WEBVTT

1
00:04:17.327 --> 00:04:19.476
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good evening, everybody.

2
00:04:20.071 --> 00:04:24.336
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are beginning today with a pre-gavel from Councilor Kanal.

3
00:04:24.625 --> 00:04:31.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is not part of our formal agenda, but it is part of our livestream and an important part of our evening together tonight.

4
00:04:32.658 --> 00:04:40.004
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This will be about 10 minutes, and after that we will open up our formal meeting.

5
00:04:40.180 --> 00:04:42.137
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, I will pass it off to you.

6
00:04:43.163 --> 00:04:44.204
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

7
00:04:44.831 --> 00:04:50.762
<v Sameer Kanal>I am proud to sponsor today's pre-gavel in celebration and observance of National Public Safety Telecommunicators Week.

8
00:04:51.324 --> 00:04:56.278
<v Sameer Kanal>Our 911 call takers and dispatchers are our city's first first responders.

9
00:04:56.870 --> 00:05:03.492
<v Sameer Kanal>They are the lifeline and reassuring voice in an emergency for both our community members and our public safety responders on the scene.

10
00:05:04.310 --> 00:05:11.877
<v Sameer Kanal>Our 911 centers are staffed with hardworking, skilled, and highly trained people 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year.

11
00:05:11.940 --> 00:05:12.036
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

12
00:05:12.149 --> 00:05:19.389
<v Sameer Kanal>My policy advisor and I recently had the privilege of being hosted for a 911 sit-along at the Bureau of Emergency Communications, or BOEC.

13
00:05:19.389 --> 00:05:22.129
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to thank our hosts Taylor, Courtney, and Amanda.

14
00:05:22.129 --> 00:05:31.949
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for all your valuable work and for patient explanations for my staff and I. Portland's 911 center also answers calls for more than just the city of Portland.

15
00:05:32.040 --> 00:05:36.620
<v Sameer Kanal>We answer for all of Multnomah County, including Gresham, Troutdale, Fairview, and Maywood Park.

16
00:05:36.870 --> 00:05:40.889
<v Sameer Kanal>And to anyone listening out there who'd like to join the BOEC team, recruitment is opening in May.

17
00:05:40.889 --> 00:05:42.170
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll save you the time, Director.

18
00:05:42.170 --> 00:05:49.098
<v Unidentified speaker>You can go to Portland.gov/911/workfor911 to learn more.

19
00:05:49.228 --> 00:05:51.504
<v Sameer Kanal>911 Is also part of a larger response network.

20
00:05:51.682 --> 00:05:56.153
<v Sameer Kanal>Many know that I'm passionate about that response ecosystem as co-chair of the Community and Public Safety Committee.

21
00:05:56.653 --> 00:06:08.283
<v Sameer Kanal>Director Cossi, who we're going to introduce in a moment, famously says that they're the Bureau of Emergencies, not non-emergencies, and launched the first-ever transition to move some of the non-emergency calls to 311.

22
00:06:08.559 --> 00:06:13.802
<v Sameer Kanal>And in the face of limited resources and national staffing shortages, it's essential that we ensure the right response.

23
00:06:13.850 --> 00:06:13.964
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

24
00:06:14.391 --> 00:06:18.533
<v Sameer Kanal>Is dispatched at the right time to reduce the burden on 911 and its call takers.

25
00:06:19.127 --> 00:06:21.567
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm grateful for Director Cossi's leadership on that.

26
00:06:21.951 --> 00:06:26.879
<v Sameer Kanal>So with that, I'll pass it over to Director Cossi and Carolyn Welch, Senior Dispatcher and PPA Workgroup Leader.

27
00:06:27.216 --> 00:06:33.701
<v Sameer Kanal>Following that, we'll have remarks from Community and Public Safety Committee Co-Chair Steve Novick, as well as Councilors Loretta Smith and Jamie Dunphy.

28
00:06:34.617 --> 00:06:35.949
<v Sameer Kanal>Welcome, Director Cossi and Carolyn.

29
00:06:36.463 --> 00:06:36.702
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

30
00:06:36.783 --> 00:06:38.244
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

31
00:06:38.309 --> 00:06:40.877
<v Unidentified speaker>It's really a privilege being here tonight.

32
00:06:41.374 --> 00:06:43.925
<v Unidentified speaker>Madam President, and City Council.

33
00:06:44.101 --> 00:06:52.216
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Bob Causey, Director of the Bureau of Emergency Communications, and this week is National Public Safety Telecommunicators Appreciation Week.

34
00:06:52.488 --> 00:06:53.130
<v Unidentified speaker>That's a mouthful.

35
00:06:53.548 --> 00:07:04.516
<v Unidentified speaker>We call it NTW for short, National Telecommunicators Week, and we at BOEC greatly appreciate being recognized for the important life-saving work that we do every day.

36
00:07:05.014 --> 00:07:09.391
<v Unidentified speaker>Our call takers and dispatchers are the first First responders.

37
00:07:10.144 --> 00:07:11.795
<v Unidentified speaker>They care deeply about our community.

38
00:07:12.629 --> 00:07:21.045
<v Unidentified speaker>They are the calm voice during a caller's worst day, and they have a tremendous impact on our collective welfare.

39
00:07:22.473 --> 00:07:24.892
<v Unidentified speaker>I brought one of our telecommunicators here with me today.

40
00:07:25.454 --> 00:07:27.826
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd like to introduce Senior Dispatcher Carolyn Welch.

41
00:07:28.420 --> 00:07:29.589
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening.

42
00:07:30.567 --> 00:07:31.641
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Carolyn Welch.

43
00:07:31.706 --> 00:07:34.271
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a senior dispatcher at Boeck.

44
00:07:34.654 --> 00:07:38.101
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Knall, for inviting me to speak at the pre-gavel.

45
00:07:38.439 --> 00:07:39.928
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to represent the group of call takers.

46
00:07:40.009 --> 00:07:40.170
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Deputy City Administrator Priya Dhanapal.

47
00:07:40.170 --> 00:07:46.089
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm one of the emergency telecommunicators and dispatchers that serve Portland and the greater Multnomah County at the Bureau of Emergency Communications.

48
00:07:46.370 --> 00:07:52.069
<v Unidentified speaker>It is an honor to be here today while we celebrate National Public Safety Telecommunicator Week.

49
00:07:52.069 --> 00:08:00.259
<v Unidentified speaker>It is true that we show up 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, regardless of what is happening within our community, our personal lives, or even the weather.

50
00:08:00.449 --> 00:08:05.209
<v Unidentified speaker>It is a calling that requires diligent effort to maintain a positive work-life balance.

51
00:08:05.310 --> 00:08:13.548
<v Unidentified speaker>Being exposed to the daily traumas of the community can have an impact on not only us as individuals, But on our families as well as our loved ones.

52
00:08:14.062 --> 00:08:20.228
<v Unidentified speaker>We appreciate Councilor Kanal for inviting us today and all of you for taking the time to recognize and celebrate the work we do.

53
00:08:20.805 --> 00:08:27.966
<v Unidentified speaker>We're also thankful for the support of our union, the Portland Police Association, as well as our partnership with BOEC's leadership and City Labor Relations.

54
00:08:28.754 --> 00:08:36.124
<v Unidentified speaker>Last but not least, we could not successfully do the work that we do without strong working relationships with the other entities we serve alongside police.

55
00:08:36.220 --> 00:08:36.428
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

56
00:08:37.201 --> 00:08:43.548
<v Unidentified speaker>Fire, AMR, Corrections, Road and Maintenance Workers, and the countless other labor groups within the city and county.

57
00:08:44.032 --> 00:08:48.894
<v Unidentified speaker>Once again, on behalf of our membership, thank you and happy National Telecommunicators Week.

58
00:08:52.866 --> 00:08:58.322
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

59
00:08:58.370 --> 00:09:00.945
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we are turning to your co-chair next, is that correct?

60
00:09:01.470 --> 00:09:02.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

61
00:09:05.000 --> 00:09:08.580
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to express my amazement at the job you do.

62
00:09:09.466 --> 00:09:22.514
<v Steve Novick>I mean, like you said, you're dealing with people in incredible stress, incredibly emotional situations, and it's your job to get them the help they need as quickly as possible and get off the phone as quickly as possible.

63
00:09:22.562 --> 00:09:24.355
<v Steve Novick>And most of the time you don't know what happened.

64
00:09:25.649 --> 00:09:32.408
<v Steve Novick>So it's always seemed to me like your job requires the technical skill of an air traffic controller and the emotional resilience of, I don't know, Meryl Streep.

65
00:09:34.769 --> 00:09:42.807
<v Steve Novick>Um, it just seems to be just— it, it must be an— I mean, it, it just amazes me that people can do this job day after day, year after year.

66
00:09:42.969 --> 00:09:45.048
<v Steve Novick>So I just wanted to say thank you so, so much.

67
00:09:45.128 --> 00:09:45.980
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

68
00:09:48.345 --> 00:09:49.116
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

69
00:09:50.500 --> 00:09:50.982
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

70
00:09:51.224 --> 00:09:53.380
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam, Madam Chair.

71
00:09:54.225 --> 00:09:55.961
<v Loretta Smith>Um, my name is Loretta Smith.

72
00:09:56.009 --> 00:09:57.374
<v Loretta Smith>I'm from District 1.

73
00:09:57.504 --> 00:10:10.649
<v Loretta Smith>I'm one of the 3 councilors, and I want to say It is so good to see you and to know that there are individuals and neighbors who are, um, working at 911.

74
00:10:11.225 --> 00:10:17.782
<v Loretta Smith>And you are those heroes who wear headsets and you play a critical role in our emergency response system.

75
00:10:18.455 --> 00:10:27.399
<v Loretta Smith>And I strongly support the well-paying jobs, Director Calzi, and I believe that telecommunications is a viable career path Thank you.

76
00:10:28.298 --> 00:10:33.250
<v Loretta Smith>Especially for those who are brave and committed and dedicated to serving their community.

77
00:10:34.485 --> 00:10:44.664
<v Loretta Smith>The jobs that you offer are a pathway for young people and those without a college degree to earn a very good wage, nearly $32 an hour.

78
00:10:45.787 --> 00:10:53.546
<v Loretta Smith>It's hard, it's, it's hard to look at it as work, but for those who answer the call, you will receive competitive benefits Yes.

79
00:10:54.027 --> 00:11:01.768
<v Loretta Smith>And you will be able to have the, um, the knowledge and the professional development that they offer.

80
00:11:02.601 --> 00:11:06.769
<v Loretta Smith>Director Bob Casi, I want to take a moment to recognize you and your leadership.

81
00:11:07.426 --> 00:11:24.195
<v Loretta Smith>You oversaw the Bureau of Emergency Communications, BOEC, during the height of the pandemic when there was a hiring freeze and citywide demonstrations while calls and volumes of calls reached record highs and staffing levels suffered, but you prevailed.

82
00:11:25.125 --> 00:11:28.000
<v Loretta Smith>This was not just a local issue in Portland.

83
00:11:28.176 --> 00:11:31.211
<v Loretta Smith>It was part of a national 911 staffing shortage.

84
00:11:32.190 --> 00:11:34.839
<v Loretta Smith>Yet, Bob, you managed to turn things around.

85
00:11:35.881 --> 00:11:41.725
<v Loretta Smith>Under your direction, you increased the training division, expanded training academies, and resolved our staffing.

86
00:11:42.254 --> 00:11:44.166
<v Loretta Smith>So I want to say kudos to you.

87
00:11:44.792 --> 00:11:48.548
<v Loretta Smith>And as a result, call response times, they have dramatically improved.

88
00:11:48.660 --> 00:11:48.788
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

89
00:11:49.485 --> 00:11:53.235
<v Loretta Smith>For 30 years, you have dedicated your career to emergency communications.

90
00:11:53.494 --> 00:11:57.405
<v Loretta Smith>Your leadership centered on care and compassion.

91
00:11:58.163 --> 00:12:01.860
<v Loretta Smith>It sets the tone and the stage for exceptional staff that you lead.

92
00:12:02.442 --> 00:12:10.528
<v Loretta Smith>You have left a lasting impact on Oregon's largest 911 system center and on every life that you have helped to save.

93
00:12:11.173 --> 00:12:11.996
<v Loretta Smith>So I thank you.

94
00:12:12.125 --> 00:12:14.480
<v Loretta Smith>It is an honor to know you and to watch you work.

95
00:12:14.876 --> 00:12:15.375
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

96
00:12:18.918 --> 00:12:22.446
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

97
00:12:22.702 --> 00:12:26.081
<v Sameer Kanal>Dr. Qazi, to your whole team, just sincerely thank you.

98
00:12:26.971 --> 00:12:37.278
<v Sameer Kanal>Anyone who's lived in Portland in the last few years has known that our 911 system has been under serious stress, serious understaffing, and it's led to some really tough results for our community.

99
00:12:38.179 --> 00:12:46.600
<v Sameer Kanal>People are calling you on the worst days of their lives, every single day, all day, and the people who you have answering the phones are dedicated professionals who are doing their absolute Thank you.

100
00:12:46.600 --> 00:12:46.600
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mayor.

101
00:12:46.600 --> 00:12:47.899
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to thank all of our city employees for doing their absolute best.

102
00:12:47.899 --> 00:12:54.919
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks to the leadership of you and your team, we're seeing the increased call times decrease.

103
00:12:54.919 --> 00:12:56.659
<v Sameer Kanal>We're seeing better call time responses.

104
00:12:56.659 --> 00:12:58.399
<v Sameer Kanal>We're seeing better service for the community.

105
00:12:58.659 --> 00:13:08.110
<v Sameer Kanal>And it is reinstilling that sense of confidence in our system to be able to be there when people call on the worst days of their lives.

106
00:13:08.399 --> 00:13:18.673
<v Sameer Kanal>So thank you to all of your teams for being such an important part of the first responder system and for Thank you.

107
00:13:18.736 --> 00:13:27.015
<v Unidentified speaker>I would like to mention that, you know, our folks like Carolyn and so many others at BOEC, they're the ones doing most of the heavy lifting.

108
00:13:27.065 --> 00:13:32.860
<v Unidentified speaker>So I really want to lift them up because it is Telecommunicator Week after all, and I'm so proud of my team.

109
00:13:33.038 --> 00:13:33.361
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

110
00:13:35.774 --> 00:13:36.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Director.

111
00:13:38.927 --> 00:13:39.898
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, thank you.

112
00:13:40.091 --> 00:13:44.249
<v Unidentified speaker>I just wanted to take a moment, Director Costi, to acknowledge your vulnerability earlier today.

113
00:13:45.336 --> 00:13:54.272
<v Unidentified speaker>And I really took your comments to heart when your staff levels were low and the calls were at a peak and you had to force overtime.

114
00:13:54.576 --> 00:13:55.445
<v Unidentified speaker>That was your reality.

115
00:13:56.038 --> 00:13:59.846
<v Unidentified speaker>And I can only imagine that the shame that you mentioned was real.

116
00:14:00.442 --> 00:14:05.471
<v Unidentified speaker>I remember going out there over 2 years ago and spending— I don't think you could get rid of me, it was so exciting.

117
00:14:05.583 --> 00:14:10.275
<v Unidentified speaker>And I was there for 2 hours and just really want to hold your team for, for hanging in there.

118
00:14:10.340 --> 00:14:10.548
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

119
00:14:10.822 --> 00:14:21.328
<v Unidentified speaker>Those of you that have hung in there, you inspired me on that 2-hour visit back then, 2 years ago, when it was kind of at the peak, and you continue to inspire me and make me proud today.

120
00:14:21.568 --> 00:14:24.697
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you, and I really appreciate you being vulnerable earlier today.

121
00:14:25.226 --> 00:14:26.927
<v Unidentified speaker>Happy, happy week.

122
00:14:27.086 --> 00:14:27.922
<v Unidentified speaker>Happy celebration.

123
00:14:28.225 --> 00:14:29.028
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

124
00:14:30.375 --> 00:14:36.407
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Carolyn, please do make sure that your colleagues know how much we all appreciate the work that you do.

125
00:14:36.486 --> 00:14:38.058
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, would you like to close?

126
00:14:38.556 --> 00:14:39.614
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thank you so much.

127
00:14:40.078 --> 00:14:51.412
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just want to recognize also that the entire bureau was recognized at the Association of Public Safety Communications Officials, APCO, Western Regional Conference, which was hosted here in Portland in March.

128
00:14:51.476 --> 00:14:53.753
<v Sameer Kanal>I had the privilege of hearing your talk, Director Casi, there.

129
00:14:54.763 --> 00:14:58.883
<v Sameer Kanal>The Deputy Director of BOEC, Steve Maudsley, is the conference co-chair as well.

130
00:14:59.235 --> 00:15:08.163
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also just want to say I learned more in a couple hours than I could have possibly imagined from Taylor and Courtney while we were there.

131
00:15:08.403 --> 00:15:09.767
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I really appreciate that.

132
00:15:09.831 --> 00:15:09.927
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

133
00:15:10.296 --> 00:15:14.729
<v Sameer Kanal>And with that, I will close out this free gavel and pass it back to the president.

134
00:15:14.873 --> 00:15:15.129
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

135
00:15:15.515 --> 00:15:15.852
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

136
00:15:16.173 --> 00:15:17.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both for being here.

137
00:15:18.181 --> 00:15:19.577
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

138
00:15:20.413 --> 00:15:26.259
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I will open our official council meeting for this evening.

139
00:15:26.370 --> 00:15:30.241
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is April 16th at 6:11 PM.

140
00:15:30.932 --> 00:15:33.999
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we have a very full agenda.

141
00:15:34.706 --> 00:15:37.259
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a number of contentious items.

142
00:15:37.613 --> 00:15:44.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a number of things on the agenda that your colleagues have brought amendments for.

143
00:15:45.322 --> 00:15:51.376
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So it is going to be a long evening, possibly at times a heated evening.

144
00:15:52.052 --> 00:16:05.575
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just want to make sure that we all are ready to be as concise as possible and move things through while also taking the time that we need to have the conversations that are important to move this process forward.

145
00:16:05.639 --> 00:16:19.621
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And To folks who are here watching and are going to be with us through a long evening, please know that we do this because we were asked to have conversations in public, and we know that sometimes that's hard, but it is really important.

146
00:16:19.769 --> 00:16:20.994
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's a critical part of the work.

147
00:16:22.970 --> 00:16:24.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

148
00:16:25.570 --> 00:16:25.863
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

149
00:16:26.238 --> 00:16:26.351
<v Candace Avalos>Here.

150
00:16:26.644 --> 00:16:27.004
<v Steve Novick>Here.

151
00:16:28.779 --> 00:16:29.057
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

152
00:16:32.275 --> 00:16:32.953
<v Steve Novick>Here.

153
00:16:33.970 --> 00:16:34.227
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

154
00:16:35.453 --> 00:16:35.857
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

155
00:16:35.986 --> 00:16:36.148
<v Candace Avalos>Here.

156
00:16:36.471 --> 00:16:36.857
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

157
00:16:37.034 --> 00:16:37.308
<v Unidentified speaker>Present.

158
00:16:37.841 --> 00:16:38.148
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

159
00:16:38.260 --> 00:16:38.583
<v Unidentified speaker>Here.

160
00:16:38.760 --> 00:16:39.019
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith.

161
00:16:40.018 --> 00:16:40.452
<v Keelan McClymont>Here.

162
00:16:41.562 --> 00:16:41.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

163
00:16:42.753 --> 00:16:46.501
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Mr. Taylor, could you please read our rules of order and decorum?

164
00:16:48.456 --> 00:16:49.991
<v Sameer Kanal>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

165
00:16:50.799 --> 00:16:57.735
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council.

166
00:17:02.567 --> 00:17:06.866
<v Unidentified speaker>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

167
00:17:07.861 --> 00:17:12.239
<v Unidentified speaker>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

168
00:17:13.314 --> 00:17:15.863
<v Unidentified speaker>The microphone will be muted when your time is over.

169
00:17:17.163 --> 00:17:19.086
<v Unidentified speaker>The presiding officer preserves order.

170
00:17:19.711 --> 00:17:29.990
<v Unidentified speaker>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, Or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

171
00:17:31.577 --> 00:17:34.092
<v Unidentified speaker>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

172
00:17:35.079 --> 00:17:37.670
<v Unidentified speaker>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

173
00:17:38.868 --> 00:17:42.352
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

174
00:17:43.490 --> 00:17:47.036
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

175
00:17:48.470 --> 00:17:50.726
<v Unidentified speaker>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

176
00:17:51.613 --> 00:17:54.218
<v Unidentified speaker>When testifying, please state your name for the record.

177
00:17:54.768 --> 00:17:56.208
<v Unidentified speaker>Your address is not necessary.

178
00:17:57.099 --> 00:18:00.528
<v Unidentified speaker>If you are a lobbyist, please identify the organization you represent.

179
00:18:01.578 --> 00:18:06.154
<v Unidentified speaker>Virtual testifiers should please unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

180
00:18:06.559 --> 00:18:06.945
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

181
00:18:11.826 --> 00:18:12.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

182
00:18:12.453 --> 00:18:15.498
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first item on our agenda is agenda approval.

183
00:18:16.170 --> 00:18:19.603
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any Requests to amend the agenda?

184
00:18:24.430 --> 00:18:27.340
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, do we have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

185
00:18:30.323 --> 00:18:30.784
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great.

186
00:18:34.814 --> 00:18:37.156
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next item on the agenda is public comment.

187
00:18:37.400 --> 00:18:40.535
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please invite up the folks who are here with us tonight?

188
00:18:41.789 --> 00:18:43.404
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Addie Smith.

189
00:18:49.045 --> 00:18:50.402
<v Keelan McClymont>Addie is joining us online.

190
00:18:52.059 --> 00:18:52.542
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Addie.

191
00:18:52.654 --> 00:18:54.314
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please introduce yourself and go right ahead.

192
00:18:55.070 --> 00:18:59.965
<v Loretta Smith>Hi, my name is Addie Smith, and as you guys can see, I'm at your old meeting place.

193
00:19:00.143 --> 00:19:01.253
<v Loretta Smith>I went to the wrong place.

194
00:19:01.414 --> 00:19:07.865
<v Loretta Smith>I wanted to be there in person to deliver this message, but, uh, I'm at your old office, so whatever.

195
00:19:08.573 --> 00:19:10.712
<v Loretta Smith>Um, today's April 16th, 2025.

196
00:19:11.616 --> 00:19:23.486
<v Loretta Smith>Today I'm speaking before the Portland City Council, and I'm speaking about problematic Portland as well as the state of Oregon, and that landlords and attorneys and judges in Multnomah County are violating House Bill 2001.

197
00:19:23.903 --> 00:19:28.304
<v Loretta Smith>Before I begin, I want to address something that has been circulating across this country.

198
00:19:28.801 --> 00:19:37.314
<v Loretta Smith>I want people to know that Democrats in Oregon have done the same thing to African American men and women that Trump administration is doing to Kilmar Abrego-Garcia.

199
00:19:37.362 --> 00:20:07.839
<v Loretta Smith>Councilmember While innocent African American men and women aren't being sent yet to El Salvador, they are being incarcerated for crimes they didn't commit and are spending lengths of time in jail, either awaiting sentencing or being sentenced to jail time after proving their innocence by racist judges like Ricardo Montaka, Kathleen Proctor, Eric Boucher, Brandon Thompson, and Judge Andrew Irwin, who gives attorneys and judges probation after they've been convicted of either watching child porn or selling child pornography.

200
00:20:07.839 --> 00:20:07.880
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember Herbold.

201
00:20:09.262 --> 00:20:11.076
<v Loretta Smith>Or participating in child porn.

202
00:20:11.992 --> 00:20:21.115
<v Loretta Smith>These judges are in Washington County Circuit Court, but the racism and discrimination and violations of the laws of the state of Oregon are being executed by judges throughout the state with impunity.

203
00:20:21.628 --> 00:20:32.230
<v Loretta Smith>They aren't being held accountable for violating the laws of the state or the laws and rights of the defendants who come before them, oftentimes due to absolutely no investigation by police and deputies in this state.

204
00:20:32.695 --> 00:20:41.130
<v Unidentified speaker>African-American young men are languishing in jail for years in Oregon for crimes they didn't commit, and Governor Tina Kotek does absolutely nothing about it.

205
00:20:41.371 --> 00:20:47.223
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe nationally it is time for us African Americans to leave the Democratic Party— the Democrat Party.

206
00:20:47.818 --> 00:20:53.278
<v Loretta Smith>I don't believe— I don't mean leave this party to be part of the Republican Party or part of the Green Party.

207
00:20:53.695 --> 00:20:58.390
<v Unidentified speaker>It is time for us to establish our own party while Trump is burning this country down.

208
00:20:58.859 --> 00:20:59.913
<v Loretta Smith>It's not just Oregon.

209
00:21:00.238 --> 00:21:03.823
<v Loretta Smith>A Democrat-led state that innocent African Americans are languishing in jails.

210
00:21:03.903 --> 00:21:08.134
<v Loretta Smith>It's also Washington State, California, New York, all Democrat-led states.

211
00:21:08.536 --> 00:21:17.480
<v Loretta Smith>These same states wherein Democrats are seemingly outraged that Trump has sent innocent people to El Salvador but are silent when judges and police do it in their own states.

212
00:21:17.913 --> 00:21:25.928
<v Unidentified speaker>In Oregon, African Americans make up less than 2% of the demographic, so the politicians don't care about our votes because they don't impact the electorate.

213
00:21:26.232 --> 00:21:31.778
<v Loretta Smith>But nationally, our votes Determined House, Senate seats, judges, and the presidency.

214
00:21:32.324 --> 00:21:34.663
<v Loretta Smith>31.78% Of people voted for Trump.

215
00:21:34.824 --> 00:21:37.628
<v Loretta Smith>30.84% People voted for Kamala Harris.

216
00:21:38.013 --> 00:21:40.433
<v Loretta Smith>36.33% Of people did not vote.

217
00:21:40.835 --> 00:21:42.566
<v Unidentified speaker>1% Of the people voted third party.

218
00:21:42.823 --> 00:21:48.336
<v Loretta Smith>While the majority of people voted for some— someone other than Trump, that 30%—.

219
00:21:48.432 --> 00:21:55.356
<v Unidentified speaker>36% Of people who stayed home did so because Kamala Harris refused to stop sending bombs and money to Israel to commit genocide.

220
00:21:55.404 --> 00:22:00.410
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember Once again, Democrats are hurting Black and brown people and still expecting our vote.

221
00:22:00.878 --> 00:22:00.992
<v Loretta Smith>Why?

222
00:22:01.866 --> 00:22:02.935
<v Loretta Smith>Because Trump is so much worse?

223
00:22:03.809 --> 00:22:06.267
<v Unidentified speaker>It is time for African Americans to leave the Democrat Party.

224
00:22:06.492 --> 00:22:09.628
<v Loretta Smith>Our rights under the law, our children, our lives, our neighborhoods—.

225
00:22:10.049 --> 00:22:10.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Abby, thank you.

226
00:22:11.133 --> 00:22:14.705
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm so sorry, but we need to make sure to stay on time tonight.

227
00:22:14.770 --> 00:22:16.213
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here though with us.

228
00:22:18.682 --> 00:22:21.327
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Audrey Zunkel de Corsi.

229
00:22:25.498 --> 00:22:26.064
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Audrey.

230
00:22:26.161 --> 00:22:27.211
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please introduce yourself.

231
00:22:27.922 --> 00:22:29.683
<v Angelita Morillo>Hello, um, good evening.

232
00:22:29.797 --> 00:22:34.128
<v Angelita Morillo>My name is Audrey Zunkel-Dekorzy, and I am speaking tonight as a private citizen.

233
00:22:35.400 --> 00:22:38.126
<v Angelita Morillo>I am before you to address the Leaf Day program.

234
00:22:39.359 --> 00:22:41.811
<v Angelita Morillo>PBOT, it's time to turn over a new leaf.

235
00:22:44.637 --> 00:22:45.432
<v Angelita Morillo>I know that's cheesy.

236
00:22:45.595 --> 00:22:55.182
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, um, at a moment of tight budgets and at a moment of newly unified administration of city services, this is the moment to reset How our city does fall leaf sweeping.

237
00:22:55.839 --> 00:23:05.346
<v Angelita Morillo>For some quick background, 5 years ago I lived in a house with one street tree that dumped its leaves by Labor Day, so when our leaf day rolled around, around Thanksgiving, it was not so helpful.

238
00:23:05.875 --> 00:23:10.859
<v Angelita Morillo>Then 3 years ago we moved all of 11 blocks away to a block not covered by leaf day.

239
00:23:11.325 --> 00:23:15.958
<v Angelita Morillo>I now have 5 mature maples lining the street, and I get to rake the street leaves myself.

240
00:23:17.175 --> 00:23:25.126
<v Angelita Morillo>We live on a greenway, so thousands of cyclists ride past every day contending with slippery wet leaves all fall and winter.

241
00:23:25.656 --> 00:23:27.388
<v Angelita Morillo>And spring, they're still there.

242
00:23:28.560 --> 00:23:38.635
<v Angelita Morillo>I submitted my written testimony earlier today to you by email, including photos as evidence of what the streets look like along this route— caked with mush, slippery, and unsafe.

243
00:23:39.711 --> 00:23:50.732
<v Angelita Morillo>2 Elementary school bike buses roll along that very same slippery street, and up in the balcony you can see 2 of the wonderful kids who ride their bikes to school along this unswept, leafy bike route.

244
00:23:52.767 --> 00:23:55.657
<v Angelita Morillo>Vice President Tiffany rode with us one of those days.

245
00:23:56.973 --> 00:23:58.940
<v Angelita Morillo>This is unfair and it is inequitable.

246
00:23:59.750 --> 00:24:05.606
<v Angelita Morillo>I also submitted as evidence the map of the leaf day zones where you can see which neighborhoods are covered and which are not.

247
00:24:06.092 --> 00:24:07.742
<v Angelita Morillo>There is not one in District 1.

248
00:24:09.565 --> 00:24:10.192
<v Angelita Morillo>We can do better.

249
00:24:11.010 --> 00:24:13.388
<v Angelita Morillo>So let's have urban forestry talk with PBOT.

250
00:24:13.823 --> 00:24:20.042
<v Angelita Morillo>Can Portland meet our goals of expanding Portland's tree canopy if we're only sweeping the leaves from the trees in some neighborhoods?

251
00:24:21.222 --> 00:24:34.848
<v Angelita Morillo>It was one thing when residents paid for the leaf day, $15 a year, I think, but now it's free, which means I am paying taxes to fund someone else getting a service I don't, and this is mostly benefiting wealthier neighborhoods.

252
00:24:35.714 --> 00:24:46.519
<v Angelita Morillo>Every Portland neighborhood deserves to have its streets swept, but if budget cuts mean we can't sweep everywhere, then we should prioritize bike routes and safe routes to schools, or rotate.

253
00:24:46.873 --> 00:24:49.329
<v Angelita Morillo>Every year, there's different solutions.

254
00:24:50.164 --> 00:24:54.630
<v Angelita Morillo>There's lots of ways we can make our streets safer for bikers, especially our youngest riders.

255
00:24:54.742 --> 00:24:58.967
<v Angelita Morillo>I support the 500 is Plenty initiative to reduce car traffic on greenways.

256
00:24:59.497 --> 00:25:03.785
<v Angelita Morillo>Street sweeping would be another way to make bike travel safer in every part of our city.

257
00:25:04.619 --> 00:25:07.640
<v Angelita Morillo>Maybe this can be partly funded by PSF even.

258
00:25:08.329 --> 00:25:12.057
<v Angelita Morillo>So I want to thank city workers who clean our streets, who might be worrying about their jobs.

259
00:25:12.184 --> 00:25:13.212
<v Angelita Morillo>Their work is important.

260
00:25:13.277 --> 00:25:15.269
<v Angelita Morillo>We have plenty of work for them to do.

261
00:25:16.025 --> 00:25:21.125
<v Angelita Morillo>I will submit my letter also to Mr. Jordan in hopes he can direct reconsideration of this program.

262
00:25:21.190 --> 00:25:23.125
<v Angelita Morillo>And I want to thank you for your attention on this.

263
00:25:23.271 --> 00:25:25.261
<v Angelita Morillo>You have so many important things on your plate.

264
00:25:25.638 --> 00:25:26.211
<v Angelita Morillo>We see you.

265
00:25:26.441 --> 00:25:27.455
<v Angelita Morillo>You're working hard.

266
00:25:27.603 --> 00:25:28.814
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you so much for your service.

267
00:25:31.147 --> 00:25:32.123
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

268
00:25:33.950 --> 00:25:35.442
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Jeff Weitzel.

269
00:25:43.305 --> 00:25:43.866
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Jeff.

270
00:25:44.044 --> 00:25:45.699
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please introduce yourself and go right ahead.

271
00:25:46.356 --> 00:25:48.269
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, my name is Jeffrey Weitzel.

272
00:25:49.087 --> 00:25:53.071
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilors, President Pirtle-Guiney, thank you for the opportunity to speak today.

273
00:25:54.244 --> 00:26:02.855
<v Unidentified speaker>My friends, if more Portlanders were biking around our city instead of driving for their daily trips, it would be to Portland's great benefit.

274
00:26:03.722 --> 00:26:08.269
<v Unidentified speaker>Cleaner air, less congested roads, fewer lives lost in car crashes.

275
00:26:08.782 --> 00:26:10.919
<v Unidentified speaker>We'd also have fewer potholes.

276
00:26:11.657 --> 00:26:19.317
<v Unidentified speaker>Bikes need much less road space than cars, and they do barely any damage to pavement, so our roads budget would go much, much farther.

277
00:26:20.410 --> 00:26:23.107
<v Unidentified speaker>None of this is news to the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

278
00:26:23.733 --> 00:26:32.198
<v Unidentified speaker>Since 2009, a key planning goal in Portland has been that a full quarter of commute trips be by bike by 2030.

279
00:26:33.498 --> 00:26:50.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Despite this laudable foresight, Despite Portland's world-famous bicycle culture, the number of cyclists recorded in PBOT's annual bicycle count fell almost every year from 2014 to 2022, and we are still 46% down from the peak.

280
00:26:51.686 --> 00:26:56.237
<v Unidentified speaker>Here in the bicycle capital of North America, something has gone terribly wrong.

281
00:26:57.535 --> 00:26:59.682
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilors, this is now in your hands.

282
00:27:00.852 --> 00:27:10.186
<v Unidentified speaker>If we want the clean air, safe streets, and well-maintained pavement promised by thousands of Portlanders trading their cars for bikes, something must change.

283
00:27:11.407 --> 00:27:17.894
<v Unidentified speaker>Our 2035 Transportation System Plan imagines streets with almost as many bikes on them as cars.

284
00:27:18.505 --> 00:27:25.843
<v Unidentified speaker>If we're serious about that, and we should be, we must make our streets as welcoming to bikes as they are to cars.

285
00:27:26.662 --> 00:27:32.715
<v Unidentified speaker>Any rider from 8 years old to 88 should have the ability to bicycle anywhere in the city without fear.

286
00:27:32.779 --> 00:27:32.876
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

287
00:27:33.887 --> 00:27:39.009
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are different streets than we have today and a different city, a better city.

288
00:27:40.406 --> 00:27:45.800
<v Unidentified speaker>This year of budget crisis happens to be the perfect time to get things moving in the right direction.

289
00:27:46.813 --> 00:27:50.169
<v Unidentified speaker>Cyclists feel safer and happier with other cyclists.

290
00:27:50.826 --> 00:27:52.689
<v Unidentified speaker>This offers us a virtuous circle.

291
00:27:53.234 --> 00:28:01.969
<v Unidentified speaker>Tempt 1,000 new riders onto their bikes with inexpensive measures like commuter bike buses and flower pots on greenways to slow and divert cars.

292
00:28:02.467 --> 00:28:07.155
<v Unidentified speaker>And the next 1,000 bikers will come easier, and the 1,000 after that easier still.

293
00:28:08.103 --> 00:28:13.176
<v Unidentified speaker>Attend to this virtuous circle and you can build up a lot of forward momentum on the cheap.

294
00:28:14.188 --> 00:28:16.772
<v Unidentified speaker>PCF grants could buy us even more.

295
00:28:18.041 --> 00:28:21.060
<v Unidentified speaker>My friends, Portland loves bikes.

296
00:28:21.654 --> 00:28:22.376
<v Unidentified speaker>We all know that.

297
00:28:23.259 --> 00:28:27.178
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe that someday Portland will have more, even more bikes on its streets than cars.

298
00:28:27.757 --> 00:28:29.191
<v Unidentified speaker>And those streets will be a party.

299
00:28:30.190 --> 00:28:32.171
<v Unidentified speaker>Vision Zero will no longer be a vision.

300
00:28:32.526 --> 00:28:36.521
<v Unidentified speaker>The asphalt will be like silk, and PBOT will have all the money it needs.

301
00:28:37.265 --> 00:28:43.299
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilors, I ask you, keep the virtuous circle of cycling in Portland turning.

302
00:28:44.041 --> 00:28:45.931
<v Unidentified speaker>Keep the bike numbers going up and to the right.

303
00:28:46.400 --> 00:28:51.662
<v Unidentified speaker>It will take attention and courage and creativity, but our city will be the better for it.

304
00:28:51.807 --> 00:28:52.147
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

305
00:28:53.856 --> 00:28:55.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for being here.

306
00:28:56.660 --> 00:28:58.248
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Brandon Morgov.

307
00:29:04.700 --> 00:29:06.982
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Brandon, please introduce yourself and go right ahead.

308
00:29:11.539 --> 00:29:12.086
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you hear me?

309
00:29:12.538 --> 00:29:13.585
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I can hear myself.

310
00:29:13.730 --> 00:29:16.017
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we can hear you even a few inches back from there.

311
00:29:16.724 --> 00:29:18.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, welcome to take a seat if you'd like.

312
00:29:18.480 --> 00:29:19.446
<v Unidentified speaker>I feel more comfortable like this.

313
00:29:19.494 --> 00:29:21.951
<v Unidentified speaker>So this is my first time in City Council.

314
00:29:22.000 --> 00:29:23.051
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is, uh, Brandon.

315
00:29:23.169 --> 00:29:27.781
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to talk about, um, homelessness and some plans to address it.

316
00:29:28.442 --> 00:29:30.982
<v Unidentified speaker>This is the first day I can get here and maybe the only day for quite a while.

317
00:29:31.208 --> 00:29:31.803
<v Sameer Kanal>Summer's coming.

318
00:29:34.086 --> 00:29:36.144
<v Unidentified speaker>First off, I'll also thank the first responders.

319
00:29:36.192 --> 00:29:41.929
<v Unidentified speaker>They came within like 3 minutes when I had to Narcan someone the other day, and they actually talked me through the process of resuscitating.

320
00:29:42.185 --> 00:29:44.307
<v Unidentified speaker>So I can attest they did their job well.

321
00:29:45.652 --> 00:29:53.012
<v Unidentified speaker>And as far as the leaves, I mean, maybe in the parks if they just kind of left some of those leaves by the trees and then Transported those workers to the places that need leaves.

322
00:29:53.157 --> 00:29:55.574
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, that'd be good for the trees and probably good for the streets.

323
00:29:55.815 --> 00:30:03.775
<v Unidentified speaker>But as for the homeless, Mayor Wilson's plan, I don't believe is sufficient.

324
00:30:04.277 --> 00:30:07.528
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe he seems good on paper.

325
00:30:08.049 --> 00:30:10.248
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm looking forward to see what he has to offer.

326
00:30:11.621 --> 00:30:16.405
<v Unidentified speaker>But unless the city changes its kind of attitude and approach towards the homeless, it ain't gonna get better.

327
00:30:16.792 --> 00:30:17.665
<v Unidentified speaker>And so here are my points.

328
00:30:17.714 --> 00:30:17.859
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

329
00:30:18.682 --> 00:30:23.671
<v Unidentified speaker>First off, I think to help the homeless, identify who does and who does not want to be on the street.

330
00:30:24.520 --> 00:30:26.108
<v Unidentified speaker>If someone doesn't want to be on the street, good.

331
00:30:26.685 --> 00:30:27.792
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are the first people who should get out.

332
00:30:27.840 --> 00:30:30.536
<v Unidentified speaker>Some people like being on the street as a way of life.

333
00:30:30.728 --> 00:30:38.538
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't advocate for it, but— so my second point, and on the first point, the city of Portland can absorb some homelessness.

334
00:30:39.051 --> 00:30:40.977
<v Unidentified speaker>No homelessness is like authoritarianism.

335
00:30:41.618 --> 00:30:45.564
<v Unidentified speaker>A city that is willing to have some homeless is actually a healthy city, I believe.

336
00:30:45.627 --> 00:30:45.949
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Smith.

337
00:30:47.296 --> 00:30:49.058
<v Unidentified speaker>Jesus said the poor will always be with you.

338
00:30:49.538 --> 00:30:57.695
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, number 2, uh, come up with a way to enlist more Portlanders, uh, to work at microvillages or shelters.

339
00:30:57.743 --> 00:31:06.268
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, and I'm going to call this— I mean, you have plenty of people working DoorDash and Uber every night, and yet you can't staff a homeless shelter during a winter ice storm.

340
00:31:06.924 --> 00:31:11.299
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, there definitely needs to be more calling out Portland on its general attitudes for the homeless.

341
00:31:11.989 --> 00:31:29.279
<v Unidentified speaker>Maybe you can have 20 bike rides Uh, point number 4, when people are trying to get their lives together, you might want to check on them a bit.

342
00:31:29.279 --> 00:31:38.039
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, imagine you're a poor person and you go to like an Oxford House and the person running the Oxford House is corrupt, which in this day and age can be— can quite happen.

343
00:31:38.519 --> 00:31:40.190
<v Unidentified speaker>You got to have some people go there and investigate.

344
00:31:40.319 --> 00:31:45.423
<v Unidentified speaker>You don't want to have a vulnerable person who's gone through All this stuff to try and get their life together being in a corrupt place.

345
00:31:45.488 --> 00:31:47.787
<v Unidentified speaker>And I've been around, I've been homeless myself for a couple years off and on.

346
00:31:47.900 --> 00:31:50.748
<v Unidentified speaker>Thankfully I have a place now, but I can attest that does go on.

347
00:31:52.178 --> 00:31:53.721
<v Unidentified speaker>These are not empty words either.

348
00:31:56.065 --> 00:32:09.902
<v Unidentified speaker>What I'd like to say is, if one thing that's important, this town needs more of a focus on low-income, on helping there be less low-income people and less of a focus on there being more low-income housing.

349
00:32:10.013 --> 00:32:11.008
<v Unidentified speaker>And these are not empty words.

350
00:32:11.056 --> 00:32:21.645
<v Unidentified speaker>I just got back from today working to try and create a program for the homeless in another town, not picking up trash, mind you, a program that's actually kind of putting them in a beneficial mindset where they can learn and grow.

351
00:32:22.431 --> 00:32:30.698
<v Unidentified speaker>And I also have a plan to turn Lloyd Center into a hybrid housing for the homeless as well as a shopping center.

352
00:32:30.746 --> 00:32:33.821
<v Unidentified speaker>And I have a written-up plan for that, and I sent it to all the papers.

353
00:32:33.869 --> 00:32:37.298
<v Unidentified speaker>They didn't publish it or any of my other stuff, which has legitimacy.

354
00:32:37.490 --> 00:32:37.795
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

355
00:32:39.077 --> 00:32:41.948
<v Unidentified speaker>And so if I could, if I could pass off either of these—.

356
00:32:42.044 --> 00:32:44.721
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, can I help you, ma'am?

357
00:32:44.769 --> 00:32:56.619
<v Unidentified speaker>I was going to finish one more point saying I would like to pass off to the city councilors an essay I wrote on turning Lloyd Center into affordable housing, as well as a general plan I have.

358
00:32:56.988 --> 00:32:59.538
<v Unidentified speaker>It's like called the Morgan Proposal, for lack of a better term.

359
00:33:00.242 --> 00:33:03.402
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you go ahead and send that to us, I'm sure folks will take a look at it.

360
00:33:03.465 --> 00:33:04.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that I will.

361
00:33:04.428 --> 00:33:05.855
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for being here with us.

362
00:33:07.450 --> 00:33:15.702
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so in here is a— it's my plan, the Morgan proposal combined with my plan to turn Lloyd Center into affordable housing.

363
00:33:15.978 --> 00:33:16.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

364
00:33:18.849 --> 00:33:20.671
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Alan Combs.

365
00:33:34.067 --> 00:33:35.316
<v Keelan McClymont>Alan Combs?

366
00:33:40.569 --> 00:33:42.012
<v Keelan McClymont>It doesn't look like they've joined us.

367
00:33:43.719 --> 00:33:45.849
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, well, thank you so much to our 4 speakers.

368
00:33:45.962 --> 00:33:49.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate you being here with us, um, sharing important messages.

369
00:33:49.660 --> 00:33:54.031
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is an important time for us to hear about things that aren't otherwise on our agenda.

370
00:33:55.805 --> 00:34:02.378
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next item on our agenda Item 3 is the committee referral list.

371
00:34:02.555 --> 00:34:07.146
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And right now our committee referral list are all things that have actually been heard already.

372
00:34:07.290 --> 00:34:21.949
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This list, as we councilors file things earlier and as the administration gets things filed earlier, will hopefully contain more things before they are before committees so that we can use this opportunity to give people notice about what might be coming on our agendas.

373
00:34:22.945 --> 00:34:51.166
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But you will see that we Uh, put forward, um, a few items that I, I won't read through because they are on today's agenda, as well as, um, an amendment to the Portland Permitting and Development Fee Schedule that has gone through the Finance Committee, revised transportation fee schedule that went to the Finance Committee, uh, adopting rates and charges for water and water-related services.

374
00:34:51.512 --> 00:34:52.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That went through the Finance Committee.

375
00:34:53.382 --> 00:34:57.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Revised sewer and stormwater charges that went through the Finance Committee.

376
00:34:59.139 --> 00:35:03.606
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Fees and charges for water system development and water-related services to the Finance Committee.

377
00:35:07.391 --> 00:35:09.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize, I'm skipping the things that are on the agenda tonight.

378
00:35:11.079 --> 00:35:19.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Amending the code to consolidate noise enforcement and improve fairness and consistency in noise regulation that went to Community and Public Safety.

379
00:35:20.248 --> 00:35:36.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Repeal the authorization of the city attorney— I'm sorry, repeal the authorization of the city attorney to appeal the judgment in the Kelly Jones as personal representative for the estate of Michael Townsend versus the City of Portland case went to Community and Public Safety.

380
00:35:37.438 --> 00:35:48.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and I believe the rest of these— oh, and direct funding for the Workforce Pre-Apprenticeship Program and Summer Works Youth Employment Initiative Went to Labor and Workforce Development.

381
00:35:52.389 --> 00:35:58.070
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next items on our agenda are on the consent agenda.

382
00:35:58.809 --> 00:36:02.882
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, I believe we've had an item pulled from the consent agenda, is that correct?

383
00:36:03.494 --> 00:36:07.907
<v Keelan McClymont>One item was pulled, item 7, 2025-138.

384
00:36:07.972 --> 00:36:08.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

385
00:36:08.215 --> 00:36:18.929
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, items pulled from the consent agenda go to the end of our agenda unless anybody would like to make a motion to put this item elsewhere on the agenda.

386
00:36:18.994 --> 00:36:26.085
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the confirmation of the appointment and reappointment of members to the Portland Elections Commission.

387
00:36:29.235 --> 00:36:32.818
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I would like to make a motion to add this to the top of the agenda.

388
00:36:33.045 --> 00:36:34.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To the top of the regular agenda.

389
00:36:36.606 --> 00:36:38.610
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

390
00:36:39.112 --> 00:36:42.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, there's been a motion to move this to the top of the regular agenda.

391
00:36:45.300 --> 00:36:47.726
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Koyama Lane motioned, and I'm sorry, who seconded?

392
00:36:48.471 --> 00:36:51.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

393
00:36:55.090 --> 00:36:55.733
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any discussion?

394
00:36:57.860 --> 00:37:00.822
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Keelan, can we do this by unanimous consent or do we need to call the roll?

395
00:37:01.161 --> 00:37:02.690
<v Keelan McClymont>I think unanimous consent.

396
00:37:02.932 --> 00:37:05.282
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any objections or do we have unanimous consent?

397
00:37:06.344 --> 00:37:06.719
<v Sameer Kanal>Objection.

398
00:37:07.079 --> 00:37:07.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have an objection.

399
00:37:07.880 --> 00:37:09.023
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, then let's call the roll.

400
00:37:09.099 --> 00:37:10.626
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, Canal.

401
00:37:12.009 --> 00:37:12.233
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

402
00:37:16.784 --> 00:37:18.284
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, uh, aye.

403
00:37:19.420 --> 00:37:19.905
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

404
00:37:20.311 --> 00:37:20.360
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

405
00:37:21.364 --> 00:37:21.769
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo.

