WEBVTT

1
00:06:41.360 --> 00:06:42.136
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning, all.

2
00:06:42.249 --> 00:06:50.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a pre-gavel presentation today, so before we officially begin our meeting, I am going to turn the floor over to Councilor Dunphy.

3
00:06:51.218 --> 00:06:51.685
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

4
00:06:52.185 --> 00:07:00.668
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month, and for those who don't know, prior to my time working here in City Council.

5
00:07:01.086 --> 00:07:11.141
<v Jamie Dunphy>I spent the last 5 years working for the American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network, working to make sure that we can use public policy to reduce the burden of cancer for families everywhere across the state.

6
00:07:13.019 --> 00:07:21.812
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm honored to be joined today by a lot of really great advocates who are in the fight against cancer.

7
00:07:22.449 --> 00:07:30.160
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to, if I could briefly invite up our very brief panel, and I will note to our panel, we each have 1 minute to talk.

8
00:07:30.208 --> 00:07:32.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, um, come on up when I call you.

9
00:07:32.678 --> 00:07:38.834
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Nikhil Surya, Dr. Alexandra Zimmer, Missy Spelunky—.

10
00:07:39.238 --> 00:07:39.886
<v Jamie Dunphy>Kalunky—.

11
00:07:39.966 --> 00:07:40.774
<v Jamie Dunphy>I can't remember your last name.

12
00:07:40.855 --> 00:07:41.307
<v Jamie Dunphy>Kalunky.

13
00:07:42.536 --> 00:07:45.810
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Susan Stearns, CEO of the Pink Lemonade Project.

14
00:07:47.487 --> 00:07:50.437
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, thank you.

15
00:07:51.572 --> 00:07:52.576
<v Jamie Dunphy>Nick, why don't you take us away?

16
00:07:54.273 --> 00:07:55.603
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, everyone.

17
00:07:56.115 --> 00:07:57.413
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for inviting me back this year.

18
00:07:58.103 --> 00:08:01.211
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Nikhil Surya, and I'm a sophomore at St. Stephen's Academy.

19
00:08:01.947 --> 00:08:05.858
<v Jamie Dunphy>Last year, I shared my mom's story, a story of hope, awareness, and early detection.

20
00:08:06.451 --> 00:08:17.011
<v Jamie Dunphy>This year, I'm grateful to stand here again, not just as her son, but as a partner in spreading awareness with the City of Portland, American Cancer Society, OHSU Knight Cancer Institute, and the Pink Lemonade Project.

21
00:08:17.588 --> 00:08:22.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>Together, they help families access information, screenings, and the kind of support that saved my mom's life.

22
00:08:23.838 --> 00:08:28.694
<v Jamie Dunphy>My mom's journey began with a mammogram that showed she was clear, but it also noted she had dense breast tissue.

23
00:08:28.807 --> 00:08:34.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dense tissue can make it harder for a doctor to spot cancer in a mammogram, so her doctor recommended an MRI.

24
00:08:35.698 --> 00:08:37.942
<v Jamie Dunphy>That MRI revealed the cancer the mammogram had missed.

25
00:08:38.102 --> 00:08:40.764
<v Jamie Dunphy>Catching it early made all the difference in her treatment and recovery.

26
00:08:41.708 --> 00:08:43.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>Without that MRI, my mom might not be here today.

27
00:08:44.818 --> 00:08:48.585
<v Jamie Dunphy>Since sharing her story last year, I've learned how much awareness and policy go hand in hand.

28
00:08:48.730 --> 00:08:55.154
<v Jamie Dunphy>Starting September 2025, a new FDA rule requires all mammogram facilities to tell patients if they have dense tissue.

29
00:08:55.956 --> 00:09:01.227
<v Jamie Dunphy>That simple change will help millions of families make informed choices and catch cancer early.

30
00:09:01.900 --> 00:09:08.197
<v Jamie Dunphy>But awareness only matters if people understand what to do with it, and that's why proclamations like today's matter so much.

31
00:09:08.966 --> 00:09:12.956
<v Jamie Dunphy>So today I ask everyone, schedule your screenings, ask questions, and spread the word.

32
00:09:13.357 --> 00:09:18.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>Together we can turn awareness into action and hope Thank you, Nick.

33
00:09:19.779 --> 00:09:20.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dr. Zimmer.

34
00:09:20.812 --> 00:09:22.504
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hi, I'm Alexandra Zimmer.

35
00:09:22.585 --> 00:09:42.115
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm a breast cancer program director at the Knight Cancer Institute, and, uh, I, I'd like to focus on the— you know, we know that breast cancer is a very common disease, uh, and, uh, you know, kills a lot of people from time to time and modifies the lives of several families.

36
00:09:42.746 --> 00:09:56.216
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think the focus on early detection is the most important at this moment because, you know, with early detection you can actually improve the 5-year survival to up to 99%.

37
00:09:56.393 --> 00:09:57.821
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that's impressive.

38
00:09:58.559 --> 00:10:05.383
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the best way to understand, to do that, is look for your healthcare provider.

39
00:10:05.799 --> 00:10:09.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>People at 25 years old should have an evaluation to understand yes.

40
00:10:10.438 --> 00:10:18.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the majority of people will not be high risk and will then have the recommendation to start with mammograms.

41
00:10:18.866 --> 00:10:28.754
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then of course there's the recommendations for further tests, but at least with mammograms at 40 years old, and that should be continued for every, every year or every other year.

42
00:10:28.995 --> 00:10:30.006
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that's an important thing.

43
00:10:30.504 --> 00:10:38.964
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just want to express that people should look for help even if they don't— if they lack insurance or anything like that.

44
00:10:39.589 --> 00:10:55.124
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have, by the way, just focused on trying to get access to people, and our breast imaging center at our South Waterfront is working now evenings and weekends to have people tested, having access to mammogram.

45
00:10:55.716 --> 00:11:03.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have other areas with that and also have the van program where it's a mobile mammogram that can reach to people.

46
00:11:05.365 --> 00:11:11.682
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And also the Breast Health for All program where people uninsured or underinsured can have access to that as well.

47
00:11:13.669 --> 00:11:15.839
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The treatment has improved a lot through the years.

48
00:11:15.934 --> 00:11:19.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have new things going on and access to our center.

49
00:11:19.085 --> 00:11:28.547
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to, you know, make sure that people are aware that we have access to world-class treatments here in Portland as well.

50
00:11:28.595 --> 00:11:28.724
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

51
00:11:30.448 --> 00:11:35.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we will continue to work for that and hope for everyone to reach out.

52
00:11:37.798 --> 00:11:38.635
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Dr. Zimmer.

53
00:11:38.846 --> 00:11:39.071
<v Jamie Dunphy>Missy.

54
00:11:39.827 --> 00:11:40.278
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning.

55
00:11:40.616 --> 00:11:43.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for inviting us here today and recognizing Breast Cancer Month.

56
00:11:44.255 --> 00:11:50.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My name is Missy Kalunke, and I will be fighting breast cancer that has metastasized to my bones for the rest of my life.

57
00:11:50.924 --> 00:11:55.147
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I've been a volunteer with the American Cancer Society, ACS, for 10 years.

58
00:11:55.446 --> 00:11:58.442
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>10 With Relay for Life, and 9 with the Cancer Action Network.

59
00:11:58.923 --> 00:12:02.499
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was drawn to ACS because they fight for every cancer and every life.

60
00:12:03.220 --> 00:12:07.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>ACS's mission is to save lives through early detection, research, and patient support.

61
00:12:08.285 --> 00:12:16.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We encourage people to use the ACS 1-800 phone number if they don't have insurance or their insurance doesn't cover other cancer screenings.

62
00:12:16.605 --> 00:12:23.466
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They're able to direct them to local resources who will assist them as well as provide educational information and patient support.

63
00:12:24.139 --> 00:12:27.057
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With regards to collective action toward eliminating barriers, Councilor Smith.

64
00:12:27.169 --> 00:12:27.714
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Barriers to care.

65
00:12:28.163 --> 00:12:41.674
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're working at the federal level to make sure Affordable Care Act tax credits are extended and also fully funding the Center for Disease Control breast and cervical cancer screening programs because we know that early detection will save lives.

66
00:12:42.123 --> 00:12:45.120
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So thank you again for your acknowledgement of Breast Cancer Month.

67
00:12:46.274 --> 00:12:46.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks, Missy.

68
00:12:47.299 --> 00:12:47.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Susan.

69
00:12:48.501 --> 00:12:48.629
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hi.

70
00:12:48.839 --> 00:12:49.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello, councilors.

71
00:12:50.041 --> 00:12:51.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for having us.

72
00:12:51.403 --> 00:12:56.600
<v Loretta Smith>Jamie, thank you for the invitation, and Priya and Nick, really, for their leadership to pull together this Thank you.

73
00:12:56.600 --> 00:12:56.600
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President Elana Pirtle-Guiney.

74
00:12:56.600 --> 00:12:57.899
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you to our impressive panel today.

75
00:12:57.899 --> 00:13:00.919
<v Loretta Smith>I'm Susan Stern, CEO of Pink Lemonade Project.

76
00:13:01.379 --> 00:13:08.740
<v Loretta Smith>Pink Lemonade Project is a Vancouver, Washington-based community nonprofit that serves all of Oregon and Southwest Washington.

77
00:13:08.879 --> 00:13:23.500
<v Loretta Smith>We offer the full cancer continuum of support from education and awareness through after a diagnosis support, education, financial and emotional support for those diagnosed with breast cancer.

78
00:13:23.500 --> 00:13:37.690
<v Loretta Smith>We know that COVID has been hard on our disease Breast cancer is the top diagnosed cancer, and 1 in 7 women are at risk of breast cancer in the Pacific Northwest when the national averages are 1 in 8.

79
00:13:38.171 --> 00:13:46.663
<v Loretta Smith>We also know with new data that screening has dropped more than 10 percentage points in both Oregon and Washington since the pandemic.

80
00:13:46.999 --> 00:14:09.496
<v Loretta Smith>So Breast Cancer Awareness Month is critical, and we appreciate opportunities like this to talk to the broader public about how important breast health is so that we can in fact catch cancers earlier, catch breast cancer earlier, and hopefully improve the quality of life, reduce the harsh treatments, and extend lives of so many affected by this disease.

81
00:14:09.946 --> 00:14:11.357
<v Jamie Dunphy>So appreciate your leadership.

82
00:14:11.453 --> 00:14:17.164
<v Loretta Smith>We love a proclamation opportunity and always partner— appreciate the partnership with the City of Portland.

83
00:14:17.453 --> 00:14:21.432
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for a few minutes to talk about this important community health issue.

84
00:14:21.480 --> 00:14:21.640
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

85
00:14:22.346 --> 00:14:24.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much for joining us this morning.

86
00:14:24.272 --> 00:14:26.822
<v Jamie Dunphy>And on behalf of the mayor, I have a proclamation that I'm going to read.

87
00:14:27.961 --> 00:14:38.371
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, whereas October is globally recognized as Breast Cancer Awareness Month, a time to raise awareness, promote early detection, honor survivors, and remember those lost to the disease.

88
00:14:38.708 --> 00:14:48.654
<v Jamie Dunphy>And whereas breast cancer remains among the most common cancers in the United States, affecting, as Susan was saying, 1 in 8 women in their lifetime nationally, but 1 in 7 here in the Northwest.

89
00:14:49.312 --> 00:14:59.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>In 2025, an estimated 316,950 women and 2,800 men will be diagnosed, and more than 42,000 women will lose their lives.

90
00:15:00.528 --> 00:15:27.774
<v Jamie Dunphy>And whereas men and people assigned male at birth can also develop breast cancer, though they are often diagnosed later due to low awareness and delayed reporting of symptoms, whereas health disparities by income, race, age, and gender continue to create unequal outcomes, and Whereas when detected early, breast cancer has a 99% 5-year survival rate, highlighting the life-saving importance of regular screening and timely follow-up care.

91
00:15:28.144 --> 00:15:43.325
<v Jamie Dunphy>And whereas federal requirements ensure patients are informed of their breast density after a mammogram, that's like the same, and advised on the supplemental screening such as MRI or ultrasound when appropriate, a critical step for detecting cancers that may be obscured in dense breast tissue.

92
00:15:43.614 --> 00:16:00.623
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Whereas the American Cancer Society is dedicated to improving the lives of people with cancer and their families through advocacy, groundbreaking research, and comprehensive patient support, striving to ensure that everyone has the opportunity to protect, prevent, detect, treat, and survive cancer.

93
00:16:00.863 --> 00:16:10.544
<v Jamie Dunphy>And whereas the Pink Lemonade Project provides education, mentorship, and financial and emotional assistance to families navigating breast cancer across Oregon and Southwest Washington.

94
00:16:11.267 --> 00:16:25.111
<v Jamie Dunphy>And whereas the OHSU Knight Cancer Institute works to free the world of the burden of cancer, one patient at a time, treating thousands each year and advancing hundreds of research and community partner projects across Oregon.

95
00:16:25.849 --> 00:16:43.462
<v Jamie Dunphy>And a youth advocate inspired by his mother's breast cancer journey has partnered with the City of Portland, OHSU Knight Cancer Institute, American Cancer Society, and the Pink Lemonade Project to expand awareness in the community, demonstrating that compassion and advocacy have no age limit.

96
00:16:43.719 --> 00:16:45.498
<v Jamie Dunphy>And, oh, me.

97
00:16:45.739 --> 00:17:05.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>Whereas Councilor Jamie Dunphy has championed this youth-led initiative by sponsoring this proclamation and elevating it before the Portland City Council, helping unite community partners including the American Cancer Society, American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network, OHSU's Knight Cancer Institute, and the Pink Lemonade Project around a shared commitment to awareness Early detection, equitable access, and hope.

98
00:17:06.108 --> 00:17:25.406
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now therefore, I, Keith Wilson, Mayor of the City of Portland, Oregon, City of Roses, do hereby proclaim October 25th to be Breast Cancer Awareness Month in Portland and encourage all residents to observe this month by participating in activities that promote awareness, support research, honor survivors, and prioritize regular screenings to save lives.

99
00:17:26.417 --> 00:17:27.576
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

100
00:17:27.951 --> 00:17:32.095
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

101
00:17:32.782 --> 00:17:35.064
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much for being here this morning.

102
00:17:38.480 --> 00:17:39.771
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Did you have a question?

103
00:17:40.272 --> 00:17:41.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hi, thanks for being here.

104
00:17:41.726 --> 00:17:43.244
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could I just want to ask you a question?

105
00:17:43.342 --> 00:17:49.926
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could you give us more information on why you think the screenings have dropped 10% since the, since the pandemic?

106
00:17:50.008 --> 00:17:52.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, um, uh, completely related to COVID.

107
00:17:52.488 --> 00:18:05.551
<v Loretta Smith>So, um, uh, there's data out of the National Cancer Institute and EPIC, which is our sort of underlying health information system that shows that screening dropped over 90% in spring of 2020.

108
00:18:05.681 --> 00:18:07.732
<v Loretta Smith>So people are afraid to go into the healthcare system.

109
00:18:08.582 --> 00:18:09.432
<v Jamie Dunphy>Life has been busy.

110
00:18:09.528 --> 00:18:10.490
<v Loretta Smith>It's the pandemic.

111
00:18:10.569 --> 00:18:15.827
<v Loretta Smith>People are trying to support their kids learning from home, all of that madness.

112
00:18:16.116 --> 00:18:23.426
<v Loretta Smith>And so trying to get people back into the routine screening mammograms has just been a bit of an uphill lift.

113
00:18:23.490 --> 00:18:23.714
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

114
00:18:24.601 --> 00:18:42.971
<v Loretta Smith>I would say the other critical change, just since we're talking about it, and thank you for the question, the leading guideline organization for the standard of care of cancer treatment across the United States is the United States Preventive Services Task Force.

115
00:18:43.566 --> 00:18:52.211
<v Loretta Smith>A year and a half ago, the task force reduced the recommended age of screening mammograms from age 50 down to age 40.

116
00:18:52.292 --> 00:18:52.849
<v Loretta Smith>So there is a—.

117
00:18:52.849 --> 00:18:52.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>40.

118
00:18:53.185 --> 00:19:00.721
<v Loretta Smith>10-Year window that we want to get the word out that women should be going in for screening mammograms.

119
00:19:00.978 --> 00:19:10.682
<v Loretta Smith>And we also know that the trends right now is there's an increase in people under age 40 getting diagnosed with breast cancer.

120
00:19:10.730 --> 00:19:19.501
<v Loretta Smith>So the breast health awareness is even more critical, and people of all ages should be noticing changes in their breast health.

121
00:19:19.550 --> 00:19:19.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

122
00:19:20.354 --> 00:19:27.193
<v Loretta Smith>Regardless of gender, age, or, I mean, they should, yeah, regardless of gender and age.

123
00:19:27.578 --> 00:19:27.836
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

124
00:19:28.204 --> 00:19:28.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

125
00:19:29.087 --> 00:19:33.873
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's so, I always look forward to you coming and I had to ask you a question to enlighten me more.

126
00:19:34.323 --> 00:19:38.705
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I also wanna just acknowledge Nick and the proud mother in the audience.

127
00:19:38.770 --> 00:19:38.898
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

128
00:19:38.979 --> 00:19:39.076
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

129
00:19:39.155 --> 00:19:40.568
<v Loretta Smith>Nick's a brave son.

130
00:19:40.729 --> 00:19:41.628
<v Loretta Smith>He's doing a great job.

131
00:19:41.917 --> 00:19:41.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

132
00:19:42.094 --> 00:19:42.207
<v Loretta Smith>All right.

133
00:19:42.270 --> 00:19:43.330
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for the time this morning.

134
00:19:43.459 --> 00:19:43.972
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

135
00:19:46.911 --> 00:19:58.535
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy, for bringing this pre-gavel to us and helping to raise awareness today, and for helping to raise awareness about the mayor's proclamation by bringing it to the council meeting.

136
00:19:59.770 --> 00:20:04.073
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, colleagues, I will convene today's Portland City Council meeting.

137
00:20:04.170 --> 00:20:07.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 9:45 AM on Wednesday, October 22nd.

138
00:20:08.182 --> 00:20:09.516
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

139
00:20:10.751 --> 00:20:11.651
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning, Clerk.

140
00:20:15.165 --> 00:20:16.249
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

141
00:20:16.476 --> 00:20:17.994
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Present.

142
00:20:18.480 --> 00:20:18.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

143
00:20:19.611 --> 00:20:19.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

144
00:20:19.951 --> 00:20:20.711
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

145
00:20:21.228 --> 00:20:22.213
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

146
00:20:23.960 --> 00:20:24.653
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

147
00:20:24.781 --> 00:20:24.863
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

148
00:20:24.928 --> 00:20:25.330
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

149
00:20:26.798 --> 00:20:27.040
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

150
00:20:27.088 --> 00:20:27.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Present.

151
00:20:27.782 --> 00:20:27.847
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

152
00:20:28.009 --> 00:20:28.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Present.

153
00:20:28.509 --> 00:20:28.670
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

154
00:20:28.734 --> 00:20:29.122
<v Loretta Smith>Present.

155
00:20:29.186 --> 00:20:29.461
<v Loretta Smith>Present.

156
00:20:29.541 --> 00:20:29.896
<v Loretta Smith>Present.

157
00:20:29.961 --> 00:20:30.784
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Present.

158
00:20:31.978 --> 00:20:32.638
<v Jamie Dunphy>Present.

159
00:20:32.720 --> 00:20:33.058
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Present.

160
00:20:33.348 --> 00:20:34.686
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

161
00:20:34.880 --> 00:20:40.648
<v Jamie Dunphy>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

162
00:20:44.416 --> 00:20:47.545
<v Jamie Dunphy>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

163
00:20:48.202 --> 00:20:52.342
<v Jamie Dunphy>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

164
00:20:52.934 --> 00:20:54.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

165
00:20:55.582 --> 00:20:57.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>Presiding officer preserves order.

166
00:20:57.426 --> 00:21:05.174
<v Jamie Dunphy>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

167
00:21:05.768 --> 00:21:08.061
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

168
00:21:08.655 --> 00:21:10.676
<v Jamie Dunphy>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

169
00:21:10.724 --> 00:21:14.394
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilmember Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

170
00:21:14.959 --> 00:21:17.957
<v Jamie Dunphy>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

171
00:21:18.829 --> 00:21:20.925
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

172
00:21:21.265 --> 00:21:23.556
<v Jamie Dunphy>When testifying, state your name for the record.

173
00:21:23.604 --> 00:21:24.910
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your address is not necessary.

174
00:21:25.486 --> 00:21:27.939
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

175
00:21:28.567 --> 00:21:31.875
<v Jamie Dunphy>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

176
00:21:32.344 --> 00:21:32.603
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

177
00:21:35.525 --> 00:21:36.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

178
00:21:37.067 --> 00:21:47.816
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, before we begin, I will note that our agenda should run us right up until 1:00 o'clock today, giving us a half-hour break before our work session that begins at 1:30.

179
00:21:48.553 --> 00:21:56.547
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that our staff and many of us need that break to get some food, stretch our legs so that we can fully concentrate on the work session this afternoon.

180
00:21:57.619 --> 00:22:00.214
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we can get through everything in time.

181
00:22:00.488 --> 00:22:09.730
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is scheduled to be able to, but if we have things run long, I will cut us off at whatever item we are debating at 1 o'clock.

182
00:22:09.795 --> 00:22:14.136
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll finish that amendment or section of the debate or agenda item that we're on.

183
00:22:14.232 --> 00:22:14.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

184
00:22:14.989 --> 00:22:24.598
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we'll need to carry over the rest of the agenda to a future meeting so that we can make sure to give everybody that space and still convene close to on time our afternoon work session.

185
00:22:26.667 --> 00:22:30.608
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first item on our agenda is agenda approval.

186
00:22:31.190 --> 00:22:33.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any motions to reorder the agenda?

187
00:22:36.170 --> 00:22:36.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

188
00:22:37.998 --> 00:22:40.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing none, do I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

189
00:22:41.217 --> 00:22:41.281
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

190
00:22:43.781 --> 00:22:45.144
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Keelan, there are no objections.

191
00:22:46.660 --> 00:22:49.178
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The second item on the agenda is public communication.

192
00:22:49.276 --> 00:22:51.063
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, can you please call up our first guest?

193
00:22:54.537 --> 00:22:58.647
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>First up, we have Grady Preston II joining us online.

194
00:23:08.730 --> 00:23:09.333
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello, councilors.

195
00:23:09.397 --> 00:23:09.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you hear me?

196
00:23:10.944 --> 00:23:11.759
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can hear you, Grady.

197
00:23:13.989 --> 00:23:14.327
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello.

198
00:23:14.972 --> 00:23:15.393
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great, thank you.

199
00:23:15.845 --> 00:23:16.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, councilors.

200
00:23:16.973 --> 00:23:18.653
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Grady Preston II.

201
00:23:18.911 --> 00:23:22.282
<v Jamie Dunphy>I live in District 3 in the Creston neighborhood.

202
00:23:22.719 --> 00:23:29.089
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm here today not as a resident only, but as a person who believes in the promise of this new government.

203
00:23:29.477 --> 00:23:31.122
<v Jamie Dunphy>You were all elected to be bold.

204
00:23:31.977 --> 00:23:36.102
<v Jamie Dunphy>You were chosen to break the white supremacist patriarchal hold on this city.

205
00:23:37.162 --> 00:23:38.432
<v Jamie Dunphy>Don't second-guess yourselves.

206
00:23:38.865 --> 00:23:46.393
<v Jamie Dunphy>This council was built to do things differently, and the people of Portland are counting on you to lead with courage, not caution.

207
00:23:50.571 --> 00:23:53.837
<v Jamie Dunphy>The people sleeping in tents under bridges don't have time for delay.

208
00:23:54.679 --> 00:24:01.646
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your years of hesitation weakens the impact of this council and undermines the very change it was designed to deliver.

209
00:24:03.001 --> 00:24:11.571
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Eric Zimmerman, these meetings are not your personal podcasts, and you shouldn't stop wasting valuable city time with your political theater.

210
00:24:13.577 --> 00:24:18.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>To my councilor Angelita Morillo, thank you from the bottom of my heart.

211
00:24:19.400 --> 00:24:23.951
<v Jamie Dunphy>You bring the passion and energy of my generation into these chambers, and it matters.

212
00:24:25.144 --> 00:24:34.287
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your voice resonates with those of us We need you to keep pushing.

213
00:24:35.851 --> 00:24:36.753
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now let me speak plainly.

214
00:24:38.400 --> 00:24:49.803
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are under siege, not just by corporate greed causing poverty, displacement, and neglect, but by a rising tide of authoritarian violence that threatens the very soul of Portland.

215
00:24:50.289 --> 00:24:52.384
<v Jamie Dunphy>And every night I see what happens when it goes unchecked.

216
00:24:52.432 --> 00:24:53.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Mitch Green.

217
00:24:53.392 --> 00:25:00.252
<v Jamie Dunphy>I see lives shattered and permanent trauma etched into the bodies and minds of my neighbors.

218
00:25:00.925 --> 00:25:10.512
<v Jamie Dunphy>These vile, gleeful Proud Boys wearing ICE badges are pointing live weapons at disabled people, threatening lives and laughing about it.

219
00:25:11.250 --> 00:25:13.077
<v Jamie Dunphy>Tear gas seeps into our homes.

220
00:25:13.590 --> 00:25:18.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>The air we breathe is laced with the ash of superheated heavy metals and chemical irritants.

221
00:25:18.737 --> 00:25:36.481
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilmember Schools are closing, and community members are being forced from their community.

222
00:25:37.269 --> 00:25:47.381
<v Jamie Dunphy>One of the most horrifying acts I've witnessed was the assault on Quinn Harlow, a blind man who peacefully protests outside the Portland Ice facility.

223
00:25:47.769 --> 00:25:48.803
<v Jamie Dunphy>He's known in the community as the King of the Ice.

224
00:25:48.852 --> 00:25:48.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

225
00:25:49.333 --> 00:26:01.041
<v Jamie Dunphy>As a gentle, lawful, always carrying a stuffed animal, he sits quietly on the curb across the street holding his stuffy towards the agents.

226
00:26:01.298 --> 00:26:07.080
<v Jamie Dunphy>He doesn't shout, he doesn't provoke, he simply exists as a symbol of resistance and love.

227
00:26:07.162 --> 00:26:09.266
<v Jamie Dunphy>And yet federal agents target him without warning.

228
00:26:09.410 --> 00:26:12.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>They grabbed him, violently dropped him on his head.

229
00:26:12.767 --> 00:26:17.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>A blind man peacefully Lawfully disabled and assaulted for what?

230
00:26:17.867 --> 00:26:18.970
<v Jamie Dunphy>For daring to be visible?

231
00:26:19.391 --> 00:26:20.314
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is not enforcement.

232
00:26:20.363 --> 00:26:21.107
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is cruelty.

233
00:26:21.189 --> 00:26:22.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is fascism.

234
00:26:23.960 --> 00:26:28.557
<v Jamie Dunphy>Why isn't the city, county, and state leadership charging these agents with kidnapping?

235
00:26:29.234 --> 00:26:33.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>Why are they allowed to commit hateful violence and abuse law without discipline?

236
00:26:33.559 --> 00:26:37.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't hold the legal authority to stop it, but I gave that power to you.

237
00:26:37.770 --> 00:26:38.431
<v Jamie Dunphy>Be the change.

238
00:26:38.494 --> 00:26:43.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>Be the inventors of a future where progressive retribution meets fascist Thank you.

239
00:26:43.512 --> 00:26:46.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm so sorry that we need to make sure to have time for everyone.

240
00:26:47.615 --> 00:26:51.508
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate your words and being here to speak to our work.

241
00:26:53.976 --> 00:26:55.765
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next up we have Vadim Mazursky.

242
00:26:55.990 --> 00:26:57.393
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They canceled their request.

243
00:26:58.102 --> 00:27:00.730
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mark Porras is next, who also canceled.

244
00:27:00.988 --> 00:27:03.147
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next we have Nathaniel Hudson Hartman.

245
00:27:12.289 --> 00:27:16.088
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning.

246
00:27:16.185 --> 00:27:16.574
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

247
00:27:17.576 --> 00:27:17.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Morning.

248
00:27:18.627 --> 00:27:26.455
<v Jamie Dunphy>You all look lovely today, and my mother's a 2-time breast cancer survivor, so I really appreciate the acknowledgment, the proclamation.

249
00:27:27.445 --> 00:27:28.403
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, save the tatas.

250
00:27:29.916 --> 00:27:33.106
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, but for the record, my, my name is Nathaniel Hudson Hartman.

251
00:27:33.655 --> 00:27:40.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've been a rideshare driver in the city of Portland, the state of Oregon, for almost 9 years now.

252
00:27:40.926 --> 00:27:45.320
<v Jamie Dunphy>But more importantly, I represent our essential transportation providers.

253
00:27:46.461 --> 00:27:51.107
<v Jamie Dunphy>You'll see none of them here today because they are out working our streets, getting people around safely.

254
00:27:53.067 --> 00:27:54.838
<v Jamie Dunphy>Some of them are living out of their cars right now.

255
00:27:56.866 --> 00:28:07.663
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm here today just to remind you all how actually amazing 2025 has been for Uber and Lyft.

256
00:28:09.117 --> 00:28:10.065
<v Jamie Dunphy>You look at their financials.

257
00:28:11.890 --> 00:28:15.092
<v Jamie Dunphy>They are paving the road to profitability on our backs.

258
00:28:15.238 --> 00:28:16.115
<v Jamie Dunphy>They are the scorpion.

259
00:28:16.310 --> 00:28:16.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are the frog.

260
00:28:17.481 --> 00:28:20.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I know the frog has taken on new meaning in our city, so I want to let that sink in.

261
00:28:22.074 --> 00:28:23.221
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I don't do it to be cute.

262
00:28:23.303 --> 00:28:24.984
<v Jamie Dunphy>I do it to illustrate our desperation.

263
00:28:26.397 --> 00:28:30.134
<v Jamie Dunphy>And how we are under the thumb, no, the stinger of these companies.

264
00:28:34.477 --> 00:28:35.762
<v Jamie Dunphy>And all you have to do is look at their financials.

265
00:28:37.240 --> 00:28:41.883
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uber has just announced recently another $20 billion stock buyback.

266
00:28:44.560 --> 00:28:50.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yet our driver community, we have several members that are sleeping out of their cars or one bad day away from homelessness.

267
00:28:52.807 --> 00:29:11.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to draw your attention to a screenshot here of a recent trip where a passenger was charged $116 and the driver was paid only $18 out of that for 2 hours of work because we do not have compensation standards to ensure that we're making a fair and livable wage.

268
00:29:12.817 --> 00:29:22.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm representing a driver right now, family of 4, an immigrant driver who was deactivated not on one but both Uber and Lyft.

269
00:29:23.057 --> 00:29:29.516
<v Jamie Dunphy>Once for legally changing his name, accused of intentionally falsifying documents.

270
00:29:30.673 --> 00:29:34.192
<v Jamie Dunphy>The other one falsely accused by a drunk passenger of intoxication.

271
00:29:35.348 --> 00:29:36.328
<v Jamie Dunphy>This driver's name is Ali.

272
00:29:36.699 --> 00:29:37.582
<v Jamie Dunphy>He is a Muslim driver.

273
00:29:37.663 --> 00:29:47.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>He has not touched a drop of alcohol a day in his life, but him and his family are underwater Underwater, amassing thousands of dollars of debt.

274
00:29:47.545 --> 00:29:47.656
<v Jamie Dunphy>Why?

275
00:29:48.364 --> 00:29:59.145
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because drivers do not have a fair and transparent appeals process by law, like they do in Washington, like they do in Colorado, like they do in Minnesota, like they do in New York.

276
00:29:59.211 --> 00:30:02.713
<v Jamie Dunphy>You see where I'm going with this, and we have no support center.

277
00:30:03.951 --> 00:30:08.674
<v Jamie Dunphy>It wasn't that long ago that this council over the summer passed a $2 fee increase without.

278
00:30:09.251 --> 00:30:10.343
<v Jamie Dunphy>A way to support drivers.

279
00:30:10.471 --> 00:30:13.836
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are still desperately— that urgency has only gone up.

280
00:30:14.479 --> 00:30:25.652
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we can't have a pay standard, we can't have deactivation appeals rights, we can't have fair transparency for our passengers without a driver resource center to tie it all together, to give drivers the support that we need.

281
00:30:26.229 --> 00:30:29.963
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so I again urge every single one of you, the time is now.

282
00:30:30.252 --> 00:30:31.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>The time was 2 years ago.

283
00:30:32.161 --> 00:30:33.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please, let's go to work.

284
00:30:33.923 --> 00:30:34.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

285
00:30:36.063 --> 00:30:37.907
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for being here.

286
00:30:41.130 --> 00:30:43.169
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next up, we have Gene Jackson.

287
00:30:57.346 --> 00:31:01.189
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning all, and thanks for this time.

288
00:31:02.573 --> 00:31:07.413
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would like to know whether the mayor— Mayor Wilson has the authority to cancel—.

289
00:31:07.896 --> 00:31:08.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, thank you—.

