WEBVTT

1
00:03:14.098 --> 00:03:15.233
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is Councilor Zimmerman.

2
00:03:15.364 --> 00:03:16.366
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just trying to do a mic check.

3
00:03:21.550 --> 00:03:22.703
<v Karen Chi Ray>Hi, Councilor.

4
00:03:22.800 --> 00:03:24.538
<v Karen Chi Ray>Uh, this is Christina with the Council Clerk's Office.

5
00:03:24.733 --> 00:03:26.843
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think they've turned on the audio yet, but I can hear you great.

6
00:03:28.240 --> 00:03:28.971
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, that's great.

7
00:03:29.100 --> 00:03:30.906
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just wanted to get on early in case it got weird.

8
00:03:31.051 --> 00:03:31.718
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

9
00:03:31.962 --> 00:03:32.467
<v Ashley Murray>Hey, no worries.

10
00:03:32.514 --> 00:03:32.758
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks.

11
00:06:32.377 --> 00:06:34.752
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good afternoon, colleagues.

12
00:06:35.187 --> 00:06:39.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am calling to order a special meeting of the Portland City Council.

13
00:06:39.637 --> 00:06:44.833
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is Wednesday, July 16th at 2:32 PM.

14
00:06:45.012 --> 00:06:46.706
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

15
00:06:48.629 --> 00:06:49.112
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

16
00:06:50.593 --> 00:06:50.851
<v Priya Dhanapal>Here.

17
00:06:51.947 --> 00:06:52.413
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo?

18
00:06:52.831 --> 00:06:52.944
<v Steve Novick>Here.

19
00:06:53.572 --> 00:06:54.040
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

20
00:06:54.201 --> 00:06:54.314
<v Ali Berman>Here.

21
00:06:54.910 --> 00:06:55.166
<v Loretta Smith>Clark?

22
00:06:55.264 --> 00:06:56.423
<v Rebecca Dobert>Here.

23
00:06:57.132 --> 00:06:57.648
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

24
00:06:58.630 --> 00:06:58.841
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

25
00:07:00.000 --> 00:07:00.387
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

26
00:07:02.696 --> 00:07:03.213
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

27
00:07:03.843 --> 00:07:04.408
<v Rebecca Dobert>Here.

28
00:07:07.928 --> 00:07:08.187
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

29
00:07:08.898 --> 00:07:09.189
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

30
00:07:09.689 --> 00:07:09.786
<v Micah Meskel>Here.

31
00:07:09.882 --> 00:07:10.413
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney.

32
00:07:10.927 --> 00:07:11.201
<v Elizabeth Milner>Here.

33
00:07:12.439 --> 00:07:17.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And could I have our attorney please go over the rules of order and decorum?

34
00:07:20.029 --> 00:07:21.156
<v Nancy Thorington>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

35
00:07:21.350 --> 00:07:27.134
<v Nancy Thorington>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

36
00:07:31.117 --> 00:07:34.553
<v Nancy Thorington>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

37
00:07:35.452 --> 00:07:39.370
<v Nancy Thorington>Individual may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

38
00:07:40.045 --> 00:07:42.180
<v Nancy Thorington>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

39
00:07:42.935 --> 00:07:44.461
<v Nancy Thorington>The presiding officer preserves order.

40
00:07:44.781 --> 00:07:52.697
<v Nancy Thorington>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

41
00:07:53.452 --> 00:07:55.651
<v Nancy Thorington>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

42
00:07:56.165 --> 00:07:58.156
<v Nancy Thorington>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

43
00:07:58.831 --> 00:08:01.850
<v Nancy Thorington>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

44
00:08:02.459 --> 00:08:05.944
<v Nancy Thorington>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

45
00:08:06.762 --> 00:08:08.882
<v Nancy Thorington>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

46
00:08:09.492 --> 00:08:11.853
<v Nancy Thorington>When testifying, state your name for the record.

47
00:08:11.901 --> 00:08:13.331
<v Nancy Thorington>Your address is not necessary.

48
00:08:13.843 --> 00:08:16.300
<v Nancy Thorington>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

49
00:08:17.055 --> 00:08:20.379
<v Nancy Thorington>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

50
00:08:20.427 --> 00:08:20.555
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

51
00:08:20.749 --> 00:08:21.454
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council Clerk Keelan McClymont.

52
00:08:22.952 --> 00:08:25.581
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

53
00:08:27.867 --> 00:08:30.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please read our first agenda item?

54
00:08:31.290 --> 00:08:44.571
<v Rebecca Dobert>Agenda item 1, refer to the voters a 5-year local option tax levy for the November 4th, 2025 election to maintain safe parks, nature, affordable recreation through 5-year levy.

55
00:08:47.485 --> 00:08:48.359
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

56
00:08:49.168 --> 00:08:58.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, this agenda item came out of a work session, not out of a committee, so there is not a committee staff summary.

57
00:08:59.850 --> 00:09:12.908
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, this is a measure to refer a 5-year tax levy to the voters to maintain safe parks, natural spaces, and affordable recreation opportunities in our city.

58
00:09:13.846 --> 00:09:23.826
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The current levy expires next year, and without this Without this new levy, we'll see 50% cuts in our Parks and Recreation Department.

59
00:09:24.586 --> 00:09:34.918
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With the new levy, we will see levy rates increase to $1.40, which will allow us to maintain the investments that we worked hard to put in the budget this year.

60
00:09:36.830 --> 00:09:53.455
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Generally, when something comes to council, we don't have a full presentation, but because at the last work session we talked about the levy conceptually, but not about the final details, and because this is a referral, And so it is a little bit different from our normal agenda items.

61
00:09:54.048 --> 00:09:57.510
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are going to have a short presentation today.

62
00:09:58.279 --> 00:10:08.283
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am going to have us start though with comments from the carriers like we usually do in our council meetings on other agenda items.

63
00:10:09.100 --> 00:10:20.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>After that, I will turn it over to DCA Dhanapal and to Sonia Szymanski to give us a little bit of information about what ended up in the final levy that we'll be discussing today.

64
00:10:20.739 --> 00:10:27.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll then, as usual, take Technical questions, move to public testimony, and then have the bulk of our debate.

65
00:10:27.407 --> 00:10:29.796
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that is our plan for today.

66
00:10:30.277 --> 00:10:32.937
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have, I believe, 2 and a half hours scheduled.

67
00:10:33.883 --> 00:10:44.624
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know that we'll need the full amount of time, and I hope that by the end of our session today, we can refer a levy to voters with strong support from this council.

68
00:10:45.761 --> 00:10:52.687
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So with that, this is an agenda item that is co-sponsored by Councilors Novick and Murillo and myself.

69
00:10:52.958 --> 00:10:57.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Novick, would you like to kick off a bit of an introduction about the levy before us?

70
00:10:58.576 --> 00:10:58.849
<v Steve Novick>Sure.

71
00:10:59.283 --> 00:11:04.227
<v Steve Novick>I want to focus on what this levy does and something about what it does not do.

72
00:11:04.822 --> 00:11:23.557
<v Steve Novick>As the council president said, we— it was concluded that $1.37 is what it would take to, combined with general fund resources, maintain the park system where it is now, which means after the add-backs that the council made Many of them one-time to the mayor's budget.

73
00:11:24.359 --> 00:11:35.533
<v Steve Novick>So this is a levy which will enable us to continue providing services at that level, and thus to some extent making up for the fact that some of the resources we used were one-time.

74
00:11:35.837 --> 00:11:43.447
<v Steve Novick>Something that we've discussed is what do we do about capital maintenance, given that we have a hundreds of millions of dollars capital maintenance backlog?

75
00:11:43.994 --> 00:11:49.950
<v Steve Novick>And what we're proposing is that we acknowledge that and recognize that we need to do something about it.

76
00:11:49.998 --> 00:11:50.174
<v Brian Sotomayor>Thank you.

77
00:11:50.496 --> 00:11:53.716
<v Steve Novick>Although we're not going to be able to do a hell of a lot in this levy.

78
00:11:54.217 --> 00:11:58.212
<v Steve Novick>So 3 cents of the levy are set aside for capital maintenance projects.

79
00:11:58.278 --> 00:12:03.955
<v Steve Novick>We anticipate those will be kind of small-scale capital maintenance projects like fixing bathroom roofs.

80
00:12:04.874 --> 00:12:18.238
<v Steve Novick>There's also a provision in the resolution that recommits the council to following a policy which was adopted in 2015, I believe, but which has not been followed in recent years.

81
00:12:18.360 --> 00:12:18.412
<v Micah Meskel>Yes.

82
00:12:19.674 --> 00:12:23.719
<v Steve Novick>The description in the resolution is somewhat technical.

83
00:12:23.831 --> 00:12:26.029
<v Steve Novick>It's on the second whereas on page 3.

84
00:12:26.655 --> 00:12:42.511
<v Steve Novick>A somewhat simpler way of describing it is a policy that at least 50% of any excess ending general fund balance and 50% of any one-time general fund resources available in the annual budget development process is dedicated to major maintenance or replacement of existing assets.

85
00:12:42.946 --> 00:12:46.764
<v Steve Novick>That's all infrastructure assets, not just— that's not just parks.

86
00:12:46.813 --> 00:12:47.856
<v Steve Novick>That could also be transportation.

87
00:12:47.921 --> 00:12:48.017
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

88
00:12:48.499 --> 00:12:52.625
<v Steve Novick>So this again is a signal that we take infrastructure maintenance seriously.

89
00:12:54.086 --> 00:13:07.432
<v Steve Novick>And the language also recognizes that we will ask the— the council will probably ask the legislature to clarify that we can use systems development charges for maintenance.

90
00:13:07.977 --> 00:13:12.619
<v Steve Novick>And it also recognizes that we will at some point need to think about a major maintenance bond.

91
00:13:13.453 --> 00:13:15.091
<v Steve Novick>So with that, I'll turn it over to Councilor Murillo.

92
00:13:15.139 --> 00:13:15.349
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mayor.

93
00:13:17.049 --> 00:13:18.094
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

94
00:13:18.654 --> 00:13:22.042
<v Angelita Morillo>I appreciate you covering all the technical stuff so I can do the other fun stuff.

95
00:13:23.245 --> 00:13:30.965
<v Angelita Morillo>This was a big decision for us with regards to how it's going to impact Portlanders, and I think that all of these decisions have been weighing heavily on us.

96
00:13:31.735 --> 00:13:37.144
<v Angelita Morillo>There is no question that Portlanders and people across the country right now are really struggling economically.

97
00:13:37.207 --> 00:13:47.732
<v Angelita Morillo>So whenever we make decisions about what changes we're going to be making to the fees and things that they have to pay for to get the services that they want, That's something that we have all really heavily considered.

98
00:13:48.341 --> 00:13:53.054
<v Angelita Morillo>And I also want to talk about the fact that this levy is going to bring a lot of benefits to Portlanders.

99
00:13:53.567 --> 00:13:59.547
<v Angelita Morillo>People really need their parks, they need recreation, they need third spaces to play, live, and thrive.

100
00:14:00.124 --> 00:14:09.614
<v Angelita Morillo>And we need to ensure that we are still using our social contract and collectively working together to ensure that working families do have those options available to them.

101
00:14:10.239 --> 00:14:16.586
<v Angelita Morillo>So I want to assure Portlanders as well who are listening to this that we are going to have direct oversight over this as a council.

102
00:14:16.634 --> 00:14:16.826
<v Karen Chi Ray>Thank you.

103
00:14:16.980 --> 00:14:24.614
<v Angelita Morillo>Council, we're going to make sure that these dollars are being spent responsibly by your city government and that we're going to be delivering the services that you care about.

104
00:14:25.001 --> 00:14:44.155
<v Angelita Morillo>The new form of government, our district system, our budget listening sessions all gave us an incredible amount of feedback about which programs and services you care about, and we are going to be watching this very closely to ensure that every dollar that we receive as the public body is going to be going directly to the things that matter most to you.

105
00:14:45.427 --> 00:14:55.090
<v Angelita Morillo>Our city is going to be responsible for this, and it's not just going to be private entities that are, you know, profiting off of private partnerships.

106
00:14:55.220 --> 00:15:00.605
<v Angelita Morillo>It's something that is a public good that the city should be taking ownership of in partnership with our community.

107
00:15:01.355 --> 00:15:06.658
<v Angelita Morillo>We also— there's no question that we need to look up sustainable funding models in the years to come.

108
00:15:07.192 --> 00:15:10.426
<v Angelita Morillo>We can't continuously rely on a parks levy to bail us out.

109
00:15:10.813 --> 00:15:18.456
<v Angelita Morillo>And so we will be working as a council to ensure that that's And with that, I will pass it back to the council president.

110
00:15:20.000 --> 00:15:20.611
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

111
00:15:22.480 --> 00:15:27.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, parks are a fundamental piece of what makes Portland a great place to live.

112
00:15:27.889 --> 00:15:31.495
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is a fundamental piece of what attracts families to our city.

113
00:15:32.154 --> 00:15:34.812
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is a fundamental piece of what helps us build community.

114
00:15:35.558 --> 00:15:43.312
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This levy is our opportunity to continue our investments in our open spaces, our recreation programs, and our neighborhood parks.

115
00:15:44.224 --> 00:15:54.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These are the places that connect our communities and provide our kids with natural areas close to home and offer hundreds of hours of classes and programs each week.

116
00:15:56.044 --> 00:16:05.490
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is our chance to continue funding those programs, and it's also our chance to make sure that we are talking about the way we fund those programs and the way we want our parks system to operate.

117
00:16:06.198 --> 00:16:22.431
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what you see in the measure before you, as our colleagues have touched on, are increased accountability measures, increased clarity around what the levy should be used for, And the start of a vision for how we want our Parks and Recreation Department to operate.

118
00:16:23.860 --> 00:16:33.822
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As we move through the conversation today, I hope that we can talk about some of those pieces because I think they are important portions of what we're doing today.

119
00:16:34.496 --> 00:16:41.100
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Before we move into the presentation though, I just want to very quickly thank the many people who helped bring this together.

120
00:16:41.149 --> 00:16:41.437
<v Karen Chi Ray>Thank you.

121
00:16:41.936 --> 00:16:48.118
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All of you have provided feedback over the course of a few months on what this measure should look like.

122
00:16:48.921 --> 00:17:09.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We had stakeholders from the employees who work within our Parks Department to businesses across the city, to our advocates within Friends of groups and the Parks Foundation and the Parks Alliance, and many other people all around the table talking about what a levy should look like.

123
00:17:10.436 --> 00:17:19.681
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In order to truly reflect the needs of our community, the ability of our community, and the type of park system that our community would like to support.

124
00:17:20.179 --> 00:17:32.359
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So a big thank you to all of those groups and to all of you and to all of the Portlanders who have already testified in support or with concerns about the levy before us today.

125
00:17:32.825 --> 00:17:35.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's with all of that input that we were able to bring this proposal forward.

126
00:17:35.923 --> 00:17:36.067
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

127
00:17:37.173 --> 00:17:49.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, I'd like to turn it over to DCA Dhanapal, who I believe is going to kick off a brief presentation to make sure that we all have a clear understanding of what the final proposal before us looks like.

128
00:17:50.142 --> 00:17:50.606
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

129
00:17:51.200 --> 00:17:53.332
<v Priya Dhanapal>Good afternoon, Council President and councilors.

130
00:17:53.669 --> 00:17:56.570
<v Priya Dhanapal>I'm Priya Dhanapal, the Deputy City Administrator for Public Works.

131
00:17:57.195 --> 00:18:02.309
<v Priya Dhanapal>I'd like to begin by saying thank you for all of the work that you all have been engaging in for the Thank you.

132
00:18:02.309 --> 00:18:07.650
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you, Mayor Wilson, and thank you to all of you for your work over the last several months, and for some of you, for the last several years, to bring us to this moment.

133
00:18:08.410 --> 00:18:25.819
<v Priya Dhanapal>As the DCA of Public Works, I'm honored to now have Parks and Portland Parks and Recreation as a part of the Public Works service area, and I have appreciated learning more every day about the work these teams bring to care for Portland's treasured park system and the funding needed to deliver those services.

134
00:18:26.109 --> 00:18:40.013
<v Priya Dhanapal>Portlanders care deeply about their park system, and I've, uh, I've been, you know, inspired by how many people, whether during budget meetings or meetings about the parks levy specifically, have showed up and submitted testimony to have their voices heard.

135
00:18:40.494 --> 00:18:48.797
<v Priya Dhanapal>And while I'm new to the— this particular levy process, I'm not new to stewarding systems that serve people, nor to the deep responsibility of holding public trust.

136
00:18:49.165 --> 00:18:53.404
<v Priya Dhanapal>I've been following the conversations to date and look forward to partnering with you on the work to come.

137
00:18:53.742 --> 00:18:58.717
<v Priya Dhanapal>And with that, I'd like to pass it on to Sonya Szymanski, the Acting Director of Portland Parks and Recreation.

138
00:19:00.021 --> 00:19:00.519
<v Sonya Szymanski>Thank you.

139
00:19:00.744 --> 00:19:01.435
<v Sonya Szymanski>Good afternoon.

140
00:19:01.644 --> 00:19:10.079
<v Sonya Szymanski>I'm Sonya Szymanski with Portland Parks and Recreation, and I'm going to be so brief that I'm managing my own slides.

141
00:19:15.363 --> 00:19:16.821
<v Sonya Szymanski>Rebecca said it's a heartbeat delay.

142
00:19:16.919 --> 00:19:17.162
<v Sonya Szymanski>Okay.

143
00:19:19.026 --> 00:19:20.064
<v Sonya Szymanski>Thank you for having us back.

144
00:19:20.720 --> 00:19:27.430
<v Sonya Szymanski>This hearing follows 2 council work sessions in June and a hearing of the Climate, Resilience, and Land Use Committee last week.

145
00:19:28.099 --> 00:19:32.895
<v Sonya Szymanski>The time and care that you've taken in this conversation is felt and appreciated.

146
00:19:34.155 --> 00:19:41.847
<v Sonya Szymanski>For the next just few minutes, I'm going to do a quick recap of where we are and how we got here, and then I know you're eager to get to community testimony.

147
00:19:44.160 --> 00:19:46.941
<v Sonya Szymanski>2 National comparators to start.

148
00:19:47.202 --> 00:20:00.719
<v Sonya Szymanski>First, Portland Parks and Recreation is ranked number 9 in the National Trust for Public Land review of park systems in the 100 most populous United States cities using the metrics you see on the slide here.

149
00:20:01.090 --> 00:20:06.255
<v Sonya Szymanski>We've been in and out of this top 10 for many years, and it is a point of pride for Portland.

150
00:20:08.398 --> 00:20:21.739
<v Sonya Szymanski>Secondly, we— you have rightfully pointed out the challenges of recurring 5-year levies, particularly when they're not sequenced as part of a long-term financial plan.

151
00:20:22.355 --> 00:20:27.269
<v Sonya Szymanski>And we are not the only park system in the country that uses this type of funding to sustain operations.

152
00:20:32.480 --> 00:20:46.105
<v Sonya Szymanski>Zooming into Portland and looking forward, we have learned through polling and community surveys and anecdotally every day what Portlanders value and prioritize most in their parks and recreation system.

153
00:20:46.364 --> 00:20:52.095
<v Sonya Szymanski>They want it to celebrate our natural environment, be safe and cared for, and be open to all.

154
00:20:54.905 --> 00:21:05.888
<v Sonya Szymanski>Based on those priorities and your guidance, the package before you today focuses on basic care and maintenance, environmental care and resilience, and affordability.

155
00:21:08.988 --> 00:21:21.263
<v Sonya Szymanski>It will fund daily cleanup and maintenance of our parks, Small but high-impact fixes to park amenities and our park ranger program to keep these shared spaces healthy, safe, and welcoming.

156
00:21:23.134 --> 00:21:34.736
<v Sonya Szymanski>It will support tree planting and maintenance of trees in parks, keep our natural areas healthy, and reduce risk from wildfires so Portland's unique and special natural areas stay that way.

157
00:21:36.682 --> 00:21:42.364
<v Sonya Szymanski>And finally, it will keep the events, classes, and programs that Portlanders use and value open and available to everyone.

158
00:21:43.946 --> 00:21:51.954
<v Sonya Szymanski>This includes free programming like Summer Free-for-All and Free Lunch and Play ongoing now, and class discounts so the cost is not a barrier.

159
00:21:54.314 --> 00:21:58.077
<v Sonya Szymanski>These slides have a bit more information, but we're going to go quickly through them.

160
00:21:58.239 --> 00:22:07.676
<v Sonya Szymanski>And the purpose of these is to show you how we got to the rate that's before you today, because that was heavily informed by the budget process that you just concluded.

161
00:22:08.528 --> 00:22:14.681
<v Sonya Szymanski>It was a difficult cycle for Parks and Recreation and required cuts well beyond those taken citywide.

162
00:22:15.307 --> 00:22:21.164
<v Sonya Szymanski>To close the deficit, the parks team advanced a large number of reduction packages to the city administrator.

163
00:22:22.528 --> 00:22:35.946
<v Sonya Szymanski>In developing his proposed budget, Mayor Wilson restored key programs you see up in the top left, including Sun Schools, citywide sports, which is home to Golden Ball, and the potential closure of a neighborhood community center.

164
00:22:36.491 --> 00:22:42.556
<v Sonya Szymanski>He did this through a combination of cuts elsewhere in the bureau and increased revenue.

165
00:22:44.608 --> 00:22:56.034
<v Sonya Szymanski>When that proposed budget came to you, you made a number of additional changes which added really significant funding back into park care and maintenance, and you partially restored community center hours.

166
00:22:56.778 --> 00:23:01.372
<v Sonya Szymanski>You did this through a combination of one-time and ongoing funds.

167
00:23:04.445 --> 00:23:26.872
<v Sonya Szymanski>So the net of all that on the personnel side is reductions of about 20 positions within the central teams that support service delivery, a few reductions to park care work, and significant reductions in the Urban Forestry Division, although about 2/3 of those were added back on the PP&D side, so they're not lost to the city.

168
00:23:29.215 --> 00:23:35.701
<v Sonya Szymanski>The net of all of that on the financial side is that the rate needed to sustain current operations Went down.

169
00:23:36.394 --> 00:23:38.799
<v Sonya Szymanski>We were talking about $1.60 for a while.

170
00:23:38.896 --> 00:23:40.479
<v Sonya Szymanski>We are now talking about $1.37.

171
00:23:42.349 --> 00:23:57.540
<v Sonya Szymanski>The levy package before you today sustains those current service levels and also includes, as you mentioned, a small but meaningful investment for high-impact capital repairs like fixes to pools, bathrooms, and playgrounds.

172
00:23:57.913 --> 00:24:03.702
<v Sonya Szymanski>It also includes a new investment that I'll touch on in this next and final slide.

173
00:24:06.236 --> 00:24:16.895
<v Sonya Szymanski>I have here a summary of key city direction included in this referral action, either in the resolution, in comments elsewhere, or in the accompanying exhibits.

174
00:24:17.712 --> 00:24:23.276
<v Sonya Szymanski>Some of these things will be carried out by organizational leaders like us, others by you directly.

175
00:24:24.750 --> 00:24:35.538
<v Sonya Szymanski>Through this action, Portlanders can expect, as was mentioned, thank you, both immediate and long-term steps towards solutions for the deferred maintenance backlog at parks and citywide.

176
00:24:35.603 --> 00:24:35.795
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

177
00:24:37.400 --> 00:24:57.510
<v Sonya Szymanski>Ongoing oversight with annual and regular reports, cadence to be determined, including in conversation with you, from the Bureau, from a community oversight committee, and at least once from an independent auditor that speak to the financial and performance outcomes of the investments.

178
00:24:58.586 --> 00:25:04.525
<v Sonya Szymanski>You'll see no impact to the Portland Children's Levy, which will be reimbursed for the compression impact of this levy.

179
00:25:05.660 --> 00:25:20.035
<v Sonya Szymanski>And you'll see, I hope and anticipate, a much stronger connection and support of partners and volunteers who are part of delivering this system with a particular emphasis on revenue-generating opportunities.

180
00:25:21.739 --> 00:25:23.088
<v Sonya Szymanski>That's the end of this presentation.

181
00:25:25.805 --> 00:25:27.258
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much, Sonia.

182
00:25:27.337 --> 00:25:34.648
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, before we move to public testimony and then our broader debate, are there any technical questions about what is included in this document?

183
00:25:36.650 --> 00:25:39.808
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Final proposal that, um, Sonia has laid out for us.

184
00:25:44.285 --> 00:25:44.980
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

185
00:25:45.642 --> 00:25:47.692
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

186
00:25:47.757 --> 00:25:49.903
<v Dan Ryan>I don't have a, um, a technical question.

187
00:25:50.179 --> 00:25:51.272
<v Dan Ryan>I have a clarification.

188
00:25:51.932 --> 00:26:11.886
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, we've been in dialogue about this for the last couple days, Sonia, and, um, in the whereas that's at the second— the second page, yeah, it talks about The City of Portland recognizes strengthening partnerships with the private sector, philanthropic community, volunteers, and grassroots, that area.

189
00:26:12.512 --> 00:26:24.308
<v Dan Ryan>I wanted to put a little bit of teeth into that with a friendly amendment that would add a sentence that we were talking about this morning and yesterday that would have some indicators that we'd actually measure.

190
00:26:24.806 --> 00:26:31.376
<v Dan Ryan>So if we're 2 years into it, we'd see it going from the 1% it's at now to hopefully a higher percent.

191
00:26:32.067 --> 00:26:33.817
<v Dan Ryan>And include that for earned income too.

192
00:26:33.993 --> 00:26:47.016
<v Dan Ryan>Because if we go through this 5-year cycle and nothing really happens with this whereas that actually indicates that we landed that, people will be mightily disappointed, including me.

193
00:26:47.417 --> 00:26:50.035
<v Dan Ryan>And so I wanna make sure that we have that type of accountability.

194
00:26:50.468 --> 00:26:55.846
<v Dan Ryan>So when we do our annual updates or whenever those are, we can actually look at that data.

195
00:26:56.473 --> 00:26:56.954
<v Ashley Murray>Thank you.

196
00:26:58.029 --> 00:27:06.644
<v Dan Ryan>So my question is, like in our conversation earlier, you're good with that friendly amendment, but you want me to specifically tell you what that is?

197
00:27:07.720 --> 00:27:11.634
<v Dan Ryan>I thought for some reason when we got off the phone that you were gonna magically put that in there.

198
00:27:11.810 --> 00:27:13.448
<v Dan Ryan>And so I apologize for not tracking that.

199
00:27:13.559 --> 00:27:14.266
<v Sonya Szymanski>No, not at all.

200
00:27:14.618 --> 00:27:24.693
<v Sonya Szymanski>There is a resolution that came from your office, thank you, that does put a somewhat finer point on what the work will look like, including dedicated staff person, focus on private and philanthropic dollars.

201
00:27:24.741 --> 00:27:33.413
<v Sonya Szymanski>It doesn't speak to particular metric, I would welcome that direction either in the resolution or here in the legislative record, and I would consider it guidance either way.

202
00:27:33.461 --> 00:27:39.885
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, give me a minute or more than that to figure that out, colleagues, and I'll go ahead and bring that to you before we vote.

203
00:27:40.029 --> 00:27:46.165
<v Dan Ryan>But I wanted to at least indicate that to people who are going to testify so they knew that that might be added into this just in case.

204
00:27:46.999 --> 00:27:47.672
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

205
00:27:47.720 --> 00:27:48.217
<v Dan Ryan>Does that make sense?

206
00:27:48.521 --> 00:27:49.066
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, thanks.

207
00:27:49.227 --> 00:27:54.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do have— we have some of— we have your original language included in the proposal.

