WEBVTT

1
00:07:28.129 --> 00:07:29.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning.

2
00:07:29.875 --> 00:07:34.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am going to convene today's council meeting.

3
00:07:34.458 --> 00:07:37.870
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 9:33 on Wednesday, April 2nd.

4
00:07:38.687 --> 00:07:44.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, a note for those of you who were not in the Finance Committee meeting yesterday.

5
00:07:45.271 --> 00:07:48.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is April, which means that our voting order has changed.

6
00:07:49.060 --> 00:07:52.192
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll flag this for folks so you're not caught off guard.

7
00:07:52.336 --> 00:07:55.113
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>District 2 votes first for this next quarter.

8
00:07:55.548 --> 00:07:58.437
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will vote in order 2, 3, 4, 1.

9
00:07:58.839 --> 00:08:02.244
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos, you are off the hook for voting first every time.

10
00:08:02.372 --> 00:08:04.153
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, welcome.

11
00:08:04.845 --> 00:08:06.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good luck.

12
00:08:07.350 --> 00:08:12.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Before we get into— actually, Rebecca, why don't you call the roll and then I'll make a couple of comments.

13
00:08:13.771 --> 00:08:14.141
<v Rebecca Dobert>Good morning.

14
00:08:14.798 --> 00:08:16.146
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Kanal?

15
00:08:16.338 --> 00:08:16.627
<v Sameer Kanal>Present.

16
00:08:16.980 --> 00:08:17.348
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

17
00:08:17.701 --> 00:08:17.925
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

18
00:08:18.343 --> 00:08:18.951
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

19
00:08:20.026 --> 00:08:20.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

20
00:08:20.812 --> 00:08:21.326
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

21
00:08:21.646 --> 00:08:21.742
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

22
00:08:22.175 --> 00:08:22.591
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

23
00:08:22.817 --> 00:08:22.928
<v Steve Novick>Here.

24
00:08:23.298 --> 00:08:23.586
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

25
00:08:24.019 --> 00:08:24.228
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

26
00:08:24.437 --> 00:08:24.805
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

27
00:08:26.120 --> 00:08:26.937
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

28
00:08:27.468 --> 00:08:27.836
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

29
00:08:28.108 --> 00:08:28.221
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

30
00:08:28.831 --> 00:08:29.216
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

31
00:08:29.552 --> 00:08:29.809
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

32
00:08:30.146 --> 00:08:30.499
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

33
00:08:30.834 --> 00:08:30.963
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

34
00:08:31.267 --> 00:08:31.620
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

35
00:08:32.038 --> 00:08:32.198
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

36
00:08:32.599 --> 00:08:33.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

37
00:08:34.123 --> 00:08:34.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

38
00:08:35.181 --> 00:08:43.808
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we have a very tight agenda, and I believe over 100 people signed up for public testimony between the various items on our agenda today.

39
00:08:44.907 --> 00:08:51.929
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are not going to get through all of that, and I'll have a note for the public listening on what we will do to make sure we hear from everybody.

40
00:08:51.994 --> 00:08:59.214
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I just want to flag for all of us that the amount of time we take on items directly affects the amount of time we have to hear from the public.

41
00:08:59.961 --> 00:09:09.047
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's important for us to be able to robustly debate items, but if you can say something in 4 words instead of 10 words, today is the day to do that.

42
00:09:09.418 --> 00:09:11.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will try to hold myself to that as well.

43
00:09:12.072 --> 00:09:19.844
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For folks who are here to testify, we are going to get through as much as we can, but there is absolutely no way that we will get to everybody today.

44
00:09:19.988 --> 00:09:22.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In fact, we probably won't get to most of you.

45
00:09:23.048 --> 00:09:25.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will be opening space tomorrow.

46
00:09:26.092 --> 00:09:37.918
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council has an executive meeting from 2 to 3:30, but councilors, I will be asking if at least a quorum of us can be present from 3:30 to 5 tomorrow so that we can open up more time for public testimony.

47
00:09:38.416 --> 00:09:39.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will make sure to be here.

48
00:09:39.650 --> 00:09:42.282
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If 6 of you can join me, I would appreciate that.

49
00:09:42.842 --> 00:09:47.398
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will also make sure that we have time at our next council meeting, which is Wednesday.

50
00:09:47.494 --> 00:09:53.107
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe that is the 16th, to take additional public testimony on these topics.

51
00:09:53.668 --> 00:09:59.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I know that we have other items that have budget implications that we need to be moving forward on the 16th.

52
00:09:59.764 --> 00:10:06.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will have to figure out how we work this all in, but I will make sure that we reserve some time to finish public testimony that day.

53
00:10:06.821 --> 00:10:24.211
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So So if you are here to testify today and we do not get to you, please know that whichever of those 2 times works best for you, tomorrow between 3:30 and 5:00, or Wednesday, I believe that is the 16th, that is an evening meeting, so we will likely get to public testimony around 6:30.

54
00:10:25.125 --> 00:10:31.532
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will make sure to have time for you at whichever of those times works best for you, and we will get to as many people as we can today.

55
00:10:31.644 --> 00:10:31.870
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

56
00:10:33.192 --> 00:10:38.528
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, with that, um, could our attorney please go over the rules of decorum?

57
00:10:42.248 --> 00:10:43.852
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

58
00:10:43.933 --> 00:10:50.174
<v Dan Ryan>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

59
00:10:53.340 --> 00:10:57.013
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

60
00:10:57.706 --> 00:11:02.125
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

61
00:11:02.638 --> 00:11:05.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

62
00:11:05.763 --> 00:11:07.285
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The presiding officer preserves order.

63
00:11:07.381 --> 00:11:16.791
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

64
00:11:17.464 --> 00:11:19.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

65
00:11:20.350 --> 00:11:22.881
<v Dan Ryan>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

66
00:11:23.315 --> 00:11:26.489
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

67
00:11:26.585 --> 00:11:26.825
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

68
00:11:27.244 --> 00:11:30.923
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

69
00:11:31.666 --> 00:11:33.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

70
00:11:34.345 --> 00:11:36.620
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When testifying, state your name for the record.

71
00:11:36.684 --> 00:11:38.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Your address is not necessary.

72
00:11:39.120 --> 00:11:42.169
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

73
00:11:42.735 --> 00:11:46.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

74
00:11:46.591 --> 00:11:46.995
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

75
00:11:49.099 --> 00:11:49.438
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

76
00:11:49.504 --> 00:11:50.894
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do have 2 councilors in the queue.

77
00:11:50.975 --> 00:11:53.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, is your comment something before we continue?

78
00:11:54.302 --> 00:12:04.557
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, when you made the announcement about stretching testimony to additional days and such, I just wanted to put a comment out that I hope we prioritize those that are in person that took the time to be here in person today.

79
00:12:05.198 --> 00:12:10.326
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And unfortunately, I don't know that our current rules allow us to do that, but we can check.

80
00:12:10.870 --> 00:12:11.543
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will find out.

81
00:12:11.672 --> 00:12:17.826
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I have suggested that we think as we talk in governance about our rules about what order we take testimony.

82
00:12:17.889 --> 00:12:20.404
<v Eric Zimmerman>Madam President, I'd be happy to suspend the rules for that.

83
00:12:22.732 --> 00:12:26.057
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can we hold that motion until we get to that part of the agenda, please?

84
00:12:26.506 --> 00:12:27.840
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I hear that you'll want to do that.

85
00:12:28.192 --> 00:12:28.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

86
00:12:29.011 --> 00:12:30.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I didn't know that would all happen.

87
00:12:30.682 --> 00:12:34.167
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, did you have a comment to make before we move on with our agenda?

88
00:12:34.294 --> 00:12:34.471
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

89
00:12:34.535 --> 00:12:37.571
<v Loretta Smith>Are you saying that we're going to reconvene as a council tomorrow afternoon?

90
00:12:37.908 --> 00:12:38.035
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

91
00:12:38.422 --> 00:12:38.566
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

92
00:12:38.647 --> 00:12:51.602
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Tomorrow we have an executive council session from 2 to 3:30, and I will ask that at least a quorum of us are available to convene in a public council session from 3:30 to 5:00 to take additional public testimony.

93
00:12:51.667 --> 00:12:56.567
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll have to end at 5:00 because we have a budget listening session tomorrow at 6:00.

94
00:12:57.145 --> 00:12:57.596
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

95
00:12:59.153 --> 00:12:59.683
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absolutely.

96
00:13:00.022 --> 00:13:05.467
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, councilors, the first item on our agenda is the agenda approval.

97
00:13:05.644 --> 00:13:10.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any requests to amend or reorder the agenda?

98
00:13:10.923 --> 00:13:11.052
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

99
00:13:15.729 --> 00:13:18.628
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing none, I believe we don't need to take a vote then.

100
00:13:18.676 --> 00:13:19.980
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We just move on, is that correct?

101
00:13:20.302 --> 00:13:21.687
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, perfect.

102
00:13:23.056 --> 00:13:29.282
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next up on our agenda is our public communication.

103
00:13:29.394 --> 00:13:31.654
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call the first communication?

104
00:13:34.850 --> 00:13:36.116
<v Rebecca Dobert>Melissa Kostelecki.

105
00:13:40.330 --> 00:13:40.668
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

106
00:13:40.750 --> 00:13:41.980
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being with us today.

107
00:13:42.044 --> 00:13:42.707
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

108
00:13:45.701 --> 00:13:47.125
<v Melissa Kostelecky>Good morning and thank you for your time.

109
00:13:47.547 --> 00:13:48.793
<v Melissa Kostelecky>My name is Melissa Kostelecky.

110
00:13:48.841 --> 00:13:51.518
<v Melissa Kostelecky>I'm a parent of 2 elementary schools in Southeast Portland.

111
00:13:51.663 --> 00:13:55.788
<v Melissa Kostelecky>I'm also a board member of Bike Loud PDX, but I'm here today speaking for myself.

112
00:13:56.501 --> 00:14:01.917
<v Melissa Kostelecky>I want to start by thanking several of you who have brought attention to the need for safer streets for all road users.

113
00:14:02.769 --> 00:14:08.544
<v Melissa Kostelecky>15 months ago, I saw a driver hit a child on a bike in intersection just off the playground in Woodstock Elementary School right here.

114
00:14:09.197 --> 00:14:13.895
<v Melissa Kostelecky>I'm pretty tall, yet even I was just barely able to see over the red car parked here.

115
00:14:14.201 --> 00:14:17.697
<v Melissa Kostelecky>Sorry, I hope you can see it at the intersection, so I knew to stop.

116
00:14:18.114 --> 00:14:21.514
<v Melissa Kostelecky>The boy biking from behind me was not so lucky to be nearly 6 feet tall.

117
00:14:21.658 --> 00:14:26.038
<v Melissa Kostelecky>So as he entered the intersection, he and the driver were unable to see each other and he got hit.

118
00:14:26.919 --> 00:14:31.138
<v Melissa Kostelecky>I reported the incident and the city acted within a few months, which the community was grateful for.

119
00:14:31.650 --> 00:14:37.089
<v Melissa Kostelecky>Unfortunately though, treatments like no parking sign put in proved entirely ineffective, as this photo shows.

120
00:14:37.153 --> 00:14:37.328
<v Melissa Kostelecky>Thank you.

121
00:14:37.442 --> 00:14:43.206
<v Melissa Kostelecky>So in case you can't see it, it's a car parked at the exact same spot where the red car was parked when the boy got hit.

122
00:14:43.864 --> 00:14:47.364
<v Melissa Kostelecky>Every single day at pickup and drop-off, drivers ignore this sign.

123
00:14:47.493 --> 00:14:48.312
<v Melissa Kostelecky>So right here.

124
00:14:48.616 --> 00:14:50.928
<v Melissa Kostelecky>So ultimately, the money the city spent was wasted.

125
00:14:51.971 --> 00:15:03.019
<v Melissa Kostelecky>To make matters worse, I found that in many places, PBOT has installed signs allowing parking right at crosswalks, a violation of Oregon Statute 811.550, prohibiting parking within 20 feet of an intersection.

126
00:15:03.451 --> 00:15:07.995
<v Melissa Kostelecky>There are intersections that PBOT doesn't want to lose parking for residents and businesses.

127
00:15:08.428 --> 00:15:24.802
<v Melissa Kostelecky>For example, on Woodstock, I discovered that a business owner actually had PBOT approach him and ask him if he wanted a 5-minute no park— sorry, 5-minute parking zone right at the corner, specifically where parked cars now regularly block visibility for pedestrians and drivers trying to either cross or turn onto Woodstock Boulevard.

128
00:15:25.605 --> 00:15:26.889
<v Melissa Kostelecky>So I have 2 asks for you today.

129
00:15:27.451 --> 00:15:33.038
<v Melissa Kostelecky>The first is that you introduce code to end this practice of overriding Oregon State Statute 811.550.

130
00:15:33.102 --> 00:15:33.278
<v Melissa Kostelecky>Thank you.

131
00:15:33.631 --> 00:15:41.179
<v Melissa Kostelecky>As much as even I enjoy a nice convenient parking spot when I drive, we can't achieve our Vision Zero goals if we prioritize convenience over safety.

132
00:15:42.028 --> 00:15:52.380
<v Melissa Kostelecky>And second, I know the city has secured some funding for intersection clearance, but the pace that we're moving at is too slow and the funding is woefully inadequate to daylight the nearly 18,000 intersections needing clearance.

133
00:15:52.942 --> 00:16:01.995
<v Melissa Kostelecky>Whatever funding we can scrap together will be wasted if our corners are not hardened with physical barriers like flex posts, planter boxes, bike racks, or even artwork.

134
00:16:02.076 --> 00:16:06.275
<v Melissa Kostelecky>And a benefit here is that these can even enhance the beauty of our neighborhoods and add some unique character.

135
00:16:06.966 --> 00:16:23.605
<v Melissa Kostelecky>So my second ask is that you examine a policy of tactical urbanism similar to programs currently in place like in cities like Atlanta and Nashville, where fast-tracked permits are issued for low-cost pop-up projects like this without the extensive bureaucracy and endless search for funding.

136
00:16:24.038 --> 00:16:26.811
<v Melissa Kostelecky>Projects like this can be done cheaply and quickly by local neighbors.

137
00:16:27.227 --> 00:16:35.163
<v Melissa Kostelecky>The safety effects can be studied and community input can be gathered based on actual physical physical changes that enhance safety and livability rather than conceptual ideas.

138
00:16:36.144 --> 00:16:37.706
<v Melissa Kostelecky>So 3 minutes goes by way too quickly.

139
00:16:37.787 --> 00:16:42.311
<v Melissa Kostelecky>So if any of you are curious about how they're doing this in Atlanta and Nashville, I would love to speak to you about it.

140
00:16:42.585 --> 00:16:43.921
<v Melissa Kostelecky>And I thank you again for your time.

141
00:16:44.934 --> 00:16:47.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here and for bringing solutions to us.

142
00:16:50.679 --> 00:16:51.408
<v Rebecca Dobert>Emily Dumerck.

143
00:16:57.134 --> 00:16:58.542
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for joining us this morning.

144
00:17:03.750 --> 00:17:06.681
<v Emily Dumerck>Good morning, council members, and thank you for the opportunity to speak today.

145
00:17:06.842 --> 00:17:11.077
<v Emily Dumerck>My name is Emily DeMerk, and I'm here today representing Alliance for a Safe Oregon.

146
00:17:11.630 --> 00:17:17.230
<v Emily Dumerck>I urge you to fully fund the Office of Violence Prevention and all funding for community violence intervention.

147
00:17:18.042 --> 00:17:26.144
<v Emily Dumerck>Over the past 5 years, Portland has lost far too many community members to gun tragedies, and public safety remains a top concern for residents.

148
00:17:26.982 --> 00:17:38.807
<v Emily Dumerck>While the ceasefire program and community violence intervention have helped reduce shootings significantly, gun deaths remain well above pre-COVID rates, and the devastation continues to impact our communities.

149
00:17:39.559 --> 00:17:42.731
<v Emily Dumerck>It is critical that we invest more in these proven programs.

150
00:17:43.484 --> 00:17:50.663
<v Emily Dumerck>Research shows that sustained investment in CVI leads to a 20 to 30% reduction in both homicides and shootings.

151
00:17:51.721 --> 00:17:55.037
<v Emily Dumerck>Over the past two years, thanks to initial investments in CVI efforts.

152
00:17:55.150 --> 00:17:56.498
<v Emily Dumerck>We've begun to see a decline.

153
00:17:56.931 --> 00:18:04.329
<v Emily Dumerck>Particularly notable is a 38% decrease in Black gun violence non-fatal shooting victims across Portland.

154
00:18:04.955 --> 00:18:12.080
<v Emily Dumerck>These programs intervene before violence occurs, help prevent retaliation, and provide support for healing after tragedy happens.

155
00:18:13.076 --> 00:18:16.398
<v Emily Dumerck>The cost of gun tragedies to Portland taxpayers is staggering.

156
00:18:16.768 --> 00:18:24.358
<v Emily Dumerck>With an average of 1,000 injury shootings and homicides each year, taxpayers bear a burden of more than $100 million annually.

157
00:18:24.951 --> 00:18:30.755
<v Emily Dumerck>By reducing gun tragedies by just 20%, we could save $20 million every year.

158
00:18:31.684 --> 00:18:36.189
<v Emily Dumerck>Investing in prevention is not just morally right, it is economically sound.

159
00:18:37.055 --> 00:18:49.205
<v Emily Dumerck>To truly make progress, we must fully fund CVI and continue to sustainably ongoing support, particularly for Black, Latino, and tribal communities who are disproportionately affected by gun tragedies.

160
00:18:49.959 --> 00:18:56.338
<v Emily Dumerck>We need to prioritize sustainable funding for these community-based organizations which are already doing the hard work in our neighborhoods.

161
00:18:56.836 --> 00:18:59.101
<v Emily Dumerck>And support their well-being to prevent burnout.

162
00:19:00.048 --> 00:19:02.359
<v Emily Dumerck>Portlanders deserve to feel safe in their communities.

163
00:19:02.778 --> 00:19:06.102
<v Emily Dumerck>To achieve that, we must invest in solutions that we know work.

164
00:19:06.791 --> 00:19:16.473
<v Emily Dumerck>Please fully fund community violence intervention, ceasefire, and the associated funding for community-based organizations based on the street intervention and prevention.

165
00:19:17.244 --> 00:19:21.307
<v Emily Dumerck>Thank you for your time and for your commitment to making Portland a safer place for all of us.

166
00:19:22.771 --> 00:19:23.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

167
00:19:23.422 --> 00:19:24.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks for sharing those thoughts today.

168
00:19:27.750 --> 00:19:31.368
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Rashid Yusufi, and they're joining us online.

169
00:19:32.746 --> 00:19:33.858
<v Rashid Yusufi>Rashid Yusufi, thank you.

170
00:19:34.198 --> 00:19:36.069
<v Rashid Yusufi>Good morning, councilors, and thank you for listening today.

171
00:19:36.150 --> 00:19:37.247
<v Rashid Yusufi>My name is Rashid Yusufi.

172
00:19:37.441 --> 00:19:41.054
<v Rashid Yusufi>I am a District 3 resident, parent to a 1st and 3rd grader, and soccer coach.

173
00:19:41.538 --> 00:19:45.846
<v Rashid Yusufi>One of our weekly highlights for the past year has been riding in our bike bus at Glencoe in Southeast Portland.

174
00:19:46.298 --> 00:19:53.355
<v Rashid Yusufi>Our bike bus captain, Rob Galanakis, inspired me to start riding the kids to school when he noticed how frazzled and stressed I was when I dropped them off at In the car.

175
00:19:54.126 --> 00:19:57.626
<v Rashid Yusufi>I started making the trip by bike and immediately saw the difference in myself and in my kids.

176
00:19:57.964 --> 00:19:59.009
<v Rashid Yusufi>We no longer feared the clock.

177
00:19:59.121 --> 00:20:00.886
<v Rashid Yusufi>My boys arrived calm and ready to learn.

178
00:20:01.272 --> 00:20:07.358
<v Rashid Yusufi>Like most Portland schools, Glencoe struggles with unsafe conditions caused by large numbers of parents who choose to drive directly to school frontage.

179
00:20:07.695 --> 00:20:12.722
<v Rashid Yusufi>And like many schools, we've had PBOT and PPS staff observe these problems and decide to make no changes.

180
00:20:13.076 --> 00:20:19.675
<v Rashid Yusufi>Unfortunately, families that are making the responsible choice to ride or walk knew it was a statistical certainty that someone was going to be injured at Glencoe.

181
00:20:19.740 --> 00:20:19.901
<v Rashid Yusufi>Thank you.

182
00:20:20.205 --> 00:20:27.403
<v Rashid Yusufi>Despite frequent close calls, advocacy, and constructive suggestions from the school community, PBOT and PPS actively chose inaction multiple times.

183
00:20:27.932 --> 00:20:31.138
<v Rashid Yusufi>I'm here because I and my kids are the victims of that statistical certainty.

184
00:20:31.586 --> 00:20:36.925
<v Rashid Yusufi>On Thursday, January 9th, while we were riding legally on the street, a student opened their door directly in front of us.

185
00:20:37.213 --> 00:20:38.288
<v Rashid Yusufi>I slammed into the car door.

186
00:20:38.721 --> 00:20:40.516
<v Rashid Yusufi>Our bike then slammed into a parked car.

187
00:20:40.820 --> 00:20:42.792
<v Rashid Yusufi>My kids hit their heads and scraped their knees.

188
00:20:43.065 --> 00:20:44.075
<v Rashid Yusufi>My hand was broken.

189
00:20:44.171 --> 00:20:46.255
<v Rashid Yusufi>My wife took my oldest kid, Sammy, home.

190
00:20:46.448 --> 00:20:48.148
<v Rashid Yusufi>Since he was too shaken up to attend school.

191
00:20:48.679 --> 00:20:50.973
<v Rashid Yusufi>I went to the hospital and got x-rays and a cast.

192
00:20:51.310 --> 00:20:55.420
<v Rashid Yusufi>I couldn't use my hand for 2 months, threatening my ability to work and my family's livelihood.

193
00:20:55.724 --> 00:21:01.488
<v Rashid Yusufi>Sammy is still traumatized, and while I've gotten him back on a bike, he no longer will bike to school, including on our bike bus.

194
00:21:01.584 --> 00:21:01.856
<v Rashid Yusufi>Thank you.

195
00:21:02.082 --> 00:21:05.483
<v Rashid Yusufi>After this crash, PBOT came out to do another site visit.

196
00:21:05.837 --> 00:21:11.069
<v Rashid Yusufi>I was told by staff, and I quote, Glencoe's traffic circulation seems to be working well and is safe and efficient.

197
00:21:11.310 --> 00:21:14.409
<v Rashid Yusufi>2 months in a cast and a traumatized kid are clear evidence to the contrary.

198
00:21:14.922 --> 00:21:25.473
<v Rashid Yusufi>It is no mystery why we have families unwilling to let their kids walk or ride a few blocks to school while parents drive 5,000-pound boxes of steel through the densest assembly of our most vulnerable community members.

199
00:21:25.891 --> 00:21:36.298
<v Rashid Yusufi>My injury and 3 years of advocacy around this very specific problem gave PBOT a gift-wrapped, gold-plated, best-it-could-possibly-be opportunity to make one of a dozen easy fixes to this dangerous situation.

200
00:21:36.810 --> 00:21:37.435
<v Rashid Yusufi>It was a layup.

201
00:21:37.772 --> 00:21:41.156
<v Rashid Yusufi>Instead, PBOT told me that actually the responsible thing to do is nothing.

202
00:21:41.221 --> 00:21:41.365
<v Rashid Yusufi>Thank you.

203
00:21:41.509 --> 00:21:42.810
<v Rashid Yusufi>Sammy's pain doesn't matter.

204
00:21:43.050 --> 00:21:45.155
<v Rashid Yusufi>The safety of the children is not worth the effort.

205
00:21:45.477 --> 00:21:46.730
<v Rashid Yusufi>It's insulting and degrading.

206
00:21:47.228 --> 00:21:49.780
<v Rashid Yusufi>It isn't representative of the love and hope that I have for this city.

207
00:21:50.519 --> 00:21:55.515
<v Rashid Yusufi>Councilors, I implore you to start taking PBOT to task, to not accept their excuses and the status quo.

208
00:21:56.060 --> 00:22:05.602
<v Rashid Yusufi>This bureau, left to its own devices, is not doing its most basic job of keeping families safe, not out of lack of budget or even lack of will, but evident— but evidently of a learned helplessness.

209
00:22:06.036 --> 00:22:11.480
<v Rashid Yusufi>You encourage us to ride or walk to school, but the people at your bureau come up with every excuse excuse to avoid making that safe.

210
00:22:12.124 --> 00:22:16.960
<v Rashid Yusufi>Even Sammy, just 9 years old, said to me, I can't ride until there's a bike bus in front of our school.

211
00:22:17.361 --> 00:22:19.433
<v Rashid Yusufi>We need more than cheerleading for families that walk and bike.

212
00:22:19.755 --> 00:22:21.012
<v Rashid Yusufi>We need changes to our streets.

213
00:22:21.618 --> 00:22:22.021
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for your time.

214
00:22:24.420 --> 00:22:25.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for sharing that with us.

215
00:22:27.380 --> 00:22:28.103
<v Rebecca Dobert>Justin Leitner.

216
00:22:29.325 --> 00:22:30.114
<v Rebecca Dobert>Justin's online.

217
00:22:31.834 --> 00:22:32.574
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Justin.

218
00:22:32.637 --> 00:22:32.719
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Hi.

219
00:22:33.442 --> 00:22:33.893
<v Rashid Yusufi>Thank you.

220
00:22:34.005 --> 00:22:34.809
<v Justin Leitner>Thank you for having me.

221
00:22:35.806 --> 00:22:44.528
<v Justin Leitner>Um, I am gonna use my time today to speak to you about hopefully fully funding the Multnomah County STI clinic downtown.

222
00:22:45.522 --> 00:22:55.993
<v Justin Leitner>Right now, there is a lot of people that use that service, and it's very helpful in getting, one, lower STI rates throughout the city.

223
00:22:56.508 --> 00:23:13.237
<v Justin Leitner>We've seen a decline of the STI infections because of the work that the Multnomah County STI clinic has done, both in its location downtown on 6th and Hoyt, I believe, and at outreach centers.

224
00:23:14.633 --> 00:23:29.166
<v Justin Leitner>The proposed budget going forward would completely take off the Multnomah County STI clinic, defund them, which is where they would also take their STI tests from the outreach centers back to get tested.

225
00:23:29.711 --> 00:23:38.729
<v Justin Leitner>And so it's very important to have a place, bring it back to, make sure that everyone can get the care that they need in that time.

226
00:23:39.643 --> 00:23:52.959
<v Justin Leitner>Uh, there's so many outreach facilities that take care of not just houseless people or low-income people, but everyone from all walks of life.

227
00:23:53.616 --> 00:24:02.451
<v Justin Leitner>It's important that we need To make sure that Portland stays healthy through all of this uncertain future coming up ahead of us.

228
00:24:03.369 --> 00:24:07.758
<v Justin Leitner>We're looking for, please, a fully funded STI clinic.

229
00:24:08.871 --> 00:24:13.978
<v Justin Leitner>The pharmacy there is also very important for people to pick up their meds.

230
00:24:15.970 --> 00:24:31.376
<v Justin Leitner>DoxyPEP has a very important— like, if you take it shortly after any sort of encounter, it greatly decreases the chance of acquiring any sort of STI infection.

231
00:24:32.227 --> 00:24:56.557
<v Justin Leitner>But as long as we can get the funding for it, for the pharmacy and the STI clinic— typically the meds are covered through insurance, we just need to make sure that we can get Thank you for your time and your commitment to keeping Portland safe and healthy.

232
00:24:57.508 --> 00:24:59.441
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for taking the time to be with us today.

233
00:25:02.190 --> 00:25:03.125
<v Rebecca Dobert>Elijah Cooper.

234
00:25:10.140 --> 00:25:11.006
<v Rebecca Dobert>Elijah Cooper.

235
00:25:20.106 --> 00:25:20.298
<v Loretta Smith>We're good.

236
00:25:20.538 --> 00:25:35.105
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, it doesn't look like Elijah is with us today, uh, so I think we are going to move on to our time-certain item on the agenda.

237
00:25:35.971 --> 00:25:41.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, item 3 on the agenda Rebecca, could you read the title please?

238
00:25:41.778 --> 00:25:56.722
<v Rebecca Dobert>Amend the Comprehensive Plan Map and Zoning Map for properties at 3508 Northeast 11th Ave and 1123 Northeast Fremont Street at the request of Derek Metzen, GreenBox Architecture.

239
00:25:57.823 --> 00:26:06.516
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So councilors, as a reminder, we heard about this at a meeting of our body to discuss land use issues.

240
00:26:07.196 --> 00:26:16.632
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We then had a first reading where we adopted the amendment, taking our recommendation and putting it into this ordinance.

241
00:26:17.018 --> 00:26:22.657
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Today is our second reading of the ordinance where we generally just call the roll and pass the ordinance.

242
00:26:22.801 --> 00:26:29.156
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I just want to create that reminder that we have had significant discussion on this item in the past.

243
00:26:29.800 --> 00:26:34.597
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any last-minute discussion before I ask Rebecca to call the roll?

244
00:26:34.678 --> 00:26:34.807
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, Mayor.

245
00:26:36.895 --> 00:26:37.826
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Rebecca, please.

246
00:26:39.286 --> 00:26:39.637
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

247
00:26:40.664 --> 00:26:40.936
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

248
00:26:42.333 --> 00:26:42.718
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

249
00:26:42.973 --> 00:26:43.021
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

250
00:26:44.096 --> 00:26:44.721
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

251
00:26:45.058 --> 00:26:45.075
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

252
00:26:45.684 --> 00:26:46.102
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

253
00:26:46.501 --> 00:26:46.550
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

254
00:26:47.000 --> 00:26:47.336
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

255
00:26:47.545 --> 00:26:47.704
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

256
00:26:48.185 --> 00:26:48.603
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

257
00:26:48.907 --> 00:26:49.036
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

258
00:26:49.244 --> 00:26:49.534
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

259
00:26:50.030 --> 00:26:50.111
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

260
00:26:50.366 --> 00:26:50.720
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

261
00:26:51.073 --> 00:26:51.088
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

262
00:26:51.473 --> 00:26:51.858
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

263
00:26:52.115 --> 00:26:52.163
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

264
00:26:52.532 --> 00:26:52.932
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

265
00:26:53.334 --> 00:26:53.510
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

266
00:26:53.734 --> 00:26:54.104
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

267
00:26:54.682 --> 00:26:54.809
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

268
00:26:55.242 --> 00:26:55.708
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

269
00:26:56.045 --> 00:26:56.093
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

270
00:26:56.863 --> 00:26:59.107
<v Rebecca Dobert>With 12 ayes, the ordinance is passed.

271
00:27:01.755 --> 00:27:02.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

272
00:27:03.103 --> 00:27:08.400
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, the next thing on our list is a new agenda item.

273
00:27:08.497 --> 00:27:16.088
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is the committee referral list, and I had told you all that we would be posting a list so that the public could see what had been referred to committees.

274
00:27:16.618 --> 00:27:21.707
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll also be reading that here just so that it is on the record for folks listening to the meeting.

275
00:27:22.782 --> 00:27:28.866
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a list of items that over the past 2 weeks have been referred Thank you.

276
00:27:29.042 --> 00:27:41.205
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To committees, these are things that committees either have at this point or will be in the coming weeks having discussion on that we can expect are likely to come back to council in the coming weeks.

277
00:27:41.881 --> 00:27:48.531
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Adding the Sustainability and Climate Commission code to our code is in the Governance Committee.

278
00:27:49.207 --> 00:28:03.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Adopting a procedure for the appointments and confirmations of Portlanders to city boards, commissions, and committees in the Governance Committee adopting the fiscal year 2024-2025 technical adjustment ordinance and making other budget-related changes is in the Finance Committee.

279
00:28:04.694 --> 00:28:21.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Amending the fee schedule for tree permits in the Finance Committee, and three items that we will actually hear today: paying settlements of Amber Williams bodily injury claim, pay settlement of Janet Krasner body injury claim lawsuit, and pay settlement of Robert Medan employee.

280
00:28:28.920 --> 00:28:32.482
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next item on our agenda is also a new agenda item.

281
00:28:32.871 --> 00:28:34.747
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, Councilor Knoll.

282
00:28:36.671 --> 00:28:36.961
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

283
00:28:37.075 --> 00:28:49.367
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to ask, and maybe this is just a clarification, under the city code that we adopted in January, items that are referred are from the— by the president are from the mayor and the city attorney.

284
00:28:49.885 --> 00:28:53.641
<v Sameer Kanal>Auditor, and one of these items at least, it may be, I think it's just one.

285
00:28:54.699 --> 00:28:57.570
<v Sameer Kanal>The second item is actually something that was proposed by councilors.

286
00:28:57.940 --> 00:28:58.726
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mm-hmm.

287
00:28:58.790 --> 00:29:14.016
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'd just like to ask if in the future that can be clarified as separate, because in the council item here, it implies that that was referred to governance at the discretion of the council president and not at the discretion of the filers, which are Councilor Ryan and Councilor Koyama Lane.

288
00:29:14.625 --> 00:29:15.315
<v Sameer Kanal>So just wanted to clarify that.

289
00:29:15.380 --> 00:29:18.637
<v Sameer Kanal>I just want to clarify that that is a separate type of item than the other 6 on here.

290
00:29:19.809 --> 00:29:28.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can divide this out differently in the future, but I do think it's important for the public to be able to see everything that's going to committee.

291
00:29:29.215 --> 00:29:30.163
<v Sameer Kanal>For sure, for sure.

292
00:29:30.242 --> 00:29:34.416
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just— because if you look at that paragraph up at the top, it implies— I think so.

293
00:29:34.690 --> 00:29:43.005
<v Sameer Kanal>It's just about an organizational thing to make it clear to the public that the reason the other 6 were referred is because under code, the council president may do so and did so.

294
00:29:43.309 --> 00:29:49.201
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's a line in here that needs to say that councilors make—.

295
00:29:50.646 --> 00:29:51.306
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

296
00:29:51.611 --> 00:29:57.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Items that councilors have brought forward where they are directing which committee the president should send them to.

297
00:29:57.695 --> 00:29:58.032
<v Sameer Kanal>Exactly.

298
00:29:58.210 --> 00:30:00.410
<v Sameer Kanal>So, well, directing it directly.

299
00:30:00.826 --> 00:30:01.903
<v Sameer Kanal>It's 3.02.

300
00:30:01.951 --> 00:30:06.640
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't have the exact thing right here, but yeah, just wanted to clarify it.

301
00:30:06.703 --> 00:30:07.121
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks so much.

302
00:30:07.250 --> 00:30:07.989
<v Sameer Kanal>Not a concern.

303
00:30:08.518 --> 00:30:08.711
<v Anne Milligan>Yeah.

304
00:30:12.337 --> 00:30:13.823
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, thank you for creating this.

305
00:30:13.951 --> 00:30:18.211
<v Candace Avalos>I think the main thing I would ask is if it could have a status column.

306
00:30:18.403 --> 00:30:26.403
<v Candace Avalos>I just feel like there's— it needs a little bit more for me because just at first glance I'm not sure how to navigate what it's telling me and like where things are at what point.

307
00:30:26.451 --> 00:30:32.429
<v Candace Avalos>So I know that's adding more to work for you, but, um, I feel this would be more helpful to me with something like that.

308
00:30:32.478 --> 00:30:33.555
<v Candace Avalos>We could talk offline, but just one—.

309
00:30:33.555 --> 00:30:39.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I think in the future there's a lot we can do to make sure that this And our system as a whole are more accessible to the public.

310
00:30:40.769 --> 00:30:49.503
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As we develop our rules and procedures, I'm trying to make sure that I'm asking the clerk to make changes for things that I don't think will change.

311
00:30:50.482 --> 00:30:58.335
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But for things where our rules and procedures might affect how the public looks at things, I'm trying to not ask them to do work twice.

312
00:30:59.089 --> 00:31:04.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if there are things we can add now that would be consistent even once we have all our final rules in place, let's certainly get those up.

313
00:31:04.967 --> 00:31:05.126
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

314
00:31:05.240 --> 00:31:11.973
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>'Cause I do want to make sure that this is helpful to all of you, but also to the public who I have gotten repeated feedback.

315
00:31:12.720 --> 00:31:21.876
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sometimes it's hard to follow along with how City Council works, and we want to make this process more visible, frankly, for all of our constituents, I think.

316
00:31:22.207 --> 00:31:23.692
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So happy to work with you on that.

317
00:31:25.516 --> 00:31:26.617
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Knoll, are you back in the queue?

318
00:31:26.835 --> 00:31:27.752
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, it's 3.02.020B.

319
00:31:32.970 --> 00:31:36.580
<v Sameer Kanal>1A1 sub-sub-whatever section A and B are the 2 parts.

320
00:31:36.871 --> 00:31:37.709
<v Sameer Kanal>Just want to get that in the record.

321
00:31:37.758 --> 00:31:37.951
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

322
00:31:40.869 --> 00:31:47.775
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Rebecca, could you please read agenda item 5?

323
00:31:52.723 --> 00:31:53.967
<v Rebecca Dobert>City Administrator report.

324
00:31:54.468 --> 00:31:55.307
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Fantastic.

325
00:31:55.372 --> 00:31:59.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, councilors, this is another new agenda item, but something that we have Yes.

326
00:31:59.112 --> 00:32:14.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have talked about, I think since our first meeting maybe, that we would ultimately be getting on our agenda, which is a monthly report from the city administrator to share with us things happening within the executive branch and the administration.

327
00:32:14.664 --> 00:32:24.093
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have also had conversations about ensuring that council has visibility on funds coming into the city earlier in the process than council traditionally has.

