WEBVTT

1
00:06:47.230 --> 00:06:48.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good evening.

2
00:06:48.105 --> 00:06:50.841
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am calling to order tonight's City Council meeting.

3
00:06:51.019 --> 00:06:54.244
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 6:03 on Wednesday, October 15th.

4
00:06:54.730 --> 00:06:55.266
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

5
00:06:55.903 --> 00:06:57.680
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

6
00:06:58.656 --> 00:06:58.886
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Evening.

7
00:06:59.228 --> 00:06:59.651
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clerk.

8
00:07:07.740 --> 00:07:08.209
<v Robert Butler>Here.

9
00:07:09.050 --> 00:07:09.713
<v Keena Rubin>Here.

10
00:07:10.425 --> 00:07:11.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Present.

11
00:07:12.543 --> 00:07:12.882
<v James Lee>Here.

12
00:07:13.271 --> 00:07:13.708
<v Darlene Sherman>Smith.

13
00:07:14.550 --> 00:07:14.629
<v Robert Butler>Here.

14
00:07:15.100 --> 00:07:15.892
<v Justin Wood>Here.

15
00:07:17.627 --> 00:07:19.701
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>Here.

16
00:07:20.964 --> 00:07:21.353
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

17
00:07:22.338 --> 00:07:22.612
<v Robert Butler>Here.

18
00:07:27.887 --> 00:07:31.259
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Lynley, could you please read our rules of order and decorum?

19
00:07:32.137 --> 00:07:32.833
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, President.

20
00:07:33.350 --> 00:07:34.805
<v Keelan McClymont>Welcome to Portland City Council.

21
00:07:34.983 --> 00:07:40.774
<v Keelan McClymont>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

22
00:07:44.370 --> 00:07:47.363
<v Keelan McClymont>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

23
00:07:47.862 --> 00:07:52.257
<v Keelan McClymont>Individuals may testify for 3, 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

24
00:07:52.757 --> 00:07:54.778
<v Keelan McClymont>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

25
00:07:55.300 --> 00:07:56.867
<v Keelan McClymont>The presiding officer preserves order.

26
00:07:57.160 --> 00:08:04.622
<v Keelan McClymont>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

27
00:08:05.216 --> 00:08:07.093
<v Keelan McClymont>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

28
00:08:07.528 --> 00:08:10.079
<v Keelan McClymont>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

29
00:08:10.593 --> 00:08:14.028
<v Keelan McClymont>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

30
00:08:14.139 --> 00:08:17.302
<v Keelan McClymont>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

31
00:08:17.959 --> 00:08:20.608
<v Keelan McClymont>Your testimony today should address the matter being considered.

32
00:08:20.767 --> 00:08:22.918
<v Keelan McClymont>When testifying, state your name for the record.

33
00:08:23.271 --> 00:08:24.923
<v Keelan McClymont>Your address is not necessary.

34
00:08:25.420 --> 00:08:28.336
<v Keelan McClymont>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

35
00:08:28.641 --> 00:08:32.633
<v Keelan McClymont>And finally, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls their name.

36
00:08:32.874 --> 00:08:33.129
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

37
00:08:34.317 --> 00:08:35.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Lynley.

38
00:08:35.471 --> 00:08:45.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll note that after we get through some administrative business, we just have 3 things on the agenda tonight, but we are expecting a lot of testimony on all 3.

39
00:08:46.019 --> 00:08:58.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you did not see the notice, it was sent to everybody who had signed up to testify, but unfortunately we had to cut testimony down to 2 minutes a person because We have almost 80 people signed up to testify between those 3 items.

40
00:09:00.240 --> 00:09:04.089
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we wanted to make sure to let everybody know that as soon as we could.

41
00:09:04.697 --> 00:09:11.787
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also will just note that in order to keep the meeting moving, we know there will be things that people will be excited or upset to hear.

42
00:09:12.043 --> 00:09:12.942
<v Robert Butler>Jazz hands.

43
00:09:13.455 --> 00:09:15.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Jazz hands, thumbs up, thumbs down.

44
00:09:15.539 --> 00:09:27.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Feel free to express that, but please do so in a way that is quiet, silent, so that we can keep moving through the meeting while also acknowledging folks' support or dissension from the things that we hear tonight.

45
00:09:28.802 --> 00:09:32.956
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, the first thing on the agenda, as always, is agenda approval.

46
00:09:33.732 --> 00:09:38.178
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any motion to reorder or add items to the agenda?

47
00:09:38.275 --> 00:09:39.591
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>None have been filed in advance.

48
00:09:41.548 --> 00:09:45.110
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, do I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

49
00:09:47.231 --> 00:09:47.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

50
00:09:48.970 --> 00:09:52.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next item on the agenda is public communication.

51
00:09:52.447 --> 00:09:54.461
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call up— Yes, Council President.

52
00:09:57.030 --> 00:09:58.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>First up, we have Robert Butler.

53
00:10:01.580 --> 00:10:09.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while Robert makes his way up, I just will note, in case folks didn't hear it during the roll call, that we do have 2 of our councilors participating virtually tonight.

54
00:10:10.535 --> 00:10:12.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark and Councilor Ryan are online.

55
00:10:12.749 --> 00:10:13.447
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They are participating.

56
00:10:14.572 --> 00:10:16.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They just weren't able to be here in person with us.

57
00:10:17.740 --> 00:10:19.373
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Butler, thank you so much for being here.

58
00:10:20.211 --> 00:10:21.226
<v Robert Butler>Thank you for saying that.

59
00:10:21.663 --> 00:10:22.774
<v Robert Butler>This is Robert Butler.

60
00:10:22.871 --> 00:10:24.355
<v Robert Butler>I'm a native of Portland here.

61
00:10:24.903 --> 00:10:41.610
<v Robert Butler>I'm going to talk a little bit first about the fact that we should be realizing now that Portland probably has the worst charter in the United States.

62
00:10:43.482 --> 00:10:44.548
<v Robert Butler>It's inefficient.

63
00:10:44.629 --> 00:10:45.113
<v Robert Butler>It's slow.

64
00:10:47.410 --> 00:10:49.207
<v Robert Butler>And it's very expensive.

65
00:10:50.475 --> 00:10:51.855
<v Robert Butler>Business is falling back.

66
00:10:52.546 --> 00:10:53.750
<v Robert Butler>Things are falling back.

67
00:10:54.071 --> 00:10:59.799
<v Robert Butler>I haven't heard anything about the annual report of the Bull Run Water Bureau that was due in July.

68
00:11:00.250 --> 00:11:04.197
<v Robert Butler>I haven't heard any progress on getting a new city manager.

69
00:11:04.374 --> 00:11:07.921
<v Robert Butler>There are a lot of things that, that are moving slowly instead of fast.

70
00:11:08.048 --> 00:11:11.707
<v Robert Butler>This is costing the city money when things move slowly.

71
00:11:11.804 --> 00:11:11.965
<v Robert Butler>Thank you.

72
00:11:12.788 --> 00:11:19.711
<v Robert Butler>So I think everyone should be trying very hard to get out of this position that we are now and streamline.

73
00:11:20.649 --> 00:11:25.214
<v Robert Butler>Secondly, downtown is a ghost town.

74
00:11:26.120 --> 00:11:27.398
<v Robert Butler>It is so disgusting.

75
00:11:27.914 --> 00:11:29.322
<v Robert Butler>We should all be ashamed of it.

76
00:11:30.323 --> 00:11:31.149
<v Robert Butler>And we're not.

77
00:11:31.860 --> 00:11:32.279
<v Robert Butler>We're not.

78
00:11:32.360 --> 00:11:35.577
<v Robert Butler>We're spending our time besides downtown.

79
00:11:35.674 --> 00:11:37.008
<v Robert Butler>We're spending our money besides downtown.

80
00:11:37.057 --> 00:11:37.458
<v Robert Butler>Councilor Dan Ryan.

81
00:11:39.080 --> 00:11:45.446
<v Robert Butler>Last year we probably agreed to spend $1 billion on urban renewal outside of downtown.

82
00:11:45.802 --> 00:11:47.385
<v Robert Butler>Should have been inside downtown.

83
00:11:48.471 --> 00:12:04.836
<v Robert Butler>So about financial responsibility, fiscal responsibility, this Parks Bureau increase of 75% for the next— this coming 5 years, a 75% increase.

84
00:12:04.950 --> 00:12:05.095
<v James Lee>Yes.

85
00:12:05.211 --> 00:12:05.809
<v Justin Wood>For parks?

86
00:12:06.246 --> 00:12:07.201
<v Robert Butler>For parks?

87
00:12:07.719 --> 00:12:08.333
<v Robert Butler>We're crazy.

88
00:12:08.996 --> 00:12:10.193
<v Robert Butler>Totally crazy.

89
00:12:10.388 --> 00:12:11.568
<v Robert Butler>I just talked about downtown.

90
00:12:13.219 --> 00:12:15.645
<v Robert Butler>Secondly, the bull run.

91
00:12:18.349 --> 00:12:24.299
<v Robert Butler>With still plenty of time to turn back and beat the schedule and save about $2 billion.

92
00:12:25.203 --> 00:12:32.144
<v Robert Butler>So take your time because we're only spending about $35 million a month and $2 billion savings.

93
00:12:32.258 --> 00:12:41.837
<v Robert Butler>We got to wait till next year before we walk away for how much money you want, we'll still be cheaper and finish sooner on schedule.

94
00:12:43.051 --> 00:12:47.924
<v Robert Butler>I wanted to mention how you were so impressed with sand filtration.

95
00:12:48.504 --> 00:12:57.796
<v Robert Butler>Sand filtration brings stuff down from above and puts it through the sand such that it doesn't get in our drinking water.

96
00:12:58.525 --> 00:13:01.008
<v Robert Butler>Well, what, what happens to sand filtration?

97
00:13:01.405 --> 00:13:04.722
<v Robert Butler>You have a mudslide, all that mud comes down and plugs up the sand.

98
00:13:05.091 --> 00:13:10.316
<v Robert Butler>You have a fire, all that fire ash comes down and plugs up the sand, and we're outta water.

99
00:13:11.020 --> 00:13:16.581
<v Robert Butler>So you know what doesn't sink down in the sand that we're not taking out of the water?

100
00:13:17.447 --> 00:13:21.596
<v Robert Butler>Cryptosporidium, the parasite, the microscopic parasite.

101
00:13:21.677 --> 00:13:22.190
<v Robert Butler>You know why?

102
00:13:22.975 --> 00:13:23.889
<v Robert Butler>It floats.

103
00:13:24.418 --> 00:13:25.971
<v Robert Butler>Crypto floats.

104
00:13:26.999 --> 00:13:27.578
<v Robert Butler>Think about it.

105
00:13:27.804 --> 00:13:30.080
<v Robert Butler>Thank you and good luck for the rest of the year.

106
00:13:30.532 --> 00:13:34.048
<v Robert Butler>And thank you, Mayor, for being upbeat and positive.

107
00:13:34.791 --> 00:13:36.048
<v Robert Butler>The rest of us are doing a good job.

108
00:13:36.097 --> 00:13:36.291
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

109
00:13:36.340 --> 00:13:38.586
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Very much for being here.

110
00:13:38.847 --> 00:13:40.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next up, we have Justin Wood.

111
00:13:45.624 --> 00:13:46.087
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good evening.

112
00:13:46.138 --> 00:13:47.480
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome and thank you for being here.

113
00:13:51.354 --> 00:13:51.708
<v Justin Wood>Good evening.

114
00:13:52.965 --> 00:13:54.157
<v Justin Wood>Good evening, members of the council.

115
00:13:54.673 --> 00:13:55.768
<v Justin Wood>My name is Justin Wood.

116
00:13:56.875 --> 00:13:58.621
<v Justin Wood>I am a homebuilder here in Portland.

117
00:13:58.879 --> 00:14:01.234
<v Justin Wood>Uh, I— my company name is Fisch Construction.

118
00:14:01.778 --> 00:14:05.993
<v Justin Wood>I'm a former chair of the Development Review Advisory Committee here in the City of Portland.

119
00:14:06.409 --> 00:14:10.480
<v Justin Wood>I also served on Governor Kotek's Housing Production Advisory Council.

120
00:14:11.874 --> 00:14:16.889
<v Justin Wood>Our company has been building affordable homeownership homes, um, in the Portland area for over 40 years.

121
00:14:17.642 --> 00:14:23.506
<v Justin Wood>The majority of our buyers make below the median family income, and they buy homes that are below the median family home price.

122
00:14:23.779 --> 00:14:29.158
<v Justin Wood>That's our passion and something we pride ourselves on, filling a much-needed niche for middle housing in this city.

123
00:14:30.153 --> 00:14:39.511
<v Justin Wood>The city has for many years offered programs that provide us an opportunity to assist these buyers through the SDC waiver program and the limited tax abatement programs.

124
00:14:40.171 --> 00:14:45.692
<v Justin Wood>These programs are not programs intended to make builders any more money, but they help us sell the homes at a price range needed for these buyers.

125
00:14:46.753 --> 00:14:50.332
<v Justin Wood>For the few of us builders who have long utilized these programs, we've had a wrench thrown at us.

126
00:14:51.038 --> 00:14:55.802
<v Justin Wood>Earlier this summer when the City Council passed a resolution removing SDCs on all new construction in the city.

127
00:14:56.636 --> 00:15:07.592
<v Justin Wood>Well, I— while this is a great step and I applaud the council for doing this to help provide more homes in Portland, there is an unintended consequence in how it's affecting those of us trying to build affordable homeownership opportunities.

128
00:15:08.506 --> 00:15:18.130
<v Justin Wood>Because our homes that had SDCs waived through the Portland Housing Bureau program, our buyers have to provide income documentation and are limited by the price-income cap.

129
00:15:18.918 --> 00:15:28.429
<v Justin Wood>Builders who are now building homes who have just simply had their SDCs removed are able to lower their prices, sell them on the market, and do not have any restrictions on who they can sell their homes to.

130
00:15:28.494 --> 00:15:30.197
<v Justin Wood>They don't have any income restrictions like we do.

131
00:15:31.065 --> 00:15:49.269
<v Justin Wood>If a buyer had an option of 2 homes that were similarly priced and similarly sized and finished, but one of them they had to fill out an application, pay an application fee, and provide wage documentation to the Portland Housing Bureau, and then the house across the street they did not have to do those, you can imagine that most buyers are just gonna simply go with the one they don't have to go through all the extra steps and hoops.

132
00:15:50.169 --> 00:15:58.190
<v Justin Wood>This is something that's gonna become a major problem for a handful, a small handful of us builders who utilize this program, and we're really gonna start to see these impacts within a couple of months.

133
00:15:58.750 --> 00:16:02.730
<v Justin Wood>Portland Housing Bureau estimates there's maybe up to 200 homes that are affected by this.

134
00:16:02.909 --> 00:16:04.809
<v Justin Wood>The solution must come from council.

135
00:16:04.809 --> 00:16:05.789
<v Justin Wood>It's a policy decision.

136
00:16:05.789 --> 00:16:09.159
<v Justin Wood>It's important to recognize that, well, this will not impact the city financially.

137
00:16:09.250 --> 00:16:11.450
<v Justin Wood>These are homes that have already had the SDCs waived.

138
00:16:12.346 --> 00:16:21.892
<v Justin Wood>The simple solution that I and the Portland Home Builders Association are advocating for is to simply remove the income cap requirements but retain the price cap so that we still are trying to sell those homes affordably.

139
00:16:22.854 --> 00:16:26.094
<v Justin Wood>That would remove the ability for buyers to need to qualify.

140
00:16:26.479 --> 00:16:33.538
<v Justin Wood>For years, a few builders like myself have been good partners with the City of Portland in filling the critical need for affordable homeownership opportunities in the city.

141
00:16:34.019 --> 00:16:38.557
<v Justin Wood>I ask the council to please be a good partner back so you don't inadvertently punish those of us trying to do the right thing.

142
00:16:38.671 --> 00:16:38.879
<v Justin Wood>Thank you.

143
00:16:39.139 --> 00:16:39.499
<v Justin Wood>Thank you.

144
00:16:40.365 --> 00:16:43.697
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for bringing forward that solution.

145
00:16:45.519 --> 00:16:47.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next up, we have Angeline Adler.

146
00:16:52.539 --> 00:16:55.553
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, is that something that we can consider in our homeless committee?

147
00:16:57.279 --> 00:17:06.307
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's certainly something that either could be considered in committee through a discussion or that somebody could bring forward as an ordinance and bring to that committee.

148
00:17:06.967 --> 00:17:07.611
<v Keena Rubin>Great idea.

149
00:17:07.852 --> 00:17:08.125
<v Keena Rubin>Thank you.

150
00:17:08.576 --> 00:17:08.914
<v Darlene Sherman>Thank you.

151
00:17:11.798 --> 00:17:15.013
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Angeline Adler.

152
00:17:16.258 --> 00:17:17.307
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>James Lee.

153
00:17:19.700 --> 00:17:20.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Lee.

154
00:17:23.105 --> 00:17:23.848
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>James Lee.

155
00:17:28.579 --> 00:17:31.142
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Mr. Lee.

156
00:17:31.222 --> 00:17:32.925
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here this evening with us.

157
00:17:34.018 --> 00:17:35.221
<v James Lee>I am James Bernard Lee.

158
00:17:35.396 --> 00:17:39.311
<v James Lee>I reside in Southeast Portland and speak only for myself.

159
00:17:39.873 --> 00:17:41.269
<v James Lee>Thank you for hearing me today.

160
00:17:42.296 --> 00:17:50.204
<v James Lee>On September 3rd, Mayor Wilson was to speak about transportation at an informal gathering of cyclists on Southeast Ancony.

161
00:17:51.199 --> 00:17:55.804
<v James Lee>When he began, an obnoxious young woman with a bullhorn began to harass him.

162
00:17:56.574 --> 00:17:59.365
<v James Lee>His security detail asked her to desist.

163
00:18:00.023 --> 00:18:05.374
<v James Lee>She continued, continued, as did her posse, also armed with bullhorns.

164
00:18:06.467 --> 00:18:13.200
<v James Lee>I approached the miscreant and with a single swipe of my left hand swatted her weapon 10 feet down the pavement.

165
00:18:13.987 --> 00:18:18.549
<v James Lee>The diversion enabled the mayor's security detail to make a discreet exit.

166
00:18:19.144 --> 00:18:20.510
<v James Lee>Quiet ensued.

167
00:18:21.957 --> 00:18:27.031
<v James Lee>In 2008, I experienced how our governance worked By filing for mayor.

168
00:18:27.978 --> 00:18:35.069
<v James Lee>At a campaign event, I answered a pertinent question: what useful ability beyond the political do you possess?

169
00:18:36.546 --> 00:18:37.605
<v James Lee>I am a physicist.

170
00:18:38.006 --> 00:18:43.910
<v James Lee>Throw a problem at me and I'll give you an answer in the most basic terms possible.

171
00:18:45.048 --> 00:18:54.578
<v James Lee>On July 8th, Charity Montez, Director of the Office of Arts and Culture, made an extensive presentation to the Arts and Economy Committee.

172
00:18:55.557 --> 00:18:56.615
<v James Lee>I was astonished.

173
00:18:57.079 --> 00:19:05.318
<v James Lee>The first objective assessment of our major arts facilities, recapitulation of predictions I had made 40 years ago.

174
00:19:06.634 --> 00:19:12.820
<v James Lee>A priori, the Performing Arts Committee had decided to repurpose the Paramount as a concert hall.

175
00:19:13.830 --> 00:19:18.624
<v James Lee>All issues Ms. Montan elucidated ineluctably followed.

176
00:19:19.201 --> 00:19:21.189
<v James Lee>There was no systematic planning.

177
00:19:21.285 --> 00:19:21.444
<v James Lee>Thank you.

178
00:19:22.344 --> 00:19:24.155
<v James Lee>Ted Wheeler has done likewise.

179
00:19:24.750 --> 00:19:30.492
<v James Lee>We are headed into the same black hole as the Performing Arts Committee drove us last century.

180
00:19:31.551 --> 00:19:43.358
<v James Lee>I ask you, as I asked Wheeler without response, to hear my 30-minute synthesis of the issues from the point of view of theoretical physics and history of architecture.

181
00:19:44.306 --> 00:19:50.703
<v James Lee>We ought to rehabilitate Keller seismically Then plan a proper concert hall and opera house.

182
00:19:51.601 --> 00:20:00.077
<v James Lee>In Charity Montez and Carl Lyle, we have 2 extremely competent and dedicated civil servants to do this.

183
00:20:01.215 --> 00:20:03.282
<v James Lee>I possess peculiar competencies.

184
00:20:04.019 --> 00:20:05.286
<v James Lee>They too should be used.

185
00:20:05.863 --> 00:20:06.262
<v James Lee>Thank you.

186
00:20:07.065 --> 00:20:10.012
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much for being here.

187
00:20:11.166 --> 00:20:12.817
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next up, we have Cassie Wilson.

188
00:20:27.665 --> 00:20:28.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

189
00:20:28.163 --> 00:20:29.574
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for joining us this evening.

190
00:20:30.970 --> 00:20:32.461
<v Cassie Wilson>Good evening, council members.

191
00:20:32.557 --> 00:20:36.261
<v Cassie Wilson>My name is Cassie Wilson and I'm a resident of the Buckman neighborhood.

192
00:20:36.405 --> 00:20:39.709
<v Cassie Wilson>My testimony tonight is on behalf of myself, not my employer.

193
00:20:40.672 --> 00:20:53.933
<v Cassie Wilson>When I moved to Portland last year, there was a small group of folks living outside across the street from me, and they lived there for months, but then they were forcibly moved across the street late last year and continually broken up and displaced after that.

194
00:20:54.800 --> 00:21:02.395
<v Cassie Wilson>While it was upsetting to witness my neighbors be destabilized, it's nothing compared to what I've witnessed since Mayor Wilson took office.

195
00:21:03.310 --> 00:21:11.628
<v Cassie Wilson>Nearly every day this year when I leave my apartment to walk to work, people are being swept right outside, and I get to the office and people are being swept there too.

196
00:21:12.383 --> 00:21:15.845
<v Cassie Wilson>There are rapid response trucks taking people's stuff away every day.

197
00:21:16.470 --> 00:21:18.634
<v Cassie Wilson>They are forced to start over every day.

198
00:21:19.676 --> 00:21:25.126
<v Cassie Wilson>There's a terrible misconception that sweeps are good for disabled people using the sidewalks.

199
00:21:25.607 --> 00:21:27.098
<v Cassie Wilson>This couldn't be more wrong.

200
00:21:27.853 --> 00:21:39.875
<v Cassie Wilson>Not only are our unsheltered neighbors disproportionately disabled and elderly themselves, but when people are forced to move from block to block every day, I am forced to find a new route through my neighborhood every day.

201
00:21:40.356 --> 00:21:42.553
<v Cassie Wilson>And that's not their fault, it's the city's.

202
00:21:43.083 --> 00:21:45.701
<v Cassie Wilson>Sweeps destabilize entire neighborhoods.

203
00:21:46.840 --> 00:22:00.571
<v Cassie Wilson>I couldn't believe it when the mayor's office sent out an email asking Portlanders to consider donating to his overnight shelters and implying that if we don't personally help get the housing crisis under control, that the feds would come in.

204
00:22:01.695 --> 00:22:09.146
<v Cassie Wilson>Well, they're here flying helicopters and brutalizing protesters anyway, and it has nothing to do with our housing crisis and everything to do with fascism.

205
00:22:09.195 --> 00:22:09.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Loretta Smith.

206
00:22:10.288 --> 00:22:16.695
<v Cassie Wilson>We have little control over how the feds try to attack us, but full control over how we treat our unhoused neighbors.

207
00:22:17.595 --> 00:22:27.214
<v Cassie Wilson>Sweeps, RV and camping bans, and overnight-only shelters have proven to be ineffective, yet the mayor continues to double down on them instead of proven solutions.

208
00:22:28.067 --> 00:22:36.096
<v Cassie Wilson>It's an obsession with the appearance of solving the problem and hitting shelter bed goals for political points without actually housing people.

209
00:22:36.978 --> 00:22:42.298
<v Cassie Wilson>It's just destabilizing and disappearing people, something fascists seem to love.

210
00:22:43.386 --> 00:22:48.707
<v Cassie Wilson>Stop with the sweeps and false solutions and reallocate those resources to housing people.

211
00:22:49.859 --> 00:22:52.070
<v Cassie Wilson>And the work doesn't end when we get people into housing.

212
00:22:52.647 --> 00:22:58.785
<v Cassie Wilson>My experience as a renter forced me to become a housing advocate because protection for renters is so nonexistent.

213
00:22:59.554 --> 00:23:04.856
<v Cassie Wilson>Renters need and deserve stability and protection without having to beg or take legal action for it.

214
00:23:04.904 --> 00:23:09.125
<v Cassie Wilson>Councilmember and disabled people deserve truly accessible housing.

215
00:23:09.723 --> 00:23:14.502
<v Cassie Wilson>Just ask the councilor who helps take my laundry in and out of the dryer because I can't reach it.

216
00:23:15.454 --> 00:23:22.297
<v Cassie Wilson>If you want to truly address our city's housing and homelessness crisis, you'll help to stabilize unsheltered folks and renters.

217
00:23:23.038 --> 00:23:24.883
<v Cassie Wilson>No one wants to constantly be moving.

218
00:23:25.240 --> 00:23:27.443
<v Cassie Wilson>Make it possible that Portlanders don't have to.

219
00:23:28.059 --> 00:23:28.287
<v Robert Butler>Thank you.

220
00:23:29.194 --> 00:23:30.313
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

221
00:23:33.655 --> 00:23:34.622
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll go back.

222
00:23:34.782 --> 00:23:35.973
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Angeline Adler.

223
00:23:39.628 --> 00:23:41.012
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That completes communications.

224
00:23:43.074 --> 00:23:47.063
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you to everybody who's here tonight to share your concerns and thoughts with us.

225
00:23:48.759 --> 00:23:52.182
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, the next item on the agenda is the committee referral list.

226
00:23:52.407 --> 00:23:57.214
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The only item on the committee referral list is Acceptable Run Treatment Projects Annual Report.

227
00:23:57.751 --> 00:23:59.978
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Referred to Transportation and Infrastructure Committee.

228
00:24:00.090 --> 00:24:01.961
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we may be missing some things.

229
00:24:02.026 --> 00:24:03.848
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll make sure that we get them on for next week.

230
00:24:06.491 --> 00:24:09.608
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next item on the agenda is the consent agenda.

231
00:24:10.905 --> 00:24:13.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll for the consent agenda?

232
00:24:15.224 --> 00:24:15.648
<v Cassie Wilson>Clerk.

233
00:24:19.614 --> 00:24:19.679
<v James Lee>Here.

234
00:24:20.201 --> 00:24:20.381
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>Yes.

235
00:24:23.497 --> 00:24:23.659
<v Cassie Wilson>Aye.

236
00:24:25.192 --> 00:24:25.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

237
00:24:25.837 --> 00:24:25.885
<v Keena Rubin>Aye.

238
00:24:26.968 --> 00:24:27.016
<v Robert Butler>Aye.

239
00:24:28.259 --> 00:24:28.307
<v Darlene Sherman>Aye.

240
00:24:31.243 --> 00:24:31.291
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

241
00:24:32.790 --> 00:24:32.886
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

242
00:24:34.627 --> 00:24:34.675
<v Keena Rubin>Aye.

243
00:24:36.319 --> 00:24:36.367
<v Darlene Sherman>Aye.

244
00:24:37.287 --> 00:24:37.335
<v Darlene Sherman>Aye.

245
00:24:39.885 --> 00:24:43.038
<v Darlene Sherman>The consent agenda is approved with 12 yes votes.

246
00:24:43.522 --> 00:24:44.784
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

247
00:24:44.896 --> 00:24:46.999
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That moves us to the regular agenda.

248
00:24:47.160 --> 00:24:49.291
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the first item on our agenda?

249
00:24:50.147 --> 00:24:59.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 5, adopt the Portland Urban Forest Plan to improve public health, build resilience to climate change, and promote environmental justice.

250
00:25:00.744 --> 00:25:01.242
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

251
00:25:02.125 --> 00:25:07.263
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is an item that came out of the Climate Resilience and Land Use Committee.

252
00:25:08.050 --> 00:25:10.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Craig, are you filling in for Claire tonight?

253
00:25:10.861 --> 00:25:11.102
<v Craig Cook>I am.

254
00:25:11.439 --> 00:25:12.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Fantastic.

255
00:25:12.161 --> 00:25:14.376
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could you go ahead and give us the committee staff summary?

256
00:25:14.795 --> 00:25:14.939
<v Keena Rubin>Yes.

257
00:25:16.397 --> 00:25:26.396
<v Craig Cook>Madam President and councilors, for the record, Craig Cook, Council Policy Analyst, and sharing the committee staff summary on behalf of Claire Adamsick, who is staff to the Climate, Resilience, and Land Use Committee.

258
00:25:27.310 --> 00:25:40.355
<v Craig Cook>The ordinance before you, document number 2025-351, was heard in the Climate, Resilience, and Land Use Committee on September 11th and again on September 25th, where it was referred to council with the recommendation to pass.

259
00:25:40.403 --> 00:25:40.515
<v Craig Cook>Second.

260
00:25:41.413 --> 00:25:47.480
<v Craig Cook>The resolution directs city staff to engage in activities implementing the recommendations of the Portland Urban Forest Plan.

261
00:25:48.378 --> 00:26:10.380
<v Craig Cook>The recommendations include prioritize the preservation and care of the urban forest, reduce the cost of tree care for Portlanders, design and create new space for trees and other vegetation, expand the urban forest through planting, stewardship, and collaboration, provide inclusive communication, training, and education about the urban forest and tree care.

262
00:26:10.460 --> 00:26:10.717
<v Craig Cook>Thank you.

263
00:26:11.406 --> 00:26:17.247
<v Craig Cook>Use data tools and monitoring to support climate adaptation, meet canopy targets, and equitably distribute canopy.

264
00:26:18.402 --> 00:26:23.102
<v Craig Cook>Improve city codes, standards, and guidelines to support community resilience and urban forest health.

265
00:26:24.080 --> 00:26:35.406
<v Craig Cook>The full impact statements on this item include information on financial and budgetary impacts and analysis, economic and real estate development impacts, and community impacts and community involvement.

266
00:26:36.273 --> 00:26:40.429
<v Craig Cook>The committee adopted 3 amendments relating to reducing the cost of tree care for Portlanders.

267
00:26:41.086 --> 00:26:48.202
<v Craig Cook>Each amendment modifies language in the specified action items in the Portland Urban Forest Plan Recommended Draft, Exhibit A of the resolution.

268
00:26:49.037 --> 00:26:57.901
<v Craig Cook>Amendment 1 modifies Action 2-3 by directing the city to establish a plan by November 2027 to assume legal and financial responsibility for street trees.

269
00:26:58.750 --> 00:27:07.679
<v Craig Cook>Amendment 2 modifies Action 2-5 by directing the city to establish a plan by 2028 for how it could assume legal and financial responsibility for street trees.

270
00:27:07.776 --> 00:27:08.064
<v Craig Cook>Yes.

271
00:27:09.153 --> 00:27:19.574
<v Craig Cook>Amendment 3 modifies Action 2-1 by clarifying that low-income Portlanders would be eligible for financial assistance under a new tree care program for private property.

272
00:27:20.471 --> 00:27:23.388
<v Craig Cook>6 People testified during the committee meeting on September 11th.

273
00:27:24.142 --> 00:27:32.444
<v Craig Cook>76 People submitted written testimony prior to committee action on September 25th, and 1 person submitted written testimony prior to council agenda posting.

274
00:27:33.182 --> 00:27:42.059
<v Craig Cook>General themes included Trees as critical climate infrastructure in reducing extreme heat, improving air and water quality, and providing habitat for birds and other wildlife.

275
00:27:42.733 --> 00:27:46.924
<v Craig Cook>Inequities in the tree canopy across districts, particularly east of I-205.

276
00:27:47.728 --> 00:27:52.801
<v Craig Cook>Requests to add measurable outlines and clear timelines to action items identified in the recommended draft.

277
00:27:53.508 --> 00:27:59.898
<v Craig Cook>Urging the city to take legal and/or financial responsibility for street tree maintenance and sidewalk repairs related to trees.

278
00:28:00.547 --> 00:28:09.458
<v Craig Cook>Encouraging ongoing community participation in education, and a request for increased publicly accessible data to track tree canopy progress by district.

279
00:28:09.930 --> 00:28:11.376
<v Craig Cook>That concludes the committee staff summary.

280
00:28:11.571 --> 00:28:11.945
<v Craig Cook>Thank you.

281
00:28:13.913 --> 00:28:15.035
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much, Craig.

282
00:28:16.440 --> 00:28:18.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, I believe you presided over this meeting.

283
00:28:19.006 --> 00:28:19.801
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

284
00:28:20.354 --> 00:28:20.630
<v Steve Novick>I did.

285
00:28:21.214 --> 00:28:24.236
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do you have anything that you'd like to add to the committee staff summary?

286
00:28:25.369 --> 00:28:30.343
<v Steve Novick>No, although I don't know if you noted that there was dispute over at least one of the amendments.

287
00:28:31.525 --> 00:28:33.096
<v Steve Novick>So was that a unanimous recommendation?

288
00:28:34.150 --> 00:28:36.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The report came out of committee unanimously, correct?

289
00:28:37.018 --> 00:28:37.990
<v Steve Novick>It did not, actually.

290
00:28:38.720 --> 00:28:38.882
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

291
00:28:39.207 --> 00:28:43.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The report came out of committee 4-1, and some of the amendments were unanimous and some were not.

292
00:28:44.001 --> 00:28:44.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that—.

293
00:28:44.194 --> 00:28:44.711
<v Steve Novick>That is correct.

294
00:28:44.790 --> 00:28:45.017
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

295
00:28:45.517 --> 00:28:46.307
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There we go.

296
00:28:46.548 --> 00:28:46.823
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

297
00:28:46.886 --> 00:28:48.434
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I knew there was some mix there.

298
00:28:50.109 --> 00:28:50.402
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

299
00:28:51.279 --> 00:28:56.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, are there any technical questions about what we have before us before we move to public testimony?

300
00:28:58.117 --> 00:28:59.953
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, is your hand in the queue for this?

301
00:29:00.392 --> 00:29:09.192
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>Yes, I wanted to find out what was the dissenting votes, which amendments, which amendments, and yeah, okay, in committee.

302
00:29:10.884 --> 00:29:12.898
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, are you able to speak to that?

303
00:29:13.042 --> 00:29:36.208
<v Steve Novick>Yes, I was a dissenting vote on the change to recommendation item 2-3, which now reads fund and implement a comprehensive Citywide street tree maintenance program, and by November 2027, establish a plan for the city to assume legal and financial responsibility for street trees to improve the health and safety of the city's street trees and support habitat connectivity.

304
00:29:36.881 --> 00:29:48.538
<v Steve Novick>Because I was concerned about ordering that we establish a plan for the city to assume all responsibility for maintaining street trees when we don't have a financing mechanism for that.

305
00:29:49.133 --> 00:29:55.018
<v Steve Novick>And I think that the implication would be that the Portland Clean Energy Fund would take over that forever.

306
00:29:55.323 --> 00:30:06.084
<v Steve Novick>And although there is a current 5-year plan during which the Portland Clean Energy Fund will provide initial funding to move in that direction, I think we need to have a further discussion before making that a commitment in perpetuity.

307
00:30:06.628 --> 00:30:09.323
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can I respond?

308
00:30:09.420 --> 00:30:10.878
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>I think you're absolutely right.

309
00:30:10.942 --> 00:30:16.058
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>And we passed SIP, the Sidewalk Improvement Paving Program, that includes tree canopies.

310
00:30:16.670 --> 00:30:18.786
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>And it will be also—.

311
00:30:19.980 --> 00:30:20.643
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>I love that.

312
00:30:21.434 --> 00:30:22.484
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>I love that smile.

313
00:30:24.913 --> 00:30:28.440
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>And it will also pay for some of this, but not in perpetuity.

314
00:30:29.103 --> 00:30:31.076
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>And we've already passed that 11-0.

315
00:30:31.155 --> 00:30:33.144
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>So I just wanted to remind folks.

316
00:30:33.469 --> 00:30:33.825
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

317
00:30:34.132 --> 00:30:34.584
<v Robert Butler>Thank you.

318
00:30:35.051 --> 00:30:35.923
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

319
00:30:35.971 --> 00:30:36.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

320
00:30:38.326 --> 00:30:39.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Madam Chair.

321
00:30:40.505 --> 00:30:45.361
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The 3 amendments that were made, I guess this is a question to Councilor Novick or anybody else.

322
00:30:46.157 --> 00:31:01.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those 3 amendments, are, are they all just plans that will come back to the council, unfunded plans, um, or actually, um, are we actually going to implement these?

323
00:31:02.536 --> 00:31:04.445
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, can you speak to that?

324
00:31:04.493 --> 00:31:06.999
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or Councilor Murillo, you were raising your hand.

325
00:31:07.047 --> 00:31:08.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You also co-chair here.

326
00:31:08.717 --> 00:31:10.564
<v Steve Novick>I'll defer to Councilor Murillo.

327
00:31:12.651 --> 00:31:18.494
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess I just wanted to say, 'cause we had differing opinions on the amendment, so I just wanted to speak to that a bit.

328
00:31:18.847 --> 00:31:30.777
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We, and I think some of the staff, were under the impression that because it does not list PCF, that Councilor Novick was reading into it that it might implicate PCF, but there's nothing explicitly written on it that does.

329
00:31:31.692 --> 00:31:39.779
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So other members of the committee did not share those concerns, but we all agreed that there has been a lot of attempts to use PSAP for all sorts of things.

330
00:31:40.296 --> 00:31:43.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So there's a reason why people are concerned about that.

331
00:31:43.604 --> 00:31:47.934
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I just wanted to state that there's, you know, there was different readings on that as well.

332
00:31:52.011 --> 00:32:05.855
<v Steve Novick>I would add, Councilor Clark, I think that they did all refer to plans or something like plans, but I have a concern about even instructing the executive to draw up plans for something that I don't think that we identified a funding mechanism for.

333
00:32:06.372 --> 00:32:09.700
<v Steve Novick>I'd rather identify the funding mechanism, then tell them to drop the plans to spend the money.

334
00:32:10.682 --> 00:32:12.589
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, I hear what you're saying.

335
00:32:12.768 --> 00:32:16.795
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just wanted to know that there's no commitment to do these things.

336
00:32:17.717 --> 00:32:18.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is an aspiration.

337
00:32:21.999 --> 00:32:22.871
<v Steve Novick>I think that's correct.

338
00:32:23.983 --> 00:32:24.644
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

339
00:32:24.726 --> 00:32:28.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, did you have technical questions for before we hear from the public?

340
00:32:28.921 --> 00:32:33.190
<v Sameer Kanal>No, I had an answer to the previous question, as I Was the one who authored the amendment.

341
00:32:33.932 --> 00:32:36.162
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Has it been answered or is there more to add?

342
00:32:36.420 --> 00:32:39.796
<v Sameer Kanal>There's one more piece to add, which is, so there were 3 amendments.

343
00:32:40.519 --> 00:32:41.894
<v Sameer Kanal>The 3rd one has nothing to do with plans.

344
00:32:42.023 --> 00:32:54.493
<v Sameer Kanal>It was actually refining a program that's being recommended by the staff to prioritize low-income property owners for a different section of this.

345
00:32:55.512 --> 00:33:04.832
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the 2 parts that are plans, they are designed to create comprehensive enough information that the future council can decide whether or not to commit to these things.

346
00:33:05.267 --> 00:33:10.921
<v Sameer Kanal>And so the answer remains yes to Councilor Clark's question, but there, there is no commitment going forward.

347
00:33:10.969 --> 00:33:15.138
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll also note that the word PCF does not appear anywhere in any of these 3 documents.

348
00:33:15.828 --> 00:33:16.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

349
00:33:16.557 --> 00:33:19.617
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Murillo, did you have technical questions or clarifications?

350
00:33:20.789 --> 00:33:20.904
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

351
00:33:21.233 --> 00:33:22.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick?

352
00:33:23.224 --> 00:33:23.373
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

353
00:33:25.512 --> 00:33:25.869
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sorry.

354
00:33:26.242 --> 00:33:32.767
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I'm gonna add a question to, I think, the line that Councilor Clark was going down.

355
00:33:34.186 --> 00:33:43.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are amending a plan, so we are not putting these in code as commitments, but we are saying that this is the direction that the city intends to go.

356
00:33:44.090 --> 00:33:46.805
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that accurate for folks who are on the committee?

357
00:33:48.720 --> 00:33:49.818
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's a plan for a plan.

358
00:33:51.238 --> 00:33:52.888
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As the city tends to love.

359
00:33:53.471 --> 00:33:53.795
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

360
00:33:54.215 --> 00:33:59.816
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I may ask this in more detail when we have folks from the bureau up here later, which I suspect will happen.

361
00:34:02.346 --> 00:34:03.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Knoll, are you back in the queue?

362
00:34:04.277 --> 00:34:15.557
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, it is designed to acquire enough information from the staff to create— so that council can understand what path we could go down before deciding whether or not to go down that path.

363
00:34:16.099 --> 00:34:19.079
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's what I'm trying to understand.

364
00:34:19.128 --> 00:34:21.492
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And again, I may ask again when we have staff up here.

365
00:34:23.851 --> 00:34:29.846
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to make sure that we're not binding ourselves to something in code that we would have to undo later if we're not able to afford it.

366
00:34:33.280 --> 00:34:33.585
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

367
00:34:34.389 --> 00:34:39.509
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, seeing no other technical questions in the queue, I'd like us to move on to public testimony.

368
00:34:40.346 --> 00:34:48.606
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that actually before we move on to public testimony, I will just note that we do have some amendments that have been filed online.

369
00:34:48.800 --> 00:34:52.532
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that it's sometimes helpful for people who are testifying to know what those are.

370
00:34:53.769 --> 00:35:02.349
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So before we move on, Councilor Dunphy and Councilor Novick, could you just do a brief run-through of what your amendments are if you plan on proposing them today?

371
00:35:03.074 --> 00:35:04.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then we'll move to public testimony.

372
00:35:06.820 --> 00:35:10.403
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, I think Councilor Dunphy is deferring to you to go first.

373
00:35:10.452 --> 00:35:10.534
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

374
00:35:11.045 --> 00:35:11.255
<v Steve Novick>Sure.

375
00:35:12.490 --> 00:35:41.324
<v Steve Novick>On the item about street tree maintenance that we were mentioning earlier, the language where currently it says fund and implement a comprehensive citywide street tree maintenance program and by November 2027 establish a plan for the city to assume legal and financial responsibility for street trees, I'm proposing to replace that with by November 2027 report on the cost and feasibility of the city assuming legal and financial responsibility.

376
00:35:41.925 --> 00:35:53.773
<v Steve Novick>Because to me, as I said before, saying that we're going to establish a plan sends a strong signal that we are moving in that direction, whereas asking for a report on the cost and feasibility makes it clear that we're just exploring it.

377
00:35:55.117 --> 00:36:04.760
<v Steve Novick>Second, I had a proposed amendment to item 2-4, which I'm actually going to now replace with a different proposed amendment.

378
00:36:04.989 --> 00:36:05.954
<v Steve Novick>And this is something that— Councilor Dan Ryan.

379
00:36:06.322 --> 00:36:19.027
<v Steve Novick>I think I supported the amendment when it was offered after subsequently, particularly after conversations with PBOT and subsequently learning something about what's in our charter about sidewalk responsibility.

380
00:36:20.909 --> 00:36:32.005
<v Steve Novick>The current language before us says identify financing strategies that include new funding sources, cost-saving measures, and other ways to improve pedestrian accessibility and reduce cost to property owners.

381
00:36:32.461 --> 00:36:47.782
<v Steve Novick>For repairing sidewalks damaged by trees, and by 2028, develop a plan for how the city could assume legal and financial responsibility for street tree-related sidewalk repairs that takes into account current projects underway for the city and includes an estimate of potential costs.

382
00:36:48.344 --> 00:37:08.262
<v Steve Novick>The amendment that I filed, that you could find online, says by 2028, report on the cost and feasibility of the city assuming, as my previous proposal, Since proposing that, I've learned that the city charter actually assigns responsibility for sidewalk maintenance to homeowners and says the city is not legally responsible.

383
00:37:08.806 --> 00:37:30.393
<v Steve Novick>So knowing that we're actually trying to mess with something that's in the charter, I propose reverting to the language that was originally in the proposal that came to— the version that came to committee, which simply says identify financing strategies, cost-saving measures, and other ways to improve pedestrian accessibility and reduce costs to property owners for repairing sidewalks damaged by trees.

384
00:37:31.409 --> 00:37:41.902
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So Councilor, your first amendment would change the changes that were made in committee, but still look different than the original.

385
00:37:41.967 --> 00:37:45.445
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Your second amendment would revert back to the original language, is that correct?

386
00:37:45.510 --> 00:37:45.913
<v Steve Novick>Exactly.

387
00:37:46.396 --> 00:37:47.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

388
00:37:47.266 --> 00:37:47.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy.

389
00:37:49.456 --> 00:37:49.972
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

390
00:37:51.353 --> 00:37:56.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, the most recent version is posted online, but I also emailed you a copy.

391
00:37:57.041 --> 00:38:04.253
<v Jamie Dunphy>My amendments are in response to some of the voices of my folks in my community, specifically Thrive East PDX.

392
00:38:05.213 --> 00:38:16.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>These are intended to strengthen the urban forestry plan by centering equitable and measurable outcomes, especially for District 1 and other low-income, low-canopy areas where tree canopy coverage and resilience yes.

393
00:38:16.675 --> 00:38:18.913
<v Jamie Dunphy>Investigations lag well behind the city average.

394
00:38:19.659 --> 00:38:26.617
<v Jamie Dunphy>If district parity is the goal, and it needs to be, equitable outcomes must be written into each and every city plan that we create.

395
00:38:28.268 --> 00:38:41.202
<v Jamie Dunphy>So these specific— it is originally introduced as 7 amendments, it is now 6 amendments— are intended to support and weave into one another.

396
00:38:41.365 --> 00:38:49.641
<v Jamie Dunphy>The centering of trees in the curb programming We set up the urban forest plan, urban forestry plan to integrate with programs like SIP.

397
00:38:49.786 --> 00:39:02.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>And as we look towards large infrastructure investments, and my hope is that by making these changes, commissions of the future will start working towards by-district parity into their programmatic thinking from the very beginning of the work.

398
00:39:03.860 --> 00:39:08.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>When we don't put those details into plans, very often district parity goes out the window in execution.

399
00:39:09.001 --> 00:39:16.885
<v Jamie Dunphy>And because the issue is deep and longstanding, We need an era of being more detailed in our expectations and outcomes until the cultural norm has changed.

400
00:39:17.510 --> 00:39:25.744
<v Jamie Dunphy>Outcomes are just as important as process, and it's up to us as electeds to step in to demand that action plans are in fact actionable and center our core values.

401
00:39:25.824 --> 00:39:31.635
<v Jamie Dunphy>So each amendment I'm proposing ensures that the Portland urban forest and canopy grows more equitably and sustainably.

402
00:39:31.778 --> 00:39:41.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>And before I dive into them specifically, I am willing— I'm open and happy to I'm bringing this forward as a package of amendments, but I'm also willing to pull any individual ones out.

403
00:39:41.576 --> 00:39:48.025
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I thank you all who have given some input to trying to refine these, including especially the Public Works staff.

404
00:39:49.500 --> 00:39:58.963
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy Amendment 1 would amend Item 3-2 on the recommendation and implementation strategy to create and expand trees in the curb zone.

405
00:39:59.547 --> 00:40:06.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>Currently it reads, create a permanent trees in the curb zone program for streets without enough space for trees in the furnishing zone.

406
00:40:06.690 --> 00:40:06.755
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

407
00:40:07.068 --> 00:40:28.195
<v Jamie Dunphy>My amendment would add, quote, and to complete a funding plan ramping up annual project completion goals, prioritizing low-income, low-shade residential neighborhoods, reporting annually starting in November of 2027 on locations, funding strategies, innovation, and district-level key performance indicators.

408
00:40:30.260 --> 00:40:41.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy Amendment 2 would take— would alter item 2-2 to develop a street tree maintenance pilot program that specifically includes District 1 corridors.

409
00:40:41.137 --> 00:40:52.391
<v Jamie Dunphy>It currently reads develop a street tree maintenance program, including a pilot program to inform— a project to inform program and cost specifics prior to citywide implementation.

410
00:40:52.922 --> 00:40:58.364
<v Jamie Dunphy>My amendment would add, quote, ensuring that at least one pilot area is located in District 1.

411
00:40:58.429 --> 00:40:58.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

412
00:40:58.865 --> 00:40:59.722
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Dan Ryan.

413
00:41:00.159 --> 00:41:11.291
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy Amendment 3 would amend Action Item 2-3 to fund and implement a citywide street tree maintenance program to include phased approaches that prioritize low-income and low-canopy areas.

414
00:41:12.523 --> 00:41:35.344
<v Jamie Dunphy>My amendment would specifically add— it says currently, the current language is fund and implement a comprehensive citywide street tree maintenance program and by November 27th establish a plan for the city to assume legal and financial responsibility for street trees and to improve the health and safety of the city's street trees and support habitat connectivity.

415
00:41:35.715 --> 00:41:46.208
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would add phased to prioritize low-income and low-canopy areas in between the words street trees and to improve.

416
00:41:47.387 --> 00:41:48.164
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy Amendment 4.

417
00:41:49.666 --> 00:41:50.652
<v Jamie Dunphy>I apologize, everybody.

418
00:41:50.701 --> 00:41:52.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is how lawmaking works.

419
00:41:53.405 --> 00:42:01.427
<v Jamie Dunphy>Amend Action Item 2-5 that expands access to the Leaf Day program to highlight Increasing access to areas without curbed sidewalks.

420
00:42:02.228 --> 00:42:12.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>Current language reads, explore funding opportunities to support expansion of the Leaf Day program to more neighborhoods and provide more frequent service to improve stormwater management and expand program access.

421
00:42:13.929 --> 00:42:20.485
<v Jamie Dunphy>My amendment would include, quote, would add, quote, including areas without curbed sidewalks.

422
00:42:21.945 --> 00:42:25.327
<v Jamie Dunphy>The street sweepers can't sweep your streets if there's not a curb.

423
00:42:25.391 --> 00:42:25.487
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

424
00:42:26.739 --> 00:42:29.052
<v Jamie Dunphy>And East Portland doesn't have sidewalks, so we don't have curbs.

425
00:42:29.632 --> 00:42:34.193
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have withdrawn the previously proposed Amendment 5 due to charter concerns.

426
00:42:34.692 --> 00:42:40.748
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy Amendment 6 amends the performance measures to include a district-level lens for performance metrics.

427
00:42:40.813 --> 00:42:52.748
<v Jamie Dunphy>Current language reads, performance measures, in addition to tracking each action in the plan, the city will use performance metrics to track— measures to track progress towards achieving plan goals and urban forest management outcomes.

428
00:42:53.021 --> 00:42:57.289
<v Jamie Dunphy>My amendment would include at the end, quote, by council district.

429
00:42:58.460 --> 00:43:09.385
<v Jamie Dunphy>And last, add action item 2-6 to create a cross-bureau team to propose potential permanent funding mechanisms to council by March of 2027.

430
00:43:09.465 --> 00:43:21.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is specifically a cross-jurisdictional effort to try and answer the question that Councilor Novick correctly raised about obligating future action without identifying sources.

431
00:43:21.978 --> 00:43:42.168
<v Jamie Dunphy>My language would add as an action item, quote, establish a cross-service area team led by the city CFO to recommend potential permanent funding mechanisms for neighborhood climate retrofits, street tree maintenance, trees in the curb zone, and street tree-related sidewalk repairs, and report back to council by March of 2027.

