WEBVTT

1
00:07:35.065 --> 00:07:35.759
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning.

2
00:07:35.937 --> 00:07:42.543
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am going to call to order our City Council meeting on February 5th at 9:34 AM.

3
00:07:43.781 --> 00:07:50.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a couple of important things on the agenda this morning, and I know we have a lot of guests with us today.

4
00:07:52.389 --> 00:08:01.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Before we begin, I just want to address the fact that I know that there are a number of folks who are here today who are very frustrated with the city.

5
00:08:01.870 --> 00:08:10.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Many of us have heard from you, and we know that you are disappointed that the administration signed off on Zenith's land use compatibility statement.

6
00:08:10.122 --> 00:08:10.269
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

7
00:08:10.954 --> 00:08:21.040
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know some of my colleagues at the dais are equally frustrated, and I know that many of us equally distrust Zenith and their business practices in the city.

8
00:08:21.956 --> 00:08:31.641
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I've personally heard from many of you that you are angry that the city seemed to operate in the past behind closed doors and that it looked like Zenith might have gotten special treatment.

9
00:08:32.958 --> 00:08:37.826
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just like no company should get special treatment, though, no company should have the law applied to them unequally.

10
00:08:38.003 --> 00:08:48.278
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember We have to create strong laws that protect Portland and ensure that those laws are implemented well, raise concerns when they aren't.

11
00:08:49.162 --> 00:09:00.225
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's why one of my colleagues— 2 of my colleagues actually— are working on a resolution to ensure that there is an investigation into the city's dealings with Zenith, to ensure that our laws were implemented correctly.

12
00:09:00.899 --> 00:09:03.644
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it's why we held a hearing that I know many of you were at.

13
00:09:03.725 --> 00:09:04.014
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

14
00:09:04.496 --> 00:09:20.115
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we'll continue to hold hearings on a number of topics to determine ways that we can strengthen our laws to ensure that we actually transition to a renewable energy economy with fewer safety risks associated with some of the fuels that I know many of you are concerned with.

15
00:09:20.903 --> 00:09:25.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to thank you for being here and continuing to remind us that this issue is important.

16
00:09:26.462 --> 00:09:29.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll also ask that throughout this meeting we treat each other with respect.

17
00:09:30.812 --> 00:09:38.320
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that council has the time to ask many of the important questions of Mr. Jordan and Mr. Taylor that are on our agenda for today.

18
00:09:40.732 --> 00:09:45.169
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, I will ask our attorney to read the rules of decorum.

19
00:09:45.283 --> 00:09:46.142
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, minutes first.

20
00:09:47.062 --> 00:09:48.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, agenda first.

21
00:09:48.496 --> 00:09:52.138
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, if I can call the roll just to establish quorum, then we'll be set.

22
00:09:52.217 --> 00:09:52.863
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

23
00:09:53.087 --> 00:09:53.556
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

24
00:09:54.619 --> 00:09:54.908
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

25
00:09:56.009 --> 00:09:56.145
<v Michael Jordan>Here.

26
00:09:56.518 --> 00:09:56.754
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

27
00:09:58.538 --> 00:09:58.668
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

28
00:09:59.571 --> 00:09:59.683
<v Owen Nguyen>Here.

29
00:09:59.828 --> 00:10:00.280
<v Keelan McClymont>Here.

30
00:10:01.038 --> 00:10:01.571
<v Edith Gillis>Here.

31
00:10:02.249 --> 00:10:02.312
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Here.

32
00:10:03.538 --> 00:10:03.652
<v Mitch Green>Here.

33
00:10:04.830 --> 00:10:04.942
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Here.

34
00:10:05.330 --> 00:10:06.410
<v Michael Jordan>Here.

35
00:10:06.782 --> 00:10:06.958
<v Keelan McClymont>Here.

36
00:10:07.587 --> 00:10:07.750
<v Edith Gillis>Here.

37
00:10:08.008 --> 00:10:08.894
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

38
00:10:10.572 --> 00:10:14.028
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Attorney, could you please, um, read our rules of decorum?

39
00:10:14.936 --> 00:10:15.649
<v Nancy Thorington>Yes, good morning.

40
00:10:16.006 --> 00:10:17.693
<v Nancy Thorington>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

41
00:10:18.139 --> 00:10:23.938
<v Nancy Thorington>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

42
00:10:27.562 --> 00:10:31.381
<v Nancy Thorington>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

43
00:10:32.072 --> 00:10:36.197
<v Nancy Thorington>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

44
00:10:36.711 --> 00:10:39.118
<v Nancy Thorington>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

45
00:10:39.663 --> 00:10:41.686
<v Nancy Thorington>The presiding officer preserves order.

46
00:10:42.167 --> 00:10:51.283
<v Nancy Thorington>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

47
00:10:52.037 --> 00:10:55.392
<v Nancy Thorington>If you cause a disruption, Oh yeah, there we go.

48
00:10:55.568 --> 00:10:56.371
<v Nancy Thorington>Let's try that.

49
00:10:56.611 --> 00:10:57.094
<v Nancy Thorington>Oh, better.

50
00:10:57.913 --> 00:11:00.113
<v Nancy Thorington>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

51
00:11:00.562 --> 00:11:03.244
<v Nancy Thorington>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

52
00:11:03.758 --> 00:11:07.626
<v Nancy Thorington>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

53
00:11:08.092 --> 00:11:11.351
<v Nancy Thorington>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

54
00:11:12.091 --> 00:11:14.514
<v Nancy Thorington>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

55
00:11:14.980 --> 00:11:17.133
<v Nancy Thorington>When testifying, state your name for the record.

56
00:11:17.308 --> 00:11:18.738
<v Nancy Thorington>Your address is not necessary.

57
00:11:19.236 --> 00:11:22.316
<v Nancy Thorington>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

58
00:11:22.783 --> 00:11:26.716
<v Nancy Thorington>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

59
00:11:27.394 --> 00:11:27.684
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

60
00:11:30.304 --> 00:11:30.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

61
00:11:31.825 --> 00:11:36.046
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, councilors, we now need to approve the agenda.

62
00:11:36.126 --> 00:11:43.032
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there any requests to reorder agenda items or add an item to the next meeting's agenda?

63
00:11:47.299 --> 00:11:47.687
<v Owen Nguyen>Okay.

64
00:11:51.624 --> 00:11:52.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

65
00:11:52.741 --> 00:11:54.524
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not a motion, I just have a question.

66
00:11:55.782 --> 00:12:00.188
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, are the lengths of time in here something that, that is part of this conversation?

67
00:12:00.769 --> 00:12:09.056
<v Sameer Kanal>And if we're running under on one item and over on another, is that going to be a concern, or do we need to amend that now to add more time to one of these?

68
00:12:10.376 --> 00:12:19.567
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Other than the time-certain agenda items, I believe that the times are there as a— as guidance to the public on what to expect but are not binding.

69
00:12:19.615 --> 00:12:20.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

70
00:12:20.596 --> 00:12:20.917
<v Olivia Clark>That's correct.

71
00:12:20.998 --> 00:12:21.350
<v Glen Devitt>Thank you.

72
00:12:25.802 --> 00:12:28.794
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any requests to reorder or move things on the agenda?

73
00:12:29.296 --> 00:12:32.672
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, without objection, we'll move on.

74
00:12:34.059 --> 00:12:35.528
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, public communications.

75
00:12:35.725 --> 00:12:38.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Clerk, can you please invite up our folks who are here for public comment today?

76
00:12:39.568 --> 00:12:40.153
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, thank you.

77
00:12:40.234 --> 00:12:42.503
<v Keelan McClymont>First up we have Injured and Pissed Off.

78
00:12:44.221 --> 00:12:47.414
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we'll move on.

79
00:12:48.909 --> 00:12:52.407
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, next, next up we have Carrie Ko.

80
00:12:53.196 --> 00:12:57.096
<v Carrie Ko>We'd like to come up as a group for the 3 of us, is that all right?

81
00:12:57.210 --> 00:13:01.553
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, uh, Carrie Ko, Glenn Devitt, and Ana Maria Perez.

82
00:13:02.105 --> 00:13:02.283
<v Michael Jordan>Okay.

83
00:13:06.105 --> 00:13:08.803
<v Keelan McClymont>Carrie, would you like 9 minutes to share?

84
00:13:10.899 --> 00:13:13.043
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, and is Carl Klo also—.

85
00:13:13.332 --> 00:13:15.991
<v Carrie Ko>Oh, I think, um, I don't know.

86
00:13:16.089 --> 00:13:17.749
<v Ana Maria Perez>I think, I think the 3 minutes for each of us is fine.

87
00:13:17.942 --> 00:13:18.442
<v Keelan McClymont>3 Minutes.

88
00:13:18.571 --> 00:13:20.164
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, thank you.

89
00:13:20.438 --> 00:13:21.259
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

90
00:13:26.942 --> 00:13:27.249
<v Candace Jimenez>Great.

91
00:13:27.748 --> 00:13:28.633
<v Carrie Ko>Uh, hello, Council.

92
00:13:28.714 --> 00:13:30.018
<v Carrie Ko>Uh, thank you for having us today.

93
00:13:30.099 --> 00:13:31.485
<v Carrie Ko>My name is Carrie Ko.

94
00:13:31.613 --> 00:13:34.577
<v Carrie Ko>I am with the City of Portland Professional Workers Union, CPPW.

95
00:13:34.691 --> 00:13:41.706
<v Carrie Ko>We are here today to introduce you to our union and to update you about our experience in contract negotiations.

96
00:13:42.443 --> 00:13:44.991
<v Carrie Ko>I am a city worker at Portland Permitting and Development.

97
00:13:45.168 --> 00:13:50.327
<v Carrie Ko>I was also part of founding this union and, and am currently serve as union president.

98
00:13:51.033 --> 00:13:52.491
<v Carrie Ko>Uh, I'm not alone here today.

99
00:13:52.620 --> 00:13:58.613
<v Carrie Ko>There are those up here with me, behind me, and watching, uh, representing our 800 members around the city.

100
00:13:59.269 --> 00:14:04.192
<v Carrie Ko>Um, classifications in our union include coordinators, analysts, admin specialists, and more.

101
00:14:04.881 --> 00:14:10.177
<v Carrie Ko>We are part of virtually every program here at the city, doing the people's business, doing essential work.

102
00:14:10.851 --> 00:14:16.419
<v Carrie Ko>Our work helps provide the services that Portlanders need from city government so that they can thrive and be successful.

103
00:14:17.174 --> 00:14:19.886
<v Carrie Ko>Think of us as kind of the glue that holds things together.

104
00:14:20.448 --> 00:14:29.178
<v Carrie Ko>We started this union because we wanted clarity in our working conditions, protections on the job, and a voice at decision-making tables that affect our careers and our families.

105
00:14:29.916 --> 00:14:31.807
<v Carrie Ko>We have been negotiating for nearly a year.

106
00:14:32.513 --> 00:14:37.754
<v Carrie Ko>Our experience is that Labor Relations says they want to get to the end and to settle this contract.

107
00:14:38.011 --> 00:14:40.320
<v Carrie Ko>However, they are not making it happen.

108
00:14:40.913 --> 00:14:42.163
<v Carrie Ko>They are dragging their feet.

109
00:14:43.302 --> 00:14:49.297
<v Carrie Ko>As we move into mediation, we are asking you to empower your negotiators at the table to settle this contract.

110
00:14:49.970 --> 00:15:00.822
<v Carrie Ko>The city does not need to push every contract through an expensive mediation process or force every union to exercise our right to strike in order to secure a fair and reasonable contract for your workers.

111
00:15:00.870 --> 00:15:01.254
<v Loretta Smith>Councilmember Herbold.

112
00:15:02.009 --> 00:15:08.371
<v Carrie Ko>So please empower your team to settle this contract so that we can focus on being your partner to move the city forward.

113
00:15:09.029 --> 00:15:11.931
<v Carrie Ko>We've also heard that you've inherited a difficult budget cycle.

114
00:15:12.427 --> 00:15:18.086
<v Carrie Ko>Our members are the financial and data analysts around the city, so we have a unique perspective on the budget.

115
00:15:18.182 --> 00:15:20.009
<v Carrie Ko>We'd love to talk with you more about that at some point.

116
00:15:20.746 --> 00:15:32.177
<v Carrie Ko>Potentially tough budget is one thing, but what we find problematic is the relentless and fearmongering communications about budgets resets and layoffs coming out of the City Administrator's Office.

117
00:15:32.835 --> 00:15:39.715
<v Carrie Ko>On top of all the national chaos that we are experiencing, this creates fear, low morale, and discontent in your workers.

118
00:15:41.014 --> 00:15:45.729
<v Carrie Ko>This is the time for us to focus our collective energies and be clear about our priorities.

119
00:15:46.243 --> 00:15:55.933
<v Carrie Ko>We are asking Council to use your power to refocus the transition and the budget on providing essential services that Portlanders need want and are required to have.

120
00:15:56.761 --> 00:15:59.346
<v Carrie Ko>Our members execute the city's core priorities.

121
00:15:59.525 --> 00:16:00.418
<v Carrie Ko>We do that work.

122
00:16:01.309 --> 00:16:09.748
<v Carrie Ko>So please empower your team to settle the contract so the city can live in its values and so that your workers can have the stability that we need to do the people's business.

123
00:16:10.426 --> 00:16:12.576
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

124
00:16:16.567 --> 00:16:17.068
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

125
00:16:20.576 --> 00:16:20.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

126
00:16:22.020 --> 00:16:22.919
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

127
00:16:23.063 --> 00:16:25.326
<v Glen Devitt>Good morning, Council, Mr. Mayor, Chief Administrator.

128
00:16:25.807 --> 00:16:28.071
<v Glen Devitt>I appreciate this opportunity to address the Council.

129
00:16:28.134 --> 00:16:28.456
<v Glen Devitt>Thank you.

130
00:16:29.258 --> 00:16:30.461
<v Glen Devitt>My name is Glen C. Devitt.

131
00:16:31.327 --> 00:16:34.809
<v Glen Devitt>Like you, I am a city worker and I am honored to serve the people of Portland.

132
00:16:35.917 --> 00:16:39.173
<v Glen Devitt>I am also a proud member of the City of Portland Professional Workers Union.

133
00:16:40.394 --> 00:16:47.886
<v Glen Devitt>I work at the Portland Bureau of Emergency Management where I coordinate our volunteer first responder program, and I'm also an on-call duty officer.

134
00:16:48.833 --> 00:17:02.405
<v Glen Devitt>I know that as a group you've been educated about my bureau's work and our holistic perspective on city business, and our entire reason for existing as a bureau is to support emergency responders and protect the public's well-being and their property.

135
00:17:03.273 --> 00:17:07.924
<v Glen Devitt>Now, I want to be clear, when I say emergency responders, I mean every single city employee.

136
00:17:08.983 --> 00:17:13.828
<v Glen Devitt>Emergency responders are not only our brave and visible frontline personnel like firefighters and police.

137
00:17:14.618 --> 00:17:18.334
<v Glen Devitt>CPPW members are also essential for many critical functions.

138
00:17:19.740 --> 00:17:30.141
<v Glen Devitt>For example, emergency responders include the CPPW workers who are procurement and grant specialists obtaining the critical materials that we need to support shelters for homeless populations today.

139
00:17:31.345 --> 00:17:37.997
<v Glen Devitt>Emergency responders include the CPPW workers who issue permits that ensure that businesses can keep their doors open and serve the public safety.

140
00:17:39.765 --> 00:17:46.739
<v Glen Devitt>Emergency responders include CPPW workers at the Police Bureau who are on call as victims' advocates to protect those most impacted by crimes.

141
00:17:47.189 --> 00:18:01.819
<v Glen Devitt>Emergency responders include CPBW professional communications staff who in the last few days have been very busy ensuring that Portlanders— Portlanders know what to do in the case of winter weather, how to get around, how to care for the most vulnerable among us, and where to go for resources.

142
00:18:02.750 --> 00:18:16.891
<v Glen Devitt>Emergency responders include CPBW Housing Bureau staff who, in response to federal threats of withdrawal of funding, I could go on, but I won't.

143
00:18:18.218 --> 00:18:20.191
<v Glen Devitt>CPPW is seeking labor peace.

144
00:18:21.016 --> 00:18:22.551
<v Glen Devitt>No one wants a strike.

145
00:18:23.619 --> 00:18:32.727
<v Glen Devitt>As an independent union led by volunteers and staffed by volunteers, our goal is to preserve stable, high-impact jobs in the City of Portland and attract the best possible talent.

146
00:18:33.599 --> 00:18:36.138
<v Glen Devitt>The city's negotiators seem to be using stall tactics to exhaust us.

147
00:18:36.284 --> 00:18:36.752
<v Candace Avalos>Councilmember Herbold.

148
00:18:37.086 --> 00:18:37.586
<v Robert Butler>Makes sense.

149
00:18:38.310 --> 00:18:43.195
<v Glen Devitt>But let's stop wasting time and tax dollars on expensive mediation and strike preparation.

150
00:18:43.873 --> 00:18:44.921
<v Glen Devitt>Let's keep doing the good work.

151
00:18:46.369 --> 00:18:49.558
<v Glen Devitt>Like many CPPW members, I've spent years of my career in the private sector.

152
00:18:50.009 --> 00:18:55.961
<v Glen Devitt>Um, to be perfectly frank, we could make more money working somewhere else, but like you, we know the calling of public service.

153
00:18:56.548 --> 00:18:57.219
<v Glen Devitt>That's why we're here.

154
00:18:58.650 --> 00:19:02.792
<v Glen Devitt>All we ask in return is stability and to focus on the good work.

155
00:19:02.938 --> 00:19:03.825
<v Glen Devitt>All we want is a fair contract.

156
00:19:05.098 --> 00:19:12.336
<v Glen Devitt>I hope you'll use your positions to encourage the city's negotiators to do the right thing, not only for CPPW but for all Portlanders we serve.

157
00:19:13.269 --> 00:19:16.455
<v Glen Devitt>So I thank you for your time and consideration, and I thank you for your service to our city.

158
00:19:19.170 --> 00:19:19.621
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

159
00:19:23.453 --> 00:19:27.159
<v Ana Maria Perez>Hello, good morning, Council, Mr. Mayor, City Administrator.

160
00:19:27.722 --> 00:19:28.935
<v Ana Maria Perez>My name is Anna Maria Perez.

161
00:19:29.200 --> 00:19:34.579
<v Ana Maria Perez>My pronouns are she/her/eya, and I'm a data analyst at the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

162
00:19:35.494 --> 00:19:38.848
<v Ana Maria Perez>I'm also co-chair of the CPPW bargaining team.

163
00:19:40.148 --> 00:19:42.621
<v Ana Maria Perez>As a data analyst, I do the people's business.

164
00:19:43.358 --> 00:19:45.654
<v Ana Maria Perez>Analysts like me perform essential services.

165
00:19:46.409 --> 00:19:49.923
<v Ana Maria Perez>Our work makes the city's work transparent to the public.

166
00:19:50.903 --> 00:19:56.407
<v Ana Maria Perez>We make sure the city is being fiscally responsible as well as equitable and accountable for our actions.

167
00:19:57.098 --> 00:20:08.016
<v Ana Maria Perez>For example, I developed the interactive city or Climate and Energy Dashboard, which is filled with graphs, charts, and maps about local carbon emissions and energy use in Portland.

168
00:20:08.787 --> 00:20:14.309
<v Ana Maria Perez>The dashboard holds us accountable to our climate goals and shares information about how we make our decisions.

169
00:20:15.691 --> 00:20:25.277
<v Ana Maria Perez>I also work with other analysts across the city and our service area to establish performance measures and report on them to ensure we are meeting the city's goals year after year.

170
00:20:26.525 --> 00:20:29.321
<v Ana Maria Perez>Without analysts, the city wastes money.

171
00:20:30.228 --> 00:20:37.422
<v Ana Maria Perez>We make sure that city work is effective in meeting the needs of the community, something that I know all of us here want.

172
00:20:39.006 --> 00:20:41.934
<v Ana Maria Perez>As I said, I am our union's bargaining co-chair.

173
00:20:42.663 --> 00:20:46.723
<v Ana Maria Perez>I am here simply to update you on our experiences at the bargaining table.

174
00:20:47.788 --> 00:20:52.530
<v Ana Maria Perez>I am in these negotiations bringing proposals forward and listening to the city's side.

175
00:20:52.596 --> 00:20:52.775
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

176
00:20:53.659 --> 00:20:58.592
<v Ana Maria Perez>Meanwhile, the city's bargaining team is not doing its part in settling these contracts.

177
00:20:59.201 --> 00:21:07.444
<v Ana Maria Perez>We have been bargaining since March 2024 and would expect to be much closer to a settled contract nearly one year later.

178
00:21:08.762 --> 00:21:18.724
<v Ana Maria Perez>For example, in the last bargaining session in January, the city's team did not bring any proposals to the table, even though we had already filed for mediation by that point.

179
00:21:19.846 --> 00:21:23.115
<v Ana Maria Perez>The city has over 20 outstanding articles.

180
00:21:23.548 --> 00:21:25.519
<v Ana Maria Perez>They should be actively negotiating with us.

181
00:21:25.952 --> 00:21:26.305
<v Ana Maria Perez>They are not.

182
00:21:27.474 --> 00:21:41.625
<v Ana Maria Perez>Instead, a majority of their work is incomplete, and we have only 12 tentative agreements, many of them boilerplate, leaving important things like sick leave, layoff protections, and overtime still unsettled.

183
00:21:42.683 --> 00:21:51.660
<v Ana Maria Perez>We've pressed for mediation as a mechanism to get the city to do their work because a slow negotiation is a waste of money For you and our union.

184
00:21:53.420 --> 00:21:57.728
<v Ana Maria Perez>We are ready for our members to get what they need and deserve— a strong contract.

185
00:21:59.150 --> 00:22:05.065
<v Ana Maria Perez>CPPW's goal with our first contract is to have clear and consistent expectations for our members.

186
00:22:06.054 --> 00:22:14.613
<v Ana Maria Perez>This is our first contract as an independent union, and we are determined to create a solid and just foundation for current and future members.

187
00:22:15.535 --> 00:22:16.974
<v Ana Maria Perez>We want to settle this contract.

188
00:22:17.496 --> 00:22:19.582
<v Ana Maria Perez>We want— we need labor peace.

189
00:22:20.673 --> 00:22:32.530
<v Ana Maria Perez>As city workers, we are united, showing that we love the work we do to serve Portlanders every day, but we also want to exercise our right to organize and be respected by our employer.

190
00:22:32.821 --> 00:22:33.257
<v Ana Maria Perez>Thank you.

191
00:22:35.724 --> 00:22:39.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for being here with us today and sharing all of your experiences.

192
00:22:41.339 --> 00:22:42.594
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Carl Close.

193
00:22:43.289 --> 00:22:48.308
<v Carl Close>Thank you for this opportunity to provide public comment.

194
00:22:48.614 --> 00:22:49.467
<v Carl Close>My name is Carl Close.

195
00:22:49.740 --> 00:22:53.990
<v Carl Close>I live in Southeast Portland, and I'm a principal at Kurt Fischer Structural Engineering.

196
00:22:54.569 --> 00:22:56.181
<v Carl Close>I run our downtown Portland office.

197
00:22:56.584 --> 00:23:02.221
<v Carl Close>I also grew up in Portland, and I'm now raising my kids here, so I'm committed to seeing our downtown fully recover and prosper.

198
00:23:03.107 --> 00:23:12.702
<v Carl Close>I'm providing public comment today to offer a recommendation, a recommendation for the council on how Portland can create more housing downtown by updating the zoning code to spur more office-to-residential conversions on the downtown core.

199
00:23:14.836 --> 00:23:16.182
<v Carl Close>Also known as adaptive reuse.

200
00:23:17.160 --> 00:23:32.613
<v Carl Close>Residential conversions in the downtown area will improve our community in 4 key ways: bringing additional foot traffic that will help downtown businesses recover, increasing our region's housing stock while providing the environmental benefit of reduced carbon impact relative to new construction.

201
00:23:33.606 --> 00:23:39.184
<v Carl Close>It preserves our historic buildings by giving older buildings a new life and avoids demolition of underutilized buildings.

202
00:23:40.276 --> 00:23:55.309
<v Carl Close>It makes our city safer because renovated buildings will be retrofitted, which means they will be much safer and more resilient than existing It sounds like a great option for Portland to convert some of these underutilized office buildings to residential.

203
00:23:55.374 --> 00:23:56.229
<v Carl Close>So why is it not happening?

204
00:23:57.352 --> 00:23:57.708
<v Carl Close>It's simple.

205
00:23:57.756 --> 00:24:04.597
<v Carl Close>These conversions are often not profitable in the Portland market or are deemed to be financially too risky and time-consuming.

206
00:24:05.531 --> 00:24:13.603
<v Carl Close>So if we want to see more office-to-residential projects move forward, something needs to be done to address the cost, duration, or risk associated with the project.

207
00:24:13.651 --> 00:24:14.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Sameer Kanal.

208
00:24:14.571 --> 00:24:17.986
<v Carl Close>Fortunately, other cities have tackled the same issue and found solutions.

209
00:24:18.644 --> 00:24:25.440
<v Carl Close>For potential ways forward, I urge the council to look at other cities that have had success with residential adaptive reuse conversions.

210
00:24:26.258 --> 00:24:28.020
<v Carl Close>One city in particular is Los Angeles.

211
00:24:28.438 --> 00:24:36.181
<v Carl Close>In 1999, they passed an adaptive reuse ordinance that was the catalyst for the city creating 12,000 units of housing in the first 15 years.

212
00:24:37.157 --> 00:24:45.782
<v Carl Close>This was done by making adaptive reuse in certain areas of the city by right, meaning that they just need to adhere to the building code, but get to bypass zoning requirements.

213
00:24:45.830 --> 00:24:53.130
<v Carl Close>Councilmember The rationale behind eliminating these steps is that the building already exists.

214
00:24:53.307 --> 00:24:59.916
<v Carl Close>So in some sense, it should be grandfathered in instead of applying new zoning and design review board requirements to the existing building.

215
00:25:00.991 --> 00:25:07.971
<v Carl Close>Thus, the main focus of adaptive reuse projects in Los Angeles is on the safety aspects of the conversion as mandated by the building code.

216
00:25:08.836 --> 00:25:11.676
<v Carl Close>This shortens the time to get a conversion permitted.

217
00:25:11.968 --> 00:25:16.348
<v Carl Close>Often by more than a year, and also reduces the risk taken on by the owner.

218
00:25:17.130 --> 00:25:26.325
<v Carl Close>While this is not likely to be the only change needed to make office-to-residential projects viable in Portland, it is a good idea that the council should consider when next looking at this issue.

219
00:25:27.132 --> 00:25:32.907
<v Carl Close>Thank you for providing this opportunity to speak, and I'd be happy to provide more information if anyone on the council is interested.

220
00:25:35.234 --> 00:25:36.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for sharing that with us.

221
00:25:38.219 --> 00:25:39.567
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes communications.

222
00:25:40.980 --> 00:25:48.671
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, uh, next we have a time-certain item on the agenda.

223
00:25:49.473 --> 00:26:03.169
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, we at our last meeting, councilors, um, heard a land use petition and moved to bring that item to this meeting for final approval.

224
00:26:04.169 --> 00:26:08.397
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we have information to share, just a brief overview about that, or—.

225
00:26:08.996 --> 00:26:28.655
<v Keelan McClymont>I'll read the title and then item 3, consider proposal of Type 4 demolition review approval for 118 Southwest Porter Street and Portland Permitting and Development staff recommendation for approval for a contributing building in the South Portland Historic District, LU24-077225DM.

226
00:26:33.067 --> 00:26:37.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe we need a motion to move this item, or we just move right into the vote.

227
00:26:37.644 --> 00:26:40.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good morning, Lindley Reese from Chief Deputy City Attorney.

228
00:26:41.480 --> 00:26:45.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, yes, last time you made a tentative vote, council prepared findings.

229
00:26:45.655 --> 00:26:53.491
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You have those in front of you, and at this point council simply needs to make a motion to, uh, approve the findings and decision.

230
00:26:53.780 --> 00:26:56.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You need a second and then a roll call vote.

231
00:26:57.009 --> 00:26:57.525
<v Dan Ryan>So moved.

232
00:26:58.364 --> 00:26:58.750
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Second.

233
00:27:00.284 --> 00:27:04.560
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Councilor Ryan moved and Councilor Green second.

234
00:27:04.980 --> 00:27:05.787
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick.

235
00:27:05.852 --> 00:27:07.090
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Novick, thank you.

236
00:27:10.815 --> 00:27:14.722
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

237
00:27:15.397 --> 00:27:15.896
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan.

238
00:27:16.041 --> 00:27:16.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan.

239
00:27:16.363 --> 00:27:16.701
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Novick.

240
00:27:17.810 --> 00:27:18.508
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any discussion?

241
00:27:19.840 --> 00:27:20.719
<v Michael Jordan>Novick second.

242
00:27:20.897 --> 00:27:22.733
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Keelan, can you call the roll?

243
00:27:22.913 --> 00:27:22.993
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

244
00:27:26.481 --> 00:27:26.498
<v Owen Nguyen>Aye.

245
00:27:26.915 --> 00:27:27.431
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

246
00:27:28.332 --> 00:27:28.380
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

247
00:27:29.135 --> 00:27:30.085
<v Sameer Kanal>Ryan?

248
00:27:30.261 --> 00:27:33.141
<v Dan Ryan>I'm going to say a couple things.

249
00:27:33.317 --> 00:27:42.060
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I just really, uh, support the— I think we all do— the Yukondo mission to provide needed services to families impacted by childhood and adolescent cancer.

250
00:27:42.720 --> 00:27:50.016
<v Dan Ryan>In fact, it was by far the most moving testimony I've ever experienced here on the dais in my 4-plus years in office for a land use hearing.

251
00:27:50.753 --> 00:27:53.421
<v Dan Ryan>I think we had to roll out the Kleenex, as I recall.

252
00:27:54.465 --> 00:27:58.868
<v Dan Ryan>So I just want to acknowledge this location and property is adjacent to an existing facility.

253
00:27:59.012 --> 00:28:07.272
<v Dan Ryan>The demolition allows the nonprofit to expand their services and facility, and this location is strategically beneficial to OHSU and Randall's Children's Hospital.

254
00:28:08.430 --> 00:28:20.143
<v Dan Ryan>There has been public and community engagement that I was impressed with in their outreach, and most important, I agree with the recommendation from the Historic Landmarks Commission for demolition of the building for this higher and best use for the property.

255
00:28:20.336 --> 00:28:20.723
<v Dan Ryan>I vote aye.

256
00:28:22.892 --> 00:28:23.005
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

257
00:28:24.410 --> 00:28:24.539
<v Lynn Handlen>Aye.

258
00:28:26.138 --> 00:28:29.885
<v Steve Novick>In the immortal words of Ronald Reagan, Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this bungalow.

259
00:28:31.873 --> 00:28:31.953
<v Lynn Handlen>Aye.

260
00:28:32.180 --> 00:28:32.599
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

261
00:28:33.632 --> 00:28:34.713
<v Olivia Clark>I abstain.

262
00:28:34.761 --> 00:28:36.150
<v Olivia Clark>I was unable to attend the meeting.

263
00:28:42.756 --> 00:28:54.239
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, I, I think an abstention is permitted as long as there's no objection from the council.

264
00:28:55.077 --> 00:28:58.433
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, any objection to Councilor Clark abstaining from this vote?

265
00:28:59.433 --> 00:29:02.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, without objection, we will accept the abstention.

266
00:29:02.720 --> 00:29:03.378
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, thank you.

267
00:29:03.683 --> 00:29:05.034
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, Green.

268
00:29:06.993 --> 00:29:14.374
<v Mitch Green>I just want to say I really appreciate the staff work that went into, um, making this a decision that I think I was able to make a clear-eyed evaluation of.

269
00:29:14.696 --> 00:29:20.884
<v Mitch Green>Our cities evolve, our cities change, and this is just a really good opportunity to, to meet that changing need.

270
00:29:20.932 --> 00:29:21.417
<v Michaela McCormick>So I vote aye.

271
00:29:24.215 --> 00:29:26.211
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, thank you for being a District 4 property.

272
00:29:27.513 --> 00:29:29.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you to the colleagues for, for doing this.

273
00:29:30.022 --> 00:29:37.882
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know that the historic nature of something is often fraught in our city, so I also appreciate the flexibility of the Historic Landmarks Commission.

274
00:29:37.979 --> 00:29:45.675
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's the way to keep subcommissions relevant and flexible to the current times, and I'm excited for what you can do.

275
00:29:45.771 --> 00:29:46.480
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I vote aye.