406
00:37:22.418 --> 00:37:22.467
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

407
00:37:23.001 --> 00:37:23.342
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

408
00:37:24.443 --> 00:37:24.606
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

409
00:37:25.318 --> 00:37:25.913
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark.

410
00:37:26.057 --> 00:37:26.235
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

411
00:37:26.635 --> 00:37:27.150
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

412
00:37:27.744 --> 00:37:27.905
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

413
00:37:28.324 --> 00:37:28.693
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

414
00:37:29.030 --> 00:37:29.192
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

415
00:37:29.835 --> 00:37:30.139
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

416
00:37:31.603 --> 00:37:31.650
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

417
00:37:32.422 --> 00:37:32.840
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

418
00:37:33.210 --> 00:37:33.257
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

419
00:37:33.563 --> 00:37:33.916
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith.

420
00:37:34.507 --> 00:37:34.559
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

421
00:37:35.012 --> 00:37:35.416
<v Keelan McClymont>Hurdle-Guiney.

422
00:37:35.768 --> 00:37:35.802
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

423
00:37:37.746 --> 00:37:42.077
<v Keelan McClymont>The item is moved to the top of the regular agenda with 11 yes votes and 1 no vote.

424
00:37:42.909 --> 00:37:43.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

425
00:37:43.262 --> 00:37:53.152
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we are on the consent agenda, and I apologize, there's nothing else that has been pulled from the consent agenda, correct?

426
00:37:53.313 --> 00:37:53.898
<v Keelan McClymont>That's correct.

427
00:37:54.108 --> 00:37:57.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Keelan, can you please call the roll on the consent remainder of the consent agenda?

428
00:37:59.132 --> 00:37:59.181
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

429
00:37:59.878 --> 00:37:59.958
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

430
00:38:05.039 --> 00:38:05.088
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

431
00:38:06.494 --> 00:38:06.541
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

432
00:38:07.221 --> 00:38:07.333
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

433
00:38:08.998 --> 00:38:09.047
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

434
00:38:10.210 --> 00:38:10.387
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

435
00:38:11.661 --> 00:38:11.693
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

436
00:38:15.534 --> 00:38:15.583
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

437
00:38:17.875 --> 00:38:20.554
<v Keelan McClymont>The consent agenda is approved with 12 yes votes.

438
00:38:21.103 --> 00:38:21.619
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

439
00:38:21.701 --> 00:38:29.489
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we are now moving on, councilors, to the regular agenda, and the first item on the regular agenda now is Agenda item 7.

440
00:38:31.119 --> 00:38:34.038
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the agenda item?

441
00:38:35.193 --> 00:38:45.018
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 7, confirm appointment and reappointment of members to the Portland Elections Commission for terms to end April 30th, 2029.

442
00:38:45.067 --> 00:38:45.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

443
00:38:45.469 --> 00:38:55.454
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, because we don't generally have committee staff summaries on appointment agenda items, I am going to turn to Councilor Koyama Lane.

444
00:38:56.108 --> 00:39:02.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Who was the presiding chair over the meeting when this agenda item was heard in the Governance Committee.

445
00:39:02.423 --> 00:39:05.554
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>All right, thank you, Madam President.

446
00:39:05.893 --> 00:39:21.253
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So the 4 Portland Elections Commission volunteers at the Governance Committee that the Governance Committee has recommended for confirmation today are part of a 9-member volunteer commission which implements and evaluates the Small Donor Election Program.

447
00:39:21.947 --> 00:39:29.233
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>At our April 7th Governance Committee meeting, we had the opportunity to hear from these passionate volunteers One a reappointment and 3 new appointments.

448
00:39:29.748 --> 00:39:32.414
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And the committee voted unanimously to recommend their appointment.

449
00:39:33.217 --> 00:39:39.739
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>For those of you that are not steeped in City Hall business and Robert's Rules of Order, I wanna explain a little bit about consent agenda.

450
00:39:40.123 --> 00:39:46.132
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Each council meeting, we have what is called a consent agenda, which allows us to approve several items with one vote.

451
00:39:46.630 --> 00:39:52.476
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We include the opportunity to unanimously approve volunteer committee appointments, Yes.

452
00:39:52.876 --> 00:39:55.777
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>As a council using the consent agenda.

453
00:39:56.596 --> 00:40:00.956
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So when these volunteers come to us, they've gone through a thorough vetting process.

454
00:40:01.211 --> 00:40:05.300
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>First, they're vetted on the executive staff side, the executive side by staff.

455
00:40:06.759 --> 00:40:11.695
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Those names are brought forward to the mayor, and then the mayor's office recommends them for appointment.

456
00:40:12.273 --> 00:40:17.996
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Then these names go before a city council policy committee that relates to their volunteer work there.

457
00:40:18.844 --> 00:40:27.342
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>At least in the case of my committee, I think this is happening in other committees as well, we hear from the volunteers all about their interests in the work and relevant experience.

458
00:40:28.001 --> 00:40:29.893
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>These committee meetings are public meetings.

459
00:40:30.728 --> 00:40:35.123
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilors do not have to be on that policy committee to vet a nominee.

460
00:40:35.282 --> 00:40:37.255
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You, any one of us can come testify.

461
00:40:38.090 --> 00:40:41.362
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You can ask committee members to ask a question on your behalf.

462
00:40:41.458 --> 00:40:43.655
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You can watch the hearing live or after the fact.

463
00:40:43.704 --> 00:40:45.003
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You can submit written comment.

464
00:40:46.190 --> 00:40:47.585
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You can see who's been nominated.

465
00:40:47.634 --> 00:40:48.771
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You can do your own research.

466
00:40:49.077 --> 00:40:59.750
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So once that policy committee has heard all of the questions and comments, Signed off on the volunteers, that list of volunteer names then comes before us here on the full— on the consent agenda.

467
00:41:00.472 --> 00:41:11.934
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The hope is that after all this vetting and acknowledging the extensive work of the committee and the volunteers, they can be unanimously approved by the consent agenda process.

468
00:41:12.527 --> 00:41:18.916
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Now, if needed, a councilor can pull these committee volunteer appointments from the consent agenda and say, no, we need more discussion.

469
00:41:18.981 --> 00:41:19.173
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

470
00:41:20.056 --> 00:41:28.990
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And if you've been to the last few meetings, you'll see that my colleague Councilor Kanal is pulling all of these off of the consent agenda as a matter of principle.

471
00:41:29.070 --> 00:41:34.663
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I want to acknowledge that I do truly appreciate how passionate and principled my colleague is.

472
00:41:35.096 --> 00:41:39.065
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We've spoken at length about his reasoning for this, and I do understand it.

473
00:41:39.739 --> 00:41:51.623
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And at the same time, I'm tasked as the chair of the Governance Committee to streamline things for our— these These roughly 80 different volunteer bodies so that all of us can get down to policy work.

474
00:41:52.217 --> 00:41:58.059
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Our governance committee has worked hard on a forthcoming resolution to formalize the process that I just described for you today.

475
00:41:58.380 --> 00:41:59.309
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You'll be seeing it soon.

476
00:42:00.641 --> 00:42:11.989
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And because of what I've heard from dozens of past and prospective volunteers, it's— what I'm hearing is that adding another layer of bureaucracy is making it harder for volunteers to feel like they can participate.

477
00:42:12.052 --> 00:42:12.358
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Thank you.

478
00:42:12.822 --> 00:42:18.159
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So these are people that are already donating their time to do really valuable and important work for our city.

479
00:42:18.913 --> 00:42:28.112
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Anyone who comes to these Wednesday City Council meetings know that we have very packed agendas, and our constituents are begging all of us to get to work.

480
00:42:28.690 --> 00:42:36.719
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We have many people here who I think are ready to give public testimony on other agenda items that we have on our list.

481
00:42:36.943 --> 00:42:38.563
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We have a long meeting ahead of us.

482
00:42:38.708 --> 00:42:45.922
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I feel strongly that it does not serve our volunteers or our constituents to go over things that have already been discussed publicly and on the record.

483
00:42:46.018 --> 00:43:00.626
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So with love and respect to my colleague, Councilor Kanal, I would ask that we respect our volunteers' and constituents' time by reserving discussion on appointments for when it's truly needed and not in order to make a point at every single council meeting.

484
00:43:01.219 --> 00:43:04.010
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And with all that in mind, Madam President, I call the question.

485
00:43:05.501 --> 00:43:06.382
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

486
00:43:06.672 --> 00:43:15.530
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we have I believe we move straight into a vote when a question is called.

487
00:43:15.594 --> 00:43:17.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't have discussion on that motion.

488
00:43:17.739 --> 00:43:18.625
<v Keelan McClymont>That's correct.

489
00:43:18.692 --> 00:43:26.271
<v Keelan McClymont>And because this is a report, um, we may need a motion to accept the report and a second before we can take the vote.

490
00:43:27.556 --> 00:43:30.063
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think this is a vote to call the question.

491
00:43:30.126 --> 00:43:30.769
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, okay.

492
00:43:30.849 --> 00:43:31.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

493
00:43:34.581 --> 00:43:38.235
<v Candace Avalos>Are we doing a vote to vote right now?

494
00:43:38.688 --> 00:43:40.192
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is calling the question.

495
00:43:40.289 --> 00:43:40.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, I'm sorry.

496
00:43:41.112 --> 00:43:42.827
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I usually state what these are.

497
00:43:42.891 --> 00:43:43.458
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

498
00:43:43.521 --> 00:43:45.246
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Calling the question is a vote to vote.

499
00:43:46.340 --> 00:43:49.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe that when we call the question, we don't have discussion first.

500
00:43:49.655 --> 00:43:52.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That immediately triggers a vote on whether or not to vote.

501
00:43:54.527 --> 00:43:55.144
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

502
00:43:56.478 --> 00:43:59.306
<v Keelan McClymont>So this is the vote on the motion to call the question.

503
00:44:01.003 --> 00:44:02.054
<v Sameer Kanal>On the motion, I vote no.

504
00:44:02.942 --> 00:44:03.103
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

505
00:44:04.152 --> 00:44:04.201
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

506
00:44:05.702 --> 00:44:05.862
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

507
00:44:06.248 --> 00:44:06.297
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

508
00:44:06.827 --> 00:44:08.835
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

509
00:44:09.222 --> 00:44:09.382
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

510
00:44:11.166 --> 00:44:11.376
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

511
00:44:11.873 --> 00:44:11.922
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

512
00:44:12.516 --> 00:44:12.902
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

513
00:44:13.561 --> 00:44:13.610
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

514
00:44:14.461 --> 00:44:14.672
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

515
00:44:15.594 --> 00:44:15.740
<v Candace Avalos>No.

516
00:44:16.971 --> 00:44:17.342
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

517
00:44:18.086 --> 00:44:18.248
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

518
00:44:18.847 --> 00:44:19.123
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

519
00:44:20.030 --> 00:44:20.077
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

520
00:44:20.936 --> 00:44:21.389
<v Keelan McClymont>Bertolghini?

521
00:44:21.809 --> 00:44:21.938
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

522
00:44:23.170 --> 00:44:26.472
<v Keelan McClymont>With 10 yes votes, the— Motion is approved.

523
00:44:27.177 --> 00:44:34.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, that moves us past discussion and to the vote on this agenda item.

524
00:44:34.242 --> 00:44:39.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will need a motion and a second to adopt the report, and then we will move into—.

525
00:44:39.525 --> 00:44:40.554
<v Eric Zimmerman>Move to adopt the report.

526
00:44:40.601 --> 00:44:41.115
<v Steve Novick>So moved.

527
00:44:42.175 --> 00:44:49.545
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think I heard a movement from Councilor Zimmerman and a second from Councilor Ryan, though I also heard Councilor Kanal say a second after that.

528
00:44:51.896 --> 00:44:54.483
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we have Zimmerman and Ryan first for the official record.

529
00:44:54.726 --> 00:44:56.197
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just wanted to acknowledge my colleague.

530
00:44:57.231 --> 00:44:58.411
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sorry for the confusion, Keelan.

531
00:45:00.250 --> 00:45:00.835
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you call the roll?

532
00:45:01.894 --> 00:45:09.905
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we are now voting to adopt the report and confirm the recommended appointments from the mayor.

533
00:45:13.456 --> 00:45:14.688
<v Sameer Kanal>I will keep this streamlined.

534
00:45:15.027 --> 00:45:27.976
<v Sameer Kanal>Madam President, if we have to have fewer, better supported, more empowered, and therefore more meaningful volunteer bodies, we need to ensure that council engages with the top We also need to guarantee public participation in this process.

535
00:45:29.369 --> 00:45:30.416
<v Sameer Kanal>I support the appointees.

536
00:45:30.592 --> 00:45:36.728
<v Sameer Kanal>I have this entire time, and I wish that we had a process that better reflected that going forward.

537
00:45:36.824 --> 00:45:40.597
<v Sameer Kanal>And I look forward to working with my colleagues who are on the Governance Committee to ensure that.

538
00:45:40.677 --> 00:45:41.081
<v Sameer Kanal>I vote aye.

539
00:45:42.034 --> 00:45:42.081
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

540
00:45:43.407 --> 00:45:43.503
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

541
00:45:45.264 --> 00:45:45.313
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

542
00:45:45.925 --> 00:45:45.942
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

543
00:45:48.438 --> 00:45:48.469
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

544
00:45:48.744 --> 00:45:49.134
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

545
00:45:49.376 --> 00:45:49.425
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

546
00:45:49.878 --> 00:45:50.152
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

547
00:45:51.172 --> 00:45:51.253
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

548
00:45:51.884 --> 00:45:52.175
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

549
00:45:52.628 --> 00:45:52.773
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

550
00:45:53.356 --> 00:45:53.809
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

551
00:45:55.362 --> 00:45:56.851
<v Candace Avalos>I agree with Councilor Kanal.

552
00:45:57.077 --> 00:46:20.380
<v Candace Avalos>I am concerned about what this process is setting up because I do think that us vetting volunteers who have very big roles and make a lot of big decisions too, and I don't agree that that process going just through committee and us I barely have enough time to do my own committee.

553
00:46:20.519 --> 00:46:25.639
<v Candace Avalos>I expect to come to this meeting and be able to make a vote and have the ability to have an informed vote.

554
00:46:25.639 --> 00:46:27.940
<v Candace Avalos>And that requires some further vetting.

555
00:46:27.940 --> 00:46:29.860
<v Candace Avalos>So I disagree with that premise.

556
00:46:30.159 --> 00:46:34.480
<v Candace Avalos>Agree with Councilor Kanal that I'm gonna, you know, I'm gonna vote for this 'cause it's not about those people.

557
00:46:34.500 --> 00:46:40.719
<v Candace Avalos>And I, as somebody who has put hundreds and hundreds of hours, know very much the burden that we put on community members.

558
00:46:40.719 --> 00:46:44.179
<v Candace Avalos>But for that same reason, I also know the responsibility that community members have.

559
00:46:44.179 --> 00:46:52.458
<v Candace Avalos>And if we're gonna put the burden on them, we need to make sure that we're doing it in a way So I'm voting aye, but I want to continue the discussion about this process in the future.

560
00:46:55.010 --> 00:46:55.059
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

561
00:46:56.873 --> 00:46:56.920
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

562
00:46:58.652 --> 00:46:58.702
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

563
00:46:59.947 --> 00:47:02.117
<v Keelan McClymont>With 12 aye votes, the appointments are confirmed.

564
00:47:04.239 --> 00:47:04.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

565
00:47:05.719 --> 00:47:21.795
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, our next agenda item is an item that we've heard a few times before, um, the Ordinance to ban AI— I'm sorry, to ban price setting through AI in housing.

566
00:47:22.307 --> 00:47:24.081
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the agenda item?

567
00:47:25.905 --> 00:47:34.728
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 9, amend affordable housing code to add prohibition of anti-competitive rental practices, including the sale and use of algorithmic devices.

568
00:47:35.130 --> 00:47:35.585
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

569
00:47:36.286 --> 00:47:48.469
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, you'll remember that we We had to cut testimony short when we first heard this agenda item and offered the public 2 additional times to come forward and complete the testimony list.

570
00:47:48.550 --> 00:47:50.297
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the second of those times.

571
00:47:50.829 --> 00:47:57.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we will move right now into picking up on public testimony where we left off after the last meeting.

572
00:47:58.351 --> 00:48:01.141
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call up folks to testify?

573
00:48:02.650 --> 00:48:03.639
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, thank you, Council President Elana Pirtle-Guiney.

574
00:48:04.724 --> 00:48:09.686
<v Keelan McClymont>First, we have Jenna Knobloch, Amy Walsh, and Christine Orlandi.

575
00:48:13.239 --> 00:48:14.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for joining us tonight.

576
00:48:17.152 --> 00:48:17.699
<v Angelita Morillo>All right.

577
00:48:17.795 --> 00:48:19.706
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hi, my name is Jenna Knobloch.

578
00:48:19.867 --> 00:48:27.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm a renter in Southeast Portland, and I'm also someone who has experienced housing precarity too many times in my life.

579
00:48:28.413 --> 00:48:33.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm here to call on you to pass this ban on algorithmic price fixing.

580
00:48:34.333 --> 00:48:36.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>First, it's clear that it's a real problem.

581
00:48:37.376 --> 00:48:44.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I learned from RealPage's own testimony here that they are already setting prices for 18% of units in Portland.

582
00:48:44.827 --> 00:48:47.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's almost 1 in 5 units, far too many.

583
00:48:48.753 --> 00:48:59.842
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And according to RealPage's own materials, they are, and I quote, driving every possible opportunity to increase price even in the most downward trending conditions.

584
00:48:59.891 --> 00:49:00.338
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Loretta Smith.

585
00:49:01.119 --> 00:49:09.324
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That is not a fair market, and this is further distorting what is already a losing market for renters.

586
00:49:11.099 --> 00:49:15.916
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Secondly, I really am failing to see any downsides here for landlords.

587
00:49:16.369 --> 00:49:26.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For all the bluster about unintended consequences, I've not heard a single real-world example from the DOGA investigation or the other cities with this on the books.

588
00:49:27.291 --> 00:49:34.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For all the discussion about barriers to building new market rate units, I've never heard price setting come up as a barrier.

589
00:49:34.659 --> 00:49:39.579
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The fact is landlords have been setting prices just fine for a long time without colluding.

590
00:49:42.121 --> 00:49:52.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In fact, it was just in the news, I was just reading just now that RealPage lost and is settling in North Carolina where they're agreeing to stop using the practice.

591
00:49:52.717 --> 00:49:55.217
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are real consequences for tenants.

592
00:49:55.266 --> 00:50:09.458
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The Oregon Community Foundation found That for every 10% increase in homelessness, there's an associated 13.6% increase in— or 10% increase in rent is associated with 13.6% increase in homelessness.

593
00:50:10.213 --> 00:50:14.356
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Trump's Department of Justice is not going to protect us from price gloating.

594
00:50:14.869 --> 00:50:18.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are all depending on you, so please vote yes on this sensible policy.

595
00:50:19.460 --> 00:50:28.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll remind folks, I'll remind folks, I just want to remind folks that we can't have clapping and other interruptions.

596
00:50:30.349 --> 00:50:38.485
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You're welcome to do jazz hands, thumbs up, thumbs down, other silent indications of support or opposition.

597
00:50:40.106 --> 00:50:47.362
<v Keelan McClymont>Amy Walsh, Christine Orlandi, Sarah Fisher is joining us online.

598
00:50:50.250 --> 00:50:50.840
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Sarah.

599
00:50:55.603 --> 00:51:04.282
<v Keelan McClymont>Sarah, you're muted.

600
00:51:06.666 --> 00:51:10.088
<v Keelan McClymont>Sarah, if you're on the phone, try star 6 to unmute.

601
00:51:14.389 --> 00:51:16.514
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, we'll come back to Sarah.

602
00:51:16.610 --> 00:51:18.784
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Michael Park.

603
00:51:21.250 --> 00:51:26.568
<v Keelan McClymont>Spencer Trum, Eric Hagstedt.

604
00:51:30.387 --> 00:51:33.335
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe one of those guests is making their way downstairs right now.

605
00:51:42.199 --> 00:51:43.653
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, while we wait, is Sarah ready?

606
00:51:45.257 --> 00:51:47.065
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, it looks like Sarah's still muted.

607
00:51:57.646 --> 00:51:59.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We want to call the next couple of people.

608
00:51:59.534 --> 00:51:59.664
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sure.

609
00:52:00.186 --> 00:52:17.628
<v Keelan McClymont>Let's see, next up we have Marion Drake, Greg Frick, Keely Coke.

610
00:52:25.565 --> 00:52:27.896
<v Keelan McClymont>Next we have Leah Belton.

611
00:52:30.431 --> 00:52:38.045
<v Unidentified speaker>Spencer.

612
00:52:40.070 --> 00:52:40.313
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

613
00:52:40.476 --> 00:52:40.753
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

614
00:52:40.818 --> 00:52:41.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate it.

615
00:52:41.387 --> 00:52:43.061
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Introduce yourself and jump right in.

616
00:52:45.090 --> 00:52:48.507
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening, Council President Pirtle-Guiney and members of the Portland City Council.

617
00:52:49.170 --> 00:52:53.913
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Spencer Trumm, and I'm here today on behalf of State Representative Zach Hudson.

618
00:52:54.911 --> 00:52:58.358
<v Unidentified speaker>Representative Hudson's district represents Oregon's 49th House District.

619
00:52:58.856 --> 00:53:03.920
<v Unidentified speaker>This includes parts of East Portland and Gresham, as well as Troutdale, Fairview, and Wood Village.

620
00:53:05.260 --> 00:53:09.001
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to urge you to pass the ordinance prohibiting algorithmic rental price fixing.

621
00:53:10.110 --> 00:53:13.563
<v Unidentified speaker>Nearly half the households in Representative Hudson's district are rentals.

622
00:53:14.351 --> 00:53:21.626
<v Unidentified speaker>Between 2019 and 2023, over 60% of those renter households were forced to spend more than 30% of their income on housing.

623
00:53:22.398 --> 00:53:26.813
<v Unidentified speaker>In other words, the majority of East County residents are forced to pay too much in rent.

624
00:53:27.666 --> 00:53:33.554
<v Unidentified speaker>One way to limit the damage caused by out-of-control rent is to ban the use of AI algorithms to set rents.

625
00:53:35.380 --> 00:53:40.068
<v Unidentified speaker>ProPublica's reporting reveals how software companies help landlords and property managers coordinate rent increases.

626
00:53:40.748 --> 00:53:46.530
<v Unidentified speaker>Their algorithms aggregate non-public data from landlords and supply them all with the same analysis to maximize rent yields.

627
00:53:47.141 --> 00:53:47.608
<v Unidentified speaker>The result?

628
00:53:48.188 --> 00:53:52.648
<v Unidentified speaker>Spiraling rent inflation, community displacement, and harder lives for working families.

629
00:53:54.360 --> 00:53:55.086
<v Unidentified speaker>Our senior U.S.

630
00:53:55.153 --> 00:54:03.423
<v Unidentified speaker>Senator Ron Wyden used a good word to describe the arrangement by which companies use algorithms to raise prices and control housing as a commodity.

631
00:54:04.097 --> 00:54:05.492
<v Unidentified speaker>That word is cartel.

632
00:54:06.726 --> 00:54:12.643
<v Unidentified speaker>Jurisdictions across America have recognized the threat posed to consumers by predatory rent-setting algorithms.

633
00:54:13.494 --> 00:54:19.056
<v Unidentified speaker>City councils in Philadelphia and San Francisco have passed ordinances like the one proposed here in Portland.

634
00:54:19.795 --> 00:54:30.931
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm pleased to say that Oregon has joined a federal antitrust suit against RealPage But housing unaffordability is an emergency across the state, and our city governments must play their part to protect Oregonians.

635
00:54:31.831 --> 00:54:34.431
<v Unidentified speaker>This ordinance has attracted a great deal of attention and support.

636
00:54:35.202 --> 00:54:42.059
<v Unidentified speaker>I urge you to listen to the voices of rent-burdened Portlanders and prioritize their need for shelter and dignity over landlords' profits.

637
00:54:42.943 --> 00:54:48.740
<v Unidentified speaker>The degree to which Oregonians are burdened by rents is unfair, unsustainable, and unacceptable, and it must stop.

638
00:54:49.351 --> 00:54:52.048
<v Unidentified speaker>Please pass this ordinance without delay, and thank you for your time and consideration.

639
00:54:52.097 --> 00:54:52.210
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

640
00:54:54.007 --> 00:54:55.291
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

641
00:54:55.934 --> 00:54:58.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please go ahead and introduce yourself and then jump right in.

642
00:54:59.289 --> 00:55:01.682
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Leah Belton.

643
00:55:02.422 --> 00:55:05.456
<v Unidentified speaker>I support the ban on algorithmic rent pricing.

644
00:55:06.114 --> 00:55:13.644
<v Unidentified speaker>I am here for myself, my fellow renters, and East County Rising, which serves District 1 and East Multnomah County.

645
00:55:14.159 --> 00:55:18.380
<v Unidentified speaker>We are deeply concerned about the housing and eviction crisis.

646
00:55:19.454 --> 00:55:29.117
<v Unidentified speaker>A 2018 City of Portland assessment on gentrification and displacement highlighted East Portland's unique vulnerability.

647
00:55:29.853 --> 00:55:37.818
<v Unidentified speaker>East Portland has had the most rapid increase in housing costs citywide since '08, the year I graduated from Reynolds High.

648
00:55:39.003 --> 00:55:49.431
<v Unidentified speaker>Over 14,000 low-income, cost-burdened renter households live in East Portland, and they're being pushed out in Parkrose and Rosewood.

649
00:55:49.994 --> 00:55:53.543
<v Unidentified speaker>Black and brown Portlanders are being displaced the fastest.

650
00:55:54.072 --> 00:56:04.750
<v Unidentified speaker>Institutional racism and historical redlining laid the foundation, and today the use of algorithmic price-fixing tools continues this displacement.

651
00:56:05.472 --> 00:56:08.956
<v Unidentified speaker>You have the power to slow this displacement.

652
00:56:09.744 --> 00:56:13.742
<v Unidentified speaker>Please do not give in to misinformation and scare tactics.

653
00:56:14.304 --> 00:56:17.498
<v Unidentified speaker>Help us pay reasonable rents instead.

654
00:56:18.253 --> 00:56:20.260
<v Unidentified speaker>Vote yes on this ordinance.

655
00:56:20.646 --> 00:56:22.637
<v Unidentified speaker>Do not water it down.

656
00:56:23.295 --> 00:56:31.099
<v Unidentified speaker>Banning price-fixing algorithms to close a collusion loophole will not tank the housing market.

657
00:56:31.724 --> 00:56:40.208
<v Unidentified speaker>Algorithmic price-fixing tools enable our capital to be mined out of our community with ease.

658
00:56:40.864 --> 00:56:44.293
<v Unidentified speaker>Help us keep our money in our local economy.

659
00:56:45.030 --> 00:56:54.356
<v Unidentified speaker>East County Rising and I urge you all to vote yes on this ordinance and protect the people who actually live in this city.

660
00:56:55.300 --> 00:56:56.407
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your time.

661
00:56:57.384 --> 00:56:58.474
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

662
00:56:59.947 --> 00:57:02.159
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, next up we have Colin Fawn.

663
00:57:04.373 --> 00:57:05.958
<v Keelan McClymont>Laurena Guyette.

664
00:57:07.769 --> 00:57:11.135
<v Keelan McClymont>Natalie Hutchinson joining us online.

665
00:57:14.320 --> 00:57:14.777
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right ahead.

666
00:57:15.606 --> 00:57:15.947
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here.

667
00:57:16.597 --> 00:57:18.077
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, um, good evening.

668
00:57:18.143 --> 00:57:19.152
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Natalie Hutchinson.

669
00:57:19.777 --> 00:57:29.139
<v Unidentified speaker>I am a grad student in the architecture program at PSU, and I'm here to speak in support of the ordinance banning AI, um, AI price fixing of rent.

670
00:57:29.983 --> 00:57:36.387
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland's soul is defined by its people— the artists, the families, the small businesses, and the neighbors who make our city unique.

671
00:57:36.867 --> 00:57:42.581
<v Candace Avalos>But the use of algorithmic devices in the rental housing market threatens to push neighbors out.

672
00:57:43.384 --> 00:57:49.498
<v Candace Avalos>As a tenant, I live in an affordable housing building where AI-based price-fixing software like Yardi is used.

673
00:57:49.884 --> 00:57:55.693
<v Unidentified speaker>In the 11 months that I've lived in this building, I've witnessed— it was 22 evictions on the first day.

674
00:57:56.391 --> 00:58:00.853
<v Unidentified speaker>On the original day of this testimony, but today it's 24 evictions in this building.

675
00:58:02.190 --> 00:58:06.052
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a clear example of the harm these practices cause, and it is unacceptable.

676
00:58:06.827 --> 00:58:12.396
<v Unidentified speaker>Renters deserve grace, not exploitation, especially in today's economic climate.

677
00:58:12.800 --> 00:58:21.063
<v Unidentified speaker>To the tech companies behind these algorithms, these practices of manipulating prices and destabilizing our housing market are just not just unethical, they're harmful.

678
00:58:21.655 --> 00:58:25.942
<v Unidentified speaker>We won't allow you to turn our city into a market for profit at the expense of its residents.

679
00:58:26.550 --> 00:58:31.768
<v Unidentified speaker>The small landlords, you are an essential part of keeping Portland weird and special.

680
00:58:32.666 --> 00:58:37.304
<v Candace Avalos>By setting rents reasonably, you ensure that our city remains diverse, inclusive, and vibrant.

681
00:58:37.818 --> 00:58:44.463
<v Candace Avalos>Supporting fair and affordable pricing benefits everyone— your tenants, your neighborhoods, and our city as a whole.

682
00:58:45.666 --> 00:58:49.358
<v Unidentified speaker>Furthermore, I urge all renters to join renters unions and stand up for your rights.

683
00:58:49.583 --> 00:58:53.226
<v Unidentified speaker>We need to hold landlords And developers accountable for their actions.

684
00:58:53.851 --> 00:58:58.795
<v Unidentified speaker>This ordinance is just the first step in ensuring that our city remains a place where residents can thrive.

685
00:58:59.532 --> 00:59:03.963
<v Unidentified speaker>Today I want to lend our community's bravery to the City Council in facing these current issues head-on.

686
00:59:04.541 --> 00:59:08.393
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm confident in the leadership of the City Council to make the right decision for Portland's future.

687
00:59:08.681 --> 00:59:14.556
<v Candace Avalos>I urge the council and Greater Portland to support this bill to protect our community from the harmful effects of AI price fixing.

688
00:59:14.876 --> 00:59:15.197
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

689
00:59:16.224 --> 00:59:16.336
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

690
00:59:17.123 --> 00:59:17.621
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

691
00:59:18.793 --> 00:59:19.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

692
00:59:19.677 --> 00:59:22.005
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, uh, my name is Lorena Gayette.

693
00:59:22.166 --> 00:59:24.302
<v Unidentified speaker>I am speaking in favor of this ordinance.

694
00:59:24.735 --> 00:59:31.222
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I did have previous testimony, but I decided to scrap it in order to rebuttal some of the misinformation that was presented at the previous council meeting.

695
00:59:31.639 --> 00:59:47.356
<v Unidentified speaker>First, in response to the claim that the software is not price fixing, or like RealPage, uh, it was reported in 2022 that RealPage executives have been quoted as taking credit for a 14% increase in rent and referral referring to landlords who refuse to increase rent as idiots.

696
00:59:48.190 --> 00:59:57.362
<v Unidentified speaker>Employees state landlords who want to charge reasonable rates have an empathy problem and have admitted to disincentivizing landlords from doing so, even kicking some landlords off of the software.

697
00:59:58.291 --> 01:00:15.574
<v Unidentified speaker>As a Latina, I took offense to the idea that this ordinance would prevent generational wealth from developing in Black and brown communities when demographics for this city show that more than 60% of Black and Hispanic rent— are renters in Portland, meaning that the biggest hurdle for our communities Is being rent burdened and first-time home buying.

698
01:00:16.487 --> 01:00:18.536
<v Unidentified speaker>What percentage of them do you think are landlords?

699
01:00:19.289 --> 01:00:23.824
<v Unidentified speaker>We need to ensure that all of our community is protected, not just those who are able to invest in property.

700
01:00:24.978 --> 01:00:30.617
<v Unidentified speaker>And you are being presented with a false dichotomy that we must either focus on building homes or regulating costs.

701
01:00:30.809 --> 01:00:34.461
<v Unidentified speaker>It is important to state that not only can we do both, but we must do both.

702
01:00:35.070 --> 01:00:43.336
<v Unidentified speaker>Under normal conditions, more housing will bring prices down, but RealPage and software like it are built for the purpose of disrupting these types of market forces.

703
01:00:43.400 --> 01:00:43.496
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

704
01:00:44.268 --> 01:00:49.554
<v Unidentified speaker>All the housing in the world means nothing if we allow software to run rampant and remove any incentive to lower prices.

705
01:00:50.550 --> 01:00:55.130
<v Unidentified speaker>This ordinance is a necessary preventative measure that needs to be applied yesterday.

706
01:00:56.398 --> 01:01:03.211
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, as a request, Councilor Zimmerman, you have asked the same questions in the Housing and Homelessness Committee as you have in general, in the general meeting.

707
01:01:03.324 --> 01:01:09.269
<v Unidentified speaker>I would like to request that you maybe write down some of the things so we don't have repeat answers in order to be respectful of our time.

708
01:01:09.349 --> 01:01:09.510
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

709
01:01:12.027 --> 01:01:13.199
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

710
01:01:13.981 --> 01:01:17.202
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for being here.

711
01:01:18.840 --> 01:01:20.336
<v Keelan McClymont>We'll go back to Sarah Fisher.

712
01:01:22.380 --> 01:01:22.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sarah, welcome.

713
01:01:23.137 --> 01:01:26.494
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please introduce yourself and you can start your testimony.

714
01:01:28.079 --> 01:01:28.565
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

715
01:01:30.052 --> 01:01:31.782
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening, Councilor—.

716
01:01:32.317 --> 01:01:37.297
<v Unidentified speaker>Council President Pirtle-Guiney, Vice President Koyama Lane, and councilors.

717
01:01:38.507 --> 01:01:40.967
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, do I need to do something to turn my camera on?

718
01:01:43.273 --> 01:01:48.105
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, Sarah, if you accept the, uh, promote to panelist.

719
01:01:54.010 --> 01:01:55.646
<v Unidentified speaker>Yep.

720
01:01:57.652 --> 01:01:58.298
<v Loretta Smith>All right.

721
01:02:03.940 --> 01:02:04.405
<v Unidentified speaker>Are you ready?

722
01:02:05.273 --> 01:02:06.092
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead, Sarah.

723
01:02:06.317 --> 01:02:09.351
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And even if you can't get your camera on, we've got a picture of you on screen.

724
01:02:09.849 --> 01:02:10.057
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

725
01:02:10.748 --> 01:02:16.224
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Sarah Fisher, and I'm an Episcopal priest serving Hope and Bread Street Church and St.

726
01:02:16.351 --> 01:02:19.434
<v Unidentified speaker>Aidan's Episcopal Church, both in East Portland.

727
01:02:19.594 --> 01:02:21.907
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm testifying for myself today.

728
01:02:22.550 --> 01:02:33.108
<v Unidentified speaker>While much of my work is with people currently living on the street, I know, as you know, That our housing crisis is about much more than homelessness.

729
01:02:33.862 --> 01:02:38.528
<v Unidentified speaker>I've lived in Portland for almost 40 years, and I've lived in every quad—.

730
01:02:38.577 --> 01:02:39.684
<v Unidentified speaker>Quadrant of the city.

731
01:02:40.181 --> 01:02:43.228
<v Unidentified speaker>I have been a homeowner, a renter, and a landlord.

732
01:02:44.206 --> 01:02:49.594
<v Unidentified speaker>About 30 years ago, a family member was visiting, and she said something I have never forgotten.

733
01:02:50.298 --> 01:02:55.494
<v Unidentified speaker>She said Portland feels like a city that really cares about the people who live here.

734
01:02:55.543 --> 01:02:55.655
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

735
01:02:56.427 --> 01:02:59.715
<v Unidentified speaker>And does things for the enjoyment of all of its residents.

736
01:03:00.440 --> 01:03:13.284
<v Unidentified speaker>When we talk about a boom loop, reviving Portland and making Portland a better city, I think this is what we're talking about: giving the impression to all who come here that we care.

737
01:03:14.699 --> 01:03:18.139
<v Unidentified speaker>This anti-algorithmic price-fixing ordinance does that.

738
01:03:19.054 --> 01:03:23.474
<v Unidentified speaker>The simple truth is that this is about putting people before profit.

739
01:03:24.538 --> 01:03:32.139
<v Unidentified speaker>If this is not a moment in history to put people before profit, I do not know what is.

740
01:03:33.534 --> 01:03:37.880
<v Unidentified speaker>My husband and I own a small apartment complex in Southeast Portland.

741
01:03:39.052 --> 01:03:47.215
<v Unidentified speaker>We do not participate in RealPage, so I guess we're one of these stupid landlords, or any other algorithmic price-fixing service.

742
01:03:47.487 --> 01:03:49.219
<v Unidentified speaker>Our apartment complex matters to us.

743
01:03:49.300 --> 01:03:52.168
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, especially as we consider retirement.

744
01:03:52.619 --> 01:04:02.670
<v Unidentified speaker>But I am here to say that it is possible to have a healthy investment property without making it impossible for everyday people to live in our city.

745
01:04:03.251 --> 01:04:05.456
<v Unidentified speaker>I urge you to pass this ordinance.

746
01:04:06.000 --> 01:04:06.356
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

747
01:04:08.715 --> 01:04:09.431
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Sarah.

748
01:04:10.342 --> 01:04:12.442
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Zach Voss.

749
01:04:15.280 --> 01:04:40.708
<v Keelan McClymont>Tessa Cole, Meg Bender Stefanski, J.M., Riley Martz, Haley Nissen, Will Spaulding, Heather Riggs.

750
01:04:42.884 --> 01:04:43.786
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

751
01:04:43.934 --> 01:04:45.639
<v Keelan McClymont>Hannah Brooks Olson.

752
01:04:48.550 --> 01:04:52.860
<v Keelan McClymont>Jeremy Baird.

753
01:04:53.182 --> 01:04:56.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go ahead and introduce yourself and you can begin your testimony.

754
01:04:58.389 --> 01:05:04.512
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening, Madam President, councilors, um, hardworking administrators.

755
01:05:05.978 --> 01:05:08.170
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for letting me come back to testify.

756
01:05:08.996 --> 01:05:15.585
<v Unidentified speaker>I am Reverend Heather Riggs, pastor of Montavilla United Methodist Church in Southeast Portland.

757
01:05:16.407 --> 01:05:17.954
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to speak in favor.

758
01:05:18.909 --> 01:05:24.188
<v Unidentified speaker>I want robots to clean my house, not to raise my parishioners' rent.

759
01:05:25.795 --> 01:05:39.047
<v Unidentified speaker>Many members of my congregation are either elderly and struggling to survive on a fixed income, or are young adults struggling to find jobs that pay enough to cover the rising costs of living.

760
01:05:40.298 --> 01:05:57.775
<v Unidentified speaker>My church includes a queer young adult group for whom affordable housing is literally life-saving because they cannot depend on their families for the kind of support that most parents give their young adult children when they are starting out in life.

761
01:05:58.996 --> 01:06:07.733
<v Unidentified speaker>This ordinance will not impact small local landlords who can't even afford to pay for these algorithmic programs.

762
01:06:08.954 --> 01:06:30.315
<v Unidentified speaker>As has been already stated during the discussion of social housing, this ordinance will also not stop developers from building affordable housing, since for-profit developers have no intentions of building affordable housing because it just doesn't pencil out to build for lower rents when we have higher building costs.

763
01:06:32.001 --> 01:06:43.032
<v Unidentified speaker>This ordinance will help to prevent the large corporate landlords from using AI to collude to raise rents in an already stressed housing system.

764
01:06:43.898 --> 01:06:54.143
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's do the right thing for the majority of Portlanders, not the right thing for the minority of those who are already making enough money.

765
01:06:54.978 --> 01:06:55.684
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

766
01:06:56.663 --> 01:06:56.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

767
01:06:58.329 --> 01:06:58.795
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

768
01:07:00.190 --> 01:07:02.032
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, my name is Jeremy Kuda-Baird.

769
01:07:02.097 --> 01:07:03.844
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll give a little bit more of a personal testimony.

770
01:07:04.581 --> 01:07:07.034
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a resident of Portland City District 4.

771
01:07:07.547 --> 01:07:14.264
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a research and development chemist who is employed in the building industry specializing in the science of developing housing materials.

772
01:07:15.081 --> 01:07:18.224
<v Unidentified speaker>My partner is a medical student going to OHSU pursuant of an MD.

773
01:07:19.106 --> 01:07:22.054
<v Unidentified speaker>We moved here in the last few years in the pursuit of a better life from Idaho.

774
01:07:22.472 --> 01:07:26.003
<v Unidentified speaker>Where AI price fixing has caused the price of rent to far exceed the price of labor.

775
01:07:27.143 --> 01:07:32.248
<v Unidentified speaker>The lack of regulations in that state have allowed this inequity to grow considerably throughout my life while growing up there.

776
01:07:32.826 --> 01:07:38.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Before coming here, we only heard rumors of Portland being something that it isn't, and we don't regret coming here at all.

777
01:07:38.443 --> 01:07:39.295
<v Unidentified speaker>The city has been amazing.

778
01:07:39.791 --> 01:07:43.789
<v Unidentified speaker>We've decided that we'd like to stay here permanently and add another scientist and a doctor to the community.

779
01:07:44.382 --> 01:07:49.856
<v Unidentified speaker>But the rent increases have been making it impossible to save money and even think about being able to save up to afford buying a house in this area.

780
01:07:50.884 --> 01:07:52.840
<v Unidentified speaker>Even with the higher paying job that I have right now.

781
01:07:54.157 --> 01:07:58.730
<v Unidentified speaker>We have already had to move once due to rent being exacerbated by the AA price fixing since we've come here.

782
01:07:59.693 --> 01:08:09.561
<v Unidentified speaker>I know this is a part of why it has gone up because all of my slightly older coworkers who make the same amounts, same salary as me, are able to do what I am not.

783
01:08:10.217 --> 01:08:18.113
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's because of a steep increase in rent since they bought houses, which conveniently happened after software companies like RealPage started existing.

784
01:08:18.161 --> 01:08:18.256
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

785
01:08:19.284 --> 01:08:25.609
<v Unidentified speaker>So we have a decision to make once my partner graduates on whether or not we can afford to live here or even in this country when she becomes a medical resident.

786
01:08:26.750 --> 01:08:30.762
<v Unidentified speaker>We have been putting off having a family or even getting married until we have the money to do either correctly.

787
01:08:31.791 --> 01:08:35.033
<v Unidentified speaker>Our main expense is rent, and it's not even close competition.

788
01:08:36.206 --> 01:08:38.630
<v Unidentified speaker>We look for the cheapest place to live, and it doesn't exist.

789
01:08:38.951 --> 01:08:44.827
<v Unidentified speaker>I hope everyone will vote to prevent us from being priced out of our favorite city before we can even start to build a life here.

790
01:08:45.908 --> 01:08:47.533
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

791
01:08:47.730 --> 01:08:49.766
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for sharing your story with us.

792
01:08:51.712 --> 01:09:09.034
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Rowan Spellman, Michael Shanks, Richard Bulkovich, Brent Hoffman, Jordan Lewis.

793
01:09:11.847 --> 01:09:13.850
<v Keelan McClymont>Tyler Fellini is joining us online.

794
01:09:17.274 --> 01:09:21.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Tyler, you're welcome to come off mute and begin your testimony.

795
01:09:22.270 --> 01:09:23.963
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, uh, good evening, councilors.

796
01:09:24.545 --> 01:09:35.119
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I, uh, I want to say that I think it's incredibly telling that the most ardent, uh, opposition to, uh, this AI ban has come from, uh, you know, multi-unit property owners.

797
01:09:35.395 --> 01:09:36.417
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's incredibly telling.

798
01:09:36.676 --> 01:09:43.444
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope that, uh, It's also a shame that so many people were not able to be here tonight.

799
01:09:44.073 --> 01:09:46.802
<v Sameer Kanal>I recognize, you know, the bureaucratic process being what it is.

800
01:09:46.850 --> 01:09:54.978
<v Sameer Kanal>It's slow and steady, and I do hope that you will do your due diligence to capture those people's statements because, you know, I believe that they had something worth saying, and I hope it gets heard.

801
01:09:55.643 --> 01:09:58.137
<v Sameer Kanal>With that, I should have said this at the beginning.

802
01:09:59.706 --> 01:10:03.292
<v Sameer Kanal>I am a registered lobbyist for and the executive director of Portland Jobs with Justice.

803
01:10:03.341 --> 01:10:03.585
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Mitch Green.

804
01:10:04.582 --> 01:10:10.059
<v Sameer Kanal>And I am just here to express my support for the ban on AI price fixing.

805
01:10:10.287 --> 01:10:11.814
<v Sameer Kanal>And with that, I'll yield the rest of my time.

806
01:10:13.449 --> 01:10:13.886
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Tyler.

807
01:10:13.967 --> 01:10:17.617
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And thank you for remembering that lobbyist disclosure.

808
01:10:17.698 --> 01:10:19.904
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know folks sometimes have a hard time remembering it.

809
01:10:20.970 --> 01:10:21.458
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

810
01:10:21.637 --> 01:10:23.578
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please introduce yourself and begin your testimony.

811
01:10:28.248 --> 01:10:28.578
<v Steve Novick>Oh, me?

812
01:10:28.891 --> 01:10:29.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, go ahead.

813
01:10:31.659 --> 01:10:31.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Me?

814
01:10:32.140 --> 01:10:33.409
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, City Council.

815
01:10:33.506 --> 01:10:36.685
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Jordan Lewis, and I'm a renter in Portland Stadiumhood.

816
01:10:36.862 --> 01:10:40.859
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm testifying here in support of Councilor Morillo's algorithmic price-fixing ban.

817
01:10:41.358 --> 01:10:46.737
<v Unidentified speaker>Something that frustrates me about this conversation is that every turn we have to consider the plight of the precarious landlord.

818
01:10:47.010 --> 01:10:54.796
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not that I don't believe a landlord can be in financial precarity, but this is a rhetorical technique that hijacks the conversation and de-centers the precarious tenant.

819
01:10:55.247 --> 01:11:00.130
<v Unidentified speaker>The most precarious landlord necessarily owns a house, which puts them above the average tenant financially.

820
01:11:00.885 --> 01:11:02.860
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to talk about how popular this policy is.

821
01:11:03.037 --> 01:11:06.121
<v Unidentified speaker>I talk a lot about city politics in a lot of apolitical group chats.

822
01:11:06.731 --> 01:11:09.912
<v Unidentified speaker>You will not imagine the excitement I got when I brought up this policy in there.

823
01:11:10.506 --> 01:11:14.024
<v Unidentified speaker>I have landlord friends, friends who own their place and rent out rooms.

824
01:11:14.296 --> 01:11:16.176
<v Unidentified speaker>This policy does numbers in those group chats.

825
01:11:16.707 --> 01:11:22.938
<v Unidentified speaker>No one gets more excited about this policy than my landlord friends because policies like this alleviate I think this will alleviate a lot of the guilt that they might feel as landlords.

826
01:11:23.515 --> 01:11:25.090
<v Unidentified speaker>They almost want this more than I do.

827
01:11:25.523 --> 01:11:32.492
<v Unidentified speaker>And while I'm not sure if I can get my friends to care about climate policy or transportation like I do, when I tell them who voted no on this, they will remember it.

828
01:11:33.407 --> 01:11:35.863
<v Unidentified speaker>This is meat and potatoes anti-gentrification policy.

829
01:11:36.280 --> 01:11:37.341
<v Unidentified speaker>It shouldn't be that hard.

830
01:11:37.484 --> 01:11:40.631
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's pass this very first step so we can move on to some more interesting stuff.

831
01:11:41.194 --> 01:11:45.994
<v Unidentified speaker>The housing crisis is a multifactorial situation, and a lot of regular Americans bear some responsibility in it.

832
01:11:46.637 --> 01:11:53.011
<v Unidentified speaker>I echo the concept of a housing cartel mentioned in previous testimonies, but people love a simple villain like RealPage.

833
01:11:53.542 --> 01:11:55.372
<v Unidentified speaker>This is the lowest hanging fruit there is.

834
01:11:55.869 --> 01:11:57.090
<v Unidentified speaker>It's practically on the ground.

835
01:11:57.251 --> 01:12:09.003
<v Unidentified speaker>If we can't pass an algorithmic rent fixing ban, which really just brings software in line with a 100-year-old antitrust law, how are we supposed to challenge the housing cartel and build the housing supply that we need if we can't even do that?

