WEBVTT

1
00:06:59.523 --> 00:07:14.937
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Good morning.

2
00:07:20.870 --> 00:07:28.449
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am going to begin the council meeting on March 5th.

3
00:07:28.529 --> 00:07:31.516
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 9:32 AM.

4
00:07:32.098 --> 00:07:34.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope everyone's doing well this morning.

5
00:07:34.204 --> 00:07:44.711
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a pretty full agenda but a lot of technical pieces to it that we should be able to move through, um, without too much delay.

6
00:07:45.358 --> 00:07:57.350
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are likely going to take a break a few hours in though if it starts to run pretty long, just so folks can have a few minutes, um, and we'll try to get through things in as timely a manner as we can.

7
00:07:57.463 --> 00:07:59.240
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

8
00:08:01.982 --> 00:08:02.367
<v Rebecca Dobert>Good morning.

9
00:08:02.783 --> 00:08:03.088
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

10
00:08:03.425 --> 00:08:03.747
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

11
00:08:04.148 --> 00:08:04.533
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

12
00:08:04.790 --> 00:08:04.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

13
00:08:05.142 --> 00:08:05.495
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

14
00:08:06.170 --> 00:08:06.620
<v Sameer Kanal>Kanal?

15
00:08:06.875 --> 00:08:07.004
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

16
00:08:07.406 --> 00:08:07.646
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

17
00:08:08.802 --> 00:08:09.348
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Koyama Lane?

18
00:08:09.685 --> 00:08:09.812
<v Rebecca Dobert>Here.

19
00:08:10.165 --> 00:08:10.487
<v Steve Novick>Morillo?

20
00:08:11.048 --> 00:08:11.257
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

21
00:08:11.547 --> 00:08:11.947
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

22
00:08:12.333 --> 00:08:12.428
<v Steve Novick>Here.

23
00:08:12.509 --> 00:08:13.134
<v Olivia Clark>Clark?

24
00:08:13.456 --> 00:08:13.632
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

25
00:08:14.017 --> 00:08:14.290
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

26
00:08:14.516 --> 00:08:14.644
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

27
00:08:14.916 --> 00:08:15.334
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

28
00:08:15.574 --> 00:08:15.896
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

29
00:08:16.345 --> 00:08:17.291
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

30
00:08:17.805 --> 00:08:18.206
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

31
00:08:19.475 --> 00:08:26.038
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And could— Lauren, could you please go over the rules of order and decorum for us?

32
00:08:28.740 --> 00:08:30.675
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

33
00:08:31.982 --> 00:08:32.885
<v Unidentified speaker>No, there we go.

34
00:08:33.192 --> 00:08:34.918
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, welcome to the Portland City Council.

35
00:08:35.144 --> 00:08:41.163
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

36
00:08:44.152 --> 00:08:47.216
<v Unidentified speaker>Information on engaging with the council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

37
00:08:47.779 --> 00:08:51.697
<v Unidentified speaker>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

38
00:08:51.922 --> 00:08:54.407
<v Unidentified speaker>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

39
00:08:55.032 --> 00:08:56.731
<v Unidentified speaker>The presiding officer preserves order.

40
00:08:56.972 --> 00:09:04.316
<v Unidentified speaker>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

41
00:09:04.846 --> 00:09:06.721
<v Unidentified speaker>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

42
00:09:06.994 --> 00:09:09.287
<v Unidentified speaker>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

43
00:09:09.880 --> 00:09:12.975
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

44
00:09:13.392 --> 00:09:16.503
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

45
00:09:17.176 --> 00:09:18.956
<v Unidentified speaker>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

46
00:09:19.004 --> 00:09:19.389
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

47
00:09:20.009 --> 00:09:21.825
<v Unidentified speaker>When testifying, state your name for the record.

48
00:09:21.889 --> 00:09:23.316
<v Unidentified speaker>Your address is not necessary.

49
00:09:23.673 --> 00:09:26.250
<v Unidentified speaker>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

50
00:09:26.970 --> 00:09:30.153
<v Unidentified speaker>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

51
00:09:30.315 --> 00:09:30.621
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

52
00:09:31.606 --> 00:09:34.111
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

53
00:09:34.451 --> 00:09:35.534
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Lauren.

54
00:09:36.523 --> 00:09:43.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, are there any requests to amend or reorder the agenda, councilors?

55
00:09:48.373 --> 00:09:52.738
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing none, do we have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

56
00:09:54.698 --> 00:09:58.849
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, without objection, we will approve the agenda and move forward.

57
00:09:59.990 --> 00:10:04.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next item on the agenda is our public communications.

58
00:10:04.519 --> 00:10:08.379
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, will you invite up our first, uh, commenter today, please?

59
00:10:09.621 --> 00:10:11.421
<v Rebecca Dobert>First, we have Craig Mossback.

60
00:10:19.447 --> 00:10:19.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

61
00:10:19.847 --> 00:10:21.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here today.

62
00:10:22.187 --> 00:10:24.142
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you all for, uh, being here.

63
00:10:24.815 --> 00:10:30.134
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, my name is Craig Mossback, and I'm a proud resident of Portland in City Council District 3.

64
00:10:30.600 --> 00:10:33.179
<v Angelita Morillo>I saw you all at the City Club event a couple weeks ago.

65
00:10:33.244 --> 00:10:33.869
<v Angelita Morillo>That was great.

66
00:10:34.542 --> 00:10:38.339
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm excited to be here in the first couple months of our new city government.

67
00:10:39.238 --> 00:10:45.398
<v Angelita Morillo>We have 12 members on this council, each person bringing their perspectives from various neighborhoods, backgrounds, and experiences.

68
00:10:45.927 --> 00:10:47.226
<v Angelita Morillo>I see Mayor Wilson here.

69
00:10:47.418 --> 00:10:52.456
<v Angelita Morillo>I think I, I see your kind heart and clear vision, and I say that's very inspirational.

70
00:10:52.568 --> 00:10:53.403
<v Angelita Morillo>I appreciate that.

71
00:10:54.317 --> 00:10:59.595
<v Angelita Morillo>And you all are here together in this chamber to make decisions to move our city forward.

72
00:11:00.429 --> 00:11:04.535
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm here today to highlight 3 projects, and when you hear about them, I hope that you say yes.

73
00:11:04.600 --> 00:11:04.729
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

74
00:11:05.948 --> 00:11:08.212
<v Angelita Morillo>The first is the James Beard Public Market.

75
00:11:08.870 --> 00:11:15.421
<v Angelita Morillo>30 years ago, the Portland Farmers Market was started by 3 friends, Ted Snyder, Rick Hagen, and myself.

76
00:11:16.802 --> 00:11:22.373
<v Angelita Morillo>This was near the beginning of Portland's culinary renaissance, and you can just see where we are today with that.

77
00:11:23.062 --> 00:11:28.601
<v Angelita Morillo>The next step in highlighting the bounty of Oregon's agriculture is the James Beard Public Market.

78
00:11:29.469 --> 00:11:34.269
<v Angelita Morillo>The market can be an iconic symbol for Portland and Oregon's thriving food scene.

79
00:11:35.051 --> 00:11:41.015
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, this will be a benefit for residents, for visitors to our city, and for producers around the state of Oregon.

80
00:11:42.182 --> 00:11:46.495
<v Angelita Morillo>When the James Beard Public Market comes to ask for your support, please say yes.

81
00:11:47.816 --> 00:11:51.004
<v Angelita Morillo>Another project I'm excited about is being led by Oregon Walks.

82
00:11:51.438 --> 00:11:59.407
<v Angelita Morillo>Now, this is a group that advocates for safe, attractive walking options, and this helps create thriving and more connected communities.

83
00:12:00.186 --> 00:12:04.344
<v Angelita Morillo>Oregon Walks is organizing community walks in each of the new 4 city council districts.

84
00:12:06.153 --> 00:12:08.927
<v Angelita Morillo>Hopefully led by you, our elected representatives.

85
00:12:09.538 --> 00:12:12.857
<v Angelita Morillo>These walks are a way for you to build connections with the broader community.

86
00:12:13.532 --> 00:12:18.809
<v Angelita Morillo>And so when Oregon Walks contacts your office to see if you'll participate, please say yes.

87
00:12:20.206 --> 00:12:26.062
<v Angelita Morillo>Finally, the big project in the room, minimizing the negative impacts of the budget shortfall.

88
00:12:26.831 --> 00:12:31.725
<v Angelita Morillo>And we can be honest that it would be more fun to govern with a budget surplus than a deficit.

89
00:12:31.804 --> 00:12:31.917
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

90
00:12:32.221 --> 00:12:45.312
<v Angelita Morillo>But whatever the budget situation, we should bring the same approach to these decisions, valuing community input, emphasizing our core values, informed evidence-based decisions, and doing the best for our collective future.

91
00:12:46.115 --> 00:12:51.028
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm optimistic that you will make informed, thoughtful decisions that lead Portland to a brighter future.

92
00:12:51.897 --> 00:12:54.643
<v Angelita Morillo>Is Portland on the upswing with our best days ahead of us?

93
00:12:55.269 --> 00:12:56.956
<v Angelita Morillo>Please say yes.

94
00:12:57.501 --> 00:12:57.645
<v Priya Dhanapal>Yes.

95
00:12:58.384 --> 00:13:06.850
<v Angelita Morillo>I value your time and for listening to me today, and I really very much appreciate the hard work and dedication you're showing to our city.

96
00:13:07.820 --> 00:13:08.082
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

97
00:13:10.072 --> 00:13:10.975
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much.

98
00:13:13.433 --> 00:13:15.373
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Thomas Karwacki.

99
00:13:17.330 --> 00:13:18.268
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thomas, are you in the room?

100
00:13:18.331 --> 00:13:19.188
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thomas Karwacki.

101
00:13:25.542 --> 00:13:27.352
<v Rebecca Dobert>Then we have Christine Burmeister.

102
00:13:31.558 --> 00:13:31.721
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

103
00:13:32.159 --> 00:13:32.388
<v Olivia Clark>Thanks.

104
00:13:32.567 --> 00:13:34.745
<v Christine Burmeister>I thought I had another minute, so I'm still chewing my mint.

105
00:13:43.879 --> 00:13:44.254
<v Christine Burmeister>Good morning.

106
00:13:45.261 --> 00:13:46.464
<v Christine Burmeister>My name is Christine Burmeister.

107
00:13:47.220 --> 00:13:56.095
<v Christine Burmeister>Uh, when I opened my diner, The Daily Feast, downtown in 2016, I loved Portland and felt we had shared values— food, nature, books, liberal politics.

108
00:13:56.952 --> 00:13:59.760
<v Christine Burmeister>I remember locking up at night and feeling a deep sense of contentment.

109
00:14:00.724 --> 00:14:04.509
<v Christine Burmeister>When the pandemic hit and the protests started, we worked with boards on our windows for 18 months.

110
00:14:05.297 --> 00:14:08.793
<v Christine Burmeister>We handed breakfast burritos through a slot in the plexiglass to our community.

111
00:14:08.986 --> 00:14:12.163
<v Christine Burmeister>We used our PPP money to keep all of our people working downtown.

112
00:14:13.318 --> 00:14:20.988
<v Christine Burmeister>There were tents on every corner, and we saw bodies and prostitution and drug dealing and drug use and all the criminal elements that show up when there aren't any rules and the world is upside down.

113
00:14:22.303 --> 00:14:24.470
<v Christine Burmeister>But even then, I still believed in Portland, and I was devoted.

114
00:14:24.518 --> 00:14:24.647
<v Christine Burmeister>Thank you.

115
00:14:25.192 --> 00:14:34.885
<v Christine Burmeister>And I was so devoted that in 2021, I opened another restaurant downtown called Taylor Street Kitchen, assuming that Portland would pull itself together now that the restrictions were lifted.

116
00:14:35.807 --> 00:14:36.971
<v Christine Burmeister>Many people doubted my decision.

117
00:14:37.019 --> 00:14:37.796
<v Christine Burmeister>Portland was a mess.

118
00:14:37.845 --> 00:14:38.717
<v Christine Burmeister>I should open somewhere else.

119
00:14:38.783 --> 00:14:39.687
<v Christine Burmeister>But I stood by the city.

120
00:14:41.030 --> 00:14:43.403
<v Christine Burmeister>Now here we are in 2025, and Portland is still not well.

121
00:14:44.662 --> 00:14:45.243
<v Christine Burmeister>I don't know why.

122
00:14:46.652 --> 00:14:49.789
<v Christine Burmeister>Rumor has it that some people want downtown to die, to stick it to the man.

123
00:14:51.134 --> 00:14:52.450
<v Christine Burmeister>Or that the city council can't work together.

124
00:14:52.499 --> 00:14:53.650
<v Christine Burmeister>It's an east side, west side thing.

125
00:14:55.042 --> 00:15:06.090
<v Christine Burmeister>I know there seems to be no unified strategy because when I sat in last Wednesday's joint meeting with Multnomah County, no one could even answer how much a shelter bed cost or how many were long-term or how many people were actually helped off the street.

126
00:15:07.779 --> 00:15:09.258
<v Christine Burmeister>You can't manage what you can't measure.

127
00:15:10.438 --> 00:15:17.683
<v Christine Burmeister>I don't know a lot, but I do know that business taxes have gone up, but the state of our city discourages people from frequenting our businesses.

128
00:15:17.732 --> 00:15:23.394
<v Christine Burmeister>Councilmember I do know that our tax rate is the highest in the nation and people are leaving.

129
00:15:23.541 --> 00:15:28.995
<v Christine Burmeister>And I know that I need to call the police every week, that both my restaurants and all my employees' cars have been broken into.

130
00:15:30.071 --> 00:15:33.750
<v Christine Burmeister>One of our reviews said something like, the pancakes were great, but my car was stolen.

131
00:15:34.184 --> 00:15:34.619
<v Christine Burmeister>1 star.

132
00:15:36.418 --> 00:15:42.250
<v Christine Burmeister>And I know that my soul is damaged by coming downtown to witness miserable people having the worst day of their life every day.

133
00:15:42.895 --> 00:15:53.937
<v Christine Burmeister>Sad, sick, addicted, angry, traumatized, in wheelchairs, shoeless, wet, filthy, hungry, Cold, bloody, their hands cracked, swollen, toothless, confused, desperate.

134
00:15:55.642 --> 00:16:06.714
<v Christine Burmeister>Portland has inadvertently found a way to keep a vulnerable population at rock bottom in perpetuity, with more people arriving every day to take advantage of this laxity.

135
00:16:07.903 --> 00:16:11.504
<v Christine Burmeister>This is why our children can't come downtown.

136
00:16:11.938 --> 00:16:13.820
<v Christine Burmeister>This is why people are moving their families away.

137
00:16:13.899 --> 00:16:14.076
<v Christine Burmeister>Thank you.

138
00:16:14.773 --> 00:16:20.759
<v Christine Burmeister>Where is our awareness of the fact that tourism and taxes pay our bills?

139
00:16:23.500 --> 00:16:23.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

140
00:16:24.988 --> 00:16:26.558
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

141
00:16:30.812 --> 00:16:36.613
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Richard Elmeyer, and Richard is joining us in person.

142
00:16:48.879 --> 00:17:00.618
<v Rebecca Dobert>While Richard is getting ready to approach the testimony table, I want to let councilors know that for the next testifier, number 5, Donna Cohen, you all have a copy of her testimony at, at your workspace.

143
00:17:01.869 --> 00:17:02.894
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Mr. Allmeyer.

144
00:17:03.471 --> 00:17:14.025
<v Richard Elmeyer>Excuse me, I'm a little out of breath, uh, trying to close the steel bridge And I was stuck on the east side for about an hour or so, so I'm a little out of breath.

145
00:17:14.858 --> 00:17:18.644
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for still finding a way to make it here on time, and I'm sorry that happened.

146
00:17:18.788 --> 00:17:31.816
<v Richard Elmeyer>Well, uh, apparently there's a signal problem, but there's going to be chaos in transportation today, so you might find that with other people who are trying to take public transportation.

147
00:17:36.165 --> 00:17:37.248
<v Richard Elmeyer>My name is Richard Elmeyer.

148
00:17:38.023 --> 00:17:46.471
<v Richard Elmeyer>I first came into this building as the chair of the North Community Action Council in 1975 to meet with Mayor Goldschmidt and his staff.

149
00:17:47.551 --> 00:17:53.080
<v Richard Elmeyer>I've been doing business with elected leaders and their staffs in City Hall ever since.

150
00:17:54.644 --> 00:18:01.394
<v Richard Elmeyer>Commissioner Eric Sten pronounced with great triumphalism a 10-year plan to end homelessness.

151
00:18:02.489 --> 00:18:08.176
<v Richard Elmeyer>Nan Roman, a leading national voice on the issue of homelessness, spoke before the City Club of Portland.

152
00:18:09.012 --> 00:18:15.038
<v Richard Elmeyer>She ended her talk by saying that Portland could end homelessness.

153
00:18:15.905 --> 00:18:19.231
<v Richard Elmeyer>No member of the Portland City Council ever talked to her.

154
00:18:20.099 --> 00:18:24.470
<v Richard Elmeyer>An excellent example of hubris and self-inflicted ignorance.

155
00:18:25.563 --> 00:18:29.971
<v Richard Elmeyer>The Joint Office of Homeless Services has repeatedly failed to deliver.

156
00:18:30.750 --> 00:18:33.784
<v Richard Elmeyer>It is neither transparent nor accountable.

157
00:18:37.220 --> 00:18:41.560
<v Richard Elmeyer>The Metro regional government declared housing a regional matter under its control.

158
00:18:42.497 --> 00:18:52.498
<v Richard Elmeyer>Voters agreed and gave Metro more than $1 billion to establish a publicly vetted regional housing policy and a plan to execute that policy.

159
00:18:53.442 --> 00:18:59.018
<v Richard Elmeyer>To date, Metro has failed to fulfill the voters' legitimate expectations.

160
00:19:00.250 --> 00:19:16.321
<v Richard Elmeyer>The authority over all housing policy in Oregon is the Land Conservation and Development Commission's Goal 10, which was recently revised to include instructions that Metro shall provide a regional housing policy and plan.

161
00:19:17.395 --> 00:19:31.047
<v Richard Elmeyer>That plan must address the disparities in public housing units in the counties under Metro's jurisdiction, where Clackamas has 3%, Washington 5%, and Multnomah County 11%.

162
00:19:31.417 --> 00:19:33.838
<v Richard Elmeyer>Excuse me.

163
00:19:35.614 --> 00:19:45.404
<v Richard Elmeyer>You cannot fix nor even have a meaningful conversation about housing if you don't understand the language and the process of how housing development works.

164
00:19:46.508 --> 00:19:50.134
<v Richard Elmeyer>The term affordable housing is meaningless and deceptive.

165
00:19:50.623 --> 00:19:53.561
<v Richard Elmeyer>Unless it is accompanied by for whom.

166
00:19:55.022 --> 00:20:00.660
<v Richard Elmeyer>The terms public housing and affordable housing are not the same and are not interchangeable.

167
00:20:01.446 --> 00:20:09.381
<v Richard Elmeyer>When you use these terms incorrectly, you are deliberately misusing language to feel good about yourself, not to communicate.

168
00:20:10.375 --> 00:20:22.541
<v Richard Elmeyer>It is no different than the mountains of information, misinformation, disinformation, and outright lies that overwhelms our political discourse from congressional Republicans and the White House.

169
00:20:23.440 --> 00:20:26.230
<v Richard Elmeyer>Most public housing is not affordable housing.

170
00:20:27.304 --> 00:20:36.059
<v Richard Elmeyer>Misusing the term affordable housing for public housing is the easiest, most fundamental way to assure no personal accountability.

171
00:20:37.069 --> 00:20:41.641
<v Richard Elmeyer>I look forward to meeting and discussing housing policy with every member of this council.

172
00:20:42.281 --> 00:20:43.276
<v Richard Elmeyer>Thank you and good luck.

173
00:20:43.339 --> 00:20:43.548
<v Richard Elmeyer>Thank you.

174
00:20:44.528 --> 00:20:45.892
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for your time this morning.

175
00:20:46.833 --> 00:20:51.019
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

176
00:20:52.019 --> 00:20:56.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Donna Cohen.

177
00:20:57.772 --> 00:20:58.559
<v Donna Cohen>Good morning, Council.

178
00:20:59.138 --> 00:21:06.930
<v Donna Cohen>Uh, apologies for not sending my slides ahead of time and for giving you a kind of a poor print copy here.

179
00:21:07.689 --> 00:21:10.477
<v Donna Cohen>Um, Donna Cohen from St. Johns, District 2.

180
00:21:10.965 --> 00:21:15.769
<v Donna Cohen>Uh, I want to point out, if you look at the sheet, what we use most of the time for Yes.

181
00:21:15.817 --> 00:21:22.356
<v Donna Cohen>Our income is from HUD, and we use that to determine housing eligibility.

182
00:21:22.807 --> 00:21:30.246
<v Donna Cohen>It's part of our housing needs analysis, and it was part of how you— your salaries were determined.

183
00:21:30.663 --> 00:21:36.351
<v Donna Cohen>But there's a problem with the HUD data, and that is that it's for the metropolitan area, for the metro area.

184
00:21:36.431 --> 00:21:37.652
<v Donna Cohen>It is not for Portland.

185
00:21:38.134 --> 00:21:42.118
<v Donna Cohen>And if you look on the next page, you see what the census data says.

186
00:21:42.536 --> 00:21:46.376
<v Donna Cohen>Our median incomes for Portland, they're considerably less.

187
00:21:46.490 --> 00:21:51.086
<v Donna Cohen>So we have these 2 estimates from census, $86,000, $88,000.

188
00:21:51.213 --> 00:21:53.423
<v Donna Cohen>This is from 2023.

189
00:21:54.794 --> 00:22:00.472
<v Donna Cohen>So $25,000 to $30,000 less is the median income for Portlanders.

190
00:22:00.586 --> 00:22:10.477
<v Donna Cohen>And I think we need to be using these figures because they will change much of what we do in our, in our housing reports and other reports.

191
00:22:10.589 --> 00:22:11.998
<v Donna Cohen>And they reflect Portlanders, not—.

192
00:22:12.016 --> 00:22:12.253
<v Donna Cohen>Portlanders.

193
00:22:13.865 --> 00:22:14.925
<v Donna Cohen>The metro area.

194
00:22:15.423 --> 00:22:21.090
<v Donna Cohen>So 50% of Portland households have incomes below, obviously, the median of $88,000.

195
00:22:21.429 --> 00:22:33.969
<v Donna Cohen>25% Of Portland households, according to Portland's housing needs analysis, are below 25% or below 50% of median income.

196
00:22:34.032 --> 00:22:35.397
<v Donna Cohen>So under $44,000.

197
00:22:35.461 --> 00:22:43.897
<v Donna Cohen>That's 1 out of 4 households live on 1 out of, on under $44,000, which is considerably lower than your salaries.

198
00:22:44.172 --> 00:22:51.921
<v Donna Cohen>Just point out, I hope you don't let your salaries get to your head and forget how many Portlanders are, are living at these levels.

199
00:22:52.804 --> 00:22:54.315
<v Donna Cohen>Another topic, the earthquake.

200
00:22:55.103 --> 00:23:07.434
<v Donna Cohen>Um, if you look on the sheet that has the map, so everybody's going to, you know, be in trouble then, but there are 30,000 of us, both residents and workers, in the North Peninsula.

201
00:23:08.711 --> 00:23:10.363
<v Donna Cohen>That are going to be particularly at risk.

202
00:23:10.412 --> 00:23:12.970
<v Donna Cohen>You see where we are across from the CEI hub.

203
00:23:13.849 --> 00:23:19.098
<v Donna Cohen>The orange are the liquefaction areas that surround 3 sides of the North Peninsula.

204
00:23:19.500 --> 00:23:30.337
<v Donna Cohen>And then you see the, the 4 stars that line up are 4 little bridges over the railroad cut, which is a 100-foot deep ditch that the railroad runs on.

205
00:23:30.771 --> 00:23:32.153
<v Donna Cohen>It bisects the peninsula.

206
00:23:32.362 --> 00:23:36.407
<v Donna Cohen>All those bridges are going to collapse in the earthquake, if not before, according to PBOT.

207
00:23:37.257 --> 00:23:39.086
<v Donna Cohen>We will be trapped.

208
00:23:40.001 --> 00:23:41.141
<v Donna Cohen>We will be cut off.

209
00:23:41.509 --> 00:23:55.086
<v Donna Cohen>Please, um, please, we want testimony when House Bill 2749, which will supply money to PBOT so we can apply for a grant for a study for at least Columbia and get that moving.

210
00:23:55.584 --> 00:24:03.365
<v Donna Cohen>So definitely thanks, Alana, for being in Salem last week, and hope to see you when this bill comes up later this month.

211
00:24:03.431 --> 00:24:03.575
<v Donna Cohen>Thank you.

212
00:24:03.847 --> 00:24:05.458
<v Donna Cohen>Okay, and I will send these to you.

213
00:24:06.006 --> 00:24:07.808
<v Donna Cohen>So I think that's it, right?

214
00:24:08.887 --> 00:24:11.012
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, right on time.

215
00:24:11.544 --> 00:24:12.027
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

216
00:24:12.285 --> 00:24:14.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here with us today.

217
00:24:19.922 --> 00:24:23.807
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next item on our agenda is the consent agenda.

218
00:24:23.887 --> 00:24:27.554
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, there were 2 items on the posted consent agenda.

219
00:24:28.270 --> 00:24:29.856
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, item number 3.

220
00:24:30.096 --> 00:24:37.977
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first of those was removed from the consent agenda, and the, uh, mayor's office actually asked to pull that back.

221
00:24:38.153 --> 00:24:38.955
<v Rebecca Dobert>Council President?

222
00:24:39.037 --> 00:24:40.786
<v Rebecca Dobert>Excuse me, I'm sorry, it's item number 4.

223
00:24:40.865 --> 00:24:41.284
<v Angelita Morillo>Item 4.

224
00:24:41.364 --> 00:24:43.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, I'm sorry, you're right.

225
00:24:43.513 --> 00:24:43.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

226
00:24:45.183 --> 00:24:48.008
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, item number 4 was pulled off the consent agenda.

227
00:24:48.087 --> 00:24:49.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Apologies for the confusion.

228
00:24:50.078 --> 00:24:54.508
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the mayor's office actually asked to pull that back from the agenda today.

229
00:24:54.587 --> 00:24:56.306
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They'll be bringing it forward another time.

230
00:24:56.369 --> 00:24:58.792
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So the consent agenda has one item on it.

231
00:24:59.147 --> 00:25:02.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item number 3 is still on the consent agenda.

232
00:25:02.856 --> 00:25:05.661
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Rebecca, could you call the roll for the consent agenda, please?

233
00:25:08.094 --> 00:25:08.400
<v Candace Avalos>Avalos?

234
00:25:10.107 --> 00:25:10.156
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

235
00:25:11.478 --> 00:25:11.816
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy?

236
00:25:12.122 --> 00:25:12.219
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

237
00:25:12.637 --> 00:25:12.992
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

238
00:25:13.734 --> 00:25:13.767
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

239
00:25:14.395 --> 00:25:14.734
<v Sameer Kanal>Kanal?

240
00:25:15.040 --> 00:25:15.219
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

241
00:25:15.685 --> 00:25:16.298
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Koyama Lane?

242
00:25:16.719 --> 00:25:16.767
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

243
00:25:17.782 --> 00:25:19.278
<v Angelita Morillo>Murillo?

244
00:25:19.568 --> 00:25:19.601
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

245
00:25:20.115 --> 00:25:20.292
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

246
00:25:20.615 --> 00:25:20.646
<v Priya Dhanapal>Aye.

247
00:25:21.226 --> 00:25:21.724
<v Olivia Clark>Clark?

248
00:25:22.111 --> 00:25:22.223
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

249
00:25:22.529 --> 00:25:22.546
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

250
00:25:23.238 --> 00:25:23.414
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

251
00:25:23.592 --> 00:25:24.026
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

252
00:25:24.299 --> 00:25:24.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

253
00:25:25.640 --> 00:25:25.817
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

254
00:25:26.208 --> 00:25:26.548
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

255
00:25:27.682 --> 00:25:29.028
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Consent agenda passes.

256
00:25:30.180 --> 00:25:40.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Moving to our regular agenda, uh, we are going to hear items 5 and 6 on the agenda together.

257
00:25:41.170 --> 00:25:42.363
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They're related items.

258
00:25:42.619 --> 00:25:48.156
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and Rebecca, could you please call the titles for these agenda items?

259
00:25:49.560 --> 00:25:59.548
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 5, adopt the budget calendar for FY 2025-26 Item 6, adopt schedule for specific council meetings to implement budget calendar.

260
00:26:00.449 --> 00:26:01.428
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

261
00:26:01.573 --> 00:26:18.869
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And these are the agenda items that will set our budget calendar and let the public know what our work will look like as we move forward in the, the council's work on considering about and eventually adopting our budget for next year.

262
00:26:19.480 --> 00:26:21.392
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, this came out of your committee.

263
00:26:21.488 --> 00:26:23.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Would you like to speak to the agenda items?

264
00:26:23.511 --> 00:26:25.213
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, thank you, uh, Madam President.

265
00:26:25.278 --> 00:26:32.439
<v Eric Zimmerman>So colleagues, uh, generally this type of action will take place at the end of our calendar years in, in the years moving forward.

266
00:26:33.210 --> 00:26:45.155
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and so this is one of those actions that we as a budget committee have to take to set an agenda, to be transparent with our public about our process leading up to the end of this fiscal year, which is June 30th.

267
00:26:45.830 --> 00:26:49.651
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so the Finance Committee, uh, a couple weeks ago heard this item.

268
00:26:50.229 --> 00:26:55.796
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, it was a presentation from our CFO's office and our, and our city budget office.

269
00:26:56.726 --> 00:27:15.335
<v Eric Zimmerman>Out of it, what you'll find in your exhibits are an amended, or strikethrough I think is the term we're using, strikethrough, uh, calendar of events that, uh, you'll see actually started on January 24th and goes through until June 18th.

270
00:27:15.835 --> 00:27:32.934
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that lays out a number of work sessions for this, for this budget committee, a number of community sessions, and a number of second— first and second readings of certain, I'll say, administrative requirements, things like utility rates, so that we're really clear with everybody.

271
00:27:33.993 --> 00:27:41.736
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I would like to come off the page to you is that we as the Finance Committee added additional budget work sessions.

272
00:27:41.817 --> 00:27:41.913
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

273
00:27:42.346 --> 00:27:59.601
<v Eric Zimmerman>To this, given the nature of a new government, the nature of a first time where the executive budget is presented to a group who doesn't have that executive sitting on its board, and the fact that we are all only 7 weeks into a new role.

274
00:27:59.856 --> 00:28:01.269
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I've added those.

275
00:28:01.638 --> 00:28:06.727
<v Eric Zimmerman>The Finance Committee heard those and, and, um, and approved that amendment.

276
00:28:06.775 --> 00:28:09.680
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that's why the strikethrough calendar is provided.

277
00:28:09.728 --> 00:28:12.042
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's the one we'll be voting to approve today.

278
00:28:13.346 --> 00:28:22.142
<v Eric Zimmerman>It also— there is, um, a whereas that we added that— well, you'll see all the whereases, but I want to be clear.

279
00:28:22.270 --> 00:28:44.232
<v Eric Zimmerman>This document also gives the variety of policy committees that we have the encouragement to engage in bureau-level, uh, budget conversations at your specified committees with your specified expertise and that's the whereas that you see, uh, striked through toward the bottom of that document.

280
00:28:44.953 --> 00:28:49.712
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then the other item, as the council president— I'm getting a little bit of feedback from somewhere.

281
00:28:49.922 --> 00:28:50.643
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am.

282
00:28:51.106 --> 00:29:04.538
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, but the other item that council president mentioned, item number 6, as you may or may not be aware, uh, our code for some reason actually dictates the time that council meetings take place.

283
00:29:05.227 --> 00:29:17.864
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so just to simply move the time of a meeting, uh, and to adjust the schedule to meet our budget passing requirements, we've got an ordinance changing that for a specified date on May 21st.

284
00:29:18.442 --> 00:29:26.154
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, instead of an evening meeting, we'll use the, the daytime in order to maximize any time we need to finalize this budget.

285
00:29:26.972 --> 00:29:34.951
<v Eric Zimmerman>So with that, uh, we have the CFO's office here, and— but my other Finance Committee members and I can always answer questions.

286
00:29:35.528 --> 00:29:39.494
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I would appreciate this and the next item both to be passed.

287
00:29:40.122 --> 00:29:40.651
<v Eric Zimmerman>Any questions?

288
00:29:41.405 --> 00:29:44.424
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are a number of questions in the queue.

289
00:29:44.761 --> 00:29:47.363
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just want to check before we move on to questions.

290
00:29:47.508 --> 00:29:53.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, do we have any public testimony signed up for either Agenda Item 5 or Agenda Item 6?

291
00:29:53.593 --> 00:29:54.009
<v Rebecca Dobert>We do not.

292
00:29:54.587 --> 00:29:58.344
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, and let's move into council discussion.

293
00:29:58.458 --> 00:29:59.255
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

294
00:30:00.327 --> 00:30:01.384
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

295
00:30:01.807 --> 00:30:11.721
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I just wanted to let the clerk know that I am here, and, um, and if someone from the clerk's office can put up the, uh, the schedule on the screen.

296
00:30:14.984 --> 00:30:17.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are we able to show this on the screen so that everybody can see it?

297
00:30:21.650 --> 00:30:23.405
<v Unidentified speaker>It's the amended Exhibit A.

298
00:30:23.796 --> 00:30:24.219
<v Eric Zimmerman>Strike.

299
00:30:24.836 --> 00:30:26.122
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, can—.

300
00:30:26.300 --> 00:30:31.704
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, someone—.

301
00:30:31.737 --> 00:30:36.184
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, while staff works on that, did you have other questions, comments, or remarks?

302
00:30:37.882 --> 00:30:38.701
<v Loretta Smith>No, Madam President.

303
00:30:38.766 --> 00:30:39.151
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

304
00:30:39.890 --> 00:30:43.472
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, while we work on getting that up, Councilor Murillo, go ahead.

305
00:30:44.549 --> 00:30:45.512
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Madam President.

306
00:30:45.979 --> 00:30:48.897
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, first I just want to say thank you all so much for the work that you put into doing this.

307
00:30:48.948 --> 00:30:52.703
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that focusing on the budget in the next few months is going to be absolutely critical.

308
00:30:52.751 --> 00:30:59.676
<v Angelita Morillo>So I'm really grateful that we're going to have more built-in time to do this because it's easy for time to get away from us and for us to get stuck in other meetings.

309
00:31:00.286 --> 00:31:02.467
<v Angelita Morillo>And this is going to be such a critical thing to look into.

310
00:31:03.780 --> 00:31:18.016
<v Angelita Morillo>I am wondering if a few things— so from what I'm seeing here, it looks like the only community feedback portion is going to be in the district listening sessions where we're going to have each one district listening session.

311
00:31:19.009 --> 00:31:26.675
<v Angelita Morillo>Obviously, people can testify in committee meetings and things like that, but This is very thorough, but I'm not seeing a ton of community engagement.

312
00:31:26.723 --> 00:31:33.109
<v Angelita Morillo>That concerns me a little bit given the really drastic and brutal cuts that all the districts are going to face at this time.

313
00:31:34.409 --> 00:31:46.586
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm wondering if there are sections where people can publicly testify, like in some of the committee meetings, if that can be adjusted in the document just so people can see where they're able to testify in case I missed any.

314
00:31:46.730 --> 00:31:51.507
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor I guess that's more of a comment and kind of a question, if we can adjust that somehow.

315
00:31:52.070 --> 00:31:55.964
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, would you like to speak to the, the conversations that the committee had?

316
00:31:57.369 --> 00:31:58.968
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, uh, that's a great question.

317
00:31:59.016 --> 00:32:07.058
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's one of the, the, I think, the bigger tasks that we tackled in terms of how do we incorporate community feedback opportunities.

318
00:32:07.480 --> 00:32:13.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and so I, I do want to highlight the district listening sessions as a first time for this organization in this city to do.

319
00:32:13.987 --> 00:32:14.828
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that, that's important.

320
00:32:15.182 --> 00:32:17.878
<v Eric Zimmerman>And those, um, I think will get a lot of attention.

321
00:32:18.297 --> 00:32:25.362
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, uh, I'm looking forward to not just the district folks, but all, all councilors attending those as they, as they find them valuable.

322
00:32:26.003 --> 00:32:27.946
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I think you bring up a great point though, right?

323
00:32:28.106 --> 00:32:33.294
<v Eric Zimmerman>There is the, the public comment that can happen at the policy committees.

324
00:32:34.031 --> 00:32:49.011
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, that I expect will be where the detailed comments come from public when it, when it when it references a specific program or specific need, because that idea is where those bureaus will be talking.

325
00:32:49.108 --> 00:33:01.057
<v Eric Zimmerman>One thing I didn't say in my initial introduction of this is that the work sessions that you see lined out here are the ones that are intended for this body when we meet as the Budget Committee.

326
00:33:03.142 --> 00:33:15.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the Council President's office and I are still working out exactly which service area will present at which time and trying to put together a calendar of topics as well.

327
00:33:16.241 --> 00:33:26.300
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that any of the meetings where we are taking an action is a time when the council president could have public comment.

328
00:33:27.073 --> 00:33:37.813
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think it is worth noting this request and kind of seeing where we might be able to fit in those different opportunities for public comment, and particularly in some of the extra work sessions.

329
00:33:37.876 --> 00:33:42.929
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's unusual, but it's not out of the realm of possibilities to have comment during a work session.

330
00:33:44.162 --> 00:33:46.959
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, but we didn't build it in here specifically.

331
00:33:48.188 --> 00:33:55.663
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to note, the Finance Committee is— um, it's important to note the Finance Committee is not the Budget Committee.

332
00:33:55.971 --> 00:34:02.345
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so a lot of this, a lot of this calendar and this action is to help the council president, who will be the presiding officer over our Budget Committee.

333
00:34:02.410 --> 00:34:02.539
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

334
00:34:03.125 --> 00:34:17.434
<v Eric Zimmerman>To see what I would say is the bare minimum it's going to take to get enough feedback and enough information to all 12 of us and have an opportunity to work with each other and the city bureaus and service areas to pass this budget.