432
00:43:43.164 --> 00:43:47.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>So those are my 6 amendments that I would, uh, am proposing.

433
00:43:48.576 --> 00:43:49.385
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

434
00:43:50.195 --> 00:43:52.980
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Councilor Green, I see your hand up.

435
00:43:53.043 --> 00:43:56.168
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is this something that we should take before we go to public testimony?

436
00:43:58.237 --> 00:44:05.096
<v Steve Novick>No, the charter considerations has raised a question for me, but that can wait until after testimony or whenever appropriate.

437
00:44:05.711 --> 00:44:08.297
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we'll get to that first thing after public testimony.

438
00:44:08.346 --> 00:44:08.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How about that?

439
00:44:10.400 --> 00:44:18.235
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call up the first panel of testifiers, and I know we have a lot of people tonight, so let's try to get as many people up at a time as we can.

440
00:44:18.829 --> 00:44:19.121
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

441
00:44:19.492 --> 00:44:20.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, thank you.

442
00:44:20.382 --> 00:44:33.668
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, first up we have Keena Rubin, Terry Prigg Rigsby, Melinda McMillan, Darlene Sherman, and Micah Meskel.

443
00:44:36.384 --> 00:44:37.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead, Ms. Rubin.

444
00:44:39.885 --> 00:44:40.853
<v Keena Rubin>Do I have 2 or 3 minutes?

445
00:44:42.880 --> 00:44:45.458
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Unfortunately, we had to cut it down to 2 minutes this evening.

446
00:44:46.038 --> 00:44:46.215
<v Keena Rubin>Okay.

447
00:44:46.601 --> 00:44:46.731
<v Keena Rubin>All right.

448
00:44:47.503 --> 00:44:48.954
<v Keena Rubin>The stakes for all of us are high.

449
00:44:49.099 --> 00:44:51.789
<v Keena Rubin>First of all, I'm Keenan McClymont with Trees for Life Oregon.

450
00:44:52.592 --> 00:44:57.878
<v Keena Rubin>The stakes for all of us are high if we don't work now to bolster the city's climate resilience.

451
00:44:58.360 --> 00:45:03.036
<v Keena Rubin>Protecting and expanding our urban forest plays a vital role in doing that.

452
00:45:03.856 --> 00:45:05.847
<v Keena Rubin>Please approve the urban forest plan.

453
00:45:06.282 --> 00:45:08.175
<v Keena Rubin>It has lots of features to celebrate.

454
00:45:09.076 --> 00:45:10.793
<v Keena Rubin>Here's just a few really important ones.

455
00:45:11.436 --> 00:45:23.108
<v Keena Rubin>To address the city's dramatic shade disparities, it sets ambitious citywide and geographically specific canopy targets, plus canopy minimums for individual neighborhoods.

456
00:45:24.344 --> 00:45:30.090
<v Keena Rubin>It spells out urban forest challenges and design solutions to create more space for trees.

457
00:45:30.989 --> 00:45:38.583
<v Keena Rubin>And it calls for a city-run street tree maintenance program that will lift the cost burden of street tree care from property owners.

458
00:45:39.336 --> 00:45:48.471
<v Keena Rubin>Relevant to this last issue, we recently read Councilor Novick's suggested plan amendments, including a language change to Action 2.3 on street tree maintenance.

459
00:45:48.934 --> 00:45:58.686
<v Keena Rubin>Majority of the Climate Committee has already approved this action's original wording, which asked for the city to establish a plan To assume responsibility for street trees.

460
00:45:59.041 --> 00:46:03.820
<v Keena Rubin>The councilor's amendment asks instead to report on the cost and feasibility of the city doing this.

461
00:46:05.527 --> 00:46:13.679
<v Keena Rubin>We do not support this amendment as the city has already spent time and resources on cost estimates, several over the years.

462
00:46:14.449 --> 00:46:21.277
<v Keena Rubin>More up-to-date and ground-tested estimates will be coming from Urban Forestry's street tree maintenance pilot program.

463
00:46:21.791 --> 00:46:23.028
<v Keena Rubin>Which starts next year.

464
00:46:23.960 --> 00:46:29.771
<v Keena Rubin>It is appropriate that this plan state the intention for the city to create a plan to take over street tree care.

465
00:46:29.900 --> 00:46:35.521
<v Keena Rubin>Residents of every district want relief from this financial burden, and they want it sooner rather than later.

466
00:46:36.146 --> 00:46:42.793
<v Keena Rubin>This onus keeps many people from planting street trees to begin with, or from being able to care for them properly.

467
00:46:43.469 --> 00:46:46.728
<v Keena Rubin>Please do the right thing to protect the citywide residents.

468
00:46:46.775 --> 00:46:46.920
<v Keena Rubin>Thank you.

469
00:46:47.226 --> 00:46:51.266
<v Keena Rubin>You collectively represent by approving this urban forest plan.

470
00:46:51.460 --> 00:46:51.786
<v Keena Rubin>Thank you.

471
00:46:53.797 --> 00:46:54.657
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

472
00:46:57.306 --> 00:46:57.532
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Terri.

473
00:46:58.516 --> 00:46:59.630
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>Um, hi, good evening.

474
00:46:59.840 --> 00:47:06.072
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>My name is Terri Parig-Rigsby, and thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight.

475
00:47:06.427 --> 00:47:10.324
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>I am with the West Multnomah Soil and Water Conservation District.

476
00:47:10.469 --> 00:47:20.429
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>I represent District 5, and I'm chair of the board, and I'm here tonight to express express our strong support for the city's updated urban forest plan.

477
00:47:21.360 --> 00:47:26.664
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>This plan represents a historic opportunity to recognize trees as public infrastructure.

478
00:47:27.369 --> 00:47:35.621
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>They are integral to protecting our community's health, supporting biodiversity, and strengthening climate resilience for generations to come.

479
00:47:35.940 --> 00:47:42.686
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>We must invest in green infrastructure to protect our neighbors and also to protect our investments in our public infrastructure.

480
00:47:42.751 --> 00:47:42.878
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>Thank you.

481
00:47:44.355 --> 00:47:49.215
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>The plan's ambitious canopy goals are grounded in clear equitable actions.

482
00:47:49.713 --> 00:47:58.681
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>They expand Portland's Clean Energy Fund-supported planting programs, but they don't necessarily rely on those funds alone.

483
00:47:58.952 --> 00:48:03.942
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>And I do want to note that the Urban Forest Plan is distinct from the tree code.

484
00:48:04.809 --> 00:48:11.976
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>The plan does not propose specific code amendments, but it establishes a policy framework and vision that we need.

485
00:48:12.751 --> 00:48:22.023
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>Um, this clarity will help align future regulations, design standards, and inter-bureau practices with the plan's equity and resilience goals.

486
00:48:24.949 --> 00:48:57.052
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>Um, I also wanted to, um, just mention that this, in response to some concerns earlier about, um, amendments this effort will result in actual plans that do include costs, funding sources, legal impacts, and will bring science to the table so that we can better understand the ecosystem and community investments that we need here for improved health of our people and ecosystem.

487
00:48:57.164 --> 00:48:57.871
<v Terri Preeg Riggsby>So thank you.

488
00:48:57.967 --> 00:48:58.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please vote yes.

489
00:49:00.909 --> 00:49:01.673
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

490
00:49:05.802 --> 00:49:06.112
<v Melinda McMillan>Good evening.

491
00:49:06.550 --> 00:49:10.025
<v Melinda McMillan>I'm Melinda McClelland, currently serving as an Urban Forestry Commissioner.

492
00:49:10.590 --> 00:49:16.755
<v Melinda McMillan>I'm offering testimony in favor of adopting this urban forest plan, speaking as an individual and not for the commission.

493
00:49:17.989 --> 00:49:22.829
<v Melinda McMillan>Um, I'd like to share, uh, insight to the community outreach portion.

494
00:49:23.510 --> 00:49:25.889
<v Melinda McMillan>You have looked over the document.

495
00:49:26.036 --> 00:49:28.137
<v Melinda McMillan>I'd like to share something about the process.

496
00:49:28.938 --> 00:49:33.650
<v Melinda McMillan>I was the Urban Forestry Commission's representative and participated on the Community Advisory Committee.

497
00:49:34.402 --> 00:49:41.134
<v Melinda McMillan>As an architect and urban designer, I have regularly worked with community advisory committees and participated in, in public outreach.

498
00:49:41.614 --> 00:49:49.322
<v Melinda McMillan>However, at the end of this period, I was convinced that this outreach process has been the most thorough, responsive, and equitable I've experienced.

499
00:49:50.012 --> 00:49:57.297
<v Melinda McMillan>Participants reflected a diverse Portland both culturally and economically, while also representing different neighborhoods across the city.

500
00:49:58.213 --> 00:50:11.590
<v Melinda McMillan>As advisory committee volunteer members, we participated in a year-long process to contribute a vision for what the Portland canopy could become to citizens, underserved neighborhoods, and overall climate resilience for the city.

501
00:50:12.505 --> 00:50:19.266
<v Melinda McMillan>Additionally, our group wanted Portland to remain a leader in urban forestry across the country with the goals we helped define.

502
00:50:19.313 --> 00:50:19.507
<v Melinda McMillan>Thank you.

503
00:50:20.213 --> 00:50:29.967
<v Melinda McMillan>These aspirations were broken down into achievable, actionable, measurable steps by our community volunteers and others with whom the UFP team regularly met.

504
00:50:30.802 --> 00:50:41.070
<v Melinda McMillan>The team received a wide spectrum of input, suggestions, and direction, and would return to each meeting with disparate information thoughtfully integrated into each draft.

505
00:50:42.177 --> 00:50:50.106
<v Melinda McMillan>We are at a pivotal time for Portland as it would experience increasingly extreme seasonal temperatures, leading to significant risk to public health.

506
00:50:50.699 --> 00:50:55.322
<v Melinda McMillan>Increasing tree canopy is the most effective tool we have for mitigating these threats to Portlanders.

507
00:50:55.900 --> 00:50:58.132
<v Melinda McMillan>However, our urban forest is stagnating.

508
00:50:58.646 --> 00:51:00.539
<v Melinda McMillan>This plan offers a clear path.

509
00:51:01.438 --> 00:51:09.239
<v Melinda McMillan>While you surely reviewed the team's process and final plan, please be assured that the community outreach was not a superficial box to check.

510
00:51:10.123 --> 00:51:10.829
<v Melinda McMillan>It was genuine.

511
00:51:12.130 --> 00:51:12.451
<v Melinda McMillan>Thank you.

512
00:51:14.150 --> 00:51:14.391
<v Keelan McClymont>Darlene.

513
00:51:16.186 --> 00:51:25.599
<v Darlene Sherman>Council President and council members, I am Darlene Sherman, a resident of District 3 and a volunteer with 350 PDX on the Shade Equity Team.

514
00:51:26.518 --> 00:51:39.329
<v Darlene Sherman>I am testifying in support of the Portland Urban Forest Plan, including the 3 amendments that the Council Climate Resilience and Land Use Committee forwarded with recommendation to adopt.

515
00:51:40.454 --> 00:51:44.585
<v Darlene Sherman>I'm a retired ecologist with a career as a restoration biologist.

516
00:51:44.713 --> 00:51:53.246
<v Darlene Sherman>Our organization is a member of the Thrive East 350 PDX Coalition, and I'm also speaking today on behalf of— on their behalf.

517
00:51:54.612 --> 00:52:09.407
<v Darlene Sherman>The revisions to the current plan have incorporated some of the urgency reflected in public comments to the draft plan: increased shade cover in the city, Prioritizing low canopy neighborhoods where the heat island effect is the most pronounced.

518
00:52:10.835 --> 00:52:22.413
<v Darlene Sherman>With all due respect to my own District 3 Councilor Novick, I cannot support the suggested revisions for the amendments in that it moves the can down the road.

519
00:52:22.733 --> 00:52:46.931
<v Darlene Sherman>I think that a lot of the work has already been done in terms of cost estimates for the street tree maintenance, and what we need is looking at funding options, and that can be done ahead of time with a presentation to the council months ahead of the date of November 27th deadline.

520
00:52:47.525 --> 00:52:52.471
<v Darlene Sherman>And I think that would be similar also for the funding options for the sidewalk repairs.

521
00:52:55.652 --> 00:53:04.157
<v Darlene Sherman>So in summary, 350 PDX and Thrive East Portland PDX strongly urge the City Council to adopt the Urban.

522
00:53:08.454 --> 00:53:08.711
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

523
00:53:11.030 --> 00:53:11.288
<v Keelan McClymont>Micah.

524
00:53:12.543 --> 00:53:13.461
<v Micah Meskel>Good evening, councilors.

525
00:53:13.527 --> 00:53:21.197
<v Micah Meskel>My name is Micah Meskel, Bird Alliance of Oregon, and I'll start with acknowledging that I know this is not the main event today, and I want to send appreciation Thank you.

526
00:53:21.197 --> 00:53:21.197
<v Micah Meskel>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

527
00:53:21.197 --> 00:53:21.197
<v Micah Meskel>Thank you, Mayor.

528
00:53:21.197 --> 00:53:27.686
<v Micah Meskel>And congratulations to you all for considering the ways that the city can lever its tools to fight back against fascism.

529
00:53:27.876 --> 00:53:31.036
<v Micah Meskel>And I'm really emboldened by you all doing that today.

530
00:53:32.536 --> 00:53:46.336
<v Micah Meskel>So as I mentioned, I am the Urban Conservation Director with Bird Alliance of Oregon, an organization that has been engaging on tree policy for 40-plus years and has been eagerly awaiting an update to the Urban Forest Management Plan.

531
00:53:46.336 --> 00:53:50.697
<v Micah Meskel>And we are very excited and urge you all to pass it today.

532
00:53:53.108 --> 00:54:06.222
<v Micah Meskel>Melinda summarized for over a year and alongside a diverse array of committee members representing East Portland and North Portland and Northeast and Southeast and North.

533
00:54:07.280 --> 00:54:13.114
<v Micah Meskel>And what we ultimately came to in helping inform a plan, I think is really strong.

534
00:54:13.771 --> 00:54:32.784
<v Micah Meskel>And in that space, I was representing the 10,000-plus local members of Bird Alliance who have remained steadfast in their support to push policy programs and funding for the city and the community to collectively and equitably tend and grow our urban forests to benefit birds and people alike.

535
00:54:34.432 --> 00:54:52.942
<v Micah Meskel>Through this, urban forestry staff put a lot of effort over the last few years to update this plan, which included significant collaboration across city bureaus, incorporated other citywide initiatives, and included the voice of community to ensure the plan took a holistic approach to improving the city's efforts to grow and steward the canopy.

536
00:54:53.090 --> 00:55:07.617
<v Micah Meskel>What we see in front of you today was further strengthened deliberation at the Climate, Resilience, and Land Use Committee where we worked alongside partners, council offices, urban forestry staff to craft some amendments to strengthen the plan, which were incorporated.

537
00:55:07.889 --> 00:55:09.764
<v Micah Meskel>There's some additional amendments in front of you today.

538
00:55:10.117 --> 00:55:15.423
<v Micah Meskel>I ask that you judge them based on if they are strengthening the plan or not.

539
00:55:15.809 --> 00:55:20.025
<v Micah Meskel>I would say the revised Dunphy amendments appear to strengthen the plan.

540
00:55:20.697 --> 00:55:28.168
<v Micah Meskel>And I also think that Novick's amendments, though were not intended, feel that they negatively impact the plan.

541
00:55:28.231 --> 00:55:28.344
<v Micah Meskel>Thank you.

542
00:55:28.456 --> 00:55:30.951
<v Micah Meskel>And so I would urge you to vote no on those amendments.

543
00:55:31.733 --> 00:55:33.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for your comments, all of you.

544
00:55:33.199 --> 00:55:34.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate you being here.

545
00:55:35.938 --> 00:55:43.817
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Abe Moland and Noelle Studer-Spieback.

546
00:56:02.501 --> 00:56:04.010
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go ahead.

547
00:56:05.164 --> 00:56:08.260
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>President Pirtle-Guiney, Vice President Koyama Lane, councilors.

548
00:56:08.932 --> 00:56:23.896
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>My name is Noelle Studer-Spievak, 350 PDX Shade Equity Manager and coordinator of the Shade Equity Coalition, with members from more than a dozen livability, health, climate justice, and environmental nonprofits representing thousands of Portlanders.

549
00:56:24.838 --> 00:56:29.994
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>I'm here to support passage of the Urban Forest Plan as amended by the Climate Resilience and Land Use Committee.

550
00:56:31.097 --> 00:56:35.525
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>Through this plan, we are building a lifeboat for the Portlanders of 2080.

551
00:56:36.766 --> 00:56:47.505
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>And I hope you'll consider adopting amendments by Councilor Dunphy, which will expedite heat relief to thousands of residents who live in local heat islands throughout the city, but are most concentrated in District 1.

552
00:56:49.144 --> 00:56:52.570
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>This is not the time to weaken action items with Councilor Novick's amendments.

553
00:56:53.003 --> 00:56:57.992
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>Which would forestall relieving Portlanders of the burden to care for public right-of-way infrastructure.

554
00:56:58.554 --> 00:57:06.304
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>Instead, it's time to set in motion planning that would need to take place to get to our tree canopy to the level that will provide climate resilience to all Portlanders.

555
00:57:07.057 --> 00:57:16.844
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>Cost estimates and feasibility studies for street tree care have already been completed by Parks Urban Forestry 2 times, and there's a 3rd study on the way along with a pilot project.

556
00:57:17.068 --> 00:57:17.855
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>Thank you.

557
00:57:19.476 --> 00:57:28.936
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>As for tree-related sidewalk repair, this expense is a primary reason Portlanders on fixed incomes and low to middle community income members do not want public street trees.

558
00:57:29.369 --> 00:57:40.693
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>In my written testimony, I included sidewalk repair budget data from 6 comparable cities, all of whom managed to fund their street trees and sidewalk repair without having access to a program like PSUF.

559
00:57:41.655 --> 00:58:00.289
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>Creating the plan in Councilor Cannell's amendments would offer the opportunity to identify funding mechanisms There are ample examples from other cities and would also provide the opportunity to identify legal pathways and would not require the city to take on these costs immediately, but could be phased in further funding as further funding is allocated.

560
00:58:01.369 --> 00:58:08.253
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>We launched the Shade Equity Coalition in response to the city's inaction in the wake of the deadly Pacific Northwest heat dome of 2021.

561
00:58:09.110 --> 00:58:11.552
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>This shook all of us who experienced it to the core.

562
00:58:13.860 --> 00:58:14.677
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>Thank you so much.

563
00:58:15.302 --> 00:58:19.373
<v Noelle Studer-Spievak>There's no substitute for good ancestors who take action today.

564
00:58:22.333 --> 00:58:24.849
<v Abe Moland>Thank you.

565
00:58:25.059 --> 00:58:25.092
<v Abe Moland>Abe.

566
00:58:25.155 --> 00:58:25.365
<v Abe Moland>Thank you.

567
00:58:25.721 --> 00:58:26.092
<v Abe Moland>Good evening.

568
00:58:26.463 --> 00:58:28.190
<v Abe Moland>My name is Abe Moland at UCHIM.

569
00:58:28.302 --> 00:58:34.619
<v Abe Moland>I'm a senior research evaluation analyst with the Multnomah County Environmental Health Program within the Multnomah County Public Health Division.

570
00:58:35.458 --> 00:58:39.942
<v Abe Moland>Thank you for this opportunity for the division to submit testimony on the Portland Urban Forestry Plan.

571
00:58:40.380 --> 00:58:42.748
<v Abe Moland>We're pleased to share strong support for the plan.

572
00:58:42.894 --> 00:58:45.625
<v Abe Moland>We view it as a critical investment in the health of Portlanders.

573
00:58:46.284 --> 00:58:54.025
<v Abe Moland>The health benefits of tree canopy are well documented, and abundance of trees in neighborhoods leads to improvements in cardiovascular health, mental health, and birth outcomes.

574
00:58:54.411 --> 00:59:02.458
<v Abe Moland>Furthermore, we are all aware of the growing need for the shade and cooling that trees provide as we continue to see increases in heat-related illness every summer.

575
00:59:03.005 --> 00:59:09.012
<v Abe Moland>We strongly support the goals and strategies outlined in this plan and want to highlight the alignment with our own division goals to improve community health.

576
00:59:10.152 --> 00:59:14.885
<v Abe Moland>A plan to improve Portland's urban forest is a plan to improve the health of Portland's residents.

577
00:59:15.367 --> 00:59:24.403
<v Abe Moland>To this end, we support the development and use of performance metrics that continue to center health equity to ensure further accountability in closing tree canopy gaps in communities that need it most.

578
00:59:24.900 --> 00:59:29.972
<v Abe Moland>We appreciate the use of the Multnomah County Heat Vulnerability Index to help accomplish this.

579
00:59:30.518 --> 00:59:40.255
<v Abe Moland>As your friendly neighborhood public health department, our team is available to consult on the health effects of the plan's implementation or other policy or system changes, and we welcome collaboration.

580
00:59:41.108 --> 00:59:51.072
<v Abe Moland>I'd like to share a final thank you to the community, the staff, and this council for the time and investment in developing this plan to improve the health of Portland's urban forests and the health of our community.

581
00:59:51.639 --> 00:59:55.907
<v Abe Moland>We look forward to the opportunities ahead to promote health and well-being through Portland's urban forest together.

582
00:59:56.554 --> 00:59:56.862
<v Abe Moland>Thank you.

583
00:59:58.916 --> 00:59:59.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both very much.

584
01:00:01.278 --> 01:00:02.396
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That completes testimony.

585
01:00:03.561 --> 01:00:04.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

586
01:00:05.746 --> 01:00:08.465
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, that moves us into discussion.

587
01:00:09.152 --> 01:00:13.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, you wanted to bring us back to the question of the charter.

588
01:00:14.996 --> 01:00:17.552
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I'm curious to understand a little bit more.

589
01:00:17.632 --> 01:00:18.344
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam President.

590
01:00:18.425 --> 01:00:27.391
<v Mitch Green>I'm curious to understand a little bit more about these charter concerns that the City Attorney's Office has raised with those of you who've had those conversations.

591
01:00:29.297 --> 01:00:29.360
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

592
01:00:29.456 --> 01:00:35.467
<v Mitch Green>Section 9-407 of the charter, which is titled Sidewalk Improvements and Repairs, Duty of Owners.

593
01:00:36.862 --> 01:00:47.554
<v Mitch Green>You know, there's a sentence, maybe 2 sentences in there that speak to the specific duties of owners of land abutting any street in the city to construct, reconstruct, and maintain in good repair those adjoining sidewalks.

594
01:00:47.603 --> 01:01:01.083
<v Mitch Green>But the rest of the section speaks to the city's responsibility and duty to ensure that sidewalks are in good repair, they are regulated, and we treat them with the same kind of authority and scope that we do the rest of our infrastructure.

595
01:01:02.742 --> 01:01:12.391
<v Mitch Green>Elsewhere it talks about if the parcel owner doesn't do a good job at this or fails to do a good job at this, then we'll just go ahead and do it for them and we'll charge them a fee.

596
01:01:12.918 --> 01:01:26.262
<v Mitch Green>So when I read this, I don't see it preventing the city from making a plan and saying, by the way, we can commit to lifting the financial obligation of the homeowner.

597
01:01:27.300 --> 01:01:29.215
<v Mitch Green>The charter doesn't prohibit the city from— yes, it does.

598
01:01:29.980 --> 01:01:31.438
<v Mitch Green>From offering that is the way that I read it.

599
01:01:31.501 --> 01:01:33.072
<v Mitch Green>But of course, I'm not a trained attorney.

600
01:01:33.889 --> 01:01:36.612
<v Mitch Green>I'd be curious to hear from the City Attorney's Office on this.

601
01:01:37.655 --> 01:01:57.864
<v Mitch Green>But I really think this could potentially be a conservative reading of the charter, and I wouldn't want that to stand in the way of the intent, which is to relieve these homeowners of the burden of not only maintaining these trees, but it solves— I mean, part of the reason we're in a situation where we plant a tree and the tree dies is we have a principal-agent problem.

602
01:01:58.666 --> 01:02:02.661
<v Mitch Green>We do not have a system where we've said, this is infrastructure, by the way.

603
01:02:02.983 --> 01:02:08.101
<v Mitch Green>We are gonna commit to this for equity reasons and climate reasons, and we're gonna put our money where our mouth is.

604
01:02:08.150 --> 01:02:15.114
<v Mitch Green>So I would really appreciate some sort of clarity on kind of the legal reasoning there.

605
01:02:16.396 --> 01:02:19.190
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Lynley, are you prepared to help us navigate this?

606
01:02:19.525 --> 01:02:22.831
<v Keelan McClymont>Well, I'll start by identifying that there are a couple of other charter provisions.

607
01:02:22.880 --> 01:02:26.876
<v Keelan McClymont>There's also an attorney, I believe, on the Zoom call who advises urban forestry.

608
01:02:27.293 --> 01:02:39.367
<v Keelan McClymont>But let me first point out, there is 9407, but there's also 9408, which provides no action shall be maintained against the city by or for any person injured because of any sidewalk defect.

609
01:02:40.715 --> 01:02:52.438
<v Keelan McClymont>There is also Section 1-105, which provides no recourse shall be had against the city for damage or loss to person or property suffered or sustained by reason of the defective condition of any sidewalk, et cetera.

610
01:02:54.590 --> 01:03:11.311
<v Keelan McClymont>What that means is that if you're going to ask the executive side to review, you know, how would we go about doing what you want to do, they're going to have to analyze whether a charter amendment is required to do that for the sidewalk portion.

611
01:03:11.358 --> 01:03:15.885
<v Keelan McClymont>These don't speak to street trees themselves, but it speaks to sidewalk repair.

612
01:03:16.175 --> 01:03:20.039
<v Keelan McClymont>So I just— and if Rob Yamachika is online and wants to speak to it, I'd love to hear from him.

613
01:03:20.119 --> 01:03:20.605
<v Keelan McClymont>I think he's on the phone.

614
01:03:21.300 --> 01:03:21.717
<v Keelan McClymont>Feel free.

615
01:03:22.487 --> 01:03:22.744
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

616
01:03:22.903 --> 01:03:23.739
<v Mitch Green>Thanks, Lindley.

617
01:03:23.786 --> 01:03:24.396
<v Rob Yamachika>I'm online.

618
01:03:24.684 --> 01:03:28.728
<v Rob Yamachika>Uh, I think, uh, good evening, uh, members of the City Council.

619
01:03:28.775 --> 01:03:30.059
<v Rob Yamachika>My name is Rob Yamachika.

620
01:03:30.123 --> 01:03:31.615
<v Rob Yamachika>I'm a senior deputy city attorney.

621
01:03:31.807 --> 01:03:36.829
<v Rob Yamachika>I advise, uh, Urban Forestry, PP&D, Fire Bureau, and the Rangers.

622
01:03:37.568 --> 01:03:45.606
<v Rob Yamachika>Uh, Lindley identified, I think, the, the major section of your charter is 1-105, which is the non-liability of defective sidewalks.

623
01:03:46.103 --> 01:04:05.221
<v Rob Yamachika>So that's I used to do litigation as well for 13 years for the city, and that's the section that we use to tender defense to adjacent property owners, coupled with the appropriate section of the code, whether it be the visibility standard in Title 16 or, um, 17, which is your vehicle code.

624
01:04:06.054 --> 01:04:19.259
<v Rob Yamachika>So, um, I think that the, the operative one is Section 1-105, not necessarily 9407 and 9408, although those are that's helpful.

625
01:04:19.434 --> 01:04:38.269
<v Mitch Green>And when we think about the previous— I mean, the plan as proposed before the amendments that calls for the city to provide recommendations on feasibility on either a legal or financial basis, does that rule out part of that saying, well, we recommend maybe a charter amendment to effectuate this?

626
01:04:41.934 --> 01:04:46.514
<v Rob Yamachika>A charter amendment would be required with the approval of the voters.

627
01:04:47.257 --> 01:05:02.114
<v Rob Yamachika>I will say, I looked at— I spoke with Ken McGear, who advises PBOT, and most street sidewalk maintenance is the responsibility of the adjacent property owner in most cities in the United States.

628
01:05:02.163 --> 01:05:04.849
<v Rob Yamachika>And I looked at Seattle's code as well as San Francisco.

629
01:05:04.896 --> 01:05:08.690
<v Rob Yamachika>So our code is not— our charter and code is not unusual.

630
01:05:08.739 --> 01:05:08.851
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

631
01:05:13.945 --> 01:05:15.280
<v Mitch Green>Okay, I appreciate that.

632
01:05:15.521 --> 01:05:28.021
<v Mitch Green>Um, I guess what I would offer colleagues is that I'm interested in passing an urban forestry plan that communicates to our city that we actually don't think this is a good way to continue going forward in time.

633
01:05:28.440 --> 01:05:40.293
<v Mitch Green>I actually think that we want to have a city that does not leave our homeowners, uh, in a position where they have to make a decision on whether they want to be in favor or against a requirement to have an urban canopy.

634
01:05:41.144 --> 01:05:44.422
<v Mitch Green>And this is kind of what our current situation is telling us.

635
01:05:44.695 --> 01:06:00.043
<v Mitch Green>And so if the resolution provides the administrative branch the sort of mandate to say, well, as part of this recommendation to council would be perhaps a discussion with the voters around a charter amendment, that's, I think, what we need to see.

636
01:06:00.690 --> 01:06:10.061
<v Mitch Green>And I would I would hope that we would entertain that rather than sort of roll back the original language, which I think was stronger.

637
01:06:11.373 --> 01:06:12.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

638
01:06:12.327 --> 01:06:13.070
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

639
01:06:15.885 --> 01:06:19.233
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm having similar concerns.

640
01:06:19.427 --> 01:06:26.922
<v Eric Zimmerman>I mean, I'll start with it's deeply irresponsible for a charter to go into the details that ours does on a lot of stuff that should be in code.

641
01:06:27.514 --> 01:06:30.876
<v Eric Zimmerman>If you take a look at Multnomah County's charter, it's pretty straightforward.

642
01:06:31.150 --> 01:06:34.271
<v Eric Zimmerman>Portland's, you need a law degree just to get through the first paragraph.

643
01:06:35.601 --> 01:06:44.351
<v Eric Zimmerman>So insofar as where should such a matter be dealt with, I find it deeply inappropriate to be in the charter.

644
01:06:44.739 --> 01:07:00.306
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I have really appreciated the movement by, I think, the city apparatus and urban forestry and PSEF and everybody who's been involved to recognize To Councilor Green's point, the infrastructure aspect here.

645
01:07:01.483 --> 01:07:09.547
<v Eric Zimmerman>Having, you know, I've had a $5,000-some-odd repair to a sidewalk in a different city that I lived in.

646
01:07:10.829 --> 01:07:18.197
<v Eric Zimmerman>No matter what you're making, that is a tough repair to get a notice from the city about because of the tree damage to a sidewalk.

647
01:07:19.614 --> 01:07:32.557
<v Eric Zimmerman>One of my earliest memories with my grandfather is being out on the sidewalk on 47th and Holgate and helping him repair where his trees had lifted the sidewalk.

648
01:07:32.653 --> 01:07:34.277
<v Eric Zimmerman>And he'd gotten a notice, obviously.

649
01:07:34.340 --> 01:07:40.637
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then we were— this was the late '80s or early '90s, and we were out there doing it Ralph style.

650
01:07:40.750 --> 01:07:41.297
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's his name.

651
01:07:41.795 --> 01:07:42.646
<v Eric Zimmerman>Just with some concrete.

652
01:07:42.693 --> 01:07:45.971
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm sure it was not by code at all, but we were trying to fix the sidewalk.

653
01:07:46.789 --> 01:07:48.268
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm looking at that house today.

654
01:07:48.396 --> 01:07:51.288
<v Eric Zimmerman>He's been gone many, many years, but I'm looking at that house today.

655
01:07:51.994 --> 01:07:52.666
<v Eric Zimmerman>On Google Maps.

656
01:07:52.731 --> 01:07:59.804
<v Eric Zimmerman>And on one picture, if I go to the old picture, I can see those old 4 enormous trees who were there and they populated that parking strip.

657
01:08:00.588 --> 01:08:02.882
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the sidewalk is walkable, but it's not in the best condition.

658
01:08:02.931 --> 01:08:04.036
<v Eric Zimmerman>You can see it being raised up.

659
01:08:05.016 --> 01:08:05.945
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's the old picture.

660
01:08:06.041 --> 01:08:09.650
<v Eric Zimmerman>Today's photo, not a single tree is in that parking strip.

661
01:08:10.371 --> 01:08:21.596
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I, I, I bring this up because I have a feeling that if Ralph had not just gotten a notice on how to try to keep things going on an area that we don't— most of us don't know how to do.

662
01:08:21.662 --> 01:08:21.822
<v Eric Zimmerman>Mm-hmm.

663
01:08:22.319 --> 01:08:30.601
<v Eric Zimmerman>That if the city had been a willing and able partner, or even in this sense responsible, perhaps those trees would still be there today.

664
01:08:30.698 --> 01:08:44.055
<v Eric Zimmerman>Some old-growth large trees, instead of being a completely— there are 2 lots now that have no coverage in Southeast Portland that I think probably would have had the city been responsible for it and not a layperson.

665
01:08:47.088 --> 01:08:48.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that is a bit of a statement.

666
01:08:48.414 --> 01:09:04.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>My question to Councilor Novick I'm a little bit surprised by the pushback that we're hearing about the language in your amendments because, and I'm wondering if you can highlight why, what is it about your amendments that are causing this concern?

667
01:09:04.554 --> 01:09:14.296
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because it seems like, for me, it seemed like some basic language, but I'm not— there's some connective tissue I'm not understanding from what we're hearing, and I'm wondering if you can enlighten me.

668
01:09:15.567 --> 01:09:17.104
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

669
01:09:17.317 --> 01:09:18.690
<v Steve Novick>To be honest, I'm a little confused myself.

670
01:09:19.826 --> 01:09:31.416
<v Steve Novick>The original one, we just heard people talk about what a great process we had and how much outreach there was from urban forestry leading to the plan that was presented to the Climate and Land Use Committee.

671
01:09:32.136 --> 01:09:39.109
<v Steve Novick>And on this sidewalk issue, I'm proposing returning to the original language that went through that wonderful process.

672
01:09:39.846 --> 01:09:49.833
<v Steve Novick>The original language was identify financing strategies, cost-saving measures, and other ways to improve pedestrian accessibility and reduce costs to property owners for repairing sidewalks damaged by trees.

673
01:09:50.572 --> 01:09:50.796
<v Steve Novick>I'm all for it.

674
01:09:50.844 --> 01:09:50.956
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

675
01:09:51.052 --> 01:09:59.800
<v Steve Novick>Exploring reducing cost to property owners, and I would like to do that in a measured way and see if there's any way in particular we can reduce cost to property owners who don't have very much money.

676
01:10:00.425 --> 01:10:12.024
<v Steve Novick>I'm not as excited about saying that we're going to change the charter and assign legal responsibility for all sidewalks to the city, including responsibility for sidewalks adjacent to people in Eastmoreland and the West Hills.

677
01:10:12.537 --> 01:10:15.117
<v Steve Novick>Now, as a matter of principle, I think that—.

678
01:10:15.117 --> 01:10:16.990
<v Eric Zimmerman>We don't really have too many sidewalks in the West Hills.

679
01:10:17.503 --> 01:10:18.113
<v Steve Novick>That's true.

680
01:10:18.368 --> 01:10:20.851
<v Steve Novick>All right, let's just say— let's keep it in my district.

681
01:10:20.917 --> 01:10:26.877
<v Steve Novick>Well, no, my district and District 4 and adjacent parts, Eastmoreland and Laurelhurst.

682
01:10:26.877 --> 01:10:27.796
<v Steve Novick>I didn't mean to get you.

683
01:10:28.296 --> 01:10:36.636
<v Steve Novick>But anyway, I mean, so I just want to go back to the original language that was presented to us.

684
01:10:36.636 --> 01:10:39.426
<v Steve Novick>And yes, I think it would be great if the city maintained all the sidewalks.

685
01:10:39.697 --> 01:10:42.157
<v Steve Novick>I also think it would be great if the city was maintaining our streets.

686
01:10:42.457 --> 01:10:49.497
<v Steve Novick>I also think it'd be great if there were police officers patrolling the area around McDaniel High School so that students aren't continually subjected to human trafficking.

687
01:10:49.777 --> 01:11:05.653
<v Steve Novick>There's a lot of things I think we should do, but I do not want to, in the context of what's supposed to be a visioning document about urban forest canopy, do something that I think commits ourselves to spending a bunch of money that we don't have and is also contrary to the charter.

688
01:11:06.728 --> 01:11:07.193
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

689
01:11:08.395 --> 01:11:22.189
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would say, as other colleagues comment, I hope that you'll weigh in if the words report on cost and feasibility is a sticking point that we're hearing from public testimony, 'cause I'm just, I'm not understanding that sticking point.

690
01:11:23.087 --> 01:11:28.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>I also just, from a comment, this is a pretty significant piece of work.

691
01:11:28.766 --> 01:11:32.360
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I will say I'm a little bit disappointed.

692
01:11:32.472 --> 01:11:46.239
<v Eric Zimmerman>No, I'm a lot a bit disappointed that urban forestry or the Parks Bureau did not walk this urban forestry plan across the floor, so to speak, in the way that I get a lot of outreach from the bureaus on their big products that are coming.

693
01:11:46.496 --> 01:11:55.814
<v Eric Zimmerman>I find that disappointing because I think In review of this, there has been a significant amount of public outreach, community outreach, some really important goals here.

694
01:11:56.038 --> 01:11:59.373
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I appreciate those of you that put some hard work into amendments.

695
01:11:59.662 --> 01:12:08.225
<v Eric Zimmerman>But this to me feels like a significant portion of the decision-making was left out, which was walk your plan with the council.

696
01:12:08.561 --> 01:12:19.835
<v Eric Zimmerman>I feel like that has really been missed given the way that we post things later because I would've liked to have been able to ask some questions of the Bureau staff, especially as these amendments came in.

697
01:12:19.979 --> 01:12:20.235
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

698
01:12:21.507 --> 01:12:23.618
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm looking forward to some of the discussion on these amendments.

699
01:12:23.699 --> 01:12:24.103
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

700
01:12:25.376 --> 01:12:39.662
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will note, and I appreciate you bringing it back to the underlying resolution, because we don't actually have any amendments on the table that have been moved, and we do have the Bureau Director and the DCA here if we need to ask questions of them.

701
01:12:41.056 --> 01:12:41.626
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

702
01:12:42.716 --> 01:12:46.444
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

703
01:12:46.605 --> 01:12:47.484
<v Loretta Smith>I have a couple of questions.

704
01:12:49.694 --> 01:12:55.739
<v Loretta Smith>Are there any preliminary numbers that we can attach to the— to these amendments at all?

705
01:12:55.820 --> 01:13:06.685
<v Loretta Smith>I know that the report is requiring the department to bring together some numbers, but I mean, just a ballpark idea of any numbers.

706
01:13:09.606 --> 01:13:11.911
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>DCA Dhanapal, would you like to answer that?

707
01:13:12.039 --> 01:13:13.814
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or Acting CA Biery?

708
01:13:13.975 --> 01:13:17.649
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We happen to have somebody with deep financial knowledge of the city up here with us.

709
01:13:19.259 --> 01:13:28.078
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, DCA Donapal.

710
01:13:28.463 --> 01:13:29.283
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Appreciate you.

711
01:13:29.572 --> 01:13:30.551
<v Priya Dhanapal>Good evening, Councilor.

712
01:13:30.953 --> 01:13:38.001
<v Priya Dhanapal>This is Priya Dhanapal, DCA for Public Works, and I have Brian here with me from Fox who will be able to answer that question.

713
01:13:38.194 --> 01:13:38.583
<v Priya Dhanapal>Go ahead.

714
01:13:39.150 --> 01:13:40.997
<v Brian Lando>Yeah, thanks for the question, Councilor Smith.

715
01:13:41.760 --> 01:13:43.185
<v Brian Lando>Brian Lando with Urban Forestry.

716
01:13:43.713 --> 01:13:55.659
<v Brian Lando>I can't speak to the sidewalk piece, but in terms of street tree maintenance, we have done a few cost studies over the years with a consultant, and it really depends on the level of service you're looking to have.

717
01:13:56.173 --> 01:14:08.328
<v Brian Lando>There's different options within it, but if we were to implement a system where— which is really the best practice— where every tree is inspected on a 5 to 10 year cycle, appropriate maintenance is done, between $15 to $20 million a year.

718
01:14:08.393 --> 01:14:08.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

719
01:14:13.443 --> 01:14:14.377
<v Eric Zimmerman>Really?

720
01:14:14.876 --> 01:14:16.984
<v Loretta Smith>That seems pretty low to me.

721
01:14:17.548 --> 01:14:19.417
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, it does.

722
01:14:19.561 --> 01:14:36.860
<v Loretta Smith>I was thinking more along the lines, particularly if you're having to maintenance the trees, hire the personnel, and we have just downsized the personnel in that department.

723
01:14:37.823 --> 01:14:47.664
<v Loretta Smith>And that, that, that alone would probably get you $15 million without even replacing the canopies and/or the sidewalks.

724
01:14:48.257 --> 01:14:58.820
<v Loretta Smith>Um, does this plan address and mitigate for the potential of ongoing funding that you're going to have to do for— does that include the maintenance as well?

725
01:14:59.655 --> 01:15:12.110
<v Brian Lando>Yeah, the, the plan— I mean, the the plan identifies that many of the action items rely on existing funding or existing commitments from the Portland Clean Energy Fund, which we know are allocated in 5-year increments.

726
01:15:13.010 --> 01:15:21.981
<v Brian Lando>So it does assume certain levels of support would continue in order for them to be— for the plan's action items to be accomplished.

727
01:15:22.061 --> 01:15:27.134
<v Brian Lando>And we know that some items don't have funding attached yet or would need future resources for them.

728
01:15:27.578 --> 01:15:27.917
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

729
01:15:28.207 --> 01:15:37.904
<v Loretta Smith>I appreciate it, and I appreciate the reports, the folks that they reached out to, and all the community engagement that took place with this.

730
01:15:37.970 --> 01:15:45.920
<v Loretta Smith>But the other piece to this that we're even grappling with is our risk fund.

731
01:15:47.006 --> 01:15:47.070
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

732
01:15:47.119 --> 01:16:05.918
<v Loretta Smith>And my concern, if we're responsible for every tree, every sidewalk in the City of Portland, That we now have to be responsible for, like, my grandkids who are riding their bike down the street and they fall and they break their knee or leg.

733
01:16:06.904 --> 01:16:10.813
<v Loretta Smith>And I can see this as a gift that keeps on giving.

734
01:16:14.782 --> 01:16:14.846
<v Loretta Smith>And—.

735
01:16:14.846 --> 01:16:18.207
<v Loretta Smith>That's something that I think that needs to really be put in there.

736
01:16:18.581 --> 01:16:25.551
<v Loretta Smith>You know, I didn't see anything about the risks fund possibilities of where this could go or not.

737
01:16:25.792 --> 01:16:26.177
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

738
01:16:26.402 --> 01:16:28.506
<v Loretta Smith>Because I can, I can see it going a long way.

739
01:16:28.586 --> 01:16:40.067
<v Loretta Smith>We just played close to $1 million, um, for a kid who, um, unfortunately had some brain issues falling off of a, you know, the, the light.

740
01:16:40.226 --> 01:16:41.447
<v Loretta Smith>And it was, it was horrible.

741
01:16:41.735 --> 01:16:48.256
<v Loretta Smith>And so that alone, I, if everyone can file a claim.

742
01:16:49.502 --> 01:16:55.217
<v Loretta Smith>We also need to put that in your equation when you're talking about the $15 to $20 million.

743
01:16:55.426 --> 01:16:56.712
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

744
01:16:57.194 --> 01:16:58.192
<v Loretta Smith>It's going to be huge.

745
01:16:58.867 --> 01:17:09.573
<v Loretta Smith>But at any rate, I would have liked to have heard some additional— I just got my colleagues' amendments today on the 15th about the proposed.

746
01:17:09.685 --> 01:17:18.211
<v Loretta Smith>And, you know, I'm going to always say if we've already passed something like SIP, and we have, to always circle back.

747
01:17:19.012 --> 01:17:31.163
<v Loretta Smith>And if SIP is going to be the vehicle to getting some of this done in the low-income and vulnerable neighborhoods, that we try to add a friendly amendment or something so that SIP can be included because we've already passed it.

748
01:17:31.564 --> 01:17:31.774
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

749
01:17:32.175 --> 01:17:43.891
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, and also identify, uh, funding sources because, you know, it's not lost on me or anyone up here, uh, that, that we have a hole in our budget and we've been talking about it for the last couple of months.

750
01:17:44.292 --> 01:17:50.498
<v Loretta Smith>And adding additional operating expenses, we also have to think about that.

751
01:17:50.579 --> 01:17:58.132
<v Loretta Smith>So I know where SIP is coming from, limited revenue bonds, but we need to identify funding for this new thing.

752
01:17:58.886 --> 01:18:09.052
<v Loretta Smith>I think we all should have trees in our neighborhoods and adjacent to our homes, and our children should understand, you know, the value of trees.

753
01:18:09.149 --> 01:18:10.159
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that's so important.

754
01:18:10.207 --> 01:18:10.351
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

755
01:18:11.010 --> 01:18:22.792
<v Loretta Smith>But just like Councilor Dunphy said, in District 1, we have the fewest trees in the city, and this would definitely help District 1.

756
01:18:23.289 --> 01:18:28.636
<v Loretta Smith>But we also need to stack up the wins and losses on each side and see what it's gonna cost us.

757
01:18:29.935 --> 01:18:30.609
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

758
01:18:31.155 --> 01:18:31.332
<v Priya Dhanapal>Go ahead.

759
01:18:31.396 --> 01:18:33.773
<v Priya Dhanapal>Councilor Smith, thank you, Brian.

760
01:18:33.885 --> 01:18:37.850
<v Priya Dhanapal>Brian mentioned the cost for the trees, the $15 to $20 million.

761
01:18:38.234 --> 01:18:46.217
<v Priya Dhanapal>If you look at the long-term responsibility for the sidewalks, The curbs and the drainage and everything else, it could be hundreds of millions of dollars.

762
01:18:46.265 --> 01:18:49.029
<v Priya Dhanapal>So just wanted to make sure that it's clear.

763
01:18:49.109 --> 01:18:49.739
<v Priya Dhanapal>So it's a lot of—.

764
01:18:49.739 --> 01:18:50.854
<v Loretta Smith>I'm sorry, I didn't hear you.

765
01:18:51.277 --> 01:18:59.721
<v Priya Dhanapal>It's probably hundreds of millions of dollars if you— the long-term responsibility for the sidewalks could be larger.

766
01:19:00.599 --> 01:19:00.957
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

767
01:19:01.346 --> 01:19:06.738
<v Loretta Smith>And that's what I wanted us to be realistic, not just like, oh, we can just take $15 million.

768
01:19:07.993 --> 01:19:09.384
<v Loretta Smith>And we're going to be able to serve everyone.

769
01:19:10.903 --> 01:19:14.037
<v Loretta Smith>We have one of the largest urban forests in the country.

770
01:19:14.779 --> 01:19:19.463
<v Loretta Smith>That alone would take $15 million to, to take care of.

771
01:19:20.588 --> 01:19:24.384
<v Loretta Smith>Um, at any rate, I will pass it on, uh, Madam President.

772
01:19:27.582 --> 01:19:28.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, Councilor Kanal.

773
01:19:29.518 --> 01:19:30.501
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

774
01:19:30.565 --> 01:19:35.305
<v Sameer Kanal>I move to limit debate on the urban forest plan resolution to an additional 20 minutes.

775
01:19:36.264 --> 01:19:39.095
<v Sameer Kanal>And then either move to a vote or to a motion to postpone.

776
01:19:41.306 --> 01:19:42.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

777
01:19:42.788 --> 01:19:43.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe—.

778
01:19:43.048 --> 01:19:43.587
<v Sameer Kanal>Second.

779
01:19:43.846 --> 01:19:44.351
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There we go.

780
01:19:44.661 --> 01:19:45.215
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need a second.

781
01:19:46.367 --> 01:19:49.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe this is not a debatable motion.

782
01:19:49.137 --> 01:19:49.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

783
01:19:50.613 --> 01:19:51.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Lynley's shaking her head no.

784
01:19:52.314 --> 01:19:54.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

785
01:19:57.582 --> 01:19:57.784
<v Keelan McClymont>Clerk.

786
01:20:02.685 --> 01:20:02.782
<v Loretta Smith>No.

787
01:20:03.318 --> 01:20:03.416
<v Olivia Clark>Green.

788
01:20:05.283 --> 01:20:07.264
<v Mitch Green>Can you please repeat what we're voting on?

789
01:20:07.311 --> 01:20:08.140
<v Mitch Green>What's the motion on the floor?

790
01:20:09.234 --> 01:20:16.627
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A motion to limit debate to 20 minutes and then move automatically to a vote on any motions on the table or to postpone.

791
01:20:17.159 --> 01:20:17.320
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

792
01:20:19.176 --> 01:20:19.561
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

793
01:20:20.885 --> 01:20:22.061
<v Eric Zimmerman>Definitely in favor of postponing.

794
01:20:22.141 --> 01:20:23.077
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think we're gonna get through this.

795
01:20:23.206 --> 01:20:24.729
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for this proposal.

796
01:20:24.908 --> 01:20:25.072
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

797
01:20:26.375 --> 01:20:26.685
<v Brian Lando>Avalos.

798
01:20:27.027 --> 01:20:27.076
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

799
01:20:30.289 --> 01:20:30.417
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

800
01:20:31.913 --> 01:20:31.994
<v Brian Lando>Aye.

801
01:20:32.703 --> 01:20:32.751
<v Brian Lando>Aye.

802
01:20:33.989 --> 01:20:34.167
<v Brian Lando>Aye.

803
01:20:36.016 --> 01:20:36.194
<v Brian Lando>Aye.

804
01:20:39.055 --> 01:20:42.270
<v Olivia Clark>Also in favor of postponing, uh, although I think this is incredibly important.

805
01:20:42.511 --> 01:20:42.543
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

806
01:20:43.957 --> 01:20:45.822
<v Steve Novick>I'm confused again.

807
01:20:45.903 --> 01:20:47.787
<v Steve Novick>It's to limit and postpone?

808
01:20:48.402 --> 01:20:53.922
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Limit to 20 minutes, and then if we are in a place where we can vote, vote, and if we are not, postpone.

809
01:20:54.275 --> 01:20:54.733
<v Steve Novick>Okay, aye.

810
01:20:59.506 --> 01:20:59.523
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

811
01:20:59.895 --> 01:21:03.371
<v Keelan McClymont>Motion carries with 11 yes votes and 1 no vote.

812
01:21:03.694 --> 01:21:09.657
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I would ask us to try to move forward as much as we can tonight.

813
01:21:10.332 --> 01:21:15.850
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The proponents of this resolution specifically requested that we do this today.

814
01:21:17.457 --> 01:21:18.353
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy.

815
01:21:19.345 --> 01:21:19.737
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

816
01:21:20.259 --> 01:21:29.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I would like to move Dunphy Amendments 1, 2, 3, and 4 as a package of amendments for consideration.

817
01:21:29.966 --> 01:21:30.592
<v Jamie Dunphy>Second.

818
01:21:31.380 --> 01:21:32.537
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do I need more than that?

819
01:21:33.565 --> 01:21:34.305
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't believe so.

820
01:21:34.368 --> 01:21:36.072
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I heard a second, but I wasn't sure from who.

821
01:21:36.216 --> 01:21:36.988
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal?