276
00:29:48.688 --> 00:29:48.736
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

277
00:29:49.490 --> 00:29:52.849
<v Keelan McClymont>The findings are adopted with an aye vote of 11.

278
00:29:55.452 --> 00:29:56.497
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

279
00:29:57.059 --> 00:30:08.353
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The next item on our agenda, moving to the consent agenda, is approval of our council minutes from our previous meetings.

280
00:30:09.005 --> 00:30:12.849
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I believe we do this without objection, is that correct, or do you need to call the roll?

281
00:30:13.527 --> 00:30:13.720
<v Keelan McClymont>Right.

282
00:30:13.848 --> 00:30:21.903
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, I would just announce that no items have been pulled from the consent agenda, and then we would have a roll call vote to approve the consent agenda.

283
00:30:22.582 --> 00:30:22.839
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

284
00:30:23.210 --> 00:30:23.758
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Avalos?

285
00:30:26.914 --> 00:30:27.092
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

286
00:30:27.672 --> 00:30:27.978
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

287
00:30:28.284 --> 00:30:28.333
<v Linda Liu>Aye.

288
00:30:28.784 --> 00:30:28.977
<v Nancy Thorington>Smith?

289
00:30:29.653 --> 00:30:29.701
<v Lynn Handlen>Aye.

290
00:30:30.233 --> 00:30:30.522
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

291
00:30:31.263 --> 00:30:31.297
<v Linda Liu>Aye.

292
00:30:32.174 --> 00:30:32.471
<v Glen Devitt>Ryan.

293
00:30:32.734 --> 00:30:32.768
<v Carrie Ko>Hi.

294
00:30:32.834 --> 00:30:33.377
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

295
00:30:36.660 --> 00:30:38.096
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can you remind me what we're voting on?

296
00:30:38.306 --> 00:30:40.080
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh yeah, this is the consent agenda.

297
00:30:40.323 --> 00:30:40.855
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm sorry.

298
00:30:40.951 --> 00:30:44.567
<v Keelan McClymont>So this is the first time our council has had a consent agenda to vote on.

299
00:30:44.987 --> 00:30:50.871
<v Keelan McClymont>So these are items that are voted on with a single unanimous vote of council.

300
00:30:51.387 --> 00:30:57.473
<v Keelan McClymont>If there is an item on the consent agenda that you want to discuss, that item would be pulled and added to the regular agenda.

301
00:30:58.124 --> 00:31:00.008
<v Keelan McClymont>We received no requests to pull.

302
00:31:00.217 --> 00:31:01.424
<v Keelan McClymont>We only have one item today.

303
00:31:01.505 --> 00:31:04.451
<v Keelan McClymont>It's approval of the minutes, and there was no request to pull that item.

304
00:31:04.821 --> 00:31:08.506
<v Keelan McClymont>So we're just having a roll call vote to approve the consent agenda.

305
00:31:08.827 --> 00:31:08.844
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

306
00:31:09.133 --> 00:31:10.032
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

307
00:31:11.542 --> 00:31:13.567
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Morillo?

308
00:31:14.114 --> 00:31:14.162
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

309
00:31:14.675 --> 00:31:14.709
<v Candace Jimenez>Aye.

310
00:31:15.318 --> 00:31:15.366
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

311
00:31:15.800 --> 00:31:16.186
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

312
00:31:18.471 --> 00:31:18.519
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

313
00:31:20.448 --> 00:31:22.865
<v Keelan McClymont>The consent agenda is approved with an aye vote of 12.

314
00:31:24.839 --> 00:31:29.397
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, moving on to the regular items on our agenda, councilors.

315
00:31:29.509 --> 00:31:44.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Today we have 2 resolutions before us from Mayor Wilson, both of which are to move forward with the confirmation of appointments that he is recommending for our city administrator and our city attorney.

316
00:31:44.753 --> 00:31:49.279
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You may remember that we approve the nomination of the city administrator, the city attorney, and the chief of police.

317
00:31:49.327 --> 00:31:50.515
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator Nancy Thorington.

318
00:31:50.612 --> 00:31:50.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Police.

319
00:31:51.095 --> 00:31:54.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will be taking up that 3rd position at our next meeting.

320
00:31:55.185 --> 00:31:59.292
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Mr. Mayor, would you like to come to the dais and present your item for us?

321
00:32:04.403 --> 00:32:08.576
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Council President, would you like me to read both items together, or—.

322
00:32:09.028 --> 00:32:10.873
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we're taking them up separately.

323
00:32:10.938 --> 00:32:11.196
<v Keelan McClymont>Separately.

324
00:32:11.294 --> 00:32:11.454
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

325
00:32:11.682 --> 00:32:14.693
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 5, appoint Michael Jordan as City Administrator.

326
00:32:22.791 --> 00:32:25.946
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mayor Wilson, City Administrator Jordan, go right ahead when you're ready.

327
00:32:30.490 --> 00:32:31.490
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Council President.

328
00:32:31.634 --> 00:32:34.845
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you and good morning to our colleagues and the councilors.

329
00:32:35.748 --> 00:32:38.683
<v Keith Wilson>Together we have important leadership decisions to make.

330
00:32:39.410 --> 00:32:44.391
<v Keith Wilson>City leaders, city workers, and the public have a great deal riding on getting these appointments right.

331
00:32:45.990 --> 00:32:51.875
<v Keith Wilson>City Administrator Michael Jordan has made this once-in-a-generation government transition one we can all be proud of.

332
00:32:53.130 --> 00:33:03.126
<v Keith Wilson>He has graciously agreed to continue serving this coming year, and I come before you today to ask the City Council to support his appointment in the same way he supported Portland.

333
00:33:04.493 --> 00:33:15.477
<v Keith Wilson>As part of your deliberation process, I would like for Council to consider an amendment to today's resolution that identifies January 2nd, 2026, as the end date for Michael's appointment.

334
00:33:16.423 --> 00:33:22.952
<v Keith Wilson>That amendment reflects my intention to launch a robust nationwide search for Portland's next city administrator by this summer.

335
00:33:24.155 --> 00:33:31.519
<v Keith Wilson>I'm grateful for Michael and to his dedication and willing to continue to provide steady leadership as a bridge to our future.

336
00:33:32.643 --> 00:33:38.770
<v Keith Wilson>Before I read the exact language I'd like council to consider as an amendment, I would like to turn this over to Michael Jordan to share a few words.

337
00:33:40.240 --> 00:33:42.977
<v Michael Jordan>Well, thank you, Mayor and Council President, members of the council.

338
00:33:43.653 --> 00:33:50.442
<v Michael Jordan>This has a certain Thunderdome-esque to it, but thank you for giving us some time today.

339
00:33:51.753 --> 00:33:55.780
<v Michael Jordan>You have a statement that I put into the record before you.

340
00:33:57.240 --> 00:34:12.507
<v Michael Jordan>It's been one of the great challenges and one of the great it is really the reason that I stayed on when Mayor Wheeler asked me to.

341
00:34:13.639 --> 00:34:28.974
<v Michael Jordan>I have found it completely up to the expected challenge, and, and I think the city is well positioned with the new form of government to, to create an amazing future for this city.

342
00:34:29.074 --> 00:34:29.306
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you, Mayor.

343
00:34:30.367 --> 00:34:42.503
<v Michael Jordan>I'm honored and humbled that the mayor would ask me to stay on for a few more months to be able to assist the council and the mayor in landing this change, if you will.

344
00:34:43.760 --> 00:34:51.487
<v Michael Jordan>We have found together, I think, that all of us are learning about how this is actually supposed to operate.

345
00:34:52.885 --> 00:34:56.128
<v Michael Jordan>We could make some assumptions, some of them good assumptions, some of them bad assumptions.

346
00:34:56.177 --> 00:34:56.697
<v Michael Jordan>I think we're learning together.

347
00:34:56.902 --> 00:34:57.110
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

348
00:34:57.929 --> 00:35:01.221
<v Michael Jordan>In the last couple of years about how this could operate.

349
00:35:01.878 --> 00:35:22.079
<v Michael Jordan>But with you all in the offices now that you hold, I think we are finding that there's a significant amount of ambiguity about how we're going to relate to each other, how information is going to flow, how can we make decisions efficiently for the city, how can we frame the appropriate questions for this body.

350
00:35:22.431 --> 00:35:26.230
<v Michael Jordan>To work on and deliberate on, uh, and move the city forward.

351
00:35:26.742 --> 00:35:29.418
<v Michael Jordan>I am grateful again for the opportunity.

352
00:35:29.483 --> 00:35:49.195
<v Michael Jordan>I look forward to the work with you and with the mayor, uh, over the next year, uh, and I am particularly committed to, uh, work with you to architect a process by which we can bring on the city's first full-time regular— I won't say permanent, but regular— City Administrator.

353
00:35:49.661 --> 00:35:55.297
<v Michael Jordan>I think it is going to be one of the most important hires that the city has ever made in its entire history.

354
00:35:55.923 --> 00:36:13.007
<v Michael Jordan>And so working with you to, to design a process where Portlanders feel like they have an opportunity to be involved in that decision as best we can will really be a great honor and opportunity for me to work with you on.

355
00:36:13.072 --> 00:36:13.119
<v Karen Chire>So.

356
00:36:13.201 --> 00:36:13.329
<v Owen Nguyen>Thank you.

357
00:36:14.146 --> 00:36:15.750
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you, Madam President.

358
00:36:15.829 --> 00:36:16.791
<v Michael Jordan>And thank you, Mr. Mayor.

359
00:36:16.871 --> 00:36:17.577
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

360
00:36:17.690 --> 00:36:20.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, would you like to say anything else about your amendment?

361
00:36:20.655 --> 00:36:21.039
<v Candace Avalos>Please, yes.

362
00:36:21.119 --> 00:36:21.456
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

363
00:36:21.938 --> 00:36:22.434
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Mike.

364
00:36:22.980 --> 00:36:30.114
<v Keith Wilson>As I mentioned, I'd like for the council to consider an amendment to today's resolution that would set an end date for Michael's appointment.

365
00:36:30.579 --> 00:36:39.155
<v Keith Wilson>I propose to add the following language to the resolution: Whereas Michael Jordan will serve as city administrator through January 2nd, 2026.

366
00:36:39.956 --> 00:36:46.760
<v Keith Wilson>With that, I will defer to Council President Pirtle-Guiney on how she would like to proceed with the amendment and discussion on the item as a whole.

367
00:36:47.594 --> 00:36:51.476
<v Keith Wilson>And thank you for your time this morning, and I look forward to your questions and discussion.

368
00:36:52.791 --> 00:36:54.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

369
00:36:54.396 --> 00:37:05.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe, councilors, that we could add a whereas to the item that says, whereas Michael Jordan will serve as city administrator through January 2nd, 2024.

370
00:37:06.498 --> 00:37:12.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and update the therefore be it resolved section to include in accordance with this resolution.

371
00:37:14.119 --> 00:37:14.697
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, thank you.

372
00:37:14.762 --> 00:37:16.003
<v Candace Avalos>I would like to move that amendment.

373
00:37:17.382 --> 00:37:18.268
<v Michael Jordan>Second.

374
00:37:20.443 --> 00:37:28.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>Madam President, for purpose of discussion though, why would we not just add it to the point of the document that talks about term where we have it similar for the others?

375
00:37:29.856 --> 00:37:31.438
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, we could do that as well.

376
00:37:31.567 --> 00:37:38.047
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The recommendation that was given to me was that we added in an additional whereas and therefore.

377
00:37:39.860 --> 00:37:40.197
<v Nancy Thorington>Okay.

378
00:37:44.791 --> 00:37:50.070
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Clerk, by process, do we vote on this amendment before we hear testimony from the public?

379
00:37:52.853 --> 00:37:54.382
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, you, you can do it either way.

380
00:37:54.527 --> 00:38:06.748
<v Keelan McClymont>You can leave the amendment open, um, so that the public can testify okay, why don't we move to public testimony?

381
00:38:06.827 --> 00:38:11.907
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When we finish public testimony, Council, we will be having discussion on this amendment.

382
00:38:12.132 --> 00:38:18.719
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll then take that vote, then have discussion on the full resolution, and then take that vote.

383
00:38:20.849 --> 00:38:24.443
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mr. Mayor and City Administrator, and we'll now take testimony on the ordinance.

384
00:38:24.893 --> 00:38:26.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

385
00:38:26.972 --> 00:38:29.599
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, first up we have Fred Neal.

386
00:38:37.793 --> 00:38:39.704
<v Fred Neal>Good morning, Madam President and councilors.

387
00:38:40.447 --> 00:38:46.047
<v Fred Neal>My name is Fred Neal and I'm the co-chair of the Government Transition Advisory Committee, or the GTAC.

388
00:38:46.518 --> 00:38:49.998
<v Fred Neal>The GTAC serves as the primary advisory body for the city's transition.

389
00:38:50.773 --> 00:39:04.791
<v Fred Neal>The GTEC did not deliberate on the appointment of Michael Jordan, but we did deliberate on the appointment process, and we recommend a robust, well-designed, timely, community-informed, transparent city administrator appointment process.

390
00:39:05.626 --> 00:39:11.503
<v Fred Neal>In December, the GTEC sent a letter to the mayor and councilors-elect detailing our recommendations.

391
00:39:11.568 --> 00:39:13.704
<v Fred Neal>We've resubmitted that letter as written testimony.

392
00:39:14.282 --> 00:39:17.829
<v Fred Neal>Last year, the city chose to contract with a recruiting firm called Modus Recruiting.

393
00:39:17.894 --> 00:39:18.039
<v Fred Neal>Thank you.

394
00:39:18.472 --> 00:39:20.190
<v Fred Neal>To develop a recommended recruitment plan.

395
00:39:20.800 --> 00:39:36.023
<v Fred Neal>This past fall, after input from hundreds of Portlanders and the GTAC, Modus Recruiting finalized the draft position announcement, community-informed recommendations for a city administrator job description, and a recommended recruitment strategy and timeline.

396
00:39:37.179 --> 00:39:49.130
<v Fred Neal>The reasons for the city to adhere to a good process are to recognize how crucial the hiring of the city's first the first permanent city administrator is to the successful transition to a new form of government.

397
00:39:49.867 --> 00:39:52.351
<v Fred Neal>To set the standard for all appointments to follow.

398
00:39:52.976 --> 00:40:00.106
<v Fred Neal>To provide transparency necessary to guarantee the charter requirement and lift up the qualifications so everyone can see them.

399
00:40:00.748 --> 00:40:05.940
<v Fred Neal>To embody community expectations of what it means to have a professional city administrator.

400
00:40:06.773 --> 00:40:20.282
<v Fred Neal>To align with good government values embedded in charter reform, to provide a roadmap for the city during a time of significant transition and elected leader onboarding, and to serve as an accountability mechanism.

401
00:40:21.108 --> 00:40:24.277
<v Fred Neal>The GTAC wants to reiterate its recommendations from December.

402
00:40:25.070 --> 00:40:34.458
<v Fred Neal>Acknowledge the overarching purpose of the recruitment is to appoint a city administrator on the basis of executive and administrative qualifications as directed by the charter.

403
00:40:34.625 --> 00:40:34.708
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

404
00:40:35.411 --> 00:40:38.590
<v Fred Neal>Receive a briefing on the recruitment efforts as soon as possible.

405
00:40:39.489 --> 00:40:44.643
<v Fred Neal>Recognize Modus Recruiting's recommended recruiting plan is a good example to follow for the initial appointment.

406
00:40:45.447 --> 00:40:48.255
<v Fred Neal>Encourage a recruitment that is nationwide in scope.

407
00:40:48.978 --> 00:40:57.456
<v Fred Neal>Ensure the process at minimum engages community, such as listening sessions and a series of interview panels composed of city and community leaders.

408
00:40:58.596 --> 00:41:07.711
<v Fred Neal>Consider whether the recommended timeline can be accelerated and a city administrator appointed before June 25th without sacrificing strategies to engage community.

409
00:41:09.610 --> 00:41:22.327
<v Fred Neal>And early on, establish and communicate to the public your general support for a formal recruitment process and ensure appointment is neither delayed nor pressured to occur outside of an open and transparent process.

410
00:41:23.085 --> 00:41:42.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In conclusion, the GTAC recommends a robust, well-designed, and thank you for being here and for continuing to make sure that we remember the advice that we've been given and all the work that you've done.

411
00:41:42.594 --> 00:41:44.961
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, sorry.

412
00:41:45.771 --> 00:41:47.266
<v Keelan McClymont>Sorry.

413
00:41:47.780 --> 00:41:51.989
<v Keelan McClymont>Multnomah County Chair Vega Peterson submitted testimony.

414
00:41:52.036 --> 00:42:05.492
<v Keelan McClymont>She's not able to be here in person, so she submitted video testimony and we'll good morning, President Pirtle-Guiney and Council.

415
00:42:06.074 --> 00:42:15.327
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Thank you so much for this opportunity to speak on behalf of Michael Jordan's reappointment as Portland City Administrator, even though I'm unable to be with you in person this morning.

416
00:42:16.679 --> 00:42:22.378
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>So many of you may not know this, but I have a long history of working with Mike in different roles over the last several years.

417
00:42:23.463 --> 00:42:33.844
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>During my time in the Oregon Legislature serving House District 47, Mike and I worked closely together when I served as a state representative on the Joint Information and Audits Committee.

418
00:42:34.422 --> 00:42:51.197
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>And Mike, as the director of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services, was a partner to me and to legislative leadership on a number of critical and complex issues that had statewide impact, whether it was digging into an audit on the Department of Transportation or bringing new IT projects online for the state.

419
00:42:51.260 --> 00:42:51.548
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

420
00:42:52.769 --> 00:43:06.565
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>More locally, I want to make sure all of you know about the importance of Mike's commitment and diligence as we worked together over the last 20 months on our intergovernmental agreement to continue addressing homelessness collaboratively as a city and county.

421
00:43:07.384 --> 00:43:12.635
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>He was a leader and advocate in these discussions and in the creation of our homelessness response system.

422
00:43:13.664 --> 00:43:18.369
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>His current role in co-chairing the HRS Implementation Committee is very important.

423
00:43:19.052 --> 00:43:22.302
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>And the true partnership he brings to this work is notable and commendable.

424
00:43:23.110 --> 00:43:28.844
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>This committee's consistent work to implement the Homelessness Response Action Plan is critical to our success.

425
00:43:30.262 --> 00:43:43.507
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Mike has the proven leadership and experience in overseeing day-to-day operations across 2 dozen bureaus and offices at the City of Portland, and he took his responsibility for leading Portland's voter-approved transition to a new form of government seriously.

426
00:43:44.217 --> 00:43:46.429
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>And I know that I, as a Portland resident, am grateful for that.

427
00:43:46.478 --> 00:43:46.849
<v Karen Chire>Thank you, Councilor McClymont.

428
00:43:48.264 --> 00:43:58.291
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>The city under Mike's leadership has worked hard alongside the county as we've implemented ranked choice voting and continued to integrate a new form of government in the way that we work together.

429
00:43:59.318 --> 00:44:07.309
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Mike's reappointment brings stability in this transition to a new form of government that the residents of Portland should welcome and will definitely benefit from.

430
00:44:08.800 --> 00:44:26.038
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>The power of governmental partnership is a value that we all hold, and I look forward to continuing our strong, effective partnership in all of Multnomah County and the City of Portland's shared commitments and work, both in the work with you as a council and with Mayor Wilson and with Mike Jordan and his administrative team.

431
00:44:26.634 --> 00:44:27.295
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Thank you so much.

432
00:44:30.632 --> 00:44:36.630
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Robert Butler, followed by Diane Meisenhelter and Nick Caleb.

433
00:44:44.737 --> 00:44:45.876
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being with us today.

434
00:44:47.222 --> 00:44:48.456
<v Robert Butler>Uh, I'm Robert Butler.

435
00:44:49.163 --> 00:44:49.596
<v Robert Butler>Good morning.

436
00:44:50.909 --> 00:44:54.708
<v Robert Butler>Um, I have a big problem with, uh, a couple of things.

437
00:44:55.880 --> 00:45:02.228
<v Robert Butler>Uh, he could continue as an interim director, but there's no point in making this a contract.

438
00:45:02.934 --> 00:45:11.253
<v Robert Butler>The mission is Is that we need the opportunity to get the highest, best qualified in the country to join us and help us out.

439
00:45:11.639 --> 00:45:14.519
<v Robert Butler>No effort has been done to accomplish that.

440
00:45:15.083 --> 00:45:22.360
<v Robert Butler>And because there's been no effort, I don't think we should postpone this any further, and the effort should begin now.

441
00:45:22.971 --> 00:45:24.793
<v Robert Butler>And he would continue as a temporary.

442
00:45:25.472 --> 00:45:35.365
<v Robert Butler>Now, the legacy of Ted Wheeler is going to continue as the ruination of this city for many decades.

443
00:45:36.190 --> 00:45:45.764
<v Robert Butler>And one of the problems is the people that he elected or chose to serve on staff, and that was a failure.

444
00:45:46.619 --> 00:45:59.885
<v Robert Butler>Janet Harsty, Chris Warner, committee members of the charter, Mingus Maps, Being given 2 largest bureaus without the experience.

445
00:46:00.559 --> 00:46:11.503
<v Robert Butler>These things are terrible, and that's why if Wheeler were to run again and the only opposition was a donkey, the donkey would have won.

446
00:46:12.320 --> 00:46:49.777
<v Robert Butler>So the biggest problem with Mr. Warner is he was selected by Chris— Chris was selected by the mayor, and this He's already failed in the sense that the charge of the last commissioners before City Council in like November was that the city must hire independent consultants to review what could be the biggest disaster in the history of our city, the $2.1 billion cost to relocate the city waterworks from Bull Run to Gresham.

447
00:46:50.585 --> 00:46:57.440
<v Robert Butler>That's $2.1 billion, and that excludes interest.

448
00:46:57.617 --> 00:47:02.954
<v Robert Butler>The interest on that, including the WIFIA loan, is about $900 million.

449
00:47:03.440 --> 00:47:03.748
<v Robert Butler>We're at—.

450
00:47:03.748 --> 00:47:05.429
<v Robert Butler>That's a $3 billion project.

451
00:47:05.931 --> 00:47:07.353
<v Robert Butler>To begin with, that was a lie.

452
00:47:07.728 --> 00:47:09.204
<v Robert Butler>See what it was going to cost us?

453
00:47:09.333 --> 00:47:10.048
<v Robert Butler>It's $3 billion.

454
00:47:11.070 --> 00:47:24.101
<v Robert Butler>So we need to immediately convince the mayor and current manager to follow the instructions of the city council.

455
00:47:24.748 --> 00:47:34.246
<v Robert Butler>We need to immediately hire the independent contractors and consultants to determine if this is the biggest disaster ever made.

456
00:47:34.744 --> 00:47:44.092
<v Robert Butler>This started out as a $150 million project for ultraviolet and $350 million lie for sand filtration.

457
00:47:44.155 --> 00:47:45.713
<v Robert Butler>July was $500 million.

458
00:47:46.034 --> 00:47:57.675
<v Robert Butler>Now we can do the ultraviolet for $700 million, and the Bull Run project is $3 billion, including $900 million worth of interest.

459
00:47:58.157 --> 00:48:02.123
<v Robert Butler>We're losing $8 million a day for every day we don't—.

460
00:48:02.123 --> 00:48:02.797
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, sir.

461
00:48:02.878 --> 00:48:06.105
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, but we need to make sure we have time to hear from everybody.

462
00:48:06.184 --> 00:48:07.454
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

463
00:48:12.909 --> 00:48:15.092
<v Keelan McClymont>Diane Meisenhalter is joining us online.

464
00:48:16.275 --> 00:48:16.784
<v Karen Chire>Can you hear me?

465
00:48:19.159 --> 00:48:19.820
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, we can hear you.

466
00:48:20.885 --> 00:48:30.039
<v Diane Meisenhelter>At the 3:50 PDX mayoral forum, I asked the question about whether there would be a national search for the city administrator and would it involve public engagement.

467
00:48:30.574 --> 00:48:34.105
<v Diane Meisenhelter>Candidate Wilson quoted, nothing about a without us.

468
00:48:34.778 --> 00:48:45.014
<v Diane Meisenhelter>He talked about a search looking for a record of success we could verify in cities similar in size to Portland and then testing their fit with our values and having public engagement in that process.

469
00:48:45.768 --> 00:48:51.527
<v Diane Meisenhelter>After the Zenith decision-making, I would urge you to consider carefully these 2 confirmations.

470
00:48:51.960 --> 00:48:59.469
<v Diane Meisenhelter>We witnessed a presentation by city staff and Zenith filled with omissions, misleading information, and evasion of important questions.

471
00:48:59.565 --> 00:48:59.724
<v Margaret Butler>Thank you.

472
00:49:00.286 --> 00:49:10.161
<v Diane Meisenhelter>Councilors are the policymakers, and this is an important precedent-setting decision that Jordan oversaw, and your involvement should not have been circumvented.

473
00:49:10.739 --> 00:49:17.693
<v Diane Meisenhelter>City Attorney Taylor, when pressed publicly, conceded that there were options for council involvement but did not help you pursue them.

474
00:49:18.447 --> 00:49:47.371
<v Diane Meisenhelter>I asked my question at the mayoral debate as someone who had followed the city's so-called climate emergency plan as well as emergency planning as a net volunteer, affordable housing policies, and public safety carefully over the past 4 years and understood that some of the same players worked behind the scenes with industry and business interests to help shelf or delay progressive key policies and push forward other policies not in the best interest for reducing emissions, health, or for the public or environmental good.

475
00:49:47.947 --> 00:49:50.978
<v Diane Meisenhelter>We know what happened with the Portland Clean Air Protection Program.

476
00:49:51.331 --> 00:49:55.385
<v Diane Meisenhelter>We watched developers overturn environmental amenities and protections.

477
00:49:55.978 --> 00:50:10.206
<v Diane Meisenhelter>We follow the cleanup of Superfund sites, the Economic Opportunities Plan, the delay on even the mildest options for the Phase 1 Build Shift Plan, much less actual decarbonization, the city's role in freeway expansion, and the list goes on.

478
00:50:11.023 --> 00:50:15.813
<v Diane Meisenhelter>In the midst of a climate emergency and other pressing needs, we don't have time for these misdoings.

479
00:50:16.150 --> 00:50:20.106
<v Diane Meisenhelter>We can't afford leaders without courage, nor players who have let Portland slide backward.

480
00:50:20.170 --> 00:50:20.909
<v Owen Nguyen>Councilmember Second.

481
00:50:20.956 --> 00:50:24.469
<v Diane Meisenhelter>We have come a long way from being a beacon of progress for localities around the country.

482
00:50:25.047 --> 00:50:32.411
<v Diane Meisenhelter>At this point, other cities have surpassed us in many policy realms, and we might learn from their skilled implementers.

483
00:50:33.005 --> 00:50:41.186
<v Diane Meisenhelter>We've managed to transform city governance and have this promising city council to build from, but you must fight for your power together as a council.

484
00:50:41.748 --> 00:50:48.840
<v Diane Meisenhelter>In these difficult times ahead, you need city implementers who will deliver on what you side and what voters have called for.

485
00:50:49.610 --> 00:50:58.505
<v Diane Meisenhelter>Portlanders want and need honesty, transparency, accountability, oversight, and public engagement.

486
00:50:58.585 --> 00:51:12.427
<v Diane Meisenhelter>We fear the old bureaucratic culture hasn't yet and may be incapable of allowing this new governance experiment to move forward in the best of ways and with the support it needs instead of being a barrier.

487
00:51:13.150 --> 00:51:25.768
<v Diane Meisenhelter>So please consider this carefully, and I would also encourage council to, in the future, support the amendment or the resolution by Green and Murillo on Zenith.

488
00:51:26.297 --> 00:51:26.668
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

489
00:51:30.153 --> 00:51:31.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for joining us.

490
00:51:32.829 --> 00:51:33.672
<v Keelan McClymont>Nick Caleb.

491
00:51:34.289 --> 00:51:35.815
<v Keelan McClymont>He submitted written testimony.

492
00:51:40.039 --> 00:51:41.039
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm, I'm sorry, what was that?

493
00:51:41.103 --> 00:51:45.101
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It sounds like maybe he had submitted written testimony and isn't here today with us.

494
00:51:46.021 --> 00:51:46.585
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, great.

495
00:51:46.746 --> 00:51:47.068
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

496
00:51:47.778 --> 00:51:53.454
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, we have Karen Chire, Harlan Schober, and Lynn Handlin.

497
00:51:54.909 --> 00:51:58.889
<v Fred Neal>Can you hear me?

498
00:51:59.518 --> 00:52:00.565
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hello?

499
00:52:04.353 --> 00:52:05.157
<v Keelan McClymont>We, we can hear you.

500
00:52:06.425 --> 00:52:09.827
<v Karen Chire>Oh, good morning, esteemed members of the council.

501
00:52:09.891 --> 00:52:14.884
<v Karen Chire>My name is Karen Chire, a business owner in District 4 and resident of District 3.

502
00:52:15.414 --> 00:52:20.197
<v Karen Chire>I'm here to speak today in support of the appointment of Michael Jordan as city manager.

503
00:52:21.128 --> 00:52:32.733
<v Karen Chire>As we consider this important decision, I urge you to reflect on the pressing matters of safety and livability that our city faces and how Mr. Jordan's leadership can advance these critical areas.

504
00:52:33.407 --> 00:52:42.184
<v Karen Chire>The role of city administrator, as outlined in Section 2-406, requires a demonstrated ability to manage complex city affairs effectively.

505
00:52:42.793 --> 00:52:49.581
<v Karen Chire>Among the core responsibilities is the imperative to advance the city's core values of equity and transparency.

506
00:52:50.094 --> 00:52:54.715
<v Karen Chire>Safety and livability are fundamentally intertwined with these values.

507
00:52:55.389 --> 00:53:11.099
<v Karen Chire>By prioritizing equitable access to safe neighborhoods, Mr. Jordan In recent years, we have witnessed challenges that threaten public safety and the quality of life in our city.

508
00:53:11.695 --> 00:53:24.432
<v Karen Chire>From rising crime rates to the impacts of homelessness, these issues require an administrator who can not only execute and enforce laws but also collaborate with community stakeholders to develop comprehensive solutions.

509
00:53:24.481 --> 00:53:24.867
<v Karen Chire>Councilor Jamie Dunphy.

510
00:53:25.315 --> 00:53:34.452
<v Karen Chire>Mr. Jordan's commitment to communication and collaboration, as highlighted in his job description, is essential in addressing these multifaceted challenges.

511
00:53:35.063 --> 00:53:45.565
<v Karen Chire>I believe Mr. Jordan will make certain that the Deputy Administrator of Public Safety will be present, communicate with public safety organizations as well as citizens of Portland.

512
00:53:46.128 --> 00:53:57.335
<v Karen Chire>Furthermore, the responsibility to control and administer the financial affairs of the city is crucial in ensuring that resources are allocated effectively toward public safety initiatives.

513
00:53:58.090 --> 00:54:05.922
<v Karen Chire>This includes investing in community policing, mental health services, and housing solutions that directly contribute to the livability of our neighborhoods.

514
00:54:06.516 --> 00:54:14.588
<v Karen Chire>Mr. Jordan's experience in budget preparation and financial oversight will be vital in making informed decisions that benefit all Portlanders.

515
00:54:15.583 --> 00:54:22.036
<v Karen Chire>Therefore, I know Michael Jordan will do the right thing and not cut emergency service budget in the fiscal year.

516
00:54:22.726 --> 00:54:30.481
<v Karen Chire>Additionally, Mr. Jordan's role in investigating city affairs and ensuring compliance with laws can enhance accountability within our departments.

517
00:54:31.557 --> 00:54:38.590
<v Karen Chire>This oversight is key to maintaining public trust, which is essential for a safe and livability— livable city.

518
00:54:39.425 --> 00:54:46.731
<v Karen Chire>A well-informed administrator can ensure that our city's policies reflect the needs of the community and are effectively enforced.

519
00:54:50.519 --> 00:54:59.762
<v Karen Chire>In conclusion, as we move forward in this critical appointment, I strongly believe that Michael Jordan is well equipped to address the pressing issues of safety and livability in our city.

520
00:55:00.199 --> 00:55:10.027
<v Karen Chire>His leadership will be instrumental in advancing our core values, ensuring efficient administration, and ultimately creating a Portland where all residents can thrive.

521
00:55:10.615 --> 00:55:12.217
<v Karen Chire>Thank you for your time and consideration.

522
00:55:12.266 --> 00:55:12.398
<v Karen Chire>Thank you.

523
00:55:15.221 --> 00:55:16.148
<v Keelan McClymont>Harlan Schober?

524
00:55:18.963 --> 00:55:19.548
<v Lynn Handlen>He's not here.