335
00:34:17.983 --> 00:34:29.471
<v Eric Zimmerman>That being said, I have heard from a number of members on this body that they have interest in some one-on-one type of town halls about stuff, things about their own district in addition to the district-based.

336
00:34:29.568 --> 00:34:29.664
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

337
00:34:30.416 --> 00:34:35.659
<v Eric Zimmerman>It— this document, I think, presents the bare minimum in what is scheduled.

338
00:34:35.835 --> 00:34:42.422
<v Eric Zimmerman>And sanctioned is the wrong term, but like, it's something we're going to organize around and hold and do the cost for.

339
00:34:42.503 --> 00:34:46.525
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I know many are going to hold their own comment sections with people.

340
00:34:47.070 --> 00:34:52.728
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I would say each of those committees offers at least one, if not several, additional opportunities.

341
00:34:53.001 --> 00:34:54.123
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I hear you.

342
00:34:54.282 --> 00:35:00.463
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think the council president and I are both open to if there's something in here that you think we should highlight as this is an opportunity for public comment.

343
00:35:01.333 --> 00:35:05.293
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, we should do that, and we can do that post-passage today, I think.

344
00:35:12.297 --> 00:35:15.288
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, are you able to see what's up on the screen?

345
00:35:15.829 --> 00:35:16.403
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that working?

346
00:35:17.612 --> 00:35:20.626
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, ma'am, and I do have a question when you get to my name.

347
00:35:21.079 --> 00:35:23.865
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor Clark, go right ahead.

348
00:35:24.684 --> 00:35:25.550
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

349
00:35:25.822 --> 00:35:33.447
<v Olivia Clark>So just to add on to what, uh, Councilor Morillo was saying, thank you for the whereas, uh, thank you for changing the times.

350
00:35:33.510 --> 00:35:34.505
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that.

351
00:35:35.115 --> 00:35:47.362
<v Olivia Clark>But also, as chair of a policy committee, um, I'm really interested in getting more direction from Finance Committee about, um, how you want us to conduct our, um, meetings with our bureaus.

352
00:35:47.731 --> 00:35:52.659
<v Olivia Clark>It would be nice, I think, if we had a standardized approach across all of the policy committees.

353
00:35:52.722 --> 00:35:52.818
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

354
00:35:53.333 --> 00:35:56.900
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm waiting for your committee to offer something to us.

355
00:35:58.862 --> 00:36:06.568
<v Olivia Clark>And I've also, just to confirm, I've gotten requests from District 4, our district, to have additional budget hearings.

356
00:36:06.938 --> 00:36:19.596
<v Olivia Clark>So again, if you— if the Finance Committee would like to offer us some guidance on how to conduct those, it would be— I would be very grateful for that so that we have some sort of a standard approach across all of us.

357
00:36:19.643 --> 00:36:20.561
<v Olivia Clark>I know we're all different.

358
00:36:20.610 --> 00:36:21.403
<v Olivia Clark>We do things differently.

359
00:36:21.456 --> 00:36:21.610
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

360
00:36:21.891 --> 00:36:25.289
<v Olivia Clark>But I think some guidance would be greatly appreciated.

361
00:36:25.641 --> 00:36:26.427
<v Olivia Clark>Just wanted to say that.

362
00:36:26.539 --> 00:36:26.827
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

363
00:36:26.922 --> 00:36:27.916
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, Councilor.

364
00:36:28.204 --> 00:36:28.766
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, Councilor.

365
00:36:28.925 --> 00:36:57.032
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, um, I want to share with you just what's going to happen this week if this passes as it's presented, that on Thursday, um, the staff and I and Council President's office are basically going to look at all the calendar dates, all of the committee timelines, the— this calendar, and start penciling in what we think is a good schedule in terms of the topic to take up by committee or by service area on what meeting.

366
00:36:57.929 --> 00:37:15.027
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we're working on— I'm going to call it a one-pager, but I make no promise that it'll just be a single page— of that kind of initial guidance for how to engage in the work, the basis for questions or priorities, knowing full well that each committee is going to have its own flavor.

367
00:37:15.411 --> 00:37:18.492
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we're working to get that out by the end of next week as well.

368
00:37:19.726 --> 00:37:19.983
<v Rebecca Dobert>Great.

369
00:37:20.608 --> 00:37:22.148
<v Olivia Clark>Just one more question.

370
00:37:22.213 --> 00:37:22.887
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate that.

371
00:37:22.952 --> 00:37:25.262
<v Olivia Clark>That will be really, really helpful.

372
00:37:25.759 --> 00:37:42.121
<v Olivia Clark>And I think digging in a little bit deeper as to how we collectively process the mayor's budget, some direction on how we're going to conduct those hearings or work sessions, whichever we choose, would also be helpful.

373
00:37:45.557 --> 00:37:48.088
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

374
00:37:48.362 --> 00:37:48.911
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

375
00:37:50.554 --> 00:37:51.329
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam President.

376
00:37:51.969 --> 00:38:21.130
<v Mitch Green>I don't have too much more to add that Councilor Zimmerman didn't already lay out, but I just wanted to reinforce this idea that when we talked about it in committee, in the Finance Committee, the whereas clause that really sort of explicitly encourages policy committees to also engage on this, I think is a really important thing to flag because we are not the Budget committee yet, and, and we shouldn't be waiting for that official budget committee to happen to have these conversations, which are quite deep, involving significant trade-offs.

377
00:38:21.210 --> 00:38:33.764
<v Mitch Green>And so, um, the way that I see it, just sort of philosophically here with this calendar, is that we are already in the public comment period that started on Friday, uh, when the city administrator released preliminary proposals.

378
00:38:33.813 --> 00:38:45.945
<v Mitch Green>And so my intention, and I would encourage all of us With our gavels and our various different forms of leadership in the community to do that to the best of our ability now and look for every opportunity.

379
00:38:46.009 --> 00:38:55.492
<v Mitch Green>I know in the Arts and Economy Committee, we're going to be holding space in each committee meeting to take up budget hearing questions, budget process questions.

380
00:38:55.572 --> 00:39:03.789
<v Mitch Green>And so it's a new form of government, but I really appreciate Councilor Zimmerman's leadership on making sure that we act pretty swiftly to put this formally in the process.

381
00:39:03.853 --> 00:39:03.965
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

382
00:39:07.579 --> 00:39:15.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, uh, Councilor Smith, because we hear from everybody once first if they're in the queue, I'm going to go to Councilor Kanal and then come back to you.

383
00:39:15.610 --> 00:39:15.867
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

384
00:39:16.750 --> 00:39:18.083
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, go right ahead.

385
00:39:18.356 --> 00:39:19.528
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

386
00:39:19.706 --> 00:39:21.456
<v Sameer Kanal>I have 4 clarification questions.

387
00:39:21.521 --> 00:39:23.463
<v Sameer Kanal>So, uh, the first is a legal one.

388
00:39:24.202 --> 00:39:37.083
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, the May 21st meeting, if it were to move to the morning as this document, uh, proposes Would we be able to recess that to the evening, or, um, this is more of a process question, evening or May 22nd afternoon?

389
00:39:37.148 --> 00:39:39.027
<v Sameer Kanal>Does that remain an option for us?

390
00:39:40.423 --> 00:39:56.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My intention whenever we've moved evenings to mornings on this list is to allow time for us to do our budget work through the day and still take on any regular items that would be on our council agenda for that week at the regularly scheduled time.

391
00:39:56.324 --> 00:39:59.438
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So yes, We would recess and still have that evening meeting.

392
00:39:59.952 --> 00:40:03.132
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please continue to hold your evenings for those times.

393
00:40:03.726 --> 00:40:08.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if we were to start the budget process at 6 o'clock at night, we would be here until 2 in the morning.

394
00:40:09.088 --> 00:40:09.346
<v Candace Avalos>Right.

395
00:40:09.891 --> 00:40:16.153
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, my understanding— second question— is that the district listening sessions were scheduled both the weeks of March 17th and March 31st.

396
00:40:16.233 --> 00:40:16.362
<v Sameer Kanal>Can—.

397
00:40:16.362 --> 00:40:19.237
<v Sameer Kanal>Did that change, or can someone speak to that?

398
00:40:19.300 --> 00:40:22.175
<v Sameer Kanal>Because the document, the exhibit, only has that first week.

399
00:40:23.860 --> 00:40:29.978
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, I'll just say those are being currently worked out by Civic Life and the City Administrator's Office.

400
00:40:30.123 --> 00:40:31.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't have the exact dates to give to you.

401
00:40:31.905 --> 00:40:37.396
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am going to glance softly at the staff to get a nod that I don't have anything new to present right now.

402
00:40:37.605 --> 00:40:38.376
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's the nod I'm getting.

403
00:40:38.664 --> 00:40:43.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, um, we're close to that and we're going to get it out as quickly as possible.

404
00:40:44.429 --> 00:40:47.737
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I just want to, if I may expand on that question, I know you have 2 more.

405
00:40:48.858 --> 00:41:02.271
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really hope that the public is seeing those and knowing that they can go to any of the district ones, not just the one that's held in their district, and that they should expect more than just their own district councilors to come to the district one.

406
00:41:02.384 --> 00:41:05.204
<v Eric Zimmerman>I plan to do my best to attend all 4.

407
00:41:06.534 --> 00:41:08.985
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is the old school high school gymnasium.

408
00:41:09.418 --> 00:41:16.614
<v Eric Zimmerman>Lots of people make sure that we are for the first time holding something in district so that we can hear from everyday Portlanders.

409
00:41:17.351 --> 00:41:25.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm looking forward to it, and I think it's one of those that will only get better as we go through it for the first time and then the next time, etc., etc.

410
00:41:26.184 --> 00:41:34.085
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I hope that you all in your own social media newsletters will highlight those 4 opportunities and not just the one in your district, because I think they're going to be important for us.

411
00:41:35.063 --> 00:41:36.121
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for letting me expand a little bit.

412
00:41:36.443 --> 00:41:37.068
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thank you.

413
00:41:37.469 --> 00:41:48.206
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I'll note on that the reason that it is those 2 weeks is we skipping the week of PPS's spring break to make sure that folks aren't out of town and do have the opportunity to come to those meetings.

414
00:41:49.791 --> 00:41:51.030
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for expanding on that too.

415
00:41:51.224 --> 00:41:59.007
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, on third question, on May 7th, would the proposed budget work session be a replacement for or in addition to the regular morning council meeting?

416
00:42:01.364 --> 00:42:11.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, that May count— that May 7th date, um, we will be hearing from the mayor about his proposed budget.

417
00:42:11.882 --> 00:42:14.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that will be the bulk of our council meeting.

418
00:42:14.755 --> 00:42:22.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If there are other items that we absolutely need to take up that day, we will figure out the calendar to make sure that we can do that.

419
00:42:23.018 --> 00:42:30.721
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I am planning for the bulk of our agenda to be hearing from the mayor and having a discussion about what is in his proposed budget.

420
00:42:32.164 --> 00:42:32.405
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

421
00:42:32.663 --> 00:42:44.543
<v Sameer Kanal>And then finally, on that whereas, which I'm very supportive of, Uh, I just want to make sure that, that, that would be not only encouraged but, uh, allowed, um, because I want to make sure there's time for that.

422
00:42:44.623 --> 00:42:53.260
<v Sameer Kanal>And I can speak to at least the Community and Public Safety Committee docket being very, very full and trying to create more opportunities.

423
00:42:54.657 --> 00:43:05.380
<v Sameer Kanal>In other words, the committee meeting would not become a budget work session, but rather there would be an additional Gap of additional amount of time for that budget work session.

424
00:43:06.039 --> 00:43:09.199
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, this is a great conflict, right?

425
00:43:09.278 --> 00:43:10.483
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's a, it's a rub here, right?

426
00:43:10.547 --> 00:43:14.766
<v Eric Zimmerman>And just in terms of time and, um, what, what we can get done.

427
00:43:14.813 --> 00:43:25.451
<v Eric Zimmerman>So a couple of things that are really important to get on the record is that when a policy committee meets about and they're talking about budget, they are not convening as the budget committee.

428
00:43:25.867 --> 00:43:29.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is this body When we gavel in as the Budget Committee.

429
00:43:30.992 --> 00:43:39.742
<v Eric Zimmerman>I look at those committee meetings as opportunities for, uh, more in-depth conversation at a smaller scale in a smaller part of the budget.

430
00:43:40.483 --> 00:43:58.054
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so, um, in the guidance that we're going to provide, we will also address kind of types of questions that— and, and commentary that could or should happen in Committee versus types that should and could happen in the full convening of the Budget Committee.

431
00:43:59.016 --> 00:43:59.820
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that'll be important.

432
00:44:00.606 --> 00:44:09.188
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I think the rub here, Councilor, is that, um, I think the committees and the chairs of each of the committees is, is going to have a lot to balance.

433
00:44:09.590 --> 00:44:20.242
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I know that I've said previously on the record, I think that committees— we've got our assigned sessions, but potentially meeting more frequently is something I'm in favor of.

434
00:44:20.353 --> 00:44:25.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>That balance and that management of that time is something I think between the clerk's office, the chair, and the president's office.

435
00:44:26.510 --> 00:44:29.860
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's, that's part of your leadership scope, um, as to how to fit it all in.

436
00:44:30.677 --> 00:44:44.682
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I'm not— from the, from the chair I'm sitting in and from this document, we are attempting to provide a direction and an opportunity, but not saying what can't happen.

437
00:44:45.179 --> 00:44:48.608
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's a negotiation between you and all the things that go into putting a committee together.

438
00:44:48.672 --> 00:44:48.768
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

439
00:44:49.682 --> 00:45:08.159
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if you have— this is me speaking from a person who's done many of these in other governments— if you have things that are part of the regular course of business for your committee and it can be just as accomplished post the budget season, I hope you're taking a look at postponing that until post-budget season.

440
00:45:09.056 --> 00:45:25.663
<v Eric Zimmerman>And speaking personally in my own, my own tactics and how I've always approached these seasons is that come March, come April, May, if it's not budget related, I'm generally not putting a lot of time toward it because I've, I have, um, lassoed this animal enough times in my career.

441
00:45:25.744 --> 00:45:28.072
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just know how sucked up into this topic we can get.

442
00:45:28.409 --> 00:45:37.449
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that would just be my advice, is that if you can push something, it'd be wise to do it, or you may not do things at the highest caliber that you want to just because you're going to be pulled in a lot of directions.

443
00:45:38.588 --> 00:45:43.065
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I Let me turn my microphone on.

444
00:45:43.722 --> 00:45:54.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I want to acknowledge that Councilor Zimmerman's suggestion that things that are not budget-related get pushed comes right at the time when our committees are starting to dig into their work.

445
00:45:54.704 --> 00:46:12.085
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And because we didn't have the runway, right, because we don't have the tail behind us as this council, we're still in that crunch time of getting our work up and running in a way that I think will be less of a conflict in future years.

446
00:46:12.905 --> 00:46:28.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as you know, and I've had a conversation with many of our colleagues about the fact that we have, I believe, 5 different, uh, bureaus or groups of people who support our work as council and each of your work as committees.

447
00:46:29.769 --> 00:46:41.235
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And to put more time on the calendar for committees requires negotiations with each of those groups, and some of those groups don't have the staff right now, frankly, to support us adding much more time.

448
00:46:41.347 --> 00:47:03.436
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I am hearing loud and clear your request for more time, and I'm, I'm saying it out loud so that we can start the conversation about what we need to do to make sure that all of the groups that support us have the resources to be able to support the caliber of work that I know each of you as committee chairs want to do.

449
00:47:04.208 --> 00:47:40.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, as we are in this in-between time without the tail behind us, without the runway to get the work started, um, without all of the groups that support us really being resourced to support us in the way that we need, um, we have some crunches, we have some rub spots, and I don't know that we can fix all of those to the extent that we may want them fixed until we actually get through this budget, which is where we have the ability to provide those additional resources so that we can do our work in an effective way moving forward.

450
00:47:40.849 --> 00:47:48.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I, I can't say to you sitting here today, yes, we can add more committee meetings, but I hear that request.

451
00:47:49.085 --> 00:47:54.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And in making sure that we talk about it thoroughly, I know that the folks who support us are also hearing that.

452
00:47:55.126 --> 00:48:02.050
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And, um, we'll need to have continued conversations about how we create that balance that Councilor Zimmerman spoke to.

453
00:48:03.255 --> 00:48:03.447
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

454
00:48:03.512 --> 00:48:04.588
<v Sameer Kanal>That concludes my questions.

455
00:48:06.909 --> 00:48:09.083
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

456
00:48:09.228 --> 00:48:16.630
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, Chairman Zimmerman, I'm trying to figure out how to ask this question, whether it's to you or to Madam President.

457
00:48:17.554 --> 00:48:23.630
<v Loretta Smith>The budget that was released last week by the city administrator, for me It was incomplete and inadequate.

458
00:48:24.192 --> 00:48:39.619
<v Loretta Smith>And in terms of us being able to have a conversation that's meaningful with the public and with ourselves, I don't know who should ask him to complete that budget so that we can have a full picture.

459
00:48:40.164 --> 00:48:46.963
<v Loretta Smith>We only have one-third, and we were given decision packages to, to cut.

460
00:48:47.043 --> 00:48:54.889
<v Loretta Smith>Councilwoman Smith, And I just wanted the public to know that we have the ability to cut the entire $8.2 billion.

461
00:48:55.306 --> 00:49:01.978
<v Loretta Smith>And so to be directed to cut a few packages, I think is unfair.

462
00:49:02.846 --> 00:49:13.673
<v Loretta Smith>And for us, I just think that it's not, um, it's not going to be productive if we're having these work sessions and it's going to be limited information, and then the mayor is going to come out with something in May.

463
00:49:13.753 --> 00:49:14.059
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

464
00:49:14.253 --> 00:49:16.039
<v Loretta Smith>It's going to be totally different.

465
00:49:16.786 --> 00:49:30.318
<v Loretta Smith>So I don't know if you can ask the administrator to do that, or if the president should ask him to release something that's complete so that we can have a full conversation in March and April.

466
00:49:31.032 --> 00:49:36.523
<v Loretta Smith>Because other than that, there's— I mean, we're just talking theoretically.

467
00:49:36.668 --> 00:49:39.106
<v Loretta Smith>We, we don't have anything to talk about, really.

468
00:49:39.251 --> 00:49:41.355
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Great question.

469
00:49:41.788 --> 00:49:47.195
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that both the council president and the Finance Committee can ask for that information.

470
00:49:47.244 --> 00:50:02.505
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I will just highlight for all members is that we are, we are in the period that qualifies— in no other words, it's the gray area of budget season until we see the executive budget proposed by, by the mayor.

471
00:50:02.971 --> 00:50:06.132
<v Eric Zimmerman>And you'll see how much of our calendar happens before that date.

472
00:50:06.260 --> 00:50:06.469
<v Jared Essig>Thank you.

473
00:50:08.284 --> 00:50:14.373
<v Eric Zimmerman>So things that, things that I'll be asking the staff to make sure that they're providing all of the councilors, right?

474
00:50:14.998 --> 00:50:22.420
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, in what was, what was released on the 28th, I keep referring to the only valuable page to me was page 12.

475
00:50:22.485 --> 00:50:30.228
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if we had that for every, uh, bureau and every program offer and every line item, that gives us a picture that is workable.

476
00:50:30.275 --> 00:50:32.429
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that gets to the heart of your question, Councilor.

477
00:50:32.492 --> 00:50:38.126
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's what you and I are used to from our previous Uh, that is necessary, Councilor.

478
00:50:38.304 --> 00:50:39.827
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is the document that's necessary.

479
00:50:39.907 --> 00:50:44.530
<v Eric Zimmerman>That kind of details what's necessary to have these conversations and be informed about them.

480
00:50:45.347 --> 00:50:49.487
<v Eric Zimmerman>And when the public testimony happens, to know what people are specifically talking about.

481
00:50:50.097 --> 00:50:54.382
<v Eric Zimmerman>Otherwise, it's just large numbers on top of other large numbers that is not meaningful.

482
00:50:55.072 --> 00:51:12.041
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I am not taking what was released on the 28th of February, the preliminary budget, as anything more than I think that's an indication of where the city administrator's mind is going, which is always dangerous to read minds, but I think that we are owed a full document.

483
00:51:12.929 --> 00:51:32.786
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the city council work sessions that are in April, and toward the top of this document you'll see them, this is an area where council president and I are spending some time to understand what will we get how will we use those to be effective when we don't yet know the executive budget?

484
00:51:34.250 --> 00:51:41.378
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I don't want to lessen those sessions, but I think it's an opportunity for us to get an idea of the direction.

485
00:51:41.869 --> 00:51:48.463
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's an opportunity for us to share our priorities to inform that executive budget as much as possible.

486
00:51:50.030 --> 00:51:54.835
<v Eric Zimmerman>Council President, I think it might be worth a microphone moment for the mayor or city administrator on this answer.

487
00:51:54.884 --> 00:51:54.980
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

488
00:51:55.295 --> 00:52:01.206
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I look at those as our opportunity to share some priorities back prior to the executive budget.

489
00:52:01.333 --> 00:52:16.494
<v Eric Zimmerman>And when that executive budget comes out, the way I will approach that, and I would encourage all of us to approach that, is that is the meat and potatoes of what we are reviewing at our committees to make sure that that makes sense and that we see that picture and that our priorities are captured in that executive budget.

490
00:52:16.911 --> 00:52:31.318
<v Loretta Smith>And Mr. Chairman, could you also ask the question, could they include if this money is in ongoing money or restricted money, if we could have the previous 2 years, if it was funded and what it was funded with.

491
00:52:31.726 --> 00:52:41.123
<v Loretta Smith>Because at that point, we can make some decisions on if this is a new program, if this is an old program, if this is an ongoing program that was put in one time only.

492
00:52:42.025 --> 00:52:44.509
<v Loretta Smith>Um, that would make a difference in how we make decisions.

493
00:52:45.637 --> 00:52:48.733
<v Loretta Smith>So it would be great if you could ask him that question as well.

494
00:52:50.918 --> 00:52:51.322
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes, ma'am.

495
00:52:52.925 --> 00:52:59.697
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor, I, I will just add, I think Councilor Zimmerman answered most of those questions quite well.

496
00:53:00.436 --> 00:53:41.782
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, not only do I think we have the, um, the power to look beyond the recommendations and make decisions about every part of the budget, I think we have— I think it is a necessity I would expect that the work we are doing both in committees and in the meeting of this body as the Budget Committee, and before we meet as Budget Committee when we're just holding conversations about what we've seen from the city administrator and what we hope to see from the mayor, it is, I think, imperative that we look even more deeply than the suggestions the city administrator gave us to make sure that we're building the best budget we can.

497
00:53:41.831 --> 00:53:41.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

498
00:53:42.039 --> 00:53:42.798
<v Priya Dhanapal>Budget possible.

499
00:53:43.282 --> 00:53:53.289
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President, because I think it's going to be a shock, uh, when we see the mayor's budget and it doesn't have anything— it doesn't look anything like, um, the city administrator's budget.

500
00:53:53.385 --> 00:53:54.664
<v Loretta Smith>And so people are going to be so confused.

501
00:53:56.998 --> 00:54:00.735
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we can start to set those expectations here today and what we say to the public.

502
00:54:00.945 --> 00:54:07.632
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Mr. Mayor, uh, City Administrator Jordan, do either of you have any comments on, on this question that you'd like to make?

503
00:54:12.130 --> 00:54:13.809
<v Michael Jordan>Appreciate the discussion today.

504
00:54:14.050 --> 00:54:20.070
<v Michael Jordan>Um, I think everything that's been said is relevant and important for us to take into consideration.

505
00:54:20.668 --> 00:54:45.474
<v Michael Jordan>This was a first time that we've ever done this prior to a mayor's proposed, and so I fully expect us to have some pretty intense dialogue about what kind of information can be provided to council so that your opportunities before mayor's proposed, April 2nd, April 16th, at least those can be productive sessions for you.

506
00:54:46.115 --> 00:54:52.827
<v Michael Jordan>And so happy to work with the council president and the chair on how we can frame information.

507
00:54:52.925 --> 00:54:59.556
<v Michael Jordan>If it's, if it's another manifestation of page 12 for, for a number of different parts of the budget, great.

508
00:55:00.614 --> 00:55:02.744
<v Michael Jordan>And we'll, we'll do whatever we can.

509
00:55:03.257 --> 00:55:13.436
<v Michael Jordan>I know the council knows this, but for the public, The documents released last Friday weren't meant to be a budget.

510
00:55:15.289 --> 00:55:22.278
<v Michael Jordan>However, they— in that released document, there is the entire budget document.

511
00:55:22.360 --> 00:55:26.657
<v Michael Jordan>There are all of the program descriptions in the entire budget.

512
00:55:27.081 --> 00:55:31.097
<v Michael Jordan>So I realize that's a huge volume of information and really difficult to process.

513
00:55:31.144 --> 00:55:42.858
<v Michael Jordan>I think it's important to note that the council so we'll work with, with leadership to see if we can figure out how can we make particularly April 2nd and 16th productive sessions, because they will be before the mayor's proposed.

514
00:55:43.099 --> 00:55:45.250
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, um, Mr. Jordan.

515
00:55:46.550 --> 00:55:52.358
<v Loretta Smith>I appreciate that first stab at it, but a description is not really what I need.

516
00:55:52.487 --> 00:55:53.177
<v Loretta Smith>I need numbers.

517
00:55:53.289 --> 00:56:01.286
<v Loretta Smith>I need an Excel spreadsheet with numbers, um, and I need to know what budget was approved prior to this year.

518
00:56:02.217 --> 00:56:12.101
<v Loretta Smith>I need to know what you're suggesting going forward, what you're suggesting to cut in one basic document.

519
00:56:12.840 --> 00:56:18.414
<v Loretta Smith>It's great to, to read a bedtime story, but I just want to read an Excel spreadsheet with numbers.

520
00:56:23.802 --> 00:56:25.766
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, anything to add, or should we move on?

521
00:56:26.918 --> 00:56:28.521
<v Keith Wilson>No, just, just a quick comment.

522
00:56:28.858 --> 00:56:33.382
<v Keith Wilson>You know, I understand where the city administrator is coming from.

523
00:56:33.512 --> 00:56:42.864
<v Keith Wilson>It's such a fluid situation, and we've had ongoing conversations, and I think this is a great conversation just to daylight for the city writ large.

524
00:56:43.458 --> 00:56:46.458
<v Keith Wilson>But it's not just about cut packages we're talking about.

525
00:56:47.003 --> 00:57:01.771
<v Keith Wilson>It's also about add packages, and that's what all of us know we've been actively looking at to really how do we, you know, raise up that revenue through other multi-jurisdictional relationships that we have and ongoing negotiations that I've really been daylighting with all of you.

526
00:57:01.835 --> 00:57:04.052
<v Keith Wilson>So it's, it's a, it's a twin approach.

527
00:57:04.405 --> 00:57:09.670
<v Keith Wilson>It's very flexible, and it's going to continue to be flexible up until that final budget, of which all you're aware of.

528
00:57:09.784 --> 00:57:14.119
<v Keith Wilson>But, um, thank you for the conversations, and we've got a lot of conversations ahead.

529
00:57:14.744 --> 00:57:15.596
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

530
00:57:16.190 --> 00:57:23.641
<v Loretta Smith>It is about cut packages because we're in deficit and we can't add anything until we cut something.

531
00:57:24.315 --> 00:57:38.894
<v Loretta Smith>And until we get people into the practice, if they're going to bring something to the budget that's not already there, they need to cut that amount out of the previous budget and they need to make the case why that is more important than what you're getting ready to add.

532
00:57:39.648 --> 00:57:42.780
<v Loretta Smith>We just can't do add packages and you don't know where the money's coming from.

533
00:57:46.422 --> 00:57:47.195
<v Keith Wilson>That's the discussion.

534
00:57:47.373 --> 00:57:58.447
<v Keith Wilson>It's, uh, Councilor, I appreciate what you're saying, but there are opportunities in the city, and it is my responsibility to make sure we investigate those opportunities to lessen the burden on our community writ large.

535
00:57:58.996 --> 00:58:07.148
<v Loretta Smith>That is so good, and I, I appreciate all the work that you've been doing around homelessness, and I just want to make sure that people know that we're not the Regional Homeless Authority.

536
00:58:07.864 --> 00:58:08.807
<v Loretta Smith>We're the City of Portland.

537
00:58:09.186 --> 00:58:10.452
<v Loretta Smith>We do infrastructure.

538
00:58:10.965 --> 00:58:16.242
<v Loretta Smith>We need to make sure that the body of work and the scope of work that we do is our book of business.

539
00:58:16.322 --> 00:58:17.878
<v Loretta Smith>And our book of business is infrastructure.

540
00:58:17.942 --> 00:58:23.362
<v Loretta Smith>It's streets, it's potholes, it's water, it's BS, it's parks, it's streetlights.

541
00:58:23.635 --> 00:58:24.518
<v Loretta Smith>That's what we do.

542
00:58:25.543 --> 00:58:31.621
<v Loretta Smith>And to put— add packages in without taking something out is irresponsible.

543
00:58:32.777 --> 00:58:40.516
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will certainly be having more of that conversation as we move forward and we talk about priorities of of all of the councilors up here.

544
00:58:41.114 --> 00:59:00.606
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The mayor will show us his priorities in the balanced budget that he releases, which will have to be balanced, and we'll then have to look at how that, um, reflects the priorities that we've heard from Portlanders and what changes, if any, we want to make based on the priorities that we are all bringing to the table on behalf of our constituents.

545
00:59:03.958 --> 00:59:04.722
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos.

546
00:59:07.090 --> 00:59:07.949
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you.

547
00:59:09.440 --> 00:59:11.728
<v Candace Avalos>I have a string of comments and questions.

548
00:59:11.775 --> 00:59:14.469
<v Candace Avalos>I'm going to try to put them together in a reasonable way.

549
00:59:15.119 --> 00:59:19.489
<v Candace Avalos>First, I'll say I share Councilor Murillo's thoughts around increasing community engagement.

550
00:59:19.570 --> 00:59:24.083
<v Candace Avalos>We talked about that on the committee, um, and I plan to keep an eye on that.

551
00:59:24.934 --> 00:59:39.981
<v Candace Avalos>As it relates though to adding more to the agendas, I, I also share, um, Councilor Kanal's concern for to what extent each policy committee should be making space for finance discussions.

552
00:59:40.077 --> 00:59:46.123
<v Candace Avalos>And to be clear, we— my committee, the Homelessness and Housing Committee, our next agenda, we're going to be talking about the budget.

553
00:59:46.204 --> 01:00:01.501
<v Candace Avalos>So on Tuesday, we have an hour dedicated to have staff from each of the different areas that touch housing and homelessness to come talk through, just give us very high-level look at the budget, but so we can just start to get a sense for where certain things are living.

554
01:00:02.085 --> 01:00:04.418
<v Candace Avalos>And so I know that there's some guidance coming.

555
01:00:05.250 --> 01:00:13.068
<v Candace Avalos>I, I'll follow up with you just to make sure that we're on the same page and that we're following that guidance ahead of the Tuesday meeting.

556
01:00:13.929 --> 01:00:25.041
<v Candace Avalos>Um, but I think largely the larger point for me here is, I guess I'm curious when we're going to have discussions about increasing capacity of the council clerk.

557
01:00:25.106 --> 01:00:27.769
<v Candace Avalos>Like, are we expected to wait until the next fiscal year?

558
01:00:27.914 --> 01:00:42.076
<v Candace Avalos>Because I think, you know, for example, I had made a recommendation that on the 5th week, because there's no council committees or council since we do 1 and 2 and 3 and 4, um, and was told that's just too much, there's no capacity for that.

559
01:00:42.204 --> 01:00:43.344
<v Candace Avalos>Again, I understand that.

560
01:00:43.425 --> 01:00:46.893
<v Candace Avalos>I'm not arguing that that's an, uh, that that's incorrect.

561
01:00:47.327 --> 01:00:52.175
<v Candace Avalos>I think I'm just concerned that I don't see what is the timeline or path for us to have that discussion.

562
01:00:52.224 --> 01:01:01.344
<v Candace Avalos>And if that timeline isn't until after the budget, then we're going to be missing several months, in my opinion, of opportunities to have more discussions.

563
01:01:01.440 --> 01:01:09.277
<v Candace Avalos>For example, in April, there is a 5-week month, and I was planning on using that 3rd meeting for my committee to do more budget discussion.

564
01:01:09.791 --> 01:01:18.974
<v Candace Avalos>So I guess I'm just feeling a little under-resourced and not sure how we're supposed to meet what I'm hearing is the expectation and what our capacity is.

565
01:01:19.248 --> 01:01:25.144
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm curious who has an answer to what we think is the timeline for those discussions about increasing capacity.

566
01:01:26.057 --> 01:01:35.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I've heard specific concerns from a few of the groups that support our work, and I have a sense of what they would need to be able to expand capacity.

567
01:01:35.831 --> 01:01:49.402
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But why don't I get a specific proposal from each of the groups that support us of what they would need, both in increased capacity for the rest of this fiscal year and also in increased budgets moving forward, um, starting next fiscal year?

568
01:01:50.028 --> 01:01:56.286
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that we can look at it as a potential— I'll call it, for lack of a better term, an add package.

569
01:01:56.976 --> 01:02:06.813
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we wanted to add that capacity for folks supporting us this fiscal year, we would need to have a conversation about pulling funds out of reserves or cutting other programs for the rest of the year to be able to do that.

570
01:02:07.422 --> 01:02:09.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's a conversation we've had before here.

571
01:02:09.188 --> 01:02:12.349
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's one that I know folks were hoping not to have again this fiscal year.

572
01:02:13.119 --> 01:02:19.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But why don't I get an official proposal for us of what that would look like across all of the Thank you.

573
01:02:20.001 --> 01:02:20.610
<v Candace Avalos>I appreciate it.

574
01:02:20.657 --> 01:02:30.371
<v Candace Avalos>I think it is timely, and I'd like us to expedite that because I just, again, feel that there's too many— that's too many months to wait to increase our ability to talk to the public.

575
01:02:31.141 --> 01:02:37.824
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, lastly, I'll just say, in, um, you know, yes, we have kind of this new process, right?

576
01:02:37.889 --> 01:02:39.860
<v Candace Avalos>We've got the city administrator budget that dropped.

577
01:02:39.909 --> 01:02:40.902
<v Candace Avalos>That's a new thing.

578
01:02:41.480 --> 01:02:44.476
<v Candace Avalos>Um, we have the typical timeline of when the mayor will propose his budget.

579
01:02:44.782 --> 01:02:45.277
<v Candace Avalos>Their budget.

580
01:02:45.422 --> 01:02:51.206
<v Candace Avalos>But compared to the old form of government when the mayor was proposing the budget, they had a lot more leeway in the budget.

581
01:02:51.271 --> 01:02:55.532
<v Candace Avalos>They had a lot, you know, a stronger grasp of overseeing that process.

582
01:02:55.659 --> 01:02:56.893
<v Candace Avalos>That's not the case anymore.

583
01:02:56.974 --> 01:03:00.643
<v Candace Avalos>So let's be clear, it is our responsibility to approve the budget.

584
01:03:00.947 --> 01:03:06.827
<v Candace Avalos>So I know for now and for this year, we are just— we're tight on time, and I understand the constraints we have.

585
01:03:07.356 --> 01:03:13.155
<v Candace Avalos>I guess I'm signaling either whether this year we could build in some more checkpoints.

586
01:03:13.204 --> 01:03:13.797
<v Candace Avalos>I don't know what that would look like.

587
01:03:13.844 --> 01:03:14.164
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's a great idea.

588
01:03:14.407 --> 01:03:28.655
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, Mr. Mayor, but I feel like there needs to be a couple more checkpoints ahead of a May, you know, mayor budget, because I'm feeling like that's going to— we're going to be in a time crunch to get to the rest of, you know, to get to approval, right?

589
01:03:29.170 --> 01:03:34.329
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and I am concerned that we're going to— we got the city administrator budget, we're going to get a mayor budget.

590
01:03:34.378 --> 01:03:40.213
<v Candace Avalos>I have no idea how similar that's going to be to the city administrator budget, and then therefore we have to put our budget together.

591
01:03:40.311 --> 01:03:41.822
<v Candace Avalos>So that's 3 different kinds of budgets.

592
01:03:41.871 --> 01:03:43.601
<v Candace Avalos>That's already really confusing to the public.

593
01:03:43.666 --> 01:03:55.184
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm also trying to figure out how to minimize what we're communicating out, because if we're like sending out, oh, here's the— this person's budget and there's this person's budget, I, I think as a public that, that would be confusing to me.

594
01:03:55.425 --> 01:03:56.690
<v Candace Avalos>It is confusing to me, actually.

595
01:03:57.188 --> 01:04:03.885
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and so I think we should assess what are some good— how we're communicating those different steps in this process.

596
01:04:04.478 --> 01:04:18.121
<v Candace Avalos>Um, but yeah, I'd like to— I can follow up, um, of course with the chair and with the mayor's office, but I feel like we might want to look at building in some other kind of checkpoint, um, ahead of the mayor's release.

597
01:04:18.297 --> 01:04:19.985
<v Candace Avalos>So wanted to put that on the record too.

598
01:04:21.489 --> 01:04:21.684
<v Candace Avalos>That's all.

599
01:04:22.152 --> 01:04:23.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

600
01:04:23.121 --> 01:04:55.329
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I, I'll say this now for anyone listening, especially on the online stream, the city administrator proposes essentially what is a direction for where they think we should head based on what they're hearing from all of the mayor then puts together a proposal of the direction that the mayor thinks we should be going with the budget, what the mayor thinks the budget should look like to be able to run those bureaus in the way that, as the, the head of the executive branch of our city, the mayor gets to do.

601
01:04:56.036 --> 01:05:03.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And council, as the policy body, legislative body, representatives of the people, put together the final budget that's adopted.

602
01:05:03.983 --> 01:05:16.315
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, Councilor Smith, so we take essentially those suggestions, hopes, and dreams from the city administrator and then the mayor, the city administrator in more of a general way, the mayor in a formal balanced budget.

603
01:05:17.134 --> 01:05:24.751
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we run that through the lens of what we are hearing from our constituents, the values of the city are, and make changes as needed.