822
01:21:37.261 --> 01:21:39.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That was seconded by Councilor Kanal.

823
01:21:39.735 --> 01:21:46.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we have Dunphy Amendments 1, 2, 3, and 4 on the table as a package.

824
01:21:46.564 --> 01:21:48.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are moving to debate on that.

825
01:21:48.896 --> 01:21:49.061
<v Jamie Dunphy>Motion.

826
01:21:49.344 --> 01:21:51.479
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, are you in the queue to debate that motion?

827
01:21:53.806 --> 01:21:55.345
<v Steve Novick>Yes, I would ask to separate it.

828
01:21:57.016 --> 01:21:59.434
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To separate all of them or to separate out one of them?

829
01:21:59.483 --> 01:22:01.720
<v Steve Novick>To separate out, well, let's see.

830
01:22:04.016 --> 01:22:06.894
<v Steve Novick>I'm looking at, Councilor Dunphy, I'm looking at your emails.

831
01:22:08.815 --> 01:22:13.185
<v Steve Novick>There's Amendment 1, let's see.

832
01:22:14.287 --> 01:22:15.806
<v Steve Novick>1, 2, 3, 4.

833
01:22:16.485 --> 01:22:19.073
<v Steve Novick>Let's see.

834
01:22:20.868 --> 01:22:23.391
<v Steve Novick>1, 2, 3, And 4.

835
01:22:24.167 --> 01:22:32.582
<v Steve Novick>1, 2— I would separate out 2 because I think that— well, no, let's see.

836
01:22:33.067 --> 01:22:39.671
<v Steve Novick>Basically, I'm okay with them except for 4, so I don't want to vote for all of them except for 4.

837
01:22:40.557 --> 01:22:47.662
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So you would ask that the motion be to vote on 1, 2, and 3 separately?

838
01:22:47.841 --> 01:22:48.197
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

839
01:22:49.072 --> 01:22:49.671
<v Priya Dhanapal>Okay.

840
01:22:49.945 --> 01:22:51.240
<v Jamie Dunphy>I accept that as a friendly amendment.

841
01:22:52.556 --> 01:22:59.528
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe this is a motion to separate, so we don't need a new amendment.

842
01:22:59.591 --> 01:23:04.145
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, would you like to vote first on 1, 2, 3, or on 4?

843
01:23:09.930 --> 01:23:11.360
<v Steve Novick>Let's see, um, point of order.

844
01:23:11.457 --> 01:23:14.336
<v Loretta Smith>That decision is with the motioner, so that should be—.

845
01:23:14.351 --> 01:23:18.810
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe the ultimate decision is, but we usually do take a recommendation.

846
01:23:21.188 --> 01:23:22.368
<v Steve Novick>I vote first on 4.

847
01:23:23.208 --> 01:23:27.592
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor Dunphy, are you okay with that?

848
01:23:28.264 --> 01:23:28.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sounds good.

849
01:23:29.948 --> 01:23:32.975
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we are in debate on Dunphy for.

850
01:23:33.827 --> 01:23:34.502
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

851
01:23:41.494 --> 01:23:55.451
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, Councilor Dunphy, I guess, um, with what I believe is going to be the inevitable postponing, I want to offer up comments of I could get there on most of what I've seen you propose.

852
01:23:56.207 --> 01:24:09.110
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's hard, uh, in this moment with respect to my real questions, not just with this but others, is perhaps why weren't they included in the plan given how robust this thing is?

853
01:24:09.175 --> 01:24:09.271
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

854
01:24:09.801 --> 01:24:17.212
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm going to be looking for responses from you, from the Bureau.

855
01:24:17.356 --> 01:24:22.443
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I don't see the Director of Urban Forestry at the table, but I expect that she's probably here.

856
01:24:22.635 --> 01:24:24.577
<v Eric Zimmerman>Like, that's what I'm hoping to get.

857
01:24:24.801 --> 01:24:36.572
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I will probably ask that question for each of these as we go through it because of— we have such a trend that usually includes the language that you've indicated, but for whatever reason it wasn't here.

858
01:24:37.261 --> 01:24:44.038
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'll just make a comment, Madam President, in the way in which we're posting exhibits in the council.

859
01:24:44.712 --> 01:24:52.324
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have found this one particularly uninformative in that Exhibit A posted multiple times.

860
01:24:52.421 --> 01:24:52.516
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

861
01:24:52.983 --> 01:25:04.235
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then not really saying what Exhibit A is and the changes has created some, I think, unfortunate misprintings here that I think could have cleared this up earlier.

862
01:25:04.317 --> 01:25:06.256
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's my question to you.

863
01:25:06.304 --> 01:25:12.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I'm looking forward to a larger conversation on all this so that we can all get there and support it.

864
01:25:12.460 --> 01:25:14.207
<v Eric Zimmerman>'Cause I agree with Councilor Murillo, it's super important.

865
01:25:14.801 --> 01:25:23.393
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I believe the question to Councilor Dunphy and to the folks before us is why these amendments were not originally included.

866
01:25:23.440 --> 01:25:23.953
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that the case?

867
01:25:25.846 --> 01:25:32.841
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if they are passed, the expected impacts, outcomes, et cetera, what do they mean from a bureaucratic standpoint?

868
01:25:33.225 --> 01:25:35.070
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I will just respond to that.

869
01:25:35.488 --> 01:25:47.806
<v Jamie Dunphy>Based on testimony we received from Thrive East PDX and a number of other folks, they were very thankful for the robust outreach, but they didn't see that their outreach was, or that their recommendations were reflected in the action items.

870
01:25:48.704 --> 01:25:53.206
<v Jamie Dunphy>That there, that it is a lot in the recitals and the beginning part, But not so much in the back part.

871
01:25:53.368 --> 01:26:08.021
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that these were some specifics that they thought would match our previous investments and our previous discussions about the particular need in District 1, which they thought they had properly conveyed, but didn't see it reflected in the file.

872
01:26:08.262 --> 01:26:12.046
<v Jamie Dunphy>So they asked for some specifics that would help strengthen these specific items.

873
01:26:14.743 --> 01:26:15.132
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

874
01:26:15.311 --> 01:26:26.460
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are you aware, and I think since 4 is about curbed sidewalks, road cleaning, I don't know enough about road cleaning to know what a curb sidewalk plays in that mechanism.

875
01:26:26.765 --> 01:26:30.743
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, is it a guideline or is it just a— that can't physically be done?

876
01:26:30.792 --> 01:26:31.835
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't know enough about that.

877
01:26:31.899 --> 01:26:42.743
<v Jamie Dunphy>My understanding broadly is that the street sweepers have the big brushes and they extend beyond the length of the car or the vehicle itself, but it goes— they drive it up to and brush along the sidewalk.

878
01:26:42.807 --> 01:26:51.386
<v Jamie Dunphy>But if you do that into an unpaved sidewalk area, it pulls dirt and shrapnel of other kinds into the brushes and makes it ineffective.

879
01:26:51.851 --> 01:26:57.461
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so streets that don't have sidewalks or don't have curbs historically don't get street swept.

880
01:26:58.342 --> 01:26:58.759
<v Steve Novick>Right.

881
01:26:58.840 --> 01:27:07.622
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I live on one of those streets and I put gravel down every couple of years in what would be a sidewalk and in the beginning parts of my driveway.

882
01:27:07.814 --> 01:27:11.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I do get it.

883
01:27:11.100 --> 01:27:14.130
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I also, I love a street cleaning situation, right?

884
01:27:14.225 --> 01:27:19.408
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I also would like, is that, I wanna know the mechanics from the Bureau in terms of what this means.

885
01:27:19.761 --> 01:27:28.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, rather than presuppose, I'd ask that we look to our urban forester, our parks director, and I see that we also have our PBOT director here.

886
01:27:28.574 --> 01:27:37.452
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you'd like to come forward, maybe you can speak to street sweeping as well so we can get some technical answers for council and then get through as much as we can in the next 17 minutes.

887
01:27:38.382 --> 01:27:38.832
<v Millicent Williams>Good evening.

888
01:27:39.088 --> 01:27:41.368
<v Millicent Williams>Millicent Williams, Director of the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

889
01:27:41.497 --> 01:27:42.380
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you very much.

890
01:27:43.645 --> 01:27:45.753
<v Millicent Williams>Almost got out of here without having to answer any questions.

891
01:27:47.686 --> 01:27:51.574
<v Millicent Williams>The street sweeping, it varies depending on the character of the street.

892
01:27:51.671 --> 01:27:59.014
<v Millicent Williams>So yes, of course, there are some where you see the brushes going down the street, clearing debris of all sorts.

893
01:27:59.207 --> 01:28:07.292
<v Millicent Williams>Streets that do not have curbs, we are not able to use the traditional street sweeper, but there are mechanisms that we use to clean them.

894
01:28:07.552 --> 01:28:10.692
<v Millicent Williams>It's mostly forced water flushing that we are able to do.

895
01:28:10.740 --> 01:28:21.725
<v Millicent Williams>For those streets that are mostly gravel or the ones that we have declared to be gravel streets, we go through and regrade those streets, and that serves as the opportunity for us to do some cleaning.

896
01:28:21.805 --> 01:28:21.854
<v Millicent Williams>Yeah.

897
01:28:21.917 --> 01:28:26.170
<v Millicent Williams>So there are several different ways that this can and does work.

898
01:28:26.395 --> 01:28:34.240
<v Millicent Williams>There are, however, quite a few streets, and especially now, that we've not swept in any way, shape, or form in the past 3 years.

899
01:28:34.417 --> 01:28:43.466
<v Millicent Williams>So we're pleased that we're able to begin to reintroduce street sweeping in communities that have not had it, which is every community for the past 3 years.

900
01:28:43.579 --> 01:28:47.125
<v Millicent Williams>We are also pleased that we've been able to establish thank you.

901
01:28:47.189 --> 01:28:48.840
<v Millicent Williams>We've established 23 new leaf districts.

902
01:28:48.953 --> 01:29:19.609
<v Millicent Williams>I know that leaf districts is a portion of what you'd like to see us increase, but even in those areas where the street sweeping or the leaf districts are increased, we have to look at the different ways that we do that cleaning to ensure that it's actually effective and that we're not just moving things around, but actually cleaning, removing debris, taking that debris to the appropriate place for processing, for cleaning, and then for composting so that you can have it back on Earth Day next year.

903
01:29:21.737 --> 01:29:40.135
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, and I'll just note that this, this is not directing additional street sweeping in areas without— this is specifically exploring funding opportunities to support the existing planned expansion of Leaf Day programs and explicitly calling out including areas without curb sidewalks simply so that it is a future consideration.

904
01:29:40.878 --> 01:29:41.591
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thank you.

905
01:29:41.752 --> 01:29:50.488
<v Eric Zimmerman>That, that was my last piece because I'm wondering why this is different than the opposition we're hearing to Novick's, which are tell us about the funding mechanism to the thing.

906
01:29:50.552 --> 01:29:53.412
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's another thing I'm just continue to not understand here.

907
01:29:53.461 --> 01:29:55.069
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm going to move into listen mode.

908
01:29:59.515 --> 01:30:00.190
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

909
01:30:00.319 --> 01:30:00.850
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

910
01:30:02.198 --> 01:30:03.323
<v Mitch Green>I'll be brief.

911
01:30:03.613 --> 01:30:14.701
<v Mitch Green>Uh, this comment applies to all the amendments, uh, to follow 4, but, um, as a District 4 councilor, as a person rich in trees, I'm always going to show up for District 1 when you're asking for trees.

912
01:30:15.845 --> 01:30:21.023
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that the amendments are all sort of saying, let's prioritize District 1 here.

913
01:30:21.828 --> 01:30:21.876
<v Mitch Green>I—.

914
01:30:22.375 --> 01:30:24.532
<v Mitch Green>And I think it's not just about me sort of offering goodwill.

915
01:30:24.628 --> 01:30:37.989
<v Mitch Green>It's about the climate challenges that we are going to face in this city, whether I vote yes or no on this, or if this passes or not, are going to affect District 1 in the largest way, disproportionately.

916
01:30:38.056 --> 01:30:52.277
<v Mitch Green>And so everything we can do Yeah, actually, my question—.

917
01:30:52.277 --> 01:31:06.337
<v Steve Novick>The reason I was prepared to oppose Amendment 4 was that my staff told me the PBOT staff said that there's a liability issue here due to the fact that PBOT staff won't be able to see the frontage zone without sidewalks may intrude into people's yards.

918
01:31:06.337 --> 01:31:06.516
<v Brian Lando>So I'm going to vote no on Amendment 4.

919
01:31:06.628 --> 01:31:09.978
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to ask Director Williams, is that a valid concern?

920
01:31:10.219 --> 01:31:12.734
<v Millicent Williams>Could you repeat what you said we said?

921
01:31:12.958 --> 01:31:13.230
<v Steve Novick>Sure.

922
01:31:13.904 --> 01:31:30.667
<v Steve Novick>What my staff said, somebody in PBOT said, is, quote, there is a liability issue here due to the fact that PBOT staff won't be able to see the, quote, frontage zone without sidewalks and may intrude into people's yards, end quote.

923
01:31:33.153 --> 01:31:33.682
<v Millicent Williams>That's a thing.

924
01:31:34.920 --> 01:31:56.059
<v Millicent Williams>But we do have the opportunity to work with our survey teams to identify where property lines begin and end, to be able to most appropriately speak to how we are, if in fact directed to and funded to do this work, able to make sure that we're not encroaching upon people's personal property.

925
01:31:56.122 --> 01:31:57.135
<v Millicent Williams>We do that with every project.

926
01:31:57.182 --> 01:31:57.391
<v Millicent Williams>Mm-hmm.

927
01:31:57.649 --> 01:32:03.284
<v Millicent Williams>So there is a liability if we were to just willy-nilly go out and do something like that.

928
01:32:04.091 --> 01:32:06.377
<v Millicent Williams>But that is not a standard practice that we would have.

929
01:32:07.356 --> 01:32:09.301
<v Steve Novick>So as far as you're concerned, Amendment 4 doesn't freak you out?

930
01:32:10.974 --> 01:32:14.782
<v Millicent Williams>If I could be reminded of what Amendment 4 says again, I'm sorry.

931
01:32:15.007 --> 01:32:21.490
<v Steve Novick>Basically expands leaf day to— has an intent to expand leaf day to areas without curbed sidewalks.

932
01:32:21.719 --> 01:32:22.828
<v Millicent Williams>I'm not concerned about that.

933
01:32:23.186 --> 01:32:23.414
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

934
01:32:25.619 --> 01:32:32.139
<v Millicent Williams>I doubt that folks would be mad if we picked up leaves in their yards unintentionally.

935
01:32:33.101 --> 01:32:33.904
<v Loretta Smith>I wish they would.

936
01:32:34.145 --> 01:32:35.029
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

937
01:32:35.109 --> 01:32:35.975
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Director.

938
01:32:36.216 --> 01:32:36.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

939
01:32:38.319 --> 01:32:39.942
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

940
01:32:40.070 --> 01:32:44.212
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll also keep my comments brief and say I intend to support all of these amendments.

941
01:32:45.288 --> 01:32:50.411
<v Sameer Kanal>I will note that District 2 is actually the district that has the lowest level of canopy in the city.

942
01:32:50.667 --> 01:32:56.222
<v Sameer Kanal>And but what I think that your amendments do, Councilor Dunphy, is offer a framework.

943
01:32:56.543 --> 01:32:59.546
<v Sameer Kanal>There's no harm to District 2 when you say at least one in District 1.

944
01:32:59.595 --> 01:33:09.100
<v Sameer Kanal>I think encouraging district-by-district thinking, not necessarily in the allocation of resources, but in terms of how we collect and display data is really helpful.

945
01:33:10.337 --> 01:33:13.581
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll be happy to support 1 through 4.

946
01:33:14.752 --> 01:33:14.929
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

947
01:33:15.154 --> 01:33:16.278
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

948
01:33:16.358 --> 01:33:17.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

949
01:33:19.024 --> 01:33:19.925
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

950
01:33:20.069 --> 01:33:28.600
<v Olivia Clark>I, I'm really struggling with all of these amendments, and I thought Councilor Zimmerman's question was good.

951
01:33:28.666 --> 01:33:31.798
<v Olivia Clark>Why, why weren't these included in the report earlier?

952
01:33:32.265 --> 01:33:43.416
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm just guessing that this report was really meant to be a policy framework, a very high-level vision without a lot of these kinds of specifics.

953
01:33:43.949 --> 01:33:46.559
<v Olivia Clark>I'm just musing about that.

954
01:33:46.671 --> 01:33:50.220
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm also very concerned about the funding.

955
01:33:51.832 --> 01:34:00.011
<v Olivia Clark>I feel like we're potentially committing ourselves or obligating ourselves to a lot of unfunded possibilities.

956
01:34:00.268 --> 01:34:05.162
<v Olivia Clark>And that really bothers me, particularly because we're coming up on an election on Parks Bureau.

957
01:34:05.661 --> 01:34:09.993
<v Olivia Clark>We're looking at reduced property tax revenues.

958
01:34:10.186 --> 01:34:11.150
<v Olivia Clark>I'm very concerned.

959
01:34:11.201 --> 01:34:21.226
<v Olivia Clark>So I I'm really hoping that we can postpone this, this conversation to take a little more time to really wrestle with all these amendments.

960
01:34:22.012 --> 01:34:33.310
<v Olivia Clark>And I also, I don't understand the conflict over asking for cost information in one amendment and, and supporting it in one amendment and not in another amendment.

961
01:34:34.081 --> 01:34:44.530
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm just, I guess I'm just expressing my frustration with this whole process and Particularly with potentially obligating ourselves to fund things that we don't have the money for.

962
01:34:45.622 --> 01:34:50.087
<v Olivia Clark>But I think it's— I appreciate the work that's gone into this, the outreach that's happened.

963
01:34:50.826 --> 01:34:52.126
<v Olivia Clark>I understand it's a guide.

964
01:34:52.287 --> 01:34:52.944
<v Olivia Clark>I love trees.

965
01:34:53.024 --> 01:35:00.972
<v Olivia Clark>I'm practically a pagan, you know, but we also have a financial responsibility here that is really weighing heavy on me.

966
01:35:02.064 --> 01:35:03.992
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Eric Zimmerman.

967
01:35:04.136 --> 01:35:05.123
<v Eric Zimmerman>You heard it here first.

968
01:35:05.301 --> 01:35:05.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor.

969
01:35:07.569 --> 01:35:14.252
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, seeing no other debate, um, I believe we are looking at Amendment 4 first.

970
01:35:14.332 --> 01:35:16.524
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll on Amendment 4?

971
01:35:17.356 --> 01:35:18.627
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is Dunphy Amendment 4.

972
01:35:19.561 --> 01:35:19.965
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

973
01:35:20.833 --> 01:35:20.994
<v Olivia Clark>No.

974
01:35:21.976 --> 01:35:22.266
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

975
01:35:22.621 --> 01:35:22.958
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

976
01:35:23.796 --> 01:35:24.055
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

977
01:35:27.234 --> 01:35:27.429
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

978
01:35:28.547 --> 01:35:29.229
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

979
01:35:29.569 --> 01:35:29.586
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

980
01:35:33.030 --> 01:35:33.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

981
01:35:33.997 --> 01:35:34.015
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

982
01:35:34.643 --> 01:35:34.724
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

983
01:35:35.287 --> 01:35:35.595
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

984
01:35:36.578 --> 01:35:36.738
<v Dan Ryan>No.

985
01:35:39.395 --> 01:35:39.444
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

986
01:35:40.922 --> 01:35:40.970
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

987
01:35:41.742 --> 01:35:41.757
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

988
01:35:42.448 --> 01:35:42.480
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

989
01:35:43.573 --> 01:35:48.953
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 10 yes votes and 2 no votes.

990
01:35:50.537 --> 01:35:51.132
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

991
01:35:51.213 --> 01:35:55.182
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any additional debate on Dunphy 1 through 3?

992
01:35:58.658 --> 01:35:59.574
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

993
01:36:02.274 --> 01:36:02.532
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

994
01:36:04.186 --> 01:36:17.922
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I think before getting to the separation of these, I guess I would look for a— um, well, put it this way.

995
01:36:18.069 --> 01:36:18.085
<v Eric Zimmerman>I—.

996
01:36:18.569 --> 01:36:26.789
<v Eric Zimmerman>The City of Portland has in many documents and many plans over the years, we've included a prioritization or a focus on low income, right?

997
01:36:26.838 --> 01:36:28.144
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's kind of a norm for us.

998
01:36:29.238 --> 01:36:45.565
<v Eric Zimmerman>To see that it was taking an amendment to bring that language back in leaves me to think there was a reason or a purpose that this workgroup chose the language they chose in the original document and not what's being proposed.

999
01:36:45.648 --> 01:36:47.520
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm looking for a take on that.

1000
01:36:47.911 --> 01:36:55.893
<v Eric Zimmerman>Then I'm looking for a staff Summary or staff report on what Amendment 1 in particular would do.

1001
01:36:57.854 --> 01:37:02.965
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am not particularly sure I care about number 2 saying District 1 gets a pilot.

1002
01:37:03.221 --> 01:37:03.511
<v Eric Zimmerman>Cool.

1003
01:37:04.170 --> 01:37:16.442
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, but for 3 and for 1, they, they have added language that you all chose to keep out, and I'm hoping you can weigh in on that and then talk about its impact down the road if and as this was adopted.

1004
01:37:17.856 --> 01:37:19.640
<v Brian Lando>Yeah, thank you, Councilor Zimmerman, for the question.

1005
01:37:22.332 --> 01:37:25.542
<v Brian Lando>Urban Forestry has established priority service neighborhoods.

1006
01:37:25.735 --> 01:37:28.235
<v Brian Lando>Those are based on income and canopy coverage.

1007
01:37:29.896 --> 01:37:34.961
<v Brian Lando>The language in the plan says that everything we do in this plan is prioritizing those areas.

1008
01:37:35.636 --> 01:37:44.662
<v Brian Lando>And so we actually made maybe more of a layout choice to not add that prioritization in every Every action item, because we have 50-plus action items.

1009
01:37:45.449 --> 01:37:58.777
<v Brian Lando>At the start of the action section and throughout the plan, we highlight that these are the inequities the plan is intended to address and to bring areas, particularly in District 1 and District 2, up to the canopy levels that we see elsewhere in the city.

1010
01:37:59.259 --> 01:38:01.297
<v Brian Lando>So we had that woven throughout the plan.

1011
01:38:01.908 --> 01:38:07.014
<v Brian Lando>They were not in every specific action item, simply because we felt like we'd be repeating the same language every time.

1012
01:38:08.105 --> 01:38:24.150
<v Brian Lando>So with that in mind, the impact of these amendments, I think the language in here, particularly 1 and 3, is precisely in line with how we intend to roll these programs out, to prioritize those areas, and is absolutely in line with all the community engagement and guidance that we receive through this plan.

1013
01:38:24.216 --> 01:38:26.104
<v Brian Lando>And that is embedded within it.

1014
01:38:28.015 --> 01:38:35.163
<v Eric Zimmerman>So given that, I appreciate that, like just the overarching, and you decided to go, that makes a lot of sense to me.

1015
01:38:36.819 --> 01:39:17.346
<v Eric Zimmerman>By adding it into the specific action language in this document, would it prevent or skew projects in light of trying to meet these words in the action item for a project that is ready to go, it's easily attainable in an area that didn't qualify as one of these, but otherwise otherwise would've met all the metrics of this plan, but now that we've put this language in there, does it put some things on the back burner that actually are quite achievable in the short term, even when others are not ready to go yet?

1016
01:39:18.052 --> 01:39:19.255
<v Brian Lando>Yeah, I appreciate that.

1017
01:39:19.414 --> 01:39:24.400
<v Brian Lando>Having that flexibility is helpful as we're trying to roll out major initiatives like street tree maintenance.

1018
01:39:24.720 --> 01:39:34.789
<v Brian Lando>I think what we appreciate in the language is that it specifies prioritizing those areas, which we do intend to do, but not precluding delivering that service yes.

1019
01:39:34.837 --> 01:39:48.597
<v Brian Lando>And some examples we have are safe routes to school, transportation routes, freight routes will span neighborhoods, but low-income priority communities will use those streets that will go across different neighborhoods.

1020
01:39:49.127 --> 01:40:02.134
<v Brian Lando>And so we wouldn't want to limit the ability of a service like street tree maintenance to address safety issues, canopy issues that are not just limited within a priority neighborhood, knowing that people travel in work and play across different neighborhoods too.

1021
01:40:02.779 --> 01:40:03.087
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1022
01:40:03.587 --> 01:40:12.244
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then can you just spend a little bit of time helping me better understand what a permanent Trees in the Curb Zone program really is trying to achieve?

1023
01:40:12.310 --> 01:40:13.069
<v Eric Zimmerman>What's that all about?

1024
01:40:13.657 --> 01:40:25.962
<v Brian Lando>Yeah, so Trees in the Curb Zone is a PBOT-led project that provides a design solution for configurations of the right-of-way where we yes.

1025
01:40:26.427 --> 01:40:29.671
<v Brian Lando>And so there's a pilot project that is underway right now.

1026
01:40:30.360 --> 01:40:39.658
<v Brian Lando>I think the idea is that this is something that we are seeing really positive responses to and a lot of successes with the pilot, and we want to, we want to keep it, keep it going.

1027
01:40:40.027 --> 01:40:59.293
<v Brian Lando>So the idea with a permanent program is that it may be identifying a permanent funding source or might just be proactively looking for funding, whatever we can, through different opportunities to continue installing these street tree facilities because it addresses areas where we cannot plant trees right now.

1028
01:41:00.184 --> 01:41:00.524
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1029
01:41:12.591 --> 01:41:15.501
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, I think that has been helpful.

1030
01:41:16.266 --> 01:41:19.073
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman, if I can just very briefly add.

1031
01:41:19.523 --> 01:41:19.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1032
01:41:19.747 --> 01:41:28.219
<v Jamie Dunphy>I fully recognize and acknowledge that the plan overarching goals do acknowledge prioritizing low-income and low-density canopy areas.

1033
01:41:28.716 --> 01:41:36.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>My intention is to be annoying and explicit about District 1 and areas where I think we should say it in every sentence that we can.

1034
01:41:37.636 --> 01:41:51.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>I do appreciate that that is a style choice, but I did want to be also intentionally flexible, recognizing that we don't want to put all of our effort into areas of of the city where there are no trees because there are also areas that desperately need extra attention and they have well-established trees.

1035
01:41:51.606 --> 01:41:58.823
<v Jamie Dunphy>So this was about signaling that intention, that overarching intention on the microscopic level without being too prescriptive.

1036
01:41:59.849 --> 01:42:00.650
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Councilor.

1037
01:42:00.876 --> 01:42:08.074
<v Eric Zimmerman>In number 3, you added the language phased to prioritize low-income and low-canopy areas.

1038
01:42:09.069 --> 01:42:20.203
<v Eric Zimmerman>From a bureau perspective, if we add the words phased, Again, going now into number 3, and this is, this is with respect to tree maintenance.

1039
01:42:20.301 --> 01:42:20.965
<v Eric Zimmerman>Maintenance.

1040
01:42:23.181 --> 01:42:46.060
<v Eric Zimmerman>If there are— I guess I'm feeling not informed enough to be able to understand if you were going to roll out a street maintenance program without that language in versus if you're going to roll it out now that we say it has to be phased, what differences can we expect I think—.

1041
01:42:46.060 --> 01:42:51.247
<v Brian Lando>I don't think it significantly changes, again, the work plan we developed and where we see that program going.

1042
01:42:52.644 --> 01:43:04.863
<v Brian Lando>We would— this is a major undertaking to maintain 250,000 street trees, so it was going to be phased already because of the need to bring on contractors, all the capacity building that's going to happen over a 5-year period.

1043
01:43:04.911 --> 01:43:05.666
<v Brian Lando>So what's the impact?

1044
01:43:06.931 --> 01:43:19.082
<v Brian Lando>And then in terms of, again, that prioritization, that is what we intend to do, to reach the areas of the city that have not been well served in this capacity in the past and bringing that service to them first.

1045
01:43:19.261 --> 01:43:21.814
<v Brian Lando>So I don't think it significantly changes where we saw this going.

1046
01:43:24.557 --> 01:43:36.444
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so in this situation, so as this rolls forward, fund and implement, et cetera, et cetera, it is gonna be great to see see contracted or city crews come out to a neighborhood and maintain the street trees.

1047
01:43:36.507 --> 01:43:38.929
<v Eric Zimmerman>Like, that is such a win for, I think, the city.

1048
01:43:40.082 --> 01:43:49.186
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would take that to mean still that me, especially because I'm one of those people whose tree covers like the whole neighborhood with its own leaves, so I'll be raking concrete here quite soon.

1049
01:43:50.341 --> 01:43:58.690
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if a limb falls, regardless of whether or not your team's got out there, a limb falls and lands on my neighbor's car, I'm taking it as I'm still on the hook to that.

1050
01:43:58.755 --> 01:44:16.949
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it kind of gets a little bit to some of the liability questions we had earlier, but I take it as it's nice that the city will maintain my tree, but I still have ultimate responsibility either to call ahead of damage happening or take it upon myself to take responsibility for the property that I have that can affect others.

1051
01:44:17.046 --> 01:44:20.644
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that a correct way to read these plans?

1052
01:44:20.980 --> 01:44:22.458
<v Brian Lando>I think that's probably correct.

1053
01:44:22.587 --> 01:44:31.002
<v Brian Lando>Our plan really focuses on the service that So urban forestry can deliver and where our area of expertise and focus is.

1054
01:44:32.319 --> 01:44:42.722
<v Brian Lando>We envisioned that as part of that, we would be working with the City Attorney's Office, working with City Risk at what is— how does the liability question play into this?

1055
01:44:42.787 --> 01:44:51.634
<v Brian Lando>Because there are different models around the country where sometimes the adjacent property owner retains the liability, but the city has committed to a level of service.

1056
01:44:52.228 --> 01:44:56.122
<v Brian Lando>There's a there's also ones where the liability does shift to the actual city.

1057
01:44:56.618 --> 01:45:06.585
<v Brian Lando>So I think there are options that we intend to explore as part of this, but the plan is more focused on reducing the cost burden, which really relies on Urban Forestry building that program.

1058
01:45:07.865 --> 01:45:08.314
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1059
01:45:08.411 --> 01:45:18.698
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I appreciate the language you're using because it is about planning for this service coming to our community versus we vote today and tomorrow everybody stops maintaining their trees.

1060
01:45:18.746 --> 01:45:20.252
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's not what's happening tonight, right?

1061
01:45:20.894 --> 01:45:25.614
<v Eric Zimmerman>So appreciate that and your thoroughness in asking my— or answering my questions.

1062
01:45:25.663 --> 01:45:26.051
<v Loretta Smith>Thanks, Brian.

1063
01:45:29.301 --> 01:45:32.202
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we are past our 20-minute time.

1064
01:45:33.262 --> 01:45:37.796
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing no one else in the queue for debate, Councilor Novick, I believe that was an old hand.

1065
01:45:37.860 --> 01:45:38.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1066
01:45:39.743 --> 01:45:45.644
<v Steve Novick>I was going to clarify something, but I can wait.

1067
01:45:45.805 --> 01:45:46.192
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1068
01:45:47.060 --> 01:45:54.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would ask if folks are okay if there is no more debate here, moving to a vote despite being past time on these 3 amendments.

1069
01:45:54.591 --> 01:45:56.293
<v Steve Novick>Oh, sorry, Madam President.

1070
01:45:56.438 --> 01:45:58.814
<v Steve Novick>Actually, if we're going to move— I thought you were just going to shut us down.

1071
01:45:58.926 --> 01:46:01.351
<v Steve Novick>If we're going to move to a vote, I do have a couple of things to say.

1072
01:46:01.448 --> 01:46:06.136
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, then we will postpone without the vote on these.

1073
01:46:06.876 --> 01:46:08.432
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to just make sure we're clear.

1074
01:46:09.210 --> 01:46:15.037
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are postponing in the middle of debate on Dunphy's 1 through 3 amendments.

1075
01:46:15.936 --> 01:46:27.448
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will pick back up on debate on amendments 1 through 3 and then debate presumably on the underlying or any further amendments that are proposed after that.

1076
01:46:27.994 --> 01:46:32.399
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This will come back at either the meeting on the 22nd or the 29th.

1077
01:46:32.512 --> 01:46:38.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I need to check agendas to see where we have the most room, so I apologize that I can't tell you which date yet.

1078
01:46:38.564 --> 01:46:51.047
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Unfortunately, because we have a work session scheduled for tomorrow, we're not able to bring this back tomorrow, but it will come back later this month and we will continue debate and move to an ultimate vote on the resolution.

1079
01:46:53.045 --> 01:47:00.914
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, Keelan, we are, I believe, opening the next 2 agenda items together.

1080
01:47:00.994 --> 01:47:03.359
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm sorry, thank you so much, all of you, for being here.

1081
01:47:04.313 --> 01:47:05.541
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will pick this back up.

1082
01:47:07.193 --> 01:47:10.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I believe we are opening the next 2 agenda items together.

1083
01:47:11.654 --> 01:47:20.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As I noted in an email to you all earlier this week, because we have a significant amount of overlapping testimony, we will open these 2 items together.

1084
01:47:21.480 --> 01:47:35.217
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Give the carriers time for an introduction on each of them separately, daylight any pre-filed amendments, and then move to public testimony on both items.

1085
01:47:35.573 --> 01:47:40.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll then separate back out for debate and votes on each item separately.

1086
01:47:40.591 --> 01:47:44.912
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please open agenda items 6 and 7?

1087
01:47:46.390 --> 01:48:00.284
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Item 6, denounce any attempts to deploy the United States Armed Forces, the National Guard, militarized federal immigration enforcement in Portland and establish the Protect Portland Initiative.

1088
01:48:00.945 --> 01:48:06.106
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Item 7, add code to enact sanctuary city status protections.

1089
01:48:08.702 --> 01:48:09.479
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

1090
01:48:10.060 --> 01:48:23.117
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And for folks who are here with us today watching in the room or online, I will note that because both of these items were referred directly to council and we did not have a prior work session on them, that's unusual.

1091
01:48:24.342 --> 01:48:27.315
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Usually things either run through committee or have a prior work session.

1092
01:48:27.992 --> 01:48:31.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't have a committee staff summary or chair report.

1093
01:48:31.592 --> 01:48:40.329
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're just moving directly into presentations, something we don't usually do in full council, but we're doing things a little bit differently tonight on these 2 items.

1094
01:48:41.853 --> 01:48:44.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I wanna thank everybody for being here today for this.

1095
01:48:44.345 --> 01:48:53.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know this is the main show that many people have been waiting for, and I just wanna take a moment to appreciate all the collaboration that went into bringing these items forward today.

1096
01:48:53.864 --> 01:48:56.436
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have said many times Thank you.

1097
01:48:56.518 --> 01:48:57.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just want to echo what the mayor said.

1098
01:48:57.375 --> 01:49:04.787
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we've seen over the last 2 weeks that there are a number of different councilors who are working on different ways that we can approach this moment.

1099
01:49:05.443 --> 01:49:23.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a federal administration who is working in our city in ways that are against the values that many Portlanders hold, and today is just one step in what I'm sure will be an iterative process as everybody up here looks to different ways to respond to that.

1100
01:49:25.061 --> 01:49:34.149
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to thank everybody at the dais who has put in work here and also everybody who is here to have conversation with us about how we move forward.

1101
01:49:34.407 --> 01:49:45.550
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also want to acknowledge that for many members of our community, there is a lot of fear right now and a lot of fear wrapped up in the conversations we're going to have tonight.

1102
01:49:45.711 --> 01:49:53.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And there are people who are not with us tonight and are not testifying because they did not feel comfortable coming to a big public event.

1103
01:49:54.012 --> 01:50:02.296
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it's important to acknowledge that and acknowledge those folks who are living daily with the consequences of the actions of our federal administration.

1104
01:50:04.448 --> 01:50:14.219
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So with that, we are going to move first into a presentation on the resolution before us.

1105
01:50:14.478 --> 01:50:17.414
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Then we'll have a presentation on the ordinance.

1106
01:50:18.123 --> 01:50:18.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll then move into a—.

1107
01:50:18.998 --> 01:50:19.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Public comment.

1108
01:50:20.524 --> 01:50:28.984
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Panel of testifiers who are here to speak to both of these items, and then into public testimony.

1109
01:50:30.122 --> 01:50:36.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The resolution before us has been co-sponsored by 4 councilors, including myself.

1110
01:50:36.291 --> 01:50:43.582
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will open us up, then we'll turn to Councilor Avalos, Council Vice President, and Councilor Clark.

1111
01:50:44.061 --> 01:51:01.993
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As leaders, I believe it is incumbent upon us to use every single tool we have to stand up for our community as we face a federal administration that is frankly hell-bent on singling out Portland in their attempts to move an ideology in our country that does not move us forward.

1112
01:51:03.021 --> 01:51:13.671
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This joint resolution is one of the ways that we are standing up to these attacks and standing up for the incredible progress that our city has made over the past few years.

1113
01:51:14.891 --> 01:51:22.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Like every city, Portland has our challenges, and we on the dais show up every day to do our part in addressing them.

1114
01:51:24.130 --> 01:51:29.735
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But the reality is that Portland has seen decreases in crime in our city.

1115
01:51:30.570 --> 01:51:46.802
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have seen increases in Portlanders and visitors who are out enjoying our city, and Portlanders from every neighborhood and across the ideological spectrum have united to voice their opposition to federal intervention in our city.

1116
01:51:49.073 --> 01:51:56.162
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This council has also been united on many of the actions that we have taken as a city, and we might not always agree.

1117
01:51:57.521 --> 01:52:03.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But as we face down federal actions, in many cases we are on the same page.

1118
01:52:04.896 --> 01:52:08.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to express my gratitude as we move forward this evening to Councilor Avalos.

1119
01:52:09.345 --> 01:52:09.586
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1120
01:52:09.779 --> 01:52:12.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Sameer Kanal, thank you for initiating the resolution before us.

1121
01:52:13.506 --> 01:52:26.890
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Your work with Council Vice President, myself, Councilor Clark, and with so many stakeholders has been instrumental in giving us a framework for the conversation that we know we will be having over the coming weeks and months.

1122
01:52:28.520 --> 01:52:47.509
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to acknowledge that as we put together this resolution and had conversations with the mayor and his administration about some of these pieces and the feasibility of moving them forward, And Mr. Mayor, it has been fantastic to collaborate with you on these efforts.

1123
01:52:48.152 --> 01:52:55.976
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate the places where you have already begun the work and look forward to being able to help move that forward as we pass this resolution tonight.

1124
01:52:56.220 --> 01:52:56.755
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect timing.

1125
01:52:58.952 --> 01:53:15.400
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I want to thank the many community members who have worked with us as we move this forward, our city employees, partner groups who are here today, and others in the community who have provided feedback on how we can address How best to address some of the challenges our city is facing.

1126
01:53:16.860 --> 01:53:24.414
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The ACLU, stakeholders from labor, business, and faith communities and beyond have helped to improve this work.

1127
01:53:25.440 --> 01:53:31.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I also want to thank the many people within the city who have helped us to make this the strongest resolution possible today.

1128
01:53:32.353 --> 01:53:47.698
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our city attorneys, Police Chief Bob Day, DCA Bob Kazi, and others who sat down to make sure that the work we were putting forward is as strong as it can be, is implementable, will lead to programs that actually accomplish what we're looking for.

1129
01:53:49.012 --> 01:53:54.270
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am proud of every single Portlander who is showing up and pushing back on the Trump administration.

1130
01:53:55.423 --> 01:54:02.894
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At the city, there is much work to do, but I am grateful that today we get to take some steps forward.

1131
01:54:03.134 --> 01:54:08.279
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to turn it over to Councilor Avalos for a brief presentation on what this resolution will accomplish.

1132
01:54:08.328 --> 01:54:08.551
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Mayor.

1133
01:54:09.787 --> 01:54:14.154
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you very much, Council President, for that amazing introduction.

1134
01:54:14.829 --> 01:54:18.250
<v Candace Avalos>Um, Council Clerk, if you could get the PowerPoint up for me.

1135
01:54:35.565 --> 01:54:36.274
<v Candace Avalos>All right, here we go.

1136
01:54:37.256 --> 01:54:40.667
<v Candace Avalos>So, uh, I'm going to take a couple of minutes to walk through the resolution.

1137
01:54:41.118 --> 01:54:41.488
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1138
01:54:43.613 --> 01:54:54.489
<v Candace Avalos>So this diagram shows the full framework of the Protect Portland Initiative, the coordinated framework structure our city will use to respond to threats of federal overreach and militarization.

1139
01:54:55.069 --> 01:55:03.841
<v Candace Avalos>These components form a comprehensive, values-driven framework that keeps Portlanders safe, informed, and protected from escalating threats from the Trump administration.

1140
01:55:04.050 --> 01:55:04.484
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1141
01:55:08.284 --> 01:55:15.242
<v Candace Avalos>This first section formally calls on the mayor to establish and implement the Protect Portland Initiative as the city's coordinated framework.

1142
01:55:15.728 --> 01:55:25.081
<v Candace Avalos>It ensures that our entire organization, from City Hall to our community partners, is aligned and ready to respond to any threats of federal overreach or unconstitutional force.

1143
01:55:25.762 --> 01:55:26.136
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1144
01:55:28.932 --> 01:55:29.557
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second.

1145
01:55:30.199 --> 01:55:45.565
<v Candace Avalos>This section directs the mayor to protect Portlanders' constitutional rights, our rights to privacy, free speech, assembly, and protest, and to take an active stand against any attempt to deploy the U.S. Armed Forces, National Guard, or militarized immigration enforcement in Portland.

1146
01:55:46.222 --> 01:55:56.231
<v Candace Avalos>The city must pursue all legal avenues to stop unconstitutional actions, and city bureaus, including the Portland Police Bureau, are prohibited from assisting in the suppression of peaceful protests.

1147
01:56:01.854 --> 01:56:03.439
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1148
01:56:09.621 --> 01:56:18.069
<v Candace Avalos>To put this framework into action, the resolution directs the city to coordinate across all levels— city bureaus, the county, the state, and community partners.

1149
01:56:18.765 --> 01:56:26.212
<v Candace Avalos>It creates immigrant affairs liaisons in each service area, launches a public-facing Protect Portland information hub, and mandates quarterly reports to council.

1150
01:56:27.877 --> 01:56:34.264
<v Candace Avalos>It also strengthens rapid response networks with community partners and secures city facilities from unauthorized federal access.

1151
01:56:34.682 --> 01:56:35.003
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1152
01:56:38.250 --> 01:56:46.020
<v Candace Avalos>We are also asking our Office of Government Relations to advocate for stronger federal laws that protect civil rights and limit federal militarization.

1153
01:56:46.390 --> 01:56:48.440
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1154
01:56:50.636 --> 01:56:57.261
<v Candace Avalos>This section ensures that Portland Police remain accountable to Portlanders, not to the Trump administration, and focused on local public safety.

1155
01:56:58.537 --> 01:57:08.126
<v Candace Avalos>It prohibits deputization of our officers, bans joint immigration operations, and directs PPB to create a clear protocol for any interaction with federal agents.

1156
01:57:08.694 --> 01:57:11.743
<v Candace Avalos>Those encounters must be logged, verified, and reported.

1157
01:57:12.489 --> 01:57:15.230
<v Candace Avalos>Officers will be trained to follow these protections rigorously.

1158
01:57:16.458 --> 01:57:19.222
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1159
01:57:20.412 --> 01:57:27.918
<v Candace Avalos>This section ensures that every city bureau must document and report any known federal enforcement activity involving city property, staff, or operations.

1160
01:57:28.735 --> 01:57:34.427
<v Candace Avalos>The Office of Equity will monitor impacts on vulnerable communities, while Civic Life will coordinate community support.

1161
01:57:35.229 --> 01:57:43.617
<v Candace Avalos>The city administrator will also set strong employee protections, prevent warrantless federal access to city spaces, and reinforce data privacy standards.

1162
01:57:43.953 --> 01:57:44.257
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1163
01:57:45.509 --> 01:57:46.422
<v Candace Avalos>That's all.

1164
01:57:47.738 --> 01:57:52.275
<v Candace Avalos>This resolution reaffirms that Portland is and will remain a sanctuary city.

1165
01:57:53.014 --> 01:57:59.652
<v Candace Avalos>No city resources will be used for immigration enforcement, and any exceptions required by law must be documented and reported.

1166
01:58:00.331 --> 01:58:04.582
<v Candace Avalos>This ensures we continue living our values of inclusion, equity, and local democracy.

1167
01:58:05.002 --> 01:58:05.375
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1168
01:58:08.640 --> 01:58:10.577
<v Candace Avalos>Our values extend to those who work with the city.

1169
01:58:11.180 --> 01:58:20.270
<v Candace Avalos>Contractors will be required to comply with sanctuary city policies, complete training on residents' rights, and refrain from sharing personal data with federal agencies.

1170
01:58:20.912 --> 01:58:25.627
<v Candace Avalos>They will also receive multilingual know-your-rights materials, and compliance will be closely monitored.

1171
01:58:26.149 --> 01:58:26.634
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1172
01:58:30.014 --> 01:58:37.990
<v Candace Avalos>Lastly, the council also commits to working with the mayor and the city attorney to identify any future ordinances or code changes needed to safeguard Portlanders.

1173
01:58:38.667 --> 01:58:45.697
<v Candace Avalos>We have reaffirmed that any deployment of military personnel, including the National Guard, without local consent is unacceptable.

1174
01:58:46.412 --> 01:58:50.353
<v Candace Avalos>Portland will always stand for transparency, accountability, and local control.

1175
01:58:52.226 --> 01:58:52.951
<v Candace Avalos>Next slide.

1176
01:58:53.030 --> 01:58:55.203
<v Candace Avalos>And with that, I will pass it back to you, Council President.

1177
01:58:55.912 --> 01:58:57.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1178
01:58:57.440 --> 01:58:58.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council Vice President.

1179
01:59:00.082 --> 01:59:01.181
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

1180
01:59:02.819 --> 01:59:09.550
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know that we are in terrifying times, and now is the time to speak up.

1181
01:59:10.935 --> 01:59:13.559
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Now is the time to stand firm in our values.

1182
01:59:14.315 --> 01:59:20.353
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Now is the time for us to model being brave rather than staying silent and hoping things will be okay.

1183
01:59:22.011 --> 01:59:27.854
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>In World War II, many Portlanders thought being silent and complying was the best way forward as their neighbors were being disappeared.

1184
01:59:28.448 --> 01:59:40.805
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I truly wish that more community leaders and everyday constituents had stood up and spoken out when the federal government forced my own grandparents and many other Japanese Americans into US concentration camps.

1185
01:59:41.752 --> 01:59:45.604
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This evening, this council has the opportunity to stand up and speak out.

1186
01:59:46.085 --> 01:59:49.841
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm proud to be part of the work to defend our neighbors and our democracy.

1187
01:59:50.498 --> 01:59:55.817
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you to all of our community partners for everything you do, have done, and continue to do.

1188
01:59:55.962 --> 02:00:00.753
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's an honor to be in relationship with you all as we fight together for democracy.

1189
02:00:04.204 --> 02:00:07.405
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

1190
02:00:08.471 --> 02:00:09.992
<v Olivia Clark>I want to make a personal statement.

1191
02:00:10.515 --> 02:00:18.939
<v Olivia Clark>I'm very proud to co-sponsor the Portland Protect Portland initiative in response to the Trump administration and federal Overreach.

1192
02:00:19.854 --> 02:00:25.779
<v Olivia Clark>The federal government is wasting tax dollars, violating the Constitution, and disrupting our lives.

1193
02:00:26.774 --> 02:00:35.011
<v Olivia Clark>I believe that as an American, as an Oregonian, as a Portlander and a city councilor, but also as a resident of a neighborhood, I believe this.

1194
02:00:35.829 --> 02:00:45.547
<v Olivia Clark>I live a 10-minute walk away from the ICE facility, and I hear the actions, I hear the noise, I hear the helicopters.

1195
02:00:45.988 --> 02:00:47.324
<v Olivia Clark>It's simply unacceptable.

1196
02:00:48.916 --> 02:01:00.466
<v Olivia Clark>It's reminiscent of what happened in Kent State when helicopters were constantly circling the university, intimidating the college students, creating anxiety.

1197
02:01:01.692 --> 02:01:04.871
<v Olivia Clark>It's disruptive, creating fear and anxiety.

1198
02:01:04.935 --> 02:01:11.224
<v Olivia Clark>Now, I want to say that growing up, I learned the value of hard work in my family.

1199
02:01:11.288 --> 02:01:11.421
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1200
02:01:11.730 --> 02:01:14.975
<v Olivia Clark>Small diner where my mother worked as a waitress.

1201
02:01:15.070 --> 02:01:22.922
<v Olivia Clark>My brother and I waited tables, washed pots, and let me tell you that my family business could not have survived without immigrants.

1202
02:01:23.981 --> 02:01:26.295
<v Olivia Clark>They are our neighbors, our teachers, our doctors.

1203
02:01:26.953 --> 02:01:34.564
<v Olivia Clark>They help build the affordable housing that we need, help pick and prepare the food we eat, and make the beds we sleep in.

1204
02:01:35.542 --> 02:01:36.297
<v Olivia Clark>They deserve justice.

1205
02:01:36.362 --> 02:01:36.538
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1206
02:01:37.229 --> 02:01:38.497
<v Olivia Clark>And they deserve dignity.

1207
02:01:39.877 --> 02:01:46.430
<v Olivia Clark>The Trump administration's actions have become untenable, and they are calling into question the very nature of the rule of law.

1208
02:01:47.907 --> 02:01:50.363
<v Olivia Clark>And this is where the Protect Portland initiative comes in.

1209
02:01:50.877 --> 02:01:58.247
<v Olivia Clark>Your city councilors, councilors are listening, and we're taking action where we can, can to safeguard Portlanders from harm.

1210
02:01:59.323 --> 02:02:01.682
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1211
02:02:03.356 --> 02:02:04.524
<v Olivia Clark>We don't want this.

1212
02:02:05.644 --> 02:02:07.119
<v Olivia Clark>We don't want this in our neighborhood.

1213
02:02:07.185 --> 02:02:10.007
<v Olivia Clark>We don't want our neighborhoods overrun by chaos and confusion.

1214
02:02:10.903 --> 02:02:15.101
<v Olivia Clark>We don't want Portlanders feeling scared, anxious, or intimidated.

1215
02:02:16.087 --> 02:02:18.332
<v Olivia Clark>So in short, these are not our values.

1216
02:02:19.502 --> 02:02:22.413
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, I ask for your vote for this resolution.

1217
02:02:23.497 --> 02:02:23.951
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1218
02:02:26.393 --> 02:02:27.283
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1219
02:02:28.430 --> 02:02:32.552
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That that concludes the introduction to the resolution.

1220
02:02:32.747 --> 02:02:35.320
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, would you like to give an introduction to the ordinance?

1221
02:02:37.826 --> 02:02:39.033
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, thank you, Madam President.

1222
02:02:40.000 --> 02:02:41.545
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to everyone for being here tonight.

1223
02:02:41.609 --> 02:02:43.751
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just going to give a second for the slides.

1224
02:02:52.677 --> 02:02:57.713
<v Sameer Kanal>In 2017, the City of Portland adopted a resolution that enacted sanctuary city status.

1225
02:02:58.146 --> 02:03:04.930
<v Sameer Kanal>This resolution followed actions by the state beginning in 1987, as well as Multnomah County's Sanctuary County Resolution from 2016.

1226
02:03:05.524 --> 02:03:10.863
<v Sameer Kanal>The resolution that we have as a city is comprehensive, but as our attorneys have told us, it's not legally binding.