328
00:32:24.189 --> 00:32:27.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is a place where I believe Mr. Jordan will be getting some of that information.

329
00:32:28.277 --> 00:32:30.249
<v Michael Jordan>Correct, Madam President.

330
00:32:30.473 --> 00:32:34.416
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, would you like to take a couple of minutes to go over the highlights of your report for us?

331
00:32:34.545 --> 00:32:38.489
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then if folks have questions, we will take questions on the report.

332
00:32:39.194 --> 00:32:41.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, do you have something before Mr.

333
00:32:41.776 --> 00:32:43.137
<v Loretta Smith>Jordan gives an overview?

334
00:32:43.282 --> 00:32:52.147
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, I just wanted to add, um, the, uh, ordinance that we passed said that the, uh, city administrator should come every 15 days, not 30.

335
00:32:52.259 --> 00:33:04.221
<v Loretta Smith>So I just wanted to make sure that So I just want to make sure that if he's going to put this in his report every 30 days, it's still missing the mark of the 15 days about putting the funding piece.

336
00:33:04.526 --> 00:33:05.231
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

337
00:33:05.345 --> 00:33:06.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>2 pieces.

338
00:33:06.789 --> 00:33:11.461
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, we have asked for certain types of funding to come to us within 15 days.

339
00:33:12.008 --> 00:33:24.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are other types of funding that come to the city as well that councilors have asked about having visibility on, and those pieces I've asked Mr. Jordan to include in his report, but you are right, there are certain types of funding that we've specifically asked for more.

340
00:33:24.660 --> 00:33:27.209
<v Loretta Smith>Which is the unassigned funding.

341
00:33:27.483 --> 00:33:28.628
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we shouldn't conflate the two.

342
00:33:28.676 --> 00:33:28.869
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

343
00:33:28.934 --> 00:33:29.916
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for pointing that out.

344
00:33:29.964 --> 00:33:30.673
<v Loretta Smith>Appreciate it.

345
00:33:32.234 --> 00:33:32.766
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Jordan.

346
00:33:33.023 --> 00:33:36.340
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you, Council President and members of the council.

347
00:33:36.807 --> 00:33:43.044
<v Michael Jordan>I'm going to try and get you some time back this morning, but I'm certainly willing to entertain questions and comments.

348
00:33:43.511 --> 00:33:54.181
<v Michael Jordan>The report that you received earlier this week Is a very, very first draft, and it's there as much for form as it is for content.

349
00:33:54.229 --> 00:33:56.384
<v Michael Jordan>There are some items in each of the categories.

350
00:33:56.738 --> 00:34:05.732
<v Michael Jordan>We have organized this generally by service area along with the Administrator's Office, and there is a section under communications.

351
00:34:06.317 --> 00:34:07.601
<v Michael Jordan>There are 2 addendums.

352
00:34:07.796 --> 00:34:12.635
<v Michael Jordan>Council has asked for information regarding settlements that don't come to Council.

353
00:34:12.717 --> 00:34:12.766
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

354
00:34:13.146 --> 00:34:14.992
<v Michael Jordan>So there's a listing there of those.

355
00:34:15.429 --> 00:34:25.371
<v Michael Jordan>And then there is also a grants page that is a first attempt at a kind of keeping up with grants across the city.

356
00:34:26.242 --> 00:34:34.110
<v Michael Jordan>I want to acknowledge and be maybe the first to acknowledge that those 2 reports are highly inadequate regarding their readability.

357
00:34:35.063 --> 00:34:41.485
<v Michael Jordan>They need a cover memo that helps people understand all the acronyms and the abbreviations.

358
00:34:41.605 --> 00:34:41.742
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

359
00:34:42.114 --> 00:34:42.807
<v Michael Jordan>And all the rest.

360
00:34:42.920 --> 00:34:46.342
<v Michael Jordan>So know that, at least we know that.

361
00:34:46.389 --> 00:34:48.456
<v Michael Jordan>I've already mentioned that to staff when I got it.

362
00:34:48.503 --> 00:34:54.094
<v Michael Jordan>I said, I can't read this, all of it, even though I'm aware of most of those things.

363
00:34:54.206 --> 00:34:58.597
<v Michael Jordan>So I wanna acknowledge those things.

364
00:34:58.708 --> 00:35:04.197
<v Michael Jordan>I also wanna acknowledge we have chosen to organize this way.

365
00:35:04.277 --> 00:35:06.836
<v Michael Jordan>If there are other categories of information—.

366
00:35:06.967 --> 00:35:07.063
<v Michael Jordan>Yes.

367
00:35:07.402 --> 00:35:10.851
<v Michael Jordan>That the council would like to see, I would love to hear about that.

368
00:35:11.318 --> 00:35:22.585
<v Michael Jordan>Also, this, the mix of items that you see in this report are a mix of things that have happened, and there are some acknowledgement of things that are going to happen and come to council.

369
00:35:23.114 --> 00:35:25.346
<v Michael Jordan>So there's a mix of those things.

370
00:35:25.442 --> 00:35:31.012
<v Michael Jordan>Would love to get feedback on your thoughts about that and what's most useful for you.

371
00:35:31.653 --> 00:35:35.762
<v Michael Jordan>So again, I wanna make sure you understand this is a very rough first draft.

372
00:35:35.811 --> 00:35:35.954
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

373
00:35:37.320 --> 00:35:46.648
<v Michael Jordan>I'm here to both capture your comments and questions today, but know that you can send them to me at any time.

374
00:35:47.101 --> 00:35:52.951
<v Michael Jordan>We will be working to refine the report for next month, and it will be a monthly report.

375
00:35:53.418 --> 00:36:01.809
<v Michael Jordan>Regarding Councilor Smith's comments, I'm working with the CFO for a different element to this report that will come to you.

376
00:36:01.889 --> 00:36:02.034
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

377
00:36:02.119 --> 00:36:07.820
<v Michael Jordan>Bimonthly, if you will, so that you can get up to date on received revenues.

378
00:36:08.317 --> 00:36:20.503
<v Michael Jordan>And I know that CFO Biery is working with the revenue division on how to organize a report so that the council can see revenues more in real time.

379
00:36:21.081 --> 00:36:27.327
<v Michael Jordan>I'm really interested in getting you a year-to-date against budget.

380
00:36:27.938 --> 00:36:38.887
<v Michael Jordan>Summary so that you can see how the whole city's doing on a more real-time basis through the year and can ask questions and see where we are from a financial perspective.

381
00:36:39.577 --> 00:36:42.065
<v Michael Jordan>So I'm not gonna go into every detail of the report.

382
00:36:42.146 --> 00:36:43.126
<v Michael Jordan>It's pretty high level.

383
00:36:43.318 --> 00:36:51.280
<v Michael Jordan>It's very abbreviated this month, but I'm here to take your comments and/or questions about either form or content.

384
00:36:51.827 --> 00:36:54.139
<v Michael Jordan>And then obviously we'll take your questions.

385
00:36:54.186 --> 00:36:54.298
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

386
00:36:56.679 --> 00:37:02.860
<v Michael Jordan>Ongoing, let's put it that way, as we can continue to refine this to make it the most useful it can be for Council.

387
00:37:02.942 --> 00:37:06.523
<v Michael Jordan>I'll stop there, Madam President, and take questions or comments.

388
00:37:08.335 --> 00:37:09.286
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mr. Jordan.

389
00:37:09.398 --> 00:37:10.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

390
00:37:11.717 --> 00:37:12.715
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

391
00:37:12.940 --> 00:37:15.275
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for the report.

392
00:37:15.742 --> 00:37:21.460
<v Loretta Smith>One of the issues that I have with the report is it is not in Excel format.

393
00:37:21.574 --> 00:37:26.255
<v Loretta Smith>It says we're going to do this, but it has no numbers associated with it.

394
00:37:26.751 --> 00:37:34.992
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, it says that you're going to take this out of the budget, but it doesn't say how much you're going to take out of the budget or how much you're going to put in for the new program that you suggested.

395
00:37:35.264 --> 00:37:36.755
<v Loretta Smith>So for me, it's not useful.

396
00:37:37.268 --> 00:37:44.081
<v Loretta Smith>It is, it is a way just to tell a story, but it is not giving me what I really need in a report.

397
00:37:44.802 --> 00:37:45.284
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

398
00:37:45.443 --> 00:37:47.304
<v Michael Jordan>From the financial perspective, Councilor?

399
00:37:47.672 --> 00:37:48.152
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

400
00:37:48.248 --> 00:37:49.067
<v Michael Jordan>Okay, thank you.

401
00:37:52.327 --> 00:37:54.255
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Madam President.

402
00:37:54.496 --> 00:37:57.099
<v Dan Ryan>Um, hello, Michael Jordan, DA Jordan.

403
00:37:57.309 --> 00:37:58.143
<v Dan Ryan>Um, couple things.

404
00:37:58.273 --> 00:37:59.268
<v Dan Ryan>One, you owned it.

405
00:37:59.349 --> 00:38:02.835
<v Dan Ryan>It's a rough first draft, and, uh, I appreciate that it's in the works.

406
00:38:02.884 --> 00:38:10.789
<v Dan Ryan>This kind of used to be our council agendas just not too long ago, so I'm, uh, I'm missing this kind of information, to Councilor Smith's point, and more details.

407
00:38:11.367 --> 00:38:19.226
<v Dan Ryan>Um, just on process, as you're working out the kinks, this is something that we should have posted In transparency on the Friday when it goes out at 9:00 AM.

408
00:38:19.568 --> 00:38:22.304
<v Dan Ryan>I know I probably missed the email, so I just saw it this morning.

409
00:38:23.449 --> 00:38:25.947
<v Dan Ryan>So you already know that, but we wanted to make sure that was clear.

410
00:38:26.547 --> 00:38:38.766
<v Dan Ryan>And then on the grants one specifically, if you could identify the source, there's a big difference between pass-through money that we get from the feds or Metro or wherever, and then those grants that we're giving from the general fund.

411
00:38:39.273 --> 00:38:41.465
<v Dan Ryan>And that's just a really important feature.

412
00:38:41.514 --> 00:38:41.563
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

413
00:38:41.659 --> 00:38:43.146
<v Dan Ryan>Feedback that I wanted to give you on grants.

414
00:38:43.697 --> 00:38:45.994
<v Dan Ryan>And I— and you owned that that one has a lot of work to do.

415
00:38:46.155 --> 00:38:50.003
<v Dan Ryan>So I want— I hope that you would start with that, at least the source of where those funds come from.

416
00:38:50.344 --> 00:38:50.764
<v Justin Leitner>Thank you.

417
00:38:54.436 --> 00:38:55.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

418
00:38:55.981 --> 00:38:56.835
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

419
00:38:56.949 --> 00:38:58.414
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Administrator Jordan, for this.

420
00:38:58.623 --> 00:39:06.655
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I think, you know, going from nothing to something is a really big step, uh, and that— I think that's a really important thing, and I want to express gratitude for that.

421
00:39:07.188 --> 00:39:17.009
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'll co-sign what both my colleagues just said and add, um, That there— I think it's worth considering that people can, can and should be able to get through more information.

422
00:39:17.780 --> 00:39:28.244
<v Sameer Kanal>So for example, on the Community Board for Police Accountability, noting that it has the ability to hear cases of alleged misconduct is kind of a core part of it that was summarized out of the description.

423
00:39:29.717 --> 00:39:33.445
<v Sameer Kanal>The settlements, having more information about what they are is great.

424
00:39:33.706 --> 00:39:43.144
<v Sameer Kanal>I will say we never had any transparency really in the last council over the $0 to $5,000 And so I— that's a really big step, and I, I want to thank you explicitly for that.

425
00:39:43.614 --> 00:39:45.188
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, yeah, thanks.

426
00:39:47.750 --> 00:39:49.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, are you back in the queue?

427
00:39:49.219 --> 00:39:49.621
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, ma'am.

428
00:39:50.123 --> 00:39:51.655
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, uh, Madam President.

429
00:39:52.043 --> 00:40:03.329
<v Loretta Smith>I also wanted to note that on the 15-day for the, for the other, uh, ordinance that we passed in February, it also notes that it should be brought to council and acknowledged in a budget modification.

430
00:40:04.018 --> 00:40:11.565
<v Loretta Smith>Not just to report to us, you have to bring it to council so that we can acknowledge it and put it into the existing fiscal year.

431
00:40:13.427 --> 00:40:22.157
<v Michael Jordan>So I'm clear, Councilor, you're suggesting that we bring a budget modification ordinance every 15 days?

432
00:40:22.822 --> 00:40:36.561
<v Loretta Smith>No, I'm suggesting when money comes in, you have 15 days to report it to council so that it can be in a modification, a budget modification, so that we can either expand our existing fiscal year budget.

433
00:40:37.751 --> 00:40:42.701
<v Loretta Smith>If it's before, you know, we need to work out something depending on how close it is to the budget.

434
00:40:42.813 --> 00:40:54.016
<v Loretta Smith>But the, uh, the actual ordinance requires you to bring it, to bring it forward and acknowledge it in a council meeting and to get a budget modification to add it to our existing budget.

435
00:40:54.650 --> 00:40:55.105
<v Marcel Guzmundo>Thank you.

436
00:40:58.126 --> 00:40:58.451
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Thank you.

437
00:40:59.509 --> 00:41:08.496
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any additional questions for Mr. Jordan about the content of the report or comments about the, uh, structure of the report?

438
00:41:10.610 --> 00:41:13.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none.

439
00:41:13.385 --> 00:41:14.047
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you, Madam Clerk.

440
00:41:14.097 --> 00:41:15.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for bringing this forward to us.

441
00:41:19.108 --> 00:41:26.702
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, the next item on our agenda— and I, let me just check with the clerk— I don't believe that we need to accept this report.

442
00:41:26.751 --> 00:41:29.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is just an informational agenda item, is that correct?

443
00:41:29.797 --> 00:41:30.284
<v Rebecca Dobert>Correct.

444
00:41:30.527 --> 00:41:31.338
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

445
00:41:32.561 --> 00:41:35.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, councilors, the next item on our agenda is the consent agenda.

446
00:41:36.427 --> 00:41:39.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, have any items been pulled from the consent agenda?

447
00:41:39.516 --> 00:41:40.405
<v Rebecca Dobert>No, none have been pulled.

448
00:41:40.891 --> 00:41:42.233
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, could you please call the roll?

449
00:41:43.059 --> 00:41:43.365
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal.

450
00:41:46.231 --> 00:41:49.452
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so, um, I am going to vote yes on this.

451
00:41:49.532 --> 00:41:50.568
<v Sameer Kanal>I do want to note one thing.

452
00:41:51.599 --> 00:41:58.614
<v Sameer Kanal>Which is that these 5 items that are on the consent agenda are, they're emergency ordinances.

453
00:41:58.824 --> 00:42:01.684
<v Sameer Kanal>I have no concern with the content of the documents.

454
00:42:01.733 --> 00:42:08.143
<v Sameer Kanal>I actually don't know why we're voting on a separate time to create a fund for a TIF district we already created, and that's maybe something we should dig into.

455
00:42:08.594 --> 00:42:10.371
<v Sameer Kanal>I also have no concern about the consent agenda.

456
00:42:10.500 --> 00:42:31.282
<v Sameer Kanal>However, on the topic of emergency ordinances, the rationale in here is that in order to deny Portlanders a second chance at reviewing this document, that advanced notice of 19 days instead of 5, and prevent you from giving easily public testimony without requesting it.

457
00:42:31.652 --> 00:42:41.621
<v Sameer Kanal>The rationale given is that it would— delaying it would prevent it from being in the FY 2025 to 2026 budget, which doesn't— is not true.

458
00:42:42.217 --> 00:42:56.568
<v Sameer Kanal>I clarified that with the staff involved in presenting this, that if we hypothetically did a second reading on the 16th, And it took effect on May 16th, we would have the ability to have it be included in the next year's budget.

459
00:42:57.161 --> 00:43:07.938
<v Sameer Kanal>And the rationale given was that it would affect the ability of the administrative staff to receive a quick yes from council and council efficiency, that that is why it's an emergency.

460
00:43:08.003 --> 00:43:09.175
<v Sameer Kanal>That is not an emergency.

461
00:43:10.652 --> 00:43:15.311
<v Sameer Kanal>We are not responsible and the public should not be punished because this was not filed in advance.

462
00:43:16.027 --> 00:43:17.831
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to be super clear about that.

463
00:43:17.913 --> 00:43:31.708
<v Sameer Kanal>And in the future, if you'd like anything to get through a consent agenda, I encourage the administrative side to file this in advance and not force us to have to weigh whether or not public— the public should get to weigh in on these things through public testimony.

464
00:43:32.119 --> 00:43:38.396
<v Sameer Kanal>Because this is a follow-up to something we've already created, I'm not pulling it off the consent agenda, but I wanted to raise that issue before voting yes.

465
00:43:38.623 --> 00:43:39.027
<v Candace Avalos>I vote aye.

466
00:43:40.143 --> 00:43:40.434
<v Emily Dumerck>Ryan?

467
00:43:41.050 --> 00:43:41.081
<v Emily Dumerck>Aye.

468
00:43:41.746 --> 00:43:42.373
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

469
00:43:42.789 --> 00:43:42.838
<v Emily Dumerck>Aye.

470
00:43:43.286 --> 00:43:43.753
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo?

471
00:43:44.554 --> 00:43:44.603
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

472
00:43:45.293 --> 00:43:45.759
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

473
00:43:45.998 --> 00:43:46.047
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

474
00:43:46.753 --> 00:43:47.123
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

475
00:43:47.523 --> 00:43:47.684
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

476
00:43:47.860 --> 00:43:48.150
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

477
00:43:48.567 --> 00:43:48.614
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

478
00:43:49.047 --> 00:43:49.514
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

479
00:43:49.867 --> 00:43:56.302
<v Eric Zimmerman>As the chair of the Finance Committee, it was my call to put it as an emergency, and I think it was the right move to make.

480
00:43:56.686 --> 00:44:05.753
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think emergency is useful for certain items, and this is clearly and, and simply just the creation of the bank account.

481
00:44:06.059 --> 00:44:15.519
<v Eric Zimmerman>There will be a larger policy discussion but the Finance Committee did hear this, and the staff did come to me and provide 2 options.

482
00:44:16.099 --> 00:44:31.521
<v Eric Zimmerman>And because I valued that the committee do the work to hear this and take that time instead of sending this to Council prior to, I was just fine with it being part of an emergency and part of consent.

483
00:44:31.746 --> 00:44:32.101
<v Eric Zimmerman>I vote aye.

484
00:44:35.989 --> 00:44:36.166
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

485
00:44:37.219 --> 00:44:37.347
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

486
00:44:38.222 --> 00:44:38.577
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith.

487
00:44:39.726 --> 00:44:39.775
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

488
00:44:40.550 --> 00:44:41.085
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney.

489
00:44:41.990 --> 00:44:42.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

490
00:44:43.041 --> 00:44:45.244
<v Rebecca Dobert>With 12 ayes, the consent agenda is passed.

491
00:44:46.282 --> 00:44:46.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Rebecca.

492
00:44:49.400 --> 00:44:55.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That takes us to our regular agenda and agenda item 12.

493
00:44:56.454 --> 00:45:00.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next 3 agenda items, councilors, are all Settlements.

494
00:45:02.293 --> 00:45:08.231
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These are emergency ordinances, and I will just address that very quickly because I know this is something that comes up.

495
00:45:08.391 --> 00:45:36.668
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Emergency ordinances— an emergency clause is often placed on a settlement so that our team of attorneys who have been negotiating with somebody who believes that they were harmed by the city can move that process of creating closure for those individuals forward and not have a delay that might make it harder both to find closure for that individual and also to maintain an agreement on the settlement.

496
00:45:36.893 --> 00:45:41.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just want to flag that for folks now.

497
00:45:42.253 --> 00:45:48.353
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe— are you presenting just on the first or on all 3 of our settlements?

498
00:45:48.449 --> 00:45:49.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>On the first ordinance, Council President.

499
00:45:50.679 --> 00:45:52.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call the agenda item?

500
00:45:53.407 --> 00:46:01.686
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 12, pay settlement of Janet Krasner bodily injury lawsuit for $200,000 involving the Portland Parks and Recreation Bureau.

501
00:46:02.311 --> 00:46:02.711
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wonderful.

502
00:46:02.809 --> 00:46:07.123
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we have Mark Rodriguez and Joseph Jesse, or we have both of you?

503
00:46:07.300 --> 00:46:08.391
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, I see Joseph online.

504
00:46:08.503 --> 00:46:08.905
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

505
00:46:08.985 --> 00:46:09.385
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wonderful.

506
00:46:09.771 --> 00:46:10.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead, Mark.

507
00:46:10.574 --> 00:46:10.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

508
00:46:11.615 --> 00:46:12.050
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

509
00:46:12.177 --> 00:46:12.547
<v Anne Milligan>Good morning.

510
00:46:12.594 --> 00:46:14.166
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mark Rodriguez, Deputy City Attorney.

511
00:46:14.503 --> 00:46:16.333
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning, Council President and councilors.

512
00:46:16.766 --> 00:46:27.400
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This lawsuit brings a claim of negligence yes.

513
00:46:27.400 --> 00:46:40.630
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ms. Krasner alleges she was on an outdoor patio of her daughter's house when a large branch of one of Willamette Park's pin oak trees broke and fell onto the property, causing her to jump towards the house, causing injury to her back and knee.

514
00:46:41.119 --> 00:46:43.639
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The property is located at the south end of Willamette Park.

515
00:46:44.269 --> 00:46:50.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The property had 2 prior documented incidents involving branches from the same park tree causing damage to the house and fence.

516
00:46:50.791 --> 00:46:59.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>On both prior occasions, Urban Forestry arborists responded and performed maintenance to the involved tree, determining that the overall health of the tree remained in good condition and did not warrant removal.

517
00:47:01.128 --> 00:47:08.213
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The City Attorney's Office, Risk Management, and the Parks Bureau determined it would be in the best interest of the city to resolve Ms. Krasner's lawsuit prior to trial.

518
00:47:09.527 --> 00:47:15.577
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The parties negotiated a settlement for $200,000 plus the removal of the 2 pin oak trees adjacent to subject property.

519
00:47:16.289 --> 00:47:19.576
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We recommend approval of the settlement, and I'm happy to answer any questions.

520
00:47:19.851 --> 00:47:20.224
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

521
00:47:23.153 --> 00:47:24.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any questions?

522
00:47:25.264 --> 00:47:26.028
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

523
00:47:28.385 --> 00:47:33.135
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just want to be clear what we just heard, particularly given yesterday's hearing.

524
00:47:34.362 --> 00:47:55.351
<v Eric Zimmerman>So Urban Forestry, quote, addressed it, but not enough to keep us from being liable, or at least liable enough that we thought it was a good idea to cut a $200,000 check for damages to this resident based on Urban Forestry's determination that the tree didn't have to be removed, that it wasn't a hazard, and then it turned out to be a hazard.

525
00:47:55.431 --> 00:47:59.297
<v Eric Zimmerman>And you said it was twice that they've been called out to this tree prior to this damage?

526
00:47:59.378 --> 00:48:00.005
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's correct.

527
00:48:00.987 --> 00:48:02.119
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for clarifying that.

528
00:48:02.668 --> 00:48:07.034
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You're welcome.

529
00:48:08.005 --> 00:48:08.909
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, first, thank you.

530
00:48:09.065 --> 00:48:09.481
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for being here.

531
00:48:09.563 --> 00:48:18.398
<v Sameer Kanal>And thank— I just want to thank the city attorneys and risk management for really improving the way in which settlements have come to us, uh, in the course of last year to present.

532
00:48:18.927 --> 00:48:20.547
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and just start with that.

533
00:48:21.012 --> 00:48:24.170
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I think you've done a good job of laying out the allegations.

534
00:48:24.315 --> 00:48:33.184
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there anyone here from Parks who can speak to, um, how we're not going to have to cut another $200,000 check for this again in the future?

535
00:48:34.001 --> 00:48:35.541
<v Sameer Kanal>Or I should say the Vibrant Community Service Area.

536
00:48:35.588 --> 00:48:37.545
<v Sameer Kanal>I think It'll be fine as well.

537
00:48:38.027 --> 00:48:39.038
<v Sameer Kanal>And I see the DCA coming.

538
00:48:39.471 --> 00:48:40.434
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry to put you on the spot.

539
00:48:41.059 --> 00:48:42.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead, please introduce yourself.

540
00:48:42.824 --> 00:48:43.369
<v Lee Heppner>Hi, good morning.

541
00:48:43.561 --> 00:48:46.112
<v Olivia Clark>Sonia Szymanski with the Vibrant Communities Service Area.

542
00:48:46.273 --> 00:48:46.802
<v Lee Heppner>I am here.

543
00:48:47.476 --> 00:48:56.170
<v Olivia Clark>We also have Paul Anderson here who can speak more completely to that question, and I see him here if that suits you.

544
00:48:57.358 --> 00:48:58.273
<v Sameer Kanal>Whoever you'd prefer.

545
00:48:58.545 --> 00:48:58.865
<v Paul Anderson>I think that—.

546
00:48:58.963 --> 00:49:01.096
<v Sameer Kanal>Let me just put a finer point on the question.

547
00:49:01.289 --> 00:49:04.097
<v Sameer Kanal>What is This didn't happen, you know, yesterday.

548
00:49:04.418 --> 00:49:14.208
<v Sameer Kanal>What has happened subsequent to the event, and what is happening now within Vibrant Communities to ensure that we're not settling cases like this in the future, getting claims like this?

549
00:49:14.449 --> 00:49:15.219
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, Paul, go ahead.

550
00:49:16.375 --> 00:49:16.695
<v Marcel Guzmundo>Thank you.

551
00:49:16.840 --> 00:49:17.467
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you for the question.

552
00:49:18.300 --> 00:49:21.318
<v Paul Anderson>Paul Anderson, Urban Forestry Operations Manager.

553
00:49:22.313 --> 00:49:24.047
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate the opportunity to answer this question.

554
00:49:24.481 --> 00:49:30.179
<v Paul Anderson>There have been significant changes to the urban forestry operations approach since the incident occurred.

555
00:49:30.324 --> 00:49:38.688
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, thanks to this, the local option levy, Urban Forestry now has capacity to proactively inspect parks.

556
00:49:39.090 --> 00:49:47.809
<v Paul Anderson>Trees in developed parks are inspected once every 3 years at minimum, and we can also provide maintenance to those trees that require maintenance.

557
00:49:48.403 --> 00:49:56.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This proactive approach has already increased public safety, reduced the risk to reduce risk in general and improves tree health.

558
00:49:56.898 --> 00:50:00.688
<v Mitch Green>So that's a really big shift from reactive work to proactive work.

559
00:50:01.876 --> 00:50:07.753
<v Candace Avalos>I want to say also Paul is virtual because Paul works at Delta Park, which is quite a long drive.

560
00:50:08.380 --> 00:50:10.740
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

561
00:50:10.869 --> 00:50:22.940
<v Sameer Kanal>And then my other question is, could you tell us the aggregate amount that has been paid out in the last year and in the last 5 years for all lawsuits involving Portland Parks and I believe Joe—.

562
00:50:23.230 --> 00:50:24.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Joseph Jesse, you have that number?

563
00:50:25.152 --> 00:50:27.668
<v Joseph Jesse>I, I do have information on that.

564
00:50:27.731 --> 00:50:34.831
<v Joseph Jesse>I do not have it broken down by lawsuits, but just general all claims, um, which would involve lawsuits as well.

565
00:50:34.943 --> 00:50:35.583
<v Joseph Jesse>Is that okay?

566
00:50:36.849 --> 00:50:37.010
<v Sameer Kanal>Sure.

567
00:50:37.090 --> 00:50:41.079
<v Sameer Kanal>Could you also clarify what else is included beyond lawsuits in these numbers?

568
00:50:42.137 --> 00:50:57.538
<v Joseph Jesse>Um, so this would be, first of all, for the— for one year, I can say that total paid out, this would involve anything from property damage to bodily injury to expenses, say, for experts or for legal expenses.

569
00:50:58.135 --> 00:51:01.744
<v Joseph Jesse>Last, last year it was total paid is $20,006.11.

570
00:51:04.021 --> 00:51:15.121
<v Joseph Jesse>Of that, $16,861.45 is related to property damage and $3,144.66 is related to various expenses.

571
00:51:16.771 --> 00:51:18.097
<v Joseph Jesse>I can bring up the 5-year—.

572
00:51:18.226 --> 00:51:20.990
<v Joseph Jesse>Sorry, one sec here—.

573
00:51:22.025 --> 00:51:24.266
<v Joseph Jesse>Related to 5 years.

574
00:51:24.773 --> 00:51:26.494
<v Joseph Jesse>The total paid out is $396,625.39.

575
00:51:31.114 --> 00:51:34.474
<v Joseph Jesse>Of that, property damage is $218,455.29.

576
00:51:37.610 --> 00:51:39.119
<v Joseph Jesse>Bodily injury is $70,629.64.

577
00:51:42.181 --> 00:51:48.244
<v Joseph Jesse>Expenses is $37,140.11, and legal is $70,435.

578
00:51:51.177 --> 00:51:51.436
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

579
00:51:51.501 --> 00:51:53.085
<v Sameer Kanal>And just 2 quick clarifications.

580
00:51:53.182 --> 00:51:58.971
<v Sameer Kanal>One, that's, uh, paid out not based on claim date or incident date?

581
00:51:59.666 --> 00:52:04.898
<v Joseph Jesse>That is based on— it is based on loss date.

582
00:52:05.606 --> 00:52:17.963
<v Joseph Jesse>So claims that have happened and it's by fiscal year, so it would be claims that have occurred since— would be July 1st, 2020 to June 30th, 2025.

583
00:52:18.047 --> 00:52:19.309
<v Sameer Kanal>That answered my other question as well.

584
00:52:19.358 --> 00:52:19.972
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

585
00:52:22.269 --> 00:52:23.592
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other questions?

586
00:52:27.961 --> 00:52:32.184
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, uh, Rebecca, is there anyone signed up for public testimony?

587
00:52:32.733 --> 00:52:33.315
<v Rebecca Dobert>No one signed up.

588
00:52:34.360 --> 00:52:37.766
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, councilors, any discussion on this agenda item?

589
00:52:41.760 --> 00:52:42.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both for being here.

590
00:52:43.088 --> 00:52:47.643
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you— oh, Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

591
00:52:48.880 --> 00:52:49.268
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

592
00:52:49.543 --> 00:52:49.592
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

593
00:52:50.126 --> 00:52:50.416
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

594
00:52:51.485 --> 00:52:53.670
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I want to thank legal for the meeting earlier this week.

595
00:52:53.914 --> 00:53:00.798
<v Dan Ryan>It's always helpful, and I was able to hear how each bureau was responding, um, in terms of practices from the lawsuit.

596
00:53:00.994 --> 00:53:01.706
<v Dan Ryan>So I vote aye.

597
00:53:02.579 --> 00:53:03.210
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

598
00:53:03.550 --> 00:53:03.599
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

599
00:53:04.197 --> 00:53:04.521
<v Helmi Hissrich>Morillo?

600
00:53:05.088 --> 00:53:05.137
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

601
00:53:05.670 --> 00:53:06.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

602
00:53:06.545 --> 00:53:06.577
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

603
00:53:07.143 --> 00:53:07.516
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

604
00:53:07.920 --> 00:53:07.969
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

605
00:53:09.936 --> 00:53:10.322
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

606
00:53:11.175 --> 00:53:11.304
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

607
00:53:11.465 --> 00:53:11.626
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

608
00:53:11.722 --> 00:53:15.074
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to, um, appreciate Councilor Kanal's questions.

609
00:53:15.170 --> 00:53:25.652
<v Eric Zimmerman>They are in line with some of the same concerns that I've had, given that yesterday we heard that the parks levy pays for much of, of, uh, the urban forestry, uh, program.

610
00:53:26.192 --> 00:53:28.050
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's a lot to be concerned here, right?

611
00:53:28.179 --> 00:53:48.311
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I would just— I will be voting in favor of this, but I hope we all are continuing to take a look at my editorializing, which is that urban forestry is in deep need of a revamp and how it works with our public to avoid situations like this where we are doing harm to the public when they raise the red flag.

612
00:53:48.617 --> 00:53:49.818
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you for bringing this.

613
00:53:49.914 --> 00:53:50.284
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

614
00:53:50.476 --> 00:53:52.608
<v Eric Zimmerman>And noted, I also appreciate how these have been coming forward.

615
00:53:52.655 --> 00:53:53.184
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you.

616
00:53:55.751 --> 00:53:55.913
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

617
00:53:58.362 --> 00:53:58.797
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

618
00:53:59.539 --> 00:53:59.588
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

619
00:54:00.360 --> 00:54:00.893
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

620
00:54:01.715 --> 00:54:01.762
<v Helmi Hissrich>Aye.

621
00:54:02.456 --> 00:54:02.795
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

622
00:54:03.150 --> 00:54:04.061
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

623
00:54:04.483 --> 00:54:04.842
<v Rebecca Dobert>12 ayes.

624
00:54:04.889 --> 00:54:05.784
<v Rebecca Dobert>The ordinance is passed.

625
00:54:08.190 --> 00:54:10.760
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please read agenda item number 13?

626
00:54:11.500 --> 00:54:19.657
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 13, pay settlement of Robert Medan employee discrimination lawsuit for $100,000 involving the Portland Parks and Recreation Bureau.

627
00:54:20.675 --> 00:54:21.012
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

628
00:54:21.141 --> 00:54:29.032
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe we have Anne Milligan, Rose Radich, and Lauren McGuire here to help walk us through this agenda item.

629
00:54:29.739 --> 00:54:30.132
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

630
00:54:31.239 --> 00:54:32.052
<v Anne Milligan>Good morning, councilors.

631
00:54:32.182 --> 00:54:36.853
<v Anne Milligan>My name is Anne Milligan, and I'm a Senior Deputy City Attorney with the City Attorney's Office.

632
00:54:37.856 --> 00:54:45.266
<v Anne Milligan>Robert Meadon began working for the City of Portland in Parks and Recreation on August 4th, 2022, as an entry-level supervisor.

633
00:54:45.987 --> 00:54:55.746
<v Anne Milligan>On or around March 3rd, 2023, Midon filed an HR complaint against his direct supervisor, a white man, alleging that his supervisor made race-related comments.

634
00:54:56.581 --> 00:55:00.996
<v Anne Milligan>After making his complaint, Midon no longer had to report to that supervisor.

635
00:55:01.670 --> 00:55:14.461
<v Anne Milligan>Subsequently, Midon attempted and attended 2 different work meetings that resulted in multiple contemporaneous written complaints from his colleagues expressing strong disagreement with Midon's behavior at those 2 meetings.

636
00:55:15.278 --> 00:55:20.119
<v Anne Milligan>As a result of his behavior at the first meeting, he was put on paid administrative leave and investigated.

637
00:55:20.903 --> 00:55:28.724
<v Anne Milligan>In June 2023, BHR completed its findings regarding Meadon's complaint, and they sustained 2 of Meadon's allegations of discrimination.

638
00:55:29.478 --> 00:55:37.539
<v Anne Milligan>Meadon's employment with the city was ended during his probationary period on July 26th, 2023, due to his inappropriate behavior at 2 meetings.

639
00:55:38.773 --> 00:55:45.204
<v Anne Milligan>On February 17th, 2024, Meadon filed a lawsuit in Multnomah County Circuit Court seeking $305,000.

640
00:55:45.911 --> 00:55:58.498
<v Anne Milligan>This complaint alleges discriminatory treatment and a hostile work environment based on race, retaliation for whistleblowing and for reporting or opposing race discrimination, and in retaliation for invocation of the Oregon Family Leave Act.

641
00:55:58.980 --> 00:56:01.693
<v Anne Milligan>Trial is currently set for July of 2025.

642
00:56:02.849 --> 00:56:07.505
<v Anne Milligan>The City Attorney's Office and Risk Management recommend resolving this case for $100,000.

643
00:56:07.601 --> 00:56:08.887
<v Anne Milligan>And with that, we would welcome any questions.

644
00:56:08.934 --> 00:56:09.030
<v Rashid Yusufi>Thank you.

645
00:56:13.050 --> 00:56:14.577
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, any questions?

646
00:56:15.414 --> 00:56:16.235
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

647
00:56:17.505 --> 00:56:34.512
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm not sure who's the right person to answer this, but the numbers we just heard, do that— do those include employment-related claims for the previous item, or are there a different set of numbers for the aggregate amount of employment-related payouts we've made for Parks and Recreation?

648
00:56:35.952 --> 00:56:47.474
<v Anne Milligan>Is your question regarding your question of Joe Jesse in risk management, is the total amount of claims for parks inclusive of this settlement that we haven't paid out yet?

649
00:56:48.045 --> 00:56:50.184
<v Anne Milligan>'Cause I think he only responded as to claims paid.

650
00:56:51.960 --> 00:56:59.744
<v Sameer Kanal>It's whether or not the response to that question includes other employment-related claims that have been paid out, if any should exist.

651
00:57:00.315 --> 00:57:00.460
<v Anne Milligan>Yes.

652
00:57:00.733 --> 00:57:08.009
<v Anne Milligan>So there haven't been any employment-related claims for parks since 2019 when there was a reverse discrimination case that the city won.

653
00:57:09.246 --> 00:57:14.159
<v Anne Milligan>We paid nothing in that case, but that was the last time there was any kind of employment claim of any kind.

654
00:57:14.208 --> 00:57:15.284
<v Anne Milligan>There have been no claims paid.

655
00:57:15.364 --> 00:57:17.003
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ms. Radich, did you have—.

656
00:57:17.260 --> 00:57:17.644
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, I'm sorry.

657
00:57:17.726 --> 00:57:19.813
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ms. Radich, did you have something to add to that answer?