604
01:05:24.847 --> 01:05:35.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So it is 3 steps, but it's 3 important steps to make sure that we're hearing what bureaus are telling the mayor that they need and what the mayor believes he needs to run the city in the way that he's hoping to.

605
01:05:35.623 --> 01:05:35.719
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

606
01:05:36.155 --> 01:05:39.641
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we ultimately need to make that decision on behalf of our constituents.

607
01:05:41.304 --> 01:05:43.500
<v Candace Avalos>One more quick comment to say agree.

608
01:05:43.646 --> 01:05:52.632
<v Candace Avalos>And also, I think then we should be talking— I know when we were on charter, we talked a lot about this, this, um, date by which the mayor needs to provide the budget.

609
01:05:52.697 --> 01:05:55.407
<v Candace Avalos>There was a lot of discussion around that, and we ended up on what it is.

610
01:05:56.231 --> 01:05:59.025
<v Candace Avalos>It's still a little too late, you know, uh, in my opinion.

611
01:05:59.623 --> 01:06:09.498
<v Candace Avalos>Um, so I think we should also discuss what we need to fix in code or maybe charter to make the process start earlier in the future.

612
01:06:09.836 --> 01:06:23.771
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that for me is a question to the city administrator and the bureaus about what pace could they start to, you know, at what point in the fiscal year makes sense for them to start projecting forward.

613
01:06:23.882 --> 01:06:30.246
<v Candace Avalos>Because I get that you can't, you know, at some point you got to wait until part of the fiscal year passes to be able to understand what the next one will look like.

614
01:06:30.630 --> 01:06:34.724
<v Candace Avalos>But I imagine that it can be much sooner than May, much sooner maybe even than February.

615
01:06:34.773 --> 01:06:49.451
<v Candace Avalos>So I think So I just want to flag that I'll bring this up as someone that's on the Finance Committee, but I'm just processing out loud what I'm seeing are things on our to-do list to fix for the next process while we kind of get through this, you know, patch year.

616
01:06:50.125 --> 01:06:50.318
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Thanks.

617
01:06:50.784 --> 01:06:51.923
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can I respond quickly?

618
01:06:51.987 --> 01:07:11.047
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think I want to use that prompt of that question as an ask to all councilors and to the Deputy City Administrators is that capturing what worked and what didn't in this year's process will be fundamental for the Finance Committee to make a better set of recommendations moving forward.

619
01:07:11.481 --> 01:07:12.878
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so, yes, I agree.

620
01:07:12.942 --> 01:07:17.405
<v Eric Zimmerman>In fact, I think I've said I think that the mayor's budget executive release can be earlier.

621
01:07:17.838 --> 01:07:19.652
<v Eric Zimmerman>We did that last year at the county.

622
01:07:20.407 --> 01:07:26.606
<v Eric Zimmerman>There are flexibilities built in, but there are going to be a number of learnings that work for any number of us up here.

623
01:07:26.670 --> 01:07:26.798
<v Robin Johnson>Thank you.

624
01:07:27.347 --> 01:07:28.818
<v Eric Zimmerman>Please capture those, right?

625
01:07:29.063 --> 01:07:40.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>When you're having a point of deep rub and frustration, if we can't fix it in the moment this year, this spring, capture that so that we can reflect on it in the summer as we prepare for next year's process.

626
01:07:42.476 --> 01:07:43.286
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

627
01:07:44.190 --> 01:07:44.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

628
01:07:46.940 --> 01:07:54.737
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to say that I'm glad that the administrator did not give us a list of recommendations adding up to the total deficit.

629
01:07:54.849 --> 01:08:00.079
<v Steve Novick>He gave us a list of recommendations that added up to a chunk of the total deficit and then basically told us the rest is up to you.

630
01:08:00.849 --> 01:08:08.722
<v Steve Novick>And I think that if he'd given us a list of recommendations that added up to the total deficit, it would have been easy for us to be lazy and say, all right, I guess that's what we'll do.

631
01:08:09.364 --> 01:08:10.181
<v Steve Novick>He didn't do that.

632
01:08:10.342 --> 01:08:23.152
<v Steve Novick>So that to me means that we all have to, as committees and individually, dig further into the budgets of the individual bureaus, hear information about what various cut scenarios might look like.

633
01:08:23.216 --> 01:08:37.957
<v Steve Novick>For example, if you were going to cut the police, and I'm not saying we're going to do that, like, What would a scenario look like that took most of the cuts from patrol as opposed to a scenario that took most of the cuts from specialty units and the crime reduction plan?

634
01:08:38.701 --> 01:08:55.886
<v Steve Novick>So it's unfortunate that we have so little time, but I think that the fact that we weren't given anything approaching a balanced budget puts the onus on us and gives us, you know, maybe feel like we have more power to dig in and shape the budget ourselves and tell the mayor.

635
01:08:55.934 --> 01:08:56.095
<v Donna Cohen>Thank you.

636
01:08:56.404 --> 01:09:07.858
<v Steve Novick>What our priorities are, including, uh, Councilor Smith, um, tell— telling him your $28 million for, um, for more beds comes at the expense of X, Y, and Z.

637
01:09:08.422 --> 01:09:21.037
<v Steve Novick>So I wish it wasn't so, um, compressed, but compared to what I saw 10 years ago when it was, to a great extent, we looked at our own bureau's budget, then waited for the mayor to come out with his budget, and then we reacted.

638
01:09:21.872 --> 01:09:25.792
<v Steve Novick>I think it's better for us to have a process we're all sort of forced to be more deeply engaged.

639
01:09:26.572 --> 01:09:28.538
<v Steve Novick>That's my cheery way of looking at things this morning.

640
01:09:29.199 --> 01:09:32.573
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for that positive spin, Councilor Novick.

641
01:09:34.436 --> 01:09:40.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Councilor Kanal, we are going to come back to you after we get to councilors who haven't spoken yet.

642
01:09:40.751 --> 01:09:41.692
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane.

643
01:09:42.908 --> 01:09:43.751
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for this work.

644
01:09:43.815 --> 01:09:45.438
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's helpful to see this laid out.

645
01:09:45.827 --> 01:09:53.710
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I agree with Councilor Clark that Um, it is important that we know in the different committees how to engage in this process.

646
01:09:53.855 --> 01:10:01.618
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, um, just want to share that in governance, we're doing some of that work, trying to figure out a way to standardize it.

647
01:10:01.764 --> 01:10:12.917
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, um, my vice chair, Vice Chair Ryan, is working directly with, uh, Councilor Zimmerman to come up with a plan to make sure that every committee is engaged.

648
01:10:14.684 --> 01:10:22.720
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I— it also just makes me think about how we can be thinking about our comms around the budget, how we can do some of that all together.

649
01:10:23.250 --> 01:10:33.114
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, just like how Councilor Zimmerman talked about putting stuff in our newsletter, maybe we can lean on our comms team to think about ways that we are making sure we're pushing out some of the same stuff for engagement.

650
01:10:33.837 --> 01:10:54.766
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And for me, um, I think this is for the mayor and Mr. Jordan, something that would be helpful for me, someone that is new to this— I mean, we're all new to being up here— is as we're looking at past budgets, uh, to see specifically what the add packages from the last 2 budgets have been and supplemental budgets.

651
01:10:54.831 --> 01:10:58.378
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that would be helpful for me to see kind of things that were added in there.

652
01:11:01.926 --> 01:11:04.002
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see the city administrator making notes.

653
01:11:04.051 --> 01:11:05.442
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hopefully it's about that ask.

654
01:11:07.193 --> 01:11:09.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, go right ahead.

655
01:11:09.453 --> 01:11:15.953
<v Sameer Kanal>Just one question on the ordinance, which is about the emergency clause.

656
01:11:17.576 --> 01:11:23.666
<v Sameer Kanal>And I recognize the need to— this is a process question exclusively.

657
01:11:24.484 --> 01:11:30.886
<v Sameer Kanal>I recognize the need to give as much community information as possible.

658
01:11:31.453 --> 01:11:44.373
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there a a practical effect to waiting, um, and doing this through a regular ordinance that would prevent us from, from doing it that way, um, in terms of the implementation portion of it?

659
01:11:44.421 --> 01:11:53.323
<v Sameer Kanal>That there's, uh, providing notice I know we'd be able to do, but the, the implementation side of it on the ordinance specifically, which is May 21st and June 11th.

660
01:11:55.105 --> 01:11:59.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is enough time for this to go into effect without the emergency clause.

661
01:11:59.626 --> 01:12:02.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Given that the dates that it affects are not until May.

662
01:12:03.494 --> 01:12:08.393
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The reason that this came with an emergency clause, frankly, was so that these 2 items could move together.

663
01:12:08.552 --> 01:12:24.626
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Otherwise, we would be passing the resolution that changed dates without the ordinance— or the resolution that listed dates without the ordinance that actually makes the changes to allow us to post those dates and those timelines.

664
01:12:25.315 --> 01:12:34.320
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we would have a little bit of a gray period there of saying, yes, we will be meeting at these times, but we haven't actually approved ourselves meeting at those times yet.

665
01:12:34.801 --> 01:12:43.359
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So this was brought as an emergency ordinance to provide clarity and make sure that there wasn't any confusion for the public around whether that was actually going to happen or not.

666
01:12:44.000 --> 01:12:44.832
<v Sameer Kanal>I understand that.

667
01:12:45.105 --> 01:12:45.810
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with it.

668
01:12:45.987 --> 01:12:51.466
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't personally think that that constitutes an emergency, but thank you for, for answering the question.

669
01:12:54.498 --> 01:12:56.231
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

670
01:12:56.503 --> 01:13:06.626
<v Loretta Smith>I wanted to say to Chairman Zimmerman, I think that the, uh, budget process is a year-round process, and because we came in half the year, we're trying to get up to speed at to where we are.

671
01:13:07.171 --> 01:13:15.095
<v Loretta Smith>But I want to make something really clear, um, the administrator's budget and the mayor's budget and their thinking should be aligned.

672
01:13:15.512 --> 01:13:18.545
<v Loretta Smith>They should not be dropping 2 separate budgets.

673
01:13:18.609 --> 01:13:19.252
<v Loretta Smith>They are one.

674
01:13:19.926 --> 01:13:23.350
<v Loretta Smith>They're, they're on the executive side, so they can't have it both ways.

675
01:13:23.847 --> 01:13:31.640
<v Loretta Smith>They can't test the waters with the administrator's budget and see if people push back and then wait for the mayor's budget.

676
01:13:31.881 --> 01:13:33.152
<v Loretta Smith>They have to make a decision.

677
01:13:33.649 --> 01:13:43.725
<v Loretta Smith>They have to be deliberate, and they have to be intentional in wanting to give us the information that we need to be able to make a, uh, to do a balanced budget.

678
01:13:43.773 --> 01:13:48.488
<v Loretta Smith>So In the future, I would like— I mean, I don't know if you have to put this in code.

679
01:13:49.867 --> 01:13:52.015
<v Loretta Smith>I don't want us to look at 2 different budgets.

680
01:13:52.511 --> 01:13:57.208
<v Loretta Smith>When the administrator drops something, it is on behalf of the mayor, not of himself.

681
01:13:57.658 --> 01:14:08.110
<v Loretta Smith>And so I think this is where, you know, Chairwoman Avalos is talking about, that it's— we're in a state of confusion right now.

682
01:14:08.463 --> 01:14:20.961
<v Loretta Smith>And because there are so few people who have done a local budget before, that That's why we're having all these questions, and we'll, we'll get into our rhythm once June— July 1st starts.

683
01:14:21.314 --> 01:14:30.300
<v Loretta Smith>But I think we need to understand that this is not going to just be after in '26, that we're going to begin the process of the budget all over again starting July 1st.

684
01:14:30.364 --> 01:14:31.724
<v Loretta Smith>It's a whole year process.

685
01:14:31.805 --> 01:14:36.238
<v Loretta Smith>So I'd like to see that implemented so we're not, you know, behind the 8-ball next year.

686
01:14:37.099 --> 01:14:37.440
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

687
01:14:40.793 --> 01:14:41.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Morillo.

688
01:14:42.654 --> 01:14:43.730
<v Angelita Morillo>I'll keep this pretty brief.

689
01:14:43.987 --> 01:14:56.698
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I think, uh, first of all, for City Administrator Michael Jordan, um, you have very clearly laid out that this was a recommendation and not a mandate in the media, in the emails you sent us, in the documents.

690
01:14:56.746 --> 01:15:01.144
<v Angelita Morillo>So I never took it as you overstepping on your power personally.

691
01:15:01.497 --> 01:15:05.317
<v Angelita Morillo>It was very clear that we as council have the budget authority.

692
01:15:05.670 --> 01:15:09.872
<v Angelita Morillo>We have it frankly, over the mayor and over whatever recommendations you make as well.

693
01:15:09.936 --> 01:15:17.813
<v Angelita Morillo>So I felt that that was very clear, and I appreciated how you gave this to us as a recommendation and as something that we could build on.

694
01:15:17.860 --> 01:15:22.769
<v Angelita Morillo>So I don't want you to get beat up too badly here on that because I think you were very clear.

695
01:15:24.180 --> 01:15:33.212
<v Angelita Morillo>And I do think I want to emphasize what Councilor Smith has brought up before, which is that having some line item details for all of the bureaus is going to be really helpful.

696
01:15:33.340 --> 01:15:45.524
<v Angelita Morillo>So like, for example, with the police bureau, if we're talking about patrols or robot dogs or cars or whatever, I need to see line items of every bureau of what those expenses are.

697
01:15:45.604 --> 01:15:54.738
<v Angelita Morillo>Personnel patrol versus other staff, stuff like that is going to be absolutely critical because we're going to have to look at every single little bit of the budget.

698
01:15:55.412 --> 01:16:01.175
<v Angelita Morillo>And so having that line item out in as much detail as possible in an Excel sheet would be fantastic.

699
01:16:01.336 --> 01:16:04.140
<v Angelita Morillo>And I say that as someone who deeply, profoundly hates Excel.

700
01:16:04.957 --> 01:16:05.902
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you.

701
01:16:06.158 --> 01:16:12.167
<v Angelita Morillo>That was just the last feedback I wanted moving forward, but I appreciate you guys working with all of us as we're making adjustments together.

702
01:16:13.322 --> 01:16:15.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, would you like to close this out?

703
01:16:15.676 --> 01:16:16.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, thanks.

704
01:16:16.478 --> 01:16:19.265
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have a full page of notes from these questions.

705
01:16:19.378 --> 01:16:21.269
<v Eric Zimmerman>So colleagues, I have— I've taken those.

706
01:16:21.318 --> 01:16:23.560
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know other Finance Committee members have, so I appreciate it.

707
01:16:23.704 --> 01:16:30.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think in 5 years' time, this item will come up and we won't even have comments on it because we'll be so used to the regular order of business.

708
01:16:30.479 --> 01:16:31.524
<v Eric Zimmerman>So this has been very helpful.

709
01:16:32.659 --> 01:16:36.600
<v Eric Zimmerman>I do want to highlight, I'm looking at this as a positive calendar, right?

710
01:16:36.712 --> 01:16:43.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it builds into our calendar the flexibility that we're going to need.

711
01:16:43.929 --> 01:16:53.278
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for any of us who've been through a budget before, there are days when you think you're going to have a 3-hour meeting and it turns into a 6, and there are days when you think you're going to have a 3-hour meeting and it turns into 20 minutes.

712
01:16:53.520 --> 01:16:54.552
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that is the nature of budgets.

713
01:16:54.601 --> 01:16:54.715
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

714
01:16:55.046 --> 01:16:57.487
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so we've laid out a bunch here.

715
01:16:57.712 --> 01:17:12.323
<v Eric Zimmerman>My hope was so that all councilors can clear their calendars at least to a minimum of what you see on this calendar, and you will be happy when Council President gives you time back on your calendar at some point versus how you'll feel if she says tomorrow you have to meet as a budget.

716
01:17:12.420 --> 01:17:15.229
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that, that's really the positive highlight.

717
01:17:15.278 --> 01:17:17.011
<v Eric Zimmerman>We wanted to carve out more time than we saw.

718
01:17:17.783 --> 01:17:19.917
<v Eric Zimmerman>Community has some time in here to reach us.

719
01:17:19.966 --> 01:17:20.158
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

720
01:17:20.483 --> 01:17:23.422
<v Eric Zimmerman>Committees are encouraged, uh, and there's more to come.

721
01:17:23.712 --> 01:17:35.625
<v Eric Zimmerman>But, um, I don't want to overcomplicate the calendar, but I did want to be transparent with all of you and also, um, so that the council president has all the tools she needs to lead us through this.

722
01:17:38.078 --> 01:17:39.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for all of that conversation.

723
01:17:40.109 --> 01:17:46.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And just highlighting a few things that you were told are coming Yes.

724
01:17:46.408 --> 01:17:50.050
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Still, details on each of these agenda items will be coming out.

725
01:17:51.867 --> 01:17:58.485
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we can add listening sessions to some of those work sessions, and we'll have details on that as we move forward.

726
01:17:59.286 --> 01:18:15.626
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we hope that you all will continue to have conversations in your own districts about this, and there will be guidance coming to each of you, um, for work in your committees about how to have budget conversations, um, in a way that complies with our local budget laws.

727
01:18:16.222 --> 01:18:30.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Additionally, uh, my office is having conversations with the executive branch about getting a budget analyst that we can all work with through this budget season so that we have somebody to help us work through all of those details that we're given.

728
01:18:31.002 --> 01:18:33.454
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So more to come on all of those pieces.

729
01:18:34.735 --> 01:18:36.706
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Rebecca, could you call the roll?

730
01:18:46.238 --> 01:18:46.253
<v Travis Ruball>Aye.

731
01:18:46.784 --> 01:18:46.833
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

732
01:18:49.201 --> 01:18:49.234
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

733
01:18:50.103 --> 01:18:50.118
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

734
01:18:51.471 --> 01:18:52.310
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam President.

735
01:18:52.600 --> 01:18:53.533
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Finance Committee.

736
01:18:53.823 --> 01:18:55.953
<v Sameer Kanal>Appreciate the red line or blue line form on this.

737
01:18:56.307 --> 01:19:01.358
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I did want to make one comment, which is I want to make sure that we're not applying the same broad brush to all bureaus or committees.

738
01:19:01.891 --> 01:19:09.557
<v Sameer Kanal>On the subject of engagement with bureaus, there's both broad idea in terms of different bureaus do different work but also the general fund versus non-general fund aspect of it.

739
01:19:10.198 --> 01:19:13.166
<v Sameer Kanal>And on the subject of committees, the work of all committees is important.

740
01:19:13.405 --> 01:19:21.470
<v Sameer Kanal>However, the urgency is not necessarily the same, and the urgency of the work on some, including the Community and Public Safety Committee, is different from some of the other committees.

741
01:19:21.904 --> 01:19:28.350
<v Sameer Kanal>In other words, it's harder to push back legislation that's not directly budget related to July because some of that legislation would affect things now.

742
01:19:28.878 --> 01:19:39.671
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also want to note that I share Councilor Murillo's views about the need for community engagement to be prioritized and commit to the public to continuing to hold town halls, my own as well as Civic Life's, to continue to hear from Portlanders.

743
01:19:39.948 --> 01:19:40.324
<v Sameer Kanal>I vote yes.

744
01:19:41.872 --> 01:19:42.163
<v Dan Ryan>Ryan?

745
01:19:42.439 --> 01:19:42.487
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

746
01:19:42.600 --> 01:19:44.101
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Koyama Lane?

747
01:19:44.603 --> 01:19:44.650
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

748
01:19:45.296 --> 01:19:45.750
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

749
01:19:46.217 --> 01:19:46.265
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

750
01:19:46.880 --> 01:19:47.252
<v Steve Novick>Novick?

751
01:19:47.671 --> 01:19:47.720
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

752
01:19:48.252 --> 01:19:48.720
<v Olivia Clark>Clark?

753
01:19:49.060 --> 01:19:49.173
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

754
01:19:49.609 --> 01:19:49.916
<v Mitch Green>Green?

755
01:19:50.417 --> 01:19:50.578
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

756
01:19:51.222 --> 01:19:51.578
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

757
01:19:52.126 --> 01:19:52.158
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

758
01:19:52.770 --> 01:19:53.384
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

759
01:19:53.722 --> 01:19:53.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

760
01:19:54.850 --> 01:19:58.261
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the resolution is adopted as amended with 12 aye votes.

761
01:20:00.247 --> 01:20:07.177
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item Aye.

762
01:20:07.679 --> 01:20:07.760
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

763
01:20:08.551 --> 01:20:14.819
<v Sameer Kanal>I just want to daylight— I'm uncomfortable with the use of the emergency clause here.

764
01:20:14.963 --> 01:20:20.831
<v Sameer Kanal>I think a preferable process in the future would be to hold the resolution till the second reading, daylight it here so that the timing lines up.

765
01:20:21.332 --> 01:20:24.225
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I'd ask my colleagues to please be more sparing on this in the future.

766
01:20:24.878 --> 01:20:37.993
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, as this is the first time it's come up, I'm not going to stand against this specific document today on that basis, but I just want to be very transparent that I may in the future, and I also want to commit to working with all of you and supporting you so that we don't overuse emergent— overuse emergency ordinance clauses.

767
01:20:38.510 --> 01:20:38.930
<v Dan Ryan>I vote aye.

768
01:20:39.546 --> 01:20:39.773
<v Dan Ryan>Ryan?

769
01:20:40.113 --> 01:20:40.243
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

770
01:20:40.923 --> 01:20:41.475
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

771
01:20:41.815 --> 01:20:41.863
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

772
01:20:42.545 --> 01:20:42.805
<v Rebecca Dobert>Maria?

773
01:20:44.020 --> 01:20:44.100
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

774
01:20:45.073 --> 01:20:45.345
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

775
01:20:45.555 --> 01:20:45.765
<v Eric Zimmerman>Sorry.

776
01:20:46.103 --> 01:20:46.118
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Aye.

777
01:20:47.649 --> 01:20:48.131
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

778
01:20:48.453 --> 01:20:48.551
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

779
01:20:49.018 --> 01:20:49.307
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

780
01:20:49.662 --> 01:20:49.838
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

781
01:20:50.161 --> 01:20:50.676
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

782
01:20:50.934 --> 01:20:50.966
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

783
01:20:51.432 --> 01:20:51.965
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

784
01:20:52.319 --> 01:20:52.431
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

785
01:20:53.043 --> 01:20:54.975
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the ordinance has passed with 12 aye votes.

786
01:20:56.386 --> 01:20:57.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

787
01:20:58.310 --> 01:21:02.573
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, the next item on our agenda is an appointment item.

788
01:21:02.653 --> 01:21:04.863
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you call that agenda item please?

789
01:21:05.778 --> 01:21:13.550
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 7, appoint Anna Allen and Laura Suarez to the Steering and Oversight Committee for the Homelessness Response System Intergovernmental Agreement.

790
01:21:14.414 --> 01:21:19.975
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, generally, as we've discussed previously, appointments will go through the committee process first.

791
01:21:20.038 --> 01:21:21.497
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Governance has been having a robust Yes.

792
01:21:21.561 --> 01:21:25.779
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've had a robust conversation about whether those go through policy committees or the governance committee.

793
01:21:26.356 --> 01:21:29.387
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This item is coming to you not having been through a committee.

794
01:21:29.981 --> 01:21:47.912
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is part of that tale of us not having our committees up and running until a month ago, and we have had a request to move this forward as quickly as possible because the Steering and Oversight Committee is waiting for these 2 members of the public to thank you.

795
01:21:49.082 --> 01:21:52.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So it has bypassed our normal process.

796
01:21:52.676 --> 01:22:04.145
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just want to be clear that it is my intent that moving forward that not happen again and that things do run through committees and that we make sure we get those requests in time for them to run through committees moving forward.

797
01:22:04.850 --> 01:22:19.798
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we wanted to respect the time of these individuals who are here today and make sure that we moved forward with the need um, that the Steering and Oversight Committee has to have their appointments as quickly as possible.

798
01:22:20.685 --> 01:22:26.409
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, I will turn it over to the mayor to introduce your appointment recommendations.

799
01:22:28.064 --> 01:22:28.793
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Madam Chair.

800
01:22:28.875 --> 01:22:31.534
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, council colleagues, for this opportunity.

801
01:22:32.460 --> 01:22:41.175
<v Keith Wilson>I'm honored to appoint 2 eminently qualified individuals to serve with me and Councilor Zimmerman on the Steering and Oversight Committee for the Homeless Response.

802
01:22:41.260 --> 01:22:41.613
<v Dan Ryan>System.

803
01:22:42.818 --> 01:22:48.649
<v Keith Wilson>Chair Vega Peterson and I appreciate all who applied for these positions and asked to serve their communities.

804
01:22:49.387 --> 01:22:57.886
<v Keith Wilson>Anna and Laura not only meet the qualifications for these positions but have also spent their careers serving the public and gaining valuable expertise in their respective fields.

805
01:22:59.025 --> 01:23:05.515
<v Keith Wilson>We are grateful you both are willing to serve and share your insights at this important governance table for our city and for our county.

806
01:23:06.657 --> 01:23:17.899
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Council President, Council Vice President, And commissioners, for your consideration of these appointments, I now invite Skylar Brock-Knapp and Jillian Shone to share a bit about these candidates.

807
01:23:18.042 --> 01:23:18.876
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

808
01:23:19.261 --> 01:23:23.028
<v Unidentified speaker>So I just— I'll start by just, uh, with a big thank you.

809
01:23:23.123 --> 01:23:24.967
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, could you introduce yourself?

810
01:23:25.273 --> 01:23:25.737
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

811
01:23:25.898 --> 01:23:26.090
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

812
01:23:26.458 --> 01:23:27.934
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, my name is Jillian Shone.

813
01:23:28.014 --> 01:23:35.420
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the director of the Homelessness Response System, and I just want to start out with a big thank you because we identified these individuals Yes.

814
01:23:35.773 --> 01:23:40.279
<v Unidentified speaker>In the last quarter of 2024, and they have been patiently waiting for this day.

815
01:23:40.984 --> 01:23:55.016
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, my feeling is that delay was largely because of the previous City Council wanting to make sure that we had all of the transition-related items on the council agenda and done by December 31st, which of course was something I fully supported in my previous role.

816
01:23:55.434 --> 01:24:07.573
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm just grateful to be here today that we are getting this done so that they can join the second SOC meeting of the year, which is next week, and rounding out the perspectives we need on that body.

817
01:24:07.621 --> 01:24:11.163
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you again, Council President, and your staff for getting this on the agenda.

818
01:24:12.333 --> 01:24:12.798
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Thank you.

819
01:24:13.119 --> 01:24:15.636
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>For the record, Skylar Brocker-Knapp, Director, Portland Solutions.

820
01:24:16.181 --> 01:24:25.979
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Madam President and councilors, Anna Allen, who is here with us today, has been nominated by the mayor to serve as the Steering and Oversight Committee Supportive Housing Services taxpayer representative.

821
01:24:26.426 --> 01:24:33.390
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Anna completed an interest application and participated in a series of interviews with myself myself and Robin Johnson of the Homelessness Response System.

822
01:24:34.371 --> 01:24:35.849
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>It is my pleasure to introduce you to her.

823
01:24:36.619 --> 01:24:43.077
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Anna is a resident of Troutdale and is the Columbia River Intertribal Fish Commission's first Regional Government Affairs Director.

824
01:24:43.542 --> 01:24:55.877
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Anna brings more than a decade of experience working collaboratively across tribal governments, local public agencies, and community-based organizations to create equitable pathways for community members to help shape programs, policy decisions, and funding priorities.

825
01:24:55.926 --> 01:24:56.118
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

826
01:24:56.938 --> 01:25:04.548
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>For many of her young years, her family was forced to become adept in navigating government-funded social services, correctional facilities, and shelter systems.

827
01:25:05.063 --> 01:25:10.377
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>We are honored to recommend Anna Allen for your consideration today and pleased that she's willing to serve.

828
01:25:11.068 --> 01:25:11.309
<v Rebecca Dobert>Anna.

829
01:25:12.448 --> 01:25:16.752
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning, Council, Mayor, Council President, and Councilors.

830
01:25:16.944 --> 01:25:25.935
<v Unidentified speaker>Again, my name is Anna Allen, and I'm here— I'm a member of the Shoshone Bannock Tribes, and I currently serve as the Regional Government Affairs Director for CRITFIC.

831
01:25:26.659 --> 01:25:37.354
<v Unidentified speaker>I know some of you have recently been engaging with CRITFIC on a number of policy issues, and I'm really honored to be here for consideration and appointment to the SOC.

832
01:25:37.644 --> 01:25:41.786
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, my background, as Sky mentioned, I think is nuanced.

833
01:25:41.850 --> 01:25:53.119
<v Unidentified speaker>It comes from the nonprofit, from the public sector, from even corporate sector and tribal government sectors, and it runs across a gamut of political issues and policy issues.

834
01:25:53.296 --> 01:26:20.238
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, during my time as the Equity Inclusion Director with the City of Bend, I worked closely with the Human Rights and Equity Commission on their time, place, and manner ordinance and ensuring that there were voices from currently and previously houseless individuals that were included in that process, and that highly difficult policy that there were very differing opinions on in community and across politicians and jurisdictions in Central Oregon.

835
01:26:21.350 --> 01:26:30.860
<v Unidentified speaker>I also have worked regionally and locally within the public sectors as well, but also really building off of my background in nonprofit work and as a youth advocate.

836
01:26:32.726 --> 01:26:45.438
<v Unidentified speaker>But really the path that brought me to be in front of you today starts long before my professional career that you have read in my resume or that Sky has shared a little bit about.

837
01:26:46.127 --> 01:27:04.266
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, you know, I was recently watching the movie, the Disney movie Outside In, with my 4-year-old daughter, and I was reflecting as she was giggling about, you know, when Sadness, that character, touches a core memory and it turns sad, and those— thinking about that joy, those joyful core memories as well.

838
01:27:04.395 --> 01:27:07.654
<v Unidentified speaker>And I I was reflecting on my own core memories at her age and as a child.

839
01:27:08.827 --> 01:27:22.844
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that's, you know, when asked why I want to serve in this position as a thought partner with you all and with the county as well, I think about that and I think about how grateful I am that my daughter will not have those same core memories.

840
01:27:22.956 --> 01:27:29.779
<v Unidentified speaker>And I want that for others that are currently and have been and will live outside within the city of Portland and Multnomah County.

841
01:27:30.005 --> 01:27:31.771
<v Unidentified speaker>Those experiences, you know, I want that joy.

842
01:27:31.868 --> 01:27:40.377
<v Unidentified speaker>I want that comfort of knowing that, that you're disrupting an ongoing cycle that might be happening for yourself or with your family and that there is a different path forward.

843
01:27:40.537 --> 01:27:48.212
<v Unidentified speaker>And I watched my mother navigate those systems, you know, in services that, that the city and county provides and funds.

844
01:27:48.485 --> 01:27:52.902
<v Unidentified speaker>And from that, she became a pillar of the community and has served.

845
01:27:53.368 --> 01:28:03.853
<v Unidentified speaker>I was reflecting You know, after she was incarcerated and returned to us, her children, her 3 children navigating those systems with us alongside of her.

846
01:28:05.104 --> 01:28:15.958
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, she— I was thinking about all the numerous committees that she served on, and there were, I believe, 8 city committees over her years once she was able to change the outcome of her future.

847
01:28:16.729 --> 01:28:28.375
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, she served on the Public Involvement Advisory Committee, the Human Rights Commission, the Community Police Relations Committee, and among many others that I won't name, with the City of Portland throughout her career.

848
01:28:29.161 --> 01:28:29.514
<v Rebecca Dobert>And there was—.

849
01:28:29.898 --> 01:28:34.963
<v Unidentified speaker>I will tell you, there was an expectation when she left in 2018.

850
01:28:35.011 --> 01:28:59.547
<v Unidentified speaker>She left us, and she was very clear with me that I was— there was an expectation from her to utilize the grit that she had given me and that I had acquired along the way, along with my professional and lived experience to continue that work, to serve in positions like this, and to utilize all of those skills and information that I've gathered over the years to benefit others.

851
01:28:59.661 --> 01:29:05.572
<v Unidentified speaker>And so with that clear expectation, you know, I, I have served in many capacities.

852
01:29:05.667 --> 01:29:14.703
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand the nuances of serving in these really highly difficult and political roles as a thought partner to the voting members on the committee.

853
01:29:15.737 --> 01:29:24.831
<v Unidentified speaker>But I will, I will stop there and just, and just share gratitude and appreciation and hope to move forward in this process and looking forward to the next meeting as well.

854
01:29:25.185 --> 01:29:25.426
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

855
01:29:25.490 --> 01:29:26.118
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

856
01:29:27.761 --> 01:29:29.162
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

857
01:29:30.643 --> 01:29:34.262
<v Unidentified speaker>So next up, also excited to have Laura Suarez before you today.

858
01:29:34.503 --> 01:29:36.965
<v Unidentified speaker>She is filling our behavioral health position.

859
01:29:37.864 --> 01:29:41.725
<v Unidentified speaker>Laura currently is a clinical social worker with a drug and alcohol certification.

860
01:29:42.511 --> 01:29:44.454
<v Unidentified speaker>Currently employed by OHSU.

861
01:29:45.001 --> 01:29:57.025
<v Unidentified speaker>She is also the program manager for OHSU's Transitional Care Program, which focuses on both in-reach and outreach activities on houseless and housing insecure patients.

862
01:29:57.507 --> 01:30:08.650
<v Unidentified speaker>She is very well aware and shares our problem-solving approach to what is an incredibly complex population to serve and how important it is that our health and housing systems be integrated.

863
01:30:09.309 --> 01:30:13.787
<v Unidentified speaker>Her professional expertise will be an invaluable contribution to the Steering and Oversight Committee.

864
01:30:13.853 --> 01:30:13.997
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

865
01:30:14.109 --> 01:30:19.119
<v Unidentified speaker>And with that, I will hand it over to Laura to say a few words, who's joining us online today.

866
01:30:19.510 --> 01:30:20.510
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, thank you so much.

867
01:30:20.510 --> 01:30:23.390
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm so sorry I couldn't be there with you guys in person today.

868
01:30:23.689 --> 01:30:27.340
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Mayor Wilson, Council President, and city councilors.

869
01:30:27.609 --> 01:30:29.689
<v Angelita Morillo>Again, for the record, my name is Laura Suarez.

870
01:30:29.789 --> 01:30:31.319
<v Angelita Morillo>I use she/her pronouns.

871
01:30:31.510 --> 01:30:38.850
<v Angelita Morillo>I am a licensed clinical social worker here in the state of Oregon and the state of Washington, and as stated, I also have a drug and alcohol certification too.

872
01:30:39.210 --> 01:30:44.149
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm currently employed here in Multnomah County as the Social Work Department Manager for the Division of Care Management at OHSU.

873
01:30:46.405 --> 01:30:48.394
<v Angelita Morillo>I reside in Washington County.

874
01:30:48.587 --> 01:30:53.074
<v Angelita Morillo>I've spent most of my career serving within the tri-county area.

875
01:30:53.619 --> 01:31:07.711
<v Angelita Morillo>As it was also stated, I also support and manage OHSU's transitional care teams, which are comprised of registered nurses and licensed clinical social workers who provide hospital in-reach and outreach to our houseless and housing insecure population.

876
01:31:08.304 --> 01:31:10.644
<v Angelita Morillo>That is also a team that I started on here at OHSU.

877
01:31:10.707 --> 01:31:16.189
<v Angelita Morillo>So it's a core, again, component of the work I've done, and I continue to support that work as a leader.

878
01:31:17.425 --> 01:31:19.574
<v Angelita Morillo>I Let's see, I'm excited.

879
01:31:19.622 --> 01:31:29.925
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm really excited to share my 10 years' worth of experience working within the tri-county area, serving marginalized and underserved patients with chronic psychosocial and medical needs.

880
01:31:30.439 --> 01:31:39.313
<v Angelita Morillo>My practice values include a collaborative, person-centered approach to case management and care coordination for mental health, substance use, and physical health across the continuum.

881
01:31:39.826 --> 01:31:44.864
<v Angelita Morillo>My professional interests include improving systems through programmatic and policy development aimed at health.

882
01:31:44.978 --> 01:31:47.096
<v Angelita Morillo>Equity and access and patient outcomes.

883
01:31:47.530 --> 01:32:02.944
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm really, really looking forward to sharing my professional experience and collaboration with the city and county and our key jurisdictional partners, including our neighboring counties, to find really meaningful solutions for our community through participation in the CO— in the SOC.

884
01:32:03.122 --> 01:32:05.369
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you all so much for having me.

885
01:32:05.996 --> 01:32:08.260
<v Angelita Morillo>I look forward to working together with you all.

886
01:32:08.323 --> 01:32:09.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

887
01:32:10.555 --> 01:32:11.405
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Madam President, thank you.

888
01:32:12.176 --> 01:32:19.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both so much for being here today, um, and thank you to Skyler and Jillian for helping to introduce the agenda item.

889
01:32:20.582 --> 01:32:24.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, do we have any public testimony signed up today?

890
01:32:25.650 --> 01:32:26.083
<v Rebecca Dobert>We do not.

891
01:32:27.175 --> 01:32:31.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, councilors, um, we are open for discussion.

892
01:32:31.088 --> 01:32:32.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, would you like to kick us off?

893
01:32:34.055 --> 01:32:36.158
<v Loretta Smith>President, thank you so much.

894
01:32:36.783 --> 01:32:42.462
<v Loretta Smith>I was really excited when I saw that Anna's name was on the list as an appointee, but Thank you.

895
01:32:43.056 --> 01:32:45.175
<v Loretta Smith>She's really someone who is a collaborator.

896
01:32:45.222 --> 01:32:48.545
<v Loretta Smith>She understands community, and that is in her background.

897
01:32:48.592 --> 01:33:03.807
<v Loretta Smith>I first met her when she was working for NEA, and then I had the great opportunity to see how she moved in a professional sense when she got hired by Deborah Kafori to be one of her, um, her senior policy advisors.

898
01:33:04.466 --> 01:33:13.007
<v Loretta Smith>And so she really understands, um, people and how to work collaboratively, and I appreciate that about her.

899
01:33:13.088 --> 01:33:23.752
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm really excited to see that you're going to be in this new role and watching you grow from nonprofit into, into the chair's office and understanding about housing and homelessness.