1227
02:03:12.340 --> 02:03:23.020
<v Sameer Kanal>These protections that we have are meaningful when they're strong, especially in light of recent heightened threats to the legal protections guaranteed to everyone here in the United States, regardless of their immigration status.

1228
02:03:23.554 --> 02:03:37.422
<v Sameer Kanal>As well as to our institutions, we've seen violation and violation after violation of due process rights, and we've seen the current federal government rescind a policy that protected schools, hospitals, and houses of worship from immigration raids.

1229
02:03:39.402 --> 02:03:41.672
<v Sameer Kanal>These are also not hypothetical risks here in Portland.

1230
02:03:42.630 --> 02:03:45.774
<v Sameer Kanal>All of us have constituents impacted in our district, including District Two.

1231
02:03:46.501 --> 02:03:49.823
<v Sameer Kanal>Last month, three people in North Portland were kidnapped by federal agents without.

1232
02:03:50.154 --> 02:03:52.725
<v Sameer Kanal>Any right to due process over a 48-hour period.

1233
02:03:53.430 --> 02:04:00.448
<v Sameer Kanal>They were violently ripped from their cars, they had their windows smashed in, and most heartbreakingly, taken in front of school while dropping off their children in a couple cases.

1234
02:04:01.943 --> 02:04:03.179
<v Sameer Kanal>This is happening in other districts too.

1235
02:04:03.725 --> 02:04:13.087
<v Sameer Kanal>District 3 parents are being stalked with ICE agents staked out in front of a public elementary school, and we also even today are receiving reports in Cully around the PCC campus.

1236
02:04:14.565 --> 02:04:16.412
<v Sameer Kanal>That's bad enough, but we also know where it could go.

1237
02:04:17.136 --> 02:04:23.850
<v Sameer Kanal>In Chicago, we have videos of ICE agents arresting a 15-year-old girl who is screaming that her parents won't know where she is and that she's 15.

1238
02:04:24.284 --> 02:04:27.324
<v Sameer Kanal>And the response is that ICE agents throw her down and briefly kneel on her neck.

1239
02:04:28.615 --> 02:04:39.969
<v Sameer Kanal>Closer to home, we've seen in Milwaukee, Oregon, a U.S. citizen born in California detained by ICE, profiled for the color of his skin and his name, as the Supreme Court has said is legal but, as Portlanders know, is immoral.

1240
02:04:41.530 --> 02:04:45.876
<v Sameer Kanal>We have both state and local protections against police officers collaborating with ICE here on federal immigration enforcement.

1241
02:04:45.925 --> 02:04:58.698
<v Sameer Kanal>There is a directive of the Portland Police Department and while there are edge cases that have raised questions, we've seen that on the whole, the rules that we have at the state and local level work.

1242
02:04:59.222 --> 02:05:14.007
<v Sameer Kanal>They've reduced not only the chances that police officers will support immigration enforcement absent judicial order to zero, but have also shown Portlanders that they can share information about a crime that they've witnessed with Portland Police Bureau officers without risk of themselves being rounded up and deported.

1243
02:05:14.725 --> 02:05:20.506
<v Sameer Kanal>And this ability to trust in local police is one of the main reasons that sanctuary status supports public safety.

1244
02:05:21.613 --> 02:05:32.757
<v Sameer Kanal>The 2017 study, The Effects of Sanctuary Policies on Crime and the Economy, which was cited in our 2017 resolution, shows that crime is lower and economies are stronger in sanctuary counties compared to non-sanctuary counties.

1245
02:05:33.672 --> 02:05:34.219
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's great.

1246
02:05:34.475 --> 02:05:35.181
<v Sameer Kanal>It's really great.

1247
02:05:35.439 --> 02:05:37.703
<v Sameer Kanal>But we are more than a sanctuary police bureau.

1248
02:05:38.007 --> 02:05:39.501
<v Sameer Kanal>We are a sanctuary city.

1249
02:05:40.960 --> 02:05:46.152
<v Sameer Kanal>And we need to provide support to our employees and their supervisors so that they know their rights and can meet their responsibilities.

1250
02:05:46.569 --> 02:05:56.408
<v Sameer Kanal>For example, the 2017 resolution created trainings for staff and resources for people who are affected and impacted by immigration enforcement, which were deployed once back then but not deployed again.

1251
02:05:57.801 --> 02:05:59.854
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's a problem that we can solve with this resolution.

1252
02:06:00.703 --> 02:06:10.878
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to pause for a moment and recognize that Councilor Murillo, one of the co-sponsors of this Councilor Avalos and I, also sponsors, are children of immigrants.

1253
02:06:10.943 --> 02:06:12.658
<v Sameer Kanal>These issues are not theoretical to us.

1254
02:06:13.250 --> 02:06:22.448
<v Sameer Kanal>We not only work on this legislation to bring justice and support for our communities, but we go home and we live the impacts of it, as we currently go home and live the lack of this legislation.

1255
02:06:23.282 --> 02:06:30.957
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Koyama Lane, one of the co-sponsors, has spoken strongly about the risks of rounding up people without due process, including earlier today in the context of World War II.

1256
02:06:31.869 --> 02:06:39.426
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick, who is also a co-sponsor, has been working with me— we're co-chairs of the Community and Public Safety Committee— for months on how to improve public safety.

1257
02:06:39.573 --> 02:06:44.938
<v Sameer Kanal>And sanctuary status is something he and I know, and I think everyone here knows as well, is something that enhances public safety.

1258
02:06:45.372 --> 02:06:53.997
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd also like to note Councilor Smith, the final co-sponsor, is one of the key sponsors of the 2016 Sanctuary County Resolution when she was a Multnomah County Commissioner.

1259
02:06:55.856 --> 02:07:00.161
<v Sameer Kanal>And just to go back into what we've been talking about here, our city workforce is also affected.

1260
02:07:00.680 --> 02:07:08.676
<v Sameer Kanal>Staff in the city have contacted my office and shared their fear and their trauma around contacting and encountering enforcement actions at home and at work.

1261
02:07:09.317 --> 02:07:12.426
<v Sameer Kanal>If they themselves were kidnapped at work, would their supervisor know what to do?

1262
02:07:13.403 --> 02:07:24.667
<v Sameer Kanal>And that despite 9 months of staff and specifically Latinx PDX, our employee resource group for Latino employees, asking, as of last month's note, no trainings nor safety rapid response plans have been offered.

1263
02:07:25.917 --> 02:07:27.952
<v Sameer Kanal>Today is the last day of Hispanic Heritage Month.

1264
02:07:29.188 --> 02:07:33.811
<v Sameer Kanal>I joined the Latinx PDX earlier today for empanadas and for celebration, but also for solidarity.

1265
02:07:34.631 --> 02:07:40.716
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wanted to highlight and celebrate the partnership that our offices have enjoyed working with Latinx PDX on this legislation.

1266
02:07:41.052 --> 02:07:45.693
<v Sameer Kanal>There is not one page in here which your words and advocacy have not affected.

1267
02:07:46.847 --> 02:07:49.497
<v Sameer Kanal>We need to act on those concerns by passing this ordinance.

1268
02:07:50.461 --> 02:07:54.426
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I also want to acknowledge the mayor for taking important steps to address these concerns.

1269
02:07:54.956 --> 02:08:06.310
<v Sameer Kanal>Today I want to celebrate he's implemented centralized intranet web resources, moved forward with immigrant liaisons, made available trainings, distributed Know Your Rights cards, signage for facilities has been posted here.

1270
02:08:06.680 --> 02:08:18.822
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a lot more as well, and I want to thank the mayor for that and say that I want to make sure that this city is resilient if there's a mayoral change in the future, as well as whatever comes from the federal government.

1271
02:08:19.689 --> 02:08:42.461
<v Sameer Kanal>And finally, I want to note that this ordinance stands on the shoulders of those who've gotten to this This picture on the right here, I'll come back to this slide later, is of Councilor Smith, then the county commissioner, speaking in favor, testifying here in support of the resolution in 2017, just after the December 2016 Multnomah County resolution.

1272
02:08:43.021 --> 02:08:56.122
<v Sameer Kanal>The city resolution back then was also authored by now State Representative Andrea Valderrama, who was then a City Hall she went on to work on the State Sanctuary Act in 2021, making it binding law.

1273
02:08:56.122 --> 02:09:03.643
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's, it's important to note it is binding law at the state level, but for the portions that are relevant specific to the city, those have not been put into binding city law.

1274
02:09:03.643 --> 02:09:05.462
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's the reason for this ordinance.

1275
02:09:05.743 --> 02:09:13.363
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to pass it to Councilor Murillo to talk about the impact of, of having no binding protections, and then we'll come back and explain a little bit about what's in the ordinance.

1276
02:09:14.262 --> 02:09:15.682
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1277
02:09:15.682 --> 02:09:19.662
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I'll keep my comments brief because I really want to hear from all the folks who have been waiting for a long time to testify, and I appreciate your patience as well.

1278
02:09:21.382 --> 02:09:21.382
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1279
02:09:21.382 --> 02:09:21.382
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1280
02:09:21.382 --> 02:09:21.382
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Mayor.

1281
02:09:21.382 --> 02:09:22.953
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Smith, for your remarks as we handle some other city business tonight.

1282
02:09:24.103 --> 02:09:46.363
<v Angelita Morillo>I think you explained the policy really well, so I won't get into that, but it makes me proud to be standing here alongside my colleagues who are bringing forward both a framework and this code change, to know that as a Paraguayan immigrant, that my colleagues have my back, that they have our community's back, and that with the tools that we have at the city level, we're going to do what we can to protect our communities.

1283
02:09:48.189 --> 02:09:53.130
<v Angelita Morillo>I am an immigrant, but my colleagues also have family members who are immigrants.

1284
02:09:54.284 --> 02:10:00.766
<v Angelita Morillo>My fellow colleague, Councilor Koyama Lane, has family members who were impacted by a fascist federal government as well.

1285
02:10:01.600 --> 02:10:14.177
<v Angelita Morillo>We all here hold different identities, whether we're queer, Jewish, immigrants, people of color, anything really, because we know that when we stand in solidarity with one another, that it means that they're going to come for us next.

1286
02:10:14.340 --> 02:10:18.222
<v Angelita Morillo>So unless we move through this together, then we're not going to get very far.

1287
02:10:20.478 --> 02:10:36.858
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that there's oftentimes where we want to talk about our values, and that matters, but I really appreciate Councilor Knoll putting this into code and making sure that this is solidified and that it is going to be more legally protective of our community.

1288
02:10:37.372 --> 02:10:43.837
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that implementation is the oftentimes less sexy but far more important work that ends up happening behind the scenes.

1289
02:10:43.903 --> 02:10:44.081
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1290
02:10:44.521 --> 02:10:46.283
<v Angelita Morillo>That leads to long-lasting change.

1291
02:10:46.801 --> 02:10:57.036
<v Angelita Morillo>And so I'm just very grateful to be here with all of my colleagues today and for all the people who showed up to testify and for all the people that have been protesting day in and day out because I actually think that we're going to win.

1292
02:10:57.779 --> 02:11:02.677
<v Angelita Morillo>It's just going to be really hard and it's going to take all of us doing our part, but I do believe that we're going to win.

1293
02:11:02.806 --> 02:11:03.895
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you for being here tonight.

1294
02:11:07.733 --> 02:11:08.699
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, Councilor Morillo.

1295
02:11:09.377 --> 02:11:13.436
<v Sameer Kanal>So just to nuts and bolts here, the ordinance does a few core things.

1296
02:11:13.550 --> 02:11:15.234
<v Sameer Kanal>It takes the 2020, Yeah.

1297
02:11:15.460 --> 02:11:24.435
<v Sameer Kanal>2017 Resolution's content, updates it to mirror the changes to the state law that were enacted in 2021 and puts them into code.

1298
02:11:25.335 --> 02:11:38.261
<v Sameer Kanal>What's not included in the state laws but are included in the city-specific components established by the resolution and now going into code with this ordinance are things like trainings for employees and protocols and procedures for employees or community members are picked up by ICE.

1299
02:11:38.372 --> 02:11:46.668
<v Sameer Kanal>It will require that the administration finds a way to ensure that all city staff know their responsibilities, and have the tools necessary to fulfill them.

1300
02:11:47.246 --> 02:11:51.125
<v Sameer Kanal>And that might include revising existing trainings and establishing notification processes.

1301
02:11:51.895 --> 02:11:56.046
<v Sameer Kanal>New to this ordinance is incorporation of ideas being implemented across the country.

1302
02:11:56.559 --> 02:12:05.936
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm sure that in addition to Portlanders at home watching this, at some point this will be watched by people in Chicago, in LA, in DC, and in so many other places around the country.

1303
02:12:06.161 --> 02:12:09.735
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you're fighting against an authoritarian government anywhere in this country, we are with you.

1304
02:12:09.783 --> 02:12:09.960
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1305
02:12:10.786 --> 02:12:12.480
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want you to hear that from us.

1306
02:12:15.694 --> 02:12:28.489
<v Sameer Kanal>Some of those ideas are labeling public and private spaces within city buildings and ensuring that people cannot enter the private spaces without a city badge or a judicial warrant, providing companion resources explaining why the signs exist.

1307
02:12:29.215 --> 02:12:38.328
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is because ICE can access any public space to kidnap people, but to enter backroom areas and private event spaces within a public building, they must have a judicial warrant.

1308
02:12:38.394 --> 02:12:41.240
<v Sameer Kanal>And so making that clear protects that's right.

1309
02:12:41.417 --> 02:12:46.305
<v Sameer Kanal>And this empowers staff asking for ways to protect our community members who may be visiting them.

1310
02:12:46.867 --> 02:12:54.240
<v Sameer Kanal>And also for even us, if you come to my office to meet with me or any of my colleagues in their office, that's a private space and nobody's getting in without a warrant.

1311
02:12:55.682 --> 02:13:04.114
<v Sameer Kanal>Finally, it directs the city to initiate— to report on Freedom of Information Act requests to get information on the federal government's activities in Portland.

1312
02:13:04.179 --> 02:13:11.286
<v Sameer Kanal>There'll be an adjustment to that text being proposed here, but broadly speaking, Portlanders deserve to know who's in our community and what they're doing.

1313
02:13:12.425 --> 02:13:21.654
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll start to wrap up here by expressing appreciation first to the City Attorney's Office and the Auditor's Office for their assistance in this process, which has been pretty significant.

1314
02:13:21.734 --> 02:13:24.078
<v Sameer Kanal>Ordinances take a lot of work, and I appreciate that.

1315
02:13:24.414 --> 02:13:29.101
<v Sameer Kanal>I also want to highlight that we've been talking about this issue for several years.

1316
02:13:29.198 --> 02:13:33.581
<v Sameer Kanal>The moment is now where it's back on the front pages, but we've needed to do this for a while.

1317
02:13:33.708 --> 02:13:38.300
<v Sameer Kanal>And a lot of the organizations that you're going to see on this slide have been in support of this for a long time.

1318
02:13:38.363 --> 02:13:38.475
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1319
02:13:39.086 --> 02:13:41.123
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's just that the moment is aligned for it.

1320
02:13:41.172 --> 02:13:43.965
<v Sameer Kanal>So I want to thank everyone on this list.

1321
02:13:44.046 --> 02:13:49.519
<v Sameer Kanal>I won't name everyone, but I did want to shout out Latinx PDX again, CPPW, SEIU.

1322
02:13:49.920 --> 02:14:03.996
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll also note the entire Multnomah County Board of Commissioners and the entire Portland Public School Board of Directors, as well as their student, their superintendent, and that does include the student representative on the school board, have all supported this, and it's for good reason.

1323
02:14:04.043 --> 02:14:04.171
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1324
02:14:06.078 --> 02:14:13.983
<v Sameer Kanal>In closing, as the federal government escalates its horrific attacks on our city, it's more important than ever that we take steps to protect our communities.

1325
02:14:14.500 --> 02:14:17.942
<v Sameer Kanal>Let's show what Portland stands for by aligning our laws with our values.

1326
02:14:18.826 --> 02:14:19.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1327
02:14:20.855 --> 02:14:22.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1328
02:14:23.900 --> 02:14:37.023
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we're now going to invite up 2 panels of speakers to provide some context for what we're talking about today, and then we'll hear from members of the public and then move into conversation and debate.

1329
02:14:37.605 --> 02:14:47.225
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For the first panel, I'd like to invite up Mercedes Elizalde, Ryan Sotomayor, Greg Parsons, Bob Cossie, and Frank So.

1330
02:14:47.627 --> 02:14:53.253
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council Clerk Rebecca Dobert.

1331
02:15:05.390 --> 02:15:08.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are we waiting for Mercedes to come downstairs?

1332
02:15:08.371 --> 02:15:09.546
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Yes.

1333
02:15:37.805 --> 02:15:43.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, as we wait to see if our other panelists are able to— oh, here we go.

1334
02:15:51.957 --> 02:15:53.698
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Call again as we get started.

1335
02:15:54.600 --> 02:16:01.014
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan Sotomayor, if you are in the overflow room or upstairs, if you want to come on down, we'd love to have you join us here.

1336
02:16:03.243 --> 02:16:03.856
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mercedes, go right ahead.

1337
02:16:03.921 --> 02:16:04.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Why don't you kick us off?

1338
02:16:05.135 --> 02:16:05.475
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Thank you.

1339
02:16:06.186 --> 02:16:06.914
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Hello, Council.

1340
02:16:06.979 --> 02:16:08.112
<v Mercedes Elizalde>My name is Mercedes Salisale.

1341
02:16:08.354 --> 02:16:10.895
<v Mercedes Elizalde>I am the Director of Advocacy at Latino Network.

1342
02:16:10.992 --> 02:16:14.634
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Latino Network was founded in 1996 to serve the Latino community.

1343
02:16:14.779 --> 02:16:28.819
<v Mercedes Elizalde>We now serve nearly 1,000 community— 11,000 community members We are here strongly in support of the proposed ordinance and resolution, particularly to codify the city sanctuary policies and set clear expectations for protecting Portlanders.

1344
02:16:29.797 --> 02:16:35.081
<v Mercedes Elizalde>As tensions with the federal government continue to grow, the city of Portland must remain steadfast in its values.

1345
02:16:35.674 --> 02:16:43.350
<v Mercedes Elizalde>We have local laws that should be respected, but we know that they can and often are already being tested to subvert our policies and.

1346
02:16:44.281 --> 02:16:45.434
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Attack our communities.

1347
02:16:46.429 --> 02:16:49.538
<v Mercedes Elizalde>But let's be clear: there is no America without immigrants.

1348
02:16:49.635 --> 02:16:52.326
<v Mercedes Elizalde>There are only Americans who have forgotten their immigration story.

1349
02:16:53.385 --> 02:17:01.543
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Codifying sanctuary policies and practices will create clear expectations for city staff who may be caught in the middle of of these tensions.

1350
02:17:01.977 --> 02:17:11.577
<v Mercedes Elizalde>It's critical for staff to have adequate training tools and consistent procedures so they will not be taken advantage of or caught without the information that they need when they receive inappropriate requests.

1351
02:17:12.075 --> 02:17:13.538
<v Mercedes Elizalde>From federal law enforcement.

1352
02:17:14.067 --> 02:17:16.268
<v Mercedes Elizalde>As an organization, we provide Know Your Rights trainings.

1353
02:17:16.332 --> 02:17:20.877
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Prior to this calendar year, we did approximately 1 or 2 a month.

1354
02:17:21.229 --> 02:17:25.486
<v Mercedes Elizalde>We are now doing these trainings nearly daily with over 2,000 community members who have been trained.

1355
02:17:25.791 --> 02:17:30.175
<v Mercedes Elizalde>We've created youth-specific training to help parents talk with their children about what is happening.

1356
02:17:31.188 --> 02:17:40.888
<v Mercedes Elizalde>And we are doing this at the same time that funding partners are either canceling grants or contracts or asking us to remove language that merely acknowledges our diversity and our equity work.

1357
02:17:42.413 --> 02:17:50.579
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Doing more to take care of our community members when every entity with more power than we have continues to demand that we do less.

1358
02:17:51.656 --> 02:17:53.966
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Our love in this moment is a radical act.

1359
02:17:55.265 --> 02:18:08.391
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Our local law enforcement resources and our local employees and public money must be spent on livability, community and cultural thriving, health and well-being.

1360
02:18:09.132 --> 02:18:16.210
<v Mercedes Elizalde>We simply do not have the money or time to waste on a political agenda that does not center or provide care for all Portlanders.

1361
02:18:17.792 --> 02:18:26.729
<v Mercedes Elizalde>Supporting these ordinances makes it clear that our local government is focused on local work and that we will not let our resources be used to hurt us.

1362
02:18:28.313 --> 02:18:35.058
<v Mercedes Elizalde>I want to thank you all very much for taking this action tonight, for taking care, for having love for the community.

1363
02:18:35.122 --> 02:18:35.219
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1364
02:18:35.911 --> 02:18:38.550
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1365
02:18:39.146 --> 02:18:41.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan Sotomayor, I believe you're online with us.

1366
02:18:47.942 --> 02:18:48.993
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Hi, are you able to hear me?

1367
02:18:50.222 --> 02:18:50.593
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, we are.

1368
02:18:50.721 --> 02:18:51.157
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1369
02:18:52.173 --> 02:18:53.012
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Good evening, Council.

1370
02:18:53.075 --> 02:19:02.682
<v Ryan Sotomayor>My name is Ryan Sotomayor, and I'm the business manager, secretary-treasurer of Laborers Local 43, a local union which represents workers of the City of Portland.

1371
02:19:03.770 --> 02:19:10.772
<v Ryan Sotomayor>And the Bureau of Transportation and the Bureau of Environmental Services and Portland Parks and Recreation, as well as other locations.

1372
02:19:11.381 --> 02:19:27.022
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We also represent workers at Metro, at the zoo, and in Parks and Nature at Blue Lake, Oxbow, and Borland Yard, and Relay Resources landscaping crews on the east and the west side, and the Port of Portland.

1373
02:19:27.503 --> 02:19:28.480
<v Ryan Sotomayor>So our folks Thank you.

1374
02:19:28.626 --> 02:19:28.947
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Public Works.

1375
02:19:29.219 --> 02:19:30.006
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Public Works.

1376
02:19:30.102 --> 02:19:41.730
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Public Works work within all 4 districts of the City of Portland, and we represent public workers who work in primarily front-facing positions and do the work that help keep Portland running.

1377
02:19:43.064 --> 02:19:50.869
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We appreciate council elevating all these issues that we're experiencing with the federal government.

1378
02:19:51.592 --> 02:19:54.852
<v Ryan Sotomayor>When people think of our members, they think of what the city is and what it will be.

1379
02:19:55.109 --> 02:20:03.856
<v Ryan Sotomayor>And we maintain the infrastructure such as the roads we drive, bike, and walk on, and down below the street level in the sewers to protect our health and waterways.

1380
02:20:03.922 --> 02:20:10.555
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We are there for working families and children of all ages at community centers, at schools, with a focus on accessibility.

1381
02:20:11.468 --> 02:20:16.644
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We maintain parks, public spaces, and buildings throughout the region that are enjoyed by all members of the public.

1382
02:20:17.076 --> 02:20:21.467
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We interact with people of all backgrounds in all 4 of Portland's districts.

1383
02:20:21.643 --> 02:20:25.575
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Interactions Can be brief but meaningful for the people we encounter.

1384
02:20:25.799 --> 02:20:27.951
<v Ryan Sotomayor>They tell us about a pothole or a broken swing.

1385
02:20:28.225 --> 02:20:30.842
<v Ryan Sotomayor>They want to talk about an upcoming event in the community.

1386
02:20:31.596 --> 02:20:38.790
<v Ryan Sotomayor>They check into the community center and pools for preschool arts programming and family lap swimming and fitness classes.

1387
02:20:39.449 --> 02:20:46.721
<v Ryan Sotomayor>They can thank us for the well-designed and maintained landscapes where their families enjoy a picnic, walk their dogs, play tennis, pickleball, basketball, and more.

1388
02:20:47.316 --> 02:20:47.620
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Thank you.

1389
02:20:48.456 --> 02:20:55.724
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We see on the news and social media that ICE is stalking community members at their schools, on their commute to work.

1390
02:20:56.140 --> 02:21:08.735
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We're worried that it's just a matter of time that we'll see an uptick in these experiences that our marginalized communities are facing, and in the public places that people want to trust and feel safe.

1391
02:21:10.019 --> 02:21:18.799
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We're worried that it's just a matter of time before ICE comes to our work where we want them feel safe to take away one of our coworkers and friends of color, or anyone, to be honest?

1392
02:21:19.139 --> 02:21:20.997
<v Ryan Sotomayor>What will our managers do if that happens?

1393
02:21:21.224 --> 02:21:22.338
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Is there a plan in place?

1394
02:21:24.712 --> 02:21:37.719
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We community members and workers do deserve to know when and where ICE is operating in our community, and the city's more than 7,000 employees that work for the city have the tools to ensure that they are ready for when ICE comes to our public spaces.

1395
02:21:38.808 --> 02:22:00.138
<v Ryan Sotomayor>With Congress's recent allocation of an unprecedented $165 billion of funding to the Department of Homeland Security, which oversees ICE and CBP, it is beyond a doubt that Trump's administration will intensify its efforts to fulfill their promise of an aggressive and militarized crackdown on undocumented immigrants.

1396
02:22:01.051 --> 02:22:09.245
<v Ryan Sotomayor>We don't want to see any of our family members, friends and neighbors, coworkers, or any members of our communities abducted by masked and armed federal agents.

1397
02:22:09.309 --> 02:22:11.250
<v Ryan Sotomayor>It does not keep our communities safer.

1398
02:22:12.680 --> 02:22:27.825
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Policies, ongoing trainings, updated signage, support resources for workers are needed to guide how the city handles interactions with federal agents engaged in immigration enforcement activities, thus providing more clarity for city employees.

1399
02:22:28.420 --> 02:22:34.184
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Thank the mayor and council for starting this work, but code makes this a permanent requirement.

1400
02:22:34.265 --> 02:22:40.195
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Councilors, on behalf of our workers and our communities, I urge you to vote yes on this and the other proposals.

1401
02:22:40.261 --> 02:22:41.498
<v Ryan Sotomayor>Thank you for your time and consideration.

1402
02:22:43.819 --> 02:22:45.118
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1403
02:22:46.010 --> 02:22:46.707
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Greg Parsons.

1404
02:22:48.344 --> 02:22:49.350
<v Greg Parsons>Uh, yes, thank you.

1405
02:22:50.993 --> 02:22:53.441
<v Greg Parsons>Um, for the record, my name is, uh, Greg Parsons.

1406
02:22:53.539 --> 02:22:59.975
<v Greg Parsons>I'm an electrician retired from, uh, IBEW Local 48 for over 30 years.

1407
02:23:00.236 --> 02:23:04.872
<v Greg Parsons>Uh, prior to becoming an electrician, I served in the United States Air Force for 6 years.

1408
02:23:07.117 --> 02:23:21.497
<v Greg Parsons>Security Police was my AFSC, and over 49 years ago, I took an oath to uphold and defend our United States Constitution against all enemies, both foreign and domestic.

1409
02:23:23.138 --> 02:23:26.435
<v Greg Parsons>I organize with other veterans across our state and nation.

1410
02:23:27.037 --> 02:23:38.682
<v Greg Parsons>I do this work with the Chamberlain Network which mobilizes and empowers veterans to protect democracy through organizing, education, and community engagement.

1411
02:23:39.772 --> 02:23:43.287
<v Greg Parsons>I also meet with others in IBW 48.

1412
02:23:43.368 --> 02:23:46.202
<v Greg Parsons>We have a veterans caucus, which I'm on their council.

1413
02:23:49.922 --> 02:23:57.364
<v Greg Parsons>I believe on behalf of the many veterans who can't be here today, I want to thank you for the work that you are doing.

1414
02:23:58.265 --> 02:24:01.789
<v Greg Parsons>This is an example of our democracy and how it's supposed to work.

1415
02:24:03.712 --> 02:24:10.668
<v Greg Parsons>Our active duty military service members are proud to be protecting our country nationally and well as abroad.

1416
02:24:11.913 --> 02:24:23.010
<v Greg Parsons>Our National Guard and Reserve service members are designated to protect and serve our nation by responding to real emergencies like national natural disasters stateside.

1417
02:24:24.069 --> 02:24:31.730
<v Greg Parsons>That is the work they took an oath to do, while our local law enforcement agencies are proud to serve protecting our communities every day.

1418
02:24:32.904 --> 02:24:49.037
<v Greg Parsons>Neither of these brave groups of Oregonians should be used to advance a divisive, reckless, and unnecessary political agenda coming from Washington, D.C. We, the state of Oregon, have our autonomy.

1419
02:24:49.474 --> 02:24:53.156
<v Greg Parsons>We decide what is best for our great state of Oregon.

1420
02:24:53.513 --> 02:24:55.677
<v Greg Parsons>Do not let this opportunity pass.

1421
02:24:57.183 --> 02:25:05.927
<v Greg Parsons>A wannabe dictator from the East Coast has no clue what would be in the best interests of the citizens of Portland or our home state of Oregon.

1422
02:25:07.362 --> 02:25:13.897
<v Greg Parsons>Please note, please vote for both sanctuary city resolution and ordinance tonight.

1423
02:25:14.476 --> 02:25:20.800
<v Greg Parsons>Our Oregon National Guard and local law enforcement deserve to see this council put your values on the record.

1424
02:25:21.343 --> 02:25:28.369
<v Greg Parsons>They also need you to take action by passing the ordinance and making these sanctuary policies a part of city law.

1425
02:25:30.143 --> 02:25:32.042
<v Greg Parsons>Thank you so much for your leadership tonight.

1426
02:25:32.445 --> 02:25:35.699
<v Greg Parsons>So many people serving our communities in many different ways.

1427
02:25:36.215 --> 02:25:37.680
<v Greg Parsons>Greatly appreciate it.

1428
02:25:38.774 --> 02:25:40.225
<v Greg Parsons>With my deepest respect.

1429
02:25:43.004 --> 02:25:44.676
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1430
02:25:47.763 --> 02:25:51.127
<v Bob Cozzie>Good evening, Council President, Vice President, and Council.

1431
02:25:51.466 --> 02:25:56.684
<v Bob Cozzie>Um, I'm Bob Causie, Deputy City Administrator for the Public Safety Service Area.

1432
02:25:57.542 --> 02:26:06.922
<v Bob Cozzie>On behalf of Chief Bob Day and the Portland Police Bureau, I want to express our appreciation to City Council and the drafters of this legislation.

1433
02:26:07.704 --> 02:26:15.718
<v Bob Cozzie>For the opportunity to contribute to an open and constructive dialogue as it relates to federal immigration enforcement.

1434
02:26:16.439 --> 02:26:29.548
<v Bob Cozzie>The Portland Police Bureau recognizes the expectations outlined in this legislation and affirms the importance of preserving local control and our duty to protect the rights and safety of all Portlanders.

1435
02:26:30.220 --> 02:26:46.650
<v Bob Cozzie>We further acknowledge the necessity of ensuring that PPB members are not deputized by federal or military entities without the express authorization of the city, and we remain committed to upholding these principles in practice.

1436
02:26:48.272 --> 02:26:54.569
<v Bob Cozzie>We appreciate the thoughtful approach City Council has taken in addressing these sensitive and complex matters.

1437
02:26:55.650 --> 02:27:12.621
<v Bob Cozzie>The actions outlined, from deputizing And joint operations to establishing clear protocols for interactions with federal immigration enforcement reflect shared values around transparency, accountability, and the protection of civil liberties.

1438
02:27:13.936 --> 02:27:29.029
<v Bob Cozzie>PPB looks forward to continuing collaboration with council, the mayor's office, and the city administrator to ensure our policies and procedures are both responsive to community concerns and are operationally sound.

1439
02:27:29.879 --> 02:27:39.095
<v Bob Cozzie>We're also committed to providing our officers with the training and support they need to understand and adhere to these evolving expectations.

1440
02:27:40.236 --> 02:27:55.430
<v Bob Cozzie>We view this legislation as part of a broader ongoing partnership between PPB and the city, one grounded in accountability, transparency, and a shared commitment to serving our community.

1441
02:27:57.150 --> 02:27:58.531
<v Bob Cozzie>That's signed by Chief Day.

1442
02:27:59.279 --> 02:28:11.716
<v Bob Cozzie>And from my perspective as Deputy City Administrator, I appreciate the collaboration that we as a service area, and particularly PPB, has had with council on this issue.

1443
02:28:12.592 --> 02:28:15.640
<v Bob Cozzie>And thank you for the opportunity to continue collaborating.

1444
02:28:17.542 --> 02:28:18.299
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1445
02:28:19.581 --> 02:28:19.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Frank So.

1446
02:28:21.424 --> 02:28:23.333
<v Frank So>Good evening, members of the council, Mr. Mayor.

1447
02:28:23.925 --> 02:28:25.096
<v Frank So>Buenas tardes.

1448
02:28:26.091 --> 02:28:30.051
<v Frank So>My name is Frank So, and I serve as executive director of Ecumenical Ministries of Oregon.

1449
02:28:30.195 --> 02:28:38.790
<v Frank So>I'm also the proud son of 2 immigrants to the United States and a very proud Portlander, especially here right now listening to what is being said.

1450
02:28:40.105 --> 02:28:47.677
<v Frank So>Thank you for the invitation to share with you why EMO strongly supports both the resolution and the proposed to ordinance before you this evening.

1451
02:28:48.078 --> 02:29:02.037
<v Frank So>IMO has been rooted in this community for over 50 years, offering services to thousands of Oregonians annually, and as a community of people of faith and people of goodwill for over 100 years here in Portland to do justice.

1452
02:29:02.375 --> 02:29:10.358
<v Frank So>IMO, through our SOAR legal program, provides representation for our neighbors who demand due process in immigration matters.

1453
02:29:11.176 --> 02:29:18.539
<v Frank So>For the past last year, we have received an average of 100 calls per day for immigration legal assistance.

1454
02:29:19.695 --> 02:29:20.484
<v Frank So>Let me repeat that.

1455
02:29:21.226 --> 02:29:25.157
<v Frank So>Every single day, 100 calls.

1456
02:29:26.720 --> 02:29:32.415
<v Frank So>Those calls mostly ask, how do I protect my family?

1457
02:29:34.184 --> 02:29:37.061
<v Frank So>Those that we serve may not be Americans.

1458
02:29:37.368 --> 02:29:40.268
<v Frank So>But we serve them because we are Americans.

1459
02:29:41.018 --> 02:29:43.054
<v Frank So>That is true patriotism.

1460
02:29:46.513 --> 02:29:49.637
<v Frank So>The city council has a duty to do everything to protect its residents.

1461
02:29:50.313 --> 02:30:02.591
<v Frank So>EMO urges the city council and the mayor to support codifying our sanctuary city status to ensure that no city resources are used to support immigration enforcement and no city employees assist.

1462
02:30:02.976 --> 02:30:05.400
<v Frank So>ICE beyond what is required by federal law.

1463
02:30:06.573 --> 02:30:10.282
<v Frank So>This ordinance is needed because city code is law.

1464
02:30:11.390 --> 02:30:19.518
<v Frank So>The Protect Portland resolution is an important declaration, and it contains necessary details for how we must fight the federal overreach.

1465
02:30:20.320 --> 02:30:23.371
<v Frank So>But code is needed to make it permanent.

1466
02:30:24.352 --> 02:30:30.184
<v Frank So>No matter who our president, mayor, city administrator is, in the future.

1467
02:30:31.472 --> 02:30:37.979
<v Frank So>We thank you for your leadership, and I welcome the opportunity to partner with you in protecting our community and our values moving forward.

1468
02:30:38.302 --> 02:30:44.485
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much for being here this evening with us.

1469
02:30:45.462 --> 02:30:48.307
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to invite up our second panel.

1470
02:30:52.924 --> 02:30:55.680
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to invite up our second panel, Harper Haverkamp.

1471
02:30:55.833 --> 02:31:01.483
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Reverend Allison Miller and Jessica Maravilla.

1472
02:31:01.483 --> 02:31:01.522
<v Allison Miller>Thank you.

1473
02:31:31.484 --> 02:31:35.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Reverend Miller, why don't you go ahead and get started while we wait to see if Harper's coming from another room?

1474
02:31:35.926 --> 02:31:36.504
<v Bob Cozzie>Sure.

1475
02:31:37.498 --> 02:31:45.117
<v Allison Miller>My name is Allison Miller, and I serve as the senior minister of the First Unitarian Church of Portland.

1476
02:31:45.854 --> 02:31:49.335
<v Allison Miller>Thank you for having me and for what you are doing here.

1477
02:31:49.769 --> 02:32:09.963
<v Allison Miller>Tonight, I am one of 70 clergy who are accompanying immigrants and immigrant communities at immigration court and at the ICE building, coordinated by Together Lab and in partnership with community organizations like the Portland Immigrant Rights Coalition.

1478
02:32:11.102 --> 02:32:17.165
<v Allison Miller>I want to share just a glimpse of why I felt called to show up in this way and a hint of what I've seen.

1479
02:32:18.000 --> 02:32:28.805
<v Allison Miller>As a Unitarian Universalist minister, I have covenanted to affirm and promote the inherent worth and dignity of every person in our community.

1480
02:32:29.575 --> 02:32:32.974
<v Allison Miller>So I've been showing up as a chaplain supporting my neighbors.

1481
02:32:33.888 --> 02:32:53.215
<v Allison Miller>I've witnessed people who are terrified to show up on that block or to go inside the ICE building, and people who are concerned about the right-wing media filming them outside and how they might misuse this footage that was filmed without their consent.

1482
02:32:54.097 --> 02:33:05.706
<v Allison Miller>I have listened to their personal histories, their work life, their family life, their faith life here as people who are a vital part of our neighborhoods, our city, and our state.

1483
02:33:06.380 --> 02:33:12.995
<v Allison Miller>And if you spend time with residents going to these appointments, you quickly recognize that.

1484
02:33:13.429 --> 02:33:17.827
<v Allison Miller>Our neighbors, like our city, are so much more than a headline.

1485
02:33:18.743 --> 02:33:34.843
<v Allison Miller>Beyond our city, there are political leaders who are succumbing to a twisted version of religion, a Christian nationalist narrative that divides communities and fuels fear and fascism.

1486
02:33:36.304 --> 02:33:42.049
<v Allison Miller>It is a version of Christianity that is neither faithful nor fair.

1487
02:33:43.122 --> 02:33:57.083
<v Allison Miller>Instead, let us follow the path of the beloved community charted for us by Jesus, by the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., and by many moral leaders of different faiths today.

1488
02:33:58.350 --> 02:34:09.281
<v Allison Miller>On behalf of myself and so many other faith leaders tonight, those in this room and those who could not be here, please vote for both the sanctuary Thank you.

1489
02:34:09.344 --> 02:34:11.861
<v Allison Miller>Thank you, Mayor Wilson, for your leadership on this important city resolution and the ordinance.

1490
02:34:12.549 --> 02:34:21.569
<v Allison Miller>It is a vital response to federal overreach and militarization, surges in ICE activity, and other acts of federal aggression.

1491
02:34:22.564 --> 02:34:39.935
<v Allison Miller>It makes such a difference to us to witness our elected leaders showing up and upholding our collective values and supporting our whole community here in Portland, including our neighbors who are immigrants and refugees.

1492
02:34:40.532 --> 02:34:44.936
<v Allison Miller>We invite you to take a stand on the side of love.

1493
02:34:47.922 --> 02:34:48.729
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1494
02:34:48.956 --> 02:34:53.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I apologize, there had been a slight change in the run of show from my printed documents.

1495
02:34:54.153 --> 02:35:01.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would like to make sure that we have Ariana Jacob and Matthew Rock available.

1496
02:35:02.236 --> 02:35:05.611
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are either of you available remote to go ahead and jump in with testimony?

1497
02:35:08.792 --> 02:35:09.711
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ariana, go right ahead.

1498
02:35:10.486 --> 02:35:10.775
<v Ariana Jacob>I can.

1499
02:35:11.130 --> 02:35:11.663
<v Ariana Jacob>Good evening.

1500
02:35:13.951 --> 02:35:15.692
<v Ariana Jacob>Um, thank you for having me.

1501
02:35:15.903 --> 02:35:26.726
<v Ariana Jacob>My name is Ariana Jacob, and I'm part-time faculty at Portland State University, and I'm the elected president of our statewide labor union, American Federation of Teachers Oregon.

1502
02:35:27.819 --> 02:35:34.243
<v Ariana Jacob>AFT Oregon represents around 18,000 education professionals across Oregon's university Thank you.

1503
02:35:34.243 --> 02:35:38.052
<v Ariana Jacob>AFT represents 1.5 million members across 30 states and territories, community colleges, public schools, and childcare nonprofits.

1504
02:35:39.063 --> 02:35:51.583
<v Ariana Jacob>Since Trump's first election in 2016, AFT members nationally and, and in Oregon have been vocal and strong supporters of sanctuary classrooms, sanctuary campuses, and sanctuary cities.

1505
02:35:51.802 --> 02:35:55.872
<v Ariana Jacob>Today we face an escalation darker than in Trump's first term.

1506
02:35:56.302 --> 02:36:01.034
<v Ariana Jacob>Tens of thousands of undocumented students are facing renewed threats of deportation.

1507
02:36:01.772 --> 02:36:06.859
<v Ariana Jacob>Faculty and staff are being placed on right-wing watch lists and harassment campaigns.

1508
02:36:07.629 --> 02:36:13.147
<v Ariana Jacob>Our city, Portland, is being attacked by a sitting president in unprecedented ways.

1509
02:36:14.141 --> 02:36:23.638
<v Ariana Jacob>As union workers in education, we have a duty to protect our students and our coworkers from targeting, imprisonment, deportation, family separation, and harm.

1510
02:36:24.327 --> 02:36:26.990
<v Ariana Jacob>We have a duty to defend the rights and freedoms Thank you.

1511
02:36:27.040 --> 02:36:35.048
<v Ariana Jacob>We are here today to celebrate the importance of public education for learners of all ages, and that's partially because, as we all know, education is one of the foundations of our democracy.

1512
02:36:36.123 --> 02:36:48.242
<v Ariana Jacob>In this political moment, workers in education from cradle to career are at the forefront of movements to resist ICE, to push back against xenophobia, and to stop our communities from being torn apart.

1513
02:36:48.963 --> 02:37:01.782
<v Ariana Jacob>We are so proud to stand with you as we work together to keep our Please vote to pass both the resolution and the ordinance tonight.

1514
02:37:02.583 --> 02:37:10.802
<v Ariana Jacob>Education workers and the communities we serve are relying on your leadership to codify and clarify a rejection of federal overreach in our city.

1515
02:37:11.683 --> 02:37:18.042
<v Ariana Jacob>Continue this important work into the future by finding ways the city can be united with our movements on the ground to keep schools open students and to keep our students safe.

1516
02:37:18.042 --> 02:37:18.143
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Jamie Dunphy.

1517
02:37:18.426 --> 02:37:19.439
<v Ariana Jacob>And communities safe.

1518
02:37:20.193 --> 02:37:29.547
<v Ariana Jacob>We must stand united and loudly push back and say Portland is a union town, Portland is a sanctuary city, and we are so proud to work with you on this.

1519
02:37:29.745 --> 02:37:30.620
<v Ariana Jacob>Thank you for your leadership.

1520
02:37:32.759 --> 02:37:33.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1521
02:37:34.325 --> 02:37:37.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Matthew Rock, I believe we have you online as well.

1522
02:37:40.393 --> 02:37:41.264
<v Matthew Rock>Good evening, can you hear me?

1523
02:37:41.661 --> 02:37:42.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, we can.

1524
02:37:42.648 --> 02:37:43.076
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1525
02:37:43.769 --> 02:37:44.954
<v Matthew Rock>Well, good evening, council members.

1526
02:37:45.772 --> 02:37:46.894
<v Matthew Rock>My name is Matthew Rock.

1527
02:37:47.295 --> 02:37:51.718
<v Matthew Rock>I own a number of small businesses here in Portland and across the state.

1528
02:37:53.065 --> 02:38:11.657
<v Matthew Rock>I firmly believe that it is the moral duty of Oregonians and above all Portlanders to send a strong message to Trump against his campaign of terror on our immigrant communities, communities that have always and will continue to make our state and city so great.

1529
02:38:11.706 --> 02:38:11.801
<v Matthew Rock>Thank you.

1530
02:38:12.716 --> 02:38:19.093
<v Matthew Rock>As you likely know, the path of an immigrant is a long and laborious one, riddled with bureaucratic hurdles.

1531
02:38:19.606 --> 02:38:23.949
<v Matthew Rock>We need to stand beside those navigating these processes now more than ever.

1532
02:38:24.959 --> 02:38:27.586
<v Matthew Rock>They are an essential part of our communities and economies.

1533
02:38:27.924 --> 02:38:43.596
<v Matthew Rock>Not only are they our friends, but they are an integral part of everything from agriculture, construction, child and elder care, healthcare, manufacturing, The overstep of the federal government must be stopped.

1534
02:38:44.143 --> 02:38:55.520
<v Matthew Rock>I urge you to vote for the resolution and to codify our great city as a sanctuary city in order to solidify these protections for our immigrant families, friends, and coworkers.

1535
02:38:55.856 --> 02:38:59.568
<v Matthew Rock>Let us demonstrate that Portland stands strong against the tyranny of Trump.

1536
02:39:00.452 --> 02:39:02.879
<v Matthew Rock>I sincerely thank you for your time and the hard work you do for our city.

1537
02:39:02.943 --> 02:39:03.072
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1538
02:39:03.153 --> 02:39:05.769
<v Matthew Rock>That you've put into addressing these pressing issues.

1539
02:39:09.593 --> 02:39:10.497
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1540
02:39:12.175 --> 02:39:12.406
<v Ariana Jacob>Jessica.

1541
02:39:14.370 --> 02:39:20.188
<v Jessica Maravilla>Thank you, Mayor Wilson, Council President Pirtle-Guiney, Council Vice President Koyama Lane, and councilors.

1542
02:39:21.273 --> 02:39:23.236
<v Jessica Maravilla>Thank you for the opportunity to testify today.

1543
02:39:23.316 --> 02:39:24.566
<v Jessica Maravilla>My name is Jessica Maravilla.

1544
02:39:24.613 --> 02:39:25.538
<v Jessica Maravilla>I serve as the policy director for the ACLU of Oregon.

1545
02:39:27.876 --> 02:39:40.336
<v Jessica Maravilla>We are a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization that works to strengthen and defend our civil rights, civil liberties, and our democracy with over 48,000 members statewide.

1546
02:39:41.122 --> 02:39:44.138
<v Jessica Maravilla>Tonight you have heard strong support from across our city.

1547
02:39:44.731 --> 02:39:52.845
<v Jessica Maravilla>I've heard faith communities, local businesses, organized labor, community-based organizations, public safety officials, and veterans.

1548
02:39:53.296 --> 02:40:00.172
<v Jessica Maravilla>All recognizing that these measures are urgently needed and aligned with Portland's values and responsibilities.

1549
02:40:01.229 --> 02:40:09.582
<v Jessica Maravilla>Tonight, I echo these voices, ensuring that the ACLU of Oregon strongly supports both the Protect Portland Initiative resolution and the sanctuary city ordinance.

1550
02:40:10.127 --> 02:40:13.397
<v Jessica Maravilla>The resolution provides a critical executive direction.

1551
02:40:13.829 --> 02:40:24.939
<v Jessica Maravilla>It tasks the city manager— the city administrator with clarifying and designating non-public areas in city buildings and urges the mayor to ensure that no city resources are used for immigration enforcement.

1552
02:40:25.003 --> 02:40:25.114
<v Jessica Maravilla>Thank you.

1553
02:40:25.180 --> 02:40:27.120
<v Jessica Maravilla>Enforcements except where legally required.

1554
02:40:27.682 --> 02:40:41.863
<v Jessica Maravilla>It establishes a vital operational framework to respond to federal overreach, militarization, including threats of National Guard deployment, surges in immigration enforcement, and other acts of federal aggression against our cities and our communities.

1555
02:40:42.538 --> 02:40:48.073
<v Jessica Maravilla>The Sanctuary City Ordinance begins to translate some of these directives into binding city law.

1556
02:40:48.875 --> 02:41:01.028
<v Jessica Maravilla>Together, the resolution and the ordinance build the legal infrastructure you need to uphold Portland's values of justice, fairness, and community care, including towards our immigrant and refugee neighbors.

1557
02:41:01.524 --> 02:41:06.139
<v Jessica Maravilla>And it ensures that local policies align with the full spirit and intent of Oregon law.

1558
02:41:07.389 --> 02:41:16.730
<v Jessica Maravilla>But these actions must be seen, please, as the beginning, not the end of what this council can and must do to protect our democracy.

1559
02:41:17.227 --> 02:41:24.299
<v Jessica Maravilla>Continued action is needed to guard against unconstitutional surveillance Thank you.

1560
02:41:25.853 --> 02:41:29.626
<v Jessica Maravilla>I ask that this council please remain vigilant in protecting our shared democracy values.

1561
02:41:30.291 --> 02:41:32.165
<v Jessica Maravilla>This legal infrastructure is not theoretical.

1562
02:41:32.637 --> 02:41:36.040
<v Jessica Maravilla>It is a necessary response to real and escalating threats.

1563
02:41:36.860 --> 02:41:41.058
<v Jessica Maravilla>Federalized National Guard troops, National Guard troops have been threatened in our streets.

1564
02:41:41.719 --> 02:41:46.560
<v Jessica Maravilla>Immigrants and refugee neighbors continue to face harassment, detainment, and family separation.

1565
02:41:46.917 --> 02:41:52.061
<v Jessica Maravilla>We have seen how the federal power can be abused to suppress protest, erode civil rights, and target vulnerable communities.

1566
02:41:54.914 --> 02:42:04.082
<v Jessica Maravilla>The Protect Portland Initiative and codifying sanctuary protections are these crucial first steps in coordinating the city's response to these unlawful and undemocratic assaults.

1567
02:42:04.708 --> 02:42:10.247
<v Jessica Maravilla>On behalf of the ACLU of Oregon, I want to express our deep appreciation for your leadership in meeting this moment.

1568
02:42:10.728 --> 02:42:17.103
<v Jessica Maravilla>By adopting both the resolution and the ordinance, you are not just only defending the rule of law.

1569
02:42:17.873 --> 02:42:25.224
<v Jessica Maravilla>You are affirming that the dignity, safety, and rights of everyone that calls Portland I urge your strong yes vote tonight.

1570
02:42:25.626 --> 02:42:25.965
<v Jessica Maravilla>Thank you.

1571
02:42:28.121 --> 02:42:28.879
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1572
02:42:29.555 --> 02:42:35.595
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you to all of our invited panelists for setting the stage for the rest of our conversation this evening.

1573
02:42:37.395 --> 02:42:47.156
<v Unidentified speaker>I will note as we move into hearing from members of the public that there are no pre-filed amendments to the Protect Portland Initiative resolution.

1574
02:42:47.852 --> 02:42:53.555
<v Unidentified speaker>There are 2 pre-filed amendments to the sanctuary codification ordinance.

1575
02:42:54.438 --> 02:43:10.254
<v Unidentified speaker>One of them pre-filed by Councilor Kanal would add an emergency clause to the ordinance, which would allow it to go into effect upon being voted on and would allow us to vote on it this evening instead of on a second reading in the future.

1576
02:43:11.137 --> 02:43:19.362
<v Unidentified speaker>The other filed by Councilor Smith would remove the codification of FOIA requests.

1577
02:43:19.959 --> 02:43:43.269
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe these are still in the resolution, but they would not be in the codification, and it would add a portion to the codification that would require the city administration to provide an annual report to council summarizing immigration enforcement communication requests and activities and a description of the city's response.

1578
02:43:45.033 --> 02:43:49.561
<v Unidentified speaker>We like to make sure folks know what is proposed in advance in case you'd like to testify to it.