658
00:57:20.568 --> 00:57:20.760
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

659
00:57:21.371 --> 00:57:25.594
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, just to add to what Ann Milligan said is these—.

660
00:57:25.771 --> 00:57:36.342
<v Candace Avalos>The numbers would, if there were, if there was costs incurred on employment claims, those would be included in those total numbers that we bring with risk management.

661
00:57:36.998 --> 00:57:44.280
<v Candace Avalos>It's just that for the last 1 and 5 years for parks, they are either general liability or auto liability.

662
00:57:45.594 --> 00:57:51.673
<v Loretta Smith>But those would be— employment claims would be included in that total claim numbers that we bring with the data.

663
00:57:51.722 --> 00:57:52.219
<v Paul Anderson>Thank you.

664
00:57:52.556 --> 00:57:53.155
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you very much.

665
00:57:53.286 --> 00:57:58.536
<v Sameer Kanal>And as a result, I don't feel a need to ask the other question, which is what are you doing about it if there hasn't been one in the last 5 years?

666
00:57:59.559 --> 00:57:59.822
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

667
00:58:00.887 --> 00:58:01.525
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

668
00:58:01.690 --> 00:58:02.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other questions?

669
00:58:05.099 --> 00:58:07.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Rebecca, do we have anybody signed up for public testimony?

670
00:58:08.985 --> 00:58:09.146
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

671
00:58:09.420 --> 00:58:13.340
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, councilors, any discussion about this agenda item?

672
00:58:17.192 --> 00:58:19.085
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you so much for being here with us.

673
00:58:19.445 --> 00:58:19.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

674
00:58:19.769 --> 00:58:21.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

675
00:58:23.610 --> 00:58:24.608
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

676
00:58:25.237 --> 00:58:25.286
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

677
00:58:26.608 --> 00:58:26.914
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

678
00:58:27.108 --> 00:58:27.188
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

679
00:58:28.155 --> 00:58:28.688
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

680
00:58:29.108 --> 00:58:29.123
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

681
00:58:29.672 --> 00:58:30.074
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

682
00:58:30.559 --> 00:58:30.606
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

683
00:58:31.429 --> 00:58:31.688
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

684
00:58:32.983 --> 00:58:45.684
<v Steve Novick>Um, based on the detailed briefing I received in this earlier, it seems clear that this person was fired for reasons that absolutely nothing— for inappropriate behavior that had nothing to do with the original inappropriate comment by his supervisor.

685
00:58:46.282 --> 00:58:50.766
<v Steve Novick>So I'm not convinced that we should pay $100,000, so I vote nay.

686
00:58:53.409 --> 00:58:53.666
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

687
00:58:54.070 --> 00:58:54.199
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

688
00:58:54.795 --> 00:58:55.021
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

689
00:58:55.762 --> 00:58:55.809
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

690
00:58:56.503 --> 00:58:56.856
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

691
00:58:57.614 --> 00:58:57.710
<v Tim McCormick>No.

692
00:59:01.021 --> 00:59:01.101
<v Molly Hogan>Aye.

693
00:59:02.137 --> 00:59:02.152
<v Heather Riggs>Aye.

694
00:59:05.289 --> 00:59:10.005
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate Councilor Novick's comments.

695
00:59:10.360 --> 00:59:26.320
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am willing to take our attorney's advice to support this, but I do hope that we are I think it's important that we are careful with our budget, that we are judicious with these decisions, and that when we receive recommendations like this, it is because it really is the most cost-effective thing for the city.

696
00:59:27.719 --> 00:59:32.485
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When there are cases where it does not appear that we have done any wrongdoing, I will vote aye.

697
00:59:34.547 --> 00:59:36.869
<v Rebecca Dobert>With 10 ayes, the ordinance is passed.

698
00:59:43.581 --> 00:59:47.557
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I missed you on this, or are you in the queue on something as we move to the next agenda item?

699
00:59:47.670 --> 00:59:59.693
<v Loretta Smith>It's just to wrap up what you just said, and I think all of us received a, a more detailed, um, description of what actually happened.

700
01:00:00.880 --> 01:00:16.047
<v Loretta Smith>And I think if you go back and go over what we received from the, from the attorneys earlier in the week, it It gave a history and a pattern and a practice, and that's important.

701
01:00:16.512 --> 01:00:18.260
<v Loretta Smith>Is there a pattern and a practice?

702
01:00:19.333 --> 01:00:22.893
<v Loretta Smith>And there was pattern and practice as I listened to it.

703
01:00:23.438 --> 01:00:24.978
<v Loretta Smith>So this is not us just giving money.

704
01:00:25.027 --> 01:00:30.686
<v Loretta Smith>You have to— you give the money when you find that there is a pattern and practice of us doing wrongdoing.

705
01:00:31.521 --> 01:00:35.898
<v Loretta Smith>It is not about us saving liability money.

706
01:00:37.028 --> 01:00:38.384
<v Loretta Smith>If we were wrong, we were wrong.

707
01:00:41.063 --> 01:00:41.418
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

708
01:00:42.382 --> 01:00:44.519
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

709
01:00:45.291 --> 01:00:48.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we do have one more settlement item to hear.

710
01:00:48.215 --> 01:00:50.804
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call agenda item 14?

711
01:00:51.559 --> 01:01:02.398
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pay settlement of Amber Williams' bodily injury claim for $81,589 resulting from a motor vehicle collision involving the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

712
01:01:04.460 --> 01:01:04.960
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

713
01:01:05.010 --> 01:01:07.581
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe we have Joseph Jesse on this.

714
01:01:10.670 --> 01:01:10.880
<v Joseph Jesse>Yes.

715
01:01:11.722 --> 01:01:12.385
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, perfect.

716
01:01:12.449 --> 01:01:12.773
<v Rashid Yusufi>Can you—.

717
01:01:13.097 --> 01:01:13.257
<v Joseph Jesse>Okay.

718
01:01:13.905 --> 01:01:27.164
<v Joseph Jesse>So this claim arises out of a motor vehicle collision involving a PBOT— I'm sorry, a PBOT dump truck, large vehicle moving heading west on Morrison Bridge.

719
01:01:28.099 --> 01:01:29.576
<v Joseph Jesse>It was merging into the far right lane.

720
01:01:30.282 --> 01:01:33.588
<v Joseph Jesse>Early in the morning on a Tuesday back on March 28th, 2023.

721
01:01:35.427 --> 01:01:44.646
<v Joseph Jesse>It clipped the driver's side rear of a 2020 Honda Civic that had our claimant in it, Ms. Williams.

722
01:01:45.311 --> 01:01:55.907
<v Joseph Jesse>This caused the vehicle to spin in front of our vehicle, which caused a secondary impact where we essentially T-boned the driver's side door of that vehicle.

723
01:01:56.512 --> 01:02:01.025
<v Joseph Jesse>It was at relatively low speed, but this is a larger truck that caused the damage.

724
01:02:02.054 --> 01:02:12.621
<v Joseph Jesse>First notice we received of this was a letter of representation from a claimant attorney stating that they would be providing a demand package upon the completion of their client's treatment.

725
01:02:13.456 --> 01:02:31.806
<v Joseph Jesse>We received that demand package and medical details at that time and were able to resolve based on the damages for the amount thank you.

726
01:02:33.032 --> 01:02:35.063
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do you have information to add for us?

727
01:02:35.960 --> 01:02:37.059
<v Mark Williams>Uh, good morning, Madam President.

728
01:02:37.284 --> 01:02:38.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Excuse me.

729
01:02:38.400 --> 01:02:39.273
<v Mark Williams>Uh, good morning, councilors.

730
01:02:39.371 --> 01:02:40.244
<v Mark Williams>My name is Mark Williams.

731
01:02:40.340 --> 01:02:46.280
<v Mark Williams>I'm the Chief Administrative Officer for PBOT, and I'm just here to answer any questions that you might have about this case.

732
01:02:46.764 --> 01:02:47.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

733
01:02:47.264 --> 01:02:47.615
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

734
01:02:48.110 --> 01:02:49.634
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, any questions?

735
01:02:50.146 --> 01:02:51.094
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

736
01:02:52.472 --> 01:03:01.873
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanna note for the record on this, we could do this a lot faster in the future if it was just in the written document and save us the time of having this question be asked in the council meetings.

737
01:03:01.922 --> 01:03:07.329
<v Sameer Kanal>I know our time is limited here, so I'd encourage you again at Risk Management to put this in writing.

738
01:03:07.713 --> 01:03:17.163
<v Sameer Kanal>But with that said, could you speak to the, or could Risk Management speak to the aggregate amount of money that's paid out by PBOT for the last year and the last 5 years?

739
01:03:18.880 --> 01:03:19.284
<v Loretta Smith>Absolutely.

740
01:03:19.559 --> 01:03:28.335
<v Joseph Jesse>Um, so regarding this, total paid by PBOT is $27,253.98 for the last fiscal year.

741
01:03:29.365 --> 01:03:29.594
<v Joseph Jesse>Paid—.

742
01:03:30.737 --> 01:03:33.007
<v Joseph Jesse>Of that, expenses paid was $2,161.91.

743
01:03:34.994 --> 01:03:37.563
<v Joseph Jesse>Total property damage paid is $25,092.07.

744
01:03:39.710 --> 01:03:43.929
<v Joseph Jesse>Um, there has been no bodily injury paid in the past fiscal year.

745
01:03:44.139 --> 01:03:51.849
<v Joseph Jesse>And then let's see here, sorry, for 5 years it is total paid out is $1,594,611.52.

746
01:03:55.170 --> 01:04:06.320
<v Joseph Jesse>Of that, property damage paid is $631,767.35, bodily injury $407,800— or $407,823.36.

747
01:04:06.320 --> 01:04:06.360
<v Joseph Jesse>Thank you.

748
01:04:09.849 --> 01:04:17.168
<v Joseph Jesse>Expense, $93,102.57, and legal, $461,918.24.

749
01:04:19.338 --> 01:04:20.206
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mr. Jesse.

750
01:04:20.318 --> 01:04:33.655
<v Sameer Kanal>And to Mr. Williams, could you speak to anything that's happened subsequent to this incident or which is ongoing now at PBOT, uh, to ensure that incidents like this are less likely and we're not asked to, to pay out settlements on it in the future?

751
01:04:34.130 --> 01:04:35.445
<v Mark Williams>Sure, thank you, Councilor Kanal.

752
01:04:35.831 --> 01:04:47.697
<v Mark Williams>Uh, first I will, um, share with the council that anytime there's an incident like this, there is a crash analysis review board, and that's made up of several representatives of several bureaus.

753
01:04:48.452 --> 01:05:04.762
<v Mark Williams>And what they do is they review the incident report, any available evidence, they review the training history for that particular driver, they review the driving history for that particular driver, and they make a determination as to whether that particular incident was preventable or not.

754
01:05:05.862 --> 01:05:16.398
<v Mark Williams>After that, that particular driver will work with their supervisor regarding any additional training that may be needed, or if this is a number of repeat issues, it may lead to a disciplinary issue.

755
01:05:18.257 --> 01:05:18.869
<v Sameer Kanal>And is any—.

756
01:05:18.869 --> 01:05:19.677
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Excuse me—.

757
01:05:20.001 --> 01:05:24.762
<v Sameer Kanal>Is any of that new, or is that an ongoing practice for a number of years now?

758
01:05:25.021 --> 01:05:27.088
<v Mark Williams>This is an ongoing practice for a number of years.

759
01:05:28.661 --> 01:05:28.914
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

760
01:05:29.083 --> 01:05:29.911
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

761
01:05:32.139 --> 01:05:33.490
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, any other questions?

762
01:05:36.800 --> 01:05:39.505
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Rebecca, do we have anyone signed up for public testimony?

763
01:05:39.989 --> 01:05:40.795
<v Rebecca Dobert>No one is signed up.

764
01:05:41.664 --> 01:05:43.244
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, any discussion?

765
01:05:46.556 --> 01:05:46.782
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>None.

766
01:05:46.878 --> 01:05:48.358
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

767
01:05:49.291 --> 01:05:50.208
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanell?

768
01:05:50.338 --> 01:05:50.385
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Aye.

769
01:05:51.157 --> 01:05:51.447
<v Melissa Kostelecky>Ryan?

770
01:05:51.786 --> 01:05:51.802
<v Javier Alomia>Aye.

771
01:05:52.284 --> 01:05:52.896
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

772
01:05:53.313 --> 01:05:53.346
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

773
01:05:54.644 --> 01:05:54.693
<v Emily Dumerck>Aye.

774
01:05:55.211 --> 01:05:55.648
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

775
01:05:55.876 --> 01:05:55.956
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

776
01:05:56.588 --> 01:05:56.992
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

777
01:05:57.235 --> 01:05:57.268
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

778
01:05:57.641 --> 01:05:57.949
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

779
01:05:58.369 --> 01:05:58.418
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

780
01:05:58.952 --> 01:05:59.342
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

781
01:05:59.666 --> 01:05:59.681
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

782
01:06:00.152 --> 01:06:00.460
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

783
01:06:00.719 --> 01:06:00.768
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

784
01:06:01.221 --> 01:06:01.594
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

785
01:06:01.934 --> 01:06:01.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

786
01:06:02.208 --> 01:06:02.646
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

787
01:06:02.985 --> 01:06:03.099
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

788
01:06:03.485 --> 01:06:03.936
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

789
01:06:04.434 --> 01:06:04.483
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

790
01:06:05.094 --> 01:06:05.675
<v Rebecca Dobert>12 ayes.

791
01:06:05.739 --> 01:06:06.577
<v Rebecca Dobert>The ordinance is passed.

792
01:06:07.108 --> 01:06:07.994
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

793
01:06:08.782 --> 01:06:12.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here, councilors.

794
01:06:12.340 --> 01:06:38.237
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We now have 2 agenda items that have come out of committee, and, um, As we take on the work of ordinances and resolutions that councilors have brought forward that have come through committee, what we'll do is start with a committee staff summary to give councilors who are not in that committee an understanding of what the conversation was in committee.

795
01:06:38.766 --> 01:06:45.688
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll ask the councilor who presided over the committee meeting or meetings to add anything to that summary.

796
01:06:46.057 --> 01:06:57.715
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll then ask the person who brought the ordinance or resolution forward to share with us what their intent is in bringing this forward and any other information they'd like us to have.

797
01:06:58.550 --> 01:07:12.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can spend some time on technical questions, and then we'll move— before we move into the meat of our policy discussion— to public testimony so that we make sure that the comments from the public inform our policy discussion.

798
01:07:12.981 --> 01:07:21.052
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Then we'll move into our discussion and voting on any amendments that there may be and on the final resolutions and ordinances.

799
01:07:21.806 --> 01:07:26.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So with that, Rebecca, could you please call agenda item number 15 for us?

800
01:07:28.063 --> 01:07:35.764
<v Rebecca Dobert>Require the city administrator to study alternative housing financing and ownership models and deliver a report of findings to council.

801
01:07:36.726 --> 01:07:37.143
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

802
01:07:38.411 --> 01:07:44.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Claire Adamsick was the Council Operations Policy Analyst who works with our Homelessness and Housing Committee.

803
01:07:44.844 --> 01:07:47.648
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Claire, could you go ahead and give us your staff summary?

804
01:07:50.800 --> 01:07:52.246
<v Claire Adamsick>Good morning, Madam President and councilors.

805
01:07:52.423 --> 01:07:56.862
<v Claire Adamsick>For the record, Claire Adamsick from Council Operations and staff to the Homelessness and Housing Committee.

806
01:07:57.989 --> 01:08:12.489
<v Claire Adamsick>The resolution before you, document number 2025-101, directs the city administrator through the Portland Housing Bureau To submit a report to council on alternative models of housing financing and ownership no later than May 31st, 2026.

807
01:08:13.307 --> 01:08:26.797
<v Claire Adamsick>The report must include analysis and evaluation of social housing models, municipal nonprofit and cooperative ownership, and financing models that efficiently leverage public subsidy to expand housing options across income levels for Portland residents.

808
01:08:27.600 --> 01:08:43.944
<v Claire Adamsick>The resolution also directs PHB to evaluate domestic and international alternative housing models, identify applicability of existing models to the city's current housing landscape, and provide a set of policy recommendations including potential funding mechanisms that may be used to implement such recommendations.

809
01:08:45.085 --> 01:08:53.502
<v Claire Adamsick>The full impact statement on this item includes a financial and budget analysis that notes that existing Housing Bureau funds may be used to complete this study.

810
01:08:54.641 --> 01:08:58.481
<v Claire Adamsick>And public testimony in committee at the committee meeting on March 25th.

811
01:08:59.398 --> 01:09:01.453
<v Claire Adamsick>6 people provided verbal testimony.

812
01:09:01.967 --> 01:09:10.707
<v Claire Adamsick>Another 26 people submitted written testimony prior to committee action, and 1 person submitted testimony after the committee meeting and prior to the posting of this council agenda.

813
01:09:11.447 --> 01:09:30.358
<v Claire Adamsick>The general themes in the testimony the committee heard included a high proportion of rent-burdened households in Portland and the resulting loss in economic activity for the region, expanding permanent housing options for people exiting homelessness, the current experiences of Portlanders with displacement due to market forces and limited wealth-building opportunities.

814
01:09:31.832 --> 01:09:37.408
<v Claire Adamsick>The opportunity to explore successful models in Vienna, Austria, and other cities nationally and internationally.

815
01:09:38.546 --> 01:09:43.818
<v Claire Adamsick>Ensuring any future housing developed using this model is held to rigorous health and safety standards.

816
01:09:44.555 --> 01:09:52.492
<v Claire Adamsick>And finally, a request for an expedited timeline or more frequent updates from the Portland Housing Bureau on the findings of the study as it progresses.

817
01:09:54.010 --> 01:09:55.515
<v Claire Adamsick>And that concludes the committee report.

818
01:10:00.689 --> 01:10:04.490
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos, I believe you presided over this committee meeting in your committee.

819
01:10:04.621 --> 01:10:06.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Would you like to add anything to that report?

820
01:10:07.417 --> 01:10:13.284
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, and I will do my, uh, as the chair but also as the co-sponsor of the bill right now.

821
01:10:13.527 --> 01:10:14.349
<v Candace Avalos>I'll do that speech.

822
01:10:14.413 --> 01:10:14.993
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You both together?

823
01:10:15.203 --> 01:10:16.025
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I'm going to do both together.

824
01:10:16.171 --> 01:10:16.363
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

825
01:10:18.033 --> 01:10:26.664
<v Candace Avalos>All right, well, I am really pleased to be a chief co-sponsor of this resolution with Councilor Green and with Councilors Koyama Lane and Kanal.

826
01:10:27.563 --> 01:10:35.969
<v Candace Avalos>As the chair of the Homelessness and Housing Committee, I'm more aware than most of the dire situation that our city is in when it comes to providing housing to meet everyone's needs.

827
01:10:36.546 --> 01:10:40.782
<v Candace Avalos>We are far behind the curve in production, financing, and affordability.

828
01:10:41.375 --> 01:10:51.606
<v Candace Avalos>And part of why we are behind is because we have spent the majority of our time since the housing crisis was declared over 10 years ago responding haphazardly and without a unified vision for how we solve homelessness.

829
01:10:52.199 --> 01:11:04.942
<v Candace Avalos>That is why I'll be leading a process to get us to a unified housing plan that creates a single theory of change and ties together the various agreements, roles, and funding streams into a system that supports individuals through the entire spectrum of housing need.

830
01:11:05.487 --> 01:11:21.112
<v Candace Avalos>We need to be creative and think deeply about all options that have proven to be successful in other communities, and I'm excited to see the results of the study because I believe that social housing can be an important piece with that, I will pass it on to my chief co-sponsor, Councilor Green.

831
01:11:23.046 --> 01:11:31.983
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor, and thank you for your partnership as a chief co-sponsor of this resolution, and to my co-sponsors Koyama Lane and Kanal for supporting this.

832
01:11:32.435 --> 01:11:35.265
<v Mitch Green>I'll keep my comments brief and get straight to the point.

833
01:11:35.747 --> 01:11:41.693
<v Mitch Green>Portland is in a housing crisis that demands bold solutions and frankly system change.

834
01:11:42.256 --> 01:11:49.545
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, we have been responding to that crisis responding as sort of a reaction to the scarcity of affordable housing in this city for a long time.

835
01:11:49.592 --> 01:12:03.108
<v Mitch Green>And so the intention of this resolution is to empower the Portland Housing Bureau to unlock its expertise and have the explicit direction to go out and study new ways of doing housing production, in particular social housing.

836
01:12:03.845 --> 01:12:08.605
<v Mitch Green>And the idea here is that Director Hissrich has studied social housing.

837
01:12:08.654 --> 01:12:13.576
<v Mitch Green>She's studied the best practices around the world and just needs guidance from council.

838
01:12:13.640 --> 01:12:14.009
<v Joseph Jesse>We're giving—.

839
01:12:14.009 --> 01:12:14.248
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Herbold.

840
01:12:14.426 --> 01:12:15.710
<v Mitch Green>Heard that guidance at this point.

841
01:12:15.806 --> 01:12:23.305
<v Mitch Green>And so, um, over the course of this year, we're going to have check-ins, we're going to have a community engagement process that brings people along.

842
01:12:23.738 --> 01:12:36.375
<v Mitch Green>But the idea is to say, how can we apply those successes we've seen elsewhere in other cities, in other parts of the world, to Portland with its unique institutions, its market, and, and so on and so forth?

843
01:12:36.439 --> 01:12:47.701
<v Mitch Green>And so the idea here is what we will have at the end of that process is a document that is rigorous, that has been vetted, and that we can then move forward with an ordinance that will stand the test of time.

844
01:12:47.748 --> 01:12:58.332
<v Mitch Green>So that way, when we look back in 20 years, our children and their children are going to say this council took action to end housing precarity forever.

845
01:12:58.750 --> 01:13:00.658
<v Mitch Green>And so, colleagues, I hope that you support this today.

846
01:13:01.139 --> 01:13:01.460
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

847
01:13:02.164 --> 01:13:07.891
<v Mitch Green>Oh, and by the way, if you're here to support our testimony or this resolution today, I thank you so much.

848
01:13:07.956 --> 01:13:16.729
<v Mitch Green>We do have a huge volume of people testifying, so if you're willing, I would just say I support, and then keep your comments brief.

849
01:13:16.778 --> 01:13:20.595
<v Mitch Green>That'll help us move through all the public testimony we have today, and so everyone gets heard.

850
01:13:20.676 --> 01:13:22.270
<v Mitch Green>So thank you for that consideration.

851
01:13:24.273 --> 01:13:25.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, councilors.

852
01:13:26.043 --> 01:13:42.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, are there any questions about the staff summary, the overview from our We'll get to the meat of our discussion a little later, but any questions about what we've heard and what occurred in committee and, and why we're hearing this?

853
01:13:42.967 --> 01:13:43.680
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

854
01:13:44.762 --> 01:13:44.972
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

855
01:13:45.167 --> 01:13:45.863
<v Eric Zimmerman>I was hoping—.

856
01:13:46.380 --> 01:13:53.144
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can we just— I want to just reiterate any deliverables that we have from this in terms of date when a report can be expected by council.

857
01:13:54.152 --> 01:13:55.354
<v Eric Zimmerman>What kind of stuff are we looking at?

858
01:13:58.309 --> 01:14:07.730
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, I believe that's a question, Claire, to you about the substance of the resolution and when we should expect the report to be returned to council.

859
01:14:07.828 --> 01:14:15.519
<v Eric Zimmerman>I ask it in a world of we, we are trying to be action-oriented and not be bogged down by study.

860
01:14:15.775 --> 01:14:22.712
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think always laying out where expectations are for deliverables is, is a good thing, because I think Councilor Green knows that I supported it in committee.

861
01:14:22.775 --> 01:14:26.356
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll be supporting it today, but I think it's good for the public to have an idea for what are we undertaking.

862
01:14:26.854 --> 01:14:26.966
<v Claire Adamsick>Yes.

863
01:14:27.256 --> 01:14:48.131
<v Claire Adamsick>Um, Councilor Zimmerman, my— and the council, um, my understanding, and as the resolution indicates, that, um, the report directs the Portland Housing Bureau, or the city administrator through the Portland Housing Bureau, to report to council by May 31st, 2026.

864
01:14:48.194 --> 01:14:49.210
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Did you have a question?

865
01:14:49.949 --> 01:14:51.905
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I just want a direct response because it's important.

866
01:14:51.987 --> 01:15:10.405
<v Mitch Green>There's, there's nuance here, which is that we don't wait until It's not laid out in the resolution, but the director, I think, has committed to a quarterly process, and she's very amenable to being flexible in how we can move forward in a way that enables us to be an action-oriented council.

867
01:15:11.899 --> 01:15:12.666
<v Mitch Green>So I appreciate the comment.

868
01:15:13.564 --> 01:15:15.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe the director is online.

869
01:15:17.500 --> 01:15:22.338
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you would like to— Director Hisarick, if you would like to respond to the timing question.

870
01:15:25.586 --> 01:15:28.291
<v Helmi Hissrich>Thank you for the opportunity to respond.

871
01:15:28.421 --> 01:15:31.912
<v Helmi Hissrich>I'm Helmi Hisarik, Director of Portland Housing Bureau, for the record.

872
01:15:33.250 --> 01:15:35.471
<v Helmi Hissrich>We are in the process of scoping this plan.

873
01:15:35.858 --> 01:15:57.435
<v Helmi Hissrich>We think that the social housing study actually has multiple facets, so we'll be presenting a quarterly— at a minimum, we will have quarterly report backs to council at the committee level on, on The findings of the report, but before we embark on the study, we will put together a scoping document showing specific deliverables and timelines throughout the year.

874
01:15:58.001 --> 01:16:04.292
<v Helmi Hissrich>And our anticipation is that we'd come back within a year with recommendations based on the study that we've presented.

875
01:16:06.548 --> 01:16:07.914
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

876
01:16:08.783 --> 01:16:09.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

877
01:16:10.292 --> 01:16:11.529
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam Chair.

878
01:16:12.960 --> 01:16:16.931
<v Olivia Clark>In a cursory review of this, I didn't see anything about studying impediments.

879
01:16:17.497 --> 01:16:20.693
<v Olivia Clark>Is that something that you intend to do?

880
01:16:21.047 --> 01:16:28.016
<v Olivia Clark>What prevents us from being a stronger housing market here?

881
01:16:28.774 --> 01:16:30.145
<v Olivia Clark>What stands in our way?

882
01:16:30.225 --> 01:16:31.418
<v Olivia Clark>Is that a part of your resolution?

883
01:16:34.868 --> 01:16:37.029
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, would either of you like to respond to that question?

884
01:16:37.690 --> 01:16:39.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors Green or Avalos?

885
01:16:39.805 --> 01:17:09.573
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I'm going to find the specific line item in here, but I think the intention for the the purpose of this study is for Helmi and her team to deliver sort of a Portland-grounded roadmap if we want to pursue some other avenues, which would implicitly say here would be some challenges and roadblocks in this city that we would have to overcome, such as financing, such as code changes, any of the like, to make possible any of the potential solutions.

886
01:17:09.621 --> 01:17:09.944
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

887
01:17:10.590 --> 01:17:13.356
<v Mitch Green>My understanding is that's pretty implicit in the intent of this.

888
01:17:15.340 --> 01:17:18.279
<v Olivia Clark>Would you be amenable to actually calling that out?

889
01:17:18.649 --> 01:17:20.916
<v Olivia Clark>I don't have specific language right now.

890
01:17:20.979 --> 01:17:25.451
<v Olivia Clark>I can work on some real fast, but it seems like we ought to also be addressing impediments.

891
01:17:27.194 --> 01:17:28.536
<v Olivia Clark>And I don't just mean financing.

892
01:17:28.632 --> 01:17:37.543
<v Olivia Clark>I mean, I'm really thinking about our zoning code, our permitting process, the kinds of things that stand in the way of building, uh, housing.

893
01:17:38.661 --> 01:17:42.094
<v Candace Avalos>I believe, you know, I hear you and it sounds like you want something explicit.

894
01:17:42.141 --> 01:17:45.880
<v Candace Avalos>I feel like it is implicitly wrapped in this entire study.

895
01:17:46.090 --> 01:17:50.615
<v Candace Avalos>The goal of the study is to explore absolutely every avenue, which would of course include impediments.

896
01:17:50.680 --> 01:17:52.323
<v Candace Avalos>I'd be open to something.

897
01:17:52.386 --> 01:17:58.551
<v Candace Avalos>I don't have anything prepared though, and I don't know where that could naturally fit in, but I can assure you that that is being taken into consideration.

898
01:18:01.543 --> 01:18:02.403
<v Sahan McKelvey>If I If I may.

899
01:18:03.524 --> 01:18:11.110
<v Mitch Green>And Councilor, with your, with your assent on a friendly, I, I would think the most appropriate place to add that at the last be it further resolved.

900
01:18:11.961 --> 01:18:24.502
<v Mitch Green>It says it is recommended that report include a number of elements, but the very last piece is a set of policy and programmatic recommendations, comma, to include identification of any impediments.

901
01:18:25.238 --> 01:18:26.377
<v Mitch Green>Would that be perfect?

902
01:18:26.842 --> 01:18:27.756
<v Mitch Green>Would that be satisfactory?

903
01:18:29.804 --> 01:18:38.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we do have a lot of public testimony, which will give us an opportunity, I think, if you want to try to workshop something while we're hearing from the public.

904
01:18:40.149 --> 01:18:40.454
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

905
01:18:40.904 --> 01:18:41.515
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

906
01:18:42.029 --> 01:18:44.601
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Madam President.

907
01:18:45.229 --> 01:18:50.908
<v Dan Ryan>I saw that there was no financial impact stated in the resolution, which really can't be true.

908
01:18:50.990 --> 01:18:53.024
<v Dan Ryan>In fact, we just agreed to do quarterly reports.

909
01:18:53.743 --> 01:18:58.712
<v Dan Ryan>My question is, how many staff will be working on this, and what is the financial impact?

910
01:19:00.948 --> 01:19:10.094
<v Claire Adamsick>Councilor Ryan, I would defer to Director Hisarick to maybe speak to the specifics of the existing Housing Bureau funding, as I understand it, that would be used and what the staff would look like.

911
01:19:10.141 --> 01:19:10.336
<v Rashid Yusufi>Absolutely.

912
01:19:10.384 --> 01:19:11.817
<v Dan Ryan>I'm glad the director joined us.

913
01:19:12.766 --> 01:19:18.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Director Hisarick, the analysis that we have from the budget office says no fiscal impacts as the resolution requires.

914
01:19:32.390 --> 01:19:34.430
<v Helmi Hissrich>Yes, thank you for the question.

915
01:19:35.119 --> 01:19:47.250
<v Helmi Hissrich>We have specifically gone after federal funding for the study of alternative strategies or alternative ownership models through a pro-housing grant, which we were awarded.

916
01:19:47.822 --> 01:19:49.680
<v Helmi Hissrich>The grant is not yet appropriated.

917
01:19:49.744 --> 01:20:01.730
<v Helmi Hissrich>It'll be appropriated for fiscal year 25-26, and using those funds, we anticipate looking at various elements of the, um, of the social housing model.

918
01:20:02.307 --> 01:20:07.627
<v Helmi Hissrich>Uh, and so that's our primary source of funding for this work.

919
01:20:08.317 --> 01:20:12.819
<v Helmi Hissrich>Uh, we have not allocated the staff or decided which staff is doing what.

920
01:20:12.884 --> 01:20:14.939
<v Helmi Hissrich>That's part of our scoping process right now.

921
01:20:15.148 --> 01:20:23.506
<v Helmi Hissrich>So we're, we're, uh, again, when we come back with our scope, we'll identify specifically who will be leading different segments of the study.

922
01:20:26.390 --> 01:20:27.969
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, that's helpful to hear.

923
01:20:28.340 --> 01:20:40.939
<v Dan Ryan>I do think considering where we're at with our budget, and clearly the most important expense we have is labor, but it's really important that we identify how much that will take to pull this off.

924
01:20:42.222 --> 01:20:42.655
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

925
01:20:43.587 --> 01:20:54.962
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, and while you're there, while I have you, what about the studies that we've been hearing about around the fair ordinances that were passed in 2018, some of the tenant rights passages?

926
01:20:55.139 --> 01:21:00.081
<v Dan Ryan>We haven't received those reports yet, so I wanted to hear how those studies are coming along.

927
01:21:01.154 --> 01:21:03.899
<v Helmi Hissrich>We have not started a study on the fair ordinance.

928
01:21:03.962 --> 01:21:21.930
<v Helmi Hissrich>It's been asked, requested that we study the fair ordinance this year, so that's in our proposed work program, but we have not yet identified funding for that study, and we are also in the process of scoping what that is, although that is a priority for the, for the Bureau to, to do the fare ordinance study.

929
01:21:23.087 --> 01:21:30.604
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, and perhaps in the Housing Committee we can look at an ordinance to remind that that would be nice to receive as well from the administration.

930
01:21:30.779 --> 01:21:31.118
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

931
01:21:32.242 --> 01:21:34.506
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, technical questions?

932
01:21:34.570 --> 01:21:44.007
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, just wanted to clarify something that Director Hystrich just said in in terms of allocating the staff or deciding which staff is doing what, does that imply that this will be done in-house?

933
01:21:47.087 --> 01:21:47.344
<v Helmi Hissrich>No.

934
01:21:47.810 --> 01:21:48.551
<v Helmi Hissrich>Yes and no.

935
01:21:49.599 --> 01:21:54.043
<v Helmi Hissrich>We will be bringing in outside consultants to evaluate different components.

936
01:21:54.494 --> 01:21:57.305
<v Helmi Hissrich>However, social housing isn't one thing, it's multiple things.

937
01:21:57.418 --> 01:22:02.497
<v Helmi Hissrich>So for example, contained in the study, one of the things that we may be studying is land banking.

938
01:22:02.960 --> 01:22:10.109
<v Helmi Hissrich>We have specific staff who works with property and real estate, so we would ask them to lead the land banking effort with outside consultants.

939
01:22:10.720 --> 01:22:13.725
<v Helmi Hissrich>Separately, there's an analysis of financing.

940
01:22:13.822 --> 01:22:20.377
<v Helmi Hissrich>We have a finance team, so financing in the social housing model is different than our current low-income housing tax credit model.

941
01:22:20.747 --> 01:22:23.895
<v Helmi Hissrich>We'll ask our financing staff to lead the financing study.

942
01:22:23.961 --> 01:22:31.923
<v Helmi Hissrich>So we have yet to allocate which staff person and how much FTE will be needed for each element of this, of the study.

943
01:22:31.988 --> 01:22:33.560
<v Helmi Hissrich>That's what the scoping process is.

944
01:22:34.810 --> 01:22:35.082
<v Sameer Kanal>Great.

945
01:22:35.179 --> 01:22:41.625
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, anytime we're talking about some or all of it being in-house is a good time for, for, from my perspective.

946
01:22:41.672 --> 01:22:42.971
<v Sameer Kanal>So I appreciate that clarification.

947
01:22:43.149 --> 01:22:49.065
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I don't see any other technical questions in the queue.

948
01:22:49.242 --> 01:22:51.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, Claire, thank you.

949
01:22:51.149 --> 01:22:58.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will note that there was a typo in the summary that we have, um, that I was just asked to flag.

950
01:22:58.722 --> 01:23:01.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It says the vote was 3-1 but lists 4 aye votes.

951
01:23:01.939 --> 01:23:03.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The vote was 4-0.

952
01:23:03.788 --> 01:23:06.153
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The clerk's dispensation out of committee was correct.

953
01:23:06.201 --> 01:23:08.966
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was just a typo on the sheet that was brought before us.

954
01:23:09.238 --> 01:23:17.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, so in case there were any questions from folks watching online about the discrepancy there, the aye votes listed is correct.

955
01:23:18.228 --> 01:23:19.354
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was a 4-0 vote.

956
01:23:20.569 --> 01:23:22.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, are you back in the queue, or is that a former hand?

957
01:23:22.578 --> 01:23:23.027
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, I'm not.

958
01:23:23.094 --> 01:23:23.243
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

959
01:23:23.586 --> 01:23:25.335
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, legacy hand.

960
01:23:25.527 --> 01:23:26.442
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, great.

961
01:23:27.613 --> 01:23:30.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Claire, for being here with us today.

962
01:23:31.127 --> 01:23:34.769
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Rebecca, I believe we have a significant amount of public testimony signed up.

963
01:23:35.859 --> 01:23:37.158
<v Rebecca Dobert>We have 20 people signed up.

964
01:23:37.384 --> 01:23:38.377
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Fantastic.

965
01:23:38.859 --> 01:23:41.715
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we will be calling folks up.

966
01:23:41.876 --> 01:23:43.849
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You will have 2 minutes to testify.

967
01:23:44.057 --> 01:23:54.622
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You'll hear a chime when you have 30 seconds left and then an additional chime when your time is and Rebecca, if you want to call folks up 3 at a time, why don't we jump in?

968
01:23:55.539 --> 01:24:01.360
<v Rebecca Dobert>First, we have Travis Noddings, John Knight, and Jenna Knobloch.

969
01:24:03.939 --> 01:24:04.235
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

970
01:24:04.284 --> 01:24:05.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for being here.

971
01:24:12.381 --> 01:24:12.850
<v Travis Noddings>Shall I start?

972
01:24:13.530 --> 01:24:15.493
<v Travis Noddings>Hi, thank you for letting me be here.

973
01:24:15.541 --> 01:24:16.578
<v Travis Noddings>My name is TJ Noddings.

974
01:24:16.862 --> 01:24:23.239
<v Travis Noddings>I am a housing justice organizer here in Portland, as well as a tenant advocate at Community Alliance of Tenants.

975
01:24:23.304 --> 01:24:29.009
<v Travis Noddings>So I spend a majority of both my professional and personal life talking to renters all over this city.