836
01:12:09.533 --> 01:12:09.759
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

837
01:12:09.806 --> 01:12:12.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Thank you for being here.

838
01:12:14.890 --> 01:12:24.698
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Adam Shippey, followed by Lee Shelton and Claire Knudsen.

839
01:12:27.224 --> 01:12:28.876
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Adam, go right ahead and introduce yourself.

840
01:12:29.529 --> 01:12:32.086
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, my name is, uh, Adam Shippey, District 4.

841
01:12:32.520 --> 01:12:35.798
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, you know, my 20s I was homeless.

842
01:12:35.912 --> 01:12:38.127
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there's only one person on this council that has like Thank you.

843
01:12:38.193 --> 01:12:43.505
<v Unidentified speaker>I have firsthand personal experience with how humiliating, dehumanizing, and violent that can be.

844
01:12:44.470 --> 01:12:50.768
<v Sameer Kanal>The people that were homeless alongside me are not here to speak to this council right now because they are dead.

845
01:12:52.789 --> 01:13:01.149
<v Unidentified speaker>Suffice it to say, my circumstances improved, not through some stupid bootstrap ideology, but just through sheer luck, right?

846
01:13:01.454 --> 01:13:23.047
<v Sameer Kanal>A couple years later, I was lucky enough to marry a beautiful woman, and in 2011, we rented an apartment in Southwest Portland That had 2 bedrooms, it was 1,900 square feet, had a balcony, in-unit laundry, uh, 2 parking spaces, and a freaking storage unit for less than $1,000 a month.

847
01:13:23.193 --> 01:13:24.546
<v Sameer Kanal>Less than $1,000 a month.

848
01:13:24.594 --> 01:13:26.591
<v Sameer Kanal>It was so affordable we were able to save money.

849
01:13:27.029 --> 01:13:32.038
<v Unidentified speaker>We saved money, and with the assistance of her family, a couple years later we put a down payment on a house that we bought for $265,000.

850
01:13:34.256 --> 01:13:35.341
<v Unidentified speaker>No, no, no, $257,000.

851
01:13:36.932 --> 01:13:37.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right?

852
01:13:37.574 --> 01:13:37.993
<v Unidentified speaker>I love my house.

853
01:13:38.041 --> 01:13:38.747
<v Unidentified speaker>I still live in my house.

854
01:13:39.823 --> 01:13:50.131
<v Sameer Kanal>But like, that story, that story about someone who rose out of circumstances that could have killed them and got to the level of comfort that I have right now, that doesn't get told anymore.

855
01:13:50.323 --> 01:13:51.271
<v Sameer Kanal>That's not possible.

856
01:13:52.251 --> 01:13:55.847
<v Sameer Kanal>And these price-fixing algorithms are a huge part of that.

857
01:13:56.185 --> 01:13:57.903
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think everybody at this council knows that.

858
01:13:57.966 --> 01:14:00.311
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you don't know that, I question who you're listening to.

859
01:14:01.404 --> 01:14:08.418
<v Sameer Kanal>I've heard a lot of disingenuous arguments 2 weeks ago I really did, by people who were paid to be here, but I didn't get to speak.

860
01:14:09.591 --> 01:14:13.779
<v Unidentified speaker>But I'm speaking now, and I just want to say the landlords are going to be okay.

861
01:14:14.100 --> 01:14:14.614
<v Sameer Kanal>They are.

862
01:14:15.047 --> 01:14:15.882
<v Unidentified speaker>They really are.

863
01:14:16.412 --> 01:14:20.408
<v Sameer Kanal>And most of your constituents aren't landlords, and they're desperate and they're angry.

864
01:14:21.581 --> 01:14:22.496
<v Sameer Kanal>So please pass this.

865
01:14:23.650 --> 01:14:24.132
<v Unidentified speaker>We need it.

866
01:14:24.292 --> 01:14:29.220
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here and for sharing your story.

867
01:14:30.311 --> 01:14:44.134
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, while Lee Shelton Welcome.

868
01:14:44.427 --> 01:14:47.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead and introduce yourself, and you can begin your testimony.

869
01:14:48.770 --> 01:14:49.657
<v Angelita Morillo>Hi, I'm Jesse Dillon.

870
01:14:50.158 --> 01:14:52.224
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, City Council members, thank you for being here.

871
01:14:52.353 --> 01:14:53.661
<v Angelita Morillo>Staff, thank you for being here.

872
01:14:54.371 --> 01:14:59.597
<v Angelita Morillo>I really have great admiration and respect for anybody who volunteers to engage in this process.

873
01:15:00.871 --> 01:15:02.219
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you very much.

874
01:15:03.246 --> 01:15:08.525
<v Angelita Morillo>My name is Jesse Dillon, and let me be clear, I absolutely do not support price fixing.

875
01:15:09.265 --> 01:15:16.390
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't support monopolistic ideals, but I also do not support this amendment.

876
01:15:17.627 --> 01:15:31.046
<v Angelita Morillo>There are flaws to the amendment, and I am very concerned that it will cost me as a housing provider to increase rents to cover the costs because I'm going to be sued for frivolous lawsuits based on the way that it's written right now.

877
01:15:32.073 --> 01:15:36.713
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm a mother, a U.S. Army veteran, a business owner, and a housing provider.

878
01:15:37.453 --> 01:15:43.039
<v Angelita Morillo>I take great pride in all of the roles that I fulfill, and I have a strong set of personal values that guide me in my decision-making.

879
01:15:43.795 --> 01:15:56.457
<v Angelita Morillo>I hold those values near to my heart and encourage those around me, as well as expect my staff, my colleagues, and my children To reflect on their personal values and live them each day with each decision they make.

880
01:15:56.953 --> 01:15:58.766
<v Angelita Morillo>My favorite personal value is integrity.

881
01:15:59.359 --> 01:16:01.541
<v Angelita Morillo>Do the right thing even when no one is looking.

882
01:16:02.487 --> 01:16:08.309
<v Angelita Morillo>Today I urge you each to exercise integrity in your position as Portland City Council members.

883
01:16:08.966 --> 01:16:16.921
<v Angelita Morillo>You are elected by the citizens of Portland to do what they cannot do for themselves, to collectively ensure the local government does the right thing.

884
01:16:17.001 --> 01:16:17.145
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

885
01:16:17.965 --> 01:16:29.226
<v Angelita Morillo>If you vote yes for this amendment to the Affordable Housing Code, it will have an unintended consequence of increasing the cost of housing, and it will entice frivolous lawsuits to be filed, resulting in housing providers in the city of Portland to be uninsurable.

886
01:16:30.987 --> 01:16:32.512
<v Angelita Morillo>I've lived in Portland for 18 years.

887
01:16:32.788 --> 01:16:38.358
<v Angelita Morillo>I've been a housing provider for the same amount of time, and I'm very proud of the work that I do as a housing provider.

888
01:16:38.921 --> 01:16:47.109
<v Angelita Morillo>It's tough, though, because I have to balance running a business with making really hard decisions related to the employees that I care about and work hard for me, as well as the decisions that residents.

889
01:16:49.489 --> 01:16:54.975
<v Angelita Morillo>Rely on me and my staff to provide them with safe, warm, and habitable homes.

890
01:16:55.412 --> 01:16:57.985
<v Angelita Morillo>I wish I had 20 more minutes, but I appreciate your time.

891
01:16:58.082 --> 01:17:00.810
<v Angelita Morillo>I'll submit the rest of my comments online.

892
01:17:00.988 --> 01:17:01.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

893
01:17:01.199 --> 01:17:02.483
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much for being here.

894
01:17:05.056 --> 01:17:07.475
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Christina Dirks.

895
01:17:09.300 --> 01:17:11.481
<v Keelan McClymont>Mike Semko joining us online.

896
01:17:12.743 --> 01:17:13.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mike, go right ahead.

897
01:17:14.488 --> 01:17:17.332
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much, Council President and members of Thank you, Mayor.

898
01:17:17.430 --> 01:17:19.019
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening, members of the Portland City Council.

899
01:17:19.068 --> 01:17:23.738
<v Unidentified speaker>I really appreciate you allowing us to testify this evening.

900
01:17:25.329 --> 01:17:26.760
<v Unidentified speaker>I do represent RealPage.

901
01:17:26.970 --> 01:17:30.337
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Vice President and Associate General Counsel there.

902
01:17:31.529 --> 01:17:34.909
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a lot of misinformation about pricing software in general.

903
01:17:36.858 --> 01:17:40.787
<v Unidentified speaker>All we do is market analysis with a pricing suggestion.

904
01:17:41.060 --> 01:17:42.122
<v Sameer Kanal>We do not set the rents.

905
01:17:44.082 --> 01:17:53.750
<v Unidentified speaker>In most of the Sunbelt, in fact all of the Sunbelt right now where we have our largest market penetration, our software is recommending lower rents.

906
01:17:54.268 --> 01:17:56.747
<v Unidentified speaker>That's from Arizona all the way across the South.

907
01:17:57.493 --> 01:18:00.279
<v Unidentified speaker>We can count maybe Denver, Colorado as part of the Sunbelt.

908
01:18:00.345 --> 01:18:02.853
<v Unidentified speaker>They'll be happy to know all the way up through Virginia.

909
01:18:03.581 --> 01:18:07.916
<v Unidentified speaker>Our software is recommending in a lot of cases double-digit rent decreases.

910
01:18:08.029 --> 01:18:08.126
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

911
01:18:09.181 --> 01:18:11.324
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's not because of the software.

912
01:18:11.856 --> 01:18:16.561
<v Unidentified speaker>It's because of the market dynamics at play in the Sunbelt right now.

913
01:18:16.836 --> 01:18:19.081
<v Unidentified speaker>And that is, they've built a lot of new housing.

914
01:18:20.470 --> 01:18:22.411
<v Unidentified speaker>That is the only way to lower rents.

915
01:18:22.605 --> 01:18:25.826
<v Unidentified speaker>And I feel for people who are having to deal with high rents.

916
01:18:25.922 --> 01:18:26.408
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really do.

917
01:18:27.109 --> 01:18:31.716
<v Unidentified speaker>But the only way, uh, to lower rent is to build more product.

918
01:18:32.010 --> 01:18:32.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's it.

919
01:18:33.313 --> 01:18:43.213
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, You know, our software really just applies math to data.

920
01:18:43.922 --> 01:18:50.759
<v Unidentified speaker>And what this draft ordinance does at the present moment, it doesn't ban price fixing.

921
01:18:51.532 --> 01:18:57.225
<v Sameer Kanal>It bans the use of datasets and applied math.

922
01:18:58.411 --> 01:19:00.877
<v Unidentified speaker>Essentially what you're doing is you're banning a math tool.

923
01:19:02.020 --> 01:19:03.318
<v Sameer Kanal>That's not going to help anybody.

924
01:19:03.430 --> 01:19:05.247
<v Unidentified speaker>It certainly won't help housing providers.

925
01:19:05.360 --> 01:19:09.007
<v Sameer Kanal>And by the way, it won't help your residents either.

926
01:19:11.756 --> 01:19:18.086
<v Unidentified speaker>If we're a cartel, we're the worst cartel in history because where we have the highest market penetration, rents are falling.

927
01:19:18.680 --> 01:19:21.787
<v Unidentified speaker>And where we have very little market penetration, rents are rising.

928
01:19:23.109 --> 01:19:23.565
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

929
01:19:24.756 --> 01:19:26.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here today.

930
01:19:26.975 --> 01:19:50.112
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Colin Brown, Joe Hovey, Rajesh Venkachalappathy, Lena Mayapool, Holly Hamilton.

931
01:19:53.970 --> 01:19:55.815
<v Keelan McClymont>Antonia Januzzi Thomas.

932
01:20:00.060 --> 01:20:01.015
<v Keelan McClymont>Jordan Byers.

933
01:20:05.470 --> 01:20:05.871
<v Keelan McClymont>Catherine King.

934
01:20:10.885 --> 01:20:11.463
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

935
01:20:12.332 --> 01:20:14.988
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go ahead and introduce yourself and you can begin your testimony.

936
01:20:15.559 --> 01:20:16.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for the opportunity.

937
01:20:17.039 --> 01:20:17.984
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My name is Catherine King.

938
01:20:18.435 --> 01:20:18.890
<v Steve Novick>Good evening.

939
01:20:22.002 --> 01:20:28.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My name is Catherine King, and I'm a rental owner since 1997, and I have had rentals in Districts 3, 2, and 1.

940
01:20:29.541 --> 01:20:33.639
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My company, KJK Properties, P.C., is located in District 1.

941
01:20:34.542 --> 01:20:37.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have managed rentals since 2003 in all 4 districts.

942
01:20:38.882 --> 01:20:41.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our company needs rental data software in order to be—.

943
01:20:42.207 --> 01:20:46.913
<v Unidentified speaker>To best serve our clients who own 220 rental doors in the Portland metro area.

944
01:20:47.978 --> 01:20:56.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As a rental owner for 29 years and the manager of many rentals before clients since 2003, I wholeheartedly oppose this policy.

945
01:20:57.363 --> 01:21:00.796
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Housing providers are your existing clients and voters.

946
01:21:01.134 --> 01:21:06.845
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Without housing providers and housing willingness rentals, you lose vitally needed housing stock.

947
01:21:07.471 --> 01:21:11.627
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We simply cannot encourage our owners to continue selling out their rentals.

948
01:21:12.301 --> 01:21:19.002
<v Unidentified speaker>We have lost significant housing stock since 2015 when the first rent control ordinance went into effect in Portland.

949
01:21:19.610 --> 01:21:24.019
<v Angelita Morillo>Small owners and professionals that house Oregonians cannot work without data.

950
01:21:24.787 --> 01:21:26.872
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are not colluding to price fix.

951
01:21:28.010 --> 01:21:34.567
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A housing provider cannot provide housing without relevant data.

952
01:21:35.448 --> 01:21:39.938
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>An appraiser cannot accurately value homes without relevant data.

953
01:21:40.515 --> 01:21:48.063
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How can Fred Meyer price eggs without being able to see the data on their inventory and suppliers and the demand in the market?

954
01:21:48.207 --> 01:21:49.025
<v Unidentified speaker>They cannot.

955
01:21:49.492 --> 01:21:54.131
<v Unidentified speaker>The easiest housing stock for renters is the housing stock you already have.

956
01:21:54.725 --> 01:21:59.511
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The easiest housing stock for renters is the housing stock you already have.

957
01:22:00.265 --> 01:22:04.664
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have driven out the majority of investment in Portland already, and we have been bleeding rental units.

958
01:22:05.532 --> 01:22:19.372
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I currently have 8 listings for sale in total that are all rentals that owners are selling because they no longer support having rentals in this policy environment that fails to see that biting the hand that feeds the housing stock is not the right answer.

959
01:22:20.096 --> 01:22:21.981
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Supply and demand drive pricing.

960
01:22:22.158 --> 01:22:24.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You are adding to the lack of supply issue.

961
01:22:26.083 --> 01:22:26.506
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

962
01:22:26.654 --> 01:22:30.368
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, we just have 2 minutes per person, but I appreciate you sharing your testimony.

963
01:22:30.470 --> 01:22:31.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Testimony with us.

964
01:22:33.887 --> 01:22:35.091
<v Keelan McClymont>Alicia, Alicia Morisseth.

965
01:22:37.462 --> 01:22:39.604
<v Keelan McClymont>Eamon Rutherford.

966
01:22:41.971 --> 01:22:45.305
<v Keelan McClymont>Ionda Allen is joining us online.

967
01:22:49.449 --> 01:22:52.125
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please go ahead and unmute yourself and begin your testimony.

968
01:22:56.095 --> 01:22:57.171
<v Sameer Kanal>Hi, can everyone hear me?

969
01:22:58.502 --> 01:22:59.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can, yes.

970
01:23:00.106 --> 01:23:00.234
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

971
01:23:00.587 --> 01:23:01.711
<v Sameer Kanal>Hello, Council.

972
01:23:01.952 --> 01:23:06.300
<v Sameer Kanal>First and foremost, um, thank you so much for taking time out tonight to hear me.

973
01:23:06.380 --> 01:23:07.551
<v Sameer Kanal>My name is Yande Allen.

974
01:23:07.662 --> 01:23:12.862
<v Sameer Kanal>I am the Director of Community Engagement and Advocacy at the Community Alliance of Tenants.

975
01:23:13.262 --> 01:23:24.432
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I am encouraging the passing of, um, the prohibition of AI being used to Increase rent, excuse me.

976
01:23:25.226 --> 01:23:29.650
<v Sameer Kanal>At the Community Alliance of Tenants, we get calls every day.

977
01:23:30.569 --> 01:23:46.484
<v Sameer Kanal>We are interacting every day with tenants across the state who are struggling to stay within their housing, who are struggling to afford the thought of even moving, much more re-signing a lease that is being increased, or—.

978
01:23:46.484 --> 01:23:47.439
<v Unidentified speaker>Please forgive me, so sorry.

979
01:23:49.176 --> 01:23:57.720
<v Sameer Kanal>Who are struggling with the thought of being able to stay in their homes much more, what their lease renewal will look like.

980
01:23:58.252 --> 01:24:16.145
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm just encouraging this council to please take the considerations as proposed by other people who have come before me and people after me in consideration in hopes of passing this ordinance to make sure that we are keeping people housed and we are not exacerbating the already ongoing crisis within the city.

981
01:24:19.097 --> 01:24:24.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for joining us tonight.

982
01:24:24.356 --> 01:24:25.533
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

983
01:24:27.637 --> 01:24:33.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, well, thank you for everybody who showed up multiple times to wait for your turn to share your testimony with us.

984
01:24:34.153 --> 01:24:41.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that the scheduling of this has been hard, but I am glad that you were able to be here tonight and that we were able to hear from you.

985
01:24:43.556 --> 01:24:48.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe Councilor Morillo has a motion to make on this agenda item.

986
01:24:50.970 --> 01:24:52.055
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

987
01:24:52.525 --> 01:24:58.234
<v Angelita Morillo>I just want to start off by thanking everyone so much who has come multiple times to City Hall to testify.

988
01:24:59.238 --> 01:25:11.889
<v Angelita Morillo>It means a lot to us how engaged you are in the process, that you've come to committee, that you've come to full council, and it's just immense how much you guys care about your community and what's going on in it, and I'm extremely grateful for that.

989
01:25:13.368 --> 01:25:24.591
<v Angelita Morillo>I also wanted to say that just this past week, an article came out that said that in the 5 hours since opening the waitlist on Tuesday, Home Forward received nearly 7,000 applications.

990
01:25:25.411 --> 01:25:35.157
<v Angelita Morillo>And our 2024 Portland Insight Survey just came out, and it showed that 72.4% of Portlanders told us that affordable housing was their top issue.

991
01:25:35.381 --> 01:25:36.988
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

992
01:25:38.431 --> 01:25:48.465
<v Angelita Morillo>It's kind of with a heavy heart that I have to say this, that there's some new litigation elsewhere that touches on similar issues with the algorithmic price-fixing ordinance.

993
01:25:49.073 --> 01:26:02.904
<v Angelita Morillo>And I wanna assert that the litigation is not determinative of what's going to happen here, but it's worth us keeping an eye on and being responsible stewards of policy and maintaining good conversations with stakeholders as we look into it.

994
01:26:03.434 --> 01:26:12.554
<v Angelita Morillo>So while the council is facing other immediate priorities like the upcoming budget, It makes sense to me to keep this item in the committee for further discussion.

995
01:26:13.184 --> 01:26:17.896
<v Angelita Morillo>So with that, I move to refer item 9 back to the Homelessness and Housing Committee.

996
01:26:18.511 --> 01:26:19.805
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

997
01:26:20.694 --> 01:26:28.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any discussion on the motion before us to move this agenda item back to the Committee on Homelessness and Housing?

998
01:26:32.768 --> 01:26:35.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing no one in the queue, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

999
01:26:37.908 --> 01:26:42.947
<v Keelan McClymont>Just to verify, that was moved by Councilor Murillo and seconded by Koyama Lane?

1000
01:26:43.011 --> 01:26:43.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Correct.

1001
01:26:43.158 --> 01:26:44.063
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1002
01:26:44.143 --> 01:26:44.448
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1003
01:26:45.011 --> 01:26:45.363
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1004
01:26:48.560 --> 01:26:50.970
<v Sameer Kanal>This is on the motion to refer back to committee?

1005
01:26:51.436 --> 01:26:51.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Correct.

1006
01:26:52.256 --> 01:27:01.432
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I can't say I'm an expert on the litigation, but I think on this particular thing, I'm very happy to follow my colleague, my renter colleague's lead on it.

1007
01:27:01.497 --> 01:27:02.284
<v Sameer Kanal>So I will vote aye.

1008
01:27:04.896 --> 01:27:04.944
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1009
01:27:06.988 --> 01:27:07.036
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1010
01:27:09.640 --> 01:27:09.689
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1011
01:27:11.747 --> 01:27:15.564
<v Steve Novick>Really appreciate the testimony tonight and look forward to seeing this item again when it comes back to us.

1012
01:27:17.045 --> 01:27:17.094
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1013
01:27:18.172 --> 01:27:18.220
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1014
01:27:20.667 --> 01:27:29.359
<v Unidentified speaker>I also appreciate the testimony tonight, and I'll just acknowledge that, uh, the chief sponsor of this has done an incredible amount of homework, and I'm just going to take her lead on something like this.

1015
01:27:29.426 --> 01:27:30.595
<v Unidentified speaker>So, uh, I vote aye.

1016
01:27:34.033 --> 01:27:34.212
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1017
01:27:35.425 --> 01:27:41.461
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much to all of the folks that come out to really express what is clearly a need in our city.

1018
01:27:42.125 --> 01:27:45.872
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and as chair of the Homeless Assistance Housing Committee, I really want this bill to work.

1019
01:27:45.921 --> 01:27:51.750
<v Candace Avalos>And so I'm eager to bring it back to committee, make sure that it can succeed, and I'm looking forward to it coming back to council.

1020
01:27:51.911 --> 01:27:52.216
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I vote aye.

1021
01:27:53.505 --> 01:28:01.447
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm disappointed, uh, that we don't get the resolution tonight, but I look forward to working on it With my colleagues in the Housing and Homelessness Committee, I vote aye.

1022
01:28:04.466 --> 01:28:04.530
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1023
01:28:06.726 --> 01:28:15.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you to everybody who is here tonight and the folks who have shared their stories and their both support and concerns over the last few times that we've heard this.

1024
01:28:15.612 --> 01:28:19.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know that housing costs too much in Portland.

1025
01:28:19.412 --> 01:28:25.537
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know that that's a challenge up and down the West Coast, but it's one that we feel particularly acutely in our city here.

1026
01:28:27.190 --> 01:28:47.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate the sponsor working with all of us to ensure that we can address this issue in the best way possible and look forward to continuing to work on this ordinance and also on the many other steps that I know we need to take to address housing affordability broadly in our city.

1027
01:28:48.336 --> 01:28:48.384
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1028
01:28:49.493 --> 01:28:50.862
<v Keelan McClymont>12 Yes votes.

1029
01:28:50.926 --> 01:28:51.747
<v Keelan McClymont>The item is referred back to council.

1030
01:29:00.390 --> 01:29:06.351
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we are moving on to agenda item 10.

1031
01:29:06.868 --> 01:29:08.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please read the agenda item?

1032
01:29:09.609 --> 01:29:16.805
<v Keelan McClymont>Amend the FY 2024-25 technical adjustment ordinance and make other budget-related changes.

1033
01:29:17.757 --> 01:29:18.353
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1034
01:29:18.658 --> 01:29:24.326
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we do have a committee staff summary for the technical adjustment ordinance.

1035
01:29:25.002 --> 01:29:28.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see Christopher Hare is here to share that with us.

1036
01:29:28.872 --> 01:29:29.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Christopher, go right ahead.

1037
01:29:30.895 --> 01:29:34.599
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening, Madam President, Madam Vice President, councilors.

1038
01:29:35.342 --> 01:29:41.292
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, my name is Christopher Hare, Council Policy Analyst with Council Operations, and I serve as staff to the Finance Committee.

1039
01:29:41.645 --> 01:29:47.149
<v Unidentified speaker>The emergency ordinance before you, document number 2025-1, Councilmember Herbold.

1040
01:29:47.149 --> 01:29:47.210
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mayor.

1041
01:29:47.210 --> 01:29:51.210
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember Herbold, I'd like to introduce Council Bill 120, which was first discussed in the Finance Committee on March 24th as a presentation.

1042
01:29:51.649 --> 01:29:58.760
<v Unidentified speaker>It was later considered in the Finance Committee on April 1st as an emergency ordinance where it was referred to council with a recommendation to pass.

1043
01:29:59.069 --> 01:30:13.489
<v Unidentified speaker>The emergency ordinance amends the FY 2024-25 appropriation schedule for certain expenditures across various budgets— across various funds and amends the number of authorized positions in the FY 2024-25 revised budget.

1044
01:30:14.872 --> 01:30:28.300
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendments to the FY 2024-25 appropriation schedule allocates resources from a general fund policy set-aside reserve to draw down $3.5 million from the projected police overtime buydown set-aside.

1045
01:30:28.831 --> 01:30:40.279
<v Unidentified speaker>It reduces $6,078,879 from FY 2024-25 bureau budgets to be carried into their respective FY 2025-26 budgets.

1046
01:30:40.328 --> 01:30:40.476
<v Sameer Kanal>Second.

1047
01:30:41.029 --> 01:30:55.760
<v Unidentified speaker>There are additional adjustments representing internal transfers, realignments, and other adjustments that do not impact the general fund discretionary or contingency balances.

1048
01:30:55.760 --> 01:31:06.979
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendments to the FY 2024-25 revised budgets reduce 1 FTE from Portland Fire and Rescue and 1 FTE from Portland Police Bureau, which are then realigned as an additional 2 FTE under the Office of the Deputy City Administrator.

1049
01:31:06.979 --> 01:31:07.020
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1050
01:31:09.966 --> 01:31:17.869
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, one FTE is being removed from the Portland Police Bureau to fund the conversion of a limited-term position into a regular permanent position within the bureau.

1051
01:31:18.774 --> 01:31:33.295
<v Unidentified speaker>The ordinance will change the appropriation in 47 funds by a net reduction of $1,777,925, primarily as a result of balancing the beginning FY 2025-26 funds and other resources.

1052
01:31:33.342 --> 01:31:33.456
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1053
01:31:34.103 --> 01:31:38.453
<v Unidentified speaker>There's also a net increase of $3.46 million to the general fund.

1054
01:31:38.920 --> 01:31:43.335
<v Unidentified speaker>The net change in FTE from this ordinance is the reduction of one limited duration FTE.

1055
01:31:44.217 --> 01:31:49.372
<v Unidentified speaker>An emergency clause has been added to this ordinance to enable the implementation of the adjustments without delay.

1056
01:31:50.238 --> 01:31:58.668
<v Unidentified speaker>The full impact statement on this item includes a financial and budget impact and analysis and information on potential community impact and community involvement.

1057
01:31:59.149 --> 01:32:02.007
<v Unidentified speaker>There was no verbal or written testimony on this ordinance prior to committee action.

1058
01:32:02.056 --> 01:32:02.248
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1059
01:32:02.975 --> 01:32:04.475
<v Unidentified speaker>This concludes the committee staff summary.

1060
01:32:04.587 --> 01:32:04.990
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1061
01:32:05.152 --> 01:32:07.311
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Christopher.

1062
01:32:07.811 --> 01:32:13.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, is there anything that you would like to add as the chair who presided over this meeting?

1063
01:32:14.283 --> 01:32:14.528
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1064
01:32:14.853 --> 01:32:15.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1065
01:32:16.952 --> 01:32:38.005
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, this is an agenda item that came from the mayor's office, from the administrative side, so we don't have a council I think moving to discussion is great.

1066
01:32:38.230 --> 01:32:38.489
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1067
01:32:38.555 --> 01:32:39.622
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1068
01:32:39.768 --> 01:32:41.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, is there any public testimony signed up?

1069
01:32:42.145 --> 01:32:42.939
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1070
01:32:43.117 --> 01:32:43.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1071
01:32:44.072 --> 01:32:46.481
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, you are first in the queue.

1072
01:32:47.210 --> 01:32:49.907
<v Sameer Kanal>I have a question and then a comment, if that's all right, Madam President.

1073
01:32:50.052 --> 01:32:56.342
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, and we do have budget office staff here with us today if anybody has questions that they need answered from our budget office staff.

1074
01:32:56.728 --> 01:32:58.849
<v Sameer Kanal>My question, yeah, it may go to either of you.

1075
01:32:58.898 --> 01:33:01.162
<v Sameer Kanal>My comment definitely will require budget office staff.

1076
01:33:02.046 --> 01:33:05.307
<v Sameer Kanal>So my question is, if you could just give a little bit more clarity.

1077
01:33:05.966 --> 01:33:08.457
<v Sameer Kanal>We use the phrase drawdown, Christopher.

1078
01:33:09.356 --> 01:33:18.226
<v Sameer Kanal>The amendments to the appropriation schedule allocates resources from a general fund policy set-aside reserve to draw down $3.5 million from the projected police overtime.

1079
01:33:18.676 --> 01:33:24.024
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you just clarify for the public what that exactly means, and then I'll make my comment after that.

1080
01:33:24.521 --> 01:33:24.762
<v Angelita Morillo>Sure.

1081
01:33:25.100 --> 01:33:26.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, I can be here.

1082
01:33:26.689 --> 01:33:26.898
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

1083
01:33:27.509 --> 01:33:28.680
<v Olivia Clark>For the record, my name is Ruth Levine.

1084
01:33:28.856 --> 01:33:30.333
<v Olivia Clark>I'm the director of the City Budget Office.

1085
01:33:30.399 --> 01:33:44.238
<v Olivia Clark>So the drawdown term— so just for general background, the $3.5 million was put into policy set aside by the previous council in the fall bump in 2024.

1086
01:33:45.475 --> 01:34:03.905
<v Olivia Clark>And excuse me, it was put there to sort of as a pot of money essentially that would be available to the council based on updated projections around overtime in the police bureau in the spring, which is now.

1087
01:34:04.420 --> 01:34:23.590
<v Olivia Clark>And so essentially the idea behind it was to sort of be able to wait and see and provide flexibility based on how, you know, certain events, specific events including like the election, panned out and how their overtime generally was trending.

1088
01:34:24.729 --> 01:34:34.653
<v Olivia Clark>And so this ordinance would draw it down, meaning it would take it out of the policy set-aside, which is contingency, and put it into the police bureau's budget.

1089
01:34:35.729 --> 01:34:37.574
<v Olivia Clark>You can't— nobody can spend out of contingency.

1090
01:34:38.073 --> 01:34:44.970
<v Olivia Clark>Which means that it requires a council action to move funding out of contingency into a bureau's budget in order for them to be able to spend it.

1091
01:34:45.306 --> 01:34:50.649
<v Olivia Clark>And so that's what that drawdown term refers to, is just moving it from contingency into the bureau's budget.

1092
01:34:51.784 --> 01:34:52.481
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1093
01:34:53.569 --> 01:34:54.346
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for clarifying.

1094
01:34:56.039 --> 01:35:08.216
<v Sameer Kanal>I, Madam President, I would like to propose an amendment, and I will send this over to— I think I have sent it over to the clerk, but if there's more information I need to give, it's a motion to make the following adjustment Councilor Dan Ryan.

1095
01:35:08.264 --> 01:35:17.721
<v Sameer Kanal>I would like to move that the council approve the adjustments to the supplemental budget as proposed to change general fund return decision packages to general fund carryover decision packages within the public safety service area.

1096
01:35:17.885 --> 01:35:33.823
<v Sameer Kanal>It would reallocate the policy set aside in the general fund by $737,427 to change a general fund return Portland Fire and Rescue carryover for firefighters as general fund return to a general fund program carryover for the Portland Fire and Rescue Department.

1097
01:35:33.920 --> 01:35:34.100
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1098
01:35:34.100 --> 01:35:34.100
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1099
01:35:34.100 --> 01:35:34.100
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilmember Herbold.

1100
01:35:34.100 --> 01:35:53.689
<v Sameer Kanal>I move that the City of Portland Fire and Rescue program carryover for firefighters and reallocate the policy set aside in the general fund by $100,000 to change the general fund return that's marked PX Contact Survey General Fund Return to a general fund program carryover for PX Contact Survey Program Carryover.

1101
01:35:54.020 --> 01:35:58.680
<v Sameer Kanal>And the amendment would also include updating exhibits 1 through 5 as needed to reflect this change.

1102
01:35:58.680 --> 01:36:03.907
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't think it So I can speak to it, but I wanted to put that forward.

1103
01:36:04.469 --> 01:36:06.505
<v Sameer Kanal>And what this— can I clarify one thing?

1104
01:36:07.097 --> 01:36:07.274
<v Unidentified speaker>Please.

1105
01:36:07.338 --> 01:36:26.548
<v Sameer Kanal>This is allowing Portland Fire and Rescue and the Public Safety Service Area to use money that is already allocated to their budget this year, next fiscal year, because they have been unable to spend that money in this fiscal year for reasons that are particular to each of those 2 things.

1106
01:36:27.641 --> 01:36:33.056
<v Sameer Kanal>It's allowing them to use their existing money for that purpose across the fiscal year line.

1107
01:36:33.764 --> 01:36:34.487
<v Sameer Kanal>Does that make sense?

1108
01:36:34.614 --> 01:36:37.331
<v Sameer Kanal>And you can clarify, Ruth, if I didn't say that clearly enough.

1109
01:36:37.845 --> 01:36:38.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1110
01:36:39.018 --> 01:36:43.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So essentially, councilors, right now this money is coming back to the general fund.

1111
01:36:43.372 --> 01:36:47.115
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It would become part of the funds available as we begin our budgeting.

1112
01:36:47.631 --> 01:36:52.498
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In some cases, we allow bureaus to carry funds over into the next fiscal year.

1113
01:36:53.077 --> 01:37:05.182
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rather than having the money come back to the general fund for future allocation, which could be to the same thing or to something else, this would carry that over and ensure that it was reallocated for these same purposes.

1114
01:37:05.695 --> 01:37:12.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Knoll, can you just restate what the 2 purposes are, what the 2 lines are that you are making this change to?

1115
01:37:13.162 --> 01:37:13.627
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1116
01:37:13.868 --> 01:37:22.121
<v Sameer Kanal>And for those who wanna follow along, the best place to look at this is Exhibit 4 in the middle of the first page, there's a big table.

1117
01:37:22.250 --> 01:37:24.880
<v Sameer Kanal>And can I share screen or have you do so, Keelan?

1118
01:37:26.219 --> 01:37:26.766
<v Sameer Kanal>Either way is good.

1119
01:37:28.403 --> 01:37:29.903
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, yeah, let me see if we can pull it up.

1120
01:37:33.872 --> 01:37:43.171
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And for folks who are following along, um, this is linked if you look at our agenda, um, which is posted online.

1121
01:37:43.353 --> 01:37:47.490
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You're going to agenda item number Councilor Dan Ryan, you're on the agenda item number 10.

1122
01:37:47.637 --> 01:37:52.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then when you get to that agenda item, you're scrolling down to the exhibits to Exhibit 4.

1123
01:37:57.208 --> 01:37:59.359
<v Sameer Kanal>Keelan, let me know what you prefer.

1124
01:38:00.063 --> 01:38:01.355
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, we're pulling it up.

1125
01:38:01.599 --> 01:38:01.856
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1126
01:38:02.068 --> 01:38:02.810
<v Keelan McClymont>Give us just a second.

1127
01:38:03.877 --> 01:38:21.998
<v Sameer Kanal>So for those who have it up, and when you see it, you're going to see a table that has a row— sorry, a column with a lot of money that's being removed from this fiscal year's money allocations, and then a second column that has the same amount for many of those things.

1128
01:38:22.832 --> 01:38:28.025
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's money that's being carried over or rolling over from this year to next year.

1129
01:38:28.443 --> 01:38:30.880
<v Sameer Kanal>There are several lines, however, that do not roll over.

1130
01:38:30.927 --> 01:38:33.636
<v Sameer Kanal>They have a zero in that second column.

1131
01:38:34.998 --> 01:38:38.204
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is in the middle, the middle big table.

1132
01:38:38.728 --> 01:38:41.859
<v Sameer Kanal>There's those 4 that you see kind of together that have a 0 in the right column.

1133
01:38:42.213 --> 01:38:43.310
<v Sameer Kanal>It's the middle 2 of those.

1134
01:38:44.149 --> 01:38:57.404
<v Sameer Kanal>And my amendment would basically be to put the $100,000 in the left column also into the right column for PX contact survey carryover and the $737,000 there for the next line for Portland Fire and Rescue over.

1135
01:38:58.618 --> 01:39:02.340
<v Sameer Kanal>This would allow, and I'll explain each one of them, they're 2 together.

1136
01:39:02.582 --> 01:39:05.787
<v Sameer Kanal>It's money that would be used for one-time training costs for firefighters.

1137
01:39:05.868 --> 01:39:05.948
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1138
01:39:06.802 --> 01:39:09.176
<v Sameer Kanal>Which would do 2 things.

1139
01:39:09.288 --> 01:39:20.561
<v Sameer Kanal>It would allow them to pay the cost of training firefighters, which takes 10 months roughly from recruitment to being able to be in the traveler pool, picking up shifts and reducing overtime.

1140
01:39:22.020 --> 01:39:32.653
<v Sameer Kanal>And it would also give certainty to Portland Fire and Rescue today, not in June, which would mean that it is more likely that they could get that recruitment done very early in the fall.

1141
01:39:32.765 --> 01:39:32.893
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1142
01:39:32.989 --> 01:39:43.465
<v Sameer Kanal>Fiscal year, which is really critical because 10 months from the beginning of this fiscal year, in May of next year, we have a 27-pay period which will lead to a retirement wave.

1143
01:39:44.203 --> 01:39:52.979
<v Sameer Kanal>So having recruits ready to go when the retirements hit, as opposed to 2 months after the retirement hit, is the main benefit of doing this now as opposed to later.

1144
01:39:53.353 --> 01:39:57.469
<v Sameer Kanal>Also, we don't know if it would be done later, but assuming even if it was, it's better to do it now.

1145
01:39:58.953 --> 01:40:00.703
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the $737,000.

1146
01:40:00.960 --> 01:40:13.854
<v Sameer Kanal>The $100,000 one is a contact survey program, which would implement a customer service post-incident event when a community member interacts with the police.

1147
01:40:14.448 --> 01:40:23.969
<v Sameer Kanal>This is something that was recommended by the community— sorry, compliance officer community liaison for the settlement agreement for Portland Police.

1148
01:40:24.403 --> 01:40:28.462
<v Sameer Kanal>It was then recommended by the Portland Committee on Community Engaged Policing.

1149
01:40:28.880 --> 01:40:31.592
<v Sameer Kanal>That recommendation was endorsed by Chief Day and Mayor Wheeler.

1150
01:40:32.331 --> 01:40:39.328
<v Sameer Kanal>It was a workshop, a work table was set up to create an RFP, a request for proposal, to find a vendor to implement this.

1151
01:40:39.729 --> 01:40:43.774
<v Sameer Kanal>That work was done, including labor, including a lot of partners, which we can speak to.

1152
01:40:43.822 --> 01:40:44.591
<v Sameer Kanal>Some of them are in the room.

1153
01:40:45.250 --> 01:40:49.295
<v Sameer Kanal>And then it went to procurement, and there was a delay at procurement.

1154
01:40:49.841 --> 01:41:00.715
<v Sameer Kanal>And as a result, the RFP would not get done in time for them to use the money So this would allow them to continue using that money into next year and avoid the entire project getting shut down.

1155
01:41:01.671 --> 01:41:03.220
<v Sameer Kanal>And that, I think, is a success.

1156
01:41:03.644 --> 01:41:04.849
<v Sameer Kanal>I can speak more if anyone has questions.

1157
01:41:06.579 --> 01:41:07.382
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1158
01:41:07.896 --> 01:41:26.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ruth, are you able to share with us whether these are requests that were made by the DCA and then zeroed out in a decision by folks in the administrator or the mayor's office, or whether these are requests Yeah, I can—.

1159
01:41:26.301 --> 01:41:29.032
<v Olivia Clark>They were requests that were made by the service area.

1160
01:41:29.306 --> 01:41:36.287
<v Olivia Clark>The reason they were zeroed out was simply that we were trying to apply a pretty strict lens on carryovers.

1161
01:41:36.481 --> 01:41:43.894
<v Olivia Clark>So we were looking at things that had actually begun this fiscal year and just didn't— wouldn't be completed this fiscal year.

1162
01:41:44.009 --> 01:41:47.018
<v Olivia Clark>So, you know, that was the rationale behind that.

1163
01:41:47.083 --> 01:41:47.314
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1164
01:41:48.855 --> 01:41:49.341
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1165
01:41:49.988 --> 01:41:51.347
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, you're in the queue.

1166
01:41:52.189 --> 01:41:54.664
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we need to have a second before we move to discussion.

1167
01:41:55.185 --> 01:41:57.497
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, sorry, you're right, Councilor Zimmerman.

1168
01:41:57.707 --> 01:41:58.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for catching me.

1169
01:42:00.521 --> 01:42:02.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we have a second from Councilor Avalos.

1170
01:42:03.655 --> 01:42:04.266
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1171
01:42:05.327 --> 01:42:05.712
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1172
01:42:06.211 --> 01:42:09.248
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, a couple things I want to get some clarity on.

1173
01:42:10.118 --> 01:42:17.043
<v Loretta Smith>So these other dollars, they also put the spring bump in here, right, as a part of this money?

1174
01:42:17.189 --> 01:42:21.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I'm sorry, I believe we're doing discussion to the proposed amendment right now.

1175
01:42:22.024 --> 01:42:22.489
<v Loretta Smith>To the proposed—.

1176
01:42:22.489 --> 01:42:23.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I should have asked.

1177
01:42:23.439 --> 01:42:24.390
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, I'm sorry.

1178
01:42:25.051 --> 01:42:30.917
<v Loretta Smith>So again, my, um, answer is still the same.

1179
01:42:31.832 --> 01:42:38.613
<v Loretta Smith>We should not be working on Budget 25-26 before we have a chance to look at the entire budget.

1180
01:42:40.094 --> 01:42:40.351
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1181
01:42:40.885 --> 01:42:51.113
<v Loretta Smith>And the DCAs, the mayor, the city manager, whoever brought this forward, the city budget office, I was going to say the same thing.

1182
01:42:51.484 --> 01:43:05.078
<v Loretta Smith>So no, we should not— until we find out what the mayor's budget is, we can't be acting on— there may be something more important than this, Sameer, that we have to do for money pieces.

1183
01:43:06.614 --> 01:43:13.105
<v Loretta Smith>I don't have a problem with policy, but money pieces, you have to wait until the budget is dropped.

1184
01:43:14.457 --> 01:43:17.747
<v Loretta Smith>And so that's where it begins and ends.

1185
01:43:17.845 --> 01:43:26.069
<v Loretta Smith>And the other piece is, if the, if the department wanted this, they've had more than enough chance to ask for a budget modification to ask for this money.

1186
01:43:27.155 --> 01:43:30.500
<v Loretta Smith>But doing it in this way, it's, it's a real sneaky kind of way to do things.

1187
01:43:30.548 --> 01:43:30.938
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1188
01:43:31.472 --> 01:43:36.724
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, this is the regular technical adjustment.

1189
01:43:36.771 --> 01:43:39.083
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's equivalent to what was the bump before.

1190
01:43:39.582 --> 01:43:49.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the question at hand is whether we should carry over funds that had been allocated last year or whether we should allow those funds that weren't spent to be part of our beginning balance.

1191
01:43:49.841 --> 01:43:52.506
<v Loretta Smith>And that's what I'm saying, Madam President.

1192
01:43:52.828 --> 01:43:58.934
<v Loretta Smith>We should not because it is causing us to make a decision about 25-26 early.

1193
01:43:59.594 --> 01:44:11.011
<v Loretta Smith>We're taking that money because ordinarily that money would be pushed over as one-time-only money or ongoing money for the next budget so that the mayor could do what he needed to do with it.

1194
01:44:11.109 --> 01:44:16.331
<v Loretta Smith>And until the mayor drops his budget, I don't know that this is an emergency right now.

1195
01:44:18.970 --> 01:44:19.722
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1196
01:44:20.073 --> 01:44:20.877
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

1197
01:44:22.398 --> 01:44:22.686
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1198
01:44:23.007 --> 01:44:25.399
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, well, it took a minute to follow along.

1199
01:44:25.494 --> 01:44:26.314
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think I'm there.

1200
01:44:26.394 --> 01:44:28.801
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think I know what lines we're referencing, Councilor.

1201
01:44:29.747 --> 01:44:34.627
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, as the chair of the Finance Committee, this is the very first minute that I'm hearing of this.

1202
01:44:35.123 --> 01:44:40.162
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, Portland Fire and Rescue, the DCA, Mr. Myers of Public Safety have not brought this up to me.

1203
01:44:40.275 --> 01:44:51.221
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is not something that, that I've heard of, and they— I do not remember any testimony from them at the Finance Committee regarding this Technical adjustment, what used to be called a spring bump.

1204
01:44:51.270 --> 01:45:04.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I, I am, um, I would like to, to highlight this moment as to underline what Councilor Smith has said.

1205
01:45:05.269 --> 01:45:08.603
<v Eric Zimmerman>I look at this page and I say, yes, some things are carried over.

1206
01:45:09.216 --> 01:45:22.162
<v Eric Zimmerman>Those are not always my most preferred method, but what I see from that is that that indicates to me that the executive branch of this government has said they They see some reason why it needs to be carried over, either because the work has already started.

1207
01:45:22.931 --> 01:45:27.421
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's very likely that they're going to be proposing it as part of the upcoming budget.

1208
01:45:28.046 --> 01:45:37.456
<v Eric Zimmerman>But it is stark to me when the executive branch pulls back something that isn't going to be spent, that is representative of a previous council, and now we're getting something zeroed out.

1209
01:45:37.520 --> 01:46:00.636
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so having not heard this case, having not heard from the executive branch on why this would be an important Amendment and addition, and recognizing what $837,000 is in terms of opportunity for our upcoming work in the coming weeks, I would really encourage my colleagues not to support this amendment.

1210
01:46:01.360 --> 01:46:21.121
<v Eric Zimmerman>This type of work is a very robust and important conversation, and I think that the committee structure continues to be tested about whether or not we're going to do the real work in committees so that we bring products to this council for, for consideration that have worked through some of the details instead of— I see no chief of fire here.

1211
01:46:21.345 --> 01:46:26.984
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would like to understand what the chief of fire would do with this money if I put it in her pocket tomorrow.

1212
01:46:27.673 --> 01:46:31.118
<v Eric Zimmerman>I can't do that from this position, and I won't be supporting the amendment because of it.

1213
01:46:32.064 --> 01:46:36.487
<v Eric Zimmerman>As fun as it is to talk numbers with our budget team, they are not our operational team.

1214
01:46:36.711 --> 01:46:42.662
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I think that this amendment also looks like putting money into the pocket of a department who's not asked for it, for a mayor who's not asked for it.

1215
01:46:43.368 --> 01:46:50.189
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think it sets a precedent that, while we haven't set a ton of precedents yet, I think it's important to think about.

1216
01:46:50.367 --> 01:46:59.659
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I hope that you will all give these programs the right time, the right conversation, and an operational look at a different date.

1217
01:46:59.917 --> 01:47:04.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>But today's amendment is— and this technical adjustment is not the time for this.

1218
01:47:05.054 --> 01:47:05.631
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1219
01:47:05.680 --> 01:47:11.253
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I would urge everybody strongly to vote this amendment down and pass the technical adjustment.

1220
01:47:11.335 --> 01:47:11.608
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1221
01:47:12.702 --> 01:47:13.039
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1222
01:47:13.184 --> 01:47:22.847
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if there are questions for the department, while we don't have the bureau directors online, we do have Stephanie Howard who will be joining us in just a few minutes if needed.

1223
01:47:26.609 --> 01:47:30.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal and Smith, you've both spoken, so I'm going to jump to Councilor Green.

1224
01:47:31.130 --> 01:47:32.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, to the—.

1225
01:47:32.304 --> 01:47:34.024
<v Loretta Smith>I put my hand up on the table, but that's fine.

1226
01:47:36.359 --> 01:47:38.233
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Madam President.

1227
01:47:39.483 --> 01:48:00.408
<v Unidentified speaker>Just to understand your intent a little bit more clearly, is your thinking that, yes, these programs may not have been started yet and that's why they're moved out of one bucket into the other, but that if we don't do this adjustment, we risk— well, introducing a risk that the whole plan will fall apart?

1228
01:48:00.503 --> 01:48:02.057
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that the idea in your thinking?

1229
01:48:02.250 --> 01:48:06.229
<v Unidentified speaker>It's like a continuity Um, may I respond?

1230
01:48:07.465 --> 01:48:08.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead, Councilor.