900
01:33:24.154 --> 01:33:28.395
<v Loretta Smith>So I wish you well, and I thank you for even considering doing this.

901
01:33:28.652 --> 01:33:29.213
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

902
01:33:30.323 --> 01:33:31.976
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

903
01:33:32.329 --> 01:33:33.614
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Madam President.

904
01:33:34.113 --> 01:33:34.561
<v Dan Ryan>Good morning.

905
01:33:34.658 --> 01:33:44.769
<v Dan Ryan>And first of all, I think both of the people who are willing to serve in this capacity seem like outstanding human beings with great professional backgrounds and, more importantly, life experience.

906
01:33:45.411 --> 01:33:49.070
<v Dan Ryan>I'll probably be directing some of my questions to you, Jillian, and you, Sky.

907
01:33:49.744 --> 01:34:04.493
<v Dan Ryan>As you know, as you both know, the rest of you might not, we had a pretty robust conversation about this, and I was, I'd say, the leading advocate for wanting the oversight system to have more independence than it previously has.

908
01:34:05.168 --> 01:34:12.230
<v Dan Ryan>I was a part of a brief little window when there was some independence, which allowed us to actually pass the policy to have Built for Zero work for us.

909
01:34:12.471 --> 01:34:18.667
<v Dan Ryan>That was being resisted upon by the culture at the joint office and by the houseless industry.

910
01:34:19.358 --> 01:34:23.065
<v Dan Ryan>And so my point is, I think everyone can agree that we have a lot of work to do.

911
01:34:24.012 --> 01:34:35.743
<v Dan Ryan>I think hopefully everyone can agree that we've had challenges being I think we've been in denial about some of the factors that have led to the humanitarian crisis that exists.

912
01:34:36.481 --> 01:34:42.018
<v Dan Ryan>So knowing that you both have backgrounds in behavioral health does please me immensely.

913
01:34:42.644 --> 01:34:50.537
<v Dan Ryan>The dialogue was about having people that weren't connected to the actual system because most of our checks and balances were quite limited.

914
01:34:51.228 --> 01:34:57.163
<v Dan Ryan>The accountability structure was mostly with people that were getting money from the SHS tax.

915
01:34:57.627 --> 01:35:03.493
<v Dan Ryan>And so we were having— in my opinion, we were having trouble seeing those checks and balances that are often necessary.

916
01:35:04.054 --> 01:35:13.155
<v Dan Ryan>I, I would often say in private meetings, and now I get to say in this one, I just wish we could have a fraction of the accountability we have for police oversight for the houseless system that we're building.

917
01:35:14.134 --> 01:35:27.296
<v Dan Ryan>And so I think what I want to know is that, are both of you willing to be those independent thinkers that will challenge the status which I think continues to need to be challenged, and feel comfortable in that role as advocates?

918
01:35:29.645 --> 01:35:30.636
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm happy to respond.

919
01:35:31.581 --> 01:35:35.957
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor, for, for really naming that and also for posing that question.

920
01:35:37.141 --> 01:35:41.533
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think, you know, time will tell, and I can prove that to you over time.

921
01:35:41.710 --> 01:35:46.534
<v Unidentified speaker>But I'm very— I will say for myself, I feel very comfortable in navigating those conversations.

922
01:35:47.854 --> 01:35:56.444
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a way to disagree with respect and not making it personal and making it about the mission, about the policy decision, and being able to come back together afterwards.

923
01:35:56.588 --> 01:36:12.628
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's something that I've had a lot of changemakers throughout my life, in my career, and really just heavyweights in many different facets of life when it comes to policy, but also community engagement, equity work, dismantling institutions.

924
01:36:12.742 --> 01:36:20.063
<v Unidentified speaker>Institutional racism within a system like the county when I was there, and within nonprofits and NGOs as well.

925
01:36:20.144 --> 01:36:21.573
<v Unidentified speaker>I work for 4 tribal governments.

926
01:36:21.989 --> 01:36:23.130
<v Unidentified speaker>I work on behalf of them.

927
01:36:23.644 --> 01:36:33.679
<v Unidentified speaker>There are often really difficult— and those policy issues reach from a federal, state, and regional level, and they're very nuanced and difficult conversations to have.

928
01:36:33.760 --> 01:36:37.966
<v Unidentified speaker>There have been tears shed, there have been hugs after, and also not hugs after.

929
01:36:38.664 --> 01:36:38.841
<v Rebecca Dobert>Right.

930
01:36:38.907 --> 01:36:40.926
<v Unidentified speaker>That's part of the work.

931
01:36:41.152 --> 01:36:42.654
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm used to that.

932
01:36:42.783 --> 01:36:56.326
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, I've spent over a decade of my career engaging in those conversations throughout different levels of bureaucracy, and I'm always willing to lean in from a space of respect and understanding and a willingness to learn and grow as well.

933
01:36:57.520 --> 01:36:59.595
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm— I would say I'm comfortable in that.

934
01:37:03.597 --> 01:37:05.845
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm happy to I can speak up and chime in as well.

935
01:37:06.149 --> 01:37:08.541
<v Dan Ryan>One moment, if I could just do a follow-up, Laura, with—.

936
01:37:08.653 --> 01:37:08.765
<v Unidentified speaker>On a—.

937
01:37:08.845 --> 01:37:12.070
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry, I didn't have my light on.

938
01:37:12.648 --> 01:37:14.108
<v Dan Ryan>I really appreciate that response.

939
01:37:14.509 --> 01:37:16.851
<v Dan Ryan>It was refreshing to listen to.

940
01:37:17.076 --> 01:37:22.291
<v Dan Ryan>My next question, maybe this then could be— you could think about this as to Laura.

941
01:37:22.851 --> 01:37:42.015
<v Dan Ryan>A lot of my— what I have witnessed since being thrown into the deep end to work on this back in 2013, 2020, but the end of 2020, was that we were using a document that— a plan, the Housing First plan, which has a lot of merits, but it was also written over a decade ago.

942
01:37:42.496 --> 01:37:43.890
<v Dan Ryan>I think it's much more than that now.

943
01:37:44.724 --> 01:37:48.667
<v Dan Ryan>And it was pre the new meth, it was pre-fentanyl.

944
01:37:49.212 --> 01:38:01.845
<v Dan Ryan>And I was always frustrated that we weren't adapting to that reality on the ground here in Portland, Oregon, especially what we were dealing with after Measure 110 passed and the, the open-air drug markets became just more obvious to everybody.

945
01:38:02.367 --> 01:38:16.990
<v Dan Ryan>And so you will all— I think what I experienced was your average voter, your average taxpayer was much more, um, they were noticing that and they were just asking us to please respond to it, and they were frustrated that wasn't happening.

946
01:38:17.329 --> 01:38:21.427
<v Dan Ryan>So I had to listen to small businesses that would say they had trouble.

947
01:38:22.296 --> 01:38:26.135
<v Dan Ryan>They were compassionate, but they still wanted to open up their storefronts, and they were losing business and such.

948
01:38:27.050 --> 01:38:42.030
<v Dan Ryan>And I hope that you will listen to those small businesses that are compassionate, to the taxpayer that is paying this, that does care, but would like to know that we're actually measuring results and that we're in one year's time making some progress.

949
01:38:42.545 --> 01:38:54.483
<v Dan Ryan>So my point, I guess, is, are you comfortable then also talking to that sector Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

950
01:38:54.710 --> 01:38:56.704
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate that question very much.

951
01:38:57.689 --> 01:39:01.578
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, what I will say is my brother is a small business owner in Portland.

952
01:39:01.899 --> 01:39:12.404
<v Unidentified speaker>My older brother is, and my younger brother is also an artist in Portland and Vancouver area, and he is a vendor of many small businesses as well with his artwork.

953
01:39:13.485 --> 01:39:18.279
<v Unidentified speaker>My neighbors, my friends, my families, my family members, many of them are small business owners.

954
01:39:18.936 --> 01:39:36.154
<v Unidentified speaker>And I, throughout my career doing community engagement work as well, a lot of time was spent with those businesses that, you know, I live in Troutdale and even doing construction land use work, right, on the culverts, those replacement projects out there, those have real impacts on the businesses around them.

955
01:39:36.570 --> 01:39:41.320
<v Unidentified speaker>How do you engage with them and identify what the core issues are and what their needs and desires are.

956
01:39:41.400 --> 01:39:58.484
<v Unidentified speaker>This isn't just about the needs of the folks who are currently sleeping and living outside, but it's also about the needs of our business owners and about others who are impacted by this crisis every day, whether that be professionally, personally, seeing it in their neighborhoods, walking their children to the park, right?

957
01:39:58.886 --> 01:39:59.962
<v Unidentified speaker>I hear all of that.

958
01:40:00.027 --> 01:40:01.439
<v Unidentified speaker>I know all of that and I feel it.

959
01:40:02.018 --> 01:40:05.787
<v Unidentified speaker>And how to identify those workarounds and address those needs as well.

960
01:40:05.884 --> 01:40:07.454
<v Unidentified speaker>Because again, it's very nuanced.

961
01:40:07.502 --> 01:40:10.099
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not just about certain needs of a certain population.

962
01:40:10.148 --> 01:40:14.298
<v Unidentified speaker>It's really identi— it's a very— there's a lot of intersectionality to this issue.

963
01:40:14.458 --> 01:40:18.641
<v Unidentified speaker>And I, and I promise you, I intend to bring that perspective to this work moving forward.

964
01:40:19.106 --> 01:40:19.587
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

965
01:40:19.811 --> 01:40:24.811
<v Dan Ryan>Um, you're already bringing that grit from East County in this dialogue, and I appreciate that.

966
01:40:24.891 --> 01:40:26.127
<v Dan Ryan>Your mother would be super proud.

967
01:40:26.462 --> 01:40:27.119
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

968
01:40:27.199 --> 01:40:31.735
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, sorry, uh, Laura, I, I wanted to make sure I finished that conversation.

969
01:40:31.832 --> 01:40:33.658
<v Dan Ryan>If you'd like to answer any of my questions.

970
01:40:33.868 --> 01:40:43.506
<v Angelita Morillo>I am sorry, guys, I'm not sure what to do with being on the virtual platform.

971
01:40:43.636 --> 01:40:48.487
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm— thank you so much for the question, Councilor Wyrin, and I'm happy to sort of chime in and give my 2 cents.

972
01:40:48.615 --> 01:40:51.940
<v Angelita Morillo>I, you know, this is certainly going to be a new experience for me.

973
01:40:52.229 --> 01:41:08.331
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I think what I lean into is not only my position as a community member, You know, I live and I work in this, in this community, and we're talking about our community members as well, right?

974
01:41:08.458 --> 01:41:26.997
<v Angelita Morillo>Now, the folks that have been impacted by this experience, not only the experience of houselessness, but as myself as an individual in this community wanting to be able to feel like we can safely engage in our community and have access to, you know, support our local businesses and everyone feeling safe.

975
01:41:27.462 --> 01:41:31.854
<v Angelita Morillo>And comfortable, and I do, as Anna mentioned, this is a very nuanced.

976
01:41:33.136 --> 01:41:47.100
<v Angelita Morillo>It's a very nuanced challenge that we're facing, and I I do think that it needs to be looked at and addressed from multiple perspectives with multiple considerations, and not just at you know focusing on one individual, one community aspect of it.

977
01:41:47.356 --> 01:41:52.743
<v Angelita Morillo>So I'm really I I am really looking forward to engaging in a really thoughtful exploration.

978
01:41:53.256 --> 01:42:07.729
<v Angelita Morillo>Of identifying all the perspectives that we need to consider, all of the gaps, and how do we come together and really, really reunify our community in a way that fits for everyone and addresses the core of the challenges that we're facing.

979
01:42:08.371 --> 01:42:30.619
<v Angelita Morillo>So I'm just really looking forward to being able to lend my perspective where I can, to be a listening ear, to bring my expertise and to collaborate and really explore how we can kind of Thank you, Laura, and thank you both.

980
01:42:30.619 --> 01:42:40.539
<v Dan Ryan>I, um, I really hope to witness the independent voice you'll bring, the courage to sometimes go against the status quo, people that we know well.

981
01:42:40.619 --> 01:42:48.060
<v Dan Ryan>Um, it's, uh, in this job I always find it more challenging to have some pushback to those that you've always usually been aligned with.

982
01:42:48.060 --> 01:42:48.199
<v Loretta Smith>I think that's what we're here for.

983
01:42:48.417 --> 01:42:54.055
<v Dan Ryan>And that's called being courageous to do the work that's needed for us to move forward on this humanitarian crisis.

984
01:42:54.440 --> 01:42:57.412
<v Dan Ryan>And so I wish you both well, and thank you.

985
01:43:00.220 --> 01:43:00.703
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

986
01:43:01.850 --> 01:43:02.042
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

987
01:43:02.188 --> 01:43:07.773
<v Eric Zimmerman>My first question for Jillian, can you clarify again which positions each of these nominations is filling?

988
01:43:07.820 --> 01:43:11.599
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know we've— in that new agreement, there are like specific positions.

989
01:43:12.197 --> 01:43:12.907
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can you talk about that again?

990
01:43:13.247 --> 01:43:21.975
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, Laura is filling the behavioral health slot, and Anna is filling the SHS taxpayer slot, so that completes the membership.

991
01:43:22.619 --> 01:43:24.472
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks.

992
01:43:24.779 --> 01:43:33.376
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I agree, both of your records— and Anna, I know you, and, and, and Laura, I don't— but your records speak for themselves.

993
01:43:34.157 --> 01:43:42.452
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I'm a little bit cautious about these nominations, and I am cautious from a perspective that we're nominating somebody from Washington County.

994
01:43:43.788 --> 01:43:46.725
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, And I didn't hear that that was a Portlander.

995
01:43:47.015 --> 01:43:52.282
<v Eric Zimmerman>There are a few people in our district who are Washington County residents, but I'm cautious about that.

996
01:43:52.956 --> 01:44:08.836
<v Eric Zimmerman>And with respect to all that it took to keep the IGA alive last year and incorporating the taxpayer, Anna, I'm a little cautious that I'm not sure that negotiation intended for somebody who worked so closely with the Joint Office previously in your roles.

997
01:44:09.172 --> 01:44:11.935
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that is that is my, my concern.

998
01:44:11.984 --> 01:44:19.307
<v Eric Zimmerman>And as a person who sits on the SOC, I'm looking forward to, I think, the independence that Councilor Ryan is talking about.

999
01:44:20.256 --> 01:44:23.372
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it was a lot of work to keep the IGA together.

1000
01:44:24.769 --> 01:44:31.931
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think the last 7 days has put that challenge in even greater risk than I thought it was, and this time it's from the county side.

1001
01:44:32.783 --> 01:44:57.112
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and so I'm going to vote to support this nomination, and I, I could choose to just not say these things in the— to the record, but I, I am working from a perspective that I think that the SHS dollars, the IGA, in spirit are the right thing to have, and that we continually are at risk of them falling apart and not meeting the public's expectations for them.

1002
01:44:57.795 --> 01:45:01.190
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so, um, I'm looking forward to working with you, Anna.

1003
01:45:01.239 --> 01:45:01.386
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1004
01:45:01.551 --> 01:45:04.493
<v Eric Zimmerman>And with you, Laura, I think that we have a lot of work in front of us.

1005
01:45:04.962 --> 01:45:06.434
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm looking forward to the perspective.

1006
01:45:07.032 --> 01:45:19.560
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for 2 people who have been on the county side, I think trying to see it from a non-JOHS staff perspective, a non-county policy perspective, is a challenge I also hold.

1007
01:45:20.126 --> 01:45:27.728
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I think the mayor has the right to make the nominations that he does in his role, and I'll vote to approve those today.

1008
01:45:27.809 --> 01:45:32.668
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I I think it's important that we talk about what makes this awkward in terms of this system.

1009
01:45:32.765 --> 01:45:36.377
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm feeling some awkwardness, so I'm putting it out there, and I'm looking forward to getting over it.

1010
01:45:37.114 --> 01:45:37.820
<v Eric Zimmerman>All right, thanks.

1011
01:45:38.783 --> 01:45:39.667
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Thank you, Councilor.

1012
01:45:39.891 --> 01:45:41.801
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>I'm just going to quickly just respond.

1013
01:45:41.978 --> 01:45:45.573
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>I really appreciate that, Councilor Zimmerman and Councilor Ryan too, on the independent spirit.

1014
01:45:46.311 --> 01:45:53.662
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Had the unique opportunity to engage with the previous council and the previous mayor on these specific appointments and what they were looking for.

1015
01:45:54.079 --> 01:46:06.996
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>So I remember those discussions really well, um, and with the new mayor and trying to determine whether that these appointments are still the right fit, um, whether these are still, um, the individuals that the chair and the new mayor wanted to bring forward.

1016
01:46:07.412 --> 01:46:17.153
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Um, I just want to say personally, I've had extensive conversations with Anna and other folks who had applied for this position, and they were incredible conversations, um, very nuanced.

1017
01:46:17.362 --> 01:46:22.640
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Um, and I'm really excited personally, um, for all the elements that Anna's bringing to this position.

1018
01:46:23.056 --> 01:46:32.286
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Um, I definitely remember, um, some of the caution and some of the intention behind a lot of these appointments, um, and these spaces on this committee.

1019
01:46:32.365 --> 01:46:41.755
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>And I think Anna will, um, make you all very proud in how she, um, addresses the many, many nuanced pieces of the Steering and Oversight Committee under this system.

1020
01:46:42.139 --> 01:46:43.516
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Um, so I just wanted to offer that as well.

1021
01:46:43.564 --> 01:46:43.676
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thanks.

1022
01:46:43.886 --> 01:46:46.704
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's an important endorsement from Skylar, so thank you.

1023
01:46:47.170 --> 01:46:49.685
<v Unidentified speaker>Council President, if I may also just offer a response.

1024
01:46:49.750 --> 01:46:50.823
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1025
01:46:51.529 --> 01:46:57.646
<v Unidentified speaker>It's good to see you, and congratulations on your successful campaign, and to all of our new electeds who have taken seat.

1026
01:46:58.400 --> 01:47:01.628
<v Unidentified speaker>I hear you, and don't feel awkward.

1027
01:47:02.511 --> 01:47:05.851
<v Unidentified speaker>We can have those conversations, Councilor, and that's perfectly fine.

1028
01:47:06.269 --> 01:47:08.774
<v Unidentified speaker>And quite frankly, I agree with you.

1029
01:47:08.917 --> 01:47:09.640
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand it.

1030
01:47:10.122 --> 01:47:35.203
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, now that I am working outside of Multnomah County and public systems within a tribal government, not only does that create some separation, and, you know, I had to work under those same public meetings laws, those same public ethics laws, and now I sit in a different capacity and I'm able to utilize those experiences professionally to how I advocate in spaces like this today.

1031
01:47:35.266 --> 01:47:40.485
<v Unidentified speaker>Because it's not always that you're going to agree on things, especially working with the City of Bend, I will say.

1032
01:47:40.903 --> 01:47:52.463
<v Unidentified speaker>I didn't necessarily agree personally with some of the decisions being made, but I was bound by those laws to be able to work unbiasedly across different sectors to gain community input.

1033
01:47:52.528 --> 01:48:10.623
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it's important to flag or just highlight that my role as a senior policy advisor and project manager under Chair Kefauver with Multnomah County and then moving later on into government relations as the tribal affairs advisor, my role was— I was not— my policy portfolio did not include houselessness.

1034
01:48:10.976 --> 01:48:30.502
<v Unidentified speaker>At the beginning of my career in 2015, I was the community engagement advisor, and really my role was to ensure that community input, diverse community input, was being authentically and thoughtfully gathered to inform policy decisions of Chair Cafuri and others within the county.

1035
01:48:30.646 --> 01:48:32.845
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I have not worked for the Joint Office.

1036
01:48:32.926 --> 01:48:34.707
<v Unidentified speaker>I did not work closely with the Joint Office.

1037
01:48:35.301 --> 01:48:42.585
<v Unidentified speaker>My job was really focused on what is the policy issue that we're working on, who are the voices that we need to hear from, and I'm going to go get them.

1038
01:48:43.162 --> 01:48:49.162
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that— just wanted to add that clarification and hope that that lends to, you know, ease your concerns.

1039
01:48:49.259 --> 01:48:59.606
<v Unidentified speaker>But also, I welcome any discussions in the future if you feel like there are moments where you want to clarify my perspective or again think through anything that from those meetings in the future.

1040
01:49:01.064 --> 01:49:01.867
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really appreciate that.

1041
01:49:01.947 --> 01:49:03.774
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for that walkthrough a little bit.

1042
01:49:03.934 --> 01:49:07.042
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, uh, as always, looking forward to working with you.

1043
01:49:07.395 --> 01:49:07.539
<v Dan Ryan>I have—.

1044
01:49:07.877 --> 01:49:09.735
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've appreciated that in the past as well.

1045
01:49:10.664 --> 01:49:12.188
<v Robin Johnson>Madam President, if I may.

1046
01:49:12.828 --> 01:49:13.085
<v Dan Ryan>Go ahead.

1047
01:49:13.164 --> 01:49:14.976
<v Robin Johnson>For the record, my name is Robin Johnson.

1048
01:49:15.073 --> 01:49:17.860
<v Robin Johnson>I'm a policy advisor with the Homelessness Response System team.

1049
01:49:18.278 --> 01:49:19.192
<v Robin Johnson>Happy to be here today.

1050
01:49:19.256 --> 01:49:26.194
<v Robin Johnson>Happy to, um, have Laura and Anna, um, ready to cross the finish line on this process of both the city and the county.

1051
01:49:26.644 --> 01:49:31.152
<v Robin Johnson>I just wanted to bring 2 things into the, uh, into the discussion for clarification.

1052
01:49:31.826 --> 01:49:42.774
<v Robin Johnson>One, the behavioral health seat had a requirement that the person who filled the role did not receive contracting funds from either the city or the county.

1053
01:49:43.802 --> 01:50:05.856
<v Robin Johnson>And so to find a person that, um, lived within the city of Portland who was a behavioral health expert that did not contract with the largest behavioral health provider uh, in our region, um, was pretty— was, um, was a pretty deep, uh, haystack to find the needle in, or to find the brightest shining star that we could.

1054
01:50:06.338 --> 01:50:11.216
<v Robin Johnson>And so I wanted to bring that part, um, into the conversation for the information of the councilors.

1055
01:50:11.730 --> 01:50:20.444
<v Robin Johnson>Additionally, for the SHS taxpayer seat, the person was, um, required to live outside the city of Portland.

1056
01:50:20.797 --> 01:50:28.564
<v Robin Johnson>And so I just wanted to just so that all folks, um, pardon me, all councilors were, um, aware of those 2 pieces.

1057
01:50:28.774 --> 01:50:31.042
<v Robin Johnson>So thank you so much for allowing me to share that.

1058
01:50:32.182 --> 01:50:33.819
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for sharing that with us.

1059
01:50:33.949 --> 01:50:41.934
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had also noted that both of the, um, nominees lived outside of the City of Portland, so it's helpful to understand some of the background there.

1060
01:50:44.069 --> 01:50:45.735
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, I see you back in the queue.

1061
01:50:47.869 --> 01:50:54.279
<v Dan Ryan>Well, actually, Robin, I appreciate you saying that, and I do know there were others that also met that definition.

1062
01:50:54.569 --> 01:50:55.742
<v Dan Ryan>I helped recruit one.

1063
01:50:56.176 --> 01:51:04.015
<v Dan Ryan>Not attached to them picking those, but please, for the record, it must be stated that there were at least— I know of one other that did make that qualification.

1064
01:51:04.594 --> 01:51:05.591
<v Dan Ryan>Um, so thank you.

1065
01:51:05.654 --> 01:51:06.811
<v Dan Ryan>Just want to make sure we heard that.

1066
01:51:07.341 --> 01:51:08.161
<v Robin Johnson>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1067
01:51:08.225 --> 01:51:09.238
<v Robin Johnson>There were exactly 2.

1068
01:51:10.458 --> 01:51:11.840
<v Dan Ryan>I must have recruited the other one then.

1069
01:51:11.921 --> 01:51:12.739
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh yeah, great.

1070
01:51:12.804 --> 01:51:14.009
<v Robin Johnson>That was exactly right.

1071
01:51:15.921 --> 01:51:26.844
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, um, so first, as someone who sat on both sides of the appointment to community committees, uh, in here in this room, I just want to say thank you for going through this.

1072
01:51:27.324 --> 01:51:31.131
<v Sameer Kanal>And, uh, it, it is a little awkward, but you're— you both seem great.

1073
01:51:31.180 --> 01:51:32.064
<v Sameer Kanal>I really appreciate it.

1074
01:51:32.159 --> 01:51:40.078
<v Sameer Kanal>I do want to make the point that often the people who have been part of a system, uh, aren't able to be constructively critical of it while they're inside it.

1075
01:51:40.913 --> 01:51:46.613
<v Sameer Kanal>Given the either written or unspoken inability of employees or, or to speak on in that critical way.

1076
01:51:47.015 --> 01:51:54.032
<v Sameer Kanal>What people who've been part of the system can do is build their knowledge, and then when they are outside of it, then take that constructively critical eye.

1077
01:51:54.225 --> 01:51:57.420
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that applies to Lauren in particular, to Anna as well.

1078
01:51:57.934 --> 01:51:59.652
<v Sameer Kanal>And that constructively critical eye is vital.

1079
01:52:00.005 --> 01:52:05.577
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll agree with my colleagues, Councilors Ryan and Zimmerman, as it relates to accountability on the dollars we spend, because they are profound.

1080
01:52:05.738 --> 01:52:08.814
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll go a step further than Councilor Ryan and say that we need more than a fraction.

1081
01:52:09.231 --> 01:52:13.304
<v Sameer Kanal>We need more accountability here than we see for police, and, uh, I believe that you both can do that.

1082
01:52:13.351 --> 01:52:13.929
<v Sameer Kanal>So thank you.

1083
01:52:15.420 --> 01:52:17.792
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, councilors.

1084
01:52:18.064 --> 01:52:25.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is no one else in the queue for discussion, so Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

1085
01:52:25.823 --> 01:52:35.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is a vote to accept the report, which means to, um, appoint these nominees from the mayor to the Steering and Oversight Committee.

1086
01:52:36.104 --> 01:52:40.262
<v Rebecca Dobert>Council President, prior to the roll, we need a motion to accept the report.

1087
01:52:40.342 --> 01:52:42.606
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize, you're right.

1088
01:52:43.248 --> 01:52:43.827
<v Mitch Green>So moved.

1089
01:52:44.436 --> 01:52:45.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1090
01:52:45.899 --> 01:52:47.391
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I see a second from Councilor Green.

1091
01:52:47.985 --> 01:52:48.306
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There we go.

1092
01:52:49.494 --> 01:52:49.849
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1093
01:52:51.341 --> 01:52:53.573
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sorry, Avalos?

1094
01:52:54.408 --> 01:52:54.440
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1095
01:52:55.693 --> 01:52:56.061
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1096
01:52:56.496 --> 01:52:57.185
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you guys for serving.

1097
01:52:57.684 --> 01:52:57.699
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1098
01:52:59.645 --> 01:52:59.677
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1099
01:53:00.954 --> 01:53:01.488
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you both.

1100
01:53:01.667 --> 01:53:01.698
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1101
01:53:03.056 --> 01:53:07.278
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, I will definitely vote yes in support of these 2 outstanding humans.

1102
01:53:07.341 --> 01:53:09.055
<v Dan Ryan>I really appreciate— I didn't think it was awkward either.

1103
01:53:09.121 --> 01:53:14.641
<v Dan Ryan>I think we're called when we're of service and leadership to be courageous and to have such conversations.

1104
01:53:14.916 --> 01:53:17.201
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate that you demonstrated that, Anna.

1105
01:53:17.905 --> 01:53:23.908
<v Dan Ryan>I will offer caution that the mayor and the chair, I think, failed to meet some of the spirit that was needed to improve this system.

1106
01:53:24.632 --> 01:53:35.698
<v Dan Ryan>That said, I hear what you're talking— I hear what you both said today, and I'm leaving this vote with much more optimism, especially in the dialogue that we were able to have in person, Anna.

1107
01:53:35.796 --> 01:53:36.502
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you.

1108
01:53:37.466 --> 01:53:45.801
<v Dan Ryan>We didn't get a— I didn't have a chance to do a briefing with you, so thanks for allowing this to be such a transparent conversation that I think will help the system improve.

1109
01:53:46.154 --> 01:53:54.113
<v Dan Ryan>So I really appreciate that, and I hope that you'll— both of you will have the courage Um, to, um, challenge, um, the status quo.

1110
01:53:54.518 --> 01:53:57.090
<v Dan Ryan>Um, clearly it needs to be challenged because we must get better results.

1111
01:53:57.381 --> 01:53:57.752
<v Dan Ryan>I vote aye.

1112
01:53:59.076 --> 01:54:00.759
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for stepping up.

1113
01:54:00.840 --> 01:54:01.326
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I vote aye.

1114
01:54:02.005 --> 01:54:03.283
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you so much.

1115
01:54:03.429 --> 01:54:03.559
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1116
01:54:05.548 --> 01:54:06.649
<v Steve Novick>Thank you very, very much.

1117
01:54:07.847 --> 01:54:07.863
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1118
01:54:09.140 --> 01:54:14.408
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you both for stepping up, and I wanted to acknowledge your comments about your personal life and grit.

1119
01:54:14.715 --> 01:54:15.782
<v Olivia Clark>I relate to grit.

1120
01:54:16.104 --> 01:54:16.719
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

1121
01:54:17.912 --> 01:54:17.960
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1122
01:54:19.257 --> 01:54:19.563
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green.

1123
01:54:20.235 --> 01:54:21.213
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for your service.

1124
01:54:21.903 --> 01:54:21.952
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1125
01:54:22.784 --> 01:54:23.090
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman.

1126
01:54:23.442 --> 01:54:23.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1127
01:54:24.228 --> 01:54:24.693
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney.

1128
01:54:25.911 --> 01:54:25.958
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1129
01:54:26.551 --> 01:54:31.873
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And thank you both for all of your time here today, as well as the time we know you'll put into the work moving forward.

1130
01:54:32.819 --> 01:54:33.877
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the report—.

1131
01:54:33.957 --> 01:54:41.957
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, I just was going to note for everyone, just process, these 2 individuals are before the county board tomorrow, so we'll report back on that outcome.

1132
01:54:43.239 --> 01:54:43.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1133
01:54:44.444 --> 01:54:46.560
<v Rebecca Dobert>The report is accepted with 12 aye votes.

1134
01:54:46.706 --> 01:54:48.466
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1135
01:54:48.805 --> 01:54:49.708
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all.

1136
01:54:52.649 --> 01:54:58.046
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I will note that the next 3 agenda items are all emergency ordinances.

1137
01:55:00.109 --> 01:55:01.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see Councilor Knoll nodding.

1138
01:55:03.750 --> 01:55:17.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, we are going to move on to item 8 on our agenda, and we will likely take a We are a little bit behind time, but I think we have a few agenda items that we can make it up on so that we don't go too much over today.

1139
01:55:17.923 --> 01:55:20.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you read the agenda item, please?

1140
01:55:20.953 --> 01:55:31.983
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 8, authorize letter of agreement with Pro-Tech 17 to extend the expiration date of the current collective bargaining agreement from June 30th, 2025 to December 31st, 2025.

1141
01:55:32.416 --> 01:55:32.976
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1142
01:55:33.698 --> 01:55:44.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we have, uh, 2 members of our labor relations team, Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddie and Sarah Daly, here to share some information with us about this extension.

1143
01:55:46.289 --> 01:55:46.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1144
01:55:48.250 --> 01:55:48.896
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, good morning.

1145
01:55:49.235 --> 01:55:53.328
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning, Mayor, uh, Madam President, and Council.

1146
01:55:53.862 --> 01:56:03.988
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Anne-Marie Kevorkian-Maddie, uh, with the Bureau of Human Resources— wow, I don't know what happened there— Labor Relations, and I'm joined today by my colleague Sarah Daly.

1147
01:56:04.978 --> 01:56:14.832
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, we're here to present this item for your authorization to extend the term of the Pro-Tech 17 collective bargaining agreement through the end of this calendar year.

1148
01:56:16.252 --> 01:56:34.399
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, currently the Pro-Tech 17, uh, agreement expires June 30th, 2025, and we have a mutual agreement with the union, uh, or a mutual desire, I should say, with the union to extend the expiration through the end of this year, December 31st, 2025.

1149
01:56:35.090 --> 01:56:48.837
<v Unidentified speaker>That will allow the city and the union, uh, more time, uh, to evaluate, uh, a work in progress, which is a comprehensive class comp study that's evaluating all of the ProTech 17 classifications.

1150
01:56:49.609 --> 01:56:56.274
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, and then we will, uh, have ample time to prepare for the successor negotiations that will take place during this calendar year.

1151
01:56:57.557 --> 01:57:13.177
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, there are no other terms, uh, in the existing agreement that will change, um, but this letter of agreement will also provide for the standard, uh, cost of living allowance increase that occurs on July 1st, 2025.

1152
01:57:13.755 --> 01:57:22.559
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, that's already embedded into the, uh, proposed budget documents, uh, and so there's no additional cost beyond that as part of this agreement.

1153
01:57:23.555 --> 01:57:25.255
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, happy to take any questions that you might have.

1154
01:57:27.854 --> 01:57:28.515
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1155
01:57:28.643 --> 01:57:34.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I noticed that we have Rachel Whiteside from Pro-Tech online.

1156
01:57:36.100 --> 01:57:38.698
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Rachel, were you wanting to offer some comments today?

1157
01:57:41.567 --> 01:57:42.680
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, thank you, Madam President.

1158
01:57:42.793 --> 01:57:44.100
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't have any prepared comments.

1159
01:57:44.166 --> 01:57:47.990
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm just here in case there are any questions by council members that I can assist with.

1160
01:57:48.201 --> 01:57:53.270
<v Unidentified speaker>I can confirm that Through a vote of our membership, there is support for this extension.

1161
01:57:53.935 --> 01:57:57.502
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The classification study that's involved with this is long overdue.

1162
01:57:58.250 --> 01:58:03.707
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We haven't had a complete one for our membership in over 20 years, maybe closing in on 25 at this point.

1163
01:58:03.771 --> 01:58:12.396
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that's a real priority for our members, and I appreciate the collaborative thinking on the part of Labor Relations to extend our contract.

1164
01:58:13.935 --> 01:58:14.274
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1165
01:58:15.686 --> 01:58:21.363
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, are there, uh, any public— uh, is there any public testimony that folks have signed up for?

1166
01:58:22.296 --> 01:58:22.939
<v Rebecca Dobert>No one signed up.

1167
01:58:24.094 --> 01:58:28.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, councilors, any discussion before we look for a motion on this item?

1168
01:58:30.018 --> 01:58:30.810
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Knoll?

1169
01:58:33.511 --> 01:58:34.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane?

1170
01:58:35.612 --> 01:58:56.157
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was just going to say I love hearing, um, what Rachel just said, that there's collaboration between Human Resources and Seeing no other, uh, interest in discussion, is there a motion to move forward?

1171
01:58:56.479 --> 01:58:57.350
<v Olivia Clark>So moved.

1172
01:58:57.738 --> 01:58:58.238
<v Candace Avalos>Second.

1173
01:58:58.738 --> 01:59:02.546
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, with the motion and a second, Rebecca, could you call the roll?

1174
01:59:02.756 --> 01:59:10.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is a vote to, uh, this is a vote on an emergency ordinance to accept the letter of agreement.

1175
01:59:14.500 --> 01:59:14.740
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

1176
01:59:15.818 --> 01:59:15.962
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1177
01:59:16.782 --> 01:59:17.152
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1178
01:59:17.649 --> 01:59:17.810
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1179
01:59:18.244 --> 01:59:18.597
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

1180
01:59:19.337 --> 01:59:19.386
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1181
01:59:19.899 --> 01:59:20.574
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

1182
01:59:21.041 --> 01:59:21.090
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1183
01:59:22.729 --> 01:59:23.099
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan?

1184
01:59:23.292 --> 01:59:23.340
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1185
01:59:24.243 --> 01:59:24.792
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

1186
01:59:25.293 --> 01:59:25.470
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1187
01:59:25.939 --> 01:59:26.261
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo?

1188
01:59:26.747 --> 01:59:26.795
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1189
01:59:27.230 --> 01:59:27.554
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

1190
01:59:27.893 --> 01:59:28.037
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1191
01:59:28.279 --> 01:59:28.684
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

1192
01:59:29.038 --> 01:59:29.136
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1193
01:59:29.668 --> 01:59:29.958
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

1194
01:59:30.297 --> 01:59:30.475
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1195
01:59:30.863 --> 01:59:31.332
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1196
01:59:31.590 --> 01:59:31.605
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1197
01:59:32.220 --> 01:59:32.543
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

1198
01:59:33.291 --> 01:59:33.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1199
01:59:34.118 --> 01:59:35.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for being here, councilors.

1200
01:59:35.903 --> 01:59:37.835
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We just made up 5 of the minutes we were over.

1201
01:59:40.110 --> 01:59:54.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, without objection, I am going to suggest, because we do have a couple of long agenda items coming up after this, that we take a 5-minute break so that our staff can have a quick break if they need it, and that we meet back here at 11:30.

1202
01:59:55.100 --> 01:59:56.855
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, is there any objection to that?

1203
01:59:57.774 --> 01:59:57.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

1204
01:59:58.096 --> 01:59:58.484
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1205
02:07:26.474 --> 02:07:28.078
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome back, everybody.

1206
02:07:28.192 --> 02:07:31.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are going to reconvene our council meeting.

1207
02:07:31.677 --> 02:07:38.792
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are at agenda item 9, um, on the regular agenda.

1208
02:07:38.873 --> 02:07:41.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please call the agenda item?

1209
02:07:44.027 --> 02:07:47.279
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, I think we have—.

1210
02:07:47.310 --> 02:07:49.278
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sorry, Councilor Dunphy, it's good to see you over there.

1211
02:07:51.779 --> 02:07:56.649
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 9, pay settlement of Woodstock et al.

1212
02:07:56.859 --> 02:08:04.350
<v Rebecca Dobert>Civil rights and personal injury lawsuit in the sum of $938,328 involving the Portland Police Bureau.