976
01:24:29.746 --> 01:24:37.005
<v Travis Noddings>And I'm here in support of this agenda item, as well as the following agenda item on banning AI rental price fixing software.

977
01:24:37.453 --> 01:24:42.149
<v Travis Noddings>A majority of the conversations that I have with renters in our city center on affordability.

978
01:24:42.502 --> 01:24:48.860
<v Travis Noddings>And the fact that most renters believe that they will not be able to afford to live in this city much longer at all.

979
01:24:49.229 --> 01:25:01.578
<v Travis Noddings>When they invite me into their apartments, they'll show me mold growing on their walls, holes in the walls, ceilings, non-functioning appliances, inadequate heating and cooling, a list of maintenance and repairs that have been neglected by the landlord.

980
01:25:02.412 --> 01:25:14.118
<v Travis Noddings>And when they go to look for other apartments to move to, to move into better living conditions, they find that there are no better options, that the floor for minimum rent prices in the city has reached a point that they cannot afford.

981
01:25:14.470 --> 01:25:34.430
<v Travis Noddings>So they feel that they have to live in these conditions and watch their rent go up every single year despite the conditions of their housing getting worse, because as a function of the private market and as a function of landlords working together to collude on rental prices, they're stuck in these spots without better options to go to.

982
01:25:34.911 --> 01:25:48.623
<v Travis Noddings>At a recent renters town hall, a retired woman came to let us know that when she pays her rent from her fixed income, Social Security, every month, she's left with only $60 left to pay for food and other necessities, which is obviously not enough to live off of.

983
01:25:48.671 --> 01:25:57.198
<v Travis Noddings>And that's why adults over the age of 55 are the fastest growing demographic of homeless in our city, because the rent is rising faster than everyone's wages, everyone's income.

984
01:25:57.712 --> 01:26:14.414
<v Travis Noddings>So I ask the councilors, when you are deciding to vote on this ordinance for social housing and to ban AI rent price fixing, to keep that in mind and know that half of this city is made up of renters who are all struggling, and we're watching and hoping and pleading for help from this body.

985
01:26:14.868 --> 01:26:15.224
<v Travis Noddings>Thank you.

986
01:26:18.769 --> 01:26:19.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right ahead.

987
01:26:19.805 --> 01:26:24.375
<v John Knight>Hi, Councilor Green, President Pirtle-Guiney, Portland City Council.

988
01:26:24.538 --> 01:26:28.377
<v John Knight>Thank you for this opportunity to discuss the social housing future of My name is John Harris Knight.

989
01:26:28.873 --> 01:26:37.224
<v John Knight>I propose the following for inclusion in the study: a combination of public, private, and civil society sector ownership models into one housing system.

990
01:26:37.913 --> 01:26:46.408
<v John Knight>I imagine a 3-part structure, a triangular stability of a republic, if you will, with practical checks and balances that treats residents as equals.

991
01:26:46.761 --> 01:26:51.819
<v John Knight>One, households organized through democratic tenant resident unions comprised of fellow residents.

992
01:26:52.462 --> 01:26:56.520
<v John Knight>Residents will build a version of equity or rental pension, kind of like Social Security.

993
01:26:56.697 --> 01:27:00.131
<v John Knight>See UCLA's Shane Phillips's proposal in my written testimony.

994
01:27:01.125 --> 01:27:04.270
<v John Knight>This earned benefit will promote mobility throughout the social housing system.

995
01:27:05.201 --> 01:27:09.837
<v John Knight>The unions will share responsibility with the city and facility management to set standards.

996
01:27:10.335 --> 01:27:15.628
<v John Knight>The unions will have the authority to petition the city if services are inadequate or insufficiently responsive.

997
01:27:16.127 --> 01:27:22.197
<v John Knight>Tenant residents will finally feel an ownership-level connection to and responsibility for the places they live.

998
01:27:23.765 --> 01:27:29.104
<v John Knight>Community-based nonprofit or quasi-governmental, perhaps property management organizations.

999
01:27:29.573 --> 01:27:37.416
<v John Knight>They'll provide the necessary professional building management, be responsive to tenant residents, and reflect the diversity of our communities and the residents of social housing.

1000
01:27:38.050 --> 01:27:43.778
<v John Knight>Management organizations will confidently rely on the city's authority to protect our city's housing units from disrepair or degradation.

1001
01:27:45.167 --> 01:27:52.220
<v John Knight>The City of Portland, as a responsive and responsible partner in ending our housing crisis, and promoting democracy in a time when democracy is under assault.

1002
01:27:52.270 --> 01:28:12.360
<v John Knight>The city will be responsible for ensuring that tenant residents have monthly rates at or below cost, responsible for acquiring safe housing with qualities and amenities comparable to median housing of that size, establish official guidance and facilitation to support the development of democratic practices by tenant unions, and provide essential safeguards in case of mismanagement or disrepair.

1003
01:28:13.024 --> 01:28:13.347
<v John Knight>Thank you.

1004
01:28:14.810 --> 01:28:15.342
<v Helmi Hissrich>Thank you.

1005
01:28:15.649 --> 01:28:15.940
<v Helmi Hissrich>Go ahead.

1006
01:28:17.493 --> 01:28:19.627
<v Angelita Morillo>Hi everyone, my name is Jenna Knobloch.

1007
01:28:19.676 --> 01:28:25.480
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm a renter in District 3, and I'm here to testify in support of this resolution.

1008
01:28:25.578 --> 01:28:33.265
<v Angelita Morillo>I've been waiting a long time for City Council to actually consider big, bold solutions and not just biting around the edges of the housing crisis.

1009
01:28:34.050 --> 01:28:38.956
<v Angelita Morillo>And social housing is a big, bold solution, but it's not a radical one.

1010
01:28:39.213 --> 01:28:46.949
<v Angelita Morillo>It's a proven model that has been tried and had great results in cities across the country and across the world.

1011
01:28:47.029 --> 01:28:56.911
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm really excited for a report to help map out concrete next steps for Portland to see how this model could help address our housing crisis.

1012
01:28:57.426 --> 01:28:57.828
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1013
01:29:00.011 --> 01:29:02.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Being here, and we'll look at that written testimony.

1014
01:29:05.818 --> 01:29:07.846
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Mason Shepherd.

1015
01:29:08.162 --> 01:29:12.543
<v Rebecca Dobert>Michael Grigsby Lane— Grigsby Lane, excuse me— and Tim McCormick.

1016
01:29:19.935 --> 01:29:23.926
<v Rebecca Dobert>Mason Shepard, Michael Grigsby Lane, and Tim McCormick.

1017
01:29:24.073 --> 01:29:24.542
<v Rebecca Dobert>Tim is online.

1018
01:29:30.180 --> 01:29:32.162
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Tim, why don't you go ahead while we wait for others?

1019
01:29:40.386 --> 01:29:40.907
<v Rebecca Dobert>Tim, you're good to go.

1020
01:29:40.956 --> 01:29:42.972
<v Tim McCormick>Yeah, can you come back to me towards the end?

1021
01:29:43.021 --> 01:29:44.957
<v Tim McCormick>I'm just setting up here at my end.

1022
01:29:49.390 --> 01:29:50.966
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, you want to call the next group and then include Tim?

1023
01:29:51.015 --> 01:29:54.524
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah, I'm going to go to Brian Bloomklotz.

1024
01:29:56.166 --> 01:29:56.905
<v Rebecca Dobert>Is Brian here?

1025
01:29:56.987 --> 01:29:57.453
<v Rebecca Dobert>Brian Bloomklotz?

1026
01:29:59.519 --> 01:30:00.216
<v Rebecca Dobert>Donna Cohen.

1027
01:30:01.043 --> 01:30:02.082
<v Rebecca Dobert>Donna's also online.

1028
01:30:02.844 --> 01:30:03.784
<v Rebecca Dobert>And Heather Riggs.

1029
01:30:09.987 --> 01:30:11.145
<v Rebecca Dobert>Heather will start us off.

1030
01:30:12.000 --> 01:30:12.402
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1031
01:30:15.074 --> 01:30:18.635
<v Heather Riggs>Good morning, Madam President, councilors, and administrator.

1032
01:30:19.572 --> 01:30:28.368
<v Heather Riggs>I am Reverend Heather Riggs, pastor of Montavilla United Methodist Church in Southeast, and I live in the Mount Scott neighborhood.

1033
01:30:29.970 --> 01:30:41.435
<v Heather Riggs>Most mornings at my church begin with me saying, hey friend, it's time for you to get up and move on, to one of our houseless neighbors taking shelter in a porch on our church.

1034
01:30:42.355 --> 01:30:48.094
<v Heather Riggs>Because of this, my congregation represents— represented today by my lay leader DJ—.

1035
01:30:48.176 --> 01:30:49.242
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wave your hand, DJ.

1036
01:30:49.636 --> 01:30:49.685
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hi.

1037
01:30:50.060 --> 01:30:50.268
<v Helmi Hissrich>Thank you.

1038
01:30:50.475 --> 01:30:54.145
<v Heather Riggs>Has made supporting shelter and housing a priority.

1039
01:30:55.442 --> 01:31:05.470
<v Heather Riggs>Many of the unhoused folks I encounter in our neighborhood are experiencing mental health issues, physical health issues, and addiction disorder.

1040
01:31:06.095 --> 01:31:14.954
<v Heather Riggs>Many of these beloved children of God cannot successfully move directly from the sidewalk to a market-rate apartment.

1041
01:31:15.739 --> 01:31:23.368
<v Heather Riggs>My church is also a part of a coalition of faith communities who are interested in building housing on church-owned land.

1042
01:31:23.917 --> 01:31:34.886
<v Heather Riggs>We are supporting a bill in the state legislature that would release pre-development funds that would unlock this land for nonprofit affordable housing or social housing.

1043
01:31:36.579 --> 01:31:50.640
<v Heather Riggs>This resolution to study alternative housing financing and ownership models is a step in the right direction for helping churches like mine build nonprofit affordable supportive housing.

1044
01:31:51.380 --> 01:32:02.363
<v Heather Riggs>However, I will say that I would prefer that we skip the study and just move forward with this model that has been amply demonstrated to work in many other places.

1045
01:32:02.957 --> 01:32:15.376
<v Heather Riggs>Providing more affordable housing as soon as possible is a life-saving measure that benefits everyone in our city— businesses, Housed neighbors and unhoused neighbors.

1046
01:32:15.729 --> 01:32:16.197
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1047
01:32:18.451 --> 01:32:20.094
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1048
01:32:20.319 --> 01:32:22.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe our next folks are both online.

1049
01:32:22.251 --> 01:32:23.088
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct, Rebecca?

1050
01:32:23.220 --> 01:32:24.470
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah, Tim McCormick.

1051
01:32:24.552 --> 01:32:25.425
<v Rebecca Dobert>Tim, if you're ready.

1052
01:32:31.520 --> 01:32:31.698
<v Tim McCormick>Okay.

1053
01:32:31.974 --> 01:32:32.282
<v Tim McCormick>Oops.

1054
01:32:33.564 --> 01:32:34.212
<v Tim McCormick>Can you hear me?

1055
01:32:34.293 --> 01:32:34.488
<v Tim McCormick>Yeah.

1056
01:32:35.023 --> 01:32:35.623
<v Tim McCormick>Hi.

1057
01:32:35.689 --> 01:32:36.224
<v Tim McCormick>Good morning.

1058
01:32:36.807 --> 01:32:38.706
<v Tim McCormick>Good morning, councilors, staff.

1059
01:32:39.015 --> 01:32:39.673
<v Tim McCormick>And administrator.

1060
01:32:40.060 --> 01:32:41.023
<v Tim McCormick>My name is Tim McCormick.

1061
01:32:41.425 --> 01:32:50.850
<v Tim McCormick>I'm a longtime housing and homelessness advocate and a contributor writer for Sightline Institute, also co-founder of the Oregon Cooperative Housing Network.

1062
01:32:51.621 --> 01:32:59.600
<v Tim McCormick>And I'm fully in support of the general ideas here of, you know, finding all tools, seeing all the options.

1063
01:33:00.693 --> 01:33:13.123
<v Tim McCormick>However, from looking at the direction I see things going, I would I would have to have concerns about whether the process that's currently envisioned is likely to do that, that job of discovering all options.

1064
01:33:13.573 --> 01:33:21.252
<v Tim McCormick>So in an earlier life, before I worked in housing, I worked in Silicon Valley for many years, and I worked on many innovation programs— internal, public, civic.

1065
01:33:21.814 --> 01:33:28.706
<v Tim McCormick>And, you know, there are well-known principles about what you want to do if you want to truly solicit bold and varied solutions.

1066
01:33:29.283 --> 01:33:34.358
<v Tim McCormick>And essentially what you want to do is you don't want to empower one central party to deliver a report.

1067
01:33:35.079 --> 01:33:44.354
<v Tim McCormick>Rather, or in addition, what you want to do is essentially more like create a platform where unexpected and varied voices have permission, invitation, and welcome.

1068
01:33:45.029 --> 01:33:58.845
<v Tim McCormick>And so I'd like to offer that to the Portland Housing Bureau to consider that, you know, what might really be effective in the long run is, is not a report a year from now, but is the establishment of an open process.

1069
01:33:58.942 --> 01:33:59.167
<v Tim McCormick>Thank you.

1070
01:33:59.551 --> 01:34:08.476
<v Tim McCormick>Whereby, rather than a very politically constrained and closed process producing a report, you create an ecology where varied things can come forth.

1071
01:34:09.328 --> 01:34:12.506
<v Tim McCormick>And finally, just to— is that 30 seconds left?

1072
01:34:12.554 --> 01:34:13.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think 30 seconds.

1073
01:34:13.917 --> 01:34:14.528
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes, go ahead.

1074
01:34:14.640 --> 01:34:15.137
<v Tim McCormick>30 seconds.

1075
01:34:15.186 --> 01:34:15.443
<v Tim McCormick>Yeah.

1076
01:34:15.747 --> 01:34:24.110
<v Tim McCormick>And as an example, I just want to throw in a couple of things that just recently strike me as sort of signs that, you know, the ideas aren't necessarily getting through.

1077
01:34:24.512 --> 01:34:38.595
<v Tim McCormick>We just had a situation where actually, input from Prosper Portland, actual other city agencies, did not get it into the, um, the impact study on legislation that the city was considering.

1078
01:34:39.252 --> 01:34:40.904
<v Tim McCormick>Uh, and so that was an interesting case.

1079
01:34:41.594 --> 01:34:43.052
<v Tim McCormick>And then I'll just leave it there.

1080
01:34:43.292 --> 01:34:46.725
<v Tim McCormick>I just want to say there are a lot of difficulties in getting all the ideas forth.

1081
01:34:46.869 --> 01:34:49.065
<v Tim McCormick>We should try to open up a platform to make them so.

1082
01:34:49.291 --> 01:34:49.595
<v Tim McCormick>Thank you.

1083
01:34:50.317 --> 01:34:50.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1084
01:34:50.654 --> 01:34:53.908
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the director is still online with us, so I'm sure that she heard that comment.

1085
01:34:55.304 --> 01:34:56.876
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next, we'll go to Donna Cohen.

1086
01:34:57.212 --> 01:34:59.201
<v Rebecca Dobert>Donna, you're on— she's online.

1087
01:35:00.515 --> 01:35:01.238
<v Donna Cohen>Yes, I'm here.

1088
01:35:01.863 --> 01:35:02.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Donna.

1089
01:35:02.520 --> 01:35:02.970
<v Angelita Morillo>Go right ahead.

1090
01:35:03.386 --> 01:35:04.909
<v Donna Cohen>Hi, I'm Donna Cohen.

1091
01:35:04.989 --> 01:35:06.898
<v Donna Cohen>I live in St. Johns in District 2.

1092
01:35:07.716 --> 01:35:23.894
<v Donna Cohen>As a community housing advocate, former chair of the Portland League of Women Voters Housing Interest Group, a current member of the Social Housing Workgroup of Welcome Home Coalition, and a homeowner who was finally able to purchase because of a first-time homeowner Program, I'm thrilled to support this resolution.

1093
01:35:24.470 --> 01:35:36.230
<v Donna Cohen>I would like to thank the Housing and Homelessness Committee and the sponsors of the resolution who understand the critical situation we're in, the work the city has already done in regard to housing, and future initiatives which are needed.

1094
01:35:36.743 --> 01:35:41.359
<v Donna Cohen>I'm pleased that the Housing Production Strategy report is being taken to heart by the city.

1095
01:35:41.791 --> 01:35:48.649
<v Donna Cohen>Pertinent sections, as cited by the resolution, identifying a long-term sustainable funding source for affordable housing.

1096
01:35:49.484 --> 01:36:01.911
<v Donna Cohen>Establishing a comprehensive citywide land banking strategy, pursuing the development of new programs that support alternative homeownership models can be, I believe, hugely beneficial towards solving our housing crisis.

1097
01:36:02.328 --> 01:36:13.536
<v Donna Cohen>As the resolution notes, we have many, many people living with housing insecurity, and we know from research done out of the University of Washington that the single biggest driver of homelessness is lack of housing.

1098
01:36:14.515 --> 01:36:21.798
<v Donna Cohen>I only have one suggestion because already the suggestion for multiple reports has been approved, it seems.

1099
01:36:22.457 --> 01:36:40.216
<v Donna Cohen>From my current comments to the council on March 5th, please note our data would show even greater numbers of individuals and households who require affordable housing were we to use not the HUD income charts, but information specifically on Portlanders' income.

1100
01:36:41.145 --> 01:36:45.184
<v Donna Cohen>And I apologize for this, but my community is desperate.

1101
01:36:45.231 --> 01:37:00.310
<v Donna Cohen>Yesterday, RJ DeMello, the head of SJNA, and myself determined that the legislature is, is stonewalling House Bill 2749, the $5 million for PBOT to design a life-saving bridge on Columbia over the cut.

1102
01:37:00.551 --> 01:37:02.521
<v Donna Cohen>Please help us get a hearing.

1103
01:37:03.018 --> 01:37:04.060
<v Donna Cohen>They are stonewalling us.

1104
01:37:04.556 --> 01:37:05.326
<v Donna Cohen>Thank you very much.

1105
01:37:05.902 --> 01:37:07.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1106
01:37:11.199 --> 01:37:16.384
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Molly Hogan, Sahan McKelvey, and Trevor Newhart.

1107
01:37:30.697 --> 01:37:31.243
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1108
01:37:33.418 --> 01:37:37.297
<v Sahan McKelvey>All right, good morning, Council President Pirtle-Guiney, council members.

1109
01:37:37.493 --> 01:37:37.884
<v Sahan McKelvey>My name is Sahan McKelvey.

1110
01:37:38.921 --> 01:37:43.475
<v Sahan McKelvey>And I am the Director of Advocacy and Engagement at SEI, Self-Enhancement Inc.

1111
01:37:44.132 --> 01:37:54.521
<v Sahan McKelvey>I'm also a member of the Welcome Home Coalition Steering Committee and am here to offer support for this resolution regarding alternative housing models and especially for social housing concepts.

1112
01:37:55.275 --> 01:38:12.025
<v Sahan McKelvey>I've been a part of a lot of conversations, um, citywide, regionally, in our county conversations as well, but one of the key points in every one of those conversations is that we have to be able to improve the alignment between our various systems.

1113
01:38:12.688 --> 01:38:21.042
<v Sahan McKelvey>Our approaches to this problem are often not aligned, and that is often why we see some of the, the lack of results and not, not the definitive results that we would like to see.

1114
01:38:21.899 --> 01:38:28.595
<v Sahan McKelvey>One of the primary places where we need alignment is to be able to manage the inflow and outflow into homelessness shelter and housing.

1115
01:38:29.289 --> 01:38:44.368
<v Sahan McKelvey>In recent conversations with several CBO leaders as well as Mayor Wilson, The mayor expressed his desire to create multiple creative housing solutions for people who are exiting an expanded shelter system and are ready to take the next step in their journey to permanent housing.

1116
01:38:45.042 --> 01:38:57.353
<v Sahan McKelvey>We discussed a lot of options, but the primary point was to acknowledge the reality that the path to permanent housing looks different, and we must maximize every option for folks to ensure that everyone can access the ideal fit for themselves.

1117
01:38:58.171 --> 01:39:00.542
<v Sahan McKelvey>Social housing should be one of these options.

1118
01:39:00.591 --> 01:39:00.686
<v Sahan McKelvey>Thank you.

1119
01:39:01.233 --> 01:39:10.345
<v Sahan McKelvey>This is a path that will help us to maximize opportunities to create the alignment that we need between the outflow out of short-term shelter and the inflow into housing.

1120
01:39:10.939 --> 01:39:17.823
<v Sahan McKelvey>I think we are coming to agreement with the concept that Welcome Home has been championing for years, and that is that homelessness is a housing problem.

1121
01:39:18.240 --> 01:39:23.743
<v Sahan McKelvey>The single biggest driver of homelessness in our city is the lack of affordable housing, and this is reality.

1122
01:39:24.113 --> 01:39:26.391
<v Sahan McKelvey>So please take this resolution seriously.

1123
01:39:26.649 --> 01:39:28.846
<v Sahan McKelvey>Please attack this concept aggressively.

1124
01:39:28.911 --> 01:39:29.038
<v Sahan McKelvey>Thank you.

1125
01:39:29.332 --> 01:39:43.958
<v Sahan McKelvey>And please commit to our city that you will do everything it takes to bring this solution to fruition for our communities, because it's time to follow the example of other cities around the world to increase livability in Portland and build a thriving community that we want to see without the reality of homelessness.

1126
01:39:45.639 --> 01:39:46.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1127
01:39:48.466 --> 01:39:49.011
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1128
01:39:49.430 --> 01:39:50.876
<v Molly Hogan>Good morning, members of the council.

1129
01:39:51.261 --> 01:39:51.984
<v Molly Hogan>Oh wait, should I just go?

1130
01:39:52.161 --> 01:39:52.739
<v Molly Hogan>Go right ahead.

1131
01:39:52.868 --> 01:39:57.246
<v Molly Hogan>Yes, introduce yourself and Good morning, members of the council.

1132
01:39:57.295 --> 01:40:00.216
<v Molly Hogan>My name is Molly Hogan, and I'm the director of the Welcome Home Coalition.

1133
01:40:01.029 --> 01:40:07.835
<v Molly Hogan>We're a multicultural alliance of dozens of organizations and individuals building a housing justice movement in the Portland metro area.

1134
01:40:08.805 --> 01:40:16.345
<v Molly Hogan>I am here today to vocalize our strong support of the resolution to require the city administrator to study alternative housing financing and ownership models.

1135
01:40:18.171 --> 01:40:24.125
<v Molly Hogan>The coalition championed and moved forward the first City of Portland Affordable Housing Bond that voters passed in 2016.

1136
01:40:24.877 --> 01:40:31.689
<v Molly Hogan>That bond has been an example of government spending tax dollars as promised and exceeding goals, and we want to see more of it.

1137
01:40:32.554 --> 01:40:42.360
<v Molly Hogan>However, we also know that traditional LIHTC affordable housing development practices have become incredibly cumbersome and expensive due to bureaucratic red tape and escalating industry costs.

1138
01:40:42.905 --> 01:40:50.381
<v Molly Hogan>Because of this, our coalition members have been learning about innovative social housing housing model— models used elsewhere that increase affordable housing options.

1139
01:40:51.167 --> 01:40:58.280
<v Molly Hogan>We are so excited to see new city leaders taking real action to move innovative housing solutions forward in our biggest city.

1140
01:40:59.292 --> 01:41:03.740
<v Molly Hogan>Seeing what can happen when a city government declares housing a human right is inspiring.

1141
01:41:04.800 --> 01:41:11.640
<v Molly Hogan>As you've heard, Vienna, Austria has been named the most livable city in the world, but 100 years ago that was not the case.

1142
01:41:12.524 --> 01:41:22.324
<v Molly Hogan>But they started with a vision of housing as a human right, and the government implemented robust public investment to make that a reality.

1143
01:41:23.675 --> 01:41:33.475
<v Molly Hogan>Vienna shows that when governments invest in housing as a human right, they can combat homelessness and inequities, and there is no reason why we can't do that here in Portland.

1144
01:41:34.230 --> 01:41:50.515
<v Molly Hogan>So we ask you, dream big, councilors, and lead Be bold and pass this resolution as the first step to move on a path to make City Portland a city that's famous for ensuring that all its residents have a home.

1145
01:41:51.131 --> 01:41:51.831
<v Molly Hogan>Thank you for your time.

1146
01:41:53.792 --> 01:41:54.534
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For being here.

1147
01:41:57.180 --> 01:41:59.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next, we have the testimony that we're hearing.

1148
01:41:59.652 --> 01:42:06.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll just remind everybody that if you can keep your support silent jazz hands, thumbs ups, all fine.

1149
01:42:06.373 --> 01:42:07.407
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That would be appreciated.

1150
01:42:07.503 --> 01:42:07.956
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1151
01:42:09.118 --> 01:42:13.988
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Toby Hodges, Jordan Lewis, and Winta Johannes.

1152
01:42:17.644 --> 01:42:19.863
<v Rebecca Dobert>And Jordan is joining us online.

1153
01:42:24.909 --> 01:42:27.146
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ms. Johannes, why don't you go ahead and kick us off?

1154
01:42:30.078 --> 01:42:30.993
<v Heather Riggs>Good morning, Council.

1155
01:42:31.073 --> 01:42:32.551
<v Heather Riggs>My name is Wente Yohannes.

1156
01:42:32.807 --> 01:42:35.569
<v Heather Riggs>I serve as the executive director of the Albina Vision Trust.

1157
01:42:36.115 --> 01:42:39.503
<v Heather Riggs>I'm here today to provide our support for the resolution today.

1158
01:42:40.194 --> 01:42:48.993
<v Heather Riggs>There's been a lot of emphasis from the mayor, governor, and others in recent weeks about the need to communicate that Portland is open for business.

1159
01:42:49.667 --> 01:42:58.943
<v Heather Riggs>This is true, but I urge you today to also consider ways that you might communicate through your policymaking that Portland is also open to partnership.

1160
01:42:59.615 --> 01:43:02.166
<v Heather Riggs>This is how we move from study to action.

1161
01:43:03.079 --> 01:43:07.649
<v Heather Riggs>The Albina Vision Trust is the nation's largest restorative redevelopment effort.

1162
01:43:08.291 --> 01:43:15.828
<v Heather Riggs>We've brought over $600 million of public and private capital to the city at a time when everybody else was running away.

1163
01:43:16.710 --> 01:43:25.738
<v Heather Riggs>We seek to build a neighborhood where people have both the dignity of stable housing and the opportunity to rebuild generations of stolen wealth.

1164
01:43:26.652 --> 01:43:41.582
<v Heather Riggs>We know that conventional economic development models and tools will not work in our effort to rebuild historic Albina, and therefore Albina needs to serve as an urban laboratory for innovative policymaking.

1165
01:43:42.511 --> 01:43:54.358
<v Heather Riggs>It is with this in mind that we believe there is great promise in the limited partnership model and we look forward to bringing both our community and our technical expertise to the conversation.

1166
01:43:55.029 --> 01:44:02.247
<v Heather Riggs>We ask that you invite us to the table not as advocates, but as serious partners committed to moving the work of the city forward.

1167
01:44:02.729 --> 01:44:03.779
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1168
01:44:07.854 --> 01:44:09.841
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, I believe our next testifier is online.

1169
01:44:10.117 --> 01:44:11.199
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes, Jordan Lewis.

1170
01:44:13.069 --> 01:44:14.451
<v Rebecca Dobert>Jordan, can you hear us?

1171
01:44:14.962 --> 01:44:15.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, I can hear you.

1172
01:44:16.408 --> 01:44:16.970
<v Rebecca Dobert>You're good to go.

1173
01:44:18.158 --> 01:44:18.496
<v Rashid Yusufi>Awesome.

1174
01:44:18.640 --> 01:44:21.323
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to give everyone time to testify today, so I'll keep this short.

1175
01:44:21.773 --> 01:44:23.042
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The social housing thing is really great.

1176
01:44:23.090 --> 01:44:23.877
<v Dan Ryan>I'm here to support it.

1177
01:44:24.904 --> 01:44:26.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Countercyclical development is awesome.

1178
01:44:27.136 --> 01:44:33.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're gonna have a recession pretty soon, and ideally you're able to do development in a recession, which social housing lets us do.

1179
01:44:33.368 --> 01:44:35.954
<v Dan Ryan>So it's a win-win-win-win.

1180
01:44:36.228 --> 01:44:36.854
<v Rashid Yusufi>Everyone wins.

1181
01:44:37.127 --> 01:44:37.865
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please pass it.

1182
01:44:38.027 --> 01:44:40.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just wish it was going faster, and we should have done it 10 years ago.

1183
01:44:41.211 --> 01:44:41.453
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1184
01:44:42.054 --> 01:44:44.469
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1185
01:44:45.359 --> 01:44:50.314
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Sarah Radcliffe, Lee Shelton, Michelle Hornbeck.

1186
01:44:59.210 --> 01:45:01.356
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Good morning, uh, members of council.

1187
01:45:01.404 --> 01:45:05.747
<v Sarah Radcliffe>My name is Sarah Radcliffe and I'm here on behalf of Habitat for Humanity Portland Region.

1188
01:45:06.591 --> 01:45:18.489
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Habitat supports this proposal, but we wanna make sure that council is aware that there are innovative models that exist in our communities, but simply haven't been funded to scale.

1189
01:45:19.356 --> 01:45:31.528
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Specifically, the community land trust model, which Habitat implements in partnership with Proud Ground, shares a lot of the core features of social housing, which I'll run through just very quickly.

1190
01:45:32.747 --> 01:45:38.344
<v Sarah Radcliffe>First and probably most importantly, community land trusts or CLTs are non-market housing.

1191
01:45:38.456 --> 01:45:49.328
<v Sarah Radcliffe>So they create a slice of our housing supply that's insulated from both the risk and the escalation that's associated with market drivers.

1192
01:45:49.938 --> 01:45:57.170
<v Sarah Radcliffe>CLTs use a 99-year affordability covenant or deed restriction that's renewed every time title transfers.

1193
01:45:57.234 --> 01:46:03.733
<v Sarah Radcliffe>So effectively ensuring that these homes will remain affordable forever.

1194
01:46:04.695 --> 01:46:16.106
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Second, CLTs, like renting in Vienna, provide a stability of tenure that renting in the US simply doesn't provide.

1195
01:46:16.380 --> 01:46:25.079
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Part of my journey from into the affordable homeownership space was informed by my experience working as an eviction defense attorney and realizing thank you.

1196
01:46:25.128 --> 01:46:29.835
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Realizing that eviction or that renting just by definition is very precarious in this country.

1197
01:46:31.622 --> 01:46:37.511
<v Sarah Radcliffe>And finally, CLTs deliver mixed-income neighborhoods, which have benefits for all residents.

1198
01:46:38.011 --> 01:46:44.770
<v Sarah Radcliffe>This can be achieved through small CLT infill projects or through larger mixed-income CLT developments.

1199
01:46:45.012 --> 01:46:57.769
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Habitat and our work with Proud Ground, we sell homes to families between $35,000 and 80% of area median income, but many CLTs serve higher income brackets as well.

1200
01:46:59.159 --> 01:47:07.405
<v Sarah Radcliffe>With stable, predictable funding and the supply of land that Director Hisrich envisions, we can bring these innovative models to scale.

1201
01:47:07.760 --> 01:47:08.082
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Thank you.

1202
01:47:09.475 --> 01:47:09.961
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1203
01:47:11.497 --> 01:47:12.501
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning, Council.

1204
01:47:12.970 --> 01:47:13.828
<v Loretta Smith>My name is Lee Shelton.

1205
01:47:14.579 --> 01:47:18.225
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm a housing policy organizer and member of Portland Neighbors Welcome.

1206
01:47:18.797 --> 01:47:20.581
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'll cut to the chase.

1207
01:47:20.869 --> 01:47:32.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I dream of diverse, high-quality, mixed-income, and family-friendly publicly owned housing that promotes community trust and connectivity.

1208
01:47:33.377 --> 01:47:43.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're living through an incredibly lonely period of American life where 50% of Americans report being— feeling lonely or isolated on a regular basis.

1209
01:47:44.712 --> 01:47:48.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I myself experienced this in the years after the birth of my children.

1210
01:47:48.626 --> 01:47:55.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I often felt alone and isolated in our single-family home, surrounded by mostly older adults with no kids.

1211
01:47:57.061 --> 01:47:59.130
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank goodness for our beloved Portland parks.

1212
01:48:00.590 --> 01:48:05.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great building design and well-integrated green space can help mitigate loneliness.

1213
01:48:06.298 --> 01:48:09.730
<v Rebecca Dobert>It can boost our opportunities to socialize and care for one another.

1214
01:48:10.663 --> 01:48:15.377
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm so excited to see what creative plans we can come up with and strongly support this resolution.

1215
01:48:15.652 --> 01:48:15.989
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1216
01:48:18.627 --> 01:48:22.488
<v Mitch Green>My name is Michelle Hornbeck, and I am part of Welcome Home Coalition.

1217
01:48:24.063 --> 01:48:28.057
<v Mitch Green>And I came today to say that I support this resolution.

1218
01:48:29.359 --> 01:48:47.510
<v Mitch Green>We, we must find a way to be able to house people So speaking from the other side, as a person who was homeless, that sense of safety is so important.

1219
01:48:48.122 --> 01:49:00.809
<v Mitch Green>So the Helen Swindell Hotel on Broadway and Burnside years ago was a hotel, and what they've done is now they just rent the rooms out on a monthly basis.

1220
01:49:01.418 --> 01:49:04.060
<v Mitch Green>And they're part of Portland Housing Authority.

1221
01:49:04.735 --> 01:49:06.685
<v Mitch Green>They receive payments from them, whatever.

1222
01:49:06.911 --> 01:49:09.052
<v Mitch Green>When I stayed, I just paid out of pocket.

1223
01:49:09.649 --> 01:49:16.969
<v Mitch Green>But it was the sense that I could go in and lock a door and know that I would be safe for the night.

1224
01:49:18.796 --> 01:49:31.490
<v Mitch Green>And we just have too many people out there that feel alone and hopeless, and you have the power To make that not their reality anymore.

1225
01:49:32.005 --> 01:49:36.372
<v Mitch Green>And I'm sorry, I get emotional because I know how hard it is out there.

1226
01:49:36.662 --> 01:49:51.240
<v Mitch Green>And when you have a roof, someplace you can rest, you can be more productive, you can look for a job, you can take care of your medical problems, or at least see a doctor.

1227
01:49:51.353 --> 01:49:53.341
<v Mitch Green>Councilmember You can eat properly.

1228
01:49:54.256 --> 01:49:56.051
<v Mitch Green>When you're homeless, you don't have that.

1229
01:49:56.500 --> 01:49:58.006
<v Mitch Green>You don't have any of that.

1230
01:49:58.729 --> 01:50:01.998
<v Mitch Green>And that's why we lose people on a daily basis.

1231
01:50:02.416 --> 01:50:16.122
<v Mitch Green>You know, we have people with mental health that rely on drugs in order to cope with whatever, you know, issue that is, but also just to get through, you know.

1232
01:50:16.619 --> 01:50:22.953
<v Mitch Green>So it's so It's so important, and I would just urge you from my heart, um, I know how grateful I am.

1233
01:50:23.453 --> 01:50:30.502
<v Mitch Green>I, I have affordable housing, and, and I've been there a couple years now, and it really has changed my life.

1234
01:50:30.663 --> 01:50:31.069
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1235
01:50:32.689 --> 01:50:35.733
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Karen, for sharing your stories.

1236
01:50:38.506 --> 01:50:42.458
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Lauren Armony and Laura Bauer.

1237
01:50:53.912 --> 01:50:55.078
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1238
01:50:55.143 --> 01:50:55.757
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1239
01:50:56.359 --> 01:51:00.256
<v Olivia Clark>All right, all right.

1240
01:51:00.578 --> 01:51:04.524
<v Olivia Clark>Hello, Council President Pirtle-Guiney, Vice President Koyama Lane, and councilors.

1241
01:51:05.042 --> 01:51:08.515
<v Olivia Clark>For the record, my name is Lauren Armony, and I'm here to testify in support of this resolution.

1242
01:51:09.363 --> 01:51:13.747
<v Olivia Clark>I shared a similar testimony last week but want to ensure all of you have the privilege to hear it.

1243
01:51:14.646 --> 01:51:16.042
<v Olivia Clark>I was born and raised in Portland.

1244
01:51:16.349 --> 01:51:22.899
<v Olivia Clark>I've worked in housing justice nonprofits in the Portland metro area for the past 5 years, recently joining the Welcome Home Coalition.

1245
01:51:23.654 --> 01:51:25.966
<v Olivia Clark>And I've also been homeless because I could not afford rent.

1246
01:51:26.930 --> 01:51:29.322
<v Olivia Clark>I grew up off Southeast 35th and Hawthorne.

1247
01:51:29.675 --> 01:51:34.154
<v Olivia Clark>Before it had a dosha spa, it was working-class families, college students, and small businesses.

1248
01:51:34.220 --> 01:51:34.539
<v Olivia Clark>Businesses.

1249
01:51:35.534 --> 01:51:36.993
<v Olivia Clark>We had block parties every summer.

1250
01:51:37.363 --> 01:51:39.735
<v Olivia Clark>Kids on the street played together, and I knew everyone by name.

1251
01:51:40.489 --> 01:51:45.284
<v Olivia Clark>Neither of my parents had a college education, and they were able to buy our house for $70,000 in 1990.

1252
01:51:46.215 --> 01:51:52.149
<v Olivia Clark>Due to post-9/11 recessions and illegal terminations perpetrated by Portland Public Schools, my father became unemployed.

1253
01:51:52.694 --> 01:51:54.970
<v Olivia Clark>We plunged into poverty and almost lost our house.

1254
01:51:55.340 --> 01:51:58.211
<v Olivia Clark>We made incredible sacrifices that still affect me to this day.