1231
01:48:08.588 --> 01:48:08.909
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1232
01:48:09.310 --> 01:48:16.837
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I'm, um, I'll just clarify, uh, for the, the, uh, $100,000 portion of this, yes.

1233
01:48:17.399 --> 01:48:24.717
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so the, the $100,000 is to spend on the pilot, uh, project, the initiation of the survey itself.

1234
01:48:25.440 --> 01:48:29.148
<v Sameer Kanal>The planning has been going on, and it has involved people Yes.

1235
01:48:29.436 --> 01:48:50.390
<v Sameer Kanal>Including, let's see, it included a staffer from the mayor's office, representatives from the PPA and the PPCOA, Portland Police Bureau leadership, Community Safety Division leadership, which is now the Public Safety Service Area DCA's office, the city attorney's office, a representative from the Portland Committee on Community Engaged Policing, and a representative from the Training Advisory Council.

1236
01:48:50.743 --> 01:48:51.756
<v Sameer Kanal>They were working through that.

1237
01:48:51.917 --> 01:48:53.153
<v Sameer Kanal>They're coming up with the RFP.

1238
01:48:53.601 --> 01:49:01.649
<v Sameer Kanal>And then procurement was delayed, which has to do with the ongoing labor conversations we had earlier this year.

1239
01:49:02.818 --> 01:49:09.148
<v Sameer Kanal>And as a result, the RFP never got out in time for money to be actually spent by June 30th.

1240
01:49:09.404 --> 01:49:09.645
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1241
01:49:10.270 --> 01:49:20.444
<v Sameer Kanal>And just to clarify, and I'm concerned that evidently people might not be aware that actually the only reason that it exists in this table at all is because it was in fact requested.

1242
01:49:21.344 --> 01:49:24.395
<v Sameer Kanal>If the bureau director had never asked for it, it would never have been in this table.

1243
01:49:24.957 --> 01:49:29.036
<v Sameer Kanal>So that is just factually incorrect, and I want to make sure that's clarified.

1244
01:49:29.292 --> 01:49:37.032
<v Sameer Kanal>There are a million things that are not put in, but if you want to see why it's in the left column, it says Bureau Requested Adjustment.

1245
01:49:37.079 --> 01:49:38.782
<v Sameer Kanal>That is the header for the column.

1246
01:49:38.926 --> 01:49:40.372
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor.

1247
01:49:40.595 --> 01:49:42.538
<v Unidentified speaker>So with that in mind—.

1248
01:49:42.538 --> 01:49:44.193
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, can we pause for one minute?

1249
01:49:44.288 --> 01:49:47.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just, I want to clarify that, which is I'm gonna have to follow up with Ruth because—.

1250
01:49:47.198 --> 01:49:47.586
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not true.

1251
01:49:47.747 --> 01:49:58.582
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My understanding was that any dollars that are returned or that are not going to be spent are returned in this way, whether or not they're requested.

1252
01:50:01.184 --> 01:50:03.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, and then Councilor, we'll get back to your question.

1253
01:50:03.168 --> 01:50:03.701
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

1254
01:50:04.314 --> 01:50:08.493
<v Olivia Clark>So I think maybe both things are true.

1255
01:50:08.637 --> 01:50:10.573
<v Olivia Clark>Let me see if I track.

1256
01:50:11.746 --> 01:50:16.676
<v Olivia Clark>It is true that the bureaus did initially request this.

1257
01:50:16.739 --> 01:50:24.623
<v Olivia Clark>We went through a process, and again, the lens was really strict on focusing on true carryover.

1258
01:50:25.088 --> 01:50:25.217
<v Angelita Morillo>This—.

1259
01:50:25.329 --> 01:50:37.034
<v Olivia Clark>We're trying to transition from sort of the former spring bump where we had a pretty, I would say, expansive conception of what carryover was intended to be.

1260
01:50:37.292 --> 01:50:43.056
<v Olivia Clark>And to a much more slimmed-down version of that.

1261
01:50:43.153 --> 01:50:45.127
<v Olivia Clark>And that was kind of the lens that was applied.

1262
01:50:45.176 --> 01:50:52.930
<v Olivia Clark>So that's why— and I think the idea is, yes, this can still be considered in, in the '25-'26 budget process.

1263
01:50:53.011 --> 01:51:07.239
<v Olivia Clark>The money will— would, would be essentially returned to the general fund if this amendment is not adopted, and then it can be considered by the mayor and then by you all in the '25-'26 budget process.

1264
01:51:07.304 --> 01:51:11.444
<v Olivia Clark>So that was the idea with the carryover, was to keep it really— was to keep it really narrow.

1265
01:51:11.493 --> 01:51:12.396
<v Olivia Clark>So it was requested.

1266
01:51:12.849 --> 01:51:21.198
<v Olivia Clark>It was not put forward by the mayor and city administrator in the version that came, that was filed and was brought to the Finance Committee.

1267
01:51:21.701 --> 01:51:24.520
<v Candace Avalos>Um, hopefully that clarifies.

1268
01:51:24.859 --> 01:51:25.490
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1269
01:51:25.847 --> 01:51:26.413
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1270
01:51:26.494 --> 01:51:26.755
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Go ahead.

1271
01:51:26.899 --> 01:51:27.176
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1272
01:51:27.547 --> 01:51:30.530
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, let me just finish my My question and comment here.

1273
01:51:33.448 --> 01:51:41.384
<v Unidentified speaker>So I understand the finance chair's argumentation, but what I'll say here is like, whatever— we do have the power to do this.

1274
01:51:41.738 --> 01:51:44.042
<v Unidentified speaker>We can make decisions to change this document.

1275
01:51:44.091 --> 01:51:45.993
<v Unidentified speaker>That is within the scope of City Council's power.

1276
01:51:48.305 --> 01:51:48.403
<v Unidentified speaker>If—.

1277
01:51:48.645 --> 01:51:56.207
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's suppose we voted yes on your amendment, there's nothing to prevent the mayor from issuing something that reverses that, and there's nothing to prevent this council from reversing that too.

1278
01:51:56.769 --> 01:51:57.643
<v Unidentified speaker>During the Budget Committee.

1279
01:51:58.144 --> 01:52:01.573
<v Unidentified speaker>So 6 in one, half a dozen in the other, as far as I'm concerned.

1280
01:52:01.639 --> 01:52:13.378
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's a statement of, as I understand it, Councilor Kanal's intention to champion a program which I'm going to be doing throughout my tenure on this council at every, every month of the year.

1281
01:52:13.765 --> 01:52:15.820
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm prepared to support the amendment.

1282
01:52:18.166 --> 01:52:19.081
<v Loretta Smith>Madam President.

1283
01:52:19.719 --> 01:52:26.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I want to make sure we hear from folks who haven't spoken yet, but I promise we will get Okay, I thought I was next in the queue.

1284
01:52:26.774 --> 01:52:29.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos hasn't had a chance to speak yet.

1285
01:52:32.060 --> 01:52:50.476
<v Candace Avalos>So first, I'll say that, uh, I said this in the Finance Committee, that in general I was not a big fan of the fact that I felt we were being given a document that needed a rubber stamp and didn't really have the opportunity to discuss why these changes are requested, how they fit into larger bureau directives et cetera.

1286
01:52:50.800 --> 01:52:59.877
<v Candace Avalos>I said also in the Finance Committee, I recognize the just, you know, patch year that we're in and that some processes we're going to need to continue to refine.

1287
01:53:00.250 --> 01:53:13.971
<v Candace Avalos>But I'm stating that because it's relevant to me to what I'm about to say, which is that I think that this amendment raises some foundational questions, kind of building off of what Councilor Green is saying on if a bureau makes a request, right?

1288
01:53:14.036 --> 01:53:18.119
<v Candace Avalos>Let's just put it that way, because they want to discontinue a program, let's say.

1289
01:53:18.193 --> 01:53:18.247
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1290
01:53:18.350 --> 01:53:18.430
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1291
01:53:18.862 --> 01:53:26.829
<v Candace Avalos>But the council decides that that's a program that is a priority to the community, do we get to direct the bureau via a budget allocation to reprioritize that program?

1292
01:53:27.198 --> 01:53:28.320
<v Candace Avalos>I believe the answer is yes.

1293
01:53:28.865 --> 01:53:44.399
<v Candace Avalos>I also don't think that our only measurement of making budget decisions should be does the bureau want or not want it, because it is our job as the electeds to combine both the expertise of our hardworking staff and consider their recommendations and to represent our constituents and their priorities.

1294
01:53:45.057 --> 01:54:02.172
<v Candace Avalos>So in general, I just want to challenge this concept that this isn't the place to have this discussion, that we don't get to make this decision, and that we don't, with our bureau— or I'm sorry, with our budget decisions— get to redirect bureau priorities based on what we believe we're representing for our constituents.

1295
01:54:02.719 --> 01:54:09.993
<v Candace Avalos>All that being said, based on the arguments that Councilor Kanal has mentioned, I am definitely inclined to support approving this.

1296
01:54:10.041 --> 01:54:10.168
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1297
01:54:10.747 --> 01:54:23.412
<v Candace Avalos>And I think on the back end, I want to follow up with the administrative side and the mayor and the bureaus to just understand what happens in a situation like this where we, again, we say we want this direction with these dollars.

1298
01:54:23.909 --> 01:54:26.012
<v Candace Avalos>And is there a negotiation process?

1299
01:54:26.092 --> 01:54:27.442
<v Candace Avalos>I don't know what that looks like yet.

1300
01:54:28.261 --> 01:54:31.422
<v Candace Avalos>But my larger point is I do believe we have the power to do this.

1301
01:54:31.551 --> 01:54:37.426
<v Candace Avalos>I think Councilor Kanal has made an argument that is compelling to me about why those programs should be prioritized and funded.

1302
01:54:37.475 --> 01:54:37.618
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1303
01:54:38.601 --> 01:54:50.728
<v Candace Avalos>And I think I'm leaving on the table this broader question about how we're going to be using our authority as electeds when making budget decisions to direct bureaus to do work that we believe represents our constituents.

1304
01:54:51.082 --> 01:54:51.306
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1305
01:54:53.109 --> 01:54:53.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1306
01:54:54.155 --> 01:54:55.122
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

1307
01:54:56.699 --> 01:54:57.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1308
01:54:57.881 --> 01:54:58.284
<v Loretta Smith>Did we—.

1309
01:54:58.430 --> 01:55:01.229
<v Unidentified speaker>Did you discuss this in the Public Safety Committee, Commissioner?

1310
01:55:02.863 --> 01:55:02.912
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1311
01:55:04.880 --> 01:55:07.076
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This came to the Finance Committee.

1312
01:55:07.412 --> 01:55:11.692
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's a technical adjustment ordinance that touches a number of different policy areas.

1313
01:55:11.756 --> 01:55:12.301
<v Angelita Morillo>I understand that.

1314
01:55:12.462 --> 01:55:14.753
<v Unidentified speaker>I, I meant this whole issue that you're talking about.

1315
01:55:14.945 --> 01:55:22.350
<v Sameer Kanal>No, we weren't— no, and we weren't aware of it at the time that the, uh, the agenda was set for the Finance Committee.

1316
01:55:23.039 --> 01:55:24.899
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry, for the, for the Community and Public Safety Committee.

1317
01:55:25.235 --> 01:55:28.586
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, the most recent meeting, it was not given to—.

1318
01:55:28.729 --> 01:55:37.372
<v Unidentified speaker>We had no ability to react in the time frame necessary to get it on the But we will have a chance to work on this when the budget comes to us after May 5th.

1319
01:55:37.871 --> 01:55:42.618
<v Sameer Kanal>We will have a chance to look at how we spend FY25-26 revenue at that time.

1320
01:55:42.922 --> 01:55:45.024
<v Sameer Kanal>This is FY24-25 revenue.

1321
01:55:45.505 --> 01:55:45.729
<v Candace Avalos>Right.

1322
01:55:45.905 --> 01:55:46.595
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I understand that.

1323
01:55:46.787 --> 01:55:51.247
<v Unidentified speaker>But we will have another chance at this when the next— when the mayor provides a budget.

1324
01:55:52.081 --> 01:55:55.402
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This could be part of the mayor's budget.

1325
01:55:55.449 --> 01:55:58.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't know yet if these programs will be included in the mayor's budget.

1326
01:55:58.833 --> 01:56:00.164
<v Unidentified speaker>But we'll have an opportunity to make that decision.

1327
01:56:02.636 --> 01:56:03.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absolutely.

1328
01:56:03.199 --> 01:56:13.024
<v Unidentified speaker>This is beginning to feel to me like the former commissioner style of government, that we're in a different form of government now.

1329
01:56:14.822 --> 01:56:18.074
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think this is really inappropriate at this time.

1330
01:56:18.430 --> 01:56:20.024
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand where you're coming from.

1331
01:56:20.121 --> 01:56:21.152
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand you want to do this.

1332
01:56:21.199 --> 01:56:22.215
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand the rationale.

1333
01:56:24.100 --> 01:56:37.310
<v Unidentified speaker>But it seems to me it opens up the door for the different bureaus to come to us anytime and ask us for things outside the process of a, you know, city manager form of government and a legislative body.

1334
01:56:37.826 --> 01:56:39.405
<v Unidentified speaker>We're going to have our opportunity to do this.

1335
01:56:40.002 --> 01:56:44.168
<v Unidentified speaker>This just doesn't seem like the right place or time to make this kind of change.

1336
01:56:45.988 --> 01:56:47.150
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for listening to me.

1337
01:56:49.039 --> 01:56:53.100
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

1338
01:56:53.261 --> 01:56:54.458
<v Steve Novick>A question for Councilor Kanal.

1339
01:56:55.978 --> 01:56:56.560
<v Sameer Kanal>What would you—.

1340
01:56:57.029 --> 01:57:08.117
<v Steve Novick>Just to make sure I understand this, do you think that it's reasonable to draw a distinction between the survey and the PF&R program carryover?

1341
01:57:08.166 --> 01:57:13.903
<v Steve Novick>Are you more worried about the survey never being completed than you're worrying about the PF&R budget?

1342
01:57:14.867 --> 01:57:17.278
<v Sameer Kanal>I think they're both valuable and I put them up together.

1343
01:57:17.663 --> 01:57:20.219
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't draw a distinction in terms of the importance of either.

1344
01:57:20.442 --> 01:57:21.324
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1345
01:57:22.192 --> 01:57:25.500
<v Steve Novick>I just was wondering if you might think that the survey might be more at risk.

1346
01:57:26.143 --> 01:57:30.253
<v Sameer Kanal>I mean, I can speak to what— well, I can't.

1347
01:57:30.720 --> 01:57:36.146
<v Sameer Kanal>The request from the bureaus actually does say what they believe the impact would be of not doing this.

1348
01:57:37.046 --> 01:57:40.965
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think they could probably— those words speak for themselves in many ways.

1349
01:57:41.060 --> 01:57:47.548
<v Sameer Kanal>I also know that we have Elizabeth Gallagher from Portland Fire and Rescue online who can speak to that and who has her hand raised.

1350
01:57:49.109 --> 01:57:54.729
<v Sameer Kanal>As well as Stephanie, who is— sorry, your name's showing as Stephanie Howard as well.

1351
01:57:54.859 --> 01:57:56.328
<v Sameer Kanal>So at any point we could reach to that.

1352
01:57:56.377 --> 01:58:03.738
<v Sameer Kanal>But I did send Keelan the request from Portland Fire and Rescue, which speaks to that.

1353
01:58:03.963 --> 01:58:05.046
<v Sameer Kanal>I can also send the other one.

1354
01:58:06.909 --> 01:58:13.784
<v Steve Novick>So I want to respond to the idea that we can deal with this in the context of the overall '25-'26 budget discussion.

1355
01:58:15.275 --> 01:58:23.064
<v Steve Novick>The fact is that when the mayor proposes a budget, then if we propose adding something in, we're going to have to say let's take something else out.

1356
01:58:24.108 --> 01:58:24.203
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1357
01:58:24.268 --> 01:58:30.305
<v Steve Novick>So that will put us in a more difficult position in terms of arguing for something than arguing for it now.

1358
01:58:30.948 --> 01:58:48.550
<v Steve Novick>So although I understand Chair Zimmerman's process point, I sympathize with Councilor Kanal's point that This is— well, I don't know if you even said this, but I think that, um, we put these dollars more at risk if we don't deal with it now and deal with it later.

1359
01:58:49.448 --> 01:59:03.141
<v Steve Novick>Uh, so frankly, I'm not sure actually how I'm going to vote, but I just wanted to make that general point that, you know, the mayor has enormous power in this system despite the fact that he doesn't have a vote, because he writes the document first.

1360
01:59:03.720 --> 01:59:09.059
<v Steve Novick>And if we vote to change his document, We're going to make somebody mad and somebody else happy.

1361
01:59:09.122 --> 01:59:13.688
<v Steve Novick>But as Machiavelli said, the people who lose are always angrier than the people who win whenever there's any change.

1362
01:59:14.881 --> 01:59:17.588
<v Steve Novick>Um, so I just wanted to put that philosophical thought on the table.

1363
01:59:19.779 --> 01:59:21.407
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1364
01:59:22.197 --> 01:59:23.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am next in the queue.

1365
01:59:24.050 --> 01:59:27.738
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I agree, Councilor Avalos, we have the budget authority.

1366
01:59:27.997 --> 01:59:29.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can make these changes.

1367
01:59:29.948 --> 01:59:37.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I will just say, when this came before the Finance I had the opportunity to see it for the first time there.

1368
01:59:38.478 --> 01:59:41.865
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My initial thought was, why on earth are we carrying all of this over?

1369
01:59:41.930 --> 01:59:59.413
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there anything that we could actually not carry over so that we have more flexibility, more opportunity to think about our priorities as we begin the budget process, and more money in our general fund that we have gotten back through the technical adjustment ordinance?

1370
01:59:59.494 --> 02:00:07.122
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor I didn't make an amendment to do that because I didn't want to take funding away from programs that were already in progress— in process.

1371
02:00:07.923 --> 02:00:13.881
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think these are both important things, and we do have the authority to make the change if we want to.

1372
02:00:14.667 --> 02:00:19.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I do want to share though that I will be leaning no.

1373
02:00:20.368 --> 02:00:35.832
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My mind could be changed, but certainly leaning that direction because I think it's important right now to Councilor Ryan, I believe you were next in the queue, but your hand is now down.

1374
02:00:35.929 --> 02:00:38.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Did you have something you wanted to add to the discussion?

1375
02:00:39.649 --> 02:00:41.792
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I'm just trying to track it here at home.

1376
02:00:42.341 --> 02:00:46.610
<v Unidentified speaker>I did notice that the Chief Jackson was on, so that intrigued me.

1377
02:00:46.771 --> 02:00:51.509
<v Unidentified speaker>I thought it would be helpful to hear from her since her name was brought up.

1378
02:00:53.832 --> 02:00:54.335
<v Sameer Kanal>Rightly so.

1379
02:00:56.033 --> 02:00:56.841
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1380
02:00:56.921 --> 02:01:01.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe we have both folks from the DCA's office.

1381
02:01:01.529 --> 02:01:07.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not sure if DCA Myers is on or not, but I know that Stephanie Howard is and also the chief.

1382
02:01:08.417 --> 02:01:14.358
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mike or Stephanie, would either of you like to say something or invite your bureau staff to say anything?

1383
02:01:17.149 --> 02:01:17.887
<v Loretta Smith>They don't.

1384
02:01:17.967 --> 02:01:21.564
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, uh, Council President, uh, this is, uh, DCA Myers.

1385
02:01:21.613 --> 02:01:24.181
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the Deputy City Administrator for Public Safety.

1386
02:01:24.872 --> 02:01:55.305
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, with regard to the context survey, and, um, I'm a bit reserved to have discussion with, um, the council here without the mayor present— there's been a lot of discussion around, um, the mayor's proposed— but the context survey discussion We had talked at length about it not being what we call shovel ready, and proposing that we would defer to putting that in the mayor's proposed.

1387
02:01:55.755 --> 02:01:56.923
<v Unidentified speaker>Now I cannot speak for the mayor.

1388
02:01:57.694 --> 02:02:02.581
<v Unidentified speaker>I will just tell you what we conversations that I have discussed.

1389
02:02:02.661 --> 02:02:06.939
<v Unidentified speaker>The intent is to at some point fund the contact survey.

1390
02:02:07.131 --> 02:02:09.791
<v Unidentified speaker>It is important to us, and Stephanie, if you want to.

1391
02:02:10.337 --> 02:02:11.509
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you add context to that?

1392
02:02:11.622 --> 02:02:13.340
<v Unidentified speaker>I know the DOJ settlement is important.

1393
02:02:13.404 --> 02:02:14.576
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you add context to that?

1394
02:02:14.688 --> 02:02:20.757
<v Unidentified speaker>Then I would like to talk a little bit about the additional funds for extra firefighters.

1395
02:02:21.833 --> 02:02:24.225
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I can just speak to the contact survey.

1396
02:02:24.305 --> 02:02:29.797
<v Unidentified speaker>I think Councilor Kanal did a great job of overviewing kind of the history and where we are in that process.

1397
02:02:30.408 --> 02:02:39.663
<v Unidentified speaker>And as many of us know, procurement is incredibly, incredibly busy and Has a very small staff, but it is still very much in progress.

1398
02:02:39.792 --> 02:02:47.435
<v Unidentified speaker>I think what I mostly want to say is that I don't think this is reflective of any intent of whether the contact survey program moves forward.

1399
02:02:47.500 --> 02:03:01.649
<v Unidentified speaker>I think you know in the DCA's office, certainly, I think with the mayor's team and I think with our other public safety leaders, I think there's absolute unity in wanting to move that forward, whether it comes from the mayor's proposed or if we retain the budget.

1400
02:03:08.920 --> 02:03:19.649
<v Unidentified speaker>And Stephanie, I don't know if you know this or not, and Council President, I think this is important as we make decisions collectively as a group.

1401
02:03:19.649 --> 02:03:23.239
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a group not represented here, and that is the labor group.

1402
02:03:24.189 --> 02:03:28.750
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, there is some interest in making sure that we have conversation with labor and that they are represented.

1403
02:03:28.750 --> 02:03:28.770
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

1404
02:03:29.247 --> 02:03:34.387
<v Unidentified speaker>Even around a contact survey, as benign as it may seem to all of us here, about bargaining that.

1405
02:03:34.710 --> 02:03:42.243
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think the union president might suggest that he is not done bargaining this issue, and something for you all to be aware of.

1406
02:03:42.676 --> 02:03:47.704
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a very— we just need to be very careful as we go forward, make decisions.

1407
02:03:48.380 --> 02:03:57.958
<v Unidentified speaker>And just to be clear, we do have our labor representatives in the workgroup that's been working on this, so we're keeping them very much involved in the Thank you.

1408
02:03:58.023 --> 02:04:06.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I should flag for you both that, um, your, your firefighters president is in the room with us, uh, watching this discussion.

1409
02:04:08.967 --> 02:04:14.922
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Madam President, going back to the queue, I have Councilor Kanal, then Councilor Smith, then Councilor Zimmerman.

1410
02:04:15.677 --> 02:04:18.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, I promise we'll get back to you.

1411
02:04:18.489 --> 02:04:19.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1412
02:04:20.641 --> 02:04:25.207
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, actually, could— so, uh, I'd actually like to hear from Fire first.

1413
02:04:25.305 --> 02:04:30.145
<v Sameer Kanal>But while we're doing that, Keelan, could you put up the request that they put up that I sent you?

1414
02:04:31.456 --> 02:04:34.992
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm happy to go after them because DCMeyer said—.

1415
02:04:34.992 --> 02:04:43.430
<v Loretta Smith>Madam President, there's a, there's a process issue here right now that I need to talk about before we have everybody give testimony that they're walking on eggshells about.

1416
02:04:43.478 --> 02:04:47.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, we are in discussion on the amendment, right?

1417
02:04:47.720 --> 02:04:53.126
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe if you have a process question about the amendment Okay, go right ahead.

1418
02:04:53.173 --> 02:04:57.349
<v Loretta Smith>First of all, if the DC want— DCA wanted this, he would have put it up.

1419
02:04:57.846 --> 02:04:58.184
<v Loretta Smith>He didn't.

1420
02:04:58.231 --> 02:04:58.858
<v Loretta Smith>He's being nice.

1421
02:04:59.756 --> 02:05:00.832
<v Loretta Smith>The mayor put this up.

1422
02:05:01.298 --> 02:05:05.440
<v Loretta Smith>So unless we pass the original, his can't pass.

1423
02:05:05.954 --> 02:05:07.416
<v Loretta Smith>He can't supersede it.

1424
02:05:08.668 --> 02:05:21.498
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, the mayor put this on so that he could use those dollars for him to make plans and do his budget, period.

1425
02:05:22.318 --> 02:05:23.908
<v Loretta Smith>And yes, we can do this.

1426
02:05:24.180 --> 02:05:25.916
<v Loretta Smith>We can actually do what you're saying.

1427
02:05:26.590 --> 02:05:37.350
<v Loretta Smith>But we have said as a council that we were not— you told me, Eric told me that I couldn't put money issues in before the mayor dropped his budget.

1428
02:05:37.430 --> 02:05:38.041
<v Loretta Smith>And it's just simple.

1429
02:05:38.088 --> 02:05:38.779
<v Loretta Smith>It's a process.

1430
02:05:38.957 --> 02:05:45.943
<v Loretta Smith>You can't put, put money stuff in before the mayor drops his budget because all he's going to do if he don't like what he sees, he's just going to take it out.

1431
02:05:46.038 --> 02:05:47.018
<v Loretta Smith>So what's the purpose?

1432
02:05:47.530 --> 02:05:49.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, what is the process question?

1433
02:05:49.457 --> 02:05:50.307
<v Loretta Smith>That's the process question.

1434
02:05:50.355 --> 02:05:52.411
<v Loretta Smith>There is a process that goes along with this.

1435
02:05:53.309 --> 02:05:54.224
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is a process.

1436
02:05:54.353 --> 02:05:58.509
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The technical adjustment ordinance is part of the new regular process.

1437
02:05:58.622 --> 02:05:59.023
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So—.

1438
02:05:59.809 --> 02:06:04.175
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, and we were not given an opportunity to know that this was the spring bump money.

1439
02:06:04.238 --> 02:06:05.234
<v Loretta Smith>This went through finance.

1440
02:06:05.282 --> 02:06:10.305
<v Loretta Smith>We should have had a work session to explain what this was, and that's the process question.

1441
02:06:10.578 --> 02:06:11.349
<v Loretta Smith>Why didn't you do that?

1442
02:06:11.510 --> 02:06:15.918
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I'm happy to talk about having more work sessions.

1443
02:06:16.256 --> 02:06:22.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had significant feedback that we were having too many work sessions early on.

1444
02:06:22.926 --> 02:06:35.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have committees to hold conversations about things, and there are many committees I'm not in that I'd like to be engaged in conversation on, and I have to trust my colleagues or show up to those committees or watch them.

1445
02:06:35.610 --> 02:06:38.625
<v Loretta Smith>So— I know I disagree because that was about Springboks.

1446
02:06:38.689 --> 02:06:38.801
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1447
02:06:39.122 --> 02:06:40.454
<v Loretta Smith>We needed to know about the spring bump.

1448
02:06:40.502 --> 02:06:42.011
<v Loretta Smith>It was hidden in the Finance Committee.

1449
02:06:42.332 --> 02:06:51.658
<v Loretta Smith>We should have had a 2-hour, 3-hour conversation just like we had to say, here's the money that has come into the, to the city since we last did our budget.

1450
02:06:51.721 --> 02:06:53.247
<v Loretta Smith>And that is the process issue.

1451
02:06:54.033 --> 02:07:01.463
<v Loretta Smith>And, and this is the reason why we're in this argument right now, because nobody had the 30,000-foot level to say, give us some more information.

1452
02:07:01.512 --> 02:07:06.403
<v Loretta Smith>Don't slide it through Finance and try to get it through here like nobody Thank you, Councilor.

1453
02:07:10.903 --> 02:07:15.243
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Knoll, you'd like to hear from our folks from Fire before you speak, is that correct?

1454
02:07:15.386 --> 02:07:22.234
<v Sameer Kanal>I can just say, if Chief would like to jump out, I'm sorry that I read the name instead of actually looking at the picture there.

1455
02:07:22.556 --> 02:07:26.890
<v Sameer Kanal>This, what's on the screen on Zoom, is the request from Fire.

1456
02:07:28.136 --> 02:07:31.342
<v Sameer Kanal>So again, this was requested by Portland Fire and Rescue.

1457
02:07:32.167 --> 02:07:35.827
<v Sameer Kanal>As was the other thing by, uh, the Office of the DCA.

1458
02:07:36.662 --> 02:07:41.332
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so, uh, I, I just wanted to make sure that that was flagged.

1459
02:07:41.509 --> 02:07:44.204
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't know if there's anything, Chief, you'd like to add, but I, I would like to hear.

1460
02:07:44.301 --> 02:07:44.478
<v Unidentified speaker>I—.

1461
02:07:45.104 --> 02:07:45.746
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1462
02:07:46.708 --> 02:07:48.698
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Chief, go right ahead if you have any comments to add.

1463
02:07:49.823 --> 02:07:53.048
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, uh, good, good evening, and I'm sorry I could not be there in person.

1464
02:07:53.193 --> 02:07:54.381
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, my name is AJ Jackson.

1465
02:07:54.429 --> 02:07:56.627
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the interim fire chief for Portland Fire and Rescue.

1466
02:07:57.365 --> 02:08:01.886
<v Loretta Smith>And this was a carryover request that we made because this training was started.

1467
02:08:01.951 --> 02:08:03.426
<v Unidentified speaker>This is our January hire.

1468
02:08:04.194 --> 02:08:11.296
<v Loretta Smith>And so as many of you have heard along the way, our training pipeline is 9.5 to 10 months long.

1469
02:08:11.666 --> 02:08:17.949
<v Unidentified speaker>So the idea was to carry over these funding to complete this class's training into the next fiscal year.

1470
02:08:17.997 --> 02:08:20.738
<v Unidentified speaker>So our hires are in January and July.

1471
02:08:21.828 --> 02:08:33.012
<v Unidentified speaker>So this would move that Continue to pay for those 10 FTE until they were ready to fill a vacancy and then reduced— continue to reduce overtime for our bureau.

1472
02:08:36.051 --> 02:08:48.546
<v Sameer Kanal>And the other thing I should mention, you're going to hear this in a couple things and I'll be very brief, is everything I've amended, proposed amending today, is something that will have positive financial effects in the long term.

1473
02:08:48.595 --> 02:08:53.039
<v Sameer Kanal>And the long term is not It's not the next month, but it's also not 10 years away, right?

1474
02:08:53.104 --> 02:08:59.832
<v Sameer Kanal>We're talking about continuing the progress that FIRE has made, which is, you know, really, really strong at reducing overtime.

1475
02:08:59.912 --> 02:09:04.070
<v Sameer Kanal>We just heard about that in the preceding work session.

1476
02:09:04.744 --> 02:09:14.716
<v Sameer Kanal>And so ensuring that we're able to do that progress and continue that progress towards it will prevent us from backsliding on the progress we've already made.

1477
02:09:14.780 --> 02:09:14.908
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1478
02:09:15.134 --> 02:09:16.145
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor.

1479
02:09:17.252 --> 02:09:22.663
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, are you in the queue, or were you in the queue for the comments that you made earlier?

1480
02:09:22.743 --> 02:09:42.427
<v Loretta Smith>No, no, no, I was in the queue for the comments later, but I just wanted to say I, I think we need to, to ensure that our budget-related changes are communicated clearly, and the money that we're dealing with, that we should have a clear understanding where they came from And how they got here.

1481
02:09:43.103 --> 02:09:59.029
<v Loretta Smith>And I think the council deserves the opportunity to assess the entire budget so we can ask some important questions and get answers to those questions, like how much money— because I can't tell from these, all these different, uh, tables— how much money was allocated, reallocated in, in the bump.

1482
02:09:59.094 --> 02:09:59.944
<v Loretta Smith>What was the bump?

1483
02:10:00.122 --> 02:10:00.716
<v Loretta Smith>I don't even know.

1484
02:10:00.859 --> 02:10:01.599
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the bump.

1485
02:10:01.887 --> 02:10:04.664
<v Loretta Smith>I know, but how much was the bump?

1486
02:10:05.034 --> 02:10:12.918
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ruth, are you able to give a quick answer to the question, how much was the total bump for technical adjustment ordinance now?

1487
02:10:13.850 --> 02:10:16.917
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I— are you asking specific to the fire amount?

1488
02:10:17.238 --> 02:10:24.658
<v Loretta Smith>Well, no, I'm asking for the entire thing, Ruth, because what happens is we got 47 funds that we're taking money from.

1489
02:10:24.787 --> 02:10:25.542
<v Loretta Smith>47.

1490
02:10:26.859 --> 02:10:32.335
<v Loretta Smith>And there's money that has come in from BITI since we last did our fall bump.

1491
02:10:32.576 --> 02:10:39.974
<v Loretta Smith>I want to know what that number is Not the numbers that have been intermingled between these 47 funds.

1492
02:10:40.103 --> 02:10:43.498
<v Olivia Clark>So, so I think I understand the question.

1493
02:10:43.885 --> 02:10:54.856
<v Olivia Clark>This ordinance does not add any funding, and Anthony can speak to the, the net numbers for, for the total, but we're not adding any funding in this ordinance.

1494
02:10:54.938 --> 02:11:21.377
<v Olivia Clark>Again, sort of as a departure from how we used to do spring bumps, the only things that were allowed in this ordinance were to return general fund, to carry over funding for those specific sort of short list of items that had been begun, and then to do technical adjustments between, between funds and to allow for funds like water and sewer that have a lot of technical changes they need to make.

1495
02:11:21.715 --> 02:11:23.032
<v Olivia Clark>So those were the only actions.

1496
02:11:23.079 --> 02:11:25.841
<v Olivia Clark>So there's no added funding at all in this Or advance.

1497
02:11:26.099 --> 02:11:29.569
<v Loretta Smith>And so we'll find that out in the general fund forecast, what that was?

1498
02:11:29.632 --> 02:11:30.195
<v Olivia Clark>Yes, right.

1499
02:11:30.292 --> 02:11:41.537
<v Olivia Clark>The, the— so the, any— the, the general fund forecast update that will come out in April will, um, will be reflected in the mayor's proposed budget.

1500
02:11:41.618 --> 02:11:44.333
<v Olivia Clark>This doesn't— this does— is disconnected from that.

1501
02:11:44.430 --> 02:11:55.213
<v Loretta Smith>Reason why this is so difficult is because generally the general fund forecast comes out first, and then you put these out to say we're where you want to save stuff or not save stuff, and then the mayor puts their budget out.

1502
02:11:55.646 --> 02:12:00.078
<v Loretta Smith>And so that's— some of this stuff is the process that I was trying to talk about earlier.

1503
02:12:00.463 --> 02:12:02.631
<v Loretta Smith>It's not in the right order.

1504
02:12:03.274 --> 02:12:09.021
<v Loretta Smith>And so it's— and then we don't have the mayor here to be able to say what he— what his intention was on this.

1505
02:12:10.354 --> 02:12:26.030
<v Olivia Clark>So just on the process point, so we've, we've historically done the spring bump around this same time, and we historically have not used the general fund forecast change in that same year.

1506
02:12:26.545 --> 02:12:29.067
<v Olivia Clark>It always rolls into the next fiscal year.

1507
02:12:29.613 --> 02:12:35.188
<v Olivia Clark>What we have done in the past is reallocated underspending sometimes within the same fiscal year.

1508
02:12:35.235 --> 02:12:36.520
<v Olivia Clark>We're not doing that anymore.

1509
02:12:36.922 --> 02:12:38.786
<v Loretta Smith>Right, that's, that's what I'm talking about.

1510
02:12:38.865 --> 02:12:49.095
<v Loretta Smith>So it's, it's, it's giving, and particularly for people like me and Eric who have done this before, We're trying to figure out why is this process not feeling right.

1511
02:12:49.287 --> 02:13:04.551
<v Loretta Smith>And so when we're sitting here having to have an impact on the '25-'26 and we don't even have the mayor's budget yet, I don't know if this is the most important thing that we need to be doing, especially if the DCA did not bring it forward.

1512
02:13:05.016 --> 02:13:09.045
<v Loretta Smith>The mayor already figured out what he wanted to do, so I don't know.

1513
02:13:09.140 --> 02:13:16.703
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Councilor Zimmerman, we're going to move to Councilor Murillo since she hasn't spoken yet.

1514
02:13:16.948 --> 02:13:17.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll come right back to you.

1515
02:13:18.659 --> 02:13:20.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Murillo.

1516
02:13:20.711 --> 02:13:21.890
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1517
02:13:22.083 --> 02:13:32.300
<v Angelita Morillo>I think I'm having a hard time with this because I think that this is kind of another discussion around our process.

1518
02:13:32.556 --> 02:13:35.515
<v Angelita Morillo>And I agree with Councilor Smith that this should have been maybe a work in progress.

1519
02:13:36.274 --> 02:13:43.068
<v Angelita Morillo>Because while I understand, I worked here when we had the spring bump and now it's been renamed to something else.

1520
02:13:43.117 --> 02:13:47.115
<v Angelita Morillo>So I kind of understand that process and what it's supposed to mirror.

1521
02:13:47.356 --> 02:13:50.425
<v Angelita Morillo>But this is, it feels like it was very sudden.

1522
02:13:50.488 --> 02:13:52.015
<v Angelita Morillo>It was posted on Friday.

1523
02:13:52.577 --> 02:13:53.573
<v Angelita Morillo>We're reviewing it now.

1524
02:13:54.087 --> 02:14:00.335
<v Angelita Morillo>Most of us who aren't on committees have already discussed that realistically we don't have time to watch other committees.

1525
02:14:00.881 --> 02:14:01.378
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Smith.

1526
02:14:01.733 --> 02:14:04.922
<v Angelita Morillo>And this is just a recurring issue that I see happening over and over again.

1527
02:14:05.502 --> 02:14:18.145
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm inclined to support Councilor Kanal's amendment because I think it's important to continue to ensure that our programs feel secure and that they have the support that they need over time.

1528
02:14:20.849 --> 02:14:40.837
<v Angelita Morillo>But I'm just kind of concerned about this process moving forward, and I would like to see some more delineation between what Is going to be heard only in the Finance Committee and when we're going to get a briefing overall, because the mayor also has check-ins with all of us on budget semi-regularly, and this was not brought up during our check-in whatsoever.

1529
02:14:41.094 --> 02:14:44.341
<v Angelita Morillo>So I have concerns about that.

1530
02:14:48.649 --> 02:14:49.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

1531
02:14:50.055 --> 02:14:52.381
<v Eric Zimmerman>So whoever wants to answer this, go for it.

1532
02:14:54.180 --> 02:14:58.945
<v Eric Zimmerman>The 10 firefighters in question, are we laying them off tomorrow if we don't pass this?

1533
02:15:01.581 --> 02:15:02.729
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, I'm good.

1534
02:15:02.777 --> 02:15:04.524
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'd like them to just figure out who's going to answer it.

1535
02:15:04.783 --> 02:15:07.742
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, if I can, Councilor, I'll defer to the chief.

1536
02:15:08.113 --> 02:15:08.356
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1537
02:15:08.905 --> 02:15:09.117
<v Unidentified speaker>Chief?

1538
02:15:10.796 --> 02:15:14.903
<v Unidentified speaker>No, we will not be laying any of the 10 firefighters off if this isn't approved.

1539
02:15:15.484 --> 02:15:16.277
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thank you.

1540
02:15:17.229 --> 02:15:21.576
<v Eric Zimmerman>The way I'm looking at $737,000 Yes.

1541
02:15:21.818 --> 02:15:30.899
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that the funding for them exists through the 30th of June, which is how we fund city programs.

1542
02:15:30.948 --> 02:15:34.957
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm getting a nod from the city administrator, so I've at least got that check mark.

1543
02:15:35.054 --> 02:15:35.262
<v Keelan McClymont>All right.

1544
02:15:36.904 --> 02:15:42.958
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in that, then that means that this program is fully funded for the current year.

1545
02:15:44.295 --> 02:15:50.302
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we recognize, from what I'm hearing from the chief, we recognize that their training program is going to go into the next fiscal year.

1546
02:15:51.828 --> 02:16:03.216
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I guess I would expect is that any bureau who has employee costs who are going to move into the next fiscal year, that their next fiscal budget would account for those costs.

1547
02:16:04.168 --> 02:16:15.318
<v Eric Zimmerman>This seems to me to be a way to plump up a bureau's budget without having to make those investments.

1548
02:16:15.496 --> 02:16:16.595
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

1549
02:16:18.967 --> 02:16:21.729
<v Eric Zimmerman>Without going through the regular budget process.

1550
02:16:21.858 --> 02:16:27.975
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that seems strange to me because this group of employees will still be accounted for.

1551
02:16:28.119 --> 02:16:38.332
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I am gonna reject this idea that because they started a 10-month training program, that tomorrow if we don't pass this, they're gonna be on a bus ticket somewhere else.

1552
02:16:38.397 --> 02:16:39.456
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's just simply not the case.

1553
02:16:39.504 --> 02:16:40.114
<v Eric Zimmerman>We just heard that.

1554
02:16:40.789 --> 02:16:42.218
<v Eric Zimmerman>So let's not, let's not—.

1555
02:16:42.218 --> 02:16:42.459
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Smith.

1556
02:16:42.748 --> 02:16:46.476
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't want to get too fired up on what could happen if we don't pass this.

1557
02:16:47.718 --> 02:16:54.777
<v Eric Zimmerman>I will say I'm more in favor of having a policy in this city who does not allow carryovers.

1558
02:16:56.013 --> 02:16:59.388
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say that knowing that it could be damning to certain programs.

1559
02:17:01.663 --> 02:17:07.170
<v Eric Zimmerman>But when we evaluate a new budget, we evaluate every dollar.

1560
02:17:07.557 --> 02:17:11.355
<v Eric Zimmerman>And to plus it up or not plus it up A few months before we pass it.

1561
02:17:12.334 --> 02:17:17.007
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is— that— there's some historical stuff happening here, and I think it's good to recognize that.

1562
02:17:17.087 --> 02:17:34.846
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think this is probably one of the last technical adjustment ordinances we'll probably ever see because the Finance Committee this summer will be looking at a more monthly or quarterly— or excuse me, monthly, or even more often of budget modifications the way other governments do to be a little bit more transparent about these changes.

1563
02:17:34.895 --> 02:17:35.055
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1564
02:17:37.676 --> 02:17:53.092
<v Eric Zimmerman>But carryover this late in a fiscal year to go further into the next fiscal year when we're about to enter into a budget is a way to get a whole lot of numbers into a budget outside of the process that Councilor Smith is noting.

1565
02:17:53.691 --> 02:17:56.005
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I agree to everybody who said we do have the authority.

1566
02:17:56.361 --> 02:17:57.868
<v Eric Zimmerman>We 100% have the authority.

1567
02:17:58.061 --> 02:18:00.459
<v Eric Zimmerman>I question none of that for my colleagues who brought that up.

1568
02:18:01.308 --> 02:18:14.725
<v Eric Zimmerman>The point I guess I'm trying to make is that if this was so important, if this was the fact that we have folks who are not going to work tomorrow because we don't pass it today, I, I think we would have heard that.

1569
02:18:14.806 --> 02:18:15.897
<v Eric Zimmerman>We would have heard it ahead of time.

1570
02:18:15.961 --> 02:18:19.449
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm not hearing that from today's information from staff.

1571
02:18:19.496 --> 02:18:21.393
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not hearing that from people who are proposing it.

1572
02:18:21.891 --> 02:18:26.406
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so this looks like an end run on something that does not seem clear.

1573
02:18:26.470 --> 02:18:38.783
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor And so again, I'll encourage folks, and I think the budget office, if you have the ability to provide an answer for what would happen if we do not pass a technical adjustment today.

1574
02:18:41.877 --> 02:18:51.655
<v Olivia Clark>I mean, I think I can't speak for every single line item in it exactly, but I think the biggest problem would show up because of those technical changes.

1575
02:18:52.808 --> 02:18:55.463
<v Olivia Clark>Across funds and from contingency into funds.

1576
02:18:55.885 --> 02:19:04.444
<v Olivia Clark>The main reason we, you know, as some folks may have heard, we weren't planning to bring this forward this spring.

1577
02:19:04.718 --> 02:19:08.033
<v Olivia Clark>The main reason we did bring it forward was for those technical adjustments.

1578
02:19:08.099 --> 02:19:15.976
<v Olivia Clark>They would probably have to come as standalone ordinances because there are some where we heard people need to do them just to keep paying bills.

1579
02:19:16.040 --> 02:19:21.147
<v Olivia Clark>So those are, those are the The sort of meat of this ordinance is for that purpose.

1580
02:19:21.998 --> 02:19:26.206
<v Olivia Clark>To be perfectly frank, the carryover is not required.

1581
02:19:26.351 --> 02:19:28.790
<v Olivia Clark>It's not a required portion of this ordinance at all.

1582
02:19:30.203 --> 02:19:51.935
<v Olivia Clark>But the technical changes are, and the general fund return gives us a better sense of what we're looking at for '24— excuse me, for '25-'26 in terms of available It allows the mayor and you all to count that with more confidence.

1583
02:19:52.175 --> 02:20:04.557
<v Olivia Clark>I think if we didn't know that number, we would be a little bit more conservative in sort of what we're assuming in terms of fund balance that's going to show up at the end of the fiscal year, just because we wouldn't have that level of certainty.

1584
02:20:04.637 --> 02:20:08.983
<v Eric Zimmerman>So just to put a finer point— I want to make sure that we're— and, and some of this is me too.

1585
02:20:09.354 --> 02:20:15.611
<v Eric Zimmerman>All right, I've done a few of these, but it's a new government and I'm, I'm, I want to make sure I'm answering learning ques— or asking learning questions.

1586
02:20:16.163 --> 02:20:31.692
<v Eric Zimmerman>For the carryover column, if we do not authorize carryover, that money then goes into the beginning fund balance for the development of the upcoming budget that starts on July 1st.

1587
02:20:31.823 --> 02:20:33.700
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that a correct state?

1588
02:20:34.023 --> 02:20:34.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>No, you're pausing.

1589
02:20:34.897 --> 02:20:35.902
<v Olivia Clark>Um, no, it's correct.

1590
02:20:36.031 --> 02:20:36.192
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's—.

1591
02:20:36.225 --> 02:20:40.020
<v Olivia Clark>I mean, I mean, sort of either way it goes into beginning fund balance.

1592
02:20:40.148 --> 02:20:45.462
<v Olivia Clark>Honestly, there's no actual change, um, right, from this amendment.

1593
02:20:45.703 --> 02:20:48.289
<v Olivia Clark>It goes into beginning fund balance either way.

1594
02:20:48.497 --> 02:21:01.326
<v Olivia Clark>It's just, um, are we sort of pre-counting it towards that specific line item, or are you, um, leaving it into the pool of, of general fund that becomes allocated through the mayor's proposed budget and then through your budget?

1595
02:21:01.424 --> 02:21:16.306
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I say I say that, Madam President, just to highlight the point that it— if there is heartburn about this, my great ask here is I would still say I would ask you please do not pass this amendment.

1596
02:21:16.370 --> 02:21:21.448
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if we do, if we go forward with that, I would ask that we carve out the carryover.

1597
02:21:21.706 --> 02:21:30.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would be happy to make an amendment that we drop all the carryovers from this, but we make the technical adjustments tonight and drop the carryover so we can just include it as part of the regular budget.

1598
02:21:30.417 --> 02:21:36.293
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor But this one-off here and there, I don't know that these are coherent thoughts yet.

1599
02:21:36.989 --> 02:21:46.575
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so what is listed here is a way in which the executive branch has signaled some direction that we think— I think will probably be reflected on the May 7th release.

1600
02:21:47.755 --> 02:21:50.150
<v Eric Zimmerman>Those are all things we can talk about throughout that process.

1601
02:21:50.263 --> 02:21:52.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think those are healthy discussions.

1602
02:21:52.915 --> 02:21:57.545
<v Eric Zimmerman>But carryover policy is appropriate.

1603
02:21:57.593 --> 02:21:58.391
<v Eric Zimmerman>We should have that.

1604
02:21:58.488 --> 02:21:59.433
<v Eric Zimmerman>We owe it as a finance and as a city.

1605
02:21:59.498 --> 02:21:59.693
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1606
02:21:59.780 --> 02:22:03.242
<v Eric Zimmerman>As a counsel to the staff, like, how do we want to approach carryover next year?

1607
02:22:05.753 --> 02:22:07.618
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I don't think we should one-off it tonight.

1608
02:22:07.987 --> 02:22:13.054
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if we can take all the carryover out and just pass the technical, I'd be fine with that too.

1609
02:22:13.799 --> 02:22:29.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>But this one-off right now, I think this is sending what— this is sending this down a direction where I'm not sure that there's a lot of confidence around the dais about exactly where things came from, exactly where things are going, exactly how it It affects the proposed budget coming forward, and I'm hearing that loud and clear.