525
00:55:20.722 --> 00:55:21.110
<v Keelan McClymont>Lynn Handlen?

526
00:55:22.242 --> 00:55:23.681
<v Lynn Handlen>Hi, City Council members.

527
00:55:23.777 --> 00:55:27.400
<v Lynn Handlen>Thank you for this opportunity, um, to address this issue.

528
00:55:27.998 --> 00:55:29.938
<v Lynn Handlen>My name is Lynn Spideleri Handlen.

529
00:55:30.018 --> 00:55:32.648
<v Lynn Handlen>I'm a small business owner in outer Southeast Portland.

530
00:55:33.228 --> 00:55:42.853
<v Lynn Handlen>Um, this new City Council is such a refreshing change from the lack of transparency Disregard and disregard for community input of the last city council.

531
00:55:43.900 --> 00:56:03.465
<v Lynn Handlen>2 City councilors have called for an investigation into Xena's possible violations of its franchise agreement and make all public records around Xena's backroom dealings with the city, which included Donnie Oliveira, who is— his boss is Michael Jordan.

532
00:56:03.547 --> 00:56:03.804
<v Lynn Handlen>Thank you.

533
00:56:04.637 --> 00:56:10.599
<v Lynn Handlen>So they asked for a pause on all Zenith-related proceedings until investigations have been completed.

534
00:56:11.255 --> 00:56:16.175
<v Lynn Handlen>This council has made it clear you value transparency and community involvement.

535
00:56:16.784 --> 00:56:23.146
<v Lynn Handlen>Unfortunately, Mayor Wilson's interim City Administrator Jordan apparently did not get the memo.

536
00:56:24.012 --> 00:56:36.403
<v Lynn Handlen>Mayor Wilson, City Administrator Jordan, and Deputy City Administrator Oliveira just screwed over the community The environment, local tribal entities, and stripped power from the city council.

537
00:56:36.902 --> 00:56:54.402
<v Lynn Handlen>You all took away your power by granting Zenith Energy the land use compatibility statement they need to continue to expand their dirty, dangerous business of transporting fossil and so-called renewable fuels with no real public process or oversight.

538
00:56:55.751 --> 00:57:04.952
<v Lynn Handlen>During the public briefing about Zenith, DCA Oliveira presented information and misinformation clearly biased in favor of Zenith Energy.

539
00:57:05.530 --> 00:57:15.019
<v Lynn Handlen>He neglected to mention Zenith's many violations, including the most recent one that led to the DEQ— that led the DEQ to require the new LUX.

540
00:57:16.349 --> 00:57:26.980
<v Lynn Handlen>In the Zenith briefing, a representative from the Columbia River Intertribal Fish Commission clearly stated that Zenith's proposed expansion violates Indigenous treaty rights relating to the river.

541
00:57:27.815 --> 00:57:31.407
<v Lynn Handlen>Why did Administrator Jordan ignore input from the tribes?

542
00:57:32.242 --> 00:57:36.782
<v Lynn Handlen>Once appointed, Michael Jordan will be free to defy the will of the council when it suits him.

543
00:57:37.280 --> 00:57:39.864
<v Lynn Handlen>He is clearly not the right person for this job.

544
00:57:40.409 --> 00:57:41.965
<v Lynn Handlen>The community deserves better.

545
00:57:42.494 --> 00:57:46.777
<v Lynn Handlen>The river and those who depend on it for their livelihoods deserve better.

546
00:57:47.163 --> 00:57:49.713
<v Lynn Handlen>And honestly, this city council deserves better.

547
00:57:49.762 --> 00:57:49.907
<v Lynn Handlen>Thank you.

548
00:57:52.219 --> 00:57:57.641
<v Lynn Handlen>Block this appointment and insist on a real process to find the best person for this job.

549
00:57:57.786 --> 00:58:02.128
<v Lynn Handlen>Michael Jordan has clearly proven he is not that person.

550
00:58:03.048 --> 00:58:03.695
<v Diane Meisenhelter>Thank you.

551
00:58:08.847 --> 00:58:13.403
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Michaela McCormick, Lori King, Laura Feldman.

552
00:58:22.367 --> 00:58:23.396
<v Keelan McClymont>Michaela, you're muted.

553
00:58:26.545 --> 00:58:30.353
<v Michaela McCormick>Hello, I'm Michaela McCormick.

554
00:58:30.563 --> 00:58:32.831
<v Michaela McCormick>Thank you for entertaining my comments today.

555
00:58:34.425 --> 00:58:39.190
<v Michaela McCormick>I'm here to urge you to not appoint Michael Jordan to city administrator.

556
00:58:40.585 --> 00:58:50.373
<v Michaela McCormick>Uh, Mr. Jordan oversaw the 2022 process, which was flawed and illegal, that led to granting the LUCS to Zenith Energy.

557
00:58:51.126 --> 00:59:01.804
<v Michaela McCormick>It included illegal lobbying by Zenith, parts of which were false or meaningless concessions that allowed them to continue pursuing their catastrophic climate strategy.

558
00:59:02.688 --> 00:59:14.507
<v Michaela McCormick>Jordan's deputy, Donnie Oliveira, said that the conditions in the 2022 LUCS, quote, were based on conversations we'd been having with advocates at the time, unquote.

559
00:59:15.309 --> 00:59:24.016
<v Michaela McCormick>To the extent he meant the environmental and community groups who have been blowing a whistle on the backroom deal, this is a complete fabrication.

560
00:59:25.494 --> 00:59:46.289
<v Michaela McCormick>Not only were advocates specifically not consulted during this process, it happened while the city was being sued by Zenith over the 2021 LUCS, where Columbia Riverkeeper was involved in the litigation to defend the Instead, the city created a separate secretive process to pursue its own agenda.

561
00:59:46.865 --> 00:59:58.449
<v Michaela McCormick>Staff also did not explain what made them decide to reverse their decision in 2022, in spite of Zenith's continued violation of the comprehensive plan and zoning.

562
00:59:59.347 --> 01:00:14.686
<v Michaela McCormick>In its presentation to the city, staff omitted key information, including that Zenith has to acquire a new Lux because it was caught doing illegal modification and use of piping and did not have adequate permission to operate.

563
01:00:15.472 --> 01:00:26.208
<v Michaela McCormick>Staff skewed its presentation to avoid mention of any of Xena's past violations, including failure to report its 2022 lobbying and ongoing investigations.

564
01:00:26.802 --> 01:00:35.996
<v Michaela McCormick>Staff declined to answer questions about the construction and modification that was the subject of DEQ's November 2024 investigation.

565
01:00:36.815 --> 01:00:47.601
<v Michaela McCormick>Interim City Administrator Jordan had the responsibility to interrupt these unethical and illegal actions and see that the process was set on a proper track.

566
01:00:48.226 --> 01:00:50.697
<v Michaela McCormick>He should not be appointed City Administrator.

567
01:00:51.179 --> 01:00:56.460
<v Michaela McCormick>Instead, the investigation proposed by Councilors Green and Murillo needs to be pursued.

568
01:00:57.375 --> 01:00:58.226
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

569
01:01:02.512 --> 01:01:02.882
<v Keelan McClymont>Lori King.

570
01:01:03.251 --> 01:01:06.896
<v Lori King>Okay, uh, good morning, good morning, Mayor and council members.

571
01:01:07.233 --> 01:01:08.099
<v Lori King>Um, I'm Lori King.

572
01:01:08.757 --> 01:01:17.429
<v Lori King>Uh, first I'd like to register my support for all Portland workers in achieving fair contracts, but I want to say I'm not happy today.

573
01:01:17.766 --> 01:01:26.726
<v Lori King>I've been very sad and angry since I heard that the city administration granted Zenith Deluxe some office in City Hall Without any public process.

574
01:01:27.384 --> 01:01:35.043
<v Lori King>It's not just that I think it was a bad decision, and I think you've heard a lot, we have ample evidence for this, but it's the way the decision was made.

575
01:01:35.829 --> 01:01:39.987
<v Lori King>My main reason for testifying is to support our city council.

576
01:01:40.501 --> 01:01:45.833
<v Lori King>Not only were Portlanders kept out of a transparent process on the Lux, but the council was as well.

577
01:01:46.731 --> 01:01:55.496
<v Lori King>The administration of the city, in large part led by Michael Jordan, And Mayor Wilson, they did an end run around the council on— around the council.

578
01:01:55.980 --> 01:02:08.891
<v Lori King>On Friday, 2 council members let it be known that they planned to introduce the reasonable resolution calling for a delay in the Lux consideration pending investigation into whether Zenith's franchise agreement had been violated.

579
01:02:09.565 --> 01:02:14.150
<v Lori King>After this, just a few days later, Monday morning, the Lux slid through.

580
01:02:14.875 --> 01:02:16.597
<v Lori King>Why couldn't that decision wait?

581
01:02:17.358 --> 01:02:24.376
<v Lori King>City staff acknowledged on 1/21 that the DEQ's February 4th deadline did not bind the city.

582
01:02:25.195 --> 01:02:30.268
<v Lori King>Where was the respect due to the legislative branch of our city government by the executive branch?

583
01:02:30.831 --> 01:02:35.889
<v Lori King>Council members at best heard about the Lux decision a half hour before the public.

584
01:02:36.851 --> 01:02:38.264
<v Lori King>How will Portland be governed?

585
01:02:38.938 --> 01:02:43.001
<v Lori King>The public wants involved council members who will ask the hard questions.

586
01:02:43.418 --> 01:02:47.253
<v Lori King>For instance, about Zenith's franchise violations.

587
01:02:47.829 --> 01:02:56.829
<v Lori King>Maybe councilors will ask the questions that the administration won't ask, because, because these questions might well put corporate players on the spot.

588
01:02:58.097 --> 01:03:03.295
<v Lori King>There's only one way I'd even start considering support for hiring Michael Jordan.

589
01:03:03.809 --> 01:03:16.516
<v Lori King>And that's if he acts legally, morally, and reasonably and rescinds the LUCS until the resolution— Councilors Murillo and Green are considered properly.

590
01:03:17.210 --> 01:03:21.784
<v Lori King>Other than that, we need a new administrator who will work with the city council and the public.

591
01:03:22.190 --> 01:03:25.077
<v Lori King>And I also want to add, in due respect, we're not leaving.

592
01:03:30.710 --> 01:03:31.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all.

593
01:03:32.438 --> 01:03:32.992
<v Keelan McClymont>Laura Feldman.

594
01:03:34.376 --> 01:03:35.690
<v Loretta Smith>Councilmember Herbold.

595
01:03:35.737 --> 01:03:37.324
<v Michael Jordan>Good morning, everyone.

596
01:03:37.677 --> 01:03:38.927
<v Laura Feldman>My name is Laura Feldman.

597
01:03:40.001 --> 01:04:08.344
<v Laura Feldman>As someone who lives in the blast zone on the North Portland Peninsula and, and who has worked on the Portland Harbor Superfund cleanup on the Lower Willamette for many years, I'm heartbroken, utterly heartbroken, that Mayor Wilson and city administrators are giving Zenith the Lux despite their legacy of violations overlooked by the previous city government, and at a time when the future of the country itself is being taken over by corporate interests at every level.

598
01:04:09.034 --> 01:04:10.594
<v Laura Feldman>It's truly traumatizing.

599
01:04:11.510 --> 01:04:23.465
<v Laura Feldman>The imminent and ongoing disaster of the Zenith Oil Terminal, which threatens the CEI hub where most of Oregon's fuel is stored, is a harbinger of whether or not Portland will be a safe place to live.

600
01:04:24.364 --> 01:04:41.806
<v Laura Feldman>I urge Mayor Wilson and staff to respond rescind this LUX and make time for this new and hopeful City Council to consider Green's and Morillo's resolution, giving council members time to investigate Zenith's violation of the city's franchise agreement.

601
01:04:42.260 --> 01:04:42.697
<v Karen Chire>Thank you.

602
01:04:46.831 --> 01:04:48.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for joining us.

603
01:04:48.659 --> 01:04:52.351
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Margaret Butler, Jordan Lewis, Jeremy Clark.

604
01:05:00.900 --> 01:05:01.237
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

605
01:05:01.302 --> 01:05:02.215
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

606
01:05:03.306 --> 01:05:04.717
<v Margaret Butler>Hi, city councilors.

607
01:05:05.150 --> 01:05:17.387
<v Margaret Butler>My name is Margaret Butler and I'm a lifelong Portlander, and I, like many people here, are utterly appalled at the administrative decision to grant Zenith the Lux.

608
01:05:17.436 --> 01:05:22.684
<v Margaret Butler>So I'm here to speak in opposition to the appointment of Michael Jordan.

609
01:05:23.503 --> 01:05:27.887
<v Margaret Butler>We need a city administrator who understands the emergency we're in.

610
01:05:28.577 --> 01:05:37.922
<v Margaret Butler>I worked in the labor movement for 40 years, and when I retired, I put my attention to the climate emergency, and boy, that was scary.

611
01:05:38.693 --> 01:05:47.817
<v Margaret Butler>So 6 years ago, I was part of a group— part of a group of Portland residents who built a garden on the railroad tracks at Zenith.

612
01:05:48.556 --> 01:06:02.679
<v Margaret Butler>And we did that because the city had a no new fossil fuels zoning ordinance but couldn't do anything to prevent this expansion of fossil fuel infrastructure that Zenith was engaged in.

613
01:06:03.338 --> 01:06:04.929
<v Margaret Butler>And we were appalled then.

614
01:06:05.507 --> 01:06:14.510
<v Margaret Butler>It was wrong in this time of climate emergency to expand the transport of fossil fuels around the globe.

615
01:06:15.246 --> 01:06:47.490
<v Margaret Butler>5 years ago, 5 of us pled guilty and went to a trial in the Multnomah County Court hearing, and 5 out of 6 jurors voted to acquit us because we had made the case that we had tried everything else to shut down this ongoing harm in our community, and that piece peaceful protest was more important and more justified than letting these oil trains continue to roll.

616
01:06:49.092 --> 01:07:00.170
<v Margaret Butler>Now it's 5 years later since that time, and the Xena throughput has only increased exponentially in that time.

617
01:07:00.527 --> 01:07:09.346
<v Margaret Butler>Emissions around the globe, it continued by Zenith's continued operation here have only grown.

618
01:07:10.003 --> 01:07:12.925
<v Margaret Butler>The evidence of climate breakdown is everywhere.

619
01:07:13.376 --> 01:07:16.635
<v Margaret Butler>The time for business as usual is over.

620
01:07:17.389 --> 01:07:20.215
<v Margaret Butler>We need a city administrator—.

621
01:07:20.215 --> 01:07:21.581
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I need to pause you for one minute.

622
01:07:21.740 --> 01:07:22.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

623
01:07:22.704 --> 01:07:29.465
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that folks want to express their support for our testifiers, but I ask that you do that in a way that is within our rules of decorum.

624
01:07:29.528 --> 01:07:36.295
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're starting to see clapping and cheering, and I want to make sure that we're able to get through everybody's testimony without interruption.

625
01:07:36.583 --> 01:07:39.021
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I apologize for interrupting you, Ms. Butler.

626
01:07:39.469 --> 01:07:40.110
<v Margaret Butler>That's okay.

627
01:07:40.815 --> 01:07:55.324
<v Margaret Butler>Um, so we need you, the City Council, to make sure we have administration who will take bold action on behalf of Portlanders in the midst of the climate emergency, which is only going to get worse.

628
01:07:55.661 --> 01:07:55.885
<v Jan Zuckerman>Thank you.

629
01:07:56.697 --> 01:07:58.599
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

630
01:08:01.010 --> 01:08:01.398
<v Keelan McClymont>Jordan Lewis.

631
01:08:06.070 --> 01:08:18.408
<v Jordan Lewis>City Council and, uh, President Pirtle-Guiney, in my friend group I'm known for being the uppity politico who's always linking news articles and makes sure everyone reads through the voters pamphlet even when they have better things to do.

632
01:08:19.395 --> 01:08:34.731
<v Jordan Lewis>Uh, after election night, I was put in this weird position of having to defend electoral politics to minimum wage workers who foresaw losing their insurance, friends who foresaw family members being torn away from them, and trans people who foresaw losing access to gender-affirming care.

633
01:08:35.485 --> 01:08:39.001
<v Jordan Lewis>For me, the best argument not to tune out was the local elections.

634
01:08:39.514 --> 01:08:46.109
<v Jordan Lewis>Me and hundreds like me spent our summer and fall working tirelessly to elect a diverse and representative city government.

635
01:08:46.574 --> 01:08:48.356
<v Jordan Lewis>We succeeded, and this gave us so much hope.

636
01:08:48.421 --> 01:08:48.516
<v Jordan Lewis>Thank you.

637
01:08:48.742 --> 01:08:49.640
<v Jordan Lewis>In such a dark time.

638
01:08:50.587 --> 01:08:53.685
<v Jordan Lewis>I spoke to over 1,000 voters, and climate came up constantly.

639
01:08:54.054 --> 01:08:55.451
<v Jordan Lewis>Zenith came up constantly.

640
01:08:56.125 --> 01:08:58.340
<v Jordan Lewis>I don't remember a single voter approving of Zenith.

641
01:08:59.255 --> 01:09:05.354
<v Jordan Lewis>At the January meeting, Donnie Oliveira said the 4th was not a legally binding deadline for the city to approve Deluxe.

642
01:09:05.930 --> 01:09:16.796
<v Jordan Lewis>So imagine how I feel trying to mobilize people against a second Trump administration after the mayor rushes approval through just before the council that we broke our our backs for can get a chance to investigate it.

643
01:09:17.309 --> 01:09:18.560
<v Jordan Lewis>Now I look like an idiot.

644
01:09:19.297 --> 01:09:22.122
<v Jordan Lewis>I hesitated to even show up today because I want to work in government.

645
01:09:22.282 --> 01:09:30.335
<v Jordan Lewis>I feel like testifying today might put me on some kind of blacklist, but there's no point trying if you can't look voters in the eye and say you have their best interests at heart.

646
01:09:31.248 --> 01:09:36.447
<v Jordan Lewis>Mayor Wilson, Zenith is a losing issue, and by rubber stamping it, you've permanently tarnished your administration.

647
01:09:36.960 --> 01:09:46.180
<v Jordan Lewis>You started your term by prioritizing the profits of a Texas oil company over the welfare of your elected if you want to see where that gets you, I suggest you ask the previous mayor.

648
01:09:46.983 --> 01:09:51.423
<v Jordan Lewis>I'm not sure what recourse this council has at this point, but it's crucial that the investigation see the light of day.

649
01:09:52.016 --> 01:09:56.362
<v Jordan Lewis>Michael Jordan is but a medium-sized fish in a larger, larger ecosystem of voter contempt.

650
01:09:56.859 --> 01:10:06.302
<v Jordan Lewis>Dysfunctional blue-state governance that, when faced with a fascist takeover of the federal government, turns around and tells us concerned voters just looking out for one another that we're the problem.

651
01:10:06.927 --> 01:10:10.439
<v Jordan Lewis>Consequences may not exist in D.C., but I need to believe that they exist in here.

652
01:10:10.534 --> 01:10:14.353
<v Jan Zuckerman>Councilor Thank you.

653
01:10:14.400 --> 01:10:15.078
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

654
01:10:16.479 --> 01:10:17.159
<v Keelan McClymont>Jeremy Clerk.

655
01:10:20.141 --> 01:10:24.663
<v Keelan McClymont>Jan Zuckerman, Edith Gillis, and Candace Jimenez.

656
01:10:30.431 --> 01:10:31.337
<v Keelan McClymont>Good morning, council—.

657
01:10:32.112 --> 01:10:32.596
<v Keelan McClymont>Councils.

658
01:10:33.485 --> 01:10:41.881
<v Jan Zuckerman>The city administrator is appointed to advance the city's core values, which includes transparency, communication, and collaboration.

659
01:10:42.106 --> 01:10:53.135
<v Jan Zuckerman>The administrator is also responsible for advancing the city's efforts to mitigate the human-made climate crisis and prioritize environmental justice initiatives.

660
01:10:54.136 --> 01:11:00.078
<v Jan Zuckerman>It is our duty to call into question the clear violation of our city's core values.

661
01:11:00.998 --> 01:11:18.805
<v Jan Zuckerman>City Administrator Jordan's and DCA Oliveira's unorthodox, non-transparent process and their poorly communicated decisions, which prioritize Zenith Energy over the health and safety of Portlanders, will place us in peril for decades to come.

662
01:11:19.898 --> 01:11:54.189
<v Jan Zuckerman>Relying on the promise of Zenith Energy, a profit-based fossil fuel company with a history of dishonesty and violations to lead the way in reducing our city's greenhouse gas emissions using so-called renewable fuels with a clear goal of increasing the throughput of flammable fuels in the hub calls into question the commitment of the administrators in advancing efforts to mitigate the human-made climate crisis and prioritize environmental justice initiatives.

663
01:11:55.265 --> 01:12:20.139
<v Jan Zuckerman>Not only do records show malfeasance and lack of transparency regarding Zenith Energy, but our administrators also chose to ignore Councilor Green and Murillo's resolution to investigate Zenith and false statements made by the city staff rather than collaborate with the city council's call for transparency and clearer communication.

664
01:12:20.640 --> 01:12:33.372
<v Jan Zuckerman>Our administrator chose to collaborate with Zenith Energy, advancing their core values over those of the city's, rewarding Zenith's illegal activities by approving the LUX.

665
01:12:34.146 --> 01:12:40.662
<v Jan Zuckerman>We need leaders who are willing to admit mistakes and take responsibility for them.

666
01:12:41.421 --> 01:12:45.774
<v Jan Zuckerman>We need a city administrator that clearly upholds our city's values.

667
01:12:46.590 --> 01:12:47.417
<v Jan Zuckerman>Thank you very much.

668
01:12:49.185 --> 01:12:50.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

669
01:12:53.430 --> 01:12:55.930
<v Keelan McClymont>Edith Gillis, Candace Jimenez.

670
01:12:58.527 --> 01:13:00.108
<v Edith Gillis>Hello, can you hear me?

671
01:13:01.350 --> 01:13:01.753
<v Keelan McClymont>Go ahead, Edith.

672
01:13:02.902 --> 01:13:03.935
<v Edith Gillis>I'm Edith Gillis.

673
01:13:04.275 --> 01:13:04.663
<v Edith Gillis>You all—.

674
01:13:04.873 --> 01:13:11.984
<v Edith Gillis>City administrator, mayor, councilors, city staff— have my empathy, best wishes, gratitude, and commitment to support you to best serve Portlanders.

675
01:13:12.090 --> 01:13:12.217
<v Edith Gillis>Thank you.

676
01:13:12.587 --> 01:13:21.963
<v Edith Gillis>Which means I also want you to immediately reverse your bad decisions to allow Zenith and to cut all budgets except the police.

677
01:13:22.478 --> 01:13:37.297
<v Edith Gillis>If you don't correct this, it will have devastating, horrific consequences for city governance and funding, public trust and cooperation, success with official city priorities, local and state economy and environment, and harm the safety and resilience of all Portlanders and regional people and entities.

678
01:13:37.828 --> 01:13:48.768
<v Edith Gillis>Zenith and cops endanger public safety and mental health, reduce housing security, cost us all while doing us no good, and are not transparent, undermine democracy, and do not comply with city priorities or the public will.

679
01:13:49.426 --> 01:13:59.226
<v Edith Gillis>Only approve Michael Jordan and the other city administrator if they aim to prevent this dangerous corruption extortion and instead provide these protections to each aspect of city management.

680
01:13:59.371 --> 01:14:01.457
<v Edith Gillis>Respect Green's and Murillo's proposal.

681
01:14:01.810 --> 01:14:05.018
<v Edith Gillis>Zenith and oil bomb trains and the costly current cop culture Yes.

682
01:14:05.145 --> 01:14:16.485
<v Edith Gillis>While robbing other departments that do more good to prevent crime than cops ever did or will means that the city and local businesses and homeowners have to pay higher insurance, raising our costs and inability to pay taxes.

683
01:14:16.774 --> 01:14:18.041
<v Edith Gillis>The city bond value goes down.

684
01:14:18.457 --> 01:14:26.590
<v Edith Gillis>Corporations in the cities overcharge and underservice, and wise investors and knowledgeable residents with the ability to— will flee Portland Metro.

685
01:14:27.055 --> 01:14:36.409
<v Edith Gillis>Those who remain will have less money and willingness to pay taxes, have less money, time, energy, health, and ability to do the unpaid volunteer work and community building and disaster resilience we need.

686
01:14:36.844 --> 01:14:42.096
<v Edith Gillis>Businesses and tourists won't come to such a dangerous, unfair, depressing, violent, ugly place.

687
01:14:42.466 --> 01:15:00.925
<v Edith Gillis>Stop Zenith until it cleans up its mess, complies with city priorities, provides proof of safety, pays fines for its lies and fraud and violations, and prepays risk bonds for future injuries, healthcare, housing, environmental cleanup, and restitution to businesses, nonprofits, governments, and civilians to return 30 years after Zenith leaves and cleans up all its mess and harm.

688
01:15:00.989 --> 01:15:01.006
<v Edith Gillis>Aye.

689
01:15:01.341 --> 01:15:07.865
<v Edith Gillis>Require Zenith to reimburse local businesses, nonprofit schools, and businesses for increased insurance because Zenith increases our risks.

690
01:15:08.378 --> 01:15:11.680
<v Edith Gillis>Prevent oil bomb trains so more housing can be more affordable along the tracks.

691
01:15:12.002 --> 01:15:20.818
<v Edith Gillis>Require Zenith have its site proven safe and effective fire prevention suppression, loud and visible public warnings for all people, and environmental cleanup and escape.

692
01:15:21.219 --> 01:15:29.524
<v Edith Gillis>Require all cops to pay their own liability insurance to the city and fire them when they don't protect all Portlanders and comply with city social justice, climate, housing security priorities.

693
01:15:29.862 --> 01:15:33.573
<v Edith Gillis>Cut the police budget and increase the parks, housing, and social justice investments.

694
01:15:33.974 --> 01:15:43.980
<v Edith Gillis>Have cops enforce laws against polluters, bad landlords, employers that cause homelessness, lying property owners and empty housing units, and bad landlords, property managers.

695
01:15:44.333 --> 01:15:53.859
<v Edith Gillis>Instead of wasting money on cops and Zenith, invest into what we need for requiring empty habitable houses and excessive peopleless housing to be available to houseless people.

696
01:15:53.939 --> 01:16:04.260
<v Edith Gillis>Affordable rent, livable wages, local solar electric and food security, a public bank and public power, hemp and bamboo for making our own face masks and medical gowns when the U.S. wars against China suppliers.

697
01:16:05.140 --> 01:16:15.359
<v Edith Gillis>Seeing us repeated lies and reckless and dangerous all along with cop culture of dishonesty and violent and unaccountable racism, classism, ableism, sexism endangers all of Portland, our economy and city finances.

698
01:16:15.359 --> 01:16:17.739
<v Edith Gillis>Give us reasons to trust and invest.

699
01:16:17.930 --> 01:16:18.800
<v Michael Jordan>Do not allow—.

700
01:16:18.800 --> 01:16:19.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being with us.

701
01:16:19.659 --> 01:16:35.460
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm so sorry to cut you off, but we need to make sure we can get to everyone and have time for councilors good morning, esteemed council members.

702
01:16:36.037 --> 01:16:39.872
<v Candace Jimenez>My name is Candace Jimenez, and I'm a tribal citizen of the Confederated Tribes of Warm Springs.

703
01:16:40.368 --> 01:16:49.257
<v Candace Jimenez>I serve as chair of the Portland Harbor Community Coalition, which is an organization committed to ensuring that the cleanup and future of the Portland Harbor reflects the needs of impacted communities.

704
01:16:50.653 --> 01:17:00.215
<v Candace Jimenez>I'm here today to stress the critical importance of holding our city administrators accountable to the people that they serve, particularly when it comes to decisions impacting the Willamette River.

705
01:17:01.386 --> 01:17:05.975
<v Candace Jimenez>This also includes tribal sovereignty and environmental justice across the board, as we've heard today.

706
01:17:06.617 --> 01:17:11.220
<v Candace Jimenez>The recent approval of Zenith Energy land use compatibility statement is deeply concerning.

707
01:17:12.006 --> 01:17:16.177
<v Candace Jimenez>Zenith Energy has a well-documented history of environmental violations and Portland.

708
01:17:16.483 --> 01:17:17.412
<v Candace Jimenez>That goes without saying.

709
01:17:18.470 --> 01:17:24.148
<v Candace Jimenez>The Willamette River is sacred to Indigenous peoples and central to the culture and survival of many tribal nations.

710
01:17:24.820 --> 01:17:33.448
<v Candace Jimenez>My ancestors have lived along these waters since time immemorial, fishing, gathering, and stewarding the land long before industrial pollution made it unsafe.

711
01:17:34.443 --> 01:17:45.778
<v Candace Jimenez>The Portland Harbor Superfund site is a direct result of ongoing and unchecked industry contaminating the river, disproportionately impacting tribal nations and other frontline communities, and all those here today.

712
01:17:47.550 --> 01:18:05.822
<v Candace Jimenez>Any decision regarding this river must center the voices of tribal nations through meaningful consultation, not as an afterthought but as a fundamental requirement of environmental justice and treaty obligations, just as the Columbia River Intertribal Fish Commission reiterated at the January 21st listening session.

713
01:18:06.345 --> 01:18:12.230
<v Candace Jimenez>And I'll also go on to say that we've had a lot of outreach with Office of Government Relations, and we still have not heard back.

714
01:18:14.029 --> 01:18:22.386
<v Candace Jimenez>Councilor Murillo made a point in this discussion, quote, our role as elected officials is to be watchdogs on policy decisions that are coming before us.

715
01:18:22.980 --> 01:18:30.935
<v Candace Jimenez>The public deserves— we deserve to have all of the information in front of us before we make decisions on granting land use credentials like this.

716
01:18:31.756 --> 01:18:46.193
<v Candace Jimenez>Yet we have seen in this process a failure of transparency and due diligence and the actions of Mayor Wilson, City Administrator Jordan, and Deputy City Administrator Oliveira do not exemplify this— the prioritization of the health of Portland residents.

717
01:18:46.787 --> 01:18:56.304
<v Candace Jimenez>Instead, we see dialogue, and approving the statement deepens the mistrust in city government and also calls into question the commitment to the well-being of our communities.

718
01:18:57.780 --> 01:19:02.033
<v Candace Jimenez>Accountability to the health of the river and the surrounding community is built upon trust.

719
01:19:02.500 --> 01:19:03.109
<v Candace Jimenez>We all know this.

720
01:19:03.801 --> 01:19:18.573
<v Candace Jimenez>When city leaders ignore the voices of frontline communities, tribal nations, and environmental advocates, they continue to erode the public faith in government and reinforce a system that continues to put corporate fossil fuel interests above the public health and safety of our people.

721
01:19:19.439 --> 01:19:28.088
<v Candace Jimenez>If trust is to be rebuilt, it starts with rejecting Xena's continued expansion and ensures a future that prioritizes environmental justice alongside you all.

722
01:19:29.255 --> 01:19:35.163
<v Candace Jimenez>As chair of the Portland Harbor Community Coalition, I know that our communities care deeply about the Willamette River and the health of our people.

723
01:19:36.170 --> 01:19:49.113
<v Candace Jimenez>I want to just end with that our tribal cultures are built upon respect— respect for the land, air, water, animals, and to each other— and we own the collective responsibility to care for the river for future generations, and we must uphold this.

724
01:19:51.536 --> 01:19:52.005
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

725
01:19:55.663 --> 01:20:00.654
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Charlie Michelle Wesley, Linda Liu, and Ao Nguyen.

726
01:20:04.560 --> 01:20:05.476
<v Jan Zuckerman>Hi, can you hear me okay?

727
01:20:06.121 --> 01:20:06.668
<v Keelan McClymont>We can hear you.

728
01:20:07.731 --> 01:20:08.149
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Very good.

729
01:20:09.083 --> 01:20:11.886
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Uh, first, thank you, Councilor Mariella Greene, very much.

730
01:20:12.561 --> 01:20:19.708
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>I am Charlie Michelle Wesley, tribal member of the Confederated Tribes of multiple tribes of this land and original stewards of our Mother Earth.

731
01:20:20.212 --> 01:20:29.324
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>You now have the privilege to reside on, and yet your Zenith decision now contributed to the contamination of our sacred mother, as evidenced by this decision.

732
01:20:29.677 --> 01:20:43.844
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>And despite overwhelming community opposition due to pollution of our air, risk to our health and safety, lack of Portland core city values of transparency, Zenith is a deadly threat to our environment and Portlanders' lives.

733
01:20:44.502 --> 01:20:45.769
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>These are your community members.

