zimmerman, is that a new hand or is that a previous hand?

1772
02:45:19.509 --> 02:45:26.729
<v Keith Wilson>Keelan, could you please call the roll on the amendment brought forward by Councilor Kanal and seconded, I believe, by Councilor Murillo?

1773
02:45:27.217 --> 02:45:31.377
<v Keith Wilson>To remove the words in the Governance Committee from the second, be it further resolved.

1774
02:45:32.996 --> 02:45:33.093
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1775
02:45:33.484 --> 02:45:33.646
<v Olivia Clark>No.

1776
02:45:34.620 --> 02:45:34.765
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1777
02:45:35.188 --> 02:45:35.236
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1778
02:45:36.112 --> 02:45:36.469
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1779
02:45:36.665 --> 02:45:36.891
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

1780
02:45:38.028 --> 02:45:38.336
<v Keith Wilson>Avalos—.

1781
02:45:38.369 --> 02:45:38.790
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, sorry.

1782
02:45:39.018 --> 02:45:39.391
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1783
02:45:40.057 --> 02:45:40.105
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1784
02:45:41.452 --> 02:45:41.662
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1785
02:45:42.082 --> 02:45:42.244
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1786
02:45:43.389 --> 02:45:43.600
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1787
02:45:44.745 --> 02:45:44.906
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1788
02:45:45.810 --> 02:45:46.102
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1789
02:45:46.376 --> 02:45:46.522
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1790
02:45:47.602 --> 02:45:48.620
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

1791
02:45:49.265 --> 02:45:49.315
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1792
02:45:50.299 --> 02:45:50.511
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1793
02:45:51.128 --> 02:45:51.176
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1794
02:45:52.362 --> 02:45:52.736
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1795
02:45:55.213 --> 02:45:55.681
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

1796
02:45:55.745 --> 02:45:59.254
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment fails with 5 yes votes and 5 no votes.

1797
02:46:00.188 --> 02:46:03.279
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, colleagues, is there any other discussion to the underlying resolution?

1798
02:46:05.873 --> 02:46:08.407
<v Keith Wilson>Seeing none, Keelan, can you please call the roll?

1799
02:46:09.472 --> 02:46:09.811
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1800
02:46:10.199 --> 02:46:10.247
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1801
02:46:11.102 --> 02:46:11.313
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1802
02:46:11.652 --> 02:46:11.813
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1803
02:46:12.700 --> 02:46:13.007
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1804
02:46:13.346 --> 02:46:13.362
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1805
02:46:14.379 --> 02:46:14.542
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1806
02:46:15.131 --> 02:46:15.295
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1807
02:46:15.950 --> 02:46:16.424
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1808
02:46:16.931 --> 02:46:16.979
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1809
02:46:17.748 --> 02:46:17.896
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

1810
02:46:20.728 --> 02:46:20.953
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1811
02:46:22.334 --> 02:46:22.622
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1812
02:46:23.281 --> 02:46:23.328
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1813
02:46:24.742 --> 02:46:25.207
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

1814
02:46:26.010 --> 02:46:27.680
<v Olivia Clark>I can't approve this without the amendment.

1815
02:46:27.808 --> 02:46:28.096
<v Angelita Morillo>No.

1816
02:46:28.771 --> 02:46:29.139
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1817
02:46:29.781 --> 02:46:29.829
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1818
02:46:30.762 --> 02:46:31.210
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1819
02:46:31.709 --> 02:46:31.756
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1820
02:46:32.832 --> 02:46:36.828
<v Keelan McClymont>The resolution is adopted with 8 yes votes and 2 no votes.

1821
02:46:37.905 --> 02:46:39.236
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, colleagues.

1822
02:46:39.494 --> 02:46:42.431
<v Keith Wilson>That brings us to the end of our agenda.

1823
02:46:43.024 --> 02:46:46.027
<v Keith Wilson>Uh, Councilor Kanal, is your hand up for a purpose of this meeting?

1824
02:46:47.104 --> 02:46:56.202
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, I just wanted to ask for unanimous consent to allow my vote on the consent agenda to be counted even though it came in after the vote was called.

1825
02:46:57.347 --> 02:47:02.972
<v Keith Wilson>Colleagues, is there unanimous consent to grant that courtesy to Councilor Kanal?

1826
02:47:04.754 --> 02:47:04.899
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

1827
02:47:05.141 --> 02:47:07.610
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, is there a motion for a vote?

1828
02:47:09.643 --> 02:47:13.014
<v Keith Wilson>Okay, Councilor Kanal is shaking his head no, he doesn't want to make that motion.

1829
02:47:14.587 --> 02:47:14.989
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1830
02:47:15.069 --> 02:47:15.310
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

1831
02:47:20.117 --> 02:47:22.480
<v Keith Wilson>Any other business before we close the meeting?

1832
02:47:23.608 --> 02:47:23.995
<v Keith Wilson>Okay.

1833
02:47:24.783 --> 02:47:38.347
<v Keith Wilson>A reminder that we are meeting in a recess meeting tomorrow afternoon to take back up the item that was brought forward by Councilor Smith on disparity studies.

1834
02:47:38.820 --> 02:47:40.451
<v Keith Wilson>With that, I will close today's meeting.

1835
02:47:40.566 --> 02:47:41.308
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you so much.

1836
02:47:41.390 --> 02:47:42.016
<v Keith Wilson>We are adjourned.

1837
02:47:44.684 --> 02:47:46.845
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