1610
02:22:31.788 --> 02:22:36.701
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to be cautious of downtrace effects if we make changes tonight.

1611
02:22:36.943 --> 02:22:42.354
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then other things that are just programmatic direction setting, and those are different items tonight.

1612
02:22:42.435 --> 02:22:42.807
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's all.

1613
02:22:44.373 --> 02:22:45.083
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1614
02:22:45.180 --> 02:22:50.922
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we are 10 minutes, 18 minutes over time and still on an amendment here.

1615
02:22:51.003 --> 02:22:53.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we do have 2 people left in the queue.

1616
02:22:53.500 --> 02:23:00.554
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would just ask that we keep comments, um, to new issues so that we can get to a vote.

1617
02:23:01.051 --> 02:23:01.870
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1618
02:23:03.125 --> 02:23:04.168
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

1619
02:23:04.409 --> 02:23:09.536
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I, I have no problem with the idea that we should, uh, be considering carryovers broadly.

1620
02:23:09.728 --> 02:23:12.975
<v Sameer Kanal>I think, um, that, that is an important point.

1621
02:23:13.247 --> 02:23:37.004
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but the question before us is whether or not That if we're doing these other 17 carryovers, we should have 2 that are for these particular programs and whether those are meaningful and things that we would like to see not only carried over, but that that certainty is given today or whenever we pass the document, not June 20th or whenever we pass the full budget.

1622
02:23:37.502 --> 02:23:42.638
<v Sameer Kanal>And that allows that money to be more shovel-ready on July 1st to get out the door.

1623
02:23:42.781 --> 02:23:43.631
<v Sameer Kanal>That's a really important part of this.

1624
02:23:43.681 --> 02:23:43.888
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1625
02:23:43.969 --> 02:23:46.067
<v Sameer Kanal>This process is having that certainty.

1626
02:23:46.504 --> 02:23:49.118
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's maybe less relevant for some programs than others.

1627
02:23:49.166 --> 02:23:49.538
<v Sameer Kanal>I get that.

1628
02:23:50.110 --> 02:23:51.191
<v Sameer Kanal>But certainty is valuable.

1629
02:23:51.610 --> 02:23:54.514
<v Sameer Kanal>It conveys a message to the people managing these programs.

1630
02:23:54.902 --> 02:23:59.307
<v Sameer Kanal>And we're being asked to be deferential to the administration.

1631
02:23:59.484 --> 02:24:00.211
<v Sameer Kanal>I recognize that.

1632
02:24:00.292 --> 02:24:12.488
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think generally speaking, if there's— if the people that we're asked to be deferential towards represent a status quo that suits us, I can see why that would be appealing.

1633
02:24:12.537 --> 02:24:12.652
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1634
02:24:13.827 --> 02:24:17.887
<v Sameer Kanal>We're being asked to be deferential to committees that we're not necessarily on, but only some of the time.

1635
02:24:18.335 --> 02:24:20.212
<v Sameer Kanal>That hasn't been enforced consistently here.

1636
02:24:20.677 --> 02:24:29.773
<v Sameer Kanal>7 Of us have a responsibility to manage the— we have a financial fiduciary responsibility to the city, the same as the 5 who are on the Finance Committee.

1637
02:24:30.368 --> 02:24:32.870
<v Sameer Kanal>That's an important thing to keep in mind here.

1638
02:24:33.319 --> 02:24:38.228
<v Sameer Kanal>And so this is where the final decision is going to be made, not at the committee level.

1639
02:24:38.532 --> 02:24:39.238
<v Sameer Kanal>We've always known that.

1640
02:24:39.592 --> 02:24:41.579
<v Sameer Kanal>The question is how deferential are we going to be on it?

1641
02:24:41.900 --> 02:24:42.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Again, we didn't have the time.

1642
02:24:42.798 --> 02:24:43.615
<v Sameer Kanal>We didn't have a work session.

1643
02:24:43.680 --> 02:24:45.476
<v Sameer Kanal>I completely agree with Councilor Smith on that.

1644
02:24:45.924 --> 02:24:50.477
<v Sameer Kanal>But council is the budget committee and not any of the subcommittees of the council.

1645
02:24:50.557 --> 02:25:04.761
<v Sameer Kanal>So with that, I would ask for a vote in favor to signal the use of the money, but also to earmark that money effectively into this— again, this fiscal year's money to continue allocating it the way it's already been allocated.

1646
02:25:04.808 --> 02:25:04.905
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1647
02:25:05.772 --> 02:25:09.336
<v Sameer Kanal>That's what this amendment would do for these 2 particular projects.

1648
02:25:10.996 --> 02:25:12.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1649
02:25:13.013 --> 02:25:14.271
<v Unidentified speaker>Madam President, I call the question.

1650
02:25:16.250 --> 02:25:16.933
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a second?

1651
02:25:18.787 --> 02:25:19.430
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1652
02:25:20.635 --> 02:25:22.852
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call the roll?

1653
02:25:22.980 --> 02:25:29.233
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a vote on whether to end discussion and vote on the emergency ordinance before us.

1654
02:25:30.579 --> 02:25:30.744
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

1655
02:25:32.092 --> 02:25:43.203
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to vote no, but I want to make a comment that I think that I would suggest we pull this and bring it to the Finance Committee meeting and bring it to our May 7th meeting.

1656
02:25:43.640 --> 02:25:45.968
<v Unidentified speaker>I would like to ask, um, I just want to put that out there.

1657
02:25:46.016 --> 02:25:51.529
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sure it'd still be timely enough to get through the process of the spring bump, but I vote no on this question.

1658
02:25:53.809 --> 02:26:02.231
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I'm going to jump in while we have a pause to say I misstated that this is a vote on whether to move to the vote on the amendment, not on the emergency ordinance.

1659
02:26:02.328 --> 02:26:06.377
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor, I think you asked a question on whether there was timing to refer this back.

1660
02:26:07.197 --> 02:26:07.613
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

1661
02:26:08.240 --> 02:26:14.844
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Which I think is out of order while we are in the middle of this vote.

1662
02:26:14.989 --> 02:26:15.762
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I think we should—.

1663
02:26:15.762 --> 02:26:23.224
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it is, but I wanted to— I had my hand up before Councilor Green put that there, and I would— I was suggesting it to you, Council President.

1664
02:26:23.288 --> 02:26:30.894
<v Unidentified speaker>I think you have the authority to pull something back and move it to a committee, and then we can bring it to the next council meeting because this is clear as mud.

1665
02:26:31.989 --> 02:26:32.328
<v Keelan McClymont>Let's move.

1666
02:26:32.814 --> 02:26:34.432
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's— we are in the middle of a vote.

1667
02:26:34.512 --> 02:26:35.692
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's finish this vote.

1668
02:26:36.533 --> 02:26:36.792
<v Unidentified speaker>All right.

1669
02:26:36.938 --> 02:26:38.587
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to let you know that's why my hand was up.

1670
02:26:38.765 --> 02:26:39.138
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1671
02:26:39.622 --> 02:26:41.143
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1672
02:26:42.729 --> 02:26:45.852
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, so we're voting on Councilor Kanal's amendment.

1673
02:26:46.061 --> 02:26:46.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are not.

1674
02:26:46.628 --> 02:26:50.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are voting to end debate and take the vote On the amendment.

1675
02:26:51.042 --> 02:26:51.238
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah.

1676
02:26:54.861 --> 02:26:55.814
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, was that an aye?

1677
02:26:56.056 --> 02:26:56.103
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1678
02:26:56.540 --> 02:26:56.781
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes.

1679
02:26:57.427 --> 02:26:58.185
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

1680
02:26:58.799 --> 02:26:58.847
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1681
02:26:59.541 --> 02:26:59.897
<v Keelan McClymont>Melvey?

1682
02:27:01.316 --> 02:27:06.811
<v Steve Novick>For the record, I'm disappointed that Councilor Ryan didn't quote Al Pacino and say, out of order, out of order, this whole council is out of order.

1683
02:27:07.281 --> 02:27:07.313
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1684
02:27:07.637 --> 02:27:08.736
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark?

1685
02:27:09.465 --> 02:27:09.513
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1686
02:27:10.192 --> 02:27:10.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Green?

1687
02:27:10.921 --> 02:27:11.099
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1688
02:27:11.568 --> 02:27:11.957
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1689
02:27:12.216 --> 02:27:12.394
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1690
02:27:13.090 --> 02:27:13.415
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

1691
02:27:13.837 --> 02:27:13.887
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1692
02:27:14.406 --> 02:27:14.798
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1693
02:27:14.993 --> 02:27:15.058
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1694
02:27:15.138 --> 02:27:15.382
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1695
02:27:17.996 --> 02:27:18.174
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1696
02:27:20.090 --> 02:27:20.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1697
02:27:21.555 --> 02:27:24.790
<v Keelan McClymont>With 11 aye votes, the question is called.

1698
02:27:25.177 --> 02:27:31.737
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we now move into a vote on the amendment to the emergency ordinance.

1699
02:27:34.329 --> 02:27:35.343
<v Sameer Kanal>Fairly obviously, aye.

1700
02:27:36.143 --> 02:27:36.959
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

1701
02:27:42.099 --> 02:27:56.950
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So as we're thinking about the upcoming budget, something that I've been hearing is that thought about efficiency and making sure that our departments are running well and also this need for stability.

1702
02:27:57.368 --> 02:28:06.949
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so that is compelling to me that this is a step towards that, that this action shows that we're trying to provide some stability for these bureaus here.

1703
02:28:07.220 --> 02:28:12.545
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so I recognize this is a little uncomfortable, but I think it takes us I vote aye.

1704
02:28:15.345 --> 02:28:15.394
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1705
02:28:18.271 --> 02:28:25.788
<v Steve Novick>So I agree with Councilor Zimmerman that we need to have a discussion about carryovers as a council for next year.

1706
02:28:27.709 --> 02:28:28.583
<v Unidentified speaker>And I—.

1707
02:28:29.746 --> 02:28:44.778
<v Steve Novick>Okay, I'm gonna waste everybody's time by pointing out that there is an argument for carryovers in that If you don't have some carryover, then bureaus might feel like they need to spend all their money by the end of the year 'cause otherwise they'll lose it.

1708
02:28:44.922 --> 02:28:47.504
<v Steve Novick>And I think there should be some incentive to keep it.

1709
02:28:47.569 --> 02:28:54.581
<v Steve Novick>In fact, when Gary Locke was governor of Washington, he adopted a policy that you don't automatically lose all your money if you don't spend it by the end of the year.

1710
02:28:55.030 --> 02:28:56.137
<v Steve Novick>You get to keep half of it.

1711
02:28:56.698 --> 02:29:01.382
<v Steve Novick>So I suspect I'll be arguing for a change in policy to that effect.

1712
02:29:01.447 --> 02:29:02.859
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1713
02:29:03.595 --> 02:29:11.433
<v Steve Novick>I am going to oppose the amendment largely because the administration has come up with a carryover policy.

1714
02:29:12.025 --> 02:29:18.724
<v Steve Novick>I don't know if I agree with it, but I haven't heard it explained in great detail, and I'm reluctant to change the policy without having a replacement.

1715
02:29:19.236 --> 02:29:25.583
<v Steve Novick>And also, frankly, I see that another chunk of money that's not being carried over is something called CIMS for PBEM.

1716
02:29:26.111 --> 02:29:33.728
<v Steve Novick>And given that PBEM is in desperate need of money, If I voted for Councilor Kanal's amendment, I'd feel compelled to offer an amendment for PBAM to keep that money too.

1717
02:29:34.244 --> 02:29:35.387
<v Steve Novick>And I don't wanna keep us here till midnight.

1718
02:29:36.319 --> 02:29:43.302
<v Steve Novick>So I'm conflicted on this, but sort of as a matter of process, I'm going to vote no.

1719
02:29:44.176 --> 02:29:44.533
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1720
02:29:44.922 --> 02:29:45.148
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1721
02:29:46.137 --> 02:29:46.429
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1722
02:29:47.334 --> 02:29:47.384
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1723
02:29:48.404 --> 02:29:48.858
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

1724
02:29:49.441 --> 02:29:49.700
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1725
02:29:50.639 --> 02:29:50.885
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1726
02:29:51.475 --> 02:29:51.638
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1727
02:29:52.309 --> 02:29:52.769
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1728
02:29:53.932 --> 02:29:53.965
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1729
02:29:57.316 --> 02:29:57.510
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

1730
02:30:01.235 --> 02:30:08.289
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As I stated before, I truly am worried about us having the flexibility that we need when the budget comes to us.

1731
02:30:08.697 --> 02:30:09.185
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I vote no.

1732
02:30:11.450 --> 02:30:14.558
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment has 6 yes votes and 6 no votes.

1733
02:30:14.622 --> 02:30:16.604
<v Keelan McClymont>It's tied and the amendment fails.

1734
02:30:18.709 --> 02:30:18.826
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1735
02:30:18.877 --> 02:30:19.461
<v Loretta Smith>Where's the mayor?

1736
02:30:19.663 --> 02:30:30.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, um, So I'm going to invite up Robert Taylor to clarify what happens in a split vote on an amendment.

1737
02:30:32.809 --> 02:30:44.138
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, predicting that this might happen, I did check in with both Robert Taylor to make sure he was here and could explain to us the process, and also on the mayor's whereabouts.

1738
02:30:44.203 --> 02:30:45.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The mayor is not in the building and not reachable.

1739
02:30:45.576 --> 02:30:46.385
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council Clerk Rebecca Dobert.

1740
02:30:47.657 --> 02:30:49.454
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Robert, please introduce yourself.

1741
02:30:51.138 --> 02:30:51.477
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1742
02:30:51.558 --> 02:30:53.388
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, Robert Taylor, City Attorney.

1743
02:30:55.454 --> 02:31:08.199
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, as it stands now under the charter, it gives the mayor the responsibility to, um, break a tie vote on a matter before council.

1744
02:31:09.228 --> 02:31:13.459
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, we read that to mean the tie vote on final passage.

1745
02:31:14.343 --> 02:31:17.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>In the absence of any council rule to the contrary.

1746
02:31:18.679 --> 02:31:23.720
<v Eric Zimmerman>Council has its own authority under the charter to adopt its rules of procedure.

1747
02:31:23.881 --> 02:31:34.157
<v Eric Zimmerman>If council wants to adopt a rule that allows the mayor to vote on procedural matters like motion to table, motion to refer, motion to amend, they can do so.

1748
02:31:35.298 --> 02:31:41.673
<v Eric Zimmerman>But as it stands now, the procedural motion on the motion to amend tied 6-6.

1749
02:31:41.720 --> 02:31:41.864
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1750
02:31:42.288 --> 02:31:42.745
<v Eric Zimmerman>It fails.

1751
02:31:45.059 --> 02:31:47.146
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any questions about that explanation?

1752
02:31:48.801 --> 02:31:51.594
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, Councilor.

1753
02:31:52.031 --> 02:32:04.620
<v Loretta Smith>I'm concerned and I'm troubled with that explanation because the same thing happened when we were trying to vote in our president, and they said except for that vote, he can break every other tie.

1754
02:32:05.103 --> 02:32:06.940
<v Loretta Smith>So here we are with every other tie.

1755
02:32:07.834 --> 02:32:09.816
<v Loretta Smith>So now you're saying he can't break this?

1756
02:32:10.727 --> 02:32:24.042
<v Eric Zimmerman>And when that issue came up on January 2nd, the advice was also— there was a question about whether council could adopt a rule to give the mayor the tie-breaking vote on the election for president.

1757
02:32:24.108 --> 02:32:24.971
<v Loretta Smith>That's not what I said.

1758
02:32:25.235 --> 02:32:27.527
<v Loretta Smith>I said you can do it based on the current charter.

1759
02:32:31.105 --> 02:32:32.894
<v Eric Zimmerman>I understand this issue has come up before.

1760
02:32:33.755 --> 02:32:36.355
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and I've—.

1761
02:32:37.228 --> 02:32:39.683
<v Unidentified speaker>And it's unfortunate it has come up again.

1762
02:32:39.731 --> 02:32:44.701
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think I anticipated this issue coming up at this venue right now.

1763
02:32:46.115 --> 02:32:47.888
<v Unidentified speaker>But we have thought about this in our office.

1764
02:32:48.610 --> 02:32:54.103
<v Eric Zimmerman>We do believe that charter provision contemplates the mayor breaking a tie on final passage.

1765
02:32:55.028 --> 02:32:58.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if you want it, the council does have their authority.

1766
02:32:58.495 --> 02:32:58.644
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1767
02:32:59.548 --> 02:33:06.927
<v Eric Zimmerman>To adopt their own rules, they can adopt a rule giving the mayor the, the ability to break a tie on procedural matters.

1768
02:33:08.386 --> 02:33:10.172
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is council's prerogative to do that.

1769
02:33:11.218 --> 02:33:13.840
<v Loretta Smith>Can we pull up the language on the charter so we can read the language?

1770
02:33:14.113 --> 02:33:15.433
<v Loretta Smith>Pull it up on the, um, screen.

1771
02:33:18.477 --> 02:33:19.290
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can pull it up.

1772
02:33:19.516 --> 02:33:26.505
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is our attorney's legal advice, and again, Councilor, I It is one line in charter.

1773
02:33:27.020 --> 02:33:28.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's pull it up so that everybody can see it.

1774
02:33:28.736 --> 02:33:30.968
<v Loretta Smith>But he's adding more lines to the charter, and that's what I'm saying.

1775
02:33:31.015 --> 02:33:33.407
<v Loretta Smith>Let's look at what exactly the charter says.

1776
02:33:33.584 --> 02:33:35.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>He's interpreting and giving us advice.

1777
02:33:36.007 --> 02:33:50.083
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There have been conversations about bringing forward a conversation around, um, expanding on the one line in charter because there clearly is not a lot of meat to this.

1778
02:33:50.435 --> 02:33:56.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's not direction on what we do if the mayor is not able to be present on a final vote when this does come into effect.

1779
02:33:57.040 --> 02:33:59.878
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So there are conversations that governance will need to have around this.

1780
02:34:00.470 --> 02:34:06.386
<v Loretta Smith>I would like Candace Avalos, who is the chair of the Charter Committee, to say what was the intent.

1781
02:34:06.627 --> 02:34:08.245
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I want to know.

1782
02:34:08.406 --> 02:34:11.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am not sure if that is in order.

1783
02:34:11.755 --> 02:34:15.027
<v Loretta Smith>She needs to tell us what the intent was because I know what it says.

1784
02:34:15.763 --> 02:34:16.468
<v Loretta Smith>He settles the tie.

1785
02:34:19.777 --> 02:34:24.320
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I don't know that that is in order, and I don't see Councilor Avalos leaning in to do that.

1786
02:34:24.851 --> 02:34:26.825
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's get the charter up very quickly.

1787
02:34:26.938 --> 02:34:28.431
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are at 8:30.

1788
02:34:28.703 --> 02:34:35.576
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to finish this agenda item so that we can take a break and move on to other meaty items.

1789
02:34:36.572 --> 02:34:38.386
<v Unidentified speaker>Madam President, point of clarification.

1790
02:34:38.739 --> 02:34:41.823
<v Unidentified speaker>Are we now back to the original motion?

1791
02:34:42.514 --> 02:34:43.014
<v Candace Avalos>We are—.

1792
02:34:44.048 --> 02:34:44.531
<v Eric Zimmerman>Call the question.

1793
02:34:44.611 --> 02:34:46.193
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are back to the original motion.

1794
02:34:46.531 --> 02:34:47.081
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1795
02:34:47.920 --> 02:34:51.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we have called the question and we have a second.

1796
02:34:53.959 --> 02:34:55.131
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor points of order.

1797
02:34:55.341 --> 02:34:56.192
<v Unidentified speaker>There were—.

1798
02:34:56.563 --> 02:35:05.324
<v Sameer Kanal>My understanding is that there were motions that were floated a moment ago, um, to table this item or to refer it back.

1799
02:35:05.486 --> 02:35:08.815
<v Sameer Kanal>It would just preclude those motions which were suggested by the person who just spoke.

1800
02:35:12.980 --> 02:35:14.791
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There were no motions given.

1801
02:35:14.921 --> 02:35:24.967
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There was an ask for me to consider sending this back to committee from Councilor Ryan, which I'm not inclined to do since committee already had a robust discussion about this ordinance.

1802
02:35:26.440 --> 02:35:31.022
<v Sameer Kanal>Well, it wouldn't be— it would be our decision as a council, not yours individually, as I recall.

1803
02:35:31.619 --> 02:35:31.974
<v Angelita Morillo>Either.

1804
02:35:32.925 --> 02:35:35.797
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And yes, council could vote to do that, but right now we have a motion to refer this back to committee.

1805
02:35:36.724 --> 02:35:40.755
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A motion to call the question, which supersedes debate.

1806
02:35:41.140 --> 02:35:42.891
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That would be something that could be raised in debate.

1807
02:35:43.068 --> 02:35:43.871
<v Candace Avalos>Point of order, though.

1808
02:35:44.497 --> 02:35:48.868
<v Candace Avalos>To call any motion, you have to have the floor, and I see there are people in queue.

1809
02:35:49.236 --> 02:35:53.043
<v Candace Avalos>And so are we accepting a motion that's randomly thrown out before looking at the queue?

1810
02:35:53.188 --> 02:35:55.003
<v Candace Avalos>I, I don't think that's Robert's Rules.

1811
02:35:55.051 --> 02:35:58.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If folks are in the queue for discussion on this, then yes, we would move to them.

1812
02:35:59.115 --> 02:36:01.509
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I thought that those were hands left over that hadn't been lowered.

1813
02:36:03.888 --> 02:36:11.076
<v Candace Avalos>In general, though, I don't think if somebody shouts out an order that we, you know, you should at least say you have the floor before you accept it.

1814
02:36:11.254 --> 02:36:14.612
<v Candace Avalos>I don't think that's Robert's Rules that anybody can just say that and you move on it.

1815
02:36:14.986 --> 02:36:20.762
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, are you in the queue on the main ordinance?

1816
02:36:21.621 --> 02:36:25.496
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, but I'm happy to let you finish this conversation if that's helpful.

1817
02:36:26.850 --> 02:36:27.165
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1818
02:36:28.986 --> 02:36:34.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, I, I don't know, do we have the charter language pulled up?

1819
02:36:34.750 --> 02:36:34.831
<v Loretta Smith>Yep.

1820
02:36:35.552 --> 02:36:36.565
<v Eric Zimmerman>Still calling the question.

1821
02:36:37.656 --> 02:36:40.387
<v Eric Zimmerman>Robert's Rules does not ask for a Zoom call.

1822
02:36:41.029 --> 02:36:43.325
<v Eric Zimmerman>We have called the question, Madam President.

1823
02:36:43.694 --> 02:36:44.882
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's time for the vote.

1824
02:36:45.108 --> 02:36:48.864
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Robert's Rules does not state what order we do things in.

1825
02:36:49.201 --> 02:36:49.572
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You are right.

1826
02:36:49.620 --> 02:36:53.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Robert's Rules doesn't say that somebody can't jump in to call the question.

1827
02:36:53.137 --> 02:37:05.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our procedures do say that this is how we take We have had folks work a little more casually before, but right now we have an objection to that.

1828
02:37:06.002 --> 02:37:13.296
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm going to defer to what our procedures are, which is that we take things in the order that is in Zoom.

1829
02:37:14.052 --> 02:37:14.376
<v Loretta Smith>Hmm.

1830
02:37:16.292 --> 02:37:23.156
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, we take things in the order in Zoom with the exception, which we've discussed before, that if somebody has not yet Yes.

1831
02:37:23.283 --> 02:37:26.351
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Spoken, they move to the front of the line, which is what happened earlier.

1832
02:37:27.041 --> 02:37:33.897
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we are still on the discussion that you have raised, Councilor, around the charter.

1833
02:37:34.797 --> 02:37:37.317
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we do have the charter section up.

1834
02:37:37.558 --> 02:37:39.726
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is under the duties of the mayor.

1835
02:37:39.934 --> 02:37:51.424
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is not written in the council part of the charter, but under the duties of the mayor, one of them is listed here, E. Vote on matters before the council.

1836
02:37:51.845 --> 02:37:54.737
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In case of a tie, when the mayor casts the deciding vote.

1837
02:37:56.995 --> 02:37:58.708
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, did you want to comment on that?

1838
02:38:00.685 --> 02:38:02.091
<v Loretta Smith>I can, I can talk.

1839
02:38:02.300 --> 02:38:04.190
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we are still on your comments.

1840
02:38:04.351 --> 02:38:05.141
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, okay, okay, perfect.

1841
02:38:05.368 --> 02:38:14.224
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, so the legal— and, and Robert, I, I, um, trust your legal experience in this.

1842
02:38:14.272 --> 02:38:26.439
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not trying to I don't mean to disagree with you, but I am disagreeing with your legal assessment because what— I don't know how you get to where you're at from just that line because it's very clear what it says.

1843
02:38:27.272 --> 02:38:33.737
<v Loretta Smith>And I hate that I didn't ask that question to bring it up when I asked you it originally, and we could have solved all this.

1844
02:38:34.572 --> 02:38:37.636
<v Loretta Smith>But to me, I, I don't accept it.

1845
02:38:38.582 --> 02:38:48.443
<v Loretta Smith>I, I respect your, your legal knowledge, but I don't accept what what, what you're telling us, because the mayor probably knew that this was going to be an issue and he should have been here.

1846
02:38:50.760 --> 02:38:55.144
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor, uh, first I want to thank you for the, the reasonable disagreement.

1847
02:38:55.320 --> 02:38:56.594
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really do thank you for that.

1848
02:38:57.077 --> 02:39:13.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then secondly, the— when we read that, we think the phrase, when the mayor casts the deciding vote, that means the final vote on passage or adoption, not a procedural motion to amend or to table or to refer.

1849
02:39:13.817 --> 02:39:16.995
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's how we, that's how we get to that conclusion.

1850
02:39:17.588 --> 02:39:20.877
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I understand folks can read that differently.

1851
02:39:21.198 --> 02:39:31.947
<v Eric Zimmerman>And again, if council wants to give the mayor the authority to cast that type of vote on procedural motions, I do believe council has that authority to make a rule like that.

1852
02:39:32.028 --> 02:39:33.343
<v Loretta Smith>He's not here though.

1853
02:39:34.643 --> 02:39:40.299
<v Loretta Smith>And so it wouldn't matter, and it's his budget item.

1854
02:39:44.252 --> 02:39:45.576
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, anything else?

1855
02:39:45.868 --> 02:39:46.239
<v Keelan McClymont>No, ma'am.

1856
02:39:46.497 --> 02:39:46.933
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1857
02:39:48.129 --> 02:39:49.066
<v Loretta Smith>They called the question.

1858
02:39:50.159 --> 02:39:53.341
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Well, in the order in the queue, Councilor Kanal.

1859
02:39:54.915 --> 02:40:06.667
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, Madam President, not to, not to complicate things further, I don't believe Councilor Novick has We are back to the main motion.

1860
02:40:06.716 --> 02:40:08.566
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, have you spoken to the main motion?

1861
02:40:10.430 --> 02:40:12.278
<v Unidentified speaker>I have not spoken to the main motion.

1862
02:40:12.503 --> 02:40:13.243
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

1863
02:40:13.338 --> 02:40:14.432
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, thank you.

1864
02:40:15.990 --> 02:40:16.859
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to call the question.

1865
02:40:16.907 --> 02:40:17.212
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1866
02:40:18.177 --> 02:40:18.578
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1867
02:40:20.920 --> 02:40:23.120
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The question has been called and seconded.

1868
02:40:23.184 --> 02:40:28.102
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a vote on whether or not to end discussion and move to a vote.

1869
02:40:31.329 --> 02:40:44.219
<v Sameer Kanal>We need to get out of the habit of using calling the question to cut off— I have to speak to my vote.

1870
02:40:44.219 --> 02:40:45.790
<v Sameer Kanal>That's my reason for voting no.

1871
02:40:46.260 --> 02:40:52.090
<v Sameer Kanal>We need to get out of the habit of using the idea of calling the question to cut off our colleagues.

1872
02:40:52.280 --> 02:40:54.579
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not a good way of doing things, and that is my reason for voting no.

1873
02:40:54.579 --> 02:40:54.639
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1874
02:41:02.345 --> 02:41:02.555
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1875
02:41:03.472 --> 02:41:04.856
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

1876
02:41:05.807 --> 02:41:09.606
<v Angelita Morillo>Wait, I'm sorry, I think there's a few of us confused on exactly what we're voting on at this time.

1877
02:41:10.058 --> 02:41:11.137
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are calling the question.

1878
02:41:11.200 --> 02:41:15.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are voting on whether to end debate and vote on the passage of the emergency ordinance.

1879
02:41:15.887 --> 02:41:16.370
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, aye.

1880
02:41:19.413 --> 02:41:20.668
<v Steve Novick>The overall emergency ordinance?

1881
02:41:20.897 --> 02:41:22.806
<v Steve Novick>So we'll be passing it without the amendment.

1882
02:41:23.147 --> 02:41:23.685
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Correct.

1883
02:41:23.897 --> 02:41:25.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The amendment was voted down.

1884
02:41:28.459 --> 02:41:30.861
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But this is the vote on calling the question.

1885
02:41:31.072 --> 02:41:32.582
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the vote on ending debate.

1886
02:41:32.679 --> 02:41:33.458
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Would you like to end debate?

1887
02:41:35.760 --> 02:41:36.472
<v Steve Novick>Regretfully, aye.

1888
02:41:38.207 --> 02:41:38.548
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1889
02:41:39.018 --> 02:41:39.066
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1890
02:41:39.844 --> 02:41:40.055
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1891
02:41:41.125 --> 02:41:41.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1892
02:41:41.951 --> 02:41:42.406
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1893
02:41:42.826 --> 02:41:42.876
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1894
02:41:43.459 --> 02:41:43.708
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1895
02:41:44.422 --> 02:41:44.637
<v Candace Avalos>No.

1896
02:41:45.815 --> 02:41:46.212
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1897
02:41:46.637 --> 02:41:49.192
<v Unidentified speaker>I would have liked to have heard what Councilor Novick had to say.

1898
02:41:49.275 --> 02:41:49.934
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, I vote no.

1899
02:41:52.100 --> 02:41:53.634
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

1900
02:41:54.247 --> 02:41:54.264
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1901
02:41:55.137 --> 02:41:55.185
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1902
02:41:56.606 --> 02:41:59.595
<v Keelan McClymont>With 9 yes votes, the question is called.

1903
02:42:04.247 --> 02:42:10.781
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, do we need a motion and a second?

1904
02:42:11.138 --> 02:42:14.045
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so we are just moving into a vote on the emergency ordinance.

1905
02:42:14.871 --> 02:42:19.682
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, this is a vote on agenda item number 10, which is an emergency ordinance.

1906
02:42:19.810 --> 02:42:23.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This vote would lead to failure or final passage.

1907
02:42:23.292 --> 02:42:25.739
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This emergency ordinance is not amended.

1908
02:42:25.805 --> 02:42:28.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is here before us in its introduced form.

1909
02:42:32.825 --> 02:42:33.245
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1910
02:42:33.453 --> 02:42:40.647
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, it's a very difficult one, and it's difficult because the process that's led us to this point has been, uh, very challenging.

1911
02:42:41.993 --> 02:42:49.236
<v Sameer Kanal>We had seen a committee get to hear it, but with limited even advance notice for them, let alone the other 7 of us.

1912
02:42:50.710 --> 02:43:01.639
<v Sameer Kanal>And now it's also being proposed as an emergency ordinance when even from the information we've heard from our staff says that there would not actually be any impact to waiting until May 7th to do it.

1913
02:43:02.809 --> 02:43:06.254
<v Sameer Kanal>As it is an emergency ordinance, and I have brought this up several times from this dais, Councilor Smith.

1914
02:43:08.343 --> 02:43:10.983
<v Sameer Kanal>It needs to fulfill the criteria of an emergency.

1915
02:43:11.191 --> 02:43:15.200
<v Sameer Kanal>It doesn't do that based on what we're hearing from the staff today.

1916
02:43:16.860 --> 02:43:26.308
<v Sameer Kanal>Avoiding future delay is not a reason for cutting off the ability of the public to see this for longer than 5 days from the posting to the consideration.

1917
02:43:28.065 --> 02:43:32.161
<v Sameer Kanal>Secondly, I mean, yeah, it wouldn't have affected my vote, but I do think it's worth saying that— Councilor Smith.

1918
02:43:33.264 --> 02:43:38.372
<v Sameer Kanal>It's important to convey to our public safety partners in the administration what we stand on.

1919
02:43:38.870 --> 02:43:46.468
<v Sameer Kanal>We stand for receiving data not only from the loudest voices in the room, but from everybody who has had an interaction good, bad, or neutral with the police.

1920
02:43:46.998 --> 02:43:57.825
<v Sameer Kanal>And we stand on ensuring that firefighters are funded for the training program so that we are able to reduce overtime while retaining the levels of service that we have been trying to.

1921
02:43:58.386 --> 02:44:05.756
<v Sameer Kanal>Maintain in very difficult times for that bureau and frankly for the entirety of the public safety service area.

1922
02:44:06.174 --> 02:44:14.265
<v Sameer Kanal>And so as a co-chair of the public safety service— sorry, community and public safety committee, I was very happy to try and convey that.

1923
02:44:14.665 --> 02:44:15.564
<v Sameer Kanal>I am disappointed in that.

1924
02:44:15.628 --> 02:44:16.878
<v Sameer Kanal>That's not going to affect my vote.

1925
02:44:17.134 --> 02:44:34.253
<v Sameer Kanal>The emergency ordinance reasoning and frankly Councilor Zimmerman's argument earlier and Councilor Ryan's argument earlier on why we don't necessarily need to do Aye.

1926
02:44:35.011 --> 02:44:35.139
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1927
02:44:35.977 --> 02:44:36.075
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1928
02:44:37.751 --> 02:44:47.288
<v Steve Novick>I'd like to take this opportunity to tell the council president that this is one of those nights that makes me think that there's not enough money in the world to get— make me take her job.

1929
02:44:47.836 --> 02:44:47.885
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1930
02:44:48.483 --> 02:44:49.048
<v Steve Novick>Mark.

1931
02:44:51.694 --> 02:44:57.049
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to say that we're really fledgling legislators and we have a lot to learn.

1932
02:44:58.200 --> 02:44:59.245
<v Unidentified speaker>We have a lot to practice.

1933
02:44:59.582 --> 02:45:02.171
<v Unidentified speaker>We have procedures to understand and to implement.

1934
02:45:02.879 --> 02:45:03.619
<v Unidentified speaker>We have a long way to go.

1935
02:45:03.876 --> 02:45:04.711
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a great start.

1936
02:45:04.841 --> 02:45:06.078
<v Unidentified speaker>A little bit of sausage making here.

1937
02:45:06.915 --> 02:45:07.403
<v Olivia Clark>I vote aye.

1938
02:45:08.298 --> 02:45:08.524
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1939
02:45:10.166 --> 02:45:10.345
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1940
02:45:11.402 --> 02:45:11.858
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1941
02:45:12.523 --> 02:45:12.573
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1942
02:45:13.336 --> 02:45:13.646
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1943
02:45:16.755 --> 02:45:19.927
<v Candace Avalos>Regrettably, I vote aye because I do— I wish the amendment passed, but I vote aye.

1944
02:45:22.976 --> 02:45:22.992
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1945
02:45:24.189 --> 02:45:24.317
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1946
02:45:25.416 --> 02:45:33.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, there was a lot of conversation through this debate about process and who had an opportunity to weigh in and where.

1947
02:45:34.132 --> 02:45:35.306
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have committees for a reason.

1948
02:45:35.579 --> 02:45:40.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We all agreed early on in this process that we wanted to have committees as part of our work.

1949
02:45:41.277 --> 02:45:41.968
<v Angelita Morillo>The full Councilor Dan Ryan.

1950
02:45:42.032 --> 02:45:42.290
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

1951
02:45:42.354 --> 02:45:46.242
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it's important to remember that the folks who gave us this form of government did so writing committees into the work.

1952
02:45:47.270 --> 02:45:55.254
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Many of us have missed opportunities to bring things to committees that we don't sit on, myself included, and that will happen from time to time.

1953
02:45:55.351 --> 02:46:05.376
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we have council, full council, as a place to, to bring things where we missed and didn't get them in in time and to have robust conversation.

1954
02:46:05.487 --> 02:46:06.147
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's important.

1955
02:46:06.837 --> 02:46:15.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But to suggest that something was rushed because it went through a committee you were not on feels highly disingenuous to me.

1956
02:46:17.163 --> 02:46:18.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't sit on policy committees.

1957
02:46:18.970 --> 02:46:23.781
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I sit on 2 committees, but not our policy committees, and I trust you all to do the work.

1958
02:46:25.309 --> 02:46:26.406
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sometimes I don't agree.

1959
02:46:26.567 --> 02:46:30.618
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sometimes I want to bring an amendment and I miss doing it before things come here.

1960
02:46:31.135 --> 02:46:32.377
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm working to get better at that.

1961
02:46:32.425 --> 02:46:33.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope we all are.

1962
02:46:33.733 --> 02:46:36.533
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope we are all working at bringing things earlier.

1963
02:46:36.618 --> 02:46:44.585
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor So that there is more time, we have created a referral list so that items can be public before they are put on agendas.

1964
02:46:45.181 --> 02:46:52.325
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I hope we all work to bring our agenda items sooner so they have time on that referral list where we and the public can see them.

1965
02:46:52.727 --> 02:47:00.802
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I will continue to encourage our administration to do the same so that we and the public have time to see their agenda items before they're placed on agendas.

1966
02:47:01.861 --> 02:47:17.986
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But again, using To use that as an excuse to not do your homework and look at what's coming and to suggest that we didn't have process because we used the process we created feels highly disingenuous, and I think that that needs to be called out.

1967
02:47:19.039 --> 02:47:19.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I vote aye.

1968
02:47:21.950 --> 02:47:24.718
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance is passed with 10 yes votes and 2 no votes.

1969
02:47:25.587 --> 02:47:26.424
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, councilors.

1970
02:47:26.472 --> 02:47:28.468
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our next 2 agenda items will come together.

1971
02:47:28.579 --> 02:47:30.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>However, they may take a significant amount of time.

1972
02:47:30.861 --> 02:47:37.594
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hate to do this because I know that we have guests here for those 2 agenda items, but we need to give our staff a short break.

1973
02:47:38.079 --> 02:47:44.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we are going to take a 10-minute recess now, and we will come back at 8:53.

1974
02:47:49.870 --> 02:47:50.525
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1975
03:02:32.139 --> 03:02:32.494
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1976
03:02:32.816 --> 03:02:35.940
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're gonna bring everybody back.

1977
03:02:36.101 --> 03:02:41.222
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope that brief recess gave everyone enough of a break to get what they needed.

1978
03:02:43.049 --> 03:02:46.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we have almost everyone back.

1979
03:02:46.753 --> 03:02:48.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll check in with our vice president.

1980
03:02:48.280 --> 03:02:55.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In the meantime, councilors, we are on Agenda item numbers 11 and 12.

1981
03:02:55.856 --> 03:03:00.574
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are going to hear these agenda items together.

1982
03:03:00.986 --> 03:03:03.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, can you please read the titles?

1983
03:03:04.409 --> 03:03:10.625
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 11, amend the City Employee Benefits Program for the plan offerings for FY 2025-26.

1984
03:03:10.801 --> 03:03:17.263
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 12, amend the Portland Police Association City Employee Benefits Program for FY 2025-26.

1985
03:03:19.731 --> 03:03:20.313
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1986
03:03:21.424 --> 03:03:34.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, because we discussed these agenda items extensively in executive committee, they did not go through one of our committees, so we do not have a committee staff summary.

1987
03:03:35.779 --> 03:03:42.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we are going to have a brief presentation, which we don't usually have in full council meetings.

1988
03:03:47.563 --> 03:03:57.376
<v Unidentified speaker>Madam President, if it's all right, I'll kick it off with just a couple of remarks and introductions, and we'll hear— I'm going to be very brief.

1989
03:03:57.487 --> 03:03:57.665
<v Loretta Smith>Sorry.

1990
03:03:58.418 --> 03:04:29.021
<v Unidentified speaker>The council knows that every year the city's Labor Management Benefits Committee, the LMBC, and the Portland Police Association Board reviews their employee benefits programs and provides recommendations for I think everyone involved in these processes recognizes the shared responsibility of ensuring employees and their covered dependents have access to healthcare plan options that meet their needs while protecting the long-term financial stability and solvency of these plans.

1991
03:04:29.757 --> 03:04:40.158
<v Unidentified speaker>Beginning last year in June, the Portland Police Association Board, LMBC, and city management have held collaborative conversations in preparation for this renewal.

1992
03:04:40.222 --> 03:04:40.447
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1993
03:04:42.079 --> 03:04:55.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Bureau of Human Resources and labor partners have analyzed many options, many choices about balancing budget impacts and changes to the healthcare plans in order to meet rising renewal rates.

1994
03:04:56.248 --> 03:05:07.994
<v Unidentified speaker>Before you today, item 11, the first ordinance would approve the fiscal year '25-'26 benefit plan document and adopt proposed changes for those employees covered under the labor management benefit plan.

1995
03:05:08.041 --> 03:05:08.186
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1996
03:05:08.329 --> 03:05:16.372
<v Unidentified speaker>Benefits Committee, LMBC, which includes non-represented city staff as well as all unions other than the Portland Police Association.

1997
03:05:16.997 --> 03:05:29.880
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 12, the second ordinance, would approve the same changes for fiscal, uh, '25-'26, uh, plan benefit document, uh, and adopt the proposed changes for the Portland Police Association.

1998
03:05:30.698 --> 03:05:41.400
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, the council, of course, will take up these ordinances separately, but we're presenting them together In an attempt to be more brief and cohesive.

1999
03:05:42.011 --> 03:05:50.268
<v Unidentified speaker>With us tonight is Ron Zito, Bureau of Human Resources Deputy Director, Michelle Taylor, City Benefits Manager, to walk us through these ordinances.

2000
03:05:50.684 --> 03:06:00.564
<v Unidentified speaker>Along with them, Erin Schmotz, who is here to represent Portland Police Bureau Board, and Rachel Whiteside representing as a co-chair of the LMBC.

2001
03:06:01.238 --> 03:06:06.861
<v Unidentified speaker>So Ron, I don't know who's going to kick off, Thank you, City Administrator Jordan.

2002
03:06:07.005 --> 03:06:08.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>Good evening, councilors.

2003
03:06:08.918 --> 03:06:14.012
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm going to immediately turn it over to our expert benefit manager, Michelle Taylor.

2004
03:06:14.862 --> 03:06:16.051
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, good evening, council.

2005
03:06:16.727 --> 03:06:17.611
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Michelle Taylor.

2006
03:06:17.674 --> 03:06:19.555
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the city's benefit manager.

2007
03:06:20.101 --> 03:06:21.514
<v Unidentified speaker>You may have to get closer.

2008
03:06:21.724 --> 03:06:22.431
<v Unidentified speaker>Scooch closer.

2009
03:06:22.736 --> 03:06:29.565
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, I'm here to talk to you about 2 ordinances, uh, which are being presented together, but you will vote on those separately.

2010
03:06:30.302 --> 03:06:44.608
<v Unidentified speaker>Both of these are being presented as emergency ordinances given the urgency to move changes forward so the benefit team can kick off our open enrollment on May 9th and allow folks to go online and make their elections for the upcoming year.

2011
03:06:46.003 --> 03:06:50.605
<v Unidentified speaker>If we move to slide 2, just briefly, here's our agenda.

2012
03:06:51.135 --> 03:07:06.530
<v Unidentified speaker>It consists of the background as to why we're here and the journey that's gotten us We'll then move into Ordinance 2025-159, which is related to the plan design changes for the Labor Management Benefit Committee.

2013
03:07:06.530 --> 03:07:10.049
<v Unidentified speaker>And throughout this presentation, we'll likely refer to it as LMBC.

2014
03:07:10.049 --> 03:07:21.829
<v Unidentified speaker>And then we'll move on to 2025-160, which are the plan design changes for the Portland Police Association represented within Portland Police Bureau, and we'll refer to them as PPA or PPA PPB.

2015
03:07:21.829 --> 03:07:21.889
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mayor.

2016
03:07:23.159 --> 03:07:29.887
<v Unidentified speaker>If we move to slide 4, we'll dive into a little bit of the background.

2017
03:07:31.042 --> 03:07:37.465
<v Unidentified speaker>So today we'll be talking about 2 specific groups, the LMBC and the PPA.

2018
03:07:38.011 --> 03:07:45.717
<v Unidentified speaker>LMBC is comprised of 22 voting members, and that is split evenly between labor-appointed and non-represented folks.

2019
03:07:46.295 --> 03:07:53.090
<v Unidentified speaker>The 2 co-chairs, Rachel And Leslie are here today to share more with you as we move into other portions of the presentation.

2020
03:07:53.844 --> 03:07:59.726
<v Unidentified speaker>And we have Aaron here as well, and his team make up the other group, and Aaron will be sharing more with you as well.

2021
03:08:00.915 --> 03:08:13.190
<v Unidentified speaker>So recommendations for both of these groups that receive an appropriate number of votes within the group get brought forth to council, who has the authority to make changes to our medical, dental, vision benefit plan design for our employees and their dependents.

2022
03:08:13.270 --> 03:08:14.506
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator Priya Dhanapal.

2023
03:08:15.322 --> 03:08:23.255
<v Unidentified speaker>BHR does not make changes on plan design unless administratively required, but we do get consulted and we provide guidance throughout the process.

2024
03:08:24.879 --> 03:08:35.019
<v Unidentified speaker>To give you some context as to how we got here, if we rewind to last year, we were facing 13% increases in our plans for LMBC and 18% for PPA.

2025
03:08:35.731 --> 03:08:43.870
<v Unidentified speaker>Both groups worked for months on recommendations for council, but ultimately we couldn't get to a place Where those recommendations met the budget constraints.

2026
03:08:45.103 --> 03:08:53.136
<v Unidentified speaker>Parties worked on ordinance amendments to bridge the gap between the recommended changes that were brought forth by these committees and the budgeted amount for the benefits.

2027
03:08:53.938 --> 03:09:05.175
<v Unidentified speaker>Council then decided, uh, on one-time funding that was valued at approximately $607,000 for PPA and $1.278 million for the LMBC group.

2028
03:09:05.881 --> 03:09:16.793
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, a $25 monthly surcharge, which is estimated at $1.8 million has been charged to employees covered under the LMBC group throughout this current fiscal year.

2029
03:09:18.078 --> 03:09:26.751
<v Unidentified speaker>The surcharge also required a letter of agreement signed by all of the unions impacted with impacted employees, and it expires at the end of this fiscal year.

2030
03:09:28.117 --> 03:09:41.730
<v Unidentified speaker>This temporary solution provided the LMBC and PPA groups another year and what was quoted last year as a longer runway to kind of get back to the table and really address the double-digit increases.

2031
03:09:42.981 --> 03:10:01.334
<v Unidentified speaker>They were asked to jump back in and then think about what could reduce the renewal increases that we were expecting for the 2025-26 fiscal year because we believed it was going to be enough— another rough year given the one-time funds and the expiration of that surcharge.

2032
03:10:02.120 --> 03:10:04.109
<v Unidentified speaker>Both groups immediately jumped into action.

2033
03:10:05.023 --> 03:10:12.486
<v Unidentified speaker>Before getting into the details of their work, I really just want to absolutely commend the committee members for their hard work.

2034
03:10:13.290 --> 03:10:26.097
<v Unidentified speaker>We had thoughtful conversations, values-based discussions, participation in various exercises with sticky notes all over the room, packaging together multiple options to present for council consideration.

2035
03:10:27.093 --> 03:10:33.462
<v Unidentified speaker>These committee members are some of the most passionate folks when it comes to employee benefits.

2036
03:10:34.217 --> 03:10:36.415
<v Unidentified speaker>They want to ensure that core services are covered.

2037
03:10:37.361 --> 03:10:44.790
<v Unidentified speaker>They're vested in protecting the health and well-being of the city's most important infrastructure, which is our employees and also their family members.

2038
03:10:45.929 --> 03:10:49.876
<v Unidentified speaker>I am proud of this work, and I hope that everybody is as well.

2039
03:10:50.277 --> 03:10:53.245
<v Unidentified speaker>I feel like these folks should be commended for their commitment to this work.

2040
03:10:54.048 --> 03:10:58.023
<v Unidentified speaker>We are in a much better place this year than we were in the past.

2041
03:10:59.559 --> 03:11:03.623
<v Unidentified speaker>We know that healthcare has changed, and this directly impacts employee benefit plans.

2042
03:11:04.331 --> 03:11:06.837
<v Unidentified speaker>We experienced a global pandemic which delayed care.