1579
02:43:50.496 --> 02:43:57.710
<v Unidentified speaker>With that, Keelan, could you please call up our first panel of folks for public testimony?

1580
02:43:57.855 --> 02:44:05.293
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll note that we have about 70 people signed up, so we will try to get as many people up here as possible.

1581
02:44:05.390 --> 02:44:17.236
<v Unidentified speaker>And if we're waiting on people to come from overflow rooms and upstairs, I'd encourage the people who are able to get to the table first to jump in so that we can hear from as many people as we can before it gets too late.

1582
02:44:19.059 --> 02:44:33.135
<v Unidentified speaker>First up, we have Shannon Singleton, Rachelle Chase Miller, Maria Segoviano, Angela Bonilla, and Salome Chimuku.

1583
02:44:36.202 --> 02:44:37.426
<v Unidentified speaker>Go right ahead.

1584
02:44:39.185 --> 02:44:40.165
<v Shannon Singleton>Thank you so much.

1585
02:44:40.453 --> 02:44:45.013
<v Shannon Singleton>Um, it's my honor to be here tonight, uh, Council President and council members.

1586
02:44:45.110 --> 02:44:47.021
<v Shannon Singleton>For the record, my name is Shannon Singleton.

1587
02:44:47.198 --> 02:44:51.726
<v Shannon Singleton>Um, my pronouns are she and her, and I'm the Multnomah County Commissioner for District 2.

1588
02:44:52.432 --> 02:44:56.253
<v Shannon Singleton>My district spans north and northeast Portland from St. Johns to Parkrose.

1589
02:44:56.831 --> 02:45:10.263
<v Shannon Singleton>And in keeping up with the, the history of this district and showing up for sanctuary policies, I'm really pleased to be able to be here and testify in support of item 2025-402.

1590
02:45:11.049 --> 02:45:21.274
<v Shannon Singleton>I firmly believe that while words are nice and sometimes symbolic actions are needed, we must operationalize our values and implement them throughout every facet of the city and the county.

1591
02:45:22.109 --> 02:45:25.795
<v Shannon Singleton>Codifying our sanctuary status into city code is a necessary step.

1592
02:45:26.516 --> 02:45:30.731
<v Shannon Singleton>Portlanders deserve to have their city support them not just with words but with action.

1593
02:45:31.308 --> 02:45:45.095
<v Shannon Singleton>I want to thank Councilors Kanal, Murillo, and Avalos for bringing this When the, when the city and the county were making our sanctuary policies, many were focused only on law enforcement, but it is important that we include all public employees.

1594
02:45:45.707 --> 02:45:55.293
<v Shannon Singleton>City employees deserve clarity about current policies regarding ICE, what they should do in various scenarios, and whether current guidelines align with sanctuary, with state laws.

1595
02:45:56.129 --> 02:45:58.103
<v Shannon Singleton>This legislation aims to do just that.

1596
02:45:59.164 --> 02:46:02.279
<v Shannon Singleton>I have the honor of serving some of the most diverse neighborhoods in Portland.

1597
02:46:02.872 --> 02:46:10.947
<v Shannon Singleton>I believe both this and Councilor Avalos's resolution go hand in hand to make a powerful statement that Portland values our immigrant and refugee communities.

1598
02:46:11.700 --> 02:46:16.164
<v Shannon Singleton>Putting our sanctuary status into code lets everyone know that we are here to protect community.

1599
02:46:17.222 --> 02:46:26.034
<v Shannon Singleton>I have begun similar work at the county to ensure that people know that leaders at the local level protect our immigrant and refugee communities and stick to our values of equity.

1600
02:46:26.773 --> 02:46:32.754
<v Shannon Singleton>I ask you to vote yes on both 2025-401 and 2025-402.

1601
02:46:33.381 --> 02:46:33.784
<v Shannon Singleton>Thank you.

1602
02:46:39.006 --> 02:46:41.172
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1603
02:46:42.900 --> 02:46:43.272
<v Keelan McClymont>Michelle?

1604
02:46:43.692 --> 02:46:48.193
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sorry, go ahead.

1605
02:46:49.593 --> 02:46:49.881
<v Jennifer Shook>Great.

1606
02:46:51.200 --> 02:46:52.356
<v Angela Bonilla>Good evening, Council.

1607
02:46:52.405 --> 02:46:53.385
<v Angela Bonilla>My name is Angela Bonilla.

1608
02:46:53.449 --> 02:46:55.425
<v Angela Bonilla>I use she/they/eyya pronouns.

1609
02:46:55.924 --> 02:46:57.844
<v Angela Bonilla>I am an Afro-Latina child of immigrants.

1610
02:46:58.195 --> 02:47:00.986
<v Angela Bonilla>And I am the president of the Portland Association of Teachers.

1611
02:47:01.724 --> 02:47:04.882
<v Angela Bonilla>Typically, I work as an elementary Spanish immersion educator.

1612
02:47:05.908 --> 02:47:16.123
<v Angela Bonilla>As public school educators, we have the privilege and duty to serve everyone in our city, regardless of ability, race, gender, sexuality, class, or national origin.

1613
02:47:16.654 --> 02:47:21.593
<v Angela Bonilla>We work to not only educate, but build connections between folks with diverse identities.

1614
02:47:22.105 --> 02:47:24.158
<v Angela Bonilla>At our schools, everyone belongs.

1615
02:47:24.207 --> 02:47:24.367
<v Angela Bonilla>Thank you.

1616
02:47:25.154 --> 02:47:31.222
<v Angela Bonilla>What we are seeing in our schools and outside of our schools is fear and uncertainty due to the presence of ICE in our communities.

1617
02:47:31.816 --> 02:47:40.520
<v Angela Bonilla>We have had at least 4 reports of parents of Portland Public Schools students who've been kidnapped off the street after dropping off their children at school.

1618
02:47:41.370 --> 02:47:52.578
<v Angela Bonilla>In the days following some of those kidnappings, educators across North Portland shared with me that their families were too scared to send their kids to school, scared to pick their students up, to attend evening events.

1619
02:47:52.627 --> 02:47:52.754
<v Angela Bonilla>Thank you.

1620
02:47:53.413 --> 02:47:58.237
<v Angela Bonilla>And this fear has been paralyzing, and as educators, we have sprung to action.

1621
02:47:58.862 --> 02:48:05.194
<v Angela Bonilla>We are following the lead of those most impacted and who are doing the work, like the Portland Immigrant Rights Coalition.

1622
02:48:05.819 --> 02:48:15.182
<v Angela Bonilla>We see what has happened in LA and DC and Chicago, and we see how governance in Chicago is standing up against ICE, and they have done that through both words and actions.

1623
02:48:16.094 --> 02:48:26.805
<v Angela Bonilla>We community members deserve to know when and where ICE is operating in our community, and that the city's more than 7,000 employees that work for Councilor Loretta Smith.

1624
02:48:26.886 --> 02:48:27.960
<v Angela Bonilla>Thank you, Mayor.

1625
02:48:28.137 --> 02:48:30.014
<v Angela Bonilla>I'm here to support this ordinance.

1626
02:48:30.769 --> 02:48:36.945
<v Angela Bonilla>This ordinance is needed because city code is law, and the code will make sure that this is permanent.

1627
02:48:37.332 --> 02:48:47.263
<v Angela Bonilla>These protections are crucial to making sure every Portlander feels like this city, the city that we love, is not just for those who already feel safe.

1628
02:48:47.938 --> 02:48:56.168
<v Angela Bonilla>I know it's hard to hold an elected position while the federal government works to dismantle everything we love about our public services, but we can do hard things.

1629
02:48:56.524 --> 02:49:03.370
<v Angela Bonilla>And I know you can pass both the resolution and ordinance to ensure that we are safe across our city.

1630
02:49:03.727 --> 02:49:04.212
<v Angela Bonilla>Thank you.

1631
02:49:05.166 --> 02:49:07.404
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1632
02:49:09.513 --> 02:49:11.590
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Uh, good evening, Mayor and councilors.

1633
02:49:11.847 --> 02:49:18.021
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Uh, for the record, my name is Maria Hernandez Segoviano, an employee with the City of Portland and a proud member of Line-X PDX.

1634
02:49:18.295 --> 02:49:26.891
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>I want to first begin expressing my gratitude to my fellow Line-X PDX members for your courage, your solidarity, and for continuing to show up for one another.

1635
02:49:27.439 --> 02:49:33.529
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>I also want to thank you for your leadership on this issue, approaching immigration with empathy, urgency, and action.

1636
02:49:34.042 --> 02:49:40.630
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Thank you for strengthening Portland's commitment to immigrant and refugee communities and for standing on the side of dignity and human rights.

1637
02:49:41.272 --> 02:49:46.639
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>When I testified before the committee, Public Safety Committee, last month, I said that sanctuary policies are not abstract.

1638
02:49:47.058 --> 02:49:47.828
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>They are lived realities.

1639
02:49:48.451 --> 02:49:50.040
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Today, I want to be very clear again.

1640
02:49:50.623 --> 02:49:52.521
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Racial profiling is not hypothetical.

1641
02:49:52.813 --> 02:49:53.688
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>It is a lived reality.

1642
02:49:54.729 --> 02:49:59.144
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>I want to ask both council and everyone in this room, who here carries their passport every day?

1643
02:50:02.483 --> 02:50:07.541
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Who worries about being questioned, detained, or profiled simply for existing in public space, for simply being here?

1644
02:50:09.501 --> 02:50:13.774
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>See, that's the difference between those impacted by these policies and those protected by them.

1645
02:50:13.824 --> 02:50:13.936
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Thank you.

1646
02:50:14.743 --> 02:50:20.006
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>I carry my passport with me every day at all times, not as a choice anymore, but as a survival strategy.

1647
02:50:21.066 --> 02:50:24.579
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>This is what it means to live in Portland nowadays as someone perceived as an immigrant.

1648
02:50:25.816 --> 02:50:28.206
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Council must also acknowledge a critical fact.

1649
02:50:28.768 --> 02:50:31.880
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Most of you hold positions of racial and institutional privilege.

1650
02:50:33.197 --> 02:50:34.770
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>That reality brings responsibility.

1651
02:50:35.282 --> 02:50:36.710
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Equity is not about intent.

1652
02:50:36.968 --> 02:50:37.817
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>It's about outcomes.

1653
02:50:38.396 --> 02:50:41.380
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Outcomes only change when those most impacted are centered in decision-making.

1654
02:50:41.444 --> 02:50:41.604
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Thank you.

1655
02:50:41.926 --> 02:50:53.721
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>When we follow leadership— when we follow the leadership of immigrant, refugee, undocumented, Black, and brown communities, and when we fund and put our money where it is in equity and engagement work rather than cutting it.

1656
02:50:55.430 --> 02:50:58.099
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>The resolution and ordinance before you are an important step forward.

1657
02:50:58.292 --> 02:51:00.947
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Resolutions set principles, ordinances make them enforceable.

1658
02:51:01.368 --> 02:51:11.625
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Together they form the foundation of a city that acts with compassion and accountability, ensuring noncooperation with ICE, protecting community members, from unlawful detainment and embedding clear accountability across bureaus.

1659
02:51:12.281 --> 02:51:17.378
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Lastly, my great-grandfather used to say, policy is only as strong as the details and the commitment behind it.

1660
02:51:17.809 --> 02:51:23.259
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>The difference between good leaders and bad leaders is whether we— they codify protections into law and stand behind them.

1661
02:51:23.658 --> 02:51:31.014
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>So I ask you today to please vote for both the resolution and the ordinance and stand around permanence, accountability, and lead with courage.

1662
02:51:31.352 --> 02:51:31.623
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Thank you.

1663
02:51:31.752 --> 02:51:32.634
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1664
02:51:34.733 --> 02:51:37.009
<v Salomee Chimuku>Good evening, Council President, members of the council.

1665
02:51:37.057 --> 02:51:38.434
<v Salomee Chimuku>My name is Salomee Chimuku.

1666
02:51:38.724 --> 02:51:43.708
<v Salomee Chimuku>I use she/her pronouns, and I am here in my capacity today as chair of the Multnomah County Democrats.

1667
02:51:44.253 --> 02:51:51.465
<v Salomee Chimuku>We urge that you support both the resolution and the ordinance because they work hand in hand together to make each other stronger.

1668
02:51:52.185 --> 02:51:56.145
<v Salomee Chimuku>As a personal note to myself, I am also a first-generation immigrant.

1669
02:51:56.209 --> 02:52:03.756
<v Salomee Chimuku>My parents both came here as political asylum refugees after a long 15 to 16 years in a refugee camp in Zambia.

1670
02:52:04.141 --> 02:52:10.895
<v Salomee Chimuku>When my family came to the United States, we understood very early on that your action, your existence is political.

1671
02:52:11.263 --> 02:52:13.013
<v Salomee Chimuku>There is no hiding behind ideas.

1672
02:52:13.060 --> 02:52:20.631
<v Salomee Chimuku>There is no putting your head down because when you are the way that you are and when you look the way that you look, you will be targeted from the very first day you take a breath.

1673
02:52:21.690 --> 02:52:38.345
<v Salomee Chimuku>I stand here proud as a Portlander who spent all of my life devoted to public service and to speaking up for those in my community as they are oftentimes marginalized, pushed aside, or just simply told to endure as others get to be comfortable.

1674
02:52:39.101 --> 02:52:52.007
<v Salomee Chimuku>I ask you today to make sure that as you're making these, uh, making these decisions, whether it be on the amendments or on the resolution or the ordinance, that you take a moment to reflect those in your life who are actually truly impacted by this legislation.

1675
02:52:52.746 --> 02:52:52.970
<v Salomee Chimuku>These—.

1676
02:52:53.084 --> 02:52:58.269
<v Salomee Chimuku>This legislation and others do a lot to show community that we are not standing just behind words.

1677
02:52:58.461 --> 02:53:06.265
<v Salomee Chimuku>But we are standing behind action, that we are putting into action the things that they are asking for, the things that they are looking for, the things that they have died over.

1678
02:53:06.650 --> 02:53:20.509
<v Salomee Chimuku>Because at the end of the day, when folks are just now waking up to the fascism that has been here in this country for as long as it's been here, we have already lost many immigrants, many folks of color, many women, many queer folks who have gone before us.

1679
02:53:21.183 --> 02:53:26.001
<v Salomee Chimuku>And I'm here to say that I'm happy that my county commissioner is bringing this to the county.

1680
02:53:26.387 --> 02:53:34.986
<v Salomee Chimuku>Because as we must know, our most vulnerable are actually our most resilient, because within them are the keys and the tools to survive something like this.

1681
02:53:35.469 --> 02:53:35.764
<v Salomee Chimuku>Thank you.

1682
02:53:37.064 --> 02:53:39.283
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you all very much.

1683
02:53:40.649 --> 02:53:41.996
<v Unidentified speaker>Rachelle is joining us online.

1684
02:53:50.229 --> 02:53:51.066
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>Good evening, Council.

1685
02:53:51.614 --> 02:53:52.920
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>My name is Rachelle Chase Miller.

1686
02:53:53.145 --> 02:54:02.092
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>I use she/her pronouns, and I'm a parent, an early childhood educator, and a member of the Portland Public Schools Board representing North and Northeast Portland.

1687
02:54:03.119 --> 02:54:08.947
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>In my career, I've worked with hundreds of children, each of them unique, but there were a few things each of them had in common.

1688
02:54:09.460 --> 02:54:16.734
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>Because despite differences in race, ethnicity, or ability, every child has to feel safe for their brains to be ready to learn.

1689
02:54:17.408 --> 02:54:22.272
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>Every child needs consistency and stability to help them regulate their bodies and emotions.

1690
02:54:23.028 --> 02:54:32.823
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>And every child needs the safety and security of a loving family to develop a strong sense of self, autonomy, and resiliency that will lay the foundation for all future growth and development.

1691
02:54:33.849 --> 02:54:38.272
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>Recently, a father from my community was kidnapped by ICE while taking his child to school.

1692
02:54:39.138 --> 02:54:46.799
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>The loss of a parent through forced separation creates waves of trauma that last for children's whole lives and ripple through subsequent generations.

1693
02:54:47.552 --> 02:55:02.127
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>In the plight of the immigrant families in our communities, we see echoes of the internment of Japanese American the separation of indigenous children from their families, communities, and cultures; the forced separation of Black families during slavery, and the brutality of slave patrols.

1694
02:55:03.105 --> 02:55:10.334
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>The persecution of our immigrant neighbors is another horrific chapter in a national national story written in the blood and tears of Black and brown people.

1695
02:55:11.298 --> 02:55:17.065
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>However, there are other chapters to our story: chapters of abolition, resistance, and liberation.

1696
02:55:17.979 --> 02:55:20.710
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>It is up to us to determine what chapter we are living in now.

1697
02:55:21.433 --> 02:55:33.171
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>By codifying our status as a sanctuary city, we have the opportunity to make a chapter that rejects our history of oppression and discrimination and prioritizes our shared humanity and the dignity we are all entitled to.

1698
02:55:33.861 --> 02:55:39.947
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>I urge the City Council and the mayor to support codifying our sanctuary city status and passing the Protect Portland resolution.

1699
02:55:40.620 --> 02:55:50.360
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>Making this commitment to our community is to live the world we want to see into existence, one where we take care of one another, respect the rights and dignity of all, and protect the most vulnerable.

1700
02:55:50.907 --> 02:55:52.049
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>This is how we resist.

1701
02:55:52.355 --> 02:55:53.176
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>This is how we survive.

1702
02:55:53.889 --> 02:55:54.986
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>Our diversity is our strength.

1703
02:55:55.050 --> 02:55:56.486
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>We're stronger together.

1704
02:55:57.020 --> 02:55:57.439
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>Thank you.

1705
02:56:01.327 --> 02:56:02.069
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1706
02:56:03.506 --> 02:56:17.474
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have Alex Reedlinger, Darren McCormick, Lydia Hodgins, Jamie Partridge and Jennifer Shook.

1707
02:56:22.500 --> 02:56:22.870
<v Unidentified speaker>Go right ahead.

1708
02:56:23.320 --> 02:56:33.177
<v Alex Friedlinger>All right, uh, Council President, uh, Pirtle-Guiney, Vice President, um, Koyama Lane, and councilors, for the record, my name is Alex Friedlinger and I am the child of immigrants.

1709
02:56:33.793 --> 02:56:40.097
<v Alex Friedlinger>I am here as a registered lobbyist representing the Coalition of Communities of Color and have been a resident of Portland for over 30 years.

1710
02:56:40.965 --> 02:56:47.198
<v Alex Friedlinger>I thank the council for proposing this ordinance and resolution and urge you to swiftly codify our city's sanctuary protections.

1711
02:56:47.855 --> 02:56:55.149
<v Alex Friedlinger>I also acknowledge the powerful testimony I anticipate hearing tonight from the community members, advocates, and attorneys working on the ground.

1712
02:56:56.066 --> 02:57:04.645
<v Alex Friedlinger>The Trump administration will always act in bad faith, forcing our city into binary choices that leave us morally compromised and materially worse off.

1713
02:57:05.222 --> 02:57:20.700
<v Alex Friedlinger>Given the nation's bifurcated justice system, and erosion of legal norms, it is imperative that we continue to demand greater transparency and accountability from local law enforcement in their management of protests and responses to attacks on our residents.

1714
02:57:21.405 --> 02:57:25.060
<v Alex Friedlinger>I believe that council is taking measures to address these concerns now.

1715
02:57:25.975 --> 02:57:35.179
<v Alex Friedlinger>Historically, the city and police bureau leaders have failed to adequately address misuse of force, prosecute offending officers, and implement meaningful accountability processes.

1716
02:57:35.274 --> 02:57:35.418
<v Alex Friedlinger>Thank you.

1717
02:57:36.174 --> 02:57:42.969
<v Alex Friedlinger>This failure has been most felt most deeply by Portland's Black community and its survivors and advocates, myself included.

1718
02:57:44.207 --> 02:57:46.552
<v Alex Friedlinger>The city and police bureau stand at crossroads.

1719
02:57:47.083 --> 02:57:52.978
<v Alex Friedlinger>How will you resist being drawn into this Kafkaesque crisis and fully embody, embody your oath to serve and protect?

1720
02:57:53.926 --> 02:57:57.156
<v Alex Friedlinger>A core question remains: protect what and serve whom?

1721
02:57:57.701 --> 02:58:06.128
<v Alex Friedlinger>Will it be federal property and the integrity of ICE operations, or those being harassed abducted from their communities and exercising their First Amendment rights?

1722
02:58:06.754 --> 02:58:12.587
<v Alex Friedlinger>How will you finally address the historically disparate application of justice in department policies and procedures?

1723
02:58:13.502 --> 02:58:22.237
<v Alex Friedlinger>While the mayor and chief of police intend to exercise restraint, resist federal demands, and protect our rights, further effort is required to build community trust.

1724
02:58:22.702 --> 02:58:32.438
<v Alex Friedlinger>We must devote resources to deconstructing any existing blue walls of silence, with the bureau meaningfully extending the practice of We protect our own to all residents of the city.

1725
02:58:34.647 --> 02:58:37.156
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your time.

1726
02:58:37.691 --> 02:58:40.425
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1727
02:58:41.024 --> 02:58:41.720
<v Unidentified speaker>Right ahead, Jamie.

1728
02:58:42.870 --> 02:58:43.501
<v Jamie Partridge>Oh, should I go ahead?

1729
02:58:44.117 --> 02:58:44.263
<v Jamie Partridge>Okay.

1730
02:58:45.396 --> 02:58:46.302
<v Jamie Partridge>Good evening, Council.

1731
02:58:47.014 --> 02:58:48.279
<v Jamie Partridge>My name is Jamie Partridge.

1732
02:58:48.940 --> 02:58:54.986
<v Jamie Partridge>I'm a member of the National Association of Letter Carriers, Branch 82, and a resident of District 2.

1733
02:58:56.352 --> 02:59:05.909
<v Jamie Partridge>My union has declared itself a sanctuary union, and we voted to support the codification of our sanctuary city status.

1734
02:59:08.402 --> 02:59:21.632
<v Jamie Partridge>Just a line from our resolution: We declare ourselves a sanctuary union that will protect the rights and safety of all our members, their families, and the communities we proudly serve, regardless of one's immigration status.

1735
02:59:22.036 --> 02:59:30.388
<v Jamie Partridge>We will not voluntarily cooperate with federal agents in the U.S. prosecution or attempted deportation of our members, their families, or our community members.

1736
02:59:31.311 --> 02:59:51.174
<v Jamie Partridge>We as letter carriers will immediately report ICE, DHS, or Customs and Border Patrol presence when we see it to the Portland Immigrant Rights Coalition hotline, 888-622-1510.

1737
02:59:51.271 --> 02:59:53.540
<v Jamie Partridge>As you know, mail carriers are on every street every day.

1738
02:59:53.621 --> 02:59:53.719
<v Jamie Partridge>Thank you.

1739
02:59:56.123 --> 02:59:59.058
<v Jamie Partridge>So we're a big set of eyes and ears.

1740
03:00:01.430 --> 03:00:05.823
<v Jamie Partridge>City workers are also on many streets and public places every day.

1741
03:00:06.227 --> 03:00:23.152
<v Jamie Partridge>We encourage the council to add to this ordinance to train and direct city workers to recognize and report any ICE, CPB, DHS presence to the Portland Immigrant Rights Coalition.

1742
03:00:26.287 --> 03:00:32.256
<v Jamie Partridge>And again, we urge the council to vote yes to codify our sanctuary city status.

1743
03:00:32.595 --> 03:00:33.014
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1744
03:00:35.709 --> 03:00:36.949
<v Unidentified speaker>Darren is joining us online.

1745
03:00:40.005 --> 03:00:41.094
<v Darren McCormick>I'm Darren McCormick.

1746
03:00:41.875 --> 03:00:44.134
<v Darren McCormick>I was born and raised in Portland.

1747
03:00:46.876 --> 03:00:53.620
<v Darren McCormick>Please stop labeling anything that you don't like as fascism and tyranny.

1748
03:00:54.745 --> 03:00:57.331
<v Darren McCormick>The government is not attacking Portland.

1749
03:00:58.343 --> 03:01:01.620
<v Darren McCormick>No one has been kidnapped by ICE.

1750
03:01:02.775 --> 03:01:09.585
<v Darren McCormick>This manipulative and extremist rhetoric contributes to political intolerance and radicalization.

1751
03:01:11.047 --> 03:01:18.626
<v Darren McCormick>We had an election And the country voted for the common-sense policy of deporting people who are not supposed to be here.

1752
03:01:19.460 --> 03:01:25.948
<v Darren McCormick>And this is hard maybe for you to understand, but ICE deportations are actually the moderate middle path.

1753
03:01:26.444 --> 03:01:31.198
<v Darren McCormick>They are the law and order off-ramp that helps avoid worse violence.

1754
03:01:32.161 --> 03:01:37.653
<v Darren McCormick>If you didn't want Trump to deploy the National Guard, you should have allowed the police to enforce the law.

1755
03:01:38.102 --> 03:01:40.540
<v Darren McCormick>And prevent illegal interference with ICE.

1756
03:01:41.534 --> 03:01:47.951
<v Darren McCormick>If the police needed more personnel to do this, you should have provided them more funding, but you didn't.

1757
03:01:48.049 --> 03:01:51.834
<v Darren McCormick>So you created the legal and moral justification for sending in the Guard.

1758
03:01:52.941 --> 03:02:11.655
<v Darren McCormick>And regarding sanctuary policies, if you oppose any cooperation at all with immigration law, if you oppose every single deportation, if you reject the distinction between legal and illegal immigrants, then you oppose our national borders and you oppose the country itself.

1759
03:02:13.067 --> 03:02:16.936
<v Darren McCormick>If that is your position, you should leave.

1760
03:02:17.177 --> 03:02:38.791
<v Darren McCormick>Instead of the mild secession that is complete sanctuary for illegals, I ask you to carve out a small exception so that when a person is convicted of a crime, their immigration status can be ascertained and make this one reasonable change and start to make Portland America again.

1761
03:02:41.961 --> 03:02:45.551
<v Unidentified speaker>Everybody remain respectful of other people who are testifying.

1762
03:02:46.468 --> 03:02:56.024
<v Unidentified speaker>While there may be people whose views we don't agree with, we still owe them respect as we listen to them the same way we do those whose views we do agree with.

1763
03:02:57.674 --> 03:03:00.182
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have Jennifer Shook joining us online.

1764
03:03:02.120 --> 03:03:03.540
<v Jennifer Shook>Hello, my name is Jennifer Shook.

1765
03:03:03.620 --> 03:03:12.932
<v Jennifer Shook>I'm a resident of District 2 in the Concordia neighborhood, and I'm testifying in favor of the Portland Protection Initiative and codifying the city's sanctuary policies.

1766
03:03:13.754 --> 03:03:15.432
<v Jennifer Shook>I love Portland so much.

1767
03:03:16.110 --> 03:03:30.365
<v Jennifer Shook>Since I moved here in 2014, I've seen advocates and activists take to the streets, show up at City Council and Planning Commission hearings, And gather together to host events envisioning how we can make Portland a better place for everyone.

1768
03:03:30.896 --> 03:03:46.606
<v Jennifer Shook>Right now, people in the highest levels of government are lying about our city, saying it is a war zone, a hellhole, that the people gathering and dancing and, yes, exercising their First Amendment rights by yelling at ICE agents are a criminal threat to our safety.

1769
03:03:46.943 --> 03:03:55.751
<v Jennifer Shook>In reality, ICE has demonstrated it is a far greater threat By kidnapping and threatening people with guns, tear gas, pepper spray, and other munitions.

1770
03:03:56.263 --> 03:04:00.240
<v Jennifer Shook>The idea that this could be escalated by a military presence is terrifying.

1771
03:04:00.978 --> 03:04:03.094
<v Jennifer Shook>I've been an anti-fascist my entire life.

1772
03:04:03.159 --> 03:04:17.078
<v Jennifer Shook>My grandparents, Holocaust survivors, were victims of fascism who lost everything and had the opportunity to start over here in the U.S., where they believed their children and grandchildren would have access to the freedoms they were denied.

1773
03:04:17.575 --> 03:04:25.421
<v Jennifer Shook>The people gathering in our streets who are bravely putting their bodies on the line to protect their community, our community, deserve protection.

1774
03:04:25.933 --> 03:04:36.297
<v Jennifer Shook>The immigrants in our community who are afraid to go to work or school or routine appointments or to testify publicly before the City Council deserve protection.

1775
03:04:36.344 --> 03:04:40.420
<v Jennifer Shook>Please pass these items and do so urgently.

1776
03:04:40.916 --> 03:04:41.768
<v Jennifer Shook>We cannot wait.

1777
03:04:42.281 --> 03:04:43.789
<v Jennifer Shook>We need to protect our community.

1778
03:04:44.143 --> 03:04:45.986
<v Jennifer Shook>From this senseless political violence.

1779
03:04:46.245 --> 03:04:46.648
<v Jennifer Shook>Thank you.

1780
03:04:50.288 --> 03:04:53.134
<v Unidentified speaker>Checking to see if Lydia Hodgins is here.

1781
03:04:57.209 --> 03:05:05.183
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, colleagues, it is 3 hours in.

1782
03:05:05.457 --> 03:05:11.287
<v Unidentified speaker>We are going to take a 10-minute recess so that our staff who are supporting this work can take a quick break.

1783
03:05:12.003 --> 03:05:16.208
<v Unidentified speaker>We have something like 60 more people signed up to testify.

1784
03:05:16.897 --> 03:05:19.481
<v Unidentified speaker>We will get to you all as soon as we get back.

1785
03:05:19.948 --> 03:05:23.847
<v Unidentified speaker>We are going to go on recess for 10 minutes and we'll be back here at 9:11.

1786
03:05:24.843 --> 03:05:27.025
<v Salomee Chimuku>No, this is the worst of us.

1787
03:05:27.331 --> 03:05:29.721
<v Unidentified speaker>No, no, it's not.

1788
03:05:29.898 --> 03:05:30.588
<v Rachelle Chase Miller>Exactly.

1789
03:05:31.567 --> 03:05:31.825
<v Jessica Maravilla>I work—.

1790
03:05:31.825 --> 03:05:33.397
<v Jessica Maravilla>Yeah, I work at 7:30.

1791
03:05:33.911 --> 03:05:36.141
<v Jessica Maravilla>Oh my God, that's not good.

1792
03:05:50.555 --> 03:05:53.512
<v Jessica Maravilla>Sorry, that's not too important to you, right?

1793
03:05:53.948 --> 03:05:55.305
<v Unidentified speaker>Stop working on your computer.

1794
03:05:55.629 --> 03:05:55.822
<v Keelan McClymont>I know.

1795
03:19:28.761 --> 03:19:30.269
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, welcome back.

1796
03:19:30.349 --> 03:19:35.932
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe as long as we have our colleagues online still here that we are at a quorum.

1797
03:19:36.460 --> 03:19:38.884
<v Unidentified speaker>There's councilors Clark and Ryan.

1798
03:19:38.948 --> 03:19:40.215
<v Unidentified speaker>Can we just get a thumbs up?

1799
03:19:42.336 --> 03:19:45.263
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, perfect.

1800
03:19:45.975 --> 03:19:47.623
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, we are at quorum.

1801
03:19:47.753 --> 03:19:50.566
<v Unidentified speaker>We are going to continue with public testimony.

1802
03:19:51.296 --> 03:20:00.852
<v Unidentified speaker>As a reminder, we had to cut testimony to 2 minutes a person so that we can get through everybody, hear from as many people in the community as possible.

1803
03:20:01.709 --> 03:20:08.335
<v Unidentified speaker>I will note a couple of people asked over the break, is it okay to come up to testify and say, I agree with what has been said?

1804
03:20:08.400 --> 03:20:09.500
<v Unidentified speaker>That is absolutely fine if you want to do that.

1805
03:20:09.548 --> 03:20:10.146
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1806
03:20:12.180 --> 03:20:13.621
<v Unidentified speaker>To keep your testimony short.

1807
03:20:15.032 --> 03:20:20.066
<v Unidentified speaker>I also will remind everybody that when you testify, come up, introduce yourself.

1808
03:20:20.146 --> 03:20:22.149
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't need broader information than that.

1809
03:20:22.550 --> 03:20:30.132
<v Unidentified speaker>Our clerk has everything they need from your signup, and as long as you introduce yourself, they'll know who you are and we can match the information that we need.

1810
03:20:30.709 --> 03:20:41.050
<v Unidentified speaker>That also helps us for folks who are listening to the recording or are using an e-reader to have, or that, that a reader, an electronic reader, To have your name stated for the record.

1811
03:20:41.713 --> 03:20:44.025
<v Unidentified speaker>And if you're a lobbyist, please identify that.

1812
03:20:44.138 --> 03:20:46.484
<v Unidentified speaker>But otherwise, we don't need any additional information.

1813
03:20:47.569 --> 03:20:51.373
<v Unidentified speaker>Keelan, could you please call up our next panel of public testimony?

1814
03:20:53.085 --> 03:21:05.584
<v Unidentified speaker>Andy Seaby, Eleanor Cassidy, Gabrielle Johnston, Leticia Navarro, Randall Blazak.

1815
03:21:06.586 --> 03:21:08.968
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead.

1816
03:21:18.899 --> 03:21:19.432
<v Unidentified speaker>Go right ahead.

1817
03:21:20.977 --> 03:21:22.009
<v Leticia Navarro>Hello, good evening.

1818
03:21:22.201 --> 03:21:23.539
<v Leticia Navarro>My name is Leticia Navarro.

1819
03:21:24.110 --> 03:21:31.388
<v Leticia Navarro>I am here to voice my support for the ordinance to codify sanctuary city status and the resolution to denounce military occupation.

1820
03:21:32.542 --> 03:21:44.807
<v Leticia Navarro>With the increased ICE activity and potential deployment of the National Guard, these are necessary first steps in protecting Portlanders, especially immigrants, from attacks from the federal government.

1821
03:21:45.689 --> 03:21:51.155
<v Leticia Navarro>I ask that the city introduces an emergency vote to approve these pieces of legislation tonight.

1822
03:21:51.781 --> 03:21:56.365
<v Leticia Navarro>We cannot wait any longer to stand up against Trump and his attacks on the people.

1823
03:21:56.510 --> 03:22:10.447
<v Leticia Navarro>Councilmember in addition, I believe a critical part of protecting Portlanders is that should be advanced immediately, is that to revoke the permit for the ICE facility at 4310 South McAdam Avenue.

1824
03:22:12.796 --> 03:22:20.028
<v Leticia Navarro>On October 4th, on Saturday, me and 6 organizers got detained by ICE.

1825
03:22:21.271 --> 03:22:24.316
<v Leticia Navarro>I spent 11 hours inside the facility.

1826
03:22:25.156 --> 03:22:33.653
<v Leticia Navarro>And even though we know how inhumane those conditions are to be in there, participating and living it is a complete different story.

1827
03:22:35.049 --> 03:22:45.103
<v Leticia Navarro>The way the cells are set up establishes the inhumane conditions, from the abuse and harassment that I faced, that I faced from the agents while I was in there.

1828
03:22:45.809 --> 03:22:51.238
<v Leticia Navarro>The temperature in those rooms are always cold, and there's only metal benches to lay on.

1829
03:22:52.298 --> 03:22:58.538
<v Leticia Navarro>The whole time I was in there, my heart broke for all the immigrants who have been there in that same cell.

1830
03:22:59.372 --> 03:23:02.388
<v Leticia Navarro>There were posters to self-deport yourself and your family.

1831
03:23:02.966 --> 03:23:13.699
<v Leticia Navarro>There were mocking posters of how detainees can contact their children and how DHS does not commit sexual abuse, both of which we know are false and a slap in the face to whoever reads them.

1832
03:23:14.516 --> 03:23:17.629
<v Leticia Navarro>I was thinking of all the individuals who have been in that facility.

1833
03:23:18.052 --> 03:23:21.814
<v Leticia Navarro>Especially the one that has been in the facility for 47 days.

1834
03:23:22.476 --> 03:23:25.849
<v Leticia Navarro>I could not imagine how they were able to survive in those conditions.

1835
03:23:26.610 --> 03:23:33.690
<v Leticia Navarro>My heart shatters for them and my soul gets anger, and I am here to approve of the conditions that got posted.

1836
03:23:34.141 --> 03:23:34.335
<v Maria Hernandez Segoviano>Thank you.

1837
03:23:34.450 --> 03:23:35.123
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1838
03:23:36.810 --> 03:23:37.197
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1839
03:23:37.599 --> 03:23:39.527
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, good evening, Mayor and Council.

1840
03:23:39.622 --> 03:23:40.924
<v Randall Blazak>My name is Dr. Randall Blazak.

1841
03:23:40.988 --> 03:23:50.038
<v Randall Blazak>I'm the co-founder of Cure PNW that was started by a federal grant from the Biden administration to find community-based ways to interrupt political violence.

1842
03:23:50.583 --> 03:23:54.174
<v Randall Blazak>That grant was canceled in February by the current administration.

1843
03:23:54.222 --> 03:23:55.217
<v Randall Blazak>Surprise, surprise.

1844
03:23:55.889 --> 03:24:00.861
<v Randall Blazak>But we managed to find local funding through the Jubitz Family Foundation and are doing this work.

1845
03:24:01.245 --> 03:24:10.978
<v Randall Blazak>I have been down at the ICE facility monthly and now weekly and now nightly, both documenting and doing some de-escalation work.

1846
03:24:11.123 --> 03:24:14.218
<v Randall Blazak>We did a training with the community members and the activists back in August.

1847
03:24:14.282 --> 03:24:14.586
<v Jamie Partridge>Thank you.

1848
03:24:15.036 --> 03:24:19.234
<v Randall Blazak>We had a lunch gathering where they could sort of share each other's concerns and learn each other's issues.

1849
03:24:19.298 --> 03:24:22.743
<v Randall Blazak>We did a de-escalation training for activists last Sunday.

1850
03:24:23.208 --> 03:24:28.992
<v Randall Blazak>And the dynamic down there is very complex, but there is all kinds of good work being done.

1851
03:24:29.313 --> 03:24:36.315
<v Randall Blazak>There's been good work to de-escalate the tensions that are there and not give President Trump his narrative that Portland is a war-torn hellhole.

1852
03:24:37.004 --> 03:24:41.635
<v Randall Blazak>That work is done by trained de-escalators who are down there, myself and other people.

1853
03:24:41.683 --> 03:24:41.810
<v Randall Blazak>Thank you.

1854
03:24:42.195 --> 03:24:45.465
<v Randall Blazak>It's done by the DLO, the Dialogue Liaison Officers.

1855
03:24:45.560 --> 03:24:52.324
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, I think we learned a lot about how to police protests in 2020, and the DLOs have played a crucial role in keeping the peace down there.

1856
03:24:52.388 --> 03:24:55.801
<v Unidentified speaker>But the majority of the de-escalation is from the protesters themselves.

1857
03:24:56.315 --> 03:25:06.091
<v Unidentified speaker>They have been courageous and it just impressed me to no end, their ability to have restraint, but also find the hotspots and calm those hotspots down.

1858
03:25:06.251 --> 03:25:08.510
<v Unidentified speaker>Again, preventing the escalation from happening.

1859
03:25:09.055 --> 03:25:12.676
<v Unidentified speaker>That includes a gentleman that's probably here dressed as a chicken.

1860
03:25:12.725 --> 03:25:12.789
<v Randall Blazak>Yes.

1861
03:25:13.061 --> 03:25:21.097
<v Unidentified speaker>But that dynamic has changed recently because the MAGA folks have showed up because of the rhetoric from the president and the tension has gone up.

1862
03:25:21.162 --> 03:25:24.112
<v Unidentified speaker>Those folks are largely from outta town and from outta state.

1863
03:25:24.450 --> 03:25:28.668
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we are seeing a new dynamic down there where it's harder and harder to deescalate.

1864
03:25:28.717 --> 03:25:31.075
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's why what you're doing is so important.

1865
03:25:31.122 --> 03:25:40.682
<v Unidentified speaker>But I also, on behalf of the women who are on the forefront of this movement and the indigenous people who've been down there fighting, also think about removing this cancer from our city.

1866
03:25:40.730 --> 03:25:40.954
<v Randall Blazak>Thank you.

1867
03:25:41.375 --> 03:25:46.935
<v Unidentified speaker>Removing this ICE facility and taking away the thing that drives that conflict to begin with.

1868
03:25:47.129 --> 03:25:47.810
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1869
03:25:49.579 --> 03:25:50.225
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1870
03:25:50.822 --> 03:25:52.581
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, let's make sure.

1871
03:25:52.677 --> 03:26:17.890
<v Unidentified speaker>Andy Seaby, Eleanor Cassidy, Gabrielle Johnston, Destiny Magaña, Magaña Pablo, Nathan Williams, Liz Kay, Anne Casper, Carlos Covarrubias.

1872
03:26:19.389 --> 03:26:25.618
<v Unidentified speaker>Go right ahead.

1873
03:26:26.067 --> 03:26:32.123
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, um, good evening, councilors, mayor, and specifically Council President Pirtle-Guiney.

1874
03:26:32.256 --> 03:26:32.406
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1875
03:26:32.520 --> 03:26:32.841
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1876
03:26:33.177 --> 03:26:41.290
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, for the record, my parents immigrated to the United States, found each other in Oregon, and welcomed me into this world at OHSU.

1877
03:26:41.772 --> 03:26:43.796
<v Unidentified speaker>They gave me the name Destiny Magaña Pablo.

1878
03:26:44.439 --> 03:27:01.189
<v Unidentified speaker>Today I stand before you as a 26-year-old woman, only a few— sorry, I might cry— only a few years older than they were when our small family was formed, and also terrified after hearing what is happening in Gresham only a few minutes away from my home.

1879
03:27:03.198 --> 03:27:06.440
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, recently I was described as, quote, very compliant.

1880
03:27:07.278 --> 03:27:11.859
<v Unidentified speaker>It hurt as if they were describing a dog, but then I thought about my childhood again.

1881
03:27:12.547 --> 03:27:13.465
<v Unidentified speaker>Apologies for the tears.

1882
03:27:16.430 --> 03:27:21.828
<v Unidentified speaker>My family experienced federal swatting and raids when I was in elementary school.

1883
03:27:23.638 --> 03:27:32.561
<v Unidentified speaker>I lost my father to the prison industrial complex And eventually he was deported, and along with him, my sense of safety and protection.

1884
03:27:33.861 --> 03:27:37.908
<v Unidentified speaker>I lost my father— my mother, sorry again— to the workforce.

1885
03:27:38.679 --> 03:27:47.896
<v Unidentified speaker>I lost the chance to build healthy and critical relationships with my grandparents, aunts, and cousins.

1886
03:27:48.635 --> 03:27:50.947
<v Unidentified speaker>Effectively, I lost my childhood.

1887
03:27:53.465 --> 03:27:54.090
<v Unidentified speaker>I share this.

1888
03:27:54.570 --> 03:28:01.960
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, instead, I was forced to experience metal detectors, handcuffs, and body searches as a young child.

1889
03:28:02.682 --> 03:28:08.806
<v Unidentified speaker>I developed a deep and constant fear of loss, pain, of violence and separation.

1890
03:28:09.639 --> 03:28:17.718
<v Unidentified speaker>My broken family fell into extreme poverty, which deeply affected my development and access to education, health, and personal freedom.

1891
03:28:18.697 --> 03:28:29.820
<v Unidentified speaker>I share this difficult and deeply personal experience because too often and historically, this council body and those who engage with it do not reflect me or my family.

1892
03:28:30.799 --> 03:28:37.915
<v Unidentified speaker>Those who protest and put their bodies on the line often do not carry the lifelong sentence of separation that my family does.

1893
03:28:38.748 --> 03:28:40.063
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know if that's the second one.

1894
03:28:41.393 --> 03:28:45.849
<v Unidentified speaker>It is, but if you need a few seconds more, I know you have to take a pause.

1895
03:28:46.041 --> 03:28:53.835
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a proud Portlander, a homeowner, and a kind stranger who wants to protect other families and children from similar harm.

1896
03:28:54.604 --> 03:29:13.063
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate and urge the full council to codify Portland's sanctuary status, to denounce and reject unconstitutional violence and overreach by the federal government directed at both undocumented and documented immigrants and refugees, and to strengthen safety for Portlanders and Oregonians through the thank you.

1897
03:29:14.200 --> 03:29:17.119
<v Unidentified speaker>Nathan Williams.

1898
03:29:18.416 --> 03:29:24.332
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here not representing my organization, but in solidarity with my friend Destiny.

1899
03:29:24.908 --> 03:29:26.545
<v Unidentified speaker>Here, right?

1900
03:29:26.704 --> 03:29:26.913
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1901
03:29:27.074 --> 03:29:37.189
<v Unidentified speaker>I also urge you to push your bravery and leadership even more at this time by setting a standard of justice and responsible use of governmental power, one that other cities, counties, and states can model.

1902
03:29:37.573 --> 03:30:02.272
<v Unidentified speaker>I urge you to include visitors in the ordinance that directs the city to create and implement a centralized and coordinated work groups to inform best practices and recommendations related to federal immigration enforcement impacts on staff and the community, including employee safety and accommodations, interactions with federal immigration enforcement agents, and protecting the dignity and constitutional rights of City of Portland residents.

1903
03:30:02.592 --> 03:30:25.626
<v Unidentified speaker>And throughout 2025-401's resolution language, when explicit— explicitly stating residents, Portland city limits include embassies such as the Mexican Embassy, and the only actively operating USCIS office in the state of Oregon, which serves immigrant and refugee residents across the states from different counties and cities, even including some Washingtonians.

1904
03:30:25.787 --> 03:30:38.566
<v Unidentified speaker>It would be negligent for our city to ignore the documented and undocumented immigrants, refugees, and their families who visit, reside in, and serve Portland, and who rely on access to essential services, resources, and public space.

1905
03:30:39.161 --> 03:30:54.177
<v Unidentified speaker>I also encourage the city to offer and share all best practice training, policies, and educational campaign materials with counties throughout Oregon, since immigrant and refugee residents and families from all 4 corners of the state visit our city for their personal needs.

1906
03:30:54.658 --> 03:31:06.738
<v Unidentified speaker>I strongly urge the city to specifically seek the feedback and recommendations from the people most impacted and protected by your sanctuary status, the Oregonians who build and make up our neighborhoods, business economy, and safety.

1907
03:31:07.156 --> 03:31:15.649
<v Unidentified speaker>Finally, I also demand the city consistently identify and respond To misinformation explicitly targeting Portland, as it can be used to harm our families and neighbors.

1908
03:31:15.746 --> 03:31:24.327
<v Unidentified speaker>Furthermore, encouraging such responses be done in coordination with neighboring counties, the state, and appropriate governmental and public agencies.

1909
03:31:24.504 --> 03:31:31.140
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for using your governmental power to better represent and protect our immigrant and refugee communities who are often systematically disenfranchised.

1910
03:31:31.575 --> 03:31:31.751
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1911
03:31:31.832 --> 03:31:32.602
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you both.

1912
03:31:39.766 --> 03:31:40.233
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening.

1913
03:31:40.569 --> 03:31:42.674
<v Unidentified speaker>I am a member of District 1 here in Portland.

1914
03:31:43.236 --> 03:31:51.152
<v Unidentified speaker>I did not have much time to prepare for this testimony because attacks on our city by ICE this week are the worst they've ever been, and today was the worst of all.

1915
03:31:52.067 --> 03:32:00.064
<v Unidentified speaker>Just today, for the first time that I know of this year, our community witnessed a GeoBus entering the McAdam facility around 4:22 PM this afternoon.

1916
03:32:00.643 --> 03:32:10.581
<v Unidentified speaker>Usually the transport vehicles coming into the facility are GeoVans, vehicles that can potentially transport a small number of about 6 people to the concentration camp in Tacoma, Washington.

1917
03:32:11.112 --> 03:32:16.453
<v Unidentified speaker>However, a Geo bus can potentially hold around 30 passengers or more.

1918
03:32:29.663 --> 03:32:35.298
<v Liz Kay>Although I am grateful to the city councilors who helped bring this sanctuary ordinance forward, I am worried it will not be enough.

1919
03:32:35.860 --> 03:32:42.572
<v Liz Kay>I ask all city— I ask all councilors to please do everything you can to protect our neighbors.

1920
03:32:43.149 --> 03:32:47.215
<v Liz Kay>And I see Mayor Wilson is here too, so please help.

1921
03:32:49.094 --> 03:32:54.529
<v Liz Kay>This includes voting yes to pass the resolution and codify sanctuary status in our city.

1922
03:32:56.915 --> 03:33:06.609
<v Liz Kay>I want to also make clear that I do not support Councilor Smith's amendment to remove the Freedom of Information Act requests in the sanctuary ordinance.

1923
03:33:07.300 --> 03:33:14.200
<v Liz Kay>How can our city hope to efficiently respond to ICE in our community if city leadership does not have All of the information possible.

1924
03:33:14.826 --> 03:33:18.888
<v Liz Kay>I hope you will rescind this amendment to grant added transparency and security to our city.

1925
03:33:19.788 --> 03:33:27.720
<v Liz Kay>I would also like to reiterate to the whole council that an annual report from city police on sanctuary exemptions is not sufficient to keep our neighbors safe.

1926
03:33:28.636 --> 03:33:37.243
<v Liz Kay>Please amend that an exemption report is completed at least quarterly, if not monthly, to ensure state police are watched closely and justice can be swift when they break sanctuary law.

1927
03:33:37.933 --> 03:33:42.990
<v Liz Kay>We have seen them historically and presently break many other laws and violate human rights.

1928
03:33:43.087 --> 03:33:43.183
<v Matt Levine>Thank you.

1929
03:33:43.394 --> 03:33:46.038
<v Liz Kay>Again, thank you for all of your work and vote yes.

1930
03:33:47.058 --> 03:33:49.864
<v Keith Wilson>And could you please identify yourself so that we have that on the record?

1931
03:33:51.593 --> 03:33:52.094
<v Keith Wilson>Your name.

1932
03:33:52.563 --> 03:33:52.967
<v Liz Kay>Liz Kay.

1933
03:33:53.370 --> 03:33:53.743
<v Holly Brown>Thank you.

1934
03:33:57.549 --> 03:34:09.774
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, Anne Casper, Carlos Cavar-Rubias, Camacia Denson.

1935
03:34:11.885 --> 03:34:15.253
<v Keelan McClymont>Minister Nathan Jimenez.

1936
03:34:18.843 --> 03:34:19.863
<v Keelan McClymont>Kathleen Hannan.

1937
03:34:22.856 --> 03:34:23.420
<v Keelan McClymont>Holly Brown.

1938
03:34:33.254 --> 03:34:33.643
<v William Hare>Go ahead.

1939
03:34:34.308 --> 03:34:34.907
<v Holly Brown>You want me to go first?

1940
03:34:35.281 --> 03:34:35.540
<v Ross Taylor>Okay.

1941
03:34:37.593 --> 03:34:39.100
<v Holly Brown>Hello, Council.

1942
03:34:39.147 --> 03:34:40.221
<v Holly Brown>My name is Holly Brown.

1943
03:34:40.317 --> 03:34:46.184
<v Holly Brown>I'm a part of Portland Contra las Deportaciones, Portland Against Deportations, and also Revoke the ICE Permit PDX.

1944
03:34:46.825 --> 03:34:51.105
<v Holly Brown>I want to voice my support for the Protect Portland resolution and the sanctuary city codification.

1945
03:34:51.635 --> 03:35:00.290
<v Holly Brown>With increased attacks on our community, it is extremely important that the city takes all emergency actions it possibly can to provide protections for immigrants and Portlanders alike.

1946
03:35:01.156 --> 03:35:04.235
<v Holly Brown>I hope that the Council takes an emergency vote on these items tonight to Please.

1947
03:35:04.299 --> 03:35:08.584
<v Holly Brown>I urge the council to pass them as we need to be aggressive in our approach in fighting back against the Trump administration.