290
00:31:08.478 --> 00:31:19.723
<v Jamie Dunphy>To cancel DEI that was adopted in 2013 by the council without current council approval, as was done in 2013.

291
00:31:21.523 --> 00:31:28.505
<v Jamie Dunphy>Either the council needs their own lawyer, or you're complicit with the mayor's attempted to bring back Jim Crow.

292
00:31:29.467 --> 00:31:37.884
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have never known a mayor of the city of Portland that would for one second commit such a cowardly, cruel, and blatant act of racism.

293
00:31:38.509 --> 00:31:44.346
<v Jamie Dunphy>We already have a president that wants to erase the history of people of color, and now the mayor.

294
00:31:45.099 --> 00:31:49.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>It does not matter what we as Black people have suffered to defend this country.

295
00:31:51.017 --> 00:31:53.501
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your America will never be our America.

296
00:31:54.143 --> 00:31:56.853
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your Portland will never be our Portland.

297
00:31:57.750 --> 00:32:04.518
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is reminiscent of the Jim Carrey movie The Truman Show, where he discovered that everything in his life was a lie.

298
00:32:05.847 --> 00:32:13.367
<v Jamie Dunphy>And to quote Claude Brown's Manchild in the Promised Land, what do you run to when you're already in the promised land?

299
00:32:14.041 --> 00:32:16.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're constantly having the rug pulled from under our feet.

300
00:32:17.730 --> 00:32:23.116
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would like to know how much money has been spent on the Prime Contractor Development Program's technical systems.

301
00:32:23.230 --> 00:32:23.309
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

302
00:32:24.528 --> 00:32:38.424
<v Jamie Dunphy>And, uh, the administration cost of the prime contractor program in the past 3 years, with a breakdown of that cost as to who received what assistance and for how much, you will see that the program has never been a budget buster.

303
00:32:38.489 --> 00:32:50.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's only because of the illegal acts committed by the previous CPO and his staff that they want— the mayor wants to get rid of this program rather than dealing with it.

304
00:32:52.041 --> 00:33:03.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now the hiring of another CPO not only has little knowledge in this area of minority businesses, but absolutely no interest or commitment to the program.

305
00:33:04.023 --> 00:33:13.492
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the city is paying $135,000 to the Hispanic Chamber and the Minority Contractors Association to just shut up and dribble.

306
00:33:15.461 --> 00:33:20.364
<v Jamie Dunphy>One of the cruelest things is that the mayor's executive order was July 13th.

307
00:33:21.854 --> 00:33:38.929
<v Jamie Dunphy>During that time, prime— 2 prime contractors, PCDT contractors, were the lowest bidders on projects in July, in early July, and were not notified until September 30th that their bids were going to be rejected and rebid to the open market.

308
00:33:39.473 --> 00:33:49.846
<v Jamie Dunphy>With all of the numbers that have been exposed, they had those projects scheduled to perform the work and not bidding on other projects because they didn't want to overbook their ability to perform.

309
00:33:50.231 --> 00:33:55.578
<v Jamie Dunphy>And they're spending money holding on employees for work that is not going to happen.

310
00:33:56.653 --> 00:34:02.402
<v Jamie Dunphy>And now they have to compete with larger firms in the open market, and it's like minnows competing with sharks.

311
00:34:03.718 --> 00:34:15.405
<v Jamie Dunphy>The PCD program, which I wrote, has never been a race-based program, and to cancel it until a disparity study is done is totally unnecessary.

312
00:34:15.518 --> 00:34:16.385
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate you being here tonight.

313
00:34:17.259 --> 00:34:19.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for bringing this forward for us.

314
00:34:20.181 --> 00:34:21.634
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That completes communications.

315
00:34:25.009 --> 00:34:25.494
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

316
00:34:26.322 --> 00:34:30.005
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, the next item on our agenda is the committee referral report.

317
00:34:30.070 --> 00:34:32.925
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At some point, we're going to have a better way than me reading this out loud.

318
00:34:34.061 --> 00:34:40.023
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Adopt the fiscal year '25-'26 fall supplemental budget and make other budget-related changes was referred to Finance.

319
00:34:40.248 --> 00:34:43.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Authorize revenue bonds in an amount sufficient to Aye.

320
00:34:43.389 --> 00:34:43.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Opposed?

321
00:34:43.389 --> 00:34:43.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Abstain.

322
00:34:43.389 --> 00:34:43.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Motion passes.

323
00:34:43.389 --> 00:34:48.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Resolution number 2, provide no more than $41 million to finance city fleet maintenance facility improvements, went to Finance.

324
00:34:49.248 --> 00:34:56.898
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Authorize the city to acquire certain permanent and temporary rights for construction on Southwest Upper Drive, went to Finance.

325
00:34:57.148 --> 00:35:02.878
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Outline decision-making criteria for the designation of council meeting items on the consent agenda, went to Governance.

326
00:35:03.748 --> 00:35:09.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Appoint and reappoint members to the Development Review Advisory Committee, went to the Homelessness and Housing Committee.

327
00:35:11.619 --> 00:35:16.849
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And authorized streetcar settlement payment was referred to full council.

328
00:35:20.916 --> 00:35:26.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, that brings us— we don't have a consent agenda today, so that brings us to our regular agenda.

329
00:35:26.351 --> 00:35:29.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, can you please call the first item on our regular agenda?

330
00:35:30.556 --> 00:35:39.179
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 4, pay settlement of Adam Gregg lawsuit in the sum of $300,000 involving the Portland Police Bureau.

331
00:35:41.019 --> 00:35:43.012
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

332
00:35:43.445 --> 00:36:00.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, as a settlement, this comes straight to council as an emergency ordinance, so there is no committee staff summary or chair report, uh, but we do have Mike Porter and Rose Radich here to remind us of the basics before we hear public testimony.

333
00:36:03.246 --> 00:36:04.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon, Council.

334
00:36:04.862 --> 00:36:09.164
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, we are, we are asking Council to approve a settlement in the case of Gregg versus City of Portland.

335
00:36:09.858 --> 00:36:13.777
<v Jamie Dunphy>This case stems from a 2015 conviction for heroin distribution.

336
00:36:14.492 --> 00:36:18.213
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mr. Gregg pled guilty and served over 4 years in prison for that offense.

337
00:36:19.070 --> 00:36:24.327
<v Jamie Dunphy>While Mr. Gregg committed the crime, the key issue in this litigation is how miscommunication led to his guilty plea.

338
00:36:25.788 --> 00:36:33.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>At the time, the district attorney handling the case believed that someone had died after using the drugs Mr. Gregg had That information turned out to be wrong.

339
00:36:34.041 --> 00:36:37.815
<v Jamie Dunphy>City records show that the DA had been told the victim overdosed but survived.

340
00:36:38.346 --> 00:36:44.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, at least one police report incorrectly referred to the person's death, and another was later changed to say the victim had died.

341
00:36:45.831 --> 00:36:51.195
<v Jamie Dunphy>One of the responding officers, Matt Brown, actually performed CPR at the scene and likely saved that person's life.

342
00:36:51.998 --> 00:36:55.195
<v Jamie Dunphy>His original report accurately described the victim as alive when submitted.

343
00:36:55.949 --> 00:37:01.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>Unfortunately, it appears that during a clerical records process, Officer Brown's report was modified to indicate the victim had died.

344
00:37:02.594 --> 00:37:07.260
<v Jamie Dunphy>It then appears that the DA and defense attorney both proceeded under this mistaken belief that someone had died.

345
00:37:08.302 --> 00:37:11.237
<v Jamie Dunphy>That misunderstanding influenced Mr. Gregg's decision to plead guilty.

346
00:37:11.989 --> 00:37:18.740
<v Jamie Dunphy>Years later, after learning the person survived, he filed this claim, uh, his case, claiming that he was misled.

347
00:37:19.286 --> 00:37:25.972
<v Jamie Dunphy>The prosecutors have been dismissed from the lawsuit due to immunity, which means that if this case went to trial, the city would be the only remaining defendant.

348
00:37:26.021 --> 00:37:26.148
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

349
00:37:27.065 --> 00:37:32.494
<v Jamie Dunphy>That creates a real risk that a jury wanting to hold someone accountable could place full responsibility on the city.

350
00:37:33.489 --> 00:37:37.152
<v Jamie Dunphy>A verdict against the city could result in millions of dollars in damages and attorney's fees.

351
00:37:37.971 --> 00:37:47.592
<v Jamie Dunphy>The proposed settlement, $300,000, avoids that risk and reflects the calculations used in Oregon's wrongful conviction statutes for similar cases.

352
00:37:48.507 --> 00:37:51.688
<v Jamie Dunphy>Finally, we would like the council to know Mr. Gregg has turned his life around.

353
00:37:51.849 --> 00:37:57.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>He is now a student at Lewis Clark Law School and spends some of his free time volunteering in the community.

354
00:37:58.230 --> 00:38:05.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>The city believes the settlement closes a difficult chapter for everyone involved, recognizes the mistakes that occurred, and reflects Mr. Gregg's rehabilitation.

355
00:38:06.070 --> 00:38:09.099
<v Jamie Dunphy>For those reasons, we recommend the council approve the settlement.

356
00:38:11.250 --> 00:38:12.869
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

357
00:38:12.869 --> 00:38:14.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ms. Radich, do you have anything to add?

358
00:38:14.269 --> 00:38:15.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, thank you.

359
00:38:15.889 --> 00:38:22.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, councilors, any questions on the content before we hear from the public and then move into discussion?

360
00:38:25.360 --> 00:38:29.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, Keelan, do we have anybody signed up for public comment?

361
00:38:31.007 --> 00:38:34.717
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, we have 4 people signed up.

362
00:38:35.670 --> 00:38:43.197
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, we have— I'm gonna, uh, call them, uh, 3 up together who would like to approach the testimony table as a group.

363
00:38:43.342 --> 00:38:50.677
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mark Welcome.

364
00:38:50.791 --> 00:38:52.179
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for being here today.

365
00:38:54.360 --> 00:38:56.469
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You are welcome to begin as soon as you're ready.

366
00:38:56.807 --> 00:38:58.144
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, thank you.

367
00:38:58.402 --> 00:38:59.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, Council.

368
00:38:59.867 --> 00:39:00.722
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Mark Porras.

369
00:39:00.931 --> 00:39:03.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>I use he/him pronouns, and I'm with the group Portland Cop Watch.

370
00:39:04.039 --> 00:39:09.164
<v Jamie Dunphy>Since 1992, Portland Cop Watch has been working towards a police bureau that's free of brutality, corruption, and racism.

371
00:39:09.617 --> 00:39:11.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this item falls under the corruption heading.

372
00:39:12.186 --> 00:39:23.557
<v Jamie Dunphy>We understand the parties have come to an agreement, and we have no objection to the city writing a check for $300,000 to settle this civil rights and malicious prosecution lawsuit for an event that happened over 10 years ago on May 23rd, 2015.

373
00:39:24.635 --> 00:39:45.985
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is different from the usual cases we testify on— people in mental health crisis who call for help and are killed by PPB, like Michael Townsend; mistaken identity and the inherent racism in policing, like that of an unarmed Black man, Manny Clark, who was shot in the back and killed even though PPB was looking for white men, and the many individuals brutalized by police while expressing their First Amendment rights, including the 9 journalists and legal observers who are plaintiffs in the Index Newspapers lawsuit.

374
00:39:46.724 --> 00:39:47.364
<v Jamie Dunphy>This one's different.

375
00:39:47.510 --> 00:39:56.509
<v Jamie Dunphy>Maxine Bernstein wrote about this case last September, and the Oregonian's editorial board followed up shortly afterwards with an opinion piece titled A Lawsuit to Hold the Justice System to Account.

376
00:39:57.293 --> 00:40:05.554
<v Jamie Dunphy>The story, according to court documents and the Oregonian's reporting, is that Mr. Gregg and another man, Mr. Cook, were both sentenced to prison for their roles in selling heroin to a man who died of an overdose.

377
00:40:05.891 --> 00:40:10.436
<v Jamie Dunphy>Or so they were told by two Portland police officers and two Multnomah County deputy district attorneys.

378
00:40:11.190 --> 00:40:23.282
<v Jamie Dunphy>The glitch was that the man did not die of an overdose, although police reports written by PPB officers Carrie Hutchison and Tequila Thurman said that he did, and the deputy district attorneys used that misinformation to get both men to agree to plea deals and serve time in prison.

379
00:40:24.260 --> 00:40:30.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>In fact, according to court documents, Officer Thurman was told by the girlfriend of the man who overdosed that the man was still alive the very same day of the overdose.

380
00:40:31.246 --> 00:40:35.438
<v Jamie Dunphy>3 Days later, Officer Thurman wrote a report that omitted the fact that the man survived the overdose.

381
00:40:36.306 --> 00:40:43.036
<v Jamie Dunphy>Officer Hutchison's report, written the following day, noted that Officer Thurman interviewed 2 individuals who had been with the man the night before his death.

382
00:40:44.193 --> 00:40:53.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mr. Cook was sentenced to 366 days in prison and in May of this year received a judgment in his federal lawsuit awarding him $45,001 plus costs and attorney fees.

383
00:40:54.297 --> 00:40:58.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>According to city officials, these amounts don't yet appear in the monthly city administrator's closed claims report.

384
00:40:59.532 --> 00:41:03.514
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because final billing and related expenses associated with the claim haven't yet been paid.

385
00:41:04.735 --> 00:41:13.226
<v Jamie Dunphy>According to court records, Mr. Gregg filed this lawsuit to obtain compensation for the 5 and a half years he spent in prison believing he had killed a man, all based on the defendant's lies.

386
00:41:13.885 --> 00:41:23.356
<v Jamie Dunphy>I neglected to mention that Mr. Gregg did not learn that the man was still alive until after he was released from prison and had gone looking for the man's family to apologize and seek their support for his plan to go to law school.

387
00:41:24.400 --> 00:41:33.905
<v Jamie Dunphy>The corruption exposed in the DA's office on this case is now a separate and it's ongoing piece of litigation as Mr. Gregg has appealed the court's dismissal of the deputy district attorneys from the suit.

388
00:41:34.371 --> 00:41:37.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today's settlement, though, will end the city's involvement if it's approved.

389
00:41:38.126 --> 00:41:41.016
<v Jamie Dunphy>A district attorney's office's work is always preceded by police work.

390
00:41:41.273 --> 00:41:47.246
<v Jamie Dunphy>According to the Oregonian's reporting, the lead prosecutor stated that he simply believed what was in the police reports when negotiating.

391
00:41:48.097 --> 00:41:55.128
<v Jamie Dunphy>When the police work is negligent or incompetent at best and corrupt at worst, people will be overprosecuted or falsely prosecuted and lose their liberty in the process.

392
00:41:56.027 --> 00:41:56.257
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

393
00:41:56.521 --> 00:41:57.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mr. Chotska is up after me.

394
00:41:59.909 --> 00:42:01.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hi, my name is Philip Chotska.

395
00:42:01.554 --> 00:42:03.056
<v Jamie Dunphy>I use he/him pronouns.

396
00:42:03.394 --> 00:42:05.396
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am also with the group Portland Copwatch.

397
00:42:06.230 --> 00:42:28.594
<v Jamie Dunphy>We appreciate the inclusion of the Bureau claims data along with the ordinance, which states that the 1-year total paid out to claims for the PPB is more than $5.7 million, not including this settlement of $300,000, the associated $45,000 Court judgment plus attorney fees for Mr. Cook, and not including the Manny Clark settlement of $3.75 million.

398
00:42:29.793 --> 00:42:36.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>Once paid out, the— it will push the total to at least $9.75 million this year.

399
00:42:37.460 --> 00:42:45.851
<v Jamie Dunphy>This ordinance does not mention it, so for the record, the Multnomah County court case number is 23-CV-44189.

400
00:42:46.610 --> 00:42:56.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are disappointed that after reading this ordinance, a person could have absolutely no idea what terrible things happened that caused the city to settle for $300,000.

401
00:42:56.873 --> 00:43:00.764
<v Jamie Dunphy>We hope the city will provide greater transparency in the future.

402
00:43:01.650 --> 00:43:10.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>According to Section 2 of this ordinance, it is classified as a bodily injury lawsuit, only this is not a bodily injury lawsuit.

403
00:43:10.737 --> 00:43:16.804
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is a copy and paste error, and fitting for a case in which 2 officers wrote faulty police reports.

404
00:43:18.405 --> 00:43:39.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>Until the Community and Public Safety Committee starts hearing these cases, I support Councilor Kanal's request for increased transparency on these settlements and that the full council continue to discuss the policy decisions or violations that keep us coming back to testify on police misconduct cases in the hope that future harm can be prevented.

405
00:43:40.472 --> 00:43:48.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>This ordinance states that no public involvement or input was sought and no future public involvement or is anticipated or necessary.

406
00:43:49.126 --> 00:43:53.751
<v Jamie Dunphy>The community is deeply impacted by police corruption incidents such as this one.

407
00:43:54.344 --> 00:43:59.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you want community to trust the police bureau, then the police bureau must be trustworthy.

408
00:44:00.396 --> 00:44:03.704
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here are some potential lessons for the community for this case.

409
00:44:04.458 --> 00:44:07.525
<v Jamie Dunphy>When the police knock on your door, it might be better not to answer.

410
00:44:08.184 --> 00:44:11.346
<v Jamie Dunphy>If the police give you information, do not expect it to be the truth.

411
00:44:12.101 --> 00:44:34.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>Be wary of officers' ability to write factually accurate If you are sentenced to prison in part because the police said you killed someone, do some research and find out if that person is still alive, because the state and police may have failed to provide basic facts of the case and exculpatory evidence as required by law.

412
00:44:34.360 --> 00:44:41.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>At the PCC EP meeting tonight, they will be discussing the exculpatory evidence directive, which would require the police to provide basic facts of the case and exculpatory evidence chief as required by law.

413
00:44:41.400 --> 00:44:41.440
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

414
00:44:41.579 --> 00:44:45.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Day wishes to weaken the directive and risk more cases such as this one.

415
00:44:46.224 --> 00:44:55.097
<v Jamie Dunphy>The city should provide, provide all exculpatory evidence to the DA proactively and not wait for the DA to ask about police witnesses that might be unreliable.

416
00:44:56.329 --> 00:44:56.637
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

417
00:45:02.590 --> 00:45:03.416
<v Loretta Smith>Good morning, Council.

418
00:45:03.643 --> 00:45:10.224
<v Loretta Smith>I'm Charlie Michelle Wesley, a member of many Northwest tribes here and I'm here with Portland Cop Watch, but including personal input.

419
00:45:11.188 --> 00:45:14.719
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So where do things stand now with the police officers who lied to Mr. Gray?

420
00:45:15.346 --> 00:45:18.766
<v Loretta Smith>Officers Thurman and Hutchison are both still employed by PPB.

421
00:45:19.456 --> 00:45:29.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do not know if either officer was disciplined for falsifying information, as neither officer has a case listed in the DPSST's Professional Standards and Economics Sanction Database.

422
00:45:30.295 --> 00:45:32.849
<v Loretta Smith>What we do know is in October thank you.

423
00:45:32.849 --> 00:45:35.719
<v Loretta Smith>In 2024, Officer Hutchison was promoted to sergeant.

424
00:45:35.989 --> 00:45:44.349
<v Loretta Smith>However, we are pleased that Mr. Gregg is in his 3rd year at Lewis Clark Law School after serving nearly 5 and a half years in prison.

425
00:45:44.630 --> 00:45:50.320
<v Loretta Smith>His display of ingenuity turned this injustice into a means to protect and serve others.

426
00:45:50.989 --> 00:45:58.009
<v Loretta Smith>We greatly appreciate that Mr. Gregg volunteered to serve on the Portland Committee for Community Engaged Policing, PCEP, all Thank you.

427
00:45:58.088 --> 00:46:04.896
<v Loretta Smith>Although his term was cut short, as we understand it, because the city attorney claimed there was a conflict of interest due to this lawsuit.

428
00:46:05.699 --> 00:46:11.577
<v Loretta Smith>We remember Vice President Koyama Lane's words during deliberation on Manny Clark's settlement.

429
00:46:11.641 --> 00:46:26.059
<v Loretta Smith>She said, when trust is broken and needs to be rebuilt, I believe as a value that those who have been harmed really need to lead the way in what that rebuilding looks like and also also get to decide when there is real change.

430
00:46:26.251 --> 00:46:33.847
<v Loretta Smith>This is exactly what Mr. Gregg was trying to do when he volunteered to serve on PCAP, when the city attorney removed him from that committee.

431
00:46:34.681 --> 00:46:42.324
<v Loretta Smith>We bring this up because the city is currently performing background checks on the already appointed members of the Community Board for Police Accountability.

432
00:46:42.855 --> 00:46:45.809
<v Loretta Smith>It is no secret that there are appointees with criminal histories.

433
00:46:46.306 --> 00:46:53.387
<v Loretta Smith>Who better qualified to shape true accountability policing than those who have firsthand knowledge of the harshness of the system.

434
00:46:53.934 --> 00:47:01.063
<v Loretta Smith>A system that includes a moral character policy of honesty, and if out of policy, consequence is supposed to be termination.

435
00:47:01.416 --> 00:47:07.565
<v Loretta Smith>However, barriers to actual accountability is aided and abetted by the same suppressive injustices.

436
00:47:08.320 --> 00:47:15.835
<v Loretta Smith>Another PPB principle, procedural justice, states involves giving people a voice and being trustworthy.

437
00:47:16.413 --> 00:47:21.695
<v Loretta Smith>But Mr. Gregg and others with that actual truthfulness are removed to keep the truth from succeeding.

438
00:47:22.755 --> 00:47:43.228
<v Loretta Smith>Amartya Sen talked about procedural justice, and I quote, in seeking resolution by public reasoning, there is clearly a strong case for not leaving out perspectives and reasonings presented by anyone whose assessments are relevant, either because their interests are involved or because their ways of thinking about these issues throw light on a particular judgment.

439
00:47:43.324 --> 00:47:52.525
<v Loretta Smith>And in closing, as a recovering addict for 25 years myself, the primary reason recovery programs are so effective is foundational principles of honesty.

440
00:47:53.103 --> 00:48:10.373
<v Loretta Smith>With PPB without honesty, the remaining principles are meaningless and continually lead to lawsuits, which are not accountability nor justice and keep some of the most ethical, knowledgeable community voices overpowered and often with tragic outcomes.

441
00:48:12.630 --> 00:48:12.760
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

442
00:48:12.809 --> 00:48:14.202
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for being here.

443
00:48:21.019 --> 00:48:22.465
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, next up we have Jared Essig.

444
00:48:25.402 --> 00:48:26.708
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, thank you for joining us.

445
00:48:29.108 --> 00:48:30.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, uh, City Council.

446
00:48:31.496 --> 00:48:33.885
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Multnomah County District Attorney, if you're listening.

447
00:48:34.557 --> 00:48:35.503
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Jared Essig.

448
00:48:35.583 --> 00:48:42.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm appearing on behalf of the citizens of Portland and Multnomah County and representing the Rose City Iron Front.

449
00:48:43.440 --> 00:48:56.746
<v Jamie Dunphy>On September 12th of last year, 13th, after the day after OregonLive exposed this prosecutorial negligence or corruption and the police misconduct that resulted in this yes.

450
00:48:56.826 --> 00:49:00.423
<v Jamie Dunphy>Unlawful, unjust incarceration of Mr. Gregg.

451
00:49:01.918 --> 00:49:18.126
<v Jamie Dunphy>I appeared before Multnomah County Presiding Judge Judith Matarazzo in an ex parte off-docket hearing, and I asked her to adopt the policy that had been proposed by Senior Deputy District Attorney Kelly Rhodes but had been not adopted by the District Attorney's Office.

452
00:49:19.153 --> 00:49:24.746
<v Jamie Dunphy>And she agreed miraculously, and it's now verbally ordered, so ordered by the Yes.

453
00:49:24.940 --> 00:49:46.545
<v Jamie Dunphy>Multnomah County Court that they will not accept a negotiated plea offer unless— in a case involving a homicide, unless there is proof of death in the form of a medical examiner's report or other affidavit testimony from some reliable witness.

454
00:49:47.235 --> 00:49:49.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now, that should have been done by the prosecutor in this case.

455
00:49:50.563 --> 00:49:59.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's why this whole qualified immunity thing has to be eroded, because the, the DA's office is the primary culprit in this misconduct, not the city.

456
00:49:59.862 --> 00:50:14.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>And you should direct the city attorney to work with me to hold the district attorney's office accountable and to ensure that the, uh, the judges abide by Judge Matarazzo's verbal ruling that she made to me.

457
00:50:14.295 --> 00:50:21.188
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to appear tomorrow before her again with a written order and ask her to memorialize that and institutionalize it in the local court rules.

458
00:50:22.014 --> 00:50:36.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm a pro se litigant and I'm an amateur lawyer, so it'd be nice to have some professional legal advice and help in my public advocacy efforts, which will save the city money in the long run.

459
00:50:39.309 --> 00:50:42.806
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now I want to shift— oh, also, the court records are sealed.

460
00:50:42.856 --> 00:50:42.903
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

461
00:50:43.255 --> 00:50:46.980
<v Jamie Dunphy>I couldn't get court records for State versus Greg or State versus Jeremiah Cook.

462
00:50:47.829 --> 00:50:56.994
<v Jamie Dunphy>This violates the Oregon State Constitution's Article 1, Section 10, which guarantees the right to a public trial, as well as the U.S. Constitution.

463
00:50:57.476 --> 00:50:58.856
<v Jamie Dunphy>Justice is not a cloistered virtue.

464
00:50:58.983 --> 00:51:05.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need to see these records to understand what happened and hold our public officials to account.

465
00:51:06.608 --> 00:51:09.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also want to shift gears a little bit.

466
00:51:09.655 --> 00:51:14.286
<v Jamie Dunphy>Say, a lot of leaders want to hold— want to hide behind the police and then blame them when things go wrong.

467
00:51:15.105 --> 00:51:16.242
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's not okay either.

468
00:51:16.387 --> 00:51:19.751
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need moral and intellectual leadership from people like yourselves and from the judge.

469
00:51:20.329 --> 00:51:23.373
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now, authoritarianism, anarchism both support each other.

470
00:51:23.773 --> 00:51:35.039
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's really easy to blame the federal government while refusing to deal with the problem of the ideology of violent revolution, and, uh, which is very popular in Portland.

471
00:51:35.135 --> 00:51:37.161
<v Jamie Dunphy>In fact, Terrorism is more popular than the police are.

472
00:51:37.500 --> 00:51:40.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, so declare a curfew at the ICE facility.

473
00:51:40.155 --> 00:51:40.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's really easy.

474
00:51:41.186 --> 00:51:42.827
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can avoid the deployment of National Guard.

475
00:51:42.940 --> 00:51:43.617
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

476
00:51:44.528 --> 00:51:45.978
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate hearing from you today.

477
00:51:47.880 --> 00:51:49.902
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That completes testimony for this item.

478
00:51:52.442 --> 00:51:53.137
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

479
00:51:54.367 --> 00:51:59.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we will now move into any discussion before taking a vote on this agenda item.

480
00:52:00.074 --> 00:52:00.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

481
00:52:01.226 --> 00:52:03.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Madam President.

482
00:52:04.753 --> 00:52:06.871
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I do have a question for Mike.

483
00:52:06.951 --> 00:52:10.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>It wasn't a technical one, so, but I'll just build to that.

484
00:52:10.815 --> 00:52:17.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>So first and foremost, I do agree with a couple people who said that this issue was primarily but not exclusively a county issue.

485
00:52:18.481 --> 00:52:27.543
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I also want to point out that due to state law providing prosecutors with near absolute immunity from civil liability, the county and DA's offices had the cases against them dismissed.

486
00:52:27.639 --> 00:52:35.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>In other words, while the DA's office and police officers were both originally respondents to this lawsuit, it's now just the police officers involved that we're addressing here.

487
00:52:36.449 --> 00:52:43.784
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I want to point out to my colleagues, I, I personally believe, and I mentioned this in our work session on the legislative agenda, that prosecutorial immunity to this level is ridiculous.

488
00:52:44.235 --> 00:52:53.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Multiple advisory groups to this council have recommended that the city take a stand on this issue at the state level, and I would like to see the city's Office of Government Relations and Thank you.

489
00:52:53.409 --> 00:52:53.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Dan Ryan.

490
00:52:53.409 --> 00:52:53.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

491
00:52:53.409 --> 00:52:53.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have a question for Deputy City Administrator Donnie Oliveira.

492
00:52:53.409 --> 00:52:57.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe that the city has been instructed through the legislative agenda to lobby on an ongoing basis to eliminate it.

493
00:52:57.409 --> 00:53:02.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this is also something that I believe would support our police officers' ability to be held to a standard that is fair for them.

494
00:53:03.989 --> 00:53:06.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>Related to that, but a little different, is my question.

495
00:53:07.590 --> 00:53:12.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is a portion of this that was alleged in the lawsuit to be a responsibility of the city, of PPV.

496
00:53:12.329 --> 00:53:13.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I want to ask 2 questions.

497
00:53:13.650 --> 00:53:17.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>One is, have there been any policy changes as a result of cases like this one?

498
00:53:17.489 --> 00:53:21.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>And was anything done specifically with and I want to stress with, not to.

499
00:53:21.998 --> 00:53:25.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>Has anything been done specifically with the officers involved on this particular case?

500
00:53:27.117 --> 00:53:27.951
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

501
00:53:28.014 --> 00:53:44.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>So to your, to your questions, yes, as a result of this case, there have been modifications, some of which were alluded to in the testimony, specifically that there will be confirmation of death when death is part of the case.

502
00:53:45.168 --> 00:53:52.786
<v Jamie Dunphy>As to the report writing, there's been continued training I would also respond, I think, and it's appropriate to your question, that there were investigations into this.

503
00:53:53.641 --> 00:53:58.871
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's how we know that Officer Brown, for example, had— his report was accurate and then was modified through the system.

504
00:54:01.228 --> 00:54:08.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>Officer Thurman has been on leave since before this litigation commenced, and so that investigation is just on hold.

505
00:54:09.295 --> 00:54:15.503
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Officer Hutchinson had a sustained finding for misinformation ending up in a report in violation of a directive.

506
00:54:15.568 --> 00:54:15.713
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

507
00:54:16.447 --> 00:54:18.954
<v Jamie Dunphy>So those are, that's sort of consequences as a result of this.

508
00:54:19.597 --> 00:54:20.255
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

509
00:54:20.963 --> 00:54:29.414
<v Jamie Dunphy>The only other thing I'd like to mention going forward is I do agree that we should mention 2 things in the documentation for settlements.

510
00:54:29.480 --> 00:54:30.378
<v Jamie Dunphy>One is the case number.

511
00:54:30.925 --> 00:54:36.646
<v Jamie Dunphy>I do think that'd be very helpful for the public and frankly for councilors too to do our own homework on it as well.

512
00:54:36.710 --> 00:54:41.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>I know it's often provided elsewhere, but, and the other piece is if there are related cases.

513
00:54:42.172 --> 00:54:55.713
<v Jamie Dunphy>I did not know about the case related to Mr. Cook until I got an email from a constituent referencing a $45,001 settlement there that because it's under $50,000 did not come here.

514
00:54:56.257 --> 00:54:56.353
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

515
00:54:56.579 --> 00:55:00.856
<v Jamie Dunphy>So for those who don't know, $50,000 and above come to City Council now.

516
00:55:00.922 --> 00:55:03.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>It used to be $5,000 prior to January 1st.

517
00:55:03.869 --> 00:55:13.673
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I think having that be involved and I'd ask, I guess it's probably not you or your office, Mike, but the risk management folks, whoever files it.

518
00:55:14.476 --> 00:55:29.697
<v Jamie Dunphy>So with that said, I guess the question before us to me is, does an open confession to a crime and conviction selling heroin that resulted in an overdose lose you your civil rights, lose you your right to be given the accurate information about the impacts of that crime?

519
00:55:29.891 --> 00:55:38.672
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think the obvious answer is no, which means I think the obvious answer to thank you, Councilor.

520
00:55:39.335 --> 00:55:51.793
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I just want to note on the record there's a question raised in testimony about Section 2, um, of the ordinance itself, which talks about bodily injury.

521
00:55:52.391 --> 00:56:03.155
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, what the attorneys have shared with me is that we categorize claims in 2 ways, either bodily injury or property damage.

522
00:56:03.702 --> 00:56:06.023
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This more closely aligned with bodily injury.

523
00:56:06.217 --> 00:56:12.333
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While that's not exactly what happened, that is the category it would fall in as opposed to property damage.

524
00:56:12.382 --> 00:56:14.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that's why that's listed in the emergency clause.

525
00:56:14.882 --> 00:56:19.391
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know if either of you want to speak to that at all or if we should just move on to the next question.

526
00:56:19.894 --> 00:56:25.724
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, just briefly, that is sort of how the claims are set up, is there's kind of 2 buckets that they can go into—.

527
00:56:26.277 --> 00:56:30.356
<v Loretta Smith>Property damage kind of reserves and claims, and bodily injury.

528
00:56:31.050 --> 00:56:39.918
<v Loretta Smith>So bodily injury ends up having to cover emotional distress, civil rights violations, employment claims, things that aren't what you think of as like a physical injury.