1255
01:51:59.269 --> 01:52:11.229
<v Olivia Clark>At the same time, We had realtors knocking on our door on Saturday mornings with cash offers— $350,000, $375,000, $400,000— knowing they'd still turn a profit if they were to sell it.

1256
01:52:11.600 --> 01:52:14.670
<v Olivia Clark>Slowly, my neighbors started taking the offers and trickled out of the neighborhood.

1257
01:52:14.840 --> 01:52:18.199
<v Olivia Clark>We stopped having annual block parties by 2005.

1258
01:52:18.199 --> 01:52:22.420
<v Olivia Clark>We managed to keep our then 110-year-old house until 2014.

1259
01:52:22.420 --> 01:52:25.699
<v Olivia Clark>It was subsequently gutted, flipped, and sold for over $1 million in 2015.

1260
01:52:26.966 --> 01:52:30.755
<v Olivia Clark>I believe Councilor Dunphy shared a similar experience in house price inflation last week.

1261
01:52:31.637 --> 01:52:35.363
<v Olivia Clark>There is a reason why adults still living in Portland who grew up here are called unicorns.

1262
01:52:35.942 --> 01:52:41.786
<v Olivia Clark>Right now, my peers and I are debating on whether to save for retirement, a house, or have children, because you can only pick one in Portland.

1263
01:52:42.283 --> 01:52:43.921
<v Olivia Clark>But we can imagine a different future.

1264
01:52:44.386 --> 01:53:01.279
<v Olivia Clark>The private market refuses to regulate itself, but I'm confident that city leadership can take this bold step to study non-market housing options for Portland and housing options that keep our communities intact, reduce housing insecurity and homelessness, and give residents the opportunity to build wealth without having to rely on a fickle real estate market.

1265
01:53:01.952 --> 01:53:07.692
<v Olivia Clark>Portland was a great place to grow up, but I can't help but wonder how different my life would have been if my family had the option of non-market housing.

1266
01:53:08.123 --> 01:53:10.480
<v Olivia Clark>Let us not make future generations wonder.

1267
01:53:11.010 --> 01:53:12.051
<v Olivia Clark>Please support this resolution.

1268
01:53:12.115 --> 01:53:12.740
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for your time.

1269
01:53:13.960 --> 01:53:14.585
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1270
01:53:19.046 --> 01:53:20.240
<v Rebecca Dobert>That completes testimony.

1271
01:53:24.210 --> 01:53:24.728
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1272
01:53:25.682 --> 01:53:29.131
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, councilors, it's time for discussion.

1273
01:53:31.987 --> 01:53:36.993
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there anybody who wants to discuss the resolution?

1274
01:53:39.738 --> 01:53:43.127
<v Candace Avalos>I guess I wanted to follow up and see if there was an amendment worked out.

1275
01:53:44.943 --> 01:53:46.594
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see Councilor Clark in the queue.

1276
01:53:48.565 --> 01:53:50.463
<v Olivia Clark>Um, thank you, uh, Councilor Avalos.

1277
01:53:50.577 --> 01:53:53.440
<v Olivia Clark>I think we've come to some agreement on that.

1278
01:53:53.586 --> 01:53:59.226
<v Olivia Clark>Do you want to offer that up, or— Sure, Councilor Green will offer the amendment.

1279
01:54:00.636 --> 01:54:02.984
<v Mitch Green>Okay, uh, let's see.

1280
01:54:03.128 --> 01:54:14.813
<v Mitch Green>So I have an amendment here that Councilor Clark has helpfully written, and it would just amend On sub, so be it further resolved.

1281
01:54:14.860 --> 01:54:36.429
<v Mitch Green>The last be it further resolved in the resolution on item five, where it says other governance and implementation needs and considerations such as funding impacts, compliance, monitoring, enforcement, administrative costs, staffing needs, and potential city liability, including and here's the amended, including identification of impediments such as zoning code, permitting process, and financing gaps.

1282
01:54:37.627 --> 01:54:42.139
<v Mitch Green>So just sort of rounds out that we're running for traps here, I think.

1283
01:54:42.186 --> 01:54:42.608
<v Eric Zimmerman>Second.

1284
01:54:45.614 --> 01:54:49.126
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we have a proposed amendment with a first and a second.

1285
01:54:49.189 --> 01:54:55.145
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any discussion of this amendment, or would anybody like Councilor Green to read just the amendment part again?

1286
01:54:57.369 --> 01:55:01.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you read just the amended part again so folks can have that pulled up?

1287
01:55:02.231 --> 01:55:03.265
<v Mitch Green>No problem, Madam President.

1288
01:55:03.362 --> 01:55:11.573
<v Mitch Green>It just simply says including identification of impediments such as zoning code, permitting process, and finance gaps.

1289
01:55:11.832 --> 01:55:15.869
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that's in the second resolved item 6.

1290
01:55:16.095 --> 01:55:16.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>5.

1291
01:55:16.480 --> 01:55:17.478
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>5, I apologize.

1292
01:55:17.606 --> 01:55:18.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 5.

1293
01:55:19.055 --> 01:55:19.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's correct.

1294
01:55:20.590 --> 01:55:20.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1295
01:55:23.030 --> 01:55:25.729
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark, are you in the queue to discuss this?

1296
01:55:26.733 --> 01:55:28.818
<v Olivia Clark>I can discuss this, but I had some general comments too.

1297
01:55:29.180 --> 01:55:29.711
<v Olivia Clark>Do you want me to wait?

1298
01:55:31.354 --> 01:55:34.467
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right now we have a motion on the table, so conversation should be to the motion.

1299
01:55:34.806 --> 01:55:37.953
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, I really appreciate the co-sponsors accepting this.

1300
01:55:38.065 --> 01:55:39.453
<v Olivia Clark>I'm thinking you're accepting it.

1301
01:55:40.051 --> 01:55:47.052
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's important that we also look at what prevents us from doing the things that we want to do in affordable housing.

1302
01:55:47.166 --> 01:55:50.898
<v Olivia Clark>This is a great opportunity, and I appreciate your willingness to incorporate that.

1303
01:55:53.118 --> 01:55:55.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other discussion of the amendment?

1304
01:55:58.358 --> 01:56:00.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

1305
01:56:01.100 --> 01:56:01.373
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

1306
01:56:01.922 --> 01:56:01.954
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1307
01:56:02.470 --> 01:56:02.697
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

1308
01:56:03.439 --> 01:56:03.519
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1309
01:56:03.841 --> 01:56:04.390
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

1310
01:56:04.810 --> 01:56:04.905
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1311
01:56:05.310 --> 01:56:05.873
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo?

1312
01:56:06.261 --> 01:56:06.390
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1313
01:56:06.810 --> 01:56:07.082
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

1314
01:56:07.307 --> 01:56:07.355
<v Lee Heppner>Aye.

1315
01:56:07.725 --> 01:56:08.144
<v Emily Dumerck>Clark?

1316
01:56:08.353 --> 01:56:08.400
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1317
01:56:08.689 --> 01:56:08.899
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

1318
01:56:09.880 --> 01:56:09.927
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1319
01:56:10.603 --> 01:56:10.956
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1320
01:56:11.326 --> 01:56:11.358
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>Aye.

1321
01:56:11.807 --> 01:56:12.113
<v Emily Dumerck>Avalos?

1322
01:56:12.386 --> 01:56:12.564
<v Susie Doister>Aye.

1323
01:56:12.725 --> 01:56:13.078
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1324
01:56:13.431 --> 01:56:13.463
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1325
01:56:13.689 --> 01:56:14.042
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

1326
01:56:14.862 --> 01:56:15.038
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1327
01:56:15.569 --> 01:56:16.296
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

1328
01:56:17.203 --> 01:56:17.251
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1329
01:56:18.836 --> 01:56:21.244
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, with 12 ayes, the amendment is accepted.

1330
01:56:22.015 --> 01:56:24.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1331
01:56:25.556 --> 01:56:31.726
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I'm putting myself in the queue because I also have an amendment that I would like to propose.

1332
01:56:32.488 --> 01:56:41.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We heard from one of our partners, Albina Vision Trust, and asked to think about how partners could be included in this work.

1333
01:56:42.512 --> 01:56:48.747
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I've brought forward some language that might allow us to work with them as a potential partner.

1334
01:56:48.859 --> 01:56:49.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1335
01:56:50.524 --> 01:57:04.743
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Potential pilot area, one of what could be a few areas where we can look at how social housing might actually work in Portland in the near term as we see the results of this study.

1336
01:57:05.114 --> 01:57:23.088
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm going to pass out some language on paper, and I apologize that I didn't get this to folks sooner, but we were working out the details of it pretty late last and I figured rather than assume folks would look at their email at 11:30, I would bring a copy this morning.

1337
01:57:23.876 --> 01:57:29.699
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This would amend the resolution in 3 places.

1338
01:57:29.828 --> 01:57:33.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It would add 2 whereases to the bottom of the whereas section.

1339
01:57:33.869 --> 01:57:37.309
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll read it out loud for folks who are in the audience or online.

1340
01:57:38.051 --> 01:57:53.779
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Whereas the 2022 State of Housing in Portland report shows that in 2022, the average Latino and Native American families could not afford a 3-bedroom house in any neighborhood in Portland, and the average Black family could not afford a 1-bedroom home in any neighborhood in Portland.

1341
01:57:54.453 --> 01:58:05.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And whereas the North-Northeast Preference Policy seeks to address many of these disparities, and the city already has partners like the Albina Vision Trust poised to build thousands of units under this preference policy.

1342
01:58:06.158 --> 01:58:15.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then in the second, be it further resolved, which is the resolved that Councilors Clark and Green just amended.

1343
01:58:15.805 --> 01:58:17.796
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There would be a new 6.

1344
01:58:18.132 --> 01:58:40.833
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The current 6 would move to a number 7, and the new 6 would say, be it further resolved, it is recommended that the report include analysis of pilot zones available for near-term implementation of social housing models at scale, including within the Albina Vision project area and other neighborhoods within the North Northeast Preference Policy area.

1345
01:58:43.016 --> 01:58:52.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am going to let Vice President Koyama Lane manage discussion on this in case there are questions for me about the amendment.

1346
01:58:56.159 --> 01:58:57.483
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Clark, we can start with you.

1347
01:58:57.886 --> 01:58:59.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hold on, it hasn't been seconded.

1348
01:59:00.002 --> 01:59:02.471
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, I apologize, you're right.

1349
01:59:02.875 --> 01:59:04.796
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was going to let her manage it through that also though.

1350
01:59:05.448 --> 01:59:07.337
<v Dan Ryan>I'll second it.

1351
01:59:07.676 --> 01:59:11.338
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think you had a second from Councilor Smith.

1352
01:59:13.501 --> 01:59:23.725
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So the amendment has been moved by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney and seconded by Councilor Smith.

1353
01:59:24.500 --> 01:59:25.368
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Will you call the roll?

1354
01:59:25.819 --> 01:59:26.350
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Discussion.

1355
01:59:26.462 --> 01:59:27.025
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No discussion.

1356
01:59:27.509 --> 01:59:28.684
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You're managing the discussion.

1357
01:59:29.344 --> 01:59:31.226
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>All right, Councilor Clark, go ahead.

1358
01:59:32.347 --> 01:59:34.802
<v Olivia Clark>I'm not going to mention the amendment.

1359
01:59:34.850 --> 01:59:37.257
<v Olivia Clark>I'm interested in more general comments later.

1360
01:59:37.836 --> 01:59:40.451
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>All right, Councilor Green, would you like to talk about the amendment?

1361
01:59:41.574 --> 01:59:43.002
<v Mitch Green>I would, Madam Vice President.

1362
01:59:43.114 --> 01:59:43.515
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1363
01:59:43.740 --> 01:59:51.426
<v Mitch Green>Um, uh, as I read it, I, I'm supportive of the amendments for a couple different reasons.

1364
01:59:51.523 --> 02:00:02.399
<v Mitch Green>One, um, the whereas clauses I think just add to the body of context for why it's important to do the study and why we have certain urgency around it.

1365
02:00:02.463 --> 02:00:11.786
<v Mitch Green>It also ties to, which I think is a practice that we should extend, prior work that identified gaps and said, you know, city supports X, Y, and Z.

1366
02:00:12.157 --> 02:00:29.086
<v Mitch Green>This does that here for a part of the city that when we talk about real estate development, if we were to ignore the impacts that earlier urban renewal projects did on the Albina District, we would be doing ourselves a disservice.

1367
02:00:29.393 --> 02:00:31.831
<v Mitch Green>So I think it does that, which is good.

1368
02:00:31.976 --> 02:00:45.104
<v Mitch Green>And then I think the, the add resolve piece, that doesn't diminish, in my view, any of the substantive original intent of the resolution and just sort of makes explicit that, you know, we have some opportunities.

1369
02:00:45.170 --> 02:00:46.088
<v Mitch Green>So I support that.

1370
02:00:52.143 --> 02:00:54.552
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Council Vice President.

1371
02:00:54.649 --> 02:01:01.525
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I am a little bit troubled by the amendment, not in the whereases, but in the be it resolved piece.

1372
02:01:02.506 --> 02:01:06.136
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it is related to how some of the public comment actually came out.

1373
02:01:06.844 --> 02:01:16.050
<v Eric Zimmerman>One of the things that I'm looking forward to in this study and why I will say in my overall remarks why I think that information, we should never be afraid of information.

1374
02:01:16.885 --> 02:01:27.386
<v Eric Zimmerman>And one of the things I'm looking forward to this study It is completed in as non-biased a manner as possible, in a way that doesn't look at just funding more of the current system.

1375
02:01:28.573 --> 02:01:38.172
<v Eric Zimmerman>But some of the public comment today were already from groups who I think are starting to see a funding solution to their own programs.

1376
02:01:38.445 --> 02:01:40.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>And this to me is kind of opening up.

1377
02:01:41.170 --> 02:01:42.163
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so where do we stop?

1378
02:01:42.596 --> 02:01:58.676
<v Eric Zimmerman>Do we have now 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10 for a variety of other organizations who also I think that what makes this study most pure would be that it not be directing work with one organization over the next.

1379
02:01:58.725 --> 02:02:02.497
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm looking forward to those results and the information that comes of it.

1380
02:02:03.220 --> 02:02:10.798
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if the study identifies that pilots are appropriate for us to consider at a later date, I think that would be great.

1381
02:02:11.007 --> 02:02:25.177
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I am a little bit concerned about The nature of this study, in the way I think some members of the public commented today, is seen as a way to just drive funding to what I would call is the old broken system already.

1382
02:02:25.610 --> 02:02:29.345
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to know more about it without having to question the study's motivations.

1383
02:02:29.856 --> 02:02:33.382
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I would— I will not support the amendment.

1384
02:02:34.649 --> 02:02:41.713
<v Eric Zimmerman>If the be it resolved portion was not in it, I would support it, but I just want to put that out for, for consideration.

1385
02:02:47.921 --> 02:02:49.770
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1386
02:02:51.167 --> 02:03:00.929
<v Loretta Smith>I have some comments about that, uh, Councilor Zimmerman, and I want you to be more specific in what you're talking about because I don't— I'm not going to assume anything.

1387
02:03:01.595 --> 02:03:20.810
<v Loretta Smith>So if you could call out what you're, you're saying organizations are trying to If I, I can—.

1388
02:03:20.810 --> 02:03:21.649
<v Eric Zimmerman>Happy to respond.

1389
02:03:21.649 --> 02:03:22.409
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You may direct your comment.

1390
02:03:22.409 --> 02:03:23.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's great, right?

1391
02:03:23.489 --> 02:03:26.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we are, we are in business and we are supportive, right?

1392
02:03:26.350 --> 02:03:32.510
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I, my point here is, do we list all of the housing organizations in this and take an amendment for that?

1393
02:03:32.510 --> 02:03:40.131
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or for do we just say, we're going to fund all housing organizations of them who we are currently trying to help and get into the business of helping develop more affordable housing.

1394
02:03:41.090 --> 02:03:57.411
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or one of the things about this, the way I'm taking this study is that it is offering more than just our current system of how we are funding nonprofit and affordable housing development, but looking at what is the next level of that.

1395
02:03:57.538 --> 02:03:57.604
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1396
02:03:58.801 --> 02:04:10.835
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't know that we have to list this for the study to be successful, but this seems like a one call-out for one group, and we could list all the groups that we do affordable housing with.

1397
02:04:11.238 --> 02:04:12.654
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, let's be clear.

1398
02:04:13.990 --> 02:04:25.240
<v Loretta Smith>These organizations would not exist if the regular system was providing communities of color adequate, affordable, Housing.

1399
02:04:25.835 --> 02:04:30.810
<v Loretta Smith>And that is why Albina Vision Trust came up.

1400
02:04:31.114 --> 02:04:41.451
<v Loretta Smith>That is why Self Enhancement, who is known as a youth development organization, they found that even their own employees could not afford the housing in this city.

1401
02:04:41.963 --> 02:05:04.349
<v Loretta Smith>And so they have created housing for elderly seniors who are African-American, and they have— they're not trying to supplement their book of business, which is in the youth development business, they're offering a service that is currently not being offered by the general housing community or ecosystem.

1402
02:05:04.670 --> 02:05:10.591
<v Loretta Smith>They had to add something to that ecosystem to serve the people that they serve.

1403
02:05:10.963 --> 02:05:14.063
<v Loretta Smith>So I would look at it at a different way, Councilor Zimmerman.

1404
02:05:14.597 --> 02:05:15.328
<v Angelita Morillo>Mm-hmm.

1405
02:05:18.984 --> 02:05:23.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>So should we include then SEI in this and Latino Network in this?

1406
02:05:23.845 --> 02:05:24.631
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's what I'm asking is—.

1407
02:05:25.210 --> 02:05:35.911
<v Loretta Smith>Well, if it makes you feel better, include them, but be able to fund them at the same level that you're trying to, to do this first, if, if, if that is the issue.

1408
02:05:36.279 --> 02:05:41.831
<v Loretta Smith>I don't find that an issue so much about what they're going to be funded because there's no numbers here.

1409
02:05:42.216 --> 02:05:49.568
<v Loretta Smith>But what I find that is a little troubling, and I'm going to add a whereas myself, and I wanted to, to bring that up.

1410
02:05:51.060 --> 02:06:04.118
<v Loretta Smith>So just so that we put a finer point on this, to, to basically settle any councilor's concerns about why people have been pointed out, listen to this.

1411
02:06:06.408 --> 02:06:10.310
<v Loretta Smith>Whereas, based on 2022 U.S. Census yes.

1412
02:06:10.376 --> 02:06:46.979
<v Loretta Smith>U.S. Census data for Portland, and this is in the report that, that they cited, the U.S. Census data for Portland, the average Black household brings in about $3,000 in monthly income, while Latino households earn $4,500 a month, and Native American households Earn $5,000 a month in comparison to white Portlanders' households earn $6,400 on an average each month.

1413
02:06:47.587 --> 02:06:59.033
<v Loretta Smith>And so if we add that data to a whereas, we put a finer point on the discrepancies and, and, and how we minimize or marginalize certain groups in this city.

1414
02:06:59.627 --> 02:07:09.378
<v Loretta Smith>And so there, there is a disproportionate amount of housing for African Americans, Latino, and Native Americans compared to their monthly salary.

1415
02:07:09.652 --> 02:07:18.925
<v Loretta Smith>So if you look at that, Councilor, I think that would help you to get to a finer understanding of why this amendment is needed.

1416
02:07:19.759 --> 02:07:22.534
<v Eric Zimmerman>Well, I think I understand the whereases just fine.

1417
02:07:22.872 --> 02:07:27.412
<v Eric Zimmerman>What, what I have made very clear is that I don't understand just the result part.

1418
02:07:27.539 --> 02:07:30.988
<v Eric Zimmerman>The whereas and And that added language that you just suggested, I think is important.

1419
02:07:32.014 --> 02:07:37.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what I'm not understanding is why we'd only look at pilot zones with one organization when we have a lot of partners.

1420
02:07:38.509 --> 02:07:42.502
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that is confusing for me in that sense.

1421
02:07:42.838 --> 02:07:44.795
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think your whereases are great, Councilor.

1422
02:07:44.922 --> 02:07:52.475
<v Loretta Smith>Well, let's add Latino Network and Self-Enhancement if that makes you feel better about this amendment.

1423
02:07:52.636 --> 02:07:53.405
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Councilors.

1424
02:07:53.599 --> 02:07:54.689
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think there are some people in the queue.

1425
02:07:54.770 --> 02:07:54.930
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1426
02:07:54.978 --> 02:07:56.726
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I see a few that would like to speak on this also.

1427
02:07:57.207 --> 02:07:57.979
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1428
02:07:59.037 --> 02:08:00.015
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, thank you.

1429
02:08:00.240 --> 02:08:08.408
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I, you know, I occasionally take off my council president hat and get to speak as a District 2 councilor.

1430
02:08:08.585 --> 02:08:13.270
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is something that is really important to me for a couple of reasons.

1431
02:08:13.318 --> 02:08:22.720
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Zimmerman, I understand your concerns, which is why the resolve specifically speaks to neighborhoods within the North and Northeast Preference Policy area.

1432
02:08:23.106 --> 02:08:24.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not just Albina Vision Trust.

1433
02:08:25.051 --> 02:08:39.399
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the reason that Albina Vision Trust has been called out specifically is because they have already been working with our housing bureau on social housing, and they have already been looking at how they might be able to pilot social housing.

1434
02:08:40.074 --> 02:08:48.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It seemed appropriate if we are asking for a study of social housing and we know that we are hearing from groups councilmember Herbold.

1435
02:08:48.920 --> 02:08:48.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

1436
02:08:48.920 --> 02:09:23.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that given that we have 2 ordinances that are specifically speaking to the need for social housing for communities that have been historically displaced, and we have an organization already working with our bureau on piloting social housing specifically in an area where we say we are working to help families come back that have been displaced, that we should call out the ability to look at that work as a potential to learn from as we go through the process of this So that is why this region of Portland more broadly has been called out in this resolution and why this organization specifically has been called out in the resolution.

1437
02:09:23.770 --> 02:09:39.296
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's not to diminish the work of anybody else who could play in this space, and it's not to presuppose a determined outcome, but rather to say we actually have an opportunity where work is already happening to look at as we do this study.

1438
02:09:39.408 --> 02:09:39.586
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1439
02:09:42.121 --> 02:09:43.645
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Kanal.

1440
02:09:44.527 --> 02:09:45.905
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam Vice President.

1441
02:09:46.131 --> 02:09:49.498
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I— this is a very interesting conversation and I appreciate it.

1442
02:09:49.739 --> 02:09:57.279
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I think I, I, I appreciate also Councilor Smith's, I guess, second proposed amendment or proposed amendment to the amendment.

1443
02:09:57.359 --> 02:10:18.207
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't know how it'll end up being done, but, um, I, I wanted to ask, 'cause I, I think, um, for me, the, the thing that makes the area unique is it's the only area where we have historically established a policy to help address the intentional policymaking in the past that displaced so many people.

1444
02:10:18.704 --> 02:10:21.354
<v Sameer Kanal>That to me is the regional interest in it.

1445
02:10:21.690 --> 02:10:24.243
<v Sameer Kanal>And also it's the only place where we're talking about building land.

1446
02:10:25.046 --> 02:10:26.122
<v Sameer Kanal>And that makes it unique.

1447
02:10:26.572 --> 02:10:28.997
<v Sameer Kanal>Unlike any other, we're talking about making more of it.

1448
02:10:30.104 --> 02:10:32.320
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that that's a notable thing.

1449
02:10:33.573 --> 02:10:48.875
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Zimmerman, I want to ask you, the actual place where the organization is called out is in the second whereas, whereas we're just talking about the project area for the sort of the Lower Albina redevelopment in the resolved.

1450
02:10:49.212 --> 02:10:54.414
<v Sameer Kanal>So I wanted to ask why the concern was about the whereas versus the resolved.

1451
02:10:54.927 --> 02:10:55.730
<v Sameer Kanal>Does that make sense?

1452
02:10:55.956 --> 02:10:56.356
<v Molly Hogan>I hope I'm—.

1453
02:10:56.372 --> 02:10:57.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, I think so.

1454
02:10:58.765 --> 02:11:00.484
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just want to be, be clear.

1455
02:11:00.564 --> 02:11:08.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>My, my concern with the resolves is that the resolve, in some sense, I think of it as, as directing language, right?

1456
02:11:08.261 --> 02:11:26.774
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that is, that is where my concern stops, because I am hoping that this study brings us back a, a study full of information that is about, I think, the heart of the way that Councilor Green and Councilor Avalos wrote the original.

1457
02:11:27.529 --> 02:11:31.006
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that is where the resolve piece, it adds this layer to it.

1458
02:11:31.136 --> 02:11:35.976
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and I don't understand necessarily why we would drive that in the resolve.

1459
02:11:36.426 --> 02:11:41.859
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's purely where, where my concern existed, which is why I can support the first and second whereases.

1460
02:11:42.677 --> 02:11:46.429
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, it is also very clear there's very strong feelings about this.

1461
02:11:46.604 --> 02:11:49.154
<v Eric Zimmerman>The geographic nature of it makes a lot of sense to me, Councilor.

1462
02:11:49.409 --> 02:11:55.863
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, uh, this seemed odd to call out one group in one area in the B resolved.

1463
02:11:55.960 --> 02:11:56.798
<v Eric Zimmerman>That was, that was it.

1464
02:11:58.533 --> 02:11:59.337
<v Sameer Kanal>That makes sense to me.

1465
02:11:59.578 --> 02:12:05.045
<v Sameer Kanal>I just, my question was, it doesn't actually call out the group in the resolved.

1466
02:12:05.832 --> 02:12:08.261
<v Sameer Kanal>It calls out the area and the project.

1467
02:12:08.841 --> 02:12:09.065
<v Sameer Kanal>Is it?

1468
02:12:09.146 --> 02:12:11.350
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's not the name, it's the idea of the focus.

1469
02:12:11.801 --> 02:12:13.377
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that, am I understanding you correctly?

1470
02:12:13.893 --> 02:12:15.195
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm trying to understand the intent here.

1471
02:12:15.619 --> 02:12:24.484
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor, I believe I, In number 2, that it says the city has partners like the Albina Vision Trust.

1472
02:12:24.774 --> 02:12:28.720
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's what the councilor is referring to, that that is a group, not necessarily the area.

1473
02:12:28.801 --> 02:12:34.930
<v Sameer Kanal>Right, but that's an aware as, and I think he— yeah, it's the resolved is where the concern is.

1474
02:12:34.978 --> 02:12:40.032
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm trying to— I just want to make sure I'm understanding it perfectly because I think we might be able to figure something out.

1475
02:12:40.112 --> 02:12:43.497
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So would you like to direct respond, Councilor Smith?

1476
02:12:43.707 --> 02:12:44.501
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not sure it matters.

1477
02:12:44.597 --> 02:12:46.447
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think the point has been made.

1478
02:12:46.966 --> 02:12:47.452
<v Eric Zimmerman>I hear you.

1479
02:12:47.533 --> 02:12:48.587
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate it.

1480
02:12:48.667 --> 02:12:50.856
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Smith, I appreciate the dialogue a lot.

1481
02:12:52.010 --> 02:13:00.984
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so it will also not change my support for the overall study, as I have clearly said from the very beginning.

1482
02:13:01.327 --> 02:13:04.328
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am looking forward to what this brings us in terms of solutions.

1483
02:13:05.927 --> 02:13:07.750
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Smith, are you still in the queue?

1484
02:13:08.059 --> 02:13:09.391
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, yes, I am.

1485
02:13:11.631 --> 02:13:13.989
<v Loretta Smith>I'm trying to figure out how do I want to say this.

1486
02:13:15.502 --> 02:13:23.774
<v Loretta Smith>Um, in the Black and brown communities, having access to capital is very limited.

1487
02:13:24.788 --> 02:13:36.286
<v Loretta Smith>So you always have to prove and prove and do a study before you actually give them resources to, to begin to develop housing for their constituency, which are Black and brown folks.

1488
02:13:36.333 --> 02:13:36.479
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1489
02:13:36.590 --> 02:13:36.702
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes.

1490
02:13:37.170 --> 02:13:41.591
<v Loretta Smith>And folks who can't afford certain types of housing.

1491
02:13:42.252 --> 02:13:43.769
<v Loretta Smith>And that has been very limited.

1492
02:13:44.605 --> 02:13:51.859
<v Loretta Smith>And I just want to give you an example because I want you to understand, and I'll do full transparency, I've worked with all of these organizations.

1493
02:13:54.101 --> 02:13:55.056
<v Loretta Smith>But I want to say this.

1494
02:13:55.219 --> 02:14:02.408
<v Loretta Smith>Look, SEI has done the Ronnie Herndon Building and they co-own it on Alberta.

1495
02:14:03.184 --> 02:14:08.158
<v Loretta Smith>The Paul and Geneva Nalls Building, they have already done that, and you all need to study it.

1496
02:14:08.640 --> 02:14:21.287
<v Loretta Smith>They are in development in partnership to try to build additional housing for people who are Black and brown folks because the ecosystem does not have them.

1497
02:14:21.800 --> 02:14:41.707
<v Loretta Smith>And to be able to study this, as, uh, the, the council president has said, I just I want you to understand, there is— the reason why government jumps into places, it's because the system is failing a group of people and they have to bring them up to level the playing field.

1498
02:14:42.252 --> 02:14:55.305
<v Loretta Smith>And so while this playing field is being leveled, we are just identifying who can do this work and who would be a good recipient of the social housing.

1499
02:14:55.770 --> 02:15:13.926
<v Loretta Smith>So I just want to be clear, we, you know, I've said this before and I've, I've noticed it, and I noticed it in the last, um, agenda item, that when we start talking about risk management and giving money away to, to Black men who have been harmed by our organization, there's some issues with it.

1500
02:15:14.487 --> 02:15:24.927
<v Loretta Smith>And so when we are trying to identify ways to do social housing for the most vulnerable group in our city, which are African Americans, we got problems with it.

1501
02:15:25.509 --> 02:15:26.783
<v Loretta Smith>And so we need to check ourselves.

1502
02:15:27.769 --> 02:15:30.092
<v Loretta Smith>Have problems with other things, bigger things.

1503
02:15:30.189 --> 02:15:32.594
<v Loretta Smith>This is just— it's so small.

1504
02:15:33.014 --> 02:15:33.952
<v Loretta Smith>It is really small.

1505
02:15:34.550 --> 02:15:45.432
<v Loretta Smith>And I just want y'all to know there's some, um, there are some, uh, implicit bias about certain things that we need to check ourselves about.

1506
02:15:45.561 --> 02:15:46.143
<v Loretta Smith>And that's all I'm saying.

1507
02:15:46.207 --> 02:15:46.578
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1508
02:15:46.845 --> 02:15:47.230
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

1509
02:15:47.328 --> 02:15:53.461
<v Loretta Smith>I'm sitting here from a different vantage point than many of you on this, on this board.

1510
02:15:53.525 --> 02:16:05.536
<v Loretta Smith>So I've been around here for a long time, and I've watched, and I've seen, and I've seen what got passed and what didn't get passed based on who the organization is and based on who they serve and whom they serve.

1511
02:16:06.386 --> 02:16:19.954
<v Loretta Smith>So I would just ask us to be a little bit more flexible in our thinking and understanding and again, if you care to add others to the list, drop the amendment and add others to the list.

1512
02:16:20.340 --> 02:16:27.597
<v Loretta Smith>But I just want to let you know that people are not doing housing because they want to support their youth program.

1513
02:16:27.966 --> 02:16:32.029
<v Loretta Smith>They're doing housing because Black folks can't find affordable housing, period.

1514
02:16:33.040 --> 02:16:34.518
<v Loretta Smith>So that's all I'm saying.

1515
02:16:34.566 --> 02:16:35.513
<v Loretta Smith>I'll— and I'll be quiet.

1516
02:16:35.931 --> 02:16:36.139
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1517
02:16:36.397 --> 02:16:36.718
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1518
02:16:44.747 --> 02:16:46.788
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>All right, I'm in the queue for some comments.

1519
02:16:47.622 --> 02:16:54.079
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, some of you know I actually ran on talking about social housing and looking into that.

1520
02:16:54.159 --> 02:16:56.552
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's something that I care a lot about.

1521
02:16:56.648 --> 02:17:03.731
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm interested in, um, what does it look like when we are able to remove the profit motive out of this conversation?

1522
02:17:04.569 --> 02:17:10.808
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also want to acknowledge that I am so impressed with Albina Vision Trust and their work.

1523
02:17:11.670 --> 02:17:14.945
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's actually someone on your team who I taught their, their kid in 4th grade.

1524
02:17:15.478 --> 02:17:23.360
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I've been following your work with the school district, and so my support for your work is, is very strong.

1525
02:17:25.454 --> 02:17:33.621
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also want to say that some of what Councilor Zimmerman is saying makes some sense to me.

1526
02:17:37.154 --> 02:17:53.656
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Maybe we can keep adding partners, um, but I do wonder if this is a study, if it's cleaner to give this to the director and have them, you know, come back with, with a list of who they can work with.

1527
02:17:54.522 --> 02:17:59.141
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, that could be part of the To be part of the study.

1528
02:18:00.440 --> 02:18:07.831
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I do know— I hear that this is small, a small addition, and we are setting precedents.

1529
02:18:07.911 --> 02:18:09.450
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We're, we're setting the stage.

1530
02:18:09.513 --> 02:18:21.584
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so I'm trying to, to separate my affinity for this group and just try to think about what, what seems like it makes the most sense and what we want moving forward.

1531
02:18:22.242 --> 02:18:44.328
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will also say that what my colleagues share, especially my colleagues in District 1, Districts 1 and 2, my colleagues with lived experiences, um, as that are very close to the Black and brown community, Latino, Native American, African American, Black community.

1532
02:18:44.505 --> 02:18:47.396
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am, I am listening to their— that perspective also.

1533
02:18:47.735 --> 02:18:52.709
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, um, But I just wanna say some of this makes sense.

1534
02:18:52.838 --> 02:18:59.790
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do want Director Hisarick to be able to do this study and really feel like there isn't anything predetermined.

1535
02:19:03.000 --> 02:19:03.950
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Those are my thoughts for now.

1536
02:19:04.627 --> 02:19:05.110
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Green.

1537
02:19:06.398 --> 02:19:07.380
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam Vice President.

1538
02:19:07.461 --> 02:19:08.638
<v Mitch Green>I'd like to call the question.

1539
02:19:09.298 --> 02:19:11.779
<v Mitch Green>I would like to vote on this amendment.

1540
02:19:16.417 --> 02:19:19.697
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I will call to vote.

1541
02:19:20.083 --> 02:19:28.539
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Uh, we're voting on the council president's amendment, to clarify, because there wasn't something else.

1542
02:19:30.090 --> 02:19:30.573
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can we clarify?

1543
02:19:30.668 --> 02:19:36.145
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe that we— if we're calling for a vote, I believe we have to vote to end discussion first.

1544
02:19:38.122 --> 02:19:40.165
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, it's a motion to end debate and call the question.

1545
02:19:44.073 --> 02:19:44.556
<v Steve Novick>Second.

1546
02:19:44.639 --> 02:19:45.522
<v Rebecca Dobert>Is there a second?

1547
02:19:47.586 --> 02:19:57.690
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I hear a motion from Councilor Green and a second from Councilor Novick to end debate and take a vote on Councilor— Council President Pirtle-Guiney's amendment.

1548
02:19:57.966 --> 02:19:58.161
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes.

1549
02:19:58.291 --> 02:19:58.601
<v Olivia Clark>Correct.

1550
02:19:58.780 --> 02:19:59.023
<v Donna Cohen>Okay.

1551
02:20:00.666 --> 02:20:01.853
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Needs to be under adjourned.

1552
02:20:03.181 --> 02:20:03.570
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

1553
02:20:06.338 --> 02:20:09.531
<v Sameer Kanal>On the motion to end debate and move to a vote on the amendment, I vote aye.

1554
02:20:15.876 --> 02:20:15.907
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1555
02:20:16.811 --> 02:20:16.827
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Aye.

1556
02:20:17.861 --> 02:20:17.911
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1557
02:20:19.009 --> 02:20:19.121
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1558
02:20:20.122 --> 02:20:20.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1559
02:20:21.899 --> 02:20:21.915
<v Heather Riggs>Aye.

1560
02:20:23.030 --> 02:20:23.047
<v Travis Noddings>Aye.

1561
02:20:24.093 --> 02:20:24.126
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1562
02:20:24.881 --> 02:20:24.930
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1563
02:20:25.557 --> 02:20:28.995
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I just—.

1564
02:20:29.334 --> 02:20:44.343
<v Loretta Smith>Before I before I take this vote, and I will have a need for further discussion, but I just want to respond to something that Councilor Koyama Lane said.

1565
02:20:44.600 --> 02:20:49.192
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, this for me— and, and so people need to understand how to separate.

1566
02:20:50.236 --> 02:20:53.063
<v Loretta Smith>It's not about having an affinity for organizations.

1567
02:20:53.191 --> 02:20:55.825
<v Loretta Smith>You have to have an affinity for the people that they serve.

1568
02:20:56.163 --> 02:20:56.468
<v Loretta Smith>Mhm.

1569
02:20:56.725 --> 02:21:03.902
<v Loretta Smith>And I have an affinity for Black folks and brown folks and poor folks who don't get to be in the system.

1570
02:21:04.503 --> 02:21:05.688
<v Loretta Smith>So we have to be clear.

1571
02:21:06.540 --> 02:21:11.227
<v Loretta Smith>And so talking about affinities for organizations, that's not important to me.

1572
02:21:11.862 --> 02:21:12.563
<v Loretta Smith>The work is.

1573
02:21:13.471 --> 02:21:16.070
<v Loretta Smith>And Albina Vision Trust has done the work.