734
01:20:46.747 --> 01:20:48.305
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Pollution does not discriminate.

735
01:20:48.771 --> 01:21:04.250
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>So if this decision was made despite horrific risks to all life, it's time to more deeply review the core city values, which should be your values as a city administrator and mayor, and should be the lens you hold up to all your decisions to earn our trust.

736
01:21:04.972 --> 01:21:05.358
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Now, only—.

737
01:21:05.872 --> 01:21:40.158
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Not only was there disregard for the core city values of transparency, but also the fiscal value which states the City of Portland is dedicated to being fiscally accountable to the public, and whereas fiscal resiliency, climate action, equity, and the needs of our most vulnerable, which is us when it comes to this decision, will be the focus of every budget decision, and whereas community values addressing inequities and transparent budgetary decisions are essential to developing that trust.

738
01:21:41.216 --> 01:21:46.863
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>This brings me to the city's land acknowledgment, which is rarely acknowledged.

739
01:21:47.408 --> 01:21:56.521
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>We acknowledge that the rivers, lakes, streams, and lands of the Lower Willamette River rest upon the occupied territories of my people of multiple tribes.

740
01:21:56.875 --> 01:22:03.114
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>We recognize the many villages, traditions, cultures, and this is your, your land acknowledgment.

741
01:22:03.676 --> 01:22:08.390
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Cultures and relationships that existed along the river since time immemorial.

742
01:22:09.143 --> 01:22:14.962
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>We recognize these tribes stewarded these lands and rivers for future generations.

743
01:22:15.619 --> 01:22:20.091
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>We recognize and undertake responsibility for the destruction of the river and land.

744
01:22:20.604 --> 01:22:22.176
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>These are our sacred places.

745
01:22:22.769 --> 01:22:41.341
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>We recognize the economic and social values that enable the harm to the river and perpetuate harm against with this acknowledgment, y'all committed to honoring and learning and working towards a more equitable and sustainable future for the Lower Willamette River.

746
01:22:42.145 --> 01:22:53.265
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>We, the city, commit to seeking solutions that acknowledge the inequities of socioeconomic policies and the harm done to people and our relationships to the lands and water.

747
01:22:54.233 --> 01:22:55.328
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>We want to trust y'all.

748
01:22:55.890 --> 01:23:03.735
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>So I ask you, how can you legitimize the harm to us and our sacred Mother Earth?

749
01:23:04.619 --> 01:23:16.457
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>My concern is this and other decisions and plans don't respect most of the core city values and the fact that Administrator Jordan is a Wheeler appointee.

750
01:23:17.350 --> 01:23:19.788
<v Charlie Michelle Wesley>Walk Jordan, rescind loops.

751
01:23:19.935 --> 01:23:20.813
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

752
01:23:22.622 --> 01:23:23.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for your testimony.

753
01:23:24.698 --> 01:23:27.256
<v Keelan McClymont>Linda Liu.

754
01:23:33.009 --> 01:23:35.157
<v Linda Liu>Hi, good morning, um, city councilors.

755
01:23:35.819 --> 01:23:47.359
<v Linda Liu>Before I make my case to oppose the reappointment of Mr. Jordan, I suggest you all to look at the room full of people and not reduce us as environmental activists.

756
01:23:47.887 --> 01:23:48.979
<v Linda Liu>We are real people.

757
01:23:49.572 --> 01:23:52.170
<v Linda Liu>You live in Portland just like we do.

758
01:23:53.212 --> 01:23:55.442
<v Linda Liu>So we want our city to thrive, right?

759
01:23:55.761 --> 01:24:02.497
<v Linda Liu>And therefore, we are here to weigh in on what qualities of leaders we require of our city administrator.

760
01:24:03.155 --> 01:24:08.993
<v Linda Liu>So I urge you to listen from the standpoint of a collective desire to build Portland better.

761
01:24:10.292 --> 01:24:13.596
<v Linda Liu>So I am a strategic consultant So I use data.

762
01:24:14.207 --> 01:24:21.725
<v Linda Liu>According to census data, more than 20,000 people moved away from Portland since 2020.

763
01:24:22.399 --> 01:24:33.449
<v Linda Liu>These are not just taxpayers or a figure, but our friends, your neighbors, people that you nod to when you go on a walk, familiar faces at your workplace and even at bars.

764
01:24:34.045 --> 01:24:37.722
<v Linda Liu>People left because we did not see a valid leadership.

765
01:24:37.770 --> 01:24:38.364
<v Linda Liu>Councilor Sameer Kanal.

766
01:24:38.769 --> 01:24:41.453
<v Linda Liu>And that's why you guys are here where you are.

767
01:24:41.841 --> 01:24:43.524
<v Linda Liu>We put you in power.

768
01:24:45.770 --> 01:24:58.386
<v Linda Liu>So when a bunch of kids got into trouble, we looked to the school, looked at the principals and asked, why did you allow your, your kids or your students to behave like that?

769
01:24:58.819 --> 01:25:03.012
<v Linda Liu>The former Ted Wheeler administration has definitely set Portland back.

770
01:25:03.880 --> 01:25:06.384
<v Linda Liu>And I say with my chest because I moved here in 2020.

771
01:25:07.253 --> 01:25:14.345
<v Linda Liu>And I'm finally feeling hopeful again for my life in Portland, where I want to make myself a permanent home here.

772
01:25:16.180 --> 01:25:34.341
<v Linda Liu>So it's evident that Mr. Jordan, as someone who has worked and dedicated his life in public serving, um, while often has put Portlanders' interests at front, we should also look at the other decisions that he helped make.

773
01:25:35.097 --> 01:25:39.479
<v Linda Liu>When people tell you who they are and who they're friends with, believe them.

774
01:25:41.064 --> 01:25:45.978
<v Linda Liu>I am a Gen Z, so I'll say Mr. Jordan can be seen as Ted Wheeler's exes.

775
01:25:47.076 --> 01:25:57.288
<v Linda Liu>So I want to empower city council members who are sitting here today and who are asking the smart governance questions to keep asking those critical questions.

776
01:25:57.984 --> 01:26:15.582
<v Linda Liu>So I was at the listening session the last time And I was very impressed by Councilor Green, Councilor Marino, Councilor Kanal, Councilor Lang, and Councilor Zimmerman to ask those difficult procedural questions in terms of your power and responsibility in relationship to city administration.

777
01:26:16.110 --> 01:26:20.009
<v Linda Liu>Those are the questions that smart people ask, and they are painful.

778
01:26:21.243 --> 01:26:24.547
<v Linda Liu>But I ask you to not be embarrassed or scared, or rather be proud.

779
01:26:25.189 --> 01:26:36.820
<v Linda Liu>Speaking as your constituent, I demand you feel supported Emboldened, inspired, and dedicated to steer a new leadership and no longer only delivers from business influence and corporate interests.

780
01:26:37.417 --> 01:26:38.060
<v Linda Liu>Thank you for your time.

781
01:26:40.710 --> 01:26:41.609
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for your testimony.

782
01:26:48.587 --> 01:26:50.810
<v Owen Nguyen>Good morning, councilors.

783
01:26:51.244 --> 01:26:52.340
<v Owen Nguyen>My name is Owen Nguyen.

784
01:26:52.694 --> 01:26:53.805
<v Owen Nguyen>My pronouns are he/him.

785
01:26:54.134 --> 01:26:55.186
<v Owen Nguyen>I live in District 3.

786
01:26:56.484 --> 01:27:15.121
<v Owen Nguyen>We have heard from multiple speakers earlier today about transparency, about the need for transparent process in searching for a new city administrator, as well as transparency in city processes and operations and decisions.

787
01:27:17.393 --> 01:27:21.604
<v Owen Nguyen>I would like to point out that the approval of the Zenith Thank you.

788
01:27:21.765 --> 01:27:25.777
<v Owen Nguyen>The way that the city handled the revenue statement is the opposite of transparency.

789
01:27:27.126 --> 01:27:43.453
<v Owen Nguyen>It came out completely out of nowhere without any input from the community, and it went to a company that has a history of ignoring the law.

790
01:27:45.109 --> 01:27:49.164
<v Owen Nguyen>They went and did construction on their site without any permits.

791
01:27:50.230 --> 01:27:54.645
<v Owen Nguyen>They have been fined by the State Department of Environmental Quality.

792
01:27:56.618 --> 01:27:59.761
<v Owen Nguyen>This is not your friend.

793
01:28:02.412 --> 01:28:16.363
<v Owen Nguyen>And I would argue that City Administrator Jordan's decision to approve this decision is disqualifying, and he should not be appointed— reappointed as city manager.

794
01:28:16.427 --> 01:28:16.525
<v Owen Nguyen>Thank you.

795
01:28:21.347 --> 01:28:25.266
<v Owen Nguyen>I urge you to reverse the approval of the land use decision.

796
01:28:27.367 --> 01:28:41.359
<v Owen Nguyen>Do not— and oppose the reappointment of City Administrator Jordan, and support Councilor Green and Morillo's initiative to bring more transparency to this government.

797
01:28:41.569 --> 01:28:41.922
<v Owen Nguyen>Thank you.

798
01:28:42.019 --> 01:28:42.404
<v Owen Nguyen>Thank you.

799
01:28:44.697 --> 01:28:45.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

800
01:28:45.988 --> 01:28:47.117
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

801
01:28:49.739 --> 01:28:50.255
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Keelan.

802
01:28:52.840 --> 01:28:56.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we have an open motion on the table.

803
01:28:57.621 --> 01:29:02.081
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that folks have a number of questions for the city administrator.

804
01:29:02.720 --> 01:29:18.632
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I am hoping that right now we can keep discussion to the motion on the table, which is To adopt the amendment to the resolution to add an end date to Mr. Jordan's service with the city.

805
01:29:20.264 --> 01:29:23.494
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are the folks who are in the queue in the queue to discuss the amendment?

806
01:29:25.069 --> 01:29:25.262
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

807
01:29:25.425 --> 01:29:26.201
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

808
01:29:28.965 --> 01:29:39.655
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to speak to something that I think Councilor Zimmerman addressed, which is a technical question on whether— why this is, uh, in a whereas, uh, in terms of adding it in.

809
01:29:39.769 --> 01:29:42.448
<v Sameer Kanal>This seems like it should be something that's in a therefore be it resolved.

810
01:29:43.057 --> 01:29:45.655
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so it's a purely technical question on the amendment here.

811
01:29:46.345 --> 01:29:50.324
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I do support adding text to clarify the end date.

812
01:29:50.372 --> 01:29:55.796
<v Sameer Kanal>That is something that I appreciate, uh, Mayor Wheeler bringing up and, and Councilor Avalos, uh, proposing.

813
01:29:56.229 --> 01:29:56.533
<v Sameer Kanal>But I—.

814
01:29:56.533 --> 01:30:06.480
<v Sameer Kanal>My curiosity is about whether or not this could be something that would be added to the, um, I want to say the second, um, the second therefore be resolved.

815
01:30:06.529 --> 01:30:07.900
<v Sameer Kanal>So, all right, sorry, it's the only one.

816
01:30:08.143 --> 01:30:15.172
<v Sameer Kanal>Now therefore be resolved that the council hereby confirms Michael Jordan's appointment as city administrator until January 2nd, 2026.

817
01:30:15.479 --> 01:30:16.483
<v Sameer Kanal>That's, that's my question.

818
01:30:16.546 --> 01:30:18.649
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I'm curious what other folks think about that.

819
01:30:19.326 --> 01:30:33.689
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, so I believe that saying, um, confirms Michael Jordan's appointment as city administrator in accordance with the resolution would point back to the therefore with the end date, but I'll let the, um, attorney speak to whether we need to make a change there to have the same meaning.

820
01:30:34.380 --> 01:30:37.167
<v Sameer Kanal>If the attorneys were to confirm that, that would address my concern.

821
01:30:38.193 --> 01:30:38.721
<v Margaret Butler>It would.

822
01:30:39.074 --> 01:30:40.051
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, the, the—.

823
01:30:40.212 --> 01:30:44.106
<v Nancy Thorington>In this resolution points back to the whereas, so it would be incorporated.

824
01:30:44.458 --> 01:30:51.092
<v Sameer Kanal>And just to, to clarify, that means that should there be a desire for further extension, it would need to come back to council?

825
01:30:51.350 --> 01:30:51.637
<v Ana Maria Perez>Agreed.

826
01:30:52.150 --> 01:30:52.342
<v Glen Devitt>Thank you.

827
01:30:53.627 --> 01:30:55.457
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor, for putting that on the record.

828
01:30:55.572 --> 01:30:57.953
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, are your comments about the amendment?

829
01:30:58.472 --> 01:30:59.073
<v Lynn Handlen>Yes, ma'am.

830
01:30:59.283 --> 01:31:00.141
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

831
01:31:00.699 --> 01:31:05.891
<v Loretta Smith>Should we also include what the proposed salary will be in that amendment as well?

832
01:31:12.748 --> 01:31:12.782
<v Carrie Ko>I—.

833
01:31:13.365 --> 01:31:23.978
<v Nancy Thorington>If you would like to make an additional amendment, I don't believe that that's you can't add it to what you're talking about right now?

834
01:31:25.430 --> 01:31:29.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have an amendment proposed and seconded with language about the end date.

835
01:31:30.524 --> 01:31:35.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We could vote that up or down and then consider a separate amendment to add salary information.

836
01:31:36.158 --> 01:31:40.023
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, because I didn't see that anywhere in the original amendment.

837
01:31:42.654 --> 01:31:53.890
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe in the staff recommendation, supporting documents we received, the salary scale was included, which is tied through our HR systems to the position itself.

838
01:31:53.954 --> 01:32:00.289
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I don't think that the placement within the salary scale was included in any of the documentation we received.

839
01:32:00.449 --> 01:32:11.664
<v Loretta Smith>Well, it would be important to know what that salary is going to be because that is also going to be something people are going to use to make their I, I'm looking.

840
01:32:11.712 --> 01:32:13.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's in the impact statement.

841
01:32:13.626 --> 01:32:15.538
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The specific salary is not, but the salary range is.

842
01:32:15.587 --> 01:32:22.167
<v Loretta Smith>Not the range, but we should know what the mayor is planning to offer Mr. Jordan if he's approved.

843
01:32:24.244 --> 01:32:38.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's hold that, if you don't mind, Councilor, until after we vote on this amendment, and then we can discuss whether we'd like the mayor to just tell us his intention or whether we would like to discuss a separate amendment okay, thank you.

844
01:32:38.546 --> 01:32:38.902
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

845
01:32:39.792 --> 01:32:41.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, are your comments to the amendment?

846
01:32:42.561 --> 01:32:42.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

847
01:32:42.868 --> 01:32:43.646
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman?

848
01:32:44.472 --> 01:32:46.335
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, do you have comments to the amendment?

849
01:32:48.012 --> 01:32:51.538
<v Mitch Green>Yes, uh, I want to thank Councilor Avalos for proposing this amendment.

850
01:32:51.942 --> 01:33:04.514
<v Mitch Green>Um, shows responsiveness, I think, to some concerns we have about the big public trust issues at play here, as well as comments that I've received about fiscal stewardship and the need to be careful with And not being in alignment with the GCAC.

851
01:33:05.432 --> 01:33:11.621
<v Mitch Green>So with that in mind, I do support the amendment to add in a clause that puts a sunset date to this confirmation.

852
01:33:16.060 --> 01:33:26.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing no additional comments, no additional hands, Keelan, could you call the roll on the amendment?

853
01:33:26.730 --> 01:33:31.880
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And can you remind folks what the amendment is as you call roll, please.

854
01:33:32.170 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>This is a vote on the amendment to add an end date to the one of the whereas statements.

855
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

856
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

857
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

858
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

859
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Nohlik.

860
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

861
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

862
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

863
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

864
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

865
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

866
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

867
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

868
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

869
01:33:38.029 --> 01:33:38.050
<v Karen Chire>Aye.

870
01:33:38.050 --> 01:33:38.069
<v Nancy Thorington>Aye.

871
01:33:38.069 --> 01:33:38.069
<v Nancy Thorington>Aye.

872
01:33:38.069 --> 01:33:38.069
<v Nancy Thorington>Aye.

873
01:33:38.069 --> 01:33:38.069
<v Nancy Thorington>Aye.

874
01:33:38.069 --> 01:33:38.069
<v Nancy Thorington>Please state your name and address.

875
01:33:38.069 --> 01:33:38.069
<v Nancy Thorington>I have 3 amendments.

876
01:33:38.069 --> 01:33:38.090
<v Carl Close>Okay, can you tell us what the amendment is as you call roll, please?

877
01:33:38.090 --> 01:33:38.550
<v Edith Gillis>This is a vote on the amendment to add an end date to the one of the whereas statements.

878
01:33:38.550 --> 01:33:40.409
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

879
01:33:40.409 --> 01:33:41.449
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

880
01:33:41.449 --> 01:33:42.170
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

881
01:33:42.170 --> 01:33:42.489
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

882
01:33:42.489 --> 01:33:43.350
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Smith?

883
01:33:43.350 --> 01:33:43.770
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

884
01:33:43.770 --> 01:33:44.029
<v Glen Devitt>Mahl?

885
01:33:44.029 --> 01:33:45.090
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

886
01:33:45.090 --> 01:33:45.630
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

887
01:33:45.630 --> 01:33:46.189
<v Edith Gillis>Aye.

888
01:33:46.189 --> 01:33:46.250
<v Keith Wilson>Aye.

889
01:33:46.250 --> 01:33:47.510
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

890
01:33:47.510 --> 01:33:50.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dunphy?

891
01:33:54.466 --> 01:33:54.515
<v Edith Gillis>Aye.

892
01:33:55.030 --> 01:33:56.965
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with a vote of 12.

893
01:33:58.673 --> 01:34:05.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, we are now moving into discussion on the, uh, resolution itself.

894
01:34:06.020 --> 01:34:14.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a question about salary, and I know that folks have questions for the city administrator that they'd like to ask.

895
01:34:16.435 --> 01:34:28.804
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, are you comfortable coming forward to discuss salary question that was raised, and after that, I believe we, um, City Administrator Jordan will invite you up in case councilors have questions for you directly.

896
01:34:30.190 --> 01:34:32.313
<v Keith Wilson>Yes, thank you, Councilor.

897
01:34:32.411 --> 01:34:33.113
<v Keith Wilson>I appreciate that.

898
01:34:35.033 --> 01:34:35.177
<v Keith Wilson>The—.

899
01:34:35.338 --> 01:34:37.465
<v Keith Wilson>Michael and I haven't had a discussion regarding wage.

900
01:34:37.529 --> 01:34:47.896
<v Keith Wilson>We wanted to go through the vote first as a, uh, course of process, but I think it would be reasonable to expect a cost of living adjustment That would be fair and reasonable.

901
01:34:48.364 --> 01:34:54.527
<v Keith Wilson>We can certainly use our recent union discussions and that increase that we had.

902
01:34:54.623 --> 01:35:00.429
<v Keith Wilson>I think that that would be reasonable, and I think that's a great spot, and I'm, I'm confident Michael and I would come to an agreement on that.

903
01:35:00.751 --> 01:35:05.216
<v Keith Wilson>I don't see anything extraordinarily above what his current wage is.

904
01:35:08.680 --> 01:35:15.353
<v Loretta Smith>Mayor, I'm not sure what his salary is right now.

905
01:35:15.967 --> 01:35:19.176
<v Loretta Smith>Could you, for the record, tell us what that is?

906
01:35:19.810 --> 01:35:21.608
<v Loretta Smith>And you keep telling me about a COLA.

907
01:35:21.689 --> 01:35:24.250
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know a COLA from, from what point.

908
01:35:31.323 --> 01:35:34.115
<v Keith Wilson>I believe his salary, you know, and, uh, I just—.

909
01:35:34.487 --> 01:35:36.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, I believe HR is in the room.

910
01:35:36.634 --> 01:35:44.359
<v Keith Wilson>I'm not sure how far down From a privacy standpoint, I'd prefer to have them follow, or I'll follow that lead.

911
01:35:46.810 --> 01:36:03.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while, while our colleague from HR is getting set up here, Councilor Smith, I will just draw your attention to the financial and budgetary impact section of our impact statement, which says that the salary range is currently $277,000 to $380,000.

912
01:36:04.817 --> 01:36:15.453
<v Loretta Smith>That's, that's very important because we're in a $100 million deficit, and I want to know specifically what he's going to be making and what the mayor plans to offer him.

913
01:36:21.131 --> 01:36:25.451
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could you introduce yourself for the record, and then we'll let you get set up there?

914
01:36:26.402 --> 01:36:26.837
<v Loretta Smith>Certainly.

915
01:36:26.934 --> 01:36:27.948
<v Loretta Smith>Good morning, everyone.

916
01:36:28.061 --> 01:36:29.384
<v Loretta Smith>My name is Risa Williams.

917
01:36:29.431 --> 01:36:32.389
<v Loretta Smith>I'm the class Comp and pay equity manager at the city.

918
01:36:36.962 --> 01:36:46.525
<v Loretta Smith>If you allow me just a moment, I will confirm Mr. Jordan's current salary.

919
01:37:03.222 --> 01:37:04.737
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you all for your patience.

920
01:37:06.088 --> 01:37:08.988
<v Loretta Smith>Current annual salary is $290,700.80.

921
01:37:13.841 --> 01:37:15.802
<v Loretta Smith>That falls within the established—.

922
01:37:15.931 --> 01:37:20.875
<v Loretta Smith>The current established compensation range for the city administrator classification.

923
01:37:23.474 --> 01:37:24.613
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

924
01:37:24.759 --> 01:37:25.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do you have a follow-up question?

925
01:37:25.819 --> 01:37:26.011
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

926
01:37:26.140 --> 01:37:29.832
<v Loretta Smith>So, Mr. Mayor, what you're saying is you plan to offer him a COLA.

927
01:37:29.912 --> 01:37:34.810
<v Loretta Smith>You don't know what percentage of a COLA you're going to offer him or if you're going to increase his salary in general?

928
01:37:35.854 --> 01:37:46.435
<v Keith Wilson>I would expect an increase in general, yes, but it would be reasonable and within existing COLA and/or union-type, uh, ranges that we just went through as a council.

929
01:37:46.612 --> 01:37:56.820
<v Keith Wilson>And as a mayor, I think that that would be reasonable, that our staff level increases should be commensurate with our senior leadership increase as well.

930
01:37:57.158 --> 01:38:03.262
<v Keith Wilson>I don't expect any more than that, and it would certainly be within reason and reasonable.

931
01:38:03.344 --> 01:38:03.664
<v Lynn Handlen>I don't see—.

932
01:38:03.664 --> 01:38:04.805
<v Loretta Smith>But you don't have an idea.

933
01:38:04.869 --> 01:38:11.434
<v Loretta Smith>You bring this forward and you have no idea of what you're going to offer him above and beyond this $297,000.

934
01:38:12.365 --> 01:38:24.702
<v Loretta Smith>I can't imagine as a, as the, you know, the leader of this organization that you wouldn't have in your mind what you're going to offer him for this position before it is approved.

935
01:38:25.938 --> 01:38:32.177
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor, I just noted it will be a reasonable increase that'll be based on a cost of living adjustment.

936
01:38:32.449 --> 01:38:36.829
<v Keith Wilson>I don't see an extraordinary increase if that's what you're anticipating, but I would—.

937
01:38:36.829 --> 01:38:50.443
<v Loretta Smith>No, I just want to know what you're going to offer him because We can't have any— see, if we leave here and don't, and, and don't know what you're going to offer, we have no way of coming back and saying what that's going to be.

938
01:38:51.074 --> 01:38:53.194
<v Keith Wilson>May I explain to them?

939
01:38:57.502 --> 01:39:02.463
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While the mayor is deliberating, um, Mr. Taylor, I know that you are our next agenda item.

940
01:39:02.658 --> 01:39:06.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just might suggest to you that we may take a little bit to get to you.

941
01:39:06.292 --> 01:39:11.336
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to make sure that, um, you know that, that it'll be a bit of time here.

942
01:39:11.384 --> 01:39:13.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have other councilors with questions as well.

943
01:39:14.997 --> 01:39:22.932
<v Sameer Kanal>It might be worth noting that we might need, uh, Attorney Taylor for questions related to this as well at some point.

944
01:39:23.335 --> 01:39:28.362
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do have an, um, an attorney from our attorney's office here with us today for the meeting.

945
01:39:35.521 --> 01:39:49.641
<v Loretta Smith>And Madam President, the reason why I'm— I am really going 10 toes down on this is because we are asked to budget to the penny and know what we're doing.

946
01:39:50.239 --> 01:40:05.886
<v Loretta Smith>But in a situation like this that we just give our executive and the mayor free rein without knowing, and then once we do find out and it's not accepted— acceptable to us, we don't have a way of changing it.

947
01:40:06.432 --> 01:40:06.994
<v Olivia Clark>Understood.

948
01:40:07.252 --> 01:40:12.550
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe the mayor may have a response for us, and depending on that response, I may have a suggestion.

949
01:40:12.854 --> 01:40:29.934
<v Keith Wilson>Let me use the word estimate here just to make sure that we're complying with the laws and such, but if we were at a cost of living at or around 3%, and then through union adjustments that we've just gone through at about a 4%, I would assume an estimate of about a 7%, Councilor.

950
01:40:32.764 --> 01:40:34.300
<v Keith Wilson>And it's within the range.

951
01:40:34.381 --> 01:40:36.742
<v Keith Wilson>It's clearly at the low end of the range.

952
01:40:37.211 --> 01:40:40.585
<v Keith Wilson>Um, I would expect that to be a reasonable amount.

953
01:40:41.811 --> 01:40:44.345
<v Loretta Smith>I try not to do math in public, but what is 7%?

954
01:40:44.393 --> 01:40:47.935
<v Loretta Smith>What does that— what does that move the $297,000 up to?

955
01:40:48.356 --> 01:40:53.398
<v Keith Wilson>Just the 7% on about $290,000 is you're looking at about $20,000 increase.

956
01:40:53.493 --> 01:40:54.167
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you.

957
01:40:54.296 --> 01:40:56.573
<v Loretta Smith>I, and I do this because people are watching on TV.

958
01:40:56.701 --> 01:40:58.689
<v Loretta Smith>You say 7%, they don't know what that is.

959
01:40:58.962 --> 01:40:59.507
<v Loretta Smith>No problem.

960
01:40:59.604 --> 01:41:15.577
<v Loretta Smith>I, I know how to calculate it on my computer, but I just wanted to let you know these are the things that I've, I've heard today about transparency, and there is so little trust in us right now in regards to transparency, and we need to change that trajectory.

961
01:41:15.640 --> 01:41:26.537
<v Loretta Smith>So As clear, you know, we need to be as clear as we can about the dollars and cents, what's real and what's imagined, and what is, is actually going to be adopted going forward.

962
01:41:27.323 --> 01:41:29.759
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I, I get it and I understand it.

963
01:41:29.823 --> 01:41:31.426
<v Loretta Smith>That is, that is the going rate.

964
01:41:31.729 --> 01:41:33.556
<v Loretta Smith>I just wanted to know what it was.

965
01:41:33.989 --> 01:41:42.837
<v Keith Wilson>Yeah, and forgive me, you know, I want to be and I want to provide candor, but also in employer-employee relationships, these discussions are customarily behind closed doors.

966
01:41:42.886 --> 01:41:45.054
<v Keith Wilson>So I, I respect your question.

967
01:41:45.279 --> 01:41:45.551
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

968
01:41:45.615 --> 01:41:58.237
<v Loretta Smith>And normally, if it was not a public need to— for us to approve it, that is the transparency that you get when you have to have our vote to go forward.

969
01:41:58.765 --> 01:42:06.939
<v Loretta Smith>And as you know, if we wanted to terminate that contract, we would not need your vote, that this council could terminate it without your blessing.

970
01:42:07.213 --> 01:42:07.327
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

971
01:42:07.457 --> 01:42:15.688
<v Loretta Smith>So I think, you know, this is not a normal employer-employee relationship.

972
01:42:16.492 --> 01:42:17.847
<v Loretta Smith>It is a public relationship.

973
01:42:18.349 --> 01:42:22.787
<v Loretta Smith>And I think we all need to understand what's at stake, what's on the table.

974
01:42:22.851 --> 01:42:25.581
<v Loretta Smith>We are the people who have the power of the purse.

975
01:42:27.167 --> 01:42:30.341
<v Loretta Smith>And so I'm trying to figure out about this $100 million deficit.

976
01:42:31.862 --> 01:42:34.184
<v Loretta Smith>I know this is small monies, but everything adds up.

977
01:42:34.930 --> 01:42:47.418
<v Loretta Smith>And I had a couple questions for, for Michael Jordan after we move off of this, but I have some questions that I'm concerned about that I need answered before I take my vote.

978
01:42:47.984 --> 01:42:48.291
<v Loretta Smith>Certainly.

979
01:42:48.710 --> 01:42:49.001
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

980
01:42:49.355 --> 01:42:49.904
<v Keith Wilson>You're welcome.

981
01:42:50.212 --> 01:42:51.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

982
01:42:51.713 --> 01:42:55.234
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for jumping up here to help us with those questions.

983
01:42:55.346 --> 01:42:55.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You're welcome.

984
01:42:55.880 --> 01:42:56.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

985
01:42:57.853 --> 01:43:05.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At this time, I would like to invite Councilors, I know that everybody has a lot of questions.

986
01:43:06.036 --> 01:43:22.840
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My request to you all is that if you can ask your most pressing question first so we can make sure that we hear questions from everybody, and then if you have a follow-up to that, go ahead, but let's try to keep it to one question per councilor first.

987
01:43:23.610 --> 01:43:26.904
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Once everyone has had an opportunity to ask a question, we can loop back around and get to the follow-up.

988
01:43:26.952 --> 01:43:27.145
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

989
01:43:29.707 --> 01:43:34.543
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll go in order of hands in the queue.

990
01:43:34.608 --> 01:43:37.235
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, go right ahead.

991
01:43:38.130 --> 01:43:41.143
<v Dan Ryan>I got bumped up since I wasn't involved with the amendments.

992
01:43:41.240 --> 01:43:41.484
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

993
01:43:42.153 --> 01:43:43.082
<v Dan Ryan>Hello, Michael Jordan.

994
01:43:43.569 --> 01:43:45.864
<v Dan Ryan>You, um, you are a legendary public servant.

995
01:43:46.511 --> 01:43:53.204
<v Dan Ryan>You have more knowledge about how state and local government works than anyone I can think of, and you are highly respected for your work.

996
01:43:53.279 --> 01:43:54.724
<v Dan Ryan>From your peers across government.

997
01:43:54.917 --> 01:43:58.304
<v Dan Ryan>And we saw that earlier with the testimony from the county chair.

998
01:43:58.994 --> 01:44:04.404
<v Dan Ryan>As such, at a time of transition, you are a good fit for 2025.

999
01:44:04.453 --> 01:44:08.515
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm not surprised that Mayor Wilson asked you to extend your service for the entire year.

1000
01:44:09.445 --> 01:44:12.849
<v Dan Ryan>And I want to thank your life partner, your wife, for agreeing to this.

1001
01:44:13.925 --> 01:44:18.034
<v Dan Ryan>We had a conversation last week, so I felt like I wanted to put that on the record.

1002
01:44:18.596 --> 01:44:20.314
<v Dan Ryan>By the end of this year, Mayor Wilson Councilor Smith.

1003
01:44:20.362 --> 01:44:20.715
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

1004
01:44:20.762 --> 01:44:31.969
<v Dan Ryan>With the approval of this body, we'll make our first big appointment of our new city administrator, and it gives us some time to conduct a much-needed national search for an innovative change agent leader.

1005
01:44:33.011 --> 01:44:38.590
<v Dan Ryan>That said, we don't have time for a maintenance leader of our one-city organization.

1006
01:44:39.359 --> 01:45:08.181
<v Dan Ryan>As we discussed in our dialogue prior to this public meeting, are you willing to do extremely uncomfortable things, make difficult decisions to focus on the movement from the bureau silos that block the creative flow we all seek with any team, and what highly taxed Portlanders deserve, to, to the urgent task at hand to integrate, integrate into the work areas we can experience, in your words, one city.

1007
01:45:08.935 --> 01:45:10.154
<v Dan Ryan>Let me just say it another way.

1008
01:45:10.859 --> 01:45:20.329
<v Dan Ryan>In just over 6 months, we will officially brought entire bureaus— this was just 6 months ago, you know this— under one DCA-led work area.

1009
01:45:21.117 --> 01:45:26.993
<v Dan Ryan>And in my opinion, now we have some pretty obvious clutter, duplication of roles at the top and in middle management.

1010
01:45:27.490 --> 01:45:37.493
<v Dan Ryan>The budget season does give us the luxury— doesn't give us the luxury of waiting for the mayor's and our first appointment of a city manager in 2026.