529
00:56:41.447 --> 00:56:53.320
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It definitely is something though where we could change the wording if we want to have it kind of clarify a little bit, even if that's just how it's set up in our system and how the templates get set up.

530
00:56:53.385 --> 00:56:57.945
<v Jamie Dunphy>We could change the language to reflect more clearly what it is if you'd like.

531
00:56:58.523 --> 00:57:00.193
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for clarifying that.

532
00:57:00.273 --> 00:57:03.179
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It may be that that's more of a broader forward-looking issue.

533
00:57:04.286 --> 00:57:04.945
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

534
00:57:06.389 --> 00:57:07.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Madam President.

535
00:57:08.139 --> 00:57:10.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't have a question, I just want to make a statement.

536
00:57:11.271 --> 00:57:15.364
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not very happy about this settlement.

537
00:57:16.007 --> 00:57:22.440
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Generally, I don't want to vote to reward an admitted drug dealer at one point.

538
00:57:23.226 --> 00:57:30.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm also someone who had a felony on their record and, and had that erased earlier in my life.

539
00:57:31.583 --> 00:57:42.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I've heard from other councilors here on the dais outside meetings that— Councilor Smith, Councilor Novick, and others— that point out that this person turned their life around.

540
00:57:43.952 --> 00:57:50.833
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also recognize that pursuing this could potentially cost the city a lot more than the cost of this settlement.

541
00:57:51.420 --> 00:57:54.463
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I will reluctantly be voting yes on this.

542
00:57:55.139 --> 00:58:03.393
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also want to take exception to some of the testimony we heard this morning that I think that saying this is corruption is really an overreach.

543
00:58:05.050 --> 00:58:07.614
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Maybe it was sloppy on the other end of the continuum.

544
00:58:07.663 --> 00:58:08.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it was a breach of trust.

545
00:58:08.509 --> 00:58:10.092
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I don't think it was corruption.

546
00:58:10.771 --> 00:58:12.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just wanted to say that.

547
00:58:12.161 --> 00:58:12.887
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

548
00:58:14.971 --> 00:58:15.663
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

549
00:58:15.710 --> 00:58:16.643
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

550
00:58:19.411 --> 00:58:20.489
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

551
00:58:23.347 --> 00:58:31.293
<v Loretta Smith>I believe this settlement is an important reminder that how we do things is as important as what we are doing.

552
00:58:32.541 --> 00:58:40.789
<v Loretta Smith>As city officials, we must hold ourselves to a higher standard because the public put full faith in us to do so.

553
00:58:41.896 --> 00:58:48.378
<v Loretta Smith>This individual paid his debt to society while living with the guilt of taking a life he did not actually take.

554
00:58:49.838 --> 00:58:59.478
<v Loretta Smith>I couldn't imagine what it feels like to have felt that you, for 5 and a half years, that you killed someone and you didn't.

555
00:59:00.248 --> 00:59:08.320
<v Loretta Smith>I admire the drive, the tenacity, Of Mr. Gregg.

556
00:59:11.193 --> 00:59:21.637
<v Loretta Smith>And putting himself through law school is exactly what we would want for people who have served their time.

557
00:59:23.610 --> 00:59:33.581
<v Loretta Smith>This is exactly what I want, and I think the system that helped people rehabilitate themselves is the system that I want to be a part of.

558
00:59:34.559 --> 00:59:44.490
<v Loretta Smith>And we have to be held accountable when we mislead folks as we're trying to prosecute in our very hurried lives.

559
00:59:45.309 --> 00:59:48.742
<v Loretta Smith>And we have to be very careful how we do things.

560
00:59:49.400 --> 00:59:55.335
<v Loretta Smith>It's not because of what he did, it was how we enacted as being the person who yes.

561
00:59:55.657 --> 00:59:59.670
<v Loretta Smith>Is in charge and the person who is supposed to be doing things by the book.

562
01:00:00.552 --> 01:00:07.679
<v Loretta Smith>And I don't know if it's overreach that the previous Copwatch folks said that it was corruption.

563
01:00:08.434 --> 01:00:11.981
<v Loretta Smith>Well, I think it's somewhere in between, but it is definitely something we should not do.

564
01:00:12.190 --> 01:00:18.675
<v Loretta Smith>It was definitely, as we looked at the data, it was put in 2 different places.

565
01:00:18.804 --> 01:00:22.255
<v Loretta Smith>So we have to be held accountable for that.

566
01:00:23.188 --> 01:00:32.762
<v Loretta Smith>I appreciate, uh, Mr. Gregg being able to rehabilitate himself, and I'm looking forward to see what he does with this law degree.

567
01:00:33.458 --> 01:00:33.797
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

568
01:00:35.708 --> 01:00:36.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

569
01:00:36.614 --> 01:00:37.391
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

570
01:00:39.139 --> 01:00:39.704
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

571
01:00:40.077 --> 01:00:41.614
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I just have some questions.

572
01:00:45.059 --> 01:00:48.487
<v Jamie Dunphy>How many prosecuting attorneys does the City of Portland employ?

573
01:00:50.110 --> 01:00:50.817
<v Jamie Dunphy>None, Councilor.

574
01:00:51.186 --> 01:00:51.378
<v Loretta Smith>None.

575
01:00:51.652 --> 01:00:51.893
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

576
01:00:52.599 --> 01:00:54.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, did we prosecute this case?

577
01:00:55.842 --> 01:00:56.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>No, we did not.

578
01:00:56.885 --> 01:00:57.222
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

579
01:00:58.699 --> 01:00:58.844
<v Loretta Smith>What—.

580
01:00:59.422 --> 01:01:07.851
<v Jamie Dunphy>For the distribution of heroin, what is a standard jail sentence that a person would get if they, uh, pled to that?

581
01:01:08.253 --> 01:01:10.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, uh, I'll answer your question.

582
01:01:10.838 --> 01:01:19.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's a sentencing guideline or grid that the courts use and the recommended, or the presumptive sentence, that's the language they use in this particular case, would've been 80 months.

583
01:01:20.376 --> 01:01:20.922
<v Jamie Dunphy>Say it again.

584
01:01:21.275 --> 01:01:21.853
<v Loretta Smith>80 Months.

585
01:01:22.143 --> 01:01:22.753
<v Loretta Smith>80 Months.

586
01:01:23.847 --> 01:01:24.231
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

587
01:01:25.775 --> 01:01:38.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>So in your estimation, does the jail sentence that this person served for distributing heroin match the normal course of what a drug dealer would have received?

588
01:01:40.735 --> 01:01:50.126
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman, I think that to answer your question, uh, I would say that the presumptive sentence is the sentence that would— the court was presumed to give when under these facts.

589
01:01:50.686 --> 01:02:03.427
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mr. Gregg's allegations are that at the time he felt that given the, uh, court's posture that he would have been able to get a reduced sentence if he'd been able to argue this point and didn't know it.

590
01:02:04.132 --> 01:02:06.007
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, I think that's the distinction between the two.

591
01:02:07.931 --> 01:02:08.775
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, that's helpful.

592
01:02:09.472 --> 01:02:25.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>If, if a person is facing a drug dealing charge in our courts, does the guilt of the drug dealing itself matter with respect to whether or not a person who purchased those drugs died or did not die?

593
01:02:27.342 --> 01:02:30.688
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is drug dealing illegal whether you live or if your victim lives or dies?

594
01:02:31.702 --> 01:02:32.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is illegal.

595
01:02:32.583 --> 01:02:36.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the charge in this case, uh, an element of it was not the status of the victim.

596
01:02:37.425 --> 01:02:37.699
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

597
01:02:39.766 --> 01:02:59.195
<v Jamie Dunphy>One of the testimonies received was malicious prosecution, and I, I know that a lot of Portlanders center their public safety concerns at the city, but I want to use this opportunity to remind folks that the City of Portland does not prosecute any cases.

598
01:02:59.259 --> 01:03:02.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>In fact, it's an entirely different government who prosecuted this case.

599
01:03:06.340 --> 01:03:12.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>I— to me, this looks like a failure on behalf of the defense attorney.

600
01:03:12.389 --> 01:03:19.150
<v Jamie Dunphy>It looks like a standard jail sentence for a person who's convicted of dealing drugs.

601
01:03:19.519 --> 01:03:30.166
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am concerned that we are continuing to cite turned their life around yes.

602
01:03:30.262 --> 01:03:43.304
<v Jamie Dunphy>As a reason why in this situation where some false information was in a police report is an argument for a payout.

603
01:03:44.010 --> 01:03:45.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is troubling to me.

604
01:03:45.376 --> 01:04:05.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that if we're on the hook for any misinformation in a police report from the moment for something that a different government prosecutes, And that a person cops to and pleads guilty to, that if they don't turn their life around, would we not be in a situation where we would settle?

605
01:04:05.487 --> 01:04:07.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>This seems interesting to me that that's coming up.

606
01:04:09.559 --> 01:04:35.088
<v Jamie Dunphy>But if I would be far more comfortable making this settlement agreement if you were here telling me if the person was— had served a sentence related to the death of another human, but that's not what I'm seeing in any of the documents or any of our briefings that we received, that the sentence was served unrelated to the death of a person.

607
01:04:37.416 --> 01:04:41.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because distributing heroin, it wasn't distributing heroin, comma, someone died.

608
01:04:42.315 --> 01:04:49.014
<v Jamie Dunphy>I guess I'm concerned about a precedent that we'd be setting as a city.

609
01:04:49.094 --> 01:04:49.545
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that's a good point.

610
01:04:50.126 --> 01:05:08.175
<v Jamie Dunphy>That after you tune your sentence, if you can find any scribner's errors, any information errors, anything at the point that the City of Portland is the piggy bank to come to and not Multnomah County, who has the duty for investigating and negotiating plea deals and prosecuting cases.

611
01:05:08.351 --> 01:05:20.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, I don't want to say that, uh, I don't think the information in those police reports should be ignored.

612
01:05:20.048 --> 01:05:24.289
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think my colleagues have made really good points about that, and you've indicated some changes there.

613
01:05:25.469 --> 01:05:40.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>What I'm failing to understand is why, when there's another government who prosecuted this case, a judge who put out this sentence, a defendant who pled to this charge, why this lands here.

614
01:05:40.907 --> 01:05:57.248
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, Given all of that and this idea that we're going to negotiate with drug dealers, I feel very dissatisfied with being brought this settlement.

615
01:05:57.329 --> 01:05:58.541
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think we should go to trial.

616
01:05:58.621 --> 01:06:00.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think Portlanders expect us to go to trial.

617
01:06:00.963 --> 01:06:16.286
<v Jamie Dunphy>When you, when you do the time for the crime you committed and pled to, I, I don't see the, the concern here in the way that it's been described in these documents.

618
01:06:16.351 --> 01:06:19.510
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I do appreciate that we've gone into some detail previously.

619
01:06:19.590 --> 01:06:20.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>I thank you for that.

620
01:06:20.903 --> 01:06:23.514
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, I appreciate your professional opinion on this.

621
01:06:24.519 --> 01:06:32.260
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, I'm uncomfortable with just how many of— or I guess our aversion to going to court on some of these.

622
01:06:32.356 --> 01:06:39.344
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it would be in the best I think it's the best case for us to say, you dealt drugs, you did your time for dealing drugs, not for killing a person.

623
01:06:41.137 --> 01:06:43.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>And they can make the case in front of a court.

624
01:06:43.708 --> 01:06:46.342
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I won't be supporting the settlement.

625
01:06:46.438 --> 01:06:49.523
<v Jamie Dunphy>I understand there is considerations about greater loss, et cetera.

626
01:06:49.588 --> 01:07:04.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I do think there is a point in which we have to look at some reasonable facts here that we're being sued for by a person who did time for the crime they committed and which they pled guilty to, and it had nothing to do with the death of a person.

627
01:07:05.871 --> 01:07:17.173
<v Jamie Dunphy>But somehow we're letting that false fact come in and say that because of that, their dealing of drugs is somehow not something to be held accountable for.

628
01:07:17.739 --> 01:07:19.835
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'll stop there.

629
01:07:20.222 --> 01:07:24.692
<v Jamie Dunphy>I do appreciate folks who— their comments that have been made.

630
01:07:24.739 --> 01:07:25.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think they're all well put.

631
01:07:25.842 --> 01:07:26.012
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

632
01:07:26.570 --> 01:07:28.130
<v Jamie Dunphy>I agree with Councilor Clark.

633
01:07:28.130 --> 01:07:33.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't expect that there was other undercurrents in this.

634
01:07:33.570 --> 01:07:38.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that mistakes happen and we've dealt with that, but there are other checks in terms of prosecutorial.

635
01:07:38.889 --> 01:07:41.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this is 3 DAs ago, by the way, I'll say.

636
01:07:41.590 --> 01:07:47.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Not the current DA, not the last DA, but the one previous in 2015.

637
01:07:47.010 --> 01:07:52.429
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I think that this case should rest at Multnomah County and not the City of Portland.

638
01:07:52.530 --> 01:07:53.190
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that we should be careful about what we say.

639
01:07:53.190 --> 01:07:53.230
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

640
01:07:53.300 --> 01:07:57.586
<v Jamie Dunphy>I— if the case needs to be argued, I think that that's the right place for it and not these chambers.

641
01:07:57.652 --> 01:07:58.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>But thank you all.

642
01:08:01.702 --> 01:08:02.431
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

643
01:08:02.512 --> 01:08:03.192
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

644
01:08:04.389 --> 01:08:06.251
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Madam President.

645
01:08:06.331 --> 01:08:17.246
<v Jamie Dunphy>First of all, my inclination is always to go with the city attorney's recommendation as to a settlement when they're saying that if we don't settle, we have a risk that the taxpayers will wind up paying more.

646
01:08:18.344 --> 01:08:26.378
<v Jamie Dunphy>There are some circumstances in which a proposed settlement seems so morally abhorrent that I would say no, let's roll the dice, even if that means the city pays more.

647
01:08:27.164 --> 01:08:31.735
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I understand people being concerned about making a payout to a drug dealer.

648
01:08:32.377 --> 01:08:41.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, I want to second the point made by Councilor Smith, which is that this guy spent years under the impression that he had killed somebody.

649
01:08:42.867 --> 01:08:55.871
<v Jamie Dunphy>And unless he is a complete monster, then suffering under that impression for years is, to me, Likely to have been at least as painful as if he'd been savagely beaten by police officers.

650
01:08:56.688 --> 01:09:03.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I want to assume that most people are— even drug dealers are not monsters.

651
01:09:03.738 --> 01:09:19.474
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the fact that this guy suffered for years under the impression that he had killed somebody, to me means that despite generally I wouldn't want to give money to drug dealers, The City Attorney's recommendation is not morally abhorrent.

652
01:09:19.682 --> 01:09:30.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I fall back on my general idea that as a matter of fiscal responsibility, I defer to the City Attorney's judgment as to what the risk, what the financial risk is.

653
01:09:32.987 --> 01:09:33.792
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

654
01:09:34.259 --> 01:09:37.993
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, we'll get back to you after others have an opportunity to speak first.

655
01:09:38.057 --> 01:09:39.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hate to do that when I'm next in the queue.

656
01:09:39.829 --> 01:09:41.617
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's a bit awkward, but here we are.

657
01:09:42.398 --> 01:09:46.154
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I appreciate the comments that my colleagues are making.

658
01:09:47.375 --> 01:09:51.277
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to be clear that when we're talking about a settlement, it's not about Mr. Gregg.

659
01:09:51.324 --> 01:09:52.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's not about his past.

660
01:09:52.385 --> 01:09:53.493
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's not about his future.

661
01:09:53.556 --> 01:09:56.849
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's not about whether he's a good guy or a bad guy.

662
01:09:56.944 --> 01:10:00.654
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it's also not about whether the sentence was right.

663
01:10:00.702 --> 01:10:02.340
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's about 2 things.

664
01:10:02.420 --> 01:10:13.237
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is it likely that we messed up in this case in a way that may have affected his civil rights, and what is the legal risk compared to the cost of settlement.

665
01:10:14.533 --> 01:10:15.895
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I want to make 2 things clear.

666
01:10:16.826 --> 01:10:20.831
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't believe that we should be taking the ultimate responsibility for this.

667
01:10:21.409 --> 01:10:26.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think the facts of the case show that the real responsibility rests with the county and the DA's office.

668
01:10:27.806 --> 01:10:35.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe that we have amazing city employees who do incredible work for Portlanders every day, and nothing about this case changes that.

669
01:10:36.779 --> 01:10:42.886
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But because we have amazing city employees, we have to hold ourselves to the highest standard.

670
01:10:43.576 --> 01:10:46.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And when we fall short of this standard, we have to make it right.

671
01:10:46.942 --> 01:10:58.805
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And in this case, I believe that there's enough risk that we fell short of our standards, our legal standards, and there's enough risk that the cost of moving forward would be greater than the cost.

672
01:11:07.416 --> 01:11:08.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Morillo.

673
01:11:08.947 --> 01:11:11.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

674
01:11:12.448 --> 01:11:16.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I definitely agree with everything that you stated and that Councilor Smith stated before us.

675
01:11:18.105 --> 01:11:21.449
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think the reality is that the law has to be dispassionate.

676
01:11:21.530 --> 01:11:34.635
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So this is not about our personal feelings about this is about whether or not his due process rights were violated, and his due process rights were violated.

677
01:11:35.020 --> 01:11:40.443
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while this wasn't being handled within the city of Portland, we do have some responsibility.

678
01:11:40.796 --> 01:11:53.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was our officers that lied about whether or not he had killed someone, and I think most people who have any compassion in their hearts, regardless of the life that they lead, would be concerned, upset, and outraged by that.

679
01:11:53.292 --> 01:11:54.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dan Ryan.

680
01:11:54.256 --> 01:12:00.182
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And have long-lasting emotional damage if they thought that their actions had led to someone's death.

681
01:12:01.034 --> 01:12:13.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I also just wanna push back on some of the comments that we heard previously because our legal system is not consistent and judges often use their discretion to make decisions about people's lives.

682
01:12:14.190 --> 01:12:21.435
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think there were multiple studies done that show that weather changes can impact whether or not a judge is going to give a harsher or lighter sentence.

683
01:12:21.484 --> 01:12:21.708
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

684
01:12:21.789 --> 01:12:21.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

685
01:12:22.287 --> 01:12:25.993
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If someone's sports team loses, they could give a harsher or lighter sentence.

686
01:12:26.314 --> 01:12:33.952
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>People are very complicated, and there is a lot of discretion in how people make decisions that changes day to day.

687
01:12:34.594 --> 01:12:41.204
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So someone being apologetic for what they have done, I think, absolutely impacts a judge's discretion in this.

688
01:12:42.697 --> 01:12:56.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we at the City of Portland, we're responsible for our police and the things that our police say and do, especially if it can impact someone's sentence long-term, and we do have to take responsibility for that.

689
01:12:56.775 --> 01:13:03.922
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also think that we really have to— I really appreciate Councilor Clark sharing part of her history here with us today.

690
01:13:04.002 --> 01:13:08.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's extremely powerful, and she's a city councilor now, and I'm happy to serve alongside her.

691
01:13:08.954 --> 01:13:16.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that means that when we say we're negotiating with drug dealers, what does that mean when someone has thank you.

692
01:13:16.359 --> 01:13:21.570
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If a person has served their time and is now doing different things and has a law degree, they're not a drug dealer anymore.

693
01:13:21.667 --> 01:13:28.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They are a person who is doing something different with their life, and they deserve to move on and to be a productive member of our society.

694
01:13:29.025 --> 01:13:32.832
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we have a responsibility here.

695
01:13:33.527 --> 01:13:35.157
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a responsibility for our police.

696
01:13:35.220 --> 01:13:42.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a responsibility to move through this without passion and to just say, are we partially responsible for this?

697
01:13:42.966 --> 01:13:46.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And our police are, and we are responsible for our police.

698
01:13:46.844 --> 01:13:58.525
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I am going to vote to approve this settlement, and I hope that people understand that no matter who you are or where you come from, you deserve to have your civil rights protected.

699
01:13:58.671 --> 01:14:00.578
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You deserve to have due process.

700
01:14:01.314 --> 01:14:13.685
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And at a time where our country is actually taking away so many people's due process, I hope that the city of Portland will show that no matter who you are, where you come from, you are owed that in a just society.

701
01:14:14.087 --> 01:14:14.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

702
01:14:17.445 --> 01:14:18.479
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

703
01:14:18.753 --> 01:14:19.448
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

704
01:14:23.257 --> 01:14:24.469
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

705
01:14:24.550 --> 01:14:28.002
<v Loretta Smith>And I just want to go back and piggyback what, uh, Councilor Murillo said.

706
01:14:28.518 --> 01:14:32.081
<v Loretta Smith>Under the Constitution, we are granted due process of the law.

707
01:14:32.935 --> 01:14:39.118
<v Loretta Smith>Under the 14th Amendment, We are granted equal protection under the law.

708
01:14:40.157 --> 01:14:41.356
<v Loretta Smith>And I want to ask you a question.

709
01:14:43.119 --> 01:14:59.338
<v Loretta Smith>I'm sure— we don't have the tape or the transcripts to show, but I bet you a dollar to a donut Mr. Gregg was told, if you do not take this plea deal, we're going to charge you with murder.

710
01:14:59.578 --> 01:14:59.713
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

711
01:15:00.979 --> 01:15:07.435
<v Loretta Smith>You gave us 80 months as a possible timeline of what he would have spent.

712
01:15:07.676 --> 01:15:09.819
<v Loretta Smith>80 Months is 6.2 years.

713
01:15:11.302 --> 01:15:17.188
<v Loretta Smith>How much would, would he have gotten if he was charged and found guilty of murder?

714
01:15:20.990 --> 01:15:23.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, uh, Councilor Smith, I can— I'll speak to that.

715
01:15:24.091 --> 01:15:27.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>The, the presumptive sentence for the drug charge was 80 months.

716
01:15:27.340 --> 01:15:37.247
<v Jamie Dunphy>The, the was in fact A written offer from the DA's office to his attorney that said, if you don't plead, there will be potential federal charges.

717
01:15:37.520 --> 01:15:47.105
<v Jamie Dunphy>And those federal charges, while not murder, would have brought many more months or years of, uh, of time in a federal prison, not a state prison.

718
01:15:47.699 --> 01:15:54.796
<v Jamie Dunphy>And some of those would have been likely, based on the record, uh, related to the death of the person who overdosed.

719
01:15:54.860 --> 01:15:55.085
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

720
01:15:55.181 --> 01:15:57.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>So yes, it would have— he, he was threatened with a longer sentence.

721
01:15:58.454 --> 01:16:02.610
<v Loretta Smith>So we can safely say without this plea deal, he was looking at a lot of time.

722
01:16:03.510 --> 01:16:10.747
<v Loretta Smith>And so he made a choice to take the lesser of time, which he was afforded due our Constitution, right?

723
01:16:11.774 --> 01:16:19.942
<v Loretta Smith>And he was getting everything that anyone who was in this position would, would have been able to receive.

724
01:16:20.615 --> 01:16:22.317
<v Loretta Smith>There's a negotiation, there's a deal.

725
01:16:22.542 --> 01:16:23.317
<v Loretta Smith>When you're doing this.

726
01:16:24.076 --> 01:16:29.225
<v Loretta Smith>And so I agree, you don't have to agree with, with what the person did.

727
01:16:29.564 --> 01:16:30.387
<v Loretta Smith>We don't like it.

728
01:16:31.162 --> 01:16:36.664
<v Loretta Smith>It has the potential of causing all kinds of things with our kids and our grandkids and those kinds of things.

729
01:16:37.167 --> 01:16:52.167
<v Loretta Smith>But at the same time, if our police gave information that caused him to make this decision, I'd say in addition to the DA's office, We are equal— equally responsible.

730
01:16:52.747 --> 01:17:00.537
<v Loretta Smith>So today is not about, like Councilor, um, our Council President said, this is not about if we like this person as a person.

731
01:17:00.779 --> 01:17:03.430
<v Loretta Smith>This is about equal protection under the law.

732
01:17:04.234 --> 01:17:04.685
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

733
01:17:06.645 --> 01:17:07.305
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

734
01:17:07.368 --> 01:17:08.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

735
01:17:08.800 --> 01:17:08.993
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

736
01:17:09.057 --> 01:17:13.301
<v Jamie Dunphy>A lot of my colleagues said a lot of what I was going to say, so I'll just, uh, hit it quickly.

737
01:17:13.784 --> 01:17:18.621
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, strongly support Councilor Smith's assertion about our high standards and holding ourselves to them.

738
01:17:18.828 --> 01:17:25.761
<v Jamie Dunphy>I agree with both Councilors Clark and Zimmerman about frustration with the county's lack of responsibility here, and we'll talk about the legislative agenda when we do.

739
01:17:26.452 --> 01:17:33.657
<v Jamie Dunphy>I agree with Councilor Zimmerman's point that turning your life around or not is sort of immaterial to the question of whether— of the settlement itself.

740
01:17:33.833 --> 01:17:46.502
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's a nice-to-know piece of information, and I appreciate hearing about it, but I think that even if this plaintiff had done the same stuff after his sentence was completed.

741
01:17:46.939 --> 01:17:49.024
<v Jamie Dunphy>The question is immaterial to the settlement.

742
01:17:49.203 --> 01:17:52.533
<v Jamie Dunphy>The settlement is about, did we create a harm and would we be paying it?

743
01:17:52.743 --> 01:17:56.127
<v Jamie Dunphy>Or in this particular case, is there a risk that a court would find that?

744
01:17:57.869 --> 01:17:59.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that makes sense.

745
01:17:59.588 --> 01:18:07.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will say one last thing, which is that I do— I really appreciated the conversation about whether or not this was corruption or a mistake.

746
01:18:07.884 --> 01:18:10.956
<v Jamie Dunphy>From my read of the record, it did appear to me to be a mistake.

747
01:18:11.003 --> 01:18:11.085
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

748
01:18:12.725 --> 01:18:14.762
<v Jamie Dunphy>On behalf of the officers personally.

749
01:18:14.810 --> 01:18:18.051
<v Jamie Dunphy>That was my most likely outcome takeaway here.

750
01:18:18.581 --> 01:18:26.153
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think that it's still important to hold officers to a standard of conduct that's been set without necessarily saying you did this intentionally, right?

751
01:18:26.345 --> 01:18:32.345
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's a criminal question sometimes, but not necessarily in our administrative context, and also not in the civil context.

752
01:18:32.681 --> 01:18:37.703
<v Jamie Dunphy>Having said that, I totally understand why there's a lack of trust, and I think that's really important.

753
01:18:37.751 --> 01:18:37.846
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

754
01:18:39.460 --> 01:18:49.939
<v Jamie Dunphy>I understand why people might come to their own conclusion that it's more likely than not that something was— something wrong was done here.

755
01:18:49.939 --> 01:18:50.779
<v Jamie Dunphy>That doesn't mean I agree.

756
01:18:50.920 --> 01:19:01.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just understand that there's been enough distrust created over the years to see how it's easy for someone who doesn't have all the information we have, in part because we don't necessarily give all the information that we have, might get there.

757
01:19:01.960 --> 01:19:04.560
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think it's a perfectly fair assessment, even if I don't necessarily agree with it.

758
01:19:04.542 --> 01:19:04.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>Agree thank you.

759
01:19:05.007 --> 01:19:05.827
<v Jamie Dunphy>With it in this case.

760
01:19:06.309 --> 01:19:13.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I want to close by thanking Councilor Murillo for saying exactly what I was going to say, which is that due process matters to everyone, whether it's any of us up here, Mr. Gregg, or an immigrant.

761
01:19:13.859 --> 01:19:16.327
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need to be standing up for universal rights and principles.

762
01:19:16.585 --> 01:19:16.876
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

763
01:19:17.425 --> 01:19:20.118
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

764
01:19:21.458 --> 01:19:26.037
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing no one else in the queue, this is an emergency ordinance.

765
01:19:26.118 --> 01:19:28.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It requires 9 votes to pass.

766
01:19:28.275 --> 01:19:29.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

767
01:19:30.311 --> 01:19:31.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>Clark.

768
01:19:31.822 --> 01:19:31.869
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

769
01:19:32.543 --> 01:19:32.769
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green.

770
01:19:33.105 --> 01:19:33.266
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

771
01:19:33.619 --> 01:19:33.988
<v Loretta Smith>Zimmerman.

772
01:19:34.181 --> 01:19:34.310
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

773
01:19:35.771 --> 01:19:36.060
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos.

774
01:19:36.398 --> 01:19:36.574
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

775
01:19:37.762 --> 01:19:38.100
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dunphy.

776
01:19:38.565 --> 01:19:38.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

777
01:19:39.078 --> 01:19:39.432
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Smith.

778
01:19:39.930 --> 01:19:39.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

779
01:19:40.268 --> 01:19:41.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Kanal.

780
01:19:41.375 --> 01:19:41.423
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

781
01:19:42.113 --> 01:19:42.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan.

782
01:19:42.739 --> 01:19:42.820
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

783
01:19:43.703 --> 01:19:44.168
<v Jamie Dunphy>Koyama Lane.

784
01:19:44.908 --> 01:19:44.956
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

785
01:19:45.871 --> 01:19:46.273
<v Jamie Dunphy>Murillo.

786
01:19:46.673 --> 01:19:46.835
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

787
01:19:47.654 --> 01:19:47.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>Novick.

788
01:19:48.279 --> 01:19:48.328
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

789
01:19:49.259 --> 01:19:49.708
<v Jamie Dunphy>Pirtle-Guiney.

790
01:19:50.046 --> 01:19:50.094
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

791
01:19:51.265 --> 01:19:54.878
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The ordinance passes with 11 yes votes and 1 no vote.

792
01:19:55.774 --> 01:20:02.162
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan, and thank you to our legal and risk teams for their work on settling this case.

793
01:20:04.605 --> 01:20:06.497
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the next agenda item?

794
01:20:12.801 --> 01:20:32.043
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 5, amend city code to adopt State of Oregon building codes by reference, amend Code Title 24 and Sections 25 thank you, Keelan.

795
01:20:32.238 --> 01:20:34.326
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is a second reading of an ordinance.

796
01:20:34.373 --> 01:20:37.331
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If there is no discussion or debate, we will move to a vote.

797
01:20:38.806 --> 01:20:40.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing none, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

798
01:20:43.047 --> 01:20:43.457
<v Jamie Dunphy>Clark.

799
01:20:43.786 --> 01:20:43.949
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

800
01:20:44.295 --> 01:20:46.707
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, Councilor, did you have a comment on this?

801
01:20:46.837 --> 01:20:46.904
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

802
01:20:47.648 --> 01:20:49.480
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize, I thought that was a legacy hand.

803
01:20:50.542 --> 01:20:51.153
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 5.

804
01:20:51.426 --> 01:20:54.256
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, okay, go ahead, Keelan.

805
01:20:54.337 --> 01:20:54.675
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

806
01:20:55.189 --> 01:20:55.787
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Clark?

807
01:20:56.742 --> 01:20:56.791
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

808
01:20:58.457 --> 01:20:59.217
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green?

809
01:20:59.734 --> 01:20:59.832
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

810
01:21:00.318 --> 01:21:00.673
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman?

811
01:21:00.948 --> 01:21:01.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

812
01:21:01.693 --> 01:21:01.984
<v Loretta Smith>Avalos?

813
01:21:02.243 --> 01:21:02.323
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

814
01:21:02.987 --> 01:21:03.359
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dunphy?

815
01:21:03.552 --> 01:21:04.796
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks to Terry Harris with this.

816
01:21:05.393 --> 01:21:05.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>I vote aye.

817
01:21:06.923 --> 01:21:07.310
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

818
01:21:07.810 --> 01:21:07.859
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

819
01:21:08.456 --> 01:21:08.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Kanal?

820
01:21:10.067 --> 01:21:10.148
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

821
01:21:11.436 --> 01:21:11.662
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan?

822
01:21:12.082 --> 01:21:12.097
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

823
01:21:13.779 --> 01:21:13.827
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

824
01:21:14.520 --> 01:21:14.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

825
01:21:15.555 --> 01:21:15.603
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

826
01:21:16.685 --> 01:21:16.701
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

827
01:21:17.654 --> 01:21:22.432
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The ordinance passes with 12 yes votes.

828
01:21:24.619 --> 01:21:24.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

829
01:21:25.305 --> 01:21:27.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please read our next agenda item?

830
01:21:29.840 --> 01:21:40.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 6, research disparities in public contracting, workforce, and employment in Portland, and report back thank you, Keelan.

831
01:21:40.594 --> 01:21:44.113
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And before we start, I want to thank Councilor Smith.

832
01:21:45.109 --> 01:21:50.313
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This was on our agenda a few weeks ago, and because of some other timing issues, we needed to bump it to today.

833
01:21:50.362 --> 01:21:54.501
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate your partnership in figuring out a time for it to come back.

834
01:21:57.130 --> 01:22:01.131
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we have a committee staff summary, I believe, from Craig.

835
01:22:01.212 --> 01:22:02.248
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mayor.

836
01:22:03.904 --> 01:22:05.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not sure if he's online.

837
01:22:05.239 --> 01:22:06.493
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know he was out yesterday.