208
00:27:54.465 --> 00:28:09.773
<v Dan Ryan>It sounds like you have Yeah, based on the meeting we had yesterday with some stakeholders and a dialogue, a couple of conversations this morning, I think people would just like to make sure that it's so transparent that we're tracking it and that the voters do that.

209
00:28:10.174 --> 00:28:14.069
<v Dan Ryan>So again, we're not— this isn't the 2020 levy, it's a different levy.

210
00:28:14.983 --> 00:28:21.652
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And colleagues, I know there are a few others who have amendments that you plan on bringing forward as well.

211
00:28:22.260 --> 00:28:34.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Without introducing those, why don't we open up the opportunity for people to just put on the record You know, a sentence or two what you have coming so that folks who are testifying know what that is.

212
00:28:35.006 --> 00:28:36.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Councilor Avalos, go right ahead.

213
00:28:37.336 --> 00:28:40.854
<v Candace Avalos>I don't have an amendment, I have a question.

214
00:28:41.512 --> 00:28:41.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

215
00:28:41.914 --> 00:29:00.068
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I— on the be it further resolved that says— that starts with be it further resolved that the 3 cents for capital projects is intended to be distributed between the 4 council districts, that section I guess I'm just trying to understand what is the intended process for this.

216
00:29:00.632 --> 00:29:06.028
<v Candace Avalos>Is this an area that could benefit from using the city's Building Belonging framework?

217
00:29:06.594 --> 00:29:12.481
<v Candace Avalos>And how, I guess, like, I don't know, is this a decision the parks director is making?

218
00:29:12.578 --> 00:29:17.221
<v Candace Avalos>How are you going to determine the equity in the distribution to each district?

219
00:29:17.285 --> 00:29:18.709
<v Candace Avalos>It just seems really prescriptive.

220
00:29:20.355 --> 00:29:32.127
<v Candace Avalos>I obviously understand the intent and also the fact that it has a section here essentially saying Um, uh, let's see, City Council members in each district will recommend which projects.

221
00:29:32.869 --> 00:29:34.016
<v Candace Avalos>I understand the intent.

222
00:29:34.113 --> 00:29:40.749
<v Candace Avalos>I'm worried about the application and it being equitable, so I'm curious if you can speak— you can speak to that.

223
00:29:40.798 --> 00:29:43.184
<v Candace Avalos>I'm assuming that would be to Director Szymanski.

224
00:29:45.732 --> 00:29:55.708
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Acting Director Szymanski, I believe that the distribution of these funds would be part of the regular budgeting process, so Council would have the ultimate decision-making authority here.

225
00:29:55.773 --> 00:30:03.204
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if you speak to how the Bureau might bring forward a recommendation, that would be great.

226
00:30:05.820 --> 00:30:17.419
<v Sonya Szymanski>We have dialed in the scope of the universe of projects that would be options for this investment with the scale of the 3 cents.

227
00:30:17.483 --> 00:30:21.365
<v Sonya Szymanski>So that kind of fixes the overall scale that we're talking about.

228
00:30:21.413 --> 00:30:26.458
<v Sonya Szymanski>And it is things like playgrounds and bathrooms and somewhat smaller-scale neighborhood park amenities.

229
00:30:27.068 --> 00:30:29.750
<v Sonya Szymanski>So the first thing we would do is gather all of those.

230
00:30:29.863 --> 00:30:36.044
<v Sonya Szymanski>What happens between there and a final list that you approve in the budget is something I hope we can figure out together.

231
00:30:36.221 --> 00:30:42.836
<v Sonya Szymanski>It would involve a lot of dialogue with you, and I would happily take your guidance about what that conversation looks like and how it's processed.

232
00:30:43.816 --> 00:30:56.065
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You have a process right now for rating deferred maintenance needs that includes a number of factors, including Things around likelihood of failure and danger and equity.

233
00:30:56.176 --> 00:30:56.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

234
00:30:57.141 --> 00:30:57.269
<v Sonya Szymanski>Yes.

235
00:30:58.683 --> 00:31:06.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So could we assume that the proposals you brought forward would be run through that same lens that current projects are run through?

236
00:31:06.740 --> 00:31:08.008
<v Sonya Szymanski>Yeah, we could definitely do that.

237
00:31:09.750 --> 00:31:11.756
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos, does that help answer your question?

238
00:31:16.030 --> 00:31:17.089
<v Candace Avalos>Not fully, but I'll follow up.

239
00:31:17.335 --> 00:31:17.529
<v Loretta Smith>Thanks.

240
00:31:19.721 --> 00:31:19.849
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

241
00:31:20.512 --> 00:31:21.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

242
00:31:23.326 --> 00:31:24.200
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam President.

243
00:31:25.185 --> 00:31:34.840
<v Mitch Green>As we get into the substantive part of the discussion, I will be bringing forward and have filed an amendment to the body of the resolution, not the exhibits.

244
00:31:35.163 --> 00:32:01.807
<v Mitch Green>I wanted to be careful not to upset a delicate balance there, but that changes one whereas clause and a therefore be it resolved clause that really speaks to the question of Kind of using a fiscal stewardship and responsibility lens, given that we are going to go in with a lower recommended levy that tries to extend what we get in terms of capital maintenance.

245
00:32:01.856 --> 00:32:17.179
<v Mitch Green>And so the basic spirit of it is to clarify and sort of suggest that we continue to use system development charges That extend the useful life or restoration of existing capital assets.

246
00:32:18.654 --> 00:32:35.170
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, recognizing that we do need to build new assets in parts of the city that are poor, it will hopefully reaffirm that it's okay for the city to do this, that we have done it in the past, and it's a really good way, I think, to use already existing funds.

247
00:32:36.148 --> 00:32:37.961
<v Mitch Green>So that's what that will be about as we get into it.

248
00:32:38.009 --> 00:32:38.154
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

249
00:32:38.573 --> 00:32:42.065
<v Mitch Green>And I hope that, uh, if you're following along in the public, uh, it's on the website.

250
00:32:42.145 --> 00:32:42.890
<v Mitch Green>It's Councilor Green.

251
00:32:43.244 --> 00:32:43.503
<v Bob Weinstein>Thanks.

252
00:32:44.473 --> 00:32:45.314
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Green, number 1.

253
00:32:45.750 --> 00:32:46.622
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

254
00:32:46.830 --> 00:32:47.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

255
00:32:50.501 --> 00:32:51.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, thank you.

256
00:32:51.338 --> 00:33:02.046
<v Eric Zimmerman>For just in terms of your intent, Madam President, just highlight where we might be offering in the second to last be it resolved.

257
00:33:02.109 --> 00:33:18.740
<v Eric Zimmerman>It starts with be it resolved that the 3 cents per capital project You know, I think that one of the things I've talked a long time about has been, you know, taking care of the basic infrastructure in the parks, and particularly in our district, in District 4.

258
00:33:18.805 --> 00:33:20.539
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's been a challenge in our bathrooms.

259
00:33:20.587 --> 00:33:30.720
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so in that be it resolved, I will be proposing an amendment in the middle of the paragraph after.

260
00:33:31.486 --> 00:33:36.232
<v Eric Zimmerman>Along with annual estimates for available funds for each fiscal year, period.

261
00:33:36.954 --> 00:33:43.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>The 3%— this is the amendment— the 3% for capital projects will be spent only on bathroom facilities, period.

262
00:33:44.028 --> 00:33:45.375
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's the extent of the amendment.

263
00:33:45.776 --> 00:33:49.944
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then it continues on with the city council members in each district, etc., etc.

264
00:33:50.041 --> 00:34:00.109
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just wanted to highlight that, and I appreciate you having these at least aired out so that if public comment has opinions, we can, we can be forthright about it.

265
00:34:00.109 --> 00:34:00.490
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

266
00:34:00.490 --> 00:34:01.390
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's all.

267
00:34:01.390 --> 00:34:02.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

268
00:34:02.829 --> 00:34:04.910
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

269
00:34:04.910 --> 00:34:05.900
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

270
00:34:06.369 --> 00:34:13.730
<v Sameer Kanal>Colleagues, I've emailed you the exact text of the amendment that I will be proposing, but to describe it briefly, it is an amendment to the body of the resolution, not the exhibits.

271
00:34:13.730 --> 00:34:44.846
<v Sameer Kanal>It would ask Parks to direct $139,000— sorry, $139,169, which is 0.232 cents or just under a quarter of a cent from within the existing $1.37 to a pilot project That would extend community center hours at one community center per district on Friday and Saturday nights in the summertime to 11 p.m. to promote access to free third spaces for all Portlanders, in particular young place young people, and promote student achievement, community safety, and youth development.

272
00:34:44.974 --> 00:34:53.387
<v Sameer Kanal>It would be an extension of hours without programming, but I'm sure that the existing text around volunteerism and my personal pledge should have.

273
00:34:53.565 --> 00:35:01.454
<v Sameer Kanal>To donate 2 sets of dodgeballs to any community center in need would help with ensuring that there are activities for people to do.

274
00:35:01.599 --> 00:35:01.840
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

275
00:35:02.804 --> 00:35:03.510
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

276
00:35:04.090 --> 00:35:07.721
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, do you have a proposed amendment?

277
00:35:08.186 --> 00:35:11.096
<v Steve Novick>I have several possible proposed amendments.

278
00:35:12.123 --> 00:35:33.065
<v Steve Novick>One thing is, and actually the Parks Alliance brought this to my attention, there's a number of places in The resolution where there's reference to capital projects, they've recommended that we in each case clarify that means capital maintenance projects, which is the intention, rather than just perhaps imply that we're talking about big fat building new things.

279
00:35:33.163 --> 00:35:34.831
<v Steve Novick>And there's a variety of places where that appears.

280
00:35:35.650 --> 00:35:42.811
<v Steve Novick>I also realized that the whereas at the top of page 3, which I actually proposed, I kind of screwed it up.

281
00:35:43.614 --> 00:35:53.836
<v Steve Novick>Whereas City Council recognized the parks and recreation system has an extensive backlog of major maintenance needs, And the 2025 parks levy will begin to address those needs, but only a small fraction of them.

282
00:35:55.313 --> 00:36:02.275
<v Steve Novick>I concluded I made a mistake in saying major maintenance because we're not talking about using the parks levy to do big fat things again.

283
00:36:02.563 --> 00:36:07.793
<v Steve Novick>So I'm proposing changing major maintenance to capital maintenance there as well.

284
00:36:08.643 --> 00:36:27.706
<v Steve Novick>And then there's a couple of other additions that the Parks Alliance suggested, which I thought were worth They wanted to add a whereas saying, whereas PP&R shall, as part of the annual budget process, describe to council the approximate percentage of its operations and number of FTE which will be funded by levy resources.

285
00:36:28.541 --> 00:36:40.690
<v Steve Novick>And then after the whereas that I was referring to before, which discusses, it says the parks and rec system has extensive backlog of capital maintenance needs, et cetera, et cetera.

286
00:36:40.739 --> 00:36:47.452
<v Steve Novick>And then the whereas that I was referring to before, And it says the council will continue to work with PP&R community on a long-range financial plan with variety of components.

287
00:36:48.702 --> 00:36:54.126
<v Steve Novick>They've suggested that we say that we will adopt this long-range financial plan by the end of fiscal year 2027-28.

288
00:36:54.932 --> 00:36:58.905
<v Steve Novick>So I just wanted to actually— I just wanted to put that out there for discussion.

289
00:37:00.967 --> 00:37:01.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

290
00:37:04.206 --> 00:37:04.902
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

291
00:37:05.097 --> 00:37:06.311
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

292
00:37:06.878 --> 00:37:09.487
<v Dan Ryan>To bring some little clarity to what I Thank you.

293
00:37:09.583 --> 00:37:13.244
<v Dan Ryan>As I mentioned earlier, I would propose adding a whereas.

294
00:37:13.373 --> 00:37:14.818
<v Dan Ryan>It's very basic.

295
00:37:16.101 --> 00:37:28.353
<v Dan Ryan>It would say this: Whereas, on or before December 31st, 2025, parks leadership in collaboration with stakeholders will submit 10 key performance indicators for council's approval.

296
00:37:29.012 --> 00:37:34.070
<v Dan Ryan>These KPIs will form the levy performance dashboard.

297
00:37:38.403 --> 00:37:41.947
<v Dan Ryan>And I'll, um, make sure we email that to everyone by the testimony is going on.

298
00:37:42.141 --> 00:37:42.400
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

299
00:37:42.547 --> 00:37:43.565
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

300
00:37:44.650 --> 00:37:52.244
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, are there any other potential amendments or technical questions before we move to public testimony?

301
00:37:55.400 --> 00:37:55.608
<v Karen Chi Ray>Okay.

302
00:37:56.382 --> 00:38:06.981
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Acting Director Szymanski, DCA Dhanapal, my suspicion is that we will ask you to come back up for our broader discussion after we hear from the public, so please don't go too far.

303
00:38:07.980 --> 00:38:17.688
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But for now, before we move into that discussion, I'd like to have us hear from members of the community about their feedback on the levy proposal before us today.

304
00:38:18.193 --> 00:38:20.621
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call up our first panel?

305
00:38:25.298 --> 00:38:26.498
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

306
00:38:28.454 --> 00:38:32.905
<v Rebecca Dobert>Jessica Green, Allison Berman, Sue Ann Ho.

307
00:38:38.699 --> 00:38:40.311
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome and thank you all for being here today.

308
00:38:43.230 --> 00:38:48.130
<v Jessica Green>Can I go?

309
00:38:48.764 --> 00:38:49.639
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead, Jessica.

310
00:38:51.219 --> 00:38:52.503
<v Jessica Green>Uh, thank you, Council, Mayor.

311
00:38:52.963 --> 00:38:53.835
<v Jessica Green>I'm Jessica Green.

312
00:38:53.885 --> 00:39:03.217
<v Jessica Green>I'm the executive director of the Portland Park Foundation, a citywide parks nonprofit whose mission is to mobilize support for parks, natural areas, and public spaces.

313
00:39:03.972 --> 00:39:12.793
<v Jessica Green>I'm here today to affirm PPF's support and commitment to leading the levy campaign in partnership with the Intertwine Alliance and you once referred.

314
00:39:13.981 --> 00:39:23.764
<v Jessica Green>I also want to take this time to thank you, councilors, Mayor Wilson, and all of your staff for the collaborative spirit in developing the levy over the course of the last several months.

315
00:39:24.840 --> 00:39:35.456
<v Jessica Green>6 Months ago, you were faced with the question of whether to refer $1.60 to the May ballot, and you made the bold decision to hit pause and discuss what this levy should be and could be.

316
00:39:36.628 --> 00:39:50.905
<v Jessica Green>The pause allowed the proposed levy in front of you to be informed and shaped by the public through polling and various forms of testimony, by conversations with each other, key stakeholders that Council President mentioned earlier, the business community, labor, CBOs, and Parkrose Heights.

317
00:39:50.969 --> 00:39:51.065
<v Jessica Green>Thank you.

318
00:39:52.300 --> 00:39:56.005
<v Jessica Green>Partners, and by a hard look at the parks budget during this year's budget cycle.

319
00:39:57.485 --> 00:40:02.932
<v Jessica Green>This has been a really thoughtful process, no matter how rushed it's felt in the final weeks, days, hours, minutes.

320
00:40:03.992 --> 00:40:12.246
<v Jessica Green>And I really want to thank each and every single one of you for carving out the time and being open-minded, coming to the table curious and with creative ideas.

321
00:40:13.646 --> 00:40:23.175
<v Jessica Green>As Commissioner Ryan said during a meeting yesterday about this, everyone in this room has had to compromise on some level, and it really shows the partnership of the city.

322
00:40:24.836 --> 00:40:33.224
<v Jessica Green>Ultimately, the levy maintains a parks and recreation system that we know and love and is essential for a thriving, livable Portland.

323
00:40:33.628 --> 00:40:45.608
<v Jessica Green>In addition to the levy proposed today, the process really has also reignited a couple very important conversations: the need to address the $600 million-plus backlog in capital maintenance Thank you.

324
00:40:45.704 --> 00:40:49.744
<v Jessica Green>And an opportunity to do more with partnerships in order to advance an equitable park system.

325
00:40:51.076 --> 00:40:57.393
<v Jessica Green>The commitment towards some capital maintenance in this levy signals a shift towards prioritizing our capital maintenance needs in our parks.

326
00:40:57.971 --> 00:41:08.282
<v Jessica Green>But as you all know, it's only just a start, and we are committed to work with you and other parks leaders to develop a long-term strategy to address parks' operational and capital needs.

327
00:41:09.275 --> 00:41:11.728
<v Jessica Green>The levy also recognizes the power of partnerships.

328
00:41:12.563 --> 00:41:18.043
<v Jessica Green>I recommend prioritizing investment also in existing partnerships, looking at how the city works with them.

329
00:41:18.876 --> 00:41:24.708
<v Jessica Green>How can we streamline systems, remove obstacles, invest in a culture of creativity and collaboration?

330
00:41:25.286 --> 00:41:29.307
<v Jessica Green>There are hundreds of partners looking to do more together.

331
00:41:30.733 --> 00:41:37.737
<v Jessica Green>And in true partnership, PPF and the Intertwine Alliance are ready to partner with you, City Council, on this future levy.

332
00:41:37.800 --> 00:41:38.041
<v Elizabeth Milner>Thank you.

333
00:41:38.844 --> 00:41:41.492
<v Jessica Green>Thank you for your time now and in the past.

334
00:41:42.681 --> 00:41:43.114
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

335
00:41:43.820 --> 00:41:44.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead, Ali.

336
00:41:45.827 --> 00:41:46.277
<v Ali Berman>Thank you.

337
00:41:46.614 --> 00:41:50.724
<v Ali Berman>And just echoing Jessica on the thoughtful process that has gone into this.

338
00:41:51.351 --> 00:41:57.436
<v Ali Berman>My name is Ali Berman, and I'm the chair of the Portland Parks and Recreation Advisory Board, a Tier 1 advisory board within the city.

339
00:41:57.565 --> 00:42:13.280
<v Ali Berman>I'm representing the board today to strongly advise the City Council to refer a levy renewal at an increased rate for the November election that will allow community centers to remain open, Stop programs from being substantially reduced and ensure ongoing park maintenance as well as capital maintenance.

340
00:42:13.842 --> 00:42:27.369
<v Ali Berman>This is vital for the health of our city, especially in light of the cuts PP&R has already faced in this year's budget and projected further cuts in fiscal year '26-'27, as well as the proposed pause on SDC collection.

341
00:42:27.947 --> 00:42:31.670
<v Ali Berman>Right now, city councilors get to determine what kind of city they want Portland to be.

342
00:42:32.280 --> 00:42:37.079
<v Ali Berman>The board believes that an extensive, vibrant, and robust park system is essential for Portlanders.

343
00:42:38.139 --> 00:42:45.588
<v Ali Berman>That parks are one of the main reasons why Portland is so special, and that parks are a material driver for both new residents and businesses.

344
00:42:46.422 --> 00:42:53.536
<v Ali Berman>But a great park system requires both operational funding for programming and maintenance, and capital funding to preserve and expand systems.

345
00:42:54.291 --> 00:43:03.121
<v Ali Berman>We're excited to build on the 2020 levy, which was very successful in fulfilling what was promised: delivering recreation programs, removing fiscal barriers to park.

346
00:43:03.521 --> 00:43:03.956
<v Mary Ruble>Yes.

347
00:43:04.485 --> 00:43:11.034
<v Ali Berman>Prioritizing services for communities of color and households experiencing poverty, and planting and maintaining trees.

348
00:43:11.548 --> 00:43:16.958
<v Ali Berman>The 2020 levy allowed the park system to be more robust and more equitable than before.

349
00:43:18.355 --> 00:43:25.594
<v Ali Berman>The board asks council to refer a levy renewal to ensure the kind of park system that would be best for Portland and their constituents.

350
00:43:26.157 --> 00:43:31.382
<v Ali Berman>The board also asked council to not underestimate the popular support for parks and park programming.

351
00:43:31.655 --> 00:43:36.034
<v Ali Berman>The support has been seen in polling and more importantly to the recent response to the budget.

352
00:43:36.710 --> 00:43:40.076
<v Ali Berman>Thank you for your consideration and all of your work on behalf of parks.

353
00:43:40.590 --> 00:43:49.820
<v Ali Berman>The board is committed to working alongside you, Portland Parks and Recreation staff, and the broader community to ensure a vibrant, equitable, and sustainable future for our park system.

354
00:43:52.097 --> 00:43:52.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

355
00:43:53.235 --> 00:43:53.559
<v Rebecca Dobert>Right ahead.

356
00:43:54.387 --> 00:43:55.737
<v Sue Ann Ho>Good afternoon everyone.

357
00:43:56.175 --> 00:43:57.135
<v Sue Ann Ho>I am Sunn Ho.

358
00:43:57.476 --> 00:44:12.634
<v Sue Ann Ho>Today I am speaking to you not as a board member of the Portland Parks and Rec Advisory Board, but as a Portland citizen asking you to refer the parks levy at a higher rate to care for and maintain our park system.

359
00:44:13.548 --> 00:44:16.134
<v Sue Ann Ho>I want to share a beautiful evening experience with you.

360
00:44:16.824 --> 00:44:23.842
<v Sue Ann Ho>At 6 PM this past Sunday, when the temperature finally dropped to 90 degrees, Adventurer Park.

361
00:44:24.371 --> 00:44:30.282
<v Sue Ann Ho>Myself and 700 other Portlanders cheered as the Summer Free-for-All concert began.

362
00:44:31.373 --> 00:44:34.875
<v Sue Ann Ho>Portland Taiko filled the stage with their big Japanese drums.

363
00:44:35.405 --> 00:44:42.342
<v Sue Ann Ho>The invigorating drumbeats inspired so many little kids to dance and wave their colorful streamers.

364
00:44:42.954 --> 00:44:46.487
<v Sue Ann Ho>Such pure joy at our shared backyard.

365
00:44:47.498 --> 00:44:53.628
<v Sue Ann Ho>The magic of the 2 hours of applause-filled performance did not just randomly pop up.

366
00:44:54.239 --> 00:45:04.684
<v Sue Ann Ho>It took Portland Parks staff months of planning and coordinating volunteers cleaning and maintaining the park ahead of a scorching hot day.

367
00:45:05.550 --> 00:45:29.646
<v Sue Ann Ho>Multiply this effort by all the other parks events this summer, by the quick run to the restroom between laps, up and down the playground slide, by the long hikes on your favorite trail, and by all the other year-round reliable, well-loved outdoor-indoor programming in community centers that are clean and cared for by parks staff.

368
00:45:30.833 --> 00:45:35.134
<v Sue Ann Ho>None of this would exist at this scale or be functional without parks levy.

369
00:45:35.887 --> 00:45:48.782
<v Sue Ann Ho>With the parks levy, this work is done daily, oftentimes behind the scenes So that we as park users can enjoy our beautiful parks and recreation spaces and programs.

370
00:45:49.681 --> 00:45:55.048
<v Sue Ann Ho>This park levy is an essential piece of Portland's next 5 years and beyond.

371
00:45:55.884 --> 00:46:03.965
<v Sue Ann Ho>It maintains the services and programs that are critical to community and the health of our city.

372
00:46:04.561 --> 00:46:16.501
<v Sue Ann Ho>I sincerely hope that you will decide on a levy amount that maximizes children and adults being inspired by our wonderful parks, programs, and facilities for years to come.

373
00:46:16.858 --> 00:46:17.311
<v Sue Ann Ho>Thank you.

374
00:46:17.911 --> 00:46:20.956
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

375
00:46:25.590 --> 00:46:30.715
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Elizabeth Aravelta.

376
00:46:32.980 --> 00:46:33.947
<v Bob Weinstein>Whoever you are.

377
00:46:35.931 --> 00:46:39.963
<v Rebecca Dobert>Elizabeth Milner, Karen Chi Ray, and John Isaacs.

378
00:46:40.465 --> 00:46:41.905
<v Rebecca Dobert>Elizabeth is online.

379
00:46:44.188 --> 00:46:45.208
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can go ahead, Elizabeth.

380
00:46:46.420 --> 00:46:46.853
<v Elizabeth Milner>Hi there.

381
00:46:47.240 --> 00:46:48.320
<v Elizabeth Milner>Good afternoon, councilors.

382
00:46:48.384 --> 00:46:52.715
<v Elizabeth Milner>My name's Elizabeth Milner and I'm the Development and Engagement Director with Sellwood Community House.

383
00:46:52.956 --> 00:46:56.195
<v Elizabeth Milner>Apologies if it's loud, we're full of summer camp today.

384
00:46:57.246 --> 00:47:00.936
<v Elizabeth Milner>Thank you so much for the opportunity to give testimony again regarding the parks levy.

385
00:47:01.195 --> 00:47:14.172
<v Elizabeth Milner>And thank you so much for the careful time, consideration, and thoughtful thought you have offered Now that you've settled on a dollar amount for the levy, Portland really needs to know what the specific vision is for how those dollars will be spent.

386
00:47:14.702 --> 00:47:17.286
<v Elizabeth Milner>What will this levy mean for people in their daily lives?

387
00:47:17.956 --> 00:47:25.824
<v Elizabeth Milner>At the last council session, one of the slides presented measured the health of PPR by comparing the number of full-time staff to other cities' park bureaus.

388
00:47:26.722 --> 00:47:30.478
<v Elizabeth Milner>By that metric, Portland is in the middle of the pack compared to other comparable cities.

389
00:47:30.543 --> 00:47:30.686
<v Ashley Murray>Thank you.

390
00:47:31.072 --> 00:47:34.398
<v Elizabeth Milner>But how well does that metric really measure what's happening in Portland?

391
00:47:35.090 --> 00:47:52.954
<v Elizabeth Milner>Minneapolis, where I lived for several years, employs just slightly more full-time staff per capita than Portland, and yet operates 47 community centers, dozens of free summer park programs, and hundreds of free concerts, movies, and community celebrations all over the city so that residents on any given day can find fun, easy activities to do with their families.

392
00:47:54.539 --> 00:48:04.322
<v Elizabeth Milner>Portland, meanwhile, operates 22 free lunch and play programs from 10 AM to 2 PM and a smattering of concerts and movies that for most of us require advanced planning and transportation in order to enjoy.

393
00:48:05.398 --> 00:48:06.733
<v Elizabeth Milner>Portland has so much potential.

394
00:48:07.088 --> 00:48:17.242
<v Elizabeth Milner>We have new music venues going in, the WNBA, great local festivals, and Portland Parks and Recreation should be at the heart of a vision for a vibrant and engaging city that attracts and cares for its citizens.

395
00:48:17.291 --> 00:48:19.170
<v Elizabeth Milner>And we are just not quite seeing that yet.

396
00:48:20.983 --> 00:48:32.514
<v Elizabeth Milner>So it's heartening to see the new language on partnerships, but please don't consider partnerships as an opportunity to outsource the work of Portland Parks and Recreation, but rather as an avenue for achieving a shared vision of Portland that we all have a stake in.

397
00:48:34.003 --> 00:48:40.152
<v Elizabeth Milner>And then support them, work with them, collaborate with them, and pave the way for them to help achieve that shared vision for our city.

398
00:48:41.148 --> 00:48:52.277
<v Elizabeth Milner>As someone who engages with hundreds of families each year, organizes events in parks, and is a parent who has accessed or tried to access parks programming for the past 16 years, here are my suggestions for this levy.

399
00:48:53.016 --> 00:48:56.483
<v Elizabeth Milner>Please make our parks and recreation more fun and less complicated.

400
00:48:56.644 --> 00:49:04.882
<v Elizabeth Milner>We need activated parks in every district, vibrant community centers, activated rivers and streets, And citywide sports, art, music, and nature education.

401
00:49:06.342 --> 00:49:16.956
<v Elizabeth Milner>Those same summer park staff, in between playing with kids all day, can clean bathrooms and remove trash, just like they do at the shack in Sellwood Park, which the Sellwood Community House activated this summer.