1011
01:45:38.056 --> 01:45:40.563
<v Dan Ryan>We need to do difficult surgery today.

1012
01:45:41.109 --> 01:45:58.659
<v Dan Ryan>Are you willing to end your celebrated, for all the right reasons, career with a tough year of doing the efficiency of merging all the bureaus into work areas and provide us with the cost savings plan that will also deliver services with greater efficiency and accountability for Portlanders?

1013
01:46:01.301 --> 01:46:01.961
<v Michael Jordan>Where was the question?

1014
01:46:05.061 --> 01:46:08.689
<v Michael Jordan>Well, it's hard to imagine a decision more uncomfortable than today.

1015
01:46:09.429 --> 01:46:24.394
<v Michael Jordan>So I'll just say I'm prepared to do a number of difficult things and recommend things to the mayor regarding organizational structure and regarding cost savings that are necessary.

1016
01:46:25.309 --> 01:46:27.797
<v Michael Jordan>The number's been thrown around here much today.

1017
01:46:28.905 --> 01:46:40.208
<v Michael Jordan>And this is as severe a budget challenge as I've seen in 40 years, and it is going to require extraordinary change.

1018
01:46:41.590 --> 01:46:48.863
<v Michael Jordan>And I think your comments about trying to move us more towards one integrated city are apt here.

1019
01:46:50.341 --> 01:47:03.667
<v Michael Jordan>And you'll recall, Councilor, that the decision that was made back in November of '23 by then City Council to adopt an organizational framework was only the beginning of change.

1020
01:47:04.149 --> 01:47:25.849
<v Michael Jordan>It provided us the opportunity then to dig deeper into the organization and look either within service areas or across service areas where there are opportunities to remove duplication, create more streamlined business processes, and fortunately or unfortunately, I'm not going to make a judgment on that, but we will reduce our footprint.

1021
01:47:26.060 --> 01:47:35.011
<v Michael Jordan>There's just no question that we will have to be a more efficient, more streamlined, and quite frankly smaller organization than we are today.

1022
01:47:35.574 --> 01:47:36.588
<v Michael Jordan>I don't think we have a choice.

1023
01:47:41.570 --> 01:47:44.083
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1024
01:47:45.212 --> 01:48:02.293
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know for most employees who've ever worked anywhere, having your salary discussed in public is It's awkward and uncomfortable, but I will also say it is the normal course of business across America that the salary of the city manager, the city administrator, is part of and known to the dollar when we adopt these contracts.

1025
01:48:02.358 --> 01:48:04.259
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that'll be my expectation moving forward.

1026
01:48:04.306 --> 01:48:09.605
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I appreciate us getting through that moment of awkwardness, and it is just the nature of the job.

1027
01:48:13.524 --> 01:48:14.787
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, so appreciate the amendment.

1028
01:48:14.900 --> 01:48:15.516
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's important.

1029
01:48:15.581 --> 01:48:15.694
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1030
01:48:15.971 --> 01:48:39.359
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, 12/31 or January 2nd of '26 is, is, I think, an important sunset date so that we can engage in a search firm, so that we can attract what I think is a national search to allow us to have the engagement of this council, members of the public, the mayor, to find that next city administrator.

1031
01:48:39.583 --> 01:48:39.953
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so—.

1032
01:48:40.306 --> 01:48:40.837
<v Eric Zimmerman>The mayor.

1033
01:48:41.511 --> 01:48:41.961
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Herbold.

1034
01:48:42.185 --> 01:48:43.788
<v Eric Zimmerman>Very much agree with the direction there.

1035
01:48:45.104 --> 01:48:58.064
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I'm going to convey a little bit in terms of our conversation when we met privately with the District 4 team is I asked Mike to take some massive restructuring over the remaining months of this year, right?

1036
01:48:58.336 --> 01:49:14.966
<v Eric Zimmerman>And insofar as I think it would be— it would hurt our retraction of new candidates to this position in the year forward if they know that they've got to come in and make massive restructuring Those are the types of moves that city managers and city administrators actually don't survive in the long term.

1037
01:49:15.030 --> 01:49:19.439
<v Eric Zimmerman>They have to make them, and then they usually have to exit that organization within short order.

1038
01:49:20.161 --> 01:49:33.805
<v Eric Zimmerman>And what I'm asking you, Mike, and you know this, is I want that to happen in this calendar year so that our next candidate can stay here for a number of years, and so that the mayor, this council, has somebody who is not having to do the most uncomfortable work that is in the career.

1039
01:49:33.965 --> 01:49:36.322
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I hope you'll take that seriously.

1040
01:49:36.515 --> 01:49:37.685
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know it's going to be uncomfortable.

1041
01:49:37.748 --> 01:49:39.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll support those restructure changes.

1042
01:49:39.657 --> 01:49:39.849
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1043
01:49:40.381 --> 01:49:41.694
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, to reduce the footprint.

1044
01:49:42.733 --> 01:49:47.548
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I also, for my colleagues, I know there's some— some— there's a big choice for us.

1045
01:49:47.613 --> 01:49:48.488
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's also new for Portland.

1046
01:49:48.971 --> 01:49:59.412
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to send one signal out for us, and I hope we recognize that it sends a signal out to the candidate pool as we go to look for our next city administrator.

1047
01:50:00.204 --> 01:50:05.234
<v Eric Zimmerman>There is at times a mindset about, do you go to a city who is split on your city manager?

1048
01:50:05.300 --> 01:50:05.349
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

1049
01:50:05.796 --> 01:50:05.908
<v Eric Zimmerman>Right.

1050
01:50:06.054 --> 01:50:10.355
<v Eric Zimmerman>That, that is part of the industry, and that can be a challenging thing.

1051
01:50:10.613 --> 01:50:24.774
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I would say is all of the issues, concerns, they're incredibly valid issues and concerns, but our appointment today, I hope, is a 12-0 vote because that will set up—.

1052
01:50:24.981 --> 01:50:25.127
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it—.

1053
01:50:25.255 --> 01:50:39.385
<v Eric Zimmerman>This meeting will be the next meeting that candidates who consider to put their name in the hat in the future across this country are going to look at this meeting and how we engage with our city administrator, with our mayor, because it signals to them the relationship that we'll have moving forward.

1054
01:50:40.510 --> 01:50:59.640
<v Eric Zimmerman>And people will make a choice whether or not to come to Portland to apply to serve us based on whether or not they think they have a council who they can work through difficulty with, or if it's always going to be a struggle to have that support where you think that maybe the job is in jeopardy every single day.

1055
01:50:59.688 --> 01:50:59.784
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1056
01:51:00.313 --> 01:51:14.954
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I think that the expiration date on January 2nd allows us to get through this budget year, get through a search throughout the summer, and gives a lot of folks cover to take a 12-0 vote today.

1057
01:51:15.228 --> 01:51:16.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that's an important signal.

1058
01:51:16.930 --> 01:51:23.720
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I recognize everybody will, will have their own opinions, but I want us to think about our reputation that we're setting as we engage in a future search.

1059
01:51:23.833 --> 01:51:25.118
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you for stepping up.

1060
01:51:25.213 --> 01:51:25.872
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll be supportive.

1061
01:51:25.921 --> 01:51:26.064
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1062
01:51:31.500 --> 01:51:36.640
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, I'd like to give councilors who've not yet had a chance to ask a question an opportunity first.

1063
01:51:37.329 --> 01:51:38.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do you mind if we come back to you?

1064
01:51:39.569 --> 01:51:39.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1065
01:51:39.789 --> 01:51:44.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green.

1066
01:51:44.189 --> 01:51:45.949
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam President.

1067
01:51:47.119 --> 01:51:50.109
<v Mitch Green>I'll just start by saying, you know, thanks for being here today.

1068
01:51:50.109 --> 01:51:50.250
<v Karen Chire>I'm a big supporter of the ordinance.

1069
01:51:51.997 --> 01:51:55.546
<v Mitch Green>You know, you've heard from a lot of people in the building about the land use compatibility statements.

1070
01:51:55.627 --> 01:51:56.752
<v Mitch Green>I won't belabor that point.

1071
01:51:56.832 --> 01:51:58.085
<v Mitch Green>I think they made it better than I did.

1072
01:51:58.823 --> 01:52:06.807
<v Mitch Green>I'll just say that, you know, I was disappointed that went forward when there was a pending and outstanding resolution to take up substantive issues with that.

1073
01:52:06.889 --> 01:52:18.809
<v Mitch Green>So I'll leave that there, and I'll just remind folks that it's the power of City Council to address big, uncomfortable policy issues and engage in oversight, and that's what I will be doing in the next few weeks.

1074
01:52:18.872 --> 01:52:18.969
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1075
01:52:20.186 --> 01:52:21.309
<v Mitch Green>But I do have a question for you.

1076
01:52:21.966 --> 01:52:27.975
<v Mitch Green>I received an email from a person who I admire and respect, Bob Weinstein, who's a resident in my district.

1077
01:52:28.760 --> 01:52:44.881
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, he's got issues with the top-heavy nature of our organizational structure, and you're aware of this, as well as the 6 DCAs, the number, and also the sort of level of compensation and the severance packages.

1078
01:52:44.944 --> 01:52:56.698
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm wondering what you can say here between now and then and setting us up for the next city administrator that can give someone like Bob some assurances that we're going to take that kind of fiscal stewardship seriously.

1079
01:52:56.873 --> 01:52:57.226
<v Carl Close>Thanks.

1080
01:52:58.110 --> 01:53:04.275
<v Michael Jordan>Well, I appreciate the question, and I've heard the comment multiple times from multiple sources.

1081
01:53:04.935 --> 01:53:18.823
<v Michael Jordan>And to the question that Councilor Ryan asked about tough choices, the illusion that Councilor Zimmerman mentioned about this year and how challenging it will be, and we should take on those challenges.

1082
01:53:18.920 --> 01:53:23.625
<v Michael Jordan>I think one of those challenges is the structure of the organization.

1083
01:53:23.881 --> 01:53:42.533
<v Michael Jordan>We did the best we could over about a year prior to November of 23, interacting with multiple cities across the country, interacting with the International City Managers Association and the National National League of Cities to try and construct a framework for the council to consider back in November of '23.

1084
01:53:43.640 --> 01:53:44.298
<v Michael Jordan>Is it perfect?

1085
01:53:44.426 --> 01:53:45.246
<v Michael Jordan>Absolutely not.

1086
01:53:45.502 --> 01:53:48.213
<v Michael Jordan>Is it absolutely the right structure for Portland?

1087
01:53:48.774 --> 01:53:49.658
<v Michael Jordan>Probably not.

1088
01:53:50.524 --> 01:53:56.716
<v Michael Jordan>And there was every expectation that we would continue to evolve that structure going forward.

1089
01:53:57.262 --> 01:53:59.140
<v Michael Jordan>And I expect that we will do that this year.

1090
01:53:59.347 --> 01:54:01.337
<v Michael Jordan>And to previous comment about—.

1091
01:54:01.337 --> 01:54:01.899
<v Michael Jordan>Councilmember Herbold.

1092
01:54:02.427 --> 01:54:03.983
<v Michael Jordan>Our current fiscal situation.

1093
01:54:04.336 --> 01:54:14.051
<v Michael Jordan>We should take into, into account both whether management is top-heavy or whether we have duplication of management deeper in the organization.

1094
01:54:14.179 --> 01:54:15.605
<v Michael Jordan>We should be looking at those things.

1095
01:54:15.878 --> 01:54:16.728
<v Michael Jordan>There's no question.

1096
01:54:17.546 --> 01:54:25.353
<v Michael Jordan>I will say, however, it, it isn't just throwing darts at a whiteboard that gets you these kinds of structures.

1097
01:54:25.417 --> 01:54:31.838
<v Michael Jordan>There are things to think about, about risk to the city, spans of control, and levels of management.

1098
01:54:32.305 --> 01:54:34.024
<v Michael Jordan>Those things aren't just made up.

1099
01:54:34.650 --> 01:54:40.788
<v Michael Jordan>We do them because there are certain parts of our organization where the activity is of higher risk.

1100
01:54:41.402 --> 01:55:02.439
<v Michael Jordan>And going to the question about our future city administrator that we'll hire this coming year, not only will they look at maybe the recording of this meeting, but they'll also They'll also go to the org chart and they'll say, can I feel comfortable being held accountable for this big organization with that current structure?

1101
01:55:03.224 --> 01:55:04.795
<v Michael Jordan>And they'll look at that before they apply.

1102
01:55:05.564 --> 01:55:12.121
<v Michael Jordan>And they'll want to know, have I got a team of leaders that can run the organization for me?

1103
01:55:12.201 --> 01:55:15.037
<v Michael Jordan>Because you can't keep your eye on 7,300 people.

1104
01:55:15.407 --> 01:55:16.577
<v Michael Jordan>There's no way to do it.

1105
01:55:17.490 --> 01:55:22.507
<v Michael Jordan>And so the development of those spans of control and levels of management are really important.

1106
01:55:22.878 --> 01:55:30.521
<v Michael Jordan>Happy to work with both the committees of this council as we move forward through this year, but we will be proposing changes.

1107
01:55:30.605 --> 01:55:31.533
<v Michael Jordan>There's just no question.

1108
01:55:33.631 --> 01:55:35.279
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for that answer.

1109
01:55:36.440 --> 01:55:47.632
<v Mitch Green>My next question is, in the last budget, there was a budget memo that sort of called for an independent investigation of sort of a consultant's view of restructuring and how to be efficient.

1110
01:55:49.126 --> 01:55:55.579
<v Mitch Green>Do you intend to put dollars into the next budget, Mayor, to sort of front-load that early in the fiscal year?

1111
01:55:56.414 --> 01:55:56.608
<v Diane Meisenhelter>We—.

1112
01:55:56.608 --> 01:55:58.326
<v Michael Jordan>Oh, I'm sorry, go ahead.

1113
01:55:59.000 --> 01:56:07.510
<v Michael Jordan>We did, just for information's sake, Councilor, we did prepare a scope of work for that independent third party.

1114
01:56:07.606 --> 01:56:08.489
<v Michael Jordan>It's prepared.

1115
01:56:09.516 --> 01:56:19.680
<v Michael Jordan>I think working collaboratively with the mayor and with your committees, perhaps the Governance Committee would be the appropriate place, but I'll leave that to the, to the Council President.

1116
01:56:19.953 --> 01:56:24.256
<v Michael Jordan>But working together, I think we can decide how we want to move forward on that study.

1117
01:56:25.478 --> 01:56:35.385
<v Michael Jordan>You know that the scope definition can define how many commas and zeros we might have to put with that analysis, but would love to work together to move that forward.

1118
01:56:35.448 --> 01:56:38.033
<v Michael Jordan>But we're prepared with a scope of work for that budget now.

1119
01:56:38.659 --> 01:56:38.965
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1120
01:56:39.029 --> 01:56:39.659
<v Mitch Green>Look forward to that.

1121
01:56:39.789 --> 01:56:49.858
<v Mitch Green>And then, uh, last comment I'll make, because I just have to say it, uh, I think the— I think the comparison to what the union got and the compensation is inappropriate because that's the result of collective bargaining with the union.

1122
01:56:50.597 --> 01:56:52.641
<v Mitch Green>Uh, and I'll just leave it at that.

1123
01:56:53.172 --> 01:56:54.797
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1124
01:56:57.220 --> 01:57:01.068
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, kind of feel like I want to take a deep breath first.

1125
01:57:05.798 --> 01:57:07.274
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>A few different things.

1126
01:57:07.804 --> 01:57:11.011
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>First, I would like to acknowledge community members.

1127
01:57:11.076 --> 01:57:15.358
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know not all of them are still here that showed up today, took time out of their day.

1128
01:57:15.662 --> 01:57:17.282
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So important that you're here.

1129
01:57:18.195 --> 01:57:26.488
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, it's important information for all of us, and I know that you all are representing just a fraction of the community members that care a lot about this issue.

1130
01:57:27.274 --> 01:57:39.079
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to say that I hear really clearly The feelings of concern, frustration, anger, those are very justified.

1131
01:57:39.930 --> 01:57:46.493
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, the concerns about oil trains rolling through our community, it's very concerning.

1132
01:57:47.631 --> 01:57:51.337
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I want to say keep advocating, keep organizing, keep showing up.

1133
01:57:51.802 --> 01:57:54.322
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Also, just like, this is educating too.

1134
01:57:54.690 --> 01:57:56.536
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I remember talking about Zenith Thank you.

1135
01:57:56.600 --> 01:58:00.930
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was just talking about this with some teachers about a year ago at Sunnyside Environmental School, and they didn't even know about it.

1136
01:58:01.108 --> 01:58:07.048
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It is like becoming more and more common that like everyday folks are hearing about this.

1137
01:58:10.009 --> 01:58:13.731
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I, um, share a lot of these feelings.

1138
01:58:14.952 --> 01:58:20.578
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I feel like we all kind of wish we weren't put in this place right now.

1139
01:58:20.980 --> 01:58:23.987
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think you both maybe wish that you weren't put in this place right now.

1140
01:58:24.951 --> 01:58:26.387
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm just taking a, taking a guess here.

1141
01:58:28.831 --> 01:58:35.081
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I, I look out and I see, um, I saw like a student with a Sunnyside Environmental School sweatshirt.

1142
01:58:35.242 --> 01:58:37.621
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Like, I know, like, my constituents care a lot about this.

1143
01:58:38.154 --> 01:58:42.719
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So this is something that, like, we have to talk about and we have to keep uplifting.

1144
01:58:43.420 --> 01:58:52.739
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'll say, hearing about the LUCS being signed last minute felt shocking and not good to a lot of folks, to me as well.

1145
01:58:53.091 --> 01:59:00.640
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I can also step back and see— I understand things get leaked, and there, there's a lot of us.

1146
01:59:00.720 --> 01:59:06.632
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so I do understand the concerns about being careful with when information comes to us.

1147
01:59:07.675 --> 01:59:17.230
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think it also puts us in a tricky spot because we're all getting emails that are also saying— I mean, one of the concerns is about timelines, due dates.

1148
01:59:18.018 --> 01:59:22.000
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, this isn't the only thing where it's been like, what is the timeline for this?

1149
01:59:22.047 --> 01:59:23.702
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then all of a sudden it just kind of happens.

1150
01:59:24.841 --> 01:59:28.935
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, maybe actually, does— do either of you want to speak to that?

1151
01:59:29.033 --> 01:59:31.618
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Like, did this have to be signed right now?

1152
01:59:33.110 --> 01:59:34.604
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's a genuine question.

1153
01:59:34.893 --> 01:59:37.912
<v Michael Jordan>Well, okay, that's great, and I appreciate you asking.

1154
01:59:38.104 --> 01:59:38.971
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you, Councilor.

1155
01:59:39.372 --> 02:00:02.341
<v Michael Jordan>Um, I will say that this is not going to be the last time that your city administrator has to do part of their job that I think is a pretty significant part of their job, and that is to assess and try to minimize the legal risk to the city.

1156
02:00:03.625 --> 02:00:14.564
<v Michael Jordan>And that legal risk isn't just a question about our image or how we want to act from a policy perspective.

1157
02:00:15.787 --> 02:00:20.795
<v Michael Jordan>It, in this case, could have significant commas and zeros behind it.

1158
02:00:22.757 --> 02:00:38.552
<v Michael Jordan>And our administrative responsibility to treat every applicant for one of these kinds of actions equally from a procedural perspective, to the degree we do not, we run a risk to the city.

1159
02:00:39.905 --> 02:00:52.605
<v Michael Jordan>And it's part of the administrator's job, working with the legal team and risk management and subject matter experts, depending on the question, to assess the risk to this city.

1160
02:00:53.989 --> 02:00:56.225
<v Michael Jordan>And that risk is usually measured in dollars.

1161
02:00:56.323 --> 02:00:56.676
<v Loretta Smith>I think that's a good point.

1162
02:00:57.719 --> 02:01:26.244
<v Michael Jordan>And so it was my view that regardless of the policy questions at, at, in play and the fact that the resolution that is being put forward has to do with our oversight of a franchise relationship and how that has been managed over the years is a legitimate question for us to look at.

1163
02:01:27.529 --> 02:01:42.372
<v Michael Jordan>It is, however, not necessarily associated with this administrative action that us taking a different approach to it than literally thousands of applicants over, over years puts the city at risk.

1164
02:01:42.869 --> 02:01:53.951
<v Michael Jordan>And so you asked the question, that's, that's at least my response to An unfortunate timing and, and set of issues, and it's really trying to assess risk.

1165
02:01:55.315 --> 02:02:13.573
<v Keith Wilson>And may I add as well, this came to me 60 days ago, and the question was, shall we administratively check this box and move it through before the January 1st assumption of power that the council and I took over?

1166
02:02:13.685 --> 02:02:19.287
<v Keith Wilson>And after consulting with multiple council members, we all thought that we have to daylight this.

1167
02:02:19.962 --> 02:02:28.277
<v Keith Wilson>And so we asked the previous administration to allow us to move it into this new year, in which we had the work session recently.

1168
02:02:29.112 --> 02:02:36.688
<v Keith Wilson>And I delayed, or wanted to delay, so I could gain as much knowledge as I could to make sure that there wasn't anything impractical.

1169
02:02:37.234 --> 02:02:40.347
<v Keith Wilson>Or as Mike said, it's an administrative function.

1170
02:02:40.429 --> 02:02:42.448
<v Keith Wilson>I wanted to know all of the parts and pieces.

1171
02:02:42.512 --> 02:02:48.601
<v Keith Wilson>And so I've been listening for this last 60 days, working and talking with all of you and community members where necessary and appropriate.

1172
02:02:49.306 --> 02:03:04.786
<v Keith Wilson>Um, and then this past week, I started working with senior executives from around the state— senior executives, not business, but political— to make sure that we had the legal protections, that we were moving forward in an appropriate manner.

1173
02:03:05.251 --> 02:03:19.519
<v Keith Wilson>And with my experience being 30 days in, all office, I wanted to make sure I was working with senior political individuals from around the state to just understand the process, to make sure that we weren't going to compromise the city legally, uh, throughout the process.

1174
02:03:19.631 --> 02:03:26.841
<v Keith Wilson>And then I did, uh, and I do agree with Councilors Murillo and Green's resolution for an investigation.

1175
02:03:27.002 --> 02:03:38.039
<v Keith Wilson>I think that that's where we really need to dig in and see and look at the franchise and see if there truly was And to find out how did we get here, because we don't want to get to this point again.

1176
02:03:38.712 --> 02:03:39.449
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, okay.

1177
02:03:39.627 --> 02:03:41.389
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm glad that you acknowledged that.

1178
02:03:41.436 --> 02:03:42.462
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That was one of my questions.

1179
02:03:42.960 --> 02:03:52.992
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And what I'm really hearing, I just want to uplift, is the hope for moving forward, especially around Zenith oversight, transparency, community engagement.

1180
02:03:53.376 --> 02:03:53.921
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know you're going to—.

1181
02:03:54.016 --> 02:03:54.449
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You're—.

1182
02:03:54.594 --> 02:03:56.003
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You want me to— I'll wrap it up really quickly.

1183
02:03:56.501 --> 02:04:01.051
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, it's just, it's clear that folks are not like, this hasn't been working.

1184
02:04:01.404 --> 02:04:03.823
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Folks are not feeling part of the process.

1185
02:04:04.047 --> 02:04:05.185
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We have work to do.

1186
02:04:05.875 --> 02:04:14.078
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, also focusing on Mr. Jordan really quickly, um, I do— I'd like to know more about what this search looks like.

1187
02:04:14.143 --> 02:04:15.007
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What's the process?

1188
02:04:15.088 --> 02:04:17.877
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How can we make it as transparent as, as possible?

1189
02:04:18.470 --> 02:04:21.402
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I also just— I, I've given you all a fair warning.

1190
02:04:21.979 --> 02:04:27.444
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I, like, am gonna force us all to see each other as human and remember that.

1191
02:04:27.509 --> 02:04:32.662
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I do genuinely care about figuring out this relationship, holding each other accountable.

1192
02:04:32.823 --> 02:04:41.974
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We don't agree on everything, but like making sure that we also are treating each other with respect and keeping humanity in mind.

1193
02:04:42.118 --> 02:04:50.306
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I, I do hear the piece that like we, we need to do a, a really great search and it needs to be transparent and we need to attract top talent.

1194
02:04:51.109 --> 02:04:53.797
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, and part of that is us working together.

1195
02:04:54.171 --> 02:04:55.173
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's being honest.

1196
02:04:55.238 --> 02:05:04.957
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's, I mean, it's doing some of this kind of awkward stuff out in the public, um, and remembering like what our goals are and, and staying focused here.

1197
02:05:05.470 --> 02:05:19.518
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, yeah, I'm kind of, I'm kind of getting lost a little bit, but basically in general, uh, making sure that we are trying to collaborate with each other, being as honest as possible.

1198
02:05:19.567 --> 02:05:19.694
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1199
02:05:20.363 --> 02:05:25.131
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Showing up in good faith, not just trusting each other but also like earning each other's trust.

1200
02:05:25.180 --> 02:05:30.929
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's a lot of trust that's been broken with the community that needs to be repaired, and we need to keep working as a group too on this.

1201
02:05:31.345 --> 02:05:31.684
<v Jessica Vega Peterson>Thank you.

1202
02:05:33.113 --> 02:05:33.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1203
02:05:34.076 --> 02:05:34.831
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Clark.

1204
02:05:36.179 --> 02:05:37.302
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

1205
02:05:38.010 --> 02:05:38.747
<v Olivia Clark>Hi, Michael.

1206
02:05:39.375 --> 02:05:43.372
<v Olivia Clark>Um, thank you, Mayor Wilson, for bringing this forward to us.

1207
02:05:44.351 --> 02:05:59.091
<v Olivia Clark>Um, Michael, I think you've done an excellent job shepherding us to this point through the charter change, and I look forward to the next level of change, implementing the charter and dealing with a difficult budget.

1208
02:05:59.622 --> 02:06:10.332
<v Olivia Clark>I think in hindsight, you know, we all have 20/20 vision in hindsight, and there were some hiccups along the way with us, but we're here now, and I think— and it's good.

1209
02:06:10.380 --> 02:06:10.588
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1210
02:06:11.006 --> 02:06:17.855
<v Olivia Clark>But building on some of the comments of others, I wanted to ask you a general question about trust.

1211
02:06:18.176 --> 02:06:19.219
<v Olivia Clark>Mm-hmm.

1212
02:06:19.427 --> 02:06:32.164
<v Olivia Clark>And, and maybe for the folks that are here and folks who are at home watching, it's sort of in the context of the new relationship, the new form of governance within a legislative body.

1213
02:06:33.640 --> 02:06:39.434
<v Olivia Clark>Can you talk a little bit about that relationship for people as well as How do you build trust?

1214
02:06:39.497 --> 02:06:46.145
<v Olivia Clark>And I would say I so appreciate your being available to all of us, to meeting with us by district.

1215
02:06:46.322 --> 02:06:47.318
<v Olivia Clark>It's been invaluable.

1216
02:06:48.007 --> 02:06:54.479
<v Olivia Clark>But how do you build trust, and, and what is transparency in this situation?

1217
02:06:54.671 --> 02:06:57.930
<v Olivia Clark>I don't mean the— this Zenith situation, I mean generally.

1218
02:06:59.006 --> 02:06:59.328
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1219
02:06:59.408 --> 02:07:00.788
<v Michael Jordan>Well, thank you, Councilor.

1220
02:07:00.853 --> 02:07:05.787
<v Michael Jordan>It's a, a big, broad question you can go a long way with.

1221
02:07:06.162 --> 02:07:07.336
<v Michael Jordan>I'll try to be brief.

1222
02:07:11.835 --> 02:07:16.944
<v Michael Jordan>For trust, at least in my experience, it's proximity and time.

1223
02:07:18.920 --> 02:07:20.289
<v Michael Jordan>You need to be close to each other.

1224
02:07:20.596 --> 02:07:22.372
<v Michael Jordan>You need to work on things together.

1225
02:07:22.548 --> 02:07:28.569
<v Michael Jordan>You need to be in a foxhole together sometimes when it's really hard and be honest.

1226
02:07:28.873 --> 02:07:33.341
<v Michael Jordan>With each other about where you're coming from and why, why you believe what you believe.

1227
02:07:33.875 --> 02:07:36.448
<v Michael Jordan>None of us have the corner on wisdom completely.

1228
02:07:37.340 --> 02:07:41.625
<v Michael Jordan>So we kind of got to bounce off of each other a little bit and hear different perspectives.

1229
02:07:42.222 --> 02:07:45.052
<v Michael Jordan>And that's part of what we're building here, I think.

1230
02:07:46.573 --> 02:07:48.322
<v Michael Jordan>Are we bumping into each other once in a while?

1231
02:07:48.451 --> 02:07:49.422
<v Michael Jordan>You bet we are.

1232
02:07:49.989 --> 02:07:52.063
<v Michael Jordan>Is there any roadmap for what we're doing?

1233
02:07:52.176 --> 02:07:52.256
<v Michael Jordan>No.

1234
02:07:53.310 --> 02:07:57.018
<v Michael Jordan>So we're kind of collectively making this thing up as we go along.

1235
02:07:58.399 --> 02:07:59.493
<v Michael Jordan>And it will get better.

1236
02:07:59.685 --> 02:08:00.440
<v Michael Jordan>I guarantee it.

1237
02:08:01.051 --> 02:08:12.077
<v Michael Jordan>I think this is the most diverse and smart and wise city council that I've ever seen for the city of Portland in my 40 years.

1238
02:08:13.789 --> 02:08:20.362
<v Michael Jordan>But that diversity and smarts and wisdom comes sometimes at a cost.

1239
02:08:20.458 --> 02:08:20.539
<v Michael Jordan>Yes.

1240
02:08:20.894 --> 02:08:21.426
<v Michael Jordan>Which is?

1241
02:08:22.332 --> 02:08:27.408
<v Michael Jordan>We're going to have different opinions and we're going to feel strongly about them and we're going to bump into each other sometimes.

1242
02:08:30.194 --> 02:08:40.765
<v Michael Jordan>If we can keep an open mind and realize that the only way this government, this new government, is prosperous and does well is if we stay together.

1243
02:08:42.136 --> 02:08:43.523
<v Michael Jordan>That's the only way it works.

1244
02:08:43.731 --> 02:08:46.555
<v Michael Jordan>I have watched it work badly in another venue.

1245
02:08:47.076 --> 02:08:51.650
<v Michael Jordan>In the Portland metropolitan area, not so distant future or past.

1246
02:08:53.694 --> 02:08:56.890
<v Michael Jordan>And if the branches do this, we're in big trouble.

1247
02:08:58.231 --> 02:09:07.978
<v Michael Jordan>If we stay together on things, even when it's hard, even when we disagree, and stay in the room till we can move things forward, we're going to be fine.

1248
02:09:09.134 --> 02:09:12.631
<v Michael Jordan>And through doing that, we'll build trust.

1249
02:09:12.680 --> 02:09:12.793
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

1250
02:09:15.885 --> 02:09:16.371
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1251
02:09:16.677 --> 02:09:25.872
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate that, and I look forward to being in the foxhole with you, particularly on the issues in infrastructure and transportation asset management.

1252
02:09:25.921 --> 02:09:26.796
<v Olivia Clark>But thank you so much.

1253
02:09:26.960 --> 02:09:27.349
<v Olivia Clark>I hear you.

1254
02:09:27.528 --> 02:09:27.868
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1255
02:09:29.149 --> 02:09:29.912
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Murillo.

1256
02:09:31.583 --> 02:09:32.314
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Madam President.

1257
02:09:33.270 --> 02:09:34.720
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, thank you both for being here today.

1258
02:09:34.997 --> 02:09:42.356
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, I appreciate Councilor Koyama Lane always acknowledging people's humanity, and it is a hard and difficult conversation.

1259
02:09:42.854 --> 02:09:49.090
<v Angelita Morillo>I also think that the best relationships require accountability and transparency in order to build that trust and move forward.

1260
02:09:50.387 --> 02:09:58.547
<v Angelita Morillo>I want to point out some of the comments that were made, that this is just a run-of-the-mill procedural process with Zenith.

1261
02:09:59.365 --> 02:10:04.238
<v Angelita Morillo>Nothing about how the city has engaged with Zenith is a run-of-the-mill procedural process.

1262
02:10:04.319 --> 02:10:04.416
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

1263
02:10:04.817 --> 02:10:17.872
<v Angelita Morillo>In fact, our own city auditor said that the way that staff engaged with Zenith was far past the scope of regular procedures, and we have much more information to look into moving forward.