2043
03:11:07.609 --> 03:11:13.808
<v Unidentified speaker>We're seeing this care come back, and in some cases it's more expensive as conditions are discovered in later stages.

2044
03:11:14.713 --> 03:11:25.102
<v Unidentified speaker>Costs of services have increased due to labor shortages, inflationary factors, advances in technology, new extremely expensive medications hitting the market.

2045
03:11:25.702 --> 03:11:28.245
<v Unidentified speaker>Medical trend is at the highest we've seen in over 10 years.

2046
03:11:29.420 --> 03:11:35.509
<v Unidentified speaker>The renewals for this upcoming '25-'26 fiscal year aren't too different from what we saw last year.

2047
03:11:35.976 --> 03:11:41.430
<v Unidentified speaker>We're looking at 13.4% for the LMBC and 16% for PPA.

2048
03:11:43.439 --> 03:11:47.119
<v Unidentified speaker>Each of the committees convene monthly, sometimes more.

2049
03:11:47.819 --> 03:11:53.456
<v Unidentified speaker>Sometimes for upwards of 3 hours, sometimes before, after homework in between.

2050
03:11:54.547 --> 03:12:09.448
<v Unidentified speaker>They jumped into this challenging work of reviewing benefit coverage levels, trends, reasons for increased claims, and considered the impacts on our employees and their dependents during times of uncertainty across the nation.

2051
03:12:10.747 --> 03:12:12.353
<v Unidentified speaker>Putting packages together can take months.

2052
03:12:12.433 --> 03:12:12.578
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2053
03:12:13.252 --> 03:12:16.906
<v Unidentified speaker>They require coordinated efforts with our vendor partners.

2054
03:12:17.658 --> 03:12:24.453
<v Unidentified speaker>We need to ensure that benefits can be figured configured into their system, and that claims can be paid accordingly.

2055
03:12:24.967 --> 03:12:28.058
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's not just something we can do off the cuff.

2056
03:12:28.941 --> 03:12:35.415
<v Unidentified speaker>We also need to ensure that analysis is done so that we can be compliant with local, state, and federal rules.

2057
03:12:36.712 --> 03:12:38.138
<v Unidentified speaker>Throughout my time serving.

2058
03:12:38.813 --> 03:12:43.031
<v Unidentified speaker>The city, all 18 years within the benefit team in various roles.

2059
03:12:44.266 --> 03:12:54.262
<v Unidentified speaker>These committees, council guidance of past and current HR folks, they've made meaningful changes to our plans that align with the city's core values.

2060
03:12:54.871 --> 03:13:04.545
<v Unidentified speaker>For example, under former Mayor Sam Adams, it was around 2012, the city added gender-affirming care to our medical plans as a joint effort.

2061
03:13:05.668 --> 03:13:15.207
<v Unidentified speaker>Under former Mayor Ted Wheeler, copays for mental health visits were waived beginning in 2019 and remain at no cost on many of our medical plans.

2062
03:13:16.121 --> 03:13:17.004
<v Unidentified speaker>And that remains today.

2063
03:13:18.049 --> 03:13:24.359
<v Unidentified speaker>Shortly after, we expanded EAP benefits to further reduce critical access to services.

2064
03:13:25.498 --> 03:13:40.385
<v Unidentified speaker>In 2021, the committee and the city and council added fertility and family expanding resources And that was under the direction of former Commissioner Amanda Fritz, leading the effort prior to her departure from city service.

2065
03:13:41.539 --> 03:13:46.411
<v Unidentified speaker>These committees, council, and BHR continue to collaborate on meaningful changes.

2066
03:13:47.484 --> 03:13:52.100
<v Unidentified speaker>We want to ensure our employees and their families are supported throughout their healthcare journeys.

2067
03:13:53.156 --> 03:13:58.364
<v Unidentified speaker>In this nation's political climate, it's imperative that we continue protecting our access to care.

2068
03:13:59.103 --> 03:14:02.409
<v Unidentified speaker>And the city remains committed to our employees who serve this community.

2069
03:14:03.596 --> 03:14:14.029
<v Unidentified speaker>With that being said, we're going to jump into LMBC, and these slides will reference LMBC-specific changes, and they are captured under the first ordinance.

2070
03:14:15.152 --> 03:14:17.511
<v Unidentified speaker>I will go ahead and turn it over to Rachel if you're okay with that.

2071
03:14:17.879 --> 03:14:18.859
<v Unidentified speaker>Yep, thank you, Michelle.

2072
03:14:19.549 --> 03:14:21.138
<v Unidentified speaker>Again, my name is Rachel Whiteside.

2073
03:14:21.251 --> 03:14:28.088
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm union representative for PROTEC 17 members at the city, and I also co-chair the labor half of the LMBC.

2074
03:14:28.879 --> 03:14:54.695
<v Unidentified speaker>And just adding a little bit to the context that Michelle provided, there have been complaints in past years from committee members that sometimes we feel like we don't have enough levers to pull in order to make the cost savings that are necessary while also making sure that we are providing quality benefits benefits package to our employees.

2075
03:14:55.032 --> 03:14:58.471
<v Unidentified speaker>And this year we might have swung a little bit far in the opposite direction.

2076
03:14:58.745 --> 03:15:02.939
<v Unidentified speaker>The LMBC started with over 30 items to consider.

2077
03:15:03.743 --> 03:15:16.164
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of these were— had very small impact, and then some of them had extremely significant impact, such as, you know, dropping Providence from our network.

2078
03:15:16.244 --> 03:15:16.388
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2079
03:15:17.143 --> 03:16:08.018
<v Unidentified speaker>In order to help the committee really focus in on where we were in alignment and where the committee as a whole had the most interest and we felt like the options aligned with the values-based discussion that we worked with a facilitator to curate before we started studying options, I helped facilitate an interactive exercise, as Michelle mentioned, where yes, we put up all of the options up in a conference room and And everybody was walking around using reds and blues and purples, and it really helped us visually see where our values aligned and where things like what you see here on slide 6 made sense and we could move forward with those options and where things really did not make sense and we chose to not consider those.

2080
03:16:09.487 --> 03:16:15.040
<v Unidentified speaker>The longer period of time is spent on Those items in the middle, obviously.

2081
03:16:15.700 --> 03:16:29.868
<v Unidentified speaker>The other thing that was unique to this year was the direction from the council that preceded you to come up with multiple packages at different renewal rates, and this helped us fulfill that exercise.

2082
03:16:31.561 --> 03:16:39.808
<v Unidentified speaker>So, um, what you see here are the recommended changes that will not have a financial impact on savings.

2083
03:16:41.024 --> 03:16:43.948
<v Unidentified speaker>But where the committee had full alignment and agreement.

2084
03:16:44.337 --> 03:16:45.861
<v Unidentified speaker>And if we can move forward to slide 7.

2085
03:16:50.233 --> 03:16:59.753
<v Unidentified speaker>These are the additional changes that were included in all levels of the 8%, 10%, and 12% packages that the committee prepared.

2086
03:17:01.217 --> 03:17:04.134
<v Unidentified speaker>The one exception is the Garner.

2087
03:17:04.698 --> 03:17:21.216
<v Unidentified speaker>Garner is a new service that would be added— actually, all of these are new services that would be added on on top of our existing Moda healthcare plan and create steerage services which can help provide folks to the most cost-effective healthcare.

2088
03:17:21.489 --> 03:17:26.066
<v Unidentified speaker>But there will be a learning curve that is associated with these for our members.

2089
03:17:27.889 --> 03:17:28.634
<v Unidentified speaker>Slide 8, please.

2090
03:17:31.069 --> 03:17:36.827
<v Unidentified speaker>So this slide summarizes the culmination of the 3 packages that were presented.

2091
03:17:37.372 --> 03:17:41.037
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sorry, that were voted on by the Labor Management Benefits Committee.

2092
03:17:42.193 --> 03:17:50.099
<v Unidentified speaker>I do want to call your attention in terms of the 10% package and the 8% package.

2093
03:17:51.761 --> 03:17:55.052
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are the 2 with significant Kaiser changes.

2094
03:17:55.649 --> 03:17:59.381
<v Unidentified speaker>And these were really a challenge for the committee to land at.

2095
03:17:59.752 --> 03:18:17.601
<v Unidentified speaker>This represents a significant change in healthcare access for folks that have been on the Kaiser plan, which previously had no deductible and a very low out-of-pocket maximum, even at the family level.

2096
03:18:17.795 --> 03:18:47.011
<v Unidentified speaker>So in addition to the information that's on these slides, the deductible at the 10% package level is increased to $450 at the family level and $2,500 out-of-pocket maximum, plus new coinsurance that applies to emergency room visits, outpatient and inpatient surgeries, um, which those are all new things that our members on the Kaiser plan have not experienced.

2097
03:18:47.427 --> 03:18:53.260
<v Unidentified speaker>And when you move to the 8% renewal package, those numbers are further increased.

2098
03:18:53.371 --> 03:19:00.962
<v Unidentified speaker>So the family deductible is $750 And the out-of-pocket maximum is $6,000.

2099
03:19:01.943 --> 03:19:08.259
<v Unidentified speaker>And it also again includes a new coinsurance for inpatient and outpatient procedures as well as some other services.

2100
03:19:08.950 --> 03:19:14.604
<v Unidentified speaker>So these represent significant changes in practice for our members.

2101
03:19:15.585 --> 03:19:25.301
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, at the 8% level, you see a doubling of the deductible from $250 to $500.

2102
03:19:25.355 --> 03:19:25.463
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2103
03:19:25.610 --> 03:19:33.043
<v Unidentified speaker>$500 And an increase in the out-of-pocket maximum by $250 as well.

2104
03:19:34.453 --> 03:19:41.952
<v Unidentified speaker>And there is the potential for members to regain some of that through the Garner Health reimbursement incentives.

2105
03:19:42.065 --> 03:19:48.555
<v Unidentified speaker>But this is a new program to the city and a new program to all of our members that none of us are experienced with.

2106
03:19:48.954 --> 03:19:53.879
<v Unidentified speaker>And there's a significant amount of concern that there's going to be a learning curve associated with that.

2107
03:19:55.203 --> 03:20:05.765
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that's why you see it added into all of our packages, but at a level where it feels more approachable for members.

2108
03:20:08.522 --> 03:20:12.746
<v Unidentified speaker>Michelle, or is Leslie going to talk about the executive branch recommendation?

2109
03:20:14.129 --> 03:20:15.286
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I would like to.

2110
03:20:15.847 --> 03:20:29.781
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe Leslie is online if she would like to speak to the management Well, I'm here, and I just—.

2111
03:20:29.895 --> 03:20:32.915
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm gonna let the folks that are in the room cover the slides.

2112
03:20:32.963 --> 03:20:39.102
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to say that this has been a great process for both the management and the labor side.

2113
03:20:39.166 --> 03:20:43.978
<v Unidentified speaker>We really worked hard to try to get to a decision.

2114
03:20:44.689 --> 03:20:56.522
<v Unidentified speaker>We were not able to get to a recommendation, but I think that the packages that were put together that everybody were comfortable with are what you're seeing.

2115
03:20:57.036 --> 03:21:04.729
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I won't take up any more time and let folks finish presenting the slides because my eyes are tired and it's hard to read on the screen.

2116
03:21:04.843 --> 03:21:07.172
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you, Michelle, for giving me the opportunity.

2117
03:21:08.377 --> 03:21:09.066
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Leslie.

2118
03:21:12.200 --> 03:21:13.814
<v Unidentified speaker>Is it okay to jump in?

2119
03:21:14.411 --> 03:21:14.654
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All right.

2120
03:21:14.815 --> 03:21:22.913
<v Unidentified speaker>So jumping into the next slide, going into this one, I want to reiterate and kind of go back to Rachel and Leslie.

2121
03:21:22.977 --> 03:21:28.882
<v Unidentified speaker>These were incredibly hard conversations that were had between labor and management.

2122
03:21:30.416 --> 03:21:35.995
<v Unidentified speaker>What is coming in front of you today is not something that is supported by the committee.

2123
03:21:36.272 --> 03:21:37.635
<v Unidentified speaker>It is not supported by labor.

2124
03:21:38.772 --> 03:21:41.736
<v Unidentified speaker>What it is is the executive branch recommendation.

2125
03:21:43.370 --> 03:21:55.326
<v Unidentified speaker>While the committee was able to talk about things that build up the packages, we were not able to get enough votes to actually bring forth a single recommendation to this committee.

2126
03:21:55.810 --> 03:21:58.748
<v Unidentified speaker>So we are bringing forth the executive branch recommendation.

2127
03:22:00.486 --> 03:22:01.590
<v Unidentified speaker>That's on your slide here.

2128
03:22:03.021 --> 03:22:16.558
<v Unidentified speaker>It Further changes the CityCorps plan deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, which Rachel talked a little bit about on the previous slide, increases, pretty significant increases to Kaiser.

2129
03:22:17.490 --> 03:22:24.380
<v Unidentified speaker>That brought us to about a 7.3% overall renewal, and 8% is budgeted.

2130
03:22:24.992 --> 03:22:30.677
<v Unidentified speaker>So the additional recommendation is to round up essentially from the 7.3 to the 8%.

2131
03:22:30.742 --> 03:22:31.480
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2132
03:22:31.978 --> 03:22:49.424
<v Unidentified speaker>So it aligns with budget and adds $670,000 into the reserves for our self-funded plan because it currently is underfunded and we want to develop a long-term solution to start bringing that back up to a level that we need.

2133
03:22:50.050 --> 03:22:55.362
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's what you're seeing today, and part of the ordinance is the executive branch recommendation.

2134
03:22:56.022 --> 03:22:56.727
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2135
03:23:00.557 --> 03:23:02.941
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, and here on this slide you'll see the costs.

2136
03:23:03.875 --> 03:23:06.306
<v Unidentified speaker>It is the various options that were presented.

2137
03:23:06.829 --> 03:23:11.074
<v Unidentified speaker>The far left column is the 8%, which is budgeted for '25-'26.

2138
03:23:11.841 --> 03:23:18.211
<v Unidentified speaker>Then you'll see the 10%, which leaves a gap of about $2.6, almost $2.7 million.

2139
03:23:19.064 --> 03:23:22.278
<v Unidentified speaker>And then on the far right is the difference between the 8% and the 10%.

2140
03:23:22.711 --> 03:23:23.032
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2141
03:23:23.653 --> 03:23:29.781
<v Unidentified speaker>8% And the 11.6%, which would remove some of the other recommendations.

2142
03:23:29.844 --> 03:23:34.818
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's— well, it would change the executive branch recommendation.

2143
03:23:35.191 --> 03:23:40.454
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to make sure I choose my wording correctly— to about $4.6 million over budget.

2144
03:23:43.875 --> 03:23:50.113
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, we're going to jump into PPA, and I will turn it over to Aaron if that's okay with you.

2145
03:23:50.164 --> 03:23:50.246
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

2146
03:23:50.792 --> 03:23:51.066
<v Loretta Smith>Sure.

2147
03:23:51.933 --> 03:23:58.629
<v Unidentified speaker>So just as an introduction, again, as Michelle has said, and I also want to note Michelle has been incredible in this process.

2148
03:23:58.725 --> 03:23:59.977
<v Unidentified speaker>This is not an easy job.

2149
03:24:01.309 --> 03:24:03.204
<v Unidentified speaker>These are all pretty emotional conversations.

2150
03:24:03.862 --> 03:24:08.888
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a husband of a wife whose life was saved by genetic testing and more surgeries than I care to count.

2151
03:24:09.643 --> 03:24:16.659
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the father to a daughter who's had more pokes and prods, and we are a maximum family user of our health benefits.

2152
03:24:16.724 --> 03:24:25.251
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the reality is, when we're, when we're talking about who the maximum expenditures are, they're the families who need the most.

2153
03:24:25.861 --> 03:24:32.909
<v Unidentified speaker>And so very often we're having conversations with a lot of people who don't use their medical benefits a ton, and this seems less scary.

2154
03:24:33.664 --> 03:24:44.701
<v Unidentified speaker>But as someone with a lot of experience, again, we're looking to balance— and it sounds awful— but we're looking to balance the budget on the backs of people who need these services the most.

2155
03:24:44.750 --> 03:24:49.715
<v Unidentified speaker>And so, you know, for me, coming— the PPA, our health benefits are what they are.

2156
03:24:50.440 --> 03:24:57.604
<v Unidentified speaker>25 Years ago, we had an arbitration in our contract, and they moved some of our benefits into our contract, and so that's why we have 2 groups.

2157
03:24:59.353 --> 03:25:04.381
<v Unidentified speaker>Being on our board, I only ever saw these things once a year, and this was not an interesting conversation for a long time.

2158
03:25:04.445 --> 03:25:08.028
<v Unidentified speaker>Our board would look at it, we'd vote on a few things that weren't that interesting, Interesting, and on we would go.

2159
03:25:09.075 --> 03:25:24.786
<v Unidentified speaker>The last couple years have been just very, very difficult, and also working with my other labor partners, and you know we have dispatch who is within the LMBC now, and just seeing how complicated this is, you know we had a really strong motivation.

2160
03:25:25.593 --> 03:25:32.407
<v Unidentified speaker>The executive board for the PPA in looking for ways to balance this so that you know things moving forward were aligning to.

2161
03:25:32.540 --> 03:25:32.860
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

2162
03:25:32.860 --> 03:25:41.270
<v Unidentified speaker>We wanted to make sure that we were keeping our labor partners together if we could, that we were being in alignment with our labor partners, but also providing services that nod to the future.

2163
03:25:41.620 --> 03:25:48.559
<v Unidentified speaker>We had a lot of conversations with the last council, former commissioner, now Councilor Ryan, is one of the ones who was there, but these were not easy conversations.

2164
03:25:50.180 --> 03:25:56.899
<v Unidentified speaker>If you want to— so most of these things are the same as far as the introductory changes.

2165
03:25:57.219 --> 03:26:06.900
<v Unidentified speaker>Kind of ironically, We went through a separate process, but the things that the PPA executive board for the PPA police side approved just ended up being the exact same things, basically.

2166
03:26:07.157 --> 03:26:10.191
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think a lot of that has to do with Aon working for both groups.

2167
03:26:11.188 --> 03:26:17.305
<v Unidentified speaker>Garner, I do want to note, on the Moda side, the thing that's difficult is choose your own adventure.

2168
03:26:17.352 --> 03:26:21.271
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a lot of services that are available, but nobody knows what doctor to go to.

2169
03:26:21.930 --> 03:26:23.423
<v Unidentified speaker>My wife's doctor just moved out of state.

2170
03:26:24.076 --> 03:26:27.897
<v Unidentified speaker>And literally, we were like looking at websites, looking at which doctor looked nice.

2171
03:26:28.450 --> 03:26:29.897
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not very effective.

2172
03:26:30.540 --> 03:26:32.243
<v Unidentified speaker>Garner provides a potential help there.

2173
03:26:32.323 --> 03:26:38.734
<v Unidentified speaker>The concern being, the way that it's sold is it is basically, it is they're the best providers.

2174
03:26:38.845 --> 03:26:41.255
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a little bit of a trust balance there of what does that mean?

2175
03:26:41.818 --> 03:26:45.370
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, what does it mean when a doctor is a preferred provider?

2176
03:26:45.418 --> 03:26:46.961
<v Unidentified speaker>Does it mean they're providing better service?

2177
03:26:47.443 --> 03:26:48.745
<v Unidentified speaker>Does it mean they're just cheaper?

2178
03:26:48.793 --> 03:26:49.034
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't know.

2179
03:26:49.129 --> 03:26:53.545
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't, you know, they say that they're the better providers, that they get you into the right things.

2180
03:26:54.700 --> 03:27:02.665
<v Unidentified speaker>The further down the road garner options, if people choose to use these services well, could be good, but we just don't know yet.

2181
03:27:02.825 --> 03:27:07.899
<v Unidentified speaker>So to Rachel's point, we view this as kind of a longitudinal move.

2182
03:27:08.092 --> 03:27:09.441
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's start with the lower level.

2183
03:27:09.537 --> 03:27:10.612
<v Sameer Kanal>Let's see how people like it.

2184
03:27:10.661 --> 03:27:11.576
<v Sameer Kanal>Let's see how it works.

2185
03:27:11.640 --> 03:27:16.104
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's make sure we're not getting doctors who are refusing to do And that's why they're preferred.

2186
03:27:16.602 --> 03:27:22.688
<v Unidentified speaker>And let's not make people lose their doctors this first year, because you can under this initial Garner plan.

2187
03:27:23.281 --> 03:27:26.701
<v Unidentified speaker>There's some benefits, but you don't have to use those doctors and still get the savings.

2188
03:27:27.360 --> 03:27:39.193
<v Unidentified speaker>And so Garner, Hinge, all the other things you see on the screen here, these are the things that we all agreed to and we thought looked logical.

2189
03:27:39.724 --> 03:27:46.441
<v Unidentified speaker>As it As it relates to Kaiser, Kaiser is a plan for many families who are introductory.

2190
03:27:46.954 --> 03:27:54.558
<v Unidentified speaker>Kind of the running joke that I like, or that I hear from people, is it's a good place to be born and it's a good place to die because they have really good elder care services.

2191
03:27:55.218 --> 03:27:56.666
<v Unidentified speaker>In the middle, it's a little bit debatable.

2192
03:27:56.908 --> 03:28:01.466
<v Unidentified speaker>And so a lot of our newer members use Kaiser because it is cheaper.

2193
03:28:01.594 --> 03:28:02.986
<v Unidentified speaker>Both my kids were born there.

2194
03:28:03.957 --> 03:28:10.768
<v Unidentified speaker>The challenge becomes None of our high-level users are really on the Moda plan, which makes it a little bit more expensive.

2195
03:28:12.459 --> 03:28:13.559
<v Unidentified speaker>We were looking for equity.

2196
03:28:14.093 --> 03:28:22.195
<v Unidentified speaker>We were looking for ways to, again, not destroy Kaiser, but also allow for a plan that would balance.

2197
03:28:22.662 --> 03:28:31.194
<v Unidentified speaker>And so these changes to Kaiser aligned our Kaiser plan with the Moda plan as far as the member impact for out-of-pocket costs.

2198
03:28:31.548 --> 03:28:34.865
<v Unidentified speaker>For our members, and so for us, our board was comfortable with those changes.

2199
03:28:36.829 --> 03:28:42.967
<v Unidentified speaker>For the PPA, last year when we were talking, a lot of the changes that Aon recommended were on to Moda.

2200
03:28:43.597 --> 03:28:48.432
<v Unidentified speaker>We're experiencing significant shortage of providers in Portland, just across the board.

2201
03:28:49.588 --> 03:28:56.805
<v Unidentified speaker>This year, Aon did not push forward anything as far as those changes because they would—they were concerned that it would lead to.

2202
03:28:56.899 --> 03:29:05.602
<v Unidentified speaker>Members not being able to get into the doctor, basically, which would lead to wellness issues, which would lead to people not getting diagnosed early and potentially leading to people being more sick.

2203
03:29:06.308 --> 03:29:12.153
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the changes that were proposed only got us to 11.9%.

2204
03:29:12.586 --> 03:29:24.659
<v Unidentified speaker>That was as far as we could go without eviscerating Kaiser, and there was nothing in MOTU that was provided that would do anything that frankly wouldn't require us That's correct.

2205
03:29:26.664 --> 03:29:34.239
<v Unidentified speaker>So to be super clear, what the board voted for and approved is an 11.9% change.

2206
03:29:34.369 --> 03:29:35.584
<v Unidentified speaker>We got about just over halfway.

2207
03:29:37.547 --> 03:29:46.611
<v Unidentified speaker>It changes our deductibles for Kaiser from what is currently $1,000— I'm sorry, going back a slide on my little phone here.

2208
03:29:46.661 --> 03:29:47.846
<v Unidentified speaker>It currently is $1,000 for a family of 4.

2209
03:29:47.959 --> 03:29:48.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

2210
03:29:48.500 --> 03:29:48.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

2211
03:29:48.500 --> 03:29:54.250
<v Unidentified speaker>So the current max is $600 for an individual and $1,200 for a family for out-of-pocket max, switching to $1,000 and $2,500.

2212
03:29:55.399 --> 03:30:00.739
<v Unidentified speaker>This is in the actual ordinance, paragraph 3.

2213
03:30:00.739 --> 03:30:03.639
<v Unidentified speaker>We agree to those.

2214
03:30:03.639 --> 03:30:10.329
<v Unidentified speaker>What we did not agree to is paragraph 4, which in our opinion is more than a bridge, it's a mountain too far.

2215
03:30:11.719 --> 03:30:13.790
<v Unidentified speaker>Most importantly, the out-of-pocket max would Yeah.

2216
03:30:13.790 --> 03:30:20.670
<v Unidentified speaker>If we were to switch to $3,000 for an individual and $9,000 for a family, it's a $7,000 a month, or $7,000 a year pay cut.

2217
03:30:20.950 --> 03:30:29.209
<v Unidentified speaker>And so, again, totally understand the financial picture we're in.

2218
03:30:30.270 --> 03:30:39.823
<v Unidentified speaker>Stand in alignment with the LMBC from the standpoint that we did look and effectively accidentally landed in the same spot, which for them was the 10%.

2219
03:30:41.060 --> 03:30:46.674
<v Unidentified speaker>That is as far as we are able to go in a way that still provides quality healthcare.

2220
03:30:48.799 --> 03:30:53.522
<v Unidentified speaker>Definitely support our LMBC friends in landing in that same spot.

2221
03:30:54.235 --> 03:30:55.173
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thanks, Aaron.

2222
03:30:55.529 --> 03:31:07.210
<v Unidentified speaker>I was just going to provide a little bit of additional clarity that the 10% package recommended from the LMBC does align with what the PPA has Board has voted for.

2223
03:31:08.306 --> 03:31:17.823
<v Unidentified speaker>The 10% package is also supported by the labor side and several members on the non-labor side as well.

2224
03:31:18.064 --> 03:31:28.650
<v Unidentified speaker>So while we didn't get to— we have a 75% threshold in order to move something forward to the council, it did receive more than 50% of the votes.

2225
03:31:31.822 --> 03:31:32.593
<v Unidentified speaker>Did I cover everything?

2226
03:31:33.202 --> 03:31:34.102
<v Unidentified speaker>I think so.

2227
03:31:34.487 --> 03:31:34.888
<v Keelan McClymont>All right.

2228
03:31:35.418 --> 03:31:36.060
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you.

2229
03:31:37.184 --> 03:31:56.823
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so moving on to the next slide, uh, similar to what we did with the Labor Management Benefit Committee, is that we are showing you what the executive branch recommendation is to bridge the gap between the 11.9% that the PPA board voted, um, versus the 8% that is budgeted for the upcoming year.

2230
03:31:57.597 --> 03:32:09.626
<v Unidentified speaker>To reiterate what Erin shared, you'll see the increase in the deductibles, the out-of-pocket maximums, and also the day-to-day services that are provided by Kaiser to our folks.

2231
03:32:13.516 --> 03:32:30.246
<v Unidentified speaker>On, I believe, our final slide here, you will see the difference in the 8% that was budgeted for fiscal year '25-'26 And the 11.9% that the PPA board is recommending, the difference between that is $638,000.

2232
03:32:33.479 --> 03:32:34.595
<v Unidentified speaker>So with that being said—.

2233
03:32:36.293 --> 03:32:39.012
<v Eric Zimmerman>Maybe just one order of clarification, councilors.

2234
03:32:39.449 --> 03:32:56.909
<v Eric Zimmerman>Before we came up, Erin was kind enough to point out that for item 12.160, just full transparency as you consider these items before you, The out-of-pocket max for the family for Kaiser, $9,000, was not referenced on that ordinance.

2235
03:32:56.958 --> 03:33:02.064
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just wanted to be clear so you saw that fully and you could consider it.

2236
03:33:02.256 --> 03:33:14.924
<v Unidentified speaker>If I can, I also would be kind enough to point out that the ordinance as it relates to the LMBC says that there were recommendations that came from the LMBC, and that is, as a term of legal art, is incorrect.

2237
03:33:15.461 --> 03:33:19.136
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, they did not recommend, uh, what is recommended.

2238
03:33:21.118 --> 03:33:27.538
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, with that being said, thank you so much for your time this evening.

2239
03:33:28.120 --> 03:33:34.282
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you to Rachel and to Aaron, to Leslie, to all of the committee members, to Ron, the support of BHR.

2240
03:33:34.814 --> 03:33:38.388
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, we'll open it up to any questions and discussions you might all have.

2241
03:33:39.162 --> 03:33:39.435
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2242
03:33:39.629 --> 03:33:39.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2243
03:33:40.072 --> 03:33:46.415
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, we do have people signed up for Testimony on at least one of these issues, but I see some folks in the queue.

2244
03:33:47.087 --> 03:33:51.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We often start with clarifying questions before moving to public testimony.

2245
03:33:51.275 --> 03:33:56.729
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also know that there are some folks who are going to at some point propose amendments.

2246
03:33:56.875 --> 03:34:05.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, Councilor Smith, do you have questions for this point in our discussion while we have our guests up here before we move to public comment?

2247
03:34:06.100 --> 03:34:08.248
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, um, a couple things.

2248
03:34:08.620 --> 03:34:08.733
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

2249
03:34:08.960 --> 03:34:21.988
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I thought that I was looking at the Kaiser going from $3,000 to $9,000, that, that was egregious, particularly for Kaiser, uh, members.

2250
03:34:23.136 --> 03:34:30.976
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, I do want to, um, to move to amend the text of the ordinance for this, and I don't know where—.

2251
03:34:31.154 --> 03:34:32.495
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 11 or item 12?

2252
03:34:32.689 --> 03:34:33.449
<v Loretta Smith>Item 11.

2253
03:34:33.805 --> 03:34:42.841
<v Loretta Smith>I'd like to move to amend the of the ordinance to budget for a 10% increase for employees' health insurance rather than the 8% increase.

2254
03:34:43.595 --> 03:34:52.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think what we should do, because we do have public testimony coming, is let folks know that that motion has been made but not second and discuss until we hear from the public.

2255
03:34:52.897 --> 03:34:53.412
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, perfect.

2256
03:34:53.459 --> 03:34:54.969
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Does that feel comfortable to you, Councilor?

2257
03:34:55.243 --> 03:34:55.484
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

2258
03:34:56.769 --> 03:34:58.520
<v Unidentified speaker>Actually, point of order.

2259
03:34:58.600 --> 03:35:06.648
<v Unidentified speaker>I think if it's seconded, then the public will know when they're testifying that that this will be part of the package now that we'll be discussing.

2260
03:35:07.085 --> 03:35:08.673
<v Unidentified speaker>If it's not seconded, they wouldn't know that.

2261
03:35:09.739 --> 03:35:14.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, are you comfortable with us receiving a second but pausing our debate until we hear from the public?

2262
03:35:14.852 --> 03:35:15.061
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

2263
03:35:16.711 --> 03:35:18.750
<v Unidentified speaker>I second it.

2264
03:35:19.558 --> 03:35:19.881
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2265
03:35:20.835 --> 03:35:22.888
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, anything else?

2266
03:35:24.166 --> 03:35:31.875
<v Loretta Smith>Well, for me, city employees are our book of business and they're the most valuable asset in city government.

2267
03:35:32.944 --> 03:35:42.120
<v Loretta Smith>And ensuring they have access to quality and affordable healthcare is a priority for retaining their excellence while they're here.

2268
03:35:42.652 --> 03:35:53.806
<v Loretta Smith>The involvement of the LMBC in this process is so vital, and I appreciate you all's work, and we should acknowledge their work in finding solutions to these challenges and cost increases.

2269
03:35:54.787 --> 03:36:10.676
<v Loretta Smith>I believe this emergency ordinance is an example of LMBC's effort to cooperatively strike a balance between managing rising healthcare costs responsibly and also providing comprehensive benefits that meet the needs of our diverse workforce.

2270
03:36:11.591 --> 03:36:14.926
<v Loretta Smith>But I believe we should follow the LMBC's recommendation.

2271
03:36:15.760 --> 03:36:38.138
<v Loretta Smith>And I was told as well that this emergency ordinance as currently draft— drafted falsely claims that the LMBC recommended the 8% package, when in fact the 10% package, while not receiving enough support to recommend to council, did get the most support from the LMBC.

2272
03:36:39.010 --> 03:36:45.394
<v Loretta Smith>For this and many other reasons, I believe the 10% package is the one the council should approve.

2273
03:36:47.266 --> 03:36:48.126
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2274
03:36:48.385 --> 03:36:51.609
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, are you in the queue for this point in our conversation?

2275
03:36:53.145 --> 03:36:53.787
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe so.

2276
03:36:53.947 --> 03:37:03.268
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not speaking to the amendment, but clarifying questions or other things that we need to get cleared up or on the record before we hear from our public testimony.

2277
03:37:03.413 --> 03:37:05.466
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, I have a question and then a comment.

2278
03:37:05.577 --> 03:37:16.615
<v Sameer Kanal>My question, Michelle, the— you mentioned that copays for mental health visits were waived in 2019 and that for most but not all, that is retained.

2279
03:37:16.888 --> 03:37:25.579
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a slide that that shows on the PPA side the creation of, or perhaps change to, primary and specialty care.

2280
03:37:26.833 --> 03:37:30.720
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to if mental health care is included in either of those lines?

2281
03:37:31.347 --> 03:37:35.011
<v Sameer Kanal>Effectively, would there now be a copay for mental health care for PPA members?

2282
03:37:35.460 --> 03:37:40.168
<v Unidentified speaker>So the copays for mental health were not waived under the PPA plan.

2283
03:37:41.228 --> 03:37:44.009
<v Unidentified speaker>That was an LMBC change that was moved forward.

2284
03:37:44.090 --> 03:37:56.039
<v Unidentified speaker>What we see on the PPA and a lot of times on the PFFA side and PPCOA and other public safety folks, we're proposing increases to the employee assistance plan.

2285
03:37:56.632 --> 03:37:59.487
<v Unidentified speaker>The employee assistance plan is outside of the medical plan.

2286
03:37:59.680 --> 03:38:08.613
<v Unidentified speaker>It provides— what we're recommending is 13 confidential counseling visits at no cost for our members and their eligible dependents.

2287
03:38:09.545 --> 03:38:14.436
<v Unidentified speaker>But the copays under the Kaiser proposed option It would change?

2288
03:38:15.879 --> 03:38:16.011
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

2289
03:38:16.060 --> 03:38:17.165
<v Sameer Kanal>From what to what?

2290
03:38:17.872 --> 03:38:19.191
<v Unidentified speaker>I have that right here.

2291
03:38:24.079 --> 03:38:29.722
<v Unidentified speaker>So currently primary care under the PPA Kaiser plan is currently at $10.

2292
03:38:30.518 --> 03:38:31.863
<v Unidentified speaker>It would go to $15.

2293
03:38:32.860 --> 03:38:35.460
<v Unidentified speaker>Specialty care would go from $20 to $25.

2294
03:38:35.884 --> 03:38:37.737
<v Sameer Kanal>And mental health is in the $20 to $25 range?

2295
03:38:40.926 --> 03:38:41.592
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, thank you.

2296
03:38:41.754 --> 03:38:42.565
<v Sameer Kanal>That's my question.

2297
03:38:42.709 --> 03:38:54.440
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I would like to also propose, and I'm comfortable waiting until after the testimony, an amendment to, um, I'm gonna make sure I have the ordinance number correctly, 2025-160.

2298
03:38:55.264 --> 03:39:00.716
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, this is the restoration of the 11.9% option that was agreed to by PPA.

2299
03:39:02.397 --> 03:39:04.337
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a second to this amendment?

2300
03:39:04.403 --> 03:39:04.500
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

2301
03:39:05.185 --> 03:39:06.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2302
03:39:08.432 --> 03:39:17.040
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, are you in the queue not to speak to any amendments but for clarifying questions or other things that need to be put on the table before we hear public testimony?

2303
03:39:17.701 --> 03:39:34.630
<v Steve Novick>Yes, I just want to address an issue that was raised— ask a question about an issue raised by Mr. Schmautz and Councilor Smith, which is that the whereas— that the language currently says the LMBC recommends the following plan design changes It's required to reduce the renewal rate to 8%.

2304
03:39:36.230 --> 03:39:39.978
<v Steve Novick>And it's been stated that the LMBC didn't actually recommend this.

2305
03:39:40.189 --> 03:39:46.889
<v Steve Novick>I wonder if— so actually, Michelle, can you explain what that language refers to and what it means?

2306
03:39:47.572 --> 03:39:49.386
<v Unidentified speaker>Frankly, it was poor word choice.

2307
03:39:50.787 --> 03:39:55.602
<v Unidentified speaker>It was not intended to misconstrue that there was an LMBC recommendation.

2308
03:39:56.183 --> 03:40:03.614
<v Unidentified speaker>When we originally had conversations There was opportunities to bring forth 8%, 10%, and 12%.

2309
03:40:05.170 --> 03:40:09.847
<v Unidentified speaker>We thought we were going to be able to bring forth 3 options and make that decision.

2310
03:40:10.365 --> 03:40:15.657
<v Unidentified speaker>And so when we had originally started drafting the language, that's what we were intending to do.

2311
03:40:15.818 --> 03:40:18.807
<v Unidentified speaker>And as we got through, we didn't edit it correctly.

2312
03:40:19.031 --> 03:40:20.380
<v Unidentified speaker>I didn't edit it correctly.

2313
03:40:20.959 --> 03:40:21.313
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2314
03:40:21.377 --> 03:40:21.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

2315
03:40:22.245 --> 03:40:23.611
<v Steve Novick>Thank you for that candid explanation.

2316
03:40:23.674 --> 03:40:24.032
<v Steve Novick>We've all been there.

2317
03:40:24.443 --> 03:40:28.826
<v Unidentified speaker>I truly apologize for any of the pain that this has caused.

2318
03:40:29.038 --> 03:40:32.224
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I don't want it to discredit the hard work that these folks have done.

2319
03:40:36.888 --> 03:40:37.897
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos.

2320
03:40:41.497 --> 03:40:42.524
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I'll wait until after.

2321
03:40:45.088 --> 03:40:48.933
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I believe that's everybody in the queue.

2322
03:40:49.726 --> 03:40:52.893
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, Keelan, could we please move to public testimony?

2323
03:40:57.510 --> 03:40:59.407
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Isaac McClanahan.

2324
03:41:04.876 --> 03:41:12.820
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't mind me doing it, but somebody needs to do it.

2325
03:41:13.680 --> 03:41:14.617
<v Unidentified speaker>Good evening.

2326
03:41:14.762 --> 03:41:14.890
<v Unidentified speaker>Ready?

2327
03:41:15.101 --> 03:41:15.554
<v Eric Zimmerman>All right.

2328
03:41:15.715 --> 03:41:16.556
<v Eric Zimmerman>Good evening, Council.

2329
03:41:17.088 --> 03:41:19.930
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, uh, Madam President, uh, my name is Isaac My name is Eric Zimmerman.

2330
03:41:19.930 --> 03:41:28.209
<v Eric Zimmerman>My name is Michael McClennan, and I'm the president of the Portland Firefighters Association, also resident of Roseway neighborhood, District 3.

2331
03:41:28.209 --> 03:41:35.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm here to— first of all, I would appreciate the floated amendments prior to the public testimony.

2332
03:41:35.750 --> 03:41:36.969
<v Eric Zimmerman>That makes my job a little easier.

2333
03:41:36.969 --> 03:41:40.549
<v Eric Zimmerman>I definitely want to support both amendments openly.

2334
03:41:40.549 --> 03:41:46.590
<v Eric Zimmerman>I was struck because when we started this council meeting several hours ago now, we started by talking about telecommunications.

2335
03:41:46.610 --> 03:41:46.737
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2336
03:41:46.787 --> 03:41:49.588
<v Eric Zimmerman>We've heard a lot about our first responders, our firefighters, and how wonderful they are, the great work they do.

2337
03:41:50.103 --> 03:41:53.663
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we all— and I share every one of your guys' comments that you made about them.

2338
03:41:53.727 --> 03:41:56.352
<v Eric Zimmerman>They are most deserving of all of those.

2339
03:41:56.852 --> 03:41:59.897
<v Eric Zimmerman>They're also deserving of quality healthcare benefits.

2340
03:42:00.414 --> 03:42:16.485
<v Eric Zimmerman>And even though this package, this 10% package, is an increase to what was currently floated in this resolution, I want to remind everybody that it's a decrease in their healthcare It's an increase to their costs and it's a decrease to their healthcare benefits.

2341
03:42:16.983 --> 03:42:19.649
<v Eric Zimmerman>All of these packages will be those versions of that.

2342
03:42:20.051 --> 03:42:26.481
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, you know, it's my— in my mind, and I spoke about this at the LMBC, I should have mentioned that I'm also a member of the LMBC.

2343
03:42:28.354 --> 03:42:36.637
<v Eric Zimmerman>One of the things people choose when they become a public employee is they know these jobs are not necessarily the most lucrative.

2344
03:42:36.829 --> 03:42:37.831
<v Eric Zimmerman>They're looking for something stable.

2345
03:42:37.879 --> 03:42:38.009
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2346
03:42:38.552 --> 03:42:41.087
<v Eric Zimmerman>And they're looking for a job that has quality benefits.

2347
03:42:41.584 --> 03:42:43.173
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's what draws people to these jobs.

2348
03:42:43.911 --> 03:42:49.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>One of the things that draws people to these jobs is that stability, but also the benefit packages.

2349
03:42:49.766 --> 03:42:55.221
<v Eric Zimmerman>And gutting these benefit packages has been proposed by the lowest level option here.

2350
03:42:55.398 --> 03:43:00.180
<v Eric Zimmerman>The 8% is really taking a sledgehammer approach to making decisions.

2351
03:43:00.355 --> 03:43:09.524
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I appreciate the time and I fully support I support these, both these amendments, and I really appreciate all the time and dedication you guys have given to this issue.

2352
03:43:10.486 --> 03:43:12.572
<v Eric Zimmerman>And with that, I yield.

2353
03:43:14.770 --> 03:43:17.179
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Keelan.

2354
03:43:17.614 --> 03:43:19.135
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Mark Henkel.

2355
03:43:29.913 --> 03:43:30.778
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2356
03:43:30.858 --> 03:43:32.653
<v Unidentified speaker>For those of you who don't know me, my name is Mark Hinkle.

2357
03:43:33.021 --> 03:43:37.700
<v Unidentified speaker>I have been employed from the City of Portland on January 1st, 1999.

2358
03:43:38.084 --> 03:43:50.247
<v Unidentified speaker>In May of 2021, I went from being a city employee to being a business rep for IBW Local 48, and now I'm the current president of the District Council of Trade Unions, which recently ratified a contract.

2359
03:43:50.344 --> 03:43:51.337
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much for that.

2360
03:43:52.652 --> 03:43:57.576
<v Unidentified speaker>I do want to echo— I had a whole thing written, But some things have changed, so I'm going to kind of go with my gut here.

2361
03:43:57.706 --> 03:44:00.659
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to echo partly what Isaac said, right?

2362
03:44:00.789 --> 03:44:02.281
<v Unidentified speaker>It's coming here as a city employee.

2363
03:44:02.361 --> 03:44:06.006
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are the things that were important to me as I was a family, you know, I had a family of five kids.

2364
03:44:06.568 --> 03:44:09.185
<v Unidentified speaker>So you know stability, health insurance.

2365
03:44:09.266 --> 03:44:11.306
<v Unidentified speaker>Kids do the dumbest of things, right?

2366
03:44:11.370 --> 03:44:12.942
<v Unidentified speaker>We all know that those that have children.

2367
03:44:13.441 --> 03:44:14.693
<v Unidentified speaker>So those are important things, right?

2368
03:44:14.742 --> 03:44:16.122
<v Unidentified speaker>And then also being a public servant.

2369
03:44:16.251 --> 03:44:18.483
<v Unidentified speaker>I worked in BES in the wastewater treatment.

2370
03:44:19.060 --> 03:44:20.329
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not really under the I'm sorry.

2371
03:44:20.329 --> 03:44:20.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm sorry.

2372
03:44:20.329 --> 03:44:24.309
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm putting it under the umbrella of public safety, but I really truly believe it also is public safety, right?

2373
03:44:24.309 --> 03:44:27.159
<v Unidentified speaker>If the brown water doesn't go away, people get really cranky.

2374
03:44:28.530 --> 03:44:34.159
<v Unidentified speaker>So what I wanted to say is I'm in support of the temper— to the 2 amendments that have been put forward.

2375
03:44:34.670 --> 03:44:40.129
<v Unidentified speaker>It is a compromise in the particular environment we are in, in a very troubling time financially.

2376
03:44:40.670 --> 03:44:45.610
<v Unidentified speaker>It does maintain it, but it also is a sacrifice on labor side, right?

2377
03:44:46.117 --> 03:44:47.210
<v Unidentified speaker>It was brought up before.

2378
03:44:47.404 --> 03:44:54.227
<v Unidentified speaker>Last year we agreed on an LOA at $25 a month, and that was a $1.8 million contribution by the members.

2379
03:44:55.277 --> 03:45:02.042
<v Unidentified speaker>This change lets them bring some to the table but still maintains the majority of their health benefits.

2380
03:45:02.091 --> 03:45:06.299
<v Unidentified speaker>So I encourage you to approve both of these amendments.

2381
03:45:06.606 --> 03:45:06.898
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2382
03:45:07.417 --> 03:45:10.093
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2383
03:45:11.049 --> 03:45:18.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next up, we Chris, are you online?

2384
03:45:20.194 --> 03:45:21.377
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't see Chris in the room.

2385
03:45:22.063 --> 03:45:23.636
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, Chris is online.

2386
03:45:26.049 --> 03:45:27.237
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, Chris, there's the button.

2387
03:45:27.369 --> 03:45:28.719
<v Unidentified speaker>I think I've joined as a panelist now.

2388
03:45:29.925 --> 03:45:30.657
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, we can hear you.

2389
03:45:32.110 --> 03:45:34.529
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much to the council.

2390
03:45:34.577 --> 03:45:35.682
<v Unidentified speaker>This is Chris Flannery.

2391
03:45:36.040 --> 03:45:47.504
<v Unidentified speaker>I am the AFSCME Local 189 representative on the LMBC Unfortunately, we weren't able to vote on all of the packages because of the delay of our ratification vote by council.

2392
03:45:48.820 --> 03:45:53.316
<v Unidentified speaker>But I also want to speak in support of the amendments that have been offered.

2393
03:45:53.734 --> 03:46:05.968
<v Unidentified speaker>Frankly, looking at the 8% package, it feels like a clawback from our bargaining in a way that makes me reconsider next time we're at the bargaining table if we're going to commit to the Labor Management Benefits Committee.

2394
03:46:06.869 --> 03:46:08.539
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, so I just want to be frank about that.

2395
03:46:08.650 --> 03:46:26.221
<v Unidentified speaker>Like, as, as a union activist, as someone who believes strongly in, uh, our right to bargain, when we were at the table, we had reservations about returning to the LMBC after last year and the way that the recommendation was put forward as from the, the committee when it wasn't.

2396
03:46:26.719 --> 03:46:34.622
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm glad to hear the understanding this time around that this is an executive branch recommendation and that the LMBC did not settle on one.

2397
03:46:34.671 --> 03:46:34.782
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2398
03:46:36.979 --> 03:46:46.530
<v Unidentified speaker>But still, the, the 10% compromise, I think, shows that, that shared sacrifice without creating enough of a burden on specifically Kaiser members.

2399
03:46:47.219 --> 03:46:55.520
<v Unidentified speaker>Although there are also some changes to Moda, there's some pretty significant impacts to Kaiser members just from the pharmaceutical changes.

2400
03:46:55.520 --> 03:47:04.340
<v Unidentified speaker>So the additional plan changes are going to hit a lot of people in their pockets, and some people it's going to impact them more than any raise that we were able to get them at bargaining.

2401
03:47:04.340 --> 03:47:04.500
<v Loretta Smith>So I think that's a really important point.

2402
03:47:04.500 --> 03:47:04.540
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2403
03:47:05.385 --> 03:47:09.665
<v Unidentified speaker>So please consider, uh, what you would like for your own family when you take this vote.

2404
03:47:10.280 --> 03:47:10.490
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2405
03:47:13.888 --> 03:47:14.912
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2406
03:47:15.918 --> 03:47:17.159
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Carrie Coe.

2407
03:47:17.784 --> 03:47:19.744
<v Keelan McClymont>Carrie?

2408
03:47:25.235 --> 03:47:26.461
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Carolyn Welch?

2409
03:47:30.110 --> 03:47:33.025
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hello, good councilors.

2410
03:47:33.666 --> 03:47:35.045
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For the record, I'm Carolyn Welch.

2411
03:47:36.055 --> 03:47:43.890
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a member of the Labor Management Benefits Committee and represent Boix Emergency Telecommunicators as a member of the Portland Police Association Executive Board.

2412
03:47:44.548 --> 03:47:59.278
<v Unidentified speaker>Over the last year, the Labor Management Benefits Committee has been engaged in a difficult conversation about how to provide the medical benefits that keep city employees and their families healthy, strong, and available to do the the vital work that turns— that in turn keeps our communities thriving.