402
00:49:17.824 --> 00:49:26.557
<v Elizabeth Milner>Where PPR doesn't have the staff or capacity to program yet, truly partner with and support the friends groups, neighborhood groups, business alliances, etc., to take on those programs.

403
00:49:27.233 --> 00:49:28.760
<v Elizabeth Milner>And finally, shake off the past.

404
00:49:28.920 --> 00:49:32.375
<v Elizabeth Milner>Just because we've done things one way doesn't mean we have to keep doing them that way.

405
00:49:32.760 --> 00:49:36.682
<v Elizabeth Milner>Current levels of service doesn't necessarily equate to optimal delivery of service.

406
00:49:37.197 --> 00:49:46.268
<v Elizabeth Milner>This is an incredible opportunity to start fresh with a bold vision for Portland Parks and Rec for the 21st century that is more robust, not less, than the one we enjoyed in the 1970s.

407
00:49:46.418 --> 00:49:47.056
<v Elizabeth Milner>Thank you for your time.

408
00:49:49.360 --> 00:49:50.282
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

409
00:49:51.900 --> 00:49:53.070
<v Rebecca Dobert>Karen is also online.

410
00:49:53.269 --> 00:49:54.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>Karen, you can go ahead.

411
00:50:04.144 --> 00:50:05.226
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe you're muted.

412
00:50:07.454 --> 00:50:07.777
<v Nancy Thorington>There you go.

413
00:50:08.003 --> 00:50:08.552
<v Rebecca Dobert>You're unmuted.

414
00:50:08.713 --> 00:50:09.101
<v Karen Chi Ray>Can you hear me now?

415
00:50:10.072 --> 00:50:10.440
<v Rebecca Dobert>We can.

416
00:50:10.585 --> 00:50:11.277
<v Karen Chi Ray>Sorry about that.

417
00:50:11.518 --> 00:50:12.434
<v Rebecca Dobert>We can hear you, Karen.

418
00:50:13.431 --> 00:50:19.371
<v Karen Chi Ray>My name is Karen T. Ray, resident of District 3, business owner in District 1, and a member of Stadiumhood.

419
00:50:19.567 --> 00:50:28.717
<v Karen Chi Ray>And while I recognize the importance of parks and recreational facilities in our community, I believe that we as taxpayers have reached a breaking point with new taxes.

420
00:50:29.375 --> 00:50:31.460
<v Karen Chi Ray>I'm all taxed out as a business owner.

421
00:50:31.621 --> 00:50:39.418
<v Karen Chi Ray>I already contribute significantly to the city's revenue through various taxes, permits, and fees, and yet I see little return on this investment.

422
00:50:40.043 --> 00:50:55.045
<v Karen Chi Ray>The promise of improved parks and recreational services does not justify the additional financial burden on residents and business owners, especially when many of us are struggling to keep our heads above water due to the rising cost of living and doing business in Portland.

423
00:50:55.766 --> 00:51:09.449
<v Karen Chi Ray>In the four-block radius of my store, Stadium Superette, within the stadium neighborhood, we have seen over 19 businesses close or move in the last few years, and just found out today that another will be moving in September.

424
00:51:10.123 --> 00:51:12.753
<v Karen Chi Ray>Most of those are due to taxes and safety.

425
00:51:13.829 --> 00:51:22.554
<v Karen Chi Ray>The proposed tax rate of the 1.4 per 1,000 assessed value may seem small, but for many of us, it translates.

426
00:51:22.876 --> 00:51:25.798
<v Karen Chi Ray>Into an added monthly expense that we cannot afford.

427
00:51:26.568 --> 00:51:34.099
<v Karen Chi Ray>At a time when our local economy is still recovering, it is essential to prioritize the financial well-being of our residents and small businesses.

428
00:51:34.516 --> 00:51:45.981
<v Karen Chi Ray>Furthermore, while the city emphasizes the operational needs of our parks, I urge you to reconsider the allocation of existing resources instead of placing further financial strain on taxpayers.

429
00:51:46.478 --> 00:51:51.907
<v Karen Chi Ray>We need to ensure that the current funds are being utilized effectively before seeking more money from the community.

430
00:51:52.681 --> 00:51:58.440
<v Karen Chi Ray>I implore you to listen to the voices of residents and business owners who are concerned about the implications of this levy.

431
00:51:58.650 --> 00:52:05.891
<v Karen Chi Ray>Instead of proposing new taxes, let's focus on finding innovative solutions to manage and maintain our parks with the funds we already have.

432
00:52:06.166 --> 00:52:06.635
<v Karen Chi Ray>Thank you.

433
00:52:08.514 --> 00:52:09.940
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

434
00:52:12.449 --> 00:52:12.677
<v Steve Novick>Good.

435
00:52:14.007 --> 00:52:17.590
<v John Isaacs>Uh, Council President Pirtle-Guiney and councilors, for the record, my name is John Isaacs.

436
00:52:17.655 --> 00:52:21.936
<v John Isaacs>I'm the Executive Vice President of Public Affairs for the Portland Metro Chamber.

437
00:52:22.032 --> 00:52:26.143
<v John Isaacs>I prefer he/him pronouns, and I'm a resident of District 3 in Southeast Portland.

438
00:52:26.768 --> 00:52:35.889
<v John Isaacs>The Chamber is the Portland region's Chamber of Commerce and Oregon's largest business association, representing about 2,400 members, over 80% of which are small businesses.

439
00:52:36.659 --> 00:52:42.793
<v John Isaacs>I'm here today to express our strong support for the parks levy resolution and explain why the Chamber chose to endorse it.

440
00:52:43.387 --> 00:52:44.610
<v John Isaacs>And because I cannot be Thank you.

441
00:52:44.675 --> 00:52:54.358
<v John Isaacs>While we're here tonight, I want to also express the chamber's support for the directly related action you will take at 6:45 PM to formally have Portland join the International Swimmable Cities Alliance.

442
00:52:55.376 --> 00:53:03.059
<v John Isaacs>In 2023, Governor Kotek and the Central City Task Force called for a 3-year moratorium on new or increased taxes with our full support.

443
00:53:03.463 --> 00:53:08.561
<v John Isaacs>Since 2020, 2 taxes have advanced without our support, and both were soundly defeated.

444
00:53:08.916 --> 00:53:14.146
<v John Isaacs>This levy is the only significant tax increase we've allowed to advance without opposition during that moratorium.

445
00:53:14.563 --> 00:53:15.141
<v John Isaacs>Here's why.

446
00:53:15.847 --> 00:53:18.077
<v John Isaacs>Because Portland's parks are more than amenities.

447
00:53:18.431 --> 00:53:20.195
<v John Isaacs>They are core economic assets.

448
00:53:20.597 --> 00:53:28.184
<v John Isaacs>For decades, Portland's growth was built on livability, safety, strong public schools, quality transit, and a reasonable cost of living.

449
00:53:28.682 --> 00:53:32.275
<v John Isaacs>But over the last decade, that foundation has eroded and is now crumbling.

450
00:53:32.789 --> 00:53:51.170
<v John Isaacs>We overregulated housing and small businesses, increased business taxes by 84 percent since 2019 and adopted the 2nd highest marginal income tax rate in the nation with little focus on results, killed our housing production market at the very worst time, allowed core public safety services to degrade, and let our core infrastructure decay.

451
00:53:51.635 --> 00:53:56.333
<v John Isaacs>The result: Portland is losing over $1 billion a year in taxable income.

452
00:53:56.686 --> 00:54:00.376
<v John Isaacs>Businesses are leaving, layoffs are growing, and private investment is drying up.

453
00:54:00.777 --> 00:54:04.032
<v John Isaacs>Population growth will turn into negative territory by the decade's end.

454
00:54:04.402 --> 00:54:09.568
<v John Isaacs>So without question, Portland will need to compete with other cities for people and growth.

455
00:54:10.081 --> 00:54:20.432
<v John Isaacs>We will only do that successfully by unleashing private sector growth, adopting a competitive tax burden, supercharging housing production of all types, and investing in our core competitive assets.

456
00:54:20.898 --> 00:54:22.117
<v John Isaacs>This includes parks.

457
00:54:23.000 --> 00:54:33.206
<v John Isaacs>And if they are core economic assets, then they must be maintained and the services delivered delivered in a manner worthy of the beloved treasures we say they are.

458
00:54:33.592 --> 00:54:36.271
<v John Isaacs>This levy must be the beginning of that transformation.

459
00:54:36.882 --> 00:54:41.422
<v John Isaacs>In 2019, the Portland Parks and Rec budget was $5.6 billion.

460
00:54:42.242 --> 00:54:52.657
<v John Isaacs>Just 6 years later, its budget is $8.2 billion, and during this time, services have declined, deferred maintenance was ignored, and trust eroded due to promises broken.

461
00:54:53.106 --> 00:54:58.416
<v John Isaacs>Still, we support this levy because parks remain essential to our competitiveness Yes.

462
00:54:59.266 --> 00:55:04.713
<v John Isaacs>We believe the longtime Portland spirit of collaboration and innovation can make change possible.

463
00:55:04.873 --> 00:55:08.655
<v John Isaacs>I want to be clear, the support of the chamber and our partners is contingent on change.

464
00:55:09.105 --> 00:55:32.677
<v John Isaacs>We expect accountability, fiscal discipline, and adoption of national best practices, like an expansion of public-private partnerships to drive increased economic and cultural vitality, development, development of more diverse revenue streams, and performance Most other cities, including all of our peer markets, formally work with the private sector to manage and activate parks to attract investment, talent, and drive economic and cultural vitality.

465
00:55:33.193 --> 00:55:34.273
<v John Isaacs>Portland must do the same.

466
00:55:35.045 --> 00:55:42.291
<v John Isaacs>Next year, when you have to consider more cuts to the parks general fund, the Chamber and our partners will hold the city accountable to ensure levy—.

467
00:55:43.255 --> 00:55:44.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, John.

468
00:55:44.155 --> 00:55:49.802
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, I'm sorry, John, but we've got to move on.

469
00:55:51.780 --> 00:55:54.538
<v John Isaacs>Thank you.

470
00:55:54.780 --> 00:55:55.317
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

471
00:55:56.630 --> 00:55:59.873
<v Rebecca Dobert>Brian Owendoff, Mary Ruble, Rob Martineau.

472
00:56:08.829 --> 00:56:12.094
<v Brian Owendoff>Councilors, Mayor, Brian Owendoff, live and work in District 4.

473
00:56:12.789 --> 00:56:13.838
<v Brian Owendoff>Parks matter.

474
00:56:14.619 --> 00:56:17.833
<v Brian Owendoff>Since moving here 17 years ago, I've been a strong supporter of parks.

475
00:56:18.246 --> 00:56:19.737
<v Brian Owendoff>Both through treasure and time.

476
00:56:21.132 --> 00:56:27.371
<v Brian Owendoff>The treasure includes over $25 million in parks SDC fees generated through 7 mixed-use towers I've had the pleasure of working on.

477
00:56:27.965 --> 00:56:36.463
<v Brian Owendoff>I've also spent significant time volunteering on the South Park Blocks, Couch Park, and the soon-to-open Darcelle 15 Park in the West End.

478
00:56:37.186 --> 00:56:43.601
<v Brian Owendoff>The proposed increase of the park levies from $0.80 to $1.40 per thousand of assessed value is a sharp jump.

479
00:56:43.681 --> 00:56:50.072
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Yes.

480
00:56:50.717 --> 00:56:53.782
<v Brian Owendoff>This proposal does not meaningfully address the backlog.

481
00:56:54.105 --> 00:56:59.152
<v Brian Owendoff>Instead, it sustains the current operations, operations that many residents believe have been poorly managed.

482
00:56:59.907 --> 00:57:05.626
<v Brian Owendoff>The recent dismissal of the parks director, paired with an ongoing city review, raises serious questions.

483
00:57:06.012 --> 00:57:11.420
<v Brian Owendoff>If the audit uncovers fiscal mismanagement, it would only deepen public concerns about how the tax dollars are being spent.

484
00:57:12.190 --> 00:57:18.563
<v Brian Owendoff>It is essential that the parks audit be released before tax-related measure is placed before the voters.

485
00:57:18.900 --> 00:57:28.277
<v Brian Owendoff>To withhold it until after the election would be a serious breach of transparency and could reasonably be seen as an attempt to obscure facts that would inform voters' decisions.

486
00:57:29.032 --> 00:57:39.195
<v Brian Owendoff>With housing affordability at a breaking point, year-over-year increases in property taxes, often overlapping with duplicative services, Places a growing burden on Portlanders.

487
00:57:39.773 --> 00:57:41.233
<v Brian Owendoff>We are a generous community.

488
00:57:42.197 --> 00:57:46.836
<v Brian Owendoff>We value public spaces, but many of us are at our financial breaking point.

489
00:57:47.800 --> 00:57:49.695
<v Brian Owendoff>Here are 3 things I ask you to consider.

490
00:57:51.090 --> 00:57:56.742
<v Brian Owendoff>One, a moratorium on new tax measures until audits are complete and publicly released.

491
00:57:57.432 --> 00:58:04.014
<v Brian Owendoff>2, A requirement for clear performance metrics and cost controls tied to any future levy.

492
00:58:04.094 --> 00:58:04.206
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

493
00:58:05.152 --> 00:58:15.701
<v Brian Owendoff>3, A mandate that capital backlog plans be fully scoped, costed with a GMP if possible, and scheduled before seeking additional funding.

494
00:58:16.518 --> 00:58:20.125
<v Brian Owendoff>Well-run, fiscally responsible parks matter.

495
00:58:20.461 --> 00:58:20.878
<v Brian Owendoff>Thank you.

496
00:58:22.208 --> 00:58:25.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

497
00:58:25.992 --> 00:58:26.762
<v Mary Ruble>Good afternoon.

498
00:58:27.338 --> 00:58:28.909
<v Mary Ruble>I'm Mary Ruble, District 4.

499
00:58:29.663 --> 00:58:42.050
<v Mary Ruble>I have been involved in Portland parks for over 25 years, having served as board chair of the Parks Advisory Board as well as the Portland Parks Foundation, and currently a Parks Levy Oversight Committee member.

500
00:58:42.597 --> 00:58:46.159
<v Mary Ruble>I'm speaking as an individual, not as a representative of these groups.

501
00:58:46.833 --> 00:58:50.652
<v Mary Ruble>I encourage City Council to refer this parks levy to the November ballot.

502
00:58:51.182 --> 00:59:01.744
<v Mary Ruble>While I am no fan of additional taxes in Portland and agree with our previous speaker, I do support this levy at $1.40 because I believe in our park system and its importance to the city.

503
00:59:02.900 --> 00:59:16.244
<v Mary Ruble>As a member of the PLOC, the Parks Levy Oversight Committee, I believe I bring unique insights into the way that levy oversight committee has been run, and I have 3 things that I would request from the council.

504
00:59:17.094 --> 00:59:35.860
<v Mary Ruble>One is that the appointments to the role, after application by people interested in involvement with the PLOC, LOC be made by a select group of city council and mayor's office representatives with input from the bureau director and appropriate staff, as opposed to simply by the bureau itself.

505
00:59:36.693 --> 00:59:44.677
<v Mary Ruble>Secondly, I recommend involvement in levy committee meetings by appropriate members of the city council and the mayor's office and their staff.

506
00:59:45.719 --> 00:59:59.128
<v Mary Ruble>And I would like to see an opportunity for levy committee members to provide actionable input and advice on specific use of levy dollars because this group has a lot of insight into how the dollars have been spent.

507
01:00:00.235 --> 01:00:12.139
<v Mary Ruble>The bureau has done a very good job of ensuring that the levy committee understands the use of the dollars, and we have certified that use as appropriate in the past.

508
01:00:12.668 --> 01:00:18.349
<v Mary Ruble>I believe that should be what we do going forward but with additional input from the levy committee.

509
01:00:19.827 --> 01:00:28.947
<v Mary Ruble>In the future, the parks levy needs to focus on daily maintenance, cleaning, and care for our parks and natural areas, as well as additional tree canopy.

510
01:00:29.701 --> 01:00:37.552
<v Mary Ruble>We need to keep our parks usable and prevent further degradation, but it is also my belief that we need to focus on maintenance.

511
01:00:38.034 --> 01:00:48.217
<v Mary Ruble>And so I encourage the City Council to also look Look to the future and to a bond for capital maintenance that will be— that will make a difference.

512
01:00:48.588 --> 01:00:54.246
<v Mary Ruble>The 3% is helpful, but it will not make a meaningful difference in that $600 million backlog.

513
01:00:54.505 --> 01:00:56.496
<v Mary Ruble>Thank you very much.

514
01:00:57.742 --> 01:01:00.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here and sharing those ideas.

515
01:01:02.811 --> 01:01:03.280
<v Rob Martineau>Good afternoon.

516
01:01:03.474 --> 01:01:04.786
<v Rob Martineau>My name is Rob Martineau.

517
01:01:05.077 --> 01:01:10.615
<v Rob Martineau>I am the president of AFSCME Local 189 and first vice president of the Northwest Oregon Labor Council.

518
01:01:11.458 --> 01:01:17.601
<v Rob Martineau>Both of these organizations I represent have been a partner and supportive of past levies and Portland Parks and Recreation.

519
01:01:19.760 --> 01:01:20.804
<v Rob Martineau>I hear the capital maintenance.

520
01:01:20.900 --> 01:01:22.635
<v Rob Martineau>I hear all of the things that need to happen.

521
01:01:22.684 --> 01:01:28.677
<v Rob Martineau>The city does a, I think, as well a job as it can at times in asset management.

522
01:01:28.773 --> 01:01:36.579
<v Rob Martineau>Asset management is a critical piece of this, whether we call it, you know, capital maintenance or however we're looking to ensure these parks remain.

523
01:01:37.159 --> 01:01:39.932
<v Rob Martineau>This is something that the city is not new at asset management.

524
01:01:40.612 --> 01:01:42.391
<v Rob Martineau>What we haven't been able to do is fund that.

525
01:01:42.519 --> 01:01:49.237
<v Rob Martineau>We've been able to do it in our other infrastructure systems, but this is one that has not moved forward with a clear plan.

526
01:01:49.829 --> 01:01:51.128
<v Rob Martineau>I am supportive of this levy.

527
01:01:51.914 --> 01:01:57.893
<v Rob Martineau>I represent nearly 1,100 people, city employees who live, work, play, and worship in Portland.

528
01:01:58.630 --> 01:02:02.702
<v Rob Martineau>All of us are beneficiaries, beneficiaries of this park system.

529
01:02:03.615 --> 01:02:11.838
<v Rob Martineau>I think about when the people I know from out of the area come to visit, and it's hard to think of something I do or that they want to do or how we spend time that doesn't involve parks.

530
01:02:11.920 --> 01:02:12.688
<v Rob Martineau>Of our parks.

531
01:02:13.331 --> 01:02:14.469
<v Rob Martineau>I said, what do you want to do?

532
01:02:14.981 --> 01:02:17.242
<v Rob Martineau>And my brother said, I've got to eat Voodoo Donuts.

533
01:02:17.724 --> 01:02:22.358
<v Rob Martineau>I don't know why I needed a bowl of cereal on my donut, but we ate that at Waterfront Park.

534
01:02:23.016 --> 01:02:33.983
<v Rob Martineau>When he said, we got to go eat at a food cart, we took that and blankets and went up and spent time on Tabor, Washington Park, our zoo, all of the things that are in our area.

535
01:02:34.079 --> 01:02:36.228
<v Rob Martineau>It's hard not to end up at a park.

536
01:02:36.565 --> 01:02:37.735
<v Rob Martineau>These are part of our identity.

537
01:02:37.831 --> 01:02:39.018
<v Rob Martineau>These are part of what we deserve to support.

538
01:02:39.067 --> 01:02:39.259
<v Rob Martineau>Thank you.

539
01:02:40.005 --> 01:02:45.371
<v Rob Martineau>And I'm sure all of us have those same examples of where we started to do one thing and ended up in our parks.

540
01:02:47.820 --> 01:02:56.114
<v Rob Martineau>This levy has got to be well-defined, giving Portland Parks and Recreation clear direction and visible accountability.

541
01:02:58.735 --> 01:03:01.465
<v Rob Martineau>Our community should rally to support and pass this levy.

542
01:03:02.385 --> 01:03:24.139
<v Rob Martineau>As a member of organized labor, I expect to be a partner, and I expect And look forward to that opportunity as we develop and lay out vision and mechanisms for our parks, a vision that will ensure Portland's parks and services thrive to buoy and support our community as critical infrastructure.

543
01:03:25.070 --> 01:03:27.621
<v Rob Martineau>This levy is not going to fix everything.

544
01:03:27.989 --> 01:03:29.047
<v Rob Martineau>That's very, very clear.

545
01:03:29.320 --> 01:03:34.806
<v Rob Martineau>But this levy is a bridge to the future where we fund the park system we want and deserve.

546
01:03:34.871 --> 01:03:34.967
<v Karen Chi Ray>Thank you.

547
01:03:36.333 --> 01:03:44.235
<v Rob Martineau>As Portlanders, we owe you, our new form of government, an opportunity to raise up our parks rather than oversee their decline and loss.

548
01:03:45.320 --> 01:03:51.385
<v Rob Martineau>This levy and new council are the only next step for the public spaces and places we all deserve.

549
01:03:53.342 --> 01:03:57.211
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

550
01:03:57.293 --> 01:04:01.621
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sandeep Divakar, Micah Meskel, Ryan Um, so do I.

551
01:04:07.215 --> 01:04:08.416
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

552
01:04:08.496 --> 01:04:08.934
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

553
01:04:11.677 --> 01:04:14.802
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's see.

554
01:04:15.014 --> 01:04:16.608
<v Sandeep Divakar>Um, my name is Sandeep Divakar.

555
01:04:16.657 --> 01:04:18.007
<v Sandeep Divakar>I live in District 4 downtown.

556
01:04:19.327 --> 01:04:24.606
<v Sandeep Divakar>Um, Councilor Green, actually I heard you say at some one of your meetings that not many people live in downtown.

557
01:04:24.672 --> 01:04:25.338
<v Sandeep Divakar>I beg to differ.

558
01:04:25.402 --> 01:04:30.152
<v Sandeep Divakar>There's a lot of Section 8 low-income housing A lot of elderly people living in that downtown area.

559
01:04:31.215 --> 01:04:32.648
<v Sandeep Divakar>A lot of high-density housing.

560
01:04:33.067 --> 01:04:35.159
<v Sandeep Divakar>I've been a resident there for about 9 years now.

561
01:04:35.385 --> 01:04:41.416
<v Sandeep Divakar>One of the things I truly enjoy about Portland is the fact that we have the ability to use these public parks scattered all over the city.

562
01:04:42.239 --> 01:04:50.547
<v Sandeep Divakar>I studied urban design in graduate school, and parks are essential in high-density urban environments because they function as backyards for people that don't have backyards.

563
01:04:52.231 --> 01:04:55.005
<v Sandeep Divakar>These parks were a godsend during the pandemic when people were cooped up.

564
01:04:55.054 --> 01:04:55.333
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

565
01:04:56.463 --> 01:04:59.152
<v Sandeep Divakar>Which brings me to the matter under discussion today, the parks levy.

566
01:05:00.639 --> 01:05:04.641
<v Sandeep Divakar>The parks we have today are not usable, and not for the reasons that I heard today.

567
01:05:05.576 --> 01:05:08.092
<v Sandeep Divakar>I walked through the South Park blocks on my way here.

568
01:05:08.496 --> 01:05:10.416
<v Sandeep Divakar>There was a drug deal that went down in front of me.

569
01:05:10.528 --> 01:05:11.431
<v Sandeep Divakar>There's needles over there.

570
01:05:11.559 --> 01:05:20.333
<v Sandeep Divakar>There's a group called Portland People's Outreach Project that hands out needles and food at 4:30 PM in the South Park blocks in front of the art museum.

571
01:05:21.072 --> 01:05:22.728
<v Sandeep Divakar>There's a preschool on the next block.

572
01:05:22.809 --> 01:05:27.454
<v Sandeep Divakar>The children have to Worry about the needles and human excrement when they come out to play in that park.

573
01:05:28.407 --> 01:05:32.994
<v Sandeep Divakar>I was at Couch Park day before yesterday for a drawing class.

574
01:05:33.434 --> 01:05:37.891
<v Sandeep Divakar>Same thing, needles, tents, homeless people, and drug use.

575
01:05:38.969 --> 01:05:42.994
<v Sandeep Divakar>So it's very difficult for me and my neighbors.

576
01:05:44.476 --> 01:05:57.503
<v Sandeep Divakar>Many of the neighbors are older and they like to go sit in the park, which they're afraid to do because there's an 80-bed shelter going in 2 blocks from where I live, 3 blocks from South Park, We went to the shelter.

577
01:05:57.583 --> 01:06:01.373
<v Sandeep Divakar>They said they have no plans to do anything except clean around the shelter.

578
01:06:01.438 --> 01:06:03.251
<v Sandeep Divakar>None of us were given notice about this shelter.

579
01:06:03.333 --> 01:06:05.114
<v Sandeep Divakar>We heard about it in the newspaper.

580
01:06:06.061 --> 01:06:09.065
<v Sandeep Divakar>And this is a no-barrier shelter.

581
01:06:09.690 --> 01:06:11.264
<v Sandeep Divakar>These people have guns and knives.

582
01:06:11.313 --> 01:06:13.304
<v Sandeep Divakar>There have been stabbings and shootings in that area.

583
01:06:14.588 --> 01:06:16.081
<v Sandeep Divakar>This is 5 blocks from City Hall.

584
01:06:17.302 --> 01:06:18.972
<v Sandeep Divakar>They will be let out at 7 in the morning.

585
01:06:19.244 --> 01:06:20.320
<v Sandeep Divakar>They will be in the parks.

586
01:06:20.802 --> 01:06:29.083
<v Sandeep Divakar>Councilor So why should we be paying $1.40 more on everything that we're already paying when we can't use the parks that we have?

587
01:06:30.268 --> 01:06:34.485
<v Sandeep Divakar>So I urge you as a city council to please do your jobs and make this city livable.

588
01:06:35.967 --> 01:06:36.338
<v Sandeep Divakar>Thank you.

589
01:06:39.414 --> 01:06:40.204
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

590
01:06:44.335 --> 01:06:45.288
<v Rebecca Dobert>Micah, you can go ahead.

591
01:06:46.047 --> 01:06:47.224
<v Micah Meskel>Okay, thank you.

592
01:06:47.483 --> 01:06:48.759
<v Micah Meskel>Um, thank you, Council President.

593
01:06:48.860 --> 01:06:50.514
<v Micah Meskel>Good afternoon, Council President and the rest of City Council.

594
01:06:50.563 --> 01:06:51.606
<v Micah Meskel>My name is Michael Meskel.

595
01:06:52.041 --> 01:07:02.838
<v Micah Meskel>I'm the Urban Conservation Director at Bird Alliance of Oregon, a local nonprofit whose mission is to inspire all people to love and protect birds, wildlife, and the natural environment upon which life depends.

596
01:07:03.916 --> 01:07:10.632
<v Micah Meskel>Building and maintaining the regional system of parks, trails, and natural areas has been at the core of our urban conservation efforts for decades.

597
01:07:11.226 --> 01:07:14.215
<v Micah Meskel>Our goal is to ensure that every person in the region has access to nature.

598
01:07:14.264 --> 01:07:14.376
<v Ali Berman>Thank you.

599
01:07:14.666 --> 01:07:16.206
<v Micah Meskel>Within walking distance of their home.

600
01:07:16.608 --> 01:07:26.291
<v Micah Meskel>To that end, Bird Alliance of Oregon has focused a significant portion of its efforts on ensuring that there's adequate funding for parks, trails, natural areas, and the maintenance of those.