838
01:22:08.617 --> 01:22:08.922
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>He's here.

839
01:22:10.645 --> 01:22:13.993
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm looking to our Council Operations Manager.

840
01:22:18.199 --> 01:22:20.622
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will figure out where our committee step— what?

841
01:22:22.576 --> 01:22:25.627
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Excuse me, my bad.

842
01:22:26.305 --> 01:22:26.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

843
01:22:28.953 --> 01:22:34.689
<v Loretta Smith>Madam President, I can give you some background so we don't have any why don't we start with the committee chair report?

844
01:22:34.737 --> 01:22:37.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe you're the carrier as well.

845
01:22:37.386 --> 01:22:37.738
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

846
01:22:37.804 --> 01:22:42.300
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Though I think Councilor Green may have presided, so we'll come back to Councilor Green with a chair report.

847
01:22:42.363 --> 01:22:44.162
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Why don't we start with the carrier's report?

848
01:22:44.451 --> 01:22:54.792
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, we actually put this up twice and I brought it forward and I was looking to use already existing resources to pay for a disparity study.

849
01:22:55.208 --> 01:23:05.689
<v Loretta Smith>And I was told that I couldn't do the state of Oregon, and I couldn't do the Port of Portland or any other previous disparity study that was not specifically for the city of Portland.

850
01:23:06.539 --> 01:23:09.123
<v Loretta Smith>So at any rate, we had to put it back on the docket.

851
01:23:09.332 --> 01:23:12.719
<v Loretta Smith>And thank you, Councilor Green, for presiding over that.

852
01:23:12.783 --> 01:23:21.835
<v Loretta Smith>I had a family funeral to attend, but I brought this resolution to the Labor and Workforce Committee on September 25th for one important reason.

853
01:23:22.573 --> 01:23:23.536
<v Loretta Smith>The city must conduct Yes.

854
01:23:23.712 --> 01:23:30.319
<v Loretta Smith>The council has directed the city to conduct disparity studies to support our contracting practices and adherence to Mayor Wilson's executive order.

855
01:23:31.248 --> 01:23:39.106
<v Loretta Smith>That requires analysis of the knowledge, skills, abilities, and other qualifications of the contractors competing for projects.

856
01:23:39.988 --> 01:23:48.231
<v Loretta Smith>When we discuss disparities in government contracting and procurement, we aren't talking about mere differences in how government contracts are awarded.

857
01:23:48.649 --> 01:23:54.503
<v Loretta Smith>We're talking about Who are, are the awarded— who awarded those contracts?

858
01:23:55.064 --> 01:23:59.091
<v Loretta Smith>And in many cases, the recipients are not members of communities of color.

859
01:24:00.021 --> 01:24:13.993
<v Loretta Smith>Disparities arise when contracts are awarded based on factors other than the applicant's qualifications and ability to do the work, often due to bias based on a person's race, ethnicity, and sex.

860
01:24:15.100 --> 01:24:17.489
<v Loretta Smith>Discrimination on the basis of race, Councilmember Herbold.

861
01:24:17.489 --> 01:24:17.489
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

862
01:24:17.489 --> 01:24:25.448
<v Loretta Smith>Discrimination based on sex, ethnicity, religion, or other protected classes in government contracting is illegal under the Civil Rights Act.

863
01:24:25.448 --> 01:24:33.930
<v Loretta Smith>I still strive for that day when discrimination against women and people of color has disappeared.

864
01:24:34.609 --> 01:24:43.670
<v Loretta Smith>But until that day, disparity studies are an essential and necessary tool for identifying discrimination in government contracting and procurement.

865
01:24:44.264 --> 01:24:44.764
<v Loretta Smith>Procurement.

866
01:24:45.037 --> 01:24:48.119
<v Loretta Smith>That is why I brought forward this resolution.

867
01:24:48.248 --> 01:25:05.051
<v Loretta Smith>I believe this is the work required of us at this moment, at this time, in this very volatile, uh, kind of federal, uh, reign of, of, of tyranny on cities and states as it relates to, uh, DEI.

868
01:25:06.493 --> 01:25:19.627
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, the other piece is that I have to bring to the clerk's attention is that either we sent you the wrong updated, uh, resolution for the disparity study, um, and that was put online.

869
01:25:19.739 --> 01:25:25.109
<v Loretta Smith>We have to amend the current, uh, resolution that's online, and I'd like to do that.

870
01:25:25.320 --> 01:25:28.166
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know if this is the time to do that, um, Madam President.

871
01:25:29.020 --> 01:25:38.908
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, why don't you wait until we hear the committee staff summary and the overview, and then we'll have you move an amendment before we take public testimony.

872
01:25:38.957 --> 01:25:39.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that okay, Councilor?

873
01:25:39.997 --> 01:25:40.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, excellent.

874
01:25:42.176 --> 01:25:43.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, should we move to that?

875
01:25:46.099 --> 01:25:46.212
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

876
01:25:46.309 --> 01:25:47.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Cook, thank you for joining us.

877
01:25:48.021 --> 01:25:51.465
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we went a little faster than folks were expecting on some other items.

878
01:25:51.561 --> 01:25:53.292
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize, but I'm glad you're here.

879
01:25:53.663 --> 01:25:54.212
<v Jamie Dunphy>My apologies.

880
01:25:54.729 --> 01:26:00.994
<v Jamie Dunphy>Madam President, Councilors, for the record, Craig Cook, Council Operations Policy Analyst and staff to the Labor and Workforce Development Committee.

881
01:26:01.657 --> 01:26:12.395
<v Jamie Dunphy>The resolution before you, document number 2025-13, 377 was heard in the Labor and Workforce Development Committee on September 25th, where it was referred to council with the recommendation to be adopted.

882
01:26:12.957 --> 01:26:19.657
<v Jamie Dunphy>The resolution directs the city administrator to initiate 2 studies to evaluate disparities in city contracting and workforce participation.

883
01:26:20.314 --> 01:26:28.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>It requests the city administrator engage a qualified consultant to perform these analyses and directs that the studies be conducted in a manner emphasizing community engagement.

884
01:26:29.131 --> 01:26:45.068
<v Jamie Dunphy>The amended resolution sets the deadline for the city administrator to the resolution acknowledges that funding for the requested studies must be requested in the 2025 fall technical adjustment ordinance and that work cannot begin until funding is identified.

885
01:26:46.539 --> 01:27:00.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>The resolution also commits council to supporting the city administrator in utilizing the findings of the disparity study to inform policies and practice— practices that promote equitable access to contracting and workforce opportunities for all Portland residents.

886
01:27:00.880 --> 01:27:09.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>The full impact statement on the item includes information on financial and budgetary impacts, economic and real estate development impacts, and community impacts and community involvement.

887
01:27:09.840 --> 01:27:23.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>There was one amendment in committee adopted during the September 25th committee meeting, which changed the deadline for the requested report from March 1st, 2026 to December 31st, 2026.

888
01:27:23.279 --> 01:27:26.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>One person provided verbal testimony in advance of committee action.

889
01:27:26.380 --> 01:27:53.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>General themes included importance of having a diverse, robust, and professionally trained workforce, strategic pathways to ensure equitable workforce development in light of Mayor Wilson's executive order on compliance with nondiscrimination laws, EO 2025-01, insight from disparity studies to center workers who wouldn't otherwise have equal access to opportunities, previous studies that were requested by council but not funded, and exploring working with Prosper Portland and others to ensure funding for studies.

890
01:28:00.939 --> 01:28:09.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I just want to add that the discussion at committee was very robust.

891
01:28:09.578 --> 01:28:18.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think what one of the themes that came up is we reaffirmed the importance in this moment not to sort of shy away from our values commitments in the city, but to invest in our communities.

892
01:28:18.779 --> 01:28:19.005
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

893
01:28:19.690 --> 01:28:36.692
<v Jamie Dunphy>In the studies that we need to do to say without a doubt we are justified in saying we do think that our procurement policies and our contracting policies should be— should try to correct previous harms.

894
01:28:37.367 --> 01:28:38.154
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so we had that discussion.

895
01:28:40.185 --> 01:28:46.929
<v Jamie Dunphy>All committee members present voted to sort of Co-sponsor this resolution.

896
01:28:46.976 --> 01:28:54.842
<v Jamie Dunphy>So this was a very unanimous committee-based approach, and we were just really excited to bring this forward.

897
01:28:55.710 --> 01:29:08.457
<v Jamie Dunphy>One of the things that we did talk about during that meeting was how that there are also intersectional disparities that emerge for people of color, women, the LGBT community.

898
01:29:08.585 --> 01:29:13.573
<v Jamie Dunphy>So this is, this is far-sweeping work, and it's important that we refund the money to pay for it.

899
01:29:13.983 --> 01:29:16.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that's, I think, all I needed to add to that.

900
01:29:18.649 --> 01:29:19.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

901
01:29:21.010 --> 01:29:27.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, are there any questions for— about— are there any questions about our committee staff summary or any technical questions?

902
01:29:31.507 --> 01:29:32.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos.

903
01:29:36.122 --> 01:29:36.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

904
01:29:37.158 --> 01:29:39.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, I have a couple of technical questions.

905
01:29:40.488 --> 01:29:44.898
<v Loretta Smith>So first, thank you to Councilor Smith for bringing this forward.

906
01:29:44.945 --> 01:29:47.929
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think this is super important, especially in this day and age.

907
01:29:47.993 --> 01:30:06.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so, um, I think that's why my questions are about just trying to understand first, given that the last city disparity study was done in 2009, I guess I'm wondering why it took so long to revisit the work, uh, and how we can ensure that studies are happening on a more regular cycle moving forward.

908
01:30:06.752 --> 01:30:09.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know who that question needs to to be directed at though?

909
01:30:09.256 --> 01:30:10.798
<v Loretta Smith>Who would that go to, Councilor?

910
01:30:11.104 --> 01:30:18.301
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you for the question because I think it was the previous, it had to be the previous council and mayor.

911
01:30:18.479 --> 01:30:25.371
<v Loretta Smith>And I don't think we can talk about all the things that should have been done and could have been done by previous councils.

912
01:30:26.109 --> 01:30:34.127
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that the important thing is that we have decided to deal with this in this council this quickly.

913
01:30:34.786 --> 01:30:42.280
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, I am actually going to put a first amendment in to say that we need to have the report by May 31st and not December.

914
01:30:42.826 --> 01:30:56.484
<v Loretta Smith>And the reason why I say May 31st is that we have to have this information before we go into the next fiscal year, or we'll be in limbo for 2 fiscal years before we actually have the diversity data on contracting.

915
01:30:56.564 --> 01:31:00.577
<v Loretta Smith>So, um, that— so I— so to answer that question, I don't know why they didn't want to do it.

916
01:31:00.625 --> 01:31:17.020
<v Loretta Smith>You have to go talk to all those folks and ask why they didn't do it, because they were very, uh, pro-minority contractors and, uh, supporters of, of DEI and equity and all those things that, that, um, try to make sure that we're equitable as a government.

917
01:31:17.117 --> 01:31:18.064
<v Loretta Smith>So I don't know.

918
01:31:18.145 --> 01:31:21.002
<v Loretta Smith>I won't even try to, uh, respond for them.

919
01:31:21.597 --> 01:31:22.256
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

920
01:31:22.545 --> 01:31:28.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, yeah, I, I appreciate that context, but I think then more specifically, let me ask this.

921
01:31:28.327 --> 01:31:28.761
<v Loretta Smith>If the—.

922
01:31:29.082 --> 01:31:35.395
<v Jamie Dunphy>If they authorized this funding for 2022 and it was never done, what happened to those specific dollars?

923
01:31:35.507 --> 01:31:36.618
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that an answer that I can get?

924
01:31:36.698 --> 01:31:38.163
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I see that Jonas is out, so—.

925
01:31:38.243 --> 01:31:39.304
<v Jamie Dunphy>For 2022?

926
01:31:39.673 --> 01:31:43.594
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, so that was what I understood, that they had authorized—.

927
01:31:43.594 --> 01:31:48.078
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe that we have Haley Blonsky here able to answer some of these questions.

928
01:31:48.573 --> 01:31:48.802
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

929
01:31:53.985 --> 01:31:54.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hello, Council.

930
01:31:54.707 --> 01:31:56.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For the record, my name is Haley Blonsley.

931
01:31:56.394 --> 01:32:00.505
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm a senior project manager for the city operations service area.

932
01:32:00.746 --> 01:32:05.738
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In answer to your question, there were never funds allocated to the disparity study.

933
01:32:06.349 --> 01:32:09.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was just the, the resolve to do the study.

934
01:32:09.256 --> 01:32:15.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was wanting to act upon it, and then those funds were never actually realized in the budget process.

935
01:32:15.436 --> 01:32:17.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so that's why the study wasn't conducted.

936
01:32:18.006 --> 01:32:28.938
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are, are our understanding of this current item is that council intends, and we do have an item within the fall TAO, to have funding recognized for this.

937
01:32:29.065 --> 01:32:32.046
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so that was the major hangup for the previous council.

938
01:32:32.367 --> 01:32:33.746
<v Jamie Dunphy>And how much funding is it?

939
01:32:34.354 --> 01:32:36.662
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The funding in the fall TAO, so it's a 2-part—.

940
01:32:36.662 --> 01:32:37.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>$450,000.

941
01:32:37.639 --> 01:32:38.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, $450,000.

942
01:32:39.002 --> 01:32:42.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that's for both contracts and workforce, so it's 2-part.

943
01:32:42.766 --> 01:32:43.423
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you.

944
01:32:43.569 --> 01:32:45.251
<v Loretta Smith>That's all, Council President.

945
01:32:45.572 --> 01:32:57.083
<v Loretta Smith>Madam President, and the reason why it was $450,000, and the orig— the original reason why I, I pulled it from the, from the original, um, council date, committee date, was because I thought it was going to cost $2 million.

946
01:32:57.854 --> 01:33:12.951
<v Loretta Smith>And then I learned after talking to, um, our procurement, um, director that it was— we were going to get a pretty good deal because of the partnership that they were going to do with Prosper Portland, who was doing another similar um, disparity study.

947
01:33:13.210 --> 01:33:16.952
<v Loretta Smith>So that's why it's only $450,000.

948
01:33:17.324 --> 01:33:18.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for clarifying that, Councilor.

949
01:33:18.847 --> 01:33:20.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos, thank you for the questions.

950
01:33:20.810 --> 01:33:21.907
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

951
01:33:25.761 --> 01:33:26.971
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, thank you, Madam President.

952
01:33:27.052 --> 01:33:42.494
<v Jamie Dunphy>My question, it was related to— we had, um, and it's probably a procurement question, um, or I might put, uh, DC Abiri on the spot here, but, uh, the this is based on the testimony we got in the, in the, um, public communications as well.

953
01:33:43.104 --> 01:33:45.252
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also got an email from a different constituent.

954
01:33:45.349 --> 01:33:56.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was about whether or not the prime contractor development program is entirely being ended, uh, and if we could just get that confirmed, and, and if so, a reason why, uh, for that.

955
01:33:57.617 --> 01:34:00.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we have somebody here to speak to procurement.

956
01:34:00.984 --> 01:34:04.078
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, Council President, Council Vice President, councilors.

957
01:34:04.497 --> 01:34:12.975
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal, actually yesterday I held a convening, the first meeting to revamp the Prime Contractor Development Program with all parties being present.

958
01:34:13.859 --> 01:34:18.983
<v Jamie Dunphy>But that did, of course, we depended upon funding to be able to stand it completely up in terms of support.

959
01:34:19.467 --> 01:34:26.476
<v Jamie Dunphy>That also includes everything, everything was discussed including risk support, bonding, and insurance.

960
01:34:28.086 --> 01:34:32.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>So being, Revamped, not being ended.

961
01:34:33.164 --> 01:34:34.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was never ended.

962
01:34:34.360 --> 01:34:42.484
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was paused due to funding and the fact that the pool was so small and it was always so lenient to a certain demographic and was not diverse.

963
01:34:44.829 --> 01:34:47.667
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then my other question is more of a technical question for the clerk.

964
01:34:47.908 --> 01:34:56.228
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just wanted to note that in committee, both myself and Councilor Green indicated a desire to become co-sponsors on this.

965
01:34:56.277 --> 01:35:07.925
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm very glad that I was, but I just wanted to make sure I daylighted that in case that's still possible to do, uh, just for the, the eventual historical record on this, because I know Councilor Green supported it very strongly in committee as well.

966
01:35:09.889 --> 01:35:10.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

967
01:35:11.595 --> 01:35:14.595
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, if you'd like that to be added, why don't you send a note to the clerk?

968
01:35:15.454 --> 01:35:16.283
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

969
01:35:17.369 --> 01:35:18.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Madam President.

970
01:35:19.430 --> 01:35:21.087
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, thank you, Councilor Smith.

971
01:35:21.152 --> 01:35:26.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm very supportive but I do have some questions because I'm also really concerned about the budget.

972
01:35:26.997 --> 01:35:31.949
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm— this is what's keeping me up at night as we start to think about '26-'27.

973
01:35:34.170 --> 01:35:39.483
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just have a couple questions for you and Councilor Green potentially.

974
01:35:42.091 --> 01:35:47.759
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You mentioned the Port of Portland and the State of Oregon have done disparity studies in—.

975
01:35:47.759 --> 01:35:56.188
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, the Port of Portland Portland, and the latest one that was done in 2023 or 2022 was done by the state of Oregon.

976
01:35:56.640 --> 01:36:01.042
<v Loretta Smith>So I originally asked, could we use that as our baseline?

977
01:36:01.621 --> 01:36:11.706
<v Loretta Smith>And in the committee, and I was told by former DCA Morrissey that we could not, that we were not able to use someone else's disparity study.

978
01:36:11.837 --> 01:36:14.270
<v Loretta Smith>It was a statewide study, not thank you.

979
01:36:14.318 --> 01:36:19.439
<v Loretta Smith>So the study was not exclusive to Portland, but a lot of their disparities came from the Portland area.

980
01:36:20.257 --> 01:36:37.788
<v Loretta Smith>So that being said, in order for us to be right with the world and, um, being able to, uh, protect ourselves from the federal government, we wanted to make sure that we had, uh, disparity studies that were specific to the city of Portland and our procurement practices and what we were doing.

981
01:36:38.382 --> 01:36:41.577
<v Loretta Smith>And so that is why I'm supporting this, and that's why I put it forward.

982
01:36:42.057 --> 01:36:52.710
<v Loretta Smith>And the other reason, you know, shortly after that we learned that there, there possibly is a budget gap, and I thought, oh my God, so I can't put this on because we don't have any money for this.

983
01:36:53.463 --> 01:37:03.842
<v Loretta Smith>But, um, after learning that this was going to be recommended in the TAO, and it's for $450,000, and, um, that's a decision that we're going to have to make when that comes before us.

984
01:37:03.890 --> 01:37:07.788
<v Loretta Smith>But we're going to get a work session today so you can learn a little bit more about it.

985
01:37:07.917 --> 01:37:09.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate that.

986
01:37:09.328 --> 01:37:16.978
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just was wondering if, if there's some way we could build off the, uh, state, um, study, if there's, if there's any way we can use that.

987
01:37:17.042 --> 01:37:25.027
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, I think they are, and I think that, um, Councilor Green is going to add some things that we would be building off of that study.

988
01:37:25.074 --> 01:37:30.222
<v Loretta Smith>So they, they, they, they're going to have a, a good baseline of, um, information.

989
01:37:31.634 --> 01:37:42.814
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, um, let me just ask another question, and maybe this will come up in this afternoon's conversation, but I'm just wondering, um, can we share the cost of this with some other institutions in the region?

990
01:37:43.184 --> 01:37:51.173
<v Loretta Smith>So we're basically sharing the cost with Prosper, and that's why it generally costs— for one disparity study, it generally costs $1 million.

991
01:37:51.927 --> 01:37:52.184
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

992
01:37:52.265 --> 01:37:58.681
<v Loretta Smith>So we are kind of piggybacking off Prosper Portland because they're actually doing a disparity study too.

993
01:37:59.372 --> 01:38:08.761
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that but the folks that are doing theirs, they're giving us a break because it's going to be the same demographic in the same city.

994
01:38:09.498 --> 01:38:11.360
<v Loretta Smith>And that's why we needed to do it so quickly.

995
01:38:11.408 --> 01:38:15.677
<v Loretta Smith>And that's why we wanted to make sure that we put this on our docket.

996
01:38:15.983 --> 01:38:22.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just wondered if maybe we'd ask for some contribution from TriMet or some other government.

997
01:38:22.884 --> 01:38:30.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>TriMet and the county are both pursuing studies within this contract as well alongside us, which is what helped bring our rate down a little bit.

998
01:38:30.720 --> 01:38:31.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, great.

999
01:38:31.622 --> 01:38:32.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good to know.

1000
01:38:32.266 --> 01:38:33.443
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's really good information.

1001
01:38:33.619 --> 01:38:40.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then I just lastly, just because of the cost, and we'll deal with that, we'll talk about that this afternoon, is just if this is something that could be phased.

1002
01:38:40.930 --> 01:38:42.237
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we have to do it all at once?

1003
01:38:42.659 --> 01:38:45.721
<v Loretta Smith>You would want to do it all at once because you need that information.

1004
01:38:46.014 --> 01:38:47.957
<v Loretta Smith>If we phase it in, people change.

1005
01:38:48.119 --> 01:38:52.556
<v Loretta Smith>And I imagine, Procurement Director—.

1006
01:38:52.556 --> 01:38:54.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>The cost would be— The cost would increase.

1007
01:38:55.059 --> 01:38:57.255
<v Loretta Smith>The cost would increase, exactly.

1008
01:38:57.911 --> 01:39:12.074
<v Loretta Smith>And I imagine the people will be different too, because if there's, there's some contracts that we're not putting out, and some of due to that delay, it's probably going to cause a lot of people to go out of business.

1009
01:39:12.747 --> 01:39:18.581
<v Loretta Smith>So as we're trying to phase things in, it may phase some companies right out of, out of business.

1010
01:39:19.140 --> 01:39:21.752
<v Loretta Smith>I think we need to do this quickly and we need to do it now.

1011
01:39:22.347 --> 01:39:23.076
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you.

1012
01:39:23.253 --> 01:39:32.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>May I, may I also add that policies will be derived from this actual study, and our practices will align with those policies as well.

1013
01:39:32.882 --> 01:39:38.817
<v Jamie Dunphy>So this is, this is probably very important as we realign in engagement with the executive order.

1014
01:39:44.344 --> 01:39:45.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor, is that all?

1015
01:39:47.622 --> 01:39:48.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

1016
01:39:50.208 --> 01:39:51.106
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Madam President.

1017
01:39:51.507 --> 01:40:00.774
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just wanted to weigh in on the deadline that's in the resolution and just provide some context for the rest of the council on what we talked about during the committee.

1018
01:40:02.247 --> 01:40:18.009
<v Jamie Dunphy>The original deadline was amended based upon a conversation I think that Councilor Novick and I think also Councilor Kanal had engaged with, with Hayley about the feasibility of the timeline given that we would find the money in the TAO.

1019
01:40:19.087 --> 01:40:27.277
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think the spirit of that conversation— and feel free to step in at any point, Councilor Novick— was that we want the deadlines in the resolution to be achievable.

1020
01:40:27.828 --> 01:40:42.673
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so if we thought that— I think the original one was March— if we thought we wouldn't secure the funding for this disparity study work until after resolution of the fall TAO, that places us in a very difficult timeline to execute and get a final report by March.

1021
01:40:44.154 --> 01:40:52.402
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we want to make sure the work is good and not, you know, sort of just a, oh, you know, deadlines are deadlines, we don't take them seriously in our resolution.

1022
01:40:52.498 --> 01:40:55.015
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that's why the deadline was shifted back.

1023
01:40:56.774 --> 01:41:08.657
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think Haley assured us that it's entirely likely that we would get the results of this much earlier than the December one, but I just wanted to lay that out for folks as we talk about this part of the—.

1024
01:41:08.657 --> 01:41:08.755
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1025
01:41:12.779 --> 01:41:13.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green?

1026
01:41:14.320 --> 01:41:42.119
<v Loretta Smith>With a sense of urgency, understanding that we have to make sure that our policies are lined up before next year's fiscal year, this gives us the urgency when we start looking at that, um, at our work session and all those set-asides and those carryovers and new money, that, that this is one that has to pass because this is going to impact all the hundreds of millions of dollars that we contract out into the community and that we accept from the federal government.

1027
01:41:42.573 --> 01:41:46.466
<v Loretta Smith>So this is one of those must-dos.

1028
01:41:47.640 --> 01:41:55.479
<v Loretta Smith>So if we can push it back to December, I think that just pushes back our sense of urgency of how important this is to what we do.

1029
01:41:55.577 --> 01:41:56.948
<v Loretta Smith>We're infrastructure government.

1030
01:41:57.270 --> 01:41:58.516
<v Loretta Smith>We do contracts all the time.

1031
01:41:58.564 --> 01:42:00.152
<v Loretta Smith>That's how we make our money.

1032
01:42:00.411 --> 01:42:10.237
<v Loretta Smith>And We got a $2 billion water project out there that is unprecedented, and we cannot allow this to, you know, sit until December 31st.

1033
01:42:10.541 --> 01:42:11.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>I mean, I tend to agree with you.

1034
01:42:11.761 --> 01:42:19.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>I guess I would ask, is it possible— we've got some folks from the Bureau staff up here— can we— can you weigh in on the timeline stuff given what we've heard from Councilor Smith?

1035
01:42:20.824 --> 01:42:25.317
<v Jamie Dunphy>I cannot definitively say that we can have it by March.

1036
01:42:25.942 --> 01:42:30.195
<v Jamie Dunphy>That was the original estimated date when I first engaged with the contractor.

1037
01:42:30.613 --> 01:42:35.622
<v Jamie Dunphy>That may slip until probably at the— probably toward the end of the fiscal year.

1038
01:42:35.752 --> 01:42:42.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>I can definitely reengage with the contractor and see if we can expedite some of the activities, and I can come back and report that.

1039
01:42:42.253 --> 01:42:49.528
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, even if we said June 15th or May 31st, I mean, at least it gives us an opportunity.

1040
01:42:49.961 --> 01:42:52.819
<v Loretta Smith>We have some cushion in there if we can get this passed in the town.

1041
01:42:54.634 --> 01:43:06.692
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think that that's kind of the crux of it, is as soon as we get the TAO passed and that is part of the package, it would allow us to go execute that contract based on the timetable that the contractor provided.

1042
01:43:07.141 --> 01:43:16.502
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They're estimating about a month of preparatory work and then 2 to 7 months— for month 2 to 7, doing the actual surveying and data collection.

1043
01:43:16.935 --> 01:43:20.034
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then they're estimating about a month and a half for their own analysis.

1044
01:43:20.082 --> 01:43:30.037
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So depending on— we could go have a conversation with them acknowledging this is the scope for both the city's 2 studies as well as the county and TriMet.

1045
01:43:30.103 --> 01:43:37.858
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we could also talk about kind of order of operations with them of, you know, what analysis they can kind of prioritize first to get it faster.

1046
01:43:38.547 --> 01:43:43.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I don't see it as coming in March just from an execution of contract standpoint.

1047
01:43:43.413 --> 01:43:43.895
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1048
01:43:43.992 --> 01:43:47.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if we're looking at June, I think we would just need some time to contract.

1049
01:43:47.591 --> 01:43:49.069
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, I can compromise on this.

1050
01:43:49.198 --> 01:44:00.829
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, we'll leave the date at December, but everybody at this table right now understanding that it is urgent that we try to get this information back before we pass fiscal year '26-'27.

1051
01:44:01.488 --> 01:44:12.273
<v Loretta Smith>And so we'll leave it as is, but there is a sense of urgency, particularly if we pass the TAO that has the resources to pay for this yes.

1052
01:44:12.369 --> 01:44:16.230
<v Loretta Smith>Absolutely.

1053
01:44:16.489 --> 01:44:16.780
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1054
01:44:19.154 --> 01:44:20.458
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick?

1055
01:44:20.943 --> 01:44:21.136
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1056
01:44:22.394 --> 01:44:38.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>I confess that I should know this because we just did have the TAO in finance the other day, but does the current TAO proposal from the administration assume a $450,000 expenditure for this, or would we have to It is in the towel.

1057
01:44:38.855 --> 01:44:39.583
<v Loretta Smith>It is in the towel.

1058
01:44:39.746 --> 01:44:39.923
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1059
01:44:41.511 --> 01:44:45.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, and we now just agreed that we're going to, we're going to leave it at, we're going to leave it at December.

1060
01:44:45.898 --> 01:44:47.041
<v Loretta Smith>We'll leave the December date.

1061
01:44:47.170 --> 01:44:56.233
<v Loretta Smith>Um, you know, but with the understanding that I am going to be calling and being some of you all's new best friends.

1062
01:44:59.542 --> 01:45:00.329
<v Loretta Smith>We look forward to it.

1063
01:45:00.771 --> 01:45:01.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's not very unique.

1064
01:45:04.341 --> 01:45:06.639
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can I get clarity?

1065
01:45:06.752 --> 01:45:11.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Does the TAO include 400 or 450?

1066
01:45:11.090 --> 01:45:14.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because I'm hearing and seeing those different numbers in different places.

1067
01:45:14.238 --> 01:45:15.507
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe it's 450.

1068
01:45:15.668 --> 01:45:22.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's look to Jonas so that we can get some accurate information maybe about that and also about how that number relates.

1069
01:45:22.180 --> 01:45:31.640
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think Councilor Novick was talking about the presentation in finance, how that number relates to yeah, thank you, Council President.

1070
01:45:31.640 --> 01:45:32.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council.

1071
01:45:32.260 --> 01:45:37.289
<v Jamie Dunphy>For the record, Jonas Biery, City's Chief Financial Officer, sitting in for the City Administrator today.

1072
01:45:38.579 --> 01:45:48.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>The amount that's in the ordinances currently filed, which was heard by Finance Committee yesterday and will come back for final vote, I believe is $400,000.

1073
01:45:50.680 --> 01:45:53.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we have a little work to do to figure out where the other $50,000 is coming is from.

1074
01:45:53.199 --> 01:45:53.239
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1075
01:45:53.270 --> 01:45:56.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>Coming from, why that wasn't reflected in the TAO.

1076
01:45:56.789 --> 01:45:57.529
<v Jamie Dunphy>But we'll be ready to come back.

1077
01:45:57.529 --> 01:46:03.189
<v Loretta Smith>And maybe you're right, CFO Biery, maybe it is just the $400,000.

1078
01:46:03.210 --> 01:46:03.859
<v Loretta Smith>I thought it was $450,000.

1079
01:46:04.390 --> 01:46:12.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, we'll do a little digging to make sure that we have either the right number in the final TAO that passes or we make sure we're aware of the actual costs and have—.

1080
01:46:12.670 --> 01:46:14.550
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, excellent.

1081
01:46:14.550 --> 01:46:16.609
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, did you get your question answered?

1082
01:46:17.369 --> 01:46:18.449
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think so.

1083
01:46:19.292 --> 01:46:32.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can I also just clarify, I know that we'll be talking more about the TAO later, and for the $400,000, $450,000, that will need to be voted on separately as an amendment to the ordinance, which is the TAO.

1084
01:46:32.779 --> 01:46:38.313
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So a vote for this resolution would be kind of a value statement of saying that we support this?

1085
01:46:38.360 --> 01:46:38.746
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

1086
01:46:39.403 --> 01:46:40.782
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, it won't be an extra.

1087
01:46:40.926 --> 01:46:42.787
<v Loretta Smith>It's a part of the whole TAO package.

1088
01:46:43.011 --> 01:46:45.613
<v Loretta Smith>This is not an amendment to the to the amended TAO.

1089
01:46:46.466 --> 01:46:47.722
<v Loretta Smith>It is already in the TAO.

1090
01:46:49.059 --> 01:46:53.663
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you, Councilor.

1091
01:46:53.712 --> 01:46:54.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan?

1092
01:46:54.453 --> 01:46:55.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, uh, thank you, Madam President.

1093
01:46:56.003 --> 01:46:59.345
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just first of all want to thank you, Councilor Smith, for bringing this forward.

1094
01:46:59.926 --> 01:47:15.694
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also just want to acknowledge, um, you, Director Donaldson, and former Director Taylor, rest in peace, that I assumed there was something in the budget because we looked at this data all the time, and it's because the former council had to look at every contract and so it was brought up frequently.

1095
01:47:15.742 --> 01:47:18.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was so helpful, at least in the procurement space.

1096
01:47:18.295 --> 01:47:25.087
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I just want to acknowledge the hard work that your group has been doing on this for several years, and I really appreciate it.

1097
01:47:25.680 --> 01:47:26.306
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1098
01:47:26.387 --> 01:47:26.628
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1099
01:47:26.868 --> 01:47:29.743
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I get why it's important to formalize this at this time.

1100
01:47:30.402 --> 01:47:30.595
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1101
01:47:30.738 --> 01:47:32.440
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1102
01:47:32.907 --> 01:47:34.399
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just pulled up the DP for this.

1103
01:47:34.528 --> 01:47:35.314
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 450.