1264
02:10:18.770 --> 02:10:42.859
<v Angelita Morillo>I am grateful that Mayor Wilson is supportive of Councilor Green and I's resolution to look into this, but to say on the one end we are going to do very unusual things with Zenith that we don't do with other contractors when we're making agreements as a city but then when accountability is part of the process, when delay so that we can do an investigation is part of the process, suddenly everything has to be by the book, right?

1265
02:10:42.922 --> 02:10:44.206
<v Angelita Morillo>That doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

1266
02:10:44.605 --> 02:10:49.208
<v Angelita Morillo>That seems like 2 separate standards for 2 different groups.

1267
02:10:50.619 --> 02:11:03.895
<v Angelita Morillo>The 2021 LUBA decision, and for folks watching at home, LUBA stands for the Land Use Board of Appeals, said that weighing Zenith's use against the city's comprehensive plan is quasi-judicial decision because of the level of discretion involved.

1268
02:11:04.344 --> 02:11:11.796
<v Angelita Morillo>So those are fancy terms that basically just mean that City Council should have some judicial oversight because this is a very delicate and difficult matter.

1269
02:11:12.757 --> 02:11:21.524
<v Angelita Morillo>The City of Portland ignored this in 2022 and then again on Monday, February 3rd, when the executive branch approved the LUX with little to no notification to city councilors.

1270
02:11:22.020 --> 02:11:40.759
<v Angelita Morillo>This was really frustrating to me as a city councilor because you were well aware that Councilor Green and I were bringing forward a resolution to do an investigation on Zenith and that we wanted to— the intention was to delay the LUCS until such an investigation had been made so that we could really make a decision rooted in the facts.

1271
02:11:42.235 --> 02:11:47.935
<v Angelita Morillo>And our city attorney himself told us that the February 4th deadline was completely arbitrary.

1272
02:11:48.112 --> 02:11:51.613
<v Angelita Morillo>We did not have to legally approve the LUCS on February 4th.

1273
02:11:52.222 --> 02:11:56.189
<v Angelita Morillo>So when we're talking about the legal consequences and the cost to the city, Councilor Smith.

1274
02:11:56.768 --> 02:12:10.475
<v Angelita Morillo>Maybe we're hearing different information, but I was under the impression that we were able to get an extension granted to us so that we could do an investigation and do our due diligence and get all of the facts necessary to actually make an informed decision.

1275
02:12:11.289 --> 02:12:12.966
<v Angelita Morillo>And so now I'm getting to my question.

1276
02:12:13.014 --> 02:12:13.546
<v Angelita Morillo>Apologies.

1277
02:12:15.109 --> 02:12:15.850
<v Angelita Morillo>Sorry, Madam President.

1278
02:12:15.899 --> 02:12:29.868
<v Angelita Morillo>I know she's trying to run this meeting like a tight ship and I'm making it hard, but— I'm a little bit alarmed to hear you say that this is going to happen again because you're going to have tough decisions as a city administrator.

1279
02:12:30.414 --> 02:12:36.086
<v Angelita Morillo>Because I think what I want to hear, or what I want to know, is how are we going to avoid this happening again?

1280
02:12:36.680 --> 02:12:48.279
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that as a city councilor, I would love to work with you and have a transparent process, and leaks wouldn't be such a big issue if we were actually more transparent with the public in the first place, right?

1281
02:12:48.568 --> 02:12:59.021
<v Angelita Morillo>So I would love to hear how we're going to repair this trust and how I know you're going to have to make some executive decisions without us, but how— we are representatives of the public.

1282
02:12:59.551 --> 02:13:00.885
<v Angelita Morillo>We were elected by the people.

1283
02:13:01.333 --> 02:13:02.715
<v Angelita Morillo>They're making demands of us.

1284
02:13:03.967 --> 02:13:09.604
<v Angelita Morillo>And if you are going over our heads to make some of these decisions, I just want to know how we can expect that there will be trust built.

1285
02:13:09.925 --> 02:13:13.713
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't want to hear that this is just going to keep happening because that's not really going to work for me.

1286
02:13:14.822 --> 02:13:16.025
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

1287
02:13:17.520 --> 02:13:19.286
<v Michael Jordan>That's a good question.

1288
02:13:19.783 --> 02:13:26.992
<v Michael Jordan>I, I do believe these kinds of tensions will keep happening.

1289
02:13:27.248 --> 02:13:27.521
<v Michael Jordan>Sure.

1290
02:13:27.827 --> 02:13:39.322
<v Michael Jordan>The, the— we have a scant few words in the charter that define our roles, and there is a wide gray space between them.

1291
02:13:40.574 --> 02:13:46.667
<v Michael Jordan>And, and so I do think we will continue to have to talk to each other about our separate roles.

1292
02:13:47.488 --> 02:13:55.280
<v Michael Jordan>And sometimes we're going to— one of us, one party or the other, will feel like the other has overstepped their bounds.

1293
02:13:56.021 --> 02:13:58.662
<v Michael Jordan>And we should talk about that to, again, continue to learn.

1294
02:13:58.872 --> 02:14:02.608
<v Michael Jordan>So I think we will keep having these kinds of challenges.

1295
02:14:06.759 --> 02:14:10.898
<v Michael Jordan>I think we made a choice based, again, on my previous statement yes.

1296
02:14:10.979 --> 02:14:12.734
<v Michael Jordan>I think it's important to make a statement about risk.

1297
02:14:12.798 --> 02:14:20.274
<v Michael Jordan>The history on Zenith presents lessons on multiple sides of the question.

1298
02:14:21.680 --> 02:14:38.438
<v Michael Jordan>Previous decisions that were remanded by LUBA present multiple lessons, not just one, in, in how the city should approach these kinds of processes.

1299
02:14:38.551 --> 02:14:51.895
<v Michael Jordan>And I think the issues of transparency and how Zenith was interacted with outside of just the administrative process is— are legitimate questions for the council to ask about.

1300
02:14:52.380 --> 02:14:58.591
<v Michael Jordan>And I believe we should talk about how that history has been played out.

1301
02:14:59.014 --> 02:15:15.203
<v Michael Jordan>I will say that I think that we need to have a serious discussion about how that happens, because I think we may have differences of opinion about how we get to those answers, and we should talk about that.

1302
02:15:22.157 --> 02:15:22.833
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1303
02:15:23.059 --> 02:15:23.671
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1304
02:15:26.828 --> 02:15:27.715
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam President.

1305
02:15:28.557 --> 02:15:29.231
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

1306
02:15:29.601 --> 02:15:32.363
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Michael, for coming forward today.

1307
02:15:32.492 --> 02:15:35.125
<v Loretta Smith>This is very uncomfortable in many ways.

1308
02:15:36.265 --> 02:15:46.782
<v Loretta Smith>I wanted to ask the question, when there are executive announcements that are made, can we come to an agreement that we have one executive response?

1309
02:15:47.600 --> 02:15:49.046
<v Loretta Smith>And I'll tell you what I'm talking about.

1310
02:15:49.784 --> 02:16:04.458
<v Loretta Smith>A couple days ago, Mayor Wilson announced a 50-bed opioid, um, new project that he was going to do at, uh, Bybee Lakes, the old Wapato, uh, jail.

1311
02:16:05.479 --> 02:16:13.516
<v Loretta Smith>And yesterday I tried with 3 people who should be in the know— where is this money coming from?

1312
02:16:13.597 --> 02:16:15.564
<v Loretta Smith>Is it coming from 2425?

1313
02:16:16.144 --> 02:16:18.851
<v Loretta Smith>Um, is it something that needs to be put on the books?

1314
02:16:18.900 --> 02:16:18.948
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1315
02:16:19.389 --> 02:16:28.654
<v Loretta Smith>I was told from Skyler at one point, the original conversation, that she thought that it was 3 or 4 months in back that we received the money.

1316
02:16:28.703 --> 02:16:36.039
<v Loretta Smith>I said, okay, then it needs a budget modification to be put in front of the other councilors because we don't know about that money.

1317
02:16:36.718 --> 02:16:39.122
<v Loretta Smith>And then she said, let me check, but I want to make sure.

1318
02:16:39.671 --> 02:16:44.549
<v Loretta Smith>So we went round and round from the CFO to others, and then the grants management, they emailed me last night.

1319
02:16:44.596 --> 02:16:44.645
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

1320
02:16:44.906 --> 02:16:45.019
<v Carrie Ko>Yes.

1321
02:16:45.709 --> 02:16:53.078
<v Loretta Smith>And said that there is no opioid money and that they didn't know when it was coming in and they didn't know how much it was.

1322
02:16:54.155 --> 02:16:57.414
<v Loretta Smith>So I said, okay, um, that's interesting.

1323
02:16:57.527 --> 02:17:00.657
<v Loretta Smith>But I also emailed you before I left work yesterday.

1324
02:17:01.138 --> 02:17:06.422
<v Loretta Smith>I said, if anybody should know this, Michael should know this, and I got no response from you.

1325
02:17:07.256 --> 02:17:19.604
<v Loretta Smith>So I guess what I'm saying is If we're a councilor, if we have a question, there is one person that I expect to know that answer and to go find out for me.

1326
02:17:19.751 --> 02:17:20.397
<v Loretta Smith>It is you.

1327
02:17:21.816 --> 02:17:34.295
<v Loretta Smith>And so I'm really frustrated right now because I got another communication from Skyler this morning that said, oh no, that money has already been noted in the fall bump.

1328
02:17:35.084 --> 02:17:36.629
<v Loretta Smith>And she sent me a list of—.

1329
02:17:36.629 --> 02:17:36.998
<v Loretta Smith>Councilwoman?

1330
02:17:37.606 --> 02:17:43.202
<v Loretta Smith>The line items that were in that fall bump, but it did not include Bybee Lake because we didn't even know about it then.

1331
02:17:43.861 --> 02:17:59.239
<v Loretta Smith>And she said, well— I said, if you have $2.1 million hanging around, which I know we have to appropriate every single penny, then either you're going to take it from another program or you're going to take it out of an contingency pot.

1332
02:17:59.816 --> 02:18:05.600
<v Loretta Smith>And in either case, you have to come before council To get that approved.

1333
02:18:06.003 --> 02:18:13.988
<v Loretta Smith>And so I want to know from you, will we have an executive response, a singular executive response?

1334
02:18:14.149 --> 02:18:16.995
<v Loretta Smith>And let me just say this off the bat.

1335
02:18:17.670 --> 02:18:24.423
<v Loretta Smith>I totally love the idea that we would put 50 more opioid beds out into the system.

1336
02:18:24.859 --> 02:18:25.764
<v Loretta Smith>That is perfect.

1337
02:18:26.152 --> 02:18:27.978
<v Loretta Smith>But something dinged in my head too.

1338
02:18:28.173 --> 02:18:28.254
<v Loretta Smith>What?

1339
02:18:29.757 --> 02:18:37.373
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know that Bybee Lakes is the appropriate place because it is a high-barrier homeless shelter.

1340
02:18:37.824 --> 02:18:40.346
<v Loretta Smith>So why would we put 50 opioid beds?

1341
02:18:40.395 --> 02:18:43.013
<v Loretta Smith>And they don't even do that at, at, at Bybee Lakes.

1342
02:18:43.351 --> 02:18:48.042
<v Loretta Smith>And why wouldn't we put it over in the Clinton Triangle where they actually do that?

1343
02:18:48.188 --> 02:18:53.023
<v Loretta Smith>So that boggled my mind that we would do that because they have to pay to be there.

1344
02:18:53.618 --> 02:18:54.566
<v Loretta Smith>They have to not be on drugs.

1345
02:18:54.710 --> 02:18:57.826
<v Loretta Smith>Councilwoman Smith, But the way it was explained to us.

1346
02:18:58.458 --> 02:19:06.125
<v Loretta Smith>And so you have to be very clear with many of us, and especially with me, because if you tell me something, I have some follow-up questions.

1347
02:19:06.400 --> 02:19:07.683
<v Loretta Smith>I'm going to ask you where the money's from.

1348
02:19:07.764 --> 02:19:09.161
<v Loretta Smith>Was it from '24-'25?

1349
02:19:09.469 --> 02:19:10.753
<v Loretta Smith>Was it from '25-'26?

1350
02:19:11.029 --> 02:19:11.841
<v Loretta Smith>Where's the line item?

1351
02:19:12.067 --> 02:19:13.188
<v Loretta Smith>Show me some receipts.

1352
02:19:14.165 --> 02:19:20.799
<v Loretta Smith>And if I don't have no receipts and I have different responses— I've gotten 4 different responses, but I failed to get one from you.

1353
02:19:20.879 --> 02:19:20.944
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1354
02:19:21.382 --> 02:19:22.154
<v Loretta Smith>About this case.

1355
02:19:22.266 --> 02:19:31.397
<v Loretta Smith>And so I need a singular executive response when I ask about a serious issue, because this is serious work.

1356
02:19:33.368 --> 02:19:43.304
<v Loretta Smith>And the second question I want to ask you too is, did you not know that Mike Myers was living in Las Vegas for the last 4 months?

1357
02:19:45.787 --> 02:19:48.263
<v Michael Jordan>I didn't get the question, the first question.

1358
02:19:48.554 --> 02:20:01.754
<v Loretta Smith>The first question, will we have a singular executive response when I ask a question, like when I asked the question yesterday, where is the money coming from for Mayor Wilson's 50-bed opioid that he's going to go over to Bybee Lake?

1359
02:20:02.559 --> 02:20:10.252
<v Michael Jordan>Well, it's clear that you got multiple responses from us up to this point, and I will reconcile those multiple responses.

1360
02:20:10.351 --> 02:20:12.135
<v Loretta Smith>Multiple different responses.

1361
02:20:12.560 --> 02:20:16.054
<v Michael Jordan>Yes, yes, Councilor, and I'll reconcile that and get you a single response.

1362
02:20:17.111 --> 02:20:18.218
<v Michael Jordan>Now to the second question.

1363
02:20:18.362 --> 02:20:25.995
<v Michael Jordan>I've been aware that Mike's been in Las Vegas, uh, I want to say since late September or early October.

1364
02:20:26.524 --> 02:20:27.951
<v Michael Jordan>I can't remember the exact date.

1365
02:20:28.736 --> 02:20:36.947
<v Michael Jordan>He has had a medical problem that he has— is, uh, not— I will just say I'm not going to discuss his medical problem.

1366
02:20:37.012 --> 02:20:38.069
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, no, you can't discuss it.

1367
02:20:38.118 --> 02:20:44.757
<v Michael Jordan>But he has a severe, significant medical challenge And he has been doing the work from Las Vegas since then.

1368
02:20:45.352 --> 02:20:49.602
<v Michael Jordan>His contract ends on April the 29th, I believe.

1369
02:20:50.084 --> 02:20:51.367
<v Michael Jordan>It will not be renewed.

1370
02:20:52.314 --> 02:20:58.569
<v Michael Jordan>I would like to have Mike stay as long as then to help us put together the recruitment for the fire chief.

1371
02:20:58.906 --> 02:21:07.826
<v Michael Jordan>He is exemplary experience, and I trust his judgment to help at least put the system together to do the recruitment.

1372
02:21:07.875 --> 02:21:08.034
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

1373
02:21:08.291 --> 02:21:12.629
<v Michael Jordan>And get us in a position to be able to make a great hire for the fire chief.

1374
02:21:12.934 --> 02:21:16.983
<v Loretta Smith>Just to be clear for the folks at home and who are sitting out here, he is not our fire chief right now.

1375
02:21:17.128 --> 02:21:19.120
<v Loretta Smith>He is over our Public Safety Department.

1376
02:21:19.296 --> 02:21:25.128
<v Loretta Smith>He was our former fire chief, and he has experience in other places that he has been.

1377
02:21:25.546 --> 02:21:43.005
<v Loretta Smith>But I was so shocked to hear when the mayor said he had just learned that Mike Myers was in Las Vegas 2 weeks ago, and he's been so diligently having coffees with every single DCA, even before— after— before we, um, before we even got elected.

1378
02:21:43.086 --> 02:21:51.871
<v Loretta Smith>And so that was very surprising that you would not have relayed that information to the mayor, that one of our DCAs is living in Las Vegas.

1379
02:21:52.370 --> 02:21:59.566
<v Loretta Smith>And so I have a problem with certain information that you are knowledgeable about that you are not relaying to the mayor.

1380
02:22:00.079 --> 02:22:01.349
<v Loretta Smith>That kind of stuff he needs to know.

1381
02:22:01.413 --> 02:22:01.524
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1382
02:22:02.663 --> 02:22:03.297
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you, Councilor.

1383
02:22:03.718 --> 02:22:04.059
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1384
02:22:07.454 --> 02:22:09.290
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Jordan, I think I get a question now.

1385
02:22:09.846 --> 02:22:09.959
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh boy.

1386
02:22:10.570 --> 02:22:23.233
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I want to ask about your approach with your relationship with Council, and a few of my colleagues have touched on this, but you're right, there are scant few words in the charter for what your relationship is with us.

1387
02:22:23.961 --> 02:22:27.524
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You manage the administration of the city, which is overseen by the mayor.

1388
02:22:28.153 --> 02:22:32.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But you are in a role that is duly responsive to both the mayor and council.

1389
02:22:33.198 --> 02:22:40.361
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we may have different approaches, you and I, we may have different approaches across council on what that relationship should be.

1390
02:22:40.522 --> 02:22:45.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And you're right, we will navigate that and work through that together to create a unified approach.

1391
02:22:45.744 --> 02:22:47.431
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I'd like to know where you're starting from.

1392
02:22:48.298 --> 02:22:54.885
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like you to speak a little bit to what you see as the starting place from your values, from your beliefs.

1393
02:22:54.933 --> 02:22:55.029
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1394
02:22:55.847 --> 02:23:00.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For what your relationship with council is and how we fill in those scant few words in the charter?

1395
02:23:01.579 --> 02:23:04.453
<v Michael Jordan>It's a good question, Council President.

1396
02:23:05.320 --> 02:23:08.548
<v Michael Jordan>I think you are accurate.

1397
02:23:09.174 --> 02:23:19.868
<v Michael Jordan>Your statement about dual accountability is accurate, but it is so short of the complexity of the circumstance.

1398
02:23:21.007 --> 02:23:27.102
<v Michael Jordan>Certainly, I'm unilaterally responsible to the mayor every day, every hour, every minute.

1399
02:23:27.647 --> 02:23:34.179
<v Michael Jordan>I am responsible to a supermajority of you every day, every hour, and every minute, and I appreciate that.

1400
02:23:35.631 --> 02:23:38.575
<v Michael Jordan>But I don't think that's very fulfilling.

1401
02:23:40.216 --> 02:24:07.064
<v Michael Jordan>I think the more fulfilling answer is, how do you as a chief executive how do, how do I interact with a board of directors that's accountable to the public and has, has all of the issues that come with that accountability for everything that goes on in this city?

1402
02:24:08.046 --> 02:24:16.264
<v Michael Jordan>You're the ones who will get probably the first phone calls, or maybe the second, but you'll get a phone call very early when folks are not happy about something.

1403
02:24:16.350 --> 02:24:16.434
<v Michael Jordan>Yeah.

1404
02:24:16.546 --> 02:24:18.936
<v Michael Jordan>Something that's going on in this city.

1405
02:24:20.316 --> 02:24:36.592
<v Michael Jordan>And often, I would say significantly, majority of the time, that will be because of how management has done its job or not, how the administration has delivered for the people of this city.

1406
02:24:37.329 --> 02:24:52.137
<v Michael Jordan>And so I view my job in very many ways as being the person that has one foot firmly planted in policy and politics and the other foot firmly planted in management and administration.

1407
02:24:52.746 --> 02:24:55.007
<v Michael Jordan>And a lot of my job is being translator.

1408
02:24:55.858 --> 02:25:11.287
<v Michael Jordan>A lot of my job is trying to inform your policy decisions with the practicality of implementation and management and, and some of the logistical tradeoffs, whether they're fiscal or managerial tradeoffs.

1409
02:25:11.334 --> 02:25:11.511
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

1410
02:25:12.137 --> 02:25:19.490
<v Michael Jordan>To infuse those into your policy conversations so that you can make a wide open, eyes wide open, informed decision.

1411
02:25:20.101 --> 02:25:34.279
<v Michael Jordan>And then when you've made a decision, it's my job to inform the implementation and managerial part of making sure that your intent manifests on the ground in the community about the policies that you pass.

1412
02:25:34.953 --> 02:25:36.029
<v Michael Jordan>And so it—.

1413
02:25:36.029 --> 02:25:36.174
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

1414
02:25:37.591 --> 02:25:43.020
<v Michael Jordan>It's a huge job and it's a high-wire act, and this is a big place with lots of moving parts.

1415
02:25:43.602 --> 02:25:49.844
<v Michael Jordan>But I think fundamentally that's a role that I play in this administrator's role.

1416
02:25:50.199 --> 02:25:58.956
<v Michael Jordan>And let me say, probably the most important part of that is to make sure you're successful.

1417
02:26:00.668 --> 02:26:03.230
<v Michael Jordan>This place does not work if you are not successful.

1418
02:26:03.280 --> 02:26:03.523
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

1419
02:26:04.433 --> 02:26:08.486
<v Michael Jordan>We can't make policy decisions from the administration.

1420
02:26:09.720 --> 02:26:11.130
<v Michael Jordan>We have to have your guidance.

1421
02:26:11.563 --> 02:26:16.257
<v Michael Jordan>You have to be able to frame the right questions so that you can deliberate on them.

1422
02:26:16.915 --> 02:26:30.279
<v Michael Jordan>I'm hoping that the committee structure will be a huge help for us to be able to interact in a, a little more informal way and be in each other's hip pocket a little more so that, one, we can build trust.

1423
02:26:30.375 --> 02:26:30.534
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

1424
02:26:31.032 --> 02:26:37.218
<v Michael Jordan>But 2, we can have informed dialogue about the perspectives between policy and management.

1425
02:26:38.406 --> 02:26:43.082
<v Michael Jordan>And, and it is a, a sometimes very challenging dialogue.

1426
02:26:43.950 --> 02:26:57.492
<v Michael Jordan>And, and I'm hopeful that the committee structure will help us with that and give us more chance to have these kinds of conversations that we can give and take and make sure we know where each other are and hopefully get to conclusions that work for everybody.

1427
02:26:57.540 --> 02:26:57.668
<v Michael Jordan>Thank you.

1428
02:26:59.032 --> 02:27:00.231
<v Michael Jordan>That's how I see my role.

1429
02:27:02.670 --> 02:27:02.912
<v Owen Nguyen>Thank you.

1430
02:27:03.605 --> 02:27:04.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal.

1431
02:27:08.027 --> 02:27:09.512
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much for being here.

1432
02:27:10.638 --> 02:27:12.947
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, apologize for misspeaking earlier, Mayor, uh, as well.

1433
02:27:13.108 --> 02:27:22.141
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, so I, I want to start, um, by saying, you know, I'm going to use a couple things as reference points here that relate to the Zenith conversation, but they're not really about that.

1434
02:27:22.600 --> 02:27:24.543
<v Sameer Kanal>They're about the process by which it happened.

1435
02:27:25.137 --> 02:27:40.931
<v Sameer Kanal>And I would have loved to have the chance to chat about some of these things before because I try not to have surprises, but I had 2 surprises come my way since our opportunities to chat, one of which was the DCA indicating their intent to step down, and the other was, was what happened with Zenith.

1436
02:27:41.075 --> 02:27:45.525
<v Sameer Kanal>And when I say surprise, I want to note for the record that I actually found out through the press release.

1437
02:27:46.023 --> 02:27:57.459
<v Sameer Kanal>So for anyone who is thinking that this is something that council knew or had a decision in, I found out through the press release, actually the email about the press release that came out a minute after, uh, it was published.

1438
02:27:57.684 --> 02:27:59.097
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just want to note that for the record.

1439
02:28:00.076 --> 02:28:02.020
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, my questions are about DCAs.

1440
02:28:02.677 --> 02:28:05.471
<v Sameer Kanal>So DCAs as a, as a role don't exist in the charter.

1441
02:28:05.712 --> 02:28:16.486
<v Sameer Kanal>They're, uh, they're something that was, I think, a good idea because there's 27 bureau directors and span of control is an issue, which is the number of people a single person can be expected to, to manage.

1442
02:28:16.873 --> 02:28:34.076
<v Sameer Kanal>So using the fact that we have been given feedback from the public alleging that, um, in this case a DCA— and I'm not saying I agree with it or disagree, I haven't looked into it— but alleging a DCA came here and gave us false information, um, that's a thing that is serious if that were to hypothetically be true.

1443
02:28:34.786 --> 02:28:36.470
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and again, I don't want to imply that I agree or disagree.

1444
02:28:36.521 --> 02:28:41.373
<v Sameer Kanal>My question is, in a hypothetical situation where we did all see that as what happened, Mm-hmm.

1445
02:28:42.404 --> 02:28:43.406
<v Sameer Kanal>And let's say it's not a DCA.

1446
02:28:43.454 --> 02:28:49.263
<v Sameer Kanal>Let's say it's anyone from the administrative side comes to and misleads, uh, or lies to the council.

1447
02:28:49.846 --> 02:29:02.941
<v Sameer Kanal>As the ultimate manager for the administrative side, directly for DCAs and directly for bureau directors, what do you think should happen if a staff member comes to the city council and lies or misleads us?

1448
02:29:03.006 --> 02:29:04.808
<v Sameer Kanal>How would you want that process to work?

1449
02:29:09.835 --> 02:29:14.987
<v Michael Jordan>Hard to comment on hypotheticals because there are so many what-ifs buried in them.

1450
02:29:16.329 --> 02:29:23.961
<v Michael Jordan>And the fact that inaccurate information gets conveyed to council is one thing.

1451
02:29:25.055 --> 02:29:28.143
<v Michael Jordan>The intent behind that is a very different thing.

1452
02:29:28.561 --> 02:29:28.738
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1453
02:29:29.768 --> 02:29:54.980
<v Michael Jordan>And I have certainly been involved More times than I want to admit to over the years in having to discern between an act and the intent behind the act, usually in a human resource perspective in doing an investigation and trying to figure out, first of all, what's the truth, and then secondly, what do you do about the truth?

1454
02:29:55.719 --> 02:30:04.481
<v Michael Jordan>And as far as an employee, any employee sitting here, And delivering inaccurate information to you, that's a problem.

1455
02:30:08.819 --> 02:30:12.774
<v Michael Jordan>The edges of that problem are really gray and nebulous.

1456
02:30:12.904 --> 02:30:24.781
<v Michael Jordan>So sometimes you'll get information— I have seen, let's say, historically I have seen, not for you— historically I have seen councils get information that is incomplete.

1457
02:30:24.861 --> 02:30:24.990
<v Michael Jordan>Okay.

1458
02:30:26.979 --> 02:30:29.404
<v Michael Jordan>And it can influence how the council deliberates.

1459
02:30:31.149 --> 02:30:36.926
<v Michael Jordan>And so, and, and, and that incompleteness, at least in my experience, has almost never been intentional.

1460
02:30:37.822 --> 02:30:42.253
<v Michael Jordan>It is that the whole story isn't illuminated yet, that we don't know everything yet.

1461
02:30:43.041 --> 02:30:46.977
<v Michael Jordan>And sometimes this is happening in real time as council is deliberating.

1462
02:30:47.674 --> 02:30:59.045
<v Michael Jordan>So to not drone on too long about your question, I think at its core, it's an assessment of truth and then an assessment of what do we do about that.

1463
02:30:59.253 --> 02:31:03.899
<v Michael Jordan>And when it comes to city employees, that's almost entirely an HR problem that I have to deal with.

1464
02:31:04.380 --> 02:31:05.759
<v Michael Jordan>So thanks.

1465
02:31:06.368 --> 02:31:19.370
<v Sameer Kanal>And related to that, you know, and, um, on the— and I'm noticing I'm gonna go and nobody else has a hand up, so I'm, I'm just noting because of this that I, I'm not— I'm cutting half of my I want to be clear about that.

1466
02:31:19.451 --> 02:31:24.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm hearing you saying related to that, but we do need to do a time check before you move on to too many topics.

1467
02:31:24.545 --> 02:31:25.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But go ahead.

1468
02:31:26.065 --> 02:31:27.066
<v Sameer Kanal>These are all about DCAs.

1469
02:31:27.309 --> 02:31:28.664
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to be super clear about that.

1470
02:31:28.808 --> 02:31:30.480
<v Sameer Kanal>All my questions relate to the DCA role.

1471
02:31:30.978 --> 02:31:48.404
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so I, I asked, um, and I, I'm curious about the assurances here at the Zenith work session, what confidence should we have that this is not going to just be issued on February 4th and that on February 5th and beyond we're just going to be told here's a thing we did and it's too late to change it.

1472
02:31:48.840 --> 02:31:50.488
<v Sameer Kanal>How can we be confident that that will not happen?

1473
02:31:50.925 --> 02:31:53.270
<v Sameer Kanal>I asked that question verbatim, uh, about Zenith.

1474
02:31:53.463 --> 02:32:00.378
<v Sameer Kanal>Again, not about this, but about the, the fact that we were not communicated with because this came out through— and again, learned through a press release.

1475
02:32:01.141 --> 02:32:04.949
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, whether this was an administrative action, quasi-judicial, it's not a normal action.

1476
02:32:04.997 --> 02:32:07.563
<v Sameer Kanal>I think, uh, Councilor Murillo said that pretty clearly.

1477
02:32:07.740 --> 02:32:15.994
<v Sameer Kanal>Do you think it's appropriate for councilors to find out about high-profile administrative decisions through press releases rather than through direct communication?

1478
02:32:16.316 --> 02:32:26.726
<v Sameer Kanal>And do you think that council is an audience for or an advisory group to the administrative side, or the part of the government that sets the direction and the mayor and administrator execute that direction, as the charter says?

1479
02:32:28.549 --> 02:33:01.199
<v Michael Jordan>Well, the first question we've already run into in other— in another venue besides CENIF, um, and I won't go into the details, But, but the timing of, um, information flow and the audiences that information flows to, whether it is the council, the press, uh, or, uh, staff, uh, depending on the issue, that timing is sometimes very tight.

1480
02:33:01.825 --> 02:33:02.855
<v Michael Jordan>Let's put it that way.

1481
02:33:03.563 --> 02:33:17.254
<v Michael Jordan>However, I don't think it's appropriate for this council to be surprised by something that is printed in the paper that is of some consequence, uh, to how the council works or issues that the council— that we know the council cares about.

1482
02:33:17.880 --> 02:33:19.390
<v Michael Jordan>So you shouldn't be surprised.

1483
02:33:20.225 --> 02:33:20.546
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1484
02:33:21.173 --> 02:33:30.789
<v Sameer Kanal>So, and the, the next thing is, based on the assumption, uh, and, and Mayor Wilson can correct me if I'm wrong on the assumption, that we have DCAs who are interim through June 30th.

1485
02:33:31.849 --> 02:33:34.721
<v Sameer Kanal>Right now, the city administrator is interim through June 30th.

1486
02:33:35.540 --> 02:33:49.924
<v Sameer Kanal>If the extension of the city administrator were to go beyond that but the interim status of the DCAs did not continue, my assumption is that the city administrator, you in this case, would be responsible for determining who is the replacement.

1487
02:33:50.308 --> 02:33:58.078
<v Sameer Kanal>And this, I guess, is in April for, for the DCA of Public Safety, and whether or not the other 5 would be kept on or replaced by somebody new and leading that process.

1488
02:33:58.143 --> 02:33:58.254
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1489
02:33:58.448 --> 02:34:00.227
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's my assumption.

1490
02:34:00.980 --> 02:34:09.829
<v Sameer Kanal>And my, my question is, and I want to be clear that I, I didn't get, uh, DCA Oliveira did not assure me that I would, that, that hypothetical I laid out would not happen.

1491
02:34:09.878 --> 02:34:12.025
<v Sameer Kanal>He was, to his credit, not— he didn't promise something.

1492
02:34:12.522 --> 02:34:17.108
<v Sameer Kanal>But I am asking you because I— to give me maybe clearer assurance on this.

1493
02:34:17.733 --> 02:34:24.081
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, you will be finding a new interim, permanent, or possibly both interim now, permanent later.

1494
02:34:24.787 --> 02:34:26.453
<v Sameer Kanal>Deputy City Administrator for Public Safety.

1495
02:34:26.566 --> 02:34:30.781
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick and myself are co-chairs of the Community and Public Safety Committee.

1496
02:34:31.519 --> 02:34:36.551
<v Sameer Kanal>Will we be involved in the decision-making process for who the new DCA for Public Safety is?

1497
02:34:37.145 --> 02:34:39.709
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to be clear, for both interim and permanent.

1498
02:34:40.415 --> 02:34:41.968
<v Sameer Kanal>And if so, specifically how?