601
01:07:27.431 --> 01:07:37.289
<v Micah Meskel>I'm representing the organization and our over 10,000+ local members and urging you to refer the parks levy renewal to the ballot in November at an increased rate of $1.40.

602
01:07:38.125 --> 01:08:01.706
<v Micah Meskel>This isn't enough, especially to meet the the maintenance backlog that the system is hampered by, but it is better than the status quo rates and will allow for you all to take iterative steps towards reducing the backlog while working collaboratively with partners, including community organizations, towards securing a more sustainable funding path— pathway for Portland Parks via a future bond measure or other strategies.

603
01:08:03.260 --> 01:08:16.131
<v Micah Meskel>Bird Alliance has helped shape and pass several bond I've been involved in bond measures and levies over the past 30 years and plan to play a role alongside Rob and other community members who have offered today in helping make this one past the finish line in November.

604
01:08:17.046 --> 01:08:28.557
<v Micah Meskel>As many city bureaus are, Portland Parks and Rec is struggling, especially in light of the cuts that PP&R has already faced in this year's reduced budget, both on the maintenance side and on the urban forestry side.

605
01:08:29.345 --> 01:08:30.869
<v Micah Meskel>Projected further cuts in 2017.

606
01:08:32.619 --> 01:08:36.898
<v Micah Meskel>2627 Also loom, and the proposed pause of the STC collection.

607
01:08:37.479 --> 01:08:49.358
<v Micah Meskel>With all of this in, in place, it is essential that right now you all as City Council give them a lifeline to remain providing services and protecting the resources that Portlanders cherish and rely on.

608
01:08:49.796 --> 01:08:50.185
<v Micah Meskel>Thank you.

609
01:08:52.798 --> 01:08:53.871
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

610
01:08:56.465 --> 01:08:58.252
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan, Ryan's online.

611
01:08:58.613 --> 01:08:59.284
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can unmute.

612
01:08:59.935 --> 01:09:00.289
<v Rebecca Dobert>And begin.

613
01:09:04.125 --> 01:09:09.860
<v Brian Sotomayor>Good afternoon, President, Council President Pirtle-Guiney, and City Council.

614
01:09:10.021 --> 01:09:11.423
<v Brian Sotomayor>It's very nice to see you.

615
01:09:12.905 --> 01:09:15.694
<v Brian Sotomayor>Really appreciate all the work that has gone into this.

616
01:09:16.128 --> 01:09:25.704
<v Brian Sotomayor>We really appreciate all of you have opened your offices to us and have come to talk to workers out in the community, out in the parks.

617
01:09:27.645 --> 01:09:36.391
<v Brian Sotomayor>We look forward to further collaboration around the parks levy and also our working relationship with the Portland City Laborers and Recreation contract.

618
01:09:36.440 --> 01:09:52.104
<v Brian Sotomayor>I'm going to back up and explain that I'm Brian Sotomayor from Laborers Local 483, so we represent City of Portland workers in both the PCL contract, which covers Portland Parks maintenance workers, and then on the recreation side, the recreation contract.

619
01:09:53.014 --> 01:10:02.335
<v Brian Sotomayor>Act, folks in community centers, folks that are involved in summer programming like Summer Free-for-All, Lunch and Play, and seasonal maintenance workers.

620
01:10:02.832 --> 01:10:08.136
<v Brian Sotomayor>And we represent folks from lifeguards up to millwrights.

621
01:10:08.555 --> 01:10:17.171
<v Brian Sotomayor>Everything that happens in the City of Portland, uh, is somehow touched by folks in the Portland City Laborers contract and the recreation contract.

622
01:10:17.332 --> 01:10:25.064
<v Brian Sotomayor>So we appreciate your work And not only collaborating with community partners, but also meeting with labor.

623
01:10:25.145 --> 01:10:29.560
<v Brian Sotomayor>That is meaningful, and we appreciate the engagement and the investment.

624
01:10:29.720 --> 01:10:44.219
<v Brian Sotomayor>We appreciate the energy that's being brought by the community, the Portland Parks Foundation, the Portland Parks Alliance, all the community groups that have brought energy and spoken to the important resources.

625
01:10:44.332 --> 01:10:51.641
<v Brian Sotomayor>Resources that Portland Parks and Recreation are, and also supportive of the workers of Portland Parks and Recreation.

626
01:10:51.738 --> 01:10:55.949
<v Brian Sotomayor>So we really appreciate that and look forward to the partnership moving forward.

627
01:10:56.867 --> 01:11:00.100
<v Brian Sotomayor>We fully support this levy going forward.

628
01:11:00.309 --> 01:11:01.386
<v Brian Sotomayor>We are in it to win it.

629
01:11:02.569 --> 01:11:08.301
<v Brian Sotomayor>483 Was the folks that were texting and phone calling in the 2020 parks levy.

630
01:11:09.365 --> 01:11:20.439
<v Brian Sotomayor>We used Apano's texting infrastructure, but it was folks from the Parks Alliance and from the foundation and from 483 that brought this home.

631
01:11:20.502 --> 01:11:31.305
<v Brian Sotomayor>And we look forward to partnering with labor, partnering with all of you, and partnering with the community partnerships to make sure that the levy is passed and that there's accountability on the other side.

632
01:11:31.435 --> 01:11:37.119
<v Brian Sotomayor>We really appreciate the look into the budget that the mayor has been doing and that City Council has been doing.

633
01:11:37.296 --> 01:11:41.119
<v Brian Sotomayor>We know that it's difficult work We appreciate your leadership on that.

634
01:11:41.666 --> 01:11:53.131
<v Brian Sotomayor>We appreciate your— looking forward to your leadership around all the struggles that we face around transportation and livability and all of the things.

635
01:11:53.259 --> 01:11:55.411
<v Brian Sotomayor>So we appreciate your leadership.

636
01:11:55.555 --> 01:11:57.305
<v Brian Sotomayor>We look forward to seeing you in person.

637
01:11:57.963 --> 01:12:03.006
<v Brian Sotomayor>Thank you for your important work, and thank you for your time and your consideration.

638
01:12:03.583 --> 01:12:03.775
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

639
01:12:06.255 --> 01:12:07.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

640
01:12:07.250 --> 01:12:07.951
<v Sonya Szymanski>We appreciate it.

641
01:12:11.609 --> 01:12:14.328
<v Rebecca Dobert>Bob Weinstein, Ashley Murray.

642
01:12:21.510 --> 01:12:22.591
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>Hi, I'm Laina Ala-Slaughter.

643
01:12:22.832 --> 01:12:26.882
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>I did not think I was going to go right after, uh, Ryan Sotomayor.

644
01:12:27.576 --> 01:12:30.512
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>I am the union rep for LIUNA 43.

645
01:12:30.980 --> 01:12:32.979
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>I live in District District 2.

646
01:12:33.220 --> 01:12:38.100
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>Um, I'm here to also, um, state my support for the levy.

647
01:12:38.356 --> 01:12:42.707
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>Uh, we appreciate City Council, the mayor, um, for working on this.

648
01:12:42.787 --> 01:12:47.877
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>I know it's been hard and you haven't been in your position for, for that long.

649
01:12:48.470 --> 01:13:07.559
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>Um, I will say we, um, I am very supportive of continuing programs, which I've been a fitness instructor from Rec Lead, and I've, I worked at Grant Park during the summer doing, uh, fitness, teaching hula classes.

650
01:13:08.216 --> 01:13:17.672
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>Um, and this levy will help our teens, our, our youth who are employed for summer camps, um, for, for these summer programs.

651
01:13:17.850 --> 01:13:24.255
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>And if, if the levy doesn't pass, um, I'm not sure if we could continue those programs.

652
01:13:24.304 --> 01:13:26.181
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>So thank you so much.

653
01:13:27.176 --> 01:13:29.707
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>Um, I look forward to working with you in the future.

654
01:13:31.149 --> 01:13:31.654
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

655
01:13:35.153 --> 01:13:36.170
<v Bob Weinstein>Am I next?

656
01:13:36.686 --> 01:13:36.832
<v Bob Weinstein>Okay.

657
01:13:37.057 --> 01:13:40.029
<v Bob Weinstein>Um, council members and mayor, my name is Bob Weinstein.

658
01:13:40.445 --> 01:13:42.840
<v Bob Weinstein>I speak today on behalf of the Concerned Citizens.

659
01:13:43.578 --> 01:13:48.143
<v Bob Weinstein>We urge you to revise the proposed parks levy before referring it to the voters.

660
01:13:48.720 --> 01:13:53.847
<v Bob Weinstein>As written, the ballot title risks misleading the public in several key ways.

661
01:13:54.376 --> 01:14:02.003
<v Bob Weinstein>First, the ballot title blurs the critical distinction between routine maintenance within operations and major capital maintenance.

662
01:14:02.469 --> 01:14:16.042
<v Bob Weinstein>The language implies this levy will help address the city's staggering $600 million major maintenance backlog, but the actual portion going to major capital maintenance is minimal, and nowhere is that made clear.

663
01:14:16.570 --> 01:14:25.462
<v Bob Weinstein>Why not specify the initial major capital maintenance maintenance allocation $2 million so voters understand what they're truly being asked to approve.

664
01:14:25.976 --> 01:14:30.570
<v Bob Weinstein>Second, the language maintains excessive discretion for parks leadership.

665
01:14:31.020 --> 01:14:41.444
<v Bob Weinstein>This vagueness enables the same mismanagement and imbalanced spending between overall operations and major capital maintenance that created our current crisis.

666
01:14:41.958 --> 01:14:43.886
<v Bob Weinstein>We do not need more blank checks.

667
01:14:44.368 --> 01:14:48.061
<v Bob Weinstein>Third, the title masks the true cost impact.

668
01:14:48.527 --> 01:15:00.216
<v Bob Weinstein>Nowhere does the ballot language acknowledge that this is a 75% parks levy tax increase from 80 cents to $1.40 per $1,000 in assessed value.

669
01:15:00.666 --> 01:15:03.122
<v Bob Weinstein>Voters deserve transparency.

670
01:15:03.796 --> 01:15:05.868
<v Bob Weinstein>This should be stated plainly on the ballot.

671
01:15:06.365 --> 01:15:10.283
<v Bob Weinstein>The measure states also it may increase taxes by more than 3%.

672
01:15:11.167 --> 01:15:21.014
<v Bob Weinstein>Without explaining that 3% is the constitutional cap on assessed value growth, making this sound routine when it's actually an override exception.

673
01:15:21.527 --> 01:15:24.702
<v Bob Weinstein>Fourth, the timing is particularly concerning.

674
01:15:25.551 --> 01:15:38.675
<v Bob Weinstein>Affordability in Portland is facing death by a thousand cuts, with recent huge utility hikes, large increases in parking, rideshare, and other fees, and And now a major tax increase in this levy.

675
01:15:39.176 --> 01:15:45.970
<v Bob Weinstein>This comes as we await an audit of the Parks Bureau and following the recent departure of the parks director.

676
01:15:46.390 --> 01:15:47.760
<v Bob Weinstein>We recommend 2 changes.

677
01:15:48.194 --> 01:15:52.387
<v Bob Weinstein>First, significantly increase the share going to major capital maintenance.

678
01:15:52.774 --> 01:16:01.067
<v Bob Weinstein>3 Cents out of $1.40 generates about $2 million, not enough to make a dent in a $600 million backlog.

679
01:16:01.131 --> 01:16:07.559
<v Bob Weinstein>Second, Second, revise the ballot title to clearly state this is a 75% tax increase.

680
01:16:08.618 --> 01:16:13.114
<v Bob Weinstein>We also request that Parks and Recreation audit be released prior to the election.

681
01:16:13.837 --> 01:16:19.472
<v Bob Weinstein>The current proposal asks for trust for a bureau that has demonstrated poor fiscal stewardship.

682
01:16:19.875 --> 01:16:27.404
<v Bob Weinstein>Without transparency and accountability measures, this levy will perpetuate the same problems that created our parks crisis.

683
01:16:28.206 --> 01:16:30.510
<v Bob Weinstein>We urge you to be honest with voters.

684
01:16:30.944 --> 01:16:35.957
<v Bob Weinstein>Voters can make informed choices only when they're given the full picture.

685
01:16:36.670 --> 01:16:37.560
<v Bob Weinstein>Thank you very much.

686
01:16:39.390 --> 01:16:39.858
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

687
01:16:42.850 --> 01:16:43.435
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ashley's online.

688
01:16:43.719 --> 01:16:44.872
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ashley, you can unmute.

689
01:16:47.149 --> 01:16:47.954
<v Ashley Murray>Hi, council members.

690
01:16:48.131 --> 01:16:52.868
<v Ashley Murray>My name is Ashley Murray, executive director of Solid Community House and District 4 resident.

691
01:16:53.529 --> 01:16:58.274
<v Ashley Murray>I want to say thank you for how much time, coordination, and effort has gone into bringing this levy forward.

692
01:16:58.322 --> 01:17:02.698
<v Ashley Murray>It's been complex and a demanding process, and your dedication truly matters.

693
01:17:03.194 --> 01:17:07.667
<v Ashley Murray>That said, as we look toward November, I'm asking us to make a shift beyond spreadsheets.

694
01:17:08.180 --> 01:17:17.606
<v Ashley Murray>Over the last 6 months, I've had dozens of conversations with park and rec leaders, Park Foundation staff, campaign strategists, volunteers, nonprofit partners, and many of you.

695
01:17:18.201 --> 01:17:25.865
<v Ashley Murray>In every Every single one of these conversations, I've asked the same simple question: who is shaping the vision for Portland Parks and Recreation?

696
01:17:26.363 --> 01:17:29.795
<v Ashley Murray>Every single time, the answer is the same: it's a really good question.

697
01:17:30.389 --> 01:17:32.313
<v Ashley Murray>That's not an acceptable answer anymore.

698
01:17:32.472 --> 01:17:39.899
<v Ashley Murray>Portland does not currently have a public unifying vision for its park and recreation system, and this isn't just my observation, it's widespread.

699
01:17:40.332 --> 01:17:44.292
<v Ashley Murray>No one can clearly articulate where we're headed or what kind of future we're building together.

700
01:17:44.356 --> 01:17:50.561
<v Ashley Murray>Councilmember We cannot move forward, not effectively, not meaningfully, without a shared vision and a visionary to lead it.

701
01:17:50.979 --> 01:17:52.054
<v Ashley Murray>We are not in a vacuum.

702
01:17:52.198 --> 01:17:54.891
<v Ashley Murray>Voters, partners, and staff feel the same uncertainty.

703
01:17:55.469 --> 01:17:56.175
<v Ashley Murray>Where are we going?

704
01:17:56.608 --> 01:17:57.746
<v Ashley Murray>What are we working towards?

705
01:17:57.810 --> 01:18:00.439
<v Ashley Murray>What does the future of Portland Parks and Recreation look like?

706
01:18:00.936 --> 01:18:07.222
<v Ashley Murray>Right now, we're asking Portlanders to support another tax increase without offering a compelling, inspiring vision in return.

707
01:18:07.815 --> 01:18:11.729
<v Ashley Murray>Maintaining current service levels is indeed necessary, but it is not inspiring.

708
01:18:11.792 --> 01:18:11.936
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

709
01:18:12.466 --> 01:18:13.811
<v Ashley Murray>People are hungry for purpose.

710
01:18:13.923 --> 01:18:18.106
<v Ashley Murray>They're eager to be part of something bigger, and they deserve more than operational upkeep.

711
01:18:18.251 --> 01:18:23.186
<v Ashley Murray>They deserve leadership that shows where we are and being bold enough to lead towards something better.

712
01:18:23.682 --> 01:18:30.717
<v Ashley Murray>The 1.0 FTE for partnership included in this levy is a start, but without a shared vision, what is that position building towards?

713
01:18:31.087 --> 01:18:37.896
<v Ashley Murray>Is it approving paperwork, or is it creating strategic collaborative relationships rooted in values like equity, belonging, and joy?

714
01:18:38.523 --> 01:18:46.762
<v Ashley Murray>Partners stepping in to meet the community needs should be seen as co-builders, co-authors, not just as applicants that require intention, investment, and alignment.

715
01:18:47.197 --> 01:18:50.345
<v Ashley Murray>We need someone who doesn't just say, yes, your program is approved.

716
01:18:50.649 --> 01:18:54.793
<v Ashley Murray>We need someone who can say, this partnership reflects our values and meets a critical need.

717
01:18:54.922 --> 01:18:57.395
<v Ashley Murray>It brings our vision to life, and we're doing it together.

718
01:18:57.814 --> 01:18:58.858
<v Ashley Murray>So I'd like to say it again.

719
01:18:59.082 --> 01:19:02.664
<v Ashley Murray>Portland currently does not have a vision for its park and recreation system.

720
01:19:03.082 --> 01:19:03.708
<v Ashley Murray>That's a leadership gap.

721
01:19:03.773 --> 01:19:03.885
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

722
01:19:04.222 --> 01:19:13.554
<v Ashley Murray>And we are asking clearly and urgently for council and parks leadership to make the creation of a shared, bold public vision a top priority over these coming months.

723
01:19:13.957 --> 01:19:20.734
<v Ashley Murray>We cannot keep answering the most important question, who is leading the vision of Portland Park and Recreation, with, that's a good question.

724
01:19:21.390 --> 01:19:24.559
<v Ashley Murray>We must start saying, here's where we're going, come with us.

725
01:19:24.979 --> 01:19:25.399
<v Ashley Murray>Thank you.

726
01:19:28.051 --> 01:19:28.908
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

727
01:19:33.292 --> 01:19:34.064
<v Rebecca Dobert>Jim Shulen.

728
01:19:45.494 --> 01:19:46.527
<v Rob Martineau>Thanks for accommodating me.

729
01:19:46.786 --> 01:19:47.640
<v Priya Dhanapal>Appreciate it.

730
01:19:47.996 --> 01:19:49.787
<v Jim Shulen>Um, I'm Jim Shulen.

731
01:19:50.158 --> 01:19:52.822
<v Jim Shulen>I am representing the Portland Parks Alliance today.

732
01:19:52.902 --> 01:19:58.398
<v Jim Shulen>I'm also a volunteer with the 40 Mile Loop Land Thank you very much for this opportunity.

733
01:19:59.752 --> 01:20:03.219
<v Jim Shulen>As a resident of District 3, I really appreciate it.

734
01:20:03.476 --> 01:20:08.202
<v Jim Shulen>I'm going to read a letter into the record from the Portland Parks Alliance.

735
01:20:09.695 --> 01:20:21.737
<v Jim Shulen>The Portland Parks Alliance is an informal alliance of volunteer-based and professionally led not-for-profit organizations that are allies and supporters of Portland Parks and Recreation and their programs.

736
01:20:22.903 --> 01:20:34.091
<v Jim Shulen>We are representative of 60 participating organizations who are concerned about the sustainability of PP&R's financial model and the long-term sustainability of its assets.

737
01:20:35.341 --> 01:20:38.868
<v Jim Shulen>Our purpose is not to advocate for individual programs or assets.

738
01:20:38.931 --> 01:20:53.528
<v Jim Shulen>Rather, we exist to advocate for the entire system of parks, natural areas, trails, community and cultural centers, and for programs that are desired by the community that PP&R is uniquely able to provide.

739
01:20:54.572 --> 01:20:59.778
<v Jim Shulen>PP&R's documentation tells us that the amount of deferred capital maintenance totals $600 million.

740
01:20:59.939 --> 01:21:01.578
<v Jim Shulen>You've heard that about 5 times today.

741
01:21:02.444 --> 01:21:15.507
<v Jim Shulen>This list includes everything from worn-out playground equipment, restrooms with failing roofs, buckled pathways, sidewalks, and sports courts, inefficient lighting, park lighting poles that are subject to failure, and the failure of entire structures.

742
01:21:15.555 --> 01:21:15.765
<v Jim Shulen>Oh, my goodness.

743
01:21:16.760 --> 01:21:19.164
<v Jim Shulen>Such as the Multnomah Art Center.

744
01:21:20.336 --> 01:21:35.634
<v Jim Shulen>Because of our concern about the deterioration of PP&R's assets, nearly a year ago we came before City Council to question the process of simply renewing the parks levy of 2020 without also addressing the deterioration of PP&R's assets.

745
01:21:35.681 --> 01:21:39.963
<v Jim Shulen>Since then, we have met and spoken to most of you about our concerns.

746
01:21:41.118 --> 01:21:52.182
<v Jim Shulen>The budget's— the city's budget office recommends an annual expenditure of $60 million just to maintain PP&R's asset base, never mind addressing the $600 million backlog.

747
01:21:52.824 --> 01:21:56.127
<v Jim Shulen>In recent history, the city has appropriated $5 million per year.

748
01:21:57.378 --> 01:22:05.252
<v Jim Shulen>3 Cents specified by Resolution 2025-281 will add about $2.1 million per year.

749
01:22:05.877 --> 01:22:13.078
<v Jim Shulen>You could say it's a start, and the PPA appreciates it as a good faith gesture in a time of financial stress for the city.

750
01:22:13.173 --> 01:22:13.319
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

751
01:22:14.554 --> 01:22:26.264
<v Jim Shulen>The PPA also appreciates council's renewed attention to its own statement of intent made in 2015 to address the city's capital maintenance backlog.

752
01:22:26.344 --> 01:22:36.097
<v Jim Shulen>Clearly, we have a long way to go, and we wish to continue working with you to find a sustainable funding model for Portland Parks and Recreation.

753
01:22:36.225 --> 01:22:36.979
<v Jim Shulen>Thank you very much.

754
01:22:37.509 --> 01:22:38.006
<v Jim Shulen>Thanks.

755
01:22:38.376 --> 01:22:45.024
<v Jim Shulen>Special thanks to Councilor Novick for bringing forward a discussion on the amendments that we propose.

756
01:22:45.948 --> 01:22:46.256
<v Jim Shulen>Thank you.

757
01:22:47.229 --> 01:22:48.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

758
01:22:49.390 --> 01:22:50.497
<v Rebecca Dobert>That concludes testimony.

759
01:22:52.350 --> 01:22:56.085
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, colleagues, that moves us into our discussion.

760
01:22:56.166 --> 01:23:03.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as we heard, we have a number of councilors who have amendments to propose to the resolution before us.

761
01:23:03.939 --> 01:23:13.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When we take our vote today, we will be voting on the resolution as well as the exhibits, which are the materials that will actually appear before voters.

762
01:23:14.242 --> 01:23:20.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The resolution will guide us in our work as we implement this levy moving forward.

763
01:23:22.088 --> 01:23:32.716
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I would now entertain a discussion on the underlying materials or amendments to that resolution that folks have brought up previously.

764
01:23:38.929 --> 01:23:47.189
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam President, and also thank you to everyone who came out today to testify and share your priorities, concerns.

765
01:23:48.652 --> 01:23:59.738
<v Mitch Green>I think the amendment that I want to bring today is responsive to a theme that I have heard since taking this office, which is sort of voter and taxpayer trust in the city.

766
01:24:00.657 --> 01:24:07.979
<v Mitch Green>And my approach to this conversation is not necessarily from the standpoint of taxpayer fatigue.

767
01:24:08.043 --> 01:24:11.521
<v Mitch Green>I think if you know me, you might think that that's not my position.

768
01:24:11.569 --> 01:24:12.707
<v Mitch Green>I see Bob smiling there.

769
01:24:13.813 --> 01:24:17.722
<v Mitch Green>But I also think from the standpoint of stewardship of our existing resources and how we use our money.

770
01:24:17.819 --> 01:24:22.675
<v Mitch Green>And that's an area that I think I'd like this amendment to speak to.

771
01:24:22.722 --> 01:24:27.002
<v Mitch Green>So if you have the amendment in front of you, I'll just read what it is.

772
01:24:27.501 --> 01:24:30.470
<v Mitch Green>Um, oh, before I do that, I just want— I just want to motivate it.

773
01:24:31.112 --> 01:24:50.993
<v Mitch Green>Um, I, I, I think that we have a narrow interpretation of ORS— uh, what is it— uh, ORS 223, which begins on .297 and runs through, um, I think it's, uh, 316, which, which is the state law that governs our use of system development charges.

774
01:24:51.652 --> 01:24:56.930
<v Mitch Green>Um, and I'll direct you to So let me go to the section on authorized expenditures of system development charges.

775
01:24:57.604 --> 01:25:04.356
<v Mitch Green>Basically, we are allowed to spend SDCs only on things that are capacity increase and capital improvements.

776
01:25:04.421 --> 01:25:06.956
<v Mitch Green>And they give us a number of definitions for what that means.

777
01:25:07.372 --> 01:25:19.068
<v Mitch Green>And they say specifically, an increase in system capacity may be established if a capital improvement increases the level of performance or service provided by an existing facility or provides new facilities.

778
01:25:19.163 --> 01:25:19.710
<v Mitch Green>And so Yes.

779
01:25:19.934 --> 01:25:37.725
<v Mitch Green>So colleagues, I just want to say that if you're looking at a facility that is near failure and a roof is about to fail or, you know, an HVAC system is about to fail or you've got tennis courts that are so buckled that you cannot play tennis anymore, that is no longer routine maintenance.

780
01:25:37.998 --> 01:25:40.082
<v Mitch Green>That is something qualitatively different.

781
01:25:40.643 --> 01:25:56.190
<v Mitch Green>And so I think from the standpoint of, you know, recognizing that yes, we do need to build some new assets for part of the city, Or kind of, I think the council president had articulated a vision for regional parks assets.

782
01:25:56.238 --> 01:25:58.761
<v Mitch Green>I, you know, things like the North Portland Aquatic Center.

783
01:25:59.257 --> 01:26:02.711
<v Mitch Green>Those are meaningful and reasonable new investments.

784
01:26:03.368 --> 01:26:14.626
<v Mitch Green>I want the resolution to sort of put in writing that we recognize that we have some internal work to do inside the city to clarify our policies, to revisit our internal assumptions about what's in and what's out of the parks system.

785
01:26:14.673 --> 01:26:15.106
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Dan Ryan.

786
01:26:16.342 --> 01:26:18.226
<v Mitch Green>Of classifications for system development charges.

787
01:26:18.292 --> 01:26:46.770
<v Mitch Green>Because if we can use a good share of the existing pot of money for SDCs to tackle some of these very important capital maintenance programs that are not routine, that are of a nature that is going to threaten the viability of the capacity of the existing system, then I think it's a strong signal to voters that— Councilor That this council is willing to take very seriously the fiscal stewardship lens.

788
01:26:47.399 --> 01:27:00.123
<v Mitch Green>It doesn't go as far as I think some would, you know, it's not perfect and I would love to refer a levy that was much higher, but I'm more interested in a levy passing than what I think is necessary for the maintenance backlog.

789
01:27:00.172 --> 01:27:08.011
<v Mitch Green>So colleagues, I would move that we adopt my amendment that's, let's see here, let me stop rambling and get to the point here.

790
01:27:08.610 --> 01:27:10.167
<v Mitch Green>All right, so there's a whereas clause Yes.

791
01:27:10.231 --> 01:27:32.252
<v Mitch Green>I have a motion that speaks to the backlog, and it says, whereas City Council recognizes the parks and recreation system has an extensive backlog of major maintenance needs and the 2025 parks levy will begin to address these needs but will only be able to make— only be able to address a small fraction of these needs, the council will continue to work with PP&R and community on a long-range financial plan.

792
01:27:32.765 --> 01:27:39.862
<v Mitch Green>We'll explore options for a major maintenance bond measure And will direct the Office of Government Relations to work in the legislature.

793
01:27:39.926 --> 01:27:40.905
<v Mitch Green>And here's where my change is.