2413
03:48:00.015 --> 03:48:13.711
<v Unidentified speaker>This discussion has been centered around an understanding that costs are rising and we need to adapt in new ways to meet this goal in a matter that still affirms our shared values: equity, access to care, choice in providers, and affordability.

2414
03:48:14.289 --> 03:48:24.058
<v Unidentified speaker>While we voted on 3 packages in the LMBC meeting different percentages of renewal costs, there is only one package that meets these values in addition to that of fiscal responsibility.

2415
03:48:25.536 --> 03:48:30.064
<v Unidentified speaker>Fiscal responsibility is important, but it should serve our values, not override them.

2416
03:48:30.593 --> 03:48:40.757
<v Unidentified speaker>The 10% package reflects that balance by augmenting our existing benefits in a way that is thoughtful and sustainable without introducing uncertainty or hidden costs.

2417
03:48:41.495 --> 03:48:46.153
<v Unidentified speaker>The 8% package, on the other hand, risks undermining new programs before they can take hold.

2418
03:48:46.795 --> 03:48:57.325
<v Unidentified speaker>It costs too soon before allowing members to acclimate to the overlay services that are meant to blunt the impact of rising costs that our families are feeling in every area of their budgets already.

2419
03:48:58.163 --> 03:49:07.564
<v Unidentified speaker>When facing illness or injury, no employee should have to pause and question whether taking their child or partner to the doctor during an emergency is the right financial decision.

2420
03:49:09.088 --> 03:49:19.915
<v Unidentified speaker>For this reason, I urge you to Affirm the amendments as presented and vote for the 10% package that Labor Benefits Management Committee has forwarded.

2421
03:49:20.525 --> 03:49:24.361
<v Unidentified speaker>We need to provide benefits that are dependable, and the 10% package does that.

2422
03:49:24.698 --> 03:49:31.406
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a values-based choice that supports our workforce and their families, and it is the only option that moves us forward.

2423
03:49:31.599 --> 03:49:32.015
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2424
03:49:32.161 --> 03:49:34.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2425
03:49:34.968 --> 03:49:36.059
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

2426
03:49:36.670 --> 03:49:48.397
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, councilors, we We have 2 ordinances with amendments on the table, um, and some discussion in the queue.

2427
03:49:48.606 --> 03:50:04.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we are going to leave both open because I suspect the discussion will be similar, but then we'll take votes on Emergency Ordinance 159, agenda item number 11, first separately.

2428
03:50:04.602 --> 03:50:04.924
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2429
03:50:05.876 --> 03:50:07.503
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos, go right ahead.

2430
03:50:12.744 --> 03:50:23.523
<v Candace Avalos>I'm going to start by saying I have a very visceral reaction to this vote, and I want to signal to you all that I am really leaning towards a no on the entire ordinance.

2431
03:50:24.137 --> 03:50:25.040
<v Candace Avalos>I love the amendments.

2432
03:50:25.265 --> 03:50:37.790
<v Candace Avalos>I think the amendments are a great step, but I think what I hate about the amendments and just the, the things that we presented to our employees is we never gave them the option of, hey, The city should cover your healthcare.

2433
03:50:38.480 --> 03:50:44.007
<v Candace Avalos>I completely agree that people come to work in a government because healthcare is a huge benefit.

2434
03:50:44.746 --> 03:51:01.040
<v Candace Avalos>I will tell you too, as somebody who went from a job at Portland State that had really great health benefits that I'm grateful that my labor union bargained for, and then I went to go run a nonprofit, and nonprofits obviously don't have a lot of money, and was immediately faced Councilor Smith.

2435
03:51:01.087 --> 03:51:08.930
<v Candace Avalos>I was faced personally with the drastic change in healthcare, and that deeply affected me in very bad ways, and I had to pay the price for that.

2436
03:51:09.412 --> 03:51:26.475
<v Candace Avalos>But then as a leader, when I was faced with making these kinds of decisions and looking at my budget and what are, what are we going to do with the fact that I had no control over the inflationary costs of healthcare, but what I could control was where my values were and how I was going to allocate my budget for my employees.

2437
03:51:27.039 --> 03:51:28.890
<v Candace Avalos>So every single year, it didn't matter.

2438
03:51:28.987 --> 03:51:33.868
<v Candace Avalos>We always budgeted, you know, 10, 12, whatever percent, and then it's like, oh, it's 14%, it's 16%.

2439
03:51:34.560 --> 03:51:35.253
<v Candace Avalos>It didn't matter.

2440
03:51:35.350 --> 03:51:41.525
<v Candace Avalos>We absorbed that cost because that is a critical, literally life-saving resource to our employees.

2441
03:51:42.041 --> 03:51:50.061
<v Candace Avalos>And when in this economy, really, like that, the last thing I want to do is put this burden on the backs of our frontline workers.

2442
03:51:50.644 --> 03:51:53.846
<v Candace Avalos>We make so many choices in this city for how to fund for things.

2443
03:51:53.908 --> 03:51:54.414
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilwoman?

2444
03:51:54.139 --> 03:51:54.269
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2445
03:51:54.558 --> 03:51:55.381
<v Candace Avalos>There's always money.

2446
03:51:55.784 --> 03:51:56.931
<v Candace Avalos>We always find money.

2447
03:51:57.463 --> 03:52:05.384
<v Candace Avalos>And yet we are presenting our employees who work so hard to make this city work with bad options and saying these— this is it.

2448
03:52:05.786 --> 03:52:06.559
<v Candace Avalos>There's no other money.

2449
03:52:07.316 --> 03:52:08.138
<v Candace Avalos>I do not agree.

2450
03:52:08.588 --> 03:52:17.461
<v Candace Avalos>I feel very strongly about this because I'm also concerned that one of the testifiers said, think about— or Chris Flannery said, think about what your family needs.

2451
03:52:19.097 --> 03:52:25.101
<v Candace Avalos>I do not have children, but many of my staff, for example, have I have several children and this is going to deeply affect them.

2452
03:52:25.438 --> 03:52:30.397
<v Candace Avalos>It's going to affect me as somebody who lives with chronic illnesses and I'm constantly in and out of the doctor.

2453
03:52:30.782 --> 03:52:45.134
<v Candace Avalos>And being able, because I had healthcare at Portland State that gave me the ability to do preventative care and to be consistent about getting care so that I could prevent further illnesses, that really affected my life, literally.

2454
03:52:45.791 --> 03:52:52.976
<v Candace Avalos>And I know what it felt like to go from something high-quality healthcare and having to go down to healthcare that was not enough.

2455
03:52:53.925 --> 03:52:57.323
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm here at the city now thinking, yay, I have better healthcare again.

2456
03:52:57.370 --> 03:53:03.868
<v Candace Avalos>And then look at this decision that I have to make that's gonna affect me too, but it's also gonna affect so many employees that work so freaking hard.

2457
03:53:04.365 --> 03:53:04.897
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm upset.

2458
03:53:05.426 --> 03:53:12.615
<v Candace Avalos>I'm clearly upset because I do not think that we should have even put these options on the table.

2459
03:53:13.147 --> 03:53:14.403
<v Candace Avalos>I think it's unacceptable.

2460
03:53:14.628 --> 03:53:15.416
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Loretta Smith.

2461
03:53:16.057 --> 03:53:29.432
<v Candace Avalos>I had a train of thought that I lost because I'm angry, but I think my point is clear that I believe that the city needs to do better to bear this brunt of these changes and not put it on the back of our hardworking employees.

2462
03:53:29.480 --> 03:53:41.024
<v Candace Avalos>So I want to signal for you all that I am probably going to vote no, and I hope you all consider my comments as we continue to discuss this, because I do believe that we have a choice that we can make.

2463
03:53:41.426 --> 03:53:44.272
<v Candace Avalos>We do not have to just accept an option that's presented to us.

2464
03:53:44.578 --> 03:53:45.398
<v Candace Avalos>We are legislators.

2465
03:53:45.462 --> 03:53:49.209
<v Candace Avalos>We can decide to go back to the drawing board, and that's what I would personally recommend.

2466
03:53:49.809 --> 03:53:50.230
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2467
03:53:51.543 --> 03:53:52.337
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

2468
03:53:53.505 --> 03:53:55.759
<v Steve Novick>I have a really dumb question for somebody.

2469
03:53:58.106 --> 03:54:01.587
<v Steve Novick>Are the parks workers in Launa 483 part of the LMBC group?

2470
03:54:02.217 --> 03:54:02.361
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

2471
03:54:03.280 --> 03:54:04.521
<v Steve Novick>Is Launa 483 here?

2472
03:54:08.334 --> 03:54:14.649
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't see anybody from their union, and nobody who was signed up is part of that union, Councilor.

2473
03:54:17.029 --> 03:54:17.977
<v Steve Novick>Um, okay.

2474
03:54:18.683 --> 03:54:49.658
<v Steve Novick>The reason I was asking is that, um, if we're going to lay a lot of people off this year in this budget, and the mayor has made it quite clear that mostly he's going to cut parks, So I think that I would like to hear from the union most likely to be affected and ask them if they would rather— I mean, just ask them, do they support going to 10% even though it means more layoffs?

2475
03:54:51.663 --> 03:54:57.498
<v Steve Novick>So I wouldn't ask anybody else to speak for them, but Councilor would trouble me to make this vote without asking that question.

2476
03:54:57.755 --> 03:54:59.459
<v Unidentified speaker>I do have the results of the—.

2477
03:54:59.459 --> 03:55:03.006
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You see your Can— I'm sorry, can you reintroduce yourself for folks who are online?

2478
03:55:03.263 --> 03:55:03.504
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2479
03:55:03.793 --> 03:55:07.004
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, Rachel Whiteside, labor management benefits co-chair.

2480
03:55:07.101 --> 03:55:11.099
<v Unidentified speaker>I do have the results of the vote if you're interested in how they voted on the packages.

2481
03:55:12.319 --> 03:55:13.266
<v Steve Novick>Yes, please.

2482
03:55:13.556 --> 03:55:27.004
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, I can tell you that there's a PCL representative and there's a Parks Rec representative and Hold one second.

2483
03:55:27.977 --> 03:55:28.867
<v Unidentified speaker>Let me get to my motions.

2484
03:55:31.989 --> 03:55:33.415
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, let's see.

2485
03:55:34.438 --> 03:55:39.365
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, both units voted in favor of the 10% package.

2486
03:55:40.385 --> 03:55:42.800
<v Steve Novick>And does that mean they voted against the 8% package?

2487
03:55:42.996 --> 03:55:44.889
<v Unidentified speaker>They did vote against the 8% package, yes.

2488
03:55:44.956 --> 03:55:45.700
<v Steve Novick>Thank you very much.

2489
03:55:45.764 --> 03:55:46.731
<v Steve Novick>I really appreciate that.

2490
03:55:46.893 --> 03:55:48.552
<v Unidentified speaker>You're welcome.

2491
03:55:49.165 --> 03:55:50.503
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

2492
03:55:52.968 --> 03:55:53.761
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Madam President.

2493
03:55:53.858 --> 03:56:07.799
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, you know, I just need to name that we're in this mess because we use self-funded reserves as a way to stabilize our self-funded healthcare plans, which are, uh, which, which are a reason why we draw people in, right?

2494
03:56:08.153 --> 03:56:12.371
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, but that is— those reserves are funds that the city can always fund, so let's keep that in mind.

2495
03:56:13.226 --> 03:56:28.117
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, but we're also in this reserve— we're in this situation because You know, we've got this unmitigated disaster that is the U.S. healthcare system, the for-profit healthcare system, which is designed to extract the maximum amount of money from working-class families as possible.

2496
03:56:28.469 --> 03:56:32.245
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the city has been absorbing that for years, and it's depleted its reserves.

2497
03:56:32.453 --> 03:56:34.270
<v Unidentified speaker>And so now we're presented with a terrible choice.

2498
03:56:35.426 --> 03:56:39.395
<v Unidentified speaker>We do need to find a way to balance avoiding unacceptable budget cuts.

2499
03:56:39.620 --> 03:56:44.534
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think you see that in the votes from the bargaining units at the LMBC.

2500
03:56:44.664 --> 03:56:44.921
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2501
03:56:46.606 --> 03:56:52.113
<v Unidentified speaker>That they're willing to sort of recognize that fiscal challenge that we're in.

2502
03:56:52.852 --> 03:57:04.236
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm prepared to support both of the proposed amendments because I think it does create a qualitative balance that's the least of the bad, I should say, in this situation.

2503
03:57:05.136 --> 03:57:12.743
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm just displeased that we could not come to a place that our labor partners could agree on a uniform So I hope we do better next time.

2504
03:57:13.559 --> 03:57:15.899
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's our work, by the way.

2505
03:57:16.764 --> 03:57:32.292
<v Unidentified speaker>So, and I fully expect our next legislative agenda to prioritize lobbying for a universal single-payer healthcare system at both the state and the federal levels, because that's— we're going to be dealing with this problem year after year after year after year for the rest of our lives until we get straight on the upstream cost pressure.

2506
03:57:32.341 --> 03:57:34.280
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's where I'm at, folks.

2507
03:57:35.529 --> 03:57:36.235
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2508
03:57:36.331 --> 03:57:36.779
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

2509
03:57:36.891 --> 03:57:39.406
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

2510
03:57:39.520 --> 03:57:47.868
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I want to say ditto, ditto, ditto to you, um, Councilor Avalos, because I actually felt like saying that we need to be paying that $4 million.

2511
03:57:48.269 --> 03:58:02.434
<v Loretta Smith>We figure out ways in which to pay things, and, and like you, I've had some, um, chronic illnesses that, that require— but it's, it's not necessarily about me, it's about the people who have to pay this big jump.

2512
03:58:02.531 --> 03:58:09.655
<v Loretta Smith>When I look We looked at going from, what was it, $2,000 to $5,000 in Kaiser to $9,000 for a family.

2513
03:58:11.191 --> 03:58:14.227
<v Loretta Smith>That, that is not sustainable for our families.

2514
03:58:14.969 --> 03:58:24.709
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that we need to do better and we need to find, you know, designated funds that we, that we can meet the increase every year.

2515
03:58:24.807 --> 03:58:26.594
<v Loretta Smith>And it's going to, it's going to increase every year.

2516
03:58:26.996 --> 03:58:40.305
<v Loretta Smith>And I do agree with you, Councilor Green, We need to be talking to our legislators and trying to figure out ways in which to cut off these healthcare companies who are gouging us every year.

2517
03:58:40.610 --> 03:58:43.324
<v Loretta Smith>They're gouging us and they know we need this stuff.

2518
03:58:43.966 --> 03:58:51.752
<v Loretta Smith>And so the employee— the employers are left to the mercy of these healthcare groups.

2519
03:58:52.314 --> 03:58:58.043
<v Loretta Smith>And that part right there is something that we need to really Um, get a handle up.

2520
03:58:58.093 --> 03:59:01.240
<v Loretta Smith>So I appreciate your words, and I, I felt it.

2521
03:59:01.727 --> 03:59:02.539
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

2522
03:59:04.684 --> 03:59:05.396
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

2523
03:59:06.220 --> 03:59:06.431
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

2524
03:59:06.656 --> 03:59:09.808
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have a question to the 2 amendments that were made.

2525
03:59:11.672 --> 03:59:14.103
<v Eric Zimmerman>They were different amounts, I think, right?

2526
03:59:14.506 --> 03:59:19.708
<v Eric Zimmerman>But were they— first, Councilor Smith, did you make an amendment only, only to one of these packages?

2527
03:59:19.925 --> 03:59:21.158
<v Loretta Smith>LMBC for 10%.

2528
03:59:21.763 --> 03:59:23.817
<v Eric Zimmerman>But not for the police one?

2529
03:59:24.171 --> 03:59:24.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor did.

2530
03:59:24.844 --> 03:59:28.073
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Kanal did the PPA.

2531
03:59:28.505 --> 03:59:29.918
<v Eric Zimmerman>But at a different rate.

2532
03:59:30.175 --> 03:59:30.786
<v Loretta Smith>At a different rate.

2533
03:59:30.897 --> 03:59:47.018
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The 2 amendments on the table are an amendment to agenda item 11 to move to the 10% recommendation, which we saw in the slides, and on agenda item 12 to move to the 11.9% recommendation that we saw on the slides.

2534
03:59:47.420 --> 03:59:48.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Recommendation, to be clear.

2535
03:59:48.656 --> 03:59:49.346
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, I got that part.

2536
03:59:49.442 --> 03:59:51.434
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I saw recommended packages at different levels.

2537
03:59:51.852 --> 04:00:03.722
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I guess Councilor Kanal then, um, because I've heard a lot of— it sounds like some testimony is somewhat agreeable to the 10.

2538
04:00:04.220 --> 04:00:11.657
<v Eric Zimmerman>I was just curious why you're recommending above that one versus making the same thing for LLMBC, or vice versa, whomever.

2539
04:00:11.931 --> 04:00:12.043
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

2540
04:00:13.690 --> 04:00:22.944
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll give the brief answer and then we might need, but effectively there were only 2 options that were presented in our recommendation.

2541
04:00:22.993 --> 04:00:29.533
<v Sameer Kanal>There was the 8%, which is actually a little lower, and then funding the reserves with the rollover, and then 11.9%.

2542
04:00:30.563 --> 04:00:36.105
<v Sameer Kanal>That does represent a 4.1% cut to the expected inflation of 16%, notably.

2543
04:00:37.094 --> 04:00:37.889
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't know if there's anything.

2544
04:00:38.327 --> 04:00:42.113
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, If I can, Aaron Schmaltz, President of Portland Police Association.

2545
04:00:42.177 --> 04:00:49.130
<v Unidentified speaker>Just to clarify, the starting point for the police was 16, and the starting point for the LMBC was 13.4.

2546
04:00:50.287 --> 04:00:54.139
<v Unidentified speaker>And just obviously 6,500 employees against like 800 or so.

2547
04:00:54.701 --> 04:01:08.019
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the move from 16 to 11.9 and the move from 13.4 to 10 is a different number, but it is in fact in parity as it relates to the actual structural changes to the plans.

2548
04:01:08.131 --> 04:01:11.620
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that actually was accidental but serendipitous.

2549
04:01:13.940 --> 04:01:15.797
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for that clarification for everybody.

2550
04:01:16.301 --> 04:01:25.497
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I, I've said this to a few members, and I have said this to some of the advocates in the room.

2551
04:01:25.757 --> 04:01:41.323
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I am nervous about a significant change to a Kaiser plan, and I say that as I'm just saying that as a person who, uh, was hired by Multnomah County and was a member of AFSCME the year before the Great Recession, right?

2552
04:01:41.404 --> 04:01:54.280
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, um, I know sometimes— and we just went through our own negotiations with our own unions this time— but unions make choices in terms of how they, how they approach healthcare, how they approach their employees.

2553
04:01:54.327 --> 04:02:02.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I, and I benefited from that, and, and the greater good took a hit because of But they preserved some, some jobs and some, some impacts.

2554
04:02:02.095 --> 04:02:22.388
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, um, and I am also an employee who, you know, when you're, when you're young and, and you're making $38,000 for a government and even $50,000 for a government, those first-line employees, first jobs out, healthcare is that stability, and Kaiser is that stability.

2555
04:02:22.453 --> 04:02:28.906
<v Eric Zimmerman>You give up some choice, and I think that we make choices to That are appropriate, but we give up some choice to have predictable bills.

2556
04:02:29.806 --> 04:02:33.934
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's where I've really valued Kaiser at one point in my life, right?

2557
04:02:33.984 --> 04:02:37.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't make that choice anymore, and I'm privileged to be able to move off of that.

2558
04:02:37.324 --> 04:03:01.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm cautious, but I also heard throughout the presentations, in other conversations, that there was a desire, or at least a willingness by the folks who sat on that committee I think it's important to recognize that in that decision-making or that negotiating board that some give on the Kaiser plan could be appropriate this time because previously maybe the Moda plan had given up a lot.

2559
04:03:01.849 --> 04:03:04.466
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'll be supportive of this.

2560
04:03:04.577 --> 04:03:20.141
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think I'll be supportive of these amendments and recognizing that Kaiser is not going to meet a need for our most— for our employees most in need of the lowest cost, of the most predictable I think some really important points have been made across the table.

2561
04:03:21.790 --> 04:03:35.769
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I hope we just monitor that and that impact on our youngest employees, our newest employees, our lowest-wage employees who still are going to have access to great healthcare even in this new plan, these new plans that are proposed.

2562
04:03:40.015 --> 04:03:44.864
<v Eric Zimmerman>But that access to predictable healthcare is going to be a little bit less after this proposal.

2563
04:03:45.297 --> 04:03:59.533
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I just want to make sure, and I hope that for all of our city administrators and others and our union presidents that are out there, is that we monitor that because I think that predictability in your first 5 years as an employee helps send a signal if you become an employee with 10, 15, and 20 years under your belt.

2564
04:04:00.079 --> 04:04:02.699
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I appreciate just the efforts there.

2565
04:04:02.907 --> 04:04:16.493
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll be supportive of these amendments as they come forward and cautiously supporting this Can I ask a question before I go in?

2566
04:04:16.621 --> 04:04:19.942
<v Sameer Kanal>What is the order we're going to take these votes in between the 2 amendments and the 2?

2567
04:04:20.487 --> 04:04:31.575
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So once debate is done, we will vote on the amendment that Councilor Smith has put forward to agenda item number 11, since that is the next thing on our agenda.

2568
04:04:32.103 --> 04:04:36.179
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Then we will vote on, once we're done with amendments there, the underlying ordinance.

2569
04:04:37.743 --> 04:04:46.609
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Emergency ordinance, then we'll vote on the amendment you have proposed to agenda item number 12, and then vote once we're through all of the amendments on the underlying emergency ordinance.

2570
04:04:48.112 --> 04:04:49.818
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2571
04:04:50.046 --> 04:05:03.337
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I guess I'll save some of this for the vote, but the really big picture, I think one of the things we talked about is maybe we need to have a narrower set of things that we do as a city.

2572
04:05:03.790 --> 04:05:07.079
<v Sameer Kanal>But that we're doing fully and that we're doing as well as we can.

2573
04:05:07.620 --> 04:05:11.989
<v Sameer Kanal>We've talked about this in a lot of different contexts, you know, over the course of the last few months.

2574
04:05:12.319 --> 04:05:15.809
<v Sameer Kanal>But basically, if we don't have the time to do it right, we don't have the time to do it.

2575
04:05:16.479 --> 04:05:18.799
<v Sameer Kanal>If we don't have the people to do it right, we don't have the people to do it.

2576
04:05:18.840 --> 04:05:20.879
<v Sameer Kanal>If we don't have the money to do it right, we don't have the money to do it.

2577
04:05:20.879 --> 04:05:23.559
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a really important thing to look at.

2578
04:05:23.559 --> 04:05:32.460
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm very sympathetic to the argument here and, um, that, that Councilor Avalos made about ensuring that we're not doing this on the back of our workers.

2579
04:05:33.440 --> 04:05:42.111
<v Sameer Kanal>As it relates to the amendment, I think finding the place where there was some agreement is at minimum a positive step.

2580
04:05:42.191 --> 04:05:50.989
<v Sameer Kanal>It may not be sufficient, and I think that's perfectly valid if not, but ensuring that what we do, we do well, to me is really important.

2581
04:05:51.745 --> 04:05:54.104
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's where I'm kind of framing my thoughts on this.

2582
04:05:54.233 --> 04:05:54.378
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2583
04:05:54.860 --> 04:05:56.255
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2584
04:05:56.721 --> 04:06:15.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, seeing no one else in the queue, we do have a first and a second on the amendment to agenda item number 11, which is to replace the current 8% proposal with the 10% proposal that we have seen.

2585
04:06:15.844 --> 04:06:30.377
<v Keelan McClymont>Keelan, do you need anything more specific for us to move this amendment, or does that give you enough Yeah, I, I think we have enough and we can confirm with the sponsor of the amendment to make sure we have everything.

2586
04:06:31.350 --> 04:06:33.433
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, could you please call the roll?

2587
04:06:34.296 --> 04:06:34.507
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

2588
04:06:35.924 --> 04:06:35.974
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2589
04:06:37.226 --> 04:06:38.180
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

2590
04:06:40.782 --> 04:06:40.879
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2591
04:06:43.709 --> 04:06:44.597
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2592
04:06:44.841 --> 04:06:46.731
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, there's a delay.

2593
04:06:50.360 --> 04:06:50.376
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2594
04:06:51.397 --> 04:06:51.444
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2595
04:06:52.287 --> 04:06:52.304
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2596
04:06:53.987 --> 04:07:04.869
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to say I really, uh, appreciate the testimony that we heard tonight, um, particularly, uh, about the impact on families.

2597
04:07:05.208 --> 04:07:11.927
<v Unidentified speaker>And I would just, uh, special appreciation to Aaron Schmaltz for actually sharing information about your family.

2598
04:07:12.717 --> 04:07:21.778
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, I was what was once known as a childless cat lady, so I really, I really appreciate, uh, hearing about your experience and really thinking through this.

2599
04:07:21.875 --> 04:07:24.443
<v Unidentified speaker>And we don't have a healthcare system at all.

2600
04:07:24.960 --> 04:07:25.948
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't have a system.

2601
04:07:26.400 --> 04:07:30.799
<v Unidentified speaker>In fact, we're paying probably 20% of our GDP is going to this nightmare.

2602
04:07:31.525 --> 04:07:32.879
<v Unidentified speaker>So we do need to work on that.

2603
04:07:32.959 --> 04:07:34.925
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Green, I appreciate that, and I'm an aye.

2604
04:07:35.296 --> 04:07:35.746
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2605
04:07:36.729 --> 04:07:37.115
<v Unidentified speaker>Green.

2606
04:07:39.551 --> 04:07:39.567
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2607
04:07:40.260 --> 04:07:40.308
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2608
04:07:41.065 --> 04:07:41.242
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2609
04:07:41.870 --> 04:07:41.918
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2610
04:07:42.674 --> 04:07:42.691
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2611
04:07:43.641 --> 04:07:43.802
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

2612
04:07:45.252 --> 04:07:45.299
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2613
04:07:46.153 --> 04:07:50.333
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 12 yes votes.

2614
04:07:51.879 --> 04:07:55.143
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, are you in the queue to discuss the amended ordinance?

2615
04:07:56.540 --> 04:07:57.296
<v Sameer Kanal>Legacy hand, sorry.

2616
04:07:57.779 --> 04:08:02.254
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing no one in the queue, do we need a motion?

2617
04:08:02.834 --> 04:08:02.914
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2618
04:08:03.530 --> 04:08:05.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, then can you please call the roll?

2619
04:08:06.202 --> 04:08:06.911
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

2620
04:08:07.570 --> 04:08:11.001
<v Sameer Kanal>Just to be clear, this is on the actual ordinance for the LMBC side?

2621
04:08:11.049 --> 04:08:18.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a vote on agenda item number 11, the ordinance on the LMBC side, which has now been amended to the 10% proposal.

2622
04:08:19.568 --> 04:08:19.986
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2623
04:08:22.043 --> 04:08:27.074
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I was uninsured or had insurance that I could not access for 6 years in my 20s.

2624
04:08:27.684 --> 04:08:35.851
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not something that I would wish on anyone, literally, because I also support universal healthcare and hope that OGR is listening when they develop the legislative agenda.

2625
04:08:36.477 --> 04:08:38.933
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I— because of that, it's visceral for me too.

2626
04:08:39.046 --> 04:08:40.636
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate that term, Councilor Avalos.

2627
04:08:41.373 --> 04:08:45.291
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, our city's core values include fiscal responsibility and also collaboration.

2628
04:08:45.565 --> 04:08:53.449
<v Sameer Kanal>And so given that, um, collaboration occurred, I'm grateful to the, uh, labor partners on the LMBC for coming to compromise at 10%.

2629
04:08:54.075 --> 04:08:57.382
<v Sameer Kanal>Grateful to BHR for doing the hard work and getting, uh, to that point.

2630
04:08:57.447 --> 04:08:57.944
<v Sameer Kanal>So I vote yes.

2631
04:08:58.009 --> 04:08:58.218
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2632
04:09:00.897 --> 04:09:09.612
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, um, first of all, I just want to start off by saying I'm going to read my comments in on this item, and it'll be the same for both, so I won't make any comments on the next one.

2633
04:09:10.110 --> 04:09:14.122
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I will add to the fact that, um, I have context.

2634
04:09:14.202 --> 04:09:14.941
<v Unidentified speaker>I think we all do.

2635
04:09:15.085 --> 04:09:16.096
<v Unidentified speaker>Healthcare is personal.

2636
04:09:16.530 --> 04:09:19.257
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, at age 24, I found out I had HIV.

2637
04:09:19.354 --> 04:09:20.574
<v Unidentified speaker>That was back in the dark ages.

2638
04:09:20.655 --> 04:09:30.120
<v Unidentified speaker>I was a working artist, and it's really shaped my life, and I've become Quite a healthcare advocate and activist ever since, and that was a few years ago.

2639
04:09:30.200 --> 04:09:33.935
<v Unidentified speaker>So I want to thank both Councilor Smith and Councilor Kanal.

2640
04:09:34.577 --> 04:09:38.121
<v Unidentified speaker>These amendments got us to the sweet spot after a year of building trust.

2641
04:09:38.506 --> 04:09:44.231
<v Unidentified speaker>The testimony by our labor leaders affirmed that point, and I appreciate hearing from all of you.

2642
04:09:44.778 --> 04:09:48.561
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a much better process than the one we— that came before us last year.

2643
04:09:48.802 --> 04:09:50.486
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of you probably know that, and I'm very proud.

2644
04:09:50.534 --> 04:09:50.759
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2645
04:09:51.465 --> 04:09:53.351
<v Unidentified speaker>To sit here and see that through with you.

2646
04:09:53.921 --> 04:09:56.897
<v Unidentified speaker>Here's to shared responsibility and shared sacrifice.

2647
04:09:57.639 --> 04:10:00.942
<v Unidentified speaker>Together we are one city team serving this very beautiful city.

2648
04:10:01.394 --> 04:10:04.358
<v Unidentified speaker>So in that, in that spirit, on this lovely spring evening, I vote aye.

2649
04:10:08.736 --> 04:10:35.936
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm really grateful for this amendment, and while I'm glad we have found a compromise, I am acknowledging I want to thank all the folks that came and testified today and shared their experiences with us, and I am really grateful for Councilors Kanal and Smith as well for bringing these amendments forward.

2650
04:10:35.985 --> 04:10:52.165
<v Angelita Morillo>I think they have really improved what we had in the negotiations and what we're ending up with, and we know that it's still a cost to city workers as far as not having the same level of care that they used to, and our workers are completely invaluable and irreplaceable.

2651
04:10:52.777 --> 04:11:01.415
<v Angelita Morillo>We know that healthcare costs are rising across the country, and now with tariffs and everything else going on, people are really struggling to afford to live in our city.

2652
04:11:01.849 --> 04:11:23.191
<v Angelita Morillo>The fact that 72.4% of people said that affordable housing is their top priority, these issues are just hitting people across the board, and so I really care about sustainability and equity, and I want to make sure that we create benefits and design systems across all bureaus that reflect fiscal responsibility and address the human and health needs of those serving our city.

2653
04:11:23.273 --> 04:11:24.377
<v Angelita Morillo>So with that, I vote aye.

2654
04:11:27.025 --> 04:11:35.613
<v Steve Novick>Although I join in the denunciation of healthcare companies, I also have to point out that in this country, a lot of doctors make too much money too, particularly specialists.

2655
04:11:35.711 --> 04:11:37.868
<v Steve Novick>Radiologists make $498,000 a year.

2656
04:11:38.700 --> 04:11:42.505
<v Steve Novick>Um, anesthesiologist makes $472,000 a year, so don't forget that.

2657
04:11:42.829 --> 04:11:42.878
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2658
04:11:44.222 --> 04:11:51.747
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to give a special shout out to Michelle Taylor and the team and everyone on the LMBC.

2659
04:11:52.055 --> 04:11:52.879
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, great job.

2660
04:11:53.673 --> 04:11:55.694
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, thank you for all your work, and I vote aye.

2661
04:11:58.110 --> 04:12:02.778
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to echo the appreciation for Councilor Smith and Kanal for bringing these amendments.

2662
04:12:02.972 --> 04:12:09.246
<v Unidentified speaker>I, I don't like I'm much closer to Councilor Avalos, and I thank you for raising that sentiment.

2663
04:12:09.326 --> 04:12:10.338
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it puts us on notice.

2664
04:12:10.933 --> 04:12:16.699
<v Unidentified speaker>I think the work that we have ahead of us is to figure out how we build a city and a budget that takes care of our workers.

2665
04:12:17.613 --> 04:12:20.281
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's— this is not going to go away, and I don't want it.

2666
04:12:20.424 --> 04:12:24.487
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't want this to be the first of many small cuts that bleed us out as a city.

2667
04:12:25.468 --> 04:12:28.536
<v Unidentified speaker>I vote aye.

2668
04:12:28.680 --> 04:12:28.952
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

2669
04:12:29.113 --> 04:12:40.030
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just going to acknowledge the I think that there is an aspect of shared sacrifice, and that's not a term I love to say, but the workforce stepped up in a way that I want to acknowledge.

2670
04:12:40.985 --> 04:12:54.849
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I appreciate that we also— that we did make a compromise here because I think that more kids are likely to have access to sports next year because we have minimized in this a little bit of the budget gap.

2671
04:12:54.995 --> 04:12:55.236
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2672
04:12:55.913 --> 04:13:06.158
<v Eric Zimmerman>And there are thousands of employees who are giving up a little bit in this, and I am acknowledging that for the benefit also of our 600,000+ residents.

2673
04:13:06.207 --> 04:13:11.290
<v Eric Zimmerman>So to everybody that participated in this shared sacrifice, I appreciate it, and I vote aye.

2674
04:13:14.896 --> 04:13:33.352
<v Candace Avalos>I will be voting no on this ordinance, not because I disagree with the health and wellness benefits being added, but because I believe the city should be covering these From the start, we should have offered the Labor Management Benefits Committee a real option where the city absorbs the full increase.

2675
04:13:33.867 --> 04:13:38.667
<v Candace Avalos>Instead, we gave them a set of constrained choices that assumed workers would have to carry some of the load.

2676
04:13:39.229 --> 04:13:41.154
<v Candace Avalos>That to me is not a values-neutral process.

2677
04:13:41.266 --> 04:13:44.000
<v Candace Avalos>It is a policy decision, and I believe it was the wrong one.

2678
04:13:44.679 --> 04:13:51.049
<v Candace Avalos>We are talking about an increase in cost that The cost is absorbable in the scale of our overall budget.

2679
04:13:51.564 --> 04:13:53.299
<v Candace Avalos>We find money for a lot of things in this city.

2680
04:13:53.556 --> 04:13:56.943
<v Candace Avalos>We could have found money to protect our workers from rising healthcare costs.

2681
04:13:57.425 --> 04:14:05.262
<v Candace Avalos>This proposal hits our frontline workers the hardest, the same people who are already underpaid, overextended, and critical to the functioning of this city.

2682
04:14:05.921 --> 04:14:10.657
<v Candace Avalos>Higher deductibles, increased out-of-pocket costs, and coinsurance all add up.

2683
04:14:11.156 --> 04:14:23.904
<v Candace Avalos>And those increases don't hit executives or higher-wage employees the same way they hit a janitor, To me, employee health and wellness isn't something that we should compromise on, especially in times like this.

2684
04:14:24.529 --> 04:14:30.745
<v Candace Avalos>Our workers are stretched thin, they're doing more with less, and the last thing they need is to be asked to pay more for essential care.

2685
04:14:31.370 --> 04:14:42.058
<v Candace Avalos>So while I appreciate the work of the LMBC and the improvements to mental health and virtual access, all of that, I just cannot support a plan that shifts more costs to the very people who keep Portland running.

2686
04:14:42.105 --> 04:14:42.235
<v Candace Avalos>I vote no.

2687
04:14:42.282 --> 04:14:42.699
<v Candace Avalos>Council Member Herbold.

2688
04:14:43.656 --> 04:14:44.371
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Danphy.

2689
04:14:46.110 --> 04:14:49.391
<v Sameer Kanal>I just, I hate that only in America are we able to have this conversation.

2690
04:14:50.459 --> 04:14:59.224
<v Sameer Kanal>There was literally one of the best TV shows that ever existed was about a man who had cancer and couldn't afford his health insurance and turned to selling meth in the New Mexico desert.

2691
04:15:00.040 --> 04:15:03.683
<v Sameer Kanal>So our American healthcare system is fundamentally broken.

2692
04:15:03.731 --> 04:15:16.909
<v Sameer Kanal>I spent the last 5 years working for the American Cancer Society begging for incremental changes to cancer treatment to save lives, and my own health insurance didn't cover the policies that we were advocating for.

2693
04:15:17.809 --> 04:15:24.554
<v Sameer Kanal>I— when I got this new job, I literally danced around just because of the cost savings for my health insurance.

2694
04:15:24.618 --> 04:15:27.652
<v Sameer Kanal>I am an adult who is living with a well-treated chronic illness.

2695
04:15:27.765 --> 04:15:34.449
<v Sameer Kanal>I am so lucky to have an incredibly healthy spouse and a healthy 13-year-old daughter, and I know that that is luck more than anything else.

2696
04:15:36.975 --> 04:15:43.381
<v Sameer Kanal>These companies are not only gouging us; they are actively making the quality of our healthcare worse, and it is leading to bad outcomes.

2697
04:15:44.120 --> 04:15:48.522
<v Sameer Kanal>And we are stuck in the same narrative, and it is heartbreaking and wrong.

2698
04:15:48.939 --> 04:15:51.573
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is the best of a bad situation.

2699
04:15:52.568 --> 04:15:56.229
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm glad we are avoiding having to bargain by making bad choices.

2700
04:15:56.326 --> 04:16:01.289
<v Sameer Kanal>I am glad that this still makes us a competitive employer, but we need.

2701
04:16:01.370 --> 04:16:04.423
<v Sameer Kanal>And to acknowledge that this is making our health insurance worse.

2702
04:16:04.614 --> 04:16:07.299
<v Sameer Kanal>This is making it worse to be an employee in this city.

2703
04:16:07.346 --> 04:16:12.365
<v Sameer Kanal>And I appreciate the employees standing up and recognizing the moment of needed shared sacrifice.

2704
04:16:12.816 --> 04:16:14.944
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope that we don't have to continue this.

2705
04:16:15.299 --> 04:16:18.200
<v Sameer Kanal>And, um, I just wanted to make sure to call that out.

2706
04:16:18.297 --> 04:16:18.781
<v Sameer Kanal>I vote aye.

2707
04:16:22.028 --> 04:16:25.036
<v Loretta Smith>I want to thank everybody who, um, testified tonight.

2708
04:16:25.763 --> 04:16:34.781
<v Loretta Smith>I want to thank, um, our HR, LMBC, And the families that have to endure some of these, um, these health emergencies.

2709
04:16:36.353 --> 04:16:40.350
<v Loretta Smith>I was elected to Multnomah County Commission in 2010.

2710
04:16:41.924 --> 04:16:48.064
<v Loretta Smith>11 Months into my first year, I had a medical emergency, and I had Kaiser.

2711
04:16:51.711 --> 04:16:54.987
<v Loretta Smith>I had a tumor, a grapefruit-sized tumor in my head.

2712
04:16:55.036 --> 04:16:55.568
<v Loretta Smith>I had a brain tumor.

2713
04:16:56.930 --> 04:16:58.041
<v Loretta Smith>And I was hemorrhaging.

2714
04:16:58.943 --> 04:17:03.195
<v Loretta Smith>I was in Seattle driving home for my son's game at University of Washington.

2715
04:17:03.630 --> 04:17:05.016
<v Loretta Smith>Didn't know, I just thought I had a headache.

2716
04:17:06.139 --> 04:17:09.641
<v Loretta Smith>But ultimately I had something that was much, much more severe.

2717
04:17:10.494 --> 04:17:28.897
<v Loretta Smith>And had I not had that— we had great health insurance at Multnomah County, and I had the ability to have 2 surgeons 2 anesthesiologists for 3— what was supposed to be a 2.5 to 3-hour surgery.

2718
04:17:29.398 --> 04:17:38.811
<v Loretta Smith>I was in there for 6.5 hours, and piece by piece by piece by piece, they took the tumor out of my head.

2719
04:17:40.603 --> 04:17:48.602
<v Loretta Smith>Had I not had that, I would have been— that is just an incident that will take you into bankruptcy.

2720
04:17:50.334 --> 04:17:57.889
<v Loretta Smith>But because I worked for the public sector, and fortunately for Multnomah County, my family didn't have to endure that.

2721
04:17:58.423 --> 04:18:00.817
<v Loretta Smith>My son was on the health insurance as well.

2722
04:18:01.724 --> 04:18:06.561
<v Loretta Smith>But I know what it's like when you have those kinds of health emergencies.

2723
04:18:07.791 --> 04:18:11.042
<v Loretta Smith>The doctor said that it was a miracle.

2724
04:18:12.256 --> 04:18:14.327
<v Loretta Smith>And so if I have a sense of urgency, Thank you.

2725
04:18:15.674 --> 04:18:15.965
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

2726
04:18:16.222 --> 04:18:21.986
<v Loretta Smith>When I'm trying to do things, it's because I know that life is so, so precious.

2727
04:18:22.033 --> 04:18:23.164
<v Loretta Smith>You can go just like this.

2728
04:18:23.670 --> 04:18:31.622
<v Loretta Smith>Why God saved me to be here to save this LMBC, but he did.

2729
04:18:31.735 --> 04:18:36.522
<v Loretta Smith>And so that's why my sense of urgency is always urgent, because I know what it's like.

2730
04:18:36.958 --> 04:18:43.611
<v Loretta Smith>And for folks who don't have what we have, I wish they did.

2731
04:18:44.245 --> 04:18:44.878
<v Loretta Smith>I really wish they did.

2732
04:18:44.975 --> 04:18:48.334
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm going to say yes, I support this.

2733
04:18:52.215 --> 04:18:55.656
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's a lot I could say, but there's also a lot that's been said, and it's after 10 o'clock.

2734
04:18:55.704 --> 04:19:00.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just want to thank the folks who are here on behalf of our city employees.

2735
04:19:01.576 --> 04:19:18.166
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, you took the time to be here very late with us to paint for us a broader picture of where our employees are, what the trade-offs are for our employees, and what the balance is that folks felt was as fair as we could get.

2736
04:19:18.377 --> 04:19:25.006
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I really appreciate your time, and I appreciate your members' time in allowing you to generously be here on their behalf.

2737
04:19:25.439 --> 04:19:25.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I vote yes.

2738
04:19:27.959 --> 04:19:31.254
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance is passed as amended with 11 yes votes.

2739
04:19:31.530 --> 04:19:34.908
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Keelan.

2740
04:19:35.102 --> 04:19:41.402
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we have another agenda item open on the table with an open amendment.

2741
04:19:41.871 --> 04:19:46.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Agenda item 12, the Portland Police Association City Employee Benefits Program.

2742
04:19:47.461 --> 04:20:00.763
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have an amendment provided by Councilor Kanal and seconded by Councilor Smith to replace that agenda item with the 11.9% recommendations that were in the presentation.

2743
04:20:01.421 --> 04:20:04.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, I'm assuming you're okay with that much information.

2744
04:20:05.283 --> 04:20:07.816
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, are you in the queue to discuss this amendment?

2745
04:20:08.713 --> 04:20:09.083
<v Loretta Smith>No, ma'am.

2746
04:20:10.574 --> 04:20:13.315
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing no one— oh, Councilor Knoll, are you getting in the queue?

2747
04:20:13.395 --> 04:20:13.700
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

2748
04:20:13.763 --> 04:20:14.581
<v Sameer Kanal>Can I just vote first?

2749
04:20:14.837 --> 04:20:19.823
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing no one in the queue, now, or, um, Keelan, can you call the roll?

2750
04:20:20.913 --> 04:20:21.024
<v Keelan McClymont>Knoll.

2751
04:20:21.809 --> 04:20:23.494
<v Sameer Kanal>And to clarify, we're voting on the amendment?

2752
04:20:24.359 --> 04:20:30.030
<v Sameer Kanal>We are voting on Yeah, I'm obviously going to vote yes.

2753
04:20:30.030 --> 04:20:33.920
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to say that it may be surprising that this amendment came from me.

2754
04:20:34.329 --> 04:20:37.440
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to speak to why I did, since I didn't speak to this before the public testimony.

2755
04:20:38.389 --> 04:20:48.120
<v Sameer Kanal>This amendment ensures that the city's police officers have a more comprehensive health plan than the 8% level, which is good for those officers as well as the broader public and our long-term budgetary health.

2756
04:20:49.129 --> 04:20:53.190
<v Sameer Kanal>Speaking first to the officers, all these changes would restore the plan to that agreed to by the PPA, which is a comprehensive health plan for all city employees.

2757
04:20:53.208 --> 04:20:57.727
<v Sameer Kanal>So as compared to the 8% one, at least we know that the PPA supports that.

2758
04:20:58.865 --> 04:21:12.154
<v Sameer Kanal>To the health of the broader public, ensuring that PPB sworn officers are more likely to pursue physical and mental health care and just be in better shape physically and mentally ensures that those officers are more well when they're out in community.

2759
04:21:12.666 --> 04:21:20.488
<v Sameer Kanal>Anytime an unwell city employee interacts with a community member, that community member's experience is going to be worse than if that city employee was well at the time of the interaction.

2760
04:21:21.548 --> 04:21:29.309
<v Sameer Kanal>That disparity is particularly stark with police officers, where a bad interaction or a good one has a larger impact than with most other city employees.

2761
04:21:30.048 --> 04:21:37.569
<v Sameer Kanal>As long as the city is going to send armed employees out into the community, the city's obligation is to ensure those employees are best able to interact safely with members of the community.

2762
04:21:38.564 --> 04:21:45.828
<v Sameer Kanal>One fewer negative interaction, speaking to the budgetary health, would save the city the cost of the claim, lawsuit award, or settlement associated with that interaction.

2763
04:21:46.278 --> 04:21:50.158
<v Sameer Kanal>City Council has just dealt with two payouts related to police conduct of over one million dollars each.

2764
04:21:51.013 --> 04:21:58.943
<v Sameer Kanal>If paying $6,000— sorry, $638,650 avoids even a single wrongful death, violation of rights, etc.

2765
04:21:59.009 --> 04:22:00.045
<v Sameer Kanal>Claim, it will pay for itself.

2766
04:22:01.012 --> 04:22:03.039
<v Sameer Kanal>And we do need to figure out later where the money comes from.

2767
04:22:03.282 --> 04:22:08.959
<v Sameer Kanal>Those who agree with me on the amendment in this ordinance may disagree as to where the money comes from, and that's okay.

2768
04:22:09.492 --> 04:22:12.519
<v Sameer Kanal>This doesn't necessarily have an impact on our overall budgetary priorities.

2769
04:22:12.953 --> 04:22:23.959
<v Sameer Kanal>But I don't want to dwell on potential future disagreements, though, at the Uh, Ryan.

2770
04:22:24.863 --> 04:22:24.913
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2771
04:22:25.995 --> 04:22:26.463
<v Keelan McClymont>Lea Malane.

2772
04:22:28.149 --> 04:22:28.182
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2773
04:22:28.968 --> 04:22:29.016
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2774
04:22:31.395 --> 04:22:41.884
<v Steve Novick>I just want to say that if I'd heard from Councilor Dunphy before the last vote, I might have voted to hold to the 8% because he reminded me that if you can't afford your medical bills, you can show some initiative like Walter White and sell meth.

2775
04:22:43.596 --> 04:22:47.228
<v Steve Novick>However, since it might be particularly inappropriate to ask the police to sell meth, I'm going to vote aye.

2776
04:22:48.337 --> 04:22:48.755
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2777
04:22:49.382 --> 04:22:49.431
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2778
04:22:50.201 --> 04:22:50.572
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2779
04:22:50.989 --> 04:22:51.038
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2780
04:22:51.584 --> 04:22:52.099
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2781
04:22:52.356 --> 04:22:53.587
<v Loretta Smith>Wright?

2782
04:22:54.074 --> 04:22:54.090
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2783
04:22:54.786 --> 04:22:54.834
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2784
04:22:55.595 --> 04:22:55.611
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2785
04:22:56.810 --> 04:22:56.941
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2786
04:22:58.997 --> 04:22:59.030
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2787
04:23:00.551 --> 04:23:03.905
<v Keelan McClymont>With 12 yes votes, the amendment is approved.

2788
04:23:05.243 --> 04:23:07.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see no one in the queue for comment.

2789
04:23:08.047 --> 04:23:10.397
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Going once, Going twice.

2790
04:23:10.960 --> 04:23:18.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, can you please call the roll on the amended emergency ordinance agenda item number 12?

2791
04:23:19.953 --> 04:23:20.066
<v Angelita Morillo>No.