1104
01:47:36.279 --> 01:47:36.615
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1105
01:47:36.841 --> 01:47:37.899
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Hayley.

1106
01:47:37.965 --> 01:47:44.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So maybe we can— Figure out that discrepancy before TAO comes to a vote to council.

1107
01:47:44.751 --> 01:47:45.627
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can I ask one more question?

1108
01:47:46.140 --> 01:47:47.765
<v Jamie Dunphy>'Cause she's—.

1109
01:47:48.104 --> 01:47:49.037
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 4:50 in there.

1110
01:47:49.697 --> 01:47:51.065
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for clarifying, Councilor.

1111
01:47:51.323 --> 01:47:51.935
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

1112
01:47:52.127 --> 01:47:53.497
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, another question.

1113
01:47:53.882 --> 01:47:59.351
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, you know, I often don't know the answer to the question that I ask, which makes me different than some politicians, but I do have a question.

1114
01:47:59.932 --> 01:48:03.065
<v Jamie Dunphy>Isn't there a fund that went from the city to Prosper to help with this?

1115
01:48:07.122 --> 01:48:08.439
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not that I'm aware of.

1116
01:48:08.551 --> 01:48:08.890
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1117
01:48:09.435 --> 01:48:10.542
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll look into that.

1118
01:48:10.703 --> 01:48:11.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

1119
01:48:11.217 --> 01:48:12.341
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's rusty, but okay.

1120
01:48:12.405 --> 01:48:13.256
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I can do some digging.

1121
01:48:13.594 --> 01:48:16.099
<v Loretta Smith>All right.

1122
01:48:16.179 --> 01:48:16.420
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1123
01:48:16.581 --> 01:48:17.350
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Knoll.

1124
01:48:18.331 --> 01:48:18.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

1125
01:48:18.667 --> 01:48:32.088
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, Councilor Ryan made me remember something, which is that actually on his way out of the role, our former procurement director, Biko Taylor, who yes, rest in peace.

1126
01:48:32.394 --> 01:48:40.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>And by the way, if you wanted to hear more about him, there's December 19th of last year, there was a lot of conversation at the council meeting that I think was instructive.

1127
01:48:42.009 --> 01:48:48.787
<v Jamie Dunphy>But one of his interviews as he was exiting the position at the city was about the need for a disparity study specifically.

1128
01:48:49.460 --> 01:48:52.778
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it's in— if you search his name, I think it's in the Portland Business Journal.

1129
01:48:52.890 --> 01:49:02.796
<v Jamie Dunphy>But just that, that's, I think, particularly relevant that there is there's so many little spots along the way from so many different leaders of the city talking about the necessity for this action to be taken.

1130
01:49:03.359 --> 01:49:15.372
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, and I appreciate the perspective from Councilor Ryan as well as Councilor Smith on this and, and all the different spots, but I think we could find hundreds of times where we said we needed to do this in the past, um, since 2009.

1131
01:49:16.145 --> 01:49:16.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it's time we do it.

1132
01:49:20.220 --> 01:49:21.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1133
01:49:21.668 --> 01:49:29.622
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we do have public testimony, but I know that it is helpful for the public to know what amendments are coming before we take public testimony.

1134
01:49:30.778 --> 01:49:33.506
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, do you have an amendment you'd like to put on the record?

1135
01:49:34.292 --> 01:49:35.256
<v Jamie Dunphy>I do, Madam President.

1136
01:49:35.577 --> 01:49:42.189
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I'd like to put on the record, and this is filed already on the clerk's website, but I had some conversations with council—.

1137
01:49:42.189 --> 01:49:44.146
<v Loretta Smith>Could I do mine first and then you amend mine?

1138
01:49:44.579 --> 01:49:46.859
<v Loretta Smith>The new— because I have to amend the entire—.

1139
01:49:47.453 --> 01:49:50.646
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Well, let's, let's let Councilor Green put his amendment on the record.

1140
01:49:50.743 --> 01:49:52.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>He has the floor right okay.

1141
01:49:52.908 --> 01:49:55.570
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then Councilor Smith, why don't we come to you for amendments as well?

1142
01:49:56.292 --> 01:50:34.565
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll note that, Councilor, it looks like the amended version is inclusive of what you— okay, so anyway, so what I'm doing here in the amendment is speaking to some of the written testimony I received from some of our labor partners that wanted to make sure that we, as we do this disparity study, we're capturing sort of all relevant data that might have outcomes and impacts on the outcomes In particular, that we're also looking at the impacts of project labor agreements and community benefit agreements on disparity outcomes, and that we're also taking a sort of race and gender look as well, because that's also a piece that's pretty determinative.

1143
01:50:34.613 --> 01:50:55.895
<v Jamie Dunphy>So in the now therefore be it resolved section of the resolution, I'm adding under item 1 where it says utilizing data from the State of Oregon, the Port of Portland, Portland and Prosper Portland, as well as obtaining— I'm just inserting any relevant data specific to the City of Portland to make sure we have an expansive universe of data on which to pull.

1144
01:50:57.132 --> 01:51:14.622
<v Jamie Dunphy>In subitem 2, I'm just sort of appending at the very end of that procurement directive, I'm saying that in addition to conducting disparity studies to perform the analysis, ensuring that the study adheres to best practices and legal standards.

1145
01:51:14.912 --> 01:51:21.243
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm adding comma, with attention paid to the potential for disparities to emerge from the intersection of race and gender.

1146
01:51:23.484 --> 01:51:37.411
<v Jamie Dunphy>I then add another bullet after item 3 so that becomes item 4 that says that the studies analyze impacts of project labor agreements or community benefits agreements on disparity outcomes.

1147
01:51:38.319 --> 01:51:38.707
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that's it.

1148
01:51:39.056 --> 01:51:39.685
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that's what I'm adding.

1149
01:51:40.587 --> 01:51:50.627
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think what this does is it just adds other relevant information for us to look at and doesn't take anything away from the core value of the resolution.

1150
01:51:50.675 --> 01:51:53.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I would ask the councilor to be friendly to this amendment.

1151
01:51:55.173 --> 01:52:06.778
<v Loretta Smith>I am friendly to that amendment, but it may not be amending what you just said because I don't think the council president understood that it is an entirely different resolution that I'm gonna be amending.

1152
01:52:07.382 --> 01:52:11.944
<v Loretta Smith>And so you're amending my second resolution, not the first.

1153
01:52:12.121 --> 01:52:18.161
<v Jamie Dunphy>The thing that's attached to the website is, is going to be consistent with what you're, what you're going to offer.

1154
01:52:18.529 --> 01:52:27.878
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, let's hear Councilor Smith's amendment, and if we need to do a little wordsmithing to make the 2 amendments work together, we can certainly do that during discussion.

1155
01:52:27.943 --> 01:52:32.006
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right now we just need to get things on the record so that we can take public testimony.

1156
01:52:32.118 --> 01:52:42.529
<v Loretta Smith>Go ahead, Councilor So I'd like, in the first, uh, in the resolution that I have, I'd like to, um, scratch the first line that says research disparities in public contracting.

1157
01:52:46.029 --> 01:52:47.220
<v Loretta Smith>Clerk Keelan, can you see that?

1158
01:52:52.649 --> 01:52:56.770
<v Loretta Smith>Striking research disparities in public contracting workforce and employment.

1159
01:52:56.948 --> 01:52:57.578
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

1160
01:52:58.356 --> 01:53:01.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are you proposing to amend the title of the item?

1161
01:53:01.761 --> 01:53:03.908
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, it's— yes, yes, ma'am.

1162
01:53:06.520 --> 01:53:11.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can we amend a title of an item and still have it be that same item?

1163
01:53:17.657 --> 01:53:25.740
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, I would like to check my answer, but I believe the answer is if it's on the same subject and it still follows a single subject rule, it's appropriate okay, thank you.

1164
01:53:26.387 --> 01:53:37.033
<v Loretta Smith>And so it will read, a resolution of the Portland City Council Labor and Workforce Development Committee.

1165
01:53:38.440 --> 01:53:54.386
<v Loretta Smith>We're going to scratch the first whereas, and the title is going to be the new title, Resolution to Initiate 2 Disparity Studies on City Contracting and Work Force participation.

1166
01:53:55.783 --> 01:53:57.115
<v Loretta Smith>We have a new whereas.

1167
01:53:57.871 --> 01:54:18.894
<v Loretta Smith>Whereas the City of Portland spends millions of dollars each year on procurement of goods, services, and construction, and— Whereas the city has a responsibility to ensure its public dollars are spent in a way that benefits the community it serves, semicolon, and Next.

1168
01:54:18.974 --> 01:54:46.645
<v Loretta Smith>Whereas the City of Portland is committed to advancing equity, anti-racism, and inclusive economic opportunities through its contracting and workforce policies, semicolon, and whereas executive order to the city employees to comply with all federal law, parentheses, EO 2025-01, Aye.

1169
01:54:48.407 --> 01:55:33.637
<v Loretta Smith>Paragraph requires compliance with all applicable federal civil rights and nondiscrimination laws, including, comma, but not limited to the Civil Rights Act of 1964, semicolon, and whereas EO 2025-01 presents an opportunity for exploration into new strategies to support small businesses and develop the local workforce in preparation for participation on public contract opportunities; and whereas, Council has received passionate testimonials from the local small business community in support of the city conducting a disparity study.

1170
01:55:34.313 --> 01:56:27.698
<v Loretta Smith>In addition to improving services In addition to improving access to resources like business technical assistance and workforce development services that support participation on public projects, semicolon, and next, whereas the last disparity study conducted by Procurement Services was completed in 2009, semicolon, and whereas peer cities have invested in conducting a A disparity study at least every 5 years as a best practice, semicolon, and whereas a disparity study would provide updated data about business availability challenges, changes, and enhance the chief procurement officer's ability to accurately assess the efficiency of various procurement programs.

1171
01:56:27.828 --> 01:56:28.296
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

1172
01:56:30.351 --> 01:56:48.554
<v Loretta Smith>Next, whereas a contract disparity study would allow the Chief Procurement Officer to examine the utilization of MBEWESB and other diverse businesses in city construction, professional services, goods and services contracts.

1173
01:56:48.779 --> 01:57:07.690
<v Loretta Smith>And the next, whereas a workforce disparity study would allow the Chief Procurement Officer to evaluate how How construction work hours on city construction contracts are divided among apprentices, workers of color, and women.

1174
01:57:08.123 --> 01:57:26.471
<v Loretta Smith>And the next, whereas the city previously authorized a disparity study through ordinance number 190781, which was passed on April 20th, 2022, to evaluate disparities in contracting and workforce participation.

1175
01:57:27.721 --> 01:57:44.766
<v Loretta Smith>Whereas the city recognizes the importance of conducting a comprehensive disparity study that considers data from the State of Oregon, the Port of Portland, and Prosper Portland to ensure a thorough analysis of disparities in contracting and workforce participation.

1176
01:57:45.583 --> 01:57:50.443
<v Loretta Smith>And whereas Prosper Portland is currently engaged in a disparity study—.

1177
01:57:50.443 --> 01:57:50.779
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilmember Herbold.

1178
01:57:50.891 --> 01:58:15.360
<v Loretta Smith>Study, comma, led by Keen Independent Research to analyze disparities in the utilization of disadvantaged minority woman emerging small and service-disabled veteran-owned businesses, DMWESB SDVS, in its construction-related contracts and public-private partnership agreements.

1179
01:58:16.501 --> 01:58:29.770
<v Loretta Smith>And whereas the State of Oregon has conducted a disparity study, also led by Keene Independent Research, to evaluate disparities in contracting and workforce participation across various state agencies.

1180
01:58:31.409 --> 01:58:31.685
<v Loretta Smith>Let's see.

1181
01:58:31.798 --> 01:58:39.028
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, while you pause there, I am noticing that most of these are the same as what is currently online.

1182
01:58:39.885 --> 01:58:42.835
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do you want to draw our attention just to the differences?

1183
01:58:43.868 --> 01:58:46.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That might be easier than reading through it all.

1184
01:58:46.854 --> 01:58:48.412
<v Loretta Smith>It's not the same.

1185
01:58:48.860 --> 01:58:50.194
<v Loretta Smith>So I can go down.

1186
01:58:50.627 --> 01:58:52.521
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can we get a written copy of the differences?

1187
01:58:52.634 --> 01:58:54.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because this is way too hard to track verbally.

1188
01:58:55.587 --> 01:58:56.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to make sure.

1189
01:58:56.663 --> 01:59:06.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So far I've noted 2 differences, the deletion of the first whereas and the insertion of the word new in the 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6th whereas.

1190
01:59:07.148 --> 01:59:08.994
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But everything else appears to be the same.

1191
01:59:09.777 --> 01:59:18.479
<v Loretta Smith>Whereas the breaks— let me ask you this, um, Keelan, do you have my updated resolution?

1192
01:59:19.385 --> 01:59:22.442
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have what was sent to our office at—.

1193
01:59:22.538 --> 01:59:23.087
<v Loretta Smith>This morning?

1194
01:59:23.202 --> 01:59:24.706
<v Loretta Smith>9:19 This morning.

1195
01:59:25.222 --> 01:59:31.467
<v Loretta Smith>That is the one that is the, the clean copy of the new resolution and all the deletions that are on there?

1196
01:59:32.387 --> 01:59:35.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't, I don't know that it's a strikethrough underline version.

1197
01:59:36.010 --> 01:59:36.542
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's—.

1198
01:59:36.542 --> 01:59:37.926
<v Loretta Smith>You don't have a strikethrough at the bottom?

1199
01:59:39.394 --> 01:59:39.618
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1200
01:59:39.684 --> 01:59:46.560
<v Loretta Smith>So if my staff could send everyone the strikethroughs that you sent me at the bottom.

1201
01:59:48.103 --> 01:59:49.939
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there changes to other whereases?

1202
01:59:50.600 --> 01:59:51.439
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, they're just cut.

1203
01:59:51.505 --> 01:59:52.586
<v Loretta Smith>They're just stricken.

1204
01:59:54.069 --> 01:59:54.328
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1205
01:59:54.408 --> 01:59:56.521
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>From the, um, record.

1206
01:59:57.716 --> 01:59:59.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Which ones are struck from the record?

1207
02:00:00.292 --> 02:00:14.012
<v Loretta Smith>Whereas in December 2024, the White House Council of Economic Advisers published a report and meta-study on racial disparities in government contracting established several important facts.

1208
02:00:14.094 --> 02:00:14.801
<v Loretta Smith>That's stricken.

1209
02:00:15.220 --> 02:00:15.462
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1210
02:00:15.557 --> 02:00:17.619
<v Loretta Smith>And the points under that are stricken.

1211
02:00:17.893 --> 02:00:18.118
<v Loretta Smith>Great.

1212
02:00:18.520 --> 02:00:26.805
<v Loretta Smith>And so we go to, now therefore be it resolved by the Portland City Council Labor and Workforce Committee.

1213
02:00:28.515 --> 02:00:43.604
<v Loretta Smith>One says that the city administrator initiate 2 disparity studies to evaluate disparities in both city contracting and workforce participation utilizing data from the State of Oregon, the Port of Portland, and Prosper Portland.

1214
02:00:44.679 --> 02:01:01.497
<v Loretta Smith>Number 2 says that the city— strike request that and go directly to that— the city administrator, in partnership with the chief procurement officer, engage a qualified consultant with expertise in in conducting the disparity study.

1215
02:01:02.479 --> 02:01:25.863
<v Loretta Smith>Number 3, STRIKE directs that, and begin with that, the disparity studies be conducted in a manner that emphasizes community engagement throughout the process, ensuring that input from historically marginalized communities is STRIKE documented and input reflected in the work.

1216
02:01:25.912 --> 02:01:26.009
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

1217
02:01:26.944 --> 02:01:29.207
<v Loretta Smith>Number 4 is the last strike.

1218
02:01:29.930 --> 02:01:52.279
<v Loretta Smith>Strike request that the city administrator submit a written, written report on— strike that— add that the findings and recommendations of the disparity studies— strike to city council— and add be presented to the Labor and Workforce Development Committee upon completion.

1219
02:01:53.662 --> 02:01:59.653
<v Loretta Smith>And strike and no later than March 1st, 2026.

1220
02:01:59.717 --> 02:02:07.140
<v Loretta Smith>Go down to the next, um, sentence and strike after participation, strike the and.

1221
02:02:08.128 --> 02:02:13.402
<v Loretta Smith>And then there's one more in the next paragraph under the be it further resolved.

1222
02:02:14.518 --> 02:02:18.685
<v Loretta Smith>Before the be it further resolved, work cannot begin until funding is identified.

1223
02:02:18.756 --> 02:02:18.951
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

1224
02:02:21.002 --> 02:02:24.289
<v Loretta Smith>And strike the semicolon and and.

1225
02:02:25.193 --> 02:02:37.256
<v Loretta Smith>Under be it further resolved that, strike City Council Labor and Workforce Development Committee commits to supporting the city administrator.

1226
02:02:38.039 --> 02:02:48.983
<v Loretta Smith>And at the end it says adopted this insert date, strike that, strike the last sentence Portland City Council Labor no, no, no, keep that.

1227
02:02:51.529 --> 02:02:52.306
<v Loretta Smith>So that's finished.

1228
02:02:54.229 --> 02:02:57.042
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I think folks need a written copy of this.

1229
02:02:57.725 --> 02:02:59.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There were a fair amount of changes there.

1230
02:03:00.850 --> 02:03:07.675
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Councilor, if you can try to get a written copy of that to everybody while we listen to public testimony, that would be helpful.

1231
02:03:08.286 --> 02:03:12.693
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I suspect that we are going to see some wordsmithing to this.

1232
02:03:14.492 --> 02:03:14.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yep.

1233
02:03:14.733 --> 02:03:20.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For folks testifying, we have 2 amendments that we expect to be considering.

1234
02:03:20.507 --> 02:03:25.082
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Neither have been officially moved and seconded yet, but we know that they are on the table.

1235
02:03:27.270 --> 02:03:29.761
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Why don't we move to— well, there are 2 hands up.

1236
02:03:29.827 --> 02:03:31.863
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Murillo, did you have a question before we move to public testimony?

1237
02:03:31.912 --> 02:03:32.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Point of information.

1238
02:03:33.149 --> 02:03:46.747
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just want to make a— so, Councilor, the language that you sent me while we're in this session, all of that, unless that has changed since you sent that to me, all of that language is in my amendment.

1239
02:03:46.860 --> 02:03:48.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>So it's already on this website.

1240
02:03:48.836 --> 02:03:53.847
<v Jamie Dunphy>So folks want to read the full complete resolution as it stands with my amendment, that's there.

1241
02:03:54.635 --> 02:03:55.967
<v Loretta Smith>That's the old one, I believe.

1242
02:03:56.161 --> 02:03:59.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's the one you sent me at like 9:38, 9:45 AM.

1243
02:04:00.641 --> 02:04:09.511
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, why don't the two of you figure out if the language that is the base for Councilor Green's amendment is accurate to what you are trying to amend or not.

1244
02:04:09.640 --> 02:04:13.613
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's get that worked out while we hear public testimony so that we can continue moving.

1245
02:04:14.431 --> 02:04:17.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Murillo, did you have a question before we move to public testimony?

1246
02:04:18.117 --> 02:04:21.819
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, no, I was requesting it written so that we could follow this.

1247
02:04:22.042 --> 02:04:32.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is also just going to be another push for me to say that I think that we absolutely need mandatory deadlines for when we submit amendments because doing this on the fly is not good for anybody.

1248
02:04:33.420 --> 02:04:36.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I can't process everything that is being said verbally right now.

1249
02:04:36.880 --> 02:04:38.340
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's just not good governance.

1250
02:04:38.380 --> 02:04:39.460
<v Loretta Smith>You're absolutely right.

1251
02:04:39.460 --> 02:04:41.899
<v Loretta Smith>And what should have happened is—.

1252
02:04:41.899 --> 02:04:43.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hey, Councilor, can I just jump in?

1253
02:04:43.199 --> 02:04:43.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You should have gotten it.

1254
02:04:43.640 --> 02:04:44.880
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's fine.

1255
02:04:44.880 --> 02:04:45.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's keep moving.

1256
02:04:45.539 --> 02:04:46.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's fine.

1257
02:04:46.539 --> 02:04:48.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1258
02:04:49.859 --> 02:04:50.039
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I understand.

1259
02:04:50.039 --> 02:04:52.529
<v Loretta Smith>This was not a yesterday amendment was what I'm trying to say.

1260
02:04:52.539 --> 02:04:53.880
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Understood.

1261
02:04:53.880 --> 02:05:02.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Murillo, you will see a proposal from me soon that includes some posting deadlines for amendments at full council.

1262
02:05:03.474 --> 02:05:10.988
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's move to public testimony so we can hear from members of the public where I suspect we are going to hear requests for additional amendments as well.

1263
02:05:11.983 --> 02:05:15.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for being here and answering some of those more technical questions.

1264
02:05:15.731 --> 02:05:19.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will likely need you back as we consider amendments, so please don't go far.

1265
02:05:20.059 --> 02:05:24.288
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, can you please call up our— We may be able to do it in one panel.

1266
02:05:24.402 --> 02:05:26.184
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Of public testifiers, or do we need 2?

1267
02:05:26.954 --> 02:05:27.934
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Maybe 2.

1268
02:05:28.014 --> 02:05:30.872
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, can you call up our first panel of public testimony?

1269
02:05:31.546 --> 02:05:43.541
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>First up, we have Terrence Hayes, Lauren Bulling, Zach Culver, Randall Friesen, and Lori Wimmer.

1270
02:05:52.920 --> 02:05:53.645
<v Loretta Smith>Terrence.

1271
02:05:53.694 --> 02:05:54.162
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, I can go.

1272
02:05:54.389 --> 02:05:55.018
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank y'all.

1273
02:05:55.438 --> 02:05:55.873
<v Loretta Smith>How you doing?

1274
02:05:55.922 --> 02:05:56.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Terrence Hayes.

1275
02:05:57.376 --> 02:06:03.171
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, Councilor Loretta Smith, I would like to just thank you first for recognizing the need for disparity study.

1276
02:06:03.622 --> 02:06:12.376
<v Jamie Dunphy>As a small business owner that do business with the city, um, I would love to just double down on the fact that there is still a lot of work ahead.

1277
02:06:12.963 --> 02:06:30.103
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, the city has done well in hiring some folks, and I think We need to continue to hire equity officers and people that is focusing on not only making sure that small and minority businesses getting opportunities with the city, but just as importantly, that they're succeeding and they're having success.

1278
02:06:30.198 --> 02:06:38.186
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is very complicated when it comes to small businesses' ability to have success with city and governmental agencies.

1279
02:06:38.300 --> 02:06:39.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's just a fact.

1280
02:06:39.646 --> 02:06:42.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>Every disparity study have continued to say that over and over again.

1281
02:06:42.854 --> 02:06:47.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilmember Again, I would recommend that one of the things that we look into is quick pay.

1282
02:06:47.423 --> 02:06:48.738
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've talked about this before.

1283
02:06:49.042 --> 02:07:02.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>Small companies, especially small minority companies, struggle with city and government contracts because net 30 makes it really complicated to pay your employees on time.

1284
02:07:03.215 --> 02:07:04.657
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would love for that to be a focal point.

1285
02:07:04.753 --> 02:07:05.730
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for your time.

1286
02:07:05.779 --> 02:07:08.697
<v Jamie Dunphy>And again, Councilor Loretta Smith, thank you for bringing this forward.

1287
02:07:08.744 --> 02:07:09.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1288
02:07:09.551 --> 02:07:13.221
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1289
02:07:16.074 --> 02:07:17.175
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, could I have a seat to Lori?

1290
02:07:17.515 --> 02:07:18.697
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1291
02:07:19.474 --> 02:07:20.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning, councilors.

1292
02:07:20.510 --> 02:07:24.233
<v Loretta Smith>For your record, Lori Wimmer representing Northwest Oregon Labor Council.

1293
02:07:24.492 --> 02:07:26.891
<v Loretta Smith>My written testimony is also in your record.

1294
02:07:27.454 --> 02:07:36.081
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, I am pleased to testify this morning to the concepts in the resolution to study racial and sex disparities in city contracting and workforce Thank you.

1295
02:07:36.128 --> 02:07:44.099
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much for your participation, and I hope that you will indulge me in a few suggestions to make this study— these studies more robust and relevant.

1296
02:07:44.872 --> 02:07:54.024
<v Jamie Dunphy>We hope that the purpose of your inquiry is to determine whether the city's diverse values are reflected in worker demographics that public dollars buy.

1297
02:07:55.601 --> 02:08:10.845
<v Jamie Dunphy>That question's worth asking, though, only if we also want to know not just whether BIPOC and female workers, for example, are able to get A job, but whether they're hired for a good job, meaning family wage job.

1298
02:08:11.599 --> 02:08:19.976
<v Loretta Smith>Such an analysis would not focus solely on a headcount, but rather would look at the types of work diverse communities are able to access.

1299
02:08:20.890 --> 02:08:28.130
<v Loretta Smith>For this reason, we believe that the studies must determine the earnings and benefits by race and sex as well.

1300
02:08:29.301 --> 02:08:31.050
<v Loretta Smith>The best way to unearth Councilor Smith.

1301
02:08:31.162 --> 02:08:37.197
<v Loretta Smith>True earnings opportunity is to look at the contracts let by the city for union participation.

1302
02:08:38.047 --> 02:08:47.997
<v Loretta Smith>Being a part of a union increases the median wealth of households of color, for example, by up to 228%, and that's according to the Center for American Progress.

1303
02:08:48.801 --> 02:09:07.900
<v Loretta Smith>Union membership addresses structural inequalities through better wages, benefits, retirement, training, safety, and job If it were up to me, every dollar the city spends would reward these good union contractors who help workers and our communities to thrive.

1304
02:09:09.534 --> 02:09:21.761
<v Loretta Smith>The study should also examine the owner-to-worker pay ratios of businesses who contract with the city to ensure that Portland is not inadvertently working with businesses that are contributing to the ever-widening pay gap.

1305
02:09:22.037 --> 02:09:23.935
<v Loretta Smith>It's grown dramatically in recent years.

1306
02:09:24.710 --> 02:09:26.786
<v Loretta Smith>Top firms have an average of 290 to 1.

1307
02:09:28.231 --> 02:09:36.542
<v Loretta Smith>CEO to average worker salary, and low-wage firms have an appalling average ratio of 632 to 1.

1308
02:09:37.698 --> 02:09:42.961
<v Jamie Dunphy>Again, it's not just the equity value of letting contracts to women and BIPOC owners that matters.

1309
02:09:43.457 --> 02:09:50.725
<v Loretta Smith>It's also the opportunity for their firm's employees to share in the prosperity their toil generates.

1310
02:09:51.560 --> 02:09:55.434
<v Jamie Dunphy>Too often, that second-level look is not part of the analysis.

1311
02:09:55.997 --> 02:09:58.220
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you very much for considering my ideas.

1312
02:09:58.332 --> 02:09:59.588
<v Loretta Smith>Happy to take your questions.

1313
02:10:02.670 --> 02:10:03.650
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1314
02:10:03.810 --> 02:10:03.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

1315
02:10:04.648 --> 02:10:07.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>Members of Council, thank you for the opportunity to testify today.

1316
02:10:07.671 --> 02:10:11.523
<v Jamie Dunphy>For the record, my name is Loren Bulling, and I'm here on behalf of the Ironworkers Local 29.

1317
02:10:12.349 --> 02:10:15.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>Diversity, equity, and inclusion for the Ironworkers is fundamental.

1318
02:10:15.844 --> 02:10:26.315
<v Jamie Dunphy>On average, our state registered apprenticeship program is between 250 and 300 apprentices, and our numbers hover around 35 to 40% diverse, while our overall membership is 24.5%.

1319
02:10:27.551 --> 02:10:34.113
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just for reference, the 2020 census data showed that 83.2% of the state identified as white, non-Hispanic, or Latino.

1320
02:10:34.770 --> 02:10:39.375
<v Jamie Dunphy>While we are certainly not perfect, we are doing the work to create a more diverse, skilled, and local workforce.

1321
02:10:40.707 --> 02:10:43.962
<v Jamie Dunphy>As Lori mentioned, we are supportive of the proposed disparity study.

1322
02:10:44.782 --> 02:11:05.557
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, we also think there are things that could Councilor Green's amendment 1 covers a majority of what we'd like to see, but I think it would also be important to say and look at when a project is done under a PLA or community benefit agreement with enforcement teeth compared to when a project was done under an equity agreement or something without legitimate enforcement teeth.

1323
02:11:05.895 --> 02:11:10.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>We really need to make sure that this study shows us which policy tools are more effective at achieving our goals.

1324
02:11:10.743 --> 02:11:10.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1325
02:11:12.317 --> 02:11:25.782
<v Jamie Dunphy>The other thing that we would really like to see is workforce diversity, and especially when a contractor is given exemption from labor standards, we often hear that those contractors have a diverse workforce, but we really like to see data that actually shows that is true.

1326
02:11:26.760 --> 02:11:29.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this is especially important if we want to grow our diverse contractor pool.

1327
02:11:30.430 --> 02:11:38.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>As for construction, if you need to get a COBID certification, you must have either the relevant license or relevant work experience to actually get that certification with the city.

1328
02:11:39.670 --> 02:11:44.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>The other thing that we would suggest is looking at local academics or researchers to conduct this study.

1329
02:11:45.323 --> 02:11:47.407
<v Jamie Dunphy>As nonprofits, they're typically much cheaper.

1330
02:11:48.126 --> 02:11:53.252
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think as well, it's important to note that Prosper's firm only has one person who actually lives in Oregon on their website.

1331
02:11:54.426 --> 02:11:58.305
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, I can't say it enough, but local understanding is really key to ensuring that we get the best data.

1332
02:12:00.144 --> 02:12:18.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>The other thing that we would encourage is transparency, and we hope that council will push to make sure that data collection the disparity study now will have long-term effects on how the City of Portland procures future projects.

1333
02:12:18.659 --> 02:12:23.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>This needs to be done right to ensure that both workforce and contractor equity are addressed in future policymaking.

1334
02:12:23.920 --> 02:12:30.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we believe a focus on creating a more diverse workforce is the best way to achieve the goal of fostering a more diverse contractor base as well.

1335
02:12:30.600 --> 02:12:31.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for your time.

1336
02:12:31.279 --> 02:12:31.319
<v Loretta Smith>Councilmember Herbold.

1337
02:12:33.659 --> 02:12:34.511
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1338
02:12:34.944 --> 02:12:35.394
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1339
02:12:35.667 --> 02:12:36.277
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hi, good morning.

1340
02:12:36.613 --> 02:12:41.221
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, good morning, President Pirtle-Guiney and Vice President Koyama Lane and members of the council.

1341
02:12:41.270 --> 02:12:42.891
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for allowing me to address you today.

1342
02:12:43.935 --> 02:12:45.525
<v Jamie Dunphy>For the record, my name is Randall Friesen.

1343
02:12:45.622 --> 02:12:49.266
<v Jamie Dunphy>I serve as the executive director of the Columbia Pacific Building Trades Council.

1344
02:12:49.796 --> 02:13:00.121
<v Jamie Dunphy>We proudly represent over 16,000 construction workers, construction professionals across 22 local unions and 14 of the 15 building trades crafts in the Portland metropolitan Southwest Washington areas.

1345
02:13:01.117 --> 02:13:04.826
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are here today to support conducting this disparity study.

1346
02:13:05.676 --> 02:13:11.761
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a vital, necessary tool for gathering the essential evidence-based metrics we need for our local contracting and procurement standards.

1347
02:13:12.774 --> 02:13:15.261
<v Jamie Dunphy>A comprehensive study is crucial for 2 key reasons.

1348
02:13:15.422 --> 02:13:18.842
<v Jamie Dunphy>It will identify which of our current policies are effective and which are not.

1349
02:13:20.127 --> 02:13:34.810
<v Jamie Dunphy>It will also provide critical insights To ensure the study is a success and provides the most valuable data, we respectfully request that the council mandate the inclusion of the following 3 key parameters.

1350
02:13:35.332 --> 02:13:37.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>And some we've already covered this morning, so thank you.

1351
02:13:38.237 --> 02:13:43.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just to reinforce that, we want— we'd like to see that the council uses Portland-specific demographic data.

1352
02:13:44.759 --> 02:13:52.238
<v Jamie Dunphy>The study must be conducted using demographic data and certified payroll specific to the city of Portland and the metropolitan area in general.

1353
02:13:53.137 --> 02:14:01.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you use a broader, like throughout the state of Oregon, it's, it's going to skew the results and it wouldn't be as accurate as it would be for our region.

1354
02:14:02.029 --> 02:14:04.260
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we don't want to undermine the study's findings.

1355
02:14:04.837 --> 02:14:06.346
<v Jamie Dunphy>Inclusion of all relevant firms.

1356
02:14:06.443 --> 02:14:21.421
<v Jamie Dunphy>The study must gather workforce data on all firms, including certified businesses, as Lauren stated, to include DBE COVID firms, etc., and any firms that are currently excluded or exempt from equity goals or specific project labor standards and agreements.