794
01:27:40.970 --> 01:27:53.591
<v Mitch Green>I say strike authorize in the underlying resolution and replace it with clarify authority for, because I believe we already have the authority to use SDCs to invest in capacity preservation of our assets.

795
01:27:53.734 --> 01:28:08.631
<v Mitch Green>And then I add a new clause that says, and will pursue as appropriate policy changes in the City of Portland that clarify and prioritize The use of system development charges for extension of useful life or restoration of existing capital assets.

796
01:28:08.726 --> 01:28:09.930
<v Mitch Green>So that's the whereas piece.

797
01:28:10.027 --> 01:28:28.353
<v Mitch Green>And then it's just mirrored later on in a second to last be it further resolved where I add a clause on that that says, and where appropriate, system development charge use will continue to include major maintenance projects, which the major maintenance piece may change and adjust pursuant to Councilor Novick's previous comments.

798
01:28:28.400 --> 01:28:28.545
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

799
01:28:29.367 --> 01:28:35.515
<v Mitch Green>That extend the useful life or restores the capacity value of existing parks capital assets.

800
01:28:35.564 --> 01:28:48.047
<v Mitch Green>And colleagues, before I yield, I just would like to mention that I had previously contemplated putting language that said prioritize SDCs for existing kind of preservation.

801
01:28:48.113 --> 01:28:53.641
<v Mitch Green>And I want to recognize that that might run afoul of some of our equity commitments and some of our—.

802
01:28:53.707 --> 01:28:53.948
<v Mary Ruble>Yes.

803
01:28:54.680 --> 01:28:57.025
<v Mitch Green>You know, uh, I, I, I don't want to put prioritizing there.

804
01:28:57.105 --> 01:29:00.551
<v Mitch Green>I just want to say let's just continue to use this practice and codify it a little bit.

805
01:29:00.599 --> 01:29:05.318
<v Mitch Green>So, um, that's what I'd like to add, colleagues, and, um, would love to, to hear a second.

806
01:29:06.157 --> 01:29:06.519
<v Brian Sotomayor>Second.

807
01:29:06.634 --> 01:29:07.110
<v Candace Avalos>Second.

808
01:29:10.395 --> 01:29:13.405
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we have a motion and a second.

809
01:29:13.453 --> 01:29:17.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe Councilor Dunphy, was that you first?

810
01:29:17.655 --> 01:29:23.960
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think 4 of us might have said it at the same time on the table, and clearly a fair amount of support here.

811
01:29:24.091 --> 01:29:25.546
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any discussion?

812
01:29:29.292 --> 01:29:33.185
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing none, Councilor Novick.

813
01:29:33.655 --> 01:29:34.775
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, go right ahead.

814
01:29:35.521 --> 01:29:47.555
<v Steve Novick>Um, I just want to raise— I, I'm, I'm a little worried about confusion because I think that there's a general impression that you can't use SDCs for maintenance, even if in fact we have used them to some, some extent.

815
01:29:47.637 --> 01:30:03.845
<v Steve Novick>And we're talking about going to the legislature, but we're also saying we're going to So I just want to know, Councilor Green, how do you think that we should manage any confusion that arises from adding this to the conversation?

816
01:30:05.408 --> 01:30:06.324
<v Mitch Green>I think it's a great question.

817
01:30:06.373 --> 01:30:14.372
<v Mitch Green>I think part of why— I mean, I think we tackle that by updating our codes and our policies that specify how we use them.

818
01:30:14.500 --> 01:30:24.612
<v Mitch Green>And we need to, as we consider Councilor Clark's asset management lens going forward, We need to incorporate maybe some of the KPI discussion that Councilor Ryan wants to contemplate.

819
01:30:24.948 --> 01:30:35.104
<v Mitch Green>We need to provide a qualitative distinction on what we mean between capacity preserving and increasing and how this fits in the capital improvement plan lens.

820
01:30:36.323 --> 01:30:57.864
<v Mitch Green>And so it may be the case that the legislature doesn't need to do anything, but I still think we got ourselves into this mess because the language in ORS 223 would benefit from some— just like maybe an example of, of how, of how, um, an investment might be a capital improvement by just fixing up an existing thing.

821
01:30:58.786 --> 01:31:05.917
<v Steve Novick>And this is always a hard question to ask without also asking for privileged information, but have you run this by the City Attorney's Office?

822
01:31:06.610 --> 01:31:09.545
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, my staff has had conversations with the, uh, City Attorney.

823
01:31:09.689 --> 01:31:15.505
<v Mitch Green>I, I forget the gentleman's I don't know the gentleman's last name, but he does not support this interpretation.

824
01:31:16.018 --> 01:31:19.338
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, I'm not convinced.

825
01:31:20.189 --> 01:31:32.844
<v Mitch Green>I can read the law here, and I do have a background in cost accounting, and I think it's fairly straightforward to say, look, you can capitalize a project, you can capitalize a roof if it threatens the viability of an existing asset.

826
01:31:32.891 --> 01:31:37.783
<v Mitch Green>So the resolution just asks us to do some internal work on our policy work.

827
01:31:37.832 --> 01:31:38.601
<v Mitch Green>So there's still an opportunity.

828
01:31:38.682 --> 01:31:45.064
<v Mitch Green>Councilmember for us to discuss what that policy change in relation to the City Attorney and have a broader discussion.

829
01:31:46.073 --> 01:31:51.046
<v Mitch Green>So I am comfortable with that tension with the City Attorney's Office.

830
01:31:51.225 --> 01:31:52.435
<v Mitch Green>I recognize others may not be.

831
01:31:55.014 --> 01:32:04.635
<v Steve Novick>I think that a little— Phil, probably okay with pursue as appropriate policy changes in the City of Portland to clarify.

832
01:32:04.748 --> 01:32:06.198
<v Steve Novick>And you said you're removing the word prioritize.

833
01:32:06.527 --> 01:32:07.126
<v Steve Novick>Which is what it had.

834
01:32:08.063 --> 01:32:10.051
<v Steve Novick>The use of SDCs for extension of useful life.

835
01:32:11.250 --> 01:32:16.496
<v Steve Novick>So maybe as appropriate is like enough of a savings word that I'm not as worried about it.

836
01:32:16.560 --> 01:32:33.662
<v Steve Novick>But then where you say in the subsequent amendment, where appropriate, systems development charge use will continue to include major maintenance projects that extend the useful life or restores the capacity value.

837
01:32:34.936 --> 01:32:46.345
<v Steve Novick>I know you're saying that there are examples that we have done that, but I think that I just feel more comfortable saying include rather than continue to include.

838
01:32:47.087 --> 01:32:52.903
<v Mitch Green>May I offer a potential compromise here that I think gets to your concern?

839
01:32:52.984 --> 01:33:00.662
<v Mitch Green>Maybe if we strike major maintenance projects, which I already don't think belongs there, what if we just replace that with capacity improvement projects?

840
01:33:00.711 --> 01:33:04.206
<v Mitch Green>Because those are the ones that can go into our capital improvement plan, and those are the ones that are already in our 2016 SDC plan.

841
01:33:06.783 --> 01:33:07.761
<v Mitch Green>So where—.

842
01:33:07.890 --> 01:33:12.203
<v Steve Novick>Let's see, actually, I'm not sure I'm looking at the same thing.

843
01:33:12.555 --> 01:33:22.787
<v Steve Novick>What I've got looking at now says, where appropriate, SDC use will continue to include major maintenance projects that extend the useful life or restore the capacity value of existing.

844
01:33:22.835 --> 01:33:23.556
<v Steve Novick>So how would it read?

845
01:33:23.621 --> 01:33:31.975
<v Mitch Green>I would say instead of include major maintenance projects, it would say include capacity-improving projects that extend the useful life.

846
01:33:32.024 --> 01:33:32.505
<v Mitch Green>That's very different.

847
01:33:32.569 --> 01:33:39.949
<v Mitch Green>It's very closely connected to the 223 language in ORS, and it's also how it is described in our own SDC capital improvement plan.

848
01:33:40.127 --> 01:33:40.302
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

849
01:33:40.784 --> 01:33:41.122
<v Candace Avalos>Is that okay?

850
01:33:41.409 --> 01:33:41.971
<v Steve Novick>Yes, thank you.

851
01:33:42.550 --> 01:33:42.983
<v Brian Owendoff>Do we have that?

852
01:33:43.511 --> 01:33:44.667
<v Mitch Green>Are we following that friendly amendment?

853
01:33:44.716 --> 01:33:44.956
<v Mitch Green>Can I—.

854
01:33:44.956 --> 01:33:46.592
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you say that one more time?

855
01:33:46.962 --> 01:34:09.929
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, so in a green amendment number 1, what I'm, what I'm getting from Councilor Novick is to replace in the penultimate be it further resolved in the last clause, replace major maintenance projects, Councilor Dunphy is the seconder.

856
01:34:09.993 --> 01:34:10.996
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are you okay with that change?

857
01:34:11.765 --> 01:34:12.010
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

858
01:34:12.725 --> 01:34:15.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, do you have that or do you need us to send it in writing?

859
01:34:17.561 --> 01:34:17.690
<v Ashley Murray>Yeah.

860
01:34:18.271 --> 01:34:18.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You have it?

861
01:34:18.837 --> 01:34:19.014
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great.

862
01:34:19.981 --> 01:34:25.822
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, colleagues, we have a slightly tweaked amendment before us now.

863
01:34:25.951 --> 01:34:27.113
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, go right ahead.

864
01:34:27.229 --> 01:34:28.690
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, to the amendment.

865
01:34:28.850 --> 01:34:31.243
<v Dan Ryan>And I want to say thank you to Councilor Green.

866
01:34:31.756 --> 01:34:36.092
<v Dan Ryan>I had a 2-year experience where I was pursuing and all I heard was no.

867
01:34:36.478 --> 01:34:40.315
<v Dan Ryan>So the legal said no, and then it was never a legislative priority.

868
01:34:40.813 --> 01:34:44.442
<v Dan Ryan>And so I think we need to do this action to get to the bottom of this.

869
01:34:44.587 --> 01:34:49.756
<v Dan Ryan>And I think the language changes that you and Councilor Novick ironed out were, were superb.

870
01:34:49.820 --> 01:34:50.126
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

871
01:34:51.009 --> 01:34:54.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Thank you, Councilor.

872
01:34:56.840 --> 01:34:59.453
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there any other discussion to the amendment?

873
01:35:00.484 --> 01:35:12.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'll note this is our first council meeting since the break, and I did say that after the break I was going to hold us to the policy and Robert's Rules of Order to not speak at length with our votes.

874
01:35:12.641 --> 01:35:17.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if folks have comments on this vote, now is the time to make those.

875
01:35:17.792 --> 01:35:18.092
<v Bob Weinstein>Thank you, Mayor.

876
01:35:21.537 --> 01:35:24.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing no one else in the queue, Rebecca, can you please call the roll?

877
01:35:27.256 --> 01:35:27.305
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

878
01:35:29.524 --> 01:35:29.573
<v Rob Martineau>Aye.

879
01:35:31.307 --> 01:35:31.356
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

880
01:35:34.289 --> 01:35:34.305
<v Rob Martineau>Aye.

881
01:35:35.867 --> 01:35:36.046
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

882
01:35:45.887 --> 01:35:45.936
<v Micah Meskel>Aye.

883
01:35:46.863 --> 01:35:46.912
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

884
01:35:48.813 --> 01:35:51.201
<v Rebecca Dobert>11 Ayes.

885
01:35:51.265 --> 01:35:52.176
<v Rebecca Dobert>The amendment is approved.

886
01:35:53.159 --> 01:35:53.802
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

887
01:35:54.703 --> 01:36:05.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, are there other— is there other discussion to the now amended resolution, or are there any other amendments to bring forward?

888
01:36:07.712 --> 01:36:08.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

889
01:36:09.716 --> 01:36:10.994
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

890
01:36:11.286 --> 01:36:14.179
<v Dan Ryan>As mentioned earlier, here's the language for the amendment.

891
01:36:14.275 --> 01:36:18.069
<v Dan Ryan>My chief of staff did send that to everybody over the last half hour, hour.

892
01:36:19.082 --> 01:36:20.032
<v Dan Ryan>It reads as follows.

893
01:36:20.466 --> 01:36:32.649
<v Dan Ryan>Whereas, on or before December 31st, 2025, PP&R leadership in collaboration with stakeholders will submit 10 key performance indicators, KPI, for City Council's approval.

894
01:36:33.037 --> 01:36:37.002
<v Dan Ryan>These KPIs will form the Parks Levy Performance Dashboard.

895
01:36:37.051 --> 01:36:37.164
<v Jim Shulen>Second.

896
01:36:39.729 --> 01:36:40.985
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, is there a second?

897
01:36:41.275 --> 01:36:41.582
<v Mitch Green>Second.

898
01:36:43.224 --> 01:36:43.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any discussion?

899
01:36:46.751 --> 01:36:47.363
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

900
01:36:48.233 --> 01:36:49.394
<v Sameer Kanal>I just had a question.

901
01:36:49.733 --> 01:36:54.164
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, can you speak to the, the choice of the date, December 31st?

902
01:36:55.506 --> 01:37:00.358
<v Dan Ryan>I didn't want to rush it, um, and have it, um, be pursued, uh, obviously today.

903
01:37:00.746 --> 01:37:01.618
<v Dan Ryan>That would not work.

904
01:37:01.974 --> 01:37:16.318
<v Dan Ryan>I thought it was necessary that we include many of the stakeholders that we've been all talking to the last And I do think that the Arts and Economy Committee, which is the rec side, I think would like to provide a space for that to take place.

905
01:37:16.926 --> 01:37:24.578
<v Dan Ryan>And I did December 31st because in a quick conversation with the current director, it seemed like it was fair.

906
01:37:25.091 --> 01:37:26.502
<v Dan Ryan>I'm sure it will come prior to that.

907
01:37:26.614 --> 01:37:28.876
<v Dan Ryan>That's why we used language that it needed to land before that.

908
01:37:30.015 --> 01:37:31.154
<v Dan Ryan>So what are you thinking?

909
01:37:31.682 --> 01:37:35.099
<v Sameer Kanal>Just to clarify, so then the intent is that they would start working on it before the election?

910
01:37:35.292 --> 01:37:36.333
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, absolutely.

911
01:37:36.559 --> 01:37:37.233
<v Sameer Kanal>Just making sure.

912
01:37:37.296 --> 01:37:40.746
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to understand that we're not asking for like a month and 3 weeks.

913
01:37:40.985 --> 01:37:50.738
<v Dan Ryan>I just didn't want the experience that we had with the last levy where there was so much confusion and what was the intent, how did it make the world better.

914
01:37:51.636 --> 01:37:59.770
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that that wasn't fair at times, but we didn't have anything clear and visible that was transparent to the public that what success looked like.

915
01:38:00.091 --> 01:38:05.900
<v Dan Ryan>So with this one, since we want to improve operations, And improve in addition to the ones I mentioned.

916
01:38:06.173 --> 01:38:07.265
<v Dan Ryan>That's why we have up to 10.

917
01:38:07.698 --> 01:38:11.296
<v Dan Ryan>And we want them to be digestible so that they're easier for people to understand.

918
01:38:11.970 --> 01:38:15.100
<v Dan Ryan>It's not going to be an insider's indicator.

919
01:38:15.164 --> 01:38:17.412
<v Dan Ryan>It's one that the public could definitely understand.

920
01:38:17.895 --> 01:38:18.216
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

921
01:38:18.618 --> 01:38:24.574
<v Sameer Kanal>And you answered my second question, which is sort of in passing, which is would this include indicators about recreation?

922
01:38:24.639 --> 01:38:27.095
<v Sameer Kanal>So I am good and I'm comfortable supporting this.

923
01:38:27.529 --> 01:38:27.833
<v Micah Meskel>Thank you.

924
01:38:29.695 --> 01:38:30.546
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

925
01:38:31.462 --> 01:38:33.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, I have a question.

926
01:38:34.189 --> 01:38:39.326
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I'm wondering about the statement that there would be 10 KPIs.

927
01:38:39.390 --> 01:38:44.751
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm wondering if you have specific KPIs in mind or why you chose the number 10.

928
01:38:45.649 --> 01:39:02.820
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm just concerned that if we get feedback back that we need an additional or that we don't need that many, are we holding ourselves to something where we then are trying to split things and we don't actually have the performance measurements that we want.

929
01:39:02.885 --> 01:39:06.064
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have the ones that we need to, to make sure it's exactly 10.

930
01:39:08.371 --> 01:39:09.259
<v Dan Ryan>How did I come up with 10?

931
01:39:10.157 --> 01:39:17.564
<v Dan Ryan>So I came up with 10 because in my life experience in doing work like this, continuous improvement work, 10 is a good number.

932
01:39:18.119 --> 01:39:24.493
<v Dan Ryan>Many times organizations will let List hundreds, and that doesn't really track as well.

933
01:39:24.622 --> 01:39:27.765
<v Dan Ryan>And people also get lost in it, and you lose the accountability.

934
01:39:28.319 --> 01:39:35.228
<v Dan Ryan>So I thought we should lift the key ones that we keep hearing over and over again from partners, and all of you will be included in that dialogue.

935
01:39:35.652 --> 01:39:40.127
<v Dan Ryan>And so it's giving us some discipline to make it so it's manageable.

936
01:39:42.820 --> 01:39:46.485
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope we don't feel hemmed in by that number later.

937
01:39:51.122 --> 01:39:52.440
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, are you in the queue?

938
01:39:53.869 --> 01:40:11.621
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I just wanted to say that the reason why I seconded this, uh, Councilor, um, Ryan and I, when we sat down to chart out what our committee would look like and what it would focus on, um, KPIs was at the forefront and kind of a data-driven approach was at the forefront of how we manage our portfolio, and recreation is a big part of that portfolio.

939
01:40:12.247 --> 01:40:20.739
<v Mitch Green>Um, you want the KPIs to be driven by a need And we have this opportunity— we have a new levy, we have some new leadership in the Parks Bureau.

940
01:40:21.476 --> 01:40:24.554
<v Mitch Green>We're hearing calls for increased accountability and transparency.

941
01:40:24.601 --> 01:40:26.824
<v Mitch Green>And so I think this is just a great way to slot that in.

942
01:40:26.889 --> 01:40:30.207
<v Mitch Green>So I just wanted to articulate why I think it's a good idea to add this in.

943
01:40:31.728 --> 01:40:32.373
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

944
01:40:32.439 --> 01:40:33.247
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

945
01:40:35.833 --> 01:40:41.215
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Ryan, since you and I are of a certain age and share cultural references, are you sure you wouldn't want to go to 11?

946
01:40:45.875 --> 01:40:52.315
<v Dan Ryan>I'm, I'm open to a number change on that, and, uh, it was— so I am open to the number.

947
01:40:52.364 --> 01:40:54.307
<v Steve Novick>Would you accept a friendly amendment to it?

948
01:40:54.613 --> 01:40:56.990
<v Dan Ryan>I really am trying to discipline us.

949
01:40:57.103 --> 01:41:02.179
<v Dan Ryan>I won't use the word hem, and so, um, hem us in, but I do think it's important that we, um, are disciplined.

950
01:41:02.420 --> 01:41:05.342
<v Dan Ryan>I'm fine with a friendly amendment of 11.

951
01:41:05.777 --> 01:41:10.859
<v Dan Ryan>And I also, when we listed testimony, colleagues, it was really clear that people want that vision.

952
01:41:11.467 --> 01:41:21.371
<v Dan Ryan>In my experience, what you measure matters, and what you put out visually does provide that transparency, and it further provides an opportunity to track that vision.

953
01:41:21.804 --> 01:41:23.951
<v Dan Ryan>Are you getting the results from what you're putting out there?

954
01:41:24.304 --> 01:41:39.618
<v Dan Ryan>So we've been operating on a lot of vision at times, or maybe ideas, and it's really important that we have an operations plan that has strategic clarity And so when you can measure it and everyone can see it and they're all seeing the same thing, that dashboard is visible to the entire community.

955
01:41:39.975 --> 01:41:42.336
<v Dan Ryan>They know where we are and they know where we want to go.

956
01:41:48.635 --> 01:41:53.541
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just want to pause, actually.

957
01:41:53.654 --> 01:41:58.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not sure if there was an actual proposal for an amendment to 11 or if that was just a joke.

958
01:41:58.703 --> 01:42:00.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm moving on to Councilor Murillo.

959
01:42:02.908 --> 01:42:07.555
<v Angelita Morillo>I didn't understand the reference, so, um, sorry.

960
01:42:07.750 --> 01:42:08.203
<v Angelita Morillo>It's true.

961
01:42:09.029 --> 01:42:23.055
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I feel like I had the same question as Council President Pirtle-Guiney, um, around the number of 10 key performance indicators, and I know that you answered it, but I'm not quite sure I understood specifically what we're looking for.

962
01:42:23.976 --> 01:42:27.613
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, so, uh, could we specify that?

963
01:42:27.677 --> 01:42:27.774
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

964
01:42:28.188 --> 01:42:35.387
<v Angelita Morillo>Or maybe just remove the 10 so we're not bound by it if we— if there aren't 10, or—.

965
01:42:35.387 --> 01:42:40.615
<v Dan Ryan>The friendly amendment that you're offering is to just not have a number, and that I hear that.

966
01:42:41.180 --> 01:42:43.583
<v Angelita Morillo>Or to hear specifics from you about what it would be covering.

967
01:42:45.145 --> 01:42:46.274
<v Dan Ryan>We have to work that out.

968
01:42:46.418 --> 01:42:48.835
<v Dan Ryan>I didn't want to tell you what the 10 were today.

969
01:42:49.011 --> 01:42:53.293
<v Dan Ryan>I think that it's really clear what some of them are from based on dialogue of late.

970
01:42:53.728 --> 01:43:01.345
<v Dan Ryan>But I'd rather take a pause and all of us come together with parks leadership and the stakeholders to identify what they are.

971
01:43:01.957 --> 01:43:05.231
<v Dan Ryan>If we did that today, this meeting would last really long.

972
01:43:06.248 --> 01:43:10.703
<v Angelita Morillo>So what if it just says we will submit key performance indicators without the 10?

973
01:43:16.613 --> 01:43:18.596
<v Dan Ryan>I can, I can accept that from the amendment.

974
01:43:18.807 --> 01:43:18.921
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

975
01:43:19.051 --> 01:43:19.863
<v Dan Ryan>Because we're going to do them.

976
01:43:20.850 --> 01:43:22.404
<v Angelita Morillo>Then I propose the friendly amendment.

977
01:43:22.614 --> 01:43:23.521
<v Dan Ryan>All right, I accept.

978
01:43:23.603 --> 01:43:25.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green, do you accept that?

979
01:43:25.385 --> 01:43:26.600
<v Mitch Green>I accept as the second.

980
01:43:27.313 --> 01:43:35.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so this would say, in collaboration with stakeholders, will submit key performance indicators for City Council approval.

981
01:43:36.292 --> 01:43:36.568
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

982
01:43:37.376 --> 01:43:39.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor Novick, are you back in the queue?

983
01:43:41.140 --> 01:43:43.806
<v Steve Novick>Yes, well, just for my own amendment, so I'll discuss this one.

984
01:43:44.225 --> 01:43:44.387
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

985
01:43:45.581 --> 01:43:48.484
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any other discussion on the amendment before us?

986
01:43:49.340 --> 01:43:49.547
<v Sonya Szymanski>Yes.

987
01:43:49.917 --> 01:43:50.256
<v Elizabeth Milner>Okay.

988
01:43:50.881 --> 01:43:58.949
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is now a slightly amended form of the amendment to say will submit key performance indicators without a number there.

989
01:43:59.962 --> 01:44:10.063
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Ryan, before we vote on this, could you let our clerk's team know where in the resolution you would like this whereas clause to be located?

990
01:44:12.186 --> 01:44:14.826
<v Dan Ryan>We placed it on page 2 and now it's on page 3.

991
01:44:14.975 --> 01:44:16.716
<v Dan Ryan>It's the 3rd from the bottom.

992
01:44:17.431 --> 01:44:20.328
<v Dan Ryan>So it's after the one that talks about the annual reports.

993
01:44:21.452 --> 01:44:21.515
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

994
01:44:21.645 --> 01:44:29.552
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So in between whereas PPR will produce annual reports on how levy funds are being spent and whereas a community member oversight committee will review?

995
01:44:29.817 --> 01:44:30.180
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

996
01:44:30.412 --> 01:44:30.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

997
01:44:33.579 --> 01:44:34.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, do you see that?

998
01:44:37.094 --> 01:44:40.395
<v Dan Ryan>It was in the email that was mailed out about an hour ago.

999
01:44:41.524 --> 01:44:42.047
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

1000
01:44:42.913 --> 01:44:43.976
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1001
01:44:44.386 --> 01:44:45.774
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, can you please call the roll?

1002
01:44:48.949 --> 01:44:49.432
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyamalene?

1003
01:44:55.091 --> 01:44:55.140
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1004
01:44:56.930 --> 01:44:57.414
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

1005
01:44:57.836 --> 01:44:57.997
<v Elizabeth Milner>Aye.

1006
01:44:58.661 --> 01:44:59.081
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

1007
01:44:59.292 --> 01:44:59.340
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1008
01:45:00.117 --> 01:45:00.408
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

1009
01:45:00.828 --> 01:45:00.877
<v Micah Meskel>Aye.

1010
01:45:01.556 --> 01:45:02.025
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1011
01:45:02.931 --> 01:45:03.094
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>Aye.

1012
01:45:04.064 --> 01:45:04.372
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

1013
01:45:05.439 --> 01:45:05.488
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1014
01:45:09.543 --> 01:45:09.560
<v Ali Berman>Aye.

1015
01:45:10.735 --> 01:45:10.912
<v Ashley Murray>Aye.

1016
01:45:11.541 --> 01:45:11.588
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1017
01:45:12.909 --> 01:45:12.957
<v Elizabeth Milner>Aye.

1018
01:45:14.037 --> 01:45:15.631
<v Rebecca Dobert>11 Ayes.

1019
01:45:15.680 --> 01:45:16.711
<v Rebecca Dobert>The amendment is approved.

1020
01:45:17.744 --> 01:45:23.561
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan won.

1021
01:45:24.140 --> 01:45:24.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

1022
01:45:26.470 --> 01:45:27.461
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam President.

1023
01:45:27.755 --> 01:45:37.569
<v Steve Novick>Um, there's a whole bunch of really tiny things here, and I'm going to I'm going to mix in the slightly more substantive proposals from the Parks Alliance with the simple word changes.

1024
01:45:37.632 --> 01:45:40.359
<v Steve Novick>If anybody wants me to divide those up, then I'd be happy to do that.

1025
01:45:41.417 --> 01:45:55.252
<v Steve Novick>So the first word change is, whereas the proposed 140 levy would include 137 for Park and Recreation options and 03 for— now it says capital projects, add the words maintenance, capital maintenance projects.

1026
01:45:55.364 --> 01:45:55.445
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1027
01:45:55.911 --> 01:46:01.201
<v Steve Novick>Then 2 whereases below, the 03 rate for capital projects, again, make it capital maintenance projects.

1028
01:46:01.970 --> 01:46:02.293
<v Rob Martineau>Yes.

1029
01:46:02.488 --> 01:46:08.421
<v Steve Novick>Then, let's see, this is a more substantive addition to the whereas.

1030
01:46:09.587 --> 01:46:27.703
<v Steve Novick>After the whereas that says PP&R will produce annual reports about how levy funds are being spent, including performance metrics, etc., the addition would be, whereas PP&R shall, as part of the annual budget process, describe to council the approximate percentage of its operations and number of FTE which will be funded by levy resources.

1031
01:46:28.438 --> 01:46:40.699
<v Steve Novick>And then below the current whereas that says, whereas City Council recognizes the Parks and Rec system has an extensive backlog of major maintenance needs.