1499
02:34:42.658 --> 02:34:47.050
<v Sameer Kanal>Will we be surprised by, here is the new interim DCA for Public Safety?

1500
02:34:47.788 --> 02:34:51.506
<v Sameer Kanal>Will we have a seat on the final interview committee, a representative?

1501
02:34:51.555 --> 02:34:51.939
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick.

1502
02:34:55.165 --> 02:34:58.209
<v Michael Jordan>The short answer is we should talk about that.

1503
02:34:58.468 --> 02:35:09.761
<v Michael Jordan>I've worked for lots and lots of elected bodies and single elected officials where I have had, I have had the authority and the responsibility to make hire-fire decisions.

1504
02:35:11.495 --> 02:35:24.704
<v Michael Jordan>And when it is a hire of significant importance, and the DCA of Public Safety would be a hire of I would like to find out how the council would like to be involved in that.

1505
02:35:24.834 --> 02:35:27.736
<v Michael Jordan>And the short answer about how is I don't know.

1506
02:35:28.442 --> 02:35:36.320
<v Michael Jordan>I think we should talk with, at least with the Public Safety Committee, to say how would you like to be involved and at what level.

1507
02:35:36.947 --> 02:35:40.091
<v Michael Jordan>I want to be clear though, the charter is very clear.

1508
02:35:40.573 --> 02:35:43.268
<v Michael Jordan>It is my job to hire and it's my job to get rid of.

1509
02:35:43.316 --> 02:35:43.748
<v Michael Jordan>I think that's a good point.

1510
02:35:44.022 --> 02:35:45.915
<v Michael Jordan>People in these kinds of roles.

1511
02:35:46.573 --> 02:35:53.085
<v Michael Jordan>And but having said that, uh, I would love to engage with you in, in what's— how do we do that?

1512
02:35:54.031 --> 02:36:03.433
<v Michael Jordan>Just as the city administrator's appointment is the mayor's appointment, but you all have to endorse that appointment.

1513
02:36:04.058 --> 02:36:12.721
<v Michael Jordan>And so you should be involved in that architectural process for how we're going to get to the decision That the mayor will have to make about an appointment.

1514
02:36:13.399 --> 02:36:29.889
<v Michael Jordan>So just, just as that, I would like to engage with the council in these really high-level personnel decisions about the talent that's going to lead the city in the administrative role to make what you all want to happen happen.

1515
02:36:30.566 --> 02:36:31.904
<v Michael Jordan>And so I think you should be involved.

1516
02:36:32.016 --> 02:36:35.013
<v Michael Jordan>I just couldn't give you an answer to the exact architecture right now.

1517
02:36:35.061 --> 02:36:35.238
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1518
02:36:35.706 --> 02:36:36.978
<v Michael Jordan>But we should interact on that.

1519
02:36:37.175 --> 02:36:37.692
<v Sameer Kanal>That, that's okay.

1520
02:36:37.757 --> 02:36:40.163
<v Sameer Kanal>Can I just get the, the very specific part?

1521
02:36:40.244 --> 02:36:40.502
<v Karen Chire>Sure.

1522
02:36:40.745 --> 02:36:41.486
<v Loretta Smith>Will we—.

1523
02:36:41.859 --> 02:36:51.040
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm specifically referring to Councilor Novick and I— can you promise us we will not be surprised by who the new interim DCA for Public Safety is?

1524
02:36:51.379 --> 02:36:52.574
<v Michael Jordan>Yeah, I think I can promise that.

1525
02:36:53.154 --> 02:36:53.413
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1526
02:36:55.171 --> 02:36:56.097
<v Sameer Kanal>I have one more, but I'll wait.

1527
02:36:58.020 --> 02:36:59.075
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, councilors, we are at noon.

1528
02:36:59.190 --> 02:37:04.673
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our meeting is scheduled until 12:30, and we have another appointment that we need to hear from, plus finishing this.

1529
02:37:04.980 --> 02:37:09.453
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm going to ask if everybody is available at least until 1.

1530
02:37:09.745 --> 02:37:11.334
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That gives us an additional half hour.

1531
02:37:12.787 --> 02:37:18.864
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we would like to take additional questions, we will need to extend that beyond 1 o'clock realistically.

1532
02:37:20.549 --> 02:37:23.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, so I'm wondering—.

1533
02:37:23.801 --> 02:37:25.257
<v Eric Zimmerman>Call the vote, Madam President.

1534
02:37:25.354 --> 02:37:26.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not sure that we need to vote on this.

1535
02:37:27.442 --> 02:37:28.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, oh, call the vote here.

1536
02:37:29.060 --> 02:37:29.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1537
02:37:30.111 --> 02:37:36.337
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's time.

1538
02:37:36.677 --> 02:37:38.215
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, okay, one more.

1539
02:37:38.538 --> 02:37:40.019
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know Councilor Knoll has one more.

1540
02:37:40.210 --> 02:37:41.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know a few others have statements to make.

1541
02:37:41.995 --> 02:37:48.406
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Knoll, I'm hoping that you can turn your question into a comment with your vote because I'm hearing folks calling for the vote.

1542
02:37:48.906 --> 02:37:50.547
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a call from Councilor Zimmerman.

1543
02:37:50.933 --> 02:37:52.012
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Did we have a second?

1544
02:37:52.847 --> 02:37:53.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know that we need that.

1545
02:37:53.878 --> 02:37:54.183
<v Nancy Thorington>Second.

1546
02:37:54.843 --> 02:37:55.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1547
02:37:56.440 --> 02:38:16.478
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we're going to close discussion and move to a vote on the resolution to appoint— this is not a reappointment because you are interim right now— but to appoint Mike Jordan, Michael Jordan, as city administrator.

1548
02:38:24.691 --> 02:38:25.745
<v Candace Avalos>Sorry, y'all, I have a statement.

1549
02:38:25.826 --> 02:38:39.718
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, um, so thank you to those who testified, and in particular Linda Liu's comments resonated with me because I agree that this appointment is about more than a single administrative decision, but instead about the qualities we're looking for in this powerful new position.

1550
02:38:40.708 --> 02:39:00.367
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, as a former charter commissioner who spent a lot of time thinking about the relationship of our new branches of government, I have a particular interest in watching how closely those powers, authorities, and responsibilities of each branch of our government are realized, because it's clear to me based on recent events that we need to thoughtfully discuss how the powers are unfolding in this new government.

1551
02:39:00.639 --> 02:39:17.218
<v Candace Avalos>The best example being the surprise Zenith Lux approval that was made without counsel despite our clear signals to delay that decision so that we could perform our elected duty to provide oversight on critical decisions that impact so I just want to state on my record my disapproval of that decision.

1552
02:39:18.518 --> 02:39:29.231
<v Candace Avalos>For me, approving this appointment without a specified end date was a non-starter, so I'm grateful to my colleagues for approving the amendment that we added prior to this vote to secure that end date within the resolution.

1553
02:39:29.985 --> 02:39:42.447
<v Candace Avalos>I want to thank the GTAC for working diligently to recommend a robust process for a national search, and I'm voting aye today to allow for stable leadership while we give ourselves the time to conduct a thorough and community-informed search.

1554
02:39:42.511 --> 02:39:42.638
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1555
02:39:42.834 --> 02:39:44.260
<v Candace Avalos>For our next city administrator.

1556
02:39:44.472 --> 02:39:44.752
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1557
02:39:44.800 --> 02:39:45.128
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I vote aye.

1558
02:39:47.115 --> 02:39:48.112
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, 2 quick comments.

1559
02:39:48.176 --> 02:39:51.808
<v Jamie Dunphy>First, I've had the pleasure of working with Administrator Jordan for 10 years now.

1560
02:39:51.953 --> 02:39:56.566
<v Jamie Dunphy>His first week working for the Bureau of Environmental Services was my first week working for Commissioner Fish.

1561
02:39:57.095 --> 02:40:02.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have found him to be a consummate professional, a systems thinker, and an ideal public— faithful public servant.

1562
02:40:03.667 --> 02:40:09.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>To that end, with regard to the comments we've heard about Zenith, I personally do not want a city administrator who feels Councilor Dan Ryan.

1563
02:40:09.540 --> 02:40:09.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mayor.

1564
02:40:09.540 --> 02:40:14.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe that the mayor is not empowered to ignore the will of the City Council and change and interpret the law as they see fit.

1565
02:40:14.559 --> 02:40:20.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>And as such, I believe the Zenith decision was ultimately the fault of the City Council for not fixing the law in the first place.

1566
02:40:20.459 --> 02:40:26.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I look forward to finding ways to make sure that we can impact whether or not Zenith continues to operate using legal bounds.

1567
02:40:26.520 --> 02:40:30.219
<v Jamie Dunphy>But, um, my vote today is based on 3 very specific things.

1568
02:40:30.219 --> 02:40:38.343
<v Jamie Dunphy>One, uh, we are facing an enormously complicated budget cycle that we need faithful and, uh, continued leadership in order to try and navigate through.

1569
02:40:38.664 --> 02:40:46.675
<v Jamie Dunphy>That budget conversation, uh, will also inform the staffing and form of government changes that are going to be vital to our success in this next chapter.

1570
02:40:46.819 --> 02:40:56.578
<v Jamie Dunphy>And third, uh, that Administrator Jordan has promised to help begin the robust international— or, or maybe international, uh, search for a permanent city administrator.

1571
02:40:56.691 --> 02:41:01.851
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that the timing on all of that would be deeply unfair to anybody other than Mike Jordan in this.

1572
02:41:01.915 --> 02:41:03.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's probably unfair to Mike Jordan in this circumstance too.

1573
02:41:04.457 --> 02:41:14.012
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, but because of those reasons and my trust in Mike, um, and the ultimate assurance that I have from this council that we will be having further conversations about Zenith, I vote aye.

1574
02:41:17.147 --> 02:41:18.608
<v Loretta Smith>Madam President, thank you.

1575
02:41:19.958 --> 02:41:24.953
<v Loretta Smith>I've been listening to the testimony from everyone today about Zenith.

1576
02:41:25.645 --> 02:41:36.626
<v Loretta Smith>I've been listening to the council folks about transparency And making sure that we have good governance and that our government is, is stable.

1577
02:41:38.203 --> 02:41:54.629
<v Loretta Smith>And as I think about how to go forward, I think that Michael Jordan has the experience, the background, and the track record to help us get someone who's going to take us into the future.

1578
02:41:55.747 --> 02:41:57.417
<v Loretta Smith>I watched his record at DAS.

1579
02:41:57.852 --> 02:42:05.397
<v Loretta Smith>I don't think there's anybody in this room or at this city who has more experience navigating at the top than Michael Jordan.

1580
02:42:06.458 --> 02:42:19.543
<v Loretta Smith>I do have some concerns in terms of how I get information, but that is not enough for me to say that we need to wholesale take him out of this position for this next year.

1581
02:42:19.609 --> 02:42:20.058
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1582
02:42:20.956 --> 02:42:41.050
<v Loretta Smith>Um, but I want to be clear, I still want transparency and I want trust to continue to build with us so that we can make sure that we have a city that is not just surviving, that we have a city that's thriving, and everyone in that city has an opportunity to thrive.

1583
02:42:41.260 --> 02:42:49.971
<v Loretta Smith>So I am going to support this vote, Mr. Mayor, for your appointment thank you, Councilor.

1584
02:42:51.244 --> 02:42:59.263
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to note this 3 times, one, uh, for each of the 3 appointments.

1585
02:42:59.376 --> 02:43:07.252
<v Sameer Kanal>I gave this feedback to Mayor Wilson when he said that he was going to nominate Michael Jordan, Robert Taylor, and Bob Day to the 3 positions that are mayor-nominated and council-appointed.

1586
02:43:07.831 --> 02:43:11.694
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, that's disappointing to me because it's keeping the overall slate the same for now.

1587
02:43:11.790 --> 02:43:16.838
<v Sameer Kanal>Now as an election widely seen as a change election, yielding 12 new out of 14 elected officials.

1588
02:43:17.433 --> 02:43:25.094
<v Sameer Kanal>At the same time, I'm not inclined to hold any one of you individually responsible for that, um, by voting against, uh, based off of the whole.

1589
02:43:25.673 --> 02:43:27.468
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'm not inclined to make a point on that.

1590
02:43:27.548 --> 02:43:31.813
<v Sameer Kanal>So my vote is based entirely off of the nomination individually in the question.

1591
02:43:31.941 --> 02:43:33.479
<v Sameer Kanal>I just want to note that for the record.

1592
02:43:34.168 --> 02:43:44.459
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I, I do hope to see some, uh, process for this particular position that looks beyond the city and beyond, um, you know, what, what we've had in the past.

1593
02:43:45.068 --> 02:43:51.127
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I— the, the question I didn't get to ask was about severance packages for DCAs.

1594
02:43:51.319 --> 02:43:52.554
<v Sameer Kanal>I also just want to daylight that.

1595
02:43:52.618 --> 02:44:01.032
<v Sameer Kanal>I think if they are, uh, continuing on, you know, there was $209,000 approved by, uh, you know, for, for each of the, the 6 DCAs.

1596
02:44:01.817 --> 02:44:09.149
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I also have concerns that didn't get brought up, I think, on the questions around Um, what does the assistant city administrator do?

1597
02:44:09.375 --> 02:44:10.789
<v Sameer Kanal>What is Portland Solutions?

1598
02:44:10.966 --> 02:44:17.983
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't think those are things that reflect on you, but I— there are things that I want to understand about them, um, that I don't currently.

1599
02:44:18.225 --> 02:44:20.935
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I just want to be super transparent about that.

1600
02:44:21.846 --> 02:44:38.325
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, first, I want to thank the mayor for— I think I'm where Councilor Avalos was at in terms of having the end date be written is really helpful, and our conversations around that have been very helpful as well, Mayor Wilson.

1601
02:44:38.983 --> 02:44:47.833
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I, I don't know that I agree with the idea that having a 12-0 vote or something other than a 12-0 vote is going to dissuade applicants.

1602
02:44:47.913 --> 02:44:48.747
<v Sameer Kanal>I may be wrong on that.

1603
02:44:48.796 --> 02:44:50.980
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't have experience as a city administrator.

1604
02:44:51.270 --> 02:44:57.950
<v Sameer Kanal>But even if that's the case, I will say that the applicants who expect a 12-0 vote are not the candidates I want to see.

1605
02:44:58.593 --> 02:45:01.527
<v Sameer Kanal>Going forward, this is a big diverse city.

1606
02:45:01.943 --> 02:45:15.768
<v Sameer Kanal>We have single transferable vote as our mechanism that yields disagreements within districts, and I think it's good for administrator candidates to know future ones for the regular position that you will need to work with each of the 12 of us individually.

1607
02:45:15.896 --> 02:45:24.459
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with with Councilor Zimmerman that I imagine that this video will be shown or will be seen by future candidates, and I'm excited to work with those candidates.

1608
02:45:24.828 --> 02:45:31.525
<v Sameer Kanal>If they should be selected, because we're not just the council president and the council vice president and 10 backbenchers.

1609
02:45:31.638 --> 02:45:35.332
<v Sameer Kanal>We're individually elected officials who deserve to be talked to.

1610
02:45:35.814 --> 02:45:44.165
<v Sameer Kanal>And I am profoundly bothered by the idea that we got surprised by that and didn't even get a courtesy heads up in the case of Zenith.

1611
02:45:44.871 --> 02:46:01.805
<v Sameer Kanal>I, again, I'm not inclined to vote based on that, but I am very concerned that the substantive leadership of the administrative side of the city is in the hands of 6 people that are all interim, and that extending this position will put that in the hands of someone who will not be here long-term.

1612
02:46:02.533 --> 02:46:04.593
<v Sameer Kanal>That's really concerning to me, right?

1613
02:46:05.128 --> 02:46:21.602
<v Sameer Kanal>Because frankly, on many of these issue areas, whether it's public works or vibrant communities or public safety, whatever, the— a lot of the driving force behind what actually gets done and what gets slow-rolled Um, in, in the administrative side of the city.

1614
02:46:22.372 --> 02:46:25.402
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I'm speaking as the only person up here who's worked at the Portland building.

1615
02:46:26.059 --> 02:46:26.924
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I've seen this.

1616
02:46:27.663 --> 02:46:28.816
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, that is really important.

1617
02:46:28.880 --> 02:46:33.305
<v Sameer Kanal>That, that's going to get driven more by the DCAs than it is by the city administrator, uh, position.

1618
02:46:33.352 --> 02:46:35.485
<v Sameer Kanal>And that is of profound concern to me.

1619
02:46:36.959 --> 02:46:39.028
<v Sameer Kanal>That is where my consideration is.

1620
02:46:39.123 --> 02:46:43.629
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm saying this out loud as I'm not 100% even sure when I started saying this how I was going to vote.

1621
02:46:44.254 --> 02:46:45.006
<v Sameer Kanal>But I will say this.

1622
02:46:45.218 --> 02:46:50.583
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilors, in closing, there's a lot of pressure to go along and get along up here.

1623
02:46:51.306 --> 02:46:52.076
<v Sameer Kanal>There is a lot of pressure.

1624
02:46:52.174 --> 02:46:53.827
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope everybody understands that.

1625
02:46:54.680 --> 02:46:59.943
<v Sameer Kanal>And there's also a separate thing, which is the fear that if you vote yes or no, you're going to get punished for it.

1626
02:46:59.992 --> 02:47:03.735
<v Sameer Kanal>That's already happened to me in being up here.

1627
02:47:04.573 --> 02:47:21.763
<v Sameer Kanal>But I know that our relationship going back to when we were at the Portland building and talking there, and before you were the interim city administrator and the chief administrative officer, was your your title then, that I, I trust that when you tell me, I'm not going to be surprised that that doesn't matter whether I vote yes or no right now.

1628
02:47:22.541 --> 02:47:30.915
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you were asking me, Mayor Wilson, to vote yes on keeping, um, the city administrator in place till June 30th, I would absolutely vote no.

1629
02:47:30.978 --> 02:47:34.865
<v Sameer Kanal>But because of that DCA situation, I can't, and I apologize for that.

1630
02:47:34.948 --> 02:47:35.986
<v Sameer Kanal>I wish we'd had more time.

1631
02:47:36.164 --> 02:47:36.471
<v Sameer Kanal>I vote no.

1632
02:47:41.961 --> 02:47:42.861
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, um, thank you.

1633
02:47:43.084 --> 02:47:49.363
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Madam President, for, um, managing and convening this, uh, challenging session that we've had.

1634
02:47:49.443 --> 02:47:49.925
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate it.

1635
02:47:50.069 --> 02:47:50.615
<v Angelita Morillo>I apologize.

1636
02:47:51.547 --> 02:47:55.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Keelan, do we need you to actually call on Councilor Ryan since this is a vote?

1637
02:47:55.770 --> 02:47:56.283
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, I did.

1638
02:47:56.363 --> 02:47:58.290
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm sorry, there must have been a noise.

1639
02:47:58.500 --> 02:47:58.725
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1640
02:47:58.900 --> 02:48:01.614
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, there was an awkward silence, so I just started going.

1641
02:48:01.790 --> 02:48:03.846
<v Keelan McClymont>Sorry, I'm hungry.

1642
02:48:03.895 --> 02:48:05.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That was my fault for nodding to you.

1643
02:48:06.047 --> 02:48:08.296
<v Dan Ryan>It's a— it's been a fascinating day so far.

1644
02:48:08.698 --> 02:48:11.815
<v Dan Ryan>Um, and also thank you, Mayor Wilson and Michael Jordan.

1645
02:48:12.153 --> 02:48:23.610
<v Dan Ryan>Um, this has been messy and necessary, so I appreciate your willingness, your patience, and your authenticity this morning— or this afternoon.

1646
02:48:24.621 --> 02:48:34.358
<v Dan Ryan>And as you said, Michael Jordan, there's no blueprint for what we're building, and we must continue to have conversations like this And we must stay together as we build.

1647
02:48:35.004 --> 02:48:36.844
<v Dan Ryan>And thank you for that reference in a past experience.

1648
02:48:38.718 --> 02:48:43.706
<v Dan Ryan>I think you have the right temperament, and actually you really did prove that over the last couple hours.

1649
02:48:45.218 --> 02:48:47.066
<v Dan Ryan>And I think you have the chops to do hard things.

1650
02:48:47.406 --> 02:48:50.227
<v Dan Ryan>That was where I had more doubt, and that's where we've had our longer conversations.

1651
02:48:51.792 --> 02:49:00.165
<v Dan Ryan>We have to move from the siloed bureau culture that still exists just because we move people around Doesn't mean voilà, the culture's changed.

1652
02:49:00.793 --> 02:49:06.088
<v Dan Ryan>And we have to build an efficient enterprise, and we have to do it in this '25-'26 budget.

1653
02:49:07.231 --> 02:49:08.873
<v Dan Ryan>We delayed this hard work last year.

1654
02:49:09.263 --> 02:49:12.043
<v Dan Ryan>I mentioned that a few times, not too— about a year ago.

1655
02:49:12.514 --> 02:49:13.977
<v Dan Ryan>And we cannot delay this any longer.

1656
02:49:15.297 --> 02:49:16.316
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for your willingness.

1657
02:49:16.689 --> 02:49:16.867
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1658
02:49:18.888 --> 02:49:27.239
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's clear that we have work to do setting up this new form of government and culture, the culture around it.

1659
02:49:27.897 --> 02:49:33.502
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I hear a lot about oversight, transparency, community engagement.

1660
02:49:33.679 --> 02:49:39.362
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I plan to fight for those things to be part of this culture, of this precedent that we're setting.

1661
02:49:40.182 --> 02:49:54.070
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Also, Mr. Mayor, I remember, I think back to our first time when we sat down at that McMinimans downtown together, and something that we do have in common is we both are, you know, we're not deeply entrenched in, in politics.

1662
02:49:54.471 --> 02:49:58.870
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Well, now we are, but we're both— we're not— we didn't come to this as insiders already.

1663
02:49:59.530 --> 02:50:03.432
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So what I see is I understand your desire.

1664
02:50:03.880 --> 02:50:13.322
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This is kind of what I'm guessing, and I think from some conversations I had, to keep things— keep what you can stable as there's a lot of new things going on.

1665
02:50:15.754 --> 02:50:22.808
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do hope, and I will push for, a national search for top-quality candidates.

1666
02:50:24.281 --> 02:50:27.454
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I don't think that we have to have a 12-0 vote.

1667
02:50:27.536 --> 02:50:28.745
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We're not going to, clearly.

1668
02:50:29.531 --> 02:50:40.527
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, but I, I still think it's true that anyone who's a really talented city administrator is looking close at what we're building.

1669
02:50:40.971 --> 02:50:46.900
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is looking close at this culture and how we're treating each other and when we give grace and when we don't.

1670
02:50:47.445 --> 02:51:00.024
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And it's— I'm not even just talking about between us and Mr. Jordan right now, talking about how we're interacting with bureau directors, with city workers, with— we have some work to do.

1671
02:51:00.104 --> 02:51:00.859
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's going to take some work.

1672
02:51:01.003 --> 02:51:12.240
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I believe that, that like we're, we're here for it, but there— it's new, so there's a lot of fear that keeps coming up and a lot of worries about power and who has it and who doesn't.

1673
02:51:12.743 --> 02:51:14.393
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And like, this is part of the work.

1674
02:51:14.458 --> 02:51:15.655
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We need to keep talking about this.

1675
02:51:17.195 --> 02:51:27.375
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, but I do believe that top quality candidates are going to do some research and they're going to look and see what's— what kind of reputation are we building.

1676
02:51:28.320 --> 02:51:36.557
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, what I have seen so far is that you are open to disagreeing.

1677
02:51:37.382 --> 02:51:41.915
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am going to hold really high standards, and I'm also going to do it in a respectful way.

1678
02:51:43.129 --> 02:51:46.566
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also believe deeply that I let people show me who they are.

1679
02:51:47.180 --> 02:51:51.101
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I heard a lot of things about many people on this dais before I actually got to know you.

1680
02:51:52.041 --> 02:51:52.058
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I—.

1681
02:51:52.369 --> 02:51:57.021
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's important to me that what I believe about you is what you are showing me.

1682
02:51:57.755 --> 02:52:00.737
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So Continue to show us, and we're going to push you.

1683
02:52:02.459 --> 02:52:03.397
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I vote aye.

1684
02:52:03.608 --> 02:52:03.962
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1685
02:52:07.810 --> 02:52:08.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1686
02:52:10.623 --> 02:52:12.916
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I want to start off by saying again, thank you.

1687
02:52:13.208 --> 02:52:18.790
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, being a city administrator is a very difficult, unbelievably difficult job.

1688
02:52:18.871 --> 02:52:31.926
<v Angelita Morillo>I believe during one of our meetings, um, Michael, you told us that city administrators have maybe one of the highest turnover rates because it's such a difficult job with such intense public scrutiny.

1689
02:52:32.475 --> 02:52:38.932
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think all of us here on the council are already, even though it's only been a month in, we're familiar with the intensity of public scrutiny as well.

1690
02:52:40.745 --> 02:52:46.174
<v Angelita Morillo>And also, I know that with great power comes great responsibility and scrutiny.

1691
02:52:47.531 --> 02:52:57.673
<v Angelita Morillo>And I fully expect that as a city councilor and as a city administrator, you know, you'll take heat from the community and from us sometimes as we're representing our communities.

1692
02:52:58.573 --> 02:53:03.504
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I also know that trust is really hard to earn and it's very easily lost.

1693
02:53:04.193 --> 02:53:07.744
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I appreciate that you addressed my questions today.

1694
02:53:08.290 --> 02:53:20.545
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that we are going to continue fighting for transparency and accountability between the branches, executive and legislative, um, and I trust that we can do that together.

1695
02:53:21.075 --> 02:53:30.334
<v Angelita Morillo>I also think that you have We had a great meeting with you where you went over all of the things that you do for the city, all of the skill sets that you bring that I think are really underestimated.

1696
02:53:31.786 --> 02:53:39.949
<v Angelita Morillo>And, uh, I think if the public saw a whole layout of all the things that you do, people would be really shocked about all of the work that you carry on your shoulders.

1697
02:53:40.889 --> 02:53:49.075
<v Angelita Morillo>So I also want to take a moment to be frank with the public that is sitting here and maybe streaming this from home, that we're in a really difficult position as council.

1698
02:53:49.138 --> 02:53:49.268
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

1699
02:53:51.405 --> 02:54:03.760
<v Angelita Morillo>We are dealing with a $100 million shortfall, new federal horrors every day that are going to impact our sanctuary city, the withholding of federal funds that could impact our economic process even further here.

1700
02:54:04.769 --> 02:54:14.993
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think that given the sunset clause and the commitments that I've heard about transparency moving forward, I feel comfortable reappointing you through the end of the year.

1701
02:54:15.522 --> 02:54:15.763
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1702
02:54:16.004 --> 02:54:18.605
<v Angelita Morillo>Because we are going to need someone who knows how the process works.

1703
02:54:18.654 --> 02:54:23.680
<v Angelita Morillo>We're going to need that stability as we face some really difficult things together moving forward.

1704
02:54:24.257 --> 02:54:33.074
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm going to be watching very carefully, and I'm, you know, I might be a little bit annoying to make sure that we have a very robust public process in picking the new person.

1705
02:54:33.748 --> 02:54:35.628
<v Angelita Morillo>That's my commitment to the people watching this.

1706
02:54:36.156 --> 02:54:37.699
<v Angelita Morillo>That's my commitment to my district.

1707
02:54:38.469 --> 02:54:45.439
<v Angelita Morillo>And my expectations moving forward are that the executive branch is going to work very carefully with council on big decisions.

1708
02:54:45.871 --> 02:54:55.522
<v Angelita Morillo>We are representatives of the people, and we should receive timely and accurate information and communications from our city administrators and the DCAs who operate under them.

1709
02:54:56.131 --> 02:55:04.515
<v Angelita Morillo>So the public and the council deserves transparency, and the council needs transparency in order to make the right policy decisions by the people that elected us.

1710
02:55:05.574 --> 02:55:12.852
<v Angelita Morillo>And with that, I, I'm looking forward to building that trust with you and meeting more with you, uh, and Let's get the work done.

1711
02:55:12.966 --> 02:55:13.367
<v Angelita Morillo>I vote aye.

1712
02:55:14.796 --> 02:55:15.118
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

1713
02:55:16.162 --> 02:55:24.127
<v Steve Novick>First of all, as a complete tangent, I have to say that coming into this council, I worried with the huge age range among us that there wouldn't be enough shared cultural reference points.

1714
02:55:24.529 --> 02:55:32.447
<v Steve Novick>So as a fan of Spider-Man since 1968, I was delighted to hear Councilor Morillo refer to a phrase associated with that cartoon.

1715
02:55:33.024 --> 02:55:41.135
<v Steve Novick>I appreciate all the comments of people who think that we need to have a very careful process to pick a permanent city administrator.

1716
02:55:41.615 --> 02:55:51.028
<v Steve Novick>And I think we've made it clear today that, uh, well, Michael Jordan is really, despite the title, an interim city administrator until next January.

1717
02:55:51.638 --> 02:56:02.604
<v Steve Novick>And I don't think that we would have had the bandwidth to do a search to find a new city administrator, given the kind of extensive search all of us want, by June 30th.

1718
02:56:03.343 --> 02:56:20.797
<v Steve Novick>And because— largely because we are going to spend the next few months occupied in the miserable task of cutting tens of millions of dollars out of a budget, which in the general fund sense primarily, almost overwhelmingly goes to police, fire, parks, and housing.

1719
02:56:21.453 --> 02:56:26.887
<v Steve Novick>And we're going to make savage cuts to some or all of those, and that's going to take up all of our emotional energy.

1720
02:56:27.078 --> 02:56:36.504
<v Steve Novick>And based on conversations that we've had with Mr. Jordan, I think that he will be invaluable in helping us make those vicious cuts judiciously.

1721
02:56:37.323 --> 02:56:50.756
<v Steve Novick>Um, uh, I also wanted to make a comment that I wish there were more of them still here, to folks who were here about Zenith, who I know also care generally about the critical energy infrastructure hub and the overwhelming issue of climate change.

1722
02:56:51.447 --> 02:57:00.338
<v Steve Novick>Um, Councilor Marina, I co-chair a committee that's specifically charged with issues relating to climate resilience and land use.

1723
02:57:00.387 --> 02:57:00.514
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1724
02:57:00.852 --> 02:57:03.390
<v Steve Novick>And I hope that you will engage in the work of that committee.

1725
02:57:04.788 --> 02:57:24.111
<v Steve Novick>We, I hope, are going to have folks from State DEQ in to ask them about what they plan to do with their charge from the legislature to regulate the critical energy infrastructure hub and require that those companies, 11 of them, including Zenith, take steps to ensure that their tanks do not explode when the earthquake comes.

1726
02:57:25.092 --> 02:57:48.320
<v Steve Novick>We also, I hope, will make recommendations to the rest of the council on how to reduce our own fossil fuel emissions, which will require tough choices that sometimes will bring you in— bring us in conflict with some citizens of the city, like more protected bike lanes, bigger investments in transit, changing the land use laws in ways that promote compact development, which is good for the climate, but some people don't like.

1727
02:57:48.898 --> 02:57:55.838
<v Steve Novick>So I hope that you will come and help us make tough decisions, push us to make tougher decisions.

1728
02:57:55.903 --> 02:57:55.998
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1729
02:57:56.433 --> 02:58:04.105
<v Steve Novick>And I have to say, just as an editorial, that personally I think of fossil fuel companies as like drug dealers.

1730
02:58:04.781 --> 02:58:09.836
<v Steve Novick>Drug dealers are evil, but as long as the demand is there, drug dealers will pop up.

1731
02:58:09.981 --> 02:58:12.502
<v Steve Novick>I think the same is true of fossil fuel companies.

1732
02:58:12.566 --> 02:58:18.474
<v Steve Novick>So I really hope you will help us engage in the really difficult task of trying to reduce the demand.

1733
02:58:19.453 --> 02:58:21.781
<v Steve Novick>With that, with those 3 tangential comments, I vote aye.

1734
02:58:21.861 --> 02:58:22.968
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1735
02:58:26.449 --> 02:58:27.459
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

1736
02:58:28.212 --> 02:58:53.012
<v Olivia Clark>I just want to give a quick shout out to the ladies of Linnton, um, the 4 ladies that live in Linnton that really put, uh, Zenith on the map and who created the incredible coalition, part of whom is here today, uh, for really bringing that to the attention of all of Portland, because most of us really didn't know about what was going on up there, and now we do, and now we can move forward.

1737
02:58:53.397 --> 02:59:02.436
<v Olivia Clark>But the Zenith, um, discussion that we've had today has really revealed, uh, many larger issues, uh, conflicting policies.