1357
02:14:21.871 --> 02:14:35.952
<v Jamie Dunphy>We believe this will provide a more accurate and comprehensive representation of how various policies are working in practice to fulfill our community's economic and equity goals, and how exemption or enforcement of policy relates specifically to the workforce.

1358
02:14:36.305 --> 02:14:39.564
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's not necessarily just to the contractor, but the folks they they also hire.

1359
02:14:41.055 --> 02:14:43.109
<v Jamie Dunphy>We also want to utilize local-based expertise.

1360
02:14:43.220 --> 02:15:04.582
<v Jamie Dunphy>Again, to touch on that note, I think and know that if we used local community-based organizations to do this study using Oregon— State of Oregon, or excuse me, the University of Oregon LERC— they could do a study like this and it would be less money and better results, right?

1361
02:15:04.631 --> 02:15:06.076
<v Jamie Dunphy>Or more accurate is what we're looking for.

1362
02:15:06.639 --> 02:15:11.586
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the affiliated unions we represent are deeply committed to improving the lives of working people in our communities.

1363
02:15:12.100 --> 02:15:15.311
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're very proud of the hard work they have demonstrated in diversifying their membership.

1364
02:15:15.890 --> 02:15:27.905
<v Jamie Dunphy>At a time when federal policy related to diversity, equity, inclusion is being challenged, it's worth noting that many of our unions already have a diverse membership that exceeds many of the goals established by agreements like the Regional Workforce Equity Agreement.

1365
02:15:28.788 --> 02:15:47.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>A, uh, U of O LURC study reinforces our belief that the union model remains the best choice for achieving sustainable, measurable equity in the workforce, as 55% of BIPOC in union programs had an average wage of $40 or more compared to, uh, just 20% in non-union programs.

1366
02:15:48.207 --> 02:15:49.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for your time.

1367
02:15:49.109 --> 02:15:50.694
<v Jamie Dunphy>I appreciate you all.

1368
02:15:51.050 --> 02:15:51.810
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all.

1369
02:15:52.814 --> 02:15:53.234
<v Loretta Smith>Zach.

1370
02:15:54.287 --> 02:15:56.295
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, good morning, uh, Council.

1371
02:15:56.380 --> 02:15:57.904
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, President and members of the council.

1372
02:15:58.724 --> 02:16:02.801
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for allowing us time to provide testimony on the disparity study.

1373
02:16:03.716 --> 02:16:14.603
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Zach Culver, and I'm the business manager for LiUNA Local 737, which is a laborers union representing over 3,000 members across Oregon.

1374
02:16:15.436 --> 02:16:19.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>It includes construction craft laborers working in local communities around the state.

1375
02:16:20.318 --> 02:16:35.988
<v Jamie Dunphy>For many decades, highly skilled and trained LiUNA members have worked on and continue to build critical projects throughout the Portland area, such as the public library bond, the North Columbia Wastewater Treatment Plant, and Bull Run Facility Filtration Project.

1376
02:16:36.808 --> 02:16:45.431
<v Jamie Dunphy>As a member-driven union, our membership and joint labor-management registered apprenticeship program reflect the makeup of our local communities.

1377
02:16:45.768 --> 02:16:52.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Since 2021, The Labor Apprenticeship Program has registered 503 total individuals.

1378
02:16:53.147 --> 02:17:02.034
<v Jamie Dunphy>Of those 503 individuals, 47 self-identified as people of color, 21% identified as women.

1379
02:17:02.691 --> 02:17:11.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>During that same time period, 94 people of color, 40 females, and 1 non-binary individual have completed our apprenticeship program.

1380
02:17:12.252 --> 02:17:16.037
<v Jamie Dunphy>About half of those who registered are still engaged in our apprenticeship program.

1381
02:17:16.422 --> 02:17:18.075
<v Jamie Dunphy>Making progress towards completion.

1382
02:17:18.750 --> 02:17:32.120
<v Jamie Dunphy>Publicly funded projects that include apprenticeship utilization standards offer our apprentices the opportunity to earn family-sustaining wages and critical on-the-job experience that is necessary to complete their training and advance their careers.

1383
02:17:33.274 --> 02:17:49.699
<v Jamie Dunphy>Based on a 2021 University of Oregon Labor and Education Research Center study, the number of females and people of color who enrolled as new apprentices in 2020, had increased by 50% compared to the previous decade.

1384
02:17:50.534 --> 02:18:10.353
<v Jamie Dunphy>We believe this important increase in historically unrepresented workers entering the construction field can be attributed to the public policies that have established minimum apprenticeship utilization requirements for certain projects, and in large part to intentional efforts by both unions and contractors investing in state-registered apprenticeship.

1385
02:18:10.450 --> 02:18:10.466
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1386
02:18:10.546 --> 02:18:10.817
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Opposed?

1387
02:18:10.881 --> 02:18:11.251
<v Jamie Dunphy>Any abstentions?

1388
02:18:12.037 --> 02:18:12.356
<v Jamie Dunphy>Motion passes.

1389
02:18:12.405 --> 02:18:12.501
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1390
02:18:12.549 --> 02:18:21.221
<v Jamie Dunphy>LaUNA encourages local public policies that continue to reinforce and expand their fair opportunity for historically underrepresented workers in our construction industry.

1391
02:18:22.504 --> 02:18:31.417
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the laborers want to support and commend the city for considering this contracting disparity study at the current moment.

1392
02:18:32.058 --> 02:18:50.612
<v Jamie Dunphy>Should this resolution be adopted, we hope that the resulting findings can reflect the continuing need to prioritize participation of contractors who are invested in BOLI-approved registered apprenticeship programs, supporting advancement opportunities for the next generation of skilled, skilled construction workers.

1393
02:18:52.141 --> 02:18:54.877
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I will go ahead and submit these for the record.

1394
02:18:54.941 --> 02:18:56.154
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for your time today.

1395
02:19:00.875 --> 02:19:01.630
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1396
02:19:04.264 --> 02:19:06.131
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, do we have additional public testimony?

1397
02:19:07.610 --> 02:19:09.578
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have one more testifier.

1398
02:19:09.644 --> 02:19:12.324
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Corey Stubenrock is joining us online.

1399
02:19:13.066 --> 02:19:15.763
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Corey, go right ahead.

1400
02:19:17.564 --> 02:19:18.290
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, thank you.

1401
02:19:18.790 --> 02:19:25.132
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, good morning, President Pirtle-Guiney and Vice President Koyama Lane and members of the council.

1402
02:19:25.632 --> 02:19:28.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for the opportunity to testify on the thank you, Mayor.

1403
02:19:28.110 --> 02:19:33.850
<v Loretta Smith>I'm here to speak in support of the proposed resolution to study disparities in city contracting and workforce participation.

1404
02:19:33.850 --> 02:19:35.610
<v Loretta Smith>My name is Corey Stubenrock.

1405
02:19:35.870 --> 02:19:41.610
<v Loretta Smith>I'm an organizer and proud member of Smart Local 16.

1406
02:19:41.610 --> 02:19:49.729
<v Loretta Smith>We represent over 2,000 members in Oregon and Southwest Washington and currently 265 state-registered apprentices.

1407
02:19:49.729 --> 02:19:56.400
<v Loretta Smith>Our apprentices earn while they learn with full family medical and retirement benefits at no cost to them.

1408
02:19:56.979 --> 02:20:01.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>They also receive a college degree when they graduate from our program with no student debt.

1409
02:20:01.641 --> 02:20:07.483
<v Loretta Smith>We pride ourselves on providing families sustaining careers for over 135 years.

1410
02:20:08.063 --> 02:20:19.038
<v Loretta Smith>More than just a nice story, I'm part of this history of lifting up working people as a proud journeyman with 17 years of sheet metal experience in the field before coming—.

1411
02:20:19.233 --> 02:20:20.594
<v Jamie Dunphy>Becoming an organizer for our union.

1412
02:20:21.894 --> 02:20:26.976
<v Loretta Smith>Diversity, equity, and inclusion are core values for my union because they make us stronger.

1413
02:20:27.407 --> 02:20:45.426
<v Loretta Smith>As part of our commitment to diversifying our workforce, my union began an intensive program for diverse apprentices that empowers them to succeed by partnering with— partnering with successful members— by partnering them with successful members and mentors who share their lived experiences.

1414
02:20:45.700 --> 02:20:56.816
<v Loretta Smith>The program allows small cohorts to advance through our program together with an active and conscientious commitment to their success from fellow members and employers.

1415
02:20:57.569 --> 02:21:06.167
<v Loretta Smith>We have already seen great success and are working to grow the program so that more historically underrepresented people can join our trade.

1416
02:21:07.594 --> 02:21:13.818
<v Jamie Dunphy>Reevaluating the way that workforce development is done is crucial to meeting the needs of our diversifying workforce.

1417
02:21:14.558 --> 02:21:23.372
<v Loretta Smith>That is why our union has partnered at the national level with the tutress childcare options that SMART is providing for our members.

1418
02:21:23.870 --> 02:21:28.993
<v Loretta Smith>I know that programs like this make the difference in being able to follow a career path in construction.

1419
02:21:29.489 --> 02:21:44.038
<v Loretta Smith>I detailed the impact of the childcare crisis on workers in the construction industry during Trades Women Build Nations in 2023 when I spoke to over 4,000 women in construction about my personal experience.

1420
02:21:44.279 --> 02:21:55.261
<v Jamie Dunphy>Despite my love for the craft and dedication to my union, I had to briefly step away from sheet metal due to challenges I faced finding adequate, affordable, and accessible childcare.

1421
02:21:56.079 --> 02:22:02.309
<v Loretta Smith>Women are underrepresented— are an underrepresented part of the construction trades and contracting industry.

1422
02:22:02.824 --> 02:22:17.444
<v Loretta Smith>Let's make sure that this study not only looks at one facet of an intersectional issue, but instead also addresses women in the trades and how we can continue to make these career pathways a viable and attractive option for women.

1423
02:22:20.101 --> 02:22:26.566
<v Jamie Dunphy>The choices you make today will have long-term effects on the workforce that the City of Portland has available for future projects.

1424
02:22:27.229 --> 02:22:33.849
<v Loretta Smith>The decision that you make needs to be the right one to ensure that both workforce and contractor equity are addressed for the future.

1425
02:22:33.978 --> 02:22:37.195
<v Loretta Smith>Without my union, without my union, I would not be a tradeswoman.

1426
02:22:37.308 --> 02:22:41.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please do not do anything that would close the door for those that come after me.

1427
02:22:41.621 --> 02:22:42.302
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for your time.

1428
02:22:43.450 --> 02:22:44.144
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1429
02:22:44.209 --> 02:22:48.699
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you to all of you for testifying today, lending your support, and also bringing your suggestions.

1430
02:22:54.507 --> 02:22:56.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do have another item on the agenda.

1431
02:22:56.260 --> 02:23:02.443
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have an agenda after this that we'll need a solid hour to get through because we have amendments to that item as well.

1432
02:23:03.520 --> 02:23:11.718
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I want to see what we can do right now as we move into discussion, but I want to note that we do need to close our work on this item at noon.

1433
02:23:14.522 --> 02:23:17.433
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we have 2 amendments before us.

1434
02:23:18.209 --> 02:23:22.621
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Councilor Smith's amendment, I think everybody now has in writing.

1435
02:23:23.566 --> 02:23:26.605
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Green's amendment, which is posted online.

1436
02:23:27.683 --> 02:23:29.452
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, you are in the queue.

1437
02:23:29.677 --> 02:23:30.111
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1438
02:23:30.240 --> 02:23:31.753
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a, a question.

1439
02:23:32.106 --> 02:23:37.445
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are we, are we all on the same page about that the track changes are from the same starting point for each of these 2 amendments?

1440
02:23:37.815 --> 02:23:42.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because I know there was a question around that, and I'm a little confused if anyone's done the compare versions yet.

1441
02:23:44.576 --> 02:23:57.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe that Councilor Green's amendments with One or 2 small exceptions fit the tracked changes that are on Councilor Smith's amendments.

1442
02:23:57.648 --> 02:24:10.531
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So for example, if you look at the therefore be it resolved in Councilor Green's version, he is amending from resolved clauses or therefore clauses that begin with that the and not directs or requests.

1443
02:24:11.832 --> 02:24:24.575
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are a few small differences that, I believe Haley has caught for us, but for the most part, Councilor Green's amend the amendment brought by Councilor Smith, not the underlying.

1444
02:24:26.989 --> 02:24:33.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, just the blue text is what I'm amending to whatever Councilor Smith is bringing forward here in these red lines.

1445
02:24:33.863 --> 02:24:35.972
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that's— that works with the crosswalk.

1446
02:24:36.021 --> 02:24:40.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>So if I were to take this, accept all changes, that would be what you started with?

1447
02:24:40.444 --> 02:24:40.864
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, correct.

1448
02:24:41.691 --> 02:24:44.977
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With a few exceptions that I think we should let Haley note.

1449
02:24:45.683 --> 02:24:46.709
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are exceptions.

1450
02:24:47.702 --> 02:24:51.182
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>One exception is in the now therefore section.

1451
02:24:52.272 --> 02:25:00.926
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith's version says that there— now therefore be it resolved by the Portland City Council Labor and Workforce Committee requests.

1452
02:25:01.391 --> 02:25:08.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know from a legal technical perspective if we can change the now therefore clause to specify a committee over council.

1453
02:25:08.959 --> 02:25:09.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that was one flag.

1454
02:25:09.986 --> 02:25:14.372
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then the last difference that I caught was in the resolved section.

1455
02:25:15.128 --> 02:25:30.084
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In Green's version, there is a piece that says— let me pull up this other— Councilor Green's version notes that there will be a presentation to first the Labor and Workforce Development.

1456
02:25:30.149 --> 02:25:32.672
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So this would be 5 in Green's version.

1457
02:25:32.864 --> 02:25:33.138
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>5.

1458
02:25:33.234 --> 02:25:39.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>5 says findings and recommendations would be presented first to Labor and Workforce Development Committee and then to entire council.

1459
02:25:40.216 --> 02:25:46.245
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In Councilor Smith's version, the presentation is solely to the Labor and Workforce Committee.

1460
02:25:48.194 --> 02:25:51.192
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, uh, and then have either of these been formally moved?

1461
02:25:52.693 --> 02:25:54.021
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Nothing has been formally moved.

1462
02:25:54.168 --> 02:25:56.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, that's— thanks for my clarifications.

1463
02:25:58.440 --> 02:26:04.246
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, would either of you like to move your amendments so that we can move— right now we are in debate on the underlying resolution.

1464
02:26:05.579 --> 02:26:06.014
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith?

1465
02:26:06.644 --> 02:26:13.484
<v Loretta Smith>I'd like to move, um, my amendment to the original resolution.

1466
02:26:14.417 --> 02:26:15.399
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second.

1467
02:26:15.754 --> 02:26:18.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I heard Councilor Ryan second.

1468
02:26:19.216 --> 02:26:22.614
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Councilor Green, are you in the queue to discuss the amendment?

1469
02:26:23.422 --> 02:26:32.022
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, I would just like to offer that my changes in blue That are posted just be folded in as a friendly amendment to your amendment so we don't have to take it up separately.

1470
02:26:32.295 --> 02:26:32.824
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

1471
02:26:33.242 --> 02:26:34.043
<v Loretta Smith>I accept it.

1472
02:26:35.183 --> 02:26:39.819
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so we are now looking at a combined ver— well, actually, let's go to the seconder.

1473
02:26:39.899 --> 02:26:41.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, do you accept?

1474
02:26:42.242 --> 02:26:42.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absolutely, yes.

1475
02:26:43.028 --> 02:26:49.926
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so councilors, we are now in debate for a combined version that includes both sets of amendments.

1476
02:26:50.022 --> 02:26:52.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Knoll, to the amendments.

1477
02:26:52.959 --> 02:26:57.575
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, though I support these broadly, I had 2 questions and a comment.

1478
02:26:57.639 --> 02:27:11.408
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the— I didn't— I'm still not 100% clear why each of the 2 whereas clauses that were removed were removed, or 3, sorry, whereas clauses in this amendment.

1479
02:27:12.226 --> 02:27:18.125
<v Jamie Dunphy>It seemed to me that this was helpful context and helped sort of advance the argument.

1480
02:27:18.173 --> 02:27:19.519
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I wanted to know why.

1481
02:27:19.599 --> 02:27:20.704
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it's— these are the— Councilor Dan Ryan.

1482
02:27:21.529 --> 02:27:33.682
<v Jamie Dunphy>First one on whereas equitable access to contracting opportunities, whereas, and then the ones that kind of cross the page gap there, whereas the city's efforts to combat, and whereas in December 2024.

1483
02:27:34.171 --> 02:27:35.788
<v Loretta Smith>We were trying to be a little bit more concise.

1484
02:27:37.736 --> 02:27:37.870
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1485
02:27:38.935 --> 02:27:54.126
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, and then the other piece of it is, I, and, and Haley just mentioned this, I, I don't, I would not support now therefore be it resolved that the Labor and Workforce Committee requests the is an action that the whole council would be taking, and I'd want it to be clear that that's the case.

1486
02:27:54.238 --> 02:28:03.681
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't have a problem with changing it elsewhere, um, to where the reports go, but just that, that header, um, I think it's— it narrows the scope of what we're, what we're asking for.

1487
02:28:03.762 --> 02:28:09.492
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm also not sure if there is a legal question, but even if not—.

1488
02:28:11.331 --> 02:28:11.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1489
02:28:12.137 --> 02:28:21.192
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do think that on the therefore be it resolved part once the council takes this action, it won't be the Labor and Workforce Committee requesting this.

1490
02:28:21.290 --> 02:28:23.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It will technically be the full council requesting it.

1491
02:28:23.822 --> 02:28:27.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm not sure legally what that means about what we need to say there.

1492
02:28:31.708 --> 02:28:34.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I am next in the queue for debate.

1493
02:28:35.334 --> 02:28:38.701
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate both of these amendments being brought forward.

1494
02:28:39.218 --> 02:28:42.853
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am generally supportive of where both are going, but I wanted to note a few things.

1495
02:28:43.131 --> 02:28:51.673
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have a few, one concern and a few things that I would love us to consider either adding separately or as a part of this amendment package.

1496
02:28:53.130 --> 02:29:00.566
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Unlike my colleague, Councilor Knoll, I actually do have a concern with stating that the report will be brought back to the Labor and Workforce Committees.

1497
02:29:00.679 --> 02:29:04.540
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Committees are by nature a subgroup of council.

1498
02:29:04.620 --> 02:29:11.259
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So by saying a report will be brought back to council, I think we could refer that to to a committee for consideration first instead.

1499
02:29:11.740 --> 02:29:14.147
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't know next year what our committees will look like.

1500
02:29:14.212 --> 02:29:17.246
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have had robust discussions about having different committees.

1501
02:29:17.985 --> 02:29:20.183
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This committee could be folded in with other work.

1502
02:29:20.231 --> 02:29:23.105
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It could be the same work but have a different name.

1503
02:29:23.843 --> 02:29:35.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think that it would be much cleaner for us to just talk about reports coming back to Council or perhaps saying Council or the relevant Council committee rather than calling something out by name.

1504
02:29:36.012 --> 02:29:36.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1505
02:29:36.477 --> 02:29:37.568
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I wanted to note that.

1506
02:29:38.129 --> 02:29:52.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also want to note that I think where in the green additions to the amendment, number 4, we say that the studies analyze impacts of project labor agreements or community benefit agreements, we should also add, or the Regional Workforce Equity Act.

1507
02:29:53.051 --> 02:30:06.592
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a very strong specific agreement that we are party to at the city, and I think that we should compare other work to that agreement that we've often raised as a gold standard in the community.

1508
02:30:06.943 --> 02:30:11.078
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I wonder if the councilors would be interested in accepting that.

1509
02:30:11.816 --> 02:30:24.716
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the third thing that I wanted to suggest— again, this could be a friendly to this amendment, or I could bring it separately— is the idea that after 4, we add a new 5.

1510
02:30:25.629 --> 02:30:55.324
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I apologize to do this on the fly, um, which would say That we analyze earnings of workers by race and gender under projects of the city contracted with those agreements, the agreements above, project labor agreements, community benefit agreements, and the Regional Workforce Equity Act, as compared to projects of the city that are not contracted for under those agreements.

1511
02:30:56.927 --> 02:30:58.082
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that was 3 things.

1512
02:30:58.337 --> 02:30:59.122
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

1513
02:30:59.459 --> 02:31:01.895
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, point of information, you said that was going to be—.

1514
02:31:02.183 --> 02:31:04.891
<v Loretta Smith>You're going to make it number 5?

1515
02:31:04.940 --> 02:31:06.461
<v Loretta Smith>Because I see that there are already 5.

1516
02:31:06.510 --> 02:31:12.808
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There would be a new 5 because it's related to 4, and the current 5 would move to a 6 if we were to do that.

1517
02:31:13.239 --> 02:31:13.384
<v Loretta Smith>Got it.

1518
02:31:13.432 --> 02:31:22.004
<v Loretta Smith>Madam President, I like everything that you said up to that point because I'm not sure if that's the same thing that we're trying to solve for on your 5th point.

1519
02:31:22.132 --> 02:31:24.632
<v Loretta Smith>I think that's a whole different ball of wax.

1520
02:31:25.498 --> 02:31:28.816
<v Loretta Smith>And I think your other suggestions are right on, spot on.

1521
02:31:28.879 --> 02:31:29.377
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first 2.

1522
02:31:29.584 --> 02:31:30.242
<v Loretta Smith>The first 3.

1523
02:31:31.106 --> 02:31:38.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, adding Regional Workforce Equity Act, changing from the named committee to Portland City Council.

1524
02:31:38.591 --> 02:31:39.103
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

1525
02:31:39.360 --> 02:31:40.546
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or an appropriate committee.

1526
02:31:40.898 --> 02:31:41.379
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

1527
02:31:41.523 --> 02:31:44.728
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And but you did not like, um, you did not—.

1528
02:31:44.728 --> 02:31:52.422
<v Loretta Smith>I think that last one is something a little bit different from the disparity and I'm— where's— did you understand that?

1529
02:31:55.355 --> 02:31:55.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I—.

1530
02:31:55.917 --> 02:31:56.094
<v Loretta Smith>From—.

1531
02:31:56.094 --> 02:32:00.721
<v Jamie Dunphy>To my understanding, it is going— getting down to the actual outcomes of the study.

1532
02:32:00.834 --> 02:32:01.524
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sounds good.

1533
02:32:01.621 --> 02:32:02.602
<v Loretta Smith>So would that help?

1534
02:32:03.003 --> 02:32:06.759
<v Loretta Smith>The last— I heard some things in there that I wasn't quite sure of.

1535
02:32:07.762 --> 02:32:13.763
<v Jamie Dunphy>Ultimately, quite frankly, ultimately the study is supposed to be somewhat neutral binding research technique.

1536
02:32:15.164 --> 02:32:21.845
<v Jamie Dunphy>That technique can take into account comparisons, but we can draw those comparisons based upon the data that we have internally.

1537
02:32:22.456 --> 02:32:31.675
<v Jamie Dunphy>But it's basically a very vanilla study to basically ask questions and to identify those participants as well.

1538
02:32:32.431 --> 02:32:32.929
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1539
02:32:33.234 --> 02:32:36.415
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then from those outcomes, we then develop policy and actions.

1540
02:32:37.170 --> 02:32:49.886
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the resolution is guidance, but it should not get into the operationalization So that's why I was concerned about that last— Sorry, I didn't mean to sound like a procurement wonk, but—.

1541
02:32:49.886 --> 02:32:56.572
<v Loretta Smith>No, no, no, you're not sounding like— I'm just trying to— it hit me in a way that I didn't— I think that's outside of what we're trying to do.

1542
02:32:56.748 --> 02:32:59.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But the third piece—.

1543
02:33:01.073 --> 02:33:07.845
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I will say this, Council President, that there is specifically carved out a workforce element to the study.

1544
02:33:08.402 --> 02:33:13.695
<v Jamie Dunphy>And in that study, we can say, identify markers that will definitely address your concerns.

1545
02:33:14.034 --> 02:33:36.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So the third piece wouldn't direct how the study was done, but would just note that we needed to have that workforce piece in the study and that specifically that workforce piece needed to analyze the difference in workforce, Earnings and benefits.

1546
02:33:37.138 --> 02:33:54.075
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So the earnings and benefits of workers by race and gender on projects that were contracted through a project labor agreement, community benefit agreement, or Regional Workforce Equity Act, as opposed to projects that were contracted in other methods.

1547
02:33:54.673 --> 02:33:54.995
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1548
02:33:55.156 --> 02:33:56.948
<v Loretta Smith>And I don't think that that deals with the disparities.

1549
02:33:57.028 --> 02:34:10.718
<v Loretta Smith>I think that is going underneath the hood on on how minority contractors pay their folks versus non-minority contractors who have bigger contracts.

1550
02:34:11.040 --> 02:34:13.897
<v Loretta Smith>I think we're just getting into— it's not dealing with the disparity.

1551
02:34:14.250 --> 02:34:18.520
<v Loretta Smith>We need to understand the top-line disparity within the contracts that we do.

1552
02:34:18.825 --> 02:34:20.879
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I want to keep us moving.

1553
02:34:21.137 --> 02:34:31.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What I'm hearing is that the first 2, adding Regional Workforce Equity Act to number 4, and anywhere where we call out a committee name—.

1554
02:34:32.395 --> 02:34:33.328
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At City Council.

1555
02:34:33.378 --> 02:34:41.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Striking the committee name and saying Portland City Council or a relevant committee.

1556
02:34:41.707 --> 02:34:42.209
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

1557
02:34:42.273 --> 02:34:43.988
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That those would be friendly to you?

1558
02:34:44.215 --> 02:34:44.716
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, ma'am.

1559
02:34:45.328 --> 02:34:47.572
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, would those be friendly to you?

1560
02:34:48.799 --> 02:34:48.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1561
02:34:49.929 --> 02:34:52.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, you're now a part of this too.

1562
02:34:52.203 --> 02:34:52.995
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Would those be friendly?

1563
02:34:53.850 --> 02:34:54.834
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It would be, yes.

1564
02:34:55.220 --> 02:35:07.599
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I'm happy to get that in writing to you if somebody can send me a version of this electronically, or if that is straightforward enough that we don't need it in writing, that's fine as well.

1565
02:35:08.808 --> 02:35:11.103
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Does anybody want that in writing, those 2 things?

1566
02:35:11.782 --> 02:35:12.364
<v Loretta Smith>And I sent it to you.

1567
02:35:12.656 --> 02:35:13.254
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, perfect.

1568
02:35:13.384 --> 02:35:14.289
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I'll work on that.

1569
02:35:14.450 --> 02:35:15.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick?

1570
02:35:17.263 --> 02:35:18.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I just had a couple of questions.

1571
02:35:20.350 --> 02:35:20.593
<v Jamie Dunphy>Questions.

1572
02:35:20.706 --> 02:35:28.904
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, one, I just wanted to ask staff, do Councilor Green's amendments cause any heartburn for you in terms of adding to cost and timing?

1573
02:35:32.715 --> 02:35:38.918
<v Jamie Dunphy>In terms of research, the breadth of it, it could, it could potentially impact, impact the group, the group study.

1574
02:35:39.079 --> 02:35:39.209
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1575
02:35:40.659 --> 02:35:42.551
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hmm.

1576
02:35:42.971 --> 02:35:43.861
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, okay.

1577
02:35:44.087 --> 02:35:53.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>How long would it take to figure out the extent to which it might I will have to engage with, engage with the parties involved in order to be— to roll that out and see how much it costs.

1578
02:35:53.882 --> 02:36:00.501
<v Jamie Dunphy>It could be very insignificant, but the execution of it, the outcomes could be, could, could be a challenge at times.

1579
02:36:00.549 --> 02:36:01.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

1580
02:36:02.376 --> 02:36:14.810
<v Jamie Dunphy>And also, I just have to say I'm confused looking at the— we talked about going back from March to December, but looking at the current version that I see online and written I don't see any reference to either March or December.

1581
02:36:15.005 --> 02:36:16.144
<v Jamie Dunphy>So is that deliberate?

1582
02:36:16.209 --> 02:36:18.613
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're no longer putting in a specific deadline?

1583
02:36:26.222 --> 02:36:27.272
<v Loretta Smith>I'm looking for it.

1584
02:36:27.691 --> 02:36:31.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the version, uh, that Councilor Smith's office circulated.

1585
02:36:31.097 --> 02:36:43.832
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so in the resolve section, uh, it says upon completion in what is now the number 5 the March 1st date was stricken, but we can add back something as well.

1586
02:36:48.520 --> 02:36:54.222
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So colleagues, what Hayley has up is the amended with Councilor Green's rolled into it, I believe.

1587
02:36:54.576 --> 02:36:54.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That is correct.

1588
02:36:54.977 --> 02:36:59.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And you're working on rolling in the 2 things that were accepted as friendly that I raised.

1589
02:36:59.924 --> 02:37:00.543
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1590
02:37:04.209 --> 02:37:16.200
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, the number 4 has the RWIA piece added, and then the number 5 reflects the change where it now says studies to City Council or a relevant committee.

1591
02:37:16.701 --> 02:37:20.880
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To Councilor Novick's question, there is no date currently.

1592
02:37:20.994 --> 02:37:23.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It just says shall be presented upon completion.

1593
02:37:26.162 --> 02:37:26.281
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Correct.

1594
02:37:26.332 --> 02:37:27.657
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, did you have additional questions?

1595
02:37:28.790 --> 02:37:29.779
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor Ryan.

1596
02:37:30.212 --> 02:37:33.068
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, um, I just have a question for you, Councilor Smith.

1597
02:37:33.325 --> 02:37:46.052
<v Jamie Dunphy>I wasn't involved in the details of this, but listening to the testimony, we heard, um, that we wanted to look at wages for women and, and people of color, and I couldn't tell if this is now included in this, uh, resolution.

1598
02:37:46.101 --> 02:37:48.027
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm con— and I'm confused why not.

1599
02:37:48.974 --> 02:37:52.360
<v Loretta Smith>Looking for the wages, because we're looking for the disparity first.

1600
02:37:52.986 --> 02:37:54.317
<v Loretta Smith>That is what we're paying for.

1601
02:37:54.527 --> 02:37:58.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're looking for the disparity just in who's employed but not what they're making.

1602
02:38:00.212 --> 02:38:00.838
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

1603
02:38:01.433 --> 02:38:06.671
<v Loretta Smith>I think if we want to add additional things like this, that we should— I mean, it's going to take additional money.

1604
02:38:06.799 --> 02:38:13.179
<v Loretta Smith>I, I believe to do that analysis of all the salaries and all of that, that's a whole different ball game.

1605
02:38:13.709 --> 02:38:15.768
<v Loretta Smith>And I think it's getting into other people's work.

1606
02:38:16.138 --> 02:38:23.000
<v Loretta Smith>I think they— if they— I think if it's something that people want, if contractors want it, they can, they can pay for that.

1607
02:38:23.065 --> 02:38:31.085
<v Loretta Smith>What we need for our executive order is how are women and people of color despaired in our contracting.

1608
02:38:33.498 --> 02:38:43.581
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now, I get that with the, the owners and such, but, you know, we got into a lot of workforce conversations, which is the value added, in my opinion, on where we're going, because that's always been what has been omitted.

1609
02:38:44.082 --> 02:38:47.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we're not going to really get to the heart of the matter about the apprentice.

1610
02:38:47.328 --> 02:38:49.413
<v Loretta Smith>Part of the matter is who's getting contracted.

1611
02:38:49.494 --> 02:38:49.788
<v Loretta Smith>That's Yes.

1612
02:38:49.915 --> 02:38:50.397
<v Loretta Smith>That's the top line.

1613
02:38:50.494 --> 02:39:02.938
<v Loretta Smith>That's what we need to deal with because the issue is COVID firms and women-owned and minority businesses are not being contracted at the same rate.

1614
02:39:03.661 --> 02:39:14.949
<v Loretta Smith>There are several sub-levels that I would like to go under, you know, in terms of how many contractors use their wives for fronts.

1615
02:39:15.200 --> 02:39:19.069
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, that, that part, I mean, it's getting into some of those things.

1616
02:39:19.069 --> 02:39:20.379
<v Loretta Smith>We have to deal with the disparity.

1617
02:39:20.610 --> 02:39:23.799
<v Loretta Smith>Let's just see that show minority and women are being disparate.

1618
02:39:23.969 --> 02:39:28.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm clearly glad I daylighted this because you're pretty passionate about the conversation, just like—.

1619
02:39:28.569 --> 02:39:30.549
<v Loretta Smith>I've been dealing with this for, for over 20 years.

1620
02:39:30.549 --> 02:39:32.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's why I wanted to get under the hood and talk to you about it.

1621
02:39:32.950 --> 02:39:33.270
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1622
02:39:33.270 --> 02:39:36.459
<v Loretta Smith>I think we need to do that in something else when we have a little bit more money.

1623
02:39:36.670 --> 02:39:38.610
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, we don't have enough money for all that.

1624
02:39:38.889 --> 02:39:48.778
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, I'm just really glad that you lifted the workforce that was here, and then that made me want to ask these concrete questions, because this is the— this is the biggest tool we have in equity in our city.

1625
02:39:48.842 --> 02:39:53.707
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is our biggest impact we can do for equity in our region, is this legislation.