1032
01:46:40.764 --> 01:46:49.587
<v Steve Novick>So first of all, I'm proposing change major maintenance needs in that paragraph to capital maintenance needs, extensive backlog for capital maintenance needs.

1033
01:46:50.431 --> 01:47:02.082
<v Steve Novick>But then follow that paragraph with the language suggested by The Parks Alliance, whereas City Council will adopt this long-range financial plan by the end of fiscal year 2027-28.

1034
01:47:04.097 --> 01:47:15.368
<v Steve Novick>And then let's see, there's a whereas which reads, whereas if approved, the 2025 Parks Levy would raise an estimated $2 million in the first year to support capital projects.

1035
01:47:15.448 --> 01:47:18.358
<v Steve Novick>Again, add the word maintenance, capital maintenance projects.

1036
01:47:20.434 --> 01:47:28.930
<v Steve Novick>In the now therefore be it resolved, also change the 0.03 of the rate will be for capital projects, capital maintenance projects.

1037
01:47:29.979 --> 01:47:40.149
<v Steve Novick>And then subsequent be it resolved that the 0.03 for capital projects is intended to be distributed between the 4 council districts.

1038
01:47:40.247 --> 01:47:43.405
<v Steve Novick>Again, add the word maintenance between capital and projects.

1039
01:47:44.280 --> 01:47:54.701
<v Steve Novick>And then in the same further resolved, Instead of capital project decisions from levy funds will be included capital maintenance projects, and then along with other capital maintenance projects.

1040
01:47:55.412 --> 01:48:01.524
<v Steve Novick>So that would be the extent of these numerous but small amendments.

1041
01:48:02.182 --> 01:48:09.305
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I believe what you're doing is adding capital to any time where we talk about maintenance projects.

1042
01:48:09.725 --> 01:48:11.054
<v Steve Novick>Actually, maintenance where we talk about capital.

1043
01:48:11.118 --> 01:48:12.511
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Maintenance where we talk about capital.

1044
01:48:12.559 --> 01:48:13.045
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

1045
01:48:14.189 --> 01:48:23.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Adding language about long-range financial plan development and adding language about reporting on the percentage of the budget, the parks budget funded by the levy.

1046
01:48:24.141 --> 01:48:24.335
<v Micah Meskel>Right.

1047
01:48:24.382 --> 01:48:25.731
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are those the 3 categories?

1048
01:48:25.923 --> 01:48:26.180
<v Candace Avalos>Right.

1049
01:48:26.229 --> 01:48:29.087
<v Steve Novick>And in one place, replacing the word major with the word capital.

1050
01:48:29.921 --> 01:48:30.418
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

1051
01:48:31.381 --> 01:48:32.136
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a second?

1052
01:48:32.762 --> 01:48:33.389
<v Steve Novick>Second.

1053
01:48:33.550 --> 01:48:34.432
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1054
01:48:34.592 --> 01:48:37.210
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe Councilor Kanal beat you to it, Councilor Ryan.

1055
01:48:38.109 --> 01:48:40.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any discussion on this amendment?

1056
01:48:41.716 --> 01:48:46.792
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, colleagues, seeing none, Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

1057
01:48:50.500 --> 01:48:50.823
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

1058
01:48:51.243 --> 01:48:51.404
<v Sue Ann Ho>Aye.

1059
01:48:52.148 --> 01:48:52.681
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo?

1060
01:48:53.264 --> 01:48:53.311
<v Sonya Szymanski>Aye.

1061
01:48:54.168 --> 01:48:54.654
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

1062
01:48:54.880 --> 01:48:54.929
<v Jessica Green>Aye.

1063
01:48:55.688 --> 01:48:55.996
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

1064
01:48:56.658 --> 01:48:56.738
<v Karen Chi Ray>Aye.

1065
01:48:57.256 --> 01:48:57.774
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1066
01:48:58.679 --> 01:48:58.728
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1067
01:48:59.666 --> 01:49:00.037
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

1068
01:49:00.944 --> 01:49:00.975
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1069
01:49:01.913 --> 01:49:02.270
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1070
01:49:02.966 --> 01:49:03.095
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1071
01:49:03.710 --> 01:49:04.082
<v Priya Dhanapal>Smith?

1072
01:49:05.229 --> 01:49:05.408
<v Ashley Murray>Aye.

1073
01:49:07.206 --> 01:49:07.253
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1074
01:49:07.930 --> 01:49:07.979
<v Micah Meskel>Aye.

1075
01:49:08.413 --> 01:49:08.462
<v Sonya Szymanski>Aye.

1076
01:49:09.154 --> 01:49:12.827
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the amendment is approved with 11 ayes.

1077
01:49:16.079 --> 01:49:16.354
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1078
01:49:16.581 --> 01:49:17.583
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1079
01:49:18.764 --> 01:49:19.719
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1080
01:49:20.057 --> 01:49:26.988
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to take the opportunity to formally propose the amendment that I handed out and have emailed in as Kanal 1.

1081
01:49:27.907 --> 01:49:50.171
<v Sameer Kanal>This would create a new whereas clause that I have placed Between the whereas on community and art centers and then free and discount options for recreational programming above, and then below the— sorry, those would be the ones above it, and then it would be directly above the strengthening partnerships ones about midway through page 2.

1082
01:49:50.738 --> 01:49:58.140
<v Sameer Kanal>Whereas a new levy would allow for $139,169 per year, $0.00232 Aye.

1083
01:49:58.140 --> 01:49:58.140
<v Steve Novick>Motion passes.

1084
01:49:58.140 --> 01:50:17.699
<v Sameer Kanal>Resolution number 4, which would authorize $100,000 of the $137,000 for parks and recreation operations to be dedicated to the extension of hours at 4 community centers, one in each council district, on Fridays and Saturdays from Memorial Day to September 30th each year to 11:00 PM to promote access to free third spaces for all Portlanders, in particular young people, and promote student achievement, community safety, and youth development.

1085
01:50:18.460 --> 01:50:24.119
<v Sameer Kanal>And, um, and just to speak briefly to it, uh, we have talked about Baltimore a lot.

1086
01:50:24.119 --> 01:50:26.119
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's also worth noting 2 other examples.

1087
01:50:26.149 --> 01:50:26.213
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1088
01:50:26.279 --> 01:50:43.820
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there are some examples of situations where the extension of community centers has hours on the evenings where young people in particular don't necessarily have something else to do that they can afford, or something else to do that they can afford that's in their home area.

1089
01:50:45.021 --> 01:50:50.796
<v Sameer Kanal>And so Baltimore extended their hours in the summertime on Fridays and Saturdays to 11:00 PM.

1090
01:50:51.006 --> 01:50:57.025
<v Sameer Kanal>Dallas has also done something quite We're clearly willing to learn from their example.

1091
01:50:57.251 --> 01:51:00.881
<v Sameer Kanal>It's— they call it the Summer of Safety program.

1092
01:51:00.930 --> 01:51:04.899
<v Sameer Kanal>And the other example I would cite is that this was a part of the conversation.

1093
01:51:05.347 --> 01:51:11.662
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to note the conversation, not the programming, around some of the initiatives we've done in the past here in Portland.

1094
01:51:11.710 --> 01:51:18.923
<v Sameer Kanal>A couple years ago, we recognized that gun violence goes up in the summertime, and we worked on a Safer Summer intervention program.

1095
01:51:19.003 --> 01:51:19.164
<v Brian Sotomayor>Thank you.

1096
01:51:20.422 --> 01:51:28.722
<v Sameer Kanal>Programs like that would be supported by having the ability to send young people to a place where they don't have to pay.

1097
01:51:29.448 --> 01:51:31.854
<v Sameer Kanal>And so that's fundamentally what this is about.

1098
01:51:32.194 --> 01:51:33.212
<v Sameer Kanal>We did have it scored.

1099
01:51:33.567 --> 01:51:37.265
<v Sameer Kanal>We're talking about an $84 million levy, and this is $139,000.

1100
01:51:38.449 --> 01:51:41.560
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just want to close with that piece of information.

1101
01:51:42.091 --> 01:51:46.458
<v Sameer Kanal>Actually, I'll also note that the testimony we got from— Councilor Dan Ryan.

1102
01:51:47.057 --> 01:51:50.042
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry, I have forgotten the name.

1103
01:51:50.252 --> 01:51:58.838
<v Sameer Kanal>Miss Murray at Sellwood Community House talking about asking Portlanders to support an increased tax without getting anything new.

1104
01:51:59.640 --> 01:52:01.855
<v Sameer Kanal>This would be something new that would be visible in your community.

1105
01:52:02.047 --> 01:52:09.671
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's a really important thing to deliver to voters is that for a very small amount of money, you'd be able to see a space open that young people could go to.

1106
01:52:09.896 --> 01:52:12.529
<v Sameer Kanal>So that is why I would be proposing this amendment and I would ask for your support.

1107
01:52:12.592 --> 01:52:12.720
<v Micah Meskel>Thank you.

1108
01:52:15.949 --> 01:52:16.469
<v Jessica Green>Second.

1109
01:52:16.712 --> 01:52:17.572
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, councilors.

1110
01:52:17.847 --> 01:52:21.644
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Murillo, are you in the queue to discuss this amendment?

1111
01:52:21.967 --> 01:52:22.372
<v Karen Chi Ray>I am.

1112
01:52:22.454 --> 01:52:23.167
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1113
01:52:24.387 --> 01:52:30.564
<v Angelita Morillo>I am definitely in favor of this in terms of the substance of it and what it could do.

1114
01:52:31.181 --> 01:52:50.423
<v Angelita Morillo>I have some concerns about this amendment and Councilor Zimmerman's amendment with regards to earmarking funds for specific things because I think that Given all of the federal funding issues that are coming down the pike and just everything else going on, that I would like to give parks maximum flexibility in how they're able to allocate those funds.

1115
01:52:50.956 --> 01:53:02.345
<v Angelita Morillo>So I guess I wanted to hear your response and analysis of that, because I am— I completely agree with your analysis on what that could do for public safety and for youth in our communities, but just have some concerns.

1116
01:53:03.600 --> 01:53:03.731
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

1117
01:53:05.628 --> 01:53:06.126
<v Micah Meskel>I hear you.

1118
01:53:07.313 --> 01:53:15.300
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that there are massive concerns around, I think, roughly $100 million a year that we're talking about in the context of grants.

1119
01:53:16.149 --> 01:53:24.231
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't— so the 2 things I would say is, one, I don't think $139,000 is going to make a huge difference either way on that particular concern.

1120
01:53:25.371 --> 01:53:28.626
<v Sameer Kanal>But it is one of the best bang for your buck type of programs we could possibly do.

1121
01:53:28.738 --> 01:53:29.636
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's a great program.

1122
01:53:30.569 --> 01:53:30.974
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1123
01:53:31.150 --> 01:53:36.699
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms— I was aware that it would be a low 6-digit number.

1124
01:53:36.780 --> 01:53:40.398
<v Sameer Kanal>I said that in the committee last Thursday when I floated this for the first time.

1125
01:53:40.447 --> 01:53:41.877
<v Sameer Kanal>I did not know it was going to be this low.

1126
01:53:42.625 --> 01:53:44.542
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's a pleasant surprise.

1127
01:53:46.163 --> 01:53:55.444
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also think that at a time when we are under significant threat from an authoritarian federal government, that one of its tactics is to divide us.

1128
01:53:55.721 --> 01:53:55.818
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes.

1129
01:53:55.945 --> 01:54:12.809
<v Sameer Kanal>Combining this with the idea of volunteerism as a way to help bring communities together in an intergenerational way, often in terms of who's volunteering to provide programs for teenagers and young adults, is actually a way of pushing back against the broader concerns there.

1130
01:54:13.289 --> 01:54:18.344
<v Sameer Kanal>But that's not the original intent, but it is sort of an additional benefit.

1131
01:54:25.354 --> 01:54:27.347
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1132
01:54:27.427 --> 01:54:27.475
<v Sue Ann Ho>I—.

1133
01:54:27.926 --> 01:54:31.510
<v Candace Avalos>And thank you, Councilor Murillo, for asking that question because I was sitting with that tension.

1134
01:54:31.606 --> 01:54:38.699
<v Candace Avalos>But I think where I'm landing is, one, the impact is very, you know, small.

1135
01:54:38.779 --> 01:54:52.135
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that the impact in dollars and in percentage of the levy translates to a huge impact to East Portland where this will greatly affect our ability to create more third spaces.

1136
01:54:52.631 --> 01:54:59.922
<v Candace Avalos>I think, you know, this is our opportunity in this levy, as we're doing in lots of other ways, to signal intent and program.

1137
01:55:00.019 --> 01:55:04.762
<v Candace Avalos>And so I see this as just another one, even though, you know, it has a monetary amount.

1138
01:55:04.810 --> 01:55:08.609
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, just like we're adding the 3 cents for capital maintenance.

1139
01:55:08.657 --> 01:55:14.009
<v Candace Avalos>So I hear you, Councilor Morillo, because I agree in general that I want us to be careful to not be overly prescriptive.

1140
01:55:14.073 --> 01:55:14.233
<v Karen Chi Ray>Thank you.

1141
01:55:15.278 --> 01:55:22.668
<v Candace Avalos>This feels like enough of a— like I can get down with this, and I think the impact is good.

1142
01:55:22.797 --> 01:55:30.015
<v Candace Avalos>And it's also us— totally agree with the assessment of us adding something visible that people will be able to feel.

1143
01:55:30.078 --> 01:55:37.539
<v Candace Avalos>So I plan to support it, but I'm grateful for the discussion that happened just before me because I was sitting with that tension, but I'm definitely landing on supporting it.

1144
01:55:37.978 --> 01:55:39.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Herbold.

1145
01:55:40.453 --> 01:55:41.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1146
01:55:41.481 --> 01:55:42.350
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1147
01:55:43.426 --> 01:55:46.092
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for this work, for your work on this, Councilor.

1148
01:55:47.282 --> 01:55:52.069
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am absolutely interested in the extension of hours at community centers.

1149
01:55:52.326 --> 01:55:54.173
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I would love to see this.

1150
01:55:54.735 --> 01:55:59.780
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am wondering also if the levy is the right place to do this type of earmarking.

1151
01:56:00.375 --> 01:56:11.291
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'm also thinking about how this is very specific and how I know voters appreciate having some specific examples of what they can expect.

1152
01:56:11.451 --> 01:56:17.496
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so I actually can see this possibly being helpful as a campaign will hopefully be ran around this.

1153
01:56:18.185 --> 01:56:20.286
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then I also have another follow-up question.

1154
01:56:20.333 --> 01:56:30.659
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm wondering about this language, a new levy would allow, and then going on, and for that money to be dedicated.

1155
01:56:31.237 --> 01:56:36.880
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was wondering if allow is the right word, or it seems a little squishier.

1156
01:56:36.976 --> 01:56:43.957
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was wondering if there's another word, like the word direct, or can I hear your thinking around that?

1157
01:56:45.027 --> 01:56:45.430
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1158
01:56:47.850 --> 01:56:57.652
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'll first say, yeah, the part about specificity, I think, is— and this is a strange conversation because we're talking about how to build something that can be more politically viable, right?

1159
01:56:57.716 --> 01:56:59.868
<v Sameer Kanal>That's just a strange concept to this entire thing.

1160
01:57:00.386 --> 01:57:03.444
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do think that having specificity will help with that.

1161
01:57:04.284 --> 01:57:08.398
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of the levy, I think next year's budget will take effect on July 1st.

1162
01:57:08.622 --> 01:57:14.695
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a lot of time between the end of the school year and July 1st where you start to see spikes in gun violence happen.

1163
01:57:15.676 --> 01:57:27.036
<v Sameer Kanal>And so we started— when I was at the Community Safety Division, we started the Safer Summer program significantly earlier than that when we could, and sometimes we couldn't because of funding and how it was funded.

1164
01:57:27.324 --> 01:57:29.365
<v Sameer Kanal>So I am thinking about that in terms of this opportunity.

1165
01:57:29.430 --> 01:57:29.591
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1166
01:57:30.153 --> 01:57:33.155
<v Sameer Kanal>So, and I think the 2 things together is the answer to your timing question.

1167
01:57:34.552 --> 01:57:39.176
<v Sameer Kanal>On the 3rd question, I think that's a really good one about the use of the word allow.

1168
01:57:40.108 --> 01:57:48.201
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think this also relates to Councilor Murillo's question of it's signaling council intent, but I don't think the resolution itself can direct it.

1169
01:57:48.313 --> 01:57:54.927
<v Sameer Kanal>And we were advised by, you know, not to amend the exhibits on the dais on the day of.

1170
01:57:54.993 --> 01:57:55.168
<v Bob Weinstein>Thank you.

1171
01:57:56.177 --> 01:57:58.789
<v Sameer Kanal>And through no fault of their own, I want to be clear, I'm not blaming them.

1172
01:57:58.869 --> 01:58:02.337
<v Sameer Kanal>It just took a little time to get the exact scoring figured out.

1173
01:58:02.385 --> 01:58:06.462
<v Sameer Kanal>And so it kind of, it made sense to frame it this way as a direction.

1174
01:58:06.592 --> 01:58:17.056
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll also just take the opportunity to note, you know, we are expecting that for 3 of the districts, we're going to have the conversation about which community center, you know, with the councilors.

1175
01:58:17.104 --> 01:58:19.725
<v Sameer Kanal>And I apologize to my colleagues in District 1.

1176
01:58:20.141 --> 01:58:21.796
<v Sameer Kanal>You only have one community center.

1177
01:58:22.798 --> 01:58:27.719
<v Sameer Kanal>For now, that's a challenge for a later problem to solve.

1178
01:58:28.155 --> 01:58:34.382
<v Sameer Kanal>But for the other 3 districts, I would hope that we're able to have input into that process.

1179
01:58:34.868 --> 01:58:35.176
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1180
01:58:36.387 --> 01:58:36.809
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1181
01:58:37.034 --> 01:58:39.637
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>All of that is helpful, and I am excited to support this.

1182
01:58:46.912 --> 01:58:58.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I I had told you when you first brought this concept up that it was something that I was excited to support in the budget next year because I do think that it is a really important thing for us to do.

1183
01:58:58.570 --> 01:59:06.891
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we've had a lot of conversations about programmed— less time but more programming, or more time even if it means less programming.

1184
01:59:07.405 --> 01:59:09.028
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm really supportive of this concept.

1185
01:59:09.091 --> 01:59:20.628
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm struggling because we costed this levy in order to be able to assure Portlanders that we would maintain all of the investments that we bought back during the budget process.

1186
01:59:20.886 --> 01:59:29.118
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I worry that if we start to say, and also this, and also this, it becomes harder and harder to keep that promise.

1187
01:59:29.262 --> 01:59:35.702
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I don't want to set ourselves up to not be able to keep the promises that we make during this levy.

1188
01:59:37.708 --> 01:59:53.644
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know it's only a small amount of money I am going to take the next minute or two as others talk to think about my vote, but I'm leaning voting no because I worry about being able to keep that promise that we will maintain what we have, that Portlanders won't see cuts.

1189
01:59:54.286 --> 02:00:02.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I did just want to state on the record that, um, if I vote no on this, that does not mean that I wouldn't support it in the budget process.

1190
02:00:02.731 --> 02:00:04.914
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do think it's a really important thing for us to do.

1191
02:00:05.043 --> 02:00:06.152
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Thanks.

1192
02:00:06.247 --> 02:00:11.742
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll just clarify, based in part on our conversations, this does not include programming.

1193
02:00:11.789 --> 02:00:23.788
<v Sameer Kanal>It includes enough staff to keep the space open, but open gyms for gyms that have basketballs, gyms that at least one of which will have dodgeballs soon, you know, those sorts of things will allow for that.

1194
02:00:23.917 --> 02:00:30.582
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think if there is a need for additional programming, there is the concept of volunteerism that we talked about in a lot of places.

1195
02:00:30.663 --> 02:00:32.826
<v Sameer Kanal>And obviously, Obviously the friends of groups and things like that.

1196
02:00:34.989 --> 02:00:44.126
<v Sameer Kanal>To the other point about costing it out, that's where the costing is based, just to clarify that.

1197
02:00:44.770 --> 02:00:45.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1198
02:00:46.140 --> 02:00:46.945
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

1199
02:00:48.154 --> 02:00:53.956
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I share the concern about this being really prescriptive.

1200
02:00:55.095 --> 02:01:04.896
<v Steve Novick>I also worry that I think that the overall message here is that we've got a levy that, in the words of Bon Jovi, holds on to what we've got.

1201
02:01:05.474 --> 02:01:10.668
<v Steve Novick>And I think that polling actually shows that the maintenance message is strong.

1202
02:01:11.327 --> 02:01:18.990
<v Steve Novick>And I'm a little worried if we say all this is about is holding on to what we've got, plus a little bit for capital maintenance, plus this one other thing.

1203
02:01:19.680 --> 02:01:24.137
<v Steve Novick>It kind of implies that we've thought that— we think that only this one other thing is important enough to be worth adding.

1204
02:01:24.186 --> 02:01:24.538
<v Steve Novick>I think that's a fair point.

1205
02:01:25.185 --> 02:01:32.278
<v Steve Novick>And maybe there's a reasonable case for that, but I can sort of see people saying, well, wait a minute, if you're gonna add things, why didn't you add this thing or that thing or the other thing?

1206
02:01:32.819 --> 02:01:40.078
<v Steve Novick>So I'm just worried about having a bit of, I don't feel strongly about this, but I think I'm a no 'cause I think it's sort of a muddled, there's sort of a muddled message.

1207
02:01:40.560 --> 02:01:45.640
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'll just quickly state, because you brought up the Bon Jovi thing, the last reference was a reference to Spinal Tap.

1208
02:01:45.899 --> 02:01:49.516
<v Sameer Kanal>This is Spinal Tap, just to clarify for those who didn't know.

1209
02:01:49.903 --> 02:01:50.256
<v Ali Berman>Yeah.

1210
02:01:53.483 --> 02:01:55.490
<v Sameer Kanal>I guess this is kind of a response to both questions.

1211
02:01:56.213 --> 02:02:01.001
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't apologize for saying public safety is special and deserves prioritization.

1212
02:02:01.595 --> 02:02:09.354
<v Sameer Kanal>I do think it's appropriate to ask why this and not that, and I also think it's an incredibly fair response to say because public safety.

1213
02:02:10.255 --> 02:02:25.470
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, for me, that is a priority that we often view very narrowly, but I think this council has come to the realization that maybe other councils did not, that recreation and community centers are a part of our public safety system.

1214
02:02:25.840 --> 02:02:27.283
<v Sameer Kanal>And so it is special.

1215
02:02:27.667 --> 02:02:31.452
<v Sameer Kanal>I do think it's an exception, and I don't mind— I'm not apologizing for that.

1216
02:02:32.798 --> 02:02:33.505
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan?

1217
02:02:33.761 --> 02:02:34.002
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1218
02:02:34.498 --> 02:02:35.140
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To the amendment?

1219
02:02:35.301 --> 02:02:37.128
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, great conversation on this amendment.

1220
02:02:37.289 --> 02:02:40.769
<v Dan Ryan>I have agreed with a couple of the comments here.

1221
02:02:40.833 --> 02:02:51.896
<v Dan Ryan>First of all, I'm struggling on my vote on this one because I I see the impact, but I also have experience where when there's carve-outs, how rough that is to land it.

1222
02:02:52.559 --> 02:03:04.543
<v Dan Ryan>And I know that we already put in a couple that were negotiated over the last few weeks, the 0.3 for capital maintenance, or— and the other one is the 1 FTE for partnerships.

1223
02:03:05.442 --> 02:03:09.666
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm concerned if we keep adding these, and it was so hard to get to 140.

1224
02:03:09.715 --> 02:03:09.764
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1225
02:03:10.131 --> 02:03:13.744
<v Dan Ryan>And so this would— something would have to probably give.

1226
02:03:14.291 --> 02:03:24.582
<v Dan Ryan>And so I'm probably just out of principle, would want to hear from parks leadership and have more time to see how they would be able to roll this out.

1227
02:03:25.001 --> 02:03:28.163
<v Dan Ryan>I agree that I want this and I would support it in the budget process.

1228
02:03:28.903 --> 02:03:34.859
<v Dan Ryan>Putting it into another earmark carve-out, whatever you want to call it, for this specific item gives me some—.

1229
02:03:34.859 --> 02:03:35.309
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Herbold.

1230
02:03:36.783 --> 02:03:37.280
<v Dan Ryan>Hesitation.

1231
02:03:38.547 --> 02:03:38.787
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1232
02:03:38.868 --> 02:03:44.591
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I just wanted to quickly state, uh, this is kind of to both Councilor Novick and Councilor Ryan.

1233
02:03:44.639 --> 02:03:57.095
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick, in, in the previous amendment, you noted that as appropriate alleviated your concern, and I would, I would say that the, uh, the, the use of the phrase here of would allow should serve that same purpose.

1234
02:03:57.929 --> 02:04:09.927
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think this relates to the conversations that, that my staff had through with CBO and with Parks about, you know, we did staff— the main concern we heard is we don't want necessarily one person to always be there alone.

1235
02:04:10.439 --> 02:04:20.740
<v Sameer Kanal>And so talking about the staffing level, we did adjust and get it rescored based on that to have the ability to have a second staffer there so that the first person isn't staying alone the whole night, you know.

1236
02:04:21.337 --> 02:04:26.139
<v Sameer Kanal>So that we did adjust based off of those sorts of pieces of feedback, and I just wanted to make sure that was clear.

1237
02:04:26.219 --> 02:04:26.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1238
02:04:26.637 --> 02:04:36.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know if that alleviates the full concern, but I think it's Okay, I'm going to try to keep moving us along because we have half an hour left today and at least one more amendment.

1239
02:04:36.770 --> 02:04:37.493
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy.

1240
02:04:38.391 --> 02:04:49.984
<v Jamie Dunphy>To the amendment, I just want to note, and I'll be a bit of a broken record because I have said this multiple times on here, but I started my career working in a middle school in East Portland in the David Douglas School District.

1241
02:04:50.257 --> 02:04:52.698
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have watched 3 of my students die of violence.

1242
02:04:52.890 --> 02:04:53.998
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've watched 6 of my students shot and killed.

1243
02:04:54.079 --> 02:04:54.801
<v Jamie Dunphy>Shot and live.

1244
02:04:55.621 --> 02:05:01.673
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've seen one of my students doing a long-term sentence because she was involved in the violent beating death of her classmate.

1245
02:05:02.203 --> 02:05:19.529
<v Jamie Dunphy>Third places for students in East Portland especially is unparalleled for our resources for public safety, and the reality is my 13-year-old daughter will not benefit from this because we live in Parkrose, and the only available community center is the East Portland Community Center, which is adjacent to Floyd Light Middle School.

1246
02:05:19.962 --> 02:05:20.859
<v Jamie Dunphy>Those are my kids.

1247
02:05:20.922 --> 02:05:27.011
<v Jamie Dunphy>Those are actually now the kids of my kids when I was there because it's been 15, almost 20 years since I left.

1248
02:05:27.492 --> 02:05:29.511
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that this may be a special carve-out.

1249
02:05:29.574 --> 02:05:39.475
<v Jamie Dunphy>I hear my colleagues' concerns about calling out one special thing versus another, but for my students in District 1, for my young people, this is the difference between life and death.

1250
02:05:39.667 --> 02:05:40.837
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it's not hyperbole.

1251
02:05:42.135 --> 02:05:45.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Kids who do not have a place to go find a place to go.

1252
02:05:45.338 --> 02:05:58.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if they don't have something positive to do, they will find something to do and it will lead to increased It is directly tied to increased gun violence, directly tied to car theft, directly tied to retail theft, and directly tied to interpersonal violence.

1253
02:05:58.359 --> 02:06:08.278
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that this is an enormously responsible use of our time to modestly increase the amount of hours that some of our kids can benefit, even if it saves one child's life.