1738
02:59:03.255 --> 02:59:14.398
<v Olivia Clark>And we have a long way to go, both on Zenith, on the CEI Hub, and how, um, per your comments, uh, Councilor, how we're going to transition away from fossil fuels.

1739
02:59:14.736 --> 02:59:18.360
<v Olivia Clark>Much larger issues at stake in addition to the immediate ones that we face.

1740
02:59:19.120 --> 02:59:27.746
<v Olivia Clark>So I think this has been one of the best discussions that we've had in our first 33 or 34 days, and thank you for that, for giving us that opportunity.

1741
02:59:28.183 --> 02:59:32.087
<v Olivia Clark>And Michael, you are the right person for this job right now, and I vote aye.

1742
02:59:33.421 --> 02:59:33.629
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

1743
02:59:36.007 --> 02:59:36.328
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1744
02:59:36.474 --> 02:59:48.266
<v Mitch Green>Um, I just want to start by saying that this is a pretty historical moment where we are going to set Um, and so I think the burden is pretty high for City Council to take this decision up.

1745
02:59:48.972 --> 02:59:54.941
<v Mitch Green>Um, and we have to weigh competing objectives and ends with this sort of holistic view in mind.

1746
02:59:54.988 --> 03:00:03.603
<v Mitch Green>And so, you know, I heard very loudly from the public, uh, disappointment around the Lux and a desire to deny confirmation as a sort of disciplining mechanism on that.

1747
03:00:04.309 --> 03:00:11.671
<v Mitch Green>My view on this is that you don't improve policy Through that mechanism alone, right?

1748
03:00:11.990 --> 03:00:33.229
<v Mitch Green>I, I think what we do and what my resolution with Councilor Murillo is intended to do, anyone else who wants to join in, uh, is, is do a forward-looking, thoroughgoing, um, investigation and, and sort of fact-finding process that can then result in new policies that can then provide very unambiguous direction for you to execute.

1749
03:00:33.647 --> 03:00:45.913
<v Mitch Green>That's what I think is the, is the future here, and that's why I am comfortable with the direction this conversation has been going and still feeling like we have a tool where we are responsive to our community.

1750
03:00:46.121 --> 03:01:08.099
<v Mitch Green>The other part of the competing agenda that really weighs heavily is this charge for fiscal stewardship and maintaining the administrative capacity of our city, particularly at a time where we have at the federal government a billionaire who is busy ripping apart the administrative capacity of our federal government, which could have Dire consequences at all levels of government.

1751
03:01:08.179 --> 03:01:15.387
<v Mitch Green>And so I think it's really important that, um, that we have some continuity in place and we take our time with a really robust search.

1752
03:01:16.045 --> 03:01:48.948
<v Mitch Green>And while I appreciate, uh, Councilor Kanal's comments to the, um, to the sort of, uh, you know, what's the signal to the person on the outside looking in, I think, I think if we are successful and we, we take this resolution that we should hear in a couple weeks seriously, with an eye towards restoring public trust and accountability, we will set an expectation that the type of people who apply for this job are going to self-select into a world where they have to have a really cooperative relationship with City Council, who wants to really clarify its power and duties.

1753
03:01:49.173 --> 03:01:52.353
<v Mitch Green>So with all that in mind, um, I vote aye.

1754
03:01:53.702 --> 03:01:54.087
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

1755
03:01:55.389 --> 03:01:55.582
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1756
03:01:55.710 --> 03:01:59.211
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate some of the comments of the colleagues, and I'm happy you stepped up, Mike.

1757
03:01:59.261 --> 03:01:59.388
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1758
03:01:59.469 --> 03:02:00.304
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for the nomination, Mayor.

1759
03:02:00.368 --> 03:02:00.769
<v Michaela McCormick>I vote aye.

1760
03:02:01.893 --> 03:02:19.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm going to take the advice that I gave to my fellow councilor and turn the question I didn't get to ask into a comment to just say, uh, Mr. Jordan, we've talked a lot about management at the city, your relationship with us, your relationship with the mayor, and we haven't talked about the folks who work at the city, our frontline workers.

1761
03:02:20.750 --> 03:02:29.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I have heard a lot since taking this position about the need for culture change within the city to make sure that we are the absolute best place to work within the City of Portland.

1762
03:02:29.816 --> 03:02:42.956
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just want to note for the record, as we sit here talking to you about your continued service to the city, that I hope you can be a partner with council in helping to make sure that we have that type of culture, the culture where folks want to work at the city.

1763
03:02:44.335 --> 03:02:51.331
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, I appreciate that you brought forward an amendment, and to Councilor Avalos for moving that, thank you.

1764
03:02:51.877 --> 03:02:52.343
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1765
03:02:52.856 --> 03:03:03.864
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is a lot to balance as we think about the need to have a robust process to find a long-term city administrator and also the need to continue to move forward the work of the city.

1766
03:03:03.944 --> 03:03:08.202
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because while we are all new and you, Mr. Mayor, are new, the work of the city goes on.

1767
03:03:09.150 --> 03:03:18.893
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And having the continuity of Mr. Jordan, but also a timeline, Mr. Mayor, for you to make sure that you move forward with that robust process was very important to me.

1768
03:03:19.441 --> 03:03:20.118
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, thank you.

1769
03:03:20.745 --> 03:03:21.309
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I vote aye.

1770
03:03:22.680 --> 03:03:26.808
<v Keelan McClymont>The resolution is adopted as amended with 11 yes votes and 1 no vote.

1771
03:03:28.322 --> 03:03:28.513
<v Jan Zuckerman>Thank you.

1772
03:03:28.563 --> 03:03:29.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1773
03:03:29.286 --> 03:03:29.943
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilors.

1774
03:03:30.250 --> 03:03:31.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And congratulations, Mr. Jordan.

1775
03:03:32.965 --> 03:03:37.478
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, without objection, I would like us to take a quick 5-minute recess.

1776
03:03:37.559 --> 03:03:40.281
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know a couple of folks have asked for just a bit of time.

1777
03:03:40.902 --> 03:03:47.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will come back then at I would like to propose that we reconvene at 12:35 to take on the last item on our agenda.

1778
03:03:47.367 --> 03:03:48.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any objection to that?

1779
03:03:49.393 --> 03:03:49.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

1780
03:03:49.795 --> 03:03:51.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, 12:35.

1781
03:11:31.943 --> 03:11:35.301
<v Keith Wilson>Well, let's— I will tell you what I'm telling everybody.

1782
03:11:35.398 --> 03:11:38.097
<v Keith Wilson>I am going broke in this job because there's so many—.

1783
03:11:38.515 --> 03:11:42.676
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am going to call us back into our council meeting.

1784
03:11:43.111 --> 03:11:55.898
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know we have a few councilors who are still wrapping some things up to come back in, but I'd like to make sure that we get out of here not councilors have given the nod to go until 1 o'clock, which is 22 minutes.

1785
03:11:56.028 --> 03:12:06.579
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think we are going to be able to hold to that deadline, but we are going to move as quickly as we can while still making sure that we can have a robust conversation with Mr. Taylor.

1786
03:12:07.929 --> 03:12:10.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Clerk, could you read the item?

1787
03:12:12.328 --> 03:12:14.674
<v Keelan McClymont>Appoint Robert Taylor as City Attorney.

1788
03:12:15.942 --> 03:12:16.296
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1789
03:12:17.308 --> 03:12:20.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And, uh, Mr. Mayor, would you like to introduce this agenda item?

1790
03:12:21.483 --> 03:12:22.189
<v Keith Wilson>Yes, thank you.

1791
03:12:23.007 --> 03:12:29.815
<v Keith Wilson>Council President, Madam Vice President, I also ask that council support the appointment of Robert Taylor as our city attorney.

1792
03:12:30.569 --> 03:12:38.004
<v Keith Wilson>Robert has demonstrated his sharp legal mind, diplomacy, and thoughtful disposition throughout the time in the city attorney's office.

1793
03:12:38.998 --> 03:12:48.521
<v Keith Wilson>He took on a leadership position at a particularly difficult time for this community has continued to lead during a time of change and uncertainty within this organization.

1794
03:12:50.520 --> 03:13:00.379
<v Keith Wilson>His process knowledge working in a parliamentary system, along with his deep understanding of city operations, challenges, and needs, are all highly valuable to our new structure.

1795
03:13:01.551 --> 03:13:05.572
<v Keith Wilson>I believe we should continue to lean on the experience and success of this public servant.

1796
03:13:06.537 --> 03:13:08.949
<v Keith Wilson>He has my confidence, and I hope he will have your vote today.

1797
03:13:09.013 --> 03:13:09.415
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Councilor Mitch Green.

1798
03:13:10.029 --> 03:13:12.807
<v Keith Wilson>With that, I will turn this back to Council President Pirtle-Guiney.

1799
03:13:14.870 --> 03:13:15.143
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1800
03:13:16.333 --> 03:13:18.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Keelan, do we have any public testimony signed up?

1801
03:13:19.951 --> 03:13:21.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No one signed up.

1802
03:13:21.479 --> 03:13:21.656
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

1803
03:13:21.720 --> 03:13:22.379
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1804
03:13:23.962 --> 03:13:36.022
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council, I think we will run through the same procedure as we did with Mr. Jordan, give everybody an opportunity to ask one question, and then depending on time left, we can potentially move into additional questions.

1805
03:13:37.002 --> 03:13:39.843
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Before moving toward a vote.

1806
03:13:40.713 --> 03:13:45.587
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So why don't we— we started it— no, we did by hands last time.

1807
03:13:45.636 --> 03:13:50.853
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Why don't folks put hands in the queue if you're interested in asking a question of Mr. Taylor?

1808
03:13:50.934 --> 03:13:52.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll start with Councilor Green.

1809
03:13:54.185 --> 03:13:58.494
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam President, and thank you, Robert, for applying for the job again.

1810
03:13:58.784 --> 03:14:03.529
<v Mitch Green>Um, uh, my question is a little hypothetical, but you do deal in hypotheticals.

1811
03:14:04.099 --> 03:14:04.891
<v Mitch Green>Um, as a craft.

1812
03:14:04.941 --> 03:14:20.368
<v Mitch Green>And so I think, um, how would you respond to a situation where a city council member, um, decided to retain, um, sort of an outside legal opinion to advance an ordinance or to, you know, advance a resolution?

1813
03:14:21.497 --> 03:14:27.307
<v Mitch Green>Uh, what would your opinion of that type of interaction be, um, as a— as the city attorney?

1814
03:14:28.065 --> 03:14:30.680
<v Robert Taylor>Uh, Thank you, Councilor.

1815
03:14:30.745 --> 03:14:32.173
<v Robert Taylor>For the record, Robert Taylor.

1816
03:14:32.575 --> 03:14:37.905
<v Robert Taylor>Um, well, I'll just tell you this, that kind of thing's happened before.

1817
03:14:39.316 --> 03:14:49.719
<v Robert Taylor>Um, previous elected officials, previous members of the executive, they know people in the community, they go get their own, uh, legal advice.

1818
03:14:50.170 --> 03:14:56.334
<v Robert Taylor>And, uh, what I tell them is, uh, hey, that's fine, go talk to whoever you want.

1819
03:14:56.382 --> 03:15:07.984
<v Robert Taylor>Councilor but, uh, you, you need to recognize that, um, I'm the only person in this city that represents the city.

1820
03:15:09.718 --> 03:15:19.046
<v Robert Taylor>And if you're getting advice from somebody that represents a particular interest or a particular viewpoint, their advice is going to support that interest and that viewpoint.

1821
03:15:20.555 --> 03:15:27.945
<v Robert Taylor>But if you want to ask somebody What's in the interest of the city as a whole, that's my job.

1822
03:15:30.554 --> 03:15:31.136
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that, sir.

1823
03:15:31.183 --> 03:15:31.506
<v Owen Nguyen>Thank you.

1824
03:15:33.344 --> 03:15:37.424
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Madam President.

1825
03:15:38.262 --> 03:15:39.793
<v Olivia Clark>Um, thanks for being here.

1826
03:15:40.441 --> 03:15:49.057
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate, uh, getting to know you and the fact that you've made yourself available to us, um, by district and individually.

1827
03:15:49.332 --> 03:15:52.513
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate your candor in those meetings.

1828
03:15:53.329 --> 03:16:06.983
<v Olivia Clark>Um, you know, we're living in— you've heard a lot about it— we're living in very uncertain times with a lot of fear, a lot of heightened emotion, um, very complex issues, which is what we've been discussing today really in terms of Zenith.

1829
03:16:07.688 --> 03:16:18.042
<v Olivia Clark>But I wanted to ask you something along the lines of what I asked Mr. Jordan, and it's not very specific, but we talked about this in our, um, meet— our district meeting, is How do you build trust?

1830
03:16:18.911 --> 03:16:23.859
<v Olivia Clark>How, how do you build trust between this legislative body and the City Attorney's Office?

1831
03:16:25.111 --> 03:16:34.075
<v Robert Taylor>It's a great question, and, um, the, the role of attorney and client is based on trust and, and confidence.

1832
03:16:35.120 --> 03:16:39.216
<v Robert Taylor>And I, I think there's, uh, two, two aspects to it.

1833
03:16:39.313 --> 03:16:43.954
<v Robert Taylor>I think first is the, the mindset you bring to any relationship.

1834
03:16:44.922 --> 03:16:56.854
<v Robert Taylor>And so you can bring a relationship, a mindset of compassion and grace and gratitude to that relationship, and that can be the foundation that you build on.

1835
03:16:58.798 --> 03:17:08.943
<v Robert Taylor>Or you can bring a mindset of distrust and suspicion, and that will set the foundation from which you're working on in that relationship.

1836
03:17:08.994 --> 03:17:09.240
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1837
03:17:10.066 --> 03:17:16.200
<v Robert Taylor>And then beyond that, you know, I think it is— you, you do judge people by how they act.

1838
03:17:16.247 --> 03:17:18.800
<v Robert Taylor>You judge people by how they conduct themselves.

1839
03:17:19.861 --> 03:17:24.533
<v Robert Taylor>And, um, if, if they earn that trust going forward, great.

1840
03:17:24.709 --> 03:17:27.263
<v Robert Taylor>If they don't, then that's a problem.

1841
03:17:27.728 --> 03:17:39.611
<v Robert Taylor>And, uh, I, I— it's important to me as the, the attorney for the city that everybody in this room has trust and confidence in my ability to, to give good legal advice.

1842
03:17:43.040 --> 03:17:43.608
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1843
03:17:45.572 --> 03:17:46.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1844
03:17:47.682 --> 03:17:48.525
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Madam President.

1845
03:17:49.200 --> 03:17:50.200
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for being here.

1846
03:17:50.522 --> 03:17:59.641
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for all you've done, Mr. Taylor, and for staying on as we do this big lift of setting up this whole new form of government.

1847
03:18:00.436 --> 03:18:02.157
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I— my question is Yes.

1848
03:18:02.207 --> 03:18:14.059
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>About thinking about your experience as a parliamentarian, as an attorney, as someone who cares a lot about good governance and is excited to chair the Governance Committee.

1849
03:18:15.370 --> 03:18:25.240
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>As we're learning this together, are there certain things that you think would be helpful for us to focus on as a council or to know as a council to be working on?

1850
03:18:25.466 --> 03:18:28.745
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Maybe specific things that we can be talking about in the Governance Committee?

1851
03:18:28.826 --> 03:18:36.027
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know there have been times when, um, there's been disagreement with your role and should you act as a judge?

1852
03:18:36.204 --> 03:18:43.126
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Or like, are there any things that you'd feel comfortable sharing with us that you think we could talk about and work on?

1853
03:18:43.318 --> 03:18:44.573
<v Robert Taylor>Yeah, that's a great question.

1854
03:18:44.845 --> 03:18:47.835
<v Robert Taylor>I, I think, um, there's, there's a couple of things.

1855
03:18:47.900 --> 03:18:50.165
<v Robert Taylor>I think first is, uh, the rules.

1856
03:18:51.500 --> 03:18:58.118
<v Robert Taylor>And, uh, you know, I, I think it would be a real challenge to yes.

1857
03:18:58.198 --> 03:19:02.164
<v Robert Taylor>I don't expect the new City Council to become experts on Robert's Rules.

1858
03:19:03.545 --> 03:19:09.050
<v Robert Taylor>And instead, I think you should be experts on the rules that you adopt for yourself.

1859
03:19:10.207 --> 03:19:18.572
<v Robert Taylor>And you have an opportunity to adopt those rules, make changes to them so they really accommodate how you want to operate as a body.

1860
03:19:18.988 --> 03:19:22.072
<v Robert Taylor>So I think that's a place to really focus.

1861
03:19:22.729 --> 03:19:24.238
<v Robert Taylor>The same goes for the committee rules.

1862
03:19:25.671 --> 03:19:35.628
<v Robert Taylor>And then, you know, beyond rules, I think there's a lot of— and I think this was alluded to earlier— just issues of culture and norms.

1863
03:19:37.229 --> 03:19:45.676
<v Robert Taylor>When I worked at the Oregon State Senate, we had rules, but there was also some culture and norms that were associated with folks.

1864
03:19:46.725 --> 03:19:47.594
<v Robert Taylor>And I think that was helpful.

1865
03:19:48.518 --> 03:19:58.685
<v Robert Taylor>And you really do have a historic opportunity as the first council to set that culture and set those norms, just like you have the ability to set those rules.

1866
03:19:59.445 --> 03:20:01.918
<v Robert Taylor>So I think those would be the 3 things I would focus on.

1867
03:20:07.172 --> 03:20:08.817
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Madam President.

1868
03:20:08.865 --> 03:20:11.850
<v Dan Ryan>Good afternoon, Mayor Wilson and Attorney Robert Taylor.

1869
03:20:12.431 --> 03:20:17.486
<v Dan Ryan>Robert, I've enjoyed my relationship with you over most of— over the past 4 and a half years.

1870
03:20:17.681 --> 03:20:26.451
<v Dan Ryan>I've claimed that You're, um, a very truthful, um, advice— you give truthful advice to public servants.

1871
03:20:27.158 --> 03:20:38.436
<v Dan Ryan>And I know I've been salty at times with you about the risk-averseness of your culture, and I think that's a really healthy tension for people in my role to have with the legal team at times.

1872
03:20:38.646 --> 03:20:41.602
<v Dan Ryan>So I've always appreciated how we get through those conversations.

1873
03:20:42.341 --> 03:20:51.314
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I also respect Mayor Wilson's decision to extend your contract as the mayor is in a new role in a major transition for our city.

1874
03:20:52.452 --> 03:20:55.388
<v Dan Ryan>I was not surprised that he asked you to stay on in this role.

1875
03:20:55.837 --> 03:20:58.596
<v Dan Ryan>So, um, thank you for agreeing to do that.

1876
03:20:59.431 --> 03:21:02.622
<v Dan Ryan>And it's really well known your expertise in the rules of government.

1877
03:21:02.816 --> 03:21:07.211
<v Dan Ryan>Not surprised that the chair of the Governance Committee called that out.

1878
03:21:07.709 --> 03:21:13.736
<v Dan Ryan>We've been thinking about that of late, and so that is one of the main reasons I'm also very Supportive of your extension.

1879
03:21:15.409 --> 03:21:22.656
<v Dan Ryan>I also appreciate your style of providing the scope and understanding when— and remaining objective when we have very difficult decisions.

1880
03:21:22.850 --> 03:21:29.291
<v Dan Ryan>I've always found that to be quite admirable, and I can tell that leaks out into the team throughout the city, the legal team.

1881
03:21:30.466 --> 03:21:37.665
<v Dan Ryan>The question for every leader overseeing an office at this time is we have to buckle up and do hard things in this upcoming budget season.

1882
03:21:37.729 --> 03:21:37.907
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1883
03:21:39.281 --> 03:21:50.625
<v Dan Ryan>How are you thinking about restructuring your team as we move from the bureau silos to the work areas in the One Portland Enterprise, the language I've heard now from 2 mayors over this last year?

1884
03:21:51.221 --> 03:21:56.352
<v Dan Ryan>And I want to start to see how that language actually becomes actionable during this budget season.

1885
03:21:57.030 --> 03:22:05.495
<v Dan Ryan>What are some of your thoughts about how to streamline your legal team as we quickly build a new and improved organizational chart for our city?

1886
03:22:07.252 --> 03:22:09.316
<v Robert Taylor>Uh, thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1887
03:22:09.672 --> 03:22:17.963
<v Robert Taylor>Uh, first, let me start, uh, I'm sure folks are listening from my office, that, um, I am grateful for each and every one of them.

1888
03:22:19.351 --> 03:22:24.254
<v Robert Taylor>They are good people doing difficult work in challenging times.

1889
03:22:25.238 --> 03:22:32.408
<v Robert Taylor>And as I said, the, the most difficult and controversial issues often end up in the City Attorney's Office.

1890
03:22:32.611 --> 03:22:35.788
<v Robert Taylor>And, uh, and we help the city navigate those.

1891
03:22:37.167 --> 03:22:41.210
<v Robert Taylor>Um, I— we do have a difficult budget coming up.

1892
03:22:41.355 --> 03:22:44.468
<v Robert Taylor>We've been asked to submit, uh, 8% cuts.

1893
03:22:44.725 --> 03:22:45.397
<v Robert Taylor>We've done that.

1894
03:22:46.313 --> 03:22:52.634
<v Robert Taylor>Um, and I do think there's an opportunity for, for us to, to do, um, further streamlining.

1895
03:22:53.066 --> 03:22:59.019
<v Robert Taylor>And, you know, I've heard from this council a desire to be well served by the City of Attorney's Office.

1896
03:22:59.645 --> 03:23:02.501
<v Robert Taylor>And so that's, I think, a focus for us going forward.

1897
03:23:03.398 --> 03:23:14.613
<v Robert Taylor>Um, I think, you know, we're, we're in month 2 of this, and so we— I do kind of want to wait and see what the demand for those services are from the council before we make big changes.

1898
03:23:14.887 --> 03:23:19.251
<v Robert Taylor>But that is something that is very top of mind for me right now.

1899
03:23:20.084 --> 03:23:28.399
<v Robert Taylor>Um, and then, you know, I've, I've heard the comments about Um, kind of the layers of management and span of control.

1900
03:23:28.802 --> 03:23:31.807
<v Robert Taylor>And I understand that's a particular concern for this council.

1901
03:23:33.372 --> 03:23:34.658
<v Dan Ryan>Can I just do a real quick follow-up?

1902
03:23:34.899 --> 03:23:35.430
<v Dan Ryan>That might—.

1903
03:23:36.009 --> 03:23:36.346
<v Dan Ryan>You're get—.

1904
03:23:36.346 --> 03:23:48.935
<v Dan Ryan>We're getting there, but I think in our follow-up dialogue we'll have— I'm sure this will be frequent over the next few months— is what I experienced is there were expertise in bureaus, and now those bureaus are part of a new work area.

1905
03:23:49.584 --> 03:23:56.782
<v Dan Ryan>And what I'm not experiencing yet in oversight is noticing the integration of those bureaus with some efficiency.

1906
03:23:57.441 --> 03:24:02.343
<v Dan Ryan>And I expect that your attorneys are going through some of that same, um, change.

1907
03:24:02.841 --> 03:24:21.235
<v Dan Ryan>And so I just want to hear about what that looks like, and so that we actually, I would assume, move away from an attorney just being with one bureau but moving more into a one-city enterprise, um, work area type yeah, that's a great, great point.

1908
03:24:21.477 --> 03:24:25.076
<v Robert Taylor>And I think I've shared this with you before.

1909
03:24:25.915 --> 03:24:36.620
<v Robert Taylor>You know, the point about bureaus being siloed is that's a— that was a real problem and feature of the prior form of government.

1910
03:24:36.781 --> 03:24:42.019
<v Robert Taylor>And I think that was one of the main motivating changes behind the charter reform.

1911
03:24:42.718 --> 03:24:57.445
<v Robert Taylor>And I think that's part of the, the culture and perspective that I have tried to build over the last few years, and that I think is even more imperative going forward, that lawyers in our office don't represent a bureau.

1912
03:24:58.915 --> 03:25:00.610
<v Robert Taylor>They don't represent a service area.

1913
03:25:00.915 --> 03:25:02.225
<v Robert Taylor>They don't just represent the mayor.

1914
03:25:02.614 --> 03:25:03.653
<v Robert Taylor>We represent the city.

1915
03:25:04.805 --> 03:25:08.811
<v Robert Taylor>And you have to have that viewpoint when you, when you do the work.

1916
03:25:08.877 --> 03:25:09.072
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you.

1917
03:25:10.023 --> 03:25:14.246
<v Robert Taylor>And I think, I think, I think that is something that our lawyers understand.

1918
03:25:14.825 --> 03:25:19.962
<v Robert Taylor>And I do think that's something that we have to keep leaning into and reminding folks.

1919
03:25:20.316 --> 03:25:32.183
<v Robert Taylor>So that, you know, we have subject matter experts in transportation or in public safety, and we have to rely on those to give advice to the administration.

1920
03:25:32.263 --> 03:25:34.447
<v Robert Taylor>We also have to rely on that to give advice to council.

1921
03:25:34.495 --> 03:25:34.606
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you.

1922
03:25:35.058 --> 03:25:36.329
<v Robert Taylor>When they're crafting policy.

1923
03:25:37.167 --> 03:25:49.245
<v Robert Taylor>And as long as we stay focused on giving the same consistent objective legal advice to everybody as a city, then I, I think we'll do, we'll do okay.

1924
03:25:49.987 --> 03:25:50.295
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1925
03:25:52.814 --> 03:25:53.591
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Knoll.

1926
03:25:57.181 --> 03:26:14.641
<v Sameer Kanal>So, uh, just to kind of riff off of one aspect here that was discussed with Councilor Ryan's question, When I used to work across the street at the Portland building, it had been made clear to me a couple times by members of the office that, that as a city employee, I wasn't the client of the city but an employee of the client of the city.

1927
03:26:15.628 --> 03:26:24.943
<v Sameer Kanal>And also, I think that it's been clear that the legal entity of the sort of capital C City is the client, and when we use the word the city, right?

1928
03:26:25.538 --> 03:26:27.257
<v Sameer Kanal>So I, I'm not objecting to that information.

1929
03:26:27.306 --> 03:26:29.138
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just kind of contextualizing the question.

1930
03:26:29.186 --> 03:26:29.235
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1931
03:26:29.657 --> 03:26:32.239
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I think it'd be transparent to use this opportunity to ask it.

1932
03:26:32.416 --> 03:26:34.352
<v Sameer Kanal>When— how do you see the client?

1933
03:26:35.144 --> 03:26:35.272
<v Sameer Kanal>What—.

1934
03:26:35.563 --> 03:26:38.434
<v Sameer Kanal>Who do you see as the client of the City Attorney's Office?

1935
03:26:38.853 --> 03:26:41.206
<v Sameer Kanal>How would you describe that client?

1936
03:26:41.529 --> 03:26:50.548
<v Robert Taylor>The client is the municipal government of the City of Portland, and we provide advice to that client through its agents, officers, and employees.

1937
03:26:50.595 --> 03:26:50.759
<v Edith Gillis>Thanks.

1938
03:26:59.097 --> 03:27:00.655
<v Mitch Green>I'm calling the question, Madam President.

1939
03:27:03.909 --> 03:27:05.072
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we have a second?

1940
03:27:05.152 --> 03:27:05.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second.

1941
03:27:07.315 --> 03:27:08.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any discussion?

1942
03:27:10.317 --> 03:27:13.433
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Clerk, please call the roll.

1943
03:27:16.546 --> 03:27:17.097
<v Owen Nguyen>Avalos.

1944
03:27:18.739 --> 03:27:19.650
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for your service.

1945
03:27:19.731 --> 03:27:20.138
<v Keelan McClymont>I vote aye.

1946
03:27:24.879 --> 03:27:24.927
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1947
03:27:25.929 --> 03:27:25.944
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1948
03:27:26.816 --> 03:27:34.064
<v Sameer Kanal>Do have a comment, so I'll just say I've had the privilege of working with you, um, for a couple years now, um, and members of your office in general.

1949
03:27:34.643 --> 03:27:37.074
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, we are voting on the overall resolution right now, right?

1950
03:27:38.345 --> 03:27:38.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are.

1951
03:27:38.764 --> 03:27:39.424
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I want to be sure.

1952
03:27:39.956 --> 03:27:56.945
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, but I also think, uh, that I, you know, you're probably right, there are people in the office that are watching, and I, I just want to make sure I'm expressing appreciation not only to you but also to people like Heidi Brown and, uh, Jennifer Johnson and so many other folks in that office who do a lot to support not only us but the city, capital and lowercase city, writ large.

1953
03:27:57.558 --> 03:28:09.609
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I think that in this particular time, having you personally as an attorney here who can speak to a lot of the parliamentarian questions is incredibly valuable for us.

1954
03:28:10.139 --> 03:28:30.245
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also think that, uh, with With a note for what, um, caveat me perhaps for what Councilor Ryan said around the implications of the budget on the office, uh, having you as a manager, which is another really important part of your job as city attorney, is equally, uh, valuable as a, um, a set of attributes that, that we need in this time.

1955
03:28:30.293 --> 03:28:31.094
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm going to vote aye.

1956
03:28:31.318 --> 03:28:31.656
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1957
03:28:32.953 --> 03:28:35.423
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1958
03:28:35.727 --> 03:28:41.815
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, thank you, Robert Taylor, for your patience today and for your willingness to step up and serve at this exciting and difficult time.

1959
03:28:42.478 --> 03:28:45.865
<v Dan Ryan>I look forward to seeing how you will reorg the legal system in our city.

1960
03:28:46.369 --> 03:28:46.709
<v Robert Butler>I vote aye.

1961
03:28:48.965 --> 03:28:49.141
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1962
03:28:50.835 --> 03:28:59.308
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I had the pleasure of working with you a few years ago when I was first in City Hall, and I feel like you have always been really fair in the judgments that you've made.

1963
03:28:59.775 --> 03:29:05.377
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, and when you've given us legal advice where we want to push the boundaries, you tell us the risks of that, but you don't try to direct us.

1964
03:29:05.996 --> 03:29:16.130
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I really appreciate, uh, your guidance and the way that you have shown up and had very frank and hard conversations with us as council, and I'm proud to vote aye and continue working with you.

1965
03:29:16.227 --> 03:29:18.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Robert.

1966
03:29:19.118 --> 03:29:31.872
<v Steve Novick>To echo what Councilor Morillo just said, I really appreciated the fact that you made it very clear that when you give legal advice, you tell us what the risks of certain strategies are, and you don't say you must do this or you must do that.

1967
03:29:32.290 --> 03:30:03.222
<v Mitch Green>I've also really, really appreciated the briefings we've gotten from you and your staff on a variety of legal issues, which have been Yeah, I think that you're a professional that has given me the confidence that you've got the municipal corporation as your client, which, which I think is what we need in this time— consistency and objective analysis.

1968
03:30:03.386 --> 03:30:05.048
<v Mitch Green>So I'm happy to vote aye.

1969
03:30:08.066 --> 03:30:08.790
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for stepping up.

1970
03:30:08.966 --> 03:30:10.493
<v Eric Zimmerman>Appreciate the nomination.

1971
03:30:11.022 --> 03:30:19.745
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I know that we'll have plenty of spirited and, I hope, intellectual debates, and I really have appreciated the way your team and you have approached those so far.

1972
03:30:19.906 --> 03:30:25.570
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm also glad you're not as popular as Mike Jordan, and so thank you for keeping this quick.

1973
03:30:25.700 --> 03:30:26.185
<v Eric Zimmerman>I vote aye.

1974
03:30:27.318 --> 03:30:32.638
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for your partnership as we build this as we build something new.

1975
03:30:32.862 --> 03:30:40.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that we are adding a work stream to what is already a very big portfolio that you and your team have.

1976
03:30:41.552 --> 03:30:52.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You have taken that on with all of us graciously and continue to provide us with the very helpful advice that many of my colleagues have already referred to.

1977
03:30:53.038 --> 03:30:57.692
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, thank you for bringing forward your recommendation of appointment of Robert Taylor.

1978
03:30:58.237 --> 03:30:58.606
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I vote aye.

1979
03:31:00.081 --> 03:31:02.549
<v Keelan McClymont>The resolution is adopted with 12 yes votes.

1980
03:31:03.621 --> 03:31:05.320
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Council.

1981
03:31:05.770 --> 03:31:06.010
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you.

1982
03:31:06.090 --> 03:31:08.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, and congratulations, Mr. Taylor.

1983
03:31:09.470 --> 03:31:12.435
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe that brings us to the end of our agenda.

1984
03:31:12.900 --> 03:31:15.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will close the council meeting.

1985
03:31:15.465 --> 03:31:16.763
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for your time today.