1626
02:39:53.819 --> 02:39:54.766
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I just want to make sure—.

1627
02:39:54.782 --> 02:39:55.441
<v Jamie Dunphy>The struggle is real.

1628
02:39:55.488 --> 02:39:56.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>It took some time to have this conversation.

1629
02:39:57.656 --> 02:39:58.412
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

1630
02:39:58.459 --> 02:40:01.045
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's not a friendly conversation or amendment to add at this time.

1631
02:40:01.301 --> 02:40:01.527
<v Loretta Smith>Uh-uh.

1632
02:40:01.606 --> 02:40:02.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1633
02:40:02.875 --> 02:40:05.941
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>One could raise that after we vote on this amendment if one wanted to.

1634
02:40:06.102 --> 02:40:06.424
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, sir.

1635
02:40:06.504 --> 02:40:08.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know that we'd have time for that today.

1636
02:40:08.157 --> 02:40:08.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>Why don't we do that?

1637
02:40:08.559 --> 02:40:12.445
<v Jamie Dunphy>For sure, 'cause then we're getting to the heart of the matter of this conversation of equity.

1638
02:40:13.171 --> 02:40:13.913
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Morillo.

1639
02:40:16.299 --> 02:40:16.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1640
02:40:19.014 --> 02:40:22.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So it sounds like we're not gonna have time to fully finalize this today.

1641
02:40:22.394 --> 02:40:32.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm asking because I really appreciated what some of the folks who came up to testify said about making sure that we're using local academics to look at some of these studies.

1642
02:40:33.319 --> 02:40:42.852
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I guess I would push back and I would say that I think it is important to see not just who we're contracting with, but also how their employees are treated and the positions that they're getting at the city.

1643
02:40:43.447 --> 02:40:46.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because I know me and Dan Ryan are agreeing.

1644
02:40:46.317 --> 02:40:48.755
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can we memorialize today?

1645
02:40:49.204 --> 02:40:49.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do.

1646
02:40:50.263 --> 02:41:23.179
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I think I understand what you're saying is that there has to be a narrow scope, and maybe this is a separate issue to look into, but I think the consistent issue that we also have at the city is that we are looking at the people at the top and what they're getting and not what the employees who are and I worry about, you know, I think that making sure that we get an analysis on the positions, pay, and benefits of women and people of color at the city so that we can see, are they actually getting into managerial positions?

1647
02:41:23.259 --> 02:41:24.575
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are they in director positions?

1648
02:41:25.506 --> 02:41:28.799
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are they only ever doing different types of work?

1649
02:41:29.103 --> 02:41:31.031
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, I think all of that is really important to this.

1650
02:41:31.078 --> 02:41:31.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1651
02:41:31.239 --> 02:41:35.697
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I would approve those types of amendments, but I don't have language at the top of the amendment.

1652
02:41:35.745 --> 02:41:36.963
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, we can look at that.

1653
02:41:37.283 --> 02:41:47.754
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I wanna make a suggestion because we are over time and I know that we have a few other things we need to get done this morning still.

1654
02:41:48.747 --> 02:42:02.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to suggest that we limit debate just to anything else we need to say on this amendment, vote on this amendment as amended, Hayley had, had it up on the screen.

1655
02:42:03.157 --> 02:42:03.382
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1656
02:42:04.027 --> 02:42:09.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then there's a fair amount of additional work that it sounds like folks want to do.

1657
02:42:10.489 --> 02:42:18.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's work that is more often done at a committee level, but we had some things brought to us today that were not brought forward in committee.

1658
02:42:19.871 --> 02:42:22.138
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we can finish that work at full council.

1659
02:42:22.186 --> 02:42:35.204
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think we need to send it back to committee, but I would suggest that we then entertain a motion to hold this over to an additional meeting to take some of these other topics that are not directly related to the amendment before us.

1660
02:42:35.477 --> 02:42:36.809
<v Loretta Smith>Madam, point of order.

1661
02:42:36.859 --> 02:42:39.748
<v Loretta Smith>So are you saying we need to take a vote if we're going to approve this first?

1662
02:42:40.054 --> 02:42:40.326
<v Loretta Smith>I am.

1663
02:42:40.534 --> 02:42:46.091
<v Loretta Smith>I would like to— we can take this at an additional meeting, but we need to take it back to the labor.

1664
02:42:46.299 --> 02:42:51.277
<v Loretta Smith>If, if that's what you all want, let's take it into my committee and have a deeper conversation about it.

1665
02:42:51.774 --> 02:42:58.765
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we could do that at committee or at council I would entertain either motion, but I would suggest that we vote on this amendment that's on the table open to correspondence.

1666
02:42:58.814 --> 02:42:59.790
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, ma'am, I agree with you.

1667
02:43:00.191 --> 02:43:14.646
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, could you please call the roll on the now amended amendment brought forward by Councilor Smith with changes from Councilor Green and myself, which Haley has up before us and which I believe the clerk has a copy of?

1668
02:43:14.694 --> 02:43:18.957
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think we need to be able to see what we're talking about because we, we can't scroll with her.

1669
02:43:19.566 --> 02:43:19.693
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1670
02:43:19.967 --> 02:43:20.847
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Hayley, could you slowly—.

1671
02:43:20.847 --> 02:43:22.433
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's been a mess since minute 1.

1672
02:43:23.587 --> 02:43:24.004
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That it has.

1673
02:43:24.629 --> 02:43:27.161
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could you slowly scroll through so folks can see this?

1674
02:43:27.657 --> 02:43:29.372
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, and I can also just abbreviate.

1675
02:43:29.436 --> 02:43:31.247
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So there was a title change.

1676
02:43:32.001 --> 02:43:35.861
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first whereas in the original resolution was struck.

1677
02:43:37.289 --> 02:43:41.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The term the mayor was removed from the executive order piece here.

1678
02:43:42.977 --> 02:43:45.797
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>New strategies included as part of this.

1679
02:43:46.112 --> 02:43:59.272
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Whereas statement, the bulk of the rest of the original remains the same until we get to the end of the whereas statements, where the final two whereases are now stricken as well.

1680
02:44:01.489 --> 02:44:05.157
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And yep, okay.

1681
02:44:05.805 --> 02:44:07.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>The two parts that are being oh you want to read the stricken part?

1682
02:44:07.970 --> 02:44:08.147
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Got it.

1683
02:44:08.375 --> 02:44:08.617
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1684
02:44:09.263 --> 02:44:10.184
<v Loretta Smith>Back to my committee.

1685
02:44:10.314 --> 02:44:11.349
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, because I'm okay with either.

1686
02:44:11.561 --> 02:44:14.716
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just don't think we can get through all the conversation today.

1687
02:44:14.977 --> 02:44:16.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know, it's a mess.

1688
02:44:24.380 --> 02:44:25.182
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And thank you, Haley.

1689
02:45:20.515 --> 02:45:21.613
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, folks are ready.

1690
02:45:21.681 --> 02:45:22.396
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's keep scrolling.

1691
02:45:26.170 --> 02:45:38.566
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then I did, uh, correct in the now therefore section where it now just reads Portland City Council rather than Portland City Council Labor Workforce Committee per our legal advisement.

1692
02:45:43.479 --> 02:45:45.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm rather confused.

1693
02:45:59.844 --> 02:46:02.132
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had 2 friendly amendments accepted.

1694
02:46:05.745 --> 02:46:15.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My quick scan earlier was that they were, but if we're going to— One of the changes was in number 4 right here, addition of RWIA.

1695
02:46:15.943 --> 02:46:23.461
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then the second change that I took up was the, uh, resorting this back to a presentation to City Council or a relevant committee.

1696
02:46:24.844 --> 02:46:32.924
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we may have missed one or two of the places where it called out a committee, but if we're going to take this up another day, I'm happy to bring a specific redlined version for those other ones.

1697
02:46:34.461 --> 02:46:44.220
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And those are namely just at the bottom here and here where it just states that the Labor and Workforce Development Committee acknowledges the funding piece and then is going to be supporting the request.

1698
02:46:44.284 --> 02:46:46.745
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I can revert those if that's preferred.

1699
02:46:47.583 --> 02:46:47.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please.

1700
02:46:47.743 --> 02:46:51.088
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, point of information, those are both going back to City Council to say City Council.

1701
02:46:51.847 --> 02:46:52.023
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1702
02:46:53.308 --> 02:46:53.629
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1703
02:46:54.977 --> 02:46:59.102
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, we were about to vote, but we now have 2 hands up.

1704
02:46:59.165 --> 02:47:02.905
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's— okay, Councilor Novick, is yours for after the vote?

1705
02:47:03.483 --> 02:47:04.702
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, no, it's before.

1706
02:47:04.766 --> 02:47:07.157
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just want to be a broken record.

1707
02:47:07.592 --> 02:47:21.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just want to verify that staff said that, um, some of these amendments, including the ones that I certainly agree with in concept, like setting the impact of project labor agreements might affect the timing and the cost of the studies.

1708
02:47:22.256 --> 02:47:23.091
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is correct.

1709
02:47:23.395 --> 02:47:29.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>It can definitely impact if we won't— we don't engage with the previously negotiated contractor.

1710
02:47:29.474 --> 02:47:35.584
<v Jamie Dunphy>It could adversely affect the timeline, not by months, it may be over a year.

1711
02:47:36.289 --> 02:47:43.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>I mean, the timeline, given that we don't have a deadline, maybe is not as relevant, but I am worried about the cost as well.

1712
02:47:43.611 --> 02:47:45.433
<v Jamie Dunphy>The cost can be significantly more.

1713
02:47:47.110 --> 02:47:51.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that response— was that response though to adding Regional Workforce Equity Act?

1714
02:47:51.514 --> 02:47:52.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, that is to—.

1715
02:47:53.128 --> 02:47:56.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Some of the other concerns that were raised that we've not yet incorporated.

1716
02:47:56.259 --> 02:48:02.958
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that we can have a conversation with those parties and come to some sort of understanding about the necessity and need.

1717
02:48:04.450 --> 02:48:07.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, colleagues, we really need to move to a vote.

1718
02:48:07.493 --> 02:48:08.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy.

1719
02:48:08.907 --> 02:48:11.509
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I just want to note that I think we're missing adjectives in this.

1720
02:48:11.845 --> 02:48:14.832
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, we will have an opportunity to make further amendments.

1721
02:48:15.298 --> 02:48:16.197
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so—.

1722
02:48:16.679 --> 02:48:18.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

1723
02:48:18.829 --> 02:48:19.938
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just a question about that.

1724
02:48:20.034 --> 02:48:30.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will— it'll come back, and we can also talk about LERC and what the role of LERC might be here, that they may be able to either, you know, work with the contractor.

1725
02:48:30.309 --> 02:48:31.722
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, let's vote on what's before us.

1726
02:48:35.888 --> 02:48:45.735
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Keelan, could you please call the roll on the now amended amendment which is before us, which Haley has the official copy of?

1727
02:48:45.896 --> 02:48:48.058
<v Jamie Dunphy>Clark?

1728
02:48:48.608 --> 02:48:48.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1729
02:48:49.351 --> 02:48:49.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green?

1730
02:48:50.302 --> 02:48:50.352
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1731
02:48:51.061 --> 02:48:51.497
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman?

1732
02:48:51.917 --> 02:48:52.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1733
02:48:52.887 --> 02:48:53.031
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos?

1734
02:48:53.291 --> 02:48:53.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1735
02:48:54.118 --> 02:48:54.441
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dunphy?

1736
02:48:54.831 --> 02:48:54.959
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1737
02:48:55.430 --> 02:48:55.818
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

1738
02:48:56.531 --> 02:48:56.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1739
02:48:57.358 --> 02:48:57.486
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Knoll?

1740
02:48:58.070 --> 02:48:58.248
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1741
02:48:58.799 --> 02:48:59.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan?

1742
02:48:59.367 --> 02:48:59.415
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1743
02:49:00.176 --> 02:49:00.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Koyama Lane?

1744
02:49:01.165 --> 02:49:01.245
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1745
02:49:01.972 --> 02:49:01.988
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1746
02:49:02.780 --> 02:49:02.828
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1747
02:49:03.603 --> 02:49:03.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>Nay.

1748
02:49:03.829 --> 02:49:04.006
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1749
02:49:04.411 --> 02:49:12.316
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The amendment is approved with 11 yes votes and 1 no vote.

1750
02:49:13.040 --> 02:49:13.362
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1751
02:49:15.215 --> 02:49:16.084
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1752
02:49:16.986 --> 02:49:17.871
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Madam President.

1753
02:49:18.015 --> 02:49:28.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm looking forward to getting the opportunity to work on this a little bit more, including the, the point that Councilor Dunphy just raised, including the whereas clauses and some of the things things that Councilor Clark and others have mentioned as well.

1754
02:49:29.346 --> 02:49:39.764
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, it is clear we're not going to be able to do that in this council today, and given the advice from Councilor Smith on where to take it, I move to refer this back to the Labor and Workforce Development Committee.

1755
02:49:43.069 --> 02:49:45.536
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, unless you'd like to second that, Councilor.

1756
02:49:45.715 --> 02:49:46.980
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not seconding it.

1757
02:49:47.158 --> 02:49:50.778
<v Loretta Smith>I want this to be approved, and we can talk about that other stuff on another amendment.

1758
02:49:51.957 --> 02:49:53.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Your amendment was just approved, Councilor.

1759
02:49:54.931 --> 02:49:56.980
<v Loretta Smith>So what are we sending back to?

1760
02:49:57.416 --> 02:50:02.841
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The now amended version so that these other topics can be discussed.

1761
02:50:03.164 --> 02:50:08.925
<v Loretta Smith>So, so we're not passing it as a go, we are bringing it back to committee.

1762
02:50:08.974 --> 02:50:13.772
<v Loretta Smith>I thought we were bringing back the other issues in a different, in a different resolution.

1763
02:50:13.950 --> 02:50:24.802
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, what I'm hearing is that there's a lot of interest in discussing other amendments, and we are 15 minutes over when I had said we needed to move on to the next agenda item.

1764
02:50:25.397 --> 02:50:38.579
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So what I would like us to do, what I thought that I was asking you a moment ago, was would you prefer to take up some of those other discussions before we pass the final in committee or at a future council meeting?

1765
02:50:38.644 --> 02:50:41.438
<v Loretta Smith>It wasn't clear on me until after you— after we took the vote.

1766
02:50:41.630 --> 02:50:43.911
<v Loretta Smith>So no, I didn't understand what you were saying.

1767
02:50:44.408 --> 02:50:44.584
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1768
02:50:44.986 --> 02:50:50.997
<v Loretta Smith>I think if we're going to do something, and this is the problem, I just found out about this No, listen to me.

1769
02:50:51.094 --> 02:50:52.780
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal just made an amendment.

1770
02:50:52.827 --> 02:50:54.301
<v Loretta Smith>I know, but I'm trying to get a point of order.

1771
02:50:55.095 --> 02:50:55.532
<v Loretta Smith>Point of order.

1772
02:50:55.662 --> 02:51:03.879
<v Loretta Smith>I just got this, and I did a friendly amendment to Councilor Green because I thought it was good for this, for this resolution.

1773
02:51:04.539 --> 02:51:12.628
<v Loretta Smith>And now people are not wanting to do it, and you're trying to bring it back to my committee when we should just pass it so we can get this stuff done.

1774
02:51:14.700 --> 02:51:21.148
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, we don't have the time to take up all of the discussion that I hear our colleagues wanting to take up today.

1775
02:51:21.245 --> 02:51:26.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I can hold this over to another council date, or we can send it back to committee for more work.

1776
02:51:27.478 --> 02:51:34.657
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am happy to do either of those, but I don't think that we have the time to get through all of the discussion folks want to have.

1777
02:51:34.962 --> 02:51:36.325
<v Loretta Smith>Send it to another council date.

1778
02:51:36.933 --> 02:51:37.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1779
02:51:37.270 --> 02:51:38.551
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll withdraw the motion.

1780
02:51:38.615 --> 02:51:39.417
<v Jamie Dunphy>I misunderstood.

1781
02:51:39.577 --> 02:51:39.801
<v Loretta Smith>Sorry.

1782
02:51:39.914 --> 02:51:41.709
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, so you misunderstood what?

1783
02:51:42.157 --> 02:51:43.311
<v Loretta Smith>So he misunderstood.

1784
02:51:43.440 --> 02:51:44.625
<v Loretta Smith>So we can take the vote.

1785
02:51:44.881 --> 02:51:48.470
<v Jamie Dunphy>No, no, no, I, that— I'm just withdrawing the motion to refer it back to committee.

1786
02:51:48.550 --> 02:51:50.954
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll let everybody else determine what happens next.

1787
02:51:51.370 --> 02:51:56.643
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So colleagues, I am going to hold this over to a future council date.

1788
02:51:57.347 --> 02:52:02.620
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we will bring it back as quickly as possible so that we can continue this discussion.

1789
02:52:03.277 --> 02:52:10.492
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If everybody who has brought up other ideas can please bring amendments Prefiled to that meeting.

1790
02:52:11.171 --> 02:52:12.576
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that would be very helpful.

1791
02:52:12.770 --> 02:52:26.994
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If stakeholders have other things you've brought up that you want us to consider, please find an advocate on council to work with and get that in writing before this comes back to full council so that when it next comes back, we can do straightforward work and get it passed.

1792
02:52:29.809 --> 02:52:33.708
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, do you need anything else for us to formally hold this over and move to the next agenda item?

1793
02:52:34.227 --> 02:52:34.358
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1794
02:52:34.629 --> 02:52:36.572
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could you please call the next agenda item?

1795
02:52:41.961 --> 02:52:51.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 7, adopt the Portland Urban Forest Plan to improve public health, build resilience to climate change, and promote environmental justice.

1796
02:52:51.790 --> 02:52:52.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1797
02:52:52.627 --> 02:53:07.486
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we were in the middle of debate on this item when we ended a previous meeting, and We had, I believe, 2 open sets of amendments.

1798
02:53:08.100 --> 02:53:12.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we had adopted some of Councilor Dunphy's amendments and had other amendments open.

1799
02:53:13.190 --> 02:53:16.013
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe we also have a Novick amendment open.

1800
02:53:17.078 --> 02:53:26.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So Councilor Dunphy, could you please start by letting us know which of your amendments are open and giving us a brief overview of what they do so we know where we're starting?

1801
02:53:28.106 --> 02:53:28.413
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absolutely.

1802
02:53:28.509 --> 02:53:31.915
<v Jamie Dunphy>My remaining 5 amendments that are on the table are in 2 chunks.

1803
02:53:32.123 --> 02:53:39.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have Dunphy Amendments 1, 2, and 3 as a package, and Dunphy Amendments 6 and 7 as a package.

1804
02:53:40.011 --> 02:53:53.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy Amendment 1, 2, and 3 would specifically— Dunphy Amendment 1 talks about completing a funding plan for ramping up annual project completion goals, prioritizing low-income, low- yes.

1805
02:53:53.889 --> 02:54:03.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then Amendment 3 adds that the pilot project will be focused on creating more shade residential neighborhoods, reporting annually starting in November of '27 on locations, funding strategies, innovation, district-level key performance indicators.

1806
02:54:03.709 --> 02:54:14.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy 2 simply adds ensuring that at least one pilot area of the pilot project is included in District 1 for the street tree maintenance program.

1807
02:54:14.750 --> 02:54:26.703
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Dunphy Amendment 3 adds the phrase phased to prioritize low-income and low-canopy areas as it pertains to street tree maintenance program.

1808
02:54:27.283 --> 02:54:37.137
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, you also note that in the official documents on the file, we have received specific feedback from Public Works about this.

1809
02:54:37.844 --> 02:54:44.237
<v Jamie Dunphy>They have across the board said that these are minor and can be accommodated.

1810
02:54:46.917 --> 02:54:54.433
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so that is Dunphy Package 1, which incorporates amendments 1, 2, and 3, and I would move those as an amendment.

1811
02:54:55.396 --> 02:54:58.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, do we— I believe these were already open and moved in second.

1812
02:54:58.993 --> 02:54:59.474
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think you're right.

1813
02:55:00.051 --> 02:55:01.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So those are on the table.

1814
02:55:01.882 --> 02:55:03.552
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, these are all the Dunphys.

1815
02:55:04.049 --> 02:55:05.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's Dunphy 1 through 3.

1816
02:55:05.977 --> 02:55:09.541
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have Dunphy 6 and 7 open as a package, and then we have Novick.

1817
02:55:09.990 --> 02:55:12.816
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I believe yours is one amendment with 3 things in it.

1818
02:55:12.977 --> 02:55:16.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Should I Let's explain 6 and 7 also really quick.

1819
02:55:16.490 --> 02:55:18.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, quickly detail 6 and 7, please.

1820
02:55:18.121 --> 02:55:21.310
<v Jamie Dunphy>6, 7.

1821
02:55:21.975 --> 02:55:30.894
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy Amendment 6 is specific to their performance measures and includes requesting specifically, adds 3 words, by council district.

1822
02:55:31.217 --> 02:55:40.101
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is to specifically give us a report about how these performance measures are being used or the plans for going into it broken out by district.

1823
02:55:40.807 --> 02:55:48.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Dunphy Amendment 7 creates a new cross-bureau team to propose potential permanent funding mechanisms to council.

1824
02:55:51.250 --> 02:55:53.065
<v Jamie Dunphy>And those would be together as well.

1825
02:55:53.713 --> 02:55:54.621
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1826
02:55:54.686 --> 02:55:57.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Novick, please remind folks your amendments.

1827
02:55:58.489 --> 02:56:02.275
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, actually I had 2.

1828
02:56:02.423 --> 02:56:10.334
<v Jamie Dunphy>One is to Action Item 2-3, And I'm going to pass them out now.

1829
02:56:15.752 --> 02:56:32.737
<v Jamie Dunphy>Item 2-3 would take the— I mean, the amendment to Item 2-3 of the recommendations would take the current language, fund and implement a comprehensive citywide street tree maintenance program by November 2027, establish a plan for the city to assume legal and financial responsibility for street trees.

1830
02:56:32.786 --> 02:56:32.818
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1831
02:56:33.272 --> 02:56:42.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>Etc., and replace that with sustainably fund and implement— replace that with the language that was originally in the plan that came to committee.

1832
02:56:43.281 --> 02:56:43.602
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1833
02:56:43.763 --> 02:56:55.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>And make it sustainably fund and implement a comprehensive citywide street tree maintenance program to reduce financial burdens for Portlanders, improve the health and safety of the city's street trees, and support habitat connectivity.

1834
02:56:56.355 --> 02:57:00.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>I note that Councilor Dunphy and I are both proposing amendments to this section.

1835
02:57:00.559 --> 02:57:04.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, if we're voting in his first, I would vote for his 'cause I think it's better than what we have now.

1836
02:57:04.909 --> 02:57:06.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>But then I would move to revert to the original language.

1837
02:57:07.569 --> 02:57:24.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>And my concern here is that although the Portland Clean Energy Fund is already paying for the first 5 years of a program to take over street tree maintenance, I— the Clean Energy Fund moves in 5-year investment plans.

1838
02:57:24.969 --> 02:57:24.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>5-Year.

1839
02:57:26.532 --> 02:57:48.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I personally am concerned about the idea that taking— although I think it would be great if the city could take over the burden of maintaining street trees, I do not want to presume that for the foreseeable future, taking over the burden of street trees from people in rich areas is more important than anything else we might do with Clean Energy Fund money.

1840
02:57:48.966 --> 02:57:57.237
<v Jamie Dunphy>And to the argument I've heard from some people that, well, it doesn't say the Clean Energy Fund, my response is, or where the heck else is the money going to come from?

1841
02:57:57.975 --> 02:58:21.906
<v Jamie Dunphy>On item 2.4, I would replace the current language, identify financing strategies that include new funding sources, cost-saving measures, and other ways to improve pedestrian accessibility and reduce costs to property owners for repairing sidewalks damaged by trees, and by 2028, develop a plan for how the city could assume legal and financial responsibility for street tree-related sidewalk repairs that takes into account blah, blah, blah.

1842
02:58:22.917 --> 02:58:38.864
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would replace that with the original language in the plan, which was simply identify financing strategies, cost-saving measures, and other ways to improve pedestrian accessibility and reduce costs to property owners for repairing sidewalks damaged by trees.

1843
02:58:39.539 --> 02:58:47.529
<v Jamie Dunphy>And again, I think that ideally the city should be paying to address damage to sidewalks caused by trees.

1844
02:58:48.188 --> 02:59:08.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>But in a context where we have a transportation system that is woefully underfunded, where we have our streets literally falling apart and no current plan to fix them, I am concerned about language that to me implies that we are assuming that the city is going to assume legal and financial responsibility for sidewalk repairs.

1845
02:59:09.117 --> 02:59:16.153
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I realize the language doesn't say definitively, yes, we will, but I'm not comfortable saying we should develop a plan for it until we've decided we're going to do that.

1846
02:59:16.218 --> 02:59:21.555
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor And I think that such a decision should be preceded by a debate about other priorities.

1847
02:59:23.736 --> 02:59:24.432
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1848
02:59:24.722 --> 02:59:28.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we had these 3 packages on the table when we left before.

1849
02:59:29.136 --> 02:59:36.334
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In the order we were planning to take them, we were going to do them in that order, Dunphy 1 through 3, Dunphy 6 through 7, and then Novick 1 and 2.

1850
02:59:37.106 --> 02:59:41.356
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I would like to move us to discussion on Dunphy 1 through 3.

1851
02:59:41.550 --> 02:59:41.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Otto.

1852
02:59:42.308 --> 02:59:43.290
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see that you're in the queue.

1853
02:59:45.209 --> 02:59:47.640
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Were you in the queue on a different piece or on a broader topic?

1854
02:59:47.737 --> 02:59:51.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>I was going to make a comment about Councilor Novick's amendments.

1855
02:59:51.635 --> 02:59:54.988
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can we do them one section at a time so that we can keep our comments cohesive?

1856
02:59:55.314 --> 02:59:55.655
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1857
02:59:56.790 --> 02:59:59.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any discussion on Dunphy 1 through 3?

1858
03:00:02.835 --> 03:00:06.315
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm going to give folks a moment because I know we're warming back up on this topic.

1859
03:00:08.742 --> 03:00:17.565
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll note while we take a moment that we had originally intended to end this meeting by 1 o'clock so that we could have a half an hour break and start our work session at 1:30.

1860
03:00:18.000 --> 03:00:20.855
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think in order to complete this work, we will need a little more time.

1861
03:00:21.452 --> 03:00:23.939
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope we can finish this by 1:15.

1862
03:00:24.615 --> 03:00:26.343
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are gonna go until 1:15.

1863
03:00:26.391 --> 03:00:31.361
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If anybody needs a break, please just take it on your own time so we can get through this.

1864
03:00:31.489 --> 03:00:36.680
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will then break from 1:15 to 1:45. to give everybody a half-hour lunch break.

1865
03:00:37.162 --> 03:00:40.615
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will start our next work, our work session 15 minutes late.

1866
03:00:41.162 --> 03:00:46.981
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Acting Administrator Biery is going to somehow figure out how to shave 15 minutes off.

1867
03:00:47.063 --> 03:00:51.808
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for the thumbs up before I said this out loud that you would try to do this.

1868
03:00:51.906 --> 03:00:52.602
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate it.

1869
03:00:54.734 --> 03:00:56.184
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, I stalled enough.

1870
03:00:56.282 --> 03:00:56.853
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's okay.

1871
03:00:57.016 --> 03:00:58.240
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Madam President.

1872
03:00:59.040 --> 03:01:04.861
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Dunphy, I've read your amendments and we've had a lot of conversations about this.

1873
03:01:04.941 --> 03:01:14.115
<v Jamie Dunphy>Obviously it was in the committee and I'm looking out at the urban forestry staff and I think what I thought is, I thought they were already planning to do these things that you're mentioning.

1874
03:01:14.181 --> 03:01:18.004
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I guess I'm confused on, you're nodding your heads.

1875
03:01:18.262 --> 03:01:18.614
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is a—.

1876
03:01:19.001 --> 03:01:20.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Why are these necessary?

1877
03:01:21.074 --> 03:01:26.135
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, there's a lot of plans that the city has where in the body it talks about prioritizing district parks.

1878
03:01:26.200 --> 03:01:29.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>District 1, East Portland, low-income areas, low shade, all these sort of things.

1879
03:01:29.747 --> 03:01:32.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm trying to be explicit about it in the individual notes.

1880
03:01:33.040 --> 03:01:43.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will just mention that, for example, PCEF dollars throughout the entire program explicitly say that they are prioritizing low-income areas of the city and heat islands.

1881
03:01:43.412 --> 03:01:51.601
<v Jamie Dunphy>But if you look at the actual dollar breakdown of where dollars are being invested, we are about 50% of compared to Districts 2 or 3.

1882
03:01:53.384 --> 03:01:56.099
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I want to be explicit wherever possible.

1883
03:01:56.324 --> 03:02:04.341
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely, I fully believe that the urban forest plan will address this and the work generally will be guided by these principles.

1884
03:02:04.453 --> 03:02:08.245
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just want to be explicit about it in every situation that I think is relevant.

1885
03:02:08.389 --> 03:02:10.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, I'm glad we are having this conversation.

1886
03:02:10.622 --> 03:02:15.731
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I've been listening to urban forestry for a minute, and I always hear them talk about everything that you just said.

1887
03:02:16.198 --> 03:02:18.575
<v Jamie Dunphy>So it's almost like we're getting a friendly amendment from the city.

1888
03:02:19.632 --> 03:02:25.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, ladies and gentlemen, they're all going like this.

1889
03:02:25.177 --> 03:02:26.251
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, thank you.

1890
03:02:26.540 --> 03:02:27.661
<v Jamie Dunphy>I guess that's all I need to talk about.

1891
03:02:27.740 --> 03:02:28.542
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1892
03:02:28.606 --> 03:02:29.200
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green?

1893
03:02:30.513 --> 03:02:40.865
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I just wanted to say briefly I support these amendments, uh, because I think it's— it is important to be explicit about, um, where we want to make our investments with priority.

1894
03:02:41.250 --> 03:02:44.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, it is unequivocally hotter on the east side of Portland.

1895
03:02:44.711 --> 03:02:45.353
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just a fact.

1896
03:02:46.317 --> 03:02:54.774
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it's also the same reason I supported SIP, where we were being very explicit on sidewalk prioritization that affects District 4.

1897
03:02:55.505 --> 03:03:00.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it's also fair to say District 1 is in sore need of infrastructure called trees.

1898
03:03:00.670 --> 03:03:02.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that's why I'm supporting this today, guys.

1899
03:03:05.608 --> 03:03:06.325
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1900
03:03:06.424 --> 03:03:09.606
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any further debate on Dunphy 1 through 3?

1901
03:03:11.583 --> 03:03:14.183
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

1902
03:03:14.814 --> 03:03:15.218
<v Loretta Smith>Clark?

1903
03:03:15.444 --> 03:03:15.605
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1904
03:03:17.075 --> 03:03:17.286
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green?

1905
03:03:17.706 --> 03:03:17.754
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1906
03:03:19.709 --> 03:03:19.968
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman?

1907
03:03:20.293 --> 03:03:20.456
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1908
03:03:21.350 --> 03:03:21.576
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos?

1909
03:03:21.917 --> 03:03:21.967
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1910
03:03:22.745 --> 03:03:23.120
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy?

1911
03:03:23.379 --> 03:03:23.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1912
03:03:24.224 --> 03:03:24.581
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

1913
03:03:29.604 --> 03:03:29.765
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1914
03:03:30.731 --> 03:03:31.038
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan?

1915
03:03:31.457 --> 03:03:31.504
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1916
03:03:32.037 --> 03:03:33.453
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Koyama Lane?

1917
03:03:33.791 --> 03:03:33.840
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1918
03:03:34.693 --> 03:03:35.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>Murillo?

1919
03:03:35.563 --> 03:03:35.611
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1920
03:03:36.667 --> 03:03:37.476
<v Jamie Dunphy>Novick.

1921
03:03:37.540 --> 03:03:37.557
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1922
03:03:37.929 --> 03:03:38.316
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pirtle-Guiney.

1923
03:03:39.140 --> 03:03:39.302
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1924
03:03:40.111 --> 03:03:44.168
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The amendment is approved with 10 yes votes and 1 no vote.

1925
03:03:45.940 --> 03:03:46.582
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1926
03:03:47.417 --> 03:03:52.703
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy, could you, you actually, you overviewed amendments 6 through 7 for us.

1927
03:03:52.799 --> 03:03:58.277
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So colleagues, I would like us to take up any discussion or debate on Dunphy 6 through 7.

1928
03:04:02.200 --> 03:04:05.397
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'd just like them separated.

1929
03:04:05.959 --> 03:04:06.281
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1930
03:04:07.068 --> 03:04:08.081
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That was a motion to separate?

1931
03:04:08.595 --> 03:04:08.708
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yep.

1932
03:04:08.916 --> 03:04:11.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor, would you like us to take 6 first or 7 first?

1933
03:04:11.761 --> 03:04:12.435
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>6, Please.

1934
03:04:12.709 --> 03:04:14.734
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, can you remind us what it is?