1948
03:35:09.353 --> 03:35:11.728
<v Holly Brown>I also want to support the city doing FOIA requests.

1949
03:35:11.906 --> 03:35:15.420
<v Holly Brown>This is extremely important and has helped us in our campaign to shut down the ICE facility.

1950
03:35:16.880 --> 03:35:30.745
<v Holly Brown>I myself was tackled by DHS and ICE 2 weekends ago, dragged across the concrete— I still have wounds— and held inside the facility for hours while other friends detained that day who already spoke were sent to a jail in another county.

1951
03:35:31.404 --> 03:35:34.359
<v Holly Brown>I now face federal charges for peacefully protesting outside of ICE.

1952
03:35:35.738 --> 03:35:41.005
<v Holly Brown>I am upset because we have been asking for months for that building to be shut down, and it led to that the other day.

1953
03:35:41.054 --> 03:35:43.350
<v Holly Brown>And there's so many others who have been harmed by that building.

1954
03:35:44.425 --> 03:35:48.326
<v Holly Brown>We really need this— the city to start treating this as the emergency that it is.

1955
03:35:48.986 --> 03:35:56.595
<v Holly Brown>And today, as someone else mentioned, we saw a huge bus entering the ICE facility, and ICE activity has drastically increased in Portland over the last few days.

1956
03:35:57.189 --> 03:35:58.038
<v Holly Brown>We cannot wait.

1957
03:35:58.230 --> 03:35:59.111
<v Holly Brown>We seriously cannot.

1958
03:35:59.432 --> 03:36:02.252
<v Holly Brown>And we must go even further than these 2 pieces of legislation.

1959
03:36:03.102 --> 03:36:10.055
<v Holly Brown>That is why I'm urging that the City Council vote yes on these pieces of legislation and also goes further and revokes the permit for the ICE facility.

1960
03:36:10.567 --> 03:36:11.770
<v Holly Brown>I am terrified for immigrants.

1961
03:36:11.850 --> 03:36:13.180
<v Holly Brown>I am terrified for Portland.

1962
03:36:13.371 --> 03:36:14.590
<v Holly Brown>The people are strong together.

1963
03:36:15.038 --> 03:36:18.307
<v Holly Brown>That facility is a hub for ICE activity, and we have the power to shut it down.

1964
03:36:18.418 --> 03:36:21.783
<v Holly Brown>I was very glad to hear the mayor say that the city could take over that lease.

1965
03:36:21.847 --> 03:36:24.716
<v Holly Brown>I think that's a great idea, and we need to look into everything we possibly can.

1966
03:36:24.780 --> 03:36:24.987
<v Kerry Ko>Thank you.

1967
03:36:25.245 --> 03:36:26.179
<v Holly Brown>To shut it down.

1968
03:36:26.581 --> 03:36:30.075
<v Holly Brown>Um, and I also, yeah, really want to encourage that we take an emergency vote tonight.

1969
03:36:30.122 --> 03:36:31.878
<v Holly Brown>We need to move these things forward ASAP.

1970
03:36:32.150 --> 03:36:33.986
<v Holly Brown>The situation is so, so urgent.

1971
03:36:34.227 --> 03:36:35.477
<v Holly Brown>So please, let's vote on this tonight.

1972
03:36:35.545 --> 03:36:36.541
<v Holly Brown>Let's shut down that facility.

1973
03:36:38.197 --> 03:36:39.027
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you very much.

1974
03:36:40.798 --> 03:36:41.834
<v Kathleen Hannan>I'm Kathleen Hannan.

1975
03:36:42.658 --> 03:36:46.138
<v Kathleen Hannan>I come before you and Mayor Wilson today with a full heart.

1976
03:36:46.881 --> 03:36:56.288
<v Kathleen Hannan>I came to thank all of you so very much for your principles and courageous words and actions taken on our behalf in the last few weeks.

1977
03:36:57.572 --> 03:37:19.884
<v Kathleen Hannan>Back on January 2nd of this year, you boarded the enterprise all shiny and new, rising to your leadership roles, finding an agenda and allies, and at the same time charting a new form of governance in Portland, one dedicated to the principles of equity and recognition that an expanded people's table is a richer and better table.

1978
03:37:20.831 --> 03:37:25.859
<v Kathleen Hannan>Now, 10 months later, you're all still shiny and new, a most beautiful body.

1979
03:37:26.533 --> 03:37:33.072
<v Kathleen Hannan>You started with buses, rivers, and pipes, pipes and parks and police, which all still needs attention.

1980
03:37:33.682 --> 03:37:37.826
<v Kathleen Hannan>That work needs to get done, and again, so proudly it is.

1981
03:37:38.565 --> 03:37:39.754
<v Kathleen Hannan>Thanks, city workers.

1982
03:37:40.895 --> 03:37:50.782
<v Kathleen Hannan>When the federal government began to call out and verbally attack our beloved Portland, Mayor Keith Wilson, well, Let's just say I don't call him Ted Lasso anymore.

1983
03:37:51.327 --> 03:37:54.037
<v Kathleen Hannan>He's tough, brave, and strong.

1984
03:37:55.367 --> 03:37:55.912
<v Tyler Fellini>So is Ted Lasso.

1985
03:37:55.976 --> 03:37:57.739
<v Kathleen Hannan>He's our elected leader.

1986
03:37:58.700 --> 03:38:00.208
<v Kathleen Hannan>The feds are telling a story.

1987
03:38:00.575 --> 03:38:01.538
<v Kathleen Hannan>It's a narrative.

1988
03:38:01.779 --> 03:38:02.243
<v Kathleen Hannan>It's a lie.

1989
03:38:02.884 --> 03:38:08.430
<v Kathleen Hannan>They think if they keep saying it day after day that it will be true, that others across the country will believe it.

1990
03:38:08.735 --> 03:38:14.792
<v Kathleen Hannan>We all know Portland is not war-ravaged, disgusting, burned-down place where most all stores are gone.

1991
03:38:15.082 --> 03:38:16.283
<v Kathleen Hannan>It's simply not true.

1992
03:38:16.972 --> 03:38:19.688
<v Kathleen Hannan>With courage, you could flip the narrative.

1993
03:38:20.843 --> 03:38:32.504
<v Kathleen Hannan>I do hope in the days to come, with time running out, that the Portland— those of us already pushing back, that the business leaders here will stand up and support us.

1994
03:38:32.969 --> 03:38:33.886
<v Kathleen Hannan>Where are they now?

1995
03:38:35.121 --> 03:38:36.471
<v Kathleen Hannan>Just as we need them.

1996
03:38:36.727 --> 03:38:39.265
<v Kathleen Hannan>We need a broad and united front in order to win.

1997
03:38:39.619 --> 03:38:46.152
<v Kathleen Hannan>Students, business, labor, seniors, religious groups, Altogether, Trump's message is just not true.

1998
03:38:46.601 --> 03:38:48.060
<v Kathleen Hannan>We don't need federal troops.

1999
03:38:48.301 --> 03:38:49.777
<v Kathleen Hannan>We have our own capable police.

2000
03:38:50.227 --> 03:38:52.681
<v Kathleen Hannan>We want to and can govern ourselves.

2001
03:38:53.113 --> 03:38:56.691
<v Kathleen Hannan>We voted for you, our amazing, brave local leaders.

2002
03:38:57.188 --> 03:38:58.005
<v Kathleen Hannan>We elected you.

2003
03:38:58.567 --> 03:38:59.386
<v Kathleen Hannan>We support you.

2004
03:38:59.593 --> 03:39:00.844
<v Kathleen Hannan>One Portland, one people.

2005
03:39:01.295 --> 03:39:02.626
<v Kathleen Hannan>I support the resolution.

2006
03:39:03.443 --> 03:39:04.342
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you very much.

2007
03:39:04.422 --> 03:39:05.640
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for being here today.

2008
03:39:06.603 --> 03:39:10.438
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, let's check to see if—.

2009
03:39:10.920 --> 03:39:12.183
<v Kathleen Hannan>Camacia Denson.

2010
03:39:14.162 --> 03:39:15.993
<v Keelan McClymont>Minister Nathan Jimenez.

2011
03:39:18.586 --> 03:39:19.558
<v Karen Shirai>Jack Dickinson.

2012
03:39:21.290 --> 03:39:22.278
<v Karen Shirai>Carrie Ko.

2013
03:39:24.772 --> 03:39:26.001
<v Karen Shirai>Cole Donahue.

2014
03:39:28.245 --> 03:39:29.859
<v Keelan McClymont>Isabella Shepherd.

2015
03:39:36.740 --> 03:39:37.691
<v Isabella Shepherd>All right, my name for the record—.

2016
03:39:37.708 --> 03:39:38.255
<v Jack Dickinson>Oh, sorry.

2017
03:39:38.900 --> 03:39:39.449
<v Isabella Shepherd>Go right ahead.

2018
03:39:39.965 --> 03:39:41.625
<v Jack Dickinson>My name for the record is Jack Dickinson.

2019
03:39:41.963 --> 03:39:43.075
<v Jack Dickinson>I'll start with the codification.

2020
03:39:43.977 --> 03:39:45.927
<v Jack Dickinson>I testified on this item when it was in committee.

2021
03:39:46.269 --> 03:39:47.927
<v Jack Dickinson>I maintain my support for this.

2022
03:39:48.074 --> 03:39:50.105
<v Jack Dickinson>Onto the denunciation.

2023
03:39:51.670 --> 03:39:59.558
<v Jack Dickinson>The only thing I have to say to this one is finally, finally, this is the kind of direction we need to be taking in response to this moment.

2024
03:39:59.800 --> 03:40:02.399
<v Jack Dickinson>And it's something that I think a lot of us have been begging for for a while.

2025
03:40:03.435 --> 03:40:06.252
<v Jack Dickinson>I support both agenda items and ask that they are voted on as emergency measures tonight.

2026
03:40:08.924 --> 03:40:14.760
<v Jack Dickinson>I also wanna talk about kind of 3 additional actions that follow in the spirit of the PPI.

2027
03:40:16.279 --> 03:40:18.637
<v Jack Dickinson>2 Are medium-term outlooks.

2028
03:40:19.266 --> 03:40:28.947
<v Jack Dickinson>One, I think the city should explore any and all possible avenues for a defamation lawsuit against Fox News for their continued lies, intentional lies about our city.

2029
03:40:29.934 --> 03:40:41.683
<v Jack Dickinson>I would also like to see the city consider a halt of purchases from Texas, Or Texas-based entities, or any other states that think it is acceptable to send their troops into our streets against our will.

2030
03:40:43.529 --> 03:40:46.245
<v Jack Dickinson>There's one urgent issue though that I want to talk about.

2031
03:40:46.904 --> 03:40:47.691
<v Jack Dickinson>That's tomorrow.

2032
03:40:48.591 --> 03:40:53.495
<v Jack Dickinson>The Design Commission will hold a hearing on the renovations to the Centennial Mills site.

2033
03:40:54.768 --> 03:41:00.971
<v Jack Dickinson>It has recently come to light that the LLC given rights to develop may have been a front for Stewart Lindquist.

2034
03:41:02.204 --> 03:41:06.844
<v Jack Dickinson>Lindquist is the landowner of the ICE facility and is a habitual violator of our laws.

2035
03:41:07.840 --> 03:41:14.470
<v Jack Dickinson>Now, I am of the belief that Lindquist should not be given another square inch of land in Portland, given his track record.

2036
03:41:15.065 --> 03:41:17.120
<v Jack Dickinson>God knows he misuses enough of it already.

2037
03:41:17.954 --> 03:41:27.603
<v Jack Dickinson>But all I am asking for today is that all of you use your platform to advocate for a delay in that approval until we can get answers on Lindquist's involvement and plans.

2038
03:41:27.667 --> 03:41:27.811
<v Ricky King>Thank you.

2039
03:41:28.456 --> 03:41:32.287
<v Jack Dickinson>We cannot just rubber stamp this and hope that it won't come back to bite us.

2040
03:41:32.737 --> 03:41:34.668
<v Jack Dickinson>The hearing for that is tomorrow at 1:30.

2041
03:41:34.911 --> 03:41:35.635
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

2042
03:41:40.013 --> 03:41:42.657
<v Kerry Ko>Hello, Council, Mayor.

2043
03:41:42.707 --> 03:41:43.593
<v Kerry Ko>My name's Kerry Ko.

2044
03:41:43.899 --> 03:41:46.028
<v Kerry Ko>I am an employee here at the City of Portland.

2045
03:41:46.075 --> 03:41:57.769
<v Kerry Ko>I'm also the president of the City of Portland Professional Workers Union, CPPW, and I'm speaking in support of these 2 items and on behalf of the 800 members that are in our union who know that what happens in our community happens to our members.

2046
03:41:59.399 --> 03:42:08.838
<v Kerry Ko>The current federal program to target, terrorize, and kidnap immigrants and citizens in our communities is not just an injustice requiring solidarity from our union.

2047
03:42:09.336 --> 03:42:13.495
<v Kerry Ko>This is an aggression that directly impacts CPPW members and our families.

2048
03:42:14.329 --> 03:42:21.698
<v Kerry Ko>When the threat is roaming our streets, as our employer, you're doing the right thing to make our workplaces as safe and secure as possible.

2049
03:42:22.340 --> 03:42:25.935
<v Kerry Ko>Our members deserve a workplace with clear and consistent protections.

2050
03:42:26.225 --> 03:42:49.581
<v Kerry Ko>Some of the things that I'm hearing from our members right now are about giving employees the training that we need on when and how to say no, to not comply in advance with federal agents, being protected from discipline if we refuse to provide information to agents or allow ICE into our workplaces, requiring the bureaus to put a safety plan in place for our members who work in the field by themselves all day long.

2051
03:42:50.655 --> 03:43:03.222
<v Kerry Ko>Not only are our members and their families being terrorized by the actions of ICE in our community, but the actions of ICE are mirroring the kinds authoritarian tactics that are often used against organized labor and social movements.

2052
03:43:03.736 --> 03:43:05.899
<v Kerry Ko>Our struggles are inextricably linked.

2053
03:43:06.750 --> 03:43:17.154
<v Kerry Ko>In our first contract, our members prioritize fighting for language that protects paid time for members to deal with tribal citizenship and immigration status for themselves and for their families.

2054
03:43:17.826 --> 03:43:24.652
<v Kerry Ko>We know that nice thoughts and good intentions are not enough, but enshrining enforceable protections is the only option.

2055
03:43:26.027 --> 03:43:34.434
<v Kerry Ko>So we will continue to push for more enforceable protections and see this ordinance as an aligned and important step towards a city where our members can safely live, work, and play.

2056
03:43:34.887 --> 03:43:35.097
<v Kerry Ko>Thank you.

2057
03:43:38.887 --> 03:43:39.359
<v Cole Donahue>Hello, Council.

2058
03:43:39.407 --> 03:43:40.985
<v Cole Donahue>My name is Cole Donahue, for the record.

2059
03:43:41.763 --> 03:43:52.897
<v Cole Donahue>I'm in support of both items 6 and 7, as I believe them to both be steps in the right direction when it comes to legislative resistance to the abhorrent actions of ICE ICE, DHS, and the Trump administration as a whole.

2060
03:43:53.554 --> 03:43:58.266
<v Cole Donahue>I call upon the council to take an emergency vote tonight and put these items into action as soon as possible.

2061
03:43:58.763 --> 03:44:04.888
<v Cole Donahue>With the looming deployment of the National Guard and increased federal activity in recent weeks, this is an emergency, and I thank the councilors who put these forth.

2062
03:44:06.058 --> 03:44:12.165
<v Cole Donahue>In addition to these resolutions, I'm imploring the council and mayor to do all you can to revoke the permit for the Portland ICE facility.

2063
03:44:12.790 --> 03:44:16.685
<v Cole Donahue>I support the mayor's recent suggestion to take over the lease of the building in order to remove ICE.

2064
03:44:17.359 --> 03:44:21.717
<v Cole Donahue>The council must do all it can to speed up the process of revoking the permit and shutting that facility down.

2065
03:44:22.950 --> 03:44:28.013
<v Cole Donahue>Trump is ordering so much terror to be inflicted on Portland precisely because he sees us as a credible threat to ICE.

2066
03:44:28.575 --> 03:44:32.629
<v Cole Donahue>Now is the time to play the leading role as a city in fighting back and kicking ICE out of our communities.

2067
03:44:34.022 --> 03:44:36.361
<v Cole Donahue>Additionally, I have a question regarding agenda item 6.

2068
03:44:36.970 --> 03:44:58.159
<v Cole Donahue>There is a section that, among other things, prohibits Portland police from assisting in or coordinating with federal agencies and the military in actions intended to suppress On the afternoon of October 12th, PPB aggressively corralled hundreds of protesters onto the sidewalks in front of and around the ICE facility, separating the assembled crowd into several smaller sections that were more difficult to travel between.

2069
03:44:58.849 --> 03:45:03.513
<v Cole Donahue>ICE and DHS have been very prone to violently forcing protesters away from the area in front of the ICE driveway.

2070
03:45:04.218 --> 03:45:18.028
<v Cole Donahue>If DHS had stormed through the gate while PPB was corralling protesters in front of the building, there would have been very few avenues for protesters to escape, and it would have likely led to many violent arrests, as DHS will often grab whoever is within reach, regardless of what they are doing.

2071
03:45:20.086 --> 03:45:24.615
<v Cole Donahue>Would this resolution prevent PPB from corralling protesters at ICE like they did on the 12th?

2072
03:45:24.956 --> 03:45:29.307
<v Cole Donahue>Because if that is not suppressing federal agencies and suppressing peaceful assembly, I do not know what is.

2073
03:45:30.146 --> 03:45:33.273
<v Cole Donahue>Again, please pass the resolution and ordinance and revoke the permit.

2074
03:45:33.370 --> 03:45:34.404
<v Cole Donahue>We do not have time to wait.

2075
03:45:34.662 --> 03:45:34.921
<v Isabella Shepherd>Thank you.

2076
03:45:41.516 --> 03:45:41.952
<v Jackie Matzer>Go right ahead.

2077
03:45:42.654 --> 03:45:46.879
<v Isabella Shepherd>Hello, I'm Izzy representing PDXED and the Coalition for Revoking the ICE Permit.

2078
03:45:47.394 --> 03:45:54.993
<v Isabella Shepherd>I'm here to voice our support for the denunciation of a military occupation of our city and for the codification of sanctuary city status into the law.

2079
03:45:55.619 --> 03:46:01.531
<v Isabella Shepherd>I'm also here to talk about concerns surrounding PPB's involvement in the protests and the abhorrent behavior we've seen from DHS and ICE.

2080
03:46:02.334 --> 03:46:05.290
<v Isabella Shepherd>Portland police have increased their presence at the ICE facility recently.

2081
03:46:05.708 --> 03:46:10.156
<v Isabella Shepherd>Last weekend, they opened the streets in front of ICE by force and threats of arrest.

2082
03:46:10.524 --> 03:46:15.046
<v Isabella Shepherd>This was during a protest which had turnout in the thousands, which would be dangerous to drive cars through.

2083
03:46:15.350 --> 03:46:22.323
<v Isabella Shepherd>It must be noted that no force or threats were used by PPB against DHS while they stood in the street.

2084
03:46:22.644 --> 03:46:28.415
<v Isabella Shepherd>I personally think PPB should be instructed to arrest DHS and ICE for such violations since they are not above the law.

2085
03:46:29.040 --> 03:46:33.559
<v Isabella Shepherd>But if it can't be done, then as a bare minimum, they must be instructed to stay out of it.

2086
03:46:33.864 --> 03:46:43.290
<v Isabella Shepherd>As a sanctuary city where city resources are forbidden from being used to enforce ICE's rule, our police cannot be used in cooperation with DHS to suppress protests against ICE.

2087
03:46:44.204 --> 03:46:48.709
<v Isabella Shepherd>The weekend before last, 5 of my good friends were arrested by DHS at another protest.

2088
03:46:49.078 --> 03:46:51.579
<v Isabella Shepherd>Their treatment that they went through while in detention was horrible.

2089
03:46:51.916 --> 03:46:57.078
<v Isabella Shepherd>Something noteworthy is that they were denied phone calls, citing that all the phones were supposedly out of order.

2090
03:46:57.528 --> 03:47:20.581
<v Isabella Shepherd>Since the main argument for keeping this facility seems to be that detainees need to be able to access their families and legal counsel during their 12-hour detention, I think you should be especially concerned with the fact that we have been seeing more cases recently where detainees are actually denied while my friends were locked up and we waited outside the ICE facility for their release and continued protesting, their treatment of us was brutal.

2091
03:47:21.061 --> 03:47:28.996
<v Isabella Shepherd>At one point, they pushed us down the block all the way through camp and up to the intersection at South Bond Avenue, where they deployed over a dozen canisters of tear gas.

2092
03:47:29.334 --> 03:47:30.504
<v Isabella Shepherd>They shot us with pepper balls.

2093
03:47:30.680 --> 03:47:33.709
<v Isabella Shepherd>They shot me on the other side of the street in the head and in the groin.

2094
03:47:34.462 --> 03:47:44.971
<v Isabella Shepherd>Allowing this facility to exist may seem like a strategic retreat, but all this repression and brutalization and breaking of the few rules imposed onto them is the inevitable consequence of giving a fascist an inch.

2095
03:47:45.600 --> 03:47:52.313
<v Isabella Shepherd>I implore you all to keep this in mind when the conditional permit returns to your desk for reconsideration next month, or if you decide to take over the lease.

2096
03:47:55.442 --> 03:47:56.063
<v Holly Brown>Thank you.

2097
03:47:56.111 --> 03:47:57.254
<v Keith Wilson>Much for being here tonight.

2098
03:47:58.764 --> 03:48:10.334
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Jessica Salas, David Pearl, Lawson D'Ambrosio, Andre Tokuyuk, And Karen Shirai.

2099
03:48:18.277 --> 03:48:18.882
<v Keith Wilson>Please go right ahead.

2100
03:48:20.278 --> 03:48:20.970
<v Liz Kay>Hi, I'm Jessica.

2101
03:48:22.137 --> 03:48:23.603
<v Keith Wilson>Hello, city councilors and mayor.

2102
03:48:24.039 --> 03:48:26.409
<v Keith Wilson>I'm here to ask you to do 2 things.

2103
03:48:26.828 --> 03:48:28.247
<v Keith Wilson>First, show us some courage.

2104
03:48:29.016 --> 03:48:33.871
<v Keith Wilson>Please join your constituents like myself and countless others this Saturday for the No Kings March here in downtown Portland.

2105
03:48:34.930 --> 03:48:36.579
<v Keith Wilson>These individuals make Portland what it is.

2106
03:48:37.316 --> 03:48:41.819
<v Keith Wilson>They are the reason our city is known for its progressive spirit, boldness, and unwavering commitment.

2107
03:48:42.460 --> 03:48:46.515
<v Keith Wilson>They continue to show up even as officers become increasingly aggressive towards them.

2108
03:48:47.093 --> 03:48:53.694
<v Keith Wilson>Night after night, they face intimidation, tear gas, and harassment, yet they still stand peacefully for their rights.

2109
03:48:54.239 --> 03:48:55.168
<v Keith Wilson>Your presence matters.

2110
03:48:55.698 --> 03:48:56.594
<v Keith Wilson>It shows that you see them.

2111
03:48:57.203 --> 03:48:59.703
<v Keith Wilson>It shows that you stand with the community you were elected to serve.

2112
03:49:00.250 --> 03:49:02.226
<v Keith Wilson>Remember, Portlanders pay your salaries.

2113
03:49:03.302 --> 03:49:14.790
<v Keith Wilson>Even simple gestures like bringing snacks or water through groups like Pizza Protest, who collect donations and provide food for protesters, remind everyone that you care, that their courage isn't going unnoticed.

2114
03:49:15.513 --> 03:49:25.747
<v Keith Wilson>With tensions high and talk about Trump invoking the Insurrection Act, it's more important than ever that local leadership is present to protect the community and ensure the protest remains peaceful.

2115
03:49:25.796 --> 03:49:26.165
<v Ricky King>Councilmember Herbold.

2116
03:49:26.840 --> 03:49:28.940
<v Keith Wilson>Second, help Portland stand our ground.

2117
03:49:29.325 --> 03:49:32.435
<v Keith Wilson>Trump wants to paint us as lawless and dangerous, but we know the truth.

2118
03:49:33.174 --> 03:49:36.590
<v Keith Wilson>Our city is peaceful, organized, and is standing on the right side of history.

2119
03:49:37.424 --> 03:49:45.281
<v Keith Wilson>When our leaders are present, when you speak out and defend the rights of your constituents in real time, you show the country that Portland will not be intimidated.

2120
03:49:45.746 --> 03:49:49.659
<v Keith Wilson>We defend our values, our friends, our neighbors, and our future, even under pressure.

2121
03:49:50.494 --> 03:49:52.417
<v Keith Wilson>Right now, that pressure is real.

2122
03:49:53.075 --> 03:49:57.684
<v Keith Wilson>Earlier today, a bus carrying around 20 ICE agents arrived at the ICE facility.

2123
03:49:57.861 --> 03:50:04.909
<v Keith Wilson>Their presence increases tension and fear, making it even more urgent for our elected leaders to stand visibly with the community and protect Portlanders.

2124
03:50:05.728 --> 03:50:14.077
<v Keith Wilson>It is, it is the beautiful people of Oregon and Trump's consistent authoritarian attacks that inspired me to run for Oregon's 3rd Congressional District.

2125
03:50:14.351 --> 03:50:17.819
<v Keith Wilson>Standing side by side with the peaceful protesters reminds me why we are here.

2126
03:50:18.189 --> 03:50:23.027
<v Keith Wilson>To defend our home, to make our voices heard, and to be a beacon of hope for the future we all stand— want to see.

2127
03:50:23.818 --> 03:50:28.204
<v Keith Wilson>I will be at the No Kings rally this Saturday, and I hope you listen to me when I say this.

2128
03:50:28.398 --> 03:50:29.189
<v Keith Wilson>Portland is watching.

2129
03:50:29.865 --> 03:50:30.720
<v Keith Wilson>Your voters are watching.

2130
03:50:31.075 --> 03:50:32.897
<v Keith Wilson>Do the right thing and join us on the front lines.

2131
03:50:33.658 --> 03:50:34.128
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

2132
03:50:37.702 --> 03:50:38.575
<v David Pearl>Good evening, Council.

2133
03:50:38.690 --> 03:50:40.906
<v David Pearl>My name is David Pearl, District 1.

2134
03:50:41.843 --> 03:50:47.975
<v David Pearl>I want to follow what pretty much everyone here is saying in that I agree with the agenda items 6 and 7.

2135
03:50:48.813 --> 03:50:54.024
<v David Pearl>But I want to specifically say that it is not enough for this to be the only thing that we are doing.

2136
03:50:54.637 --> 03:51:13.934
<v David Pearl>We need to be standing strong and doing everything we can to be prevent— to fight fascism, which means that we need our mayor to step forward and issue as many executive orders as possible to lay the groundwork to continue fighting for what we need done.

2137
03:51:14.913 --> 03:51:20.904
<v David Pearl>We need to stand up for the people that continue to be assaulted and attacked by DHS and ICE.

2138
03:51:21.515 --> 03:51:40.365
<v David Pearl>We need for the mayor and everyone that has agency to step up and talk— to step up and challenge the DA from his unlawful, immoral, and immoral challenges of the— shoot.

2139
03:51:40.495 --> 03:51:45.152
<v David Pearl>Councilor To challenge the arrests that are unlawful.

2140
03:51:47.537 --> 03:51:48.663
<v David Pearl>We need to continue to fight.

2141
03:51:48.921 --> 03:51:50.805
<v David Pearl>Fascism does not take a rest.

2142
03:51:51.513 --> 03:51:58.840
<v David Pearl>Once the fuse is lit, it will continue to go, and they will continue to pick new and more and be more egregious in their attacks on our society.

2143
03:51:59.307 --> 03:51:59.582
<v David Pearl>Thank you.

2144
03:52:00.774 --> 03:52:02.193
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you very much.

2145
03:52:03.257 --> 03:52:04.612
<v Keith Wilson>Go right ahead.

2146
03:52:06.967 --> 03:52:08.816
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>Greetings, Council, Mayor.

2147
03:52:08.965 --> 03:52:10.103
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>My name is Lawson D'Ambrosio.

2148
03:52:12.271 --> 03:52:18.975
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>And greetings to all my fellow residents here in Portland, which I have been incredibly privileged to call my home for the last 10 years.

2149
03:52:19.727 --> 03:52:29.737
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>I'm here today, like many of my fellow residents here, to urge you to adopt the measures before you, reaffirming and enshrining Portland's sanctuary city status.

2150
03:52:30.236 --> 03:52:36.502
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>Make no mistakes, the actions of the Trump administration are just the first stages in a fascist authoritarian attempt to cripple what remains of American democracy.

2151
03:52:39.319 --> 03:52:43.360
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>And lay the groundwork for an autocracy in the image of fascists like Stephen Miller.

2152
03:52:44.209 --> 03:52:51.727
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>Everyone in this country, no matter their immigration status, has the right to due process, legal representation, and a fair trial in the court of law.

2153
03:52:51.903 --> 03:52:55.590
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>And when those rights are threatened for any one of us, they are threatened for all of us.

2154
03:52:56.231 --> 03:53:17.786
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>Right now, here in Portland and across the country, our neighbors, friends, and family members are being abducted off the streets by masked, unidentified jackboots Working for the branches of our federal government that have already succumbed to this fascist rot, it is imperative that we do everything in our power to push back against these unconstitutional authoritarian abuses.

2155
03:53:18.302 --> 03:53:24.083
<v Lawson D'Ambrosio>And in the sake of time, I will yield the rest of my message and again encourage you to pass these measures in front of you.

2156
03:53:27.395 --> 03:53:28.574
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

2157
03:53:28.787 --> 03:53:29.556
<v Keith Wilson>Please go right ahead.

2158
03:53:31.058 --> 03:53:31.219
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, me?

2159
03:53:31.443 --> 03:53:31.700
<v Karen Shirai>Oh, sorry.

2160
03:53:32.745 --> 03:53:33.113
<v Karen Shirai>Good evening.

2161
03:53:33.177 --> 03:53:34.350
<v Karen Shirai>My name is Karen Chi Ray.

2162
03:53:34.527 --> 03:53:46.004
<v Karen Shirai>I'm a lifelong Portland resident, a veteran, a resident of District 3, a business owner in District 4, and I'm not afraid to say I want a no vote on the resolution and the code.

2163
03:53:46.084 --> 03:53:48.363
<v Karen Shirai>I'm sure your heart is in the right place.

2164
03:53:48.557 --> 03:53:58.638
<v Karen Shirai>I too care deeply for all people, but what I don't want is illegal immigrants in our community breaking laws, bringing drugs, trafficking women and children, and not paying Texas.

2165
03:53:59.310 --> 03:54:06.415
<v Karen Shirai>Technically, we're all immigrants, but we cannot stand by and let illegal immigrants continue to cause harm to our communities.

2166
03:54:07.234 --> 03:54:16.599
<v Karen Shirai>I have spoken countless times in front of you and county commissioners on how you should be focusing on making our streets safe and livable for everyone and keeping our businesses open.

2167
03:54:17.192 --> 03:54:27.347
<v Karen Shirai>Yet what I've seen lately has now taken the focus off those important issues and instead mocked our crime victims homeless, and mentally ill by saying Portland is fine.

2168
03:54:28.102 --> 03:54:33.882
<v Karen Shirai>Portland is not fine, but it definitely can be if we all work together to hold people accountable.

2169
03:54:34.670 --> 03:54:41.959
<v Karen Shirai>While we are not a war zone like our president said, every day people are fighting for their lives, their homes, and their businesses.

2170
03:54:42.634 --> 03:54:47.129
<v Karen Shirai>What is our democracy— that is what our democracy is supposed to protect.

2171
03:54:47.675 --> 03:54:48.029
<v Karen Shirai>Thank you.

2172
03:54:48.156 --> 03:54:49.425
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

2173
03:54:50.025 --> 03:54:51.051
<v Holly Brown>Thank you very much.

2174
03:54:51.898 --> 03:54:53.282
<v Keith Wilson>Please go right ahead.

2175
03:54:55.887 --> 03:55:14.435
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, uh, checking to see if Andre Tokayuk— next up we have Eddie Wang, Philip Weeks, William Hare, Charlie Michelle Wesley, Michael Yurkovsky.

2176
03:55:17.009 --> 03:55:17.299
<v Keelan McClymont>Go ahead.

2177
03:55:18.772 --> 03:55:19.710
<v Eddie Wang>Hi, thank you.

2178
03:55:19.905 --> 03:55:21.296
<v Eddie Wang>Um, I'm really glad to be here.

2179
03:55:22.049 --> 03:55:23.521
<v Eddie Wang>Um, my name is Eddie Wong.

2180
03:55:23.602 --> 03:55:24.993
<v Eddie Wang>I'm the PPS board chair.

2181
03:55:25.754 --> 03:55:29.281
<v Eddie Wang>Um, thank you, city councilors, mayor, uh, for being here.

2182
03:55:29.556 --> 03:55:33.242
<v Eddie Wang>I really appreciate all that you do in these challenging times.

2183
03:55:33.451 --> 03:55:34.033
<v Eddie Wang>Really respect.

2184
03:55:34.099 --> 03:55:40.935
<v Eddie Wang>I just want to share that for the first time probably ever that I hear across the city that people feel like they're actually finally being represented, and that includes me.

2185
03:55:41.478 --> 03:55:43.212
<v Eddie Wang>And so thank you for all the hard work that you do.

2186
03:55:43.877 --> 03:55:56.695
<v Eddie Wang>I'm here, but I want to— I want to hear to kind of share some time or speak for a population that doesn't often get represented, and that's our students, our school-aged kids.

2187
03:55:59.637 --> 03:56:03.808
<v Eddie Wang>Director Chase Miller stole my thunder and said everything I want to say, so ditto on that.

2188
03:56:04.148 --> 03:56:06.534
<v Eddie Wang>So I'm going to get real with you and just share a personal story.

2189
03:56:06.627 --> 03:56:07.269
<v Eddie Wang>Story of mine.

2190
03:56:07.766 --> 03:56:10.242
<v Eddie Wang>Um, kids are— I was a teacher for 21 years.

2191
03:56:10.594 --> 03:56:12.138
<v Eddie Wang>Kids are weird, right?

2192
03:56:12.281 --> 03:56:20.365
<v Eddie Wang>Uh, I mean, I, I— in one year I had a kid that wouldn't stop arguing with me that black holes were proof that our universe was a digital simulation.

2193
03:56:20.638 --> 03:56:28.994
<v Eddie Wang>At the same time, another kid spent 2 months on a dare and succeeded that proved that he could put a noodle in his mouth and pull out of his nose.

2194
03:56:30.527 --> 03:56:38.213
<v Eddie Wang>Um, however, the day that one of our students in our class parent got deported, you could say that the music died.

2195
03:56:39.807 --> 03:56:42.922
<v Eddie Wang>That was the day the music died, and there was Trump.

2196
03:56:43.327 --> 03:56:44.754
<v Eddie Wang>The thing about trauma is it spreads.

2197
03:56:45.826 --> 03:56:54.575
<v Eddie Wang>And one thing that, you know, as board members we try to do as hard as we can is protect our, our kids in our schools, but we can't protect the kids right outside of our schools.

2198
03:56:54.640 --> 03:56:57.192
<v Eddie Wang>As you know, uh, Time.

2199
03:56:57.564 --> 03:56:58.582
<v Eddie Wang>I'll keep this brief.

2200
03:56:59.898 --> 03:57:11.213
<v Eddie Wang>We need this code— sorry, to be the sanctuary status to be codified because it strengthens the foundation that we can actually do real action to protect our kids.

2201
03:57:11.359 --> 03:57:12.200
<v Eddie Wang>We need your help.

2202
03:57:12.329 --> 03:57:13.461
<v Eddie Wang>Our kids need your help.

2203
03:57:13.816 --> 03:57:15.498
<v Eddie Wang>So please, please vote yes.

2204
03:57:15.742 --> 03:57:16.049
<v Tyler Fellini>Thank you.

2205
03:57:16.356 --> 03:57:16.709
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Thank you.

2206
03:57:19.362 --> 03:57:19.813
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

2207
03:57:21.854 --> 03:57:22.256
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>I'm next?

2208
03:57:22.578 --> 03:57:22.804
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Okay.

2209
03:57:24.411 --> 03:57:27.377
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>I'm Charlie Michelle Wesley and a descendant of multiple Northwest tribes.

2210
03:57:27.523 --> 03:57:34.547
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>And lately I've been making sure that I carry my tribal, federally recognized tribal ID just in case.

2211
03:57:36.668 --> 03:57:41.574
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Then I'm going to paraphrase a quote from an amazing racial justice activist and dearest friend, Matt Levine.

2212
03:57:42.902 --> 03:57:47.632
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>What people care about and what they don't is heartbreaking and mind-numbing.

2213
03:57:48.293 --> 03:57:56.858
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>I, I had to really agree with that in that moment when we were discussing the response to counter-protesters who claimed to love ICE.

2214
03:57:58.292 --> 03:58:01.070
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Revealing the racist lack of caring for immigrant lives.

2215
03:58:02.227 --> 03:58:22.394
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Those that do actually care about our immigrant communities and fight for them, like our courageous protesters and several city councilors who came to us with care in their hearts to actually include the most vulnerable and have the courage to prove it, they tackle the historical performative acts created to pacify us.

2216
03:58:22.956 --> 03:58:30.780
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Such as core city values, land acknowledgement, protect and serve, DEI, Green Portland, and yes, sanctuary city.

2217
03:58:31.760 --> 03:58:37.929
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>They get criticized and bullied for the humanitarian courage to do what caring leaders do for community.

2218
03:58:38.587 --> 03:58:39.375
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>They serve us.

2219
03:58:40.354 --> 03:58:41.784
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>They fight to protect us.

2220
03:58:41.960 --> 03:58:49.222
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>They hear us and speak out to flip the script from us being the problem to where it rightfully belongs— those with violent racist powers.

2221
03:58:49.351 --> 03:58:49.575
<v Jackie Matzer>Thank you.

2222
03:58:50.009 --> 03:58:57.832
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>That are ripping a hole large enough for fascism and hate to invade in the already flimsy fabric of freedom and democracy.

2223
03:58:58.745 --> 03:59:09.132
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>The war being waged on our immigrant communities is nothing less than a systemic racist profiling and seizure for no other reason than to fulfill the evil regime with the form of indigenous genocide.

2224
03:59:10.047 --> 03:59:12.290
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Codify Portland as a true sanctuary city.

2225
03:59:12.450 --> 03:59:13.284
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Vote with your heart.

2226
03:59:13.477 --> 03:59:14.406
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Show us you care.

2227
03:59:15.240 --> 03:59:16.924
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Be the model for true humanity.

2228
03:59:17.020 --> 03:59:19.761
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Vote to keep families together and reside safely here.

2229
03:59:20.386 --> 03:59:20.834
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>This is urgent.

2230
03:59:20.915 --> 03:59:21.332
<v Kathleen Hannan>Thank you.

2231
03:59:21.751 --> 03:59:24.967
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>We need a moral code to double as a city code.

2232
03:59:25.877 --> 03:59:26.363
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Thank you.

2233
03:59:30.086 --> 03:59:32.467
<v William Hare>Hello, I'm, uh, William Hare.

2234
03:59:32.772 --> 03:59:34.477
<v William Hare>Uh, I'm a resident of the 3rd District.

2235
03:59:35.009 --> 03:59:46.229
<v William Hare>Um, the phrase exercises unlimited arbitrariness and violence unchecked by any legal guarantees seems a more apt description of federal immigration enforcement with each passing day.

2236
03:59:47.298 --> 03:59:57.469
<v William Hare>We mustn't allow Portland to condone the creation of a dual-state justice system in such a way, and we are seeing a normative and prerogative state created in our very backyard.

2237
04:00:01.397 --> 04:00:08.158
<v William Hare>But more than that, we may— we can never allow any state funds or city staff to be involved in this insidious enterprise.

2238
04:00:08.335 --> 04:00:20.994
<v William Hare>The current administration enforcement agencies are steeped in a culture of violence and lawlessness that I believe will infect any city personnel that become involved with We must not allow the imperial boomerang to land on our doorstep.

2239
04:00:21.637 --> 04:00:29.027
<v William Hare>And this is just the very first step and bare minimum we can do by codifying this within our city statute.

2240
04:00:29.734 --> 04:00:33.363
<v William Hare>We hear stories about everyone suffering and struggling today.

2241
04:00:33.990 --> 04:00:54.463
<v William Hare>And as we stand in this marbled, beautiful City Hall, we have to ask ourselves, if one Portlander, regardless of citizen status, is kidnapped ever, what's the point of all of this if a city can't even keep its own civilians safe when masked thugs just show up and, and tear them away from their families?

2242
04:00:54.904 --> 04:00:55.638
<v William Hare>What's the point?

2243
04:00:56.045 --> 04:00:56.631
<v William Hare>What are we even doing?

2244
04:00:58.516 --> 04:00:59.336
<v William Hare>I yield the rest of my time.

2245
04:01:02.567 --> 04:01:04.380
<v Philip Weeks>Good evening, council members and mayor.

2246
04:01:05.061 --> 04:01:12.659
<v Philip Weeks>I'm here to speak in support of the, uh, Protect Portland, uh, resolution and certification of sanctuary city status.

2247
04:01:13.119 --> 04:01:13.495
<v Philip Weeks>My name is Philip Weeks.

2248
04:01:13.545 --> 04:01:13.807
<v Philip Weeks>I go by he/him.

2249
04:01:13.871 --> 04:01:19.288
<v Philip Weeks>I've been a resident I've been in Portland for 2 years and reside in the 4th Council District.

2250
04:01:19.704 --> 04:01:26.547
<v Philip Weeks>Prior to moving to Portland, I worked with numerous organizations in St. Louis that investigated transparency and accountability in law enforcement.

2251
04:01:27.093 --> 04:01:33.886
<v Philip Weeks>There are many similarities to the out-of-control law— to an out-of-control law enforcement agency and the pattern and practices of ICE.

2252
04:01:34.560 --> 04:01:37.836
<v Philip Weeks>That is why I support the codification of Portland as a sanctuary city.

2253
04:01:38.254 --> 04:01:42.300
<v Philip Weeks>I also support the— I oppose the resolution that would—.

2254
04:01:42.300 --> 04:01:42.959
<v Cole Donahue>Councilor Dan Ryan.

2255
04:01:44.308 --> 04:01:46.217
<v Philip Weeks>Support only an annual report.

2256
04:01:46.281 --> 04:01:48.078
<v Philip Weeks>I think the FOIAs are necessary.

2257
04:01:48.689 --> 04:01:52.362
<v Philip Weeks>Portland has an opportunity to offer a different vision for America than the Trump administration.

2258
04:01:52.797 --> 04:02:00.387
<v Philip Weeks>The immigrant families and U.S. citizens that are caught up in the brutal dragnet approach of ICE will need trauma assistance to cope with what they are experiencing.

2259
04:02:01.059 --> 04:02:07.799
<v Philip Weeks>The motivation to establish this assistance is unfortunately becoming more prevalent, as seen by the videos and filming of ICE.

2260
04:02:08.200 --> 04:02:19.336
<v Philip Weeks>The militant raid of Chicago apartment complex not only violated the norms of policing and numerous amendments of the Constitution, Councilor but also caused an incredible amount of trauma to those terrorized by ICE agents.

2261
04:02:19.513 --> 04:02:27.665
<v Philip Weeks>If what happened in Chicago is the tip of the iceberg of what might happen in Portland, then Portland should offer assistance to those suffering the consequences.

2262
04:02:28.259 --> 04:02:45.620
<v Philip Weeks>Recently, Chicago made a similar pledge to its residents who experienced the horrifying and traumatic policing of the Chicago Police Department Commander John Burge, who, according to The Guardian, tortured 118 Black U.S. citizens in public custody between 1970 and 1991.

2263
04:02:45.652 --> 04:02:46.004
<v Philip Weeks>Order.

2264
04:02:45.764 --> 04:02:45.798
<v Ross Taylor>Aye.

2265
04:02:46.155 --> 04:02:59.608
<v Philip Weeks>Chicago has made trauma counseling available to those victims through the Chicago Torture Center— Torture Justice Center, which was established as part of the historic reparations ordinance.

2266
04:02:59.995 --> 04:03:08.566
<v Philip Weeks>In addition to the mental health of those ensnared by the terrorizing tactics of ICE, there's also the financial harm to immigrants and citizens who are brutalized by ICE.

2267
04:03:09.082 --> 04:03:17.652
<v Philip Weeks>LA County is enacting an eviction moratorium to protect renters who have been financially harmed by this administration's grossly irresponsible crackdown.

2268
04:03:18.087 --> 04:03:19.010
<v Philip Weeks>Portland can do the same.

2269
04:03:19.074 --> 04:03:20.221
<v Keith Wilson>Very much for being here.

2270
04:03:24.777 --> 04:03:39.643
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Michael Yurkovsky, Matt Levine, Madeline Carroll, Deborah Stevens, Casey DeSantis.

2271
04:03:45.912 --> 04:03:46.938
<v Matt Levine>Hello, community members.

2272
04:03:47.467 --> 04:03:54.376
<v Matt Levine>My name is Dr. Matt Levine, and I'm an activist, academic, and facilitator who specializes in intersectional racial justice.

2273
04:03:55.049 --> 04:04:05.371
<v Matt Levine>I'm here today in enthusiastic support of Councilors Kanal, Avalos, and Murillo's efforts to live up to the words that we've committed to as a sanctuary city.

2274
04:04:06.190 --> 04:04:12.634
<v Matt Levine>We absolutely must make our city's current sanctuary city resolution binding law by putting it in city code and with an emergency ordinance.

2275
04:04:12.682 --> 04:04:12.793
<v Cole Donahue>Thank you.

2276
04:04:14.299 --> 04:04:16.254
<v Matt Levine>In fact, we need to go much further than that.

2277
04:04:16.879 --> 04:04:25.644
<v Matt Levine>So to directly respond to the white supremacist Darren we heard from earlier, yes, we need to question our approach to borders and immigration wholesale.

2278
04:04:26.380 --> 04:04:35.576
<v Matt Levine>You may not think that's appropriate to your job as a city council member, and I understand your trepidation, but that would be to not recognize the reality of the situation.

2279
04:04:36.635 --> 04:04:42.002
<v Matt Levine>The reality of the situation is that the president of what is now known as the United States has started a civil war.

2280
04:04:42.129 --> 04:04:42.242
<v Holly Brown>Thank you.

2281
04:04:43.380 --> 04:04:52.790
<v Matt Levine>And our city, what's now known as Portland, is one of the first battlefields of that civil war, along with what's now known as LA, DC, Chicago.

2282
04:04:53.737 --> 04:05:07.192
<v Matt Levine>And remember, that civil war was started because there is no limit to what the current administration will do to wage war against Latinx communities, Black and brown communities, people who speak Spanish, and people who work certain jobs.

2283
04:05:07.306 --> 04:05:07.433
<v Ricky King>Thank you.

2284
04:05:08.174 --> 04:05:25.458
<v Matt Levine>To think about that wholesale reframe of borders and immigration, please remember that this city we love is actually the nexus of rightful ancestral occupied lands of Tualatin Kalapuya peoples, Multnomah peoples, Cowlitz peoples, and more indigenous peoples of the Lower Columbia River.

2285
04:05:26.486 --> 04:05:41.362
<v Matt Levine>Put simply, a government that was created by people coming to a land to which they weren't invited, who committed genocide upon arrival, have no right whatsoever to say that others are not allowed to cross the imaginary lines that that genocidal government imposed.

2286
04:05:42.131 --> 04:05:48.076
<v Matt Levine>Furthermore, Mexican people and Chicano communities have much more of a right to be here than any white people from Europe.

2287
04:05:48.861 --> 04:05:56.137
<v Matt Levine>Remember, Americans like Lewis and Clark in the 1800s were perpetuating settler colonialism on top of settler colonialism.

2288
04:05:56.489 --> 04:06:00.639
<v Matt Levine>And even after that, Oregon was the southern border of the US.

2289
04:06:01.120 --> 04:06:02.162
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for being here.

2290
04:06:05.280 --> 04:06:23.300
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, uh, Madeline Carroll, Deborah Stevens, Casey DeSantis, Gregory Parson, Pedro Anglada Cordero, Jose Gamero Georgeson.

2291
04:06:26.313 --> 04:06:27.210
<v Kerry Ko>Casey's online.

2292
04:06:27.809 --> 04:06:27.993
<v William Hare>Oh, okay.

2293
04:06:28.197 --> 04:06:29.165
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, great, thanks.

2294
04:06:38.908 --> 04:06:39.700
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>Hello, councilors.

2295
04:06:40.282 --> 04:06:42.287
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>Uh, my name is Jose Camero-Georgeson.

2296
04:06:42.950 --> 04:06:49.754
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>I'm speaking for myself, but I am a school board member in District 1, and I am an immigrant.

2297
04:06:50.385 --> 04:06:55.350
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>I came to this country when I was 7 years old Yes.

2298
04:06:55.690 --> 04:06:57.934
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>And lived in a mostly immigrant community.

2299
04:06:58.840 --> 04:07:22.969
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>And I lived most of my life, um, quietly turning around if a police officer was nearby, afraid of what they could do to me or my friends or my family, being uncertain of if even going to college is worth it because what do I do if I don't have papers?

2300
04:07:23.084 --> 04:07:25.209
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>Or I don't— not knowing what to do.

2301
04:07:26.643 --> 04:07:42.316
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>I can only imagine how bad it is for my community now in the current state that we're in, because it was so hard on me, and it's a fraction of how, how it is now.

2302
04:07:43.735 --> 04:07:46.942
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>And as a school board member, I'm hearing that from the families.

2303
04:07:47.441 --> 04:07:56.465
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>We're hearing recordings because they don't want to show up at the school board or come anywhere of them saying, I don't know if I should take my kids to school.

2304
04:07:56.865 --> 04:08:06.661
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>I don't know if we have to move back to our country because they've deported my husband and I can't afford to raise 4 kids by myself.

2305
04:08:06.950 --> 04:08:10.561
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>These is what we're hearing from our parents.

2306
04:08:12.005 --> 04:08:16.016
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>We also passed a resolution and codified it.

2307
04:08:16.370 --> 04:08:22.338
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>So I'm glad you're taking that step to put strength behind your words.

2308
04:08:23.397 --> 04:08:41.050
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>And honestly, I've been very, very happy to see most of you on TV lifting your voices because you have the platform to do so when so many people are afraid to do it for themselves.

2309
04:08:41.583 --> 04:08:43.629
<v Jose Gamero Georgeson>So thank you for this, and thank you for what you're doing.

2310
04:08:47.831 --> 04:08:50.129
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, uh, we'll just run through the names one more time.

2311
04:08:50.177 --> 04:09:03.373
<v Keelan McClymont>Deborah Stevens, Gregory Parson, Casey DeSantis is not online, Pedro Anglada Cordero, Justin Skolnick.

2312
04:09:05.471 --> 04:09:06.796
<v Keelan McClymont>Jay Amayachi.

2313
04:09:09.006 --> 04:09:10.590
<v Keelan McClymont>Tyler Fellini.

2314
04:09:11.867 --> 04:09:12.997
<v Keelan McClymont>Jacqueline Moezer.

2315
04:09:21.047 --> 04:09:22.030
<v Holly Brown>Welcome, go right ahead.

2316
04:09:25.467 --> 04:09:27.548
<v Justin Skolnick>For the record, my name is Justin Skolnick.

2317
04:09:27.629 --> 04:09:28.751
<v Justin Skolnick>I'm speaking in support.

2318
04:09:29.221 --> 04:09:31.156
<v Justin Skolnick>I'd be lying if I said I'm surprised by events.