1574
02:21:16.474 --> 02:21:23.220
<v Loretta Smith>Self-Enhancement Inc. has done the work, and they have a product just as Albina Trust does.

1575
02:21:23.648 --> 02:21:25.543
<v Loretta Smith>So we have to get away from—.

1576
02:21:25.543 --> 02:21:25.824
<v Loretta Smith>Councilwoman?

1577
02:21:26.386 --> 02:21:31.049
<v Loretta Smith>Liking organizations just before— just because they're the organizations of the day.

1578
02:21:31.690 --> 02:21:35.791
<v Loretta Smith>You have to like what they do and how they do and how they move in this world.

1579
02:21:35.855 --> 02:21:52.888
<v Loretta Smith>And Albina Vision Trust moves in this community as a supporter of Black and brown folks being backed into the community in the Albina area where my grandparents— and the reason why I'm taking this so seriously, my grandparents were moved from the, um, from that Albina area.

1580
02:21:52.952 --> 02:21:53.129
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1581
02:21:53.386 --> 02:21:53.497
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1582
02:21:53.561 --> 02:22:04.327
<v Loretta Smith>Moved to have a freeway, moved to have a, uh, the Coliseum, moved because they were Black and they thought they could move them because they would be the least resistant.

1583
02:22:04.648 --> 02:22:09.477
<v Loretta Smith>So we have to be clear on why we support people and for what we support people for.

1584
02:22:09.942 --> 02:22:10.792
<v Loretta Smith>I'm very clear.

1585
02:22:10.953 --> 02:22:26.417
<v Loretta Smith>I know exactly why I support Albina Vision Trust and Albina Vision Trust being in this language, because again, this this conversation, it just shows why we need people who are African Americans who can have a voice for this platform.

1586
02:22:26.513 --> 02:22:31.519
<v Loretta Smith>And if you don't have them at the room, in the room, they are not going to have anybody speaking up.

1587
02:22:31.904 --> 02:22:39.940
<v Loretta Smith>Now, if I wasn't sitting here, you wouldn't have anybody on this, on this dais speaking the way that I am, because you can't speak from experience.

1588
02:22:40.245 --> 02:22:42.459
<v Loretta Smith>You can't speak from understanding the community.

1589
02:22:42.730 --> 02:22:44.897
<v Loretta Smith>I lived in District 2 most of my life.

1590
02:22:44.977 --> 02:22:46.532
<v Loretta Smith>My grandparents still have their home.

1591
02:22:46.596 --> 02:22:46.725
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1592
02:22:46.837 --> 02:22:51.797
<v Loretta Smith>65 years in Albina after they were moved, and we still have the home.

1593
02:22:52.118 --> 02:23:06.818
<v Loretta Smith>So we have to understand, we have to bring others to our ecosystem to be able to, uh, to, to give us the appropriate, the accurate information about who we are and why we are serving.

1594
02:23:06.948 --> 02:23:14.231
<v Loretta Smith>And so I will support shutting this down, but not for the reason that you're doing it.

1595
02:23:17.546 --> 02:23:17.561
<v Helmi Hissrich>Aye.

1596
02:23:18.563 --> 02:23:18.611
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1597
02:23:20.355 --> 02:23:24.538
<v Rebecca Dobert>With 12 ayes, debate is closed and the amendment is accepted.

1598
02:23:25.039 --> 02:23:30.363
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe that closes debate, but we still need to now immediately move to vote on the amendment.

1599
02:23:32.003 --> 02:23:35.498
<v Rebecca Dobert>Correct.

1600
02:23:36.111 --> 02:23:38.897
<v Sameer Kanal>Having to follow that, uh, is challenging.

1601
02:23:39.718 --> 02:23:46.978
<v Sameer Kanal>And between the moral argument and the D2 argument and being the only person of color representing D2, it's a very easy vote for me.

1602
02:23:47.059 --> 02:23:48.030
<v Sameer Kanal>I vote aye on the amendment.

1603
02:23:49.569 --> 02:23:50.103
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1604
02:23:50.719 --> 02:23:51.027
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

1605
02:23:51.384 --> 02:23:53.020
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, I'm supportive of the amendment.

1606
02:23:53.067 --> 02:23:56.615
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to say I'm glad we're connecting the dots with the North and Northeast Preference Policy.

1607
02:23:56.712 --> 02:23:58.252
<v Dan Ryan>That was what I really enjoyed about it.

1608
02:23:59.063 --> 02:24:06.216
<v Dan Ryan>I think as we were identifying those that have the greatest disparities, Black, Latino, Native American, let's include Pacific Islander.

1609
02:24:06.381 --> 02:24:10.752
<v Dan Ryan>They're often misrepresented, and also elderly and disabled.

1610
02:24:10.849 --> 02:24:14.197
<v Dan Ryan>So that's just a way of saying that I hope that gets added to the study.

1611
02:24:16.305 --> 02:24:16.369
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Aye.

1612
02:24:19.689 --> 02:24:24.560
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm grateful for Councilor Smith's presence on this council and voice.

1613
02:24:25.061 --> 02:24:25.796
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for sharing.

1614
02:24:27.353 --> 02:24:30.793
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for sharing your personal experiences and for bringing them with you to work.

1615
02:24:30.889 --> 02:24:34.291
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You don't necessarily have to do that, and we're benefiting from that.

1616
02:24:35.157 --> 02:24:47.370
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I trust that the director of the Housing Bureau will be able to move forward with this study and there won't be anything presupposed.

1617
02:24:47.515 --> 02:25:03.037
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'm happy to support this amendment knowing that— well, I'm wanting my colleagues to know that I will If we are going to list other partners, I will continue to bring this up, but I vote aye.

1618
02:25:04.629 --> 02:25:04.968
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo?

1619
02:25:05.939 --> 02:25:05.987
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1620
02:25:07.960 --> 02:25:08.009
<v Mark Williams>Aye.

1621
02:25:10.159 --> 02:25:16.417
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I have a certain amount of discomfort with the resolved, uh, ad.

1622
02:25:17.501 --> 02:25:30.441
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I am a little hesitant to call any individual organization out and I felt a little jealousy, actually, like, well, what about Southwest Corridor?

1623
02:25:30.682 --> 02:25:32.674
<v Olivia Clark>You know, we've done a lot of work on that corridor.

1624
02:25:32.754 --> 02:25:34.746
<v Olivia Clark>We want to preserve affordable housing.

1625
02:25:34.795 --> 02:25:38.411
<v Olivia Clark>We have a large immigrant and low-income population in Southwest Portland.

1626
02:25:38.700 --> 02:25:51.868
<v Olivia Clark>However, listening to our council president say a little bit more about the progress that Alameda Vision Trust has actually made on social housing, that maybe they're a great uh, a test pilot for this.

1627
02:25:52.710 --> 02:25:54.041
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I will vote aye.

1628
02:25:58.587 --> 02:25:58.620
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1629
02:26:01.747 --> 02:26:07.253
<v Eric Zimmerman>I met Loretta Smith in her first campaign in 2010.

1630
02:26:07.334 --> 02:26:11.786
<v Eric Zimmerman>She is my longest colleague on this dais, my best friend on this dais.

1631
02:26:12.792 --> 02:26:19.332
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think the health of being able to Have a spirited debate across this dais is really damn good.

1632
02:26:21.224 --> 02:26:22.016
<v Eric Zimmerman>I made my points.

1633
02:26:22.711 --> 02:26:29.261
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that with Councilor Ryan's comments as well, there are other groups that we could be listing.

1634
02:26:29.358 --> 02:26:39.370
<v Eric Zimmerman>Cascade AIDS Project comes up for mind for me of an organization from my community who has a deep need for housing, a deep, deep other needs where people have been displaced.

1635
02:26:39.433 --> 02:26:41.577
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I think those points will still come out in the study.

1636
02:26:41.626 --> 02:26:41.754
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1637
02:26:42.615 --> 02:26:52.037
<v Eric Zimmerman>But, um, when your longest colleague makes a spirited and important point, you change your mind.

1638
02:26:52.218 --> 02:26:53.006
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I vote aye.

1639
02:26:57.231 --> 02:26:57.602
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

1640
02:26:58.101 --> 02:26:58.117
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1641
02:26:59.147 --> 02:26:59.534
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1642
02:26:59.872 --> 02:27:00.033
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1643
02:27:00.468 --> 02:27:00.903
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

1644
02:27:01.805 --> 02:27:01.836
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1645
02:27:02.626 --> 02:27:03.157
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

1646
02:27:04.059 --> 02:27:04.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1647
02:27:04.960 --> 02:27:07.186
<v Rebecca Dobert>And with 12 ayes, the amendment is accepted.

1648
02:27:08.379 --> 02:27:08.844
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Very good.

1649
02:27:09.905 --> 02:27:19.045
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I believe we have a few people in the queue to speak to the resolution as a whole, and I do just want to do a time check.

1650
02:27:19.140 --> 02:27:23.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are scheduled to end at 12:30 with a work session to begin at 1:00.

1651
02:27:24.007 --> 02:27:34.689
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we can extend this meeting to 1:00 and postpone the start of that work session to 1:30 if there is not objection, so that we can at least begin our final agenda item when we're done with this one.

1652
02:27:34.737 --> 02:27:35.684
<v Rebecca Dobert>Excuse me, Council President.

1653
02:27:36.186 --> 02:27:37.876
<v Rebecca Dobert>Testimony is completed for the resolution?

1654
02:27:38.520 --> 02:27:39.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For this resolution?

1655
02:27:39.163 --> 02:27:39.613
<v Rebecca Dobert>For this resolution.

1656
02:27:39.662 --> 02:27:40.111
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, I'm sorry.

1657
02:27:40.481 --> 02:27:44.858
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that we can begin the testimony for the ordinance that's after this for the final agenda item.

1658
02:27:45.561 --> 02:27:46.463
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I should have been more clear.

1659
02:27:47.236 --> 02:27:50.602
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any objections to that slight schedule change, councilors?

1660
02:27:53.034 --> 02:27:53.244
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1661
02:27:53.438 --> 02:27:55.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark, to the resolution.

1662
02:27:56.343 --> 02:27:57.039
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1663
02:27:58.932 --> 02:28:03.849
<v Olivia Clark>This is kind of emotional for me because I started my career in affordable housing.

1664
02:28:05.650 --> 02:28:09.259
<v Olivia Clark>So I really welcome this resolution, and I'm grateful that you brought it forward.

1665
02:28:09.949 --> 02:28:12.674
<v Olivia Clark>It's really music to my ears, very close to my heart.

1666
02:28:13.316 --> 02:28:17.998
<v Olivia Clark>I thank you also for including the addressing impediments amendment.

1667
02:28:18.689 --> 02:28:30.027
<v Olivia Clark>I truly believe a significant segment of our housing needs to be outside the market and remain outside the market to stay affordable over time.

1668
02:28:31.346 --> 02:28:33.490
<v Olivia Clark>I've been working on this for a long time.

1669
02:28:33.539 --> 02:28:38.504
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciated the comments from the Reverend from Montavilla who mentioned the pre-development loan fund.

1670
02:28:39.084 --> 02:28:44.097
<v Olivia Clark>I got the legislation to create that pre-development loan fund, so it's very close to my heart.

1671
02:28:45.360 --> 02:28:47.994
<v Olivia Clark>We did amazing things in Portland during World War II.

1672
02:28:48.365 --> 02:28:51.016
<v Olivia Clark>I know I've referenced that during the campaign.

1673
02:28:51.579 --> 02:29:03.858
<v Olivia Clark>The federal government actually came in and preempted Oregon's— our Portland City Council's Portland zoning code in order to build affordable housing for soldiers and for the people who were working in the shipbuilding industry.

1674
02:29:04.451 --> 02:29:07.278
<v Olivia Clark>We just don't have that kind of gumption here.

1675
02:29:07.647 --> 02:29:10.248
<v Olivia Clark>We're not— I don't feel like we're acting like it's an emergency.

1676
02:29:10.344 --> 02:29:14.054
<v Olivia Clark>So I wish the date had been moved up on the delivery of this plan.

1677
02:29:15.033 --> 02:29:19.031
<v Olivia Clark>And I would echo the comments of the people who said we don't need another plan, we need action.

1678
02:29:19.465 --> 02:29:20.509
<v Olivia Clark>I believe that's true too.

1679
02:29:20.750 --> 02:29:20.909
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1680
02:29:21.472 --> 02:29:25.900
<v Olivia Clark>But I'm happy, very happy to support this and appreciate your bringing forward.

1681
02:29:26.368 --> 02:29:29.426
<v Olivia Clark>And lastly, my best friend lives in Vienna, Austria.

1682
02:29:30.070 --> 02:29:34.277
<v Olivia Clark>I think we should take a field trip and go check out that housing.

1683
02:29:34.862 --> 02:29:37.272
<v Olivia Clark>And I know she's never coming back to the United States.

1684
02:29:37.736 --> 02:29:39.780
<v Olivia Clark>And with that, I'll close my comments.

1685
02:29:39.844 --> 02:29:40.246
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1686
02:29:44.835 --> 02:29:45.528
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1687
02:29:46.284 --> 02:29:46.768
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1688
02:29:47.346 --> 02:29:53.189
<v Loretta Smith>I would like to, to to be able to add another, uh, whereas clause to this resolution.

1689
02:29:54.344 --> 02:29:59.386
<v Loretta Smith>And I, I don't know if this is the right place to, to do it because I think it's so—.

1690
02:29:59.417 --> 02:29:59.787
<v Olivia Clark>This is the time.

1691
02:30:00.123 --> 02:30:00.397
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1692
02:30:00.782 --> 02:30:01.441
<v Loretta Smith>Is this the time?

1693
02:30:01.504 --> 02:30:01.809
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes.

1694
02:30:02.066 --> 02:30:07.092
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, because this is very important to have the data about the numbers.

1695
02:30:07.685 --> 02:30:08.360
<v Loretta Smith>Numbers don't lie.

1696
02:30:09.451 --> 02:30:15.760
<v Loretta Smith>So the new whereas would be based on the 2020 US Census data for yes.

1697
02:30:16.738 --> 02:30:29.411
<v Loretta Smith>The average Black household brings in $3,000 in monthly income, while Latino households earn $4,500 and Native American households earn nearly $5,000.

1698
02:30:29.811 --> 02:30:38.489
<v Loretta Smith>In comparison, white Portland households earn $6,400 on the average each month.

1699
02:30:39.130 --> 02:31:01.593
<v Loretta Smith>And in that report that you identified that's in the Portland Housing Bureau, it shows that white residents can afford a home in about 1/3 of Portland's neighborhoods, while basically Black, Native, and Latino residents, they can't.

1700
02:31:02.094 --> 02:31:10.350
<v Loretta Smith>So you make your point, and I wanted to see if I could add that as an amendment because that data needs to be very It's in the report.

1701
02:31:10.397 --> 02:31:13.539
<v Loretta Smith>I, I took it right out of the report from the Portland Housing Bureau.

1702
02:31:13.875 --> 02:31:14.451
<v Mitch Green>I second that.

1703
02:31:15.221 --> 02:31:19.451
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we have a motion and a second on the table.

1704
02:31:19.548 --> 02:31:22.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This would be to add an additional whereas.

1705
02:31:22.496 --> 02:31:26.630
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, have you specified where that whereas would go in the resolution?

1706
02:31:28.121 --> 02:31:35.768
<v Loretta Smith>I don't have a specific space, but I think after— when you make the comment that the average Black household can't afford you don't have any numbers to it.

1707
02:31:35.816 --> 02:31:40.120
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So would you like it to be after that, whereas— so it'd be the second to last, whereas—.

1708
02:31:40.120 --> 02:31:41.210
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, so that people can see the data.

1709
02:31:41.275 --> 02:31:49.432
<v Loretta Smith>And I can take while that I, that I added, while Latino households— it can just be Latino households earn $4,500.

1710
02:31:50.185 --> 02:31:52.691
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we'll get that language written up for the clerk.

1711
02:31:52.738 --> 02:31:55.324
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see Rebecca looking over here for that.

1712
02:31:55.709 --> 02:32:01.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In the meantime, um, we now are in discussion to the amendment because it has been first and seconded by Councilor Green.

1713
02:32:02.720 --> 02:32:06.295
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Councilor Green, are you in the queue for the amendment?

1714
02:32:07.425 --> 02:32:08.329
<v Mitch Green>I am, Madam President.

1715
02:32:08.556 --> 02:32:09.668
<v Mitch Green>I, I support the amendment.

1716
02:32:09.781 --> 02:32:19.290
<v Mitch Green>I implore my colleagues to just accept this amendment, not debate it and discuss it, so we can vote on it and vote on the original amendment and move on with the agenda, because it's uncontroversial.

1717
02:32:19.532 --> 02:32:19.840
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1718
02:32:21.976 --> 02:32:26.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't see anyone else in the queue for discussion of this amendment.

1719
02:32:26.583 --> 02:32:30.157
<v Loretta Smith>Madam President, uh, Councilor Avalos wanted me to read it again.

1720
02:32:30.206 --> 02:32:31.542
<v Loretta Smith>She didn't get it.

1721
02:32:31.638 --> 02:32:32.396
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1722
02:32:32.477 --> 02:32:33.459
<v Loretta Smith>I'll read it again.

1723
02:32:33.683 --> 02:32:51.693
<v Loretta Smith>It says, whereas, based on 2020 US Census data for Portland, the average Black household brings in about $3,000 in monthly income, Latino households bring in— earn $4,500, and Native American households earn $5,000.

1724
02:32:52.515 --> 02:33:01.559
<v Loretta Smith>In comparison to white Portland households who earn $6,400 a month on, on average each month.

1725
02:33:02.779 --> 02:33:12.977
<v Loretta Smith>And then I said the report shows that white residents can afford a home in about 1/3 of Portland neighborhoods, mostly adjacent to the city's eastern border.

1726
02:33:14.405 --> 02:33:17.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, is that the language directly out of the report?

1727
02:33:17.243 --> 02:33:21.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we're sending it to the clerk I could copy it from the report and send it to her.

1728
02:33:21.399 --> 02:33:21.981
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Exactly.

1729
02:33:22.320 --> 02:33:27.299
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor Avalos, you got it?

1730
02:33:27.962 --> 02:33:33.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I do not see any other discussion, um, anybody waiting in the queue for discussion.

1731
02:33:33.799 --> 02:33:41.451
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, uh, Rebecca, are you comfortable calling the roll as I pull that language up to send to you, or would you like us to wait until you have it in front of you?

1732
02:33:44.060 --> 02:33:45.387
<v Rebecca Dobert>If it's you're sending it now?

1733
02:33:45.760 --> 02:33:46.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am.

1734
02:33:46.198 --> 02:33:47.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm pulling up the report to send it to you right now.

1735
02:33:48.599 --> 02:33:49.701
<v Rebecca Dobert>We can call the roll if council—.

1736
02:33:49.701 --> 02:33:51.924
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, if you could call the roll, that would be great.

1737
02:33:53.646 --> 02:33:54.066
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

1738
02:33:56.476 --> 02:33:57.640
<v Sameer Kanal>On this amendment, I vote aye.

1739
02:33:58.886 --> 02:33:59.176
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

1740
02:33:59.629 --> 02:33:59.710
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1741
02:34:00.422 --> 02:34:00.971
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

1742
02:34:01.570 --> 02:34:03.200
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I enthusiastically vote aye.

1743
02:34:03.907 --> 02:34:04.406
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo?

1744
02:34:04.938 --> 02:34:04.986
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1745
02:34:05.742 --> 02:34:06.159
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

1746
02:34:06.466 --> 02:34:06.546
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1747
02:34:07.045 --> 02:34:07.431
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

1748
02:34:07.753 --> 02:34:07.800
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1749
02:34:08.251 --> 02:34:08.557
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

1750
02:34:08.959 --> 02:34:09.136
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1751
02:34:09.393 --> 02:34:09.810
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1752
02:34:10.020 --> 02:34:10.036
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1753
02:34:11.147 --> 02:34:11.195
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1754
02:34:11.806 --> 02:34:12.174
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy.

1755
02:34:12.528 --> 02:34:12.592
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1756
02:34:12.944 --> 02:34:13.298
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith.

1757
02:34:14.356 --> 02:34:14.822
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney.

1758
02:34:15.398 --> 02:34:15.528
<v Joseph Jesse>Aye.

1759
02:34:16.522 --> 02:34:23.646
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we now are back to discussion on the underlying resolution with its 3 adopted amendments.

1760
02:34:23.693 --> 02:34:25.699
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, are you in the queue or is that—.

1761
02:34:25.907 --> 02:34:27.399
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not in the queue anymore.

1762
02:34:28.025 --> 02:34:35.181
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, last chance for discussion on the underlying resolution with 3 amendments.

1763
02:34:36.128 --> 02:34:38.599
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing none, Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

1764
02:34:38.679 --> 02:34:40.004
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Kanal.

1765
02:34:41.118 --> 02:34:42.409
<v Sameer Kanal>Housing is a human right.

1766
02:34:43.000 --> 02:34:46.621
<v Sameer Kanal>Government has an obligation to make sure it's available and accessible at every income level.

1767
02:34:47.120 --> 02:34:50.245
<v Sameer Kanal>Like most of the country, we're in an affordable housing crisis in Portland.

1768
02:34:50.518 --> 02:34:58.277
<v Sameer Kanal>We cannot rely exclusively on the private sector and its profit motive to be the sole solution, and social housing is therefore one of the ways that we can address Portland's crisis.

1769
02:34:59.837 --> 02:35:01.191
<v Sameer Kanal>I am going to support this.

1770
02:35:01.240 --> 02:35:04.674
<v Sameer Kanal>I do want to encourage Director Hystrich to keep as much of the study in-house as possible.

1771
02:35:05.513 --> 02:35:11.336
<v Sameer Kanal>And to listen to the public testimony we received from the Sightline Institute rider and create spaces for the public to weigh in.

1772
02:35:11.400 --> 02:35:18.188
<v Sameer Kanal>So PHB and eventually the council will receive the unexpected and varied voices he mentioned, including from people that we've mentioned, the groups.

1773
02:35:18.748 --> 02:35:21.507
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also want to thank everyone who wrote in testimony as well.

1774
02:35:21.974 --> 02:35:26.336
<v Sameer Kanal>I was already in support of this document, but it was nice to hear why from so many of you, especially the renters.

1775
02:35:27.573 --> 02:35:30.653
<v Sameer Kanal>We're 47% of the population, only 2 or 3 of us up here.

1776
02:35:31.252 --> 02:35:43.876
<v Sameer Kanal>I also want to note one piece of written testimony which noted the positive impacts of social housing on our construction workforce by smoothing out the sort of ups and downs of the market in construction that hadn't been brought up yet.

1777
02:35:43.940 --> 02:35:46.387
<v Sameer Kanal>So I wanted to make sure to daylight that as well.

1778
02:35:46.934 --> 02:35:50.905
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks to everybody for putting this forward, in particular Councilors Avalos and Green.

1779
02:35:50.977 --> 02:35:51.354
<v Sameer Kanal>I vote aye.

1780
02:35:53.665 --> 02:35:53.876
<v Emily Dumerck>Ryan?

1781
02:35:54.476 --> 02:35:57.425
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I'm supportive of the resolution as amended.

1782
02:35:57.490 --> 02:35:58.236
<v Dan Ryan>This study's needed.

1783
02:35:58.947 --> 02:36:01.740
<v Dan Ryan>And I do hope we concentrate on studies from cities in this country.

1784
02:36:02.254 --> 02:36:02.736
<v Dan Ryan>I love Vienna.

1785
02:36:02.800 --> 02:36:04.503
<v Dan Ryan>I've never been there, but kind of liked it.

1786
02:36:04.583 --> 02:36:06.525
<v Dan Ryan>Wasn't that in Sound of Music when I was a little kid?

1787
02:36:06.574 --> 02:36:08.115
<v Dan Ryan>All right, there's that.

1788
02:36:08.597 --> 02:36:09.817
<v Dan Ryan>But our reality is this country.

1789
02:36:09.881 --> 02:36:12.338
<v Dan Ryan>So let's focus on cities in the United States.

1790
02:36:12.451 --> 02:36:15.149
<v Dan Ryan>I look forward to this robust, unbiased study.

1791
02:36:15.824 --> 02:36:25.877
<v Dan Ryan>And while we're all here talking about the humanitarian crisis, I hope we start demanding that we offer behavioral and mental health services for everyone who needs it in our city and county.

1792
02:36:25.941 --> 02:36:26.068
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1793
02:36:26.342 --> 02:36:35.548
<v Dan Ryan>That will get us to the heart of the matter with direct action to be to a bold solution to address this humanitarian crisis and get individuals into housing who need it.

1794
02:36:35.900 --> 02:36:36.284
<v Eric Zimmerman>I vote aye.

1795
02:36:39.173 --> 02:36:41.570
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm thrilled to support this and be a co-sponsor.

1796
02:36:41.666 --> 02:36:47.184
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's a lot I can say about social housing, but I want to cede my time to make sure we have time for public testimony.

1797
02:36:47.298 --> 02:36:47.683
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I vote aye.

1798
02:36:49.129 --> 02:36:49.146
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1799
02:36:49.825 --> 02:36:49.876
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1800
02:36:51.847 --> 02:37:03.362
<v Steve Novick>I have to say, I started off wondering why the rush to adopt this resolution so early in our term, given that the idea is to explore a model pioneered in Vienna, and Billy Joel specifically tells us that Vienna will wait for us.

1801
02:37:03.833 --> 02:37:07.875
<v Steve Novick>But I've been convinced by my co-sponsors and the testimony the timing is appropriate.

1802
02:37:09.340 --> 02:37:09.516
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1803
02:37:10.388 --> 02:37:12.324
<v Olivia Clark>I also enthusiastically vote aye.

1804
02:37:12.549 --> 02:37:15.630
<v Mitch Green>Thank you all for your support.

1805
02:37:16.099 --> 02:37:16.147
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>Aye.

1806
02:37:18.579 --> 02:37:18.611
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1807
02:37:19.173 --> 02:37:20.260
<v Candace Avalos>Social housing, let's go!

1808
02:37:20.573 --> 02:37:21.018
<v Candace Avalos>I vote aye.

1809
02:37:24.090 --> 02:37:25.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, colleagues.

1810
02:37:25.650 --> 02:37:33.897
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Every time we try to make a bold move on housing, whether it's affordability, stability, or fairness, we hear the same refrain: the private market won't build if you do that.

1811
02:37:34.041 --> 02:37:36.451
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So it's time for us to stop waiting on the private market.

1812
02:37:37.019 --> 02:37:38.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a supply-side problem.

1813
02:37:38.620 --> 02:37:39.978
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is not a regulatory problem.

1814
02:37:40.541 --> 02:37:56.652
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A developer recently told me that if we handed him the land and the permits for free, They still wouldn't be building in Portland today because the financiers of housing construction won't invest unless they're guaranteed exorbitant returns in the form of extremely high rents, which requires a constrained supply.

1815
02:37:56.844 --> 02:38:02.001
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That means there's no scenario in which developers will build enough housing to affect the supply problem.

1816
02:38:02.627 --> 02:38:04.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They're not going to risk their own returns.

1817
02:38:04.409 --> 02:38:09.597
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if developers won't build what our city needs, then the city must explore how we do it ourselves.

1818
02:38:09.663 --> 02:38:09.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1819
02:38:10.272 --> 02:38:11.442
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I have some concerns.

1820
02:38:12.582 --> 02:38:22.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As a government, the City of Portland has abandoned our historic responsibility to build things, and we've especially lost our ability to build things at scale in a timely and affordable way.

1821
02:38:22.797 --> 02:38:30.046
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I look forward to the report coming back with tangible and specific recommendations for this body to take in order to get the cost per square foot down.

1822
02:38:30.575 --> 02:38:35.978
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Simply, this project will not work if we're building at 200% of what the market, the private market provides.

1823
02:38:36.509 --> 02:38:39.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So let's get the facts, let's get the tools, and let's get ready to act.

1824
02:38:39.630 --> 02:38:39.992
<v Brian Calacci>I vote aye.

1825
02:38:41.926 --> 02:38:41.976
<v Travis Noddings>Aye.

1826
02:38:43.074 --> 02:38:48.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate Councilor Avalos's work to develop this important resolution.

1827
02:38:49.653 --> 02:39:00.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This speaks to how we move forward in addressing our needs as a community in a way that says that we're open for business, open for partnership, and open for people, and that we don't have to choose between those 3 things.

1828
02:39:01.448 --> 02:39:04.735
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This work sets up an important conversation about what our future looks like.

1829
02:39:06.136 --> 02:39:08.623
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As council president, I'm thrilled to see us do this work.

1830
02:39:08.944 --> 02:39:31.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as a councilor in District 2 in North and Northeast Portland, where so many people have been displaced, I appreciate my colleagues' willingness to think about how we can use the North and Northeast preference policy and ensure that that is part of the work that's done in this study and that our partners who are already working on social housing with us are a part of this work.

1831
02:39:31.820 --> 02:39:31.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1832
02:39:32.609 --> 02:39:33.092
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I vote aye.

1833
02:39:34.299 --> 02:39:38.146
<v Rebecca Dobert>With 12 ayes, the resolution is adopted as amended.

1834
02:39:41.069 --> 02:39:43.897
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we have one agenda item left.

1835
02:39:44.218 --> 02:39:46.756
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have 55 minutes.

1836
02:39:46.950 --> 02:39:51.567
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for your flexibility in that short change to our agenda.

1837
02:39:53.495 --> 02:39:56.655
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Rebecca, can you please call agenda item 16?

1838
02:39:57.870 --> 02:40:13.378
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Amend Affordable Housing Code to add prohibition of anti-competitive rental okay, and I believe we have Claire coming back up to provide a committee staff summary for us.

1839
02:40:19.289 --> 02:40:24.990
<v Claire Adamsick>Uh, Madam President, councilors, again for the record, Claire Adamsick from Council Operations and staff to the Homelessness and Housing Committee.

1840
02:40:25.666 --> 02:40:34.837
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance before you, document number 2025-45 adds new provisions to Portland City Code Section 30.01.088.

1841
02:40:35.546 --> 02:40:47.487
<v Claire Adamsick>It prohibits the sale, purchase, or use of price-setting tools that analyze or compile competitively sensitive information to recommend or set residential rental prices, fees, or occupancy levels or lease terms for dwelling units.

1842
02:40:48.222 --> 02:41:03.065
<v Claire Adamsick>It further prohibits a landlord or landlord's agent from sharing competitively sensitive information for use in a price-setting tool or price-fixing scheme within the city, or from allowing a third party with access to competitively sensitive information to establish rent prices for a dwelling unit.

1843
02:41:03.788 --> 02:41:12.827
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance describes an aggrieved tenant's private right of action and eligibility for damages and calculates violations for noncompliance with these code provisions.

1844
02:41:13.325 --> 02:41:18.448
<v Claire Adamsick>And it also allows the city attorney to investigate violations and seek injunctive relief, damages, and civil penalties.

1845
02:41:18.703 --> 02:41:18.816
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1846
02:41:19.201 --> 02:41:31.139
<v Claire Adamsick>Any action under this section may be filed within 5 years of the violation, and penalties authorized by this code section will apply to any contracts entered into after the effective date of the ordinance.

1847
02:41:31.941 --> 02:41:37.438
<v Claire Adamsick>I will note for the council that the committee adopted an amendment prior to moving the item to full council.

1848
02:41:37.950 --> 02:41:44.168
<v Claire Adamsick>The effects of that amendment are summarized in the— or sorry, the effects of the amendment on the original ordinance draft are summarized in the committee staff summary.

1849
02:41:44.217 --> 02:41:44.745
<v Claire Adamsick>Thank you, Deputy City Attorney.

1850
02:41:45.082 --> 02:41:47.005
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1851
02:41:48.272 --> 02:41:57.921
<v Claire Adamsick>And the full impact statement on this item includes a financial and budget impact and analysis, economic and real estate development impact and analysis, and community impacts and community involvement.

1852
02:41:59.108 --> 02:42:26.409
<v Claire Adamsick>In terms of public testimony heard by the committee at the first committee meeting on this item on February 25th, 5 people provided verbal testimony, 83 people submitted written testimony prior to committee action, and an additional 21 people submitted testimony the general themes of the testimony included strengthening protections for renters, particularly low-income people of color and seniors, people with disabilities at risk of homelessness.

1853
02:42:27.639 --> 02:42:46.157
<v Claire Adamsick>It also included the use of technology tools by third-party companies to coordinate anti-competitive rental pricing practices, policy alignment with current state and federal actions, protecting fair market competition in Portland's housing market, and ensuring that the city's housing policy is code enforcement as an alternative to private right of action against property owners found in violation.

1854
02:42:47.456 --> 02:42:53.753
<v Claire Adamsick>The correlation between higher rents and increased vacancy rates, limiting potential— potentially limiting access to affordable units.

1855
02:42:54.763 --> 02:43:00.899
<v Claire Adamsick>Ensuring landlords and property owners may continue the use of revenue management tools to support their business operations.

1856
02:43:02.054 --> 02:43:07.228
<v Claire Adamsick>The request for evaluation of the city's current rental housing regulations prior to adopting new regulations.

1857
02:43:07.889 --> 02:43:15.279
<v Claire Adamsick>And finally, damage for violations of this proposed code as a potential deterrent for future housing development.

1858
02:43:15.552 --> 02:43:16.763
<v Claire Adamsick>And that concludes the committee report.

1859
02:43:18.384 --> 02:43:18.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1860
02:43:19.095 --> 02:43:23.042
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Avalos, I believe you chaired the committee.

1861
02:43:23.626 --> 02:43:25.745
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there anything you'd like to add to that committee report?

1862
02:43:26.229 --> 02:43:27.588
<v Candace Avalos>I do have things to add.

1863
02:43:27.927 --> 02:43:28.171
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>All right.

1864
02:43:28.977 --> 02:43:30.530
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you, Claire.

1865
02:43:31.240 --> 02:43:52.370
<v Candace Avalos>Before the ordinance sponsor, Councilor Morillo, introduces the details of the bill, I would like to offer some additional context about how this bill traveled through my committee because I want this on public record since this ordinance serves as a test case and it is important for the entire council to be fully aware of some of the challenges we will all have to address in the absence of guidance or codes.

1866
02:43:52.979 --> 02:43:59.672
<v Candace Avalos>First, when this policy was first brought to our attention, we planned to schedule it for 2 45-minute hearings to include public testimony.

1867
02:44:01.148 --> 02:44:17.670
<v Candace Avalos>But on February 24th, we received new guidance from Council President stating, quote, moving forward, you may of course discuss and debate an ordinance or resolution for as long as your committee needs, but if an ordinance is ready for passage after being posted for just one hearing with public testimony, of course you are ready to send it to council, please do so.

1868
02:44:17.846 --> 02:44:20.063
<v Candace Avalos>There is no need to schedule a second reading of the ordinance in the committee.

1869
02:44:20.736 --> 02:44:32.844
<v Candace Avalos>But because this change in direction came the day before the first hearing of this ordinance, I didn't feel comfortable changing the direction and insisted that it come back to committee a second time so that there was ample time for committee members to engage and offer amendments.

1870
02:44:33.519 --> 02:44:37.719
<v Candace Avalos>So then on February 25th, the ordinance came for the first hearing and it received public testimony.

1871
02:44:38.153 --> 02:44:43.974
<v Candace Avalos>And after the hearing, our office engaged with stakeholders including RealPage and Swift Public Affairs.

1872
02:44:44.085 --> 02:44:52.313
<v Candace Avalos>We met with the attorney's office to get several questions answered, and we assumed that all offices were doing the same to prepare for the second hearing and to offer any amendments that they had.

1873
02:44:52.986 --> 02:44:59.720
<v Candace Avalos>By the time it came back to committee a full month later, it had received a full legal and clerk review, and the language was improved to offer clarity.

1874
02:44:59.769 --> 02:44:59.864
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1875
02:45:00.345 --> 02:45:05.072
<v Candace Avalos>We found no substantive changes to the intent or the outcomes, and this was confirmed by the attorneys and the clerk.

1876
02:45:05.792 --> 02:45:12.058
<v Candace Avalos>I personally was satisfied with the bill and ready to vote it to full council if a majority vote of the committee agreed.

1877
02:45:12.699 --> 02:45:17.569
<v Candace Avalos>We had a majority of the committee members who felt the same, and we voted to refer it out to council.

1878
02:45:18.290 --> 02:45:29.088
<v Candace Avalos>I will also note that days before the bill came to the committee the second time, my chief of staff had a couple of conversations with council president's office and received instruction that public testimony was required at least once.

1879
02:45:29.137 --> 02:45:29.264
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1880
02:45:29.665 --> 02:45:33.308
<v Candace Avalos>But there's no need for additional testimony unless substantive changes were made.

1881
02:45:33.772 --> 02:45:40.686
<v Candace Avalos>It should also be noted though that there is no code, neither for committee procedures or council procedures, that require public testimony after amendments are made.

1882
02:45:41.152 --> 02:45:52.638
<v Candace Avalos>I understand this has been best practice in past council sessions, and we do expect that practice to continue in council at the discretion of council president, which is why I felt it was important to get this ordinance in front of the full body.

1883
02:45:53.407 --> 02:46:04.183
<v Candace Avalos>I look forward to sharing my experience and my recommendations for how we can improve our processes with the Governance Committee at their earliest convenience, because it is urgent that we all agree on the procedures as soon as possible.

1884
02:46:04.359 --> 02:46:06.769
<v Candace Avalos>So I wanted to add that context 'cause there's been a lot of discussion.

1885
02:46:06.833 --> 02:46:21.867
<v Candace Avalos>And again, I think this serves as an opportunity for us to reflect on ways that we can make sure we're being inclusive, not only of the public, but also of our councilors as we are moving legislation forward and we're all weighing in from the perspective of our districts, which is what happens at council meeting, not at committee.

1886
02:46:22.318 --> 02:46:25.845
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, I'm going to pass it forward to Councilor Morillo to introduce her bill.