1213
02:08:06.993 --> 02:08:19.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, we have Denise Vannier, Naomi Sheffield, We don't actually.

1214
02:08:23.645 --> 02:08:25.015
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Commander Dobson here.

1215
02:08:25.257 --> 02:08:29.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sorry, we had a 4th person listed who wasn't up there with you all.

1216
02:08:30.567 --> 02:08:31.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, perfect.

1217
02:08:31.067 --> 02:08:32.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Rose Radich is here online.

1218
02:08:32.599 --> 02:08:33.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wonderful.

1219
02:08:33.099 --> 02:08:33.551
<v Dan Ryan>So we have—.

1220
02:08:33.551 --> 02:08:34.421
<v Eric Zimmerman>Chief Dobson.

1221
02:08:35.163 --> 02:08:36.034
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Chief Dobson.

1222
02:08:36.131 --> 02:08:36.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry.

1223
02:08:37.197 --> 02:08:37.680
<v Craig Dobson>It's all right.

1224
02:08:38.945 --> 02:08:41.774
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My notes don't say chief.

1225
02:08:41.935 --> 02:08:43.293
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am really sorry.

1226
02:08:44.037 --> 02:08:49.368
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, We will be hearing from the 4 of them about this agenda item.

1227
02:08:49.546 --> 02:08:50.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1228
02:08:51.920 --> 02:08:54.092
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you, Madam President, members of the council.

1229
02:08:55.011 --> 02:08:56.122
<v Robert Taylor>My name is Donnie Vanier.

1230
02:08:56.203 --> 02:09:08.753
<v Robert Taylor>I'm a senior deputy city attorney, and with me here, as you noted, are Naomi Sheffield, chief deputy city attorney, Rose Radich, senior claims analyst, and Chief Craig Dobson of the Portland Police Bureau.

1231
02:09:09.815 --> 02:09:14.073
<v Robert Taylor>The matter before you today is a proposed settlement in the case of Woodstock et al.

1232
02:09:14.122 --> 02:09:14.717
<v Robert Taylor>Versus City of Portland.

1233
02:09:17.073 --> 02:09:22.725
<v Robert Taylor>U.S. District Court's case number 320 CV 01035 SI.

1234
02:09:23.902 --> 02:09:36.439
<v Robert Taylor>I will start by giving you an overview of the case and of the proposed settlement, after which Ms. Sheffield, Ms. Radich, Chief Dobson, and I will be happy to answer any questions that you might have.

1235
02:09:38.595 --> 02:09:46.738
<v Robert Taylor>This lawsuit began in June of 2020 when 6 individuals initially filed the initial complaint against the city.

1236
02:09:47.725 --> 02:09:57.185
<v Robert Taylor>Following several amendments which added and deleted several parties, the lawsuit eventually involved 9 individual plaintiffs and 1 corporate plaintiff.

1237
02:09:57.828 --> 02:10:03.963
<v Robert Taylor>The corporate plaintiff was Index Newspapers LLC, the owner of the Portland Mercury.

1238
02:10:05.555 --> 02:10:06.756
<v Robert Taylor>The lawsuit was complex.

1239
02:10:06.805 --> 02:10:10.898
<v Robert Taylor>It involved numerous overlapping claims by the several plaintiffs.

1240
02:10:11.622 --> 02:10:28.707
<v Robert Taylor>But in particular, the 9 individual plaintiffs were all journalists or legal observers challenging various aspects of the law enforcement response to the 2020 protests in the city that followed the murder of George Floyd by police in Minneapolis, Minnesota.

1241
02:10:29.813 --> 02:10:40.551
<v Robert Taylor>The plaintiffs alleged First Amendment violations, Fourth Amendment excessive force claims, and violations of Sections 8 and 26 of Article 1 of the Oregon Constitution.

1242
02:10:40.631 --> 02:10:40.886
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Mayor.

1243
02:10:42.087 --> 02:10:56.020
<v Robert Taylor>The lawsuit asked for damages for those alleged injuries, as well as prospective, so forward-looking, declaratory and injunctive relief seeking certain changes in policing practices.

1244
02:10:57.600 --> 02:11:08.534
<v Robert Taylor>In July of 2020, the plaintiffs in the lawsuit obtained a temporary restraining order related to the Portland Police Bureau's interactions with journalists and legal observers.

1245
02:11:09.380 --> 02:11:16.560
<v Robert Taylor>The city subsequently stipulated to a preliminary injunction in the case that remained in effect until 2023.

1246
02:11:18.956 --> 02:11:34.867
<v Robert Taylor>Then in March of 2023, the U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon— I'm sorry— ruled in favor of the city on a partial motion to dismiss, and the court dismissed as moot plaintiff's claims for declaratory and injunctive relief against the city.

1247
02:11:34.917 --> 02:11:37.408
<v Robert Taylor>So those forward-looking claims seeking policy changes.

1248
02:11:37.475 --> 02:11:37.704
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

1249
02:11:38.685 --> 02:11:45.637
<v Robert Taylor>It also dismissed plaintiffs' claims under the Oregon Constitution, and it dismissed the claims by Index Newspapers.

1250
02:11:46.793 --> 02:11:58.292
<v Robert Taylor>In doing so, the district court concluded that there was no realistic threat that conduct similar to that alleged in the complaint would occur again in the future.

1251
02:11:59.720 --> 02:12:10.180
<v Robert Taylor>As the court explained, quote, the state legislature has changed the law that allowed for arresting journalists and legal observers who refused to disperse from an unlawful assembly, end quote.

1252
02:12:11.073 --> 02:12:26.358
<v Robert Taylor>The court also noted, quote, as a result, PPB revised Directive 63510, which establishes how PPB responds to public order events, so that failure to comply with an order to disperse is not a crime and shall not be the basis for an arrest, end quote.

1253
02:12:28.466 --> 02:12:36.197
<v Robert Taylor>The court further noted, quote, the legislature has also limited PPB's ability to use tear gas for for crowd control purposes, end quote.

1254
02:12:37.641 --> 02:12:46.618
<v Robert Taylor>And the court concluded, quote, where intervening legislation has settled a controversy involving only injunctive or declaratory relief, the controversy has become moot.

1255
02:12:47.261 --> 02:12:51.435
<v Robert Taylor>The Oregon State Legislature has effectively settled this controversy, end quote.

1256
02:12:52.015 --> 02:12:54.728
<v Robert Taylor>And again, that was the ruling on the prospective relief.

1257
02:12:55.403 --> 02:13:14.757
<v Robert Taylor>So following that dismissal, what remained in the case were the 9 individual plaintiffs and specifically their retrospective claims for damages for the alleged injuries that occurred in 2020, plus those plaintiffs, those 9 individual plaintiffs' claims for attorney's fees and costs.

1258
02:13:14.805 --> 02:13:21.190
<v Robert Taylor>Because since this is a federal civil rights lawsuit, it does bring with it a right to recover attorney's fees.

1259
02:13:22.506 --> 02:13:34.689
<v Robert Taylor>So following further discovery in the case, the parties eventually agreed to mediation before Magistrate Judge Stacy Beckerman here at the District Court in Portland to attempt to, to resolve those remaining claims.

1260
02:13:34.689 --> 02:13:41.609
<v Robert Taylor>And through Judge Beckerman's mediation, the parties eventually reached the tentative agreement that is before you today.

1261
02:13:42.170 --> 02:13:56.579
<v Robert Taylor>That agreement would settle all the claims for damages by the 9 individual plaintiffs, plus all of those plaintiffs' claims for attorney's fees and costs, for a combined total of $938,327.64.

1262
02:13:56.579 --> 02:13:56.619
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you.

1263
02:14:01.530 --> 02:14:16.814
<v Robert Taylor>The city would also agree to make no material deletions to Portland Police Bureau Directive 63510, Section 11.2, through December 31st, 2028, unless intervening changes in state or federal law require amendment.

1264
02:14:17.121 --> 02:14:27.979
<v Robert Taylor>And that police bureau directive is that directive that the court cited in its order on this partial motion to dismiss that deals with how PPB addresses public order events.

1265
02:14:31.256 --> 02:14:37.015
<v Robert Taylor>So the City Attorney's Office, Risk Management, and the Portland Police Bureau recommend that the city agree to this settlement.

1266
02:14:37.819 --> 02:14:44.422
<v Robert Taylor>Um, and at this point, Ms. Sheffield, Ms. Radich, Chief Dobson, and I will be happy to answer any questions that you might have.

1267
02:14:44.873 --> 02:14:45.180
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you.

1268
02:14:46.953 --> 02:14:47.921
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1269
02:14:48.082 --> 02:14:54.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, before we move to our questions and discussion, I do believe that we have a few folks signed up for Public testimony.

1270
02:14:54.469 --> 02:14:59.662
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to provide them the opportunity to, uh, go ahead since we're already a little bit behind schedule.

1271
02:15:01.350 --> 02:15:05.052
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you invite up folks who have signed up for public testimony, please?

1272
02:15:05.873 --> 02:15:06.969
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hi.

1273
02:15:07.564 --> 02:15:14.442
<v Rebecca Dobert>First 2 testifiers, Kelly Simon and Athul Acharya, um, want to approach the table together.

1274
02:15:16.975 --> 02:15:18.155
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both for being here today.

1275
02:15:19.192 --> 02:15:19.448
<v Attul Acharya>Thank you.

1276
02:15:20.653 --> 02:15:26.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And can you please introduce yourself as you start?

1277
02:15:27.125 --> 02:15:27.445
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Will do.

1278
02:15:28.265 --> 02:15:33.292
<v Eric Zimmerman>Good morning, Council President Pirtle-Guiney, Vice President Koyama Lane, esteemed councilors.

1279
02:15:33.966 --> 02:15:37.226
<v Eric Zimmerman>It is great to see so many of you who represent this city.

1280
02:15:38.301 --> 02:15:39.395
<v Eric Zimmerman>My name is Kelly Simon.

1281
02:15:39.747 --> 02:15:43.248
<v Eric Zimmerman>I use she/her pronouns, and I am the legal director for the ACLU of Oregon.

1282
02:15:44.083 --> 02:15:52.212
<v Eric Zimmerman>The ACLU of Oregon is a nonpartisan, nonprofit membership organization With more than 43,000 members statewide.

1283
02:15:53.444 --> 02:16:00.997
<v Eric Zimmerman>We work in the courts, the state legislature, and with communities to defend and advance our democracy, civil liberties, and civil rights.

1284
02:16:02.949 --> 02:16:08.618
<v Eric Zimmerman>The ACLU of Oregon urges you to approve the mutually agreed-upon settlement terms before you today.

1285
02:16:09.422 --> 02:16:25.293
<v Eric Zimmerman>We believe it is in the best interest of the City of Portland to resolve these claims to avoid additional expense To the Portland taxpayers who have already borne too high a financial and emotional burden for police violence against protesters in this city.

1286
02:16:26.688 --> 02:16:49.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>The ACLU of Oregon would like to thank our clients, some of whom are here today, our cooperating attorneys at Brown Hagee and Borden and Public Accountability, the Reporters Committee for the Freedom of the Press, Legal Observers for the ACLU of Oregon, the National Lawyers Guild, and the over 60 news organizations that joined in an amicus brief in support of this case.

1287
02:16:50.504 --> 02:16:56.301
<v Eric Zimmerman>We were proud to fight with all of you to defend and advance the fundamental freedoms that protect our democracy.

1288
02:16:57.971 --> 02:17:09.011
<v Eric Zimmerman>In 1971, the United States Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black stated in the seminal case New York Times Company versus the United States that the press was to serve the governed not the governor's.

1289
02:17:10.165 --> 02:17:18.391
<v Eric Zimmerman>The freedom of the press protected by the First Amendment is critical to building a democracy in which the government is accountable to the people.

1290
02:17:19.691 --> 02:17:30.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>A free media ensures that the public always has a watchdog that can investigate and report on government wrongdoing, like the violent police backlash we saw and experienced in 2020.

1291
02:17:31.174 --> 02:17:40.842
<v Eric Zimmerman>A free press ensures we have access to the truth even when that truth does not serve the narratives that those who abuse power would prefer to tell us.

1292
02:17:42.156 --> 02:17:49.945
<v Eric Zimmerman>We continue to see that defending the truth and those who dare tell it is urgently vital to defending freedom for everyone.

1293
02:17:51.115 --> 02:18:09.461
<v Eric Zimmerman>It was a recording that exposed the violent murder of George Floyd, and it was recording after recording that followed that exposed the racialized and violent police backlash that confirm that these characteristics are the systemic and nationwide hallmarks of our policing institutions.

1294
02:18:10.136 --> 02:18:27.759
<v Eric Zimmerman>I urge you to interrogate the history of the city to understand why the Portland Police Bureau became the national face of the violent police backlash in 2020, and I hope that we can find ways to work together to bring a different kind of leadership and culture to the city of Portland, one that welcomes accountability and the truth.

1295
02:18:30.127 --> 02:18:30.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1296
02:18:32.717 --> 02:18:39.968
<v Attul Acharya>Good morning, uh, Council President Pirtle-Guiney, uh, Vice President Koyama Lane, and city councilors.

1297
02:18:40.325 --> 02:18:41.719
<v Attul Acharya>My name is Attul Acharya.

1298
02:18:42.093 --> 02:18:46.716
<v Attul Acharya>I am the executive director of Public Accountability, a nonprofit civil rights law firm.

1299
02:18:47.266 --> 02:18:52.909
<v Attul Acharya>We litigate civil rights cases around the country, but we're based right here in Portland, Oregon, and these plaintiffs are my clients.

1300
02:18:53.370 --> 02:18:53.809
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1301
02:18:53.809 --> 02:18:53.809
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

1302
02:18:53.809 --> 02:18:54.110
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Herbold.

1303
02:18:54.110 --> 02:18:54.110
<v Attul Acharya>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

1304
02:18:54.110 --> 02:18:54.110
<v Attul Acharya>Councilmember Herbold.

1305
02:18:54.110 --> 02:18:54.110
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

1306
02:18:54.110 --> 02:18:55.829
<v Attul Acharya>Journalism is not a crime.

1307
02:18:56.090 --> 02:19:03.129
<v Attul Acharya>It's a fundamental First Amendment right, and in fact, it's the only profession that's explicitly mentioned in the Bill of Rights.

1308
02:19:03.270 --> 02:19:05.829
<v Attul Acharya>Being a legal observer isn't a crime either.

1309
02:19:06.309 --> 02:19:11.909
<v Attul Acharya>Journalists and legal observers are a key part of accountability at protests for everyone.

1310
02:19:11.909 --> 02:19:14.709
<v Attul Acharya>They're a key part of maintaining public order.

1311
02:19:14.870 --> 02:19:20.769
<v Attul Acharya>They're what differentiates the public order of American democracy from the public order of say Tiananmen Square.

1312
02:19:22.194 --> 02:19:24.292
<v Attul Acharya>The Portland Police lost sight of that in 2020.

1313
02:19:24.742 --> 02:19:25.879
<v Attul Acharya>They targeted journalists.

1314
02:19:26.040 --> 02:19:38.022
<v Attul Acharya>They threatened, they beat, they gassed, they threw grenades at, they shot, and they arrested my clients even when there were no protesters around, when my clients were wearing big fluorescent press vests and carrying bulky professional cameras.

1315
02:19:38.840 --> 02:19:40.986
<v Attul Acharya>And they left real injuries that my clients still live with today.

1316
02:19:42.203 --> 02:19:43.950
<v Attul Acharya>A lot has changed since 2020.

1317
02:19:45.023 --> 02:19:53.793
<v Attul Acharya>The Portland Police Bureau has adopted new policies that recognize journalists' right to report on protests, And this agreement protects those new policies from change.

1318
02:19:54.746 --> 02:19:57.459
<v Attul Acharya>We have a new city council, a new mayor, a new form of government.

1319
02:19:58.012 --> 02:20:02.297
<v Attul Acharya>And so I urge you to approve the mutually agreed-upon settlement terms before you today.

1320
02:20:03.040 --> 02:20:04.042
<v Attul Acharya>It's a fair settlement.

1321
02:20:04.802 --> 02:20:12.000
<v Attul Acharya>It's a good deal for the city's taxpayers, and it'll help bring to a close a dark and painful chapter in this city's history.

1322
02:20:12.468 --> 02:20:12.773
<v Attul Acharya>Thank you.

1323
02:20:14.402 --> 02:20:15.577
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both.

1324
02:20:19.126 --> 02:20:20.775
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next is Mark Porras.

1325
02:20:21.433 --> 02:20:22.138
<v Rebecca Dobert>Mark is online.

1326
02:20:23.371 --> 02:20:24.895
<v Steve Novick>Good morning, can you hear me?

1327
02:20:26.015 --> 02:20:26.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can, yes.

1328
02:20:26.881 --> 02:20:27.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks for being here.

1329
02:20:28.324 --> 02:20:28.885
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, fantastic.

1330
02:20:28.965 --> 02:20:31.175
<v Steve Novick>Council, thank you for the opportunity to testify.

1331
02:20:32.090 --> 02:20:35.599
<v Steve Novick>My name is Mark Porras, I use he/him pronouns, and I'm with the group Portland Copwatch.

1332
02:20:36.513 --> 02:20:45.299
<v Steve Novick>We understand that the 2 legal observers and 7 journalists who are the last remaining plaintiffs in the Index Newspapers lawsuit lawsuit have come to an agreement to settle with the City of Portland.

1333
02:20:46.038 --> 02:20:54.529
<v Steve Novick>The agreement calls for this civil rights and personal injury lawsuit to end with compensation totaling $938,328, and we have no objection.

1334
02:20:55.122 --> 02:21:06.841
<v Steve Novick>We at Portland Cop Watch testify on settlements like this as a prompt for our elected officials to discuss the harms done when policies were either followed, indicating a design flaw, or disregarded, indicating that officers were at fault.

1335
02:21:07.708 --> 02:21:15.093
<v Steve Novick>Journalists and legal observers must be allowed to do their work observing and reporting on law enforcement actions during protests without being subject to police violence.

1336
02:21:15.832 --> 02:21:26.509
<v Steve Novick>The short version of this lawsuit is that PPB fired rubber bullets at, tear-gassed, pepper sprayed, threw flashbangs at, and battered legal observers and journalists who were covering protests following the murder of George Floyd.

1337
02:21:27.311 --> 02:21:38.054
<v Steve Novick>To quote from written testimony of one of the named plaintiffs, our work was met with violence and disregard, which should never happen in a society that values freedom of expression, the press, and the right to peaceful protest.

1338
02:21:38.711 --> 02:21:45.608
<v Steve Novick>The lack of information about this lawsuit and even the title of the ordinance seemed designed to let this nearly million-dollar settlement slide beneath the radar.

1339
02:21:46.313 --> 02:21:50.691
<v Steve Novick>The ordinance states that it settles a personal injury lawsuit brought by Woodstock et al.

1340
02:21:51.059 --> 02:22:01.099
<v Steve Novick>Relating to journalists and legal observers at the 2020 protests, and that it settles tort claims relating to journalists and legal observers at the 2020 protests involving the Portland Police Bureau.

1341
02:22:02.029 --> 02:22:09.308
<v Steve Novick>We've already pointed out that relating to and involving in this case mean that police tear-gassed, flashbanged, pepper sprayed, and otherwise used violence against the journalists and legal observers.

1342
02:22:10.546 --> 02:22:15.364
<v Steve Novick>We appreciate that this settlement is on the agenda, as all settlements over $50,000 are now required to be.

1343
02:22:15.846 --> 02:22:23.075
<v Steve Novick>However, we ask you again to ensure that you revert to the prior policy of putting all police misconduct settlements over $5,000 on the agenda.

1344
02:22:23.798 --> 02:22:30.063
<v Steve Novick>This settlement brings the total paid out by the city for police brutality during the 2020 protests alone to over $4 million.

1345
02:22:31.091 --> 02:22:33.998
<v Steve Novick>What have the city and police bureau learned from this nearly million-dollar settlement?

1346
02:22:34.158 --> 02:22:34.720
<v Steve Novick>What went wrong?

1347
02:22:34.786 --> 02:22:42.555
<v Steve Novick>What discipline was imposed on officers responsible for brutalizing journalists and legal observers, and what safeguards have been put in place to ensure that this doesn't happen again.

1348
02:22:43.388 --> 02:22:52.054
<v Steve Novick>This lawsuit covered abuses occurring on many different days in 2020, beginning with PPB's use of tear gas on June 2nd, 2020, also known as Tear Gas Tuesday.

1349
02:22:52.760 --> 02:22:57.605
<v Steve Novick>On that day, families who were peacefully gathered in Pioneer Square got exposed to chemical weapons by PPB.

1350
02:22:58.472 --> 02:23:08.115
<v Steve Novick>Nearly 4 years later, and after a stretch of time without significant protest activity, there were multiple days in May 2024 when the Police Bureau responded to protests at Portland State University.

1351
02:23:08.837 --> 02:23:17.404
<v Steve Novick>According to PPB's use of force dashboard, more force was used in May 2024 than any month prior, dating back to 2017 and up until today.

1352
02:23:17.966 --> 02:23:23.019
<v Steve Novick>It's a bit misleading because prior to this, PPB did not include force used during protests on that dashboard.

1353
02:23:23.645 --> 02:23:31.361
<v Steve Novick>Nonetheless, PPB's data showed that chemical incapacitants were used on 16 individuals that month, most of which was during the protests at PSU.

1354
02:23:33.850 --> 02:23:39.190
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next is Dan Handelman.

1355
02:23:39.190 --> 02:23:39.679
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dan is online.

1356
02:23:42.860 --> 02:23:44.719
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, uh, councilors, can you hear me?

1357
02:23:45.250 --> 02:23:47.049
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can.

1358
02:23:47.049 --> 02:23:48.290
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, great, thank you.

1359
02:23:48.290 --> 02:23:49.989
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, my name is— thank you, good morning.

1360
02:23:49.989 --> 02:23:51.100
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Dan Handelman.

1361
02:23:51.149 --> 02:23:52.190
<v Unidentified speaker>I use he/him pronouns.

1362
02:23:52.190 --> 02:23:53.979
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a member of the group Portland Cop Watch.

1363
02:23:55.030 --> 02:24:01.850
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, uh, we are connecting the dots here because the PSU protests that you heard about fell during the second quarter of 2024, which was after the mayor's executive order.

1364
02:24:03.646 --> 02:24:15.326
<v Unidentified speaker>After the compliance officer community liaison's last report to Judge Simon, who oversees the DOJ settlement agreement, and before the first expected report from the new court monitor, which will cover 2024 quarters 3 and 4.

1365
02:24:16.194 --> 02:24:25.995
<v Unidentified speaker>Unless there's an independent investigation into PPB's use of force at the protest in May 2024, we will have lost the first real opportunity to understand what PPB has learned about crowd control during protests.

1366
02:24:26.702 --> 02:24:29.497
<v Unidentified speaker>Judging from the amount of force used, there appear to have been some missed lessons.

1367
02:24:29.611 --> 02:24:29.788
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1368
02:24:30.477 --> 02:24:40.352
<v Unidentified speaker>And now many of the same officers from the rapid response team responsible for brutalizing Portlanders in 2020 have been allowed to rejoin the RRT and will potentially be improperly policing peaceful protests.

1369
02:24:41.137 --> 02:24:51.748
<v Unidentified speaker>Also slipping through accountability cracks, the compliance officer noted in their final report that an officer had been found liable in court and asked the monitors to verify the PPB has taken proper steps for the city to maintain compliance.

1370
02:24:52.439 --> 02:24:55.996
<v Unidentified speaker>They are referring to the million-dollar-plus jury award for the estate of Michael Townsend by a jury.

1371
02:24:56.782 --> 02:25:04.509
<v Unidentified speaker>Mr. Townsend, who was expecting— experiencing a mental health crisis, called 911 for a welfare check and wound up being shot and killed by CPB in June 2021.

1372
02:25:05.695 --> 02:25:12.027
<v Unidentified speaker>The city is shamefully appealing the jury's verdict and racking up a 9% interest until the appeal is complete.

1373
02:25:12.412 --> 02:25:16.259
<v Unidentified speaker>We hope to testify before you when council asks the city attorney to withdraw that appeal.

1374
02:25:17.220 --> 02:25:40.012
<v Unidentified speaker>Paragraph 222 of the DOJ agreement requires review of civil lawsuit information to help determine whether the bureau is in fact a learning organization that sees patterns and responds by changing policies and training To avoid making the same mistakes over and over, we reiterate our request for the monitor to pick up where the compliance officer left off in reporting on police lawsuits and to focus on the policies that led to the suits.

1375
02:25:40.638 --> 02:25:48.608
<v Unidentified speaker>One time in the eight years, the compliance officer published settlement data only one time, and they only talked about the amounts paid out rather than the underlying policies that led to the lawsuits.

1376
02:25:49.507 --> 02:25:54.343
<v Unidentified speaker>It's important also that they report on the amount and time money spent by the city attorney's office and risk management on settlements.

1377
02:25:54.200 --> 02:26:01.079
<v Unidentified speaker>In this case, the plaintiffs are each receiving $44,000, which means lawyers representing them are being paid over $500,000.

1378
02:26:01.680 --> 02:26:03.979
<v Unidentified speaker>The city likely has racked up similar costs.

1379
02:26:04.879 --> 02:26:11.139
<v Unidentified speaker>At Chief Day's confirmation hearing last month, he said other jurisdictions, including overseas, were interested in Portland's approach to crowd control.

1380
02:26:11.260 --> 02:26:14.659
<v Unidentified speaker>But the new system has only been in place since June 2024.

1381
02:26:14.659 --> 02:26:17.750
<v Unidentified speaker>So were they actually interested in the violence they saw at the 2020 protests?

1382
02:26:18.079 --> 02:26:19.229
<v Unidentified speaker>It's worth getting clarification.

1383
02:26:20.100 --> 02:26:33.979
<v Unidentified speaker>We have a particular interest in making sure the city follows state Statute 165.540, which protects cop watching, that is recording officers conducting their duties in public places, and the corresponding Police Directive 635.20, which also protects cop watching.

1384
02:26:34.299 --> 02:26:46.059
<v Unidentified speaker>We understand this settlement also assures that protections for observers stay in place until 2029, but ideally the policy and training will be reworked so that nobody at a protest who's abiding by the law gets attacked by the police.

1385
02:26:46.059 --> 02:26:47.040
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1386
02:26:47.139 --> 02:26:49.849
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Thank you.

1387
02:26:51.494 --> 02:26:52.744
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Jared Essig.

1388
02:26:57.658 --> 02:26:59.102
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Jared.

1389
02:27:01.274 --> 02:27:12.167
<v Jared Essig>Good morning, councilors, Mayor Wilson, Administrator Jordan, and citizens of Portland and Multnomah County.

1390
02:27:13.090 --> 02:27:14.125
<v Jared Essig>My name is Jared Essig.

1391
02:27:15.979 --> 02:27:18.933
<v Jared Essig>I'm here because bastards' lives matter.

1392
02:27:20.073 --> 02:27:29.220
<v Jared Essig>And that's why I was at the unlawful assemblies, um, back in 2020 that were shut down by police, usually around 10 PM, sometimes 11 PM.

1393
02:27:29.461 --> 02:27:41.280
<v Jared Essig>A riot would be declared around midnight or so, and that's when I got flashbanged and tear gassed and bull rushed and all that because I tried to report on the, uh, the events.

1394
02:27:42.718 --> 02:27:58.770
<v Jared Essig>Um, it was a risk that I assumed by choosing to be at a, uh, riot, and, um, my choice to engage in reporting and investigative journalism does not absolve me of the responsibility to not riot.

1395
02:28:00.370 --> 02:28:14.200
<v Jared Essig>So I did choose not to sue the city because the money is simply coming out of our parks, our recreation, our sanitation, and our clean water, our community development for a lot of Black and brown communities that need it.

1396
02:28:15.532 --> 02:28:17.942
<v Jared Essig>It's not actually stopping the police.

1397
02:28:18.200 --> 02:28:28.626
<v Jared Essig>The police are funded at record levels because you've incited a crime wave, and now everybody all over this state and all over the country are pointing to Portland as an example of why not to defund the police.

1398
02:28:28.978 --> 02:28:32.111
<v Jared Essig>Okay, and they hate it when I quote MLK Jr.

1399
02:28:32.159 --> 02:28:33.219
<v Jared Essig>They hate it when liberals do that, but I will.

1400
02:28:33.283 --> 02:28:34.070
<v Jared Essig>Councilmember No.

1401
02:28:34.568 --> 02:28:38.807
<v Jared Essig>Riots are designed to fail, and they are counterrevolutionary.

1402
02:28:39.706 --> 02:28:42.257
<v Jared Essig>And that's why this protest movement failed.

1403
02:28:43.237 --> 02:28:47.587
<v Jared Essig>Now, I want you to do not approve this, okay?

1404
02:28:48.310 --> 02:28:51.408
<v Jared Essig>Fire the city attorney and hire a city attorney who can win.

1405
02:28:52.645 --> 02:28:54.058
<v Jared Essig>Their role is to defend the city.

1406
02:28:54.154 --> 02:28:59.259
<v Jared Essig>That means including through political and moral and intellectual arguments and leadership.

1407
02:28:59.307 --> 02:29:00.495
<v Jared Essig>That's what's needed from all of you.

1408
02:29:00.993 --> 02:29:01.154
<v Jared Essig>Okay.

1409
02:29:01.314 --> 02:29:06.420
<v Jared Essig>Okay, pay out $9,000 at most, maybe $1,000 to each of them.

1410
02:29:06.532 --> 02:29:07.463
<v Jared Essig>That's the most they deserve.

1411
02:29:07.880 --> 02:29:18.736
<v Jared Essig>Okay, this is a massive wealth transfer away from the taxpayers toward plaintiffs' attorneys and toward media technology professionals who want to engage in the form of Fight Club-style news entertainment.

1412
02:29:19.153 --> 02:29:28.754
<v Jared Essig>Okay, this was on the front page of the Oregonian today, by the way, and the Oregonian reported on all those protests as well, and their reporters were not parties to this lawsuit.

1413
02:29:28.949 --> 02:29:39.971
<v Jared Essig>It's possible to engage in professional journalism without rioting, or if you choose to riot in order to get a really good story like I got, then you assume the risks.

1414
02:29:43.159 --> 02:29:52.259
<v Jared Essig>The problem is they've adopted the Palestinian strategy of protest, which is to incite violent revolution, start a fight, and then try to get sympathy by claiming victimhood afterward.

1415
02:29:53.534 --> 02:29:55.165
<v Jared Essig>That's what happened in 2024 of May at the.

1416
02:29:55.422 --> 02:29:59.003
<v Jared Essig>PSU, Palestinian Intifada, that a lot of these people have mentioned.

1417
02:29:59.661 --> 02:30:05.216
<v Jared Essig>By the way, that intifada cost $1 million for a PSU plus 3 months of the library being closed.

1418
02:30:05.618 --> 02:30:14.882
<v Jared Essig>And how many hundreds of people died in the murder epidemic in Portland as a result of this ideology that might makes right, that you can just join a mob as a solution to any problem?

1419
02:30:14.931 --> 02:30:17.097
<v Jared Essig>And that's what Donald Trump and his cohort are doing, by the way.

1420
02:30:17.403 --> 02:30:17.933
<v Jamie Dunphy>You see—.

1421
02:30:18.046 --> 02:30:20.566
<v Jared Essig>And that's why they're in power.

1422
02:30:21.415 --> 02:30:21.899
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, sir.

1423
02:30:21.979 --> 02:30:23.531
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate your perspective.

1424
02:30:23.595 --> 02:30:25.066
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

1425
02:30:29.125 --> 02:30:30.487
<v Rebecca Dobert>That concludes testimony.

1426
02:30:32.549 --> 02:30:34.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I don't see anybody in the queue.

1427
02:30:34.346 --> 02:30:36.225
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any discussion on this agenda item?

1428
02:30:36.679 --> 02:30:37.487
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal?

1429
02:30:38.492 --> 02:30:41.293
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I'd like to invite the presenters to come back, please.

1430
02:30:41.780 --> 02:30:44.052
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, this is our first settlement.

1431
02:30:44.102 --> 02:30:49.451
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I had a couple questions that, uh, I had asked for as it relates to settlements going forward.

1432
02:30:49.980 --> 02:30:54.341
<v Sameer Kanal>And there are 4 things that I think we should be looking to do, colleagues, on these.

1433
02:30:54.950 --> 02:30:59.439
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll— I think one of them's been addressed, and I'd like to ask some questions about the other 3.

1434
02:30:59.550 --> 02:30:59.935
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

1435
02:31:00.369 --> 02:31:06.764
<v Sameer Kanal>So I put in a standing request that settlements will no longer be on the consent agenda for the duration of my term in office.

1436
02:31:07.389 --> 02:31:12.167
<v Sameer Kanal>This ensures both transparency and the opportunity for public comment on the expenditure of public dollars.

1437
02:31:13.306 --> 02:31:16.257
<v Sameer Kanal>To the community, you should not have to request that this happen.

1438
02:31:16.370 --> 02:31:18.791
<v Sameer Kanal>You deserve that transparency and opportunity to comment.

1439
02:31:18.855 --> 02:31:20.557
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's why I put in that request.

1440
02:31:21.326 --> 02:31:33.229
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I requested that staff also include in, in the presentation a specific description of the allegation rather than just something like a motor vehicle collision involving X bureau, um, but a summary of what the plaintiff alleged.

1441
02:31:33.278 --> 02:31:41.105
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'll ask the city attorneys, could you please put into the record, uh, what it is that the plaintiffs alleged in their claim.

1442
02:31:41.429 --> 02:31:43.591
<v Sameer Kanal>And that does not imply that the city agrees with it.

1443
02:31:43.672 --> 02:31:47.559
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to be very clear with that, but I— that we're putting into the record the allegation.

1444
02:31:48.920 --> 02:31:52.546
<v Robert Taylor>Uh, yes, I should have those here.

1445
02:31:54.615 --> 02:31:57.885
<v Robert Taylor>All right, so as I said, there were 9 individual plaintiffs.

1446
02:31:58.560 --> 02:32:08.081
<v Robert Taylor>Uh, so plaintiff Doug Brown alleged that on June 12th, 2020, PPB fired a flashbang grenade directly at them and hit them with their bats.

1447
02:32:08.513 --> 02:32:17.195
<v Robert Taylor>Also alleges that on June 14th, 2020, PPB threatened to arrest them so that they left the scene and were unable to continue as a legal observer.

1448
02:32:18.384 --> 02:32:28.831
<v Robert Taylor>Brian Connolly alleges that on June 15th, 2020, PPB launched a flashbang grenade directly at them after seeing that they were using their camera.

1449
02:32:29.778 --> 02:32:35.201
<v Robert Taylor>They alleged that they were later told they had to leave even if they were media and that PPB pursued them down the street.

1450
02:32:35.331 --> 02:32:35.459
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1451
02:32:36.679 --> 02:32:55.961
<v Robert Taylor>Uh, plaintiff Matthew Lewis Rowland alleges that on May 21st, 2020, they captured an image of a PPB officer aiming a gun at them and that the officer then fired on them and that they were struck with what was described as shrapnel and tear gas.

1452
02:32:57.212 --> 02:33:05.121
<v Robert Taylor>Plaintiff Kat Mahoney alleges that on June 2nd, 2020, they were subjected to tear gas from PPB.

1453
02:33:06.132 --> 02:33:12.436
<v Robert Taylor>They alleged that on June 10th, 2020, PPB hit them with a rubber bullet that caused physical injuries.

1454
02:33:13.736 --> 02:33:22.398
<v Robert Taylor>They alleged that on June 29th, 2020, they were subjected to pepper spray and later were hit with a police truncheon that caused physical pain.

1455
02:33:23.200 --> 02:33:29.527
<v Robert Taylor>And they alleged that on August 8th, 2020, PPB took them to the ground and arrested them, causing physical injuries.

1456
02:33:30.995 --> 02:33:40.968
<v Robert Taylor>Plaintiff Olmos alleges that on June 6th, 2020, they were hit with a truncheon and threatened with tear gas because they were recording PPB.

1457
02:33:42.856 --> 02:33:58.289
<v Robert Taylor>Plaintiff John Rudolph alleges on June 29th, 2020, they were subjected to pepper spray while they were documenting a protest, and that later they were pushed to move with the crowd by a PPB officer who said that they did not care if that plaintiff was media.

1458
02:34:00.039 --> 02:34:09.754
<v Robert Taylor>Alex Tracy alleges that on June 2nd, 2020, they suffered exposure to tear gas when caught in a— what was described as a PPB gas trap.

1459
02:34:10.384 --> 02:34:25.043
<v Robert Taylor>They alleged that on June 7th, 2020, PPB threatened to arrest them if they did not leave after recording a PPB arrest of 2 people, and that later they were hit with a non-lethal round by PPB.

1460
02:34:26.074 --> 02:34:33.704
<v Robert Taylor>They also alleged that on June 6th, 2020, PPB threatened to arrest them, and the plaintiff was unable to continue reporting on the arrest that they were documenting.

1461
02:34:35.016 --> 02:34:41.727
<v Robert Taylor>And then they allege on June 29th, 2020, uh, PPB threatened to confiscate their camera as evidence.

1462
02:34:43.320 --> 02:34:59.203
<v Robert Taylor>Uh, plaintiff Tuck Woodstock alleges that on June 30th, 2020, um, PPB tackled and arrested people to either side of the plaintiff, and then PPB then shoved plaintiff, uh, even after plaintiff informed PPB that they were media.

1463
02:35:00.135 --> 02:35:14.073
<v Robert Taylor>And finally, uh, plaintiff Justin Yao alleged that on June 5th, 2020, they were covering, uh, PPB's dispersal of the crowd, um, and PPB threatened them with arrest even after being notified that they were press.

1464
02:35:14.671 --> 02:35:22.421
<v Robert Taylor>And then they allege that on July 1st, 2020, plaintiff was tackled by several officers and arrested, causing physical injury.

1465
02:35:23.048 --> 02:35:37.608
<v Robert Taylor>And finally, plaintiff Yao alleges that on July 2nd, 2020, PPB refused to return plaintiff's seized equipment within the time period required, so that plaintiff was unable to publish their footage with 2 news agencies.