2319
04:09:31.206 --> 04:09:39.654
<v Justin Skolnick>I know that many have seen, many Many have been caught off guard by the speed with which this crisis has arrived and by the fragility of our institutions.

2320
04:09:39.831 --> 04:09:44.941
<v Justin Skolnick>Many have said this is not normal, as if everything depended on one single election.

2321
04:09:45.358 --> 04:09:47.905
<v Justin Skolnick>This crisis has been rolling our way for centuries.

2322
04:09:48.176 --> 04:09:57.356
<v Justin Skolnick>Broadly, we're up against the descendants of slaveholders who refuse to accept any outcome that doesn't reinforce their conviction that they compromise a natural aristocracy.

2323
04:09:57.693 --> 04:10:05.530
<v Justin Skolnick>We're up against strands of Calvinism that mistake wealth for virtue and interpretations of the Gospels that are iffy at best about Jesus' thank you.

2324
04:10:06.429 --> 04:10:09.143
<v Justin Skolnick>We're up against sadists who get off on causing suffering.

2325
04:10:09.897 --> 04:10:16.255
<v Justin Skolnick>We're up against some who experience the dissonance of city life as a personal assault and who want the police to stop the blue hair.

2326
04:10:16.961 --> 04:10:20.013
<v Justin Skolnick>We're up against others seeking revenge on life itself.

2327
04:10:20.174 --> 04:10:23.497
<v Justin Skolnick>No amount of empathy will bridge the gap between us and them.

2328
04:10:24.027 --> 04:10:27.398
<v Justin Skolnick>There is no compromise we can reach to make them be kind.

2329
04:10:27.784 --> 04:10:37.274
<v Justin Skolnick>The world in which that style of politics works our job in this world is to protect those among our neighbors the regime is trying to enslave or eliminate.

2330
04:10:37.899 --> 04:10:43.796
<v Justin Skolnick>We will also need to reject the propaganda launched at us by self-interested groups like People for Portland and the Business Alliance.

2331
04:10:43.971 --> 04:10:47.400
<v Justin Skolnick>For instance, the eugenic language of cleaning up the city.

2332
04:10:48.235 --> 04:10:53.939
<v Justin Skolnick>The greed that inspires this language that we've long just let slide has impaired our solidarity.

2333
04:10:54.307 --> 04:10:57.703
<v Justin Skolnick>What has been normal is a game of keep away played with the basic human needs of shelter, food, and housing.

2334
04:10:57.768 --> 04:10:57.863
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Thank you.

2335
04:10:58.890 --> 04:11:00.287
<v Justin Skolnick>And this is not a game we can win.

2336
04:11:00.415 --> 04:11:03.351
<v Justin Skolnick>We can't sacrifice our neighbors and expect to thrive.

2337
04:11:04.023 --> 04:11:07.297
<v Justin Skolnick>This proposed suite of protections is an important first step.

2338
04:11:07.472 --> 04:11:08.595
<v Justin Skolnick>We do need more.

2339
04:11:08.980 --> 04:11:17.755
<v Justin Skolnick>This regime trying to occupy our streets and stealing our loved ones has also threatened to blast its detractors out of the water like a Venezuelan fishing boat.

2340
04:11:17.900 --> 04:11:21.477
<v Justin Skolnick>It's time to accept that our destinies were already intertwined.

2341
04:11:21.831 --> 04:11:23.354
<v Justin Skolnick>We are on this boat together.

2342
04:11:23.659 --> 04:11:24.380
<v Justin Skolnick>We sink or swim together.

2343
04:11:24.430 --> 04:11:24.654
<v Justin Skolnick>Thank you.

2344
04:11:29.772 --> 04:11:32.334
<v Keith Wilson>Hi, councilors.

2345
04:11:33.078 --> 04:11:34.878
<v Jackie Matzer>Councilors, my name is Jackie Matzer.

2346
04:11:34.942 --> 04:11:36.773
<v Jackie Matzer>I'm a constituent of District 3.

2347
04:11:37.617 --> 04:11:44.849
<v Jackie Matzer>I serve as the education program manager for a nonprofit here in Portland that provides mentorship for youth involved in the child welfare system.

2348
04:11:45.380 --> 04:11:45.912
<v Jackie Matzer>I'm going to be brief.

2349
04:11:46.346 --> 04:11:50.831
<v Jackie Matzer>I'm really still here in the room because I want to be here when this passes, so I hope you can help me out with that.

2350
04:11:50.895 --> 04:11:51.120
<v Jackie Matzer>Thank you.

2351
04:11:52.763 --> 04:11:54.708
<v Jackie Matzer>Please vote for the resolution and ordinance tonight.

2352
04:11:54.933 --> 04:11:59.847
<v Jackie Matzer>Many of the youth I work with came to Portland as unaccompanied minors seeking asylum and refuge.

2353
04:12:00.314 --> 04:12:08.361
<v Jackie Matzer>My job is to support these youth in accessing an education and building the skills and mindsets to feel smart, capable, and inspired about their future.

2354
04:12:08.971 --> 04:12:15.765
<v Jackie Matzer>I cannot do this work if my students are afraid to go into the community to study or explore their interests, or if they're afraid to go to school.

2355
04:12:16.521 --> 04:12:22.189
<v Jackie Matzer>These youth need to feel connected to their community and protected by the adults and public servants of the city they call home.

2356
04:12:23.120 --> 04:12:27.343
<v Jackie Matzer>I'm also the proud parent of a 6th grader and a 1st grader who attend Portland Public Schools.

2357
04:12:28.259 --> 04:12:37.009
<v Jackie Matzer>Their education is enriched by the experiences, culture, and the nothing short of miraculous resilience that their immigrant classmates bring to school with them every day.

2358
04:12:37.570 --> 04:12:45.951
<v Jackie Matzer>I need to know that they're safe in their schools, that their friends are safe in their schools, they can play in the park or go trick-or-treating without having their right to be here questioned.

2359
04:12:47.469 --> 04:12:53.390
<v Jackie Matzer>Please support the resolution and ordinance and stand firm in the face of intolerance by adding an emergency clause to the ordinance tonight.

2360
04:12:55.031 --> 04:12:55.191
<v Keith Wilson>Thanks.

2361
04:12:56.143 --> 04:12:56.577
<v Ricky King>Thank you both.

2362
04:12:57.545 --> 04:13:03.703
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have— oh wait, let's check— Jay Amici and Tyler Fellini.

2363
04:13:05.431 --> 04:13:07.384
<v Keelan McClymont>Next we have Ross Taylor.

2364
04:13:08.465 --> 04:13:19.924
<v Keelan McClymont>Joining us online, followed by Enzo Carpio, Hugo Flores, Mindan Okan, and Ricky King.

2365
04:13:25.606 --> 04:13:26.549
<v Keith Wilson>Hello.

2366
04:13:34.010 --> 04:13:35.342
<v Ross Taylor>My name is Ross Taylor.

2367
04:13:36.015 --> 04:13:38.135
<v Ross Taylor>Hello, city councilors, other folks that are there.

2368
04:13:38.888 --> 04:13:44.860
<v Ross Taylor>I live in District 4, and I'm a member of the organization SURGE PDX, Showing Up for Racial Justice.

2369
04:13:45.950 --> 04:13:48.068
<v Ross Taylor>I just want to provide a little context.

2370
04:13:48.614 --> 04:13:54.649
<v Ross Taylor>We need to remember the racist basis for all the immigration law and policy since at least the 1600s.

2371
04:13:55.451 --> 04:13:59.335
<v Ross Taylor>Immigration laws defined who was white and eligible for citizenship.

2372
04:14:00.798 --> 04:14:08.736
<v Ross Taylor>Defined who was in the country legally, and it was defined on a racial basis who was covered by labor protections and who had the right to organize.

2373
04:14:09.315 --> 04:14:13.444
<v Ross Taylor>Currently, ICE is openly using racial profiling to decide who to kidnap.

2374
04:14:14.698 --> 04:14:23.182
<v Ross Taylor>Um, this resolution and ordinance are the minimum of what needs to be done tonight, including Councilor Kanal's proposed amendment.

2375
04:14:24.097 --> 04:14:36.201
<v Ross Taylor>I've had a list that I was going to give of further steps that are needed, but I think the important thing right now is to pass this resolution and ordinance on an emergency basis, uh, so these things can go into effect.

2376
04:14:36.754 --> 04:14:37.388
<v Ross Taylor>Thank you very much.

2377
04:14:39.519 --> 04:14:41.158
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

2378
04:14:46.043 --> 04:14:48.838
<v Enzo Carpio>Good evening, Mayor Wolfson and the Portland City Councilors.

2379
04:14:49.111 --> 04:14:52.707
<v Enzo Carpio>My name is Enzo Carpio, and I am a Hi, I'm Sameer Kanal.

2380
04:14:53.450 --> 04:14:54.191
<v Enzo Carpio>I'm a high schooler.

2381
04:14:54.289 --> 04:15:07.584
<v Enzo Carpio>I'm here to support the sanctuary city ordinance, and I am deeply concerned about the expansion of the federal immigration and the unlawful use it has, not just in Oregon but in the whole country.

2382
04:15:10.489 --> 04:15:13.075
<v Enzo Carpio>My family and most of my friends are immigrants.

2383
04:15:13.641 --> 04:15:16.083
<v Enzo Carpio>They have done nothing illegal, though.

2384
04:15:16.713 --> 04:15:17.635
<v Enzo Carpio>They have committed no crime.

2385
04:15:17.683 --> 04:15:18.056
<v Enzo Carpio>They've harmed nobody.

2386
04:15:18.634 --> 04:15:37.389
<v Enzo Carpio>Nothing wrong morally or legally, and yet they are still scared of going on public transportation, of going to work, going to school, because they believe that if they are seen by ICE, they will be arrested because of how they look or because of an accent.

2387
04:15:39.513 --> 04:15:48.612
<v Enzo Carpio>Now, since January of 2025, the Schumer administration has rescinded protections for sensitive locations like the schools, hospitals, and houses of worship.

2388
04:15:49.721 --> 04:15:57.906
<v Enzo Carpio>And there are reports of ICE agents arresting people without due process, refusing to identify themselves, and targeting individuals based on race and ethnicity.

2389
04:15:59.302 --> 04:16:07.176
<v Enzo Carpio>In Oregon, an estimated 108,000 people alone would face potential deportation under these aggressive actions.

2390
04:16:08.659 --> 04:16:11.549
<v Enzo Carpio>And this climate of fear tears apart the families.

2391
04:16:12.048 --> 04:16:13.720
<v Enzo Carpio>It disrupts the children's education.

2392
04:16:14.235 --> 04:16:20.635
<v Enzo Carpio>It prevents people from accessing healthcare and undermines the trust between the communities and the local law enforcement that's supposed to keep everyone safe.

2393
04:16:23.055 --> 04:16:27.250
<v Enzo Carpio>And immigrants in Portland, they make up 50% of the workforce.

2394
04:16:27.941 --> 04:16:36.845
<v Enzo Carpio>They are 19% of the entrepreneurs, and they contribute $12.4 billion annually to our regional economy, including $5 billion in taxes.

2395
04:16:38.745 --> 04:16:43.851
<v Enzo Carpio>Protecting immigrant and refugee families protects Portland's prosperity, its safety, and values.

2396
04:16:44.429 --> 04:16:58.140
<v Enzo Carpio>By passing this ordinance, you will keep families together, protect children, uphold constitutional principles, strengthen the community safety, and affirm that in Portland, no matter where you were born or what language you speak, you belong here and you deserve to be treated with dignity and respect.

2397
04:16:58.655 --> 04:17:00.790
<v Enzo Carpio>I urge you all to vote yes on this legislation.

2398
04:17:01.064 --> 04:17:01.385
<v Enzo Carpio>Thank you.

2399
04:17:01.465 --> 04:17:02.252
<v Jackie Matzer>Thank you.

2400
04:17:03.815 --> 04:17:07.897
<v Hugo Flores>Hi, my name is Hugo Flores, and I'm a member of District 4.

2401
04:17:08.656 --> 04:17:15.474
<v Hugo Flores>As a first-generation Mexican American, I am part of the community that this measure is written to support and protect.

2402
04:17:17.102 --> 04:17:24.174
<v Hugo Flores>I want to say thank you for your sincere compassion and make a stand against this unjust, racist federal government.

2403
04:17:24.933 --> 04:17:26.079
<v Hugo Flores>I support this measure.

2404
04:17:26.225 --> 04:17:27.039
<v Hugo Flores>I want it to pass.

2405
04:17:27.448 --> 04:17:39.456
<v Hugo Flores>However, unanswered questions on cost and with Portland Police may we ask you to hold off another week and try to provide some answers to ensure better transparency and bridge much-needed unity within our city.

2406
04:17:40.433 --> 04:17:49.990
<v Hugo Flores>This rush to put something out there so that we can, as a word, as the president of his council says, meet the moment with unanswered questions regarding funding, is eroding public trust.

2407
04:17:50.856 --> 04:17:56.903
<v Hugo Flores>This resolution speaks of Portland Police Bureau's deep commitment to constitutional policing and mental health supports.

2408
04:17:56.950 --> 04:17:57.415
<v Isabella Shepherd>Councilmember Gonzalez.

2409
04:17:57.913 --> 04:18:01.293
<v Hugo Flores>However, my experience with Portland Police has been far from that.

2410
04:18:01.854 --> 04:18:11.435
<v Hugo Flores>My own recent painful experience with them involving a mental health crisis with my family member resulted in the violations of my civil rights and the loss of my dog Snoopy.

2411
04:18:12.414 --> 04:18:17.653
<v Hugo Flores>This act of solidarity to show your support to fight a very real threat towards immigrants from the feds is noble.

2412
04:18:18.278 --> 04:18:29.632
<v Hugo Flores>Yet I just can't wrap my head around that when a direct request for justice and accountability was sent from the son of those very immigrants, My request was met with complete silence from every one of your offices.

2413
04:18:30.485 --> 04:18:31.063
<v Hugo Flores>Think about that.

2414
04:18:31.674 --> 04:18:48.108
<v Hugo Flores>Your inaction to respond to local police abuses from your constituent makes me kind of understand the point of view that it is easier to politically be a hero fighting the federal boogeyman than it is to actually be a responsive public servant solving local crises.

2415
04:18:49.103 --> 04:18:52.541
<v Hugo Flores>It appears the resources are there and public commitment is immediate.

2416
04:18:53.246 --> 04:18:58.604
<v Hugo Flores>And the bureaucratic gears can turn right away, which is fine because this is much needed.

2417
04:18:59.090 --> 04:19:04.236
<v Hugo Flores>So I believe that the city can also act with the same urgency that us as locals face.

2418
04:19:05.027 --> 04:19:09.316
<v Hugo Flores>And I just wanna say thank you to Mayor Wilson's office 'cause they were very kind to respond to my email.

2419
04:19:10.368 --> 04:19:10.841
<v Hugo Flores>So thank you.

2420
04:19:15.787 --> 04:19:16.272
<v Ross Taylor>Thank you.

2421
04:19:16.645 --> 04:19:18.377
<v Ricky King>I thought there was a mendon before me, my bad.

2422
04:19:18.845 --> 04:19:21.664
<v Ricky King>My name is Ricky King and I'm a resident of District 3.

2423
04:19:21.727 --> 04:19:27.153
<v Ricky King>I'm also the grandchild of Afro-Latin immigrants and a Lummi descendant of the Caribbean Arawak tribes.

2424
04:19:27.890 --> 04:19:30.649
<v Ricky King>I'm here in favor of the sanctuary ordinance.

2425
04:19:30.713 --> 04:19:37.177
<v Ricky King>I'd like to thank your offices for supporting it and for bringing it here, and to support leaving in the FOIA request language in the ordinance as is.

2426
04:19:38.093 --> 04:19:46.882
<v Ricky King>We need our city workers to be prepared for an increasingly weaponized ICE, especially since as of this summer, they are now better funded than most of the militaries in the world.

2427
04:19:47.540 --> 04:19:58.905
<v Ricky King>Our City of Portland workers, especially those from immigrant and Latin communities who are most impacted, Deserve clear infrastructure about what to do when queried or confronted by ICE agents or other federal agencies.

2428
04:19:59.801 --> 04:20:09.495
<v Ricky King>A lot of time when I hear talk about law enforcement, it's— there's the assumption that any and all law enforcement is by default fair, constitutional, and itself lawful.

2429
04:20:10.136 --> 04:20:15.486
<v Ricky King>But the constitutional right to legal counsel is denied for immigration proceedings.

2430
04:20:16.944 --> 04:20:31.397
<v Ricky King>And 2017 research into migration policy showed that one of the most effective ways to prevent these deportations and to keep our community members here was by addressing the due process gap at the local level.

2431
04:20:32.423 --> 04:20:38.351
<v Ricky King>The 2017 resolution addressed the issue of legal representation and the due process gap.

2432
04:20:38.656 --> 04:20:40.337
<v Ricky King>From what I can tell, it was in the short term.

2433
04:20:41.235 --> 04:20:50.255
<v Ricky King>That part of the resolution reads, be it further resolved that the City of Portland will support the Multnomah County Public Defenders in its work to help immigrants fight deportation.

2434
04:20:50.770 --> 04:20:55.646
<v Ricky King>Including through the February 2017 allocation of $50,000.

2435
04:20:56.127 --> 04:21:03.618
<v Ricky King>I'm not saying that they need to go specifically through the public defenders, but how are other ways that our city can address the due process gap at the local level?

2436
04:21:03.698 --> 04:21:06.441
<v Ricky King>I know I'm about out of time, so I urge you and your staffers to vote yes.

2437
04:21:07.290 --> 04:21:13.739
<v Ricky King>I urge you to vote yes and for you and your staffers to look further into ways that we can protect our immigrant population further.

2438
04:21:14.012 --> 04:21:18.005
<v Ricky King>In what ways does PPB still help ICE by corralling nonviolent protesters?

2439
04:21:18.452 --> 04:21:19.343
<v Ricky King>Like you heard about today?

2440
04:21:19.747 --> 04:21:21.852
<v Ricky King>In what ways are we not meeting the due process gap?

2441
04:21:21.966 --> 04:21:23.083
<v Ricky King>Thank you for your time.

2442
04:21:24.766 --> 04:21:25.608
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

2443
04:21:26.076 --> 04:21:28.648
<v Keelan McClymont>Tyler Fellini has joined us online.

2444
04:21:31.606 --> 04:21:32.058
<v Tyler Fellini>Hi, good evening.

2445
04:21:32.123 --> 04:21:38.190
<v Tyler Fellini>My name is Tyler Fellini and I'm the executive director of and a registered lobbyist for Portland Jobs and Justice.

2446
04:21:38.496 --> 04:21:42.156
<v Tyler Fellini>I'm a resident of District 3 and I'm also a third-generation immigrant.

2447
04:21:42.885 --> 04:21:48.393
<v Tyler Fellini>I'm in regulation with FOIA Chicago, D.C., and L.A., and I fear that the worst has yet to come for Portland.

2448
04:21:49.177 --> 04:21:58.041
<v Tyler Fellini>I appreciate the spirit of the resolution and ordinance before the council this evening, and I appreciate how this council has chosen to be bold at a time when so many organizations have preemptively complied.

2449
04:21:58.636 --> 04:22:02.337
<v Tyler Fellini>However, we know this doesn't go far enough, and I want to encourage you to push for more.

2450
04:22:02.403 --> 04:22:07.340
<v Tyler Fellini>Please continue investigating ICE's land use violations and encourage the city attorney to take action.

2451
04:22:07.611 --> 04:22:10.865
<v Tyler Fellini>Please consider other ways to impede federal agents' assaults on Portlanders.

2452
04:22:11.363 --> 04:22:18.922
<v Tyler Fellini>Like bans on them concealing their identity and legal challenges targeting their indiscriminate use of chemical weapons, similar to recent legal efforts in Illinois.

2453
04:22:20.109 --> 04:22:25.501
<v Tyler Fellini>And lastly, please continue reviewing the ways in which local law enforcement engages with protesters and federal agents.

2454
04:22:26.302 --> 04:22:38.242
<v Tyler Fellini>On this point, I'm going to echo what others have said, and I'd encourage the council to review the ways in which PPB's rapid response team is actually causing more chaos and potential danger to protesters by attempting to keep the one block in front of the ICE building clear and open to vehicular traffic.

2455
04:22:38.965 --> 04:22:42.754
<v Tyler Fellini>Only to vacate the area the moment federal officers begin pushing protesters back into the street.

2456
04:22:43.637 --> 04:22:53.656
<v Tyler Fellini>This reckless endangerment of peaceful protesters runs counter to the language within both the resolution and the ordinance, and it seems to me that an easy fix would be for PPB to actually shut down the street to vehicular traffic.

2457
04:22:54.700 --> 04:23:00.689
<v Tyler Fellini>Citizens of Portland are looking to all of you now to protect our rights, to defend our values, and to fight for dignity and safety for all of us.

2458
04:23:01.443 --> 04:23:02.664
<v Tyler Fellini>I have faith that you're up for the task.

2459
04:23:03.146 --> 04:23:03.403
<v Tyler Fellini>Thank you.

2460
04:23:10.051 --> 04:23:12.940
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm checking to see if Mindan Okan is here.

2461
04:23:17.031 --> 04:23:29.911
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Brittany Jones, Stephanie Engelsman, Annie Naranjo Rivera, Aiden Summers, Brian Kim.

2462
04:23:37.891 --> 04:23:38.951
<v Keelan McClymont>Go ahead, Brittany.

2463
04:23:39.015 --> 04:23:43.075
<v Brittany Jones>Hello, my name is Brittany Jones.

2464
04:23:43.188 --> 04:23:50.811
<v Brittany Jones>I am a Democratic candidate for Governor of Oregon, founder of the Ravens Party, and a PLRC for District 50 for the Multnomah County Democrats.

2465
04:23:51.518 --> 04:23:56.236
<v Brittany Jones>I'm mixed indigenous of Patawomeck, Mexican, and Welsh descent, and I'm here to talk to you today about ICE.

2466
04:23:57.006 --> 04:23:57.120
<v Brittany Jones>Yes.

2467
04:23:57.445 --> 04:24:02.310
<v Brittany Jones>But I want to start with a reminder that if you are of European descent, then you are a descendant of illegal immigrants.

2468
04:24:03.596 --> 04:24:17.770
<v Brittany Jones>Even if your ancestors didn't directly steal land, you are actively benefiting from stolen land, benefiting from the genocide and forced assimilation of our community, benefiting from the death and enslavement of the Black community, and benefiting from the low-cost labor our Southern relatives provide.

2469
04:24:19.632 --> 04:24:28.472
<v Brittany Jones>With that being said, Indigenous People's Day is a state-recognized holiday, yet this year our community had to gather outside of the ICE facility To take a stand for our stolen relatives.

2470
04:24:30.867 --> 04:24:37.797
<v Brittany Jones>ICE does not have the authority to detain citizens, and yet they have detained an elder multiple times, one time cutting off her bra and stealing her skirt.

2471
04:24:38.467 --> 04:24:42.465
<v Brittany Jones>They have detained a 17-year-old Two-Spirit and stole his flag, pinning it to the wall like a trophy.

2472
04:24:43.818 --> 04:24:46.844
<v Brittany Jones>Just a few days ago, they seemed to flashbang protesters.

2473
04:24:47.360 --> 04:24:55.318
<v Brittany Jones>People gathered to exercise their First Amendment right, talking among themselves, some even wearing inflatable animal costumes, and I know how terrifying that might be for some of you.

2474
04:24:57.003 --> 04:25:03.944
<v Brittany Jones>So I want to ask you a question that I hear every time I have delivered supplies to camp, every time I have stood shoulder to shoulder with my community: Where are our leaders?

2475
04:25:05.729 --> 04:25:07.466
<v Brittany Jones>So I want to ask you, where are you?

2476
04:25:08.743 --> 04:25:10.417
<v Brittany Jones>What are you doing besides signing papers?

2477
04:25:10.933 --> 04:25:14.845
<v Brittany Jones>Because our community knows all too well how little a signed piece of paper means to your government.

2478
04:25:16.027 --> 04:25:20.742
<v Brittany Jones>Today, if you—if any of you plan to vote no, I come here demanding that you join us, that you stand with us and.

2479
04:25:29.663 --> 04:25:36.619
<v Brittany Jones>Then take what you learned and use it to make change, to see why keeping ICE from being militarized is important and why we must keep the Guard from deploying in our city.

2480
04:25:37.036 --> 04:25:38.110
<v Brittany Jones>Silence is compliance.

2481
04:25:38.157 --> 04:25:39.183
<v Brittany Jones>Compliance is complicity.

2482
04:25:39.617 --> 04:25:43.912
<v Brittany Jones>If you are not willing to lead from the front, then step down to allow someone who is willing to fight for us to take your place.

2483
04:25:43.976 --> 04:25:49.201
<v Brittany Jones>Councilor turning a blind eye, hoping it goes away, won't work with the fascist wannabe dictator in the White House.

2484
04:25:50.284 --> 04:25:50.590
<v Brittany Jones>Thank you.

2485
04:25:51.634 --> 04:25:52.774
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2486
04:25:54.606 --> 04:25:56.422
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>Uh, thank you all for still being here.

2487
04:25:56.550 --> 04:25:57.417
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>It's 10:22.

2488
04:25:57.980 --> 04:26:07.286
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>Um, and I just wanted to say, Council President, Vice President, and councilors, my name is Annie Naranjo Rivera, and I serve as the state director of the Oregon Working Families Party.

2489
04:26:08.185 --> 04:26:14.011
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>Um, we're a statewide grassroots political organization made up of community-based organizations and labor unions.

2490
04:26:14.582 --> 04:26:19.467
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>Who are committed to building a society that works for all of us, not just the wealthy and well-connected.

2491
04:26:20.519 --> 04:26:26.376
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>We advocate for economic justice, racial equity, and a democracy that centers working people and their communities.

2492
04:26:27.199 --> 04:26:35.468
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>I am also the daughter of a Cuban refugee, so the issue under consideration today is personal to me, as it is to so many of you and your constituents.

2493
04:26:37.096 --> 04:26:44.102
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>Working families in Portland and across all of Oregon value safety, free speech, and the right to organize without the fear of government intrusion for all people.

2494
04:26:45.899 --> 04:26:51.595
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>The current immigration enforcement violates these values and must be opposed with all the tools at our disposal.

2495
04:26:52.574 --> 04:27:06.532
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>We support both this ordinance with the emergency clause and the resolution under consideration tonight to improve Portland's commitment to all of its residents that they'll be protected from excessive immigration action and overreach by the federal government.

2496
04:27:07.398 --> 04:27:13.864
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>All people deserve to feel safe in our neighborhoods, and in the current political climate, our immigrant and refugee communities do not feel safe.

2497
04:27:13.913 --> 04:27:26.496
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>Councilmember immigrants and refugees face all the same hardships that working people across the country face, and they also face possibilities like being rounded up and thrown into detention with no due process at any time.

2498
04:27:27.800 --> 04:27:32.049
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>It's crucial that Portland take these practical steps to protect and provide for our communities.

2499
04:27:33.815 --> 04:27:45.745
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>As we've seen across the country, citizens as well as noncitizens have been terrorized by the federal government's immigration policies, and so it's essential that Portland take action tonight to protect and inform our most vulnerable vulnerable communities.

2500
04:27:46.251 --> 04:27:56.541
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>You have the opportunity and the people's mandate to lead with courage so that other cities may follow, not just here in Oregon but across the country.

2501
04:27:58.041 --> 04:28:07.066
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>We look to you for leadership at this time, and we're here to amplify the voices of tens of thousands of WFP members in Oregon who stand with you as you stand on the right side of history.

2502
04:28:07.728 --> 04:28:13.676
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>At the Working Families Party, we stand with everyday Oregonians who believe in upholding community safety, and we look forward to a unanimous vote.

2503
04:28:13.725 --> 04:28:13.837
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2504
04:28:13.887 --> 04:28:14.582
<v Annie Naranjo Rivera>I'm sorry, I have to take a vote from others.

2505
04:28:15.704 --> 04:28:16.153
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2506
04:28:16.569 --> 04:28:19.918
<v Aiden Summers>Hi, uh, for the record, my name is Aiden Summers.

2507
04:28:20.254 --> 04:28:23.796
<v Aiden Summers>Um, I'm a registered lobbyist for the Portland chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America.

2508
04:28:24.421 --> 04:28:32.433
<v Aiden Summers>Um, we fully support both the, the resolution and the ordinance before it, especially with the, um, you know, emergency amendment to pass this tonight.

2509
04:28:33.074 --> 04:28:43.858
<v Aiden Summers>Um, I think it's been encouraging hearing from folks of all, you know, or at least most walks of life around this city coming here In support of this.

2510
04:28:44.611 --> 04:28:50.603
<v Aiden Summers>I'm also really encouraged by the ordinance including partnerships with community organizations.

2511
04:28:51.197 --> 04:29:00.332
<v Aiden Summers>I think that's the kind of thing that we need a lot more of, partnerships between all these different organizations that have had many different representatives here today and council.

2512
04:29:00.891 --> 04:29:07.671
<v Aiden Summers>I think that's the only way that we're going to have the strength and presence to push back against what the federal government is trying to do in this city.

2513
04:29:08.296 --> 04:29:08.567
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Thank you.

2514
04:29:08.761 --> 04:29:18.592
<v Aiden Summers>So I thank you for this, this great first step, and I look forward to the many, many other resolutions and ordinances that'll come forward to try and face this difficult time.

2515
04:29:19.139 --> 04:29:19.688
<v Aiden Summers>Thank you.

2516
04:29:20.527 --> 04:29:28.849
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Thank you.

2517
04:29:33.877 --> 04:29:35.941
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, uh, let's see, Stephanie Engelsman.

2518
04:29:39.739 --> 04:29:53.341
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, um, next up, uh, Brian Kim, Makwa Crow, Jeremy Bosole Smith, Elizabeth Mintz.

2519
04:30:02.269 --> 04:30:04.572
<v Makwa Crow>Hello everyone, my name is Makwa.

2520
04:30:05.143 --> 04:30:14.023
<v Makwa Crow>I'm a Portland resident, a community organizer from Bad River Reservation and the Anishinaabe Nation, and at my core, I am an Indigenous land defender.

2521
04:30:14.795 --> 04:30:26.359
<v Makwa Crow>Over the past several months, I've been doing Know Your Rights work outside the Portland ICE facility, offering Know Your Rights booklets, connecting neighbors with legal support, and the occasional comfort to my neighbors as they attend appointments.

2522
04:30:27.259 --> 04:30:45.397
<v Makwa Crow>In this time, I have seen families ripped apart, individuals go in but not come out of that ICE facility, And I cannot ever forget the faces of detained immigrant community members transported via white GeoVans and now buses out on their way out of state.

2523
04:30:46.325 --> 04:30:53.584
<v Makwa Crow>As an organizer, I know that real safety depends on trust, and trust can only exist when people know their city will not turn them over to ICE.

2524
04:30:54.336 --> 04:30:58.808
<v Makwa Crow>And as a resident of Portland, I carry this truth that no one on this land is illegal.

2525
04:30:59.545 --> 04:31:01.852
<v Makwa Crow>All of us are living on indigenous territory.

2526
04:31:01.963 --> 04:31:02.092
<v Makwa Crow>Thank you.

2527
04:31:02.365 --> 04:31:06.521
<v Makwa Crow>And that understanding calls us to protect people seeking refuge and belonging.

2528
04:31:07.132 --> 04:31:12.259
<v Makwa Crow>I urge you to pass this code and make sanctuary not just a declaration but an action.

2529
04:31:13.180 --> 04:31:14.200
<v Makwa Crow>I ask that you vote yes.

2530
04:31:14.413 --> 04:31:14.889
<v Makwa Crow>Thank you for your time.

2531
04:31:19.393 --> 04:31:20.918
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>My name is Jeremy Bosley-Smith.

2532
04:31:21.175 --> 04:31:25.868
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>I am a member of the Portland Democratic Socialists of America, but speaking on my own behalf today.

2533
04:31:26.558 --> 04:31:28.871
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>Thank you to those who have brought these resolutions forward.

2534
04:31:29.429 --> 04:31:30.954
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>The world's looking at Portland right now.

2535
04:31:31.516 --> 04:31:34.327
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>You can hear the Customs and Border Patrol Black Hawk overhead.

2536
04:31:34.504 --> 04:31:37.186
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>I know I've been hearing it for the past month at my house.

2537
04:31:37.637 --> 04:31:41.138
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>Just a reminder that we're all being collectively punished for not complying.

2538
04:31:41.974 --> 04:31:46.840
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>Now is the time to lead by example and show this fascist regime that we're not afraid of them.

2539
04:31:47.514 --> 04:31:51.417
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>These resolutions are the first of a thousand steps we need to take to protect our neighbors.

2540
04:31:52.189 --> 04:31:54.277
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>The passage of these resolutions is not the end.

2541
04:31:54.356 --> 04:31:55.191
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>It is the beginning.

2542
04:31:55.612 --> 04:31:58.932
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>Of a greater campaign against the rise of fascism in our country.

2543
04:31:59.514 --> 04:32:00.940
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>Keep taking the fight to the feds.

2544
04:32:01.297 --> 04:32:02.656
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>I know we'll keep doing it in the streets.

2545
04:32:03.132 --> 04:32:03.458
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>Thank you.

2546
04:32:12.852 --> 04:32:14.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we have someone online.

2547
04:32:15.956 --> 04:32:17.814
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Yes, I don't know how to do this.

2548
04:32:18.315 --> 04:32:20.867
<v Elizabeth Mintz>I'm just gonna— first time, so what do I do?

2549
04:32:22.011 --> 04:32:26.040
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go ahead and introduce yourself, and you'll have 2 minutes for testimony.

2550
04:32:26.747 --> 04:32:27.630
<v Elizabeth Mintz>All right, thank you.

2551
04:32:27.808 --> 04:32:30.552
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Let me— hello, I'm Elizabeth.

2552
04:32:31.484 --> 04:32:37.103
<v Elizabeth Mintz>I encourage you to vote yes on the Protect Portland Initiative and the Sanctuary City Ordinance.

2553
04:32:38.019 --> 04:32:43.622
<v Elizabeth Mintz>I am a proud neurodivergent immigrant rights activist born and raised in the U.S.

2554
04:32:44.425 --> 04:32:56.565
<v Elizabeth Mintz>I spoke English as my first language and I was blessed to grow up in both the U.S. and Bolivian cultures and was taught to love all people and cultures just as God did.

2555
04:32:57.576 --> 04:32:59.695
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Currently, our democracy is at risk.

2556
04:33:00.082 --> 04:33:07.645
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Nirmal's Holocaust poem says, when they came for said minority, I did not speak up because I was not them.

2557
04:33:08.416 --> 04:33:11.401
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Then they came for me and there was no one left to protest.

2558
04:33:12.044 --> 04:33:14.502
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Today, dictator Trump is coming for the immigrants.

2559
04:33:14.549 --> 04:33:18.066
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Councilor and people who speak a different language or with an accent.

2560
04:33:18.853 --> 04:33:20.636
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Eventually they will come for us all.

2561
04:33:20.957 --> 04:33:26.707
<v Elizabeth Mintz>So vote yes on both sanctuary and protect Portland so that all can feel safe and welcomed.

2562
04:33:27.461 --> 04:33:35.268
<v Elizabeth Mintz>We as a collective must make a strong statement against the military occupying our cities, as this puts every single citizen at risk.

2563
04:33:35.894 --> 04:33:40.953
<v Elizabeth Mintz>We have witnessed ICE agents use chemical weapons on peaceful protesters, myself included.

2564
04:33:41.001 --> 04:33:48.301
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Councilmember unbadged federal agents aggressively arrest people and threaten an ambulance helping an injured activist.

2565
04:33:49.040 --> 04:33:55.971
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Next, we must broadly stand up to defend our city's sovereignty, because once it is taken away, we cannot regain it.

2566
04:33:56.901 --> 04:34:03.783
<v Elizabeth Mintz>We must also walk in unity with the city and community partners helping immigrants as they face budget cuts and arrests.

2567
04:34:04.362 --> 04:34:06.671
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Give immigrants some relief by standing behind them.

2568
04:34:07.330 --> 04:34:14.234
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Please encourage PPB to not engage in immigration enforcement, um, because everybody should be safe.

2569
04:34:14.491 --> 04:34:18.601
<v Elizabeth Mintz>They are ready or not— people are ready or not calling 911 out of fear.

2570
04:34:19.532 --> 04:34:24.205
<v Elizabeth Mintz>And lastly, please uphold the city's promise to solidify Portland's sanctuary status.

2571
04:34:24.719 --> 04:34:33.902
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Revoke the ICE permit today and say no to fascism by voting yes on the emergency clause by Emergency crossing.

2572
04:34:33.983 --> 04:34:35.046
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Yes, revoke the permit.

2573
04:34:35.111 --> 04:34:35.772
<v Elizabeth Mintz>God bless.

2574
04:34:36.383 --> 04:34:36.754
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Thank you.

2575
04:34:37.109 --> 04:34:38.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, thank you.

2576
04:34:40.967 --> 04:34:42.331
<v Elizabeth Mintz>How do I mute myself?

2577
04:34:44.163 --> 04:34:45.976
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We might be able to help you on our end.

2578
04:34:49.543 --> 04:34:57.699
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, uh, Brian Kim, Mahogany Bennett, Kim Jones.

2579
04:35:00.612 --> 04:35:01.770
<v Keelan McClymont>Seema Abhusseini.

2580
04:35:07.012 --> 04:35:07.977
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Go ahead.

2581
04:35:09.263 --> 04:35:11.418
<v Kim Jones>Hello, my name is Kim Jones.

2582
04:35:11.755 --> 04:35:17.685
<v Kim Jones>I am a 4th generation Mexican-American, and I've lived in Portland since 2017.

2583
04:35:18.583 --> 04:35:27.586
<v Kim Jones>I come here to stand in solidarity with my Latino siblings and all undocumented peoples who have sought safety in Portland but instead have suffered persecution for their citizenship.

2584
04:35:28.893 --> 04:35:35.893
<v Kim Jones>Portland is being attacked due to its commitment to equality, diversity, and community under the guise of fighting domestic terrorism.

2585
04:35:37.043 --> 04:35:41.652
<v Kim Jones>How can we call ourselves a sanctuary city before holding those terrorizing our community accountable?

2586
04:35:41.942 --> 04:35:47.012
<v Kim Jones>How can we protect Portland when we are protecting the pockets of the elite?

2587
04:35:47.543 --> 04:35:51.073
<v Kim Jones>Hold the real domestic terrorists accountable and revoke the ICE permit.

2588
04:35:51.102 --> 04:35:58.003
<v Kim Jones>Hold Stewart Lindquist, who makes $2 million a month by leasing the ICE building, accountable and for allowing 25 violations to its conditional land use permit.

2589
04:35:58.003 --> 04:35:58.062
<v Kim Jones>Councilmember Loretta Smith.

2590
04:35:59.782 --> 04:36:00.584
<v Kim Jones>Use contract.

2591
04:36:01.177 --> 04:36:04.835
<v Kim Jones>There has to be some sort of accountability factor amended into this resolution.

2592
04:36:05.509 --> 04:36:08.413
<v Kim Jones>I would like for our city council to consider that when drafting future.

2593
04:36:09.360 --> 04:36:15.665
<v Kim Jones>There should be no vagueness to abuse or loopholes for federal agents to use to continue committing acts of terror against our community.

2594
04:36:15.954 --> 04:36:22.274
<v Kim Jones>I'm here to express my support with changes for the Protect Portland initiative and ordinance to codify sanctuary status.

2595
04:36:22.900 --> 04:36:25.932
<v Kim Jones>I support this resolution and ordinance with the following changes.

2596
04:36:26.445 --> 04:36:37.813
<v Kim Jones>Emergency resolution to revoke the ICE permit and expand and elaborate on the prohibition, not just decline in participation, on city cooperation with federal agencies.

2597
04:36:38.809 --> 04:36:42.791
<v Kim Jones>This city council paved the way for what we are seeing today by allowing this permit in 2011.

2598
04:36:43.129 --> 04:36:45.905
<v Kim Jones>You have the power and moral responsibility to revoke it.

2599
04:36:46.837 --> 04:36:49.005
<v Kim Jones>Thank you for your time, and chinga la migra.

2600
04:36:49.871 --> 04:36:51.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2601
04:36:56.716 --> 04:36:58.720
<v Keelan McClymont>Simab is online.

2602
04:37:01.883 --> 04:37:02.530
<v Simab Husseini>Yes, greetings.

2603
04:37:02.644 --> 04:37:03.276
<v Simab Husseini>Can you guys hear me?

2604
04:37:04.248 --> 04:37:04.881
<v Keelan McClymont>We can hear you.

2605
04:37:04.993 --> 04:37:05.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, we can.

2606
04:37:05.626 --> 04:37:06.664
<v Simab Husseini>Okay, wonderful.

2607
04:37:06.922 --> 04:37:08.850
<v Simab Husseini>Uh, good evening, Mayor and city councilors.

2608
04:37:09.654 --> 04:37:24.808
<v Simab Husseini>My name is Simab Husseini, a community organizer working alongside immigrant and refugee communities who live every day with the threat of the fascism and the tyranny of immigration kidnapping and have been victims of civil rights violations over decades.

2609
04:37:25.418 --> 04:37:31.087
<v Simab Husseini>I'm here in strong support of codifying, codifying Portland's sanctuary city resolution and ordinance.

2610
04:37:31.938 --> 04:37:37.480
<v Simab Husseini>This is an important step, one that moves our city from promises and resolutions into binding law.

2611
04:37:38.380 --> 04:37:46.026
<v Simab Husseini>It says clearly that Portland will not allow its people or its resources to be used to harm our neighbors because of where they were born.

2612
04:37:46.074 --> 04:37:46.202
<v Simab Husseini>Thank you.

2613
04:37:47.359 --> 04:37:51.311
<v Simab Husseini>But I also want to be clear, passing this is only the beginning, not the end.

2614
04:37:51.616 --> 04:38:03.473
<v Simab Husseini>The strength of this law will depend on how it's implemented, how city staff are trained, and how communities most impacted by ICE and federal overreach stay centered in oversight and accountability.

2615
04:38:04.694 --> 04:38:12.390
<v Simab Husseini>Codifying sanctuary must come with a living structure that ensures city employees, departments, and partnerships all understand their obligations.

2616
04:38:12.504 --> 04:38:12.599
<v Aiden Summers>Thank you.

2617
04:38:13.454 --> 04:38:16.790
<v Simab Husseini>And that immigrant communities have a seat at that table.

2618
04:38:17.983 --> 04:38:20.755
<v Simab Husseini>We also know that sanctuary without investment is fragile.

2619
04:38:22.032 --> 04:38:23.547
<v Simab Husseini>We cannot just declare safety.

2620
04:38:24.346 --> 04:38:26.235
<v Simab Husseini>We must, we must build it.

2621
04:38:28.413 --> 04:38:38.791
<v Simab Husseini>Portland modeled this commitment through the Diversity and Civic Leadership Program under Civic Life, which invested directly in community-based organizations, many immigrant and refugee-led.

2622
04:38:40.162 --> 04:38:44.319
<v Simab Husseini>To build civic and leadership, civic power and leadership across communities.

2623
04:38:45.314 --> 04:38:48.332
<v Simab Husseini>I know because I organized under this precious funding for 3 years.

2624
04:38:49.151 --> 04:38:55.074
<v Simab Husseini>We need to build on that same spirit now, but matched to today's realities.

2625
04:38:56.068 --> 04:39:06.711
<v Simab Husseini>Reinvesting in programs like DCL and expanding funding for immigrant and refugee organizations that provide legal support and advocacy and healing is how we meet the needs of this moment.

2626
04:39:06.776 --> 04:39:06.871
<v Simab Husseini>Thank you.

2627
04:39:07.530 --> 04:39:17.241
<v Simab Husseini>I know the city faces real budget constraints, but even in scarcity, we must invest in what keeps people safe, in the networks that prevent harm before it happens.

2628
04:39:17.452 --> 04:39:24.730
<v Simab Husseini>So yes, codify this resolution and ordinance, and let's commit to building a Portland where sanctuary is not just law but practice, culture, and care.

2629
04:39:25.573 --> 04:39:26.458
<v Simab Husseini>Melt ice, free Palestine.

2630
04:39:26.651 --> 04:39:26.958
<v Simab Husseini>Thank you.

2631
04:39:33.084 --> 04:39:35.580
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, um, Adina Wing.

2632
04:39:37.061 --> 04:39:38.013
<v Keelan McClymont>Katie Cowie.

2633
04:39:39.485 --> 04:39:40.387
<v Keelan McClymont>Robert Butler.

2634
04:39:54.532 --> 04:39:56.032
<v Robert Butler>By popular demand, I'm back.

2635
04:39:59.093 --> 04:40:08.103
<v Robert Butler>Well, 108,000 people in Oregon, immigrants at risk.

2636
04:40:12.451 --> 04:40:13.297
<v Robert Butler>What are you going to do about it?

2637
04:40:17.557 --> 04:40:18.736
<v Robert Butler>We have a problem.

2638
04:40:20.526 --> 04:40:26.054
<v Robert Butler>There's this guy who opened the borders, let in millions of people.

2639
04:40:26.812 --> 04:40:30.203
<v Robert Butler>We didn't even know what they were, who they were, what they were going to do.

2640
04:40:31.812 --> 04:40:33.073
<v Robert Butler>Millions.

2641
04:40:33.073 --> 04:40:35.242
<v Robert Butler>We got 108,000 of those in Oregon.

2642
04:40:36.672 --> 04:40:39.573
<v Robert Butler>Maybe with kids now.

2643
04:40:40.453 --> 04:40:44.352
<v Robert Butler>Maybe they're criminals.

2644
04:40:44.352 --> 04:40:45.622
<v Robert Butler>What do we do?

2645
04:40:46.372 --> 04:40:50.782
<v Robert Butler>How many of those are in Portland of the 108,000?

2646
04:40:51.953 --> 04:40:52.633
<v Robert Butler>What are we going to do?

2647
04:40:52.712 --> 04:40:52.933
<v Loretta Smith>We're going to do what we've always done.

2648
04:40:53.709 --> 04:40:55.157
<v Robert Butler>This is not the answer.

2649
04:40:58.860 --> 04:40:59.640
<v Robert Butler>We need answers.

2650
04:41:01.365 --> 04:41:01.885
<v Robert Butler>What do we do?

2651
04:41:07.102 --> 04:41:17.174
<v Robert Butler>The other thing is that, just for example, no city employee will help ICE.

2652
04:41:21.103 --> 04:41:36.619
<v Robert Butler>So if I'm a city employee and I call a whistleblower on some criminal immigrant, I have violated— no city employee will help ICE.

2653
04:41:38.709 --> 04:41:45.077
<v Robert Butler>The mailman that was just here on your side, He's a federal employee.

2654
04:41:47.294 --> 04:41:48.021
<v Robert Butler>Reverse that.

2655
04:41:49.538 --> 04:41:50.247
<v Robert Butler>Reverse that.

2656
04:41:51.247 --> 04:41:55.266
<v Robert Butler>What if he was a city employee helping Trump?

2657
04:41:56.163 --> 04:41:56.904
<v Robert Butler>What would you do?

2658
04:41:57.631 --> 04:42:03.165
<v Robert Butler>That guy had the safety of coming here and being safe.

2659
04:42:04.084 --> 04:42:07.012
<v Robert Butler>Otherwise, what would you do to his job as an employee?

2660
04:42:07.193 --> 04:42:08.362
<v Robert Butler>He's a federal employee.

2661
04:42:09.856 --> 04:42:10.843
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

2662
04:42:14.505 --> 04:42:17.013
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, um, just doing one more check.

2663
04:42:17.141 --> 04:42:25.449
<v Keelan McClymont>Mahogany Bennett, Adina Wing, Katie Towey.

2664
04:42:29.301 --> 04:42:30.463
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much, Keelan.

2665
04:42:30.527 --> 04:42:35.026
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you to everybody who has been here to share your thoughts.

2666
04:42:35.348 --> 04:42:37.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Support and concerns with us this evening.

2667
04:42:39.552 --> 04:42:41.008
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, it is 10:39.

2668
04:42:41.364 --> 04:42:43.352
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have 2 items before us.

2669
04:42:43.854 --> 04:42:54.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have staff ready to stay until 11, and I am working to see if we can stay later to get through things, but how long this takes will depend on how well we work together.

2670
04:42:54.593 --> 04:43:04.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we are moving back to, um, separate debate and discussion on these 2 agenda items.

2671
04:43:04.976 --> 04:43:14.050
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will take agenda item— what is this, 6— first, which is the resolution which creates the Protect Portland Initiative.

2672
04:43:14.761 --> 04:43:16.865
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see a number of folks in the queue.

2673
04:43:16.929 --> 04:43:20.050
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, are you in the queue to debate the Protect Portland Initiative?

2674
04:43:25.140 --> 04:43:26.125
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, Madam President.

2675
04:43:28.975 --> 04:43:29.443
<v Loretta Smith>Go right ahead.

2676
04:43:32.123 --> 04:43:40.388
<v Loretta Smith>I, uh, first want to commend my colleagues for sponsoring this legislation, for coming together to shape this powerful resolution.

2677
04:43:41.593 --> 04:43:53.991
<v Loretta Smith>As Portlanders, we are sick and tired of folks taking down— talking down to our city, um, fearmongering and launching baseless accusations about our city.

2678
04:43:54.449 --> 04:43:55.955
<v Loretta Smith>Councilmember Herbold.

2679
04:43:56.293 --> 04:44:04.760
<v Loretta Smith>I'm proud that despite our many differences, we can stand together and denounce the chaotic lawlessness of the Trump administration.

2680
04:44:05.755 --> 04:44:07.984
<v Loretta Smith>It has gone on for too long.

2681
04:44:09.219 --> 04:44:26.614
<v Loretta Smith>The Protect Portland provisions underline a management philosophy, and I recognize the emphasis on the city's leverage as an employer to reinforce our obligations to our labor partners and city staff in creating safe working environments.

2682
04:44:27.399 --> 04:44:33.504
<v Loretta Smith>Creating a public-facing information hub is something I strongly support.

2683
04:44:34.705 --> 04:44:38.118
<v Loretta Smith>The city contractor preparedness plan is particularly compelling.

2684
04:44:39.336 --> 04:44:47.236
<v Loretta Smith>If private contractors receive public dollars, they should be held to the same standards as public servants.

2685
04:44:47.856 --> 04:44:50.333
<v Loretta Smith>Extending to protecting the public.

2686
04:44:52.184 --> 04:45:09.148
<v Loretta Smith>I won't take up a lot of time, but I look forward to working with everyone on council closely and with the mayor and the Public Safety Service Area to successfully enact the provisions relating to the Portland Police Bureau.

2687
04:45:09.711 --> 04:45:10.179
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2688
04:45:10.903 --> 04:45:11.646
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2689
04:45:11.725 --> 04:45:17.136
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, are you in the queue to debate this Yeah, I'll keep my comments very brief.

2690
04:45:17.296 --> 04:45:30.029
<v Mitch Green>I'll post a longer statement about this, but I just want to say the value of this resolution is that it expresses this body's will in one document, in one vote.

2691
04:45:30.736 --> 04:45:40.182
<v Mitch Green>And we're— I'm very grateful to have a mayor who has led with the same values that I see in the resolution, but we may not always have a mayor that's like that.

2692
04:45:40.935 --> 04:45:44.671
<v Mitch Green>And so the ability of this resolution here today is to lay our values down here on the table.

2693
04:45:44.736 --> 04:45:44.912
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2694
04:45:45.185 --> 04:45:56.361
<v Mitch Green>It's never been more urgent to denounce this administration and its attempts to use our city as a site of increased fascism.