1935
03:04:15.216 --> 03:04:23.040
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, uh, 6 amends the performance measures on page 71 to include a district-level lens for all performance measures.

1936
03:04:23.234 --> 03:04:27.331
<v Jamie Dunphy>It specifically adds 3 words, um, by council district.

1937
03:04:27.731 --> 03:04:32.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>This aligns with some of the work that is already going on in the Bureau about investments across the city.

1938
03:04:33.834 --> 03:04:34.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1939
03:04:34.476 --> 03:04:35.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

1940
03:04:36.226 --> 03:04:36.418
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

1941
03:04:36.498 --> 03:04:37.575
<v Jamie Dunphy>I appreciate separating them.

1942
03:04:37.702 --> 03:04:43.915
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have definitely appreciated the memo I received from the Parks and Public Works section.

1943
03:04:44.735 --> 03:04:49.375
<v Jamie Dunphy>My reason for separating is I do have concern around Dumphy 7.

1944
03:04:50.113 --> 03:05:00.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>In the response that I got from the Parks Bureau, really I respected what they had to say about maybe not putting themselves in the position to develop that funding strategy.

1945
03:05:00.827 --> 03:05:03.876
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I really value that they brought that up.

1946
03:05:04.349 --> 03:05:22.034
<v Jamie Dunphy>In the competing interests of city priorities, I think it best if we stop having smaller groups try and say this is the method, because all that ends up doing is having methods that are competing and not looking at the whole picture.

1947
03:05:22.084 --> 03:05:27.755
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because if your job is to serve— solve this one problem, I think you view it with a certain lens.

1948
03:05:27.804 --> 03:05:33.603
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm likely leaning toward a no vote on Dumphy 7.

1949
03:05:33.958 --> 03:05:41.380
<v Jamie Dunphy>While I understand his point, I do appreciate the Parks Bureau memo on this and their thinking about why it wasn't included originally.

1950
03:05:41.445 --> 03:05:42.344
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks, Councilor Dumphy.

1951
03:05:42.394 --> 03:05:45.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

1952
03:05:47.745 --> 03:05:51.532
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any discussion to Dunphy 6, which is the amendment before us on the table?

1953
03:05:56.049 --> 03:05:58.396
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Keelan, could you please call the roll on Dunphy 6?

1954
03:06:01.930 --> 03:06:02.414
<v Loretta Smith>Clark?

1955
03:06:02.800 --> 03:06:02.962
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1956
03:06:04.028 --> 03:06:04.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green?

1957
03:06:04.656 --> 03:06:04.674
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1958
03:06:05.626 --> 03:06:06.013
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman?

1959
03:06:06.207 --> 03:06:06.254
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1960
03:06:07.175 --> 03:06:07.547
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos?

1961
03:06:07.739 --> 03:06:07.852
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1962
03:06:08.450 --> 03:06:08.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy?

1963
03:06:09.015 --> 03:06:09.064
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1964
03:06:09.531 --> 03:06:09.887
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

1965
03:06:13.504 --> 03:06:13.635
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1966
03:06:14.156 --> 03:06:14.254
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1967
03:06:16.113 --> 03:06:16.277
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1968
03:06:17.663 --> 03:06:17.711
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1969
03:06:19.204 --> 03:06:19.254
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1970
03:06:20.756 --> 03:06:20.984
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

1971
03:06:23.021 --> 03:06:26.352
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The amendment is approved with 10 yes votes and 1 no vote.

1972
03:06:27.219 --> 03:06:27.921
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, colleagues.

1973
03:06:27.986 --> 03:06:30.040
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We now have Dunphy 7 before us.

1974
03:06:30.774 --> 03:06:32.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any discussion on Dunphy 7?

1975
03:06:39.423 --> 03:06:41.007
<v Eric Zimmerman>Ditto to Councilor Zimmerman's comments.

1976
03:06:44.569 --> 03:06:45.671
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, I had some notes written out.

1977
03:06:45.719 --> 03:06:51.634
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm next in the queue, but honestly, my concerns are quite similar as well, so I will just put myself in that category too.

1978
03:06:53.790 --> 03:06:55.354
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other discussion on Dunphy 7?

1979
03:06:57.090 --> 03:06:57.625
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy?

1980
03:06:57.690 --> 03:07:06.995
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I was wondering if, uh, uh, CFO Beery might be willing to speak about the financial plan for this and the concerns specifically here?

1981
03:07:08.440 --> 03:07:24.465
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm sorry, Councilor, I'm just not— For number 7, we are asking to convene a new cross-bureau workgroup on the financial plan for this.

1982
03:07:25.540 --> 03:07:31.561
<v Jamie Dunphy>There were some specific concerns about who's the right person?

1983
03:07:31.641 --> 03:07:34.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this puts it in CFO's position.

1984
03:07:35.013 --> 03:07:46.622
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so there was concern about whether or not that's the right position, whether there's an expense, whether that is something that is— Yeah, I guess I would just say, Councilor, I'm not prepared to talk about what those costs may be.

1985
03:07:46.751 --> 03:07:50.878
<v Jamie Dunphy>Certainly happy to accept that if that's the will of Council and take that forward.

1986
03:07:51.792 --> 03:07:56.898
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, we do have a lot of things going on at the city, and this will certainly compete for those limited resources.

1987
03:07:57.578 --> 03:08:01.818
<v Jamie Dunphy>But that's something I'm willing to accept and take forward as effectively as we can.

1988
03:08:03.659 --> 03:08:08.007
<v Jamie Dunphy>And colleagues, I hear the concern for sure, and this is not a hill I'm gonna die on.

1989
03:08:08.073 --> 03:08:11.381
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm still gonna vote for it, but, you know, vote however you wanna see.

1990
03:08:13.115 --> 03:08:13.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1991
03:08:13.929 --> 03:08:15.656
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other discussion on Dunphy 7?

1992
03:08:16.739 --> 03:08:18.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, let's move to a vote.

1993
03:08:19.092 --> 03:08:19.511
<v Loretta Smith>Clark?

1994
03:08:19.914 --> 03:08:20.058
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1995
03:08:21.105 --> 03:08:21.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green?

1996
03:08:22.154 --> 03:08:22.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1997
03:08:22.859 --> 03:08:23.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman?

1998
03:08:23.603 --> 03:08:24.009
<v Eric Zimmerman>Nope.

1999
03:08:24.963 --> 03:08:25.352
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos?

2000
03:08:25.692 --> 03:08:25.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2001
03:08:26.665 --> 03:08:27.004
<v Loretta Smith>Dunphy?

2002
03:08:27.313 --> 03:08:27.394
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2003
03:08:28.074 --> 03:08:28.431
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Smith?

2004
03:08:29.515 --> 03:08:29.791
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Kanal?

2005
03:08:30.325 --> 03:08:30.471
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2006
03:08:31.685 --> 03:08:31.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>Ryan?

2007
03:08:32.263 --> 03:08:32.408
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2008
03:08:34.176 --> 03:08:34.722
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Koyama Lane?

2009
03:08:35.220 --> 03:08:35.236
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2010
03:08:36.200 --> 03:08:36.747
<v Jamie Dunphy>Morillo?

2011
03:08:37.229 --> 03:08:37.278
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2012
03:08:38.049 --> 03:08:38.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>Novick?

2013
03:08:38.675 --> 03:08:38.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2014
03:08:40.218 --> 03:08:40.668
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pirtle-Guiney?

2015
03:08:41.979 --> 03:08:42.060
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2016
03:08:42.747 --> 03:08:46.980
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The amendment fails with 6 yes votes and 5 no votes.

2017
03:08:49.034 --> 03:08:49.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

2018
03:08:50.961 --> 03:08:53.738
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy, thank you for bringing forward all of those proposals.

2019
03:08:54.316 --> 03:09:02.585
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, we have your amendment number 1 on the table, which amends action item 2.3.

2020
03:09:02.683 --> 03:09:05.798
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any discussion to Novick 1?

2021
03:09:06.440 --> 03:09:07.227
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos.

2022
03:09:08.527 --> 03:09:13.697
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, we kind of ended the last meeting on this note, and I had had a couple of comments about it.

2023
03:09:14.310 --> 03:09:14.746
<v Jamie Dunphy>Back then.

2024
03:09:14.811 --> 03:09:17.577
<v Jamie Dunphy>It looks like this hasn't changed from the last time, right?

2025
03:09:17.641 --> 03:09:21.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So these amendments are exactly the same as they were proposed last time, yes?

2026
03:09:23.682 --> 03:09:30.981
<v Jamie Dunphy>I actually thought that one of them has changed, and I forget, to be honest, which one it is.

2027
03:09:33.894 --> 03:09:37.565
<v Jamie Dunphy>I can't remember whether I had alternate language for 2.3 or 2.4.

2028
03:09:38.052 --> 03:09:41.647
<v Jamie Dunphy>So what you have in writing is the I would look at both of them.

2029
03:09:41.793 --> 03:09:42.297
<v Jamie Dunphy>For sure.

2030
03:09:42.931 --> 03:09:48.078
<v Loretta Smith>I think still the general gist here for me is, I'll speak to.

2031
03:09:48.158 --> 03:09:55.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>So first I'll say that we talked about this a little bit last time, but a plan would be non-binding as it's currently written.

2032
03:09:55.564 --> 03:10:02.218
<v Jamie Dunphy>I know that we had some discussion with, you know, staff about it, but I remember that being one of the outcomes of that question.

2033
03:10:02.798 --> 03:10:11.765
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I understand why people are concerned about committing the city to anything that we don't feel that we have funding for, especially as we're staring down another brutal budget.

2034
03:10:12.167 --> 03:10:23.870
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I think the concern that I'm hearing, and I share, by removing this language and therefore the direction to make the plan, is that once we get those costs back, it's gonna actually take longer then to come up with the plan.

2035
03:10:24.384 --> 03:10:32.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So what advocates were trying to communicate is that they feel that we don't wanna unnecessarily delay the construction of the plan.

2036
03:10:33.100 --> 03:10:34.288
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's not binding as written.

2037
03:10:34.335 --> 03:10:34.545
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2038
03:10:35.426 --> 03:10:51.842
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it is, you know, having it constructed in a way that pushes and directs the city to make those plans now can include all of these other financial analyses, and we can have that broader policy and financial discussion.

2039
03:10:52.194 --> 03:11:00.514
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I will not be supporting these amendments for that reason, but I just wanted to add, lift up what I was understanding the advocates were saying, 'cause people had asked.

2040
03:11:00.643 --> 03:11:00.754
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2041
03:11:01.076 --> 03:11:04.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>They had questions about why they didn't support your amendments.

2042
03:11:04.959 --> 03:11:06.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is why, and that's also why I do not.

2043
03:11:07.055 --> 03:11:08.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I won't be voting for these.

2044
03:11:08.343 --> 03:11:08.665
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

2045
03:11:09.956 --> 03:11:10.665
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2046
03:11:10.745 --> 03:11:11.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

2047
03:11:13.650 --> 03:11:14.844
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Madam President.

2048
03:11:15.183 --> 03:11:25.457
<v Jamie Dunphy>I worked with several groups, the staff of PBOT and Parks, to develop this along with the advocates that are being referenced here.

2049
03:11:25.699 --> 03:11:27.320
<v Jamie Dunphy>So this amendment, this language.

2050
03:11:27.433 --> 03:11:32.375
<v Jamie Dunphy>The, the version that is now original to us today was an amendment that I put forward in committee.

2051
03:11:33.433 --> 03:11:43.093
<v Jamie Dunphy>I understand the concern around the idea that the text we currently have might be committing us to effectively doing whatever the plan says, sight unseen.

2052
03:11:43.222 --> 03:11:43.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I—.

2053
03:11:43.318 --> 03:11:47.138
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's not how I read it, but I think it is a legitimate, um, concern.

2054
03:11:47.811 --> 03:11:55.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also fully agree with Councilor Avalos about the idea that we're both creating an interim step and not thank you.

2055
03:11:56.549 --> 03:12:09.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>I had a suggested piece of text because I— it says establish a plan for the city to assume, and that appears to be both the actual text that's being changed here and where the concern actually lives.

2056
03:12:09.908 --> 03:12:13.227
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's not fixing text that references other text.

2057
03:12:13.420 --> 03:12:37.591
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I wanted to ask Councilor Novick if the— if a phrase such as, for example, develop a plan that would, if implemented, allow the city to assume, would resolve the concern around a establish being very directive in terms and potentially implying that it would be implemented no matter what.

2058
03:12:38.183 --> 03:12:53.691
<v Jamie Dunphy>And also by explicitly saying if implemented and putting that would in there, establish that there is a further decision point beyond this decision point for whether or not to I would say that I think that would be preferable to the language now.

2059
03:12:54.590 --> 03:13:16.603
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, I would prefer to simply go back to the original language that came to committee after a robust process, which the advocates all said was a good process, and which is more open-ended and says sustainably fund and implement a comprehensive citywide street tree maintenance program to reduce financial burdens for Portlanders, improve the health and safety of the city's street trees, and ensure that the city's and support had with that connectivity.

2060
03:13:17.438 --> 03:13:25.844
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm a little confused because I'm talking about 2.3 right now, I believe, and my understanding—.

2061
03:13:25.844 --> 03:13:26.022
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was aye.

2062
03:13:26.102 --> 03:13:29.054
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is not the amendment I'm seeing proposed in writing.

2063
03:13:29.454 --> 03:13:31.412
<v Jamie Dunphy>I saw the reversion in 2.4.

2064
03:13:31.941 --> 03:13:34.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, actually, I thought I did.

2065
03:13:34.668 --> 03:13:37.042
<v Jamie Dunphy>I— did you not get— I just, I just passed this out.

2066
03:13:37.188 --> 03:13:38.085
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, it's right there.

2067
03:13:38.536 --> 03:13:39.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>Did not even see that.

2068
03:13:39.577 --> 03:13:58.245
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, well, Given that, let me say that I am open if these amendments should fail as they currently are with the reversion to something like what I just said, establish a— sorry, develop a plan that would, if implemented, allow the city to assume for both 2-3 and 2-4.

2069
03:13:58.920 --> 03:14:04.993
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I do sincerely hope that that is an open conversation because I do hope that these 2 amendments fail as a result of that.

2070
03:14:05.361 --> 03:14:14.368
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think I will say that there was a you're right that there was a process that was developed and went through to get to this point.

2071
03:14:15.058 --> 03:14:23.629
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also praise the community engagement work that Malcolm Hoover and team, along with, I think it was CELS, did in developing this.

2072
03:14:24.143 --> 03:14:37.875
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I also will say that the process to get to these amendments was equally robust in terms of working with advocates, working with PBOT staff in one case, working with Parks and all the cases, and they are the ones who actually wrote this text.

2073
03:14:38.100 --> 03:14:39.807
<v Jamie Dunphy>It wasn't coming out of a council office.

2074
03:14:39.871 --> 03:14:41.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>It wasn't coming out of the advocates.

2075
03:14:41.804 --> 03:14:46.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was actually city staff that developed the text that is where we are now.

2076
03:14:46.226 --> 03:14:48.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'll be voting no on both of these.

2077
03:14:48.058 --> 03:14:55.802
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm open if they should fail to having a conversation about how to improve it while still retaining the, well, everything Councilor Avalos said, so I won't repeat it.

2078
03:14:55.965 --> 03:14:56.158
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2079
03:14:58.412 --> 03:14:59.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2080
03:14:59.125 --> 03:14:59.756
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

2081
03:15:01.453 --> 03:15:08.487
<v Jamie Dunphy>In the interest of time, I'm just going to echo what Councilor Avalos and Councilor Kanal said and say that I will not be supporting these amendments.

2082
03:15:11.549 --> 03:15:12.242
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2083
03:15:13.586 --> 03:15:25.657
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, I share Councilor Novick's concerns about tying us to, uh, funding or, uh, legal liability before we're ready to do that.

2084
03:15:25.804 --> 03:15:32.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also think it is helpful to get plans in advance so that we can make those decisions well.

2085
03:15:32.649 --> 03:15:43.384
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, I will be supporting you on your first amendment because I do believe that the language there will get us a plan that we may be somewhat locked into.

2086
03:15:43.979 --> 03:15:53.060
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll note now so that I don't have to speak later that I will not be supporting the second amendment because there what I'm looking at is identifying financing strategies.

2087
03:15:53.109 --> 03:15:53.351
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2088
03:15:53.853 --> 03:15:56.156
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But not requiring that we move forward with them.

2089
03:15:56.206 --> 03:16:03.328
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I feel comfortable with the language that was changed in committee in the 2.4 section.

2090
03:16:04.834 --> 03:16:10.421
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any other discussion to Novick 1, which amends action item 2.3?

2091
03:16:12.668 --> 03:16:14.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

2092
03:16:16.796 --> 03:16:17.156
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Roll call.

2093
03:16:21.127 --> 03:16:21.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2094
03:16:22.177 --> 03:16:22.405
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green.

2095
03:16:23.165 --> 03:16:23.245
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Nay.

2096
03:16:24.637 --> 03:16:25.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman.

2097
03:16:25.332 --> 03:16:25.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2098
03:16:25.672 --> 03:16:26.772
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos.

2099
03:16:27.192 --> 03:16:27.434
<v Candace Avalos>Nay.

2100
03:16:28.389 --> 03:16:28.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dunphy.

2101
03:16:28.908 --> 03:16:29.136
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2102
03:16:29.980 --> 03:16:30.256
<v Loretta Smith>Smith.

2103
03:16:31.084 --> 03:16:40.625
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can I— Novick.

2104
03:16:40.930 --> 03:16:40.961
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2105
03:16:42.391 --> 03:16:42.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Guiney.

2106
03:16:43.099 --> 03:16:43.147
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2107
03:16:44.559 --> 03:16:49.195
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The amendment fails with 5 yes votes and 6 no votes.

2108
03:16:52.229 --> 03:16:57.675
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any discussion on Novick 2, which amends action item 2.4?

2109
03:16:59.280 --> 03:17:01.882
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

2110
03:17:04.097 --> 03:17:04.407
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Clark?

2111
03:17:04.815 --> 03:17:04.913
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2112
03:17:05.808 --> 03:17:06.183
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green?

2113
03:17:06.933 --> 03:17:07.096
<v Olivia Clark>No.

2114
03:17:08.270 --> 03:17:08.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman?

2115
03:17:08.970 --> 03:17:08.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2116
03:17:12.474 --> 03:17:12.715
<v Loretta Smith>Nay.

2117
03:17:13.004 --> 03:17:13.165
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2118
03:17:15.578 --> 03:17:16.415
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

2119
03:17:21.054 --> 03:17:21.183
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2120
03:17:25.015 --> 03:17:25.257
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2121
03:17:26.066 --> 03:17:26.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2122
03:17:27.031 --> 03:17:27.079
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2123
03:17:28.335 --> 03:17:28.899
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2124
03:17:29.704 --> 03:17:34.051
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The amendment fails with 4 yes votes and 7 no votes.

2125
03:17:34.711 --> 03:17:35.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2126
03:17:36.979 --> 03:17:41.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any discussion to the underlying urban forest plan?

2127
03:17:45.602 --> 03:17:47.117
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

2128
03:17:47.375 --> 03:18:01.007
<v Jamie Dunphy>So first, let me say that I stand by what I said a few moments ago, and I am still open if there is a desire to address that, to that change, 'cause I don't think that that loses any of the gains that have been made.

2129
03:18:01.435 --> 03:18:05.585
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, in terms of the, the text that was, in my view, improved in committee.

2130
03:18:06.323 --> 03:18:16.643
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, separately, I, I do think that there— it's worth noting that having property owners bear financial responsibility for street trees and street tree-related sidewalk repairs deepens and furthers inequities.

2131
03:18:17.460 --> 03:18:33.638
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I think that there is a clear argument that, that, um, accepting a street tree can create a liability for, um, people in lower-income— homeowners in lower- Lower-income neighborhoods because they may not know that they're going to have several thousand dollars around for repairs.

2132
03:18:34.700 --> 03:18:38.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>The city has a demographic profile on the website by neighborhood.

2133
03:18:39.905 --> 03:18:40.632
<v Jamie Dunphy>You can look at it.

2134
03:18:40.956 --> 03:18:42.993
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it's just neighborhood demographic profiles.

2135
03:18:43.058 --> 03:18:46.734
<v Jamie Dunphy>Civic Life, I think, maintains it where you can see a pretty clear correlation.

2136
03:18:46.845 --> 03:18:52.174
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's not perfect, but between the level of the percentage of people who live in poverty in each neighborhood.

2137
03:18:52.238 --> 03:18:52.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

2138
03:18:53.038 --> 03:18:55.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>Inversely to the percentage of tree canopy.

2139
03:18:56.532 --> 03:19:06.921
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so there are reasons for that that go in both directions causally as well as coming from a tertiary source.

2140
03:19:07.450 --> 03:19:12.484
<v Jamie Dunphy>There are parts of each of those that perpetuate the other inequity is a better way of putting that.

2141
03:19:13.125 --> 03:19:23.854
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'll also note that as you look at these as well, it's just a couple pages higher or lower, That, that also correlates with the percentage of poor owners of color in each of these neighborhoods as well.

2142
03:19:24.626 --> 03:19:30.113
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I want to look at options for maintaining our street trees and sidewalks beyond property owners footing the bill.

2143
03:19:30.788 --> 03:19:41.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>If a plan that we created allows for the exploration of adjustment by voter approval to any charter amendments, I'm open to that too.

2144
03:19:41.781 --> 03:19:46.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that's what the purpose of these amendments are about, is to Is to say, how would you get from here to there?

2145
03:19:47.077 --> 03:19:53.661
<v Jamie Dunphy>Identify a potential destination that we're interested in looking at and, and having staff say, what would it take to get there?

2146
03:19:53.740 --> 03:19:56.134
<v Jamie Dunphy>And what would it take to do each of the steps along the way?

2147
03:19:57.497 --> 03:20:07.676
<v Jamie Dunphy>If one of those steps fails, and sometimes that require— would require an adjustment, sometimes it would require completely giving up on it in the case of a charter restriction.

2148
03:20:08.094 --> 03:20:15.272
<v Jamie Dunphy>But that doesn't mean that we shouldn't at least say, hey, if there's a charter restriction, It is theoretically possible to refer something to the ballot to change that charter.

2149
03:20:15.759 --> 03:20:19.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then if voters agree, then it's a good idea because voters said so.

2150
03:20:20.483 --> 03:20:31.862
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think that we often get a little too stuck in how things already are in this building instead of being willing to trust the voters on it in certain scenarios.

2151
03:20:31.911 --> 03:20:36.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think while we have limitations in terms of the funding for how to get there, that's really important.

2152
03:20:36.799 --> 03:20:36.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Laura?

2153
03:20:37.448 --> 03:20:40.843
<v Jamie Dunphy>In the big picture, we can't make a decision without doing first the research.

2154
03:20:41.325 --> 03:20:47.379
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think these improvements that we've already made, getting locked in through approval of the Urban Forest Plan, will help us to do that.

2155
03:20:47.523 --> 03:20:49.097
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'll leave it at that.

2156
03:20:49.259 --> 03:20:49.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2157
03:20:51.587 --> 03:20:52.246
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2158
03:20:52.407 --> 03:20:53.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

2159
03:20:53.692 --> 03:20:59.358
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just wanted to say that I very much appreciated the suggestion that Councilor Kanal made earlier on changing language.

2160
03:20:59.486 --> 03:21:06.040
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if he wanted to move his proposed change language as an amendment, I would be happy to second.

2161
03:21:06.393 --> 03:21:17.343
<v Jamie Dunphy>In addition to that, I'd like to say that I appreciate those of you who have said that despite my concerns about how it might be interpreted, none of this language commits us to do anything.

2162
03:21:17.953 --> 03:21:26.512
<v Jamie Dunphy>And as a result of that and the fact that we've had a robust discussion, I am planning to, however it winds up, voting to approve the urban forestry plan as a whole.

2163
03:21:27.251 --> 03:21:28.198
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2164
03:21:28.711 --> 03:21:29.337
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2165
03:21:29.417 --> 03:21:33.706
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I put myself in the queue because Councilors Kanal and Novick are bumping this to each other.

2166
03:21:33.770 --> 03:21:58.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as the person who just said that I don't wanna bind us to anything, but I do want the plans, I will motion that we strike in action item 2/3 the word establish after by November 2027 and insert the language develop a plan that would, if implemented, Plan for the city to assume legal and financial responsibility.

2167
03:21:58.477 --> 03:22:01.959
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess we're, we're crossing out establish a both there.

2168
03:22:02.183 --> 03:22:03.226
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And replacing it with?

2169
03:22:03.787 --> 03:22:16.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're crossing out establish a in between November 2027 and plan and replacing it with develop a plan that would, comma, if implemented, comma, and then it continues, plan for the city to assume.

2170
03:22:17.825 --> 03:22:20.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe that's what Councilor Kanal said before.

2171
03:22:20.940 --> 03:22:24.253
<v Jamie Dunphy>I actually said all but the last verb there, which was allow.

2172
03:22:24.558 --> 03:22:28.772
<v Jamie Dunphy>Develop a plan that would, comma, if implemented, comma, allow the city to assume.

2173
03:22:28.949 --> 03:22:30.781
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ah, allow the city to assume.

2174
03:22:31.521 --> 03:22:31.713
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2175
03:22:32.261 --> 03:22:34.236
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll second that if that's what you're moving.

2176
03:22:34.364 --> 03:22:43.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So colleagues, we have crossed out establish a plan for and replaced it with develop a plan that would, comma, if implemented, comma, allow.

2177
03:22:44.365 --> 03:22:45.975
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that was in both 2.3 and 2.4?

2178
03:22:46.552 --> 03:22:48.270
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was doing that just in 2.3.

2179
03:22:48.613 --> 03:22:51.652
<v Steve Novick>I'll second it anyway, but—.

2180
03:22:51.652 --> 03:22:53.084
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Would you like it in 2.4 also?

2181
03:22:53.199 --> 03:22:54.908
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was just trying to move us along here.

2182
03:22:56.925 --> 03:22:59.224
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, in 2.3, seconded by Councilor Kanal.

2183
03:22:59.289 --> 03:23:01.102
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Murillo, are you in the queue for debate?

2184
03:23:02.627 --> 03:23:03.305
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yep.

2185
03:23:03.369 --> 03:23:03.886
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

2186
03:23:03.998 --> 03:23:04.466
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, great.

2187
03:23:05.208 --> 03:23:24.726
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I feel like this is watering down what this proposal was meant to be for when we were talking about it during the climate committee, something that came up is that the city, we are obsessed with making plans to make plans to make plans, and I literally cannot take it anymore.

2188
03:23:25.290 --> 03:23:29.370
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are we gonna plant trees and protect our canopy?

2189
03:23:29.515 --> 03:23:35.032
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And are we committing to that as a value and as a thing that East Portland needs and that all of our districts need?

2190
03:23:35.081 --> 03:23:37.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are we going to commit to being climate resilient or not?

2191
03:23:37.855 --> 03:23:42.496
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because the city has already done numerous studies on our tree canopy and what needs to be done.

2192
03:23:43.155 --> 03:23:50.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So the only question is, are we going to actually put our money where our mouth is and commit to making this work?

2193
03:23:51.584 --> 03:23:55.904
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I feel like this amendment further waters it down again to a plan to create a plan.

2194
03:23:56.802 --> 03:24:02.872
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just— unless I can be convinced otherwise that maybe I'm reading this wrong, I think I'm probably going to be a no on this.

2195
03:24:02.921 --> 03:24:03.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2196
03:24:05.524 --> 03:24:06.542
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2197
03:24:06.867 --> 03:24:07.641
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos?

2198
03:24:08.579 --> 03:24:10.486
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm getting the same read as Councilor Morillo.

2199
03:24:10.729 --> 03:24:12.152
<v Jamie Dunphy>I appreciate the efforts.

2200
03:24:12.264 --> 03:24:17.816
<v Jamie Dunphy>I know the intentions, but I think that it is written well as is.

2201
03:24:18.477 --> 03:24:21.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would like to keep the language, so I will be voting no on this amendment.

2202
03:24:23.606 --> 03:24:24.270
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2203
03:24:24.351 --> 03:24:28.849
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any other discussion on this amendment?

2204
03:24:30.608 --> 03:24:32.496
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing none, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

2205
03:24:34.079 --> 03:24:34.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Clark.

2206
03:24:34.924 --> 03:24:34.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2207
03:24:35.918 --> 03:24:36.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green.

2208
03:24:38.698 --> 03:24:38.713
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2209
03:24:38.961 --> 03:24:40.777
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sorry, was that aye or nay?

2210
03:24:42.668 --> 03:24:43.781
<v Jamie Dunphy>What do you want it to be?

2211
03:24:44.183 --> 03:24:45.506
<v Jamie Dunphy>No, it's, it's aye.

2212
03:24:46.119 --> 03:24:46.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2213
03:24:48.602 --> 03:24:48.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman.

2214
03:24:49.247 --> 03:24:49.296
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2215
03:24:50.311 --> 03:24:50.524
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos.

2216
03:24:50.736 --> 03:24:50.950
<v Candace Avalos>Nay.

2217
03:24:52.436 --> 03:24:52.730
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dunphy.

2218
03:24:53.074 --> 03:24:53.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

2219
03:24:54.644 --> 03:24:54.938
<v Loretta Smith>Smith.

2220
03:24:57.418 --> 03:24:57.467
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2221
03:24:59.923 --> 03:24:59.971
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2222
03:25:02.993 --> 03:25:03.155
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2223
03:25:04.851 --> 03:25:05.013
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2224
03:25:05.755 --> 03:25:05.772
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2225
03:25:06.305 --> 03:25:06.352
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2226
03:25:07.370 --> 03:25:13.315
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The amendment is approved with 7 yes votes and 4 no votes.

2227
03:25:14.969 --> 03:25:18.244
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any other discussion to the Urban Forest Plan?

2228
03:25:21.472 --> 03:25:26.152
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm shocked, but— Councilor Ryan, are you raising your hand?

2229
03:25:26.200 --> 03:25:27.754
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just want to thank the Urban Forestry team.

2230
03:25:27.801 --> 03:25:29.036
<v Jamie Dunphy>You've been really patient with us.

2231
03:25:29.549 --> 03:25:30.558
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we just acknowledge that?

2232
03:25:30.751 --> 03:25:35.781
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you for showing up late at night and again late into this meeting.

2233
03:25:36.119 --> 03:25:37.801
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm hangry, so I should stop right there.

2234
03:25:37.977 --> 03:25:38.281
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

2235
03:25:39.019 --> 03:25:39.996
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2236
03:25:41.022 --> 03:25:52.702
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we would all echo the appreciation for our staff who have put this together and beared with us through a few different meetings here, and I think everybody up here has a lot they want to say, but we're trying to move quickly.

2237
03:25:53.780 --> 03:26:02.994
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, seeing no one else in the queue, and with apologies to all of the advocates and staff who have put a lot of time in and aren't getting to hear all of the remarks that we prepared, could you please call the roll?

2238
03:26:05.397 --> 03:26:05.639
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Clark.

2239
03:26:06.203 --> 03:26:06.252
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2240
03:26:06.944 --> 03:26:07.171
<v Jamie Dunphy>Green.

2241
03:26:08.138 --> 03:26:08.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2242
03:26:09.023 --> 03:26:09.490
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman.

2243
03:26:09.829 --> 03:26:09.990
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2244
03:26:10.716 --> 03:26:11.022
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos.

2245
03:26:11.441 --> 03:26:11.488
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2246
03:26:12.487 --> 03:26:12.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dunphy.

2247
03:26:13.132 --> 03:26:13.262
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2248
03:26:15.000 --> 03:26:15.356
<v Loretta Smith>Smith.

2249
03:26:15.550 --> 03:26:16.004
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Kanal.

2250
03:26:16.929 --> 03:26:18.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is on the actual underlying, right?

2251
03:26:19.587 --> 03:26:19.977
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Correct.

2252
03:26:20.024 --> 03:26:20.058
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2253
03:26:20.236 --> 03:26:20.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

2254
03:26:21.451 --> 03:26:21.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>Ryan.

2255
03:26:22.262 --> 03:26:22.440
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2256
03:26:23.299 --> 03:26:23.558
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Koyama Lane.

2257
03:26:23.961 --> 03:26:24.010
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2258
03:26:24.786 --> 03:26:25.254
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Morillo.

2259
03:26:25.496 --> 03:26:25.545
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2260
03:26:26.400 --> 03:26:26.820
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Novick.

2261
03:26:27.031 --> 03:26:27.079
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2262
03:26:28.001 --> 03:26:28.468
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pirtle-Guiney.

2263
03:26:30.649 --> 03:26:30.682
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2264
03:26:31.425 --> 03:26:35.272
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The resolution as amended is adopted with 11 yes votes.

2265
03:26:36.452 --> 03:26:38.166
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, colleagues.

2266
03:26:38.231 --> 03:26:44.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With nothing further on our agenda, we We actually made it by 1 o'clock, so Jonas, you get your full time.

2267
03:26:44.170 --> 03:26:50.340
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will be back here at 1:30 to begin our work session, and I will close today's City Council meeting.

2268
03:26:50.340 --> 03:26:50.379
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council adjourned.