1466
02:35:38.126 --> 02:35:43.012
<v Robert Taylor>That is a summary of the allegations in the plaintiff's 3rd amended complaint.

1467
02:35:43.076 --> 02:35:45.742
<v Robert Taylor>That is the complaint that would be settled by this agreement today.

1468
02:35:46.529 --> 02:35:46.977
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1469
02:35:47.235 --> 02:35:56.388
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, would you also put into the record the aggregate amount of the settlements paid out from this bureau over the last year, as well as over the last 4 or 5 years, whichever is more convenient for you?

1470
02:35:57.126 --> 02:35:57.672
<v Robert Taylor>Yes, Councilor.

1471
02:35:57.752 --> 02:36:01.831
<v Robert Taylor>Um, actually, I believe Ms. Sheffield has that data, or actually—.

1472
02:36:01.862 --> 02:36:02.923
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For the entire bureau?

1473
02:36:04.174 --> 02:36:06.085
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think, um, Ms. Radich has that information.

1474
02:36:07.563 --> 02:36:08.461
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, um, I do.

1475
02:36:08.525 --> 02:36:09.216
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, councilors.

1476
02:36:09.472 --> 02:36:11.512
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, let me get that.

1477
02:36:11.559 --> 02:36:20.920
<v Unidentified speaker>And so just a couple, um, I guess qualifiers on the, um, the data numbers is that this is kind of the best information that I have right now.

1478
02:36:21.128 --> 02:36:22.684
<v Unidentified speaker>But, um, just a couple things on it.

1479
02:36:23.440 --> 02:36:29.492
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so the payment for this settlement, um, you know, hasn't been approved yet, hasn't been paid out.

1480
02:36:29.556 --> 02:36:33.538
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's— that number is not included for the, the $938,000.

1481
02:36:33.634 --> 02:36:33.970
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1482
02:36:35.158 --> 02:36:44.096
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, some of the claims are open claims, so there is a possibility that something could be paid in the future on them if there's a resolution or verdict or something later.

1483
02:36:45.382 --> 02:36:52.020
<v Unidentified speaker>Or also on attorneys' fees, there's often a little bit of a lag for those to get billed into our file.

1484
02:36:54.704 --> 02:37:14.162
<v Unidentified speaker>So let me get— so for one year for Portland Police Bureau, And I'm sorry, just to clarify, is this just— are you seeking the numbers for total claim costs, like including legal expenses, or just the amount paid out to like plaintiffs or claimants?

1485
02:37:14.691 --> 02:37:15.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Actually, both would be great.

1486
02:37:15.798 --> 02:37:21.204
<v Sameer Kanal>I was only asking about the paid out, but now that you mention it, it does seem like a good thing to add for the record.

1487
02:37:21.269 --> 02:37:21.510
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1488
02:37:22.391 --> 02:37:22.617
<v Angelita Morillo>Great.

1489
02:37:22.952 --> 02:37:29.056
<v Unidentified speaker>So for Portland Police in the past year, and this includes all coverages.

1490
02:37:29.332 --> 02:37:44.513
<v Unidentified speaker>So not just sort of, as we've been talking with protest claims where there might be like use of force or civil rights allegations, but also like auto liability if there's a vehicle collision, general liability, employment liability, things like that.

1491
02:37:45.691 --> 02:37:54.825
<v Unidentified speaker>So with all of my caveats, in the past year, the total paid out For plaintiffs and claimants has been $12,977.41.

1492
02:37:59.450 --> 02:38:05.676
<v Unidentified speaker>For legal costs, that is $8,792.03.

1493
02:38:07.702 --> 02:38:17.947
<v Unidentified speaker>And then expenses, so that can be like deposition transcripts, you know, expert witnesses for litigation, things like that.

1494
02:38:18.075 --> 02:38:21.093
<v Unidentified speaker>It's $1,038.72.

1495
02:38:21.157 --> 02:38:21.334
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Thank you.

1496
02:38:23.632 --> 02:38:32.188
<v Unidentified speaker>For the past 5 years, those totals.

1497
02:38:33.272 --> 02:38:37.074
<v Unidentified speaker>So I have for the one year that was all property damage.

1498
02:38:37.461 --> 02:38:51.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Our files have the money sort of separated between property damage and then like injury, bodily injury, which includes those civil rights, um, and like constitutional claims.

1499
02:38:55.998 --> 02:39:09.138
<v Unidentified speaker>And those are for the total paid out, including both injury and property damage, but I can break that down further if you'd like, is $4,525,367.29.

1500
02:39:15.495 --> 02:39:22.255
<v Unidentified speaker>And for our legal costs, that is $6,487,107.57.

1501
02:39:27.824 --> 02:39:31.708
<v Unidentified speaker>And then expenses is $404,104.19.

1502
02:39:37.485 --> 02:39:38.408
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Ms. Radich.

1503
02:39:39.998 --> 02:39:48.020
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I think that's very helpful information contextually for the fiscal responsibility element, and also it shows a trend downward, and I want to recognize that as well.

1504
02:39:48.373 --> 02:39:54.041
<v Sameer Kanal>And I appreciate the representatives here for bringing up the policy change as well.

1505
02:39:54.105 --> 02:40:00.087
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to make sure that I also recognize the 4th thing, which is asking a bureau director or their designee attend and be able to speak.

1506
02:40:00.168 --> 02:40:04.049
<v Sameer Kanal>And I appreciate DCA Myers being online and Commander Dobson for being here.

1507
02:40:04.681 --> 02:40:07.364
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there anything that you would like to add about the PPBs?

1508
02:40:08.317 --> 02:40:15.479
<v Sameer Kanal>Work to sort of ensure that we're not asked to pay out another $900,000 in the future on a similar type of claim?

1509
02:40:16.443 --> 02:40:16.700
<v Craig Dobson>Thank you.

1510
02:40:17.246 --> 02:40:20.555
<v Craig Dobson>Thank you, Madam President, as well as council.

1511
02:40:21.663 --> 02:40:26.207
<v Craig Dobson>We have worked not only, as it was mentioned, city or state law has changed.

1512
02:40:26.399 --> 02:40:27.412
<v Craig Dobson>We changed our policy.

1513
02:40:28.486 --> 02:40:32.148
<v Craig Dobson>We now have body-worn cameras to hold us more accountable to those things as well.

1514
02:40:33.225 --> 02:40:34.942
<v Craig Dobson>We've trained— changed our training as well.

1515
02:40:36.050 --> 02:40:40.468
<v Craig Dobson>We have accepted the National Tactical Officers Association's standards.

1516
02:40:41.370 --> 02:40:50.647
<v Craig Dobson>We actually train our normal officers to a standard that a team of a Tier 3 team would be, which is 8 hours a year.

1517
02:40:51.872 --> 02:40:56.100
<v Craig Dobson>And our team that we have reconstituted receives 96 hours.

1518
02:40:56.518 --> 02:40:59.154
<v Craig Dobson>Of those hours, it's not all tactical type training.

1519
02:40:59.731 --> 02:41:10.140
<v Craig Dobson>It includes also de-escalation training, training on decision-making, training on lots of the theory side of crowd theory and how does that work as well.

1520
02:41:10.284 --> 02:41:18.191
<v Craig Dobson>And so with that, we believe going forward that there will be less— we have mitigated much of the exposure that we had prior.

1521
02:41:19.265 --> 02:41:19.843
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much.

1522
02:41:19.923 --> 02:41:28.022
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also just want to observe that when Chief Day was here, he also noted that he'd read the Citizen Review Committee report on crowd control as well, and that was a part of it.

1523
02:41:28.085 --> 02:41:31.398
<v Sameer Kanal>So I appreciate the transparency there, and that That concludes my questions.

1524
02:41:35.665 --> 02:41:36.500
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

1525
02:41:37.030 --> 02:41:42.573
<v Olivia Clark>I just want to express my appreciation to the legal team for, um, briefing us in advance.

1526
02:41:42.684 --> 02:41:48.198
<v Olivia Clark>I think we all had an opportunity to ask a lot of questions and get a lot of answers, and I appreciate that.

1527
02:41:48.840 --> 02:41:56.693
<v Olivia Clark>And I also think that we have all learned a lot since 2020 and obviously changed practices, and I appreciate that as well.

1528
02:41:57.036 --> 02:41:59.536
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor.

1529
02:42:00.722 --> 02:42:01.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Murillo.

1530
02:42:02.983 --> 02:42:03.959
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Madam President.

1531
02:42:04.488 --> 02:42:07.823
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, first, I want to thank the legal team for putting this together so well.

1532
02:42:08.095 --> 02:42:13.289
<v Angelita Morillo>It was extremely helpful, as Councilor Clark said, to get the briefing beforehand and to hear about everything going on.

1533
02:42:13.945 --> 02:42:32.944
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, and I want to also thank Councilor, uh, Kanal for laying out those questions, I think very beautifully, to kind of, uh, point out the fact that we are in a budget deficit and we're having these And the cost of these settlements for our taxpayers and for us as decision-makers is not something that can be ignored.

1534
02:42:33.362 --> 02:42:48.273
<v Angelita Morillo>And I hope that as we move forward into another difficult time where people are going to be expressing their First Amendment rights and the tensions will be high, that our police bureau is prepared to handle things with as much de-escalation as possible.

1535
02:42:48.418 --> 02:42:55.833
<v Angelita Morillo>It kind of hurts my heart a little bit to see the amount of money that we're spending Revisiting some of this as someone who was in person for a lot of these things.

1536
02:42:56.489 --> 02:43:10.299
<v Angelita Morillo>I remember back then I was 110 pounds soaking wet and the, you know, wearing a little raincoat and the aggression that I received from police at that time was quite intense when I was doing essentially nothing other than standing around.

1537
02:43:11.102 --> 02:43:24.140
<v Angelita Morillo>I know some of the plaintiffs too, just seeing viscerally how small some of these people are and how truly non-threatening they are in the face of fully armored police that look like Bionicles, if anyone knows those '90s toys.

1538
02:43:25.600 --> 02:43:30.153
<v Angelita Morillo>You know, it's— there's a real difference in, in that power and how you have to exert it.

1539
02:43:30.201 --> 02:43:34.467
<v Angelita Morillo>So I, I don't know, it's surfacing a lot for me revisiting some of this.

1540
02:43:35.941 --> 02:43:48.274
<v Angelita Morillo>I also think that we as the City Council have a responsibility to right past wrongs and to make sure that we're doing right by our constituents, both as people who are expressing their First Amendment rights in our city And who are taxpayers.

1541
02:43:48.933 --> 02:43:52.096
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think that there are improvements that have been made.

1542
02:43:52.320 --> 02:43:55.195
<v Angelita Morillo>Obviously, our police have body-worn cameras and things like that.

1543
02:43:55.532 --> 02:44:04.799
<v Angelita Morillo>But I don't want to— I don't want us to lose sight of the fact that a camera in the hands of a civilian, a camera in the hands of a journalist, is a very different tool.

1544
02:44:05.569 --> 02:44:13.841
<v Angelita Morillo>You can capture a lot of different things based on who is behind the camera and whose perspective is being shared and what they're choosing to cover.

1545
02:44:14.162 --> 02:44:17.038
<v Angelita Morillo>And that, that is something that's really critically important to protect.

1546
02:44:17.520 --> 02:44:27.417
<v Angelita Morillo>And the— there is a lot of beauty, in my opinion, in those who are willing to bear witness to what is happening in order to record these moments in history so that we can fight for a more just future.

1547
02:44:27.754 --> 02:44:35.113
<v Angelita Morillo>So I want our colleagues to remember that, the importance of citizen journalists and legal observers as well in this process.

1548
02:44:35.274 --> 02:44:44.137
<v Angelita Morillo>And I, I'm grateful for all the work that was put into addressing the past harm And I hope that we can move into a future where we don't have to do this again.

1549
02:44:44.431 --> 02:44:44.691
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you.

1550
02:44:46.010 --> 02:44:47.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1551
02:44:47.262 --> 02:44:47.896
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1552
02:44:51.667 --> 02:44:52.448
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

1553
02:44:53.775 --> 02:44:58.318
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to say to, uh, the plaintiffs, I am so sorry that you had to go through that.

1554
02:44:58.851 --> 02:45:10.463
<v Loretta Smith>And I had a question in terms of, was there any, um, video on this, on, on any of these Yes.

1555
02:45:10.916 --> 02:45:11.400
<v Robert Taylor>I mean, some—.

1556
02:45:11.805 --> 02:45:12.500
<v Christine Burmeister>Sorry, go ahead.

1557
02:45:13.032 --> 02:45:17.104
<v Robert Taylor>Oh yes, uh, you know, not for a lot of them, but for some of them, yes.

1558
02:45:18.737 --> 02:45:21.471
<v Loretta Smith>And for which ones?

1559
02:45:25.479 --> 02:45:27.743
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm trying to think if we can go through each of them.

1560
02:45:28.099 --> 02:45:30.459
<v Loretta Smith>I guess what I'm— so let me make it a little bit easier.

1561
02:45:30.831 --> 02:45:35.442
<v Loretta Smith>Um, Was that how you came to the conclusion that we should settle?

1562
02:45:37.190 --> 02:45:38.324
<v Loretta Smith>Was it based on the video?

1563
02:45:40.329 --> 02:45:41.299
<v Robert Taylor>Not, not solely.

1564
02:45:41.433 --> 02:45:42.352
<v Robert Taylor>It was part of the analysis.

1565
02:45:43.450 --> 02:45:43.740
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

1566
02:45:45.325 --> 02:45:45.470
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1567
02:45:45.567 --> 02:45:56.725
<v Loretta Smith>And your sense was that we would be in court for the next so many months or years and that it would be cheaper just to pay out a settlement?

1568
02:46:02.356 --> 02:46:10.718
<v Robert Taylor>I, you know, what I would say is, is no, I think that's too reductive.

1569
02:46:11.299 --> 02:46:13.545
<v Robert Taylor>Um, it's not simply about time.

1570
02:46:13.804 --> 02:46:32.566
<v Robert Taylor>Um, I also, you know, want to be mindful of the fact to not, um, you know, I, I basically, I don't want to have sort of attorney-client privilege conversations you know, in this open setting, I would be very happy, you know, to give, to give, you know, a sort of private briefing about the risk analysis.

1571
02:46:32.614 --> 02:46:39.097
<v Robert Taylor>But definitely, yes, it was, it was based on a review of the evidence and the case and a variety of considerations.

1572
02:46:39.941 --> 02:46:41.056
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you so much.

1573
02:46:41.727 --> 02:46:42.890
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are the client.

1574
02:46:42.940 --> 02:46:44.234
<v Eric Zimmerman>The public is the client.

1575
02:46:50.219 --> 02:46:53.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I don't see any other comments in the queue.

1576
02:46:54.591 --> 02:47:13.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll just add that, um, I appreciate you beginning the information you shared with us today, uh, with sharing what has changed, because one of the questions that I think is really important to always ask when we hear about settlements is what we've learned and what we're doing different.

1577
02:47:14.161 --> 02:47:19.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I never want to hear that we have to settle for the same issues more than once.

1578
02:47:20.031 --> 02:47:23.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that will happen sometimes, but I think that's a worst-case scenario.

1579
02:47:23.959 --> 02:47:33.513
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I appreciate hearing that not only are we bound by changed state laws, but that we have also changed our own procedures and our own directives within our police bureau here.

1580
02:47:34.218 --> 02:47:37.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope that that means that we won't see a settlement like this again.

1581
02:47:37.969 --> 02:47:41.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal noted that we're seeing a downward trend thank you.

1582
02:47:41.915 --> 02:47:55.308
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We also have had some easier years the last few years, and I hope that if we have harder years, we continue to see those changed directives, um, changing what things look like so we don't have to see settlements like this in the future.

1583
02:47:56.192 --> 02:47:57.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, thank you all for being here.

1584
02:47:58.457 --> 02:48:01.363
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark, are you back in the queue, or is that an old hand?

1585
02:48:01.734 --> 02:48:02.055
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1586
02:48:03.531 --> 02:48:06.567
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, councilors, this is an emergency ordinance.

1587
02:48:06.631 --> 02:48:11.209
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do need a motion So moved.

1588
02:48:12.656 --> 02:48:12.961
<v Steve Novick>Second.

1589
02:48:13.202 --> 02:48:16.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you for the change there, Councilor Novick.

1590
02:48:16.420 --> 02:48:19.227
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Rebecca, could you please call the roll?

1591
02:48:22.558 --> 02:48:22.945
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos.

1592
02:48:25.807 --> 02:48:31.691
<v Candace Avalos>I agree with the overall sentiment that we want to reduce these kinds of settlements because we're reducing the incidents.

1593
02:48:31.886 --> 02:48:36.390
<v Candace Avalos>So I will continue to look at that from a poli— Policy perspective as a councilor.

1594
02:48:37.031 --> 02:48:37.361
<v Candace Avalos>I vote aye.

1595
02:48:39.780 --> 02:48:40.022
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1596
02:48:40.684 --> 02:48:40.781
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1597
02:48:41.655 --> 02:48:41.962
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

1598
02:48:42.802 --> 02:48:43.030
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1599
02:48:45.131 --> 02:48:45.342
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

1600
02:48:48.123 --> 02:48:49.706
<v Sameer Kanal>So start a note on the process.

1601
02:48:49.834 --> 02:48:51.136
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks for answering the questions.

1602
02:48:51.200 --> 02:48:54.270
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope we move towards this being in the presentation and the document in the future.

1603
02:48:54.317 --> 02:48:57.033
<v Sameer Kanal>We shouldn't have to ask, and neither should the public, for transparency.

1604
02:48:57.308 --> 02:49:07.845
<v Sameer Kanal>But I really appreciate the explanations of state law directive changes and the work that PPB has done in several places, including training changes and the differences and, and increased training not only for the RRT but for other teams.

1605
02:49:08.680 --> 02:49:14.164
<v Sameer Kanal>This is how a presentation on a settlement should go when parks are coming up, when fire has a settlement, or any other bureau.

1606
02:49:14.211 --> 02:49:15.141
<v Sameer Kanal>This should apply equally.

1607
02:49:15.237 --> 02:49:16.263
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not a police thing.

1608
02:49:16.697 --> 02:49:19.390
<v Sameer Kanal>Transparency and fiscal responsibility should apply to everyone.

1609
02:49:20.369 --> 02:49:27.584
<v Sameer Kanal>Moving now to the content and the specific specifics of this, I want to talk about the circumstances that lead to a settlement like this in the first place.

1610
02:49:28.066 --> 02:49:29.254
<v Sameer Kanal>Because they may come up again.

1611
02:49:30.153 --> 02:49:33.379
<v Sameer Kanal>As the council president noted, Portland saw a lot of protests in 2020.

1612
02:49:33.523 --> 02:49:36.958
<v Sameer Kanal>With a second Trump term underway, we might see more in the future.

1613
02:49:37.536 --> 02:49:53.007
<v Sameer Kanal>Public protests cannot result in civil rights violations, and we cannot erase the First Amendment in the context especially of the Trump administration, but even otherwise, we must respect the public's right to peacefully assemble and to be protected from unreasonable search and seizure as well.

1614
02:49:53.231 --> 02:49:53.457
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1615
02:49:53.569 --> 02:49:54.179
<v Sameer Kanal>The Fourth Amendment.

1616
02:49:54.709 --> 02:50:04.852
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but because of the patterns here, I think we also need to start a conversation about how crowd intervention and crowd control can best be handled to support public safety without compromising First and Fourth Amendment rights.

1617
02:50:05.461 --> 02:50:11.784
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, because Portlanders who are peacefully protesting or engaged in nonviolent civil obedience shouldn't have to fear for their physical safety.

1618
02:50:12.522 --> 02:50:19.648
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, another consideration is the potentially increased risk of liability that the city faces when it coordinates with federal law enforcement and protest response.

1619
02:50:20.484 --> 02:50:23.518
<v Sameer Kanal>The plaintiffs in this case also sued DHS and the U.S.

1620
02:50:23.599 --> 02:50:26.551
<v Sameer Kanal>Marshals in connection with incidents in the summer of 2020.

1621
02:50:26.986 --> 02:50:43.040
<v Sameer Kanal>And given that the likelihood in the current administration is that there will be more protests and that those protests may be about the actions of the federal government, in particular ICE, we may need to be prepared for both how we're going to handle not only our own police's response, but what we're going to do if and when federal agents show up.

1622
02:50:43.522 --> 02:50:49.106
<v Sameer Kanal>And in either case, Portland has a responsibility to safeguard its residents' civil rights and uphold the Constitution.

1623
02:50:49.865 --> 02:51:00.859
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so I, I appreciate what everyone brought up about the overall fiscal situation as well, in particular Councilor Murillo on this, and make sure that we're acting in a— from a space of fiscal prudence as well.

1624
02:51:01.361 --> 02:51:03.326
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but with that said, uh, I do vote aye.

1625
02:51:03.489 --> 02:51:03.829
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1626
02:51:07.051 --> 02:51:22.228
<v Dan Ryan>The protests and riots of recent years, especially those directed at the police who are the— at the who are the same frontline public servants who are called to provide crowd control, were complex and have provided a learning opportunity for local governments and law enforcement agencies.

1627
02:51:22.726 --> 02:51:25.147
<v Dan Ryan>Perhaps nowhere in the country is this more obvious than in Portland.

1628
02:51:26.109 --> 02:51:35.375
<v Dan Ryan>The toll that the protest intensity and duration of 2020 had on our city's residents and on those in local law enforcement personnel was dramatic and has been lasting.

1629
02:51:36.609 --> 02:51:41.908
<v Dan Ryan>PPB has made changes to its practices and policies in response to more than 100 days of protest.

1630
02:51:42.456 --> 02:51:46.618
<v Dan Ryan>Thank goodness we finally joined most cities in the country with body-worn cameras.

1631
02:51:47.500 --> 02:51:55.778
<v Dan Ryan>My greatest hope is that our city evolves from past violent expressions of disagreement to showing civility during conflict and respect for our beautiful city.

1632
02:51:57.280 --> 02:52:02.789
<v Dan Ryan>Although this amount seems extreme, I vote in support of the hard work our legal, legal team has been through.

1633
02:52:03.192 --> 02:52:03.209
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1634
02:52:07.612 --> 02:52:07.677
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1635
02:52:09.277 --> 02:52:17.323
<v Angelita Morillo>I hope that this brings some peace to the folks who went through this process and that you feel that we have taken some responsibility here.

1636
02:52:17.597 --> 02:52:27.735
<v Angelita Morillo>And as many of my other colleagues have stated, we will continue to ensure that there is strong police accountability at the city so that we don't have to pay these settlements in these types of situations moving forward.

1637
02:52:27.834 --> 02:52:28.352
<v Angelita Morillo>I vote aye.

1638
02:52:30.575 --> 02:52:30.804
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick.

1639
02:52:30.886 --> 02:52:33.554
<v Steve Novick>I was very pleased to see the widespread support for the settlement.

1640
02:52:34.620 --> 02:52:41.958
<v Steve Novick>Um, I feel compelled to note that this is a time when freedom of the press is under assault in a way that we probably have not seen since the First World War.

1641
02:52:42.573 --> 02:52:45.743
<v Steve Novick>And if I were a praying man, I would pray that we still have a free press 4 years from now.

1642
02:52:46.456 --> 02:52:52.949
<v Steve Novick>And finally, I hope that Councilor Murillo did not mean to suggest that as a general matter, small people cannot be dangerous, because I would take offense to that.

1643
02:52:53.564 --> 02:52:53.579
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1644
02:52:58.745 --> 02:52:58.777
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1645
02:53:00.771 --> 02:53:09.450
<v Mitch Green>I hope this settlement brings some closure to the plaintiffs who have sought for nearly 5 years to find some measure of accountability and remedy for the infringement upon, upon their rights by the Portland Police Bureau.

1646
02:53:10.405 --> 02:53:32.002
<v Mitch Green>Uh, this nearly million-dollar settlement is a statement by the city that by the evidence they believe they are likely to lose this case in court, uh, and that judgment would show that the plaintiffs were unjustly harmed As one of the people that was out there many nights myself, I saw it with my own eyes, so I'm not surprised to see this case brought forward, and so many others did as well.

1647
02:53:32.146 --> 02:53:46.039
<v Mitch Green>So I do appreciate that the bureau has revised its policies and has taken some proactive measure, but this outcome reaffirms to me— reaffirms for me a commitment to, you know, an independent oversight system that produces real accountability up and down the chain.

1648
02:53:46.102 --> 02:53:46.215
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1649
02:53:46.280 --> 02:53:49.703
<v Mitch Green>Upstream to prevent this kind of suppression of free expression rights.

1650
02:53:49.929 --> 02:53:53.643
<v Mitch Green>And I'll be working to make sure that that's something that's, uh, that's in place on this council.

1651
02:53:53.708 --> 02:53:54.270
<v Mitch Green>So I vote yay.

1652
02:53:55.412 --> 02:53:55.831
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1653
02:53:56.057 --> 02:53:56.201
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1654
02:53:57.413 --> 02:53:57.880
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

1655
02:53:59.349 --> 02:53:59.397
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1656
02:54:00.881 --> 02:54:04.398
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the ordinance is passed with 11 aye votes and 1 no vote.

1657
02:54:07.059 --> 02:54:07.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all.

1658
02:54:10.292 --> 02:54:22.040
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>One other, um, Um, uh, it is a workers' comp claim, so a little bit different from this settlement.

1659
02:54:22.727 --> 02:54:25.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Rebecca, could you please read the agenda item?

1660
02:54:27.471 --> 02:54:34.612
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 10, pay workers' compensation claims of Jerome Johnson for $100,000 involving Portland Parks and Recreation.

1661
02:54:35.993 --> 02:54:37.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1662
02:54:37.583 --> 02:54:47.355
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we have I believe Linh Vu and Vicki Bisbee— and it looks like Vicki's online, perfect— to share some information with us about this agenda item.

1663
02:54:48.216 --> 02:54:51.362
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Great, thank you, Council President and councilors.

1664
02:54:51.557 --> 02:54:52.433
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My name is Linh Vu.

1665
02:54:53.016 --> 02:54:54.704
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am a Chief Deputy City Attorney.

1666
02:54:55.500 --> 02:55:00.773
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Online with me is Vicki Bisbee, who is a Senior Claims Analyst with Risk Management.

1667
02:55:02.468 --> 02:55:14.474
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>To provide you with some background on this settlement, Jerome Johnson worked for Portland Parks and— worked for Portland Parks and Recreation.

1668
02:55:17.845 --> 02:55:19.720
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, is it possible to turn the volume up on the mic?

1669
02:55:19.963 --> 02:55:20.334
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is not.

1670
02:55:20.384 --> 02:55:21.595
<v Rebecca Dobert>Our volume is maxed.

1671
02:55:21.726 --> 02:55:22.727
<v Rebecca Dobert>You're going to have to—.

1672
02:55:22.792 --> 02:55:23.601
<v Dan Ryan>Here's your theater voice—.

1673
02:55:23.601 --> 02:55:27.563
<v Rebecca Dobert>Speak straight to the microphone and project.

1674
02:55:28.274 --> 02:55:30.055
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>All right, I apologize for that.

1675
02:55:30.152 --> 02:55:30.944
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will start over.

1676
02:55:31.477 --> 02:55:34.397
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will provide you with a little bit of background on the settlement.

1677
02:55:35.191 --> 02:55:39.593
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Jerome Johnson worked for Portland Parks and Recreation as an Arborist 4.

1678
02:55:40.861 --> 02:55:49.768
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>On July 26th, 2021, Mr. Johnson sustained a work injury while removing a fallen tree branch that was blocking the road.

1679
02:55:51.573 --> 02:56:02.231
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Risk Management, which is tasked with administering the city's workers' compensation program, accepted the claim and processed it pursuant to state law.

1680
02:56:04.052 --> 02:56:17.752
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>To date, the city has provided Mr. Johnson with benefits, um, under his workers' compensation in the form of medical services, time loss, permanent disability benefits, and vocational assistance.

1681
02:56:19.291 --> 02:56:22.137
<v Loretta Smith>Um, Mr.

1682
02:56:22.218 --> 02:56:31.084
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Johnson, through his attorney, has requested a settlement of the remaining benefits to which he might be entitled to under his workers' compensation claim.

1683
02:56:32.021 --> 02:56:33.378
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This is what the settlement reflects.

1684
02:56:36.466 --> 02:56:51.566
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Under the terms of the settlement, Mr. Johnson will retain his rights to medical benefits under this claim so long as there remains a material relationship between the need for the medical benefits and his work injuries.

1685
02:56:53.054 --> 02:56:59.569
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will stop now, and then, um, if you have any questions for me or for Ms. Bisbee, we're happy to respond to them.

1686
02:57:02.299 --> 02:57:05.325
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Rebecca, do we have any public testimony signed up for this agenda item?

1687
02:57:07.343 --> 02:57:07.941
<v Rebecca Dobert>We do not.

1688
02:57:08.811 --> 02:57:10.683
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, councilors, comments?

1689
02:57:12.102 --> 02:57:12.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1690
02:57:14.102 --> 02:57:20.638
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, and Madam President, thank you for also pointing out that there is some similarity but difference between this item and the previous one.

1691
02:57:20.686 --> 02:57:22.801
<v Sameer Kanal>Nonetheless, one portion of it does apply.

1692
02:57:23.091 --> 02:57:35.349
<v Sameer Kanal>Could you, uh, please let us know on the record the total paid out in workers' compensation claims related to Portland Parks and Recreation in the last year, in the last 4 or 5 years, whatever's more convenient?

1693
02:57:35.909 --> 02:57:41.727
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes, um, and we're talking about the total amount of benefits paid, is that your question?

1694
02:57:42.543 --> 02:57:50.958
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, in, in similar situations to this one, um, there's a claim that's, you know, been coming in that relates to Portland Parks specifically.

1695
02:57:51.215 --> 02:57:52.179
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sure, sure.

1696
02:57:52.612 --> 02:58:04.420
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So over this, this current fiscal year, um, the total amount of benefits paid, um, when I checked in with Risk Management last year, is just a little bit under $86,000.

1697
02:58:05.030 --> 02:58:11.119
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, it would not include, um, most of the payment that's already been made for this claim.

1698
02:58:12.349 --> 02:58:27.268
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>For the previous 5 years, fiscal years starting July 1st, 2019, about a little under $2.7 million have been paid out for parks— Portland Parks and Rec workers' compensation claims.

1699
02:58:29.074 --> 02:58:33.845
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>About $600,000 of that represents payments on this claim.

1700
02:58:34.922 --> 02:58:35.324
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1701
02:58:35.404 --> 02:58:40.977
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the second and final question is, are there any policy implications of this particular incident?

1702
02:58:41.025 --> 02:58:51.263
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there anything PP&R could do from a policy perspective, or which they've already done, to reduce the likelihood of us being asked for $100,000 for a similar claim in the future?

1703
02:58:52.530 --> 02:59:04.092
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, so when work injuries such as this one occurs, um, by state law, employers are tasked with, with performing a root cause analysis.

1704
02:59:04.172 --> 02:59:08.325
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so part of that analysis is what went wrong, what could we do better.

1705
02:59:10.041 --> 02:59:17.753
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I would say that in this case, all the employees who were involved were doing everything correctly.

1706
02:59:20.649 --> 02:59:29.769
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This particular job classification falls within one of those job classifications that carries a little bit higher risk.

1707
02:59:30.309 --> 02:59:33.192
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They work at elevated heights.

1708
02:59:33.355 --> 02:59:35.700
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They also use lots of power tools.

1709
02:59:35.782 --> 02:59:35.847
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

1710
02:59:36.409 --> 02:59:59.851
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So when I checked in with Parks and Rec with their risk team, what they did tell me was that one change that they have made is when they prepare a work plan, if there is any change to that work plan, they will stop and make sure everyone is on board and understands what the plan is, what the change is, and what the plan will be going forward.

1711
03:00:00.788 --> 03:00:01.047
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1712
03:00:01.353 --> 03:00:01.434
<v Loretta Smith>Sure.

1713
03:00:02.037 --> 03:00:02.424
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Mike Fisher.

1714
03:00:04.381 --> 03:00:04.995
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1715
03:00:06.807 --> 03:00:08.117
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

1716
03:00:08.828 --> 03:00:17.548
<v Loretta Smith>Question, you had talked about that this settlement would include benefits that he would have ordinarily received.

1717
03:00:17.612 --> 03:00:20.341
<v Loretta Smith>Could you tell me what those benefits would have been?

1718
03:00:21.253 --> 03:00:37.845
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes, so under workers' compensation laws, injured workers are entitled to Um, a slate of benefits particular to this claim is Mr. Johnson would be entitled to vocational assistance benefits as one of the primary costs.

1719
03:00:38.136 --> 03:00:40.911
<v Loretta Smith>Um, Yeah.

1720
03:00:41.523 --> 03:00:51.853
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My understanding is that he would have been approved or was approved to engage in a vocational, uh, training plan that would have lasted about 18 months.

1721
03:00:51.902 --> 03:00:56.354
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So that's, that's one One potential— well, actually one actual benefit.

1722
03:00:56.498 --> 03:01:05.447
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The other, um, are injured workers retain aggravation rights for a period of 5 years after a claim closes.

1723
03:01:05.976 --> 03:01:15.132
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So he may be entitled to additional time loss, permanent disability, um, uh, and then related costs for, for medical benefits, of course.

1724
03:01:15.998 --> 03:01:19.735
<v Loretta Smith>So was it the issue that he did not pursue voc rehab?

1725
03:01:21.351 --> 03:01:22.594
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That is correct.

1726
03:01:23.370 --> 03:01:27.590
<v Loretta Smith>And did he say why he didn't pursue voc rehab?

1727
03:01:28.188 --> 03:01:31.209
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I don't have any insight to that, uh, Councilor Smith.

1728
03:01:31.549 --> 03:01:36.621
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, those conversations would have been between, um, Mr. Johnson's attorney and—.

1729
03:01:36.896 --> 03:01:40.052
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you.

1730
03:01:42.935 --> 03:01:44.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, any other discussion?

1731
03:01:48.665 --> 03:01:55.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, and Rebecca, do we need a motion on this item, or do we just move forward with a roll call vote?

1732
03:01:55.870 --> 03:01:57.306
<v Rebecca Dobert>We can just take the vote.

1733
03:01:59.596 --> 03:01:59.904
<v Candace Avalos>Avalos?

1734
03:02:00.808 --> 03:02:00.855
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1735
03:02:02.195 --> 03:02:02.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dunphy?

1736
03:02:02.922 --> 03:02:02.969
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1737
03:02:03.566 --> 03:02:03.858
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

1738
03:02:04.519 --> 03:02:04.567
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1739
03:02:05.424 --> 03:02:05.995
<v Sameer Kanal>Kanal?

1740
03:02:06.629 --> 03:02:06.679
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1741
03:02:07.606 --> 03:02:15.021
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I just want to support the legal counsel's recommendation for the resolution of this I.

1742
03:02:17.450 --> 03:02:17.498
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1743
03:02:19.150 --> 03:02:19.199
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1744
03:02:20.608 --> 03:02:20.721
<v Craig Dobson>Aye.

1745
03:02:21.904 --> 03:02:21.952
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1746
03:02:23.782 --> 03:02:23.799
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1747
03:02:24.494 --> 03:02:24.510
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1748
03:02:25.318 --> 03:02:25.496
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1749
03:02:26.450 --> 03:02:28.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perhaps I should have said this in discussion.

1750
03:02:28.617 --> 03:02:30.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will say it now though.

1751
03:02:30.736 --> 03:02:36.449
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I said earlier I always ask what can we do better, and I understand that accidents happen.

1752
03:02:37.313 --> 03:02:42.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that many of our employees across bureaus have very dangerous jobs where accidents do happen.

1753
03:02:43.949 --> 03:02:57.414
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I hope that Parks has looked very carefully at whether there's anything else they could do to ensure that our employees who put their own lives on the risk— on, on the line every day are as safe as possible when they go to work.

1754
03:02:57.510 --> 03:02:59.674
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's something that I think is really critically important.

1755
03:03:00.075 --> 03:03:00.506
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I vote aye.

1756
03:03:01.757 --> 03:03:05.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>The ordinance is passed with 12 aye votes, Thank you.

1757
03:03:05.251 --> 03:03:07.721
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1758
03:03:09.569 --> 03:03:14.064
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we are going to hear the next 4 agenda items together.

1759
03:03:14.451 --> 03:03:17.573
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They are all related to foreclosures.

1760
03:03:18.477 --> 03:03:21.691
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm going to have the clerk read all 4 agenda items.

1761
03:03:21.802 --> 03:03:36.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will open it up for, uh, presentation and discussion on all 4, and then we will vote on each one Rebecca, could you please call all 4 agenda items, numbers 11 through 14?

1762
03:03:37.262 --> 03:03:46.454
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 11, initiate foreclosure action on 11514 Southeast Alder Street for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1763
03:03:46.888 --> 03:04:04.522
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 12, initiate foreclosure action on 10218 North Tyler Avenue for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against Item 13, initiate foreclosure action on 111 Northeast Killingsworth Street for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1764
03:04:05.120 --> 03:04:13.463
<v Rebecca Dobert>And Item 14, initiate foreclosure action on 4121 Northeast Grand Avenue for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1765
03:04:15.120 --> 03:04:15.474
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1766
03:04:15.700 --> 03:04:19.921
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And DCA Biery, would you like to kick off the presentation and introduce your team?

1767
03:04:20.388 --> 03:04:20.855
<v Donna Cohen>Yeah, great.

1768
03:04:20.935 --> 03:04:22.917
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you, Madam President, Council.

1769
03:04:22.967 --> 03:04:29.558
<v Jonas Biery>For the record, My name is Jonas Biery, Deputy City Administrator for Budget and Finance and the city's Chief Financial Officer.

1770
03:04:32.010 --> 03:04:47.006
<v Jonas Biery>Council, each of the 4 ordinances before you today begins foreclosure proceedings against a property with delinquent city liens, each of which properties are eligible for foreclosure under Administrative Rule 14.10, the collections and foreclosure process.

1771
03:04:47.055 --> 03:04:49.075
<v Jonas Biery>And I believe we're getting a presentation loaded up.

1772
03:04:50.038 --> 03:04:57.728
<v Jonas Biery>By way of introduction, these liens were placed against the properties by Portland Permitting and Development for code enforcement violations.