2695
04:45:57.371 --> 04:46:05.062
<v Mitch Green>I'm personally going to also denounce a number of the comments I heard tonight saying that we need ICE in our community and that ICE is somehow a compromised position.

2696
04:46:05.656 --> 04:46:07.809
<v Mitch Green>We'll never compromise on that.

2697
04:46:08.209 --> 04:46:09.173
<v Mitch Green>That's where I stand on that.

2698
04:46:09.222 --> 04:46:09.333
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

2699
04:46:09.431 --> 04:46:10.025
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor Mitch Green.

2700
04:46:10.523 --> 04:46:11.195
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2701
04:46:11.276 --> 04:46:12.765
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Morillo, to the resolution.

2702
04:46:13.903 --> 04:46:18.886
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, this is me urging my colleagues for us to stop talking and just vote this through tonight.

2703
04:46:19.207 --> 04:46:22.444
<v Angelita Morillo>Our constituents have been waiting for months and months and months for this to happen.

2704
04:46:22.573 --> 04:46:23.726
<v Angelita Morillo>This is a good resolution.

2705
04:46:23.919 --> 04:46:31.883
<v Angelita Morillo>It outlines everything our city values, and we have some codification stuff that is also going to materially hit really hard and is gonna be really helpful.

2706
04:46:31.948 --> 04:46:35.201
<v Angelita Morillo>So let's just get it done tonight, guys.

2707
04:46:35.296 --> 04:46:35.921
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm begging you.

2708
04:46:37.106 --> 04:46:37.833
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2709
04:46:37.915 --> 04:46:38.771
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

2710
04:46:42.760 --> 04:46:44.199
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks there, Angelita.

2711
04:46:44.440 --> 04:46:46.813
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I don't disagree.

2712
04:46:46.878 --> 04:46:56.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think perhaps I will request to violate the rule in the spirit when we don't speak when we vote, and I'll share some comments then.

2713
04:46:56.082 --> 04:46:58.039
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm in full support of everything that's on the table tonight.

2714
04:46:59.516 --> 04:47:02.241
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Why don't we give ourselves each about 3 sentences when we vote?

2715
04:47:04.082 --> 04:47:04.757
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

2716
04:47:05.783 --> 04:47:06.152
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2717
04:47:06.248 --> 04:47:17.208
<v Sameer Kanal>I will withdraw this if it's not friendly, but I wanted to ask— I heard in the testimony the request that we adjust the word residents to residents and visitors throughout, and that was a compelling argument to me.

2718
04:47:17.738 --> 04:47:32.316
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I would both, uh, I would, I would make the, the proposal, move to amend in all scenarios in the document residents to residents and visitors, ask Councilor Avalos and the other co-sponsors if it's friendly, and then ask the Council President, to ask for unanimous consent.

2719
04:47:34.223 --> 04:47:35.552
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos's thumbs up.

2720
04:47:36.040 --> 04:47:37.580
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kreil-Mullane's thumbs up.

2721
04:47:37.662 --> 04:47:38.538
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark?

2722
04:47:40.241 --> 04:47:41.702
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark is nodding yes.

2723
04:47:42.897 --> 04:47:46.212
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know that we can do that through unanimous consent.

2724
04:47:46.294 --> 04:47:48.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We had to discuss it about— Let's take a quick vote, please.

2725
04:47:48.315 --> 04:47:48.623
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2726
04:47:49.595 --> 04:47:50.662
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will second that.

2727
04:47:51.293 --> 04:47:56.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if there is no discussion— Councilor Ryan, are you in the queue to discuss this amendment?

2728
04:47:58.613 --> 04:47:58.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2729
04:47:59.013 --> 04:48:00.788
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

2730
04:48:03.126 --> 04:48:03.512
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

2731
04:48:03.915 --> 04:48:04.076
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2732
04:48:04.800 --> 04:48:05.108
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

2733
04:48:05.445 --> 04:48:05.622
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2734
04:48:06.090 --> 04:48:06.396
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

2735
04:48:06.653 --> 04:48:06.782
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2736
04:48:07.234 --> 04:48:07.604
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

2737
04:48:07.863 --> 04:48:07.911
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2738
04:48:08.829 --> 04:48:08.925
<v Robert Butler>Aye.

2739
04:48:10.037 --> 04:48:10.085
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2740
04:48:10.778 --> 04:48:11.084
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Knall.

2741
04:48:11.326 --> 04:48:11.375
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2742
04:48:11.729 --> 04:48:11.955
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

2743
04:48:13.104 --> 04:48:13.153
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

2744
04:48:13.994 --> 04:48:14.544
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

2745
04:48:14.884 --> 04:48:14.934
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

2746
04:48:15.322 --> 04:48:15.564
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo.

2747
04:48:16.018 --> 04:48:16.195
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2748
04:48:16.438 --> 04:48:16.761
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

2749
04:48:17.069 --> 04:48:17.117
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2750
04:48:17.507 --> 04:48:17.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2751
04:48:17.635 --> 04:48:21.263
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 12 yes votes.

2752
04:48:22.028 --> 04:48:22.727
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

2753
04:48:22.842 --> 04:48:25.411
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, are you in the queue to discuss the resolution?

2754
04:48:27.037 --> 04:48:27.901
<v Dan Ryan>I am, I am.

2755
04:48:28.158 --> 04:48:32.006
<v Dan Ryan>First of all, I agree that we should try to keep this brief now.

2756
04:48:33.047 --> 04:48:37.312
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to say thank you to all my colleagues that worked so hard on this.

2757
04:48:37.376 --> 04:48:39.268
<v Dan Ryan>I'm so sorry I'm not in council chambers.

2758
04:48:39.701 --> 04:48:43.628
<v Dan Ryan>I do believe in science, and I had an opportunity to get my vaccines today.

2759
04:48:44.028 --> 04:48:48.886
<v Dan Ryan>I think going forward I'll get them one at a time, but I just am really supportive of this.

2760
04:48:48.983 --> 04:48:51.788
<v Dan Ryan>I do have a question, and I have to get it out there.

2761
04:48:51.835 --> 04:48:51.883
<v Dan Ryan>Sure.

2762
04:48:52.012 --> 04:48:55.705
<v Dan Ryan>Can we get information about the budget impacts of the legislation in front of us tonight?

2763
04:48:56.283 --> 04:49:03.862
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to make sure that the budget office, uh, or someone speaks to the cost of the training, um, because we're in such a budget challenge.

2764
04:49:04.070 --> 04:49:10.751
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to make sure that what we're voting on actually gets implemented and that, um, we're aware of the cost.

2765
04:49:10.991 --> 04:49:11.361
<v Sameer Kanal>That's all.

2766
04:49:12.019 --> 04:49:13.753
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for that question, Councilor Ryan.

2767
04:49:13.898 --> 04:49:28.460
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll note that we did work with the administration to try to ensure that things could tag onto other trainings that existed, but we happen to have Mr. Biery here filling in as Acting City Administrator, and I'd ask if you could answer this question.

2768
04:49:29.279 --> 04:49:30.419
<v Jonas Biery>Yes, Council President.

2769
04:49:30.820 --> 04:49:34.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For the record, Jonas Biery, Chief Financial Officer, sitting in for the City Administrator tonight.

2770
04:49:34.979 --> 04:49:42.751
<v Sameer Kanal>That's correct that we believe the training is aligning and consistent with other activities in motion using existing resources.

2771
04:49:43.524 --> 04:49:47.743
<v Sameer Kanal>And so anticipate that budget impact, incremental budget impact should be minimal.

2772
04:49:49.152 --> 04:49:49.722
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you very much.

2773
04:49:49.819 --> 04:49:50.420
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate that.

2774
04:49:50.487 --> 04:49:52.926
<v Dan Ryan>I wanted to make sure that we didn't find that out 6 months later.

2775
04:49:53.008 --> 04:49:53.220
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

2776
04:49:54.943 --> 04:49:55.708
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2777
04:49:56.773 --> 04:50:06.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue for debate, we have had a request to give everybody outside of our normal rules just a few sentences in order to try to speed things up tonight.

2778
04:50:06.853 --> 04:50:08.937
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's try to keep it to just a few sentences.

2779
04:50:09.032 --> 04:50:10.582
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Keelan, could you please call the roll?

2780
04:50:15.203 --> 04:50:15.336
<v Keelan McClymont>Clerk.

2781
04:50:15.404 --> 04:50:16.804
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, you are on mute.

2782
04:50:20.771 --> 04:50:22.976
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All right, then I won't say anything.

2783
04:50:23.573 --> 04:50:23.588
<v Robert Butler>Aye.

2784
04:50:24.039 --> 04:50:29.256
<v Mitch Green>I'm proud of my colleagues.

2785
04:50:29.867 --> 04:50:30.784
<v Mitch Green>I'm proud of Portlanders.

2786
04:50:33.099 --> 04:50:33.116
<v Jeremy Bosley-Smith>Aye.

2787
04:50:35.847 --> 04:50:49.455
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's a little bit about meeting the moment, and I think that there— that speaking to this is important for those of you that introduced it and how you shared where I just appreciate how each of you introduced this, both of these items.

2788
04:50:50.674 --> 04:50:53.458
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've been really proud of Portlanders over the last few weeks.

2789
04:50:55.669 --> 04:50:57.460
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're winning the information campaign.

2790
04:50:59.302 --> 04:51:11.651
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, you know, who knew that humor in the form of a green frog was going to be the great tactic of our time to push back on a paramilitary overreach by the federal government?

2791
04:51:11.781 --> 04:51:11.994
<v Robert Butler>But it is.

2792
04:51:12.044 --> 04:51:12.452
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Mayor.

2793
04:51:12.636 --> 04:51:13.215
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it's working.

2794
04:51:15.703 --> 04:51:17.361
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm also very cognizant of that.

2795
04:51:17.441 --> 04:51:18.537
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's not a joking matter.

2796
04:51:18.617 --> 04:51:26.468
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for a lot of our members of our community, this has been— it remains an incredibly stressful, sad, maddening moment.

2797
04:51:26.840 --> 04:51:29.103
<v Eric Zimmerman>And nobody on this council is making light of that.

2798
04:51:29.185 --> 04:51:31.901
<v Eric Zimmerman>Nobody is considering it humorous.

2799
04:51:32.840 --> 04:51:39.401
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we are in an information campaign against those who would do us ill. And so I've appreciated the way Portlanders have shown up.

2800
04:51:43.361 --> 04:51:46.632
<v Eric Zimmerman>Snatch and grabs are not a normal American practice.

2801
04:51:47.808 --> 04:51:51.384
<v Eric Zimmerman>Law enforcement hiding their faces is not a normal American practice.

2802
04:51:53.812 --> 04:52:04.412
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've said for a long time that confusing camouflage with law enforcement and continuing to blur the lines between law enforcement and our military is not a normal practice, nor should it remain.

2803
04:52:04.598 --> 04:52:04.700
<v Aiden Summers>Thank you.

2804
04:52:05.934 --> 04:52:06.465
<v Eric Zimmerman>But here we are.

2805
04:52:06.916 --> 04:52:29.944
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're continuing to see it happen more and more, forced on us by a president who seeks unknown ends, by sycophants who seek to advance an information campaign against American communities to inspire action of some sort against American communities, again, to unknown ends.

2806
04:52:31.252 --> 04:52:34.215
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's nothing honorable about what's going on right now in the federal government.

2807
04:52:34.650 --> 04:52:40.385
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's nothing honorable about what they've introduced into Portland or in other cities across these United States.

2808
04:52:42.375 --> 04:52:45.495
<v Eric Zimmerman>We have longstanding due process for a reason.

2809
04:52:46.837 --> 04:52:48.665
<v Eric Zimmerman>That reason is our Constitution.

2810
04:52:48.712 --> 04:52:50.525
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's our American way of life.

2811
04:52:52.012 --> 04:53:03.720
<v Eric Zimmerman>They demand that we protect due process through laws through practical process, and ignoring it is an affront to everything American.

2812
04:53:04.902 --> 04:53:11.295
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have to speak with respect to the federalization of the National Guard members to Portland.

2813
04:53:11.879 --> 04:53:22.261
<v Eric Zimmerman>This action has now multiple times been determined unnecessary, out of compliance with the intent of federal laws, and unconstitutional.

2814
04:53:24.973 --> 04:53:42.205
<v Eric Zimmerman>For a political party who has long preached states' rights and the issues of states' rights, all I hear is silence and the occasional bursts of glee by the cowards that are beating the drum for military intervention inside American cities.

2815
04:53:44.593 --> 04:53:47.241
<v Eric Zimmerman>Shame on the United States Congress of these, of these states.

2816
04:53:47.677 --> 04:53:57.132
<v Eric Zimmerman>Shame for them shame on the governors of states not joining us in our court cases to stop this infringement of our states' rights.

2817
04:53:59.883 --> 04:54:01.939
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't want to end on shame.

2818
04:54:02.118 --> 04:54:07.758
<v Eric Zimmerman>I will just state again just how damn proud I am of the way Portlanders have shown up in this moment.

2819
04:54:10.503 --> 04:54:11.751
<v Eric Zimmerman>You've shown your dissent.

2820
04:54:13.402 --> 04:54:15.741
<v Eric Zimmerman>My colleagues have written good documents tonight.

2821
04:54:17.396 --> 04:54:20.175
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know that people are sad, they're mad, they're scared.

2822
04:54:21.315 --> 04:54:23.501
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, we are winning this information campaign.

2823
04:54:23.581 --> 04:54:28.791
<v Eric Zimmerman>We are winning our court cases, and we will win history of these times.

2824
04:54:31.231 --> 04:54:36.907
<v Eric Zimmerman>The sad is a little bit too much for me, so I'm going to stay in the mad category because I think I'm more effective in the mad category.

2825
04:54:38.067 --> 04:54:47.773
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, and I'm going to stay steady in preventing any further federal Overreach and any other un-American norms growing far too damn normal.

2826
04:54:49.097 --> 04:54:49.581
<v Loretta Smith>I vote aye.

2827
04:54:52.744 --> 04:54:56.666
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you to my colleagues, to the community for standing up to protect Portland.

2828
04:54:56.894 --> 04:54:57.252
<v Brittany Jones>I vote aye.

2829
04:55:00.329 --> 04:55:00.579
<v Robert Butler>Ditto.

2830
04:55:00.679 --> 04:55:01.646
<v Robert Butler>See you guys on Saturday.

2831
04:55:03.586 --> 04:55:03.602
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Aye.

2832
04:55:05.044 --> 04:55:07.151
<v Loretta Smith>I want to thank my colleagues for bringing this forward.

2833
04:55:07.312 --> 04:55:10.957
<v Loretta Smith>You all have made me grow in a way that I didn't think was possible.

2834
04:55:11.812 --> 04:55:21.323
<v Loretta Smith>But one thing is very clear, this is a ferocious federal overreach, and this will help to combat that.

2835
04:55:22.164 --> 04:55:28.330
<v Loretta Smith>And I hope that everybody follows this lead because it is important and it's critical.

2836
04:55:28.882 --> 04:55:29.884
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, and I vote aye.

2837
04:55:33.421 --> 04:55:38.127
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to the co-sponsors, to everyone involved in drafting this, the council leadership for getting this on the agenda.

2838
04:55:38.819 --> 04:55:42.487
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll probably put more out on social media and keep it short here, so I vote aye.

2839
04:55:42.697 --> 04:55:42.843
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

2840
04:55:46.590 --> 04:55:51.528
<v Dan Ryan>I need to start with how deeply sad it is when we separate children from their parents and guardians.

2841
04:55:52.318 --> 04:55:56.433
<v Dan Ryan>May we hold those dealing with such trauma in our hearts tonight and going forward.

2842
04:55:57.686 --> 04:56:03.670
<v Dan Ryan>Rage politics won't help us, but pragmatic politics can help us get through this current storm.

2843
04:56:04.055 --> 04:56:10.969
<v Dan Ryan>Tonight, because of all of my colleagues, we are taking a pragmatic step, centering those most impacted.

2844
04:56:11.947 --> 04:56:15.380
<v Dan Ryan>Remember, everything this president has touched has gone into bankruptcy.

2845
04:56:15.444 --> 04:56:17.353
<v Dan Ryan>So please, we need him out of our business.

2846
04:56:18.331 --> 04:56:33.496
<v Dan Ryan>And finally, to quote one of my favorite inspirational leaders, quote, while recognizing that appropriate policies are necessary to keep us safe, I encourage you to continue to go advocate for society to Respect the human dignity of the most vulnerable.

2847
04:56:34.144 --> 04:56:35.032
<v Dan Ryan>End of quote.

2848
04:56:35.598 --> 04:56:36.018
<v Dan Ryan>Hope Leo.

2849
04:56:37.150 --> 04:56:37.617
<v Elizabeth Mintz>I vote aye.

2850
04:56:38.805 --> 04:56:42.306
<v Keelan McClymont>Our neighbors are worth fighting for.

2851
04:56:42.822 --> 04:56:43.386
<v Elizabeth Mintz>I vote aye.

2852
04:56:46.064 --> 04:56:48.098
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you to everyone who brought forward this resolution.

2853
04:56:48.146 --> 04:56:50.039
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it gives us a great outline of what to do next.

2854
04:56:50.087 --> 04:56:56.871
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm going to keep it brief because I am also going to make a video to talk about what comes next, but I heard a lot of the testimonies say that this is the first of many steps.

2855
04:56:57.329 --> 04:56:58.883
<v Angelita Morillo>And I agree there is more coming.

2856
04:56:58.963 --> 04:57:15.633
<v Angelita Morillo>So I just wanted to let the community know that my office is bringing forward 2 more policies, a detention facility impact fee and a surveillance policy to make sure that ICE and other federal agencies are not able to use our data to track immigrants and protesters, and that we're going to be protecting people's rights on all fronts.

2857
04:57:15.780 --> 04:57:16.208
<v Angelita Morillo>I vote aye.

2858
04:57:18.552 --> 04:57:18.811
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

2859
04:57:20.542 --> 04:57:38.788
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm grateful to my colleagues who drafted this measure to give us the opportunity to Join our immigrant families, uh, people in, in animal suits, and Judge Karen Emmergut in opposing inhumanity and lawlessness and fascism.

2860
04:57:40.575 --> 04:57:40.606
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2861
04:57:44.524 --> 04:57:50.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I feel like I need to continue to set the example of not speaking too much, so I will simply say aye.

2862
04:57:51.672 --> 04:57:54.952
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I am so glad To join my colleagues in support here.

2863
04:57:56.471 --> 04:58:00.027
<v Keelan McClymont>The resolution as amended is adopted with 12 yes votes.

2864
04:58:01.401 --> 04:58:05.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we have another item before us.

2865
04:58:05.424 --> 04:58:11.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know I am the killer of celebration at every exciting council meeting.

2866
04:58:12.366 --> 04:58:15.312
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are moving on to agenda item 7.

2867
04:58:15.989 --> 04:58:20.774
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That agenda item has already been opened, which is why we are able to go there after 9 o'clock at night.

2868
04:58:22.397 --> 04:58:27.893
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I know that there are some amendments that were pre-filed.

2869
04:58:28.725 --> 04:58:33.614
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right now we do not have any of those open, so we are speaking to the underlying ordinance.

2870
04:58:34.111 --> 04:58:42.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If it is helpful to allow everybody 2 to 3 sentences at the end, as we just did, to move along debate, let's do that.

2871
04:58:42.491 --> 04:58:45.200
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have staff available until 11:30 tonight.

2872
04:58:45.537 --> 04:58:46.322
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

2873
04:58:46.497 --> 04:58:46.657
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Thank you, Mayor.

2874
04:58:48.599 --> 04:58:49.549
<v Dan Ryan>That's legacy, sorry.

2875
04:58:51.031 --> 04:58:51.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

2876
04:58:52.561 --> 04:58:52.755
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2877
04:58:52.802 --> 04:58:54.638
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll make this brief if I can.

2878
04:58:54.880 --> 04:58:57.312
<v Sameer Kanal>I also agree with Councilor Murillo.

2879
04:58:57.456 --> 04:58:58.132
<v Sameer Kanal>This isn't enough.

2880
04:58:58.356 --> 04:58:59.610
<v Sameer Kanal>We know that there's more coming.

2881
04:58:59.706 --> 04:59:05.603
<v Sameer Kanal>We daylighted 7 of these pieces of legislation among several councilors at the Community and Public Safety Committee.

2882
04:59:05.684 --> 04:59:07.515
<v Sameer Kanal>So after this, there's 5 more to go.

2883
04:59:07.934 --> 04:59:11.775
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm excited to work on mass identification verification and an ordinance coming up.

2884
04:59:11.855 --> 04:59:15.921
<v Sameer Kanal>And also we're working on chemical weapons-related legislation as well.

2885
04:59:17.722 --> 04:59:27.674
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also want to say I'm aware the government has a role to play, but ultimately resistance to authoritarianism is led by the people, and I'm committing to continue to support community response to everything we're facing here.

2886
04:59:28.541 --> 04:59:29.758
<v Sameer Kanal>Also, and a chicken suit.

2887
04:59:29.919 --> 04:59:30.769
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to shout that out.

2888
04:59:31.601 --> 04:59:35.096
<v Sameer Kanal>So second, thanks for the testifiers that wrote in.

2889
04:59:35.705 --> 04:59:44.925
<v Sameer Kanal>You saw a lot of testimony in person, but also County Chair Jessica Vega Peterson, SEIU president, principal of a middle school in D4, and a couple people I met cheering for the Timbers together.

2890
04:59:45.619 --> 04:59:58.628
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I just want to also make the same motion I made on the last thing, uh, which is to change residents to residents and visitors in 3 places: paragraph 9 of the underlying ordinance, C1 in the underlying ordinance, and in the code Appendix A 23.20.030.

2891
05:00:01.687 --> 05:00:02.059
<v Angelita Morillo>Second.

2892
05:00:02.738 --> 05:00:02.980
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

2893
05:00:03.368 --> 05:00:08.544
<v Sameer Kanal>In paragraph 9, it documents the problems we're facing, says only residents are being questioned when we know that visitors are too.

2894
05:00:08.949 --> 05:00:15.329
<v Sameer Kanal>In C1, it talks about protecting the dignity and constitutional rights of all residents, but if you're a visitor here, we have that responsibility too while you're in our city.

2895
05:00:15.762 --> 05:00:23.781
<v Sameer Kanal>And in the code section, it says the training needs to include at a minimum guidance for staff on how to respond to requests for information from the federal government regarding city employees or residents.

2896
05:00:24.039 --> 05:00:30.122
<v Sameer Kanal>But city staff might also have information about those who do not live here but simply visit here, or who work at a private business in Portland.

2897
05:00:30.460 --> 05:00:34.537
<v Sameer Kanal>So this is changing in 3 places, quote, residents, end quote, to residents and visitors.

2898
05:00:34.668 --> 05:00:36.354
<v Sameer Kanal>I have a second, and I will stop there.

2899
05:00:38.302 --> 05:00:42.701
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, if you are in the queue to debate this amendment, can you please raise your physical hand?

2900
05:00:44.380 --> 05:00:48.592
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing no debate on this amendment, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

2901
05:00:48.672 --> 05:00:52.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is an amendment to change residents to residents and visitors in 3 places.

2902
05:00:54.422 --> 05:00:56.605
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, may I confirm who seconded?

2903
05:00:57.593 --> 05:00:58.079
<v Angelita Morillo>That would be me.

2904
05:00:58.661 --> 05:00:59.372
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Murillo.

2905
05:01:00.585 --> 05:01:00.925
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2906
05:01:02.204 --> 05:01:02.252
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2907
05:01:03.756 --> 05:01:04.207
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2908
05:01:04.418 --> 05:01:04.450
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2909
05:01:04.644 --> 05:01:05.015
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2910
05:01:05.208 --> 05:01:05.290
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2911
05:01:05.547 --> 05:01:06.064
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2912
05:01:06.338 --> 05:01:06.371
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2913
05:01:06.742 --> 05:01:07.114
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2914
05:01:07.453 --> 05:01:07.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2915
05:01:07.809 --> 05:01:08.164
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2916
05:01:08.503 --> 05:01:08.550
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2917
05:01:08.905 --> 05:01:09.310
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

2918
05:01:09.488 --> 05:01:09.567
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2919
05:01:09.810 --> 05:01:10.100
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

2920
05:01:11.201 --> 05:01:11.217
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

2921
05:01:11.778 --> 05:01:12.293
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

2922
05:01:12.646 --> 05:01:12.693
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

2923
05:01:12.983 --> 05:01:13.367
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

2924
05:01:13.688 --> 05:01:13.737
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2925
05:01:14.026 --> 05:01:14.347
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

2926
05:01:14.829 --> 05:01:14.861
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2927
05:01:15.294 --> 05:01:15.631
<v Keelan McClymont>Roggeny?

2928
05:01:16.097 --> 05:01:16.258
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2929
05:01:16.674 --> 05:01:20.992
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 12 yes votes.

2930
05:01:21.234 --> 05:01:22.004
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2931
05:01:22.051 --> 05:01:26.080
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, to the now amended ordinance.

2932
05:01:26.306 --> 05:01:28.072
<v Mitch Green>I would like to speak after Councilor Smith.

2933
05:01:28.135 --> 05:01:29.773
<v Mitch Green>I believe that Councilor Smith has an amendment.

2934
05:01:29.901 --> 05:01:31.008
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith?

2935
05:01:32.244 --> 05:01:33.257
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

2936
05:01:33.512 --> 05:01:35.711
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to say to my colleague, thank you.

2937
05:01:36.001 --> 05:01:40.062
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Councilor Kanal, for your leadership on this legislation.

2938
05:01:40.495 --> 05:01:49.368
<v Loretta Smith>He and his staff and my staff worked very diligently and brought in a broad array of stakeholders and administrative leadership to introduce it here today.

2939
05:01:49.898 --> 05:01:51.968
<v Loretta Smith>So I want to tell you, I'm going to support this.

2940
05:01:52.609 --> 05:01:54.117
<v Loretta Smith>And where did you get that picture from?

2941
05:01:55.015 --> 05:01:58.257
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a screen grab from the video from Open Signal.

2942
05:01:58.305 --> 05:01:59.748
<v Loretta Smith>Where did you get that picture?

2943
05:02:00.085 --> 05:02:01.224
<v Loretta Smith>I want that picture.

2944
05:02:01.450 --> 05:02:02.973
<v Loretta Smith>I do still have that jacket.

2945
05:02:04.113 --> 05:02:06.711
<v Loretta Smith>So I don't throw away clothes.

2946
05:02:08.220 --> 05:02:12.066
<v Loretta Smith>One of the most important things about this legislation is the training.

2947
05:02:13.652 --> 05:02:14.381
<v Loretta Smith>It's important.

2948
05:02:15.141 --> 05:02:27.004
<v Loretta Smith>I think training builds organizational culture and norms, and it also makes expectations and values operational, and it allows us to hold each other accountable.

2949
05:02:27.726 --> 05:02:29.913
<v Loretta Smith>I didn't have a problem with the FOIA request.

2950
05:02:29.976 --> 05:02:33.051
<v Loretta Smith>I think we need to FOIA them every day for 8 hours every day.

2951
05:02:33.691 --> 05:02:47.608
<v Loretta Smith>But the issue that I had, I thought we were getting very rigorous in our direction to bureau staff where we were on the line to what the charter required for our duties.

2952
05:02:47.671 --> 05:02:48.867
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I had a problem with.

2953
05:02:49.532 --> 05:02:56.970
<v Loretta Smith>I think that the FOIA requests, they, they may not come back at all, but we still need to keep the pressure on.

2954
05:02:57.584 --> 05:03:01.189
<v Loretta Smith>So I'd like to put A motion forward.

2955
05:03:02.433 --> 05:03:40.295
<v Loretta Smith>And I wonder, I'm not sure, I'm not sure I know what the compliance looks like, but regular FOIA requests, and I wonder if this tool is better used in the context of specific, um, I don't know, I'm going to switch this around, but if, if we can forego the FOIA and somehow figure out how to less direct the bureaus in a way that is consistent with our charter, that would be helpful.

2956
05:03:40.830 --> 05:03:43.149
<v Loretta Smith>And you can help me out, uh, Councilor Green.

2957
05:03:44.212 --> 05:03:44.812
<v Mitch Green>I'm very happy to.

2958
05:03:45.848 --> 05:03:48.373
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor Green.

2959
05:03:48.616 --> 05:03:55.998
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you, Councilor Smith, um, and thank you for your early leadership on this, the spirit of this legislation almost a decade ago now.

2960
05:03:56.960 --> 05:04:00.134
<v Mitch Green>I did prepare a friendly amendment to your amendment that you posted.

2961
05:04:00.407 --> 05:04:00.888
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

2962
05:04:01.673 --> 05:04:06.115
<v Mitch Green>I hear your reasoning about your motivation for pulling that FOIA piece out.

2963
05:04:06.226 --> 05:04:08.406
<v Mitch Green>And I thought what I would do is in Section E.

2964
05:04:08.969 --> 05:04:09.305
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

2965
05:04:09.689 --> 05:04:14.531
<v Mitch Green>Under the new item that is now about to, which is really about the, it speaks to the reporting.

2966
05:04:15.862 --> 05:04:36.102
<v Mitch Green>Your clause says the city will also provide an annual report to council summarizing, and here's where I, I'm proposing, if you're friendly to it, adding back in summarizing Freedom of Information Act requests for immigration enforcement communication request activities and detailed description of the city's response, because then that ties back to the resolution we just passed.

2967
05:04:36.472 --> 05:04:39.058
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, I, I totally— I agree.

2968
05:04:39.363 --> 05:04:39.924
<v Loretta Smith>I accept.

2969
05:04:40.343 --> 05:04:41.032
<v Loretta Smith>It's very friendly.

2970
05:04:41.385 --> 05:04:43.860
<v Mitch Green>Okay, then I'll send that language to the clerk.

2971
05:04:44.358 --> 05:04:44.775
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2972
05:04:46.269 --> 05:04:48.741
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, has this been moved and seconded?

2973
05:04:49.354 --> 05:05:00.423
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I'd like to move that we, um, support my amendment with the friendly amendment that Councilor Green has put forward.

2974
05:05:00.762 --> 05:05:01.037
<v Mitch Green>Second.

2975
05:05:01.828 --> 05:05:10.125
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this would remove C as you had put forward, Councilor Smith, and in the new 2 add in language about FOIA.

2976
05:05:10.400 --> 05:05:12.063
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct, Councilor Smith and Green?

2977
05:05:13.679 --> 05:05:17.837
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, we do have the language that we're going to send over to The clerk.

2978
05:05:17.998 --> 05:05:20.151
<v Loretta Smith>Do you— okay, I think she has it.

2979
05:05:20.393 --> 05:05:21.437
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, and I'll send it to—.

2980
05:05:22.320 --> 05:05:23.734
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, you already have it?

2981
05:05:24.007 --> 05:05:24.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, great.

2982
05:05:25.211 --> 05:05:27.348
<v Candace Avalos>Point of information, can you just explain it one more time?

2983
05:05:27.493 --> 05:05:31.108
<v Candace Avalos>I'm looking at it here, but I'm not seeing what you're, what you're describing.

2984
05:05:31.414 --> 05:05:33.389
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, hold on just a second.

2985
05:05:33.437 --> 05:06:01.406
<v Mitch Green>So if you, if you're looking at the Smith Amendment, um, in the Section E, uh, what is now the newly numbered Item 2 under E, there is a statement there that says the city will also provide an annual report to council summarizing, and then I'm adding in Freedom of Information Act requests to then complete for immigration enforcement communication requests and activities and a detailed description of the city response.

2986
05:06:01.487 --> 05:06:10.884
<v Mitch Green>So it codifies in the reporting under the sanctuary city code that we're, we're going to summarize Freedom of Information Act requests.

2987
05:06:10.933 --> 05:06:11.029
<v Robert Butler>Thank you.

2988
05:06:11.494 --> 05:06:16.193
<v Mitch Green>That we are then providing some urging to the mayor to do in the resolution.

2989
05:06:16.322 --> 05:06:19.241
<v Mitch Green>So that's what that's doing.

2990
05:06:20.635 --> 05:06:24.662
<v Candace Avalos>And that's also including removing her whole amendment, right?

2991
05:06:24.790 --> 05:06:25.448
<v Candace Avalos>All of C and—.

2992
05:06:25.448 --> 05:06:25.608
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2993
05:06:25.929 --> 05:06:26.088
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Okay.

2994
05:06:26.715 --> 05:06:27.548
<v Candace Avalos>All right, I understand.

2995
05:06:27.676 --> 05:06:27.917
<v Kim Jones>Thanks.

2996
05:06:28.415 --> 05:06:32.263
<v Eric Zimmerman>And just, you kept saying Section E, and I think you mean D.

2997
05:06:32.985 --> 05:06:33.177
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

2998
05:06:33.481 --> 05:06:33.643
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

2999
05:06:33.690 --> 05:06:34.220
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for that.

3000
05:06:35.471 --> 05:06:36.208
<v Mitch Green>The numbering gets—.

3001
05:06:36.512 --> 05:06:36.786
<v Mitch Green>Yep.

3002
05:06:38.199 --> 05:06:38.920
<v Mitch Green>It's late.

3003
05:06:39.306 --> 05:06:40.333
<v Loretta Smith>It gets confusing.

3004
05:06:41.087 --> 05:06:43.672
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane, are you in the queue to speak to this amendment?

3005
05:06:44.042 --> 05:06:44.137
<v Loretta Smith>No.

3006
05:06:44.524 --> 05:06:46.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, are you in the queue to speak to this amendment?

3007
05:06:47.253 --> 05:07:03.867
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I just had a— this may just be a syntax issue, but I think that word for, F-O-R, should be a comma, because otherwise you would have only immigration enforcement communication requests and activities that are in a Freedom of Information Act request, which I don't think is the intent here.

3008
05:07:07.331 --> 05:07:08.448
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I'm picking up what you're laying down.

3009
05:07:09.893 --> 05:07:19.518
<v Sameer Kanal>So I, I think that, yeah, if it, it should say, if you're trying to add Freedom of Information Act requests there, it should say Freedom of Information Act requests, comma, immigration enforcement.

3010
05:07:20.483 --> 05:07:21.206
<v Mitch Green>That is my intent.

3011
05:07:21.544 --> 05:07:21.705
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

3012
05:07:21.802 --> 05:07:23.009
<v Mitch Green>Is that acceptable to City Council?

3013
05:07:23.235 --> 05:07:24.602
<v Loretta Smith>It is acceptable.

3014
05:07:26.026 --> 05:07:26.787
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll just—.

3015
05:07:26.917 --> 05:07:27.563
<v Mitch Green>I'm sorry.

3016
05:07:27.887 --> 05:07:28.180
<v Robert Butler>Go ahead.

3017
05:07:28.471 --> 05:07:32.543
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll just say I I'm going to say I would accept this as friendly.

3018
05:07:33.281 --> 05:07:34.984
<v Sameer Kanal>I am supportive of FOIA requests.

3019
05:07:35.450 --> 05:07:41.438
<v Sameer Kanal>I can't count votes legally under state law, but I know I need 9 to get an emergency clause done today, and that's what I'd like to do.

3020
05:07:41.663 --> 05:07:43.398
<v Sameer Kanal>So, uh, that's why I'm going to accept it.

3021
05:07:43.477 --> 05:07:48.262
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also have faith that the mayor will be doing these, uh, FOIA requests.

3022
05:07:48.695 --> 05:07:50.912
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and if that changes, then we'll talk again.

3023
05:07:51.280 --> 05:07:59.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I, I think that the mayor and team are, are well suited to Linley, do you have what you need for us to move forward on a vote?

3024
05:08:01.370 --> 05:08:08.728
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Maybe just confirm for me and Keelan, it would read summarizing Freedom of Information Act requests, comma, immigration enforcement communication.

3025
05:08:08.905 --> 05:08:09.834
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just making sure that is clear.

3026
05:08:10.139 --> 05:08:10.861
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we're good.

3027
05:08:10.990 --> 05:08:11.886
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

3028
05:08:13.234 --> 05:08:17.850
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And you're comfortable with this amendment moving forward given that this is an ordinance?

3029
05:08:19.084 --> 05:08:19.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yep, we're good.

3030
05:08:20.304 --> 05:08:20.463
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

3031
05:08:20.804 --> 05:08:21.311
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, great.

3032
05:08:21.671 --> 05:08:24.734
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, no— seeing no one else in the queue, can you please call the roll?

3033
05:08:27.369 --> 05:08:28.015
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

3034
05:08:29.370 --> 05:08:29.387
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

3035
05:08:30.193 --> 05:08:30.340
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

3036
05:08:30.824 --> 05:08:30.871
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

3037
05:08:31.485 --> 05:08:31.856
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

3038
05:08:32.033 --> 05:08:32.194
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

3039
05:08:32.680 --> 05:08:32.905
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

3040
05:08:33.243 --> 05:08:33.293
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

3041
05:08:33.616 --> 05:08:34.034
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

3042
05:08:34.293 --> 05:08:34.455
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

3043
05:08:34.632 --> 05:08:35.003
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

3044
05:08:35.422 --> 05:08:35.471
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

3045
05:08:36.052 --> 05:08:36.262
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Mall?

3046
05:08:36.391 --> 05:08:36.505
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

3047
05:08:36.651 --> 05:08:36.941
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

3048
05:08:38.008 --> 05:08:38.105
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

3049
05:08:38.898 --> 05:08:39.933
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Koyama Lane?

3050
05:08:40.352 --> 05:08:40.483
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

3051
05:08:40.724 --> 05:08:41.338
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

3052
05:08:41.888 --> 05:08:41.937
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

3053
05:08:42.310 --> 05:08:42.713
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

3054
05:08:43.183 --> 05:08:43.230
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

3055
05:08:43.602 --> 05:08:44.103
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

3056
05:08:44.475 --> 05:08:44.525
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

3057
05:08:45.220 --> 05:08:46.965
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 12 yes votes.

3058
05:08:50.741 --> 05:08:54.498
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, are you still in the queue or was— okay, that was from previous action.

3059
05:08:55.654 --> 05:09:00.231
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos, are you in the queue to speak to the now amended ordinance?

3060
05:09:00.472 --> 05:09:00.584
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

3061
05:09:01.661 --> 05:09:04.406
<v Candace Avalos>I also have a quick friendly amendment.

3062
05:09:05.225 --> 05:09:14.088
<v Candace Avalos>So I want to add a friendly amendment that was caught by Councilor Kanal's team that would strengthen the ordinance to be consistent with the language that we have in the Protect Portland resolution.

3063
05:09:14.940 --> 05:09:19.575
<v Candace Avalos>So I'd like to add a friendly amendment to where Public-private signage is posted.

3064
05:09:20.030 --> 05:09:36.806
<v Candace Avalos>So in Section 23.20.030, uh, we're going to add the words and leased spaces and— so that whole phrase, um, so that it encompasses both spaces owned, operated, and occupied by the city.

3065
05:09:36.885 --> 05:09:44.226
<v Candace Avalos>That is something that we were specific about, uh, including leased spaces, uh, in the PPI.

3066
05:09:44.308 --> 05:09:48.400
<v Candace Avalos>So we are just trying to standardize this in the ordinance.

3067
05:09:48.705 --> 05:09:49.041
<v Sameer Kanal>Second.

3068
05:09:50.260 --> 05:09:55.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So in D, after city-owned and before buildings, you would add leased—.

3069
05:09:55.315 --> 05:09:55.685
<v Candace Avalos>Correct.

3070
05:09:55.780 --> 05:09:57.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or after buildings rather and before will.

3071
05:09:57.545 --> 05:10:00.435
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>City-owned buildings and leased spaces will display.

3072
05:10:00.740 --> 05:10:01.077
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Correct.

3073
05:10:02.279 --> 05:10:04.301
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Lynley and Keelan, you have what you need?

3074
05:10:05.408 --> 05:10:07.094
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

3075
05:10:07.799 --> 05:10:10.479
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane, are you in the queue to debate this amendment?

3076
05:10:11.711 --> 05:10:17.572
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can I just confirm, 'cause we'd gotten some written language and I just wanna make sure, Councilor Avalos, this is what you had.

3077
05:10:17.748 --> 05:10:24.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It had said city-owned buildings and leased spaces and buildings, and you're intending to not have the second and buildings in there?

3078
05:10:24.729 --> 05:10:25.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just making sure.

3079
05:10:33.043 --> 05:10:35.703
<v Candace Avalos>So it's gonna say city-owned and leased spaces and buildings.

3080
05:10:36.688 --> 05:10:43.356
<v Candace Avalos>Um, it's going to say city-owned and leased spaces and buildings will display, uh, visible signage.

3081
05:10:45.045 --> 05:10:46.991
<v Candace Avalos>I can copy-paste this real quick to you in the chat.

3082
05:10:47.057 --> 05:10:47.539
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, that's fine.

3083
05:10:48.022 --> 05:10:48.278
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Thank you.

3084
05:10:48.407 --> 05:10:55.337
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, colleagues, seeing no one in the queue for debate, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

3085
05:11:01.953 --> 05:11:02.385
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

3086
05:11:03.493 --> 05:11:03.621
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

3087
05:11:04.554 --> 05:11:04.761
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

3088
05:11:05.180 --> 05:11:05.227
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

3089
05:11:06.158 --> 05:11:06.577
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

3090
05:11:06.705 --> 05:11:06.753
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

3091
05:11:07.829 --> 05:11:08.133
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

3092
05:11:08.327 --> 05:11:08.359
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

3093
05:11:09.032 --> 05:11:09.419
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

3094
05:11:09.595 --> 05:11:09.723
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

3095
05:11:10.959 --> 05:11:11.264
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

3096
05:11:11.762 --> 05:11:11.811
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

3097
05:11:12.404 --> 05:11:12.791
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

3098
05:11:13.128 --> 05:11:13.175
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

3099
05:11:14.171 --> 05:11:14.380
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

3100
05:11:15.455 --> 05:11:15.504
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

3101
05:11:16.419 --> 05:11:16.965
<v Keelan McClymont>Liam Elaine.

3102
05:11:17.383 --> 05:11:17.510
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

3103
05:11:18.041 --> 05:11:18.362
<v Robert Butler>Neil.

3104
05:11:18.907 --> 05:11:18.955
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

3105
05:11:19.486 --> 05:11:19.807
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

3106
05:11:20.031 --> 05:11:20.850
<v Keelan McClymont>Bryan.

3107
05:11:21.332 --> 05:11:21.781
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

3108
05:11:22.440 --> 05:11:22.616
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

3109
05:11:39.030 --> 05:11:42.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For folks online, we are waiting to make sure our staff are on the same page on what just happened.

3110
05:11:44.163 --> 05:11:45.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, yeah, maybe we should.

3111
05:11:47.343 --> 05:11:50.330
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, we're— couple just quick clarifications.

3112
05:11:50.587 --> 05:12:03.854
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, just want to confirm that In every instance where it says resident, we will add and visitor, 'cause there's some discrepancy around how many instances there are.

3113
05:12:03.919 --> 05:12:06.118
<v Keelan McClymont>So we just want to confirm that.

3114
05:12:06.551 --> 05:12:07.452
<v Sameer Kanal>I had 3.

3115
05:12:08.078 --> 05:12:10.566
<v Sameer Kanal>Can I pull up the right—.

3116
05:12:10.566 --> 05:12:13.312
<v Sameer Kanal>Your intent matters most.

3117
05:12:13.600 --> 05:12:16.973
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, but yeah, everywhere it says residents should say residents and visitors.

3118
05:12:17.566 --> 05:12:18.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

3119
05:12:18.690 --> 05:12:19.414
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, thank you.

3120
05:12:21.402 --> 05:12:21.562
<v Keelan McClymont>Good.

3121
05:12:22.079 --> 05:12:25.040
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 12 yes votes.

3122
05:12:25.700 --> 05:12:26.312
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

3123
05:12:26.907 --> 05:12:27.841
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane.

3124
05:12:28.823 --> 05:12:29.580
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

3125
05:12:30.462 --> 05:12:35.685
<v Keelan McClymont>The violence that the federal government is inflicting on our communities is an emergency.

3126
05:12:36.278 --> 05:12:39.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I formally move that we add the emergency clause as pre-filed.

3127
05:12:39.557 --> 05:12:41.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If this isn't an emergency, what is?

3128
05:12:42.442 --> 05:12:42.855
<v Sameer Kanal>Second.

3129
05:12:45.975 --> 05:12:49.940
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that Councilor Kanal just deferred to Councilor Murillo for that second.

3130
05:12:50.526 --> 05:12:51.469
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe that's what I saw.

3131
05:12:53.804 --> 05:13:00.026
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, seeing no one in the queue for debate on the addition of an emergency clause, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

3132
05:13:02.346 --> 05:13:02.667
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

3133
05:13:03.776 --> 05:13:03.792
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

3134
05:13:04.435 --> 05:13:04.644
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

3135
05:13:05.544 --> 05:13:05.592
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

3136
05:13:06.186 --> 05:13:06.508
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

3137
05:13:06.924 --> 05:13:06.957
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

3138
05:13:07.327 --> 05:13:07.616
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

3139
05:13:07.954 --> 05:13:07.986
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

3140
05:13:08.355 --> 05:13:08.613
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

3141
05:13:08.918 --> 05:13:08.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

3142
05:13:09.882 --> 05:13:10.010
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

3143
05:13:10.685 --> 05:13:10.702
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

3144
05:13:11.086 --> 05:13:11.118
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

3145
05:13:13.952 --> 05:13:14.129
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

3146
05:13:14.757 --> 05:13:14.805
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

3147
05:13:15.962 --> 05:13:16.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

3148
05:13:16.542 --> 05:13:16.927
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

3149
05:13:17.088 --> 05:13:17.136
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

3150
05:13:18.294 --> 05:13:18.327
<v Brittany Jones>Aye.

3151
05:13:18.455 --> 05:13:24.491
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 12 yes votes, and the emergency clause is added.

3152
05:13:28.022 --> 05:13:36.717
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, seeing no one in the queue to debate the now amended emergency ordinance, we will move to a vote.

3153
05:13:36.895 --> 05:13:41.891
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is an emergency clause, so we get to vote tonight, and this requires 9 votes for passage.

3154
05:13:42.518 --> 05:13:44.266
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

3155
05:13:45.342 --> 05:13:45.518
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

3156
05:13:46.784 --> 05:13:50.844
<v Mitch Green>I want to thank you guys for bringing this forward.

3157
05:13:50.973 --> 05:13:53.716
<v Mitch Green>I'm proud of us for coming together unanimously on this.

3158
05:13:53.844 --> 05:13:54.886
<v Mitch Green>Well, I'm presuming so.

3159
05:13:55.672 --> 05:13:58.063
<v Mitch Green>Um, it's— this is just the beginning.

3160
05:13:58.480 --> 05:14:01.577
<v Mitch Green>Uh, we're gonna need to see you guys out there on Saturday.

3161
05:14:01.722 --> 05:14:04.882
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm going to be out there with a veterans contingent at Friendship Circle.

3162
05:14:05.076 --> 05:14:05.858
<v Mitch Green>On the Waterfront Park.

3163
05:14:05.991 --> 05:14:06.773
<v Mitch Green>So I hope to see you then.

3164
05:14:09.245 --> 05:14:09.277
<v Robert Butler>Aye.

3165
05:14:09.811 --> 05:14:10.538
<v Keelan McClymont>Sorry, Zimmerman?

3166
05:14:10.941 --> 05:14:10.957
<v Robert Butler>Aye.

3167
05:14:11.603 --> 05:14:11.895
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

3168
05:14:12.574 --> 05:14:12.653
<v Brittany Jones>Aye.

3169
05:14:13.365 --> 05:14:17.159
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm incredibly honored to do this work on every day, but especially today.

3170
05:14:17.273 --> 05:14:17.657
<v Sameer Kanal>I vote aye.

3171
05:14:18.332 --> 05:14:18.591
<v Dan Ryan>Smith?

3172
05:14:19.008 --> 05:14:19.041
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

3173
05:14:22.143 --> 05:14:34.172
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to just take an opportunity to thank everybody involved in this, and specifically, it's behind the scenes a lot of the time, but Councilor Koyama Lane, our Vice President, has done a lot to ensure that this happens.

3174
05:14:35.008 --> 05:14:39.653
<v Sameer Kanal>From a process perspective, Council President as well, and so many other folks that are involved in it.

3175
05:14:39.703 --> 05:14:44.072
<v Sameer Kanal>But I wanted to make sure that the flowers are being circulated where they need to go.

3176
05:14:46.495 --> 05:14:47.570
<v Sameer Kanal>This is not the end of the story.

3177
05:14:47.717 --> 05:14:49.915
<v Sameer Kanal>This is second chapter that we just wrote today.

3178
05:14:50.143 --> 05:14:50.338
<v Eric Zimmerman>I vote aye.

3179
05:14:52.492 --> 05:14:52.735
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

3180
05:14:53.980 --> 05:14:59.691
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I want to start by saying thank you, Councilor Kanal, for our spirited conversation last night.

3181
05:15:00.151 --> 05:15:00.888
<v Dan Ryan>In my office.

3182
05:15:01.481 --> 05:15:02.171
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for that.

3183
05:15:02.620 --> 05:15:11.295
<v Dan Ryan>I want to offer my appreciation of all of our city employees, including police, who are weathering their personal worries and continue to serve our city.

3184
05:15:11.760 --> 05:15:13.541
<v Dan Ryan>I vote aye.

3185
05:15:14.471 --> 05:15:15.962
<v Keelan McClymont>Colleagues, I feel really proud of us.

3186
05:15:16.717 --> 05:15:28.638
<v Keelan McClymont>I kind of was caught off guard that I feel a little emotional, but I am grateful that we are going to defend democracy together, and I know that we Do get out on the dais sometimes.

3187
05:15:28.752 --> 05:15:31.974
<v Keelan McClymont>But see, Council President, I told you earlier today, it's gonna be a really good night.

3188
05:15:32.281 --> 05:15:33.716
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it is.

3189
05:15:34.070 --> 05:15:34.312
<v Keelan McClymont>I vote aye.

3190
05:15:36.711 --> 05:15:40.455
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Kanal, for all your work on this and for everything else everyone contributed.

3191
05:15:40.504 --> 05:15:44.938
<v Angelita Morillo>This is the start of some really great and wonderful work that we're going to do to protect our communities.

3192
05:15:45.122 --> 05:15:45.539
<v Angelita Morillo>I vote aye.

3193
05:15:47.735 --> 05:15:47.783
<v Elizabeth Mintz>Aye.

3194
05:15:48.631 --> 05:15:56.305
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We said, Early on that we were going to try to never have one of these late-night meetings again.

3195
05:15:57.299 --> 05:16:16.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Along with my gratitude for all of my colleagues, I want to express immense gratitude for our team, BTS, our security folks, Open Signal upstairs, our clerk and attorneys and others for agreeing to stay late so that we could finish this work tonight.

3196
05:16:16.540 --> 05:16:22.473
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that it was important to a lot of Portlanders who were here today to be able to see us take this vote.

3197
05:16:22.602 --> 05:16:30.955
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So thank you to all of you and to all of our staff that work in our offices for being willing to stay late so we could do this.

3198
05:16:31.052 --> 05:16:36.912
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If ever there was a reason to break that commitment to not stay this late ever again, I think that this is a worthy one.

3199
05:16:38.143 --> 05:16:38.158
<v Aiden Summers>Aye.

3200
05:16:39.225 --> 05:16:42.526
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance as amended passes with 12 yes votes.

3201
05:16:46.363 --> 05:16:48.098
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm here late.

3202
05:16:48.731 --> 05:16:51.442
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, thank you for working quickly.

3203
05:16:52.812 --> 05:17:02.880
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will have a work session tomorrow, if you haven't noticed, and we are canceling our morning check-in tomorrow so folks can sleep in.

3204
05:17:04.625 --> 05:17:05.643
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I adjourn our meeting.

3205
05:17:05.740 --> 05:17:05.918
<v Robert Butler>Yay!