1254
02:06:09.154 --> 02:06:09.445
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you.

1255
02:06:09.608 --> 02:06:10.743
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1256
02:06:10.985 --> 02:06:11.603
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

1257
02:06:13.581 --> 02:06:22.104
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I just wanna say that I think public safety begins with strong and safe and healthy communities, and parks are a cornerstone of that for me.

1258
02:06:23.336 --> 02:06:51.497
<v Mitch Green>I think for all the other reasons that have been articulated, I think this is such a small amount of money that has the potential to save a lot of public safety expenditure on the back end that this is frankly, in a time where we do have budget challenges, I think just a really cost-effective I also, you know, I hear that— I do hear the structural concerns about like, okay, what are we cobbling together here and are we creating confusion?

1259
02:06:51.545 --> 02:07:03.765
<v Mitch Green>But I do think voters are looking at us to be increasingly creative in how we stretch the value of every resolution, every measure, everything that we refer and ask them to pay for.

1260
02:07:04.375 --> 02:07:14.813
<v Mitch Green>And if we can say, all right, this has a very, very small impact on the rest of the program delivery, but has a huge impact on public safety and, and, and whole communities, I, I think is really something we should support, colleagues.

1261
02:07:14.862 --> 02:07:15.672
<v Mitch Green>So I intend to vote yes.

1262
02:07:17.416 --> 02:07:18.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1263
02:07:18.157 --> 02:07:18.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos?

1264
02:07:20.476 --> 02:07:26.548
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I agree with Councilor Green, and I just want to note there's been a lot of negotiating and carve-outs that happened before it came to this table.

1265
02:07:26.613 --> 02:07:33.623
<v Candace Avalos>So, uh, I think that this is another one that is actually people forward, which is why I'm going to support it, and I think you all should too.

1266
02:07:33.912 --> 02:07:34.170
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thanks.

1267
02:07:35.430 --> 02:07:36.190
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1268
02:07:36.579 --> 02:07:38.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other discussion to the amendment?

1269
02:07:41.011 --> 02:07:43.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

1270
02:07:45.520 --> 02:07:45.923
<v Ashley Murray>Koyama Lane?

1271
02:07:46.426 --> 02:07:46.475
<v Priya Dhanapal>Aye.

1272
02:07:47.235 --> 02:07:47.640
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo?

1273
02:07:49.375 --> 02:07:51.155
<v Angelita Morillo>Sorry, I know we were supposed to have all our discussion.

1274
02:07:51.204 --> 02:07:51.917
<v Angelita Morillo>I'll be very brief.

1275
02:07:52.475 --> 02:07:56.448
<v Angelita Morillo>I think in general—.

1276
02:07:56.497 --> 02:07:57.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A sentence brief?

1277
02:07:57.783 --> 02:07:58.685
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes, a sentence brief.

1278
02:07:58.828 --> 02:08:06.244
<v Angelita Morillo>In general, I think that we should be able to indicate legislative intent when we are on the dais and have that be a part of the public record.

1279
02:08:06.694 --> 02:08:13.210
<v Angelita Morillo>But since this is such a small impact to the budget with such a big impact for the community, I will be voting yes.

1280
02:08:14.177 --> 02:08:23.739
<v Angelita Morillo>But generally, I'm quite tired of us being stuck in one position because we have specifically allocated funds when we need maximum flexibility.

1281
02:08:23.902 --> 02:08:24.569
<v Angelita Morillo>But I vote aye.

1282
02:08:25.689 --> 02:08:26.081
<v Rebecca Dobert>Nay.

1283
02:08:29.671 --> 02:08:29.898
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green.

1284
02:08:30.966 --> 02:08:31.015
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1285
02:08:32.132 --> 02:08:32.569
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman.

1286
02:08:33.720 --> 02:08:33.881
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

1287
02:08:35.890 --> 02:08:36.131
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos.

1288
02:08:37.118 --> 02:08:37.167
<v Sonya Szymanski>Aye.

1289
02:08:38.105 --> 02:08:38.559
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy.

1290
02:08:39.546 --> 02:08:39.707
<v Karen Chi Ray>Aye.

1291
02:08:40.386 --> 02:08:40.743
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith.

1292
02:08:42.618 --> 02:08:42.877
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1293
02:08:45.029 --> 02:08:45.271
<v Micah Meskel>Kanal.

1294
02:08:45.773 --> 02:08:45.935
<v Mary Ruble>Aye.

1295
02:08:46.501 --> 02:08:46.872
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan.

1296
02:08:47.488 --> 02:08:47.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

1297
02:08:49.752 --> 02:08:50.284
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney.

1298
02:08:50.577 --> 02:08:50.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

1299
02:08:53.337 --> 02:08:57.722
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the amendment fails with 6 aye and 5 nay.

1300
02:08:57.835 --> 02:08:58.140
<v Angelita Morillo>Pardon.

1301
02:09:02.720 --> 02:09:04.784
<v Rebecca Dobert>Passes with 6 aye and 5 nay.

1302
02:09:05.988 --> 02:09:07.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need 7 to pass.

1303
02:09:11.739 --> 02:09:13.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can we get the final vote count, Rebecca?

1304
02:09:13.554 --> 02:09:14.251
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes, sorry.

1305
02:09:14.444 --> 02:09:17.442
<v Rebecca Dobert>The amendment fails with 6 aye and 5 nay votes.

1306
02:09:17.782 --> 02:09:18.090
<v Ali Berman>Okay.

1307
02:09:21.039 --> 02:09:25.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Madam President.

1308
02:09:26.646 --> 02:09:36.979
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, as I indicated earlier, I would like to just add the sentence in the second-to-last resolved clause.

1309
02:09:37.805 --> 02:09:43.962
<v Eric Zimmerman>The sentence reads, the 3 cents for capital projects will be spent only on restroom facilities.

1310
02:09:44.109 --> 02:09:44.287
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1311
02:09:45.287 --> 02:10:01.413
<v Eric Zimmerman>So the reason I have shared before, and being the representative for the downtown area in particular, but actually across our district, this is one of those areas where I actually think specificity in levies is important.

1312
02:10:02.680 --> 02:10:21.835
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in particular on this topic, the reason I'm presenting this as an amendment is because I think I think we have seen over the last few years, we have seen where restroom facilities in our parks have been downgraded, if you will, in terms of their prioritization.

1313
02:10:21.882 --> 02:10:25.587
<v Eric Zimmerman>Instead, we saw the parks put in porta-potties and things like that.

1314
02:10:27.644 --> 02:10:31.185
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think it is important that we be specific that this is also part of it.

1315
02:10:31.363 --> 02:10:43.493
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I appreciate the rest of the other capital maintenance and Councilor Novick's I think those are all really important signals and pieces to send.

1316
02:10:44.569 --> 02:10:48.771
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the additional 50% open to other items.

1317
02:10:48.836 --> 02:10:54.386
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I do think it's important for us in this time to consider calling out the park restrooms.

1318
02:10:54.515 --> 02:11:01.542
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because for whatever reason, I don't think that park restrooms are held in high regard in the cultural decision-making of the last levy.

1319
02:11:01.591 --> 02:11:01.814
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Novick.

1320
02:11:02.634 --> 02:11:07.997
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or in the last several years of parks, and so in this case, I think it's important.

1321
02:11:08.092 --> 02:11:11.032
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would never shy away from specificity.

1322
02:11:11.305 --> 02:11:19.542
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that the health of a levy would be that this would all be more specific, and I'm willing to be flexible on this entire levy.

1323
02:11:20.199 --> 02:11:26.814
<v Eric Zimmerman>But in this in this case, I I think for this one, I would like this three percent to be clear and that be resolved so that.

1324
02:11:37.957 --> 02:11:38.296
<v Candace Avalos>Second.

1325
02:11:38.345 --> 02:11:40.149
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seconded by Councilor Ryan.

1326
02:11:40.908 --> 02:11:42.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy to the amendment?

1327
02:11:43.261 --> 02:11:49.425
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, um, Councilor Zimmerman, you know, there are— I think I'm ultimately going to be a no on this.

1328
02:11:49.538 --> 02:12:00.458
<v Jamie Dunphy>I appreciate where you're going, and I've seen firsthand how, for example, For example, when the bathroom at Ventura Park was chained shut for a year, it led to less use by families and more use by bad behavior.

1329
02:12:00.507 --> 02:12:09.807
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I also see situations like Lewitt View Park in my neighborhood where the rubber on the surface of the playground began crumbling within a year.

1330
02:12:10.519 --> 02:12:16.472
<v Jamie Dunphy>The pipes that were used to irrigate the plants got run over by a lawnmower and never got replaced.

1331
02:12:16.940 --> 02:12:20.474
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the splash pad has been out of commission for the last 4 years.

1332
02:12:20.523 --> 02:12:31.872
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, There are some, you know, especially in my district, there are reasons beyond simply restrooms that people are no longer able to use a lot of these public spaces.

1333
02:12:33.367 --> 02:12:43.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I would be hesitant to only specify that, especially because there are bathrooms in East Portland that are— I'm sorry, parks in East Portland that simply don't even have bathrooms.

1334
02:12:43.757 --> 02:12:44.002
<v John Isaacs>So.

1335
02:12:48.100 --> 02:12:48.822
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1336
02:12:48.903 --> 02:12:49.625
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

1337
02:12:50.909 --> 02:12:53.993
<v Steve Novick>I wanted to second Councilor Dunphy's reference to playgrounds.

1338
02:12:54.056 --> 02:13:03.417
<v Steve Novick>The current language of the levy says that a new levy would include 0.03 of the rate for capital projects to maintain our park system, such as repair of bathrooms and playgrounds.

1339
02:13:03.466 --> 02:13:05.520
<v Steve Novick>So it does call out bathrooms.

1340
02:13:05.698 --> 02:13:11.734
<v Steve Novick>And as a 62-year-old man, I yield to no one in my appreciation of the importance of bathrooms, but I would not want to exclude playgrounds.

1341
02:13:13.893 --> 02:13:14.877
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1342
02:13:18.288 --> 02:13:25.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Councilor, I also am concerned with just calling out restrooms.

1343
02:13:25.710 --> 02:13:27.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Playgrounds stand out to me.

1344
02:13:27.100 --> 02:13:37.511
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are also a number of facilities in my district that could support the type of partnerships that we are asking for parks to do more of if only the facilities were more usable.

1345
02:13:37.650 --> 02:13:39.333
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Things Like cottages.

1346
02:13:39.430 --> 02:13:59.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know in Sellwood Park we've heard about the shack that need roof repairs and other upgrades to be able to be usable for the type of partnerships that we're talking about that actually come in at about the same cost range as the bathroom projects that I'd like to be able to have on the list.

1347
02:13:59.981 --> 02:14:17.078
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If folks are interested in moving this forward and the votes are not there with that I would suggest that I would be happy to say prioritizing bathrooms, but not excluding other projects to give us some ability to look at what the needs are in our districts.

1348
02:14:18.680 --> 02:14:27.646
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>However, if the votes are there without that or are not there at all, I don't need to move that forward, but I am concerned with the current language as proposed.

1349
02:14:29.520 --> 02:14:29.903
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Avalos?

1350
02:14:32.283 --> 02:14:34.354
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy.

1351
02:14:34.692 --> 02:14:36.056
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, agree with your points.

1352
02:14:36.698 --> 02:14:55.484
<v Candace Avalos>I don't see how at a moment where we are scraping by, we're already sacrificing so much by choosing this 140 number, we're already carving out 3 cents for capital and that's not even close to being enough, and our playgrounds are deteriorating, I don't see how we could put this kind of restriction on ourselves.

1353
02:14:55.743 --> 02:14:58.921
<v Candace Avalos>To make it only go to bathrooms, especially when East Portland barely has them.

1354
02:14:59.002 --> 02:15:00.038
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm going to be voting no.

1355
02:15:01.289 --> 02:15:01.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1356
02:15:02.136 --> 02:15:03.082
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1357
02:15:05.229 --> 02:15:05.957
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Madam President.

1358
02:15:07.823 --> 02:15:09.546
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Glad you're with us, Councilor Zimmerman.

1359
02:15:10.221 --> 02:15:11.381
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I have a question for you.

1360
02:15:11.832 --> 02:15:16.422
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I kind of wish I could just ask you this not on the dais.

1361
02:15:18.671 --> 02:15:41.708
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm genuinely wondering and a little confused and wondering if you can speak I am genuinely curious, and, and it might be that those two are quite different, but can you speak to that a little bit, help me understand?

1362
02:15:43.699 --> 02:15:44.676
<v Eric Zimmerman>Well, those are your words.

1363
02:15:44.938 --> 02:16:01.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>I didn't speak to Councilor Kanal's issue about specificity, and I agreed with Thank you for clarifying.

1364
02:16:01.350 --> 02:16:04.409
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's helpful.

1365
02:16:04.409 --> 02:16:05.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, anything additional?

1366
02:16:06.810 --> 02:16:08.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Nope, thank you.

1367
02:16:08.189 --> 02:16:10.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green?

1368
02:16:10.770 --> 02:16:16.649
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I was— Councilor President, I appreciate you brought in that potential.

1369
02:16:16.649 --> 02:16:16.810
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's a good idea.

1370
02:16:17.020 --> 02:16:21.692
<v Mitch Green>Amendment that you can make, because that's something that I was going to suggest that could move me.

1371
02:16:21.756 --> 02:16:33.799
<v Mitch Green>But I think, yeah, I think that Councilor Novick has pointed to the language in the ballot that does identify the bathrooms.

1372
02:16:34.298 --> 02:16:35.890
<v Mitch Green>Bathrooms are a huge problem in our district.

1373
02:16:36.212 --> 02:16:36.664
<v Mitch Green>I know that.

1374
02:16:38.226 --> 02:16:43.815
<v Mitch Green>I also think that we have an opportunity with the amendment that we passed from Councilor Ryan with the KPIs.

1375
02:16:43.926 --> 02:16:44.023
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1376
02:16:44.834 --> 02:16:47.308
<v Mitch Green>To say, look, we're in the 5-year levy period.

1377
02:16:47.829 --> 02:16:48.854
<v Mitch Green>How are we spending our money?

1378
02:16:50.510 --> 02:16:52.037
<v Mitch Green>Are we prioritizing the right things?

1379
02:16:52.375 --> 02:16:54.882
<v Mitch Green>And yes, bathrooms need to be opened up.

1380
02:16:55.525 --> 02:16:56.780
<v Mitch Green>We shouldn't be using porta-potties.

1381
02:16:56.891 --> 02:16:58.918
<v Mitch Green>But I don't know if I'm there yet on this.

1382
02:16:58.983 --> 02:17:02.877
<v Mitch Green>So if there's further discussion, I might be able to be moved.

1383
02:17:03.281 --> 02:17:07.646
<v Mitch Green>Or if you want to have a response to me, please, please, please go for it.

1384
02:17:08.373 --> 02:17:09.282
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

1385
02:17:11.180 --> 02:17:16.063
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I think that this levy should have specificity.

1386
02:17:16.254 --> 02:17:22.245
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think there's so much about this levy that is being taken on faith, and I have great concern.

1387
02:17:22.744 --> 02:17:35.625
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think being able to signal a couple of areas where we have seen time and time again the decision-making within the bureau has not prioritized something, and so that's all I'm really trying to, trying to, you know, signal.

1388
02:17:35.674 --> 02:17:35.834
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1389
02:17:36.108 --> 02:17:49.122
<v Eric Zimmerman>Solve for here is because I think that it can be very easy to get a bureau to talk about repairing a playground, but for whatever reason, um, that decision-making has not ever prioritized restrooms in our community.

1390
02:17:49.171 --> 02:17:53.150
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I, I don't disagree with a lot that's being said.

1391
02:17:53.664 --> 02:18:05.585
<v Eric Zimmerman>I certainly wish this levy was more transparent in terms of what was being included in it, and I thought that this one little ounce of that might palatable.

1392
02:18:06.422 --> 02:18:11.570
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I just want to highlight a little bit of a difference when we talk about some of the parks that are in West Portland.

1393
02:18:12.239 --> 02:18:23.001
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're usually— when you stand in one position of that park, you know, you can see almost the rest of the entire park, except for, of course, the Forest Park.

1394
02:18:23.708 --> 02:18:30.236
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's a little bit different than when you stand in some of the parks across our cities who occupy larger blocks and larger areas.

1395
02:18:32.710 --> 02:18:45.308
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the reason I bring that up is sometimes the behavior that happens in and around our parks is the kind of thing that you can't get away from when you're in an urban area park in the downtown area, that you will just choose to leave that park.

1396
02:18:46.288 --> 02:18:56.475
<v Eric Zimmerman>And sometimes, and a lot of times in our district, that is what I've noticed is it's toileting, and it is, you know, it's the porta potty getting dumped over.

1397
02:18:56.877 --> 02:18:57.149
<v Eric Zimmerman>Right?

1398
02:18:57.198 --> 02:19:05.763
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's the it's the it's that kind of stuff that's you can't just go to the other side of the park when that park is only one square block and think that you're away from it.

1399
02:19:05.810 --> 02:19:08.334
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I am I am hearing folks.

1400
02:19:08.768 --> 02:19:12.382
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would still support and hope for some support on this.

1401
02:19:12.543 --> 02:19:22.184
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know it's a tiny amount, but I am I'm pretty worried about the future of this levy and and where we're going with it, and I think.

1402
02:19:23.880 --> 02:19:30.399
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for the questions, and I, and I recognize it's not everybody's cup of tea, but I appreciate consideration.

1403
02:19:33.992 --> 02:19:34.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Morillo.

1404
02:19:37.379 --> 02:19:38.335
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Madam President.

1405
02:19:38.513 --> 02:19:40.832
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, thank you, Councilor Zimmerman, for bringing this forward.

1406
02:19:41.186 --> 02:19:51.226
<v Angelita Morillo>I, uh, I think I share the same concerns, uh, that some of my colleagues have already brought up, and just the fact that restrooms were already referenced, I think, is a good thing.

1407
02:19:51.592 --> 02:20:01.264
<v Angelita Morillo>But I did just want to say, put it on the record right now, that whenever you want to work on opening more restrooms and repairing our restrooms in the city together, I'd be happy to work on that with you.

1408
02:20:01.859 --> 02:20:15.140
<v Angelita Morillo>I do think it's a really critical issue, and I think that in the coming years, frankly, we're going to be experiencing more housing and homelessness issues because of everything happening economically at the federal level and locally.

1409
02:20:16.440 --> 02:20:22.311
<v Angelita Morillo>And this is going to be a really critical resource for people who are on our streets and just for anyone who wants to use our parks.

1410
02:20:22.391 --> 02:20:35.119
<v Angelita Morillo>So I hope that this is signaling some legislative intent to move this forward and that maybe in the next budget cycle we add some specific budget notes as well to direct the Parks Bureau to have a specific focus on this.

1411
02:20:37.055 --> 02:20:37.881
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1412
02:20:37.995 --> 02:20:39.015
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1413
02:20:39.939 --> 02:20:40.764
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Madam President.

1414
02:20:42.690 --> 02:20:47.572
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This is a helpful discussion and Thank you for clarifying, Councilor Zimmerman.

1415
02:20:47.844 --> 02:20:51.290
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That does refresh my memory, and I remember you saying you appreciate specificity.

1416
02:20:51.786 --> 02:21:02.538
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I would be interested if any colleagues are interested in sharing if you voted no on that last amendment specifically around concerns around specificity but are considering voting yes on this one.

1417
02:21:02.986 --> 02:21:06.863
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'd be interested if you're comfortable hearing a bit of your thinking there.

1418
02:21:07.697 --> 02:21:20.949
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I, I said in my last vote I'm interested in specificity, and so I And I want to make— I make my voting decisions based on what I think makes the most sense and what's going to be best for Portlanders.

1419
02:21:21.408 --> 02:21:24.316
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so I am also interested in this a bit.

1420
02:21:24.752 --> 02:21:40.132
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am wondering, Councilor Zimmerman, if you might be interested, if you might be open to a friendly amendment that Council President and I were just whispering about over here about it saying bathrooms, playgrounds, and other small structures.

1421
02:21:40.185 --> 02:21:40.238
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1422
02:21:40.677 --> 02:21:46.731
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Or if the Parks Bureau has a more— a better word besides small structures, insert that.

1423
02:21:47.054 --> 02:21:51.591
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Would you be open to that, Councilor Zimmerman, adding in playgrounds and other small structures?

1424
02:21:53.549 --> 02:21:53.936
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1425
02:21:54.097 --> 02:22:01.962
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, I know, I'll just remind folks, we have a maintenance budget in the Parks Bureau outside of this 3 cents in this levy.

1426
02:22:02.893 --> 02:22:09.218
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so nothing would stop them from doing those projects that you're referencing, Councilor.

1427
02:22:09.299 --> 02:22:13.748
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I appreciate the nod, I think, to get there.

1428
02:22:14.922 --> 02:22:30.086
<v Eric Zimmerman>The reason I actually value including the term restroom in this one solely is because I don't think that those— the prioritization for restrooms actually exists within the thought process within the bureau structure as it currently is.

1429
02:22:30.601 --> 02:22:46.765
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that was actually part of the reason why I think calling it out individually was important because the other aspects of park maintenance— excuse me, the other park maintenance funds seem to already be trying to keep up with some of the other areas.

1430
02:22:47.022 --> 02:22:58.612
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm noticing what I think is an inequity in terms of how they apply those maintenance dollars, and this is a signal to one of those areas that I think has been on the lowest end of the decision-making.

1431
02:22:58.661 --> 02:23:09.002
<v Eric Zimmerman>So So it's not that I, you know, I think some of the framing here has been like, for some reason this is against playgrounds or something of that nature.

1432
02:23:09.257 --> 02:23:10.511
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's certainly not the case.

1433
02:23:10.686 --> 02:23:14.718
<v Eric Zimmerman>I obviously was supportive in the regular budget and continue to be.

1434
02:23:15.280 --> 02:23:16.515
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just talking about this in this one.

1435
02:23:16.564 --> 02:23:21.108
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I wouldn't quite be there for that friendly amendment, but I do appreciate the nod.

1436
02:23:22.247 --> 02:23:23.034
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, thank you so much.

1437
02:23:26.766 --> 02:23:30.095
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

1438
02:23:30.403 --> 02:23:35.480
<v Loretta Smith>I just wanted to say that, um, I agree with you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1439
02:23:36.161 --> 02:23:43.399
<v Loretta Smith>I think that, uh, bathrooms should be, um, pointed out, and I will be supporting this amendment.

1440
02:23:46.900 --> 02:23:47.481
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1441
02:23:47.561 --> 02:23:48.239
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan?

1442
02:23:48.611 --> 02:23:49.885
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Madam President.

1443
02:23:49.981 --> 02:23:53.078
<v Dan Ryan>I did second this because I wanted to have this conversation.

1444
02:23:53.370 --> 02:23:58.058
<v Dan Ryan>I was I was equally challenged with the last one by Councilor Kanal.

1445
02:23:59.593 --> 02:24:05.899
<v Dan Ryan>All of us have heard from countless constituents, especially parents, who tell me their frustrations with bathrooms being closed.

1446
02:24:06.350 --> 02:24:12.540
<v Dan Ryan>And so clearly this is an operational issue that this council must stay on top of from— for oversight reasons.

1447
02:24:13.104 --> 02:24:19.532
<v Dan Ryan>But because I voted no on the last one, there's some similar themes on this, and that's where I'll land to stay consistent.

1448
02:24:19.612 --> 02:24:19.838
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1449
02:24:19.940 --> 02:24:22.198
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1450
02:24:22.875 --> 02:24:24.809
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any other discussion to the amendment?

1451
02:24:27.440 --> 02:24:29.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none, Rebecca, can you please call the roll?

1452
02:24:31.780 --> 02:24:32.184
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane.

1453
02:24:33.498 --> 02:24:33.547
<v Micah Meskel>Aye.

1454
02:24:34.552 --> 02:24:35.040
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo.

1455
02:24:35.688 --> 02:24:35.736
<v Priya Dhanapal>Aye.

1456
02:24:37.326 --> 02:24:37.747
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick.

1457
02:24:37.894 --> 02:24:38.120
<v Steve Novick>No.

1458
02:24:39.191 --> 02:24:39.485
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green.

1459
02:24:41.129 --> 02:24:41.177
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1460
02:24:42.367 --> 02:24:42.823
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman.

1461
02:24:44.238 --> 02:24:44.417
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1462
02:24:46.208 --> 02:24:54.068
<v Candace Avalos>Um, no, no.

1463
02:24:54.954 --> 02:24:55.261
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

1464
02:24:58.640 --> 02:24:58.689
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1465
02:25:00.810 --> 02:25:01.952
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

1466
02:25:07.269 --> 02:25:07.479
<v Rebecca Dobert>No.

1467
02:25:07.998 --> 02:25:08.079
<v Elizabeth Milner>No.

1468
02:25:11.373 --> 02:25:14.751
<v Rebecca Dobert>The amendment fails with 5 aye and 6 nay votes.

1469
02:25:18.750 --> 02:25:23.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, those were all of the amendments that I had noted folks said they were bringing.

1470
02:25:25.381 --> 02:25:29.647
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If there are any other amendments though, please feel free to put yourself in the queue.

1471
02:25:29.843 --> 02:25:47.504
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And in addition, because we are trying to not give our speeches with our votes now, if there is anybody who would like to If anybody would like to speak to the now amended resolution and attachments as a whole, this would be the time to get in the queue to make those comments.

1472
02:25:48.210 --> 02:25:48.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy.

1473
02:25:49.914 --> 02:25:50.299
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1474
02:25:50.379 --> 02:25:53.014
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, first, colleagues, thank you for this conversation.

1475
02:25:53.191 --> 02:25:59.218
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that the debate back and forth has been great to add some value and to continue to work with you all.

1476
02:25:59.619 --> 02:26:01.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you to everybody who's been involved in this so far.

1477
02:26:01.708 --> 02:26:04.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm eager to support the renewal of the Portland Portland Parks Levy.

1478
02:26:04.198 --> 02:26:10.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm really thankful to everybody who has— and all the work that's gone into the compromise proposal before us.

1479
02:26:11.100 --> 02:26:28.978
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, as I said just a little bit ago, and I've mentioned repeatedly, in my brief time on City Council, I've insisted that we treat parks as a vital public safety infrastructure, especially in East Portland, where far too many residents lack access to safe, accessible places to play, gather, and connect.

1480
02:26:29.814 --> 02:26:36.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe strongly in investing in these spaces, not just to maintain what we have, but to grow and transform what our parks can be.

1481
02:26:37.280 --> 02:26:40.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>But let's be clear what we have heard from every part of our community.

1482
02:26:41.295 --> 02:26:43.494
<v Jamie Dunphy>This cannot just be business as usual.

1483
02:26:44.264 --> 02:26:47.316
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're asking Portlanders to dig deeper into their pockets.

1484
02:26:47.717 --> 02:26:54.509
<v Jamie Dunphy>If we are asking Portlanders to dig deeper into their pockets, especially in my community in District 1, we must demand more in return.

1485
02:26:55.086 --> 02:27:01.815
<v Jamie Dunphy>Holding ourselves and parks and recreation to the highest standard of fiscal stewardship, accountability, equity, and imagination.

1486
02:27:03.195 --> 02:27:06.551
<v Jamie Dunphy>Our parks should be more than vibrant or more than beautiful natural spaces.

1487
02:27:06.985 --> 02:27:17.518
<v Jamie Dunphy>They should be alive and vibrant with youth programming and cultural celebrations and music and food and community events that bring neighbors together and activates these public spaces year round.

1488
02:27:17.968 --> 02:27:19.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>And where the bureau can't do that on their own.