1773
03:04:58.387 --> 03:05:01.341
<v Jonas Biery>The liens are delinquent and the violations have not been corrected.

1774
03:05:01.934 --> 03:05:14.264
<v Jonas Biery>Each property comes before council as part of a coordinated city effort by Portland Permitting and Development and the Revenue Division to actively pursue remedies, including foreclosure, for vacant and distressed properties.

1775
03:05:15.004 --> 03:05:25.969
<v Jonas Biery>Each of these properties has been identified as causing significant problems for, uh, for neighbors and has been the subject of multiple and frequent police calls and/or numerous enforcement activities.

1776
03:05:26.707 --> 03:05:32.265
<v Jonas Biery>Foreclosure Prevention Manager in the Revenue Division has reviewed each case to ensure it meets the criteria for foreclosure.

1777
03:05:32.730 --> 03:05:42.761
<v Jonas Biery>He's also reviewed whether any aggravating or mitigating conditions exist within the case history that would prevent the city from moving forward with foreclosure or would warrant an adjustment of lien amounts.

1778
03:05:43.306 --> 03:05:57.879
<v Jonas Biery>The property owner and parties of interest have received notification of pending foreclosure action Today you'll hear from the Foreclosure Prevention Manager Kevin Foster about the properties recommended to be included on the foreclosure list for sale.

1779
03:05:58.668 --> 03:06:09.745
<v Jonas Biery>Also in the room, Sharon Nickelberry Rogers from the Revenue Division, representative from City Attorney Mark Rodriguez, City Treasurer Bridget O'Callaghan, and Mike Leafield with Portland Permitting and Development are also available.

1780
03:06:10.165 --> 03:06:11.780
<v Jonas Biery>And with that, I'll hand over to Kevin.

1781
03:06:13.306 --> 03:06:14.254
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, Council.

1782
03:06:15.251 --> 03:06:16.986
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, I'll start by stating my name.

1783
03:06:17.260 --> 03:06:18.465
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Kevin Foster.

1784
03:06:18.771 --> 03:06:21.406
<v Unidentified speaker>I am the Foreclosure Prevention Manager for the city.

1785
03:06:23.549 --> 03:06:24.560
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

1786
03:06:27.409 --> 03:06:36.302
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland Permitting and Development, the City Attorney, Revenue Division, and the City Treasurer are the team that works on foreclosures for the city.

1787
03:06:36.479 --> 03:06:40.945
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to start by giving a high-level overview of what each team member does.

1788
03:06:41.058 --> 03:06:41.203
<v Kevin Balick>Thank you.

1789
03:06:42.256 --> 03:06:48.379
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland Permitting and Development recommends priority properties to the Revenue Division for foreclosure.

1790
03:06:49.406 --> 03:06:56.025
<v Unidentified speaker>The City Attorney reviews each property and identifies barriers to foreclosure and advises us on legal matters.

1791
03:06:57.084 --> 03:07:08.784
<v Unidentified speaker>The Revenue Division reviews delinquent accounts, reviews the recommendations from Portland Permitting and Development and our City Attorney prior to moving a property forward with foreclosure consideration.

1792
03:07:08.864 --> 03:07:09.088
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1793
03:07:10.174 --> 03:07:19.429
<v Unidentified speaker>The Revenue Division makes attempts to engage the property owner in a resolution for their property, and the city treasurer conducts the foreclosure sale.

1794
03:07:20.940 --> 03:07:21.655
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

1795
03:07:24.906 --> 03:07:28.924
<v Unidentified speaker>This targeted approach for foreclosure started back in 2016.

1796
03:07:29.924 --> 03:07:34.327
<v Unidentified speaker>This was in response to address the vacant and distressed properties throughout the city.

1797
03:07:35.550 --> 03:07:42.144
<v Unidentified speaker>The city wanted to minimize the adverse effects that these types of properties cause in the neighborhoods that they are in.

1798
03:07:43.611 --> 03:07:59.131
<v Unidentified speaker>The goal of this foreclosure program is not to foreclose on the property, but the goal is to motivate the owner to correct the violation on their property and put the property back into a productive use.

1799
03:08:00.500 --> 03:08:08.144
<v Unidentified speaker>Foreclosure is used as a last resort when all other options next slide, please.

1800
03:08:11.984 --> 03:08:17.860
<v Unidentified speaker>These are some of the characteristics of what the referral— what the foreclosure referrals will look like.

1801
03:08:18.709 --> 03:08:25.813
<v Unidentified speaker>They start with the community member complaint against the property, which is routed through Portland Permitting and Development.

1802
03:08:27.209 --> 03:08:32.390
<v Unidentified speaker>For each property that is referred to foreclosure, I will order a police calls for service report.

1803
03:08:33.531 --> 03:08:40.539
<v Unidentified speaker>This report, this report identifies the police calls that have been called to the property.

1804
03:08:41.326 --> 03:08:46.153
<v Unidentified speaker>The dates I use are the date that the first lien was assessed to the property through the current date.

1805
03:08:49.319 --> 03:08:54.186
<v Unidentified speaker>All, all the properties that I will present today have a record of police involvement.

1806
03:08:54.477 --> 03:09:07.199
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember These properties typically have complaints for unlawful occupants at the property, uncared-for landscaping, excessive trash and debris being left at the property.

1807
03:09:08.170 --> 03:09:15.493
<v Unidentified speaker>If the owner doesn't clean it up, the property— the city then incurs costs for having to hire a private contractor to do the maintenance of the property.

1808
03:09:17.203 --> 03:09:19.123
<v Unidentified speaker>We ensure all properties are vacant.

1809
03:09:19.720 --> 03:09:24.319
<v Unidentified speaker>We do not want any lawful occupant displaced by our foreclosure program.

1810
03:09:25.463 --> 03:09:34.478
<v Unidentified speaker>Last week, Portland Permitting and Development went to each property that I will present today and confirmed there were no lawful occupants at the property.

1811
03:09:36.870 --> 03:09:45.259
<v Unidentified speaker>The owners of these properties are typically unresponsive to our letters, our phone calls, and they're not motivated by the incentives to correct the violation.

1812
03:09:47.984 --> 03:09:53.335
<v Unidentified speaker>With these violations going uncorrected and nothing being done, Over time, the properties get worse.

1813
03:09:55.459 --> 03:09:56.136
<v Keelan McClymont>Next slide, please.

1814
03:09:59.299 --> 03:10:06.217
<v Unidentified speaker>The city offers many opportunities for property owners to correct the violations and solve the delinquencies on their properties.

1815
03:10:07.379 --> 03:10:11.004
<v Unidentified speaker>One option available is the lien reduction review program.

1816
03:10:12.168 --> 03:10:18.501
<v Unidentified speaker>After the case is closed, property owners can apply to have their lien reviewed for a reduction in the balance due.

1817
03:10:20.250 --> 03:10:27.013
<v Unidentified speaker>Engaged owners who qualify are given fee waivers to allow time for them to work on the property and correct the violation.

1818
03:10:28.423 --> 03:10:32.237
<v Unidentified speaker>In the Revenue Division, we offer payment plans we can extend up to 60 months.

1819
03:10:32.930 --> 03:10:35.972
<v Unidentified speaker>We can also offer hardship plans that extend out to 12 months.

1820
03:10:37.283 --> 03:10:43.915
<v Unidentified speaker>We're also willing to work with property owners to come up with a mutual agreement to bring about a resolution in a reasonable time frame.

1821
03:10:43.979 --> 03:10:44.125
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1822
03:10:46.209 --> 03:10:51.921
<v Unidentified speaker>Consideration is given to those with financial, medical, or other hardships beyond the owner's control.

1823
03:10:53.649 --> 03:10:55.102
<v Unidentified speaker>We are not able to waive all fees.

1824
03:10:55.281 --> 03:11:02.048
<v Unidentified speaker>Hard costs incurred by the city, such as for cleanup, demolition, etc., we are not able to waive those fees.

1825
03:11:03.425 --> 03:11:09.034
<v Unidentified speaker>Once a property is approved for foreclosure, all of these options are no longer available.

1826
03:11:11.238 --> 03:11:11.933
<v Jamie Dunphy>Next slide, please.

1827
03:11:15.176 --> 03:11:19.756
<v Unidentified speaker>These are the results of our foreclosure program since its inception in 2016.

1828
03:11:21.059 --> 03:11:26.307
<v Unidentified speaker>57 Properties were referred to foreclo— referred for foreclosure consideration.

1829
03:11:27.750 --> 03:11:31.489
<v Unidentified speaker>42 Of those properties paid off prior to the foreclosure sale.

1830
03:11:32.860 --> 03:11:35.213
<v Unidentified speaker>$2.2 Million has been recovered.

1831
03:11:37.872 --> 03:11:41.787
<v Unidentified speaker>74% Of the foreclosure referrals avoided foreclosure.

1832
03:11:43.172 --> 03:11:46.135
<v Unidentified speaker>10 Properties have been sold at city foreclosure sales.

1833
03:11:48.074 --> 03:11:50.825
<v Unidentified speaker>$1.3 Million in proceeds was received from the sales.

1834
03:11:52.719 --> 03:12:01.601
<v Unidentified speaker>Because of the consistency of this program, owner engagement has, has significantly increased since I started in this position in May of 2023.

1835
03:12:01.648 --> 03:12:01.795
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1836
03:12:03.061 --> 03:12:06.915
<v Unidentified speaker>When I received this round of foreclosures, we started with 10 properties.

1837
03:12:08.840 --> 03:12:09.360
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

1838
03:12:12.739 --> 03:12:20.227
<v Unidentified speaker>Today I will present 4 properties, 4 residential properties with a combined total of 12 liens.

1839
03:12:20.968 --> 03:12:24.448
<v Unidentified speaker>All of the properties have code enforcement and nuisance liens on them.

1840
03:12:25.575 --> 03:12:27.573
<v Unidentified speaker>Roughly $265,000 is owed.

1841
03:12:27.620 --> 03:12:27.831
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1842
03:12:30.731 --> 03:12:31.281
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

1843
03:12:32.931 --> 03:12:36.295
<v Unidentified speaker>This is just a map showing you where the properties are located in our city.

1844
03:12:37.805 --> 03:12:38.601
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

1845
03:12:41.799 --> 03:12:47.466
<v Unidentified speaker>This property is located at 11514 Southeast Alder Street.

1846
03:12:48.352 --> 03:12:50.235
<v Unidentified speaker>This property is located in District 1.

1847
03:12:51.250 --> 03:12:54.862
<v Unidentified speaker>There are 2 liens against the property, delinquent since 2024.

1848
03:12:56.308 --> 03:12:58.379
<v Unidentified speaker>Roughly $6,700 is owed.

1849
03:12:59.375 --> 03:13:04.851
<v Unidentified speaker>The property owner is deceased, and the heir to the property is the owner's son, lives out of state.

1850
03:13:06.022 --> 03:13:09.265
<v Unidentified speaker>The son's plan is to sell the property after probate is closed.

1851
03:13:10.518 --> 03:13:16.362
<v Unidentified speaker>The cases are closed on the property, and the son did agree to a payment plan which was to start last month.

1852
03:13:17.824 --> 03:13:20.826
<v Unidentified speaker>He has not returned the agreement or made the initial payment.

1853
03:13:21.540 --> 03:13:22.940
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, for the payment plan.

1854
03:13:23.005 --> 03:13:24.356
<v Unidentified speaker>That's why I'm proceeding forward.

1855
03:13:26.690 --> 03:13:32.835
<v Unidentified speaker>If the agreement and payment is received prior to second reading, I will have this removed from the foreclosure list.

1856
03:13:34.319 --> 03:13:39.862
<v Unidentified speaker>The property complaints on this property are for unlawful occupancy and trash and debris being left at the property.

1857
03:13:41.594 --> 03:13:42.353
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

1858
03:13:44.314 --> 03:13:49.213
<v Unidentified speaker>The next property is located at 10218 North Tyler Avenue.

1859
03:13:49.998 --> 03:13:51.943
<v Unidentified speaker>This property is located in District 2.

1860
03:13:52.980 --> 03:14:00.386
<v Unidentified speaker>There's one lien against the property, delinquent since 2008, with $232,000 owed.

1861
03:14:01.810 --> 03:14:04.305
<v Unidentified speaker>This property has been vacant for several years.

1862
03:14:05.549 --> 03:14:09.204
<v Unidentified speaker>Portions of the roof have collapsed, leaving it open to the outside elements.

1863
03:14:11.129 --> 03:14:18.484
<v Unidentified speaker>Inside the, inside the home, portions of the wall— inside the home, portions of the wall coverings have excessive amounts of mold and mildew.

1864
03:14:18.531 --> 03:14:18.645
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1865
03:14:19.078 --> 03:14:19.627
<v Unidentified speaker>Growing on them.

1866
03:14:21.176 --> 03:14:26.487
<v Unidentified speaker>The top picture is a cur— is the current condition of the backyard.

1867
03:14:27.620 --> 03:14:30.381
<v Unidentified speaker>It appears there may be some— someone camping back there.

1868
03:14:31.700 --> 03:14:36.373
<v Unidentified speaker>Most recent complaints indicate that there's a rodent problem generating from this property.

1869
03:14:38.000 --> 03:14:46.103
<v Unidentified speaker>The property owner did reach out to me and asked for 6 additional— 6 months to figure something out As a way to rectify the problem.

1870
03:14:47.122 --> 03:14:58.434
<v Unidentified speaker>After reviewing the situation, the delinquency date, and considering all people that are being affected by the property in this condition, I've decided we're moving it forward with foreclosure consideration.

1871
03:15:02.399 --> 03:15:03.014
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

1872
03:15:06.231 --> 03:15:11.454
<v Unidentified speaker>The next property is located at 111 Northeast Killingsworth Street.

1873
03:15:12.774 --> 03:15:14.781
<v Unidentified speaker>This property is located in District 2.

1874
03:15:15.183 --> 03:15:16.885
<v Unidentified speaker>There are 2 liens against the property.

1875
03:15:18.313 --> 03:15:22.694
<v Unidentified speaker>The delinquent since 2024 with $6,800 owing.

1876
03:15:24.092 --> 03:15:27.077
<v Unidentified speaker>This property had 2 fires at it in 2022.

1877
03:15:27.847 --> 03:15:31.171
<v Unidentified speaker>The fire caused severe damage to the roof and structure of the home.

1878
03:15:32.343 --> 03:15:35.167
<v Unidentified speaker>This property is covered in— is covered in graffiti.

1879
03:15:35.809 --> 03:15:39.197
<v Unidentified speaker>In the past, there has been problems with unlawful occupants at the property.

1880
03:15:39.261 --> 03:15:39.388
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1881
03:15:40.807 --> 03:15:43.376
<v Unidentified speaker>This property has generated many complaints.

1882
03:15:45.090 --> 03:15:49.854
<v Unidentified speaker>This property was approved for foreclosure by council in September 2023.

1883
03:15:50.888 --> 03:15:56.005
<v Unidentified speaker>Prior to the foreclosure sale, the owner paid off the liens, causing us to remove it from the list.

1884
03:15:57.442 --> 03:16:04.227
<v Unidentified speaker>I have been speaking with the owner, and they are currently in negotiations with Habitat for Humanity to purchase the property.

1885
03:16:05.625 --> 03:16:11.837
<v Unidentified speaker>Habitat for Humanity plans to demolish the— demolish the property and build 4 townhomes on the property.

1886
03:16:13.819 --> 03:16:14.405
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

1887
03:16:16.992 --> 03:16:20.788
<v Unidentified speaker>The next property is located at 4121 Northeast Grand Avenue.

1888
03:16:21.352 --> 03:16:24.069
<v Unidentified speaker>This property is also located in District 2.

1889
03:16:24.474 --> 03:16:30.158
<v Unidentified speaker>There are 7 liens against the property, delinquent since— delinquent since 2020.

1890
03:16:30.721 --> 03:16:32.906
<v Unidentified speaker>With $19,600 owed.

1891
03:16:34.398 --> 03:16:38.316
<v Unidentified speaker>This property is a vacant lot originally purchased in 2016.

1892
03:16:39.136 --> 03:16:43.534
<v Unidentified speaker>The property was to be developed into a 3-story, 18-unit apartment building.

1893
03:16:44.514 --> 03:16:47.903
<v Unidentified speaker>The owner has not moved forward with the plans to build the apartment complex.

1894
03:16:49.347 --> 03:16:54.984
<v Unidentified speaker>The lot continues to have complaints for excessive vegetation growing, which is impeding the sidewalk.

1895
03:16:55.048 --> 03:16:55.191
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1896
03:16:56.496 --> 03:17:00.547
<v Unidentified speaker>There are constant cases of debris and trash being left on site.

1897
03:17:01.260 --> 03:17:04.450
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, unlawful occupants were seen camping at the property.

1898
03:17:05.400 --> 03:17:12.898
<v Unidentified speaker>There's been no engagement from the owner, and the city is continuing to incur costs for having to maintain the property.

1899
03:17:15.739 --> 03:17:16.406
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

1900
03:17:19.554 --> 03:17:22.690
<v Unidentified speaker>The next step in the city's foreclosure process yes.

1901
03:17:23.346 --> 03:17:27.737
<v Unidentified speaker>Council will vote at the next hearing on whether to move forward with these ordinances.

1902
03:17:29.115 --> 03:17:36.022
<v Unidentified speaker>If approved, it will authorize the council treasurer— the city will authorize the city treasurer to conduct the foreclosure sale.

1903
03:17:36.985 --> 03:17:41.135
<v Unidentified speaker>Property owners may pay the amount owed up until the sale date.

1904
03:17:42.176 --> 03:17:50.086
<v Unidentified speaker>After the sale, the former property owner can still reclaim the property during the 90-day redemption period.

1905
03:17:50.185 --> 03:17:50.381
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1906
03:17:50.448 --> 03:17:51.808
<v Unidentified speaker>That will conclude my report.

1907
03:17:51.988 --> 03:17:53.448
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd be happy to answer any questions.

1908
03:17:55.826 --> 03:17:56.665
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1909
03:17:56.728 --> 03:18:02.981
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Before we move on to councilor comments, Rebecca, do we have any public testimony signed up for any of these agenda items?

1910
03:18:03.481 --> 03:18:04.141
<v Rebecca Dobert>No one has signed up.

1911
03:18:05.011 --> 03:18:05.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1912
03:18:05.896 --> 03:18:06.522
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1913
03:18:07.280 --> 03:18:08.212
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

1914
03:18:08.308 --> 03:18:10.465
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much for the, uh, presentation.

1915
03:18:10.577 --> 03:18:23.165
<v Loretta Smith>Could you tell me how much in assessed value Um, did you, did you assess before, um, giving the foreclosure what's the assessed value of the properties, the 4 properties?

1916
03:18:25.143 --> 03:18:28.659
<v Unidentified speaker>That information I don't have readily available.

1917
03:18:29.579 --> 03:18:37.371
<v Loretta Smith>And the second one, the people that you think that there's some camping going on, uh, have we given them some information about getting shelter?

1918
03:18:38.841 --> 03:18:39.760
<v Unidentified speaker>That I can't speak to.

1919
03:18:39.888 --> 03:18:45.032
<v Unidentified speaker>That would be something, uh, the housing inspector Um, would have to be—.

1920
03:18:45.513 --> 03:18:45.771
<v Robin Johnson>The who?

1921
03:18:46.316 --> 03:18:49.448
<v Unidentified speaker>That would be something that the, the housing inspector would be in charge of.

1922
03:18:49.689 --> 03:18:55.212
<v Unidentified speaker>I could readily defer to Mike with Portland Permitting and Development.

1923
03:18:55.452 --> 03:18:58.761
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, Mike Liefeld, Portland Permitting and Development.

1924
03:18:59.484 --> 03:19:03.882
<v Unidentified speaker>Typically, our inspectors will try to make contact with occupants at the property.

1925
03:19:04.862 --> 03:19:12.020
<v Unidentified speaker>If they're available to speak with us, we inform them of safety net programs, resources available.

1926
03:19:12.388 --> 03:19:16.864
<v Unidentified speaker>But oftentimes we're not able to find somebody, so we're not out there surveilling the property.

1927
03:19:17.378 --> 03:19:18.565
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a site visit.

1928
03:19:19.063 --> 03:19:24.773
<v Unidentified speaker>We check on it a couple times, but oftentimes we don't come face to face with anyone to have that conversation.

1929
03:19:24.837 --> 03:19:28.254
<v Unidentified speaker>Our legal notices go out to the listed property owner, right?

1930
03:19:28.367 --> 03:19:35.872
<v Loretta Smith>I saw a couple of the tents where they were on site, and so I didn't know if someone was in those tents when you took the pictures.

1931
03:19:36.691 --> 03:19:53.024
<v Loretta Smith>And so I just wanted to make sure that we offered them some, um, resources for them to get off the streets so that they could have some safe and secure place to, to lay their head instead of on a foreclosed property, um, particularly the one that has rodents on them.

1932
03:19:53.522 --> 03:20:25.941
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, there's one in District 1, but I just wanted to make sure that no one is living in those properties or we do our best with our right to entry when we perform those inspections, and oftentimes when we do these occupancy verifications, we're limited to the right-of-way, or we can get permission from other properties, but we don't have explicit rights of entry to go knock on structures or announce ourselves and have people come out of temporary structures to talk with us.

1933
03:20:25.989 --> 03:20:28.030
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilmember Herbold, Thank you.

1934
03:20:29.924 --> 03:20:32.760
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Madam President.

1935
03:20:32.986 --> 03:20:35.641
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, thank you, Kevin Foster, for the presentation, and Jonas.

1936
03:20:36.386 --> 03:20:45.355
<v Dan Ryan>Um, can you explain to all of us— it was, it was moved to 3 months, we voted on that last year— the, the journey after we vote on it to foreclosure, correct?

1937
03:20:45.533 --> 03:20:46.582
<v Dan Ryan>What was it before that?

1938
03:20:47.242 --> 03:20:47.870
<v Unidentified speaker>It was 1 year.

1939
03:20:48.031 --> 03:20:48.837
<v Dan Ryan>That's what I thought.

1940
03:20:49.240 --> 03:20:56.472
<v Dan Ryan>So, um, so, um, That's kind of why I need to bring up the 111 Northeast Killingswood, uh, property.

1941
03:20:57.210 --> 03:21:00.997
<v Dan Ryan>Um, that's been a long journey, and we did vote on that.

1942
03:21:01.542 --> 03:21:06.100
<v Dan Ryan>Um, and you're now— I'm learn— so when I saw this on the agenda, I was quite surprised.

1943
03:21:06.677 --> 03:21:11.781
<v Dan Ryan>Um, and then you said that, that the, the owner came about and made a payment.

1944
03:21:11.828 --> 03:21:12.566
<v Dan Ryan>Could you explain that?

1945
03:21:12.630 --> 03:21:21.725
<v Dan Ryan>Because I didn't receive any communication as a public elected official who's worked hard to advocate for many neighbors, some who've had to who have left the neighborhood over that property.

1946
03:21:21.806 --> 03:21:25.283
<v Dan Ryan>Could you explain when that happened and why there was no communication?

1947
03:21:26.579 --> 03:21:26.629
<v Sameer Kanal>Sure.

1948
03:21:26.743 --> 03:21:30.193
<v Unidentified speaker>So we were preparing for the foreclosure sale in April of last year.

1949
03:21:31.860 --> 03:21:33.570
<v Unidentified speaker>Foreclosure sales are held on Monday.

1950
03:21:34.717 --> 03:21:43.783
<v Unidentified speaker>The owner actually paid the, the balance due on that Friday, so we— it was a last-minute thing, so we removed it immediately.

1951
03:21:45.763 --> 03:21:49.104
<v Dan Ryan>You removed it after we voted to do the foreclosure, so you removed it as an administrator, correct?

1952
03:21:49.170 --> 03:21:57.661
<v Unidentified speaker>No, no, no, we Removed it after the owner paid off the delinquent liens, and he paid them off right before the foreclosure sale.

1953
03:21:58.174 --> 03:22:18.302
<v Dan Ryan>My point I'm making, Kevin, is that when we make these— when we do these votes, especially now that we're in district government and we're going to be closer to the constituents that we're communicating with, when there's a change like that, we need to ensure that your office communicates with the public elected officials so they know What has changed?

1954
03:22:18.983 --> 03:22:20.859
<v Unidentified speaker>Definitely, we will definitely do that going forward.

1955
03:22:21.084 --> 03:22:29.842
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, I was surprised to see this, and I hope that this journey goes much faster because that's been delinquent and causing challenges for that neighborhood for quite some time.

1956
03:22:32.536 --> 03:22:33.020
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1957
03:22:33.584 --> 03:22:37.129
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I think that's the point that I really needed to deliver.

1958
03:22:38.750 --> 03:22:39.453
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1959
03:22:40.240 --> 03:22:40.879
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

1960
03:22:42.739 --> 03:22:43.540
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam President.

1961
03:22:43.722 --> 03:22:44.956
<v Mitch Green>Um, thanks for the presentation.

1962
03:22:46.379 --> 03:23:02.816
<v Mitch Green>I'm curious about the rules governing, um, the process by which you move from code enforcement, delinquency, liens to foreclosure, the opportunity to get it out of that status, go back a couple steps, and then, you know, go forward.

1963
03:23:03.427 --> 03:23:05.295
<v Mitch Green>Is that something the city controls by ordinance?

1964
03:23:05.504 --> 03:23:06.197
<v Mitch Green>Is it the county?

1965
03:23:06.293 --> 03:23:07.547
<v Mitch Green>Is it a state, state law?

1966
03:23:10.989 --> 03:23:11.872
<v Unidentified speaker>The city controls that.

1967
03:23:11.968 --> 03:23:23.957
<v Mitch Green>Okay, um, I, I just— I asked the question because I think we, we are in, we are in a housing crisis, and we cannot afford to spend years on properties.

1968
03:23:24.647 --> 03:23:24.663
<v Mitch Green>I—.

1969
03:23:24.710 --> 03:23:41.216
<v Mitch Green>Many of these, many of these owners are LLCs, developers, trusts, um, who, who, who've made speculative plays, and we're asking people in our community to suffer and wait for affordable housing so that these owners can realize the full value of their expected play.

1970
03:23:41.683 --> 03:23:49.801
<v Mitch Green>And so I would encourage us to think about policy that speeds this up and allows us to dispose of these properties at a much faster pace.

1971
03:23:50.237 --> 03:23:51.690
<v Mitch Green>That's the only comment I would like to make.

1972
03:23:55.996 --> 03:23:56.852
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

1973
03:23:59.146 --> 03:24:00.114
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, Madam President.

1974
03:24:00.583 --> 03:24:02.908
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, Councilor Smith, I have an answer for your question.

1975
03:24:03.376 --> 03:24:04.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>About assessed value.

1976
03:24:04.435 --> 03:24:05.013
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1977
03:24:05.479 --> 03:24:10.554
<v Eric Zimmerman>The total assessed value is $494,000 of assessed value.

1978
03:24:10.602 --> 03:24:11.421
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's not real market.

1979
03:24:11.822 --> 03:24:13.668
<v Eric Zimmerman>If you want the details of each one, I did that too.

1980
03:24:14.375 --> 03:24:21.102
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I have a question relative to— because I've done this on the county side as it relates to not paying your taxes.

1981
03:24:21.150 --> 03:24:27.765
<v Eric Zimmerman>So looking at these properties, I imagine there are some who also are delinquent in their property taxes.

1982
03:24:28.906 --> 03:24:36.736
<v Eric Zimmerman>If that is the case and these are sold, does the county property tax roll get made whole during the sale?

1983
03:24:39.770 --> 03:24:40.954
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to defer to Mark on that one.

1984
03:24:45.403 --> 03:24:46.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Introduce yourself.

1985
03:24:46.601 --> 03:24:47.345
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, councilors.

1986
03:24:47.426 --> 03:24:49.014
<v Unidentified speaker>Mark Rodriguez, Deputy City Attorney.

1987
03:24:51.292 --> 03:24:54.018
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so can you— sorry, I just— I will jump in.

1988
03:24:54.066 --> 03:24:54.783
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you repeat the question?

1989
03:24:55.046 --> 03:25:00.490
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm making an assumption that at least for some of these, they probably are also delinquent with their property taxes.

1990
03:25:01.245 --> 03:25:11.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>In the case where they are foreclosed and then we sell, is the county, from its property tax collection standpoint, made whole at the point of sale?

1991
03:25:12.314 --> 03:25:13.389
<v Unidentified speaker>So not necessarily.

1992
03:25:13.453 --> 03:25:14.015
<v Unidentified speaker>They can be.

1993
03:25:14.402 --> 03:25:20.264
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so as foreclosures being, uh, essentially, and legally speaking, it's a debt collection process, right?

1994
03:25:20.538 --> 03:25:32.201
<v Unidentified speaker>So the sales price and the formula, that's in the rules too, and there's state law that provides for this as well, but it's 75% of the assessed value, market value, or the liens plus cost of sale and so forth, whichever is greater.

1995
03:25:32.795 --> 03:25:33.708
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's the starting bid.

1996
03:25:34.444 --> 03:25:42.552
<v Unidentified speaker>Whatever the end sale price is at the bid during the foreclosure sale, the city is paid back first from the sale proceeds, right?

1997
03:25:43.033 --> 03:25:49.347
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the balance of that, there is per rule or per administrative rule now, um, a sequence of order of events.

1998
03:25:49.507 --> 03:25:52.859
<v Unidentified speaker>So whoever is a lienholder, there's essentially priority.

1999
03:25:53.036 --> 03:25:55.023
<v Unidentified speaker>Tax usually has the highest priority.

2000
03:25:55.537 --> 03:26:05.448
<v Unidentified speaker>So depending on that and the amount that it was sold, a portion would, in collaboration with the county— and we ask the same from them sometimes too— um, to pay the proceeds.

2001
03:26:05.495 --> 03:26:07.756
<v Unidentified speaker>And then other lienholders would be notified as well.

2002
03:26:07.900 --> 03:26:12.520
<v Unidentified speaker>So, and essentially any surplus of that after the amount owed goes back to the property owner.

2003
03:26:13.818 --> 03:26:21.566
<v Unidentified speaker>Goes back to the property the surplus of proceeds goes back to the property owner that we're foreclosing on, that the city is foreclosing on, if that makes sense.

2004
03:26:24.682 --> 03:26:30.161
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, uh, since I'm hearing whispers around the dais, I think it's worthy of a little discussion.

2005
03:26:30.209 --> 03:26:39.034
<v Eric Zimmerman>So you foreclose on my property, I owe both the city because I'm, I'm— I've allowed trash, I have code compliance issues, I have that lien.

2006
03:26:39.693 --> 03:26:41.769
<v Eric Zimmerman>I also haven't paid a few years worth of taxes.

2007
03:26:42.778 --> 03:26:48.815
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and it sells for $100,000, but my debt to those 2 agencies was only $20,000.

2008
03:26:50.164 --> 03:26:57.405
<v Eric Zimmerman>The remaining $80,000 goes to me as the property owner and not the city who foreclosed on it?

2009
03:26:57.549 --> 03:26:58.496
<v Eric Zimmerman>Am I getting that correct?

2010
03:26:58.610 --> 03:26:59.188
<v Unidentified speaker>That's correct.

2011
03:26:59.573 --> 03:26:59.734
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

2012
03:27:00.296 --> 03:27:05.433
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so are we then taking ownership of these properties at any point?

2013
03:27:06.059 --> 03:27:09.543
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, the foreclosure sale Well, no, sorry, not the city.

2014
03:27:10.265 --> 03:27:13.540
<v Unidentified speaker>So during the foreclosure sale, it's an auction, right?

2015
03:27:13.620 --> 03:27:16.960
<v Unidentified speaker>So whoever bids the highest ends up the owner of the property.

2016
03:27:17.409 --> 03:27:19.416
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, uh, thanks.

2017
03:27:19.801 --> 03:27:21.054
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that clarified some things.

2018
03:27:21.230 --> 03:27:25.131
<v Eric Zimmerman>Like I said, I've done this on the county side only from the tax perspective before, so appreciate that.

2019
03:27:25.967 --> 03:27:33.143
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, just in general, and I'll be quick, I just— I appreciate that we are doing this, and I— and Councilor Green, I appreciate your comments as well.

2020
03:27:33.207 --> 03:27:34.539
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think these are blights on the neighborhood.

2021
03:27:35.998 --> 03:27:46.799
<v Eric Zimmerman>And they have real impact across neighborhoods in a way that is on the news almost every day and immeasurable at the local level if you're on the street with these.

2022
03:27:46.863 --> 03:28:03.332
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I just want to highlight for the fact that I think some of our staff have tried previously and have been told, not by this council in the, in the past era, but by individual commissioners about how we're going to approach Code compliance, particularly related to homes.

2023
03:28:03.590 --> 03:28:07.926
<v Eric Zimmerman>And they were— the code compliance at different times was told, we're not going to do that.

2024
03:28:08.200 --> 03:28:12.451
<v Eric Zimmerman>And what it does is it creates these gaping holes of, of problems.

2025
03:28:12.727 --> 03:28:27.933
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so any modern society, any, any city our size has some aspect of this work, and it is important, and it has third, fourth order effects in terms of the livability across neighborhoods.

2026
03:28:28.191 --> 03:28:39.540
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so, um, I appreciate the staff process, which is we bring these only to you in the last— this is our last effort to try and fix something, because when we let things go too long, more of these show up.

2027
03:28:40.106 --> 03:28:44.630
<v Eric Zimmerman>And a few years ago, we really had to turn that spigot back on because this went unchecked for way too long.

2028
03:28:46.436 --> 03:28:57.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it's also, you know, you don't have to have it be occupied all the time, and you don't have to have a significant amount of money to keep things looking good.

2029
03:28:57.799 --> 03:29:07.501
<v Eric Zimmerman>But once, once the property, you know, nosedives into becoming a problem for everybody who is just trying to get by in the neighborhood, that's when we've crossed the line.

2030
03:29:07.565 --> 03:29:13.463
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that's important to note here, that this is not a grab at, at poverty situations.

2031
03:29:13.528 --> 03:29:15.859
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's not a grab at vacancy situations.

2032
03:29:15.906 --> 03:29:19.729
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's a grab on the impact that a property is having across the neighborhood.

2033
03:29:20.260 --> 03:29:31.234
<v Eric Zimmerman>I will also say that this cannot go— this is an important action today, and I'll be supportive of all these, but to continue the same work relative to our commercial properties.

2034
03:29:31.730 --> 03:29:39.897
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we have a number of them where we've got owners with significant means who are choosing not to do the right thing, and I'll have my eye to that as well.

2035
03:29:40.490 --> 03:29:41.372
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for the work.

2036
03:29:41.453 --> 03:29:42.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll support all these.

2037
03:29:42.319 --> 03:29:43.957
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for clarifying some questions there.

2038
03:29:44.021 --> 03:29:44.165
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

2039
03:29:44.647 --> 03:29:45.439
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, thanks.

2040
03:29:46.343 --> 03:29:49.893
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Madam President.

2041
03:29:50.377 --> 03:29:53.153
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I want to reflect a lot of the words that my colleagues have said.

2042
03:29:53.218 --> 03:30:01.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are in a housing crisis, and I also recognize that, uh, we have many exhausted neighbors across our city right now trying to deal with these properties.

2043
03:30:02.040 --> 03:30:05.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have no sympathy for people who are in active negligence of their own properties.

2044
03:30:06.189 --> 03:30:06.561
<v Unidentified speaker>These city—.

2045
03:30:06.756 --> 03:30:16.305
<v Jamie Dunphy>These properties are being allowed to sit negligent and become attractive nuisances that That is a problem.

2046
03:30:16.369 --> 03:30:26.592
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I will be actively having additional conversations about this in the Housing and Homelessness Committee, including understanding what the carrot and what the stick is with regard to these vacancies.

2047
03:30:27.745 --> 03:30:35.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>That said, I do want to raise a flag in that one of these 4 properties feels slightly different to me, and I'm going to be supportive of the ordinance.

2048
03:30:35.996 --> 03:30:52.263
<v Jamie Dunphy>But the first one that is on 115th and Alder, the one that is being proposed by Councilor the specifics of this, looking at the amount of liens owed being roughly 15% of the assessed value, and this clearly having been an older adult who aged in place and then died.

2049
03:30:53.545 --> 03:30:59.923
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have, uh, we have an increasing— a disproportionately aging population in Portland.

2050
03:31:00.340 --> 03:31:09.763
<v Jamie Dunphy>A lot of times people's wealth is entirely tied to their home, and when people don't have— when their kids move away, it often becomes complicated.

2051
03:31:09.810 --> 03:31:09.954
<v Kevin Balick>Thank you.

2052
03:31:10.435 --> 03:31:19.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is obviously slightly a different situation, but I just want to flag that there are older adults in our community who are struggling to be able to stay in place and to be able to maintain their options.

2053
03:31:19.754 --> 03:31:23.024
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I know we also have additional programs around that.

2054
03:31:23.218 --> 03:31:35.998
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I just want to make sure that we are keeping in mind that there is a difference between an institutional investor who buys a property with the intent of redeveloping, and when the market doesn't pencil the way they want, they let it sit fallow, versus someone who is truly struggling.

2055
03:31:36.047 --> 03:31:36.158
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2056
03:31:36.309 --> 03:31:38.097
<v Jamie Dunphy>Struggling to be able to maintain their home.

2057
03:31:38.662 --> 03:31:53.588
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I just wanted to get that out there and make sure that, that we are, uh, recognizing that there is a, a humane approach to this when it comes to an individual, and that we're not necessarily, uh, acting punitive towards someone who is not of means to be able to actually maintain.

2058
03:31:57.156 --> 03:31:57.804
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2059
03:32:01.847 --> 03:32:02.770
<v Sameer Kanal>I have a question.

2060
03:32:03.060 --> 03:32:07.722
<v Sameer Kanal>At the beginning of your presentation, Mr. Foster, you mentioned, uh, police calls specifically.

2061
03:32:08.155 --> 03:32:14.566
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that the, the number— are you looking at the dispatching out specifically to police or the 911 calls in the aggregate that relate?

2062
03:32:14.630 --> 03:32:17.628
<v Sameer Kanal>Because there are going to be fire-related calls and things like that.

2063
03:32:17.675 --> 03:32:19.343
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm trying to understand if those are captured.

2064
03:32:19.840 --> 03:32:28.222
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, these are specific police calls, and they give how many calls came to the property within the time frame and also what those calls were for.