1887
02:46:26.944 --> 02:46:28.611
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

1888
02:46:29.927 --> 02:46:31.665
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, first I want to start off with my colleagues.

1889
02:46:31.763 --> 02:46:35.805
<v Angelita Morillo>Can you raise your hands if you watched the Housing Committee presentation from February 25th?

1890
02:46:39.886 --> 02:46:41.190
<v Angelita Morillo>Oh, okay, great.

1891
02:46:41.817 --> 02:46:48.105
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I think it's important that we have this discussion on process, and I'm not going to delve on it too long, but the reality is the thank you.

1892
02:46:48.201 --> 02:47:01.465
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it's important to note that the previous— that this current setup actually punishes you for having a lot of public support for your testimony, because now we have less than an hour to go over antitrust law and algorithms, which are both very complicated things to cover.

1893
02:47:01.931 --> 02:47:16.407
<v Angelita Morillo>And we have done everything we can as an office to hold your hands through this process and make sure that you have as many answers to your questions so that I don't have to answer the question about whether or not our ordinance bans Excel sheets anymore, um, because it does not, just for the record.

1894
02:47:17.081 --> 02:47:35.012
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, and so I think that, you know, in the future we need to discuss what it means to actually have a robust public engagement process, because we have a lot of people who are here, I know, in support, and we are essentially getting punished for having that public support because it's eaten up some of our time to go over these complex matters.

1895
02:47:35.524 --> 02:47:47.415
<v Angelita Morillo>With that, I'm going to go over my overview of the policy, and then we're going to have some experts, including folks who are in opposition to our ordinance, come and speak because we thought it was important to have their perspective here as well.

1896
02:47:48.120 --> 02:47:52.110
<v Angelita Morillo>So I want to start off with how this all began with a Department of Justice lawsuit.

1897
02:47:52.447 --> 02:48:01.308
<v Angelita Morillo>So in 2024, the United States Department of Justice sued a company called RealPage, alleging that its software represented a price-fixing scheme to raise rents.

1898
02:48:01.805 --> 02:48:16.463
<v Angelita Morillo>In May of 2024, the FBI raided the Atlanta headquarters of a parking manager Cotland Management as part of an ongoing investigation by the U.S. Department of Justice into potential antitrust violations into the multifamily housing industry.

1899
02:48:17.138 --> 02:48:29.061
<v Angelita Morillo>I want to note for my colleagues that the Department of Justice does not bring things forward unless there is serious evidence, findings, evidence of collusion, evidence of cartel behavior.

1900
02:48:29.174 --> 02:48:31.022
<v Angelita Morillo>And I know everyone's afraid of the word cartel.

1901
02:48:31.102 --> 02:48:34.737
<v Angelita Morillo>We're not talking about thank you.

1902
02:48:36.980 --> 02:48:45.685
<v Angelita Morillo>This is going to be hurting everybody— renters, small housing providers, and small businesses and small landlords— because people aren't investing their money in the economy.

1903
02:48:46.025 --> 02:48:56.457
<v Angelita Morillo>Everybody hurts and everybody loses except for RealPage and companies that are using these types of algorithms to price fix and to help themselves at the expense of everyone else.

1904
02:48:57.039 --> 02:49:00.274
<v Angelita Morillo>So people have asked us a lot, is this even a problem in Portland?

1905
02:49:00.420 --> 02:49:02.245
<v Angelita Morillo>And I can I can absolutely tell you that it is.

1906
02:49:02.680 --> 02:49:06.102
<v Angelita Morillo>46% Of our constituents are renters.

1907
02:49:06.777 --> 02:49:16.914
<v Angelita Morillo>2 Of the top 3 largest landlords that are named defendants in the federal lawsuits against RealPage own a minimum of 32,000 units in the city of Portland.

1908
02:49:17.219 --> 02:49:18.954
<v Angelita Morillo>That would be Greystar and Avenue 5.

1909
02:49:19.532 --> 02:49:27.211
<v Angelita Morillo>They didn't identify themselves in public testimony, but if you read their written testimony and you search some of the names, you'll find which companies they work for.

1910
02:49:30.934 --> 02:49:50.412
<v Angelita Morillo>According to the United States Department of Justice, the Portland market is a market where, and I quote, agreements between RealPage and landlords and agreements among landlords to share nonpublic competitively sensitive information for use in pricing conventional multifamily rentals have harmed or are likely to harm competition and thus renters.

1911
02:49:51.085 --> 02:49:52.657
<v Angelita Morillo>Common sense laws exist to protect renters.

1912
02:49:52.722 --> 02:49:52.995
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Herbold.

1913
02:49:53.156 --> 02:49:53.673
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1914
02:49:53.737 --> 02:49:53.915
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Mayor.

1915
02:49:54.012 --> 02:49:56.854
<v Angelita Morillo>This is an emergency ordinance to address problems that might happen in the future anyways.

1916
02:49:57.436 --> 02:50:02.459
<v Angelita Morillo>And this is a very common-sense law that is coming not just in our city but across the entire United States.

1917
02:50:06.716 --> 02:50:09.759
<v Angelita Morillo>This is what our ordinance does and what our ordinance does not do.

1918
02:50:10.843 --> 02:50:11.781
<v Angelita Morillo>This is what our ordinance does.

1919
02:50:12.299 --> 02:50:16.487
<v Angelita Morillo>It prohibits 3 categories of practice, and each of these practice categories have—.

1920
02:50:16.667 --> 02:50:16.879
<v Angelita Morillo>Are—.

1921
02:50:17.320 --> 02:50:19.395
<v Angelita Morillo>Fall under anti-competitive practices.

1922
02:50:20.112 --> 02:50:23.936
<v Angelita Morillo>But the 3 in concert function as highly anti-competitive business models.

1923
02:50:24.434 --> 02:50:45.015
<v Angelita Morillo>So that includes landlords sharing competitively sensitive information with other landlords or entities that operate a price-setting tool, a person or entity using a price-setting tool entering into an agreement to use a price-setting tool charging rent that was determined with a price-setting tool or engaging in a price-fixing scheme, and entities selling or licensing price-setting tools.

1924
02:50:45.564 --> 02:51:00.638
<v Angelita Morillo>What this ordinance does not do— mom-and-pop landlords can continue to use spreadsheets like Excel or algorithms to track their property data, as well as the data of any property in which they have the majority or beneficial 25% ownership.

1925
02:51:01.333 --> 02:51:18.189
<v Angelita Morillo>Using spreadsheets or algorithms to track their property data along with aggregated data of publicly available listings, preparing or using report studies or other forms of market research using publicly available data, and using tools like Zillow or other services that provide existing rental data value estimates.

1926
02:51:18.558 --> 02:51:20.753
<v Angelita Morillo>I also want to note that our office met with Zillow.

1927
02:51:21.105 --> 02:51:25.913
<v Angelita Morillo>They had zero concerns about our ordinance because they are not using their public data to price fix.

1928
02:51:27.019 --> 02:51:33.092
<v Angelita Morillo>Using any other tools in this manner that does not facilitate price fixing and coordination is completely acceptable.

1929
02:51:33.540 --> 02:51:44.837
<v Angelita Morillo>To the extent that you need to share competitively sensitive information, like information about your pricing strategy or supply and demand data to your bank or legal advisors, you can already do so under existing agency law.

1930
02:51:45.400 --> 02:51:56.129
<v Angelita Morillo>However, under existing antitrust law and rules of professional ethics, it is potentially problematic for you to do so if the bank employee or legal advisors are your competitors.

1931
02:51:57.365 --> 02:52:09.988
<v Angelita Morillo>The analogy that I would use for this, if it makes it simple for you, is if you are playing a soccer game and your referee is a part of one of the teams and they're the ones making the calls, well, it would be beneficial for them to make calls that support their own team, right?

1932
02:52:10.132 --> 02:52:12.012
<v Angelita Morillo>That's the simple analogy that I can make for this.

1933
02:52:12.846 --> 02:52:16.266
<v Angelita Morillo>This ordinance does not change any of the existing antitrust law.

1934
02:52:16.781 --> 02:52:23.396
<v Angelita Morillo>This is simply closing the loophole on algorithms and the 21st century version of this problem.

1935
02:52:24.728 --> 02:52:29.048
<v Angelita Morillo>I also want to point out to my colleagues that this is going to be the norm across the entire United States.

1936
02:52:29.450 --> 02:52:30.781
<v Angelita Morillo>4 cities have already passed it.

1937
02:52:30.925 --> 02:52:33.494
<v Angelita Morillo>Berkeley, San Francisco, Minneapolis, and Philadelphia.

1938
02:52:33.735 --> 02:52:36.254
<v Angelita Morillo>5 other cities are looking into the ban as well.

1939
02:52:36.768 --> 02:52:39.224
<v Angelita Morillo>The state of Washington is on the verge of passing it.

1940
02:52:39.897 --> 02:52:45.418
<v Angelita Morillo>And we have legislators at the state and federal level who are trying to push this legislation.

1941
02:52:45.868 --> 02:52:51.518
<v Angelita Morillo>Senator Gorsek is trying to pass this at the Oregon legislature, but the bill has not been rescheduled for another hearing.

1942
02:52:52.352 --> 02:52:58.307
<v Angelita Morillo>Senator Ron Wyden is pushing this at the federal level, but given the makeup of our federal government, it's pretty unclear if it's going to pass.

1943
02:52:58.354 --> 02:52:58.514
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1944
02:52:58.579 --> 02:52:58.804
<v Angelita Morillo>Pass.

1945
02:52:59.478 --> 02:53:05.004
<v Angelita Morillo>This could be our one and only chance to protect Portlanders against corporate landlords who are price fixing.

1946
02:53:05.663 --> 02:53:14.561
<v Angelita Morillo>Our ordinance reaffirms over 100 years of antitrust laws under the Sherman Antitrust Act, and it simply closes the loophole for our advancing technology.

1947
02:53:15.253 --> 02:53:20.424
<v Angelita Morillo>So with that, uh, Council President, this ordinance is at the intersection of law, economics, and technology.

1948
02:53:20.552 --> 02:53:27.489
<v Angelita Morillo>It's a very simple premise: the idea that price fixing and coordination are illegal, whether conducted in person or digitally via datasets and algorithms.

1949
02:53:28.066 --> 02:53:42.495
<v Angelita Morillo>But given the complexity of the topics implicated, given the fact that the majority of my colleagues did not have time to watch the Housing Committee presentation that detailed this, we want to ensure that everyone is on the same page and have subject matter experts who are available to speak to the common misunderstandings.

1950
02:53:43.876 --> 02:53:46.556
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor, for that thorough overview.

1951
02:53:47.165 --> 02:53:50.500
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, there were a number of comments made about thank you.

1952
02:53:50.500 --> 02:53:50.500
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

1953
02:53:50.500 --> 02:54:00.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do want to acknowledge that we have had a few questions about our process, which I think I'll address another time because I'd like us to get through our technical questions and get to hearing from at least a few folks before 1 o'clock.

1954
02:54:01.579 --> 02:54:17.440
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So this is the time not for discussion, but to clarify some of what we have heard about what happened in committee so that everybody on council has a clear understanding of the discussion so that we can make informed decisions today, even though we were not a part part of it.

1955
02:54:17.726 --> 02:54:19.747
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Of that full discussion in the past.

1956
02:54:20.292 --> 02:54:22.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, do you have such a question?

1957
02:54:23.037 --> 02:54:25.155
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, um, thank you, Madam President.

1958
02:54:25.202 --> 02:54:30.706
<v Loretta Smith>I do have a question because I may have a, a possible, um, conflict of interest.

1959
02:54:31.363 --> 02:54:33.657
<v Loretta Smith>I am a, a smallplex owner.

1960
02:54:34.492 --> 02:54:56.193
<v Loretta Smith>I am a part of that 77% of the people who actually are considered mom-and-pop, and I was wondering If there's a way to put where we can exclude those folks who are in the 77% group from not being held responsible for this, that would be great.

1961
02:54:56.675 --> 02:54:57.638
<v Loretta Smith>So that is my question.

1962
02:54:57.702 --> 02:54:58.024
<v Loretta Smith>Is there—.

1963
02:54:58.024 --> 02:55:01.524
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That would be an amendment proposal which we could talk through in discussion.

1964
02:55:01.894 --> 02:55:04.093
<v Loretta Smith>I— okay, no, I'm just asking the question.

1965
02:55:04.543 --> 02:55:05.105
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that possible?

1966
02:55:05.170 --> 02:55:06.406
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is it technically possible?

1967
02:55:06.453 --> 02:55:08.284
<v Loretta Smith>Is that technically possible to do that?

1968
02:55:10.020 --> 02:55:16.254
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, would you like to respond to the technical possibility of that with the language that you've put forward?

1969
02:55:18.049 --> 02:55:25.067
<v Angelita Morillo>I would say that some of our testimony are probably going to articulate this, but antitrust law is already incredibly difficult to prove.

1970
02:55:25.486 --> 02:55:29.806
<v Angelita Morillo>I keep hearing about these mom-and-pop landlords that are terrified that they're going to be sued under this.

1971
02:55:30.819 --> 02:55:36.287
<v Angelita Morillo>They are not the ones, and we've even spoken about this, they're not the ones using this technology, so they are not price fixing.

1972
02:55:36.719 --> 02:55:40.075
<v Angelita Morillo>They're not going to get tried under a court of law for this.

1973
02:55:40.558 --> 02:55:44.282
<v Angelita Morillo>I also want to point out that other jurisdictions have much higher penalties.

1974
02:55:44.346 --> 02:55:45.840
<v Angelita Morillo>We went pretty gentle with this.

1975
02:55:46.353 --> 02:55:56.662
<v Angelita Morillo>Philadelphia has $2,000 fines a day for this type of thing because antitrust law is so difficult to prove that it needs to be a deterrent for the companies that are doing this.

1976
02:55:57.834 --> 02:55:58.781
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1977
02:56:00.397 --> 02:56:00.724
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1978
02:56:01.113 --> 02:56:02.869
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, technical question?

1979
02:56:03.649 --> 02:56:06.218
<v Mitch Green>No, my question's for after we hear from the invited testimony.

1980
02:56:10.208 --> 02:56:12.362
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll talk about the testimony pieces in a minute.

1981
02:56:12.556 --> 02:56:13.344
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

1982
02:56:14.888 --> 02:56:27.972
<v Steve Novick>And cut me off if these questions are inappropriate, but I just— and I apologize, I have not studied the legislation closely enough, didn't watch the committee, and I had folks who are opposed or have concerns come to me just yesterday.

1983
02:56:28.239 --> 02:56:39.308
<v Steve Novick>So I'm playing catch-up here, but like one of the questions raised was, well, if you're saying it's okay for people to use spreadsheets, why are spreadsheets listed among price-setting tools?

1984
02:56:40.558 --> 02:56:44.522
<v Angelita Morillo>So, and I want to point out a problem in process, right?

1985
02:56:44.569 --> 02:56:46.736
<v Angelita Morillo>My colleagues have all heard from corporate lobbyists.

1986
02:56:46.783 --> 02:56:52.929
<v Angelita Morillo>They're not going to get to hear from the community as much today, and they didn't go through all of the materials when we're having this substantive discussion.

1987
02:56:53.763 --> 02:56:54.356
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's partly a time issue.

1988
02:56:54.469 --> 02:56:54.549
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

1989
02:56:54.613 --> 02:56:57.195
<v Angelita Morillo>So it's a timing issue and a process issue, and I just want to acknowledge that.

1990
02:56:57.371 --> 02:56:59.408
<v Angelita Morillo>It's not like an individual sin from everybody.

1991
02:56:59.953 --> 02:57:10.329
<v Angelita Morillo>The reason it's listed there is because there— you could technically use a spreadsheet in Excel to price fix if you so desired to, but that doesn't mean that you are using it for that purpose.

1992
02:57:10.715 --> 02:57:14.500
<v Angelita Morillo>So it is naming the specific technologies that could be used for this.

1993
02:57:15.365 --> 02:57:17.884
<v Angelita Morillo>If you are using Excel not to price fix, then you are fine.

1994
02:57:18.460 --> 02:57:23.745
<v Angelita Morillo>If Excel was going to be banned, I promise you that Microsoft would be all up in this building.

1995
02:57:26.957 --> 02:57:27.903
<v Steve Novick>Okay, second question.

1996
02:57:27.951 --> 02:57:29.632
<v Steve Novick>I'm going to try to limit this.

1997
02:57:32.158 --> 02:57:40.022
<v Steve Novick>Another argument we heard was that competitively sensitive information used to be nonpublic information.

1998
02:57:41.010 --> 02:57:52.748
<v Steve Novick>And so if nonpublic is no longer there, does that mean you're saying that competitively sensitive information even if it's public, should not, should not be used in this manner.

1999
02:57:53.168 --> 02:57:58.114
<v Steve Novick>But basically the argument was, why don't you go back to say information not available to the general public?

2000
02:58:01.729 --> 02:58:04.880
<v Angelita Morillo>Competitively sensitive data is a legal term.

2001
02:58:05.656 --> 02:58:08.420
<v Angelita Morillo>Susie, do you want to take this one, or is Tony here to explain this?

2002
02:58:10.041 --> 02:58:11.131
<v Susie Doister>I'm happy to take it unless—.

2003
02:58:11.164 --> 02:58:13.034
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Susie, could you introduce yourself for us?

2004
02:58:13.198 --> 02:58:13.603
<v Susie Doister>Yes, of course.

2005
02:58:13.956 --> 02:58:15.336
<v Susie Doister>Hi everyone, I'm Susie Doister.

2006
02:58:15.402 --> 02:58:17.055
<v Susie Doister>I'm Councilor Murillo's policy advisor.

2007
02:58:17.103 --> 02:58:18.114
<v Susie Doister>I'm also an attorney.

2008
02:58:18.692 --> 02:58:19.031
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2009
02:58:19.335 --> 02:58:19.720
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

2010
02:58:20.235 --> 02:58:20.507
<v Susie Doister>Thank you.

2011
02:58:20.556 --> 02:58:24.073
<v Susie Doister>I don't know if Tony's here, but I'm happy to respond if that's helpful.

2012
02:58:24.554 --> 02:58:29.420
<v Susie Doister>So competitively sensitive information, I think it's important to be able to look at the—.

2013
02:58:29.484 --> 02:58:31.539
<v Susie Doister>Oh, go ahead, please continue.

2014
02:58:31.700 --> 02:58:32.373
<v Susie Doister>Oh, hi Tony.

2015
02:58:32.422 --> 02:58:40.001
<v Susie Doister>Yeah, so competitively sensitive information, I think it's very helpful to both look at the text of the definition and think about the intent.

2016
02:58:40.066 --> 02:58:46.070
<v Susie Doister>So this is how a court would examine this So competitively sensitive information, looking at the text in the ordinance.

2017
02:58:46.552 --> 02:58:51.738
<v Susie Doister>We changed this definition to first be in greater alignment with best practice in this space.

2018
02:58:51.787 --> 02:58:55.880
<v Susie Doister>So this definition was pulled directly from the Cortland proposed final judgment.

2019
02:58:56.186 --> 02:58:58.337
<v Susie Doister>So Councilor Murillo alluded to that previously.

2020
02:58:58.755 --> 02:59:09.494
<v Susie Doister>Cortland was a defendant along with RealPage and many other named property managers and other large organizations that were being accused of using Price-fixing tools and other collusive measures.

2021
02:59:10.407 --> 02:59:17.670
<v Susie Doister>This definition was pulled directly from that PFJ, proposed final judgment, and we wanted to be in greater alignment with it for that reason.

2022
02:59:17.718 --> 02:59:25.700
<v Susie Doister>So the text of it, I think, is quite clear about what is prohibited and what is not, what is treated as competitively sensitive information and what is not.

2023
02:59:26.038 --> 02:59:29.372
<v Susie Doister>And to the extent that it's not clear, we provide precise examples.

2024
02:59:29.661 --> 02:59:38.262
<v Susie Doister>So we are listing in this examples of information, all all of which are— they provide a competitive advantage and they are sensitive in nature.

2025
02:59:38.310 --> 02:59:40.156
<v Susie Doister>So they are nonpublic in nature.

2026
02:59:40.575 --> 02:59:42.742
<v Susie Doister>So that's the text.

2027
02:59:42.887 --> 02:59:49.051
<v Susie Doister>But then, you know, moving to intent, which is something else that the court would look to if intent were not perfectly clear in the text.

2028
02:59:49.533 --> 02:59:52.055
<v Susie Doister>Again, let's look at the name, competitively sensitive information.

2029
02:59:52.183 --> 02:59:53.661
<v Susie Doister>What is the purpose of this ordinance?

2030
02:59:54.030 --> 02:59:58.364
<v Susie Doister>We are trying to prohibit the exchange of information that provides a competitive advantage.

2031
02:59:58.477 --> 03:00:07.388
<v Susie Doister>If we are both landlords and I have information that I would not want to share with you, it is typically because it would provide you with a competitive advantage.

2032
03:00:07.452 --> 03:00:09.202
<v Susie Doister>You would use it to steal my clients.

2033
03:00:09.524 --> 03:00:14.358
<v Susie Doister>That is the type of information that is prohibited here with respect to use in a price-fixing tool.

2034
03:00:14.904 --> 03:00:15.641
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2035
03:00:15.882 --> 03:00:19.833
<v Steve Novick>Would it defeat your purposes to simply add in the words nonpublic?

2036
03:00:20.282 --> 03:00:21.373
<v Susie Doister>Yes, that's a great clarification.

2037
03:00:21.423 --> 03:00:31.990
<v Susie Doister>So what I would suggest in that case in terms of quality of information, Quality of statutory drafting, and we are not opposed to this, would be adding a definition for public data that is distinct from competitively sensitive information.

2038
03:00:32.327 --> 03:00:33.676
<v Susie Doister>So these are distinct definitions.

2039
03:00:33.773 --> 03:00:34.770
<v Susie Doister>They should be treated as such.

2040
03:00:34.834 --> 03:00:36.055
<v Susie Doister>So let's put them separately.

2041
03:00:36.119 --> 03:00:37.661
<v Susie Doister>And this is also what Courtland does.

2042
03:00:37.725 --> 03:00:48.423
<v Susie Doister>I mean, it is not legally necessary to include this, but we could, for the purposes of clarity, as we did with our previous amendment, add additional definitions and elaborate on those definitions, include additional words.

2043
03:00:48.503 --> 03:00:49.514
<v Susie Doister>I think that's a good idea.

2044
03:00:49.852 --> 03:00:50.511
<v Susie Doister>Happy to do that.

2045
03:00:50.880 --> 03:00:53.259
<v Susie Doister>But no, I mean, public data could be its own definition.

2046
03:00:53.371 --> 03:00:57.532
<v Susie Doister>And as we did with competitively sensitive information, be quite explicit about what that entails.

2047
03:00:58.546 --> 03:00:58.962
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2048
03:00:59.011 --> 03:01:11.271
<v Steve Novick>And finally, on the issue of your lawyer, your banker, et cetera, et cetera, the argument I heard was, well, okay, you and your lawyer are both mom-and-pop property owners.

2049
03:01:11.448 --> 03:01:12.861
<v Steve Novick>Each of you owns 2 properties.

2050
03:01:12.909 --> 03:01:14.629
<v Steve Novick>So theoretically you compete with each other.

2051
03:01:15.530 --> 03:01:22.566
<v Steve Novick>But should you really not be allowed to consult with your lawyer about something because in some abstract way you both are landlords?

2052
03:01:25.434 --> 03:01:27.440
<v Angelita Morillo>So, sorry, Susie, do you want to take this one as well?

2053
03:01:27.504 --> 03:01:28.313
<v Susie Doister>No, no, I mean, you can if you'd like.

2054
03:01:29.023 --> 03:01:36.109
<v Angelita Morillo>Under existing antitrust law, you are not allowed to collude, whether you're doing that through an algorithm.

2055
03:01:37.129 --> 03:01:41.034
<v Angelita Morillo>The issue is that antitrust law has not really been enforced for 150 years.

2056
03:01:41.450 --> 03:01:45.556
<v Angelita Morillo>So people have gotten into pretty sloppy practices about how this works.

2057
03:01:46.833 --> 03:01:55.040
<v Angelita Morillo>But you're not allowed to share competitively sensitive data with each other, whether you're doing that through an Excel sheet, an algorithm, or in a smoky back room.

2058
03:01:56.203 --> 03:01:56.962
<v Angelita Morillo>Did you want to add?

2059
03:01:57.899 --> 03:01:59.417
<v Susie Doister>Yes, I would just want to add to that.

2060
03:02:01.023 --> 03:02:14.868
<v Susie Doister>So, you know, it has— the councilor alluded to this in her initial statement, but it is the case under existing agency law that you can share information that pertains to your enterprise, your business, with a designated agent.

2061
03:02:14.915 --> 03:02:18.458
<v Susie Doister>So it has to be a legitimate agent, but a real estate agent is an agent.

2062
03:02:18.778 --> 03:02:21.358
<v Susie Doister>I mean, you know, an attorney is an agent.

2063
03:02:21.807 --> 03:02:21.950
<v Susie Doister>Any—.

2064
03:02:22.528 --> 03:02:27.512
<v Susie Doister>I mean, a relative could be an agent if, you know, they conform to the definition of agent under the law.

2065
03:02:27.976 --> 03:02:32.495
<v Susie Doister>So you are permitted to share information, competitively sensitive or otherwise, with your agent.

2066
03:02:32.639 --> 03:02:34.563
<v Susie Doister>This ordinance does not change that.

2067
03:02:34.962 --> 03:02:38.568
<v Susie Doister>This ordinance says nothing about usurping longstanding agency law.

2068
03:02:39.032 --> 03:02:52.622
<v Susie Doister>Similarly, uh, longstanding antitrust law— so again, it's been in place for 100 years— indicates that, you know, regardless of the business situation that you may be in, or, you know, marital situation, uh, that is not an exemption.

2069
03:02:52.671 --> 03:02:54.754
<v Susie Doister>It's not a, a free pass to price fix.

2070
03:02:55.010 --> 03:03:04.711
<v Susie Doister>So if I happen to be in a business relationship with a competitor landlord landlord, who is an agent in the context of that relationship, that would be problematic.

2071
03:03:04.922 --> 03:03:06.328
<v Susie Doister>I would want to revisit that.

2072
03:03:06.700 --> 03:03:08.237
<v Susie Doister>That is not true under this ordinance.

2073
03:03:08.496 --> 03:03:10.704
<v Susie Doister>That is true under longstanding antitrust law.

2074
03:03:11.075 --> 03:03:18.486
<v Susie Doister>And if we wanted to relitigate that, we would need to, you know, hop in a time machine and go back 130 years to relitigate the tenets of the Sherman Antitrust Act.

2075
03:03:18.798 --> 03:03:20.007
<v Susie Doister>That's not a product of this ordinance.

2076
03:03:22.282 --> 03:03:32.458
<v Steve Novick>Councilor, any additional questions for technical clarity, or can we move on so we can I will subsequently follow up some of what I've asked, but no, I'll shut up now.

2077
03:03:33.727 --> 03:03:36.969
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor Zimmerman, technical questions.

2078
03:03:37.404 --> 03:03:37.676
<v John Knight>Thanks.

2079
03:03:37.950 --> 03:03:49.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, this question is for our city council, uh, or council lawyer, um, for our city attorney who is at the table.

2080
03:03:49.542 --> 03:03:51.051
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that— yeah, okay, thank you.

2081
03:03:51.372 --> 03:03:53.668
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I can't believe that wasn't clear in how I stated the question.

2082
03:03:54.968 --> 03:03:55.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, Tony, thanks.

2083
03:03:55.933 --> 03:04:04.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>So with respect to the enforcement aspect of this ordinance, we've got 2, as I read it, right?

2084
03:04:04.079 --> 03:04:17.114
<v Eric Zimmerman>We've got an area where the City Attorney's Office now can investigate— I don't know if the right word would be allegations of wrongdoing as it relates to this ordinance— but we also have the private right of action.

2085
03:04:18.772 --> 03:04:33.325
<v Eric Zimmerman>My question is broad, and so I'm just going to I'll put it out there so you can go through your answers, but where else does the City Attorney's Office investigate items that are in violation of city code?

2086
03:04:35.186 --> 03:04:38.459
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I'm used to that happening by other entities.

2087
03:04:38.717 --> 03:04:48.165
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then secondly, the— as I read the calculation for damages and the numbers of times that something happened, if I were to I will also— I should say this.

2088
03:04:48.358 --> 03:04:54.235
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am also a one-unit landlord, so I qualify as the potential conflict here.

2089
03:04:55.165 --> 03:04:56.273
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm trying to understand it a bit.

2090
03:04:57.029 --> 03:05:10.404
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if I execute a lease or my property management company executes a lease, that one action, let's say it's on January 15th, the way this is written is that every month when the rent comes due, that's considered a new violation.

2091
03:05:11.061 --> 03:05:17.050
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I was hoping you could talk about those 2 items so that we can understand just how that would be used for those 2 arms of enforcement?

2092
03:05:17.981 --> 03:05:18.334
<v Paul Anderson>Sure.

2093
03:05:18.543 --> 03:05:21.465
<v Paul Anderson>For the record, Tony Garcia with the Portland City Attorney's Office.

2094
03:05:22.958 --> 03:05:24.323
<v Paul Anderson>Let me first talk about enforcement.

2095
03:05:25.190 --> 03:05:27.549
<v Paul Anderson>We have many different ways of enforcement here at the city.

2096
03:05:27.613 --> 03:05:33.200
<v Paul Anderson>We have code compliance when there's cannabis businesses and entities.

2097
03:05:33.778 --> 03:05:34.726
<v Paul Anderson>We also have noise.

2098
03:05:34.773 --> 03:05:36.780
<v Paul Anderson>So there's many different ways in which we enforce.

2099
03:05:37.389 --> 03:05:44.969
<v Paul Anderson>What we have under this ordinance is consistent with the last time we brought a new code provision, which is the delivery fees regulation.

2100
03:05:45.019 --> 03:05:46.769
<v Paul Anderson>So the ability to subpoena records.

2101
03:05:47.218 --> 03:05:58.397
<v Paul Anderson>So that's what we're doing in this one, but certainly a decision for this council whether to continue with that practice or to have it mirror other sections of code and our other enforcement that we have.

2102
03:05:58.846 --> 03:06:01.656
<v Paul Anderson>Does that answer your question on that piece?

2103
03:06:01.720 --> 03:06:02.122
<v Paul Anderson>That does.

2104
03:06:02.235 --> 03:06:05.238
<v Paul Anderson>So we don't have subpoena authority under all provisions.

2105
03:06:05.592 --> 03:06:06.408
<v Paul Anderson>We would have it here.

2106
03:06:07.179 --> 03:06:11.235
<v Paul Anderson>There is one other section of code where we have that, but there are many where we do not.

2107
03:06:11.683 --> 03:06:21.140
<v Paul Anderson>I think the benefit would be it would allow our office to initiate actions without having to first go to either circuit court or to the hearings office to start an action.

2108
03:06:22.022 --> 03:06:22.792
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks.

2109
03:06:22.841 --> 03:06:24.893
<v Eric Zimmerman>So it basically, okay, I think I've got that.

2110
03:06:24.988 --> 03:06:25.757
<v Eric Zimmerman>Let's do the next part.

2111
03:06:26.111 --> 03:06:28.259
<v Eric Zimmerman>The different, the way violations are calculated.

2112
03:06:28.755 --> 03:06:30.935
<v Mitch Green>The way they're calculated.

2113
03:06:30.984 --> 03:06:31.545
<v Paul Anderson>We have it in here.

2114
03:06:31.610 --> 03:06:40.000
<v Paul Anderson>So there's separate calculations depending on whether it's a private right of action or whether it is a city enforcement mechanism.

2115
03:06:40.048 --> 03:06:50.763
<v Paul Anderson>And yes, if the city brings a case, then each month that an entity is in violation, the city could recover, you know, the fines or fees appropriate for that monthly violation.

2116
03:06:51.918 --> 03:07:00.056
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then also the person and all people in that complex could also down the civil side or sure.

2117
03:07:00.602 --> 03:07:12.429
<v Paul Anderson>I think the way you would actually see this work is if the city brought a case and we went to the hearings office, I imagine that would occur on one of these larger-scale multi-unit cases under the facts that have been presented here.

2118
03:07:13.280 --> 03:07:17.763
<v Paul Anderson>And if the city brought a case, the city would find the violation.

2119
03:07:18.037 --> 03:07:35.367
<v Paul Anderson>That would be a determination that then a private individual could take that over, Thank you.

2120
03:07:40.602 --> 03:07:42.185
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, technical questions?

2121
03:07:42.783 --> 03:07:44.449
<v Dan Ryan>I just wish we could hear testimony.

2122
03:07:45.191 --> 03:07:49.539
<v Dan Ryan>I had a very different take on the committee experience, and here we are, and we still haven't heard testimony.

2123
03:07:50.296 --> 03:07:52.727
<v Dan Ryan>And so I think we just need to get to it.

2124
03:07:53.759 --> 03:07:55.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe you're the last person in the queue, so why don't we do that?

2125
03:07:57.396 --> 03:07:59.242
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

2126
03:07:59.355 --> 03:08:03.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I'm not going to do a second call for technical questions right now.

2127
03:08:03.534 --> 03:08:05.915
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm going to take Councilor Ryan's advice.

2128
03:08:06.974 --> 03:08:08.331
<v Dan Ryan>And are we prioritizing the people that are here?

2129
03:08:09.540 --> 03:08:17.409
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Unfortunately— well, so there are You're with me on that one.

2130
03:08:19.619 --> 03:08:21.042
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, here's what we're doing.

2131
03:08:23.079 --> 03:08:23.356
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are—.

2132
03:08:23.356 --> 03:08:25.981
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is nobody else in the queue, I don't believe.

2133
03:08:26.031 --> 03:08:28.314
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, I believe that's an old hand, is that correct?

2134
03:08:29.630 --> 03:08:30.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, for technical questions.

2135
03:08:30.902 --> 03:08:36.066
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am sure there will be more questions and it sounds like proposals for amendments when we get to discussion.

2136
03:08:37.038 --> 03:08:41.772
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next step in the process that we have been operating under is to hear testimony.

2137
03:08:42.350 --> 03:08:55.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are a couple of folks who are here to testify who might be able to provide additional context, um, who we will call up, and then we will move to the order that our clerk has.

2138
03:08:56.424 --> 03:08:58.546
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have 26 minutes.

2139
03:08:58.995 --> 03:09:05.197
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will get through as many people as we can, and then we have that time on Thursday, and we will have time on the 16th.

2140
03:09:05.727 --> 03:09:08.370
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am sorry, folks, that we don't have Thank you.

2141
03:09:10.066 --> 03:09:12.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was hoping we would have about an hour for testimony.

2142
03:09:13.284 --> 03:09:19.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I want to start us really quickly with these folks who can provide context before we move to the broader list.

2143
03:09:22.579 --> 03:09:34.064
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That is Marcel Guesmundo, who will be followed by Dr. Brian Callasay, Mark Paul, Albert Fox-Kahn, and Lee Heppner.

2144
03:09:35.004 --> 03:09:37.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then we will move to the broader list.

2145
03:09:38.073 --> 03:09:42.966
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if those folks are available, let's have them move through as quickly as they can.

2146
03:09:46.770 --> 03:09:52.483
<v Marcel Guzmundo>Good morning, City Council members.

2147
03:09:52.836 --> 03:09:53.449
<v Marcel Guzmundo>May I begin?

2148
03:09:54.969 --> 03:09:55.291
<v Marcel Guzmundo>Please.

2149
03:09:56.146 --> 03:09:57.435
<v Marcel Guzmundo>My name is Marcel Guzmundo.

2150
03:09:57.581 --> 03:10:04.630
<v Marcel Guzmundo>I'm an attorney that focuses and specializes in housing law and represents housing providers in the area and across the state.

2151
03:10:04.988 --> 03:10:12.408
<v Marcel Guzmundo>I'm here on behalf of Multifamily Northwest though, which represents about 300,000 units kind of in the state, in the greater area.

2152
03:10:14.567 --> 03:10:17.574
<v Marcel Guzmundo>I would invite questions whenever possible.

2153
03:10:17.671 --> 03:10:20.757
<v Marcel Guzmundo>I think that you'll get the most out of this if that occurs.

2154
03:10:22.198 --> 03:10:22.345
<v Joe Gardner>I'm not—.

2155
03:10:22.345 --> 03:10:24.120
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sorry, Marshall, but we have 2 minutes for you.

2156
03:10:24.269 --> 03:10:28.394
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Folks can reach out to you, I'm sure, I'm not here to support price fixing.

2157
03:10:29.211 --> 03:10:32.610
<v Marcel Guzmundo>I don't believe anybody is, but I do oppose the proposed ordinance as drafted.

2158
03:10:33.299 --> 03:10:40.112
<v Marcel Guzmundo>It does in fact prohibit housing providers from using publicly available information when setting rents, despite the testimony that I heard earlier.

2159
03:10:40.770 --> 03:10:45.563
<v Marcel Guzmundo>If you read the statute, it certainly does not exempt it in any way, and that was one of the questions that I heard earlier.

2160
03:10:46.444 --> 03:10:51.782
<v Marcel Guzmundo>It also prohibits property managers from considering their own internal data and expertise when setting rents.

2161
03:10:52.654 --> 03:10:54.729
<v Marcel Guzmundo>Property managers represent different owners.

2162
03:10:55.038 --> 03:11:05.400
<v Marcel Guzmundo>They might represent 2 different owners on different sides of the street, and you're essentially asking them to put on blinders when they're setting rents, even though that's basically impossible.

2163
03:11:06.318 --> 03:11:23.278
<v Marcel Guzmundo>I think the city council hasn't had adequate time to really take into account all the stakeholder input and other information that it didn't receive, and as a result, it would be hasty to set this policy that, though while well-intentioned, will inadvertently add to Portland's reputation as kind of being a hostile place to build.