1489
02:27:20.393 --> 02:27:31.475
<v Jamie Dunphy>Then we must be bold enough to pursue partnerships with community organizations that can, like the Sellwood Community House and others that have shown us what is possible if— when our public assets are community-powered.

1490
02:27:31.811 --> 02:27:47.648
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I support this levy, and I'm— let's also use this moment as a call to action, a challenge to ourselves and to the Bureau to raise the bar, to build a Portland where our parks reflect the vibrant, diverse, thriving communities that they are meant Thank you.

1491
02:27:48.558 --> 02:27:49.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1492
02:27:49.595 --> 02:27:50.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1493
02:27:52.371 --> 02:27:52.712
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1494
02:27:52.762 --> 02:27:56.325
<v Sameer Kanal>I actually have a couple questions for the park's leadership.

1495
02:27:56.406 --> 02:28:06.397
<v Sameer Kanal>I separated this out so I can propose my amendment, and it's related to some specific testimony that we had here.

1496
02:28:07.478 --> 02:28:13.864
<v Sameer Kanal>Both Mr. Ohendoff and Mr. Weinstein referenced an audit that they said had not been released publicly.

1497
02:28:13.929 --> 02:28:14.906
<v Sameer Kanal>Could you speak to that?

1498
02:28:16.108 --> 02:28:18.879
<v Sonya Szymanski>Yeah, I don't quite know what that is.

1499
02:28:18.976 --> 02:28:25.530
<v Sonya Szymanski>I know there are a couple of audits underway with the city's Audit Services Division, none ready for release.

1500
02:28:25.626 --> 02:28:33.909
<v Sonya Szymanski>I think one is maybe scheduled for fall and one's a little earlier in the sequence, but those are released publicly and contemporaneously by the auditor.

1501
02:28:34.774 --> 02:28:34.918
<v Sameer Kanal>Right.

1502
02:28:34.998 --> 02:28:39.165
<v Sameer Kanal>And then there's— when you say in the fall, before the election?

1503
02:28:40.264 --> 02:28:41.166
<v Sonya Szymanski>Up to the auditor.

1504
02:28:41.779 --> 02:28:43.486
<v Sonya Szymanski>I kind of think so, but I don't know.

1505
02:28:43.905 --> 02:28:44.049
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1506
02:28:44.355 --> 02:28:59.266
<v Sameer Kanal>And then last year there was a conversation when I was on the Parks Board about the— not by the auditor, but an independent look into the levy, specifically the current levy, and that that had, as far as I'm aware, been publicly released.

1507
02:28:59.316 --> 02:28:59.834
<v Sameer Kanal>I've seen it.

1508
02:29:00.061 --> 02:29:00.255
<v Sonya Szymanski>Yes.

1509
02:29:00.693 --> 02:29:04.194
<v Sameer Kanal>And I was on it as a volunteer, so I assume if I could see it, anyone can see it.

1510
02:29:04.341 --> 02:29:04.647
<v Sonya Szymanski>Correct.

1511
02:29:04.969 --> 02:29:07.048
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I'm seeing nods over there for the record.

1512
02:29:07.095 --> 02:29:08.183
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's helpful to know.

1513
02:29:08.248 --> 02:29:10.684
<v Sameer Kanal>And I might just, for the record, it was a clean audit.

1514
02:29:10.781 --> 02:29:12.438
<v Sameer Kanal>Like it was a very positive audit.

1515
02:29:13.770 --> 02:29:15.106
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1516
02:29:15.510 --> 02:29:26.540
<v Sameer Kanal>Second, is there any current strategic planning process underway at Parks or for that matter in the Public Works service area?

1517
02:29:27.427 --> 02:29:28.040
<v Sonya Szymanski>Or in the city?

1518
02:29:28.718 --> 02:29:30.511
<v Sonya Szymanski>Yes, in the Parks Bureau.

1519
02:29:30.558 --> 02:29:32.060
<v Sonya Szymanski>I might ask Sarah to come up.

1520
02:29:32.596 --> 02:29:44.672
<v Sonya Szymanski>Briefly, I think the Healthy Parks, Healthy Portland framework is really the strategic conversation about directional priorities for the Bureau, and within that, how to get there.

1521
02:29:45.057 --> 02:29:47.449
<v Sonya Szymanski>Could you give us 30 seconds on that?

1522
02:29:48.108 --> 02:29:48.316
<v Nancy Thorington>Thank you.

1523
02:29:48.364 --> 02:29:48.718
<v Ali Berman>Certainly.

1524
02:29:49.150 --> 02:29:49.728
<v Ali Berman>Thank you so much.

1525
02:29:49.793 --> 02:29:52.331
<v Ali Berman>Sarah Huggins with Portland Parks and Recreation, for the record.

1526
02:29:52.843 --> 02:29:54.948
<v Ali Berman>So the Bureau has a strategic planning framework.

1527
02:29:54.995 --> 02:29:56.923
<v Angelita Morillo>It's called Healthy Parks, Healthy Portland.

1528
02:29:57.180 --> 02:30:00.930
<v Angelita Morillo>It includes both a mission, vision, values, equity, and anti-racism commitment.

1529
02:30:01.010 --> 02:30:03.364
<v Angelita Morillo>It also includes a performance framework.

1530
02:30:03.429 --> 02:30:12.626
<v Angelita Morillo>We call it Actions and Results that looks at performance over time and how those link up to 6 identified outcomes that are also in that strategic planning framework.

1531
02:30:12.947 --> 02:30:16.647
<v Angelita Morillo>It has other elements as well, but that is sort of the, the guiding principle for the bureau.

1532
02:30:17.272 --> 02:30:17.529
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1533
02:30:18.170 --> 02:30:29.202
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, colleagues, I just wanted to note, I, I think my— I, I'm a supporter that it's a 2020 document, and, um, I think we need to also evolve over time.

1534
02:30:29.251 --> 02:30:38.636
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that there's been some valid criticism of parks that that's insufficiently focused on recreation to the point that we often just say Portland Parks and it is Portland Parks and Recreation, right?

1535
02:30:39.424 --> 02:30:41.952
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think that's worth noting here.

1536
02:30:43.513 --> 02:30:49.158
<v Sameer Kanal>And I hope that there will be a strategic planning process that can inform the next levy through this process.

1537
02:30:49.224 --> 02:31:01.548
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a fair thing for voters to ask because as Ms. Murray mentioned, and I think Mr. Schuilen as well, That there is a lack of cohesive, understood by the public vision in that shorter, more concise way.

1538
02:31:01.933 --> 02:31:10.683
<v Sameer Kanal>When I met with Mr. Shulman's group, I referenced my vision statement for parks, which is that parks are the thing that move your life in Portland from merely surviving to thriving, regardless of your income level.

1539
02:31:10.861 --> 02:31:13.879
<v Sameer Kanal>That's helpful context for our purpose.

1540
02:31:14.328 --> 02:31:15.421
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not specific enough.

1541
02:31:15.918 --> 02:31:19.354
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I want to note that and say that we do need to get there at some point.

1542
02:31:19.403 --> 02:31:19.514
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1543
02:31:20.656 --> 02:31:27.882
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I'll just mention, Mr. Weinstein also mentioned the risk of conveying something to voters that's not what they'd be voting for on major maintenance.

1544
02:31:27.962 --> 02:31:31.175
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think Councilor Novick's amendments resolved that for me.

1545
02:31:31.399 --> 02:31:34.870
<v Sameer Kanal>I also mentioned this exact concern in the work session in the committee last Thursday.

1546
02:31:35.495 --> 02:31:36.667
<v Sameer Kanal>I checked all the exhibits.

1547
02:31:36.717 --> 02:31:38.659
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we have resolved that issue.

1548
02:31:38.804 --> 02:31:40.250
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I wanted to just note that.

1549
02:31:41.519 --> 02:31:45.838
<v Sameer Kanal>Finally, I agree with Councilor Dunphy that we should treat parks as part of the public safety infrastructure of the city.

1550
02:31:46.352 --> 02:31:49.996
<v Sameer Kanal>Unfortunately, that didn't happen today, and we had an opportunity to do that.

1551
02:31:50.608 --> 02:31:56.756
<v Sameer Kanal>I've been told in the Portland building and told for years, next budget cycle, next fall bump, next spring bump, we'll get you the money.

1552
02:31:57.656 --> 02:31:59.694
<v Sameer Kanal>That never happened under the previous mayor.

1553
02:31:59.774 --> 02:32:05.907
<v Sameer Kanal>So we'll see if the current mayor puts up a budget proposal that includes extended community center hours.

1554
02:32:06.422 --> 02:32:06.951
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope he does.

1555
02:32:07.369 --> 02:32:09.617
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe that he is interested in this work.

1556
02:32:10.097 --> 02:32:12.104
<v Sameer Kanal>And having said that, even if he does, we won't have it in June.

1557
02:32:12.450 --> 02:32:15.729
<v Sameer Kanal>June, which is when schools are out, but before the budget takes over.

1558
02:32:16.263 --> 02:32:22.012
<v Sameer Kanal>Having said all of that, this is at the upper end of what I said was a good amount.

1559
02:32:22.139 --> 02:32:26.129
<v Sameer Kanal>I said $1.30 to $1.40 was my range when we had the work session.

1560
02:32:26.670 --> 02:32:36.954
<v Sameer Kanal>I think they've threaded the needle on where the people— and when I say threaded they, I mean the people who did the negotiations over the last few weeks.

1561
02:32:37.132 --> 02:32:37.540
<v Micah Meskel>Thank you.

1562
02:32:39.123 --> 02:32:45.593
<v Sameer Kanal>Threaded the needle in terms of resolving both the needs of the operational side and contributing a small amount to the capital side.

1563
02:32:46.376 --> 02:32:52.843
<v Sameer Kanal>I committed then not only to donating dodgeballs but to knocking doors for this levy, and I intend to keep that, and I will support this.

1564
02:32:53.577 --> 02:32:53.802
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1565
02:32:55.449 --> 02:32:56.222
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1566
02:32:56.480 --> 02:32:57.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos.

1567
02:32:59.400 --> 02:32:59.884
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1568
02:33:00.191 --> 02:33:12.130
<v Candace Avalos>I just wanted to put my thoughts on the record about This, um, ultimately I do plan on voting aye because I believe that this resolution is better than failing to address our budget shortfalls.

1569
02:33:12.243 --> 02:33:19.531
<v Candace Avalos>But I'm definitely disappointed that we didn't have a bigger investment in parks, um, that that wasn't really on the table.

1570
02:33:19.611 --> 02:33:28.984
<v Candace Avalos>It seemed like there was a lot of discussion, um, uh, about, you know, what would be palatable, um, with different groups.

1571
02:33:29.128 --> 02:33:34.047
<v Candace Avalos>And I just feel that, um, we missed the mark and that within the $140 million range, we could have gone higher.

1572
02:33:34.094 --> 02:33:34.447
<v Karen Chi Ray>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1573
02:33:34.688 --> 02:33:38.310
<v Candace Avalos>I think there was a number at like $1.47 that would have gotten us a lot more.

1574
02:33:39.465 --> 02:33:45.908
<v Candace Avalos>And I felt, you know, politically we could handle those 7 cents as well as it's just what we need.

1575
02:33:46.710 --> 02:33:53.908
<v Candace Avalos>East Portland's parks and recreation facilities, they're crumbling, as we have said over and over again, and we have so few of them to begin with.

1576
02:33:54.325 --> 02:34:05.625
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm just hoping that we really talk about how we stop this cycle of underinvestment and deferred maintenance that just continues to lead to all of these even worse problems down the road.

1577
02:34:05.994 --> 02:34:12.708
<v Candace Avalos>I hope we're prepared to have a discussion about how we make some progressive taxes instead of regressive taxes.

1578
02:34:13.203 --> 02:34:33.677
<v Candace Avalos>Of course, it's not easy to add more taxes and fees to people who are struggling, and yet the folks that often fight us on some of those fees are the folks that don't let us do the progressive taxation that we need from the people who Leaving, take— not giving us the infrastructure dollars that we need as a city to build and thrive.

1579
02:34:34.305 --> 02:34:43.472
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm ready to have that conversation, uh, to start figuring out how we do some other taxation measures that ask those that have the most to pay their share.

1580
02:34:43.552 --> 02:34:45.030
<v Candace Avalos>So that's where I'm landing.

1581
02:34:45.287 --> 02:34:52.770
<v Candace Avalos>I will be voting yes, but I wanted to continue to raise our concerns about how we really invest in our infrastructure that we need.

1582
02:34:52.834 --> 02:34:53.075
<v Sonya Szymanski>Thank you.

1583
02:34:59.399 --> 02:35:10.079
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, when we had our work session, um, I had indicated, uh, my directional preference for the— my upper and lower bounds for the levy, and $1.40 was my lower bound.

1584
02:35:10.079 --> 02:35:11.360
<v Mitch Green>And, and here we are.

1585
02:35:11.459 --> 02:35:18.940
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I would prefer a higher number for all the reasons that Councilor Avalos has already articulated, um, but I didn't want to let the council down.

1586
02:35:18.940 --> 02:35:19.079
<v Karen Chi Ray>So I'm going to support the recommendation.

1587
02:35:19.079 --> 02:35:19.120
<v Karen Chi Ray>Thank you.

1588
02:35:19.484 --> 02:35:20.398
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1589
02:35:21.555 --> 02:35:31.523
<v Mitch Green>I do believe that we have a council that is invested in hearing constituents and advancing that forward into accountability and transparency, and you have my commitment on that.

1590
02:35:32.326 --> 02:35:44.063
<v Mitch Green>Part of what got me here and part of why I think we have a real opportunity is the willingness for this body to consider an amendment to more clearly specify how we might use system development charges to really leverage our backlog.

1591
02:35:44.127 --> 02:35:45.315
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's a really important step.

1592
02:35:45.813 --> 02:35:46.759
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a win today.

1593
02:35:48.218 --> 02:36:00.700
<v Mitch Green>I do think as we contemplate the future, you know, future levies, future funding packages that we do, we always gotta remember that you gotta noticeably improve people's lives to keep them in the game.

1594
02:36:01.680 --> 02:36:03.156
<v Mitch Green>And this is a game of political economy.

1595
02:36:03.219 --> 02:36:05.593
<v Mitch Green>At the end of the day, we are losing people out of our county.

1596
02:36:06.989 --> 02:36:10.471
<v Mitch Green>That we are primarily losing people in the middle of the income distribution.

1597
02:36:11.966 --> 02:36:14.671
<v Mitch Green>Who really want prized assets to raise a family.

1598
02:36:14.943 --> 02:36:17.229
<v Mitch Green>And the, you know, parks are a big part of that.

1599
02:36:17.295 --> 02:36:19.082
<v Mitch Green>So it's got us partway there.

1600
02:36:19.209 --> 02:36:21.433
<v Mitch Green>We've recommitted, but we have more work to do.

1601
02:36:22.986 --> 02:36:23.988
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thanks.

1602
02:36:26.640 --> 02:36:27.336
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1603
02:36:27.853 --> 02:36:28.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1604
02:36:31.072 --> 02:36:32.165
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

1605
02:36:32.422 --> 02:36:43.463
<v Loretta Smith>I think that my District 1 councilors have identified that I think that taxation without representation is real key here.

1606
02:36:43.900 --> 02:37:01.754
<v Loretta Smith>And I think the fact that we have probably one of the most vulnerable districts— the average income in District 1 is $60,000— and I know we know that from groceries to gas, every dollar counts.

1607
02:37:02.521 --> 02:37:13.433
<v Loretta Smith>And this council has attached to itself many, many additional taxes this year, all the way down to the parking.

1608
02:37:13.709 --> 02:37:26.635
<v Loretta Smith>I felt it this past weekend being downtown, $3.50, and that's a huge, huge amount of money if you're asking folks who have very little to do more with less.

1609
02:37:27.220 --> 02:37:30.682
<v Loretta Smith>But the importance of this particular levy is Councilor Smith.

1610
02:37:30.762 --> 02:37:37.061
<v Loretta Smith>This is being thoughtful and transparent about, you know, what is important, what is critical.

1611
02:37:37.414 --> 02:37:46.279
<v Loretta Smith>It's not about expanding or, you know, increasing and improving shiny objects, but preserving what Portlanders love.

1612
02:37:47.111 --> 02:37:52.770
<v Loretta Smith>And Portlanders, they love our parks, our trails, safe and clean community spaces.

1613
02:37:53.507 --> 02:37:57.627
<v Loretta Smith>Without this funding, Portland risks the decline of some of our greatest assets.

1614
02:37:58.653 --> 02:38:08.396
<v Loretta Smith>Parks are not luxuries, but they are on the frontline infrastructure for public health, climate resiliency, and social connection.

1615
02:38:09.469 --> 02:38:14.822
<v Loretta Smith>And I believe delaying investment today could cost them far more investment tomorrow.

1616
02:38:15.638 --> 02:38:23.635
<v Loretta Smith>This levy protects access for children, seniors, and all Portlanders while preserving skilled jobs in critical sanitation.

1617
02:38:24.920 --> 02:38:34.843
<v Loretta Smith>Our parks are economic engines that help protect the value of the properties in the communities that they sit within.

1618
02:38:35.436 --> 02:38:48.539
<v Loretta Smith>And so I've listened to all of you, and I've listened to Portlanders, and I believe we would not ask for this increase if it was not necessary, critical, important.

1619
02:38:48.602 --> 02:38:48.796
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mayor.

1620
02:38:49.743 --> 02:39:02.737
<v Loretta Smith>Parks are the lifeblood to our communities, and this levy was designed to be targeted and subject to accountable stewardship by our partners at Portland Parks and Rec.

1621
02:39:03.701 --> 02:39:11.941
<v Loretta Smith>And I just believe that this is something that the community wants, and we have to deliver.

1622
02:39:12.728 --> 02:39:14.543
<v Loretta Smith>So I will be supporting the.

1623
02:39:16.091 --> 02:39:17.300
<v Loretta Smith>And thank you, Madam President.

1624
02:39:19.270 --> 02:39:20.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1625
02:39:22.146 --> 02:39:36.531
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, as a parent, a coach, a summer free-for-all fan, I have used parks a lot, and I see the uses a lot, and I see the need in our parks a lot, especially around bathrooms.

1626
02:39:38.250 --> 02:39:40.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Parks are part of what hold our community together.

1627
02:39:40.791 --> 02:39:41.818
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They keep people safe.

1628
02:39:41.931 --> 02:39:43.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They keep people healthy.

1629
02:39:43.680 --> 02:39:58.279
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They're places that we can connect our communities, provide our kids with natural areas close to home, regardless of income level or the amount of free time parents have, and that offer hundreds of hours of classes and programs each week.

1630
02:39:59.643 --> 02:40:08.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This continued funding will ensure that our park summer programs can continue, and it will begin to address Thank you.

1631
02:40:11.691 --> 02:40:23.295
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This measure gives us new accountability tools, things that we have asked for and that we have heard community members ask for, because our parks must be everything they are and more.

1632
02:40:24.209 --> 02:40:28.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And for too many neighborhoods, our parks start to feel like they are less and less.

1633
02:40:29.975 --> 02:40:32.784
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This measure will start to make a difference.

1634
02:40:33.302 --> 02:40:34.314
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In that accountability.

1635
02:40:35.308 --> 02:40:48.759
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Tonight I am excited to refer a ballot measure that I hope we can all get behind and that I think Portlanders can get excited about, one that balances the needs of our parks with our community's financial capacity.

1636
02:40:49.897 --> 02:40:53.092
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will do everything I can to make sure that this is a win for our city.

1637
02:40:54.166 --> 02:41:03.898
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope that you all join me in that, and Portlanders, I hope that you will join us in continuing to invest in our city, in our kids, and in our future.

1638
02:41:04.509 --> 02:41:07.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, thank you for being a part of this robust debate today.

1639
02:41:10.389 --> 02:41:11.115
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1640
02:41:12.439 --> 02:41:12.923
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1641
02:41:13.486 --> 02:41:24.235
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I really see this moment right now as an invitation to our entire community to join together in making sure our parks are able to exist and operate both now and in the future.

1642
02:41:24.605 --> 02:41:34.397
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I support this levy at a $1.40 rate as a smart investment, even at the same time as I acknowledge that it will not address every need for our beloved park system.

1643
02:41:35.233 --> 02:41:45.298
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How exactly these funds will be used equitably to benefit all of our communities is a really important issue that we will need to address and explain really clearly to the public.

1644
02:41:46.148 --> 02:41:54.254
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>For example, I'll be looking to see how these funds might impact the years-long backlog of removing the more than 20,000 barriers to our parks.

1645
02:41:54.319 --> 02:42:00.072
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Parks facilities that were identified in the 24— in 2014 as part of the city's ADA transition plan.

1646
02:42:01.002 --> 02:42:11.320
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I want the community to know that I commit, along with my colleagues, to holding all of us accountable to the stated intent of the use of the levy funds, and I look forward to a successful result.

1647
02:42:11.657 --> 02:42:22.747
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And finally, I want to share that with the newest park reopening in District 3, Berrydale Park, I look forward to enjoying a newly renovated and updated park that ensures a park that's safe and accessible for all.

1648
02:42:23.262 --> 02:42:29.340
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I want to invite everyone to join in the celebration on Friday, August 8th, from 3 to 5 PM.

1649
02:42:30.414 --> 02:42:32.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1650
02:42:32.323 --> 02:42:34.727
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, you may be closing us up today.

1651
02:42:34.888 --> 02:42:35.546
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, thank you.

1652
02:42:35.851 --> 02:42:37.037
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

1653
02:42:37.149 --> 02:42:41.993
<v Dan Ryan>First, I want to thank the many stakeholders who have been very active in this, putting this on the ballot.

1654
02:42:42.763 --> 02:42:44.527
<v Dan Ryan>We've had a lot of tension to get to this point.

1655
02:42:44.992 --> 02:42:49.122
<v Dan Ryan>I wasn't sure how we were going to quite land this, On this date, and no one got everything they wanted.

1656
02:42:49.605 --> 02:43:01.299
<v Dan Ryan>Special nod to the many conversations I've had with you, Council President, and you, Councilor Novick, in between some of those creative meetings that we, that we were all participating in.

1657
02:43:01.798 --> 02:43:12.638
<v Dan Ryan>I'm supportive of this parks levy, and although I initially had a hard time going above the 1.20 rate, knowing that we intend to address maintenance needs at a higher rate moved my thinking.

1658
02:43:12.750 --> 02:43:12.846
<v Elizabeth Milner>Thank you.

1659
02:43:13.476 --> 02:43:22.918
<v Dan Ryan>As did the willingness to join other big cities in the top 10 of parks around the nation to attract more revenue from philanthropic sector and more earned revenue connected to our rec programs.

1660
02:43:23.272 --> 02:43:28.049
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm thrilled with the crisp performance measures that we will bring forward.

1661
02:43:28.386 --> 02:43:39.834
<v Dan Ryan>I hope that all funding measures in fact become more crystal clear when we go to voters so they can track what success looks like and become— and that voters and taxpayers deserve this accountability.

1662
02:43:40.492 --> 02:43:45.742
<v Dan Ryan>I support obligating some of the levy funds to tackling a backlog of parks' deferred maintenance.

1663
02:43:45.950 --> 02:43:53.593
<v Dan Ryan>However, we know that the need is far greater than what is the reasonable levy is able to fund, and we need a plan for funding maintenance for the long term.

1664
02:43:53.834 --> 02:43:55.681
<v Dan Ryan>This entire council is committed to that.

1665
02:43:56.259 --> 02:44:04.558
<v Dan Ryan>I've been a vocal advocate for long-term planning to push legislation changes in the state to utilize SDC funding for maintenance of capital assets.

1666
02:44:04.913 --> 02:44:07.402
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Green, for your amendment.

1667
02:44:08.109 --> 02:44:20.975
<v Dan Ryan>It's clear that parks needs to undergo a cultural change and a transformation, including some structural changes, funding stabilization plan for the long term, and prioritizing core services the public expects.

1668
02:44:21.297 --> 02:44:26.565
<v Dan Ryan>I'm looking forward to starting this work immediately and so that we can regroup after the levy focus.

1669
02:44:27.158 --> 02:44:30.002
<v Dan Ryan>I will always be a champion for parks outreach and partnership development work.

1670
02:44:30.050 --> 02:44:30.147
<v Elizabeth Milner>Thank you.

1671
02:44:30.772 --> 02:44:32.343
<v Dan Ryan>Which really fell off the last few years.

1672
02:44:32.775 --> 02:44:45.279
<v Dan Ryan>They had a robust donor development partnership team prior to the last levy, and I want to revive that, which is why it's important to me that this position was included in this levy and that we'll have dedicated more to this work.

1673
02:44:45.439 --> 02:44:54.863
<v Dan Ryan>I hope to bring forward a proposal in the fall bump to find a second position to do that type of work so that we can achieve more funding stability for parks operations.

1674
02:44:55.457 --> 02:45:02.727
<v Dan Ryan>I'm so thankful that the North Portland Aquatic Center will stay in this levy to keep the promises the city has made previously to North Portlanders.

1675
02:45:03.240 --> 02:45:06.661
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm also thrilled to see the Old Town Skate Park is also included.

1676
02:45:07.157 --> 02:45:14.271
<v Dan Ryan>These are promises that were made dating back well prior to I joined the council in 2020, and we are now equipped to deliver.

1677
02:45:14.865 --> 02:45:23.295
<v Dan Ryan>Although it would have been ideal to resist— reset the culture change in parks and do some organizational shifting before we consider this levy, timing didn't allow for that.

1678
02:45:23.782 --> 02:45:29.233
<v Dan Ryan>I fully expect that after today, we'll start working on what our parks can look like in the future.

1679
02:45:31.819 --> 02:45:32.513
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1680
02:45:32.658 --> 02:45:38.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, seeing no other discussion or debate, Rebecca, can you please call the roll?

1681
02:45:39.199 --> 02:45:47.797
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'll note this is on passage of the final package of resolution as amended and attachments as submitted.

1682
02:45:49.033 --> 02:45:50.494
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Koyama Lane?

1683
02:45:50.911 --> 02:45:50.959
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1684
02:45:51.889 --> 02:45:52.611
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo?

1685
02:45:52.916 --> 02:45:52.965
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1686
02:45:53.735 --> 02:45:54.297
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

1687
02:45:54.441 --> 02:45:54.489
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1688
02:45:55.581 --> 02:45:55.950
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

1689
02:45:56.688 --> 02:45:56.736
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1690
02:45:57.843 --> 02:45:58.356
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1691
02:45:59.335 --> 02:45:59.432
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1692
02:46:00.459 --> 02:46:00.843
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

1693
02:46:01.983 --> 02:46:02.031
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1694
02:46:03.041 --> 02:46:03.490
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1695
02:46:04.309 --> 02:46:04.438
<v Jessica Green>Aye.

1696
02:46:05.064 --> 02:46:05.496
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

1697
02:46:06.877 --> 02:46:07.005
<v John Isaacs>Aye.

1698
02:46:07.840 --> 02:46:08.192
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

1699
02:46:09.123 --> 02:46:09.172
<v Laina Ala-Slaughter>Aye.

1700
02:46:10.085 --> 02:46:10.551
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

1701
02:46:10.808 --> 02:46:10.856
<v Karen Chi Ray>Aye.

1702
02:46:11.707 --> 02:46:12.236
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

1703
02:46:13.376 --> 02:46:13.504
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1704
02:46:14.659 --> 02:46:18.815
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the resolution is adopted with 11 Aye votes and adopted as amended.

1705
02:46:19.728 --> 02:46:20.819
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, colleagues.

1706
02:46:20.916 --> 02:46:24.381
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This was the only order of business on our agenda today.

1707
02:46:25.167 --> 02:46:32.370
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am going to adjourn our special meeting and we will be back here at 6 o'clock for our regular council meeting.