2065
03:32:29.167 --> 03:32:39.209
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'd love to see this be a part of the calculation if there's other types of first response required, um, because we have a broader system as well.

2066
03:32:39.658 --> 03:32:47.942
<v Sameer Kanal>Not to erase the police portion of it, that's unique, but there may be other considerations that come up as well if it's a call that ends up going through fire or something like that.

2067
03:32:47.992 --> 03:32:50.031
<v Sameer Kanal>That's, um, just a comment there.

2068
03:32:50.094 --> 03:33:05.251
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd also like to understand— I agree with Councilor Zimmerman's point about commercial properties, and, um, as well as just Councilor Dunphy in general, but, uh, on everything, um, but But I, I also wanted to let the record show he said shucks.

2069
03:33:05.507 --> 03:33:18.851
<v Sameer Kanal>But the, uh, the, the other point I wanted to, to make is that the city would ideally have a right of first refusal over some of these properties before they go in.

2070
03:33:18.915 --> 03:33:21.515
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is something that we'll need— it's the council action.

2071
03:33:21.564 --> 03:33:38.495
<v Sameer Kanal>I know it's not anything that, um, our staff would be able to just do, but, um, And, and I think we have a broader conversation to have around land banking and asset management and a lot of other things there that I'd like to explore, and that does relate to this conversation in a tangential, at least, way.

2072
03:33:39.322 --> 03:33:41.282
<v Sameer Kanal>But just wanted to flag that for the record.

2073
03:33:41.412 --> 03:33:41.752
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thanks.

2074
03:33:44.750 --> 03:33:50.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For better or worse, by allowing my colleagues to go first, much of what I had written down has been said by Councilors Dunphy and Kanal.

2075
03:33:51.064 --> 03:33:52.488
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate both of your comments.

2076
03:33:52.590 --> 03:33:52.798
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

2077
03:33:53.568 --> 03:34:02.465
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While properties like this are often— are always a blight, they are occasionally also the only wealth development that an individual has.

2078
03:34:02.721 --> 03:34:24.909
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as we see more of these coming forward, I'll be looking for where that line is between a property that was a gamble, as some of my colleagues have talked about, and a gamble that the city shouldn't suffer from somebody making, and properties that are the only wealth an individual or a family has that, um, has fallen into disrepair.

2079
03:34:25.215 --> 03:34:28.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's an important line, and I appreciate Councilor Dunphy for bringing that up.

2080
03:34:29.450 --> 03:34:42.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I am really interested in having the conversation that Councilor Kanal brought up about why the city is selling off properties when we hear over and over that we need to be land banking and turning properties into affordable housing.

2081
03:34:43.566 --> 03:34:47.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I understand that the foreclosure process is in many ways a debt thank you.

2082
03:34:47.159 --> 03:34:57.379
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that the city is committed to following the asset relief process and that the delta in value of asset that we obtain goes back to the property owner.

2083
03:34:57.379 --> 03:35:11.500
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I think that there is a policy conversation to be had about the city's role in ensuring that these properties, when they have been a blight on a community, are actually turned into an asset for that community through land banking and development as affordable housing.

2084
03:35:12.280 --> 03:35:16.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know it's a conversation not relevant to these individual items, but I think that it's something that but we need to continue to i think about.

2085
03:35:16.292 --> 03:35:19.739
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Think this is an important time to air that issue.

2086
03:35:20.626 --> 03:35:22.349
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, I see your hand back up.

2087
03:35:22.494 --> 03:35:50.846
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, I'm sorry, I, um, I was gonna let it go, but while I'm supportive, I— those last 2 comments, I just want us to think there may be no greater authority that we have than taking someone's property, and I don't want those comments to go without At least a nod to a very thorough conversation, because one of the things that makes this look not like a grab for our government is that we don't ever take control of it.

2088
03:35:50.959 --> 03:35:51.695
<v Eric Zimmerman>We sell it out.

2089
03:35:52.081 --> 03:35:54.341
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I just— I want to nod there.

2090
03:35:54.405 --> 03:35:55.495
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is an important thing.

2091
03:35:55.847 --> 03:36:01.715
<v Eric Zimmerman>These make some sense, and there are a lot of examples in the past where we have bad history, right?

2092
03:36:01.843 --> 03:36:05.593
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so, um, I think we shouldn't keep things that we foreclose.

2093
03:36:05.690 --> 03:36:13.567
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's in our nature, in our, in our best interest to not have So, and I was off by $3,000 on that number earlier.

2094
03:36:14.213 --> 03:36:20.763
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, I appreciate that point, and I think that's why we need to have the policy conversation at some point.

2095
03:36:21.407 --> 03:36:22.051
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

2096
03:36:22.599 --> 03:36:23.210
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam Chair.

2097
03:36:23.259 --> 03:36:30.386
<v Olivia Clark>I was just going to suggest that we put a pin in this for the Housing Committee and definitely look at it, because there may be other options than us just taking it.

2098
03:36:30.450 --> 03:36:33.568
<v Olivia Clark>Maybe we turn it over to a nonprofit in the area.

2099
03:36:33.618 --> 03:36:34.417
<v Olivia Clark>There's, there's got to be lots of options.

2100
03:36:39.365 --> 03:36:43.769
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm so sorry, but Councilor Clark's, uh, comment made me think of something.

2101
03:36:43.816 --> 03:36:49.070
<v Sameer Kanal>You mentioned one of them is potentially in the process of being sold, uh, to Habitat for Humanity.

2102
03:36:49.568 --> 03:36:49.762
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

2103
03:36:50.131 --> 03:36:54.373
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, how would this process interact with that possibility?

2104
03:36:55.370 --> 03:37:04.796
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so if, if they move forward with foreclosure, um, the property owner They have a 90-day redemption after the foreclosure sale.

2105
03:37:05.442 --> 03:37:15.996
<v Unidentified speaker>So if they close— because the property will still be in the current owner's name— if they close on that sale prior to the redemption period ending, the sale can— the sale will go through.

2106
03:37:16.888 --> 03:37:17.197
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2107
03:37:20.295 --> 03:37:23.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, any other discussion?

2108
03:37:27.257 --> 03:37:32.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, these are ordinances that are non-emergency ordinances, so we actually are not voting today.

2109
03:37:32.931 --> 03:37:34.441
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a first reading.

2110
03:37:34.488 --> 03:37:38.507
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They'll move to second reading at our next council meeting.

2111
03:37:40.110 --> 03:37:45.995
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Rebecca, do you need any action from us other than an acknowledgement that we've now had the discussion and are moving forward?

2112
03:37:46.530 --> 03:37:47.426
<v Rebecca Dobert>No, we're good.

2113
03:37:47.605 --> 03:37:52.191
<v Rebecca Dobert>All items will move to second reading at March 19th, uh, 6:00 PM meeting.

2114
03:37:52.885 --> 03:37:56.415
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we will see these back on the agenda at our evening meeting later this month.

2115
03:37:58.055 --> 03:37:59.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all.

2116
03:37:59.831 --> 03:38:02.656
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2117
03:38:02.736 --> 03:38:08.102
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The final item on our agenda is a land transfer.

2118
03:38:08.620 --> 03:38:10.709
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, could you please read the agenda item?

2119
03:38:11.859 --> 03:38:29.057
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 15, declare property located at intersection of I-405 and South Northwest Naito Parkway as surplus property and authorize Bureau of Transportation to dispose of property to Oregon Department of Transportation in exchange for accepting property at west end of Steel Bridge ramps.

2120
03:38:30.989 --> 03:38:31.119
<v Kevin Balick>Thank you.

2121
03:38:31.166 --> 03:38:33.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And councilors, this is also a non-emergency ordinance.

2122
03:38:34.007 --> 03:38:38.818
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the first reading, so we are hearing information today and then it will go to second reading.

2123
03:38:40.528 --> 03:38:49.699
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, we'll turn it over to our Thank you.

2124
03:38:50.070 --> 03:38:53.768
<v Priya Dhanapal>Uh, good afternoon, Madam President, Madam Vice President, and members of the council.

2125
03:38:54.497 --> 03:38:57.343
<v Priya Dhanapal>I am Priya Dhanapal, Deputy City Administrator for Public Works.

2126
03:38:57.975 --> 03:39:07.157
<v Priya Dhanapal>Uh, this item comes from Portland Bureau of Transportation and seeks authorization to facilitate a land swap between the city and Oregon Department of Transportation.

2127
03:39:08.156 --> 03:39:19.007
<v Priya Dhanapal>Uh, the purpose of this land exchange is to consolidate property property rights at the west end of the Steel Bridge, enabling Portland Parks and Recreation to construct and maintain the future Old Town Skate Park.

2128
03:39:19.728 --> 03:39:30.001
<v Priya Dhanapal>By doing this, the city can move forward with this project while ensuring that PBOT, ODOT, and TriMet can continue to operate and maintain their respective facilities in and around the site.

2129
03:39:31.106 --> 03:39:39.219
<v Priya Dhanapal>This agreement represents a collaborative effort between multiple agencies to maximize the use of public land for both transportation and recreation.

2130
03:39:39.781 --> 03:39:47.569
<v Priya Dhanapal>And with council's approval, we will take an important step towards activating the space for community use while maintaining critical infrastructure.

2131
03:39:48.211 --> 03:39:58.310
<v Priya Dhanapal>And now I'm pleased to introduce Kevin Palack, supervisor with PBART Real Property Services, and Travis Ruball, Portland Parks and Recreation capital project manager.

2132
03:39:58.969 --> 03:39:59.772
<v Kevin Balick>Thank you, DCA.

2133
03:40:00.174 --> 03:40:02.245
<v Kevin Balick>Thank you, Council President, for introducing the ordinance.

2134
03:40:02.422 --> 03:40:03.513
<v Kevin Balick>Good afternoon, city councilors.

2135
03:40:04.252 --> 03:40:05.713
<v Kevin Balick>For the record, my name is Kevin Balick.

2136
03:40:05.793 --> 03:40:14.673
<v Kevin Balick>I'm a supervisor in PBOT's Real Property Services Group, here to discuss the property transactions associated with the Old Town Skate Park at the west end of the Steel Bridge.

2137
03:40:15.266 --> 03:40:21.095
<v Kevin Balick>Before I discuss the proposed transfers, I'd like to turn it over to Travis Ruball, Capital Program Manager from Portland Parks and Recreation.

2138
03:40:22.316 --> 03:40:22.845
<v Travis Ruball>Thank you, Kevin.

2139
03:40:22.958 --> 03:40:23.986
<v Travis Ruball>My name is Travis Ruball.

2140
03:40:24.033 --> 03:40:26.635
<v Travis Ruball>I'm a Capital Project Manager for Portland Parks and Recreation.

2141
03:40:27.389 --> 03:40:30.938
<v Travis Ruball>Uh, thank you for allowing us here today to talk about this very important project.

2142
03:40:31.019 --> 03:40:32.415
<v Travis Ruball>I'd like to start with a little history.

2143
03:40:33.090 --> 03:40:44.505
<v Travis Ruball>Over 20 years ago, Portland Parks and Recreation began working with an appointed advisory committee known as the Skatepark Leadership Advisory Team, otherwise known as SPLAT, to develop a citywide skatepark plan.

2144
03:40:44.569 --> 03:40:49.194
<v Travis Ruball>This plan identified Stillbridge Skatepark as the largest regional skatepark destination.

2145
03:40:50.190 --> 03:41:01.136
<v Travis Ruball>Council approval of this land swap agreement will mark a major milestone on realizing the vision set forth long ago by so many advocates of the project, including SPLATT and many others.

2146
03:41:02.129 --> 03:41:14.295
<v Travis Ruball>In fiscal year '23-'24, then Parks Commissioner Dan Ryan allocated $15 million in SDC funding and was joined by Prosper Portland with an additional $364,000 in project funding.

2147
03:41:15.843 --> 03:41:19.029
<v Travis Ruball>The skatepark system plan, which was approved by council in thank you.

2148
03:41:19.077 --> 03:41:26.045
<v Travis Ruball>The Skate Plan 2008 included over 35 public meetings, analyzed over 350 sites with a focus on equity for all wheeled riders.

2149
03:41:26.932 --> 03:41:36.246
<v Travis Ruball>The plan identified 13 skate spots— excuse me, skate spots— 5 district skate parks, and 1 regional skate park, the Stillbridge Skate Park in Old Town.

2150
03:41:39.927 --> 03:41:47.396
<v Travis Ruball>Upon council approval of this land swap agreement today, we will continue our community engagement plan with our current 18-member project advisory team.

2151
03:41:48.148 --> 03:41:57.224
<v Travis Ruball>Site investigation work will move forward with survey, geotechnical, environmental investigation, and design concepts will begin in earnest.

2152
03:41:57.689 --> 03:41:59.067
<v Travis Ruball>And with that, I'll turn it back over to Kevin.

2153
03:41:59.211 --> 03:41:59.772
<v Kevin Balick>Thanks, Travis.

2154
03:41:59.950 --> 03:42:00.286
<v Kevin Balick>Appreciate it.

2155
03:42:00.879 --> 03:42:13.465
<v Kevin Balick>Um, before you today, PBOT is requesting council declare surplus the property currently located within the I-405 freeway and the Southwest Naito Parkway overpass outlined in red and highlighted in yellow.

2156
03:42:14.188 --> 03:42:17.318
<v Kevin Balick>And sell the city's remaining undivided interest to ODOT.

2157
03:42:18.636 --> 03:42:27.707
<v Kevin Balick>In exchange, ODOT will sell its remaining undivided interest to the city in portions of property outlined in red located at the west end of the Steel Bridge.

2158
03:42:29.137 --> 03:42:49.153
<v Kevin Balick>The background behind the property transfer is that both sites are jointly owned remnants from the 1940s-era Harbor Freeway, in which the city owned a 60% undivided interest a successful trade of these property interests will result in each agency having sole ownership of their respective parcels.

2159
03:42:50.940 --> 03:42:53.618
<v Kevin Balick>To get here, PBOT went through the city surplus process.

2160
03:42:54.424 --> 03:43:01.224
<v Kevin Balick>In 2024, the property was declared to be excess to PBOT's needs and was then formally submitted for citywide review.

2161
03:43:01.954 --> 03:43:06.681
<v Kevin Balick>Having received no interest from other bureaus, PBOT is requesting that council formally designate the property as surplus.

2162
03:43:06.729 --> 03:43:07.055
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilmember Herbold.

2163
03:43:08.082 --> 03:43:16.236
<v Kevin Balick>In accordance with ADM 13.02 and , this property is eligible for disposition under Category 1 determination.

2164
03:43:16.994 --> 03:43:23.495
<v Kevin Balick>Both ODOT and city staff concur that the property rights had similar values, therefore no additional compensation is required.

2165
03:43:25.695 --> 03:43:40.025
<v Kevin Balick>The proposed council action before you today is to declare the city property at I-405 and Southwest Naito Parkway as surplus and authorize PBOT to transfer the city's 60% undivided interest to ODOT in exchange for ODOT's 40% undivided interest in the Steel Bridge site.

2166
03:43:40.764 --> 03:44:01.284
<v Kevin Balick>In addition, within 1 year of recording the property transfer deeds between the city and ODOT, Parks and PBOT will enter into a written agreement that describes the boundaries of the Steel Bridge Skatepark, creates springing easements or other protections for operation and maintenance of the Steel Bridge ramps, and transfers day-to-day control of the skatepark property to Parks.

2167
03:44:03.853 --> 03:44:11.064
<v Kevin Balick>Parks and PBOT would like to thank all the project partners, advocates, and stakeholders that continue to support the skate park at the west end of the Steel Bridge.

2168
03:44:11.577 --> 03:44:21.099
<v Kevin Balick>These include ODOT, TriMet, Prosper Portland, Old Town Community Association, Steel Bridge Skate Park Coalition, Skate Like a Girl, and many others.

2169
03:44:22.238 --> 03:44:22.864
<v Kevin Balick>Thank you, councilors.

2170
03:44:23.138 --> 03:44:26.799
<v Kevin Balick>We'll return to answer any additional questions and discussions after the invited testimony is over.

2171
03:44:27.251 --> 03:44:29.334
<v Kevin Balick>Along with any public testimony that there might be.

2172
03:44:29.899 --> 03:44:36.200
<v Kevin Balick>I'd like to now introduce the invited testimony of Ryan Hashigan, who is the director of the Steel Bridge Skatepark Coalition.

2173
03:44:40.819 --> 03:44:41.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, Ryan.

2174
03:44:41.436 --> 03:44:42.289
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

2175
03:44:43.739 --> 03:44:45.031
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thank you, councilors.

2176
03:44:45.240 --> 03:44:45.837
<v Sameer Kanal>Appreciate your time.

2177
03:44:47.000 --> 03:44:57.119
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, yeah, I just want to say that Portland Parks, SPLAT, Skaters for Portland Skateparks, and many others have been working on this for over 20 years.

2178
03:44:57.712 --> 03:44:59.721
<v Sameer Kanal>This day is one to celebrate.

2179
03:45:00.861 --> 03:45:08.879
<v Sameer Kanal>Our group, um, came into existence in 2017 when PBOT decommissioned a remnant Harbor Drive ramp through the site.

2180
03:45:09.425 --> 03:45:23.995
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, we conducted a ceremonial ribbon cutting, uh, uh, groundbreaking, and our first pour of concrete for the site, um, along with a press conference with speakers from Chicks in Bowls, Portland's All Wheels Welcome, Skate Like a Girl, and other organizations.

2181
03:45:25.166 --> 03:45:30.447
<v Sameer Kanal>Prosper Portland was very supportive, provided $250,000— over $250,000 in initial planning.

2182
03:45:31.281 --> 03:45:39.577
<v Sameer Kanal>And then in 2024, Commissioner Ryan stepped up and identified $15 million in SDC funds to realize this crown jewel of skate parks.

2183
03:45:40.588 --> 03:45:54.315
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan continues to be a great champion for this project, uh, helping provide guidance to city staff, ensuring this project will become a world-class skate facility, a new landmark for downtown Portland, attract showcase events and international talent.

2184
03:45:55.600 --> 03:45:59.969
<v Sameer Kanal>The skate park will be an inclusive, welcoming public space with plazas for spectating.

2185
03:46:00.644 --> 03:46:09.237
<v Sameer Kanal>There are plans for a potential kids section and beginner section that will activate the north section of Waterfront Park, and also plaza spaces for parents, grandparents, and tourists to spectate.

2186
03:46:10.458 --> 03:46:19.667
<v Sameer Kanal>The Seal Bridge Skate Park Coalition would like to thank, um, City Council, Commissioner, and Portland Parks leadership and staff for all their work on this project.

2187
03:46:20.799 --> 03:46:33.836
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, Project Manager Travis Rubio deserves significant appreciation for shepherding this project through the property transfer with ODOT and PBOT, all the while keeping an eye on building a skate park and plaza that will attract international attention.

2188
03:46:35.371 --> 03:46:40.736
<v Sameer Kanal>Finally, we'd like to thank the partners, the additional partners that have been crucial to this the process.

2189
03:46:41.560 --> 03:46:47.084
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, individuals at Prosper including Sarah King and Director Shea Flaherty-Benton.

2190
03:46:47.770 --> 03:46:56.688
<v Sameer Kanal>At PBOT, Gabe Graff, David Mackeldowney, Kevin Ballick, Director Millicent Williams, Art Pierce, and Deputy City Administrator.

2191
03:46:57.879 --> 03:47:04.415
<v Sameer Kanal>ODOT, we'd like to also call out to thank them for their, their participation in the transfer as well.

2192
03:47:04.962 --> 03:47:14.370
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, ODOT staff, along with Ryan Windsheimer at Region 1 and Director Chris Strickler, have been incredibly helpful making this process move smoothly.

2193
03:47:15.204 --> 03:47:16.087
<v Sameer Kanal>And then TriMet.

2194
03:47:16.489 --> 03:47:19.781
<v Sameer Kanal>TriMet is going to be helpful here in the future, and they've been helpful to date.

2195
03:47:19.941 --> 03:47:29.397
<v Sameer Kanal>Libby Winters at TriMet has helped in the process, and they will be working on, uh, the easements and the access of their ramps.

2196
03:47:29.976 --> 03:47:45.405
<v Sameer Kanal>But they also will be hopefully benefiting from having activation at the Old Town MAX And TriMet will serve this location as a regional destination, allowing youth and others to be able to get here by transit from throughout the metro region.

2197
03:47:46.325 --> 03:47:52.059
<v Sameer Kanal>With that, I'd like to just say thank you, Council, for this landmark decision, and I appreciate all your work.

2198
03:47:54.052 --> 03:47:55.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much for being here.

2199
03:47:56.305 --> 03:47:58.879
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rebecca, do we have any public testimony signed up?

2200
03:47:59.763 --> 03:48:01.147
<v Rebecca Dobert>We had one person signed up.

2201
03:48:02.265 --> 03:48:03.024
<v Rebecca Dobert>Libby Winter.

2202
03:48:06.543 --> 03:48:07.125
<v Rebecca Dobert>Libby Winter.

2203
03:48:13.549 --> 03:48:18.006
<v Rebecca Dobert>Looks like Libby's not joining us, and that would conclude testimony.

2204
03:48:20.569 --> 03:48:22.797
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, I see a number of hands in the queue for discussion.

2205
03:48:22.861 --> 03:48:24.717
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, would you like to kick us off?

2206
03:48:25.540 --> 03:48:25.912
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

2207
03:48:26.154 --> 03:48:31.674
<v Eric Zimmerman>I put my hand up in the queue to Hopefully set a tone as the district, uh, councilor for this area.

2208
03:48:32.299 --> 03:48:34.301
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am fully supportive of this swap.

2209
03:48:34.525 --> 03:48:39.381
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am fully appreciative of all the staff and advocates and neighbors who've been involved in this.

2210
03:48:40.230 --> 03:48:47.682
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know absolutely nothing about skateboarding, and I think this is a testament— you can be supportive for cool stuff that you know nothing about, right?

2211
03:48:47.906 --> 03:48:54.140
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then when I, when I think about Old Town, I've said it before, I think it's ground zero for so many of our other issues.

2212
03:48:54.638 --> 03:49:09.706
<v Eric Zimmerman>And when you are at the north part of Waterfront Park, it feels like you are a mile away from Lan Su Chinese Garden, given how difficult this area of our community is just to get from one part of a neighborhood to another.

2213
03:49:10.941 --> 03:49:29.715
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's been, it's been the subject of so many challenges over the years that this is An exciting swap and an important step toward, I think, a real solution, something that's innovative and something that the neighborhood needs significantly.

2214
03:49:30.308 --> 03:49:45.625
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to appreciate the nods to a variety of different cultural aspects that I think are going to be highlighted by this project in the future, a nod to the improvement of walking, biking, types of transit situations in that area.

2215
03:49:47.310 --> 03:49:57.185
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the connection that Old Town, I think, will feel by being connected to the north part of Waterfront Park, where we have an option besides just going across the steel bridge now.

2216
03:49:58.229 --> 03:50:07.606
<v Eric Zimmerman>And lastly, a deep appreciation to Councilor now and former Commissioner Ryan for putting some real money at this, because real money makes real things happen.

2217
03:50:07.896 --> 03:50:08.795
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you for that.

2218
03:50:09.468 --> 03:50:10.978
<v Eric Zimmerman>I hope everybody will be supportive today.

2219
03:50:11.027 --> 03:50:11.155
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

2220
03:50:14.117 --> 03:50:15.101
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2221
03:50:15.165 --> 03:50:17.118
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

2222
03:50:17.828 --> 03:50:25.757
<v Olivia Clark>Um, this is even more shocking than learning that our, uh, Councilor Zimmerman doesn't, uh, doesn't use a skateboard.

2223
03:50:26.750 --> 03:50:27.270
<v Olivia Clark>I don't either.

2224
03:50:29.018 --> 03:50:30.049
<v Olivia Clark>Um, never been on one.

2225
03:50:30.308 --> 03:50:31.889
<v Olivia Clark>Watched my brother skateboard a lot.

2226
03:50:32.647 --> 03:50:40.915
<v Olivia Clark>Um, but what I wanted to say is that this is a classic example of intergovernmental coordination, and I'm, I'm all about that.

2227
03:50:40.962 --> 03:50:44.846
<v Olivia Clark>I'm a real nerd for intergovernmental relations and making these things work.

2228
03:50:44.911 --> 03:50:45.986
<v Olivia Clark>And thanks to everybody.

2229
03:50:46.033 --> 03:50:46.724
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Ryan.

2230
03:50:47.381 --> 03:50:49.451
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, thank you all for making this happen.

2231
03:50:49.900 --> 03:50:59.352
<v Olivia Clark>I'll just echo what Councilman Zimmerman said, is that this is really important to activate this part of Old Town, the, the far north part of Old Town.

2232
03:50:59.737 --> 03:51:05.738
<v Olivia Clark>I'm really looking forward to that activation and what it can do, um, for more than just the skateboarders.

2233
03:51:05.915 --> 03:51:08.805
<v Olivia Clark>For really everybody in the area and citywide.

2234
03:51:09.337 --> 03:51:13.082
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you for all the hard work over the many, many years.

2235
03:51:13.194 --> 03:51:14.018
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate it.

2236
03:51:14.066 --> 03:51:16.319
<v Olivia Clark>And thank you to Councilor Ryan as well.

2237
03:51:20.165 --> 03:51:20.923
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

2238
03:51:21.793 --> 03:51:24.566
<v Mitch Green>I'm glad that the— thank you, Madam President.

2239
03:51:24.630 --> 03:51:26.813
<v Mitch Green>I'm glad that the first 3 of us are from District 4.

2240
03:51:27.170 --> 03:51:31.936
<v Mitch Green>Um, yeah, I just want to praise— I want to start by saying I praise the staff work that went into this.

2241
03:51:32.147 --> 03:51:36.334
<v Mitch Green>I think We're in this moment now where voters are like, what the heck's going on at the city?

2242
03:51:36.512 --> 03:51:38.343
<v Mitch Green>What's going on in our levels of government?

2243
03:51:38.391 --> 03:51:46.183
<v Mitch Green>And this is a really good example of sort of identifying constraints and working to clear those in a very sensible way that rationalizes the problem.

2244
03:51:46.730 --> 03:51:48.643
<v Mitch Green>So keep that up, and that's a model.

2245
03:51:49.365 --> 03:51:54.475
<v Mitch Green>I also want to uplift as well, Councilor Ryan, your vision and support here.

2246
03:51:55.968 --> 03:52:00.442
<v Mitch Green>I know it takes a little courage to go out and say, There are scarce resources.

2247
03:52:01.992 --> 03:52:04.718
<v Mitch Green>We should use that for this thing that I, that I believe very strongly in.

2248
03:52:05.316 --> 03:52:08.997
<v Mitch Green>And I think it's going to support the arts and economy work we're doing in our committee.

2249
03:52:09.435 --> 03:52:11.042
<v Mitch Green>We're talking about downtown activation.

2250
03:52:12.638 --> 03:52:18.129
<v Mitch Green>Um, you know, we're hearing from community members who are saying, you know, there's no reason for us to come downtown with my children.

2251
03:52:18.179 --> 03:52:19.145
<v Mitch Green>My children don't feel safe.

2252
03:52:19.628 --> 03:52:21.399
<v Mitch Green>Bring your children and teach them how to skateboard.

2253
03:52:21.640 --> 03:52:25.985
<v Mitch Green>We have, uh, you know, uh, girls— Skate Like a Girl, I think, is the organization that's on there.

2254
03:52:26.382 --> 03:52:27.284
<v Unidentified speaker>They do great work.

2255
03:52:27.896 --> 03:52:31.084
<v Mitch Green>Um, it's very accessible, and that's, that's what the skate park's going to be.

2256
03:52:31.278 --> 03:52:35.674
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'll note that, uh, I, I am a skater but not a very good one.

2257
03:52:36.272 --> 03:52:36.450
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

2258
03:52:37.162 --> 03:52:42.110
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I had my career stunted when I moved to a gravel road at the age of 13, so it doesn't work out.

2259
03:52:42.820 --> 03:52:52.815
<v Mitch Green>Um, but I, but I have fond memories of hanging out at the Burnside Bridge and just observing, trying to learn to skate, and feeling like a certain level of mentorship that you get from older people in the community.

2260
03:52:52.879 --> 03:52:52.944
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

2261
03:52:53.328 --> 03:52:55.175
<v Mitch Green>And learning how to behave and conduct yourself.

2262
03:52:55.239 --> 03:52:57.457
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's, that's part of the skater community.

2263
03:52:58.629 --> 03:53:04.347
<v Mitch Green>It's, it's going to lend some public safety benefits, not just to this area, but, but, but citywide.

2264
03:53:04.396 --> 03:53:13.632
<v Mitch Green>I mean, if we provide places for skaters to skate, then you'll, you'll see less sort of guerrilla skating innovations made that people complain about.

2265
03:53:14.099 --> 03:53:15.495
<v Mitch Green>So just a slam dunk here.

2266
03:53:15.720 --> 03:53:20.620
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to support it, and I look forward to buying a skateboard, I guess, and breaking my leg.

2267
03:53:20.668 --> 03:53:20.844
<v Robin Johnson>Thank you.

2268
03:53:22.753 --> 03:53:24.141
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks.

2269
03:53:24.835 --> 03:53:27.016
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you so much, Madam President.

2270
03:53:27.260 --> 03:53:28.584
<v Dan Ryan>And I'll just say a few things.

2271
03:53:28.712 --> 03:53:34.443
<v Dan Ryan>First, I want to say, when ODOT and PBOT can make a land swap, anything can happen.

2272
03:53:36.270 --> 03:53:36.558
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2273
03:53:36.930 --> 03:53:40.618
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I've been involved in a couple now, and it's— they seem to take quite long.

2274
03:53:41.068 --> 03:53:42.180
<v Dan Ryan>So bravo.

2275
03:53:42.566 --> 03:53:53.869
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I want to also say, um, when this investment was made from the system development charges There was a lot of heat coming, like, why would this be a good investment?

2276
03:53:54.494 --> 03:54:02.649
<v Dan Ryan>And I want to acknowledge how the hospitality community downtown, all of them, were really excited about this.

2277
03:54:03.323 --> 03:54:07.057
<v Dan Ryan>And it kind of makes me go back to, like, how the world's changed quite a bit in over 20 years.

2278
03:54:07.745 --> 03:54:09.844
<v Dan Ryan>So I'll wear my Uncle Danny hat right now.

2279
03:54:10.309 --> 03:54:16.787
<v Dan Ryan>So like all of you, I, I, you know, we had really bad skateboards back when I was Uh, somebody that would have done that.

2280
03:54:17.108 --> 03:54:18.763
<v Dan Ryan>In my teen years, they really improved.

2281
03:54:19.356 --> 03:54:22.987
<v Dan Ryan>And so I watched my nephews and nieces as I got older, um, do that.

2282
03:54:23.051 --> 03:54:23.807
<v Dan Ryan>Now they have children.

2283
03:54:24.320 --> 03:54:25.204
<v Dan Ryan>They're in their early 40s.

2284
03:54:25.959 --> 03:54:27.870
<v Dan Ryan>Tattoos with children, then they skateboard, right?

2285
03:54:28.336 --> 03:54:32.577
<v Dan Ryan>And it was, I think, an activist thing over 20 years ago for some reason.

2286
03:54:32.626 --> 03:54:35.468
<v Dan Ryan>And now it's more like, hey, this is a thing.

2287
03:54:35.726 --> 03:54:37.942
<v Dan Ryan>Like, everyone really likes this and my kids want it.

2288
03:54:38.393 --> 03:54:42.713
<v Dan Ryan>And I don't want to go traveling, um, into cities like Portland when there's nothing for my kids to do.

2289
03:54:42.795 --> 03:54:42.939
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

2290
03:54:43.067 --> 03:54:53.183
<v Dan Ryan>So basically, we heard from the owners of hotels and bed and breakfasts and such that our clients, when they come to the city, their children are often looking for something to do.

2291
03:54:53.775 --> 03:54:59.802
<v Dan Ryan>And so they will be able to hang out with the Ryans of the world and down in this wonderful park.

2292
03:55:00.203 --> 03:55:09.004
<v Dan Ryan>And I think it's something that will really lift Portland once again as that magical place where we take, um, life and joy to a different level.

2293
03:55:09.084 --> 03:55:09.277
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

2294
03:55:09.807 --> 03:55:12.986
<v Dan Ryan>And it's— so I think it's really important that we keep leaning into this.

2295
03:55:13.354 --> 03:55:16.694
<v Dan Ryan>And I want to thank Ryan and all your community members for being patient.

2296
03:55:17.128 --> 03:55:22.298
<v Dan Ryan>I think all of you have probably— you've all aged, of course, 20-plus years in this process as well.

2297
03:55:22.891 --> 03:55:24.320
<v Dan Ryan>And so it's a long time coming.

2298
03:55:24.737 --> 03:55:41.156
<v Dan Ryan>And co-chair Green didn't mention, because he's a humble guy, but on the next Arts and Economy Committee meeting, we will have panels, 3 panels, that look at, uh, investments that we're making to activate downtown where we already are in motion.

2299
03:55:41.541 --> 03:55:42.856
<v Dan Ryan>So we don't need to stop that motion.

2300
03:55:42.905 --> 03:55:44.252
<v Dan Ryan>In fact, we have to expedite it.

2301
03:55:44.637 --> 03:55:50.234
<v Dan Ryan>And we look forward, um, to all of you, uh, coming to, to be on that panel at that, on that, that time.

2302
03:55:50.586 --> 03:55:54.291
<v Dan Ryan>And I just want to let my colleagues know that we'll be drilling down into this at the next committee meeting.

2303
03:55:54.820 --> 03:55:57.307
<v Dan Ryan>And with that, um, looking forward to voting yes on this.

2304
03:55:57.548 --> 03:55:57.804
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

2305
03:55:58.189 --> 03:55:59.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dunphy.

2306
03:56:00.674 --> 03:56:00.948
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2307
03:56:01.012 --> 03:56:08.856
<v Jamie Dunphy>As quickly as I can, because I know this is the final issue, but this is not in my district any We're close, and I am no longer a skater, but I was for quite a while.

2308
03:56:09.259 --> 03:56:18.326
<v Jamie Dunphy>But this is the kind of, uh, complicated, community-driven, cross-jurisdictional, uh, issue that I ran for office on.

2309
03:56:18.406 --> 03:56:34.005
<v Jamie Dunphy>Taking something that is currently a nuisance in the community and turning it into an asset in response to the community around it is the exact kind of thing that we should be spending our time on— finding opportunities to uplift those kinds of projects, both specifically this project as well.

2310
03:56:34.069 --> 03:56:42.827
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm really bullish about where the future of this, and I'm excited to be as supportive as I can, but also looking for opportunities like this in every section of our city.

2311
03:56:43.677 --> 03:56:46.084
<v Jamie Dunphy>These are the kinds of things that the community wants us to do.

2312
03:56:46.164 --> 03:56:51.521
<v Jamie Dunphy>They want us to take properties that are a problem and turn them into something that people actually feel proud of.

2313
03:56:51.649 --> 03:56:55.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you to everybody for the patience that has been involved in this.

2314
03:56:55.708 --> 03:56:58.531
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is an extremely long process to get anything through government.

2315
03:56:58.578 --> 03:56:58.674
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2316
03:56:59.397 --> 03:57:04.791
<v Jamie Dunphy>And thank you, Councilor Ryan, for the— your prior work on this and making sure that this is actually going to happen.

2317
03:57:04.888 --> 03:57:05.834
<v Sameer Kanal>So thank you.

2318
03:57:07.200 --> 03:57:08.468
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

2319
03:57:08.966 --> 03:57:10.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, thank you, presenters.

2320
03:57:10.636 --> 03:57:11.229
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to Ryan.

2321
03:57:11.293 --> 03:57:14.216
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to Councilor Ryan and then Commissioner for your work on this.

2322
03:57:14.504 --> 03:57:21.070
<v Sameer Kanal>The magic word here, I do think, is activation, and I appreciate the call-out by multiple colleagues on the public safety side of this.

2323
03:57:21.391 --> 03:57:30.361
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that is something that connects this, even though it is It's, it's many things, but it is one of those things is a public safety, uh, thing.

2324
03:57:30.474 --> 03:57:31.789
<v Sameer Kanal>So I, I appreciate that.

2325
03:57:32.157 --> 03:57:35.766
<v Sameer Kanal>I do think we should all have to be on the record as to whether or not we were skaters or not.

2326
03:57:36.313 --> 03:57:49.867
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I think it's not just were you or were you not, but also can you, can you point to if you skated on a PlayStation, which is how I got into the, the Tony Hawk Pro Skater 2, um, Goldfinger, Superman, all that stuff.

2327
03:57:50.186 --> 03:57:52.385
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, yeah, that's, that's an important thing.

2328
03:57:52.433 --> 03:57:53.949
<v Sameer Kanal>We should have to do that as part of our votes.

2329
03:57:54.111 --> 03:57:54.855
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, and thank you.

2330
03:57:55.261 --> 03:58:00.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't even know— I'm happy to explain Tony Hawk to you some other time, Councilor Ryan.

2331
03:58:00.990 --> 03:58:03.591
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was a large part of my time spent with some of my cousins.

2332
03:58:06.020 --> 03:58:13.620
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, councilors, this item will move to a second reading on our March 19th agenda.

2333
03:58:14.022 --> 03:58:15.719
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the last item on our agenda.

2334
03:58:15.800 --> 03:58:26.043
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to note for the record that, um, The afternoon council meeting that we were previously recessing until has been canceled.

2335
03:58:26.157 --> 03:58:37.788
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That noise violation, or rather noise, um, uh, the appeal of the noise ordinance exception was withdrawn, so we will not be seeing that any longer.

2336
03:58:38.320 --> 03:58:43.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, tomorrow we do have an executive session, but there are no other public council meetings this week.

2337
03:58:44.764 --> 03:58:48.461
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, So with that, I will close today's meeting.

2338
03:58:48.976 --> 03:58:57.101
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, and Councilors Avalos, Smith, Clark, and Murillo, if you all can hang back for just a minute, uh, Shuli's wanting to do a picture.

2339
03:58:57.148 --> 03:58:57.325
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2340
03:58:57.807 --> 03:58:59.718
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all and have a good rest of your day.