2164
03:11:26.179 --> 03:11:38.608
<v Marcel Guzmundo>Worse yet, the ordinance is so broadly worded with such a disproportionate penalty provision that it could potentially bankrupt any housing provider for factoring in advertised rates or their own data when setting rents.

2165
03:11:39.388 --> 03:11:55.384
<v Marcel Guzmundo>I think to Commissioner Zimmerman's— excuse me, Councilman Zimmerman's point, if you, with the statute of limitations of 5 years over with 12 months in a year at a $10,000 per month penalty, that would be a $600,000 lawsuit for one tenant.

2166
03:11:56.024 --> 03:12:04.216
<v Marcel Guzmundo>So you would want to take that very seriously when considering the penalty as it relates to the vagueness and breadth of the policy.

2167
03:12:04.296 --> 03:12:12.620
<v Marcel Guzmundo>Again, not objecting to the policy of preventing price fixing, objecting to the breadth of the ordinance as drafted.

2168
03:12:13.486 --> 03:12:25.947
<v Marcel Guzmundo>I think, you know, this does in fact prohibit housing providers from scraping data from Apartments.com, Zillow, and putting into their own system, into their own spreadsheet and algorithm.

2169
03:12:26.028 --> 03:12:34.361
<v Marcel Guzmundo>We're not saying that the ordinance— I will cede time, but I have a lot to say and happy to share it with any council members that are interested.

2170
03:12:34.441 --> 03:12:35.565
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, and please feel free to.

2171
03:12:35.629 --> 03:12:37.808
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To send information to us as well.

2172
03:12:39.188 --> 03:12:41.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see Albert Foxconn online.

2173
03:12:41.431 --> 03:12:43.113
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Why don't you get started?

2174
03:12:43.257 --> 03:12:49.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Dr. Brian Kilaci and Lee Hepner, I believe, are joining as well.

2175
03:12:50.486 --> 03:12:51.977
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>Thank you so much.

2176
03:12:52.088 --> 03:12:58.195
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>My name is Albert Foxconn, and I'm the executive director of the Surveillance Technology Oversight Project, a New York-based civil rights group.

2177
03:12:58.275 --> 03:13:01.320
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>I also am a fellow at NYU Law School.

2178
03:13:01.385 --> 03:13:09.969
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>Previously, I've studied antitrust and technology issues at Yale Law School, Harvard Law School, and the Kennedy School.

2179
03:13:10.692 --> 03:13:18.548
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>Basically, we're trying to prevent the erosion of rights that have been protecting tenants since the 1890s.

2180
03:13:18.628 --> 03:13:32.796
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>We're talking about such a modest first step here to restore the protections that have, you know, safeguarded Americans from price-setting conspiracies since— for truly generations.

2181
03:13:32.924 --> 03:13:50.896
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>And I, I should also note, as someone whose family are also small landlords as well, I know that there are a number of regulatory burdens that landlords face, and having to avoid violating the Sherman Antitrust Act by not conspiring with your fellow landlords is a very modest burden.

2182
03:13:51.650 --> 03:14:12.156
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>Right now, we have seen landlords across the country able to skirt the law, commit felonies, avoid liability simply because of the difficulty of actually pursuing these cases under existing Sherman antitrust law, I should note that yes, there are some broad technologies here that can be implicated.

2183
03:14:12.509 --> 03:14:21.825
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>But you know, the same Excel program that 99% of the times landlords are using in a legal way can be used illegally.

2184
03:14:21.888 --> 03:14:27.388
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>It's no different than thinking about a car that someone uses in a completely.

2185
03:14:27.709 --> 03:14:28.865
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>Safe and lawful way.

2186
03:14:29.332 --> 03:14:32.720
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>And if they are running people off the road, they face liability.

2187
03:14:32.880 --> 03:14:37.490
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>When you use Excel to commit price fixing, it causes real harm.

2188
03:14:37.539 --> 03:14:45.810
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>And you have to understand that some of the most dangerous algorithms in America today aren't in some cutting-edge machine learning system, some neural network.

2189
03:14:46.050 --> 03:14:50.806
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>They're operating in very simple equations in Excel and other similar systems.

2190
03:14:51.495 --> 03:14:54.772
<v Albert Fox-Kahn>And I really think that this is an indispensable act to protect renters.

2191
03:14:55.849 --> 03:14:56.265
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2192
03:14:56.572 --> 03:14:59.349
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being with us, Dr. Brian Calacci.

2193
03:15:00.569 --> 03:15:02.143
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize if I mispronounced that.

2194
03:15:03.637 --> 03:15:06.575
<v Brian Calacci>Nope, you said it both the ways my immediate family says it, so all good.

2195
03:15:07.233 --> 03:15:17.284
<v Brian Calacci>Thank you, members of the council, for the opportunity to provide testimony on the proposed ordinance prohibiting the use of algorithmic pricing— price-fixing tools in Portland's rental housing market.

2196
03:15:17.765 --> 03:15:21.797
<v Brian Calacci>My name again is Brian Calacci, and I'm the chief economist at the Open Markets Institute.

2197
03:15:22.262 --> 03:15:34.433
<v Brian Calacci>Which is an anti-monopoly think tank based in Washington, D.C. And my colleagues and I have published several articles on algorithmic pricing tools, and we've recently filed amicus briefs in 2 algorithmic price fixing cases, Cornish et al.

2198
03:15:34.545 --> 03:15:37.354
<v Brian Calacci>V. Caesars and Gibson v. Senden Group.

2199
03:15:38.141 --> 03:15:47.038
<v Brian Calacci>And so our support for a ban on algorithmic price fixing is grounded in antitrust law, economic theory, and empirical evidence of the effects of algorithmic tools.

2200
03:15:47.102 --> 03:15:47.326
<v Brian Calacci>Thank you.

2201
03:15:47.952 --> 03:15:54.183
<v Brian Calacci>Now, what collusion does is it restricts supply and raises prices, and it's illegal under the antitrust laws already.

2202
03:15:54.921 --> 03:15:55.996
<v Brian Calacci>Just last week, the U.S.

2203
03:15:56.060 --> 03:16:06.738
<v Brian Calacci>Antitrust Commission reiterated that the exchange of competitively sensitive information can violate the Sherman Antitrust Act, even if the information is exchanged through an intermediary like a software provider.

2204
03:16:07.123 --> 03:16:13.274
<v Brian Calacci>And the economic literature keeps on turning up cases, you know, where algorithms end up colluding even when they aren't programmed yes.

2205
03:16:13.354 --> 03:16:14.274
<v Brian Calacci>—Designed explicitly to do so.

2206
03:16:15.177 --> 03:16:22.260
<v Brian Calacci>So the empirical evidence strongly suggests that the algorithms currently in use in housing markets do in fact drive rents higher and not lower.

2207
03:16:22.680 --> 03:16:35.073
<v Brian Calacci>While there is a theory that algorithms can lower rents by helping landlords respond more quickly to softer, say, demand conditions, the empirical evidence we have to date tells us this effect is far outweighed by the software's facilitation of collusive outcomes.

2208
03:16:35.994 --> 03:16:40.247
<v Brian Calacci>So the quantification of this is yes.

2209
03:16:40.842 --> 03:16:44.695
<v Brian Calacci>And is it an argument that banning price fixing will hold back development?

2210
03:16:45.016 --> 03:16:49.063
<v Brian Calacci>If landlords are unable to artificially hold up prices, then developers will lack the incentive to build.

2211
03:16:49.513 --> 03:17:00.495
<v Brian Calacci>In fact, collusion raises rents in a way that discourages rather than encourages investment by thwarting the normal operation of supply and demand, because collusion raises prices by increasing vacancies, which results in excess capacity.

2212
03:17:00.849 --> 03:17:04.156
<v Brian Calacci>Developers don't make profits by building into an environment of excess capacity.

2213
03:17:04.575 --> 03:17:04.884
<v Brian Calacci>Thank you.

2214
03:17:04.933 --> 03:17:09.739
<v Brian Calacci>So collusion is illegal whether it's done in smoke-filled rooms, over the phone, or via a third-party software provider.

2215
03:17:10.590 --> 03:17:12.490
<v Brian Calacci>So yeah, thank you for the— yeah, thank you.

2216
03:17:12.958 --> 03:17:14.295
<v Brian Calacci>That concludes my testimony.

2217
03:17:14.971 --> 03:17:15.503
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2218
03:17:16.389 --> 03:17:16.953
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Lee Hefner.

2219
03:17:19.326 --> 03:17:23.297
<v Lee Heppner>Good afternoon, President Pirtle-Guiney and council members.

2220
03:17:23.361 --> 03:17:24.314
<v Lee Heppner>My name is Lee Hefner.

2221
03:17:24.411 --> 03:17:28.897
<v Lee Heppner>I'm an antitrust attorney and senior legal counsel at the American Economic Liberties Project.

2222
03:17:29.388 --> 03:17:34.698
<v Lee Heppner>We're a nonprofit nonprofit advocacy group dedicated to advancing fair markets for consumers, workers, and small businesses.

2223
03:17:35.291 --> 03:17:55.978
<v Lee Heppner>We've now weighed in on over a dozen pieces of legislation like this at both the municipal and state level, um, and, and they all seek to do one thing, which is to say that price fixing is illegal under current law, and that price fixing by algorithm is as illegal as that handshake in a smoky back room which many of you and colleagues have spoken to already.

2224
03:17:56.316 --> 03:18:02.036
<v Lee Heppner>You can't use digital tools to violate the rules, but existing price fixing law is challenging to enforce.

2225
03:18:02.405 --> 03:18:11.281
<v Lee Heppner>So no one enters into an illegal agreement openly, and the advent of a price fixing algorithm is to further conceal the existence of an illegal agreement to fix prices.

2226
03:18:11.778 --> 03:18:19.950
<v Lee Heppner>So there is real value in establishing bright line rules to prohibit the misuse of competitively sensitive information to set rents.

2227
03:18:20.606 --> 03:18:28.916
<v Lee Heppner>A White House study determined that renters across the country pay an additional $3.8 billion in rent per year because of rent-fixing algorithms.

2228
03:18:29.270 --> 03:18:30.779
<v Lee Heppner>But it's not just about high rents.

2229
03:18:31.277 --> 03:18:36.688
<v Lee Heppner>Evidence introduced in pending litigation in Arizona says that price fixing also increases rates of eviction.

2230
03:18:37.362 --> 03:18:49.277
<v Lee Heppner>Furthermore, as Dr. Colacci mentioned, price fixing holds badly needed housing units off the market by providing the owners with the assurance that they can meet revenue targets even if a greater number of units are left vacant.

2231
03:18:49.757 --> 03:18:52.326
<v Lee Heppner>Now, this isn't about undermining the efficient setting of rents.

2232
03:18:52.391 --> 03:18:58.059
<v Lee Heppner>In fact, we believe that the fair competition sets rents most efficiently.

2233
03:18:58.413 --> 03:19:02.234
<v Lee Heppner>But we also have to be clear about what this legislation should not prohibit.

2234
03:19:02.652 --> 03:19:11.337
<v Lee Heppner>If a landlord wants to hire a pricing consultant and share their own data with a third party to set rents, nothing in this bill present— prevents them from doing so.

2235
03:19:11.804 --> 03:19:21.700
<v Lee Heppner>There is nothing illegal about a landlord researching the market In fact, that's exactly the price competition that this body should encourage.

2236
03:19:22.361 --> 03:19:24.574
<v Lee Heppner>So I look forward to any questions.

2237
03:19:27.211 --> 03:19:27.583
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2238
03:19:27.840 --> 03:19:38.125
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I know folks have a lot of expertise and councilors may have questions, so I would just encourage people to connect offline to get questions answered.

2239
03:19:40.940 --> 03:19:42.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, are you in the queue?

2240
03:19:43.193 --> 03:19:43.259
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2241
03:19:43.356 --> 03:19:44.844
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, are you in the queue?

2242
03:19:46.038 --> 03:19:50.966
<v Mitch Green>Yes, but I just want to say briefly, um, testimony.

2243
03:19:51.047 --> 03:19:56.016
<v Mitch Green>Okay, I just— you heard from some economists.

2244
03:19:56.065 --> 03:19:57.194
<v Mitch Green>I won't reproduce those arguments.

2245
03:19:57.340 --> 03:20:04.487
<v Mitch Green>I laid on your dais station my attempt to summarize the economics of competitive pricing.

2246
03:20:05.551 --> 03:20:07.617
<v Mitch Green>Review at your leisure, ask me any questions.

2247
03:20:07.665 --> 03:20:09.099
<v Mitch Green>I didn't want to break public meetings law.

2248
03:20:09.449 --> 03:20:10.657
<v Mitch Green>In the spirit of Steve Novick.

2249
03:20:10.738 --> 03:20:12.869
<v Mitch Green>So I cede.

2250
03:20:13.691 --> 03:20:14.481
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2251
03:20:14.577 --> 03:20:26.453
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I was remiss in not mentioning in our Council Operations staff summary, we heard about the various statements and analyses that were included in this.

2252
03:20:26.599 --> 03:20:32.617
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I had said that I would put on the record that some of those analyses had been updated.

2253
03:20:33.490 --> 03:20:37.845
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There had been a question about why they weren't included earlier this week, and they are up now.

2254
03:20:37.941 --> 03:20:44.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just wanted to put that on the record to make sure that we have that included in the, the official record since they came on a little late.

2255
03:20:45.805 --> 03:20:49.418
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Rebecca, we have 14 minutes.

2256
03:20:49.692 --> 03:20:54.066
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's see how many folks we can get through to make sure that we can hear from some of the people who are here today.

2257
03:20:55.459 --> 03:20:58.791
<v Rebecca Dobert>First, we have Chris Olson, Travis Noddings, and John Knight.

2258
03:21:00.536 --> 03:21:08.070
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I will just let folks As soon as you come up, start speaking so that we can have as little transition time as possible.

2259
03:21:08.873 --> 03:21:14.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if our staff who are at the table maybe want to clear those seats for now, that would be great.

2260
03:21:16.966 --> 03:21:17.967
<v Mark Williams>Hello, my name is Chris Olson.

2261
03:21:18.014 --> 03:21:19.129
<v Mark Williams>State my name for the record.

2262
03:21:19.726 --> 03:21:23.679
<v Mark Williams>Thank you, Council President and Vice President, for allowing us to speak.

2263
03:21:24.462 --> 03:21:37.114
<v Mark Williams>I'm a renter and I'm a resident in District 2 and a member of the Portland Democratic I'm going to be speaking on my own behalf, but also of the experience of renters that I've met through this working group.

2264
03:21:37.564 --> 03:21:39.022
<v Mark Williams>I strongly support this evidence.

2265
03:21:39.166 --> 03:21:43.816
<v Mark Williams>As a lifelong renter, I've experienced firsthand the relentless rise in housing costs.

2266
03:21:43.912 --> 03:21:53.177
<v Mark Williams>Despite working hard to keep up with rent, the increases constantly outpace my wage growth, making it nearly impossible for many Portlanders, including myself, to get ahead.

2267
03:21:53.772 --> 03:22:05.860
<v Mark Williams>This ordinance is necessary because algorithmic pricing software enables landlords and property managers to artificially inflate rents, effectively engaging in price fixing that puts stable housing further out of the reach of many working people.

2268
03:22:07.096 --> 03:22:11.370
<v Mark Williams>Through the Portland DSA Housing Working Group, we have heard from hundreds of renters across the city.

2269
03:22:11.981 --> 03:22:19.469
<v Mark Williams>Portland's housing market is already unaffordable for many, and the use of secretive profit-maximizing algorithms only worsens the crisis.

2270
03:22:20.353 --> 03:22:33.730
<v Mark Williams>As I reviewed written testimony yesterday, I was struck by the overwhelming amount of public however, one opposing statement from a landlord stood out to me, and I quote, the only solution is exporting people to lower cost of living states.

2271
03:22:34.710 --> 03:22:35.817
<v Mark Williams>This sentiment is appalling.

2272
03:22:36.188 --> 03:22:41.838
<v Mark Williams>To corporate landlords, we are not people with lives, families, dreams, and communities that we want to live in.

2273
03:22:42.095 --> 03:22:46.847
<v Mark Williams>We are just a number that can push around like cattle from apartment to apartment or from state to state.

2274
03:22:47.233 --> 03:22:48.549
<v Mark Williams>Our lives do not matter to them.

2275
03:22:48.693 --> 03:22:49.931
<v Mark Williams>We are simply numbers on a balance sheet.

2276
03:22:50.011 --> 03:22:53.206
<v Mark Williams>Councilmember easily displaced when we can no longer afford to pay.

2277
03:22:54.555 --> 03:23:01.459
<v Mark Williams>Portland risks allowing corporate landlords to turn the city into an exclusive playground for the wealthy, as they've done to San Francisco and Seattle.

2278
03:23:01.556 --> 03:23:10.739
<v Mark Williams>The harm caused by algorithmic price setting is not hypothetical because across the country, as you know, many attorneys generals have pushed back against this.

2279
03:23:11.237 --> 03:23:14.882
<v Mark Williams>I urge all city council members to vote yes on this ordinance during the next city council meeting.

2280
03:23:15.203 --> 03:23:15.734
<v Mark Williams>Thank you for your time.

2281
03:23:15.814 --> 03:23:16.119
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

2282
03:23:17.179 --> 03:23:17.500
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2283
03:23:18.703 --> 03:23:21.176
<v Travis Noddings>I spoke previously, so I'll keep my comments brief.

2284
03:23:21.593 --> 03:23:28.242
<v Travis Noddings>Homelessness and evictions are on the rise in Portland and Multnomah County, and that is overwhelmingly due to rent prices.

2285
03:23:28.754 --> 03:23:34.423
<v Travis Noddings>Marcel Guzmundo, who spoke previously, is an eviction lawyer, though he spoke in euphemisms about his job title.

2286
03:23:34.520 --> 03:23:35.354
<v Travis Noddings>He works at Andor Law.

2287
03:23:36.286 --> 03:23:37.843
<v Travis Noddings>Business is going extremely well for them.

2288
03:23:37.907 --> 03:23:40.363
<v Travis Noddings>They're one of the top eviction firms in Multnomah County.

2289
03:23:40.413 --> 03:23:51.331
<v Travis Noddings>You can find them every single day At eviction court, I would encourage any of the councillors here to get an idea of the impacts of our rental crisis, to go to eviction court and speak with tenants there.

2290
03:23:51.395 --> 03:23:53.627
<v Travis Noddings>They're breaking down in tears every single day.

2291
03:23:54.365 --> 03:23:57.834
<v Travis Noddings>40 To 50 to sometimes 80 households on any given day.

2292
03:23:57.897 --> 03:24:13.682
<v Travis Noddings>We just opened a section, a second eviction court in East County so we can get through our eviction docket faster because evictions have been going up 30% year over year for the last few years, and we desperately need to do more to stop this.

2293
03:24:14.278 --> 03:24:16.997
<v Travis Noddings>And I'll end there and ask that you support this ordinance.

2294
03:24:21.059 --> 03:24:26.968
<v John Knight>Councilor Morillo, President Pirtle-Guiney, Portland City Councilors, my name is John Harris Knight.

2295
03:24:28.056 --> 03:24:29.722
<v John Knight>I'm a 10-year resident of Portland.

2296
03:24:30.240 --> 03:24:32.183
<v John Knight>I work as a nursing assistant in a local hospital.

2297
03:24:32.280 --> 03:24:37.621
<v John Knight>I'm representing myself today, where I've worked since 2020 to help during the pandemic.

2298
03:24:37.831 --> 03:24:44.751
<v John Knight>Despite working in public education for the state and in social and public services, I have enjoyed the highest income of my life over the last 5 years.

2299
03:24:45.425 --> 03:24:50.933
<v John Knight>Still, since mid-2019, I've had to move 10 times in Portland.

2300
03:24:51.608 --> 03:24:58.768
<v John Knight>Housing sold or closed for renovations and conversion, relying on friends for a room or ADUs, luckily below market rates.

2301
03:24:59.393 --> 03:25:02.711
<v John Knight>An ADU declared uninhabitable from a neighbor's complaint against the landlord.

2302
03:25:03.305 --> 03:25:06.799
<v John Knight>Unaffordable corporate rent increases approaching the state's 10% annual limit.

2303
03:25:07.313 --> 03:25:19.433
<v John Knight>Staying with my twin brother and his partner— thanks, bro— for months or a year at a time while searching for something affordable or saving up to get through a 1-year lease, all because I can't find one decent place that stays affordable.

2304
03:25:19.913 --> 03:25:25.896
<v John Knight>Using algorithmic technology to maximize profits instead of using it to minimize costs to renters is a scam.

2305
03:25:26.569 --> 03:25:37.136
<v John Knight>Price fixing, collusion between corporations withholding units from the public to create false scarcity to rationalize raising rents should be illegal and grounds for revoking these corporations' business licenses.

2306
03:25:37.873 --> 03:25:44.217
<v John Knight>These conditions further harm anyone granted less opportunity and privilege than my white, able-bodied, college-educated male self.

2307
03:25:44.634 --> 03:25:45.646
<v John Knight>The whole city suffers.

2308
03:25:46.078 --> 03:25:52.710
<v John Knight>I have tried pursuing a graduate degree to raise my income, but To afford school, more work is required, interfering with school.

2309
03:25:53.449 --> 03:25:55.922
<v John Knight>Finding safe, affordable, quality housing should be easy.

2310
03:25:56.210 --> 03:26:00.577
<v John Knight>To take additional jobs and hours to subsidize corporate greed is chasing the dragon's tail.

2311
03:26:01.028 --> 03:26:04.448
<v John Knight>If they want billions, they should get a second job or a third one like us.

2312
03:26:05.105 --> 03:26:07.563
<v John Knight>We are all living versions of Les Misérables.

2313
03:26:07.979 --> 03:26:15.045
<v John Knight>As Fantine, we sacrifice our lives, health, and dignity to satisfy ever-increasing demands from these corporate Thénardier.

2314
03:26:15.644 --> 03:26:19.344
<v John Knight>While they abuse our cosettes until we are lost to each other forever.

2315
03:26:23.221 --> 03:26:25.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I know that there were some good lines there.

2316
03:26:26.225 --> 03:26:30.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are going to try to keep order and quiet in chambers so we can keep moving quickly.

2317
03:26:31.209 --> 03:26:31.340
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca.

2318
03:26:31.568 --> 03:26:35.899
<v Rebecca Dobert>Brennan Poole, Michael Adara, and Joseph Gardner.

2319
03:26:39.686 --> 03:26:40.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

2320
03:26:40.254 --> 03:26:42.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As soon as you're seated, just please introduce yourself.

2321
03:26:43.685 --> 03:26:44.231
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good afternoon.

2322
03:26:44.665 --> 03:26:45.516
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My name is Brennan Poole.

2323
03:26:46.078 --> 03:26:51.699
<v Paul Anderson>I am a physicist and software engineer renting in Mill Park, and I'm a regular volunteer at the Oregon Food Bank.

2324
03:26:52.180 --> 03:26:55.119
<v Paul Anderson>I'm testifying for myself today in strong support of this ordinance.

2325
03:26:55.808 --> 03:26:58.730
<v Paul Anderson>Price fixing is illegal in this country and has been for over a century.

2326
03:26:58.780 --> 03:27:04.623
<v Paul Anderson>It's illegal if it's being done in a smoky bar between old-timey tycoons, or if it's being done in a well-lit office using an app.

2327
03:27:05.362 --> 03:27:12.487
<v Paul Anderson>Price fixing the rental market artificially raises the price of rent pushes people into homelessness and suppresses the creation of new affordable housing units.

2328
03:27:13.226 --> 03:27:17.685
<v Paul Anderson>This price fixing violates the free market ideals of our economy and actively hurts honest landlords.

2329
03:27:18.665 --> 03:27:24.377
<v Paul Anderson>I have been a renter my entire adult life, and I have only seen the price of rent increase and the quality of those rental units decrease.

2330
03:27:25.099 --> 03:27:32.398
<v Paul Anderson>Many of my friends have been less fortunate than myself and have had to move out of the city in search of more affordable housing, many of them needing to live with their parents to make ends meet.

2331
03:27:33.264 --> 03:27:33.699
<v Paul Anderson>These Thank you, Mayor.

2332
03:27:33.763 --> 03:27:34.020
<v Paul Anderson>Thank you, Mayor.

2333
03:27:34.084 --> 03:27:42.818
<v Paul Anderson>These price-fixing acts encourage landlords to keep perfectly serviceable units off the market to inflate housing prices, and as such, finding affordable housing in this city is a significant challenge.

2334
03:27:43.557 --> 03:27:54.636
<v Paul Anderson>This ban is not a complete solution to our city's housing issues, but it is an important, important first step in reining in the lawless speculation on the vital needs of the hundreds of thousands of working-class Portlanders who make this city great.

2335
03:27:55.102 --> 03:27:56.563
<v Paul Anderson>I urge you to vote yes on this ordinance.

2336
03:27:56.788 --> 03:27:57.060
<v Paul Anderson>Thank you.

2337
03:28:01.138 --> 03:28:04.527
<v Joe Gardner>Members of the council, I'm Joe Gardner speaking on behalf of my client RealPage.

2338
03:28:04.672 --> 03:28:18.689
<v Joe Gardner>I'm also testifying as a lifelong renter and a tenant in the Portland metro area, a tenant who is deeply worried that this council is on the verge of exploding the cost of the rental market by massively increasing rates of frivolous lawsuits while also driving away desperately needed investment into new housing.

2339
03:28:19.266 --> 03:28:24.388
<v Joe Gardner>Many of you may be tempted to vote on this ordinance based on false allegations and inaccurate statements made by its sponsors.

2340
03:28:24.469 --> 03:28:24.549
<v Joe Gardner>Yes.

2341
03:28:24.726 --> 03:28:27.406
<v Joe Gardner>Allegations too numerous for me to rebut in the 2 minutes I have.

2342
03:28:27.968 --> 03:28:36.427
<v Joe Gardner>I— but I wish to address a few of these, not to malign proponents, but as evidence that this proposal is brought to you without appropriate attention to detail and consideration of unintended consequences.

2343
03:28:36.941 --> 03:28:41.501
<v Joe Gardner>Proponents of this ordinance have falsely claimed that RealPage is part of a price-fixing scheme driving rents higher.

2344
03:28:41.917 --> 03:28:48.146
<v Joe Gardner>In reality, the cities where RealPage serves the highest market share have experienced some of the most significant rent drops in the country in recent years.

2345
03:28:48.659 --> 03:28:52.078
<v Joe Gardner>Proponents claim that RealPage is coordinating a conspiracy to control rents in Portland.

2346
03:28:52.576 --> 03:28:57.250
<v Joe Gardner>Yet testimony also acknowledged that only around 18% of the rental market in the city is served by this software.

2347
03:28:57.667 --> 03:29:09.054
<v Joe Gardner>No explanation has been given for how RealPage can be both the central linchpin of a price-fixing conspiracy while also being so superfluous that 82% of the rental market is allegedly able to collaborate in the scheme without using the software.

2348
03:29:09.536 --> 03:29:19.155
<v Joe Gardner>Far from pushing the rents higher, average RealPage recommended rent levels in the Portland metro area over the past 5 years have ranged from 1.5% to 6.3% below equivalently publicly posted rents.

2349
03:29:20.375 --> 03:29:25.288
<v Joe Gardner>RealPage does not pressure customers to adopt this rent value estimate, as Councilor Murillo has previously claimed.

2350
03:29:25.593 --> 03:29:26.443
<v Joe Gardner>This is patently false.

2351
03:29:26.540 --> 03:29:33.025
<v Joe Gardner>In fact, in the majority of cases, customers choose to diverge from software estimates based on their own insights into local market conditions.

2352
03:29:33.379 --> 03:29:37.569
<v Joe Gardner>This ordinance will not help marginalized populations, as some proponents have claimed.

2353
03:29:37.954 --> 03:29:56.129
<v Joe Gardner>In reality, part of the impetus for the software was to reduce the importance of face-to-face bargaining in renting, a process that's subject to severe implicit bias effects just in this hearing, we've heard contradictory claims from proponents about whether Excel is implicated or not, whether private information is exempted or not.

2354
03:29:56.483 --> 03:29:59.597
<v Joe Gardner>Not even the supporters can agree on what this law you're voting on does.

2355
03:30:00.015 --> 03:30:02.938
<v Joe Gardner>Finally, proponents have claimed that this ordinance will come at no cost to the city.

2356
03:30:03.259 --> 03:30:10.967
<v Joe Gardner>To the contrary, the severe problems with this proposal and the severe confusion all but guarantees that its passage will result in lengthy and expensive court cases.

2357
03:30:11.031 --> 03:30:11.174
<v Joe Gardner>Thank you.

2358
03:30:15.729 --> 03:30:17.058
<v Sahan McKelvey>Hi, Mike Edera.

2359
03:30:17.610 --> 03:30:21.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am a member of the Democratic Social Housing Working Group.

2360
03:30:22.148 --> 03:30:26.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And just a little information on our canvassing project.

2361
03:30:28.219 --> 03:30:38.483
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've been canvassing renters from one end of the city, from basically from the border of Gresham all the way to the border of Beaverton, in the last year and a half.

2362
03:30:39.108 --> 03:30:57.103
<v Paul Anderson>And in our last 2 canvases, particularly in our last canvas in Northeast Portland off 122nd, we started running into tenants who were telling us that they just got a rent hike and their manager said it was out of their hands.

2363
03:30:57.167 --> 03:30:59.603
<v Paul Anderson>It was the quote unquote algorithm.

2364
03:30:59.731 --> 03:31:01.591
<v Paul Anderson>So this is just empirical.

2365
03:31:01.959 --> 03:31:14.941
<v Paul Anderson>This is just, Real-life data, but it is, we're running into it and we're running into it more fre— we seem to be running into it more frequently as the time goes by.

2366
03:31:15.391 --> 03:31:15.682
<v Paul Anderson>Thanks.

2367
03:31:17.101 --> 03:31:18.422
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all so much for being here.

2368
03:31:18.550 --> 03:31:21.193
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call up 2 more people to testify?

2369
03:31:23.170 --> 03:31:26.243
<v Rebecca Dobert>Mavi Munoz and Javier Alomia.

2370
03:31:39.738 --> 03:31:42.406
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please go ahead and introduce yourself and get started.

2371
03:31:45.039 --> 03:31:48.622
<v Candace Avalos>Good afternoon, council members and present— Madam President.

2372
03:31:49.430 --> 03:31:50.609
<v Candace Avalos>My name is Mavi Munoz.

2373
03:31:50.867 --> 03:31:53.756
<v Candace Avalos>I've been a realtor within the Portland metro area for 11 years.

2374
03:31:54.350 --> 03:31:57.191
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>2 Of which have been within property management.

2375
03:31:57.898 --> 03:31:59.408
<v Candace Avalos>I am opposed to price fixing.

2376
03:32:00.227 --> 03:32:03.215
<v Candace Avalos>I'm already— it's already illegal under state and federal law.

2377
03:32:03.842 --> 03:32:07.183
<v Candace Avalos>I am not opposed to making it illegal under city ordinance as well.

2378
03:32:08.033 --> 03:32:16.032
<v Candace Avalos>As a real estate practitioner, I encourage Black and brown buyers and sellers to purchase and sell real estate as a pathway to create generational wealth.

2379
03:32:16.932 --> 03:32:24.061
<v Candace Avalos>Many of the single and multifamily homes here in Portland are owned by Portlanders who have worked hard to leave a legacy for their families.

2380
03:32:25.041 --> 03:32:26.951
<v Candace Avalos>As written, this measure is confusing.

2381
03:32:27.466 --> 03:32:33.744
<v Candace Avalos>Does it apply only to expensive software like RealPage or Google Sheets and Microsoft Excel too?

2382
03:32:34.450 --> 03:32:38.513
<v Candace Avalos>Does it ban sharing only private or public data as well?

2383
03:32:39.332 --> 03:32:48.082
<v Candace Avalos>For such a confusing measure, the penalty of $10,000 is a lot, especially if it's calculated every month for a month-to-month lease over 5 years.

2384
03:32:48.599 --> 03:32:50.361
<v Candace Avalos>That's $600,000.

2385
03:32:51.252 --> 03:32:58.048
<v Candace Avalos>As written, this measure would impact every single landlord in Portland, no matter how small their real estate portfolio may be.

2386
03:32:58.675 --> 03:33:07.380
<v Candace Avalos>I am very concerned that the Black and brown families that I work with will give up their dreams and stop offering housing to their neighbors.

2387
03:33:07.804 --> 03:33:08.846
<v Candace Avalos>That's bad for all of us.

2388
03:33:09.206 --> 03:33:09.939
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for your time.

2389
03:33:13.629 --> 03:33:14.720
<v Javier Alomia>Good afternoon, councilors.

2390
03:33:15.155 --> 03:33:16.310
<v Javier Alomia>My name is Javier Lomillo.

2391
03:33:16.841 --> 03:33:18.976
<v Javier Alomia>I've been a proud Portland resident for 25 years.

2392
03:33:19.104 --> 03:33:27.117
<v Javier Alomia>I'm a real estate agent with 2 decades of experience, a board member at Portland Metropolitan Association of Realtors, and a former member of Hacienda CDC.

2393
03:33:27.503 --> 03:33:35.659
<v Javier Alomia>At Hacienda, during my time at Hacienda, we focused on increasing the supply of affordable rental housing across the region because we understood something fundamental.

2394
03:33:36.430 --> 03:33:39.289
<v Javier Alomia>The only way to sustainably bring rents down is to build more homes.

2395
03:33:39.336 --> 03:33:39.465
<v Javier Alomia>Thank you.

2396
03:33:40.106 --> 03:33:41.775
<v Javier Alomia>More supply is the foundation of affordability.

2397
03:33:42.754 --> 03:33:50.074
<v Javier Alomia>In my career, I've also worked closely with small local housing providers, the mom-and-pop landlords who own just 1 or 2 units.

2398
03:33:50.796 --> 03:33:52.289
<v Javier Alomia>These people are not large corporations.

2399
03:33:53.106 --> 03:33:57.761
<v Javier Alomia>They're community members, retirees, and families who fill a vital gap in Portland's rental market.

2400
03:33:58.500 --> 03:34:01.308
<v Javier Alomia>And yet this ordinance sends the wrong message.

2401
03:34:01.870 --> 03:34:05.272
<v Javier Alomia>More regulation, more risk in a city already burdened with red tape.

2402
03:34:05.319 --> 03:34:09.993
<v Javier Alomia>Councilmember this is just one more reason to stop investing, and many have already left.

2403
03:34:11.356 --> 03:34:13.397
<v Javier Alomia>To be clear, I do not support price fixing.

2404
03:34:13.670 --> 03:34:15.050
<v Javier Alomia>It is wrong and it's already illegal.

2405
03:34:15.836 --> 03:34:18.132
<v Javier Alomia>But this ordinance goes far beyond banning collusion.

2406
03:34:18.791 --> 03:34:26.514
<v Javier Alomia>The language around non-public competitor data is so vague it could prevent a landlord from using their own rent history or internal business data.

2407
03:34:27.220 --> 03:34:28.248
<v Javier Alomia>That is not unethical.

2408
03:34:28.746 --> 03:34:30.786
<v Javier Alomia>That is just smart, informed property management.

2409
03:34:30.834 --> 03:34:31.011
<v Javier Alomia>Thank you.

2410
03:34:32.054 --> 03:34:34.389
<v Javier Alomia>This ordinance does not solve our housing crisis.

2411
03:34:34.550 --> 03:34:35.195
<v Javier Alomia>It compounds it.

2412
03:34:35.694 --> 03:34:40.237
<v Javier Alomia>It creates confusion, drives away investment, and distracts from the real solution.

2413
03:34:41.131 --> 03:34:41.904
<v Javier Alomia>We need more housing.

2414
03:34:43.206 --> 03:34:52.156
<v Javier Alomia>If we truly want to lower rents and create opportunity, we need policies that support housing production, not ones that punish the people trying to provide it.

2415
03:34:53.176 --> 03:34:53.436
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2416
03:34:55.121 --> 03:34:55.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2417
03:34:56.013 --> 03:34:57.635
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That puts us at exactly 1 o'clock.

2418
03:34:57.770 --> 03:35:01.558
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we need to allow staff time to turn over the room for our work session.

2419
03:35:02.361 --> 03:35:14.788
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, to folks who have signed up to testify, if you are available tomorrow from 3:30 to 5, we will make sure there is a quorum of councilors here to continue hearing public testimony.

2420
03:35:15.397 --> 03:35:25.143
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you would like to testify and you are signed up and you are not available tomorrow, we will be scheduling this item for additional time at our evening meeting on April 16th.

2421
03:35:25.255 --> 03:35:27.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That is a Wednesday, 2 weeks from today.

2422
03:35:28.531 --> 03:35:32.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You are welcome to come to either of those periods of time to continue testifying.

2423
03:35:33.684 --> 03:35:39.915
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are closing the oral record today, which means we are not going to take signups for additional public testimony.

2424
03:35:40.412 --> 03:35:49.805
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will keep the written record open in case folks who have signed up are not able to come to either of those other 2 dates to testify and would like to submit written testimony instead.

2425
03:35:49.852 --> 03:35:49.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2426
03:35:50.542 --> 03:35:54.605
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Closing the oral record does not mean that we won't be taking additional public testimony.

2427
03:35:54.718 --> 03:35:58.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It just means that we won't be taking new public testimony signups.

2428
03:35:59.198 --> 03:36:05.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I want to thank our staff, especially our clerk who is stuck here while we are here, for running a little bit over today.

2429
03:36:06.584 --> 03:36:15.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And with that, I am going to recess today's meeting to tomorrow when we will continue testimony on this agenda item.

2430
03:36:15.190 --> 03:36:15.287
<v Helmi Hissrich>Thank you.