2792
04:23:20.975 --> 04:23:21.332
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

2793
04:23:23.504 --> 04:23:23.683
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2794
04:23:25.587 --> 04:23:25.636
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2795
04:23:27.435 --> 04:23:27.484
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2796
04:23:28.094 --> 04:23:28.111
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

2797
04:23:28.801 --> 04:23:28.850
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2798
04:23:29.604 --> 04:23:29.781
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

2799
04:23:30.488 --> 04:23:30.537
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2800
04:23:32.094 --> 04:23:43.122
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just gonna say, while I reject the idea that all first responders Members are in deep need of mental health, and I think the comments that were made a minute ago are deeply inappropriate in many ways.

2801
04:23:43.703 --> 04:23:44.525
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am supportive of this.

2802
04:23:44.702 --> 04:23:45.009
<v Eric Zimmerman>I vote aye.

2803
04:23:48.522 --> 04:23:52.609
<v Candace Avalos>The comments I made on the last resolution are the same for this one, and so I vote no.

2804
04:23:54.683 --> 04:23:58.764
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, colleagues, for all your hard work on getting to a defensible space.

2805
04:23:58.976 --> 04:23:59.413
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

2806
04:23:59.851 --> 04:24:00.272
<v Unidentified speaker>I vote aye.

2807
04:24:01.470 --> 04:24:01.486
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2808
04:24:04.467 --> 04:24:08.902
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My same comments, Erin, to you as I made to our other labor representatives who are here tonight.

2809
04:24:10.059 --> 04:24:10.076
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2810
04:24:10.781 --> 04:24:14.430
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance has passed as amended with 11 yes votes and 1 no vote.

2811
04:24:16.620 --> 04:24:18.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, councilors.

2812
04:24:18.338 --> 04:24:27.113
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are overtime at 10:20, but we've checked with staff and can keep going for a little bit longer if folks have the stamina to do so.

2813
04:24:27.918 --> 04:24:33.102
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have 3, 4, 4 more agenda items.

2814
04:24:33.359 --> 04:24:37.724
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I don't believe we can get through all of them, but I'm hoping we can get through a little bit more.

2815
04:24:37.869 --> 04:24:39.361
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are folks open to continuing?

2816
04:24:40.822 --> 04:24:42.650
<v Candace Avalos>What does a little bit more mean?

2817
04:24:42.747 --> 04:24:43.693
<v Candace Avalos>Like, what's the timing?

2818
04:24:43.887 --> 04:24:46.791
<v Eric Zimmerman>I move to table to the next council meeting.

2819
04:24:46.920 --> 04:24:59.761
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I think I have the floor right now, and, uh, I'm— what my question is, is did you allocate a specific amount of time, or did the staff tell Staff have not given us a hard stop for tonight, no.

2820
04:25:00.002 --> 04:25:02.329
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I have not allocated a specific amount of time.

2821
04:25:02.908 --> 04:25:11.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My intent would be to ask this same question about our willingness to keep moving before each of the upcoming agenda items and take them one at a time and see how folks are doing.

2822
04:25:13.023 --> 04:25:15.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2823
04:25:16.299 --> 04:25:20.619
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we have— it sounds like we have an objection to continuing moving.

2824
04:25:24.399 --> 04:25:24.513
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

2825
04:25:24.756 --> 04:25:27.262
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Take a— Councilor Kanal, you are in the queue.

2826
04:25:27.343 --> 04:25:29.002
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, I thought that was a legacy hand.

2827
04:25:29.084 --> 04:25:29.816
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, that was a new one.

2828
04:25:31.255 --> 04:25:43.092
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, my question for you, Madam President, is if we were to not be able to get whatever number of items we can't get through tonight, are they by necessity going to the next, uh, council meeting, or is there the recess opportunity?

2829
04:25:43.674 --> 04:25:58.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our normal recess time is Thursday afternoons, but we have It is possible the way we have committees scheduled, we do have Wednesday mornings and Thursday afternoons free on committee weeks.

2830
04:25:58.981 --> 04:26:06.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What I don't know sitting here right now is whether our support staff can add another meeting to our busy committee weeks.

2831
04:26:08.045 --> 04:26:13.980
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But what I would do if we recess was work with staff to figure out if there is an available time for us to meet on Wednesday morning.

2832
04:26:14.093 --> 04:26:14.220
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

2833
04:26:14.766 --> 04:26:17.801
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To recess to between now and the next council meeting.

2834
04:26:18.058 --> 04:26:27.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if not, they would go to the top of the next council meeting agenda, which I will note is also a very, very full agenda.

2835
04:26:29.218 --> 04:26:39.109
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, then I, I would be supportive of pursuing a potential recess if for whatever we can't get to tonight, um, which would leave you the opportunity to find other time if it is available.

2836
04:26:42.867 --> 04:26:54.993
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see a sidebar happening with the folks who do have the next agenda item, and the next 2 things on the agenda we have been told it's important to do today if we can.

2837
04:26:56.700 --> 04:27:00.647
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mike Jordan, do you have— Councilor Koyama Lane?

2838
04:27:02.252 --> 04:27:16.424
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I was going to say that I'm under the impression that for the next I'm under the impression that for the next agenda item, there's a sense of urgency because of a timeline, but maybe that's for this commission.

2839
04:27:21.207 --> 04:27:30.927
<v Unidentified speaker>The change in the code is necessary as we move forward with appointments soon for the commission, and I know that that's been in the works for a long time.

2840
04:27:32.132 --> 04:27:35.129
<v Unidentified speaker>I do not think there's a drop-dead date on this.

2841
04:27:35.977 --> 04:27:44.183
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, my suspicion is that the next agenda item won't be terribly controversial, but that there may be a lot of conversation about the 3 after that.

2842
04:27:44.791 --> 04:27:49.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would suggest that we at least get through the next agenda item and then perhaps reevaluate.

2843
04:27:50.319 --> 04:27:55.495
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And seeing nods from the vast majority of people, okay.

2844
04:27:55.688 --> 04:27:57.674
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, could you please call agenda item 13?

2845
04:27:58.630 --> 04:28:01.058
<v Keelan McClymont>And Sustainability and Climate Commission Code.

2846
04:28:05.440 --> 04:28:09.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we have a committee staff summary for this agenda item.

2847
04:28:09.953 --> 04:28:22.056
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Vivian, we generally don't do presentations at council, so we're going to do the committee staff summary, and then if you want to stay up there in case we have questions for you, that's great, but we'll let our committee staff take it away.

2848
04:28:22.959 --> 04:28:23.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and Ashley, welcome.

2849
04:28:23.916 --> 04:28:26.593
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think this is your first time doing a committee staff summary for us.

2850
04:28:26.704 --> 04:28:27.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

2851
04:28:28.614 --> 04:28:30.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, if you could introduce yourself and then go right ahead.

2852
04:28:31.102 --> 04:28:33.092
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Madam President and councilors.

2853
04:28:33.750 --> 04:28:38.709
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For the record, my name is Ashley Hernandez and I serve as a staff to the Governance Committee.

2854
04:28:39.141 --> 04:28:56.587
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The ordinance before you, document number 2025-118, was considered in the Governance Committee on April 7th, where it was referred to the City Council as amended with a recommendation to— for the ordinance is passed.

2855
04:28:57.663 --> 04:29:06.492
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the ordinance adds City Code Chapter 3.136 related to the new Sustainability and Climate Commission.

2856
04:29:07.550 --> 04:29:17.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Chapter 3.136 describes the purpose, membership, and terms, duties, and procedures for the commission.

2857
04:29:17.968 --> 04:29:19.976
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The ordinance also amends City Code Yes.

2858
04:29:20.057 --> 04:29:29.216
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Chapter 3.3 to remove the Sustainability and Climate Commission from the preview, uh, preview of the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

2859
04:29:30.695 --> 04:29:37.506
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The committee adopted amendments prior to, um, prior to them moving to the full council.

2860
04:29:38.000 --> 04:29:45.155
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The effects of amendments on the original ordinance drafts are summarized in the committee staff summary.

2861
04:29:46.647 --> 04:29:56.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The full impact statement of these items includes a financial and budgetary impacts and analysis, community impacts, and community involvement.

2862
04:29:57.731 --> 04:30:05.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>One person testified during the committee meeting on March 31st, and the same individual, individual submitted a written testimony.

2863
04:30:05.186 --> 04:30:22.807
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The testimony focused on alignment and aligning the new commission with the recommendation made by the Government Transition Advisory Committee, GTAC, regarding the clarifying of scope of purpose of city advisory bodies.

2864
04:30:25.559 --> 04:30:26.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

2865
04:30:26.862 --> 04:30:30.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane, you were the presiding chair for this meeting.

2866
04:30:30.340 --> 04:30:32.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there anything you'd like to add to the staff summary?

2867
04:30:33.297 --> 04:30:42.300
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Just that these hardworking staff members have been— have spent 2 years researching and engaging community Thank you.

2868
04:30:43.007 --> 04:30:44.051
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for your hard work.

2869
04:30:44.388 --> 04:30:49.014
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This item before us is to codify this commission in our new form of government.

2870
04:30:49.433 --> 04:30:52.050
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The Governance Committee saw this item twice.

2871
04:30:52.581 --> 04:30:55.391
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Committee and public comment led to multiple amendments.

2872
04:30:55.471 --> 04:30:57.850
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for your work on those.

2873
04:30:58.186 --> 04:31:03.199
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And their current recruitment process has been underway since November 2024.

2874
04:31:03.326 --> 04:31:13.574
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The mayor's appointments will be seen by Climate Resilience Thank you.

2875
04:31:15.170 --> 04:31:21.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I see some hands up, and we do have a number of folks here who can answer questions.

2876
04:31:22.111 --> 04:31:26.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But first, Keelan, is there any public testimony signed up for this agenda item?

2877
04:31:27.373 --> 04:31:28.468
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't believe there is.

2878
04:31:30.540 --> 04:31:30.838
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mayor.

2879
04:31:31.265 --> 04:31:31.827
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, that's okay.

2880
04:31:32.406 --> 04:31:34.204
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sorry, will you repeat the question?

2881
04:31:34.253 --> 04:31:35.939
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Was there any public testimony signed up?

2882
04:31:36.099 --> 04:31:37.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, I don't think so.

2883
04:31:37.304 --> 04:31:37.545
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

2884
04:31:37.689 --> 04:31:38.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry.

2885
04:31:39.069 --> 04:31:40.209
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

2886
04:31:41.477 --> 04:31:42.458
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

2887
04:31:42.522 --> 04:31:45.347
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think my question's probably to the committee chair.

2888
04:31:45.798 --> 04:31:56.218
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's an amendment or a strikethrough, if you will, Exhibit A, and it looks like the powers and duties paragraph originally had it said the commission may and then listed a lot of duties.

2889
04:31:57.356 --> 04:32:04.139
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it looks like y'all changed it to the commission's powers and duties include but are not limited to.

2890
04:32:05.406 --> 04:32:08.371
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm wondering if you can speak to the purpose of that change.

2891
04:32:08.808 --> 04:32:24.038
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I ask that question from a position of, uh, I think that some commissions and advisory councils and you-name-it type of committees have at times grown their own set of legs and run in a way that is a little bit rambunctious.

2892
04:32:24.088 --> 04:32:24.156
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

2893
04:32:24.916 --> 04:32:26.953
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm curious about your thoughts here.

2894
04:32:27.578 --> 04:32:32.438
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say that also because there is another point where this commission will establish their own bylaws.

2895
04:32:33.288 --> 04:32:38.435
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I was hoping you might be able to— if there was any discussion at committee about that amendment that was made to the document.

2896
04:32:39.782 --> 04:32:44.192
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm going to see, would either of you like to respond?

2897
04:32:44.240 --> 04:32:50.415
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know that a lot of the amendments were made based on the robust discussion had, and you all were part of that.

2898
04:32:51.679 --> 04:32:52.309
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, good evening.

2899
04:32:52.406 --> 04:32:55.174
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, Vivian Satterfield, Chief Sustainability Officer.

2900
04:32:55.400 --> 04:32:58.459
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, pardon, this hour is usually not my best for my finest thinking.

2901
04:32:59.360 --> 04:33:17.115
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, to recall, um, to recall, uh, the commission's powers and duties will be— the, the commission, uh, advises the mayor, city council, and city administrator, but the agenda, uh, is ultimately set by, um, in working with me.

2902
04:33:17.873 --> 04:33:21.816
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and so So to the question of the striking of the may—.

2903
04:33:23.395 --> 04:33:36.488
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's more to the point of adding but not limited to that is giving me concern because I think that the best practice would be to define the role of the committees and not write a blank check.

2904
04:33:36.729 --> 04:33:42.515
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm trying to understand if there was a reason to this or if it was a politeness in our current form of English.

2905
04:33:44.819 --> 04:33:48.738
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I cannot recall precisely without looking at further notes from that time.

2906
04:33:48.802 --> 04:33:49.580
<v Unidentified speaker>I apologize.

2907
04:33:49.936 --> 04:33:50.455
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's okay.

2908
04:33:52.503 --> 04:33:58.870
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate it because it kind of sounds like something we say, but we don't necessarily understand always what the meaning of it is.

2909
04:33:59.307 --> 04:34:06.353
<v Eric Zimmerman>But it is giving me a little bit of pause, Chair, and I'm just— if there are strong feelings about it, I would welcome hearing those.

2910
04:34:08.039 --> 04:34:14.349
<v Eric Zimmerman>But given the other one, and I'm not sure if this question will go to Robert Taylor, and I'm saying his name So he knows I'm about to ask him a question.

2911
04:34:15.010 --> 04:34:27.918
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, but, uh, do most of our commissions, committees, advisory panels, etc., write their own bylaws as members, or do we provide those to those organizations when we create them?

2912
04:34:30.899 --> 04:34:31.512
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor.

2913
04:34:31.562 --> 04:34:32.950
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, Robert Taylor.

2914
04:34:33.241 --> 04:34:34.419
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, it's 10:30 at night.

2915
04:34:34.468 --> 04:34:35.566
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's past my bedtime.

2916
04:34:35.664 --> 04:34:36.003
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree.

2917
04:34:36.099 --> 04:34:39.006
<v Eric Zimmerman>So it's going to— I'm going to do my best to answer that question.

2918
04:34:41.514 --> 04:34:45.020
<v Steve Novick>They do.

2919
04:34:45.776 --> 04:35:00.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>The Office of Community and Civic Life has template bylaws that we give to them to try to help guide, but they have the ability, I think, usually to make adjustments to that to help guide their work.

2920
04:35:00.835 --> 04:35:03.348
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks for that clarification.

2921
04:35:03.431 --> 04:35:03.838
<v Eric Zimmerman>That was helpful.

2922
04:35:06.065 --> 04:35:08.813
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor, if I may, Vivian Satterfield, CSO.

2923
04:35:09.761 --> 04:35:13.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Looking back at the notes, this was a direct suggestion as a result of public comment.

2924
04:35:13.601 --> 04:35:35.090
<v Unidentified speaker>A member of the GTAC committee did offer public comment and suggested that the original language, the commission may, was a rather narrow reading, that that was all they could do, and suggested that we add this additional language so it could reflect that the other duties could be vested by, and in this case it would be myself since there the commission would be directly attached to my position.

2925
04:35:35.555 --> 04:35:39.208
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's from a member of the public.

2926
04:35:39.289 --> 04:35:39.721
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's helpful.

2927
04:35:39.769 --> 04:35:42.526
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for looking it up on the fly, not knowing that question was coming.

2928
04:35:43.055 --> 04:35:50.346
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I think that this council is who vests duties, and so I'm not particularly comfortable with that train of thought.

2929
04:35:50.441 --> 04:36:11.769
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think I understand where it looks like this kind of came from a GTEC side of things, but I just, I do have I have a lot of concerns in how we use our volunteer commissions and keeping the scope of work within the scope of work and not in a world where I think mission creep has really defined so much of Portland civic engagement.

2930
04:36:11.865 --> 04:36:27.496
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm not a big fan of that first sentence on powers and duties, and I think what would be good for us to actually ensure that only this body gives duties and powers to the, to the groups who advise us, uh, and not, not individual staff members.

2931
04:36:28.011 --> 04:36:29.716
<v Eric Zimmerman>But, uh, that's it for my comments.

2932
04:36:29.780 --> 04:36:30.006
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

2933
04:36:34.763 --> 04:36:38.757
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to say ditto, ditto, ditto to what Councilor Zimmerman just said.

2934
04:36:40.412 --> 04:36:41.411
<v Loretta Smith>And let's take a vote.

2935
04:36:44.004 --> 04:36:47.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are you calling the question, or shall we continue with the discussion in the queue?

2936
04:36:54.922 --> 04:37:05.179
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, first I'd like to point out that, um, in a previous agenda item we were told that the people who weren't on the committee can't ask the questions, and, and evidently, um, that's not going to be applied, uh, equally.

2937
04:37:05.292 --> 04:37:10.100
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's, uh, something concerning to me, um, because that, that was told in an earlier item.

2938
04:37:10.278 --> 04:37:12.344
<v Sameer Kanal>Having said that, I actually agree with Councilor Zimmerman.

2939
04:37:12.393 --> 04:37:19.866
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we should be evaluating things here Sure, I completely agree with all of your points actually on the question around the powers and duties.

2940
04:37:21.011 --> 04:37:23.383
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm glad that we're having this conversation here.

2941
04:37:24.400 --> 04:37:31.491
<v Sameer Kanal>So with that said, I did propose an amendment to this and I will formally propose it here.

2942
04:37:32.332 --> 04:37:39.686
<v Sameer Kanal>It strikes 3 words, a maximum of, under 3.136020, Members and Terms, Part A, first line.

2943
04:37:39.750 --> 04:37:39.974
<v Eric Zimmerman>Second.

2944
04:37:40.448 --> 04:37:48.400
<v Sameer Kanal>So it would change it from the commission consists of a maximum of 20 active members to the commission consists of 20 active members.

2945
04:37:48.915 --> 04:37:53.100
<v Sameer Kanal>And although I am proposing that one amendment, I'm very open if there's any others that anyone would like to.

2946
04:37:53.166 --> 04:37:55.098
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm very happy to hear them and discuss them.

2947
04:37:55.837 --> 04:37:57.609
<v Sameer Kanal>That's our job, and I'm very happy to do it.

2948
04:38:01.015 --> 04:38:02.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe that was a proposed amendment.

2949
04:38:03.105 --> 04:38:03.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a second?

2950
04:38:04.402 --> 04:38:04.564
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

2951
04:38:06.289 --> 04:38:09.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, that moves us into discussion on the amendment.

2952
04:38:10.096 --> 04:38:11.870
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are a number of hands in the queue.

2953
04:38:15.100 --> 04:38:17.317
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, is your hand up from your previous comment?

2954
04:38:17.609 --> 04:38:17.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2955
04:38:18.240 --> 04:38:23.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, are you in the queue to speak to this amendment or for when we come back to the underlying ordinance?

2956
04:38:24.562 --> 04:38:26.952
<v Unidentified speaker>My point can straddle both of the items.

2957
04:38:27.048 --> 04:38:27.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

2958
04:38:27.630 --> 04:38:30.066
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll just speak to the amendment.

2959
04:38:30.197 --> 04:38:32.117
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't have an issue with the amendment.

2960
04:38:34.058 --> 04:38:35.778
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it's good to strike maximum.

2961
04:38:35.923 --> 04:38:40.957
<v Unidentified speaker>Makes it clear that we should try to target having a set number of active members.

2962
04:38:43.240 --> 04:38:45.511
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to speak to Councilor Zimmerman's concern.

2963
04:38:45.592 --> 04:38:57.093
<v Unidentified speaker>I actually think, I actually think a committee is an extension of the administrative side of our government, and it— this committee would report to the Chief Sustainability Officer.

2964
04:38:57.806 --> 04:39:01.987
<v Unidentified speaker>And while we We legislate by creating code changes and ordinances.

2965
04:39:02.966 --> 04:39:06.673
<v Unidentified speaker>What's left is to be established through administrative rule setting.

2966
04:39:06.738 --> 04:39:23.690
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I see this as a sort of— this relationship between saying here are the powers enumerated, duties enumerated, but they are not limited to— provides discretion for the bylaws to be adaptable in relation to the Chief Sustainability Officer.

2967
04:39:23.755 --> 04:39:25.070
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that's entirely appropriate.

2968
04:39:25.312 --> 04:39:25.423
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2969
04:39:25.746 --> 04:39:27.405
<v Unidentified speaker>With the delegation of powers in our government.

2970
04:39:27.840 --> 04:39:28.033
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2971
04:39:28.098 --> 04:39:32.204
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2972
04:39:32.283 --> 04:39:33.234
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane.

2973
04:39:34.056 --> 04:39:35.344
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I would like to speak to the amendment.

2974
04:39:35.890 --> 04:39:46.172
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I would also like to point everyone to number 9 in the, um, proposed ordinance.

2975
04:39:47.415 --> 04:39:50.949
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So it is clear that we need to work on these advisory bodies.

2976
04:39:51.402 --> 04:40:08.751
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You all know this is something that we're talking about in governance, and that is why we added as number 9 that on March 31st, 2025, we actually had folks from the Office of Community and Civic Life come and present to us about their— the plan that we're working on with them.

2977
04:40:08.991 --> 04:40:15.544
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Well, they're working on it and they will be including us to align and streamline, modernize all of these bodies.

2978
04:40:16.605 --> 04:40:26.209
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Part of why I feel comfortable not not having it say exactly 20, or, um, they're being a little— it being a little bit squishy.

2979
04:40:26.787 --> 04:40:36.626
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I hear what you're saying, Councilor Zimmerman, is because this specifically outlines that this commission will be subject to this project, at which the point of it is to have some streamlining.

2980
04:40:36.977 --> 04:40:46.931
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I've actually talked to these 2 people quite a bit and know that, um, having 20 might be a stretch, that there's also a plan to have a lot of seats on here.

2981
04:40:47.541 --> 04:40:58.074
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so there is some worry about having it say exactly 20 in case, you know, youth might be a little— have their lives in flux a little bit.

2982
04:40:58.459 --> 04:41:08.768
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And the desire to not be out of compliance just because a couple people are not on this commission is something that I heard from them about wanting to be realistic.

2983
04:41:08.848 --> 04:41:10.437
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I will not be supporting this amendment.

2984
04:41:10.518 --> 04:41:13.245
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Thank you, Councilor.

2985
04:41:13.311 --> 04:41:15.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, are you in the queue to speak to the amendment?

2986
04:41:15.796 --> 04:41:27.027
<v Steve Novick>Yes, I actually was just going to say basically what the Vice President just said, that I'd be worried that if we say exactly 20, that might suggest that the commission can't meet unless it has exactly 20 people.

2987
04:41:27.465 --> 04:41:28.567
<v Steve Novick>But maybe I'm just being paranoid.

2988
04:41:33.052 --> 04:41:35.579
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, are you in the queue to speak to the amendment?

2989
04:41:36.064 --> 04:41:46.652
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, I will ditto being paranoid, and that's why I supported the suggestion from GTAC, um, to make sure that we gave enough flexibility so they could start operating and move forward.

2990
04:41:46.895 --> 04:41:51.486
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm really proud of how well they're doing on their recruitment, and it's going to be a great commission.

2991
04:41:52.316 --> 04:41:53.685
<v Unidentified speaker>I will not support the amendment.

2992
04:41:55.639 --> 04:41:57.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, we are back to you.

2993
04:41:57.603 --> 04:41:57.845
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2994
04:41:58.585 --> 04:41:59.744
<v Sameer Kanal>So a couple things.

2995
04:42:00.244 --> 04:42:08.861
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, first off, there are— I found at least 10 other groups that have volunteers on them in city code This is required, by the way.

2996
04:42:09.119 --> 04:42:21.594
<v Sameer Kanal>We, the city council previous in 2017, passed Resolution 37328, which says that the category of advisory groups that include all those required by city code, charter, or state law have a set number of seats/members.

2997
04:42:24.013 --> 04:42:29.064
<v Sameer Kanal>When I looked in the code, the Citizen Review Committee, it says the committee will consist of 11 citizens.

2998
04:42:29.662 --> 04:42:34.312
<v Sameer Kanal>The code that creates the Community Board for Police Accountability, the CBPA, shall shall consist of 21 members.

2999
04:42:34.490 --> 04:42:37.442
<v Sameer Kanal>Water Quality Advisory Committee, committee consists of 9 members.

3000
04:42:38.116 --> 04:42:40.973
<v Sameer Kanal>Public Utility Board, board will have 11 permanent members.

3001
04:42:42.031 --> 04:42:44.183
<v Sameer Kanal>The Urban Forestry Commission consists of 11 members.

3002
04:42:44.759 --> 04:42:49.478
<v Sameer Kanal>The New Portlanders Policy Commission will consist of 25 voting members.

3003
04:42:50.087 --> 04:42:53.891
<v Sameer Kanal>There are— vast majority of them have a set number.

3004
04:42:54.325 --> 04:43:04.366
<v Sameer Kanal>In none of those cases, uh, have they ever said, oh, it says 11 people on the Citizen Review Committee, That has never been the interpretation.

3005
04:43:04.415 --> 04:43:09.416
<v Sameer Kanal>I think Robert— or actually, sorry, Heidi, if you're still here, to put you on the spot from the City Attorney's Office.

3006
04:43:09.479 --> 04:43:25.143
<v Sameer Kanal>But having read the entire public meetings manual and having brought 20-plus appointments to City of Portland advisory groups to this dais on that side, I know that it does not actually create that concern.

3007
04:43:25.190 --> 04:43:25.447
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

3008
04:43:27.198 --> 04:43:41.223
<v Sameer Kanal>What I noticed when I read the notes and heard the conversation at governance is that originally this was proposed as setting the number between 10 and 20, and that the conversation there was to— that that was too broad of a range.

3009
04:43:42.220 --> 04:44:01.813
<v Sameer Kanal>By removing the lower end, that 10, and saying a maximum of, although it does not say a minimum number in any way, there is actually, if you read the rest of that section, A minimum of eight because it says four are reserved for youth that can overlap with the membership must include at least two individuals from each of the city's four council districts.

3010
04:44:02.135 --> 04:44:07.755
<v Sameer Kanal>So it actually has created a broader range, changing from ten to twenty to a maximum of twenty.

3011
04:44:09.023 --> 04:44:18.223
<v Sameer Kanal>I can also say that recruiting youth, if if one focuses on it, and by the way, we're not talking about the resolution that's kind of come forward, but I'll just preview my my statement that they did.

3012
04:44:18.319 --> 04:44:21.532
<v Sameer Kanal>They did such a fantastic job at recruitment for this.

3013
04:44:22.272 --> 04:44:25.983
<v Sameer Kanal>It rivals only the Charter Commission in terms of how well they did recruiting it.

3014
04:44:26.383 --> 04:44:30.272
<v Sameer Kanal>And as long as we are doing our job, there's 630,000 Portlanders out there.

3015
04:44:30.722 --> 04:44:31.492
<v Sameer Kanal>We can find 20.

3016
04:44:31.686 --> 04:44:33.259
<v Sameer Kanal>We can find a hell of a lot more than 20.

3017
04:44:33.758 --> 04:44:37.886
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I am not concerned that they will fail to meet this.

3018
04:44:37.951 --> 04:44:45.067
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not concerned that anybody that actually has the necessary support to do this work would ever fail to meet a number as small as 20.

3019
04:44:45.211 --> 04:44:45.388
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

3020
04:44:46.307 --> 04:44:46.852
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

3021
04:44:47.287 --> 04:44:49.568
<v Sameer Kanal>And so that's the sort of clarification.

3022
04:44:50.340 --> 04:44:56.093
<v Sameer Kanal>No other city code-defined volunteer group has a maximum clause without a minimum clause.

3023
04:44:56.205 --> 04:45:00.491
<v Sameer Kanal>They either have a range or they have a number.

3024
04:45:00.941 --> 04:45:04.794
<v Sameer Kanal>And the ranges, there are only 2 that do, and they're very narrow ranges.

3025
04:45:07.091 --> 04:45:13.544
<v Sameer Kanal>I mentioned the resolution that requires this, which is part of what establishes best practices for advisory committees.

3026
04:45:14.152 --> 04:45:17.252
<v Sameer Kanal>It allows for staff to predict the size and nature of their conversations.

3027
04:45:17.299 --> 04:45:22.808
<v Sameer Kanal>As we all know, a group of 5 is very different than a group of 12 in how the dynamics of that conversation go.

3028
04:45:23.208 --> 04:45:25.698
<v Sameer Kanal>As you can imagine, 8 and 20 are very different from each other.

3029
04:45:26.276 --> 04:45:34.866
<v Sameer Kanal>And finally, it gives certainty to the public that there will be a dynamic representative SCC because it shows that the city will commit to trying to achieve 20.

3030
04:45:34.947 --> 04:45:38.815
<v Sameer Kanal>And if a person resigns and there's 19, it can keep going while we strive to achieve 20.

3031
04:45:38.880 --> 04:45:39.088
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

3032
04:45:41.010 --> 04:45:44.031
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is something we've done for hundreds of advisory groups.

3033
04:45:45.109 --> 04:45:49.722
<v Sameer Kanal>They're only the ones mentioned in city code that I went through, and I won't bore you with the rest, so I will stop here.

3034
04:45:50.270 --> 04:45:51.866
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

3035
04:45:53.798 --> 04:45:56.523
<v Eric Zimmerman>Mine is for after the amendment is voted on.

3036
04:45:58.450 --> 04:46:04.916
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, could you please call the roll on the amendment?

3037
04:46:07.459 --> 04:46:07.475
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

3038
04:46:07.880 --> 04:46:08.106
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

3039
04:46:09.190 --> 04:46:09.449
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No.

3040
04:46:10.630 --> 04:46:11.098
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

3041
04:46:11.616 --> 04:46:11.762
<v Loretta Smith>No.

3042
04:46:12.425 --> 04:46:13.606
<v Loretta Smith>Morillo.

3043
04:46:14.512 --> 04:46:14.610
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

3044
04:46:16.207 --> 04:46:22.531
<v Steve Novick>I appreciate Councilor Knoll's knowledge and his, um, solving my paranoia.

3045
04:46:22.854 --> 04:46:30.513
<v Steve Novick>I also have made a personal commitment that I will strive to vote with Councilor Knoll and against Councilor Zimmerman as often as I vote with Councilor Zimmerman and against Councilor Knoll.

3046
04:46:31.034 --> 04:46:33.167
<v Steve Novick>Since I've already done the opposite today, I vote yes.

3047
04:46:34.426 --> 04:46:34.847
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

3048
04:46:35.412 --> 04:46:35.653
<v Loretta Smith>No.

3049
04:46:36.849 --> 04:46:37.139
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

3050
04:46:37.656 --> 04:46:37.996
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

3051
04:46:39.159 --> 04:46:39.483
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

3052
04:46:40.583 --> 04:46:40.745
<v Loretta Smith>Nope.

3053
04:46:40.955 --> 04:46:41.263
<v Angelita Morillo>Avalos?

3054
04:46:43.869 --> 04:46:44.549
<v Candace Avalos>My vote is yes.

3055
04:46:44.614 --> 04:46:45.763
<v Candace Avalos>I'm actually kind of surprised.

3056
04:46:45.812 --> 04:46:48.028
<v Candace Avalos>This seems pretty obvious of a change that we should make.

3057
04:46:48.126 --> 04:46:48.561
<v Candace Avalos>So yeah.

3058
04:46:49.383 --> 04:46:49.754
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

3059
04:46:50.027 --> 04:46:50.222
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

3060
04:46:51.172 --> 04:46:51.608
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

3061
04:46:52.431 --> 04:46:52.705
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

3062
04:47:07.213 --> 04:47:07.311
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

3063
04:47:07.812 --> 04:47:12.401
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is split vote and the motion fails.

3064
04:47:14.369 --> 04:47:16.776
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was worried that's what was happening there again.

3065
04:47:19.666 --> 04:47:23.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, you are in the queue for the underlying Thanks.

3066
04:47:23.549 --> 04:47:26.258
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I was looking at the financial impact.

3067
04:47:26.979 --> 04:47:33.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are you able to describe— so it looks like PCF funding is being used for staffing here and some commission work.

3068
04:47:33.473 --> 04:47:33.826
<v Eric Zimmerman>What is that?

3069
04:47:34.177 --> 04:47:34.932
<v Eric Zimmerman>What are you envisioning there?

3070
04:47:34.995 --> 04:47:44.631
<v Eric Zimmerman>It looks like $450,000 of PCF funds will be used for this program, I guess inside Civic Life or inside Sustainability.

3071
04:47:45.495 --> 04:47:46.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for the question, Councilor Zimmerman.

3072
04:47:47.164 --> 04:47:56.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My position as a result of an ordinance that was passed by the prior city council, moved me from the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability to the city administrator's office, myself.

3073
04:47:56.378 --> 04:48:00.047
<v Unidentified speaker>And this is Elaine Viska-Livingstone, the Sustainability and Climate Commission coordinator.

3074
04:48:01.121 --> 04:48:04.615
<v Unidentified speaker>Those resources are for the 2 of our positions and our associated resources.

3075
04:48:05.688 --> 04:48:19.068
<v Unidentified speaker>The— for the sustainability and— for the— I'm sorry, the Sustainability and Climate Commission, we have been proactive and actually secured some outside resources through some grant funding through My Memorial Trust for the first year of its operations.

3076
04:48:19.182 --> 04:48:21.809
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But the PSF funding specifically is for our 2 positions.

3077
04:48:22.002 --> 04:48:22.872
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, that's helpful.

3078
04:48:24.349 --> 04:48:31.324
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, Mr. Jordan, off the top of your head, do you know how much of the city administrator's team is supported by PSF funds?

3079
04:48:34.834 --> 04:48:36.715
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't off the top of my head, but I would—.

3080
04:48:36.812 --> 04:48:37.843
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is it more than just those 2?

3081
04:48:37.957 --> 04:48:41.361
<v Unidentified speaker>I would suspect that it's not Much more than just those 2, if it's any more.

3082
04:48:41.747 --> 04:48:42.490
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks.

3083
04:48:46.330 --> 04:48:46.605
<v Keelan McClymont>Yep.

3084
04:48:50.111 --> 04:48:53.890
<v Sameer Kanal>My question, I guess, 2-part, and it's sort of rhetorical to all colleagues.

3085
04:48:54.067 --> 04:48:59.707
<v Sameer Kanal>One is, is there anything that we're trying to do with relation to clarifying around the powers and duties?

3086
04:49:00.145 --> 04:49:06.434
<v Sameer Kanal>And the second thing is, are we comfortable with it still being 8 to 20, even if it's not a hard number.

3087
04:49:07.115 --> 04:49:09.403
<v Sameer Kanal>Just asking the question if anyone wants to comment on it.

3088
04:49:09.728 --> 04:49:10.686
<v Sameer Kanal>If not, I understand.

3089
04:49:15.546 --> 04:49:18.073
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, I saw that you were in the queue, but you're not now.

3090
04:49:18.154 --> 04:49:19.361
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Did you have comments to make?

3091
04:49:20.709 --> 04:49:32.959
<v Loretta Smith>Well, yeah, I, I do, and I feel like we're in a constitutional crisis once again, and we really need to settle this because this is not going This is not going to go away.

3092
04:49:34.540 --> 04:49:47.270
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, I briefly mentioned before that there had been some conversations about expanding upon what's written around the duties of the mayor to break tie votes.

3093
04:49:47.439 --> 04:49:55.880
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think this could be an opportunity for us to look to the chair of our Governance Committee and ask that that be added to the list of things that governance takes up in the coming weeks.

3094
04:49:57.709 --> 04:49:58.532
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Was that a thumbs up?

3095
04:49:58.855 --> 04:49:59.503
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>2 Thumbs up.

3096
04:49:59.744 --> 04:50:00.083
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

3097
04:50:02.086 --> 04:50:02.635
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

3098
04:50:04.591 --> 04:50:05.237
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Madam President.

3099
04:50:05.317 --> 04:50:09.594
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to entertain the rhetorical question offered, presented by Councilor Kanal.

3100
04:50:10.365 --> 04:50:15.848
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, I supported the amendment because I think it's better to specify the number, and I think it's more consistent.

3101
04:50:16.156 --> 04:50:16.935
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendment failed.

3102
04:50:17.632 --> 04:50:42.891
<v Unidentified speaker>So in this situation, what I'm going to hope to lean on is the fact that the amendment Is that this did go through a pretty robust public process, that the bylaws section of this is an opportunity to clarify how we deal with our, you know, prioritizing the work of the committee and also the Chief Sustainability Officer and ensuring that we're always seeking to be as close to 20 as possible.

3103
04:50:43.037 --> 04:50:47.244
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's— I don't know if that's satisfactory, but that's how I'm thinking about it right now.

3104
04:50:47.294 --> 04:50:47.438
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

3105
04:50:49.654 --> 04:50:52.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, would you like to respond?

3106
04:50:52.602 --> 04:50:53.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thank you.

3107
04:50:53.243 --> 04:50:55.279
<v Sameer Kanal>The, the latter is definitely satisfactory.

3108
04:50:55.887 --> 04:51:06.769
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I— there is a, a lot of research that's been done around and, and, and, uh, conversations including at this dais about why it's not a good idea to have it be clarified in the bylaws.

3109
04:51:07.346 --> 04:51:13.034
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, most notably, you fill it to 20 people, they amend the bylaws to make it 19, force someone to get kicked out.

3110
04:51:13.275 --> 04:51:13.852
<v Sameer Kanal>That has happened.

3111
04:51:14.078 --> 04:51:33.000
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, so, uh, that— I'm not suggesting that would happen here, but, uh, I, I do think that having it be clarified outside of it— and this kind of goes back to, I think, uh, Councilor Zimmerman's original question around, um, the sort of distinction between a, a committee charter, which can, um, be the code, uh, and the bylaws.

3112
04:51:33.434 --> 04:51:40.109
<v Sameer Kanal>The distinction is effectively what, what we think should be within the realm of the members, the volunteers Yes.

3113
04:51:40.333 --> 04:51:42.595
<v Sameer Kanal>Authority to change on their own versus not.

3114
04:51:42.979 --> 04:51:48.914
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I definitely agree with the second part of that.

3115
04:51:49.074 --> 04:52:00.797
<v Sameer Kanal>And I know that in our conversations around this particular briefing that the CSO and team are, which by the way, this is the team as I understand it, and we should fix that at some point.

3116
04:52:00.862 --> 04:52:13.942
<v Sameer Kanal>But the CSO and team wanting to To— And committing to achieving that number is something I do think is worth relying on, at least until we can figure this out in code.

3117
04:52:14.408 --> 04:52:19.514
<v Sameer Kanal>I will say that the advisory body's restructuring project is something I served on last year.

3118
04:52:19.804 --> 04:52:25.712
<v Sameer Kanal>We're in, I think, the 5th iteration of it at this point, and it cannot change code.

3119
04:52:26.209 --> 04:52:27.510
<v Sameer Kanal>Only council can change code.

3120
04:52:27.831 --> 04:52:30.417
<v Sameer Kanal>So at some point, we will be deciding on this again.

3121
04:52:31.020 --> 04:52:33.518
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and that's just an important thing for us all to keep in mind.

3122
04:52:33.792 --> 04:52:34.081
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

3123
04:52:37.096 --> 04:52:39.029
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I don't see anybody else in the queue.

3124
04:52:39.111 --> 04:52:48.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We did have a few people hint at other changes they might want to make, so I'm just giving us a few seconds here in case anybody else wants to get in the queue to propose additional amendments.

3125
04:52:52.130 --> 04:53:12.926
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Otherwise, Keelan, I think we could call the roll on the, um, Point of order.

3126
04:53:14.364 --> 04:53:16.492
<v Sameer Kanal>Is this a— this is not a first reading?

3127
04:53:18.077 --> 04:53:18.949
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, it is a first reading.

3128
04:53:19.691 --> 04:53:23.616
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I— you know what, we just went through so many emergency ordinances that I was just on a roll.

3129
04:53:23.890 --> 04:53:24.278
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

3130
04:53:24.380 --> 04:53:26.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That is my mistake.

3131
04:53:28.024 --> 04:53:29.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

3132
04:53:30.737 --> 04:53:33.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I got caught up in our role with emergency ordinances.

3133
04:53:34.108 --> 04:53:42.681
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is not an emergency ordinance, so this will move to the second reading calendar at our next council meeting.

3134
04:53:43.917 --> 04:53:45.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we are nearing 11 o'clock.

3135
04:53:46.902 --> 04:53:52.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next agenda item I suspect is going to take a little bit more time.

3136
04:53:52.827 --> 04:53:58.168
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was originally scheduled as a short agenda item, but since then we've had some folks raise concerns.

3137
04:54:00.394 --> 04:54:03.585
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, do you all want to keep going, or should we let our staff go home?

3138
04:54:03.779 --> 04:54:05.043
<v Loretta Smith>Just go, just keep going.

3139
04:54:07.259 --> 04:54:11.276
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hold on, Councilor Smith, I'm looking at some faces saying different things.

3140
04:54:12.848 --> 04:54:14.415
<v Steve Novick>Even Spinal Tap only went to 11.

3141
04:54:15.820 --> 04:54:24.242
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can I Can I get a thumbs— well, actually, let me say this first.

3142
04:54:26.659 --> 04:54:34.568
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can choose to continue our conversation at a special meeting.

3143
04:54:35.168 --> 04:54:44.087
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To schedule a special meeting, we need 7 councilors to sign a request to the auditor for a date that has not been previously scheduled.

3144
04:54:44.248 --> 04:54:44.879
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

3145
04:54:46.683 --> 04:54:53.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to have time if we're going to move things to talk to the clerk about the best time to do that.

3146
04:54:53.429 --> 04:55:03.894
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I would suggest that if we don't get through our whole agenda today, um, folks allow me until Friday to get you a proposal for a special meeting for sometime next week.

3147
04:55:04.454 --> 04:55:17.133
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, but that Friday I would ask for an additional 6 of you to sign on to something with me to schedule that so we do have a means Councilor Clark.

3148
04:55:17.375 --> 04:55:22.568
<v Unidentified speaker>Don't we have an extra week, uh, some time on the week of the— is the 28th?

3149
04:55:22.633 --> 04:55:22.877
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do.

3150
04:55:23.038 --> 04:55:28.219
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have an extra week this month, so we could do that as well, and that might be easier for our staff.

3151
04:55:28.543 --> 04:55:36.102
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, but Councilor Clark, don't forget that week a lot of us are going to be at that conference, the League of Cities conference.

3152
04:55:37.468 --> 04:55:38.542
<v Candace Avalos>So just FYI, because I know—.

3153
04:55:38.558 --> 04:55:42.370
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll check with— I'll check with people's schedules and check with the clerk if we need to do that.

3154
04:55:42.883 --> 04:55:45.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are folks in the queue to discuss this?

3155
04:55:45.544 --> 04:55:46.312
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

3156
04:55:47.307 --> 04:55:52.130
<v Eric Zimmerman>Madam President, I would move to suspend the remainder of this agenda to a future date.

3157
04:55:52.354 --> 04:55:56.568
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would also move that this body start seriously considering meeting weekly.

3158
04:55:57.626 --> 04:56:03.539
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is the 4th month in a row where we have something we're going to— these are important items that are coming up, very important items.

3159
04:56:04.277 --> 04:56:07.135
<v Eric Zimmerman>They deserve people who are engaged.

3160
04:56:07.584 --> 04:56:08.629
<v Eric Zimmerman>It is 11 o'clock.

3161
04:56:08.790 --> 04:56:10.426
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is becoming deeply unserious.

3162
04:56:10.619 --> 04:56:11.566
<v Eric Zimmerman>We continue to do this.

3163
04:56:12.867 --> 04:56:15.564
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is the largest city in the city— in the state of Oregon.

3164
04:56:16.174 --> 04:56:17.026
<v Eric Zimmerman>We should be meeting.

3165
04:56:17.380 --> 04:56:19.274
<v Eric Zimmerman>I do not care what GTAC or anybody said.

3166
04:56:19.546 --> 04:56:28.828
<v Eric Zimmerman>We should be meeting as a council every week, and nighttime meetings should be minimized to items that do not get protracted into long debates as this is.

3167
04:56:29.276 --> 04:56:35.193
<v Eric Zimmerman>So So again, I will move that we suspend the remainder of this agenda until a future meeting so they get the time they deserve.

3168
04:56:36.930 --> 04:56:38.536
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a second to that motion or not?

3169
04:56:39.072 --> 04:56:42.448
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll second it, though I don't agree with all the analysis, but I agree with all the proposals.

3170
04:56:45.290 --> 04:56:46.500
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Whereases and therefores.

3171
04:56:48.866 --> 04:56:51.873
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, councilors, any discussion, or should we move to discussion?

3172
04:56:55.069 --> 04:56:55.653
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green?

3173
04:56:55.754 --> 04:56:56.405
<v Loretta Smith>Are we going to take a vote?

3174
04:56:57.584 --> 04:57:00.422
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will ask for unanimous consent once we get through discussion.

3175
04:57:02.069 --> 04:57:02.183
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

3176
04:57:02.263 --> 04:57:02.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green?

3177
04:57:02.651 --> 04:57:11.937
<v Unidentified speaker>Briefly, I'm going to agree that there is no way we can take up these items in any reasonable measure at this hour and beyond.

3178
04:57:13.426 --> 04:57:16.991
<v Unidentified speaker>But I, and I agree that we need to have weekly council meetings.

3179
04:57:17.072 --> 04:57:18.789
<v Unidentified speaker>We just need to do what it takes to figure that out.

3180
04:57:18.935 --> 04:57:29.750
<v Unidentified speaker>And then finally, this bonding ordinance, I'll just say, This, this is probably going to create the need for an emergency ordinance by kicking this down the road.

3181
04:57:30.200 --> 04:57:40.688
<v Unidentified speaker>And I only say that because it's a, it's a, it's a strategy for freeing up general fund resources that we're going to need to fund our, our programs in the next fiscal year.

3182
04:57:40.737 --> 04:57:41.780
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's what I'll say.

3183
04:57:42.327 --> 04:57:44.944
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I'm going to support tabling this.

3184
04:57:46.101 --> 04:57:54.629
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I believe if we have an interim meeting this would still be second read at the same meeting that it would be if we did it today.

3185
04:57:54.789 --> 04:57:57.052
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we wouldn't need to move to an emergency ordinance.

3186
04:57:57.598 --> 04:58:01.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if instead we bumped things to the next agenda, you're right, we likely would.

3187
04:58:02.480 --> 04:58:05.579
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, are you in the queue there?

3188
04:58:05.788 --> 04:58:06.768
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, I am in the queue.

3189
04:58:07.136 --> 04:58:18.829
<v Loretta Smith>I agree that we need to be in a, In a more coherent kind of state.

3190
04:58:20.393 --> 04:58:30.283
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, I can go as long as people can go, but I want people to be— I think people have made their decisions on what they want to do too, in that part.

3191
04:58:30.413 --> 04:58:34.055
<v Loretta Smith>But I think that other folks want to have a conversation, a longer conversation.

3192
04:58:35.362 --> 04:58:40.165
<v Loretta Smith>And I am for that longer conversation, but— Councilor Smith.

3193
04:58:41.049 --> 04:58:45.197
<v Loretta Smith>If we start this, we're, we're, we're probably not going to get finished until about 1 o'clock in the morning.

3194
04:58:48.359 --> 04:58:49.198
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor, that's—.

3195
04:58:49.328 --> 04:58:56.287
<v Loretta Smith>And, and, and I want to be assured that we're going to get this done within the next week because this has been hanging for far too long.

3196
04:58:59.379 --> 04:59:00.120
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

3197
04:59:00.330 --> 04:59:05.432
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I assure you that between the next 2 weeks, um, I will find us a time.

3198
04:59:05.980 --> 04:59:12.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next 2 weeks because that still allows us to put things on the next council agenda for second reading.

3199
04:59:12.613 --> 04:59:15.076
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It won't slow down the final work on these.

3200
04:59:17.486 --> 04:59:22.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, councilors, we have a motion and a second, and I think we can do this by unanimous consent.

3201
04:59:24.297 --> 04:59:24.684
<v Keelan McClymont>Sure.

3202
04:59:24.908 --> 04:59:25.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What do our attorneys think?

3203
04:59:26.919 --> 04:59:38.166
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any objections to— um, I believe this would be This is not— are we ending the meeting and then scheduling a special meeting?

3204
04:59:38.825 --> 04:59:39.290
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it is.

3205
04:59:39.402 --> 04:59:42.083
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we would be adjourning the meeting to schedule a special meeting.

3206
04:59:42.197 --> 04:59:43.223
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any objections?

3207
04:59:44.204 --> 04:59:44.380
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

3208
04:59:45.102 --> 04:59:48.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, without objection, I will adjourn the meeting.

3209
04:59:49.181 --> 04:59:57.225
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, I will get you a proposal by Friday on an additional date to add a special meeting so that we can continue this work.

